001to come here tonight for um because they had a previously scheduled work commitment um I just wanted to give everyone some background to bring everyone up to speed with how we are here tonight um so miss cabalo had mentioned about over a year ago wanting to have a discussion about um facility fees and um and and and what and bringing some kind of fairness to how we handle facility um in June of last year Finance met to discuss the fee schedule and they had ongoing conversations about it um again in October and it came uh to the board of ed um it got recommended by Finance by divided vote and it came to the board of ed um on November 11th of last year on November 11th board unanimously voted to defer the discussion to
002a future date because we were hearing from different stakeholders that about other fees being also unfair um including pay to playing gate fees and we felt that we wanted to have a bigger discussion on November 25th U Miss cavalo asked for the P scheduled me back on the calendar on the agenda which I did um and we had as a board about an hourong discussion about fees and about whether again to do a workshop with a bigger picture view instead of doing a peace meal effects that might be very well get turned over at a future Workshop um and at that date the board voted again um to hear the picture workshop on fees then here we are today um just wanted to to explain to everyone we're not voting on anything tonight we won't
003find any um action item on the agenda um there might perhaps be another meeting on fees um if we can't get to consensus tonight um and there are as Mr um uh Smith and Mr Martino are probably going to get into there many different kinds of fees um but basically tonight we're going to be mainly discussing fees that impact bed Revenue okay so I'm going to turn it over uh to superintendent Smith uh to do an overview of current fees and policy I just want to bring up um this is the folder that was shared I'm not going to go over all of the documents here each fold older has a series of documents in it um we'll post these documents online for people that want to see them um for tonight we going to
004take it through a series of um documents that we kind of called for this meeting some of these documents are in the packet they have but not all of them some are more complicated first thing I want to start with was our current policy so right now going to apply for an application to use our facilities form out these are the Bas right basic commun relations policy activities and they scroll down because what we're really GNA focus on tonight at the bottom of that this is the um original document that is um kind of starting to ation back at finance committee meeting a while ago so we're not going to spend a ton of time on this but I just have it here as a point of reference it's in your packet been a lot
005of conversation uh different organizations and relationships this is the 2017 op Warner um agreement signed with u between pop Youth Organization and District this was 2017 before I got here the 10e agreement um then I didn't put this P it it's kind of lengthy but it is in the folder we'll post it online for anybody U that wants to see it but what was negotiated in 2017 was that pop War would pay a one-time fee of $10,000 and get access to our FS for 10 years this is document that we shared um at the finance committee meeting that talked about gate fees um and what we currently charge um what an annual pass is sold for what those fees go to how many are collected and U this is pretty much a net zero piece
006the district takes said no Revenue uh from gate fees the gate fees that come in pay for the officials um and other people that work at the gates uh we put together a document U that you swc friends this has all of the um the swc school districts um and what they charge at each of their GS U not everybody is does everything exactly the same so there are some Nuance between the um different school districts but you can get an idea of um what each distri outlines of Revenue so prior to the 2223 school year did not break out revenues stand it them in our budget but we had no past performance of what we collect in facility fees and how that impacts our budget so we started doing that in the 2223 school
007year um you can see a list of all of the revenue that the budget takes that the school district takes in uh both the budget and the actuals for 2223 23 24 um and we budgeted for this year you'll notice that if you look at the facility rental fees again we budgeted we didn't have any historical so 10,000 as a placeholder um we had two years where we exceeded what we budgeted um this year we budgeted 10,000 as well but um the assumption would be that as long as we're running ahead of that 10,000 that budget close that 177,000 for the 25 26 school year in which any decision that comes out of this that's when you talk about impact and cost benefit that's where that's going to show off Jos and that's that's completely
008not of any custodian and that's both profit and not that's the energy fees that's all anything above that we directly P for custodial or labor rate I'm sorry no no I just wanted to make sure because I know and some of them when we were looking at finance and Facilities we had the number group together and then was kind of I just wanted to make sure that was so just for clearity only money is collected from this um yes so at the finance committee meeting we started talking about change this is the uh we didn't Mr Martino and I didn't make any changes to this other than what was discussed at the finance committee meeting but this was the original proposal to kind of loop lump groups a what currently is a through e into
009what would be the new a and then what is currently group F will become Group B becomes group so this was the original one so because and I know this I just want to understand this was when we went up 25% on the four profit ones not the 20% that Heather had for right this has the 80% 80% midle s right which we talked about in finance and then the fee for booking yeah the penalties and actually there there's one little discrepancy on this too the energy fee really would only apply to FNG G in the in this example do CD and E so in reality if you exempt it out you would the energy Fe only grps FG just give no examples and FNG are only for profit right so we decided like mobilo
010y you have I'm going to show you a list in a minute what that would look like if we kind of forward we did it as an example because we wanted to just kind of play out um I know this is at the time we didn't table we pulled it back because we want to have this bigger conversation but this was kind of the last uh document that came out of Finance so we want to roll it forward with the example we're talking about tonight so you had an example that's this one's a little small there's a couple things on it one thing you'll notice all the way e we added the hourly rate so this has group a exempting out all the folks that were in the group current groups D sorry group a
011to Group D would fall into the the no fees group except for custodial excuse me can you just say this is this is the spreadsheet that correlates with the draft and the other final correct thank you sorry so but I think it's the spreadsheet that cour free this decision that's what I'm hearing I just want make this is what it would look like if we made the Chang make the change is just what you got so and what we did try to capture here is obviously the new group b and the new group C's and what they would pay we did we did roll the fees forward as best we could obviously this assumes all these same groups stick with us all that kind of what do you mean so oh so you're saying where
012we say group a through e that becomes all a now group f is B yep so go on to Group B Josh that's part the best example so mobilia for example will move into into the new group b so that is so that so that we we adjusted his rates forward and and made that change so that that's what you see there so we we we up we up those rates based on on the new numbers and then same gross Group C made adjustments forward I'm so sorry you guys are much more in can we phrase the header because I'm looking at the highlights thinking you're talking about e and I'm looking at under yeah the highlights the only highlights only P that kind of matters so they're we just adjusted those so we're actually
013the category not in the columns okay sorry no problem okay and then the same would grow for group we then adjusted Group C forward into where they would fall into the new buckets as well and that's out of town out of town so the reason that we're saying the church or water B Symphony Orchestra would be charged out of town is because they're not in town they're out of town they're not for PR they're out of town so like Laurel music camp for example is under camp matat but they're out of town they're not for PR they still be out of town rate but if they had 80% middle they would move up right because I I just want to make sure that we're not like creating some sort of yeah bias if they're serving
014our students I think you all know my position but if they're serving our students of our community and those even even community members and that's 80% M very southberry I would really like them to all be treated the same some of these folks may fall into into B we didn't NE drill down we didn't really Rost that so an example so some of those folks may very well fall to be but at least for the moment we're kind of least lumping them together then when you scroll down a little more you'll see for example we took the so if we if we take the rates that we we go up in Bui Revenue by about $2,000 based on we currently collect today $117,000 but what we were trying to capture was inside the Cal rate
015so in reality everyone pays the Castillo fee rate for weekend work so we were looking at that on kind of a sliding scale so we took a $3 rate if we up that rate for c for weekend work so that would get us another $700 or so which then give you a new Revenue projection appro $21,000 so we're saying sorry je no that's right we're saying that we would add non because codian like contractual everyone so if you're during the week we have codian till 11 o'clock at night we don't charge you're great if you any week can work open the building up obviously there's a Saturday and Sunday rate and a holiday rate as well it's a minimum four hours um we try to split it up so two groups come in try to
016work if we can kind of divide up the money a little bit but that's kind of just what we have but everyone pays that rate park and rec calls up we pay that rate so in the land of things that we think could be adjusted you could put an additional increase on that rate of $3 and that would kind of help you offset um some of the revenue changes there know some of the for $2000 example that you know because that that would be money we would be collecting on top of the C custodian yeah that would be like almost like make a difference again I do think you do have risk of losing some groups I don't know they are um so that will give you at least an additional item there to kind
017of help get case as a as a lever for yeah that those rates are voted by the board um in June so so just to kind of wrap up my textual understanding of this in this proposal every single group that serves our students in our community that is nonprofit school affiliated and local yes but that 80% of them serving us would have no fees except Cod everyone has a Cod if it's a weekend weekend work so that would groups that are for profit but local would have a fee yes and groups that are out of town would have a fee unless of course that out of town group had 80% midle grade middle right and with that change we talk about that yeah it was not that was the one you mention with the church
018so let's leave that off theable so out of town for profit those two groups have fees everyone who is in town and nonprofit has no fees and you're saying that math tells us that the revenue does to change effect post a little bit yes I you know that my position is I don't care about this Revenue because I think it's rounding here but just in um okay but this is a 20 this is the 25% Adder right I just want to be I I want to understand the the reason that the fees that we're getting more fees is because we grossed up the out of town for-profits 25% I just want to be cognizant of the fact that some of us felt that 25% on the for profit in ad ofon was too much um
019and that you know if this was sorry to me do this in real time like if this was 20% right that like can we do this can we run this at 20% 20% increase or 15% increase to just truly understand because I think that was part of the reason this didn't move forward is because we felt like we were really putting too much pressure on the for profit I think too it's it's like we always say it's a dial so if you take the toal rate to $5 you could drop for example I mean I'm against adding two parts of the conversation here because I love your summary jeck love it wanted that out of slide this meeting so really appreciate you at least like training it that way very helpful um and I recall
020a conversation that if we bump up those other um fees too much 25% it could what we anticipated as projected by do could actually go away because the cost are too high we could find other facilities so that's a risk and something have to look at but I think the second piece of the conversation is really where we were going kind of back and forth and that's the piece related to the gate fees so regardless of what we do with the facilities and I think that and I've said this before I'm going to say again I think that this is such a noble um initiative I think it's critically important it benefits our students and I think we heard everyone at the table my recollection knows that this needs to be tackled it's that other
021component right and that's the piece while we have this great summary we then need to look at how are we going to H tackle the people that are doing pay for play and paying for the gate fees because that is a significant portion that hits families students that are in our school not taking away anything that is in here and it's put down and that's the piece where I think we have to find the balance because collectively that is a much larger impact budgetarily right and I think that was the initiative why we're here today saying we have to make sure the Sprint to use your words has to get done so that we have a level set of what we would like as a board going into the budget season in March so I
022just want to put that other side of the coin there that there's a lot of consensus from my perspective that this is an important initiative that people are behind but we have to find that balance and I think that's the that's the piece right so I would say wholeheartedly what youve said what we've outlined is great but how do we weigh that against the other Revenue piece and I think if we can look at that and then say is there an opportunity where we can adjust some of the to play or G then I think it's a more Equitable conversation and the thing about for a second let let Joe and Josh do their presentation and then we'll have our discussion I appreciate this like I just want to I trying to like understand where
023yeah and just one thing that I just wonder there's right now the current policy is a Caro if you're an autotown organization that is servicing the local kids there can hit Jeep so the way the policy sits like kind of in our draft there's no way to move them lower so to your point if you so if you out let's say I was and I was a coach I was running an organization on a water break but I was I was using your facilities you're I'm 80% midle sof kids but I'm still out of time I still fall the cheap that's for example a baseball team INE doubt in the um but the um if they are they're an out of town profit organization um we don't have any of their rosters but you know
024I'm assuming that a large portion of the students or the kids that play on that team are our students and Liv to I recommend we tackle the 90% though yeah yeah doesn't stall the whole project in those but it's I was we adopt was right so that's that's yeah um so there's a couple of other documents that we put in here um that I'm not going to spend a ton of time unless we need to but uh Mr Marks who couldn't be here tonight did put together a pretty nice research document that took um some of our peers to put their policies so if people want to dig into this um it's there um did anything stand out on that you thatth pointing out just did actually so we pulled a specific PID out of
025region 12's policy that's your packet so uh region 12 does two things here's an example of how very organized their um bees it gets a little bit to the conversation um that we just had so we pulled two pages out of this policy and put them in the packet you have for you tonight um the second one is their actual Fe structure um what I would point out the bottom of this has their custodial staff um and so they are um well we talked about maybe three or5 sear charge there substantially more um but we can move in this direction and that would negate um that potential risk with uh rental fees again we built the model that you saw tonight was built on what we collected in the past I have no way of
026project whether or not those people will continue to rent from us whether they go up or whether they find somebody else or whether they're just not going to use space Also there but also it's interesting they list a during during the week rate reality you don't charge if your FES are here so that I haven't talked to the finance director out there I could certainly give her bu um but it would seem to me like if you use the facility they almost kind of like tack out a custodial rate for cleaning or something of of of the area you're in so that makes or Associated cost Associated cost yeah that's like how they that it makes it much more clear yeah so the reason we P this out is because the model that you have
027kind of mirrors a little bit of this as an example and then we talked about this a little bit that related but parking lot so for example like use are parking lot we have clubs sometimes that we'll use like I can't think of the there's a um a summer program that uses kind of like a bus stop um in South par um yeah but we don't charge for that it's a parking lot I'm not going to like you know so they have a parking lot $100 motorcycle something yeah maybe kind they they they use it like yeah three four times a day not last year yeah guess could have that I'm going suggest needed them say that sof the last piece that I would highlight is we started to talk a little about other student
028fees to your point this isn't necessarily U relevant to tonight's conversation these feudes are collected from students um I shouldn't say that I guess some of this list U like parking fees and pay is on here but then we started to list out other fees that students might have to pay most these are high school students um and most of these go to like a yearbook fee a graduation that pays for their caping down you have an instrument like these aren fees that are currently in our budget they don't touch our budget but we started talking about just other fees that exist um the payto playay fee um we have listed as Sports here but middle school students who pay a pay play fee for music um but we just started this parking lot document
029and listed fees there um so if there are other fees that you didn't know about that we didn't capture um but we wanted to honor the request the after Fe even if it wasn't Rec time to tonight has a quick question about Rel this um is there a way for families who aren't able to pay those fees like I know for sports like are all of those fees kind of covered underbrella there's two different ways that um that happens so one would these students that qualify for free IND lunch then we do have like hardship cases where social workers or others in district and kind of refer a family to ask for supports do we have so we started to down that pth a little bit um and it's there's a lot of clubs it's
030all over the place some of those clubs we don't charge clubs for space so it would be um if you're in a club going on a field trip or require some materials a lot of that is self-sufficient there's no fees that the districts collects um and most those clubs set their own Fe R so is it just parking on here that we go to to the revenue everything so where Shar point where that not I'm confused then so that's so you pay to play and then if you want to go watch your child you pay to go in the date but that's everywhere my son plays a basketball PID $40 it is it is I don't know kind part of conversation okay so then we'll move to the the board discussion part now you but
031well no but it's it's a good point right because the GE fees which we didn't really talk about too much right the geek fees is something that should be considered right because that is revenue that is brought in I every place charges it though so it's not something you can take away right you can't take away say okay no gate fees because then we would lose the fees from all the these towns that come in there and we could this is exactly why we had such a robust discussion a couple wees ago exactly we have to look at big picture because we have parents that are play pay they're paying to play yeah paying to park they're paying to watch the kids play the sport they play for and then we're paying to the facilities
032so that's why agreed agreed so I didn't even know till recently right this is like maybe on me that there's an app where you can bet a family pass and you can go to everything for one price I've definitely given the district a lot more because we go and watch and support my son place for mobilio his games here at the high school so we pay every time we walk in now I have whatever I paid something and now we can go watch that so maybe there's a there's like a balance but I I just don't know where that lands at so I have a question on gate P because my children are in middle school and we don't do this yet um are there are we gate fees for the same organizations that have
033rented the fields or the gate fees for p Rock football pom Rock basketball which is part of the school organization so gate fees are net zero right so we collect gate fees as um listed here um and those eight feys show up this is what they cover so we collect about 45 actually I last year we had net a little more um I these organizations have so to in a in a sense there are two conversations going on it is how we handle these organizations to rep facilities and how we handle the we don't have any groups that cross over where someone is renting the field for x amount of dollars and they're paying gate fees unless that that organization charg not things to us correct okay I just wanted to make sure that they
034were that they were separate so like high school football charges G but High School football is dance on there charges for tickets they their facilities okay I want to make sure that they were cross thank you I just think too some of the thing with the the reason we were talking about gate fees is some of the emails that came in from parents were saying that we were the only ones were charging G and that's why we asked to have a little survey of the other districts which did really we not the only one charge it's what we charge them for that diffr the schools I mean we're not necessar an outlier but no I just I get how it can seem like that you're always paying something right you're paying what ever it is
035and it to me it was just like money was coming in from all these different places and then going out and what was revenue and what was n and it just made it hard to get a handle so I mean it looks like some of these places do five do instead of eight what do we five it's five agnostic of location or sport like five for football and five lacrosse five for basketball and oh so it's it's really the $1 Fe we don't get it and is any gate fee ever used for I what I would call it like infrastructure or like longterm so so for example the new scoreboard the football field will be bought um like five or six years were saved um so let's say we collected this is the chart that
036we put Finance tonight let's say we collected 52,000 a year and 8 who SP 45 um that Delta would be saved year to year and then so this this runs through Student Activity fees it doesn't touch our budget it doesn't touch Revenue it doesn't touch cost the question would be if you reduce a would we then subsidize it from we operating that's that's di so if we reduce it fee somewhere that pays for something we have to increase it fee somewhere um because the officials and things are really this is kind of how it moves outside other than S SC what else might be pleas go to official paying officials so like that's so for efficient games all all those those those costs come out of that those need do you have a ledger like
037that other one on the C fees I I don't for this I mean we can easily do that that's not in the a official for games no that those those come out of the so you know how many GES you're going to have and how many officials you need does that figure to your calculation of what to charge we have enough G to my knowledge in a lot but I mean somay you might be like I ran out of money to pay somebody because the G AR high like yeah like I just it just seems but do point was like I can tell you said I mean you would think if you have a schedule of activities and it would not be part of the Athletics budget not forish and it's not but that's a
038decision right yeah again easily add $50,000 to the budget take a these deser or against that but that'll be an example what no different than you change pay to play if you puppet Revenue go up bud lower you go the other way you reduce them you'd have to add money Athletics same thing with security right so security is an add-on not part of the budget but we know we need it because there are requirements yeah out here theoretically it could all be budgeted and it would be a plus $50,000 we thought part of this pring question dealing with the rental rates was kind of least the where the the board always has the pur to adjust Revenue inside the budget so if adjust um what our pay play rates are we' say look it's going
039to cost 10,000 you have to PO it so that's kind of where where this hard policies the play like you said you know you heard about P2 advisory you were saying that you were concerned about dat of play it's the same thing dial down the P to play then we have to increase it the cost in the budget another and I think that's why we got into the conversation we did the last whatever November 25th meeting because it is right it is this balance so the facilities whether or not we want to move forward yay or may on this I think the other side of the equation right is pay to play and dat please and and what we're willing going into the budget cycle to to consider so I think part of this discussion
040involved like what is what are our facilities for like what is school for right are we a revenue generator are we a community resource you know like what is our um philosophy on that and I think that really does dictate like how we handle this because it you it used to be like an idea that we're here for education and great athle Athletics music um like those all play a part in education too but it's kind of like a little bit above and beyond reading and writing right so we typically have had a philosophy where these organizations or sports or whatever music has some skin in the game not a huge absorbent cost like it is for private clubs um but it's it's something so I guess like it depends on where the board what
041the board feels about that you know like what are community resource or Revenue generator or something kind of in between in my thought process on some of that is I actually don't care if we put fee on the nonprofits as long as it's Equitable across our organizations right now it's not Equitable across the organizations and it creates disparity on how we treat people and that's my biggest issue I don't feel that we should charge fees but if that's the place to go right these buildings are paid for by our taxpayers and there are for our children in this community you heard lacrosse football all these various people come to these meetings and talk about how their programs are helping your children prepare for high school how everything that they're doing they're partnering with coaches at
042the high school to learn skills to learn how to get here and be successful they need space to do that and it's crazy that our students go to other towns to do this because they can't afford right because they try to keep their cost low to be in our school in our stat so that's right like let's make it Equitable regardless I totally agree I think for me though then it it would be really ideal to try and look at the pay to play and or the gate please on the good side and that would be maybe throwing it out there would pay to play go up slightly but then things get removed right just somewhat offset Optics on that every time you go and watch your kid you're paying a gay um do we
043reduce pay to play to zero and just to GS right and and not become a revenue generating kind of item but it's just an additional supplement like you said that balance and I'm not saying that any of those things are maybe the path we should go down but I do think that there's so much conversation in that space um I think I I've said this before I a few GE advisories now it's come up it's been a significant portion of the time of um of those meetings so and with all the emails relative to this I think we at least ow that part of the community a little bit of air time to understand how we can maybe address some of their concerns very similar to what I feel like we went through our game
044years so two things on that um they're separate one is there a way to because I think what happens is you know you go to the game with you know the crit kid and it's two parents in the be a gr well that's $15 or they're $18 that adds up really fast is there a way and this might be a record keeping nightmare but to put that towards you know like or to cap that you know hey you've already spent this this amount we're not going to keep dodging you for you know almost $20 again G when you could have gotten this pass for so yeah one one is you know at least half of that 45,000 comes from other people coming to our games right because we do sell a good amount of passes
045but to your point salary we could take that $110 family pass and you could make it $30 you could make it you get a family pass free with you know your pay to play or add $30 to pay to play get the family pass for free and then that specific example came up like you know um someone was watching like a sibling swimming and they brought friends and between the parents and the siblings and the friends it was a really expensive day to watch their child in their athletic program while they've already paid for that so I I think that to me feels like at least we're we're listing right I think that makes a lot of sense and I I want to say that I do not think we should be seeking Revenue in
046any of these Endeavors we seek to cover operational costs like custodial and out of town needs to pay their their share because they're not paying tax into these schools for the taxpayers of these two towns paid for these schools these facilities just like parks that are out there you're not they're not charging you to go to Med Park right you go to the park now there's other Nuance to that I think the P to play idea built into the um gate ke thing I think there's something there um we know that it costs money to play sports at at all different levels even in organized high school and stuff like that but I do agree that's frustrating to have to keep doing out funds feels like you're being nickel and died and I think that
047communities have invested a ton of money to this region to these facilities and nickl and D go right to me so I hope we can move the other concern that I wanted to bring up because I generally clop agre with that with the question of what we are what I think we're a community resource but we're I also don't want to become the Arbiter of this team gets this and and this team it's there they Shi priority like I like I mean you know if every Sports 80% get you know 80% of 15 that could be a really subrace so like I don't like this lacrosse coach I'm going start my own lacrosse team and then who's who's deciding to get St time um and and I would that's a different operational right that's what
048what I'm saying is that's why I don't want to get into I don't think that's our job as the bo bed and that's why I would really like to Loop in parks and W and have then because because it can I mean I've been around Sports long enough to know back in Snowball the problem with Parks and Rec it becomes political right the park and recits on boards that are elected officials right so there there's a political component I right so that's why it's like take that like we're not political component right we're School serving children there is space at any given nights in our schools I you know Maran had asked me months ago I mean p the turf in the auditorium right like are there's is there ever competing want like fighting over
049that no but if you make everything free which I'm okay with I just don't think we should be the one decided yeah but the order of priority and I've said this in finance a few times the order of priority would not change so the order priority would still be like schools can have you know use of it then I can't remember what it is Park and W comes next and then it would be the nonprofit so the the priority wouldn't change do that we just serve our students it does I just don't want to get in I mean if there aren't if there aren't fees associated with playing it makes it much easier to start a competing organization and I don't think that we should be the ones deciding this organization gets us and that
050gets that I'd like to take that piece away us right I agreed and totally heard right I just I there's space in our schools and our spaces right even you come here on the weekend the CH Fields open you know five six hours I think there's optionality for them I think people go elsewhere like lacrosse goes to post and uses that post because it's post charges them $70 for the whole day we charge them $100 an hour so they pay for a bus to bus their CH our children to another to right to a college that's offering them because they want the children to excel so like to me it just looks most bad of us right where we're busting our children to other places to use facilities because other people are more willing to
051give it right I I mean I do think we need more facilities we need more CH Fields right we need when you go to these other schools they have these beautiful complexes and hopefully you know as Josh as we plan right kind of our next phase that long-term planning we're talking about when we were looking at building a new school part of that is facilities for our children right that's more turn field more field space so that all the children can grow and develop more Auditorium SPS in these schools but can we go back to Sally's comment I'm not quite sure I fully understand like I understood your concern about and I agree with you like I don't want to be in a place that we have to be the decision maker on yes you
052can or no you can't right um when you had said you you said like that snowball what I would just want to make sure well I think it's not that hard hard if it's to say well I'm going to start a b rece that's you know little very lacrosse because my kids play lacrosse and I played in college and no I want per time I I just don't think that we should be the people that are deciding if there are competing organizations because we do have two towns here and yes a lot of things are um when I grew up we weren't alive someone the South very sharp so we have to go to Watertown because they let very team like I think that there is a um I think that there is an an
053inherent difficulty that could come up and I just don't want the board to have that job I just don't think is that risk so how would you what would your proposal be or to because what we're talking about here ex that risk it exists but you it gets a lot bigger because the 8020 not just when there's not you know like it's easier to request space when you're not for it but if people want like right like mobilia runs a great program this is PID right and he fills those spots right so like if people because running an organization right and I think there's a lot of presidents of organizations it is a lot of work you spend hundreds of hours coordinating dealing with parents making sure you're serving to the best to all of
054the children in the community right like to say it's easy to serve 513c like it's exhaustive right and excruciating that you're trying to do the best for the kids I don't think people are just doing that like because they want free space if they feel that their model is just charge more right if their program is so good like mobilo is a for-profit organization right and he's the high school coach here he's great so people will pay for it and he pays for space because right so I just think that right I don't think that people are just going to open up all of these ones and that we're going to have a I don't want to be the one beside you right yeah that's right I I have a question and I would that
055I don't I don't understand and I think it kind of goes a little bit to your point Sally that if people want to not pay fees going to the park and rest is an option right and that has historically been the way it it goes like if you don't want to pay fees then you can go through the parking rack why doesn't everyone just go through the parking rack so like so not actually the case for middleberry parking rack they have to adopt it it has to go through their political process it's not a fair forall situation at the Middlebury Park in so there have been programs brought to them and they have turned it down because why AR they fighting the battle there then I mean I I think it can I think it
056can be F I think middlebury's a lot of battles going on right everyone knows right so that that is happening too but it's like when you have politics dictating paths for children and here's the thing and I like I keep saying I don't care it's middle it's middle right but I don't care if we charge everyone the same or everything nothing just needs to be fair we can't say okay go through Park and rack have them put a seal on it now you're indebted to some political situation versus organizations who are putting time and effort in to serve our children should should be allowed to do that as they desire they have their own board for a reason right let them run that way instead of being dictated by parking wck and then there's charge
057fees like so you're a middleberry resident say I want my kid to go do something in southberry I got to pay extra to that parking wck for Fe is for them because the pomog organization is out of southberry but now you pay extra right you pay extra for pth swim it's like unfair to the the residents of the other towns as well cuz they upch charge you when you're out of town I think the thinking is that people in South you're paying taxes to run the parking wreck and if people are coming from out of then they should pay like a little bit more I [Music] think whatever I'm not like I I just don't understand why people like kind of because it's a problem heard this issue in southberry and like I know that
058that basketball switch from southberry to Middlebury but like I don't know but that was aelf issue right I think we need to make sure ours it's fair Equitable and the right way to do it regardless of that town Poli taks in need of it yeah I think to your point I'm sorry to your point I think it's we have an existing policy is it the right time to update the policy based off of the conversation I still don't want to look side of G right and all that good stuff I have a policy it is on us to make sure that it is reflective what we want to be and and I think what's G to ultimately happen is that we' set the fees and then PNC surprise will have to like make it pretty
059right and like for instance this policy right now does not have memor I written down the priority um that's just been so let's put it in the for example there's also the unwritten which I respect every years that middle Park and R has first shot at middleb buildings s Park first shot so makes sense but I mean it's kind of Unwritten thing one other thing just close some Loop by what we folks may do with it P BR basketball would not have to fall on their park and wreck anymore because without the fee issue they then get on their own again and then they would have to go to park should be allowed to yeah because that way they would fall to a and that doesn't matter so so War groups May stand on their
060own and not be part of Park and wreck or have the need to go under Park and wreck shingle because in reality the fees s of race always quite anyway but they would be exempt from fees if they all fall and would give everyone a choice if they want to get parking W to collect right their money and they don't have their own website and their own organization own fundraising situation that can go your right par is more for the smaller classes but if you're running a nonprofit organization right you should be able to stand on your own and not be hold into people scheduling new things um and kind of running it through that way so everyone should get to the scheduling to me gets political potentially and I do think that as part
061of this there should be some prohibition about who does the scheduling because like that's where it get I don't think don't think like you know I think this needs to go back to PNC because right now if you read this and I've spent a lot of time reading this right the right now the principles are the way that it's supposed to work is you contact the principles of the school the principles to the schedule if there's a conflict the representative from say I'm organization a and Jeff's organization B you are to work it out and come up with a solution principle doesn't say like yes no like the organizations are supposed to work it out so if you think some of this and I would say m J preach to my time here I've never
062princi called group come some accept to use so I mean that's um we never had to refere Big thir field yeah we had options for basketball for of open gym space the turfield we have the only turfield in town and there's a lot of you a lot of demand for the Youth so um I don't think we've ever not been able to resolve the conflict but that has the most pressure especially in the spring we have the most athletic our own that space I think that was my concern do we have enough space for the means that we have in our region before we it it can what was that to suay the tur in the fall can that hard because football has it and when jail or soccer has it you know you're practicing
063at six in the morning yeah but our schools have priority SCH are as well they should yeah they should be able to set their times first yeah should be clearly I I agree with that it should be clear because it's hard when you're D purchas this exam practice so um I guess um is there oh sorry sorry all right go ahead um I well I just wanted to synthesize a little bit of what you said um because you know I think uh from the beginning I wanted to involve Carm in this discussion um because you know I do think that whatever I think involving them gives us more options this moment when we're talking about ourselves and we're talking about we wantable solution when we say well it could be zero Fe or whatever things
064um you know you've said before like you don't care you don't care if we charge something but if we do inherently we're going to have to go back to par and say well we decided you know that we're going to Levy this Fe um and that is going to be seen as a protocol move regardless of our intentions you know I think that that would be an unexpected outcome of this discussion of with us having it in and so I think if we're talking about we want an equitable solution now today between all of us really the only option before us is to take those thingss down to zero I do think salary has a good point you know we have possibly you know a tragedy in the comedies um when we do that um
065so you know I just that's kind of what's in my um as to what what is an outcome that we could make that isable really seems to um disagree but um in terms of booking space um I I do think it is going to be difficult because we are two challeng of pretty good size with a pretty good number of sports being played by our youth and we have very little resources and we can't pull on the CH field or another Auditorium um out of a sa um and that's you know I so again I I do think you know amongst ourselves but also amongst all of the youth organizations in our two towns like we need to have a discussion not just with the board event but with towns about what is required to
066you know what what the citizens of the towns want and need and if it is something that um we bring outside organization like why or um whether we feel better by having a big complex in our schools like that is a decision that we need to make longer term I don't know if that doesn't seem like something we're g to work out um but you know those are some of the issues um that I kind of see the chorus that kind of keep going after this discussion um got there yeah so what you're saying is that you want to reach out to the parking Rec of both towns and see what their position would be on I'm saying if there's not consensus amongst our coordinators that those fees should be zero then I think the
067next logical step is to invol PRS and rights what we're here here's the problem we're trying to solve we are trying to be Equitable being Equitable with being you know charging either pars passes through fees to their organizations and that's how we handle it I think there's a lot of but that was that a where she was saying right they're a they're B right now so she was saying I keep saying let me I just want to clarify because being Mar so confused because I keep saying I don't care just want to be Equitable Heather is saying that the only way that would be fair right now for parkner is the proposal that Josh originally put up that came out of Finance was to make a R keep me honest Joe right a all no
068charge including no energy exactly isn't Park and W in3 it is yes yes but I was saying if we charge everyone the same so if you charge Park and W and Lacrosse all exed $25 that before we did that we would have to we could reach out I said I thought in The Proposal not is already a no charge so what do we really charge I think the what we've been discussing about you know what has sounded like to me all this time that we've use the word Equity is that program that runs through Park and you know that we shouldn't be giving um fuel to whatever you know whatever politics is going on that makes uh an organization decide to become a nonprofit her to run through middle bar parking her to run through
069South like we shouldn't be creating a policy that creates those problems totally we're not but what's been put forward doesn't create that problem because it would be in the no charge so the existing policy has that problem this policy potentially removes that but I do think just to represent what you know other board members have said too is there is a flat feed or some other feed structure that we want to discuss then I think we'll make to bring our town we're g to raise the fee for the parking wre yeah we'd have to consult with the parking W like I and I I said I said this in finance too I'm not in favor of raising the people because the towns pay our bills so I guess what I'm trying to do is like
070Focus discussion on where right right you want to think I commented yet um but um so I just want to remind people again that um so Equity is in the eye of a holder the reason we added these a long time ago was because people felt the budget in its entirety was unequitable or inequitable because say if you're inherited Village you're paying your they thought the Halls were goldplated and everything right so that was it was a mechanism to get budgets so just a reminder um I I I hear you um with the pulling in park and wreck but that to me is just a just such a hard know like I do I don't want their peanut butter in my chocolate like like it like I we just we can barely get done the
071work that we're supposed to get done and I just feel like that just that just opens it up um uh I don't think you would mention consensus I I would love consensus but I don't think we have to have consensus we just have to have enough vs to move something forward um I'm fine with the and I you know I like to start talking about like what's the next steps but I feel like now we're just sort of maybe going around and round I'm fine I agree like it I like where the new policy is at it can be it can be Equitable to be more Equitable right so the whole not for profit being put in um you collapsing the M know the one group um I do agree it's a rounding error I
072like the 0 like I don't I don't want to have I don't want to lose Revenue but I I don't want to keep talking about $177,000 either so yeah 8020 is is is great um we can make $177,000 up somewhere else I don't know but I think as far as and and and a lot of the facility use fees to really a lot of it is for the pre- nth graders right it's for when they don't have these clubs so I feel like in a way that does if we want to talk about something Equitable I feel like this policy affects them I could be wrong but affects them sort of more and we're we are we want them to take little swishers or whatever because they're going to be feeding like our basketball team
073at the high school somay so think I'd love to just get consensus on the the policy that was Sol we could maybe just move move that along um we can always throw levers and budget seas and if we want to change the fee you know go up or go down to make it easier for people to do have to pay a feed to to afford it um pay for play actually I was thinking I you know I haven't really seen people actually like it doesn't seem like could be out of touch like like that that much to me there's a cap for pay to play um if you're in a lot of sports there's cap I think there's a family cap too right so uh um so I think I again we can move a
074dial at budget season but I think P for play is is okay um and we also offer assistance the gate fees maybe you know we have the annual pass if we want to again maybe we can just like we we into this maybe charge you know if you have someone a bunch of kids or they're under 18 or whatever it is or students maybe they get in for free um something along those lines uh so I you know I really would like to see kind of you know how do how do we move how do we move this um how do we just oh and lastly do with with these speeds I don't I don't think they should be zero though the the facility speeds because I do I do think people do have to
075just have some skin in the game so we can we can make them Fair like you know Equitable but I think there should be something just to the game so I would love to be able to moving even parking uh where what was the policy now it's no charge for parking char No Fe they do pay cost right I'm just reading what it get in the game yes yeah so the way it is some yes just the policy the way it is and I also think we wanted to I don't know how You' enforce it but charge them if they overbooked and then didn't show up which I think that's really appropriate because you you screwed let's charge sure just on the bottom so that's my 10 move it but Heather do you have anything
076that you want to add no this point no um did we talk I I did want to address pet Sally's concern a little bit too because one thing I was thinking was stores there are going to be a lot of people who want to use it and like other like I have seen other parts other uations do you our facilities you know they're limited resources lied um and you know there there is like scheduling software you know you could have a portal that that would be kind of like a non-biased portal that people could go through and request make these requests is that something that we have or could have we have't right now we're just in the process kind of growing it out yeah yeah so right now it's not public facing there opportunity
077we just migr year I would be very interested in that especially in this direction um can I can I question I'm so sorry um that that list that you flashed up early that had um other you know other things that we could talk about um I do you know I know we're trying to focus in on this policy and this schedule so I'm only going to mention briefly I think that one of the things that bothers people the most about these fees is that they come as a surprise absolutely um and I really you know I just went through high school orientation I've been through Middle School Orientation I really think like this being part of you know the paperwork slides the presentations that you get um as you come into these different environments I
078think that would be so helpful for families to have um and be able to reference because you know some of these fees you know they you're going to see them at whatever school you go to in the state of Connecticut um but I but I think what's annoying about them is you don't really think about them until you know your kids needs a yearbook people it's a $65 yearbook really so I think you know having these a little bit more up front read your book in the summer but can I give you back on that because I think one big ticket item that is missing but the line of sight and planning purposes should be included in that and I totally Echo your comments I feel like we had this conversation like five years ago
079um is the uh the uh field trips that are approved um because we see we have the line of side those a year before on the international ones and there's some standing ones M School even at the elementary school people should know that this is what we're anticipating for the year I think that even for your middle school experience or your high school experience this is dances BR dance estim some estimat especially washing trying to get people like two or three year lead time you know I know for the sixth grade classroom they talk about about the fifth grade orientation down but I agree especially bigger trips that a right but those are options right the bigger trips are right I would throw one more thing in um if we're going to talk about Equity
080amongst groups too I think it has to be this is what they charge this is what they get nobody gets any more or less so we set something this is this is what it is there's no extras because I know there's a lot of talk about you know this group gets this this group gets that um but like even like storage so like if we have certain groups that have storage but certain groups that don't we have certain groups that ask for storage not I real we have like Grand than stuff right now but like going forward if everybody's paying the same thing it's not we have to talk about the fact that this is what you get everybody puts it or you don't get it no there's got to be some discussion in there
081as well limited space yeah or it's an add-on or something you know whatever don't not to make it messy depends a little bit so the fuel storage pretty kind of cut and dry we can give you 10 by 10 space in the storage shed when it gets to like so the cheerleading mats for example we share the high school and the community organization shared when it gets to like pack swimming and high school swimming some of that so I think that just want to this you know transparent certain things are easy um which when you get to consistency it gets really hard to to manage unless we say like to rent space in our storage facility this is what that is that's it's got to be equable it's got to be same we have a
082storage issue at high school we have things in lockways now because we have no space so I'm just trying to think like long term in that respect too so that we're not pigeon into a corner of we made this you know side deal that's going to last this long and then another team comes in and says we would like the same thing why can't we get that that's unfair I just don't want if we're talking about Echo we got to keep it there everybody gets the same opportunity before they and but Jos Point like on that right like the ma that the high school girls youth were paid by Youth Cheer so the maths that are our region 15 high school students used were not paid by the high school they were paid right by
083Youth Organization that's something they can Deals they should be like ones done can I just go back to what question sorry could you lot you must have mentioned the tury and I yeah right I read it there's two Fe or two locations that we charge kind a supervisory the first is the auditorium here where you know if you want to rent our Auditorium you can't dis command and use the the sound board and the light board you know you have to hire one of our staff um we charge that same fee on the tur um and it's historically I would argue that it was inconsistent and one of my um push backs I guess against the process was that we said you need a Turf supervisor but if we couldn't find one we let organization
084run um for the auditorium for example if we don't have somebody that can run the booth you can't have it so if it's important enough to say you have to have it then you shouldn't be able to use it without that person because then how important is it so we do think that moving forward there's a Nuance as we get a new U scoreboard as we have um new lights um as we have a new audio system there might be the same piece um but then it would be if you want to use the scoreboard as part of your rental here's the fee for that person um just like it is for the auditorium but historically we charged at B to have a turfield supervisor where some organization bring their own uh we could also
085look at like a security deposit so the origin of that was some people had rented the field and had not taken care of it so a solution that was put into place this was you know again before Joe I were here but at that supervisor it's just been up F consistent was that supervisor cleed up after as well making sure making sure yeah they weren't actually providing service they were just making sure when they left right what about locking and unlocking supervisor do that so that there is I mean can can we get rid of the need the supervisor then or you said by withs I think that's the Sunday stal is the most complicated because we don't have Stans on site so you rent the tur field on a Sunday and we don't have
086supervisor then we work under custodian's contract is it a 4our minimum sense so they so they get charged a custodial fee for a Sunday you have to pay a 4 hour minimum even if we're just coming in unlock eight in the morning and lock the G at night right so that's a piece that we have to work out a little bit on how we provide access really on Sundays so the short answer is I think we need to rework what the purpose of that tur field super ADV visor is and I do think the opportunity of the new equipment down there we're going to put in a $50,000 scoreboard we're going to put in a $30,000 sound system you know whether or not we're just going to turn the keys over to an outside organization
087and say you know go ahead and use it I think as a conversation we would never do that our sounding and lights in Auditorium so I do think like some of is going to be organic and that that conversation sh so what you're saying is that Turf fee supervisory fee is not part of this discussion tonight it's not it's not in any of our that's on the hourly with all right so I guess does anyone else have any comments before we start kind of see where we are no all right so then I guess um I hear a lot of consensus and there what has been there was consensus back in November for um not charging the nonprofits that are for region 15 students um a fee we still would have pay the custodial Associated
088cost but not a fee um but where are people with the parking W I'm sorry the gate F so that was going to be one why one comment because I wholeheartedly agree when when St is thinking like where our next steps are I'm fine with with what's been proposed I just want to make sure that we have a really open conversation if there's something we can do for families related to the gate fees that are doing payer play Come budget cycle because I do think that that should be looked at and I like um what you had mentioned Josh about maybe we can if half the revenue is coming from south car residents that are already paying the play even if we cap or offset or do something there and then we get the revenue
089from out of town you know people that are watching that I think becomes a little bit more more I think fair to the families that are paying so I I would just like to make sure that we can keep that conversation open and go into budget season with that in an open mind um given some of the conversation and I think that Sally example was right on point with some of the concerns that were presented on in some other conversations during advisor yeah like even if we i' like really like to add $30 like or it's a choice right for $30 you get the past to bring your family or whatever and then that kind of shuts it down right so you're paying extra $30 for the past you get entrance to everything you're not
090asked to pay to walk through the gate again and then right that kind of solves the the family issue where pay but what's the cost of that to us well that's we have to model I as part of the budget right we're talking about LS right when we come to the budget season we see it that that $30 versus whatever it is now that adding the custodial three to five Adder on the weekends like those are all levers I think that we can like call right if we have a budgetary so it's not like so would be Happ this number right so I'm just thinking like budget numbers because in this number you already have a large amount of region 15 families that are buying these passes so there be some reduction um but you
091know but it wouldn't be I don't 15,000 let's say you know we will model it and get exact but um again it wouldn't be exact be a projection based on how many you've sold the last few years but um you know it wouldn't be half of 45 it might only be 10,000 of that um if you were to take away that that the board's budget would have to pick up right fig students are already pay $20 right and a lot of our students do have their pass um so you're not losing kind of full gate LS um at every sport event um and it's it's inconsistent too so you know we have a lot more attendance at Friday Night Football game than at you know not being on our cross country team or cross country
092team's amazing it's part of to watch it has few Spectators you know we don't necessarily charge um we don't charge for um softball because the way the field set up there's no point Venture so really the geek fees are for sports that happen on the turn field because you have a single point of entry um so it would and um swimming and you know winter sports basketball um so it wouldn't be like half you know you wanted to look at like budget projections um 10 15,000 the other this is more of a tweak to the model thing you can do is night games are Co like whatever sport you're playing there's something really exciting about Under The Lights you know like there are some schools that kind of charge a little more for a night
093game you know it's it's it's versus a 3:30 this list we want you know and the idea that if you're an elementary school basketball player or middle school basketball player Bo in the bar of Entry to come to watch High School game that we want our students that aren't necessarily part of the high school to be able to come andu those as well was the sum M chair please summarize you summarize it just for the gate piece we can model like if you wanted a cost analysis we gave out gate either at $30 um I mean our pay to- playay fees are already 150 season so that bring up to 180 I mean we could model wouldn't do like a season it wouldn't like 30 extra doll a season because then they would pay more
094I would think if you had again we model but I would think if you had an athlete that played any season as a family you paid the 150 we would just give you a family class and that would allow you to come into any sport event uh home event obviously it's not going to get you into W you get into any home being um because you've already contributed you know as a family to that we Mo the revenue but 15,000 one other thing that I heard from the PTO was that they feel that the P play in the middle school should not be equal to the high school right because I guess they play less games or whatever is included 2012 2011 when we went through some budget pieces and increased the P of play
095the philosophy of the time was it shouldn't um shouldn't separate um after school activities whether it be Athletics or music but they wanted kind of equity across so it wasn't just athletes but anybody taking advantage that was that the philosophy of the topic at the high school the after school music programs are tied to courses in the high school and so they don't pay feeds for some of the like jazz band um at the high school those don't back P the play TI to coures not tie to coures charge or and is that unusual I do think that's but are we paying right like I guess maybe it doesn't matter does that go to the school or does that go to the music teacher stay afterwards right because that's goes into the revenue line M
096middle school music Middle School yeah so here's what the budgeted amount and actual out for each of the um pay to play pieces does that include triber chorus is that all of those things it's all those things okay because I was like do we have a break Place Sports Middle School versus high school we could I don't have it on same amount of money is I know that's but there kids and team I just to because I'm wondering what it looks like if it's a $100 but they have like like less I know I'm saying is right so I guess my point is that we're gonna increase P to cover gate FES or something like that I was just like I would I would kind of like look at maybe doing only High School right
097no and I was thinking also Middle School often I've noticed um don't have referees yeah parents are like hello there's nobody here wait what was sometimes the middle school teams do not have like a referee so you show up and you play a game and it's the two coaches the coach doing it and it's frustrating for the kids and coaches because they're not getting coaching because they're having to do the job with refere and they're not getting a break on that's paper plate Middle School like now I'm totally like this is down open do we still have the videos for no but I'm just sitting there saying like we're we're generating I don't like that's that term generating revenue revenue generating stream I get it we have to manage our money and and everything but
098going back to what do we stand for very hard for me to sit here and think that we are charging middle middle school families to play for sports with me and I had a referee and for music so I think we add that to what we could potentially work at and make modifications and if it is $155,000 that's not even around our to use your words money but it's not8 million budget1 million budget like 2011 2012 had some budget failures I it was more of a symbolic thing I think when you look at it from a practical standpoint yes like it's yes it's not all revenue matters but but in the brand scheme of things it the impact of the kid to have to pay to play and Jazz Dan like yeah it just like
099it impacts a lot of also talking creating situation where middle schooler could join a 501c3 jazz band and use our facilities for free and still be prepared to play jazz you could start that band that so you were asking about where we are where the next steps are I think the next steps in my opinion are moving this policy forward for a vote support then PNC can do the the process pie but this has to move forward before we're in the in the isn't this is this part of this isn't part of the policy it's a the ending first and second I think we move forward fee schedule and then we execute the policy of it but I want the fee schedule in place before next if we agree on before the next U year
100starts right so that that would we would go into it with the new schedule well and can we have a conversation on when this starts right because there's a dance group that is trying to right compete and there's spat for them to do so the $75 usage fee right puts a hamper on the affordability because the youth organizations sponsor children right and not everyone can pen so then when you only have you know I'm just making numbers up people they kill me but like right if you're sponsoring children right who can't pay and then there's P the program could run the negative and we don't allow programs to run in the negative so those end up getting canell because you can't run a program in the negative so like I guess understanding and making a
101decision on when this will change impacts children who are trying to kick off programs for their March SE so that all I would ask is us just be transparent because then that changes when whether someone can run a program or not can I just make that op it sounds like we somewhat near consensus that we would want this potentially to go to a board so I sit here and say well we have to go first and second read that's our policy and it would be the schedule the schedule would just be voted on it's not it's not a policy it's a but we I do think that we need to have a policy that reflects this conversation like we should have um our policy reflect the priority like I think that's very important um and
102you know the yeah I'm suggesting that we don't wait for that to P this schedule we separate the two to answer Shannon's question then wouldn't it start and minut it's approved by the board I mean that would be my proposal yeah which would I mean if that's next Monday right we don't to meet again tonight so s the second piece to move forward I think we should do it a very similar exercise to collapsing payto playay and um e Feast as well as payto play you know U strategy across the board middle school high school and I think the way this documentation was brought together and we looked at the finals and we looked at how it operates I think what I'm not Su we have to have another meeting like this on that piece
103but I think we need to make sure that there is an audience for pay to play and um need to be part of this what do you mean an audience this group like whether it's a finance committee or take time with the board or whatever that is we don't have to have another special meeting on it but we do need to make sure we meet on it and address it it can't just ripped up well we're continuing it now that's fine too I'm good with here all night I just I didn't fees we did that as part of the budget process and we did a step down over to which minimized budget that so you could look at doing something like that where you took some of those fees and redu them by portion and
104that so this page here whatever you reduce has a direct impact on the budget F so if you take any of this number down we have to increase the budget or find Revenue somewhere else so we can do however we want um but that this is the page that has a direct right so what I appreciate and I I forgot to give kudos to you guys um you spent a lot of time researching like how we can learn from what we were talking about at our November 25th meeting to make this uh a better pill to swallow I guess and the original one that was out there felt the the four profits were going to be hurt too much with the higher fees that they were going to be facing I very much appreciate um
105the looking at the associated cost and just increasing that $3 that's amazing because then it makes it budget neutral without possibly Turning Away organizations um so I really appreciate I I know the amount of time that you guys put into it because I helped you guys too so just really appreciate you guys coming up with that option that really um helps us to make this this part here not have a budgetary impact it sounds like the gate and the paper play or music or whatever that's GNA have more of a budgetary impact and I would Advocate that similar to what we did in the past that's part of the budget Workshop conversation I do you think that um and I really want to thank um finance committee for Bring It Forward because I think bringing
106this did have a broader conversation it's about the middle school and the everything else it's connected so I really think that it was great that we were able to do the special meeting I took people away from their their homes an extra night but if we can at least look at this knowing that this is a topic that we spent a lot of discussion on if we can build it into the budget Workshop I think that would be helpful um and then we can at least look at what those levers may be because we also I don't want to have this conversation like oh we need to do this we need to do this we don't know what the budget's going to look like and we don't know what other variables are out there and
107so we may as you said may have to have something tiered or maybe we can't do it this year maybe we do it next year but I think that again holistically have that conversation but I would wholeheartedly say we move forward with with this as it is so my only con certain I think we talk talk about here but um maybe make it start contingent on the budget passing this year because I just don't want to put us in a bucket of we have to pull levers that we've now negated kind of um kind of and my other concern was that I I like that it was budget neutral per se can't guarantee that the model that we built grou as long as every stays the same we we actually pick up so that was
108my concern and then because we're so about the gate fees and pay to play I don't want to give a break to the outside organizations without considering P to play in Gate fees because I don't think it's fair that the students and families of the PR for paying Fay to pay and gate fees that they should have to should shoulder the burden at the costs so if we're going to be talking about Equity I think that's still in the you know still at play um but my major concern is that when you you know we pass those because if we have to come back to the table and and L are a worri about that's what what happened par I would say though I actually think that this I think the pay to play in
109the gate field wholeheartedly that's kind of what I was trying say earlier that is tied to the budget um for this I I don't I don't see this as a as having significant impact from a budgetary perspective because I'm thinking about the pay to more like how we manage the parking wholeheartedly agree that it's all revenue and as you said Steve it's all important um I don't I don't know what what added value it is to wait until the budget who for this can get can move forward or we move it forward if the budget fails it's still something that we can revisits yeah visiting a lot what is $2,000 G to do it's Gonna Cancel kid program well no I'm not just saying that but I'm saying like it's all of it like to
110me I look at it this and PID play and gate fees and everything else that's all kind of still the same bucket say I'm not we we're just not going to move stuff forward I think we're all in agreement once we see the budget that we all want to do something about pay to play and making right but but I think the intent of this is let's let our children paid food leave run some programs and have access to space I think the link though is if you're paying $150 for your middle schooler to do something that that a Youth Organization is getting for free like I think that's the link and it's not free well that's that's the feeling go to the school I pay $150 for this and I'm pay i p believe
111sit there to teach my child Jazz I I mean I'm fighting for a dance program right now I just have children I don't even have daughters I'm explaining the link that I think Heather is pointing out in terms of I agree I'm fine doing this now but I think that like it's hard to actually say we're going to that like and look at it like I don't know how you s modify that or make make that promise we're making that promise to each other here at that table that's what we're doing right we all every every time that we stand here and say something the promises we make is everything I say at this table I need and us as professionals we have to hold that to our accountability I'm just for $15,000 I me
112I wouldn't vot against it I just I think want to point that out I have heard that from other people too like I say I think this is the right thing to do and I don't think regardless of what the budget shows we should waiver from doing this uh I also don't think there's ever going to be enough Revenue here to rectify any sort of Bud discrepancy that we're if we're this close to a budget failing really done something wrong on the so I I think we this fication so I heard s so when we do the budget um we'll break out the sports middle and high school for that Revenue line talk about a dial um we'll look at the impact of reducing the um Family passes and student passes is there anything else
113you want out sorry I think that's something like I would like to explore further if we are in but I I'm sure that it was was a budget fail they were looking to make money in some way but like I'm not saying I want to I don't know I'm curious I'd like to know more information about how we compare to other districts with that so does anyone need any further information okay and further information before we present well we're not we're not voting tonight no but I'm saying if for done here is this AA so the next meeting board yes I just want to understand that do we have to request it like do I have to send another okay what did I'm still hung up on the fact that like scoreboard was broken and
114we like didn't show up on like a capital and then paid for it out of some of these other funds like is there a way might be too that budget season the kind of um the like well like we shouldn't we shouldn't be relying on pay for play to pay for scoreboard I feel like that's kind of just be clear sorry sorry see we have too many words um gay fees to pay for a scoreboard like that just I don't know that still just blow blows my mind but I would love to know like is who's keeping track of the ins and outs of what we're taking in for gate Visa what we're actually paying for is there something else that's going to come up that that we happen to have some money somewhere that
115we need to we why isn't that just part of the Athletics budget yeah falls into a Student Activity account so it doesn't touch the District budget it it runs as a side parallel piece the reason there's a couple pieces but that's always student so it doesn't touch if if you were to do anything with that Student Activity account it doesn't necessarily touch our Revenue unless you reduce the uh gate fees to such a point that we couldn't afford the Reps and other things that we pay for out of that account then we have to subsidize that runs outside um until um 2019 we didn't break a lot of these these outs this is when we changed from from net budgeting to gross budgeting and started kind of being more transparent with the budget and we
116shipped it our financial system so that we could do that um now also had postco um some money started to build before you had like three or 4,000 you couldn't buy any big purchases um and it went to do some small repairs over time we be able to build that account when scoreboard I would say originally would have been in like a capital line um it deteriorated a little faster our ability to kind of band it and and keep it on life support started to wean and you had some money available which is why we Shi it to replace that now as opposed to waiting till we make the um I am not suggest now of any kind but like we made the booster clubs go through a process right with the policy and they
117can be audited now I'm just wondering what is what is happening in G are audited they're in a system I they've been all of ours activity accounts are part of our anual they were by the internal they were done by the internal could that be like a running balance on the financial report at Finance like some line of stud like I don't want to be surprised thatan couldn't pay some ref because gate were oh so for example if if the account isn't allowed to go into deficit so we have to make a so it's like a correct yes so in prior to I've been the account will go over you have to then take Journal fund dollars and put it towards cred account yes that's but we don't have that issue here any other concerns
118or questions before we're ready to vote next meeting right I just like it noted for the record Mr ol this is the fastest Sprint finally got to it year and a but one meeting was very successful and it speaks and I appreciate you putting it together because it's easy to keep you can down the road because there's always questions and questions and there's never any amount of questions and we just got to jump into it right we used to talk about it more regularly like this this General conversation just yeah that was a t of dat yeah it was a lot of data a lot of work thank you and appreciate that you guys coming up with that solution for sure all right um we'll move on to the comments from citizens um the Board
119of Education will recognize citizens of middleburry and southberry and citizens are asked to State their name their town of residence and to limit their comments to three minutes in accordance with region 15 Board of Education bylaw 9325 a speakers are asked to express themselves in a civil manner with due respect for the dignity and privacy of others who may be affected by their comments while it is not in the board's intent to stifle public comment speaker should be aware that if their statements violate the rights of others under the law of defamation or invasion of privacy the speaker may be held legally responsible um and just so that people know for comments um you know the board welcomes comments and is always happy to listen um but we are we are not permitted to necessarily
120respond to comments so it's not a question and answer um you got three minutes when you come to the podium just that you know the the mic is up a little here um and just write your name down we have your name accurate for our minutes and I'll have a have my timer and it just kind of keeps everyone honest to the three minutes so anyone and I want to just thank all of you for taking the time all the time you put in to have this discussion on just to play pleas um I just wanted to clarify I think this is all going to go into discussion so I do really appreciate that but just to clarify and make sure things are discussed um as you said all athletes pay play our high school
121not all parents have to pay to watch their kids play as Josh said it's really only parents whose kids are on the CH or in the swim or at the basketball court those parents have to watch their so there's really not Equity between sports you don't have to pay to go watch baseball you don't have to pay to go watch Tennis right there are facilities that are associated with those Sports and parents don't have P to watch those play so I think again if we're talking about Equity we should really look at what are we say right to have our kids participate in sports I would rather see that data PL increase to get away from gate fees so that it's dispersed to runs to all student athletes and not just some student athlet think
122it also feel Community when all members can come students seems a lot of times there's not a lot of opportunities for parents to come on the campus and every time we are coming on the campus have here um it doesn't really promote Community within our school or in the Greater Community um so I would just like to have especially the Comm really taken a look at and then as it was noted there is a huge difference I to me discrepancies you pay $150 for your middle school to play or High School child to play they are getting about half of the practices and I did record all this I'm happy to share my members because I had kids at f um the facilities are not as good at our middle schools we don't have t
123Fields there um you know the facilities are in disar most of the time um we oftentimes don't have um officials at those games and games canel they do not get rescheduled so if you have a season there's a lot of rain or it has to be G it's not you're still right so again these are things I would just like this group to discuss and really talk about I think there is ways to go to Net Zero as you get in budget season if that's necessary but I would appreciate the conversation just looking at our Sports programs and the last one I have would just like to say there are other um booster club so we talking about like these that parents should be prepared to pay booster club runs outside of the school but
124boore club events and fundraising activities do have a huge impact on our parents they're paying and what they're expected to pay it gets to parci sports um the snapshed is something that is run by clubs that could potentially be run by the school to help offset so that's going forward and I would just lastly say I would be interested to see just how the portrait of a graduate um how that came back and what that looks like how that includes things like theater sport um curricular activities and what should be what are expectations for a graduate and what of these extracurricular activities should be our thank you for your time um Peter Dawson from southberry like to address a little bit of the recent events over I've been here over 11 years with three kids
125in all the schools seem go all the way up to the senior in high school we've watched everything change here over time this Bulls superintendent everything so we we've seen a lot of different sound over that time without an attempt to accuse of failure frustration minimize successes in our region uh I believe it's time to evaluate audit I think there's a lot of missteps that have occurred while we've been here with my children with the community whether it was disciplinary whether it was education based based on High level Learners lowlevel Learners and I just would like a review I'd like it to be transparent that way any decision we make regardless of the events the recent events or not we know the right path we make that with an educated decision um it's really all
126I have to say thank you my name is J from littlebury I'm part of the basketball board was part of the board transition to becoming a personally independent we're independent we just partner with the parks organ for both towns why basketball separate is because we want to keep our kids together sh we need more eal opportunities for not Cloud across all areas um and it's really important for the kids as they transition into Middle School we have so many different elementary schools seeing them participate in basketball other activities together Girls Scouts all those sort of things it really helps the Middle School transition because we're able to keep our costs down through middleburry it's not just simply the pleas it's about insurance it's about use of scoreboards about lots of different things but we have
127over 500 kids in our program we employ over 30 high school students as well so there's a lot that goes into it if anyone's curious about the M Small prr we're happy at any point to dis more information but it's an amazing opportunity we've been told my parents that the Middle School transition is much easier on the kids because they see more kids because the kids have more of an opportunity when there's over five kids are able partipate in our program and we're able to include our high school students that don't necessarily play a competitive sport but they play just for fun at the end of the day we need opportunities for our kids have safe places and uh I think that the board is important because all we want to do is make sure
128there's more sleep places for our kids to just enjoy B kids together and that's what it's really about at the end of the day thank you thank you for those of you guys that don't know me I'm K PUO so I'm a middleberry resident my daughter goes to mes she's in fifth grade um I really appreciate all of your time I know sometimes it's a thankless job and spend a lot of hours and there's a lot of complaints But ultimately I hopefully we can all come to sometime of conclusion on the facility fee I think shn I kind of spoke on behalf of the dance program so I was the ones that kicked off the dance program last year I'm actually the new recent treasur pag volunteer and just going through all the finances the
129urgency that we have here it's really critical for us so we're trying to get clinics off the board our budget meeting is this month in February and we have to set registration fees so we have to you know we want to be transparent with votes too so they sign up for competition cheer and it's not just the registration cost it's the travel costs that go into it when they go to attend a competition here they have to pay entrance fees we want to make sure that we're looking at everything from every angle we understand exactly the costs that go into it not just from our program perspective but being transparent with parents to say if you're signing up for this this is what you can expect to pay um we do have some families obviously
130that just can't afford it so we want to still be able to help out those families and and honor the hardship um process that we have to support those families so we never want anyone in our mle barrier Sou very Regent 15 District to feel like they can't benefit from these programs we want them all to be able to take benefit of that so I just really appreciate it sounds like the discussions have been going on for a long time about the facility fees I've seen some things in the past where there's been a lack of clarity on like where we exactly fall um we did some clinics last year in June on the chair side for example um and it wasn't an understanding we would get charged significant amount of fee for after school
131season was closed um so we charged a certain rate we hired professionals to come in and Coach the girls and went way through the program we were told oh you need to pay actually almost $500 per day um so six hours wor three different days uh two hour clinics we ended up paying almost $500 to rent that high school so for you guys from a budgetary line perspective you know that's nothing but for our program like we we were at we ran that cled at a loss and and we can't continue to operate like that so we really just need to be transparent of exactly all of these costs I think the prioritization is another good discussion right so do par and W get priority and booking space over other nonprofit programs um because we
132need those facilities right to hold our practices to be able to prepare our girls for cheer for football so if there is some type of prioritization decision and you're going to say parks and Records going to continue to take priority so we need to know that because perhaps that's a decision for our organization to say well we're all middleberry southberry residents um that are in this program so maybe we need to reconsider our decision and partner with paron so thank you all that's all I had to say hi um my name is Rebecca try and I live in midbury um my family and I moved here into District about five years ago um we have looked at several different towns and what Drew us to the Middlebury Southbury region is not just the Stellar school
133system but the fact that when you walked into businesses you saw plaques hanging on the wall of pizza places that sponsored sports teams um that when you drove by meow Park you saw soccer teams playing while kids were playing on the playground and that any given day at community house or at um other parts in the region you would see baseball practicing while soccer was going on while lacrosse was on the field and it was that sense of community that are thriving and trying to achieve um that several ofic in the room that are represented we're not just here because of sports team we're here because we are trying to do what's best for kids I'm also a 19-year public school educator and I'm telling you that as a fight as an educator I'm fighting
134against digital addiction I'm fighting against drugs I'm fighting against alcohol I'm fighting against bullying and these extracurricular programs Dance Theater Sports they help kids feel like they belong within our school system and that's a partnership that pette should fill with nonprofits in town we say to our K that when you wear your name across the back of your jersey or on your sleeve you're representing pm and that's middleberry and southberry together and now as my daughter as an eighth grader is deciding there to go to high school she's looking at pck but she's also looking at nonog and sound schools and private schools can bring kids outside of our community and that's something else that I think you guys need to consider that when date fees dissuade parents from attending sport events um our kids
135don't get to see the beautiful facilities that they could one day aspire to go to um and yet they get to run around tap's campus as part of a cross country meet and see those facilities um so I I hope that you consider um not only the the equity of the situation but also do we want to retain our sense of community and our sense of Pride that our kids build in that Comm so that they will be as proud to be part of PM Rog as I am to be part of PM Rog in the future and thank you so much for all your time that you put in thank you anyone else I did come here um I I come to you as a resident taxpayer business owner parent PTO officer and an
136active member of his community I know we are all here to discuss fees but we are also inting on Rec um in sit by super great as we reflect on the situation I want to emphasize the importance of not only forgiveness and understanding but compassion Redemption and the power of community versus the arm with his head mentality our superintendent has served this region with dedication passion and a genuine commitment to our students and families during the global pandemic and an unprecedented grad because of his decisions and opening with fions in 2020 I was able to keep my business and the livelihoods of my staff going and open while many of my friends with small businesses close permanently just in the next town old it is evident that Mr Smith has worked T tirelessly to Foster
137an environment of learning growth andity he has advocated for our children champions of educational excellence and strengthening the bonds within our community this Legacy of good cannot be overlooked we all make mistakes that is inherent part of Being Human what truly manages how those mistakes our superintendent has expressed remorse and is committed to learning from this experience I also trust that our Board of Education members decision making speaks to the level of his character and the professional relationships I appreciate all of you forgiveness is the powerful act that allows us to move forward and grow stronger together by extending Grace we affirm our belief in Second Chance capacity were changed in my life I've had to not only receive Grace but offer Grace to amazing humans both as employ laer and as someone who has
138been in car this incident does not define who our superintended nor does to diminish the positive impact he has had on our region I support our superintendent as he works to rebuild trust and continue his mission of serving our community with Integrity in closing let us Embrace this opportunity to show compal support for Mr SP by doing so we can not only help him on his journey but also reinforce values that b us together as a thank youse okay um may have a motion to you got that again all right all those in favor IED thank you everyone