001right you yeah 15 Board of vegucation order for Monday January 27th can we please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Pledge aliance to the flag States the lice the mission of reaching a collaborative Community committed to Excellence is to educate every student to be productive ethical and engaged in a global Society through proven and innovating learning experiences supported by its strong Community whose decision- making is faced in the best interest of all students I'm going to start with our student representative Miss Tess and Mr Brendan Fen good evening everyone as for p Rock High School we had recently finished midterms last week and our senior semiformal this past Saturday had a great turnout it was very fun for all students who went as for Memorial Middle School quarter 3 is off F great start sixth
002and seventh graders participated in the quarterly rise character recognition power program and honored four students from each grade level for their excellent citizenship and modeling of the values in their school Charter thank you to the board of ed members for able to visit MMS on Friday January 10th it was a pleasure touring the building with you to see the great work happening in the chapter this past Friday students participated in first chapter Friday where teachers read a short passage from a book they are currently reading and time has been given to students to read independently this initiative was created to promote a love of reading on part of our students as for rheno Middle School they have made their way to the second half of the school year as well quarter three and second semester
003classes began on Wednesday January 22nd they'd like to thank the board of ed for also visiting RMS on Friday the 17th to visit C's room tour the building sixth grade students are participating in the living museum projects in their English classes staff and students are hearing up for the annual Super Bowl canned food drive to support the SAT Food Bank there will be a UniFi student versus staff basketball game coming up in the next few weeks we look forward to some friendly competition with our student athletes and support Partners video production Club has been making some quick broadcast short videos and stay tuned for their annual cornhold tournament which is coming up in the next few weeks all right thank you Tess moving on to the elementary schools the fourth and fifth grades band in
004Orchestra concerts are happening this week at long medal Elementary fourth grade students visited the newly renovated Peabody Museum and had a wonderful time uh at poog elementary school they are hosting a special Community Day this Friday featuring a star student assembly to recognized students who are striving to be their best selves um at Memorial elent Memorial elent midle they had a successful Danberry hatrick fundraiser and there was a great turnout uh they will also be hosting a ro at rer Magic where families will have the unique opportunity to skate and take breaks to enjoy Story Time sessions with Mees staff members um and then moving on to the athletics department HCK has continued recognizing student athletes weekly for exceptional sportsmanship on the field um the unified basketball registration is now open and be starting off
005soon the boys swim and dive team had their season they started their season strong with their first two meets uh the boys basketball team is now seven and5 girls basketball is now 9 and5 and the Watertown P par hocke is five and thank you very much um anyone have questions on the reports all right thank you um next we have uh student recognition the American math competition finalists I'd like Mr Walsh to come up we have I believe seven uh American math competition finalist and uh first wsh she going to tell us about sure good evening everyone uh M the board public parents students so um very pleased to be here tonight to recognize special grou students each High School joins um high school students volunteer join approximately 300,000 other students across the country um
006up about 4 4,000 uh districts to take part of national competition it's called the American mathematics competition it's actually run not just United States but also Canada um and so it's broken up into the amc1 which is an exam for grade 10 students of 12 so uh this past year this past November we had student participants approximately 40 45 students um take part in this academic competition what I'm most proud of is the students um it's an academic competition we have a lot of other competitions and we don't have as many academic competition so this one shines um and students take their time during the day um to take part in this exam and so we would like honor um those students to place within P for the AMC 10 first second and third place
007AMC 12 so I'd like to recognize those students now um for the AMC 10 we have a Time uh for third place shy and Max and first to Brandon congratulations thir goes uh third placees and first place this year went to so the comption of the American American he also placed in the American AAL mathematics plan and I should offer some explanation of that that is the next level beond the AMC only had a few years since I've here qualified it's the top 20% of all participants in the AMC so soan good luck all done congratulations and thank you so much for making region 15 proud that is really an important achievement thank you and next we have our portrait of a graduate um presentation and I'll turn that over to Mr Smith he's ready
008so as we um pull up the presentation a couple of things um uh Dr mchan Who helped Deerhead and Shepherd us through this journey um is is uh incapacitated this evening um a bit of a journey of her own let's say um so she won't be joining us um unfortunately she came ill this afternoon um so um we're going to pinch hit for her um it's one of the U portrait of a learner skills that we're going to exhibit this evening in being flexible and resilient um there's some committee members here um I like U to recognize uh Mar Milo g Nelson Don ruano J zwick um and Amy thank you Ry sorry a I apologize um all served as members of the committee can help answer questions um and I'm G have Dr chiaa
009walk through um some of the free to chime in go um so like uh Mr Smith said uh L McAn was the was our facilitator through this process um and then there on the board is a list of the committee members so we had uh teachers from various levels we had parents from various levels we had two high school students with us we had administrators from various levels um all participate in our meetings um um as steuding um we actually started this process in August um where we had uh Dr mckuin come and work with us as an admin team um she also uh did some uh focus groups where she not only met with adults um she also met with students in grades 4 through 12 um and then other community members um there
010was about 600 survey responses that were collected if you remember there were surveys that went out in the fall um and uh that 600 respones actually showcased um that our community was involved and they were interested in this process um the different um focus groups were uh was where she was able to actually dive deeper in to talk to staff and to talk to students about what they were looking for what it means um to be a learner here in region 15 and what what they want to see have happen as they move through the grade levels and what they need to be prepared for um when they graduate uh from region 15 and so um this process is really about um looking at the community what the community um feels needs to have happen
011um a way to Foster communication and collaboration between um teachers and students community members and parents um so that we all with ownership in what the portrait of a learner is going AG in 15 and again uh here's some numbers because always great to have numbers up on um so uh the amount of surveys that uh responses that were collected the amount of focus group groups that she's done and again those were with staff and with students um um and then the community focus groups that she did and then this is just some examples of when she worked with the different um focus groups uh they were given chart paper and they were asked to talk about like things that they felt were very important for us to have as not only students um to
012be a fortable learner but also for the adult here in anded and so then we get down to the steering committee so uh the steering committee had um a few meetings this fall and it actually we ended our last meeting in December and so um at our first meeting what we did is we looked at the data that was collected from all the different um either surveys or focus groups um and so we were able to break into groups and analyze those and we identified some themes or some priorities that showed up from that data that were collected um at our second meeting we um collaborated a lot with each others so um we were in different groups um multiple times throughout meetings um to not only get to know one another but to get
013to share our ideas um and so we uh then were able to mock up some portraits that we thought um should happen and give some visual representations of some key characteristics for those different portraits um at our next meeting um what we did we uh did an activity called dot voting where we were putting dots um on different things that we either agreed with or that we thought um something that was unique to uh the group the different groups and so we um ended up at the end of that me be able being able to prioritize the attributes um for the portrait of the learner and then we started voting on um which of those attributes did we all feel were important as a group as a steering committee and that's where those dots came
014in um and at our last meeting um of the year what we were able to do is actually come up with an initial draft of the portrait based on all the feedback that we received some feedback from the surveys feedback from the focus groups feedback from um from our steering committee and um what we did is we kind of word smmi um those portraits um Dr U mckuin was able to synthesize all of the information but she also plugged things into um AI multiple times and multiple AI um generators to uh to get the best um wording that um you know she could for each of those and then it was brought back to us as a group to then further um look at that and give feedback and so what you'll see tonight is
015actually um the initial draft that we came up with at the last um meeting that we had that's just a small um group of our steering committee um a picture that was taken there were about 20 members um the grou and so the key outcomes um we came up with a portrait of the learner and so one of the things we talked about was rather than it be a portrait of a graduate we wanted to be a portrait of Warner and so there were a couple of reasons for that um number one we talked about at the elementary level it's really hard for you know kindergarteners to imagine a graduate and so um how do we make sure that we continue to talk about learning no matter what level you're at we also talked about
016it being a portrait of learner because it's not only for the students here in region 15 but it's for the staff in region 15 it's for the parents in region 15 it's for the community members in region 15 so how how do we continue to learn no matter what um position we're in here in in our community um and so uh um we talked a lot about like the collaborative work and made sure that it was clear and comprehensive and that it reflected all of the things that we saw in surveys and focus groups in our discussions um we talked about the community buyin um because it needed to be um and we needed to listen to what parents said what students said what our staff had said um and then again I talked about
017that shifting from graduate to learner um and that idea of like it's lifelong learning it's not just learning to 12 and how do we make sure that it's it's learning that is being adaptable and that it's it's it fits our world whether you stay here in this area or you go outside of this area and then we needed to make sure that our lines to the newly asked standards and ensuring that our practices need like those external benchmarks not just what's Happening Here what we want to have happening here but what has to happen outside of here and so um the Community Vision for our Learners was that this portrait of a learner encapsulates the collective aspirations that our community wants for our students it emphasizes the skills such as critical thinking creativity and collaboration
018but one of the things that came up is we didn't think those those seword were the only thing that um that it should encapsulate we wanted to put something that actually clarified those c-words which you'll see in the final draft um we talked about this Vision um reflecting a commitment to inclusivity uring that all students have the opportunity to thve um and that it represents a guiding framework for educational practices and policies across the district and so that I don't know if you can see it clearly that's what um the the committee came up with so um it's an our portrait of a learner includes an empowered learner um it includes um I don't know if I can read that um in Problem Solver problem thank you cont yeah ethical contributor um productive collabor thank
019you and effective yeah thank you so you'll see in front of like some of those CW we felt that it was it was necessary to put um something that was a little more clarifying and so underneath each of those I can't read those so I don't expect you to either um are description of um what each of those learner um characteristics are but on the right hand side are key words that then play into each of those um those characteristics I know I didn't even bother open the paper think we get yeah I did send an email with attachment so if you didn't see it right so you do have a one pager in your email as a PDF and that's the same PDF that we'll post um to the website the idea being is
020that what we'd like to do is have kind of a comment period um while we've got a lot of input um and I'll let the committee members speak things they want add but it was really important for us um to not have kind of um superintendent or people put their finger on the scale so to speak and to keep this a pure process um the idea of those um keywords on the right when we start to talk about how do we build this into our curriculum process what does this look like um with our prek students and our third grade students we can to those keywords as elements that we look for um to embed or identify in our curriculum documents um and so you know we didn't want this to be something that lives
021on a shelf we don't want this to be an esoteric aspirational statement we well we that's a part of it we also wanted to have kind of practical application in and cross gr levels um so the thought is after tonight we will post this on our website oh I'm sorry got ahe we didn't really rehearse this we didn't plan on doing so here you go Ken uh so we would post this for a public comment perod we want to get input I don't know that it's gonna unnecessarily shift the um work of the committee but we want to understand what questions people might have and how would to answer or clarify um the implementation and planning would be to look now and free grade level progression of what this looks like in our curriculum and
022across our grades um so how do you measure and by measure I'm using a lower phas end of that and we're not going to give a test on curiosity but I do think we want to have a conversation on what does curiosity look like and how do we have conversations with students on what it means to be intellectually curious and build assignments that Foster intellectual curiosity um the next phase is to look at our curriculum in in our normal curriculum writing cycle we're not going to go back uh and on you know June 1st rewrite all K12 curriculum across the district but as we go through that cycle of curriculum writing how do we embed or identify where these things are there and not just make sure they're in our cric but have discret conversations
023about them part of this work is making sure that that metacognitive piece that students understand what I'm doing in this assignment is to build that ethical collaboration it's not just an assignment that they do not aware of that skill that they're developing um and then to go through we just came out of policy a little while ago U we're not going to go back we started at the beginning but as we go through our policies like where do these things show up in that process and what does it look like and again that idea that this is um intentional and specific in the language that we use and the our work that we do we want to make sure these things show up and are embedded into the work leave anything else anything out committee
024members Miss Ron um and and I do think that you know the committee that came together um was representative of students and staff and family members and community members and um this was a lot of work I appreciate the time they took to come to me to engage in dialogue to to argue and wrestle about some of these things U because it's important and this is something that if it's going to be meaningful has to be a living document it has to be something that we work with on a regular basis and all the voices make and one of the students on the committee is going to make a logo with all of our attributes no pressure yeah he volunteer is that that any questions myself committee members question so thank you and thank you
025for all the hard work um if you go back on slide do I just want to make sure I'm hearing the information because we already are past the public comment period with the survey because that's what led you to the trending and now we're in the implementation planning right so curricula and policy are going to be the next phases for this going to be clear so what we want to do yes but so what we want to do is put this document out to the public you fill that survey um and we really want to create a comment Pera where people can say hey help me understand what this means I don't you know I don't know how that trans I don't know again that we're looking to significantly change same thing for board members
026eventually we want to have the board doops so that was actually going to be my question because having you completed the survey and clearly you um analyzed the data trended it um but I wasn't sure what the pathway back to the community and to the people that received the surveys was on all of that so when you talk about that public commentary that's all in of like we completed the survey these were the like this whole present now it's an opportunity for the public to comment and that will continue to drive the conversation right and then my next question is when we start thinking about implementation curricula and evaluation can you remind me and what the timeline is as far as an evolution is it on an annual basis is it a fiveyear plan I
027can't recall when um this was originally presented like what's the expectation of how this evolves over time there's probably a couple answers that so there is an annual curriculum writing that we have a plan for and every summer we go into the budget you know new courses and rewriting so that is kind of like an annual your fiveyear cycle that you talked about um in addition to that especially at the high school level where we're going through meas and we're doing some specific targeted uh curriculum review it may not be Rewritten at this time but it might be highlighted and identified U for that and then when you think about at an elementary level um right now we're in implementing a new bonic program math program we're meeting weekly expectation so some of this language
028will show up on a on a on a weekly Ong basis less formal than that annual cycle but it's a continual kind of evolution a continual conversation that will adapt over time I just don't want people think that it ends it's really actually now is when the work actually starts to put into into um into play like those grade level competencies and so we talked a lot about like having I can statements so like as a kindergartner I can you know do whatever in order to show that I'm an effective communicator and then what does that look like as an I can statement for like middle schoolers what does that look like for an I can statement for high schoolers so actually coming up with those grade level competency progressions is is really the bul
029of work and then once we come up with those what does then that look like in a classroom when go visit classroom to when teachers are teaching so um so to me this was the easier part putting all of this together it's now putting that progression together you know pre k12 and then um what does that look like then when you're teaching you know your your different um areas and well for like if I just pick on the ethical contributor in for example like L is I'm do the bridge um there may be a lesson that might be part of um school counsil lesson it maybe but it also may show up in math class when you have students that are disagreeing on the solution you know who's going to function as the bridge builder
030these these might be terms that show up in curriculum as u a member of your group is going to be the bridge builder and it's going to have to come you know help the group come to consensus and and there again long term the goal is that our third graders is going to know that I'm building a skill that's going to help me be an ethical contributor when I graduate you know that's kind of that kind of that progression going to start smaller but it's going to be on any other questions any other questions for our committee members anything you guys want to say all this way I'll just say it was a great process and um Dr McKuen was really great at making sure that we had all of the data in front of
031us and she constantly was going back and synthesizing and looking at different corts and setting it up in different ways for us to analyze it so you can be sure that this is reflective of those who completed that survey their voices were absolutely heard even though they may not have been at the tables with us this survey was highly valuable and we looked at at Rockton so how many people do know off hand about how many people received the survey and how many completed like what was the complete gr I I think it was only about 600 respondents um and I believe it was sent to the whole District right like we pushed it out from each school you know we have the power school app so each principal is able to send it out
032and um if I'm not mistaken that's the way that we shared it fig we about 3,400 students family members actually document doing was surprise their responsory typically you know they look at 10% um it's kind of a a valid respons talk School St so she was surprised that we got it but I think even at one point like our first meeting we saw that one area I want to say students was relatively low and so we said can we go back and push it back out to students to get more responses and so um that was done I think middle and and high school pushed it out again so that when we came back to our second meeting we had more student responses because our students on the committee actually spoke up and said like
033there only like five students that answered can we get more so um so we ended up pushing it out again then we did the focus group students so they they made f up survey do groups the fourth grader didn't get the survey um but gave tremendous Insight actually thank you so much thank you for all your effort appreciate it um next may I have a motion to approve the minutes for January 13 2025 regular meeting of the Board of Education thank you heather do I have a second second thank you Aon any changes or questions all those in favor I any names or extenstions it carries thank you next we have information and proposals board committee reports policy and curriculum committee Miss Heather the policy and curricul throughing that earlier this evening where we continued
034our review of 5,000 Ser policies um I know it seems like maybe I just give that update every other time but we are making progress um we did actually um finish our when we started the 5,000 policy review we had had um broken those there's a lot of 5,000 policies so we had broken them up into um different groups this committee has already approved um this board full board has already approved um policies related to Independence the next block that we looked at was student health um and that was actually what we finished this evening so um the committee approved n student health related policies um come for the full board for full for first read uh shortly um and then re just got rolled up our sleeves and got to work on the next
035block of policies which we have called our student rights policies um that's what's next up on our agenda we will be meeting again February 10th right any questions see all right and next we have the G PES feasibility study committee update and Mrs Rogers is up tonight uh the GES P feasibility study committee will meet this Thursday January 30th here at BHS in the media center from 5: to 7M tekon has done a walk through of GES and PES and they will be giving us an update and timeline at the study this meeting is open to the public will be recorded and posted on our website any questions not all right exciting stuff and next we have our superintendent report leave me I apologize Advance there's a lot I'll touch on here um just wanted
036to REM the board the legislative session has begun since the beginning about two weeks ago there's been over a hundred bills introduced relating to education so um it's going to be a busy spring keep you posted um as things progress through the system and if there's anything that we may want to weigh in or testif testify on um last week the um our health insurance Consortium met um the committee reviewed our self-insurance claims and came to consensus that the budgeted amount for next year would be an increase of 153 a half% and while that um sounds like big number and is a big number um in talking with about 13 districts in our area increases range from 8% to 32% um and so the 13 and a half really falls about average um when you
037look among districts just as a reminder um we budget about 11 million a year for our health insurance plan and 13 and half% point to about a million for so um it is an ongoing conversation that we have across the state around help care cost it's a national conversation we are not immune from that um and in our you know no surprises um that is um the meeting that we had last week and I want was aware of that um for at the high school the PA system at the high school is maybe not exactly original but soon after the school was built um is the PA system in here it's been a challenge for us at the high school um to manage that PA system we've been looking for a new system uh we
038found a new system that works off with the Wi-Fi and they're going to require that we rewire all the systems in here um it is a safety issue we have begun replacing that system and hopefully in the next week or so that will be included um and then we no longer need we8 assist um speaking of building repairs some people have been made aware that we're down a uh sewage pump at Memorial um that pump has caused some inconvenience but I just wanted to assure everybody we have been in contact with OSHA we've been in contact with the health department um while inconvenient it does not change our ability to keep that building open the pump um is pretty original to the building that is the only School in this R which would not have
039a rebant system uh that pump is out at a facility right now being rebuilt and assuming we can rebuild it I hope that we'll have a back in the next couple of days um and it will be a very quick reinstall um if for any reason we can't rebuild it and have to look at a new one that will change the current plan um and we will have to Pivot because it'll be probably an extended period to the new um pool and we be happy to know we are finally running um our main HVAC unit um it has been um just I think the paint actually watching the paint Drive was faster but it is online um I am not removing the supplemental heat system that's in there until everything is checked validated signed off
040on and that system is fully functional running on its own for a period of time maintaining temperature in that room at which point we will then disengage the supplemental um once we've um have that new system on and running if people are in the pool you'll see that there's some TI working things it look incomplete because it is um until the heat system is fully functioning they can't finish off all the duct work and venting so once that heat system is up and running then we can kind of do that finish work of the tile and some of the um the vents that you may see that look unfinished right now should we have to take any of those vents down that's why they're not depleted um the other piece that um people may have
041heard or read about is there were some federal guidelines um around I agents entering schools um we are uh monitoring that situation we have met with legal counsel um we are awaiting the state Department's guidelines um I know that they're working on their end to make sure the guidelines they provide are in line with new federal regulations um and so our administrators have some guidance for going to meet tomorrow then to review that guidance um the base though is that things don't don't change if you are not a parent of a child you don't have a reason to see that child you can't come into our schools um if you have a warrant then you can but we're going to verify and validate I'm not looking to uh read any statements I just want our
042families to know that our job is children um that doesn't change and if you want to come um visit child in our schools you need to be a parent Guardian um or have a war do so um once we have clarification by on the website and share them out with people um and that all right to any questions from Mr Smith all right we'll move on to board member comments sure if I can um some consult the audience um thank you so much uh to superintendent Smith Joe I isn't here everybody who helped organize the the tours um our principles all the teachers that allow us to kind of observe um the work they do in the classroom it's really a privilege and an honor to go in and see our schools um I know
043I had said Thank you last time that was part one and this was part two because there were more tours that had happened um but I know it's it takes a lot to coordinate that and I also know that it creates a a level of vulnerability when you have a group of people going in and kind of seeing behind the curtain I just want to extend a b thanks um really very very helpful um particularly um when we think about what we do last year with the budget how some of those things are being implemented and put forward and then of course I think um just giving people some perspective on what perhaps would be coming to us in March but um really want to thank you um and I know it's a lot of
044people's time but it was great anyone else okay next we have comments from citizens the Board of Education will recognize citizens of middleberry and southberry and citizens are asked to State their name their town of residence and to limit their comments to three minutes no all right all right next we have both business requiring action um may I have a motion for approval of the new THS family and consumer science course offerings move that the Board of Education approve family and consumer science new courses introduction to culinary arts grades 9 through 12 pastry and baking grades 11 through I'm sorry 10 through 12 food service and restaurant management grades 11 through 12 as presented second any discussion questions be excited next next me definitely ready to have the baking competition definitely I'm excited for competitions
045I'm excited forast the drones can deliver it all right any other questions or comments on the policies that are before the no right all those in favor um and all any Nays or exensions right carries thank you next I have a motion for approval of new pa+ career in technical education course offerings move with the Board of Education approved Career and Technical education courses Esports experience grades 10 through 12 ECE that's early college experience digital media and animation grades 10 through 12 as presented second thank you all right any discussion or questions on these course offerings right all those in favor I any Nays exensions carries next may have a motion for approval of new PHS physical education course move that the Board of Education approve new PHS physical education course Wilderness physical education grades
04610 through 12 presented thank you any discussion or comments on this um course all those in favor I I any nams orions okay all unanimous next may I have a motion for approval of a Quebec Middle School field trip shall I just keep going yes the Board of Education approved Memorial Middle School and Rambo Middle School field trip to Quebec City Quebec Canada Saturday November 22nd 2025 through Tuesday November 25th 2025 as presented all right any discussion or comment on this go ahead oh my question is a little silly but I was wondering if nth graders could go because my's be crushed know she missed yeah they have one this year my that last have a trip this is the summer they the summer they're actually going to to Paris High School is yeah she's
047in eth grade right now same they ail right so just so Logistics because I was surprised I don't know the time to get up to for that I know like flight driving 22 to the 25th I'm thinking and that's why Thanksgiving or right before right up um what's the travel time are they going by bus or by plane by bus It Is by bus say it's eight hours so six and a half six and a half six and a half under eight hours so the only thing I thought was wow it's a lot of travel um and is if the point is to really give them a lot of cultural emergin they're spending a lot of time on bus um so just something I you know to consider particularly on a a week that is
048usually traffic volume maybe not right before Thanksgiving but just something to consider um and then in here it says in the school it says in the for the year so it said for next year so I'm assuming it's 25 26 calendar year that this is yeah yep it's coming fall okay so the next school yeah um and my only comment you know the other side of me says okay so if we're going to do this for for those in um taking French what will be we be doing for those that are taking Standish love to hear those ideas a current conversation so right now one of the um one of the challenges there's a lot more Spanish students um the advantage is it's a lot easier to find a Spanish emerger so that is a
049current conversation happening whether or not it would be the same um form so to speak May there it's a different structure might mple OPP you could take that many you so I think that's one of the ongoing conversations then we wanted to start to increase the amount ofer experiences students the high school one will shift more to Paris becomes an option test that out um obviously not quite ready big middle schools on that dat the trip U but this is much closer you can do you think that um this wouldn't take away from any other field trips that are happening just add on and I wouldn't be concerned at all that it's a short period of time like DC is kind of somewhat similar and they just pack in the activities you know around the
050clock um exhausting the for Mr Bernardi um and the and the kids it is impressive um and I think this is a wonderful thing that the middle schools are doing um for the students and I I just um I I really encourage that and I think just a wonderful opportunity you're providing our students um to really bring French um to life so thank you for offering discussions that we've had regarding this trip is not that it would be an annual trip would be open to seventh and E grade student participants so it wouldn't be okay when is a seventh GR and then I'm going to go again as an eighth grader so it provides kind of like that seventh eth grade Cod for on every other year basis so you're capturing seers as oppos to
051having to make decisions on basis so does this have to come up every two years or is this just a blanket for well not not this type of proposal just as our request to go got right any other questions all right all those in favor I any ma any extensions no it carries I get what does Mr s say back um all right next may I have a motion for approval of the 2025 2026 friends together tuition rates I'm happy to make the motion this one app um move at the Board of Education upon recommendation of the finance committee approve the 2025 2026 friends together tuition rates as presented great all right so Heather has a a question I know unfortunately Mr Martino is um not feeling well and Miss cavalo is on a work
052thank you Josh all right go ahead ask your questions so I just want to acknowledge that I I did uh pepper Josh with some questions before this meeting um but I just um just wanted to recap you know my concerns about this is um you know this preschool program is um I think it's a gem I think there's just no better um uh preparation for getting kids ready for kindergarten and having a program where they can eat in an elementary school cafet area and ride an elementary school bus and walk in elementary school hallways um and just looking at the the rate increases not just this one which I know is a modest increase but over the years I just want to make sure that this program continues to be accessible to the community um
053that we are able to um field you know an adequate number of gear models for the kids in this program um and that you know I just want to make sure that um you know I know that over the years there's been various bottlenecks to having like a one to one ratio of this program can STA and space and you know I know this is a complicated issue um but you know I just I looked at this rate increase and it just gave me pause and I just wanted to put it on the table that um to understand what the driver is and I just want to understand the the health of the program and do we have new people coming in are they um is it remaining accessible to the community well I would
054say share your desire to uce fundaments um if we had a space that was twice the size we would love to have more typical students come in I I'm bias but I agree with you this is a tremendous program um and we offer highly trained staff we offer with a few other child care facilities can offer in addition to that transition um we do try to keep the cost modest as we're not going to balance the school budget on um this tuition but at the same time labor costs go up Insurance costs as I mentioned before go up Transportation costs go up um and we find that we are still um very competitive with other options and uh probably one of the very few Child Care Facilities that provide transportation at all um so I
055think that uh is is a Unique Piece um you know and in some ways providing transportation is good for families but it also helps us manage kind of the parent drop off piece parent loation Lo we don't have a dayc care Le middle of the day parents that we managed about when we talk about school security and all that so um it'd be hard to kind of try to tear down this is what it costs with Transportation this is what it costs without um and then adding it if became mid year or whatever so um know we're very conscious of the fees that we pass on to families um we have and and I want to be clear like we don't make this a supply and demand right from you know I mean we have
056um the parents um that are interested all know the date that registration opens and honestly if you're not kind of on that list by noon you're you're not going to get a spot we have a very long waiting list the half day program is a little more of a waiting list just because or a little less of a waiting list because that's a more challenging program for families to manage with the full day program we could fill freeold um and we need compare our price to other similar Child Care Facilities um we are still more cost effective box the overall price of child care um and high quality daycare and preschool programs um is extremely and it's problematic with like all the kindergarten start good figure there just not enough um so you know we
057don't kind of just move the price um based on that desire you know we probably double the price and still fill our slots AR that many that's not that's not necessarily Josh I'm reading between what you said I mean the biggest increase right was in this calendar 2425 so and I look at 256 is almost like no they relative to rate increases so I I would have expected more significant impact right in this current er um but did it impact we went want to say three years without much of an increase or any then we kind of compounded that but no we had no I guess I don't know if that price deterred anybody from um applying but we have w today did anybody call and raise concerns about the cost again when we look
058at what we're able to offer our parents mostly are how do I get my child in and you know I I think kind of to your point like if if we had unlimited space that would kind of factor in more um and you know maybe in the future we'll have more space but um the other challenge we have is we start out the year in eventually under subscribing to the program because we know that as students age in as threey olds we're going to have to accommodate the Mandate inside of that so we have to create space in our classrooms you know for them to grow so our classes in September are smaller than questions that answer question it it does answer my question best answer it's not the best version of the answer I
059would love but you know space is our biggest mod any other questions all right all those in favor I any Nam exensions right cares next may I have a motion for approval of Reserve fund for educational expenditures move that the Board of Education upon recommendation of the fin committee approved the reserve fund for educational expenditures second all right yes so if you remember last year um there was a state statute passed that gave us the option to have or create a um Reserve fund currently we have what I called a capital reserve fund that we can add money to through board motion and you can take out of through board motion the current account only allows for onetime non-referring Capital interest which is good but somewhat restrictive so last year the state allowed Regional School
060Districts to create a non rearing or sorry a reing educational expense fund challenge is we can't just rename our Capital monitary curing account the call the educational Reserve fund we have to create a new fund um and we can't just take money out of the current fund and move it into the new fund so um what I anticipate is that we will continue to have the capital reserve fund that we have and then over time we will begin adding money to this new fund So currently our practice has been only year end balance goes under that capital reserve in the future we will move that end ofe balance into this new fund the advantage is this new fund is restricted as restricted in the types of things that you can purchase on so for example
061if we had a short if the state in the future ever underfunded a revenue grant that we were expecting this might be a place that we have funds to compensate for that um it doesn't have to just be a capital expense it could be some other educational can it also be used forit can so originally we were kind of hopeful that we could take our current account and just restructure it um there's some debate among Auditors as to whether or not that is allowed they're not going to test the waters with that just create a new one kind of the advantage the thing I was most worried about was those are that's an interest bearing account that we collect interest off of both of these accounts will basically be one account they'll be sublines within
062one Financial account so from an interest standpoint they'll be seen as one account and you can drive so putting funds in a new one isn't going to remove our good like interest of what's that I think my um concern before was that we're not going to drain our capital reserve fund to fund other things we we have a short call from or something like that but that was my concern we've taken great pains to grow that but we could do the work on the schools that have been needed for years that's what was woring to me that it would be just like oh just take it from there so this would be separate we continue to add funds you don't have to and one of the I think there was a public testimony on it
063so I don't think that disparaging anybody but one of the U concerns of this legislation was that fors ofed wouldn't have discipline um and we would go to this fund and rate it to kind of subsidize budget increases on basis or buy down some other place and not use it for some of the capital emergencies but unlike a town school districts don't have any kind of reserves so Regional districts this does provide some some saf that we don't currently have so will there be parameters as to what percentage goes into which funds year so that'll be a conversation for the board to have you could I mean I guess we could create a fiscal policy that help to dictate that but right now least gu of some sort yeah so that you're not just going
064all in one all in the other then I don't think this group would but this is going to have Legacy so that's where my mind went you know I pulled up here our policy 3292 which governs our Capital amount current expense fund and if we were to move this forward tonight I would want to have a conversation very quickly in PNC about establishing a policy for this that being said we're not ready to do that I'm not sure there's urgency and maybe want to table that and make sure the board is absolutely ready because I don't think there's anyone doing it so I would love to know what our plan is to have those guidelines around this fund prior to establishing it at least having room for that conversation before esta but if there is
065time sensitive issues that require the actions might these let us first of all can't tell you how thrilled I am that you want to have that conversation I do think would have some type of governing policy does kind of Mak it a little um unclear and really easy um so I'm a fan of having that policy conversation uh there's no funds in there right now so we could create the account there urgency to create it other than um I guess the sooner we create it the sooner we have a policy conversation um and then we can wait till we have the policy before come in I mean I'm open to whatever that actually makes me concerned because if we don't know what we're going to put and how it's going to be put in and
066with the boundaries then why are we going to create a fund to put it in so I almost feel like that the concept is like I I understand the concept but for me it's differentiating what is an educational expenditure that's a big bucket um and I recognize it's different than capital expenditure and I can understand the rationale to put this to to put this in place but if you start off with a zero balance right off the bat we're going to want to put money into it and then what's and how is the parameters of how that money used so I'm I'm meaning in the it's hard to forward thinking that we can create this without knowing in what Capac it will are you saying kind of what Tom's saying we should have a policy
067before we create it at least get condition bu is as equal to having right having a fund zero not knowing how it's fil that's the policy right like so created and at the same time say any excess from the prior year goes 60% in capital 40% here whatever that is some sort of structure to it then we can build off or is it going to come with the recommendation of superintend his budget proposal you know spoiler it's not no I'm saying if this improv like would that because we've had a lot of conversations about work in capital how it's used but we don't often specify in the budget what we expect we will have in Reserve at the end of but we build up the reserve so are we G to take this up if
068we ended the fiscal year with just theoretically 100K we don't necessarily know we're at time that's not in the budget actually what happens is so at the next finance committee M um we have the audit from last year that audit has a yearend balance in it typically that's the fund that we put into our Capital that amount is from the prior from the prior years that's correct but we can we have a lot of conversation budget cycle over how we may or may not be building up that Capital cor two two different so so one is the operating Capital that's the line in our budget that we talk about at budget season that is for Capital expenses the other is the non-referring capital account that go outside of a budget cycle think of it like
069your saving account for break that account typically we built that account up by taking our year end um unexpended funds and after the audit we add those funds to that nonre account it's different than the operating bud so the operating budget is like the pump at Memorial BR last week when you fix it that's the operating Capital the capital non recurring account is a roofs out two years from now that we're kind of saving money that conf fit or a tur or something like that b not um but the referring Capital account does not show up in the operating budget that to I think what I'm asking for is let's say this hypothetical 100,000 at the end of the year would normally go right into that capital reserve now we have a policy that says
070this percentage of it goes into capital reserve this percent of it goes into this new fund therefore giving us a mechanism to fund this without somebody just waving a one deciding how much they want to go I don't know if I want Pion was right off that was 6040 5050 I think every year could be a little different I don't think we're proposing the policy tonight right we're just creating the I think the issue is putting forward a motion and it's not really clear in what is going to be used and and what maybe some of the boundary conditions should be and the GU brange considered relative to how it would be utilized so you're proposing that we send the straight to PNC so is there any time Sensen that having it done before you
071next fin no because we don't necessarily so we audit like dat we don't have to talk about like which what we do with that per se it goes to the full board doesn't have cre now right so there is the time cent piece I want to say this year I want to confirm that um you also want earning interest right yeah I mean there will be some interest earn piece but I don't so the the pieces is by the end of whatever the timeline is I want to say June 30th I just want to confirm that um you have to do two things you have to create the account and then we have to do the motion to move the funds um so that's kind of a m that process um so there is a
072Tim table to it I don't know if it's urgent we have a couple a couple ofs to do that speaking for myself I don't feel completely comfortable voting sign on something I don't fully understand um I might ask uh would it be possible maybe to collect some resources that you could send the board just more information about the establishing this account and you know I I don't know if there makes sense to some stue but I haven't done any research and preparation for this vote so anything that might be better understand the opportunities and the risks um and then maybe there's you know some time between that and March more informed discussion yeah again only speaking for myself but I I did not do any research on this and I'm not it's okay the statute's
073like one line so I don't know it's kind of answer questions that you're asking I mean I think I don't know if this sample policy that dictates this yet no there's um again there's only about 14 districts in the state that this applies to uh the the core of the statute was really so uh right now school districts in order to access their capital reserve account has to go through a board of Finance Town Municipal Board of Finance unlike a regional board of B that you manage that that has caused some political challenges in school districts where access to that comes at kind of a quck quot that has caused problems in the past so the core of the legislation allows boards have had access to their own capital reserve account without going through the
074municipality the add-on to that was because boards already have the capital account but you have no other reserves so for example and I think you're driving a good questions the um the energy fee that's being passed on we didn't right we didn't know by it last year's budget in theory this account would go and subsidize the unknown search Char on our energy if we had to set up um but right now I don't believe there are any guiding principles the risks I think of what you identify is that without some discipline and structure um how boards use that could not be you know consistent um you could have a board drained something and another board built time and so I think that's one of the reasons that some of my colleagues were concerned about this
075legislation written the way it was I'm happy I mean it's a policy conversation it's a board level conversation whatever we can provide I don't know that there's like a a document he has in policy on this yet um I mean I think we're one of a couple of other Regional districts have created these accounts but I honestly I appreciate all of you because I don't know that I think we you going who s and asking these questions just don't think there's a whole lot of I mean it's just there's a lot of issues to consider the first thing that pops into my head is this discussion right now that's going on at the Reserve at the state level and we've establish these fiscal guard meals but anytime there's a you create a pot of money
076that is unassigned that doesn't have an assigned purpose there will be pressure from all kinds of stakeholders tap into that um so I would hate to put that under I think some districts um so we've done good job collected was Tred to build a special education Reserve in our operating this year we took a $600,000 access cost our Reserve funds aren't enough to totally zero that out this year it's come where there so other tradeoffs and I think we're going to be able to do that without any core damage to dist another year that could be different and you know if you had to take that cut and you didn't have those special education reserves think this is that account you know to if we had three students moved in tomorrow that do that account
077up and a million dollar short distri did currently there's no safety that for us for a municipal District they would go to town and say we need a special appropriation there is no special appropriation for Regional School Districts we'd have to go to referendum or we'd have to freeze the budget or lay off staff or do some proponent measures but we Cur operate that way we definitely operate that so so that situation could hit us and it could have hit us and and so this is a way to kind of build up offset that which it's there's always the risk it up and would we still be funding would we still so becomes a conversation saying we're adding another thing that we're going to be thinking about funding um it may take pressure off Reserve
078have a reserve outside of it I think again I think you're asking a really good question question about guard rails and policy but I also think it could more should be in special it's going to reduce the capital reserve because you're not going to build your capital reserve at the same rate just going to have to put some over there that has to be decided upon like because at some point Capital reserves those those bills are large but used for that we can use you're right and that's a good it's just it doesn't get funded from no something is has to go down for this to go up and I just want us to have some scope on that and expectation on that so am I hearing like people want to table this PO I
079what I'm hearing is is that um it would be helpful to determine what the use cases are and maybe build some guards around that and certainly those are things that be amended we find other situations but I do think I think from what I've heard I think special education is a perfect example of something you know that we are managing with a resered fund that's within our operating budget but which is Le has introduced some risk each year you know as we um operate with parameters and having something I'm yeah I I I generally like to support our subcommittees um in their recommendations I and I was at the finance meeting when they were discussing this I don't think this subject came up so I don't like I I I think it's okay for either
080withdraw the motion um and we could figure out what's the next step or we could table it I think the other hard thing is that Joe and Shannon are yeah I don't want them to yeah and I think to have them be part of the conversation would be extremely helpful and and certainly I'm not in a position where I could this board not because I'm I'm not interested in the topic I just don't know enough and I think this was a robust enough discussion that I would really um respect their expertise to to speak and talk through and and some of the things discuss today sorry about that well I missed that finance committee too so there was a lot of absente I would like to see the motion for the fund accompanied with the
081motion for how we operate we policy with creation of fund yes and honestly the other thing I like about that is also okay so do we want to withdraw this motion or do we want to table it table I don't know will re to be taken up at the next meeting well I can't ask tell someone to withdraw it that person who made the motion has to voluntarily withdraw it okay I will draw the motion thank you for the hints I will youw you just withdrew it so it's and then we'll ask the finance to take another crack at this with the guidance of the board thank you for your thoughtful um concerns and responses all right so um we're on to announcement of future meetings um so as Heather Roger said this Thursday the
08230th um we have our G es PES feasibility study committee meeting here at the media center at 5:00 that is a public meeting and public is welcome to attend um we will not be going into an executive session at that meeting um and this is late breaking and we didn't get this in time for the um agenda to go out but on February 3D next week we will be having another Board of Ed meeting on our um the facility fee discussion um that will also be at 5: here at the um PHS Media Center so that's Monday February 3rd 5 o'clock here and that's the fee discussion um Monday February 10th PNC is meeting at the media center at 6:30 um followed by our regular meeting at 7:30 and Wednesday February 12th Finance meets at
083MJ at 6:30 um oh here he goes still going on Monday February 23rd PNC meets at um the PHS me Media Center at 6:30 followed by our regular board ofed meeting that same night at the media center at 7:30 I have a motion to adjourn motion thank you heather do I have a second thank you Sally all the in favor right J thank you everyone