001all right thank you all right good evening we're going to call this meeting of the region 15 Board of Education to order for Monday January 13th can you please stand for the pledge of States indivisible and justice for all the mission of region 15 a collaborative Community committed to Excellence is to educate every student to be productive ethical and engaged in a global Society through proven and Innovative learning experiences supported by its strong Community whose decision- making is based in the best interest of all students we will start with our student Representatives Miss Tess girkins and Mr Brendan Finn all right good evening everyone starting off with h high school we have our senior semiformal on January 25th and today we have therapy dogs that came to visit in the career center for a little
002midterm distress and we have College Planning night tomorrow from 6: to 8 as well as midterm exams that are starting this Thursday the 16th moving on to BR B Middle School RMS students and staff have't me to be since returning from winter break they're excited to achieve goals that have been set for the New Year all students have recently completed the winter n WBA math ass and RMS PTO is cering ski nights to Mount Southington the sixth grade Winter concert and select small Ensemble concert is to be held Thursday January 16th and the drama club rehearsals T kicked off for this Spring's musical production as well as student council who is engaged in a cook Drive stay tuned for the RMS Super Bowl can drive and the end of their Quarter Two is Tuesday January
00321st all right thank you Tess moving on to all Elementary Schools kindergarten registration is now open and kindergarten orientation is set to take place on Thursday March 6 at 6m moving on to P Rock Elementary School in January students are following the star initiative focusing on striving to the Beer ourselves um the Winter band course and orchestra concert is set to take place on January 29th at middleberry elementary school they are expanding their after school activities to provide students with diverse opportunities to explore their interest and skills the current clubs they have include the board games Club the make your space Club um future Engineers Club and the basketball club uh this month students are also following the church initiative where they're participating in activities designed to foster a welcoming and support of community and
004this Friday families are invited to attend a atck hockey game fundraiser um as a way to gather the community and raise some funds for these school programs moving on to the athletics department the winter seasons are in full swing um this includes boys basketball girls basketball wrestling indoor track Watertown H rck Holy Cross hockey boys swim and div the ski team and gymnastics and then Mr serani to answer your question from last meeting um we have informly gathered information from various students at P rug regarding the payto pay policy and the general consensus is that students would rather not pay the $150 fee for sport however they feel it is completely reasonable price very very good thank you any questions on your rep thanks for the follow very dipl all right thank you very much
005appreciate it than um next we have the region 15 enrollment report superintendent so board members were sent a approximately for each slide um detailed overview of the entire enrollment report I'm not going to go over all the slides tonight I have about maybe 11 or so that I wanted to highlight and then provide space for questions the entire uh report will be put on the website and included in the MX um the purpose of this um I think everybody here has seen it before but i' like to remind those watching at home the um state of Connecticut uses October one as our official enrollment snapshot snapshot that enrollment uh on that day called our ADM or um average daily membership um becomes official on October 1 so if students move in on October 2 that's
006fine they're just not included and this number is used to drive anything that involves the size of the district um so any federal reports any state reports any calculations all come from the October one snapshot um the numbers that you're going to see tonight account for all the staff that work here it does not uh differentiate or disaggregate based on how we pay them so if they're paid out of the grant or out of the operating budget they're all included here as employees um we'll talk a little bit about that ADM and it drives the funding for each town and Community um and this report doesn't happen with a lot of collective effort so M bego plays a large role in um doing this and um our HR Director Mr is here tonight in case
007you asked a lot of detailed questions that um I can't answer although now we've been doing this for a few years and maybe not quite a well oiled machine but um they have a down pack on how we collect men dat um this is a little slide on demography there's a science and an art to it um we use two different demographers for this nzq is the U New England School Development Council they provide this service to us as part of our affiliation with that organization however they do kind of a a 50,000 foot view they don't get very granular um for about 10 years now the district has worked um Mike zuba is the actual demographer he's worked in a couple of different organizations over the years he's now on his own doing this
008work we've stayed with him even though kind of the organization he works with has changed um this is the nezda kind of high level where we are right now is the 2425 so if you look at their kind of um 2014 to 2034 spread we're in the middle of that um we've seen declining enrollment we're at the bottom of the trop so to speak and what they anticipated is over the next decade we're going to see um a slight enrollment increase but kind of the decline in enrollment we're at the the bottom of that curve this is that ADM the average daily enrollment this was sent to municipalities on October 7 and it get a little confusing because it's really a year in advance so the um October 1st 2024 drives the community responsibility per
009percentages for the 5 26 school year so this chart reads a little bit uh right to left in that the current school year percentage is driven by the 1023 data um which has middleberry uh paying 33 we got four decimal points here kind of one of the trade-offs and going for decimal points is you're guaranteed to shift every year um we could but the shift is may not be as extreme some districts only go out one decimal point some districts stay at a pure percent it's only Regional districts do this math um we go out four decimal points um but when you do that you'll see that the change so this current year that's the um breakdown 33.86 one7 for middleberry 6613 83 for southberry as we prepare for next year's budget the shift will
010be middleberry will absorb a higher percentage of students in southberry slightly less it's always in that one3 2/3 uh but that could have a a shift in um or it will have a shi in the community responsibilities for next year um I gave you the high level this is overall School summary um the ins and outs of each elementary school so you can see that um last just current school year we had a reduction of three elementary teachers over last year um you can see that the average class size when you kind of roll it all up is about the same or about two10 less per student per class overall but kind of you have ins and outs um of each school and where they're at one of the things that we've heard a lot
011this is not the first slide this is the first slide but at the last slide you'll see this uh this evening that we've had the cining enrollment and we have't reduced staff um I think that gets a little messy if you talk about it in aggregate staff but when you look at specific staff here you have an example of 68 fewer elementary students and three less Elementary teachers um then you can get into the non-certified staff and here's where you know the increase that you see is special education instructional assistant that's a pair educator that we added griven by a specific student need other than that uh enrollment Staffing Li flat year to year this is a hard to read chart but this is the same um type of chart when you look and roll
012that up um for our 612 staff so you'll see the I highlighted the family consumer science feature that's a feature that we added in the budget last year um I'm on this one the slide number is hidden I think we're at like 20 thank you say 19 so good slide 20 um when you get into those special ad and speech you'll see a fraction um I highlighted we went from 13.1 uh special education teachers to 13.4 if you think about a point2 is about is a day of school so a 1.0 employee um is 5.2 with a02 being a day so when you see that we added three of an employee it means that we're providing about a day and a half of additional services at the high school which means that staff member is
013split because we don't really have a person that only works one day or is in in this case it could be a contracted service and the same thing with speech you have about a half a day of services that will Prov at high school so when you roll all of that up the grand summary of Staffing um year toe and student enrollment the chart at the bottom I think is the best explanation for that question of how do you have declining enrollment and adding that so we added a culinary teacher that was a decision we made to add programming we added a multilingual teacher who was a staff member we added to increase um our ability to service students we added two Mathes those one was in the budget one was in the grant um
014but we added those to improve our instructional practice we added a Learning Center teacher a half a music teacher and an occupational parist and we removed Three classroom teachers so net we added teachers year Toe with the cining enrollment the teachers that we added all provide services that students need outside of the classroom so I think that's one of the challenges when you just look at student enrollment and you don't look at the types of teachers and services we're providing that kind of oversimplify that currently we have nine parent educator positions open that's pretty steady even as we hire some we lose others um and so we see that kind of um EB and flow of parent Educators uh in that position this is the entire District um a little Aster at the bottom we
015don't include in this substitute teachers technically they're employees of the district but we don't include them in our kind of Staffing total because they're um inter intermittent nor do we include athletic coaches again people who get a paycheck from us but are kind of intermittent in their role here our cafeteria employees are not direct uh employees of the Board of Education um although we're self-operated cafeteria system the employees work underneath that structure and our transportation our bus drivers uh work underneath our first student contract we're not direct employees of the board so uh we have approximately 639 full-time and part-time staff that work there every day and then there are some intermittent staff outside of that um I summarize there's about 15 slides if anybody's interested in really looking into enrollment drivers housing birth rates
016uh I didn't go through all of that tonight kind of the SU summary um is that the projections were revised downward slightly um based on this year's kindergarten enrollment one of the things that we don't know is the change in the kindergarten start date and the impact so is that going to create disproportionate amount of enrollment next year um there's kind of a an internal debate among demographers about how that's going to impact us um all three models show that we're going to grow in that short term especially at the elementary level um and then over time that increase in elementary is going to work its way through middle and high school and then you can see in elementary over the next five years or so we'll see about a 9% increase um in the
017middle schools it takes a little longer but we'll grow to the 962 um by that 2035 um and then that will roll up into the high school one of the questions that um board member had asked was what's the um accuracy rate of the demographers and what's their kind of um proficiency rate so we looked at a fiveyear uh projected number so if we went back and looked in 2020 what they had projected and what the actual was in 2024 oh typo there 25 that's this current school year um K12 they were off by 43 students or about 1% um K5 has the highest again kindergarten is the hardest to project because those students haven't been here before we don't know we know what the birth rate is for people who live here we don't
018know the um inward migration for kindergarteners so that 2 and a half% really is driven by that K5 number and I would tell you it's really driven by the K number um but once you're established in our school district um they're very accurate and um we're off um over four years they were offed by three students at the middle school and four students at the high school so you know when we talk about the fiveyear out rate um I would say the most volatilities in that kindergarten number once you can beond that they're pretty accurate and how they uh project our enrollment once you get the F Beyond five years it starts to become a little less active but we do this every year so you have current and then we can look five years
019out and they all show the same Trend that we're going to move up slightly over the next five years whether you look five years ago or in today um and that's the summary any questions or slides that I left out that you want to dig into no so first thank you for the prere very much appreciate it I know that's been a soap box I've been on for a long time so thank you um also really appreciate the information and the data you address one of my questions that I had about kindergarten because I recognize that kindergarten registrations happening now um how is it kind of trending relative to yours T given the changes and then have one additional question but you want to take one at the time yeah so I would think right
020now we haven't seen a a major shift um we um try to advertise as well as possible we have a very high percentage of people that who have older siblings in the building if this is your first showing making sure we communicate with dayc carees and things like that as always um I would say that by mid-February we have a majority of our kids come in and then the rest of the school year we see another bump kind of in July and August but those are people that usually move into the community um if you're in a um preschool or some other type of service like you're aware that um open a yeah I it's interesting to see like the class enrollment size because of the changes but I actually commend fact that we retain
021the class structure and the anticipation that it will bump up my second question is related to um I know you provided the summary slide on the enrollment and Staffing on slide 12 but if I drill down in some of the details where there was the um the shift in the Educators I think it was head count neutral if I look at slide eight um and I think it was the third and fourth grade at p as well as fifth grade at Mees we see somewhat of a significant increase in my opinion from 16 to 21 kids in the class 18.75 to 22 almost 23 we heard a lot of conversation last year about the importance of having individual time um Educators with children in the classroom and we ALS also heard a lot about that
022um the importance of that time to get to know how students learn to be able to individualize instruction relative to those students I am interested to hear um your philosophy and thinking because when I look at some of those shifts it's a significant impact on teachers who are already busy trying to balance all of that where in some of those teachers because the class sizes have been reduced from four sections three three SS or three teachers um it has an impact on their workload therefore it could potentially have an impact on that individualized time and assessments and all that could you speak a little bit about that because I do understand that there needs to be adjustments I do understand that we have targeted enrollment rates um but I've heard a lot about that importance
023for that individual customized education and I am concerned about the increase in the classroom and the burden that has on already um I would say Educators that are pretty well spread in so can you speak to that a little bit Yeah I think especially at the elementary level the conversations are different there the they're the same in that over time the pressures on classroom teachers and what we ask them to do are growing substantially and so you know there'll be people that argue that performance-wise class Size Doesn't Matter most people don't teach in a classroom you know and when you talk classroom teachers the difference between 18 and 24 is substantial so one of we talk about this frequently not just in onee conversations but kind of in multi-year because the other thing that is
024important is if we're going to recruit a teacher to come in we don't want to Art not artificially but bring that teacher in this year knowing that next year we're not going to have a space for them and vice versa I don't want to cut a position knowing that next year we're going to have to recruit so when we have this conversation around class SI we don't just look at the current year we look at kind of a a three you know what are the grades before it and how is that going to impact over time um and then we also try we have four Elementary School to create parody you know so that teachers in one building at one grade are similar to where they are I I think that um what you'll see
025when you look across is that we have pretty good parody I within two students the average class size on each grade with a couple of exceptions from time to time the more sections you have for grade the easier that is um you know and we're preparing now sapping is the biggest D that we have of our budget some of the questions going into next year's budget you know if today we think there's 21 students in a classroom you know do we add it a teacher or if we're at 18 students and we cut it and we go to 21 students you know like that that's a fine line but those are 60 70,000 conversations and so we try to look not just just at um so in the PES specific case um we had natural
026electrici at that grade level uh we knew that the fourth grade had three sections and that the second grade had three sections so if we hired a teacher for that grade we knew at the end of this year that teacher was not going to be needed and we'd have to move that teacher or not a position for and when we looked at the class size at other grades so like at the budget time that's not a position that we would have red circled and removed that teacher um but when natural attrition happened and the decision you make do you make a new section or do you kind of keep parody with the other schools you know that's one of the the factors that we weigh in so if you if you kind of not artificially
027but if we made when it um when it's status quo and it EDS and flows that's one conversation when we make a conscious decision to kind of bring a class size down in one bill bu and we don't do in other buildings that's where you have some parody issues um and I would say that every grade has you know kard an interesting room as we go into next year you know and if we're close we um hedge and keep kindig class sizes a little lower at budget times um expecting that bubble of students that didn't come next year but if they don't come this year then you have kind of and this happened I feel like in Co year we could could have been more aggressive with some of our kindergarten SE we had kindergarten
028class signs in like 12 to 13 which you know if you're a kindergarten teacher you would say that's very effective and if you were maybe more um of a a fiscal conservative you would say that that's unnecessary and so that's that tension that we kind of have that conversation knowing and and it's like different you know the high school is a little harder because it takes longer to get that critical mass or at the elementary schools um it's a little more um cut and dry so as far as that kind of the map you know at a SE remov um that's not a decision that myself or Mr Martino or Dr T P make an isolation that's um the elementary school teachers and and I um the principles start that we start that conversation pretty
029early really October I would say we started looking to next year um and even last year had questions had kind of areas that we're watching you know there are certain grade levels that we know are like on the cusp of course the cusp is also contextual right like we have sa that would feel that 16 in classroom is appropriate and that 18 is high because we've been able to deliver that for a lot of years when you talk to peers in other districts they would be shocked at our class size AES you know and so like contextual is what what matters to us and what what kind of the expectation we've established right we had 20 six in a fifth grade classroom or we hired a teacher this year that had 30 in a first
030grade classroom like we would have this audience full if we tried to do that and that's and I want to be respectful my colleagues that that's kind of where I'm going because I've heard consistently a narrative which I agree with about the complexities of Education it's very multifaceted the time needed to really reach children academically and I've also since my time on the board seen parents and community members be very tuned to enrollment class sizes so when I see those shifts being made I'm not challenging the rationale but I just want to be very cautious because we are not a school district with 30 kids in a first grade classroom and to change from 16 or 17 to 22 in a classroom that's a significant increase to a teacher regardless of how good or you
031know they are how how many years they've been in education and when I look at that relative to where we're trying to get from a curricula and performance perspective I want to be very conscientious of the narrative that's been built out in this paperwork as we start to go into the budget because it's as you know it's a very careful balance um but at the end of the day we want to make sure that our kids are getting what they need but also our Educators have the time and the bandwidth to be able to deliver the quality of Education that I think we as a region have kind of you know we're supporting um so that's my two sense I appreciate that commentary but um know that I would be keenly interested in the conversations
032coming in Mar yeah I think when we look kind of pay to our general um operating expectation I think that we built somewhere in the 16 to 18 um and when you get to five or probably in the 18 to 22 you know it's we may have a year where you have less than 17 in a third four grade classroom for a classroom that it's 23 but it's pretty rare I think that we if you look back over the last five or six years we've been pretty consistent in that 18 to 22 and most classes probably live in that 18 to 20 um and we've had a couple of outliers in um A2 um I think there was one two years when they're like 13 or 14 but most of the time it's in that
033like 15 I didn't say this and I'm sorry that's but it's also the infrastructure of our school it's impacting the classroom I mean anybody that goes into the elementary schools in c22 thingss in the classes there's not a lot of space I mean they're pretty P so I know you take that into consideration so thank you yeah a couple comments number one I was also going to thank you for the pread I'm right up there on that soap box with you so thank you two if you're following along at home strongly encourage you to uh open this report it's very detailed uh extremely transparent um some vulnerability in here and sharing this a little of detail every year this report gets longer I thank you for that um that makes us so much more informed
034as we come to those decisions later in the year uh three I very much appreciated you answering the question the board member had last year about how accurate are the democratics um because you know I had done that research myself last year and found them to be pretty accurate but I had done that again in prep of this and even more important I think than getting the exact number of students bang on you know I went back to your report from the 1920 school year and that far back they also had predicted that we would be in the draw like six years ago they said this year would be the draw year and so far that is that is held up so I'm actually more uh concerned with making sure we get the big trends
035correct as opposed to maing the exact number of students but yeah marphy work checks out um I did want to comment on um the question which you address I think fairly which is um you know you can't expect necessarily a correlation between the clining student population and our staffing levels um and I very much appreciate you pointing out that it's a different discussion year to year versus cume over you know however many years so when I pull up that 19 to 20 report we have the same snapshot and you look at how we have grown as a district and yeah our student population's down about 7% and in that same time our staffing is up close to 133% so I understand those lines don't quarterly but like clearly when you have one line going this
036way and one line going this way at twice the speed like that's not sustain right um now that is going to change and I agree with you on having to address specific needs I think that's less of a concern when you get to class sizes because I think that is a little bit more cut and dried right if we have suddenly a hundred more students in the grade yeah the stacking is probably going to correlate to to that a lot closer I guess what I am building towards is I think you've been extremely fair about how you've allocated teaching and class sizes as we look at non classroom positions I think that's we've had the biggest growth in our staff um do you foresee that as continuing to be a trend or do you think
037that the Investments we've made over the past six years have got us to a place where we are now ready to face the what we expect the you know increasing a well so or just wait two months in the budget no but I don't want to be like obuse about it either so like for example in 1920 we had no social works right so the demands of our students we talked about social emotional very differently postco than we did preco and so you know we created Two Social Work positions for 3,400 students and families who have a lot more um structural needs than they had that you know we added a a multilingual teacher this year because our percentage of multilingual students is almost doubled in so like to say that's going continue our our
038special ed special education par professional when you even break that down to 15% some of those are fair professionals some of those are non-certified staff and they're driven by student meets so our uh the special education identification rate used to be 13 um in like 2011 2010 now we're approaching 20% not just here like Statewide So when you say that like do I anticipated continue to some extent yes because Hartford and Washington continue to act more of school districts um and while they say they're unfunded mandates um or their mandates that don't cost anything to districts typically what they do is cost Personnel right which don't show up in kind of the OPM the office of policy management when they do their assessments um you know so we have more things being asked of us
039and a lot of the staff that we see aren't about instructional needs directly but about student service needs um and those have grown substantially over the last eight years and I don't know that they're going will totally go away you know I don't know that there'll be a you know will it be at 26% like I don't know that it will remain at 133% if you did another 5 year analysis I don't know that um but even when you look at this slide here of class size especially Elementary School like sometimes you lost 10 students and that was a reduction of a teacher sometimes you lost 27 students and that was a reduction of a teacher you know or we lo you know so some cases you may add students and not add a teacher
040um it all depends on kind of what grade they're in and when they move in but the service piece is really and that's the slide towards the end I think that I really wanted to highlight is um the exception of the math coaches um and maybe the uh elementary teacher uh music teacher a little bit which is really about a delivery service model rest of those are directly tied to programs you know and I think that's the hard part when you say like it's unsustainable I don't I don't disagree with you but I don't know I don't know how we Define sustainability right and and I'm going to talk a little later tonight that lines continue on that eventually they'll cross right so s 300 years from now that's yeah I don't think that's gonna
041we never GNA have more Staffing students that I'm pretty confident on uh but I do think there's this shift of responsibility from federal and state government down the local communities and that has triggered you know some of the services that we offer and we offer less than some of our peers are in direct response to no longer let's say the state sponsored through the Health Service and pushing some of those Services um into um it's the tough it's one of the toughest questions I get asked as a board member when people ask about Staffing um so thank you for your thoughtful response um I'm sensitive to the issue but I appreciate now having something to point people back to as the answer um and as a cap to that um I think we're very fortunate
042to be in a position as a district to have been able to invest so much in student support services in teacher Support Services I mean we build a whole coaching program over that period um that doesn't help happen without good planning and that doesn't help me without the supportive community in the RO so we're very very fortunate to have a very supportive commity and Bo these things un to un don't leave very quick again also on the pre reading so far just thank you uh and then the reason for the the interest in the demographer accuracy too to me is if we're talking about the GPSs feasibility like I wouldn't want to refurbish or build a new school and then have it be either too small or too big because you know we estimate um
043you know or we use numbers that were inaccurate but I mean I don't I don't know the answer to that it's really more of a comment I think that that'll come out as we discuss you know as the the planning takes long like well how much you know what what what are what are we sizing and whatever model commun serious thank um this may come out in later discussions but you one of the things I was curious about understanding was we've had a lot of discussion in the past couple years about team size at the middle schools it's not kind of called out specifically here um but you know what keeps what I keep coming back to in that discussion was that um our team sizes are still relatively large compared to our peers in
044middle school and I guess I would be interested in getting a follow on that the budget process or you have thoughts yeah I can speak a little so in the full report we go to little score which are slides 177 and 18 um the team sizes you'll see um if you take um the 128 students that's the team size and the 123 I think um part of the reason that we have the schedule so while there are um let's say 130 students I the average class size is relatively um manageable going under 20 I think they just what every class so there's kind of two layers to that one is I think we'd like to get to a place where team sizes were more0 more um if we did that though um and if we
045got there we wouldn't necessarily need the the schedule we had part of the the rationale behind the drop schedule that the Middle School's function under is so that each class kind of their sharance point before teacher contact time in that CL um is more but they're lip as a whole team um and then you also have um split team so that team of6 or 28 um really has in cases like six teachers um and some of those teachers teach two grade nums so um you know which again adds an advantage in that your student load is less but a complexity and that you're keeping to great um you know unfortunately fortunately one of the Dynamics of a teaming model is that you have kind of this critical mass that you have to grow to in
046order to justify adding a team which is what happened two years ago when we added that team um in between there you have these less desirable models that kind of the split teams or um who tried one the airr remember there's probably people in the audience but we had like the white team at Memorial was like 25 students that was you know an experiment that you know we we did not continue with or structure um so I mean I think there's a lot of ways um what's been important here and really in a lot of places is that Middle School model of having a consistent group of teachers teach a consistent group of students so that as students go through complex developmental time there's lots of conversation between teachers over how those students are developing
047and they can they can share that um otherwise you go back to like Junior High model where you structure middle schools like a high school where students just take a social science class and they're not part of the team um developmentally that model hasn't been as um supportive of students I think um so right now we kind of and and really for the foreseeable future we're not going to have uh enough students to have kind of a two team per grade Mage at one point in our history be that um but de demographically it's going to be a long time before that comes again so so we're going to have to live with this hybrid team structure um and we meet pretty regularly to kind of monify and adjust one of the small things that
048we can change to make it better and then one of the big things is how a one of the Milestone or or points in time when we're going to be a make some of those shapes some of them are going to have other choices you know whether it means adding certain sta that to make those other structures work do we see though in these demographics the rising time through the middle schools are we seeing like that there's going to be some like an infection where it's like that's know keep an eye on that because that be the point add even if it is another hybrid model um I think the way we're structured right now is going to allow us to heav and flow which is part of the reason I know there's some U
049challenges with our Middle School structure but it allows a lot of flexibility as far as being able to absorb uh I think it's this year's fifth grade class and third grade it's this year's third grade class that is disproportionately large um and then they get to the middle school but the fifth grade class is smaller so you know so the eighth graders are going to be leaving um or smaller than the sixth grade is larger so one of the things that we worked for kind of the question before about looking at this as a like four or five year cycle is all of our Middle School teachers are now certified up to 8 grade we had a point in time five years ago when there was a proportion of our Middle School teachers that could
050only teach up to sixth grade which made split teaming really hard so kind of to your point about looking out ahead we knew that this was going to be a problem when we move to this hybrid schedule that we have to do we wouldn't have the enrollment J by two grade but in order to do that I need to have teachers that to sixth grade and eighth grade uh content and so over the last four or five years we've work really are to either hire teachers that could teach all middle school grades not all contar but if I'm a math teacher before I might be a cas6 certified ma certified teacher I didn't have a specific math and now all of our teachers can teach their content area of Comm gr so we have more
051flexibility um Staffing strategy so we can manage some of those as of players thank you was this your's third grade large class was that the bubble we were surprised about years ago yeah think that um before you got here um no I was here this was we added I feel like this was a kindergarten that came in um whatever three years ago and we kind of were we added I think one or two sections because we had and I'm thinking back to um Steve's point when we had the last for lack of the better name feasibilities in the committee ilation um that's when we had demographers and they thought projections and everything else and then we ended up with a surprise additional kindergarten CL that year so some of those L are the same yeah
052you know and so likees but to Steve's Point too so like they don't know if there's another book Sign that's going to be bu three years from you know like so what they don't they know the housing Trends as of today they know how many housing permits were there when they pulled this data but if there is 100 Acre piece of property that someone purchases and builds 50 houses on three years from now these numbers don't take that into consideration or kind of postco where you saw this ship uh people that could work remotely and maybe left New England and moved to someplace else where they might have lower cost living but could still work remotely so um you know I feel like some of that actually helped as people migrated kind of to the
053suburbs from some of the urban centers um but they only know what they know at the time they sorry the other thing is the district moved from half day kindergarten to full day kindergarten and that was are We Done Right next thank you very much yes thank you um may I have a motion for approval of the December 9th 2024 regular meeting of the Board of Education minutes we've got the board approved the December 9 2024 regular meeting board minutes thank you Steve you have a second thank you Sharon second any changes questions right all those in favor I and may I have a motion for approval of the December 17 2024 special meeting of the Board of Education minutes thank you heather is moving a second Sally Romano any questions or comments right all
054those in favor I thank you next we have information and proposals board committee reports policy and curriculum committee Miss other um policy in curriculum met this evening to discuss policies related to student mental health some good progress there um the other thing that you have before you from policy and curriculum is these meet course proposal these are something we looked at um towards the end of last year um and have mve them forward to first read during this for this meeting um we have six new for proposals um you know we've made a pretty big investment in um program and I think um this is reflective of some of the um new uh learnings that students can access from that space so we have um some courses a little bit of a rework you know
055maybe some existing courses into more of a structure um so now there will be an introductory Force to culinary arts um there will be a v pastry there will be a restaurant management course um there's also an existing International cuine course um and also what would be like also another like culinary to Arts kind um what comes after the introductionary second so um I mean this is looking like a very nice structured program that you know we have sta for um so the costs here if you review these fores are really about um you know we have a couple uh career in technical education courses orts experience and then ECE course is an early college experience you may remember that we have grant funding these courses so um that EC does have a curriculum writing
056cost but that will be covered under um then we have a new physical education elective oldness physical education um which will have a lot of Outdoors activities um try to capture um interests of the students with that that course um you know if you're looking for for C there's writing there's also for that one there's equip be meetings fishings and whatnot so that's what you have before you um any questions yes sir uh so I mean I did look through but also there's no so it's not a new staff they were just three none none of these are new staff no and then um prior to the addition of the remake of The Cone room we talked about the cin culinary kids wanted to take culinary and they they could yeah so is has that
057what that class is that now coming introduction to culinary arts so when you so there will be like there will be an entry level um course for culinary arts that will cover you know maybe some um you know kitchen safety type lessons that you know thiss should probably you know know how to use a knife you um you know that'll cover kind of um kitchen Basics before they really get you know so everyone to take any culinary would have to take the in um and I think there will be a certain amount of students who maybe have not been able to take culinary who may be able to skip all I think the intent is that we want everybody to start with in may be a bit of a phase in but we want everybody
058to um and then so when we added when we approved the culinary space and then added the t-chart I remember it being sort of like there were dual reasons one was we wanted to grow the program like just offer basically Beyond just culinary right but then we also wanted to increase like part of the criticism was that there were kids students that for four years you know put that as a primary elective and could not get into it so and um you know there was talk about um uh you know specifically Dr R had mentioned that uh you know we want every student to find like their person and interested adult and they're they're quick um if we I just want to make sure that if we now start like adding other programs like that
059seem to be dependent on getting that first course like so got these other programs the young people that can take it are the kids that got into that very first like five sections of intro you know so we haven't really helped any more any more students I guess that's we'll be like an AR right so in the beginning we may only offer one section of these for one semester and then more sections of the in class and then as kind of we hit that saturation point of the intro you can offer fewer sections remember all of our you're proving the course being created you're not approving it running so the courses will run based on student enrollment so if you have more students enrolling in the intro class and fewer students enrolling in the baking
060class you may only offer one section of baking and four sections of that's and so what you have now is by having with two teachers and and a structure available you effectively double the amount of students that have access that space and so this allows us now so for students that want to continue you can now offer these classes and again we're doing enrollment coming up soon um those things will you know e and flow based on where the interest is BAS if there was a ton of Interest it is conceivable that at some point you were either saying I'm going to take a set of students that have had interest or Colin I'm going to allow one of these sections to run and I'm going to put those students in another section and therefore
061there are perhaps other students that have had no culinary classes and would like an intro course but maybe there is not enough sections because we have chosen who run higher level courses in L of having iing about the arc but at some point like there's still going to be if it maintains this popularity we could still find oursel in a situation where not everyone is getting into int C so yeah so these are like one semester classes so you could say you know every other year I'm making this up but every other year you might offer that pastry and baking class so that um students that want to take it are going to take know this year it's not being offered but next year it will be and so you know if you take that
062intro year freshman software year and we alternate some of those you'll have you know lots of sections in the fact we have your courses you'll be you could offer two sections of one first semester one second semester and there's but only one second you know and so then the students um can be spread out over the course of the year you know but it'll be driven if there's that much interest in the intro and I think in the beginning there's kind of this backlog of students that want that intro it'll be skewed that way the beginning and then over time you'll be able to kind of create some kind of a like an ecosystem of how we run some of these fores and then does it does this lead into future growth with you know
063some type of certification the food service and restaurant for will have Ser safe certification there was some discussion right now so that serve safe uh certification will allow students to walk out of our classrooms and into a resurant uh right now for example our drone class um you can do something similar if you want that drone license that's on you because it's your certification um there's some conversation around this one where there are districts using um a state Grant to subsidize that for students um whether we do that or not is a a topic for discussion I think um but historically if this is something that is yours to keep outside of the school district that causes stent an ECE credit for example if you want credit from Ukon you pay for that credit sure
064you don't pay for that um so that's a little bit of a discussion right now um but either way it wouldn't be built into the um operating budget of the SCH dist right so I'm sorry so just to clarify it's like the Drone course where go take the restaurant management course and you wish to get the start you can do it and there's a cost associated with it whoever P thank any other questions and heads real quick a couple quick things I'm not speaking from the data but eyes and ears tell me that like the additional capacity of the room and the additional higher culinary arts has broken up that log gy that enrollment log JY maybe that's something we can get a definitive answer to but I've never heard of freshman getting into culinary
065this year which is hard to believe so um yeah it would be good to have confirmation on that when we reviewed these in PNC we had a helpful kind of org chart of like intro and then you could break into these classes yeah it is it is in the um course proposals for those culinary courses maybe not a diagram but there's a there's oh it's right here okay so it's uh I'm bring this up Steve's question there's you know this right here you take right now it's called it's called food and nutrition in the original version it's now in The Culinary then you can see under that like second level is col baking Regine and then the third level is a f services and was a blue I saw a blue and yeah I guess
066the last thing I'd say is you know Mr Smith just pointed out in that certification class which is wonderful and I was you know someone who felt strongly about the culinary program I think that's the the dream to get a certification you know I think in the budget we currently do have it built in as $179 per student for that c so if that's an ongoing certific uh discussion so be it I think it'd be nice if it's a requirement of the class that we're able to offer that and even nicer if that's something in general apply but talking more about it other questions Heather first this is the first there will be a second all right thank you next you have financing facilities Miss shanon cavalo thank you very much sorry I'm late coaching
067basketball so we met today at noon at central office and discussed various things I'm not going to go in order the agenda um but we talked about right and next time the friends together program tuition will come here for board go but we did push that through today on the agenda you'll see misscellaneous salary but we are reviewing that internally to make sure it's alignment before it comes here to the full board and then the one other thing um the excess cross dollars and I don't know if we want to go in specific to bitly we've got refunded at 65% right which is Bel low kind of waterm Mark or 68% and we budget it 65 I guess the state informed go and J today that it was at 60% so that's a 4 485,000
068485,000 deficit that we will have to make there's more abely that my super update does matter that it is it is set that is um it's not tied to the upcoming plan budget is the based on last year the current operating budget so the state calculates um they they give us their um projection so to speak last year um the recommendation from um some of our friends and I'm careful and that this is not this was their intent it wasn't um malicious or naive um but they were talking 84% reimbursement um that is their desire the problem is the pool of money um doesn't allow for 84% reimbursement so what they do is then they downward adjust the percent um reimbursement based on the alloted alloted fund the state has allocated and the requests that
069districts have submitted we knew last year at the time that that Delta was about 80 million dollar that districts were going to ask for 80 million more than the state allocated um they did not make an adjustment in the allocation during last year session um then there was uh inflationary cost on top of that uh which was why Mr Martino and I decided that 65% would have been the lowest funding I think in history if not recent history um we thought we were being conservative in that 65% um we learn new things every day and what we learned is that that wasn't conservative enough um and we were funded at 60% districts um across the state were funded in the areas of like 59.5 to to the high Watermark I they weer the districts funded
070at 68% um some of the the lowest um socio socio economic District in the state we at 68% those districts by the way have been funded at 96% when we were at 84% so you're looking at about a 20% shortfall for us um that is $480,000 approximately that we had anticipated Revenue that is not going to the great Liv um had we budgeted at the 84% uh we would have budgeted about 1.6 million in anticipated revenue and that would have been a very very P goal um kind of the the good news if there's a silver lining there's two silver linings as I see it one um our out of District tuition lines um are to the good we had some students that we anticipated paying for that have moved out a district that we
071did not have to pay and we have not yet touched the um contingency for special education that we increased I think two years ago um in anticipation of volatile costs so we are somewhat insulated from this um unexpected uh change the other piece um this has been a very very contentious conversation for over a year now I do think that um our friends at Harper understand that 60% is the lowest in the history that we can do in research at least of 2007 which is kind of when we started tracking this um and it's substantially lower so I do think that the understanding in Hartford is sharper um and as they go into a VM budget um this when we talked about cost being shifted from from to be fair from Washington when the ID
072BR legislation was enacted in the 70s they were supposed to reimburse States 100% that's never happened um and districts were supposed to be reimbursed at 100% there were a couple years I want to say like 2009 and 10 um that we were reimbursed at 100% again if we were reimbursed at 100% now you're talking about $2 million in costs that the state would that instead local taxpayers are um so that is um didn't bad news of that surprise um and will make us think a little bit about how we budget next year and and help conser we consider conservative in that estimate but you probably looking at about a half a million dollar shift in that conversation r as we enter next budget year I think Finance um at the meeting today you guys had
073an excellent enclosure number five I would encourage everyone to take a look at it because you guys really went down to like every year that it's it's shocking to see how it just goes down every year um from where it was in 20 um 2007 so I would encourage everyone to take a look at that funds they're just not increasing their allocation but all the cause says you guys know very well increased costs and they're not keeping up with those increased costs for the fact that there's more services that we're now providing for students and by the way our deductible that four and a half times um the per people that we are responsible for continues to grow so this is like at four and a half% of a $20,000 student we pay for the
074first $90,000 of that student that number grows every year what our per pupil grows so even in defining enrollment as our per pupil grows faster that metric still works and so we have a higher deductible than we've ever had and we're receiving less reimbursement than we've ever had so it really is kind of pulling both ways um and every time there's not a conversation with a legislator the so they just need to allocate more they can find somebody else to break their promise with I know we haven't touched the contingency but how comfortable are we with the current incumbrances in the special Edline what what would affect that and kind of increase beyond what we've already UNC so um we're not ready to do any laps yet I think the piece of that outward the
075external tuition funds is that in at any day we could have a student we know there's a few students that could potentially need those services or one that would move in so as of today we're watching those accounts but we're not doing any shifts to say this equals that you know I think as the picture gets clearer we'll we'll know better um unfortunately like some of our PE um budgeted in the 70s and took that 60% and are looking at things like budget freezes or are some more kind of theing fiscal measures we're not there today um we get surprises all the time um and we continue have adjustment any other finings and Facilities questions right next we have PTO advisory committee Miss Shar so P2 advisory met on January 2nd and um we continued
076conversation about teacher grants and there's a lot of work being done in that space uh just to bring Clarity to what can and cannot be considered as Grant the process Etc so I commend on the work that's being done there um there was also an update regarding to in about P to play and where we are with the facilities USB policy and the fact that um that is kind of in a Sprint for review um and this I think it starts next week um there was also discussion related to kindergarten registration and the fact that that's opening and to make sure that people are aware ofing registration is curring um and lastly a conversation over fundraisers um so the next meeting is scheduled for February 6 any questions for Karen on the report right next
077we have the superintendent report superintendent Smith just want to start by saying Happy New Year this our first 2025 meeting appreciate that you did a lot of work in 2024 so nice job and um we're just getting started so you know don't take too much of a breath but um I think we're pretty excited about what is uh in front of us the only piece I would add on the excess cost is that there's a reason we delay some of our repair and maintenance work toward the end of the year um because that creates a space that other things uh that we can't control from many um the only other piece I wanted to talk about was the U power tool data breach um last week we were notified um by power school that they
078had a data breach um it really was National um what's really amazing is 5 seconds once they told us where to look we found where person gained access and it took L than five seconds to P like 25 years data um that data system and structure is part of our contract so the students data privacy feys is part of our contract with the vendor so while this the data PR it's not a region 15 data this wasn't our system it wasn't well it's our data we host that data with them they're responsible for the security of it um we do not store after 2007 there's no student Social Security M right in 2007 state of Connecticut didn't have What's called the student identification number they used social SEC number so there may be some data
079um not of any student that's active but if there was Legacy suit data in there that is part of the the report that they're supposed to provide to us on the 17th of January the data that was taken we do know they went into um it's mostly demographic data minimizing that at all but it wasn't any medical records it wasn't U those files that they um any discipline data anything like that our school has ured us that they identified the indidual that took it and they were had assurances that all data was destroyed and not shared um I'll leave to you the skeptic of that but they use some pretty specific uh data um kind a discovery and destruction methods to ensure that um that is Again part of the assurances that I expected they
080will give to us as any protections or um solutions that they will offer directly families that may have been impacted but um we are kind of the middle people here we need to hold them accountable as our vendor um but I am not taking and I don't mean this in a bad way but our region is not taking responsibility for their data breach um it's not our insurance we do have Cyber attack Insurance um Mr Maro I met multiple times on this um this is not part of our policy because this fall under their responsibility and so I expect they will need right y any other questions on report okay next we have board member comments go ahead Shar well just one and it's part one of a really big thank you um a pleasure
081uh to go on the um ORS and privilege to go on the school tours really appreciated um everybody's time and willingness to allow board members into the schools it's a great opportunity to see um the schools in action and really appreciate the teachers willingness to allow us to step into the classroom and kind of see um how things are operating um really really appreciate it and I know it's people are really busy and so to take time and have board members come and be okay with us like watching them I I just want to say big thank you and as I said part one because I plan to go to the ones that are happening this week and this week and so I'll be thanking everyone again a second time but um really thank you
082so much I just wanted to say thank you for you know having the culinary or the culinary program inviting us in I did the uh pomp rug bake up this morning at 8 am. so that was really nice being able to see the students interact they had to take like a lesson learned they had to give a little speech they had to create something they had to Plate it and they did a really great job so that was a nice experience to be able to see that and be in the classroom and kind of see all the work you did here to put a room into fruition and how they like because I got there early so I could see them kind of move around the room and and how this space really worked out
083so that was really nice so you know thank you and you whoever invited us there because it was really nice to see that so I don't know if anyone else is going or have gone but so you voted I voted so those if you don't like those things that were picked right as I picked things today which is also why I grabbed a lemon cookie on my way because good one was Miss Kean The Culinary teacher who invited the board very nice of her I think Mr Rano is going tomorrow and I'm going but we're doing quick threads I think these were quick okay cookies yes it's something it's how like it's uh baking soda I learned a lot today learn like the difference between baking soda and baking powder and how those are formed
084in recipes I learned a lot so it's like a great start to my day I got to eat delicious cookies and quick breads so so you you'll get a nice experience forward to it all right let see was just a follow up on the school tours um Sharon Tom and I were at MMS and guess noteboard and we did see the cafeteria which could be a little bigger just sort of moved a wall uh so that's that's probably um and it would would decrease the amount of lunch waves they need and it sort of have all these skating benefits um but it is a bit prices so in my personal opinion is kind of on on the wish list but and we also saw the tennis cour um uh which would be great to PVE
085that over and maybe use it for some physical education and recess space um and Sharon and I were at Mees um we saw the media center which was really just really I hadn't been in there I think so but it is I thought that was a great space we saw the music room which was uh had to be redone because of the leak um and that looked really nice and we discussed or was explained to us how um we're going to try and mitigate or you prevent prevent the leak from happening again um hopefully uh we saw um the room with where the water had come in is that the library Pao rightside is Ms Library M that was the bottom of the library Courtyard was yes so a lot of water we did not
086see any um and the uh that's been reion and M needed so the water drains away a number from awnings to drains um The Learning the CP classro that we created last year yes with the for focus on um different types of special needs that was it was very nice uh and we saw it in use so good to see that um that uh utiliz after the money was spent to Furbish it um and mes is is a little crouded um I haven't been there in years and years and years so what I saw at the very first time it was like it was actually way more crowded than it is now but um they're almost cor people working in closet so I are working in closet how you solve that but um yeah no
087yeah I um but it's still it's yeah it's not so so again I quick hits uh yes thank you to principals the staff the students this be a disruptive part of your day tours have been great so far and looking forward to doing more on Friday uh two if you're not doing anything tomorrow after lunch um don't get excited there is a cave webinar on K through a social studies curriculum I guess has changed at the state level um I know we have an upcoming presentation here at the board on social studies so I'm going to try to make that over lunch and see if can learn anything in advance of that and then the third thing I just wanted to um toss bqu for uh the new lighting at the high school probably notic
088tonight and phen I if you want to speak about that but it's a tremendous upgrade thank you for that we budgeted in last year's Capital that was one of the projects that we budged well it really is was a safety issue um I do think if before you leave tonight you down there it is we joke it's night and day because it really is daylight the saf is so much better on so many levels walk down to the Trap is that no it just Downs to the end of where the Athletics area is the pool side has additional lighting as well the gym side yeah you canate and we saw the security cameras being installed at MS2 again with Bond grant money as well so it's nice I know a lot of planning did to
089kind of P that together so there's a lot going any other comments All Right Next we have comments citizens uh the Board of Education will recognize citizens of middleberry and southberry and citizens are asked to State their name their town of residence and to limit their comments to 3 minutes in accordance with region 15 Board of Education bylaw 9325 a speakers are asked to express themselves in a civil manner with due respect the dignity and privacy of others who may be affected by their comments while is not the board's intent to stifle public comment speakers should be aware that if their statements violate the rights of others under the law of defamation or invasion of privacy the speaker may be held legally responsible so any public comments just me which means that's good because I
090can go home after this which I think you all what to do I'll try to keep it less than three minutes if you could just write your name there should be a piece of paper on there so we can get your accurate um spelling um and for your name for the minutes got it and then I have a little timer watch here so it'll let you know when you hit three minutes we be on the SL all right um so first of all thank you for your time uh my name is Jason Saunders I'm a resident of southb Connecticut I currently I'm a member of the prog youth crossboard here in town very active in the community got two young boys one is six and three and uh you know one of my charters for
091the board is to really just try to increase support for obviously the youth cross program all programs um in town some play soccer they play basketball and also work on better integration into the high school former College cross player I've also coached at the high school level uh for a region region n Joel Baro so I have a lot of understanding of how regions work and did a lot of work in that Community to try to improve uh their overall organization um I've also spoken to some of you Josh I know we've talked about this really fun concept of field cost um and I'm also a fiscal conservative I understand um the inflationary factors that counts under and uh also understanding that you know my taxes have also gone up 20% um the last year
092too as the South Bar's recess um all that being said the issue that I'm really working to address is a high field use costage uh High field usage cost for the nonprofit program that I represent um in the past we costed kids through other colleges outside the community um we've had to cancel practices uh there's just a long list of events and what we're really trying to do is is again integrate the community uh integrate the high school into the youth program and you know having access to the high school field obviously with beautiful weather we have in the Northeast in the spring as an example um we being able to bring the high school students down the field if they're available to watch maybe the seventh and eighth graders play there's just so much
093you can do um but the cost of $100 per hour is been pretty prohibitive um we have to be fiscally conservative just as you all are look at the bottom line as we're a nonprofit you know spending 5 10 $15,000 a year the you the field know just wasn't pable based on you know the economics of the last few years um and it's kind of counterintuitive the ecosystems that I'm trying to build but again I understand that there's a balance in everything right um that being said I know there's some good ideas I I've been talking to some of you I've been talking to people the community I know there's some ideas floating around about how we can try to make this um a better situation but also make sure that it's fiscally you know
094in line with that you know taking a giant chunk out of the budget um and uh and I'm very very hopeful that all the ideas that are fling around will come to some type of resolution that you know many people in this town will be very excited about that is just a good North Star and kind of a vote forward uh for the youth programs to make people feel you know excited about what we're trying to do in town for for our kids so um again I know the vote that you originally had didn't go through but I know that because there's more detail needed and and uh I just want to say I look forward to meeting on the 21st and thanks for listening sorry that was extra three seconds you got it appk
095you very much have a great night appreciate thank you so much any other comments all right um we have announcement of future meetings um Tuesday January 21st is a special meeting of the Board of Education and I apologize it's um mated in the um the agenda it's at 5:00 and it'll be here at the library media center so that's next week Tuesday 5:00 library media center here and I'll send that a reminder to everyone it's a special meeting and all tend to get confused if it's not a Monday night um Monday January 27th PNC has their meeting at the media center at 6:30 also Monday January 27th we have a regular board ofed meeting at the PHS Media Center at 7:30 we will be discussing a portrait of a graduate um may I have a
096motion to move into executive session move that the Board of Education break into executive session for the purpose of reviewing superintendent Smith's midyear goals and to invite superintendent Smith and interns Eric alanza and Jody Mady into the meeting you have a second second okay second Steve serani all those in favor