CorpusRecord 111218

BOE Budget Workshop 2

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SPS BOE
Date
2025-01-10
Location
Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,387 words · about 53 min
Collected
2026-06-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right I think we're it says it says yeah it's starting it just hasn't yep it's cold needs to warm up yeah I was gonna blame Glenn because he's here yeah I I was gonna ask when that why my time on my computer is always wrong no matter how many times I reset it but that's okay we are live I thought I was late we're live hi everyone welcome to the Shelton Board of Education special meeting budget Workshop number 2 today is Thursday January 9th 2025 it is 6:02 p.m. and we are going to call the meeting to order if I could get a roll call please Joan Littlefield here Jason nevs here Patricia moonin here Anthony smarino is absent Kate cach here Jim fan will be late Lorraine Rosner here James orette here and

002Amy Rano here also in attendance Ken serich Jacqueline tuling John Calhoun and Glenn Newman perfect okay if we could all please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States One Nation indivisible justice for all I'm glad we're all in unison were we barely a little Echo it was kind of yeah it was good it was good okay can I please get an approval of the agend a motion to approve the agenda motion to approve the agenda Madam chair okay motion made by James oretti second I'll second second by line Rosner all in favor I okay moving on to agenda items today we are going to discuss the operational Department of our budget um we are going to start with security item number one and Mr serich we

003will let him speak and take that over thank you madam chair so I I just want to talk about although I am going to start with security the the agenda is security technology and then facilities and maintenance um all three of these departments we have worked with the city in the past in terms of funding their allocations um through a capital plan uh what you'll be seeing tonight is the aspects of the capital plans will be presenting to the city I think that is in the best interest of the city as a whole um since these are what I'm going to call like one shot items you know um to to put them in our budget and then increase our budget amount our general budget amount from year to year when we're really just we

004just really need um certain aspects to be paid as a one time annual piece as they come up it's the most effective cost effective for the city the taxpayer it's worked very well with the city again um so our intent would be that we're just going to show the capital projects for an understanding for the board and the public um and and then we'll put those as part of the budget book but it will not increase our general um line items for the budget Exel both security techn both security and Technology do not have any line item increases to their current budget um so I will speak on just the the security Capital plan I'll have Glenn speak on his Capital plan for technology um Glenn always finds ways to save money within his Department

005to reallocate money to other line items um which is a real asset for us so that we do not have to increase his line items over time but um definitely still meet the needs of the district um and speaking for Glenn with that we know next year is going to be a major technology year for us as a lot of renewals and contracts come up but uh the year after next we're doing this budget next time but for next year we believe uh his line items can stay stagnant we can work within those means um but we do have the the capital items when we go to John John will present his Capital plans as well um but he's going to talk about two two needs that go under the general budget um one one

006which is um Rising equipment costs you know that he'll talk about when we get there and and another aspect of the budget that we want to make the board aware so we can have talking points and guidance from the board as far as how we want to proceed um with those needs with that said I'm going to share the screen um we're going to be sharing a lot of um visuals today and this is why the virtual environment works well um it is my intent to put the visual up and then take it down so that we could see everyone and talk about it if necessary I know all board members have copies of them so after I've shown it you can refer to your hand copy or or whatever copy you may have at

007home um but I will show it to just discuss it first so I'm going to talk about the security Capital plan let me just share my screen okay so if you can see what what is being um tasted is this is the security Capital plan for now I I'd like to just speak to it briefly to kind of say you know um after the very very unfortunate incident that took place in New Town um over a decade ago our city um which prioritizes you know student and staff safety invested a lot of money in a capital plan over 10 years ago to fit all of our schools with cameras and security needs and Beyond and we're very very grateful for what we have but to that end this is over 10 years ago and as

008you all know what technology and security needs um we need retrofitting and Replacements and over time um so this Capital plan really is is a need to express to the city about a lot of outdated security measures that we have that we want to be um in compliant with um uh mediate systems that are breaking down um so we can continue that effort of security for our students and our staff and even further the security issues um as we continue to see the worlds associated with excuse me one second because Mr fan is joining us um the world associated with um just School violence and safety and and as such so you'll notice on the capital plan it it mentions by location so perial School uh we really would like a repeater on the building

009of per Hill School um per Hill school is a large facilities um although the school was retrofitted new back in 2009 the building itself is an older building a lot of concrete a lot of Steel and its designed and to really uh emphasize the effectiveness of the radios that we use and to communicate with those radios districtwide um uh Mr trapa you know our head of security with you know in working with Mike mag magone which is the um head of management security for the city would like to put a radio repeater tower um within Perry Hill it will emphasize the communication within the building as well as speaking of when per Hill open which I believe was in 2010 is when we opened the building um those security aspects of the building haven't been

010upgraded since 2010 here we are entering you know 15 years later so we need to upgrade some of the com the the security systems um the card readers cameras within the building itself and that's the first line item that you see the second line item goes to the high school um there's really a focus of attention on just upgrading security measures um particularly in the upper field areas where we would just like to increase security around those those areas then we get to Elizabeth Shelton the design of Elizabeth Shelton those of you who are familiar with it um when they put that addition on years ago back um not on the fourth grade Wing but the opposite Wing where we go down to music and such um there's an entrance way the door directly goes

011out to um uh the pl ground area um there is no access door to get back in the building from that area so in the event that you know you have to evacuate the building and reenter um uh students and staff have to walk all the way around to either where the library is or the front of the building and it just seems sound to put a card reader access um in that end of the building um so that students you know can get back into the building if students were out at the playground and there was a need to come back inside of the building um that that's the most direct route for us so on a security measure would be easier to put the card reader there and then as a whole as

012I just mentioned earlier you know many of our cameras although we are extremely grateful for all the security that the city invested um more than a decade ago um are some of them are failing some of them are just outdated and old um we still have high security members in our in high security measures within our schools but it is time for an upgrade so the last line item speaks for a systemwide upgrade um to those cameras that need the most TLC within the system themselves so as I said since the board themselves has copies of this information I'm going to stop sharing to kind of open the screen so that we can all see one another and uh open if there's any specific questions about security um otherwise Madam chair I could entertain we

013can move over into technology okay just Ken I I just have a quick question the the repeater has there been any discussion with the city about uh co-use of the repeater on the perill school yes that's a great question at a great point because um once it's there it would be accessible not only for school use but they can also use it for emergency services as well so it then that's why you know we originally looked into it to a grant that would be funded partially through the city um because it would the city can do that and benefit from its use as well okay any other questions okay sensing none then we will move on to the next line item in Tech which is technology and our technology director Mr Newman is here and

014I'm sure between Mr Newman and Mr serich we will let them take over so I'm going to turn it over to Glenn to speak I am going to share the screen Glenn and put up um the capital plan on the screen okay I know if you need to say something beforeand before I share it or I could just share it direct no nope share away okay yeah thank you Glenn for joining us this evening it is good to see you okay wise yeah so thank you um so Yep this is um next year's um technology Capital plan uh request um it's very straightforward um and and simplified um so I'll just start from from the beginning um The High School auditorium projector in screen is a carryover from from last year um it wasn't um

015replaced last year but it is a you know quite an old system and and as you you know have aging projectors and screens the screens you know start to fall apart and the projectors start to get dim and and blurry um and it's just the nature of how that technology works so that's why that one is there um the next item is um the first item for for next year for Chromebook replacement plan um essentially when it comes to the Chromebooks um you know we do have um enough in the district you know to have one per student in grades K through 12 with Perry Hill and up being actual oneto ones um and so when the Chromebooks get to about five to six years of age that's when the hardware um has quite a

016few miles on it um and tends to fall apart and we need to be looking to to to replace them so that's kind of why everything's positioned where it is here and then also um Parts availability affects whether or not you can repair it and so the market dictates whether or not you know you can repair them depending on the shape that they happen to be in but um next year that would basically replace um half of the ones that are in K through 4 um at the you know the next line item down um and then continuing for next year is something that we just we keep in the following year because it's a constant need is the interactive displays um so now when I first started um and first put this together um

017you know four years ago or so um four and a half years but when I finally put this together was about four years ago um that number of interactive displays that we had to replace was um a little over around 370 um so what I have tried to do um is utilize small grants um every year anything I can do to chip away at it um so we've been fortunate enough to get that number from 370 or so down to 253 um in the 747 th000 whereas you know even just last year it would have been over a million um because we're able to to to to you know take a chunk out of it this year um and you know we do my my staff are very very good and diligent at trying to

018keep them operational um a lot of them are between 15 and 18 years old um and you can't get the parts anymore so we retrofit new projectors and different mounts and you know we scavenge anything from a district who might have upgraded and has anything we can use um so we do everything we can to keep them running and they do a great job with it um so the hope is you know that we just keep keep chipping away as best we can um and then for the following year um that's when the high school Chromebooks um which we went one to one for the first time at the high school in 2020 um so then that brings us you know around five six you know seven year mark where you just they just need

019to be replaced you know at that point um and so the following year you know we project there wouldn't be need to be any replacement and then after that in the fourth year we come back to fifth sixth seventh and eighth grade which we have been able to consolidate into one block um it used to be in blocks of Fifth and seventh grade um when I first started and that's kind of it was that way because that's how they were piloted initially um but we were able to combine them and and consolidate and and get them on a similar schedule so it's easier to to to manage um so yeah and that's the technology Capital plan um Glen I guess the only thing that I would I mean of course we have to put this

020together for the city but in my eyes and I'm sure that you know this is going to be a whole package with explanations but I would probably just suggest and I don't know who puts it together you know in the end that we have like under the notes like for example the shs auditorium projector you know like maybe a little ASC that says carry over hey we asked for this last year we didn't get it and you know we're trying to stay on type some type of schedule I know they gave us the money for the Chromebook thing but we didn't we didn't get this and then even for the interactive displays maybe under the notes say that we were at 370 and you know you know what I'm saying like an as with some

021details of what you just gave us so that when they get this information you know they they know also they can't remember everything from year to year to year to year right so any like those little bits of information Ken you know in Glen that would be nice to maybe just put in the notes so it shows that we're making our effort to fix them and repair them and you know we're chipping away at this number too yeah so I'm sure Glenn can make those additions on he's the creator of the spreadsheet and then get them Jackie Jackie ultimately will include it in the budget book when we we ship it over to I think it just it it just flows nicely so that you just gave us that presentation but somebody else reading it

022will then just see those little notes absolutely right is that okay yep I'll take care of it yeah thanks I just think it would be nice but that's my only comment but it it's nice to see that 2027 2028 we could take a little break well I have to say um the the the largest thing to carry which to Glenn's Point we've been trying to do for years is getting us past this interactive board report I mean it is such a need and at a cost um we can't fix what we have they don't make them anymore they don't make the parts I mean I truly give credit to our tech center of macgyvering as much as they can you know to to help instruction but even to a certain point uh you you just

023can't do some of it and I know last year I showed a video of what some of those worst screens look like and they're inoperable like to some some teaching staff can't even use the boards in their room and so you know Glenn is you know has been trying to you know parcel money through eate to kind of get some interactive new displays which has been you know helpful to the city because the increase that we've been asking over time has diminishing but let's remember even though the number of boards that needs to replace diminishes the cost of the board year-to-year continues to rise so the longer we wait the more that you know like that that cost either stays the same or or just continues to rise and eventually we're going to have to

024replace every single board that we have well but we we've sort of came to an agreement with them with this Chromebook and and doing the Chromebooks you know each year a little bit we really need to try to tie them down and say this is such a big number but we're not doing anything about it we really need to get on some type of schedule we have to try to Myers down right you know and say okay we'll give us this much this year then some type of plan moving forward over the next say you know three to four years and and last year because we've had this number annually for the past few years last year I did speak to the mayor directly I did speak to John and glaz directly that this is

025the total number if they wanted to parcel some out and we spread that over three years we we'll be fine with that just to have some kind of commitment to to kind of do a stagnant replacement of the boards that need to be replaced exactly I ask you a question about the you said the boards increase on a yearly basis why are they increasing they should be decreasing with the use of the techn I'm saying those boards you can't even buy anymore we have to buy an totally different product so it's a it's a new product buying to replace right but the new product the new product as we're buying it and the following year they should be less and less as the technology is rapidly increasing as even you suggested that so that that

026those boards should be decreasing in price on a year-to-year basis is that right well it it depends it depends yeah it's um I mean the model if you have a new model you know it can be a higher price if you get a bigger size it can be a higher price um you know we we do well with them where you know and if you buy them in a bigger bulk you know you'll get a decreased price I get bulk pricing but I mean if you're buying the same model you know this year then next year the next year the the price should be on a should the Redemption price should be lower because of you know the the te the technology unless you're unless you're buying a new product every year well and that's

027what I was going to say to to answer my statement to your question Mr is you are correct I mean a product but at a certain point in time they stop production of a certain model and then it's the new model just like look I I'll use the example of the iPhone you know you have the iPhone 6 or whatever and then the iPhone 7 comes out then the iPhone 8 comes out and then what's the availability of a particular product so you're going to have to move to the next model itself yeah I don't think these boards change as fast as the iPhones I know my iPhone changes every year Madam chair I have a question on on that on the J go ahead so to to your point Ken if we took this

028747 and we spread it out um you know with three-year plan or whatever it is I know Glenn mentioned that he uh he was able to get 120 units roughly uh through grants which is great Glenn thank you for that um how did you spread those out through the district did you H how were they provided to the schools or what schools I should say yes I mean all of the schools have had Replacements and it's based on need and the state of the displays um before the last go around we actually viewed every display in the district okay and we actually documented it how they looked with the lights off and the lights on and we went found the ones that were in the worst shape so like we we didn't have the you

029know we weren't able to just say oh let me just replace half the ones at this one school we went to the worst ones in every building and and and and decided to take care of those um to to help out where you know where the need was okay I understand the process now to Mr or's point the uh you know I see uh a 900 units at $44 each and then 1,600 units at 44 I I I would wish to believe that there would be some sort of buying power uh in terms of uh you know the amount the amount uh that that we are purchasing there would be a a decrease in numbers and then is there is there one these numbers provided from one um one outfit that provides these or is

030there multiple people I should say that multiple companies that we can purchase these from yes these are these are based on prices that we have you know previously paid and the 404 that you're seeing for the Chromebooks isn't estimated price and we actually paid less than that the last go around um but they you know were you know vendors and resellers were aware of a price increase um so I wanted to make sure these numbers were as accurate as I could make them um and you know especially given with you know shipping issues and things going around you know as far as global trade goes um you know they were worried things were going to get a little more expensive so there was a you know a cushion built into that um safe Baseline I

031got it okay and then the and then uh you mention mentioned six years is that the life expectancy of of these or you can actually rebuild these after six years or is it six years and they're done the thing is with a with with with student use I mean you know just like you put miles on a car um when you get to about five six years it's a lot of miles for a student device yeah yeah and and when they are brand new they come with a three-year warranty that we'll purchase so they're repaired by the manufacturer you know and we'll ship them out after that they're repaired inhouse and we have to purchase the parts um and so then you have the issue of Parts availability which we can't predict um it it's

032all supply and demand um but generally um you know there that that's around the life cycle and you know if we could still get parts and some of these are holding out and you know some of the models are you know military spec or you know and they're holding up very well or kids took care of them you might be able to adjust the year in which they are replaced um and this is only possible now because there is also something called the AE or the auto update expiration from Google where there was a software update Cliff that we basically you know had to contend with for many years where once you reached the point where the AE expiration was reached you couldn't test on them for mandated State assessments um and even if the

033hardware was still useful you you couldn't use them anymore you had to replace them so you know Google since the pandemic has extended those out on new Chromebooks quite a bit so basically at this Point you're not going to be worrying about software expirations you're going to be just worrying about when the hardware is going to fail when you can't get the parts anymore appreciate it this will Mo mostly be the chip right the chip will be replaceable I mean different models have different right different scenarios basically a monitor now yeah there's different there's all types of components and parts you know and the actual you know main boards are sometimes the hardest to get well that's yeah yeah I mean a monitor is a monitor yeah the screens are are readily available it's the

034main sometimes that are are toughest to come by so we we're looking into that also right what's easiest to update I'd be concerned about that well the usage on the Chromebooks just from the kids don't last either like he's saying there you know after five six years I mean you could getting beat up every day yeah being used by kids so versus say our laptops or teacher laptop that we might be able to get a couple more years out of I think five six years for a Chromebook is actually pretty go good it's usually a fiveyear life cycle yeah yeah for a kid usage we get six seven we're squeezing some time out yeah there's Keys missing everything else but kids are we replaced them we did on these on these new ones a which

035I I've just looked at a few of them recently they they're basically strictly monitors that's what they are and they come with the CPU unit that has all your information and your chips and those are interchangeable not not the monitors don't really go monitors could last you 10 12 years well they get cracked a lot yeah well who's cracking them the book bags the kins well they should be h respons well they have they you have the option insurance which I mean you know it's out there for parents I'm just looking it I'm just and then they do have to pay if they did damage completely right but you know the the money that we're collecting for listen it's like 30 bucks if every single kid bought the insurance which they're not that would still

036be like 40 Grand that's going lens parts are we talking laptops talking about the monitors in the school that you're looking for the laptops talking about the monitors in the school that that are being replaced right talking talking about Glen I thought we were I was talking about the Chromebook chomebook chooks talk strictly Chromebooks and I'm talking yeah because they're they're going in backpacks every day yeah well well yeah like are different my laptop sits on my desk my backpack once a month there is a a form that they signed Jimmy as a parent I know you could buy the insurance for $30 I do it you know because God forbid otherwise I think it's like they they show a replacement cost if your kid totally broke it and you know but again that money

037is going towards Parts it's not like we're getting some Revenue stream in for that no I'm talking do the math you can do the math apologize I'm talking about something totally different I'm talking about your your your in classroom your your in classroom your our in classroom monitors sorry well we should try to see if we could get some type of an agreement this year to start spreading that out because I don't foresee them giving us $750,000 but we got to try to come up with a game plan and spre and start spreading it out and chipping it away but I'm sure it could be on a you know the conversation of hey we found grants here and there so each year you know Glenn keeps looking for Grants and there's communication to say hey

038he found grants and he could get I don't know three and then you guys buy this you know we we have to just work together with them and try to have that deeper conversation and try to start spreading that out are there any further um questions regarding the technology plan or shall we move on to maintenance maintenance okay then I guess we're going to maintenance okay thank you Glenn thank you so John um before I put anything on the screen I was going to put the small Capital up first yes please okay all right take it away Mr Calhoun okay well thank you very much um once again I'm submitting my request for the small Capital facilities plan um just want to know um using you know a lot of competitive bidding and and quotes

039uh we were able to to really uh do a lot with the money that we were given this this past year um we also fortunately had money in there um for a couple of them really big emergency repairs as you guys know um so it's been it's been a real a real helpful tool for us in this in the facilities Department to be able to accomplish a lot of things and and take care of some things that you know that were unforeseen so uh going forward um this coming year um we have a couple of larger projects we'd like to look at the first one which is really bigger big bigger one um would be to replace the boiler at central office um it's well over 50 years old and it's the only boiler in

040the building and if that goes down central office unfortunately goes down as well um the other another thing we're looking to do is continue refinishing uh and refurbishing our gym floors last year we did Elizabeth with Shelton and uh this year uh we'd like to do Mohan Elementary um we also need to continue in the process of doing our state mandated uh uniform inspection and evaluation of our school HVAC systems that's a that's a five-year program so we're going to do the next two buildings in that as well and then um one of the things you see down toward in in the lower one we a clock replacement at the high school um we have the old Old Clock system there it's an old Master Clock system well when those are failing and the wires

041we've had a lot of internal wiring and stuff that has failed I think probably due to the fire over you know in the past and a lot of different reasons a lot of clocks have been replaced by um battery powered clocks so as a result of that there's a lot of manual upkeep of that but also with that we don't have a system that that keeps everybody in sync with with each other so certain classrooms may think they're getting out 2 minutes earlier than someone else it can cause a lot of confusion so we're looking at it like a radio a Radio based system that would would sync all the clocks together and again that would be that would be a pretty big upgrade for the high school and help help out with that with

042schedules and everything so and again um other things we want to do is just you know some rooftop unit repairs try to try to keep those going along till we can replace those um we want to do some work at the spa we want to we want to do a repair of that floor as we all know it needs a little bit of TLC um and again some HVAC repairs um plumbing repairs um again uh working on um upgrading some of our custodial equipment so those are that's kind of a a quick um nutshell look at the uh at at the request for this coming year anybody have any questions on any of those items just I don't have that P Ken can you share that that uh can you share that again oh you

043took it down for we discuss I just closed it I can get it back up that's fine yeah no okay well well you gotta wait a minute it's all right he can put it back up all right not everybody printed exactly well I I thought I did I mean it could be in my printer I know there was a bunch of pages and it's not they were all separate so it's you had to go to each one to print yeah John I I uh the yeah I know that we talked before the the boiler replacement over at uh central office that that didn't that fail once before uh we've had some we've had some work done on it but it never actually we never had a full failure thank goodness um right but we have

044had you know we've had some we've had issues with it where we've had to do repairs and everything and it was down down a day or so um but again it's just the the age of it is just and the fact that there is no secondary boiler to count on there that's that's that's the scary part of that that building um is just that there is just a one unit are these uh uniform inspections are these already uh are are these already uh do we have appointments or uh we started this year we we're in we're in the middle the the the company that we contracted with is is uh reviewing documents right now going through plans and and blueprints so we're doing uh we're doing uh Sunnyside this year and um Sunnyside and mohagen

045this year and um so yeah so those are those are you know they got of course have to do some more work they got to come out to the buildings but with the Christmas shutdown we kind of had to push those off a little bit so those are those are ongoing so we're going to continue with the the next two elementary schools um but again the the you know knowing that as we get to the bigger buildings the cost is going to going to be larger as we move forward y makes sense all right John yeah every I mean obviously you you you uh you've done a good job of manipulating uh you know the the needs of different schools and what's important and what's not due to the uh the this the budget we

046get so um yeah everything looks good okay thank you and this is his typical 250 that you submit every year to the city he always sticks around that number which seems to be and that's hard to do with all these buildings we own yeah but the mayor typically funds this you know he funds the the 250 and he trusts John and his thank now John for the gas boiler at central office are you looking to put two in now or a high efficiency because you said there's not a backup right no we would go with it just just one a high efficiency high efficiency boiler I think two would be I mean that would be a pretty pretty large Capital not only that because you don't have the space in the in the boiler room

047for two but it would be it would definitely be a high efficiency boiler for in there um and again uh like I said U it's a it's a fairly small space um it's a smaller building to to to heat so that's why I think we can do it on this format as as opposed to putting it on like a six-year Capital plan yeah okay we can get it accomplished a lot quicker are we doing some of that inhouse with that 133 or is that well my my H fat guys would definitely work with the contractors on that um but again you know we're going to have to we're this what I'm going to be doing this spring is going to be scoping all the the work out um and seeing what what are the best

048what what options are best for that building what what type of system we want to go with so um but again I want to put on everybody's radar and I'd like to you know once we get the approvals on these things uh get it out to bid as early as possible and uh get it done before the uh before the winter next year okay all right yeah anyone else on these items I think we're good so we can move on to the sixe capital budget yep so I'm G to share the sixe capital um plan obviously it is much more detailed and it brings us all the way to 2031 when you um so as John and I had discussed we do have a building and grounds meeting coming up next week I think and

049so we can go into this much more detailed the building and grounds meeting as needed and John can just kind of do a a basic overview of of the six six-year plan right now okay thank you um so yeah as you see um what we've done is we've just kind of we've we've pushed some items into the next year um we've added we've added a few items um you know and again as as you know we need to we need to really put a priority on our our roofs and our windows and our boilers um and then I've also put on there about starting to replace rooftop units on some of the buildings as they're getting close to 25 30 years old um and then um toward the uh toward the end of this I

050I've started to put some numbers in so we could start looking at um at some HVAC units with with air conditioning for the elementaries and that's something I think we should all talk about as we move forward it's something that we really we all know we need to do it but I think we have to start putting that in the putting that in the the in the budget for uh uh to to Really to really make it um a reality so if there's any questions any of that or we can discuss it we'll put it on the agenda for next week and we can go over it in more detail if anybody wants to do that um and again but again a lot of it is a lot of it is items that are um

051that are pushed pushed forward or um are carried over and as we um as we get ready to have buildings uh building committee meetings we're going to start uh ramping some of these items up there so they um we'll be in we'll be in shape to to start those in the next fiscal year I know that we could go over these at buildings and grounds but I think that we should still maybe even highlight the ones that have gotten pushed over again like I mentioned about you know to Glenn say hey these are the items that we're pushing I think we all understand what's happening with the Mohan roof and the building committee didn't meet they didn't have a commit there was there's been a lot of drama going on over there so we we

052know what's happening there but I think that submitting the budget we highlight the ones you know could even be a color an asterisk something that said hey yeah these have gotten these gotten pushed over just you know and if we don't keep if we don't keep up on it with the building committee because they are allocating the money for like the roof and stuff like that but I think we need to show them at the budget session hey these are getting pushed over and you know and and the next thing you know it's going to just get too large so they have to get on top of that building committee so I think we should highlight those during the budget presentation what those items were very good yeah absolutely I'll do that with an asterisk

053I'll put those uh put those on there that those to note that those have been move forward yellow highlighter yeah yeah Weis and know you know I know Jason is on top of it he has been like a crazy man taking pictures yeah he already highlighted it he knew he's been working on it taking pictures sending it talking to Bernie I know Mr edti is you know sees Bernie they're all been talking it's just I think that now they're finally saying they're going to do an emergency meeting they just didn't have a committee as a whole so I think there was some problems there and I think now we're hopefully moving forward I appreciate that and appreciate everybody advocating for that as well yeah Jason's been doing a good job absolutely John thanks for everything

054you you're welcome so if there are no more questions regarding um the the the capital plans uh we can move to the last part of John's budget okay so uh as I mentioned when we started the meeting you know the security technology and um facilities are really funded through Capital plans but there are aspects um that live within our general budget um we are we are recommending no increases in the security line items the technology items line items but we would like to talk about um what we believe is a very modest increase um in some of John's line items and we'd like to explain the reason for that I know uh on Tuesday we talked about keeping any further increases at a minimum and I think this really is um Jackie John and I

055have had discussions about how we can start looking at Cost Savings in other areas of John's budget um to transfer money over for his needs um but it's still by evidence of some of this data that John's going to show um may still ask us to have further so John I'm going to show the graph if you want to speak to it the first one that talks about um budget and cost comparison sure that' be great so I'll share that one right now if you want to speak to it go right ahead okay so the first the first graph you're seeing um is is BU so I took a look I just uh took a a snapshot of 2018 when I was at a a much higher um amount for my custodial Supply account um

056you see that was $175,000 and this year in 2024 when I did for the analysis because I had complete years worth of data was 124 so that was basically a basically a reduction of 29% there um uh you guys were gracious enough to to put another 20,000 in this year but as you can see by my cost I mean we were spending um $ $140,000 and in that year we spent $21,000 so what happens then is is you know again with these Commodities these are things that are that are must haves in the district they you know their trash liners their chemicals for cleaning and sanitizing um their paper products which are of course in essential um in general general cleaning products um so what happens is is I need to when I do this

057I need to take monies from other accounts so as I do that um what it does is it takes money out of Maintenance it takes money out of other Supply accounts so therefore we have we either have to defer maintenance on certain on certain areas because we don't we have to spend that money in the custodial lines and the other thing is is we have to um sometimes we have to just you know reject projects in whole and and not and not do them um so with the the mod like like Ken said the modest increase we asking for 20,000 we're going to use some Savings in the budget to kind of make up the difference but I've also been working with a lot of um vendors and looking at some various purchasing consortiums and

058and other other ways to to bring down that cost that you see for from year to year um again we don't want to go we don't we don't want to use inferior products that are you know that are like for instance a paper towel that is so that has no absorbency whatsoever because you're going to end up using more of the product and you're not really going to save a lot of money so we have to find that happy medium in there um so so we are you know providing the district with products that are that are a certain you know a good quality but yet they're not the highest quality and they're certainly not the worst quality so again in um trying to to look at everything look at chemical systems that would bring

059us to where we need to be um different type of dispensers that are more efficient as far as dispensing out products whether it be soap or paper towels so we don't have waste um so we're looking at a lot of different a lot of different initiatives to uh to try to to try to bring those numbers closer together John want me to show the other graph as well that speaks yeah yeah you can show the next one stop this and I'll get the other one up and as we all know we all we all live this every single day with the the costs in our our own homes um well those costs are also you know affect the the school district as well there go John the comparison's up there so that so you you're

060looking chemicals you know they're they're up 31% uh paper products 48% trash liner 60% uh miscellaneous custodial supplies 40 43% so we've had some pretty hefty U increases so we're trying to again like I said through through different measures trying to bring the numbers that we need to spend and the monies that we have available to spend we're trying to bring those to to where we're at a fairly close uh at a at a fairly close uh perspective at this point um because it's it tends to be a uh kind of an uphill battle um when you get into just you know into the the new year and you're already finding that your custodial budget is next to zero and you know you've got two three four months left to go so then you have

061to start robbing from Peter you know and um and that makes it tough so um again that's I know it's a lot of lot of conversation for a mere um 2% of the overall budget but it's just something that I think we have to look at and and um and I would appreciate it if we could give that some serious consideration hey John are we running these products now through the Amazon account and if so what type of savings are we seeing I know you're showing the increase but I I know that everything's gone up drastically but what type of savings are we seeing using our our account there well we we use vendors like Amazon we use vendors like Granger we're we're seeing savings and in some of these areas um because they are

062they are giving us a discounted rate but there are there are some other ways too in in which we can do it um sometimes Amazon can be really effective and other times uh other times they can't match the price of what some of the vendors are are are doing because of uh because of the the vendors have relationships with the paper with the paper companies and um and there's various programs you can get into uh utilizing their dispensers that they'll install at no cost and um using them much more efficient efficient type of towel or um so yeah there there has been savings on on all aspects um and again we uh we're turning over every like I said every Rock to make sure that that we can um try to so even with even

063with the savings that we're accumulating from our our new accounts that we set up we're still seeing that type of drastic increase in Supply well it's it's just yeah it's just the nature again the nature of the commodity the trash liners are a petroleum based product you know where that's G in paper products you know you see that you see that in your everyday thing chemicals um those have been a some of those have been a smaller increase but um but again it's h we we use currently use a dilution system which so we're not paying uh we're not paying a company to provide us with a bottle of chemicals with 90% water we're buying a concentrate and putting our water in it and um you know so we're we're we're we're actually on the

064on the dollar we're paying Pennies on the dollar for for some of our chemicals but again we got a lot of schools and we use a lot of disinfectant we use a lot of uh peroxides and floor cleaners and window cleaners um so it's you know there's a lot of building to be maintained so again we and we're not we're not by any means tied into any one particular type of system we're looking at um anything we can that um that will that will produce the savings to the district so if I may add to that I mean there's there's two major aspects that are allowing us to keep the rising costs at a minimum John just spoke to Amazon which you know we're we're highly encouraging and looking into so that we can kind

065of find the the the least um costly product the second thing is that we did this year was the initiative to um get rid of um the the storage containers the rental fees on the storage containers right um we we eliminated all of those other than the storage containers that we had purchased and we own the rentals are gone so that was a rising increase and that was a big initiative that that you know Jackie had identified that rental cost rising and then John worked on making sure they're you know moving out all those equipment and we're happy to say that they're all gone at this point so the money that we did towards those rentals we can then offset towards equipment cost as well good John would you refresh my memory because I know

066there was all this with covid and all that I I thought that at one point why do I feel like thought we took out all the paper dispensers and went hand dryers we we well we did in the general public bathrooms the ones that you would find in the in the hall hallways but um you would not believe the amount of paper towel dispens that we have in the elementary schools because many of the classrooms have a sink in the classroom oh yeah a lot of the a lot of like the K and prek those bathroom they have bathrooms in their classrooms so and the science rooms art rooms all the they all use them and you can't you obviously can't have a hand dryer in those in any of those spaces so there's still

067a very large majority of nur's offices they can't have hair dryers why though why can't well again because the spreading of you know you want to if someone's sick and they're doing that you don't so they have obviously they so the hand dryers are considered spreading the whatever germs they yeah they blow around you know they they do blow around whatever happens to be in the atmosphere so um certainly a nurse's office wouldn't want to have anything like that right that's fine for the nurse's office I didn't know if it was we had to stop using them completely during Co didn't we we did we had to shut them we had to shut them off during Co and we had to reinstall you know individual towel stations in the in the restrooms but again we

068did save hundreds of cases of of of towels um but again um you'd be really would be surprised how many towels we're still using in in classrooms and and stuff like that it's it's really a very large amount how much are those hand dryers I just didn't know I just didn't know if there was any other areas that was like Hey if I put in five more I get don't I I I don't know if there's any more areas that would be effective to invest in some of no not at this point we've looked at all that only because I'm sure you did I'm just you know they're they're probably $5 $1,600 a piece so I mean they're good in in they're really good in area in large volume areas they're they're really good and

069and of course it cuts down on vandalism too because the kids are not vandalizing the towel to spend ensors um so they've been pretty rugged as far as that goes um so um again we've used them to the best of what we can and so right now but there is there are new dispensers that are coming out every day um that are more efficient and that the students won't you know a lot of the older dispensers you know they just keep pulling and pulling grabbing more and the newer dispensers you know they tear off at one sheet and um yeah they're they're they're much better at um at product control you have to wave your hand it comes down yeah well you can you can do battery or you can do man manual ones yeah

070um obviously the manual ones are are are less expensive and uh less expensive to maintain but they they work just as well and they again they they they really are are like I said the technology has really changed a lot on a lot of these items because um the paper companies know that you know that their their products are a higher commodity and people people need to save money on them okay okay thank you y anyone else have any questions for John while we have them I mean we could still talk to them next week we could talk to them anytime well I do have one more and I oh there one more there's one more yeah so um just I I'm going to end the night with the updated Financial walk that reflects the

071$20,000 that we're talking about but what we did not include on the financial walk that I'm asking John to speak to which I would really like not necessarily this input not the input this evening but before we submit our final budget is an outstanding issue that John has had contention to do and whether we need to budget for so John if you go ahead and talk about the vehicle okay so you probably all sick of hearing me talk about me needing a new vehicle um but I I have I have to I have to keep uh I have to keep plugging along here um when I started here in 2015 um maintenance Fleet consisted of 12 Vehicles there was a vehicle for the facilities director there was there was bunch of vehicles they had some

072vehicles that were only used for plowing on the property they weren't roadworthy there were there was a lot of junk they put a lot of money into this stuff and I eliminated quite a few of the vehicles that were NE that that were not necessary um and in doing so um we got down to about 10 vehicles that that were we use currently for all the Tradesmen we use for plowing we use for uh salting salting the sidewalks um moving furniture whatever um so right now as of today we have eight vehicles that are that are actually in service we have two of them that are out of service right now um and and one of those is the one that we use to put our sander on um so as a result of that

073um we used to we used to plow in in salt and sand um Sunnyside and central office as a result of not having the vehicle with the with losing the plows the ability to put them on a put a plow on these vehicles and this and the sander um that that falls on the that falls on the City so that gives them more work to do which is tougher for them because they already have they already have quite a bit to do um and another thing that we use our sander for which is um is like when we have freezing and refreezing of um of our um you know in our parking lots in our play in our play in our black top playgrounds um what we would do is if we had iced when

074we came in in the morning at 6:00 a.m. we'd run the we'd run the sander out there and throw some salt down and and it would be melted before people got in so now again we we're at the mercy of if the city folks can get out there to hit it with some salt and I'm talking I'm not talking like spot salting or something that we would do with a hand standard but I'm talking larger areas and again that you know you worry about a liability of people slipping and falling or or having something happen to their cars so again it's um we have you know we have the means to do it we have the people to do it we just we need the uh we we need the vehicle um I've put that

075on my my small Capital list you know for many many years running now and it hasn't made the cut um so one of the things that I asked Ken if we could consider was to run it through our our Board of Ed budget um and that's something you know obviously you all can discuss but um the need is the need is great um and again um that that's in your hands to see what how you how you would want to handle that what's the dollar amount um well there's there's two different ways we could there's two different ways we could go about it we could buy new which I mean trucks are very expensive and and you know new trucks are very expensive and and and I and I certainly wouldn't advocate for a for

076a new vehicle if I could get a used vehicle that would be you know um that I could get you know 5 10 years out of um because um again does anybody want to spend $85,000 for a pickup truck or you know um when we can get something maybe four or five years old and spend half of that money so um and Jackie has sent me information about various auction sites um so you know we we'd look at some various um ways to to do that without having to spend money on a brand new vehicle you know John I think I since I've been on the board for six years you've been asking for this vehicle I told you I'm kind of I kind of myself 250 it was but that it I was told

077that that was not happening this year okay but wait so let's back up for a second I feel like I agree with Patty it's been in that 250 every year but then the city gives us 250 so they don't no they don't they they have to they allocate money as John appropriates based on the list so they say we would like to give you that 250 but then John goes in and then next thing you know they give it to us for everything else but not the truck right that way is that's what's been happening and there's been other circumstances where and and John has mentioned it before like this past year if an emergency situation takes place like it had this year where we have a break and things like that now we're going

078to spend money towards the break off of the money that was allocated with the 250 well then there goes the truck you know like things are going to based on circumstances I mean that that's yeah does the Board of Ed have the ability to finance a new truck and spread the payment throughout you know five years but five years of the budget are you on the finance committee no I think that that road has been that road has been going down before it did it did not it did not end very well okay but what is it usually on why do I feel like it's only been like 25 Grand sorry Jason I mean to inter how much is the dollar um I I would say I would say if we put in $35,000 for

079that we could we could find something that would be adequate I mean Jason Jason knows obviously the value of used vehicles he he he deals in these kind of things um um I I think we you know we would be satisfied with something like that like again I'm not asking for I'm not asking for a brand new off the showroom model um but something that's serviceable for us to be able to take care of our our needs in the district yeah I agree John anything anything lower than that it's going to be nothing but a headache in in in a money pit um I'll tell you John that City's done really well with uh going down to these auction sites and picking up some trucks as of late Jackie Jackie has just provided you know

080John and I with the websites for those auction sites as I don't know if I want to still put it in the regular budget like I think I don't know Jimmy I think we should add this to the list of conversations that well this is a capital I know it really is a capital that you know that I don't know in the city and the city has ACC access to it so I I think we'll have to have a conversation we have like a list of things that we've been talking about that we have to go sit down with the mayor before we this and say mayor we're gonna we've been submitting this for years but we do still have a list of 250 John is there anything on this 250,000 list that you could

081get rid of and we allocate more for the truck for and put these items for something else for the following year a priority would you rather have it this year and do the clock system the following year I I'm looking at the numbers you know what I mean like maybe you want to relook at that and then we could go offline and Advocate to say mayor really need to get this truck I mean if that if that's something that you think would be successful um but again um yeah I would I would absolutely put that a priority over over some of the lower items on that list um but again um sometimes what happens is is you know it doesn't it doesn't happen and then then the other items don't happen either right let's let's

082I I I think we're gonna we'll have that conversation with John I'm going to need some specifics of exactly what type of truck you're looking for um so that you know I could pitch that idea so well I actually did at the beginning of this summer well I need I need for you to get that me no I know but I I actually we went out to we went out to bid for a used a used vehicle at the beginning of the summer um just to see what was out there and we didn't have any that just get me that I can give you I can give you those specs yeah exactly what the what is it that you desire and what's the minimum requirement y I'll need to know the minimum requirement also I

083have I have all that stuff all written up okay I would appreciate yeah and then I think that that's the conversation that we have before we submit this budget to be like well you know yes this this this is a fluid spreadsheet that you have for your 250 it is we don't want like you're saying that you include the truck they don't give it but then now we could have maybe done the other items so maybe by having like what is there what what is it that they don't want to buy the truck I think that's the conversation that we have to have so we know get that answer from them have that conversation and then report that back to the board to know really where to put that that line item of the truck

084I don't want it bounced off either and then we missed out on the other things so I think we have to have we make this a list for Mr oretti and I to have that conversation to see what is I need to know exactly you know if you can spell it out we know for sure uh when we're speaking about this exactly what you're going to be using it for and why without a doubt absolutely okay so it makes it easier for me when I'm having a conversation so that and then what it will do to actually relieve the city responsibility and they're duties correct because actually as you as you mentioned before it's putting putting work onto them also because they they're having to pick it up it is because somebody has to do

085it and somebody has to do it and they're not you know they they have a they have a they have a very big job that they have to do themselves and and this we're g be having a conversation very shortly so you get me that I would appreciate it are the other items out of the 250 that we usually submit besides the truck have they been getting done yeah um the other items have um again we um we had to again we rep prioritized a couple of things when we had those major uh those major water main brakes those were those were run through there um but again we got the gym floor done uh we we had uh quite a bit of the quite a bit of the other items uh were taken care

086of okay um the elevator the you know the elevator upgrade and uh and necessary services that were done those those have all been those have all been taken care of so um again they I mean I I have I I have no complaints it's been really it's been really great to uh to have this list to be able to work on this because it it certainly does it certainly does help us to um to move forward without that being in our operating budget okay we'll get you that truck John yeah we I know I know where there's one parked up on Fran way hasn't moved in a while Madam oh no I don't at Jason's house maybe at Jason's job but oh we could look there too my has hand raised we know how ridiculously

087expensive those trucks are oh yeah they are expensive yeah and the plows and and the Sanders and everything else well yeah I'd rather have that conversation before we you know to say if we put the truck back on and take off two of those other items that they're gonna not give us a hard time about it or then leave those two on and find an alternative way before we make the board makes that decision maybe we should get a little feedback first great right that's what I'm thinking okay Madame chairman yes um John and uh Ken as well as for the chair uh our dealership although we do fire apparatus and other things we have access to those uh auction sites and have bidding numbers on it and we kind of would be happy to

088help any way we can if you do want to try to find a vehicle um we can help facilitate that and help the district out in that area that that would be wonderful thank you John did that have a plow in a sander because you were saying Sanders we we are we have those already so you put that on the truck yes okay yep we wouldn't need the we wouldn't need the other items you may have to retrofit the the plow the plow kit but the sander the sander would uh again would be could be used on as long as it's the right you know the right weight of the truck so not a 150 H the request for the requirements correct correct okay anything else anyone Mr Mr SAR are you putting back up

089the financial walk now I am something I am so you know to the end of what what we just talked as we and and this particular um Workshop everything that was presented would be presented and put in the budget book as capital projects um to the point that we just had we wanted a discussion with the board we left out the truck off the capital project as well as the walk the only thing that we have included on the walk as I'll share it with you right now is um a $20,000 increase um under building and equipment supplies uh as you can see so when you see the new walk you know this second column is the is the increases um these first three line items is what we discussed on Tuesday the only addition

090is the 20,000 here um which raises our our total from Tuesday um by 3/10 of a percent and that's where we are tonight okay so that's all we have to present for tonight so I'll leave it to you madam chair okay well I think if does anyone have any final questions on the presentation this evening okay well we could send any further questions to Mr serenic that you might have and he will get those answers for you there'll be a buildings and grounds meeting next week and like they said they'll they'll be continuing that conversation and um I think that we should just do a little due diligence on the truck like we've been talking to see what the right spot where sh where we should put that request to make sure it doesn't backfire

091on us and that would be all for my comments so if everybody if nobody else has anything else they have a plow attachment kit for a Land Rover oh Jimmy no it's r i mean Jason has one too use his round up a couple of Land Rovers John for you okay that'll work and a nice Jeep Cherokee BR like spanking wait wait yeah Lena don't do that that'll work well thank you no that was not gonna work John patty patty you're not too you have Expedition you got a big board truck yeah I'm always thinking come on yeah you can do it to my little CRV there you go oh okay you could do the sidewalks we get one for that all right well with that said we um can I get a motion to

092adjourn motion to adjourn go not the name second by Mrs Littlefield all in favor I everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.