001e e e e let make sure my mic is not on for that all right so uh next item is on our agenda is the zp approval and I'll turn it over to the superintendent school to go over sip request Alicia I think we just had two changes in the Sip request right we um eliminated the repairs to the second floor here and um we adjusted Steve's what was the line on the uh the transportation or no what was it oh it was the um the Portables two different figures so it's the higher figure that's been adjusted since last last time we met and if you you have any questions um Chris and Steve can answer them from the technology end as well as the maintenance and custodial end question discuss so the portable is
002a big expenditure um is there anything this year that we can move to make room for that amount of money I don't know if I can actually answer that one if it comes to money moving students I don't know um the I think that's more you sh than me I just want to make sure I'm understanding the question it's it's around 500,000 you're asking if we have that in our budget this year no I'm saying so that's a big expenditure um are all these other things musts if if that's if that's GNA that's what I'm saying okay can we I'm saying is there a more prudent way we can do it so we're not asking for that much of an increase so can we reduce other sip items from next year exactly got it less
003that that that makes so in in um in an update is um we have had you have seen the thermal image report on the roof for the Stonington High School and it actually isn't um I mean it's not great but it's not horrible either so there is an expected at least three years life on that road 2 3 years this year I did put in for a million towards that roof I mean obviously that could be delayed to another year but it would mean an increase in the following year it's just dividing across two more years you know and that would lower this year's request on the SI defy um the football field I did have that reviewed I had rad that was actually the installer of the football field 11 years ago um they
004did walk the field and reviewed the track and field and felt it was in good condition our taxs have been positive a good word our tests have been good um and uh we feel that um the field itself has a few more years before we replace it I mean a M's given another three years of life before we seriously have to pull it out and replace the the turf you know so there is movement but it it's within few years thank you does that make sense and even if we do that we would still want to have all of those things out there this year for that decision to be made ultimately so that we're being transparent about what's coming next yep makes sense thank you I guess it would be helpful to know too
005for those that toured the Middle School the other day kind of what how that went and what you saw and and you know uh it was pretty tight yeah it was it was TI yeah I know the library is was just going to I was just going to say is a closet y yes yes they're do I can say they're doing a great job with the space they got you know with the resources they have right but knowing there's 30 more bodies coming in next year essentially y we do have the updated enrollment it's not quite 30 but we do have the updated enrollment for uh figures for you I'll walk you through all these documents in B perfect thank you just good to know yeah and I think if you're looking for perspective because
006I was with Chris on on that Journey thank you for hosting us um but I regardless of the increase I think the space in that building is problematic so even if there was no increase even if we're maintaining the student status quo I I I don't think it's ideal space for the students uh or for the staff it's it's really challenging for everybody uh that library that we describe as a Nook it's l Closet in with a very small desk for the person to sit there and try to provide uh help and support for those kids so I think you know I left there and I spent a couple of days thinking about it it's I you know I I recognize that the Portables could solve an issue but I don't know if that really
007solves the issue the issue is that that building is too small for the entirety of the Town um this building has its own challenges I I recognize that the safety is priority number one um but even if you do do we bring the Portables and do these Portables the Portables are a Band-Aid they're not the answer they're not really the answer there has to be a solution and I recognize that we need a Runway to figure out what's wrong with the school but the broader answer to the people from my perspective as a person who toured that school on on your behalf I guess is that what we are providing today is not meeting the needs of the staff and the students so we need to look or discuss maybe a a you know a
008solution and I recognize that solution will take time in the portable is just a patch so anybody listening anybody watching you making decision you need to recognize or know that at least that the portable is just a Band-Aid to get you to the final answer or solution that we need to provide the the staff the space to be able to offer the services they offer to the kids education and for the students to have that space and environment for uh learning is not really the best the best space for the number of students that we have and just as a reminder when Mr Smith was lucky enough to be the principal of two middle schools um he was asked at the board meeting will the will the student body fit in this building at 204
009and the answer was yes um and that there was a reason why paket site was not selected and were lucky we have that facility we had an emergency situation but it certainly isn't designed for that student population and the the need the learning needs are different now right we want them to have stem spaces we want them to have um other kinds of learning spaces that are have been taken away and repurposed um in that PO at the pock site just to make the numbers work what do you think about some sort of a addition going forward to that site uh that becomes a personal opinion not a board opinion but uh you know it's like I I love I it's really it's hard to answer because there's a process to this right so there
010has to be a committee and it can't be our decision as a board so recognizing those comment you you know recognizing that that's not our role um me personally I I I love the character of the building I love that the location of the building I have emotional attachment to the building that could be potentially a good site for an expansion yes I I would say yes but will that like if we look fast forward 20 uh well not 20 how about you need what 20 years your kid will be graduating high school um but if you fast forward 20 years will that site provide what we want from that uh that you know will that will that site provide the students what they need in 20 years and in education I'm not the expert
011in that I can answer boiler questions structure questions building questions from structure angle from probably cost angle probably that's a great cite for expansion I don't know the answer to the uh academic me so we'll have to wait the pro or the community will have to weigh the pros and cons between the the money spent and the best use for the children 100% so that's why uh I think I don't know if it's a statute that you have to have a committee to to look at that evaluate it uh but there has to be a further conversation or larger conversation in the community about what is what's what's the vision of the graduate in 20 years and what do they need and will that site offer that at what cost of an expansion for me
012I love the site I love the building has ton of character it can you know we did a great job with West F and and and the Expansion Project so yes can be done but like what's the vision of the graduate in 20 years and it's it's going to be on your on part of it is on your shoulders to make that EAS I want to make sure that I'm interpreting spreadsheet correctly um so for this fiscal year we adopted a sip of $2,690 th000 351 and the proposed sip for next year is 2, 330,000 and like three no am I not reading this right it it's it's not right we we corrected the the error in the there was an error did you see the two white outs yes yeah so that was actually
013750 and 890,000 okay um they were a transposition from the um the roof replacement was transposed to that them two boxes as well so we deleted we covered them but we removed it from the end total but we did not remove it from the next year's total or the total for the following year so the the total I'm sorry the total this year corre this year's correct but next year would be 1,997 5, or 97428 in the uh following year would be minus8 9,934 sorry for the confusion but the numbers were transposed we corrected the total at the end but we didn't correct year next few years um so correct me help me clarify here um is the Sip this year lower the proposed sip this year lower than what we adopted for last year
014yeah okay okay so I I am I am looking at that last year's number is correct this year's number is correct 26 27 and 27 28 those two there was a and that's where that white out adjustment was there was two additional numbers in there those totals aren't correct but the grand total at the end has been adjusted excellent okay so this year's sip is lower than what was adopted last year including the portable classroom expenditure excellent the um Can can I just say something about the the the the Portables So based on based on the numbers that were proposed for the portable in the mount isied in this it it wasn't easy to do there is no specified location there was no drawing saying this is what we're doing and what we were putting
015in I done my very best to get that as close as possible I did get contractor pricing for 100 ft underground pipe in I did I did based on prevailing wage but I feel like like I said in that in that um there is a page now that has a breakdown on the costs that were associated with adding the um the port to the sco there is the the Wild Card of the covered or enclosed walkway so the the company who lease the portes also lease enclosed they also leas covered walkways but if it becomes considered I don't know if that would be considered a security issue or not but if we go to an enclosed walkway the actual cost of an enclosed walkway is around $250 a square foot being 6 ft wide we're
016talking $1,500 a foot to make that walkway work to the the Portables and is a true wild card in that in that cost estimate right now the the valid the speaking with um I have contacted Colliers and they have given me an estimate of $41,500 and that would rate all the bid specs put the documents together for us to go out to bid for an architect and all contractors on the project um his estimate for an architect to actually do the drawings is actually it's I thought was well it's around $70,000 which seems really high but I mean that's what you told me the active number is for two portables so we're talking about roughly $11,000 that would be needed we would need a commitment for prior to the budget year it first he was
017in the 32 35,000 range but now after the conversation today is in the um you see up to 70,000 for an architect and I'm not sure where that number come from it seems pretty high but I just I'm only going B what people tell me at this point so for me he actually accomplish for us to accomplish and have Portables at 42 Street for the opening in September it would almost require a commitment from the town at this point of 111,000 to do draws to to specs and I've provided a timeline of construction in there as well so even at the point of June 13th when the kids leave the building the project would have to start at that point contractors are going to want POS in to start their project their budget cycle is
018July 1st I'm not sure how that would work with it would be need a we need a commitment from the town two weeks prior to the start of the budget year so I'm not sure how that would go through and I will go to the board of Finance meeting if it is approved here to to see what we can do and make this happen Okay and then are you intending to carry the lease for the Portables in your operating budget for the two years post that in that quote 510,000 there I did quote that in the year lease so that that was it's the lease is approximately 60,000 a year but that included a covered walkway so the building the building cost or the structure cost is $224,000 a year per building and that would
019be two classrooms per building so I did include that release cost in the S um at this point got so there is no other cost that will creep up into the not that we're aware of at this time I will say it may be more prudent to put the lease in the board's operating budget the second and third year but at this juncture we just want all of all of it in one place so that people aren't having to look in different budgets different lines it's all right there two and uh so that in total is four classrooms addition correct that it the the structures are 24x 60 and and the ones that I i' had spoken there is a company that has some structures available right now in the structures seemly stand about a
02024x 60 and and that is either A2 standard classrooms or 45 offices however it's set up in that structure so Steve what made me think it was 80 grand that we needed from the town Town um to be acquired yeah that's that's what I was under that's why I was correcting it right now excuse me the the the coler's quote was 41,500 and there was a a document that I did receive that showed that a bid went out for um uh Portables and it was a two portable project the only difference was the Portables that in question had a facade put on them they were a higher grade portable a brick facad because they were going to be in place for 9 years so um in that Court there was uh three or four options
021or three or four quotes and two or three were 50,000 and this quote was 2 years old and one of the quotes were 32,500 assuming that I would take the lowest but according to um the person who provided the quotes the architect firm did not perform well in the contract and probably wouldn't use again so which would P push pushes out to 50,000 and then he he put a cost escalation into that price and he said to be on the safe side you should be in 110,000 range for request so that's where the number went from 80,000 to 110 got it okay thank you how much of that would be do Steve um before July 1st 2025 so the the the commitment from the town for for me to or for the project to move
022forward would actually require us to hire Colliers to write the bids back and also the architect to do the drawings the we have to submit to the town planning and zoning and for permits and that would all have to be done prior to construction so that that commitment we were asking for is 110,000 prior to um the budget year Steve what's the bathroom situation in the Portables let's that's a really good question so it is a good is a good question if you see in the the quote I did have an optional ,000 in there for water and storage assuming that the power comes from the building there will be a trench dog so that would be a cost of piping to the building for water in sees I mean the S line height works
023at that point um as we know the location in the building the the Portables um the if it's within a decent range there's bathrooms I think we talked about it there's bathrooms right inside the hallway door so that doesn't seem like a major point to have it um inside the Portable Buildings but they do come with it that's why the option is there so it it it that would be a as we move ahead option and we could review that based on location does that make sense okay um this isn't directly related to the portable so I don't know if anybody else had questions on that um but it sort of is is all the expenditures that we've had to date due to the Middle School situations have we gone back to the board of
024Finance for do we have a number of how much more we've spent because of the move and everything and what are we going back to them before at all to recoup any of our there is so most of it we were able to pay out of last year's General Board of Ed budget last year being this year no last year being 23 24 all right um and sip transfers so most of it is completely covered there is I don't know exactly what it is off the top of my head but there is um an amount that was wasn't covered by either of those but I think we are going to be able to cover in this year's budget um with saves in electricity and heating oil if Allison here doesn't take all of that money
025do we have a guesstimate estimate on how much we're talking about for the fiscal year that we're currently in that around 100,000 and outside of this one item in the CIP and maybe there's a couple other in there that are direct uh effect of uh the Middle School movement the portable classrooms and I don't know if there was is there anything else I saw the park lot p uh the 40,000 then for the move of Gabby's program to from 4 Field Street to 204 that 40,000 is to provide a kitchen in the garden level and also any modifications to um the room in um party Field Street if it needs any modifications to um become a a useful space for the student in middle school for anyone who doesn't know who Gabby is it's the
026um chance yeah yeah transition program thank you so those are the only two items in the Portables in her moving over classroom correct um the money that we have allotted for uh the parking lot repavement of SMS is that I assume this parking lot that's actually been transferred to a different line on the town side at this point that's one of the transfers that the Sip transfers that was made to cover the expenses to move buildings so that would come into play if we uh end up moving back here I guess that would be part of the whole yes parking lot work would need to be done if students return to this building now I know we're going to the board of Finance for these CIP items but even like what Sarah said earlier our
027request is 300,000 less than what we asked last year and if we didn't have the additional 550,000 between Gabby's classroom and the portable classrooms it'd be even you know less than that it' be you know 1.8 million as opposed to 2.3 and this current year was 2.7 um obviously the board of finance will be told that but that doesn't come under special consideration or anything like you know because of extraordinary yeah extraordinary C circumstances or emergency situation or anything no just yeah exactly we're competing with all the other interests in town with fridge repair and sewers and everything else sewers sewers I know how they like to uh you know break out their uh red pen or their white out and and uh you know remove items from our budget um sometimes they do it
028as a line item veto which is uh wrong of them not not in the Sip they have they have the power to line item veto in the Sip they don't have that power they do in the Sip they do oh in the Sip they do not in the general not General buet yes so if they review our budget and say you're 550,000 too much they can line item veto some of our sips we you know we we obviously will need that 550 in order to have a unfortunately the Sip uh functions slightly different than operating so they will line item veto line item let's say Portables God forbid line item veto line item Portables you cannot move money from something else to Portables it's Portables that goes away so they have that power to line
029item veto line item and unip they can eliminate a specific item you cannot as a board of ed move item money around for it they could though say the 500,000 that we have in our budget for the high school re roof repair they could correct make that a dollar and correct because actually that's a reserve we're asking to be held so they don't they don't necessarily it's prudent and advisable to be held but it can be moved to Future years so they can take that 500 make it the year after or the year after uh it's not to do a replacement next year but they can make that decision uh but just to be clear we cannot change something back if they if the board of Finance just so they could move things to $1
030or Zer and and uh usually make it $1 that way it's still there correct um but we can't add to that like if they made the Portables $1 then we just say well we want to make take it from the roofs and put it into the no you can't do that no um you can ask after that doesn't mean they have to agree with you uh but that they have a true line item control on your s requests are there any other items in the uh current fiscal year budget such as the parking lot um money that was reallocated can you repeat your question well you said the the SMS parking lot repaving of uh 60,000 was one of those items we moved to cover the expenses of the middle school are there any other
031money set aside in ourr current budget that was moved to um cover existing movement costs or what have yes there were several sip I I just would have to look at a different spreadsheet tell I can wait I mean we can I don't need it toight but yeah there were there were several sip line item transfers all of which were so say it wasn't technology something that we knew we were then going to have to go back and replenish they were all things that were sated for this building anyway um the parking lot repavement um that typee of thing so um yes we have moved several lines can you get us and we can request that of the board of Finance but for so say for the 2526 sip they wouldn't do a line item
032transfer until January so January is the soonest that we could request that in that current fisal year can you get us that list of those things yep AB obviously not tonight thank you I think that's all I have can I speak to the fuel tank um because it did have an option in the just to explain that so in the the fuel tank replacement for um uh now district office the the tank is end of Live come year 200 uh 20 2728 um that money would need to be allocated in that year however there is a state waiver that is available which extends the life of the tank for 10 years because it's a healing Heat and Fuel tank um the only thing being it's not a guaranteed you got it um so basically we
033have to do a site survey and make sure there is no Wells within 1,000 ft at the Tank's location there is a back property that does have well is right on that line um it would actually need to do a a a review of the area actually measure the wells um and also the current tank that we have it it's required in that life expecting that life extension it's called a sump and it's where all the piping um connections are made under in a in a a well on top of the tank that shmp has to be sealed completely can't have any drainage holes in it so that at that point we don't have a sealed sum on that tank so the cost actually um remove and put in a sealed sump sump is around
03450,000 so that's why I left it as an option if the town feels that they should take the chance and and and pay for a survey a site survey and see how many walls are around knowing they would incur a cost of 50,000 to extend the 10 years on the tank which does seem like a good deal of it is feasible um but the the right now we have the years left on the tank if we do it this year we lose the two years we have life left on the tank the 10 years start from the day that you apply for that 10e extension so just an update on there yes sir yes sir yeah it total cost is 360,000 So the plan is to remove the underground tank and the new tank would
035be an above ground tank a convolt tank the the underground tanks are are slowly being fizzed out in all towns just because of the the maintenance of the underground tanks and the the life expectancy of underground tanks um it's just a a growing Trend to put tanks on or above ground and it's different from the high school t tank and that the high school tank is way smaller or no the the high scho the high school tank is bigger and it's only a removal so the high school tank was uh the high school at some point actually as of last year was a g fuel system where it would run on oil or um natural gas the boilers that were it was already in place when I came the boilers that were speed are all
036100% natural gas boilers which would eliminate the need for oil tank on that property there is still 7 years left on the life of that tank there go extend the cost out on that for removal I did check on the the maintenance costs we still have to maintain that tank over the life of what we have under theg ground it's about $500 a year for doing testing on the tank but I feel like there's no rush to pull that out of the ground right now but it does have to come out and that's the cost for the removal only filling back in doing the soil testing and Paving over the the the extraction area so um if you can understand my confusion you had fuel tank removal district office was 360,000 yes then you had
037fuel tank removal for the high school at 6,000 300,000 right correct but the district office is act replacement yeah removal replacement sorry about that yes you're 100% correct I usually confused thank you while you guys talked about that I looked up the overview that I gave the Board of Ed on September 12th of this year and there was a transfer from the SMS sip parking lot repaving of 131,000 500 and an additional sip transfer from SMS flooring for 20,000 and those are the only zp transfers that have been made to cover expenses for the move so we still have that 30,000 in the parking lot repaving an smns for this year then St is saying no why not I I I guess it's a good question is a good question I I I I wasn't
038sure with I I guess I held off just because I'm not sure what's going on with this building in general um actually we contemplated a couple of things for this building but due to the you know until we understand what's actually going on with the building and the schools R in the building I think um maybe that's why I didn't put it in I'm not sure it's a good question but so it's potential let's call it that yes sir Chris I just have a question about uh the Top Line you got here it's it's two4 it was 246 last year 250 this year and then it goes down 25,000 every year after that what's uh what's that savings yeah so actually this year over uh last year's projected uh for this year for sip um
039we've come down almost $100,000 across the board on all six of these accounts um from the computer infrastructure side uh just with technology um we're getting uh more efficient and being able to pack more in less space um so they're actually while costs are rising uh we're getting more efficient with the use of our servers um we're starting to consolidate some of these workstations because we've now gone one to one with Chromebooks um so we're seeing repair costs go down uh as well because we have the Chromebook insurance program now um that offers families that option uh so we've done a lot of different things to help become as efficient and effective as possible from the the tech side of house so what you'll see is that 10e out projection each year I update the
040next nine years out and adjust accordingly um so as we see some you know bumps in certain areas uh whether it's supply chain shortages I'll go ahead and map that out obviously we can't predict the future 10 years out so uh what I do is level fund everything and we kind of just keep those uh accounts active it's great thanks yep sorry and back to the adopted fiscal year 2024 2025 that 20,00 000 in the library SMS I assume that's this building since we don't have Library um I'm looking at line one well line number 158 um sorry apologize 157 floor flooring repair library at SMS the transfer she spoke to is the 39750 but then there's an adopted 20 in this year so that's that's this building so this ZIP spreadsheet doesn't show you
041transfers that have happened we can certainly add that to it so that you can see the current balances but you didn't request the transfer this month yet no so this would be the 20,000 would be actually this month request because it's this year it's 2024 2025 adopted so you wouldn't be able to transfer before this month right and we haven't asked to transfer we transferred a portion of it so that there was um money in that specific project from a prior year and that's what the transfer requested I guess from me looking at it from here to to your question there's about and I'm not holding anybody on the money here but there's about $50,000 that you can transfer I don't know who asked the question at the end but you have about $50,000 in
0422024 202 that was allocated to this building and this is an opportunity for me to address a question from the public that came via email we did not spend there was a question about the parking lot and have we researched other options to repave we did not repave the parking lot the money was used to move the schools around so to to your point there's about $50,000 that can be allocated towards something different this year which is could be as of right now you're saying my perspective not what Alicia agrees to I just remember there being one line and I think it was flooring repair that um I thought we had the full amount and jib Sullivan corrected me and said Peter had actually spent some of that money um so like I said I
043will I'll ask Maria to add transfers to this so you can see the actual balances and we can get a better idea it's hard because I'm trying to gauge the room see if there are any other questions you're good good right so I'm looking for a motion to accept the Sip budget as presented for the FIS year 2025 2026 at [Music] 23305 so 2, 33,3 second there's second any further discussion yes um can we uh be refreshed on what the process is now for the Sip that of course it now goes to the board of Finance correct the same night the general and budget goes they'll go through this they can zero out things they can make $1 things they can um yes uh the process like you know again you know it's just different
044and I think they go through sip before they go through operating correct me from they do they'll do both for the board of add in the same night though we have one we have our own night I believe correct our own special night but uh the the they will do them independent of each other and decisions made independent of each other uh and the the process for the Sip is they will go through line item by line item the team will be there to answer any questions uh they'll look at the quotes and they will have the the authority and the power by eliminating line items in totality or keeping them at a dollar we don't have any Authority or power to change that after that the operating budget the discussion depending on um how
045it flows But ultimately at the end of the night they will uh be able to talk about a total number and that's then what what comes back to you what comes back to you to make decisions on later is the operating budget where you can shift things around and move things around to uh meet that specific number when do we send them our sip budget after tonight after we approve it or typically I mean we don't have a reason to hold on to it we send it to them let them review it let them take a look at it and typically they sometimes come back with questions and we get them answers and just to get them familiarized with it specifically now that there are the portable classrooms as a an item that there will
046have that that will have a lot of questions from the board of Finance I believe I promised Jim Sullivan that I would email it to him first thing tomorrow morning he then updates his books based on what the Board of Ed approves and Dan just so you know what we I think we have a meeting on the books right after the uh the next meeting when we come back with the superintendent's recommendation with the liais on from the board of Finance so that we can explain our rationale before it goes to the full and that meeting their layers on yourself our chair Alicia or anybody else or just the two of you just yeah well do we have a we have a lays on to the board of Finance that's what I thought but okay
047there's a motion there's a second on the floor any further discussion all those in favor please indicate by saying I I I that was unanimous for the record thank you uh next item on our agenda is budget discussion and I'll turn it over Mr chairman yes sir I would um like to entertain a motion to suspend the agenda and move line item uh five up a notch um I'm not sure how long our budget discussion will last but I think there are citizens in the uh audience that would uh like to speak on whatever items they want to speak on and I think there's a motion on the floor to move item number five and replace it with uh as number four and move number four down to number five is there a second second
048there discussion on the motion all those in agreement please indicate by saying I I I anybody against n uh so that was 6 to one vote motion passes um uh so next item on our agenda is item number four comments from citizens regarding items on the agenda I ask citizens to please State um your name and address uh when you go up to speak and uh please keep the comments to item on the agenda each item is allowed 20 minutes of comments and 3 minutes per individual person we only allow uh uh citizens of the town and employees of Stonington public school to speak so floor is yours hi hi my name is Suzanne Johnson I work at St Middle School um before I begin I just want to say what I'm about to read
049you is a little personal and I believe that a lot of our parents that work for the styal school are in my same situation [Music] so I'm a special ed teacher a pair professional I'm sorry at the stoning middle school and I actually like my job I really do I've been working there for years um I'm sorry so I'm a proud 58y old woman and I don't speak out or share my personal issues with anybody because they're personal obviously but at Christmas time I decided that I best speak out for myself and for others every year I struggle and I struggle really bad um to pay my bills but this past year has been really hard for me my two boys have moved out they're on their own living their lives and doing quite well
050for themselves it's just me and I'm trying I'm trying really hard to stand on my own two feet but it's not easy I've had to crawl to family members to help pay for my bills I've had to even my own kids I've had to go to them and ask them to help pay me pay for my bills can you imagine can any one of you imagine being 58 years old or older having to ask your family members for help I I don't think any of you quite understand that and how embarrassing it is for us I I would love to move out of my house but because of the prices of rent the prices of food I can't do that I have to stay in my house I have to struggle every year to pay
051the bills to pay the taxes on it and whatever else we have to pay um doing this it affects me obviously financially socially and emotionally there's days that I can't even get out of bed to go to work but I push myself to go because I'm so drained from having to be up half the night wondering where I'm getting money to pay my bills or to even put food on the table for my myself and that's what I'm going through right now I barely eat because I have to pay for my electric I have to pay for my oil I have a car payment that I have to pay and I don't have the money to pay that unless I craw to family members guarantee you any of you here do not have a car
052payment or have to worry about paying your oil or your electric bills I come to work every single day with a smile on my face and doing the best I can to bring joy to these kids to do my work and try not to think about my outside Life as a proud 58-year-old woman it has not been easy to share this with you it's not easy to say that I sometimes have to choose my bills as I said over my food many Paris have shared this and it gives me strength to do this I need you to see me as a human being and doing my best so please do your best for me and my fellow parents and find it in your hearts to consider us when settling the debate again my name is
053Suzanne Johns and thank you thank you Su good evening worded we have done the math and are astounded that seven people in the upper echelons of administration with Stonington make the combin sign total of $1 million $91,000 meanwhile 67 Paras make the total income of $1,273 th000 with the average salary being around $119,000 a year and for some of us that's being generous this is a difference of $181,000 and 990 so much money at the top and so little at the bottom for those of us who are in the trenches working daily with the students of Stonington we won't even mention the difference in sick time for those of us who work directly with the students versus Administration who have little to know interaction with the students those same six figure salar employees get 20
054SI days to our six that's me and 12 for full-time employees steps were frozen for several years you have the opportunity here to be the heroes and write this wrong from a Strictly Business Point of View doesn't it make more sense to invest in the Paras that you continue to employ over 40 Paras have resigned in in the last 2 years two meetings ago I asked you what was the attrition for teachers administrators custodians secretaries versus Paris ask your school administrators teachers and special education teachers what the scramble is like daily to provide coverage for children with a legally mandated IEP I've been told by my Administration that it's far easier to CB for an absent teacher than for missing Paras and it's become a common practice to utilize teacher substitutes in the role of
055a par and a much higher wage than the pair they are covering for how is that fair each new employee is a potential investment for the children of Stonington and yet the revolving door of new hires and I mean Paras ultimately ends up costing the district and the students in our care so much more the percentages proposed in the TA that's the tentative agreement they look good on paper but we as a district are still playing catchup the wage increases are far from a livable wage Waterford Paris just received a new contract contract where they got $3 increases across the board a movement is happening where par of professionals are being recognized for the importance that they bring to the classroom with increased wages in other districts in Connecticut Rhode Island and Massachusetts this is
056an opportunity for Stonington to get ahead of the curve aren't we on the same team our support from the community has only grown these are your constituents who had voted for you to have to fight for what is right for the students of stowton and we wonder what they will make of learning that seven Administration positions make nearly the equivalent of 67 of your hardest working employees we will continue to show up to the board ofed meetings rally the community and shed light on the needs of the students of zton this is an opportunity please don't squander it look at our last wage proposal that differed only by 13 cents for the first step and whopping 75 cents for the last step and that's for paas like Mrs schlink and Susan who have been in
057your district for over 20 years and don't make $20 an hour being a par is both emotionally and physically taxing and yet we are forced to work two and three jobs to make ends meet Suzanne didn't even tell you she works for the anchor Club that's the ston before and after school program she works for that program and can can you even imagine presumably you are in these positions because you care about the welfare and education of every student in Stonington your actions thus far diminish your commitment to our students our resolve is unwavering we too would like to come to an agreement however we are ready for arbitration arbitration which has yet again been delayed yet another surgery I've never heard of so many surgeries but yes another surgery each day the pass without
058a resolution to this conflict continues to hurt the students of Stonington thank you for your time thank you Michelle okay next item on our agenda is budget discussion back sure um I just want to go through some of the handouts with you first off this is really um most of it is your homework to kind of just get you um some some information that will be helpful as you have to make some decisions on the 30th and probably meeting after that as well so we uh we have a hard copy of the slideshow for you that we're going to start to go over uh we also have the questions that you have been submitting we're going to put these I think they're actually Anna probably already has them on the the website so that as
059you email questions about the budget to us we're creating a a master document and then we'll put the answers next to those so you have a card copy of what we have collected thus far I I think most of these are kaes um Kevin might have a few in there uh so that's there for you and we'll again it's available electronically and we'll we'll update it in real time for you and for the public you also have the enroll School enrollment move ahead numbers so that's helpful that's always an a perennial question that the public asks is if the class size is if enrollment is going down how can we we can't reduce teachers etc etc um just on that just as you want to make probably a not on there for you is that
060we've included the annex children in the high school numbers but we've also just pulled them out below just so you can see how many are um in attendance and that's a very Dynamic number as Allison can tell you and then you have a an amazing document with it shows you the the 22 buses that we have numbered cleverly from 1 to 22 on the next sheet uh has the capacity of the particular bus we have U various sizes buses some of them are I think one is is probably Allison's van in there I'm not sure the the VTech one Allison is that the prek one is that one of yours bus number 11 no okay um so that's a smaller bus but you'll see the varying sizes uh for ridership and if you take a
061look like if you just take a look at this the um let's say bus number three it will show you in the morning remember the high school kids and the middle school students all around the same bus so we pick up 14 of the high school kids 19 of the middle school kids um they make that run and then that bus heads to get to uh pick up 42 students that are going to go to Dean's Mill and then you can see the afternoon route so if you take a look at um bus number 20 this is something that is going to be very important for you because it may um be able to capture us some money uh but it will come at an expense uh for some families so bus number 20 is
062a bus that uh is servicing stonington's uh Stu Stonington children who attend magnet schools okay by law we do not have to do that that has been going on as a courtesy practice for several years now um so I wanted to point that out to you so this is going to come to play uh on January 30th when we make have some discussions about the buses because we did um ask in in the budget that you have in front of you um you we're going to see an an ask for an additional Bud an additional bus to help us out you also have a longer document that explains the statutory requirements and how many buses we're sending where the non-mandatory buses where they're going The Squeeze on our sports teams because sometimes we're not able
063to service our own students for extracurricular activities because we have to we are we are currently servicing children that don't attend our schools that something else to notice and and Steve is the one who's been doing a lot of work with this is in the past when we've had those two separate start times for the schools we we had buses that were half half full it made it very easy to accommodate all the children who wanted to go to the Como after school or um you know various other programs uh this year the buses are tight and so that that's another reason that we may be suggesting down the road that you give some consideration to eliminating service to some of these magnet and uh charter school students and keeping that USS to um better
064take care of our before and after school needs or after school needs rather for the families who are taking advantage of those um those programs those after school programs and those programs that have been so good to us as well so take a look at those it gives you maximum capacity of the different buses and things like that this is really for you to kind of get an idea when we have our discussion on the 30th what's in play and Chris or C are right there on page three the only thing that concerns me about the buses um is every time we it seems like we accommodate first student a lot and like we never see any savings from them like during Co these new routes that we got and it just like like we
065always expect these savings where do they all go the co situation was was um a directive to actually keep those those folks paid so we didn't have any control over that that was a a Statewide I think it was the governor actually who um put that in play um no what I was worried about is like they wouldn't even like come to the table with us about renegotiating when we weren't even using them as much you know we have a 5e contract they always like hold us to the fire no matter what and we make all these accommodations for them and they it doesn't seem like they get maybe it's time to start looking at other bus companies well we do have a fiveyear contract and I think we have three years left on that
066and just so you know that when we went out to bid last time they were the only the only ones that came forward at the end of the day so um we have I think three bus companies say they intended to bid all three came only one actually put in a bid got it so it's like monopolized I didn't say that yeah that's right we didn't say that I said it I said it and there actually has been a decrease so if you look at last year's budget for transportation and this year's they're the same despite that we had a 5% increase this year because they're using one less bus I didn't increase that line for this year even though there is a 5% contu actual increase just so I can understand this better um
067so I'll just use an example of bus 20 so we're sending bus 20 for 1 two 3 four riders that guy over there handles Transportation so I'll let him speak to it sorry you're do you know people spend their whole careers organizing and Bush roots and and it it's not a soort are non let me get to that page that's yeah that's going to be on I think you're absolutely right um that we're running um up bu for four students on the non mandatories the other the other pieces some of these writers are inconsistent so they show up some days and not the other days right so could we could we today and I recognize you've made commitment at least for this year but can we today not that you have any extra bands Alison
068but could we today switch a bus to a van for a Ghost Rider it still takes up a driver in a vehicle at that point the contract is I say I can't answer that question how the contracts written on the banner bus or SE capacity of the buses um with the total capacity they have to maintain fors on bus seats But ultimately the if somebody drives a van whether L our van are you asking if a special ed band can be used to transport those four students instead of for student the answer is no the answer is a is a hard no Those runs are really really complicated for the special education students at this point um and I think Allison would actually love another van if she had somebody to drive it she she
069has one in the budget just for the record but what is what is the fuel cost to run a bus for that number of students 21 um we we actually did have that um it's not on the sheet I want to see um I can't remember I don't want to say it out loud I I can get that to you but there is there was a cost can I estimated for that bus to drive to Y in back um when we we're talking about it at very beginning when we do the budget presentation on the 30th there will be a slide that breaks out all of the specific costs for a magnet I just wanted you to have a sense of how many riders and how many families so because it will impact families and
070they are taxpayers and I want to be sensitive to that but I also want you to also see the strain on us trying to accommodate the elementary kids um getting to their after school programming and some of our our athletic teams it's always a scramble we just thought it would be helpful for you to have this for a couple of weeks to look through before the meeting on the send some more questions um our way just to go back to this really quick what does this mean the combined Roots I mean I think I know what you're trying to say but so sometimes do you want to go take this I can I can answer so basically a lot of times when we have uh either it sometimes does happen when they have a driver
071shortage like somebody calls out but there is a lot of times like there would maybe a trip goes out early in the morning during or is you know during a pickup time or there is a sports event that's leaving high school before the buses can return from um the elementaries to pick up or whatever so what they'll do is they'll one of the the buses they got lesser capacity to combine them it usually adds about a 10-minute delay per stop when we combined buses to accommodate sports or field trips thank you I totally blame you for bringing up the bus issue but do you want to keep going so it's t but just wanted to explain those documents keep looking at them and then um Alicia is going to start the slides show so I
072think in years past I haven't gone to the podium because I have my budget book and U my computer in front of me in case you guys ask questions so that I can look things up on the Fly we're just going to start by reviewing what this is so I will remind you this is not the budget this is the budget development process it used to happen behind closed doors and LT meetings and then we would just come to you and say Here's the superintendent budget but when we do that nobody knows St it's broken nobody knows what we've cut to get to that point oh seriously no okay all right well I can just talk about it so I really was just going to go over that um the fact that it is the
073budget development not the budget the 30th you will get the superintendent budget um after the 30th when you give us feedback um on what you would like to see moved or changed then we will come back to you and that will become once you vote on it the board of education budget and then that is what will be given to the board of Finance for approval just to remind you of some of the terminology that you may see throughout the budget document a daak is a cost center essentially so it's the building or the department um actuals versus so the history gives you the budget and the action uals back to I think it's 2021 um for this year so the actuals is the actual um expenses made in each account I don't think we
074have any Grant discussions going on but just in case um the government is often very particular about what we can use gr grant funding for it is to supplement our budget not to supplant it so in other words we if we're paying teacher a now now we can't use the grant to pay teacher a we have to bring in teacher B it has to be a new person um and 99% of Grants are um formatted that way I think the covid grants skewed people's understanding of this a little bit because they allowed supplanting which is very very rare for Grants FTE is a full-time equivalent so if you see a one FTE that's a full-time person if you see a 0.5 that's a halftime we do have some 6 teachers or 04 teachers so you
075may see that so all colorcoded we have the three different iterations of the budget the first one is maintain current services and so that really is take this year's budget move everything forward so just take all of those lines and say equals last year's budget um where you see an increase is because we know that there's a vendor increase in that line otherwise it will be all things the same so now that that piece of the budget is out I'm still working with vendors to spef to clarify what uh their increases will be next year and I'll still be making changes to as we go along based on new information that comes to light the next iteration is is the Improvement request so we get together with LT and they say the leadership team and
076they say these are the things that we really need to function and operate the way that we should be and then from there we listen to the Board of Education we further clarify with vendors what costs are going to be and we bring forth the third iteration which is the superintendent budget the three different sections of the budget so it starts with the overview that compiles all of the data onto one sheet and tells you what the um budget and actuals and percentage increases are by that um cost center the deck the dashboard there's a dashboard for each deck and that gives you an overview of that specific department or building and it also allows me to track any changes so that you can very easily see which lines increased and decreased and there will
077be a you know a vague note I don't have a lot of room in there but you know a note to indicate what it's for I don't expect you to be able to see that this is just me showing you that's the overview page you can go ahead St that's a dashboard and then this just tells you in the the so each dashboard is followed by a detailed page and this just kind of gives you an overview of what those detailed Pages give you the description tells you what are we spending the money on um and then again the color coding of the maintain Improvement and then next time you'll see the orange superintendent request and then to the right is all of the historical data I Rely really heavily on that because when I'm
078looking to make next year's budget I want to see did we spend all of it last year did we overspend um so sometimes you'll see increases in the maintained current Services budget or decreases that are based on that from a prior year um major budget drivers for next school year um one is Wages as you know the minimum wage in Connecticut keeps going up um every year um and so we're kind of chasing that and the you know the cost to live has gone up and so we're seeing that in um settlement rates with unions and they're higher than you know it it used to be a really good contract if you increased by 8% over three years and that just isn't the case anymore um and so that's driving wages up the cost of
079you know it's everything you know Brian is talking about the cost of baseballs being through the roof and then and then there's um the cost of special education and transportation and um so the cost of everything as we all know from our personal lives is going up and that transfers to the school budget as well special education we will give probably a 45 minute slide to this on the 30th um we do currently have six students who are um placed in different facilities so there students whose needs we can't meet in District it's very expensive to do that um and there are six students that are not included in this year's budget so at this time last year Allison did not know that we were going to have these students or that they these needs
080were going to develop so um if you think about each of these students could be $100,000 or more it's a pretty significant amount so six doesn't sound like a lot it really is uh the threshold for excess cost so excess cost is a this is not on the slide I'm just kind of going rogue here excess costs as a as a reimbursement that we get um for students who it costs the district four and a half more than four and a half times the regular education per pupil expenditure and we'll say that one more time so the per pupil expenditure which is our budget divided by the number of students that we have multiply that by four and a half that is the number that we have to spend on a special education student in
081order to get any reimbursement for them so it's a really high threshold so we don't get any assistance unless it it is those students who are very costly in programs that are very costly percent yeah so when Allison is doing this she's both projecting what the expenses are going to be and what the excess cost is going to be especially at this point in the year it can fluctuate so much even between this year and the end or now in the end of this year this is a chart of the so the total increases that we have these are the the heavy amounts um the largest amounts the wages as I already talked about um impacting the bargaining process we did negotiate with four unions this year we four five five I think um and
082we start with the teachers next year trans transportation we talked briefly about an additional bus being needed so that 14728 includes both an additional bus at approximately $70,000 and the increase um it's not the full 5% um increase that the contract is going up it's based on um this year's actuals and and so we don't pay $5 per bus we pay a certain amount for 4 Hour 4.25 hours 5 hours so knowing what that is going to be next year is pretty impossible we can we can project essentially say that again the bus is 70,000 70,000 for an additional bus because of the additional students at the middle school and that is included in that number health insurance that's another Big Driver um it has historically been underfunded so Anthem and Brown and Brown who's
083the district's health insurance broker every year will give us an estimate based on what they're seeing in our claims and um what are changes in shares U paid by employees is they tell us you need to budget this amount to cover all of your expenses for next year I don't know that we've ever done that um and so the number that's in the budget is reflective of that exact number that was given to us by anthem honestly $413,000 is not a huge increase when it comes to health insurance for that many people um so our Trends were actually pretty good this year uh special education that is that amount is not reflective of salary INF fringe benefits that is just for programming and supplies does anyone have any questions yes if we can just go
084back yes thank you thank you um so the health insurance is a percentage typically right so the health insurance they actually because we're we're fully funded we're self- funded rather right they actually give us a number that we need to budget so they gave you a dollar not a percent they give us a dollar amount yes and for the special ad is that increase cost or increase pupil both so what is attributed to what like how much is attributed to each take that yeah yeah so um and no tuition tuition where do I begin um so um I think Alicia talked a little bit about the tuition increases so unanticipated um and and again I just want to walk everybody through kind of my thought process and trying to predict the budget so right now
085I'm trying to predict the needs of students for this time next year um and you know Alicia uses a spreadsheet I use a crystal ball um and so that is extremely challenging um and what we're dealing with right now this year is a great example of that of UNP you know needs that we didn't necessarily project we also had a student move into District who needed an out of District placement that can happen at any time um we also really important to note is that and I think we've benefited this from this in the last couple of years is we do not have any High tuition students exiting this year so that's really critical there are years where we've had one to two students that may have been you know $300,000 worth of tuition reductions
086we don't have that um coming up in the next year the other piece is there's a significant cost and increase in the programs we're doing our best to project those while Alicia has the ability to pay me contact vendors and get that information our contracts start in July so we actually don't get the tuition bill for a private school until August maybe sometimes later we're still working on adjustments to some of those invoices so we're often at the mercy of a private provider and not knowing what they're going to charge us next year um most recently uh Easton who's one of our local resks we we use learn mostly for our students we don't have any students in programs with Eon um they just recently announced to districts who have children in their special education
087programs that they're going to raise the tuition right now 15% so I would suggest that's probably $2,000 a student that those districts are going to have to absorb immediately so there's that piece of real um unpredictability the other piece we're seeing is I just want you to know that we continue to really push to provide whatever we we can to keep our students here in District um but what that means is that we need to hire more contracted services so sometimes we have a student coming in right now we're seeing really really high behavioral needs at the preschool kindergarten and lower elementary levels so we're bringing in sometimes Behavior technicians or agencies to help work with them my um other consultation needs in the area of communication I have over 12 students right now that
088are non-verbal students who need augmentative communication consultation so like all those Consultation Services have also increased with the increased needs of students so is your crystal ball 50/50 on that number I can't tell you what my crystal ball says today I'm I'm I'm I'm hoping you know right now again it's seeming really high um I the other piece we have to prepare for too is I could project something decreasing but then I could also run into the same problem that I'm in right now with which is in June something could could increase that so um we also have to be really thoughtful about keeping somewhat of a I don't want to call it a cushion so much but we have to be able to um afford to provide programming for these students um so this
089is this is what we're trying to project in terms of what we think we absolutely are going to need to meet the needs of the the IEPs Allison won't toot her horn so I will toot it for her we do such a good job Alison and her team of keeping our students in District and that's for the benefit of the students but it's also really beneficial financially um and and she has done that at least the couple years that I've been here without increasing staff so it's like there's there's this additional programming um that that is much more intensive and we're doing it with the Staffing that we have not we're they doing it with the Staffing that they have so um I think we've been lucky not to see huge spikes in special education
090costs in the past because of that um I'm just going to put a commercial in there for those Portables again if the board of Finance is listening and that some of the programs that Allison would like to replicate that are in place at the high school she would love to do that at the middle school but there's no physical space and so some of that relief that the portals will provide will also give her creativity um some space to to work with and the opposite of that is true as well if there is no Bas they'll be outplaced this is just a quick slide to show you so of the total increase um that is included in our budget 6% of it is um Improvement requests go to the next slide and show that the
091the total Improvement request is $6,550 so very negligible very negligible and if if I want to just remind the board that they kept emphasizing that the priority that was the most important to them was future Focus teaching and learning and when you see those modest requests that's going to give you probably a Coming Attraction of what number you're going to see me come back with on the 30th because they're not asking for much does anyone have any questions on these special requests we do have our building our principles are here and I know I know they're going to want to ask M about her promotional video that was really good I was going to ask go for it can you just explain to me go to the mic Alicia so they can we can bring
092the mic to you Alicia uh so uh couple of reasons uh the promotional video um just in my current Nas visits that I've been taking uh the past year and a half I notice when I get on to the high school's website and do a little preview I notice the first thing that catches my attention are these fabulous professional videos so we don't have one and we need one um secondly we have uh we saw about two months ago I think Allison had shared um a video with us of our um daily living program and it was amazing so it was just all the stars aligned and we really need one at the high school we do some amazing things and we don't showcase all of the things that we do so in looking at
093that um I really would like a professional one done um it does cost a lot of money uh so that is why it is there uh Nas is breathing down our neck we will be um having our visit shortly uh probably in about a year so we really need to be prepared but more importantly there are some amazing things happening at our High School uh and I would like to showcase our students and staff so and we are currently interviewing uh different companies and right now we would like to focus on um a former student who is seems to be doing an incredible job so I I just wanted to add that um I have several conversations with other superintendents with other parents um and they're always surprised at of the amount of programming that's
094been offered or is being offered at the high school school and that this is a way that we can actually showcase it in one spot rather than uh me putting it in my monthly reports for the Board of Education and hoping that people are listening but uh for a tiny district there is a lot and a tiny High School there's a lot of program that we keep adding to every year um even had a conversation with uh the Mystic seport again this year uh this week about some other internship opportunities that um are happening and going to be available to our students our internships alone could we could 15 minute video um I would also like to say that currently we I feel as though we are becoming a baby bow tech school um the
095offerings we have for such a small community and such a small um student body is should some should be showcased in what we have to offer so um ideally the worst thing that can happen um at the beginning of the school year is when we find out students are transitioning to School whether it be you know a u Roso Tech or a private school I want to keep our students I would I would like them to stay with us because we have a lot to offer so um we want to keep our enrollment up so from a financial perspective correct to me it's an investment because we're either going to pay tuition or transportation for those students to go elsewhere when we're already doing so much of that programming in house so in the past
096you wouldn't have thought of the public schools having to do marketing but we have to do marketing at this point well hear me out when I say I asked the question because I think that number is low okay we can increase that to 15 no I'm just like I I it's good at right I mean honestly I'm in negotiations right now with somebody and it it will probably exceed that I I can tell you it's Tri yeah um for what I would like for the high school well but the the production that your former student did for that promotional video is fantastic and whoever that person is she or he is is very talented um and since you're up there is that your request for World languages book or is that districtwide the World Language
097books that's curriculum that's curriculum and that's for the high school yes yes yeah so yeah 7 12 got it how many l and they are Spanish and French that cost triple that's six translated promotional anything else anything else for the high school while I'm standing here no that's why we sent Mr Kelly on a trip to translate that in Spanish right ready sounds good to okay any other questions on the Improvement requests looks good I'm just curious what's the um it looks like a a few different things on the SMS line the interventionist what's a PBIS supplies what is that I'm Miss come on up to the mic Chef um so PBIS essentially stands for positive reinforcement of of behaviors basically so that would be a program for that so we're trying to really double
098down on a lot of that stuff this year and we'll do it into next year so supplies to reward students for those positive things we do a lot of um at assemblies honoring different students of the month for a variety of different reasons so maybe some sort of rewards value off thought May a t-shirt for a student as the student of the month or something along those lines so it's a very small line item in the budget but just a little bit of money to kind of buy those types of things to be able to support positive student behaviors which at the middle school level is so important got it got it and that's and that's also on that same line it's a new furniture for the the Portables yeah whether that be for the
099Portables or maybe some new space that becomes available within the school because of Portables or or you know to be used in either of those yeah okay thank you and your interventionist is a reading interventionist correct reading yes yes which would that would bring us up to the same number for math that we would have for reading because at this point we're point for different thank you yeah I'm curious that this is um the Improvement requests are what the superintendent those are what the principls have asked for oh that that's what they asked for correct oh so you haven't snipped yourself or anything this is their dream this this is their this their Christmas this is what well I would call it a wish list these are just Improvement requests now I was always the
100impression that they come up with their wish list and then they you guys debated it and you took a look at it then you came up with what was more realistic then you sent it to us and then we took a look at it then we sent it to the board of Finance but this is like their complete wish list that hasn't been touched correct correct so the next the next iteration will be my recommendation to you folks okay and then you have at it gotta I want to be really clear on behalf of the people sitting behind me it is not a wish list they would be a whole lot longer if it was this these are the things that they really you know they meet with their teams and then they bring it
101to the leadership team meeting and and they tell us what they really need to best um provide services to students and it's very modest I mean look at that that's a very modest ask no I think it's a good reflection of of responsible being responsible for what they actually need and I'm really sorry for jumping in on this and I know this not designed to be questioned as much as no it definitely is it's a workshop we want I really like what caught my attention is how how low the number is for the promotional video Alicia Alicia maybe you can get a communication specialist out of this so keep keep working it I'm all in on that yeah who any more questions on this this might be a dumb question but is is summer painters
102and security updates two separate things or is the painting the security update so under description anytime you see a dash that's another item another item so it's just to fit everything on this one page in a font that you can see I just kind of have to smush them all together so on each of the dashboard Pages you can see exactly what was increased for exactly what project or request it wasn't a dumb question I thought of it I just didn't want to say it I was like maybe it's reflective paint I was like trying to piece it together I don't know there does doing that Esports lab that she doesn't want anybody in you the security updates um I know Steve many times throughout the year will have principles come and say this door
103isn't functioning as it should or this or that and and we really do need a little pot of money that he can go to for that because when it comes to security we don't want to be in a position where we have to say we'll put that in next year's budget we just want to fix it now a lot of times that we have safety meetings in things will come up and it would actually just be a recommendation and obviously there's a a funding source needed to can you know support the recommendations plus it actually gives us priorities on the suggestions that we have based on our budget that we have in our security budget so we have around so the next part to gear Point Dan is now um we really go through everything
104uh if the Improvement requests were five times what they are then we probably would be saying all right you got you have to pick between this and this because they're so modest I don't know that um maram will uh really do that because they've already really been um phisically responsible in their asks so um I will just keep working on finalizing vendor costs and that kind of thing and I will adjust things including the promotional video apparently uh between now what are we doing 18,000 for r at the 20 okay um and so that's what'll happen over the next two weeks and so my goal is to go to print on the next version by next Friday and have them delivered to you next Friday so that you'll have the weekend and um um about
105a week to review them does anyone have any more questions on that or in general in general can can you see this far so this is your uh School enrollment move ahead schedule do you have it available yep is there a formul error on the high school or is it my math is bad so this isn't actually I don't know who created this but it wasn't me Anna do you have a copy I I have it electronically so I can pull it up to you because she doesn't need a promotional video of this map is right oh that the numbers are so steady oh there's something on yep it dropped no it dropped it dropped dramatically no but this is this is yeah that's not right yeah it's not correct 17 yeah that's way yeah
106this year it's every year yeah so it should be change 373 and we'll send out a revise of this but that is 506 the following year is 512 that's what I was saying the following is 497 then 489 515 okay she gets to keep the promotional video Yeah 55 it was a formula error yeah but again if you look at that the numbers aren't that I mean it's fairly steady it's very we keep every time we get rid of a bubble class we have a bubble class we place it anything else Alicia would you have a sample of one of the promotional videos from one of the schools that you're kind of looking to emulate or is there a school I should look I just want to see like what we're okay what was the
107one that started with the aiel video that was so cool we were looking at oh okay okay okay she does not like there was one that had a drone come okay oh okay okay okay [Music] perfect I just think it'd be great to kind of see what we're what we're trying to copy we could put a little clip in the budget in the um budget presentation on the 30th just a little clip that would be nice yeah we could do that find the best one break up the numbers a little bit select your favorite one Alicia for the board meeting on the 30th okay further discussion of questions on the budget for today bro I do want to go back to your question about sip very quickly I looked at the most recent balances that
108the Town Sent and you're correct those amounts are still where they were so 50,000 I'm only good for math you [Laughter] yeah um all right next item on our agenda is board comments or concerns I should have brought this up before when we were on the Sip but I'm late to my Reflections it kind of combines what what Dan mentioned and what Sarah mentioned on on a leaner sip this year 25% of it almost is related to the middle school I think that that just speaks volumes to Chris to Steve to all your teams to working to really be thoughtful um and present something that really is um reasonable attainable and again when 25% of it is essentially Portables and and based on this unprojected move so nice work that's all thank you next item
109on our agenda sir go ahead if you have something please uh I was just uh this is a regular meeting right it's so um and we're not held to the same uh guard rails at the we don't I can speak to something outside the agenda correct yes no so well I don't want to make a motion to add anything I was just uh wanted to talk about items outside of uh all right well first of all the floor is open to you so speak you want I think we all received uh emails from several residents concerning the solar um panel proposal investigation um I was just curious if there's an update on where we at with that yeah the last board meeting we empowered the no that's okay the last board meeting we on vacation
110we empowered the superintendant school to sign the letter of intent with the uh uh with the with the team that came and did the presentation uh the prior the the two boards uh meeting before so it's to initiate the conversation there is no cost associated with that letter of intent um it's just for them to start the actual research behind the solar panel project so I don't know if you signed it but we you were it's been sent it was signed and sent out and I don't know if there's been any more Communications to so the latest update is obviously we talked about focusing on the two elementary schools as our first two customers for solar there is the consideration because we have previous history of uh 40 Field Street as an office building and
111a school so we're considering a smaller system on that that site and I'm hoping to have uh all three proposals in front of you for next regular board meeting because the there is a state um they open the state is opening up a new program which is the the compet the the solar bidding system for State funding is a competitive bid system so to make give schools more of an opportunity to to add solar they've created a 25 megawatt window just for skills to bid on this is the first time they've ever done that it opens up in March so I want to be prepared be at the table have our bed ready to go into to that 25 megawatt if approved and in the commitment is a three-year once we commit once we put
112that offer once we get approved for solar we have three years to install the solar array at the end if we do complete within 3 years there is a small fee for putting the bid forward thousands couple thousand then we will lose the couple of thousand but that there's no locked in intent with the state even if we change our mind after that fact once we I'm sorry I'm giveing you too much information but once we receive that approval for bid then we will go based on what option we pick whether we going to own the systems or go with PPA then that system would either go out to bed for either way once we make a decision so it's hot it's moving fast and hopefully I'll have a proposal next uh board meeting in
113February um mention in state funding do we have any uh idea from either our local State Rep state senator or uh State of the State on what we're looking at as far as um money from the state are they looking to cut us any feedback at all from what's going on he doesn't give his State of the State I think until February 6 correct um but I don't know if you have any intel on that you're talking about ECS fundings is that what you're talking about yeah whatever the funding is ECS ECS uh yeah we don't have any indication yet um casbo which is the everybody around the state who does my job they will track bills and um and where the budget is at and I'll monitor that over the next several months um
114I was hoping uh reading the paper recently I've seen some articles on um other districts in the country I guess they were um and they had a report on uh what the cell phone bans have uh impacted their uh schools and I was wondering if we could get one if we have any it's funny um Jeff just sent me some data for the first quarter on comparing IPL data from last year to this year I was going to put it in your letter but I'll I'll get it to you it's um definitely has made some improvements and i' really um Jeff I I'm sorry to put you on the spot but if you don't mind just coming up here and giving the same update on your experience with a ban um to the board that
115you gave at the tour because he gave some Intel sure um so we've had a lot of new stuff at Stonington Middle School this year year um and one that has actually just been a resounding success has been the the Yonder pouches and our cell phone policy and all that and and truth be told we didn't really change the policy a ton I think we've just really had great Fidelity with it and we've added obviously the pouch system to it um when when when I took this job I was looking at that whole process and I was like this could go either way let's I don't know what I stepped into here but it's been fantastic um the kids have I think bought in is maybe not the right world but they've complied and and
116um they're doing a good job with it I am confident that we have less than a handful of students that maybe have their phone on their person in a given day and are trying to you know eek around the rules um generally all students are away and in their Yonder pouches um we had just to give you a little kind of anecdote about it so we had our first dance back in November first school dance of the year um and we had the students lock their phones up and there was a lot of complaining about it prior to but they all got there and they they locked their phones up and we had a nice spot in the office for all of them and they were in their y pouches some of them didn't lock
117them up but we just kept it in the office um and within 2 minutes they all forgot they were engaged with each other they were having a great dance they were partying like it was 1999 um and it was fantastic it was the best middle school dance I've ever been a part of um even including the ones I went to when I was in Middle School and um it was just a fantastic experience we've seen little to no cell phone related discipline issues um we actually had a minor uptick in the week after winter break with a couple little social media related things things not coincidentally they were just home for a couple of weeks and and I know if it were my children I wouldn't be making them lock their phones up at home
118over Christmas break either so um you know so we saw a little bit of an uptick there in a period of time when they had a little more access to them so um I think uh it's been a resounding success I hope we can continue with it I think it's positive for the students I think it's positive for our school Community I have absolutely nothing negative to say about it it is not slowed our dismissal our arrival some of those logistical concerns we have nothing um the pouches have been pretty durable very few Replacements um almost no deliberate damage um a couple you know accidental little breakings here but we have a little bit a few extras we've been uh restocking with so um are you outside of just putting in our letter supplementing what
119he just said can we do like a like a formal report of all this you know some of the stuff that he just said and some of the information that he sent you and maybe you know make it a press release or or something just to to advertise to our community that you know they were very supportive when we instituted this policy back in September and especially the parents or just something that says you know this worked you know we did it it was a bold move you know it was a very bold move and there's not too many towns I think we're probably the only town in Southeastern Connecticut that really stepped up and and did this and you know you know we should congratulate ourselves but even more importantly you know show the
120citizens and the parents especially this of the students that we have um that how effective it's been and and hopefully there'll be you know not only less problems in the school having better dances such they had in November but also you know hopefully there'll be some long-term mental health gains and and social gains and you know you didn't touch on the free play aspect and yeah the recess and the oh yeah the recess as well yeah I I spoke about that the other day so there's a um there's a tangible difference in our cafeteria on indoor recess versus outdoor recess days and you can and when you if you come into our cafeteria on an outdoor recess day Cu uh lunch is after recess and then come in on an indoor recess day and you
121can feel the difference in the room um it's a Ken concert versus a ACDC concert um two very different levels of decb and and student energy and they they're they're they're it's a much more enjoyable place to be after outdoor recess that's for sure um so the kids love that so Dan we can put something together but I just want you to know that this work has was really the Cornerstone to why the town got this the municipal Excellence award um and not just this but everything the community's been doing so it has been covered but we can put something together with some data and see if anybody will pick it up and we have the second part of Yukon study coming up here next month month uh they're where they're surveying the seventh graders
122to see the impact on their mental health so we'll we'll have a look at that data obviously down the road and then um you know like you said the policy was pretty much there it was just a different way of enforcing it with the Yonder pouches and what have you I was just wondering if that policy is the same one that we have for the high school and if uh you know the policy committee needs to do any further movement on it or if uh we can find out what resources outside of a promotional video that our high school principal needs to you know she's you know obviously uh your friend there Dr Uh Kevin helped me out there the the guy that did the book yeah that you know the age level went through
123High School it wasn't just the middle school kids the age level went through high school with uh you know all the downsides of a cell phone so um you know now would be the time outside of doing all this uh so exciting budget stuff that uh we start doing some little bit of Thea did you want to say anything about the high school and your because you have the real experience of like what kinds of incidents are happening and not happening um are you are you asking my opinion as a mom whose child has one at the high school or what are you asking so I can answer it appropriately I'm just asking is is is you know what can we we as a board do or do we have to do anything to move
124this forward not just to the middle school but to the high school the Yonder pouches yes whatever it takes to imp you know to to curtail uh cell phone use and all the negative associations with so I I think honestly we need to drill down to the data and and what's happening at the high school and start from there that make sense I think if you if you can share a little bit about how many incidents you have where children are actually um breaking the policy in the classrooms so since September we've had three incidents of uh cell phone policy but is that three incidents because that's the number of incident that happened or those are the number of incident reported and no the teachers report that right but how many times the students I'm
125not going to ask you to guess but but you know I I was I was I had the pleasure to be at your high school I think two weeks ago and I brought it up to the class that I was speaking at and um it was it was a great debate with the with the students around their opinion on Banning the cell phones and using the Y pouches at the high school and uh one of the students that was in the classroom was a senior and he said maybe it's a senior privilege to have your cell phone but lower grades maybe you want to put them in the under pouches and I guess I I recognize your your your uh you asking us to look at the numbers and it's only three but would it
126would it make sense that that we have the such a great uh positive experience at the middle school is to carry that experience forward into the high school now that you have the E uh and eighth grader graduating and going into high school to carry on the whole concept of like maybe a gradual um a gradual rele u a gr releas a gradual lessening of those restrictions into that yandre pches because one of the one of the points that the students brought up in in the high school is that we use them for curriculum we use them in science classes we use them so yeah and I think it's it's a it's a bigger question to to answer right here um because there's so many factors involved with it so just like Baro said in
127fact I happened to be in the class when we were uh discussing that so most teachers do use cell phone for certain things in class uh not everybody um are there alternative devices that they could use in the classroom sure um at this point in time um I would say math science they do use their cell phones for various things um all of the there is zero cell phone use in the classrooms as we speak um study halls included so when you ask about data and how many incidents we've had we've had three where a student has taken out their cell phone and a teacher has reported that um but it it does go beyond just that what are the school rules what are our policies in place it's what are they being used for
128in the school um and I would say right now if you were to walk through the high school through our three lunch waves you would see students on their cell phones uh if you walk into a class um if you were to watch uh Mrs Fernandez in the hallway and they're working on their uh robotics yes they they use them Mr smilanich Mo a lot of the science teachers use them um but in regards to um regular classes they're not they just not used that much um so there's a lot of factors involved in it that I'm happy to discuss um it might be I know Alicia and I have had a couple conversations about after this year is completed um you know would it be it would it be helpful to build on that
129whole idea of the the unstructured play and all that to take to have some type of a like a a media-free lunch so that the kids are at the tables talking with one another it's like the dance right take devices away and then that provides them a window but nothing's been decided yet about that and she really she was quite honest she's like I want to go see see what happens to Parkinson this year yeah and I'm also watching I'm then we'll have a discussion my daughter um who High School implemented them this year so I I have I have certainly a parents perspective um what's going well what's not going well um so I'm I'm happy to share that too so I'm coming at it with two different lenses one as a principal and
130one as a mom um and we'll kind of leave it at that the mom perspective right now so um yeah it's there's a lot good and there's a lot not so good there's there's some successes that are happening at the middle school right now that I love um I don't love seeing our students in the lunchroom with their with their faces down um but you know there's a lot to be said so um the there's there's a policy the the AR the AR is already there that go aligns to the policy and you if you look at it it's online obviously the AR spells out what's happening at the elementary school what happens at the middle school first what happens at the high school First Defense second defense third defense so I think maybe in
131the springtime at the end closer to the end of the year we could invite Alicia to come to the policy meeting well I mean I I guess you're asking her to make a I don't know what you're asking again are you asking her to make a change you were just you were just saying that you know we could look at this further but it's just like I then the reason why I bring it up tonight is you know if we are to do something for next fall what we have to do between now and then to to communicate and budget and yeah and you know do we have to do that now in order to prepare for the future or you know or is what she's saying that she's content with this what's going on
132now that we don't need to do anything um you know so do you want some time Alicia to think about that before sure okay I was just afraid that if we wait too late in you know the spring or you know end of the school year that you know we then have time to implement something for September you know I do think this is just my opinion and I haven't again Revisited I do think um Yonder P pouches for high school kids is is not developmentally appropriate that's my sense of um what I see happening at the middle school I just don't think that is we want them to be a little bit more independent so if we're going to ask them not to use their phones the expectation in my opinion would be you
133put your phone away and and then you deal with it if you take your phone out yeah and and again I do I do like the idea of a no phone launch because we want them to develop those relationships and those social skills um so I'm happy to come to a policy meeting just to simply answer some questions um if you were to ask me hard and fast right now would I entertain getting them at the high school today my answer would be no based on what I see data what I see in the classrooms um I'm certainly up for just to talk about it um but I'm giving you that opinion based on what I see day in and day out in my building and what I'm watching my daughter experience at her high
134school so again I'm I'm happy to talk about it but if you were to ask me right now Dan to make a decision on whether or not to get Yonder pouches at the high school my answer would be no today so and again and and I look at this too as our students are coming to us 14 years old and I'm preparing them to cross the stage shake their hand give them a diploma as an adult and I would like to treat them as such so you know there's again there's different lenses um but I'm I'm I'm happy to again I'll happy to come to policy and talk about it thank you I don't know if I'm not my um time or not but I guess the last thing and um it was touched on
135by uh the par president in her remarks but um an update on the for the public to know coming from us on where we are with the arbitration and the fact that there was a delay and do we have another date for arbitration through no fault of anybody's um these arbitrators have had a series of Health um um incidents uh we're looking at March dates I I reached out to Rebecca Santiago yesterday we have no definite dates yet it's a lot of bodies to coordinate Dan it's the um three arbitrators but there's also an expert witness that the pars have to um airlift up from DC uh and then you know Council as well as our as our Witnesses so we're hoping for early March we want to get it done as soon as possible
136and we'll keep you posted when we get a date we did ask if we could look for different arbitrator um which Rebecca did uh they weren't available until April so the person that we originally had will be available to come back with us in March which was sooner than a replacement for that person there doesn't seem to be a lot of them and that's half the problem is you know we're trying to go after people who's have very limited availability and I have been adding this to the Personnel report too just so you know under um negotiating negotiation sorry I'm getting tired um updates it'll say can't this date was cancelled and give a snippet of why and I don't believe the latest uh update had that date cancelled it had that date live because
137I think there was just a timing between the report and when the arbitrator canel I just want to make sure we're transparent to all parties involved and to the you know obviously the public that you know and if we have to say at every meeting that you know we're trying to get it resolved but due to circumstances or situations outside of our control that it's why it's getting delayed thank you thank you motion to adjourn is there a second second all in favor I I motion was anous