CorpusRecord 111978

Board of Education Special Meeting 2024-12-11

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Torrington Public Schools
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Northwest Hills Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
2,262 words · about 13 min
Collected
2026-06-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001to pledge allegiance please I pledge allegiance flag the Unites stands one nation indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right thank you everybody I'm gonna stop sharing and I'm going to hand it over to Dean and Rachel and and oh no I sorry I'm not hold on because I am running this meeting I have to pull up hold on guys the agenda sorry okay have it here thanks Mike all right I'm gonna start with the roll call Mr Burger here M Conway here Mr Corey Mr Cronin here Mr prus here Mr ulo is excused M Miss hona is excused Mr Kisco here Mr Knight if he can't get in he will be excused Mr putam here mayor Carbone or representative Mrs Ferguson here Miss K KUSI Sorry Miss uh Miss Labby here Mr prola

002miss suty Mr Wilson here all right now I just have to pull up the agenda sorry again bear with me here not a big fan of this Zoom setup but I guess it's convenient you're muted Dean hold on one second [Music] Dean all right so agenda item number three discussion of the fiveyear facilities and Technologies Capital plan so now I will hand it over to Dean and Rachel if you want to do some uh presentation and discussion around it and then we can open it up for questions okay I'll go first yeah go ahead okay uh and excuse me um if the phone rings we do have a little bit of emergency over the school so um trying to handle that from here um all right so we put together uh this fiveyear plan that

003you take a look at um a lot of this stuff that on here uh came from the facility study um some of the stuff came from um U me Direct going through looking at what we're doing with the schools and red dising and and things that um you know um were of high need uh so as you can see the we broke it out to each individual School uh 25 26 that column right there if you look at forb school we have uh you know um certain things on there from ADA compliance to uh to drinking fountains that should be installed um and you know I'm guessing that everybody had an opportunity to take a look at these um so I went through every school um to try to figure out what what what should

004be this year and what can we maybe wait for next year there's some stuff on here that's very borderline uh whether we can wait or not including that Chiller uh at at at Tor for that's probably our weakest link right now um is the Tor for Chiller and hopefully you know we'll get some money this year to take care of that so um if there's any questions i' i' I'd like to answer any of them or any thoughts that you guys had on all of this I know it's a lot to absorb so I'm hoping you had time to take a look at it and um Can can quiz me on it anybody have any questions for Dean would wouldn't be fun if I it wouldn't be fun if I didn't have one or two

005yeah that's true go ahead um Dean did I've asked we talked about it previously did you get a chance to talk to the energy folks the seens guys about possibly rolling that Chiller into an Energy Efficiency program we talked about yeah so so um so they're looking at I have I've spoken to them and I've also spoken to ABS who is our mechanical um our BMS at um the new high school and there are BMS at I believe vulgo right now they also have given me a budget number uh to go by and also they work with the energy companies also so that is something that we can definitely look into uh Jeff I haven't gone any further than like put the number down and worst case scenario we have to pay for it we

006put it in there but that's something that we can definitely look at and it's a good possibility I didn't get a definite yes or no out out of out of both of them because a little bit of leg work would have to be done to to get there so yeah I figured I just we talked about it a couple times I wasn't what the plan was these numbers are a number right I mean at the end of the day if we approve these and move forward with them this is what we intend to spend the money on but it can certainly change is that an accurate statement that is a very accurate statement you know and that includes you know our our 72 to 72% back from the state which is you know I'm sure

007it's still going to be there but that's always a fluctuate number also so yeah I mean I just I look at the the list like Forbes and Southwest and with obviously we have we've got some tentative PL for the buildings but nothing's been finalized yet so you see the you know typical height toilets on the and I'm assuming that would change if it needed to some of these things can change based on what the ultimate use of the building ends up being or not being yep yep thank you de yeah this is all this is all flexible as the years go on seeing that it's a five-year plan so it's something that I'm sure you'll readdress in facilities and budget year after year or even month after month like you do today things will change

008but it it does give us a somewhat of a picture to be able to send to the city y y did you have another question Jeff no I bundled them both in there oh okay anybody else questions or comments Glenn no all right Dean is that you're good then for for now with your your numbers and you're ready to un let you have other questions uh yeah you know everything is pretty self-explanatory there to a point I I mean we can go really into the weeds but I don't think anybody really wants to that's that's you know that's what it is um so and it'll get and and you guys spend a lot of time on this throughout the year too so there's no doubt it'll continue to be addressed all right Rachel did you

009want to go next did you wait Rachel I'm sorry before you go did you both roll in your um plans into one number or Dean do you have a separate number and Rachel has one separate they are separate can you go back down because I don't want to leave this page again it go back to my email just so I could see the final um right here I think by year oh okay all right perfect thank you okay thanks are you ready ready when you are um so I I spent a lot of time digging into um our warranties on our devices this year um when things were going to expire um I've been having a lot of meetings particularly with apple um and what they suggest we do um when it comes to a

010refresh rate of their devices um so you'll see um for the upcoming year there's MacBook and iPad Refreshments because the warranties that we have are going to be expiring um that year um so like to get those those devices um refreshed so that we can have a new warranty and make sure everything is covered um that way we're not you know putting the bill for anything that might um Break um and then you'll also see um in several spots um equipment to upgrade buildings to the new phone system uh so now that we'll have the system um in place at the new high schoolmiddle school um and then we have the redundancy at our current Middle School building um it would be a good idea for us to get all of our other buildings up

011to speed especially because our current um phone system is obsolete um they do not sell it or make Parts when we buy phones a lot of the time it's off eBay according to the company um so yeah we don't buy them off eBay but they do um so um yeah any questions yes uh just a couple um the warranty thing you probably have enough data and I did not admittedly go back and look at the prior presentations on what our repair expenditures were but it is $330,000 a thirdd of a million dollars in warranties alone on the devices that would say based on the cost to replace them that we are having extensive damage to one out of four devices over the four years it's you know it's a quarter the cost of a new

012machine when you look at it we had kind of talked about this previously looking at the data that's $85,000 a year in Damages that let's say were not covered by somebody having paid for the insurance it's just a lot of money that we should probably look at this or maybe you already have Rachel you have all the data I have no doubt you've taking a cursory look at this but looking at what our damages costs were last year on them apples that happens to be the grade level we had ironically the least amount of damage so do you have any numbers to support the warranty for four years or do you do we want to take a look at it later I mean I just wanted to ask the question because we talked about it

013a couple maybe a year or two ago yeah I would definitely have to back and get those numbers for you but I do want to stress that you know if we're looking at numbers from last year we have to realize this is covering that device for four years right so multiply that times four um and it's also covering two damages to the device so if a student was to break a screen twice within those four years it would be completely covered whereas if we didn't go with that um you know it's about $360 just for a screen um and that's a huge amount um to for us to incur and if they break it multiple times over the four years that they have that device you know think about you know 360 times four now

014sure I understand that of course I we we live in the same space to some extent here the but it is when you have 10 devices the warranty from a third party like you know the Apple warranty makes in ARP andion a lot more sense because the odds of saving money on it are much lower your pool of possible damages is Tiny whereas when you have 1,800 devices the odds of self-insuring sometimes works out to be better we don't have to have that conversation now certainly we can I don't have a problem submitting it with the warranty I just might want to we could figure out what the actual damage cost were I know you have it and I apologize for not having looked um but we can if it's not really $85,000 a year

015and sustain the damages that we're not getting back it might actually be cheaper for us and could get you more equipment sooner which I know is always difficult right is to find you money to replace the things that need to be replaced maybe we need to reallocate it but it can be a discussion for another day okay I can look into that as well thanks Rachel I don't know how to raise my hand on this thing how can I ask a question Susan yes of course how how many many total MacBooks do we have um probably just under 1,500 there was 1,200 in our first order which is what you see um in that little um on the first year the 1,200 that would be going out a warranty um and then we have purchased

016a few more um when we first began this whole Apple implementation um we started off with you know students and certified staff um that has grown to um some other staff members who needed the capabilities of MacBook as well um as well as um just replacing devices that were either damaged Beyond repair or did not come back to us um but we saw much better numbers on that this year so that's like 80% of our MacBooks are going to be replaced in one year yeah that because we we bought them all at one time so the warranty is going to be expiring all at once um on those so I don't know this is I guess this be more of a computer question that I can't answer does it make any more sense to try

017and stagger this so that we don't have this huge expense every four years or we can plan plan better per year we know we're going to have 25% replacement costs spread them out over four years so everything's always covered under warranty but it's more of a fixed expense yeah um there are there are programs that we can um work with apple to reduce these costs um I just wanted to shoot for if we didn't have um those programs available to us yeah just in case what the worst case scenario would be if replace them all right thank you can I tag a followup on Glenn's question quick sure uh Rachel the other thing is those are what those are M1 MacBook Pros probably yes so if they're M1 MacBook Pros the other thing we can

018look at is potentially I mean it's not just the $240 warranty the device has Apple support for security like kind of like our Chromebooks do far past the four years what do we do what happens are they trading are we trading them in with them we can certainly extend the life of these a usability standpoint longer than four years if if we needed to not that we justly should but it's an option they're still supported so not it's not just the warranty cost it can also be extending the life of the asset kind of where Glenn was going with it by staggering you know if we were to say hey let's get you a third of them this time a third of them next time and a third of them that would stagger the capital

019expense a bit and yes it would carry some of these units out of warranty but might also be a good way to test you know what our exposure rate is going out that far right the return on investment for these devices is that you know it it's not going to get um it's going to get lower after four years um because it won't be covered anymore and if anything is to happen to it then we can't uh replace it so if we were to join say a buyback program um where they give us a percentage back for each device based on how well it was taken care of um you know if we do that at the end of our four years of warranty coverage then we can get the most back for our devices

020um so that's it's kind of part of that plan that I was talking about um yes they can absolutely be used past four years it's just that if we want to uh sort of like trade them in and see a return on it then that's the the best point to do that um so that we can get a return on our investment and then put them into um more devices or against the cost of more devices yeah so let's let's leave it the way it is and when we get to that point if we get the money from the city to do any of this we can figure all that out then sounds like you got a good handle on it so we'll sort out the warranty stuff when the time comes I appreciate it

021thank you uh can I make a point for a minute hello yes we need to take the trip thong out of equipment for 2025 26 or the city will catch it and we'll look bad is enough for you no that okay oh an equipment it's to an extra you perfect any other questions I don't know where did Sue go she's muted oh okay oh I'm sorry I didn't know I was muted I was talking any other questions no all right so I think at this point Michael I think I don't know if we do we need to vote on this to move it to the city for you to send it um by the 31st make a motion that you um uh inform the superintendent to send the proposed fiveyear capital and Technology plan to

022the city as discussed this evening and I will write a letter along with uh Donna and we will present that and get that over to the city okay excellent okay so do I hear a motion uh to authorize a superintendent to prepare a letter and send the proposed Capital fiveyear plan that we just reviewed and discussed to the City by December 31st so moved second who was second Glen all right any discussion do we need to add the total amount in that motion um because it's as presented the totals are there J think that's yeah that's appropriate that'll okay um no discussion all in favor I I I any opposed no opposed all right motion moves forward you can go ahead and get that ready Michael whenever um I'm assuming this week next you'll have

023it Don and I will work on it okay and any no other questions comments okay motion to adjourn so move second second Glenn and John Merry Christmas everyone so this is our last meeting Merry Christmas everyone merry Christmas have a wonderful holiday thanks bu even you have a knees or a Kisco I somebody has to at least acknowledge it I I did earlier it it was mentioned that was good John but you still have on your red shirt that's good a little bit spirit it's Christmas it's Christmas anyway bye everybody bye have a everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.