CorpusRecord 112240

Waterbury Board of Education Workshop - December 5, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Waterbury Board of Education
Date
2024-12-06
Location
Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,121 words · about 79 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] for [Music] for e e it started with good evening sorry for the delay that was on me today is December 3rd today's December 5th oh my God can we please have a silent [Music] prayer we are going to have the Pledge of Allegiance by Kings Berry's [Music] finest I PL allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible and liberty and justice for all right Miss Sam can you introduce your pledge of allegiance to people oh come over come over I have McKenzie Harvey in fourth grade Zion Roland and kindergarten I have Omar Torres in fourth grade and I have Dean stra Rafel in fifth grade thank you so much hi my name is Di and I'm kindergarten gray all

002[Music] right be the next you know who she [Music] is has met a mik [Music] thank you thank you good evening president Hernandez vice president Brown secretary Saran Orono Commissioners student Representatives interim superintendent Dr Schwarz and mayor pineri I'm Hannah Sam principal of Frederick John Kingsbury Elementary School and I would like to welcome you to our school welcome I want to acknowledge our student I already acknowledge our student so I thank you so much for brazing um the weather and coming here to represent in K kinsbury School kinsbury serves 420 diverse students with a dedicated and committed staff who work to promote Excellence academically emotionally and socially because of their commitment to our students the state department of education has recognized Kingsbury as a school of Distinction had a recently released accountability report we have

003identified the following Focus areas to continue this growth and improve our student outcomes keep going Ela math and science supplementing the district curriculum program with generation genius and Freckle a pilot program focusing on Mad fact fluency for our first graders we are also committed to decreasing our chronic absenteeism rate and building stronger Partnerships with our families addressing our students social emotional needs is important to increasing the achievement this is why kinsbury school has partnered with CT connecting to care for children Under The Children Health and development Institute to enhance behavioral and supports for our students I'm excited to share a few highlights of what we're doing to improve student learning Kingsbury continues to be a higher order thinking School a program that is grounded in social emotional learning culturally responsive teaching and multiple intelligence theory

004we continue to enrich our students learning through teaching artists Arts workshops and schoolwide performance our first school performance schoolwide performance was a success enjoyed by all with Reflections from students on what they [Music] learned our highlight number two is our after school programs we do have two after school programs currently running in our building the first one is extended school hours which provides academic support in math and Ela for our students performing below grade level based on bench Mark assessment the second is an enrichment program through arts for learning for students performing at or above great level while Esh is mainly focused on math and Ela support we do have planned enrichment opportunities through seven angels theater and experiential learning through the Connecticut Science Center our highlight number three is our attendance strategies we do

005have a robust attendance team that analy this data on a weekly basis our goal is to be proactive as a school and to ensure that students are attending school on a regular basis some of the strategies that we've put in place are weekly announcements of the great level with the highest average daily attendance and percentages are posted on our attendance board for all great levels classrooms get to keep our personalized kinsbury attendance trophy for a week additionally each classroom has a designated week week to lead morning announcements teachers select students to lead announcements with the principal and our students look forward to this opportunity students are also awarded monthly end of Mark and or end of marketing period attendance certificates with prizes and Raffles for families whose students have perfect or most improved attendance based

006on our Trends we have scheduled spirit days to ensure that our students attend school and communicating with our families about reasons for those absences and how best we can support them here are a few snapshots of our attendance efforts okay a highlight number four is our parent engagement piece engaging our families is crucial we provide a Weekly Newsletter accessible via parent square with translation options parent workshops in literacy math and Title One have been organized alongside community events to bolster parental involvement I am pleased to announce the election of our school governance council members focusing this year on Ren reviewing our student achievement data and developing a school home compact to enhance student outcomes finally I want to thank board Commissioners interim superintendent Dr Schwarz assistant superintendent Dr Johnson for your unwavering support of our

007school community and academic programs at this moment I would like to acknowledge all our school members community members that are in attendance here with us please stand as I recognize you my assistant my assistant principal Susan [Music] [Applause] grappy members of the school governance Council our parent who are here our parents who are here with [Music] us amazing teachers and [Music] staff please stand to be recognized thank you I'll be happy to answer any questions you may have at this time any questions here Dr Schwarz student has one of the questions there but um I just want to say uh you skipped over one slide because I knew you you probably have a time limit and you wanted to do it but it wasn't on here but it's in our packet and I just want

008to say um congratulations and thank you so much for uh the kingsberry staff I know Eric Brown was also the principal here last year but becoming a school of Distinction is very special it's very unique and you are one of three schools in the city of Waterberry that earned School of Distinction which is uh from the State Department of Education in other cities just so everybody knows all the other cities that are similar to Waterberry at most they had one school ear in school of Distinction last year we had three and kingsberry is one of them so I want to thank all the staff I want to thank the families and the students those that are here and that are not here because it is an amazing accomplishment uh former principal Brown uh I want

009to say congratulations I want to give you another round of [Applause] applause oh I'm sorry could I could I have you come back for one minute uh I I you talked about the attendance and there is a chart here but unfortunately I forgive my eyes but I can't read it uh there's a chart about attendance attendance attendance all right and it looks like it's improving but I I can't see the actual data go yeah keep going next yes so the bottom piece you see the data that's our attendance our attendance data when we meet that's the agenda and we we track week by week so we have this week we look at our average daily attendance and we look at our chronically absent students so we look at Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday and then we

010track it we compare it from the previous week and we see the difference and then we try to identify why is this the reason one of the reasons when you look at the first one that's at the beginning of the school year and we realize that when we have half days we have kids not coming to school and so one of the um strategy that we came up with was to have spirit days and our students love spirit days and so they come to school when we have spirit days so you can see the bottom one is uh when it's it's green that means that we exceeded we met or exceeded our goal so what we have is that our goal is to decrease our attendance by 5% we we're currently at 26.7% at the

011end of last school year so we're trying to reduce it by 5% but we also have weekly goals which is 95% average daily attendance and so that's the measure that we look at and when we look at the average daily attendance by great levels we're looking whether we're Meeting those goals weekly and then we're coming up with strategies and interventions to support those efforts and so that's what you see we do I do communicate with families in our newsletter about attendance on a weekly basis we have our attendance team we make phone calls home visit as well and then you see the announcement we have our announcement Cruise example of that as well as our efforts um with our kids to Second thank you and these are the spirit days that we've had so far

012are great it sounds like you really are have a concerted effort on attendance so thank you very much because it is a huge uh issue thank you thank you any other questions any more questions now miss Sam you're good to go thank you okay Committee of the we have an update on the superintendent's search Miss slamb I asked uh miss Lamb and Tyra to come but Tyra was busy to just uh give the Commissioners an update on what on the process and what's going on um since the last uh it table that they had and just that was the N touch base well good evening and thank you president Hernandez and vice president Brown secretary Melissa oorno and interim superintendent Dr Schwarz thank you for having me and student Representatives um my name is Sherry

013lamb and I'm the Assistant Director of Human Resources and as the president said my director Tara sha was unable to be here tonight um both Tara and I would like like to provide the board and the community an update regarding the current superintendent of schools recruitment um as a continuation of our last meeting here November the 7th we are committed to being transparent and informative so for those of you that are not aware the position of superintendent of schools was posted October the 30th and since this uh date J Consulting met with close to 45 Community stakeholders and staff and that it also included Commissioners board members Union presidents and many Community organizations in addition both Tara JG Consulting and myself hosted two Town Hall meetings where the community members Express their concerns and desires

014for the next superintendent of schools um a survey was also established and distributed throughout the city soliciting community members feedback it was supposed to close on November the 30th um we currently have 493 as of today at the time last week we only had a little shy of 330 so we decided to extend the survey date and it's closing tomorrow at Friday tomorrow at um 11:59 p.m. so Flyers have been distributed throughout the building thank you um principal uh Sam for Distributing them and also um it will be available on the um Zoom not zoom but what is this uh YouTube screen um for you to scan the QR code and that QR code will send you directly to the survey um now this community input is used to develop the candidate profile for the

015next superintendent and so as of today we don't have the results of the survey uh but based on some of the feedback from the town hall meetings with your permission president Hernandez I could review some of them if you like okay so some of the things that were discussed um we broke it down 80 over 87% feel that the next superintendent should have strong communication skills a good communicator 78% feel this person should be approachable and visible over 76% feel that they should have the ability to make and defend difficult decisions um and over 69% feel that um they should be able to be capable of developing relationships especially in the work place in unions in addition um Sumer responses were regarding teacher retention um they felt that was critical and critical issue retaining High

016qualified minority teachers um special education was a common theme um they were concerned about inadequate resources and support for special education um in in addition to requesting more funds towards special education because a growing need uh um they discuss teacher retention Building Systems to retain talented Educators and equity and opportunity promoting fairness in access to resources and support for all students um and then last I just highlighted some of them focus on under served schools um prioritizing support for those struggling schools um and these were some of the um voices that we heard and concerns at some of these Town Hall meetings our off office Human Resources we are committed to Fidelity in our civil service process our Civil Service rules and regulations um all applicants currently apply directly to JG Consulting um and we

017don't have the applicant nams who they are where they're coming from but however um as of today we did we were informed that we have over 10 applicants that applied so that's the update from Human Resources any questions oh thank you so much all right thank you for having me have a good night thank you item number three request approval of the 2025 2026 oh sorry I went ahead of myself item number two State Department of Education to Next Generation accountability [Music] update good evening president Hernandez vice president Brown Commissioners student representatives and interm superintendent Dr Schwarz I'm joined by Tara biston our supervisor of research testing um to go through the Next Generation accountability results for the 2023 2024 school year good evening the Next Generation accountability results were recently released by the Connecticut

018State Department of Education is there a trck Once you walk them through it I'll help them find it find it okay Stone was leaning out of the way I appreciate that um Next Generation accountability was devel developed several years agoo by the Connecticut State Department of Education it really takes into account a holistic perspective on school and District performance so they really moved Beyond just looking at student test scores and take into account many other variables so it's a broad set of indicators and everything is calculated by the State Department of Education uh first they look at and primarily academic achievement and academic growth uh that's across the subject areas of English language arts mathematics and science they also look at participation rates chronic absenteeism College and Career Readiness coursework College and Career Readiness exam

019performance whether students are on track in grade nine four-year graduation rates six-year graduation rates postsecondary entrance within one year of graduation physical fitness and arts access with all of those indicators they produce a final number that's the overall accountability index there we go so we have that's the slide I just explained looking at all of the 12 indicators so we're going to look at some performance over time looking at the district level yeah oh I'll jump in on that one thank you so I added the slide uh for you Commissioners because I wanted you to see this accountability index um really started back in 2014 and 2015 and so this this whole accountability index uh for those that were around in 2014 2015 paying attention to this it was to get away from just looking

020at like reading MTH scores it was to look at those 12 indicators that tar Bon just went over give us a general score on how we're doing on all those indicators and then um make judgments on the basically the district on how we're performing on a more holistic perspective Ive if you go back all the way to 2014 2015 you could see we were at uh if I read that correctly 60 60 points is what we received now they've tinkered with this formula a little bit over time uh I want to point out one thing uh from 2015 2016 to 2018 2019 We Grew From 57.8 to 64.6 and Tara and I checked this like many times to make sure we were correct so I feel very comfortable saying this in that time that's pre

021pandemic the Water Public Schools grew more than any other prek-12 District in the entire state of Connecticut um so from from from from 1516 to 189 we grew more than any other prek-12 District in the state of Connecticut we also had a Long Way to Grow right so when you're closer to the bottom you have more room to grow so we celebrate that but we also know that we have a lot of work to do would continue to do obviously you can see from that 64.6 you see the dip back down after the pandemic to 599 592 now pulling ourselves back up from last year to 612 getting closer to pre-pandemic levels but not quite there yet but I wanted to show you that little longevity piece to show you that the the the impact

022of where we were going with our coherence in the district the impact of the covid uh uh uh uh pandemic on our on our scores but now the Resurgence of what we're what we're attempting to do so um I thought that was important and the next slide it's it's a that we can sit here and talk all night on this one um but you'll you'll have it and and that basically is all 12 of those indicators broken down individually over those years so that you can have a little bit more time to look at this I'm sure you'll have some questions we'll be happy to answer more come back and go into more depth with this honestly this could be a 200 slide presentation as you know um if you break down all the indicators

023but I just wanted to show this uh to you to to highlight a few things um number one uh you can see that our uh our Ela uh performance index for all students it's still not quite at the 1819 level we are at 55% we're at 51.9 so we're still trying to an Ela uh if you go down that 1819 category we're just not quite there where we were before the pandemic except for um our Ela uh uh academic growth and uh T you can talk a little bit uh about what academic growth is that again academic growth we actually get more points in in in the growth category than any other category this is to recognize districts that who's growing the students the fastest you know because a lot of our students also are

024coming in not quite at the pre kindergarten or kindergarten levels and so they're recognizing by the time they get to third fourth fifth sixth grade who's growing who's closing the gaps the fastest and so we actually are at the prepandemic levels uh for many of those or we're right next to it uh based on that and I also wanted to highlight uh one more thing you know although chronic absenteeism and you heard principal Sam tonight and uh uh uh Jade and Dr Johnson uh the team we have a chronic absenteeism goal we review the data monthly a cabinet we talk about uh the cronic absm of the schools because we're losing points on that still and that's kind of hitting us if we we were at our pre- pandemic chronic ABS aism levels you would

025see those numbers jump up so we're losing a lot of points still with chronic ABS aism we're getting better but we're not quite where we should be but number uh five preparation for um College and Career Readiness and the percent of taking percent of students taking College and Career Readiness courses um and T you can go in a little bit more about what qualifies for that but pre PR pandemic we were at 60% we're at 90% last year so it's like the one area it's like forget the pre-pandemic levels we're blowing that out of the water and we can talk a little bit more about why we're getting more points in that area a lot of that had to do with opening up courses for students getting rid of the restrictions for students to be

026able to take certain courses creating uh that common program of studies throughout the district and talking more working more more closely with our high schools uh to be able to do that so this is this is a um um I I wanted to include these in the presentation because you could look at this and probably dissect it and come up with a lot of questions and I know the rest of the presentation uh will go on and I'm sure we'll have some questions about this specifically but U um I wanted to highlight that uh before before Tara continued and I'll be happy to take any questions or if the president wants me to take any now I'd be happy to do it to commissioner vanstone thank you mam president uh for the the opportunity to

027do it now because I'm not finding these two slides in our package so I I added these when I reviewed it all and so it's in the it's in the it's in the um uh it's in the virtual presentation that you will get um but I added these because when I looked through it I wanted to make sure I highlighted the growth over time for you because some of you have been here the you've seen this over time and I wanted you to see this okay but I wanted to be able to ask questions now so thank you madam president because after we see all this other data mhm yeah lots of data so let me let me stick with these for now if I may uh the first one was the line graph was

028that when you um were talking about the the largest growth of uh prek to 12s were you talking about against our own dur or was that the state of any school any school district that had schools in prek to 12 and I I qualify at that because there's some districts that have prek-5 districts there's some distri that are 612 districts there are some districts that are prek-3 districts and so when I say prek 12 districts I'm talking about any school district in the state of Connecticut serves pre- 12 commissioner van Stone just sorry the voice is over here um just to elaborate what Dr Schwarz was talking about we're talking about academic growth so right here on the screen is the overall accountability index with all 12 indicators we were talking specifically about the academic

029growth indicator which which is how much students are approving academically um Ela and math over time so we were speaking specific to that one that thank you fourth to eth grade specifically oh it's 4th to eth okay but another qualifier should also be if you look at something like a darianne who is already in the 90s something percentile if they go from 93 to 94 okay we did better than them percentage wise so we qualifiers on a lot of things now this chart um you know I I love the fact that we're challenging students to take College you know entry type courses CP courses whatever they may be called now um however 30% growth in it are are those students able to do the work I mean it's easy to put more students in the

030classroom I can but are we able to actually get some benefits yeah I mean I love challenging the students because you never know when you're going to find a diamond in a rough that can do all that work like an like an Aiden or Sinclair yeah so so I have an answer for that if you look right below that blue if you go to number six the percent of students I can't see that I know I'll read it to you so the percent of students actually passing the exam in 1819 only 12% we passing last year 23.3 so we're finding so not only are they they're taking more but they're actually doing better that's exactly what I wanted to hear thank you and that's thank you to the schools for you know making this achievement

031because that's important because we talk a lot about the negative numbers and you know I will later but that is challenging our students and finding out that students that we maybe needed a push MH are being successful and that is one of the biggest things I go after and you've heard it from me a million times the student that comes in in the morning goes home at the last bell we need to get those students engage and this is showing me that we're starting to do that thank you madam president oh I'm sorry vice president Brown okay hi thanks good evening thank you for the uh information I had a question is Reading part of ela yes reading and writing okay reading so reading is Ela okay so it seems like um we're pretty stagnant

032there if I'm looking at that line are you speaking about academic achievement yeah I mean prepandemic so we're actually down so that we haven't recovered when you look at the traditional mathematics in Eli you know where we're lagging is certainly at those the mathematics and um Ela level we are not back at pre granted we were on a good course prior to the pandemic we need to get back there now we are but we are and I know it gets a little tricky that's just how many kids are actually passing the exam if you look at how we're growing the students we're pretty close or if not better than where we were pre pandemic okay now granted students dropped after the pandemic so to grow them to your point the qualifier there is we have

033to grow them and we have to grow them fast and close the gap and so um we're we're growing them faster or just as fast as we were pre pandemic but we're not at the proficiency level where students are are acing the exam yet we're not we're not where we were pre pandemic and so you know with all the good stuff there is we are and and commissioner vanstone you've you've seen me go come come up here for almost 10 years now talk about scores there's always the other side and we recognize nobody sits back and says oh well we're doing great let's just let's relax and take our foot off the pedal and so you know we recognize where we're doing well and we like to highlight that but I also don't want anyone

034to think that we we we take that for granted and we we take our foot off the pedal in terms of the areas that we know we need to accelerate we know with the new addition of the ELA curriculum um this year too uh with the right to read Grant and uh the new additions that we have there we're really excited at what we're starting to see come out from that and look looking forward to those those bumps happening but our initial goal right now is to get to pre-pandemic levels and then we'll move from there to try to get to the state the state average thank you and I you know I I do uh do think we are moving in the right direction but when budget time comes around I really want to

035have a conversation about the resources we are putting into reading and what resources we really need to turn the curve here because we you know we are growing but but not the way we should be and if kids can't read by fifth grade I mean then then what are we doing here so I really I really would like everyone to to say okay what do we really need what kind of teachers what kind of resources what what do we really need to focus on reading because we can do all this stuff but if the kids can't read what are we doing so I'm I'm I'm very passionate about this well and I also like to point out this is the wide view the district view but we also look at these numbers by school and

036by grade level so that we can get very specific about where where we're seeing growth where we're seeing the most growth who needs the most health help as far as Ela curriculum we purchased K through2 Ela curriculum for this school year that's being rolled out now good um it will take some time to see the effect of of the new curriculum on the reading programs but we we do monitor we don't wait for the next smarter balanced assessment to see how students are doing we have internal measures uh three times a year so that we're looking at growth in both math and Ela um using assessments that are aligned with the smarter balance testing with the SAT exams and so we do monitor that all year and we did invest substantially in these reading programs

037we're really hoping to see the uh success there but I think if it's a matter of resources I think we have to look as a board at the realignment of resources because reading to me is a priority but anyway thank you sure so we're going to continue on with our district level highlight remember as Mrs fish just said we're looking at a big picture view of the entire District uh so most of those 12 indicators did improve compared to the year before uh the items that improved are listed here the overall accountability index rating improved along with academic achievement and Ela math and science so all three subject areas academic growth as Dr Schwarz was speaking about is the Improvement of students over time so we're not really looking at just that single snapshot data

038point where we see that with academic achievement but looking at how students are growing over time that improved in English language arts Ela math and even for our multilingual students their literacy assessment on the last links we also saw Improvement in chronic absenteeism where we reduce those rates College and Career Readiness coursework we are actually receiving the maximum amount of points available so enrolling those students in higher level courses and then also we saw success on College and Career Readiness exams uh referring back to what Dr Schwarz said earlier about how the state has tinkered with this formula over time they've actually are now including our dual enrollment Pass rates in this indicator so we have seen Improvement uh because they're not only looking at AP and IB which we don't have um Connecticut SAT

039but they're also now including dual enrollment p Pass rates in that indicator uh we also saw Improvement in on track in grade n towards graduation our sixe graduation rate and postsecondary entrance within one year of graduation so the vast majority of indicators did improve from the prior year we always like to look at ourselves compared to our peer counterparts uh so our Urban peer group consists of six other districts that were previously identified by the State Department of Education as District reference groups they previously grouped all of us together based on similar socioeconomic status and need so our Urban peers that we compare our results to are Bridgeport Hartford New Britain New Haven New London and Windam so we always take a look at our performance compared to our Urban peers and the next slide

040shows you where we ranked first in our group of urban peers or second so number one we were ranked first in academic growth for English language arts we ranked first for participation that's really fundamental getting all of our students to take the test we are very high in terms of participation across Ela Math and Science our on track in grade nine to graduation rates our four-year graduation rate and our six-year graduation rate so rank number one among our Urban peers then we are rank number two and the following areas the overall accountability index we are right number two to Windom we are above all of our other Urban peers academic achievement Ela and math again we are right number two behind Windom chronic absenteeism we are right number two behind New London and then physical

041fitness number two behind Windom so in all of these indicators listed here we are right number one or two among District of similar status in need moving on from big picture at the district level we do have some school highlights to present for you we had some schools with a high level of success this year first of all Wallace Middle School was removed from the state turnaround list they used to be a category five they have now moved up to a category three category one is the highest uh they are only one of three turnaround schools in the state to exit the turnaround status this past year there were 38 turnaround schools so only three exited uh congratulations also to Westside in Wilby they earned a year of credit to exiting their turnaround status to

042exit turnaround you have to have two consecutive years of progress um to meet that requirement they earned one year last year so with continued success this year they could be poised to be removed from the turnaround list next year we saw three schools kingsburry Maloney and rean who all improved from Category 3 to Category 2 we'll speak more about the categories in a moment um and part of what Dr Schwarz said before about kingsbery we also have Chase and rean who were all identified as schools of Distinction uh he also specified that we had three schools in our district whereas our Urban peers each only had one we saw Hartford had one New Britain had one and Windham had one whereas Waterberry had three the three schools who were selected for distinction it was all

043based on academic growth in ela great lot of numbers here on this chart but I'll take you through it this is how the state grouped the the schools into their categories and with the actual overall accountability index rate was on the Le hand side you see a graphical of what the categories mean so category one is the highest with schools who've earned between 855 to 100% of their points uh Waterbury did not have any category 1 schools this past cycle however we did have several schools that were in Category 2 that's schools that earned between 70% and 84.9% of the available points so you could see those schools are all highlighted up at the top they are in white uh then there's category three uh the vast majority of schools in Waterbury were category three

044uh that's earning anywhere from 0 to 69.9% of the points those are all shaded in a light gray and then they're sorted in descending order by the percentage of points earned and then finally there's category four and five we did not have any category 4 schools that were newly identified as turnaround or Focus but we do have four four schools at the bottom Westside Crosby Kennedy and Wilby who are all identified as turnaround schools however if you look towards the right hand side I start comparing these to last year so all those schools that you see a check mark next to did increase from last year and that does include three out of the four turnaround schools at the bottom so they saw improvement from the prior year the next column shows schools that improve

045d one or more categories and then finally we have our schools of Distinction to put it a different way we had 20 of our schools that had Improvement in the overall accountability index so the overall numbers were shown on the prior slide but here we're giving you the percent change from the prior year so initially up at the very top we see International their overall accountability index score for this year was 79.6% of points earned and that represented a 7.9 percentage Point increase from the prior year so I'll leave that up for a moment for you to take a look at before we move on to the next Slide m president commissioner van Stone thank you m could you just give us a a little better maybe lower down a little I didn't want to

046say dumb but Dum how the accountability index number is created what what is a little bit of the background to what that number is to help us understand what we're even looking at okay so if we go back to the beginning that broad set of indicators here so if we're looking at an element El School certain things like graduation rates would not be included um at the elementary school the primary focus is going to be academic achievement and academic growth they also have chronic absenteeism and physical fitness rolling all of those together gives them this number that you see on the screen the percentage of points earned when we get to a middle school we bring in one more component which is the on track to grade n they actually look at our middle schools

047tracking the students back to where they were in eth grade so our middle schools get some credit for where they sent students to to school in 9th grade and how successful they were the high schools have the most out of those indicators so the um the graduation rates including on track foure and six-year graduation rate plus the coursework the college and career rightness coursework in exams and the Arts access indicators so the high schools um probably have the the most amount of indicators however all all goes back to the biggest uh factor in all of these is going to be academic achievement and academic growth so some calculation in the background these indicators are weighted and and feed in to give us his final number it's just something back here that so for example academic

048performance is worth a maximum of 300 points correct we earn a certain number of points you calculate the percentage for academic performance for that one indicator academic growth is worth a maximum of 400 points you earn a certain number of points you calculate the percentage for that line and and on as it goes down okay any deeper is too much but yes thank you for that you're Jan because that really I hope it helped others too that really made a little more sense to this number for me thank you yes to put it a slightly different way um at least 50% comes from our student assessment data so academic achievement and academic growth the other indicators represent a smaller portion I'm going to move to the next slide we did have nine schools that had

049a decline in the overall accountability index from the prior year so again I will leave this up here for a moment it's read the same way uh the school uh the percentage of points they earned in the overall accountability index and the percent change from the prior year wow wow can I ask a question I'm I'm surprised that the prek to eight schools uh went down Carrington and Wendel cross because um those are pretty much brand new schools and I I could take that Jen so it's like it we kind of warned this like last year rean for example had this huge drop last year and everyone was like oh my God what's happening at Regan well Regan's Regan's on School distinction this year so just we always are a little careful on the one

050year look we like to look at it holistically when we meet with with the schools and so I wouldn't get too caught up on wow look at that big gain look at the sometimes it has to do with the class sometimes it has to do with a lot of other indicators I mean we we're presenting it to you because that's how we do it every year but we look at it over time as a line graph well it I mean it seems pretty significant to meus 21 minus 15 those are wasn't likeus 2.1 Sor thank you 21 21 would be another story 21 okay thank you yep I feel better thank you small print small print and so every year um really before this school year ends we start planning for the next year to

051we look at our data and we have Improvement plans and we have school Improvement plans for every single School some of those schools have the same indicators in common some of them zero in on certain strategies that they feel they need to work on um those plans in the associated data are monitored monthly um monitored for Fidelity adjusted as their need they need to be adjusted adjusted um we've improved our SAT and smarter balance aligned assessments um the the ones that we give three times a year as well as the ones that are embedded in the curriculum uh that that monitor the the units of study we've had a lot of success with the math 530 and Ela 480 clubs in high school those students are uh achieving better their SATs and we are continuing

052those programs we've implemented curriculum implementation walks we can spend a lot of money on new programs in writing curriculum but if we're not implementing that curriculum with Fidelity we don't know if it's effective or if we need to change it and so that's one of the pieces we have to look at to see if if it's effective and and going to help instruction um we administer professional learning on highly effective instructional strategies and that's being implemented at all schools we we're now working with Dr Cormier in all of waterburry schools not just the turnaround schools and so we have um three three levels three groups you know from um schools that have been working with him for four years to to two years to the first year and so we'll be continuing that and we're

053looking at our um Data Systems to see how we can pull data more effectively and break it down into different subgroups and so we're always looking to improve we're trying to celebrate our wins and I think we had some nice wins this year and we have to acknowledge the hard work of our our teachers and our and our principles but we're never satisfied we know we have a lot more work to do and um we just roll up our sleeves and and just keep at it every year are there any more questions commissioner van Stone big surprise thank you m president through you um yes Improvement and I I do want to give the teachers that worked on the curriculum for our new Ela program and also uh how they're implementing Dr mortonson's Dream curriculum

054I get the drop dea's name um that and just for the rest of the board to understand especially uh you know vice president Brown's question this new curriculum is carrying our uh language arts over all courses and it's developed into so that you uh implement it as well in say math he told me and and other courses so it's it's taken a much more Global look at our education than we did before it's not kind of like Ela in a bubble it's Ela across our district and it's I'm really looking forward to the changes there I think that's going to be a significant mover for us so I just wanted to make sure I gave credit to because I did visit the teachers during the summer who were writing rewriting the curriculum it's off the-shelf

055curriculum however we did do some changes to it to implement it in our school distri district and I really like to thank those teachers that did that and the teachers that are working with it now my feedback has been it's been very accepted and teachers are looking forward to implemen that in all our classes so um and still though these numbers I'm one thing and I wrote it down I've been critical uh on a lot of it but I I never celebrated being in like third place in our Durk I guess we have a new name I have to get used to but uh I'll call it D for a while so um but seeing that we are now positioning in first and second place in these categories um I'm very happy about that because

056uh there's there's been years where we celebrated moving from 4th to 3D and I did not celebrate we needed to do better and obviously we did uh the only one well I disappoint is too big of a word for when I look at this data it it's a little disappointment but I know we're working hard and I I want to see it continue uh but I am a little uh discouraged that whams is a category three it's from your uh School assignment chart that is a school that we interview and hand select our students we should not be a category 3 on a school that that's how we select the students that is an academy and that school jumped out at and it really needs to do better did you mean Career Academy Williams is

057a two oh I'm sorry career so sorry Williams is doing yeah Williams is fine sorry about that thank you for the question and you know what just just to let you know when you see this here um the cut score for a um Category 2 is a 70 they had with rounding it would have been a 70 but it was a 69. uh 98 I believe so they were very close I actually inquir with the State Department of Education cuz their official report says 70 but the actual score was just below so they were really close to being a category 2 makes me feel that much better okay so that's that's the one that jumped out at me I know that some of the others you know we've been working hard with Washington has had

058a couple good years going back and uh you know they're hanging in there but um you know I think they were distinguished last year if I'm not mistaken Washington um there when I was talking about implementation strategies I had a little note here that I wanted to mention and I forgot um there there was some talk about a third grade only being 19% proficient oh yes that class was a fourth grade class last year and focusing on small group instruction at the elementary schools and it it's not not a match cohort it's it's a rough cohort 23.9% of those students were proficient in fourth grade and so by implementing those strategies and really working on individualized instruction and and small group we we are getting those children to move because we know it's critical the

059younger they are to get them caught up so yeah we're we didn't really in this presentation there's so much we didn't really go into the grade level stuff too much and you know from from all the years we've been doing this together that my concern is always fifth grade mhm that is the grade for whatever reason worries me because it is such a big jump after they leave fifth grade that they have to be so prepared um so and again we didn't get into the individual grades but I will look forward to seeing that data uh by the grades all right um better but you know um I hope this uh Ela curriculum helps us I think it will I'm very very confident it will and um and I I agree with Dr Schwarz we

060can't look at only one year we do have to look at a pattern um and patterns do tell us something and but a pattern really needs to go with the grades right if you you can't say fifth grade is doing better because those students are now sixth graders you know that so we have to keep an eye on that too all right thank you thank you ladies thank you I personally to the two student representatives and I did not introduce them although everyone has been acknowledging them I I want to acknowledge them now uh I have aen Mai who's uh in the 11th grade and Sinclair Hudson who's in the 12th grade and they both go to Crosby High School um and their principles are here as well awesome Shan mosle Shan Mosley and Mr

061ver Baker Verno I don't want to mess it up but I did anyway and who else that's it okay so welcome is there anything you'd like to say before I move on um no just I'm happy to be here with all of you and I look forward to see what's going on in the district from now and moving forward thank very good thank you thank you for that Sinclair okay moving on request approval now of the 2025 26 school year [Music] calendar good evening president Hernandez vice president Brown Board of Education Commissioners Board of education student representatives and interim superintendent Dr Schwarz I'm here this evening with a uh our proposed 2025 2026 school calendar um there have been several meetings uh regarding this uh between uh myself Mr zuda Mr Barry certainly Dr Schwarz

062uh we did meet with WTA we did meet with saw we met with WTA president Mr rean saw president Mr Johnston um and there was a consensus over over this we had some great conversations on how to handle some specific dates but this is what uh was agreed upon in the end um if I can give you some of the highlights uh early dismissal professional development days there are nine in the calendar full day professional development there are five there are 25 holiday days and recess days throughout the year the first day of school is August 25th which is the one day earlier than this year but still a Monday uh winter recess uh begins December 24th and ends Wednesday December 24th and ends Monday January 1st uh the spring break is uh April 3

063through April 10 April 3 is good Friday so it's a continuation of Good Friday and then the following week there are uh at this time June 10th is the last day June 10 2026 and it's 181 school days um we did look the always the uh topic of conversation is when do we put the spring break in uh we did follow other looked at other school districts in the area some had theirs uh published some did not yet but I'll give you the ones that have and how they uh match with us wlit is the same week uh region 15 is the 13th through the 17th region 15 being middleberry and southberry Meridan 13th through the 17th nog tuck did not publish their calendar yet Watertown did not publish their calendar yet region 16 which

064is Prospect which is Woodland Prospect uh is the same as ours the third the second through the 10th if you will um Eid is March 20th 2026 um rashash Shana September 22nd yam Kapur October 1st both 2025 any questions any questions thank you Mr Alini thank [Music] you item number four update on Chromebook policy and procedure Mr zuda good to see you good to see you too good evening president Hernandez vice president Brown Commissioners student Representatives Dr Schwartz um tonight I'm here to talk to you about revamping the why we revamped the Chromebook distribution in our schools um it really was to improve efficiency sustainability and access this is pretty much a PowerPoint of the memo that you guys received just so with some other talking points that was in your packet um why why

065the change um the issues were previous Chromebook management was unsustainable leading to in inefficiencies and high costs a lot of the problem areas were significant damage loss and theft of devices which led to inequitable access to technology and you can see by the picture that's just a bunch of devices that have been damage at schools that have been dropped off for students to for our team to correct and fix and see if we can put them back out if you see some of these pictures here these are some of the devices that we're getting uh you see the damage that's coming in on these devices um if we could fix them we're fixing them we're part them back into production um here's a picture of our interns working on these devices so the interns Have

066Been instrumental in getting the devices fixed and back into production um these guys come in after school on weekends um and they've been really great we're trying to teach them life skills getting ready for the workforce they're learning about how to fix Chromebooks they're learning how to use the Google um ecosystem they're learning um how to manage School environment they're going out with the tax they're learning how to do inventory and auditing so we're trying to give them some real life skills give them a real skill set to be available to jump into the workforce so um it's been really great It's Been instrumental um all right so here here's the real deal right so this is the financial impact on device management and device laws when you look at over the last four years

067I mean these are staggering numbers on and the reason why we had to make some changes and we had to make some changes fast you look at the damage Beyond repair these are devices that have been damaged and cannot be repaired no matter what we do to them we cannot put them back in production that's about $2.5 Million worth of damage devices laws are reported stolen $ 8,433 over the last four years almost $3.5 million that's $6 million in damage Beyond repair and loss and stol in devices then you look at damaged screens damaged keyboards damaged housing and damaged other and we put a price tag to them and that's just the repair cost of we bought the part and our in turns are fixing these that's about 500,000 if we couldn't fix those that's

068another $2 million worth of damage devices that we wouldn't have for devices or we would have to come up with to get these back into production these numbers are staggering and it's the one the main reason why when we started this process we've been looking at it over the last few years that we had to make a change and we had to make a change fast all right so the key takeaways of this new strategy is just pretty much to optimize device management we're talking about streamlining this process we're talking about accountability now you know all these devices are assigned to a classroom they're assigned to a school member these devices must remain in that classroom or office these students that need a device or uh are given a loaner device from the media center

069and they must return that device by the next day this ensures Equity that all students have access to technology and at the end of the day it's cost Effectiveness by reducing damage loss of repair and replace replacement costs real simple why why we did this new process it's really a shift from Individual Student Assignment to the classroom school-based distribution bottom line that's that that's the major change that happened um here's a timeline quickly of of the implementation in April of 2024 the tech committee came back after you know multiple meetings we talked about the process we were looking at the numbers looking at what we had to do we came up with some recommendations we presented them to the superintendent and cabinet cabinet and superintendent agree that these changes were necessary uh we sent a

070temp then we developed a template that we sent out to schools and families informing them of the change and why were're changing um that that went out in April in May and June we started collecting and reassigning for the elementary middle and prek to 8s um these devices were collected they had to be repaired they had to be refurbished had to be and then put put into the classrooms and be ready for end ofe testing and the next school year and they were locked in and they were assigned to those classrooms for inventory and audited purposes the high schools different story we really could not do much with the high schools just because of the fact that they still had end of your testing going on um they had take final exams um collecting them

071would have definitely impacted the learning environment so we we we could not do it dur at the end of the school year for the high schools just because of that we could there's no way they test till the last day of school versus the elementary and the middle schools they were their testing schedule was done early June so we were able to start collecting as the different grades were done testing getting these devices in and getting them ready for Back to throw back out into production um and then July 2024 the high schools were asked for to start their device collection and they they started calling families and through parents Square notifying them that these devices had to be returned and we were collect them so we can look at them evaluate them and get

072them ready for the start of school year we did have to pause the high school collection because we had the Y roll out we so we didn't want to confuse anybody you know doing a y roll out in a Chromebook collection so we did a little pause for about a week or two in beginning of the school year but then we started we picked it back up by the end of September all the high school devices had been assessed all the devices that were collected we were able to refurbish repair get back into production put into the classrooms Chromebooks were distributed to all core classrooms Chromebook laner program was implemented detailed instructions provided to the schools how to loan them out and what the process was and how the media center is going to check

073these devices in and check them out um in October and November of 2024 we met with the high school Iden IFI devices that were needs per room um these were pretty much a Target not the core classrooms now we're looking at you know unified art elective courses um and then by November we did a complete audit of what we put in there to identify how many devices were missing and how many devices so after the complete audit there was about 2,000 devices that we couldn't find but that was just we couldn't find because they were taking out of classroom put in another classroom so we were able to you know rescan those classrooms find the devices get them back to where they were rescan them back into that through the audit process and make sure

074that these devices were still in the building you know at this point I showed you that number I think we're at 700 still that we still can't account for but you know so the accountability is the most important piece for us and we need to make sure that these devices stay in that classroom and if there are checked out that a student takes one out of the media center out of the laner program not from a classroom so that's the most important thing we're trying to drive home with this whole new strategy change so the long-term objectives it's pretty much simple it's really to reduce costs to decrease the replacement repair of expenses reduce the number of loss or stolen Chromebooks reduce the number of damag Chromebooks sustainability which means less waste more durable use

075of resources Equity is consistent access to technology in the district right um so that's the most important thing we have some challenges and we're going to have to make some adjustments um the high school roll out like I said the delays were because of the end of the Academic Year um and the policy and the Yonder bag roll out but we're doing a biannual reconciliation now so we're auditing each classroom to ensure that devices are in working order that any any damage is identified any missing devices are all counted for you know we're asking the schools and the staff to be accountable for this to ensure that students don't damage or take devices from the classroom we're able to now with our new um Inventory management system um kind of provide a report to schools

076so when we did the audit of the schools we send a report to the school saying these are the devices that are missing your school these are the number of devices that were damaged and they can look at it by teacher to make sure that if it's a classroom management issue or what was going on so they can identify that the the the teachers and staff that they need to talk to to make sure these devices in the classrooms are not being damaged or not being taken out of the classroom and um and they're accounted for and then you know and that the other important challenge is going to be making sure that that laner program is working because it's important that kids who don't have a device can take a device home still but

077it's got to be checked out and checked back in okay that's only way we can have accountability in this whole process it's it's really hard to manage I mean I think to this day I mean there's 28,000 devices that we had to repair over the last four years you know 11,000 something repairs just last year alone you know it's a lot it's a lot of work it's a lot of Manpower um future steps feedback collection really talk to schools talk to teachers gauge the effectiveness of this program if it needs to be monitored or adjusted to refine the process you know that's what that supposed to be right that feedback collection and then that biannual review at least twice a year sit down talk to the necessary stakeholders ensure that this um you know the

078process that we have in place is working and review the audit to make sure that these devices are in there and address any concerns that we can address in conclusion just pretty much this is a transition from Individual classroom based Chromebook distribution because it's necessary right the evolution the district's technology management strategy and you know and the commitments got to be that ongoing dedication to adapt and refine the technology management to serve the operational needs in the community better um went through it really quick I know you guys are but I have any I'm here thank you for listening and um answer any questions commissioner Arling I do yes um I have maybe two or three questions sure um and to ask out in the public um because this is now happening with the new

079loaner with the Chromebooks can a student bring their own laptop or Chromebook they' always had the ability to yes they can yes correct right y okay and the second question is uh for the loners that are being taken out are they being sanitized I I'd lie to you i' give you an answer they they should be but I I I don't know you know what I mean so um you know it's it's like checking out a book or checking out a book it's the same process you know kid comes into the media center sends into Chromebook device is taken from the Chromebook cart it's scanned it's assigned to that student student takes it home and then when it comes back they're supposed to inspect it make sure there's no physical the damage in the device

080is still working and then just one more question we invested during Co and you know not to think anything negative but will are we prepared for another pandemic if something was to happen with the electronics will we be prepared with our students currently we are and we have about 4,000 in inventory still but the issue is sustainability if you know if you look at the number of devices that get damaged in a given year at the end of this year if we don't have any inventory and we continue on the same trajectory we will not have enough devices for beginning end of year or any type of testing so it's really key that we monitor this with Fidelity and ensure that these devices are not damaged and that we're holding people accountable for it because

081there I have a zero dollar budget to be able to replace these and it's expensive I we spent I think $200,000 just on Chargers over over through eser that we were able to afford those that money is gone that money is no longer available how do we sustain this program how do we ensure that we have online curriculum we have all class work is done online um testing is done online assignments have to be done online so um and this is the reason why the strategy change took place and I saw that the uh teachers aren't asking for any news so it looks like the students are all prepared or they have their laptops to do their work during the day correct every classroom has them uh we've asked I've s out multiple we've met

082with um administrators with Dr Schwarz has organized that meeting multiple times and we have had no requests so far so and anybody we still get a couple requests now that they're saying you know oh this classroom might need it so that's fine we have plenty of inventory we'll give it to them you know so um you know I'm not trying to be the gatekeeper I just want to make sure that we have enough devices and I want to bring to everybody's attention the challenges that we have so everybody understands what's happening in the school district so you I don't want to be anybody to be blindsided when I come back to you and say that we don't have enough devices okay thank you you're welcome and if I may thank you commissioner Ireland great questions

083you know it was a little bumpy in the beginning uh but our high school student students our student advisory council did speak up um they did talk about some classes uh Mr zuda has done a great job communicating with principes principales getting back to him working I know even Crosby and uh Mr Vero and and and Mr zud have been working together closely on trying to make it more sustainable operations in high schools and so um Miss scp's been working with them as well so again we'll keep putting it out there if they need it in a classroom Mr zo is ready to get it in there some of the laner programs I've heard you know some some are more advanced than others right now so we're looking on making that a little bit more

084efficient as well but we'll continue refining this uh to so that in the end we want students to be able to access devices during the day and have a laner program so that they could take it home do their AP classes EC courses or any other course and to do that uh uh and to to function like this over the next few years um you know as we get to budget season we have to think of that thank you any other questions because Dr Schwarz took what I was going to say oh sorry thank you Mr zuda thank you have a great night everyone that'll work huh wait we are going to go into a 10-minute recess take starting out take a vote no no good we're recess for 10 minutes grab a coffee e

085e [Music] I [Music] [Applause] [Music] we are going to go into the special meeting right now oh okay good evening today is Thursday December the 5th this is a special meeting of the Waterberry Board of Education silent prayer Sinclair can you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge to the flag of the United States of America and to the rep for it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all vice president Brown here commissioner Ireland here commissioner Jackson commissioner obri commissioner Oro commissioner Sano adoro commissioner vanstone present president Hernandez here mayor perar rusi here you have form okay Madame President I request that items 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 and 4.7 be removed from the consent calendar so order commissioner orsel 4.1 item 4.1 I move to approve Amendment

086one to the Construction contract with action ear Systems Incorporated RFP 7804 for HVAC Replacements at Wilby high school and North End Middle School second all in favor I oppose discussion discussion please I'm sorry discussion commissioner van Stone thank you madam president through you how can we do this how can we do this they're on the agenda that we're going to go back to in our Workshop that I have a million questions on and now we're going to bump it to a special meeting and vote on it before we talk about it in our Workshop Mr Alini is here to answer any question you have so what do we so what are we just going to skip them when we go back to the reg to the workshop we're going to remove them from the workshop

087agenda that's never been done in my 11 years that we do a special meeting for items that are in a workshop the special meeting maybe should have been held at the end of the workshop attorney Britton could you please answer commissioner van Stone's questions thank you thank you madam president um commissioner what we're doing right now is essentially you're having the discussion so by removing them from consent it's allowing you the opportunity to ask the questions that you would have asked you're tell work told I know but I'm telling you that by virtue of Robert's Rules it it is permissible I'm not saying it's not permissible but the reason we have workshops is to work through the items before the voted on again if this was at the end of the night I would be

088fine but it's not and I have a ton of questions I also was under the impression that people from these companies were going to be here tonight and now you have to sit here and speak for all of them where are all where are the people that are ripping us off by continually asking for amendments for more money and more time where are they there's no way we should be voting on this tonight and I will be voting no on every single item this is just totally I don't even know what to call it don't even know what to call it because every single one of these items I have serious questions for the contractors they just keep coming back and asking for more time one of them is because they didn't order their parts

089in time but we gave them more time two months ago to do that and more money this is out of control out of control no way to run a business I don't have to speak on the others because I think you know what I I'm thinking this is absolutely out of control [Music] good evening president excuse me mayor perar rusi president Hernandez vice president Brown Board of Education Commissioners Board of Education student representative and interim superintendent Dr Schwarz I'm here this evening um uh the education department respectfully request your review and approval of amendment one to the Construction contract to complete repl placement of hbac equipment at wiby high school and north and middle school with action a systems there was a long lead time on uh some of the equipment uh the um project

090is completed essentially uh but it was not completed in time for the air conditioning component to be turned on the heating component over the winter is functioning and that's been able to be inspected commissioned uh startup uh gone through the project and the problems uh whenever you put in a big unit like that but we haven't been able to um test the air conditioning component so we're waiting for the warm weather that's why we're asking for June 1st 2025 so we can test the air conditioning component of the system um there's not an added cost here we are holding money as a retainage as we do with all the projects until full satisfaction that the job is completed and functioning properly um and warranty is in in place and the architect signs off um and

091the city signs off as well as the contractor so that's what we're waiting for on this particular project with action a at willby high school and Northend Middle School commissioner Orel Nick does the warranty start June if we approve this the warranties do they start in June after the completion or does it start now we want them to go as late as possible so we want it to start at the end not in the middle because the full system has to be on so that's what asking for the warranty to begin okay at the end at the end okay at the end sometimes and we fought the contractors and this was one of the points to commissioner van Stone's uh concern and rightfully so one of them tried to have the warranty start on the

092delivery of the equipment the architect and the city did not accept that uh partway through they wanted us to accept it we're not accepting that it has to be something that we can have our full year of warranty on it even the heating portion of it Nick I'm sorry even the heating portion of it when it's working out correct yeah because one may affect the other [Music] okay Mr Alini if we don't vote on this tonight what does that do that means that contract will end December 31st uh we wouldn't have any way of guaranteeing that the product is ready for air conditioning so if there is an issue we're paid in full and we don't want to do that we want to retain money sometimes it's 355,000 sometimes it's 100,000 depending on on what

093is left um so we would have to finalize the contract if we want them to come back we'd have to enter into another contract and that's more money for us it could be uh not necessarily but it could be more money but they can't do any work on the they wouldn't have a contract with us we wouldn't want them on our property we wouldn't have their Certificate of Insurance so we're just looking for an extension of time to make sure that they will come back and finish their job and then we could pay them in full we always keep retainage we don't pay in full and then wait for them to come back we are holding money so right now we're holding money correct and they're asking for an extension correct until well because the

094contract is going to end and we won't be done before then so we're asking for the extension okay [Music] any more discussion all in favor I oppose no motion carries commissioner Orso item 4.2 ladies and gentlemen I move to approve Amendment one to the Construction contract with all state construction RFP 7859 for mechanical UPG grades at multiple School gymnasiums and cafeterias second [Music] discussion if if I may as well um this one and the next one were a little different we had an added component for a challenge and that's and not disparagingly but eversource you can't guarantee your Transformers even though they may have 13 on the shelf for us they won't promise them to you they'll only give them to the people whose job is ready so you can't schedule that ahead of time

095we had a schedule for telephone pole uh um installation at all these units at all these schools so that slowed a lot of this down um but that was just an added challenge with with the eversource this was this was an eversource added [Music] layer there there if I may as well uh we don't always we don't always Grant an extension or a missed item with a contractor um for instance uh they'll come to us and say we need 10,000 50,000 to do this and we have and we did this with the auditoriums you missed it that's part of the contract you should have had it in your quote and they've had to go with that so we don't just always oblige what they're asking for our Architects work for us our project manager works

096for us and they evaluate whether it's a mistake on their part or something that is unforeseen uh for instance on the Doug and Gill Martin and you'll see that later on here we're getting back $200,000 because of something they missed uh at State Street um we're getting back $35,000 on something that uh was a good product we didn't have to change it we're bringing back 35,000 to the city so there are times when we don't give the contract contracted what they're looking for and when we have money coming back we put it back into our funds all in favor I oppos no motion carries item 4.3 I move to approve Amendment two to the Construction contract at all state construction RFP 7 894 for H fact Replacements at seven elementary schools bunler Hill International School

097kingsbery rean spray Washington and Wilson second discussion Mr Albini this was the um he second half of the elementary school cooling centers that we're putting in heating Heating and Cooling centers we call them cooling centers but they're Heating and Cooling centers uh there was uh six schools and seven schools so this was coordination with the architect the contractor eversource electricians um and this is the same as the last one all in favor I oppose motion carries commissioner or item 4.4 ladies and gentlemen I move to approve Amendment Three excuse me to the Construction contract with all state Construction LLC RFP 7497 for HVAC upgrades Replacements at gil Martin and dougen elementary schools second discussion Mr Albini these two uh schools had uh hbac upgrades and I had mentioned earlier the dug in we're returning two

098$200,000 back because that contractor had missed something with the electrical so we're getting 200,000 back to us um and this is just for again commissioning in the in April May uh so that we can verify that the air conditioning is working [Music] properly I commissioner Ora I just want to clarify something what every everybody too Nick correct me if I'm wrong in my other job or my other life when I was here before when there was change orders and and things like this it wasn't a one person making up the decision it was always a committee uh School inspector's office The Architects um so that still continues correct it's not just okay I'm going to take this or not take that correct it it will be the architect depending and there's different Architects with different

099projects the architect will be involved the project manager will be involved uh School inspector I will be involved and and some things will sit well with some and some won't uh and it it could come as down as far as well we want to work Saturday and we may say we don't want you to work Saturday uh that's overtime for our maintainers if you miss something you should be paying for the the overtime on that so we do negotiate thanks for Mr Al beanie so you said we were getting like $200,000 back now is that Esser money or it'll come back into the general fund general fund okay thank you MH oh it was aser but it's coming back we have expended all of our Esser funds so that's coming back okay for both Mrs

100biolo was very strategic with the yeser to make sure we didn't leave anything on a table which this would have been a perfect example of leaving it all there then not spending the 200 and now we'll lose it because time has expired so we strategically used it all commissioner Arling Mr Albini is that for both 200,000 and the 35,000 correct correct and others as well those were just two that come to mind but correct there out of the 89.7 million there was not $1 left yeah it's completely spent [Music] during capital capital capital yeah it would go back to the capital account okay forgot where I was all in favor I oppos no motion carries commissioner Oro senior moment I forgot which one I read here iot where I was at too 4.5 okay thank

101you good item 4.5 I move to approve Amendment two to the Construction contract with Ferguson mechanical Company Incorporated for certain mechanical upgrades to Waterberry Arts Magnet School and the palace [Music] oh second discussion Mr Alini this is again this again is the commissioning of the aond conditioning component for whams all in favor I oppose no motion carries commissioner or item 4.6 ladies and gentlemen I move to approve Amendment one to the Construction contract with Ferguson mechanical RFP 7858 for HVAC replacement at johnf Kennedy High School second discussion this this is also for commissioning but there's also added construction this was a late project um certainly a lot of problems with this um structural walls the penthouse the fan rooms uh the pool slab U so this this will this will entail a little bit more

102work but uh this will be completed by June 1st as well all in favor I oppose no motion carries commissioner Orel item 4.7 I move to approve Amendment two to the Construction contract with srao Mechanical Services Inc for HVAC Replacements at Crosby High School and Wallace Middle School second discussion commissioner van Stone thank you madam president I said I wasn't going to talk but I am I just want to let everyone know that the base contract dollars for the items on tonight's agenda base is uh $40 million that were spent in here the other amendments that we have made to these uh eight items seven items whatever it is uh in previous amendments we had we've granted almost 10 million additional dollars for various things in many of that is for things that I don't

103feel we should uh then late POS of course then prices go up that's not our problem when they can't get another company to do something and it stops them from work that's not our problem but you know what we have approved in the past to make it our problem and if we continue and I'm glad the mayor's here tonight to write contracts to allow contractors to take advantage of us in these particular ways we are wasting taxpayer dollars and it needs to stop it needs to stop because we just keep approving these and approving these and approving these when it's a contractor's fault on many of these not tonight because it's just schedule and we say just schedule schedule's money whe whether it's actual dollars or not schedule means money that's how it works and

104the fact that we just keep passing these on and passing these on and giving these contractors more money is is a disgrace and it and it needs a stop we need to learn how to write contracts so that people realize we're the customer on these contracts right now we're basically just giving away money to these contractors because the way the contracts are written they have a gun to our head and it needs to stop we're talking millions and millions of dollars I don't care if it is grant money it's still taxpayer money and it needs to stop thank [Music] you madam president by um mayor piski thank you uh first I'd like to thank you all for accomodating my schedule and I understand commissioner Vance Stone your frustration at not having the workshop first but

105uh I was able to get here to make the Quorum and because of my schedule they decided to go at 700 it was the right time so I appreciate that having said that I am disappointed that we have so many Commissioners missing from the meeting tonight and that there seems to be I know there's just some issue that's going on I think we're going to have to address it going forward on the idea of what it takes to be a member of a board especially one as important as the board of education but um again thank you for accommodating my schedule this evening with respect to this I just want to say this we we do a lot of construction contracts education and otherwise throughout the city and I understand there's always a great deal

106of frustration when there are change orders and additional costs um but we look at these things for the most part not for the most part in every case very carefully our Corporation Council is very serious about looking at these things and they look at the totality of the circumstances and there are just times when you're doing bidding contracts where it's not possible to get everything into the contract and there are changes that occur over time issues that have happened there are there are supply chain issues now that are occurring many that are outside the contractor's control and in those cases we look at it and decide what's the best thing to do is as far as uh pursuing the case trying the case and settling the case and in most cases the recommendation to settle

107is after a full analysis that says the risk of not settling is greater than the risk of of dealing with what you're doing so they're not done halfhazard um our lawyers the corporation council's office right now does a terrific job when they need outside help they go to outside lawyers and make that work um and these things are done very very seriously unfortunately throughout these kind of projects things occur that drive the costs up a little bit but they're not necessarily improper it's just that people didn't understand what all of the circumstances were when they started doing this and biders are often in a difficult position bidding and they don't always have all of the information that they might otherwise have until they actually start the project but I I go through this on the

108board of alderman as well with with these issues of change orders and I just want to say we're not just giving away money to avoid trying the cases we do do an analysis I meet with the corporation Counsel on most of these cases as far as the settlements go and it it really is the best advice that they can give us having practiced law for 37 years I can tell you sometimes it's better to settle than take the risk of moving forward on these issues because it is very likely that you're going to pay more as as as a result of going forward that way so I just want to make that clear without you know I know there's a number of them here tonight but I do want to say we do take them

109very seriously as part of the process thank you and if I may as well sometimes some of these proposed change orders these PCOS sometimes they're initiated by us that we're doing a specific job and we say we have a chance of doing another room making an improvement enhancing something and we will go with it because we have the contractors there give us a price let's take a look at it and we may do more and it happened with the auditoriums uh those auditoriums were not supposed to be as elaborate as they ended up but as we were going through it you want to not change this after spending this so we added that change so sometimes they are initiated by us if we're trying to enhance something I will admit any further discussion all in

110favor I oppose motion carries commissioner Ireland thank you Mr Alini thank you I moov to convene into executive session for a discussion concerning the appointment employment performance evaluation health or dismissal of a public officer or employee second we are now in an executive [Music] session please go into EX [Laughter] I would like to have D Dr Schwarz go into executive session [Music] okay commissioner arand motion to return to the regular order of business with the record reflecting there were no votes taken second can I have a motion to adjourn motion to adjourn second all in favor I oppose we are adjourned from the special meeting [Music] oh I go back to we are returning from Recess to our regular meeting Workshop I'm sorry number five no motion can I motion no Madam president I move

111to remove items 11 through 17 from the agenda second discussion [Music] all in favor I I oppose no motion carries I I know all right number five you didn't do those okay number five number five five request approval of the educational specifications Mr Alini no can't good evening thank you I'm here respectfully requesting approval for uh [Music] elevators we don't have a quum if he leaves we don't have a Corum this is ridiculous this is ridiculous hold on Mr [Music] Alini I think he thought there was no more vots he could [Music] go I told I told him he had St you e course Mr Albini thank you I'm here respectfully requesting approval for uh four elevators in the city Driggs elementary generali elementary Tinker Elementary and Wilson Elementary discussion thank you Mr Alini item

112number six request approval of Rotella interm interdistrict magnet schools operation plan Mr Johnson Dr Johnson good evening president Hernandez vice president Brown uh good evening board Commissioners student representative and interim superintendent Dr Schwarz on behalf of the rella interdistrict madting school I respectively submit the latest draft magnet schools operation plan that will be submitted to the state department of education's office of strategic planning and partnership the operations plan which is completed every 5 years is a co-constructed comprehensive document that articulates Rell School design admissions process academic programs and organizational structures just to name a few pending updates and input from the board the final document will be submitted to you and sub subsequently filed with the state department I'll field any questions or concerns you have any questions it's a few updates I know that

113you've been given I just want to thank Dr Johnson and the team at Rotella you put a lot of hard work this is a very big document I so appreciate all the work you've done on this good so would I thank you thank you no questions item number seven FYI job specifications for the new position of district attendance coordinator Jean I a even going to try you last night uh good evening uh distinguished members of the Board of Education Dr Schwarz uh we are bringing forward a position that was brought to the uh Personnel subcommittee of the board on November 4th and for your consideration to the full board it is a district attendance coordinator it would report to the chief academic office uh as part of your initiative that you have brought forward to

114focus as Dr Schwarz mentioned earlier tonight on district attendance that he's already doing at the cabinent level uh this position is designed to coordinate and monitor uh various data and also coordinate efforts on a training level across the district in order to enhance our efforts to improve uh attendance across the district I'm happy to answer questions I should also add it is a grant-funded position at $85,000 and we should thank thank uh um Chief academic officer Jan fenis for really being a driving force and bringing this job description before you any questions commissioner Arland do we know how long the grant is for for this position it is a one-year Grant any other questions thank you thank you item number eight propose revisions to policy number 5114 discipline School climate policy Miss Johns good evening

115president Hernandez vice president Brown Board of AD Commissioners student representative and interim superintendent Dr Schwartz uh tonight I will briefly be uh presenting the proposed changes uh to our current board policy uh 5114 which is titled discipline in school climate um at the October board policy committee meeting the Commissioners asked for this to be discussed at workshop for the proposed revisions this was aligned and we're trying to align to the recommendations that were provided by Cab in their July 29 2024 brief something to consider they're asking us to condense our policies um because both policies are aligned in subsequent legislation which is in that third bullet the Public Act 2445 which is an act concerning education mandate relief School discipline and disconnected youth as part of the legislation alignment uh section 13 specifically uh reduces

116the maximum number of consecutive days for in school suspensions from 10 to 5 and then section 14 is for out of school suspensions from preschool to grade two and it shortens the maximum out of school suspensions for these for the year from 10 days to five in the C recommendations they specifically outlined refined definitions and those definitions are not listed for you but are in the board backup for your review um exclusion removal in school suspension so no more than five consecutive days there's also clarifying language on suspensions for grades 3 through 12 as well as prek through 2 and there's also clarifying language on expulsion specifically the suspension definition has been extended all suspensions must start as in school in grades 3- 12 unless and this is an either or for these bullets um

117a student poses such a danger to persons or property or such a disruption to the educational process they can be excluded or based on evidence from previous discipline that we have evidence of and Administration has already addressed those disciplinary issues through interventions which are documented suspensions and grades prek through two can be OSS so out of school suspension if the student in those grades is violent or there's some sort of sexual nature beyond the discipline however as part of this um section 14 it specifically outlines that we as Board of Education staff members are still mandatory reporters there's specific criteria for how administrators may or may not sanction and that as I review uh previously it has to start with ISS in school suspension there's also verbiage about providing trauma-based resources to students so if

118we are excluding students from school we must document our referral attempts to our outside providers for mental health resources or our current contracted employees that we have in our buildings for mental health clinicians for students that have a 504 plan or an IEP we have to be meeting frequently on ongoing concerns and making changes to those plans and as part of this sanctioning we have to notify parents within 24 hours and we have to document that class work was provided as part of the um recommendations from cab there's also additional definitions which is part of your board backup for review and all of the different definitions and new names are listed for you finally as part of the revisions proposed revisions um the removal from class was specifically outlined so there has to be notification

119from the school principal and documentation of the ongoing behaviors and what we're doing to address them so that needs to be provided to parents teachers also have extended rights through this new um recommendation from cab for the board policy revisions they can request a meeting of the crisis intervention team when a student has challenging behavior in the classroom I'm happy to take any questions that you may have commissioner arand yes just one question for the uh redefined definitions suspension grades 3 through 12 not to exceed 10 days now does that mean the student can still get up to nine days or is there a certain I'm on yes so basically once we get to 10 um there's certain things that have to happen as part of the revised policy to support the students but students

120can have up to 10 okay thank you a question commissioner van Stone and then vice president Brown thank you m president through you thank you for the presentation um and I like when it's just to the point and we have our backup information so thank you for that no problem um the page and I think the way I heard it I'm very happy is uh you gave that either or situation for the suspensions yes and you were talking about Progressive Behavior how it could be taken into account that that's a that's a real change that uh we didn't necessarily do that and I'm very happy that we've made that change because I think it's important because I'm always one to sit here to say I'm concerned about the students that may have been affected by

121the behavior that may cause them to not come to school tomorrow or just throw them off course so I'm very happy that Progressive behavior is being looked at in this either or situation so thank you correct thank [Music] you okay okay good evening Wendy thank you uh for the presentation and I know in our discussion at the committee meeting uh there were other issues that we we brought up in terms of the capacity of our schools to deal with these changes correct and I'm wondering if you can comment tonight if we'd have to if we had to make any significant changes to accommodate the shorten length or the fact that you know now they have to have in school suspension I mean I I just wanted to know what the impact uh on you know

122the Staffing and the school culture so what our administrative teams in our principal meeting in October were provided professional development on not only restorative practices which is part of this legislation as well um but also the fact that every school by the end of this school year will have to establish what's called a school climate team as part of the legislation so they are already documenting who is on that team and best practices dictate that we should be meeting monthly anyway to review students that are receiving interventions in our building what some principles and assistant principles have been doing is empowering staff at their building that may have not done this type of work in the past by allowing them to attend professional development or view asynchronous recordings which are provided through my office and

123others great thank you are there any other questions thank you Miss Johns number nine request approval of the re revised tuition rate schedule this one's a good miss Bello and Miss Johns good evening again uh president Hernandez vice president Brown board members student representative and Dr Schwarz uh Wendy and I are here tonight to um discuss an increase in tuition charged by Waterbury schools for special education costs to other towns um9 it has been quite a while since we have ever increased these rates um and as we get costs that we have to pay out we realize that other towns I mean probably I mean it's probably a good what 30 40% more than probably us so we feel it's time that we um are more comparable to other towns um for the rates that

124we send out so this is what the proposal is and I can have Wendy if you need to um go through um the spe the services and the [Music] rates if I may to jump in I think we we have the rates there I just I do think this is something uh that would need to occur should occur every August and we should come to the board every August and not wait 5 10 even more years to raise our rates every other District does it we're getting 15 years maybe since the last time we've raised it so we are providing services for at a very steep discount and um I want to thank Wendy's team and dorine's team for catching this bringing this tonight and I I do want to put it on the consistent

125calendar for an August uh rate increase even if it's a 3% or 2% or five whatever the going rate is I think we should do it every year um because it it it's it it it's just it's all the money I just think of all the money over the 15 years that we haven't been able to collect because we didn't raise the rates and so um you can see the rate increase it's in the the backup but um we're going to put it on the agenda for every August commissioner vanstone thank you m president through you boy this is one that really makes me happy tonight I love this I think we should raise the rates every year as was mentioned except we should uh do percentages that bring us up to par as opposed

126to one or two% um the question I have though is the the literature here says that we're we're talking about surrounding towns and school districts um there are schools within Waterberry also that we provide special ed services to are we also raising rates on them or how does that exactly work or did they get it from us for for free students and I'm talking about the parochial schools and the different type of schools no so actually how we are providing special education to our non-public Partners um is actually through a proportional share of the Ida Grant and that's actually based upon um how we get a flow through so that's different we don't charge we actually provide the services to them this is strictly for our current students that are attending our IND District magnet

127schools that live in surrounding towns all right and you know what once you said that I knew that that that that we passed through money for those we've talked about that before so tough tough to remember sometimes thanks mam president how much of an increase are we doing matters of service so you can see in board backup um a comparable surrounding town I included Bristol's current rates we are at least 40 to 50% below our neighboring towns and we are often the Nexus for students that are in um care of the state and when we received tuition bills this is what prompted Mrs boo and I to have a discussion with cabinet can I ask a question vice president Brown I don't know if you have the figure but um in terms of excess cost

128sharing do we know I know it's always been controversial because we don't get uh you know it's capped in the budget but how much are we getting from the state in excess cost reimbursement at this point for the last fiscal year you know off hand if not if you could get it to me that's fine it's pretty close to around 2.5 million okay all right and does that and then on the other side are we getting Medicare or insurance reimbursement for some of the medical students who are you know in that category we are okay all right and is that going to the education budget or back to the city it goes into education Revenue that is on the city Side so it doesn't come in back into our general fund budget it just goes

129to revenue was considered part of that 150 something million correct part of what this it goes into what the city allocation is to the uh Department of Education okay thank you I thought so which I think is kind of double dipping a little bit I going to say so we don't make any and I think it's you know maybe something we can you know discuss as we go through budget process with the city yeah because we're paying it's in our budget we're paying and then we try to get reimbursed but that reimbursement goes to the city side and then that's counted for that their their uh portion of dollars fund education so it's kind of we're we're getting really less right okay I just want to to clarify that thank you okay are there any

130more questions okay thank you number 10 FYI yeah so just um information to the board as we do every month the um Esser ARP expenditure report nothing different from the last month other than the fact that we have obligated all the funds in resser 3 we have applied for an extension of two little over 2.6 million with the state who will then in turn um send that to the US government um because it is a Federal Grant and we will wait um to hear about that uh probably sometime in January and how much is the extension it was uh little over 2.6 million I think 2 million 634 okay are there any questions okay thank you okay item number oh item number 18 use of school facilities by school organizations and our city departments Mr

131Alini thank you Miss Bell good evening once again Commissioners with your approval of the committee on social and school school facilities and grounds the superintendent of schools recommends approval of the use of school facilities at no charge for eight School organizations and City's depart City departments as listed any questions number 19 use of school facilities by outside organizations and O waiver request mcel beanie with approval of the committee on school facilities and rounds the superintendent of schools recommends approval of the use of school facilities by six groups and organizations subject to fees and insurance as required and as listed any questions okay thank you Mr Alini thank you interim superintendent update Dr Schwarz good evening president uh Hernandez vice president Brown uh Commissioners student representative uh I'll be brief tonight I just wanted to highlight

132um some positive news in the district our Bunker Hill ptical is finally uh completed it's beautiful absolutely gorgeous I want to thank uh the team that worked on that internally including Mr Albini uh for sticking with this and the and and the staff at Bunker Hill where they had to adjust throughout the year but it's absolutely gorgeous I recommend everybody uh taking a look as they they drive down that uh bucker Aven see that beautiful School beautiful Roberto Clemente International du Language School receives their niyak accreditation this is not an easy process this is a multi-year process it's a big deal big big deal uh this makes our 12th school with n accreditation in the district and we wanted to say congratulations to Roberto K and Feelgood story right so we had a Rotella students

133come who made their own ornaments for the uh tree at office and we helped hang those together and the students were thoroughly impressed how high I could get an ornament so uh that's me displaying that a lad that length without a ladder and so that was uh a great uh opportunity want to wish everyone a happy holidays and I also want to congratulate uh waterbear Career Academy in their playoff win yes against the number one team Capital prep uh beating them in their their first football playoff win um I think it might be in school history but I think in a while so uh we let's let's root for them and uh they have a game uh upcoming weekend and at Bloomfield Sunday right let's do it so ghost SP great don't leave out Kennedy's

134first historical appearance in the state tournament correct and Kennedy's first appearance in the state tournament amazing good are you done I'm done that concludes my report thank you oh okay 21 interim superintendent notification to the board read at your leisure can I have a motion to adjourn motion to adjourn second all in favor I oppose motion carries we are adjourned by the way principal Sam said that members of the board could take these beautiful points at us oh as a gift from uh kingsberry school oh thank e e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.