CorpusRecord 112357

1/28/2025 Board of Education Special Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WPS Meetings
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,684 words · about 49 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001with the attendant costs associated for associated with it for you know those that are responsible for paying uh our property taxes and so I think we learn every year that budgeting is not particularly easy uh decisions have to be made some of them uh people may not like uh I can tell you uh that budgeting that budgeting uh an education budget is not like budgeting a corporate budget um it's very different um we have uh a different constituency uh and the impact of uh decisions uh have a direct effect on uh not only the quality of Education uh but people's taxes so it's not um it's not an easy balance but here we are um on January 28th and we're about to continue this conversation and hopefully this evening we'll come to determination as to

002um what we think the right budget is uh for this upcoming fiscal year and I'm sure my fellow members will have comments along the way so uh thanks for letting me uh make mine and I hope everyone on the board uh offers up their thoughts as well so the next item on the agenda um is public comment um and before we get to that um I think you'll find that uh the budget is changed a bit since our last uh our last meeting um we've added back or at least and team have added back uh funding a recommended funding for the theater arts program uh and for the cheer program um so I know that is a concern of uh members of the community so with that uh we'll move on to public comment um

003we read a disclaimer at the beginning of this uh at every meeting and the disclaimer says the board welcomes the opportunity to hear from members of the public about matters concerning Weston Public Schools public comment is an important chance for the board to receive input and feedback from our school Community we listen attentively to all comments shared and while we value and pay close attention to public comment it is our practice not to respond substantively or sometimes at all during public comment and there are several reasons for this first engaging in a discussion on non-agenda items could violate the board's obligation to comply with the Freedom of Information Act second the board or the administration may not be prepared to discuss certain matters raised in the first instance by public comment and third the board

004develops its meeting agenda carefully to ensure that the board addresses matters that are pressing or relevant at the time of the meeting we encourage members of the public with specific questions concerns or complaints about our schools to reach out directly to the superintendent and you may also email the board at our email address Board of Education Westport ps.org uh and additional details and public comment at board meetings can be found on the Weston uh Board of Education website and so with that um Jody um you there we go thank you um for all any of the individuals who are in the attendee mode right now if you would like to speak for public comment I'm going to ask the you raise your hand there's a little button down at the bottom of your screen that

005says raise hand um when you do that and I promote you to a panelist something is going to come up on your screen telling you to accept um the promotion to a panelist once you are a panelist and ready to speak please um take um please show your camera state your name and state your street address and at that point you will have five minutes to speak um is there anybody that would like to speak for public comment at this time please raise your hand okay Alex I'm going to promote you to a panelist give me just one moment Alex you'll be joining now please turn on your camera state your name and state your street address and you will have 5 minutes to speak please apologize I'm in a car and a parking lot

006so I'm just going to just turn on my video okay my name is Alex haly 42 Lord's Highway so I appreciate I only glance at it briefly on my way home but the effort around some of the items in the budget reductions um and hopefully and if anybody had not please let me know so I can read forward but I sent an email with two different letters attached to them with more flushed out thoughts around the budgeting process and specifically comments questions on the 2526 budget um partly did that in writing mostly because it's hard to get everything out in five minutes so hopefully you guys receive that I was unable to watch the meeting yesterday I don't know if any of them are were addressed maybe somebody could come in on that when I'm

007done um but there are a few things that I would like to reexpress from those letters as well as my last several comments um one is I I continue to think and I'm not exactly sure the time table but I don't know why this can't be done but I continue to think that if we have Clarity on health insurance benefit costs ahead of an atbm I don't know why we wouldn't caveat anything we send to the board of selectman or the board of Finance as subject to finalization of that it just seems improved to me as such a large item would be subject we would we would send for approval and then have that sub be in flux I think I said in my letter one way is that if we think we're going to

008know we should wait if we don't think we're going to know that I think that to the extent there is excess I do believe that there should be some type of credit towards taxpayers for basically prepaying for that amount so that's one comment second comment is I I continue to believe that the approach on the capital budget seems to be um a bit at least from the information publicly online bit laxidasical and what's in it why it's in there why it's needed why now why values changed why it increased 200% I just I continue to think that like that piece of it seems to be brushed over you guys submitted a revised operating budget with changes which is great because it's a very large amount but you're also asking for $3 and5 million doar in

009capital budget which is twice as much as last year and makes the overall budget versus last year like almost 6% more which would be in some ways unprecedent on the historical so I expect that there I will be in contact with others and other boards to really dive into some of this as the process continues because I just don't think that um brushing over that type of thing is is prudent um and I do appreciate some of the reductions on the operating budget and look I you know seems like you guys are trying so I I do appreciate that the other thing is there continues to be items in the operating budget that I just don't mathematically understand I'm not going to sit here and purport to know everything about Staffing levels you know pupil

010to teacher ratios Etc and it seems like overall the increase seems to be better on the operating budget side but there continues to be two items around pension contributions and Social Security that are going up 10 plus percent when salaries are flat which just doesn't make sense to me when those contribution percentages should be relatively flat so that doesn't make sense to me um and again it's more I just you know the arithmetic doesn't just doesn't make sense I appreciate some clarity there and then on the capital budget you guys obviously have heard me um quite a bit there um that to me it's just been my issue all along is like that budget seems to be an afterthought despite it contributing quite a bit to the overall amount so um again I hope you

011guys got the letters I I still stand by all those comments and hopefully question those questions and comments on the actual budget get answered prior to any type of approval um I would not approve the budget today that's my opinion I I still think that there's unsolved stuff even from the last meeting I think um uh one of the board members talked about getting detailed information around cost per student and other data and I'm not sure that that was posted to the public file so it seems to be open items that um still aren't resolved um and so I I don't know what the rush is to approve right now um versus submitting and having open items that continue to be refined and maybe that's the answer which would be fine and then we can

012continue working through it but um that's your I don't think it's appropriate to to approve tonight thank you so much uh we generally don't make comments but Alex first of all I'd like to thank you for your letters they're very thoughtful you know it's it you've took a lot of time uh to put those together um I don't happen to agree with everything you say but I did agree with uh with much of it I would incur you know I came to the Board of Education from the board of Finance I'd love to take some time and sit down with you you know whenever you're free we can go through the process because it's not as defined as you it's very defined actually it may not it's not as fluid as you know one would

013like it to be uh but I would like to thank you for in particular for taking the time for putting together those very thoughtful uh two letters that you sent to us and I and you know my phone number is on my email address and i' love to get together with you when you ever get a chance great and look I appreciate you guys putting up with me I know I can do a little bit of pain in the neck so just just just just pay attention to the road please I'm on the parking lot I'm not driving so everybody can rest assured thank you so much thank you I'm going to move you back to an attendee now if there's anybody else that would like to speak during public comment please use the icon

014at the bottom of your screen and raise your hand anybody else okay I think that's it we have people just viewing at this point nobody's raising their hands Okie do so let's uh move on to uh uh the next item item number four uh the first is H the proposed adjustments Lisa you want to take that um thank you Steve uh the proposed adjustments as you said at the beginning of the meeting the administrative team met immediately um that afternoon um when we had our last meeting to go over different things and and look we don't want to put things and I I shared this in emails that I sent out that divide groups you know we need to come together as a community and look at this uh budget as a community and we

015felt strongly that that you know the amounts that were involved in components of both the athletic and the um District theater program it's it it's not worth the The Angst and the heartache quite frankly at um a nominal uh amount um we don't uh as you said enter into these decisions lightly it's really hard because um each uh reduction um means something um however we are comfortable right now with the with the list of reductions that we have um and I thank Mr Cross for putting together another spreadsheet um I would say that um every one of these budget adjustments you know when you see things like that there is a restructuring of project challenge that does not mean the program is going away it means it's a restructuring like we did at the middle

016school when you see something about you know uh some World Language uh reductions we feel that um that they can be absorbed in Spanish in particular in a way that is not going to hurt the offerings and to be frank um it's been said early on in the process that um the Chinese uh numbers have not warranted on being able to continue the program um you know this often happens it happened to the German language program in Weston and it's happening with this and as it's a tough uh decision to put on we um we needed to to put it on um I think that we're in uh good shape with with this budget right now I'm really proud of the work that we did I still remember when we were at that subcommittee that

017for the board of finance a couple of weeks ago and they were talking about projections and they said you know we put a placeholder in a 3% and I am really proud of the fact that we got to 3.05% with this budget you know it's um clearly not easy but this is a what we need budget I know there is also a concern about um how do we sustain this kind of uh budget and how do we sustain these levels of Staffing and and I would say to you not that this budget um has reduced the equivalent of um seven FTE or full-time equivalencies and that moving forward um it will be uh the responsibility next year of the new uh superintendent and the administrative team in the board to continue to look at ways

018to balance our um enrollment projections section projections programming Improvement um when you look at Staffing for for example intervention and uh special programs all of that uh you know every budget has its own theme and its own context at that particular time so I think I'm going to stop talking right now um but uh yes we would ask you that you would approve this budget again remember this is a preliminary budget estimate and those words are important because it does go to the selectman it does go to the board of Finance It ultimately goes as U Mr eie said to the town um to the community at the um atbm and that those are all important parts of the process and we will continue to collaborate with the um upcoming U meetings of the two

019different boards uh on that process um but I do um encourage you to uh support uh tonight's number thank you and we're here again to clarify anything or I know that sometimes people ask you questions in the community and um please feel free to to ask or give um any feedback and we're happy um our team is happy to respond thanks Lisa do members of the board want to comment or ask additional questions before we move move on to a vote you know it would be helpful I think if Lisa if to Alex's question because it is an important one to explain or maybe Phil uh the increase in the pension and the Social Security Mr Cross please the increase in in pension is per attributed to noncertified staff I did send an email over

020to Alex explaining the difference that while we may have a difference a negative or a small reduction in overall salaries those salaries that are attributive to seor to semors had increases so that's really the drivers of that um what's also missing from or what Alex is is not saying are those salaries that's also included in the grants and the grant servies are also subject to to both seamers and all Al to uh Social Security and Medicare does everyone understand seers for the listening public why don't you go explain that Phil sure uh Seer is a is a pension plan for our non-certified groups for pretty much for all groups that are outside that that's outside that's not teachers are within the not teachers union outside of the teachers union and part of the WTA is

021that like Connecticut Municipal Employees that's what it stands for right Connecticut Municipal Employees Retirement System thank you yes it looks like Phil is having some connectivity issues so um our non-certified staff belong to that group um and I think it's worth noting that our uh we do not contribute as a district to our teachers retirement system and our our uh certified administrators are also part of that group and that's managed by the state correct David any additional questions why don't we just go around and see what everyone thinks David is there additional questions you would like to ask or any comments you'd like to make no no no okay Michael um I I I have a question just on on the capital budget I think um and I don't I don't think Mike is is

022Mike Dom mro here maybe not so it may not be appropriate I guess I guess no he's not but we've been in a lot of meetings I think go ahead and ask it um yeah I mean the one thing I just wanted to bring up on this is with respect to the HVAC system in North house so um we all know this is needed right I mean I mean I have a daughter actually that's in second grade this year so um no no one knows that more than more than me at this point um I guess my my only question is um the planning for this we all know we all we all have known that this has been needed for quite some time and so I guess I'm just I need clarity as to

023why um if you think about the design the design phase The Ordering of the materials phase the you know um um the installation phase of that let's say project I guess my question is why have have we why have we waited or delayed the design because I think we don't quite know from the last discussion yet yesterday at least what I could make of it um we don't quite know what system we can put in which of course of course calls to question the number so I guess was there a reason and and again I don't know this was there a reason why we hadn't moved forward with the design and gotten um better Clarity on what actually was possible there so that we could have a more firm number um in terms of what

024that potential cost would be and then I guess I guess the corollary to that is does that all have to be approved this year or can that cost be spread out let's say assuming it's 5050 material materials materialdesign and then labor can be can that be spread out so that it's you know we're approving let's say design slash materials this year so we don't hold up the process and then next year we have the labor part the other 50% kick in when it's going to be installed I guess th those are my two questions around that one that one line item in the capital budget I don't know who can answer that and maybe that's fine I'll I'll I'll take a step at it um so over the past several years right we we've been

025having these kind of conversations both for H but and also for the middle school where we've put items on our capital budget and at some point because of affordability or whatever it is or similar conversations as what we have now they pretty much they pretty much came off the capital budget so to be honest with you the reason why that study was not been done was because we we we weren't certain what direction the was head in and also whether or not the town could afford could afford whatever renovation that that we needed to do so we held back because we didn't want to spend money on projects and something that could not be funded because we we we pretty much thought it was a waste of funds so we pretty much held back um

026to be honest with you that those funds were approved maybe a budget cycle or or two ago and we held off um it's no different from the high school where we have um two wings I keep getting them mixed up two wings of the high school that needs renovation and we do have money within a capital budget for to hire a consultant to do that but the question always remains what is your affordability what can we do when can we do it and what are and and things like that so this year similar to what we have done in the past we the administration we've said we need these things to be done right we know that the question may come up as to whether or not the town can afford it but we know

027that these these items or these projects need to be addressed at some point and we need to have them on our capital budget so even if they're not approved but we can have discussions just like what we're doing right now so if it is determined that the town can afford and the Board of Education would like to approve um adding the HV at at H but yes we could split the cost over two years because as Mike mentioned the first phase right so we're getting the funding right now so that money is in place and the summer of 26 so we can start the project so over two years we can fund one phase now the initial design not the design but we can we can do a quarter some let's say up to 50%

028in year one and then the second 50% the second half in year two okay so it was a little bit of a chicken the egg scenario with actually funding it but funding it to funding actually the study to at least understand what the Poss what was what was possible to install um but of course we need to confirm that we had we would we would move forward with it or that it would be affordable for us to go ahead and to do so is that is does that sound right yes um if you were so sorry guys Steve got yeah so just on that point so if we were to fund the study I don't know what that cost I was gonna ask this next God yeah so there is money already approved in the

029budget um we do have money air marked in our Capal budget um for the study we will be issuing an RFP within the next two weeks our goal is to issue an RFP and to hopefully have a firm number or something to start a conversation before the board of Finance votes in in March was this approve sorry was there money approved just just to be clear uh Phil was there money previously approved for the study or is it it was money's correct we did not do anything because here's why we started we started the conversation Prim I don't want to give you a hard time I'm just trying to understand no no no it's okay I'm just trying to just trying to for you to to kind of paint the picture we were hyperfocused on

030the middle school we were moving along with the middle school and then right as we were as we thought we were at the end and ready to make decisions the the bricks were applied on the middle scho middle school project once the bricks were was applied on the middle middle school project we paused on doing anything else because again in our minds we did not know what the town could afford and whether or not it would be a waste of funds to even to even start doing the Consulting work or engineering work for any kind of project both at hurlbut and also again at the high school do you do you recall so um to Steve's question I was going to ask this anyway if if you um if you separate out the design phase

031here do you so I guess do you have an idea as to what that would cost if we split this up in two years you know do you have an IDE first of all I guess if it was previously approved was that then part of the Surplus that then went back to the town okay okay you're saying no okay say no um because that was a capital that was Capital funded okay okay it was Capital funded okay got it um and then I guess if if we go forward now do we have an idea since we don't know what necessar what system let's say gets put in place there and hopefully hopefully we can upgrade it and it's it's um it's more of a central you know air ccra um system but since we don't

032know exactly the system that's going to be put in play do we at least know what the potential cost of the design phase again getting back to what Steve was getting at too do we have an estimate for that fill or we don't have an estimate for that we don't have a firm number on that on that so we do have I think if I'm not mistaken I don't have the exact number it's somewhere between 35 and 50,000 that we have for Consulting fees um you know even even when when you look at on the the the updated schedule that was presented by kers for all the projects that we have you'll notice that all the projects are funded over two years in year one that's the cost for the engineer and the consultant and

033everything else with and once that cost has been established in year two is when the fund is is pretty much done listen heret has been the way it has been now for several years right this is not something that is new to anyone on this board or to anyone in in the community and we've always just we've always deferred the projects all projects right and I'm just talking open right now all projects for both the middle school and for Herber have been deferred for over 10 years prior to my start I have been told that the Board of Education or facilities were told let's hold off and doing any major renovation at either end for the past several years last for the two years ago we had nothing on for the middle school right and

034we're at a point where we need needed to do something for the middle school and we added projects the last project that we added to for the middle school was the locker improvements right and that as that know I think that's that's been great for for the students so we've been trying to trip away at stuff guys a lot of times items are on our Capital list right because we need to have these conversations whe whether it's approved or not but we need as a board we need to have the this kind of conversation and yes we have put items on on on Capal list and those items have been deferred and if we're if we were to defer this we'll defer it and then we can always come back again at some point the

035town Board of Finance one second Steve the board of Finance is in the process of formulating the the debt capacity for the for the town so we'll have a better sense in a few weeks or in a month or so as to ultimately what the town can afford but just getting back to the HVAC project can it be phased in over a couple of years or once you start it you have to finish it no once once we start we can do the Consulting portion the engineering portion of it and make a decision not to do anything okay but once you make the decision then we have to go ahead then you have to go ahead and that's a million s what our estimate right is a million three is a million three correct and

036that would be in we would either include it in this budget we're talking about now or possibly postponing it to fiscal year 27 if a decision is made to defer to anything I would I would I would recommend that we partially funded so that at the onset we can e we will have funds in place to order the equipment and then as a project um proceeds then we can have funding to pay on the labor side so funding could be over two years not not to not not to use the the negative uh words of non-aps account but that's what we're basically potentially suggesting if we fund it over more than one year um I think another way to look at it Steve it's it's would be similar to what we have done with the

037high school track um where parks and Rex have has pretty much had a syncing fund where funds set aside and that was done over five years or so and then last year or maybe maybe the year before we actually the board of education got their approval for their portion off the project and the project was completed and and Phil I'm not sug I'm not suggesting that we delay look would they I mean they need something done at hurlbut for this I think it's been delayed long enough I think a lot of I think we tend to kick decis uh decisions you know we Ki Kick the Can um once in a while in terms of some of these some of tougher items and they're hard um but I think this needs to get down a

038hurot the question is just um I wish I guess at this point there was a little bit more clarity in terms of what the plan was that was my comment then my question was can we still move forward with it without um without delaying the project at all if we just fund it over the two years and not just all in the first year again the first year let's again I'm thinking about this simplistically the first year funding would be design and enough money to um set aside to order the parks because those will take more months and months and quarters potentially and then when when they're when they're in and we're ready to install then we have the second the second sort of trunch of money then ready for for labor for them to

039go ahead and install it so instead of all just one chunk here it's not that we're delaying it it's just that we're spreading out the cost of it over two over two years okay absolutely and our goal right now our goal is to have information that can be presented to the Board of Education sub subcommittee sometime in March if even if it means that we have to call a special meeting just to discuss this one item that is our goal but ultimate but but absolutely if if we are agreeing or if the board is agreeing to fund this project it could be fund are proposed to spread the cost over two years so procedurally if that's the decision my guess is not to speak for everyone else that seems to be the right thing to

040do how do we do that tonight um the way to do that tonight would be to reduce the offer the capital budget request okay can I just ask a quick question related to that um if we don't this this is something that needs to be done I think we are all in agreement it needs to be done the question is when when does it actually get done and it's not at this point I think a delay on the part of the Board of Ed or the administration it's a process it's getting the parts it's getting the design so if we approve the full amount tonight the likelihood of us spending that in the upcoming fiscal year is unlikely or maybe not likely to spend more than 50% just due to timing so what happen happens

041to that money at the end of the coming fiscal year sure um just as a reminder all fund within the capital in the capital budget do not expire right okay so if we were to delay or change the funding my concern would be we are now starting at an elevated increase or ask next year uh because we're just shifting that money we know we need to spend into next year's budget so we're kind of I think putting ourselves at a disadvantage in January of 25 for our January 26 conversation yes and no um yes to the part that we're starting the year with an increase but what this does or what we have always tried to do is try to not have whip sace where one year will have a spike and then for it

042to come down so what this will do is that it will level out the funding request over several years historically that's what we have done again this year we only have this one item that's really spiking the budget but if you strip that out you'll realize that our budget tends to be in the million or so um range for Capital budgets okay and so then why wouldn't we just do that if you look at where the likelihood of the money needing to be spent or encumbered it sounds like 50% of the one point .7 million is not likely at least 50% not likely to be needed until fiscal year 207 correct but but if we spend half of it to buy equipment we're g to spend all of it the next you know in the

043following fiscal year because you know you're committed at that point right and I think that we I think we should be committed to the project I don't think there's any question about that I think we are as a group I think maybe where I was originally heading was just take the money should be in the budget now and because it's a non-aps account but then Phil you kind of brought up the point which makes sense to me as well it levels spending out on the capital side if we uh kind of split it into two years of budgets this year what we likely will be doing and we know we're starting out next year's capital budget we just take that number of 1.7 million right and you can chop it in half move half of

044it over to the projected or or next year so for my purposes I think we're committed I think it maybe from a leveling perspective it does make a little bit more sense so we don't have this big spike as Bill kind of said and then a drop so ju I mean just recognize from a a budgeting point of view you know not knock on wood we haven't determine what the operating budget is but let's assume we go forward with the with what's being proposed uh the big contentious budget between in the town between the town and the Board of Education will not be their respective operating budgets it'll be Capital right so um that's G to when we get before the board of selectman and board of Finance the big conversation is going to be

045capital and so be competing with whatever you know whatever the town believes you know they need that's just as much a necessity is robot so but if if that's the case then I think it would make more sense than to spread it out over this year and next year so that yeah that's essentially what I'm saying yeah so then would you like us to consider reducing our request by $875,000 which would then bring it to 2,461 th000 if we split it in half would that would that be sufficient Phil would we be safe if we were to split it in half I I I believe so yes then that makes sense to me yeah I agree okay we're we're jumping a bit ahead but um well I just made a note we can go back

046okay we'll go back to that okay um and just if if I may um just to in 20 in fiscal year 2223 um the Board of Education and the board of Finance did approve $50,000 for Consulting work relating to the um to the north house okay um Michael any questions on the operating budget no I'm good thanks Steve Sharon uh Peter uh I I have no questions on the operating budget I you have a comment um Chad is not on the call he's I think now flying from Las Vegas to San Francisco um his his text to me said please ask at some point if project challenge should be added back at its previous level besides that no questions yes I um I can just add that I wrote a response to Chad and said

047that it was not taking it away but it was restructuring it and the program will continue so the administrative team did the exact same thing um at the middle school and quite frankly nothing was raised and there hasn't been anything raised since that approach correct Mr dop there's been no concern so um I see no reason to add it back in when we know that it is been done successfully okay well we can report that back to chat um I mean I don't have any questions you know we I think collectively as a group have asked Lisa and team a lot of questions you've been in incredibly responsive Lisa as you've proven yourself to be in previous years and um I I guess without any additional oh Lisa L I'm sorry I did I should

048have asked you you're good okay so uh do we want to have a vote on the fiscal 26 operating budget Phil do you want to just repeat it so give me one give me one second okay um that amount is 61 million1 151,000 $439 and that's a 3.05 increase that is correct right so uh can I have a motion to approve uh the proposed fiscal 26 operating budget I have the language you want me to read the language yes please okay move that the Western Board of Education approved the fiscal year 26 operating budget in the amount of 61 mil1 151,939 which represents a 3.05% increase thanks David is there a second okay all those in FA Let's uh do a roll call um Lisa left I approve Peter Gordon I approve Michael Guido sorry

049um I approve can I make a comment about it U about it Steve really quickly of course I I look I just wanted to thank everyone for the process um the Administration has worked really hard for this um they've answered a ton of questions given us a bunch of detail look I I do think everyone that the process can be better from a timing perspective right I think we've all I I've I've personally struggled a little bit with this um in that we're being asked I know it's been brought up before we're being asked to approve a budget with question marks around potentially Big Ticket items that are not firm or yet confirmed and so I don't I don't know again this is probably and and I'm sure there'll be some eye rolling but I

050I don't know I don't know what to do about that again is it a change to the Charter in terms of when we deliver the budget is it a change to our process in some way I know it's very difficult and we're always sort of coming up against you know against the timing constraint here um I also think just last comment here then then then we'll move on um I also think I I just still struggle with the sustainability the budget and again some of these metrics are arbitrary by you know by some looking at like cost per pupil or cost per staff or whatever uh and unfortunately gets back to headcount um I do want to be clear that I think look I don't want to be here frankly right I don't want to

051have to make those decisions but I also know that going forward I would rather make smaller decisions today to make the budget more sustainable than having to make bigger more impactful decisions later down the road that really just impact the students or the quality of Education or um you know or the experience the students have again my kids go here I'm very supportive of this I'm very supportive of the administration and all that they're doing I just wish that um again we can get to something that's probably a little bit more sustainable again maybe it's a headcount situation I do feel like we need to delve into that a little bit more maybe it's the non- student facing headcount I don't know um I'd love to see I'd love to delve into that more um

052I guess we're gonna have to do that in the future I don't think it's going to get easier um but with all that being said you know given where we are you know it's 3% it's not neily like I said the number it's just the sustainability sort of below the surface here um especially knowing that there will there could be Insurance costs here that continue to crowd out let's say investment going forward so I'm just I'm I'm very uneasy about the trajectory although I'm I'm supportive of the administration and I and I I I approve the budget thanks Michael David I approve and I would just like to add something much more brief than Michael I agree with most what Michael said um this being I have look over my shoulder I think my fourth

053or fifth budget cycle I have learned so much about the way the public schools operate that is different than the private sector um and you just simply like someone like Alex who clearly has a wealth of knowledge and wants nothing for the district but the best for everybody we just operate so differently and I cannot say enough good things about the conversations I've had with Lisa Phil Julie everybody to educate me I mean Lisa and I spoke a number of times just today just to kind of get my head around a level of comfort so it is ex I've learned it's exceptionally complex to understand how our budget works you can't just go and say this position should be eliminated that person is making X their benefits are y therefore we uh can save Z

054it just doesn't work that way in the public school system is incredibly complex and I'm just very grateful for the administration's commitment to our students and just their ongoing willingness to continue to educate me so that when I vote Yes it's from a very educated perspective and there is more work to be done but I'm very comfortable with this year's uh budget I've seen the report card they've uh they have on you David um you have a little bit of work to do I'm working on it all right Sharon you're not that brief David you're not that brief you're unmute Sharon that's funny all right David unlike you I will be brief we are in the precipice of some big changes that are taking place in our district um but having said that um I

055think that the Administration has worked really hard I appreciate all the work that you've that you've done in answering all of our questions um about getting this budget to a a place that's palatable for the community um especially having been given some curveballs that we were not anticipating um but I I also happen to agree with both Michael and David in as far as sustainability and that's kind of what I'm referring to when I talk about the precipice but um I think where we are right now is solid and um I'm looking forward to a great next year under this budget and um and addressing what we need to address to to move forward so I a yes as well great um look I made some opening comments you know thanking Lisa and everyone on

056this call um for all the work that you've done I really don't have anything to add I I really would like to compliment my fellow board members you know David Michael I know how much time you put in having conversations with Le the same with you Sharon and Lisa so um you know it's been a long process and we started in a much higher number we've come down to a very workable number um because we do have the students to be concerned about we also have our staff to be concerned about and people who are delivering the product and so you have to be cognizant of all of that so I'm a yes as well Chad is not here um and he can't vote in absentia so uh with that uh the budget the operating

057budget passes um can we move on to the capital budget is there more comments on the capital budget beyond the HVAC system that anybody wants to make well I have a comment on the HVAC system I right now I would vote against any deferment of full commitment of capital for that because historically We Kick the Can down the road even with some money spent we've seen that in other projects you know I'm a member of ashra right so Asher is the HVAC engineer and Technical Society I'm a member of the technical committee 2.7 which is hbac for schools I'm not a mechanical engineer I'm an electrical engineer and one of the first things they talk about it's and Bill and Mike dmaster actually has the guidelines is your school district committed are they going to

058see it through because it's it's expensive it's a lot of work and it's easy to get sidetracked right so here we've been sidetracked for 10 years we could be sidetracked for three years it should be expedited not wait and maybe see what they say and then maybe Implement something that clearly is lacking system systemically in North house so now you have prek K kids and K kids and their parents going hold it what is there ozone in the air is there dust my kids aren't heated my kids aren't cooled they're sucking down flu virus and you have no answer for that except well we'll look I consulted then we'll maybe look at some of the system op options then maybe we'll make a decision or maybe we'll defer that because somebody else wants to spend

059some money on something while we'll wait three more years to actually fund it and then her butt will have the same agback that is had for 60 years and those prek kids will be sucking down fumes and their parents would be like you had an opportunity board you just keep deferring it you just keep pushing it down the road so there's some palpability well I I don't think that's particularly fair to a bunch of prek andk kids now I say you have to go all in and the aser mechanical engineers now they're not taxpayers I understand that but they're like you gotta get you got to be committed for the front because it gets side railed it gets put on hold for some other reason and you never get to it and now you spent

060$800,000 and got nothing I rather uh commit to 1.3 and get a lot and then it's done and then we know it's done and then it lasts for 20 years because Mike deaso is a good facility guys and train and carry and those guys are really good Handler guys and it gets done right so that's my two cents I would I would not vote for a capital budget if we defer commitment on this I'd be a no vote this evening that's how strongly I feel about it okay Peter sorry Peter are you suggesting that I'm not suggesting that we delay this at at all I'm just no I'm suggesting that we have to commit en no you gota because you don't know the timeline you'll get to the point where oh you know we spent

061some money we feels like you know we should actually order some some equipment now and we need the money and guess what the guys could start actually earlier than we thought the other way is well we don't have to really have a schedule well we really won't have to order equipment and then the guys we won't have to pay there now increasing the wages three years from now because we don't want to spend the money so it's a matter of heartfelt commitment and I think you know my maybe the town doesn't commit to much but if you're going to do this for these kids you go all in and you say yes we're going to commit to this we're going to see it through to the end and that's going to be the message to

062the Consultants to the equipment suppliers to the contractors these guys committed to it I'm putting them on my schedule because they committed the money to it and they'll be the money will be there if not they'll be like well next year you'll vote I'll take a couple other jobs then by the time you vote and maybe there's some discussion I'll move on to another job I'll move on to the Westport HVAC guys I mean that's that's the warning I get from the technical society that looks at this nationally they've seen this over and over again like don't a lack of commit me means ultimately a lack of success that's just my message I I don't know I kind of trust the engineers on this one right they've seen a thousand HBS being installed or not

063being installed in a thousand schools so we just have a lot of History Steve Steve what does what does approving it all this year and again I I'm simply proposing may think you know an a reallocation if it doesn't hinder progress knowing that I think we're all committed to your point Peter um Steve also made a point before about um there we are competing for dollars with the town so I guess the question Steve then back to you is that if we were to put it all in this year's budget would would would that even be palatable for the town I I guess I guess it's it's not I don't want the you know the perfect to be the enemy of the good here um maybe it is preferable Peter I don't know maybe it

064is preferable to just approve it all this year but is that even possible Steve and what is what is what is the path of path of lease resistance here that is not going to result in a delay of the project and buying from the town so I guess if the town accepts the whole thing this year Peter fine but if the town is gonna is gonna balk at that then we have to be flexible I I don't know Steve yeah I mean you you guys are really thinking hard about this but my answer would be let the people who vote no look at the parents in the office of PK kids and say I don't want I don't want your kids to have clean air and com I personally have no problem putting the full

065amount into the capital budget uh and having this very same conversation with the board of selectman and the board of Finance um but we're competing for dollars and my guess is the questions that we've asked this evening about can it be spread over two years will be the same questions they're going to ask um so do we W to prejudge that prejudge that and just say we recognize we're probably going to be assist again or or just go all in I mean my view is if they gave you know if we split it 5050 900 one year n in round numbers 900 the next year if you have $900,000 expended buying equipment you're it's not I know you're shaking your head per it's not going to sit in the locker for you know for purpose

066you're there in fact that's that's kind of the base of the next Capital Year's budget but you know we can we yeah it's it's you know it's it's like I've dipped my con toe in and I dipped my ankle in but unless you jump in and this stuff's tough yeah but but if you have $9,000 $900,000 of equipment setting in a warehouse thing yeah not to mention well you want to start that build then you want to hire you got to need the money if you have any equipment these guys are wantan to get started right because you've captured that wage uh at an a year earlier and that uh time allocation to get it installed and get it calibrated and tested you know that it's OSHA and it's EPA it's complicated so any you

067know if you're going to bring in consultants and then you're going to bring in some equipment you're going BR train or Carrier or Mitsubishi then you're going to they're going to bring in their favorite local contractors who know how to install it they're they want to get going they're not gonna let any sit in warehouse this this is just gamesmanship if we really believe it's necessary and which it seems like everyone believes it's necessary let's just put it in the budget let the board of Finance or Board of selectman uh you know make a determination I don't necessarily disag age with that but I think we just need to be prepared to defend why we're going to have the full amount in there because initially you know in talking about it it made total sense

068to me that we could easily defer half of it and and not have such a you know lessen this Spike shall we say but that being said you know having worked a lot with contractors contractors don't like to commit their time unless they know that the money is there right and for us to say no no no no we promis we're just going to pass it in the next year's budget might actually put a lot of the contractors off so to Peter's Point yeah I and I'm with you we can we can put it all in but we just need to be able to Def they're watching this call right now so we just need to be prepared to defend our position we're gonna defend our position regardless I just want to quickly say we're

069we're we're alloc we're we're timing the allocation of money with when Mike delmastro said is likely to hit so I see this as two separate issues where uh or three we're committed to the design which has to happen first that money has been earmarked but it was the the design Phil said was essentially delayed because there wasn't a commitment to actually move forward with equipment because there was no money so we have design has to happen first then there has to be the parts that have to be ordered Michael said it's it was unlikely that this was going to be completed until summer of 207 so we are we're simply taking the dollar amount we are allocating it in the year it's likely to hit we are creating a uh more of a straight line

070on the uh Capital uh budget so there isn't this big spike and in my opinion because of the pre the pressures from the town to to what Steve was saying there two years of looking at it just send the full amount and it it's going to be lwh hanging fruit and the town's going to probably say allocate it in the year that you're going to spend it and if by some chance we um do what I'm suggesting which is we allocate it in the year that we spend so we do half this year and a vendor shows up in February of 26 and says we can get rolling on this starting March 1st we just had a big project open up we can ask the town for a special appropriation we haven't locked ourselves out

071so my position is allocate the money in the budget it's likely to be spent and if you truly have a concern Peter that there's going to be installers on March first saying we're not waiting till July 1 and if we are the price going go up by 30% we're ready to roll tomorrow then we go to the town and we ask for a special appropriation it's I mean Sharon builds houses she I mean we all mean I I went through $100,000 quote with my age Factor folks right I mean the mentality is that's residential when you go to commercial it's a 10x it's like blood in the water for the Sharks which is a bad way of saying but once they know you're committed once they know there's there's funds allocated to this they're going

072to move faster than slower right they're going to want it they're going to want to get it done fall of 25 not fall not some number of 27 right so it it compresses it without a commitment it just La it will just keep on going and those we'll have to look at the the newborns by the time this hbac gets put in another and and Mike Del Maser is being conservative because he he can't commit to these guys up front so he's like well I'm gonna have to play a game with them it's blood of the water they see the money you're going to find uh all the all the pieces on place and the kids benefit sooner and later if the if the money's not out not not to mention there's only there's only

073probably a few companies that can actually do one of these installations right and they are going to take a look and say Okay so we've got a variety of different projects on our plate to look at and they'll take all of this into consideration before they commit to doing anything for us they'll they'll look to see whether or not this has been approved by the town and so you know and if it's not been approved by the town they'll be like you give us a jingle when it's you know when you guys have approved it and then we'll come back and put you on our us when your kids want to breathe good air well I wouldn't quite go that far Peter but they will say call us a little bit I know but so

074I I just think we need to be cautious of that because we don't want to lose the opportunity to have these people come in and install this I mean I'd love to have it early but even on time because we haven't appropriated the funds until we think that we're going to need them you know I mean that's just just just Contracting world sorry just to complete the circle then Sharon you're in favor of put it in the budget now I am you know initially I was like yeah let's go ahead and divide it but thinking about working with contractors the amount that we work with contractors yeah I I am in in favor of putting in the budget now and I know we're going to get push back from the town we need to be

075prepared to defend it that's all Peter I don't think I have to ask you that question well well I will make a commitment since I'm clearly a vocal proponent I'm going to the Astra technical trade show in two weeks in Orlando and I'm meeting my fellow committee members I'll try to get a testimonial that supports our my assertions so we have something in writing from the technical do you have a TR organization you have a thought on this um I really believe that um Peter and Sharon are right I believe that I'm too afraid it's going to be the fire truck that was 2third paid for and they were having doubts about the last payment and this is really too important we put it off for so long that it shouldn't be it's going to

076be two years it should be expedited as quickly as possible and push it through with a company that can do it quickly Michael um I was trying to think think of a more efficient way of doing this from an affordability standpoint where we're asking the town all the considerations around it I don't want to delay the project obviously um hes needed this you know gosh years ago and so I don't want to delay the project um if we all believe that um committing the funds immediately is going to speed up the process then okay then I I can go along with that um if I I'm thinking from a from a financial standpoint um you avoid as Phil said the saw too there's a time value of money of course it's involved and um going

077off of Mike's Mike Dom Mastro's previous comments I thought there was an opportunity potentially there to go ahead and reduce the ask of the town again um I don't want to delay the project if you all think I haven't dealt with contractors that are associated with municipalities if you all think that um in some way that's going to encumber the project then okay let's let's put the full amount to the town now and see what they have to say I mean I wouldn't I wouldn't be shocked if they approved or told us to go back and rethink it but um I'm happy to put it forward if you all think that that's that's the way to go David it's summertime work it is not happening summer of 25 so the soonest is happening in summer

07826 I say allocate the money in the year it's going to hit so the answer for me is no okay uh so so David they never do HB in Alaska with that logic if it's an internal for duck work they you know in the state of concut they put handlers on on roofs in the winter I mean come on it's not summertime work it's yearlong work what are these guys down in Florida all all winter because I can't get work come on do you think you're going to have mechanics working on the roof and in build in the building with students never going to happen for security inconvenience there's so many reasons it doesn't happen you have you have Windows of opportunity to get worked up what do you think Mike D Mas doesn't getting

079worked on during Christmas break and February break now you're arguing with me about an assertion of the start okay a nonsensical argument okay well that that's not going to be solved now I'm actually in favor of putting it in the budget now and then having a conversation because there was a comment made about the lockers I don't know Dan how long did it take the lockers they put in Middle School 10 years I think it was a conversation every year while and the bo we're glad to have them though thank you very much for the support no but it took forever and the conversation was well they look okay to me you know but ultimately they failed so um are there any so so we should take a vote on this uh because we don't

080vote this the individual we don't vote the uh the totality of the capital budget we vote it by projects what one one more comment Steve on this um before Phil mentioned and I think it was what 175 1.75 is in the budget in the capital budget for this line item Phil did I mishear you before that you said it was around 1 point4 or 1.4 no I'm sorry that iount is 1.7 oh okay you said a lower number earlier yeah I I did that's that that's on me I'm sorry it is 1.7 1 M 750 it price has already gone up Peter okay so we delay we delayed the vote 30 minutes I mean another 30 minutes God knows so so ju so just I'm just confirming the amount so the amount is 1.75 million

081is that correct that is correct okay that's all I want to know thank you okay so uh this is a line item can we uh have a motion to approve uh what's the exact number fill I don't have it in front of me David do you want to read the motion or no yeah I don't have the line item though I just have the overall capital budget is is this vote on the one item or the entire capital budget St no I think we should do each item I mean that's the way it's voted by the town you want to do it by number then rather than bold statement I mean what is Expedition well I guess the question is let's make it simple for the board are there any other parts of the capital

082budget people are concerned about no okay well if that's the case then why don't we just vote the number yeah pH you're up okay um move how ironic move at the Western Board of Education approved the fiscal year 26 capital budget in the amount of 3,336 th000 is there a second second all the uh let's do it by member Lisa that's I you're on mute that's a yes I approve okay Peter I approve Michael uh approve David no Sharon approve and and I approve uh so we move forward and the capital budget is approved and move on to the board of Finance and I think that's it for the evening I'd like to make a comment please thank you so I I want to stress that I think that this process is really very important

083and you know at times you said um you know you asked a lot of questions we spent a lot of time together and individually and writing documents and on the phone um but clarifying questions understanding feedback providing you with um important data so that you could um make a a decision um it's it's just an important part of the process that's what we teach our children in the western Public Schools right so you are modeling that for them on behalf of the administration the faculty and the staff I would like to thank the board for its support and I'd like uh to remind you of something what you voted for and supported was to empow power every student to achieve success what you voted for was to support teaching and learning and the development of

084those skills that are so essential so that our kids leave and become young adults that are ready to contribute positively to our society and boy do we need that now so I just want to remind everyone you know Weston and the schools and the schools are Weston and I am so proud of this community we can come together we can disagree we can work through things um which is all part of the process and again that we can honor that's your belief right honor the uniqueness of every individual and what that person brings so um really um this is uh the end for me as far as passing getting the budget pass at this Board of Ed uh Board of Ed um we are committed to continue with the other boards and and we're still

085not there in the atbm and we will continue to methodically uh work through the process um but again I want to thank you and I realized today how many of our staff watch these meetings because I was at the middle school and I was stopped throughout my walkthroughs with Mr do he's shaking his head and they're like Lisa I heard this question Lisa how do you think this is going to go and I'm like listen it will be fine we just have to continue through the process so thank you no thank you Lisa and thank you thanks to everybody really appreciate it yeah thank you very much Lisa and and everyone Phil Lisa I mean all everyone who contributed to putting this together this was a this was not an easy budget year this was

086a really difficult year and this you know having been here now for five of these this is this is really not been easy at all and I appreciate everyone doing it and Lisa congratulations on getting your your final budget through the board now let's you know keep uh keep going and getting it through the uh to through the referendum as well so thank you everyone for all your hard work thank you thanks everybody with that can we have a motion to adjourn so move okay second I okay

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.