CorpusRecord 112358

Board of Education Special Meeting (Budget Workshop)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WPS Meetings
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,187 words · about 102 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001fiscal 26 budget it's our last Workshop ahead of our meeting tomorrow uh when we're going to uh where we're going to vote on the budget uh the first item on the agenda is Pledge of Allegiance you can do that pledge allegiance to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all go Lisa all yours thank you Mr R morning everyone happy Monday um so we had sent you a bunch of uh documents over the weekend the documents are posted on the uh District website correct Miss Setta and um what we thought might be good is is the administrative team met on Friday afternoon and kind of put together a sort of a a topic presentation if you will that we think might address um uh some of

002your questions and your feedback and then at the end we can uh you can ask some more specific questions if that's helpful I believe that uh we are going to start this morning there's been a lot of uh questions about the mental health providers the roles and the responsibilities of them and I would like to um let uh Tracy Edwards kind of uh go through that for us this morning and the explanation if you're looking is in Board of Education Workshop January 27th document page one Dr good morning everybody um thank you for giving me an opportunity to talk a little bit about Mental Health Services and Staffing in our four schools during today's Workshop before I speak about the structure of Mental Health Services in the district I do want to provide some context

003about the PPS special education budget in general um that I think is important information as we review any of the related line items uh while we have seen declining enrollment in Weston we have seen a steady increase in the number of students who are qualifying for special education services which just so we're on the same page that's consistent with the trend that's being observed across Connecticut and also Nationwide um to add some flavor to that in the 2021 school year 11.9% of students in Weston qualified for special education Services uh the Statewide average at that time was 16.3% so we were almost 5 percentage points below the state average since then um the identification rate has increased in Weston to 12.6 in the 2122 school year 13.7 in the 2223 school year and 15.6 in

004the 2324 school year uh last year the 2324 school year the Statewide average was 17.9% so we're still below that state average um but there's less of a discrepancy between our identification rate and the state in addition to that increase uh the increase in the number of students who are qualifying for special education services we also have more students qualifying for 504 accommodation plans and as we've discussed in terms of previous budget recommendations we have more more students require requiring multi- Lang multilingual learner support or MLL support in our district so with that kind of broader context I want to discuss Mental Health Services uh specifically it's important to note here I think that our staffing in the area of mental health support has actually remained flat um in the five years that I've been

005in the district remembering in that time we were coming off of the pandemic and of course have more students who are requiring support we did make a couple of shifts in the model so we shifted from school counselors to social workers at both hurlbut and whis um but the headcount in both of those buildings remained consistent you also might remember and I'll talk more about this this morning that we added a social worker position at the high school to support our Pathways program um but that was replacing uh a contracted Services Program um that was provided by an outside agency and actually at that point represented a cost Savings in The District budget so we've had a lot of conversation and question about what do our mental health professionals do within the district so I

006want to provide an overview of that without rehashing everything on the question and answer sheet beginning at hurlbut and wh um there's a lot of continuity in the mental health support structure in those two buildings and the roles and responsibilities of the providers in those two buildings are very similar Hess and Wiis each have a school psychologist and a school social worker as I mentioned we um had social workers replace school counselors at the elementary level um I made that recommendation because social workers bring a different level of expertise regarding mental health challenges and and the impact on students social emotional and behavioral functioning both in and out of the classroom which I thought was more appropriate for our youngest Learners um at hurlbut and whis the school psychologist provide individual and group counseling they

007provide small group social skills opportunities families in the district might hear about those they're called Lunch Bunch generally um they support the implementation of social emotional learning programs in general education classrooms in this case ruler and responsive classroom and they attend various meetings to support students with IEPs 504 plans intervention plans um they provide support during crisis situations and they serve as resources for colleagues and families to support the well-being of our youngest Learners I want to underscore here and throughout this that our mental health providers in all four schools do not just work with special education students they provide a range of support and services um to a range of students and those needs can vary throughout the school year the school psychologists specifically at both both hurlbut and whis and across all four

008buildings also have the responsibility of conducting all psychoeducational evaluations for initial and trienal uh evaluations within special education that's an important role and responsibility and so I wanted to highlight it here as we transition to the middle school and the high school consistent with the model at hurlbut and whis each building has one social worker and one school psychologist the providers in these buildings are using DBT steps a as their guiding framework for social um emotional support and their role and responsibilities are honestly very similar to that that I just described for hurlbut and whis so I won't repeat myself at Weston Middle School in addition to the school psychologist and the social worker there are three school counselor positions one for each grade level which aligns very closely with the teaming model that I

009Know Dan has discussed in previous meetings um and that teaming model we've talked about how important it is for a consistent group of adults to be working with students in those respective grade levels our counselors provide individual and group counseling they work with students to support course selection and scheduling and also assist in transition planning um they also respond to crisis situations as needed um they develop I think most importantly three-year relationships with students and often serve as a primary point of contact for families when there are concerns about their child's social emotional Behavioral or academic performance our counselors participate in core team intervention meetings 504 meetings and ppts and they also case manage all students with 504 accommodation plans um our counselors are also responsible for coordinating the advisory program and serve as resources

010for students uh families and colleagues in developing support plans for students at school Weston High School has five school counselor positions um including one school counselor who serves as both a school counselor and the director of guidance so she has a reduced case load counselors at the high school also follows students for all four years which is consistent with the structure at the middle school and as a result they too serve as a primary point of contact for families and School staff in addition to all the roles I described at the middle school the high school counselors guide students through the College and Career exploration process in coordination with our college and career counselor assist with applications standardized test registration scholarship searches and financial aid applications um our college and career counselor who I know

011has spoken at length uh with all of you as a board every year to describe her work with students in grades 10 through 12 provides individualized support to Juniors and seniors to ensure access um to the resources necessary for postsecondary planning she's also the person who plans and facilitates the camp College summer enrichment program again the theme Here is that these providers are working with our whole school population not just students who have special education or 504 accommodation Services um finally we have one social worker at the high school who dedicated to the pathways program this program has been in place since the 2122 school year and replaced a program that was previously offered by an outside agency which was more costly and honestly less effective than the program in place now um the pathways

012program is a school within a school model designed to support students with complex internalizing social emotional challenges within this program students can access some or all of their coursework within the pathways program while also participating in electives and other general education opportunities the pathway social worker is providing ongoing individual and group counseling and is in regular communication with families outside providers and School staff she's also participating in ppts team meetings and works very closely with building and District administrators um to support students who are returning from day placements residential placements and sometimes hospitalizations I do just want to point out that without this program we could expect to see an increase in the number of students placed outside of the district in therapeutic day placements um we've discussed our moral and ethical obligation uh and

013legal obligation actually to provide programming and what we call the least restrictive environment um and this program allows students to access access the offerings of Weston High School while providing them with the individualized social emotional support they need to access school from a financial perspective given that we are talking about budget planning it's important to remember that out of District placements are often averaging above $100,000 per year not including the cost of Transportation which is a required related service um you know in short our ability to provide the mental health services across the district directly impacts students ability to access instruction in the classroom um this team has worked extremely hard in the last several years in particular to provide the personalized individualized detention that we talk so much about in our budget meetings to

014all of our district students and their families um and the proposed budget maintains the Staffing levels that are needed um to meet those needs for for all of Weston's students I'd be happy to answer thank you for listening that was long-winded I'd be happy to answer any questions you have about any of that information hi Tracy thanks a lot I mean I realize how important our support services are and how much they're doing and I really appreciate you taking the time to get us the support documents and give us this analysis of exactly what they do I just have some questions um how many students are in our Pathways program um it varies year to year the maximum number of students for that program when we designed it was 15 we have between 10 and

01512 right now I I don't know the exact number but between that window I just I was just wondering about that so you know um I looked at page 73 of the budget um where you have all the support services for our 2053 students and these Support Services run across most school districts and you're doing a wonderful job of personalizing and individualizing the support Stu services for students my Wonder becomes and I'm going to do more of a gross analysis and and you can let let me know that you've you know um have the support services between counselors and social workers so I count that as nine counselers and five social workers which are 14 and so the case loads are well under 150 but the state uh case loads for guidance counselors and S

016social workers are best practice 250 and most school districts can't attain that so we're very we're well below which is wonderful we personalize and individualize um but can we reorganize to make this a little bit more efficient I understand um Pathways is an exceptional program targeting special education but when we look at counselors and psychologists we're looking at the entire population of students as we support them with best practices um if I can start and then Tracy can finish let's look specifically at Pathways Pathways financially basically is a 1.6 allocation roughly that program costs us about uh $200,000 we have 12 students in the program if you take one of those students out to be perfectly blunt and put them in a therapeutic boarding school that probably will be at least $150 to $200,000 so

017we believe that it's money well spent when you look at the um academic return on investment the other piece to that is and I was a big advocate for getting rid of the uh I'll be perfectly blunt the subcontracted service because I was there I liveed it and uh I do not think that they were effective I knew that our people could do the best the other thing that we have to remember is we want these students they are our students in the Western Community we do not want to uh for lack of a better word send them out somewhere um we want them in our community where they will have that kind of support within Weston to be able to do that but financially that 1.6 just looking at dollars is money quite frankly

018well spent because that $200,000 could be easily tripled if several of those students go on an outplacement uh basis Tracy do you want to speak to the other thing about the restructuring Lisa I I agree with you about Pathways uh you know because I I 100% agree it's least restrictive environment it's best for the students to be within you know the school population and with that said we still have very small case loads for the rest of our students we have small case loads I suppose if you compare it with the state but again I'll go back to our vision we want to be the standard and when you look at Westport and you look at Wilton and ukan and Daran they have similar case loads so I would not compare ourselves to the state

019average because we pride ourselves on the level of personalization I think it's a slippery slope when you look at 250 students and you know the other duray we they look we look at them all the time they don't have those kinds of ratios Cy do you have anything to add yeah I I think the question seems to be centering around the counselor case load at the high school specifically and I can Echo what Lisa superintendent uh just said Lisa I hear your point about Statewide average but I do think that number is extremely misleading um in and many and most other districts counselors are providing support around schedule development and course selection they are not providing the level of individualized personalized support to students and families that we as an administrative team expect of them

020and also that students uh and families in Weston expect of them that will be lost in any sort of restructuring that would potentially need to happen at the high school level if we had one fewer counselor um our counselors do provide social emotional support to students they serve honestly as kind of Liaisons between families teachers um anytime there is any sort of concern that is that's a family's first point of contact that counselor is involved in meetings with school teams to try to problem solve and make plans for students again not just those who um are receiving any sort of plan they're also connected to um the packed program which is organized by counselor at this point so that the counselors have an opportunity to in addition to meeting with students individually also meet with

021them um in the context of small group um so it it's it's a very different model than what I think is traditionally thought of when we think of school counselors um and again our model is aligned to how our area districts are providing the support and our case loads are not significantly different from from those districts can I can I add to that for a moment too Lisa that number of 250 that I believe is the recommended number for the National Association of school counselors that's that's kind of the the the max right and that's really to mitigate schools who are exceeding that number sometimes by 100 to 150 students so when we talk about best practice and the number of counselors that represent um students that 250 should be you know the maximum and

022we are in a position where we have such personalized service our counselors know our students they know their family they know the siblings they know their story and no place was that best exemplified and most evident than on Thursday um when we were dealing with our school situation and the way that the counselors were able to step in they were work working with kids they were working with siblings they were able to help us identify students get everyone on buses and really um ensure that we really had safe um effective and efficient practices and you know to do what we did in a really um well practiced and and HED and personalized way so I I always worry when we talk about that 250 number because that is really to mitigate schools um through budgeting

023and other you know um systems that have a far higher number it is it is not um known as a national necessarily best practice I I think that that our support uh staff does an excellent job I just was wondering um if the uh small case loads couldn't be redirected because when we talk about counselors and social workers we you also have four psychologists who do the counseling and testing so it was just you know looking at page 73 and the amount of support staff that we do have it's wonderful for personalization and individualization and ensuring that we have those social needs met and with that um as we look at our budget these are our Support Services can we refocus and reanalyze how they're given so maybe fewer people could support them I I

024think we're saying no now you have a a wealth of experience in education if you have a suggestion please share it with us however I am not going to jeopardize the social emotional um well-being of our students to in to make those case uh loads higher I won't do it I'm sorry all of the top districts in Connecticut do not have those kinds of case loads and that is just somewhere we won't go again I welcome if you have an idea but um we've tried a lot of different things over the years and this is serious if kids do not feel comfortable in school you know this they will not learn and we are not prepared to go there Lisa um uh I have to apologize because my uh my connection dropped off and it

025dropped off just at the part that I was really kind of hoping for and Tracy it was when you were describing the high school counselors there are five high school counselors in conjunction with a school psychologist and a school social worker I I lost um there was one I understand that we have one school counselor per grade um and we're looking at about 170 students per grade and I think it's a wonderful um approach for us to have a school counselor that follows the students for all four years while they're at the high school builds a relationship with them with their families I really appreciate that I like that I think you guys are doing a great job I did not understand and this is again because my connection died what is the role of

026the fifth social or not social the fifth school counselor can somebody explain that to me please so can I just clarify our our school counselors at the high school are not assigned by grade level I made that comment for the Middle School you are correct though that the school counselors do follow students for all four years um there are five school counselors at the high school I explained that one of those counselors has a reduced counseling case load because she serves as the Director of guidance she has a lot of responsibility overseeing our programming in general you might remember that we did a curriculum revision um last year or the year before um she's done a lot of work with um the technology that we're using in the district and how we support students in

027the College Planning process um so I maybe that answers your question that's how her responsibility differs from others it's also if I can draw attention again to the document that we provided you on Friday it's spelled out in a chart and all the information is there for all of these positions I guess what I didn't see was um was the uh the fifth what Tracy just explained I saw what what school counselors do don't get me wrong but to have a fifth person who is responsible for uh basically running the department um it sounds like an acting as a liais on to different departments um was something that I didn't get out of the chart so okay thank you I appreciate it I'm happy to jump in at this point um my concern is the

028the spend that the the the percentage increase I mean that's really just sort of the bottom line I've said for years I feel like we're on a not ins unsustainable trajectory and I feel like the fourth as I saying earlier this is my fifth budget book and I think that we've hit it this year and I could be wrong I'm speaking both from a board of ed members perspective and a taxpayer and I don't know that I've said this before I don't know that I have the expertise with how the district operates um to suggest where we are uh where there could be better higher higher utilization or whatever the case may be um and I think Lisa left brought up you know the the the case load for guidance counselors I hear what Tracy

029is saying loud and clear it's not an area that we should be looking at it's it's an area that while the numbers look low they provide a level of service that requires that type of case load so really I guess my question is I think the budget percentage it's it's it's too big um and I think the health the potential health savings is not really an offset it's a it's a maybe so if we take the potential health savings out we're looking at a 6% plus increase and if we have to tell the community it is what it is there's nothing we can do we as a board of ed and we as an Administration have looked under every turned over every stone looked in every place it is what it is I I feel

030like for me individually that's where I'm at I'm at it's it's too big of an increase and we've hit yeah and yeah and we hear you David and I would respectfully ask that we wait till we go through the other presentations the um the coupon that you said last time about the insurance that's real money okay and we'll when I go through the cuts we've got it down to a 3.0 budget but I think it would be helpful for Julie now to present about the profile of the District staff because the only way you're going to get to significant Cuts is District staff it's not going to be these other things and we're pretty much where we where we feel comfortable going jul uh Julie can you can can I just ask ask one more

031questions go going back um to what Sharon said so one of the counselors is uh uh supports the entire guidance counselor department but we have two assistant principls at the high school with you know under 500 students um the assistant principal doesn't support the guidance counselors and the direction that they go in you have a special guidance counselor who does that it's a director of School counseling we can get you the job description but the assistant principles have other responsibilities as Tracy talked about the numbers of the 504s they're involved in that the assistant principles also um several years ago because I lived it had to absorb being a Student Activities director because that position was taken out of the budget and Dan is shaking his head remember Dan when we had to take that

032over so I don't want people to see that oh you have a lot of administrative staff at the high school they're all kept extremely busy especially with um the in the areas of both uh regular education and special education and working with students in that area they hand all the 504s that is a huge amount of people Tracy do you have anything to add I I think I can just maybe add that when we're talking about this and I know we're very focused on numbers and the kind of quantitative measure of the work that's happening and I understand why we're focused there but I also think we need to be thinking about this qualitatively and the the change we've talked in many previous Board of Education meetings about the increased complexity of student need especially

033from a mental health standpoint so you know one student Now isn't necessarily consistent with the the type of student profile that we were working with six years ago um the reality is we do have more significant mental health concerns we have more crisis situations which just so you have a flavor in a context when we have a student in crisis um that could take one of the professionals an entire school day to work through meaning that they're not able to see other students who also might be struggling with something less significant and all of that work needs to be pushed to the next day I mean Megan spoke about what happened at the high school on Thursday and the Hands-On approach that was needed there there are there are situations across the high school that

034happen on a more regular basis honestly than I think people think where individual students need support in order to be able to access their academic instruction and these are the people doing that work um and I mean I think you can hear from all of us that I I and we have very significant concerns about having to restructure um that model if I could also just clarify because I think there there may be some uh misunderstanding when talking about the role of the director of School counseling firstly there are 600 9 students currently at Weston High School so I just I just want to be clear about that the second is the person who's currently functioning in the role of director of School counseling is a school counselor she assumes all of the responsibilities that

035Tracy described under a high school counselor with a reduced case load and that reduced case load is something that allows her to assume the additional responsibilities of that directorship so I I think I just want to be clear that we don't have four school counselors and a director of School counseling we have five school counselors one of which has a I'll call it a release or a reduced role in order to accommodate those additional responsibilities can I ask another question and I know we probably want to move on and then look back at the totality um if we have a crisis I I guess it's a two-part question so every everybody in every profession has an emergency that you can't plan for right that's why it's an emergency and it becomes an all hands on

036deck when you have an emergency so logistically speaking I have two questions uh logistically speaking do we have on a regular consistent basis a these types of situations where there's a student in crisis and um it causes the other four counselors uh sorry takes that one counselor offline and the other four can't pick up their workload for the next day or two is that a common occurrence there are students in our programs that present with a range of needs on a regular basis so when you're talking about a crisis situation there's a there's a range in what I'm describing that could be occurring in that but when a student is experience and experiencing any sort of emotional disregulation um and it could be for a number of reasons yes potentially that mental health provider who

037is most closely connected to that student whether it be a school counselor a social worker or a school psychologist are with that student for an extended period of time during the day and yes sometimes other people um Provide support in those moments but also there are occasions where some of what they would be doing then needs to be put ped to the next day I mean that's that's the reality of the work I think these are the providers in our district who are most impacted by those kind of unpredictable situations it could be a a peer conflict it could be an issue that they're dealing with at home but it is so pronounced that they're having a hard time attending in whatever classroom they're supposed to be in it could be an issue that they're

038having in a particular class um or it could be a social emotional challenge that isn't necessarily directly linked to one specific thing but is instead a combination of factors that are leading them to have difficulty participating in the school day um and yeah I think those things do happen frequently across our buildings and I think that those needs are most pronounced at the middle school and high school um where there is more intense uh pressure and expectation and responsibilities for students who are trying to assume you know becoming young adults and becoming more independent um and navigating many more facets to life than our herbet elementary school students for example and just and I'll wrap it up uh on this topic and are we not able to if we have a student in crisis and

039we have a counselor offline or a social worker offline are the high school uh excuse me are the Middle School guance counselors able to come up are they is that allowed from a uh what what you know I'm not sure where the right word would be but you know they train to you know come up and and and backfill for the day from the from the Middle School David I think when we're talking about these situations there's a cost to each move and each decision right so every counselor has their schedule today every counselor has their family meetings their scheduling meetings their C just general counseling meetings where they might have on a students's plan one-time weekly counseling so every time we we do work together there are times that we will make a phone

040call but I I think just we're talking about the needs of kids and you know the staff that we have that is working for the current population of students that we have we also see it periodically throughout a school year there are times that we see heightened levels of emergency or crisis situations with students so um we will always work together we have worked across buildings depending on the extent of a crisis situation we can certainly work together but to believe that high school middle school counselors are going to come to the high school that's just not the reality of the day because those middle school counselors have their schedules and their meetings as well okay I'm not trying to be a dead horse but I'm just going to kind of link it to my

041world and Dan's World Dan DeVito's world we walk into crisises all the time because the end of the day we're plumbers we just happen to be working with computers and I feel like part of our job is to look at where we can uh uh reposition staff to deal with the crisis now we're dealing with technology we're not necessarily dealing with a student who's in crisis so my questions really are they Circle back to I think the we're on unsustainable trajectory this seemed to be an area that's out of my area of expertise but there was the appearance that the number of people providing the services compared to the number of students consuming the services strictly on an enrollment perspective looked skewed and I think what I'm taking away is um these positions are absolutely

042critical we need them we need them at the Staffing levels they are okay thank you without actually wanna I wanna I want to support David on that too I I totally think that um the it's not that we are suggesting B stretch imagination that the mental Daron we lost you um I just think that you know I think it's an important conversation I think it's important to put it out there because it's also you know part of this discussion is for the the public to hear you know people see numbers and they think that that we can do different things you know um I've been here a long time I've seen a lot of different combinations this works it works and there will be unintended consequences that will adversely affect the district if we tamper

043with these numbers I'm being really just blunt I think this is a good segue to Julie to talk about to give a little bit of perspective I know because it's important to understand the profile of the District staff and and kind of um where we are right now and everything else because when you talk about um sustaining programs or not sustaining you know programs and and that kind of things and funding um I think it's important to to have this background Julie if you will thank you um so thank you Tracy um for those details and I think that that conversation play into what I'm hoping to speak to you about this morning um there have been a number of questions that have come up relating to the nature of the work of our staff

044and the impact of any staffing changes that we have proposed um so I'd like to just give you an overview of the makeup of our staff because sometimes I think as I've said in previous meetings the language that we use um might be misleading when we talk about certain groups of staff members uh and I'd also like to provide some explanation of the considerations that we have in the face of Staffing reductions So currently in Weston we employ 381 staff members 89% of which are student facing meaning they have direct interaction with students on a regular basis 89% the biggest groups within that student facing group include our teacher group and our par educator group and when I use the term teacher I want to underscore that that includes not only classroom teachers but also

045interventionists media Specialists counselors social workers psychologists speech and language professionals and also our curriculum instructional leaders that group represents 58% of our total staff our par educator group is the next largest group of Staff members and they represent 16% of our total staff that student facing group includes those two groups teachers and Par Educators as well as our school administrators our security Specialists School nurses the administrative assistants who staff the school offices our permanent substitute pool lunch and recess AIDS providers like um occupational and physical therapists and bcbas as well as a vocational specialist we also contract student facing staff as daily substitutes on an as needed basis and in stiped positions such as um coaches Club advisors and uh theater production staff so all this to say the vast majority of the people that

046we employ we do so because they are in routine direct contact with our students providing service the remaining 11% of our staff are not student facing on a regular basis though I would underscore that their daily work ensures the safe and efficient operation of the schools and district and this group includes our custodial maintenance and ground staff our it professionals our staff in finance and operations the district administrators and administrative support assistance when we plan for our staffing needs we do so in FTE or full-time equivalency there have been some questions about this FTE is a metric that expresses employees workload in relation to a full-time position so a 1.0 FTE is a full-time position Etc a05 is a halftime position our initial budget request included both increases and reductions in certain areas based on

047projected enrollment and student needs for a net decrease of 5.5 FTE those changes are comprised almost exclusively of fractional ships for example there is a projected .2 FTE reduction in art districtwide reductions have been recommended in our previous proposals within the teacher group including at the Elementary classroom level in the high school core area in The districtwide Specialist Group and in academic support as well as in the par educator group within special education and again those proposals are based on the enrollment projections that we have and our best estimation of student student needs today we are planning to propose additional Staffing reductions which Lisa is going to detail in just a moment when we have reductions there are a variety of considerations that come into play in terms of the impact on the profile of

048our staff procedures relating to reductions in force um we typically call that those riffs are outlined in the bargaining unit contracts and we have have to abide by these procedures which depending on the contract include consideration of seniority job classification tenure status qualifications and experience certification as well as recall rights of any previously reduced employees furthermore we have to account for other circumstances which may arise throughout the spring and summer such as retirements resignations the return of tenur Staff members from extended leave or future leave requests and this is all to say that the the determination of which staff members are affected by a reduction in force is a complex decision and so just to give you a simple illustrative example um and this is very very simplified we're anticipating a reduction of one section

049of third grade or 1.0 FTE from the teacher group that does not necessarily mean that one of our current third grade teachers will be impacted Elementary classroom teachers are certified in grade bands they might be certified to teach k6 or six or prek through three and so it's not as simple as one person in one assignment is the person who is impacted let's say have a retirement of a teacher who's currently working in fifth grade where the sections are projected to remain the same in that scenario a third grade teacher might simply shift to fifth grade as an assignment or they might shift shift to fourth grade and the fourth grade teacher might shift to fifth grade that's one possible scenario but let's say that there are no Elementary retirements and a teacher must end

050up being being separated tene status is a first consideration if there are non- tene teachers in the elementary group they are impacted first and then the same kinds of shifts as described in the retirement scenario can proceed now this is an isolated and simple example and you can already see that there is a dominal effect in play so I ask that you project that scenario uh into one where there are now multiple fractional reductions in various content areas and consider that we have staff members who serve in multiple assignments or across multiple buildings or who hold certification in multiple areas it can be very challenging and it is very challenging in this moment to say exactly what the impact of Staffing reductions will mean for the overall profile of our staff I will say we

051have an extremely talented and experienced group of non-tenured teachers some of whom will be impacted by the proposed reductions 19% of our teacher group is non-tenured furthermore given the fractional reductions that have been proposed we can expect that there may be more part-time assignments available and or more shared assignments or people working across buildings these circumstances can present challenges because parttime positions are generally less desirable for applicants or even for our current staff and shared positions can be very difficult to schedule some of the reductions will also have an impact that extends Beyond Personnel truly affecting our ability to deliver existing programming to the same level we will of course continue to do our best to provide the highest quality educational experience for our students but I hope that this explanation and this you know

052short example has provided some insight into the intricacies um of Staffing particularly within a small District like ours um so I am happy to answer your questions and I know I'm just going to UND underscore again the Lisa has some additional um reductions that she would like to discuss this morning hey Julie thanks for that I appreciate it um question for you all and I'm feeling a little under the weather so I'll try to make this short um um would love Lisa at the end of this and it sounds like you're going to tee this up you're going to go through the proposed reductions and sort of take us through how you got there what this actually impacts in terms of you know the Paras and the software and everything else that you're here um

053to your point Julie um and and I'd love to know also Lisa how many actual actual full-time employees this proposed reduction encapsulates it feels like it's a lot of like 02 here 02 there there may be one reduction of one Pera to from four to three um so maybe there's one there's a reduction of one headcount I know that in in reality may be more just because of you're taking fs and tws but from a headcount perspective I'd love to know what that actual reduction is um Julie before we get there Julie um when you're talking about all these considerations I get it right um You are reducing potentially people's hours and so then what do you you you were doing is you're impacting sort of their schedules and their lives and that has KnockOn

054effects for um what they're doing right they have they go from full-time to part-time all of a sudden and then they have to recalibrate for their own their own lives and their own situations is it not easier Julie then when you're looking at this stuff to say well it's just a cleaner way to go ahead and just reduce the number of heads directly as opposed to taking a 02 a 0. five disrupting a lot of people's lives and in the course of that of course um potentially having those people leave later on because they just can't let's say sustain let's say a a part-time position and or it doesn't work for them for some reason so would love your view on that and then I know Lisa you're gonna you're gonna go over the the

055proposed reductions here would love to just understand how many FTE we're actually talking about here um why don't I start and then we can go back to that question and give Julia a time to I'll look at the staff thank you Michael sorry you're under the weather glad it's remote um so I I want to take the opportunity to talk about like sort of the the story behind the numbers if you will so if you look on page nine of the 1725 um budget I think it was David that that wanted someone requested you know what what was the total number of staff and so right now we have um a number of staff and then we have the U you know the what we had before and yes there were 300 roughly 300 less

056students but I think one of the things that we have to really uh think about is um over the years well as long as I've been here um we have really tried to uh maximize uh Staffing in a way that works both for you know the individual in the district as well as the program and when you look at academic return on investment and the best way to piece these things together I just kind of want to give you a little bit of a history both for non-certified positions and certified positions of of how it's worked when it's worked well um back in 1991 when there were very few children at the high school I think it was about 300 um I along with 14 other people were shared staff and so that meant School

057Road we were joking around in those days we didn't use the golf carts about how we could have really uh used them because what happens with shared positions and if they're full-time people right but they're shared um you have that they you're really not owned by any school you kind of you know go to the high school do a couple classes and then go down to the elementary school so right there culturally you know when you get into the high numbers like that was a lot of people doing that 14 also when you're shared staff you get reduced duties if duties at all if it can be arranged so then you have the unintended consequen of just basic duties how you're going to cover them on top of that it's very different when you have

058a shared person between secondary and Elementary and frankly I learned about that when I became superintendent because with an with an elementary person for example you can say you can work uh Tuesdays and Thursdays and make it work you're a really great qualified person or Tuesdays and Fridays and we can make that work and they spend all day secondary it's very difficult to do that you have to do a morning rotation you have to do an uh afternoon rotation to make it work so then you get into that again we're always looking for the most qualified people but it can be a challenge if you go and um look back at the WMS teaming model Mr do showed where what happens especially at the middle school when you only have morning and afternoon but it

059happens at the high school too I'll give you an example it's very common in World Language to have shared staff I was the World Language teacher and we were really struggling a few years ago with how do we fill these classes how do we find the level of quality that matches someone's uh personal life and I went back to 40 years ago when I T with someone at Daran High I knew she retired and I said hi you're probably the best person that can teach both Spanish and French that I've ever met would you like to come and do it for us and lo and behold she agreed and she's been doing it for us she likes doing it in the middle of the day like it works great but that's really really hard to

060find I want to give you a flavor of how in this current budget and in recent budgets and especially the Staffing is challenging when you look at um High School Staffing because you're right Michael it's often pieces so you have for example we have historically and even now combined different levels of a language for example Latin 4 Latin 4 AP is together French and French AP they're together because the teacher can differentiate the numbers are such it's a higher level of the language and we want to make sure that that those children get that level we offer courses every other year APM is offered every other year courses like Facing History and ourselves with American tapestry we want to be able to offer the program and we offer it every other year so if a

061student wanted to take a APM junior year we knew that um he or she needed it maybe it's Junior maybe it's senior but we make sure that that FTE um is available that course is available when that student needs it we have classes combined like AP Studio Art and Studio Art they're combined right now and we differentiate within that and it seems to be able um to work so that's those are some examples of of how we work with um combining staff and there's another example I'll get to it when I talk about the reductions but for example the talented and gifted program at the middle school is delivered by the library media specialist it's a small portion of his position we do not have to and that was done a few years ago under

062my watch we do not have to hire like who who are you going to hire how are you going to get an elementary school person and a middle school person mes the schedules together figure it all out and deliver a quality program and we think that that's working and and more to follow about that reduction because I think people see it and say oh no we have uh a solution when you look at other people people that perhaps don't uh necessarily with the rubber meets the road in the classroom let's look for example at grounds so you have grounds I've been here when we've cut the grounds person and I alluded to overtime not only overtime but we had to bring in subcontractors to be able to work on the baseball field and everything else

063so you're literally taking a pot and putting it somewhere else like the money is going to different places same thing with Pathways you have a 1.6 allocation before you would see that money in out placements um and the money was more so we're trying to make sure that that doesn't happen at one point um in recent years we didn't have an HR director it was decided that the HR Director would be eliminated when I came on board I saw this as an untenable situation with an assistant superintendent doing 70% of HR along with the lawyer along with the superintendent we need a qualified HR Director same thing with Safety and Security we've gone through all kinds of you know we had more staff then we reduced then it didn't work then I wanted to put

064in the floater we didn't have a a a direct C we finally got that on the right track which is what we need you know smaller examples are the things like um the Student Activities guess what you're going to do Student Activities AP um APS at the high school we used to have a person that was dedicated to power school at the high school that did do all scheduling all grading um it was a big job and when you say well can the assistant principles help out in PPS no because that position was eliminated and now that's their job to do that so one of the assistant principles does that work at the high school there used to be one at the middle school guess what Drew Walters is the person now the assistant principal

065so we really shifted and that works is it ideal no but it works and we can deliver what we need to deliver so this is all kind of what I would say h a flavor we used to have a finance coordinator and Phil cross said you know what we're gonna give up the finance coordinator our group will take on those added responsibilities been a real challenge for Phil Crossing company and I worry about it especially with um different projects that are coming up he does operations he does transportation we used to have a transportation director I don't think we need one but he does that but he gave up the finance coordinator you know there are layers and unintended consequences when you look overall at moving staff and and what can happen and what what

066can't happen um we really tried the very best we can to make sure that every single person matters when you go back and you look at or nine years ago no Pathways program you look at it no uh extensive uh security you look at um the things that we didn't have that we have and we've been able to offer courses like AP Computer Science every other year to make sure that the program stands the easiest when you get to um a one person one person it's going to be in Patty and Laura school that's the easiest or in a a social studies teacher or the core academics at the middle school or at the high school that's the easiest way to get to that one person unfortunately when you when you're looking at some of

067the cuts that historically we've had especially at the high school and Julie can speak to these little pieces then we have to figure out and it's frustrating because some of the these people are top-notch new employees that oh great now you know we're going to lose uh down to a0 three you know you're losing 30% of your salary do you still want to work here that becomes frustrating unfortunately that's been the case for years and we just have to really mitigate the challenges um I think that case just really quickly in that case if you're reducing 0.2.3 um you're still providing benefits right so depends whereas okay so whereas let's say the way just I'm thinking about it is if you if you got if it worked and you got rid of let's say one

068full-time employee you you actually get rid of obviously the salary and the benefits if you're reducing 0 tws and 3s you may you may come to the same salary equivalent but you're not getting potentially rid of the benefits so there is that added cost if do it that way absolutely right Michael and Phil and I have mitigated that like when you look at a couple of these you say well how did you get to that number we know it's a specific person we know it involves uh benefits and that's how we can get to that number so you're right it really you have to look at all of it and kind of figure it out and take that into consideration you know you can have a certain number you put in for a placeholder but

069that's where um what's the term fill um cost savings is that savings what is the term fill that you you use when we hire someone different what's the called Turn savings turnover savings turnover savings thank you turnover savings but it's a fine line and you really have to have to analyze it and we get in the weeds with looking at this um Julie can you talk um did you have time to look at the specific breakdown can you share that before I go over the reduction list yeah so um Michael just to go back to your question I think Lisa just provided some some color um but to the question of is it easier to reduce headcount yes operationally and and from a budget perspective uh it is easier to reduce headcount however it's not

070instructionally necessarily better to do things that way right like our first consideration is programmatically are we able to deliver the quality instruction that we need to for the student group that we need to and and their needs uh and I think that's why you see reflected in The Proposal these these fractional changes um to your question about how many people are we talking about how many full-time positions are we talking about um there are there are four in the initial request um Lisa is going to talk about one additional um but that again doesn't necessarily mean um that there are five people who will no longer have positions in the schools because we have people who are already employed at a part-time level and so those fractional R reductions could result in elimination of those

071part-time positions as well which my rough estimate looks like impacting uh the positions for seven people total um but again that can be offset when we receive resignations retirements things like that so uh again it's complicated I I hope that gives you a sense of what we're looking at but to Lisa's point we always try and look at these things um in terms of how we can implement the program with the most efficiency maintaining our high quality staff and to your question about benefits we offer benefits if someone is working for us at a 0.5 FTE or above right right um yeah there's a difference I get it there's difference between head that you count right so head count and full-time FTE equivalence right which could look similar however you're just basically taking again 0

072tws and 05s you may not be reducing benefits at all actually in that case and it it may not even be those people so I I get all of that it's it's it's you know it's the Carousel of sort of trying to figure out what exactly is going to minimize the disruption right to to to the teaching sort of to the instruction that we deliver um and the support we deliver I I get that so um if you guys can just go over then what the proposed reductions here are that would be great just I I and Lisa I just want to understand why these so so so what the net effect is why these how did you come to that decision just just as you go through sure so um we look at the

073overall program the impact of the overall program the uh number of students that um you know are involved in the program and you know it's it's really um a challenging uh process because every principal wants um his or her item off the list I'll say that up front so I guess you could say that the bug stops um with me um when I uh put it on the list and um I mean let's be clear no one really wants to be where exactly right no one wants to be here we we as board members and and I I don't I don't want to speak necessarily for everyone but I I know I don't I don't want to necessarily be the one here coming in and cramming down let's say the administration to generate cost savings

074here we just want to make sure that obviously we minimize any disruption but that we're on a sustainable path so um we're we're relying on you guys obviously to tell us how best we can achieve that and so that's why I'm just trying to understand you know why you think you can reduce you know by one per not two and just so on and so forth sure um I'm happy to I'm happy to go through the list um I will start uh you know with the top and work our way down it it wasn't it was just put on it wasn't like in order of anything to just say upfront um so we put in instructional pair of professional um there currently are four regular education pair of professionals two at each elementary school that's

075not counting the um special education um Paras that are there and the the the ones that that work um uh in the classrooms in that capacity okay in instructional paa is um you have uh a PA in the library and then you have Paras that that help with um General uh classes pushing in math language arts helping to get the science labs up and running things like that so um and this has been uh a second cut to this so we had four and um I'm sure that Patty and Laura didn't want to put the one on the list um but we do believe that by reducing by one each building will have one and then there will be a third person and that third person I would leave to the principles of those schools

076to use that third person as they see fit whether it be like we talked about what kind of a split that would look like if it would be a split by day if it would be a split by time of day if it would be a split by week for example if something was going on in Patty's um science uh lab that they have or Laura's lab and they said they work together say you know we really need this schedule this time contractually it works well because they're on the same start and end time so there's no problem with that um you know they also do sometimes help cover classes so we're going to have to really work on getting uh substitutes to uh you know our our substitutes to come in but we believe

077that um while not ideal that is something that um we can put on the table it requires much more of a flexibility than oh I'm the math paah or I'm the language arts paah I'm the science PA it's I'm an instructional paah and you know require both administrations to work together to see how you know they have the one in their building how they're going to work but how would they share a a separate person the next one on the list is to eliminate point4 of World Language Chinese point2 and Spanish point2 again we look at the overall program So currently we have 10 students in Chinese 3 Chinese much to my dismay of having started the sister school back in 2005 the enrollments have been declining there is not the interest in it right

078now we have um 10 students in Chinese three 10 going to Chinese 4 10 going to Chinese 4 as seniors if they so choose that language they have um what I would say is a robust three levels you know we talked to Randy Greene about how this also implicates and looks on a college transcript they have three levels of World Language um it's going to be very hard to F hire quite frankly a person that can teach one section of Chinese four for Max maximum 10 students and whenever you schedule them you're probably really looking at eight because there'll be other conflicts maybe seven so that was the decision that you know we made um the program is sunsetting and that's why uh we put it on the table with regards to point 2 in

079Spanish again that is at the high school and in looking at it it's particularly about the Spanish four uh course level although remember if there's a need in you know it shakes out a different way within the Spanish um it it could be a different um it could be a different level of Spanish right now we have two sections of Spanish for two sections of Spanish for honors and uh you know I used to do the scheduling I've looked at these numbers it's where the students fall we believe that we can have three sections not four and still be able to accommodate those students in both of those levels because you never know someone might be in Spanish 4 for example and they might be taking Spanish 4 honors their sophomore year at the same

080time where they're teaching chemistry honors and that might be that you know what I want to go to Spanish for a regular I don't want to do the Spanish 4 honor so there's fluctuations between those two uh those two um you know uh qu you have a level but then there's fluctuations between honors and standard so we can comfortably do that and when you look at people again we have um someone that has been teaching um us helping us teach the course she's a part-time retired person so you take all of this into consideration can the kids get the program yes they can get the program and um that that won't be uh affected eliminate project challenge point5 FTE perhaps eliminate is the wrong word I want to take a moment to it's the FTE

081not the program and I want to take a little bit of time to talk about that so we have project Challenge and and Tracy please jump in why don't you explain our responsibility and the numbers in the program and then I'll talk about a a way that we think we can still be um uh meeting the needs of those students try yes so um our project ChalleNGe Program serves students who have been identified as gifted and challenged um as gifted and talented I'm sorry and our responsibility in Connecticut is to identify Services students who would qualify for those services but not necessarily actually provide services so we have solely an identification responsibility who meets the criteria of gifted and talented in Weston uh for a long time we have taken that responsibility one step further

082and provided support to students Patty you can correct me if I'm wrong but I think there are approximately 20 students in grades three through five who are currently being supported by that program yes about that yes so that's the cont text really so at the middle school Dan can you paint the picture at the middle school please yeah um so we have a few more students than that in our school because we cons we um the students are re-evaluated in fifth grade to see if anybody else qualifies to be identified and then any students that are new to Weston also get um uh assessed each year we have currently around 35 3 six students uh in our four grade so we have four sections um of project challenge here at the middle school can you

083talk about the um culminating experience or whatever what these students do Dan yeah so um the their main culminating experience is their Master project that they work on um it's an individual uh project uh of high interest to the student and um they work on that uh for quite a bit of the time especially in the second half uh of the year and it culminates in a in a fair that we have here at the middle school where each student is uh presenting uh their project and their learning uh to the school community and to the parents and how are we delivering that program now with the FTE that we have so we did have to get creative a few years back uh when we were looking to make some budget cuts and we folded

084that into the duties and responsibilities of our library media specialist which did seem like a really good fit because that's where the library media specialist can really assist students in their research and their exploration and Patty can you um speak a little bit to the um the intermediate school program I believe there's another culminating experience I think I attended it last year yeah so that similar to what uh Dan shared at the middle school our students uh they spent part of their day uh working in a classroom uh on a grade level um learning and then the majority is done work focusing on this master project that they work on individually or they could be working with a with a a a a classmate um and then it culminates in the spring in a maker

085Tech um a project challenge Fair um and those M those um Master projects are purely based on their individual interests and uh where they want what they want to uh learn more about or um study so when we say the0 five the0 five actually is an FTE that is allotted at uh Weston Intermediate School Patty can you talk about we T we have discussed internally and Dr hankle feel free to join in basically we're looking at students at find a passion in an area it could be in a variety of things I remember seeing one last year that had to do with science and creating um a research project around that area and then presenting it at both schools Patty why don't you start and then maybe Dr angle can fill in what we talked

086about about how we can not eliminate the FTE but still deliver the program right so when we're talking about it we're looking at a potential Staffing cut not a program cut I don't want you don't want to lose the program per se but it's looking at how we can still have that program for our students U maybe it look may look a little bit differently but still being able to um ensure the uh that experience for our kids um I I not we haven't flushed it all out but I really believe that we can make that happen with our with our current levels of Staffing I think which includes the library media specialist correct a piece and we have a current FTE that we think um it will work Tina can you add some color

087there yes sure you kind of started the the idea around curriculum enhancement and enrichment is really most connected to a library media specialist curriculum around digital literacy technology integration and um problem solving and critical thinking so as Dan mentioned it weaves really nicely um in uh alignment to um the library media specialist curriculum and supporting on how to enhance any content area that they're very skilled in um in their expertise in So at the Intermediate School we have approximately like Tracy and Patty mentioned between 20 and 24 students um that we've identified and given the fact that we currently create opportunities for all students at the Intermediate School through uh the digital literacy and digital citizenship curriculum that sh that our library media specialist um utilizes we believe that we can consider looking at schedule

088changes or look at um ways to enhance the current uh program through the library media specialist curriculum and see see how we can still um allow for Project based learning through critical thinking passion projects genius hour um to support project challenge um curriculum and support those 24 students per se through the library media specialist position it would require different scheduling it would require um us having a conversation around different way that Intermediate School currently um enhances the curriculum through the library media specialist Cur curriculum first and see where we can allocate time and think about um how to still uh provide some enrichment experiences um for students that are identified okay so I think when people see the list they say oh my God you're getting rid of the program we're really not we're doing

089kind of what we did at the uh uh middle school and again it goes back to looking very specifically at what people are doing um the next request is to reduce uh textbooks by $25,000 they um was a reduction we often quite frankly do this and we go and we look and we see um is it a want is it a need um to be determined that's still in uh negotiations with the principal's where but we feel comfortable that we can um reduce it by $25,000 um so that was the the next piece again these are very small pieces the next one is the whs cheerleading program and low participation is cited now the next two the drama and the leading program I'll be frank with you it's a 007 not really a lot okay

090we can certainly if you saying these are important programs we don't want to put them in I get it um but when you look at and again you say well why did it make the list well it made the list because the first of all there's no um winter cheerleading right now at the high school there weren't enough students uh to carry the the the program um it was I believe less than 10 I don't want to speak the number so we don't have it fall we have you can see that there are many many children um at the lower levels that absolutely adore and Love Cheerleading uh what we do find out is is you know um because cheerleading is a sport when they get to the high school many of them choose to

091play a a winter sport instead of doing winter cheerleading sports like ski team sports like basketball um th those Sports um so that's why we felt comfortable with putting it on the list it's a it's a nominal amount but you might say well why did you then well frankly if I'm not going to run an AP chem class or only do it every other year for the same number of students I do think it's appropriate that we put it on the list and we consider it um in looking at everything will $15,000 really break the budget clearly not the next again talks about um the fall drama program this is not um this is looking at one production within a drama program and looking at it through the lens of if you look at the

092drama or you look at um the other schools do one big production then perhaps this is something that we need to consider at the high school remember there are Productions that have stiens associated with them and there is also a company advisor and that the students do other types of performances that are not necessarily tied to a big production like it whether it be fall or spring that could still continue and in fact from the spring could be moved to the fall Patty I'm I'm gonna ask Patty F to speak a little bit to this because you know for those of you that don't know that was Patty's uh background before she um came with us and then she has always enriched that background so Patty can you talk a little bit about that for

093us I mean sure a lot of schools will do like a one year it's a drama one year it's a musical that could rotate that way there's other ways it can do student Le performances sort of the dialogues they have the dialogue performances move those into the fall instead of having two Productions in the spring those are uh more student Le Productions with there with your um company advisor overseeing that um uh there's there's lots of creative ways that um that you could draw maybe even more students in um to have that drama experience that like they used to have an improv group years ago at the high school I remember when they had that um again and that was company Le and the more student L but the company adviser sort of oversaw that

094so there are some creative ways of making sure that they don't lose that piece of the program thank you yeah I remember that improv group as a matter of fact and it was done through the company advisor it wasn't yeah a separate STI and you know these Productions cost about yeah 24 Grand to put on um with all the positions again it's a point what is it 0.004 so that brings us down to how did we get to it enrollment looking at overall program trying to be creative looking for ways that won't um detract from the program um but perhaps we can shift some things around and even oftentimes these are opportunities to revitalize um other areas that may have been um you know done in the past that um could we resurface again with

095that software um Dan DeVito I'm goingon to ask you to speak to this we can't hear you Dand Devita okay so yeah when when it comes to software we're every single year we look at redundancies and efficiencies and we're pretty confident that uh there's some software programs that we can Sunset without negatively impacting curriculum instruction so uh we're going to be uh it's to be determined because we have a couple in mind uh and we're going to evaluate and see which the best option is but you feel comfortable Dan with that number yes okay um so that's that's kind of it I hope I gave you enough flavor of where we're going so right now with those reductions you know it it's a042 reduction which gets us to a 3% um which is I think

096a very respectable number I think there is a reality here to go under 3% and you want more sustainable ility you're going to be cutting staff and adversely um affecting the uh overall experience of the western Public Schools that's the charge that's the charge we feel comfortable this is this budget has a 7.4 reduction of FTE 7.4 that's that I think is uh significant um I think that you know if does anybody else have any questions about the the items on the list if not we can go on to um the technology teaching and learning sorry I cut somebody off is that you Chad yeah go ahead go ahead okay I I have a quick question Lisa uh actually it might have been um uh Julie you said this I just want to understand a

097little bit better the tenure piece um I think reading between the lines what you're saying is that we have I think it was 18 or 19% of our staff is non- tenured uh there's quite a bit of our staff that uh it's quite good even though they don't have their tenure yet and if we were to do uh cuts it is uh last in first out so we would lose uh potentially quite a few really good non- tenyear teachers does that sort of encapsulate one of the themes of what you were saying Julie it does um I just I just want to be clear it's not exactly last in first out um the non-tenured staff is considered as a group of people who are qualified for a certain position and ultimately uh within that group

098it is the superintendent's decision it's not necessarily a matter of you were hired two days before I was and therefore I'm the one that's out um so it it can be a little bit complex but yes the long and the short of it is we we are talking about people who came to us uh many of whom with prior experience um as is articulated in some of the documents that were provided for you uh today and just because they are not tenured yet in our district they they would be part of that group okay add I'm sorry if I can just add about the uh the non-tenured um we take that responsibility very seriously full disclosure I was a Spanish teacher at jryan high and I lost my job because of declining enrollment moment look

099I ended up in Weston but I remember how that and I wasn't the first choice um I remember how that felt and we are very very committed to this staff we spent so much time hiring great staff and you know for example people have to let us know if they're going to come back from Child Wheeling I go so far as to if I know the the the person I'll call them up hey what are you thinking what's going on hey look we're not pressuring you you have to until this certain date but there are other people that this could impact it could impact their positions and anyone that if they have to move on from here for this reason we are committed to finding them another job and helping them that's what I experienced

100in a durg district that's how I ended up in Weston and that's really important we value people we work through it we look very carefully at what certifications are because um nobody wants to be in this position that being said it's a reality and how we respond both ways with the cut and then helping someone that's top-notch find another position you know I feel very very strongly about that so yeah and I agree with you this is not a position I think any of us want to be in and it it if if we're not at least having the conversation we're not really for in my opinion as a board of ed member I if we do share responsibility at least have the conversation so um Rel my next related question though is actually two-part

101question uh tenure only applies generally speaking to the folks that are standing in front of the classrooms directly educating our students right the the the support staff okay I see some okay so tenure does it apply I'm not picking on the guidance counselers it's just an easy social workers do they have tenure yes so under Connecticut's teacher tenure law um a teacher is defined both as a classroom teacher what you're envisioning but also so that that group encompasses um that people services staff that Tracy described this morning counselors social workers psychologists it also includes certified administrators all of those people have the ability to achieve tenure within a public school district in Connecticut based on certain Provisions uh related to their level of certification and their previous experience okay and then my last question related

102to this is um this is not about pushing out you know the senior folks FKS but they do tend to retire right they've worked a long time and they want to move on to stage two of their of their life which is you know where Lisa's going and Patty's going as much as we're sad to see you go um when do the conversations generally occur if you know as we're meeting today we have a staff that's instructing our students right now and counseling our students and doing all these things if we're going to have retirements in the spring when it's two-part question I guess when do those folks generally let you know Lisa or you know Julie and do you have proactive conversations with them during budget time like now uh to help forecast expected

103retirements so I will say you are currently aware through our consent agenda of all of those staff members who have already provided us notice of their intent to retire and you named them um there are conversations that are happening I've had requests to meet with certain people who are considering their retirement it is a significant consideration there have been some um recent changes in terms of um Social Security and retirement Provisions within the uh Municipal group that uh have caused some people to think differently about what their options might be um so there are some initial conversations that are happening I would expect that we will continue to have those conversations over the next several weeks um there is not a hard and fast deadline by which uh someone needs to provide us notice that

104they are choosing to retire as of the end of this year and while I would say we have uh a responsibility to provide resources and advice to those who are considering their retirement it is a little bit of a dangerous game to reach out to people preemptively to say hey are you thinking about retiring this year um we can provide resources we can provide information I'm working actually right now on um my monthly newsletter through HR that I send out to people to try and provide information about some of those changes in the laws that we've seen um but no we do not uh specifically Target certain people who are within a group who might be considering their retirement unless they reach out to us first thanks that's that's it for me could I respectfully

105sugges toy minute um break we have some members that would like uh five minutes right now is 10:35 could we come back we'll say 1040 is that okay thank you e e e yeah see e B [Music] okay if you're back if you could turn your cameras on so we know that you're ready to go that would be helpful can you hear me okay I'm speaking with a headset I just want to make sure sound quality is okay it's child it's a little muffled Chad hear you no I'll switch I'll switch off and not do that yeah that's better Lisa do you want me to jump in or did you want to start Lisa you're muted are we all back and ready to go are the principals back yeah it should be noted that today

106is Holocaust Remembrance Day so if you see some of our principles jumping on and off that's because they're uh making sure that the things are um moving smoothly along yeah just a little plug on that at our next uh curricul subcommittee meeting in February we will have our curriculum and instruction leader Shauna Johnson joining us to give us a synopse of today's events we have visitors and presentations um at the middle and high school throughout the day today Dina can you hear me better now or not much better yes okay good good good I'm off video because I have that my phone press up against my head apologies everyone I'm having to fly across the country today so I'll spare you the background of the airport uh I I'll pitch my two cents on the

107and then just I guess let others continue and then depending on when you want to segue I do have Tech questions on the technology documents you shared Lisa thank you for that but uh let me get my two cents on the budget first just to be a bit of a contrarian on this I I actually think you know before we Pat ourselves too hard in the back about cutting this and cutting that I don't know that we necessarily want to proceed with everything that's on this list I'll give you a couple examples I think the Administration has done a heck of a job demonstr like incredible fiscal Prudence in terms of trying to suggest some of these but I don't think we should necessarily say yes we should do each of these and the reason

108is is that we also have to take our administration's advice at face value that they're doing the very best to educate our children and give them an exceptional quality education here in Western Connecticut people move here for the schools in many ways it's the single biggest attraction to this neighborhood and there is such a thing as getting a sort of a a vicious cycle of reinforcing thing where we enforce some sort of um forced austerity that then actually ends up degrading the district after so slightly which decreases people's willingness and excitement to be in the district etc etc so as you're going through this laundry list of items to me but I think the administration will know better of course but to me some of these things like seem like maybe they're fiscally prudent and

109some seem like a genuinely bad idea uh the fall drama program seems to me concerning project challenge definitely seems concerning with when you see as much concern about cutting of gifted and talented programs across the country I know that you're suggesting this is not a cut but an adaptation uh the Chinese language phasing out perhaps that does seem seem to make some sense as do the cheerleading program based on what you said Lisa I'm not so convinced about the Spanish but anyway my point is simply before we get too carried away patting ourselves in the back about carving off an extra 15K here or an extra 30k here the first and foremost question we should be asking ourselves is is this good for our kids and is it good for the district and so I

110think it is worth asking the question if to achieve these budget cuts we're talking about cutting headcount do we want to cut head count so that's my provocative question to throw into this whole equation uh you all can can do without what you will I'm going to listen for a moment Lisa did you want to transition out to technology or not yes okay so now we have um technology and learning this is document two and Dr hankle and uh Mr duo will take us uh through this and then at the end uh we will entertain questions the stage is yours oh great thank you good morning is it still morning yes it is okay so um just to clarify we um have began this technology conversation since our first uh board ofed Workshop in on

111January 7 so there is um this is our third document now that we have provided to you regarding whether it's technology equipment and or the enhancement or use and purpose of um technology in the classroom so specific typically the the third document that was provided to you on Friday um was in response to three broad uh three or four broad conversations around technology and intention of Technology um the first is specifically talks about instructional software tools and how we currently use specific tools throughout the district not only for students but also for teachers so that they have an opportunity to achieve high levels of success and engagement in the classroom in that response we went through and tried to paint a very clear picture around different usage and rationale around um instructional software specific instructional

112pedagogy and and um the way in which that we um use technology to enhance the learning also cited with specific research which is always how we ground a lot of our pedagogical conversations in um and education um um and so that was the first portion of the response we also wanted to highlight some of the ways in which we balance um the amount or or use of screen time and and ensure that it is developmentally appropriate we're not overusing technology we're not using it as a hindrance we recognize that um you know students in a kindergarten level versus students at a senior level um are using it differently and um the balance in which we are using the technology is definitely something that we are very mindful of so that we're using in moderation and

113have uh explicit purpose and intentionality um the third component of that document was focused around Brain Breaks um we really wanted to uh lean into that conversation a little bit it kept coming up um so we had an opportunity to really ask specific questions around brain breaks and um um movement breaks uh whatever whatever topic you want to mention and the importance of um allowing for students to kind of step away and re re fire their brains before they transition to a new content area specifically so we added some explicit um topics and research around that and then finally based on some uh requests in the field uh we involved our staff around some of these same conversations through a survey um to give a full picture the survey was sent out last Friday we

114usually allow about a week for staff to respond there's a lot going out on throughout the the district and so we did have some hiccups in our week's plans and we wanted to make sure that we gave enough time for staff to respond um we did offer an open-ended response uh question in our survey and some of those responses are also in uh in included in um the document we sent out on Friday so with that being said we wanted to make sure people had more time um to respond to the survey and um so we did extend that out a little bit further so um the synops basically on the last part of this document was really talking about um we asked about 20 questions to our staff and Julie mentioned earlier you know

115about 90% of our positions in the district are directly related to you know interacting with students um facing directly related to facing students and student instruction um of the 197 participants that we received on our survey it represented 83% of our teachers we are really um thankful that the distribution that we gathered across all the different grade bands were was pretty equal so we had about an equal distribution ution of responses from prek to2 3 to 5 6 to 8 9 to 12 and um those 20 questions that we asked range from um you know specifically technology usage and the amount of time that we use technology on a given day or a given week we also talked about um usage of homework and atome Technology usage with activities we talked about the impact of

116technology on instruction and the given outcomes that the teacher see um for students we also ask specific questions around challenges and barriers you know what challenges do you face when you use technology in your classroom what aspects of instruction are most affected by technology if you if it were to be removed when it comes to delivering high quality instruction in the classroom we also talked about um asked questions regarding student engagement in 21st Century Learning and preparedness um in the long term for students as they graduate Weston um we ask specific questions around wellness and brain breaks and how they use technology to um provide opportunities for movement-based activities in the classroom and um whether or not they feel that technology helps to facilitate some of those activities throughout the throughout the day or the

117week and then finally like I mentioned we also asked uh we gave them the floor we asked them to um if they had any additional feedback or thoughts about our survey and why we're asking them to engage in that conversation today and um we gave some highlights um we gave some highlights to the openend of responses so in general as as we said um on this on the summary you know 92.3% of our Educators believe that technology is positively enhancing engagement and the experience for students in the classroom um and um you know we really feel that uh this opportunity for teachers to engage in this survey really helped solidify some of what we've been talking about over the last couple meetings with all of you and now we have some explicit data to back

118that up and some also maybe qualitative components that also um also shed a light on how the teachers and the educators are feeling around this topic as well so that's kind of the summary of The Last the third document that we've provided to you I know we have given explicit um responses given to the equipment um requests in the budget but then also we talked a little bit more about um the application the integration in the classrooms um in uh a previous document as well to this one Lisa did you want me to highlight anything else no Mr javito you spent considerable time looking over the data do you have any highlights to add just wanted to make one uh comment one of the a bunch of the um open-ended responses as as well as

119some of the questions did highlight the need for properly functioning technology uh the teachers did feel that you know one of the biggest downsides is when the Chromebooks in grades 3 through eight are down just due to their age it then sets them back a little bit uh when students have to wait for them to either get a loan or Chromebook or for it to get fully replaced so that's really all I wanted to touch on but it's not just Chromebooks it's also the other technology correct and this gets quite Frank ly at the Staffing that you have in your technology department because we talked about that as well um and how important it is this just in time service if you can elaborate on that please yeah sure so you know with all the

120with the the district technology staff is they're constantly running around to make sure that everything is fixed as quickly as possible and it and it can be difficult at times when you have older equipment and especially front facing equipment that needs to be fixed because we know that it's negatively impacting the education experience so so uh you know and we've also had staff members mention you know the the fact that they need a Smartboard if they have an old piece of equipment or they don't have a Smartboard in their classroom so it did stress the need for the technology equipment as well as the support for the technology equipment questions yeah I'll jump in real quick uh Tino just to confirm one thing Dr hanle the document just so I'm making sure I'm looking the

121right one at the end of it there was the 92% number and then a handful of qualitative uh responses that the actual survey was not included nor was a the sort of citation document with the various studies that were referenced in it is that right so the document in the beginning portion of right the citations and the yes and the research was provided in a a previous document well and in the there was actual research in the first couple question before we gave a summary of the of the technology survey um yeah yeah so we we are in the process of itemizing every individual question as I mentioned we usually like to give about a week for staff to participate we had a little bit of a hiccup to our schedule at the end of

122last week um so we just gave a brief overview and summary of the data that we gathered based on some of those questions gotcha if it's possible even if we don't have the final responses and to share the questions before tomorrow that would be great reason being is like I'm I'm happy to see some of the responses from The Faculty about how you know essential they see this that kind of thing but not all technology is created equal meaning rain breaks are different from a Google chart different than a Smartboard different than something else so I am curious in terms of where they think there are uh potential areas that are not so useful anyway I'll I'll sort of give you my whole gist on this and then I'll I'll just listen so that I

123don't bother you all with background airport noise uh so that would be great to see the Brain Breaks themselves I still think we need to look look a little more closely at that reason being some of the research you have cited is from ' 05 09 04 06 things like that and the idea that a video game essentially which is what a lot of brain braks are is necessary or even actually does what the research says Brain Breaks do is dubious which would be another example of when we could potentially have a cost savings uh thing instead of that software platform have the teacher lead The Hokey pokei or have a student lead a dance maneuver whatever and I know in the past we've talked about you know there's ableism involved with that but you

124could have a student do it anyway my point is like not every single thing within this is necessarily equal so uh I think it's worth looking at but the bigger Point really is that if we're talking about staff cuts which is the first part of this conversation then I think buying a bunch of new Chromebooks is a silly use of the district's money I am perfectly happy to be proved wrong by what the faculty say in terms of the essential nature of all this but if we're actually talking about removing teachers and buying Chromebooks I think it's a I think it's a misguided philosophy well we're talking about two of the teachers that were uh taking out from the classroom at Intermediate School is strictly deal to enrollment uh purposes we would do that regardless

125of whether we had the technology or not and I want to be very clear I have presented this budget to the different faculty during the time when this survey went out and there was a great deal de of chatter amongst them saying you're going to take away our technology one person frankly said I guess I better go look and go work in another District I'll go to another durg District where they value it so you talk about unintended consequences that's an unintended consequence as well I did also want to bring up the concept that if uh new equipment if new Chromebooks uh were not purchased that's actually going to increase the downtime because now we'll be on year six for those Chromebooks and if we're not going to be removing them we're not going to

126take them out they're part of they're embedded in curriculum instruction so we do have to factor in the increase exponential increase in downtime where if you have a classroom of 20 students and you have three Chromebooks that are offline now and they're either waiting for a replacement or or waiting to get a laner which we're becoming more and more short on then those students then suffer from they they can't learn at the same level and speed as everybody else so I did want to keep everyone into consideration that it's not a yes or no not replacing the Chromebooks does then increase the downtime of the existing Chromebooks yeah well so look I'm I'm more than happy to be proved wrong on this whole thing maybe that's if you can't share questions or some more dat

127before tomorrow if you can't do that then maybe we have we can have more of a tomorrow before the vote but if I'm just wrong about this then that's great news because then then I'm a Lo voice and actually we're using technology really well and if this just forces us to look a little more closely at some of the I think great uses like brain breaks Etc then then great and if I'm wrong then I'm wrong and then I will I will stop wasting everyone's time on this if the faculty really says that this is uh not just an important but a deeply essential need so I'll stop talking now thank you thank you we appreciate that and as we um whenever we uh give student surveys out we always let parents come in and

128look at those surveys we're more than happy to provide you with the survey we will get it out this afternoon um of what the questions look like absolutely is there is there more to the this morning's presentations Lisa yes we saved the best for last okay Phil you're on sir we're GNA talk about I think we need to have a conversation about the capital budget great thanks Mike hey good morning everybody thanks for uh thanks for having me to explain a little bit better off what we have going on here so I know there's a little bit of frustration with um with capital budget and timing of pricing and things like that the last couple years we've uh taken it upon ourselves because of numbers that came in skewed so one thing to note is

129that numbers that we have here these are direct proposals these aren't estimates or guesstimates or some sort of engineered ideas these are actually hard cost with material outlined so it did take a little bit longer we're already working on next years and the following years so I don't foresee this continuing for another year but that's that's what the delay was with some of the costs it was actual walkthroughs with mechanical contractors um with all the necessary pieces electrical companies and fire fire companies so these are actual hard costs so I'll go over a CLE the things that the numbers were put in we have one addition one move so the one addition that we have is um it's energy management software Hardware upgrade what we have is we have a beginning to have a licensing

130issue that began January of this year um we have told about October to do some sort of an upgrade to protect us against any kind of any kind of in and also so we can get on with our our equipment now I have a zoom meeting coming in the next few weeks with their it department and Our IT department with Dan um Dan's already been made aware of the project and he's been working with me um hand in hand because I don't really understand the it side of it so this is just this is just a number and we're hoping that these numbers will change but the $40,000 was put in because that would be the Max cost if things stay the way that they are we had one move move the one move was

131just because we need to get a little bit more information and I didn't like the way the project was going and this was the Weston High School the front foyer HVAC Edition to the um to the area um I got a I got a rough estimate there which includes all the the material and the Tradesmen but it didn't like the way that it was going so we push this back um at least until next year but we have some cost put in for our which was our districtwide Energy Efficiency upgrades for for all buildings and by the way we do have a walkthr going right now with our audit company so we will have a much better idea where we are with this but the first number was about $75,000 for the LED retrofit this

132would just be hardened figure just for lighting um not the hvc side of it just lighting uh upgrades um and both get an itemized idea of where we're going to be a little bit better off the next few weeks as to what locations we're going to hit classrooms and move on from there ideally it will be a little bit of each building not just focus in one building and move we have a cost of where are we $190,000 for the Western High School locker room replacement of the heating system including air conditioning we have a struggling unit um that we're looking to have changed out back in ' 06 when the addition was put on they tied into the unit to do two additional large space rooms so over the time the unit's just beginning

133to fail and we're having a hard time just keeping up with the heating aspect of it so now we're looking to just change the rooftop unit and have it a self-contained unit with heating cooling fresh air that was the second Coster we' have gotten in the next one was the Weston Intermediate School of V V box Electronics what this is is you have about roughly 80 or so rooms large space small spaces closets miscellaneous rooms that have their own temperature control so you have a unit that feeds a certain degree and then you have a makeup unit in every room closet large space to find fine-tune the temps it's just such a huge square footage rooms are different east side of the building north side of the building uh west side of the building so

134temperatures are different um and when the building was built this is what that was introduced so this is the electronic side so it can be monitored through Energy Management um that cost I believe was roughly yeah $165,000 for all all all units and the one scary number that everyone is seeing is the um the Elementary School North house HVAC replacement so this this in includes an upgrade repleting the both plants the heating side cooling side the initial 400 everyone has seen has been that was just an S&P number back in 17 just to add air conditioning into the spaces which would just been in Split systems similar to what we have in the south and east but it would not have it would not have recogniz rectified our issues with the unit ventilators that are

135from the 60s and 70s so this this cost is a lake for Lake univ ventilator and after we get our analysis done engineered um specs we could see if we could do any sort of large scale air handler or rooftop unit but that will all be determined within the next several months everything else has remained but those are the costs that were added With The Changes um I don't see anything else on my end I'm sure you guys have questions but that's really the whole nutshell that I have you guys oh I take back the uh PA system which was uh line two the PA system is for the high school for middle school for elementary school this is the PA this is the Bell System this is everything integrated with the um the systems

136and again today we had the high school go down which happens every every month or so um in every building we have one of these go down we have a hard cost phase one is going to be the three schools at $100,000 next year will'll be faced two changing of the um the clocks that go with the system and that is all I have for you guys I'm sure you have questions and I'm here so in terms of next year's capital budget not the current fiscal year we're talking about we moving how much into next year um only one was moved to next year if I'm understanding your question right Steve yeah that's right yeah that was just the high school unit um for the just the addition when the addition was put on in

137' 06 they removed two Heating units for makeup heat to to allow for the open space so this was just something to um bring those units back but I didn't like where it was going so this is the only this is the only project I shifted to next year okay I have a couple of questions I was waiting to see if anybody else wanted to jump in um I'm still confused year-over-year why we pay for things like LED Audits and Replacements when as a consumer um I can get that done at no cost from ever source and I don't um read a ton about um what schools are eligible for but I get enough that in them that I always feel like there are funds set aside for schools to be able to access this

138type of stuff at no cost so can you bridge that gap for me why uh we pay for that yeah no the analysis that we're having done now for the uh for the um for the LED retrofit is there is no cost there's a cost that goes to the company doing it but it's paid by eversource so we haven't spent a dime to move forward with any kind of analysis if we have to go any deeper then there could be an Associated cost to the buildings but at this point with our walk through and where we're going to get direction there is no cost out of Weston's pocket okay and then my other question which one of the um one of our community members brought up at our meeting last week I don't know the

139answer to this question myself so why did hhac go from 400,000 to north of 1.5 million okay the initial cost that was put on from S&P back in 2017 was strictly the addition of dis SPC air conditioners which are the units that go outside and the units that sit on the wall that only takes care of one aspect of our North house issue that did not include any of the air handlers for the gyms for the science build for the science piece or any of the classroom unit ventilators so there 24 somewhat rooms we have a gymnasium hallways so there's a lot more to it than just what S&P had put on for the $400,000 for the addition of air conditioning to the spaces okay so are we um talking about se you know again

140layman's terms here centralized air conditioning for the north house so we get away from those portable units and those window units yeah it's it could it could go either way um we don't know if we have the space for a rooftop unit or an air handler so to speak but at least this cost is associated right now is a like for like with the addition to air conditioning into the unit ventilator as opposed to the unit ventilators that we have in place now that are strictly just heat okay A couple of years ago um I walked through Hess with I want to say it was you Lisa I'm not positive but it was you right so um actually I'm sure right and what one of the things that we talked about if I remember correctly

141is that there appears to be an enormous cost to maintain these individual window units and units they lend themselves to humidity we wind up with tiles that get moldy so it was seem to like this system in place today is expensive to maintain but we're thinking we're thinking about replacing them with similar I'm just I'm can you clarify that piece well if we can let me let me try and then Mike can jump in the reality is is something needs to be done about the air handling units and Laura is shaking her head at North house okay um you just have to walk down the second grade class the whole second grade's there and two classes of first grader on the bottom floor plus the gym is there it has to be done now we

142are also being very cognizant of you know there might be other things we need to do in that building that is extremely old so how we approach it because let's face it I don't think anything will be done any other way for for years to come we've got to be able to do something now to improve it so I'll turn it over to you Mike as to how we're kind of trying to maneuver this that has been neglected Mike before you start so so David it is not a like to life this is an addition we currently only have unit ventilators that provide heat into the space and what we have right now to your point is that we have four of the units in some of the classrooms so this is a brand new

143system that will address both the heating and coolant we should address and also ultimately address the humidity issues that we have in that building but will it address and sorry Mike then you can answer the question so I think I do remember correctly from walking the building with Lisa a few years ago these portable units are thorns in everyone's side from I understand from the maintenance people to the moisture that they create to the ability to maintain them to the damage they do to the ceiling tile so I'm my my question is more along the lines of if we're going to spend money are we spending it right and even if it means more money so I'm not suggest you know this might be one of the few times that you hear me say in

144this budget we should spend more um but you know we should be doing things right uh so yeah so my question is are we expanding on a system we know is not good or like yeah can you just explain that for the 1.5 or so yeah we're trying to upgrade so we we're going to issue an RFB with a request to design the system for the nor house we just don't know if we have the room for duck work which would be if it was a rooftop unit or an air handler for different rooms or different spaces so be it but the cost the cost has generated is a unit ventilator with cooling integrated into it which would allow also Fresh Air Heating and Cooling to maintain the space those portable units would be gone

145and it would just be the units on the wall ideally um uniters will not be put back in and we will have a cenal system whether it's two or three units we just don't know before we issue or get the response back for the request for design if we have the capabilities of putting a large scale hbac unit in with duck work to Feed and Supply Air heating fresh air to the spaces okay so this is more like a a budget placeholder so to speak because we know we need to do something I've heard this year-over year and this will this come back uh to us as a board to approve um the expenditure because of the dollar amount or just by approving it in the budget uh that gives you the ability to pick

146what you perceive to be the best option and proceed with that we'll we'll see where we are when we get the um request for design back ideally we'll be in a much better place and they they'll surprise us with a an upgraded system that we could put in as opposed to what we're doing but um I'm sure something with this cost and magnitude I'm sure would be discussed and and What's the timing of all that we we should have within the next few months the design built as to what we can do to upgrade the north house HVAC system so we really won't know for we probably we're probably end of the school year end of the school year and then we can start moving forward to how we're going to do it for the

147next fiscal year that's correct and then oh so on that comment if if we this is going to be a fiscal 27 project I don't think the the work could even be started till 27 but if we wait till 27 to allocate the fundage and we don't order equipment till July 1 it will never be done at that point so if we have our scope brought back to us from the um from the RFD and we have a we have a vision of what we're going to do moving forward to what equipment we're going to do we can pre- purchase the equipment before the school year ends and get working on this as soon as the school year ends which is the next school year Michael couldn't we I think Steve this might be kind

148of the direction you're kind of leaning towards if this isn't going to be an expenditure until possibly 27 and I'm not in any way saying this doesn't need to be done I like I said spoke with Lisa years ago and I walk the building and this has been known for years if we need to get a design and we want pre purchase at the end of this fiscal year and we haven't approved it in the budget aren't aren't two things potentially true number one uh we potentially have some money in the non laping account specifically designed for this purpose I feel like but number two we could go to the town for special appropriation as well especially for something like this which is a capital expenditure well first of all we don't have money in

149a non-aps in account so the question is do we've ask for do we ask the town to create up a to create a non-aps account funded partially this year and the balance in 2027 so that's a conversation I can have and Mike how much of the expenditure is equipment versus labor do you think uh generally what you see with any kind of project like this it could go 5050 or it could go roughly a third material twoth thirds labor okay thanks Michael you gonna say something uh no no I'm fine thanks okay Lisa we where is Lisa oh there you are upper right hand side of my screen is there is there more that you'd like to discuss this morning yes Bill take it away I give a Qui Insurance on health insurance um I

150know there's been conversation that the numbers that we have presented um over the past couple of weeks have been more of an estimate um I have received some updated information as it relates to claims experience um for the period July through December and unfortunately we are not seeing any kind of improvement as it relates to those claims as it s as of December our claims our claims experential loss ratio is pretty much 120% 20% which means that the insurance compan is paying 20 20% more than what we have paid in in in claims in addition um there's one company that has responded uh to the RP that we issued that was issued by Brown and Brown and their first stake is that the increase will be somewhat in the tune of 40 plus per over

151our current rates so what we presented sorry I'm sorry I just want to make sure 4 Z okay 4 zero um so the rates that we have presented are rates that are from the state partnership plan and as it stands right now all indications are that may be the direction that we're heading um we still have not heard from sign in terms of what their final numbers will be um but I'm not overly optimistic that we'll see any significant improvements over where we are right now just to give some some perspective the state partnership on a premium on based on the premium premiums only are somewhat similar to what we have projected from for Sigma pretty much means that they're pretty much the same the same the same cost the savings that we're seeing our

152savings related to not funding not needing to fund an HSA and also the increased funding from the opep trust fund for retirees so I'm saying all that to say that the numbers that we have for health insurance at this point those can be considered to be solid so does that mean so does I may be wrong about this does that mean the number you gave us where we thought there might be savings is now not the case no no no no the savings the savings that we have um approximately $800,000 that that's those savings are solid we do not um at this point anticipate to see anything better than that if we are great but I shouldn't I do not that be the case and just to give just to give some more perspective um

153what we're what Weston is seeing in terms of claims experience is not isolated to to Weston the state is also seeing an increase in in their Clans experience in fiscal 24 the overall increase for active employees was 2% on the state partnership plan in November the state gave their gave their initial projection to roughly be for Fairfield County to be about 11% the state gave an updated percentage in January and that number increased by 2% um the final numbers will be known in March but as right now there's no indication from anywhere that we'll be seeing anything better than what we currently have okay thanks pH so Phil the savings there just I think you put a finer point on it right there are savings that are real but the the savings are not necessarily

154in the cost in the premium cost it's in the funding of the hsas is that that's okay um is there any reason to think that we will not be able to make that change if it turns out that that is the best way to go to move forward is there is there anything Visa V contract related Etc that that may preclude us from doing that and then of course elevating the cost if if the if the private you know if the RFP comes back that's you know that's higher than expected sure so so so two pieces to it um the requirement for the state partnership plan is that all groups um should should be transferred to to to the to the plan the second part of is that we just need the unions to to

155agree um on this move again so the the if we are to make a change um Mid mid contract um it has to be a like for like um plan um and the state partnership plan is a lightful life planine meaning in terms of in terms of services that are offered in terms of coverage in services yeah yeah um is there is there any reason to think that the Unions would be not inclined to to go ahead and improve and and you know the move if we chose if we you know deemed at that point that that was appropriate for us at this point I'm going to say no okay um just to that end um I just want to Circle back Phil on a question asked I don't know if you have the answer

156I think I think Steve sort of looked into this a little bit as well but I just wanted to be clear on it um I know we're due for a vote soon it does seem like there a lot of items here that are still tbds and placeholders um the question I guess is um if we voted on it prior to the board of Finance voting what is the process by which it could come back to us for reconsideration is that something that is an you know a determination for ourselves or do other boards does the board of Finance have to agree to let us sort of reconsider the budget once again do you guys know that that answer so it's not necessarily say that it comes back to us if we have new information that

157that will change the budget then we will present that either to the board of Selectmen or to the board of um Finance Prior to their final votes and and they they can well you know let's say something came in you know I don't know you know if something came in you know much much much cheaper much more expensive we would present that to them and then it would be under their consideration as to whether or not to accept the new estimate is that am I thinking about that correctly well yeah go ahead right so ultimately the board of Finance has a number in mind so even if we give them a number plus or minus it's not necessarily that they're going to accept our number if the board of Finance determines that the funding for

158the Board of Education should be X and if the number that we have given them is in excess of X then we would have to find room within our budget to make to meet um their their X okay I I I think I understand that I mean basically it's but but it's but it's their they're making a determination look they're taking our recommend our recommended budget then they're making determination and then if if there are if there was any other changes plus or minus to the numbers that we want to Comm we would obviously communicate they would take that to consideration but that wouldn't necessarily be us having to rote on it is that does that is that correct normally anything that is presented to any other board is normally first discussed and approved with

159the board of the Board of Education right so there's no subsequent approval if things happen to change you know let's say you know materially when when when you say discussion would let me better understand that no I was I was saying that there's no there's no um there's no sort of subsequent sort of discussion slash vote if things happen to change materially and we need to reconsider you know an item or two in the budget there's none of that we just present the updated numbers as you know as we find out about them and then they sort of take that to consideration when they're looking at the pre-approved budget and what they have in mind in terms of the board of vets budget is that is that correct from a discussion perspective if the board

160of Finance should reduce the budget the Board of Education would need to make a det in terms of what exactly within our budget will be reduced or similar to what we did last year was that we just listed the item as a as a as a TBD right okay so just to kind of put a button in I think what Michael's asking ultimately if we vote tomorrow and approve the budget that is essentially um we're essentially saying at that point we're in agreement with all aspects of the budget uh there are things that I know couldn't can change Phil uh the the requests can go down if there are savings and stuff like that really what we're doing is we're saying this is the cap um this is what we've approved but our work is

161then done so if we I think if we as a board of ed don't think certain areas have been thoroughly vetted or looked at or we think that uh there's still some more questions about the ability to pick up efficiencies or what program utilization and stuff like that once we vote that ship has sail not right as far as our ability to compel the administration we we voted on the budget you not you know we we we have to deliver under the charter a budget by February 3D to the board of selected I think if I may the important part is and I I would encourage you to read the town Charters uh article 9 because what you are voting on it's entitled preliminary budget estimate must be done by right February 3D that's Monday

162and it goes to the Selectmen and it says when you look at the duties of the board of selectman they hear the budget they can suggest things okay then it goes to finance Finance can tell us needs to be CAU by this amount I think that again I go back to Phil this is a marathon clearly clearly we want if there is something that comes up or whatever with anything that it's going to reduce it then um certainly um with insurance or whatever that that we would um look that look at that and communicate that because that I think is our fiduciary responsibility to the town what we're asking you to do this week is to vote on this preliminary budget uh request and I think it's interesting the way they they write that in

163the charter preliminary budget as estimate okay Finance can cut selectman can suggest what one last question for you Phil just on the insurance bit um I if if the unions come back and say actually you know if it's deemed that we want to move to the to the SP then the unions basically vote now decline what is what is there any recourse to that decision are we are we then sort of stuck with the with with the current plan that we have um at a potential potentially elevated cost let's just say I don't want to say yes or no to that question I think ultimately what we what we have to do is whatever it is we have to negotiate with the unions it may mean that we may have to offer up some concessions

164to the union or it could go either way um so it's not as if we're saying to the union this is the plan this is what we have to do we'll we we have to really reopen our reopen negotiations with the unit at that point and see if there's any concessions that either party can give also part of our challenges I know there's been people in the public that are like how could you vote on this it's premature you don't even have these numbers it takes time to get them it takes time to get these projections no one has been trying to stall this and there is the reality by the charter that we have this date we are doing the very best we can um to move this forward there's no reason to be

165defensive so you know we have a budget I just want to clear because I know I I've heard and and read what some some people are putting out there and saying and I just want to clarify that we're really working hard here to get the information we didn't stall on it this is the timeline and unfortunately in a perfect world the timeline goes with the charter here it doesn't but I trust um what Mr Cross is saying and I think that um this working through this insurance is certainly very doable okay anything more fail Lisa um yes there is something more and it's kind of along uh what Chad said so tomorrow we have another uh Board of Education meeting there will be public comment at the beginning we um gave our reasons behind why

166certain um programs and things were on this list um to get this and pH I I need your help here if we do these reductions I believe where we will be at 3 like 01 budget is that correct Phil that's correct and if we say you know what we don't want to go there with um a couple of the things and put them back on the on the list for example the drama uh the cheerleading something like that then we would be at a 3.07 if you will um we are very confident when we look at this it's I shouldn't have written the word eliminate project challenge um restructure project challenge because we did this at the middle school and it was very successful and we think that these uh this list is um is

167appropriate and it will not diminish the overall educational and coo experience I guess what I would like is we're going to send you the computer the the technology uh survey Dr angle is putting together the clean copy so you can look at it and I want you to to really start to think um if there's anything else that you would need um for tomorrow um we would be happy to provide it but basically we're looking at a we're presenting either a 3.01 or if we add a couple of those things on a 3.07 for all intents and purposes I think it's a three% budget which um correct me if I'm wrong MREs when the finance depart Finance board was working on different projections and in the future they said a 3% budget would be dare

168I say a respectable number yeah that's that's the case that's the case so we got there and we certainly hope that you support it thank you so can you just uh tell us so for for tomorrow you you can kind of see I think leading to tomorrow's meeting there maybe there isn't full agreement on some of the Board of Ed members of you know what's been done Chad clearly I think Peter for that matter don't want to see any of the cuts that have been uh presented I think to your point Lisa project challenge actually H to of my kids didn't you participate in Project challenge because I would hate to see that cut it's not being cut it's just being retooled so to speak so tomorrow are we going to be are you presenting

169us essentially two options one with the recommended cuts that uh we talked about one without is it going to be eight different options because there's some of those cuts like what what are we what should we be prepared tomorrow uh to see I think that we listen to the public comment um and then I think that you know my suggestion would be is the administrative team will talk this afternoon but um it's going to be like I said between a 3.01 and a 3.07 there's no eight other options maybe we can um split the difference on the cuts on the list and we can work on that and give us uh our your suggestions to it but I would sort of come to terms with the 3% budget and see if that um is something

170that you can support if I'm being clear now if you want something else pleasee tell us please tell us and we'll we'll look at it differently Lisa just just to clarify as well are we asking the board to vote on all the items for each suggested recommend suggested recommendation that we presented plus or minus I you know I help with how you want to do this no you're gonna present a budget uh we're you know we're not going line by line unless people want to but it doesn't seem to make a lot of sense I mean there's a gazillion lines well look in looking at this the only in looking at this list and the and the proposed Cuts I I don't want to speak for the administrative team but I will tell you that

171you know if we just decide to um put back in another $35,000 that's only a .06 increase which would be a 3.07 it just present a budget to tomorrow that you're comfortable with that's fine and we'll and there'll be obvious discussion that's fine does that uh meet everybody's needs here yes yeah there's anything else that anybody um wants uh please reach out to me and I will um make sure you get the answer that you need the only item I would ask the only item I would ask for Phil for tomorrow is just even clearer words for myself and the community how the insurance piece is 700 some OD thousand uh how that you envision impacting potentially our budget in years moving forward um I know you can't you don't have a crystal ball but

172I feel like there's a potential savings if we go to state partnership but then there might not be and if we do we lock ourselves in for three years so I just think that we need to be clear there is I think there may may or may not be a savings this year I think what you're looking at is the Simplicity of if we go we know what the premium would be for the state partnership plan right so you're kind of using that as this is worst case scenario for fiscal year uh uh 2526 but we then lock ourselves into this for two years more right because it's a three-year agreement um and we exited the state partnership plan I think it was three or four years ago because the cost skyrocketed so uh we

173wouldn't be able to exit it for two years it is that right that's that's the risk yeah and just for the clarity it's a commitment we're pretty much joining in with a commitment that will be on the plan to three years um if we should exit after say year one there's a 5% penalty so there's really a penalty that's associated with exiting the plan prior to the end of the three years so again so I'm I'm still trying to understand what part of the discussion so far has not been clear to you David no it's not that I I want to make sure I understand that the potential $700,000 savings is based on we don't know for sure what the premium is going to be from our current carrier we know what the cost is

174to go to the state partnership plan right and that is been factored in as worst case scenario so if our current carrier comes in with a lower increase one presumes will go with that but if they come in with a higher increase we know the cap is the the state partnership plan right correct okay but the risk which Steve validated the the the risk is that uh the state partnership plan is in fact less expensive this year but now we're locked into the state partnership plan for two more years beyond that which was the very reason we exited the state partnership plan a few years ago was because the initial rate looked pretty good and then uh we we couldn't I if I remember correctly we couldn't exit it because of the con the teachers

175contracts but as soon as we could exit it we did so again if in year two we determine that the the rate increase is more than what we can afford we can make a decision in year two to exit the plan if we can find a cheaper alternative the the the cost associated with leing est State partnership plan after year one is a 5% penalty so again it's a commitment but if the state is telling us in year two that we're going to be faced with a 20% um increase one again everything goes back to claims if our claims experience is such that it it's a 20% increase is Justified I can't I cannot tell you that a that a carry is going to look at that and say you know what West then based

176on your claims experience at 120 to 130% loss ratio I'm going to give you a reduction in your rates I can't guarantee that I'm saying that this is the best option that's out there right now because of the ability to pull all the claims the rates fluctuate um again so we have had years where the state has their initial numbers where has come in higher and and and come March that number settle for a lower amount this year they're starting higher it's a possibility that it could be less but I think where we are at 11 to 13% is really the cap on those rates for fiscal 26 okay so we we have a motion to adjourn and take it up tomorrow so moved there second hey thanks everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.