CorpusRecord 112359

Board of Education Special Meeting (Public Forum #2 with Administration on Budget Request)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WPS Meetings
Date
2025-01-24
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,315 words · about 41 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001right we're live great thank you uh good evening everyone uh it's January 23 uh 23rd 2025 uh it's 703 and this is a Weston Board of Education special meeting it's our second uh public form uh to review the uh Western Board of Education uh budget for fiscal year 2526 um we have a quorum so the first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance so I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all as we do with uh uh all meetings where we have public comment uh we read a uh read a statement ahead of uh ahead of taking public comment the board welcomes the opportunity to hear from members of the

002public about matters concerning Weston Public Schools public comment is an important chance for the board to receive input and feedback from our school school Community we listen attentively to all comments shared while we value and pay close attention to public comment it is our practice not to respond substantively or sometimes not at all uh during public comments and there are several reasons for this first engaging in a discussion on non-agenda items could violate the board's obligation to comply with the Freedom of Information Act second the board or the administration may not be prepared to discuss certain matters raised in the first instance by a public comment third the board develops its meeting agenda carefully to ensure that the board addresses matters that are pressing or relevant at the time of the meeting we encourage members

003of the public with specific questions concerns or complaints about our schools to reach out directly to superintendent barbiero and you may also email the board at our email address Board of Education westonps.org and additional details on public comment at board meetings can be found on the board of education website and so with that jod um Lisa do you want to say anything in advance or should we go right to public comment right right to public comment she's working on something all right um I have a few attendees um I'm going to call your name um I'm going to promote you to a panelist when I do there's going to be something that pops up on your screen please click on it to allow yourself to be promoted from an attendee to a panelist once I

004promote you you will have five minutes to speak and just prior to speaking could you please State your full name and your street address in Weston Alex I'm going to promote you to a panelist okay Alex you've joined the meeting please take yourself thank you for turning your camera on and just State your full name and your street address Alex Staley 42 Lords Highway so I have um a few questions and comments um and I had sent an email so I appreciate the response from Phil cross on the uh Healthcare stuff a couple things I'm gonna start with the capital budget so as a general matter it's a bit frustrating as we get two public comment times the first one the capital budget had tbds on pretty much half more than half of the items

005and then the for this public comment period the capital budget was updated but the date actually on the file is as of today which again a little frustrating that of that that you're just filling in the capital budget and expecting the public to comment on it second off it actually was was it posted as a revised budget so I actually had to go back into the original file to see that it was updated so without having known that I was assuming that the budget hadn't changed and there were still tbds okay so very frustrating from a transparency of information to really understand what's going on in the budget in light of what I just said that's number one number two on the actual numbers despite all of that you guys are proposing a capital budget

006that is $3.3 million which if I run ran my math correct the last three minutes was $2 million is more than the proposed budget last year and significantly more than past budgets it's uh six times five to six times more than what you guys are saying is the following year um there's items in here the biggest of which is the hurlbut North house HVAC replacement which had an estimate last year for this year that was 400,000 and it's in the budget for 1.75 million there's not a single comment or commentary of this item in written anywhere in the materials there's no understanding of how this estim was developed um how detailed it was how much beta there is in the number and if you actually layer that on for everybody who's in attendance and reviews

007this in recording that $2 million increase on the capital budget versus last year coupled with the various other increases in the operating budget alike the budget increase to something like six or seven per year-over-year which would be um by far the largest do uh percent increase in the budget in the past decade by far like by a multiple of at least it was already the highest before the healthcare rerun I think that came down and before the capital budget was finalized and so again not exactly sure what it's for I'm sure I can follow up the email on what it is but the level of like transparency and understanding of some of these items the day of the second public comment period where we actually don't get another public comment period after this is actually

008very frustrating as a resident of this town um on top of that I'm still not sure on the health insurance so one thing that it sounds like the health insurance cost which is the biggest driver of the operating budget is still in flux and I think it would be imprudent for us to set a budget based on an estimate on Health Care uh health insurance costs which is really an estimate from a consultant with no with no um actual premium increase from an insur or proposal and pass that through to the the taxpayers um with the potential that it may not be that I think that's terrible financial planning at a very minimum there should be if we are concerned about an increase there may there might be a modest increase in the budget and

009then some top up with the reserves or something such that we're not just like prefunding an estimate that accounts for 75 to 80% of the increase year-over-year we shouldn't be setting a budget knowing it's in flux until we know that number given the the the amount that it relates to I think that'd be you're basically asking the taxpayer to F front the bill not knowing what's going on with it until later meanwhile next year's budget will be set starting with this year's budget so not only does it mess everything up this year but then exponentially thereafter we have now a new marker that is B on something that is an estimate I'm not I'm not sure on what business world like that type of budgeting actually flies on top of the transparency and everything else

010and I apologize if I'm coming off frustrated because I actually came into this meeting why I ask a couple questions until I saw some of the stuff on the capital budget and whatnot um we're like I said like we're talking about a six or s% in increase year-over-year on the budget that number nowhere is posted nobody posts the capital budget plus the operating budget year overy year so that actually is not transparent unless I was on this phone call I'm sure it never would have been talked about and on top of that we're not g even gonna have an opportunity to really digest these items because my guess is this was posted like six hours ago in a file that in a place that was an original file so you have to actually defin it

011so all in all the budget is too high I don't and frankly I said this last time the capital planning has to be dovetailed with what the board of Finance is doing on a long-term capital planning we shouldn't be spending $ three and a. half million dollars 1.8 million of it on HVAC without a fome understanding of what the needs are Beyond a single year this is the problem this whole time is that it's what's needed this year let's not think about what's needed over a longer period you might be able to do all the HVAC cheaper if you knew what your needs were the overall budget planning is very siloed it's very ad hoc it's not in conjunction with a broader town and school plan especially on the capital budget and I think it's

012in prudent for us to set a capital budget or propose a capital budget to the board of Finance the board of selectman without the full picture of what the board of Finance is doing on the debt plan and on the fome town Capital plan and so I I would ask that we don't do anything with that until that is done and we revisit it once that's complete and we can look at it in whole and actually talk about these items in a very you know educated knowledgeable way as opposed to ad hoc you know because we have to send a budget to the board of Selectmen in eight days I think it's I think it's terribly improving so I'm sure I'm well over my time which I appr I'm sorry you're five minutes went off

013already but I was just letting you continue it's fine yeah fine so that's that's where I stand I mean never going to be able to talk about this budget again after this day but I just hope people see that like the numbers are way higher than what they're saying that's the overall point and it's too high I will move you back to an attendee if you'll just give me one moment me and if there's anybody else that would like to speak please raise your hand click the little bottom okay the next person I'm going to promote is Kelly James KY give me just a moment to promote you click the button that comes across your screen to join Kelly you can turn on your camera State your full name and your street address and then

014you'll have five minutes to speak hi can you hear me yes great uh good evening my name is Kelly James I live at 11 burn hard drive um I just wanted to take a moment to express my sincere gratitude to all of you for your thoughtful decisions regarding the school budget as a mom of two elementary school children at hurlbut and whis I know how crucial it is to maintain smaller class sizes where each child can receive the attention and support they deserve your choice to keep funding intact for this important aspect of our children's education truly reassures me and I'm sure many other parents feel the same way class size plays such a PIV pivotal role in the quality of education and I'm so relieved that our district recognizes this thank you for prioritizing

015the educational experience of our kids and ensuring they have the best environment to learn and thrive on behalf of my family and countless others thank you again for your commitment to our children's future we are deeply grateful for your leadership that's it thank you Kelly I will promote you back to an attendee just give me one moment if there's anybody else that would like to speak please click the rais hand button that the bottom of your screen I I do not see anybody's hands raised at this time so that looks like it's it for public comment tonight okay great well thank you is there any uh comments or questions from the board um I I I have a question actually actually um I don't know if it's if it's you Steve or or maybe Phil

016Phil to to the comment that was just made I know that we're scheduled next week um to vote on the budget one when is the one is the absolute sort of um how long could we delay it if we had to delay it Phil when does that approved budget have to be delivered um because to to I think that last point and to conversations that we've had on in past board meetings um it it doesn't appear that we're goingon to have any final resolution on the insurance side um maybe even until mid to late February so just Ju Just a Little Bit of of uh of detailed context around around the process and the timing here Phil if you could um so by Charter we have to have um our our budget to the board

017of Selectmen I think by the 3D of February so again Michael I know there is always been concerned about any items um within our budget and there's there's been several years that a lot of the items that we have within our budget where there estimates um and this that's why we've always had the M the the Mantra that it's it's a it's a marathon right because Phil you froze yeah I think he's still frozen yeah you know what Michael while we're waiting for him to come back um one thing that I wanted to say was again the town Charter is the third Phil you froze there but I wanted to give um Michael just a quick little comment here it goes then to the board of Select and then to the board of finance that

018doesn't mean that it can't come back to us right so if if the board of Finance if there's something that happens by the time it gets to the board of finance that we know is going to change things drastically we can let them know this and it can get sent back to us too how far in advance how far down the line here can it can it come back to us meaning so it goes to it goes to the appropriate boards here throughout the process what what what is what is the estimate for um I guess the furthest date in the future by which we can still weigh in if it you know if if something changed and it came and it had to come back to us what what does that look like Phil

019can you guys hear me is this better yes yes okay perfect so Sharon you're absolutely right so in terms of when it comes back we work the Board of Education will vote in January we continue to work on our Budget prior to the the vote by the board of Finance so that that for me is is has always been the deadline that right before the vote for the board of Finance that's when we make our final changes and we have done that for the past several years and and remind me of that of that date fil uh you have to give me one quick minute for that sure sure thank you I appreciate it with that being said Jody I have a question for you hopefully you can help me out with this because since

020you seem to know a lot of the details um while Phil's looking for that this is going to Alex's comments that he made earlier about public comment and how he's a little disheartened and disappointed about the fact that this would be the last opportunity for him to have a chance to comment on the budget and he feels um as if he didn't really get enough of a running start um with the changes that were made which is fair I mean there there's a lot in here so um with that being said when it goes to the board of Finance excuse me the board of Finance is going through the board of education budget is there an opportunity for public comment during the board of Finance review of the budget as well okay that is a

021Steve E's question not a Jody question I know but I didn't know if Jody knew that there was like is is the board clerk so Mr reses can you please answer she's got the dates yeah all right so go it's not about date sharing it's about protocol and it's about meetings and if there's public comments at them dur during my tenure on the board of Finance we took public comment uh during the uh during the review of the budget great but just so you know the process is it goes to the board of Selectmen the board of Selectmen reviews it uh but they have no approval right um they can they can they can say you know this is fine with us they can offer up their comments but the ultimate decision well the ultimate

022decision is Towns at the atbm but the board of Finance you know will say yes or no I just didn't know if the board of Finance had what we have which is scheduled public sessions on the different budgets that's why I was asking calar so that was my mistake Jody do you have the calendar in front of you I just don't have it in front of me so real quick so historically historically the board of Finance has had a meeting where the public has an opportunity to chime in right great that that has been the case and just go back real quick there are two dates for the board of Finance the first meeting is on March 5th and if needed the second meeting will be on March 6 um 13th sorry okay so hopefully

023Alex if you're still on the call you um hear that information or if you're watching recorded you'll hear that information because we certainly don't want to give the impression that we are not looking for public comment we definitely want public comment on this because obviously it's up to the town to to either accept or deny this this budget so um you know please well in if I may it is listed in the budget document the other thing is is when we have our meeting on the board ofed on Tuesday January 28th that is a board of ed meeting and there are is public comment there if we don't reach the vote and approval there then there is another meeting on January 30th 30th Thursday and the same thing there's public comment at these meetings great

024perfect thank you Lisa so we have the opportunity to weigh in obviously next week on on the vote to advance this by February 3D and then we we potentially do have another buy at the Apple here through early March is that is that fair okay if I may um so our next meeting is um we have another Board of wed workshop on Monday uh we have um other documents that we want to give you our Target was to have them all ready this afternoon unfortunately some unforeseen events um precluded that from happening so we will be sending out to the board tomorrow the additional documents we will post them on the supplemental documents on the budget page so that you have a a chance to um to review them they include I know David I

025just have to double check everything the uh historical enrollments that you wanted to see over the last five years like what was the enrollment was was the projection medium what was the projection low it includes and the um low um model of different options if it was we used the low projections and what the um cost savings would be if there were any in FTE we have they're already it's just I like to double check everything before I send them out I I apologize for not getting to it uh this afternoon but we have that ready um we are working on uh correlating the information on the uh technology survey I know that uh Mr DeVito and Dr hle were working on that got sidetracked today but we'll have all of that that we will

026share with you so um hopefully the goal is is the next uh board workshop on Monday that um we'll be able to continue a rich discussion on all of those uh documents that we uh provide the clarifying information for you um so we can uh get further along here I did want to just ask a couple clarifying questions sort of uh kind of off Michaels so if we once we have to vote on a budget before it goes to the board of Selectmen and we have to vote on that by February 3rd right I'm looking at Phil but I'm not sure if I'm looking I know you don't know I'm looking at you but that's okay we have to it has to be delivered to the board of Selectmen by the third which right but

027it can't we can't yes yes we have to vote we have to we have to right and the board of Finance can review it but can they they can't I think in the past they've made some minor changes to it which really were more I think capital expens es that like Paving and stuff like that that would fall under maybe the town rather than the Board of Ed but do they have the ability on a line by line basis item to say this looks too high or we don't agree with this and send it back to us for for the review I don't think they do do they no right they vote a number I mean they can comment line by line but at the end of the day um they can't say you know

028lower paper and you know raise you know right you know heating oil right okay my my concern is that once we've voted on it it can it can make its way back to us but we as a board have approve the budget and so the collective work that we've been doing to date as a board um you know probably each of us has our own ideas and you know we collaborate together during these meetings it's the ship has sailed pretty much at that point unless there's some change like right like last year there was we we pre-purchased some books so that I think it was a $400,000 savings but that was just savings that that materialized between the time that we approved the budget and the time that it came back to us I don't

029know I'm just thinking I don't know have saying it's coming back to us is really of any it's it's non-binding The Binding piece is the amount that that we approve prior to February 3rd no The Binding number is the number the board of Finance sends to the atbm okay well Steve here's a question Steve um whose decision is it if we wanted if it came back to us is it is it our discretion that we request it back or does someone does the board of Finance have to approve that request how does that work I don't know the answer to that because it's never you know in my tenure that's never occurred but frankly if we think that we can't come to a resolution I haven't read the charter is this in the charter fil

030I you know I don't know I mean I can read the charter but if we think there's a reason why it's not going to meet this timeline um it does have to meet a timeline uh because it does have to be approved before I believe it has to be approved before the start of the new fiscal year at you know at the latest um but if we think we aren't going to meet the timeline to get it to the to start the process with the board of Selectmen then we just you know we have to inform them of that and take the process you know through whatever we think it's comfortable but ultimately it has to be approved by you know it has to get to the board of finance and then to the atbm

031and I think the atbm is kind of fixed in stone yeah and I'm just thinking about this not only for this year but if the if the benefit costs are going to be if the insurance costs are going to be an issue for the foreseeable future you know this may not be again just a just a a one- Time Event here a one time issue that we have to deal with it may be an issue we have to deal with in subsequent years so just thinking forward okay yeah look you you and I have spoken about that you know I share that you know history would tell you that insurance costs are going to be high it's just how high is high right in the in in you know for example in the past yes

032insurance insurance costs may bump around a little bit but um these are potentially meaningful increases so I think that's that's why the emphasis on SES the timing aspect now yeah okay yeah and I'll just wrap up by saying I personally don't know that I'm going to be ready Tuesday to vote I feel like there's still a lot of information that I have to digest especially with the new information that we got today waiting for Lisa so I'm just wondering if we want to try and push it out a little bit further unless I'm the one man out and I will accept that but I I feel like we're trying to hit a deadline and haven't necessarily digested all of the information but last comment here I mean I would just say that um I guess

033that's depending David on you know we won't necessarily have all the information um next week I guess this depended on the process by which let's say it could come back to us if we are surprised in some way um Visa let's say insurance cost that may be drastically off from from where we are I I I don't know if I may so we have a situation where we had the original budget at 4.75 then we had the tweak with what Phil presented um and that primarily the the big savings was the insurance that we understand and all the other districts around us are going through the same thing is up in the air but that got it down to a a 3.4 it would be helpful for us to and we don't have to say

034it tonight or whatever but to understand where individual members are you know I we can get you the information and all of that but if there is a sense amongst um the board it would be helpful for us to um know going into Mondays so we can have the right mindset that you know it's well we would be comfortable with um the budget being at 3.2 or three or looking at this and looking at the insurance cut it would also be helpful if you could show us what the impact would be if you know this also happened you know some direction here and I know I'm being vague would be helpful for us so that we um can also reflect on that I'll just simply say on the insurance side I feel like that's walking

035down the sidewalk and we found a coupon and the coupon is going to offset our costs this one time so I think that the there's a we haven't saved money we found a coupon um so what would you like us to find then this is helpful so and believe me I understand and I'm gonna be frank with you every time we build a budget ever well you know I've done a long time for just one school but the the the as superintendent every year we try to figure out a way to best manage um the needs with the uh fiduciary responsibility to the town and we find little coupons along the way and then other things that are sustainable um beyond that if I'm being clear so what would you like us look at beyond

036the coupon I guess I would say I think it hit the on the head sustainable savings that's my biggest concern and I've said this kind of year-over-year I always feel like we are on an unsustainable trajectory our operating costs and I you know our total budget our total budget we're on unsustainable trajectory so I would love to hear uh some sustain some ongoing sustainable savings um that and that can you give us just for I know I'm pushing I want to understand can I finish please ongoing aable savings when you look at Savings in a budget and 80% of it is staff is that what you're referring to David well so yeah our budget this year at the moment is I think what Just sh 61 million bill is that 61 yeah so for every

037basic math I know but just for every one for every 1% we'd have to find 6 600 600 yeah 600,000 right um that's the 61 million um combined with if you divide out the math that's about that's just north of $30,000 spending pure pupil that's off the charts compared to other districts that's what I mean by unsustainable so I don't know that's that's my my my red flag is that we we continue on an unsustainable trajectory with spending per student and it is very much out of line with some of the duray around us and I understand you know we're small we're unique but I just are small yeah yeah no we are small we are unique our budget has consistently come in lower than all of the other schools but they districts but they

038have more children so you know there's certain things but when you're talking about sustainable um and forgive me but I'm I'm just really kind of pushing to get clarification so you're talking about 600,000 is a percent so 600,000 to be sustainable in that kind of a thing is to me staff to be blunt you know you're not going to get it by shaving uh $60,000 or 0.008 whatever percent is that what you're asking us to go back and look at as part of it yeah and I don't know that I'm suggesting that we should be cutting staff but I'm certainly saying we should look at utilization we should compare maybe things like and I am out of my league in many ways so I I want to be very careful and not be disrespectful because

039I just don't know how the school district operates so I will look at this simply as the way the private sector operates you know it's utilization are we overstaffed in some areas and if we're not maybe the data that shows that we're not is a data that I would feel comfortable then with where we're spending $330,000 per student um and we are not overstaffed we are not under we don't have underutilized uh folks and I'm talking about across the board I'm not talking about cutting teachers I'm not talking about cutting support staff I'm not talking about cutting landscapers I don't know but no I understand and and I don't think you're giving yourself a CR credit I think you do know a lot about the intricacies and the running of it but I'm just being

040really blunt here because we're kind of looking for how we can you know when you talk about sustainable savings you talk about sustainability efforts clearly in uh the running of the buildings and all of that but um there's also um you know then yes I would say what would make me more comfortable with approving the budget is that that you have looked at the utilization or the workload or what whatever metrics you would use and there's easy ones we don't want a teacher to stand up in front of a classroom with 35 kids right that's that's simple um and I think when I asked you to add one student per section that was a simple way for us to see the the educational you know it's not that's easy right it we don't right yeah

041yeah so I would say from where I sit if I knew that you looked at the utilization whatevering is and it is it is it is it is staff sure yeah and we can look like that and and you will get the um charts tomorrow where it is very interesting when you look at the low enrollment projections for next year and you look at the medium projections for next year it's going to require the same amount of sections because again it's that Tipping Point and how many kids so we can certainly um you know look at that I can tell you when you look outside the classroom for example and you say um okay well we have four grounds people so we'll um one then the cost of overtime goes up in the other categor

042so you know there's always a trade-off so we can certainly go back and and look at that but that's you know that 600,000 is um when you're when you're looking at programming and and staff and uh infrastructure that's where it's going to have to come Lisa I cut you off and I um apologize I just I just wanted toed go to you I just wanted to add on to what David was saying and I really appreciate your budget and keeping class size smaller on the smaller side and that's really important and and I really appreciate you doing that when I was looking at um page I think 73 and the support staff and I know I sent you questions it um I finished we I apologize we were going to get them out today tomorrow

043go ahead oh okay well okay that's great great and because I still have some questions about that and I was you know not saying anything I thought we were going to do that Monday so but you know that's kind of along the lines of what David W was saying looking at the support staff that isn't going to affect students in the classroom but more so um you know outside and the Staffing and the uh amount of of uh students and uh what they're doing with those students outside the classroom okay so we will uh put together get all of the information out and we will go back and look great um that particular area and any other area you um would like to see I can tell you that there not a lot of wiggle

044room with some of the stuff but we will go back and do it our best efforts you know so you know just one other you know question are do you have an indication of Staff retiring of being able to rearrange maybe staff that um putting a round peg in a round hole so they might be doing other things um better and so kind of rearranging it as people retire and leave so not I would say to you we do that every single year when we look at the staff and we are assigned people and Miss gavone is already on it about finding out who is retiring um perhaps and uh analyzing down to the looking at the schedules what do they do how can we best uh use them miss gavone you have anything to

045add um yes I would add um it's I would say it's early to know for certain about retirements we're we're starting to get some indications um those indications are are very limited at this point I wouldn't expect necessarily even that retirements result in situations where there can be reductions because in some cases those retirements are in uh very necessary programmatic areas so I understand the question Lisa and I appreciate the question and and it it can be challenging and it has to be weighed on a Case by case sometimes you know we can uh have buyouts for um you know staff that we'd like to see move on and there would be other staff that could replace them just just a Wonder yeah no and we've done that in the past we've offered um the

046uh erip early retirement incentive and that's very complicated uh but we would have to you know you have to look at that you have to look at the Unions that's when Phil talks about turnover savings and how he adjusted that number that's imp part part of that what we're trying to do here well that's great I good thank you and alsoo just quickly ask um Lisa when you put together the information I guess I'm kind of asking for it would be really helpful to understand the parts I don't understand right the folks that stand in front of the teacher the the teachers that stand in front of the students that's easier for me to understand the folks that I meet with like on these meetings on a regular basis the superintendent assistant superintendent the principles

047I understand what they do do I don't understand all the other layers of what people do in the district do we have any numbers that we can say Weston has X number of them just making it up guidance counselors and those guidance counselors are responsible for X number of students yeah we're working on that yeah okay right that's that's one of the um questions that Lisa had and that um I think we're almost done with it um so we'll get that up to you tomorrow it has different those specific positions uh Julie's working out the responsibilities what's the case load we're we're trying to provide all of that for you so you can uh get a better understanding because yeah I mean sometimes you look at a position and say what does that person do

048you know and will will we have the ability to look at you know what I'm focused on again is a $30,000 per student and it might be that we can justify that and you know I always say you know you have to be able to defend something right so if we can justify defend $30,000 per student then that's great it would love to know how does a Westport how does a Wilton how do these other schools get down to 27 28,000 per student there's got to be uh some formula because from what I understand our class siiz guidelines are on par with schools right so there's got to be other places where they have more they're responsible for more students whatever that role is in other districts than Weston one of the documents that we

049um are putting the final touching is on I believe you asked what was the historical number of Staff going back a certain amount of years David you had asked that and we have that oh that's good we'll be giving that out too just to clarify and I don't know if this is a different question but the first round of questions that have been already posted does include that a chart historically back in 2017 overall Staffing versus enrollment and that chart's already included in board Workshop 1.7 1.7.2 five right January 7 2025 um that's already been posted and I know that we're we're looking for more details around Staffing so I just want wanted to make sure I know there is as Sharon mentioned there's a lot of documents and we try to keep up with

050all the questions so that we're as transparent as possible so um it may have gotten buried um as people were looking at things yes thanks Dr ankle you're right it is in there we did do the Staffing um the total number of Staffing yeah and also I just want to take this opportunity to mention and just clarify David to your point um you know not every staff is create Staff role is created equal right um and just like every student is not created equal with the number of resources they need in order to access uh their educational experience sometimes it's not so black or white to just get look at an overall number and how that correlates also to per pupil expenditures because every district is different every the needs related to students um and

051the staff that they are required to support their educational experience is also different so um we just need to keep that in mind when we're talking about reducing staff and I have one more quick question on the capital budget or maybe isn't the capital budget there's been a lot of talk about the electrifying of school buses and uh I don't know where we're at with the change at the federal level but if we are moving moving towards that has that cost where has that cost shown up in our uh budget or has it not yet no it's not it's well you know that mandate may change uh given the new Administration but the previous mandate was by 30 2035 and right so so as I as we understood at David because I was I was

052part of this Transportation you know RFP as we understood and correct me if I'm wrong Phil or Steve is that it would start to impact us the next the next RFP which be which would be we just signed what fiveyear contract right so it would it would start to impact us our budgets in 2030 I believe it's it's a good question David because even though um even though the go even though we're not mandated or no one's mandated to uh to Electrify their Fleet until 20 35 the recommendation from first student Michael was uh if there are grants outstand if there grants available you should take them now now I don't know if you know the the conversation in the new Administration over the last couple of days about electric vehicles is going to also

053take into account buses but I guess we'll see and it's probably a good question Phil to ask for a student what they think yeah it's it's I'm sorry it's it's a few things that we have to answer both as the Board of Education and also by the on the townside um because we really need to find a home for the buses if we're going to add electrification to that um because the current the current facility or current location will not support full electrification um so so there's I guess there's more conversations to be had um so in the near term there's no we have no allocation for electrification of the buses um but it is a conversation that I know the town has started and we'll also Pigg it back on that discussion as well

054and that was the basis of my question well it wasn't so much about the first student contract I I peripherally remember that piece but we're going to have to provide the facilities to charge those buses to house those buses and so when I that's kind of it it it parlays or as part of my concern about sustainability no pun intended of the budget that we may be faced with having to literally build a structure um to house and charge these buses right and if the state has great incentives that that we want to Electrify the buses even if the at the at the you know the the administ the new Administration doesn't mandate it we might still want to do it um for our own sustainability purposes so what I'm saying is that I feel

055like we have a potential huge infrastructure costs or Capital expense yes we do right and that's the my again that's my concern with with sustainability for the budget now so I'm I I wanted to ask about yeah it's like the middle school project we have a couple things that we know are going to be expensive that we're going to have to do and the electrifying of the buses the buses show up and they're electric we have to have a place to park them house them and charge them and that's going to be on us well it's going to be on us and we are waiting direction from the town because there has been talk about moving it um but it's been a preliminary talk and we have not been involved in a robust discussion on

056that because you can't just Electrify them where they are there's not enough space so in short there's nothing involving those those buses in any of our plans right now because it's premature and we have to see what the federal government does and also enter into a a more robust discussion with the town regarding infrastructure not only of buses but also of um our school and Community needs right and we I think I've asked this question before Phil we can't reserve we don't have the ability to reserve money for like in our Capital budgets going out next year the year after the year after of course in this year is or this coming up budget the HVAC cost as Alex pointed out as well it's a huge number right so my I immediately went to that

057so what I what I was thinking in my head was in 26 and 27 and 28 I would want to see some money for the electrification of the school buses uh but we don't we can potentially budget but not put money away for it right like we can project but we can't have a reserve it that's called that's called a non-aps account and we won't be able to do that yeah that's that's one way another way um but again everything revolved involved discussion with the town and board of Finance is to establish a syncing fund where funds are just put aside every year um to build a fund again it's I don't want to muddy the waters right now um with with cost and everything else off those buses I think we have a lot

058as it stands right now with our current budget so so I guess the in the in the near term we there's nothing in our budget to to address those needs the town has started to have some conversation the discussion with all the vendors to explore um locations so I think maybe sometime in fiscal 26 as we think about what ultimately we will do with the middle school that will probably be part of that discussion as well but that's a that's an interesting idea David we should have that conversation with the board they can the town can create a fund a a non-aps they've done that uh for fire engines as an example and for the track right the track that's right right because Steve as as we kind of talk about especially as a small

059community whether and one of the reasons I was for the buses to park and to charge I as a taxpayer will have to foot that bill whether I foot it through my taxes that go to the board of education or I put it through my taxes that go to uh the operation of the town but the town has flexibility to kind of create that Reserve account and I think ultimately the town if I understand correctly they're responsible to provide the facilities that we operate the schools in so it would seem like it would make sense that they would provide uh if they had the ability to reserve for budget for whatever this this uh bus depot we should be having a conversation now but It ultimately it affects me Steve Michael everybody else uh directly

060as taxpayers it just doesn't it it's just it's in one budget not the other yeah no they they we collectively with the town have to come up with a determination on where the buses are going to move too and there's only a couple places right there's the DPW garage you know off of you know you know off of volhard Road um or the transfer station that's pretty much it uh so a decision ultimately has to be made and you know I think made to your point within the next couple of years and then then then you know the following decision is okay we move the bus depot what happens to that property there's some talk about sell it to a developer but I personally don't think that will ever occur it's 100 yards from the

061school so we not going to and and right on the corner of the busiest Corner in town so it's it's a it's something that the town has to address sooner uh not later and we'll bring it up to them but just getting back we have yeah yeah I know but just getting back to your regular uh your earlier comment about maybe not being prepared to vote on the budget uh next week um I'll read the charter to see if there's I I don't remember if the it's state specific in the charter but if we really don't think we're going to meet the current deadline uh then I should give a heads up to uh to the uh to the board of selectman and to the board of Finance so um and I should do that

062probably tomorrow even ahead of you know our conversation next week to say we may not get there uh by that date we may but there's a chance uh there's a chance we don't so I'll do that um because it sounds like we'll definitely need the extra day that week oh yeah yeah yeah but this this this is a this is a big decision we don't need to rush it so you will check with the select about making sure that we're within the boundaries of the charter I'll read the charter tonight and then thank you if it's not and if it is in the charter or if it's not I'll reach out to both uh the first Selectmen and the chairman of the board of Finance this evening and say there is a chance we don't

063meet uh we may not vote on our budget in the current timeline just a quick reminder um I know we have increase in cost both um when we look at salaries and also health insurance so the reminder is this is the final year for current contracts for all three groups so as we make decision as well maybe we maybe we think about that as well because if if we can pull all the the levers at the right time not negotiating with anyone right now um but if we can pull the levers at the right time as we go into negotiation with all these units there may be some benefit in delaying some decision regarding health insurance as well but that's just want to remind the board that we're at this is the F 26 is

064a final year of the current contract more from the board tonight yes Steve Al Chim in one I'm I have to be in the C and I have to take his call so I'm off video to spear you all bright lights anyway yeah couple comments one I don't know if the gentleman who was the first public comment is still listening but uh given this much discussion they anyone can always email questions as well so if there are specific questions because he referenced I have two or three other things I wanted to get to but this was just posted today so certainly if anyone's listening and they do have specific questions the public should certainly feel free to email those questions and then the next would be Lisa thank you so much for the work to

065bring together this sort of survey about the the technology I am eager to look at that I will be curious of of course what the sort of questions are and the reason I say that is that if the faculty really thinks that we're using technology in a very sound way then that's got to be a pretty satisfying thing to me uh if there's some more gray area with that then I think it's pretty hard to have the discussion about potentially cutting staff positions and justifying technology Investments depending on what the faculty say so I'm very curious about about what that will be and I don't think this fits in a budget conversation per se but I do think it's relevant to the topic that I would be curious too of what the technology survey says

066about cell phones in high schools as well that's kind of aside from the budget of course but if we're doing a survey about tech that'll be an interesting interesting thing to find out from The Faculty too that's all for me Steve thank you okay thank you Dr hle do you have your hand up I see a hand oh okay just sure no it's okay are questions comments talk on Monday have a motion to adjourn they moved wait Michael doesn't want to go yet no no I think there are other part other people other attendees that is there anyone else Jody that wants to make a comment I see other people that are in attendance no the gentleman that was here before is watching along with somebody else but there's nobody here for public comment okay

067all right got it well have a motion before maybe I'll make my comment then have Jour go ahead Alex watching so I like I like uh David's drive towards austerity I think it's a serious conversation with Michael andol also interesting the metric is $30,000 per student is perceived is too high I me Alex said the whole budget's too high so there's some subjectivity there and well westport's at 28 too so let's say we say the Bogey's 282 right we're at parody that's $1,800 per student off the budget which on a $60 million nut would be 3% so if we lower our budget by 3% we can be at parody with Westport and those that think the budget's too high but we need to be at a certain cost per student can play with that fire

068because that fire means much more than staff that fire means programming Sports theater or God so if you use the metric we have to be at parody with Westport prepare for The Firestorm that comes when you don't offer AP courses next year so we got to be careful with that metric and we got to be careful with the budget's too high fine 3% to lose on Just for warning The Firestorm that will happen if you continue with that metric I like the drive towards austerity that's not my my beef it's the metric that may be misguided misplaced Peter I'll just leave off with I don't I don't know why you go directly to cutting programs or cutting AP courses that is we're asking Lisa to look at utilization and I think it is you're prejudging

069what she's going to come back with so let's let Lisa look at those things we've already determined I think as a board we like the guidelines we like the small class size we like the intimate settings it's very beneficial I think that both Patty and um Miss cadis has said it is so important at the lower age groups to have the smaller class sizes we're committed to that let's look at other places this the class guidelines that we use are on parody with Westport and Wilton so let's look at the other areas that won't directly have impact the small class sizes and see if there's room Lisa may come back to us and say there simply isn't or if you cut this you lose that but I don't think we should yell fire in the

070movie theater until we get some data from Lisa well it's the metric that was proposed is the uh the issue I took right so I say stop with the metric and look at austerity because you're not going to satisfy yourselves nor the taxpayer cares that the metric has to be in parody with Westport because either someone will find that's not good enough I want more austerity you can only go so low because of the laws in the state or parents will say that certainly isn't good enough because you're cutting all the programs to meet a bogey of 282 so it's just a advice I guess to not use that metric and to stick with austerity but intelligent yeah I'll chime in there I I couldn't agree with Peter Moore on this point I think that

071we get caught up far too much in comparison with the duks it's as though it's some sort of like keeping up with the Joneses that isn't always necessary that goes for a bunch of things and I think the faculty even have some sort of jokes about it too in terms of how we try to always align ourselves with the geographic areas that are near us those communities might have very little to do and I mean that for a whole variety of things that we anchor to these other districts I think Peter's point is a good one which is that we really should be looking at overall excellence and what we're trying to achieve as opposed to cost per student based on districts we're surrounded by I think there's just more interesting more rigorous ways to

072look at how we accomplish the budget constraints that we have to deal with anyone else excuse me anyone else we'll get this stuff out to you by tomorrow afternoon okay and I just S I just sent a note I sent a note to Samantha Nester and Michael lber just now let them know okay now can I have a motion to adjourn so moved all right all those in favor or second second thank you I move

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.