CorpusRecord 112361

Board of Education Special Meeting (Budget Workshop)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WPS Meetings
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
20,373 words · about 114 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

00116th is that what today is I can't remember which um and this is a special meeting of the western Board of Education to continue our discussions on the budget now we have a quorum first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United stes Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible for liberty and justice for all thanks everybody Lisa back to you morning everyone I um there was a document that was sent to you this morning that there a link was missing out of it but I think that it's all been corrected thanks to Dr hanle um it was the technology document we would like to start with any questions on technology and then we can move on I know that David has

002a question that I need to to back up to explain um regarding class size so um I'll turn the floor over to uh to you all and U Mr davito uh is here and Dr hankle to uh answer any questions about technology Le Lisa would it be helpful just to give a brief overview of the document that you shared and how we put it together or just let them ask let everybody El I don't know would that be helpful for the board okay Mike's shaking his head uh yes so um yes please why don't we um take a look at the document I don't know if anybody can uh put it up there would it have to be Andrew okay D DeVito thank you great so based on the first uh working group uh session

003that we had there were conversations around technology integration technology use as well as physical infrastructure and equipment so Dan and I worked collaboratively around um the first off the the purpose of Technology integration and how we you how are we use it throughout the district so we have been um on this journey to explain for the last couple years around our District's approach to Tech to technology how it emphasizes we emphasize purpose intentionality relevance and in a very strategic way right we want to enhance the learning we want to ensure that when we integrate technology across the Continuum we line with curricular goals and we always support developmentally appropriate ages when we are considering how students are using technology in the classroom in the um non-classroom environment such as the library media spaces or even

004through any kind of extracurricular activities um we do use technology in a variety of ways not only for Hands-On learning in the classroom but also for intervention purposes also for small group instruction tools as well throughout the district um we again when the theme around purpose and intention is key when we are thinking about technology integration and enhancement of curriculum and how we decide those tools throughout the district um tools like Lexia um throughout the district is a component of our supplemental tools as well as Symphony math some of these tools are not necessarily used by all students as you'll see in our in our um outline for you that we put together um but they do give us the ability to personalize and enrich the learning we use them these tools to scaffold instruction

005to ensure that students are also um learning uh different applications on technology that are essential to build their digital skills and we also balance some of these tools so that we ensure that there's not an excessive amount of time um in front of a screen right because we know that for younger students um no matter if it's technology or not there is a amount of time on task that they can uh use that will really focus their attention their stamina and make sure that they're um um you know able to really lock in on what they're actually learning so that their attention SPS um um you know are are we mindful of the attention spans that student have students have especially as early as five six seven years old um we also want to be

006mindful that when we're thinking of that curricular alignment in all content areas we're not just talking about the classroom instruction we're talking about the library media uh curriculum as well um this is where we house our International uh technology standards as well as our computer science standards the uh those are the curricular aspects that we are meeting our um State and expectations around how do we build their digital skills and ensure that um technology integration at a at an early age uh builds their foundational skills um we also know that some non-instructional um aspects of Technology also helps um the management of the district such as how we use technology to support assessments that includes assessments as early as kindergarten when we're doing um our Dibbles assessments for reading um our math assessments on nwaa

007um as well as our state mandates for smart a balanced and the Next Generation accountability science um assessments the alternate Assessments in special education um and so on S also is is online although those are individual devices but technology and infrastructure to support all different aspects of devices and Technology use is something that we are very Mindful and cognizant of when we make decisions um regarding technology um so Dan also then so that was kind of my portion of the document talking about explicit use um relative to curriculum enhancement and um the instructional aspect I've also linked for you some just to give you some background right because as I mentioned we've been talking about this for a while uh actually the first year that I was here we started that conversation I'm sure it

008was even before that so I did kind of summarize of those previous year presentations either through the curricular subcommittee meetings um or through some presentations that we've been um doing um internally with staff um so then after that Dan um kind of provided a very in-depth uh analysis um around uh devices explicitly when it comes to infrastructure and Equipment um so that gives an overview of that document and and maybe that gives you some context of why we put it together and hopefully it helps solidify some of those questions and um lead the discussion a bit yep and I just wanted to hop in real quick and just over I'm sorry can you please yeah uh go through how the plane has been changed Chang has been flexible but also when you go to the

009dur gate chart can you provide some color around what type of devices it's all listed there point that out to the board because I know they had questions about in what grades do certain kids get devices thank you no problem so when when I started here I started putting together a six-year technology plan and it's not a static plan it's a plan that gets looked at every single year and a new year is tacked on at the end of it and we're always looking so the board of education is acutely aware of what the overall goal idea and vision is in terms of technology for the district what are the big ticket items that are coming up that need to be replaced so originally these Chromebooks that we're looking to replace or the Chromebooks that

010are in grades 3 through 8 were originally purchased in 2020 uh right in the in the height of the pandemic and the when you have Chromebooks that are that kids are either taking home with them or using on a daily basis the average lifespan you're going to get is about four years of wear and tear before they physically just break to the point where they're no longer usable or sustainable to be up and running for a long period of time so originally so this this first graph I'm showing you is actually a snapshot of the six-year technology plan from the FY 23 budget book that shows that this year was supposed to be the year we were supposed to replace the student Chromebooks however during the following year when I was doing a further analysis

011on our backend infrastructure like our firewalls our switches our wireless access access points those needed to be replaced sooner rather than later originally those were going to be replaced the following year but due to some endof life announcements and some critical security updates we had determined that we had to replace that backend infrastructure in order to keep the district secure and as such we had to push out the replacement of these Chromebooks until FY 26 and what that does is there's a cascading effect because we also have to consider replacing the staff laptops the staff laptops were purchased during fy21 and or fy22 and again those are a 4-year plan to replace the saf laptops but because we had to push out replacing the Chromebooks by one year we in turn had to push out

012replacing the staff Chromebooks by one year and so we never want to have one year with the technology plan where we're looking at an $800,000 purchase if you see year-over-year throughout all the budget books I try to keep a similar dollar amount year-over-year between you know $250 and $400,000 I never want to present the board one year where I say hey we need a million dollars worth of equipment so it's it we're we're always looking at balancing that act between what we need and how much we're requesting the board ofed to fund so when you look at it you know cuz I know one of the questions was hey can we push out the replacement of the Chromebooks so there's the cascading effect so if we pushed out another year for the step for the

013student Chromebooks we'd also have to push out another year for the staff Chromebooks and what ends up happening is once the extended warranties are done with these devices it is now up to the district to purchase replacement parts when it comes to something like Chromebooks there's a sweet spot of a couple of years after the Chromebook has been manufactured where you can get brand new parts at a relatively inexpensive price we've now passed that so we can't find brand new replacement parts for these Chromebooks so what we're actually purchasing are refurbished parts so to go over so this uh graph right here or this this table right here shows over the last 12 months what we've had to repair repair from a hardware perspective so we had to replace 209 LCD screens we're not per

014we're not able to purchase 209 brand new LCD screens for those Chromebooks we're actually purchasing refurbs and there have been times where we've purchased a batch of refurbs and they're awful and we have to send them back because nobody can find brand new LCD screens because they're proprietary to Chromebooks Chromebooks are different different than like a desktop computer where a lot of those parts are interchangeable if you need a Chromebook a part for an HP Chromebook you can only get an HP Chromebook part you can't get something generic and and and necessarily have it be functional so it's becoming more and more difficult to find quality replacement parts how does that affect the students we have laner laptops the laner laptops are in the same scenario as the regular lap as a regular their Chromebooks

015those laner Chromebooks are also in bad shape so now you'll have a student whose Chromebook is broken because let's say the LCD screen is broken or they need to replace the motherboard they now have no device we give them a laner device that laner device barely works itself if it takes us two weeks to purchase equipment now that student has to wait two weeks before they can use their Chromebook and when we're using the Chromebook aligned with the curriculum they need that Chromebook to learn and for instruction now they can't use it so they're stuck behind so from a purely Hardware perspective kind of hit that critical point where we really have to replace these Chromebooks next year because if we don't it's going to be even longer and longer and longer and more difficult

016for us to find the parts needed to repair these Chromebooks so the students have them during instructional time I also wanted to go over a history of one: one in the district right prior to Chrome uh PRI prior to covid only students grade 6 through 8 took their Chromebooks home there were devices at the K through five level but they were what we considered one: one during the day so they were in carts in the classrooms they used them during the day and then they went they did not go home with them of course during covid we had to provide devices for all sta for all students in order for them to be able to learn remotely when we originally came back and started school back up again in that hybrid year we still had

017everybody taking the devices home once we resume to some kind of normaly in in the district we realize we don't need the elementary students taking these devices home so at the elementary level kindergarten and first grade students they have iPads second grade to 8th grade they have Chromebooks and it was determined there's no need for them to take the devices home they can they have homework that they can use that does not need technology so we started phasing out at the younger grades them taking the devices home and we're continuing to do that because at one point the third grade students were taking it home last year after a discussion with the third grade teachers and Patty it was DET and Tina it was determined that third grade students did not need to take the

018Chromebooks home we're currently having that discussion about fourth grade students as well so although we're giving them devices we're always looking at do they need to take them home and if the answer is no they don't take them home but they still need to have a onetoone device during the day because shared carts is just not a sustainable model in in how much uh you know how aligned the technology is with the curriculum one of the questions was also what are the dur A's and and and uh what are their onet toone programs so I worked with all the local Tech directors and this table shows what every single School District what every single dur a district does basically every single K8 District dur a district has a onetoone program most students take those devices

019home between fifth and sixth grade some going down to third grade some going to fourth grade like us uh but like new Kanan for instance they take them home in third grade the high schools the majority of the districts they're bod so I just wanted to talk about how you see uh we are in line in terms of the replacement cycle and our onetoone program uh as the other durs so just to uh reiterate from a device perspective for Weston kindergarten and first graders they have iPads second through eighth graders they have Chromebooks so I just wanted everyone to understand as well as from a an instruction curriculum standpoint why there's such a need to replace them from a hardware and infrastructure standpoint there's one other thing that I would like to add we created

020the typical day for Hess and whis that was where the link problem was and the reason we did that is because I think that there is a bit of a I would say a perception that students are sitting on these Chromebooks or iPads um every day for uh a great deal of time and I encourage you to look at the typical day because they are not and we tried to reference where it whether it be in small groups or when the Smartboard was used in large group instruction um thank you we make it yeah you can open it up make it very clear as to how the Chromebooks or how the technology is being used uh the other thing I wanted to add is that I I also think that what happened at the intermediate

021school earlier this year was that students were taking them home not to do homework with them but to charge them and when we became aware of that that was dealt with with it providing charging stations PTO actually supported it so you know students weren't bringing them home lugging them back and forth in fourth grade for electricity purposes that is no longer happening so I hope that this kind of provides some uh background on um on the technology I mean this is our stance we are um there are no plans to remove this technology um from the hands of our students if you have any questions on this I would encourage you to ask them I actually do have a quick question um I do see that we are in line as as far as the

022Chromebooks go for um for all the other durs that we're in but my question is are Chromebooks we didn't necessarily find that Chromebooks were necessary for um I guess it was like second grade through fifth grade prior to the pandemic is there any possibility that we could go back to a more coste effective oper U option of the iPads um for that grade level I mean are Chromebooks necessary is it too much technology or is the curriculum built around the technology of Chromebooks good question so know why don't you start and then I'm sorry Dan and then Dan jump in go ahead yeah I mean instructionally it's nice to have the peripherals available for students um with a with a Chromebook like from an instructional standpoint part of it is we're teaching kids how to

023use the keyboard how to use a mouse how to navigate some of the platforms that we have on an iPad everything is touch or at least that's how we've used iPads in the past everything was a flat screen um so correct Dan yes yeah and and from a um uh an ability perspective iPads are a little bit restricted in what they can do versus Chromebooks in terms of educational software so a lot of our you know iPads are app based and a lot of our instruction software does not have an app version a lot of our software is uh web- based and it doesn't function properly on iPads also from a financial perspective iPads in the long run end up becoming around the same price as Chromebooks so if you look like at at the

024breakdown right the $365 for the Chromebooks that's the cost of the Chromebook a 4year um accidental damage protection warranty and a case an iPad an educational pricing iPad without uh warranty and without case is $300 so when you include the cost of accidental damage protection and a case it's almost the same exact cost so we would assume that hey a tablet would actually be more cost effective but it's apple and the you know the price is is actually in line to the cost of a Chromebook all right okay that makes Clarity well uh it's it is more cost effective on a maintenance perspective Dan's team can replace a screen a motherboard a keyboard on a Chromebook which is faster and cheaper and uh you can't do I'm sure you guys wouldn't even attempt a screen

025replacement on an iPad you you you you lose a tech for an hour and they'd be frustrated as hell so just ongoing maintenance is also less expensive with the Chromebook okay all right any other questions on uh technology you can certainly um submit a question if you you have one later if not we can U move on to uh facilities um are we ready to move on I see Mr dmaster is eagerly awaiting his participation okay um Mike why don't you would it be helpful if Mike began by just kind of going through the capital plan if you had any questions is that helpful as a starting point yes please thank you all right good morning everybody all right so as we discussed briefly with the uh the board meeting a couple couple weeks back

026it's a it's an ongoing Capital um budget we we're working carefully with cers and our um our team approach of getting campus where we need it to be um we are working with a an audit for Energy Efficiency so as I'm sure a lot of you know or maybe you don't our systems here there's a lot of different Heating and Cooling plants in each building other than Intermediate School that was built in 2006 we have multiple multiple plants in every school so we're trying to get a vision of how we can come into today's technology and unify our HVAC um that could be from boilers that could be from rooftop units um trying to alleviate unit ventilators which are constantly a nuisance so these um these audits the contracts have been signed I believe that

027they will be here as early as next week to begin their walkth through to give us some sort of vision working with us not just their vision of how we can condense and unify our systems as opposed to the approach of addition addition addition and just adding on to our plants that's more line uh line six so I'll get into that a little bit down the line um so I'll go through our line our first line is um District wide security initiatives so again this is um going to involve our building perimeter as well as our perimeter our property perimeter so be fencing our doors um through the years we've been replacing anything that needs to be done trying to fortify our buildings trying to fortify our proper and will continue to do so this

028will also include um likely camera upgrades as we did a tremendous up update this year upgrade but it's a work in progress and needs to continue um line two is has been a nuisance for for quite a while now five six seven eight years our PA systems that are not just PA systems they are integrated with our clock systems they're innovated with our scheduling middle school high school element School we've had constant issues probably up near six to six to a dozen calls a year getting our um our contractor out here to work on it we don't have a lot of people that can work on these systems so they're very difficult very temperamental um clock sh all over the place schedules go out it can be very very disruptive to uh Administration they have

029to do things manually we have a TBD on this at this point we just have some questions with the company that's giving is pricing um because we want everything to be included um not just the PA we want the clock system integrated to it we also want to have our Bell schedules into it we are certain that our Bell schedules are integrated into the PA systems now we're just working on our clock system and exactly what our cost would be because we probably have somewhere between two and 300 clocks in each building depending on square footage so that's something that we would definitely like to to upgrade just to and it would be the three schools intermediate school at this point being about 20 years old still works fine no issues knock on wood line

030three we have the Intermediate School playground site renovation the site renovation um if you've been back there it's a bit of a golly so it collects a lot of water and as you know when we get rain here it's not just a Sprinkle it's usually a deluge and it pounds water um to the point of no grass and it's mud kids are playing in the mud we have a asphalt basketball court back there so the asphalt is deteriorating to the point that it needs to be Mill and paved so this line item is to bring elevation up to grade running water from the building out as well as the pavement for the um for the basketball court line four is our continuing uh parking lot driveway maintenance and Paving we like to maintain what we

031have in place as well as keep the turnover of our asphalt um parking lots and driveways we've gotten last couple years we've made a lot of progress and we would like to continue we have a number of lots that are deteriorated for whatever reason um a lot of cracking and it's it's gone beyond any kind of maintenance for a lot of the Lots um some Lots like the Intermediate School certain areas can be maintained so this line item we would like to keep for the next couple years to keep going I would imagine few years down the line we'll be able to decrease this when it's just going to be maintenance as opposed to the mill and pavees this year and probably the next two three years it'll be um a large amounts we need

032to do quite a bit of Paving around campus line item number five is districtwide Furniture purchase this is for all schools um we need to start upgrading our classroom desks chairs um Cabinetry things like that as well as common areas where the kids like to um do some team learning when they're not in the classroom and then we get to line six which is our um districtwide Energy Efficiency upgrades um it also obviously includes the lighting but that's I want to say the small part of it but that's just the small tiny piece of what we're trying to do with our with our audit so what we have here is a couple of items in here um pricing is coming in as we speak um I should have most items by the end of this

033week I received another piece yesterday um so this will include the Weston High School front lobby back in 06 when did the addition they made a larger front opening and what they had done was they remove the two heating elements so in the front of the school we have no no makeup heat so we're looking into doing a little bit of um addition towards the auditorium side and the main entrance nothing nothing crazy split system so it could take care of some dehumidification in summertime which I'm sure as you walk through there you know that it can be very humid and de of winter is extremely chilly so that's one of the items I have on there that pricing I should have I Believe by tomorrow i' I was promised did a number of walkthroughs

034with this trying to trying to assess exactly what our what our vision is how we want to um condition the space next one is also in high school in I believe it was mid 90s a rooftop was put in for the center old gym location not for the gym itself but for the boys locker room girls locker room they have a um two team rooms on the boy side two team rooms on the girl side uh they have a training room hallways and the the rooftop that they had dropped in about it's you know it's turning about 30 years old it struggles to keep up on a yearly basis so the locker rooms are not very conditioned um right now it's strictly Heating um the upgrade I would like to do is drop a package

035unit um with heating cooling fresh air to get us back into um spaces like uh science of the high school and the Intermediate School um get some of that dehumidification underway get a little bit of cooling and obviously wintertime with some heat it's a center part of the um building which you would think would need a tremendous amount of makeup heat but it does um it just doesn't maintain the heat so that was that uh that project the work in progress that we have is the uh the next line the north house HVAC replacement RFP is going to be ridden for a new vision uh the majority of those spaces classrooms there 24 classrooms it's mostly unit ventilator 1960s 1970s long ago technology um it needs to be revamped so we're looking into a way

036to heat as well as cool because there was very very limited Cooling in the north house um and as well as fresh air so we'll come up with a a request for design as to how we can how we can condition this space I going to imagine that this is going to be a pricey um pricey renovation so this would probably be a line item that's going to carry through a couple of years as opposed to just a single year in order the equipment put it in core boiler room again put in about 95 rough roughly at the elementary school um boilers decent shape um starting to show some wear and tear um I've already replaced a section on each boiler if you don't know most of our boilers here are pieced together they're not

037just one um one solid unit um we've had some cracking um some Replacements um pumps need to be replaced for efficiency uh the core if you don't know has five Air Handlers in the Attic that feed all the spaces um those at this point I believe I have another five years down the line for replacement for those units to be um taken care of as well as the roof for the elementary school okay line seven is our radio upgrade a couple years back we were piggybacked with the town to change our infrastructure and radio technology from town with police with Fire EMS as well as a school at some point we were not included so we need to do this on our own so it probably looks like a a large cost for just a

038radio replacement but it's much more than a radio replacement it would be to add repeaters we have a lot of dead areas in our schools it's to carry the signal from the tower which is at the police department through our buildings through our campus so it also includes a lot of um a lot of infrastructure changes not just radio changes line item number eight is uh Weston Intermediate School cafeteria table purchase if you've been in the intermediate school they have tables and chairs which are separate from each other and what happens is you have six lunch shifts so there's a lot of movement a lot of tables a lot of chair sliding and it seems like on a weekly basis we almost have to empty out the room and have our cleaning or our evening

039cleaning company come in give it a quick buff because it just looks T tth Tetter um these would be foldup tables like we have in elementary school and we have in the middle school with seats in graded into them um it's it's a it's a simple upgrade we can get rid of those tables and chairs in there at this point we hold the chairs on because it is a cafetorium so they do do a lot of their presentations in that gym so we would hold on to the chairs for the 10 or so times that we actually do presentations in there um but the tables would go also Intermediate School for line item number nine it's a it's called VI box Electronics what we have is every room in the Intermediate School whether it's a

040classroom whether it's a closet whether it's a office Library everything has its own separate temperature control rooftops feed a certain temperature down and then there's every single room has a box which makes up the temperature it's all electronic um whether it's a hot water valve to add more heat a cold water valve to add more cooling or a damper for air flow the electronics are starting to fail at a pretty pretty high rate um we get quite a few few complaints and we have to change them out so at this point being again about that 20y old Mark um I'd like to be proactive and just go in there and change the valves the actual electronic actuators that and this is all through our energy management system um everything can be seen on the computer

041line item number 10 is rest refen field sitework if you've noticed over the C past couple of years you've seen a cascading Wall come in from the hill heading from um Lord's Highway so what you have is there's no drainage up on the field so you have a delusion water that comes down and it goes from the wood line which would be like the rear of the middle school and it runs to school road side and it funnels to one location and it erodes the it had been eroding the hill away and we had to keep bring in the so bring the soil bring in the gravel from school road back onto the site couple back we did a cascading wall to get the water off so this last piece is the refson field side

042because now because of all the delusion water we have a little bit runoff underneath the fence that's up on top on the left field side of the baseball field the varsity field so this would add a little bit of um little bit of holding for the waters and it would stop eroding so that's this year's Capital uh 10 items I'm sure there are questions I don't have anything else to speak of but I could certainly answer anything that you uh would like to ask I just have a quick comment um in general it sounds like the way we operate is we defer a lot and I'm not I I understand why um but it sounds like we're still we are deferring a lot it's it's it's this isn't really a comment on you by any

043stretch it's just this is the culture of how we operate is that that's true for this coming year as well right we we seem to defer a lot well we have some things that we looking into getting done middle school wise well with Ker's um plan as well as ours it's about two years away to come up with a decision how we're going to start upgrading some of the HBC over there and some of the items that we have on the list so I I I don't if I would say deferring just prioritizing and um trying to keep things we know that aren't going to move or possibly change keep those areas moving forward okay so then related to the middle school what is we know that we don't know what we're doing with the

044middle school and we know what we don't know is two years if we do anything which one will presume we will have to do something is probably two years away so from a budgeting perspective and this came up a bit last night I think somebody raised the question of I think it was related to the communication systems um are we potentially looking at investing equip are we making decisions or are we compelling the town into contracts to uh make changes at the middle school when in the next 18 months it's so fluid what we're doing in the middle school we might be doing work that's going to be undone like how do we make sure the community knows that we're not putting money into a system that in 18 months because we don't know right

045that's why we have we've decided to hold off on the HVAC side of it the PA system regardless of what we do that will be able to be reused even if it has to get let's let's just say it is going to be a new school being built it could be pulled out and reapplied to the new building um if we're just going to piece the middle school and do our repairs so be it then we'll we could still use the PA system it's it's not a throwaway it would still be still be used and for the HVAC side of it everything is specific to the area there are um 20 some odd Air Handlers to feed different spots of that that school so at this point anything that would be a repair would have

046to be built it would have to be made at the Machine Shop um we had the art and science unit go down about seven or eight years ago and took us about 3 four weeks to have um items machined to put in and so at this point it doesn't make any sense to replace any of those Air Handlers when our vision would be moving forward especially when we do our our audit would be to get rooftops whether we have to structurally engineer the roof or what have you to get us back to today's techn ology and really improve the indoor air quality of the building so the so there is that the moving component or the unknown component of what's going on with the middle school that's been factored into the budget and the things

047that's kind of was the basis of my question was we're not putting good money into something that we're going to potentially lose or have to completely undo but at the same time we can't be you know the analysis paralysis things are going to fail we have to do something about yeah we've been mindful the last uh handful of years to not jump on the HVAC changes even though I do have a number of prices to start working on it um we've kind of put a little bit of a pause to it that way we could get our vision find out where we're going to go with the building but yeah we're not throwing money away that would be a a year fix 18th month fix two year threee fix absolutely not I have a quick

048question about the radios I think you have um I believe it's $200,000 scheduled for the update of the radio system This was um this goes hand inhand with the new radio system that the town just purchased for the fire department police department correct that's correct and it's is there any way that we can um leverage that um what any of the any of the infrastructure that they have or anything like that to help offset that cost of 200,000 because it's it's just it's a big number clearly we need to be in the same frequency and the same radius system with them but is there any way that we can Leverage What the town has already paid for to help lower that for us that that cost there is to work with what they've already put

049in place the all the cell technology that they put up and everything that they have on their Tower we would just have to get it building to building over here so it would be repeaters I think at this point we have one repeater in the high school that would have to be changed out which is certain Technologies to let the radio flow through the system is what we need to start working on right they did they get a grant do you know if they got a grant for those I can't remember they did so just just to add a little bit of um some background to to to the radio so a few years ago when the town decided to upgrade their radios the original plan was that a board of education would be a

050part of that um um process what we found out was the grant that they applied for was only was only related to emergency responders or emergency services and that pretty much excluded the Board of Education from being a part of that of that Grant um there was a delay in communication um in in informing us that we would not be included in that in that Grant I think we found out maybe two years or so and then that's when we started to add it onto the project so just can we stop there for a second who who made that decision that we were not to be included I I think it was a decision not to interrupt Phil but I think it was you know that's when I came on board and I remember going

051over to the meeting and okay let's find out about the radios and they said unfortunately the grant that we're applying for guess what you're not included it was I think the former Town Administrator told us correct just just to clarify it's not to point a finger to any one person the grant right the grant was an emergency services Grant the bir of education is not included in emergency services so we were not in included in the Grant application and pretty much we were pretty much forgotten there's been other funding source that the town has received that that covered cost off radios but we definitely we're pretty much told you're pretty much ear on with this project and once you were told that we included that if you look back to fiscal 25 that's the first

052time that it appear on um on our the $200,000 is a placeholder we honestly do not know what the final cost would be we've been working with a consultant that been a little bit difficult to to to to get in contact with so we're not 100% certain that the 200,000 that we even have as a placeholder will be the final cost but we we wanted to have something there to start a discussion okay so can I can I just make a suggestion going forward in the future when a situation like this occurs we'll make this the decision whether or not we will participate or how we'll participate um we we don't need the town to tell us we don't qualify we we we we'll make we'll make that decision for ourselves and maybe there's a

053way of circumventing that by going to our it's an emergency radio system that that's what we're dealing with here and so I can't think of I can't think of one group in town that is more in need of having an emergency radio system um than the Board of Education since it's and so I I I'm I'm afraid that decisions are being made on our behalf by people who are not in a position to make a decision for ourselves for the Board of Education bring I think that that had more to do with where the grant was originating from having being not necessarily geared towards sorry but not being married to a fireman I got to hear a lot of details about this whole radio thing and it was geared not towards school systems in any

054of the communities but it was geared specifically towards First Responders right so I think that that's why it's unfortunate that the communication wasn't made to us that you know I mean I would love to say absolutely we should be on their coattails because we are we should be a part of that um and every school system should be but I think that the grant was specifically just for First Responders uhuh so if I if I may say something that that's important I'm concerned that people hearing this think that we are in an unsafe position in the campus and the thing I want to stress is that we have ample radios for the staff that need them not on that same frequency um and um Mr deito correct with our alert buttons now we also have

055ways to contact so I don't want people to walk away thinking that yes we need to correct this radio situation but that does not mean that we don't have ample radios for our own usage is that do you want to add anything Dan yeah and I mean the the quick alert buttons you know we we're we're on on schedule with getting those set up and that's a direct line of communication to dispatch um and you know we've also done other things like increasing cell phone service in the middle school and stuff like that so we're not at a at a at a disadvantage I don't I I agree with Le I don't I don't want anyone using that taking that away from this conversation that you know we're in Dire Straits no and that's not

056my point my point I'm not suggesting we are in that but this is the second time in my history where radios were being purchased for one part of the town and we had and we had to do it on our own so in the future when there are opportunities like this um I I'd rather not I'd rather I if there's money available Sharon no matter how the grant is written you can always go to our state legislators or whomever uh to work on our behalf or else it just falls on us you know on our on our overall budget so I just don't I don't I'd rather I'd rather be in charge of our destiny than just take someone's word for it yeah just real quick just just want to add that there there's been

057that was during the transition time with with leadership so a few things were a miss and the communication wasn't necessarily as clear as it needed to to to be but now working with Larry Roberts uh we definitely have a better working relationship and also with Carl um so we we're we're on the same page and um and I think we have definitely improve the line of communication okay well it it is good to have Larry given his you know given his position in the fire department and and then having taken over you know emergency communications I was just going to ask and I agree with you 100% Steve I think there was an opportunity when uh they went and got money from the legislature uh we should have said we need X plus 200 to

058do the whole project to include the schools um so that was a missed opportunity uh but this kind of goes into a question I was going to ask ask uh later when it came up but maybe now we don't have a grant writer within the school district right because I know that there are Grant there's grant money out there for all kinds of initiatives but if you don't have the person with the expertise so do we don't have a grant writer right is that yeah and and you know as we talk about budgeting and stuff like that are there grant writers out there that can be um engaged on a per Grant type of basis where if we have I know that there are grants out there for emergency communication systems for schools you know

059the window film and stuff like that is that do we have like a contact that we could you know we we pay X but we we get back Y is that something I was going to ask about this later in the budgeting but this is just something that it's timely now you know if if I may um no we don't have a person that is solely dedicated to grant writing um we do um have people um such as Tracy such as Tina such as Phil Dan that are constantly I get emails about grants and they put them forth themselves and then we we get our funding by that I I mean a clearly a full-time position would not be I don't not believe needed at this at the district level but I I think that

060over the last few years we've done a a good job at it and I look forward to when Jim Willy comes on specifically in the area of security Now if people need help you know we do work as a team in writing it and all that we can certainly work together or there's no problem if we need a certain level of expertise um reaching out and finding someone but Steve you've uh Steve Phil you've also been successful correct putting in Grants and um Mike I know that that you you guys have put in Grants and gotten funding correct Phil I don't know what happened to Phil oh I'm I'm sorry I had to take a quick call Lisa can you just repeat the last part I'm talking about you know David's point is well talking

061about writing grants and things like that we don't have a grant writer but but you out of your office also there have been grants written to be able to to do this I'm thinking in the area of security right yeah I think we we we recently received um a a grant um there was a multimedia Grant which funded um based on the state reimbursement the project that we did um last summer so we we have been successful what we've tried before and we did not receive those Grant a lot of times we're excluded from the grant um because a lot of the grants that's out there they're really based more so best way to say this on minority communities um so there's really limited funding um for towns like Weston Tina has has definitely done

062a lot as well to to get those grants there's a lot of funding that became available with to co to to the pandemic Rel for Esser and for arper we have received some of those grants and we've made the relative adjustment so I think collectively as a team we we we've used our Collective resources um really to to to write these grants and in some parts we've been successful in others we have not so I think ultimately one to Lisa's point when Jim starts I mean there's probably lots of Grants out there and there's there's limited time for each one of you uh to be doing stuff like that and that's just the reality of it nobody likes to have money not make it to you know your desk so to speak but so maybe

063what we can do is on the when Jim starts since Lisa and a whole bunch of you get these types of emails things that are security related and this m there still could be an opportunity right it's it's one of those things where uh there could be a grant option out there that can help offset this cost but I agree with you Steve 100% it's basically missed opportunity uh that we have to now pay for hey David I'll chime in this is this is chat I have to be on U off video right now I don't know how deep we want to go into the grants conversation and I know I've carved out a reputation for myself as the anti-tech dude but this is a very ethical and good use of tech actually so uh

064this would be a perfect opportunity to try to draw on two things one you could write these things much more efficiently now because of large language models and AI tools and the second is that we have a deeply talented community in Weston so if we are trying to kind of up our our grant game I think it would be worth just kind of putting some feelers out because there's probably Lots of Volunteers in the community who would be happy to be researchers and also potentially some labor force in terms of writing this kind of stuff if people are spread too thin so my thoughts on up for two cents thanks um we appreciate that and um under uh D DeVito's leadership we do use um we do have a a large language model that we

065have been using to both analyze uh budgets and all kinds of things and and help us in uh creating and fine-tuning documents for their Clarity so a good suggestion to extend it to the grant we good job Dan thank you Lisa I don't know if there were any other questions so we went through the capital but were there any other questions regarding within the budget uh the operating budget with equipment that we that involv facilities with Staffing with any of that if there's any um clarification you need while um Mike is here I do want to point out um we still have a few um items that we that we're waiting on pricing when we do receive those pricing there may be a need to rep prioritize some items that we have in the list

066and maybe to even shift items to to those other years um so hopefully by the time we get to a decision we'll have pricing and we can have further discussion related to those items can you just remind me what they are Phil Mike you have the list in front of you I do um we have the PA system which we just have to kind of fine tune that we can we'll have very shortly and then it just comes to the HVAC side with our efficiency um with our audit on the lighting side of it I have numbers for the um high school locker room uh hbac replacement I'll have a number tomorrow for the high school Lobby hbac um Edition because there is none uh the boiler project I already have um North house is

067going to take a little bit of time and the last one we have which I should have shortly we have have a couple vendors working with us is the line out of nine and that's the Intermediate School of VAV box electronic um actuators okay thanks let me ask a question and apologies about missing the beginning of the meeting for a doctor's appointment so if you've already covered this forgive me uh I just want to I do want to revisit conversations about smartboards and laptops and that kind of thing but I don't know if that fits under Mike's category at all or not or if I've missed that so is that to come or have we already passed passed that in which case I want to ask a couple questions about it we began with technology

068and um Dan DeVito and Dr Tina hanle presented great it does not involve um Mike delmastro okay with um as you know is everybody okay with Mike do Master dropping off the call and then Chad can get his technology questions answered anybody need Mike okay farewell Mike thanks Mike Chad's yours Chad okay sorry apologies I thought leis I thought you meant that Tina or Dan were gonna begin to start sorry about that I I basically just want to I know I Advanced this conversation a whole bunch in the large group meeting a couple weeks ago and we' said we're gonna you know kick it down to the conversation on the 16th so I I still have sort of the same basic questions which is what are the educational outcomes that we anchoring to technology and

069some of particularly things like brain breaks and stuff like that that are actually uh not helpful for what they're claiming in terms of uh benefit for our learners but more to the point how do we need Chromebooks and smartboards as for kids under fifth grade and how are we going to justify that in a budget that is going up 5% and we're talking about potentially having a look at Personnel so it's a sort of still the same basic questions I just love to get more more detail on that Lisa did you want us to start did you want us I I guess I just have one question did you review the the technology documents that we sent out early this morning or did you not have a chance to yeah I've taken a look at

070it I I suppose that I mean I I guess it just comes down to the kind of the brass tax of can we justify to the Community Technology over teacher salary if that's the the the Crux of decision we're ultimately coming to because the the conversation a couple weeks ago was like if you want to push this budget down at all you have to be cutting head count and my position is that I think as a community parents are always going to ask for teachers rather than technology and I'm not particularly persuaded that uh that Chromebooks and smartboards are actually even necessary so uh I might just be a minority opinion on this beating a drum be but I I do really wonder are they even necessary well let let me begin with that um

071and um I think you missed my earlier comment we believe they are necessary we believe that if you look at all the presentations and the links in the document provided that explains our stance along with research and everything we also did a typical day to clarify that students are not constantly on this equipment um I think that when you talk about something like a Smartboard you have to be able to project some way shape or form and we're not going to in a classroom and we're not going to go back to using the overhead projectors of the 90s and um you know if the board so wants us to look at how we can reduce the budget I think that we have some other ideas but our Our intention and our position is to continue

072on the trajectory of supporting the current technology plan Dr hanle can you um elaborate on that please yeah sure um I think I know you missed the beginning portion Chad but um the document that we that Dan and I collaborated on to put together around the instructional aspect of the K12 um curriculum and Chad you've been involved in these conversations so um I as Lisa mentioned I think this may be a topic that maybe we agree to disagree on right um since I arrived here we've had multiple conversations whether it be at um subcommittee meetings or um during Board of Education meetings to talk about how we intentionally and purposely and strategically enhance our curriculum through through the use of Technology as one aspect of why we need these why we need a variety of

073equipment to support our educational experience and the educational needs in Weston not just in Weston I mean broadly I think any educational environment is at this at this point right um in addition to that we've outlined explicit um ways in which we are very strategic and meticulous about how we are using different applications different software um different devices um that are individualized based on student needs throughout the district um we try to put that together with again as Lisa mentioned not only with an overview of how we use these devices and what we need them for but also I know you've been asking a lot specifically about the earlier age children and so that's why we put to get together a typical day in the life of a a hurlbut student which is a kindergarten

074first grade and second grader and then as you know as they evolve and get older um because as Lisa mentioned um contrary to what communication you have may received um these students none of our students it doesn't matter what grade none of our students are sitting in front of a computer for six hours um and so um our teachers are explicitly designing learning experiences throughout the day and week and months that are connected to standards in a variety of ways and without these tools we wouldn't have a rich educational experience um so that would be my instructional aspect of the conversation I have linked a variety of very detailed presentations that we've involved over the last three years with our library media Specialists who support our International standards for technology and educ ation and our

075computer science standards as well as our tools and and needs for intervention for assessment um for special education um uh for classroom instruction that's just from the curricular enhancement side not even tapping into what Dan has extensively provided in that document around the history and evolution of our devices and the lifespan of the devices so um that's kind of what you missed in the beginning but we've also captured that in that full document um and I know Dan did a really good job of explaining kind of that historical aspect of it too so yeah and I and I also wanted to jump in and and talk a little bit about from a purely Hardware perspective that you know what I had spoken about earlier this morning in the document overlays is that the Chromebooks that

076are in the district right now they really have reached their end of life and by pushing out replacement of these Chromebooks uh anymore also pushes out the replacement of the staff laptops by another year and that's something that we unfortunately are really not in a position to do due to how difficult it is to Now find replacement parts for older equipment and I also wanted to touch on the fact that this is the use of technology in the classroom is not something static it's something that we're constantly talking about and evolving based on the data that we're seeing so you know like Tina said the students are not on the technology 6 hours a day we're looking at you know reducing that the students the age groups in which the the students take the devices

077home we're constantly evolving that right now our discussion is on fourth grade last year it was decided that third grade students no longer take them home and from a we want to prepare our students for life after school and whether we want to admit it or not technology is a heavy component in life after school and if you look at the compet if you look at our dur a comparisons every single K8 dur a district has a one toone program that starts in kindergarten they're all slightly different in the way they're implemented but students starting in grades four five and six they to take their devices home but a onet toone program does start at the K level for every uh dur a district so this isn't something that's in a in a vacuum that

078we're making a decision as ourselves this is something that not just dur a but nationally that that school districts are doing when they can afford to do it Chad sorad go ahead go ahead it's fine no please Michael go ahead um I I guess just you know drilling down this a little bit um Tina what would we be missing if we removed the you know the pads the Chromebooks the iPads from the younger children right so the the K through two K through five what is it in the instruction that this is enhancing what would we be missing if we remove that that let's say the teacher couldn't do as good a job or better without those tools what what what is specifically what is the advantage to having the tools in those settings and

079then my second part to that is I I I understand that you know when you look at and thanks for putting together the comparison with the other duras um you know I see everyone has everyone has the um the hardware in K through a are we using it differently in in in terms of instruction and how we integrate it in in in instruction the curriculum than other durg a schools so I guess that's that's that's two parts what we what would we be missing and are we using it differently in the instruction yeah so I mean we we I outlined it a little bit in in the way that we use our technology in the document I think that one of I think the biggest theme around the the lower grades especially when it comes

080to lesson design and planning is the individuality of for students at that those at any grade it doesn't even matter you pick a grade you know technology helps us individualize the needs for students at the lower grades as well um you know the tools as I mentioned such as some of those intervention programs PRS they're adaptive so depending how students Master different content areas for example it adjusts to what their needs are on the spot in the moment right so that's an enhancement feature to the curriculum um we use the tools for immediate feedback for students and that's kind of the adaptability that I talked about um we've been expanding and exposing students to more computer science standards in the library media area so they're integrating more coding um and interactive devices through um I

081forget the name the iRobots that we have at the at the lower grades um that really gets them actively participating and they're very engaged right um I think another aspect of it is the technology helps us with some of those foundational literacy skills that we um and digital skills that we're trying to get them prepared for when they transition to third grade um that's typing like that's an explicit skill as the students are evolving that has to be taught somewhere it doesn't just happen overnight right uh finger formation and making sure they understand how to use the keyboard functionality on a device because they do research even at the early grades and the research helps them with their writing projects and with their units of study and literacy um so you know I know um

082Chad mentions the Brain Breaks um the interactive tools for teachers when it comes to the smartboards that's how they're displaying the music that the students are getting up and moving during that time th that those Brain Breaks that you're mentioning are literally a few minutes during transition between math and literacy instruction um and also to build on what Tina was saying you know with the computer science curriculum that all school districts in Connecticut have to have finished and it start s at grade K if I'm not mistaken right Tina the the the computer science Chad remember a few years ago we were discussing computer science and programming and you had said yeah I would really love for the students to understand how to do that how they're building stuff and that's what this computer science

083program is for is to show them the back end this is how you're creating something this isn't just making a cartoon this is about um sorry my phone keeps ringing uh this is about the back end how they're building it what steps are taken from behind the scenes to make something into what it is so we're bu you know so what you had mentioned a few years back is exactly what we're looking to do and as a state requirement we're we have to start this down at the K level yeah well let me make a couple clarifications first of all one forgive me for being the the insensitive dude who shows up late to the meeting and ask a bunch of redundant questions and uh I I recognize the absurdity of that so thank you

084for your Indulgence uh the second is I don't know how I communicated that I thought kids were on screens for six hours a day I I have never thought that nor do I currently think that and so you you don't need to make any clarification there I'm sorry if I conveyed that impression that was not my impression at all I I know that I'm often asking the same questions over and over again I do think they're worth asking and I'll give you an example two years ago we were all in a meeting and every principal said no cell aren't a problem in our buildings and then we've removed cell phones and literally everyone has been talking about how much better the atmosphere is at school without the cell phones so I do think it's worth

085interrogating these things pretty much over and over again and I think it's very smart to draw a distinction Tina I have you know been in the the curriculum meetings for the last two years I'm very impressed at how Weston uses technology when we're mindful about it so I'm not talking about computer science I'm not talking about robotics and not talking about the great work you're doing Dan to help our kids understand not how to work technology but how technology works and I applaud all of that and I'm not actually a lite I built an app in 2015 and a a VR headset in 2016 for clients what I am concerned about is two really concrete things one is it worth the money and two are we certain that it is as good an alternative as

086you're documenting here I'll give you one very uh example a bunch of the things the interventions that we're talking about having an online component or a tech component those were started during the pandemic and they've actually been shown to not be that good of a solution Con Academy is a perfect example I don't think the homework lessons that our students are required to do on laptops and KH Academy are actually Superior to what instruction would be or even working it out on their own or with a parent or a caretaker so I've been really on this for you know a couple years now from a pedagogical standpoint but I also really question if we even need the laptops I hear your point about individuation but in all the meetings I've listened to the primary thing

087in individuation is about testing or one of them anyway but uh I would just ask okay so the other dur schools do it but there's a bunch of educational changes we've made the last few years that actually are not good so why are we as concerned about if they all have laptops do our kids actually need the laptops and is the either 100 or 300K price tag whatever it is worth it I recognize we have to replace the teachers laptops I do recognize that technology needs to get sunsetted to your point Dan and things are past their end of life usefulness but uh and I hear your point also about you know respectfully agreeing and disagree and I'm perfectly happy to be the the lone voice on this but I I still think if we're

088trying to save money on a budget that's 5% higher I don't see that kids need Chromebooks and replace smartboards as the way to you know spend some of our precious resources so if if the entire Administration thinks I'm wrong I get it and the board does as well I I still think it's a worth a worthwhile question to provoke well but but it's not just a question of money if we were to do that it's a question of how we're delivering education and that's a much bigger conversation it's not just I agree I would weigh in that I think like that as an example A lot of it is actually delivered worse via the technology I mean as one one very concrete example is there a hard and fast rule about using as just an

089example uh Danny goes or go noodles or brain bricks is there a a requirement in terms of classroom time or not across K through five so can I if I can say something um I think if you want to do cost effective it's an extremely cost effective way to engage students if you don't have a computer then you're going to have to have another teacher in the room who is individualizing that instruction for students who are having issues you have to have an encyclopedia I mean that's like 30 years ago but an encyclopedia in every classroom the home book offers an enormous opportunities in individualized application individualized work we can always hire more teachers we can always replace the computer with enormous um budgets for textbooks but fortunately we're at a time where we have

090a computer that offers um Savings in all these different different areas and allows the student to become more independent and not um um ha have other uh other sources that they have to be dependent on but that's assuming that's assuming that the the the changes are superior I mean I'll just go back to the example it's because the one I know about like why how is Con Academy homework better than traditional homework yeah can but we're not think we use KH Academy homework yeah yeah yeah we do that's part of the curriculum yeah we do but I thought we were focusing on the lower levels I'm Lisa is saying that all all these technology tools are better at engaging the students and they offer a a better cost to cost ratio and I'm suggesting that

091some of the programming some of the curriculum is actually worse than traditional so that's why I'm using KH Academy as example but we're not going to decide today right we're not going to we're not going to decide how we deliver the educational experience Thursday morning at 10:20 in the morning this is a much bigger conversation over whether or not we spend a dollar or $300,000 on Chromebooks yeah I I agree Steve I it's a little bit to David's point though about things delaying like I get it so the question that will be when do you have that conversation I mean obviously conversation for curriculum committee Etc uh but this is also the moment when the rubber hits the road in terms of how we spend the resources of of West and Conneticut so if you

092see a price tag for a whole bunch of new Chromebooks for kids that I'm not at all convinced that the parents of whom want the Chromebooks then when do you have the conversation well if we want as a board schedule that conversation we should schedule it if you disagree with spending $300,000 on Chromebooks then you just vote you you vote against the budget gotcha okay well I I mean I don't mean to derail meeting and I I recognize people maybe getting a level of frustration with me so I I still have some of the same concerns I will do a second Deep dive of the documents and yeah I do think it's worth talking about how these tools are superior or not because I'm not at all convinced that they are uh but yeah it

093at some point I think the conversation is worth having so to the extent that you agree Steve is is chair let me know if you want to have that conversation at some point I just want to clarify though for the record just a couple points all of our instructional software tools that we have um many of which have been in our um in our toolkit prior to covid let's just be very clear for example Lexia is one of those tools and that was here prior to Co in addition to that and I think I mentioned this um actually I've mentioned multiple times right um every year especially after covid um teachers leaders we call through our instructional software on a yearly basis to look for redundancy usage alignment to curriculum and we determine whether or

094not we are going to um remove or add instructional software as appropriate um different amounts um um in addition to that I just want to reiterate the goal of having a variety of instructional software tools which all of which and con is is a free tool um we don't we don't pay for Con Academy by the way um but the tools that we do purchase they're they all have white papers associated with them Lexia for example Symphony math for example um because the goal is to have not only digital tools so plugged in tools but also unplug tools so Hands-On resources for classroom small group either it's classroom instruction Andor intervention as well as plugged-in tools um all of which have white papers associated with them that correlate student achievement um and different concepts and

095skills that students need I mentioned before the goal of all of these tools is to ensure that we have individualization so that individual students can create goals and um Stu uh teachers can actually unpack the data so they can actually individualize and zoom in on small group needs for students across every grade right um so I just want to clarify maybe some some points that I heard just to reiterate but we can we can surely go back and and expand on even more of what we've been um talking about over the last three years around technology enhancement there there's one other thing I would like to add um if I may um and we certainly I don't want to portray that I'm frustrated I think there is an element of frustration because we talk we

096keep talking about and I brought this up before well you know we don't even know if the parents um want this we don't know that they don't want it but there's a bigger issue here we have a highly educated staff that has multiple degrees in instructional pedagogy and experience and if we were going to continue this discussion I would like to hear from their level of expert because we build this budget organically of what they think that they need and I do not want to disregard the staff and their feedback because they're living it every day in the classroom and you may have a little snapshot of what you think is happening in the classroom but they are truly the experts that give us the feedback on the software on the types of materials down

097to the use of time that they are spending on it that is just discussed especially in the areas of intervention and that to me would be an extremely important voice instead of anecdotal information about what parents do and don't want Lisa I completely agree with you you know what will get get me get me off everyone's back about this permanently is if you could show me that you know 80% of the staff think that these tools are useful they are mapped to positive educational outcomes then I will stop this because I the I am not skeptical about the human power in this district and Tina has done a marvelous job in curriculum the last couple years talking through some of these things I am a fan of how Dan tries to help our students learn

098how technology works as opposed to how to work technology and if you think the faculty say these these these tools are essential these tools help do this and that great I would love to be educated about that I think it's a a great use of time and I maintain my skepticism on a bunch of these tools because I see whether doing in our society r large and that's why I'm hammering certain examples like KH Academy etc etc I think one of the great battles that we all have to is as Educators and parents and community members in this era is try to help our kids protect their attention spans their ability to learn and it's a much bigger risk that our kids are facing of as opposed to getting out of school and not knowing

099how to use technology the bigger risk is that their their brains are so scattered that they don't actually have the ability to sit down and spend four hours with with an original text or something like that so great I would love that and if the teachers all say these are essential tools we need them I will I will let the other board members talk about the things they're concerned about and I will seed my floor time the one thing I do want to add is is that you know this is a partnership and you are absolutely right when we look at the cell phones that is an area where I think we all can agree based on experience both at home parents with the cell phones and in school and that that was a great

100example of working together to um to do something beneficial uh for the children this other piece with the instructional pedagogy I I I think is a little bit more complicated and um I appreciate your willingness to uh listen to what the teachers have to say Lisa I would love any ideas you have about how to kind of you know pull the The Faculty about that I would love to see that and again if if they're much more the experts on this than I am you're right they're living their the moment to moment in the classroom if they think these things are essential then I'd love to be educated about that so please let me know how we can do that and I would really look forward to that conversation okay Lisa is there uh what

101more is there to discuss today um there's I know that David has a question that I think might be um David you want me to go ahead and kind of uh talk a little bit about the uh the enrollments and the sections and all of that you know what David just had to pop off the call yep no I haven't popped off yet but oh you're there Sor I have I have a 10:30 I can't oh I'm sorry I'm so sorry no no no no no if so but I'll be back so if you guys are still okay when you back yeah I I have to pay for my screen time here by do my day job sorry Chad okay so we'll we'll wait till you return and then we can uh go through that

102that that that would I really would appreciate that sure no worries all right so while we were talking about um uh class size I think that you're going to address that before we talk about class size and I think the lower grades and I think that's what David wanted to address I wanted to um talk a little bit about class size I guess or what's happening in the high school and the reason is because I saw a couple of alarming um figures when there when we were looking at the projections of the number of students in some cohorts that are moving into the high school so we have I think a very small cohort as a freshman class and also one as an eighth grade class um and my concern is that we and we

103know that's what's happened is a lot of younger families moved to town we have quite a few younger kids who are going to be coming in through the system we're going to see it building up again but you know when we have prek kindergarten some first that we're going to start to see that growth coming in and in the meantime we're going to see a large dip going down in the high school how are we going to address address that as far as Staffing is concerned because as much as you know I love our I have a senior in high school right now I I love our high school teachers I think that they've done a great job for my son actually for two of my sons um but my concern is um how are

104we going to handle the dip in the um the enrollment in the high school knowing that it's going to grow again um as the other cohorts are coming in but at the same time being financially responsible you know that's a it's like eight years that we're talking about holding on to staff um so what's what's our plan with that okay so let's talk a little bit about the dip that you're you're talking about so if you look at the page of the medium projections page 65 in the budget book you have for next year 676 uh students projected at the high school and then yes it goes down to about it flattens out to about uh 600 so when you look at that you know you're looking at about 70 students less um the things

105that you have to understand about high school scheduling is you cannot look at the high school necessarily by pure grade level because the majority of our classes at the high school are mixed grade levels for example if you look at something like um math there are students in 9th grade in Algebra 2 honors there are 11th graders and Algebra 2 honors so it really is all mixed up Spanish four you'll get Spanish four kids that are sophomores Spanish four kids that are seniors the only pure level classes are things like social studies world studies ninth grade that's the only class that every ninth grader takes there's no honors component so when you look at the Staffing and you see how the staffing has been established we look at a couple of different things and we

106go through and we build the schedule we look at the course offerings we look at how we offer these course offerings is it the last in a series for example is it Spanish six um which is the last in the series and maybe they have 13 students and we certainly want to run this because it's the last in this series um because we do have uh certain you know enrollment guidelines but how we address it and how we've addressed it in this budget if you will is the reduction just give me one minute I don't want to missp speake um in the introduction under specifically the high school [Music] um we have a change this year of 15 students and so we reduced uh Staffing at the high school I believe it's a total of

107uh 1.3 and how that's adjusted is on enrollments and what we think students are going to take if we get a class and there's not enough students to take offering oftentimes it's not the the the course but it's the section we will reduce a section for example if we did not have enough let's say we thought we were going to have I don't know four sections of psychology and only enough students that enrolled in it were for three sections of psychology then we would be reducing that um allotment in social studies sometimes it's picked up in another area sometimes it's not so the Staffing is really built like there's 600 students we build the Staffing based on the needs of 600 students making decisions about the overall program keeping in mind that uh clear almost

108everyone goes to college and we have to have certain educational Pathways for them whether it be stem whether it be fine arts whether it be um you know math whether it be Humanities I I know if I'm I'm making sense so that's where when you see some reductions already it's because how we are predicting of what the students um wish to take and what they're guided to take so that they have a robust transort so when it goes down to 600 you could say okay that's 70 kids that are not in class anymore well 70 kids but again it depends on what grade level where do they fall how the adjustment is made it's not as easy to say all right we have 75 kids Less in fifth grade that's three sections we're not going

109to have three teachers you've got to balance that with where are those 75 kids if they're concentrated in one grade or the 75 concentrated over four grades you know then what are we looking at a section per grade but what are the courses something like a world studies very easy something like an English nine very easy English 10 or 10 honors very easy not so easy when you look at calculus Greek cal um those kinds of courses I I don't know if I'm explaining myself you are explaining but I mean I think that it just um I I understand what you're saying in as far as we have you the the offerings are there but at the same time if the students aren't there if if our enrollment because I mean we're you know um

110691 now um and in in a 10year the median projection in 10 years is 598 that's you know more than a hundred students Less in the high school that that that's a substantial drop now we can't make that change overnight but I think that we definitely need to start steering our ship in the direction that's going to address it I I certainly don't want to see kids not have the opportunity to take Spanish six but what about combining um Spanish six and and an AP I mean because there's got to be some similarity as far as I mean doing things like that so we can combine a classroom room so we can make sure that our headcount stays in line with our enrollment um you know I mean look there private schools where there are

111kids four kids in a classroom or one kid in a classroom but that's you know that's just not feasible when when it's a when it's a public school to be perfectly honest with you um let me paint a little bit more color on this Sharon if this is helpful um because you all know I've been here a long time and it might be future work that the future Administration will have to engage in the board with um when I um at one point there was less than 400 students at Western High School this was I think it was in the 9s and that's when you know said oh I taught the middle school I taught at the elementary school that's because uh you know I had to um that's how we kept full-time we had

112about 17 people going back and forth shared teachers to accommodate you know you have 10e teachers what are they going to teach all of that so we kind of have done the opposite and I'm really I guess have a a strong background in the opposite of how do you grow and when the school was less than 400 you say well what did we offer and how did we offer it and how did we make decisions increasing our offerings and in this case perhaps sometimes decreasing our offering offering so it the enrollments it's kind of the same strategy either way for example we have AP Chemistry and you say to yourself from there were years when I was high school principal where we could not run um AP CM right now we're looking again at APM

113and if you look in the book it's I'm trying to find it really quick I believe it's I want to say eight but I don't want to misspeak AP cam currently has nine students in it okay and so next year we do not have AP CM running and the reason we don't have AP CM running is because we've looked at who those nine students are what are they taking and if we can't I mean nine was pretty low to run I remember when it was 78 we didn't run it what is the alternative for those students to have a rich robust um plan what they what a great many of them take are things like um they'll go to the other AP uh physics level there's two levels they'll go to the AP environmental which

114has become extremely popular so often times when you're building a robust transcript you're looking at if you are removing this what is the alternative for that student to take because you want to make sure that overall it's based on student need but also based on um robust offerings for many years when I first um became High School principal actually it was even before um thinking back on it not that we want to make more work uh sorry guys is there was a report that we had to generate that said sections under 15 at the high school and what we saw in those sections it was a report I would have to present in the fall to the board about how many sections are less than 15 and so for example you might have six sections

115in world studies and you might have out of the six one section is less than 15 you say well why is that because you have to have a certain amount of sections to be able to accommodate kids that's not really as as big a deal but then they would say and that's where we started combining classes well okay we only have this many and if you look at World Language now and I believe some of them are combined it would be let's look at World Language and see like you know um where Latin 4 honors Latin 4 AP is combined and it would be all right we offer combined sections we offer um there were times where we only called it intermediate Latin honors believe it or not we did that for a year because

116we would flipflop back and forth you would do Virgil and then you would do stories I'm probably really getting into the weeds but that's what you have to do and and people have to understand um you know done this Staffing since 2002 so maybe so much of it is in my head and being able to uh internalize it and I know Julie has built the Staffing so uh we're in good hands having someone uh uh in central office as well as the high school team to be able to look at those nuances and how we can combine you know for example we have in music right now I believe we run two sections of Orchestra because of the number of students well at one of the levels well if the numbers are decreasing we only

117offer one and then it's fine to say where do we offer it because then you look at conflicts and sometimes a child you know years AG go ahead to say well I really want to take Spanish five honors and it's the same time as Orchestra or or or band what am I going to do well guess what we have a jazz band you can do that in the evening so then you say well do we do some kind of a extra call it not Jazz Orchestra I don't know something like that to provide that student that opportunity it's all about really looking at it through a particular lens of quality of program classes under 15 sections how do we look at it what decisions we make and involving people like Randy green all right saying

118Randy College and Career how would this look if we didn't have this and students want to apply to these competitive uh colleges it's a very complex thing but rest assured we've done it going down like when I first came it was high and then it went down now it's going up and I would encourage the board to perhaps ask for that report next year of how was the what are the sections what's the story in preparation for looking at it as it is being reduced over the well you're saying it's going up now and as far as we're adding staff or no we're not adding we're reding right okay because we say in my history I've had it up and then go down and then I've had it go back up and some of the

119the things that are helpful for people to understand is that report I used to do in the fall where they'd say what are the numbers of sections uh and 15 and what's the story it's the story behind it it's not as simple as just looking at numbers you know no I agree section lower and you know it you really get into the intricacies of the the scheduling we we rely on the expertise of the power school people there we sent them to Power School University Julie went and got a free backpack um and how that we can leverage power school to be able to schedule that school because you're right it's very complex it is exceptionally complex and we're definitely relying upon you and your staff's expertise to make sure that we're doing that but

120I think that you understand we are definitely in that downward slope right now and you know I mean even even things like you know you look at classroom teachers that's one thing but you also look at you know um for example um uh guidance you know right now we have five guidance counselors but as a number of students goes down it's it you know I hate to think of having to you know eliminate a guidance position but maybe that's one of those things that we have to look into doing as well so we just have to be super mindful of the numbers are going down in the high school we're gonna have to make sure that I I would love to see robust offerings I'd love to see all those teachers stay there for one

121those larger cohorts come up no question about it but physically that's just not responsible so I I you know I think that we need to make some tough decisions if I can just add a little bit and maybe um I was looking to see oh yeah Tracy is on the call sorry I'm looking her face um I want to talk a little bit about the school counselor thing because you know I I understand but what you're saying and what we weigh against that is the needs of the students and also emerging needs that we've seen quite frankly another conse quence of Co and how we are using those counselors you know again we pride ourselves in Weston to really have that access to um help right whether it you know help and connection and with

122the um team that we have at the high school with the counseling staff the social worker all of that and in all the schools the exact level um the different types of needs that we are seeing that must be addressed Tracy would you like to add a little bit to that perhaps yes absolutely I Sharon I hear everything that you're saying about enrollment and I think it's something that we have our eye on um moving into the future but it is not a recommendation right now you know I think Lisa touched on this in her response um the the types of challenges that we're working through with our high school students is very different now than it was even a few years ago and so while we typically think of guidance counselors or school counselors

123um as providing guidance around course selection and you know academic access they are providing a tremendous amount of social emotional support to our students that looks vastly different than it did five years ago um and I think they're the right people to be doing that work because they do see the overlap between the college process the academic coursework and you know some of the difficulties students are facing academically um we have a psychologist and a social worker who also work to support the needs of specific students um but I would have very significant concerns about us trying to at this particular Moment In Time absorb the work of one of our guidance counselors in the roles that exist right now again in the future we might very well be having that conversation but not in

124this proposed budget no we again not necessarily suggesting it in this proposed budget either but when I look at those numbers going down it's just fewer students you know and I and I again I understand the importance of guidance counselors don't please don't misunderstand but when we have fewer students there's fewer there's less Demand on their time and I think that that's an area in particular that we'll have to keep an eye on as we as we think about where changes we just so you know a lot of these questions we internally push the envelope and ask ourselves what if we did this what if we did that how can we do this what can we mitigate what it's always about that Tipping Point and we've had I mean I want to say okay what

125if we're getting rid of of of these things what is the impact of it whether it be you know an adverse impact or a positive impact it's um you're right these are things that we're going to have to continue to look at every position has to be looked at in a fine tooth comb quite frankly and what the person does and whatnot and just anecdotally I was having conversation with a parent just yesterday about um singing uh somebody's praises and we all had these stories with a counselor at the high school who happened to be my daughter's counselor and she said you know she got my child to come back to school school avoidy is unfortunately um something that when I think back over my 40-year career it's very prevalent now and to be able

126to have the time to get that child back um to be blunt if that child can't come back then what are we looking at an out placement no we want to first of all it's about the child we want the child back right but but these sometimes are the unintended consequences that can happen if we do not have a level of stopping to really work with these kids um or right I'll stop sometimes I think I'm getting on a soap box I'm sorry if I could just add one one piece to this because I think what's challenging Sharon I appreciate your comments and your questions and and certainly look looking at those numbers will have us asking tough questions in years to come um what's challenging is the incremental Decline and and at the high

127school as Lisa um explained in detail that that can be difficult to pinpoint given uh the different trajectories that students are on but one thing that I want to highlight because I think it's important for language purposes when we talk about one section at the elementary level we're talking about one position one one teacher when we talk about one section at the secondary level we're talking about one class essentially and that's not a whole person um so sometimes when we talk about these uh incremental changes we're talking about making a move from someone being a whole a 1.0 FTE to being a part-time staff member a point8 or a point 6 and sometimes that can have significant implications on the quality of Staffing right we have people who won't want to stay with us for

128less than a full-time job so that's also a consideration when we look at Staffing changes is what's the impact on the quality of the instruction that we'll be able to provide because it might result in a Personnel change I appreciate that um and I think that I I I think the reason I raised this is you know we had in public comment last night um one of uh our residents mentioned you know the atvm and we all sit here and we listen to you know 04 reduction 0.5 reduction 02 reduction and we as a board member I think we've been speaking this language long enough that we all kind of understand what that means right um but for the people who are actually voting on this budget they don't and they don't understand the repercussions

129of well if we get rid of one section at the high school that's not one person that we're getting rid of that person is only teaching that one class but she also Al or he also teaches you know four other sections in different classes so if we eliminate him or her there then that you know throws everything in a disarray so I bring this up because Lisa I believe you are on stage right or is it Steve that's on stage um during the atbm yeah so yes I'm on stage I I didn't really understand that comment though last night I have to say related to the atbm and the budget well I think that she was kind of more focused to be perfectly honest with you on the um the facilities aspect of it and

130looking forward to um you know what we're talking about doing down the line but I do think that we are going to have a group of um people who are going to be very vocal about Staffing and why we're not cutting our staffing when we're seeing our especially our Secondary School the numbers go down while we're waiting for these other cohorts to come in and I think that we as an Administration need to be extremely ready and buttoned up and ready to explain that not as simple as it appears and here are the repercussions of you know getting rid of X Y and Z I think that because right now this you know right now the way it flies if people don't understand certain things like that you know this this budget risks not being

131passed by the town and that's not something we want to see either so just be prepared um to exp we understand that I and I again I encourage people to read the documents that we spend an incredible amount of time in and really understanding them I I think unfortunately you know uh one of the disadvantages is everyone goes to school so right everybody thinks that they know how schools are run and they come with their own certain perception of whether it be their own childhood or 20 years ago or 10 years ago when their child uh graduated and it's really important to look at everything contextual and to understand um some of these complexities that we have faced over the years and we've always been able to manage well and and I I think that

132you guys have done a fantastic job of creating these documents to help us understand but at the same time I think you need to be prepared because the average citizen is not reading them so you just need to be prepared to to explain that to them especially at the atbm if they come in and they decide that they want to take a scalpel to our our budget you need to be you know ready to explain to the person who hasn't read that document you know why and exactly we are standing behind the numbers that we're standing behind so that's I'll stop at that but I think that you guys get my point I know you're not being critical I know that you're you're you're talking about something that I was thinking about last night and

133I think it's h our Collective responsibility as an administrative team to explain look um I can't say oh vote for it but I it's so important for me to explain and provide information and then people make their own decision so we are happy to spend the time to explain and put out these documents and um you know what's helpful is is that then the people that are raising it if you could please look at what we've put out as well so you have a clear understanding of um how this uh these decisions will impact um the education in this town I also think it's really important and um Phil forgive me for quoting you from last night he's like whoa what did I say um but I think it's really important to share something that

134Phil and I discussed and that was you know right now the biggest driver of this um increase in the budget is the insurance and benefits there's no secret there that was discussed last night in the meeting but I think that we also need to be very very aware of the fact that we don't know if this is a trend we don't know if this is a one-time thing we don't even know if these numbers are going to hold we Phil is just being you know physically responsible and and looking at the projections based upon what he's dealing with right to make sure that we are not going to find ourselves in a in a you know where we don't have enough money in the budget to cover what needs to be covered next year however

135that being said to make any substantial Cuts or changes to anything that's going to especially affect the students right any programs or things like that might be very shortsighted um for something that is um basically you know who knows maybe a one-time thing maybe not but if we if we get into this one year and we make some big you know Cuts so we can accommodate this onetime thing then suddenly next year we're find ourselves in a situation where we're like gosh I had I wish we hadn't cut that program that was a really it was a great program it's unfortunate we cut it now we have to start building again so I think we need to as we approach this budget I think we need to really have an eye on the long uh

136the long game and make sure that um we just take that into consideration as we as we move forward there we go Phil I hope I I hope I did your your comment Justice you know you're bringing up a good point Sharon that I would like to um to expand on you know and and especially that is true about class size and I would encourage you to look at the teaming model document of the middle school because you know if you make a decision to well let's reduce the suction or do this and that or why aren't we doing that it dismantles an entire um teaming model that you know you have to look carefully at over the years over the 10 years and what that teaming model provides um what is the consequence of

137that and I think that's an important um thing to consider so I guess if I could extrapolate that that discussion over to a document that you guys provided I know David will be joining us shortly I don't want to get too into the weeds in in it um the documents on the you know on the H as well as the whis projections so I'm just curious as we try to sort of balance here you know fiscal Prudence of course the enrollment Trends and what's going on and of course also minimizing disruption um you know amongst the staff what exactly happens I I'll I'll Point let me see um okay so for example in grade one if you pull that up you'll see that there are eight sections this year the proposal here is six sections

138um this coming year that you that that you guys have all put into the budget and then of course because the enrollment moves around a bit and and just forgetting about the accuracy of the enrollment in the past but um it moves around a bit and then it goes from eight to six to then again eight what happens with those two with the teachers the Staffing of those two sections that for let's say that this one year um are no longer going going to be teaching you know grade one are they reallocated are they eliminate are those positions eliminated um just if you could describe sort of the disruption to um let's say those two those two staff for example um and then what that impact is if any to the budget meaning if we

139just take the two staff and we move them around and we're not getting rid of them for example then there's really no impact to the budget no savings there versus eliminating them and then having to hire two people let's say you know if if this is correct if the projections are correct the following year so so help me understand disruption impact Julie would you like to take this one please sure um so it's I I'll start by saying it can be complicated um the first thing is if a position is eliminated that position is eliminated um that that assignment is eliminated that doesn't necessarily mean that the person in that current assignment is the person who's leaving us there are um Provisions in the contract and related to teacher tenure that um uh guide our

140processes uh in terms of how that person might move um but essentially the answer to your question is if that assignment is eliminated there is a reduction in our staff it may not necessarily be that person it may be a person in a different uh role or similar role who is similarly certified but who might be a non-tenure teacher uh or something to that effect it it depends it really depends on the players involved it depends on the certifications that they hold and their qualifications their level of experience whether they're tenured or non-tenured and the provisions of our contract as well as teacher tenure law um so when you see reductions they are reductions in our overall Staffing but in terms of who they impact uh that that can be a complicated process to figure

141out okay so it may not be you know two of the teacher two teachers for example have two sections in grade one this year they may just be reallocated let's say temporarily replacing two other positions that are actually being eliminated and then those teachers potentially because of their experience and familiary with the with the curriculum and the program and the schools ET and the school Etc they may for example for the following year those two teachers may be coming back to then again teach you know grade one sections so again expanding from six to eight once again and then I guess on the back end then at that point you would consider let's say in the next budget whe whether or not we need to fill vacancies that they had assumed let's say um during

142this reallocated year for example is that is that the right way to think about that okay yes yes and in fact it can at times be um a little bit more complicated than that because there are times when we have staff members who are on leave who may be returning to us in a subsequent year so we um you know throughout the winter and spring we kind of keep all of those factors in mind and we think about in at least initially in this process um what are the impacts who might move where could they possibly move um does that create a scenario where there might be a shared Staffing situation between buildings there are a lot of things to consider um but yes I think your explanation is is uh spoton and I would

143assume that so so it doesn't am I am I right then to assume assume if I see a reduction here that there's a direct correlation to sort of a budgetary impact so again you may not be getting rid of those two but you are getting rid of two positions um again again it's not as easy as us saying okay let's take you know uh salaries and benefits for for two tenured Educators and we can take those out of the budget it may be um non-tenured uh full-time you know employees that are getting paid quite less so we would have to it's not it's not as easy as just saying okay we're taking out two salaries we know what they are and that's a direct um impact to the budget it it may be vastly different

144in terms of of its budgetary impact is that right correct okay anyone have any question other questions I I don't see David back yet David just sent me a text that he's gonna be back in in five minutes and I think he's tiptoeing Michael you were just tiptoeing around what David is gonna be bringing up so sure does anyone else have anything I would I I would also ask this so in the uh in the Sills document then just sort of on this topic of minimizing disruption understanding that look you know we're talking about tws and 0. ons but these are individuals who have full-time who you know let's say as of today have full-time jobs whose jobs may be upended and were reallocating and introducing disruption you know to their lives of course um

145and in addition to that there are considerations then about sort of retaining good or the best talent right uh you know in our district district and and and attracting that Talent as well um in the sales program I think it was mentioned in one of the in one of the documents one of the supplemental documents that you provided that we're reducing the 12 sales from a 1.0 to a08 which is effectively you know let's say a day a week um but when I look at the BD budgetary impact it looks like the budgetary impact is is not you know point two times you know 12 which is you know 2.4 you know a a cumulative 2.4 reduction um instead it looks like the budgetary impact in this chart is 1.1 so is the difference there

146are those people just getting again just for clarification purposes are those people just getting reallocated that 1.3 difference for example it there's no there's no savings there's no budgetary savings there the budgetary savings is only the 1.1 that other 1.3 is just getting reallocated to other um you know other functions other tasks you know within these within the within the district is that right Lisa do you want to start and no you you go ahead Tina okay sure so a couple things Michael um so while some of the positions currently are full-time that will be reduced to 08 so 1.0 to to one to 08 what the reason I provided the chart was because when we restructured and rethought about the framework we did look at the number of teachers that they support as well

147so you'll see that there are two positions that also increased we increase their role for the Cil right so the overall is the 1.1 um so yes uh basically uh as the frame re structuring explained um while their overall uh FTE is a 1.0 point8 of that is to support the curriculum and instruction leader job description for K5 point two of it is to support small group intervention and at the secondary level 02 of their FTE will be to teach classes um so therefore all secondary all secondary Cil positions will have at least one teaching section or teaching assignment um but at the K5 level as Julie kind of alluded to even before it it's not so easy um you can't just you can't flip-flop that so their allocation of the point two will be

148for intervention and small group instruction I hope that clarifies yeah no it does it it does I'm I'm I'm you know trying to understand sort of the the you know the tapestry of functions that you guys are trying to weave together here as you move around trying to save 0 2 and 0.1 and minimize the impact to the students especially you know as Sharon has has mentioned I've mentioned this too in the past look I would hate to make of course um a short-term decision that looks good let's say today that then sort of costs us more in money and disruption in time you know a year or two down the road um on the other hand right when I look through and Dave will be joining I guess in a minute or two when

149I look through I mean these projections have been coming in lower so I don't know and and I'm sure he'll he'll ask this question I don't want to sort of elaborate on it just yet but um you know when we look at the projections here and the open seats and the class sizes you know I I I do think um I do think it makes sense to take a look at whether or not we should be discounting um some of those numbers um in terms of what the projections look like because they have come in high at least from what I've seen over the last couple of years um discount those to bring them more in line with at least uh the difference between what's been projected and what the actuals are and then of

150course determining um what that looks like in terms of class sizes so um I'll I'll save I'll save that that fire for for David when he gets here but um um if I can add Michael you're making a good point if you look at um and that's specifically why if you look at our kindergartens we're requesting seven sections excuse me with a class size of 19 and then if you look at for first grade we're uh asking for six sections and it's already capped out at 20 we actually predict that we're not confident in that 135 number based on what happened with you know the the age change and everything else in kindergarten so why we're asking for seven and six for a total of 13 sections in that those two grade levels we anticipate

151that it will probably be six and seven if I'm explaining myself right so kind of try to factor that in every little bit um because we really don't want to start the year with 20 in first grade with no open spots but we feel comfortable going with the you know it was six of one half it does have another we had the 135 we said well we'll put it at seven for in kindergarten knowing that most likely it will be six in kindergarten and um seven in first grade and that's what we have to do Lisa sorry to interrupt David's I guess waiting to be admitted oh I don't know if someone can can do that um on it on it I have to step off for a minute I'm tell should we take a

152break maybe a five minute break you need a break before talking to me um I really yes it would be most appreciated why don't we try for a three minute break and knowing it'll probably be a five because I need to uh take care of thank you e e e e e e are we ready to continue can you hear me um yes I should mention that um oh Sharon is here Sharon is it are you taking control over this meeting now because Steve has a meeting with samester is that correct yep okay just wanted to clarify that all of this meeting just seems to roll on without really any direction right now if we're all back we have Chad or Chad I think are you back yet Peter Chad Phil Dan fer yep I

153am back this is Chad I'm just still on on audio only but yes I'm back all right perfect I think we're gonna cue you up now because I think that we you know Michael did such a great job of setting you up for your your questions so why don't we address what you wanted to talk about right to the point where Phil's like I need a break Phil knows me after three or four years sorry about that I appreciate the Break um yeah so I mean my my question I think I you know I I came in and I was able to hear I think Sharon Michael you both kind of queued up for the question I asked Lisa um at our last uh our initial meeting was what would the impact be the sections

154that we would run if we simply added one student to the guidelines for each grade section um and my interest would be up through 8th I think there might be a separate question about the high school in the future but really Elementary and Wiis is what we typically focus on CU I know the whole teaming model is the MD yeah that's that's a little bit ster but okay if D DeVito could kindly pull up the um the uh class siiz document for herba the option side now kind of um he actually helped me with it as well with some of this stuff um to because okay let's go with grade two okay Dan yeah hold on yeah I'm just pulling it up give me one moment the hbut one you said gos do hbut grade

155two okay okay so where it gets complicated and and some of the way we arrive at these decisions is you have we have to look at um as I said in the past open seats uh availability when students um move in and I didn't forget that you asked how many new students move in and we're still compiling that information if you will um we have it in rough data and we have to put it into a chart like uh to make sure that we have available spaces for our students um that that come in during the year to to have some wiggle room so if you look at it's the best way I think to explain this and and I appreciate Jan's help with this is to look at if you look at for example

156B the oh 26 um can you I'm sorry can you pull up the one that is in the that was posted because it has certain highlighted things on it not this document thank you this one thank you yeah yeah let me zoom in yeah again one second great to yeah perfect there you go so well I just great to I find it a little bit easier so if you look at 2520 six there's 158 students in grade two okay so we are recommending seven sections and then the class size and this is pretty it's it's a lot easier than for example the high school is 22.6 we know we can't have a point6 of a child in a class um which is uh so there's 30 uh 10 open seats so there's 10 open seats

157across those seven sections it could be you know um at least one per class right that would be seven extra kids and then another class uh and three other classes would have two open seats am I explaining myself with that information just to to make sure clear so if you say let's say you took that number and you said okay we want to Max it out to 24 or 25 so if you if you did that and you said all right we want to have um class size at 25 um 25 then you would need 6.32 sections which 6.32 you know you can't have a. 32 of a section so certain classes would be maxed out and certain wouldn't which can be problematic when you're looking when you're talking about higher numbers and Equity between

158the sections if you look to reduce one whole section let's say we said you know what we want the number to be at about 25 so we're going to make it because again you can't have like a three of a section we're going to reduce it to six sections then you have 26.3 students in a class which means that it will vary between 26 and 27 students at grade two that's that's how you have to look at what the impact is can you go to the bottom of this please to that other chart that you help me with thank you so if you look here and you say all right if we did option one we have 20 sections if we did option two we could have 17 if we did option three 14 and

159you have to look at again the Tipping Point of what do those sections look like and are some you know higher than others and and what do you do if you went to option two you could save uh three FTE or three teachers which would mean that we would um cap it at 17 where we would have to uh go back and look now go look at kindergarten you look at kindergarten and if you were looking only at kindergarten you went to option three you know no one is going to be happy with those options right you're not going to be happy with 23 to 27 kids in a Kindergarten class when it's the first year of school so maybe you don't do it in kindergarten um go to the next one please but maybe

160you say okay can we do it in grade one you know go from the 20 to the uh classes of like 23 24 again that's a board decision um the guidelines have been established a long time I guess you could save an extra one there go to the next one please and then if you look at this one um you know you're already looking at 23 between 23 and 25 students you'd have to get down to six sections and that's the class size I think that it's problematic the administrative team does especially in K12 where students are learning to be student and they're learning the um program to um and learning to read to do this can you go to the bottom please the last chart yeah but it does save option two does save

161uh three sections if you wanted to do in just two of the grades it would save two sections there would be a small Savings in the special areas such as art music but that that's really minuscule at that that age because of the way you know the way that the program is is implemented but that is the example at this grade level of what the options are and I I played them out totally and part of the reason I did this too was because um when we were thinking about the middle uh I'm sorry the herba and saying you know what do we need in hobot for the next 10 years go back to that chart please um how many classrooms physical classrooms do we need if we were using these enrollments you can see

162that over the next 10 years you would need anywhere from you know if you want with option three 14 to 19 classrooms or from you know 20 to 25 17 to 22 those are the physical classrooms that you would need in herbut to accommodate that space if you were looking at space Also space utilization um am I explaining myself would you like to look at the 35 because maybe that's more of an area that you could say well let's look at the impact in those grades because um it it might be interested to look look at that one can you pull that one up please and Lisa as you're pulling that up and and as as um David gets you know set to ask his his FLIR of questions here about this um no that's

163the the one question I have here is that we are presupposing here in this analysis we're assuming that the enrollment numbers that we are using are correct and I understand that these are the projections that they're giving us I'm wondering if we sensitize and and you know it shouldn't it shouldn't be too much trouble I don't want to I don't want to create a whole ton of work but I wonder if we sensitize this analysis um um for the fact that uh in the past the numbers have been higher projected than what they've actually come in at I'm wondering if we look back sort of you know measure or or get a sense for how higher how much higher they've been projected versus actual update these numbers here sort of sensitize these numbers here and

164then flow them through um the analysis to see what the impact you know what the classroom sizes look like there because I think again maybe they're right maybe they're not but the trend has been that at least since I've been here that the projections have come in higher and that the classroom sizes then of course um we're looking at data that's not that's not essentially you know all that accurate so I wonder if we do that um apply it to these projections and then take a look at what the impacts are if I may offer a suggestion compromise I I think that um we can certainly look at that there is in the budget book and I did this um I think last year and it it would be easy enough to do it with

165the low projections now remember Mr zuba does low medium and high so if we looked at the low projections and put it in the same formula we could get a sense because the other thing is is that we have to take into consideration that's kind of why I'd rather do it that way and we can get that done a lot quicker is it's not just the enrollment it's the Tipping Point in the section if you will because I remember I I analized this all last year like what's the difference between the low and the medium and where that difference may fall based on the data he gave us because in some situations the section number doesn't change with the low and in some it does so um are you okay Michael um we have those

166low charts and we can um relatively simply plug it into our spreadsheet and get the lows out so we can at least Begin by looking at it there to see where is that Tipping Point in these in these projections I would not really do the high because we've never gone to the high right frankly no no no I guess I guess the only and and I'm happy to do that again I don't want to create more work for you guys and if that's the easiest way and that's pretty accurate then great let's do it I would just stress that you just take a look at what the ACT what the projected versus actuals have been I know what you mean and if it if it actually if the lows sort of you know project that

167Trend more accurately great let's do it but I do want to make sure it's it's somewhat in the realm of of accuracy there so yes so so this is what we'll do we have the information of the the projected and then the actual and we can go back let's say I don't know um five years to look at that if that's helpful and then we can as well so we'll have a chart with that so you can see what the what the difference is if you will from the um medium projections and then the actual and then we will go back and refit you know we have these charts in Excel we'll go back and we'll do the low projections with the class siiz options that we have here um for you guys is that

168okay yeah that's great thank thanks I appreciate it okay um let's look at grade three just why not um because it's a little bit different you know it's um now the children are reading to learn so again you have here if you if you're okay with the 22.8 and only seven optional seats you could go down to the five sections and it would get it up to about 27 uh point4 but some will be at 26 obviously some will be at 28 if you reduce the section because again sometimes it's not just if you shave off a kid it's it's shaving off the kid but looking at the overall total and seeing how it applies to the section formula if you will so if you go to the end you know we did this for

169third and fourth and fifth again we had the different options and what was interesting was it was the same result as it at hobot you know if you go to option two you're saving three sections if you go to option four your saving uh six sections um within uh the range that we that we have so I think that that's interesting and and it'll be interesting when we put in the low options to see where to see where we fall would you like us to look at the middle school well just real quick and um Michael is a very good um uh I've trained him well because he asked my question exactly so but I I think ultimately Michael really did ask the question that I would love to see which is rather than using

170the projections which I think is what Michael's saying rather than using the projections let's compare the LA I was going to ask for the last three years the projection we use which I think is always medium with the actual and then we would have a chart or we would then know how many students are actually sitting in these seats because I totally three so and so years later I understand the thing that you always say to us which I agree with which you haven't said yet which is we don't want to hire a teacher in August um oh God yes that's the worst right sorry right right um so anyway so I think Michael really did sort of ask the the only question I had for the uh Hess and whis and just to make

171sure we put kind of put a pin in it I think what we're both asking for uh but we did not collude ahead of this call is can you just show us what proje that we used medium for the past three years who how many students actually showed up and therefore for the past three years in each grade section how many students did we actually have in chairs in each section yeah I'm thinking okay I I'm understanding what you're saying so the number of sections yeah how right how many students right how many students actually sat in seats based on who actually showed up in September because then we also can compare the the accuracy of you of continuing to use medium and then the risk of going with low right because we know the

172risk is it's a twofold risk if we go with low the risk is we hire a teacher in August because now the classes are too big um and the the risk of going with medium is that are we overstaffed that that's yeah David do you want us to focus on K5 we did a separate kind of analysis for the middle school because it's a little bit more complicated yeah I think on the Middle School piece um I looked at the document I think it's the teaming model which I still three plus years don't entirely understand so uh on the teaming model honestly we have to defer at this point in my opinion to the administration's expertise you know there's some things that I think we are just not going to understand or maybe I won't

173understand and if if the academic impact especially to our I think our middle school kids the ones that you know like for those of us that have had middle schoolers uh it's awkward for them it's a major transition year years for them personally if the academic value of using the teaming model is know I'm saying like I'm not sure I'm articulating correctly but at some point we have to defer to your expertise on that it's a little bit it's harder to understand the Middle School sections and the teaming model than it is to say 25 kids in a second grade classroom versus 23 I think we can understand the impact of that okay so I guess on so my question on the teaming piece is would you just summarize based on the chart that you

174posted uh on the website for everyone to see there there doesn't appear to be any we I think I saw the word destroy uh in your document that if we make a change we d destroy something and that's a pretty strong word so is there are making changes in the Middle School uh really that impossible that dire I mean to me in the middle school it's it's a lot more about the students being their age and their transition than it is about M yeah yeah and I appreciate your willingness to kind of defer to us um uh Dan why don't you pull up the teaming document on middle school and I'll take you through it Dan and I worked um on it just kind of give you a little bit of a flavor um and

175for those of you that might not remember I was Middle School principal from 20 200 20067 and age my Glory Days um can you please pull that up Dan thank you and you know really living it let me tell you as a high school person I thought I got it and to your point David you had I had to live it so here is the overall thing and there's just a couple things I want to point out so clearly um the reason that we um go to the schedule please the first schedule keep going keep going it's a chart keep going keep going okay so thank you so clearly um if you um look at this this is the model that we currently have and the reason that we put it this way was were

176a couple of things to get at and I'll kind of uh review it with you this is a typical um academic teachers schedule right now in the Middle School basically we have uh eight sections per grade level right so it's um the four key academics and it's really important um that these are full-time people and that here's a typical social study schedule so what we're what we get out of that is they have their team meeting they have their parent conference time everyone is available to meet at those times so every other day they um have a team meeting they could have a parent conference time they could have their hands up meeting where they go over with the counselor um every student they literally go through every student on the team they also have

177on the opposite day they have curricular partner time that um is really important because it um ensures uh consistent um instruction and assessment so it's not like well gee and my you know eighth grade Sal studies are doing this and um you know and over here they're not doing that or whatever so these are really important collaborative times that are built in the schedule the other thing that was added um to enhance this model was the workshop model which is the students go through a workshop Block in every uh of the four subject areas over the four quarters and during that time they do um extensions of the curriculum special projects that they um have worked on that teachers have developed that is also a time a little bit towards the end of the period

178where they can get extra help from the overall um different four core academic areas which is huge because um otherwise you know these kids leave after school they're going to all their different activities and there's there's literally no time so it was it was all brought in and this is kind of the explanation go to the next one please if you say all right we want to um eliminate a section we want to go to seven sections what you are effectively doing with the way the schedule works is you are also eliminating the workshop um um and so if you look at it here you have they have the team meeting and parent conference time they have the curricular partner time on those on those two days uh where they uh do those courses but

179the thing is is if you went to seven okay this is one grade level go to the next please there will be a team that because it's seven there will be a split grade level team we use to have that structure and what that means is your child could be on a team that all the teachers teach seventh grade or you could be on a your child could be on a team where the teachers teach uh two seventh grade and they teach three sixth grade now what's the adverse impact on that if you look at this schedule you'll see that the grade six social studies teacher cannot attend anything for seventh grade so the 50 students that he or she has in seventh grade he can't go to the hands up meeting he can't go

180to the parent conference meeting they have to you know turn in a written report they can't go to um any kind of a a team um a team meeting where uh they are uh working on interdisciplinary uh projects or um Team activities they just can't go because the way the schedule works and they lose that which is quite frankly a big loss to that seventh grade team or vice versa so when you reduce to the seven you have to remember that there would be a team A and A Team B and the other thing is is that the curricular partner time you would have no curricular partner time to work with your seventh grade social studies partner and where it gets really complicated is when it's math and we had it when it was math

181remember we have different levels in math and then you have someone like an eighth grade math teacher teaching seventh grade um algebra and eighth grade geometry and eth grade uh standard level math and and all of these curricular partner times you you just don't have it um so it it really complicates the schedule in addition um Dan do worked out as like you could also next slide please end up with some part-time People based on this and when you you know chop people up if you will and this part um frankly I I wish Jam were here to explain a little bit better but basically if you have a part time teacher that there could be a possibility of part-time teachers on these teams look at what happens then so if you have social studies

182in English and let's say they were part-time only in the morning and Math and Science and they were parttime in the afternoon a team that might have one or two part-time teachers would then have people that were not even available to meet with the team because of the way that the part-time Works whether it be a morning or an afternoon rotation which is different quite friendly than at the elementary schools part-time people are used differently it's not based this way so it really um you know Dan had written words like destroy and everything like that in the uh uh explanation because he got very um concerned as we all are on we're trying to make gains in uh this particular um age group it is so important in this particular age group where there are

183a lot of struggles and if you dismantle the team you're basically going back to some of us I know me I won't date myself but the others in the room to a junior high model which we had and that's why we moved to uh this model can you put up the um the enrollment page that I just asked you to post Mr DeVito and I sent out to the board they probably didn't get a chance to look at it I was fine-tuning it but we did the same thing thank you if you can blow it up please we did the same thing with um the project C for the Middle School to just show roughly the numbers like okay this is what would happen with the numbers if you and what would the savings be

184and everything else and um you know if you went to seven sections if you went to six sections I also linked the um the teaming model document at the top of this and it's posted on the website go to the last page please the last chart thank you so here again it talks about savings but especially here and I so appreciate what you said David this really destroys sixth and seventh and eighth grade and what we are trying to accomplish in those grade levels can it be done sure we can go back to that model but it's like a junior high model and it really negates the overall uh vision and Mission and what this um what this school district is known for that level of personalization it will just be it'll be gone um

185it it just will be can kids get educated I know there are people that say well yeah sure they can they can but um it's not as our vision says we want to be the standard uh exemplary and this by no means is the standard of what we would consider exemp re education for this age group thank you for uh showing that Lisa is there a um enrollment level in which is it it it I might oversimplifying it but in order to to keep the teaming model um you have to I not sure this right wording but you kind of have you have to pair you have to it's it's yes an even number of right okay is there an enrollment number that you guys are watching that uh we would fall to potentially where

186you would have to where you could make changes yes I'm sorry Jim repost it so sorry there was another thing on that page I I need to point to yes David we are looking at it because the other challenge here is thank you Dan there was another chart I think it's before this one no it's down below it's down below eth grade it's not a chart it's my notes so here I did a summary analysis of these charts for option one based on the eight sections so this is where it gets tricky if you look at overall enrollments and you say Okay I want to look at the overall impact across the three grade levels and which at what time is there really kind of a lower enrollment in a section so for example in

18725 26 we know that seventh grade you might say my gosh there's only 18 kids in the class yeah that is pretty low and in eth grade there's only 19 but it goes to Sharon's point of do you dismantle an entire team for what that that's the concern here you look at 0607 so I have there's 1 2 3 4 five six 7even there's seven of the 10 years over the next 10 years where there are sections particularly actually in this upcoming year where the sections are low you know you're looking at at about 1819 and you could say well is that where we have to look at adjusting something with the team um it's very tricky at this point here I don't think it's dropped low enough to make that kind of a change

188I think it would have to go a little bit lower because when you have one team that is um let's say five classes and another team that involves two different grade levels uh uh to when a teacher schedule involves two different grade levels let's say it was between seventh and eth it really adversely compromises the overall experience of the of the students so you would have to and I'm kind of trying to make my thinking transparent I feel like I'm in a elementary math class you would have to look where the enrollments would kind of be able to be split between the two teams to ensure the equity and access that's given in a balanced approach to be able to do that and if you did that let's say the enrollments were higher there they

189not but this is a hypothetical you may consider removing workshop with which um is a possibility you know when the enrollments were higher we didn't have it but it it levels out and balances out I don't know am I explaining myself I think I think there's two things uh it's similar to um K through five it I think it would be helpful to know what actual was versus projection for the past three years so how many kids actually were sitting in these seats okay and then similarly um model out let let's say I'm not the teaming model really does the end of the day it I struggle with it and that's why you get to a point where you just have to defer to The Experts uh which is the group I'm looking at right

190now um if you were to cut out an even number or whatever that term would be so that you don't destroy the scheduling piece but ultimately winds up with more kids sitting in a classroom what what would that look like so Tina kind of nodded her head that maybe she gets what I'm saying but can you model out something where if you did cut out a straight line or two or is it four we already have a small number of teachers in those teams right so you have two on one team two on another so the only option that you're asking is to Red remove a team in order to maintain the partnership that Lisa is trying to like paint the picture around that schedule so that means you'd have to take all of the

191students so let's say you have 17 here and 17 in this class and 17 in this class right that's how many let's say let's do 20 40 kids right you'd have to take all 40 of these kids then and move them into this team and we would be well above guidelines based on the contract if we had three teams right um Team A Team B and team C you could get rid of Team C probably and the impact on that class number would be less but Weston is Weston's already very slim when it comes to the number of teachers supporting these teams so in order for you to break up that we don't have the flexibility to take a team away right at this point because the only option is to basically reduce it by

192a whole team in order to maintain that structure and that would be two teachers to support and and it it would take a it I'm not a I can't I'm not you know I don't predict the numbers but I'm tell it's it will probably never happen yeah no I otherwise you dismantle that whole model is what we're trying to say and then you wouldn't have that teaming model anymore right and that's the heart of my question if we don't want to destroy the teaming model correct but we did want to redu okay so as you said the right terminology would be we would have to produce a team we only run uh three teams right now right or is it two it's two okay right okay so that's where you cannot right if we right

193if we had more teams the net effect of removing a team you've got more places to put these kids right and what Lisa was talking about if you're gonna remove a team even with the smaller ones then that means you'd have to have a teachers that that teach across grade levels teaching seven and eight and then you wouldn't have a pure teaming model where you only teach one grade level and then it's going to impact the schedule that way as well right now actually that was gonna be my other question too and I go back to my days being in middle school I remember our science teacher Mr Gold brener uh he did teach we we were a seventh and eighth grade school we didn't have six in there um but has have we looked

194at all at uh the teachers are certified right a science teacher is certified to teach uh six seven eight right in the Middle grades yes yeah yeah when you get to the second yes when you get secondary level they they well their content specific like biology certified chemistry certified as well but at the middle school they can teach um they're yeah David I would venture to say based upon your age and mine uh it probably was not a middle school model it was probably a junior high school model yeah we also have bunson burners that actually burned with gas and the place didn't burn down and our buses went in reverse and we could could use real sauce to cut wood so it was definitely I roam the world with Dinosaurs like you yeah so

195and that was before they got a little wiser and they were like kids are falling through the cracks what can we do let's create teams so that's why the Middle School concept is in place right and again you know the nice thing about my struggle understanding it three years on the board of ed it's probably something that the community struggles understanding the concept of teams as well and really the end of the day the value and value has a cost and so you've kind of you you've essentially answered my question which is there isn't there isn't there's no prudent way to look at the teaming model and look at utilization without as Dan do I think wrote in that document destroying what it was in put in place to do um if I may um

196you know we talk about educational outcomes are are I would say um can be tied to educational outcomes because we are very concerned about the mouth scores at the middle school and during that time the teams were destroyed and you had that inequity in the team specifically math you had the you had an eighth grade math teacher teaching sixth grade math and he was never available to to do those those things that he needed to do so um that's kind of an important Point uh as well but we'll work to get to you uh some of the documents that we we'll create a document where you can see what was uh projected and what was actual as well as taking those lower projections and kind of feeding them in and I'll include the Middle School

197in that chart as well hopefully we'll be able to get to that to mid next week if that works if not sooner that sounds good um I'm gonna jump in here I'm GNA take a look at the time it's 11:54 so we have six minutes left in this meeting and I think rather than jumping into a new topic unless anybody's got some that's really pressing that they want to touch on um I do want to be respectful of everyone's time and the fact that um people have jobs and they need to make money and that we have um an Administration that needs to educate our children so if it's okay with you guys we I just take a look at the schedule we've got plenty of more we've got another budget Workshop um uh both

198uh for the board members only and we also have um a public meeting coming up as well so um I think if it's okay with everyone we can wrap up for today um and we have let's take a quick little um look at the uh schedule of what we have coming up here sorry um I think our next meeting I just had that up here sorry guys um here all right so today we have this budg uh so our next the the finance uh the Board of Education finance committee meeting is on Friday and then on uh the Boe monthly meeting is going to be be on Tuesday since we have a long weekend with um MLK weekend here so we're GNA see everybody on Tuesday aside from that our next U meeting on the

199budget specifically is on Thursday January 23rd and that is a zoom meeting um that is uh the public forum again and then we're going to follow that up uh the following Monday on the 27th for just the board um in the administration a another another meeting like today that's a 9 to one so pack of lunch any anyway um so if everyone is okay with us doing that um can I go ahead and have a motion to adjourn today's meeting so moved all right and uh can I have a second second great all in favor has her finger up yeah one last thing um again if you have any questions email them to us okay because it will be very challenging just hear about the next Thursday we have to have time to able to

200through them so um you know uh thank you appreciate great thank you everyone a lot some tough topics here so um administrative team we have another meeting after this so if you could kindly check your

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.