CorpusRecord 112362

Weston Board of Education Budget Meeting Public Comment 1-15-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WPS Meetings
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,365 words · about 25 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001third I believe the next one is on Zoom 7 o'clock same time tomorrow we have the board Workshop where we where we will continue um discussing the budget I'd like to um share a comment if those um of you haven't heard from my dear colleague uh Mr felc Cross who always reminds us about this budget that what is it you say pH we're in a marathon it's not a Sprint and what that means is is that um it is continually a work in progress especially in the next couple of weeks as we try to refine things and uh get some additional information that we have been waiting for um particularly on health insurance which is a huge driver huge driver of this this year's budget um and we're waiting for that information you know unfortunately

002sometimes we are tied to a a time frame a calendar that doesn't always get us the information in the within the same uh timeliness so um that being said I know tomorrow we have the uh the workshop and also at our Board of Ed meeting next Tuesday uh there's a budget update on that uh agenda and we are hopeful that um we might have some uh more definitive information about how to uh perhaps mitigate this um health insurance that is significant ly uh driving the um budget increase so with that I'll turn it over to um to you Mr aiz and and members of the board and um I know that um it's nice to see the the public here um and we can uh certainly listen to their feedback great so before we take

003public comment um uh we read a uh a statement uh before uh before every public comment uh part of our meetings the board welcomes the opportunity hear from members of the public about matters concerning Weston Public Schools public comment is an important chance for the board to receive input and feedback from our school Community we listen attentively to all comments shared while we value and pay play pay close attention to public comment it is our practice not to respond substantively or sometimes not at all during public comment there are several reasons for this first engaging in a discussion on non-agenda items could violate the board obligations to comply with the Freedom of Information Act second the board or the administration may not be prepared to discuss certain matters raised in the first instance by a

004public comment third the board develops its meeting agenda carefully to ensure that the board addresses matters that are pressing or relevant at the time of the meeting we encourage members of the public with specific questions concerns or complaints about our schools to reach out directly to superintendent barberio you may also email the board at our email address Board of Education West westonps.org um an additional details and public comment at board meetings can be found on our uh Board of Education website with that um I'd like to welcome anyone from the public who would like to make comments to the uh to the board on on the proposed uh budget for fiscal year 2526 kindly state your name and your street address and you'll have five minutes to speak thank you yeah cool my name is

005Alex Staley I live at in on Lord's Highway um since it's since you guys probably won't engage I guess one question because I haven't had time to listen to All of the meetings is on the health insurance point which obviously is the largest component of the budget increase is there a particular historical meeting you guys discussed that at length that I could just go back and listen to exactly the issue as opposed to trying to find it myself I don't I don't know if you guys know off top of your head like if there's a particular meeting that would be most useful to listen to on that point Phil probably microphone I think we discussed that um at the last finance and and operations meeting so November December so one of those me I don't

006remember which one exactly okay um that's the subcommittee correct subcommittee correct subcommittee the other thing that might give you some background information Alex is if you go on the website under HR and you look at the contracts um you will see uh the negotiated contracts um and we are up for beginning negotiation we're entering our last year of the contra cont so that can give you kind of the background of um what are these policies what they look like what is the uh the board's responsibility and the employees responsibility to kind of give you the background yep okay um one comment I wouldn't make that or question along the same lines and maybe it's similar spot to look is on the pension contributions I guess so the numbers don't really make sense to me in

007the sense that like salaries go up very little but then the pension cont contributions as a whole go up 20% I'm not sure if that's a you know Union like that's just like a administrative thing that just is changing or if that's just like I don't fully understand that mathematically but like so the pension cost in the budget that's are State that's a state driven um percentage increase so we are at currently at 17 I believe 17.26% increase for the employee portion of it so that's really what's driving it so if you look year of a year it's pretty much within line based on what the incre As a matter if I'm not mistaken I think it's going down this year because last year we had a higher percentage percentage rate and I think we're

008lower this year slightly higher this year but it's a number determined by the state yes it's not determined by us yeah and whose pension is it can you paint a little bit of a picture here for those that might be listening thinking they're not clear so in terms of the increase so these are for our for all groups other than teachers and administrators got it okay cuz I just when I look at the numbers pend if you're what you're saying is true that the the percentage contribution went down from last year the budget shows a 125% increase versus last year but salaries was flat so that doesn't necessarily drive but I may also be missing something cuz I'm coming in kind of late here that's just one comment um another one a more of a

009comment is on the capital budget so two things from my perspective it's a little bit misleading to say the capital budget's a million dollars when there's like seven items that are TBD um the other thing is I do think and it dovetails into the overall budgeting process I think it's imprudent to really think about a capital budget this year without the context of the overall long-term planning that I know the board of Finance is doing um because there some of the items that are listed even TBD are substantial items and may or may not change depending on that long-term plan financially what's needed for the schools if you pursue a new school if you change what school you renovate Etc so it would be imprudent to just set a capital budget just to set a

010capital budget knowing that there is a substantial amount of work being done on a long-term plan I just more of a comment that like I I would hope this would be the case but all of that is being tied in together when setting the capital budget not only for the school but for everything um that that's all I have I may have questions as I go through it I I presume I just would send them to leis to superintendent if you would and then she'll um answer them and post them on the uh on the board of education website okay under the budget thank I can make a comment about the capital budget might might as well take advantage of this opportunity yes you're exactly right because I I even said it I said you

011know we're saying it's a million dollars but we have all of these tbds and I think that's the and and um this is this often happens this is when we can't get accurate pricing I think that that's why there's a long time you know the capital budget is separate from ours to figure out um how we flesh that out and there are things like there's a whole bunch of tbds in the area of um retrofitting things like that with the um Energy Efficiency things at the high school things at um uh North house that um at H but that uh I would say that there are things that have to be looked at sort of regardless of what happens with the overall plan maybe in 10 years because if we're talking about for example you

012know uh HVAC or things like that what can we do and we always do look at it through that lens because there are some unanswered questions but um about clearly about what's going to happen to the campus the district ydep replacement is a TBD we've been waiting for that number that is a big number but I want to point out that that districtwide PA replacement um is probably one of the most important tbds on there because it also relates to Safety and Security when you have a PA system in a building um let's just use this as an example I see Mr um and people not can't hear it throughout the building or the quality isn't good that that's a a big concern for us and we've been waiting to get accurate pricing now we

013get that pricing of course when we say districtwide there are schools are three schools that need it to be addressed we may have to make a choice of which school needs it the most quite frankly Mr dooke I don't know if you want to put a little color or any of the other principles that have p pa problems it might be uh worthwhile just I think you alluded to the the largest problem there are areas of the building where you don't hear the PA announcements um and I think that's I see Laura shaking her head for her but and Megan for the high school that's one of the big problems but Alex I want to just put timing in perspective because some of this Capital budgeting are for uh items that need to be addressed

014today if we were to and and I use the word if if we were to do something to this building um the earliest we would start anything is sometime in 2027 you have to submit your plans to the state by June we will not be prepared to do that by June 2025 so it would be June 2026 the state responds with what type of reimbursement they'll give you at the end of the calendar year so that would be the end of 2026 so the earliest you could even start any type of construction would be 2027 and you know construction would take I don't know conservatively two years could take longer so now you're talking you know 2029 so we're you know we're four years away that's not right we're two and a half to three

015years away from anything happening and that's if anything happens because there's another meeting going on :00 just talking about the board of finances having um and ultimately the decision to do anything is the Public's decision so we're we're away from this for a while understood thank you for I mean thank you for all the input on the budget I know it's a lot of work so I no thanks Al thanks for answering my question any other comments questions [Music] Lynn Kimberly 3 Broad Street I hadn't planned on coming here to speak but I sat on the board of ed for nine years I was on the board when we opened the new school and we've been doing studies since 2017 we need political fortitude to say hey maybe we really should go down to three

016schools I grew up here I survived going to school in three schools and maybe you may need to make some tough decisions and really think about that because I feel like I'm in a barber shop or a hair salon lather rinse repeat we're going to make the same mistake we made 20 years ago your enrollments are going down they're not going up and you as a group whether it's the Educators or the Board of Ed members and the Board of Ed members don't just represent people who have kids in the schools I think you're making a huge mistake going down this road and it isn't about taxes it's about affordability and what our houses will be worth again if we do this again and I get it I'm going to the next meeting because this

017is a really serious problem and you don't just represent people with kids in schools two-thirds of us don't have kids in the schools and I really see what I look at is that our outcomes are going down and if our outcomes are going down and we're not even spending money on maintenance my question is why aren't we digging in to figure out why and yes I'm a product of the schools I have two kids who graduated from school here who are very success successful as adults but I think we've lost sight of We Are not a town to build a building we're a town to educate the kids who are in these buildings and I work with kids outside the school environment who go to school in military schools which are the worst in the

018country I go work with kids who come from reservations worst schools in the country and inner city kids who they don't have the advantages we have here and they may have rain coming through the roofs I think we've lost sight of what we're supposed to to be doing which is educating the kids and the buildings we need to spend some money on it I get it but I think you need to dig deeper you spent all this money on consultants for year after year after year the last time a strategic survey was sent to this town was in 2017 and the town's people came back with their number one priority was affordability it had nothing to do with amenities buildings schools and when I was on the board of ed there was a group that

019came here that said don't build another building because you don't manage what you have and I think you need to go back to the drawing board and have a conversation I was highly disappointed to find out that six people voted for a four School structure crazy I think you need to go back and think about that decision very seriously and if you were worried about an atbm last year let me tell you from what I hear it's going to be even bigger and I think you need to look at your budget I think you need to think about what you're doing not just for today but for the future thanks L any any other comments from the public okay any yep please hi my name is Debbie low and I live at 18 Northfield Road

020um I just wanted to comment on this year's proposed budget uh first of all thank you for having this forum and thank you for all your hard work and I'm sure plenty of hours and hard decisions in putting it together um my questions and I don't have comments so much as questions uh the insurance um to me it seems not just high but extraordinary and kind of um I don't want to say unheard of but close um so I'm kind of wondering about the reasons behind it um I realize that it's a work in progress that you will get more information as time progresses but what do you see the trend being and um Thinking Beyond this year um you know I'm not sure I'm what the history of insurance increases have been is this

021a oneoff is this an anomaly is this a trend is this going to continue um I just hate to see such a spike and then their first response is well if we make Cuts they're going to have to be in programs there has to be hopefully a better way of thinking about and managing Insurance um to either mitigate against the spikes do a better job of predicting them change carriers um and I know there's no magic bullet when it comes to insurance I know that it's difficult and expensive but if this becomes a new normal then it's quite um quite worrisome so I don't know if you can talk about it more tonight but I'm just interested in how much you have dug into the reasons behind the spike and what the future forecast entail

022I'll let you comment on the reasons for the increase but um I think it's fair to say insurance medical insurance increases are not uh solely the issue of Western Connecticut it's it's a national issue um it's not something that we're the only ones that are engaged we we do uh we do go out and get competitive bids for uh insurance carriers I think the last time we did it there were two years ago two years ago but I think there were three it's not like it's not like 10 people are going to do it there were effectively three carriers and the state mhm uh and there was a period I don't know pH five six years ago we were when we were in the state plan and then the state plan uh premiums increased dramatically

023so we went out uh for a bid um and there were three carriers at bid um and we chose the one that was most attractive um because at the time there was concerns over the viability of the state plan it's also part of every negotiation with the unions about how much they're go how much each individual is going to assume of the premiums so it's not it's a puzzle with a lot of different pieces it's not you know it's not like buying car insurance it's a it's a it's a much more complex also just so you so you know other districts are experiencing the districts that stayed with the state plan are also experiencing a tremendous increase in their uh in their cost this year as well you'll see that from other dur a schools

024that stayed in the uh in the state premium in the state plan yeah and um I appreciate all of that um and I'm familiar with some of the school budget increases and and working with insurance it just seems that 20% is extraordinary um and I am not sure um I I would like to see sort of comparison to what other districts perhaps are going through 20% seems out of the even high range um and I am again I I think I'm more worried uh for the town and um and the affordability issue in the future where is this trend going is this the tip of the iceberg is this a once you know once in a hundred years kind of increase um so I just look forward to hearing sort of more indepth uh information

025or um questions about the about the issue and I and I and I get that it's expensive and I get that people are going the comparisons for you and you know for our durate sure um school so we you know so you have a point of reference right and and also Trends you know are we just progressing slowly up it's just like we're steady and then poof and then it'll go back down um just want to know how volatile it is so thank you just real quick it it is volatile I mean insurance is really driven by claims whether you are a self-insured plan or you have a fully funded plan everything is going to be driven by claims two years ago coming out of Co um we had claims experiences that were relatively low

026um since over the past two years let's say within the next 18 months or so the trend has been significantly higher for the past 18 months our claims experience has been approximately pretty much 35% more 1.35% more so what for every dollar that we pay in our current providers paying 35% more on in terms from a cost perspective so we're using that and we're saying if we're currently at 35% claim to experience what can we relatively anticipate that we will see in terms of a increase for this year so we had some we had some conversations with um for 26 we had conversations with brown and brown and they're saying hey you can look somewhere based on where we are currently to be in the range of 25 to 30% right so for right now

027that's where we are if you look at where we are in comparison to the state partnership plan the state partnership plan is slightly better but not significantly better for the state partnership plan their initial estimate is that there will be increase in by approximately for Fairfield County between 9 to 11% so anywh you take it where everyone in in the state partnership plan will be seing an increase of 10 to 10 to 12% so our we at the top there's abs and flows with with with claims experience and you can and you can't plan what the health of anyone will be as you know health is is unpredictable you may be healthy today and tomorrow you're not so for right now where we are in the past 18 months is that we have had people

028who have been sick and the claims have just been higher okay thank you and I understand the reasons for not being on the state plan so thank you Phil can you explain who Brown and Brown is please for the listening and BR our health insurance our consultant and these are Consultants that also provide information when we go into negotiations which we'll be doing uh next year well you will be doing um next school year hi good evening my name is Carrie quey we have three children in the district um we mooved back here in 2021 and I just want to thank each and every one of you um for your time and your talent and for really prioritizing and investing in our schools in in our Educators it truly truly is a driver for our

029community and um it really does make a difference in people wanting to move here so thank you welcome other [Music] comments hello my name is Hillary mandal I live at three hedge R common and I have a question question with the capital budget um forecasted for the schools the school buildings um is there a possibility that that would impact the town's credit rating no could you tell me why well the town is a AAA credit rating your credit rating is based on your ability to tax right but isn't it also somewhat dependent on the debt level um no actually it's not so um your your credit rating is is basically the ability uh of the town to tax so um you know most of the most of the towns in Fairfield County are AAA rated

030towns now I understand we're AAA rated I would just hate to see our credit rating be reduced because then our costs will go up even more um if you go to the next meeting uh that is a uh you know that is a topic that I know the board of Finance is concerned about okay thank you [Music] welcome anyone else any questions or comments from the board I have a quick question I think it would be helpful if the health insurance is a Big Driver if we can just talk briefly about the obligation do we have the to just change health insurance providers like we can car insurance when it expires in the middle of a Union contract I don't know the answer to that um there's always language within all contract that gives the

031board the right to do certain things um within the current contract there it the right exists for the board to change providers or administrators um the caveat is that there technically needs to be approval by the unions um there's no language in the current contract that allows for a reopener so to speak um the reopener that was in the current contract was specific to the exit from the state partnership plan in short we have the right to change providers but we have to ensure that this that the that it's equal um so I think we're we're doing that and and just so that everyone is aware um BR and brown has issued an RFP um to for price comparison so we're waiting on that as as well so that's why I think when when we

032think about whatever it is that we're doing we're really at the start of our process we may not necessarily know what the true increase will be um come the 28th and we may not know really until maybe mid February into Mark into to identify what that percentage will be so it's not as if we can tell you that we can use a placeholder because our previous plan was a state partnership plan and we can use that the state partnership plan based in where we are right now is about 27% or so higher than where we are right now that's one of the reasons why we left so there is no situation that I'm seeing today that will result in anything in any significant reduction to the premiums for 26 we're looking into it but from

033everything that I'm seeing and what I'm hearing I can't neily say that we will see that and as Sharon pointed out across Fairfield County and across the state a lot of districts are really struggling with the cost of health insurance some districts experienced that last year for West then we were fortunate enough that we had a two-year contract that we had a second-year rate lock of 99.99% this is the final year of that contract and we may have to go out but again I I I cannot sit here today and say hey we're going to do an RFB and we're going to see significant um significant savings any provider that comes in they're going to look at our historical claims experience and unfortunately for us we're at the very top of those claims for right

034now okay so the summary pretty much is we could get a new uh quote but the coverage cannot change through the uh the uh Union agreement we have and chances are if there's only three vendors pricing is going to be relatively similar so there's we're still going to go through the exercise but you can't bank so to speak on expecting a significantly lower premium that would be correct as of today if you need um some more specifics on the language I just pulled it up on the teachers contract it's on page 12 where it's specifically addresses reserving the right to change insurance carriers and it explains that but hey we continue to be hopeful we will work through this we will work through this we know that we have to um get the budget down

035I I correct we will work through it but I do not want to se unrealistic expectations yeah I meant work through the whole process not not not just insurance it's okay that good yeah thank you yeah anything else from the public from the board I just have one followup so I think it was asked by um by the last by the last member of the public um so we have this big increase this year that it's going to be in in a Range that's going to be similar where we are I guess depending on whether we go to another carrier we look at the state plan it's all somewhat similar um going forward and and and I think I've asked this too but just for the benefit of of of everyone sitting here um what

036can you expect in the in the coming years so um we have this huge increase this year is there any reason to think that it settles back down next year or are we are we looking at another another double look I I I know you can't predict but are I'm I'm assuming just to set expectations here I'm assuming it's not going down to a 3% increase next year and it's going to be somewhere on the lines of high single low double digits is that is that reasonable as we think about how much of the budget the insurance is going to take up as we look at you you know just beyond uh 26 yeah it's it's it's it's difficult right so if you even think about the state partnership plan when we were on that

037plan so they would give us early indication about January February and that early indication has always been an extremely high number and the final number would not come out until March so it's really difficult to determine what that final number will be um what I can tell you is that if we make a change to the state part and go to the state partnership plan the state partnership plan if I'm not mistaken requires a three-year commitment y right if we leave before then there will be a penalty um in terms of what the state rates have been have not been following up we have been fortunate but state state rates have been technically going up over the past several years I I think when you just look Nationwide just the cost of of health insurance

038has just been sign have seen significant increases we're definitely not immune to that we can do we do the best that we can we do rfps just like what we did for for everything else and we hope again it's just unfortunate when we changed two years ago we were at a very let's call it the Sweet Spot our our claims were at a low level where we had competitive bids all the bids that we received were similar in pricing I think it was just the level of service that each provider offered that ultimately that we ultimately decided to go with our current provider so again it really is going to be claims driven um but I don't know but I think it's safe to I think it's safe to say that a dou digit increase

039over the next several years is not out of the question and am my last follow up to this is just yeah I mean I mean as you as you just think think through this um you know what I don't want to do obviously is switch upend the whole plan to save two or 3% let's say this year only for us to be you know 2 or 3% down or or the uh the increases to be even greater than they would have been in the subsequent years so I I don't know how you know if there's a way we can think that through as we evaluate the process but I I I just I I I don't want to be shortsighted in in in what we're doing here right I I I do like like to

040ask for time because time is really the only thing that will guarantee that this is not a rush decision and we do have time to negotiate if we ultimately decide to go with on a provider outside of the state that we have time to look at where we are and to negotiate I don't necessarily want to rush so again it's Samaritan right I the way I look at this we do not have to have a final budget I would say until the end of February going into March when we have our conversations with with the board of Finance historically we've gone into we have waited until March because new we have received new information and we have made mitigate and adjustments to our budget sometime in March again I'm not saying I'm not and I'm

041not trying to not give an answer I'm just saying if we're trying to make a decision shortterm and longterm we need we need time and it's not something that we will have a definite answer um within the next two weeks but your first question is the right question you know so you know is should we be assuming that healthcare costs are going to be you know 20% 15 to 20% a year you know I think the Layman would say yeah you know it's going to be the increases and that's why the world does not like health insurance companies but you're also talking about this in isolation you know this also has you're also going to be talking about this with the Union contract that's coming up so it's a big part of the conversation so

042right it's it's we're talking about one aspect of it when I think there's others other aspects that have to be thought about thanks and anything else in the board or the public Lisa you want to say something I'd like to say um something in closing uh we work really hard to get um information out um we call it supplemental documents to support the budget and I want to thank uh Mrs saketa for getting everything posted thank you Grandma saketa um for posting everything if you go on the front of the web page there's an icon budget you click on it the budget's there but not only is the budget there but we've already begun to um we sent you guys the documents they're all there and there's a lot of information there um so I

043would encourage uh the public to look at it and look at it again next week because we just finished uh another document thank you um Mr DeVito and Dr hankle about uh technology analysis and all that we'll be putting that up um but there's a lot of information there to kind of help paint the picture of the budget so I would encourage you to uh to look at it and as is the meetings are recorded and they'll be up y if there's nothing else can I have a motion to adjourn come on dve second those in favor I thank you thanks everybody thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.