CorpusRecord 112363

Board of Education Special Meeting (Budget Workshop)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WPS Meetings
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,225 words · about 80 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Workshop meeting um the first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if we can all stand I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all Lisa back to you hello good morning everyone um happy Tuesday um so uh this is our uh first uh day of stuning hours kind of pouring through the budget I would ask um the board we we really wanted to begin with the schools we have all of the principles here if that's um uh acceptable um would you like to go school by school I'm I'm looking for a little bit of uh guidance here however you you'd like anybody want to jump in here does anyone want

002to offer up uh overall comments uh before we start the meeting of where they'd like to see it go uh in terms of First Impressions for what uh we heard last night um congratulations Chad your book is released today um I have a Kindle copy uh oh looking forward to reading it uh and and I will try not to say um uh during the course of uh during the course of uh today's today's meetings um what happens on Schoolboard meeting stays on Schoolboard meetings you're free to do anything you want Steve all all you unfortunately they're recorded Chad so uh you know you can't hide but congratulations well thank you thank you very much um there I just said um there you go uh so how would people like to proceed do people want to

003offer up comments would you like to just go through the agenda as Lisa uh had planned it kind of leave it kind of leave it open to everyone okay I think that we should do it school by school but um I have an overall question for Phil um because it's a 4.75 increase um and instead of me drilling down on the budget um what I saw was that most of the increase comes from um the uh income behind the the support for salaries SE 70% of the budget is a combination of salaries and insurance closer to 80 but that's not the question is that 4.75% increase um is coming from the increase in Insurance that's correct most of it the vast majority of it is coming from health insurance okay thank you anyone else I

004don't have school by school questions I have a like larger overall uh questions but it's it's more specific so if other folks have a systematic way they want to do this I'm I'm game to hear that we can you want to can I suggest something perhaps if we go through each board member just give us your overall questions that we might not answer because I'm taking notes and things like that because we we write responses and then maybe we go back school by school does that work because i' I'd very much like to know what question you know what you're thinking um that you need more information on I'll quickly jump in just say I'm GNA be a little bit quiet for a change just because I've been through this process so many times at

005this point and I feel like I kind of knowa like Sharon what the end looks like even though we haven't gotten there yet um I'll just simply say I I think it would be fair to say with 80% of the budget being contractual obligations there's no real meaningful place to do reductions unless we start reducing headcounts I'll leave it at that well that's very unlike you David to leave it at that but I appreciate not teasing and I agree that that um that does point in that direction I'd love to see a way that we can um that we can uh find a way to minimize its impact on the kids right um the I I think I want to drill a little bit deeper into the insurance portion of it because 4.75 is an

006exceptionally High increase uh in my opinion I think we pretty much have agreement on that and um especially in light of what we are looking at with facilities moving forward um and so I guess you know I I needed to drill I'm still drilling down into this um you know it's a couple hundred pages so um trying to get a better understanding I understand that you know with the contractual obligation towards salaries at a 2 and a half% increase that's not 4.75 so I would love to get more color on that Phil from you about um why the insurance cost went up so much as to drive the overall um increase to 4.75 and then of course I have other detailed questions too but I I think if I ask them now it'll be like

007basically it'll be a game of Buckshot so I think and some of them may get answered um throughout the throughout the meeting as well so but that's just my initial thought and um yeah I'll leave it there Le is it okay if I just give a quick response as it relates to health insurance yeah I think we we have been signaling now for the past couple of months that we have we we've seen High claims experience um our claims experience is significantly High I think we're we're Trend in um in excess of about between 25 and 35% of what our premiums have been so pretty much what that saying is that the insurance company is paying 35% more than what we're paying in for premium so at this at this onset We Believe based on

008my conversations with um our consultant bronan Brown that these costs will be passed on to us um and so we are conservatively conservatively um projecting that our increase will be in the range of 25% or so um and even if we should make a shift um I think when we made the ship back maybe two years ago we were at a good place right we were coming right out of Co we were seeing low claims experience and that was favorable to us and that pretty much allowed our premiums to be to be lower now what we're seeing is that coming out of the pandemic we have people going back to the doctors more and we do have some employees who have some significant health issues and that's some of the reasons why that's driving um

009the claims experience the current claims that we have if we compared to where we were which is which was with the state partnership plan it's not significant ly lower the state partnership at plan right now is is looking at about 16% more than where we are currently so again in terms of where we are in terms of drivers there's not a lot that we can do um again as as we always say samarathon right so it's early in the in the process um we do anticipate getting the initial um in increase from Brown and Brown I'm sorry from Signa sometime in January which will kind guide or a decision in terms of what the next steps are but this is just pretty much where we are at this present time Phil I I I think

010a lot of uh I think a lot of focus is going to be on this obviously you know looking back the numbers I mean this is triple any the maximum costs I've seen in any year in recent history um so there are two ways to do this right in terms of benefits um number one obviously we can try to mitigate the cost I don't know if there's if we go to another high deductible Health Plan carrier if if that mitigates it at all I assume that they probably be all in the same range unfortunately right um so I I I assume you're working with the consultant on that as well um I was going to bring up the state partnership plan as well um looks like you've looked into that you know the the only

011other the only other way to reduce that of course is to Tinker with the headcount um as it's been said before um I agree with Sharon that I want to minimize obviously the impact to the kids um and look into the performance of the school system so um I think that that requires further digging into I know you'll come back to us with with additional information there um my other my other big picture items look 4.75 is a lot as we've said um over 5% if you if you look at it versus you know the adjustments that we made with the pre purchasing um this past year of equipment as well as supplies and materials my other two big questions aside from drilling down to headcount and the benefits uh on the supplies and materials

012front that's a that's a awfully big number as well in terms of the increase I think that represents you know 14% of the of the increase on a year-over-year basis as well um now we use some of the Surplus from last year to go ahead and and and pay for some of those materials um there's still a $400,000 increase here so I guess I I guess my question for and maybe this is for you Tina you know later on um I assume this is Again part of changing the curriculum um we saw an increase like this a couple years ago um I don't know how sustainable this is to have $400,000 sort of increases in these materials every year so I guess I guess the question is with respect to the questions are with respect

013to the current sort of roll out of the changes to curricula are do we have a schedule by which is this sort of a one is this a onetime cost increase here like a bulk increase or do we anticipate that there's going to be a continued roll out and I saw some language in the board book about it but is there going to be a continued roll out where those costs are going to be elevated for the next couple of years and then my second question is how often do we anticipate and this is a harder question how often do we anticipate sort of or could we expect the refreshing of these material so like I said like two years ago last year the the year-over-year increase wasn't that much two years ago it was

014another $400,000 the years before that again it was it was a fraction of it so H how do we anticipate sort of those changes I know it has to do with curriculum and curriculum changes um but have you given any thought to sort of looking out over the let's say a fiveyear time Horizon for yourself I assume you can anticipate some changes that are coming down from the state and so potentially I don't know two years three years standards change that's that's starting to be spoken about that we can anticipate hey in year fiscal year 27 and year fiscal year 29 we should really be mindful that we could see another bump in those materials because it does seem to be a lot um lastly just on the equipment again you know every little bit

015counts here um again this is another increase which is which is pretty high um relative to Prior years Dan DeVito I saw in the back I had all these questions about you know useful life of the Chromebooks and how often we refresh and I saw your schedule in the back um so that was very helpful um is there any is there any way that we can think about and and I know you're being thoughtful about it but think about maybe staggering this a little bit differently in terms of the outlay of the tech costs um because again it seems to be that the benefits are hitting the supplies and materials are hitting the equipment's hitting and then of course there's the headcount situation which we have to dive into a little bit more um when

016I just look at this last comment and I'll shut up um but when I look at it I I do want to make sure I know you guys have been thoughtful in putting this together but I do want to make sure we're on a sustainable path here I mean at this point with this budget you're you're now over $330,000 cost per pupil and it it just feels like you know last year that was a seven and a half percent increase according to to my math this year it's another almost six and a half% increase you know how sustainable is that you know running five six s% um increases on a year year basis on a cost per pup so um my initial comments thanks I guess I'll piggy back as board member board member given

017Michael's comments but did am I jumping in prematurely did anybody want to say something regarding uh Michael's comments first oh go ahead we're we're take I'm taking notes on all of this and then we'll we'll how we answer and I'm already thinking on what documents might help us s okay all right uh so piggybacking then I guess what Michael was saying I I don't think what I'll talk about is the most crucial but I think it could be of the simplest given that there's so many other things that would be a lot harder decisions and I'm sure it won't surprise anyone which area that I'm skeptical about but uh going further than what Michael said I don't know why we would spend money on new Chromebooks and smartboards and I I used to be like

018a dog on a bone about this issue because of pedagogy which I think is only more true now but also as it relates to this budget it seems to me it's one of the few like board L needless expenses and in a budget that's 5% essentially 5% more expensive when enrollment is a tick lower I think we should be looking for everywhere we can I mean I'm the I'm the opposite of a a budget hawk in this in that I believe I believe in spending money for positive outcomes for our kids and I believe in building a state-of-the-art new middle school and when I look at the budget there's a lot of places we can't cut to your points about you know 80% of this is salary and insurance and I think we should compensate

019our teachers because I know how hard they work so to me that makes a tech decision one of the few easy places parents don't actually want more Tech and it's not just me that like is always bringing this subject up a whole bunch of fourth grade parents uh last year wrote us about the the teacher email wrote us and they wrote emails about complaining about the Chromebooks and also having to bring them home in the first place and I I don't see that most of the much of the way we use Tech to me still seems problematic Go Noodle brain breaks is a perfect example they're not actually breaks they're actually the opposite of brain breaks they're they're not good for our kids' brains so and I also don't think we have technology tools that

020are consistent in terms of the parameters from what I understand anyway like one of the most respected teachers at whis doesn't even use Tech and parents have been very responsive to that so the the simple blunt question I have from from all this and I'm sorry for giving the most massive Preamble in history but the simple question is show me the educational outcomes that Tech helps our kids learn better and then if we can't show that which I don't think we can why are we buying new laptops in a community when everybody has too many laptops in their houses practically and new TVs that we're not actually using in a way that is profoundly better for the pedagogy and if we're not even being systematic about how teachers are guided to use it it's expensive

021from what I can see parents don't want it and we can't map it to positive educational outcomes there's a lot of research that it's even inferior isn't this a very obvious and easy place to literally like read out a line on the budget and then I'm thinking if tech is kind of bloated in this way where are the other places we can look for the the easy cuts because the 80% is going to be the hard stuff so that's kind of the beginning and end of my thoughts on this I know that's probably not a dramatic surprise to many of you but um that's what I'd love to look more about and my suggestion is we just literally take a red pin on that and it's a nominal number I know it doesn't move the

022needle in a budget this big but it seems to be one of the easier decisions so anyone else um I'd like to um talk about um the curriculum instructional leaders I mean I really like the fact that um you're putting in model classrooms um I didn't see any um support for for teacher coverages for the teachers going into the model classrooms but I was also wondering what the con the curriculum instructional leaders do with a a point date um how many teachers they support and some data that shows the Improvement in instruction and um academical for the students Peter do you want to say anything before we go school by school using I like Peter your audio is breaking up pretty badly it any everyone else is that true for everyone else too can you

023hear me better now yeah try again I'll try again my forehead do the the um word I'm using is umbrella sorry Chad this is the umbrella view of this I really like it's a very I think that's at all right I think it's already said that's that's the deal you want kids that Peter I hate to break it to you're still breaking up a little bit can you like swallow the microphone or well I'll call in call in give me a second I'll call in yeah yeah yeah pardon me as Peter calls in um Lisa barbiera I I I had a question just um actually piggybacking off of Lisa left um just understanding this new model with sales right um that would be helpful I I also again to what Lisa had just uh mentioned

024I don't know what a 08 versus a 1.0 um s represents um so if you can help us with that as well just give give us a primer at some point um of the adjustments to the program and then sort of what do those cuts mean in actual practice as we think about you know their impact uh you know on the uh um in the schools so that that would be very helpful too looks like Peter's having some issues why don't Lisa why don't we jump into unless you have some initial comments to make why don't we no this is all very helpful and um but Steve do you have any questions you haven't thrown any out there I know you're leading the meeting but you any specific for you too no I'm listening to

025everyone else I just want everyone to understand that if we're going to start the only place to save any significant money is on personnel you can Tinker around the edges 6,000 here 10,000 there but at the end of the day it's personnel and we're trying to provide a well-rounded educational experience for our students uh for our children and if we're going to start talking about reducing the number of employees I think we have to look at it with a you know with with a blank piece of paper you know it's not only you know it students there are the educational side and there's the extracurricular side um and all of those should be on the table if we're going to start reducing uh the number of uh the number of people so I think we

026need to look at both the classroom and the extracurricular side um because uh it all kind of melds into the overall cost of running the the school system so it could be technology it could be particular classes it could be particular extracurricular activities um uh but then at the end of the day we have to make sure that we're delivering uh to the children a well-rounded educational experience so it's easy to say let's just reduce I've heard this conversation before well let's just reduce the budget by I'm making the number up a million dollars okay let's do that but it has to be a interactive conversation between the board members um and the administration on if we were to do that what would be the overall impact on the educational experience that our kids are

027going to have easy to say let's reduce much more difficult to determine where that is going to take place if it takes place Steve can I ask Phil just one really other follow question so I so I understand the benefits angle of this so This increase let's say of approximately 1.9 right um million in the in the benefit section um what does that look like Phil Phil are we expect bigger bumps and it may be too early to say but in your discussions are we expecting bigger bumps in future years as well so for example you know fiscal year 27 and 28 is this something that's going to be recurring or the year by-ear increases there going to going to moderate to what we've seen in the past I'm I'm just curious how persistent this

028is because as we think about just future budget as well I just want to be prepared for um how that may impact our decision making even this year nowood then that is actually a good question it's it's rather difficult to determine On Any Given year what the cost will be if you think when we went back when we went to siga um we had a low let's call it introductory rate and then we had a rate cap in year two of 99.999% um I think based on where everything is ultimately going to be driven by our claims experience right and every year it's it's it's going to be it's going to be different I think where we are you have that you have the ABS on the flow where we are right now in that

029overall so in any given fiveyear span you you will have a year or two where you have significant spikes I think where we are right now we are at the very peak of that so I think it may come down a little bit but It ultimately depends on when that happens when within the does do we start to see that the client in claims experience so it's hard to say but I I think it's if you think of the trajectory off the state insurance plan the initial the initial guidance that we're getting from the state is that we're looking at about if we should go back there of course everything has to be negotiated with the Union right it's it's going to be an 11% increase based on their base rate their base rate is

030higher than our base rate in terms of what what the the premiums are and so I think we're going to continue not just Weston but the state the country is G is going to continue to have high medical costs I think when when I look back even last year in some of our neighboring districts they had significant more significant increases as it relates to health insurance than we did um again you know we're we're we're we're looking at the numbers but I'm not going to tell you that we're going to see um any kind of reduction in premiums that's going to be less than 10% I think that that's extremely optimistic to assume that it will be less than 10% I think at the minimum we may if we get lucky we may have a

03110% increase it's just where we are in the cycle which is just rather unfortunate but I Phil I I I think we need to make sure everyone's aware that this is a big part of Union negotiations oh absolutely and those are coming up in June when's the next one Phil I think it's coming up soon it's going to be maybe early next year I think Julie this summer for the WTA we'll be in yeah so this in many ways this is the biggest part of the conversation um in in all the union negotiations correct and I think there's a clause within the contract Steve that if we have sign ific increases in our health insurance cost it could trigger a reopener so to speak but either way if we make decide to make a change

032we would need to bargain um with the unions and to figure out what the ultimate cost or what the cost year will be so there's still work so we have two P components of it we have the carrier component of it and then we have the bargaining component of it yeah if I can just quickly jump in one more thing just to Circle back to a Steve you said and what I opened with I agree with Steve 100% uh everything other than the contractual obligations and the the headcount I think is what Steve basically was alluding to which I was saying unless you're going to make changes there it's it's window dressing so we might save a little here and a little there so the only other question I would have for the the schools

033would be if there have been any models down or can there be models done that if we change the classroom guidelines just by one student uh if it uh project if we could project out if we were to just increase our guidelines by just one student in each section does that change the number of sections we would potentially be running in next fiscal year um I work on those charts I already almost have them ready I can get them for you yep let me jump in and give like a little counter opinion on this just that I recognize it's not much but look at tech for a second but even let's just look at like number of apps and things like that that you all categorized and listed which I really appreciated we also I

034guess could look a little bit at materials in terms of how effective the uh American reading company curriculum has been or is not Tech is I guess it's like I'm thinking I think it was like 300K or something like that that's essentially two salaries so I'm just thinking of the parents last spring who came and were so upset about the cut the uh people leaving from the music department I know that was not about salary Cuts I know that some left we replaced all those positions but I'm just imagining the parent voices who are like okay you bought 300K of new Chromebooks but now we don't have this music thing or we don't have this elective thing so I recognize that the the bulk of this budget is salary and insurance I get that but

035my point is we have to sharpen the red pain anywhere we can so that we can try to not do the worst parts of it which is just losing headcount losing uh losing resources for the kids so I guess I'm suggesting a both and approach and I think if we just look at that 80% number we're also failing to optimize all the other stuff so I think there are some minor cuts that could potentially save a headcount or two here or there yeah we are certainly very willing to sharpen our red pens and go through everything but I I want to make it very clear that there is a rich instructional program here and that that uh as far as the F and Performing Arts and all of those special subjects and everything um we

036are actually um improving it in this budget and again I I know and Dan you can Chim in a little bit on this one just so kind of focus a little bit on Tech so let's let's let's take a step back and and think about where we're coming from and again a lot of a lot of a lot of what we're doing right now really stems from the pandemic so when we during the pandemic we had a lot of outdated equipment right we have because we're we had a history of making reductions to the to technology because again it's it's a big number so a few years ago maybe three years ago we decided that we were going to invest in our technology and we we had a four-year plan where we invest in our

037technology to to replace and also to enter where we'll have at least pretty much in place right so currently we do release all of our equipment this should be year four for release because the goal is to establishing to have built in recurrent leases within our Contra within the budget so we're not having those huge whipsaw in terms of the cuts and not being able to afford afford the technology coming out of the pandemic it was a significant cost to pretty much change all of our equipment because we had not sim to our buildings we were not investing right because because we had budgetary constraints we're not invest in in our our technology and we decided the board decided that it was important to invest in our technology and this is what we have been

038doing for the past four years well but not all Tech is created equal and by that I mean I'm not talking about every single thing I recognize it as an example Tableau has been a big investment that you all have made to try to figure out how to represent data better seems to me like that's a pretty smart use of Technology dollars for the life of me I don't know why in this District we need to provide Chromebooks for all of our students I don't I don't see the benefit I don't see the educational outcomes we live in a district when everybody has laptops I know there's some challenges with that but the teacher that I'm referencing I won't call her out by name because I don't think it's important to do that but there's

039a teacher in fourth grade who doesn't use Tech and the parents are very very happy or sorry doesn't use Chromebook take-home assignments and people are like chomping the bit to get into her class so I think it's a blanket it's too too broad a blanket statement of saying we're investing in technology which Tech how are we using it is there better educational outcomes I think the smartboards are an even better example I don't I don't see the significant Improvement so if we're really talking about like cutting salaries cutting benefits the hard challenges that come with that the messaging we have to do to the parents about that like why are we buying a bunch of Chromebooks for students I'd like to um talk a little bit about that just so we can have some clarity

040and context onto the Chromebooks so the Chromebooks that we P that we are looking to purchase they're replacing Chromebooks that were purchased uh right when the pandemic started in the year 2000 in the summer of 20 000 and in the fall of 2000 these are Chromebooks that do go home with the students for some grades and they stay with some grades in the classroom these Chromebooks are at their end of life they actually as if you look at part of the six-year technology plan I had extended out the life of these Chromebooks by one full year because last year the focus had to be on replacing our aging infrastructure for security purposes so uh and Mike to your point to talk about like let's say can we do this as a multi-year process the the

041issue is we also have aging staff laptops so if you look at the six-year technology plan next year is to replace the staff laptops and both the staff laptops for I'm sorry for FY 27 so the staff laptops in two years from now and the Chromebooks for next year they've already been shifted by a full year to replace them so from a productivity standpoint they're falling apart and I have the the number of work orders that have happened beginning probably in the last eight months specifically with these Chromebooks have increased exponentially because the Chromebooks are breaking and we're we have to constantly purchase replacement parts and because the Chromebooks are older it is getting more and more difficult to find those replacement parts the crack screens the motherboards the keyboards so right now the Chromebooks

042are not in the best shape and I always use this analogy but we're we're kind of running out of bubble gum and duct tape to keep them together for being used so we want to be able to provide high quality Equipment for the students and right now this is really their last year of of proper use before we have to replace them I also want to remind everyone and kind of build on what Phil also said we are leasing these and when I mean lease it's a capital lease so lease to own so at the end of the lease they are ours we don't return them at the end of the lease so although the budgetary request is let's say $400,000 for this year that is not the actual budget impact because we are doing

043a four-year lease so rudimentary you want to break it down to let's say it's actually the actual impact of the budget is closer to a little bit over $100,000 it is not a $400,000 impact in terms of software a lot of the software we purchase is aligned with curriculum and instruction this is something we go over year over-ear myself and Tina all the curriculum instruction leaders and all the staff members every single year we look at our software for redundancy to determine is there anything that we can get rid of because we now have a product that's been expanded on that now does what we need it to do so we're always looking at it and it's so it's never just a snapshot we are constantly evolving and looking at it we've replaced products we've

044gotten rid of products but a lot of the new uh curriculum and instruction has a an online piece to it that is part of the entire process and I know Lisa I mean Tina I don't want to overp speak I'll let you talk a little bit about that in terms of the smart uh the smart displays we're looking to replace 10 on the Aging projectors the interactive projectors that we we have I also want to specify that um we're not just using them to show movies or to do breaks we are using them for interactive lessons and these are specific the interactive TVs are really going to be used for the high school right now hurlbut there is no new technology Hardware that we're purchasing for hurlbut this year so everything they have they currently

045have so the Chromebooks are going for whis and the middle school and the smart TVs are going for the high school so I just kind of wanted to clarify everything about that because there's a lot of questions with technology and just so we all are on the same page with that yes I believe next Thursday we're going to be going over specifically um technology and Facilities I I would respectfully suggest we move to the schools yeah I agree this you're right it's getting too detailed thank you for the we'll revisit it thanks um so um all the principles have been listening and I would ask them to start perhaps weaving in some of the the the comments and feedback that you shared in their responses sort of as a summary what you heard and then

046we can take um individual questions why don't we start with U Miss cadus who perhaps can give a flavor of um some of the supplies those kinds of different things that the issues were raised and um the instruction and uh technology Laura Thank you Lisa so in terms of um Staffing for H but we do have a a small increase in enrollment for students across the school but we are able to absorb that and not show an increase in in sections in K2 and that is because of the class size guidelines being larger in the second grade um we will be starting the year with projected uh enrollment numbers with 22 and 23 students in a class in second grade um in terms of supplies the bulk of our um incre our increase really is

047in the consumables it's the paper and pencil supplies for the students our reading program notebooks um the word study notebook books foundations notebooks that the students um handw write in and our math program uh consumables are um are an increase in our supply line um you know we do have a a copier um paper for The copier uh line um paper has increased over the years uh Phil and I have talked about that it's just an unfortunate you know rise in cost with inflation so that's really the bulk of the hurlbut budget um other than that we don't really have other increases it's just the the move from The District budget into the hurlbut budget for the new reading and math program when you look at consumables um you know when you look at like

048math consumables reading consumables if you can add a little bit more color to this Laura these are things like these math consumables that do occur every year correct yes yeah they anual they're consumable so the students write in the notebooks they use them they do the activities and then at the end of the year we need new ones for the next group of students um there is you know very small amounts nominal amounts of money for maybe uh you know the base 10 blocks maybe you know broke or didn't survive the year but those are very very small amounts really the the cost is for the consumable the paper and pencil activities that the students do just just a quick question Laura on that um changing all the curricula here I I I know that

049there's the annual increase um due to all these consumable materials and far be it from us to um deprive you guys of pencils and paper and copier I can't believe we're talking about that but I I get it um have the have the non-consumable textbooks and any materials associated with the curricula changes have those all flowed through um hurlbut at this point have those all been refreshed and so what we're talking about specifically here this year and going forward at least unless there are changes are we just strictly talk about the consumables or is there a need to continue to are we are we having to refresh um any materials that are non-consumables as a part of a roll out of the change in curricula at this point and a lot of those materials are

050the same you know the big cost really is the consumable the notebooks for the students the paper and pencil part okay the base 10 blocks you know the Spinners the dice for games the Shelf activities for kindergarten there are times we have to replace pieces of those but those aren't the big that's not a big expense and if I could add no once we have a set of base 10 blocks for a grade we use them every year over and over and over right but there's not a massive refresh of let's say just materials due to curricular changes at this point aside from consumables is that correct there's remember it's not just one curricula so when you talk about curricula it's in every content area across not just the core areas but also PE Health

051art music right so when we say the word curricula we have to remember that that's quite deep when you look at a K12 Continuum so for hbut specifically I think you're the large chunk of the funds that you're speaking to was in literacy that's reading specifically they are in their second year of implement a the cons the the bulk of the initial implementation was already offset at the district level um during last year's budget and some of that was offset with a grant that I wrote right it wasn't enough but it did help a little bit so the consumables that Laura is specifically talking about is really on journals those student journals that they use within the reading and the math ma program um math when I arrived here kindergarten math was already in its

052um second year of implementation with a new core resource um this school year we've adopted grade two to have a new updated curricular resource because in math we were we were very outdated almost 15 years with the first adoption of that resource that we haven't refreshed and realigned to standards we are scaffolding throughout the district her grade level um in various years to be mindful of that fiscal implementation that you know the state was maybe not mindful of with reading right um so the um at hurlbut grade grade one next year is in my budget at the district level because that will be a new uh implementation as I mentioned last night the first year of implementation comes out at the district level on under my um umbrella and then it gets moved to the

053school based levels when they're focusing on consumables so that initial implementation is always higher but then the second year is always second year and Beyond are always focused on consumables and um our cils help support um looking at inventory being very mindful if there's any additional resources beyond the first year of implementation that may help us with any cost savings so we don't duplicate manipulatives or additional uh supplies beyond that first year when it's not necessary that includes books authentic texts in the classroom for reading um in addition to any of those consumables that Laura is talking about so for hurlbut they are almost fully at the point where they're just looking at consumables and because they've been under a full refresh for literacy and math next year it will be grade one math will

054be the first year of implementation um I just want to remind everyone though as we talk about curriculum refresh we have not um refreshed social studies now that the new standards have been updated in 2024 this past summer we have a mandate with computer science K through 12 that every District in the state is required to have a clearly articulated computer science curriculum um K through 12 um and we also have new health and PE standards that are um recently being adopted this past summer as well the state is not mindful of a scaffolded implementation um it's our responsibility to to make those decisions um and decide the right grade level to begin implementing and um the the need to support our teachers with that implementation process as well and I think we do a

055pretty good job of being mindful of the mandates while still being mindful of the the intellectual load and the impact of the teachers when you're rolling out new curricula and the training that goes along with it any other questions for Laura comments concerns I actually have one question I think from my notes last night it has to do with math intervention reduction I saw that can you can you talk to that Laura why um why there's a reduction in the math intervention yeah so based on um the student needs that we're looking at and the success of our students we uh believe we are able to support the students with that minor reduction okay still beet the needs of the students I'm trying like I I actually in my homework last night didn't have the

056opportunity to compare and make sure that how our test scores are looking in math there we seem to be strong as far as your you know okay all right perfect yeah and if I could just add the multi-tiered system of support which is what I mentioned last night as well is grounded in general education students and the need for intervention in math and literacy and every year we every actually it's not every year it's every uh every time that we administer our benchmark assessments our NWA assessments we revisit the number of students that need support in both literacy and Mathematics and then when we come back to the budget request this is part of how we reallocate and determine based on scheduling based on group size based on need um how many interventionists we need

057to support math and literacy and um next year there is a slight reduction based on the number of students that we currently are uh servicing now and who we are anticipating for next year a slight reduction remember sometimes with intervention it is a little tricky um because it does require us to think strategically about group sizes um and the schedule throughout the day and how that imp because they can't miss core instruction they can't miss their math time they can't miss their math their literacy block so we have to think strategically about when to schedule groups Beyond those time frames and that also sometimes pigeonholes us with um the ability to reduce um uh schedules interventionist per se just a broad statement all right was it Tina re just really quickly a quick follow up

058to that what what is that or or Laura what does that mean in practice so I'm getting back to my question before um a point to you know reduction in the inter interventionist does that mean essentially I'm assuming that has that has a budgetary impact right um but what does that mean in terms of just availability of the interventionist does that mean that essentially you're lopping off one day a week um from the in terms of their availability I'm trying to just understand what what the impact there is to this to the to the student sort of support that's a good question so you know it really depends on the school and the level try to build that staff member schedule around the needs of the student so it may be that you know they're

059they're not working the last hour and a half of the day or you know it could be yes a point two would be you just Lop off a day um you know across the week a 1.0 is 02 every day but we want to have the Maximum Impact for students so we schedule those people based on student schedules student needs classroom schedules to get the um the time when we need them the most and it's that's true too if we're sharing somebody across schools you know principal to principal we work on where can we make the biggest impact on students based on the schedules of the individual schools does that help perfect thank you okay let's move on to the Intermediate School Patty if you'd like to First share um your thoughts based on the

060board's comments like some uh hello yep so uh very similar to Laura you know obviously the first thing as I mentioned last night that we look at is enrollment I mean our our numbers are we're at 23 students going into third grade next year um which is very close to the the end of that board of aded guidelines um and 22 for fourth and and fifth grade um so um I think our projections are good for next year um as far as supplies again our costs really are pretty much what uh Laura had shared it's consumables it's consumables for the reading program it's the our new math program um which is just fifth grade for next year um um it's the it's the workbooks we don't have a lot of replacements for um resources such

061as you know fraction circles and things like that but there's a little bit uh in there um but it's mostly um uh workbooks and consumable um notebooks and uh for for reading and for um for math as well as we are um augmenting our classroom libraries next year and making sure that um what we have really current text a diverse uh range of uh books in our classroom libraries as well as obviously students are multiple students are reading them so the books do get worn out um and we need to replace those as well I do want to U mention just a little bit about the technology you know we work really hard to make sure that we every every teacher uses technology in our school and we use it purposefully you know what are

062what's the most impactful use of Technology um and that's what um our teachers strive to use technology for that um we did have a big conversation this year as Chad mentioned about fourth grade and um that our most of our fourth grades are now are not bringing their computers home as much um that's mostly our fifth graders but they still are using them in the classroom um for a variety of um purposes um so just want to Circle back on that other questions quick question for me um what goes into the costs that are associated with the PBIS program uh that really is not very much we have uh little bit we have our uh subscription to ruler which really brings in new resources um for the for for the staff training as well as

063for student training um not very much for PBIS Patty I think it's a yearly subscription to lessons I believe like you said it's a it's a minimal amount but the access to PBIS curricula and lessons correct I believe or is that ruler sorry ruler for K5 okay it's the curriculum it's classroom lessons that the teachers use resources we send home to families it's not a lot of money a lot of money um it's like a$1 thousand yeah something like that um but it's but it's very very um helpful it's uh money well spent money well spent yes thanks I'll chime in on audio for a second here uh just I don't want to dominate the conversation about tech so just Patty thank you for the call out about tech whis and I guess one question

064to flag for all of you in the responses that you give is what are the consistent ways in which classrooms are guided to use these tools or not and is it justified by that I mean I think some fourth grade classrooms or fifth grade classrooms or others at whis use Tech others don't so to me it seems like if it's an absolutely essential tool then what are the guidelines about doing it we don't I don't need an answer right now but Leisa if you could put that on your list of stuff that would be great to get some responses on yeah I have it on the list but Patty I'd like you to speak a little bit more you said all teachers use it can you elaborate on that please how they use it paint

065a picture because Chad is talking about people that are not using it and I just I just think that you need to talk a little bit about from when a kid walks in the building what to what extent is technology involved in his and her day so obviously it's going to be appropriate so a third grader will use technology lesson maybe a fifth grader will use be be using technology you know we spend a lot of time um I every every classroom teacher is is using technology to some extent at some point during the day we do talk a lot about we we meet in meetings about um during we're talking about new units in Reading um you know for writing time um there are certainly in science there's some wonderful programs in science our

066amplify unit um they students use that all the time um again I said fifth grade has science every day third and fourth grade has science um uh they're in Block schedules um so I all of our testing is all done all of uh is through um online assessments as well um we have our morning meetings our morning show is uh projected did on our Smartboard every morning uh for our students um I'm trying to think of it's done very purposefully we are really really careful about um not overusing it but using it purposefully but I know our students need to have skills in and typing um and doing uh you know as they get certainly older and at the more that they're uh writing the easier it is for them to be um incorporating texts

067and and writing longer pieces when it on on a computer um our little ones are mostly starting in their drafts and in their notebooks but then they are transitioning onto computers as well so it's um I think it's we're trying to be very careful about how much technology we're using but we do understand that there is a need for technology um and so and we're also preparing our kids especially as they move into into the middle school for being uh competent users of of Technology Lisa I I hate to I don't I don't want to take this meeting sideways about this one issue there's so much to get to but you know since you brought it back up I I don't think it's appropriate here to mention specific teachers names but it is my understanding

068that a couple teachers there don't use Tech so I don't know if it or not sorry not don't use Tech at all saying use it nearly as exhaustively as others do so if there is consistent guidelines about which assignments when how much that sort of thing that would be good to to weave into the answers that you respond about this and again I'm not saying like I'm not leite I think we should be using in smart ways I do question if even if it's just 100K to your point about the lease versus 300K I do really question If the parents of this community would rather have 100K for kids to get updated Chromebooks or let that Sunset do they need Chromebooks and instead keep one more teacher at that 100K salary so that's my my

069provocative question about this yeah no and we hear what you're saying and I would also like to you talk a lot about the parents I also want to mention mentioned the teachers who have a high level of expertise in instructional pedagogy and we're very proud of that so their use and the way that they use it um is also important I was at the Midale school today in three classes this morning and I can say that it was all being used extremely appropriately but why don't we move on to the middle school now thank you Lisa so um just an overview of our supplies and materials account um our largest cost break down areas the general Support Services those are the supplies I think like Patty and lur have mentioned before that support all of

070the classrooms uh it's the papers the pencils the markers the uh the needs that all of the teachers throughout the building uh really rely on having access to throughout throughout the year um and then there are certain departments at the middle school that are much more intensive in their use of supplies for example art um uh they have a lot of consumables there's a lot of materials whether it's uh in the area of drawing and painting or sculpture or the digital art uh there's different different needs and we are looking um to offer some more elective options next year so we had to budget some uh additional art materials uh for that science is another big area with the labs the Hands-On activities and the consumables uh not just for the the science classes but

071also for the science Workshop classes which um are also some a little bit resource intensive in some of the supplies um the other areas I think that the standout would be Tech and Engineering um again with consumables especially in the seventh grade area uh where they are using the wood shop um but also with uh eighth grade when they work uh on the Robotics and some replacement parts for some of those uh robots that the eth graders are using in teeken engineering and I think you just see the the normal modest uh uh supplies music uh is a big area um some of our um more traditional I guess classrooms like um social studies and World Language actually have very little costs in the way of materials and supplies uh but uh that's kind of

072an overview of our materials and supplies I did want to make a comment for the question about PBIS one additional cost for the PBIS is each of the schools does have a PB coach so there is a stipend associated with that but again it's it's uh fairly minimal uh and the work that those coaches do is phenomenal um that's the organization for The Connect uh classes that we have here at the middle school and we actually for some of our ppis initiatives it's not just the the school board budget that supports it but our PTO also supports some of our initiatives uh they give us uh gift cards so we do monthly drawings for students who earn the store cards uh when they're caught doing uh good things in school we do that on a

073monthly basis uh but as Patty said there's sometimes there's not a lot of cost uh we have a student of the month we put a poster up we put it on the morning show we we email the parents and let them know um but it's there's not really much of a financial cost to much of our PBIS initiatives Dan can you speak a little bit to how we are trying to enrich the um uh program at the middle school with regards to Art and Technology sure so you know we've been looking at our you know every year we look at our our offerings and one of the areas when we did like a little of an internal audit you know we have a wonderful music program here um and we've even expanded the um the

074ability for you know the pullout lessons whether it's students in any of the ensembles whether it's uh the band Orchestra or chorus uh students are having opportunities to not just have their every other day large Ensemble group but they also have pullout lessons with smaller groups whether it's uh sectionals or um instrument groups um but we do have other students who don't take one of those ensembles they have been in general music and that General music class was meeting also for the entire year uh every other day and ever since uh I guess probably the last major um renewal of our scheduling concept uh the we've noticed that the art offerings have been more limited um at one point everybody got a trimester of art now um some of our students only get a quarter

075of art whereas the sixth grade gets a a semester of art so we're trying to find ways to offer students more options especially in the areas of Art and uh uh Tech and Engineering especially for those students uh who are currently having a full year of General music which probably isn't in many cases their preferred subject area and at the same time uh it gives them more opportunities to explore other areas that they might then continue to explore once they get to the high school I think that was part of the conversation as well as how how can we give students more access more exposure to more opportunities at the middle school so that then they might carry on and uh at the high school and explore those interests further I have a I have

076a question here I saw some of the special um special Area Teachers are being cut does that apply to your school I um need to kind of see where that there's one um change because of the switch in having General music be a semester course instead of a year-long course that did create a reduction um in music okay all right and the other one was just I don't if you were considering World Language as part of that special but we also that's probably more enrollment based um than it is programmatic in terms of trying to be more efficient so we are projecting a reduction of one most likely span class for next year interesting okay all right no I had in my notes specials in particular but I don't I didn't think it was Spanish

077I thought my my my guess would have been more art music related um but I didn't know yeah I have to go through I my are a little cloudy some of that um art is more of a reallocation of FTE but there is an overall savings okay right thank you who moved to the high school hi everybody um so similar to what you've heard from the other three principles um our I would say we are very frugal in our supply lines and our materials budgets I can give you the example of our for our entire English Department I think in terms of materials you know they have 500 $113 spread across um all the whole department for their you know typical materials of um posted notes the big posted notes in classrooms and stuff like

078that um they do then also have um a supply or a books budget um to provide for updated books because we do want to be really conscious of what students are reading and you know updated texts um and novels that students have access to and make sure that we're keeping up with you know the pedagogy and the literature modern day literature as well um and you'll see that across the board through our math programs um math has a little bit of a stronger budget in materials because of their consumables whether they're Math workbooks and again those large Post-its and how often they use those um Chad to your point we're also really focused on you know building thinking classrooms as all the schools are um and we were really fortunate to receive a grant from

079the PTO this year to increase the number of whiteboard we have in our classrooms and with that becomes more of that collaborative um and really productive and Hands-On work that the kids are doing so our consumables really pair with that we are um I guess auditing our textbooks so we're recognizing how outdated some of our textbooks are I know especially in our world studies program and social studies some of the covers have fallen off um and as much as they are history textbooks we also want to make sure that we have those text to get us into the modern age as well so um there is an increase in the high school budget overall for those new textbooks which are sorely needed we' put that off for a number of years additionally um we are

080we budgeted to purchase the AP biotech uh bio textbooks um that's another additional cost so that's why you see that increase in that supply line for for books there um those books would be out of compliance with the AP curriculum next year so we' we've budgeted for purchasing that new um addition or updated addition so as you remember last year we had a reduction of art um this year we have a reduction um overall of 1.3 we reduced our intervention but really um we looked at that as if we can reduce um the FD the FTE that we put toward intervention we're going to apply that to that 1.0 for a math interventionist and a literacy interventionist at the high school that we felt like that gives us the flexibility for that person to then

081create their schedule throughout our 8 Day schedule six period rotation every day um and if you have questions on that I can do my best to explain our schedule um to help that make sense to you um we also have a reduction in Chinese as you know we're sunsetting the Chinese program just based on student interest and enrollment and over the coming months we'll survey our students to see if there are other languages you know or a language that students really have a profound interest in um that we might add in future years but for right now we're um reducing we have our last year of Chinese language at that fourth year um at the high school ask a question about books in general in terms of uh this is going to go counter to

082what Chad said on Chromebooks um delivering books electronically so they can be updated um more frequently or as they're updated and since every student has a Chromebook and I guess in high school they have their own uh their own laptops yes so we are a bring your own device school where students purchase the device they can select from any of those devices that are out there we see a lot of MacBooks walking around but we also see a lot of kids on their PC whether they're using them for school or sometimes gaming sometimes they serve dual purposes so that sometimes informs the way students choose their computers I also recommend often to nth and tth grade parents like you can also purchase a very inexpensive Chromebook to get your kids through nth and 10th grade

083as they kind of age into their passions and interests and then want to spend more money on the desired technology that really fits their interest um in terms of the book Steve I think you know technology is a balance we are living in 2024 as a teacher I was super excited to have my overhead projector and my transparencies in the classroom and for kids to come up to the front and like color in different countries and like map things out and the technology has grown and developed since then and I think it's really important that not only students can use it to access information but they're using it to create and problem solve and that's what we're really seeing at the high school so textbooks are a balance too I think that there is a

084Val the research tell tells us there is a value in kids taking notes by hand right there there it improves their memory they retain it more when they write versus type i t I try to tell my own children that sometimes they use that advice sometimes they don't um the textbooks in terms of a cost there really isn't a cost savings to purchasing the online textbooks versus a a print edition uh we are purchasing the print edition of the AP book a P biob books we do we are there's a blend in terms of the world studies and how we're offering it to our 10th grade honors and then our ninth grade classes we decided again that there was a cost um factor in this we decided to purchase I believe it's a Well we

085haven't done it yet but what we are requesting and recommending is that we purchase the online text for world studies for one year so that we can really get a sense of the textbook and how we would use it and how we want to move forward so I think in that way we are kind of doing a measured integration of this new edition of the textbook and there are the pros and cons the number of resources that online textbooks can offer students is pretty phenomenal you know that they can read they can annotate online but then there's also that added benefit of what you know encouraging kids to take notes by hand kind for that memory and retention so technology is a balance and I think our teachers do really great job of supporting students

086and understanding that balance and using the online textbooks in effective ways or using those print textbooks in effective ways to maximize learning I was G I was gonna actually reach out to to you and ask you the same question um you know what you're seeing in education overall yes are you you're asking me right Steve I think um exactly what Megan is speaking to most districts are um starting to transition to um access to online texts um however I do think that as Megan said around the balance we do see that that students some students still want to have a physical text to reference um there is a difference between being able to highlight underline add Post-its right whether it's a physical text or if it's a um academic text so we are asking the

087kids I mean we're our teachers are making note of how many students are using textbooks let's say if we've purchased a whole classroom set versus how many of them actually accessing the physical text versus just accessing the resource online so in some cases I was just going to add on to Megan's um explanation in some classes specifically in social studies in those content areas that she's speaking to um we are working with the teachers to decide whether or not maybe we want not a full classroom set of of text but we have maybe a a couple groups five to 10 physical texts that that can remain in the classroom so while instruction is going on um if they need to or depending on the activity depending on the instructional pedagogy that the teacher is designing

088the learning to be for the day they have physical texts in the book it um in the classroom but then the full access for all students is available online um because seeing that a lot of times when uh students are leaving the classroom that's the easier way to kind of um access the the information and what they need to complete homework or complete projects um so there's a combination not every class or course is treated equal and we really are being mindful of um asking the teachers and how the students are using either the online version Andor the physical texts in conjunction because sometimes you get both it's cheaper sometimes to um like Megan said just get the online version or just get the physical text um sometimes they they package them in bundles right

089but it always is more costly if you want the bundle it's not um double but it is um it is it is um an increased cost if you're looking for the physical text and the online piece so that's where we're really trying to ask teachers and students like how are you using these materials in the curriculum and how are the students using them so for that specific case we've made an adjustment for next year and we were very mindful of which class wants just a couple sets in the classroom and access online for all kids versus buying a full classroom set for every kid one to one thanks thanks J I think it's my fault of course that this this thread is keeps coming up in each school so sorry and you're welcome I think

090it's mostly just sorry uh this is exactly the kind of question I think is worth having during the budget process because to your point in the high school it's a bring your own device do we need to pay for devices in the other schools and also your point Tina is saying like some like digital text some like paper this is uh an Mangan from University of stavenger and Norway the study's old it's April 11th 2013 but this is from an article the reading brain in the digital age the science of paper versus screens in Scientific American the ease with which you find out the beginning end and everything in between and the constant connection to your path your progress in the text might be some way of making it less taxing cognitively so you have

091more free capacity for comprehension which is why actually having the page may be vastly better than having an endless digital rectangular scroll so I'm just asking for the same type of rigor considering are we going to spend 300K on unnecessary tools versus necessary especially when a lot of them were started during the pandemic which was achieving deeply suboptimal educational outcomes anyway I promise I will now shut up for the rest of the meeting on this issue I've already spent too much time on it thank you for Indulgence I I just want to add I mean we're talking about the general population it's not either or there's no question that text is important textbooks are important but in our age 2025 computers are just as important you know what wasn't brought up was the differentiation that

092it has ability um to support students um the engagement the community the reaching and access to outside other schools other opportunities there's no question about it text is important old school is important except we live in an age and we're so lucky that a computer that took up my entire desk in 1984 is now in a small cell phone so it's not either or it's and and we have to have our children use these devices in order to be competitive in 2025 if I may again on Thursday the 16th of January we will begin with technology we have heard you and the team will speak to it at length thank you C can you hear me now yeah Peter all right maybe my uh having my video off is good for all of us so

093um I have a question for Megan uh about her presentation last night then I'm going to give a 15-second math lesson so please indulge me then I'm going to uh address the superintendent and the assistant superintendent so Megan if you could finally explain in your presentation you had like remedial linear algebra you had some some uh more granularity in that course can you explain the rationale for that um and uh we'll take it from there and then I'll give my algebra I'll give my math lesson so let's just start with that like what's your thinking behind that the motivation why what the outcome you expect so let's start with that sure I'm going to start with saying that I am not the math expert so um I lean on others when we make these decisions

094as a team but what I will tell you is based on the data and the data comes from um you know our assessments with students their Proficiency in algebra and also you can remember last year we had conversations of about the accelerated algebra geometry course and what we are seeing is that there are there is a population of students that will persist through high school but they need more time with the algebra linear equations before they get to quadratics tinana you're the math expert so I just want to make sure I'm getting this right okay um so we have proposed that new course that went through the curriculum subcommittee so when we that was just one of the um elements of our program that I wanted to highlight because as I've always said we're constantly

095um you know assessing what we doing and how effective it is to support students so we feel that um providing this class concentrating on linear equations waiting to get to linear equations in a potential next course is really the best move for a number of our students to help their overall math proficiency knowing that algebra is the foundation and we do see that creep up you know throughout their progress um in math as they move through our sequence at the high school yes well done Megan um so just to add a little more um Riley rapor is our curriculum and instruction leader for 612 um Megan mentioned you know having multiple con conversations and dialogue uh when we make these decisions and looking at the data um the standards related to algebra just to give

096some full context it's a large bucket of standards that districts are required to design courses around to ensure that the foundation of algebra is mastered prior to students going on to higher level mathematics classes like free calculus calculus um statistics and so over time what we're what the data is showing us is that we needed to add this course based on Riley's suggestion and the data that she presented to both Megan and I and with com a combination of um conversations with our classroom teachers that are currently um teach teaching nth grade specific classes um we were able to create halfe classes where we could focus on foundational algebra skills which also gave students more time to deepen their understanding of those Concepts prior to moving on to those upper level math classes so it's

097not um a class necessarily that we may need forever but for next year there is a need the data is showing that there is a need we presented this uh to the curriculum subcommittee as a change to courses in the math department moving into next year's program of study um and we will continue to Monitor and look at student achievement to determine whether or not how long we still need to revise some of these classes and offer at the high school level all right thank you for that explanation I can't wait for your math lesson so here's the math lesson please indulge me and then I'll return to the superintendent in the assistant superintendent with my uh I'm taking notes pration so in a linear algebra the the standard form is ax plus b y

098+ Cal Z slope of that form that that equation I recall is negative B over a right Delta y Delta X you have to put the X on the other side of the equation so what I've heard is it's really good to have granulation like pixels of capability in classes I thought Megan gave an excellent example and I think she's totally dead on I don't really want to stop with ninth grade algebra I actually want to go backwards to starting with kindergarten so now that's my math lesson if the slope is we have to cut head count the perpendicular line to that slope is B over is A over B and here's my what I'm offering I really liked that the superintendent talked about expanding right we're not Contracting we're expanding I really like that

099Lisa uh talked about we have yet to begin to teach you think the state's going to put demands on us last year this year it's not even started right we're gonna have social studies we're going to see math or reading it's all can to become more and more challenging and more and more competitive and then you have Mr Cross who says wow insurance just costs this much it I don't I think he's underestimating personally and it's no not a criticism I think you got to count that it's going to be much more uh brutal than even his numbers so here's here's the perpendicular line that's contrary to where we started our discussions earlier right I think we should hire more teachers because the reality is that you're going to have to have granular ity starting

100in fourth grade in intervention you may have to have a whole class of Young Learners that need a little kicker and you may have the middle class and you may have kids that are like savants at math at fourth grade that are just bored and you'll see this just Ripple up all the way through Middle School I see it now in middle school because I participate in middle school so I'm like headcount Cuts I'm like to expand a curriculum to be ambitious like the two young kids that were that were highlighted last night what remarkable kids right you're gonna have to hire more teachers so if you're gonna have to hire more teachers to add granularity to teach more things that the state's going to ask of us and to achieve and have rigor something's

101G to have to give that's what's what's what's GNA have to give on headcount that's the discussion of today because what's not going to happen who's going to create the list that's says wow more teachers more insurance money more granularity K through 12 what don't we have I think our Board responsibility is to sort of start figuring out that list because there's only a few places and we all know what they are right if you don't like $30,000 per kid have you know was it 29 31 right if you want 28 but you have to have more teachers guess what you don't get to have you don't get to have a football and baseball te team you don't get to have sports I I like Mr burkwitz da Eagan is a heroine right she's probably

102the best spokesman our town has but we just may not be able to have football if you got to have algebra so let's start getting real with ourselves and a criticism to all of us you could Tinker around the edges you could say I want less cell phones in school don't buy as many postet but the reality is either we're going to be academically inclined we're going to have exactly what Megan pointed to to or we're just going to just float and we're just going to try to Tinker and we're just not going to do our jobs that we're volunteering for so that's my cering using a little bit of linear algebra to be a contrarian to go perpendicular to the line that this conversation is taken so that's why I was glad I got

103my uh sound back on my computer now I'll turn it off and I'll see uh what arrows come shooting at me okay um moving along so we've gone through the schools there's I'm gonna let Mark bko shoot all the arrows at you on that one Peter there are some other sections of the of the um the book um Tracy Edwards is here um perhaps if uh you know and again I know there's a lot of stuff here and we if you're not um you don't have any feedback or comments or questions on sped PPS today that's fine but I I did want to give um you all an opportunity to um hear from Tracy any thoughts or feedback Trac there any comments you'd like to make terms of Trends you know what you're seeing you

104know do we [Music] need are there more more children that you're having to serve I mean it's I guess it you know this is the wild card in the budget that we have little control over or limited control over yeah I mean I think the summary that I provided last night kind of captures where we are we are seeing an increase in or at least projected for next year students who are going to um require a program out of districts there's a number of different reasons and causes for that that are really um student specific in terms of the other budget lines there's some um relative continuity and things like contracted Services Staffing really is consistent I do think we have the right people in each building to be meeting the needs of the students

105um but as you just said and as I think I say in every single meeting so people are probably incredibly sick of hearing about it these are the lines of the budget that are about specific individual students whose needs can change at any moment in time we could have a student who is you know not presenting with any concerns at all who maybe isn't even receiving special educ Education Services who has a crisis in some way and is all of a sudden necessitating something very significant be it a high level of service in District um a level of service out of District in a day placement or in some cases a level of service that warrants um the most restrictive placement which is a residential placement um and these placements are incredibly costly and the

106cost increase at a rate that is inconsistent with um what I would consider more General budget increases for everyone else um meaning the public schools so it's just something that we have to watch all of the time we're watching this year's budget um in real time with current students that is a that is a daily process um and of course you know next year's projection is based on exactly what we know right now in this moment and we're asking for that budget to carry us all the way through um next June so it it's very complicated it is very tricky um as I noted last night we are not including contingencies this is based on information we know right now um I monitor this on a weekly basis Phil and I meet regularly to discuss

107um patterns and Trends so that's that's where we are um at this moment if there are specific questions of course I'm happy to answer them Tracy I do have a question this is more of like a philosophical question I don't even need an answer I'm actually just asking because I it's it's just a fascinating I guess for where we're headed do you think this is sort of like an issue of like for lack of a better word diagnosis or do you think things have actually changed on the ground meaning do more kids get this because parents are more aware society's more aware Etc or do you actually think you know the ground has sort of shifted under us in terms of the level that these kids need support um that's an interesting question I know

108you said you aren't looking for an answer but I I will weigh in on it I I think it's a combination of both um I do think for a variety of reasons we're seeing increased need the pace of everyone's life is very different than it was 15 or 20 years ago and I think that has impacts on all of us and especially our young people um and at the same time I think your points about increased awareness and increased sensitivity to needs also um contributes to how we program and problem solve when students are facing specific challenges so I would say both things are true Lisa de yes I'm here I'm sorry Jody telling me something a little bit important um in a timely manner um I don't know if anybody has any uh questions

109for Phil what why don't we move to him just just before I know everyone is hyper focus on uh on health insurance and it's it's good right but I think what it's lead into is that it's kind of helping us to really better and understand the overall budget um I will continue to say it's a it's a marathon guys um we we have until ultimately I would say until March before you know to get really get things together I know the board has to vote by the end of this month um I'm constantly in contact with a with our health insurance broker so I think for our discussion if I may just let's not focus for right now in the immediate in the near term um on health insurance we're working on that and let's

110just kind of focus on everything else do want to point out that um in terms of when we mention supplies that also included in our supply lines are our utility cost um there's really a modest increase in our utility cost um coming in for for fiscal 26 um we are based on we are anticipating a lower um reimbursement rate called reimbursement our credit rate from ever source for our virtual net um meter in credit so that's kind of factored in but overall there just a modest increase that we have um for our um for our utilities I think we have a better Trend um in terms of where where we are projecting in terms of usage um coming out of the pandemic so I think we're we're in a good place R into utilities we

111have long-term contracts for our supplier rates for electricity and we just signed a new contract for natural G gas so we're in a good place for utilties I think hey Phil just really quickly we went through a couple of um rfps this past year uh cleaning Transportation Etc um the the Food Service um any anything upcoming you know again parking the the health the health insurance situation is is there anything coming up here um over the you know in the next year or so that we should be mindful of as we think about um you know project projected cost other services going out no I think those were those were the big ticket items that we have um really those are the three main contracts that we have everything else is really in-house um so

112not not really um I do want to point out that while we have our budget last year you guys may recall that the board of Finance did um propose a reduction it was a TBD line item um we did not have a specific line item that we did reduce um for fiscal 25 so that number is a plus for this year um and that's a 37 um increase that we have so it's really kind of swung back to us because there was not an identified reduction so we do have some savings um for those three contracts that you mentioned um so this pretty much just offset that but I just wanted to kind of paint the broad picture in terms of every component that we have in the budget Lisa is there more that you

113want to cover or the board wants to cover um no not really um I think that you've given us um a flavor of some different things we are um going to uh you know work on providing uh answers to that um specifically in the areas of um class sections for example last year and I'm and I'm almost done with it for this year what we did was we looked at the class sections for the next 10 years projection this is what Michael lber was specially interested in and we looked at it for um you know this number of sections within the guidelines and then if we cut one section which is in effect what David is saying if we raised it a little bit how would it impact the sections and then we looked at

114overall like for example her but goes from I think it's 20 sections this year and in the next 10 years at some point over the next 10 years we'll need 25 so it kind of gives us a flavor of the EB and flow of not only the section numbers but the f te numbers with regards to specifically uh classroom teachers we did that um the same with uh the Middle School um we've been um trying to tap out at eight sections you know it gets very complicated with the team structure if you go below that but we've certainly uh worked on that we can get that to you by uh by this week just again to give you a flavor of where are we going with this and I think that one of the things

115that we really want to work on is sort of painting a picture of you know when we talk consumables I think that or instructional supplies or supplies in general because it's a big bucket um it's kind of like what is that we got a little bit of a flavor of it today but I think we need to be a little bit more specific in what does that look like what actually is that and to Michael's Point how you know what percentage of that or amount of that will need to be carried over every year you know if you're going to have a math program and the kids work in a math workbook you're going to have that every single year and to look at how that um plays out you know I've been around a

116long time and many years ago used to uh it was workbook crazy crazy back in the uh you know 90s for example World Language at one point every language had two workbooks a workbook and an activity workbook okay those days are gone but what is left of that that is necessary um because to um to Laura's point you know if you don't provide a workbook a consumable workbook and I've seen the kids working them in in class then what are you going to be doing uh Xerox in it you can't do that it's a copy right and then the the paper becomes exorbitant so I think we need to provide some more color with that we'll work on sort of spelling out again and and reiterating you know it's great when we talk through answers

117but then to produce written responses I think is helpful because I know I go back I reflected on every written response that we did last year to see how we this is impacting this year and if we're being clear and transparent with what we're talking about um and I guess lastly I will say that there there will be um at some points in over the next several uh weeks um we will agree to disagree I think on certain things and certain um perceptions if you will and and that's fine you know that that's all part of it to Chad's point this is the place one of the places to raise the issue of the cost of technology that being said I know that we have worked really hard especially with uh looking at uh software

118requests and usage um of it and how it's used and I I think NE uh at our next meeting it is important for us to to show the evidence indicators of um what else is being done in the school day because I don't want people to walk away thinking the kids are sitting in front of screens for six out of the 7 and a half hours that we have them it's not um so so we will work um we will work on that and I'm trying to think if I missed anything Dr hle is there anything that comes to mind Lisa Lisa there's one thing um and I don't know when you're going to cover it i' I'd really like to hear about the construct the uh curriculum instructional leaders um and there yes I

119was getting to that with calling on Dr hanle oh thank you yeah sure and one thing I can tell you right now is you talk about like when people watch classes they observe classes and coverage is done that the cost of that is all in the uh substitute lines in the budget but Dr hle if you'd like to um share a little bit about your thoughts about how to kind of um paint the picture of the Sals sure I started a little bit last night with the chart and looking at where we currently are with fullt FTE full-time cils and those that are less than full-time cils um I know Lisa talks about this a lot right our curriculum and instruction leaders support a variety of teaching and learning initiatives throughout the district and um

120they really are the heartbeat of all the different content areas when it comes to support and ensuring that our teachers have what they need to deliver and Implement um high quality curriculum high quality instruction um with that in mind uh we are also so very mindful of that overall increase that that we're looking at right now and when we think about Personnel we wanted to see if there was any way to um revise some of that model to uh provide some cost savings overall within uh the position so we know that um connecting to students as well as staff is is part of their role um on a daily basis and so at the K5 level um we looked at intervention and looking at small small group support that a lot of them already do

121through that multi-tiered system of support framework that we've been spending a lot of time on this past year revising and refining throughout the district so I met with each of them I had a conversation about um their schedules and the balance between supporting classroom teachers when it comes to curriculum implementation and weaving in within the week throughout the week small group in instruction to support intervention is that feasible is that something that based on the data we feel we can maximize the support for teachers as well as um reducing some of the intervention support um overall they all agreed they thought that they already sometimes are working with small groups of students anyway um throughout the day throughout the week because they work hand inand with our interventionists so um we're we believe that at

122the K5 level we can adjust some of that 1.0 FTE to a08 so that 02 of that time they're also working uh with small groups of students throughout the week um at the secondary level it's a little different right schedules are a lot different when you get to middle school and high school um when we look at supporting teachers modeling best practices Lisa you you you zoomed right into to my model framework around a master teacher um idea where a lot of times when they're co- teing or model in instruction they're working alongside the teachers in the classrooms and so by revising their FTE to include one class where they're they're actually applying what they're already doing with teachers to lesson plan and unit plan and talk about pedagogy they can revise their schedule so

123that one of the one of the blocks of time will be to the point two would be to actually teach a class in their given content areas um I've met with each of them as well some of them are very excited for that opportunity and um all feel that they um can still um balance some of what they do with um small groups of teachers during department or curricular planning time um and also teach a class um so that's what we're proposing for next school year I just want to make a comment that um you know whenever we talk intense it always makes a little nervous right because when we design job descriptions our job descriptions are designed as full-time positions right and so an interventionist job description is a full-time job description a curriculum

124and instruction leader job description is for a full-time job description and so when we start going less than that 0.8.2 um we need to make some hard decisions around what the priorities are when we're focusing on a Cil point8 and a point2 interventionist right for example um and so this individual group is very mindful of that and um they recognize that through support from their principles from support from me and Lisa um we identify and work with them on some aspects that maybe need to take less of a priority given the fact that your point8 Cil and maybe can't meet with every grade level we've talked about this I know you're you you weren't with us last couple years Lisa but um we talked about what the what the scheduling impacts mean when you reduce

125from a 1.0 curriculum and instruction leader position to a point eight it means that not everyone is going to get the same amount of attention because of how the scheduling um the scheduling Falls within a secondary environment let's say um but we're going to work with Megan um to make sure that hopefully the first period is the block of time that the culum and instruction leaders teach their class so we can maximize the remaining portion of the day to work in small groups with teachers they still can support department meetings they still can support um the multi-tiered system of support the data meetings that a lot of them run and facilitate and organize and manage um as well as um the additional roles around curriculum implementation and design so that's that's our goal I'm putting

126it in writing I mapped out the chart I added a little bit more to the chart to show um the number of teachers that every individual Cil supports throughout the district when it comes to um the different content areas the levels because it's it's not it's not all the same right um so that also helped us make some of those decisions when we revised some of the structure for next year it's not a huge overall savings but um it definitely is a savings and and I feel like we're still going to be able to maximize our program and U meet the needs of our of our teachers based on the scaffolded implementation uh for the different grades and the different curricula that are being um implemented for next school year thanks so look at the

127chart thanks does anyone have anything else that they would like us to this kind of on their radar that you would like us to to be thinking about um things that we're looking at um you know uh I think one of the big questions always is is that you know um and I'm I'm a big one for and that's why I I talked about Josh and Eliza uh the the kids Behind the numbers and so um when we talk about a 4.75 budget and you say okay Lisa get it to 3.75 I mean we already start doing this right what would it look at what would it look like um and we've already started that exercise I I just and we can certainly talk about that at the next workshop and uh how it would

128impact and if we get some of these documents done sooner we'll share them with you um I think the important thing to know is is look um every I've been around a long time and I've seen a lot of ways that budget is is presented and different things like that the way that I've tried to present our budget is this is what we really need I I'm not I don't believe in like well let's just add a few things because we know they're going to cut this is what we need um in to this is this is what we need not what we want we can certainly go through the exercise and we will but I want you to know up front that that to be blunt hey it's my last year I don't play

129the game of of padding with3 or $400,000 now you might say well how did you end up with uh surpluses at the end of the year to be very blunt through a lot of hard work and a lot of careful planning and a lot of Staffing and maximizing Staffing and studying those enrollments I mean you know we were very fortunate this this past year when we didn't need staff to to um for kindergarten sections we didn't put it in we look at it const constantly I mean when Laura says that she's looking at enrollment right now and and right now I can tell you I look at the enrollment between kindergarten and the first grade and we know that one of those sections will go down and one of them will go up we don't

130know which but and Laura shaking head we're pretty confident it's pretty maxed out in first grade most likely we'll get that section from kindergarten because we're not confident we need that many sections and what I appreciate with this board and with this town is whenever we really needed something thing you have been there to help us fund it and um and I I've seen it for many many years so this is our our attempt to give those kids what they need and what they deserve and we will work to see because I know it's a high number I I try really hard to to come in low I met yesterday with um the durg superintendant and uh we we meet um every month and it was a great meeting and all the talk was things

131like benefits salaries Transportation uh all of that and how challenging this environment is as well as to sustain the instructional program that we have we take our work very very seriously and how perhaps we can look to share things I'm not sure what you know if it's outplaced Transportation different things these are beginning conversations but know that we are a United committed group to work together for the best that we can bring to our kids so with that um you know I'll I'll close it out and I'll turn it over to you again or if you think of something after the meeting ends Lisa you know you said this and I really want to see about that sir i' I'd like you to look at this or like you to look at that while you

132were talking I've already started documents and sent out emails to a variety of people like we need to have these answers because we can't come in at the last minute throw you all in answers you have to have time to process it and think about it that's how we um have always I think come to a a realistic budget of what we need and we want to make sure that we afford you that time to be able to to come to grips with it Lisa I do have two other things I wanted to ask you to add to your your list one is can you um give us not today um what the a cost analysis is of the pure teaming model that's come up a couple of times yes yes okay so know what

133is the cost to have the pure teaming model and the important part is for our viewing audience as Sharon sometimes says um what the perer teaming model is because it is really hard to understand unless you've been on the board so what is the cost and and what is the benefit because then you can tie the two together of course and the other question I have if you could let us know next time we meet are any of our staffing uh requirements today as a result of the Esser funds expiring so the what I'm really kind of asking is okay because when we when we were on the board 100 years ago and we got Sr funds uh through the state the free money you know the concern was is it uh something that we're

134going to be feel obligated to continue and then budget for so all of the things that we paid for through all the staff and things we paid through Esser funds have left we're no long that's no longer a cost to us like we haven't taken those people and put them into our budget what I can tell you David and that's what I mean by really planful I knew when I took over this role that there was a limited amount of Sr funds and everything else and so we've been planning since uh postco to make sure that it's was done in a planful way you know um so there's no like oh no we don't have the Sesser money next year and now we had to load this up that that's that ship is sailed um

135right Phil yes um however along those lines you know when you talk about let's say a 20% you know 02 right 20% of an FTE decrease in math that's how far into the weeds we get like Laura said by looking at who are these kids what are they actually going to need an intervention and if we don't need to uh if they don't need that extra point to them we're not going to take it that doesn't mean that the following year based again on student needs and teacher um analysis of data that it could be an extra 0 2% math and we decrease in Reading Our Hope especially with this new reading program is to continually look at getting that reading intervention lower at the middle school to be perfectly Frank that's the goal it's

136got to be based on not just carrying people in the budget but what does the data show us the student performance show us and how we can continually Flex it which we've done to accommodate the needs of the kids that are here um and so that's where you'll see like a slight increase at the Intermediate School in the math and a slight decrease in uh herbette because it's we're looking at the data of the kids that are here and what is going on and you know they're they're implementing that new um the math at the intermediate school and it's really really important that we have a little bit of extra intervention to make sure it goes well the following year who knows again it's based on what we need okay and I remember years past

137we got a sheet and I haven't discovered it in the budget book yet so it might be in there where we saw the Staffing numbers uh over the course of I think four five six years is that in the budget book where we can look at Staffing from 20 for example fiscal year 2020 2021 2022 um cor to that yeah no it's it's it's not in the book but we can provide that okay what would be helpful for me is to see uh going back to let's say 2020 or maybe 2019 2020 being kind of that odd year with uh the change over to covid but uh uh staff count enrollment if I could see those two numbers that would be helpful um for me anyway yeah we we it's two separate we'll provide that

138that has to be two separate documents what we can provide that um one thing I want to point out is in our supplemental documents last year for the 2425 budget there was a WMS teaming model overview done that doesn't mean that I want Mr do to please look at that and we will do it a little bit more through the lens of of explaining the impact of going to the seven sections or something like that I think that's perhaps needs to be a little bit more but but know that you know all these supplemental documents that we did before like the teaming model and and some other things um will'll uh redo them through the lens of this year's budget if I'm making sense got that Mr do thank you and Phil Phil really quickly

139just piggybacking on what um what David requested um if you can provide a little bit more detail I guess maybe certified staff non-certified staff and going back in history um that would be helpful I think you're on mute we can't hear you you're on mute the document that I'm thinking about does show both certified and noncertified sturn it goes back quite quite a bit um we may need to update that um so yeah but we can provide that though I know exactly I think I know the one that David is referring to great thanks are we uh are we good for the day is that a is that a yes so if that's the case can we have a motion to adjourn so moved second second all those in favor I I thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.