001tonight's meeting yes is there a motion to approve tonight's agenda motion thank you Pat is there a second second thank you Nicola all in favor carries unanimously um comments from the public I have a comment okay I know I never have a comment but I I thought I I'm here anyway so I may as well comment so this is what I thought and I'm sorry I missed the last actually two meetings because I became a grandmother congratulations and it's thrown me off my game completely off my game I am over so I just wanted to tell you what we do I don't know if you all know but I'm the the Education Association president and I just want to tell you what we do just quickly do you want to come so we meet twice
002a month one of the times that we meet per a month is with the the uh representatives from the schools and this year I've been part of the union for I'm going to say 10 years maybe and this year we have more reps than we've ever had before which I think is a good sign that people want to get involved and they want to you know improve the schools and all of that so um we meet with them once a month and on the other month we do what you guys just did we have an executive meeting where we try and solve the problems and I would like to shout out to Maria because she comes to those meetings and we brainstorm then we try and solve you know whatever little problems big problems are
003happening in the schools and it's nice and we're having a good year so far so I just wanted to tell you that I am here and available I kind of have a pulse on the teacher side of uh you know our school system so if you have any questions please use me I am an asset to you and I would like to wish you all a happy holidays any other comments from the public hearing none um consent agenda um the consent agenda consists of the minutes from the organizational meeting on December 5th then our regular meeting following that on December 5th and the board briefing on the prek tuition increase are there any um comments or questions on the executive I'm sorry on the consent agenda hearing none is there a motion to approve the
004con sorry actually I do have a question on the um on the prek tuition increase do we I know we we looked at all the comps did we talk about what to do or was there a was there an action suggested from that just to improve the just to improve okay 2% and I believe two and a half two and a half 25 and then three three points three is there a motion to approve the consense agenda thank you Lori is there a second second Thank you Pam all in favor I motion carries unanimously for chair's report I would just like to take a minute to say thank you to everybody and that everybody includes everyone around the table teachers staff administ ERS custodians and parents everyone who sets a foot students sets a foot
005into our building lives in our community I can't believe it's already halfway through the year here we are halfway through the year but it's been a really um tremendous positive year and I spent the last couple of weeks going through um the all the schools and it's just a Marvel and I was at all the holiday concerts and that's also a Marvel and so I just want to um say thank you and give our gratitude and appreciation to everybody and all their hard work wish everyone a happy and healthy holiday break a new year and um to have some you know good times with family and friends and um really just enjoy the enjoy the season you too I just have a couple of things and I just I'll kind of repeat what um Peg
006just said it has been a pretty good you know in that she shouted out Maria shout out p and the executive I Maria every time and it's been a really good constructive set of conversations so far so things are in a good place and we're Contin to get better I'll work on my snow calls um so two things tonight um one I'm going to ask everyone to save the date for our next long range planning session it for February 25th 6:30 we're planning a panel discussion with Executives and professionals from um across professional sectors including law business industry u tech highered Healthcare entertainment um the panel discussion will focus on the impact of AI in those various Industries today um what these professionals anticipate with respect to AI in the next 5 10 15 years
007or so and then um recommendations for what we as a school system should be doing now curricularly to better prepare our kids for this um change already way what was the date again February 25th so Tuesday 6:30 to 8 yeah and so we have um I think three or four folks so it's going to be a really good high level conversation and should so we'll finalize the panel early on will where will that be um I have a schedule for the zelner I just have to verify that there's no conflict and so we'll send invitations and depending on the RSVP you know I think this could get a draw even in late February um so we TBD for now okay um and then just um kind of the last update here um as part of
008my re-entry plan you know that I've been um kind of entertaining this year um I've met with most of the administrators um in the New Year I'll start my um individual and small group meetings with staff um and then I'm also holding a series of opportunities for parents and for the community so I wanted to give you the dates for those parent meetings um the mid goal will be January 28th at 10: a.m. you don't have to write this down I'll send it to you I just want to make everybody aware that I'm doing it and when it is um that'll follow their PTA meeting U at which point I'll also be talking about the budget um I'll be at CER mill on January 7th at 10:15 that also will follow the PTA meeting which
009I'll be at the Middlebrook PTA meeting um is January 16th at 9:45 um and then the high school um is here in evening on January 8th so that's at 7 7:30 um and then I'll be also holding an additional evening session for you know anyone um parents community members other on January 14th 6 to 7:30 Miss eler and then in addition to you know I've scheduled um just kind of St droing opportunities at each of the schools um in late late January through F like I mentioned i' got a long list of folks that I'm anxious to talk to so I'll be setting up those invitations that's it can I ask um through each school if there could be like a parent square that goes out so parents and everybody um knows about it and
010next up is the financial report great so the um financial report there is not much to talk about which is good news um spending is where we expect it to be for this year we continue to monitor it lla shared that we're able to secure some additional discounts through Amon bus with that's and then beyond that there are a couple minor transfers so you can see you know small small dollar amounts they're all kind of within category so some Transportation transfers from fall to winter season see there's anything else that's wor here now we had to buy a new ice maker for the science department so we moved from digital resources saw that new ice Banker yeah fancy right yeah and then the um science department just they took some money out of there we
011we didn't send [Music] anyone so they move that to equipment to purchase um Vex kits for the engineering course is that your course yes right so enjoy Kevin on the year-to DAT forecast vers year-to dat actual expenditure if there's a Delta where our actual expenditure is under what was forecasted year today does that mean we're had a budget on those so on life insurance it might just be the timing of the payment that's yeah so I I wouldn't read um I wouldn't read too deeply into the contractual Services is 3 million yeah not so just probably timing Services there timing of expenditures yeah you know again like just now got me looking at it like you would expect you know variability building repairs some of those are not scheduled kind that's any other um questions
012or comments on the financial report we will move to um review and discuss the first item up is policy 3160 budget and L item transfers to be renamed to budget procedures and line item transfers with Cal 13 14 and 18 so this policy it's a long-standing policy that describes the budget development requirements um we follow this policy annually through the creation and the adoption of the budget um we exceed the policy mandate through our actual interactions with the board of Finance um as you know we have a long-standing position of holding a joint meeting with the board of Finance we solicit questions from them and respond and writing the same way we do through the budget process and then you know those documents become part of the budget cation process um you know more recently
013in terms of the partnership to the r both of us and so that open dialogue is probably never better um so that's really also um hold business operations meetings periodically through the in which two Board of Finance members gener participate um as we just did we monitor the budget through the monthly budget updates and then we report on our transfers monthly also um so what's new in this policy is the um the last piece the unexpended funds provision um last year the statute changed to enable boards education to establish non-aps accounts in which boards can deposit unexpended budget funds from the prior fiscal year um the amount deposited annually cannot be greater than 2% of the appropriated budget but there's no cap on how large the account can grow over time so the opportunity is
014beneficial uh for some obvious reasons um you know we have unmet needs so you know this can create an incentive to be a little conservative with our spending to have some money that we can spoil away to address some of those unmet needs um if we have emergency needs um you know here's also an opportunity so you know we've been talking about boilers endlessly over the last systems for the last two years so you know again if there's a need there we can can address it um what we'll need to do is to consider um some regulations on how to guide how these funds uh may be directed um what I'm imagining and is in place in lots of other districts is you know things like extraordinary unanticipated Education costs um one-time type purchases so
015maybe there's a technology thing that comes up you know is not in the budget so here an opportunity to do that um emergency facility needs um the like so I wouldn't imagine ever using an account like this um to carry recurring costs you know that's not really the the spirit in which it's created um so I think you know to address some of the concerns that you know you raised earlier this year the funds are deposited in an account by board approval and then they're expended by board approval so you know you as a board would maintain full oversight is there a definition of educational purposes anything to do with the budget of the yeah I don't think yeah so I think no no what I mean is like does it have to be does
016that mean it's only for classroom user if we had other needs to support the school system yeah I I think it's pretty Broad in that you know it's the school facilities education yeah I me anything that we would T you know as part of our operation would be permissible I have a question if that if it's deposited by board approval at the end of the year the 30th of June we don't have a meeting after that how do we approve so we'll have to work on the timing um so I think what um we might have to meet later in the year you know sometime in July and or come up with another um another mechanism but what you know I'm anticipating we would do is we're closing out the accounts I would notify you
017in writing about you know what's unexpended with a recommendation to deposit um and then we would have to meet either in person or you know virtually for you to apply on that I think in Years Gone by before your time the there would be like a million dollars returned to the town in unexpended funds is there going to be a amount over which it would have to be returned to the to the town that's always um you know I I think there's discretion there right um well 2% isn't it 2% is the max yeah which you know I mean that's a million dollars is not 2% of our budget right so if you if that was the number you were contemplating we'd be within that so anything over than that you can't return anything over
018if we're not if we're if we got more than 2% expended then we had a we didn't budget very we really we get down to Dollars and cents like pennies I I think we should have a conversation you know I don't know that the town you know these days anticipates um supporting the general fund with unexpended Board of Ed funds um but that's a it's a good conversation you know to have with the board of Finance um and so you know if that would if something unusual happened in a year where there might have been a need then that could a conversation you know collegially across two boards I think too it's important that you keep in mind is as we we initially come out with a budget proposal that's always higher than what the
019guidance is we acknowledge the maybe the things that we would have spent money on um and try to I don't know not keep track of it but like let's let's assess you know things that we took out of the budget that we really wanted that we weren't able to get and then look at that fund potentially to go back and make those expenditures for the following year great Point yeah so the um opportunity to to establish an unexpended funds account has existed for a long time um what's different is the authority to establish it so prior to this year um that Authority existed with the board of finance and so now you have the opportunity to do it so we're looking at this policy anyway so so it's just it's good we did have a
020conversation with Matt about it you know we didn't go to the full Board of finance and ask for an opinion but you was supp recognize recognize the the value in in the concept and the idea yeah and um and also kind of also understanding that I think the right way to look at it is these kind of non-recurring costs um and that it's not kind of like a budget offset yeah off set fund um but I think you know for over the years that I've been you know sitting on the board um for the most part we budget pretty pretty well so there isn't that much and like like towards what you said there was the co year that was a substantial a year that we had substantial savings because the school wasn't in session
021and we did return that money to the town so I think when you find ourselves in extraordinary circumstances like that the the whole town is operating kind of in an extraordinary circumstance and that's when you do have a broader kind of discussion at this table and with others about what is leading to that circumstances and then what is the the appropriate you know allocation does that money sit in an interest bearing account we I don't know interest good question I'll ask hopefully ibly yeah one um top the first paragraph um I think because it's like shipment language when it say transfer sh be provided to the think it should be the financial Authority oh noove the unexpended here there oh yeah right it should be the financial authorities yeah BR it's of Finance or Board
022of Finance yeah the previous draft had it um General and then kind of described all the different possibilities that it could be yes okay next one this is AED policy entitled academic honesty this is a recommended but not required policy we're bringing this policy forward really as we Voyage into the age of artificial intelligence um our high school maintains an academic Integrity requirement through its handbook um as does our our Middle School um so this policy will um support and enhance that um that handbook regulation by specifically um defining and prohibiting cheating and plagiarism including the use of artificial intelligence I mean I think that it's a good addition to our policies I think it's important for um the value of academic honesty to be um sted out and um be put in place especially
023as traditional Notions of integrity and honesty um shift over time with technology advances and um I do like that it focuses on um the positive that we are the expectation and the understanding is that we are operate in the community that values and honesty and behaves in that manner but in the the off chance that here's the understanding of what those expectations are so the definition of plagiarism seems very narrow in that plagiarism is defined as using another person's original ideas or work uh or materials okay it's not as narrow as I thought I didn't read the or truly as an and or I read it as Andor but it's or so with with AI this is a discussion going on right now in II generally which is does the AI tool itself do a
024good enough job citing its sources so there's a dependency on the AI tool itself to tell the user where the information is coming from and so to say that the student has to always figure that out like we're going to have them use this technology I think we have to be very specific yeah about this piece of it because it's not always clear to the student and they could submit a piece of work that they thought was legitimately sourced but they didn't know and they didn't follow through and figure it out yeah or it's just I mean AI pulls from I mean these models run across the entire internet yeah like every piece of content on the internet so but if they're not sourcing something if they've taken an idea or a concept and they're
025not sourcing it within their work right if they say hey I wrote this whole thing myself and they had chat GPT write it yeah absolutely right but if they're providing a source I think the key would be making sure that whatever they've sourced has been at least an honest effort right and I don't know if there is to your point some language that we need to to add about that I mean I don't know that that would live in this policy because that's like that's a that's a literacy skill it's a digital literacy skill one of the things that you know you can expect is if they're using an AI tool they would site that they use the AI tool yeah and that's something that you know is kind of being woven into the instruction
026as we speak yeah and I think you're also saying like you know AI does these hallucinations so if it like AI itself kind of hallucinates a source that you take the AI at its word like where does that live or what you would that do to me that's not plagiarism but agreed with the way this is written you know somebody in a bad mood one day could take this policy and say yeah I just don't I don't want to leave that much room for subjectivity in the interpretation of this with a technology that's developing so quickly that we're still trying to figure out how to implement I I just I think we should try to get tighter on that definition or or at least ask more questions of people who might be able to we
027I guess have the teachers taken a look at this um I I no they so we could yeah I just be curious what their thoughts were because I'm sure that they I mean I know for sure my daughter came home she's like so and so you say hi today and you got a zero I was like good um and so it's definitely happened in the classroom but I think it would be interesting to see what the teacher said about taking something on good faith that a student has cited a source or potentially and this would I mean like this is going a little dark but like knowing that AI is in question and that people aren't necessarily trusting it and kind of using that as a way to manipulate the system as well right and
028say well they know that AI can screw up so I'm just going to make this up and I'm going to put a source in there but it really doesn't have to be legit because they know that AI is sure pulling from random places get it there I don't either do we have are we I don't have the answers just post problems perfect uh yeah may maybe it's maybe it's just def referring to our Definition of artificial intelligence if we're writing a separate policy on AI yeah yeah to say hey if you're using AI within the proper bounds of how we've defined the proper use of AI in that policy all good right because like if you're following the rules that we laid out for you we're not going to yeah what's the behavior we don't
029want we don't want students just offloading all the work on the AI and submitting at their own we do want them to know how to use it to help Define how they think and solve problems and write pieces and be efficient so there's like a balance there and we know what we think is right and not right I just want to make sure that we make the the policy doesn't stop people from doing the things we think are right with AI yeah and I think let's the I think the next policy up is the is the AI policy look that I would love for the department head yeah I'll I'll s this over to to Bob and have to circulate it among the ILS and just get some comments I got tangential question relating to
030um number cheating is defined as a number three is obtaining test questions and or copies of tests do we have is there do we reuse tests at the high school and is when outside tutoring agencies get hold of them is there not a better way we could not reuse tests you know I um I would defer to our ILS on that question and this has been um I think a concern and a question certainly you know we've had some specific conversations with some members in the science department who um you know reported that you know a year or so ago because were screenshotting taking pictures of some of the tests and sharing with some of the local tutoring and then you know they were using them so well if there's multiple classes of the same
031course yeah right if there's a morning and afternoon well the teachers have multiple versions of tests do you want to some of those prac yes have ABC and D ab and D each class gets two different versions so the person near them doesn't have the same test um I rewrite tests every year I do use some old problems and we all do because it's just impossible the issue with the other schools having the tests or other tutoring places having the test are very specifically AP exams because they get from the a people and there's a limited amount of questions that you can ask and that's that's what's that's tough yeah I think that it's like important so that um that a child or student knows that if they take the picture and share it with
032the tutoring agency that's considered cheating even if they didn't if grade didn't actually benefit from that practice so I think that that's kind of an important we should spell out in the I think I mean so so taking or benefit you know so it's you don't the benefit might not be directly in your test taking but it's creating a cheating environment within the within your class yeah well if you take a picture with your phone you're you can't do that anymore you're break another rules solve that problem solve that problem so you take it with your and you know the spirit of that right is help it's not to to punish students but to um reinforce the the good values and the high expectations that we have for them to be the best the best
033versions of themselves all right so this one will come back so I'll get staff across the way and the next one um is the um yep the generative AI draft policy so here too so this is this is a new policy um and you know this was one we've been kind of looking at and talking about for a year and a half and you know just kind of personally you know I when I started looking at I thought yeah we really need an AI policy and thought are we ready to have an AI policy and you know kind of you know turn back and said we do need to have an AI policy but what do we want the policy to do um and so this policy really does two things one it recognizes the
034potential of AI Patrick to your point about uh you know this being a potentially really strong learning tool um you know recognizes that it's it's changing we don't really fully kind of know the potential um but that's the first thing the the second thing this does is um kind of formally establish a district AI task force that is going to be responsible for a number of things you know one kind of engaging conversation about Ai and just you know deepening you know our understanding of you of what it is and how it's changing and how it can serve us um to recommend you know policy updates um around generative AI um to establish um some guidelines for use for both students and staff um to um provide Prof Prof development support for staff and for
035students as we're all learning how to use these tools um and then to ensure accessibility to promote the usern way that supports inclusive learning so we have an AI task force kind of in place um and it's been doing some of these things but this kind of formal Direction setting is this all your own work or is this some shipment language yeah it's um I think it's some Shipman some Fran some some me um some others um the when the the AI committee had met last year one of their topics over the course of that year was um if there's a policy what should be in it and so that group did generate some policy recommendations um I think you know some of the recommendations some of the language out here I also looked at
036C no and I think that it's good that it cross references you know responsible use policies and student privacy probably add a cross reference back to the ademic honesty piece so they're um LinkedIn together so that's one any there no other questions just you got kind of mull it and put we definitely need one the uh next um policy on the list is proposed draft for advanced courses and challenging so this is an example of a policy that's catching up with practice um the intent of this policy is to ensure that students have access to challenging curriculum and advanced classes um we have a wellestablished process of reviewing student progress and making course recommendations uh we also have a very robust and growing catalog of H and advanced placement and um ECE type courses um
037and then we provide some initial course um planning through the flight classes and all the Freshman participated um I was curious to know kind of just today what percentage of our student body here at high school is taken at least is enrolled right now in one honors AP or EC type class um and so grade nine it's 43% you know makes sense most of those kids are in one of the honor sence classes are Humanities um grade 10 it's 64% grade 11 75 and grade 12 it's 84% so you know I think that makes perfect sense if you look across the trajectory of most kids careers in this High School um so I think the numbers are good so I think we're meeting the spirit of that policy something that I think would be a
038good conversation to have with faculty with Administration is you know should that 12th grade number be closer to 100% right and you know that's more of a philosophical question than anything um but if most kids are going to college do we want them to have some assured College type experience so I think there'd be a lot of perspectives on that question so Kevin those stats you just read were percentage of students that are enrolled in a advanced or challenging curriculum course right and so that would be for me an honors class uh a class designated as an honor class or something beyond the pr track um an AP class or EC class right so anything that's I don't think I'm missing any general category am I missing in yeah that's it right that's the% a
039really impressive number Yeah Yeah by 12th grade I mean most most kids and you know and I just asked for like one you know and I think the reality is most kids take you know multiple multiple ones yeah and I just I share those you know so there's not a problem here no we want to just you know have a mhm the policy catch up with the practice yeah anything maybe we need more yeah no I think then having a reference point I'd be curious not at some point in time to know so that we talked about philosophically and 43% of the nth like what Beyond just your core academic classes that you can be enrolled in like that Hors level what are the general opportunities for like if you're in ninth grade you're not
040really looking at AP or EC so it's just kind of your core academic correct yeah I think the I have to double check this but I thought like the AP research class might have been one that was up in the freshman confused by that not Tred um yeah I mean generally generally most of them have prerequisites that's right okay so generally you know by sophomore year I think there's the catalog has expanded a little bit for sophomores with specific regard to AP courses but generally have access to the line share of either AP or EC classes we move on to our um possible action items with our discussion and approval um there are both um related to the prohibition sex discrimination and sexual harassment under Title Nine one is for students and one is for
041personel in the work places so just an update um ear this week we all got an email from a parent who notified us that she was a member of moms at Liberty and had children both at the middle school high school so I consulted with our attorney about that there was any impact here on kind of your decision tonight um and so what she shared was that um the injunctions apply to schools attended by the children of current and prospective members of moms of Liberty young Americas Foundation female athletes United um the organizations are supposed to update the list of schools attended by their members and then file those updated lists with the court um the last update occurred in late November and as of that um as we already know C andris were on
042the list but um the high school nor Middlebrook were yet included um so her recommendation was that we perceive as planned um you know I recommend that you adopt the new policies we um as plan continue to retain the 2020 policies and then if we receive a title nine complaint at either the middle school or high school and the court lists have been updated to include middleberg and the high school we would just apply the policies that's not confusing not confusing so are there any questions on um that new additional piece or um the policy itself so we're approving the go forward policies yeah and I revised um I cleaned up the language and the other so it's but you know you have the the pre yeah these actually you know so this so I
043want to we need to um just correct this because we're updating right so now we're GNA have two sets thank you Lori for that so it's you have 51444 and B so we need so it's for actual so it's four four I'm sorry I didn't catch that when I was looking at this agenda last week so I apologize it's the four that I presented to you the last time right so um the motion would be to improve um kind of in the first item here 54544 and 54 5.44 and same for the and the reasons why we have two new because the regulations changed or were updated yeah so in um April of this year the Biden Administration prated um new title N9 rules they were effective as an August 1 and because of the
044lawsuits were maintaining um any other additional discussion on this if not can I have a motion to approve policy 5145 44 and policy 51 14544 B prohibition of sex discrimination and sexual harassment Title 9 students thank you heather is there a second Thank you Pam all in favor motion carries unanimously and then if I could have a motion to approve policy 411 18113 and policy 13B prohibition of sex discrimination and sexual harassment in the workplace Title 9 Personnel so move thank you Patrick is there a second thank you Nicola all in favor motion carries unanimously moving on to uh um future business and information items there's an updated enrollment report attached to um the agenda in addition the next Board of Education meeting will be on January 9th at 7 o'clock Dr Smith will present
045the um budget of that meeting so it's G to be riveting and um and then the three meetings scheduled after that are Boe workshops that'll be taking place on January 16th 23rd and the 30th at 6:00 in the evening is there any other public comments hearing none um somebody have a watch yes I don't put my phone 7:46 7:46 meeting is adjourned thank you have a great holiday no