001good evening as chairperson of the Hartford board of education I hereby call to order the December 17th 2024 regular meeting I wish to extend a warm welcome to everyone present and our television viewers the board superintendent and I are pleased to have you join us as we celebrate achievement review information and make policy decisions related to the effective operations of the Hartford Public Schools this is a regular meeting and all items that will be discussed or voted on this evening have been posted as required by law as the Hartford board of education we are here to set goals listen to the reports of the superintendent approve budgets contracts and Personnel appointments make policy for the district we are not here to make management decisions or solve the problems of individuals management is the responsibility of
002the superintendent the monthly meetings of the board are open to the public they are a time when the board conducts its business of governing the school system in a public Arena the regular meetings are not meetings with the public therefore comments from the audience will be confined to the time designated for the public to address the board theorum and courtesy are important elements in effective public meeting please silence your cell phones or communication devices and refrain from talking while others are speaking since it is legally mandated that proceedings be accurately recorded I may have to ask for order periodically should noise begin to interfere with our recording capabilities I am pleased that you have taken time to join us this evening we are very proud of the school system and thank you for your interest
003in the Harford Public Schools this will now be read in Spanish Harford Harford harf IND El [Music] thank you uh before we get to public comment we have some um groups to celebrate tonight so I'm going to turn it over to Dr Torres Rodriguez thank you uh chairperson henal good evening everyone um do want to begin with celebration um the Connecticut State Department of Education uses accountability uh measures to uh look at the success of schools and districts in achieving their goals focusing on educational outcomes and performance across multiple indicators um the accountability purpose is to measure school and District success toward goals tiered uh system of resources and supports available to schools based on those accountability scores Provide support for schools with lower performance uh provide recognition for schools with high performance and or
004growth monitor the performance of high need students provides public access to compare schools and districts on 12 key common indicators and also to satisfy state and federal requirements and so tonight we are here to uh acknowledge uh and celebrate some of our schools and I will um name the school and the specific area that um for the recognition we are very proud of all of the hard work that everyone has done everyone that is here tonight and of course our Educators um our support staff our students and our families and so I will begin and you know don't be shy about celebrating um the success I'll begin with uh Renzulli academy uh the first Hartford school to achieve category one status that is an accountability index an accountability index greater than 85 points this is
005the first Hartford school to excel all ultimate Targets in for ELA math science performance um indices all students and all high need students it's identified by the State Department of Education as a school of Distinction for high performance and high growth in math for all students and for high need students achieving 80% or more um for all students a highe students in math and the average percent Target achieved more than 20% Point uh Improvement in highe students in math uh outperformed pre-pandemic accountability index by more than 10 points with greatest areas of improvement occurring in math chronic absenteeism and physical fitness um and one of 10 schools in the state with that uh recognition so I know that tonight we have uh assistant principal white former assistant principal crra uh Mr Ruiz miss chinii and
006miss clap is here uh if you can come up we have a a a certificate yes Miss calderan come join I would like to but might be hard I would like to do a picture at the end next we'll call up Banis learning lab Magnet School recovered Category 2 status for the first time since 201617 with an accountability index greater than 70 points outperformed pre-pandemic accountability index by more than 5% uh Five Points with greatest areas of improvement occurring in ela uh lost links and chronic absenteeism principal darbin Patel is [Applause] here montor magnet at Annie fiser uh achieved category two status for the first time you can clap for the first time with an accountability index greater than 70 points just nearly reached pre-pandemic accountability index with greatest areas of improvement occurring in math
007and chronic absenteeism principal Noel McDonald and AAP barovsky are here [Applause] next we have rosson Elementary the school with the greatest accountability index Improvement of 14.4 from 2022 23 to 2023 24 outperformed pre-pandemic accountability index by more than the 10 points with greatest improvements occurring in ela and math and principal edaron is here tonight yes [Applause] Expeditionary Learning Academy are our friends here yes improve the accountability index by more than 10 points with the greatest Improvement occurring in ela math and physical fitness principal Cobb is here good to see you twice in a week it's a great school visit earlier this week or no La was that last week last week Mr principal cop last week already Annie Fisher stem uh we're going to congratulate Annie Fisher stem improved accountability index nearly 10 points with
008the greatest Improvement occurring in math and chronic absenteeism and we have several uh team members here today principal Wilson Ruff uh assistant principal Barco uh Miss Cullen Miss Ramos Mr blanchfield Miss McKenna Miss Williams and Miss barnabi because like they are a team This Is How They Roll all the time I'm so proud of all of you standing strong [Applause] we have some neighborhood schools in the house as well uh canelli uh improved accountability index by more than five points with the greatest Improvement occurring in math and physics Fitness principal kahill is here and the assistant principal Schulman and assistant principal Aragon are here congratulations team we have Dwight Bizzy as well a dual language outperformed pre-pandemic accountability index by more than five points with greatest Improvement occurring in last links oral um average percent
009Target achieved and in chronic absenteeism and principal dava is here I believe [Applause] yes monor at bacheler montor Magnet at bacheler they exited Focus School identification due to substantial progress in high need students Ela and outperformed pre-pandemic accountability index due to improvements in ela and last links literacy principal fure mccon is here and assistant principal suril are here yes no maybe not yet okay classical magnet exited Focus School identif ification due to substantial progress in high KNE students math average percent Target achieved outperformed pre-pandemic accountability index by more than five per five points due to improvements in ela math physical fitness and access to Advanced coursework principal Sullivan is here our friends and colleagues from Naylor the team at Naylor achieved highest accountability index for our neighborhood schools outperform pre-pandemic accountability index with greatest Improvement
010occurring in ela and last links literacy lowest all student and high knee student chronic absenteeism rates among our neighborhood schools and our assistant principal uh Miss Cecilia is herei and be yes come on over Behavior you wish wish Maria Sanchez Elementary the team at Sanchez outperformed prepandemic accountability index with the greatest Improvement occurring in chronic absenteeism and physical uh Fitness winess and principal Overton and Miss oh yes this is a this is a dynamic du all the time [Applause] congratulations we have two more wish Elementary outperformed prepandemic accountability index with the greatest Improvement occurring in physical fitness and life links literacy principal Ryan and oh an assistant oh okay go ahead social worker yes conat and last but certainly not least University High School of Science and Engineering reaching an accountability index of 70 or
011higher which is where the state says the bar is and so uhss has has set the bar yeah thank you principal Tomy yeah can I that's rightone ofu happens without [Applause] people chair president hucking Hall thank you um thank you everyone for the opportunity to recognize the the hard work that everyone is doing we at har for public school know that we have a long ways to go in making sure that each and every one of our students has access to high quality learning experiences and when we have any opportunity to celebrate the hard work that is happening across all of our schools we will take time to do that while staying focused on continuously improving our work so thank you everyone and come on my yeah but I was like I don't want no
012painting a but parents coming thank you a wi going to definitely thank goodness all right everybody smush together a little more if you can this is awesome everybody over here we got you all this is amazing all right congratulations thank you so much oh e all right thank you all again and congratulations to all of those schools who have improved so great to see you all tonight that was wonderful thank you so much all right we will now move on to public comment Mr Mills this is not as exciting as all those Awards we as a board in collaboration with the superintendent and District leadership are committed to cultivating a culture of excellent at all levels of HPS we thank you for taking the time to attend tonight's board meeting we appreciate you coming out
013to learn more about Hartford Public Schools and for sharing your thoughts and concerns we have established a protocol to track and respond to concerns raised we want you to know that we take your concerns seriously and to that end staff will follow up within 48 hours if followup is required via the preferred method of contact the speaker has indicated on the signin sheet we will follow this no contact method of followup for the time being inhering to safety protocols as a reminder you have 3 minutes to speak and at the two-minute Mark the bell will ring letting you know that you have one minute left at the second Bell please wrap up your comments now this will be read in Spanish by Christina because mine is bad thank you harf [Music] in for our first
014speaker is Alisha Ortiz hello my name is Katherine Haley I will be assisting Miss Ortiz also I am the next person to speak so I will be giving her my time if it makes it easier for you to set the timer for five minutes but it's up to you to start oh you have to hit the thing um hi my name is Alish artiz um and I'm a former Crow of harer hi um Dr Tores um do you remember the letter you wrote to me um you told me that we have similar goals to grow up and change heart for schools for the better this in Inspire my dream of becoming a superintendent just like you you show me that a kid from that kid from Puerto Rico who graduated from Harford public high school
015could make a change just like you I want to fight for that little girl who was forgotten but the system but have you fulfilled that same promise to me Dr Torres you boo about the value of seeing something and saying something but instead of encouraging communication you all establish a few of it I know this because you hide behind simpy in call it accountability I wish I could say I was a proud CED cried of Harford Public Schools but I consider myself more as a Survivor my chance at the successful future was supposed to be my right but instead you made it ATS and that should be illegal everything my age wants to be independent to make choices for themsel unfortunately choices were made for me and they weren't in my best interest every Milestone
016I'm supposed to have is now a struggle I cannot read rooll science how am I supposed to get my driver's lesson textas speech shouldn't be the only way I can express myself how am I supposed to get my first job my eighth grade in high school graduation should have been about me but they were more like performance to make the B the or look good before I started High School my principal forced me to remember a book by ear this was so I could make it look like I was improving in front of the special director in my mom it was not my ability to read that made my mom tear up with pride it was my good memory I was a nice student I was an actor the spotlight made me feel like I
017was worth something but it wasn't a reality the role I played was an Open Secret every professional including the chief of school knew that I could not read that book instead of helping me I was L on by empty promises this performing followed me through high school in two days before graduation I was told to accept that I would never learn to read or write on my own that I can walk the stage but never receive my diploma even though I give my childhood in my teenager years for with our mercy and not a chice was going to be made for me and with my whole body I rejected that imagine re realizing that the people who were supposed to lift you up who were supposed to bring out the best than you were actually
018the people who humiliated you and made you think of yourself in the worst way possible imagine having nightm where you are a powerless power powerless child conolly drowning in the sea of adults that ignore your cries for help I Liv this nightmare where I was awake and asleep this nightmare destroyed my mental health and physical health my panic attacks made me feel like I was burning alive I couldn't eat I lost weight losing more of myself for 12 years I felt useless and invisible this made me believe that I was I was better off death if I end up taking my life then it will only be a reminder of your faure to give me a chance I want to make it very clear that I'm not here for you I'm not here to perform
019for you I'm not here as that ectric girl who somehow made it through high school I'm here as a human being I'm here for the kids who suffer and continue to suffer just like me I believe in a future where each to will leave har for public high school where a stories have success a story that will show the entire state that being from the C is something to be proud of the love that I have for my city goes beyond everything you have put me through and now as a college student I am more than determined to fix what you have broken thank you [Applause] ra good evening Dr Torres and good evening board of directors and G ladies and gentlemen I'm actually here I'm happy that um ruli Academy staff was here and
020I want to read what my sentiments are saying about their [Music] performance um ruli is recognized finally as a tier one school staff and I wanted to congratulate it and the and the recognition your your your recognition is is a statement that the skills in the dedication and unwavering commitment that they had done the dedication to being the best in the field has paid off and I am so happy that there they are finally getting the recognition that they deserve um they earned this with a tremendous effort behind it the the the same have not been unrecognized the cheers to your success and look forward to future success I am telling to ruli academ me I have been working there nearly eight years and I just wanted to tell the public and to the board
021and to Dr tus I guess one of the reasons that they succeed is uh the stuff are happy because the head supports them and um that really help everyone is happy when the when the staff is Happy the children are happy and they still continue to be happy um Dr I mean Miss sieri she worked there for a long time with me until August 2024 she did a lot of effort then we have a new principal right now she's also very good and I'm I'm sure that they still going to keep this success and I just wanted to tell you that the children are very happy that they were finally recognized de one so the best wishes to all RI staff and kindly sincerely from my heart from the bottom of my heart Thank You
022Caroline Dow hi um hi my name is Caroline Dow I'm um a proud teacher at esm here in Hartford excuse me and I'm also a member of Educators for excellence Heartford division as well as their national teacher Leadership Council um the information I'm about to share with you has already been emailed to the board liaison and has been presented to the superintendent the mayor's office and the Blue Ribbon commission leadership um so this fall Educators for excellence work to survey over 300 Hartford teachers across nearly 30 different schools um and as we know teachers offer invaluable Frontline insights into student needs and classroom realities and over the past three months teachers throughout Hartford have identified three top strategic planning uh priorities the first being teacher Recruitment and Retention the second being high quality teaching and
023learning and the third being student social emotional and mental well-being of these top priorities um the number one by far uh is a m vast majority of teachers identified um um was teacher Recruitment and Retention they also teachers also identified three top desired priority shifts the first being P providing additional annual pay for teachers and hardto staff schools and subjects to address vacancies the second being to provide additional pay for highly effective teachers to retain them in their schools and in the district and the third being to better align professional learning to curriculum and to teachers needs um teachers are aware of the district's financial situation we know that ideally all teachers should make more money um however through our focus groups and data collection it's clear that the most most pressing vacancies are among
024special education teachers these shortages impact the entire districts both schools students teachers Etc as Hartford spearheads their strategic plan we must listen to Educators and give them everything they need to address our students throughout Hartford successfully so I thank you for your time today and look forward to working with you guys in the future thank you [Applause] Mike saly I know you're all getting used to seeing me um um but obviously you know that I come before you I speak about my school I'm proud of my school um that's why I'm happy that um the last speaker had mentioned about listening to your teachers okay so uh last month I talked about the ssos and how I felt they were being treated um this week I'm this time I'm going to focus on the fact
025the shortage that we have on our BTS right so we're supposed to have four be Behavior Techs in our school I know that I have a behavior Tech here from a different school um I don't have to tell you guys about the work that they do um but they're obviously very integral to how schools function about leting the load on teachers um and also administrators as well we're short two we're supposed to have four okay we had one through otm I don't know how people have explain to me I've heard it a couple times but we had hired a BT for Harford high and he he was given another another job as a College and Career specialist at New Visions so he worked in our school for 2 days and then decided I'm going to
026go with the other offer so I'm still confused on how that's a thing how we can within the same school district be able to be offered two positions okay so that really hurt us because that was filling a vacancy for a BT who had left and she didn't leave because she wanted to get out of there she left there because she had gotten a degree and she wanted to do something with that degree so now we have two BTS one is on the third floor with the freshman and we have one person working for the sophomores Juniors and seniors that's not Equitable okay I remember all last year of hearing about Equitable budgets and being Equitable be behind our schools but I can assure you that is not equable for our students our staff and
027our BTS because those BTS are doing a lot of doing a lot of work and I have to figure out what is it is it essential for me to call the BT to come to my room for a situation if I think it's minor I shouldn't be put in that situation because I'm thinking about how much work my be Behavior Tech is doing so what I urge you is I want otm to definitely work to get this solved because we have a behavior Tech who's supposed to be starting I want to make sure he lasts I want to make sure that he's not being offered another job within the district I want to make sure that our school has consistent presence in there with behavior techs because we're short security we're short sces let's fill
028the vacancy that we have for the behavior Tech Two Behavior Tech positions because one I forgot to mention is on medical leave so I hope you take this plea from a teacher and realize that this is an issue that needs to be solved now Robert yazo my name is Robert yazo seventh grade science teacher I'm here on behalf of mcdunn Middle School to discuss our partnership with terer and Flynn my first year teaching I was dapped as a teacher and felt lost not sure what to do teer and Flynn joined us and walked me through ways to improve as a teacher and helped me with classroom management and data collection I believe if I didn't have teer and Flynn supporting me I would have drowned my first year as a teacher because College doesn't really
029prepare us for the classroom I've had a pleasure to work with them for three more years since my first year working with them I feel more and more confident as a teacher every day I work with them tein Flyn has helped our school grow in our data collection they sit in our meetings and help us generate ideas for student work analysis protocols lesson plan analysis protocols and our plan due study act protocol or pdsa models which positively affect our inst instructional schoolwide working with them we've completed massive amounts of data collection on each student to help create intervention plans and better support our students we've worked with them with doing the hands up protocol to help identify students that may need support in social emotional Behavioral or academic needs so I please hope that you
030guys continue our partnership with them thank you [Applause] Carol Gail good evening members of the board and superintendent of schools my name is Carol Gail I am a Harford resident teacher and president of the Harford Federation of teachers the union and the board recently made a tentative agreement on a new teachers's contract that agreement is on your agenda this evening seeking your approval and I am here representing hft to strongly urge you to approve that agreement such that it can be signed by the union and the board as the new contract for 2025 to 2028 the agreement you will review represents almost two years worth of preparation by dozens of union members and 3 months mons of active negotiations between the parties the union presented many proposals with the goal of strengthening the existing contract
031to better recruit and retain teachers in Hartford our negotiation team consisted of 15 members representing a diverse cross-section of positions grade levels magnet and district schools and experience in the field of Education Additionally the parties agreed on ground rules that allowed for up to 10 observers from each side to attend 10 negotiation sessions over 20 hft members signed up to be observers and each negotiation meeting was attended by an average of 8 to 10 observers we believe this high level of involvement from our members both in the planning and preparation stage as well as the active negotiation phase led to better proposals and increased buy in for the final agreement hft is very pleased and proud to report that that the tentative agreement was ratified on December 2nd 2024 by 98% that's huge tonight you
032will review all the changes that are in that agreement I would like to highlight a few that strengthen the contract towards the goal of better Recruitment and Retention one a 15% salary increase over 3 years this increase reduces the gap between Hartford and surrounding towns that was making it rather easy for certified staff to leave Hartford for higher paying districts it also helps make up for three years of salary freezes our members accepted between 2017 and 2019 and that had never been adjusted for in previous contract negotiations it also stands as an acknowledgement for our hardw working and dedicated staff who deserve adequate compensation number two the school day is shortened by 30 minutes this is also huge it's a huge step towards improved working conditions the longer day in hardford did increase the stress
033and fatigue for both staff and students and was the longest school day in Greater Hartford also causing staff to leave for Less work and more pay in other districts number three an attendance incentive allows staff who take five or less sick days to choose ,000 incentive instead of ACR the five days number four a longevity incentive provides a $1,000 bonus in appreciation of Staff who have worked for Hartford for 25 or more years and number five a preference for Hartford graduates in the hiring process and a $2,500 sign on bonus this can potentially help recruit more teachers of color to Hartford as well as improve the teacher pipeline to bring our students from our class rooms to our colleagues although the contract alone cannot solve the Recruitment and Retention problems in Hartford this agreement at
034least begins to address a few of the issues that have certainly contributed to the problem hft remains committed to working with the district to further improve teacher retention and recruitment education is changing and we must keep up with these changes hft thanks all the neg negotiators on both sides for their hard work and expects to see the board approve this contract later this evening thank you Richard the May hi Richard De May educator in Hartford good evening Hartford board of education superintendent and Hartwood community of families and children I come before you today to introduce a transformative proposal the Hartford teachers advisory Council or htac for short this initiative is a groundbreaking step towards aligning the critical decisions made by this board with the lived realities of our classrooms this proposal was developed with the
035input from more than 200 Educators from across the district starting in 2022 and was put in the hands of the Board of Ed members in April of last year 2023 and was then poo pooed and dismissed by members of the then regur Le school board and a few board members are still dismissing it today let me be super clear htac is not an attempt to undermine the authority of this board it is instead a collaborative tool a bridge to ensure the board's decisions are better informed Equitable and rooted in the expertise of those who dedicate their lives to teaching hartford's children htac as a council would be composed of teachers as Frontline experts who bring daily nuanced insights into the challenges and successes of hartford's classrooms it would serve solely in an advisory capacity complimenting
036the Hartford board of ed Authority with indispensable perspectives on teaching and learning this is not about giving teachers voting power on this board far from that instead htec would offer realtime classroom data and practical insights ensuring policies are not just well-intentioned but that they are in fact effective and sustainable why htac is crucial in this moment right now as I speak hartford's educational landscape faces multiple concerns including ongoing investigations external reviews and at least one pending lawsuit more than ever decisions must be grounded in accurate classroom level information ignoring teacher input when shaping policies is akin to navigating without a compass which would be well-meaning but fraught with avoidable missteps studies consistently show that teacher involvement in policymaking leads to better outcomes for students and to that end htac would number one help align resources
037directly with student needs number two improve the evaluation of contracts and initiatives ensuring the highest return on investment for our children 's education number three and it would enhance communication between this board and classrooms fostering trust and mutual understanding in short htac would make board members smarter in their decision and policymaking what htac is not it is not another bureaucratic layer htac would integrate seamlessly into existing board committee structures nor would it be a platform for advancing self-serving interests teachers primary commitment is and always will be to their students my call to action board members this proposal is not just practical it is an ethical imperative by embracing htac you send a clear message that Hartford values collaboration and respects the expertise of its Educators you ensure that our children's Futures are shaped by decisions
038as informed as they are well meaning let us rise to this moment together with purpose and a shared commitment to our students as Helen Keller wise said alone we can do so little together we can do so much for the sake of hartford's children I urge you to adopt this proposal it is not just the Smart Choice it is the most decent honorable and just choice for the future of our schools and above all the futures of hartford's children thank [Applause] you and our last Speaker John Walton good evening superintendent distinguished board members uh I had some talking points but I was so touched by the Young lady who was a student of Harford and when she spoke we all failed you anybody who's been in Harford for a long period of time our Educators
039no matter if you're in operations or academic so we all failed this young lady and to Harr the community leaders will fail you what you need to judge us on is our character behavior and investment uh to Governor Lamont you cannot afford to have a failing Harford Public School System just can't do that and it be the capital city so we have to begin building from the structure up too long we have had a model of building from a roof down and that never works if you ask any engineer who does any building they never build the roof first they always build from the foundation up and we've been building from the roof down and that's why we've been so topheavy and that's why all our spending has been so bad mayor aronin you have
040got to invest more into the city workers which 80% of my union are City residents and they work for the Harvard public school so when you invest in them you begin to build the tax base and the people that can help this city move away from the deficit not in just education but in other areas as well Harford Community we've got to start educating ourselves on these processes we've got to be informed of how this all works because this is a system that has been failing us for a very long time let's just be honest about it and I go into my meetings and I have meetings with your cabinet members uh superintendent and one of the things that they start the meeting off is intentions and we should all assume that intentions are good
041well that would be okay if actions follow good intentions but when we went to our last contract negotiation and I hate to talk about ourselves but again 80% of my membership live here so they're the stakeholders that this board represents when we went into that contract negotiation we started off at zeros and that's how people felt about or at least leadership felt about the stakeholders of this community zeros let's give the lunch ladies zeros let's give the custodians zeros let's give the Tradesmen zeros all the people who help provide a health and safety help and Safe Community for our kids to come into school let's just give them zeros because they're not worth anything that's what we're saying to the parents so it's it it leads to a child of this community that we failed
042because we're failing their parents because we don't think of them as anybody is because they just work in operations and if that's the type of leadership and the type of model that we're going to build on then we're going to continuously be at this table having these same old discussions we've got to get to a point where we recognize that the people who help us no matter what they do are just as important as everyone with a title and until we start doing that we're going going to continuously fail that young lady back there who I have a daughter who's in college who's her age so I really feel for her and I hope we don't fail mines um but that's what we're going to do if we keep continuously taking all of our resources
043and giving it to people who hold titles and not investing in the people who actually live in this community that we serve so I'm I will say this about this board I'm happy that we did restart the leg legislative committee I would love to see not only bringing back the student board members so that they can be a part of this process and be educated in this process and their parents be educated in the process because until we learn to start governing ourselves in this community we will be taking advantage of Harford Community so we've got to do a better job I'll give you a little secret that's happening it's not secret cuz it's out in your facilities Department right now all of our Tradesmen have left we basically have one Tradesman per trade and
044the ones that are left are getting ready to leave because they're going to places in the private sector and other school districts that pay better and we continue to have a model where we're advertising jobs for management and supervision but to supervise who and as long as we had that model and we don't restructure and say all right let's do away with all of these layers of management and get directors to communicate to the superintendent who then can communicate to a supervisor who then can get it to the direct ground workor and start restructuring our money to go can you imagine we have 30 vehicles or over 30 vehicles in our Fleet Fleet and we have our our our our Fleet worked on by a company that's outside of the city that charges upwards of
045$800 for a simple toe imagine when our electricians who we won't have any and we're down to one imagine I just went and got a socket done at my house 287 bucks for just a socket so homeowners think about that hard for taxpayers what do you think they're going to charge us when we no longer can support ourselves and we have to Outsource this again we have to be able to take care of ourselves and the way we take care of ourselves as we begin to prioritize the ground up and stop building from the roof down thank you for your time I wish you guys a happy holiday and I just wanted to give you something to think about thank you and that concludes public comment thank you and thank you to everyone who came
046out for public comment tonight we do appreciate all of your words thank you very much um we are now going to move on to the report of the chair uh first is an update on the Blue Ribbon Commission on education the Blue Ribbon Commission on education held its final scheduled meeting on December 11th a draft report should be received by the commission members for review by early January and available to the public in the coming months I encourage those of you who are interested in learning more to visit the website where you can find the agendas meeting recordings and meeting materials at Hartford BL ribbon. the Strategic plan continues to move forward thank you to everyone who's participated so far from the surveys focus groups and the in-person Gatherings we are grateful for the time
047that you took to provide feedback and your own vision for the future of the schools we as board members continue to meet one-on-one with our Consultants to ensure we are up to speed and to be sure we're also participating in the process process this month the district held two community events with several board meetings and attendance the conversations continue to be engaging and meaningful a special thank you to all of those who have come out to participate and to those facilitating the conversations we continue to be grateful for your time and energy if you haven't already completed the survey but wish to participate you can find the survey and additional information online at Hartford Public schools.org the board convened the legislative and accy task force which has met twice via zoom and which were live
048streamed and recorded the task force spent time learning about the upcoming legislative session legislative and advocacy goals of other agencies supporting education throughout the state and the district schools our next meeting is scheduled for January 7th we look forward to working with towards the collective goal of advocating for the students in Hartford Public Schools the Board of Education hosted an in-person Community office hours event on Saturday December 14th at the park Street Library we look forward to hosting additional events throughout the community in the coming months to give those who are interested in speaking directly with board members in an informal setting a chance to do so we look forward to seeing you at a community event soon the board of education is currently accepting applications for those interested in filling the current vacant elected
049seat if you are interested in joining the board more information can be found online at the Hartford Public Schools website app an must be residents of Hartford a member of the democratic party and cannot be a current staff member at Hartford Public Schools to apply please submit your resume and cover letter or your letter of interest to C Santiago hartfordschools.org no later than January 7th as a reminder you can find the superintendent's report full committee reports student reports all attachments and videos in the meeting's agenda on board docs this month we discussed all contracts that are up for vote tonight at each of the relevant committees as well as high school and postsecondary success at the T teaching and learning committee we discussed a request to rename classical Magnet School the elected board vacancy reviewed
050a graduation policy change related to financial literacy credit requirements and impressed the importance of revisiting the school closing consolidation policy policy only at the policy committee we received an overview of student connectedness to schools Community Partners received presentations on the burns and Buckley School building projects and received reports on the school governance Council Title One and the Welcome Center in the family and Community engagement committee and we reviewed the monthly budget report for period 4 discussed the use of non-aps fund reviewed the fiscal year 2025 excess cost projections related to special education and had an initial discussion about the fiscal year 2026 budget at the finance committee lastly at this month's Workshop meeting we learned about progress monitoring report update and tools as a preview for 2025 and January committee meetings they will include a
051discussion around the possible Hartford teacher advisory committee for the board a presentation from the Hartford promise legislative priority updates strategic plan updates and further 20 F school year 2026 budget discussions amongst other topics all committee and workshop meetings are live streamed as well as viewable after the meeting the YouTube links are saved in each of the meeting's agendas on board docs I highly encourage the community to view the meetings and read the reports when possible if you have any questions or feedback please contact Christina Santiago our board liaison at C Santiago hartfordschools.org we will now move on to the report of the super superintendent Dr Torres Rodriguez thank you um I have a few updates um one is relative to our budget timeline uh we did discuss the preliminary uh budget timeline which is structured
052to ensure collaboration transparency and input from Key stakeholders including of course our Board of Education the community and school teams leading to the board of education's final vote in April so I encourage everyone to review uh the timeline but the key Milestones by month starting um which already started in December which we began um with an overview of the Board of Education finance committee just a overview presentation to the full board as to um the process in January we will begin with our community engagement the first public forum is held together Community input and ensure stakeholder voices are reflected in the process uh also School team engagement where the training will be provided to school teams and sgc's to provide uh to support the development of the school level budgets um the next month in
053February we continue the focus on uh engaging with different groups including a budget discussion with our Union leadership and public forums to gather input and feedback from our community and then submitting um their uh schools then submit their first budget draft for review after receiving the training and as we move into early spring uh March is focused on feedback provided to schools so they can begin to finalize their budgets ensuring alignment with what our district goals and priorities are and a final draft budget is shared with the board's finance committee for review and we then do additional forums um so that we can address any potential questions and Foster additional dialogue and Community with our Community Partners and then ideally in April mid April uh the final public forum and then the board of education's
054budget vote again this is a preliminary timeline um knowing that we have to have a parallel of our strategic planning priorities that you all will ultimately see and um approve and then you know trying to embed and align any recommendations from the Blue Ribbon commission um and any feedback that we get from the State Department of Education inquiries um that they are also uh engaging in my other uh report is relative to Chronic absenteeism and just giving um an update as to um some of the work that is happening we continue to focus on uh chronic absenteeism I will highlight that um our home visits continue and thus far 2400 home visits have been logged uh so far this year with focus in the fall months um on building awareness and engaging with families around
055why it is important for our students to attend schools uh regularly um and lastly I will um just give a a a gratitude uh message to everyone that is uh participating in our advisory groups which uh launched uh in this last week and this week um specifically this week uh we launched the school leader advisory committee which enables Educators to uh collaborate our leaders uh to collaborate provide feedback to improve teaching and learning this one is specifically focused on fostering collaboration addressing challenges and cont uh contributing to continuous Improvement in teaching and learning across uh the schools we also have our teacher educator ad advisory committee uh providing a platform for educators to share their perspectives offer feedback and engage in meaningful dialogue with uh District leadership and then our caregiver engagement panel which is
056a caregiver group dedicating also to increasing caregiver engagement and also amplifying diverse voices and fostering collaborative dialogue and so all of our committees including the superintendent advisory committee um and the other committees that will um that have launched will at one point or another also contribute to for example the development of the budget recommendations that are made relative to policy um and any new initiatives um that we are um engaging in and so just wanted to congratulate and thank everyone from from across our schools that are part of those advisory committees this concludes my report thank you superintendent um we will now move on to our business agenda so item 4.1 administrative appointment Chief Operating Officer motion that the Hartford board of education approved the superintendent's recommendation to appoint Jose cologne to the position of
057Chief Operating Officer do I have a motion thank you a second second thank you uh superintendent yes I'll do a a quick voice over uh um relative to the position actually and also um Mr cologne um just relative to an overview of the position of the Chief Operating Officer um it is a position that is focusing is a senior leadership role responsible for overseeing operational areas um key responsibilities include uh departmental supervision of it enrollment and school choice facility Food Services and transportation um primary focus um also around uh supporting our multi-year strategic plan uh ensuring that um there is seamless not only integration but communication and collaboration with key groups outside of Harford Public Schools like the regional school choice office um our uh partnering magnet operators and um open Choice districts and of
058course um with other partners throughout um the city of Hartford um relative to Mr colog he is uh a season educational leader with over 25 years of experience in urban education um a proud graduate of Harvard Public Schools his journey um is fueled by a deep commitment to the community that he calls home and the transformative power of Education he holds a bachelor's uh degree from University of Connecticut uh graduate degrees and ADV Advanced certificate certificates from uh in education from Eastern sacred and saart University um he has returned to the district um after being a student and a graduate of Harford Public Schools he returned to the district to serve in a variety of roles including career counselor teacher and administrator of several uh communities in in across our city um throughout his career
059he's demonstrated a commitment to Equitable opportunities and access for students uh the capacities that he administrative capacities have included assistant principal principal executive principal District leader and most recently as an administrator in higher education um he is an advocate for all students uh prioritizing environments where diverse voices are heard and valued um he I know is eager to bring his expertise and experience to the role of the chief operations officer um and is excited to uh work alongside all of us to improve operational efficiency resource allocation and support this the Strategic vision of our district um he some fun facts he is the former executive principal at harfa Public High School uh the school I think when you were initially overseeing was wor four smaller acmy and then um was became one Comprehensive High School
060um has experience across all grade levels prek to 12 well actually prek to 16 if we include his um most recent um experience in higher education and also served neighborhoods and magnet school so I'll pause there that is a an overview of not just the role but also of Mr colum thank you superintendent um any questions or discussion from board members Miss birie I just have a question as to because I'm trying to like who who who will report be a direct report to him from leadership uh the team in it enrollment and school choice facilities uh food service and transportation the directors executive directors in those departments as like an immediate report that I understand your question Miss Bry yes followup Madam chair so there will be some will there be a realignment as
061far as like duties of um current um cabinet members as far as what you just described like Schoo Choice uh yes so currently um Miss uh Chief Davis G um needs to tend to familial um uh familiar balance that is needed for uh Chief Davis gu and so um she will be supporting us in other with other administrative duties thank you any other questions or discussion seeing none the board did have an opportunity oh I'm sorry Mr Walker um yes um um so I had the opportunity to meet with um Mr colom virtually and um Wanted to um review uh his performance as administrator in his previous um time here as a principal executive principal and uh wasn't able to get that executed and wasn't able to get a full picture of his performance and
062so um my comment is I would really like a process that will allow full examination of of candidates to come before us as well as a a complete picture of the realignment that you just um discussed um because I also didn't receive that and did not have that available to me um I will first speak to the realignment question I think I'm going to perhaps go back to the question um uh and it is it is not a realignment um I think it's been uh Miss Brody I hope I I answered your question that the duties and responsibilities of the C the person that is currently in the role of Chief Operating Officer um will uh shift to the new chief of operations um and so I know that you use the word realignment um
063say again I'm clear okay yes I I I under I think I understood your question with um after I tried to color Yes um so there is I just want to clarify that there is no realignment um and um the the management you know has the responsibility to vet um all of our um applicants and candidates um and we have done that and so I'm I'm here before the board to um put forth a recommendation yes so um my my comment to superintendent is then our approval is to to approve that that process was followed that we understand that it's follow if if I can't see it all then it's my my to me my my my vote is is one that doesn't clearly it's it's hard for me to give approval when I can't
064fully see all the steps that were followed I in essence I'm I'm I'm trusting you but that's not the same as me seeing understanding it and having visibility into it thank you any any other followup I just want to say that we did as a board have the opportunity to uh meet with Mr cologne um over two different time per or two different days so we did have the opportunity to talk with him and ask questions of him and also after speaking with several board members it does sound like maybe we should go back and revisit our policy around um how we are approving or you know fetting and those kind of things but for today um we will go forth with the information that we have available and revisit the policy going forward Mr
065Walker yeah so to add clarification to that those sessions to meet Mr cologne was yesterday and it was last Friday and and um and so and meeting someone yesterday it's challenging to fully V make an approval today it certainly hasn't been provide the opportunity for the board to fully um collectively talk among themselves in terms of our feelings about Mr cologne and what he has to offer so um I just want to put the context of what those sessions mean and how much time we had to do this um selection of a very very senior role within the district leadership thank you any other discussion no seeing none um the motion that the Hartford board of education approve the superintendent recommendation to appoint Jose cologne to the position of Chief Operating Officer all those in
066favor signify by saying I I I I uh nay nay abstentions the mo the eyes have it the motion moves item 4.2 contract continuation approval teer and Flynn motion that the Board of Education authorize the superintendent to execute a contract with terer and Flynn for the term outlined in the contract ending June 30th 2025 in an amount not to exceed $25,500 do I have a motion so moved thank you second second thank you uh super yes just a a little uh context the purpose of this agenda item which uh the funding source is special funds Commissioners Network Grant um is a uh continuation of leadership coaching Services uh that have a state approved part of the commissioner's Network plans for developing systems structures and core leadership practice that leads to improved instructional practices both both
067at MCD middle and harfa public high school this is work that has been going on for the last two years um they um they meaning Tupper uh and and Flynn um have worked with the schools on three areas instructional leadership team practices formative observation and feedback cycles and then professional learning planning and implementation additionally uh they have collaborated through ongoing work to improve the schedule at these two schools for uh department and grade level teams we know that adults learn best when they work um in collaboration with one another um and so that has been a focus as well as increasing time to review data and discuss areas of student growth connected to both the academic and behavioral outcomes and instructional planning practices and thirdly increasing opportunities for ongoing responsive professional learning for educators um
068as we're trying the team is trying to be responsive to uh more individualized professional learning professional learning needs um I will pause there in case there are additional questions and I know that um we have several team members here from our schools um in addition to our chief of schools Miss Barney thank you superintendent any questions questions or discussions from the board members Miss Brody is terer and Flynn present yes they are can they come forward please we have Patrick [Music] Flynn so my question through you madam chair would just be um because I did not um get a chance to um hear um in committee so I I guess my simple question is how do you make our school district better this year three at McDon middle school and the continuation of the work
069for the Harvard public high we really have three themes that we've been working towards and that is knowing our students uh knowing ourselves and knowing our impact and as U um the superintendent alluded to the focus of our work really is in Three core areas instructional leadership team development bringing voice to teachers and teacher leaders who will bring back to their classrooms the type of instructional practice that's necessary a shared decision-making model that flows through that uh bringing coaches administrators and teachers together to ensure that department level and grade level meetings are functioning so that we dig deeper into knowing our students when you ask how do we improve schools it is through a shared decision- making model collaboration and making sure that teachers feel that they are a part of that leadership process in
070helping to develop a successful School sure and I think to add just to the final point of the real creation of sustainable practices I think is the key when we're talking about something like a commissioner's Network school and so when we create these shared models we're ensuring sustainability beyond our time in those those schools Mr Walker yeah um so to clarify so are you only working with schools within the commissioner Network yes sir okay um so followup question then chair um so does your relationship with the school then end when they out of commissioner network is that how that's going to yes sir okay so third piece I'm sorry so then okay so have you measure how sustainable are is the work is is there some way we measure that that that collaboration is sustained
071beyond the the moment because someone now I'm looking over Beyond you to see can someone from that staff or somebody come and talk about that this work is really sustained and a value beyond that and as they step up I would just suggest that you know the same levels of accountability are applied within the commissioner's Network that would be applied to all of your schools that you celebrated this evening so we are looking to try and ensure that kind of growth within the system um but the commissioner network does have a a set of um assessed criteria that they are looking to achieve and we've gotten tremendous results over the course of the last three years in regards to uh from our initial audit through to our year three now at MCD and our years
072of work with Harford public high so we have seen growth and we can show you that data at any point in time so yes and I think one of the biggest ways to highlight um the sustainability is you heard one of our teachers I'm marre rice I'm the principal at MCD you heard one of our teachers speak this evening earlier about the impact on him at the classroom level and the impact that then had on our students and their accelerating their achievement but also in terms of sustainability it supported us in building out an instructional leadership team that has built enduring practices within our school that we can continue throughout years Beyond being in the commissioner's Network excellent weekend we actually have one of our teachers here who led an instructional leadership team session this
073evening um with our staff um my ADSL was present but that's one way that the the work will be sustainable is that we have been coached to embed these practices in our day-to-day existence within our schools yeah Elvis MinGa the principal at haror public high school um for us in addition to what principal rise was sharing is this year we are a very new um leadership team um so it's really important uh to continue that coaching and build the leaders capacity so we can um again share that ownership with a structural leadership team uh we do have also some new U members of the instruction leadership team as well so um it's through coaching us at leaders and also working leadership team I was going to uh say that because of the work that we've
074been um doing with tempor Fring on the last uh 3 years uh based on the commission's network um audit we were able that um as effectiv of leadership team we are at four which is the highest that you could have got uh through the CN um um the walkthroughs and data collection so um it's it's really important that we continue that partnership uh is vital to our success and to um you know making a difference in in students achievement and a students uh performance um yeah um thank you um and to the the principal right from MCD I yes that was compelling um endorsement from your teacher this evening thank you any other questions oh yeah Mr Mills um so this isn't really about you guys this is more of a budget question so just
075for reference I plan on saying yes regardless but um because this is a special fund like by Contracting with this group we wouldn't be spending money on something that we could otherwise be doing internally right like it's not general fund this is specifically for this type of work correct yes as approved by uh our partners at the state right they have to submit an application and a plan and a budget and so this is fully in alignment and approved by State Department of Education all right thank you Mr Tatum yeah that's a good transition to to my perspective on this um which has been swayed by hearing from from people here today um one of my principles in decision-making as a board member is to prioritize the perspective of the people who would be most
076impacted by the decision and I simply don't have the heart to vote against when a teacher comes up and says that this Pro this has made a difference in in my career in my you know life as a teacher that said I came in tonight prepared to vote no on this contract because um for some uh more highlevel uh ideas about the system that we're operating in and um I think I'm glad that I will be able to set those aside but it will help me set those aside if I say a little bit about why first so yeah this is these types of contracts I think very critically about um and want to be careful in terms of their impact on a school system and I think I'm glad too that I won't wind
077up making an example of this particular contract because I think it does provide excellent services and there is a lot of times value in bringing outside consult in to support School initiatives that said broadly speaking in our education system it seems easy to fun like create funding opportunities for uh hiring Consultants education Consultants to go in and you know provide their services and uh rather than simply increasing school funding so that theed Educators and the school leaders can do what they know they need to do in their buildings um for so for example right the commissioner's network was funded by State Statute or created by State Statute in 2016 and uh provides funding for uh 25 of the like lowest achieving schools in the state uh and creates these funding opportunities that allows these schools
078to jump through a lot of Hoops to to go through an application vetting process to access these funds that let them bring in these Consultants so that was passed by the general assembly in 2016 in this time period the general assembly has not fully funded the Equitable cost sharing formula the general assembly has you know not done what it could do to support these schools directly through funding um and so I I was prepared to vote no on this contract as some way to try to resist this tendency in our education system to think that consultants and outside experts are going to be what creates the change that we need in our school system and with all due respect to your work and and and the expertise that you bring I don't think that's what's
079going to get us a better education system it might improve the experiences of people in the building and that is important and that's ultimately why I am changing my mind uh however I'm looking for ways to resist this trend in our system more broadly this felt like one of them at least I've been able to say it um and sort of put the general assembly on on alert that if creating things like the commissioner Network make you think that you're doing what we need to do to support our highest needs schools you've got another thing coming like we need to really step up uh our direct support through funding to our schools um that's just what uh needs to happen very soon and when you know the state for the last several years have had
080a multi-billion dollar Surplus in the budget it's just unconscionable that we would not get that funding to our underfunded schools that are having budget cuts and budget gaps um yeah that's just got to happen so I've said my piece and I will yield thank you Mr Tatum any other discussion yeah Miss birie just one quick question does anyone outside of the school like on your team is anyone being trained also I don't know that they currently are being trained but in the past I know that um central office or our instructional leaders instructional coaches a central office office I'm thinking back to the time when we were at a Buckley um high school session sure we had that was several years ago I think that was probably close to 2016 that uh that was uh
081my former company revision learning was supporting that process um the work I think in between that at that point and now we have provided other services that wrapped around some of our work at mcdonut and at the high school uh including working with your professional development and evaluation committee to rewrite your evaluation plan so a lot of the same principles and structures and and systems that we work with within the schools we were trying to apply to the new legislation the new process for for educator evaluation so that's an example of a wraparound where we might have helped to support some other work within the district that might be more systemic and more Central if that if that answers your question any other questions followup okay seeing none the motion on the floor is that
082the Hartford board of education authorize the superintendent to execute a contract with terer and Flynn for the term outlined in the contract ending June 30th 2025 in an amount not to exceed $25,500 all those in favor signify by saying I I I I opposed abstentions all right the eyes have it the motion moves thank you thank you uh item 4.3 first reading graduation policy and I'm going to turn this over to the chair of the policy committee Miss Ruth Fortune thank you madam chair changing the policy for the financial literacy graduation policy is necessary due to a new state requirement that all high school graduates starting with the class of 2027 earn a 1 half Credit in personal finance or financial literacy this impacts the current sophomores who are of the class 2027 last year
083the department of teaching and learning spent time examining the best way of meeting this requirement and alignment with existing courses it was decided to integrate the standards in learning in this new requirement with the existing microeconomics course already offered in at least two of our high schools we will structure this as a social studies course requ requirement so microeconomics and personal finance will be added to the social studies course and we're adding a 1 half credit requirement to the required Humanities credits this increases required social studies credits from three credits to three and a half credits and decreases elective Humanities credits from one to 1/ half credit students will have their own students will have their other elective credits through which they can choose to take additional Humanities courses if so desired thank you as
084this is a first reading no vote is required all right we will now move on to the consent agenda items on the consent agenda 5 .2 approval of school construction plans and scg 042 submitt phase 3B FFN Burn School 5.3 approval of school construction plans and scg 042 submitt phase four playground Burn School 5.4 approval of school construction plans and scg 042 submitt phase 8 fne Buckley school I will say that these items were also talked about at the Hartford School building committee earlier or just yesterday so you can find that um on YouTube as well uh 5.5 acceptance of funds Canali school and 5.6 approval of minutes from the November 19th meeting any comments or questions on the consent agenda Mr Tatum just a just a quick comment on the um 5 what is
085it 54 um for any Community watching uh the the sort of big news from the family and Community engagement committee was that the there has been a delay in the construction process and anyone looking for more detailed information about that and the new opening date or new projected opening date for Buckley High School uh would would do well to watch that uh committee meeting the it was the U family and Community engagement committee meeting uh for December thank you any other um hearing no other comments or questions do I have a motion to V vote on the consent agenda so moved second second all those in favor signify by saying I I I I NZ abstentions the eyes have it all right um we'll now move into executive session the for the collective bargaining agreement
086we will be going into executive session to discuss the proposed collective bargaining agreement for the Hartford Federation of teachers do I have a motion to enter the executive session it's a moved second uh all those do I sorry Christina do I say who I'm going to bring in first yes do yes you do okay sorry um we will be taking with us superintendent Torres Rodriguez Deputy Paul Foster attorney Tom Mooney and attorney Lori Miser all those in favor signify by saying I I I I nay abstentions all right the motion passes we will be back thank you [Music] n [Music] n [Music] n [Music] n [Music] n [Music] e [Music] m a [Music] he for [Music] la [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] [Applause] [Music] want four [Music] was [Music] e e e [Music] the [Music]
087e e do I have a motion to exit executive session and reconvene the regular meeting so moved second thank you um all those in favor signify by saying I I I nay abstention the eyes have it item 7.1 proposed collective bargaining agreement the Hartford Federation of teachers local number 1018 AF AFL C IO motion that the Board of Education approves the proposed collective bargaining agreement with the Hartford Federation of teachers local number 1018 AF AFL CIO do I have a motion so moved second all those in favor signify by saying I i n abstentions abstain abstain thank you the eyes haveit thank you for joining us the December 17th Board of Education regular meeting is now adjourned e