001e e e St you you got to when that kind of thing happens you got to go with me what what's going on I mean that's you see the you see the mil Gib podcast so are there any limitations on the questions we can ask other than like you know some personal thing yeah you stay away from health issues Mill anything personal it could be philosophical absolutely you got to ask the same question every time though yeah all right I'd like to call to order the special called meeting work session for January 29th 2025 Mrs Johnson if you call Mr Hill here Mr Daniels here Mr Holbrook here Dr hot here Mr n here Mr FIS here Mr you have a forum you we have a motion to approve the agenda as presented so move
002Mr H Brook do I have a second second a motion by Mr H Brook and a second by Mr Daniel any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed agenda is approved Miss Johnson if you will bring in our first interview just to give some background while Miss Johnson goes to get our first uh interviewee uh we we' set interviews for tonight uh for the District 3 Schoolboard seat uh we're going to ask a series of questions um there were uh a total of 12 applicants uh and we narrowed it down to four to interview and one back out so tonight we're going to have three that we interview uh we're going to be asking a series of questions we're going to do 30 minutes each um each interviewee will come
003in um and then once they've been interviewed they will go back to the back and and uh at the end this board will go into Clos session to go and make a decision and come out and make a motion to appoint all right welcome sir hey how's it going great if you will tell us your name and one thing you want us to remember about you uh my name is Steven Hill and uh I want to remember for this school board uh I'm a new L Academy Forest Middle School JF alumni proud of my time in bford County schools and uh excited to be interviewing with us Mr night good evening hey my question for you is uh I'd like for you to please describe your idea of the best form of government uh I
004mean a constitutional representative democracy is is my ideal of the best form um I would consider myself uh more on the conservative with a Libertarian Ben so the the government that govern governs best governs least so kind of a uh an approach to government to where you are empowering the people that are already there to make those decisions but also empowering the constituency to you know improve the area with themselves without government interference at all possible okay what uh what would be the main thing you want to accomplish on the board my main thing and and I've been following this for years is bford county has a reversion coming up in couple years we've got a we've got a cliff that we're going to come off of and you guys have done a great job
005at preparing for that but you know $7.5 million saved up is great for that first year but it's you know going forward on that um that is you know I am I I'm a residential land developer run with a concrete company um what I do is you know manage multi-million dollar projects and I understand the complexities in in doing budgets like that and understand you know where to you know cut where to raise revenue where to uh to make those issues because I think that's the biggest threat to us if we you know lose almost $8 million and in operating Capital it's gonna have to cut something and if you can make a plan to get that cuts earlier to where you soften the blow that makes it a whole lot easier door it's purpose
006um so what do you feel would be your strengths that you could bring to the board and what may be your weaknesses I gota um my strengths are I am I'm very fiscally conservative very numbers oriented um I am I I joke with my wife my love language is Excel spreadsheets I love a good Excel spreadsheet um and so you know being able to be uh to look at the data look at the information that is provided to to see where we where it's most strategic to make your Cuts where it's strategic to to grow to expand um and how to how to balance all of that with meeting the the public need for providing the service to the public my weakness honestly in a school work capacity is curriculum I'm I've been in the
007business world for a long time I I really understand that portion of it I'm very weak on curriculum my sister is a is a teacher at Forest Middle School and and you know we have those conversations and she loses me entirely when it comes to you know the the education side of things it's probably one of my bigger weaknesses right how are you see doing great I'm CT hubach um what uh what is your overall impression of Bedford County Schools so like I said I went to bford County Public Schools growing up I uh I started in third grade in new L Academy and graduated JF in 2004 um loved my time there loved my time with the teachers there my family is very invested in bford County schools my my mother was a pair
008professional for years my sister is going on her 20th year as a public school teacher at Forest Middle School I when I built my house when I decided on where I wanted to live me and my wife decided to build in bford County so that we can send our kids to bug for kind public schools uh invested in not only is it succeeding for the greater good but on a micro level for my own children uh I've got a I've got a third grader a first grader and a three almost foury old so I'm going be in the school system a long time and so I want to make sure that it is producing the best not only for my children but for for all the children of B County um also as a as
009a land developer I understand the importance of a good school system I understand that if you're wanting to raise revenue if you want to to raise tax value a good school system is the number one selling point when I look at land to to purchase just one of the first things I look at is is how's how's it going to sell and one of the first things is is school system there how you doing doing great man doing doing good um one of the things about this job is is that you try to gather all the information that you can um before you make a decision um you have to understand that when you make a decision it's going to make some people happy and some people not knowing that what what um life and
010work experiences do you have that would help you approach these situations and how would that help you guide your decision making yes um so I as a a land developer um also as a my other job is I I run a concrete company um so those those every day you're having to to make decisions between employees and customers and vendors um you know obviously we're we're all behold into the bottom line but we also want to have great relationships with all of our with everyone that we interact with um and so it is it is balancing that it's balancing um from from the um Land Development side it's balancing governmental forces it's Market forces buers builders that whole that whole gamut there you're trying to always make sure that you're protecting protecting our own self
011but also keeping everybody happy as best you can and sometimes you can do that and sometimes you can't um but focusing on what's most important and what's most important is continuing the uh the job that you start out so uh as an answer to my first question you said that you know small government power to the people representative Republic or democracy is is what you feel is the ideal type of government uh how can you practically and potentially better than others contribute to this form or philosophy of government I got you um like I said District 3 I grew up in I know District 3 I know it well um I also am very open to others opinions I've been in front of this board several time give my own opinion on things and so
012um being able to to I have kids in the school I'm able to to not only know from a um gathering information from constituents but also seeing it on the ground um seeing how the decision that this board makes affects how my kids are at school and how how they are um how they interact with that so I guess my my biggest thing for that type of government representative government is gathering information from constituencies doing what's best understanding there is a a loud minority but also a a p portion that needs to be heard and needs to be um expressed out there even if it is from the loud [Music] myor so this takes takes a lot more time than you would think it does tell you that right now um so do you do
013you feel that you would be able to meet those meet the time requirements and and and yes sir yeah being that you run you know running a business in to and and I've talked with my partners about that and we've we've kind of all all agreed you know see how this works out I I before I even applied for this I talked to Mr Nelms for a good while uh just saying hey what is the time commitment for it because that is that was my first question is hey what's the time commitment here um and going through that speaking with obviously my my most important boss my wife um and determining how that it would affect our family we all kind of agreed that you know this is something that that we think and I
014think Bedford County Schools is important enough to make those sacrifices purpose um how do you feel about Chrome books in the classroom and outside of the classroom a big Hot Topic I I got you I don't know it's a Hot Topic but I I literally I at new L Academy we have something called the Watchdog program so I just spent the day um on Monday in the schools and that was one of the things that I observed I am I'm not anti- techn techology but I also think that there needs to be a limit to it um you know the use of it in the classrooms especially in the elementary school was was relatively minimal um but you know in between in between lessons and stuff like that it was it was used often I'm
015not a huge fan of of at least at the elementary school level where I have the most uh interaction with of of taking them home of you know the more I can get my kids away from technology in the evening the better for me um and so I think that you know Chromebooks have a place technology has a place and the classroom it just has to be has to be limited and has to be not leaned on as a crutch but but used as an advantage all right um you have already told us that you've got some close ties to Bedford County schools because of your experience personally because of family that's on staff uh kids that are in this School conflicts will arise where there are personal interests at stake maybe in opposition to
016what needs to be done how would you handle situation like that um obviously I know a couple years ago we had a um we had a a district rezoning um or a rezoning proposal and I was Vally against it those who on the board probably saw me speak a couple times about that um if something like that arose where it directly conflicted with my personal um with my personal uh viewpoints or opinions uh as far as how it affect me I think the best move is to recuse yourself from those type of decisions um if you've got a conflict of interest the best thing especially in a in a government where you want transparency and in a government where you want um your leaders to uh not act within their own personal interest but for
017the the greater societal good I think you have to recuse yourself in those issues thank you um one of the things here in in the county that I'm sure that you're aware is that our goal is to try to prepare kids for whatever their next step in life is if that's college or career um we have as a board have worked pretty hard on our CTE program can you um just let us know your thoughts on that and if there's any other things you think that we should be doing yeah big fan of the trade schools obviously I'm in concrete I'm in construction so um we have a major lack of skilled Tradesmen out there right now um and it's affecting everything from housing Supply to um I mean repairs and any type of work
018you're trying to do it's I mean all of the the guys I work with have long weight list uh and so I think it's very important to to be offering those educationals offering different types of um of trying to I forgot my word there uh different typee of accreditations um whether it's Plumbing or electrical or Roofing or obviously concrete um and so I think it's very important that we enable the uh the trade school to take more of those students out when I grew up it was you either went to college or nothing I remember teachers telling us that if you didn't go to college you were going to be a failure um and I think you know obviously I went to college I got a Bachelor's degree um I realized that now that I've
019gotten to the to the world and I'm in the construction world I understand you know some of the smartest people I know are you know never finished High School uh and so I think there's a there's a lot of value in empowering those students that Maybe not maybe they're not going down the academic path but they still they have a valuable place in our society and and I think to prepare them for that future is is a great use of our of our County resources there thank you all right um so we've each you guys have each asked two questions with follow-up questions did anybody have third questions or any add additional information that's needed okay all right thank you sir I appreciate it guys thank you thank you I ask you if you had
020additional questions no [Music] I for [Applause] thank you welcome hello thank you thank you for having me absolutely if you will tell us your name and one thing you want us to remember about you okay my name is Dena Jones Thank you for having me here I would like you to remember that I have dedicated not only my career but much of my personal life to education and Community involvement all right good evening um so my question for you is I'd like for you to please describe your idea uh of the best form of government okay thank you um you know I believe that the best form of government um if you are you know speaking at the Schoolboard level um I believe that the best form of government um is a group of leaders
021who listen to their constituents um who understand their role um as wise and discing stewards um and who remember who they are there to serve why they are there to serve um and remain um transparent and um open in all of their um actions in government how you doing hi so what would be the main thing that you would like to accomplish on the board well I think the board does does a great job um I think one area where in my interim role you know though it it be just an interim role I think that there's still a lot that can be accomplished and I think we have some of the best Educators and some of the best teachers anywhere and I would love as you saw in my application to open up additional
022channels or be a part of the people who hear regular feedback from our instructors from our staff members I think we have so many opportunities I think that our staff members and our teachers and our schools are often the very first people who see an issue that may be arising and I believe that in my role I would love to accomplish being someone who listens and who is part of avenues of feedback from the teachers and staff to the board um I've done done that in other community roles and I know that I could do that here so um what do you feel would be your strengths if we appoint you and then also your weaknesses absolutely um one of my strengths is that I have a very interdisciplinary perspective um if you saw my
023application you know that my background is a mixture of I'm trained and I've practiced in clinical mental health I have over a decade as an educator at the University level I have worked in curriculum development I have advised nonprofits on marketing and fundraising and strategic planning so I believe a big strength that I have is that my experience in these different areas can be Blended together and applied here because in an organization like a school board you often need multi-disciplinary Solutions and you often need stakeholders from different areas your businesses and your Educators so I think that I am perfectly poised um to give those Blended perspectives and to pull from my different areas of experience um and then you ask as well um about a weakness um you know I believe that it would
024be great to have um even more K12 experience um on the board I have a decade of course development and professional development and teaching at the University level um I wish I had more hands-on experience in the classroom with our K to 12 students and my plan to overcome that is that I listen to teachers I listen to staff members I am very good at identifying the the people who have had the experiences that I haven't had and listening to and learning from and collaborating with them you know I'm Kurt hubach um wanted to ask you about your overall impression of Bedford County Schools as they are today I think that Bedford County Schools we very intentionally move to this area so I love Bedford County schools and next year I'm going to have one
025student at elementary one student at middle and one student at high school so I feel like that gives me what the parents and the teachers and the administration I'm connected to I get to see a lot of levels um I'm also the president of the um Council PTA so if anyone you know is newer to that term it's just when all the PTA presidents come together from all the Bedford County Public School schools all the principles and PTA presidents come together and I'm the president of that board and that group um so I have seen strengths at all levels and I think that we are a district that sometimes we forget what incredible resources we have because I think we have just incredible Educators um you know I was sitting waiting to come into this
026interview just chatting with other applicants and what was coming up was just talking about some of the incredible teachers that we have so I think that while I look at our district and I see that we have a lot of challenges there are a lot of areas where Solutions are needed I think that we have what it takes and what we need within our people and resources here um good evening uh one of the things about this job that I happens all the time you gather as much information as you can and try to make the best decision that you can ultimately those decisions they impact everybody so some people are going to be very happy with those decisions some people are going to be upset knowing that what work life or work experiences do
027you have that would help you approach those situations and also would help guide your decision- making yeah and you know it's so hard I think everyone in this room knows you know I've read it I've heard it if you want to be a leader you have to be willing to be misunderstood by the people that you're working so hard to help and that you're working so hard for and it's just going to happen no one gets to be in leadership and gets to not have that experience so I have been in leadership at different levels PTA levels nonprofit organizations one experience that really guides me in so many ways a few years ago I was able to head up the event coordination of um events that helped organizations and people um respond to the opioid
028epidemic so if you remember a few years back that was just a huge problem facing everyone um all demographics were being impacted by the opioid epidemic and I got to um work in four different states and be the connecting person between the Department of Health and Human Services um the American Association of Christian counselors which is a local organization and Grassroots organizations in North Carolina um Pennsylvania Virginia and California and we went to these different Grassroots organizations and we brought in private counselors we brought in government resources and we trained firemen police officers teachers on what to do about the opioid epidemic prevention um just noticing when someone might have a problem um stopping the epidemic from spreading further and in that work because I was able you know on one hand I'm working with
029a government organization on one hand I'm working with a priv organization of counselors on the other hand I'm working with the local churches and the fire departments and the people that wanted us to come and being in that role showed me so much how we're coming from different perspectives and we're coming from different backgrounds but so much of the time we all want the same thing and that taught me so much to look for the common ground to remember the purpose to find the unity in why we're here because often if you can get to that usually there are points to connect on and you can kind of work backwards from that shared purpose so as an answer to my first question you you sort of described what you feel like is the ideal government
030in particular for at the Schoolboard level um how do you think that you would practically uh and potentially better than others be able to contribute to that ideal form go yeah I love to talk practical um you know I know that you probably saw in my application that I'm an adviser for nonprofits and I don't want to come off as if I'm just theoretical or if I'm just an advocate because I like to be a person who physically gets work done who physically walks into the schools um I've joked with the administration at New London Academy that they could create a Bluer real of me coming into the school because in the fall I'm coming in with like a bunch of of pumpkins and in the spring I'm coming in with a bunch of markers
031and I like to not just be a person who strategizes which I am and I can be but I like to be in person and talk to the people that the policies that I'm making are impacting um I would like to within the next two months I would like to be appointed and then I would like to within the next two months um visit or revisit all of our Ved County Public School schools I said earlier that I think we just have some of the most wonderful people here and I would like to be someone who seeks first to listen and seeks to understand um in order to be understood so this this job takes more time than would be expected um do you think you'd be able to make the sacrifices required to take
032the position yes sir I do I was um talking about that last night and you know I think that I am aware I think I'm more aware than most of the significant amount of responsibility I've been in roles before where it's a lot more work than it looks like um and I hope that you know that I see your hard work I appreciate it I respect it and yes S I am ready so so how do you feel about Chromebooks in and outside of the classroom and just are they effective how what are your thoughts about them I think it certainly varies by level I believe that you know our high schoolers they many of them are a year months away from being in a Workforce where they are going to be on their computers
033often in many of the roles that some of our our students will choose I also you know as an educator I know that there are many different types of learning and the younger that we get at the more Elementary level I love when I still see them not on the Chrome book but I see them engaging in learning activities where they are physically moving their bodies where they're listening where they're engaging all of their senses so I believe that the implementation of Chromebooks um should be incremental I believe that a Reliance on them in the Elementry ages is you know could be detrimental if overused and you know I also think that it's important to remember um you know we still need to connect our students still need emotional intelligence um so not over relying
034on the Chromebooks I believe is important we still need to be able to listen to someone giving a presentation you know research shows writing down our handwritten notes does lead to better memory retention than typing out our notes um so I believe that it's important to continue to look at what the research says about the use of Technology um coming from an educational perspective you have uh shared with us that you've got many roles already within the school system as a mom at all three different levels and and PTA um there will be times where there's conflict between decisions that need to be made here and where the river hits the road and uh how will you handle those kinds of conflicts I am aware of that and I have been in roles before where
035you have to have a clear lineation um and you have to you know be willing in leadership to make sacrifices and sometimes you know those sacrifices are that you don't get to share every bit of information you have sometimes those sacrifices are you have to just physically miss being at a place that you would rather be at sometimes those sacrifices are that you have to look at a situation um from different perspectives that may not be understood um I understand that there are conflicts um between perspectives um in different places and I know that it won't always be easy but I do feel that I am prepared to be an excellent board member and to be not only transparent but also very committed to my role on the board um here we believe that whether
036you you know when you're getting ready to graduate we our job is to try to train you for your next steps which is going to be either college or career um a lot of that also has to do with you know we have a robust CTE program um just give us kind of your thoughts on that when it's coming to kids and and which path they decide to take and is there anything in that in that program or anything that we're doing over there that um if we're not doing that we should be doing that's a great question I'm I'm going to try not to talk too much about this because as you know you know on my application my background is in career development I was a career counselor so I'll try not to
037sit here and talk about our young people's careers for the rest of the night um but from a career development perspective what a lot of career theorists talk about is how careers it used to be like an elevator or it used to be like a car where you know you pick your path you get on and you continue moving up or you get in a car you're going to a destination and you keep going and the way that careers work today is that there are often a lot more lateral moves it's like taking an Uber to the airport and careers you see people changing Industries so much more you see people in dual roles so much more you see people in hybrid roles so much more I think it's incredibly important to keep our students
038aware of the opportunities I mean our students who are in high school school right now we might have a third of them who want to do jobs that might not have existed when some of us were in high school you know um so I think that it's very important to have and we do this but to continue um the relationships that we have with the professionals and the trades and all the different Industries to continue those strong relationships with businesses who can come in and talk to our students and give that real world application and communication I think that we do well and I just want to see that grow all well thank you all very much thank you for [Applause] if you will tell us your name and one thing you want us to
039remember about you oo my name is Joseph verus and one thing you remember about me is I have six kids six boys who I truly love two sets of twins and I'm 35 with the gray hair that I have because of all of their lovely Spirits great good evening hey could you please describe your idea of the best form of government the best form of government um I truly believe that those in places of leadership within our government really should be listening to the voices of the people who have put them there to represent them um I believe these are is probably my biblical background in values but in in servant leadership and that you're there to be able to um serve the people who you've been called to lead for whatever time that is
040and to be able to make an impact that positively changes the community I believe that um I believe in the voices of parents if we're talking about government in the context of of school division um the voices of parents to be able to be heard I believe that a lot happens within the home of forming citizens young people who are going to be growing up and living in their communities and being leaders in them and perhaps one day being in positions of authority in government as well and so I think some of that formation um starts at home and then from the perspective of those who are in authority I think realizing that you've been entrusted with responsibilities to um guide and lead and with the best conscience that you have to be able to
041make the decisions that um you believe that is leaving the world better than what you felt it or what would be the main thing you'd want to accomplish as a board member I think the way that I just ended the last question being able to leave something better than I found it I know that this position this appointment is only guaranteed the next 11 months and then that might be it and so it might just be a short time that I perhaps could help influence or bring to light certain perspectives that would be helpful for our community for our schools um and so I think that in everything that I would do I approach it with humility to be able to listen to various viewpoints and sides on the issue I'm sure that there's never
042been different Expressions announced in in this room uh from members of the community but um I I I feel like I have the ability to to hear both sides and be able to come to a decision that I can make clearly and confidently and in good conscience and so I think for whatever time I might be afforded in this position I would just want to be able to do things that provide students with the best educational opportunities possible to give our teachers and schools the resources that they need to do that and to really be able to contribute to raising the next generation of leaders here in our community um um I've seen it in my professional experience and being able to travel internationally and seeing in so many different parts of the world that
043education really is key to breaking down so many barriers cycles of poverty um and giving children the best chances to obtain an education and to make a difference in their world and so if I could play any part in that um that's that's what I would hope to accomplish okay hi I'm D peris um what would you feel what do you feel would be um your strengths in this kind of situation in our on on our board and what would be your weaknesses um I think from a strength perspective um I'm uh I'm very administrative just kind of by nature and my in my personality and being able to um do tasks I have the ability to kind of zoom out and kind of see the whole picture and just think what's if we have
044a a certain goal that we'd like to come to what are the steps that we need to take in order to accomplish that goal I believe that I can uh zoom out um as well for that I like I said I think I have the ability to kind of put aside my own presuppositions or you know on a on a subject and be able to listen to different perspectives um I lived overseas for a period of a couple years I was an instructor um at a at a seminary and first of all that was my first time teaching never top before so that was brand new experience creating curriculum and teaching but then also teaching in a crosscultural setting for the very first time and I'd never been in that culture or anything like that
045and so I really had to understand different viewpoints different worldviews from my own in order to meet them where they're at I needed to understand their position as as best as possible and so I think through some of that experience translating in this role I think that would be a strength in order to um just listen to the different voices uh of our community and and come to a decision you ask weaknesses as well um any weaknesses um I I know that some matters that come before the board require immediate decisions or timely decisions I know that there are other things that might be postponed or just delayed for further discussion or um or research or or whatever um I'm very much an internal processor and like I said trying to con weigh the pros
046and cons and see the different viewpoints and so if I need to make a decision I think I can come to one um quickly and confidently but um I don't want to overthink too much but I think if I had to say something as far as weakness maybe just overthinking or giving too much time to um something Mr beis I'm Kurt hubach uh wanted to ask you about your overall impression of Bedford County Public Schools as they are today well um in my experiences with my children um my oldest is in fifth grade at Thomas Jefferson I have a fourth grader I have twins who are in second grade and then I'll have have my last set of twins who will be coming through to um Thomas Jefferson the year the next uh school year
047after the next one um that's so Thomas Jefferson Elementary teachers are kind of my my basis of um reference there and I can say that we've had nothing but positive experiences with every teacher that we had um I feel like from our interactions with them that they're supported that they're valued there um and I can honestly say that we've none of our kids have really had any complaints about their teachers um and and so my experience with Bedford County teachers in the schools has been very positive I myself is am a product of Bedford County Schools um was uh raised and came through Force Elementary forest middle and I was at Jefferson Forest just met Dr cornette in the hallway here and he was I think his first year at JF was was uh in
048his class there in algebra and I know Dr Calbert was a principal there overlapping same time even though you probably don't me know me which means I stayed out of trouble um but I I truly believe that the Bedford County schools that I can kind of came up through really did shape me into the person that I am today and did set me up for um successes I've seen a lot of change that's happened for the better um and more opportunities that are afforded to students now that weren't necessarily opportunities that we had in programs of study or curriculum back when I was in school and so I think um I don't have high schoolers yet but I think it just seems like we're doing a very good job of Preparing People not only with
049like head knowledge but but technical skills and um and just resources like practical knowledge as well that are coming through uh different things and I know teachers have a lot to do with that as well and the way that they care and interact with um the students and being able to shape and mentor and mold as well um the students that are are coming through there and so I am I'm proud to have my kids in public school and uh we have friends who are like how are you going to do middle school next year with your um because we have some friends who have bailed out and gone to home school or private school or something like that and I said we've just had such great experiences and it's different kids are getting older
050the world is not as safe as uh or innocent as it was so many years ago but um uh just hope and pray that they continue to be upstanding young men and uh I I'd want that the same for for anyone coming through our schools thank you thanks for being here um and you kind of talked about this a little bit but one of the things about this job is that you try to gather all the information that you can process it and make the best decision that you can that decision makes sometimes a lot of people happy and sometimes a lot of people not so happy um knowing that what experiences that you have from life and work um that would help you approach these situations and then how would that help you guide
051your decision making so I think the heart of your question is kind of how you deal with conflict maybe in a way um I uh we don't ever have conflict do we um this is being recorded so who knows for prosperity and and talking about work experiences um what might be there but um I I I know kind of where I am in my professional employment um at World Health and Forest a humanitarian Aid organization um I've been there for eight years and and I've loved it all but of course there are certain times where decisions are going to be made that you don't necessarily agree with um and in my position kind of as an assistant director level I have the director who's kind of the goet between kind of like executive team and
052then kind of us who fall beneath that and there are sometimes where I either make suggestions or prepare certain things or um make certain plans that then can be changed last minute I don't agree with it but I abide by it I live with it um I was supposed to be taking an international trip last next week it got cancelled kind of bummed but you know it's that's that's the way it is and so I'm very much so that I uh personally like to have all of the facts and being able to if we have data to look at data in order to um make a decision and make a compelling case and I realize that on this school board not every vote is unanimous some votes are split um and I think that there
053is Beauty in having disagreements with one another that really helps sharpen us and learn from one another and um and just being able to I think help refine our own positions and understanding of certain things so I think that there is some healthy conflict that's good on both sides but um I'm one that if I'm able to make sure that my side is known My Views are known and making sure that all parties involved can kind of understand each other and where they're coming from I think there's an ability though though to be able to make your decisions or cast your votes or whatever it may be um and you could be on two different sides of it but in the end that doesn't mean you shut down and you stop working together but enables
054you to just continue going forward because in I would hope and I I know it's true in my workplace we all have the same desires and goals and we all want to be rowing in the same direction sometimes people want to take different paths and I think here for the school board as well we all want what's best for our children um and for the children who are in our schools and so there might be differences in opinion on how we go about it but would love to seek to know what someone else's position is or thoughts on it and um talk about it and come to a decision did that answer all parts of your question thank so you sort of answered this already um with some of your other answers but maybe I
055can probe a little bit deeper um my first question you know you answered my first question as to the type of government that you feel is best and you you sort of basically said you know a government in which the leaders are listening and and hearing from their people and representing them right right so my question my followup question is you know how can you practically and potentially better than others uh contribute to that type of leadership yeah I mean um I I'm not ashamed that I'm a Believer and and raised in a Christian background and I think a lot of that influences the way that I lead whether um it's in my family or lead at work or in other um situations where I find myself and I I truly believe that servant leadership
056is the way that we should be um leading people and realizing that what we have I mean we're we're all blessed beyond beyond measure and being able to realize that we've been entrusted with certain resources that we can um we can have and that our artist to steward and um you know being in a position of leadership is not about gaining knowledge or power or anything for yourself but being able to um Empower and share that with as many people as possible can you repeat your question just to make sure I'm fully answering the line of question that you'd like to go down sure yeah and and I think you are but um yeah I was just basically asking how you could practically right because sometimes we can answer things very theor you know theoretically
057but we can't really describe how we would practically accomplish those things right and so you know what would you do to be able to lead in the way that you think is the best way to lead which is a representative leader yeah and what would you practically do to accomplish that um well I'll be the first to admit that there are certain things practically about the role of a Schoolboard Schoolboard member that I might not fully know at this point and there might be things I know that there's things that been outside of the the cameras that are in here which I've been looking the whole time and trying to see where the views are of because I've seen cameras at different angles at different Schoolboard meetings before um and so I I'll admit that
058there's there's more that I don't know um I I I think practically leading I would want to so I I was the recent school board that was talking about the the different um projects and renovations and stuff at at Liberty and St River um you know in order to I think make an informed decision on something I would have to go and see something with my own eyes I don't want to just sit here and like never be in the schools or never be in the community and never like truly understand what others um what are their pain points or or something like that so I guess in a way of leadership but the servant leadership that I've talked about just being willing to take that time and to go and to understand and collect
059answers or evidence or talk to people for myself to be able to really understand like is this issue being either communicated to me in the correct way or am I understanding it in the correct way or am because I don't want to sit up here and do something that um has unintended consequences that's one of the things I had mentioned earlier I think a strength of mind is be able to zoom out and kind of see the whole picture sure and if we have a goal what are the practical steps that we can um take to that so if I can just say maybe one thing practically as it comes to issues of the the school board and and anything that might come against it I'd love to be able to talk with people and
060to see feel touch whatever um the issues that are kind of being B for because I think that helps make that decision you're not just r ring on the reports of other people but being able to to see and verify firsthand and expence you kind of said You' like to go out and do the things and look at them and see them and stuff do you think you're going to be able to have the time required to be an involved board member yeah I truly do um I I I'm lucky enough as far as my full-time job goes that it's very uh you know you're still required the 40 hours and things like that but if I had to take time off in the middle of the day in the morning in the afternoon my
061schedule is like flexible enough where I'm actually able to do that so um I'm sure I mean I know everyone has their own things that they're doing and and you guys all have to balance that as well but um but a short answer yes I feel like with my current work and then life balance as well especially if it's during the school day and um and kids are in school being able to see and do the things that are needed for the board during the week obviously there's these evenings that are are happening with all the meetings and certain other things that I'm sure committees and meetings that happen in other times but um I don't know the full scope of everything but from what I kind of see and know myself I do believe
062that I can do that effec so hi how do you feel about Chromebooks inside and outside of the classroom in their place um I don't have any problem with them I think obviously our world is becoming ever more technological and um I believe that we need to provide our students with the resources that they need to be successful and um obvious when it comes to computers that's just a very necessary part of our world moving forward um the Chromebooks that like my fourth and fifth graders have had for the most part they stay at school I don't know if that's a normal thing if it's if it varies from um from school to school as far as the implementation of it but um I I don't feel like without them I don't I'm not teaching
063my kids your skills at home and shoot they could probably teach me some things after uh learning uh on there so um I don't have any issue with books in schools it's sorry just to I know you're getting ready to as some but it's just different because um like my oldest Sons sometimes say taking tests on there and and they're like oh yeah I scored such and such I was like how do you know your grade already your teacher didn't grade and I'm realizing that just things are being done differently as well now with using the technology aiding the teachers in some of it as well but um they're getting comfortable with yeah thank you um you've got a bunch of kids in the school system and there will be times where decisions need to
064be made as a board member that may be in opposition to what may be best for your family from that perspective how would you handle that kind of conflict yeah I think um I'm very much like a factual person and when it comes to data and spreadsheets that that's kind of My love language in a way um that just that speaks to me and so I think I could have personal feelings on something just cuz practically and this is you know either easier or or or whatever it be but when you're looking at data that is perhaps irrefutable um I that's just how I'm wired as far as making decisions and would make as a decision in the school board that um you know I I I know Mr Hill you were here through all
065the throws of covid and I think a couple maybe were in in part of that and those are hard decisions as far as masking and distancing and and all of those things and did I agree with all the decisions no but I'm sure that there was also data and other just practical considerations that taken as a whole makes sense that you need to make this decision and make it in this way so again I think I can consider different perspectives and even if I had to make a decision that might affect me in a way that is makes it more difficult or or whatever it be um that that's how I'm going to have to look at it and make decisions that way thank you all right so in bever County Public Schools our job
066we feel is to um get our kids ready for that next stage of life when they're when they're getting ready to leave whether that's going to be college or it's going to be career um we have a pretty robust CTE program with with trades I just want to know kind of your thoughts on that and and in our is there anything that we are not offering that that we could in a CT program um how would we expand it or anything that we're not doing that we should be doing yeah um I'll be obest up front I don't know the full scope of all the CTE offerings that the that the county has and I'm the type of person where I I'll definitely do my research in my homework should I be on the board
067um to be able to one kind of be caught up to speed but then also be able to make um informed decisions that come before the board this calendar year that's all that I'm able to serve um and being able to to make those decisions but as I was saying I feel like the the division now has many more opportunities than what were even available to me when I came through and um you know the world is Shifting and no longer is the assumed path always just High School to college you know you have the rise of content creat or whatever who are going through things and so having programs in in marketing in business in personal finance I mean who would have thought that um you know there's so much that you didn't learn
068in in school as far as just how to do your taxes or or something like that and so um being able to make well-rounded people while we have them through middle and high school to be able to be successful whether they're going to college whether they're going to the military whether they're pursuing these trades that are necessary and vital and of course needing a whole generation of people to replace those who are are going out and so I think that there's High importance on that um you know even as young as my kids are there's a couple of them who I see who are like probably the four-year traditional College path is not for them and they could be 16 starting their lawn moan business or or whatever like that love working with their hands
069and so I think we need to have like parameters in place to be able to give all children the best opportunities possible and some will take path a some will take path B some will go off to C and do something that we've never even thought of before and um and I think being able to have that breadth of offerings and preparing I mean what's the model uh building citizens PS promoting success you know we're building these citizens in our communities and we want them to be successful for the future of being able to do that as well I've seen through you know my work and my travels overseas where education is not always assumed through high school and people really have to work to stay in it and be able to continue and um
070university is unattainable for so many but what what is an option to so many is vocational training and different skills that can be used to start businesses and be entrepreneurs and be successful contributing citizens of society any other questions all right thank you so much okay thank you appreciate it all right do I have a motion to go into close session Mr chair I make a motion uh that we um go into close session pursuant to Cod of Virginia 22- 3711 A1 for the discussion consideration or interviews of prospective candidates for employment assignment appointment promotion performance demotion salaries disciplining or resignation of specific employees bever County Public School have a motion by Mr Daniels to have a second second second by Mr H Brook any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I any
071opposed BR in close session e e e it's good to see you what's out to yeah stay need wife stay [Applause] cheese do I have a motion to come out a close session so moved I have a motion by Mr Daniels do I have a second second by miss perose any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed M Johnson if you will certify Eder County school board has convened a closed meeting on this date pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act and where section 2.2 3712 D of the code of Virginia requires a certification by this school board that such closed meeting was conducted in Conformity with Virginia law now therefore be it resolved that the bford County
072School Board hereby certifies that to the best of each member's knowledge only public business matters lawfully Exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification applies and only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard discussed or considered yes yes yes yes yes thank you and for action on Clos meeting items do I have a motion um Mr chair um I would like to make a motion first I would like to thank um all three of you guys for coming out and putting your hat in the ring and U I know it's not easy I've been in that spot before so I want to thank you guys I want to thank any everybody else that applied um to
073um serve this community is is certainly a great honor and um it takes a lot you talk to your families about it and see if it's going to be a good fit so I appreciate everybody um for coming out here uh today um and with that though um Mr chair I would like to make a motion that for the um the district three um appointment that we would appoint step Hill to that position we have a motion by Mr Daniels do we have a second second a second by Mrs parvis any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed welcome Mr Hill right um yeah all right we also have another motion yeah um Mr chair I would also um like to make a motion that we approve um the Personnel
074um uh report as presented all right we have a motion by Mr Daniels do we have a second second second by Mr Holbrook any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I any opposed right that is certified Mr Hill if you want to invite him to join the join for the rest of the meeting again thank you very much for intervie certainly all right um the next topic is for the finance committee fisical year 26 recommendation before I turn it over to Mr Haggler um I just want to make a comment that Mr Daniels and I uh we have spent quite a bit of time with the executive team going through this uh we asked them to present um one where are we financially uh what have things looked like over the last three
075to five years um what are we requesting and why and if if we're not able to get that financing then what are our options what I want to remind everyone is this is not the final budget this this is being presented for us to have discussion we will come back next week um with any kind of tweaks that you may have or recommendations and we will approve this budget for Mr Haggler to take forward so um what I ask for you to do is to make sure you pay attention to the presentation uh as far as what's being presented um ask questions of course I know you're kind of um you know you're going to have to spend some time and they invite you this week to come in and actually go through and understand
076where we are in the process so all right Mr Haggler I'll turn it over to you thank you um good evening everyone and based upon your comments I'm going to get off a script right away so got of explain something uh the committee has worked diligently over months um looking at every single budget line item asking questions uh for the purposes of just what are we doing and actually how does it impact students I mean that was a question that kept on coming back uh were there any effic genes anything we could do on that so I appreciate the finance committee that was a lot of meetings getting that done when we got into January looking at the governor's budget and where do we stand with that and so tonight we're going to be presenting
077what's coming out as a recommendation from the finance committee um from the members on there working with executive staff and talking about the timeline especially for our new newest member um the school board is tasked with coming up with a budget to present and do a request to the Board of Supervisors for funding and so that's what we're going to present tonight you'll have a week and we're bring back next Thursday and the board can make changes or vote on that next week that goes over the Board of Supervisors the state still working through their budget uh don't know what that's going to look like I know what the governor's budget looks like the House and Senate look like they're a lot different which is better funding for schools don't know if that's going to
078transpire or not so we'll have to watch that they get the House and Senate together they come into conference they go to governor and there's veto session all that so the Board of Supervisors is also considering their entire budget the tax rate and everything and then they'll communicate back to us what our funding is when we've got all that back then you come back together and we finalize finalize our budget for next year so there that'll probably be in the uh probably in April by the time we get all said and done if the general assembly doesn't go into an extended session so any questions on that timeline we're watching the general s me I'm watching the house and I will provide information to the board as I get information from Richmond and give what
079what the house would give us what the Senate would give us and just keep you updated on that okay so I jumped to the very end real quick but I thought I'd give the timeline at the front um with that um as uh Mr Hill was saying we worked on a presentation with uh the committee and our executive staff and we'd like to present that to the full board tonight we've talked to a couple individuals and kind of just trying to paint a picture of where we are as Bedford County and uh some of some of the challenges and some of the things that uh we're going to be facing so we're going to go through a slide deck here um pretty quickly and talk about a couple items that are like um pretty important
080and then after that we'll open it up for questions and some comments or other things that you may be requesting and then we'll switch over to actually looking at the 25 26 budget so with that I'll turn it over to Dr Woodford and she'll start us off on our slide Dr calber I'm looking at you okay I got the clicker so I got that right you have the clicker uh good evening uh I would like to start a discussion tonight by reviewing salaries and retention rates in bever County um starting with teacher s comparison uh we currently rank 107 out of 131 in the state um and I've linked there uh everybody's ranking that's on the sheet if you click on state um we in region five we rank 16 out of 20 in the
081region and we are off of the state average if you're looking at begin teacher Sal were off uh about $4,175 from the average and if you're looking at about 25 years is the worst we're about 63,000 I mean $637 off from the average meaning we are lower than the average um Mr agler so in um finance committee we discussed what would it take to raise our ranking in the region so we did a calculation the state is giving money um contributing to S soqs and the money for s s soq positions to help us get a 3% raise so we're assuming with this calculation that every division would give a 3% some of them will not and some of them will give more um but assuming the 3% um we would need to give a
0827% raise to raise to number 15 out of 20 and and we would need to give a 10% raise to get to number 12 out of 20 so the other thing that I did is we looked at classified uh wage comparison so I went online and looked at the division salary scales from all the divisions listed here and I looked for the lowest paid salary the starting salary that was the lowest and that in different divisions that's different categories um and as you can see here we at 1350 are comparative are comparative to ammer and bat um but we are not to Campbell Rono Rono City and Lynch Park and that pay differential that we're seeing will explain the retention rate in this slide um our retention rate for clerical staff is 92% bus drivers
083is 89 custodians 76 pair professional 69 and nutrition 59 that means that 41% of our nutrition staff turns over each year they are what starts our scale at scale 104 so they are the lowest paying scale on the on the chart so as you can see here salary really does equal retention rate so at this point I'm going to turn it over to Dr Wood to discuss achievement and spending I ask a question real quick sure what is the retention rate among teachers 84% and most um of the 16% I think 68% of the 16% that we don't retain is in the first 5 years so similar to the trend we see with salary compar for our teachers and staff when we look at achievement and per pupil expenditures um and we compare Bedford to
084our surrounding divisions you can see that we also spend less money per pupil than our surrounding school districts um this amount is calculated by adding federal state and local allocations for education and these numbers come from reports from the Virginia Department of Ed education um we currently rank 103d in the state in per people expenditures for our students um I do want to say even though our funding ranks near the bottom um we rank 36th in the state for academic achievement so while many other school divisions spend more with lower results I have to commend our instructional staff for their focus on academic Excellence even though their pay and resources and support um maybe less than other school divisions that surround us in the region and state um it's really our belief as an executive
085team and as an instructional team that part of the reason that our academic standing is in the top third of the state is that Bedford County prioritizes placing our funding in positions that directly affect students um the state provides funding for the standards of quality um and you'll hear us talk about s soq positions often um one issue with State funding is that there are many state requirements for positions programs and training that's not supported with funding from the state um if you look at the chart here you'll see that um we have several categories of what we call S soq positions that First Column is what um we are funded by the state so an example would be we we are funded for 19 principles well we we have 21 schools so we pay
086for 21 schools in Bedford County so the amount over the soq is um 1.09 so we spend about 250,000 out of our local funds in order to support making sure we have principles at every school therefore when you look at this chart I've highlighted the yellow areas because all of those areas um are directly working with students our instructional PA professionals our special education PA professionals our teachers and our botch teachers there are many other categories but I think this really highlights um what we're putting our money in the state funds us for five instructional PA professionals I don't know about you but I couldn't imagine having five Paras and splitting it between 21 schools we have 43 that's what Bedford County funds um and so that's $1.3 million over what we're given um by
087state and federal allocations um special education there is absolutely no way we would be able to support our special education students with only the 12 that we are funded for um and so we put a priority there when you look at our priority um we spend a little over $8 million in additional positions over what the state is funding us that directly impact students um I want yes um forgive my ignorance but I'm sure other people are going to have this sure in the community are going to have this question can you explain why we're only funded for five PA professionals or 442 teachers versus what we need the year I don't know you want to take that Randy the the state state said so the state sets the standards of quality and so what
088criteria good question it's it's not what's happening in the schools and there's been some uh discussion with the state it's they're actually discussing in the general assembly and there's been push back from schools that the state should really be looking at what are schools actually doing and how much does it cost and that's how they should be coming up with their funding but the soqs and some of these things and even our support positions are arbitrarily like no this is all it takes you know like you only need one custodian for you know for a school and it's like are you only it's just some things that just don't make sense so when you look at these um across the board I'll give you one statistic I heard at a conference call uh which was
089earlier this month in January when you look at the state calculating what it cost to run schools in Virginia all schools they calculated on our Cal sheets that we get funded by and What U Dr Woodford was referring to the soq positions you you see up there that they do support we don't get 100% funding for those we're picking up quite a bit of that we have to match it what we're doing here is above that we don't get any funding so what they're doing there um they calculate and what they send out um that it cost um 11 billion to educate kids in uh Virginia the actual cost is 17 billion there's a$6 billion dollar disconnect between what's actually happening in the schools and what the state says you need to run schools so
090that that's at that's at the Richmond level and kind of working through that and saying what you're saying is really not possible um we have to go up and above and there's no there's no way to fight that there's no way to say no you you you don't understand how many students we have or building I mean there's no argument there and this is just not us this is every division has been making this argument but I don't know if K12 has gotten theed uh the cut of the pie or the attention in the last you know in years past I think there's a tension there I just don't know if that's going to come or materialize into more funding I think my my message to the community here is if anyone is listening is
091we should be making phone calls to our representatives in Richmond as you know citizens saying look you know this this is an issue right it's not something that the board can necessarily change but um or that your staff can change but I think citizens should be reaching out to our Representatives about this in real dollars when you look at inflation adjusted um the state I think this year or next year will finally reach pre-recession levels so when you factor in inflation we're finally getting back to how they funded education back in 2007 so it it's been a long haul after the recession before cor K12 cut divisions are are meeting these by because their local taxes are higher that's right than what we have here is the main locality makes well you know we're going
092to share some other data but I think there's some dis there's that at the state level it's on the S soqs and uh that that's in the law that's in the budget process yeah I also think it's important that we are in touch with um those that are in the general assembly the people who represent us at the state level um there are hundreds of bills in education that are put before them every year um when they get passed then it's up to the school divisions to figure out how to fund that we were looking at one bill that is getting a lot of promise that it may go through it's going to require us to hire two people to cover the mandates in the law and we were talking about that there's no funding
093coming with that there's no funding attached to the bill so uh I think we try to stay up with what is happening in the general assembly and we are emailing our legislators but that's important for all of us to do I think as bad as that disconnected I Will Show a slide later the state has increased their funding yeah and I'll show that other five years and I want to be thankful for that but it seems like it's falling behind on some things and if you ask me why you give a 1% raise to all teachers it's a big number it you know there's a lot more employees in the school system maybe in other departments so you can do this here for a lot less than making a little move in education it just
094takes a lot more money because it's so big so and the Sops are they just the minimum that you have to have is that what that is or so on that chart there's a couple things the instructional administration at the bottom is a support position s soqs are mandated by law you cannot go below that the support positions you can they just say this is kind of how we're going to fund you but you don't have to but the S soqs you do that's how many teachers you cannot go below that that's the minimum and we're above the minimum on almost just about every POS we're we're above the minimum on every position in the schools so this it it's just amazing I mean we talked I brought it up a couple of meetings ago
095about the special ed par professionals and I mean that's an eye- openening number but if you want to get down to something that just does not make any sense it's principles you have 21 schools we have 21 principles we're funded for 19 it's like getting on a plane and not having a pilot I mean just does not make any sense so the the plane wouldn't go neither does the school because I mean that that that that just makes it operationally makes zero sense so is that saying basically that they expect us to only have 19 we need CL that's the minimum assistant principls you you'd only have six right for the whole division just not necessary um there used to say principles could split between you know small schools I think now it says you
096have to have La at every school but um you only get funded for 19 so and and to be honest for the funding on that um we have two facilities that really don't have the student record you have Susie Gibson in the alternative Ed Center so you have some things going on there that the state doesn't recognize those facilities so that's that's why there's a funding difference so I I do want to say um that bottom category in the past there have really been a lot of questions from I think the community and the board at times about a topheavy central office that there are a lot of positions here however I think this chart shows that the state funds us for 73 3.3 positions that are support basically they're funding for those people who
097are overseeing programs doing all the state reports doing all of the work to kind of keep things going um and as Randy said that category is not required that's one category we can go lower than the soq and that is what our board and our executive staff have done and we only find 50 positions that do administrative instructional work um and we send that $2.1 million to our schools so we recognize um you know I think we all learned that we do this for the students and the people who directly have the impact with students are teachers PA professionals the people who are with them every day so we try to put as much money as we can there without jeopardizing turning in things to the state and doing the work that's required of us
098also um at this time I'm going to turn it back over to Mr Haggler who's going to talk a little bit about historical um budgeting uh for our School Division and and as we go through this it's not really to kind of ask questions and just paint a picture not to blame anybody it's just where we stand and what's happening so on on this chart we're showing inflation um and where that data this is the accumulated number as of two 2025 is not in there we're in the midst of the year but about almost 21% inflation in the last five years um I think some of you could look at some of the things you're buying right now or your electrical bills or something else and say it's a lot higher than that uh but
099this is an average accumulation so um however our County funding and now this is just our operating fund this is what we do every day this is where all the teachers maintenance bus this is where we we do everything each day um the change in our County funding has gone down by 2.7 million um Over The Last 5 Years with record inflation um we've been balancing our budget on state increases which I'll show you in a minute but it's getting harder and harder we've made Cuts we've done this it's like how far can you go I will make a note um that over that same time period the county has increased funding to our maintenance Reserve fund to full on that that's gone up by 3 million over the last five years that has gone
100in there for two reasons one is to help us with our facilities and maintaining some things that got backlog during the recession number two is we have this thing called reversion coming up in which we're receiving favorable funding from the state right now that will go away in 28 29 to the tune of8 million that will just be gone overnight and so not to put any board on a hot seat to find $8 million of cuts at one time we are building that uh building that up in that Reserve fund doing projects but that will shift over to operating at that time so I want to commend the Board of Supervisors for recognizing helping in moving forward that but our operating fund has gone down and the and the other things you've seen there so
101I just wanted to kind of paint that picture and kind of what we're dealing with the next chart kind of puts that with the inflation and the state funding and then two of our big movers in our budget are health insurance and also our salary increases so salary increases over that time period is 18% inflation is 21 you can look at that chart and say um our our salary increases have not even kept kept place with inflation so in real dollars our employ emploees are probably making less than they did in 2020 State funding has gone up 33% um even with and I will say this yes we've had decrease enrollment um we talk about that when we do our projections and so even with decrease enrollment the state has contributed 33% more towards us
102I will say when the state calculates our numbers a lot of our funding comes from a variable Co variable calculation for every student you get a certain amount some are fixed I use this as an example exle if you were to cut 20 students if we go down 20 students people say well you can cut out some cost well that's one student per school and I'm going to receive 150,000 less from the state I don't know what budget cuts I can make and one given school when I'm losing one kid you can't go down to eight or a teacher so it's accumulative we have made Cuts I'll show that later but when you put it in perspective we lose State funding right away for every single kid but you cannot get that back in C
103in Cost Cuts right away um that's very difficult and then health insurance 133% in five years I I'd argue that's pretty good considering what other people have gone through we've kind of managed that pretty well I will note that based upon our uh self-funded health insurance uh we will be recommended another s% increase in health insurance this year uh going into next year so that's going to add pressure to the budget going into next year um we going on to the next slide here so this is real dollars I've showed some percentages um um the these are um some other things that are big movers in our budget and what's happened over the last few years and how that money's changed you can see the state up $19 million that's 33% and if you look
104down at the the bottom of that Revenue line we're up about 17 million in its entirety up on the state and then down on the locality there on the expenditures I show the the salary increases health insurance but here are some other ones off is up 55% um that's almost entirely due to uh inflationary pressure uh we put more money into sports uh we put uh the transportation pressure on fuel prices and also buses are costing more in the last five years buses have gone almost from 100,000 $135,000 uh we got to maintain our Fleet Maintenance um cost of repairs and uh people we bring into repair things that's up 44 utilities um I got my electric bill in De simmer so there's a lot of pressure there so there might even be more pressure
105there going forward and then Federal and other the point I want to make here is when you look at the bottom line over the last five years our revenues are up 17 million our expenses are up 21 that doesn't bounce so and the last five years we have eliminated 53 positions of $3.4 million from our budget to make ends meet on our budget in five years so we are adjusting our budget down for enrollment loss but even beyond that so we can give the raise of 18 % and do other things in our budget so um we do recognize that has been hard and so that's where we are right now as we move forward in dollars of what's happened in the history of this um and with that I think that was my last
106one Karen so the goal of this presentation was really just to highlight the history of our budget revenue and expenditures over the last five years while our rankings and per people expenditures and teacher pay are at the bottom in the state I do want to just say the work that we um are you know called to do is really about students and I want to again recognize the people that make this division 36th in the state for student achievement working really hard staying with us through the hard times for lower pay and fewer resources um the reason we wanted to share this information was really to show um the board and the community how the school board has prioritized students in every budget um and this has really paid off for us an academic achievement
107which we can see um we're going to be recommending asking for funding for this year's budget in order to compensate our staff in order to retain them in order to provide our students with the resources to um give them the experiences that may be over and above the everyday core stuff that we're required to do um so we're going to continue to focus on students and having them have the best education possible um before I turn the presentation back over to Mr Haggler to present this year's budget recommendations um we are happy to answer any questions you may have about this historical presentation Mr oh sorry I don't have a question but I do say thank you for putting this because we hear so many different things about you guys need to do this you
108need to do that we have we have uh and this this is all factbase of what what you just showed the good news is we're still 36 out of 131 for student achievement I think one of the things that I want to make sure we highlight and I I think you did but when when the governor goes and says 3% increase we don't get funded for 3% we get funded only for soq positions at one .5 so all of those overages where we have said as a board we need to focus on student achievement anything over that so soq number we are only funded at 50% of the so soq everything else we have to fully fund so I I think that is important as we go into this budget discussion to understand why you're
109going to see some of the numbers that you see so right board members I believe and I'll just say for anybody watching um we do have we're we're going to scroll it on the screens for who's here uh but if anybody's watching online these documents are available on the uh board dos for under the agenda item for tonight so you can follow along with these each board member I think has a sheet so you don't have to look up and it'll be easier to follow along the first sheet we'll look at is um just and how we build a budget and how I approach building budget we start off with the previous year and then we start making adjustments to that so at the very top you'll see the previous the current Year's budget 2425
110this is only the operating fund that we're going to address first and move down uh Federal I put at the top because on the most part Federal if I get more Revenue I go up on expense if I get less I go down so it's a one for one uh tradeoff there it really doesn't affect the bottom line and we adjust positions and spending accordingly um the board members will prove those grants as we apply for them these are just estimates of where they'll come in next year um slight difference on the sr3 because there was a line item left in there from last year that shouldn't have been but everything else is one for one uh reductions or increases um as I said with reversion U I mentioned that before the county is putting
111in an additional $500,000 each year until uh we hit that final year our board committed to putting $600,000 aside each year so you'll see that I'm reducing the operating fund by $600,000 this year to make sure we're ready for reversion in the future that money can be spent on maintenance projects out of the maintenance Reserve fund and those reductions that we are moving into there on our own out of our budget makes up that $2.7 million reduction in our operating fund we're reducing it to prepare but we don't have anything flowing into there to help us with other things that are going on the cbcc uh no dual enrollment this was coming out of the state um we have dual enrollment where our teachers are teaching kids in the classroom um we would if down
112in the green area we would usually pay CBC 400,000 they'd get us 285 back those both go away so that's a positive gain for us 400,000 Less in expenses 285 Less in uh revenues but it it we come out ahead on that and we thank the state for recognizing that none of our kids have to pay for dual enrollment that is being taught in our schools um the state change um when I look at the governor's proposed budget an increase of $1.1 million from the state next year that's you know we are having an enrollment loss there but that's the increase interesting to note that if we did not give the 3% increase we would forego 1.5 million so that would be a negative number if we don't give the 3% the 3% is tied
113that we're we're saying we're giving it if we don't give it we don't get the money so that number would be a negative number if we don't give the 3% well if we don't give it we just fall further behind yes sir yeah in the region and the state and everything else but I just wanted to tie that that all the state money doesn't come unless you do certain things it has strings attached so if you get down in the green area the way I approach a budget these are technical adjustments I would say these are half toos um really don't have a choice on these um not not a choice but we're going to do the 3% what's the calculation we have steps in our salary structure so those two first line items add
114up to a 3% salary increase a step plus a cola to get to 3% it's not a step plus 3% if you put those two numbers together that's about 2.5 million as I mentioned before the state's given us 1.5 million so to do a 3% increase for our employees costs we got to come up with a million dollars to do that Staffing standard changes as I said if we have changes in our enrollment we have prescribed Staffing standards that automatically go into effect and we actually see increases or changing based upon each individual school and what Market blanket ship projects for the schools uh he usually presents that November December so I use those numbers and you can see there's about a um a recommendation of six reduction in staff members there um mainly at
115the aid level and that's mostly in the elementary schools um the flu shot it's a small line item but our nurses used to give our employees uh flu shots we'd order them and then they would administer them don't know if that's entirely appropriate you all of our employees under our medical plant can go to and get the flu shop for free so that's under our Pharmacy um plan and so that can be done for free so we're going to eliminate buying those sometimes there was I wouldn't say waste but we would buy them and they wouldn't show up and we're just donating those flu shots at that time so we're going to eliminate that I don't think our nurses should be doing that and so did the staff bus leases um under the finance committee
116we're committed to we used to lease P lease purchase our buses we would lease them for seven years and own them for 15 so it would take seven years to pay them off and then we'd run run them for another eight we decided to start moving out of that because of interest rates going up and trying to save on that save on that so we put a plan in that last year we bought two buses next year we bought four then six eight and we got to get back up to 12 to maintain our Fleet didn't do it all at once because it had been over a million dollars to do that so as our leases roll off we buy more buses and that's going to cost us a little bit in the short term
117but in the long term it's going to save us a lot of money on those interest charges so this is just a plan to get us out of that and that's another $70,000 next year prices of buses going up so for those four buses it's going to cost us 32,000 more than it did last year um adding in Middle School sports the board took action in July this year uh 24 to add Middle School sports and so that's the cost that we factored into that um to add those sports that was not in the original budget by adding that in at the beginning I have to build in that that into next year I mentioned before the health insurance rate uh increasing by 7% we typically split that percentage increase between employees and the board
118I typically we use an 8020 split the board takes care of 80% of the increase the employees about 20% if you get too far off of that then the 3% will not cover the 3% sour increase will not cover the the increase in insurance for our lowest paid employees so we want to always be mindful of that um and then software software is not anything new uh we do purchase software sometimes in multip multiple year contracts to get big discounts this is a year we have about two or three of those coming on and then they come off in the next two years so it's on one year off two years this is the year they roll on so next year there would be about a $380,000 savings coming off the budget and then three
119years later it comes back on so that's just the cycle of um the software the yellow technical adjustments are when I do my second quarter forecast I'll be presenting that at the next board meeting I've already reviewed that with the uh finance and budget committee but this is where I'm looking at the budget and saying what's actually happening in this year's budget compared what what did we budget and what is what are we actually experiencing so liability and workman's comp is increased 77,000 health and dental technical adjustments this is where people are moving between plans more people participating I plan for a certain amount but what what insurance are they taking um family plans so that's about 145,000 salary is a big decrease um each year I look at what our salaries are coming in
120at the biggest savings that you should experience every year uh on on salaries is you have turnover you have people retiring at the top of the scale highest paid people coming in at the lowest I just don't know what that's going to be so I'm always one year behind on capturing that I actually look at what's actually coming in and then build that into the following Year's budget so about $587,000 of just technical salary adjustments there so that's good savings um for the S soqs as Dr W Woodford was saying we looked at where we were staffed for um English language Learners and we were one under my midyear forecast already kind of adjusted for some of this but I that was that midy year so another 31,000 for the other half a year for
121that to recognize that full position coming in there and then other technical uh the finance and budget committee they they had a whole list of this but this is about 20 line items um 10 of them are going up 10 of them are going down and in total they add up to about $100,000 um I do have a list of that if any of the board members want to see that I can send that to them but that would drag this on for a long time and it's like a $5,000 here $10,000 they're just smaller hitters on that one so other technical adjustments there so the green and the yellow um are technical which I believe are almost half twos the blues are request that came through the committee uh to the full board uh
122there may be other requests um uh Mr h made wanted me to make sure that for the rest of the board you're hearing this for the first time if there are other requests or there other items that you want in the budget please feel free to ask and and discuss that either tonight call US during the week and ask for calculations so we can come back next Thursday and be prepared to discuss those so this is coming from the committee but it's the whole board's budget so if there are other items please make that known to us and we can do the calculations and have that ready for the full board to discuss next week but on these these coming out of committee um Google domain um as we go forward what used to be
123free is no longer free um so some of the services are you either have to pay or you lose them and these are security features to the the Google domain I would almost make a point that this is probably almost mandatory rather than in the Blue Area restoration steps so those that have been on the board they're um we froze step for s seven years and we've restored almost all of our employees there's some there's just a few groups that have not been restored their step they they are still Ed six steps um so those small groups would be uh clerical workers maintenance bus garage and health workers um on that no no one at direct or above would get any restoration steps just letting the full board know that so that's below director anybody
124that would be ow to step um cost of living as Dr Calbert was saying we've we' fallen behind the other the area um so the committee said what would it cost to do another 1% above the 3% that's $840 $5,000 and so they're recommending that as you not if you remember back from her slide that won't even move us one step up but eight% is a large number so it's recognizing that um but that's what that would cost security um equipment replacement cycle M mainly for our cameras a lot of that has been dependent upon grants uh we don't always win those grants and we don't have a replacement cycle so we need to build that in to make sure that when those cameras fail we can replace them and maintain that equipment um these
125are some smaller ones at the bottom stiens for 501 coordinators we have stiens we give out to a lot of a lot of Staff but 50 um 504 504 did I say 501 again I'm sorry I'm in taxes here 504 coordinators uh they take care of our medically Fragile Kids and have feedings and do a lot of extra work but none of that's recognized they're just doing that all for no pay and a lot of work uh it's almost like going through an IEP meeting for special education there's a lot of work in paperwork so it's recognizing that and that's not a lot there but to recognize that this is um the sro's um we have budgeted right now uh 200,000 we're paying 33% for the 14 sro's that were awarded to the sheriff and
126a grant that will come to an end in 26 27 27 28 um can't M I'm not sure which once that Grant comes to end from the state we will have to pay 100% of the cost so our budget is right now 200,000 it will need to go up to 8 or $900,000 here in the next few years to pay for all those for those 14 SRO those will be on us right in time with revers yes sir all hitting at one time my my recommendation to the committee is instead of like with ver reversion ending instead of having to come up with all that money at one time let's go from 200 to 400 this year and the 600 the next year and you take incremental steps to get there we can use this
127$200,000 on other equipment and security and anything else we might need while we're doing that but it can shift over towards the SRO at that time and then finally we have um administrators in the elementary schools that are assistant principles they're in 11mth contracts there's a lot to do during the summer to prepare and there's a recommendation to move them to 12 months I kind of went through those pretty quickly so I'll take a breath and get a drink of water here and just see if you have any questions on that first page or comments or uh any recommendations for us to do other calculations for bringing anything back I had a couple um of school has been using lynchford College they had a contract um in the meantime cbcc had that where they don't
128charge so can we put a little pressure on gov school to say hey let's go back to cbcc is post to lybg college so that we don't have to pay as much for the go school um there there was a there was a reason why they moved it and changed it because there was because cbcc was charging them a lot and um Dr Smith talked to them about lowering that price and CBC said said no so he went to Lynchburg College to to and sign a pretty decent contract with them but then in the meantime the governor made it so that we don't have to pay for cbcc um classes now now and so the G school could go through cbcc as opposed to Lynchburg college and save a lot of money which hopefully would
129trickle down to so why isn't that done through the board at the GU school to force Smith to do that that's what I'm wondering if we can we can do that and and I would have to ask Dr Smith because the state has told the community colleges to fund any duel enrollment in the in the actual high schools but I didn't think they were doing any dual enrollment at Regional gov schools so um I I'll follow up with Dr Smith because he must be getting some different information I have a rut gub school um meeting on Monday and I'll ask if they do Virginia Western what they're doing with Virginia Western and their dual enrollment so I'll check into that you can find a I mean I'm happy to make a motion I don't next
130meeting but um but I I don't know what all of the details on how can he get out of the contract with Lynchberg college so that he can go right because he signed a threeyear right I think maybe and okay basically from what I understand he has his still his instructors but they are they are dual teachers for for the University of Lynchburg right now um and so then it would just basically make them dual teachers at cbcc yeah because the fees and it's been a year or two the fees from cvcc went up right yeah and now they're done now now there's zero so we we should go back to that the other thing is I'd like to understand um and get an answer from if we eliminated Chromebooks from elementary schools um uh
131Elementary School students and just have them only in the middle and high schools um of course teachers would have their Chromebooks and have their their access to everything um how much money would we save and then also if we only had Chromebooks in the classroom and and they the kids could check them check them out periodically but they wouldn't just take them home step on them cram them in a you know we would how much would we save if we didn't have each child having their own Chromebook at home but just have them only in the classrooms um and access to them at home only through checkout or special special projects or whatever how much money would that save us in in the county for the add in Middle School sports 370,000 what was it
132before that was the that was adding Middle School sports but the biggest cost that we added there at the beginning of the year was for three athletic trainers because they were get we only have three athletic trainers one per Zone and we've been adding Middle School sports and they're spread very thin so the biggest cost increase was there recurring cost of three athletic trainers but we added uh Dr cornette uh what sports did we have Middle School cross country Middle School track and middle school competition cheer to each of the three middle schools and I I guess my question was what what were we spending on Middle School sports before um I don't have a dollar figure on that but we were supporting certain programs this was to expand the programs we had and I'm
133not sure we also added um additional coaches we added an assistant coach at each Middle School sport um comparable to the the JV and Varsity Sports so I think that was $30,000 yeah I think he was asking what sports did we have at middle school before I guess what I'm saying is we added to our budget 370,000 for Middle School right well middle school and the the athletic trainers are going to help out at middle school but also at the high schools there will be some Shar in there so I it's probably and I'm not complaining you know me put some money on sports right but my question is I guess um what is our total middle school budget Now Sports do you know no what sports do we cover in Middle School um a
134lot of them I mean I I can start naming them okay um we could get that main it's mainly the stiens for the co and the allotments out to the schools and then Transportation so those those that's typically makes up the bulk of the cost um the schools do a lot of fundraisers and and there's a lot of volunteers there's a lot of people that are volunteering their time I'm just curious and again I'm not complaining I'm curious that you know with that added 370 what is our new Middle School sports budget you know how much are we spending on Middle School sports total so we can bring that back also on the Chromebooks bring that information back we can provide that out as soon as we have it so you have it even maybe
135before next Thursday but we'll work on that as quickly as possible um because that's a little bit easier I think on the Chromebooks if things are eliminated I'm just I'm the accountant here I'm sorry but then you may have to buy textbooks do we have enough money to go out and buy hard book textbooks to supplant all you know to replace it we got to do some calculations on that and the instructional team will do that so we can bring that back and I think you know seeing you know $370,000 increas is is great but it it it looks even better or worse when you see what that is compared to what it was right so understanding the growth or whatever and I think like Mr Haggler said we' had to be careful with that
136athletic trainers because they are they're still based at the high school but they're also they're splitting now um so we can cover all we would have lot that out between high school and middle school so how many athletic trainers do we have now um currently we have four we haven't been able to fill two of those positions so the goal is to have six though sir two two for each middle school high school combo yes okay I guess what was happening is there was multiple events at M multiple locations and you know even at the high school level there were multiple events not being covered and then you throw the Middle School the middle school they were getting very little well I've seen what I've seen what Hood does at St River and he is
137he's there late at night and he is running around he's working his tail off every all three of are trying sure they were probably needed before you expand Middle School sports but expanding Middle School sports just exasperated help that out and so we we we packaged that together with that so I mean that's good that's good um before we switch to the next page uh any other things that we yes sir um I'd like more information on the on the SRO position and from my understanding that that was awarded as a grant to the Sheriff's Office and that allowed us to take on what 14 additional SRO officers and you know to a certain date and then it's going to become our responsibility correct y the first year the grant was 100% paid by the
138state and if you think about how long it takes to advertise hire and bring people in the first year went by with heart maybe they had one filled it took a long time to get this program going and so the state didn't have to spend any of that money then it was 33% for the next 3 years and then it's 100% on the locality so is that a grant from the state uh the sheriff applied for that Grant to the state okay so uh the the county is seeking reimbursement from the state for those SRO and they're receiving that in to balance their budget the 33% com us and is this is a grant that can be requested again um there's talk about security and what they're going to do and even govern I don't
139know what's going to happen within two years do do does the state say everybody has to have an SRO at every school and they fund it I there's a lot that could happen but grant funding is not guaranteed um so when this comes up it's either funded or it discontinues and well but didn't we agree that we would pay 75% and then the county is going to use them during the summer um so that's true we're not paying they pay the entire cost for outfitting okay um the equipment um and and I think they give them cars too so they're paying for that and then we don't bear 100% because they do have access to those SRO for two months during the summer so we're we're GNA be paying the full cost really for 10
140months but not the outfitting and all that so yes sir that's okay just want to be transparent yeah and the County Fiscal Department bills me for that and keeps the county for that I was just making sure that the grant wasn't such that once you hit this date you have to keep paying you you know what I'm saying like you say yeah I agree you'll pay for this amount of time and then we'll pay for this amount of time versus it just stopping and maybe we could get another Grant still g go it it's a grant through the Sheriff's Office so you have to pursue that it's his employees um he's paying them so um we're going to build for we we're in a difficult position with that because number one everybody wants an SRO
141in the in the school system and it's that's reasonable um you know in today's climate the kids deserve that protection um parents want that protection um I guess the question is in in a tight budget how how are we supposed to absorb that cost and are there some creative ways that we can look at you know transitioning and and getting that funding the Grant's not guaranteed you know why is it all falling back on the school board uh you know does the county not want that parents surely all want SRO in the school that that's something we need to be brainstorming about to to find it because it's it's a going to be a growing expense and that was my idea of putting it on here so it is in front of the board that
142this is coming rather than me dropping something like the year now that's it's not an educational it's not an educational position position it's a community safety position it is and I would say you know once again I don't want to pass blame but the doing it through grants either they believe in it or not or what do they believe in is the best security thing but it's like they're just here's a grant here's a grant but not here's reoccurring funding let's get this done bottom line we've been told we have to pay for it we can't sit and wait and get a $800 $800,000 Bill we've got to start somewhere right if we can get grants that's great but we've got to have it in this budget put some be putting money aside while in
143parallel we're trying to figure out a better way yes but this is kind of preparing for that was the whole purpose of saying this is coming and it's coming quick yeah yeah I mean we need to be prepared that's why that dollar amount is truly this is what we need to go ask for and here's why so the red number at the bottom is for all this to happen the blue the yellow the green um we need another if you just round it up to $4.3 million to make this budget work if we don't receive 4.3 million and more funding from the state or for the locality we're going to have to make cuts like some of these blue items might have to go away and then we might even have to go further in
144that depending on what's Happening so that's the reality of what we're facing right now and we can switch to the second page here if you want for those that are listening and for everybody here these are not recommended Cuts right now let me say that aloud these are not recommended Cuts but if funding doesn't come through these are potential things that our school board will have to consider um these add up to more than a 4.3 the finance committee asked the executive staff to do some calculations to say what triggers what things can we do if we're short on funding what you know what items can we look at so we've done some calculations these are wh ifs these are not currently in the recommendation let me reiterate that but if this if the funding
145short these are some of the things and there might be some other things but these are some of the things that we've came come up with with the committee and um those are for the board members to take a look at and if people are looking at this and saying you're cutting this and we we're not cutting that we're advocating for funding so we don't have to make Cuts like this this is this is the idea behind what the committee wanted to accomplish and as you go down there the one thing I have on there is eliminate all the blue items on that first page and that would save $1.4 million and then you can see a lot of the big movers on there is decrease in Staffing 85% of our budget in the operating
146fund is salaries and fringes you can't do much on utilities you got to replace your buses you've got to pay for fuel you don't have much maneuver you don't have a lot of discretionary funding really in the operating fund you have a little bit but I'd say over the last five years we've cut a lot of that out in that $3.4 million Cuts in the last you know those were positions but we've had other cuts too um so these are just ideas um none of them look good but when it comes to it you we're going to have to make choices to balance this budget so I don't know if you want me to go down each one or just let the board look at these over the next week and just consider those or
147is there anything else um I think Chromebooks is the one we'll add to this list uh uh from what we gathered tonight is there any savings to move to that Middle School sports is just a calculation it's not necessarily savings is there any other items the board would like us to consider I I just have a question so do any of any of these would any of these cause a decrease in funding in other words you know one of the options on here is close a school save 840,000 would closing a school decrease funding it the only funding it would decrease is um I I'd have to look at how they fund maybe a principle but on the support positions not as much um the only other funding we received by school is for technology
148for I think we re a certain amount for every school we operate uh for our technology replacement cycle for Barry sexon and the technology department so there' be a little bit there if the school was not operating but it it it's negligible yes okay and this is you know when we the calculation there for closing the school I put a name there it's just a rough calculation when you think about if you close the school the teachers and the AIDS and the support go with the kids it's mainly the support principal custodian clerical worker you're reducing those that's where that's where the savings is nutrition workers and stuff because you don't have to shift all those to the other school and then long term what's not in here is the longterm maintaining of that facility
149so um the board has spoken on that and that's not a pretty option either but that was a calculation we had from last year and we just added it in there so I just wanted to make sure it wasn't counterbalanced by some loss in funding but might be a little bit but not not and those Randy those those are recurrent savings that's recurring savs that's not the hard assets of the building not for the roof the roof and the uh HVAC and stuff that's not that's a reoccurring savings that we kind of calculate yes sir mainly the electrical savings the fuel savings for heating it and the positions and the school and I know there's someone listening and possibility people are going to get upset but we're we're talking about options here yep um you
150know let's say there is a school that closes and you save 800,000 can we go over again what the opportunity for selling that property is um it used to be that in the past um I think about eight nine years ago as long as the county really doesn't gota be careful if the county had a need for that building it might be that you'd work with them but school boards can't sell property now real property used to be that we couldn't we had to we had to turn it over but now we can't sell it if and you work with your county and stuff so we could sell that property this and we would be able to use that money as long as the as long as the board supervisor appropriates the money for you
151to use they they have to appropriate money that's the legality that happens of any money we receive has to be appropriated by the Board of Supervisors or I can't write a check so it's working in conjunction with that yeah so these these potential ideas in reduction are all would all be reoccurring for the most part that's that's what we were focused on right yes so if we did them all which I mean no nobody wants any of these to happen at all I think all those add up to over more over more over 7 million 7 mil 24,90 we weren't just trying to get to that number we were saying you could pull different levers or different triggers to bounce if you don't have the funding and that's what the board would have to struggle
152to figure out what to do and and what you're saying is that immediately really we need 4.2 just as of now from that first just as of now yeah and and and even if you looked at that if you were to cut out the blue just say you're not going to do any of those Blues it's only 1. you know that saves you 1.4 you still got 3 million 2.7 million you still have to cut and that's and you can't really go into the green and yell it it's kind of ler technical can you explain what eliminating testing coordinators means exactly so um we have testing coordinators that um do all of our so testing um we used to just have High School testing coordinators because testing is so tied to graduation so they do
153a lot of work with not only so testing but CTE testing AP testing all of that when the state required um us to do growth assessments three times a year in addition to so testing um we knew we needed to provide some help at the element and middle schools so it's the person who actually codes all the test they um uh it's it's a lot of coding a lot of requirements with the state you they actually make sure the tests are started on the computers or stopped they're closed out they make sure there are no testing irregularities it used to be that our counselors did that as just part of their job um and during testing time that was all they were doing um which when it's just the spring SOS that's one thing but
154with um growth assessments we were doing three or four weeks of fall testing three or four weeks midar testing and then three or four weeks at the end of the year so we added testing coordinators we are hearing from the state that with the new accountability system um that we might not have to do growth assessments uh we still have to do something because the general assembly says we do but it may not have to be like the so type um so our thought was well we could go back since we're not doing as much testing and bring those positions offline and then have someone else in the school added as a duty so we could just cut out SOS right well I can't so so what about using Librarians for doing some of those
155testing coordinating um appropriating St yeah I think yeah we'd have to think about that and um I know they did that at at E Class yeah they use Librarians during the testing time yeah if we were going to consider cutting that could could you guys present an idea of how you would do whatever testing we have to do still and I think most of us are for only doing the testing we have to do right like we all agree we do way too much you know so maybe just just a plan for how you would handle if we especially if we don't need to do all the testing that we were once doing right the reason you'd establish those positions right and that's specifically just so and growth assessments I mean we're still required by
156the state to do some type of Benchmark three times a year we're required to do um now it's K8 reading screening um so we still have a lot of required tests that our testing coordinators don't support that our other you know we do have volunteer supporting so yes we could Dr Woodford Dr calber can you guys um address the third line item there what what ramifications there would be to increase class size 4 through 12 eliminating 17 positions is what this number is calculated on what would that mean for the teachers that are left behind and how large would the classes get on the upside and um I'm remembering correct we did not add one to K3 we added one to 45 so 4 five I'm looking at the Staffing standards 4 five is currently
15722 so it would go to an average of 23 that's an average which means some classes would be higher and some classes would be lower um Middle School it's on ry's cut sheet if you Middle School is currently 22.5 it would go up to 23.5 on average and high school is 25.75 so it would go up to 26.75 so it would be it' be full and that's about as far as we can go before we can't we can't go against your soq so we're that would be a problem we kind of did that calculation to show you what a one change would be yeah um not you could extrapolate from that what would a half be what would a quarter be in smaller moves but we just wanted to give you a full one would
158would do this and it depends on where the school is and I'll let them take over because you could change that and the school might not lose anybody in our calculation because it depends on how close they are to their next one because we round up okay so if you're at if you're well above if your if your percentage is like um 14.96 then it goes down to 14.45 you still get 15 teachers it's but there is savings there yes yeah I was going to say it as we know it impacts our smaller schools the most and really when I say impacts the board has to make a decision because you've got those small schools that might be on the cusp of they've got 25 kids in a classroom and and nobody likes that but
159do you go and make a class of 12 and 13 and then you have your larger schools that can make that and they have 22 23 in a class um the other thing is they're middle and high schools what they're going to do because kids need to pass English they have to do the math the science the history they'll start cutting their elective programs which is why our kids come to school that's what they love about being in school so those are the ramifications as we were thinking through that that we would see by adding making larger class sizes what what I would ask is anything that we have on here we all need to understand what is the student impact bottom line and if it's not worth the dollar amount that's showing up there
160we've got to come up with something else so how does it impact a student I had a question on the last item if you close Susie G Gibson and utilize C cbcc CTA um I got cut off Academy yeah um it cuts 25 positions you would talk about closing a school and having to move all of the people and just not have the principles but this would be a little different because that would be completely closing the school and those kids would just go back into whatever but um but then they would go to the cbcc which would be free of charge except for it's tuition no it's tuition but we factored that in we we looked at the tuition for the exact same number of students who we currently have at Gibson to pay
161the tuition for them to go to CTE Academy um and we would still have that you know a little over a million dollars because you're not moving those teaching positions to a high school like you would if you were closing a school you still need those teachers the teachers are already at cbcc and the CTE Academy I would predict that we might have a lot of kids who would say I don't want to go to cbcc all that way every day um so our enrollment may go down we might look at some of our our more popular programs and centralize them like cosmetology huge waiting list we could do two or three classes of that we would may consider putting that at a high school centralized or something so I think there are lots of
162things we could play with um obviously we're super super proud of our Gibson programs and our CTE programs I think what we were doing is okay we we've heard from the community that closing you know schools that kids are in is hard on them so we looked at what buildings what facilities do we have that people aren't so um their heart's not as tied to maybe um I I'm all for CTE but if we can get it if we can get the same programs a lot less expensively now I know that there's a cvcc branch here in Bedford isn't there that's for Early College that's for early college and it's not the same so they'd have to go all got to remember we've got Stanton ruer students who are not going to want to travel
163to Lynchburg every day yeah the CTE Academy also they have such just like Gibson has specialized um equipment like for HVAC and those that's why they have one the CTE Academy because they have very intense programs welding things like that um just like we have those programs here we have the programs with so much of the um equipment here at Gibson because there's not as much room for those at the like an automotive program we couldn't if you really that was going to be the question I was going to ask how we have what like 400 kids in um we have it's I want to say it's 240 total for morning and after okay could they take all 240 KS um that would be a question we would have to ask them they may not
164be able to they've been trying to get us they have so many programs I think there's a diversity in programs um could they take all of them I don't know and what about ships instead and some of those things companies in Bedford in Stanton River I think the only thing that we would be concerned about would be you have to have the the CTE hours in coursework to get CTE completers which is part of our high school graduation requirements so there are sequences and requirements when you do CTE courses that um can only be done with teachers marking off competencies and things like that you don't have anybody to do that in an apprenticeship who would certify Transportation concerns so I don't want to keep focusing on this these are things that we asked them
165to give us as examples it doesn't mean we're going to have to go chip away at this these are just things for us to be able to think about to say what could we cut if we had to C can you remind me what is our um revenue from the county dollar amount yeah for this year it's I'll pull it I pull it up percentage is not dollars um total including all funds is 39 39.3 million um and Mrs peris asked me yesterday we were talking about what percent of the County's budget goes towards the school system Mr Haggler and I talked about that today we don't have an exact number um I think calculating a few years ago it was under 50% but an exact percentage I don't we don't have I'd have to
166request that from my counterpart the average is 51% for the state for yeah for something like that for for each County 51% like over 50% usually goes to their schools and and and just to be truthful here I mean of that amount 5.4 million is going into the maintenance Reserve so we can do some facility stuff but to prepare for reversion too so the end of reversion is a burden um there's been increased funding from the state for 15 years it's going to be coming to an end um so you know we're preparing for that wisely both the county and us so it's the operating fund that I've been kind of highlighting tonight though um so uh 30 about 33.6 for the operating fund and we get about 80 million this year from the state
167and then we got a little bit of other and then also Federal money coming in but those are the two big members and Randy remind us what's the dollar amount that we get from the town of Bedford I don't know uh the county collects taxes from them but that does not come directly to us when they were a city I did charge them and that's before weers so that's they're charging County so that would come from the county yeah okay the county is probably collecting I believe I I'm not sure if it's one bill to the residents of the town where they the county collects both for the the town and for the county and they have to revert it over to the town I'm not sure might be going down that happen that way
168but the town collects money from every the county collects money from the town from every resident in the town to fund the whole County to after reversal back to the CTE would Stanton River be able to utilize um a community college in Rono as opposed to so there are some stipulations with regional programs um the the the way it works is that certain regions are tied to certain community colleges that's to enable community colleges to serve you know an area and we don't infringe and all of that typically our region has always gone Central Virginia Community College um so I would have to look into that I don't even know if Virginia Western has a CTE Academy though but we could I mean if we were to don't want to get rid of our CTE
169program at all if I can but I'm just looking up we had to how can we service these kids this just hypothetical off at this pointway um got two more pages if any more questions or comments on those okay we'll bring some additional data back on that um since this is that we focused mostly on the operating right there are three other funds that um are in existence that we deal with every year um two funds that I don't really deal with was there construction where we have borrow and self self-funded health program but texbook fund is in good shape um we're preparing work with Dr Woodford um with our current contributions to that we should be able to take care of any adoptions we have for the next six seven eight years so it
170looks like our funding levels there are good can I ask a question about that this is going to sound crazy but did do we use textbooks because I've never seen my kids have a textbook before so in recent years we have done a lot more digitally so we get classroom copies of the hardback books that kids can check out if they need to are used in the classroom and then all companies now are providing the digital so this textbook fund is for their digital we buy a seven-year license typically it's negotiated by the state of Virginia with companies that they approve um and then you might get like in the younger grades consumables and they'll replace your consumables your workbooks every year but the main text is online so the the software and things that
171we get for the Chrome book you know is over here but then we're buying textbooks that are uh digital for their Chromebook right right so there are textbook adoptions like for you know the The Core Curriculum piece then we do have some additional softwares that we purchase um just to support um you know additional resources giving teachers a little bit extra and resources we have some software for um our music programs things like that that don't come in hardback textbooks things like that okay sorry I just I've never seen them good question hardware and software that are business software or supporting programs are all the operating the only thing comes out of textbook is content so it's digital or hard textbooks the reason this you don't have to have this fund the reason we have
172this fund is it it's not it's just like preparing I come to you next year oh we got to do a math adoption I need 1.2 million on my Opera um we're building and making sure we're funding and building up that so this These funds build up for when we have to do those large expenditures so so this textbook fund is just we're going to be like we're going to be replacing math so we're going to be using this for math it's going to cost us 1, 232,000 uh no this is just the budget for the year we um when you look at the budget I'm looking at the revenue coming in and maybe the expenditures in a year that we do an adoption um we actually spend a lot more than that than we
173do at given a year so it it it fluctuates some years we don't do an adoption so we might spend $300 or $400,000 out of the fund but we're accumulating money in there so there's there's more money in there but when I set a budget I'm looking at the revenue I'm going to bring in and I set it at that um but we have accumulated funds that I can pull down and spend when we do a large adoption is it generally more expensive to do the online or do textbooks for everyone um I don't know that there's really a difference I mean right now be used for more than seven years right but the the digital just automatically comes with any textbooks we get um on average when we moved over to the digital and
174classroom sets of text the adoption was about the same they're going to they're getting their money one way or the other the other pieces in the textbook fund that aren't where we do big adoptions every year we commit to gub school early college we purchase textbooks and we all know when you're in college classes the professors like to change the textbook every year so we have to buy almost every year new textbooks for our dual enrollment kids go school that kind of stuff um there Susie Gibson they have some consumable textbooks for CTE that have to be consumable because they're marking hours and doing so there are some just textbook fees we have every year no matter what because we're replacing but it's crazy that we have to get new math textbooks that should be
175the same since like the beginning nothing's every time the standards yeah s so's change standards change what comes in which grade level books that kind of stuff they don't do math like we used to do ma kid I can't do it I can't even help my kids um so yes on the textbook fund anything left in the in the account at the end of the year which is probably going to be above a million gets reappropriated and added to this we can spend that down on any year this is just how much am I going to recognize more or less in Revenue we've got to have it y yeah Ian yeah it makes sense okay uh nutrition fund this is uh once again it's not showing the beginning or ending bounds but what's the budget
176and what what are the changes there um been talking a lot about this fund with the finance committee there's pressure on the nutrition fund um inflation has really hit that pretty hard um increase in salary where you have you gone to minimum wage has gone way up Staffing and what's minimum Staffing um we are looking at that we're probably going to shift some staffing around and see some um Some Cuts there to get more levels in places um but I've shared with the finance committee overall the strings that we have the strings that come attached with the money hamper you and I don't know if this will be self- sustaining and definitely in the future if it doesn't kind of get closer to that level we have reserves right now but if it continues to
177go in the direction it has been last two years eventually we're going to have to shift operating money over to nutrition to make it whole um so we're doing all we can been working with the finance committee we've got ideas and we're going to try to curtail some expenditures there well isn't there something in the state to Randy that's going around nutrition right now um free yeah there's and I use air quotes I will say um it's not free but every kid would there would be no charges for kids um so that that's been floated in the state I don't know if that'll make it through or not there's a lot of things there um and either the house or the Senate that I've been watching they won't all make it through but we'll see
178what happens so some of our schools are already not charge right they are but Federal the complicated and as the the finance committee will test to you if the entire school is under no kid pays we don't get the same back from the federal government for every school it depends on their level so one school might get $22 cents back and one school might get 80 cents back for every kid that goes through it's mindboggling uh of everything you got to go through and um and that's not necessarily what the cost is for that lunch it's like and and before we make a whole school that way there's calculations and estimates and assumptions that I work with our supervisor with to see if we're going to lose a lot of money or if it it's
179a break even or something and look I don't want to make light of it because we have students in beer County who do not eat unless they come to our school every day so I'm not making in light of that yes what I think is federal state has created a monster when it comes to nutrition we got to figure out how to how to deal with it because we're losing money which just doesn't make sense to me right yeah so we might need to grow our own crops good look F the uh the maintenance project um that's just the budget for next year and I've got another sheet on that coming from the facility committee um and uh we are recommending with this budget also so that the entire board at the same time they
180pass the operating and all these other budgets the 5year plan uh CIP plan and so that's on the last page and for you all to look at I've kind of used the same kind of color coding uh the things in blue have been completed things in yellow should be done by the summer of 25 and the items in green by the summer of 26 the ones that aren't highlighted are in progress we're talking about or working in the future so this is an idea for schools to know when things may be coming but for the full board to take a look at that feed uh provide any feedback back to the facility Committee of any changes uh one change we did add um make note of two things on here at the very top we
181put the construction fund that's where we require borrows funds that's working with board supervisors to borrow money to get these bigger projects done the maintenance Reserve is we we're taking care of Ro hvacs U boilers and parking lots I'll make one final note on this with reversion if you look at the very bottom uh the 2728 year is the last year reversion is in effect you can see 8. .7 million going into the maintenance Reserve fund that will all shift over to the operating fund the next year for that cliff and you can see in 28 29 we'll have zero dollars projected we can deal with that it can't be there we're going to have to do but I'm just saying there's no plan for that we're going to have to do something but if
182we don't put dollars in there we're not going to be able to do projects long term so not only reversion not everything have you heard tonight but long-term funding of our facilities will become an issue that we're going to have to solve in the next 5 years we've got to be strategic you know I see construction fund $66,000 for a bus garage we also just got off of a conversation about Suzie G and CTE to me we could deild that bus garage and we put it at Suzie G to grow our Diesel and grow our programs but if we're even contemplating having to remove CTE it doesn't make sense to go build a million bus garage at Suzie G you know does that change the conversation so some things are intertwined and you got and
183you got three or four years so you don't you don't want to do something and then like wait if I knew that I wouldn't have done it and again let's be clear those are just conversations that is nothing that we are even remotely ready to move on or have discussions around those were just options that we asked the executive team to give to the board so we can start looking and asking questions yeah and on this sheet the things in the color are are in progress being worked on or architectural drawings are being done and when we're projecting things to be done so those things are in full swing by my maintenance department things below that are two or three years out can be shifted around or moved around for as they as as we
184see that nice job facilities Committee of putting this together and you know us being able to see what we're actually spending money on and what projects we're getting done we used to talk a lot about stuff now we can show this is what we're we're doing and we're getting it done so I appreciate the fact that you guys put that together any other questions do I have a motion for adjournment I have a motion by Mr Daniels you have a second second second by Mr hubach discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed we are adjourned