001as I see Dr Jones has uh has logged on uh 701 um and I'd like to call the uh this meeting SL Retreat of the Board of Education uh to order in which I will start with say the Pledge of Allegiance uh I pledge allegiance to the flag of United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all um I know we were originally scheduled to um start the retreat with an executive session um and we will be rescheduling that uh we will find a date that works works best for for all parties involved um so on to the discussion portion of our uh meeting uh the first item up for discussion is the elimination of flex time um I know we
002were given a a little an update and report from uh uh principal Mayo so I do not know if Dr Jones and principal Maya would like to uh open the discussion with a an overview of their of their report I am going to kick it right over to uh principal Mayo think you're un you're on mute Ralph if you all recall thank you guys if you all recall all uh last spring Dana and I came to you with a proposal to change uh the end time of our school day and at that point in time you asked us several questions about um what the impact of that end time would have on on students so we went uh through the first six seven months of the school year we looked at those issues that you
003had brought up at that board meeting uh so uh but going back a little bit the staff survey last year uh stated 202 out of 223 teachers support elimination of flex time um and there were many challenges uh many students struggled to use flex time effectively um they have campus without permission and athle experienced lots of different conflicts um and uh parents were uh calling them out of flex time on a routine basis so and then you got like I as I said before you all uh raise concerns about traffic and dismiss dismissal Logistics um and also about uh students being able to uh be able to participate in clubs and activities and also uh getting any help before and after school so let me take them one at a time so traffic traffic if
004you come to the high school and I'm not I'm going to go off the report a little bit if you come to the high school at around 3:15 in the afternoon the traffic on Hillside has is cleared out um we have neighbors coming across us to congratulate us on how well we've done in clearing the traffic and I owe that to the uh chief of police he has uh we changed our where our officers were placed at the end of the day so we have our SRO uh guiding the buses out of the front Circle and we have a traffic officer down at the end of Hillside and uh Hillside and the Post Road working the light so that when at 3:10 when we're ready to lease the majority of our buses uh that light
005goes green and traffic is moving right out on the hillside the only time we have a problem with that is if there's possibly an accent on on the postr but for most days that's working and I can tell you that from personal experience because I'm out there most days so I and I see it from myself so um so that was the traffic part and uh we did a few other things with traffic but mostly that uh running that light at the end of Hillside and the the post rad was the biggest uh thing that we did we also uh had the seniors that are parked in North Lot leave through uh driveway 5 so that helped and uh and we made a uh we had an ordinance that uh was passed so that the
006when you leave driveway 4 it's a right turn only and that also helped so that was that's traffic supporting students in clubs uh right now and I'm going to let Karen um Foster talk about it just a little bit but she put a charart together for me and you got you all have that chart on on uh the documents that I gave you and approximately 150 clubs are operating right now at the at the high school so Karen I hope you there somewhere you want to talk about your chart that you gave me sure um yeah I as you'll see um what I did is I took the numbers of clubs that we had preflex and pre you know pre-co so I went back to 201718 which is when clubs typically met before or after
007school because there was no opportunity block Flex block or anything like that so you'll see that um about 31% of the clubs met before school and you'll see that 66% of the clubs met after school what's interesting is at that point there were 86 clubs at the end of that year at the end of the 20171 18 school year um then you have some data uh from the 2122 school year up until now um right now we have about 36% meeting before school and 57% meeting after school which is a shift from what they've done during Flex block however you'll notied it's it just went right back to what it was before the flex block was ever there um and what I want to note is that we now currently have it's actually 147 active
008clubs this year so you'll see that that even with the elimination of flex block we still have a significant amount of clubs actually way more than we had back in 201718 um you know so as far as the clubs go flex block is not significantly affecting it or affecting it at all um you know the numbers are great we have in typical Clubs closed at the end of the year and we have new clubs um you know new clubs that come every year so we're right on track with what we were preflex Block in terms of when they're meeting before after school and they're not also not having a problem finding advisers because as you can see we've had um it's actually 66 it says there I think we're up to I think we had
00971 new Club applications so that's 71 teachers that have offered their time either before or after school to meet okay I'm just going to move on then when I get to the end of this we'll uh we'll take questions if that's okay with the board um we were also uh the board was also concerned with uh extra help uh and uh when students would uh be able to get that extra help now during the school day um we provide extra help in every subject area there's a learning center for every subject area um there's five English and social studies uh Learning Centers one house partially uh those Learning Centers are used for um ninth graders but also for students uh with h a c minus or or lower in any class that they have but
010it's also used for students who come in and take uh test in the in English or social St we also have a math testing center um so that students can make up assessments there as well because that was a big uh issue with um some of our parents at the beginning of the year um so they do operate um during all blocks if something happens during the day and we're not able to staff a Learning Center um the students are directed to go to the house and the their counselor or their uh house administrator will will will take care of them and uh support them in ter in terms of taking a uh a test or any kind of assessment they need to students have been using uh ex before and after school and one
011of the things they had to get used to was uh making an appointment with their teacher because their their teachers while they have to be there at a certain time 8 o'clock and they have to be there until 3:15 in the afternoon they uh are often up and around doing things uh meeting with their colleagues making copies get checking the mail whatever um and so students needed to pin them down and make an appointment so I think the students are are there now and are are being able to access um that support before and after school but also what we what we did and with uh Mr Georgio's support uh we opened room 900 right after school as a study hall so um students could complete assignments there if they wanted to stay after school
012and do that and we run a late bus on at 4:15 uh for those students and that's also for students who want to uh attend a club meeting or or some kind of activity after school they don't have to wait around till we change the late bus time from 5: to 4:15 so they didn't have to wait around till 5 o'clock to to get home and our late bus is I continue to run on Monday Tuesdays and Thursdays and that seems to have been working out for students I still haven't uh oh we'll get back to that uh but it's a it's extremely um uh safe dismissal process um reduce traffic congestion from my point of view and I'm standing on Hillside every day uh we with the elmination of flex time as we showed
013you last year you get increased in structional uh time um we've had greater participation as that Charter show uh shows and Student Activities but also in athletics and in jeros and we'll talk about that in a second because G let Pete discuss that and we have en practice opportunities um that have helped contribute to three cic championships and now not just one but two FCX championships because the girls cheering team won the FCX Championship uh last Saturday so that was a great win but it's it's the building is so much calmer now without Flex time I can't tell you how much uh how tomm buing is without uh Flex time uh in there um and that's because I think there's there was a lot of moving Parks a lot of people were going a lot
014of different ways and I also think um for safety for the sake of safety for students which is what Dr Jones and I were most worried about is that everybody's leaving at the same time people are not cutting out they're not uh leaving early and uh when they shouldn't be um those are you know all the way from freshman to uh Juniors leave that were leaving early the uh when we had flx in in uh the schedule last year so overall I think it's working out well um Pete can you talk a little bit about Athletics sure um good evening everyone after uh speaking with some of the coaches and some of the players uh it's been really positive without Flex time the kids are happier that the coaches are out there earlier prior to
015the kids would get ready but the coaches still couldn't join till after their school day was done uh the coaches seemed to have more time this fall we were able to gain at least 20 minutes of daylight as we got late into the fall um ironically enough and we could say it's for Flex for the argument of this case but our numbers went up in the fall and in the winter for kids doing um Athletics we have roughly about 35 to 40 more kids in the winter season and about that in the fall as well um Ralph touched upon our intramural program we do offer the fitness room all your long uh kids take full advantage of that when we do have some downtime in between um Seasons or when teams are away we do
016offer other offerings in the gym and the study all has been really well we just uh heard from a couple of parents and students can we extend the hour so we went from um in the memo it said 4 but it was 4:15 we pushed it to about 4:30 um so it gives them enough time so if the kids are going to catch a late bust they gone the kids start practices usually the later practices start around 5:00 so the 4:30 stop time gives them enough time to grab a quick snack change get ready for practice uh so we're going to keep monitoring that and if there's need to extend it a little more we can um and other than that I can't reiterate the fact of how quiet the building has been after school
017uh like Ralph mentioned earlier and uh any of you come through the building we still have a bunch of kids that love to hang out in the gym for year and in the athletic hallway especially the athletes they consider that they home but uh that's by choice not by you know by need because the room 900 is open so um yeah that's what I have for you guys right now thanks Pete and thank you folks you have any questions for us um I see Kathleen's hand up but the one qu uh question that I was going to quickly ask is I know we talked a lot about Athletics and clubs which I think it's fantastic to see our students are you know able to access clubs and and and are returning to that as well
018um and I you know my question just is have you seen any uh impact that this has had on students getting support uh academic support after you know school time if they need to finish a test or get support uh with any of their teachers I know sometimes that time was used for that as well yeah as I said Karen students really had to get used to uh because they they haven't had uh this before they always had FL time where they could make something up so we had to get them used to making an appointment they were not used to doing that and they just assume that their teacher would be you know in their office or in the classroom and they had and once they did that they there hasn't been I don't
019think anyway there's been an issue with students finding their teacher after school for support or before I think most kids most students come before after school has uh in the last three or four years has not been a great time for kids to to uh for for their own schedules to go and and meet a teacher they typically there would come before not after after they are booked thank you it's good to see that they're engaging in school outside of just the academics whether they have Flex time or not but I did want to make sure that it didn't negatively impact those in the other ways so thank you for that um if you don't mind I'll add to that what Ralph said our coaches are doing a good job of monitoring too as well
020when I do the eligibility list to make sure our kids are eligible the grades haven't been impacted so I know that uh they had that opportunity too as well so I just wanted to add that in there oh thank you Kathleen yes um this is great I have to say I am on the academic question I find that the teachers make themselves available all the time I mean you email a teacher and an an hour later they'll try to find something I know today it's today snow day my kids are emailing their teachers when can I make this test up and the responses are within like 30 minutes it's it's impressive and for that I just feel like we should be so thankful um so I just wanted to get that in there um I
021have a question on the chart do you mind if we go we don't have to pull it up but um I am a little concerned still about you know I think we we probably have traded a little bit of the Athletics is great and people can get um to their sports but I still think that athletes at least is my understanding then are per pretty much making the decision to not participate in clubs um and and that's maybe fine and perhaps at one point you do need to make that choice um but if I were let me just look at the data for a second if you were to look at this current year so 2425 just to make sure I'm understanding it and I don't know I'm sorry if this question is to Karen
022or Ralph um so you had 17 Clubs closed so far this year correct right and that's that just the number jumps out at me because you're only halfway through the year and it's the same number than as 2122 so it does suggest that it's impacting it a little bit right because because your pro would suggest you're going to close 34 clubs by the end of the year um not necessarily some of them you know I mean if like you said 2122 was the same you know 17 clubs have closed some of them were really clubs that should have been closed at the end of the school year and then after further consideration they came back and and the adviser was like Yep they're not meeting or yeah they were seniors and and I renewed and
023I shouldn't have so not all of them um I can actually pull up the let me just [Music] see um most of them so some of them were actually ones that I was waiting on like I just said uh there's about nine that the kids you know at the end of the year were kind of on the fence and then they got back to me and said that they were were not going to be active this year um then the other ones like there were no student leaders for one the other ones they just weren't meeting I don't feel that it's a significant amount that have closed because of flex time I've only had two clubs out of all the clubs say to me you know what can we just put our our club on
024pause for right now they're actually not closed um but can we just put our club on pause right now because we're trying to find a good time that works for everyone um you know and they had said you know it was because of flex block not being there anymore but they're not closed they're just trying to figure out a time that is going to work for them um you know like I said we have a high number of you know even if you look at the numbers right 152 141 168 146 clubs like right by the end of the the year La you know for the last four years um but we do have a significant amount that close and new ones reopen right right so you know the 17 that have closed it's not
025like I said no one has said to me it's because of of of flexb I have two that are on hold because of it okay no that's helpful I mean because it's a huge it's a shift right I mean 80% of the clubs were meeting in Flex block last year so the kids have had to readjust um I mean I guess just what I'm concern and the reality is it's probably still the best situation overall right but how do we improve it to because my understanding too is you know it's you're right like I think they're having challenges keeping the participation in some of the clubs because for some people it's better to meet in the morning but then perhaps you're seeing your teacher in the morning right or for some people it's better to
026meet it after school but then there are a few kids I know leave like very quickly from clubs because they have to get to their Sport and those are all like the right choices um just trying to think if there's like another solution I mean you don't want to send them to Google meets I think that was an option kids don't seem to want to do that right I mean if there's a way that we can structure I think we had talked about at one point could we do it on Home Room The Home Room days but then the issue is that you wouldn't be able to get your um Club um sorry who was it your sponsor necessarily to have that line up right with they're open right during yeah and our advisory base
027you know we have counselor advisory there's a lot of program stuff that's yeah you know that's put into there so that's not going to work either I'm just trying to see if there's another creative solution um but I'm sure you've all wrapped your brains as well so um just to make it available to everyone but we continue to advertise our clubs that are in existence uh on all our boards and there are some really new interesting clubs in fact I'm advisor to one club that just started that wants to take care of plants in the student center and I I had 15 uh students coming every other Monday at 8 o'clock in the morning so wow they even broke you in that's yeah got me plants are always a good thing they they help provide
028oygen for an environment but I do see that uh Mike thank no problem so Mike and then Sophie yeah um excuse me Ralph I don't want to put words in your mouth but um the executive summary here uh from everything you're saying it sounds like this is a this is a big win right the uh overwhelming posit Michael I think this is uh a real big win for granch high school and and and and for the biggest win is it's a safer place and Dr Jones will you know will cooperate that with me it's this is a safer place now than it was when we're I mean it was just working like a wild wild west during Flex time u in past years and we could sustain that okay Sophie I mean I think this
029sounds great I think a little bit I'm gonna repeat Kathleen's concerns of just you know I worry about making sure that everybody has the opportunity to compete um to not compete in clubs but participate in clubs especially students who are competing in sports in the afternoon or participating in sports in the afternoon um so I just think keeping an eye on what is the composition of the students who are you know involved in the clubs and making sure that everyone still has an opportunity because it's you know it's a really important part of being a student at grage high school you know um to have both opportunities and I I think the challenges as Ralph was suggesting a lot of students are meeting with their teachers before school for academic reasons but but then that
030makes it really challenging um to also have a club meet then so I just think we should keep an eye on it but it sounds like a positive change overall yeah so if it's a big shift it really is and uh I think uh as our students uh get used to the the time change and they'll figure it out because they're the most flexible people in the world we we ielt it's not so much but the kids will will figure it out and they'll uh find time to uh enjoy the clubs that they've always enjoyed so it's uh it's been a good change Mr G did you have your hand up because you had a yeah I I just put my hand up so I could add in on that we were talking about clubs
031participation and we talked about athletes and I think one thing that we might be a little bit overlooking and just because you might not be aware of it yet theodre Burke has done such a great job with Unified sports that we have over 35 kids the majority or athletes that are participating in that two days a week so those are the kids that sometimes would be going to a club that they're trying to figure out when their clubs can meet so the the fact of getting out at 255 and enriching that program we have 15 or 16 participants and like I said over 35 uh partners that vary between the seasons because of their Sports and those athletes from freshmen to seniors find ways to be there so I think that could be another piece
032on why uh Miss Foster clubs are having hard times to meet and we also had another new club that some athletes and non-athletes set up that's called clear the gear and they're trying to um to get equipment for kids that are looking to participate in sports that may not have the equipment or the means of getting it or not sure they want to invest in it yet so I think our kids are getting a lot of opportunities to to give to the community at the end of the school and many different ways other than clubs and feel valued as well so I just wanted to add that in yeah I was say I know that a lot of it's not just students they have stuff after school but we also have people involved in Orchestra
033and art that have you know and and plays and a lot of that stuff happens prior to an after school and I know they all seem to in the past have at least found time and hopefully this is an opportunity for them maybe to create some additional clubs that meet at different times maybe Wendy it's a busy Place Karen it's a busy place I miss it Wendy uh I just want to say I was really con concerned about you know the the kids being able to meet with their teachers and making up tests um and the clubs and you guys have done it looks like a a really nice job of figuring out all these moving pieces because I know it's not easy it's a big school um but I was wondering do kids are
034they allowed to meet at night like at 6 absolutely student student government for example their executive uh board they meet at night in the student center um so yeah any club okay so that's another okay time that they can meet okay great thanks thanks Ry does anybody else have any questions or comments in regards to flex time if not we can move on to cell phone uh usage going once okay going twice off to cell phones so uh the next topic uh up for discussion for us is uh the update on the cell phone um the changes to cell phone uh usage at the high school um and that the implementation of that uh revised policy okay so um back in July uh late early August Dr Jones and uh and I and uh all
035the building principles got together to talk about how we were going to regulate uh cell phones uh moving forward in the 2425 school year the reason we Dr Jones organiz this all is because the she knew that the State Department of Education was going to come out with new guidelines and she was worried that they were going to be highly restrictive and uh she wanted us get to get a jump on it so we all met um um in a big group and then Dr Jones and I met about the high school and at that point we determined that uh we we were going to uh not allow students to use their cell phones uh throughout the school day uh not even during lunch not even during their open time so that was the the
036regulation that we came up with for the high school and you can see it um uh it's highlighted there and you can click on it if you want to see what the regulation looked like we then decided once we uh did that was to form a committee of uh parents students teachers and administrators to review what we had decided and make a recommendation back to uh Dr Jones so uh we began meeting uh on the what to say September 27th and we met regularly um throughout uh the beginning of the school year up until including um the last one of the last meetings was in December um we this was an interesting uh committee because uh I would I would have thought that you know that the the students would be you know uh would
037be against this new regulation the parents would be you know yes they're all for but it wasn't there the opinions Vari no matter which uh uh constituency you came from so that that was an interesting way to uh to sit there I didn't give my opinion I just sit listen uh uh and uh we discuss next steps at every meeting so because our committee could not really come to any um conclusion uh about how the regulation should be implemented we decided to do uh a survey to the parents students and to um the teachers um we submitted we we sent that those uh surveys and reminders out multiple times and we we did get a uh a nice uh showing in terms of people participating in the surveys for example parents we got uh 1280
038parents uh they uh responded through the survey uh 1100 students responded to the survey and uh 29 teachers out of well that's out of 252 so that was a we we thought the based on those numbers are our our uh survey results are pretty valid and if you look at questions uh so the teacher survey you look at question seven student survey you look at question 10 the parent survey five and six um we based our recommendations to the superintendent based on those numbers and the majority of of student teachers and uh The Faculty said yeah let's let the students use their cell phones during um opens and uh lunch so uh that's the and I'm skipping some a lot of stuff here but that's the recommendation that I made to the superintendent and uh
039and that's what I'm presenting to you all here tonight and so there's also a draft of the the new regulation at the last page of this uh document and I don't need to go fast but [Music] um slow down a little bit um it is uh interesting uh in that you know we brought in all sorts of data and articles about cell phones and um what other people were doing around us so let me share that with you a little bit uh for example uh Richfield uh they can use their cell phones during threee periods and lunch um no walk they don't they didn't develop their policy yet so they're still working on their cell phone policy uh Newan and students can use phones in the Halls free periods and lunch and that may have
040changed since uh the last time we contacted so I have to update you on that um Wilton however they mooved to 100% Yonder pot pouches and and a bell-to-bell phone ban um so that I I need to talk to uh their principal who I went to graduate school with and Kevin Smith who their superintendent see how that's working out for them but they they went to a belt to Bel ban uh the uh Staples again they can use their uh phones there opens and Stanford High School um it's just their their P their their regulation it's just about um classroom so we had a big discussion about uh the classroom and how we would uh have the student the teachers uh either use their the pockets that we have provided to everyone or to our
041have the students put them in their book bags and uh we as a staff at granch high school have to decide on one consistent measure and that's a method and that's what our our committee said to us actually I said that at the faculty meeting on wednes this past Wednesday we need a consistent method so we need to discuss how we're going to do that whether it's everybody puts their phone in a pocket or everybody puts their phone in the bag when they enter a classroom and uh so that's uh that was more of a focus as well uh I also collected some data from uh actually Tom Perera collected did this data on the cell phone uh the code of conduct that and we put cell phone violations into the uh code of conduct
042this year and there's been uh 67 referrals on cell phone usage in the classroom and uh so uh the first time uh that happens cell cell phone's out during the class it's kind brought to the house office um second time uh it's confiscated brought to the house office and uh it stays there for an additional day uh third time uh it could be three to five days it would stay in the house office and there would be a meeting with parent to discuss uh a plan for the use of a cell phone um but that's when students use them during uh CL in the class and so uh the teachers have been really good about enforcing this I've been in many many many classrooms this uh this fall I haven't seen CL uh cell phones
043but the students that were on this on the committee with me uh they said they have so we have to do a better job with that in in the classrooms I think we're almost there it's it's over the last three years it's been it's gotten better better and and uh even uh more better this this year but uh we need to uh uh come up with a consistent process so when a student comes into the classroom they're going to do one thing or another and they know what the drill is there there's no you know you're going to do this in uh Mr George's room but you're gonna do something different this is Fosters room uh we don't want to wait and we do not want to waste instructional time uh getting into arguments about
044that so yeah we'll be coming up with something new for them uh and I'll be uh um hopefully by the end of March so yeah that's uh my information on cell phones and I don't know any of the other staff members uh want to pitch in I know Dana is on tonight Dana yeah are you on tonight and uh Pete and Karen but uh I don't know if anybody has any comments about cell phones other than what I've just made and and there's a by the way when you get to the surveys there is a ton of comments after each question so um more than I could uh go through tonight would take it literally took me uh a couple hours to get through the comments and then going back again and looking at the
045comments again um to see uh what students teachers and staff had say so that's my uh that's my report on cell phone so what we're asking is that we uh change the regulation that we uh that we uh put together in August and go back to our previous regulation which was um to allow students to use their cell phones during open time and uh during lunch and uh 100% not using them in any academic area um I was just going to say I don't know if any of the other administration had wanted to to speak to your findings but I wanted to first off just say thank you for convening um a committee that included stakeholders from all different areas for this and taking um you know surveying the students parents and staff and and
046taking their feedback to revise um your recommendations as to what seems to work best for all of the stakeholders um obviously we're not going to be able to make everyone happy um in every circumstance that is ensuring that our students um are being able to access their education and and have the other uh supports that are needed um I had a quick well question or two just in reference to the regulation and I don't know if this was brought up because I I know I'd mentioned it before um especially looking through the responses the regulation that you posted um had uh recommendation to put the phones into the phone uh pocket holders but it didn't seem as though that was the majority response that a lot of this no it's not I'm sorry mean yeah
047that that was half the committee F that was a good idea to have did and so we we put it in and uh because we wanted to remind ourselves that we need a consistent method it may not be the pockets but it's got to be something that's consistent from classroom to classroom so um we're not asking you to uh do anything with that that's that's that's something I just know I brought this up when we talked about just seems like that according to the survey that wasn't the option that necessarily was supported by all three different stakeholder groups I just my concern is that it adds time when students are entering and leaving the classroom to put stuff in and out of a a pouch or or a pocket and or could be you know
048and again we just have to consider about the the issues of responsibility of ownership because if we put the phone in the pocket then it's becomes if a student's private property then becomes we're responsible for that so if something gets damaged or lost or misplaced when it's our dut the school's duty of care I just want I I want to make sure we've thought about that um that I think about that especially if students or if student leaves something behind it forgets it they have their ID they can't pay for lunch if they have to get back to a classroom if it it then causes a distraction for other students in that class that they have to run back so I just wanted to make sure that when you guys are going through that regulation
049that's something you you think about because we often don't think about that you know responsibility who whose property it then becomes in the interim so absolutely yes is our biggest consideration shall we um so I think I saw Laura's hand up first then Wendy's then sophies so I like the I like that um there's a policy in discussion that sort of um considers students free time when I believe they should be able to have access to their phones versus instructional time when they should absolutely not I mean in the lower grades this is you know really in a way all day but it's really for the high school where the kids are older some of them are driving some of them need to coordinate with parents in their free time so I think um you
050know if you recall there were multiple um um petitions before yes I do I do you know the community had a petition of you know parents and then God bless those industrious students they created their own petition um as as students do when they want to be heard which is adorable and so I just want to congratulate you for considering all of the um stakeholders and you know these are humans on their way to becoming adults and so you know they want their their time to be their time during the day where if they need to um return a text message or something to their parents or whoever is picking them up it's it's helpful in that regard so um thank you for considering all of that thank you Laur and I just want to
051say Laur the uh the petition uh that the students had the students from all over the country were signing that petition that which I thought I thought was I didn't know that until some from sleep away camp Oh yeah and uh yeah so yeah that was that was fun but you know what um we've been talking about Freedom with a responsibility since we walked into that uh building in 1971 and uh yeah you can use your phone but if you don't use it responsibly we're gonna uh make it difficult for you have a pay phone at school any you have a pay phone at school anymore no the the nine payones are all gone they they've been gone for a long time I figured I haven't found one yet walking around so that could explain
052why Superman has not been you know available these days uh Wendy um I I just want to Echo what you said Karen about the responsibility and we need to think about that that's very important and also what um Miss Cen said about um you know just I'm so thankful for you guys for revisiting this policy because um I did not I did not like the way it was written over the summer and it and I'm I'm relieved to see it's very reasonable for the for the people in high school for the students in high school I'm I'm happy that um they'll be able to use it during their free time and that we're giving them the opportunity to be able to manage their use of their cell phone which is what they're going to have
053to do in the future um the only thing that I I would maybe ask is that why don't we give the students the opportunity to do the right thing and to let them keep them in their bags on silent and then if they break or violate the policy then you could put them in the in the shoe bag on the door um but I don't know if we're beyond that now Wendy we're gonna like I said I'm gonna have the faculty discuss that because they're gonna have to implement so I'm gonna H have them have a rich discussion about that and we're not going to make a a quick decision we're going to put I want it to consistent whatever it is okay Sophie I saw your hand up then Jen then Mike and then
054Kathleen yeah um well one I just wanted to note I I I loved the survey and I thought it was so interesting to see particularly the responses from the teachers and how you know universally they feel like it's a problem and universally they feel like it is interfere I mean maybe there was 2% or something who didn't feel like it was interfering with learning so I just think this is such an important thing for us to address and I'm so glad that you are addressing it um because obviously it's a huge distraction is specifically when they're talking about the amount of time that it takes in the beginning of class to get the students to put away their phones you know if we can get that down to just automatic that they're a way you
055know and we can recover that those instructional minutes um I think that's really important and kind of relating to that and I feel like um Dr m Anthony is probably going to agree with me on this I think it's really interesting that Wilton is doing something much more aggressive and I'm glad that they are the guinea pig for a more restrictive um you know regime and I and I look forward to seeing how it goes for them in terms of both AC you know academically do they see you know test scores go up do they see academic Improvement and also you know what are the impacts that they see in terms of um you know emotional social emotional health right and so I'm glad someone is doing it I I don't think that it should
056necessarily be us but I'm glad someone is doing it so that we can see you know it gives us an opportunity to compare ourselves to appear and see what is the right thing um and I'm going to be really interested to see how it goes in Wilton but I'm excited about what you described and so thank you so much oh you're wel yourself I have great I have great connections in Wilton because like I said I went to uh graduate school with the principal and so I can call him and see how he's how he's doing so I I can uh let you know on how that's going thank you I would love to know that thanks okay Miss beat um I pretty much Echo what everyone is saying about really paying attention to cell
057phone uh regulations usage um I too am interested to see how the other schools that you mentioned fair at the end of of this year after they've implemented uh whatever their regulation is as compared to how we will proceed and shape and and work with within our regulation but I do have just one question when I was looking at the documents and maybe you could speak to it in the student portion they did they did um just pulling up the number I don't know if you want to pull it up there but there was kind of a high percentage of students saying that they're using their phones for Teacher directed tasks do I have that correct in in under some of the information the student surve highlight the teacher the teachers uh says to them
058they could take out their phone and use them they can take out their own use them right so that that's not something that's going to change yeah no I mean everything within that classroom would be teacher directed based on the regulation of the the school regul kids like to lots of kids like to take a picture of the notes or the assignment before they walk out of the room we're not We're Not Gonna uh stop the students from doing that's a it's their way of being organized their way of uh you know getting their information so yeah that's not an issue okay thank you okay Mike and then Kathleen yeah I think um um I think it's fair to say I'm not echoing what anybody's saying except maybe Sophie um I think this is a
059real missed opportunity um I think the research is clear um that this is a crisis I think the nape scores that just came up are underl that um and I think um it's far too early uh for us to reverse course um and it sounds like the teacher survey data is supporting us um the teachers are saying you know in that survey the teachers are saying how significant this is and the majority of them are telling us are arguing to to put it away um so um um I think um anyone who who hasn't um read at least um excerpts from from jonath from the Jonathan hate book about the anxer Generation Um really needs to because um it's um it's frightening what what's happened in the trends here nationally um I think what we
060have to be mindful of as we continue to think about these regulations is um the difference of a 14 15y old brain um and an 18year old brain um but what way we're writing it right now the regulations writing right now it seems like we're going from 0 to 80 uh from eth to ninth grade um and um I'm unconvinced and I'm pretty sure the science and the researchers also UNC convinced that that's a great idea um to go from no freedom of cell phone to I can take it out in between classes I can take it out at lunch I don't have to sit and talk to friends anymore or I can look at Facebook and all this stuff and um saying that um well we have to teach kids how to self-regulate kids
061like that it's not that simple this is these devices and these software are designed to be addictive they're designed by um adults Insidious adults to addict young people that's not me saying that that's a Surgeon General and um all the internal Facebook documents and everything else that have said that that um and I think it is I think Wilton probably is concerned about that and all the other schools around the country that have gone to 100% ban but I think we need to if we're not going to do that I think at the very least uh we have to uh be mindful that uh 18y olds self-regulate uh much differently than than 15 yearolds um I think the other thing that as we continue to talk about regulation that we have to be mindful of
062um is institutionally um how we're undermining this um by um the school uses of of cell phones the um um which which gives me a little bit pause like do we need to be asking kids to using their cell phones as much as we should to buy lunch to take out a book and things like that every time we take out your cell phone and things like that you see the all the blips and dips and things like that and suddenly you absorbed in that world and like I said that's not I don't know if that's fair for our 15year olds um I think there's a reason why all of us it seems curious that we're saying oh you know what they're not ready for that in middle school but then suddenly in high school
063um we're saying it's cart blanch and suddenly kids can handle all that um so I think we have to I think we have to rec I would strongly consider us to to reconsider this direction uh particularly in and we're thinking about more of a gradual release Michael I got I got a whole bunch of I don't disagree with you at all tell you the truth um but in our on our three levels cell phones are never allowed in elementary school they just never were and I think what happened at the the middle schools was we always had when I was there anyway for 14 years when I was at Eastern um we always had the students uh turn off their phones put it in their bags and put it in their lockers and we got
064away with that away from that during Co so it's not like we we uh changed dramatically here it was it's always uh not always but for a long time that's been our procedure um I think that the biggest danger uh and you described it very well um the algorithms that these people write that get people hooked on um different uh types of social media but that's the danger social media is the danger it's not the phone itself it was just a flip phone and uh you didn't have any apps on it it would be it' be a great thing but it's not it's it's social media and that's what we have to teach our students uh to we have to you know uh give them some tools to be able to stay off social media
065and to stay focused on what they're doing in the classroom uh social media is the uh it's not the phone social media is our uh it's really our our opponent here and it uh it it hurts a lot of kids but again and I'll give you some just uh w i do lunch duty for almost an hour every day and the kids are talking to each other um not on their phones they're not playing some of the boys I got to admit they're playing games but okay but they be doing that with uh you know with some other way but uh for the most part during lunch the kids are talking to each other and they in open time they're working on their schoolwork they're on their laptop so just my casual observations as you
066know I I work in the student center for a couple hours uh every week just to see what's going on and that's just my observations and uh the kids are working not on the phones and then uh yeah during lunch the kids are trying to find each other with their cell phones which uh is helpful for them and then when they get to their their tables they're talking to each other so it it's the good and the bad and I think the social media is the real real bad I think uh uh getting through the lunch line now is 100% faster now that they can open their cell phones and scan it and that that buys them at a lunch I mean so that those kinds of things coming into the building you got to
067show your ID um and it's on your cell phone U it makes this a safer uh building um because uh and and if you don't want to have your cell your ID on your cell phone you can always get a hard copy and you could still uh you know punch in your number your code for your uh your lunch but I I in educationally I there's no way I can disagree with what you just said um I right before I know Kathleen had her hand up but thank you Mr Mayo for also pointing out because every time I've been there for lunch you see the students actually conversing and talking about stuff the only time I usually see them pull out phones is if they're trying to coordinate something a schedule or showing something like
068a f you know something to somebody else on their phone and you know I'm glad to hear that the lunch lines moving quicker yeah I was just going to add I mean I think this is a really nice balanced approach and I appreciate how there were dueling petitions over the summer and then you took surveys from you know all the stakeholders I was most intrigued to see that parents and students strangely aligned and I don't think that was premeditated so that's that's exciting um but I think that I like everything you said Ralph you you kind of I don't even want to say anymore because you concluded it perfectly in the sense that you're seeing the students there every day I was lucky enough to be there yesterday and I 100% agree I mean kids
069are talking they're engaging with one another but I also like the little bit that you said that sometimes when they come into that massive student space that can be a little bit intimidating and to be able to text a friends like hey where where are you and then join them is also really powerful and um you know those are the things that we didn't have necessarily growing up and I'm saying that was a good or a bad thing but that's the reality and that's that's a nice um something because that Student Center could otherwise probably be a bit overwhelming right especially if you're if you're new to the school um so all those things I think are great um and I I also liked what Wendy said I think that maybe a good idea is
070I think consistency is key but that you maybe start with you self-regulate you put it in your bag and then if if that's not work for you then perhaps we have to take a different approach but um that's just I I love this conversation so thanks for all this information absolutely thank you Kathleen thanks for uh uh congratulations to you for your uh Thomas uh getting that scholarship uh division one scholarship that MIT was a wonderful thing but the other thing a club that Captain's son going back to clubs started that and endowment Club they have uh they've offered the high school uh a little over $3,000 to buy uh that what they' like us to buy some uh games for the Student Center so students would get off their phones and maybe play some
071games uh in the students area I know Sophie uh brought that up to me at the beginning of the school year so I think uh thank you for your kid by the way well thank you for helping him so and happy happy to donate some uh some appropriate games for for the lunch lunchroom I have a a few that uh my kids have outgrown but ready to ready to move them out K Wendy I see your hand up I I I'm just looking at the data again and so I'm just a little confused how can we how can teachers say it's a problem because 6 74.5% of the students reported that teachers ask them to pull out their phones and and I I also have another point on that and and if the teachers are
072asking them to pull out their phones how disruptive is it going is it going to be for them to have to run over to the shoe rack to go and pull their phone off of it to take a picture of whatever the teacher wants them to take a picture of and and when that's what we have to figure out okay it' be easier if the phone's in the bag their bags are always right next to them but um but we need to have a discussion about I'm not going to make that decision I'm gonna The Faculty is gonna have to come together and make a decision and and they're they're more they're very concerned about uh class time and the number of minutes they're engaged with their students so we'll uh we'll have a rich
073discussion about that and and figure it out I'm sure you will thanks Ralph thank you Wendy um I don't know if anybody else has any additional questions or comments um but I do want to again say appre say to you Ralph and to the administration at the high school and and so forth how much um I think it's clear that we all greatly appreciate that you have been very open to including the stakeholders um and their viewpoints and I'm sure that our students our staff um and the parents do appreciate that they were that their opinions were heard in this manner and that their opinions were taken into account and you guys are finding the best way to move forward that that supports our you know our teachers and our students in their academic and
074other social emotional things and to comments to those who you know in case so we don't get uh frustrated emails later or whatever that for students that are on the Wi-Fi just if you could clarify they there are certain like uh social media sites and everything else that are blocked right so if they're using the school Wi-Fi they can't access there are certain social media uh applications that are blocked um on our Wi-Fi but they can always get them on uh on their net networks on their 5G network if they're if they can get that in schools uh however folks just remember we're spending $2 million to upgrade our our ability to uh use the cellular system so um but that's a that's for safety I mean I'm just saying we're doing what we can
075to ensure that students if they're using our school Wi-Fi and things like that don't have access to some of the social there's a there's a double you know uh block to uh any of that kind of stuff that we've deemed be uh inappropriate I just wanted to make sure those that that didn't know knew that we we had those there yeah however that doesn't you know once they walk out of that building and they're on their own networks then that that is true but anyway I do appreciate that you guys have taken the time and and energy to to Really you know review all of this this past semester I'm sure we look forward to seeing how things go the next semester uh you know the school year for for the students in I want
076to give uh uh like thank Dr Jones for allowing us to go through this process and and determining uh and making the chain the regulation based on what the committee decides so uh Tony I don't I don't see you on there but you are and so thank you for uh giving us the opportunity to work through this uh uh during the beginning of the school year thank you Ralph and thank you to your whole team you guys have done a lot of great work between flex and the cell and even you mentioned the code of conduct all of that was brand new worked on over the summer um and Tom pra did a lot of work with the Middle School principles on that so great job thank you yeah just to thank you Tony again
077and just to be consistent with the with the middle schools uh with the coda conduct so yeah we did a lot this was a big summer thanks thank you uh members of the board appreciate it course well if there's no other comments I again we'll look forward to getting another uh you know little update at the end of the year I'm supposing um and we can move on to our action items um thank you for uh to our Administration that's here this evening um and we are going to roll over to the Hamilton Avenue HVAC um discussion that we're going to have as as an action item and going to find the uh we have a motion to make to put this on the table um not pulling up sorry um the one thing I
078didn't have out sorry uh the document sorry um I'm assuming we just have a motion to uh add Hamilton Avenue HVAC to the FY 26 Capital plan do I have a second okay Miss C thank you for second we need a a price well I think we're just putting the we haven't even decided which HVAC oh I see what you mean so it's just to put whatever decision we make into I guess the the in into our um budget request for the next you know upcoming year um I know where the discussion that we're having this evening is uh there has been a revision to the recommendation uh well there hasn't been a revision to the recommendation but uh in in the way we're using if we decide to uh reuse the geothermal uh the
079emac has worked I mean I'll let somebody else Ben is here and I don't know if Dan is here but there was a discussion with emac and they have revised how they uh would recommend we reuse and re redo the um geothermal cells a geothermal system which would better support the school so I'm going to hand it over to uh to to ban I think right are you leading this I I'll kick it off Mike do you mind promoting Dan Watson I see he's in the uh the gallery uh as he's getting prom we also have uh two representatives from Acom they've joined us in the past uh there are content expert and there are Engineers that worked on the project I don't want to go through all the bullet points that we included in
080the summary but just a two couple things to highlight uh one is des despite our best efforts uh we we do not this project does not qualify for the ITC uh the Consultants really nerded out on this one and we had several meetings on spreadsheets and depreciation schedules and just couldn't get there so that we're very confident on uh that we couldn't get there so that does take that that off the off the table we are having some conversations with eversource if if there's a possibility there but anything eversource will provide doesn't even come close to this area of magnitude that ITC was um potential so um I want to close the book on that one that that ITC is not eligible for geothermal uh the report is updated as as Karen mentioned that we
081we were successfully working with emac they were very helpful in some uh Concepts uh and so aom was a very great chasing that down uh uh Chris imper who's who's our counseling expert he showed up on site I think he was up in the attic running around in the basement so he was uh really chasing down all these options but the the bottom line is and the math speaks for itself but uh we are recommending funding for the geothermal system and for a couple reasons one is it is consistent with the RTM somar that was passed in in April uh it is when you look at the numbers the uh upfront cost is slightly higher for the geothermal compared to Conventional but that is made up in the in the long run when you look
082at maintenance and I think lastly we when we were looking at this really came down to we've already invested in in those geothermal Wells and we do want to see if we can maximize that depreciation of of the asset that we've already paid for and haven't been using so it it was a close I was almost uh nose nose and nose on the on the final when it came down to it but uh we just wanted to present I think a very good comprehensive report that uh has really been vetted for for a lot of people so it's up to you now uh if you have any questions and a com and Dan and myself we willing to uh answer any questions you may have on the project okay I see some hands go up
083I will start with Laura and then Mike sorry Mike can you uh Elevate Dan he just said he hadn't been elevated I guess before we have questions Dan if you have anything you'd like to add uh no um I I think that we have uh beat this dead dog so we're ready to move forward okay uh there was a quote for the paper ladies and gentlemen gr's time I was about to I was about to say you know what I'm I'm sick of hearing kick it down the road so I got a new one out there I was I was about to to say I wouldn't have gone with that phrase but you know um I'll go with Miss C and then Mike so I just want to ask Acom um I saw the name
084uh in our panelist um because you know if we're about to spend millions of dollars um rehabbing a geothermal system are there any limitations to its use to the field um to the fields use no and you know our original scope of work for the project was really to see was the field designed properly for the school that we had and for the load that you were putting on it and ultimately that answer was yes it was designed properly it should function properly so to be able to reuse it now is only a benefit to yall no reason it shouldn't shouldn't function no I'm asking about use of our actual field with the geothermal um infrastructure under it is are we um should we be conscious of say putting heavy Carnival equipment on our field
085heavy equipment that could damage any of the components that are in the ground um you know this is an area that um has had um Carnival traffic carnival rides all that in and you know we've been told don't put any stakes in the ground we've been told you know proceed cautiously and I don't want to do anything to jeopardize A5 million plus investment um that you you know our students and staff have been you know basically relying on a giant trailer outside um so I want to be explicit in asking you um how we best preserve what we've done yeah so I think Dan and his team have found the holes right Dan I mean I think they were about five feet deep yeah we have we have the general layout of the wells cor
086yeah so with that General layout I would caution you anytime you do try to put stakes in the ground or anything like that but from you know being that deep and with it being a flexible pipe there shouldn't be a serious damage only from a puncture so you know understanding what Dan has in his you know pile that we can maybe stake out and say Hey try to avoid these spots I think that would be the most caution when when you're actually putting something into the ground and heavy equipment on top is not a concern for you again depend I mean if it's going to be able to sit on grass it probably would be okay but if it if it's starting to make dents in the grass like sinking in and it's probably too
087heavy oh like if there's like rain and soil is soft like things yeah yeah okay and and there are ways around it I mean you know there's obviously if you can spread the load out what more and not have significant Point loads in spots um that would be the only CAU making me feel very comfortable just saying okay all right yeah but again the field so so far the field is intact so you know anything you've done previously has not damaged field to date so the pressure tests and everything came back okay um so um okay Mike and then Wendy right so um Ben um you can just help me understand make sure I have the the numbers right here because um I couldn't get the the different pages to reconcile so I'm I think
088I might be reading something wrong so um so where see we see the total cost of updating the geothermal here and the at 5.24 six that right yeah that that is a CIP sheet what yeah probably is throwing you off on recon calization is there's two line items that have been added to the CIP sheet that are not in the aeom report the very first one is the design A&E so design cost is not included in the uh um report and also the contingency contingency was not included so those two line items uh will will pretty much throw throw off your reconcilation right right could okay so that's why it's a different number on the executive summary of the Acom report yes that makes sense gotcha okay so we see at the at the 5.2
089number um um savings um over the 25 years years of of of of about how much we think you go to page 71 of the report that's where it has the um the present value cost and I think that shows you the future Savings of 27 almost 280,000 okay over the you know like the 25 great comparing traditional and the geothermal okay okay awesome thanks that's what I just wanted to clarify thank you for that I appreciate it oh so um on another note while I just have a mic so I I heard some um Chris the um I was talking to some folks today who um were concerned about the depth of the wells like um um that um they've been talking to Engineers that traditionally The Depths are the wells are a lot
090deeper than these and these only went so far deep um um you can concerns about that the uh functionality and and thinking about that you know how these compare to to um Wells traditionally are they as deep as they need to be or um any kind of about depth that we think we need to be worried about no so these holes are about 400 feet deep um we've done some here in Colorado 600 plus feet deep we've looked at other ones where we can go you know a th000 feet deep it's really all up to the geology in your area and specific you know requirements in your area and you know the 400 ft is a reasonable number for similar projects of this scale in that area okay and all the wells are 400 yes
091thanks okay um so I think uh Laura didn't feel com confident with um Chris's explanation but I'm going to try again as is there a precise measure of how much weight the wells can withstand um it would depend on the soil above it right so I think there if there's five ft of soil above it whatever that soil consists of would have a different compressive strength than you know say a clay or a rock or something else I don't know off the top of my head what that number is and how much weight and connections tock on those things but again what you've done to date hasn't damaged them so you know I mean and we can just avoid that area sure right I mean they're not that big the wells don't take I mean
092they are big don't get me wrong but they're you can avoid them I think with this with this if we you know kind of stake them out and kind of plot them you know specifically where they are it would definitely help in the long run to say Hey you know there's something under here avoid avoid doing anything here if you can okay all right thank you I do just want to say uh Chris and uh and Mike they've doing a great job answering this question uh they this was not part of their original scope so they're they're doing very good answering the question we never we never primed them on this but uh the question that we're asking and I think we're all talking TOS they're not engaged in that uh but I just want
093to make clear that we weren't avoiding it this was not in the scope of the work that we were try trying to do but Chris is doing a great uh offthe cuff response I just wanted to put that out there okay um so I I actually I don't see any hands up so I actually had a quick question um and I know we've sort of as asked this before um in regards to doing um reusing the geothermal you noted that you found the Geo the found the Geo field location for the existing wellheads that was we had some discrepancy in two different documents so thank you for doing that um and you still wanted to just I guess there was some other work that you wanted to do in regards to that that require digging
094up portions of the field in order to to a further further testing which is what you noted so like a thermal conductivity test or I you I'm trying to figure out where it was that you noted so you know in the next steps for the estimated schedule for the ReUse of the G geothermal system I think it's shows like page 15 uh it's page 27 of the document but page it's notes it's page 15 of your report um so next steps other 5.2 it says field testing of the existing geothermal well uh and Fields the well field includes field locations of well heads and testing them to for impact design so I just didn't know if that include you know if that required uh digging up any of the field um I think what Dan
095has now and what Dan had found previously was kind of that field location of Wellhead so that was kind of you know we've checked that box the TC test is something that won't really impact anything that we're doing um it may be recommended just for your own benefit to have a solid TC test on file since the one we found was semif flawed um and then the flushing and purging I think was actually completed already um so a lot of that work has already been done by Dan and his team um okay so that I I just assume that that means that we don't need to dig up the field we're not taking the field offline to do any of this prior to correct okay correct um so that's good and then I guess the
096other question I had is I know we've talked about it I know that there was a different recommendation um from emac and I will you know I've been sitting on that committee and I'll say I really appreciate the time energy and dedication that they've had to finding out you know ways to best support use of the current system you know to reuse it as well as to um support you know the RTM Sumer with wanting to also reuse it um and taking into account the way the school uses uh Heat erir um so I think that was it's been really well thought out um but I assume that you know especially uh it changes a few things including reuse of of certain systems and re revising and redoing how we do things within the school
097so I was just curious to see if you knew if we go with this plant how long it what the estimate of the time for construction would take because I assume during that time uh the building would not have access to possibly heat or air conditioning because we obviously have to take it off offline and there's a change with the way that they were going to reconstruct some of it right so from a construction standpoint it would be the same kind of timeline as you would do in the traditional if you went with the other system so the the construction timeline should be identical there's the same amount of work inside the building that needs to happen um and a lot of the work for our solution some of the demo and everything can be
098done prior to you know taking things out and offline um so with with the temporary system you do have set up today obviously that can help support and back feed to anything that we do when we have to do take something offline um so in in our scenario I think the boiler system that's actually on the generator and on the backup heat you know it can provide heating for the building while we kind of work on some of the other things but ultimately we're trying to get this thing done in in the course of a summer right so that we don't want to have to deal with you know all of that stress and and stuff that comes with with the winter and things freezing right so if the school isn't used over the summer
099we can try and get in there get this done uh and get out of there and have it ready for the next year perfect you you gave me the exact answer I was looking for is that there's really no difference in time that the S you know and how and impact to the school and the students right depending on which system we we go with so that that answered that question thank you um I don't know you know if anybody else has questions I see no hands raised no no questions anyone so um I guess with that I I will I can turn it back over to I guess you know uh for Ben and Dan and because I suppose that the next question is for us as the board to have this discussion as
100to which option um it is we were going with uh for HVAC it seems the recommendation here is to um go with the new you know to to go and reuse the geothermal uh Wells with the revised recommendation for the system that will allow for um the school to switch from heating to cooling uh during the day uh as needed correct yes and uh depending on the vote whatever the the board votes tonight hopefully there is a vote tonight we would then uh tomorrow just it worked out very well with the inclement weather we now with the BET tomorrow we will be presenting the CIP sheet to have them include in in their deliberation when they for the budget okay so um I guess I can open the discussion and up to members of the
101board to to see what your thoughts are a about which system we would go with uh ver and as well as you know if we are in agreement to can certainly take a vote on that this evening I think we've we spent a lot of time over the years talking about it so um I'm not going to go with Dan's comment on moving forward but uh I'd like to try to take a vote on this this evening so we can we can put this in our budget request Sophie I was just gonna say I agree I think we've talked about this a lot I really appreciate all the work that's been done and I think I'm in favor of voting on this and I'm in favor of moving forward with the geothermal system okay uh
102I mean if every you know I don't know if anybody else's comments or things that they want to share I mean I'm perfectly happy to move forward to have that vote this evening um again I much like Sophie and especially after having sat with emac and reading through the report so much due diligence has been done and the fact that the school will be able to use the if we revise this the system to be able to use it in the way that best suits the needs of the school um it also supports another elected body's wish for us with regarding the RTM I'd like to be able to support that as well um and yes it's a minimal impact financially at the start but as you can see shows that uh that money comes
103back in other ways Mike I think you should I think you should amend your motion well I will I just we're still in that first piece of the discussion but I figure I have to I was waiting to amend it to see where you know we because I would make the based on the the choice and the finances Wendy you're muted Wendy thank you um I am not in favor of the geothermal uh unit for this particular project um I if I'm just worried that it puts the carnival at risk the the St Rock's Feast which I think is part of the community and part of the part of greenwich's tradition to have this and it's home to um our immigrant families and I think I I just think it would be terrible if if
104um we put that in Jeopardy okay I don't if anybody else has comments that they want to share um I'm happy to make a motion uh for one option and then see how that goes if it doesn't if it fails we can make a second motion Mike all right I'll talk again the um I appreciate Wendy bringing out the elephant in the room because for those people watching at home many of those questions board questions were about St rocks and things what I heard Chris say is that anything that we've done over the last 20 years hasn't impacted the wealth so I'm confident based on that that this is not um that there's nothing said here tonight that would prohibit us from continuing um the very important um tradition oh the St rocks which is
105just a feast which is just as important to the community probably as air conditioning um so I I don't I I I I appreciate Wendy bringing it up I don't see the two concepts in in com okay well our responsibility is to the schools and the students within them so that's what I'm going to focus on um and hopefully we can figure all of the other pieces out of Know Field use and whatever it's partially where I wanted to see if we needed to dig up the fields at all to do this so um I don't know if anybody else has any comments Dr Jones yeah I just I just want to remind the board because I think this is an issue we'll want to nail down but we didn't have the carnival since 2009
106when the geothermal was put in so we only have is it I think the last two years so we really don't know but we we need to work on trying to get get a good solid answer for this um because the idea that we are going to be able to manage staking out the field um every summer I don't think Dan Watson's team is going to have the time to do that and you used to be able to see the well head sitting on the top of the field and then when we leveled it all out and put in soil it's a little more challenging now than it it was even just five years ago so we obviously are going to have to look at that okay uh m hat I do agree with you
107Karen that our first priority is to the schools um although I know that we want to work in concert with different Community Partners um but our first our primary responsibilities to the schools and the function of those of that that school in particular and if we can strike a happy balance after great um but I think we need to keep our focus on what's best for the school and the the field yeah so this this vote is uh does anybody else have a a comment otherwise I'm just pulling up the the cost and I'll make I'll make a motion for one if it fails we'll we can make a motion for the other that works anyone comments okay um so uh I'd like to amend the motion the my initial motion made um to sorry
108uh add Hamilton add the ReUse of the re I don't know exactly how to say it I guess it's the uh reconstruction of the geothermal the cost of the Reconstruction of the geothermal cell system for Hamilton Avenue's HVAC of I'm sorry is it 5,2 46,000 uh to the FY 26 budget FY 26 Capital plan do I have a second I'll second okay Sophie Coen seconds um I will call it's a since we're on line I have to call for a a verbal vote uh M bead yes um Miss koven yes okay Mr M Dr mccan Anthony yes okay M Stow yes Laura m c yes Wendy no the also okay uh and then I know I always forget to take my own vote I'm a yes and as we know uh Cody is absent this
109evening so that is 610 yeah 610 so that passes um so I I'd like to so we can add those CIP sheets and if we could send those out to uh the BET as soon as possible this evening so that they have them prior to tomorrow morning um when we're meeting with them at 8:30 I would greatly appreciate it I would that be okay yeah we we can make that happen um and then I'd like to make a request because I know it is important to the community that you know I'm not sure if it would be through aeom if we need to or how we would do it is to um do look at the fields and see what kind of weight load uh it can take going forward so that we can you
110know figure that that out for uh other needs of the neighboring Community as well um the use of those fields if that's okay that that's not part of the motion but it's just a request um which leads us to our next uh topic uh is the amendment to the FY 26 Capital request for pool repairs uh excuse me for the grenwich high school and I know to make a motion we just got that earlier um and that would be the motion that I'm going to make is to I'd like to make a motion to amend the FY 26 Capital request for pool repairs uh once we have uh more details in regards to but well I'll just say I'm making a motion to amend the FY 26 Capital request for full repairs at ghs I
111don't know if I have a second I think you would want to say full repairs at the ghs pool we're F okay I will second that Karen thank you Miss koven and that we can open it up for discussion and you know so I'm gonna hand that back over to banon I'm gonna kick it over to Dan but before I do I we don't anticipate any action tonight I think uh some of the comments were shared as we dig into it but uh Dan really has been um digging into this this pool so I'm going to turn over to Dan to uh this gu so I just want to uh give you a little history on the pool um when the pool was and and bet I might go off a little bit here so
112kick me under the table um when the pool was originally made it was it wasn't deep enough and I still have yet to determine why the reason was that we added depth to the pool whether was uh a safety issue or whether it was to meet uh NCA rules be that as it may um the pool was made Deeper by putting a curb around it so that was done in uh 1997 I think it was the date and I I wish I had all my notes in front of me but I don't but in any event uh in the summer of 2024 we did did a um more of a cosmetic upgrade to the pool where we put a an epoxy deck coating on we took the tiles up that were showing age and were
113popping loose so we put a slip resistant uh deck coating on um came out very nice everything's very positive about it once it was completed we started noticing uh ponding water on one of the corners of the pool outside the pool on the deck and it appeared that the water was coming through a joint that was created when they added the concrete curb so the concrete curb in the original deck this what's called a cold joint and we thought and we still think that water was getting through that cold joint in any event uh we had some professionals come in we noticed uh more tiles inside the pool were coming loose at about that same elevation at various areas around the pool so we did some further investigation including we emptied the pool and um
114some questions came up about the drains that were at the bottom of the pool so in uh 2008 or 2009 it was a federal law that came out um stemming from a a horrible incident where a young girl lost her life um by being trapped by a pool um some a pool drain um so at that time they went into an immediate action they came up with a design um they did some repairs to the pool pool was put back in place everything was good to go but once we started looking at the pool this time around our professionals came up with an issue that they don't think that it's compliant so that's number one we've since then did a uh a quick remediation on the pool that included a a u an emergency button
115that would shut down the filtration and pump system immediately and we've installed it um and we've we've trained uh or we've discussed that with the athletic department and the coaching staff and we put in place uh uh requirement that somebody be at the pool at all times that their sole job is to be by that emergency shut off so that's number one um also while we're looking at the pool with this professional probably a bigger item came up is that there appears to be a Headroom issue with the diving board if anybody's been to the pool re recently or ever there's a large girder that is almost within reach of the diving board and I'm gonna say almost with reach if you if you're a non- diver you wouldn't think oh there's there's no way
116anybody would touch that uh but after doing some measurements with the professional uh it's non-conforming it's within uh a Headroom issue uh for diving standards so that's another problem we're having so we've talked with uh the engineer who's looking at it now as well as the engineer who did previous uh repairs there's some um differencing of opinions that we have yet to really come to the bottom of so that's that's where we're at right now um we we we see there's an issue it's just it really depends on how it's reviewed and um which engineer can prove to us whether it's inconformity or not so we we don't have much more to tell you other than that there are issues we are working on it at the present moment um the way the pool is
117operated uh we're we're okay uh with the pool itself okay um lot to take in there sorry yeah no I know I had sent a question in earlier and I I think you uh had answered some of it but I just was wondering if you had any information you know information as to any pro other than you know you mentioned the Curbing and the changes to the drainage um and shut off switch have there been and you know obviously in the decking but is have there been any other major or minor repairs done uh since the pool was originally installed uh to the best of my knowledge no we still have most of the original filtration and pumps um the electrical service is the same so um all that comes into play it's it it's
118there's a need of a major renovation and I I hate using that word but um you're gonna peel the onion here and so that when you said we have so the original uh electric and and stuff and filtration so we have not since the pool was opened in many years ago um we have not I just wanted to see if we've replaced any of the systems or major components so we haven't replaced heating filtration not not in a whole a wholesale scale I mean there may have been you know a component to a pump that may have been changed but the actual pumps or the actual filters themselves no they're they're original to the uh installation I mean I personally love a good you know vintage piece but probably not in my pool so all
119right Sophie um thank you Dan for that update um I think I just wanted to mention I'm I'm very familiar with the pool I spent a lot of time there um because I have a son who plays water pool and swims so yeah I I know how it looks and um it's my understanding that the curb was put around the pool partly because the pool is used both for um varsity and JV girls and boys swimming and also water polo um so the pool is is really much too shallow um to be used for water po but we do the best that we can but my understanding is I think that that was part of the reason the curb was put in place is just to even um make it somewhat more workable for um
120for those teams to use it um the pool originally was put in in the 1970s right when the school was originally built is that right Dan um yeah but I don't have the exact year I think it was an added attraction I don't think it was uh there when the pool when the school opened they don't have those notes but it's sort of roughly about 50 years old I would say before 74 but again so so we're talking about a 50-year-old facility um yes right okay so I mean I appreciate that we're in early days of thinking about what's going on with a pool but a 50 50 years um for a pool is a long time um so I'm not surprised that we're we're seeing some issues and it feels like maybe There's an
121opportunity to do something here you know that you know could significantly improve the quality of facility if we if we need to explore all of these different issues as you were saying it's going to be peeling the layers off of the onion and you know my concern is when you have a facility that's nearing end of life you know we're going to see problem after problem so I just I hope that you know for us as a board that we can start thinking about okay how do we want to approach this problem and be smart about it um because we have a lot of great programs going on there we have I think it's 116 athletes participating um in competitive Sports in that pool every year um and we still do some quatics um for
122the Freshman so it's a busy place and so I'm sure this will be complicated and I'm glad that you're looking into it appreciate it and um I think we'd just like to get updates as they come in Mike yeah I'm sorry if you said this D the I st out did um um what's our time frame here um um if we trying to we're we're trying to make the 20 um we're trying to make this year's budget vote so is that what I'm hearing that was our original game plan uh and as we continue to do our due diligence we had more questions and answers and so so right now it's TBD but we're definitely not in position to uh ask for any dollar amount uh unless the BET brings it up we don't plan
123to bring it up uh tomorrow because we don't have a formal uh quest in front of them okay that makes that makes sense I don't see any other hands up um I guess so I'll ask uh a question having I mean granted pool at this High School is indoors so it's probably slightly different I know we have a pool a in my backyard uh that was also put in the 19 in the 1970s and I know just in the uh you know 20 years or whatever that I've been here how much money we've had to put in and how many times we've had to replace things like the filter and and other equipment so I'm amazed that the stuff at the high school has lasted uh and is workable as long as it has so
124um I the question I guess I would have for for Ben and for Tony is um do we have any any funding um to do an actual review of what would need to be done uh to improve the the pool getting pricing for uh you know if we need to change the depth we obvious and change the filtration to meet the current uh uh legal requirements for those not the filtration excuse me the um the filters at the bottom uh and sides because obviously we would need to have some kind of idea of of cost to do all of this work so so Dan has engaged the professional uh uh to to do some of this work and we're we're finding the money I believe out of our operating budget for some of that design
125we have zero dollars for any Capital so that's why once we have an understanding of what what is what is on the table what can be addressed it'll have to be uh an interim or uh depending on the the frequency or the the cycle we put it in the capital plan uh next year or it all depends on what we know we just don't know right now the timing yeah I assume we also don't know the actual extent of the work that needs to be fully done and what needs to be replaced versus you know beab so correct yeah Sophie I'm just wondering when do you have a sense of when he might have a recommendation or be able to present findings I I want the short answer is no because we really we really
126were trying to make it for this meeting and just the stars did not align with the consultant schedules and their workload and as we kept digging so I just any number any any date I'd give you would I would be making it up and I would okay that's fine no I appreciate your honesty so we'll find out when we find out thank you okay does anybody else have any questions um I would like I know you guys mentioned this before and I know it was mentioned in the information that was you know shared with us but you know again I want to ensure that people know that the pool we have added workaround so the pool is safe for students uh to be in it so I know we're talking about questions about rehabbing and
127doing work to the pool um to bring it up uh to standards and things but it this pool is is safe for our students uh to be in there so we're not looking at an immediate uh issue correct correct if it wasn't safe we wouldn't have it open I just wanted to make sure that that was very clear um as we're having this discussion tonight so that we don't have anybody that misunderstands it that the pool isn't currently safe so um so then I guess I'd like to table the motion to add you know that was made earlier in regards to this uh to you know when we have more information T table the action on this Ken can I just one quick question uh sure I also Jen I don't know if your hand
128went up but Sophie and then if Jen has a question I wasn't sure um Ben you may not be able to answer this question but do you feel like we have adequate funds you know in the operation operating budget to do like a thorough analysis of the pool or do we need to ask you know that's what I just asked too earlier yeah sorry I'm know still TBD unfortunately we okay we have enough to what we started and just depends on how how deep we go and how much farther we have to go we may have to we may may have to ask but we're we're trying to do our due diligence the best we can okay sorry to be repetitive Thanks Jen I don't know if you were just stretching or you actually had
129a question no just stretching okay um so uh if that is all for this evening I there's a motion that can be made on well before I you know before we make that motion I did want to thank um you know aom and our high school administration and all the other people who are coming here and sharing this information with us this evening because I see a lot of you are still here this evening um but with that I don't know if there's a motion that somebody would like to make this evening aaren you need to withdraw your motion first so this oh I'm sorry I thought I did I said I I said that before but I can do it again I that I was t i was wanted to table the motion I
130guess I will withdraw the motion to a later date as opposed to saying I'm tabling it is that correct Mike excellent thank you thank you Sophie I would like to make a motion okay I'd like to make a motion to adjourn okay there second Wendy all right I'm gonna have to do this verbally so Sophie yes Mike yes Laura Laura Laura you're muted you're muted I unmuted to say yes okay thank you Jen yes Wendy yes Kathleen yes and I too am a yes and uh with that prior to saying uh thank you to everybody wanted to wish uh all of our staff and our students and parents a wonderful February break as I know that uh is coming up next week and uh say I look forward to seeing the BET members tomorrow and
131having uh in-depth discussions about our about our budget so thank you and uh have a nice even night