CorpusRecord 113555

January 28, 2025 CMSBC Special Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Greenwich Public Schools
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,534 words · about 20 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001before 8 o'clock still waiting for another voting member Tony Turner hopefully to join us I did not receive his I contacted everybody I did not get any confirmation from Tony that he would be joining us but I'll we have another minute or so to um wait for his appearance and we'll try to start promptly here this morning youone don't see Turner on yet okay that we need him Joe this is Todd you can hear me yes okay okay it's uh I have eight o'clock January H Tony Turner just joined us excellent excellent okay it's again 8:00 28 January 2025 this is is the Central Middle School building committee special meeting for today uh meetings called to order if you will join me please in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of

002the United States of America and to the Republic for which stands one nation under God indivisible Liberty justice for all thank you very much Christina could you call R yes I can um one second please all right um Jo Rosetti present oh and it's worth noting this is a fully virtual meeting thank you be on Virtual uh CLA kill Gallen Claire I see you but I don't hear you oh present there you thank you Christina present as well Harry fiser here Laura C here thank you Tony Turner Tony's here thank you uh Josh caspy here Todd CLA heard you earlier Joe Kelly I'm here thank you Dennis Yi Pres Steph Coy here Lauren Raven Rachel coven Susan Rudolph silver yeah Tom Healey all right Joe back to you okay regards voting members I have eight

003voting members uh said present I did not hear Todd CLA CLA are you on you were on a moment ago I think he's having audio issues Joe here I'm here sorry very good thank you uh we have uh two items on our agenda this morning the item it's label item three GMP discussion and potential vote and number four is the bid Bond discussion and possible action uh going to try to make this meeting relatively brief but uh comprehensive so focusing now on we have no housekeeping or adjustments I do not believe Claire any of comments on housekeeping or adjustments no good okay item number three GMP discussion and potential vote for approval uh I want to make a few comments regards this um we uh have been presented on the exhibit a exhibit a amendment

004to our to our agreement uh dated 23 January 2025 exhibit a essentially is the GMP proposal by Turner dated 23 January 2025 uh best most recent version of the GMP includes schedule one which is the listed of all the bids basically and allowances a comprehensive price essentially and one one change to that to that GMP most recent change is a uh for bid package 11 uh is a basically a $3.2 million allowance for masonry uh over the past week or a couple of weeks uh we have seen withdrawals by the masonry two masonry contractors of their lower bids and now we have Turner carrying an allowance for that work of 3.2 million we will talk about the withdrawal of bids and the bid Bonds in our next item item four bid Bond discussion but for

005the for the moment the focus is on the GMP Amendment also on schedule five uh of the GMP Amendment uh there by the way I just want to remind everybody did have all these documents over the weekend and you've had many many opportunities to take a look and make comments on so I'm just trying to focus on some key points that is in the recent most recent GMP amendment in schedule five item number four Roman numeral 8 uh was a uh a note added to have Turner provide us a construction schedule by the end of February 2025 and also and items clarification number 8 C uh the Builder's risk language and references were uh tweaked and amended and edited multiple times toh show a a builder's risk coverage through phase two which is essentially late

0062026 so those are the the few key items that have been changed most recently I do appreciate everybody I think everybody's had an opportunity to comment on this GMP uh contribute talk to our attorney discuss with him be included on several meetings uh Etc and by the way in your most recent packet you hopefully you all read Shipman Goodwin's uh summary of the edits and changes and discussions that we've had over the last several weeks gards the GMP and uh I think his opinion is fairly clear and in a positive way recommends or suggests or Pines that uh it's ready for approval um okay those are my comments Peter Raider do you have any comments to offer or add regards the current GMP Amendment yeah only only that I you know just Echo the sort

007of comprehensive review and appreciate all the support in doing that so I think uh you know we're we're happy to offer a recommendation for your the committee's approval this morning thank you um Steve Mario or Kemp are you on would you offer any comments or suggestions I'm here Joe uh no I think what we saw seems appropriate thank you and Tim are you on or Jo they are on they are in as attendees and need to be elevated to panelists but I don't have the power to do that yes did it him are you any any comments before we might take an action on the GMP uh no Joe I just got elevated uh no I don't have any further comment I just one final comment that I do have the the the proposed price

008uh just to make sure it's clear is 93,587 1800 that's uh in written in the exhibit a to the GMP um okay so I've made my comments any discuss further discussion from anybody any comments clarifications very good Laura did you want to make a motion oh I would like to move that we approve the GMP and if there's a specific motion I have to say other than that uh tell me I'll second that I have Laura C making a motion to approve the GMP um and Joe Kelly seconding it I'd like to make uh clarify or see if if GLA is Con concurs with this motion language uh motion is to approve and execute exhibit a dated 23 January 2025 the guaranteed maximum price Amendment between owner Board of Education town of Greenwich and the

009construction manager Turner Construction company with a guaranteed maximum price of 93,587 $800 you okay with yes please amend my motion to reflect what uh Joe red he just said thank you very much I second it would apply to that as well okay thank you have a motion second uh any further discussion Christina could you take a roll call vote please yeah uh Joe Rosetti yeah approved yes is a yes Harry fiser yes Laura Coston yes Tony Turner yes Josh caspy yes Todd Claire Todd Joe Kelly yes uh I'm gonna Circle back Todd more time before all right 800 I'm just going to Mark Todd is not being here I don't see him necessarily all right the Joe the motion should pass but I think you're technically supposed to say it Tod okay he's um sorry

010I thought he rejoined Tim is in the attendance again one moment please bear with me I don't see Todd in the panelist list anymore so he may have had connection issues okay so uh what's the conclusion of the vote Christina please all right motion passes thank you very much on that um moving to item number four midbond discussion and possible vote for Action um I just want to kind of summarize what this issue is is um again with respect to bid package 11 uh shown in schedule one masonry Turner is carrying an allowance of 3o $2 million and a few few more dollars uh why the reason why they're carrying that allowance is because over the last couple of weeks as mentioned a few moments ago there's been a the two low biders have withdrawn

011their bids that caused us several people on the committee to wonder well gee we have a bid Bond what can we not pursue the or pursue a compensation underneath the bid bond to recover some of the potential losses that we might have by going to the next highest bidder um we've had several discussions with our attorney Bob O'Brien from Shipman Goodwin about courses of action uh I've been on the call I know Joe Kelly and Josh caspy have been on the call I think uh Claire I think you might have been on one call prior to that so there's been a few of us have discussed with theor what our possible actions are um the the gist of this is that well I'm gonna let I'm gonna let Peter kind of summarize our discussion if

012that if that's okay Peter we want to you want to a little bit thanks sure so um you know I think we heard the whole the whole group loud and clear kind of frustration around um the the biders dropping out and our capacity to go and and uh pursue the bid Bond so uh we did do a deep dive into that looking at every bid really and there were several we've developed a a matrix for us to track that um and and use that to manage our review with with our attorney um and the long and short of it is there were for number of technical reasons and I think our attorney did that so I think th those who joined the call understand the kind of comprehensive review that they did um he cded

013took a look at case law and and that there wasn't a lot within Connecticut but there was you know a few cases nationally so kind of echoing the sentiment that we heard with some of the folks leading into that that there's not a lot of precedent that being said um there were kind of uh for a number of reasons um re we the the focus came around the potential for um pursuing if if the committee was interested in that um in uh the the masonry but for a number of technical reasons you know in terms of the language with the two biders um we thought the position in pursuing the original low bid Fernandez if the committee decided to be was was our best chance but it was really in the end uh not recommended

014for a number of reasons and and and it had to do with the language in terms of accepting the bid and what constituted that so really we couldn't accept the bid without Contracting with Fernandez who knew right this during the scope review fell short um so where we ended up landing at the end of these multiple conversations was the best course of action for the committee or for we thought um for the project would be to reject all bids and rebid that scope um and and that's where we are we just had that Co conversation the last one yesterday um coming out of that I think that's our recommendation as well um we had a a fair amount of conversation about who you know whether those two biders could come back to the table or

015not um those that's all to be determined but right now I think we're looking for the committee's alignment with that approach so and uh see a number of question so Joe um and then Harry Joe Kelly thank you uh yes uh the information given to us by the attorney was very helpful uh I'm certainly uh uh very upset with these biders pulling out but one thing I did detect in the uh summary from the attorney is that uh not that we have a lot of processes or biders left to do certainly this one if we rebid it uh but we have to make sure Peter that the our our that tuners uh uh tightens up their uh uh firms up their procedural process uh I understand there was some flaws uh which would made it

016harder uh for us to sue for these uh uh these bonds uh because of the uh not foll exactly as the attorney said we probably should have so if we can maybe get some more information from the attorney on how this should be done properly and whatever whatever biddings we have going forward which are not many maybe it's not worth it at this at this at this point but certainly a note to the next building committee to uh to make sure that uh there uh that these these processes are done properly so we can in fact go after the bid I understand one of the biders only put 5% or was only allowed to put 5% when we require 10% we can't allow that to happen again if we P perfect this process and uh

017uh and we can actually go after these big bonds uh then basically we uh uh we have to make sure that the full 10% is down and that way we follow the procedures that the attorney suggests we follow in order for us to gain these because the reason why these these bid bonds are in place so these these people can't withdraw their bids and uh and hurt our project uh so uh so Peter if you could make sure whatever little we have going forward and Joe if we could pass on to uh uh to the next building committee that they should make sure they tighten up this process process would be my recommendation thank you thank you yes absolutely Joe yeah I have I have two questions first one is does this affect the schedule

018because concrete's one of the early projects so so Harry kapaso we've um engaged for the concrete they were the second Mason so right now um uh we're talking about rebidding the masonry package only and not concrete so so the quick answer short answer is we anticipate around a 3-week rebid process so there should be no impact on the schedule no no significant impact and the second is I'm I'm a little lost on on how many biders withdrew um and are are we purs are we not pursuing any of those well we had um the Fernandez was the original low they withdrew in the end for uh um I'm trying to recall the split between the two I I believe they were a mathematical error um and then so then um and that came out of

019um Turner having done their scope review um so following the scope review they came back a number of weeks after that to say withdrawing our bid and that's actually one of the primary reasons why if we were pursuing um any action we feel like the attorney felt like our our case would be stronger with Fernandez now so then the next uh the next bidder up was capasso um once um once Fernandez withdrew their bid um uh again Turner did a scope review the very next day they came back and withdrew their bid um and for I guess I believe they cited an administrative clerical error um or something to that effect and so um again um we leaned on our attorney to aine on that and the language and he felt given that scenario we

020don't have a case you know as much standing there um so I'm I'm giving a little bit of context I'm getting a little longwinded the concern is that we still in rebidding this we need to have a competitive environment Turner I know um when we yeah we first bid this it's right so we don't necessarily want to discount these biders or or at least making sure that we get a sampling but to Joe's Point um Joe Kelly's Point um you know we need to um insert some additional language or processes to um make sure we don't you know encounter the same kind of situation so yeah weren't there other trades that also withdrew there were and and we reviewed those with the attorney so the shade pocket for example um that bid was under 100,000

021so we actually didn't have a bid Bond um with them because it didn't have it didn't reach that value um and uh in in the other cases um again the uh language around the the um the contract um with not having entered into a contract with Turner um for the other bids um Bob um from Shipman and Goodwood felt like we did not have a case so um the one he felt like if we were interested in pursuing that we perhaps had a case for would be Fernandez but even with that it's a lengthy process likely he said over a year legal fees are things we would not recoup um and so you know we have to balance sort of the the benefit um and and just I'm sorry I did take the so much

022time but one more what was the low bid versus the $3 million allowance and what's our risk of a bid coming in above of three million yeah um Jose do you recall or you want to we can bring that up um so Harry the uh the low bid was at the two five and we're about a $700,000 difference I think Turner or Tim or Joe can take their allowance how they how they factored that in but um there was about a uh from the first low bid to the third bidder um there was about $700,000 uh value difference but we are at risk under the three million it would seem yeah that is that is correct Jose um the low bidder was 2.5 the value of the allowance is the value of the third bid

023okay thank you yeah and and and the adequate bid um pool is important I Katie from Turner noted on our call yesterday I think we had guys reached out to 14 or so biders right and we we received Tim refreshed my memory was it five or six four yeah and so um again I we we uh in in looking at this one bidder coming back after the scope review what is what is you know what is the potential ad there they they did discuss some numbers but obviously you know and and based on the that input they probably still would be the low and and Turner was ready to execute that contract with them they've done work with them before so they're a qualified bidder so again we we to Joe Kelly's point we want

024to make sure we have some additional steps in place with rebidding this but that you know we we shouldn't necessarily discount that for that bit or for that reason right so um we we need to get the best price um to deliver it for for you guys I that's our goal here I would take from that that that the the guys that Rene could come back and bid again they potentially could you know I mean you know and and honestly the bid Bond you know having um you know I mean this part of the bid open bid process right where we open the bids on on that we record the low bids that's part of public knowledge all of the biders see that and then when we re go back and then have to do

025a scope review and talk it's you know there's something fundamentally uh you know perhaps you know not right in that process but that's our the process we have to follow so it's truly truly unfortunate the way this is played out because of what you just said it's all now public information yeah yeah so I wish we had a little bit more latitude in that unfortunately we don't so right yeah okay thank you Harry Harry some of the discussion was uh was should we if we go to rebid should we allow or not allow the two low biders that withdrew to bid and and by do if we did do that not permit them to rebid it would again limit the pool a potential so it's it's just this Balancing Act we're trying to pull off

026and get do the best kind of stepping back trying to be pragmatic about this and do the the right thing for our job not to not to stand on uh uh you know rules and regulations I get it moral Authority Claire just in terms of next steps um you said it's a threee process when are you talking about that happening and uh I'd like to understand it there seems to be from what I gather a gap in the processes um in terms of the tightening up I I would if it's possible I don't want to put a burden onto GPS purchasing but I know they had definitely had viewpoints when the bid originally went out um that we that uh there's a collaboration um between Turner and GPS purchasing if they're able to give their

027advice on uh the processes and how the package is put out sure I can take that we have already had conversations with GPS purchasing um through the first round of bidding uh we were in lock step with GPS purchasing we followed the as requirements um the the gaps in the processes that are being alluded to again I'd be very um very um um I wonder what those are um I was on the call last night as well and I didn't hear Bob O'Brien bring up any specific Gap in a process we bought public work before so I'm interested in what those are so that we can um make sure we we we fix those if there was something that we did incorrectly but the reflection that Turner did something and there's gaps in our processes

028I'm not aware what those are Yeah Tim can I just clarify I think I think the statement was referring to the 5% bid Bond instead of a 10% bid Bond um so the the owner has the rights so we at that time when we got a 5% bid Bond we could have disqualified the bid immediately um but the owner does have the right to to wave inconsistencies is the term so the bill in the committee at that time waved that instead of disqualifying the low bid we move forward with the 5% bid bond that was provided now again that does put you at disadvantage because then you can't go after a 10% bid Bond right there wasn't an an expectation at that point we would be doing that so we didn't disqualify the bid we

029mve forward the low bidder so I don't know if that was the issue that maybe was being presented as were procedures weren't being followed um but the owner was able to take advantage of the 5% bid bond by keeping the low bidder so that therefore they didn't have the advantage of a 10% value um in the future which which ended up coming up right right I hope that clarifies that that was the one of the issues good good point Joe yeah and and uh Claire uh we have been talking with Eugene and Karen and and and uh um procurement uh to make sure you know I know they've committed if if we this is the path we decide as a committee um that that they're on standby to help us move this through quickly um

030I know um you know there's some discussions about with a rebid you know what that front end looks like to make sure we meet all of their requirements so there's a little bit of work um but we would hope to do that very quickly right and and and uh Turner has kind of been on board with that as well in terms of the bid package it's you know the drawings and and the specs essenti they're all the same right so um much of the documentation will be the same um it's just um making sure we satisfy the specific requirements that Eugene's office will have with a rebid um and uh and making sure that we get the yeah I'm just wondering if the if the failure of the biders to calculate property um is how

031much of it is there error versus perhaps Clarity in the documents I'm not saying there wasn't Clarity of the documents but it's I think it's good to just double check and maybe it's adding a cover sheet or calling attention to Salient points that were were Miss that we got in feedback if we did from these bids as to why they um you know reneged in essence yeah yeah and that's where I think Bob O'Brien was good in taking making sure we did a very comprehensive review he wasn't quick to dismiss because he hasn't seen a lot of case around this you know cases around this he looked at the merits of this and said you know looking at some of the there were B basically three requirements in within the bit bond that had to

032have been met and he he went through in a very systematic way so I think that's why you know in looking at that um and it's really that Contracting requir not even just the acceptance of the bids that was the um which is why we're kind of suggesting we reject all the bids and um uh and and um and rebid this so short of that the only way we would really be in a position to go after this bid would be to pursue it with you know and and and start to enter into a contract with a bidder that we know doesn't have the scope right which is not what we're interested just to be able to challenge this so that's not what we're interested in what we're interested in is making sure they've got

033the scope captured in their number for the best price so okay any further discussion uh I'd like to make a motion that we uh rebid bid package 11 excuse me that we number one reject all bids for bid package 11 and rebid bid package 11 masonry uh opening up the bids to as normal all all public uh qualified biders to include uh those that may have withdrawn their bids in the previous bid request I'll second that Joe thank you Joe Kelly uh Christina can we do a quick vote on that roll call please uh yes uh Joe Rosetti yes to rebid Claire kill Gallen K gallon yes Christina POS yes Yuri fiser yes La C yes Tony Turner yes Josh caspy yes Tod Claire Joe Kelly yes 800 very good thank you uh that concludes

034our items for this special meeting uh any further questions or comments our next building committee meeting is next week at four on four February 8 o'clock at the havm building uh without further comments that concludes and uh our meeting do I have a motion to adjourn kill gallon motion to adjourn thank you very much everybody for participating in the GMP the votes today and I do mean everybody the entire committee and project team very good work we're looking forward to Turner and their team being out there on site they are already on site if you haven't been out there they doing some going to town so we appreciate that very much uh I think we officially need a second second toj very first or second thank you very much meeting adjourned good job Jo Rosetti

035good job this is a big step forward good job well done agreed thank you all Jose can you stay on the phone Jose yep I got you Joe uh so I need we need to get together yep I just want to stop

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.