001it's 7:01 and uh I will call the meeting to order um and like to start with the uh Pledge of Allegiance so if we could all stand I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible and with liberty and justice for all um next item on our uh list is the consent agenda um and uh I I have to double check but I was going to split the approvals into two as uh Miss beet was not uh here for the first part of those uh minutes in order so should not be voting on them so I don't know if anybody wants to make a motion but I'm happy to make a motion to approve um the minutes from June
00212th both meetings from June 12th both meetings from October 7 October 24th and October 25th as well as believe it's November 1st and 7th do I have a second wait how are you breaking them up I'm just sort of confused I was breaking them up into the meetings prior to adding the an eighth member a versus you know after prior to an after okay second okay so all in favor uh I have to since we're virtual I have to ask Kathleen yes Jen oh you're abstaining um I assume Jen the the dates that you listed just for clarification some of them I was there the November November and December she was there November and December I I didn't add no I said November 1 which I don't think you were there for were you there
003for November 1 yeah everything after the okay that was the only one I added okay do you want to amend your motion I can amend my motion uh for the minutes up to uh you know through October 25th so second okay if you could include November 1st that was an exposion hearing okay I did have I had that initially and then yeah then I don't then I will remove the amended mention amended uh motion I'm withdrawing my amended motion and I'll stick with the initial one through November 1 okay okay kathlen yes Jen obene Laura yes Sophie yes Wendy no I have an going I have an ongoing objection our resolution before we should be voting on these obain you're abstaining Michael Joseph Mike uh I'm abstaining I didn't get a chance to as everybody
004know you might know I'm down with the flu so I didn't get a chance to review yes okay these were uh yeah coming from you know from June through October so um all right so they pass with a 53 53 did you vote Karen oh sorry myself as a yes um okay so then I will I think it was 431 to be clear 413 413 sorry yeah 413 okay sorry about that thank you um so I will make a motion to approve the minutes uh you know the consent agenda for the minutes for November 7th November 21st and December 12th second okay I will do a voice call again Kathleen yes Jen yes Laura yes Sophie yes Wendy no okay Cody St Mike okay so that would be I and I'm a yes as well
005so that is yes okay so then we can from there we can move on to and I have noted um Wendy's uh a comment um and I'd like to make sure that's reflected um and then you're welcome and then I'd like to move on to the public hearing our first uh speakers for the evening are our student government uh Representatives I know we have a change this evening uh as Rocky is uh participating in a sporting event and we'll have mave speaking uh as a senior class president along with me here Shaw hi can you guys hear hear me yep all right hello Dr Jones chair herish and members of the board my name is miir Shaw and I'm the student body vice president at grish high school it's great to be back speaking with
006you in the new year at ghs the students are hard at work studying for the midterm exams we've been studying all month which culminated in the eight block review day on Tuesday the school and Greenwich Community has very accommodating to the studying students from all schools inviting therapy dogs into grch High School promoting studying in the school media center teachers expanding their office hours and even the Greenwich Library hosting their annual study escape the student body could not be more grateful for these amenities recently in student government we discussed new fundraiser and event opportunities the freshman and sophomore classes are brainstorming ways to bring together the ninth and 10th graders for a joint social event in the spring the juniors are planning ahead for their Pi Day fundraiser which is on March 14 last year
007the fundraiser saw many staff members including our own SRO Wall-E and Mr silkman getting pied during lunch block finally we are in the process of developing a student government newsletter in order to share School news and future events the important ideas Behind these events are to Foster school spirit with midterms ceasing next Tuesday the student body is looking for a way to relieve the nerves of the huge exams it's our job to Foster popular events and get students active into spirited moods on top of this a goal that I personally have is to promote athletic and Performing Arts events to our students for instance our girls basketball team is undefeated after having a hot start to their season the boys basketball team is also having an important home stretch of games with a home gaming
008new can in tomorrow night the hockey team is also showing off their success and has big home games at Dorothy H finally our music groups the choir orchestra and Band came together in December for their first annual Candlelite con concert which was a beautiful performance and a huge hit across our community these events alongside the class events are very fun ways for the students to celebrate ghs thank you for inviting me to speak tonight and now I would like to introduce mave KY our ghs senior class president hi there can you hear me yes we can hear you welcome amazing well hi there and good evening Board of uh members of the Board of Education Dr Jones and community members my name is ma Cary and I'm the senior class president at ghs I'm happy
009to be here tonight to provide an update on the current activities needs and feedback from our student body first I'd like to highlight our recent discussions in student government the senior class has reached a very big milestone as most college applications have been submitted and we were recently introduced to the senior options program that we will participate in later this spring as many students eagerly await decisions on post high school plans student government is planning fun events and fundraisers to ease the stress our school's winter spirit week was a major highlight prior to break and was a great way to lift Spirits events like this is not this not only boost school spirit but also provide an opportunity for students to build connections across different grades additionally we are excited to be participating in the
010districtwide pajama day on febu Friday February 7th the day before we begin February break it's a big event for students to raise funds and create awareness for children battling cancer at Connecticut's children's hospital and finally since we've been back most students main concern has been midterms on behalf of my classmates I'd like to emphasize the importance of continuing and expanding support for academic resources and support for mental health health during these weeks as they can be particularly stressful thank you for inviting me to speak tonight thank you so much for joining us this evening ma um hope you guys are uh doing well with your midterms so you know if you're not here we'll we'll know you're home studying uh next up is our GAA president Lil Peron Lil are you there I am here
011welcome you might hear my dogs in the background so um all right so I'm getting tired of saying the same thing I've been saying it for two years and I've been preparing everyone about what the what's happening with uh in Connecticut and with teachers uh teachers leaving shortage of teachers shortage of Paris or shortage of subs and uh you know I don't buy that uh you know greenish never wants to be like any other district and I'm tired of hearing that um about oh it's it's okay for other districts we've never we've never ever done that so my dog's crying right now I wish you could hear them so uh you know uh we can't hide behind what the issue is and you know I've been in Greenwich for 37 years and we have never
012had teachers leave the district we have never had teachers uh offer jobs and turn them down the reality is here and the reality is here and I'm tired of talking about the same thing and um I'm tired of people hiding behind bet whatever who's ever making the decisions in the district and it has nothing to do with the border of bed you guys I respect you you have done what you need to do but I am tired of people hiding behind this is good for grenage no they're hiding behind that sentence this is not good for grenage and you know you will all be exposed and we will be at those meetings and my parents and everyone are behind me my teachers and we will be seeing what you vote and we will be there
013in November and this is this is so bad for the teachers it's so bad for people if you're not in the buildings and no the shortage area of subs and parah impacts every single student teachers have to cover classes teachers have to be Paras Services cannot be delivered as they should be at the full level and I will be delivering and educating at all the BET meetings and with all my parent families because I was at the PAC meeting and the parents are asking for what they can talk about and asking for how they can help and you could probably hear my dog cry in the background because I practice my speeches on them I don't know if you hear them um we will be there we will be there so we will be educating
014everyone and I'm I'm done with these speeches and I will bring every possible force that I can and I want to thank personally I lobby at the state and I want to personally thank all my grenage Representatives uh Senator Ryan fio stepen Mesker uh hect um you know Rob Sam in my area Rob Samson Leslie zupkis and all those other people when I Lobby whove come visiting my home I will be at the state lobbying for things and I want to thank personally the the Greenwich uh and Stanford you hear my dog thank them all because um we they support me they support grenage um and this connec Family Leave is was a good thing but teachers aren't hourly employees so I know Hector will be working with me at the state level um we're
015listening I just want to put it out there for those people that are saying oh it's good for grage I'm gonna hold you accountable that's it uh thank you lil uh next up is our PTA council president John Fisher hi excuse me um hi sherff Cher hirch Boe memb superintendent Dr Jones everyone online thank you for this opportunity to speak I'm John fiser the Gren PTA council president parent of two of the 8,513 great kids in the Greenwich Public Schools the PDA council is the umbrella organization made up by and for the independent PT in town we have just under 4,000 PTA families in Greenwich who together spend more than one and A4 million annually to enhance the learning experience of every student and to support our teachers we appreciate the boe's broad strong support
016for the proposed operating budget with the vote at the last Boe meeting now all eyes and ears and attention shifts to the bet the 800B gorilla in the budget process for the benefit of everyone listening the next steps in the budget process are on January 28th the BET budget meeting starting at 6 PM town hall meeting room where the first selectman presents the proposed Town budget and the Boe and the superintendent present the school's budgets and then everyone has the opportunity to speak out to the bet at that meeting on February 6 the BET budget committee will hold an all day meeting on the school's budget with lots of detail and Q&A on March 26 the full bet will hold a public hearing on the schools budgets only starting at 7 pm at Central Middle
017School that meeting is specifically to give everyone an opportunity to speak out to the bet about the school school's budgets Pac strongly requests that the Boe members and the budget committee members in particular attend these meetings especially the February 6th bet budget committee meeting we know from years of experience attending that meeting many bet members join and there is typically a lot of conjecture about all the various places in the budget where big budget where big Cost Cuts can be made the only true experts on these questions are the Boe members and especially the Boe budget committee members to quote Mr KD again as I did before we have all this mandatory spending and very little control over that there's not a lot in the budget to argue about the percent change possible is really
018not much we're counting on the Boe budget committee members to provide that authoritative voice in the BET budget discussions turning very quickly to the agenda we note the late addition of the discussion item about changing the waiting of midterm and finals grades at ghs we will highlight that there are strong opinions on this topic and call on the Boe to objectively Del be to be objectively deliberate in considering this before you vote on it we also note the discussion on the on the proposal for the new ghs modern band music course which my teenagers thought was a good idea uh and we note the action item on the Riverside feasibility study and we urge the Boe to ensure that this continues to move forward expeditiously with that uh I wish uh doc uh to get
019over that flu quickly uh and I thank you all for your public service and for this time to speak thank you so much John um and I will hand this over to uh Miss C our secretary for Community comments uh our first speaker is uh Carrie Bisby and um I will keep time uh wor two minutes or three minutes two minutes three minutes what are we giving them no the public speak the opportunity to speak we give each individual speaker three minutes um and as a reminder to to you know be civil and and so forth yeah uh so Carrie you have three minutes and um uh if she could be elevated so she could speak that would be great I have been can you guys hear me yes okay good evening I'm Carrie Bisby
020Riverside School parent and PC facilities Committee Member the Riverside School Community has waited a long time for a renovation project and we are excited that a vision now exists for what our school building could become in hopefully just a few years you may have received emails about it in recent days and I expect you can see a number of people currently tuned in to hear tonight's presentation this evening you will hear from others who will go into greater detail about elements of the project that are particularly important to our community on that note I'd like to call attention to an email you received highlighting the school's inability to follow proper allergy safe kitchen protocols due to lack of space and I encourage you to take note of that when evaluating the proposed kitchen expansion overall
021the vision laid out in these Ed specs brings our school building up to standard in three ways first it fixes long-standing accessibility Safety and Security issues the fact that these compulsory elements of the project are very likely to get done doesn't diminish their importance and urgency when it comes to creating a safe environment second it calls for an accompanying renovation that brings the building into the 21st century this is a 90-year-old building and it's not clear as schoolwide renovation has ever been done peac mealing improvements is not cost-efficient and does not leave us with a highquality facility the work should be done to a degree that makes this project last for decades to come third it includes an expansion that gives the building the space it needs the proposed rear addition is not extravagant and
022includes no incremental change to the number of K5 grade level classrooms despite those being in short supply just last year instead it provides the room to bring grade level classrooms roughly in line with current size standards it creates additional small spaces for instructors and service providers who currently use hallways repurposed closets and shared spaces it allows us to right siize our small cafeteria kitchen Health suite and administrative offices and it creates a multi-purpose room for the dozens of Hands-On learning experiences and assemblies that occur and would end the ongoing pattern of displacing teachers and playing metaphorical games of musical chairs to carve out space for these typ of activities as you can see these are practical fixes that give the building what it needs to provide a safe comfortable learning environment that the children and
023our community deserve lastly with the town's budget development process on the horizon it is important that the BET has the most reliable information as it makes decisions about funding this project to that end while we know it will take time to properly vet these Ed specs we ask that you approve a final version ahead of the BET's decision day on April 1st thank you for your support thank you so much Carrie our next speaker is Betsy mckintyre I'm not seeing her on oh okay she Rose her can you hear me we hear you go ahead thank you good evening my name is Betsy McIntyre and I'm a parent and the PTA co-president at Riverside School tonight tonight I'm here in support of the proposed Riverside renovation plans and specifically want to focus on the need
024to expand classroom size and our cafeteria and kitchen facilities Riverside has some of the smallest classrooms in the district averaging 738 Square ft this figure is significantly below the Connecticut state standard of 850 Square ft for grades 1 through 5 and 1100 square feet for kindergarten in fact 80% of all of our classrooms and 100% of our grade three through five classrooms fall below the state standard for classroom size to put this in perspective classrooms of this size hinder Collaborative Learning limit flexibility in instructional strategies and strain our ability to support students with special needs furthermore small overcrowded spaces can exacerbate the spread of illnesses a concern we're acutely feeling right now and create challenges for safe evacu uation during emergencies the proposed renovation plan while not a perfect solution will reduce the number of
025classrooms below the state standards to 35% this is a reasonable not excessive outcome for our school our cafeteria and Kitchen paint a similarly Stark picture Riverside has the smallest K through 5 cafeteria and Kitchen in the district on a square foot per student basis these limitations can make our lunchtime feel chaotic exacerbating behavior issues and creating long lunch lines leaving students with as little as 10 minutes to eat their meal a the proposed cafeteria and kitchen is an improvement but it still puts us in the middle of the gpsk K through five pack in terms of size an improvement yes but certainly not extravagant overall capacity issues at Riverside School are real and well documented in the district's Master planning report Riverside was the only GPS Elementary School to receive the highest priority rating of
026five in the reports prioritization worksheet underscoring the severity of our facility challenges despite the urgency conveyed in that report it's important to emphasize that the renovation proposal is not about luxury there are no nice to haves or bells and whistles the renovations are designed to bring Riverside up to par simply meeting the standards our students and teachers deserve thank you thank you our next speaker is Caitlyn Wardell can you hear me yes go ahead good evening my name is Caitlyn Wardell I am a parent of a sixth grader at EMS and a fourth grader at Riverside I'm here tonight to advocate for the much needed renovation and expansion of Riverside School Riverside is a gem in the GPS Community people move to Riverside so that their kids can attend Riverside School and they pay a
027lot of money and taxes to do so last year my third grade daughter was in a dangerous classroom situation dangerous enough so that she and her classmates had to be evacuated at least seven times from their classroom and learning time to avoid the threat of physical harm such as being hit with classroom Furniture when a child in the class repeatedly became disregulated and that's only the times I can verify children thrive on routine being repeatedly displaced to the hallway Media Center other side of the room or wherever else those 19 kids were sent was highly disruptive on both an educational and emotional level wondering who was going to get hurt next was also degrading of the Riverside and GPS Norms such as be safe and care for self and others last year's interim principal Gordon
028binstein informed me that other schools in the district have sensory rooms so that when a child is disregulated they can be safely removed from the class however that is not an option for Riverside because there is no available space for one in our perennially undersized and overcrowded building the Ed specs for the upcoming renovation project include the creation of a sensory room space at Riverside and I urge you to keep it in these plans the example I provide from my daughter's class demonstrates how the absence of a space like a sensory room something other schools in the district now have is directly impacting our children's education at Riverside if GPS cannot provide a safe environment for students and one that meets the state of Connecticut's education standards people will look elsewhere to spend their housing
029and tax dollars thank you thank you our next speaker is Alysa langal hi thank you for the opportunity to speak I won't ask you if you can hear me I'll assume you can and I will get started to save you one head nod this evening my name is Alyssa langle and my son and daughter proudly attend Riverside Elementary School as a parent and active member of this community Through the PTA i' like to take this opportunity to educate you more about the severe need for a multi-purpose room as part of the much needed renovation and expansion of Riverside schools plan that we've been you've been hearing a lot about tonight as this year's largest Elementary School in The District in terms of enrollment I have only ever been met with Surprise by newcomers who learn
030that we do not have a multi-purpose room where our children can gather to learn and collaborate what is a multi-purpose room it's a space where more than one class section can come together without disrupting the essential day-to-day activities in the gym media center and classrooms I'm sure you aren't tired quite yet about hearing about those Riverside classrooms and how there're some of the smallest in the district but my issue tonight with the multi-purpose room is that we expect students to engage in small group project-based interdisciplinary learning that modern educational standards demand but we don't have the space to support this at Riverside today with dedicated access to space beyond the classroom teachers will be able to more easily incorporate materials tools and Technology into their Collaborative Learning examples of this include a PL popup Planetarium
031and exploring forces in motion through creating pinball machines all with the objective of deepening students learning if the students and teachers Aren't Enough of a reason to create a multi-purpose room please consider the bir of our custodial and Cafe staff we default to the cafeteria to gather as a group when school opens because it's often the only available space consider that lunch waves begin at 11:00 a.m. so the janitorial staff must take the time to break down and set up chairs and tables for grade level programming with upwards of 90 students in one grade that takes up to one hour both at the beginning and the end of the day but if the students and the teachers and the custodial and the cafe staff Aren't Enough of a reason to create a multi-purpose place please
032consider the needs of the before and after school programs that families in our community of Riverside rely on currently these programs must use the cafe or gym and therefore encounter scheduling conflicts as a result of borrowing other spaces in the building that are in regular use and if the students and the teachers and the custodial and the cafe staff as well as the before and after programs Aren't Enough of a reason to fund the multi-purpose room please consider the needs of the entire School a dedicated multi-purpose room would serve as the venue for the dozens of performances ceremonies and assemblies that occur during the year this matters a lot because we would no longer have to displace the teachers and classes and rearrange other rooms in the school to student program sorry that's three minutes
033thanks so much you can email us the um remainder if there's any points you would like to make that you haven't got to uh the next speaker is Jason Martin Miss Jessica punat is SEC is next oh did I miss one sorry Jessica uh you are next then uh Jason Martin hi can you hear me yes okay good evening thank you for the opportunity to speak my name is Jessica punet I'm the GAA vice president of membership and music teacher at Riverside School as a member of the feasibility committee I want to focus your attention to the essential components the project addresses and why it's pivotal that the project continue to move forward and maintain your unwavering support in November I spoke to the status of our cramp spaces safety and accessibility concerns and curricular
034hardships but tonight I would like to focus your attention to how the renovation and addition would fix a major problem of shared spaces and the curricular learning hardships at Riverside outlined in the Ed specs currently the math interventionist reading specialist band teacher otpt sped fles ESO and media teacher in addition to a multitude of our extra programs are all operating in shared spaces in the school I have borne personal witness to sped OT and math intervention surfaces happening on top of each other in the media center at neighboring tables as each service provider tried to make their group as small and cramped in one corner as possible to cut out sound bleed to the neighboring group all while media classes and Bookout were chat happening this cannot be what's best for student education and just
035because teachers can make it work and our outcomes are high does not make it right and it does not absolve the town of their duty to provide students updated SA safe and reasonable accommodations for student learning the feasibility study took an input from stakeholders and revised their Ed specs and design plans multiple times to provide you with a draft that makes the most sense to meet the needs of the school and provides Riverside with the spaces that it lacks The Architects kept in mind the cost of this short project and took into account moving only the walls that they needed to move to give all of the programs mentioned above their own spaces while also getting band Orchestra and others out of hallways and closets and into properly sized classrooms the design is smart for
036flow and for student traffic and hallways and safety when moving around the building for example keeping all the specials on the ground floor and of course it adds in the safety and accessibility that we are all severely lacking the plan put forward allows for Riverside students to access all areas of the vision of The Graduate not only to just achieve in literacy and math in their home rooms but to also have the allocated spaces to let their creative genius shine to move to express themselves to get the supports they need in appropriate spaces that are conducive to learning and to be safe teachers are working exceptionally hard to work beyond what we have to make sure our students don't feel the inadequacies of this building but their efforts should be spent elsewhere I urge you
037to continue your un unwavering support to this project both to the timeline and funding so that we can bring it to fruition for our students thank you thank you uh next is Jason Martin and I know I saw him there all right can you hear me gotcha yes all right good evening members of the board superintendent and those in attendance this evening my name is Jason Martin and I'm honored to serve as the principal of Riverside School tonight I am here to express my gratitude for the board of Ed's support of the Riverside renovation to share my appreciation for the progress made so far particularly with the thoughtful development of the Ed specs as I shared during my October remarks the limitations of our current building Force constant compromises this renovation represents an opportunity to
038eliminate these compromises and provide an environment that Fosters Excellence across the board although I consider myself an experienced principal this is my first renovation and I'm genuinely impressed with how inclusive and deliberate The Architects Architects have been throughout the process they have taken the time to listen to every voice in our school teachers staff administrators and parents Gathering detailed insights to ensure the design meets the unique needs of each role this level of collaboration has been both refreshing and inspiring and I am grateful to be a part of it what stands out most is the responsiveness and the transparency of The Architects they've been attentive to our concerns and flexible in their approach carefully balancing the needs of our school Community with cost considerations their work has demonstrated a commitment to creating a space that
039will allow each person whether they teaching learning or supporting to thrive from reimagining classroom layouts to addressing critical access um accessibility concerns their designed Solutions reflect an understanding of the challenges we face and a genuine desire to make Riverside School a better place for everyone I was particularly impressed with the architect's ability to honor the unique character of Riverside while also preparing it for the future Riverside is a community with a rich history and deep pride in the school and it is clear that the Architects understand and respect this Legacy at the same time they're designing a space that positions Riverside as a leader in the in 21st century education one that will help us attract and retain teachers and families in a competitive educational landscape while I recognize there are still steps to take
040before this renovation becomes a reality please know that I remain wholeheartedly committed in seeing this project through and I'm super excited thank you for your ongoing support and for recognizing the transformative potential of this project together we have the chance to provide Riverside students teachers and staff with a space that not only meets their needs but Inspire inspires their best work thank you and let's go Red Hawks thank you uh next is uh Alex pop good evening bordered members my name is Alex pop I'm a lifetime grenwich resident and I've been teaching 26 years at Riverside School it's been an honor to be on the feasibility committee overall the architect did a masterful job collecting Gathering every idea every suggestion every wish that the teachers wanted to see in the new school Inc and incorporating
041them into a single plan but it should be noted that the feasibility committee members acted advisory our task was not to prioritize any of the input and there were no votes taken so the Border ad has the hard job of consuming all the information digesting it and filtering in and filtering out what is actually needed for the final draft there's three points that probably need further evaluation first is the appropriate room size I've been in my classroom for 26 years I'm quite pleased with the space it's 71 it's 7ou 710 square feet and I think many of my colleagues are have the same failing yes there are classes that are undersized and definitely need fixing but these ADP specs enlarge every General Ed classroom by at least 150 200 square feet I would be cautious
042regarding shifting walls around besides losing the charm and characteristics the character of the IND individual classrooms my concern is larger classroom space invites larger class sections down the road more space means more students for instance last year's fourth grade class had 26 students in each class and I worry with a larger class but that might be a more common occurrence the second thing is probably parking the committee briefly discussed parking but we weren't tasked with developing a comprehensive plan and I don't think we actually identifi the number of spaces that would be required but I would guess that the area shown on the plan or the or the map is signif significantly underrepresented and this third thing is you know I'm just would be cautious about how this project proceeds this is going to be
043a multi-year renovation some sections of the building will be completely gutted therefore a Clear Vision of what will happen to the students during the renovation needs to be considered thank you for your time thank you uh next we have Stephen ESC I see him there so uh yes hello um thank you for uh for giving me the opportunity to speak tonight um I'd like to introduce myself I'm not just a a parent and U um and a Community member here at Riverside um though that is my most important job um I also am an architect I'm a registered architect and I've planned and designed and constructed over $3 billion doll in major public works over the past 20 years I've also operated and overseen major transportation facilities within this region including one that had over
044a dozen buildings with more than 50 years of negligent and under um underinvestment and I've seen how this can affect the reinvestment into a a community the facility like Riverside School first as a professional I'd like to also highlight that working with these large public facilities can also um create new opportunities for reinvention not just for the school itself but also for the public and the community at large first off i' would like to look at this as a holistic investment these types of projects can significantly reduce their operation and maintenance over the life cycle C uh over the life cycle of the building um doing this by uh by looking at this holistically not just as one component that could be switched in and out or taken out early on in the process to
045save money on the budget I'd also like to recommend that this project be looked at for Energy Efficiency standards such as lead building certification as this would not only increase the Energy Efficiency of the building but it would also reduce the overall cost of operating and mainten and maintenance for the building and this would fit well in line with the town's climate action plan when tackling projects where significant investment had been delayed for a substantial amount of time in this case over 30 years there is a substantial need to fully invest in the process the cost of the project is usually comes with a need to carry out a contingency throughout the process to ensure that the project is not scuttled by the discovery of new and challenging issues along the way this means a
046commitment that is followed through and is understood holistically by the parents the teachers the administrators the Board of Education and the other people in the community that are involved investment starts at the very beginning of the project both with an understanding and a comprehensive plan and following through on that plan this does not mean reacting to one issue or another but it also means having a holistic plan from the beginning means that you are not finding out new undiscoverable issues later on in the in the course of the uh project lastly as I said in the beginning of this this is a a a community resource Riverside like many other schools is a local resource for local families and it's also has other functions with throughout the community it's also one of the few schools
047in our on the west Eastern side of uh Greenwich that is not in the flood point and so and is not at at risk of becoming part of a hazard issue and it becomes a sorry this is this is your three minutes I'm sorry no problem I've submitted the rest of my comments as well oh terrific thank you so much um next we have Lynn sterer I knew I saw her you're go you can go hello I'm Lyn Sterner the literacy specialist at Riverside I'm here to support the need for the Riverside renovation and to explain that the current need for shared spaces has been a real challenge I teach reading and writing to small groups of students who need additional support in the past I had a class room for myself and my students
048this was my students quiet and safe space where they could ask questions freely take reading and writing risks without judgment and use multi-sensory activities which were often fun active and Loud such as acting out an event to think about and experience how a character is feeling this atmosphere helped ensure growth in student confidence and more risk-taking which brought about Improvement and then even more confidence this positive cycle has helped many intervention students flourish unfortunately due to other students needs and space allocations in the school I now must share a smaller room with the math intervention iist with Less storage space and less wall space for my reference charts these easily accessible charts are a must for students who need additional review and practice of reading or spelling skills having to give up crucial wall space
049has been challenging since out of sight out of mind became apparent without some of these visual supports in this new smaller space even though everyone tries to be quiet intervention students often get distracted from the other teacher or group in the space which isn't optimal distraction often requires teacher redirection which replaces valuable teaching time I also coordinate Riverside's reading Champions fluency volunteer program trying to find quiet spots for the tutors to work with their students has also been a real challenge this year I must go upstairs and unlock the band room and the social workers room for the tutors anytime those spaces are available I prefer not to use the social workers room since it houses confidential documents but since there's no other place in the building for the tutors to use I have to
050make sure all confidential materials are locked away again not optimal but reading Champions is trying to make it work until a more designated area such as a multi-purpose room is built Riverside is making the best of this current situation but knowing how different my groups and reading Champions can run with our own private spaces makes me determined and excited about this important renovation the feasibility study to draft building design plans fixes my and so many other space problems we run into at Riverside let's move forward with this crucial project thank you for the opportunity to speak this evening thank you so much um our next speaker is Janet McMahon hi can you hear me yes go ahead okay great thanks good evening chairwoman hirh members of the Board of Education Dr Jones and guests my
051name is Janet McMahon and although I'm a member of the RTM in District 8 education delegate and Pac facilities chair I'm speaking you to you tonight as a private citizen and a mother of two Greenwich Public School students thank you for your service to our schools and our students I'm in full support of the Riverside school education specifications as drafted as you are all well aware Riverside School has been in dire need of renovation and expansion for many years and the building's accessibility capacity and safety issues have been well documented for more than seven years in the district's facilities master plan in fact they existed to such a degree that Riverside was identified as one of three schools with the highest priority needs just last year the school had to relocate 26 fourth graders to
052accommodate an injured classmate on crutches who was unable to reach his home room and other classes on the second floor the school also came close to not having enough classrooms for teachers delivering core instruction and as we just heard specialized instructors have been forced to teach in vestibules or other shared spaces because dedicated classroom space just isn't available well this long awaited 79-page document prepared in collaboration with members of the Riverside School feasibility committee as well as principal Jason Martin assistant principal Mary Dolan Colette and 42 staff members and Educators at Riverside School finally addresses all of the aforementioned deficiencies and more the updates to accessibility Safety and Security will finally bring this building into compliance with Ada fire codes and current security standards critically important however is the 14,000 squ foot rear Edition which
053will expand grade level classrooms beyond the minuscule 1933 size classrooms the addition of spaces for specialized instruction and student supports a larger cafeteria and kitchen the addition of a multi-purpose room and sensory room and the expansion of health and administrative offices all of these improvements will greatly improve students quality of life life academic performance and overall School satisfaction please vote to approve these escs without delay so that this 92-year-old building can begin the much needed and required Renovations students shouldn't have to learn in vestibules and elevators and fire sprinklers shouldn't have to be a luxury in a town like Greenwich a no vote will only delay this project increase construction costs And Delay other important School capital projects behind Riverside thank you for your consideration thank you Janet uh our last speaker is Lucia Jensen
054I do not see her in the speaker list if she is there if she could raise her hand please she's raised her hand good evening members of the Board of Ed and superintendent Dr Jones my name is Lucia Jansen and I serve on the bet I was also privileged to serve on the Riverside feasibility committee contributing to this critical project to address Riverside's significant facility issues including Ada safety enhancements and capacity challenges from the outset the feasibility committee was informed that no vote would be taken on the Ed specs and that our individual perspectives could only be shared through this public hearing this is a proposed $ 45.5 million in investment with 80 pages of information released only 4 days ago I urge the board to take more time and discussion before a final vote
055I want to focus on a key concern the proposed expansion of prek facilities at Riverside currently Greenwich operates federally mandated prek programs across six schools at an annual costs of 5.1 million as noted in your fiscal year 26 budget the Ed specs propose adding two pre-lay classrooms to Riverside at a cost of 1.3 million for 2200 square ft and a $200,000 playground bringing the total to 1.5 million Beyond costs this expansion would also impact critical field space and parking factors that I believe weren't further evaluation in researching why prek was included in this project I found no reference to its necessity in the kg& D study or Capital worksheet to gain more insight I conducted a benchmark analysis of 11 peer districts including schools in drga drgb and drgh I reviewed their prek programs budgets
056and spoke directly D with program directors the T the key takeaway from my research is that no peer District spreads federally mandated prek programs across more than three locations in fact many districts centralize these programs to optimize specialized resources like speech occupational and physical therapists here are some examples Trumble with 280 students operates from a single facility Stanford serves 304 prek students in one facility West Hartford serves 294 students across two buildings and Fairfield serves 256 students in one main location and two small satellites in contrast grenwich with enrollment of 270 students already operates prek in six schools including Old Greenwich ccob and Julian Curtis each just minutes from Riverside adding prek at Riverside further dilutes resources without clear justification I urge the board to carefully consider this information and ensure the Ed specs receive
057thorough review before any final vote thank you for your time and dedic to this important project thank you Lucia uh that concludes our speaker list for this evening um so I was I would like to make a motion to move up our one action item for the evening uh the Riverside School feasibility uh presentation and discussion as uh prior to the discussion items on uh our agenda as we have a significant number of individuals here um to give this presentation I'd happy a second that makes sense okay um so I guess I if that's the case I'll just verbally ask uh for a vote to move that up Kathleen yes Jen yes Laura yes Sophie yes Wendy yes Michael Joseph yes and Cody is he is he still here did he have to drop off
058I think Cody had to drop off so that's a 70 um so I'd like to move that up and have to State your vote oh my vote sorry is yes I keep forgetting that I haven't voted myself so that's a SE 70 to move it up um with that uh just that gives an opportunity for uh those making the presentation to prepare but uh we'll next move on to monthly reports uh and I'm starting with the superintendent report um just for a couple of items tonight um first of all if you remember at our last meeting um we had some public comment that was about um the basketball floor and I just want to take a moment to say thank you to our facilities team who really stayed on it and we had great contractors
059working over the break uh we got back on the floor early and again just you know thank you to Dan Watts and his entire team um for staying on top of that also to our athletic director uh Pete Georgio who communicated with families and we got a lovely note from all of them um just they were so thrilled to be back on the floor um I do want to also just reiterate um that just over a week January 28th we will be um presenting the board of EDS budget um to the BET and the schedule for that evening is six o'clock the first selectman uh does the town budget 6:30 the Board of Ed will present uh your budget and then at 7:00 is when the actual public uh comment or public hearing will start
060so um our parents have been very very interested in it and if you're watching what's going on around um the state of Connecticut budget is a big topic uh for everybody this year and a lot of this same challenges um as far as budget pressures from transportation to you know the same areas that we talk about um I also just a reminder we're out of school on Monday so if it really does snow four to six inches you can sleep in and then play in the snow which will be wonderful but that's what they're saying as of today we may have a big snow and last but not least I just want to update um also had a wonderful meeting with Jen Veno today as we're looking at the first uh set of phasing that
061will happen in that building the summer starting with art and music and um then in the summer they also will have both of their playgrounds that will go in we just did another letter for the state today on that so OG is moving ahead and very very very exciting um to to have all these shovels in the ground and celebrations of these projects that are getting completed thank you thank you Dr Jones um I'll move on to reports of officers committees and liaison does anybody have a report Miss c um I would just like to say um that the distinguished teacher um Awards committee has been meeting and we are soliciting um nominations for outstanding Educators in the district it is one of my favorite committees to be on um we have such a Maj
062amazing Educators so please if you have um an educator you love in the district please think about nominating them so they can be recognized um packets are due at the begin of March so you still have plenty of time and um as far as the CMS building committee I would just like to report I drove by CMS on my way home um from shopping and I did see some trucks out on the field so they're mobilizing and um we're so thrilled to see that um project moving ahead so that's all I've got for today thank you does anybody else have a committee or the aison report that they'd like to give M yeah just real fast the gr Alliance For Education all as well good things going on there but I just want to specifically
063point out um February 28th save your dates that's for the trivia challenge so start Gathering your table okay um Mike I do think this is the year that we finally compete in that as a board of feel confident in our in our in our in our in our ability here um the policy committee met yesterday we contined to make Po uh progress on an artificial intelligence uh draft policy we hope to bring that to the full board next month uh we also reviewed our current policy around political activity on school grounds that was a source of some conversation in the fall um and particularly around the homecoming game which is an annual EX ception um to that rule where we have municipal candidates allowed to um campaign at the uh football game and we were
064unable to make a decision as a committee so we're going to be bringing um suggested revisions to that policy uh to the full board next month as well okay are there any other committees uh that would like to report no um Miss beat um although this isn't a committee report um I'd like to share some observations um I've had the pleasure of visiting eight schools already and two of them alongside Miss koven and I'd like to thank those administrators who took time out of their busy schedule to meet with me and us at times um each school was unique with their own successes and challenges um illustrations of their own vibrant School communities and climate of the building and I could speak endlessly on each one of them so far um but nope don't worry
065I won't tonight um although each school was special in its own right commonality surfaced and each school had engaged students working with engaged professionals showcas pces of student learning and achievement and personal connections between administrators and students there were lots of high fives in the hallway and in the classroom and there was just great collaboration across the buildings um and with central office as well so I just wanted to say keep up the great work and thank you for all that you do for our children and I look forward to visiting the remaining school soon thank you it's always nice to uh to get positive feedback on what's going on in our schools so thank you for sharing that with us um and uh are one last call for any committee updates okay if not
066then I'd like to move on to our action item for this evening um which uh I can ask uh our Committee Member Sophie koven if you'd like to put it on the table for us yes I'd like to make a motion um to open the discussion of the Riverside feasibility study and the adpc um I guess I'll second that is would that is there a motion is that motion in order or it should be approved as presented and then you discuss it I think it's a approve is presented um but uh you know and I'll second if you're okay yes I'm a motion to approve as presented the ad spects for Riverside School um and I'll second that um with just as a note to uh members new new uh and old who haven't been
067through this it doesn't necessarily mean that we have to approve them this evening we can certainly have that after our discussion as to was to if we're going to vote on them tonight or uh or table them for our next meeting as this is our first viewing of them so I will uh reach out to each one of you to verbally M beat I'm sorry Karen can you just repeat oh no I don't actually I'm not making the motion I'm just opening it for discussion I'm so sorry this is what happens when uh you're on all sorts of antibiotics Mike has the flu and I have STP throat so it's all sorts of Joy over here oh I'm sorry in Zoom land so I'll just hand this over to uh Dr Jones and M koven
068and our Architects and then come back to me because I do have a question yeah and I'm going to actually turn it over right away um to uh Ates who has a a presentation for us first 15 20 minute overview so everybody is uh knows what it what it is so Lisa it's all yours if you want to introduce your team absolutely um thank you Dr Jones let me um share screen and make sure that you can all see and um I have this set up so I can zoom in um but it's as as large as possible so with me this I am I am Lisa y I am an architect from anazi Associates with me this evening I also have frandy fiori from CSG she's an educational specialist and she was um the
069seminal part of our team in writing the educational specs because this is a shorter presentation she's here to answer your sort of education related questions as they come up we also have with with us Rick Kera from construction cost estimates to walk us in in Greater detail through uh his estimate for the associated project with with the Ed specs and so tonight um as as I heard mentioned first of all I'm Blown Away by the uh the public response and in particular um how obvious it was that this document has been uh read and that's just great and it is it is a 79 page document and I am um not presenting all 79 pages of it this evening I have everything available if anybody has questions I can I can bring those up but
070um I'm going to try to focus on the key points for discussion and so this is you know just just our introduction and on the left here is a list of our feasibility committee we we met I think six times over the fall um as it was mentioned earlier it's not a voting committee but they provided a lot of valuable Insight um in addition uh Fran and uh Patty one of the members of our office spent a full day with uh staff and teachers at Riverside um asking them questions about every single department and we isolated some particular goals which I have I have listed on this side that this is I'm not going to take us through all of the text of the educ ational specs just because of of time but I encourage
071us to to uh you know let me know if there's an issue I'm going to go through some of these um and a lot of these have been mentioned security and accessibility improvements are mandatory uh the existing facility is cramped in particular um classroom sizes are on the small size side the cafeteria in addition to being small we noticed a serious issue with flow in out of the cafeteria because it's not just the size of the room where you're eating it's how fast can you move through the line that's what reduces your lunch window um yeah the core the core classroom issue was particularly um a more smaller classrooms we're on the second floor and as happens with a lot of elementary schools now I'm seeing um I do a lot of elementary schools and
072we see a lot of this older School do not have these sort of right siiz smaller spaces for resources resource rooms and uh special education and it's it's and also we have more staff in the school today so we need more space for the staff and for the the students and then the traffic flow and I'm just GNA see if there any so this this turns into a series of goals um we are we we looked throughout this we are looking at a 473 student student enrollment capacity which includes uh 30 prek which we'll I'll show you in the plan um security is key the way you walk through the the the front door of this building is is difficult it's difficult to keep it secure uh you have large Windows everywhere we have to
073watch the perimeter um you need new MEP mechanical um electrical and plumbing systems this building will require sprinklers I don't think that's on this page but that that's in issue for sure uh updating the the building for the 21st century is is very key um the new electrical systems and infrastructure uh when I get into the existing plans I want to point out I try to remember to point out um i' I've never seen a school that has U your main electrical service in a teacher entrance um I'm going to go right into the Matrix when I go through the plans and actually when you read the educational specifications there's there's a project scope section which is more Technical and talks about the building and when Rick talks he's he's responding to those scope items
074and they also sort of come out when I'm when I'm going to I'm going to present the plans to you as well but first we're going to go through the the way that we looked at the sizes of spaces in the building so on this left hand column when Fran and Patty met with everybody we we came back with what we're calling an ideal area for each space and this is commonly how we start and many times it ends up with an in sort of an inflated school really a lot of space and then we we did a comparison against the existing areas because this is a renovation um you know it's it's not so blue sky for how you're how you're laying out the rooms and then these proposed areas are what is reflected
075in the plans that we're showing you tonight and we were really trying to find a happy medium because you know you have to you you have to start with your ideal goals because um you know other otherwise we're we're not going to know what you you really want but at the same time we really want this to be a successful Real Construction project and in order to have that happen the overall size of the school has to be reasonable and you know it it size is the single biggest thing that's going to impact the budget so these are your academic core classrooms you can see the the ideal 850 um square foot class size and and these vary but on the plans we've called out the square foot size of each proposed room and we
076also have included the multi-purpose classroom that was mentioned earlier um the math and reading intervention are separated we have um fs and Native Spanish classroom esol their separate spaces and then we have the advanced learning for ELA and Math and Science and then the next two departments we have special education and student support and again these these the resource rooms are you know really when you're renovating a school that's the these are the spaces that you're you're looking for these sort of right siiz um Mid you're often midsize spaces um both both here in the ideal and then we have slightly different areas for propose but you know good locations good good size rooms for the number of students we think that will be in there we do have the sensory room in here as
077well as otpt um phys fed um the gymnasium we're we're keeping the existing sizes within the gymnasium because it's it's a big special space and it is already constructed and it makes sense so for Food Services um as we know we have an addition which I will be showing you for for the cafeteria which allows us to accommodate your school population and should significantly reduce your lunchtime window and we're devoting you know we're being careful about the kitchen and we were careful about how we placed this space so that you could have um good flow and queuing space for the lunch line and a separate way out that are both within you know it's it's centered within the building which which helps with flow um Arts and Music so we we actually we spent a
078lot of detailed time with the committee looking at orchestra band Core Music and chorus and I think we we came up with something that works for everybody and the rooms are all relatively close to the gym space which is great because that's where the stage is the nice size art room and then our library media center is going to occupy the same basic location where it is now but it's right now you have sort of lots of other spaces in invading your media center um which now have their own homes so it's it's going to be a more dedicated space for for media with a with a maker space included within and and then administrative and support spaces um I will say I have not seen a smaller princip principal's office than the one at
079Riverside um this this plan sort of takes over what was a classroom on one side of the admin wing and we're also looking really carefully at the front entrance and making this safe and and laying it out with um access um mult multi multi- checkpoints and and visitors come in through the front door and are routed into the office before being um permitted to go into the school proper and this is um you know it it comes up less when people are asking for what they need but we need bathrooms um we need a correct amount of mechanical electrical and plumbing space and we need we need a place to bring in deliveries so that that's these core spaces and then we are also looking at the the circulation and because I was able to
080analyze the existing building and and we looked at it when we were for making the ideal areas we used a factor which replicated the existing school and then we looked at the actual existing and our actual proposed and this brings us to our totals for area within the within the building so our grand total the ideal area was at 880,000 Square ft you currently are only you're just under 58,000 and we to sort of take a the temperature of the space we we look at the maximum reimbursable eligible area per state standards and because this building is older you get a little bonus um the calculation is it's based on I think it's a 80% of the area that's pre 1959 I could take you through the math but it's more interesting to look at
081the plans but anyway that brings that brings the state would allow would reimburse 70,2 2017 square feet in a renova's new situation it's a good barometer the ideal area was almost 10,000 square feet over that so when we looked at the plan and there are actually also reasons um involving the way the site is laid out to to sort of tighten our additions and to be more Compact and to try to be really efficient and I did a the first version of the plan that we did actually took us the whole way back to the 70,000 square ft and there were missing elements and things still felt a little bit tight so right now we are um 1,734 square feet over the space standard which is pretty reasonable and with that I'm going to take
082you on a tour through the plans so this is this is our site plan and we are proposing to addition additions I know some of you are familiar with the uh 2019 master plan which had an addition back here with a courtyard and by tucking this addition in closer to the school we were able to minimize disruption to the Green Space out here which I think is very helpful there are a lot of big mature trees on this side and by we are rotating one of the fields slightly but I think that's going to be minimal impact to the to surrounding trees this addition on the left here is is for two prek classrooms with an entrance and this play area would be updated we are not significantly changing the paved areas on the site
083this area back here was a play area and it becomes parking this area was staff parking and we are estimating um I think the new PL the between the new plan and the old plan both of them are around 118 parking spaces so we're we're maintaining what is there now additionally um upon finding out that you have one bus the bus stops over here and isn't currently using this Lane we're looking at making sure that this this Lane can work as a parent drop off a little bit hopefully more efficiently than it does right now we're going to take a look at the curbs it might get slight slly wider just wide enough for a drop off with with the capability to pass a car that's off to the right there is a there's connection
084between these two parking areas we're proposing a gate in this area because we understand that there's a lot of Confluence of traffic in this area at when during drop off and pickup times and this way if you come in this way you have to leave this way which will which will help the speed of this queue because we we have our delivery area back here I'll show you the plan the service Drive which is here now will be used for deliveries we're proposing another gate in this location because there's a crosswalk here to get to take you to the play area so that way during the daytime or if you're worried about trucks coming in you close the gate then the next slide is just to help us zoom in a little bit more um
085we're looking I'll talk very briefly about zoning we're looking at the potential for pitched roofs at this rear addition because it really goes with the character of the existing school we didn't find any serious issues with zoning in this area except for the height in this neighborhood the maximum height is 35 feet to the peak of the roof this Koopa in the middle I think is 75 feet and the roofs that are right around it are in the 50ft range it would certainly be possible to build this addition at 35 ft or less with a flat roof or a very low slope roof but we are showing these pitches which will bring it a little bit over to stay in keeping with the historic character of particularly this portion of the building that's next to
086the Koopa and then this addition is near a flat roof area would would have a flat roof most likely I'm going to quickly take you through the plans and when to look at these plans and I know members of the feasibility committee understand but I'm going to zoom in just a little when you see you know the the line work underneath the color that's that's you know possible demolition of these walls this is happens to be the main office so we might you know keep a little bit of one wall or the other but you know to expand this second grade classroom for instance we're removing one wall and then the red lines sort of indicate new walls I'll take you sort of around well I'll take you in the front so the first step
087here is to secure your front entrance and the way that we will do this you have you have a vestibule wall here if we relocate closer to the corridor you're able to have this access path through the main office and you can see we're expanding the main office to both sides and taking care of the nurse as well um and then coming right through you have the cafeteria is right here and the way this works you have the kitchen which is right next to receiving and Facilities so it's easier to bring in food but students come here this this um hallway is a queuing space you can come in and then you'll be right next to a double survery line we always like to see a double line because it increases the flow of students
088through the space usually usually one of is cold and one of them is hot the one closer to the kitchen would be a hot line and then cafeteria is is amply sized and you have a separate exit and also it's centrally located within the school our kindergarten is concentrated over on this side next to the prek this blue these are their music programs where we're keeping we're trying to keep the grade levels together and where you can see I'll zoom in a little bit so you can see the the square footages of the spaces for the classrooms are more in keeping with with uh ideal classroom sizes we really focused on that for the core classrooms most especially for the for the you know the grade level classrooms and here's our sensory space otpt multi-purpose
089room we put reading intervention next to the media center for obvious reasons you have art classroom on the first floor um special ed take you upstairs quickly oh this is you know as as I mentioned before the gymnasium is um you know it's adequately sized and and uh I won't say that we're making no changes there will be MEP upgrades and I think Rick you'll talk about we're replacing the the glass block um Windows there some new windows and some old windows so we're keeping the new ones and getting rid of the old ones this is the second floor so this is that addition again on the second floor it's a little bit harder to read because you have so much roof right but there's a there's an older above the gym there's an older
090there used to be showers up here there actually still are showers up here they haven't worked in a long time so we're we're taking this space for mechanical and building storage this addition so everything above this line um enabled us to really make classroom sizes work on the upper upper floors it was trickier to get good classroom sizes on the second floor than it was on the first floor and so we have fifth grade is on this side third grade is on this side one of the things that we're doing that that helps control control costs by being less invasive to the building we're keeping these toilet rooms on both floors in the same basic location and they were recently renovated so we're going to look at the entrances which don't have um adaa compliant
091clearances at the doors but the toilet rooms themselves this plan is actually a little bit older there are already Ada stalls in there and then one thing I didn't mention yet these the the building has beautiful terazo in the corridors um for this reason and also so just because it makes construction sense we really prioritized maintaining Corridor locations throughout the building so we're moving walls but we're not moving Corridor walls very much at all and again up here we have resource spaces that are right sized um dispersed throughout the second floor then back to size our roof plan again you Can See Clearly where the proposed additions are and how they tie into the roof I will very quickly take you through your existing plans you know your building well but this was one of
092this was the thing I wanted to mention that shocked me when we first tour the building um that you have you have electrical panels back here and this is you know if you're a teacher you park in the back and this is how you come into the building in the morning and then again you see that the classroom sizes are small and that you have lots of you're you're moving your sped into the media center because that's where you had space and then your uh your kitchen this should say cafeteria anyway the the um this this flow over here is sort of like a dead end and it was really problematic we were there at lunchtime one day and and we could really see it in action and then I'm gonna I don't even have
093to dwell on these very much just to show you small classrooms right 713 to 722 square feet and then your existing roof plan and Rick with that I would ask you to I have these I think three slides but I I think you may want to steal the screen because you have a lot of background information but I'll let you walk us through these and I'll Advance these for you all right I'll I'll do that right now I'm me sure you cannot share um yeah you if if I stop you can before before I hand it over because I blew up the sizes of these numbers your your to your total cost is $ 45.5 million and that's based on um your your to total construction Cost Plus your soft costs and now I will
094stop so you can start okay okay so um Le you could see this everyone can see this screen um so I I met most of the people on the panel but um I just want to introduce myself tell a little bit about myself um my name is Rick kazer I'm with construction cost estimates LLC um I've been in the industry for 35 years um cost estimating and pre-construction and I've H held many leadership roles at U Top CM firms in New England like um Bill ban and Turner my most I I've worked there most of my career um most of my career has been in the K through2 industry uh probably 90% which equates to almost $2 billion dollar worth of construction School projects in preconstruction so um I'm older so I've seen a lot
095and and the last project that I was on Gran was the um grenwich High School renovation project with Turner so I was really happy to hear from Lisa when she asked me to to help her with the estimating on this project um a little bit about how we put together the estimate um anazi and Lisa in their group put together a really good package they really go to the next level I work with other Architects and I just want to say that there's a lot of information that we could we get and that's most important when you put the budget together and test the original budget and Benchmark it and make sure you're correct going forward because there's nothing um that creates a more successful project coming out of precon than than a certainty of
096cost so it's really um refreshing when I have an architect that really goes to the next level too with with the documentation um we take those documents and we um take off what we can what we what we can't take off what's not developed on those drawings we lay out from other school projects that we've done similar size and scope um fortunately the engineers also on this job are most of the injuries we work with on other projects in similar mechanical systems so we can just take that information and um implement it into this estimate to provide more cost um uh and more detail which I think is really good at this point it's not often done but it gives everyone a good understanding of the cost and then you can manipulate that cost and
097control the budget from there that's the most important you can't do that with lumps so that's why I want to um call that out the the the most important I'd say the most important but at each phase especially on this one we take a look at the similar size projects we've done and we look at bid tabulations for the systems so that's very important on this screen I won't show you some of the schools because it's kind of Priory per se but the bid tabulations from the last three schools that I've done in the last two years similar size and scope I can look at those systems and after I do a takeoff and estimate I could do it a benchmark and make sure that I'm on track before we kind of move forward so
098I just want to let you know overall how that that process is done um I want to go through um the estimate really you know at a very high level I'm going to start from the bottom and then work work my way up believe it or not um and tell talk about the direct trade cost are 28.8 or 28.1 million and someone I want to talk about some of the markups and explain those design design and estimating contingency that's really used to as an allowance to cover the details in the development that's not on the drawings yet or that may come to pass it's very important that to note that at the end when you get the GMP that becomes zero so that 2.1 million trickles up into the two $28 million to cover that
099cost and it helps helps cover the cost of the UN um the non-designed items right now that will become there we reached out to building the Greenwich Building Department get the rate um and then our staffing this is the general conditions Staffing the construction cost of the construction staff on your project um and I want to tell you a little bit about how we create that so we we create that with starting with the schedule of your whole project I know it's very hard to see I'm try to zoom in a little bit um to make it a little bit more legible but it'll give the idea you the idea of how we lay this out it's important it's a big cost it's a huge cost driver one .7 million on this project it's a
100project we want to nail down um or or the Staffing we want to make sure we're correct going through we my experience on these type of projects um affords me to put the a staff together so first thing I'll do beside putting the schedule together put the staff together put their contribution on the job or their participation how many how many hours they're going to spend and the rate over here to get the final cost but most importantly when I put the schedule in here this is kind of a very high high level um outline schedule but it identifies when that work's going to be done and in what time of the year so we could understand also project requirements um winter conditions um dehumidification during the summer and then allocate periods of time for
101enabling which is going to be very important during the summertime so we can do the work like as best as abatement when the kids aren't there and also all the MEP ruins and the tunnels coming up through so when we get to those phases and I have identified two major phases here um six-month renovation phases but there there could be more within that 12-month period or or less um it's a placeholder this is not a guar this is not a set in stone schedule this is a schedule that has been thought out to get to the right number or closer to the correct um number here so this gets this gets manipulated and changed um quite a bit as we talked to the staff and the and and um the principal we talk we understand
102the school more that gets more um developed um I want to switch real quickly to um my one of my drawings here Lisa was showing you the drawing but to give you an idea of phasing and how we would do that is that once the addition is built in the cafeteria prek we also take a look at carving out space for swing space such as for specials maybe in the we'll build a coral during the enabling summer and so that'll be a swing space multi-purpose within Media Center we maybe become a swing space our idea is that we're going to take the all the classrooms after the additions are built classes swing into those areas and then the balance gets distributed among the sco see what our goal is to not to get have Portables
103Portables they're very expensive um they be they become logistic issues as to where you would locate those um as a high you know maybe Portables could go here but it'll interfere with the addition so you don't really want that um also logistically taking the kids and walking them out in it's snow it's really not feasible there's a lot more walkway requirements lighting and so on so we do the thought is that we want to make sure we carve out enough interior space within reason to phase this within the building I just wanted to um talk about that real real real briefly um when you go upstairs obviously when the addition is done you have more classrooms you could swing into again just a place alert is not set in stone this is going to take
104months of coordination with your eventual cm to understand how this puzzle works and how everything moves but it can be done um we least and I did a kind of a test look at it and it's feasible let me um if I can get back to the schedule or the the estimate um the other markup items are professional general liability insurance construction contingency that covers unforeseen or changes throughout the job this is a CM fee which is typical for this size of the project payment performance bond and escalation now we have it at 6% hopefully that rank that comes down just to give you an idea where the um annual percentage rate for construction projects and escalation has been throughout the whole year I did a study a couple years ago over the course of
10525 years it was like three and a half to four and a half% CO hit it it spiked obviously went to about 10 or 12% it's come down to 6% over the last couple years um and I'm hoping that it it tracks a little bit lower for right now we have it 6% and then that's important because when we look at our when we look at our um schedule we understand when that's going to start so you understand how many months you got to car for escalation that was another point of doing the the rough schedule um preconstruction um estimates and also management and and um investigations and constructibility reviews and that's all in that $100,000 so when you get to the bottom line it's 38.8 million and that's where we come up with the
106costs um in the con total construction cost as Lisa mentioned before we allocated 177% for soft cost we have a list of items here that that typically includes and that's a that number is a good number and I and I've tested out a work course of three different projects and it's right right in line with it what that does is that gives you a good owner contingency as well there are some uh that tracked a little lower but the owner contingency was much lower so it was kind of you know one of those things that they decided to be more risky but this is a good especially in renovation of especially in good point yes good point um especially in renovation projects the owner contingency is important because as I mentioned Lisa we've carried as
107best as a batement allowance and allowances in here however with a lot of plaster buildings plaster construction ceilings and walls you could get more as best this and it gets more complicated when it comes to the containment and the removal of that so um that's a good number of them to carry um does anyone have anyone on the board have any immediate questions before I kind of go and look at the high level items cost drivers okay so I'll start with the highlighted some of these highlighted cost drivers um project requirements we've carried again 1.5 well I don't you may have seen a lot of people have seen this estimate we carried $1.5 million as an allowance for phasing and temporary classrooms I put portable here but I really you know like I said the
108focus is get swing space interior to the project so it makes it much much more controllable and and it'll keep the cost down this project this um category also includes all your temporary offices and includes um your uh indoor air quality plans and monitoring and then down here is the actual equipment that's going to do that extremely important that the CM sets up equipment that monitors negative pressure within those containments and it's hooked up to um not necessarily A BMS system but a warning system that's electronic that goes right to um um the main office so you can know when there's if there's an issue which hopefully there's not this winter conditions is a is costs looking at the scheduled um we also have temporary toilets so all this this whole section here covers all
109the project requirements to to to build the job that's not on the drwings it's site Logistics and then it's cleanup um and that's what is it cost driver there masing is is another big cost driver on this project and U beside the interior masing which Le said provided new interior masery Corridor walls for durability with tile uh we're replacing in the later down in finishes you'll see that we put tile on the existing um Corridor walls for um more durability but um this exterior Mery wall and the additions it includes all the cast stones cast stone items that you see on your existing building so it matches um the a big part of this is going to be their masonry restoration on this project so we've uh We've carried cleaning and pointing and patching of
110the existing masing partition um exterior wall but when it comes to the um the lentils and the windows prior to replacing the windows um you want to make sure that you you you have no rust on those those lentils and you want to repair those I've done a lot of work up in Harford with Brownstone buildings in this regard so um I could actually show you a picture here if I could real quick to give you an idea of um an example on your building here oh Rick is pulling that up our structural engineer saw this rust like from his car so when yes so we um when you when you look at potential Rusty it's I canum a little bit more how I don't know how blurry it's getting on your end but you
111can see it's starting to rust and when the lentils rust they fail when they fail the brick cracks and it affects the window and the brick and the wall and the water getting into it so it it becomes a problem if it's not addressed right away um so we have an allowance in our estimate to take care of complete replacement which takes this Ro this brick rollac out this header out um it Shores up the existing brick above it we are going to grind down and reseal the lentil and then replace them the brick and that becomes um you know very expensive item then the balance of them that we think that are okay we're going to still go and um refinish and grind the exposed portions of the lentils so there's no additional corrosion
112so that's part of that cost um driver in there um getting back some other ones here um Roofing so when it comes to the roofing you have your existing flat roof re roof that's going to happen you see that over by prek Edition between the preke and the gym and then you have uh some new flat Roofing that's be portions of your um kitchen above your uh between your kitchen and your existing building and um your cafeteria and exist bu there some new flat Roofing there the big part is that re-roofing of the shingles so we had um to we took a look in the Attic um and I and I'll tell you why I'm getting at this is that you want to be able to provide the right insulation so your your insul your
113Roofing has to be replaced but then what do you have for your insulation so when you go to your attic you have uh blown in insulation here and that's providing your insulation plus you have a concrete floor which OB obviously adds some our value but when we replace the the roof we're going to on the um the top roof side of it we're going to be providing rigid insulation so you can then reuse this um slab there's going to be quite a bit of mechanical piping in your new in your Renovations and we're going to be putting it up here so we won't we'll have insulation in the roof and this area will be heated for your fire protection which we're going to be adding in there it's very important plus the other piping so
114we saw that as is a really good solution um I want to give you a little look we have we have um what they call Yankee gutters so the you put insulation on top of the roof it'll be a little bit higher but we think we could visually uh make that go away by the the height so you'll have the Yan Gutter and actually over here it's a Yankee gutter in here um so you'll see there's a there's quite a bit of sloped asphalt Roofing that'll be replaced there's some copper roofing at the Dormers here's the flat Roofing existing that will be also replacing with a builtup roofing system not an EPDM or or mechanically fastened or directed here um builta Roofing is is much more durable in that regard so um the green is
115a slow image because it it's 36,000 square feet it includes also the slope by the way because that it's a the system accounts for that here's your flat roof here's your new sloped roof here's a new flat roof over by prek so um big project and it's also a project that you know could be done mostly um during the Summers and trying to get that done um as as well as exterior uh mfy restoration it's kind of you you kind of it's less in invasive if we could get that done plus obviously all the roofing is usually done in the summer between um March and October anyways so it's a good time to get that in there um jumping back to the estimate I'm sorry if I'm a big item is the the replacement of
116the windows and doors exterior windows um sorry to interrupt I think this is great but do you mind if we start asking some questions I please jump in okay um actually I was gonna ask sorry to put you on the spot but if Dr Jones or Sophie or anyone could just give us like a little bit of insight on where they think we are and sort of bring it to a vote Maybe so I I'm happy to just talk about I think it was a great process um tremendous amount of staff input uh made themselves available to take input from anybody that wanted to come and sit down at the table all of that was taken uh into into account I will also just mention it does have pre the two prek classrooms um just
117because we had a public speaker that mentioned that uh we are out of space in the district and I think it's really important for the board to understand that's why it's in Riverside we now have 17 prek classrooms and we are extremely fortunate that as our enrollment has slightly declined around the district we've had one room here two rooms there that we've been able to absorb and repurpose into prek rooms at no cost and many of the districts around us like Fairfield or Norwalk or Stanford have invested in an entire uh prek facility and if we were to do that we would need another principal custodial facility maintenance I I just I share that it's very very expensive model so I I encourage the board to um ask questions if you have them about prek
118but we're struggling literally today trying to find where we're going to put the next room you need a restroom it has to be on the first floor very limiting so that's one element of this building um but I think again the SPAC is trying to right size the spaces for 21st century and but not you know just going crazy knocking walls down everywhere that's why you don't see you still see some smaller size classrooms but trying to really work with what we have within the building um I think they've just done a terrific job so I'll leave it there um I think I'm I'm going to just talk a little bit about the process as well um one thing I think is really important to point out is that the kg and d report which
119is you know seven years old one of the the things that it noted was that the functional capacity for Riverside School is 383 students and right now we have 460 so you know this has been a problem for actually for decades but specifically was highlighted seven years ago so it's I guess it's a good thing to have it confirmed again but I mean we know that there is a huge problem with capacity in the school and um I went on you know I've been a parent in the school for 13 years but I went on the tours with the feasibility committee I was there with members of bet um you know kids are standing in the hallway to get into gym to get into art to get into the cafeteria like it's absolutely jammed um
120all the time during passing periods um so that's really challenging and I and I do want to also reiterate you know the the ideal size was 80,000 and what's being proposed is 70,000 so it's significantly less this isn't kind of a everything you could ever want plan this to me feels like a very reasonable plan to address first of all the overcrowding issue and then all of the um you know issues that were discussed about Safety and Security Ada um fire those are huge issues that we need to address and I just tonight when they were talking about the windows that really brings up nicely I think highlights nicely that we're in a situation right now where we could start this project and be proactive and do something really positive for the community and not
121be in a crisis reactive situation which we have been in in so many other buildings in the district recently um but the reality is this building is almost a hundred years old so if we you know every year that we wait um you know something could fail uh some system is going to fail and what I would what I don't want to see is that suddenly we have to take on a certain project in the school and then the failure of some system is driving the bus as opposed to we have this really intentional study that had all this input and that this would be a really positive productive plan and and you know how nice would it be to to be leading with something because it makes sense for the school instead of responding
122to something that's a crisis for the school that requires our attention and you know frankly that's always more expensive too um waiting and responding to a crisis as opposed to being proactive so um I think it was a really thoughtful process I think so many other people have spoken so I won't go on any further but just to note you know this all the conclusions that came through this study match with what kd& said seven years ago so I think we have a really nice confirmation that this is what needs to happen for the program in Riverside School Miss C so I just wanted to ask um I heard a lot about phasing is the intent to keep the students on site in in areas of the building that aren't under construction and then complete
123those areas and then sort of inhabit them with the kids or how is the fa I heard phasing I just I want to sort of understand the um the rationale and um and you know this is a project that we need to get done and planned for as best we can so I you know I really want to see it proceed right so we anticipated on a rolling basis um having between five and 10 classrooms out of commission at any given time and we will we will start with the additions and we'll we'll use the additions as I always call them light life boats so that you can swing kids into them ideally permanently and then look at uh repurposing of other spaces within the schools also there are some steps that that the district
124can take as this comes up if um you know sometimes we try to get kindergarten accommodated somewhere else for the duration the really little kids um you know accommodated somewhere else within the district but will it's going to take um it's it's not a feasibility study or a edpc answer um it's just something that you know Rick and I we both have a lot of construction experience we looked at it in depth enough to give you an accurate price understanding that the details um you know will require further attention and we do understand that Portables are your last choice and who will you know proceed accordingly okay uh the next hand that was up was Wendy hi so I I just um I think the kg& D study said that the capacity of the school
125was 383 I don't know what functional capacity is I've never heard that term before do you could you explain that to me well I'm actually I'm opening this St we didn't we didn't write the study but when I read that study my interpretation was that they analyzed the building and they they did an honest takeoff of of how many students they felt could adequately fit in there and it would it would um reflect more than size right it would reflect the layout of of the spaces um I don't think that cafeteria could ever hold fi what did you say 500 and what Sophie sorry no I said the KT kg andd said that the functional capacity of the Riverside School is 383 this year we have 460 students in the school so I'm just saying
126that they you know we are over capacity according to KD G and D and also that was the same conclusion of this feasibility study I wasn't talking about how many students fit in the cafeteria I mean we have so many lunch waves because you know very few students fit in that cafeteria because it's the smallest cafeteria out of all of our elementary schools even though we have I'm actually agreeing with you Sophie I agree it's a very small cafeteria yeah um so I think we have 440 students not 460 as well so um maybe I'm looking at the old number and the Capa 500 it's 500 capacity not 383 no I don't know where the what is the 500 capacity where is that coming from exactly um you said I did I never said 500
127I have the the kg& D study that that we have a copy of says the functional capacity of yeah okay I think the okay all right thank you yeah I was 383 was the functional capacity and I think this year we have students we've had as many as 460 in the past few years okay um I guess I think the kg& D study was for a onetoone program that was never implemented I don't know okay all right thanks thanks so much okay Michael Joseph I see your hand up and then Dr Jones unless Dr Jones you have something that directly just in response all I wanted to say was functional capacity is just how many children the building can hold in a functional appropriate manner not how many children we can cram into a building
128and that sound that's just an easy way to put it um so there are Architects that use that word functional okay thank you uh Michael Joseph yeah thanks I'm I'm I mean I'm all in favor of this uh project for all the reasons we we we heard this evening um it seems like um this is something that that is uh well past du uh my concern here and I think it's worth further discussion over the next month my concern here is the conflation of the the needs of Riverside uh with the needs of the of the of the prek um I I I don't think it's a coincidence that none of the public speakers tonight said anything about prek except negative I think over the next month I think it behooves us especially since this
129is the second uh biggest Capital project this decade um to really have an analysis of of prek and make sure that um this is the right move for us I can tell you that adding adding prek to Riverside which is you know often our biggest elementary school already you know gives me some Paws and I say that as a as a Riverside parent the um especially since you know we're also losing we're losing two play spaces here um both the black top and the um um Elementary age level playground um and we know that traffic is is already a um an issue here um especially with Eastern across the street and and adding pre which is all pickup and drop off is only going to exacerbate that so so I I think it behooves us
130over the next month to to to really have uh take the time that to to to look at our prek options and and see you know what what really makes it make sense and I say that meaning that ironically uh realizing that ironically um eliminating prek from this project might end up making it more expensive because if I'm hearing the Architects correctly that might um um impede phasing because that's one less addition that might impede phasing and we end up with u another temporary classroom but um I think some short-term uh challenges for for for long-term challenges is something we we need to work out and and I I don't think that's something we can rush in this evening I'll say while I'm here only because I floor only because the um I'm fading fast
131here um I do think also at the same time I I think it makes sense for the finance committee to take this up um I'm I'm wondering and I'm I'm I'm not clear where things like Windows and Roofing and Ada where that might one those some of those allocations might already exist in um in the in the fiveyear plans here and um that's something we should probably map out a little bit too oh was going to jump in here and ask because I know you mentioned something about prek and losing a play but I I just wanted to double check because I thought I read through those the Ed specs and it specifically stated a new playground for ages two to five and then there's one for the older students right so we're not losing
132a playground it's just being moved that is that is we are rebuilding the playground at for for ages two to five near the prek um additionally we are adding um hey Rick can I steal the screen back for a sec yeah y um we're we're adding a paved play area um to make up for the potential lost one so where's we are or aren't losing an elementary age prek uh an elementary age playground the we yes I'll show you th this playground is currently I think of all ages in would be two to five specifically for the small kids we are for K to five right this this area back here that's a play area we are proposing to pave here which is less less rectilinear but you have the area right so regardless we're
133losing play Space because we're losing green space that's play space with the black top there and then we're using um Elementary age playground in the back for pre- playground so we are losing two Place yeah this is this is um partially paved now but this this sliver here would be paved yeah right and it's play Space right so I just want to confirm so we are losing two play spaces for elementary kids yes um you are losing this space and this space will be it will be relocated here so it becomes paved and then you have the green out here I think the paved playground area Michael Joseph that is just really that's like a sliver of grass on the edge of the field I mean it's not and it's actually also a driveway okay
134so it's not it's not like a meaningful play area it's a driveway now but yeah it's a driveway now most of that what's being so it wouldn't that that would make a big difference I can I hop in for a second I agree with you Michael I think it would be interesting to talk about um what is the cost if we eliminated the two prek classrooms I think for us to think about first of all right does that mean that there's additional swing spaced costs that is kind of like sunk cost where we have to pay for some space that we don't end up with anything in the end especially if it was portable classrooms I feel like that's something worth discussing and then secondly I think as a district we should talk about what
135Dr Jones was referencing that it you know if we don't build the prek here where are we building it elsewhere and is it cost effective to put it in this building reservation or or is it cost effective to put it in another building renovation but I don't know where that would be um the third thing I think just for us to consider is for the student experience of you know if we don't have prek in this building then we're depriving students who qualify for prek in our um in our en catchment area from being able to have prek at their local school yeah they would have to travel and that you know and it's so just those are things to consider right I can tell you that's not really a concern of mine because prek
136is not a neighborhood school program it's a federal program most school districts do not um prek in the neighborhood school um so I I I I don't know I don't I I hear I no I know that that's not most school districts but that is the choice that we've made Gage Public Schools just and I appreciate that it's the way that it's developed that we haven't built one big pre Center and instead as Dr Jones said we've squeezed them into schools as we could but it also means that it is a bit inequitable that if you live in Old Greenwich there's a prek program if your kid is you know qualifies for services but if you live in Riverside there isn't I I don't necess see that as inequitable I mean my son did the
137prek old grage it was perfectly fine um but I he well I if there's no space right you know I mean it's just a it's just something that we can discuss I think that's something that's a definite discussion to be had not necessarily just in you know relevance to uh Old Greenwich um I had did have a question but I see Dr Jones's hands up first yeah I just um as we are preparing even for the BET um you know for our next meeting when we put this on as an item again that's what it sounds like we can uh share the utilization of the buildings um we've been doing that work um give you an idea we actually have two slides in the budget presentation that show the number of prek classrooms and it
138I used to say doubled now it says tripled um over time because prek just continues to grow um but we are at the point that literally I I can't find a room today and as you know we were going to add a class in February I can't find a room to put the prek class and so we are already starting to feel pressure and really what that means is that if we don't build for pre space then we're either renting space which is very expensive um or we are going to a trailer model which I don't some people call them learning Cottages but where in districts I've been in where they had to have them but people generally don't like them um and you know we're we've reached that point and or we can increase
139class size and I really don't think that's pable to our staff um or to our parents either one but that's really where we are for a choice and if you remember those of you that were on the board we talked about this on the JC project and then the JC project wasn't fully funded and I I think it actually might have even gotten pulled out of the edpc uh in that JC project so we've been talking about this for a couple years we knew we were going to be here um but if we're not going to build it here it needs to be somewhere else um or we're going to be having pretty expensive options um in the future because it's a federally mandated program I was going to say that when when we were
140having this discussion I think that something maybe we can add as a separate discussion not be based on Old grenwich just about our uh prek needs and something we can talk to when we get towards agenda planning if if your thoughts are there yeah I'm happy to put together a prek and sty will K come and help me we talk about prek almost daily now um speak what while while we're on the discussion of special education my quick question was you know when I was looking at the plans um I was curious as to the placement specifically of uh the special education resource uh space on the first floor opposite of the you know entrance and next to the cafeteria you know it's not near otpt the resource rooms upstairs and the special and the
141you know the the psychologist and special uh social worker offices are all sort of spread out through through the school and I was just wondering if you could speak to um the thought process behind that as opposed to having um a lot of those resources sort of together in case there's additional supports that are needed so we have some special ed downstairs and some upstairs to help reduce student travel uh this space was also we are when we have internal spaces we're careful about what we put in there um the main classroom spaces um who we need to have windows so sped is is is one of the options that could be placed in a a space that has no windows I will also say um not to sound like we're being casual about this
142but you know this it's like a puzzle right so you're packing everything into the puzzle and then once everything is in place um we made a few last minute swaps I don't know if any of you know when when Rick was going through some of his plant some some spaces were in slightly different places and those were some last minute swaps that we made that we that Rick and I agreed didn't cost anything that they occurred after his estimate and when I look at this sped resource here and I look at the faculty dining I I see that kind of thing is potentially interchangeable as this design um evolves but we we did feel like we needed to have at least one on the first floor with all of this the younger kids that that
143I definitely understand the reason I was asking about placement is because you know for students who uh may have attentional issues or um those who might uh Moonlight and and and Escape Escape RIS we're gonna have a much more we're gonna have obviously a much more secure um entryway so that shouldn't become an issue um by being by the front door by next to the cafeteria with a lot of the noise that come disruptive and so and or you know people coming in and going you know back and forth you know uh by the office and entranceway because I suppose even if it's doesn't have outdoor Windows is going to have some some opening towards the other than a right right and you know we're not really drilling down into final door locations but for
144this I would definitely say the door would stay where it was because then you have you know you're really you're really over here like I said was my question as to just that why it was there this space was not um this the location of this space was not a driver right so we have you know say six other drivers on this floor right you have obviously the gym wants to be where it is the big spaces want to be where they are you want to keep the the classrooms uh you know in sort of villages by grade um with your music on this side um and then then you have the dispersion of the you know the perimeter spaces versus the interior spaces yeah that's certainly having having stuff it helps with the flow
145within the school but like I said I just was that seemed like an odd location to me and um one of the other questions I had um specifically was you know I know that you were talking about doing this project in phases and and having CL like five to 10 classrooms or or other you know spaces out of commission for six months and that I think is a a larger discussion we as a as a board certainly need to have as to what we would be doing with those meanwhile um you know but I I was just trying to sort of see you know what are the you know and I guess you can go through this with us maybe not tonight or you know if we're not tonight to go through it either either
146at some point because that is obviously a cost uh if we have to have students um off site somewhere for us um you know and and your thoughts on that as to how to do the phasing with the most minimal impact on and their academic support um I know you mentioned having kindergarteners you know that weren't there having a student whose school was being renovated when they were in kindergarten their first entry into a school um it was I will say it does make it sometimes difficult when you you have those students especially the you know kindergarten I offsite they're they're not in their traditional space they're support staff that they would get to know obviously the same diff difficulties with with an older class who are used to you know being part of that
147so it's something I think that the board is further discussion it's always a challenge in a renovation of an existing school and at this point um our main goal sorry I we're skipping back and forth together but our our real goal here is to make sure that you all understand that it's it's a heavy lift and it will you know you will see impacts but also to make sure that we're reflecting in our cost estimate um enough funding and enough time so that we can we could do it in a way that impacts the kids the least yeah so I I to me I think and that's not something we as a board have looked at or discussed obviously this is our first time having this presentation but definitely think that this is a comment
148more for the board and Andor you know Dr Jones is having uh thoughts on what we might do if that's the case and and cost estimates for different options for you know what we might do if we have to find a space for students that offsite at some point right right understood um Dr Jones's hand is up so I'll go to you and then Kathleen I see you up next and then when yeah I just want to remind people that are watching and also for the board this is only conceptual and if you go back and you look at feasibility studies by the time we actually get to the building committee the building may not even look like this and so we don't really talk about we just I mean we put it in the
149estimate that we would like to phase so that you're not bringing in trailers and all of that but that happens at the building committee level and I will say if you look at um OG's phasing plan it's incredibly incredibly detailed and it it will give people an idea of how it's going to work because that project is going before this one um but again that that really isn't a discussion we would generally have in edpc that happens with the building committee later on Kathleen um I was just going to say I think it's um a very wellth thought out detailed presentation I really appreciate how you keep the traditional uh unique character of Riverside and then bring in all of the new functions and reality of um you know Ada and fire safety and all
150um so I like that I also think it's impressive that the number has gone down it started off at 50 and our original and our budget book we had it at 48 first of all that's an amazing estimate to Dr Jones and Ben um well done because to we we agree it was um refreshing to see a a you know a reasonable guess that's not not um you know overly optimistic right not a pie in the sky like clearly they really thought about it and I certainly appreciate it because it helps as we've done our financial planning so the fact that that you're in that zone and in fact you're coming in under it um is is really um satisfying so um I suspect we want to keep learning more I'm happy to learn a
151little bit more about the prek um but I think what you've done here is really fantastic so thank you yeah and and I'll I'll add to that right before I go to Wendy who has her hand up as well to say uh Sophie mentioned this and I just did want to say I appreciate that you guys came to us with a a plan that you know had 880,000 square feet and that this the committee feasibility committee really looked for ways to to hone that down so it's not an O you know over impact to the community at large with a much larger building and also you know keeping the costs slightly lower so I thought that was really impressive and it's a big a kudos to you guys and to the feasibility committee for for
152looking at that I think in that way Wendy hi um hi Lisa thank you again for this presentation uh and I know you from our JC building committee um I did have a question though as a speech therapist um I is there any way you could put the speech room somewhere away from the band and Orchestra room I just think it could be a little distracting for you know kids with sensory needs and issues it's it's a it's a smaller room I'm sure we could get it somewhere else um it might be nicer to be near the other support staff as well um so if you could try to find a different place for it that would be great um but I I think I love all of I I do I think you guys
153did a really great job on this plan Sophie thank you for you know being on this committee um and I do support this project uh I think you know as I I mentioned before the cafeteria is small and the kitchen needs upgrading uh the music spaces are problematic um and you know the children and parents deserve it they've waited a long time for this so I think um you know we need to get this done but I don't support the plan has as written and my problem with it is the preschool and so I know Karen said that we would have different we would have more conversations About Preschool I just I feel like if if we're going to have pre Universal preschool it should be a transparent thing that we've brought out to the
154community and to the parents and everybody should be on board with it and I feel like what we're doing is we're just implementing Universal preschool whenever we have a building a building committee that's meeting to to to update or renovate a school so let's be transparent about it if that's actually what we're doing um and let me see and so you know I think we need to have a a a robust discussion about it and and that's it um yeah I I just as an aside it's not my understanding that we were looking at Universal prek it's just that the numbers of students with special education needs in the prek um age group I think is exploding not just in Greenwich obviously but um and I think that that was I just wanted to put
155that out there and make sure that that's that my understanding was I don't know which way we're looking at it yeah it's definitely not Universal prek I don't I don't want to I don't want to promise uh listeners that we're going to provide that I I just wanted to be clear and so I really do think that you know we have people asking questions of board members about uh our prek program so I really would like to we'll we'll pull that out of this discussion at the Ed specs for the moment but and have that as a a board discussion separately thank you um does anybody else have any specific questions for our uh architecture and planning uh individuals because if not then we can have a discussion as to if we're you know if
156we're ready to vote on these this evening it doesn't from the discussion it seems like there may be some uh additional questions um people have uh and they may we may want to move this as an action item uh and table it till our next meeting but I you know I don't want to speak for the board anyone want to opine anyone else um yeah I I think it's fine for us to table it and um reopen it the next meeting when we have an opportunity to talk more about the prek in particular um so you know if if that is if that's the case if people are okay with that I mean I don't think I withdraw we don't have to with Mike I'm making sure we don't have to withdraw the motion I
157just make a motion to table it till the next meeting the action to take action on it uh you would with withdraw the motion and then just move on okay to the next item raw my motion uh you know uh for approval of the Ed specs at this time yes I can second that right we don't have to vote on that correct drawing it so um and if that's the case I want to thank all those who came and and gave such a detailed presentation um I'll let the board um members know that if you guys have any specific questions um that come from tonight's presentation or the Ed specs overall um you can share those and we'll put them together and get them off to um through the feasibility committee and our uh you
158know um other individuals to answer whoever can is the proper uh area to answer them send those on over to us and uh we'll get the responses back to um so thank you and with that we move on to our action items which would be excuse me our discussion items uh the first of which is a proposal for a new high school music course Ken Karen point of order um do you guys still have a quorum if I drop off yes okay I fear I am probably going to abandon you all but uh I'll see you on the other side all right sound terrible yeah everyone's so sick good luck thank you feel better thank you so um I see Mr Deo here good evening the ropes to you then sir thank you so much
159uh well wishes to all who are sick we'll be brief tonight we're pleased to bring one new course to your attention modern and uh here to talk further about this offering is James antonucci and Jason police so if we could Elevate both of them Mike that would be great James if you can unmute yourself all right let's try that can you hear me now okay great uh good evening thank you uh Mr Deo good evening Dr Jones Cher hirs the Board of Education my name is James Anon I'm the new Arts coordinator thank you for the opportunity to present a new course proposal for modern band an ensemble and enrichment course geared towards contemporary popular music that reaches students that traditionally fall outside of our band chorus Orchestra and Ensemble programs this course will be
160created and taught by Mr Jason polus since my arrival here in GPS I have been continually impressed with Mr polis's ability to bring relevant and modern material into our classrooms at Greenwich high school and guitar classes jazz band E music classes and also as an associate band director his ability to masterfully perform on a variety of instruments be incred knowledgeable in technology and recording leads to his ability to incorporate almost any genre of music that will motivate and interest students Jason also develops great relationships to inspire students who work together and to practice independently on their own I'm excited about this potential offering to our community and now Mr pus we'll give you some highlights of the course okay can everybody hear me thank you can everybody hear me great um thank you for your
161time tonight as I present a proposal for a new honors modern band music class at ghs before I begin I want to take this opportunity to thank Dr Jones Ralph Mayo Dana chilada and our new Arts coordinator Jim antinucci for their unwavering support of the entire music program working in a district that supports our ideas for increasing musical opportunities for our students truly sets grenwich apart and makes it a really special place to work there are a number of reasons that ghs needs a modern band class in my opinion significant growth in in the guitar 1 and two program over the last two to three years has led to a number of students wanting to continue to develop their skills and engage in an ensemble experience we have approximately 100 students enrolled in Guitar this
162year many of the students are continuing on to take our higher level music electronic music classes and infusing a new energy into the music program overall we now have a mass of students wanting to form bands and play music in the genres of pop rock ree hip hop and folk music in a format that closely resembles bands and artists that they look up to because students in a modern band Ensemble also participate in separate musical groups like choir band Orchestra and electronic music it would facilitate collaboration between students that exist in every in many different backgrounds while serving all these diverse Learners in a school-based setting students in an honors modern band um will will utilize the recording studio our amazing recording studio at ghs throughout the year and will collaborate quite a bit with
163the students that are already in the electronic music program project-based learning allows for students to work together to plan reflect and continuously improve the learning process which develops and strengthens students 21st century skills this class will meet once per week from 7:15 to 8:25 a.m. auditions will take place in early September similar to our Jazz ensembles and string ensembles students must be currently enrolled in a ghs music class to be eligible for this before school Ensemble students will be expected to collaborate on a body of music and prepare for several performances throughout the year in preparation for these performances the students will also be learning how to set up the equipment and operate the sound reinforcement for their own performances this will help these students finish the class with a host of real world and
164marketable skills in addition to their music making skills modern band will make will be made up of three to four bands approximately 20 students in total each made up of similarly skilled guitarist bases vocalists and pianists after teaching music in many capacities at ghs for seven years now I am confident an honors an honored modern band class will add to the culture and offer many students at ghs a chance to collaborate and refine musical skills that they are already passionate about thank you um I don't know if anybody has any specific questions um in regards to this present you know proposal I think it's a fantastic idea I know a lot of students who take uh electronic music as a a course as a freshman um and then really aren't sure where where to go
165with this I know we have a explosion of incredible musical Talent um within our high school and so I I love this idea and thank you for presenting that to us um Wendy I saw your hand go up first and then Jen I just want to say I love this idea I love this program my son did um did the electronic music course like I think for three years and loved it uh Mr pus and Miss fredman they're great and and I I think my son was one of these like beta PE uh people or groups that actually had to learn how to play he I think he had to play Feel Smells Like Teen Spirit during the class and uh anyway he had a lot of fun so thank you for being so creative
166Jen thank you I love the idea of this course um I just have a really quick question when I was reading through and maybe you could just help me out [Music] here it's open to 9 9 through 12 that's correct is that correct so if a ninth grader comes in I understand the prerequisite is guitar one is that right no that's not right they just have to take the Bas the only requirement is that they are enrolled in a music class in oh okay then okay because I so that could be that could be guitar that could be a guitar class that could be a um Orchestra any anything musical perfect so the idea is that these type of bands are made up of students from all sort of walks of granish high school so
167they might be a guitarist they might not be in the band right now and so we want to try to encourage as many paths for them to to be part of something like this and collaborate excellent thank you sure uh does anybody else have any specific questions no um I know this is uh is on here as a discussion item um not that I necessarily want to move this up because I think it's probably too early for us to to do that but I mean if anybody nobody has questions and there's no obviously there's no cost to this I don't know if anybody else would have interested in moving this to an action item no we'll just leave it as a discussion item and vote on it at our next meeting because we're missing some
168members does that work better I'm a different so whatever you want I'm happy to vote I'm happy to vote as this is a special meeting and this is listed as a discussion item you cannot act on it yeah okay okay but uh I do support the idea so we'll I think you guys know where this is heading so thank you for your time we really appreciate it gave me the effort of having to come back all right thank you so much of course um our next items um are backtack uh Financial reports so uh oh no actually I take it back the next discussion item is the Gren High School grading options for midterm and finals sorry I didn't mean to Jump Ahead um so I will uh hand that over to Dr Jones uh
169just to put out there as a initial discussion item um so this was a request of s of the board and so basically what you have that was um posted is the history over the last couple of years so if you look through your packet um of how we've had several different changes and then there are a couple of just relevant and board policies that go along with this item so I'm going to give it right back to you because I think it's a a board discussion so um I know uh kathen has her hand up I know this was something that uh she brought forward um as a discussion item for us so I'm going to hand it then over to to you Kathleen if you'd like to sure um you know it's something
170that um many parents had reached out to me about and and students and um I know we had talked about it a few years ago and I thought well this is just an interesting topic to have at the board level anyway um but I mean I think you saw it with we just added it yesterday and there were a few parents that emailed just a few hours ago um I mean my perspective is it offers a nice balance right so you have um still the I mean I think that it's very important to have midterm and finals I think it gives them college readiness um I do think it's nice to have the option though for some students to make it you know there's a chance for them to to prove their Mastery by the
17110% and the 10% traditional model but for those that are anxious and find that sort of big test um a little bit worrisome to then also not have it you know tank really their grade is also a nice way to sort of reduce anxiety on the other thing so like a few people have said it's a nice balance um and so I just think it's something that we should like talk about and um you maybe get some other comps on um and see if it's something that we should you know do because I know we did it a few years ago and it seemed to have gone well so um wondering why we shouldn't bring it back I guess that that was my my personal question was to to see if we could find any
172other comps other any other districts that do something similar to this um not that we always need to be in comparison to but I would just be curious to see how that is handled um I know the one thing for me is I know this is a bit of a larger discussion and it would make it very difficult to try to put this into play uh right now I know the kids are going through midterms so I don't want to give anybody any false false hope or expectations any students that are watching this that uh they should not be home and studying for their midterms right now um Jen don't think you need to worry about that want to make sure just wanted to make sure seen the library tonight um so I saw Jen's
173hand up as well yeah I just had a quick question so if I'm if I'm understanding this and and correct me if I'm wrong this is the grading that's predetermined at the beginning of the year the beginning of the course I should say because some are first semester second semester is that correct yes like our high school grading you know it is decid it's not per course it's very semester rather you know half a year course or full depending on the course percentage of what the weight of work and inclass participation versus a midterm or a final is set at the beginning of although it does vary sometimes for AP classes it should be noted yeah I mean that's what I said it's but it's set not it doesn't change it's it's based on the
174specific course and yes AP is slightly different right so so potentially although both grading systems according to what was here from 2022 both systems depending on how you split it right are for the best results for the student but that means that each teacher this is an individual based grading system right per student it's not the course meaning the course does not follow this the student would follow this is that correct so potentially in a given class let's say you had a class of 24 12 would opt to do it one way and 12 would opt to do it another way is that thinking correct I think that it would just be the greater of right so think of it that way right so if you had this has happened a few years ago basically
175if you had you know 20% 20% 2020 10 10 that yielded an A minus but because you did um you tanked your final but you otherwise did well in the quarters right then your quarterly grade would then have the emphasis of 22 and a half% 22 and a half 22 half 2 half five and five right it justly changes the weight like how much the midterm and or final is right I I'm talking about the actual computation for the teacher to have to can't speak for the teachers because I am not one but it it does go I mean it's an easy calculation right it's just I would hope it's done in with an aspen or if not I could certainly send a macro on how to do it right but it's I'm just wondering
176what the teacher perspective is I just wanted to make sure that I had the model correct right so if the teacher is making the decision which one to follow that's most beneficial for the kid right that yields according to this the high the higher final grade then that teacher is making that decision and what so if I have the model right then what is the teacher input on working that there is a teacher input it's just mathematical right no no no no no I'm talking about what was their um input in using this model right the either or model like how did this come to be so to speak so if I have the maybe I'm not explaining right so if I have the model right and I I get that it's math I understand
177that it's math I got that how did this model come to be like who's input went into it to decide that this so this is initially was it a committee or came through during covid and it came through during Ro policy um what other a lot of other districts were doing because the first year of Co like the kids didn't have terms and finals the stress the anxiety they didn't have the same access to support that they did in the past and so to help relieve the anxiety and stress and this was not just done here this was done in a lot of other places it was ways to help reduce the stress and support our students mental health during the during that experience and I I don't remember exactly what the basis is I
178know or at least I saw um Mr Mayo um here earlier he may have left yeah I was reading it I didn't know if it was like it was a you know committee with input it it said that it had input from parents teachers kids you know the the whole group but I didn't know if it was like a formalized community or committee rather not Community Comm rather we did that through again through policy the board had a discussion I think the administration at the high school I think Dr Jones could probably speak closer to that because okay I'm just Cur I just wanted to get some background a little bit about it and make sure I understood the framework and the implication for the framework for Teacher students staff Etc so that was that
179was yeah it maybe I should have led with that go back and get you that additional information too Wendy so this essentially would just make maybe tests and quizzes worth more more than the actual midterm or final correct right like everything else that you are doing within the quarter of the semester is that that's all worth more than the actual midterm and final um I don't know I I kind of the homework isn't worth doesn't become then be worth more it's just a it's a small percentage of it right instead of 10% it'd be 12% okay I I mean I I would be interested in in seeing or hearing what the other districts around us are doing because we are we are preparing them for college and they are going to have to take midterms
180and finals and so I don't want to set them up for failure once they get to college with um not knowing how to you know really properly study for something I feel like a lot of times people don't actually really learn the material until they're sitting down to study for the midterm or the final um so those are just my two scents um does anybody else have a questions or comments Dr Jones yeah I just want to comment what you'll notice about the packet tonight is there's not an actual proposal and and I think it's really important to say that that when this came up it really was from a mental health standpoint and you know I saw a slide this week that um was sh just the increase in mental health of anxiety and
181stress and it's the same conversation I think the board literally has had since 2020 when we started in Co and every year looked a little bit different and so that's why we tried to go back and just pull the history um and the board policy does say that we have annual notification and that's what the first page is that gives you the current waiting and how it works and those of you that have asked questions were really looking at should we have another option that also balances out the mental health needs but um I think it could be anything it doesn't have to even be what you did last year or two years ago or three years ago I think it's a it was a bigger conversation than that um not trying to just replicate
182necessarily what happened during one of those years yeah I mean that's why I'd love to just do I didn't because I know this is something we briefly discussed but I haven't had a chance to do my research and I'd love to see what other you know it's not just districts in Connecticut I'm just curious to see what other schools are are doing and looking at um in regards to this too because you know these students are under an incredible amount of pressure and it gets harder for them oftentimes every year so um hand up yeah I just think um I mean again I'm taking for sort of hearing from people from a mental health perspective I mean it's frankly not something that my in my family it's ever been utilized but I have heard from
183other people I mean we're talking about therapy dogs it's actually Cody had mentioned that um there is clearly like a lot of anxiety um for many of our students and we spend money and a lot of time on trying to reduce that anxiety and to me this is sort of like a a free way of perhaps reducing that anxiety for some of our students that get themselves unnecessarily wound up for these these days and yes one day then it probably would put some of an emphasis more on those unit tests during those quarters but perhaps for some children there is you know they they for some reason that doesn't get them as anxious um but then I like the balance because for some of those students who you know are doing really well but then
184they sort of have that Mastery of the content at the end right there's more of an emphasis than for them to sort of Spike thir grade because all of a sudden they were like you know B+ B+ B+ B+ and then they hit an A+ on the midterm in the final because they understood the content so to me it sort of is rewarding both our students that for some reason are exceptional on those big days and for those that um are just really solid throughout the quarter and then have like a a weak moment if you will right so you know to me it's kind of like an easy win for maybe have sort of like having all Tides rise if you will yeah yeah I also like theide a that for students who think
185that homework or class participation isn't as important as just focusing only on the midterm this will remind them that it may very well be very important to focus and do you know homework and have class participation because even by then maybe their midterm will be even stronger than they would have but otherwise because they're really engaged in doing all of the work you know that just a 10cent thought though yeah Sophie your hands up yeah I I just think it would be helpful to just do a little modeling like while we continue this conversation right of just of like maybe if we just for the next discussion had like 10 examples you know so that we could see what it looks like and we I know we've been kind of talking about hypotheticals but just
186to actually see it because then I and also to see how practically speaking how do teachers do this and what does it look like um just so that we know know you know but I I'm supportive of the idea and I also feel like I appreciate that we do need our students to be preparing for college but also um having had two kids who went through college or one's in one's done you know in college there there are a lot of um professors that offer things like like that where there is this sort of like Dynamic like if you do better on the first paper it counts for more or whatever so you know I think it's an interesting idea but I would love to see just if we had like five examples you know
187because then I think it's much more concrete and we can see why it would make sense I can certainly um work with Mr Mayo um and he can involve you know his team and um we'll put something together for you that's great and I was gonna say I had spoken Michael Joseph had I think he was very interested in this idea given that he's an educator so I know that he was very much on board with the concept of once you like have master and content so I'd love to get his opinion anyway um and I know that Cody was just excited about the conversation so I'm sorry he had to leave because I think this is like an interesting philosophical discussion um which I know he also enjoys so I think um it's good
188for yes for us to model it and then bring it back and you know reach I the fact that we posted it last night and we already heard from a few parents when people seem to be asleep at the wheel lately um on some items so I actually think it'd be good to also reach out to parents I think we probably know where the students stand um but it would be good to hear from them as well so yeah well so Kathleen thank you for bringing this forward as a discussion item and you know I do think it's important that we have the input of the you know all of our members uh you who have different students and different experiences be able to hear you know pros and cons and you know I certainly
189I'm hopefully our students aren't watching this and they are home studying um but we I'll also reach out to XCOM and see if they might have any additional input to add um but you know I'd love to hear from our students you know so parents if you're listening and you have high schoolers who have some thoughts feel free to ask them to uh send us an email or come speak um but does anybody else have any input for this topic otherwise we can move on to our financial reports well again thank you Kathleen for bringing this forward and then I am going to uh uh ask uh Mr bran to come forward and discuss our monthly financial report and then budget transfers good evening all I'm actually going to turn it over to Patrick lie
190who is our new Director of Finance he promoted we promoted him from the budget director so very excited that he'll be uh more involved in the financials and uh his reward as he gets to present the report to the board of AD so well I was gonna I was going to note and say thank you and congratulations because we've uh had a great experience working with you so far so love to see that payoff thanks so Patrick the floor's yours okay great thank you Ben and um thank you everyone I'm excited to taking up this new row and continues my contributions to the school district so for this month the financial report we posted into the uh meeting agendas uh if you kind of look through the report uh two things that I would like
191to highlight tonight only one is on our operating budget so over all year today up to the end of December we spent 97.8 million which is 50.8% of our current year operating budget and um comparing to last year this time it was 52.1% and then the second area is the school lunch program um I mean when we look at the December uh result the preliminary physical year forecast that we look at that we may we may need a an inum appropriation uh to bring forward in the next month monthly meetings so just want to kind of like uh put the U information out there and then we are still doing additional analysis on the school lunch fund when it is ready we will bring it up in next month and all other areas are are
192okay and it is under control if you have any questions reading the report feel free to reach out San or myself does anybody have any questions nope uh so I guess seeing none I will also ask uh if you want to just there's a brief budget transfer you if you want to yep the next one is on the budget transfer again uh it is for information only um so the information is included in there again if kind of like if you have any things questions after uh on looking at the the reports on the budget transfer I'm be happy to answer that does anybody have any questions this one's Prett easy no okay well thank you Ben thank you Patrick congratulations again thank you uh well actually we'll probably a little bit before that with
193a budget presentation so thank you guys um and I guess we move on to agenda planning so I did not have it in my packet I just realized that um but just so that you know in the next two meetings we have a couple of items coming up um ham the HVAC will be on the agenda we will have the PCG report um an update will be on the agenda we will also have a capital item which has to do with the swimming pool which I had emailed the board about um which will need a project and then the policy committee will have a couple of policy items as well but I don't know which of the two meetings are falling on because I don't have it in front of me but uh they are
194coming and I know those are big items yeah and I and I I said you know I know we need to um add uh Riverside on as an action item but I I know our next meeting is February 6 but that's a retreat with an executive session so I I assume that would go on Thursday February 20th we probably will not have an executive session if we are virtual um we won't come and have but that's why I'm waiting to see kind of what the status is because we can't be talking about special education especially uh when we don't know who's in the background and who's in the room um as you know that's you know something that we don't even keep the documents um that the attorneys utilized obviously we we can talk about
195that prior to then and have a discussion but um so we needed to add that back on um that would be helpful and um I guess we'll find a a good time to have another an an additional discussion on uh grading the high school once we once we know when the researchers is coming in that does anybody else have anything I missed that needs to go on um other than the Luna contract when that's ready yes that is on the list as well yeah perfect okay so I guess I guess that is it for this evening so I you know Laura do you want to make a motion ah just as I plugged in my computer um I will make a motion to adjourn who wants who wants the privilege of seconding Wendy you look
196like you want one oh Jen yield to Wendy if she'd like itend I will second all right so uh by the way I was gonna say my closing remark is for everyone to stay healthy there is so much going around I don't know if you guys know but like feel like yes I am not feeling well over here so yeah a lot of kids sick I have to take a a verbal vote uh for meeting so Sophie yes Jen yes Laura yes Wendy yes me who looks like she's ready to go to sleep yes Karen is a yes so that is a six right one two three 6 zero antibiotics so thank you to our Mary 13 attendees who who stuck it out to the end and uh I hope everybody stays healthy so yes
197thanks vitamin C you good night everyone