CorpusRecord 113557

December 12, 2024 Board of Education Special Meeting - Business Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Greenwich Public Schools
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,575 words · about 98 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay it's uh 7:03 and I'd like to call the meeting to order um can we all stand and say the Pledge of Allegiance please I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all with that we can move on to the consent agenda do I have a motion to accept the consent agenda so moved okay uh is there a second okay Sophie koven thank you uh so I will as we're doing this uh electronically I will call each individual member to uh point of order um is there anything on the consent agenda is there anything on the consent agenda there's no minutes oh well they were supposed to be posted I know we at

002least our executive our um minutes from um well I guess we won't I hadn't looked at them uh there so I apologize so I shall withdraw my moot I'll ask I thought you knew something I didn't thank you I had thought that they were there so I guess we'll we'll take that up uh later so with that we can move on to our public hearing uh and first up our our fantastic student uh government um Representatives I don't know if uh Rocky or Mah are here we can see if they raise their hands hello all right hello chair HST Dr Jones a member of the Board of Education my name is miir and I'm the student body vice president I'm great oh oops sorry hold on my computer's not loaded all right it's a pleasure

003to be back speaking here tonight I want to speak to you about something that is near and dear to me and our ghs community school spirit is one of the foremost goals that student government has this year Amy the school spirit chair is doing a great job collaborating with Miss Foster in Student Activities to get Cardinals excited about our school next week we have a winter Spirit Week With activities and dress up themed days Monday and Tuesday will feature a gingerbread house competition hosted by the PTA where Rocky mave Chloe and I will compete against the rest of XCOM and other Gren high school students to build the best gingerbread house then students will dress up throughout the rest of the week on Wednesday December 18th students and staff will dress for a blizzard will

004wear hats scarves gloves and then during lunch we'll take selfies with friends in front of a winter backdrop on Thursday December 19th there's the white out will all wear white like snow during lunch students can guess how many snowflakes are in the jar in a competition finally on December 20th which is Friday before the break we will have our holiday spirit day where we will dress up like our favorite character from a holiday movie wear an ugly holiday sweater or any other fan favorite holiday accessory we're excited to dive in and see everybody have fun for the winter Spirit Week on on a separate note the ghs cell phone committee was able to roll out a cell phone survey to ghs students parents and teachers we will be analyzing the feedback this week and making

005appropriate recommendations tomorrow morning in our next committee meeting I know that the administrators and board of EDS share this as a high priority and as such we are working hard to get a proper regulation passed that everyone can agree on finally I wanted to talk about the Greenwich Public Schools budget it is our understanding that if the appropr budget increase is not passed some teachers will risk losing their jobs to the students this can have a tremendous impact whether it's decreased academic support and guidance less class selection larger academic Labs Learning Centers and study halls or just less staff around the building to keep a feeling of security students rely on these faculty for so much of our education the ghs student government wholeheartedly supports the superintendent's budget to keep current staff classes and programs

006thank you and have a happy holiday we here at Grinch High School can't wait for our break and hope you have a happy one too now I would like to pass the microphone to Rocky or suud and body president hello good evening members of the Board of Ed Dr johnes and community members as always it is an honor to speak before you today building on some of M's previous comments I would like to Prov provide an update on our subcommittees within Student Government let's starting with our advisor based subcommittee under the leadership of Angela B this group is focused on optimizing advisor base to better serve each grade level's unique needs a notable aspect of their efforts includes refining cardal news they are diligently collaborating with Mr Pereira to adjust the content specifically to increase

007segments promoting student clubs and adjust student interviews the student center and environment sub subcommittee have been actively improving our school's physical environment they're currently working on several key projects including replacing outdated flags and pl and planting new trees in the Planters as M will as M has explained our school spirit subcommittee is preparing for an engaging winter Spirit Week scheduled for next week before a holiday break with games and dress up days to live and up the school atmosphere during a bustling time of year next the Food Services subcommittee is taking significant steps to improve our food offerings they are focused on updating our vending machine selections actively seeking healthier options to include in our product product dialogue and to provide nutritious and appealing choices for all students to reaffirm mahir's previous comments on behalf

008of all grenwich high students we express our full support of the superintendent proposed 2025 to 2026 budget we reaffirm the board's commitment to increasing our school budget and providing the best learning experience possible for our students this commitment not only enhances our educational experiences but also supports our overall growth and success thank you for your dedicated dedication and continued support we are eager just share more updates at our next meeting thank you guys so much and uh I'm sure you're goingon to have a wonderful spirit week ahead let's hope the snow stays on the uh within the clothing as opposed to on our grounds um next up we have GAA um Lil if you're here there we go I am here ready to go chair Hurst all right good evening chairwoman Hurst board members Dr

009Jones parents teachers and Community Members First i' like to start off uh with the topic of extended day talk about the extended day at hamv um I have known and work with uh principal Daisy Chipeta at ghs wiro is now principal of hamv school she's an innovator and a go-getter and gets things done we need to start doing and thinking about things differently to meet all Learners and have all St students meet their potential G EA is a support of the extended day at ham a let's talk let's play a little game here let's change it up a little here um we're going to do a little category game here so I'm going to talk about uh something and you see if you can guess the category definition the ability to achieve an end goal

010with little to no waste effort or energy means you can achieve your results by putting the resources you have in the best way possible put simply something is blank if nothing is wasted and all processes are optimized this was Jeopardy I do if we were in person I'd do my little time clock here but we don't so in case you haven't guessed the word it's called deficiencies efficiencies is the word of the evening but the the term efficiency can be defined as the ability to achieve an end goal with little to no waste effort or energy so what does that mean well gaa's interpretation are Polar Opposites to what the town and the BET interprets oh pay attention my friends my parents my teachers and the GPS Community yes little o or no effort for

011the town of be e t to just take a vote to just cut and slash no energy is needed to put their cuts and demands on our student and staff but what is the waste or the waste which rhymes with disgrace here are only a fraction of the list because it is a grand list and I will be updating all trust you on that so here is what we consider some of the waste and it is my moral responsibility to tell a story how it affects our child children students and staff from the operating budgets and so-called efficiencies I'll give you the short list because it is quite extensive FYI 20 2024 reduction 18.9 staff 1.2 K5 reduction in St stiens 1.0 K5 Elementary 4.0 Middle School 6.0 High School 7.7 non-certified staff administrative assistance

012year 25 9.0 certified staff positions 3.0 World Language core sections Middle School 3.0 reduction of two sections at the high school reduction 1.0 dean of students so to this end these are just small little details and I will be talking about and you will hear in future speeches because I am limited on time tonight and the list is long how it really impacts the classroom our students our teachers to be continued and I'd like to wish you all a joyous and happy and healthy New Year and I leave you all with this message we all know who has been naughty and nice and we all know who deserves coal in their stockings and to all good night thank you thanks Lil next up we have a president of PTA Council uh John fiser and then

013I'll roll this over to uh his Coston to run the public uh Community Conference thank you chair hirs Boe members superintendent Dr Jones everyone online thank you for this opportunity to speak I'm John fiser the Greenwich PTA council president and parent of two of the 8513 great kids in the Greenwich Public Schools the PTA council is the umbrella organization made up by and four the 15 independent PT in town we have about 4,000 PTA families in Greenwich we put our kids in the schools we put our hearts and souls into the schools with hundreds and hundreds of hours of volunteer work we put our money into the schools through the taxes we pay and the more than1 and A4 million dollars that ptas spend annually to enhance the learning experience for every student and to

014support our teachers we appreciate the discussion and the apparent support for the proposed budget at the boe's budget meeting last week to quote Mr KD we have all this mandatory spending and very little control over that there's not a lot here to argue about the percent change possible is really not much I am pleased to be here preaching to the choir every year there's some discussion about whether and how the Boe should identify budget cuts to the proposed budget to bring it more in line with bet Guidance the notion being that the Boe would then be making our own decisions well that's a red herring the Boe will make your own decisions to quote bet chair fiser in a recent opinion piece it is crucial to approach the budget process with clarity Focus rather than

015emotional rhetoric budgets are about choices and priorities so let's talk about some things that might add some clarity the grand list in Greenwich is 36.4 billion dollar the largest it's ever been and to quote Pete minarski it is the largest Grand list by far in the state the next largest Grand list is $2 billion less we have 50% more tax base than the second largest community base the grenage mill rate is 11.6 that is essentially the lowest mill rate in the state towns we like to compare ourselves to are not even close Daran new Canan Westport are all at least 50% higher Stamford and Norwalk Two Times Higher Weston Three Times Higher and don't even talk about Westchester County our community is quantitatively wealthy and getting wealthier our poverty rate has declined significantly to just

0164% that's why our Title One funding has been reduced by $600,000 and 800,000 in ARP money that we had this year came to an end but we still have those title one schools we still have in fact we have more great kids who need additional educational support than we used to have as a district we recognize that 1.4 million was money well spent and we recognize the need to continue to fund those areas in other words we still have the same needs we just aren't going to be getting as much of that free govern government handout money and the schools generate about 4.2 million in Revenue which goes directly back to the town an amount remarkably close to the presumed funding Gap and just under half of the year-on-year budget increase the cost increases the

017district is contractually obligated to cover by themselves push the budget over the betet guidelines as Mr KD said we have all this mandatory spending and very little control over that on the other hand adjusting the mill rate by an incredibly small amount could cover the Gap and Greenwich could still have the lowest mill rate in the state that's just a fact and it's about priorities and choices in a quantifiably wealthy community I'm not suggesting the Boe should give the BET guidelines on setting the mill rate it's not your job the boe's job is to ensure that we have a responsible budget that appropriately funds High achieving High ranked schools serving a diverse learning population and providing a quality educational experience for all students and we thank you all for doing that thanks John uh now

018I believe uh we will be turning to our community comment each speaker has three minutes and we begin with Matthew Maloney if he could um raise his hand or identify himself I believe he's permitted to talk hello um I would like to thank you all for letting me speak tonight my name is Matthew Maloney and I'm a captain of the basketball team at grch high school I'm here to today to address the upcoming construction of the basketball court at ghs it is my senior year and I would like to play my home basketball games at ghs in front of my family and friends the leak in the gym occurred on December 1st since we started tryouts on December 5th we have been practicing on the floor which shows no damage I would like to ask

019the construction of the gym to be moved until after the season is over so the winter sports athletes can enjoy their season on their home floor if we are able to safely play on the floor now I don't see why we can't continue throughout the season with the construction going on which is set to start on December 18th six basketball teams the wrestling team fencing cheerleading and UniFi Sports would have to find practice times after school on only two Courts at the moment the varsity basketball team practices at 4:30 my teammates and I stay after school and study before I practice in the homework club with so many teams having to play on limited Court space we may have to practice on one of the Middle School courts which would make it hard for athletes

020to find rides and get to practice coach Bram our head basketball coach has already reached out to Central Middle School to see if we can practice on their Court while the construction is occurring they said we couldn't practice until late at night this would be a struggle for young younger kids who don't drive or working parents who can't make that time commitment this would impact the academic achievement of kids on our team getting home extremely late with homework or a test due the next day would force us into staying up late not allowing us to get the amount of quality sleep that is essential to teenagers thank you good evening uh this is Joe laori can I start speaking laori you're muted yeah terrific I'm un sorry yes oh great thank you good evening uh

021Board of Ed thank you so much for your service uh to our town and these roles I'm here to speak about the critical role this board plays in managing our school budget with schools accounting for 45% of Green's total Town budget your responsibility surely is immense and it's not just a rubber stamp proposals or budgets but to ensure every dollar enhances our students education over the years though we've seen our budget dramatically increase without performance improving significantly this should be a flashing red light for the board not a reason for more spending if investments in education aren't paying off as much as they should for our kids shouldn't we look closely at where those funds are going I mean at the end of the day it's not how much we spend but where we spend

022it and the return we get on it that's important and with the declining enrollment of 500 of 500 students and academic outcomes not improving shouldn't we critically assess and redirect spending once again anyone using the Press marshalling Union reps and leveraging the PTA to push for a bloated budget is it's it's just deeply concerning this shouldn't be the grenage way the narrative that about significant increases will lose essential programs is misleading and disingenuous I mean let's remember that the superintendent works for the board not the other way around and ostensively there are board members on this on at this on our board who who can appreciate the concept of return on investment and fiduciary responsibility but it often seems the board is following the superintendent's lead rather than guiding it the board must reclaim its

023Authority and fulfill its Duty for instance it's repeatedly claimed that there's no room for efficiencies or savings on page 19 of your budget book you're asking for nearly a million dollars in new programs does this align with the claim that a 5.4% increase is the minimum needed we need everyone in town to trust our school board and leaders Hyperbole and misinformation erode that trust can we agree that Honesty transparency and accountability must be the Hallmarks of our budget process I mean meanwhile Democrats in Harford are forcing policies like tampons and boys bathrooms and males competing against females and sports this certainly doesn't reflect our educational priorities here in greenage right I mean coupled with a lack of accountability for student achievement it suggests a disconnect from our children's needs at both the state and local

024levels our money should focus solely on academic artistic and athletic Excellence opportunities that we can increase for our children and school security we've seen decisions like constructing schools at exorbitant prices and transfering transferring expiring federal funds onto local taxpayers with schools taking such a large slice of our financial pie can the board resist this pressure scrutinize every line of this budget and prioritize and invest and fund what directly benefits are students our Boe members must lead this process rather than being cheering bystanders on the sidelines just too important this is the way to restore confidence bring maturity to our school system and secure a fair budget that works for kids parents and taxpayers thank you appreciate it our next speaker is Susan mulie ratray um I've been looking through the attendees but I I don't

025see that name if they want to maybe raise their hand if they're here um if she is not then our next speaker is Jim Maloney and he can go ahead and start speaking good evening uh thanks for the opportunity to speak to you this evening um my name is Jim Maloney um my son Matthew just spoke I'm incredibly proud of him and I'd like to to kind of echo his words all of them and um and and sort of give you my perspective on the matter um I'm a longtime volunteer in town I'm a current on staff coach at Greenwich High School in the boys basketball program for the last four years and you know I just want to advocate for for for kids for the same reasons uh Matt spoke about I'm I'm concerned

026about kids being displaced for longer than alleged um we we've seen water issues at the high school before um I'm not casting any blame or or I'm just uh we haven't had a ton of feedback and I think the plan to um sort of deal with the next month or so is going to be more complicated um then we then we think uh I think again around getting kids to and fr from around parents knowing what the schedule is going to be um and and um you know just uh I'm a little bit frustrated as a parent but and I'm a little bit frustrated for these kids as a coach because the winter sports I I think all uh High School sports it's kind of a narrow window right so basketball maybe two and a

027half months and so for this to to happen at this time is unfortunate um I'd like to see um maybe other options maybe seeing if the floor can um be usable um uh until maybe the end of the year I don't want to I'm not talk I'm not just only advocating for the basketball um program um one other sort of point of frustration around that is that every evening when we leave or or sometimes if it's raining as it has been there can be buckets placed um on the floor um that we have to either work around and and we're managing kind of a water situation on a daily basis already so you know over four years that that's kind of always been a little bit of thorn in my side and and to have

028this happen at this time is um you know it's a um you know it's something that I I don't want to see happen to Matt's team nor the other winter sports um I I'm advocating for other parents um maybe who who don't know about this meeting um and P Georgio our athletic director has been assistive trying to to work up a plan um and I'm just doubtful about the timeline um and that that's pretty much yeah that's pretty much where I'd like to to end thank you thank you to our speakers that is um all we've got for tonight thank you um I will now move on to uh monthly reports Dr Jones sure I think first and foremost um the exciting part is we open Western Middle School Fields today and um Sophie and

029Laura were both able to be there and it was just great it was very cold um but we kept it short and I think the best part was at the very end where all the eighth graders got to literally run across the field so they'll be able to say they're the first um students that stepped on that field so I also just want to say a very special thank you to Dan Watson his entire team this was a big project and a big project to manage so thank you so much to Dan uh and and his team um I want to just remind you the Candlelite concert is next week uh you could go on the 18 18 or the 19th and this is the first one that we've done at the high school and

030it really is all of the different groups coming together for one a big concert and musical evening we're really looking forward to I think it's going to be fabulous um and I know Laura you'll probably mention later but just as a reminder ribbon cutting for Central is next week so we're having a lot of fun right now um and then I I do just want to mention because of the speakers I um I you know hear what they're saying about the gym floor and I just want to reassure the note I sent the board a week or two ago that really hasn't changed matter of fact we got an update today um from Mr Watson and um demolition begins on the 18th uh the material we will be delivered on the 19th and it they'll

031get the subfloor down uh it takes about three or four business days and by the time the floor is back together um it's going to be right around that second week in January around the 15th we think so it it should be a fair really fast process um and just as a reminder it's you know something that was beyond our control um where a coil in the unit didn't drain completely and then it froze and burst and there is damage we brought in the expert flooring people and they looked under the floor and it's because there is uh in that subsurface there's there is damage and you can't have kids on a floor just even for insurance purposes there's even like one little hump uh somebody breaks the leg then um you know that would

032be on us so and and if you have more questions on that I'm happy to you know if Ben or Dan want to chime in but we're going to get it fixed and get kids back on the floor and Pete's doing a terrific job I talked to him several times today um making sure that he's taking care of the kids and the teams that's all for me thank you yeah my my disappointment at uh having the Western Middle School ribbon cutting uh Fields uh for the fields from yesterday to today was was heartbreaking for me because I I'm not in town so I was uh I was sad I can't wait to run across that field when I get home though I was going to call it the Field of Dreams any who had a

033great speech so um I don't know if there are any other committee chairs that would like to um you know present now uh I have an update for Central oh perfect great so um things are moving along at at Julian ctis um so a couple of weeks ago we sent out a letter of intent and award letter to rfj Associates uh for phase one and phase two uh we and that phase one and phase two is primarily focused on Ada improvements and other essential issues to bring a school up to speed and um we're going to begin in summer of 2025 and uh that's when we're breaking ground and uh we and and we'll be up we're we're already we're already we're all meeting and discussing preliminary work to dis to discuss phase three of

034um of the plan and so I'll have updates for that to come that's exciting I see um Dr McAn Anthony's hand up as well thank you um the policy committee policy is on the agenda but um in addition um you you know the board the policy committee met on Wednesday um we have a substitute policy um that's passed our committee that'll be coming to you uh the rest of the board next month in addition um this week we started work on revisions to the bring your own device policy to better align it to existing practices particularly at the high school and uh that will be coming your way soon um we also uh had a preliminary very preliminary start of a conversation around um a new AI policy which we hope um over the next

035couple of months to finalize with the help of Dr Jones's committee um and that also will be stay tuned this winter for for more conversations about artificial intelligence perfect does anybody else have a committee update Miss Cen um so as uh Dr Jones mentioned um CMS is going to have its groundbreaking um on the 20th right before break it's a great way to um celebrate What will what will be to come and um uh it's really you know primarily it's for the school community so um we've got a special day or special afternoon planned for the kids they already had their final field day on the current field and um this puts a um a little um excitement for what's to come um in their day as they head off to break so um we're

036very excited and um I think that's all I've got for you oh wait one more if you know a distinguished teacher or educator please do nominate them um we love reading all the um great things about our amazing Educators not just teachers but also administrators so um uh I hope you'll everyone out there will consider um nominating an educator who's made a big difference in their child's life and we do have some sometimes we have students nominate their teachers which is really also pretty cool so anyway that's my plug and thank you Laura when is the deadline for the distinguish teacher oh I should know that sorry we're not close yet we're not close yet okay good because I know it's a long process so okay um yeah Dr Jones has been putting it in

037her um Friday Note have you not been been reading your Friday note homework um are there any other committee updates I know I know we've uh we've met recently so the only other committee I mean I can add mine um emac met this week um and we're talking um again about solar panels for Central Middle School um as well as some other topics um I know we're still waiting on um some other information regarding the HVAC um you know uh a geothermal over at uh at Hamilton Avenue but other than that uh it was a productive meeting and were waiting for some answers on a few things but that was pretty much it at at emac okay doesn't sound like we've had any other committee meetings to go over so we can move on to

038action items um and our first action item is the Old Greenwich School building committee schematics um um happy to make a motion to put that on the table so we can have a discussion um the greenish board so I'm would like to make a motion for the grenwich Board of Education to approve the submitted plans and specifications for the Old Greenwich expansion and renovation project dated November 22nd 2024 prepared by Sil silver petrulli and Associates and the cost estimated on November 12 2024 prepared by d's construction to proceed to the office of Grants Administration for a plan review completion do I have a a second I will second the motion thank you and we can open this up for discussion um I don't know Mike or or Ben if you'd like to to kick us

039off yeah I mean I um thank so the um on on the call tonight um you'll see our vice chair uh Jackie Welsh as well as David Stein from Silver Petrelli and our Lawrence radi our building web here with Ben um they um we are doing double duty here as a building committee because um the bet is also um meeting and things like that so um you should have received um a link to the 100% completion documents here for the Old Greenwich uh program which is very exciting uh but I'm happy to turn it over to Jackie Welsh who who's going to lead us through this thank you um good evening Board of Education chair hsch and superintendent Jones I am Jackie Welsh Vice chair of the old grwi building committee and with me to

040answer any questions you may have are David Stein our architect from Silver petrielli Associates and Lawrence retti our owner's representative from the maranti group um the Old Greenwich building committee approved the construction documents and cost estimate at our last meeting um with your certification construction documents and cost estimates we will be able to attend the state meeting next Thursday for a plan completion review which will lead to an approval for us to go to bid in February and start construction this coming April um David and Lawrence do have anything to add to this I know David might all I could say is this is the um this is identical process that you recently did with the Central Middle School it's a similar process that you did where we LED at the Greenwich high school project

041so your approval of the plan specifications an estimate allow us to move to that plan completion review any comments that come out of there from the state and then ultimately their permission to go out to bid we did receive or in the process of receiving all of the signatures from your local building fire 504 and Health Department we've secured those signatures which was part of the plan review and there's about 80 items on our checklist that we will be presenting to um to the office of Grants Administration which also uh endorses that we had planning and zoning and ARC approval and also any other land use approval so forth so essentially these documents are ready to go and in short order we'll be we'll be out to bid and Lawrence do you want to add

042to this I know you got most of the signatures it's a big job yeah as David David pretty much covered it up tomorrow I'll be picking the plans up and meeting with a couple people and uh in preparation for next Thursday with our PCR meeting so um board of education do you have any questions for us I do I have one okay it's it's is it usual for boards to approve hundreds of pages of technical documents I just don't feel like I have to put my name and my stamp of approval on you know what materials you're going to be using in the Windows like I I feel like that's a a bigger P I feel like we should be voting on something a bigger picture rather than this entire I'll give that to David

043he's had many of these reviews so I I'll be happy to happy to answer that yeah obviously the the link that we sent you was pretty voluminous with two volumes of drawings and and three specifications Lawrence I think has broken his back because if you see the amount of paper that he's carrying around so to expect the Board of Ed to do a technical review that's not really the perview here um what what the board of education is doing is just allowing permission there is a building committee which has has an array of experts that are sitting on that town has hired an owner's rep or Lawrence rosadi we have a construction manager who has done their part of the project this this approval that's being asked upon or the motion that's currently there is

044to move this through to the plan completion review so the state Architects have the ability to do the plan review so yes this is part of the submission and it's the attachment that goes along with this but this is actually statute driven this process that requires the Board of Education the building committee and obviously your Architects so in terms of the approval and liability that's there it sits on the stamp and shoulders of our expertise and the team that has been assembled around that but this happens on every project as I mention this and the your last two projects the grenwich high school projects that we were the architect of record for and your Central Middle School project which is which is performed by another team this is the common practice that happens in all

045169 towns in the state of Connecticut are there any other [Music] questions no if there's no uh other questions on this I'm happy to uh call the question um and I will go in in order uh Mike yes Jen yes Laura yes Sophie yes Wendy same Kathleen yes and Cody yes and uh I'm a yes so that's 701 correct yeah thank you very much thank you look forward to uh to to seeing us move forward with this wonderful project too so next on to the big uh big item of the night and uh Mike did you have you had a hand raised or you just waving no I was waving goodbye oh thank you just checking my fellow building committee members no problem I was say we move on to the big the big topic

046of the night the operating budget for 2526 um and I will make a motion to put that on the table so can I make I'm making a motion to approve the proposed FY 2025 2026 operating budget as presented do I have a second a second thank you Sophie and I will turn this over to uh to Dr Jones um first of all just thank you to the team um the cabinet that really worked on getting all of your questions answered over the last uh since the last meeting there were there was quite a bit of data if you haven't had a chance to look at it I encourage you because I know it comes so quickly and this meeting came quickly so um there's a lot of really great data in there so I encourage

047you to look at that if you haven't had a chance to study it enough um but I'll turn it over to the questions that you have um tonight and again we've answered so many questions on on paper that I just want the community to know there's a lot of out there okay does anybody have any questions for Dr Jones anyone have a hand raised no questions no comments nothing okay Cody yeah I'll uh just get right into the action um the so I have a comment um actually before I say anything it just cracked me up in the public commentary the uh oh we have the lowest mill rate and the highest property value uh it's like as if those two things aren't related but I digress um uh so with the budget um like

048I've said I think it's pretty reasonable budget we're we're staring at my budget book um there's uh I think there are there's an interesting Dynamic on the way we do budgeting which is oftentimes we'll look at individual programs and we'll curtail them so we'd say you know positive Pathways can we get 50 grand out of that or um ham have like that might cost 150 or whatever um or uh Laura what's the thing that um is always on your list uh professional development professional development yeah yeah and and like everybody will kind of everyone has their different things and then we all kind of you know Nick away at them based on what we know at that moment and then the actual administrators have to go and um implement the budget and the way that

049things are in 2026 ends up being slightly different than the way they are today what I've struggled with is I've tried to figure out how to what the right levels are is there are some things on here from my own review and reasonable people can disagree um that you know they really are ranges and these are Point estimates and we tend to pick upper ends at least in my opinion of ranges which is a responsible thing to do if you're trying to make sure you have enough support uh for any individual program but on a collective basis what you often end up with or what you can end up with is if you take the kind of what you think the upper level is for every item then when you put them all together you

050end up with a little extra um and so instead of trying to nitpick on individual things the idea that I had um was wanted to propos to everybody was what's two there's one particular program that I want to strike I'll come back to that and then the other um thing is having a general bucket that instead of us deciding you know and arguing over which little pool we wanted to pull back on or where there's ranges uh you know which which ranges we wanted to encroach on to instead say uh or or ask the administration um and say you know hey we'd like a general bucket that you can apply across wherever you see fit but the expectation is that you would find you know Call It Whatever an efficiency bucket or something but you

051you're going to have to go apply that bucket to some of these areas like I have my own sense of where I think that would end up but uh I'm recognizing that my information is not as good today as it will be for say Tony a year from now and so um getting that savings without forcing it to necessarily be there to make sure that the Administration has flexibility to implement it so what I uh want to seek or proposed and recognizing that um uh this probably can go through anyways but if we want to get to like a maybe broader support for the budget would be a $500,000 efficiency bucket or whatever label we want to come up I don't care that's that's topic one for me if you want to do that though

052just when you're going through topics you just have to make it as a motion so that oh yeah I'll do it as a motion I just this is just general Cody thinking and then happy to talk about it or do the motion thing or whatever uh the other the only specific line item that I want out uh for my support is the teacher devices refresh just to I'll stop talking because I know I've been talking for a while although I spend a lot of time in the background on the budget committee so spare me a minute or two um uh the teacher device refresh I obviously get the if you give if I gave the folks that work for me new devices and then I took them away at some point they would show up

053at my house with pitchforks so I understand the um uh motivation the my hang up on it is two things one is that it's a program that was only created because of covid for emergency measures um that doesn't mean that emergency program can't become a great program like all any good government emergency program it's moving into the permanent Zone but the main thing is that we already have an existing computer program and we're not phasing that out so right now we would have two pro two comp sets of computer programs one with the desktop in the classroom one with the laptop what I would say is I have no issue if the administration wants to phase out the desktop program if they want to create an optional program where teachers can pick one or the

054other or whatever I don't care just as a matter of principle if we have something that was created only to address a very specific specific crisis in the moment and we want to continue it and make it permanent without replacing the thing that it was put in place to do that would be my objection I totally don't expect to convince you know I don't know I wouldn't be surprised if I couldn't convince any of you of that but for me to vote for the budget those are the two things that I'm in favor of um and otherwise I do think the budget is in a reasonable place and I think the um Administration did a very good job not just assembling it but explaining the rationale behind things and how they put it together um

055and uh you know that's obviously Tony but Ben and Patrick too um so let me stop talking for a moment and uh I just wanted to kind of lay my cards on the table and everyone wants to ignore them and proceed that's fine m so um yeah just taking a step back that was um first of all I just wanted to thank Tony and everyone again and Ben who's obviously um been working on this for a long time new to our district but not new to uh Greenwich um this was an incredible process and that's why I think um it's been such a robust process that I you found so many of the efficiencies and so and I and I I think Cody and I are agreeing on on that um just to remind everyone

056you know we started this process I guess on November 7th right um we've had multiple budget meetings we've had um a couple budget meetings which have been really helpful where we've gone through um a lot of these difficult questions I think Dr Jones just submitted the part four budget Q&A so I do encourage everyone to go online I just for those of you that you know it's a busy time of year so um I just don't want people to think that we have't been working hard on this there has been many meetings many hours and most importantly the administration and the team have spent tireless I can't even imagine how long it took to constantly keep responding to our questions so thank you for that um one of the things that I find interesting although

057it's very small and this budget is Hamilton Avenue and um this and I noticed Diane Fox is on tonight so perhaps she's going to talk to us a little bit about that um I am excited about that I know that is an investment and it's a additional it is $200,000 so um and at first though I have to admit tonight I was going to say well you know if it's if we haven't done our proper due diligence on it I'm not sure I'm willing to sort of consider it in the budget but then you sent a PowerPoint presentation and now I am starting to get comfortable with it um so that's not a 202,000 a 200,000 that I could feel easily comes out however I do feel um that they're probably look it's a $22

058million budget if Cody suggesting 500,000 we're talking 0.25% um I think that that while we always do we get seemingly closer and closer every year on how much money we return to the town and we are starting to be in a margin of ever of less than 1% um I could maybe get comfortable with a 0.25% efficiency if um I hear from Dr Jones and Ben that um you know if if they if it if over the next few weeks they feel like they could hit every pocket they could get somewhere um I'm just concerned that then adding um a program on top of that might be difficult but I want to hear about that I guess so Karen do you want us to speak to the programs first sure I mean I knew I

059had sent some some questions in regard to Hamilton Avenue um you know I see daies out there so she like to step for as well as to address anything yeah and and I'll just I'll start with um the Hamilton Avenue program and then I'll let Daisy speak because she actually worked on that PowerPoint um for you I think one of the big takeaways for me is the one slide that actually shows where extending the day by two hours and you could see exactly where the staff at Hamilton Avenue are looking at putting that instructional time it's reading and math which can really impact children and you know currently we have a 6 and a half hour day um adding those two hours is the equivalent of 55 extra school days and it's kind of hard

060to wrap your head around that that's a lot of instructional time so I think you know the one thing we hear during the budget every year is what can we do differently think out of the box especially in our schools where children are learning you know English as a second language and um they have a lot um to teach children and so I think it could be a really powerful program for us so if you want to elevate Daisy if oh there she is I see her on the screen so Daisy do you want to add um anything to the program based on the great PowerPoint and that you recorded I'm happy to answer any questions I can't uh start my video but I can uh unmute myself um thanks for the opportunity to um

061allow me to share the PowerPoint it was certainly has been an interesting experience researching uh extended school days and um working with um different various people on thinking differently for Hamilton Avenue School we are really excited about it cautiously optimistic it's it's a big lift for our school but we we the one thing that I've heard for three years that I've been here this is my third year at Hamilton Avenue School is time is really important to our students and we have used some grant money to extend our school day in in various different ways with some before school programming some after school programming to help support our needest Learners and we're just uh looking and decided to just make the school day longer not just have tutorial kind of services for our kids after

062school so I'm happy to answer any questions from you all is any oh okay Miss beat um good evening um principal Fox I was wondering if you could tell us some of the metrics that will be using to determine success with this program if and when it does launch sure um we are will most likely use some of the same metrics that we are currently using now we use lots of um standardized testing and research-based uh models and programs within the school so things obviously are standardized uh test scores uh through linkit through SBA but also sort of the interim pieces of data that we collect and examine on a regular basis from iabs or fibbs which are the interim assessments we would also look at our Lexia data ourl data we do this currently

063and on a regular basis and we use that data to inform instruction and to create small groups so certainly that would be um some major data points as well as looking at things like um you know um attendance student satisfaction um staff satisfaction and and parent uh satisfaction as well thank you does anybody else have a question Cody um the uh it just Benz on right P Ben bener Patrick do do you guys have the number for what what hamv school costs in total uh yes I just wanted to make a point which I think is worth mentioning which is the one way to measure the output of these schools is instruction of all all the schools we have is instructional time and this is a 28% increase in instructional time and I wanted to

064just compare that to what the actual increase in cost is when you think about baying for your buck like this is one of the programs I think is the most exciting if anything we're going to hopefully do this year or for next year um but uh Patrick when you find the number because it's very interesting to take the 200,000 which by the way I mentioned the band I actually think it will come in costing less than 200,000 we don't need to worry about that because I think that will show up hopefully in my bucket but um uh I just can't remember the number off the top of my head and but it's worth what is it oh sorry yeah it is on the budget book page um the 2026 budget for Hamilton fu is $

0656.07 million yes so it's a um it's a 3% increase in cost to get a 28% increase in output which for all the loose throwing around of words like efficiency and stuff that is I think really really like I'm not aware of anything else that we're doing from a dollar spending standpoint where we get more output okay Mike yeah I me while on on on on ham AB um at the same time it is uh school with you could argue looking to achievement data our most acute academic need um so I mean I'm all for it I think this is um um a terrific idea I commend Miss Fox and and and the team for putting it together the only thing I think the um we need to make sure of as a board is

066um we come back and take a look at it the I think it would make sense when we think when we come down to to um agenda topics later in the meeting I think it makes sense to have an because this is so different the um an implementation check B based at the end of the year and see you know how we're ready to go you know and how the planning is going and things like that stuff I think is part of all this we because I think and then again next year I think it's something we have to talk about um but I think it's um I really think it's marvelous thank you um does anybody else have any questions otherwise I I'll toss one out um I know we consistently talk about ways

067to shrink that academic divide um amongst the students at all of our schools and I think this is an incredible program an idea of a program it's something I know we've talked about for over the sort of on and offer it's been mentioned over at least the past year um and you know if you look at studies um about programs like this um you do see incredible gains in academics and school connectivity and and other things so I think it's a really wonderful idea um I just wanted to ask at least you know just basically two questions I know um it wasn't or at least I don't remember it being addressed um in the presid but is this something you're looking to do for the entire school or is it simply like a class per

068grade um thanks I think you know originally how the superintendent wrote it in her budget was for um one class per grade so we've been still in the examination phase of of trying to figure out how we Implement something like that and which teachers get um you know stay and get the extra two hours and which ones don't we don't necessarily need to I I would prefer for it to be the entire school because I do think there will be an equity issue if we try to do it one grade per uh one grade per you know one section per grade okay I guess that asks leads me to the next question then is the funding that we have um put here is that is that just for one class per grade then or are

069we looking to do it uh per school because I assume if we are looking to do it for the entire school if there's families that can't uh have their students there for a full day we we'd have to look into other you know other other things but if if I might jump in um so it we've built it so that we could have it's it's a two section school it's not a four section school which means you have two classes on each grade level this number could swing in either direction and I think Cody kind of mentioned this before when you're building a new program we built it on a teacher that is like at at that 120 125 uh ,000 so a lot of it depends on who in up taking these positions and

070what roles and the number gets refined once we actually know that but that's the way it was absolutely built um was so that we could do it on the two sections okay and you know I know you know I guess um I know I'd sent a couple of questions and I I think I think it would be really helpful to support this program if we know of any other districts that have schools being run with this model and we can show how you know the improvements that have been made there somewhere in the general local regions um but I guess my final question is you know I don't know this is an entirely new program and not an entirely new way of running one of our schools if that's the case and and uh bell

071times and scheduling and things like that I know there's a lot that goes into it um but I assume we would be uh looking at this as if it were a pilot program and making a commitment to run it for a certain period of time while we consistently go back and look at data to you know achievement data and other data um do you know how long I I don't know if you're looking at it that way or you you know well and the honest answer yeah is the first year that I was here I was told never use the word pilot and I don't know what pilot we had um but don't use that word because people see something and maybe all those people don't watch these meetings anymore or aren't involved I don't

072know so I've never used the word pilot when since I've been here because I was told not to so to me anytime you implement a program it doesn't matter what it is if it's special education like the program if it's our C- teing program we are constantly studying the data is the program working is what we intended to happen is is that the result that we're seeing and you usually give any program at least three years because we know that from research-wise that's just what it takes generally to see change and one of the questions you I think it was your question that was uh really good was you know you you asked a question almost just like that and the answer was you know because it does add the equivalent of 55 school days

073there are some schools that have seen quicker returns rather that's been adding 20 days to the end of the year or beginning of the year or rather that's extending the school day so will it take as long to see if the program is working it may not um but you generally when you're implementing you want to give something solid at least three years but we should be we should be reviewing and evaluating all of our programs which we do every single year so so that I mean that's how we look at Specialized programming perfect you gave me the you pretty much gave me what I was looking to here is just that we're we're making the commitment to to give this time to see to be able to reflect back on data to see if

074it's you know I don't know whoever said this earlier but cost on you know you know investment you know return on investment and I you know like I said from all of the studies that have been done on doing this I you know we've seen it around the country I'm hoping we can see it as well here I'm sure I'm sure that would be the case does anybody else have any additional questions on ham or otherwise M um well I have questions otherwise but I I wanted to make sure we're done with Hamilton Avenue so yeah that's what I was just gonna say if anybody else has a question on Hamilton Avenue speak now Jen I was just wondering um where or rather what your goals are for the program in terms of data would

075you like to see like X percentage of students who you know um are in the program achieve at certain levels do you have an idea of you know kind of what your goals are for the first year or potentially the SE second year rather or the third year how are you defining the goals that you'd like to see for for the program first of all I think once we get into really the fine points of the program we would actually be looking at defining that but the best example I have is if you think about New Lebanon this year and what what the change happened and the results they got that we shared with you in the fall we were seeing 10% 11% uh increases in growth and that is that's phenomenal um so that's

076what we would love to see you know at another Title One school is to be able to emulate that type of success um but we would refine that as we go in and really look at um individual students and you know what are the different growth targets and where do we think that we we can be to get us Beyond to close more of that achievement Gap in a building that has a lot of students it is our demographic that has the most students who are also learning to speak English at the same time they're learning um to read in English Okay Cody is that is this about hamv yeah I was just going to say we actually have a principal of a school that practices this program currently on our board uh I don't

077want to put him on the spot but Mike it I you didn't mention that in your comments it might be worth sharing your observations from actually running a program like this well well obviously New York City is full of um a lot of robust extended day schools it's it's um but yeah I mean I I can I can say that I've seen this firsthand the um both for like you're saying for language acquisition um literacy closing skills gaps all the things that simply is not possible in the length of a traditional school day um it's it's it's uh it's it's a absolute fundamental necessity yeah so so um and I don't want to quote I don't I'm I'm not one of my pet peeves is uh educrats who talk about oh and the research is

078full of all this without being able to cite specific examples of research so I'll refrain from that but I I'm sure that um you'll be able to find lots of examples out there because this is this is not an this is not an uncommon strategy thank you Cody for putting me on the spot Sophie I saw your hand up before yeah I just had a question about um I mean I am generally supportive but I'm and I'm very very pleased with the strides that they've made at New Lebanon and I'm wondering what have they already implemented at ham that is similar to what they're doing at newb you know and is that not working there you know or or is this kind of an interesting running our own experiment where we have newb doing one

079type of intervention and then ham would be doing the other like you know just sort of I'm curious from Dr Jon's perspective why have two different tracks so it we really wouldn't have two different tracks and I and I think it'd be good for Daisy to talk about um she has looked at what they did at new lab and looked at that carefully and has done a great job partnering trying to get some funding in the school uh and thanks to the greinwich alliance so Daisy do you want to talk about the model they're using at newb and kind of how you've made some adjustments with the additional um grant funding but that grant funding will run out and that's always a concern it I'm happy to talk about that um we actually have been

080really successful in in getting some grant funding for a few programs for Hamilton Avenue School as you know our school is unique um from the other schools in that we really didn't have we don't have um recreational Afters and we didn't have a whole lot of academic Afters here um last year we got a grant from The granch Alliance For Education to run an after school kindergarten program because we didn't have any uh after school support for kindergarteners and that's up and running this year in addition we were awarded some title for grant money where we did some before and after school programming that really focused on academics and that was really um to we gave teachers an opportunity to identify students that they thought could benefit from receiving some extra instruction in math extra

081instruction in ela but also um um some support around vocabulary growth and language usage and game playing and and things that are we are really noticing that some of our students are lacking for a variety of reasons maybe uh because moving into the country or moving or coming not having exposure to preschool so uh we we really used the grant funding last year to support some of those programs this year uh we were really um interested and excited for our friends over at New Leb school so I did spend uh quite a bit of time with Dr Russo in kind of examining their model of um um administering the interim assessments and then using those to formulate groups so because we had some funding from title 4 last year we were able to start our

082school year off um specifically with before and after school programming to uh fill gaps and and build skills for our students we didn't wait until like in Prior years we we waited until sort of halfway through the school year before we implemented this program programing so we can collect some data this year we used data from end of last year beginning of this year um specifically a really helpful tool was using the linkit to identify um areas that were gaps for our students and that's what we're doing right now we call them um if you will boot camps where we're um inviting students either before or after school to get some of this tutorial support we have a variety of teachers that are doing that but not only are like our our neighbors at new

083lab we're administering iabs we're analyzing the data formulating the groups we're bringing the kids in we're T we're giving them some tutorial services and then we're reassessing them and then either keeping them or sending them out you know back and then you know starting up with a new group so it's been really exciting the teachers are so positive about it and really working so incredibly hard um so that's exciting for for us as a school thank you so much does anybody else have additional questions for principal box if if not uh we can move on to other questions and topics and um Diane thank you so much the enthusiasm and and the excitement over this program um it's clear from members of the board and from you yourself I'm glad to hear that the teachers

084are are also excited about this I know our parents and students will have a great benefit if we are you know able to put this in play yes Cody just practical question with the ideas I laid out before is it appropriate for me to make a motion to implement those and L what's the right way to do that motion to amend yeah motion to amend do you want to do that now or do you want to wait till like a couple of people had I guess questions and I don't know I don't I don't want to do it either way I'm not sure what the best practice is can I ask one question I guess and then maybe we then maybe we can try to make some motions okay cool yeah keep going okay um

085oh good I have a charger coming away um Dr Jones could you tell me a little bit about um I guess just go a little bit into the device program if you will so I can everyone can understand that a little bit more yeah so I I was listening to both of those that Cody said and I I will say on the device program um there there is definitely some misunderstanding about the program so the program was here long before I got here and we've had a onetoone program in Greenwich elementary middle and high school and somebody that's on this call may know the exact year but I would say 2016 2017 somewhere around in there but it was established before I started um and when we got into covid it's not that we implemented

086a new device program uh for covid the problem we were having in the spring of 2020 and that's when they shut everybody down you know across the country is that the devices we had the Chromebook were not robust enough and so when we were getting ready to go into that next year we had some covid grant money that really helped us um get new devices in the hands of our kids because once they had so much online not only through schoology and Google classroom and they needed to be able to run videos and have all these things going at the same time um they needed a higher level laptop and secondary so we bought new laptops that were more robust so that they if they chose a especially kids that chose and their parents chose

087to be remote um because we had families if you remember entire K5 remote school we had remote students in middle school and high school because it was parent choice um so we've always we've had the Ono one for a very long time so I just want to clarify that you know first um we we have to have a desktop and a laptop in order to operate um in our in our schools so they're used differently they're used often simultaneously um the other thing is just the way that you connect whether you're using the Smartboard you know with the desktop but then you're also doing uh you're monitoring something that students are doing out in the classroom through your laptop there's just they're used differently and that's just the way that teachers teach today um we

088also if we to tried to take a laptop and when you think of greinwich high school and you were connecting reconnecting all the devices all day long um they would also wear out and that's that's something that Mike teting has talked about um before when we discussed this but as we were building the budget that the laptops wouldn't last at all we have teachers who share classrooms you know we don't have the space at the high school where everybody just owns their own room that's just not how they operate and so if we tried to disconnect unconnect it just doesn't work um so there's there are issues and you know as recent as in the last week you know I had the math coordinator come to me and say how can I get this teacher

089a new laptop she's teaching uh in one of our Title One Schools she's teaching math her laptop will not stay charged you know looks okay the keys are all there it will not stay charged and she's trying to use it in the in the instructional lesson and it it won't work um and so you know we did like an emergency reached out to the text we need to get a new laptop that's just an example where the coordinator was in model teaching and you know partner teaching with the teacher so we know about it but we've you know the stories around the district keys are starting to fall off things like that so I'm a little worried about not funding that 225,000 when it's an instructional tool that's it's we rely on it um and

090we have for many many years and more so now than ever Kathleen I was to say just just to jump I think those were rolled out like 2014 2015 with the implementation of the prior strategic plan uh for personalized learning it was on to one devices I think I'm correct I don't know Kathleen Am I Wrong um I think so sorry I'm moving on to my next question which which is a followup so in my head I was like asking it um and maybe it's to Ben because I I want to I think I can get comfortable with the 500,000 efficiency Cody I'm just trying to understand then the teacher devices is an additional 225 as it is currently in in the program I mean Ben is that that's only a partial refresh obviously that

091wasn't every device I mean what were we talking here and so I can try to understand are we at the upper end of the range and this particular case Cody is this more middle is this low like I'm just trying to get a sense for it the math on the devices is it's a fouryear refresh out it's 250 devices per year at 8.99 so it's in the course of four years you'll refresh about a thousand devices well right now there's you know 975 issued so it's it's it's 250 a year Ben what's what was the um because this is an increase over last year what was the refresh for last year these are the first time this this these devices are hitting the refresh cycle but what about for Chromebooks or just existing uh or

092were all the Chromebooks replaced at once yeah it was a onetime lump some yeah that's so that put us put every that put us in this position right now by the way just to clarify by the I'm not saying get rid of the Chromebook program it's just go back to the program that we had before Co yeah that's what that's what we're actually doing so these are actual the teacher devices so most the a lot of these are not even Chromebooks we have mac airs we have regular um just uh regular PC laptops we have uh Chromebooks and it very much especially during covid um we tried to make sure that you know we had the device that the teacher is most comfortable on because a lot of it depends on you know what subject

093you teach um you know which which device you may be more comfortable utilizing based on what you're utilizing with students but the students are all the same as far as Chromebook but in teachers it's very individualized as far as uh we have two or three different I think and we may have even had a a tablet but um there's two or three different choices they had um so that they weren't making changes if they are not a Mac person not used to being on a Mac most most people don't want to switch um but but there was a level of laptop quality that was available pre-co and this is the thinging this is the teacher device and it's it there's teacher devices are teacher devices um they're just wearing out but the student devices have

094been Chromebooks and those were upgraded but that's not what this is so this was this program was unaffected by Co it was unaffected other than we had to upgrade some of the teachers which they they still need now because the technology that we started infusing in Co has not gone away so we may have had a student on a Chromebook and or sorry a teacher on a Chromebook and it couldn't really do what they wanted it to so they may have switched to either a Mac like a Mac Air or a regular just PC uh laptop because the Chromebooks weren't robust enough um to to manage the software and the that we were using them and that has not gone away um you know the things a most of what we were using like this

095meeting we would have never had this meeting pre-co it's not really going away to have virtual meetings so it's just the way we teach and the way we work is very different and it has changed yeah know I guess I just wanted to make sure because some of the details that we talked about like budget committee are slightly I guess we we can't say that there was no impact of Co on the laptop program but Co required us to upgrade some of the you know the performance characteristics like I get the idea that during Co you have you say okay there's much greater demands from a laptop standpoint so therefore we do this big refresh and people who used to be using Chromebooks which are a lot cheaper suddenly are using $900 laptops by the

096way like you can buy a really good laptop for $300 and my my contention with this is the performance characteristics of the laptops that I think are needed in a non-co environment are different than the ones needed in a Co environment and therefore it doesn't make sense to budget around that level but that's that's just to kind of I guess level set on the bid ask here yeah I mean I think that I'm just going to say from a professional standpoint we have to make sure the teachers have the tools and resources that they need and I think that's what we have right now and it's it's supporting the teachers and these devices last I mean you know they they're not just a year or two and even with the Chromebooks that we replaced we

097end up moving a lot of those down to Elementary where they're not as robust but they can use them to write stories and do things and they can you know do their uh practice assessments so that they're getting ready for esack on them so we're very very thoughtful um about how we utilize the devices um so I I think we're asking for what we need and and and again it kind of goes back to some of the other line items you know we're talking about 225,000 a year to make sure our teachers have what they need and we have a a lot of curriculum resources that are online a lot of them uh Mike's hand to it was first and Laura thanks thanks I just want to um make sure I clarify here this this

098conversation starting to rais lots of my uh inner warning worries about screen time and things like that but that's a different conversation um so make sure I'm clear so uh as a matter of uh practice right now uh Dr Jones so we issue um every teacher a a computer yes yeah laptop if they want one I mean we may have a few that don't want them but the vast majority need them in their role depending on what they do yes okay all right and the numbers went too fast for me so the the the the the 200 this year um the 225 this year we think is um purchasing how many new devices for teachers uh 250 devices per year so that just be every every year it's 250 that'll put the entire laptop on

099a four-year replacement cycle okay and we have about a thousand you said you have about a thousand out there yes okay so that hence the fouryear yep cycle okay all right and the last time any of the devices were we placed is right around 2020 the devices we're talking about we did a lump sum purchase in 2021 in 20121 okay s two funds okay so this is this was it so in that case it's C to related a little bit that it's this was erra money at least the that now where're we're trying to replace with with with um um District funds correct okay okay Laura I just want to make sure everybody understands these are so the teachers have lap uh computers that meet their needs like with one running the Smartboard and the

100other being used for assessments and other um tasks within the within the classroom I I don't know that everybody understands that these are teacher devices has nothing to do with Co and they need them to um Implement their lessons that's I just want to make sure everybody's you know clear well Laura just it does relate to Co in the sense that we upgraded the performance characteristics of the types of laptops that the teachers have during covid and we were able to do that with government money that was free and quotes but these are you know these are different yeah but like what a second grade teacher needs a $900 laptop for teaching second graders there's a reason reasonable people could disagree about the performance characteristics required of a computer for that role I don't think

101that sorry I'm jumping in and I think Dr Jones or Ben can sort of speak to that but I don't think they were suggesting every teacher is getting a $900 Chromebook $900 Mac I was saying I think she was saying that depending on the needs of a a teacher they may have a different type of device but you know they do get outdated we do like part of the reason we have to buy new some of the new textbooks which have all gone online is because you know the new software that comes out with the you know with the with computers and things can't run the old textbooks the textbooks have you know other things that are required um it's why we have to refresh textbooks as well um you know online because but this

102assumption is all of them are replaced at $900 which is my beef with the amount right I don't think that's what Dr Jones was saying though but then we don't need the number to reflect that is in fact the Assumption right yeah that's the math exactly like Karen that's exactly my point about my hesitation on this one so I guess if I could say it a little bit differently we took advantage we had to replace the laptops right and you could argue Cody if if they were too good or not um at that time we took a we used funds which I think was probably a good call at the time rather than taking it from the district funds so we were able to use our Esser funds because I'll remind everyone since I was

103very happy to be on the board during that time that we get a lot more funds than any of our towns because we were the first school to what go back to school in the state and therefore we get a lot more money than we anticipated and so I'm pretty excited that we use that money um to take advantage of it at that time to buy laptops now I appreciate that we are now four years into the laptop program um I can tell you my laptop is probably at the end of its lifetime um and so I think $900 to me Cody is kind of middle of the road when I look at them um and I I look at what's out there um so I suspect that we're just taking an average um but

104I can see how this is now a four-year replacement cycle this figure does make sense to me now that I understand it a little bit more I was not Cody I do admit that we it was a little bit confusing um the way I originally understood it through our budget meetings but I think I now finally appreciate it Mike and then Sophie sorry no I forgot to lower my hand okay um yeah I just this is a very helpful conversation because when I think about a the last round of the laptops being replaced for years from now I can say that I don't know very many laptops that last seven years so that actually makes me concerned um but also just wanted to to speak to I appreciate that there there was a significant change

105in the way that teachers teach because of Co and that's continued on and there's also this expectation that um they are using laptops to communicate with parents to communicate with students um in a way that that I can just say as a parent I saw there's been a a real see change like I doubt there's any teacher in the school system that isn't using a computer because because you need it to communicate with you know to evaluate your students to communicate with parents communicate with the kids so you know I do feel like this is a priority to have a good high functioning equipment if that's like key to interfacing with students and parents Mike is your hand back up or want to call on you but I'm not sure if you yeah I I

106just worry I worry about comments that and I hear what you're saying Sophie I'm worried that we're institutional we were sometimes we're institutionalizing um practices that maybe we shouldn't I I mean is um we talk about instruction not returning to pre-co um some um tradition sometimes that's good sometimes that bad the um um I I I I have a lot of concerns about how much we're on screens um over the course of the school day and and and and I worry if we might be um if anything you know sometimes unintentionally accelerating that with some of this they um just like we are with maybe not buying more books instead of online um curricula and things like that but that's a whole different conversation I don't think it's but I do think it's it's slightly

107connected when we when we make these purchases why will say that when we buy textbooks that are online and the programs are online we do always have uh physical copies of books for students to be able to bring home so that they're not always on the computer as well but we are talking about our Educators who do run things uh through that as well so um but I think the screen time yeah discussion it will probably come back at some point I'll call on Dr Jones and then Mike and then you know yeah you kind of you kind of mentioned what I was gonna say Karen I don't want anybody to be watching this meeting and think that our kids are on laptops all day because that's just not accurate and we've invested in that

108ARP funding more in if you look at like our K5 and the libraries and the books that we have in classrooms now because of that funding and those of you that have been out in the buildings and visited the classroom that's what you're seeing you know we have hegerty we have found foundations those are all those are teachers teaching and it's not they're not on laptops and the classroom libraries have been expanded because they they've got books in their hands so I just want to make sure and that you know all the way through high school you can go and watch these amazing Socratic seminars and um and again when we have those visits if you haven't been out in the classrooms we encourage you to come so that you can see what's really happening

109the thinking classroom some of you been able to see that you know that that's students collaborating around the board that's what you see in our schools so yes we use laptops we use them appropriately um but I don't want anybody to think that number one we didn't rely on Virtual like school districts that were closed for a year and a half so we didn't develop the same bad habits and in fact our teachers it was so difficult because they were still teaching face to face and doing everything handson they could and in our secondary they were also streaming in people's houses because they were afraid for their children to be in school so I think we don't have the same bad habits and it's another reason we don't have the student achievement um challenges that

110many districts do with our demographic that we're out of school for a year and a half so I I just want to be sure that people know we have great teaching going on okay Cody um do we have um could someone just remind me how many teachers in the high school have have a laptop is it's it's useful probably to to separate between the different environments because for the most part teachers across the distric whether you're elementary middle or high school they all need them you will have some teachers that maybe they have their own and they prefer their own and they're on their own more often um because they could utilize their own device if they wanted because they're still through our filter um but the vast majority of teachers if you are somebody

111who's testing children all your testing software you may not be a face to-face classroom teacher your testing software is all online you have to no no I'm I'm totally with you on that it and this isn't saying don't have teach use laptops it's saying that there was a step change in the way the laptop program worked during Co do we have the number of teachers that we were providing laptops to that chose not to use their own device pre-o versus post I don't know that we could go back and get that number I can certainly check with Mike teen he was here through that period I don't know if he's kept data like that or not but again we have been a a onetoone district for a long time so I I don't I don't

112know like a Chromebook what does a Chromebook cost the district again without he's not on this call I'm sorry yeah I sort of was asking that as a leading question it's I believe it's but Chrome but there are a lot of teachers that don't like Chromebooks they don't do what we need them to do um and they're you know they definitely are a different device and you know Google created those Chromebooks basically for onetoone in school for young people to use not for Professionals in their profession to do what we need them to do you know as educators so there is a difference I mean they were created initially so that schools could afford um to move in a onetoone environment when uh the country was changing in education and Wealthy school districts a lot

113of them uh you know were some of the first implementers actually had Mac airs in every in in the hands of all their students which they were for their students s and 800 a device and there was a real need I think in the market and that's why they exist um they they really weren't created for adults professionals I was just going to say I think but we did sorry Karen go ahead no I was just going to say I was going to add on to that I think you know there's a vast difference between what we're giving our students uh versus our Educators because our Educators not only have to run a lot of that you know a lot of the testing software and you know data compilation they have there's a lot that

114they do during the day that you know presentations and all sorts of things that the kids don't necessarily have we're also teaching our students you know to sort of be how to participate in a in a digital world the the older they get and some of the other things it's you know repository for a lot of their work and and portfolios and things like that but ultimately what it comes down to is you know what we're talking about now is for our Educators to make sure that they're at least once you know one or two steps ahead of what our students have in a lot of ways even though some students have more um but this is for them to be able to run multiple different types of programs not just ensuring that our students

115are educated but ensuring that they can uh go through each student individual data so you know build individual plans for those students and run multiple different types of software um you know and again I as I think Dr Jones said yes I I understand the assumption but you know I would assume that there's there's multiple different levels here um so again I don't know if you guys want to continue to go down this path or Cody I know you had made a suggestion before of a blanket cut is without you know and this separately but I don't know if you want to make a motion um but questions can I make just one more because I don't want to be misconstrued the issue I have is we had a status quo of laptops pre-co the

116government came along and said here's a ton of money anyone who wants a laptop can have a laptop a bunch of people got new laptops some of which were much higher performance characteristics than old laptops also to my point that I made about like I wouldn't want to have to take these away from if I gave them to my own employees and then it took away like I would not there's some things like I Tony's being completely sincere about this but also it would be a we'd be putting her in a very difficult position to say oh tell us about the things we should take away from all the teachers right like nobody wants to be in that position it's a very different statement like I'm not interested in revisiting our strategic goal one to

117one thing or all that stuff sure there's an interesting conversation around that that's not my focus my focus is and my suspicion and from doing my own kind of slothing in the background is that we now have our laptops not just as an educational program but as also sort of a nice to have almost pseudo form of extra compensation to teachers which if you're going to compensate teachers just compensate them directly but that like that's my my key thing here especially given that you know if you're in particularly the fixed class classroom zones to have two computers and one teacher and a $900 computer even if it's a $900 average still means that you know the lower one computer is like we'd be providing a $2,000 laptop or something that's my main issue is where

118this is sized and I would if you just think about like which direction would this number be biased in if the administration is doing their job kind of trying to stand up for teachers it's probably not biased in the lower Direction maybe the right answer is to stick with my broader philosophy of pull just drop this as a particular line item and add a little bit more to the general efficiency bucket but my deep suspicion is that a lot of the laptop applications particularly in some of the classrooms do not require a $900 laptop plus an existing desktop in the same room I know all the things what if we want to use the Smartboard and send an email at the same time stuff I'm just saying directionally this one feels like it is higher

119than lower I would have preferred to push it back and say Hey We're not gonna we're resetting from this government sponsored Splurge that started during Co I like I think I said in the beginning reasonable people will disagree about this one but um I just would encourage everybody to think directionally of Are We likely overspending or under spending on this one uh you know where you would where you would place that bet but Tony will tell you why I'm wrong or whatever now well I was I know to Dr Jones I'm going to give you opportunity to respond Laura but I I was G to say I think you know now we're into the philosophical discussions of of of laptops here so you know and uh whether you consider them a bonus or the fact

120that they're required to have them to teach our students and be able to be responsive and and plan for the next day because oftentimes they have to do that at home they don't get planning time during the day um so I'm going to hand this off to Dr Jones and I don't know if you want to make a motion for this uh because I know we have other items in the budget to to to discuss too first more than anything I just want to clarify so the money that we got because I don't want anybody to think that we've created some sr2 ARP Cliff because that's what people read in the news and you know they think that oh you got this bunch of money you were able to do something we were going to

121we were going to purchase these laptops anyway and in the spring of 2020 had no idea that we were going to get sr2 we had no idea we were going to get AR ARP which happened to be what some people call sr3 at the when we first got our first grant and I think it was in the spring of 2020 it was called like covid it was covid money and all it did was by mask and hand sanitizer and stuff like that but we had so much criticism in the spring of 2020 we had to upgrade the laptops we could not do what we needed to do and so either the town was going to fund it and if you remember we built an entire remote School K5 I had no idea how we were

122going to fund that but the board supported getting our schools open and do the work and then we'll figure it out and so that's what we did and so I just we were really responsible in how we spent the money because we were doing this anyway and then it was just very very fortunate that at the federal level they recognized that a lot of schools didn't have the resources and we got to you know capitalize on that and not go for an interm or whatever we were going to have to do um because it had to be done but again the style of teaching hasn't changed and it's so different now than it was preco and our teachers are very mobile again they share classrooms they do work at home they it's just providing the

123professional device they need to do their jobs and wow what great work they do Laura I don't know if we've exhausted this topic already but um I know uh Lil texted and she is happy to sort of talk through the mechanics of how they're used particularly at the high school because I know that was a question so if um anybody wants to entertain some more explanation um it is available but I am not the chair so um I leave that to you and she's perfectly willing to um to advise you know I'm I'm happy to have that addressed if that's you know people would like I I had reached out just to because obviously viously I can't uh Elevate so I was reaching out to to Mike Antonio if I see if we can can

124you reind me who you want me to elevate no I I mean I'm good I don't need uh an explanation the high school is the least controversial part for me that that actually makes sense I I think I made my points I don't think I'm convincing anybody of anything so I have a I have a tribal L Karen I what so the um based on what everybody's saying so they um I'm wondering because I understand I understand the questions I understand all this a little bit more now and I think I agree with uh a lot of what Cody's saying around the challenges of creating or or the long-term systemic issue of creating additional line items and things like that and basically um what we're kind of doing here is um not only um adding

125a 225 to the budget but kind of creating or edding a 4-year um uh refresh cycle um at like a $900 average um strikes me as maybe um more than necessary but I'm wondering here's what I'm wondering though instead is if it makes sense instead of adding that line um increase the increase the um existing refresh line that Cody was talking about not by 225 but you know um by um by by by you know by by I I think at Line's currently 500 the um so increase it to 600 or U 625 like half that so that you're still refreshing we're still having some funds there so that we can start refreshing laptops as necessary but um I don't know um putting everybody on a four-year laptop typ refreshment uh it seems Seems like

126um um as an S replacement seems Seems seems like a lot so I wonder if that could be a a way of providing the you know the teachers with the laptops with the missing keys and things what they need without also guaranteeing that maybe we're buying Hardware that we don't necessarily need to what does the number go to if it's a fiveyear replacement cycle I was doing that math when everyone was talking it's uh 180 179 800 but it's just called 180 so you save 45,000 because your 250 goes to 200 so 200 Time 5 is 1,00 so 200 times 899 gets you the 180 um I know well we've had a lot of discussion on laptops and you know I don't know if you want want to make a motion Cody if you want

127to wait to make a motion uh or if anybody has questions on other topics uh on the budget wait sorry Ben I thought I could hold that in my mind longer than I could to write it down what was the number you just said if you want to go to a fiveyear replacement schedule you that that means you're going to be buying 200 units so 200 units at 8.99 get you 179,000 800 or a savings from the what's proposed of 45,000 got it so Karen I would like to make a motion maybe now tell me if this is the wrong time to do this but to be consistent with what I said in the beginning which is I think that it's more powerful to broadly identify certain buckets and then actually seed some of the

128control on how those are allocated uh to the administration I would uh make a motion to adjust you're going to correct me on the right wording but to adjust the current operating budget down by or uh $600,000 and then pause on the motion just with the with the intention of that $600,000 being efficiency savings whatever you want to call it driven by the administration if they think that the most the best savings available is to go from four years to to five years in the laptop program great if they think there are other Pro things or that to make the average laptop price 600 or two grand and find it somewhere else right but again that's me adding I'm gonna I think it was the I'll walk away from the laptop thing that's me kind

129of taking round numbers in my mind of various potential efficiencies and by the way I should not the last few years every year you're in the process of making a motion so you have to just make if you're gonna thanks thank you you're right sorry I never make motions I'm bad at it I'll make a motion to adjust the budget down by $600,000 period do I have a second is there a second I will second the most okay there's a second it's like man if I couldn't even get a second okay I'm happy to take a I have to take a ver you know vote verbally on this particular motion before we move on well we we we discussion don't we discuss it now we just finish this okay oh yeah all I was gonna

130say is I probably beating beat this um but uh the idea here is to oh the last point I was going to make was that just to flag for everybody the last few years it's like something like 450,000 to 800,000 has returned to the town every year anyways uh and those are numbers after we would do line item Cuts so um this is me taking what I think is a smaller set of areas for potential savings than normal years which is why I would the uh like in past years I would have had a bigger General efficiency bucket but I think for this year from reviewing everything that um 600,000 is a very uh uh achievable number I'd be interested just now that we've moved away from the laptop thing what if Tony has any

131commentary on on you know when she thinks across the broad swath of these what the achievability of that is and if that gives her if she prefers the flexibility of having a general bucket versus US whacking specific line items yeah I mean I certainly think that you know if the if the board wants to vot a reduction of 500,000 or whatever that is I I'm worried about the laptops still I just want to say that one more time because it's a tool we need um could we go I'm driving the laptops no more laptops okay all right no more laptops but 600,000 okay that's still probably 100,000 too high if we're thinking it's coming from that light on it but I I think we can find efficiencies and continue to do that what it means

132is and I'm going to use the laptops as an example because we do our budgets so early in greinwich by the time it passes it's like the end of the year so you know poor in efficiency finding out again it's not a four-year replacement cycle and that's one thing I want to clarify it's because you're only replacing 250 they're already four years old so you're talking about some of them being six years seven years and the worst will go eight years before they get new ones so what you would do is you would start by okay where do we have these laptops that literally are not working they're not charging they're not and maybe it's less than 250 and for people that say they would absolutely need their laptop for next year and you could

133find efficiency there you could look at hamv you know we have uh the efficiency of the year the school the extended year who is it that's actually going to teach in that program what is the actual salary because we'd have to be there before you know we get too far into the year because that's part of what we do for contracts as we look at next year so it's looking at things like that across the entire budget which we do that when we build the budget we go we zero out and build everything up um but it's just going back in again with a fine tooth comb and um you know we certainly can do that I mean we the board has this discussion every year and we will make work what the board votes

134for us to do for sure wait sorry before Kathleen goes T is it preferable for you for us to pick specific line items or do you like the idea of having a general basket I I mean we've never done a general basket but I think that that's good because we can go back in and and things change again it's so early like most of my colleagues in in the region don't even present their budgets till January February so it gives us an opportunity to look at what's changing you know one thing that often changes between now Sometimes good sometimes not like utilities will we know more about utilities later on I mean there are things that you know can be adjusted in the budget as we go through so if it's done like that um

135we I'm sure the bet would expect us to work very quickly um they may not be as patient is what the board is saying but um you know that that's an exercise we could definitely do we haven't done it before but we could okay uh Wendy I saw your hand up did it go back down yes I was gonna ask a question but codyy actually asked it for me thanks okay uh Kathleen and then Sophie yeah so um I guess I I'm a little worried that there while we have returned some money in the past we often have to go for interms as well um and special education is just something across the state that continues to be so unpredictable and um it just worries me that I feel if we're going to do an

136efficiency bucket which I am understand the rationale for um I feel 500,000 is sort of the upper end of my range um when I start to get beyond that I am starting to get nervous and I feel like we're setting ourselves up for immediately having to go for an interm like earlier in the year um I don't want to put us in that situation either I want to be sort of responsible in our budgeting choices um so and looking across everything I like the approach Cody of sort of saying we're giving the administration Dr Jones and Ben the ability to find sort of if there were any areas that they could sort of cut away at maybe they have to go into 30 line items to get to 500,000 um I'm comfortable with that sort

137of going beyond that I do get a little nervous Sophie um yeah I mean Kathleen sort of well two things one thing that you were saying about the Special Ed I totally agree with and that was something that I was going to say just looking at um one of the questions that was asked was that you know talking about the demographics of our special education students and how we've gained 233 special education students in the past four years right so um that's something we just we don't know how that those costs are going to escalate and then I just wanted to also comment on what Cody was saying about returning the money I think that speaks to how well the budget is developed that we come that close but also when you were talking about

138like are we are we always at the top of the range for everything if we were you know that we wouldn't be returning any money right like the fact that we return some money shows that like we're close we're doing a really good job but we we are actually giving money back um so I and I would rather have that buffer right than be like down to our last dollar at the end of the year I'd rather be giving the money back frankly and and last thing just about the um teachers and the laptops because I think there was a bit of a misunderstanding when I was talking about teachers interfacing with parents and students through the laptops it was really the after school um like what people are talking about with with lesson planning

139putting in grades um all of that kind of stuff you that's where I see teachers and especially having been the parent of a high school student now consecutively for 10 years right there's a lot of information that the teachers are conveying to students not during the school day but through the laptop and if they didn't have a functioning laptop um you know that would be very problematic for the students experience for example if they couldn't input their grades right and you know we're right in the middle of college season a lot of the teachers are using their laptop to be able to help the students get all the information in they need for their college applications stuff like that like you need to have a good computer to get that done and to to risk

140that put that in Jeopardy I think is really compromising our students experience um so that that is my concern about this the um computer so I just want to clarify that it wasn't about so much about using them to teach in the classroom although I know obviously they do that too the the whiteboards but it was more they use them often times for work you know in the evenings and on the weekends as well uh Cody and then I have something to to say I think the laptops are saved now uh so um the uh oh just s the one thing I wanted to say was that the in years past we would chip away at all the line items and then there would still be savings where in this time we wouldn't be chipping

141away at the line items so the like in the absence of extra chipping away you would like put it differently if we went back to a previous budget year and we took away all the chipping then they would have return even more to the town um so so I I still think I mean 500 600 it's kind of we're we're talking to Kathleen's point about percentages like I'm trying to pick a low number I know it'll feel like oh you didn't get laptop thing so and I do think that there's probably a little bit of savings in the laptop but I'd be happy to say maybe I'm wrong and I'd rather put it in the hands of the administrators who would say uh yeah there definitely isn't savings here but we have you know a

142higher and better use of capital is to buy laptops on whatever terms uh keep it a tighter cycle or whatever and if they feel that way they can probably make it up in one of the other areas that I think um exists uh so but I think laptops are safe I don't know I I my motion was for 600 um and uh that's something that would um you know I think you'd have the support at least for part of the caucus that I hang out in um I was gonna say I um much like uh you know well Kath Kathleen is a little you know higher than I am I'm not really even comfortable at 500 I would think 400 maybe at the most to have some you know discussion on on finding some sort

143of efficiencies um but I do have a I do have a worry I know that there's this rumor that's been going around that we have a already a gap in our budget of $1.1 million in transportation costs um due to uh changing time Flex time at the high school which I know is not not exactly correct I know I mean I'll let Dr Jones respond to that or or been um but I am worried because I know you know our the transportation um costs are definitely going to be uh going to be you know an issue going forward we've had you know every time we add additional special education students we need to be able to provide for the most part most of the transportation that has a cost you know when we add extra

144extra programming like a second uh you know another preschool uh class halfway through the year because again we have students with special education needs that come in at different ages um those have costs for transportation as well getting students to and from um and I I really worry when we're given uh guidelines that aren't actually based on the actual data that we have you know that we know we have contractual data we know how much we have to increase our you know teacher salaries every single year we know what you know the contractual information is for contracts for for transportation and and other things that we're not even able to to meet those contractual needs so if there's things we can you know find to reduce that's you know or smaller that's fine but I

145I I'm not comfortable at 600 I'm not really even comfortable at 500 um and you know I'd be more happy having a discussion on um ways we can also help increase Revenue if we have to have slight increases uh for some programs or return to charging for you know High School football games which we we did for years um you know a slight you know entrance feere or whatever um you know I'd rather be able to do that and be able to raise you know bring bring more money back into the town in that way as well that's just me Mike had his hand up and then Laura or actually I would let you know Dr Jones or or or Ben answer the question on on Transportation if you want beforehand go ahead pin no

146it's the the flux time has has no bearing on the the transportation increase is being presented in 20 in the budget in front of you you really is what's driving it when we look at the numbers is the sped and prek numbers it's it's not the elimination of of flex time so that's also for this year that's not for next year as well not just next year we're not in the whole no no like I said okay Mike and then Lauren yeah if um it sounds like um here if if we're here in from um um um I don't want to put words in anybody's mouth but if we're hearing from the uh budget committee chair here um that um he thinks that we can find um 600,000 here and um the vice chair is

147more comfortable at five um I think those are I think that that's those that's probably a reasonable number um the for hearing from two members of the budget committee that that that there their fici is be found here um so that sounds that that sounds that sounds positive it sounds like where we might be moving towards something Laura I feel like we're playing Let's Make a Deal here I mean we've got a motion on the table I think we need to dispense with it and um and if there's another motion to be made after then then so be it but I I do think um I'm really uncomfortable with this sort of like um here's another random number so hit it I mean it's just it's what the BET did when they gave us a

148random number to go hit it and I I just I'm not feeling like there's any kind of um science we direct superintendent to implement this budget and and we're saying find some efficiencies but what if we don't like those efficiencies or and I'm just making this up um I mean I'm sure whatever Dr Jones does would make perfect sense um but I I'm uncomfortable with having this in front of us for weeks and we're giving no Direction about what our priorities are other than to hit a random number and it just Fe feels completely um it's just vague and it's it's not doing our job I I'm 100% opposed to just cutting by lump sums it just doesn't make any sense okay Cody and then you know unless we have one other statement after that

149I'd like to be able to call the question on Cody's motion um I would just say that it's not random there's uh a lot of thought goes into to I mean I laid out the theory of you have different ranges on different things and we could pick off individual ranges but I think it's preferable by the administration for us instead of doing that to say hey here's our general sense based on our own every one of us can have our own probability waiting I don't mind if you say hey you're wrong about those numbers I would just say that I didn't pick it out of thin air Kathleen yeah I was just going to actually add to that I mean believe it or not I I do think this was it's it it was a

150pretty scientific I mean we spent weeks on this and so um there are a few buckets that I would look to to get to 500,000 but again the reason I like this approach is because I think we all have slightly different priorities and rather than the eight of us debating what those priorities are I think it's responsible to give it to Dr Jones and Ben to figure that out but I feel comfortable at no more than 500,000 in doing that um and whether that and I'm taking off all of the things we've talked about including laptops because that's not I'm saying that's not for the choice for us to make I'm saying I feel comfortable with this budget basically I'd make the motion at m431 51 I'm sorry well we have to take the motion

151that's on the table now no no no I'm saying I would make such a motion I was okay just checking hypothesizing yes okay Wendy do you have something to add because I I wanted to call the question for this I do I just I just want to say that I you know I appreciate all the work that the budget committee's done and um I could probably I wish it was higher but 600,000 is a number that I could I could go with um or work with and hope that the BET could you know similarly make some more difficult decisions um but I just would I think it's it's worth it's it's we should know that 29 % of our neighbors can't afford to live in Greenwich according to the Greenwich United Way they kind they

152just came out with a report um this past week and I'm worried that this budget is going to result in a tax increase which would hurt our GPS families and um I think we should consider that as well when we're voting tonight okay so I'm going to call the question then um on Cody's motion uh for a blanket reduction of 600k um and I going to call by names okay Wendy yes Mike yes Jen no so no Kathleen um geez I I mean no Cody yes Laura no and I'm also an O so that's 44 and it uh oh that's excuse me that's five Zer four five five excuse me 54 my brain is mushed I'm sorry I think it isn't it three five five three Karen five five three this is what happens I'm

153sorry I'm sitting here my family's already out for you know pre-graduation dinner and I make can I can I make a motion do we have another motion on the table do I have to amend the motion or can I just with that motion failed you can make an additional uh motion and then we'd have to amend then we can either withdraw the initial motion or amend based on what we continue to do here okay um I'd like to make a motion to reduce the fiscal year 2526 operating budget by 500,000 and give Dr Jones and her team the um ability to find the efficiencies I will second uh Mike you were the second yes okay I just wanted to make sure because I know for my can't anio he likes us to to use say

154the names um is there a discussion for this or do we want to just uh call the question on this just call a question I just wanted to see if anybody had comments okay uh Wendy pass come back to me okay Mike yes Jen yes Sophie yes Kathleen yes Cody yes Laura reluctantly yes Wendy no and I'm also a no so that is six to2 so I can withdraw the is there any other discussion that we want to have otherwise I can withdraw my initial motion and we can make uh or I can just amend the mo my initial motion what what are we amending now now you have to actually vote for the actual number the actual budget yes see initial the actual because it you know was we I made the motion to

155have it as presented um so I'd have to either amend or withdraw so I think I'll just you know amend right I think so okay so I'd like to amend my motion I don't have the number in front of me hold on one sec 202 what is it what 202 million2 431,000 $51 okay so uh I'm just going back to where I at it okay so my I'd like to amend my motion um to uh approve the proposed FY 2025 2026 operating budget with the uh amended $500,000 reduction uh so to approve for a total of 202 m431 51 do I have a second a second okay any further discussion okay if not I will call the question uh Wendy H um come back to you is that what you're thank you okay Mike yes

156Jen yes Sophie yes Kathleen yes Cody yes Laura yes Wendy no okay I am a reluctant yes so that's sorry Laura you know it's maybe not so bad if both of us are reluctant yeses okay so now I'm G to move on to the next item on our agenda which is and uh the Food Services budget I'm happy to make a motion to approve the proposed FY 2025 Food Services budget as presented on page 243 and 244 of the superintendent FY 26 budget do I have a second okay Kathleen discussion Cody would just like make sure that muffins are involved in the Food Services budget we have solved muffin gate I just want all the kids to know how the government tries to ruin their lives every day okay well you were doing so well

157are that's why I go to I volunteer to talk to all the Civics classes with Karen and she always hears me do that mention that um we did have a robust discussion on muffin gate um this year so I don't know if uh Dr Jones or or Ben you guys want to address anything with the Food Services budget fori to us uh nothing to add just to point out that we are proposing uh the 15 increase for lunch and breakfast across the divisions and I I believe there were no laptops involved in the school lunch fund I mean somebody has to figure out the calculations for what's getting paid right um um all right is there there any discussions or questions from the board otherwise I'm I can happily call I will call the question

158that's the case Okay Wendy yes Mike yes Jen yes Sophie yes Kathleen yes Cody yes Laura yes all right and I am also yes so 8 z laah um next action item on our agenda is so that passes 8 Z as I just said so next item on our agenda is uh the Board of Education meeting calendar for 2526 I'll put it on the table with a motion to approve the 2025 2026 Board of Education meeting calendar as presented there a second a second Sophie okay uh Dr Jones if you have anything to add no I think it's um you know it's as presented and follows similar patterns to what we've had the last couple of years okay uh any discussion nope okay happy to again call the question Wendy well I'm never in never

159want to vote for um any of these Dei policies I am happy that Michael was able to amend no we're we're doing the we're doing the we're doing the Board of Ed calendar not Poli oh that one yes that's an easy one let's make sure the Dei stops not in the calendar like we're taking a stand okay so hold your Hold Your Fire for the next discussion um Mike yes Jen yes Sophie yes Kathleen yep Cody yes Laura yes and I am also yes so ra another we passing next year's meeting calendar in 80 um and next up on our action items are is the policy 9311 um Dr MC do you want to make the motion or would you like me to sure no I'd like a motion to approve um policy um oops

160should bring it up sorry um policy 411.ca diversity um as presented in the minutes in the agenda I mean I'll second that if you'd like thank you um so as Wendy alluded to um like I said our the policy committee met uh yesterday and we had a discussion on the first read um some folks raised some concerns here about what was um what the um original drafted policy was directing the superintendent to do um particularly in regards to having to use certain State uh State resources um the revision everybody has in front of them does not do that um it's a reminder uh what this policy does do is it requires um us to uh Draft A diversity and vote on a diversity plan which is something we did um last March um what you

161also want it's also worth noting for the public that the uh diversity plan which we did approve um um ensures that ensures that we hire the um the best candidate for the for for the job which is something we'll always want to do in Greenwich uh but also makes to ensure that we cast a very large net in looking for that candidate um so U this policy is very important that we have this policy in place um in the off sense that um um people have an issue with any of our hiring uh we don't want to expose ourselves to any uh vulnerabilities here or by not having a policy that the state requires us to have so in that case it's um um there it is we'll happy they take any questions I want

162to pass the policy committee um unanimously these divisions any discussion questions Wendy now's your time if you want to say anything oh I was just gonna say as you all know I'm against um Dei and any discrimination hiring based on immutable characteristics so I'm happy um that we took some of that the those paragraphs out and um and that the policies yeah the policy required by Hartford um that revision is no longer um we're not relying on Hartford anymore uh and we're we're retaining we're taking our control back and um anyway yeah so um no I mean yes I'm gonna V yes okay um are there any other questions or comments not I'm I can call the question Wendy do you want me to call you last Wendy you're muted yes okay was that a

163yes to the motion or a yes to calling on you last yes to calling on me last okay Michael yes Jen yes Sophie yes Kathleen yes Cody yes Laura yes I'm a yes Wendy yes okay fantastic 8 Z Now now we're really rolling so next up our discussion items um and I will turn this over to Mr bran for the monthly financial report uh I'll just say as presented happy to answer any questions you have oh that is such a good way to do the report does anybody have any questions thought it was price self-explanatory but are there any questions no okay well then we are moving on to agenda plan um I don't know if anybody has comments or questions about the agenda plan well I think to oh sorry Tony no I just

164wanted to point out the items that were added um just so you didn't miss them because it's uh January 16th is when we're going to hear about the H hamf HVAC we also added Riverside feasibility for January 16th um those firms will all be ready to go then on February 6th which is the retreat uh principal Mayo was already going to be there for the academic update so he's also going to be prepared to talk about an update on flex and the cell phone policy so we've added that and then on uh Thursday February 20 20th uh PCG is uh prepared to go and give you the update on the special education action plan and that needs to be added and we'll be after tonight that's it okay um Kathleen did you have something no

165I just think it's to I think Michael Joseph you ra it we should probably make sure we have Hamilton Avenue come back and uh present to us in like two years though well no I think at the end of this don't you think in April or May they'll know more I was going to say I think we should add them towards the end of the year when there's a a little bit more you know information as to what they're actually like a little bit more of the implementation plan I think that was kind of my yeah that was kind of my thought like in in you may or April so we can just put a note when they're to add them when they're ready um the only other thing is and I'll send out uh

166to the board um we need to go through committees so I will send out an email to you guys and can put forward um your interest in which committees you'd like to to be involved in um and and um I know we also yes I I had a before we move on I had a question about next meeting topics that's right I'm sorry the um not not long but I mentioned last month the I didn't see it on here but I I would uh I'd love for us to be able to to talk about uh field usage um um at at this level I think it's um I think it's an important topic that we we need to we need to think about well now that we have um Western Middle School back online and

167Central may be going offline who knows um at some point when that schools uh being built um and uh you know I know there's some other discussions on on on Town fields and stuff so I you know I think I think it's a good idea to have as a topic especially if we want to talk about maybe you know uh Revenue driven uh for field rentals as well um but we can also I think reach out maybe to the town to see if they're they're doing any updates or audits on Town field usage and base it on dates on that that work Dr Jones I don't know if you have any information or if they're looking into anything I can reach out yeah I don't I don't at this time but we we can actually

168we could do that where they are all right perfect um so as I mentioned um you know I'll send out information to you all in regards to committees um the other thing I wanted to mention is you know our um board goals um talk about having um professional devel vment so I'll reach out to you guys um as well to see if there's any specific topics that you have interest on um I have some thoughts but I want to make sure it's something that um all of our board members uh are going to find uh worthwhile as well um Cody do you have a question yeah sorry I completely spaced partially because I was thinking about the budget after the public comments I don't know if I'm too out of order but the the comment

169the public just before we go maybe I can couch this as considering future agenda items but the comments about the basketball um Arena uh I meant to say at the beginning at the high school yeah yeah it just that sounded very compelling and interesting like the point that why would you do all the work right when the season starts you know um is that uh Tony do you have any comment on that or is it something Ralph you need to check with Ralph on no that's that's the issue I had emailed the board about about uh week I think the week before last where the the it had bursted and the water was flooded we were hoping that we wouldn't have to replace the floor but it got down through the lines got down to

170the subgrade and it is not perfectly level and so we can't go ahead and just play competition games on a floor that is not appropriate um for High School athletics and so we're getting it repaired and it's a five-week repair um I did talked to uh Pete the athletic director I've talked to him almost every day but um today we talked specifically about this issue and I think there's the I don't know if it's a rumor if that's the right word but some people thought they were losing the court for this repair for the whole season and probably because when you think about the sole remediation like for baseball last year we had to move them you know for the whole season we've had some of that but that's not the case with the back

171basketball floor and it does need to be repaired and it will not be out all season and we'll get the kids back on it fully um probably second second week of January thank you yeah thank you for uh for addressing that I was saying yeah sorry to delay everyone's conclusion of this meeting that one just we've had we've had a lot of sports that have been uh side you know pushed aside when we did all the field remediation at the high school as well a lot of Seasons full season so I'm glad to hear this is a short window um and with that H does anybody have a motion that they'd like to make I'd happily make a motion to adjourn isn't Laura the one that always does it I I offered her the opportunity

172and she just sort of looked I tried to I tried to get her fired and get the job to Sophie the I'm happy to make a motion to adjourn okay it's all second I'm I'm seconding okay uh Cody yes yes please Mike I'm abstaining you're uping all right Jen yeah Laura I just like you all so much okay yes or no yes I have I have a college almost graduate sitting there waiting at dinner for me sorry so Kathleen yes H Sophie yes I said yes yes and I don't see Wendy so I guess she's she was tired of being picked first so she I guess she's logged off okay so that is a I'm a yes so that's 70 um and I just wanted to wish everybody a you know a wonderful uh holiday

173season if we don't see you guys before then congratulations to your son yes congratulations Karen well well we'll see you on Saturday

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.