CorpusRecord 113996

2-6-25 Groton Board of Education Policy Committee Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Groton Public Schools
Date
2025-02-07
Location
Southeastern Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,993 words · about 56 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001thank you good evening everybody this is the Gren Board of Education policy committee special meeting of Thursday February 6th it is 5:00 p.m I did say and uh we are meeting is being held remotely uh members of the public May view or listen at the meeting uh and there are instructions you can go to obviously if you're here you know you going to be here and if you're not here you have to go to the website so our first order of business we've called the meeting to order I'd like to review the minutes of Thursday January 23d have the members had an opportunity to read the minutes Andrea had an opportunity but I didn't do it so there you are Ian any comments would either of you like to move the minutes is it your

002preference that we defer the minutes of that meeting until the next meeting this is a special meeting we can defer this or table it until the next regular meeting which will be held sorry I did my mic was off I said so moved okay Andrea would you like to second second yeah second okay it has been moved and seconded is there any discussion hearing no discussion I'll ask all those in favor to indicate by saying I I I I I it is carried 3 to0 to Z okay before we go to Old business uh I'd like to talk about a way to try to move this uh as rapidly as possible and try to keep this at under two hours if we can the more under the better so uh when we start on this

003our first order of starting on it is Ian had a request that we reorder the discussion of the very same items there would no addition of new items or new topics just a reordering of those so that will be the first order of business once we have the order of business it's my hope that since Ian um was uh instrumental along with his committees uh unfortunately um Jen is unable to join us Mike is in the peut gallery right now and available if um if we want him to participate um and I would ask Ian to start start the presentation on each of these um the members can comment uh if we need any particular help Ry is here and and uh Susan is here and I'll try to be the role of a moderator

004rather than a participant and if I have any comments I'll try to save them to the end um is that satisfa is that process satisfactory to you guys yeah yeah I'm fine with that um do we need to make it official as far as making a motion to reorder absolutely would you like to make that motion sure I'd like to uh make a motion to reorder oh use the letters use the same letters and I'll put a number for the order using numbers give me the order of the letters that you want as first 2 third fourth and fifth well do we need to suspend the rules first just to be fully correct I think we're following the rules by making a motion and a change that does not we would suspend the rules if

005we wanted to add something to it but we're not adding anything to the agenda all right uh very well I make a motion to uh reorder um the uh agenda such that we we take 3120 first followed by 3160 then 32 z0 3310 and then 3320 so that be a straight numerical order according to the uh code of the policy yeah that was bothering me the numerical order okay messed up so I have a motion that we uh that we change the order to discuss in the following order 3120 3160 3200 3310 3320 is there any is there a second to the motion second okay so move to rearrangement uh motion um and at this point also I want I'm fine with sharing the screen and and running the document uh you you you or

006Clint can do it it matters not to me Mr Thomas if you'd like the Reigns please by all means I have them ready if you need a backup Roger that thank you okay is there any discussion on rearranging the order of what we're going to be doing hearing no discussion can I ask for a vote all those in favor of the rearrangement suggested by Mr moved by Mr Thomas 3 3120 31 160 3200 3310 and 3320 please vote I I I I so it's three no abstentions no opposed the order is rearranged Ian let's all of us get out our documents number 3120 we'll start there yeah time um whenever you want to okay um I'm glad you're gonna actually I'm glad you're going to be putting it up Ian because Erica Erica was Ill

007the last couple of days and we uh were waiting for the updated version with the changes or the recommendations as of our last meeting and and had to figure out which which was the correct version they weren't in an order so this is the one we had looks like the same well good good we're all on the same page that you can't lose all the time okay go ahead Ian all right so um the way this was left I believe like we're all you know everyone was pretty much you blow that up anymore um got a couple of I'm older than you are and my eyes are weaker than yours thank you so um to my recollection the main body of the text was pretty much all uh agreed upon everything in green um or

008black but the debate was over the uh paragraph that's in blue um and so I took some time and I came up with a different paragraph uh reworded it some to accommodate where some of the concerns that I heard um so I can uh I'm going to just for the sake of expedience I'm going to just I have a working document I'm going to take this PDF down and put up the word document that has the adjustments in it that might be need to be a little bigger too so uh Ian would you be okay if we just pulled the group on their satisfaction with the green to be sure that there in in the interim that there haven't been any changes or ideas changes everything except the yellow highlighted area yeah uh well so

009we'll start at the top and we'll work down um the one that's now on green that starts the superintendent shall be shall direct the preparation Andrea is is that satisfactory do you have any suggestions it's fine okay that's fine with me too uh we are going down to the second which is currently barred in red are we all comfortable with that barring y okay now we'll go down to the board and administrators and go go ahead Ian uh did you have something more on this one let's move on this one okay so um so yeah it changed it up a little bit from the previous draft and a lot of it's just rephrased so I didn't do the whole line out line in because the whole paragraph is Up For Debate anyhow um board officers

010in administration May report any Communications with Town officials that are intended to be used as specific line item or function code guidance upon which the board is expected to act any such Communications must be documented in writing submitted at the next regular or committee the whole meeting and confirmed as accurate by all parties involved to be considered valid and actionable by the board okay Andrea any observations why why the is the word officers there the board officers what does that mean that means uh chair Vice chair secretary or chair of any subcommittee is my understanding of what board officers mean well I don't know that we are have used that term so I don't know where that how how that's applicable I would just say the board referred to another or we could do board

011members I guess I mean it's the board officers was referred to in a couple other policies elsewhere when it talked about I've never seen that I've never and I've never heard it used before um can I suggest Ian that we um make that instead of highlighted in yellow highlight it in some other color and we'll come back to that let's get to let's see what what else that just that one word and we'll come back to that word can I ask the question in because I know the original one talked about communication regarding any budget planning related matters I'm not so clear as what's meant by specific line item or function code guidance upon which the board's expected to act well so Bev mentioned in one of the meetings previous that you know General broad

012conversations such as like oh I only want to see a 2% increase you know overall right like a a a casual comment like that um would not necessarily be a thing that that you know the intent of this wording would would want to have reported because that's a broadscale thing more about like specific line items or object codes or function codes like you know something that oh we need to adjust this by that much or or you know you you better put this in your budget you know or or we're you're going to need to take this on you know referring to like a a specific function like you know case in point the nurses last year um I know but the only thing is if you're having a casual conversation with somebody say I

013run into Bruce Jones and we're just casually talking I'm not going to write an email about that oh Bruce said to look into your nursing account and see if you could save money I'm not going to write an email about that to be honest right well yeah to that end like the point is like you know well that's why I like that you had the word May in there yeah may I don't have to I may do it if I want to right and and so I took that's why I took the Sha out of there yeah yeah I didn't like the shell but you have May so I don't have to if I you know okay and to what Floyd I remember Floyd saying and I would say is that I would be happy

014to add that paragraph to regulations because it really is kind of um it it's not really by law but it's by how we want to proceed or how we want to do business right right so to me and I would you know I would make you that promise that I would put it in regulations with whatever else we need right but that's that's just I'm just putting it out there I'm not even a member I'm just saying I would I could do that right and and my response to that would be that uh you know when this is brought forward to the whole board a couple months ago during his first read um you know I proposed this amendment and um the uh the a large consensus there's a lot at least I would say

015five members or so Vo some support for having something like this in the policy side since you know regulation tends to be like from you know District administration on down and this is something that would you know guide the board as much as it would you know uh superintendent's office or any of this you know anyone that works underneath the superintendent the ultimate goal Ian what are we trying to accomplish with this um that that if if there are Communications about like certain significant items um I this came out of the whole nurse situation just to just to cut to the chase here like you know I the goal was to avoid create policy that would avoid prevent and protect everyone involved so that you know if there are Communications about significant line items or

016object codes or function codes that it is Thoroughly vetted before is used as guidance for the board to make decisions on budget on the budget well then that should be in regulations then that's right I agree that shouldn't be in policy that should be in regulations how do we my my other question is how do we as administrators draw the line as to what do we communicate and what do we done well and that discussion too about the nurses was that the town had promised to keep it in their in their um on their side and it was on their side for a long time and um then they would transfer it over so we didn't even get into what function code or or anything we just the expectation from our end was that it

017was going to be all right well that that that's the past I'm trying to focus on forward to create a policy that would you know uh again prevent and protect you know and in in my mind I mean this won't do that it seemed like it seemed like it was a it's you know ra I mean um Floyd's commentary was basically like Dealers Choice so could be in regulation or it could not be and and you know my logic is basically like you know regulation to me seems to be more like District admin on down and board policy guides board action and this is something for the board officers as well as Administration and you know dividing line I mean again again it's it's like if there are specific things if there are emails saying

018that you know the you know the general feeling of the council you know is that you know there we don't want to include this item in our budget we want to shift it over to your budget you know like the property insurance or the um you know something to do with health insurance you know if if they're saying something about that you know or or the nurses you know that basically it allows that would be the dividing line it would be specific Town guidance like you know where they're like saying we are not going to be doing this on our end and the Board needs to take this up wouldn't that be done in I'm not I apologize I didn't mean to interrupt you I'm sorry well it just it did not happen in the

019past is what I'm saying and but my question is something like that wouldn't it happen in a public meeting though if it did not happen in the past it didn't happen in the past one time that that we know of well that I know I don't know of a lot of things probably that might be happening but yeah and again like the the the the main point like the the second sentence really clarifies the first where it says any such communication must be documented writing submitted to the next regular or committed the whole meeting and confirmed as accurate you know in order to be considered invalid and actionable by the board so you know if it's if it's someone that you know spoke casually that doesn't count that's not like specific specific guidance that's not

020like coming from the town side of things yeah but that's not what it says it says to begin with it says that um the uh Administration May report any communication okay and then it says any such communication must be documented in writing so that's in direct conflict with itself well I could rephrase and I could put to be considered act action valid and actionable by the board comma any sucks I could I could move this phrase to the to the beginning of the sentence to clarify that that's contingent you know so anyone can re can can you know refer to Casual conversations as general like you know background knowledge but if it's like specific to an action that we're supposed to do something about that the board is expected to act on and make a

021decision based on that that the thing so if it would clarify it I could move this Clause to the front Okay can I uh do that if you want I'll wait take your time so I thank you for that that does actually clear it up grammatically I'm still a problem some at some point I'd like to comment but I'll take my I I'll wait until you guys ready well Matthew I'm back for a moment I'm back to officers because I have a real problem with that because any board member can just make up any kind of a a um termin techology and apply it to policy we don't have board officers that not that they're that's the term for it anyway I I would just cons be consistent with the Board of Education and then

022board in in parenthesis and I would do or Administration well we don't need we already have the already have the board in parenthesis one could just say board well I would think that you would say board members right or administrators no no because we do the Board of Education and then we put it the board in parentheses as Matthew is saying at the end that's that's what's consistent throughout our entire policy since I've been there we need to be consistent if if the idea is to get a handle on informal conversations that could I'm I'm trying to put myself I'm trying to channel you Ian so if I'm got it get it wrong please uh just politely tell me I'm wrong uh I think the intent is that to minimize the Perce any potential for

023perception that there is lack of transparency by initially requiring now making it optional that such conversations which could affect decision making get back to the board we've changed it from must or shall to may but from there on it's it's how you're going to do this have I got that have I got the intent correct Ian um somewhat yeah I mean like it's unclear you know when the board chair and vice chair and the superintendent are meeting with the town manager and town officials it's unclear when and how those meetings are documented and what messaging is supposed to be coming out for them and how much gravity the board is supposed to be attaching to that um so that is the int ENT of trying to clear this up saying that you know if it

024is going to be something that is supposed to have a lot of gravity then everyone should be H should be comfortable with having that in writing saying that it is the position of this body or or this staff member that you know or whatever that you know like uh you know we're not going to include this in our budget so you need to take care of it on your side let me one thing ask another question Ian whether it was an individual position whether that's just your position or whether that's a position of your committee if it's a if it if if that's the representation of your working group uh or is it that in the intention of the working group or is this a personal thing I'm like that clarification well you both but

025I'd like to know it because if we've got a committee that really feels strongly I have to listen to it in a different way right well I mean that would be part of the communication it it could be either one like this says Town officials it doesn't like I don't want to be specific to a to a body or to to a person some people carry more weight than others you know in the in the duties and responsibilities of their position you know some can only act as a body and others can act as individuals um and others carry the message of another the body um so um I don't know I mean I don't think we have to be specific on that well whenever you guys are ready I would like to weigh in

026with my reading of it mat you have my hand up oh I'm sorry be I please please all right um if I can just flip to the other side of this and when it says the board offices well the board you're going to go with an Administration May rep report so that gives us a leeway that we don't have to report but it's almost it's almost like um you know that the that the board members would not trust their Administration or I has the board offices to come back to them and tell them of anything of importance that has to do with the budget this s this paragraph to me is based on mistrust that okay the board board chair the board Vice chair whoever on the board's going to know something and they're G

027to hold it and not share it with anybody else when it has to do with the budget that wouldn't happen I mean if we knew something if I personally knew something that's going to help with the budget that everybody should know as board chair I'm gonna share it so this makes me think you don't trust the board offices that you have to write this in there to do the right thing oh it's almost face that that that's a certain reading of a certain intent but it's not it's more like the trust but verify thing you know approach philosop philosophy and in some ways like I said it it it prevents miscommunication and it also protects everyone involved I will point out I could just finish if I it doesn't prevent miscommunication because I could just

028finish my point please it prevents miscommunication because everyone has to commit to a to a shared message everyone that's involved in the message if there is a distinct and direct message intended to be sent um and okay I'm gonna I'm going wait hold on please I am going to exercise My Prerogative to interrupt with my apologies it we've used up over a half an hour of our time and we haven't gotten through one so my question to right but but you just cut me off on on the major point I told you I was to try to structure this meeting so we could move through things and my choice would like to offer is do we push this to the back and go on or do we to a conclusion everybody's had a chance to

029talk no then you know what then that would say this you know one you invited Mike to to like you know to to be available for comment so maybe let him have a say on this by whatever means necessary two I would like to finish my point about how it protects everyone involved and and and and that that point is that you know it doesn't put anyone over their skis like if you if people walk away from a conversation with a certain understanding but then that it turns out that that understanding is not correct this creates a procedure where that you know it sort of protects everyone involved because then you have to validate your understanding of the conversation are you are you done yet so when when a board me when a board member

030comes back you know to the board they they can feel confident or administrator comes before the board and you know asserts an understanding of like Town officials on a certain thing they can feel confident that there's Clarity all around and and you know what the message is um thank you Ian thank you and I would suggest this also as a Ian thank you I would like to have a chance to speak and I'm going to exercise my chance we've been in this 30 minutes I've let everybody talk now it's going to be my sh I do like your idea of allowing uh Mike to come in Bev could we take you uh off as a participant so we can have Mike on and still respect the not having a majority of the board members as

031active no you don't have to take me off I'm ex official I can come to all the meetings you don't have to take me off I don't want I don't want to be in the position of having five board members participating no I'm I'm just I'm not part I'm this ex official I don't have a vote or anything okay so would you add Caitlyn would you add Mike to the uh panel yes I just promoted him thank you I would like to make a couple comments um I would support being board members if if if this goes through I would support it broader because it should apply to all my feeling is three-fold the word has any any any I just like absolutes I dislike absolutes where it says any and all because it means

032any communication and that leaves it because it says may it leaves it in the eye of the beholder as to whether he or she will communicate as long as it's in the eye of the beholder it has no teeth to it it in my humble opinion the language makes the makes it pointless second I was going to raise the issue is trust myself from a slightly different perspective we have it now the chair is Bev before it was Jay before it was Kim I don't know who exercised it before but when we elect a chair and a co-chair we are putting our trust in them to behave in an ethical fashion I understand the desire to make things more transparent I I would like to see something that says that in in a way that

033I could support the second part says to be considered valid so the person may report on something but what the person has to say to the board is only valid and actionable what is actionable the person says I spoke with so and so on the council we spoke about X Y and Z he asked or she asked what I thought I expressed that I wasn't speaking for the board but I thought XYZ this is the way government functions it doesn't function I mean Maybe I'm Wrong after 45 years playing this game but government functions on conversations that people have where they clarify for one another where they stand if when represents him or herself as speaking for the board if a counselor told me he or she was speaking for the council I wouldn't believe

034them no one counselor speaks for the councel and no one board member speaks for the board the third one is the process I think this whatever we do to to make it more uh transparent I would like to see you uh come up with new language that you're content with that we can look at together that avoids absolutes that conveys trust and that has a simple process that doesn't gum up the works undone Mike you're here would you have any comments be grateful to hear them yes thank you for having me here I've been listening in um so I will say you know that um this comes out of this policy comes out of the original draft came out of the ad hoc uh committee and so that was voted on and accepted by the

035the entire committee um this particular pair RH and the and the reason for it like the recent reason for it I guess um I think was was felt quite strongly by um all committee members me not being on the board um last year at that time I was probably the least strong um feeling on that um that said um you know the budget is produced it's a public document and it's largely produced by during a public meeting uh but it's also has this Foundation of information that um also should be public and I think the intent here is to have those well I know the intent here is to have those uh foundational pieces of information um whether it be the transportation contract or some other contract um be public too and in this cases

036that that added interplay between uh the town and um and um board members or or the superintendent um and so yeah I I do uh agree with um you know the motivation that Ian's put forward and uh and uh the importance that um the committee uh placed on on having um something of that form in the paragraph um I don't have a real uh solution to get the exact word smithing uh but I I will say you know I I think we would a lot many of us would like to see this new updated policy adopted for um this budget season and um and and I know we think oh well the board part of it in some sense is over at the end of February or so but it really continues um throughout the

037whole approval process um so so I'm happy to to answer any um questions uh further on that but I do see that blue paragraph is as important some way I hope you guys can find a way to to to get it in there was this the original paragraph because the one I have in front of me is very different I have a question for Mike if I may okay uh I support the intent I don't support the paragraph but you have been very helpful a couple of times on finding language which Bridges gaps and I would like very much to bridge the gap so that we can have something that uh I can support so I guess the three things that we heard were institutional process of individual meetings we heard the issue of trust

038and you heard me talk about being concerned with any absolutes having heard those three a do you think there's any validity in those con concerns and B to the extent that there's a way to bridge the gap can you make some suggestions that would help us move us forward yeah I have to think of the the line by line part for Bridging the Gap um I guess I didn't speak to the the the trust part actually I really think sometimes um uh the policies themselves have helped cultivate that trust like the the knowledge that oh well this is the process um that will be followed so we don't have to uh be concerned with um sort of um nebulous um foundations or conversations that might happen that might be viewed differently on the town side

039than than on our side I and uh just briefly going back to last time I wasn't there for it but it did seem like uh the uh the town side kept better records than than the board side or the the school side and that that caused some problems um so but in terms of language I mean the board officers versus Board I can I can see that changing the board even though officers is in a lot of policies um let's see so what what happens Mike if a member speaks to a counselor or an admin person speaks to somebody in the town and just and and does something that substantively you and I might agree is inappropriate but this policy says that that person may report it there's no obligation to report it it's toothless

040yeah maybe maybe it just needs let's see but we took out we took out the obligatory shall or must for the reason I think or at least one of the reasons was we didn't want to be having a deluge of paper coming in from six or seven different board members uh occupying three or four hours of meeting and we're at 5:45 and Ray that is hand raised I was gonna raise did you want to respond to that or just think about it Mike and while I recognize Ry oh one one thing I'd say is that you know if you change board to board officers to board you could change Administration to a superintendent and then and then as um Susan was saying the what happens within like with a business manager or Finance director or

041whatever um that could be more of a regulations thing right so that we're not stepping outside of that but board and superintendent would cover that part um I think the idea here is sort of that second line you know specific line item function or code guidance um I I think that's trying to get to uh some something that's foundational and and and is intended to be actionable uh a comment on hey we think you should uh up you know Town Council says hey we should you should up the budget by 20% you might fall over on that but or or decrease it by that that's not that's not foundational that's not really guidance either right it's just uh expressing opinion um but but I do think that second line um gets to in some way

042gets to what kind of um communic what kind of um Communications matter right like it's not everything um so I'll let other people talk Ry would you like to say something and then Bev I'm I'm just trying to understand the full effect I I know you're trying to get additional transparency but for example today I had Communications with with John I had Communications with d on specific uh stuff that affects both budgets I mean we do that on a daily basis but um for me to write reports I I'll spend half my day writing communication reports I I it's really not effective to tie our hands that way I fully understand where you're at like for example we could be coming back to the board and say Yes we finally we're gonna we've worked with

043the town we're trying to build a better relationship with the town so that we can at least move things forward um and get Beyond where you guys were a year year and a half two whatever it was I mean that's not my headache but I am here I'm here to help move things forward and this I've never seen anything like this and I've worked very closely with um Mayors first Selectmen Town managers and other districts um and and I've never I've never seen anything this restrictive in a policy I mean the trust was there we were hired to do a job and to try to move the district forward I can see if you would like a report as part of our process and procedure we can write that into our procedure or regulations as

044as suset but to through policy this is Cade wouldn't even recommend something like this they've got a a handful of attorneys that would lap us right out of town I mean I I mean I'm it's up to you you're the board but it you're going to find a hard time fulfilling positions if you want to tie their hands this much I I'll be very blunt and honest with you but I've said my piece I'm done um Bev did you want to speak I no I'll listen and then I'll speak after I listen Andrea then Mike thank you um I have no idea what this is doing in because I don't believe it it belongs in policy in any way um and that's I can say that I I would agree with with Ray but not

045that notwithstanding I don't know what this is doing in here I don't that's all I have to say it doesn't belong in here mik I have a question for Ray it's m get Mike and then you're you'll be next okay thanks um just quickly actually uh raised concerns are are you know I I hear them and actually that's I think where Susan's idea about having something like like a parallel regulations so that because that's really his superintendent purview um interactions with the staff and so if you have the board and superintendent then that doesn't obligate uh in in terms of this policy doesn't obligate G Ray or anyone else to um have to report these U but then the regulations might um the other thing is um we you could write this paragraph in a

046way that it just ensures that we have a regular like budget Communications uh report at every time every time we're at um either a regular meeting really but these special budget meetings right and and so that might be the time to to have that report right and then you could I could foree the superintendent giving a report very much like um um they do anyway but just specific to Communications um or at least part of it and then um uh the same thing would naturally come from say the uh the chair or um Vice chair can I just intervene to say that I've been really working hard to kind of work with my team and work with John convert on things and and be able to you know whether it's through an email it might

047be a collaborative email just in in making sure that we're you know dotting our eyes and crossing our tees and we're kind of together on things it's been a real goal of mine as you know because I I want to have a smoother process and he's been very responsive so you know not that we've made any big decisions together but there's certainly been things that happen in the business office and without a business manager for about a month and a half except that I've got Ry now um it's you know it's required me to kind of step in um to make sure that we're communicating with the town and getting everything done so um I I'm fine with putting something like this in a regulation um I just don't know what legal reference it would

048have as a policy and it doesn't jive with the one I have in front of me exactly it because the other one was more broad-based about budget planning related matters but um so it's I'm just having a hard time figuring out you know I don't know that I would actually talk to the town about specific line items or function codes unless I was in a public meeting with all of you and they were asking me specifically about it so I don't know I'm just having a hard time wrapping my head around how this would play out and I would be the one responsible for making sure it played out the right way so I just I just need your help with that um so this paragraph that's on the screen now is different than what

049was in the packet because I was drafting something up to try to accommodate the concerns I heard in previous meetings and this is as the best I could do at the time with the information that I had um you know um I could I could see you know making the adjustments as far as the board and the superintendent you know that way like you know we're not reaching into the uh District administration too deeply with this um but you know a Communications report I mean we could do it could take the shape of something different it could just be you know it doesn't have to be every specific communication it could be a summary of and you know to that end I was I just curious to know I mean like what what is it

050that's being communicated you know when you say you've been working with the town manager closely and and and looking at things and doing like what what is that then I mean if it's not specific stuff like oh you should really move this number there um I mean if you're talk it's like related to the audit making sure we got everything done and just checking in so I can make sure I support my staff I mean it's the day-to-day workings of what we're doing it's not like we're trying to influence each other one way or the other that's not the that's not the target of this of this communication or this um this policy like or this paragraph um you know that again it I mean it may be maybe last year was an anomaly you

051know but um you know other things have come from the town as far as like you know the property insurance stuff and you know like you there was a there was a lot of back and forth as far as like you know how how you know who's going to be covering what costs for what to you know for what purpose or how long and that is the the content of the stuff that that we that I think would be the intent of this paragraph is is is again the second line talks about if it's going to be used as guidance or the sorry the the the second part of the first sentence guidance like you know meaning like the communication is intended to direct the board to think and approach a problem a certain way

052if it's just general background information or just general sharing updating of I cross and's that that's not that's part of our usual order of business and then when you say we're up to date on the audit that kind of covers all that um you know that's another function but this is specific to like moving things in or out of budgets that that you know between the town and the board budget I mean maybe that's another way we can refine the language is you know we talking about moving things between budgets between the town side or the board side that makes sense that makes better sense to me Ian the way you just it so is there some way I'm trying to be mindful of our time is there some way that uh we could take

053a three minute break and Ian you would uh be able to construct some language in that fashion sure or or if there is consensus that this is best served in uh regulations Susan though this is your purview would you be able to work with Ian if that were the choice of this committee that would be in regulation I would be happy to work with Ian on that whatever you guys decide I'm fine with Ian what what is the process do you want to take a few minutes to try to rework this because honestly I can't support it as it is but I understand the goal and I support the goal so would you like to the word would you rather work with Susan and rigs um I would rather take the time now to try

054to find a way to craft it so it fits in policy I'm fine with like a parallel version of a bean and rs that's far more specific and detailed for all the it's 557 we're going to take a five minute break so Ian can do what he needs to do I think I'm gon to release Ray because he really thank you Ray needs to appreciate have dinner with his wife so appreciate you Ray thank you for your input that's good and he just he just texted me say this really isn't policy it's reg's but that's his that's his position but I'm not it's you're the board and I'll I'll bow to your wishes um would you frustrate to the wishes H you'll be Hing a replacement and they read these so just be careful how

055stringent you want to become let's put it that way because every one of us that have have this 085 that have obtain an 085 we have to meet certain criteria otherwise we don't get the 085 just like Susan's 092 so actually 093 oh I'm sorry I have an 092 too I got a few things he has a list long list of stuff but I I just want to put a word of caution on I understand where you're coming from I've been in your shoes I just I just put a little Caution out there try not to squeeze things so tight where people may look at it and say I don't want to work there so okay thank you Ray five minute break it is now yeah enjoy your dinner Ray we come back recess the

056time is now 6:08 p.m. we've had our recess and we're ready to go back on to work we're working on policy 3310 and Ian has uh crafted a new version okay let's uh everybody take a take a moment to read what Ian has I'm gonna start with Mike when he's ready um because you also sat on the committee with Ian in your opinion does this get us closer than the last one at meeting both the intent of your committee and the concerns raised by some of the members and administration and if you have other suggestions would you share them with us um yeah just got through it um I I think any version um is faithful to the um the ad hoc budget committee's intent um and then the concerns you guys will all have

057to weigh that but it does seem like it to me um on the last sentence it so so I see the file reports documenting I mean if you wanted a word Smith it usually we delivering reports but or some you know um that's not a big deal what suggest simply to report report communication yeah yeah that's true too that would work as well to to report yeah you talk about documentation in the next sentence right okay yeah okay I think that's nice and clear in terms of that first sentence is about this is like high level or or or or or really things that are going to be truly incorporated into budget numbers right like that's what this is getting across in a in a good way um the second sentence I I like that

058it adds in sort of a timing so that it's not okay okay you have to report every day or every few hours on this it's at the next regular meeting or could meeting the whole but you might be want to put regular um uh you know special budget meeting or something like that because that's what we have this time of year it's not regular or committee the whole it's that these special meetings um or special budget meeting is that what you mean yeah I don't know if that's the real term but that' be what that that intense special budget or budget workshops yeah yeah that's that's right that's right that's what we call them can I go back to the first sentence and offer a a friendly suggestion to tighten it up so be be

059used as guidance for the board to move budget line items period the board all right um but also like the In-N-Out of the budget well if you want that that's different from what I had in mind but that's fair fair game for the board well that seemed to like that's fine that's fine it wouldn't be my choice but that live with that well Susan was I seem to clarify things when Susan was we're talking yeah that made sense to me but I is it restricting us too okay I'm going to interrupt myself myself when working that I've I've been watching Andrea her hand has been up Ian would you allow me to to would you let us let Andrea comment I have a question and that is I should have asked this before but what

060is the purpose of this paragraph um does someone else Mike do you want to handle that one was it what the purpose of the paragraph right it's your it's your paragraph It's the committee's paragraph um but it it the intent is is it is to make sure that you know when we're getting guidance about moving items in or out of the budget substantial items you know that that there is an understood intent an understood message between you know who's relaying the message and who's sending the message and the body that's receiving the message I have no idea what that means and um is to clarify the process by which we communicate well well that that's that's Ian subjective as he understands it I um the board is is in constant flux because we're we're the

061the we're elected every four years and as is the Town Council so they're never the same people I don't I just don't okay I'm not comprehending what this is for right so again to be specific this the most clearest example I could I could draw again you know is the nurse situation from last year where there was some confusion as to what the intent of the communications were that were coming from the town officials to the superintendent to the chair and the way that and and the the communications that the chair and the superintendent relayed to the board was a different understanding than what was intended by the town side how would we know what those intentions of the Town were that's the point of this paragraph Okay um I'll never I'll never actually this

062this something like this would help protect the chair and the superintendent from proceeding with a misunderstanding right so if there is a misunderstanding it it it's for I know that the the town thought was a misunderstanding I'm sorry de you you have something to add we'll make it a round table you're on mute be thank you um I can support the first sentence but that last sentence to be considered actionable by the board such Communications must be summarized I'm not for that sentence I can go with the first sentence the board and the superintendent are expected to report communication with Town officials that are intended to be used as guidance for you know I don't have to read that sentence but I'm for the first sentence but not for the second sentence okay so maybe

063the second sentence could be in regulations but uh but not in the policy do regulations uh dictate board actions and and Communications or are they only for district admin and Below no the regulations dictate um have to go with the policy they have how we process it how we proceed okay it get more specificity on our process but we all have to follow the policy and then the regulations support the policy right but I have a problem with Ian is that I think we can make it easier in in one regard without any problem at all is a budget at the next regular regular Committee of the whole or budget work session meeting that could go with the first sentence and that wouldn't bother me if but the problem that I have is to be

064considered actionable what does that mean to be considered actionable meaning number no it's not clear I know it's clear to you in your mind what you mean by it but the words are not clear at least in my mind but such Communications must be summarized in writing confirmed as accurate by all parties who are all parties the member of the board or the superintendent does that mean they need to get a a comment in writing by John or whomever that they agree that that's what they discussed oh my gosh this is not going to be conducive to functional government can I say something else Matthew sure okay um you know I spoke to Floyd and I sent you all the uh one email at I give you an update of what I my conversation with

065Floyd was without even this policy I read back to Floyd the email I was going to send to you guys so he can see that it's accurate so you know sometimes you do you you just do these things you don't need a policy you're just doing them you know right but policy to do that I just I thought it was something important that I should read back to him to make sure that what I'm writing was okay but I didn't send it to him and say sign off on it and all that jazz I just call them up and I don't do that all the time but something of importance I did it right that that and that's how you conduct yourself as chair and that's great um you know but as as um Andrea

066noted like it's there's you know turnover on the board from time to time and you know things change and okay and that's when I said Ian you have to trust your chair don't don't don't nominate a chair that you don't trust not that that that's another can of worms to to open up the the the um you know I'm not gonna go down that road but um no I'm just say you don't have to go down the road I'm just saying I wouldn't I wouldn't go to a doctor I didn't trust so the same thing I wouldn't nominate somebody I don't trust again I I don't know I mean this assignment of trust again it kind of boor us on the end of like you know gauging intent you know or assigning intent I mean

067I'm that's how that's how the language appears to to yeah trying to do is is is trying to like formalize the process by which like big ticket items or major shifts that are being communicated are just being validated you know and and it protects everyone involved you know the town and the board side and the admins like you know it just validates I mean you know the nurse example is just the most re you know that's a very Stark example you know there were there were Communications that there was and there was misunderstandings between what the intent was and you know we we do depend on you know the people that are making these communications you know to to be accurate and and you know so that again like establishing a process and that way

068like it's not someone is it's not an individual chair saying to the man an individual manager you know oh I I you know I don't trust you look get this in writing it's just saying this is our procedure I'm not comfortable with that procedure as written um I think I think the the E the a way to make it maybe a little more palatable would be to say that what we're talking about should be intended to to report uh uh at the next regular Committee of the whole or budget work session meeting that adds a little more Force to the first sentence because you're setting a time frame and I I I think if there if there a substantive right what you're saying is that you wanted for substantive issues not for every right right

069substantive issues yeah like you know and and and you know like the who who but that doesn't say that and it leaves it for the person then then where would you put the words in I'm asking I'm my my personal feeling you asked a question my personal feeling is that uh I think it's very constructive to report back on on substantive discussions with Town officials that affect uh the moving of items u in and out of the board budget in and out of the board [Music] budget as far as the business all the communications I mean there is nothing morally wrong in any fashion of filing more reports and generating more stuff but it look at the length of all our meetings all the detail is not functional to getting the work done that's what

070Ray said from another thing he what I what I understood him to have said was you put stuff like this in and people are not going to be wanting to go to work in an environment where they're not going to be able to get their work done I would just push back on that a little bit it's like we didn't have anything like this and we already do have people leaving so we're already there and we didn't even have this in there so you know in a lot of ways like this this again would protect people because then it's expected that that you know anything that someone's being told to do it will um you know they they will have to you know validate that and you know it's not just going to be verbal

071there would be some validation I remind you it's 6:23 and stopping at I would just say this like you know I could I could live with you know um taking the actionable part out and moving like you know the the specific things about the communication being summarized and writing that could be a debate for regulation but getting the the philosophical policy stance that there is an expectation to report Communications with Town officials you know and that they you know need to come up at the next regular meeting um how about this the board and superintendent are expected to report I mean time to report in a the communications with Town officials that are that uh will affect substantive I had it better before substantive uh changes in budget line budget line items and to make

072such report at the next regular Committee of the whole or budget work session meeting yeah that sounds good and I mean if you're if you're comfortable working with Susan on the regulations so we can move on to the policy no no board members don't work on regulations Susan works on well I asked Susan if she'd be willing I'm happy to share it and work with yeah on this one yeah I can do that I think that's a reasonal compromise um and uh start the substantive um Matthew I'm sorry could you I'll try it again sure yeah uh I would actually say board members and the superintendent board members and the superintendent because a board is a unity and we're even talking about individuals that's members in the superintendent are expected to report Communications with Town

073officers uh that uh affect Subs I'm changing it from before that affect or that may affect substantive budget line item uh budget line items period these reports should be made in a timely fashion at the next regular Committee of the whole or budget work session period what do you think Bev what do you think Mike I I that sounds good but I did like um um moving items in and out of the budget okay I did like that okay you could just add that you know Subs budget line items and or moving items in and out of the budget what happened here sorry I had a little sketchy connection there could you rephrase what you just said or just restate sorry that Bev said she wanted to she liked the the uh inclusion of moving

074items in and out okay and where would you see that put in I don't no that may affect substantive changes of substantive changes comma moving require substantive ch changes to the budget I would say might that may yeah m is present or might is past May is present so decide which you're in present or past tense and if I said I might disagree with you wouldn't that be a future no I may disagree with you okay I might oh thank you thank you Andre I appreciate that made this again so I might might is past tense yeah I might have done that in the past may not you say I might go to the party I may I may go to the party okay we're getting without paying any tuition we're getting educated don't give

075it any idea she might start charging us I start I may start Char I messed up already you need some remedial help see I won't forget that now not delivered not delivered we don't need to be in writing we just just make the Blessed report shall be given shall be such report shall be made uh at the next shall be made at the next how do you do that shall be made such report shall be you make a report how about given shall be given shall be given fine okay all right all right that sounds good now all right the any anybody object to taking the yellow background out of that I don't it's no longer required if but don't forget I it's the board members board members good I think that's much better yeah

076I do too it's clearer I understand it now okay um the next paragraph can we make that lighter so it's reible again um which one the next one do we anybody have any questions on this paragraph starting the board shall review nope I don't okay go to the next paragraph uh any comments Andrea no next paragraph all budget meetings or public meetings I don't know what what the function of that is there's nothing in it that I find disagreeable but it's that was which one are we on now yeah the last one the last paragra that that one came out of cage and I I I who said that I don't I don't know what I don't know what it's there when I read it through I I I thought to myself what's that even

077doing in there you know like that how is that policy the only reason it's included is because it came from the cave draft and it seemed like a formality boilerplate language I'm not attached to it if people want to cut it out let's cut it out B what do you think I could hear you better if you weren't muted you may want to change that then all all all board meetings are public meetings unless you're in executive session yeah so that's redundant that's you don't need that in there we've agreed on that okay what do we have anything more nope you got your next policy to go through okay well not yet are there I want to ask do anybody have any more comments before we move to a vote hearing no comments I'll ask

078uh all those in favor of adopting policy 3110 as amended in our Workshop please indicate by saying I I I all those opposed opposed okay and so we have no abstentions so we're three two one Zer with Andrea okay okay uh we have 28 minutes to go and let's move on to 33 I'm sorry 33 no not 33 forgive me 3120 is that what's next no help me guys now that's the one you just did Matt no no we did uh 3120 we go to 3160 you did 3160 already no we haven't done it we've done only 30 only the first one what's 3120 we did we just that was 3120 we just finished and okay that's what I thought thanks I and 3160 would be the next one up okay 3160 okay uh would

079you be kind enough to put that up this time so blow that up if you can blow it up even once more M the draft that appeared in the in the agenda packet but this is not the draft that was put forward by the ad hoc budget procedure committee okay this I understand Susan correct me if I'm mistaken uh what I understand has happened is that Erica listened to our last meeting and tried to incorporate in tried to make the Amendments that she discerned in our trans well not transcript but in listening to the tape and came up with this uh is is that how we got here Susan have we lost Susan Caitlyn is Susan still on oh she's away from She's away she's still on but it looks like she's not sitting where

080she was so she might be out of the room okay because I do have I have two I I have two versions in front of me the one that's on the screen and the one from the last meeting where I had uh I had made a comment that I thought the second sentence in this third paragraph was awkward and I think she like I don't really want to speak to her I know I made comments that I thought it was awkward and made some suggest suggestions and I believe that this is her best faith effort at incorporating those suggestions so I guess I'm sorry I answered the um door and my neighbor had a coyote following her with a dog and then a bird flew in my house oh my God you can't make it

081up did you need me for anything are you guys okay no we need you what do you need what do you need Matthew okay the the change that I had recommended I'm I'm reading from my old thing I'm not married to this I'm just trying to figure out Erica has been ill and we just had to get together and try to figure out what she was preparing for us I had had in my notes expenditures for school purposes in each fiscal year should not exceed the appropriation made by the fiscal Authority take out the word combine and substitute the word along such money as may be received from other sources now did this come from cab language do you know where this came from um well that that's the question I mean I got 3160

082up on the board up on the um but this is not the draft of 3160 that the ad hoc budget procedure committee had put out um so I'm not sure where this came from not work on it Ian was have we not worked on it well we did not get to it the last time we even attempted 3160 was in the December 18th meeting but then it got tabled because we ran out of time and there was this is the only one I've ever seen I don't know okay but maybe you have to send the other one to us to look at so we can it was in the report that uh we submitted in October and I had sent it to to Matthew and I've sent it a number of times in the big

083package drowning in paper right own the fall so let me ask a question Ian we've got roughly 20 minutes left do we want to work on this one or go to another one and come back to this one we can clarify I want I want to work on this one for a quick minute for the point of showing the next document that I want to show okay which is um this is what I found in cab on this on this um on this policy can everyone see it's just all black ink transfer of phones between categories so this I copy and paste it out of the cave um manual and I wanted to emphasize that there's actually three different versions of this policy that cab put out there as options to choose from and so

084this was version one which is incredibly stringent um as you can see their note up here at the top that I've highlighted in blue says this version does not permit any transfer of funds even an emergency without board or educa of of Education approval um now there's a second version that um is a little less stringent um that allows for emergency situations and that one introduces also a threshold here where it allows stuff to be moved around under a certain amount um under emergency conditions and just reported afterwards isn't that one we had dealt with in 3310 isn't it well 3310 had to do with purchasing like that was a similar approach but from purchasing okay 3160 uh 3160 has to do with transferring money within the budget during the school year during while the

085budget's active um they call it categories and amendments but for us our language what we use in our document it would be function and object codes and then there's a third one that's kind of a blended approach that allows some more wiggle room and a flexible threshold where you know it's up to the board to decide um what that threshold is um so I wanted to share this to show that like C provided like a menu of options and So based on that the draft that the the committee submitted um was sort of the Middle Road approach and I can put that up on the screen now if that's a thing we want to proceed with or do we want to table this for now and I can send out all this documentation to the

086committee members everyone that's involved in this meeting right now so you can take some time with it and we can come back to it well I would have two questions a do you think we can do this in the time we have uh or and or B do you think that something else is of Greater urgency or that this is of Greater urgency and needs to be dealt with in this order um answer to a no I don't think it can be done in the time that we have left uh answer to B um I think maybe 3200 we could take a look at and maybe get done between 47 but um you know I don't know I mean the major one that I considered the most important was 30 is the 3120 and then

087thankfully we've got that voted going back to the board now so that's thank you for that um so this one and the rest like I wouldn't mind like you know I can I can I can set up a package of of the documents that you know the drafts that came out of the committee along with the supporting documents of like where they came from the cave documents could you do this I think that would be great and when you do that could you somehow um date the different documents where there's a date attached to them or some way we can find the sequence of documents uh pagination dates yeah I can I can put together a package so that the the title of each document will kind of explain what it is okay um and

088if they multiple documents paginate them label them as document a b c whatever and paginate each Bunch yeah A1 A2 B2 B3 because it is it is ingrate it's nuanced and I don't want to try to rush it and you know so are we agreed that we're going to table this uh would somebody like to make a motion to table this until our next regular meeting so moved seconded okay so we're we're tabling 3160 well so it's been moved and seconded by Andrea and Ian table to the um Feb regular February policy meeting right oh actually sorry I misspoke oh never mind is it February or March Matthew uh I thought this was a special meeting and that we were going to have a regularly scheduled February meeting but if you if if you're up

089to your eyes with this you tell me I thought I saw somewhere that it was March the next one was March 13th uh it is it is marked March 11th you are correct I stand corrected so we will postpone it to our March 11th meeting that's fine to on March 11 Matthew yes is the sexual harassment policy on your agenda it will have to be on our next meeting oh is that on it's not on this agenda no this agenda has five items only they're all to dealing with the finance that's why I thought it was a special meeting and we were going to deal with the sexual harassment later this month oh okay but you know we could have another special meet we could have a regular meeting it's going to be a special

090meeting anyway whatever we label it do I apologize I'm just still get trying to get this bird out of my house okay so I guess my question to all of us including Susan is uh do you perceive that the time is of the essence on this uh sexual harassment or that we have time to wait till March I don't know um we were kind of instructed that we had to go back and so I'm using the old policy it's posted still posted so we're told not to use the new policy so I mean I would like board approval to you know resend it but we could do that at a regular meeting I mean I there's no word smithing involved this is just reverting back to the old until who knows when I think this

091is a political thing yeah and I don't yeah I don't want us to be I want to insulate us from as Mu as much of that buffeting as yeah me too and matth you that I sent you Floyd's suggestion right I do have Floyd's suggestion with regard 160 right Floyd indicated he felt this was redundant to um that 3200 is redundant to 3160 I hear he did tell us that we we could just eliminate it right that's that's what he said but I'm hearing Ian say that one is for transfer of funds and that the other is for uh reimbursement yes there's a difference between 3160 and 3200 um and I have a different 3200 I don't know how I got these other policies well hopefully going forward everything is going to have a date

092stamp right Susan well these are the latest ones that I got from Erica so I don't know yeah yeah but if you guys will excuse me I really do have to get this bird out of my house or I can't sleep tonight so okay just let me know what I need to do okay have a great night Susan thank you appreciate it okay thank you right so um so we're tabling 3160 did we do we vote on that no we're voting on tabling no we haven't voted on it do you have any more conversation um no I I just wanted to yeah I think 3160 we could table I think 3200 could table and so let's do one at a time let's table can I have a vote on all those in favor of tbling

0933160 I I I so we've tabled it three to zero to zero okay that is good news we are now on 3200 do we want to go to this was 3 160 plus so yeah I just to explain 3200 the confusion there I think C changed their coding um you know so that at one time like 30 there was an old 3200 that had do transfers between categories and they had a separate one that transfers between functions and they're very similar um now with a new coding 3160 was rewarded to kind of cover both functions on both you know transfers between both levels 3200 now was changed to deal with how reimbursements and income is documented tracked and all that so we are you suggesting that we uh change the title uh lead the uh

094business non-instructional operations but change the subtitle to uh reimbursements yeah something like that um but again I I I I don't know like we are kind of running up against the wall of time so I I think um you know we we could table this one too and I could make the motion I I'll motion a table 3200 is there a second second is there any discussion I just wanted to note that I will send out a package with the um the uh revised 3200 that is correlated to the current coding that's in C okay uh when I had chatted with Ry he pointed out that we don't that checks are like buggy whips and that there's no need to to include checks because we don't get any everything is electronic transfer right understood okay

095um I'll make a note of that and we can deal with it when we edit it okay so and for ready for the vote all those in favor of tabling the discussion on p3200 until the next meeting I saying I I Ian I Matthew i3000 p3200 was table um P 3310 and what do we have 3310 and 3320 um do you want to try to get into could you stand an extra to gamble an extra 10 minutes Andrea and go on to 710 in the hope that in 20 minutes we could get the 3320 done what whatever the the will of the pr is I'm fine what's your pleasure um 3310 we did a lot of work on last time and we just tabled it because we ran up against the wall um so I

096think we're probably in we might be able to just kind of do a quick run through and and okay let's start 33 we're going to work on P 3310 can we put that up I have a couple of suggestions that I think will strengthen this uh yep stand by one second all right so is that up there 3310 purchasing guidelines yeah so my my reading of this and I could be wrong that the second paragraph um is in its entirety if we if we refer the Border his agents uh we should make a reference to P 9270 which to my reading policy 9270 uh essentially States all this I think this is redundant to that uh we may want to delay actually working on this till you've had a chance to read that and decide

097whether you agree with my assessment or not not and that's fine with me but I think we can by we can State this by reference you said 3270 9270 927 9270 okay if I'm to take a look at that if there's something I'm mistaken then I'm mistaken but that was my sense and I if if we do if we were to use what you have here now I would add another phrase at the very end it's you could type in if you want or through the use of State of the State for pre-negotiated prices um that's a fair useful portal where there's already been competitive bidding and the states gotten some economies of scale and we don't want to per we don't want to preclude that from happening unintentionally preclude that from all right so

098so yeah I guess I I will have to read that 9270 and for that sake I guess maybe we should table this one too okay we have a motion motion so mov so it's a move to to table Andrea and seconded by Ian y okay any discussion hearing none can I have a vote all those in favor I I I 3000 to table thank you very much our last one for the evening is 3320 is there anything we can do we have seven minutes left uh no I'll motion to table and and then yeah I'll motion uh I would offer Ju Just a couple of places where you can type in it for consideration uh second paragraph first line shall develop regulation and procedures for district purchasing instead of the is District purchasing and the

099third paragraph second line only upon the approval of the superintendent and Ray pleaded or finance manager because the superintendent has designated her for this function and I asked him about POS he told me that at this point everybody has been instructed no PO in Advance no reimbursement okay I got those notes and I can I can take a run through and and I ask him what if there's an emergency he said somebody just needs to pick up the phone call you and we'll authorize it we'll authorize a pre-authorize a reimbursement but it's got to go through channels okay okay I'm ready for you uh Andrea for your magic words motion to adjourn motion to adjourn second I'm in favor favor okay okay it is now do I have a vot Mike anything for the good

100of the order Bev anything for the good of the order no have a good night okay all those in favor of joury please say I was that enough yeah I'm waiting to hear who and I so it's three to 0 to zero it is now 6:55 p.m. and we are ajour w

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.