CorpusRecord 114000

1-23-25 Groton Board of Education Policy Committee Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Groton Public Schools
Date
2025-01-24
Location
Southeastern Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,938 words · about 67 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001today is January 23rd 2025 it's 5:05 p.m. and I'm calling the meeting of Gren Board of Education policy committee to order at 50:05 p.m. uh present are members uh Andrea acan myself Ian Thomas and visiting with us observing our uh well observing is a member Adrien Johnson and Bev Washington as chair is a member uh I'm not sure what the ex officio you but you're you're official member so she's can certainly participate uh Ian I just want to be sure you're on could you come on and say hello so we don't start without you thinking that you're there uh yes I am here thank you good evening good evening thank you so uh we're going to start then with a review of the minutes of the meeting of uh December 18th is there any discussion

002any emissions uh deletions or something we need to add for that Ian anything from you I'm all set Andrea anything for you no then can I have a motion to uh approve the minutes of December 18th so moved Thomas may I have a second second seconded by Andrea aiman uh any further discussion any further discussion hearing none I'll ask her vote all those in favor please uh indicate your preference all those in favor say I I I and I have also vote I so that is approved 30 to Zer moving on to the um old business uh the first agenda on the item at Susan's request was evaluation of the coaches p411 15.3 but as our head of Athletics was supposed to be an invited guest uh I think we can move on to the

003next item and uh as soon as Susan and or our director are here we can uh take up evaluation of coaches as our next item of business any objections to that is a process Ian I'm I'm fine with that okay so we are currently so many papers to shuffle good Lord so I am now looking at what is currently P 5131 181 uh currently titled uh use of electronic communic uh use of communication of electronic hey Matthew Matthew can I inter you for a second sure Susan's having Wi-Fi issues can you ask Caitlyn to send her the link to the meeting I will right now okay thank you thank you very much okay so we we'll start on this and we if she comes in with the director we can suspend this and come and

004go back to it after we deal with the other one so uh the former um the former use of Comm communication device actually can I have a motion to uh adopt for purposes of conversation a motion to adopt the revised P 181 oh yes so moved Thomas okay the second this is for purposes of discussion this is not a vote in favor I'll second it okay the initial uh the initial policy dated to 2008 just at the moment that t mobile devices and cell phones were um entering into usage and did not even consider their existence so we've had a pretty uh thorough discussion about cell phones that discussion had in with input um we had circulated a number of Articles showing how other Connecticut school districts were dealing with cell phones how other districts

005and states and uh bodies were dealing with student use of cell phones what was considered appropriate what was considered inappropriate and how one might act on that in addition Clint Kennedy our director of it came and joined us I think on occasions I won't swear it was two but I think it was two occasions and as we also had visits from uh maybe if Susan's coming on hi Susan hi I was having internet connection problems uh where what's the status of our uh so Susan Austin superintendent has joined us what's the status of our um athletic director joining us at this point I understood he was joining us okay so we are on devices and we're going to continue on that and when he arrives decide if we're going to suspend that and then go

006to him or if we're close finishing that he can just wait a little bit I will text him while you move on to the um okay the next one and Caitlyn has them so we can put them up if you want them okay thank you very much so having had all the input uh including the principles from the middle and the high school and feedback from some of the Elementary School principles the administration uh on its own appropriately as a matter of Regulation modified the student handbooks at all levels elementary middle and high school to uh have certain regulations in effect and the function it was I believe correct me anybody if I'm mistaken the consensus of this board that pending the completion of the Yukon research study Andor legislative action that those recommendations already

007articulated and enforce in the uh three levels of educational system would be the basis for a policy so our policy in fact handshakes with the regulations the understanding is and again Susan I really want you to agree or disagree uh at such time as a we get further information B the legislature Acts or C we have the uh access to yukon's opinion at that at one of those points we may come back to revisit what we might conceivably do tonight are we on the same page so far am I going too fast no no I'm fine with it okay Susan I'm good okay so you have in front of you the proposed uh the proposed policy update that would functionally uh supersede the the policy of 2008 it has been renamed to be talking electronic

008devices and the reason it's the the reason it is no longer electronic communication devices it is is because as I understand it there are already on the market things that uh stress stress that go Beyond Simple Communications voice voice Communications social media Etc so we are trying to have a title that would be inclusive rather than limiting uh have I got that have I got that right guys okay so I'd like us to take a look you can see what is in red was for the old commun the old policy that's been deleted and what you have essentially is about 2third of a page of text the green being what we are uh considering adding prior to subject to our discussions today and board approval obviously and the black is the residual amount from the

009original policy which really isn't very much so um I guess since admin prepared this I it would be my inclination that we let the superintendent present what she did and why she did it for our edification uh are we all on the page with that approach okay um I'm fine with that I just wanted to note that um I may have to step away from the meeting for about five or 10 minutes um uh so I I just will might have to interject to announce when I'm stepping away and then interject when I step back in that's fine and I will do my very best to update you on all that has transpired in your absence and what I miss Bev and Andrea and Susan Adrian and maybe even Caitlyn will uh correct me if

010I get something wrong Roger that yeah no I feel pretty comfortable with this subject and and I'm aware of the background but um well I said that not for us I said that in case somebody wanted to see how we what we were doing and why we were doing it that that was basically for the public of course yes all for the record yeah and exactly that's why you know um I'm not objecting to hearing it it all again because I I think it's important to do it all as a whole um since this is looks like it might pass on the first read so okay is yours so it was this is really kind of an easy solution what we had in our handbook was a little more restrictive with cell phones and more

011consistent across the different grade levels and but what the practice had become was more in relationship to the policy in the part that's been crossed out so in the policy um it basically says that electronic commun this is in red electronic communication devices are permitted under certain restricted conditions and so they're listed here if you look kind of in the middle of the page um and that all electronic communication devic may be used during the regular school day to support teaching and learning under the following circumstances the super supervising teacher grants permission use of technology is um Pro provided in a student's IEP it is needed in an emergency that threatens the safety of students and while all of those things might be really good reasons to use it we don't we're not really calling

012it out and what happened was the teachers um were using using different rules in different classrooms and it was very confusing for kids so what we did was we took what was in the handbook and it clearly stated that cell phones were you know allowed in school but they had to be in their backpacks and not coming out during class instructional time and we've gone back to that in elementary they don't come out of the backpacks really at all until the end of the day and they're a home going home if they need it for communication with families and that kind of thing and Middle School's pretty much that way too when they are walking in the doors and when they're going home they can you know when they're walking in the doors it goes

013in the backpack and it's not to be seen and it you know only comes back out like at the end of the day if they need to contact a parent um in the high school there's a little you know it's the gradual release they're able to check it during um I guess the lunch waves or in the hallway but um during instructional time in the classroom there all to be put away we feel like they have Chromebooks now and they have other devices for teaching and learning that they can use and that they don't need the cell phone and honestly the cell phone causes a lot of drama and you know that's where kids get into trouble meet me in the bathroom you know so we just we really are just following our own handbook

014and um I think the kids adjusted really well because they were mostly doing that but now it just took away you know the teacher and the teachers I think feel more comfortable that you know but if a child had an IEP or if a child needed it or even some of our children who have a second language and need it as a resource tool those things are provided as as we go along but that comes from this from the office from the you know guidance and the office to you know make those permissions not just teacher by teacher it's really orchestrated in a way that is based on student needs so um I think that it's been a a good shift um and I have had kids asked me why did you take away our

015cell phones and I said actually um it's something that is may be legislated so be careful what you wish for because you actually get some time where you can check in and you you know so um you know it's this is what's in your handbook and this is what is expected so um so what we have here is on one second Susan uh Andrea your hand is up did you have a question for Susan to you want to interrupt Susan would you yield the floor for a moment absolutely thank you Andrea go ahead my question is if a child has an IEP the Chromebook address that inad of a phone most of the time if there was something in the IEP that required it then we would I said we would absolutely whatever is in

016the IP is the law you know so whatever was needed um I mean is couldn't couldn't they whatever was in the IEP couldn't they get to that in terms of of use the use of the U Chromebook and not the phone I would say probably so yeah so it's not like even a big issue these days even with children who speak different languages they're resources on the Chromebook that can help them to speak to other people so guess there's so much right now that is that they can do with their Chromebook so it's really not it's a moot point so to speak I could imagine Andrea that there was a psych logical profile on student X that describe that person is having so much anxiety that access to a telephone uh was medically necessary I'm

017not saying such a case exists but I think we were trying to provide the IEP trumps all so if the IEP were to say necessary it would happen yeah I I know that but what I'm saying is unless it says exactly you know this child needs to be able to contact his parents by phone that that's the law but it otherwise if it doesn't if it isn't as specific as that couldn't my question is is everything else available via chome yes and if there was something specific we would have to put it in place I don't know there's something we're not even thinking about you know we have to make it work but we're just not putting it in the policy like if those exceptions to the rule are necessary that would be happening at

018the principal's office or at a PP or somewhere not in the classroom so that the teachers didn't have to worry about making those decisions exactly yeah okay I'm going to recognize Ian first and then Bev uh thank you yeah I just wanted to point out that um may not be an i IEP thing but there would be uh could be some medical concerns there as far as I know that uh some of the modern diabetes treatments uh require a cell phone interface with a monitor on the body that's a good example y yeah so you know but again that's all Case by case and yeah yeah and um I think we have the language in here uh and I would be welcome to be guided towards it um where that those sort of car routes

019are allowed with the proper documentation and process I think those those would occur in the regulations yeah right yeah that's probably where it would go exactly that's a good example Ian though thank you I'm very glad because some people may listen to this and and these these uh so-called little things are very important they are and you know you see that we've taken the most recent cave document most of this is in green now it could change legislation could impact it we could be looking at this again you know by the and I just I just also wanted to point out real quick too that uh you know some of the Chrome Chromebooks um there may be some apps on a phone that may be more conducive to supporting an IP accommodation um and the

020Chromebook may not be able to accept those apps or there might be some technological hurdle but again I think that would just require you know through the regulations you know a due process where someone could apply for an exemption and then they have to document it and and demonstrate why it's needed yeah it would be a 504 an ID right thank you or a Health Plan Bev you're up oh um actually this is the moment where I do have to step away for five minutes or 10 minutes so I'm going to step out and I'll let you know when I'm back thank you now Susan personally I like to strengthen this policy and it's the sentence in Black where it says the one two three the fourth paragraph disciplinary action may be taken let's say

021it will be taken let's make the policy have some teeth in it well it actually does happen I mean they they get a first they get a first time chance and it gets taken for the end of the day no it gets taken away from themen will be taken will be taken that's it I'm just explaining what it is that happens do you want to know I I want to know but I want some teeth in these policies because the same thing with the attendance policy people are saying we don't have enough teeth in these policies so I think may I see correctly I think saw that too correct me if I'm wrong Bev I think Bev wants to hear it say that disciplinary action will be taken under all circumstances where there's a a

022supposed violation that action does not mean there'll be punishment the disciplinary action will be administrative and the administrators will determine what if any disciplinary action occurs what what the results are but Bev's point if if I'm understanding her correctly is that she wants to assure that there will be thorough action on each alleged violation am I understanding you correctly Beth correct and be May so some people might say well it says May so I don't have to do anything because it doesn't you know I it's too much it's a wiggle room no we want teeth in this policy so all teachers know this is what the policy says that may well you may do that and you may you know May and may not no it will be so it does happen it happens in

023elementary middle school and high school if they have their phone out it gets taken away okay no more may will will it does it just take gets taken away now I think at the middle school high school they can go get it at the end of the day but if it happens twice the parent has to get it and they can't bring it back the question is is whether the polic whether the your talking about the operational process Susan as I understand it what happens when it's right I just wanted to explain so you know what happens is talking about the policy language I know and I put I think that it we we'll get to that when we do a line by line so I agree but I'm just saying that it does happen

024okay they have they have a system of how that happen so if it does happen there's no argument about changing that made a right there's no argument okay so I'm so back to you Susan this going to be kind of up and back because I want everybody to pitch in when they have something to say so I was just saying that the green language the black language was what was there before the green language is the new language based on the cap and the red language is what we're taking out but we certainly can put things in the regulation that could be related to health or IEPs or whatever if needed if it's the only way you can do it on the cell phone and you can't do it on the Chromebook you know um

025Andrea you're you have a question and the other thing I would uh I would take out of that the black line is that that word against that word should that puts the school in contention with the student it won't be taken against it will just be taken right I agree okay okay so I guess my procedural question now you you do you have anything else Andrea don't want to cut I don't know I don't know not for the moment okay not for the moment so uh I think what I'd like to do so that anybody who views this we're not jumping from one place to another why don't we start at the top uh can we is it possible to have a split screen Kaitlyn so we can have put it up yes what number

026is it this is 5131 8181 okay Susan is the word wellbe one word or is it a hyphenated word or is it two words two separate words well two words yeah so you see where it's one word on the second okay yep okay is this the one that's the one you're right first time out of the box good for you she's a good co-pilot isn't she yeah I just want to hang on just one second guys okay so I'm I'll uh I propose reading it one paragraph at the time make whatever discussion we have on that paragraph and after we've done all four paragraphs to read it once more afterwards as a full document to see if anything else jumps out at us can we kind of read it to ourselves and if there's anything

027you want to talk about we don't need to read it out loud and go through yeah can we start Andrea you you have a question Andrea well I have a question about the first H paragraph okay I'd like to to read the whole thing through before I say anything okay so we we're read I think I'd like us to read it aloud because different people have different learning styles so uh don't read it out loud twice though no I won't read it out loud twice be would you be willing to read the first paragraph Yes I would Matthew thank you the Board of Education board and parenthesis is committed to providing a safe positive and productive learning environment for its students the board recognizes that depending on how they are used cellular telephones and other

028Wireless communication devices can either be can be either a valuable learning tool or a source of disruption in the learning environment in order to maintain a secure and orderly learning environment student use and possession of cellular telephones and other wireless communication devices shall be subject to the limitation set for in this policy I put a I put a comma in there after positive for you Andrea oh thank you um we should also take out in order you should never use that um I agree so it the last sentence would read according to Andrea's suggestion to maintain the secure and orderly learning environment deleting the receding words in order is that then does that anybody have a problem with that no I don't no further comments so then that second uh sentence I believe um the

029board recognizes that um depending on how they were use cell cellular phones and other wire devices and all that thing that should just go we don't have to say that it uh it just to maintain a secure and orderly learning environment student use and possession of of cellular of I'm sorry telephones and other Wireless Communications will be subject to the limitations of this of this policy Bev Susan any comments yeah tell me that again Andrea please what are you uh the board recognizes that depending on how they are used used the cell yeah the cell your cell your telephones and other Wireless that that whole sentence should just go I think that opens the door for argument and um I have learned that if you give your decisions and not your reasons people will accept

030your decisions they'll argue with your your reasons oh so you want to eliminate that whole sentence I do y I have a comment but I'd love to let Bev and Susan CH I'm not married to it Bev any response nope I'm not married to it either I almost feel like um Andrea that word depending is is depending again on depending on what and who so let the regulations State what the regulations are going to stay if there's any wiggle room you know what I mean so I agree okay so my response is that that dependent clause depending upon how they are used should definitely come out but I would respectfully ask Andrea to consider that we have two functions in a policy one is to State the policy and where there is a a policy

031that people don't understand they react strongly so we have the educational function that's our that's our mission teaching and learning is for the purposes of Education our educational function here is to tell people we have a policy because of such and such and I would ask you to consider having it read the board recognizes that cellular telephones and other Wireless Communications can be either a viable learning tool or a source of disruption in learning environment period get rid of the marshmallow phrase yeah I think that's a good idea Matthew because the next sentence makes the that that sentence that you wrote flow right into the next sentence to maintain secure and yeah to maintain a secure and orderly learning it explains why we're doing this actually the first paragraph I I I I really think

032we have an educational function beyond our K12 we have an education function to share how education works with the community it's a way we build support for the community and if they disagree and they argue and the folks storm the storm the the boardroom we'll take what they say into consideration at that time but Andrea feedback no I I uh I I disagree I think that opens up the door I I can see this actually going to court that in defense of this was an educational uh resource for my child he had a to to know how kids uh react there are Arguments for that there are Arguments for that I I agree with there to maintain a secure and orderly learning environment yes the rest of it I I can see that argued over

033and over again and um knowing what we seeing in the country right now I could see us I'd like toing Ian seems to be be are you back uh yes that's affirmative I have returned so I'd like to bring Ian up to speed on where we are because I was just thinking where is Ian when we need him okay we're looking at the first paragraph We read it aloud so anybody could hear the first sentence was accepted the uh final sentence beginning and the Green in order to maintain and secure Etc we deleted the words in order and just started to to maintain to secure there was agreement on that and there's a third change on the table uh the middle sentence that starts the board recognizes that um I think there's General agreement well

034Andrea would you state it in your own words I don't want to to to try to unintentionally deform what you have to say Okay I uh move that we will I suggest that we um eliminate that second sentence that says the board recognizes that depending on all that sentence that a whole second sentence goes uh my rationale is that that opens the door for argument and again if you give your decisions people will accept them if you give your argument people will argue with them if you give your your your uh reasons people will argue with it and there are reasons in here that open the door to arguments and I I say we just take that thing up so yeah you're suggesting just eliminating the second sentence alog togethere correct okay um and I

035and I respectfully disagreed with Andrea I uh agreed that the depending upon how they are used needed to be removed but other than that I felt that we should leave it in and my rationale was that as an educational institution uh we have an obligation to educate and the public has a right to know why we're doing what we're doing yes however is my hand still up I guess however oh I'm sorry um go ahead please okay um I'm almost losing my thought here um take your time don't worry take your time um oh we did say that unless it's in I IEP or 504 some odd reason that a child has to have a cell phone and then that's the law but we did say that all other areas on that they may need

036to access are available on the Chromebook so cell phones are not are not necessary in any way because the access is available on so Ian now that you've heard uh two takes I don't know if Bev wants to add her two cents or not do you want to add anything Bev so before we ask Ian his comments no you can ask Ian and come back to me okay Ian so now that you've heard these two takes your thinking with us um well I can see value in both um I can understand Andrea's uh position for sure um and it does sort of set up a a contrary Thing by saying that we recognize the valuable learning tool um yet we're restricting them heavily so I mean I and they actually have other tools that would

037work the same or better that we give them right yeah I would be inclined to to to to agree with Andrea on this one just for the sake of brevity and Clarity um because it I think there's ways we can well I mean yeah anyway we're going to deal with like the exemptions and the regulations um so I I'm fine with like getting getting rid of the sentence I think it could you know anytime we can eliminate unnecessary words the better B yeah I I agree with Andrea as I we read it we don't really need it okay in the interest of comedy and consensus I still feel the way I feel but I'm I'm certainly willing to Incline before my colleague so we will uh remove the second sentence in its entire is that

038our understanding yes that's correct got it got it got it so the first sentence stays intact the sentence second sentence is completely removed the third sentence we remove the first two green words in order and we begin the sentence with a capital T in to maintain are we agreed that that's what we've done on the first paragraph yep yes okay want me to read the second one sure all right there is a growing body of evidence that suggests student access to cellular telephones and other electronic communication devices may be detrimental to student emotional well-being and academic growth therefore the use of electronic communication devices and other such technology technology at school is considered a privilege not a right oh well the first thing you like to comment on on on your reasoning for that text

039what was that Matthew I was asking if you would share your rationale for for it wasn't mine it was the lawyers that came okay yeah I just gave you the lawyers I didn't write the policy okay okay get rid of there is just start a growing body of evidence indicate shows whatever um or suest detrimental yeah just get rid of their got it and is is it maybe or is detrimental or can be I think well and I would say it just as a growing body of evidence that suggests student access to cellular telephones and other electronic devices Maybe um but you can't say that it is always not true yeah yeah okay just get rid of the there is I have a I have a suggestion um to maybe clarify the thought there go

040ahead yeah all right so uh I agree with Andrea as far as taking out there is and just jump right into it say a growing body of evidence indicates and I would suggest uh I would say a growing body of evidence indicates that constant student access to cell telephones and other electronic communication Dev devices is detrimental I think by adding the qualifier constant would give us cover on putting in is but the word word constant is a a word that the beauty is in the eye of Beholder of what constant is I'm just doing once an hour it's not constant right once every 10 minutes no I that's why I said the other night never use adjectives and adverbs in your in in your sentences yeah yeah I don't like that sorry Ian yeah me

041too that's fine I did I did go to to uh our Lord and our Lord Google and Google says well-being is hyphenated oh yeah we we did that already okay yeah yeah I'm fine with that paragraph As with the chain with I'm getting rid of there is and starting with starting with a a growing otherwise I'm fine with that whole power the only other thing I have is totally grammatical and that the words there therefore and however those kinds of words are what they call interrupts and they should not ever begin a sentence and since we're the Board of Education we should end indicate that in our writing that we know those rules so the use of electronic communication devices I guess therefore you know it should interrupt it should not be it should not

042begin the sentence that's we even need it could we just say the use of um electronic communication devices and other such technologies that school considered a privilege not a right yeah do we need therefore no we don't let's excise wherefor there for and make a capital T the use how does that sound Ian your hand is up Ian I was suggesting Andrea that we delete therefore and begin the with the use of Ian your hand is up oh yeah I was just wondering um did we ever I I didn't receive any electronic copies of this of the agenda packet I'm wondering does anyone have a document that they could project and edit in real time way to Ian I've got it I'm I'm doing it right now this is a PDF and this is what

043went out in our packets and you know electronically we got this I never the agenda they always add them when when they post it but anyway we've got it I have a I have a problem with a considered a a privilege that means in my view okay then uh I could um I could be granted the privilege of a of a cell phone yeah you see you could be if you follow the rules that are outlined and you go through the process no the policy says no cell phones and oh little Johnny over there was a nice little well I I'll leave that part Little Johnny over there gets to use his telone because he's been a good little boy and he's obeyed the rules but little Bobby over there is a little imp and

044he note yeah no no no no well they're not say oh yeah they are the US they you could say the use of self of electronic commission devices and other such technology at school is not a right you could say that yeah no why do we even say that that that could be argued in court too if we're saying no phones that means people can argue Andrea people can argue that they have the right to to control the curriculum each parent can control the curriculum in each class to suit that family's need and they do argue it in court but that is the place where it should be argued it's not to be argued in the policy right and here this one says that um it's if you did that well that then it's my

045right just get that out of there so you want to get bid the whole sentence I think it destroys the par it destroys the function of the paragraph either we have access to phones or we don't and we're saying in our par in our policy we no phones and now we're saying well it could it's it's your right huh well then the purpose of the paragraph again is educational we might want to go to the SEC the next paragraph because kids are allowed to carry them on the school property but it tells you specifically that we you know we really keep them out of the classroom okay do you want to pass on second paragraph and go on to the third yeah let's hold up second uh Andre you read a paragraph B you no

046hey hey baby I don't read all you don't read I'll read the next one too okay all right students May possess cellular telephones and other wireless communication devices on school property and school sponsored Transportation provided students adhere to the restrictions contained within this policy and regulation specific guid guidance regarding cell phones and other electronic devices is available in the board regulation and student handbooks any unauthorized use of cellular telephones and other Wireless communication devices during the instructional school day or at such times as not authorized by the school principal or design is prohibited as it disrupts the instructional program or distracts from the educational environment I see I think that's pretty strong I think that's strong I would take out as a disrupts you don't have to tell them why we just have to tell

047them no I I respectfully disagree Andrea I I respect that that's your opinion it's not one that I have to share well I think that this whole movement is founded because we have found it does just disrupt and it does cause problems there's so much drama I can't tell you Andrea with these cell phones and meet me in the bathroom and you know and let's have a fight and um it's just it's just you know I agree with you your boyfriend is your boyfriend with my girlfriend and you know it's just awful it does takes their mind off of everything else I I agree totally yeah um I should but I I say uh is prohibited period not because it distruct the educational program and distract and distracts from educational environment no it's just not

048acceptable we say no that's it and and again you're given your reasons not your decision Ian your comment is your hand up in what about taking the first sentence of the um the second paragraph and bringing it down to the third paragraph and um eliminating um the the you know if we want to eliminate that second sentence in the second paragraph right that means that second paragraph will only have one sentence so can we bring it down to the sentence um to the third paragraph make it the first sentence into the third paragraph yeah I think that's a good thing let's try that yeah that's that's sounds good and I I hear what you're saying Andrea but I'm not against explaining why we're doing this and I think by having uh because it disrupts um

049the where is that again oh because it disrupts the instructional program or distracts that's the sentence that you're against yeah yeah I'm not against explaining why we're doing it we're just explaining this why we have this uh policy because it disrupts the Ed instructional program and distracts from the educational environment explaining if you move that sentence that talks about the body of evidence the research it kind of connects with that too yeah yeah I'd be inclined to agree with that reasoning I I I think you know we we eliminate that so weum I think I'm hearing consensus that we are eliminating the second sentence of the second paragraph completely I would offer for a suggestion that before the word uh evidence we add research hyphen based evidence because it's it's not uh just people saying

050it it is research-based evidence but we do putting that Matthew so I there is a growing body of research-based evidence before evidence research based evidence it's not evidence can be testimony growing body of research-based evidence I think that's what Matthew read yeah now what but if we bring that down doesn't that say what that last sentence says and we could just end it um at um is prohibited because I think that f as bevly said to bring that first sentence down all of what is in that um as it disrupts section all of that is already in that I do have one question about the Transportation uh I am I have no knowledge of what goes on on the school bus transportation but do we know if the driver feel that the use of cell

051phones uh gets to the point that it interrupts and and compromises the potential safety of our students is that something no I've never heard that and honestly we can't Monitor and control that and there are parents who want children to give them a call or to text them when they're on the bus I'm not getting into policing that forget it okay okay fair enough can I say something Matthew hm let me think about it okay Ben okay thank you sir um I I I hear Andrea say she wants to she thinks it' be a good idea to eliminate that last sentence in the third paragraph any unauthorized use right Andrea let me see um oh gosh I hope not I I would want to keep that last sentence I just want to I wanted to

052ended at see in that we have taken that first sentence out there and I like that I I just want now to end it as prohibited and get rid of as it disrupts because I think that the first sentence says that and that's then going all to be in that paragraph will you I'm I'm inclined to agree with Andrea on that one please please read it as you want it Andrea I'm not quite sure I I see where exactly where you want to put in okay yeah and can you can you can you hear me I just want to check in you're good yeah you already checked in okay thank you go ahead Andrea um I don't know what I stuff is is blocking stuff is picking up coming in on my I don't know

053what it's about anyway it's blocking the so if we take Beverly's suggestion of bringing that second sentence down because it's in the second paragraph yeah yeah and making that part of the the this paragraph that we're working on now we then can end the last sentence at um by that is not off raised by the principle of disign is prohibited ended at prohibited and take out as it disrupts from there to the end of the sentence because the first sentence now that we brought it down has those thoughts okay the reasoning I agree I think that's strong somebody like to read the amended the proposed amended version okay I'm going to read it since it's in my notes because I've changed it okay so a growing research-based evidence and I don't know that seems a

054little awkward to me but indicates student access to cellular telephones and other electronic communication devices is detrimental to students emotional well-being and academic growth students May possess cellular telephones and other Wireless communication devices on school property and school sponsored Transportation provided students adhere to the restrictions contained within this policy and regulations specific guidance regarding cell phones and other electronic devices is available in the board regulation and student handbooks I think any unauthorized use of cellular phones and other wireless communication devices during the instructional school day or at such time as not authorized by the school principal or designate is prohibited period period I think that we in that that new second sentence we've got two discrete ideas one is possession and the other is use and mixing them in the same sentence is not going

055to be clear to everybody well if you add the word while in the beginning while students May possess cellular for telephones and other Wireless commun ation devices on school property and schools you don't see why I can't read out loud students must must adhere okay I like that while students May possess all the way to Transportation comma delete the word provided start students must adhere to the restrictions contained within this policy and regulations hey Matthew making it strong I like that do you have a complete sentence because you're starting with while while students May possess cell that's fine that's anuse that's an introductory long introductory clause it's a qualifier yeah and then you put a comma after it and put the the independent clause after right I know but I thought you said put a

056period no and students must adhere adhere you know what why don't you put up that thing that you're working on so we can look at it I can't it's in it's the oldfashioned way so I read I'll read it again read it again sus I'll read it again okay while students May possess cellular telephones and other Wireless communication devices on school property and school sponsored Transportation comma comma and you're saying take out the provided students take out the provided provided they yeah no no take out the provided take out the provided um okay students must Comm students adhere hey you could leave and provided comma provided they adhere to uh uh restrictions I think it makes it a lot stronger Andrea because it it it it says possession is made they're not obliged to use

057is definitively they must adhere how about I try it one more time well they may carry they must adhere I think that's right TR again Susan okay did Ian did you want to say anything before I try it again uh no I'm just trying to get into a position where I can open up a laptop and offer the services go ahead Susan okay while students may may possess cellular telephones and other wireless communication devices on school property and school sponsored Transportation students must adhere to the restriction s contained within this policy and regulation specific guidance regarding the cell phones and other cellular devices is available in the board regulations and and student handbook and then it goes on to say any unauthorized use of cellular telephones or other wireless communication devices during the instructional school

058day or at such time that's not authorized by the school principle or designate is prohibited I'm okay with that with the content I would make two suggestions first that the the sentence specific guidance be bolded so that really stands out oh it already is it's in Black I'll bold it okay okay and that perhaps we want to say any unauthorized used as a separate paragraph so it really jumps out that it that that now it's good there it's good there I think it's just I think it's just it it partners with that we're telling them they got to follow the policy and Ian if you have a hand raised find if you don't okay I'm fine with it as as Susan just read it okay and so that one sentence will be bolded yep okay

059um I I'm I'm opposed to any Bolding of any kind but you know again that's me but and that's because it it diminishes the rest of it the rest of the policy it when one thing is is bouldered it makes it more um substantial than anything else and that's not our intention I agree with no Bolding let's keep it all consistent okay that next next paragraph something else Ian Ian your hands up something else NOP B set okay okay so we're g now go down to uh disciplinary action are we agreed yes y okay rock onary what I printed because you made a a a suggestion disciplinary action will be taken if the policy is violated but did you want to put um disciplinary action will be taken for the use of cellular telephones and

060other wireless devices in any manner that disrupts or do you just want to say is violated period I have two ways of saying it wordy and not wordy yeah let's go with not wordy you want to read it Susan L this what I took from you all was disciplinary action will be taken if the policy is violated yeah right do and sweet and I I if I say cellular telephones and other wireless devices communication devices too many times I slur we say it too often well you know is a is a smartwatch a cellular phone no is it something that people use and they communicate and they use it to to talk and chat social media yes so well and I think they've been restricted too teachers have had to have in the I would

061say an other an other other yeah even say Wireless it just say other communication devices let them go I think it's okay in the rest of the policy Matthew just we say it over and over again so I don't think we need it here too your call and that's what this policy is about you know and there going to be thousands of of things that are going to in the in you're just exponentially appear on the market now do you want anything about in the manner which it disrupts educational environment or violates the rights of others including the use of the device to take photographs locker room bathrooms or should that go into the regulations should be yeah I agree everybody else anybody else because that is that's a problem too but I'll put it

062in regs I would like to an doly share that I use walking my dog as a way of being in touch with students i' haven't gotten over the uh Mystic side of town but I go out in the city and elsewhere when I run into kids early in the morning I ask them how's the cell phone stuff working and I do hear some grumbling yeah but some people say ah but okay I guess I understand and others say I'm so glad these new Rags are in force yeah good we always had them we just didn't use them right just just buy a biscuit for my dog there you go and you know the teachers who are uh not adhering to this policy have to be taken to task by the principal so I'm just watching

063my time because I haven't had lunch or dinner so um it's now been an hour we've done one I know that's what I was we haven't done anything yet are are we satisfied with this at this point are we ready for a vote I'm glad we've taken the time are we ready for vote wait wait go back again real quick so how are you doing the last paragraph what what's the last paragraph going to say is it gonna be or sentence please read the last paragraph again so it really is just one sentence disciplinary action will be taken if the policy is violated maybe that just goes onto the sentence before uh details of such action appear in the regulations yeah and you know the more details the more open doors are open for them

064okay it's not in the policy okay are we comfortable in voting on accepting this for is this a first reading or a second reading I've lost this is going to first reading this is the first reading so are we is any further discussion before I ask for a vote I have nothing yeah and the only thing is Susan you're taking out everything else except violation read the first sentence that you're going to disciplinary action will be taken if the policy is violated details of such action will be in the regulations yeah just a policy is violated let them find it in the regulations yeah and you know what the principles need to have the authority to figure that out I mean we can put some of this in the regulations but it's really up to

065the and the levels that they do it so well in your regulations you have first offense second offense and third offense that's true yeah I know it's already in there we don't want it to be too much up to them because then we have too much discrepancy between principes that's true so do you guys want to have the sentence details of such action will be in the regulations I would appreciate it I think it's good to have it because then it indicates that the regulations are contingent on this policy and that you know there's going to be an expectation that the regulations are adhere to uniformally across District the other thing I would like Susan if if you're in agreement is presuming that this gets passed for a first reading I'd like you to send

066this to all seven principles yeah ask them if uh if you have any objections speak now or forever keep your peace H that that they're not the board this is the board's policy let them see what we're what we're doing okay and if and then you know if we get feedback we get feedback so I see how about this I see um both Matt and Peter next Tuesday for the principal's meeting how about if we just look at it together and just say this is what we're proposing and they'll be fine this is what weend keep in the loop this is what we're sending yeah yeah but that's this is what we're proposing yeah okay all those in favor of the uh amended policy P 51 31.817324 okay Matthew to Z to zero this passes

067for first reading so uh I am more than willing to go on for another hour are you folks willing to do that if so do you want a three or four or five minute break Susan has she worked all day Susan worked all day Susan worked all day she hasn't eaten and no that's okay I don't mind getting through some of these but I just you know if we can just put them up and um show them these are I think um Kate you have the 3310 so I'm gathering not going to be doing the uh we're going to postpone working on the coaches is that is that yeah I he didn't answer my my text so he must not have gotten the memo so could I have a motion to table the discussion on

068the coaches until our next regular meeting our next monthly meeting don't moved I'll second that all any discussion all those in favor of uh tabling discussion on P 41153 until the next regularly scheduled meeting please indicate by saying I all right okay so we are uh tabled to February 30 we have p13 we're moving on to discussion of P 3310 expenditures expending Authority unless there is something in the order of what we're doing it has to be on the agenda but if there's something that's more most critical tell me and we can change the order no I think just go through it in numerical or in this order that we have it I think we'll be easier okay uh this one is expenditure Authority 33 chicken has to now yeah know okay so we have

069before us the policy we also have the regulations which is not the board authority but uh uh the admin will seek our comments before they adopt their rigs so can I have a motion for the purposes of discussion to adopt P 3310 business non-instructional operations expenditures SL expending Authority who is this me Andrea okay yeah may I have a second second Thomas okay thank you Mr Thomas thank you Miss A Dr aan um can I just had a point of privilege here I'm I'm going back to my emails here and I I do not have the electronic version of the agenda packet I wonder if the superintendent could forward it over um I think for the S of sake of expediency it would be uh beneficial to to be able to project these things and

070edit them in real time and I do have the capability to edit PDFs so if I could get the pdf version of this agenda packet as is usually sent out um I could project it and edit it so that we could all see what's being the adjustments that are being made and I think is that technically possible now Kaitlyn do you have that can you forward it or Susan can you foran do you want me to forward what you sent me if you have it because I'm looking for it on my iPad I'll send him what you just sent me earlier all right thank you thank you Ian for the suggestion thank you well what did we do before this we just took notes off that I know like I just did of the oldfashioned

071way yeah that's all I mean let's not make a big thing out of this well it's a matter of we just spent a lot of time reading something over and over again to get the language and the Linguistics and the particular grammar Parts where I think if we did it un projected and edited live we could all see the words and intuitively understand that certain things are are fine probably still be reading it out loud ah Bev you can come to my house and read a bedtime story I just sent it to you Ian so silly thank you three little piggies okay okay so we are now fine so I would still appreciate if we could read it aloud there are some people for whom auditor the auditory channel is most effective in comprehension Bev

072do you be our reader or do you want it to be somebody else no I could be your reader thank you um so you're on purchasing right yep okay as a public agency the board of education is and parenthesis board is is aware of its responsibility are you reading read the regulations or are you reading the no this is the green this is the C policy and the red is will be will transpose into regulations eventually that's not what I have in front of me 331 I have 3310 it says the purchasing guides I'm yeah I I have the Board of Education or its agent shall refrain from entering into contracts I don't know what that one is I got in the packet that's what I got in the packet you don't have the first

073paragraph on there no ma'am I have nothing in green I don't know what you have then do you have what's on the screen Matthew pardon do you have what's on the screen I'm looking for it I don't believe I do well can you just read along on the screen sure I'll go read along on the screen I'm I just that I tried to prepare in advance and what I prepared for is not on the screen fine no problem I have Caitlyn can you put that back on the screen Ian is putting his up well that looks like a hotness all right on the screen I'm gonna be with my paper because you see underlining and all that so I'm just going to read what I have as a public agency the Board of Education board

074and prentes is aware of its responsibility to spend its funds to obtain the greatest possible educational value for every dollar spent the board that should be in in capital B right right the board will make its purchases locally when bids prices are fully comparable with those of outside biders every reasonable effort will be made to award contracts to the lowest bid and the lowest price for goods and services and that's the first paragraph well I don't like reasonable but I can I there's no point in arguing that I I see both ways okay my my only concern is um you know the lowest price is not always the greatest value well that's true yeah and I I I don't know I can agree with um Andrea that the word reasonable is is kind of Wiggly

075um you know but uh I would just say effort will be made take out that all that stuff no now you're now you're in the passive don't do that oh well well is it's in the passive anyway it is yeah but we do we do want to be care we do want to be careful to avoid a contractor from saying I had the lowest bid yet chose somebody it's not always be that go ahead Ian go ahead so let me just uh there was another um version of this that the ad hoc committee had submitted um and I'm just looking at the regular K policy where it starts with the Board of Education or its agents shall refrain from entering into contracts with or purchasing Goods within all right so I just I just uh

076switch screens here and um this was the draft that the ad hoc budget procedure committee had submitted uh for as a suggestion and it captures all the cave language all the C langu the C language I see yep yep and the existing language is in black and the green language is what um the budget procedure committee recommended um I you like that better Ian I I agree I think your committee did a great job I think though definitions procedures All That Jazz I can put in regulations right and I I I saw that in the edit and I would agree that we could just like get rid of all that um I mean I don't want to get rid of it I could use I mean I mean sorry I mean shift it to to

077regulations where the technical stuff can exist I agree you you've captured the cave I think that's this goe this policy that's in not packet is not a cave policy I I don't I thought it had been based on Cave not what I have in front of me from C I have in my hand the C policy 33 10 it may it doesn't say when it was adapted in July of 07 but it says it's three paragraphs long right that's the length of it and it reads it reads different differently I asked um Erica to get the latest ones that c published and it's just like what Ian has up here with those blue paragraphs fine let's go with what Ian has there's nothing in what I'm looking at that that the the the only difference

078that I see is the the one that c has with the exception it says with the exception of purchases of $5,000 all purchases of and contracts for blah blah blah must shall be based on competitive bids with the exception of purchases of $5,000 or less I think we moved it up to 755,000 though I think we better be careful I wouldn't put in the dollar amount at this point um go ahead well I I'm just I remember C did I thought C the C version had just a blank there suggesting a threshold be inserted no I have I have I I have what purports to be a cave it's on their letterhead and it it cites $5,000 oh it does okay so that's where that I I I am uh agnostic as to the amount

079as long as because that will be the amount will certainly be discussed at the board when we present our proposal if we say 5,000 or 50,000 there's bound to be an argument one way or the other so right on the board to discuss the number don't worry about it and and I I I would just be in favor of having some threshold that is defined what that is I defer to the board to determine did you want the super attendant says is a matter of practical operations but we that we can do that at our at the board meeting right so I could just like you know put a question Susan would you prefer 10,000 rather than $5,000 $7500 I can't hear you you're muted I I don't even know what number to put in

080there let me check with Ray so we'll put a I think it has to correlate with the ones that I've already passed I thought it was 7500 or 15,000 so I've got to check to see what we did could change tomorrow right huh that could change tomorrow like the price of eggs well yeah well I don't see anything in our current policy that has a figure so we're adding we're doing something brand new so I I'm talking about other polic IES that have already gone before the board and we've done a second reading we had we had widened the threshold so it forbids so you gotta get rid I understand what you're saying Susan if we could just put in a a placeholder number and all of us all of us will agree that it

081is a placeholder number subject that's right that's right and I'll talk to to Ry and look at that with Erica she'll know I'm Susan do you want 10,000 or are this 7500 I don't know so let's just we're going to put a placeholder in Bev and then I'll find out what our other policy that we agreed on says so it matches okay Ian Ian has modified it to $7,500 as our placeholder is that are we comfortable with that well I like to see 10,000 but it's it if it's just a placeholder I'm agnostic whatever you guys want is fine with me well 10,000 would be better because things really cost things cost more eggs are like $10 no hey but the price of eggs are going down soon isn't it oh are they like gas

082yeah hey gas has been steady since before we're lower now than the times of hurricane whatever it was in New Orleans yeah all right so there's our 10,000 threshold okay maybe maybe we should do something like because I see something uh maybe maybe it should reflect like according to the market or or something like that because no I don't think so I think we could put in for now we could even put in a blank line and put in to be determined by the board okay we'll have that discussion all right put put in a blank line and then we're not it doesn't seem as if we're trying to force something on them yeah I agree okay so I'm blanking this out then and put in TBD yeah okay so now and take out and

083put in x x000 uh why did you want to take the 10,000 out we don't want to Prejudice I don't want to Prejudice somebody who's reading this for the first time to think that we really deliberated and came up with this number okay this is the the the number that we want I would value we might have already decided on it and it's in another polic right match um and this is is this a first read or a second read where yeah this is gonna go to first okay so you're GNA change the language so it reflects the one that is consistent like instead of the Board of Education and then yeah do the board after that and Erica knows all that stuff yeah she knows all that stuff so what's that the last blue

084paragraph that you had Ian can you explain where that came from the last which one the last blue paragraph before the within the framework of applicable laws and regulations purchases and use of materials and Manpower shall be accomplished in accordance with good business practices this this if it's blue it came out of cave that was what I was doing when I constructed I don't see it on my cave yeah I don't see it on my cave if it's not then I then maybe that that must be a typo then um and uh that might be maybe old was that old yeah I just don't know what I don't know that it's adding more to the policy though yeah uh I have my hand up please okay um on you didn't get this policy but um

085on the previous policy before Ian put up his stuff I actually like the F the first paragraph of the other policy where it says a public agency the board of education is aware and blah blah blah blah I actually like that paragraph excuse me I need to step away for two or three minutes Ian would you conduct a meeting in my absence how about Bev if we take that as the first leading paragraph and then we follow by the board and it's refrain from blah blah blah okay let's put it together then all right I'm working on that and and then take out that second paragraph you don't need that well the thing that I wanted to capture was the greatest value as determined um yeah but that's in the first paragraph every visionable effort

086would be made to W contracts so that's that that's not that reasonable is debatable personally I don't need the second paragraph because the first paragraph to me says it all no I mean you're talking about the goal of a success we don't need to know the goal of a successful purchasing system well I mean I thought that's the idea of policy was setting forth like what our principles are what we're operating under I don't know where that that that goal statement is coming from yeah I don't know either and that's why I'm saying we should take it out that's that's language that came before that was if it's black then that was like oh previous Oh you mean from the older policy yeah well I don't see it in the new pay policy they don't

087have anything about a goal so so my recommendation would be to take that second paragraph out agree but I do like the idea of uh being clear in what we say that we that price not be the only uh metric that I like the idea of a cost benefit analysis well do we say that in the three paragraphs that are coming up don't we talk about that how about that and I'll just take out the second one as a agency the board of education is aware of its responsibility to spend its funds to obtain the greatest possible educational value for every dollar spent as determined by a comparative cost Ben benefit analysis um the board will make it per and then everything else is the same as it was um cost benefit what are we

088doing here now I'm trying now there could be things like um that we're purchasing that would be a one source and there things that the board has agreed on let's say like our Wht and wisdom program but we're not going to then not get it because of the price or do a cost analysis with some other program that they haven't decid you know I it we've just got to be careful that analysis it doesn't it doesn't imply the rigor of it so I mean like it can just be like you know that could be as determined by the superintendent the administration you know as long as there's something that's you know presented there are three dimensions there's cost there's quality and there's deliverability and sometimes there's a sole source like that you guys have decided

089maybe through curriculum that you want to do this and cost that would make the cost benefit pretty simple you well maybe you want to add in comparative cost quality and um um and um I don't know what' you say deliverability availability deliverability could be availability stuff I talk about in regulations yeah I don't like that sentence period I'm just trying to make it work yeah I don't think we I think we could say the the board is aware the board is responsible to spend its funds to obtain the greatest educational value for every dollar spent well it yeah it does say that and that should be period That's what I'm saying and then we get to the cost benefit analysis somewhere else well we need to include it somewhere else well we can add it

090down in the red for um regulations how we do it are you comfortable once I get a business manager that will stay are we going to get an exit interview with her and find out why she left I I don't know if she'll I don't know if she'll do it but I I told Lor's gonna try to reach out to her to see and you know before she leaves maybe yeah um let we should probably keep it to the agenda yeah yes say that too that's let's not go there I know and this is all videotaped too I I want to just talk about as the public agency I don't think that's necessary let's just say the board is aware of the board is responsible we don't need to say we're aware of it the

091board is the board of education is responsible to spend funds to obtain the greatest possible educational value for each dollar spent period I'm fine with that I like that I like job Matthew yeah is responsible okay and where do we stand on that sentence which one uh uh for every value spent as determined by a comparative cost benefit analysis the other part of that sentence I'm sorry I didn't hear delete the word possible delete the word possible we never know what certainty is not in my vocabulary and for each dollar spent each dollar spent there's a different specificity there I have no objection to that Andrea are you okay with that okay period spent period all right Andrea how do you feel about that uh the modifier at the end as determined by comparative cost

092that's a different sentence it's a different idea we can if you want to put it in put it in as a new sentence where where where I I got lost the first sentence as it stands has a uh a modifier on the end attached by a comma saying as determined by comparative cost benefit analysis I think I'm okay with that Ian how about you I'd rather keep it in there to indicate that you know there is going to be some level of of of analysis applied even if it is as simply saying there it's a sole vendor is all we got yeah like to add in quality cost quality and availability so it's just not cost but I suggest Ian that we make it a period after spent and then make a new sentence that

093says uh we shall we purchases shall be made via a compare a cost benefit analysis considering a b and c yeah that's purchases will use cost benefit analysis got the first we'll be based on we'll be based on it cost benefit cost benefit anal comparative cost benefit analysis comma quality no puras decisions will be based on takeout a it is on on comparative cost benefit analysis including but not limited to okay including but not limited to price quality deliverability and was there some other ones and one wanted to add no that's all I said yeah I didn't I didn't say de deliverability I said availability okay okay availability well time timely availability okay timely availability yeah we can get to your Better Price it'll be three years but don't worry price will be great things

094are going down next year so hold off on that uh sheet rock yeah yeah okay okay I think that that communicates what we want and I think it's a little clear yep okay I'm good with that you need a you need a period after the word price between price and quality price comma quality comma that's what I mean comma not a period got it what about saying all things being equal the board will make its purchases locally no no no don't need that's I don't know that we can always promise that we do do that I mean es with our farm you're the ones who determine if all things are equal I don't think make purchases locally whenever bids and prices are fully comparable so yeah I think that implies that it's competitive and that

095would be included in the in in as part of the comparative cost benefit analysis that's part of the decision- making process I think I think it is good as it is as it stands okay now we did the other two sentences what about well wouldn't we want to then would we not want to excise the final sentence because we've already said that seem it seems I think that that that gets us out of the reasonable effort yeah right all right so let me write this in here is that okay is everyone okay with that delete or should I put it back in no sounds good yeah we're okay yes the next sentence should be take out of Education yeah thank you and why do we have the administration in there I mean where it could

096be U it could be um not West every purchase is not going to be approved by the board directly if they're under the threshold so I think that makes sense to have it in there I'm just saying the administration because it's not always the administration who else agents or it's agents who else who are other agents okay so take out the administration right be Sam well he's administrator yeah he is Administration director yeah but you think of administration as principls Vice principls uh superintendent and so on well I think of my directors in the same light you know yeah well I don't think so just say it's ages I don't think you need that okay um I'm I'm open either way Matthew how do you feel I would say agents includes Administration okay don't say

097too much yourself in when you when you say too much that's fine that's good I'm with it I'm I'm fine with it I I I don't like sh refrain how about will not or shall not yeah will not into well I think well this this again this came directly from cab yeah I don't know okay there may be some times where there is no other choice and but cave is if you really read their stuff sometimes you wonder whether they even speak the English language yeah that's true the cave is not all s of sank for sure I agree with that um but they do have attorney's V they do have their attorney's vett it so in this particular case so I I see why wiggle room might be needed because like you said what

098if there's a Sole Provider and it just so happens that you know they have some relationship with somebody you know Susan how do you feel about Shel we frame yeah I I mean I think it's fine okay would the word uh sign instead of entering into be better I mean how do you enter into a contract you sign a contract right this show she refrain from signing contracts well aren't there verbal contracts yeah I just say entering in because you just don't want a loophole you don't do verbal cont sign it I hope you don't enter verbal contracts because that's uh no no we don't that's a bear trap sure is you it's supposed to be on my I'm I'm okay leaving it entering into and Matt where are you on that I'm I'm I'm

099just entering into his fine with me okay too even though you didn't ask me in yeah I I know be you and I are on the same page I was thinking the same I want Matthew to go back because he asks me what I think I'm looking at the phrase who has a sales representative who uh from any firm or individual who the the intent is to say if there's any potential conflict of interest right and I think we already have board policy that discusses that don't we Susan isn't the conflict of interest uh if if Porsche is a owner of a business and that's a business we need to buy from uh my instinct is that Ian will recuse himself from all discussion and all participation in that discussion yeah so and I think

100we have that somewhere in our I think that's yeah that's covered under ethics somewhere had that one yeah I will I'll go back and double check though are you proposing this whole paragraph get tossed no okay where are you which paragra for any for any individual or that might have who any potential conflict of interest yeah who but not that who who may have yeah any potential right contract yeah conflict of interest yeah you know because it could be my my twin brother might be doing it and you know yeah my poor brother yeah yeah because I had some feedback on this paragraph from uh some people and um they thought there was a conflict of interest for board members in this paragraph with any potential find a way to say it but the idea

101is we we are Tak culate that we won't tolerate any potential conflict of interest [Music] okay and the problem that the people I was talking to had because in the first sentence it says from any firm um the board or its agents should refrain for entering into contract to purchase and or service from any firm or individuals who has a sales representative or owner on the board and then it says shall not apply to goods or services so what's the difference that's what they're saying board members should not go ahead I was gonna say goods and services that are put out for public bid or where there are no other I know but what's the difference if a board member bids that's a conflict of interest if it's gonna if if I'm on the board

102and I bid I'm gonna I'm GNA and my bid wins I'm going to benefit from that and the board members should not benefit from that that's a conflict of interest if I'm reading my understanding is that you know with a public bid process that that that basically pulls into play the the ethics um Clauses or you know where where it's like disclosures required of any connection between a voting member and and then a board member should not be able to bid if they're on the board and that's what people are saying to me that a should not be want me to ask Floyd about that one yeah you were supposed to ask him the last time oh I'm sorry I've had a little bit on my plate just you know we need substitutes and I'd

103love to substitute but I'm not allowed to substitute because it might be a conflict of interest you know it's not whether we need it or not it's a question whether it's a conflict of interest it's interest yeah and and we need substitutes so why can't you substitute they always sh the substitutes right but you can't it's a conflict of interest the same thing with the bidding thing it's a conflict of interest if I'm on the board and even if I Bid and Win it that's still a conflict of interest I'm gaining from being I'm gaining monetary um you know I'm getting uh you know what I'm saying I'm getting money and from the Board of Education that I'm on the board of education that's not right the only problem I see with that is if

104if if you as a a company owner or what ever you know own uh can are the only you're the only supplier in the country you know what if we needed to buy a Pakistani elephant and you are yeah okay I get that part that's that other part Andrea where it says where there is no other comparable source of Supply like you're the only supplier in town and we need your whatever you're selling yeah okay I think and's tamic reasoning about Pakistani elephants I think we have to understand that there is a law of probability that's in play here too and we don't need we needn't go to Pakistan no I but you know what I mean yeah so you have to make that clear Susan that that's the only time that a board member

105can benefit if there's no other comparable Source that's what the S says I mean that that's what those words say it says this politician go ahead that they're put out for public bid or do we take out for public bid and just put where there is no other process okay I mean if we want to take that out I mean I guess let ask I'm gonna ask Floyd about the whole thing ask Floy best we can and pass it on to Floyd for his comment public bid process has a whole RMA Ro attached to it like there's there's all these regulations attached to that and inside that I believe there's you know requirements for disclosure of any connections and all that stuff so but the fact I I put it down I promise I don't

106want to think and hear what other people think I want to hear from the attorney really no disrespect to anybody but we all got our own opinions here okay and send this stuff back to Erica for me oh I definitely will no problem okay thank you you that's the next paragraph is not true because it's not just transportation we have a contract for our solar panels that goes well beyond a year and and my point is not that it's rare but it is it does come up from time to time do you within a year not to except yeah and you know the other thing is um I there you know like even with your attorney Floyd Dugas you're not going to go out to bid with Floyd dugat every every year unless she had

107a concern and wanted to try somebody else I mean you know and and we have teacher contracts and I would call that Services yeah so I don't know this this may be a paragraph that needs to get clipped out because it's too specific too limiting this was from cab so cab is kind of you know boiler plate not always applicable to particular districts why don't I it says I'm asking about the other let's let's highlight that and I'll ask Floyd about that I'm comfortable you do have that comfortable with a limit on contracts to a maximum of 5 years except that that's not the case with what we already did on the solar panels the and and and it may not be what the contract is on the future buses if we get buses because

108you're going to have to amortize them over more than five years to make them feasible right yeah this may just be too constraining as as a as a paragraph As a have to watch that yeah um so what would be the process here if we're okay with everything else um actually like looking at the last paragraph well I'd ask you uh Ian uh for the purposes of this year's budget process is there anything in here that would require that we send it to the board immediately or is this something that we can uh we can defer to next month's meeting on this one yeah this one definitely I think could like broad oversight man long-term management um so I don't think it's immediate impact on the budget right now no let me see what Floyd

109says is if it's an easy I'll send you back the corrections and then you guys can decide all right um yeah well I got I think I'm I'm fine with that too our next meeting our next meeting is Monday so I know to I don't want to have another special meeting I either we do it tonight or I recommend that we table it I recommend you table it until you get the attorney so you know what you do I don't know that I can get Floyd tomorrow it and let's do it right yeah no away from this one though I just wanted to look at that word Manpower and recommend that maybe we change it to labor H very good good catch okay yeah that's real good so uh we have a motion on the

110table now to uh pass for first reading 3310 does somebody want to make anot an amendment to that motion to table so so move Thomas motion to table is there second second second Thomas and aaman okay any discussion hearing none I'll ask for vote all those in favor of tabling discussion on P 3310 until the February meeting please say I I I I 30 z z and frankly I think we made a bunch of progress on this one guys well I think if we can bring you know we've got a really packed agenda Beverly and I reviewed it for the regular meeting coming up up on Monday and um I think if we can um get the school the cell phone through that's a that's a big accomplishment so um and then we'll we'll get

111these some of these others you know in the future agendas because we've really got a packed agenda it is now the one the one policy that is really time sensitive to the budget is the 3120 okay so my question is that is now almost 700 p.m. what would you think of our taking a half hour off I really can't I can't I've got too much to do I've got board notes yeah do you my day is not over yet guys I would just say I would I would I would put forth this proposal is one 3120 has gotten a lot of scrutiny and I think all the paragraphs have been hashed through thoroughly except that one third paragraph that we kind left hanging and I would be willing to go for another 15 20 minutes

112to to make a determination on that third paragraph and be able to move that towards the board can I put that in regulations for you Ian I'd rather do that in regulations because you know I just think holding a board to those kind of um restrictions I have a I have a proposed it's it's it's really proposed adjustment to the language yeah and you know we're all human and I don't know about Susan or anybody else I am dead and this stuff is now just jumbled in my head and if somebody would like to make a motion to I hear what you're saying Ian I think this is a my colleagues will say here's a moment to step out on faith Susan be a good superintendent and don't um I'm not I'm not okay with

113that No in fact like you know with all the conversation about this over the past many months like you know I'm a little frustrated with the process that you know again here we are you know running out of time running out of energy and it's one paragraph and I do believe it's legitimate it and it is you know Floyd never said it was illegal he said it seemed granular and maybe it was more of a regulations yeah and you know and and then that's worthy of note but also let us let us work when this was last if I if I could just finish my thought when when this was last before the full board a majority of the members expressed interest in having some sort of phrasing in the policy that brought this idea

114forward um so I mean I really do want to get to that 32 3120 but it has to go through policy first so we have no motion on the floor is there any motion on the floor FL I I make a motion to to move to uh approve um 3120 as a second read is there a second is there a second no is there a second okay in that case the motion fails for lack of a second are there any additional motions to be put on the floor yes to adjourn I hear a motion to adjourn do I have a second I'll second that motion to I I I do not agree I do nope I'm opposed okay I haven't taken the vote yet but I'll gladly take the vote so on the um 3320

115uh motion to advance was not seconded so um that was um Thomas no second I mean Matthew you and I spoke a few days ago you proposed an alternative pathway with this I I did and the pathway I asked at the beginning was uh Matthew mat you have a motion to adjourn on the table uh I will withdraw my second so that I can respond to Ian and then I will determine if I want a second I think Ian is deserving of a response okay I'm just letting you know I did ask at the beginning if there was any priority to these that something was urgent to be done now to please tell me and we would shift shift the order of them I did make I did say that and I did not hear

116anything if somebody says I missed something I'll buy that and I'll own it and I'll go on otherwise I will second the motion to adjourn and I I really understand your your frustration Ian I share the frustration too but thank God we started at five not at six that's all I can say it's uh six do I have a vote on the motion to adjourn I all those in favor of adjourning say I I I all those opposed I opposed okay so I'm I'm I'm reading that as motion to adjourn at 658 uh two in favor one opposed I I say two and that would be Andrea and Matt and one opposed oh Ian I'm whipped too I'm sorry Ian um so we are we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.