CorpusRecord 114008

12-18-24 Groton Board of Education Policy Committee Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Groton Public Schools
Date
2024-12-19
Location
Southeastern Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,285 words · about 91 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001it's uh 5:05 pm and I'm calling the December 18th special meeting of the policy Committee of gron Board of Education to order uh before we begin any proceedings could we show the agenda case so you'll note on the agenda that we have seven items and we may or may not get done with them in within the hour that we usually do you can take that off now Clint so uh what I propose doing is if we're not finished at the end of an hour I'll ask the board the board members who are on the policy committee if they're willing to meet for another half hour if they can't for whatever reason we'll end the meeting if they can we'll do another half hour at the end of that half hour if they're still not done

002I'll ask again this way nobody is you somebody needs to go they need to go okay so we'd like to review the minutes of the uh November 19th um committee meeting uh does anybody have anything they would like us to can I get a motion to adopt them and then we'll have discussion well so move thank you do I have a second for uh moving to adopt the minutes of the last meeting Andrea would you second that for purposes of discussion sure second okay we have a a motion and a second is there any discussion on the review of the minutes for October sorry November 19th Ian I'm not hearing anything from Ian I don't have any questions I'll call for a vote all those in favor please say I I I have two eyes

003any opposed any abstain abstain I note that the Dr akman is abstaining she was not present at the last meeting that's why I believe she's abstaining was I wasn't on the committee okay so we have now adopted the Mee the first item of old business is a discussion of p 2 uh adoption on a policy for prohibitions on sex discrimination and sex-based harassment you have in in front of you from the packet a uh Green Sheet that is the latest version and I guess Denise or Susan um any comments before we ask for a motion to u to approve you know what maybe we'll ask for a motion to approve that uh to approve it and get a second and then we can begin discussion Mr SCH M chairperson Schulman if you if I may

004uh may I speak absolutely I I have our attorneys from beram and Moses on the phone I had posed to them the question that I believe the board members had at the first reading of the policy and correct me if I'm if I'm wrong I believe the question was um how would an oral report be received by the administration and how would we know that what's being recorded on the oral reporting form is accurate continue yeah Ian do you recall I think that might have been your question was that the the gist of your question sorry uh yeah that's correct um my concern was like having some sort of verification from the complaintant that whoever took the uh report carried through their uh details to a satisfactory fashion Carolyn do you feel comfortable responding to

005that or do you want me to respond to that okay hold up hold on one moment um attorney Carolyn Dugas is on the phone so I'm going to put her on speaker phone Mr chairperson Schulman is that acceptable with you he will be welcome or she will be welcome I'm not sure what the for what the first name was okay it's car attorney Carolyn Dugas I guess she will be welcome okay okay go ahead attorney Dugas good evening everyone I'm also here with my colleague can we increase the volume probably W add to whatever I have to say but I want to assure you that um all employees for the district are required to be trained on Title 9 that's all employees not just um certified Personnel but your question was the example was how

006are we confident that a teacher will accurately report or even report the information so one they're trained two they're trained on title N9 they know they have the obligation um if they um suspect that information has come to them that would possibly be uh fall under title N9 they are to reach out to the ttle N coordinator so in terms of receiving information from a student or employee um they would the process should be they either immediately or shortly thereafter pick up the phone and attempt to speak with the to line coordinator to convey that information and or and or follow it up in writing an email would be acceptable you have a separate layer of uh a safety net so to speak because then once the title n coordinator is advised then his or

007her responsibility kicks in to seek out the potential complaintant and speak with the complaintant at which point the title n and they may or may not want to bring a complaint they are entitled to possibly receive supportive measures one way or another so your tieline coordinator is going to meet with the potential complaint if if the complaintant is known and then that tline coordinator will in her his or her uh bi notate what happened at the meeting what was the allegation so there's almost a a check on what was originally reported and most importantly you know is what will end up in the title n coordinator's record yeah and I would agree with that I would just you know say that the complainant may also add information you know maybe they said something in passing

008uh that was reported up the chain to to the title 9 coordinator they may give a lot more information so you know one's not exclusive of the other they're they're just two separate memorializations of what was being told okay so it sounds to me like there was um a uh so to speak a natural check in the system where once the oral report is provided to Title 9 coordinators those coordinators would reach out to the complaintant and take a more devel statement thereby like that would exactly yeah yeah the the timeline coordinators can offer and and point the complaint in the direction of completing a formal written report um the complaintant does not have to do that to trigger the district required response but it's always encouraged to attempt to get a complaintant to fill

009out the written uh Complaint Form okay well I mean the sounds like the the way the process is set up that it would leave at least my concern that there would be an opportunity for um an oral report to be verified with a complaintant uh at one at the the title coordinator picks up the ball and starts running with it yes and of course if there's an investigation um that does follow if they do file um a formal complaint then you're going to go even further in terms of the verification they're going to be interviewed they're going to you know potentially be supplying in um evidence that's going to get you know more and more pinned down to get the most accurate information and I I think if I can just add I think the

010question that that you had Ian was there are some cases where the complaintant does not wish to file a formal report and that is when you know in order to ensure that the district is not being deliberately indifferent that is where the title 9 Coordinator would file the report on behalf of the complaintant okay um that satisfies my concerns so okay I'm fine with moving as is thank you does anyone else have any questions I'm do you have anything else that you want to share with the committee Denise I don't want to cut you off either no no I just want to thank attorney Dugas and attorney Goldberg for calling um in response to my question and um just let you know that you had really uncanny timing because we were just starting the meeting

011and and I was number one on the agenda it's all in a day's work yeah I think I think we all need to buy a lottery ticket tonight okay thank you attorney Dugas we really your courtesy bye bye you too bye bye well having heard that is anybody interested in making any other comments or making a motion uh do we do we already make the motion to put it on the floor for no we did not make a motion no we we had the the attorney was waiting online so we have not had a motion made okay well then I'll I'll um and forgive me this is at a second read level correct yeah correct I believe so so uh I'll move that we approve a second reading of P51 145.5 [Music] one2 do I

012have a second to that well I'll second that if I'm allowed to I think I am allowed to yeah so is there any further discussion you the only thing I have is that um I had two questions um one superintendent of schools and I think we've decided in past policy meetings to just make it superintendent to be consistent and then there was a the verb is and I don't know if this is a legal thing um this policy shall contain which which paragraph are you on I'm on one two three four the fourth one down it says superintend of schools and then my recommendation is to take out of schools to be consistent and then um uh the superintendent of schools shall establish a regulation uh to to accompany this policy that shall contain um

013grievance procedures yeah agreeance and I thought that the the the verb should have been um should that will maintain uh procedures in accordance to to title uh nine but now that I'm reading it I'm I'm seeing that contain is probably the the correct word Ian are you comfortable with just making a friendly Amendment without needing a vote on dropping the word of words of schools yeah I'm fine with that okay so we so ordered oh I like that phrase uh we are we've amended it to have the superintendent shall establish a regulation at this is the beginning of paragraph 4 having made that uh uh amendation uh do I have uh anybody else want to comment before we vote well I do see that there's attachments here Janise you might want to explain that these

014are some of the forms that are attached to the policy too yes yes there are um there are the formal complaint form um there are um there is also uh non-disclosure agreements um that we ask the parties to sign um to maintain confidentiality there is the right to appeal if the um either party disagrees with the result of the with the finding of the investigation um and there are the notices the notices are very important because once um a complaint is accepted in terms of Investigation uh we notice uh both the complaintant and the respondent so that's really important because it outlines um the steps that will be taken and some of the options that they have in terms of um bringing some advisors to to support them have there been any changes to any

015of these documents since we last saw them at the time of the first reading no there have not okay and I also see that you out of courtesy brought forth the regulations as well you must have had those at done at the same time through Cape is that right uh these are I'm sorry were you asking me that Susan yeah because I see policy and regulations in my packet yes these um this this is called a title 9 toolkit because it has everything that you need to implement the new regulations that were in effect August 1st um the these are from burum and Moses these are from our attorney okay and I will just just note for the record that uh if we our vote tonight is on the policy it is not on the

016regulations the regulations fall in the purview of administration which has consulted with us well let me let me make a comment about that and although we don't talk about or uh address the content of the regulation it's still our policy book so if there are discrepancies in terms of U keeping a consistent wording or if there's a comma out of place then we'll address we always appreciate those edits I want you to know Dr AR you find things that nobody else finds you're good at it that was why I was the terror of the Seas okay any any further comments from anybody this evening on this this matter uh the only other thing that I have and that is uh Denise uh I've got some some of those level um comments about the uh notifications

017and all that stuff so where do you want to do that Matthew where do you want to do that the these are in the regulations or in the in the policy that you're speaking about no it's not the policy it's in the um the the notifications and all those other uh documents that that are kind of like letters that go out or forms that you that one let me run something up the flag pole and see if you guys are comfortable with it given that we have so much on the agenda tonight I'd rather focus on these other issues if you are comfortable Andrea and Denise yes to send the information to Denise Denise will integrate the the comments and and uh we will send this for second reading but it will not be put

018in the book without the corrections made are you both comfortable with that yes yes are you comfortable with that Ian yeah if there no substantive uh changes it's just all grammatical typo type stuff um I'm fine with that there's there's one or two little things that are substantive and one of them is I'll just tell it to you one of them is in the uh um the uh I guess I I'm not sure which one it is but anyway the the word victim is used and I'm I'm uncomfortable with that word I'm I would like to see a change to the subject of a sex discrimin uh discrimination occurring instead of victim what about the word alleged coming before victim the alleged victim i' still be be I'm still uncomfortable with the word victim I

019would still like to see it say just plain subject and can you just let me know Andrea where are you seeing that yeah you know what I'll do why don't you send me this uh via email an attachment and I'll just U highlight those places and then maybe we can come back and look at it at a different time when are when is our next meeting the board meeting where this is going to come up to a vote I think it's the third the regular meeting is the third meeting oh no wait I think we added a policy meeting we're doing a meeting just to vote these in right do you remember that again and that is what third or the fourth January there's a special meeting added to at five o'clock right right before

020do we have do we have time for you to collaborate on on these changes that you have in mind Andrea and to get copy out uh electronic copy no more paper electronic copy out to Ian and me to be sure that there's that everybody's on board before that meeting absolutely need you just send that to me and I'll send it back to you would that satisfy your everybody that's fine yep I'll do that right now Andrea conc I could also I would just you uh as far as like the victim thing I mean maybe uh complaintant uh would be better we did it on two yes plant plant would yeah okay okay I like that okay we've got that one excuse myself I have to excuse myself I have to turn the lights out I'm

021gonna get I'm gonna fall off my chair if I don't okay because of that something that you were gonna um I've got Beverly online I'm going to put her on speaker she was reminding us what we discussed about doing policy on the 7th you want to say that out loud Beverly can you hear mear absolutely yeah okay instead of um doing the policy on January 6 as as part of the budget review and we are we're going to have a special meeting on January 7th for the policies and to talk about the electric buses when was that change made I don't want the meeting on the 6 to be long and drawn out like at 10:30 some people do not like leaving at 10:30 so that's why we have two meetings January 6 budget and

022January 7th we talk about these houres and electric buses okay no that's your your right as chair I mean I have no objection I'd rather get thank you Matthew for no objections all right thank you Beverly you're welcome Susan all right talk to you later bye I would say if if any if any member of the board felt uncomfortable with the procedure at the meeting on the 6th on the basis of not having uh adopted the policies he or she will clearly speak up and express his or her or their feelings at the at that um meeting on the sixth I or the seventh are you talking about the seventh no the sixth because we're what we're what I'm hearing Ian say Ian if I'm misspeaking for you please correct me Ian has Ian would

023like to see this wrapped up before we get into the budget and that's the whole point so well I I one meeting that week and I think Beverly thought it would be better to do I understand but I'm I'm sharing what I perceived as Ian's thing and I'm trying to to thread a needle and the needle is to uh we accept in good faith that uh everybody understands what we're going to be doing the next day and that we're going to act under that assumption and that if there's any board member who's not happy with the way things are proceeding they'll articulate their concerns at the meeting on the 6th yeah I'm just not sure when that decision was made I mean because when we uh ended the meeting on uh last Monday it was

024um that January 6 was going to be the special chairs have changed Chang meeting dates and things and as I that's her discretion and her right as chair yeah I agree with it um I'm uncomfortable with it but you know I don't have that Authority so I can just express my dis discontent and we'll carry on okay so we're now back to uh policy I guess one thing I would want to clarify and uh that whatever is passed would be applicable to this budget session even if it's passed after the technical opening of this budget session you you've asked that question a number of times I've reached out in orally and communicated in writing that that would be the case as soon as a policy is accept is uh this is my understanding and I

025ask Susan to confirm or deny that as soon as a policy is accepted by the board it takes effect instantly did I understand that correctly Susan yes so now we have it memorialized a yes very good thank you all right um I'm good with moving on if uh we're ready to move on is Matthew Frozen I don't know Matthew Clint can you tell I believe he is oh no I would say we give him a second to uh reconnect okay Bev is uh on as an attendee uh I can certainly promote her to uh panelist as well is do you see Irene on to Irene is on okay good I believe the chair is is um an ex official member of all committees so she can far as I'm I'm concerned she can be raised

026up to be a full panel because she can as an ex official she can interject anytime she pleases she's rejoining as a p panelist as we speak thank you I just does Matthew know to kind of Disconnect and reconnect so that he can be heard again I would be willing to bet but I can reach out to him if you'd like okay that'd be great thank you Clint [Music] hey can you hear me yep yeah uh I I just want to say some people don't want to um be at meetings to 10 10:30 at night so I'm trying to accommodate those people because I don't want to lose them as board members because I really respect them and I really need them to stay on the board of aded and I was at a learn

027meeting today and they're surprised that our meetings go to 10:30 they said one board CH said if you're not doing your job if your meetings aren't over by 8 8:30 and they start at 6: so I'm just trying to accommodate everybody not just you Ian I know you want to push these policies through but one more day it is not going to hurt thank you B yeah I appreciate your comments and uh and and you know that's your reasoning and you're the chair you can do that that's fine no it's not that I'm the share that I can do it I'm trying to do what makes uh other people happy not just you happy I'm trying to accommodate other people and they don't want to be there till 10:30 at night so that's why I

028said let's do it on January 7 it's just one more it's just another day past the six it's not gonna kill anybody all right it's not gonna kill anybody the policies will still be that's just new information like your tone just trying yeah I'm just trying to correct your attitude I I listen my attitude does not need me correcting and uh I don't re appreciate those tones um could I I apologize for my wardrobe malfunction I'm back and uh I'll just uh interrupt because I think it's been a long week and I'm going to take a deep cleansing breath and go on can I have a vote now on policy P 41181 one2 all those in favor please indicates by raising your hand saying I I I Andre are you voting three so we have

029three in favor none opposed none abstaining this motion is passed for second reading thank you have a good evening everyone thank you for getting the attorney on board oh to Denise have a good evening Denise that was unexpected and appreciated okay so we are now on p3113 setting budget priorities um what I have as the document that was sent to me is a one paragraph long uh setting budget priorities uh which included a recommendation made last time by Ian to start the uh to have a new beginning of the first sentence before adopting the budget comma and then it goes the Board of Education board and we have that document in front of us can I have a motion Irene go ahead Irene thank you um Matthew I have both policies set by side by

030side if you'd like me to share them s would you be kind enough to do that sure okay so you should be able to see on the left this was Ian's policy on the right is the C policy okay I'm I'm trying to feel my way on what the uh appropriate way to handle this is the document that was sent in the packet is the one that starts with the line in blue before adopting the budget so it is my intention unless somebody corrects me and says I'm mistaken that we should take a motion uh is this this is for a second reading or for first reading this this is already gone through the first reading okay so this be for second reading so then I would like to take my intention is to ask

031for a a motion to adopt uh the one that starts with before adopting the budget and for purposes of discussion and then we can discuss the contents of the two any other material any other member wants to bring forward or Administration is there any objection to that process well I believe the one on the right is the one that attorney Dugas had checked off on and said was accurate uh Susan that that is true but that is not what went out in the packet and therefore we cannot ask I we need to did that's the one I in the packet Matthew they both I think no I don't know that the other one did I have out yeah yeah um the 3113 that I'm looking at is the one on the right that came in

032the packet Matthew I think you may be thinking about 3120 where there's no it says I've got 3113 okay I've got this as your I think we receiv received that from I from you Matthew um later after after the packet went out oh that could be okay well then I I stand Matthew I can't see these I can't see these Eileen can you uh enlarge them I'm sorry it's okay yeah that's great thanks okay so what I'm hearing it just disappeared yeah that the one we have a mountain on the left the one that's on the right of the Mountain at the moment good okay that's a mountain I don't know what that is so let me find the other cave one I want to start with making a motion to adopt what was sent

033out in the packet and then from there we can make whatever amendments anybody wants to make I apologize I'm trying to find the one that was sent out in the package we will go on vacation to the mountain exactly then we just need to reopen it sorry just one moment I have too many Word documents open so I'm just going to close them so that we can just look at the two in a time that looks good that looks like it yes that's what I have okay so would somebody like to make a motion to uh pass this to approve this and pass it on for a second reading and if there's a motion in a sec and we will then discuss it you would you you're just moving to uh to discuss correct just

034moving to discuss okay oh Ian would you like to second that well I'm not sure with the word discuss as opposed to just approve as a second read um and then we can make all the discussions under that fine I move then make it as a motion to for second read second reading thank you for your for your comment all right fine so I'll second a motion to approve is second read okay um is there any discussion um I or anybody but I would invite anybody who's here to to participate in the discussion it's just again comma things like that so Erica can send it to me I'll put it in the comments okay Irene do you want to speak to it because I think we did review it and it was reviewed by Floyd

035correct it was um Matthew this was the one that you requested come back because you wanted to change some wording Matthew are you still with us I I'm still with you I'm reading it again uh my long-term memory is okay my shorter term memory is not as okay but that's life um I'm not quite sure whether it was the phrase before adopting the budget or if I had some other concern but as it stands now um there is nothing substantively in what is before us that is problematic to me so I do see that the black language was what we had originally and the new green is probably the update from CES is that right Irene correct that's correct and one of the things the last line says the Board of Education and collaboration with

036the superintendent shall initiate this process each year in September so I think that's also from the ad hoc committee they wanted to get it started even earlier so we did include that um and you know it's really the initiation of the priorities and the process start with the superintendent and administration and do include with supported by the board so the superintendent shall take into consideration the financial priorities and needs of the district with with the staff and involve the administrators um in its development and that's the part that we have been very much kneed deep and involved in probably since September October and um I think even the board recognized that and when our principles were before you you said tell us what you really what are your real needs and um we have you

037know put some of those to we have put those together for you all to see in in January so I thought that was a very important part um that needed to be added especially cons considering how the process actually works and Susan just to provide additional information so on an annual basis when the Board of Education sets its goals for the district for the year that's when you're also setting your budget priorities then we know marching forward from September on that we need to align the budget with the priorities as identified by the Board of Education and the superintendent it's to ensure that there aren't shifting priorities unless there's emergencies during the budget process after it starts thank you Irene Andrea Ian no I'm fine with it uh yeah no I'm fine with it as

038well as written it captures uh captures what needs to be captured and sets the groundwork for any uh regulation that's going to follow it I'm I'm content as well is there any additional conversation before we take a vote okay we're now going to take a vote on whether we're adopting p3113 setting budget priorities for a second reading all those in favor please indicate by saying I I I I so we have three in favor opposed none abstain this is approved for second reading thank you very much um I do have a question on regulations uh before we go on to 3120 please um typically Administration has shown us proposed regulations and asked for comment uh though it's clearly their purview U did you want to look at that now or come back at another time

039no I'll speak for Irene she's really like I said she's still wrapping up the audit and we at the same time we have a town review which while we've got some support on that that's still there and then we also have um the budget process so that's what our focus is and she said that when we can get to that after the budget process we will get to that and bring it back out of courtesy to share with you I'm only speaking for myself I'll ask my colleagues oh go ahead Ian I see your hand is up thank you um yeah that was my understanding as well based on a couple of emails exchanges that went back and forth or uh that uh all regulation discussion um and review you know presentation or review was

040going to happen in March of 2025 uh after we clear the budget um giving the administration the time they need to yeah appreciate that and also the ad hoc committee did uh you know put forth some draft documents um as far as like what we thought would make for good regulations now of course uh admin's not bound to that but it is there as a suggestion or an outline or a framework to start the discussion thank you thank you Andrea so Erica is just going to send me the I have to apologize I dropped these this morning and I'm I don't know where things are so Erica is going to send me the regulations and then I'll send that to Matthew and we'll see where okay if you have any comments send them send it

041to me with a copy to Ian as well yeah okay yeah okay oh and probably send them to Susan as well she could she I don't know she'd be interested in or not but we'll send it to her anyway I always do so um so we'll move on we'll move on thank you for this we'll move on now to uh 3120 do you have that one to Irene to put up H yes iene we took out of schools here uh did we want to uh start talking about this now or or make a move uh a motion and open it for discussion and then had discussion I'll I'll make a motion to approve uh p3120 as a second read coming out of committee I'll second that so uh Irene did you want to uh make

042some comments believe there's much changes we discussed this one last time as well I believe so some of these strikeouts um were from Floyd so instead of referencing specific sections in town Charter he's just indicating the chapter the reason why is if at any point the sections change the numbering when the charters updated then we don't have to come back and redo the policy and the green again is C and the blue was the S was a suggestion I think from Ian right correct U well okay so yeah the the green was sort of mix of cab and the ad hoc committee um and then the blue is the paragraph that um I wanted to to see reinserted but this also this paragraph did come from the ad hoc committee um and was the paragraph

043yeah the blue paragraph um so that's basically the main uh that's that's the reason why 3120 came back to committee was was cuz uh the the majority of the board um to my recollection said that they were in support of this paragraph in principle however they just wanted to make sure that it was uh reviewed um for you know legal and linguistic concerns did we have Floyd look at this Irene I Can't Remember yes Floyd did look at it and indicated the blue paragraph is not legal is is not legal he said it was your right it was it was just uh granular he didn't say anything about legal or not legal no I believe we have it in writing that it's not legal do you have that document and can you project it I'll

044have to find it I don't have it readily available for tonight because the notes that I had with uh with Floyd uh he said that uh it was just seemed granular um but was and and possibly more in the Arena of Regulation but Ian could you help us to understand what was the purpose of the paragraph can you explain you know what what had occurred that you really wanted to um prevent I mean if there was an issue that happened I'm I'm just not sure yes there were a few issues in last year's budget meeting or budget deliberations where we are given uh in particular in regards to the nurses um situation where we're given information anecdotally in in a meeting and uh was were given that as guidance like as a way for us

045to like determine what we're going to do with our budget and uh after the fact um and we did make decisions based on that information um and then after the fact um after we passed our our approv budget um new information came to light that there was actually a good bit of uh contention about that issue and uh that you know there there was a strong desire for that we probably should have known that there was some interest in cutting that budget item out of the and put it into the board uh and that was not communicated um clearly to the majority of the board uh at the time when we could have done something about it um that's the most explicit case and there's and and that kind of just left us in my

046opinion uh kind of hanging out over our skis um so the the the goal with this paragraph from the ad hoc committee was that we would find a way to formalize anything that is given to the board as guidance um that is coming from like Town staff any sort of communication that's coming from external sources uh through a person typically through the chair or the uh superintendent to the board and being given to us as guidance for forming our budget that there would be some documentation to back it up so that we could rest assured knowing that we have a firm understanding of what it was that was intended to be communicated as guidance from The Source um that's the main concern um and so I'm open to suggestion on ways to tweak it but

047again the consensus of the board at the last meeting was that a lot of a lot of folks wanted to see something like this in this policy as a principle that we would follow um so that we didn't end up in a situation again where we're depending on you know one person's interpretation of a conversation that happened verbally um The Hope was that you know if there were verbal conversations that there would be an email or something afterwards to memorialize that where the person who was on the other end of that communication would have a chance to verify that that indeed was what was intended to be communicated through that third party to the board I think there were some emails though that were shared with the whole board too communication they came after it

048was after the fact M it came this came out later I don't know Beverly with your expertise what are you thinking about this is Beverly online I don't see her face or yeah I'm here I'm here I'm listening I'm here I'm listening um I don't what did Floyd said is not legal I believe so I have to look at my document and I don't have that with me tonight he either said it wasn't it was you know he said a lot of it's granular it's regulation or it's there were a couple things he said that were not legal but I don't know if it it was particularly this one I mean I think for transparency it's important I mean there oftentimes that I have something that comes up and I will talk to my board

049chair and you know and then you usually the advice is to forward the information to the whole board so I try to to give that out um but there's a lot of times that when we meet it's a meeting that is um not recorded but I usually when I go to any meetings it's usually with other people you know other directors as well so um and you know not everything we talk about is then passed on to the board it could be just every day kind of you know getting updates on Audits and that kind of thing yeah but I believe Ian's um to Ian's point it's specific to budget related matters right so that wouldn't apply um and I don't have conversations with um d as far as the percentage increases that are not

050disclosed to you as part of that budget process so I'm not opposed to this uh if it's just for Budget reasons it's fine with me as long as it's fine with Floyd I'm G to go back to whatever Floyd says really but it's fine with me I can double check with Floyd I I do have the docum on Ian Andre's had her hand up for a little while recognize you as soon as she's done Andrea yeah I'm I'm not fine with this this is something that I know it's in the bud in the uh budget section however you know this kind of thing can spill over like there could be a lot of different conversations that just occur somebody could tell a lie about a board member and somebody else could never pass that on

051you know we could be getting into places that don't want to get to with this and this could spill over into other areas of policy and I I'm not fine with this at all uh Ian then Bev then I'll take a turn um well I would just uh I can understand Andrea's concern and and um but I would call attention to the first sentence that says board members and administration are required to report any Communications that they have with Town officials regarding any budget planning related matters you know so that's very specific to the budget it's in the budget if any of these communications are intended to be used as guidance upon which the board is expected to act the and again that's like because it's if it's given to us as guidance then I

052think that carries a little more weight what people talk about whe where they're going for lunch or whatever that is of absolutely no concern um this is all about like if there's specific information that is being passed through a third party to the board um that's going to be used as gu a guidance that we're going to make decisions based upon that's the main concern with this and also uh Matthew I did find the document uh Floyd's email where he had his uh bullet points so um if I I'm more than willing to share my screen to to project that out so people could see uh what his comments were on this on this um on this policy I'd like to hear from Bev and Andre is your hand up again no iess I guess

053okay I'd like to hear from from Bev and I'd like to say a little something and then I'll come back and and uh if you want to put it up that's fine yeah go go ahead be okay thank you Matthew again I like to hear from Floyd uh from Irene's conversation with Floyd if she can get us that information what he told Irene I know what he told us but what he told Irene my other question is okay um if I'm if I'm at a function and I run into um Jill Russ and she says hey B don't come in with a budget for more than 2% I'm not going to put that in the email that that wasn't a formal conversation that was just I mean I was at a party and she was

054there and we just started talking about it so I just want to make that clear that you know that won't be part of an email that I'm sending out because that wasn't a formal conversation I had with the town counselor or anybody else that's just my perspective so otherwise if it's a formal meeting that I'm having with John and uh Susan and whoever else it's a formal meeting I'm not opposed I wouldn't I myself wouldn't be opposed to sending out an email saying uh we met and this is what happened at the meeting as far as the budget is concern thank you okay I'll take a turn uh I had hoped to speak at the meeting last board meeting but I was sick and didn't make it because as I read this document uh three

055of the paragraphs if I found very troubling um I guess I'll focus on the one in the middle since that's what we're talking about uh when I look at a document I look at three things I look at the content I look at the tone and I look at the language I support the intent the content to uh report substantive communic I'm I'm not going to try to Wordsmith this now but just just just speaking from from the heart I support the idea that that s substantive conversations with other officials need to be shared with the board through the chair and the chair will determine if it gets sent on to the rest of the board this whole process of governance is based on some level of trust and we have a process and the

056process is that information throw flows through the chair maybe that's the worst process in the world but I haven't seen a better so Matthew if like I'd like to continue I use my train of thought uh the tone of this can easily be construed as one of distrust as required to any any all any these these words they are lexically accurate to the intent that's intended there's nothing wrong with with them lexically but in aggregate they convey a terrible sense of distrust and I don't think that that's what I mean I don't think that's what Ian had in mind so I think the language there needs some serious working I'll go back up to the first paragraph School representatives of the community students certified non-certified staff if by this we mean people Representatives community Through

057the period where we have public comment through emails or phone calls to the members through letters uh that's fine but that's not what it says students if we mean that through the student Representatives that's fine but that's not what it says certified and non-certified staff If this means that it's through the process of the various union leaders getting their members opinion which they pass on to the superintendent which and Andor the this the chair that's fine but if it means a free-for-all where everybody's going to set up new committees with lots of representatives from these it's dysfunctional because this is the superintendent's budget it's not our budget we take it when it's given to us now go to the last paragraph it's not a budget document policy all board meetings are public meetings the public

058is encouraged to attend all of that's true but that's our policy that's in our already stated in our in our Pol in our excuse me in our communication policy explicitly and also in the communication plan uh if you want to make a referral to strengthen a Comm a communication plan by all means do it I'll look very favorably as an incoming member it doesn't belong here this has nothing to do with budget other than that I think it's great I don't want to the superintendent budget development process turned into a political process the superintendent and her staff are the professionals we hired there's plenty of time for the public to weigh in on the proposed superintendent's budget formally and informally I've been wrong before I may be wrong now but I I'm I'm concerned about

059this document as it is I can't vote for it as it is okay who's next is it Ian or you next oh Andrea's hands been up before mine but oh yeah I just want to uh go back to what Beverly said and um to to talk about uh the implications of this uh language in terms of the example that Beverly gave that's all that I had to say uh Ian B okay so uh to address your concerns on the first paragraph Matt um the last sentence kind of wraps it up and and can so the procedure for such involvement shall be developed by the superintendent and implemented by the superintendent's office following review by the Board of Ed that empowers the superintendent to to determine how they collect that input so the superintendent could just

060just as easily say you know what I'm just going to go off of what already's been documented through letters emails pre-existing public hearings on various other things and other public comments that I've heard all year long to determine um because that's the that's the budget document that's the superintendent's job to figure that out all this all the paragraph is trying to communicate is that efforts need to be made to take those components into consideration which is already natural part of the process and the superintendent could easily just we already have a lot of this information coming in through the natural pre-existing reporting channels and the public comments that have been available all year long so I don't see this is mandating any creation of any committees unless the superintendent because the power is is put

061in the superintendent's hands with that last sentence so if the superintendent decides they want to go that route that's up to them um but chances are that's not going to be the case because there's already a lot of input already coming in through all these other sources all throughout the year um so I mean and in this language uh did if memory serves that kind of came mostly from c um right it one of those areas where the committee's draft and the cab draft lined up pretty well um and as far as the uh last paragraph again that also came straight out of the cave draft um I the committee draft I don't think had that in there or if it did it was only because it was a vestigal limb from the pre-existing draft

062of the of this policy um that last sentence is again just kind of boilerplate um take it or leave it I'm not attached to it like you said it's already implied and it's already noted and stated in various other aspects of the policy document um as for the third paragraph I am open to word smithing that paragraph to tighten it up in such a way that it is becomes very targeted towards formal budget guidance Communications um I can understand the concerns uh expressed by some of my colleagues there um and yeah CU see you know maybe it the language could be you know tightened up so as with everything that no no draft is ever final you just have to stop editing it at some point so um I could see something like board members

063in administration are required to report any Communications that are intended to be used as guidance upon which the board is expected to act in relation to the budget so Matthew I'm not able to raise my hand because I'm sharing the screen so I lost that task bar Irene please um the Ian's correct that very first paragraph and the last paragraph those are both directly from cab and um where this is getting at the needs of the school representative the community student certified and non-certified staff that's discussions that they have with the principles about what they need and the principles put forward Susan and their recommendations so everybody is pretty much already involved in that budget process it's not indicating what we're going to create a new committee or subcommittees to try and have like a

064internal administrative budget committee that's that's not what we're doing at all um so you and you are correct that that is already what is taking place as a natural part of doing the budget for the blue section now that I know what we're looking to achieve I can reach out to Floyd and see how we can um rephrase that paragraph because I can let them know what the intent is and why I would appreciate that thank you Beverly thank you thank you Irene Beverly thank you Irene um can you go back to the first paragraph because maybe we can tighten up that sentence in the first paragraph to make the budget a comprehensive reflection of financial needs of the student uh representatives of the community because it does seem you could interpret it like Matthew

065said that you're going to have that you're can to have committees and that the community is going to actually come in and sit down and and talk about the budget or the students or so maybe we can tighten up that sentence a little bit where it doesn't make it seem like it's going to be committees that we can be more explicit of what we what we actually mean what you said Irene that Susan's already doing that and it's through the administration through the principles that all that comes into place we also had this year especially we have two um open um sessions public hearings and that's another great way that we hear from the community when they come to speak my because otherwise that sentence is kind of confusing to me my concern is not

066with the intent my concern is that the words say yeah exactly that that's all to to me the budget is a comprehensive reflection of the needs of the school system there's a period that goes there the board will take into consideration the needs of of the various stakeholders uh through a variety of methods you know I lost you there m consideration the the input from a variety of from from a from our stakeholders yeah I like that from stakeholders from our Stak holders in the process the actually it's the superintendent because it's the superintendent's budget well I would say that once I propose it or once I project what I think it's gonna be it becomes our thing to work on yeah the your thing when you vote on it uh you're talking about what

067you mean I'm talking about what the word say the superintendent is responsible for the direct Pro pre prepar preparation of the recommended annual school budget take out the second superintendent sorry first responsible not shall be is is shall forever will be responsible for the preparation of the recommended annual School of her recommended annual school budget oh don't don't say her Matthew just say the the recommended annual school budget the recommended annual school budget thank you take out that superintendent appreciate that we're striking all of this I would uh humbly suggest that we um where you have stakeholders in the maybe just eliminate representatives of and just like let that be in the community and then comma students certified comma and that way kind of Blends like that that's what we wanted it that's what we

068would hope the superintendent would capture in drafting their budget would be like all that input that already is pre-existing and coming through the other funnels I hope Andrea will be proud of me we just put input from Community stakeholders well I can I can say this to be true when we had the liaison meeting last year and I heard loud and clear that the expectation from our community was to you know uh Sunset all of those our bester funds that was one of the major things in my consideration so it does it does help to hear from the public whether it's the liaison committee or its parents or you know Administration or you all so that is all in there you know when I think about the process so I'll make another thing to tighten

069up it a little bit more the second sentence that's highlighted and read this budget process will take into consideration and a period at the end of Staff we in lie of the superintendent will take into consideration the process will take into consideration this budget process will take into consideration input input from the Comm from Community stakeholders do it certified staff ad and administrative staff period yeah that sounds good that sounds good Matthew what do you all think no okay no how realistic is that I mean everybody go ahead I was just saying it already happens it's already been happening yeah well yeah and and informally and all that but you know when you're going to say you're going to take into consideration this one and that one and all these people and then they're going

070to say well I said and and this group said and it's not you got you got $2 million or whatever it is however many million dollars you got to to work with and that's that you know and there's buses to be paid and electricity to be paid and it's it's not realistic you know it's implicit that we do that but actually stated you I I could never I could never vote for that go ahead bever what why don't we say we'll try to take into consideration input from the and that may address some of your concerns Andrea if somebody comes in and says well I want to pool at the high school I mean that's not going to happen because like you said we do have bills to pay so uh well attempt very good

071Matthew there you go that makes more sense to me uh I I listen I I just want to say that taking into consideration does not mean it's going to immediately Grant consideration just means it's been noted and involved in the conversation whether or not it actually makes it through is another another like that that's it like that that gets decided one way or the other but like just take consider I think take into consideration I think that gets a little bit wordy and clunky but well the budget process will consider input that solves that a lot takes out three words well consider yeah I mean because consider does not mean we're gonna confer you know consider just means okay we heard that concern and now we're going to think about it weigh it with this

072other cost benefit analysis and that thing and then maybe it comes out on the other side the way they like maybe it doesn't but either way we're just acknowledging the fact that we're looking back on all past or the superintendent is going to be looking back on all the past years worth of of input coming from all these different sources why don't we just say that we're going to instead of that we're going to take into consideration why don't we just say that we're that in even in another place that that there are going to be uh public budget hearings because I think that's what what we have in mind anyway you know there there there are places where very very good Andrea the budget process will include public forums to hear Community stakeholders blah

073blah blah period yeah to hear from yeah public hearings right do we call Process will include public hearings yeah it's me yes includ public hearings to hear from Community stakeholders Bravo Andrea oh my god well that's exactly what we do right Andrea yeah yeah I'm just I'm just laughing at when the Lord gives you something to say you better say it are we striking the rest of this yeah they're all stakeholders yeah I just don't want this to turn into to a a a contentious political process so then we're striking this I'm just I I I don't know I just I'm I'm I'm confused as to like how I don't see how that's coming out of this this was all boilerplate Cape stuff um and uh you know I thought it was nice to have

074the acknowledgement of those different groups since we hear from those groups in different ways all throughout the year that's that was the thought of having those listed out is so that if does review the policy we're stating it that is a priority for us to at least check in you know but the only thing is that I don't want to leave anybody out so I hear your point Ian but I'm thinking well parents aren't in thereon group isn't in there you know there's others that when you say community stakeholders it it's all people that we serve that was my fear that if you if you leave some without by stating by naming them and if you leave somebody out you're in trouble you can always say included but not limited too but so let me

075ask a question about the next sentence because I'm not clear on that remember I said that uh it was talking about possibly thinking that committees were going to be formed or might be formed and that was sparked by the word procedure for such involvement um that that's just that is this that is what the superintendent does along with the chair she's she consults with the chair on this if if you think that's necessary I'm willing to consider it I just don't see that it's necessary I thought we had a pretty good Draft when we had just the uh take into consideration Community stakeholders comma everybody else we could have thrown a phrase in community stakers stakeholders including but not limited to um procedure again that that last sentence was just that came from cab and

076it just means like if the superintendent for whatever reason in a given year maybe wants to do something different that that that procedure is up to them to uh present to the board and and then carry on with so I mean it could the board has anything to do hey Matthew what about the second sentence to make the budget a comprehensive reflection of the financial needs of the school system is that a sentence or does that go something else okay to make the budget a compehensive put a comma it will include okay comma there the budget process that's good but then we have public hearings to hear from that's a little redundant uh so we should get rid of that to hear from yeah public hearings for Community stakeholders including but not limited to and

077if we want to throw in y parents and Guardians parents/guardians I'm fine with that if we want to cover that base the word four should be inserted thank you even why don't you just end public hearings that that includes everybody everybody yeah that's true that's true that includes everybody Susan what about the word multiple public hearings well we do have them this year but I don't know if we can say that we're gonna have them every year but I would say if you just say including public hearings because even even the liaison group does that is that's open to the public so really anything that we do is open to the public but to hear from the public is a different story right it's only in certain occasions that we can do that so okay

078Matthew don't say too much just let itars who's doing the typing who's doing the typing doing the typing Irene all right are you adding stuff Irene pardon go ahead go ahead Andrea no I said your name wrong and I apologize that's all that's okay yeah just just just hand it a hearings it's implic okay is everybody okay with them I am so what is the review of the Board of Education of the superintendent's budget doesn't that review come after the budget is presented to us oh yeah does it ever you've seen that list of of dates and times that we're going to be getting together the next two months yeah so I'm I'm wondering what the procedure for preparation of your budget not the final budget your oh okay to we what is following review

079by the board of education do in the formulation of your budget um I I think there may be a slight misinterpretation of that sentence it's procedure for such involvement originally the sentence before that said the budget process would involve getting input from those groups so that phrase procedure for such involvement is referring back to the process of involving taking in of involving input coming from Community stakeholders students certified staff all those people listed if we're taking all that out then this sentence may just be moot at this point because it's not referring back we've cut out what it was referring to you lost me we've cut out what that sentence refers to the procedure for involving the public of all those stakeholders that we had listed out are is no longer there it's no longer

080it's just now we just have to make the budget a comprehensive reflection the budget process will include public hearings done that's it beyond beyond the public public hearings what what are we going to do differently for the budget process with the public than we already do this was just again this came from cab and it was just a the way I read it it was a formalized uh formalizing of there is a formal acknowledgement of that level of input coming from the community and that there the superintendent would take that information in by whatever procedure they deemed most effective and that they would share that procedure with the board at some point that's the way I read that paragraph The Way It Was Written prior to all these edits correct that's That's How It Was

081Written say again correct that's the purpose was how we were going to reach out to all the different stakeholders right so then that that made this last sentence sort of the the Capstone to say like the procedure for such involvement would be developed by the superintendent and implemented after a review by the board of V so like if we're now defining the process by saying it's going to include public hearings then this last sentence no longer matters and for the record like I I I would rather just go back to the way it was with a couple little tweaks to say included not limited to and you know some of the the first couple edits I was fine with the rest of this I think we've gone far field of what the intention of the

082the the paragraph Was the the intention of the paragraph the way I read it was to allow broad latitude for the super intended to determine how they're going to take input in from all these stakeholders uh to create the proposed budget um and that might change from year to year depending on you know know certain concerns so I'm not I'm not he I'm not hearing I'm I'm missing something you're saying Ian I'm I'm not challenging you I'm simply missing it beyond the public hearings I don't think see any public input channels that we're not already doing right I'm saying like this this this policy was just a formality that paragraph was just a formality to memorialize it in writing of what we commonly do already and that's the way I read the C draft that

083where that language came from um so I mean I don't I don't I guess I I was confused as to see like so much concern addressed to it it seemed to me a very straightforward paragraph with maybe just a couple of tweaks to it the intent the intent was clear the the words were less clear uh you might want to put in to to accommodate your your concerned for naming the stakeholders uh we could put in a sentence and say a uh a special effort will be made to reach out to and Community stakeholders including but not limited to again and then we're going back to where we started um the less you say the less you say the more you say you're G to get in trouble with this but now we're saying nothing

084besides just now now it just says it's limited to now it's just public hearings which doesn't really identify the whole previous year's worth of citizens petitions and letters emails uh focus groups liaison meetings all the things that happened throughout the year already would have been all opportunities to take input in performing the budget that's all this that's all the previous par the previous edition of the paragraph was intended to do was to just identify that and allow the superintendent to to identify that as their procedure that's the way I read it that's why I had no problem with the way it was written save for a couple of phrases here and there um would it be can I make a suggestion Irene can you say save this or can you get the other one up

085side by side with this one or is that impossible start changing it I think I have a word that might help what if we deleted include and put in um I'm sorry I can't move it it's not letting me gonna see the mountain again well we might not be able to say the whole thing but at least it kind of marks it side by side so we can hear Ian and you know I I do like maybe we can give examples of or maybe we put those examples in the regulations here are some of the things that the district does because I I am hearing what Ian is saying about there's so much that goes into this right I might be sitting with a group of Juniors and seniors who talk to me during budget

086season and I usually do those focus groups and they tell me specifically some of the things that they definitely want to you know keep having or that were really valuable to them and and or I see parents and they talk to me about certain things that they they like they don't like and board members do the same thing in the community so sometimes it's very informal how you're gathering information sometimes it's a written letter or an email um it could be something that c comes up in one of our surveys like we've got this strategic planning going on and the parents are saying some really good stuff we'll be sharing with you once we close it out so um I I agree that there's so many different ways and it's hard to capture them all

087but they all go into you know what are the needs of the district and some of them there's not a lot of wiggle room because those contracts are the contracts and we're going to pay what we're going to pay right for 85% of the budget but there's some other things that you know we have Liberty to change or rearrange and um we're getting that Community input all the time I know that's long Ed but I don't know what's the best way to say IE here's a couple things or to put it in regulations um we definitely know that we have the public hearings but then what are some of the other definite things that we're doing if we policy is law regulations can be changed if we took out the word include and put in

088the instead the verb solicit would that help but it might it might be unsolicited right that's unsolicited we have no control over unsolicited we do have control over soliciting broad input from the various stakeholders Susan I agree that we should put it in our regulation how we are receiving input y right you're here I think we need to say something about receiving input from members of our community um yeah to that end I would say maybe go back to the original version and just put in include shall be shall include but not be limited to the list that we had and then you know leave it as is you know leave it in that in that form um go that the public hearing shall include but not limited to the public hearing Community stakeholders and

089then students staff the rest of the list why don't we just turn in regulations that makes perfect sense yeah policy guides regulations though so I thought it was good to have this paragraph which kind of stakes the the principle under which the regulations are going to operate we're clearly guiding we're clearly guiding regulations if they put in what we asked them to do so what do you want me to put in here we go back to in both gearings or who's driving minimize the document on the right for a moment document on right is the C policy the one on the left is the one that we've been changing that's in highlight the only thing is um on the the policy on the right talks about administrated staff and I can't see the rest noncertified

090certified staff and the one on the left is only talking about public hearings but I I can go with Susan where she could put that in the regulations um but the public hearing is not so much administrative staff or or certified staff I mean even though they can come to the public hearing but I know Susan when she develops the budget talks to the principals and they get their feedback from the teachers and whoever else they get the feedback from so right I don't know and and we all agree that we think that it should be included somewhere I'm hesitant uh reluctant to to have it in the policy but in the regulations as as long as it's there um as long as it's said I I think that Susan a suggestion is the way

091to go well and if we're saying that we want to gather input from our constituents right we could in the regulation say some examples of this are and we could list some examples but not limited to because one year we might come up with the whole new idea that we could as long as it's Gathering that information um and I think it's solicited or unsolicited I mean you get it both ways you get it in written form you get it you know when you're out in the community so you have you know I'm not going to be your superintendent all for always but you'll want a superintendent who's very responsive and and does listen and pays attention to what the community is saying right [Music] yeah I agree with that assessment and and but I

092mean again like the way I read the paragraph the original uh paragraph you know like I said we could throw in the phrase included but not limited to and also like throwing public hearings there you know just as examples I thought it was good to have examples in the policy um because policy does guide regulations in that sense um but I don't know I mean I you know because if we take all that out then there's going to be basically no first paragraph here and nothing's even like talking about like this you know how does a budget document come to be like policy does this policy existed prior to this with a paragraph that was very similar to what was what was suggested here um you know the the original version of 3120 had a

093paragraph like this it was just you know a statement of of purpose um and intent but then I don't know I mean I you know we can put whatever up for a vote and vote on it I mean I I I was fine with the original paragraph you know at with with a couple of tweaks to make it you know non-specific and not mandating any committees I'm okay to say an example of this is the um public hearings but it's not limited to that there are other examples too right because that's the one that stands out to me you know yeah uh Irene is there any way to put that um the right hand document up and edit that one a little bit um just I want to just try something out and see if

094maybe that we kind of split the middle here okay uh to make the budget a comprehensive reflection of the financial needs of the school system all right so um comma the budget process shall include public hearings comma shall include but not be oh sorry okay shall include comma but not be limited to comma sorry uh back before public hearings shall include but not be limited to public hearings input from Representatives or actually you know what community stakeholders get rid of Representatives of the community just do community stakeholders input from Community stakeholders students certified not and then and then we can get rid of um put the period after administrative staff and get rid of shall be involved in budget process um you want to put parents in there sure about parents care or parents/guardians then

095comma students you You're Gonna Lose leave leave somebody out and it's going to be a problem well we got included but shall include but not be limited to public hearings public hearings says it all so put a com after include I mean I would just propose something like something like that could be not be limited well we still have uh remind you we still have another four things to do yeah and uh it is 6:40 p.m so we're going to keep working through this but gives consideration as to if you want to continue I suggest we'll take a five or eight minute break so people can get some coffee or or something to snack on so the thing I like about this is that it's broad-based enough and we know we do these public hearings

096and we know we want to gather information from our community stakeholders and all these others um yeah but that that's it's not limited to Justice exactly so I think I think it gets the message through that we're going to be open and responsive to our community in setting these there's going to be 85% of it is going to be based on country contract right but the other things um are based on you know what is the Mission Vision and goal of the district and a lot of the board's you know ex expectation when I'm doing this but then it also you know being open to other suggestions or other priorities right Y and put that put that in regulations yes exactly in regulations right I think we're good as we are right now with this

097paragraph As written after the word public hearings as well as input from sure yep that's good I like that bridge um and comma after hearings and um no it's not it should not be limited to public hearings there's no comma after two no that's that's an a positive phras like that's but shall include but not be limited to public hearings as well as input public hearings is is one thing and then as well as input input can apply to community stakeholders input can apply to parents Guardians so input connects to everything after that in the series The Challenge is they're going to be talking programmatically and we're talking financially and sometimes do doesn't matter that's not our concern all they do all we need as far as I'm concerned the intent of this paragraph is

098just to broadly announce to the public that we are open inclusive and constantly seeking input from all different sources and uh and then like we can get more granular in the regulation but I feel like this this gives the super great latitude towards uh how they want to bring in input I'll never I'll never vote for that that that stuff needs to be in the regulations not in the policy okay Susan what do you think Susan is this good in the policy or do you think I you know I understand concept I understand the concept of wanting to say that in this process we do take into consideration um our community stakeholders I mean and and really needs to follow through maybe on regulations right so what do you suggest with this sentence well if

099we could could I could I are we done I I want to hear from Susan if you don't mind Ian let her finish up please I just wanted to figure out where we're what she was going to comment on which one are we talking about I'm still on the first paragraph thank you um suing your tongue tired I know I'm rereading it from start to finish and I'm getting tired let's see yeah the what if if I'm saying that it's a reflection of the financial needs of the school district and it the budget process shall also include um you know what know what you all should do this my suggestion just table this think about it and come back again and talk about it I mean unless you're going to be talking about the same

100policy for the next well I think the the the the goal here is to get this back to the board on the seventh now right I know but we already have well all this and the other policies I knows it has to come back to policy because we have to tweak the language with Floyd um yeah so why don't you just think about it and come back with something instead of keep going it has to go back to Floyd anyway so right think about what you want to do and come back with it I mean we already have public hearings and we already we already take into considerations what the students say and the staff say so it's not anything that we're not doing or right that's true Beverly right I mean it's up to

101you mat is your committee I'm trying to give you guys as much latitude as you want I'm [Music] not I think we've beaten it to death and I think Beverly's right that we have to get a step away from it think about it is there any objection I mean we do have four others to do tonight yeah we know we have to come back to this so let's move on to the other I would definitely recommend that blue language coming out but I think we need to pass it by Floyd first so this one let's put off the table for now all right and and to just follow up on the blue language you know from what I understood Irene like you you were going to uh now that we had some discussion about what

102the intent was having like budget guidance Communications that's the main purpose of that I'll discuss it with um Floyd to see how we put something in there that gets to what um we're trying to achieve right and and and yes I wouldn't want to see it go away completely I'd like to see something in there that's like some modified version that is yeah right I agree with your intent I agree agree that's sound like to do I think that's what we're trying to think about to in the first paragraph if you get the intent out there in the right way and let's not be driven by a date let's be driven by the policy thank you okay shall we move on to 3310 um do you have to move to table does anybody need a

103does anybody need a five minute break um yeah I think we do need to move a t like uh well yeah I guess we have to move to table um go ahead all right so I'll withdraw my motion to approve as a second read and I believe I seconded that I'll accept your motion and we will table oh no that was just the motion to all right everyone just walked away have a nice cup of coffee see you in a few minutes all right well go on the table just so we know okay oh I didn't know that no way e e e the call you still there Adrien ready when you are great thank you well set thank you well we three are back hope we're not the witches of lendor I was gonna

104say procedurally I think what we need to do is I need to withd draw the motion to approve and then we make a motion to table but um are we back on are we doing this are we going to talk about this or we can certainly do that [Music] recorded I guess the recording is still on recording is still on thank you so why don't you make your motion to withdraw well um I was just taking some time to think about it and and if I do that and then if we have to run this language back through Floyd again and has to go back through policy again we're looking at a policy committee meeting in January that might get preempted by budget sessions or may not um so it starts to like so the

105next time this could see a vote would be the regular meeting at the end of January if we approve this as a second read in the next policy it certainly isn't my desire that we wait that long but as myself the I ask myself the question is I think we've been clear enough is what we want and Susan has has heard all of that um I'll use my word uh Susan's indicated that a once it's passed it becomes immediately the practice the question is are you comfortable enough is there anything in here that's that that that needs to be passed before then I mean is there's something that that particular we're going to get to it again we're going to get it's just like to me not the time frame that we would like but

106yeah we're we're basically we're tending towards a situation where this 3120 is going to end up in you know not passing until uh after the budget session is over is over like I'm looking I don't think so it'll be after we well may be at the end of January but is there any what what is not what what would not happen by not passing it until then so Matthew I think the concern is that um that blue paragraph that I need to tweak with Floyd that we need to make sure we have something in there so that we don't wind up with the nurse's situation again and if I I just share can we pass it without that paragraph for now and then come back to it and amended after the budget session without that

107paragraph if I promise you bring it back for for a review once we know what Floyd says we can amend it well in my opinion you have Floyd says right here though too that it should again Susan that's not the most recent responses from oh okay so there's something else that I have not seen right okay well that that would be good to know well you're cced on this one on the one that's projected yeah yeah but Mar just said that there's another communication regarding this paragraph that has not been shared with the policy committee it's it's Floyd's feedback when we sent him several of the policies to review again um it's Floyd's feedback that was um I believe copied to suan I again I don't have the email with me to look at because

108this is the I went through my emails this is the last one I could find that had his feedback in it yeah there's more there's more responses from him later all right well that's frustrating to to to know that those Communications were happening and not being shared with this committee uh since we're I don't think it was the intention not to share it I don't even know right if I could find it on my email I can look and then share it with you I find I'm happy to share it was um we were asked to go back and put in Cape and provide an update so those were the ones were shared with Floyd and then he provided feedback on those okay is that something that could be forwarded over just so I can

109kind of get up to speed on where everybody is yes I can send it to Matthew like I'll try to do it in the next two days um trying to have a budget for you by the sixth no apprciate that's our top priority right now oh yeah basically what's the priority the the copy of the email or the budget so but I will share I have no problem sharing that information um I don't know in my opinion like the reason why I'm I'm focused on the third paragraph is because I believe that that would that's a substantial change and it's one that I think was clearly supported by uh consensus from the board uh so that something I I was taken as a personal priority to bring something back to them as soon as possible

110so that we just get this thing done my my one my understanding between the lines of what I've been hearing you say Irene is that you're going to ask Floyd if he can find a way confirm or deny that I'm getting this right that you're going to ask Floyd to uh draft some language that would accomplish the goal in a tone uh in a in a way that is legal and in a tone that is support corre other request yes now that I know the intent I will follow up with him on that and if it needs to be a 15 minute special policy meeting before a budget Workshop that works too okay I'm I'm I'll good with that if we if we could just I'm just eager to get this thing settled and and

111done I think we feel the same way Ian I agree with you we we want this you know for this okay to have this all this ready we agree we're all back let let's called the the the meeting uh is back in session we are we're back in session I thought when we had conversation pardon I said I thought we were back in session with that whole conversation well I want to move us I want to move us to 3310 it is now 7 o' well then let me let me I'll make my motion to withdraw um this uh for the purpose of tabling it until time proper make that a friendly motion by accepting it since I seconded that so it's been withdrawn can I have a motion to table this motion so moved

112all those in favor please say I I I I the motion to table is three to Zer to Zer this I this 3120 is tabled we're now on to 3310 iene would you be able to put them up on the screen uh yes I apologize I had 3160 next but I can 3160 oh that's that's F on our agenda okay so let me get 3310 up one moment okay so this is the purchasing guidelines for goods and services uh we struck guidelines because the prior policy was procedural in nature that why everything is stricken out in red um and I am already working on a draft for the regulation because there's several things that are not missing in or that are missing even in this as far as Soul Source procurement how we decide who

113gets awarded bids Etc it'll have that level of detail in it so what we did is we um Incorporated the cave updated information and and the green sections here in the first line uh Irene it should just say District capitalized instead of school district yeah just District capitalized would somebody like to make a motion for purposes of discussion this is uh motion by Andrea I'll second the motion all those in favor please indicate by saying I I I any opposed any abstained okay I'm going to abstain on this one for a minute okay well I just I'll just abstain actually sorry okay okay well we're open for discussion who would like to begin so I thought we just voted no we have we have a motion to uh it was a a motion was made

114to send this to the board now we're going to discuss whether we want to do it you are correct Ian I miss the misstep the misstep was mine and asking for a vote on a motion that was the error is completely mine okay sorry uh so that's shoot me all I ask is that you shoot straight and don't make me suffer all right so that vote was invalidated we're not doing that that vote was that vote was invalidated that was a motion to uh bring this up for discussion got it okay um I'll jump in I tired yeah uh yeah so I mean I I don't have any uh significant quibbles with this as written but it is different than what was put forth out of the committee um and also um different from what

115some of the cave language is not in this draft that did come from c um and I was just doing a bit of a cross reference here um but I don't think it changed the uh substance do what's being said so you yeah yeah if you recall we at at the board meeting recently um you did approve unan unanimously about the the threshold so there is another purchasing one that has already been approved by the board this just starts to outline how we reframe from entering into contracts um it's it gets more to the ethical sentence that's from cab um that we refrain from entering into contracts with or purchasing goods or services from any firm or individual who has sales representative or owner on the board if we come into a situation like that

116because you know we are we are a smaller community and um in that particular case that board member would just need to excuse themselves from any type a vote remove themselves from the table that's the clean way to do it that way if we award a contract that particular person's not involved in that vote and is that something we put in regulations to explain it better yes I think we have something in the 9,000 Series which uh States uh discusses ethical behavior of boards of board we do but that also needs to be updated that's one of my March items because it's not not only board but it what we're missing is staff for disclosure of any financial interest so that one again is a March rework okay yeah this does say the Board of

117Ed or its agents so that could include staff right yes but we'll make it very clean in the 90001 we'll have a disclosure form that would go on file if um with human resources and their personnel file and uh the reason for striking out all the definitions procedure that's all regulation stuff where you got the terms and definitions exactly so you're going to see this come back in the regulation where you're going to see it all like not stricken out and then the procedure itself um needs to be updated to be in accordance with the state of Connecticut procurement laws and um and is that what what what Ry was talking about uh and had sent some emails about no that's something internal but that would be added to the regulation where any um so

118what Ry was talking about is if a staff member makes a purchase and is looking for a reimbursement they need to ex they need to seek principal approval first or director approval first prior to making any purchase in order to get reimbursed but that would also be in the regulation okay sounds so regulation will also include so Source um there was a a chart here previously about exceptions that was against uh state of Connecticut Law the The Only Exception per state of Connecticut Law is for utilities until such time um there's competitors in the area and previously we had to you know Legal Services were exempt Professional Services were exempt textbooks were exempt that is not based upon state of Connecticut statute the only way locally to put in those exemptions is um by Town

119Charter or by Town ordinance which there's neither they're both silent on purchasing and procurement okay so we defer back to state of Connecticut Law all right I just have to say I'm so glad to have Irene on board because she really knows the law and she knows you know she she really is paying close attention to all these things so I appreciate that thank you Irene thank you I'm just trying to make sure we're covered I know that's what I think we need likewise appreciate that too um I'm good with it as written um so I'm ready for a vote if anyone else has anything I mean the only uh the only thing I would pass out um or cross out is uh that are I don't even know where it is um uh the

120words it it should I can't even find it now I'm sorry um but if you have Eric send this to me I'll just highlight it yeah it's just not necessary to be in there okay I'll make yeah it just says um it'll say the same thing with that it it'll just be clear I don't even know if clear's a it'll just be correct it could be where you even get an email from me tonight and I'll copy Erica and Susan sure that's great thank you thank you be any com yeah it's it's the last line in the second paragraph it's uh where there are no um other um sources just send it to me because I'm pooped we do thank you now I'm go with it Matthew okay in that case I'll ask for vote

121all those in favor of uh sending on P 3310 to the board for Action please indicate by saying I I I so it is three to zero to zero and 31 3310 passes we're now going on to 3320 3320 again pertains to purchasing it was just updating language um let me go strike this District and remind us Irene about the Red Cross out there at the after the second paragraph that's regulations too yes this is regulations um so just for everybody's understanding as far as goods and services it goes to lowest cost an example I often use and I'm not plugging any particular brand but you can buy Microsoft office suite at any big box store or online you're not able to buy Frontline or e finance so that's s source with the buying a

122good it is always lowest price when it comes to a service it's not only lowest price but it's most qualified so even though someone brings in the lowest price if they're not able to provide say Psychological Services that we need for a specific group of students or they just um graduated from college so now they're going to be lowest price but they don't they aren't necessarily the most qualified um you award based upon that so when it comes to a service itself you have both parameters that you need to evaluate because if you go lowest cost um then you're sacrificing what we're actually purchasing because they're not able to provide what we need so in this particular strikeout um it's to buy the prop proper product have it available the proper amount and the proper

123price in this particular case you know we don't need that level of language here it's all going to be spelled out in the regulation about all the different methods and means by specific area meaning like we just talked about Goods versus services and how bids are awarded and all that information will be put in to the regulation and that will follow state of Connecticut Law um and I would just note that uh there was a draft of this that came out of the ad hoc budget procedure committee that um was based a lot on what Ray sent in some emails and it was drafted as a recommended regulation um well initially it was drafted as a policy but then after conversations this is one of the ones that I would definitely recommend the administration take

124a look at and I can resend it uh to have it I've actually got it right here and it says just what you said it's more of a regulation got it I got it right attached to it right so that one has a lot of green ink um yeah yeah I got it all right and then like yeah the one two three4 is built out to match what Ray sent forward yeah thank you sure thank you Andrea comments no just again um I I think a superintendent of schools is there is crossed out however also um it should be um school should be crossed out before Finance business manager and and I don't know why so it's the new title s Susan is that U finance a manager instead of business manager is that changed

125well I don't know if it's officially changed she that we get called Finance director or business manager it's almost like a slash because some people you know depending on what it's going to be called you know it's always been the business manager and it's never been the school bus business manager no so I would just say make it just um through the business manager and but the title actually is Director of Finance um then use the title it's not business manager if it's Director of Finance then that's what it's seen as both so that's why even I think on my emails it says slash because I believe there needs to be um but I'd have to follow up with Jay on what needs to occur to make that change even though it's publicly out there

126yeah whatever the title is right and we've updated other policies that had this Director of Finance business manager that we're just recently voted to okay well when you send me this uh Irene send me all the the regulations to I'll look at those there's a witch CL or which thing that needs to be crossed out I'll cross it out and send it back so with the regulations those would come back in spring so you don't even need to look at them yet they're still being changed as we speak yep that's fine I'm just trying to make sure we incorporate all references to uh Connecticut statute and follow Connecticut procurement law and federal law and local I get that let's just be grammatic sometimes sometimes I see from cave and from other places and I just

127right here yes I'll I'll be sure to save I'll be sure to send you the drafts okay thank you is there any further conversation that we' want to take on this um I'm just a little I guess I'm a little confused as to like you know the the drafts being sent that are being discussed and have been discussed on a number of other policies I mean we're voting to move these things forward are there going to be further changes made that are Beyond minor teal adjustments no no they're grammatical or like if we need a comma or semicon or that's pretty much it I thought the draft that Irene was referring to was the uh regulation regulations yeah right that's what I do and and if you like I can CC all of you on

128it it's not a problem so that way when it does come to the meeting that we have it grammatically correct and then you already know it's coming to the meeting yeah I would appreciate that I think we can even highlight the changes and I'll make sure that it's reviewed by Floyd before the draft even comes over so that we're not trying to discuss something that he hasn't vetted yet yeah yeah nobody got appreciate that thank you and and just remember the regulations of the perview of the superintendent not the policy committee am I right Susan you're right we have um we have been when we've had a policy and a regulation together I tend to bring them both so that at least the policy committee can see it um you know and um but it

129is the you know policy is the procedures that we put in place for our organization so um out of courtesy you know we'll show to more than courtesy because we have we have in the past uh observed things in regulations that when we brought them to the superintendent in in attention she has altered the regulations so yes it's her purview but but she has included us right yeah I'm not saying she doesn't include us there's always room for discussion and she can change it if she likes to if she wants to but she doesn't have to because it's her regulations that's all I'm saying right she always but they always bring it back for discussion right and the way I perceive our role is like you know if we see something that is either contradictory

130or maybe not you know not um or something that could be added or enhanced like we can make those suggestions and make those requests but we don't have the power of a vote to command it right that's what I just said yeah yeah so I understand that thank you so um are we ready to take a vote on p3320 hearing no objection I'll ask all those who want to all those in favor of passing p3320 uh on to action by the full board please indicate by saying I I I and it passes three to Z to zero Matthew these are all second meetings correct yes yes okay for that se for the um January 7th right and already we have four so that's one of the reasons why we didn't have it didn't do these

131policies on the six yeah because look how long us two and a half hours just for this right right my daughter just called she goes you're still working have you have dinner and I said no not yet she goes mom this will be this will be the last three-hour meeting because um well I just wanted to say that that's the reason we didn't do this on January 6 so it's explicitly clear yeah okay I we have in front of us P 3160 transfer funds uh between fund categories amendments under business non-instructional operations do I have a motion to uh move this to the full committee for second reading for the purposes of discussion I'll second that so okay uh Irene you're up so just to note 3160 and 3200 item G on the agenda are

132exactly the same so whatever changes we make to 3160 then we can Sunset 3200 uh and just remove it um there's no K policy 3200 so that's the other problem we must have numbered it years ago right but so my question is the way I read it 3160 was a transfer between budget functions and 3200 was transfer of funds between budget categories which right there's not a budget functions one there's no policy that um there's no policy or law about budget function but there is about categories is that right Irene yes so it if you look at the existing policy that's stricken here um this whole chart by budget function that does not exist and that is um this one I know I have in writing from Floyd that it's not legal there's nothing that

133restrictive and then I can speak to why and the reason being is the in this is my fourth state and in all four states when you vote the budget for the Board of Education you're voting bottom line total what that does is allow the flexibility to move things around in your budget for the student needs especially in a military Community where things shift as people get deployed or changed or or sent somewhere else where you may need to change um the focus on science because there's depletion there but you need more focus on World Language that allows the flexibility to transfer the budgetary dollars between those areas it also allows you to create better budgets going forward in the out years because you're putting the budget where your expenditures are occurring with the e upgrade

134the the I've been in the training as well as seeing what some of the new functionality will be we can actually create a budget transfer report for you so that's something in the monthly budget and expense report how you currently say year-to-date expenditures you see incumbrances you see the FY 25 budget what you will then see is a new column it would be the fy2 but budget and you'll see the fy2 revised budget so you'll be able to see those transfers with an explanation why they were done so budget transfers as of today um schools can do but you're limiting them to not be able to move Monies to support you know special education from regular instruction if we're seeing an increase in special education and we're seeing a reduction in regular instruction it basically

135ties the hands of the principal and the superintendent to make the transfer to where it's needed the reporting will occur um and additional information regarding why that transfer occurred will also be provided this language also includes for the non-aps account that is a board transfer and that must be voted by the board so anything in the balance sheet that's sitting in non-aps or undesignated no matter if it's a penny that does require Board of Education approval this particular policy allows the flexibility to move the operating budget dollars not Grant dollars not anything else it's the operating budget dollars I also see that we're the board is to provide a written explanation of transfers made under emergency circumstances to Town Council um and the RTM and we certainly Know What emergencies are defined as because we

136had many urgent sudden serious events and unfortunate unfortunate circumstance unforeseen things that were happening last year if you can recall and um we had to pay for it right away um so in this particular paragraph and thank you Susan for bringing that up this particular paragraph is identifying costs that we're paying say and KN what this does not happen um it already happened in the past see you know when we had the flood at the new schools because of the the new water fountains to refill um reusable flasks and and drink holders that's not something we have budget in anywhere and we may need an undesignated fund transfer from the town to the schools to help cover that cost that was not covered by insurance this paragraph provides that written notification of not only what

137happened but the fun that we're requesting that level of transfer will will require Town Council approval as well as RTM approval but it also provides that notification we have a situation that's unbudgeted that if you know we don't have those additional funds we may have a deficit by year end so we'll we'll try our best to cover it how however if that request for the additional funding is denied and we do run into that deficit situation it'll show our Outreach um to ask for that funding and it also I made sure that this part of C was included because I do believe this is important is it starts to create that more positive relationship between the board and the town on how those monies are being spent you know especially emergency situations we could have

138a a FEMA disaster where we incur the expense this year but we don't see reimbursement for up to 18 or 24 months but we still have to pay for that in that fiscal year uh Matthew F please all right so thank you for that explanation um and clarifications the so if I understand correctly the 3160 and the 3200 that were in the policy manual already Yes um one was 3160 was identifying budget functions and 3200 was identifying budget categories trans and having to do transfer of funds between the two um you're saying 3160 that was written for Budget functions was not legal or the law that's that's my understanding standing from Floyd is specifically um the chart that we included in some of our statutory references um were not correct not correct or just not

139current not correct this particular chart this whole thing here um I know he said it's not legal it's not part of any statute so I mean that was all pre-existing like as far as like the ad hoc budget procedure committee we came across this um and that was just part of what was already there right right the adjustments that that we made came from cab uh in the the document that I sent previous uh that had a lot of blue ink in it and uh so transfers between functions cannot happen period is that what is being established here at at this point the way that is written if um the principal for Fitch High School needs to move a penny from regular instruction to special education or um other instructional programs it requires a board

140of education review and approval right and and the cave documents that had this um they basically said that there's like a b a three- tiered approach um that you know any board or any Administration could choose to to engage in and one was you know completely hands off and and all all that was required was reporting um and the other had like sort of a middle ground approach and the other was this highly restrictive approach um and so the draft that was uh passed out a committee was um uh you know sort of like a middle ground area um but that's not reflected in this document um and also I just want to get clarity like so transfers between budget functions functions are the the the the bigger categories like the the um I just

141want to get my terms and definitions correct because sure right there's a hard firewall between functions but between codes and categories that's a softer more permal membrane um categories are um as as I've been providing in the narrative categories are salaries you know when you're transferring salary to salary U because we've been having a hard time um bringing in full-time year round teachers and we're hiring more substitutes or tutors right now you're not able to move those budget dollars where they're needed that's why you're seeing a lot of negatives in your monthly reports um and overspending is a high probability of occurring because we're not able to transfer those budgetary dollars where they're needed okay but but after this policy goes through Irene what what will be the difference the difference is that if um

142like I said you know using the example of Fitch high school you know if Matt Brown knows that he has excess money in science um in salaries for classroom teachers because we can't fill but he's seeing a deficit in tutors and substitutes it allows the option to transfer those funds in that year to where he's seeing those deficits occur and it helps us in future years for budgeting purposes it doesn't eliminate positions um you know there are union contracts that protect those positions but we're attributing the funds to where they're needed and where they're being expended do this answer your question um yeah and and one is a technical question but so if I'm understanding you correctly this basically just means that you know for every this this will allow the administrators to do what

143they have to do uh on the ground to make the adjustments they need but there this also requires a reporting yes right and that's what I'm committing to is providing you with that level of reporting it would be an addition an additional column in your existing monthly reporting with how I've been putting tons of notes in we can put in notes you I can once KN on would um the new e finance system is up and running after January 31st what I've seen in training is I'll be able just to print you a report from the system that shows where it transferred from and to and then also put in the why in there so you'd have that as part of your um monthly Financial packet and your monthly financial report all right sounds good

144um so um you know I guess like what I'm I was hoping for is to have one one I just want to get some uh Clarity of terms and definitions so I've come across terms like functions which are the the the function codes are big accounts correct and then subset to those are like object codes and various other categories you you said salaries but what are the object codes like when we start looking at object codes those are inside the could I redirect could I redirect us to this policy because it's getting late you and I have that I'm trying to understand why the change in title that it's an easy clarification object codes exist when you have built out um it's about a a 20 character string and that's IM munice are the object

145codes and object codes are subsets of functions correct functions are like a hard and fast you know there should be some have the function code is science example my function is science underneath science my object code is a salary code and account right so it's a subset of the function so it goes general fund function location account okay can you say those are your salaries through your dues and fees hundreds through the 800s all right so general fund for ofed budget and then the functions and what did you say after functions location location and then after that is the account the account which so when people refer to object codes what are what are those attached to object codes are a town accounting function and the um uniform chart of accounts in Connecticut those object

146codes are Town function codes that's something that we'll get to but we don't have currently so in object codes for a town the 51 100 series is all salaries okay but that's not something that we have in the Boe chart of accounts when we go to m you'd see you'd be able to run a report just by the 51 series for us if we want to see all salaries it's just the 100 series and I can run a report that way and then benefits are 200 yeah that's that's something different it's so in fun in object codes in the town any benefits are the 512 asterisk series but for school school accounting object codes are 100s to the 800s right right so that's the difference is in the town you'll see the 51s the 52s

147the 53s the 54s right so the draft that came out of the committee um was a little more articulated I guess and there was a lot of parallel between the 3160 and the um and but there was a threshold set that basically allow and this was based on like cab recommendations where they said well if you want a Middle Road option set a threshold and underneath that you know Administration has broad latitude but above that they do have to go through the board um Matthew isn't this a subject for the budget I have I have asked once to have this be a conversation a learning conversation for you which is perfectly valid and not to spend another more time on this now we're so I'm going to this is bringing it back to the to

148the to the policy at hand like we are looking over the text now do you have any more different conver different points that you'd like to make regarding the text several there's a few paragraphs missing here and and like one of the things was like to figure out like you know okay if there's going to be a big move of money that's the thing that should go through the board but if there's like micro moves then maybe that that that obviously that is something that Administration should have the latitude to do but the question is like size and frequency so we're putting it right here we'll get you that language insert threshold language all right and and like I said in in the draft that I sent out originally when we start like putting forth

149these policy revisions um there's a lot of blue text that was all cab language and that got Lost in Translation um you know it's just it makes it hard to have these conversations when those notes didn't make it through as far as like what the committee wanted to see discussed um it looks like the blue is very similar to the green when I go back and forth yeah the the green is from cave yeah the greenage I I hear what Ian is saying Ian did send me a copy of a markup that included a authoriz the superintendent or the design is authorized to transfer an amount up to 10,000 I am neither for the purpose of my comment now I'm neither endorsing nor refuting it but uh I would have preferred if Ian had made

150a motion to amend to include x y or Z at a certain point and then we could talk about that rather than these long circuitous conversations I'm exhausted Ian I need to go to sleep I'm not the only one I I recommend that I review this language and then come back with something um because in in some cases you know like this particular paragraph the superintendent has no authorization to do this at all as far as transferring from the balance sheet accounts and then the RTM and Town Council notification right so I can look at the threshold language $10,000 in the budget our size is is we'd be having just board meetings to discuss budget transfers so it could be an upward you know a threshold of 50,000 th000 yep yeah no I think that

151that's the conversation I like to have in regards to this policy um and I would just ask like moving forward um yeah I mean if if for the next time we sit with this document could we have the committee uh the the ad hoc committee's draft also available to refer to would that has the the the blue ink and the green ink and the black and red I do have that aable um my understanding was it was too hard to read on the screen so that is something that I can provide okay we yeah we were actually to when we reviewed this Ian we had them on the big screen and Irene and I were looking at them side by side okay I would like to entertain a motion from somebody to table this and

152uh Ian will get uh if they don't already have what you need Ian get what you have and put it in and then we will discuss it as a committee at our January 14th meeting okay sounds good it sounds like like uh this is a conversation for Irene and Ian and if you have these questions why don't you make an appointment with her and just ask them well I think it's valuable to having a meeting because also other board members are either watching tonight or would be reviewing this video and also for the public understand what we're talking about and that's why I wanted to get the terms and definitions kind of on the table too and how they Rel I said too much I apologize I agree with the so I have a motion

153to table table Andre made the motion I I'll second it okay so we are vote on the motion to table 3160 um to our January 14 meeting all those in favor I I all those opposed you you an i or nay and I I okay okay so U my we have now in front of us a on as an agenda item a discussion on the removal of p3200 transfer of funds is a duplicate of P 3160 before I ask for any motion uh is everybody am I understanding you to say that this is a duplicate and that deleting this is not going to in any way affect our budget functions until we vote through 3160 we we have to do them together 200 live so then can I have we're gonna table that one too

154can I have a motion to table p3200 no moved second all any discussion all those in favor of tbling P 3200 till January 14th please say I I I I three in FA four in favor three in favor uh none opposed none abstain uh Referral List anybody have any new items for the referral list for our committee not at this time not at this time Andrea no okay nothing new uh future meeting topics uh our list is our October meeting Susan had said we would uh have a draft Administration draft on cell phone policy uh that would handshake with what's in the student policy manual could we have that ready for the January meeting I think we've already reviewed that I thought that was already done I'll ask it's not been done it's not been

155done it's not has Erica has something okay so that's on the agenda we're gonna have Matthew I think we have enough on the agenda and that's an important thing to to to discuss and I don't think we're going to have time to devote to it we're going to be tabling it so I I would we may table it but we may table it that's fine but I'd like it on the agenda we never Hope Springs Eternal in the human breast there will be no more Matthew no no more three remember January the January 14th meeting that you're going to have yeah right it's a five it's going to be right before the budget meeeting so you're only going to have an hour well a little less than an hour that's right just keep that in

156mind when you're doing your agenda thank you very much for that appreciate that okay well fine uh the residual B pup budget work we have to do um I know Susan you have many other items uh what don't you give me two three we'll put them at the bottom list so we can just identify I'm so tired I can't even think of them can I go look at it later absolutely not now no and no you cannot look at it later I just want to help Irene with this budget in this and I'm not really much help but I mean I just want to get us to good okay for so I just want to give your head up it's coming up uh maybe in February I'd like to have Clint report on the what

157we're doing as on AI in the school system now what he has learned and give us some background on policy which is not going to be developed for another three four five months but he's ready to bring us up to date as they first pass at something so not next month uh Matthew Matthew on that you you asked me if Clint could come to a regular board meeting at the committee of the whole meeting to talk about Ai and he has agreed to do that in February oh because he I thought when I spoke with him he suggested he thought he should visit with the committee first so we had some insight to it and at that point I thought he could come in January but that's clearly not gonna happen I'm flexible for either

158option whatever the board chooses so I'm getting confused because people are talking to two people at the same time so okay so you can have him at policy and I don't have to worry about media the whole thing okay so February February for Clint okay uh is there anything else for the good of the order before we take a motion to adjourn M Andrea you're do you have a motion to make motion to adjourn good night everybody sus go to bed good night Lucy good night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.