001good evening this is um the Gren border education special meeting being held on December 16 2024 and it's being held at the central office in room 11 um I like to call the meeting to order we have all board members except for Jay Jay's not here hopefully he's on his way and I don't think I missed anybody else um the first item is dis discussion with um you introduce yourself Chris with our legislators to talk about items that are specific to Granton thank you Chris for coming out on this rainy day um this rainy night you could be home in your warm pajamas relaxing but here you are with us tonight so we really appreciate it and um as you know funding is a big issue for school systems lately and we we had some
002pandemic relief money but that's going to dry out or soon dry out and that helped us get over you know a lot of the bumps and helped us to funas and you know other things that the school system needed but now we're back to reality so we're here to talk about the things that Granton needs so the first item is um being held harmless for ECS and I'll let Susan no Matthew Matthew's gonna talk about that I'm sorry okay so you don't know Chris but I'm in a terrible public speaker so I prepare in advance and I read it and prise it won't be more than 20 minutes okay I want to voice concern about a long-term State funding I don't mean the ECS formula or per per pupil support levels you can talk about
003them if you want but that's not the focus they go beyond our district what worries me most what worries us most is the hold harmless status and the impact future termination will have on our students and our taxpayers we've made great strides as an alliance District we've eliminated demographic inequalities in our district with a single middle school and a five School intradistrict magnet system different themes let parents choose what's best for their child or children and we take a great pride in welcoming and integrating a large cohort of military students each year you strengthened minority and socioeconomic access to challenging upper level classes we've increased career options added Navy RC pathway program we've instituted the state's transitional Premier transitional de K program we now offer Elementary level French and Spanish instruction we'll be hydroponically growing
004fresh greens year round for School meals and we launched a high do tutoring that helped our kids move up a grade level or more in its first semester and I just truncated it to that there's there's more that we could have gone on but we have a long way to go our board superintendent and Leadership teams are focusing on reducing chronic absenteeism and boosting children's academic achievement levels both aimed at eliminating the academic achievement Gap that's plagued us among many districts Nationwide the good news is that gron is moving towards graduation pick another word if you don't like that from the alliance status the bad news is that graduation from Alliance could well be a poison pill it's a significant risk for which we need your guidance and support we're in the third year of
005the hold harmless status for State funding for which we owe you and Joe a debt of gratitude what what's next here here are clearly a few of the known unknowns what happens when our hold harmless period ends in two years what if and when we graduate as an alliance District so my question to you this is a collective View for the three of you is what scenario or scenario do you see for Gren schools if our success in eliminating inequities and raising acade academic performance results in a multi-million dollar cut in state aid if this transpires how much of all that we've accomplished could be threatened unless you can help us find a solution whether this Rises to the top of your priorities this year we need to begin working now to forge a plan
006that protects US 24 months hence we'll do everything we can but given the voice priorities of the new federal Administration about Department of Education and Department of Defense funding for Education my ask tonight is how you best see us working together this year year to flesh out a strategy to mitigate the challenge in the Horizon I'm sure my colleagues have different perspectives that they would like to add yeah let Chris an and they can jump in so I know the whole delegation was invited today for folks who were tuning on on the TV world or watching YouTube World later um I know there are multiple meetings tonight and I know traffic and Ice was bad in Harford so folks could be delayed I'll update um the Heather and Andre um when I hear from them
007and I'm sure we'll be talking about something in the next couple days um to give them the updates if they're not able to make it today um but you have been an alliance District The Alliance program Grew From 30 to 33 districts in 2017 that's when myself Heather and Joe were here um at that point you the town of Gren was to lose 8 million if we were not an alliance District in ECS funding there are two issues isues that made us most likely to be Alliance one was our chronic absenteeism rates which have been high for a while I know folks are working on it but we're still pretty we're still we could do you know we're still when you look at the other districts we're still got a little ways to go with
008that our other factor is enrollment um Granton has had steady enrollment declines for years for a good decade and they were held harmless for a decade before they became an alliance dis and then when the enrollment hold harmless ended in 2017 there was the big adjustment now what happened to other towns is other towns had a five-year adjustment period for their enrollment um our 8 million hold harmless has become a $10 million hold harmless and that's due to enrollment so my first question is where do we stand on enrollment because numbers were due October 1st and again our enrollment fluctuates in this town but it's always the o October 1 enrollment so are we on the upswing of enrollment which will help with any adjustments or are we continually on the downswing from enrollment and
009if you don't have those numbers you can get them what are they so um this year they were four 4,458 um and the year before it was 4,448 the year before that it was 4,461 so we basically have about 850 students coming come in and lose about 700 um and that's every typically every year we have that kind of Mobility so it's but over the last 15 years the overall trend is down and next year it's predicted to be 4,688 yeah so getting us those predictions to show that you could be on the upswing next year is very important give you this package and I know a lot of folks may have been on the board in other rules I know one person certainly was on the board back back in 17 but it was
010the the biggest way we were able to keep us home hold harmless was the enrollment data with Dr grineer to show um where we are because right now we are being compensated for students when we were first held home hold harmless and we are being compensated for the enrollment rate of a very long time ago we are not being compensated in the formula for our current enrollment rat um so in 17 we grew the program to 33 scho districts the 33 most underperforming districts and we were able to be capped into that 33 um two years ago the program grew again to 36 districts so the 36 most underperforming districts were in we're still in that group so while we we will be re-evaluated in two years but it doesn't mean we have to leave
011we may very well still be in the 36 group or the program May grow from 36 to 37 and we may still be in the alliance that would give us an additional 5 years of steady funding the main thing with Alliance District while you do get a lot of services from the State Board of Ed and tools you get a hold your hold harmless continues that's the main good thing about being the alliance district and I know some folks either here or on the TV world don't really like the status of being an alliance District but the reality is you don't want to be the 37th most underperforming district and lose million of funding for folks who are looking to move into districts who are looking at the stats alone and the stats don't really
012represent a lot of communities well um but if you're looking at you know a couple a couple numbers that folks might Google when they're looking to move into the community and they look at some of the reasons why we're an alliance District if they look at our absenteeism if they look at some of our scores compared to some of our neighboring districts if we go from 33 to 37 no one's good people who are looking at those stats are not going to choose to live here they're still going to say you're in the bottom group and gron has been in where it is you know fluctuating a few points here and there and our students are diverse our students are wonderful but I would say it's a good thing to be in the alliance District
013because not only do we get $10 million of funding we get a lot of services from the state of Connecticut that we wouldn't have otherwise right and that's helpful to the board it's helpful to the superintendent's office it's fundamentally helpful to the students so there's a lot of benefits here so I wouldn't want to graduate if I was on this Board of Ed um our number one ask for the entire delegation every year you might not know the gr's number one ask is to continue to be held harmless that's what we ask for the budget is to continue to be held harmless um by change if the ECS formula is changed and I'm not saying it will be changed but if it is changed they could change the hold harmless and how it works and
014there's a lot of other districts who are held harmless and we ban together as state reps and say we'd all like to be held harmless together so you've got 20 or 30 people who like to be held harmless now where that becomes difficult is while we are held harmless or in some people's according to the formula we are overfunded by $10 million other districts are underfunded and that's where a lot of our our fight in Hartford have to be is they'll look at these communities and they're Suburban communities like ours um man Manchester EAS Hartford a lot of suburban communities are in this hold harmless where they have they're overfunded for enrollment these communities will say well how about us you know we're underfunded and these folks are overfunded we want the adjustment to happen
015and that's something that we talk about in caucus as something that the speaker talks to all of about all of us about and so far we have been successful the last eight years to keep the hold harmless to keep the funding where it is um and that's your number one ask and it's our number one push it's get gets difficult at times it was much easier when we had Co money and there was money for everything this is the first real budget for the state of Connecticut postco money and it just coincides with us to expect cuts from the federal budget so if the federal government gives the state of Connecticut less money the state of Connecticut has less money to give other everyone which includes municipalities it does include higher red it includes everyone
016we're preparing for cuts you know kind of plan for the worst hope for the best and we're kind of going to see what happens over the next couple months together so when you're doing your budget proposals my first thing is do not plan to get more money forget that's off the table we're expecting Federal cuts um so do not plan on getting more state or federal money than what you got last year and let's try and hope that we can keep this hold harmless let's hope that we can get as that we get Federal money to what we expected let's hope that plenty of Grants state and federal grants become open and Things become federally funded we will know more mid-February we will know more March we won't know until we get a little bit
017into this Federal um and everyone gets Warn and we see their first budget so we will know more kind of in the spring right when you're in the middle of your Council budget time and then we will adjust we do have a very large rainy day fund in the state of Connecticut and that's why we didn't spend the rainy day fund on other things because we didn't know what was going to happen with the presidential election we didn't know what was going to happen with a lot of things so we'd have kept that rainy day fund um very flush so we'll be able to react to a lot of things but we're not quite sure what we're going to react to yet and how that panss down to each department um again if if the
018Trump Administration ends special education funding that's a problem our rainy day fund is not that big just to be clear we can't we can't solve all problems but we don't know what problems we will have until budgets start getting released so we're going to have to just wait react adjust kind of move through the punches um for folks who weren't here in 2017 I know we didn't call Dr arriman at 2 or 3 in the morning but we certainly called Dr grineer at 2 or 3 in the morning every time we got a budget update we were sending it over we were texting the new chart we're updating and we'll do the same with Dr Austin sorry it'll be early that's all right um and she can update you guys when the business day starts
019once everyone Rises that call from Sam now when his iy roades yeah so we'll give you the call like we have this budget update we have this or that hopefully we do get a budget our budget will not come out fully so folks aren't sure about our budget process it's sort of similar to years except the months are different um the governor starts with his proposed budget which will be end of January again it will be based on the knowledge at that moment it will not be based on the full knowledge of what federally happens so there'll be estimates in there um then the budget goes to committees Appropriations Committee meets with each and every Department including the State Department of Education there's public hearings where superintendents Board of aded members parents teachers can come
020unions come and talk about funding and what they need more of or what they can do without all of our state departments have been asked to present a 5% reduction so that folks can see what those Services look like at a 5% reduction across the board so we can make educated decisions um Appropriations Committee then comes out with the next budget draft like budget two that comes out the end of April then the budget gets completely relooked at everything is an open book there's no requirement you don't need I know like with RTM and Town Council you need two-thirds for one thing in half for another nope we just do more drafts um and then so we do more leadership drafts starting out in April by then we end of April we start to get
021our tax returns dollars in for folks who are filing your taxes on April 15 to see if folks made a little more or a little less money now for you and me most of us we make about the same we have Fairfield County in our state so those folks who do the hedge funds their income goes very different very high very low they can have swings of of you know tens millions of dollars each year lucky group not me uh for most folks our swings and our who are W2 workers we have very small swings within a few thousand dollars or your your businesses your small businesses have a swings within you know you kind of know what a good year and a bad year is and it's not that far off but Fairfield County
022those swings are really really big um so when we start getting reports in as people are filing their taxes in Fairfield County we either get really excited or we get a little concerned um and so we start adjusting how much money we have coming in in April early May and then we can look at departments about putting more money back in oh great these monies are flowing that's great we can make sure we're um appropriating money correctly across the state of Connecticut if they end up slow or if we have big Federal Cuts then we make more adjustments we will probably do a budget first week of June that's when we'll know um and get those updates now in 2017 we went all the way till November because we struggled with with Municipal funding so
023we kept going in we kept talking we kept having meetings and we went in throughout the entire summer we spent a nice fall together at the at the lb we saw the leaves turned together at the L and we figured out a fair budget not until November so hopefully we get you before school starts so you can have how much you're planning but I would say plan for level funding do not ask expect any more money from the state or federal government and let's plan you know this enrollment numbers are important but looking at your numbers you really have not rebound enrollment so a hold harmless change is devastating for this District as it's a big change even if you're offsetting it by 10 years a million each year is a lot is a lot
024of change in services for the students so one of the things when you talk about enrollment people need places to live and we have a lot of families besides the military coming in and out and basing you know that projection on what the military what might happen to the military you just don't know and then you also have the whole Norwich New London ledgard Groton connection and we share kids a lot and they they move very often to find more affordable housing and then you have the homeless section and while it might be 40 families involved it's still a lot and then they're in hotels across the bridge or wherever they can find or you know be taken care of so you know with Transportation cost to that but it's you know there's not a
025lot of affordable housing in cten Mystic at all that's available um so it's hard to say that we're going to grow enrollment and families even though we have EB and we have the Navy um Beyond what's in you know Bal for batty for the military and then other places that would be affordable um now I know it seems like there are some building projects going on I don't you know that's something that I have to find out from the town if they see anything coming up that would have you know families talk to me about needing three bedrooms not two you know and um having in place but an affordable living a lot of more families are getting by with two bedrooms there's nothing wrong with sharing a bedroom with your siblings a lot of
026us did it growing up but they need to find those too and I don't know that there's a lot of those around so if we do want to grow enrollment then we do need affordable housing for families so yeah and that's something I do sit on Planning and Development which does our affordable housing laws so hearing you tell that to your families is when we start talking about the changes that we make in Statewide zoning to allow affordable housing when we have folks who locally are against that hearing you say you're in support of those things and if you talk to your board of ed members maybe they'll speak out and say they're in support of some of those things too yeah that it's a benefit to the community we hear a lot about negatives
027to the community yeah with affordable housing I'm a fan I voted for all the bills for affordable housing and for multi- um use housing and to have apartments on one side and to have more um areas for commercial on the first floor something that would fit into Route One something that would fit into a reuse of Pleasant Valley School um it would be perfect for something like that that spot but when we look at our schools and what are we going to do you know building a a house that is three4 of a million do is not going to help the enrollment for the town of gr you might get three kids out of it maybe for a couple years but not that long you know if you when we look at lot sizes and
028where I live in the town of Grant is very small lot sizes and I love my neighbors we're a little closer than than folks in Mystic are but we get along just fine um but there are kids different kids and there's renters and there's owners and it's a nice mixed income Community where it is lovely and people can walk you don't need a car to get to different variety of jobs where I live in my side of town um so you have teenagers who can walk for high school jobs and you have can have adults that can walk um over for electric boat jobs these are lovely mixed use communities and we could expand that into other areas of grind and it would help with the ECS funding as well I'm a fan of affordable
029housing too so Ian um thank you uh so just to recap the the main characteristic of our district day qualified US for the alliance funding and put us in the alliance District was the declining enrollment no the hold harmless result is the enrollment okay so we have been held harmless for about 10 years before we were in Alliance District so we were held harmless for our student population levels so as the student population each year was going down and going down and going down we were held harmless for those population drops so our ECS dollar stayed the same why we're in Alliance district is a variety of factors um income test scores one of the issues that I think we can do better is attendance um you can't change folks it's very difficult to change
030a community's income or to deal with test scores it is you have control over better control over students attending and why aren't students attending that's something that the district was asked and is try doing its best to try to fix up um but the hold harmless is separate from the alliance we just fell under well we didn't really fall under the 30 districts because what we were able to do with the help of the governor's office and many others we were able to grow the alliance District program from 30 communities to 33 communities so that we fit within it a result of being an alliance district is we have continued that hold harmless when in 2017 that was removed for non-alliance district communities yes so I'm just trying to get a handle on on what
031it was that initially qualified US for the alliance our scores are our scores are income is there so in the process of doing all that was there like some sort of like application and documentation that that was you know verified that we had to the state of Conn you do not fill it out the state of Connecticut has all that data the district does not fill it out the state of Connecticut has all the data about families and families and income we have access to tax returns um you know what percentage of students are on certain State you know we have their zip codes who's getting food services who's getting husky who what our family's income um we have your test scores they get reported to the state of connec anything that's reported to the
032state of Connecticut from the um the school department we can use all that data and that all those numbers together because it's not one thing it's a combination when you look at it the bottom certain number of school districts right now it's up to 36 are considered Alliance districts which means they get extra help from the state to try to Bo boost those students up unfortunately it's most of our cities are in Alliance this in our Durk so in the district reference group yeah so New London's in Alliance stonington's not an alliance um when you look at some factors so a lot all of our cities our cities are all Alliance districts it's when you look at wealth and how wealth is Con concentrated in the state of Connecticut lower income people live in cities
033or more populated areas um and there's pros and cons so is there is there some document that we could um take a look at that would show us like what the barriers are what the thresholds are as far as like you said uh income test scores absenteeism everything together everything together so like if there's an overall drift upwards in income average medium income for for this area would that be a disqualifier alone not nothing's a disqualifier alone yeah she you look at all these there's about 30 different factors and you look at all of them throughout all the school districts in the state of Connecticut and if the number stays 36 Alliance districts the bottom 36 districts will be an alliance District so when you look at all the different factors is there some document
034that kind of encapsulates all that to show us like how like can look at Alliance District funding yep it's right state of Connecticut look up the alliance District funding the whole program's there so each district that's in the alliance has a report no the state of Connecticut defines the alliance District funding at the Connecticut web Connecticut General at the um Department of Education in the state of Connecticut you can look up some information does the state of Connecticut have a dossier on each district I wouldn't have any knowled about that hey Jen um just I'm sorry we didn't introduce ourselves that's okay I know who you guys are okay my apologies so um so if we I know you're saying like try to stay as an alliance District right but if we have aspirations of
035not being an alliance District because we want our kids not to just be only 50% or 60% passing and we want to improve the test scores and attendance and there's multiple factors right I'm okay I I'll say this being an alliance District if it's based on income because we can't control that but I want us to be held accountable so that the kids who are graduating from our district have a fair shot of like being able to like move from one soci economic bracket to another so that they could get either better jobs or have different opportunities and not just say you're in the 40% that's not cutting it and that's okay with us so that we can keep $10 million that's not okay for me so I don't know it's almost like it's like
036a dilemma like um kids or money and to me it's like I want the kids to have higher test scores I want them to come to school and I don't know what all the the other 27 factors are but what would you suggest to us I I want focus on whether because I hear a lot of people talk about graduating alliances if they want to and that somehow the students know that they're the students have no idea they're in an alliance District there's no again there's 306 other communities big communities Hartford New Haven Bridgeport New London Norwich very Vernon Vernon Andi a little competition withfield in it um killing Le's been in and out for a variety of reasons they're right on the edge um so the students don't know that they're an alliance district
037and don't have a concern our students do well regardless if one student has a low test score and one student has a high test score regardless of income our students do well our students graduate get job training College training go on to life that's teaching and learning that's what the board of EDS should and continue to remain focused on what you do not want to become focused on is trying to be one step out of the alliance District so you still need all the resources that you should be getting and be not receiving those resources so there's a lot of Pros to the board there's a lot of teacher training there's access when you're doing curriculum um training and researching for free to the board of State Board of Education that Alliance districts get enhanced
038access to yes because they need additional help so if one of our goals is to say we're going to improve test you it might improving test scores might not get you out of Alliance okay to a certain point like I said I'm okay with that if we're in there because of income totally fine you're still going to be in an income range that makes you more likely to become an alliance District because there's certain things that are going to stay the same the state department of Ed sets up a target for all districts the new canans to the Monro to the Grotton to the new londons and that expectation for 2030 is something I've outlined in my goals that that's really something that you know I want to accomplish but that is for all and
039that they've set up the metrics that that is basically you know for all students to make be successful to reach those goals I I understand that but if we say like we're like 20% attendance rate you know like and we improve it to 15 but that kicks us off you know what I mean like then maybe we go from 36 to 37 Alliance districts it's not this isn't as yes and no as some may think it is yeah it is a lot of negotiation in Harford okay so we will depend on you so if we keep focusing on like you work on teaching and learning yes yes helping the kids get their test scores up and their attendance up and all of that and you guys will continue we'll continue to know that's your number
040one request but there's other things you know you can't control so you as much as we can't control enrollment as much as we'd like that enrollment figure if that continues to go down at some point the hold harmless is going have to get adjusted and not necessarily Allin one but in a small amount so when folks are talking about grotten one thing you all can do is when folks are saying rotten grotten you can say that's false that's not right and be a good advocate for GR because a lot of people moving in here it's easy to Google test score it's easy to Google an average income it's hard to learn why this is such a good school district if you're on your computer so when you see people on the community forums saying negative
041things you guys can say this is a great School District I love our town um you know our teachers can say this is great and our students and parents and everyone can join together to say our town does great things and you know be it math educ science reading scores are improving or Sports or our things are our students music are doing all these good things everyone together to get the enrollment up is what will benefit this community enrollment isn't keeping us on Alliance enrollment is the budget problem that Alliance is banding but what is okay you probably have all the background but what is the break even point because if we start increasing to the point where we now need to add teachers we need to reopen schools we need to get principal and
042will the funding that we're trying to save it's covering what we have now are we going to get additional funding for those extra people no because you're already getting funding for them yes so then by funding for students Ed short so that the more people we add then we're spending 17,000 per student and then now we're going to spend 15,000 per student but if you're if we just if all metrics become aside and we just look at the enrollment Statewide we have to start coming to term with the fact that we are being compensated for students that don't live here correct so it is not at all Statewide Fair correct for districts that are being compensated so we need to start I have another question that I think would be helpful okay wait wait thank
043you the wait wait Matthew cause does somebody else have a question Dean okay no jumping in like that no jumping in yes ma'am was was Cindy done was joh were you done were you done Jen yeah we're good I'm sure like all of yeah yeah because Matthew just cut her right off right in you means well he doese go ahead Dean so I think Jen's question you can correct me is is is premised on there being an upstream effect about being labeled an alliance District in other words kid works his tail off and Gren uh may have less of a chance of getting into the same schools the same kid working his tail off in stone conington which is not labels an alliance District I don't know whether that's true or not there is that
044suspicion because you have to know that institutions of Higher Learning will say well Straight A's are not all straight A they not all worth the same you know straight A from District a not you know a 40 average is not necessarily the same as a 40 average over here and they probably wait schools what school did you go to and and the fear is that well these kids came from the alliance District so you know Kudos on being the validator but they have half the chance of getting into our school as a kid that came from a non-alliance district say is that pretty much what your concern is Jen no I'm just more con that's a valid concern but that wasn't what I was trying to get because if it doesn't matter then then I'm
045not worried about it because you're probably right I think the kids have no idea what an alliance district is should be focused if they're not but should be on their own progress no my concern is if we're going to work to get test scores up and we're going to work to get a up and we get it I mean oh yeah down sorry down test upend down tendance down and if we are successful at that we fall out of Alliance we are going to fall out of Alliance but I am not willing to trade off test scores and attendance just so that we could keep money oh I I understand you know what I mean that's where I'm coming no one's asking you to make that trade okay what we will look at is every
046year the state of Connecticut looks at all these factors and you may improve your test scores but all these other schools may do the exact same thing MH and you may be exactly where you are in the list of schools keep focusing on teaching and learning because we want our students to have the best test scores we want them in the buildings learning achieving being ready to be adults yes one there are some factors that you do we cannot control that make us in the lower end of the districts and that will continue to be gr because that is part of what makes Gren GR is that we have a a diverse community and those things will continue to stay and we may despite increased test course we may continue to be in Allied districts
047and okay and that's fine and our students who are succeeding have no problem there's no you know show like brown dark spot or Cloud over their head that we an alliance District colleges don't look yeah colleges don't look at that as like you're an a for Alliance as a bad thing or an a for Alliance is a good thing it's a funding issue and everyone in the funding world knows how they are pros of being an alliance District when it comes to funding and there should be because our districts that need the most help should be getting more help than your districts that don't need that much help um be it funding be it access for again our board our department our superintendent to have extra access to the state of Connecticut our teachers get
048free training other communities who are not Alliance districts have to pay for a lot of that training again the ones who have who are higher in those St stats they can afford to pay for it we get it for free that is a benefit it's a great benefit to our our teachers that they're getting training and it's a great benefit to your budget that it's not costing you a dime for some of this so there's a lot of Pros with Alliance district and I think sometimes we focus on it being or some people in the community focus on it being a negative it's not a negative it's a budget reality I've got I had more to my question and I was going to shift over to uh it had to do with Gem's bringing this
049up the $25 million 25 million chains I have seen that in the town's budget as a source of funding for 27.3 is it 27 27 okay you would be upset at 25 yeah it's that figure that range has been there for like eons it seems um and I can remember and I could be wrong uh and this is why you heard people when we're talking about school construction years ago people were making the claim but we're declining in enrollment I seem to remember that we had enrollment figures maybe just kissing 6,000 or north of that so when we talk about you know getting enrollment up are we talking about hundreds or I don't know the Thousand kids to get back where we were when we were established at the figure that we're at now say
05025 $27 because I I don't remember but those figures have to be around because they seem to remember we were in the low sixes we were definitely in the fives and now we're in the fours so if what you're saying is correct to avoid any jeopard we have to get back to the good old days and we had 5700 kids instead of 4700 kids and is that remotely doable that's something we can possibly control I know because like at some point you need to like check the break even point of like where where's the money and what expenditure and what's the right I don't want this to sound like a math G but what's the right number of students so that we can do everything we want to do and we can't control that yeah
051some of your lows you were in the high threes like some of your lows you guys were in that because again we took we take the October 1 level every year so if if October 1st happens when one sub's out and another sub hasn't moved in it does get low we kind the state of conc kind of looks like r with a little more flux than other communities because we have that and so we kind of look at like okay this could be aot what is you know October was this and we've asked Dr Ganer you know what's December to has that gone up and some years it is drastically different between October and December when we're looking at those numbers because we are very unique with our enrollment but we are we are being
052compensated for a much higher level many years ago yeah on the this part again part of my I had all this when I when I is this your last question because I want to get to my yeah no I understand okay U and that had to do with the the we talk about the military population [Music] fluctuating have we had the same fluctuation all these years or is there something different about the military fluctuation now because it's the military FL military fluctuation as a factor has always been about the same we get this many we get this many we get this many we get this but that's always sort of the background noise and really our decline in enrollment has to do with everything outside the military I'm not really interested in talking about the
053military kids that's going to be a fact of life as I said the background noise we're going to be plus minus you know a couple hundred kids I would say we've seen more fluctuation because of Economics for families trying to find affordable housing and they'll go over to New London and they'll be there for a year they'll come back here they'll go to Norwich I mean they're moving all the time to talking about military military family about I was I was simply addressing the the military fluctuation I think our military numbers have been pretty status quo over the last few years that was that was what I was that's why you call it background noise that's something you sort of assume over the decade but it does change the seating in our schools all of
054this Factor throughout the year so October one doesn't look like December doesn't look like May or March they change yeah does it matter one less thing does it matter and then I'll then I'll stop does it matter I mean do so we're we're seeing a decline in enrollment what about the state overall our overall student enrollment is not going down the same level because again you're you're being looked at in the piece of the pie so we're going down relative to the rest of the St we're going down relative to the state kind of going down generally yeah um but if you look at what happened 15 years ago if you look at how many kids did people have like we don't have to be statisticians people used to have more kids yeah you used
055to see families of three or four kids were quite common now families of one or two kids are more common enrollment is changing because of that and and there's a lot of factors as to why families when they're deciding between that second kid to go to the third or fourth most it's economical you know the cost of daycare the cost of raising a child the cost of educating a child other times people are just very fertile and have a lot of children so it doesn't mean there are some families that are very large in our town but when you look around if we were to turn back 15 years ago as to you know how many siblings do people have versus today it is less and that's enrollment we stopped the three because we were
056outnumbered okay Mike thanks and thanks for coming having this discussion with us um so before being on the board of ed just now been on the RTM for quite some time and um what what we see every year in the budget process is that um the the cost as you just mentioned to educate a student or students is rising and rising and um and there are many reasons for that the same things we feel like transportation is increasing AP partly because of um the the pay to the bus drivers and people but also just fuel costs and then that um heating cost hits us too uh these are things you need to educate uh students but aren't aren't directly related to education it's just you need that support infrastructure so I see uh our costs
057going up and up over over the years and we talked about the P for ECS funding for State educational cost share but um that pie hasn't grown right like you know we're talking about our different slices of it but that's not grown over the years and this same thing where uh relatively unique in the state of Connecticut because the uh level of federal impact Aid because of the um defense related uh institutions including the subbase but uh the federal impact Aid U it hasn't gone out commensurate with the cost that it cost to educate um students so um over what we end up seeing in the RTM is that the the town share of the budget has grown to um uh uh you know accommodate the the needed cost to educate and support our schools
058educate our students and support schools what we're looking for is uh and I know what you said about budget pressures we're looking for more help from the federal government and the state level to do that um because basically costs are going up and the only it's only at the local level that the um the support has gone up in dollar amount yeah so the state of K does not print money so I cannot make more income come to the state of Connecticut um we can raise taxes but often times folks say don't raise my state income taxes that's the only source we have to raise money is your state income taxes um the governor was very strong last year that he was not ra we actually reduced state income taxes last year for our folks
059who are at the lower end of the economics people got a reduction because of the cost of living people are saying rightfully so I'm having difficulties affording rent and affording groceries and if you can give me little more wiggle room that would help me stay in this state so we were we did lower income taxes which means our pie got a little smaller now that's okay because we're still able to do everything but if over a quarter of our state budget comes from the federal government so if that number gets reduced we cannot generate income um it will either be raise your state income taxes or reduce Services the concept of getting more State money I just want to be crystal clear I don't think that will happen and it's unfortunate my colleagues aren't with
060me that I'm the only one telling you this news um but I that's not I don't think that's a realistic budget expectation I think the realistic budget expectation for this year is a lot of concern over what's going to happen federally um and then what is the state of Connecticut going to do with its rainy day fund what are we going to support if these cuts are too big for all the M for the money in our rainy day fund over a two-year period what are we not going to be able to support the same and I know Dr acrian was here in 2015 when we had reduction in the overall ECS pot and we had we received less money the town of gr received less money and in 16 we received I think a
061two end up with a $2 million reduction your ECS that's the 25 million you're thinking of and then it went back up to 27 million those were really hard choices for prior Boards of EDS how what do we do with this um I hope we are not making those decisions over the summer I hope we're able to keep it status quo but it there is no additional money for ECS um for towns that are being held harmless and the goal is that if we redo ECS and maybe the dollar value per student changes and if your enrollment increases and all these other things so if the dollar per value student is higher and your enrollment has gone up just a little bit you've closed that Gap a little bit where eventually you'll start getting additional
062ECS dollars but right now you're still your gap's still a little bit far apart between your total student population and the amount per student student you're still not there but again we have the state has increased the amount of dollars per student you were just held harmless more than that increase so you didn't see an increase you saw a status quo um I'm not saying at all that anyone's doing anything inappropriate with funding because you're doing great things with the money you have and if you had more money you could do more things but there is a reality of funding um and we don't print money like the federal government now I'd like them to print money I'd like them to fully fund EC um special Education Services I would love them to do that
063just like everyone else would I can't make them do that I I work in Harford I don't work in DC so some of those things are are conversations um to our federal delegation so if they if the federal government fully funds special education you wouldn't have budget problems you wouldn't care about a hold harmless or an alliance District the reality is some of the the funding problems that this district and every district has are because of not being adequately funded for some federal levels for our special education students and then trying to look at other sources and saying well what about this what about that the reality is we're not properly funded in certain areas and no one is across the country because they're funding special education was it 35% of special education funded yeah
064that's moving that number to 80% would be a total different budget way total for for the kids across the country right if everyone got if people got Services they needed that would be wonderful for Education as a whole I I don't think that'll happen next year and there is excess cost for those really high um fees you know especially for children who might be outplaced but we've done a lot in Gren to try to take care of our kids with all kinds of programs for autism and for behaviors and you know really trying to make it work so they can stay in our community and we don't have those excess costs and they they can even ramp up excess costs when they're here you know depending on the IEP so Adrian do you have any
065questions um yeah actually um do we is the calculation changed at all because of our the effects that grotten seeds um because of our military population so we have a lot of housing that contributes children to the school system and there aren't any taxes paid on all of that property so there's no there's no townside income from that um and I believe the federal government um gives us back and grants what maybe 40% of the cost of the students or something like that no just $3,000 three three th do you remember um Shannon the costs that we get back in Impact aid for the military children the active duties living on um in B for baby I thought it was like $3,000 per student it's a about a total of we estimated four million but
066this year we got six million so we're going to look at that more carefully you're not just fun your folks who live in military housing you're funded for every military connected student so if you have a military family who's paying taxes and Mystic paying their full taxes you're still getting the military funded 3,000 or 4,000 whatever it is for that student so you're getting their taxes plus the military money um and it's for military connected students and parents who work on base who are civilian parents as well and those who are in um Federal um areas that Fally funded like even the casinos then they might those those get tribal impact students tribal impact tribal impact it's the same dollar value per student but tribal members if they're living in groten anywhere right we get
067the we get the impact aid for those that student and EB um if they're on the boat on October one for a certain amount of time they count that's the kind of information we have to get through the you know impact dat yeah yeah so if Mom or Dad is on you know EB going down and doing work offshore down in um you know riding down over to to Virginia on the barge and it falls on October 1st that counts for the whole year um so but that impact Aid is is a federal it's a federal program so I can't change it in any way yeah I I was just wondering if the state takes that into account that we do have the state does not take into account your your impact Aid dollars no
068that you're getting extra dollars for impact Aid to that supports the school system the state looks at each one of those the student demographics as the same as traditional student demographics they do not look at that $6 million of extra income um as extra income nor would it be any different so if those students were living in um public housing that doesn't pay taxes versus military housing that we get six million in Impact Aid they're looked at the same as those students scores that's fair and then um I I just check some numbers and I figured since we've been talking so much about decline declining enrollment um I just went back a little bit and I figure it's probably good for everybody to hear some real numbers um the it to go back to the
069200920 school year we had um 5,029 students 1415 um we had 4565 1718 was 4381 and it seems like on the state site it's been about 4,100 since 2020 I um and I know we have different numbers for that I'm not sure exactly why but maybe it has to do with the accounts you're you're out of District kids so you count your students your Gren students that go out of district oh in a different way than how the state calculat cards are going to show the kids that are actually attending in District but we're counting the ones that we're actually paying for right because those services are going you know that student is getting that service at that location and so it's looking at each student who's getting services in what town so if you
070were a receiving town you may benefit versus a sending town that was one of the desires of getting students back by increasing some of the reason um addressing some of the reasons that parents were choosing to go out of District a couple years ago we have gotten a lot of students back in my opinion more students are did come back um um with things like treehouse with with the child care needs with a lot of the needs that why parents were choosing but not you're not going to choose you're not going to solve every parents because some parents are just looking for other educational options and I get just to switch gears a little bit have you seen much of a change um in certain areas like we're obviously heav heavily tourist area and we've
071lost a lot of housing Str strs um and I know that's something that's that's coming up at the state level um is that something that the state is taking into account so whether or not someone has a child in the house versus Str Str renter owner occupied is not something the state has control over so we have a lot of renters in our area who are renting single family houses or multif family houses um some of them have children some of them don't you know but Str strs you know Str Str is a rental yeah whether it's you know short term for six months or shortterm for seven days clearly a s day you're not going to have a child in the school system but a lot of the short-term rentals aren't necessarily seven days
072yeah a lot we have a lot we have a high rental population in gr and in other towns um but we do have a very high rental population all right well thanks and I I also just wanted to kind of echo what what Jen was talking about is as a district I um strongly believe that we should improve student achievement test School scores and absenteeism um regardless of and and try to and thank you for um trying to maintain our funding um but but we as a board need to focus on you know teaching and learning yeah just don't ask to get removed early from Alliance you want to have Alliance be what it is and Chris you did you all all three of you helped us so much because in 2019 they wanted to
073graduate us if you remember I do and you came to the rescue our scores everything was going up I yes all those factors must have made a difference we got a couple blue ribbons in there but I would say that that was right before covid and my goal is to get back up where we were and even improve but that was you know like I'm not a big numbers person with test scores because I don't think by assigning a child a number you're assigning the child what their abilities are right it's a day it's you know but I think when we look at why our children some children are improving and some children were not improving the reality is our district still needs a lot of help and it and some of our children are
074exceptionally great on paper and are amazing test takers but it and some of our children have a rough time with test or had a bad day with that test but it doesn't mean that we our district needs in my opinion more State help to help us grow and to help get our students um increasing I'd love to see reading and math scores higher I'd love to see attendance rates reduce we all want to see that I want to see more children getting being ready and being prepared for adulthood we all want that I have to tell you with all these doia grants the Department of Defense is looking at not just military kids I mean we always compare that and they tend to do better than the average but now it's really for all kids
075in all areas so um we are really held you know accountable in these grants which provide the extra funding and we do look at all that information on a regular base yeah and when our students were you know when our students have struggles in some of these testings when you look at it our military kids are per pering at a higher level of the tests than a lot of the gr residents so some people say you know it's hard to move around and it's hard to to be a military kid but when you look at the test scores their test scores are higher so a lot of that achieving and overcoming is is being translated in overcoming learning and and doing well learning so our military kids are doing good our our gr and town
076and city kids and Mystic kids you know we'd like to see them do a little better and our military kids who need a little extra help we want to help them too Ian has a question yes um again thank you for for taking the time to be here and making the effort um you know I definitely uh share the concerns and and and and Echo the positions of Jen and Adrian as far as like you know and I take your point you know let's focus on teaching and learning that's what we can do and we worry about the money you know and putting to be held harmless um you know for the time being you know and I think honestly like this conversation just kind of reaffirms to me you know a broader need to
077look at something on a more macro level as far as like how education funding is determined across the board but that's a conversation that's not for this room and not for tonight and it would involve uh the federal delegation as well um and there's a lot that we don't know yet we don't know what the next year is going to look like you know after January so we have to kind of wait and see to see how it really all plays out um but um yeah so the um I did want to follow up on something uh Adrian said about the Str strs I I think you know from my perspective you know that ties into the affordable housing thing I mean housing prices have gone up astronomically around this area and and part of
078that is is the SDR Dynamic where there's there's less housing stock so there's less Supply there's more a higher price um and I agree you know with the assessment as far as affordable housing it is a a struggle in this area and um you know it would be good to see it there's a number of developments that are in Play Already um but they're not bound by any contracts to put in uh certain percentage of affordable housing at this point the ones that are in play uh there's opportunities to to to uh um you know change that moving forward but that's also like you know again years down the road um so I I appreciate everything that you've done you know to to help us out and I look forward to working with you in
079the future um so if you guys if now you guys can't change Str strr regulations but the state does allow municipalities to do SDR ordinances if they want to make it 30 days 90 days oh Andre Andre z uh for a minimum they can do that it doesn't affect the Board of Ed um Str strs are not in my district the way they are in Mystic I don't represent I don't represent the water side of mistri that is Andre's District in the 41st so I don't see the strr issue that maybe Adrian's talking about in the dayto day um because I don't have the southern part of the city of gr and I don't have what folks would consider you know Mystic proper I have um cow Hill and field crust um and that side
080of Myst doesn't have that that tourism aspect in the way that the other side does um I see Working Families every day in my district that's who I see I see military families Working Families um folks that are are getting by and doing their best to educate their kids yeah so but some of those larger houses when we look at sections of town that have larger houses there aren't many children going to public school there some of those larger houses it doesn't matter if it's a rental or an owner those kids are are not going to the public school systems if you see where the buses go and those in some of those larger communities they're not going to the public school system children are getting driven to other dis other schools so I would
081focus on teaching and learning our kids um you know supporting when we have opportunities for affordable housing supporting your town counselors when they're being asked you know not to put in 10% or 20% for affordable housing or intellectual disabled housing um and then look at some of our new building projects they all happen to be in my district um when you look at those the new apartments that are coming up there are students living and what do those students need you know do they have places to play outside of school they don't you know they're putting up 300 units across the street from me with no Park you know with a small park so when we look at the the development that came on Route 12 across the street from Belford Bey those are a
082lot of new residents that have moved there when you look at the folks that live in L Triumph when you look at the folks who live in on Mitchell Road um there's a lot of families living in those apartments and some of those families are doubling up because of financial requirements so they have you know two families in the same apartment I don't it's not called affordable on paper but it certainly is when you've got six people living in a two-bedroom we see a lot of that too with family members you know extended family members um living together so that's another way that families get by is that they you know open their home to other relatives and people so we've seen that too well just to kind of close out my comments and questions
083I just wanted again thank you for uh clarifying the fact that um you know for us to uh focus on achievement closing the achievement gaps we're not going to run the risk of uh exiting out early because there's always other characteristics to look at um and I will do some more research I am curious uh as to like finding out all the characteristics and just kind of getting a better understanding of how that works um but I do look forward to Future conversations and looking at you know maybe more uh more Progressive ways to to to address education concerns in this state as I do my research thank you um I just want to introduce Andre Gardner he just came on board thank you Andre we're talking about thank you so much i' I've uh
084experienced significant connectivity issues this evening thank you so much Madame chair uh congratulations on your new role uh congratulations to our new Vice chair as well um and just an amazing team um as we all know so much has gone on in the last couple years especially in the last year and I just want to assure this incredible Board of Education that our entire legislative delegation and thank you Chris so much for being in the building this this evening um our entire board of education has been hard at work day after day dealing with so many issues confronting our school school children um representing our community in all the best ways and I I just have to tell you you know just as public servants it isn't easy uh doing the work that you do
085right um You Have Not only meetings after meetings each week but subcommittee meetings dealing with a nuanced set of issues right uh you have curriculum committees you have uh just so many issues and so I I just want to commend you for your volunteerism because it really is a labor of love um and you're on the front lines so thank you for all that you do thank you for um our incredible Board of Ed staff uh who work day in and day out taking care of our school children but um I will not uh truly um under articulate how much is going on right now um we are experiencing a lot of change at this time so um I just want to commit to the board of ed that no matter what is happening uh
086with respect to funding with respect to uh just your dealing with your day-to-day issues I appreciate truly um all the volunteerism that you do and again um to all of the incredible Board of Ed staff that we have um thank you for everything that you're doing to protect the welfare of our our school kids um I have had the utmost privilege serving with my dear colleague Chris over the last two years uh representing our young school children on a multitude of issues um we're going into a new legislative session this year as Chris has articulated and it is so incredibly important that we continue this incredible partnership um I've been listening in I I genuinely apologize about some of the connectivity issues um but I I just want to make sure that especially since we're
087going into a new legislative session uh that is um incredibly it's incredibly important that um we understand what the financial asks are for the community um as Chris has articulated especially with respect to um the funding in place for uh HVAC right um it is really important that our Board of Ed our legislative delegation and our most importantly Our Town Council is on the same page with respect to funding for HVAC funding for air quality for school children um it remains in flux we're going to be entering potentially round three but is it again is not guaranteed um it was announced that round three may or may not happen so it is incredibly important that our school board prepares for another round for HC funding uh if it does if it doesn't happen it it
088may not happen right but in case we are entering round three it is so incredibly important that gron is prepared to make an application to the state of Connecticut um that does again require a match from the town right it will require a match in some places from the Town Council but again facilitating that conversation is critically important that where again Chris myself Senator Summers stands ready to provide assistance um again there's no Republican Democrat anything in between way to ensure that our kids are clean are breathing clean air so I can't stress enough again let's just make sure that we're all rowing in the same direction on that front um I I'm here to listen I I have listened in again but that that remains a huge focus of mine um your incredible superintendent
089and I have had have had a lot of conversations about the nice to haves and you know and that includes um some funding for for example um really incredible programs uh that students want um that would include um funding for a state-ofthe-art um culinary arts program right and that's something that has been talked about in terms of Capital Improvements uh capital projects for our youngsters um that again requires um some form of collaboration from the Town Council um as we know with capital projects it requires approval from the town manager and then approval from the Town Council as a whole but again uh given that culinary arts right the nice toab versus mus haves right clean air that's a must have but nice to have I would include in that bucket the culinary arts program
090and I think there is a lot of opportunities in the future um for our legislative delegation to collaborate um with the town Council um as we all know gron is eligible for CIF funding I would note CIF funding is eligible for both nonprofits and the Town Council technically Boards of EDS cannot apply for Sith funding but we can still engage in kind of um creative approaches to funding for for on that front so um I just stand ready again to partner in collaborative ways and um I just really want to thank each and every one of you for um being committed to uh supporting our school children there's a lot of pressures on our Board of Ed right now and um I've done an off talking I've been doing a lot of listening and I
091again apologize for my tardiness but uh here to answer any questions you may have Sam do you want to talk about the HVAC system and the culinary arts program at the high school I'm not really prepared to talk about culinary arts other than the fact that we did submit it in the CIP again this year did you hear that Andre yes I did and I would only mention um thank you so much for that answer um I I would just only mention again with with capital projects it requires again significant uh partnership from Our Town Council and and obviously collaboration from the town manager but uh can you also um Sam can you speak to the fact that what's unique about the culinary arts program is that slam for example completed a uh a study
092of uh you know of that plan um they also if if I'm not mistaken um you know slam meaning you've collaborated with um the folks who were responsible for the nuts and bolts of the school construction project um they've done schematic designs and I so I just want to um kind of preface it with that the town of gron has already done the necessary groundwork to necessitate funding uh for that program in the future right through um you know extensive schematic plans already I think we took care of that in one of the board budgets a few years ago we do have those plans we're really taking the space that we have and and repurposing it we've also used Perkins grants to buy some stoves and sinks and things to bring that up to code
093so we've done it in multiple ways but I think that re purposing that space will allow more students to be College and Career ready and we know that the careers in the restaurant business are you know we have so many um possibilities for our students and um it's really a very popular course we have several levels of the culinary arts and um we really want to you know also get back to opening up that you know Cafe that we had so that we can bring other people into the school so that they can you know um experience that I think that would be really a cool thing and maybe that's what we have to do kind of getting ready for this but um a lot of people will say that Gro already has a program
094but all of our fch Falcons can't fit into Gro for that program but they all you know it's such a popular course that it's almost like every kid in that school wants to have at least a semester course and there's some who want to make that their career so I think important but we are looking at Perkins grants to help support some of the equipment but this would help really repurpose that space so that more kids could participate how much was that CIP for the culinary arts program Sam do you know 600,000 six so 600,000 did you hear that Andre yes I'm aware okay yes and thank you madam chair and congratulations on your new role and with some of the grants do Reach Out out to the delegation to support the grants um it
095is something with your state grants that is heavily looked on is do you have letters of support from the delegation I've have not been asked to sign on to a state Grant letter from the town of gr and I know that's something we talked about as a delegation um in a quite a long time so as you're doing your state grants reach out to the whole delegation we support these from our other school districts uh ask us we often get asked I get asked in my other District to sign on to federal grants as well you know the more the marrier the more that pile on and say this is a good thing never said no to a school project right now the Perkins is a categorical so somehow they figure out the funding source
096based probably on I don't know many factors so and Title One is the same thing and some of those grants we've seen some increases and some we've seen some decreases so I don't know if that would help like if you wrote if that would help us with the funding compe anything that's a competitive Grant letters of support from the delegation are okay a factor looked at if if you're leaving money on the table because you didn't ask for a letter of support don't do it okay got it absolutely we do them as a group letter all the time yeah no and I I I would like to align myself with with um my my good colleague on the other side of uh of of Gren so to speak um you know and I would just
097preface it all again saying um the nice to haves versus must haves right and and not to say that um a you know State of the State of the art culinary program is a nice to have but uh in the whole scheme of things when we Benchmark it against um you know our just uh the incredible importance to ensure that every school in our district has clean air right that is not a nice app that is a must have um and so you know um it is again not an ask to the entire delegation but it's still something to consider in the future in in the totality of of the As forr and I I will always say we must always a punch above our weight class right always you know aim for the highest
098there's so always so many different grant opportunities on the table and uh the one thing about Chris and I is that we will never hesitate to share that with the entire Board of Education consistently and our entire town as a whole uh to ensure that whether it's nice to have or mus haves we're um you know punching above our weight class to ensure that our school kiddos uh get the best Services possible and in doing so you know we just again continuing to make critical investments in our um you know our school district and it's really important that our entire legislative delegation sener sumers myself and um you know obviously in um representative Conley who's been so consistent in supporting our school kiddos um making sure that we're just at the table uh in the
099room and to provide assistance to your um you know to you in the work you're doing so I had a question for both of you we've noticed the electric bill going up and up with eversource and this year in particular we've been charged for um during pandemic when people couldn't pay their bills they're now putting it on the taxpayers and the you know the school districts so even nonprofits are getting additional bills and it looks like this year we're predicting that it could be as high as $493,000 um not just the additional but just the the escalated cost of ever source and then with that on top of it we are starting to see some of the solar panel um you know coming towards us and it's supposed to help offset that bill a little
100bit but it's like uh what we've seen so far is like $15,000 from you know the three schools that are you know have the solar panels it's wonderful be in gr Municipal electricity isn't it so for the so where folks I think there's some misconceptions about that increased cost the majority of that increased cost is not covid it is a 2017 bill that Millstone asked for additional funding to keep Millstone open and keep jobs in Eastern Connecticut so in 2017 when when I voted on it and Joe voted on it and had they voted on it we did not know Co there was no thoughts of Co if there was we would have all stocked up on you know clorex and toilet paper right so most of that money is for the millstone expansion um
101and that was set out into everyone who has um eversource and UI basically everyone who doesn't have n electricity each paid a portion in so that Millstone had a set rate and they were able to get their funding from their hedge fund and how all that electricity works nationally um what did happen is Pur did add to that cost the covid um amounts but that is not the majority of it you would still have seen an increase and you would have still seen that increase but that does keep parents employed in your in our district um so that while that was a big discussion Point um in the news over the summer and over election time about covid there was some truth to that and there was unfortunately some inflation which happen sometimes in politics
102acting as if all that money is co money now could Pura and will we address electricity I expect us to address electricity in this session um Pura did make it a 10mon period of time and we could stretch that out to like a 24mon period of time would bring those down for everyone um but you know your electricity is a lot more expensive in your eversource area than it is in your gr utilities area in my district most people have gr utilities it's wonderful yeah um so but those are some of the things that are increasing are there are some set costs like you got to keep got to keep the lights on in the building for the students to learn we do have less lights going on at Grant Middle School though I check
103them out every time and there's just fewer and fewer so it's not like the beacon of light that it used to be it still has to keep on some lights but it's definitely changed I've noticed some improvement and and represen obviously representative Conley's preing the choir here um I would just know you know as she mentioned she she was um in the house when um All That Jazz H was happening with respect to um that very critically important bill uh to ensure that um we pect jobs here in South Eastern Connecticut with Millstone had I been in the legislature like Chris I would have voted yes um but um you know while I was on the council I would know um one of the things I learned from our former mayor um Patrice granoski is
104that uh no matter the circumstances whether you're in the green or in the red um you have to think critically about supporting our our school kid OES especially with respect to capital projects so um I'm very proud while on the council along with Council councelor bordon and former mayor Juan Mendez to again emphatically and consistently supporting CIP projects for the the the town of Gren and it's so critically important again to have that partnership with our Town Council uh to ensure that when it comes to CIP projects capital projects that they are Partners in this right and they're willing to make those matches when it counts um so again it takes Partnerships it's not just one group versus the other it it works it it requires all of us to row in the same direction
105and the beauty of living in a community that has a public utility is that we have the ability uh to create programs that are Innovative in their own right right that is what makes Groton utilities unique is that they are uh their own Municipal utility uh their own local leadership that understands our unique areas of our community therefore uh it enables um unique collaboration Partnerships among our school district and I think there's a lot of opportunities with respect to energy Creation with our schools obviously we've seen that with um our um our uh you know our Middle School um utilizing um Partnerships uh or utilizing programs um with our with Pura right that have enabled investment from the Green Bank that allowed us to have solar panels on our rooftops right at our middle school
106and why not have that throughout all of the school districts um that are cited in Gren utilities as well so I think there's a lot of opportunities for again future partnership but again that requires really critical uh concerted Partnerships and efforts to uh site solar panels on the Gren Utility side and I think that could also achieve significant Savings in the long run but it requires conversation um so I stand ready to have have the conversation Chris uh and nauseum always stands ready to have those conversations um but um you know any effort we can take to reduce energy prices for the town whether it's on the Gren Utility side or ever eversource side side um I stay ready to engage in those conversations I would also note uh this legislative session uh I will
107be serving as the vice chair of the environment committee um but I've also beeno appointed to the energy and Technology committee which has oversight over uh energy policy for the state of Connecticut so um I I look forward to engaging these conversations and again there's no stupid question to ask or have um especially um when it pertains to energy policy so um again just um commit to you each of you that um I'll be a partner on that front thank you Andre the other escalating cost is transportation oh did you want to speak about that sorry yeah I just wanted to follow up on the uh thank you thank you beev um on the eversource question um our financial uh director did identify the pandemic recruitment fees as uh as a driver in our increased
108electrical costs that's what they had reported to us the eversource in the letter that that's what's driving the cost and and I I thought we were going to get some firm numbers on that as far as I just gave it to you that was the 15,000 for school was all pandemic recruitment fees it's or was that wrapped up in the other thing oh yeah was it's four so the total electric bill projection for this year is $493,000 over so you have any idea what percentage is pandemic recruitment fees we've only gotten about1 155,000 but they're going to be um you know periodically we're going to have to be paying towards that okay so I guess my question for the delegation would be um you know seeing as how a board of education you know is
109a public service um is there any uh any state level action that could be taken to relieve us of our burden uh to pay back pay these pandemic recruitment fees so you're not being charged pandemic recruitment fees separate that's what I think there was that's where the misunderstanding and the false information are as part of the increase in bills there is a line item that has Millstone and the pandemic in there most of that money is Millstone it's not separated out separated out I don't have that Authority eliminated no I don't have that Authority because the millstone passed um so Pura is not just as far as like numerically speaking can we get numers separated I don't have that Authority an I don't know how to say that a different way well I I I
110don't understand I don't know it's a matter of authority it's a matter of math no I don't have access to it you don't see you see one charge the district sees one charge the bills which are not set by the state of Connecticut in any way do not have those charges separate so everyone who has an eversource Ever source that combines the numbers and they won't relinquish the information I don't have the access I don't have any access to that information from a private company in the state of Connecticut I don't have the means to get that information from a private company so but if folks are quoting that increase that increase is predominantly Millstone and that was the 2017 Bill way before Co and so will Pur change I'd like them to will there
111be some legislation on that and discussions with Pur continued discussions with Pur about the covid because again I live in gr and utilities folks in gr and utilities are not getting that charge but also we're not getting folks who who are having struggles with covid did not get any part of their bills forgiven there's no difference in me if you live on my street versus if you live three streets down the road folks are having very different um costs well I would just shift the question then to representative bum Garder then um in your seat on the energy and Technology uh you said you might have um some opportunity to ask some critical questions and take some action is there anything that could be done as far as like trying to inquire after eversource to
112differentiate those numbers and create a separation between what is Millstone and what is pandemic recruitment ever Source doesn't go before the energy and Technology committee they're a private company Pur has some oversight there p is not oversight by the general assembly they're oversight overseen by the government the governor only I did have a bill to change that but it did not get picked up um unfort was that last year I put in a bill to um in 2021 to bring Pura in under the general assembly so again as much as we discuss and we can legislate some things and we did um five or six different bills over the course of my time there at the general assembly to try to help with the eversource we we made their lobbying costs not be allowed to
113be transferred to Consumers there are some areas that we can regulate electricity but it is not we do not have control over Pura we do not have control over their day-to-day they are a for-profit corporation that happens to be within the state of Connecticut so they do not have any legal requirement to open their books to us to answer us now we can choose not to give them additional grants or offer things um and they have not been given very many grants at all but if you look at the paper you know every time Pura says no to them they call for the the chairperson of Pura to be fired by the governor every single time they just did it last week when Pur was being stronger to them and then their um their profit
114margin changed their projections were changing if some of the P regulations came they all called last week and said fire them fire them fire them um electricity Pur is very complicated very strong um they're strong lobbyists we again we don't let them pass their lobbying dollars onto ta onto the the rate payers but no we don't have the ability to control them we don't have the ability to call them in for a public hearing like we have the ability to call in state departments and is there any ability to like pass a law that requires um more articulation on the bills they're a private company they're private they're not public oh I guess all right well this conversation definitely again highlights an area of of great concern I guess in depending on for-profit companies essential
115services so thank you and I I think you both both hit hit the nail right on the head uh you know as CH Chris mentioned they're very much a private company right uh there's only so much the legislative delegation can do uh as much as eversource uh you know the the number one lobbying class of uh the legislature is the hospital Association right but not too far behind is uh eversource and they have a significant uh lobbying structure in the state of Connecticut but I will also know as does uh ever Source uh Granton utilities has a very strong lobbying core as well uh and they've done incredible work to ensure that our rates continue to be low some of the lowest rates that our state sees in uh the entire again the state of
116Connecticut uh at a time when ever Source nearly doubled rates right this is why we're having the conversation about those crazy utility costs brought in utilities lowered rates to the tune of 99.5% and that is something to celebrate uh that is something I think to recognize uh that would only happen because uh they are a public utility all profits are reinvested in invested back into the grid rein reinvested back into the workforce reinvested back um into uh the entire uh system and that is something to celebrate um but again uh that does not happen by accident that happens because uh we have incredible an incredible legislative delegation uh that supports the work of Bren utilities at the state level uh we have very robust leadership at the local level uh with the city of gron
117and most importantly we have uh rate payers that uh very much support our governance structure and will never support um a eliminating uh the uh again the uh utility very unique utility structure that we have um I am someone who believes that um we should consider uh changes down the road um you know grotten uh 100% of groten is not grotten utilities uh it is something that I would love to see down the road right um but again that is just not real realistic at this time um so you know I I very much would implore the Board of Ed to think critically about how we can reduce energy costs with respect to our schools in uh the eversource electric service area and again our our legis ative delegations very much stands ready to engage
118in those conversations and um have the back of the school board on that front to ensure that our school board can reduce energy costs we have much appreciated thank you another Susan to let so with transportation of course we had increased costs due to a contract which they you know we had only two bids and they both came in high but we took the lower bid but in addition to that we have um um the excess or extra cost with special education and the curtain um system and we have I think three or four different systems that we use and we have children who sometimes travel you know across the state and I you know and it's a hardship you know it's on a hardship on the children as well to have to travel but
119to get to some of those sites and those costs seem to be escalating as well I think when we look at the budget we may be been seeing a something near $250,000 overage between those two factors but we're keeping a close eye on it and we're trying to encumber as much as we can but you could have a child moving in from Hawaii military that um you know in their IEP they need a certain level of care and they might have to be transported to another school somewhere to meet the needs so we do look at that with each new IEP but those costs do seem to escalate and our cost um per pupil for special ed is was really pretty high so um I don't know if there's any legislation about helping to support
120those excess costs in special education as we seem to be having more and more students identified I think we're up to about 20% um special ed and so I mean a part of that I think has to do with military population this is a very good place to be um we have really Wonder ful resources in special ed a lot of families choose to live here and go on multiple tours of Duty because of that or come back to grotten because of the services that's what we've been told by Miranda and a few others but um you know it just seems like a lot of that movement in and out that 800 that you know come to us and the 700 that leave going back and forth we do seem to keep a lot of
121the special needs students with us and um there is that significant cost that goes with it yeah I would caution describing any one group of students as more special education or more needy than others um I think that that group of students doesn't appreciate that if I'm not saying they're more but we do notice military families who choose to come to Groton and have children and it's actually listed as one of those preferred communities for them our education system in the state of Connecticut is better than education systems and other base locations where bases are um as a whole I think the desire for Connecticut education amongst military students is the desire to be in a I'd rather be in Connecticut than a lot of the states that other military bases are and I'm saying
122that knowing what's happening in other districts nearby that those statements have been used in a very negative way towards folks who have disabilities again our military students test scores are higher than the student test scores for the town of gr um so to be accurate about you know who needs most I think our town of Gren kids and our military kids both need access to services but if we're going to talk about um who has more special needs let's try to use percentages and data so that we're not having falsehoods said about different groups of folks that that could be seen as unfair so in the military though their kids with special needs so that they do give them priority in placement so just to know that that is something that the military does yeah
123but I do I think you know I would love to see more Federal money going to special education like we went over that before the fact that the federal government funds each and every state at 35% I think is disgusting I do not work for the federal government or represent there um I if there is an issue I could see an issue with a transportation out of District as being a regional request is I haven't on the last cave list I haven't seen that request but that might be an opportunity to get some Regional resources there because every District you know kids are going to the school for the death death from a lot of districts and each one of those children is getting transported from their home District that's a good idea I know
124some people that learned yeah know that's a good idea that could be a good opportunity for some sort of a grant Pro process or something where folks could get their paret a share that's a that's fairly distributed amongst a multitude of districts and assist in that way good idea and certainly point point well made by uh representative Conley um I would just note as um uh the daughter of a former Admiral uh and just again someone who has been consistently uh supportive of our uh special needs children I can just again speak to that from personal experience U my brother uh who has autism who has gone through a Grant Public Schools um has uh and some right uh it is not easy right it is so nuanced um you are uh constantly dealing with
125the hand you are dealt right as much as um we think the school board has control over their own finances we all know that is not the case right you have a lot of Partners in the process um and so you deal with the hand you are dealt and I would just note that uh in terms of the hand that gron is consistently dealt uh Granton punches above its weight class to ensure that every child who has special needs has the care that they need to succeed um and so I just want to commend uh the leadership of our school board and certainly superintendent Austin for consistently fighting for our children with special needs uh it is something that is not negotiable um one issue that um I would um like to introduce right is
126that the state of Connecticut does not subsidize special education cost of the tune of 100% uh I think long term that is something the state must look at that is obviously a huge fiscal note for the state of Connecticut that we would have to wrap our minds Around It is Well above my pig rate to address but I fundamentally believe uh in order to address some of the issues that representative Conley just outlined right and that we all know in our Parts in terms of ensuring that every school child has the services that they need to succeed irrespective of what school district they live in the line share of that would require our state of Connecticut to pick up those costs right um it is uh just I think unrealistic to place that burden on
127our school boards to ensure that our our school children especially our most vulnerable school children who have autism who have Down syndrome who have any form of Developmental Disabilities it is incredibly in crucial that in the long term our state covers those costs um so it is something I would implore our state to do uh should any proposal come before our legislature to move in that direction I would very much support it but I I fundamentally believe it's something the state of Connecticut should uh again think about in the long-term basis it may not be something we address this legislative session I certainly wouldn't commit uh you know commit to that and I'm in no position to do that but it's it's something I I fundamentally believe would make a huge difference for uh your
128school budgets but also in terms of your your governance um because again uh no matter the costs I know superintendent Austin and the entire school board will always make the decisions that are in the best interest of our our school kiddos thank you Andre okay it's almost 8 o' and Chris has almost been here for two hours wow so go around one last time something quick that you might want to address with Chris you want to go first Dean or yeah I'll go for some pass okay thank you Dean um again probably just some more of a moonshot comment question um one thing uh that's been discussed Loosely around here is is the idea of uh right now I mean the municipal municipality is a primary fiduciary for for us and uh they um seem
129to hold do a lot of internal bookkeeping um and uh we've had some trouble as far as getting like good data as far as like status of accounts from time to time um so one of the things I was looking to get some information on uh maybe some assistance from the state level is like looking at ways uh a board of ed could have or like Board of Ed accounts that are being managed or being managed by the town they manage the financials but can they be separated from the general funds so that it's easier to get a just a clear debit credit statement of like what's gone in the account what's gone out the account on a monthly basis or quarterly basis so I don't see the state of Connecticut doing that and the
130reason is Boards of educations are so diverse amongst our state of Connecticut so we have to make rules that are laws and funding laws that are applied equally to every District so have districts you have towns in the state of Kut that don't have a school system and those students are funded and then the money would go to a school you have towns that have a k through eight system and then they pay into a Regional High School program each student lives in a town but not each student goes to that board of education so if you have kids here that you know go to Ledger for uh V for boag Ledger you know so the Gren kid the grotten resident get money in the town that they live that's where their money goes and
131then that money has to go to the appropriate School District again we have a variety of school districts and while you may be looking at the needs that you see in struggles between this Board of Ed and This Town Council the state cannot solve all those struggles because of the variety of school districts we have um the state has to do what's most fair for everyone and that is every student is a resident of a town and that's how the money gets divided up to the town now if you are having struggles I would encourage more discussions between the Board of Ed and the Town Council more discussions between Susan Austin and John BT to try to get over those struggles if you feel you need legislative help I'm sure we'd be willing to help
132you with that um but we can I the bookkeeping nightmare of how all the school districts and how every town proportionately pays to you would see negative effects to that if you only got your gr kids money from your Gren Board of Ed um you would see a negative to that um and I can add that one of the things that we feel the board has suggested and we feel and I've talked to John Bird about is moving to a software like am munus which they used to and now having a business director who's very familiar with that a couple of them and has really um and and Clint Kennedy who has looked into that too and has had work that that when those two vehicles are the same and they can talk to one
133another other I think that's going to help us immensely in communicating the e finance system that we have is a little cumbersome and um it doesn't always talk nicely to Im munist so we we have to go through a lot of Hoops to make that work and I think looking at the endgame of really changing a software that might communicate better is really the ideal I think in this situation in collaboration so um yeah and if I mean that's something we're contemplating and if you're you're looking for Grants again Ask to support those grants so you can get your software upgrade if you know I know you've had a variety of business managers here and how everyone budgets even though you're budgeting you can budget differently and how you encumber funds is different from person
134to person and how that looks when you're pulling reports from multiple people into multiple computer system I think all of those things together have equated to some of your budget struggles and your communication struggles about funding and what what lines over and under different periods of time as your staff has been transitioning hopefully some steady staff will solve some of those problems um and maybe a computer upgrades needed too I think that's true well appreciate that and I definitely duly noted that it's primarily a municipal and Board of Ed situation to negotiate a resolution to thank you ajan you have anything yeah um I was uh very happy to hear you talk about special ed Andre um I think that uh the state um funding special ed um you know more fairly I guess um
135would be huge for Boards of Ed um because as we know when we get a new specialed student if we have to pay out of out of District tuition that's a $100 or $100,000 or whatever it is um that pulls away from everything else because we are on a fixed budget we started the year with a budget and we need to finish the year on that budget and um taking out some of that variability um will also um it will bring a little bit of equality into education so I I really hope that um you know I know that that's not going to happen this year um but I do appreciate that that thought that we're thinking about that and the substantial B bulk of special ed money is federal the state is pennies because
136the Federal Law requires the federal government to pay for special education and they have not met that that they have not been following that law since probably since public education came about maybe the first year of public education they followed LA but after that for decades and decades the federal government is failing us all of us across the entire country of funding special education yeah but maybe the state and I I would just know just you know due to Federal funding I mean if if we're going to assess things on that basis then you know quite frankly it it would uh you know let's be honest you know when it comes to any form of federal funding especially with respect to uh the multitude of uh school children who are not originally from Gren or
137born in uh Lawrence Memorial Hospital but came here by way of uh the Navy by way of uh their orders right um still it's not negotiable to ensure that those school children are their education needs are met right um so whether we get um the aid from the federal government or not um It's Our obligation to ensure that those School kiddos get the best education that they deserve um and so you know it really is important I think to elevate that conversation certainly appreciate it and just to Har back on on the comments on from uh representative Tom uh repres uh representative Thomas dating myself here uh uh Board of Ed education member Thomas it's so incredibly important that um we again all R the same direction and and it's all about Partnerships right um
138when school boards run in the same direction Our Town councils run in the same direction and our legislative delegations rowing in the same direction uh the uh only constituency that stands to benefit the most is our school kiddos thank you Andre Dr a you have anything no just thank you so much thanks Jen you have anything else course no I'm just kidding thank you um thank you for sharing your Insight regarding you know the liance district I am one of those people who don't like oh who don't like that little um you know umal tial so thanks for sharing oh you want to share Sor show you microphone no I just want to thank both of our representatives for coming here and uh appreciate the elimination thank you and I have a small suggestion about
139the student I see there's a deficit in the student meals account yeah as someone who doesn't have children in the system but would be willing to contribute if known I think there's a lot of folks who either their children have aged out or they don't have kids in the system and if there was a way that um it could get through either on your newsletter for folks who find themselves with a little extra could put in I think a lot of folks would but I think there's probably you know if there's a way maybe longterm not shortterm to get that figured out so folks who find themselves a lot of folks feel like you know it's if someone doesn't have school meals um it does cost $90 million do School meals for the state of
140Connecticut so that is a a big number and is that for everybody for free that's for everyone for free is 90 million per year so we don't have that extra dollar and I would not want to take that dollars away from things like special education and and other school funding and other programs um but we do have folks here in districts that could help contribute if there's a way long-term to find a way that um it could be posted I know other states have figured that out or other districts have figured that out folks who may either in the district or out of the district could donate if they would we were almost at60 um ,000 last year but through the generosity of so many people who came forward and some of the fundraising that
141Ernie kashmeer did um we really were just 10 million after all of that so that is a good idea 10,000 sorry 10,000 um but you're right that's and we have now five of our seven schools Community eligible thank you all also to Ernie kashmeer and his hard work with the team to ensure that we you know Fitch does not have to pay grotten middle DK FES River and Mystic River but Nea and Charles barnham still does and there's still that issue with military kids not getting SNAP benefits because they have TR care and not Husky and having parents deployed up to seven months in a year makes it harder to fill in those forms and sometimes the pride too not wanting to fill out the forms so you know it would be great if if
142we you know could do more because the military families are all eligible for SNAP programs but kids who have husky are automatically enrolled in staff right because the finan the family um financials are in the Husky program so they're just automatically enrolled our Tricare kids they're not automatically enrolled because the state doesn't have and that's the issue that it's not automatic so folks do have to fill out the form and it's hard to F if your parents away um we may not have and some folks who are eligible choose not to fill out the form and some folks are just too busy and can't get to it but in the end the kid needs lunch so I'm glad that our kids aren't none of our kids are being deprived lunch um none of them and
143and super super well articulated by representative con conell really nothing to add there I'm very much uh you know apprecia to the choir here to superintendent Austin but um I just want to truly commend Ernie koser for again punching above his weight class right terms of fighting for um you know ensuring that we reduce uh the cost for providing meals to our school kiddos uh and that um really again Innovative idea to ensure that the bulk of our school kiddos have free School meals um was just such an Innovative approach to uh to policymaking Ernie is on the front lines uh when it comes to State policy on um ensuring that every school child has access to school meals whether it's breakfast lunch Etc snacks uh and not just snacks but healthy snacks uh local
144made snacks and one thing as as a member of the environment committee and now Vice chair I'm very interested in the farm to school movement um so to the extent that really gron can continue to be leaders on that front uh St ready uh to provide assistance and uh again push forward some innovative ideas on that front and um here to again be a partner to the uh grun board event on that front well I will definitely reach out because there's some State competitive grants and I will ask for your support and Shannon weel's right here with me so is here in this too so we will absolutely I would love to see a universal prek and see some of those Smart Start dollars for Early Childhood so we've got lots of wishes so we
145will definitely be in touch I will be in touch they'll write the letters we write the letters we do them as joint letters we do it all we're happy to do it you're never you're never bothering us when you ask us to sign a letter and we much appreciated happy to help to get some grants some more grants the more money you have the more you can do I know Chris can I um uh ask you about the state partnership plan I think that was a concern of Ian at one point we had a presentation from my health insurance consultant and excuse me nothing and um I think Ian had a concern about this state partnership plan so can you tell us more about that plan I mean well the concern was just tangential related
146to the mpg the Consultants the town hires uh they made some mention about concerns about some reporting transparencies but I honestly I reviewed their comments and I did some research I can't find what I haven't found no news stories about any transparency concerns so like I don't know what they were talking about in regards to that but I'm wondering if if there was something that's something I missed or no the com controller's office does our state of Connecticut Healthcare program for state workers um and the partnership program there's there's luckily no concern about transparency Statewide um Sean Sean's office is being run very well um but I do know sometimes when you have private Consultants that are trying to sell you multiple products regardless of what it is sometimes they say things that one product
147is better than another or one concern is different I would take that as a salesperson response um the Board of Ed by the last time I I know last year when it was priced out the Board of Ed would save money by getting on the partnership plan the town of gron would that plan would be more expensive for the town of Granton and peise and what you currently have now what the board of red and the town of Gren should do together I will leave that in your trusted hands we are here to make sure that you know you have access to the partnership plan it is a good plan I recommend and I've recommended since I was on RTM a very long time ago I won't say how many years ago um that we
148should 10 years over 10 years ago that we should be pricing out the programs often um I remember we did that one year and got a better price in the partnership plan and then the folks who did the health insurance for the town the Board of Ed went back to the Blue Cross Blue Shield vendor and the Blue Cross Blue Shield vendor beat that price oh there you go so you got the best of both worlds you found out that you know it could have been cheaper and then in the end it was even cheaper for everybody so it was better so I think I look at purchasing health insurance just like purchasing car insurance or purchasing anything else shop around get your quotes y you're right see what suits you best again the last
149we did it last year where we priced out the partnership plan in the board bed would have saved money the town would have it would have been more expensive and again I I will let you guys deal with those things um you know I I believe you do have to be on the same page with that we want to get reach out to our um unions too and our Union leadership so at least they'll have the information and they can have a conversation with us and I believe there's also a concern for the retirees yeah right re yeah we don't want to leave them out right yes and and nothing to add here but again um in complete alignment with my good colleague in the 40th price out your health insurance you for clarifying that
150concern yeah no Sean Sean's office is great and if folks have additional questions reach out to Sean um Sean scalen directly or if you'd like our help we can help too if you're if you find yourself um having troubles with that but it's a very good office and he's been huge on transparency in that department most prices and most things are available online I know the quotes you got within 24 hours so if you need fast quote we can help you thank you and one last question from Matthew yes you mentioned Chris that uh there are some school districts that have figured out how to recruit donations to offset meals if you have any particular ideas of which districts we could reach out for so we can get further information we'd be grateful to see
151I'll look online but I know some districts are accepting online donations um for folks so I know there is a way to do it I don't know if you're Municipal C code or if it's a techn ology issue um or even if folks have to come down here with a check that's what they've done if you very generously if you get it out the word that you have $10,000 short and we can spread it through H where to make your check payable to mail it to drop it off I know there are people in the community that would donate but again if your kids aren't in the school system you wouldn't know what to do so it sounds like a referral for theun yes and and really great Point made by again Chris by Chris
152but um you know once a month we hear on that you know folks who who um have no other time other than watch every single town meeting in gron we all know every month in in the Town Council uh during our Town Council meetings they read a plethora of names uh that have contributed to various uh Town funds to ensure that um we have robust funding for um energy assistance for Human Services and so that that's just something to consider I I know in my heart there are no shortage of community members that would be willing to also provide their own personal uh funding on on that front too so it's just something to consider as well um you know as we're um you know um thinking about budget making and um uh every possible
153tool at our disposal to ensure that our uh School kiddos have no shortage of opportunities and I know you have your your newsletter that goes out every week I read it I know a lot of people do read it a little wordy newsletters are never too worri mad super communicate with people so see what's happening pictures are great some of them I take myself and some Mark takes if you want to spend a special email out just about that maybe yeah you know where to donate how to donate if you can do it online or check or cash or how it works I know people if people knew you were struggling with feeding kids people would be donating that's a great idea and Andre we do recognize people at a regular board meeting who have
154contributed um for different things a laptop or trips or whatever we do recognize them all right well thank you Chris you very much for coming thank you Andre thank you you Andre than you madam chair and again congrat congratulations congratulations to the new leaders new leadership team uh we beat ourselves so much in in local government we all forget uh that this is a labor of love at the end of the day this is again I've said it at nauseum it is for our school kiddos and I know uh no matter the struggles each and every one of you have not lost sight of that and so I just want to thank you for your continued volunteerism I want to thank every single um employee of our school board teachers our central office staff uh
155and everyone in between um it is uh it is so important we all Row in the same direction in the benefit of um every single child in our school system so I just want to thank you all from the bottom my heart and uh pledge to all of you that I'll continue working with our incredible local delegation to find on your have now my question is should this only be an annual meeting or should we meet more than once a year I'm just trying to get a feel of it you can call us anytime you wish um note that once we get into session we all do sit on different committees um and that does require us to be in Harford on different days so it does get difficult for us to get back here
156by 6 um but it doesn't mean that you email call if you want to do a zoom with us again I know when we've had budget troubles before we were calling this superintendent all hours of the day and night um we won't bother you guys in the day and night but any questions you have reach out to us we're around we're available getting us physically here at six o'clock between January and June is difficult um but we do the best we can and sometimes we send one to represent all three in person and we can offset that but we are um we will get very quickly into committee meetings that do go a little bit late um of the Committees we are in so Andre you're in three committees right four this year for this
157year I don't have my assignments yet because I'm on um committees that meet different days so the Committees that meet the days Andre is there they announced today I'm sure I'll I think I'll be known to this week I'll find out um and I know the Senators are on at least six or seven committees wow so there because there's less of them and more committees it's just how the math Works um and Chris Chris S herself a little short here because she leads the committee uh of all committees right that reviews the bills for all of the committee so uh and the whole scheme of things you know whether she serves on one two three five it really doesn't matter because we all know uh there's a considerable amount of time spent working on screening
158um and so you know again when it pertains to just again this meeting tonight I think at a bare minimum uh once a year uh certainly suffices and it's incredibly important that each of us have the FaceTime with the board of bed leading up to the legislative session so Chris is in the room uh Chris again very much appreciate you for taking one for the team uh this evening um but again um you know it's so important that all of us participate at least once a year in a public fashion like this so thank you for for for your opportunity to um allow us to to or for including us in your meeting this evening well I want to thank you because any time I call you pick up the phone and I really appreciate
159it and you kind of give me some good insight to things so and I know our other districts sometimes they'll call they'll say you know is there some that can go on in the morning I know you guys a lot of you work too so it doesn't mean that everyone can come when we say we you know we need to have a question but we know there's enough voices who can be morning lunchtime afternoon to talk about things so reach out when it works for you and we'll help um and come but you definitely have us to come at least once a year yeah um but if you're waiting on the day that we can all come during the middle of budget time don't wait on just like I know New London does all the
160time what time can we do tomorrow and we'll find a 15minute period that we pop on okay with this with mostly the staff but they get the questions of the elected officials to us as well okay well thank you very much see you soon all right thank you have a good session thanks guys thank you Andre have a good trip there a lot to update you on all right talk to you when you get home we'll do okay next one agenda is if we could do Shannon with okay Shannon you want to do electric bus do you mind Sam if we let shann ladies first a Sam all right retrograde if that's still appropriate Sam says she's to staying with us what uh sure yeah so good evening everyone um hopefully this will be pretty
161quick um so we are considering applying to a um program through the Environmental Protection Agency it would be um it's a rebate program so kind of similar to a grant except the application process is much easier um and it is their clean School Bus program so they are providing funds for school districts to purchase electric buses um so uh basically they cover the entire cost of the bus uh and we would have to um turn in three of our retired buses um it's a lottery so it like I said it's a very simple application um and then we will get priority um we are considered a priority District based on our demographics um and our geographic location and they will will cover up to 325,000 per bus um we talked about what we would be
162interested in purchasing if we were awarded the rebate and determined that um you know rather than we we could purchase up to 50 buses but we decided we would start slow um since this is New Territory for us and uh perhaps get three um of the mini buses which we could use for uh after school activities and for uh field trips during the day um we already have the infrastructure uh to plug them in uh there's a couple buses um that other school districts are using right now uh Ford has a model uh another popular one is I included it in your packet um oh I only included a copy of the the Ford but there's another one called Bluebird I think that's very popular um but we would look into that more um so
163in order to proceed with the application we would need a commitment letter from the board [Music] um if we were to be awarded the rebate we still have the opportunity to back out of it if we change our mind so there's really no risk for us at this point I included a copy of the commitment letter that a representative of the board would need to sign the uh application is due June 9th so we have a little bit of time to think about it but would certainly want to get it in um as soon as we get back from break would do we need to talk to S oh did I say June 9th January 9th janary sorry yeah Sam we need to talk to sta in any way or would this be just owned
164by gron public schools or I I I believe that we could own the buses they uh have already said that they could provide drivers for us um but as um Shannon and I talked about briefly I I would still uh like to te uh talk to the STA management and see whether um if we had drivers of our own for instance coaches uh the drive them I think about the band and a lot of other places that could really use something like this so you need a special license for it but it's easy to get um so it if we could do that um that would be helpful too I think would relieve some of the pressure on sta too for getting some of these smaller teams to events a swim team perhaps some of
165the smaller teams to events but Channon did you say that um we would have to turn in three three of our buses uh yes now that's St though right we don't have buses do we we don't own any buses right now so I guess we'd have to verify that it would be okay to turn in three of the I don't know if you've seen the buses that are Mary Morris offline now they're at Mary Morrison being stored before they're sold off so I think um SDA would probably allow us to trade those in for something if if they agree to the program okay and you talked to grisal and they're finally getting theirs now it took them a long time now I think yeah so uh griswell did it a little bit differently they had
166SDA submit the application and um they're still waiting for their buses so I guess there's quite a bit of back order with them any questions Adrian yeah one um I know that it's a big undertaking um because we don't know exactly how this is going to work but um is there risk in only going for three now if there's if 's funding available um as what happens with funding is sometimes it disappears so is there risk that this funding might just go away and we might be um leaving like an important investment on the table by only um taking three mini buses and not really taking um you know kind of the the bulk of the school load you know with full-size buses or taking full routes um yeah that's a possibility but the timeline
167is coming up pretty soon so it would probably be something we would have to really spend a lot of time I wonder if we should call Andre since he's on that committee maybe he has some advice about advice about you know about the you know having more of the buses and if it's a is it a grant or is it just a this is a EPA Federal Federal so I mean it has been going on for several years now um I think I I can't remember what the um commitment is for the next couple years if it's been obligated already I believe so but all right well I would be I mean um clearly there's probably some discussion on how we ended up at three buses and there's probably good reasons for that but I
168would be interested to know what that is and um you know so the the positives and negatives of going you know for a few more buses like are what are we worried about with going for you know more whatever that number would be you can answer that I think so uh one um one of the reasons we're looking at smaller buses and we have to clarify this but um we already have the infrastructure at our schools that would probably charge these uh the short the uh the smaller buses the mini buses rather than um residents plugging in 24 hours a day we could actually uh plug these buses in from what I understand but again we have to verify that but so we could have a couple of buses uh over at fames River a
169couple at the high school are at the the middle school and a couple over at Mary Morrison and use our electricity to to charge these buses without spending the additional money on infrastructure um charging stations somewhere else like at the STA garage or somewhere else in town although we could do that we could do that we did talk about the potential of if we needed to put in additional charging stations uh if the if this grant allowed it we would uh probably do that again at Mary Morrison where we have essentially mostly an empty parking lot where we could we could set that up so so is there um is there uh grant funding for the charging infrastructure so we potentially could I mean is that part of the same rebate y you can ask
170for up to 50 buses but and and and 50 buses plus the charging infrastructure but we do have a contract for the next couple years of buses although the way they're turning them around it might take that many yeah I mean my understanding with how we how the lease works with SDA I think we kind of determined that it wasn't we didn't want to Tinker with the contract too much but we tried to figure out how many we could host you know have on our own property and Mar and Mary Morrison is uh gr utilities [Laughter] right Jennifer you have a question oh oh several okay um so it was mentioned that Griswald you know submitted the grant application um I'm going to just rattle out my questions right why don't we do the same
171what's the benefit of us as a district doing so um has anyone researched or talked to our attorney um to ensure that we are not violating the current contract by owning our own Vehicles because that's a revenue um loss opportunity for our current um vendor and the reliability of the buses like um technology wise if it's cold you know um lose power how and then the buses don't get charged up I mean if we go the 50 route right this is just for the three route and then now we're in um now we're going to potentially have additional property tax and the impact on our insurance you can't just make a decision oh it's a grant here are some of the other things that I just thought about sitting here while you guys were presenting
172and I'm sure there's a lot of other items too well I think that was part of the idea with starting small is not getting not at all yeah yeah you got your answer to the question um I don't know um was any of this researched before presenting to the board well on on that paper they said check with st about contract conflict so they are they are going to do that but the reliability of the buses oh I don't know like before we want to go too far ahead we want to make sure that this was something that the board would be interested in supporting and then like the property tax insurance I don't know if that was ever considered property tax on public to public institutions pay property tax well I don't know they
173charge us taxes for addition they um the town shifted more taxes to us this year in our budget for the buildings so I'm not sure are we going to own the bus buses or is SCA going to own them the way the proposal is now is for us to own the bus okay so we may I don't know so look property tax yeah and insurance insurance we definitely would have to pay yeah and I don't are we considered a nonprofit because nonprofits on pay property taxes do that yeah yeah so we probably won't have to pay him okay that's my guess I don't know but you look yeah Insurance yeah yeah okay what was your that was it that was it that was it goe de so I'll say up front that I'm wary of
174this in and of itself I couldn't care less one way or the other about the technology but I look at it from this point of view whether they're electric gas fired or you know happy balloon powered the idea of because the town already has a fleet of vehicles everything from the Broom Bear to the police cars and and everything in between and I don't know whether we have some vehicles of our own that we you know are part of the Town inventory these have to be bought over and over and over again sometimes very quickly sometimes not but there are police cruisers for example there's a large Fleet of those those have to be replaced there's very clearly a desire to not just get a couple of buses to maybe you know have a little
175extra wiggle room when it comes to transporting kids after hours to games and whatnot this is this is the Gateway this is something that some people want is a larger program hence the questions here why don't we just get the whole thing right now so imagine if you will even in an ideal world where somebody else it's always somebody else pays for all the infrast structure pays for all the buses pays for the insurance in the first year or what have you we now have a fleet of buses that we own that we never owned before hooray and they were free but the next set will not be free and what do we use now it require the use of about what 40 buses or so more than okay than 50 so we're gonna have
176a fleet a comparable if not not exceeding I'm not sure but comparable to the rest of the Town combined those will be our buses they'll be our drivers um I don't know if the drivers will remain unorganized they may organize so we'll have another bargaining unit to deal with we have insurance there will be maintenance costs for the buses um Etc and I'm wondering to what purpose so that's why I'm wary of this if all we were going to do is try out a couple of buses and see how those buses are because it'd be night might be nice to have a couple of our own vehicles that would be one thing but I clearly see this as they say the no the camel's nose Under the Tent and uh so I'm not crazy about
177this I think that this would that's my initial position I'm sure I could be dissuaded with the right amount of evidence but that points to this having this requiring a larger study and I see the deadline of January 9th and I can't do anything about that that's not a recipe for me to uh to to rush into this um I think we I think it requires um a much deeper study to see if this actually is beneficial for us in the long run because we already get bus service now if someone said well if you had all of this new setup in the long run life cycle costs and all of that it'll be cheaper for us to transport the kids fine I'm open to that and I don't care how the buses operate um
178but I notice we're not considering uh internal combustion engine Vehicles we're considering this because they're electric and electric is Chic period end that's why we're considering this that's why this is so sexy so that's where I'm coming from Matthew just to to a question and a comment the question is is this a sole and single round Grant round or is this something that's baked into the EPA that there'll be another around down the road last time I looked at this I I I believe this was a multi-year opportunity but we're starting a new federal that was your round and um that could change but yeah I mean it's a program that's been going on for a couple years now I would say can I say that we really looked at this to meet a specific
179need that to really have more access to field trips and after school activities and um you know I've heard from some of my robotics team and you know the smaller clubs um that could really benefit they pay a lot through the booster clubs to transport kids the band for instance and so I was thinking that is really um an area where we could really solve a host of problems and provide more access for our kids for competitions and you know practices and so I was looking at it through the lens of what we could do for our kids and how that could benefit them and give them more than what we have in the contract so even if we started with that it might lend itself to if it really works out it's kind of
180like a field test um if it really works out it might be that we could grow it and um yeah supplement to what we're doing right now right right it would relieve the booster clubs from having you know that they could do other things with that money right can I ask my second question with regard to technology uh I don't know if it's Chic or not um but the the Retail transportation the Teslas have by and larged proven their viability as far as trucks and buses that's less so the case at least in the United States um they've been rolled they were talking about rolling out self self-guided taxis Robo taxis they're talking about rolling out within two years well I first heard that two or three years I heard that a decade ago so
181I'm not convinced that the technology that's available now is going to be on a par with what's going to come out having said that if we're really talking about trying three vehicles and and really committing to let's try them out for three or four years and see how it works over an extended period of time before committing to a fleet or expanding it I I'm for that but I I really don't see this I I don't want it to be the nose of the camel in the tent so that in 16 months we're talking about going to a big Fleet we need to see how this technology works thank you man thank you Bev um yeah I would uh you know I think this is a is is um a fair moderate step forward uh
182to to one experiment with the technology you know it's not too much of a commitment um given the Grant and the other supports um but I would definitely um highlight the points that superintendent brought up uh having worked with the um M the the marching band booster club and having close associations with robotics club and the um and also fencing um there are a number of smaller clubs that do need transportation and there have been a number of times where that Transportation has had to come out of the pockets of the booster club you know which is always a cost benefit analysis to be had of like if we spend on this then what is you know what ises that money what else could that money go for um which usually goes for scholarship sh
183um to help support uh you know ban students that are that are moving forward um so uh I'm in favor of of this as looking as a one a small supplement to the existing Fleet we have to a pilot to you know experiment with the technology and and you know determine its viability over time um you know but I do share uh Jen and Dean's concerns you know of not wanting to move too fast too soon um well I can appreciate Adrian's know inclination to to to to you know look at a whole Fleet option you know I do think it is prudent to move with um you know caution and you know technology is does evolve at at exponential rates so we need to kind of be mindful of that and um and uh
184a side note I was listening to like you know and looking at the notes as far as like listening to S talk about plugging in um this would solve a certain problem of having other cars plugged into our pedest if we had our own buses plugged into our P oh there's that thank you I I don't I don't want to say everything again but I agree with with just what Ian just said I hope nobody in this room is pluging a car in a overnight if you are I apologize can I just clarify for the record because it's been said twice now that I proposed um a fleet of buses um I did not propose a fleet of buses and I don't think that that would be a good choice slightly more buses um specifically
185buses that are actually um would be used similarly to if we had more of them so maybe one or two larger bus just so we kind of knew cuz they're going to have bigger batteries take longer to charge maybe need different charging infrastructure and maybe would wear out quickly or maybe they don't need any maintenance for a long time who knows um but um I do want to kind of clarify that because I also how long have we been I mean I know we just signed an sta uh contract which I I didn't see the the rush to sign that but how long have we been considering this um as an option the the bus um probably about a month it just came out right we just saw we did talk about it a year
186we have been talking about in finance and Facilities the ofed has talked about it for a lot of years for for many years about having uh like smaller move smaller teams around right we actually had sta come in and talk to us about this had one more question B okay had you given thought to having one full-size V uh bus I mean we have an arrangement with sta that we can have three my memories correct three field trips a semester or a year for every school school for every school uh if we had a bus we might be able to do some more field trips and uh I think these a class size right 24 kids that the number that was ideally what you wanted yes um I think there might be a limited um
187type available from the manufacturers right now but remember that's what you wanted yeah and then the larger bus I think requires a different kind of hookup right these would fit for what we have the the smaller buses would fit on any of the thing areasan requires a special non-bus licens if you go to a bus then the bus then you need the bus again stda said they could provide the driv for is this something we had have the vat on well I think we apply for it and then once we get it if we do get it then we have to really make the decision is this something are you asking the board if this is something your thoughts are okay so just going around real quick this is an official vote just to give
188them an idea should we push through and getting these three mini buses for 20 students or fewer to be used for fail trips and after school activities in your first yeah I'm in favor of moving forward more information I'm in favor of moving forward but also adding one or two larger buses if that if people are interested in that thank you yes yes yes for yes okay I'm yes because we're not committed so like even if we get the grant we could still back out that's right but I would request if it's okay with the chair that we price out the cost of a larger bus okay Dean de want to know what I want I want to hear you no I I'm a no but I did have that question as well when I
189didn't have a chance to ask it which is okay we get the the gr covers up to 325 uh K per bus but that includes infrastructure which in this case with a very small acquisition we wouldn't have to worry about that so that would be per bus my concern was well if the buses are each say 400k I'm just making a number of 400k that's 75 each we'd have the pony up and do we know that going in so to price yeah so but I'm still no we we've also talked to the uh property owner uh where the bus gr where stda stores their buses and he would be amenable to having the infrastructure if needed uh because the larger buses you'd probably want to put somewhere down there with the other buses um they
190he he would accept having the infrastructure put on his property as long as he didn't have to pay for it and this grant would so but would he own it would he end up owning theing it or it would be his yeah he he would own it if we put it on his property on his land but again we could we could look at doing it at Mary Morrison too depends upon the cost of the infrastructure that the site okay so I think it's the consensus that you can move forward on this um but we do want some answers the price for the larger bus and check with um SCA about contract conflict conflicts and did I miss anything the insurance EXC me Insurance the insurance insurance peace the insurance piece and property tax and
191also estimated maintenance over time so did you write that all down estimated maintenance over time Insurance property tax which I don't think we pay um price for a larger bus and the STA contract conflicts one more thing maintenance cost is one thing but for model XYZ what's the average repair rate you know what are the average cost of repairing it over three or four year period whatever period you think is appropriate yeah like to the vehicles if you can find out that information but otherwise you I think it's the consensus that you move forward with this okay and I would also throw in that I'm also in favor of hearing quotes about the larger buses yeah we vote that they're gonna get back to us on that would you like me to share that um
192some four can you come back and talk to us about it this where if we have any further questions we can ask you okay okay so this has to be approved by we have to vote on it by the 9th though or no we just give a consensus to move ahead with it because then if we we do receive it then we have to come back to you okay we actually can't take any action as a board because we're not meeting as a board tonight are we no we're meeting as the wait yeah Special meeting oh oh we are a board you are a board okay for some reason I thought this was a cow I'm sorry if we were a cow we wouldn't be able to really vote on anything officially well we didn't
193really vote we just gave a like a consensus to move ahead but we can reach out to Andre and Chris and Heather to get a letter if we need one I don't know if we need one no okay um so gonna Shannon you're GNA come back on Jan our next meeting is January 6 but it's a budget meeting but we're going to hold a special board meeting before that to um to vote on some second readings of policy okay so maybe at that time we can come she can all right okay and and remember board F that when she comes and we do the policy we got the budget after that so let's not try to drag these meetings out that we're half at 11 o' we we have a hard end at 11 so
194okay no one thing I'm going to request on this um just going to the agenda there was no uh notes of attachments and I did not get the bus packet in mine I didn't either um so um it would be nice if agendas in the future if there's well I can get it later now but I would have read you can have it I already looked on it I'm just saying future agendas listed that there should be an attachment so I know what to asked for it if it's not there she may not have had the attachments although I don't know she did somehow get your tools for schools I don't know that on my desk thank you Shon so where did that come from that just gave Adrian than no I didn't see that
195was on my desk thank you Shannon thank you Shannon okay s the man thank you madam chair no no just Sam the man go ahead Sam should be noted that a chair a couple of uh uh persons ago um held me here very late at night and then forgot to call on me at the end of the night so I I really appreciate you uh calling on me at least I'm not GNA mention any names so um I'm I'm gonna give you an introduction to uh so tonight I just want to give you the introduction to Tools for Schools and what that's about it's part of a program uh that the EPA put together uh to ensure that we have healthy buildings that we have a good indoor air quality and so this is a
196part A of of of that initiative and Part B is uh I spoke to you about previously which is the HVAC testing that we got that we are required to do in our schools and we are I told you I think at the last meeting that we are starting with col Nasi and Northeast Academy over the uh winter break so on the HVAC testing but the tools for schools are part of it uh I included in your packet um samples of those not filled out but uh I do have hard copies here of of all of those that have been filled out uh this program was developed by the a EPA so that the school staff could actually do these checklists uh to us so that um uh the healthy uh school committee within a
197in a building could actually do these uh reports uh or the maintenance staff um could do the maintenance portions of them which has been U completed at this point and so um that that um brings me to uh why I'm here tonight uh especially is because it's required that I come to the board of ed uh to make these available to the public at a board of ed meeting so I think Dr Kennedy is also going to he's putting up uh the blank me um forms that I sent to you earlier um but he's also going to uh put up there at some point uh the uh website site uh where the results these are the written results but uh the results of the uh uh Tools for Schools that were completed by each school
198and by the maintenance department over the course of the year so we are required to do that and have it submitted um to the state by December 31st and it has been posted on our website and so that if there are any persons uh that are looking on uh tonight they'll be able to find that website and find that on our um gron schools.org site um so uh once the um the the second part of the uh indoor air quality um program is the HVAC testing um and so once we get those completed uh those two uh schools over the break when I get the reports from them I will come back to you and give you the results of those as well so I think that um the other the other thing that I
199wanted to point out was the things that as I went through these reports which I've gone through a couple of times now with both my maintenance uh uh supervisor and my custodial supervisor um because the things that we found in here wanted to make sure we wanted to address as quickly as possible um they were the things that we uh often hear or get um um purchase orders or work orders on on a on a fairly regular basis and um so these things again were reported uh within the Tools for Schools checklists um the the the three things that come up most often are concerns about temperatures uh in the classrooms either too cold in the winter or too hot in the summer or in the spring or early fall um water leaks um every
200time we have a water leak somewhere in the building everybody say it's a roof leak they not necessarily roof leaks but water incursion into a building if it's not remediated quickly uh you know uh can turn into a mold situation which we seem to have more and more in New England than we ever had before um and possibly due to these super storms that we seem to be having on a more regular basis so there's a lot more humidity in the air um and and the third uh one was um adj dusting uh in classrooms so uh the custodial uh superviser uh Mr Varner has already uh spoken to uh a couple of the teams and couple of the schools about a reports from teachers that they uh would hope that there's um a more
201uh detailed dusting were done in their classroom so those are the three things that come up mostly that we've seen mostly in in in the reports um all all of the HVAC systems have been looked at um and uh so I think the other one was the um I wanted to mention was the walkthrough inspection checklist which is part of your um packet that is generally done by that that one particular one the others might be the maintenance checklist is done by the maintenance department ventilation is done by maintenance um you saw that there's a Food Service uh one in there so Ernie has his staff has done that portion of the checklist integrated Pest Management was done through our custodial group and the walkthrough inspection checklist that's the one item that is generally done
202by the um the school healthy and safe school committee um and so um the smaller schools it might be just that committee uh in in a school like fit High School which has many different areas I believe they broke it up into three or four different teams to go around different sections that build in to do it so but they are developed so that uh the uh the staff within the school teachers custodians uh Aid um I think even one SRO went on one of these tours with them to look at things too so that's uh that's the uh Tools for Schools program um and so I would entertain any questions that you might have about Dean yeah just looking through some of the reports it looks like fly colors you can see it on
203your phone yeah yeah I I think most most of the reports came in um um on a positive note for the most part yes I would say so good job good Matthew what frequency do we do you do these checks the the indoor air quality reports are done annually the HVAC testing that's going to be done um is done every five years but um you I think I spoke to the entire group the last time uh initially the state said that you had to do all schools all one shot and do that every five years but then they realize there aren't enough testing uh contractors available to do that so they allow us to do 20% of the school each year and then it it rolls over so that you just roll right right back
204over into the first one on the fifth year thank you any other questions sounds good sounds good thank you thank you Sam thank you Sam you're welcome and thank you thank your staff that we got flying report there a good report right according to Dean it's not perfect it's not perfect there are there are things obviously now I get to do the six-page report for each of these schools to the to the states ah submitted to the state by the 31st so you got your work cut out for you always he we lots of hats have you noticed well thank you thank you up at 400 am making sure those roads and he said they're icy out here Susan said I think we gota do a weren't so hot this morning now he said the
205higher elevations yeah it's a not everybody thinks about it but you take um Charles baram school for instance higher elevation than when you get down here um down into themes themes River for instance or even Mystic River much lower elevations so the temperatures totally different the conditions are different okay yeah we don't think of that we just think of oil of gr and that's it yeah yeah and then we worry about flooding on top of it too we have different areas and then the buses can't get through so you have to think about all those things City I think this is great too for parents um if they have concerns about a building they can just go and look at the form on on what we've been doing it's good for Community you know to
206have knowledge about what's going on as well absolutely so and it's all online right go on the website these These are on the website now yes they put on today is it under each school or did you have them in a central location all together they're they're all um I did did he put it up I think he put it up there he did so um school I think is it is it in maintenance folder or something wait he's doing something right now for us yeah building and grounds you got it right there too in a centralized location all right well thanks Sam yep thanks all right next is superintendent gold that was in your original packet that was added to your you guys all have it anybody has it okay so how do you
207wantan to go about this so could I Orient you because I know one of the things that was asked of me was to make sure that we had metrics that we could consider for achievement especially and um so really in this performance go goal one is it's really all about student achievement and how are we what systems do we have in place um and so I if I could go through that but the first one really talks about having um a system that we collect data and we're constantly monitoring it and looking at student achievement and based on every child succeeds act which is Essa federally and also the accountability system through the Connecticut State Department of Ed we have this next Generation accountability system that has a goal for all districts of 85 that's
208that Target number for the entire accountability index and that's um by 2030 so if you look at GPS um and our accountability which is close to 70 we're 15 points away from that Target and I'm thinking this is a six-year goal but I think that we can reach it in five years if we did three points per year but we might even get more aggressive it's hard to predict but if that's kind of a set goal and you know we communicate that that's what we're looking for um you know that could be really very doable and um we might even reach the target before the deadline so um you know that's the expectation from you know whether you're a new Canan or whether you're you know what whatever Town you're from Fairfield County Lichfield County
209Hartford County um or South Eastern Connecticut so um and then if I look the next um account index is the district performance index the DPI for ELA Math Science and the goal is 75 that's the Target so I looked at um Ela specifically it we're at 65 and if we looked at 65 to 75 that's a 10-point gain and I'm doing five years not six so I'm trying to get there even before we're supposed to get there um even if you did two points a year you could get there but it let's say we did three points a year we might get there even sooner so really just looking at that as an indicator um and we're definitely we've got math and um Ela and science really as goals in our strategic planning so we
210are going to be looking at ways to do this even better then if you look at the science goal the science goal um for um this past year was 61.9 but I'm going to call it like 62 to 75 that's 13 points away so you know that in five years might be doable at 2.6 but if you look at 3% you could get there even sooner um and sooner than the the sixe spread I want to also say that there's other data that you collect remember that ESC is one day in a kid's life and it could be a good day or it could be a bad day it's actually over several days because it takes a couple days to do the math piece it takes a couple days so it almost takes you know
211really we spread it out so it's a few days every week that they're taking this test but for each of the indicators you know it's it's a day in their life so one of the things that I'm really pleased with is our dibles Universal screener and doing that three times a year and now it's really um K5 universally and it can be used all the way through 8th grade and it is being used at the middle school for tier two and three um students we're also looking at another assessment that could be possible for the upper grades looking at lexiles um would you the name that you said lexiles thank you it's a way that you you know figure out where kids are and what the readability of text is it lined with the readability
212of text um and then we're also making sure we use the ibaas which are the interim assessment blocks and we're actually looking at the data we're doing it as a district so I'm interested in sitting down with Lauren Cassini and the principles and looking at the data that we've so so far collected in ela math um in science I think Ben moon has created some internal assessments but he is looking to put those iabs through the grades 34 and five six seven and eight and then um probably 10 and 11 so we can keep track so that's another piece of data that's going to help us and then there's PSATs and SATs and our kids will do PSATs in the fall and spring we kind of compare that data and you can then compare and
213we let kids know how they're scoring and what the expectation is and then you do that for 9th and 10th grade PSAT and sat they took it in 11th grade in the fall in kind of getting ready for sat in the um spring so really monitoring that data and looking you know it's always about looking for growth and kids have their own internal targets too that they're seeking so you know we heard about the seventh grade phenomena of 71% of the kids meeting their T Target goal or better so those are the kinds of things that we're looking at as um and encouraging for our students to even understand and our teachers um the school district the district data team meets you know probably quarterly and the school data teams meet I would say they
214meet um monthly so that they're really looking at their data and then they meet also at grade levels too and Lauren Cassini gets out there and helps support that work as well um and then you know really looking at um presenting the district data to the board and we kind of see it throughout the the year like the accountability index has just come out and so we have more information I want to be able to share with you all on the accountability because we did have two schools of Distinction who really did not have a gap at all CK really deserved a shout out and so did themes River for their work and so that's also information I want to be able to share with the board so you can understand it more deeply I
215just ask I just I was out the room for a minute I just want to make sure I'm on the same page is everyone I'm this one here yeah that's I'm looking at that but you mentioned a lot of numbers yeah so the numbers are all in here but I did some math for you you're in a different right no I had the bullet point document this one and then I also had this you know but this one only has the check marks I see bullet points on your page yeah what I did was I had Tak an action plan and I had it on a separate document but these are the the actual steps of action the bullets yes to support what the goal is to show you how we're going I understand that
216I just don't I don't have that I have an extra cop I think that's is there was a I've had several versions exactly that was the one from um I want to say okay yeah this one has the specific numbers you just mentioned yeah all right so I wasn't seeing that do I'm sorry well it was actually Matthew's idea to make sure I put metric in and he had a really great idea no I don't have that cop and if I can do if we can do better I applaud it I will encourage it I mean I think it's really important but even if we we look at you know a two to 3% increase we can get there before even the sixth year which I think is pretty my question I'm sorry D it
217came with the board package I didn't get a chance gra all I had was the emails to go off oh yeah it came the board I just downloaded the emails sorry Matthew sorry okay but I did have a question Susan uh for example [Music] you you said that uh we wanted to go from 65 to 75 on one metric and we would do it in five years at 2% a year and I'm kind of uneasy with that because we're just dividing a number by five there's no real rational reason that I understand why we think we can do two a year one more second please and my my limited experience and I emphasize the word limited is that if one wants to make a goal whatever it is you tend to do relatively quickly at
218first and it's the last mile it's the last mile that takes more time so I would love to see the type of metric you're talking about but understand why you're picking 2% a year or whatever the percentage you pick that's your role but that there's a rationale for that rather than simply dividing it into equal parts because I'm I don't grasp I don't grasp the logic behind that so it typically is that districts are making about two to three percentage points per year so that's what kind of is the goal and I'm thinking about also the 2019 where we had done really well and how that's going to bring us back up to those kind of um figures with those accountability indexes you know you can also look at at in terms of the amount
219of students who are meeting the tar who are meeting the um you know proficiency range so you can look at it that way as well but I know that with the accountability index it really showcases kind of like the yard stick did years past all the different metrics so in the accountability index we're looking at not only scores you know of ela math science SAT but we're also looking at college career Readiness we're looking at you know um graduation from high school we're looking at physical fitness we're looking at Arts access so all those different factors in the accountability index which you know we're really held responsible to so you ultimately want to get to that Target of 85 which is what the state is asking all of us to do by 2030 I I
220may I continue yeah I see us having three audiences we have the board how we're measuring our progress and how we can be supportive of you we have the students how do we construct this in a way that becomes motivational for the students uh for example we for SATs we say well what is the average SAT score for Yukon what is it for Westcon what is it for Eastern Connecticut or different schools so that the kids can see at the outset if I want to go to school th this is the kind of bracket of the average score that they're going to have it gives them a a goal and motivation so the student is is the second one and the third if my can put my memory is the faculty motivating The Faculty because
221by setting goals uh we are encouraging faculty to go for specific things we can do a lot of stuff but some of this can be rolled into the um what's the word we used before the dashboards that we that we were talked about with our cave training so I see this linked to the dashboards and that the dashboards not only be information but motivational so uh so every data team even the district data team we're looking at all those various dashboards all the time and we're looking at specific students so we're not only looking at it by school by District but by student and so that's really important too for the teachers to be able to recognize or the counselors the school counselors when they're talking to kids about their an internal process um I
222remember it being said and correct me guys if I'm wrong and gals um they were talking about actually having physical dashboards at a district level and at a school level so when when a parent walks in he or she or they can can see how the school is tracking so the students can see how they're tracking maybe that's not going to work with first grade students but it's certainly going to work with middle school and upper students anyway just some some ideas because I think this it's a great start and I really applaud you for having done this um but I think we can make it more robust okay thank you thank you any other comments on performance goal number one we're doing each at a time okay Jan and and Adrian where so I'm
223taking it from a different perspective you battled off a lot of stuff I know I'm sorry right yeah when we have a goal three or four so that we maybe three three to five so that we can manage it right and um more is not necessarily better all the time so if we say teaching is learning if the teachers aren't there their kids can't learn if the kids aren't there they can't learn or teachers if they're not there they can't teach and if the kids aren't there right so maybe you focusing on absenteeism for the kids and absenteeism for the faculty that's your goal because once they're in there then we can start focusing in on all of those other things that you've mentioned need to get them in building so that they can learn
224both s so that is a goal and you know and I'm working on all these things and in the accountability index that certainly the goal is to be at 5% chronic absentee and we're far away from that but even if I can make two or three percentage Point gains or 3% or 4% each year we're going to get closer and closer to that goal of five but if going back to like the metrics red yellow green if let's say absenteeism is at 20 and our goal as a district is 10 or eight whatever it may be we all need to decide and if you're within this range you're red yellow and green that's easy for enough for us to track then we can bring that down to the school level right and then we can
225sort of see and then if we're tracking that and then when the scores come back at the end of the day we could be like well this school um has 8% um and look at all their scores whereas this school has 20% look at their scores I mean it's it's going um we're in such a um like a sort of bad shape I'm not bad but like we need to keep it simple so that we can track so that's the kind of work I'm doing on a regular basis with the principales at principal meeting we're looking at their absenteeism and an Marie has helped with that we did a whole you know 45 day we're going to do a 90 day we're looking at that we're talking about how the teens are working on encouraging
226kids and staff no I know but yeah and then as part of your presentation you're saying oh this is achievable right like and we can get it can any when we set goals it's all more aspirational and how you're going to get there and even if it's a stretch so that when we do get there it's like you we work hard to go there if we're making goals that we know we're going to achieve why bother well that's true I don't know that I can say for sure I know but I can see a pathway by setting benchmarks if I know that this is the expectation I said in six years and I'm looking at the expectation in five years you know to get there ahead of the game and then I be I'm able
227to see where are we from that Benchmark and then I kind of figure out well what is that going to be then each year if I'm saying it's 3% I'm going to get there in five years I would love to have a 4 per or a 5 perc year we can get there even quicker so I'm I'm just saying that's what the expectation for the whole state is not just for grotten yeah yeah but we could do better than the state we don't have to do the expectation of the state well it's it that's through the Essa is that's what you know the national and the state is saying that for every child succeeds this is how you you know equate every child succeeding and certainly if we did better you know I like I'm
228competitive are you kidding I think that's why Matthew is saying the first year should be higher could I did write up three proposals that I would like to make in the form of a motion this may not be the time to do it because I want to be sure everybody has a chance to weigh in and I don't push something premature all right wait off for now because Adrian has something to say and then Ian okay yeah um so just just going back I'm trying to remember the state had a Target goal they did they push that back to 2030 did it used to be sooner for that standard it might have been sooner but it is at 2030 now at this point yeah so this I I I thought I remember might been Co
229related too like 26 or 27 that we were supposed to reach that goal so this is already this is already goal post that's been pushed out um the 2030 goal which is why I I somewhat agree that we should you know we should have been working for this for a long time and I you know there's some questions that some people well I'm going to leave that there um I I would just like to say that I would I I agree that this this is great that we're actually putting numbers to like where we need to go um I would like to see that by school understanding that um some schools may make Higher Achievement and some schools make lower but the reporting in the goal because ultimately we're giving you a goal but it's
230not you that has to do it it's the principles and well in the the staff the teachers the Paras everyone needs to work towards the goal um but in my own opinion I think that um I think that it we really need to be able to break it down to to at the individual School level um rather than just say the district as a whole because you know whatever I forget what it was seventh grade's doing great in math but sixth wasn't as great and and we can't we I don't think averaging is the best way to do it we need to look at it what we can do is that I can talk to the principles about incorporating this idea because really the thing about goals is they have to be aligned so the
231goals that I set have to be aligned with board goals and have to be aligned with school goals you know and have to be aligned with the state now the state has just put out uh their new strategic plan and it's really quite interesting so some of the language that I've looked at is when we're doing the strategic planning is going to be related to the state so all of those things need to come together but I can absolutely ask the principles to take the model that I've done and take their their own data and then see what that looks like for them I think that's a great suggestion all right yeah all right thank you um but he wants um he wants the goals to be for each School you understand I know but
232I'm saying that in my goals I have to look at it as the district but then we can have the schools in order to meet them I can have the schools outline what it would look like for each of the schools so you will say to the principal I'm making this up we want to see a 2% G I want to see no I want to see what is the end goal game you know in five years not six so that's already a little bit bringing it back and then how much is it going to take each of your schools to get there you know so they're going to have to do the math to figure out the time frame and and what how many points they oh the first year we we want to
233see 1% gain no they're going to be looking at you know some of the schools will be looking at you know instead of three points Four Points what depending on the schools what tools are you giving them to be able to improve if they haven't done it yeah so I haven't gotten there if you can let me get there with my strategic planning because there's going to be a lot of work we've already started with literacy and I'm looking to see literacy through k12 and then the other thing is the mathematics and um Beverly said what are you going to do about mathematics so we're working on that but it's a whole Community effort that we're really working on the strategic planning but there might be some and we're going to take some information from
234the state and recommendations from the state on some some things that are actually working and and use some of the things we've already been doing that are working and then try to share that with others when are the principles doing their goals so they haven't done them yet no they they've done their goals for me their own personal goals okay their school goals so really what they've come to you with their plans that will go be incorporated in their school plan and their school goals okay so um I'm getting confused it's getting to be a big marshmallow but I'm not goinging my own well the principals the school the principal has his goals get the schools then he has the goals for the school right and they already gos and so he already did the
235school goals right got they've got what they've come to you with the data and their action plans but they also create a school plan so that will go into their school planning but this could be something that we could add to so do they have like uh a math we want to increase our math scores by 2% do they have stuff like that in their goals they don't have this metric but we can use this metric and see what it lays out for each of the schools so with the goal for Essa it it seems to me a little late in the year I mean for you this is how it is but I wish I would have saw the principles I wish I would have known those were their goals you know and I
236don't know when they came through when they came through I just they were talking about their test scor this process usually takes place in the summertime but then when we it does in the summertime we might not have all the data so the good news about doing this late is that we now have a lot more data okay so I get into my next question h no in go ahead what happened oh no we're getting to my next question all right go ahead get to it so um so all right one other thing I would you know before I get to that question um I would personally like to see AP and IB IB testing um as part of this because um we spend a lot of money as a district on those classes um
237so we dedicate a lot of resources that could be going elsewhere to those classes and to to have um some data on improved scores in those um and actually the standardized scores not the individual you know grades but um but I would personally like to see that um but second can I just jump on there for a second and also um do our kids really are our kids that go to IB if we compare to a school like eastl that doesn't have IB are our kids going to better schools than their kids or you know I'm just trying to get a a head heads up on why we're stuck with IB and why we think it's so good as compared to whole presentation but I'd love to bring that yeah I love I would say
238that yes they can go to almost any school that they yeah but are so are our kids going to any better schools than the schools that don't have IB I would say that they absolutely get into the the top schools and that is really looked at at the University level as a big can you give me information how many kids are going to these schools and what are you calling the top schools are you calling the Harvard the Browns okay I just want to I don't want to I don't the top school too I don't want I want to make sure we're talking about top schools the Y and the Princeton yeah yeah yeah as a separate as a separate thing maybe we should have um somebody that has worked in an admissions office like
239a like come in and speak to us about about what we needed to be doing for college readiness um you know somebody that's kind of outside of the The Wheelhouse that we have that has a different perspective right um but the last thing is down at the bottom here um it said um November um is when we're going to get the data by November board meeting um and I think that's unrealistic um and it would be like typically what do we have 90 days after the superintendent's review to come up with goals is that what the cont contract stipulates yeah that's what Susan's contract but we typically most super all superintendant that I know of get their review like in the summertime yeah and then they set their goals for the next year but like
240I said it is harder to set goals when you don't have the data so this actually we have the data in June though the state yes so the state gives us that data or we have all that data in June and I don't understand I mean we still haven't seen the Dibble scores from this um the spring or the fall as a board I mean it's a separate thing um but we have all that data and I feel like we should be reviewing it in the summer because we're it's almost like when we get that data in November we're planning for a year out rather than the year that we're coming up on so this is based on Spring data by November so that was really the Spring State data um but we can give
241you the Dibbles data once it's taken once we you know once we gathered the data that's not anything the state just has that data is available to us though I mean all that testing data is available to us correct in in June no you just can't make it public I thought I no it's it's bargoed they they release the data on a certain date after they've done all this testing of the data so I um so I just was looking at um this was the data was reviewed in in 20 um 2023 in the September meeting I did an over so I I bring it to you in pieces so I gave you something in September that was overarching for the whole district and then we break it down so that you eventually get the
242school data by November October November um and then the accountability index is a whole another story that I want to share with you but that you know so throughout the year and then there's a report card at the end of the year so the way the state lays out the data and brings it to us is all throughout the year so um I just I just want to get back to this because we keep getting off of so the state we do it we do all the testing we have all the data all of the principals and teachers have the data so the district has the data um and I think Ian brought this up and you had mentioned this before when we talked about it um a long time ago um there's a rule
243by the state that says you're not allowed to release the data to the board it's not public yes well we're not the public we're I know but it's it's only really they they test it out to make sure would you see clarification on that yes I'll let a write something up for you but also I I going back to the November thing that data was available in the end of August this year so in my own eyes I feel like if we're reviewing the superintendent on an annual basis next year Bev is running the show well not that it since Bev is running the show I'm going to guess that we're going to do that um superintendent review um in the summer and then we've got 90 days so presumably we could review that data
244so we have accurate data for this and it's at the beginning of the school year not late school year so I I would personally like to change that November date to um mid-september because that should be a prior now are you saying all the data like even the schools data and their presentations all in September you can give us the data dump and then the schools can come in and talk about it but then at least we have the data okay I mean it was all on the it was all on the State website anyway in the end of August okay um but I think um giving the data are you on this page a yeah down at the bottom of it on the you know um in the italicize paragraph at the end it
245says by the November board meeting the super will superintendent will present the information based on the spring data so I I I feel like that should be September so we can actually I can put September and I'll just check with AIT to see what he's thinking the release will be so that it you know there's also analysis that has to be done too so it's not like just data dump there's a whole analysis it was on the state all of the numbers were on the State website in I think I I I think I forwarded the link to everybody it was in the end of August um when it when it came out so I think that the board should be notified of that and that you know okay if we're if we're making it
246as goals should be reviewed on goals okay I'll be happy to put September in yeah in um thank you Adan for bringing that up about the data that was one thing I did want to ask about I'm trying to get it going earlier and overall like um yeah the moving forward the next year uh the evaluation you know I'd like to you know see it happen earlier um you know it feels like we're doing a lot of things after the fact um just remind me Ian we'll do too um one thought I had here was just looking at this italicized um paragraph where you had all your numbers broken out and you did the math and talked about like 2 point whatever percent per year um I don't see that 2 point uh whatever percent
247per year in this italics no because that's just what I've done is I've taken where we're at currently I understand the math I just don't see it written but I'm just saying if you meet that goal then that that expectation of three percentage points a year can get you there even a year ahead of time one thing that could help possibly you know is maybe formatting this as a table a little table of like year one year two year three what year anticip what your goal for increase would be yeah whatever we determin that to be um uh otherwise I mean I'm glad to see numbers involved you know uh I know that was discussed a number of different times in different places that having something that could be measured um you know as opposed
248to just narrative is is a step in the right direction as far as like just creating more clarity and accountability um as far the math I can I agree with the assessments um by Matthew and Adrian about like you know trying to move faster sooner um you know I can understand your math as you just basically kind of did even split with one year shaved off on the back end um you also need to know that in order to do this we need to implement some new strategies and programs and curriculum and with the implementation that does sometimes you know it's going to be interesting to see with wit and wisdom the first year youly we really had some tremendous success so that implementation went really smoothly but typically after 45 years I could say
249this that and I've implemented quite a bit in my tenure starting in new Canan where we revolutionarily changed mathematics and saw tremendous gains but it does take time when you're implementing because teachers are learning new strategies new programs um and so it so sometimes it might not be the first year you're implementing but maybe after that the second year gets even better so you neily say you know having a structure to it and you know then you the the analysis afterwards let's see what happens you know it's at first like just get things implemented get them going have the goal what it is and if it doesn't make the goal then we analyze why not you know that's Monitor and adjust right exactly so uh you know and also yeah there's lots of tools out
250there so um but I would just you know first and foremost I think when it comes to like creating metrics let's you know think about a chart a very you know clear way of organizing the numbers as far as like how we want to progress from one year to the next okay thank you nothing thank you okay points have been raised already um I've been hearing that things take time since before I was on the board and things do take time but there are so many moving pieces and there are so many unintended unintended delays that we just move at a glacially at a glacial Pace uh the situation with their absenteeism the situation with our scores I understand the the arguments about the imperfections of standardized testing but every school district faces the same
251thing so we are being compared one to another I don't think we can wait another year or two so I'm going to make three motions I'll make one and if anybody wants to Second it we can discuss that if it's turned down that's okay with me but can you make them suggestions because these are mutually agreed upon goals I will phrase it in the terms of a motion and see if anybody wants to suggest it I have wrestled with this it's I don't want it to be a suggestion I want it to be a friendly directive that certain things need to happen if the board doesn't like my reproach that's fine I can live with that the sun will come up in the East I promise you I move that the superintendent shall present to
252the Board of Education a districtwide school by school chronic absenteeism reduction action plan no later than April 1st 2025 we can make changes if the dat's not good it shall be preceded it shall be accompanied I'm sorry that's the wrong word it shall be accompanied by a monthly dashboard that includes comparable data going back to Sy 201819 I picked that date because it was the last full year before covid this plan shall articulate types of human and fiscal resource resources currently appli to this task and her meaning the superintendent recommendations of future human and fiscal resources needed to move forward with a 2-year Horizon plus chronic absenteeism goals by district and by school for FY 2526 and 2627 and based on one of my colleagues statements I'd say we should have absenteeism for faculty and
253students or teachers and student you want to say teachers or staff teachers and staff teachers and staff staff would be inclusive of both of Paris and thank you thank staff and students uh and please which are this let's make some very delicious sausage I don't care if second Thomas a point of order we have a special meeting yeah so by law we have to stick to the agenda it's on the agenda I know it says discussion regarding superintendent's goals I'm not saying that I have the answer to this it does not say and potential motion board action on those on that topic I don't know whether that if we were to vote on if motions made and then voted on and voted positively whether that would constitute an invalid action on the part of the
254board tonight under this well and the goals are mutually agreed upon so you can give me a suggestion so then we'll get a sense of the board we'll take a straw poll we'll take a straw poll i i i incline to your wisdom yeah I'm not saying that I have the answer I'm raising that as a potential you really that on the agenda for uh uh to vote so you really can't that's a strong point yeah so you could do a consensus what do people feel so is there a consensus I'm asking whether or not there's consensus that something this strong be be done he part of Susan goals and I'm open to neg do you have anything I didn't beat anything about absenteeism um I felt like I put it in here just don't
255know where thought I heard it too it's with a strategic plan it's definitely it's definitely part of the accountability index and I can call it out certainly Susan but is it written in here yeah I thought I had it in here if you and your develop a plan it will be less ephemeral than just discussion it'll be a plan that you guys have agreed on and it needs to be your plan not our plan because that's operations but the the policy the philosophy what we're saying is we need to attend to this now not in a year and a half from now so we do have a plan and a policy and tiered interventions of support for kids who are absent I just don't know that I mean I can certainly send it out to
256you so you can see what we have well I found I found carmita's presentation it made me joyful remember I Ed the word joyful never heard me say that she sounded to me as if she had a real strategy strategic plan in mind so they each do but they have we have a district plan too so then let's articulate it as our absentee action absenteeism plan that's laid out for exactly how it's going to work what the metrics are have been in the past what the metrics we see happening for the next two years the resources that we're using the resources that we think we need to use that's the plan and it can be done in the front and back of two pages unlike anything I would write I will get that to you
257yeah ad I I I support that strongly I feel like this um this goal is just putting together a plan that is that the board can review and think about it's not it's not like we're asking you to have chronic absenteeism at 10% next year which would be fantastic but um but we're not we're just asking for a a real plan in place that we can measure going forward if the plan is working okay so I I I totally agree with that um and I think it's vague enough and um where it leaves like kind of as Matthew read that it's it leaves enough room for um I mean it's probably just more or less what you have already ready some modifications and I'll work with the principles before sharing it with you to make
258sure that that's happening you know and what parts of it are working and what aren't so I will do some leg work on that and this will let them when we get to the third one this will give them the information that they can use to make the dashboards for their schools and I think there's ways that board might be able to help in parts of that okay I'll bring it to talk about all right so should move on to number two well for the record I just also wanted voice support for that proposal proposed suggestion right me too okay me too me three me four I'm over got that okay okay so that's that okay okay second uh she didn't do goal number two yet so okay let's suan do before you tell me
259what to do it and tell her what to do wasn't it academic achievement that we've been doing we just did um student student achievement that's what number two is about number two and where on my on his list okay oh I thought you were doing gold number two on Susan's list so you're doing number two on your list I'll read the first sentence you tell me if I'm out of order or not but just tell me where it is on your lick I thought Jen said I was supposed to reduce the number of goals I have you're just giving me more no I think we can you can W everything you said can be wrapped into these okay where's your second goal on this sheet of paper page one the second dot the second dot
260okay so I'm not going to read it you guys can read as well as I can now so okay the superintendent shall the superintendent is invited to present to the Board of Education the districtwide academic achievement recovery action plan before commencement 2025 the plan should include one defined year-to-year metric measurable Improvement goals for student standardized testing results it's not in there but that would include esac PSAT sat ngss Dibbles lexid iabs or whatever the superintendent things are the appropriate metrics for those meeting or exceeding State minimum standards at the elementary level aggregated by school GMS and Fitch two strategies by grade or and school level to increase student uh I said attainment I should have said achievement okay it was a long day such as high dosage tutoring electronic tutoring adult volunteers off-site support linkages
261with Park and wreck local industry employee volunteers other support con College Avery Point interns or other what the resources we're going to bring to bear on this three how we can refocus District priorities to mastering foundational skills with no or minimal impact on existing upper level course offerings Andor examining costs and benefits of restoring honors level classes this is a lot current fourth then finally current and desired fiscal and Staffing Resources needed to support such goal attainment this is a heavy lift but I know you can do this Susan the team well I also have to do a budget and I have to I have a lot of jobs to do that's why I set the date as commencement 2025 if you want to push it off to August I will fine but a date
262certain that we will have something to look at so we can maybe Implement something this next school year you didn't give him month the 2025 can I take some time to consider this and what that was sure the first one we've already kind of agreed to right right yeah measurable and that those we're going to come up with right now okay vew the only thing um you say in your little circle number one um improving goals for students standardized testing results for those meeting or exceeding now nowhere do I see and I could be missing it those that are not not meaning or exceeding what about the kids that are approaching that's the ones I'm thinking about too two all of them everybody needs to grow yeah two answers uh the num if we have
26320% meeting or exceeding that means we have 80% to or not so whatever the number for one is we automatically know the number for the other but if you want both that's fine I've no I would have to have that I I have no objection to that um your second part of your question was no that's that was my question where are they approaching and where are they not meeting but that's the hard thing for approaching that I've always had a a handle on approaching is basically it's saying the second cortile the first cortile is 25% 50% but we I don't know on this approaching Lev where how many of those are 26% and how many of those are 48% we do well that knowledge has not come to this board member so it it's
264really Child by child they have a Target so one of the things we're trying to do in Granton Public Schools is every teacher and every kid understand their target when they're ready to understand their target and if our children the closer we get to the 100% of the kids making their target the better off we're going to do because those kids are going to jump Court to because that's what the state has let us you know let us know that that's those are the parameters of making significant growth over time and and that's how some of our approaching kids are going to be meeting the goal that's how some of the kids who are at risk will be approaching so if we can focus on the student targets which we have been doing some more
265successfully than others that's the way that you make that growth for all kids I'd be very open to having uh two charts one that shows uh based on meeting or exceeding goals and another another chart that says meeting or exceeding growth Target individual growth targets we can still preserve the anonymity and respect privacy but that'll give us a much clearer picture uh and if we have 80% of that second quartile meeting goals and we're still having 20% who are not achieving the the standards because we're judged not by the goals we're judged by the public on the basis of this is a district that's got 35 to 60% not making uh minimum standards across grades and disciplines I know there's a national problem but we can't solve that all we can do is work to
266solve ours if I could jump in on that I just feel like could add a little um I mean you're on I I agree with where you're going with this I think you know for every student you know every education you know you're looking at two different ways uh you know it needs to be analyzed two different ways you know there's standard standards that we either seek to approach meet or exceed but then there's also individual students personal progression and I think what what we're lacking on our end here is getting a good sense of You know despite the fact of like maybe the standards are not being met you know certain percentages but who's growing but who's progressing right how are the students progressing along that track so if there's some way to aggregate
267that data maintaining anonymity um that would be a crucial piece to age I agree and it sounds like you have that data I have that a matter of like how to make it Anonymous and then uh aggregate it yep and you know given the fact that we have so many Trent uh such a transient population that knowing what the growth data is really brings a lot of color to the the other we have M kids coming from I'm picking on Mississippi because they're the easiest ones to pick so they won't have a growth Target because Miss Mississippi doesn't have an ESC the only way we'll get that growth Target is for kids who are moving within Connecticut and even with kids moving within Connecticut remember that Norwich New London gron connection you could have a
268kid who's been in Two Towns or three towns in one year so while we can still measure the growth Target it might not be the responsibility all of grotten in meeting it maybe they were in Norwich for a while in New London for a while right that's true and so that does have impact so you have to know that that does have impact so the best you can and we trust you right that's all I can do right let's move on to Susan's performance goal number two because it's almost 10 o'clock so and at 10 o'clock I'm hoping everybody would want to go home and we can oh I told you that soe this is the goal which is around Ed leadership and it's grounded in making relationships and I'm one who really believes in
269a lot of in-person relationships that's why you know I like to be in person for as many meetings as I can with the board and um you know I like to be in those buildings and um you know certainly to outreach to the Greater Community and all those family engagement kind of activities I can't get to them all but I try to get to you know every school engagement at some point um but in this you know some of the big areas are working with the board faculty and staff on implementing the mission and vision and goals of the district and I know that this this um board wants to really take a look at their goals more closely and what are those goals you know and belief statements I think but we do know
270that um you know our vision is teaching and learning and a lot of people really understand that it's simple but it really is powerful too at the same time um and also working to implement an action plan um and a strategic operating plan so we will be working with the community there's going to be surveys and Outreach I encourage the board to take the Strategic um plan I know anarie sent it out um and we're going to be encouraging that and then we're going to do some focus groups she's really done a marvelous job outlining this and she's done prior work in this too as I have so um we're also modeling it after the state comprehensive plan which I'll get you a copy of but it you can find it on the web page
271which is every student prepared for learning life and work Beyond school so not just College this is really career and life beyond school um and you know so that is one of the big ways that we're going to be looking at that and then to also promote School culture and climate um and see continuous Improvement and we did see some improvement from one year to the next we're going to be looking at making it more uniform so we can continue to look year toe at the culture and climate survey um but part of culture and climate too is our new Granton Public Schools educator evaluation reimaging plan because it oh see it wants me to go to bed sorry guys I don't ever go to bed this early but it's reminding um so at any
272rate you know part of the plan is to get principles and administrators into classrooms more often and to look at possibly six opportunities throughout the year for every single teacher that's a huge goal but it is been really well received by our teachers our faculty and they feel like um it's a a big Plus in their plan that they they get that feedback they get to meet with the principal three times a year setting goals mid year and then end Year and that they get feedback on any time that they're observed so um and it's personalized so I think that personalized approach is what's so important in this goal you should check and learn about that new app that they have where the teacher gets immediate feedback yeah I will a week later yeah I'll
273ask after the person the evaluator leaves the room and sends it so we give both written feedback but the thing that they love the most is meeting with the principal and that's supposed to happen within 24 hours and they actually team up and they talk they just have conversation so so that's the Ed leadership peace any oh Jen go ahead and here's like me going back to be basic so that we can you know set the foundation right those are all great I mean I want you just doing that you know just part of your normal course right your goal this year should be setting and establishing or reviewing the Strategic plan boom right um um because you know what I mean but we're also implementing this new plan that got approved by the state
274so everything falls under me and I believe me I'm paying attention but a big focus is that strategic plan that is highlighted in my mind just make sure you know that is the goal we can we can track you on that right all that is wonderful that is great that is part of your daily like you that should be part of your job description you should be doing that you know and um if you're not doing it now yes definitely we should make it a goal but if you're already doing that um I don't necessarily think like I want to make that maybe we pick one or two of those items and then we can measure it I don't want to have 10 on goal one 10 on goal two and 10 on goal three
275and now we have 30 things for you to get measured on and each of the principal gets whatever portion of yours and theirs and it's just going to be a big old mess so I'm going to Star the the Strategic plan if everybody's thinking that's you know what highlight I mean that's what you think that's what I think that's just me but I'm like give me two or three things in each one of those categories so that we can measure it and it's something that will push us forward all of those pushes us forward and you should be measuring yourself on that I do I do that self-reflection on all the something that we can measure you on so what did you say Jen like complete the Strategic plan the Strategic plan will include ABCD
276so in my it's not been created yet you have your mind the elements that you want your plan to have but we are looking to the community to give us input at least ABCD correct I mean that's just me so because I'm like more like less is better so then I can see less is better you're actually performing because if you give us 10 things and you did well on seven of them and completely fa I need to do all of these things Jen this is what you need to understand that all these things are things that I do it's part of what I do of your job you have to do it but you don't need to tell us or we don't need to evaluate on every single move like you blow your nose
277we're gonna you know what I mean like I'm not no no no not I'm being fous at this point but if you give us 10 you should I'm expecting you to do that and I don't expect to evaluate on every single one of those items because I know that's your job and I'm not going to monitor and measure you on on your on every component of your job I need to know what is one thing that shows that Susan is the leader of this organization boom she's setting the objective for whatever like whatever it may be and then we can measure you on that like all the 10 things that lead to that I don't care I mean not that I don't care like I know that if you've completed it you've actually all done
278like the Lesser steps and I don't need to evaluate you on all of those 10 steps that got you to our main goal that's all I'm trying to say well and I'll bring to you as we go through the year it's not like it's going to be just the end product I will bring you some of the Insight that we've had and I'll ask you for your Insight as well and as we develop this I just wanted to express my support for Jen's proposed approach um like having a it's a simplified goal that we're assessing that's all inclusive of the Lesser steps that lead into that I think it's a great approach and I just wanted to kind of clarify a couple of terms I guess this a strategic Improvement plan that you mentioned and
279in the neas report from a couple years ago there was a school Improvement plan that was y those all have to align right so School Improvement plan is that thing is that has that been a document that's been shared with the board so the school Improvement plans are really based on their data but the strategic plan will probably set a new format for the school plans because they have to be aligned the school Improvement plan already is in existent and that that is like a districtwide thing that's has school by school SCH the school plans we have a districtwide that has been in place for as many years as I've been here and then revised so and that's what the school plans were based on this is a new strategic plan it may have some
280of the same ideas but it might even have some new ideas but it's really going to be you know we're really looking to um align it with the state plan as well can a board member sit on that committee I don't know if one wants to but just in case one wants to sit on that committee when did you meet um we are meeting like um I think about once a month you meet during the day even during the day and so we have to be somebody that can get off during the day look at me um all right so thank you for clarifying there's a difference between the school Improvement plan and the Strategic Improvement plan yes strategic Improvement plan is not we we do have a strategic plan that exists and we've had
281it in place for about 10 when I got here we created it and then we updated it probably in 20 I don't know know 20 right around covid and then um so we're really looking to have a new plan did you ever see the old plan Ian I I gave you copies of it with your new was that I can get you a copy if you want to see the old plan but we are going to be creating a new plan I think that would be good and and you know just um I'm looking at a way to try to streamline the goals because I see all these in the same way as as Jen identif a lot these these kind of all lead into a larger larg I would rather have fewer to refer
282so I mean if we have like to develop a strategic strategic Improvement plan by a certain date and then Implement then that we use that plan as the tracker of this goal so step one would be finish the plan and step two would be so we've just started the process so it's just beginning but you've had you've there's a previous draft that existed yeah so there's going to be some recycling no doubt I'm presuming you've looked at the last plan in your group and said well this is what we wanted to do here's where we succeeded here's where there's still some work to be done and that's we just started that process we've just had the first initial discussion around it yep see like because then this shows your leadership of getting like all of
283whatever like the community the teachers everyone involved this is you this is your goal to um get that all organized and implemented and whatever it may you know and then whatever date you choose right so maybe it's next like at by the end of the school year that's kind of where I'm thinking I would say could roll it out for the maybe maybe this goal could be simplified into just that complete the Strategic Improvement plan by the end of this school year okay by the 24 25 school year okay I like your suggestions I love your suggestion I think about all these things all the time you know and like we like we expect you and we expect you to but I don't want to like you I don't want to like monitor your every
284movement or micromanage thank you all right so Susan you have a little update on wants to say something you do I wanted to say is as I listened to the conversation and I looked at sus F and it's two ways of looking at the world two ways of interpreting it and Susan's goals deal with the the greater um direction of Education this board's grow goals is looking at the very specific data in terms of education and and I think that what we need to do is to to sit together and to to combine those two I would never want to lose how you present your your vision for the district I would like to see that reflect the data that that and the actual numbers the actual ratings that this board is looking for I
285don't know how maybe you get can bring us together in that and really really they got high expectations beverlys you're at it fix the United Nations too like that Beverly going did I make a mistake just to bring two different ways of looking at the world of Education together yeah I would say you're process oriented and I'm outcome oriented and I think that's what I that first one it is in a lot of ways I mean I think we're doing exactly what I think so too that's kind of what we're doing yeah I think I think that's that's what Andrea saying she wants to see your vision documented by statistics I need to write the book I need to do the dissertation about my vision I won't tell you what people used to call it
286because I've always got one idea or another because I think basically that's what the whole board wants statistics and data want they want to something you could measure right not to Tang like the plan the Strategic Improvement plan would be a tangible right that'd be something that we can sit and be well now we have a document the goal was to create a document that would help guide the interestingly they use that document too like some of these other documents that just sit there with all of the doia grants eight of them that I have nurtured crafted created followed through we've always had the data like you see in number one but we also have other things that are really important to Department of Defense and those are things like enrollment in courses um looking
287at um teacher efficacy around new programming you know and and really getting teacher insight about how they're feeling about something that's new um there are surveys and surveying kids and surveying parents and surveying so there's a lot of other things that we can do that I can bring you data but that really show that something is working in another way besides just numbers so you can kind of look at that I mean we do that with culture and climate surveys and so one of the things I've learned is they've actually shifted more to not just the numbers and they've actually they're looking for more of these other things I'm not going to call it Soft Data but it's like the buyin from the community and the and the buyin one of the things they applaud
288Gren for is the buyin of these grants and how we move forward and how the teacher efficacy part is appreciating some of this you know professional development because we get a lot of that through these grants so just putting that in mind that it's good to have a kind of a combination of data points but I'll tell you we don't go home we're all gonna pass Matthew you have something to say no I have nothing to say ah really really I think she has something I would just say with organization management I would like to highlight our collaboration and working with budgets together and I'm really hoping for more success how we're going to measure that I don't know but in rolling this out and we have yet another new business manager but if you
289could see the level of detail that she's putting in looking at over time and Trends I feel so confident in what we will eventually get to you so I'm really feeling like you know I'm looking forward to this year working side by side and and so if we could even check that off at you know the we did get some good information about the audit Beverly you want to tell them that because that's in there that it's looking at the Audits and looking at the bo the budgets um John said he received a draft um draft review of the audit and so far it looks good and clean and timely timely so I mean I think there's still some things that have to you know um I shared that with Irene she says well there's
290still a couple things that we're working on but it's not done yet but it's definitely a work in progress so if I were going to Star something that would be it to focus on if that's okay with you what the no the the organizational management our collaboration and our work together on the budget and the budget three the reduction in the number of times you tear your hair out in the course of or maybe the number of hours we're deliberating number of hours we no I'm just kidding but that's part of the collaboration actually yeah all right and then community relations wait wait we don't want to just rush through oh okay well I used 10 o00 in my Bedtime Rush us through without us thinking some CRA was a that was a yeah right
291right I set it up so I don't know it's 10 o'clock if you want to continue yes or no Dean yeah I'm going to continue to continue okay okay okay sorry I'm good to go Ian's good to go Adrian's good to go good to go good to go no do John Kane right sorry so can we get an end point though for Dr aan sake like how much longer half hour max yeah 10 10:30 Max okay yeah well I'm looking for the focus so I'm going to streamline this because I like Jen's idea and all of your ideas so any comments on performance goal number three okay moving to Performance number four community so this and and yes Community um sorry yeah back to three submits and implements a comprehensive hiring retention plan to csde
292communic Cas de School community and the board um just with things like that I mean is there a way we could put a date on that so those have all been delivered we're just waiting for feedback so um we have that um Dei plan is with the state department as soon as I get it back I will present it to you guys or we'll have Lauren come in and that'll be a full presentation is there a component of that plan for reten recruitment hiring and retention yes it's all part of it it's all part of the plan and had to be state approved so that's already something submitted and and and actually was reviewed by the state they gave us some suggestions we've resubmitted it so we're waiting to get it back um so the
293community relation is you know again a personalized approach is really important um through the title one I tried to make it clear in board notes that it's not it's Title One schools but that have been identified and that's Gren Middle School Katherine Kowski fames River and Mystic River although Fitch was coming in pretty close so we really have Title One students throughout our district so there's also a district portion of that and then um I wrote I showed you the narratives and how we write it up um but one of the things I wanted to say um or highlight is that we also added the different family events at each school we had a Google doc and the principles took time to showcase the many many different opportunities that families have to come together and
294we think that really matters my school matters is getting ready to go out before the holidays it's all ready to go and we're editing it um and I've heard good feedback from you know even making sure the larger Community gets the weekly updates so the school community and the larger community so those are just ways to touch base with the community I look at um you know making sure that meeting with the the unions you know I treat them to breakfast once a month and all of them and I want to extend that to the pair leadership too this year so that's one of the ad additional pieces that I'm going to put on to help cultivate that relationship a little better because it's really been stressed between you know um doing our um negotiations
295first and then um you know I just feel like if I could focus and you asked me for a focus area that that not that I'm not going to do all these other things but I would think if I can meet with their leadership team and their larger leadership team with Lori and with Denise at least four times a year and if I can take them out for breakfast you know in the morning and you know really meet with them and just have those honest Communications because that really saves us from grievances in the future there's somebody on and Jay had wanted the board to have a liaison committee with the Paris also so maybe that's something I can set up I can get the information from sus who the par people are and call
296them up just like we have the agsa and G on um um wanted to have they meet in the evening I'd be interested in serving okay you got itate because we used to do it too with the custodians too we used to meet with them also but I don't know what happened I think breakfast meetings with uh individual groups or do you just have a friendly breakfast with all the so what happens is it's their leadership is their president their vice president um separately or with several groups at once no I just do the agsa once a month I then do the GAA and now I would like to do the parent the Paras and then um so I'll focus on that to build stronger relationships in that area I really feel it should be
297our Target and I like the fact be helpful to have a board member attend the breakfast too not the breakfast the breakfast is just where they you'll have your own meeting yeah the breakfasts are where they really will share Heart to Heart what they need and I I put out fires before they start you could can you send me don't forget to send me the I will send you that the numbers sure can you possibly put like um like a number like we'll meet with them like eight times within a school year or seven times with a I think it should be whatever we're doing with the other groups because I wouldn't want them to you that's almost too much for you know I think we meet quarterly with the with the no but maybe
298if we get two more time maybe we get it in the winter in the spring we us with more than that maybe you could put at minimum like three times a year right if it's quarterly you could say minimum three CU we only mon huh yeah use the phrase no fewer than yeah something like that I don't want it to be let me look at the language that's because it's actually something spelled out through the GAA and the agsa joins the gever I think quarterly I think it's quarterly too and we usually set it up because we usually have a final finale of meeting together yeah yeah know because I don't want it to be like a goal and then like you said you come back not that you're going to do this oh like
299I met with them once specific number would be good yeah so if it's well the board meets with them quarterly I don't know how often board chair maybe I meet with them no I meet with them once a month okay for and then and then yeah we only totally maybe not even that three times a year we were supposed to meet in October but that got cancelled November got cancelled December got cancelled so now we're on to January and you figure after January there's going to be one other meeting and then it's going to be summer yeah so this year was twice it's be twice a year but usually it's like three or four times a year yeah we W hopefully we won't have the budget eating Us Alive this coming year Matthew do you
300want to be on the one with the Paris with Ian um to go to a a breakfast no to do no's on meeting's on meeting it'll be an evening haven't you given me enough to do you could say no if we don't want to I would love to but I'm not going to okay Adrian do you want yeah do you want to do it no you already have Ian and uh you need like three people oh okay yeah if you need three people then yes just in case in Cas Ian can't make it talking about a we're just talking about a quarterly meeting the pair is sometimes I as feel like 5 530 is good for me okay thank you and Jen okay I like this you do a if you need a fill in
301I'll do it okay yeah an alternate well somebody can't make it but but of course the have green name so you def want to be on it right okay okay now the Fifth Fifth goal is really bu any comments on any other comments on this goal number four um Jen stole my thunder I was just looking for something definite so that's that's good so the next goal five which I really think is my most important goal is my working with this board and listening very carefully to your good thinking and having you listen to my good thinking it goes both ways um but also I I really applaud and appreciate the Civility and the respect between us too I think that's really important I think it models to the rest of the community too the
302way you know that and the larger you know Community um so I would say that when I I think about one of these goals and you can you can give me a suggestion too one of the things that I'm very aware of is when there are emergency concerns to make sure you get immediate feedback sometimes during an emergency I don't even have all the information right away but as soon as and the principles have done a fantastic job about Community their Communications to their families when something has happened and then I always ask them to send that to ahead of time and we talk about it and then I once they've decided the communications I make sure you get it and sometimes they even give you a heads up on it and there are certain
303things when it's dealing with personnel and certain issues that you know some of the information is confidential and you might be called to help with the situation so I'm just very aware of that but you know beyond that and the the time that we spend on you know the board notes and other things um the other thing I've asked my principles very specific specifically as a goal is to make me aware of anything that they feel clear expectations to administra Administration so that they realize the importance of getting board information in a timely manner and not having surprises you know I've been caught up in surprises where I didn't know I mean it goes back a few years um with some things with the band and band credit if you kind of remember that and
304so I really had to work with the principal to say the these cannot be executive decisions they need to go through me they need to go through the board so I will continue to do that and I think that's another starred Aster thing that I will continue to do and you know hold people accountable and have it in goals so that we really and and communicate always I always say you know even if you don't know if you're not sure just let me know so we can talk it through and make sure that it's if it's something the Board needs to know I need to tell so I think the board may have been remiss in not having expressed to you to pass on to your principles how much we appreciate uh way they've handled
305the emergencies that have gone on yeah they really do and I can't say enough about LJ fararo in the police department right being by my side you know whether it's an emergency and we've had lost a student and in an automobile accident getting in touch with me in the middle of the night um and anything you you know he just right by our side this Police Department is fabulous on the city side and the town side so we do appreciate them too in working with us in emergency situations but if I that can be my focus those two pieces that would be great what will you focus so the setting clear expectations Administration that um you know that any information that needs to be sent to the board in a timely fashion or you know
306things that we're contemplating and that's the principles and it's the central office staff because there were a couple things that Dave laid out and you know that I just um we're not Co well I shouldn't have used his name but you know that we've had people lay out and then you know if I don't have all the information I need then it's never good um and then what was the other one that I asked oh the emergency concerns that making sure you have communication as soon as I can get it to you are you comfortable about putting in something about getting U the dashboards functional by September in the buildings district and Theo level boards this would go back to student achievement yeah it's going say that's not in this Jay also asked me about
307the dash well I think that goes really under goal one okay as long as it happen you're I'll I'll put something about the dashboard bringing that up I was going to talk to Susan about it tomorrow put in my notes okay so by that a deliverable date by so it's it's up and running by the beginning of the next school year okay may has sounds reasonable to me yep it's GNA be a summer well there's there's certain things that we already know about that are on our dashboard we just have to set it up we have it soon Tuesday get soft starts if I have a six-year plan I'm trying to get it done in five please fiveyear plan has a very negative imitation anything we go soon get done I'm almost done it's just
308um no no no with Goal number five yes I'm done with Goal number five Adrian yeah um in this part I I would personally like to see some way to track when there are questions and we'll get back to you or I'll get that for you um some way to actually track that because a lot of it we do get the information but sometimes you know we don't and and from tonight's meeting I think Ian had asked for um something about the testing data how it like there was some State regulation where you couldn't release it that came up um whenever that meeting was um and that and I think you said you'd get back to us on it and we didn't hear but and that that's just a small thing but I think from
309my end it would be nice to have a record of things like you know like meeting you know meeting requests and a way to follow that and then follow up on so it's not that's gonna be our job to write down the questions and make sure make sure I have well I even have all my secretar watching because we you know record everything so they go through it with a fine Toth comb and I've asked them to put down anything that comes up as a question for me I had a thought about this actually and it just kind of came back to me now thanks for bringing it up um maybe we could take a take a page out of the FY or the FAQ sheets that we used for uh 2025 budget was uh
310you know maybe have like a rolling set that up right for me so that it's not just one email that shows up but we have a a standing sheet that we have access to that we in you know if you have those people taking notes like that just the date that a question was asked asked you know who asked it just the initials or whatever and then the question and the answer and whatever links to whatever documents that might be relevant that's good maybe have that updated within certain amount of time of the meeting so whatever is reasonable for so yeah if any individual board members were like no I remember this we can send that email out say was this on there something like that next Central database of those kind of questions anything
311else goal number five oh it's not goal it's just more like how to set up that because like if they do it um column based right in an Excel spreadsheet we could do pivots off of it and then we could have a report by date by topic we did that with the questions that you asked at B budget time we just added links and things yes no not links but the spreadsheet itself would be descrip destion date um General category like type and then whatever four or five other columns let me work on that and I'll bring it to you and check yeah because then we could do a pivot table off of that and say like give me everything from June of whatever 2024 or three and then we could see everything like that
312was discussed in those meetings like a searchable database for all information that we have exact you have to try to like yes on keywords and email searches to find how was the problem with those budget FAQs trying to like search for things like we asked them twice and yes but like we need to like yeah if you need help with whatever the topics are and then we can so that we can develop the datab ongoing brainstorm yeah and I know that some questions are easier to answers are come easier to come up with and I know that Irene has said that she has promised like meeting to meeting like find if it's asked in finance and Facilities that she'll get it back and I think that's just because there's so much going on right now
313between the audit and the budget and she's prioritized which I appreciate the audit and the budget because that's what we need and I'm telling you I can't wait to show you the details she is like really and following policy to the core and teaching others how to follow it so I couldn't be happier every time I see her in the hall I ask what she's doing I think she's happy here with all the pressure that's on her I she likes it here she likes it here yeah all right here only visit us well there's free breakfast up [Laughter] here than appreciate your suggestions that helps me streamline it I feel and I'm in a better place and I'll redo this document did you do number six yeah I just oh did I no no no
314oh this is Oh I thought that was under six the frequently Asked oh no never mind y this is number five so way of tracking board still have 10 minutes and keep going what Happ I don't know if you still have 10 minutes so let's keep going so I would say here's one of the things I want even though this is personal professional one of the things I think I'm really good at is my um networking with all kinds of group whether it's the state department of Ed and asking for funding and all of a sudden I get a check because I said you got all these unfunded mandates and you want me to do this this and this or whether it's working with my learn group I mean they're so wonderful and supportive whether
315it's caps CES cclm all those different organization I really take time to professionally feed my myself you know feed my soul my my intellect my heart and to really Network and get other people's good ideas because I think we can't do it alone so you know that's where I feel like personally and you know I I really care and I really you know think Integrity matters and caring matters and I just anything I'm faced with in a problem like I don't try to blame people I try to I identify what the problem is and bring people in on the problem solving approach that it's not just my idea I'm going to fix it so it's very collaborative but I would say when I look at this um one of the things that I really want
316to have happen this year is for everybody to understand this vision of The Graduate and we started bringing it to all different groups but also with the board to understand it better catchphrase the education always has these catchphrase what vision of The Graduate well it is something that's identified in the state and it's got to be part of our plan and the high school had created the plan but nobody else was involved at that time so everybody needs to be involved because it starts in prek and if this is the vision of The Graduate when they graduate what's happening in prek what does that look like what does Elementary children what does it look like for them what does it look like for middle schoolers who soar I guess do you soar first and then
317you rise or do you rise first and then you soar I don't know I don't know but yeah but it's definitely something that um I like that one you know it it goes along with the belief that every student can achieve at high levels in this district and can find their proclivities and their passions and you know which will help them in their life find the thing that they love to do so I really want to take that as an initiative and I don't know how we'll rate it but I can certainly tell you and keep uh track of all the different ways that we've communicated and if you feel at the end of the year you understand it better and you've had to say so in it then that matters that you know it
318wasn't just some document that we filled out and did for the state and for the plan for neas so do you have this document already the vision of The Graduate did you give it to us no I mean I've got the I've got it outlined but I I can get it to you okay I mean it's probably the same vision we have I'm going to send you an email on that I I'll copy the rest of the people okay use it or not okay so uh again just only a deliverable date on that we can expected is that is it done or is it still in drafting it's in drafting but my idea is to com make sure that the whole Community understands it the board understands it deeply and can talk about it and
319can you know that the staff understands it I think it's part of our strategic planning is to get them to understand it we've already I've already laid it out at a administrative Retreat for the administrators to really think about it at each of their levels so is this something that you're making up you're no it's something that the no it's the it was required through Nas the high school created it they surveyed people and but then it wasn't really shared with the rest of the school community so it was just part from the high school and I've always thought a child comes into the school at prek and sometimes they stay all the way to 12 12th grade but I think it's really something we have to think about at every level almost like benchmarking
320with you know what does it look like here what does it look like here what are what are expectations for them to thrive so I I would just say along those lines just to uh you know to close it out to have a deliverable date where the draft is going to be completed like a deadline to like finish so I would say the end of the year because it's not just a draft I would get you what we have but then I want you know to be able to work with these different groups work with you on what does it look like what is what does it mean not just for the 12th grader who graduate I guess also with that then a schedule for like how are we going to accomplish it we going
321to meet who are you meeting with when yep in order to complete that task and then like the final final revision of that document okay when could we expect that just to have like some hard deadlines like throughout well it's going to take me this year to do this right understood yeah if it takes that long all I know was like I I just I'm just looking for I would like to actually amplify it on the website too you know so that people who come to gron will see what our vision of The Graduate is and um what that means to all of us yeah I have a comment on it though okay okay you know I but I hope it's a good one so oh come on no no she's oh she's gonna okay
322let me talk fast let me talk fast yeah so if you don't know what it means it's right up here no no no so what um so but in order to be there at 12th grade I don't know in your plan if you're like what do they need to look like at the end of fifth grade what do they need to look like at the end of eighth grade because if they're not there at fifth grade they will never get to your 12th grade so I don't know if you're going to do it that way or if you're just like this is my goal for 12th grade no it's it's actually to do what you're saying is to expand it so what does it look like when they're you know after preschool prek and going
323into Elementary what does it look like when they leave Elementary what does it look like in the middle school when they nice I think that kind of benchmarks it a little bit for us helps us to Define it a little clearer yeah I can't wait to see it it's an idea right now Jour I wanted to say but I thought of something to to clarify what I was trying to say before and that is that Susan looks through at the world of Education through the right brain this board looks at it through the left brain but I am the mathematician too I know that besides that's but that's the difference yeah looking at it through the right brain and the left brain and it's I think it's our job together to because the what I'm
324hearing tonight tonight is asking for very specific ways that Susan is going to get through through through very lofty goals and very admirable those but just wants to know exactly how so and I'm good with that and I like that we could reduce it to things that matter for you guys though I've got to do all those things you have to do all of them are you going to adjust this to what we talk I am gonna adjust this okay yeah okay we're good with the dates and the structure and the formats and now Andrea aeran has something to say now we don't have another board meeting can I just say something until January 6 we're gonna have a a special board meeting before we go into the budget to talk about the policies and
325channings thing all right special board meeting long night bring food one night only when um so we've got Shannon say we're adding and then we're going to do the policy whatever policies go through the policy committee that's and have a second reading not a first reading this second just a just a second just a second the first meetings the way to the regular board meeting okay and then I handed you all some other stuff that I thought you know the the legislation you've got some enrollment numbers here to to look at for the projection for 26 and so I have to I have this messy budget calendar and just see if that looks right to you just know that we've got public Hearing in two places and the reason we had it in the second
326we had it here on the 10th of February is because then we'll know more we'll have gone through this and we'll have had if we have this joint meeting I think B you going to check to see if they want a joint Town Council RTM meeting um but that was always something I've been here 10 years and that was always something that we thought we would do um so that they could give us some feedback and then we would do the public hearing so we typically did the public hearing after we met with the liaison group but now we're doing it twice we're doing it once on the 13th and once on the 10th so just if that's what you want if you think we need that I don't know if we need I just
327Chim in on that I mean as far as like the ad hoc budget procedure committee meeting you like we when we talked about it we did identify wanting to have like sort of a bookend approach to like having like public hearing on the front end of the board's deliberations and then as we as we're poised to transition the document towards the Town Council okay to have a second one so this draft is good I can get it cleaned up for you I had no objections but those there based on all our past deliberations okay all right and you know the Compromise date of January 13 so I'm going to put clean up and send out where did we get this date on Wednesday February 5th did we get that date along with the Town Council
328or did we make this date up ourselves I mean do they do they know about this date already I don't know that they know about that date I don't know the answer to that question Mr there's always been in early February it has been yeah it gives us a little bit well it's always been in early February but my question is do they know the date or did we just put this down here we were try to find them if this date is okay with them we couldn't do it on a Tuesday so that's why we put it on a Wednesday we couldn't do it on I'm saying do we no but can you can you find out from them if well if they're interested first of all in doing it and then that date
329is how does that date yeah day we might but we I mean in the past there have been unlike the other departments in town the board of heads had a couple of meetings with the counsil I'm not suggesting we do one is I'm just saying in other words there was one meeting where the council would say well we don't like your numbers could you come back and tell us if we trimmed X dollars what would happen we'd come back again and bad that kind of because I because this meeting is on a board Ed night this February 10th is that that's a board night right I think we usually go to the Town Council they don't come here well we do we do it in the annex but we sit usually in the area to
330do a leaon and we'll have a budget meeting after that so it's we don't I don't know well think about it you we went home last year why don't you find out what works for both of us last year is at the Senior Center no not the liaison meeting no and Town Council was at the Town Hall Annex last year but then we usually have a room we go to so we can do more budget remember going home all right your memory is better than mine yeah maybe I went home too I think I was mortified after we heard about what like was in for Sam salary I'm not sure what we're talking about as far as like the liaison meeting or vers like the joint Town Council joint The Joint one yeah yeah those
331at thriving spot no it was up there then we had a public hearing with the RTM people yeah well it wasn't the whole RTM though was it no it was Mike wh mik but it was at the Town Hall wasn't at right 55 table I remember sitting a lot yeah the only public comment I remember was that motion motion to adjourn all those in favor all right we discuss not Deb not debatable