CorpusRecord 114011

12-9-24 Groton Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Groton Public Schools
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Southeastern Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
26,031 words · about 145 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay good evening it is uh December 9th 2024 it is 6: PM and I'm calling this uh regular meeting of the Gren Board of Education to order our first order of business will be the Pledge of Allegiance and I'll ask our student representative Melanie to lead us in the pledge to thead of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all as I uh previously announced um I am resigning um as the chair effective upon the selection of a new chair this evening um just commitments in my life have made it more and more difficult to uh to really um devote the time that I feel is necessary to that role I will be staying on the board it's been

002a privilege to work with all of you and it will be a privilege to continue working with you um so at this point um I will open nominations um for the uh position of chair of the Board of Ed and I would like to nominate bever Washington second okay are there any other nominations for the position of chair okay hearing none uh without objection nominations are closed I just want to say that um you know Beverly has uh been chair of the board previously over the past year she's really been the co-chair um and I know she's going to do a fantastic job um and we're very uh fortunate to have her she's on the board of learn she's been uh very active with cab um and I think um it would be an excellent

003choice is there any other discussion oh an excellent choice the only choice in my view I move the chair cast one vote for Beverly Washington and the elector by acclamation okay without objection she's so elected by acclamation congratulations thank you I hope I can live up to everything Jay just said but the two most important things for me is trust and communication so we have to have that on this board if we're going to move forward and if I don't answer right away if you email me don't forget I do have a life other than On The Board of Education but just give me a chance to get back to you and thank you for believing in me and I hope I can live up to whatever in your mind you think I'm supposed to

004be doing so thanks again um oh the next order since I was vice chair I'm G to have to step down and we need a a nomination for vice chair so we're opening the nominations for vice chair I'll I'll nominate Adrien Johnson oh you beat me second that second sorry Andrea so Ian nominated Adrian and the second by Mike Whitney um any discussion comments sure are you sure Gateway br so we'll close the nominations and all those in favor Adrien say I I I oppose extensions well all right thank you Beth thank you thank you everybody I'm honor you to be working beside you yeah me as well thank you uh the next on the agenda is recognition and participation of visitors and delegations we don't have anybody today um the next item is comments

005from citizens in regard to agenda items and other subjects of concern that lie within the jurisdiction of the Board of Education this is the portion of the agenda where the board welcomes comments from citizens each presentation should be limited to five minutes or less and citizens should if possible submit written comments presentation should be related to maners C to gron board members will only ask questions in order to clarify the speaker speaker presentation and that respond during the comments of Citizen por of the board meeting citizens should make their presentation from the podium and state their names and address for the record do we have anybody question could we get a microphone oh she has my my voice is so loud if it wasn't for recording you wouldn't even need a microphone so we we'll

006use it so make sure everybody gets uh here's it um so my name is Porsha bordelon I live at 2024 Jefferson Drive BR in Connecticut for full disclosure Ian Thomas is my husband for full disclosure I'm a Fitch high school graduate for full disclosure I was a PA in the Gren public schools with in the medically fragile room at one point back in the day when I was a stay-at home mom um and I um you know um excited to be here to talk because I'm very passionate as you know about education um first I just want to congratulate Bev for being on um Bev is actually it's interesting to go back I graduated from fit 8 Beth handed me my diploma um I was good friends with her daughter in high school through track

007in cross country I spent almost all my time with Porsche actually her name happens to be Porsche as well I'm excited also to see so congratulations to you be I'm also excited to see Adrien Johnson um who was definitely one of my top members I know that you stated you know beev was your only choice but I definitely Adrian was somebody that I was really convincing to join this board because I felt he'd have a lot to bring in a different view that um wasn't being represented with that I'm here I'm very concerned about the the article in the examiner about brought and public uh schools pitch tutoring Raffles and accountability to address the low test scores um I know for the new members you guys are kind of being handed this and this is

008something that you guys can work over the next you know several years to improve but we need to get back to what your mission statement states which is teaching teaching and learning um I kind of you know I reached out to a few of my friends that are teachers in and out of the district and around other districts when they read this article and got their opinions and thoughts the teachers are working with very little support and very little um help um and financial support um they really are like First Responders on ground level most times we can't even get Paris in there and they have to continue forward and deal with a lot of different things that are going on in our culture our community at the time and so my hats go off

009to those teachers and what they have to deal with as a person who's come here and spoke about the honors level courses at Fitch High School do you hear me now do you hear me now honors level courses are needed at the high school level we cannot continue on the track and the trajectory that we are on if we truly are educating our children if our lowest level is College Prep which in fact as a person who speaks very openly the word College forup to me is an insult why would that be an insult I see your face why is that an insult not everybody that leaves Fitch high school goes to college so why should they be subjected to college level classes they should be meeting the standards of Workforce Readiness in possibly College

010we should look at ways to change that class in fact and say something like career and Workforce Readiness as well as college entry level enhancement by putting kids that are already at a lower level that normally would have been General in a college prep class it's kind of a joke I thought it was a joke I've been speaking about it since the change happened seven years ago it's a concern and this board and I imploy our new leaders on this board to look at that you can not have a Continuum of Education which is a linking block like math and when you look at the scores that were presented here in the uh online um without having the middle block the feeder program that enhances that you have to do that it is indicative to

011have honors level courses the science level and I'll speak openly because my son is no longer in the school both of my kids are gone we were met with roadblock after roadblock after roadblock with Injustice and infrequency when you look at like I come before you often asking about your career counselor arttime career counselor for how many students I look at other districts less students full-time career counselor teaching and learning get back to that message if you truly care about those sat store scores act and even asbab scores get yourself a full-time career counselor the access and accessibility to um Prat program and build up to the test taking almost not existing at one point they offered a class during the day my son tried to get in they said they didn't have any more

012room what are you supposed to do constantly this article talks about oh the you know the children that are getting free I'm tired of hearing about free and reduced launch h of it stop Landing the scores on the people on the backs of the children who don't deserve it the most who need the help and enhancement stop blaming it on our most critical students who um are in um IEPs and special LED for your scoring and I'll speak openly my son had an IEP one had a 504 and I had to fight every every step of the way to get to what he has why did I have to fight because they wouldn't give him anything my son proudly now is in the upper level he was the only student at the time I had

013to fight for that you know what they told me in Middle School Mrs bordelon we don't have anybody to push into that class in Middle School to help him I said that's a problem that you should be proud of find him to help got to high school they didn't have the tutors oh we have tutors Mrs bouron not for calculus our tutors we hired are not trained in calculus at one point Mr Brown was privately tutoring Aiden a couple days a week for a short time when he had free time we were told Mrs bordon we have the Falcon Academy okay well he has an IEP you have an individual education plan a requirement by the state to provide high level service to students on their level where they're at individual education plan use that

014word for everybody even the kids that are not in special ed that should be your goal as a district and it's not we're not meeting the needs students overwhelmingly are not getting the support that they need and those kids that you call the free and reduce you're right they are not meeting the grade because their parents can't afford private tutors like I was able to and if it wasn't for that my son would not be on a full ride to main mayor time Academy if it wasn't for my advocacy and my husband's advoc and that's why he chose to run when he went back looking at getting a masters in special education he was uh tutoring um working over at Old Li East Li schools and brought back a program that we have here now

015called task I advocated for it because I was publicly elected and he brought the knowledge that we didn't have that can help 504 students military kids there was non-existent programming we can do better in grotten we have the resources let's get our heads together and make it happen these scores need to come up I don't know how that's not the first agenda on your your your paper tonight 25% and then oh well we're a high needs District we know that we' known that forever then they say we got Transit military kids I my kids were those military kids too and we were local we know that figure it out come up with a plan how do we have tutors that are hired that can't do calculus but yet overwhelmingly we keep offering these higher level

016courses but we can't meet the needs sou Academy is a great option if a student doesn't have a self-esteem issue or doesn't want to go meet with a peer and expose that they're not understanding how to learn you know you know that's that's pretty big at 15 years old to say I'm not getting this now let me ask this cool peer that's getting it to help me and that's the only option available well Mrs Bon that's all we have when I called other districts they said that's unacceptable and no offense Mrs dittle I know we've had our struggles and I'll speak openly I've been in meetings where I was told you know by Mrs dle herself that in fact you know I don't think the problem is that you know Aiden's IEP I think he's

017in two high level classes maybe he should change a few my husband was there to witness my concern is that's where you should want to be just because a kid has an individual education plan doesn't mean they're not College Bound and in fact they just have a different way of learning that Groton hasn't figured out and they need to figure it out and they need to provide the services to make sure everybody can succeed and that should be our goal here how do we not have the tutors I looked at other things in different States and they what they did is they added programs where high level teachers you might have a middle school teacher who can teach higher level math they offered them a stip an extra check on top of their their um

018their salaries if they wanted to come teach a math club or an enrichment program for prats we need to start thinking outside the box we have a concern here red flags are going off Sirens Let's Go Math and Science and we need to look at our curriculum a lot of folks even teachers I've spoke to who won't come up here and publicly speak about it all our curriculum is not Continuum we need to be doing better to make sure those kids overwhelmingly at times at Middle School level we'd get there and they'd say these kids aren't ready high school they get there they're like what happened in middle school there needs to be more collaboration to make sure everybody's on the same page and those teachers are getting the support at ground level you cannot

019fill the lower level classes with a ton of kids and offer no support and then say we barely have 50 you know however many percent of the PA is not available I was a par there were days I was moved from one kid to the next kid to the next kid meanwhile I have two kids both behaviors trying to mediate trying to keep the cat class calm so the teacher can teach but also making sure those students are allowed to be there and deserve to be there to learn at their level we have to figure it out we cannot keep funding enrichment programs and saying you're worrying about the mo morale of the teachers and sending them off enrichments and learning in Hawaii and here and there and paying for those but not paying for

020high Lev tutors those are great those should only be happening if and when we have done done everything to exhaust the support at the ground level those programs shouldn't happen you know what if I'm a teacher and and the true enrichment happens if you really want to teach and learn your goal is to make sure those students your obligation like I left my work today feeling fulfilled that I re reached my goal as a teacher when you walk out of there your job is to make sure those kids are passing and excelling at what they're being taught and they have all the tools that's the morale support happens day to day not in Hawaii not in enrichment if they're certified and they come here ready to teach they're ready to teach and if they're older

021teachers that have been here a while they even have more skills the the enhancement of those enrichment programs are a nice thing to have if we can do it but you can't say you're going to cut our tutors and fund other programs and then people are going off all these vacations and do everything which is wonderful but they're not supporting high level tutors let's get to teaching and learning let's get back to getting those honors classes back here let's look at renaming that class that's College Prep which is insulting when our college success rates of leaving are aren't even that high and you're calling you're telling everyone go into this college class that's insulting someone's dream might be to be a weldered EV and we should help them get there not in the college PL

022course let's get back to teaching and learning thank you Mrs Board online anyone else would like to address the board anyone online no one online has their hand raised okay thank you um next is response to comments from citizens anyone would like to respond to miss border line I just uh thank you for coming out and sharing your thoughts and uh I look forward to working with the board on addressing many of those issues okay student so this week on Friday um FES participating in the Statewide pajama day to support the Connecticut Children's Foundation so the kets club will be collecting $1 from anyone who wants to participate and the money will go to the Connecticut's Children's Center for Cancer and blood disorders um also the student leadership Club is finalizing a holiday spirit week

023for next week and so everybody's getting very excited for a break and there's lots of holiday spirit at F TR did you get any feedback from what you talked about last meeting about the Chromebooks and the water filter yes um I heard that they're working on that it sounds like there was like a Chrome extension kind of problem and I've already noticed that my Chrome books already been working better and I'm very glad and what about the water toas um I actually saw people working on the water fountains last week at school so um that was very nice to see and I'm glad that that it's being like that we've got the right people in the room hearing this to make sure that it happens thank you I don't want your concerns to go under

024thank you um the next is superintendent speak all right so I have um some guests to introduce you to that are going to be talking to a little bit about our Early Childhood Program that we currently have and some things that we're aspiring to do in the future and and I wanted the board to weigh in on this and start thinking about this but it's always we've always kept Mary Morrison as a school and it certainly has supported um Ernie and the food service program and Treehouse and our early childhood assessment team and we always wanted to keep that as a school building because we wanted to make sure that if we were ever in the need to extend our Early Childhood Program or had the need because of the number of students that we

025are receiving that we would have a place for them so Denise dou and and Karen and Jen and um Meg are here to help us um and talk to us a little bit about the current program that we have and we were very proud of it we were the first um District in the state to come up with a transition to kindergarten and Meg Walker was really our first teacher of the program it was once so one you know you know one full day program for the whole district and that was because of the age students were coming to us at the age of four and maybe not turning five until December 31st or January 1st and our teachers had always come to us and said that's really young and now the state and its

026infinite wisdom has changed the the starting date for kids to the September they had to be um five by September one to come to kindergarten and we were in a really just right place to transition some kindergarten teachers at each school and to have Meg Walker's leadership um and Jen theal as our social worker for Early Childhood to help support the program and it's really gone well but I'm going to turn it over to you all because you're the experts in this and you can talk to us a little bit about the program and some of the ideas that we have thank you superintendent Austin um so I'd like to introduce you to um the folks who are here tonight uh Karen hayatt I think this is your first time meeting Karen oh thank you

027Jen thank you very much Jen uh Karen hayatt is our supervisor for Early Childhood programs and Karen comes to us from the Brooklyn Public Schools she started this summer and Karen actually has a background uh as a behavior analyst she's a board certified behavior analyst as well as a specialed teacher and Karen has taught in a variety of settings including some self-contained classrooms with students with more significant disabilities so we're happy very happy to have Karen join us we also have Jen theel who is our early childhood social worker Jen supports teachers students and families at the preschool kindergarten level both at fames River and Mystic River and we have Meg Walker who was our Pioneer for the transition K program um Meg uh worked with Susan and naen very closely to create the the

028transition K program and this summer um I really couldn't Karen and I couldn't thank her enough Meg trained the additional three teachers who were hired uh for TK which we affectionately Call Transition k um and she shared uh just a variety of resources that she has in terms of her schedule she has researched curriculum um all sorts of tips tricks and a little bit of the play based learning initiative from the state that you'll see in the presentation this evening so I really want to thank Meg Jen and Karen the three of them are are leaders um in the early childhood area and our district is very fortunate to have them I'd also like just to add to that that it was our Preschool teachers and our kindergarten teachers that came together with Meg in

029designing the curriculum and really the three of the four were really experts in that and had worked side by side with Meg so for them to take that on it was just it really was a smooth transition and then they'll they'll possibly go back to kind Garten next year but we'll we'll see we've got some ideas so Karen is going to get us started and um if you recall as Susan just um alluded to this is the first year that we have um worked with our new legislation for those of you who are new to the board um who might not recall we did a lot of work prepping the board in our district uh last year in terms of the change to the kindergarten eligibility age so this is the first year that students

030in Connecticut had to be five by September 1st in order to enter kindergarten um so with that in mind Karen's going to lead us through a presentation of how things are going and uh some ideas that we have for the future okay all right thank you um so we just wanted to give an overview of what the current programming looks like for Early Childhood um and so right now this is what it looks like basically we have um five five kind of programs in District um the first and we'll talk a little bit through the slides um about each one um but we have ecat which stands for the Early Childhood assessment team um and that's currently at Mary Morrison we have integrated preschool we in the pre the next slides you'll see we're going

031to hopefully continue current programming for that um they at themes River and Mystic River right now early otter um is our specialized programming for students with more intensive um needs for their IEPs um and that is right now housed at Mystic um Mystic River pre kindergarten um is currently at themes River and Mystic River and then transitional kindergarten which I couldn't do without Meg here so she's going to have a great spiel about that later um but they are actually at four of the schools Mystic River themes River Nea and CK so Charles Barnum children get a seat at one of those programs if they were eligible yes y so I'll just we just kind of wanted to go through um and talk a little bit about each program a little bit um so ecat

032really serves as our bridge between the berth to3 Services um in our school district they do the transition meetings they are the ones that initially meet the families um they have another p a ppt1 we call it um is really is just a meeting for um if meeting the family and if they need any further evaluation um planning that um and then they will do the observations the evaluations they write the reports um and then we come back for another a second PPT um and they plan the IEP if they're eligible and what services are best for that student um they also screen evaluate students who may be referred who don't come through the birth to three process that are in Pre kindergarten um and they also provide um a weekly speech groups for students

033who are eligible ages 3 to five um as part of their IEP these students are the ones that wouldn't meet criteria necessarily to go into the integrated preschool um but do meet the criteria for that Weekly speech group um there it comprises of two uh special education teacher and a speech pathologist right now um and they do a fabulous job over there so that's kind of um our integrated preschool um really are for students who either have an IEP um for special education services or they made the criteria for peer models um so each three to five-year-old is screened um come for a screening and GR in and based on what the results of the screening they get you know kind of an assessment result and if they meet peer models um they would go

034into the program to serve as like kind of a typical peer and an integrated it's a really nice model um for socialization and everything like that so it's either students with an IEP or a peer model um students are 3 to five years old um we have 12 sessions so we have six class CL rooms three um right now at Mystic three at themes and they are half day programs so um there's 6:00 a.m. and 6 PM there's 192 slots total um in those two programs for both students with special education services and the peers um and like I said they're at Dames and mytic right now um with that we have an early aut program which is really our more intensive specialized program for students three to five years old um there is there's

035one classroom right now but two sessions AM and PM um and it's about 10 to 12 slots um total in the program so like 5 to six in the morning 5 to six in the afternoon um and that it's a really nice model with the integrated preschool because they do get to go into the integrated preschool rooms get time for socialization work on those skills um with you know kind of typical peers um or that criteria would that meet that criteria all right um our current pre kindergarten and you know this is as we talk um this is probably what you'll see the biggest change or one of our ideas for next year um but right now it's for students who meet the criteria for Kinder kindergarten Readiness skills so again they'll come to that

036screening um and based on those results if they meet a certain criteria they will get put into this program for really um learning all of those pre- Readiness skills for kindergarten um you can it's with or without previous um preschool experience so some come with it some come without um and it's for right now this school year students who turn four within the calendar year of 2024 next year you'll see um it's a little bit different just because of a legislative change right now we have four sessions so we have a classroom at Mystic and we have a classroom at themes who split um at AM or PM session so there's four total and we have 64 slots um for students within the district um now I'm going to hand it over to Meg who's

037going to talk all about her baby transition um just want to first thank the board for all your support for the past this is my sixth year here in gron doing transitional kindergarten and I appreciate all the support and what you guys did have found this program because as an educator it's been just the best opportunity um transitional kindergarten students I always say are the happiest kids in the district I was really able to create a program that meets the needs meets these children where they are and gives them the gift of time i' had been a kindergarten teacher prior to starting the program and seen how those youngest students were struggling many needing a second year and when you need a second year and your first year struggling puts a bad taste in your

038mouth for education so this gift of time has really helped our students to come in and have a great first year their needs are being met we're learning at a pace that works for them individually um and then I'm able to extend and push them further and see real growth and success um so we're building that foundational knowledge that gets them ready for kindergarten transitional kindergarten students coming with a lot of needs either academically or socially emotionally and then we're building those skills for them so they enter kindergarten with a very strong Foundation um with the focus on both those pieces um in TK I use a very play based approach um both in Center work as well as play open Play time and you know get them outside side working on those self-regulation skills

039working on pre-literacy pre-math skills and then when they're ready um especially this year with the opportunity for more kids to be involved in TK I've got some who are ready to read and we can work on those skills as well and challenge the kids who are ready for that challenge um but every kid's met academically and socially where they are um and then I've also had the great experience of seeing my kids as they move up in the grades with that confidence and the skills you see them coming TK shy and quiet nervous or maybe lacking in some area and now I see them in second in third grade and they're The Confident when they see them you know the progress they've made I talk to teachers I'm oh I had him in TK they're

040like he was in TK he's my top student I'm like because he was in DK he's your top student they have that opportunity that they really know themselves and so it's been a it's a great program and then this year we've extended it out we have three other teachers teaching it and they're giving me the same feedback they love their jobs because they're able to meet the kids where they are and then Challenge and extend with them through that play based model which J's can talk more about so um I don't know if we've discussed it before at a board meeting but there was a with the change in the age for kindergarten there was also a play-based learning legislation piece so now in Connecticut um preschool prek TK and kindergarten must provide play based

041learning on a daily basis um and so we've been working with um an outside consultant and doing some training last year and this year in preschool in kindergarten um and so I just kind of put some ideas on here of different things that um can be done and have been done with play based learning in our district um a lot of the literature in this change in um the legislation is based on developmentally these kids learn best through play at the young age and so while we're trying to enhance our academics we need to build up our play skills and making sure that it's really planful and how we're going to Target things that the kids need whether it's um more vocabulary and language or if it's theal skills and conflict resolution um what one

042of the the pictures was actually um like a science investigation which really bridged out an entire literacy block that was about animals and hibernation um but it led into speakers and field trips outside on the grounds and the kids making things and so really tying all those things together together so that the kids are remembering the things that they're learning um tied into the curriculum um really having more with what me was talking about the centers TK is like the perfect place to have this start out because it's already being done in her classroom all the time and really having those engaging centers where kids are able to be Hands-On with the different learning tools um and really planning it out aligned with the curriculum um I put on a one little I love this

043little loose Parts picture um loose Parts is really becoming some something I'm reading about a lot when it comes to play based learning because kids are having to use their imagination but also being able to stretch what they think a lot of like the toys are when you give kids like a cash register they can only use it as a cash register um if you give a kid um a cucumber they can only use a cucumber but when you have a lot of different Hands-On materials they're using their imagination to play and they can use it into different ways um so it's just another thing we're implementing in all their Early Childhood classrooms all right thank you um and I mean Meg and Jen are here today and you as you can see we're all

044very excited and enthusiastic about this but it's really the whole team um it's a great Early Childhood team um and I think if they all could be here they would um you know hearing the speaker before you know I think especially my experience so far in groten the early childhood Educators love their jobs they you know they really and they're so committed um it's it makes my job very easy um but it's also you know it's really exciting and this is where it all starts where all the learning starts so um you know we're just going to try to enhance that moving forward um so at with that our kind of our proposal or idea for next year um it looks like really continuing ecad Services as it is um at Mary Morrison um kind

045of continuing the current programming there same with integrated preschool um for next year at least um and they would remain at themes River and Mystic River um early otter were hoping will transition with us over to um Mary Morrison um because our idea is really to merge um our pre kindergarten rooms with our TK rooms because we've seen how successful um they are with the full day program with the kind of a little bit more rigorous curriculum that Meg and the team have created um and making them three full um classrooms um which would be really nice we would still have 16 to 18 students per session um and then you know we're hoping if we can look into and I know Susan's already on it um we all are looking for Grants um maybe

046expanding that even more so we can start to offer more of a universal pre kindergarten um for the kid kindergarten Readiness um and again it it it goes back to like that teaching and learning this is where it all starts and expanding it I think um we're all really exced excited about it and you know we've seen how much success the programs have made that we just want to continue that um we would move these um transition to kindergarten what we would call the prek TK merge um to Mary Morrison hopefully um and start to build um kind of An Early Childhood Center there um next year so I thinking a tour with Sam Kilpatrick and just marveled at how well the building has been kept up and they have a whole section of six

047classrooms that were dedicated for preschool and k um prek and K back in the day and um I just met with Melissa Jenkins from the state department she's in charge of Alliance districts and we had a wonderful two-hour meeting and shared some of the things that were happening in Groton um she you know had some connections with anarie um and an Marie's amazing work in East Hartford and what she was able to accomplish and when we mentioned this she talked about Smart Start which is a preschool program and she was going to contact me as soon as she finds out more about this Grand opportunity that helps um really essentially help grow almost a universal prek experience so imagine that every child in Granton between the grant that we get for Early Childhood that supports

048Riverfront and Head Start programs or um ecdc EC DC it sounds like a rock band devel but and then to have a program of our own you know that we could nurture um and have a kind of An Early Childhood Center um you know would be really exciting but we thought start small with what we have and and grow it and um but we have the space the resources um Karen's administrative maybe a teacher leader you know who could help support it and um you know we just just wanted to introduce the concept to you and it would also alleviate I think you've heard from both themes River and Mystic River and you've seen the school that Mystic River re they really have a lot of challenges they have some of our most significant programs

049and the you know the largest number of students and um I think if if we could help support and move some of those programs to An Early Childhood Center it would give them more room for the District magnet and I think more support from us so that's another piece of the puzzle I will let you all pass questions here any questions um if we add those two extra classes how um what percent of the population in that TK pkk would we be able to support because obviously right now we we're not supporting all those the kids so so I think because it would be a full day program it would be very advantageous to our families and even with having tree housee we could possibly do some before and after care right there because Treehouse

050is there so I think for our families um it would be the kind of thing that we could even get them there at home so I think that it would really be a program that would grow and flourish even if we started small with the three programs right now the half day programs at prek there's a little bit of responsibility for families getting them back and forth and it doesn't really it takes like all year for it to fill up so I feel like we're going to get more for our children when you know Miss bordon talks about focus on teaching and learning I couldn't agree more and we know that early childhood is where we need to start if we want to accomplish all that we want to accomplish for kids if we could

051really have a robust Early Childhood Program in this District um it would help our kids it would just lift them up from the beginning and it's always been kind of a dream of mine um but it's the dream of a lot of peoples you know I would say we've talked about it even as a board when we started with this TK program and trying to you know get it off to a good start oh I totally agree but right now I'm just trying to understand like what percentage of the population TK 2K are we able to support cuz like you said some of them goes to ecdc um Riverfront right I just want to make sure that like yes that and maybe um can we support like 100% of all the kids that need it

052you know like um we do have some students who go to the Friendship school that learn provides It's a Wonderful Early Childhood Center and I think they're even taking on little one babies for next year so our our families do have other places that they can go and I think this this would fill a need so that you know I would love for every Granton parent if they had a child and they wanted to have a program such as this to be able to have it one in one place or another between you know the resources that we have so the children that um attend Riverfront Children's Center and the early childhood development Development Center those children um are funded through what's called a School Readiness Grant um and learn manages the grant we're kind

053of like just the pass through for the grant funds so they're they're not necessarily programs that we administer and that we coordinate um we're just supporting those children's seats in that program but we're very involved with Children First grotten who also is a liaison with those programs so that the Community Partnerships are still very important we're not trying to take those children from them you know they still have a place in our community but I think this would just give us added um seats in our in our district so are we at 30% supporting like every family who needs um or wants or are we at 50% that's what I'm trying to understand I don't think we really have a a picture of the number of families that have three to five year olds okay

054um you know we certainly work with the families who come to our screenings but we don't know if those are the only students that there are in the district that are between three and five years old I can I can say this though with transition K we were able to provide every child who would have gone to kindergarten but was no longer eligible a SE so whether they went to the transition K or they went to another pre year of preschool or whatever it I mean I never heard from a family that did not get a seat no that was our goal really to have these programs this year to bridge the gap with the new leg ation for the um the the age the eligibility age for kindergarten so what we're trying to do

055now is is Envision what this would look like next year I like the idea by the way thank I just want the reason I'm asking is like I just want to understand like how many parents who have kids um who appli but weren't able to get in that's the number I'm trying to get at well generally speaking the only children who apply that don't get in are children who um are referred to the Early Childhood assessment team that Karen reviewed with you and that the reason they do get in eventually but they get in because um they get first they get an individualized evaluation so sometimes we have children that come to our screenings who have never been in uh preschool who are nonverbal um and they obviously you know need an individual evaluation and

056they they've sometimes in the early otter program they need that really specialized support so they do get into the program but we need to determine what's the most appropriate program do you have a waiting list please we do not we used to but we don't now no we do not we really try to take them all yeah we have some children who are sometimes they're too young to screen and we just say to the parent you know why don't you come back to our next screening you know sometimes they'll cry they don't want to leave their parent or were unable to screen them but for the most part everyone gets screened and you know just about everyone gets a seat thank you did you have I did I did just just two questions uh I

057wanted to get it I think I wanted to get at the same thing Jen so let me take another approach uh is the population pretty steady from year to year in kindergarten in first grade we say that we're each year between I'm making up numbers between 200 and 230 do do we have a baseline number for a given class age that yeah a fork that's reason well that that's a good question and this year was a different year because not all of our children came to kindergarten I but I'm looking for I'm looking I'm trying to to to see where we're going with this uh we have 192 slots let's stipulate that there that the average class size for kindergarten over the number of years is X I don't would 192 represent all of X

058or is it uh represent what what is X can you give me a rough idea of what a fork would be I do think um I and I don't remember if it was Denise or Susan um oh Lauren said roughly 350 to 375 for kindergarten so but I do so there is a there is a population that goes to like the mag the Friendship school for example because it's a full day program I do think if we opened a full day program for more slots that Pro I would imagine a lot of them would come back to District so I would think we would increase that percentage okay so let's stip let's stipulate that 350 is a good working number to play with okay and we've got 192 we' probably pull some but not all

059in the Friendship school we might pull some from some other Prov ERS uh that would still leave us perhaps 50 to 100 more students than we have now do we have the capacity to deal with that next year like putting money aside putting money aside do do we have the capacity we we are starting small after talking to Miss Jenkins I was really thrilled because she's going to get back to me on what it would look like if there if this Smart Start Grant came through and you could get two more seats because that would give you you know another um probably 36 kids that you could take care of so okay um for a full day instead of half day programs um but learn does a spectacular job I have to say when our

060children go to learn for the their Early Childhood Program I always am confident when they come back that they're ready to learn as well so I think that through the community we're not going to take all of the children from the community program some of them are really near their homes and they love those Riverfront programs and so you know I'm not competing with our community I'm just trying to enhance our community because I know that there's lots of other programs that are wonderful as well so what I hear what I'm hearing between the lines is that this year we have 192 slots in a perfect world we're in grot and we're pretty close in a perfect world we would like to increase that by 30 next year and the following year another so some

061metrics so we can we can see how we're progressing so 192 if I can interrupt that's the integrated preschool so that's three to five year olds okay so that doesn't include your pre I think you're just talking about the four year olds that would go to yeah I'm I'm just okay I didn't understand that okay fine yeah thank you second question you referred to a peer models could you tell a poor Pilgrim what that means of course sure um so when they come to the screenings uh we do an evaluation or a screener um that really looks at you know their communication levels uh their play skills their social skills you know their ability to follow directions if they meet a certain criteria on that then they you and I mean I could get it

062for you after this but um the criteria bases you know of a more typical student that would be entering into preschool or kindergarten um in what we think would be like a nice model for a student that may need you know help with those skills that answer the question closer okay I may need some tutoring hi do Tut let me try to clarify further so the integrated preschool programs are really created to support the students who have IEPs coming out of birth to three to be in preschool um and what we want for those classrooms is to be more like a tra traditional classroom where they're not just with other students with IEPs but they have other students who do not have disabilities do not have an ie with them so those peer models are

063those regular education students students without an i AP All also balancing out a classroom does that makes yep thank you no problem do we note the chat up there kindergarteners PR okay thank you Lauren Mike thank you got two questions one's help with the the number student numbers and the other one's more about Mary Morrison but the the student numbers so I've got this slide with the the very helpful with the four bubbles it's the state as is um and for the the two bubbles on the right the the pre kindergarten you see that's four half day program 6 to 18 16 18 per session um and then on another page that's 64 slots so so I get that um the transitional kindergarten for full day session classrooms 16 to 18 students per class uh

064there was for I didn't see anything for transitional kindergarten the number of slots um currently but if I put that together is that another 64 yeah okay and so is that currently to 18 students and we have four yeah and and is that what we currently have in about right I don't think we fill up those um TK slots at the beginning the pre kindergarten the TK are pretty y I'm talking about the prek yeah prek is not so it takes a while like I think there's about seven or eight in each session right now and we try to continue to grow that program so it's not I wouldn't say it's necessarily 64 at this point so in the prek so so it's it's more like 50 yeah something like that so okay and then

065with the the new the proposed for next year with the three bubbles I can I can see you know the change of course to the right with the the merger the prek TK and I can see reasons for that uh but then I've got three classrooms times 16 and I come up with way less slots I don't understand that at all like where what happens to the rest of the students so I mean I think that is one of the reasons why we're looking for grants for um the extra classrooms but there is also a smaller number of students this year because this year was the first year of the legislation we had a larger number of students that we call her like the bur babies the like September October November December students that's why

066the reason you know for the expansion of TK this year we do have a small bubble of those students kind of left that would qualify for TK but the law has kind of created a smaller and then next year it'll be even smaller however we don't really know ever what that and I I get you know it looks like it is a smaller number of slots um but we don't know like the typical four-year-old so then it would just be the not all four-year-olds we would be going off of the law which would be January 1st to September 1st moving forward this year we did not but so now so for next year what proposed 3 * 16 is 48 right um that's less yeah we we would do 18 I I'm just going kind

067of the numbers have always been by the lower end so um okay uh you know 50ish that's less than the slots that we currently have for prek and then we also have another 64 slots that I know there's a bubble but it's currently full it seems like we're um merging classes but heavily like maybe cutting in half at least uh the number of slots for students and um is that because I I see what you're saying about the bubble uh but is that entirely because you're projecting that you're going to have a need that much less need because I heard if you offer full day that we get more people back um or is it just a lack of funding that that's what I'm wondering about because I the numbers literally don't add up and

068was to start small um but we're starting smaller we we have we've started and now we're making it smaller so it's not we we've we've already started and so that it's cutting it right so it's not starting at small well well when you think about the fact that those prek programs this year are not really being utilized to their full capacity 50 students right I think there's less more than that no I think it's 30 yeah well let's get the right numbers then sure let's not think what they are let's get what they are sure y we can do that um and then we are hoping um if grants pan out to add two additional classrooms so our goal would be to have five full day PK classrooms at Mary Morrison if funding allowed and

069I was sticking the only reason I said three Mike was because those are the positions in our operating budget we already have two prek positions and one TK but when went to do this I had told the board that we're going to transition over some of the kindergarten teachers to do the TK but at the end of the year I wasn't promising that we would put it in operation funds that's why I wouldn't have said you know it would be wonderful to take the four that we have and add the two more pre that would give us six but I wasn't going to put that on our budget and on the board at this point if I can get the two extra though through a Smart Start Grant and do something like that you know

070that would give us even more slots so that was kind of the ultimate goal but I didn't want to saddle um who's funding Smart Start Department of Ed and how long is the grant for do you want to come up because you know a little bit about the grant you can tell us because she did this in East Hartford and it was very successful we got the good chair so Smart Start hasn't been um is we're waiting on legislation for Smart Start right now so we won't know until I think they're in session but um Smart Start was originally issued I want to say back in I applied for that when um maybe 2014 or 15 and um East Harford uh was awarded that Grant um we received funds for that grant for a number

071of years in fact I believe District still receive some funding for that Grant to fund uh teachers for at least one or two classrooms um over the years I believe the um amount was reduced um and that is just because it's been probably about 10 years since since that Grant has beened to the district and when we reached out to the State Department of Education just recently um you know we were uh let they let us know that you know they're kind of waiting on the legislation for that that's something we can talk legislators about that is something that they would like to um to fund so P you had to break for 10 years yeah they really created the whole Childhood Center and welcome center yes so um at the time East Harper wanted

072to transition they had a number similar to the model that is in place here in gron they had um uh prek in um a variety of elementary schools and they wanted to bring them together into one Center um in which would be essentially what we referred to at the time as a One-Stop shop so it would be all of our preschool classrooms um we had a um school-based Health Center at the time in we guarded a health school based Health Center um we um established a Welcome Center for Families there um and we also wanted to at the time um relocate our um Central registration there unfortunately we were not able to do that just because we ran out of space the demand for preschool was So High by our community um that we continue

073to um open up more preschool slots if you will can I ask my my Mary Morrison question so so I do this is this more for a superintendent so I do understand the um um advantages of centralizing uh potential ones but um also Mary Morris and I remember as a old and cold school maybe it can be warm sometimes but it's not going to be young um and if you do that if you bring more students in I recognize there were already some students but uh don't we then need a principal a vice principal school nurse a nurse's assistant um different busing routes that are probably going to be longer for these little little kids um and that would also add uh Transportation costs um I'd like that that and and then we have less

074slots which I'm now realizing um I'd like I'd like to know about at some point those those full costs and that's in the context of of budget but but this this could be I know it's this is a superintendent report but I think this could really be an agenda item for a future meeting too abut this quite a big change yeah um thank you but but I would like to know if we do this do we need principal vice principal nurse busing rots and it's the school's still cold oh you can answer the cold question but it looked in very good condition when we walked through and it was would be very easy to set up and you do need an administrator um but with Karen's experience with early childhood and um in New London

075what they do is a teacher leader person with an administrator so they cover their bases I love the idea of school-based Health but we also have a floating nurse so there are things that we have in place that could help us put this together in a small way it might have to grow it might need a grant to help us grow but it's it's an idea I wanted to really let you all hear about and and busing it's a kind of centralized location for us but it be it'd be a separate route like they I would guess right now they're probably going I guess at least they're going to themes or Mystic River are they on separate buses right now um or they go with the the other elementary kids um it depends on their

076age and size so um some day runs they're by themselves but program but the morning and afternoon are they the the prek and transitional K are they on the yeah so I think we're g to have quite a big expense there too by parents is is there a real space like I I know the middle school has a space issue I we had all the principles through I didn't hear Spa issues unless I missed it for the elementary school so and then we're having only three classrooms which is less than we have now so is there a space pressure here they missing just I had mentioned themes River and Mystic River has the significant programming and the preschools and so you know it leaves less room for the older kids especially in a lottery situation

077um so we felt like this would be actually supportive of those two buildings which really have the largest amount I would say all of our schools are pretty full though there's not extra classrooms like if I go around like At first we said what if we put a TK in every school and we did that but now that these TK teachers need to go back and teach kindergarten because that will fill them at 350 or more um we don't have that extra class room in every school so that was an idea too but there's just no room at the end but there but right now transitional K is at four different schools uh prek at Mystic so Mystic and things and thing okay so I mean presumably that's um at least six rooms right well

078the the TK teachers need to go back and teach kindergarten so that those classrooms will go back to kindergarten so there's not an additional room in each of the schools so we'll needed sium with faculty positions not with the model we've shown you if we added the two extra positions through a grant we would get grant funding but not everything here is just um would keep us even with what we have should we wait for the grant funding to come first and instead of like Michael saying that now we're going to have less slots so less kids but you're hoping we get a grant fund funding so we can have more kids to you wait instead of having less kids I mean that could be an option but we're going to miss an opportunity I

079think I would like to get you the actual numbers of how many kids are in that that would we miss the opportunity well that we wouldn't be able to have kids who are in a full day transition kindergarten program how soon would you find out about the gr we Beth by is yeah the head the commissioner of Early Childhood is on leave right now so we've I've gotten this in with Melissa Jenkins so she was GNA try to find more information and I'll give it to I get it so we're really in the early stages of this proposal um we wanted to share with you about the play based learning and how well the expansion of transitional K has been this year um so we just really wanted to put this on radar we'll go

080back and do the heavy lift in terms of crunching the numbers and working with the Grant and come back and give you an update Ian has a question uh thank you um first I just want to thank you all for your efforts sounds like a great program uh in you know the way that it's it's structured um but I do share a number of my of concerns as my colleague Mike has identified um but just a a little clarification with the chair I guess and the superintendent um is there an action item attached to this coming before us tonight no it's just an introduction that's all okay yeah um will there be an action item or will this be an item to be considered as part of the budget coming up yeah I mean I

081would want the board's vote on this if this is something even if we wanted to start small I would want the board to support this if we did that and I'm not going to be proposing this to the public anytime soon I want to make sure we have everything lined up what would it look like next year and in the future especially if we got the grant okay um yeah so that would be for the 25 26 school year um so yeah I would uh just for the sake of efficiency and respect for everyone's time I maybe I think it might be wise for us to maybe just kind of wrap it up uh for tonight and you know look at uh scheduling I'm just saying I'm I'm just speaking as I'm speaking as an

082individual board member speaking as an individual board member speaking as individual board member that's just my preference all right and and anybody hasn't had a chance to ask a question so we'll move on from what you're saying right anybody else I think in moving you know but I I would just want to say that when we do reschedule I think it'd be important to have like all the firm numbers um and and the grant info and have it you know if it's going to be part of the budget discussion then let's you know make sure we have time for that uh ear you know scheduled early with all information thank you agent has a question if it's all right with Ian that you speak yeah um I you know I think TK has been a

083fantastic um program and I appreciate that um I do kind of go back to the um grant funding of that type of thing to continue and you know as we've seen before Grant funding is temporary um where board priorities can make things permanent if they're successful um and one thing that I would personally like to see is earlier earlier identification of students with um learning difficulties um because I believe um at least from some of the reading re um discussions there have been um intervention is going to be um less invasive and less costly from the district if some of those inter interventions are given properly at maybe you know 5 years old rather than 8 years old um those those will cost the district a lot less money the outcomes for students are um

084are um tremendously increased um throughout their education so um so I am you know curious to see how this goes in the future um and I would be interested in in in a real program that that the um that the board Gets behind I can tell you one Factor has been the hegerty um femic awareness program that has been throughout all of our preschools and prek and TKS and all the way through and that has made the teachers love it they've seen such significant difference but to get kids to have that pheic awareness even before they have phonics you know is critical to this work so that's one of the biggest I think real things that we've seen and the play based is really critical so do we identify students um earlier when we have

085these programs that's what I was going to to comment that you know these are um really comprehensive high quality early intervention programs and our goal is you know to provide that intervention early on and give kids the skills that they need to be successful in future years and you know hopefully exit them from having an IEP so that but do we enter them on having an IEP Are we more successful in in um in picking kids out that need an IEP that's the purpose of the screening so when we hold our screenings which we hold several times a year and in the summer we're looking for students who may um need to work with ecap for an individual evaluation we're looking for students who may be peer role models who have some strengths in their

086skills and then we're looking for kids who have that kindergarten Readiness and would need a prek program so we're screening for some different um you know different buckets when we screen and birth to three is an automatic so any child that's received birth to three automatically by the third birthday they have to be in the seat so that's really a wonderful program that I think our famili need to know about right so outside of the screeners though are teachers making referrals uh well we're talking students who are three to five so um many of our referrals come from parents um dayc carees Nursery schools for students who are not currently in our programs we do get referrals from this you know students in the prek program not as many because they've already been screened but

087we do get some and we do get some from the TK program as well no I'm talking about referrals for um for additional Services yeah me too all right but the heg that kind of phic awareness program is for all kids and there's assessments that go with it really helps us to identify if there could be some issues coming along um while they're with us yeah Matthew I have a a question for you is it possible to determine dyslexia with a preliterate population well there are some red flags that we look for in the hegr curriculum um such as kids who have difficulty learning to rhyme um children who have you know weak poor um short-term memory skills with letter identification um sound symbol associations um there are some red flags that we can identify

088through our tier one curriculum um so I wouldn't say we would identify a child that young as having dyslexia but we certainly can monitor them and provide more intensive interventions um at an earlier age thank you Jan has a question it's not a question it's for us like as a board we've talked about having an offsite and I would like to just bring that up again to both of you to see if we can make it happen that we need to look at um from kindergarten to 12th grade what we want our district to look like this is a great model that um we currently have what they're proposing is just as good but we need to decide and be able to provide guidance to say okay we like this centralized um approach because we've

089seen it be successful in another school district um and then say okay so now we've identify kindergarten and then let's say okay from first grade to fifth grade what do we want and then rather than we we get all good ideas from everyone coming in here but for me it's very Just Junk you know it's not um like flowing I want us to be able to give them good guidance so that they're not putting two proposals together for us if we tell them this is what we want um and then they can put something even if it's like hey we're having a hard time with half day kindergarten let's move to full day kindergarten so um those are some of the things that we need to help um and that's just my oh no no

090or not the the preas sorry the preas that's probably how it happened with kindergarten too we said you need it full day yeah yeah so if um if it's not working then um I don't want us to have teacher resources working with seven kids but if we converted that to a full day and we get like 18 kids like how much better would that be that's exactly what I was trying to yeah exactly any other thank you thank you thank you all I hope it stopped raining for your drives [Laughter] home well you're probably gonna end up I'm believe yes we like that thank you thank so much thanks he's still here okay next is um director Finance report and that's attachment to in our packet and I think was Clint gonna put those up

091for you did he have those or do you have one [Music] a can you the participants on the stream pleas thank you thank you 1149 the year funded budget is a total of 68 million that both actual vur and year-to dat incumbrances year-to dat expend actual expend are4 million and we incum 41.6 million you'll you'll see this year over last year that we're encumbering a lot more funds anytime we enter into an agreement or a contract with a vendor we make sure that we're putting encumbrances in we're also making sure that with the respective areas within the school that if they know they're going to be using a service three or four times or even once a month we're encumbering the funds now so that we can get a better look at what our end

092of fiscal year is going to look like so not much has changed as far as uh over last year um I'm sorry as far as our last meeting we're still seeing those areas we discussed before Property Services and purchase services are still we're projecting those to be in the negative um and then the areas to watch or areas of concern again it's electricity we did see that delivery cost increase due to the pandemic recoupment we are starting to see some of the solar credits come in so I have as part of your handout tonight answers to some of your questions regarding that so for just October alone we received a credit of about $111,000 in solar those fundings um we don't get an automatic credit on our eversource bills we get information from Direct Energy

093and then we have to request that be applied to our eversource bills so you're going to see about a month lag on those and then your um utilities dashboard I plan to update that and include information that shows just the credits so it'll be called out separately so those are getting reworked right now that's why you haven't seen for a couple meetings now then also the repair and maintenance um for equipment um again as Sam could probably speak to it's not necessarily that Sam and his team are lagging and doing what they can this specifically goes to the Deferred maintenance because we haven't been able to get some things through the capital Improvement program to fund and without that then we're going to have deferred maintenance not only on vehicles but we're also going to

094see that in our building buildings they're doing the best they can they're doing an amazing job with what they have but that is something to look at because we will continue to see expenditures increase in those areas um in proportion to budget because we haven't been able to get those funds the more we push things out um the more that those costs are going to increase Transportation the rising costs um as we spoke about before we are seeing some um situations with special education out District transportation but we did identify with Denise that there were uh two months of Billings that we were not supposed to receive regarding some Transportation so we'll be receiving some credits from curtain for that so we can see this come down a little bit but not by that much

095in school lunch uh meal balance the outstanding debt sorry as of 1129 is trending towards about $10,000 and um and Sam Ernie and Arnie's team they're reaching out on a weekly basis for the ones that are not paying their bills to see what we can do to help them you know is it simply a form that needs to be completed and we're also addressing it through our Communications team now with the central office so we're trying to get that information out to people that are in need so that we can reduce that balance please keep in mind any um deficit in school lunch at the end of the fiscal year is the responsibility of the district to pick up that's why we have this as an area to watch is if we see it continue

096to Trend up I'll make sure that I update this with Sam um and ear on a monthly basis so that you can get a better gauge of how much we would have to cover within the District budget for unemployment compensation um you can see last year or in Prior years we didn't see that much unemployment compensation going out and we budgeted 35,000 compared to what we were actually expending in Prior years but with the reduction of the positions in the FY 26 budget you're seeing that our expenses related to unemployment for our portion are almost double and that'll go through probably until about um January February because I believe they have six months of unemployment insurance benefits before they either need to find a position or find another way um to fund their lives while

097they're looking for employment will this number increase yes because it you know if the reductions occurred in as of June 30 and we would notify people in July they can apply for unemployment insurance up to six months so you're still going to see this number increase um for the months of December and most likely January we do know that many of the parist and tutors did get jobs Even in our district or got jobs in other districts so we might not you know many of them may have gotten jobs so we have to wait and see but just keep an eye on it uh the computer network Services um I can actually speak that this has actually gone up even more these are services that we have to do for the district so the budget

098was 99378 th000 and year-to-date actual expenditures incumbrances as of 1129 we're 177,000 as of yesterday we're peing at about 299 ,000 and these are services that we have to provide to keep our systems up and running and all the communications that we're doing um if this is something you'd like additional information on I can work with Susan and see if we can bring Clint perhaps to the next finance and Facilities meeting so that he can let you know what happened about $300,000 that was previously covered in Grants Sunset we no longer have those Grant funds but we still have to provide those services um the cost associated with the town operational review that's something that we're still um looking at and we're going to keep track of so that we can provide a monthly update

099to you about conditional expenses we're incurring I believe Susan had a conversation and I don't want to speak to that but we're making sure that we carve out what those expenditures are so that you can actually see what those are so they're not buried within budget line items or either date actual expenditures other business still occurring within the finance office is we're still working on the fy2 24 audit we're getting questions still daily on that um FY 26 budget worksheets we have those back from the school we're still in the process of compiling all the information and we hope to have an update for you next week I believe on the 16th um and as well as policy updates that we're working on um a few that you'll hear tonight and then the actual numbers

100if anybody has questions on these um there were some outstanding questions from the October 28th meeting and then just last week's finance and Facilities meeting so that's in your handout uh one of the big ones was in regards to account 105 for administration line five what was creating that deficit is an issue with an encumbrance and um with that particular line item that as of just this past pay cycle as of 1129 um $98,000 of that pertains to raise interm salary so he came in he was originally um hired on for two days a week but he was needed five days a week so that's what Drive was driving that number and then he's still assisting with 8,000 for R salary yes when the race start ail I think something like April right but this

101is just from July 1st till now oh okay this is not going back to those prior months that's just for now um he has agreed to stay on to assist with the town operational review so that we could stay focused on the audit work as well as the budget work so he's working um two to three days a a week just on the town operational review items and like I said we're keeping track of those expenses separately but only charging us when he has the work to do right exactly he doesn't charge us if he doesn't have any work yeah so if they've given him a list of things he's got to go and you know provide then he it does require his time so that's sorry I am I am confused this is from

102July 1 till now yes that's five months $20,000 a month it was higher in the months before I was hired um and then we tailored it down to 1 day a week and only then it was a half day so this is predominantly from July probably through mid October if that I think we need to check with Lori too he gets back that is actually Ray was in the office today and confirmed that that is a salary $20,000 a month yeah um so there was um open positions correct for about two months each for the assistant superintendent and the finance director um so um that's I was just doing rough math and it seems like it maybe is around $60,000 um is that reflected in here yes savings from those open positions that's already still

103behind 150 more yes because there's also another position that we're still reviewing um to make sure that it's the position that Susan and I think it is but the person we need to confirm that with is unfort out of the office until Wednesday what do you mean POS I don't there's another position involed this 149 that I just need to confirm with the department head but they're not here to confirm that with right now all right so so we may or may not have budgeted for that third position the additional position is not budgeted that's why you're seeing the excess all right so there is another position that's largely contributing to that right so that was um in the response it was that there's you know a remaining balance it's under review it is another

104position and it's not it's not within the business office when will we find out what that position is as soon as we get the person back and we can review it with them well we know the position and we you're for the person no I get it we're not sure what the position is no one of the things that has happened I think you might be sure what the position is the e finance software when I try to to run the various extracts to see where things are getting built against accounts you have to go back to paper based information unless they were built into the budget last year so if it's something brand new that wasn't added before there's not a clean way to research it out of our existing software that's why we

105need munus yes it would have been much easier I could have had it within 10 minutes and I spent about 3 hours today looking through various reports and there's no easy extract to find out that particular position build to this account number so if I'm sorry if if we have a cost account right and like we're swiping our card or we're like saying so like if like like I'm charging Department whatever 210 we don't have that no and I actually provided a sample to show you um but this is actually the general rer looks like it just tells me in that account that a PGE oh that's that piece of paper that I was y yep so it's digging into that payroll charge is actually physically digging into that that specific payroll not cumulative to

106see the distribution that was done to that specific account yeah and so our operational review let's put something in place to like fix that because not knowing what we're paying exactly yeah that's something that um that's why you know that's why I did recommend and put the the Apple Improvement request forward to uh John Bert is for munis because that is something I could have printed a report and had it to you in 15 minutes yeah instead a of people around the table are seeing the light more now that you know it's so much easier if you want a vacancy report right I can run that in less than 5 minutes if you want to see all positions FTE where they're coded it's an Excel data dump maximum 15 minutes and most of it's for

107the report to run well even Irene's work and all of you many of you said this last budget season trying to look at just central office and how many you know under my department under HR which is shared there's other things that are kind of miscellaneous so we're really trying to um Irene's doing a great job trying to really heel out heel the onion and really get central office where it should be with all the positions and all the you know expenses under each department so that it's much easier I think even with um Sam's last year there were extra things underneath his Department that were really weren't related to Sam at all so we have to it's just the way things were always done here can I ask you to say question a different

108way I am understanding I hope incorrectly that just for that raise salary or the expense that that that's incurred for the work that he is doing uh is all targeted towards the town operation review from last week forward from dece December 2nd forward it's going to be buil that's what he's working on and before that period he was doing what you're doing now that was the interm fin the interm and then um about mid October we cut back to just half a day on Fridays for any additional you're probably talking 85 to 990,000 of it being the interim position and only small part being for the town the that 98 is pretty much that was everything through 11 29 so that was when he was serving as interm Finance director here from December 2nd forward

109that's the town operational review and I think some of the audit was in there too there was some additional things that he was able to help out with you know um in the transition and um so we'll we'll get more information on that exactly J Jay then I and mik so is he being paid by the hour by the day by the hour contract by the hour he's a he's a hired employee with the Board of Education okay and this is the actual expense from July first to present this is not encumbered right there's nothing encumbered right now for Ray and this other [Music] position um what is it we have to find that's what we're digging into the detail to find I spent three hours today so the challenge with the payroll documents as

110of today with our current e finance system that's getting upgraded so it could change next month and I would be thankful for it um you cannot export anything out of payroll into an Excel document everything is PDF period that's just the equipment that we have the software we have today we're getting the upgrade done by the end of January and I'm so hopeful that we'll be able to export things out to excel because then I'd be able to find it for you right now it's looking through every staff member's name it's a page for every single staff member and where they're all coded to try and find it it's not through a searchable PDF it's very difficult so I was able to find Ry because Ry was assing me finding Ry um but the other

111position I just need to verify and no he didn't charge the board for that either we did it long time who knows who is it that you need to ask who we're waiting for us who's on vacation the HR department they can help us probably through their own files so when these payroll entries go through there's no employee code attached to there's an employee number okay each person has their own specific employee number but it's not as uh like similar in the private sector you would have a grouping of employee numbers for each area we don't have that as soon as you're hired you get the very next code um I just I want to ask what I actually came to ask about um before this came up was um your your use of the

112encumbrances you know just looking at the at your highlight page without going into the rist yet um so we've got year-to date expenses the we know these of them the encumbrances represent something that there's either been a purchase order or um or a contract oh thank you uh purchase order or a contract um with regard to purchase services and Property Services um these are all the the purchase orders are in through the end of the year um but are we are we concerned that this I mean we're already in a deficit I mean are we still are there still Services we haven't even put out yet that I can defer to Sam I can just look at numers so if there's additional Property Services such as repair and maintenance and that could definitely occur where

113we don't have a purchase order well like last year when we had all of those floods and things that kind of came up we don't have like a a fund for emergencies right we don't have a contingency like the town does that is something I'm proposing for FY 26 but um for example we we have budgeted for all the hbac testing yes yes has that been have purchase orders been cut and and funds encumbered yes so the standard ones like the fire testing and the HVAC testing all of those we've encumbered okay these are the the unknowns that we wouldn't have encumbered because if it's a repairer you didn't know you needed to make that repair so that is still some areas that you would see a purp order issued okay fortunately we have staff

114maintenance staff and custodial staff that does the work in almost all the cases but you know if we need to rebuild wall because of a flood or something we have to then reach out to Insurance not that I'm pre giving any premonitions on that right well without getting into you know detail on every single line for example for transportation you've encumbered 6.7 million does that mean that all of the established routs that we have are are encumbered through the end of the year we encumbered the contract okay because we made that commitment all right and so that this available is for those Sports special ed that sort of thing that we maybe don't know about yet right it could it could shift in between line items too okay all right I'm just trying to understand

115because in the past um we we've had business managers that really didn't use the encumbrance tool the way right she's doing it very care so I'm just trying to understand how you're how you're all right I I think that's enough for me for the moment yes without using the tool create surprises towards the fourth quarter that no one wants to see so we're trying to be proactive more um diligent I can't even think of the word diligent is good word I would say you have actually helped the every department head to be even more diligent so I applaud you for that Irene thank you um so I just want to revisit the the um mystery position here real quick um it it's I just want to clarify it's not a mystery it's just the person

116I need to ask is out on vacation okay so when she's back Wednesday I can ask her the question it's a mystery in the e finance software right so I mean I definitely highlights the need for for uh correcting the software situation but um and I understand that the attraction of munice but to my recollection we still haven't yet discussed or voted on on what we're going to do with that um as a board I know that there's been some a lot of talk a lot of research uh but I would like to make that official you know have like a presentation of all the options that are out there and you know at some point in the near future that's a good idea like make that a referral item for the future based out

117of this conversation um although I do believe that munus does have the inside track uh but I think just for due diligence sake um I'm just it's just astounding to me that and now I have concerns that if there's if we don't have that track that accountability throughout our departments I mean are there other positions that may be running over do we have other overages or other costs that you know there there are some others that we need to be able to dig into the detail for but again and I'm hoping with the upgrade that we'll be able to start being able to export things out to excel so I can get a clearer answer right now it's just not feasible definitely welcome that um and I just to clear up some confusion in the

118leop left corner of this uh paper it says pentamation Enterprises um what is I mean is that just the software yeah okay that's and uh so if I'm looking at this correctly the expenditures that we're not sure what the position was or is uh What's the total spent on that right now for that particular one um we're up to about the the difference between gray and the meing position so you're about $50,000 s oh this is the sample okay where is the um the savings on the other two positions then it's already built into that line so the savings is already being overexpanded too so no savings on top of the deficit they're all in that particular line item yeah but I'm saying if the savings was will say $60,000 um that's already the encumbrance

119is changed for that savings somewhere else yes the encumbrance is the encumbrance is just for the positions that are filled and then the encumbrance goes into that if it's vacant then there's not an incumbrance for that sorry all right um matth You have a question yeah I'll I'll just um I got to recollect my thoughts so I'll pass on for now go ahead go ahead um so for the operational review um so Ry if I understand right as of last week December 2nd that if he's working for the schools that's what he's working on right exactly for last week do you have a kind of estimate how many hours how many days he worked last week he worked two days two full days so about 14 hours the average is between 14 and 16 this

120week he's working three days okay who else last week or or this week too was working on the operational review dedicating hours no okay there's no additional support staff available okay and then and then you mentioned before I guess before December he was still in his interim duties and and at I guess maybe through November he was working half days on Fridays just one half day on Friday one half day on Friday um before in November for instance was he working on the town operational review no so so who was working on it then no one but that was the memo that we sent to jmb that was distributed to you that there's no resources to support this additional work we had met with the organization Joe and um we prioritized we got them started

121on looking at policies and and um he has a whole laundry list of things and he's kind of it sounds like he's doing one thing at a time asking us for details so we got him started and we met with him and now he's got a list of some other things to do so he being the auditor yeah yeah well I don't know if you C aitor he's the town consultant for the operation okay and and so so okay so before you met with him before uh December but no no work in filling his information request started until last week no all right and then so uh it was quite a long request do you have a sense of um I mean some of it was existing information from that would have been prepared from

122previous year audits but um how far along in the requests are are we talking is it almost filled half filled no scratching the surface scratching the service okay the level of detail underneath every sing of those oneline item requests could generate um Ray was uploading 20,000 page reports so we would be hopeful that the prior audits would help support the work but what we understand is that he's looking for us to to provide that that the town is not providing that okay so just speaking for myself uh I'd like to see more of a balance between I mean so so Ray's an employee but I'd like to see some of our other um Town staff sort sharing the load there so that um because uh you know any any of raise time now is by

123definition unbudgeted and um but uh our our staff are here and I I know I know there's a lot of workload I know that but that's something we have budgeted in so that that's just speaking for myself well we're still doing the budget currently the audit currently and like last year we've been asked sometimes two three times for the same information so we go back and we re you know give them more the information that we've already given right and so it's really been extended and then you know you know we think we're done and then they come back with more items so it's very similar to last year that you know if there's an extension it's because of things that they're asking that you know either again or in addition to so we have

124to take care of the audit and the budget is kind of our first priority at this point and um you know we we explain that to this you know consultant that that's our priority and we were getting extra help to help give him and he's been pretty good about giving us one thing at a time so I don't feel like we're lagging but to Mike's Point if we only have Ray that's going to cost us a lot of money that we don't have in the budget so you're going to have to look for somebody in our office back well we had figure it out right now right now that's going to cost us a lot of money 10 to 12K a month right now we're laughing a staff accountant what you say 10 to 12

12510 to 12K a month yeah 10 to 12K a month so as of right now I'm serving five positions in the business office I'm the staff account the budget analyst the procurement person and the director of purchasing while being Director of Finance while trying to do an FY 24 audit making sure everybody's following the laws and the regulations and policies is the board working on policy and trying to work on a budget and doing a system upgrade for finance it's a lot there's nobody else in the office that can do this work that's why I've been asking for position since I got here and I think some communication with the yeah did we was um and that's something we can forward to the Town Council that raise coron as 10 to what you say mik

12610 to 12 at least 10 to 12 if it's 20 cuz Matt 20K a month if it's at full um well that wasn't at full he was always part he's never been full-time right well he did do the five days was fulltime for several weeks yeah I'm still he hasn't been fulltime since I got here I'm still confused we had Matthew apologize Jed to say something I'm sorry matth I um I totally understand where you're coming from I feel for you um you probably don't have the right mix of people to support you so I totally agree with that Ray we know as a consultant Consultants come in at a higher rate so we know that too um so if we're over 15,000 and let's say we are supposed to be favorable 60 that really

127means we're over 200,000 um so and let's say raise 98 or half of that we have this position that we're not disclosing right now because somebody's like missing on what you know they're not coming back on one day we know what type of position that is I just want to understand and if you don't have it this time for the next time we meet is is um what is that HR position or maybe we're just asking HR and it's not really an HR position was it existing and an ex exting position or was it unfunded um and we just need to understand because that's like 100 Grand that we could have a teacher or a couple Tutors or whatever it may be I'll follow up I'll let her know and see if she'll provide an

128email with that information yeah so I can provide it to the board yeah no I like I totally feel free I understand where you're you know coming from so you have our support um but um yeah let's see if we can transition um maybe some of the clerical type of stuff and get away from a higher costing individual so um Ray may come in and do the Strategic type of stuff in support of you but we get like a clerical person to um do the submissions do the photocopy do whatever it may be so that we transition from x amount of hours to more of like um so that we can um have our funds go at a um you know stretch it out a little bit any are you finished continue you okay thank

129you um there was a question about line number eight which is account 108 what exactly is the dean coordinator so that's the athletic director for Fitch and gron middle middle school there was a question about um lines 2930 and 31 about clerical support how it's broken out into three different sections for special education the uh account 133 is called high school completion that's clerical support for that and then 134 is a combination of the superintendent office and support services there are three positions the temporary registration part-time human res service sorry parttime human resources and a Boe clerk so that's Jones position our book there so that's the kind of thing we need to really clarify that when it's all under one bucket it's really harder to and especially with this system to find out who

130what it is actually so we're trying to really split that out so central office we have each department with who reports in that department and all the staff within the department instead of spread out in these buckets right it's like a jigsaw puzzle so Al line 55 uh 2011 that pertains to health insurance and Adrian your question is in here about the concern um from last year so the FY 25 budget is now 10.5 or 10 about 10.1 rounded million um as compared to FY 24's budget was only 6.8 million so our average quarterly budget is about 2.5 so we're about ,000 over estimated on a quarterly basis so about maybe $112,000 by the end of the fiscal year not like last year yeah so the guess was the educated guess of was correct good

131job yes the plus is the budget was increased uh there was a question about the student intern on line 76 account 325 that one is providing the instructional services from the University working in the classroom as substitutes as well as student teaching so that's what that pertains to that was unbudgeted um and we're estimating a total of 27,000 for the fiscal year we've expended about 19 so far um there is an open question for you Mike that is the line9 for um the telephone cost which driving an increase and Clint is working with breez line to um determine what that driving cost is and why so we are still waiting on an answer and I know he's going to follow up with the vendor again and then last but not least um was the electricity

132are we receiving our solar credits yes we are for um but it hasn't hit your accounts yet in line 174 because we have to request the credit that Direct Energy is provided from ever source so as of um line 174 account 631 there aren't any credits posted to this $1 million yet or I'm sorry the 578 no I'm sorry I'm messing it up again so it's $1 million for the total expense um and we're going to see credits hopefully within the next month to two months but we need to ask for them on a monthly basis so they will get applied directly against the expense because it's not Revenue in addition to it's credit so so that's why it's being booked there against the expense and the total credits for October just for the month

133of October were $1,333 B may I ask a question the amount that we're receiving in credits does that match or exceed or come in lower than we had projected I can find out I don't know what the original projections were but I can look into that thank you um just to Circle back on the recruitment uh for the uh the pandemic recruitment fees in the electricity bill do we have an actual number on that like the percentage that were being assessed and like what we're actually paying on top of the regular that's what I'm working on for the update to the electric D or the utilities dashboard to start breaking out into all that additional information so you can see what changed great um you know one of the things budget first one of the

134things I'm looking to talk to our delegation about is is finding um relief from the recruitment fees uh for Boards of Education not just here but across the whole state um so having the actual numbers so we can put a monetary value on it and equate it to what it would cost what that's costing us in staff and student support um I think would be a great uh arguing uh point okay um and do we have an actual total on what we're tracking the numbers now on what's being spent to provide the items for operational review um do we have the actual figure on that was that just the 20ish or I I'm not sure if I heard the number specifically that's why I'm asking like what have we spent so far so raid just

135started working on operational View December 2nd so he spent about 15 hours at about $160 per hour um last week and then this week he plans to spend I believe about 21 hours on operational review so he did five he did 15 and now he's scheduled do 21 okay and then there was additional equipment that was needed um so that he could work on it was dual laptop or dual screens and a docking station and that total was about $500 for that additional that was it um so in your opinion and and um expertise do you think it it would be like a like a temporary clerical staff H would be in order to help support what has been mentioned here as far as like trying to like take some of the more like grunt

136work for a lack of a better term away from Rey and like have Ray be strategic and organizing but have someone doing the scans doing the uploads doing all that stuff if I have higher attempts in the past and I found is it takes about two to three weeks to train just so they can gather the information and try to find where the information's at we are running into situations where we're recreating not recreating but we're creating new information um that as that's been requested found out that was requested that was not previously requested so we're creating new documentation and um again the request was for all new hires since July 31st 22 till current which again our current system doesn't allow us just to see new hirers and provide that as a report as

137well as all terminations so it's not something that we can easily run out of the system okay so we'd have to have a confidential temporary employee then we train them on the system to try and generate that level of detailed report for um the review so right now it's yes we'll need temporary help R soon but he's not doing any grunt work right now he's actually just he knows where the information is that we provided to the CLA our audit firms in the past and he's uploading that information it's it's not creating any new information yeah he's not scanning documents or anything like that or making you do anticipate that coming yes all right and we were talking about getting clerical support for that we didn't want him wasting his time on that in that

138case I would definitely recommend commend that you know we consider that as a board a request to submit to the Town Council to fund a position such as that um excuse me and um see and just just to confirm like once once all the details about the um the position that's not been identified um that will be shared with us as a board yes thank you that's why I have it as a followup in your in your questions thank so I'll just keep track of all your questions and then try to provide them on a monthly basis so that you know as they come available it's not just sending an email out just having it in a clear concise report so that we have it available to that end will this document be included in

139the minutes for this meeting yes I provided them to Joyce okay and typically what I've been doing is as you ask for information I start incorporating it into the notes great future so that example was the what is in the other line items I presented that and then also I Incorporated it in the notes so that you didn't have to go looking through prior documents to try and find that information appreciate it thank you J has a question um the audit was mentioned and and again I I realize you are working with the current budget you are budgeting for next year you're doing the audit and so I realize it's a lot to have on your plate all at the same time um but how would you characterize the progress of the audit at this

140point now that we're in December um do we know how close we are to fin it's I believe it's just a few tying up some questions that are lingering okay um when we had a meeting last week y um we basically stated that we were on the right path and we weren't going to file need to file an extension this year excellent now that that's good to hear unless they come up with other things that they didn't ask for this is true not come with right well and and and just to to get back to that for a moment so um it's been said you know that they're asking for the same information over and over but if I understand correctly part of what an auditor does it's test records and so maybe that's part

141of their process to make sure they're getting the same answer twice so I just don't want to make it sound as though we're um questioning their methods I mean they obviously have standards they have to go by to make sure that the audit is is complete um the other question um uh you know at um so Ray has done everything that that that he can do to be helpful with the Auditors have they been in physically and done the records testing here in the office about the audit the Auditors the Auditors yes the Auditors were here the annual Auditors um about two or three weeks ago finishing up their testing okay um if there were items that they still needed for testing I've been uploading those to them as well okay and we've been having

142weekly updates with the town as well as you know the district is anybody involved in the audit we're in the weekly updates okay we were warned it would be very difficult to get back on schedule with the audit so it's good to hear that we've made this this kind of progress that it sounds like may be within Striking Distance so thank you very much for your work on that and also to Ray for his assistance early on with that any other questions or comments um just a quick one are so do we have open positions in the finance office right now um there's one open position that we're going to be recruiting for I'm read right now currently in the business office everybody has the same job title it's accounting assistant and then it changes

143when you roll I'm working with Lori to update the job descriptions they were last updated in 2008 so it's making sure that we have a grant accountant that we have the you know payroll specialist that we have a budget analyst that we start looking for pro you know at least write the job description not to hire yet but a procurement specialist that could be part of the budget analyst's role um but I'm working with Lori on that to make sure that we're getting job descriptions that meet what the expectation is so that when we're recruiting we're getting a better response to our recruitment efforts and more expertise in those designed areas and then the cross training that she's already started in Ray had started but she's continued so that more than just one person in

144right who's sitting in that seat in business can do some of that work so that's something we've known about for several years well thank you for your your work any you fin I'm these are the policies that's all um thank you I me thank you yeah really good work it's she's doing a great job it's hard work appreciate yeah yeah even though we ask these questions no it's okay that's that's what you're here for unfortunate at the next good evening good evening thank you madam chair um for full disclosure I just have to report that I did move over to this chair I was over there in the corner which is a place that I spent many hours as a youth um and um and so was bringing back memory so I came over here

145so that I could see the board and and the presenters um it's the truth um and the presentation uh which was nice uh also to share the mic with Dr aaman and um and and to be closer to the candy dish um and not NE and not necessarily in that order I I've got five items that I'll report on tonight uh that I shared with the finance committee the other night so um the state required HVAC testing that we will be doing at both uh Northeast Academy and and Katherine colasi we will be doing over the winter break so fuss and O'Neal was the winner of the bid for that project uh and they needed the assistance of our um computerized uh building uh automated building system uh uh company in order to uh to

146do the project so those two companies fuss and O'Neal and abs or automated Building Systems will be here to uh work on those projects uh at colasi and Northeast Academy during the winter break Sam can you give us some numbers for that meaning how much this is costing us uh it was in 45 it was 45 or $47,000 to be both schools and what did we put in our budget for we put 180 in because at the time the state was saying that we had to do the entire District um but since then the state has allowed us to do uh 20% or one of the of the building so this year we're going to do those two buildings which have had the uh probably the uh more frequent uh concerns about humidity in the

147building so we're going to do those two first and of course you know that we also put into the CIP for replacement of the units on those two buildings as well because uh those two buildings were built with HVAC units that do not dry out the air it just recycles the air so that was part of the problem with the humidity and since then we've been doing active dehumidification which is essentially running the boilers to dry out the air that's coming back in as as it's recycling which is uh not uh not inexpensive to say the least you have a cuse for that too I do not I mean we can get one but uh can you get one first yeah how can you get it sooner than later uh it'll probably be later than

148sooner it's but we'll work on that okay I'll do it as quickly as I can um it's it's um it it it's it's a number that doesn't it it kind of floats around so it isn't uh really a hard number uh to figure out so it's based on temperature sunny days versus cool um cloudy days all kinds of different things that may have occurred over the years um maybe in the summertime too when the when the humidity is even worse but I I think cor me if I'm wrong I think Bev is looking for the cost do we have upto-date numbers on the cost of the the CIP are the numbers we've given to the town oh is that the question yeah those were in the those were in the millions of dollars so but

149they are current because I mean we put these CN for many years and I don't know how often we review them yes uh I had to pay a u a professional give us a professional cost estimate on those and they were four plus million dollars at one school and just about four million in the other that's current Nea is a little has uh between four and eight classrooms less then they could do four to eight more classrooms there um so it's a little bit smaller than kashki that's yeah that's not no eight million well it was close to 8 million with the two schools yes because when we meet with the state delegation we we want to tell them talk to them about this too yeah absolutely uh the the other item one of the

150the other items that we're working on presently is that the state has now uh started the audit on the Gren Middle School building project um so we are gathering information here within our own uh confines as well as working with both Public Works which did the project uh and arcadis which was the uh administrator of the project so uh all three of us are putting numbers together and getting that to uh the state for their audit uh once they get all of that information uh they will be coming down for an on-site review of the paperwork that is at the public or at the Annex Building with public works that's a shared service they're sharing that responsibility the town and the district they're just now auditing GMS yes okay no comment I don't know what

151the time frame is well let's freshen everyone's mind maybe they'll find some money for to add a few more classrooms I don't know if everybody's back to the office yet so maybe that had something to do with it um the third item is um the EV charging stations at the rotten Middle School fed River and Mystic River schools um we looked at it we talked about it at the finance committee uh uh last week uh um and looking at the potential cost the estimates for upgrading those so that we can uh charge people who are actually charge those who are charging their vehicles there um it it would be the estimate is about $66,000 per building so that's going to have to go out the bid so we're going to have to put that together

152as a bid package and go out so that we can uh move forward with that now is the town doing the same thing I think we worked with the same group well the town has already started with a company I don't yeah I don't know how they did it um I've got a call into Bob sheret who's the head of Public Works here at least not not the very head but the person that I would talk to at Public Works about uh their bid package and if indeed they did go out to bid on it it's a company that they use uh have used previously so I don't know what the idea was but I got a call in him I'm just waiting to sit down with him and go over whatever that bid package

153was uh that we may be able to use to help put it together um the um the Edo 49 uh which is the uh form that goes to the state uh osgr which is the office of school Construction Grants review um that um form is uh ready to go to the state so it's in the process of going to osgr at this building Sign Sealed but not delivered that is for the Barner roof okay yes the last item that I had to report on is the uh we we're we're looking at um the possibility of uh getting some small um uh electric buses uh or maybe uh something like uh 16 passenger vans uh for events or to move uh people around the district and so uh Shannon Weagle is confirming with grisal I asked

154her today she doesn't have an update on that since our last Finance facilities committee meeting but uh rwal has already started a project um and so we want to talk to them see how it went and what they had to do to get it so we're waiting on Shannon to uh to get some information from them oh aan go ahead oh I was just gonna um ask about the Chargers um do we have any answer on if we can shut them off at night or maybe put up some signage to say that you know teacher parking or anything like that staff parking I should say yeah I could probably shut the I could probably turn the circuit breakers off each night if that's what we decid if that's what your pleasure was I think we

155could do that with the labor maybe the additional labor just doing that twice a day outweigh the cost of leaving them on overnight yeah I guess it probably yeah sure I'm sure it would is it a big task to do to turn the circuit breakers off no I just have to we we would have to train somebody um you're right we probably would need a sign too because people could get frustrated if they felt like or they could show up early in the morning and leave their car there for the day I'm just wondering if we should put a staff parking only sign that way at least some kind of thing that we can go back on to say to somebody you know if we see someone's car there five days in a row are

156you staff maybe there's a way to you know where the the building Administration can deal with that to save some spots for staff so are you saying that it's okay for staff members to charge their vehicles on our electricity without paying for it then well during the day that's what that was the intent correct I don't know what the intent was it was part of the project but I I don't know what the intent was it was required by the state for the new building right it was just do we know what it's costing us I mean to that out we don't have a hard number is it significant there's no meter on that there's no meter meter or we could put it on can we just turn it off completely deta yeah yeah so

157we we could we could put a sign out there for instance that said that as of January 1 these these meters will be turned off at uh 4 p 4 pm daily and restored at 7 a. or something if you wanted to do that or then we want want to say staff parking because I can see people pulling in and using those spots we really need the spots well more of the more of the principle of the spots for us you know so because there isn't enough spots that's right like Middle School Park parking is a premum at a premium at all three of those schools that's true and then you would turn them off completely on the weekend that's probably no good idea we could add it to agenda and get a board vote

158and see how we want to proceed with that okay yeah okay appreciate that b was I was going to make that recommendation um the uh I I definitely would like to hear the uh I'm looking forward to hearing the bid reports the bids coming in from the town manager as far or the um you're saying you're reaching out to get like who they were talking to about installing that that equipment to charge for yes all right yeah public works all right so is that something that that you'll come back to the board and share the information with so we take a look at it and get a sense of like what that looks like thank you um I'm not sure I was out of the room for a minute um but did you discuss at

159all the auditorium situation I did know um last I knew uh the way things were that the um CIP was approved um for the 141 to redo the the uh the auditorium sound system yeah sound system yeah was it just a sound system or I thought it was like the lights and everything and and seats but that maybe of a Clint question there may have been some lighting on the stage included in that yeah audience thank you yeah sure Dr Kennedy to the Rescue all right so the project I heard the first question I heard was what was it for it was for lights sound projection and seating as needed I know there's been some work done for handicap seating and so forth in the front already great that's good to hear um so as

160of right now is the CIP the the funding that came from the town being used to to pay for that it is and we have a RFP that has just been blessed to be sent out I'm hoping this week all right and um so the neighborhood Grant was not a successful so we it was decided in in October which is why we've been delayed and I haven't put this out because we wanted to see that through and we were not funded uh with through the neighborhood Grant so that's why we're proceeding with uh using the CIP funds but again using the appropriate Town requirements for an RFP to be put out and so forth excellent appreciate it and as far as the timeline goes yep uh when do you anticipate uh breaking ground so to

161speak breaking ground I'd like by February 1 we've kind of sketched out a time frame to have minimal impact on students and activities and so forth we are in the midst of a bunch of stuff that Auditorium gets used day and night through December we get a bit of a reprieve in January especially through um exams and so forth which is typically third fourth week of January and then a little bit more because as the semester starts we're not having many performances per se at the beginning of the second semester but we also know that very quickly things will ramp up come March April and then it it gets used again every day through beginning of June so we're trying to hit that sweet spot because as has been mentioned by you and others around

162this table we do not want to impact programming experiences and so forth and certainly safety concerns if we have construction going on in there and so forth but I I believe we were able to mitigate that and I will have as light of footprint as possible as far as shutting that area down um and we've thought through as best we can what makes the most sense so we're being having a minimal impact all right appreciate it um sure definitely I I know I mentioned in the past that about you know um some frustration with it happening in the middle of school year but sure upon further reflection thinking about like you know I I think if if there is a window that you've identified where you can minimize the impact on the current student population

163and the use of that space then I say I'm all for it sooner it gets done the better um it's way overdue yeah it be great to see that in operation uh for the graduation coming up yeah summer the biggest impact just as an FYI my concern and that's why we're going to be bidding this out making sure that we have it certified and so forth is the additional features that we want to put on some of those hanging poles above the stage those obviously have to be certified and you know extra secure this is not my air of expertise but I'm trying to work with the experts to make sure we do that that's my one concern not that we can't get it done but that has to be that has to be right

164full stop understood cool all right um yeah so that that's great to hear uh so that means you know as we move forward to the Town Council this year you know and talking about cips uh this one has been already activated and is in play is being used as identified it's good to know than yes sir all right appreciate it is the RFP for the whole project or just for the lighting it it's for the we're taking on this particular RFP will deal with Lighting and Sound those are the most urgent needs um projection we were able to do some in-kind work over the summer so we have a working system actually two a pit based one and a hanging one it's not what I want we're repurposing projectors and so forth so I want

165to the lights are the most important one to do first and then if I have to make some compromises you know lens kits things like that and projection I'll do that afterwards and you have had an interim um support for the sound because people have said that the kids sound so much better I know there's a lot of events this week we've yeah I'm sorry to interrupt we have been able to make some incremental changes through some of the peg Pisha dollars both the 2023 and the 2024 Peg PESA just as an FYI are dollars that we can apply for and receive it's typically funded after those extra charges you'll see on your phone bill or your cable bill or what have you that we apply for these are small numbers but they've been helping

166us do additional wireless mics and receivers things like that because we were aware of some of those issues and we're trying to make it better the additional CIP funding will help build out more of the infrastructure so that we can do 12 16 18 especially for some of those larger shows where we want to wirelessly mic up students or a chorus or what have you it's a Broadway quality stage we're trying to get as close to possible as Broadway Quality Lighting and Sound no promises but that's the goal so it's the goal as long as you get rid of the blinker yeah the one that blinks all the time yeah yeah keep that in mind we'll do our best but please let me know so just for clarification uh the lighting you're talking about is

167the stage or the show lighting as opposed to the field lighting above that was all done with the LED lighting project that we completed uh months ago at this point Thank you anything else oh Michael yeah just quick statement on the the Chargers uh since the I'm glad that we'll talk about it in a later meeting but since the the town's moving forward I want to say that um the state has designated ALR and as an environmental justice Community uh as has um Environmental Protection as you can see at the federal level uh part of that because the state has done that is that uh people in the town who who live here if they want to buy a electric vehicle or a hybrid plug in electric there's an additional credit for that and the

168idea there is so that and it's the same thing for T like schools Vehicles Town Vehicles fleet vehicles they can do the same thing because as an environmental justice community we are disproportionately impacted by environmental pollution problems including air pollution and so by getting anything that helps um get more electric vehicles uh in service in our town the argument is helps with the quality of life here uh so our our electric uh charging infrastructure is Wolly inadequate and having at the schools and a couple plac of town helps a little but isn't what's needed but I do view it as a step backwards if we're turning off the Chargers um uh at certain times or or charging from them or for them um so and I and I would insulting to to If I Were

169a staff member to all of a sudden have to you know essentially pay the charge my car at um a school where um they're probably not thinking they're making the big box right so I think that'd be a morale issue that uh by having it free for anyone who wants to charge and works there for sure um would be well worth it dollarwise for us so that's my statement paper gas you have for gas right yeah can't be a trite though you're not allowed to moving right on you all done Sam thank you yes thank you thank you Sam um next is policy policy what mat's right here so policy is going to need I think on December 18th and we have some policies on the agenda curriculum the curriculum meet no okay um finance

170and Facilities thank you madam chair well we met last week last Tuesday to be precise at six o'clock In This Very Room and we discussed or was presented all the information that you heard tonight was was presented to us then except for the auditorium information that was not brought out but everything you heard everything you heard the finance director facili director talk about tonight that's what we discussed at that uh at that meeting okay thank you the ad hat budget procedure oh yeah we're currently on Hiatus okay um I don't know but the an ihack committee is only for a certain length of time so in a month's time I'm going to disband to that committee and if we need it we'll go back with but it's not a standing committee ad hop is you

171had a mission did you accomplish your mission you can answer that question um yeah we did to some extent but there was still some work to be done and that's why to be done it was on the uh the software question so if in fact the board takes up the software question and votes on it and takes some action and does the research and due diligence and all that then that would probably close out our work okay well the board can take up the so Qui question all right um learn meets this week but nothing to report for learn I go th St to learn um athletic fields who's on oh that's me uh athletic fields did not meet in the time since last meeting Trails is Matthew and he said in library actually Matthew

172said Trails um it really doesn't have much to to do with the school system I mean you could talk to Matthew about it but he said it doesn't have much to do with the schools and okay why be on it okay okay um the next is the consent agenda um we have approval of the Cal meeting minutes of November 18th and the regular meeting on November 25th we texting four and five did everybody have a chance to look at those minutes they have a motion to approve the consent agenda so mov okay a second second second Jen any questions discussion comments but I do have a question for maybe somebody else remembers this but um on the um November 18th on uh special education discussion on four um said that staffing has gone up 1%

173from last year for special ed does anyone else remember that I thought it was the number of students that went up I didn't rewatch the [Music] meeting that was November 18 I don't remember you were thinking it was Staffing that's easy to find now that we have everything recorded I'll find out well she it's it's written as Staffing but I don't remember talking about increase in Staffing so you think it was students I have a feeling it was students okay I would look into that any other comments okay all those in favor of approving the consent agenda say I oppose exensions okay so before we get to the old business I'm going to say good night Sam so you can go home and have dinner and and Marie has long travel and she's back here

174with me early in the morning so Irene's going to stay for some policy Andy to get them home again jiggity jig she feels about me thank you we used keep it to the end and then skip over here that's right the good old day all right so the first policy question and possible action regarding a second reading of policy 3110 budget planning and do I have a motion I so moved and do I have a second second okay so that policy let me find the poliy is not here go ahead I'm trying to find it all right so budget planning policy go ahead Irene you want to explain this policy sure it's the new language from C and then in many of the policies instead of saying Board of educationeducation we shortened it to board

175or the board so you're going to see it in the very first um sentence green anywhere there after the old lang education we're just stking out education and then same thing with super superintendent superintendent in superintendent schol soen is new and anything black is the old the old stuff all right any discussion about policy p3110 J so um just for those that might be following along at home I this may be redundant but so this is our second reading but I just want everyone to understand that a lot of these started in that ad hoc budget procedure committee that was before mentioned um with Ian and um Ken and Mike uh Whitney um and then through policy and then we already went through a reading here so if it looks like we're kind of moving

176through some of these quickly um this has gone through two committees and and uh a first reading and our attorney and it's been through the attorney so a lot of work has gone beyond these and and thanks to everybody that has uh had a part in creating these policies and their amendments than sh the same could I just add off of one thing I'm sorry I had to leave the room for a minute um on the second black paragraph second paragraph with the black type if took out the words steps shall be taken and inserted after administrative staff shall be involved in the budgets we don't want to have reports on steps we want to have the results then the staff is going to be involved in the budget so say so so I'll read

177the sentence as it would be blah blah blah the of the financial needs of the school system comma certified and non-certified staff and the administrative staff shall be involved in the budget process which is what we do anyway okay if that's a friendly amendment that people are comfortable with otherwise that's what we do that's what we do right so he's taking out steps she'll be taken yeah we don't need to know about steps we just need the results and you're avoiding the passive pardon you're avoiding the passive indeed I am all right have a problem with doing that nope no okay all right so all those in favor of um approving policy p3110 say I I oppose exensions so after your head so you do on the next one the next one is and possible

178action regarding a second reading a policy 3113 setting budget priorities uh I'm going to ask this be referred back to the policy committee as I've reread it again this week I find uh three things that I think are of concern and rather than spend 45 minutes or an hour with the board debating it and kicking it up and back we're going to be meeting on the 18th I believe and we'll have it back to you for the first meeting in January okay and I I gave copies to um Ian and to Bev so they put it on your table today I got thank you all right but how do we do how do we handle that like I'm of course fine with it but do we have I'm making a request that it go back

179to we refer back to the policy committee we don't vote on it so the second reading didn't happen it's yeah the second reading didn't happen go back again to policy and then come back for a second meeting we table we yeah table postpone just ignore it [Laughter] overlooked all right the next one on discussion and possible action regarding second reading of policy p3150 adoption of budget um you want to be that motion I move that we adopt policy 3150 adoption of budget as submitted for a second reading a second I a second Michael thank you Michael all right discussion did everybody get a chance to read the policy yeah this is a second meing so any questions about the policy Matthew do you want to say anything about no I think this one is pretty

180clear Ian you have anything to add no just reviewing the final text it looks pretty good to me okay all those in favor of approving policy 3150 say I the next one is discussion and possible action regarding a second reading of policy 3323 soliciting prices and bidding requirements um Jen can you read that for me motion um to approve policy 3323 that right right um soliciting prices bidding requirements as a second reading do I have a second second okay I mean this is one that you wanted so do you want to say anything about this policy no it was um again looking back at the C policies and the prior policy that's stricken out in red at towards the bottom that's actually a regulation so you're going to see the regulation come back um after

181you have a budget I'll bring the regulation back because we're going to add more information to this as far as Soul Source procurement um and other sections as far as I researched all these exceptions and there's they don't align with State Statute so if we do this and we award contracts like this or bids then we won't be in in compliance with federal or state laws or even Charter so that's why when it comes back you're going to see The Only Exception that's allowed by state procurement law and by our Charter is utilities that's it there's nothing else so this actually goes back to the cave policy so that's why we put in in um green is everything from C with the exception of the dollar amounts because those are set locally this aligns our

182thresholds with the town procurement office which is so if we're sharing same vendors um then we don't have two different sets of figures that they need to try and figure out which one needs a bid or a quote or going out to um ower contract s so we're in line with their dollar values in this recommended change that makes sense any I sorry I wasn't here for the first reading um I have some some grammatical quibbles a couple of logic quibbles um it's just I read a couple of things and they don't maybe it's just me I've got to read it more often that there something don't hang together but I'll start with this so the state doesn't require state law doesn't require that we have three competitive bids so we're saying we should have

183three competitive bids correct right the state threshold is $25,000 for bidding or the bid anything below that they don't have anything as far as quotes or um Sound business practices that's something that was in our prior policy and then that's also in the town's um procurement manual there's not a town policy for procurement so my question is um because I've I remember years and years and years many years ago when I was an engineer um sometimes it was difficult working with New York City to actually get three bids on something believe it or not on the New York Metro you find two because nobody else wanted to deal with a city um so I remember then that process I had to provide some justification some justification to the city of why it we only had

184two biders before I was allowed to actually it would keep me from having to go out to rebid right so it's when we say uh sh be based when possible on at least three competitive bids I'm thinking all right what what do we what are we implying is going to be our process for saying you know what let's not get you know it's not possible to get three bids who determines whether it's possible and what's how was that determined often times it's um just being through so many audits myself as far as you know providing the information to the Auditors is basically the test that the Auditors will do is they'll basically just go right on Google and then indicate if there's other people that provide that service near me so if you have multiples

185and you only got few bids instead of three bids you can push the bid information out to the other vendors to see if they'll bid if they don't bid you can't force them to bid but it'll show that you did due diligence to try to get the additional bids okay my concern is that well we have policies to direct conduct okay uh if everyone could be counted upon to be a you brilliant angel of some sort we wouldn't have to have any written policies at all we would all know what to do at all times uh but we have written policies as standards P back on so the procedure I mean what you talked about is what the AUD would look would look at um that's fine as long as you actually have conscientious staff

186but suppose we have somebody who isn't paying attention or it does it another way because it came from another District or something like that and that's the way they always did it and there's nothing in the policy we can fall back on frankly that kind of a person might not be reading the policy to begin with but I go back to my question of you know who makes the determination it's what you're saying is when the audit's done this is what the auditor will do as long as they see that our due diligence has been so let's take the bus contracts that's a that's a good example we've only ever gotten as far as I know two bids because apparently we say in Eastern Connecticut there isn't a third company that is willing to bid

187because they're not capable of providing a bus services that we need we happen to be a much larger District than most right in this ENT of the state what's to stop an auditor from saying well you know um there are other bus companies out there so uh you know this is there was a flaw in your bidding process but how do you keep that from becoming you know just a matter of opinion it should you know in other words should we have something in the I don't know how you would word it to be honest with you but should we have something in the policy that says okay here's kind of why here's kind of what we would show here's who determines you know whether it was possible or not and how that we couldn't

188get three bids so that justification is already there's a recipe for it or some sort of a recipe answer that question it's already a two-point process uh great example and unfortunately I think Sam left but if Sam's going out and doing the biddings and opening the bids as director purchasing underneath my umbrella I make sure that we did our due diligence to get the beds before I sign that we can actually issue the PO I sign all the POS so that check and balance is already in place so I put on the auditor hat to make sure that we have documentation that we can scan in and have available so if the Auditors pull that one we have that read readily available in our response for when they ask for that contract I guess larger

189question now that I'm thinking about it is should we bother having something like that that whatever you just described in the policy or do we simply leave it to the implementation of the policy it should be in regulation another example is so Source if there is nobody else available that provides that service in our area right than um Department and directors fill out a soul Source procurement form well then you're safe and they provide all the additional information and then I do the auditor test to see if there's others available and if there's not it is soul sourced they sign I sign and then we issue a PO but there's no PO issued without us going through this process that's the check and balance okay where previously POS were issued so that's something new that

190we're trainning people on um thank you the um I'm going to hop around on the one two three fourth paragraph it says bid shall be open to the time specified and all biders and then we've crossed out and other interested persons as out of out of here which I find that deletion curious because it's is supposed to be all new language but anyway says shall be invited to be present which is open to the public I find that awkwardly worded I'm willing to leave it where it is I'm just simply pointing it out it seems all awkwardly wor well our policy committee did talk about that we were trying to make sure that people knew that these processes were open to the public and we question the other interested persons like what what do we

191mean by that you know who who'd be interested but the the gist of this is that the biders will show up that are interested and the public can show up as well right and so we everybody's included I I get I get the meaning of it that's why I say I'm willing to let it lie but I get the meaning of it I don't think it could be it could be construed any other way um trying to think here where I found there's some language in here that's very specific for example it'll say uh suppliers will be invited to have their names placed on electronic mailing list you know suppose somebody doesn't consider themselves to be a supplier so let's say somebody's providing Services they may not think of themselves as quote suppliers they'll probably

192read themselves into this and say okay or the the staff will say well by supplier we mean anybody who is we don't necessarily mean somebody who's supplying Goods de for example would you be comfortable with the word vendor right but where is it in the policy oh well one two third paragraph uh next the last sentence like third lineup it says suppliers shall be invited to have their names placed on electronic would vendors satisfy your concern I can put vendors yeah by the same the same way it says when specs are prepared they'll be emailed to all merchants and firms again merchants and firms that's the first time those words appear in this and again no one's expecting that this is going to be one of these you know things that take all the way

193Supreme Court kind of things where the language has to be all that tight I think you get the meaning anybody reading this gets the meaning what would you make it to be Dean because we had to move on here yeah no I understand it this happens to be the bigger one what do you want instead vendors vendors is fine vendors vendors in both places yeah I suppose yeah vendors both places um and there was a logic one I'm sorry Beth but there was there's a logic one in here um the notice shall also contain a notice of State contract requirements I'll leave that alone where are you oh third paragraph So the notice shall also contain a notice of State contract requirements concerning non-discrimination and affirmative action pursuant to section cgs4 a-60 and comma when

194applicable and it stops and it says requirements concerning the awarding of contracts of small contractors Mar business Enterprise and individuals disability nonprofit corporations pursuant to section cgs4 A- 60g stop those those I'm not sure whether there was something wrong with the editing there yeah that's an example of something that really is kind of ambiguous not even really ambiguous I don't know what it exactly it's all supposed to mean I can Irene would a period after 4 a-60 solve that we need to keep in when a put well but what's the and there must be something missing no we strike the and this this is language directly from the state okay oh what else did in that sentence that paragraph I'm I'm I'm leave that one right there so removing the end is okay with you

195and then well I mean do everybody else think does does it when you when you write it that way does it make sense does it does it um eliminating the end I think solves the grammatical problem because it's just comma when applicable it's just a little hanging Clause tell me where we are because I lost I was on some oh I'm sorry it's on the third this uh you don't have control of the screen are you going to corect anything on the next sentence thing it says requirement see we can highlight it there well yeah I mean that one doesn't even have a um a verb that's just that's a clause of some sort it doesn't go with anything I mean which paragraph are you on I mean the third paragraph highlighting still on ah

196so maybe the requirements should be that's still an ongoing sentence was it supposed to be and comma when applicable comma requirements concerning the wording maybe it's probably that's what it was like that before but then it was too wordy so can write it either way yeah yeah you're right because the second sentence is in the sentence right so reduce the r to lower after the end yes yeah get that out of there oh yeah I mean you can eliminate one of the other out take one of and the comma take and or the comma I I think the and I think the and has to stay in and it needs two commas around when applicable because it's just a long sentence complex sentence yeah right so the N stays in yeah okay and where's the

197coun going where it is and after applicable yeah this yeah you want the whole long sentence in that's what it was must have been State stuff will fer did it so wa La he made a point there a point after one applicable instead of a period it's a comma yeah and then instead of starting a new sentence requirements would be lowercase R wow that's a long sentence still one still requires a verb no that's got one it's early on first one you brought up the notice because we refer to it as an advertisement we could change notice to advertisement yeah yeah like that what sentence is that second you could also say the notice shall shall also contain State contract requirements yeah but oh yeah inad of not that's just a style all right so

198you wanted to say the notice shall also contain State contract requirements yes so we take out that yeah so are we taking and out no no they're leaving it put keep an end we're going super complex on the sentence so putting the comma before and before and and then after applicable is that what yeah that's correct no that no it's not long and then you go to col of requirements concerning the water contract blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah BL from the state because appc the notice the notice shall contain the requirements both Federal what happened we wait wait we got too many conversations going please you'll see this language both in federal and state law when it comes to bidding and soliciting prices and all procurement Al together so where this comes

199into play is to make sure that we're following this process because if we aren't we could be jeopardizing our federal and state grants that we receive because when we sign for the grant and we apply for a grant we ATT test that we're following a federal state that's why it's important this language is here oh I'm not disputing the language sentence that they want to havean all for this um if we're GNA go for the long sentence option the win applicable would have that's is introducing the second thought right the requirements that's introducing requirements if we leave the period in and go for two short sentences the win applicable would then attach to the previous thought which is not what's intended if I understand you correctly right it's the second set up right the first

200thought is hard and fast that's it that has to happen every time no matter what the second thought is contingent it's a dependent right because on when it's those categories then you don't have to go back out to bed so that's what we should decide when applicable comma requirements lowercase are blah blah blah blah blah that's that sentence makes sense not a sentence so if we're going to go for two short sentences let me just finish this I just had now so if we're going to go for two short sentences we should put the period at the end of cgs4 a-60 period new sentence when applicable comma requirements concerning the awarding of contracts and so on it would have to say it would I like that it say when appical comma the notice shall also

201contain requirements or you could just have a longer sentence what you do for the the the the the super like comma train we have a lot more to do you know William F not spend a lot of time on this let's just decide how do we want to go two sentences one sentence two sentences two sentences both with verbs two sentences with verbs two sentences me the two sentences um you have it Irene yeah with Mike's help because Mike solved the subject verb problem right yeah okay you need to read it back to us no truster we trust you R truster okay so ahead Mike I've got one on on the short paragraph right above the all contracts and open market orders when that's all contracts is it all contracts and Market orders above that

20215,000 yes so we put that in cuz I don't know if there are contracts that are less than that but it wasn't clear to me we may have contracts um if it's required by the vendor for items under that but it's not something we would require so so is it okay to add or maybe it's redundant but all contracts and all open market orders uh of 15,000 or more just iring that from the uh previous paragraph it makes it more clear if it's already clear to everyone else it's I'm fine without it so all contracts and all open market orders of 15,000 or more yeah okay Dean will you finish are you finished M I'm sorry while while we're I'm sorry so last paragraph where there are references to section 16-h and and 16-h with

203they okay as long as we're here we said CGS before when referring to State Statute again it could be inferred but they don't say CGS so they should say CGS section or just CGS 16 Dash this should be second of all these but it doesn't I think we know 16- 244b and 16-1 it should say CGS just so we know okay I think we should send it back to P this is one that we really need right away this is one that probably our top priority so if we can get this straight tonight it would be really wonderful and then in the first paragraph oh the the first paragraph there's a C.G dos such a CGS even I is an old man I've learned to live with less than Perfection remember that Comm same lives

204right all right ready to vote on as amended as amended okay all those in favor voting approv in p332 three as amended say I so appr okay last one is um P3 read two monthly budget and expense report um that yeah I'd like to make a motion to approve policy P 3432 monthly budget and expense report anual financial statement second reading I have a second second okay I don't think we did any discussion no all those in favor approving the what again the first one we did pass oh I've got that yeah you want to uh well you know no we discussed about this in policy and at the last meeting um so uh I think um we're in a good good place with it honestly and uh yeah I think we're off to a

205good start for the reporting and for the record the second paragraph is one sentence I second doesn't pertaining to this policy let's send it back to Andrea for this particular policy itself I plan to work with our Communications team to beef up our financial portion on our website um to include prior audits the budgets the budgets to actual all that information or links to the town to find the information so that is coming um in the third quarter thank you right any other comments all those in favor of approving policy3 42 say I exension approve thank you awesome thank you guys a lot of hard work I appreciate pleasure to you yeah everybody us on the right appreciate it okay the next is new business um discussion and possible action regarding approval of the 2025

2062026 school calendar can I have a motion Jay uh let's see I move we approve the proposed 2025 2026 school calendar have a second second discussion you have just one quick question actually I'll make another point but um in October 2025 at the end of the month there three um parent teacher conference days 29th 30th and 31st um those will be early dismissal for elementary middle school so three first is Halloween does that is is that workable I'm I'm just asking because it's Halloween I know the school acts a little differently on that day so you say it that way it's it's very doable for the teachers because it's a half day but what they do is they have afternoon conferences I think on the 29th and the 30th they have afternoon and evening which

207takes care of that afternoon so it's just the teachers that go home early because the evening conference so no evening on the 31st no evening on the 31 yeah for the kids or the parents and and then I just suggest a minor change um not to any of the dates or anything but but uh the parent teacher conference it says right below it it has the description it says parent teacher conference early dismissal Elementary Middle uh years ago there used to be a dash there so it said parent teacher conference Dash early dismissal elementary and middle and I wouldn't have thought that was important except for this year the high school conferences didn't happen and so I think that Dash might might be helpful so you know it might be important put Fitch high school

208and I'll tell them I don't know if they need three days but even if they had two days well well it used to have the dash so that should be a time when every school has parent teacher conferences I get that Fitch doesn't have to have a half days for that um but but they should have conferences so okay um well I know they're they're planning on it well so but now it's a little late but they are planning on it like in between semesters so so just suggest a dash on on both of those ones that in it had it in the 2020 21 went away in 2023 24 um just because probably so Fitch is not having any on this calendar there's no parent teacher no I'm saying we're going to put the

209dash and I'm going to remind fit that they're going to offer that at that time yeah I've already talked to Matt about it it's the same for um March um I don't know if they had parent conferences at the end of the year I can ask it's a good idea help with BH at two places right anything that can help parent teacher interaction I know certainly helps we need it with the test scores C we may not need it for graduating seniors you might need more so you might yeah I would I've be in favor seen it all the way through all the schools yeah and both spring and fall Adrian um I just have a a couple of comments kind of to follow up on what Mike was talking about but um maybe the

210the 31st October 31st and March 27th maybe they shouldn't say parent teacher conferences on that it should just say half days because there's no parent teacher conferences on those days correct yeah so it's almost like you need the parent teacher conference days are really the 25th and the 26th but the early dismissal of the 25th 26th and 27th correct and then the same thing um with the 29th and 30th so if we want to make a half day on the 31st it should have nothing to do it may be it's a contractual thing as a as kind of giving some te time back to the teachers right right exactly um so so my other comment is um Middle School um only had parent conferences one day um they only had one evening all right all

211right Middle School had um conferences one evening last year in the fall but in this or I mean one evening in two days in the fall but then in the spring um the Middle School only had one day of conferences so let me talk to Peter bass to see what the needs are cuz if they if they need to have have it in the spring the way they had it in the fall all then we can put this together but if they don't we can take away one of those days for them yeah so yes what I'm getting at is is we're going to be running the buses for long days for the middle school because they're running for the high school yeah so we can potentially save a day of busing if the Middle

212School of an additional bus run I don't if that has any Financial impact um but now we've got to do three bus runs because it's Middle School and High School yep share that half I work with Sam and the principles I see them tomorrow so maybe we can maybe we can try to coordinate those two on both of those MH you know with Fitch and in the middle school on both of those for bus runs thank you so what are you saying like on March 27th would be a half a day well maybe one of those doesn't need to be a half day if the middle school is only using one day if they're if they're only using one day as conferences in the spring which um so nice I think they need to be

213consistent like adrianne's saying that whatever we're doing for the Middle School we're doing for the high school too all right yeah here's here's the thing from um March 4th this was sent out in parent Square last spring conferences will be held on Thursday March 21st there will be an early release day for students on the 21st and the 22nd so it sounds like what happened at the middle schools is there wasn't a half day on the Wednesday but the calendar should reflect that but I don't know I mean this is just a parents sare announcement it might not have well I see him tomorrow so I'll ask him Susan can I ask a question yeah go um so in August yeah so in August like first day of schools the 27th with kindergarten the 28th

214and then preschool and prek um the 29th should it be reversed like letting the little kids come on the 27th so that they can have like the school before all the other older students are there we need to get those 180 days in 181 days in with preschool we don't and what we like to do is do a screening so we like time prior to just especially children we haven't already seen okay we want to get to know that why why the preschool starts on a Friday why can't they start on that Thursday too I mean it doesn't make sense they go to school one day and then they're off for it makes it makes sense to our teachers and staff who are watching all these little ones come in so one day we have

215the kindergarten come in and we make sure that they're here and checked in for the whole staff for every school it takes a lot of attention when you got all these little ones riding the bus and they usually need two days for the preschool for the screening and they only need the one for kindergarten because we built it into our schedule in the summer in the um spring and in the summer from to school on the 29th for that one day and then off three days that there's same reason timate well it it's almost like a um it's almost like a welcome back and or you know sof start a soft start and um you know kind of getting to know everybody and okay so Dan sure um one one quibble first um June 20

216June 26 Calendar it says 11 days I count 10 that's how you get to the 180 on the June 26 Calendar You' got five days the first week and then five days of the next week the 12th is the last day of school early dismissal that's it so the only way you have 11 to report 11 for that month which would take you to 181 but it doesn't is to include the PD day on the 15th but the school kids are not coming they're so they only really have 10 days not not 11 days that month it's a small thing so because we give the kids 180 one days in the district um you could you could have a school year with 180 that's all the state provides but we do pay the teachers so

217the teachers have got to come in then on the 15th but I'll I'll re go over with Erica she did this a few times to make sure we got the num all the numbers as you as you track through when you accumulate when you finally get the June 11 plus 170 gives you 181 well the only way to get that the 11 days in June is to go past the last day of school so I'm not sure what is the 11 intended to cover the PD day or is the 11 11 intended to cover or is that number which ought to be 10 intended to cover the last day of school that's my yeah I've got to go through and count it again you have a more serious question though um on the uh winter

218holiday recess December into January and then again in April where we've got the week off I'm curious um I know this is impossible to align with all other districts but it is something that teachers ask and sometimes parents ask as well you know how aligned are they with uh with the surrounding districts tabs with you know water for and stoning Etc this came from the regional calendar okay and and um actually the reason why we we thought about the two weeks it was actually the you teachers union that said boy that would be great and um there are about four other districts that I know were committing to the two full weeks off um but start the starting and stopping really is about the same some people take a whole week off I think it's

219lime old lime takes a whole week off for February break so there's some subtle difference but mostly the start and end times are pretty similar um in all of our calendars and then the graduation date you know we typically do a Friday but that is juneth and the town and the district have been um recognizing that as a holiday so it might be that our kids would graduate on Thursday the 18th I don't know and let's hope for not having lots of snow days so that we get our days in and we don't have to extend but that's always the mystery right well on the shore at least they Ledger we get a lot more snow than we oh yeah yeah anyway thank you excuse me for April um you know that week off is

220it always like the second week of April because I was just wondering if you're already having Friday off like could you have like that week of the sixth to the 10th off then this way it's sort of like probably because it doesn't go with the other school it doesn't go with the other schools the other schools and we are responsible for taking you know transporting our magnet schools so it it differently or does it differently that's a real problem or Ledger that could be a real problem to us because then we still have to transport their kids yes when they're going and then we transport ours when they're going so it might yeah more transportation did you ever have professional development at the end of the school year like this yeah we have we have

221and what are you doing well I mean to me professional development you have it and then you use it right but this is you have it and then you you're off for the summer I would say with wit and wisdom we wish we had a couple days at the end of the year so teachers could have taken their manuals home and gotten a kind of a sampling and so um with roll out of new curriculum it's really important and sometimes it can be a book talk um that they want to continue in the summertime or there's a lot of different things that they can be doing and how's the attendance I'd love to see that they actually show up because I think you know it's you know they have to really get special permission if

222you know what I mean if they miss like the first last day or the days be before or after a vacation you have to get a doctor's note well they have to yeah they have to um yeah check in with their principal yeah just a uh I don't know maybe this would bother lots of people but is there a thought if we needed some time to put a half day before Thanksgiving break which I believe we used to do um on that Wednesday and I know some well yeah instead of having because then we would pick up maybe that extra one day we get 181 which I don't know um how many people travel on Thanksgiving and the effects of that would be they'll just skip school I'm just throwing that out I believe districts

223around do have day on that it might hurt our intendance rates unfortunately oh and and we've got that as a problem I would say because of the military influence if people if they're you know traveling at that time that's been a real plus I think for some families but you're right if they needed to take it they would just take it you know yeah how do other people feel about uh making a day before Thanksgiving a half a day instead of a whole day off I think it's impractical I mean I would love it to count as part me my experience you know Wednesday was a half day but I'm not the one who had to get in a car and drive that was my dad so I think what's going to really happen is

224people who have to travel and that's a lot of people um are just going to take the whole Wednesday off they're going to pull their kids out heck they pull them out to take them to Disney World for Pat sake so they'll definitely take them off for that Wednesday because they know the half day before Thanksgiving is a nothing's really going on that day anyway so if I take my kid out of school because I gotta get an early start that's what they'll do so hooray we had a half day but who shows up that goes back to what mik as well just take off yeah okay what you say Ian um I can agree with the sentiment of Adrian's idea but I'm I'm I'm I'm find myself more in agreement with Dean's analysis okay

225Michael oh yeah I think we should have the whole day off because it like putting that in you just kind of structurally increase your absentee rates unfortunately I mean it's just true and and we'll see the hit yeah Matthew on for vacation okay Jen know if they're going to they're going to take you know count to 180 days or at 181 and if they're going to take it they're going to take it anyway so I'm for leaving it as a half day or making it for that y j well I think it used to be a half day and it was um considered an improvement to give it the whole day so and I think that the teachers even the teachers and the parents so I say we stay with the full day off okay

226sorry AJ no I I was just thr I actually think I would leave it at the at this point hearing what everyone had to say I appreciate we could meet we could meet that day in the morning start in the morning too yeah all right anything else on the calendar and we ready to vote and we're just gonna like tidy up that that CL recount tidy it up it it looks like the previous years they they kind of had different wording too I think it's all there yeah just yeah have here's the school the time the school starts it will have all that yeah yeah okay so so just to be clear the amendments are going to be it's going to be specific on what um conferences are going to be in what schools yep

227yeah CU La last school year that 2023 2024 I look back just now and they did have uh for that March one ele Elementary only and then had the middle school and Elementary so they just spelled it out I think it's just kind of overly consolidated ated here maybe in the text yeah cuz they used to have um am kindergarten and PM kindergarten those schol for am Kinder all that on there yeah all right so you'll get this back to us okay and then we'll take a peek at it but you want to vote on it now shot on this one yeah okay we can say as amended so if you find any flaws you let me know amended again as to be amended as to be amended C blanch so all those in favor

228of voting on The 2025 2026 school calendar as amended pending Amendment making sure it's correct okay exensions all right thank you all next is uh information proposals letters Communications and comments by board members or meeting items and other items in our jurisdiction um who wants to go first you you're just looking at me I was just looking up to see who else is raising their hand it's like playing we used to play seven up when I was a kid in school I love that peek don't peek Mike you want to go first I can't remember what what I hadn't said from the last one I was trying to remember that um I'll just I'll just okay I'm good good Jane um I'm good except for like um like our offsite at okay we try to

229work on that not Jay I don't have anything okay Adrian um I'll just be quick um this weekend I went to the fencing Winter Classic or at least part of it um until my child was eliminated but there um there was there was a child board member remember that was there all night so um and and won so the entire event so have to congratulate Annabelle Whitney yeah Tournament champion that's a I mean that's a that's a real competition it was what 3 well 32 kids division so it's fantastic well done Annabelle Ann she's everywhere I saw carolling like this weekend she's had a busy weekend yeah and I will be looking forward to the auditorium lights I attended an event a little while back where it seemed like they couldn't dim the lights for

230some reason um in the audience so it'll be great to have the lighting you know fix in the auditorium so I look forward to that than remember the game password that sit there with a little card and go I'll pass um well I just wanted to share that uh so um the policy committee meeting that is happening on December 18th that's going to cover policy p3120 that we talked about at the last meeting with that third paragraph It's not in this this agenda packet but it from the 25th that was the one that got sent back to policy to to get uh tweaked and like kind of like figure out a way to put that third paragraph into the uh into the body um also I guess 3113 is going to be on the agenda

231right and it's just going to be focused on those two or anything I think we have four or five okay uh I would you ask ER tomorrow she can send out the a pre agenda so everybody can look at it if anybody problems with it we can get back to her immediately so we can amend the agenda and not cancel another meeting sounds great okay um so the 3120 and the 3113 would complete the set of the five prioritized policy proposals coming from the ad hoc budget procedure there's still four other ones that were not prioritized just because they come they handle stuff later in the uh budget oversight um process have you completed your work is a committee on those other four um yes yes everything because U that everything was in the report

232all nine were in in the interim report um that we issued and um also um there was some that were dra as regulation which also is going to be handled in the spring um so there's just more Susan the regulation well it's going to be in collaboration with the policy committee as usual the Susan does it and then she gives it to the policy committee I don't do it by myself you know I do it with the business has to be how they're doing their job we've we've handled our documents in the past no what let not say no to the best of my knowledge Susan has no obligation whatsoever to show anything to us in terms of regulations she does however show us everything she proposes in regulations and we get a look at

233it sometimes she changes her regulations as a result I listen that that one is pretty clear and it's in a 9,000 Series another I mean functionally functionally we we get to look at it we get to comments on it and Administration has listened yeah no well I'm sure that be an ongoing conversation um the uh I also had a conversation with um uh Jay uh couple weeks ago and I'm not sure how to handle it well actually no just close out on the policy thing though the 3113 and 3120 um and any other policies that are passed and and and dealt with in that uh December 18th meeting I would hope to see um maybe scheduling a uh this kind of dovetails on the next agenda item the January 6 meeting um I'd like to

234see us consider having a uh we already talked about that meeting yeah Special meeting prior to that go on with that so that that is gonna happen yes it okay very good um so uh oh yeah so the calendar um the budget Cal calendar we also at one point Jay and I discussed uh trying to reintroduce the idea and I'm not sure how that would work um of having the January 6th meeting also be prefaced by a public hearing and moving it from the 13th to the 6th because uh that motion you know at the time uh it was a split it was a TI vote and one of the members was not in the room um so that's something I thought might be worthy of some level of reconsideration and I just say that

235one of the things we've done in the past is we've made sure that we had our leaon meeting before we shared it with the public because we wanted Insight from the Town Council and the RTM I know that we actually adjusted that date in the past so that it didn't come prior to that liaison meeting and I think the six is too soon for the public to have enough information to come out and talk about so you need to give us a little more time you heard Irene she's had a lot to deal with and she's doing a dynamic job and paying such close attention to detail I really appreciate it but you know I what's right in front of her right now is finishing this audit from 24 and getting this budget ready to

236go before the holidays and there's two weeks so we've got a lot of pressure on us right now so to have a public meeting when I'm just introducing I mean the public can certainly watch and I'd encourage them to watch you know but I think that we need a couple weeks to work together and then fine-tune things a little bit and then bring out the public that's just my good thinking my advice so so Ian says there was a vote and it was four to four so you were oh no I think it was three to three actually no it passed from the 13th it passed from the 13th yeah we all said with the 13 it passed okay well Jay I don't know if you wanted to speak to it at the risk of

237felt like that was going to cut in on our work session on the 13th theoretically see how many people come out we'll keep it on the 13th wait I'm I'm confused now the 13th of December no January January they wanted to on the 6 of January but that failed because it was like you're GNA present it and then like people yeah would give people a chance to review it it failed on a TI vote but it failed on a tie right but the my my recollection of Roberts is that if you want something reconsidered you can't be on the losing end you better be on the winning end to say you know what this is true that's why I didn't make the motion to reconsider I said maybe the i' like to make a motion

238to reconsider the um public comment um that's not on our agenda though can I put it on this no com hope to put on our oh we' have to put it we have the rules twoth thirds of us have to vote to add something to the agenda which we can do because and then another two3 then we'd have to have a two-thirds vote to reconsider something right is that is that in our rules or is that the other body no no let's move on please um you have anything else that's it for me okay Adrian you done I'm done I mean now Jay Jay did you finish saying what you're were saying because it was like contested four all I said was it's cut in on our work session on the 13th but we can

239consider this again well the six is the work session too I thought it was her presentation yeah and then it says budget work session yeah and then we followed by the budget work it's just that I'm going to give that that same presentation twice in two weeks no I don't think we were going to give the presentation before for the public we always give them when the public comes out we always share like the big idea and what's happening in the budget I assume that it was this room probably right well I guess maybe it could be 5 55 yeah or somewhere but um when you present and then just hearing U people's comments that day which may or may not be related yeah which may or may not necessar may be priority priorities of

240the of the you know people of the Town not necessarily commenting on each individual budget line item yeah they they usually come out and speak and you know on behalf of education and whatever they really are interested in and we've sent out the strategic planning so we're getting a lot of good feedback from parents that went on parents School in the community so we've already gotten a couple hundred so they know they've got some ideas percolating I would encourage parents or citizens to come to all of these meetings there's some serious stuff at work just let everybody know on um can you mark your calendars on next Monday December 16th at six o'clock we're scheduled to meet with our legislators um Chris Heather and Andre by [Music] zoom and a complete Zoom meeting the entire

241board complete Zoom meeting or hybrid no right here okay Andre is gonna be on Zoom because he's going to be away but Heather and Christine connley will be here nice thank you and um after that meeting after they come and we talk with them I would like to do the superintendent's goals and get that done with because we can't do our goals until we do the superintendent goals and you know we're already four months into this so can I send them out ahead of time with the prioritize and because I've neaten them up for you so you can see the action steps with the goals could I offer a comment on on superintendent's goals would that be off topic what concerned me about the superintendent's goals was nothing that you said it was what wasn't

242said the goals as I saw them were mainly process goals I saw no metrics by which we can measure success or not so would like to see you consider what metrics you would put uh particularly you know an academic achievement what metrics we're going to use so that we so our teachers have goals we don't have to make all of our goals every year but we can motivate Everybody by having some goals and discuss that later don't lean away from the mic that's all oh okay like come back to us thank you Ian I appreciate it I thought you were talking to me so don't December 16th um we're meeting with our legislators they want what we want specific to gron no broad no state stuff whatever is specific to us like um uh what

243did I tell you Jay um the HVAC the HVAC system and since the town council's prioritizing Nea and CK right um getting out of the alliance District meld har and asking them for their counsel and advice as to how we can do this because we don't have the answers we need their well they have a one one person has a whole different take on that so and when they come they'll tell you about that I'm sure they will speak for them I'm sure they will I don't want to speak for them when they come they'll speak is that is that pandemic relief sech charge on our electric bills that's Statewide is that is that fair to know how much money we're spending because they want they want yeah cost they want dollars well it sounds

244like Irene's going to get that number that it doesn't have to be the exact amount but a roundabout amount um and some things they said that we had on our list I think it was um H what was it I wish I would have wrote it down it was it was one of yours in um transparency oh yeah yeah okay they said if you have any questions that's not really for discussion because that's not gron specific um just to write down your questions give them to me and I'll give them to them and they will get back to us on question well actually I'll have to review that meeting with MDG because that that's where that note came from it wasn't anything that I knew of or had concerns with in particular it was something

245they said yeah but they um one legisl I talked to said there it's there it's all set it's good I'll review the MDG meeting and and see exactly what it was they're referring to and cross reference that I mean I hope there's no concern I don't really have a concern no concern there's no lack of transp what do keep in mind NDG was the Consultants that are doing our health insurance okay yeah they said keep in mind if we go with the state partnership plan then that consultant loses their job so see the big picture well they did say that they they said they would still be um Consulting for us with the state plan I believe that's what they said in the meeia anyway it did say but any questions you have um I

246think another one of your I I'll text you and tell other they said just write down your questions sure can can we also at that meeting with the state legislators highlight the career Pathways because that Workforce training element I think um speaks across every aisle and uh it's something I think that we're a growing leader in yeah we can so and it could use an infusion of funds well if you have anything additional that you want to talk about manufacturing center send them to me can you email them to me and I'll about putting them on the list they want to know what it's all going to cost yeah like you can't they don't just want to say unfunded mandates which unfunded mandates do you want them to eliminate and how much does it cost

247grotten yeah they're not interested in just revoking 72 unfunded mandates they want to know what's affecting groten and how much does it cost yeah it's going to be tough between now and when they to get all that yeah we do and they only want to talk about four or five so yeah and I can say you the top four that I have and for transportation they want yeah what are we looking that's one of them on the list Transportation electricity the HVAC and the Lions that's the five on the list there's one that's both Groton specific and Statewide at the same time that's the ECS there has been nothing no increase since 2017 and we're getting the same amount for student which means we're buy we're getting now we're getting about 18% less purchasing power

248because they haven't raised it it's 11525 you couldn't talk about you're not gonna see anything with that you can't just raise Groton it's a whole pot I understand that's why I'm asking you if that should be on you to all right so we all be hearing this December 16th for our state delegation come cookies's got so everybody has the future meeting dates and all that any suggested agenda items no only the two that we discussed earlier tonight tell me again um there was uh the the prek TK that hold a further deep dive on that you know especially that's going to be an um you know in the budget and the business software and business software yeah let's have an up or down vote on that and like a nice you know presentation of what

249options exist Bev do you think it would be useful to update the full board on the uh Grant opportunity and the decision not to pursue it and maybe let Clint talk about what he's done about AI he knows a lot and I think it'd be good for the board to hear what he has to say go ahead I know if this is an agenda item for the full board or for the maybe the finance committee but um we we should have a a clear strategy about how we're Staffing the um the um the town operational review uh I was concerned about something as I was hearing and just just the amount of money it's going to cost so I guess I could make an official referral uh to the finance committee to can you write

250that construct construct a policy towards that um Str yeah strategy yeah we my thinking is we should have a cap on how much we're spending to win I don't want to cut you off be rude um okay all right um um since I'm the chair now Jay will be on policy right Finance Finance always on finance and facility that was your committee Andrea is going to be on policy she's going to take my so we won't have to word Matthew Andrew is G be on I got your email that's wonderful Jay's gonna be and uh Adrian can I ask you to cheer curriculum because Andrea wants to step down as chair she still wants to be on the committee but yeah yeah okay and we've got Mike I'm on curriculum who's gonna be the third

251um curriculum no oh Andrea she's just stepping down she just says okay stay on okay all right all right there have a motion for adour motion to Second 9:35 I'm a pretty good guess

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.