001e all right welcome everyone um thank you for joining us I'm going to call the new Harford Public Schools Board of Education regular meeting of February 4th to order at um exactly 7 p.m. uh first item is the Pledge of Allegiance if you're able please join us I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay uh next item is the order of business I have no changes to the order of business bus does anybody have anything they'd like to add modify adjust okay seeing none on to uh item C Communications to the Board of Education uh we do not have any Communications between last meeting and this meeting so we'll move right
002to public comment would anyone like to address the board would just please start with your name and address please Kristen CBA 41 zerlene good evening I wanted to express my concern regarding the use of eded van for classroom parties I understand the importance of providing students with enjoyable safe snacks I have significant concerns about the affordability and quality of the food being provided the cost of the food for class parties through Ed Advance is extensive particularly considering the quality of the items as a parent I'm already asked to contribute funds for various initiatives such as numerous fundraisers gifts for faculty teacher appreciation week and end of the Year celebrations it could be quite overwhelming also as a room parent myself we often contribute extra as it's hard enough to have parent volunteers um I personally
003spent $36 a loan on snacks for my daughter's class party as I refused to ask parents for additional contributions as I refuse for the kids to miss out on a fun opportunity of a Class party I discussed my concern with the director of student services who suggested I could let them know if there are any families in need and he thought the PTO would contribute if necessary however the pto's involvement with class parties is to organize the room parents for teachers to help facilitate communication and events that take place in and out of school I personally believe it is extremely inappropriate for parents to be put in the position of discussing financial matters with others it should not be the responsibility of any parent or individual to address someone's else's financial situation this is something
004that should be handled by the school not the individual parents furthermore there are numerous alternatives to Ed advances offerings that are not not only more affordable but also healthier with options that cater to Common dietary restrictions such as dairyfree nut free gluten-free Die free and are made with non-GMO and organic ingredients unfortunately some of these features Ed Advance does not provide to make it easier I have compiled a few examples of better more affordable options that meet these criteria I have it at home I forgot it but I could also email that to you um in their place of what they're offering while I do want snacks to remain part of a classroom party I believe there is need for them to be more affordable and accessible to All Families if the decision is made
005to continue using Ed advance I respectfully suggest that the board consider renegotiating the terms of the contract especially given that we already rely on their services for our lunch PR program across all three schools it is important that we strike a balance between ensuring students having fun during these parties with a reasonable snack and craft while also being mindful of our families I appreciate your attention and I look forward to hearing your thoughts on potential solutions that could help make classroom parties snacks options more affordable for the families thanks thank you Kristen do you want to share that with us for the record your letter and then if you would like to email it please do yeah Elizabeth thank you want please would anyone else like to address the board um I have same things
006but I WR wrote mine in a notebook so I can send an email that's fine um Melissa wac be my address 15 Spencer Brook Road um so my concerns and just thoughts were kind of along the similar line of Kristen's um so good evening thank you for allowing me time to speak about my concerns um my first concern is surrounding the safety choices being made as a classroom parent um we previously had access to the classroom allergies knowing what allergies were present um and we were given them as a classroom parent we were given the list not specifically what student had the allergy but we were allowed to know what allergies were present in the classroom so when we brought classroom um when when we brought things into the classroom we knew ahead of time
007um so now that information is not given to the classroom parents so when ordering from Ed Advance we have no idea what allergies are present in the classroom um being a classroom parent for fourth grade class this year unfortunately I ordered ice cream and there was a lactose tolerant child in the room which I found out from my child and that child who lactose tolerant was not able to enjoy the the treat unfortunately um so that's just a concern that I have um and then secondly the nurse still has to check all classroom snacks when we order from Ed Advance anyway um so for these allergies if that was a concern that was a reason for going with Ed advance I wasn't sure that it was really alleviating any of the checks in balances in
008place anyway um because the nurse is still checking everything that's going to each class anyway so that was just kind of something I was thinking why is that being put into place for the safety and concern of the children if the nurse is having to do that check and balance anyway um another concern that I had was kind of along Kristen's thought was the money and flexibility there really is no flexibility in this new system in a world where we really need a lot of f flexibility as parents we know that flexibility is really key um first off you can only order in amounts of 20 or 24 for a school where most classes are under 20 it really causes a lot of waste um recently in classro settings we had four or five extras
009and the kids unfortunately fought over the last ice creams which you know is going to happen um and we kind of are able to account for this when we bring outside treat in um we're able to account for two per child or exact amounts and we are able to do that beforehand when we get there with this system the treats are automatically there and we're not able to account for that so they see all the treats and just assume um while it might not seem like a lot of money there are four parties for per year that we need to um deal with per as a room parent and if you order just fruit in a cookie it's anywhere from $32 to $44 per party so it's about $120 a year um and that's on
010the lower end for the parties for the year and myself as a room parent when you're given the room parent list you don't have access to every uh parent in the room a lot of times parents will take their name off the list and they don't want to be accessed as a um participant in the room they take their email or they'll even go as far as remove their child's name from the list so it becomes a financial burden to the rest of the class um in my particular class there's three other children that are not able to be contacted so being the room parent I fronted the $75 for the two parties that I threw initially and I did eventually ask for reimbursement and only received reimbursement for from three fours of the class
011so while I am not toting my own horn by any means and financially okay I don't feel it should be my responsibility to have to burden that $75 where had it been another um where we would take outside donations families would be okay with going to the dollar store or another area where they could have gotten a cheaper treat for maybe making brownies for a dollar um so those were just some of my concerns and if it was something as simple as you know the the allergies being taken into consideration I thought that that really wasn't being alleviated because the nurse is still checking them so thank you for your time thank you would anyone else Dan good evening I don't know if I need this Dan jeram 535 downhill Road a former customer that
012three children go through your school um in January couple things nothing too intricate uh in January the board selectman were dealing with volunteer recog nitions and it comes uh to the thought that we don't thank our volunteers enough uh being on the board of ed isn't easy I'm sure it's going to be we're heading into budget season I'm sure it's going to be a challenge but thank you for everything that you're doing uh not a lot of people here tonight but it's not an easy job and we're appreciative uh so I've imposed myself if Jeff Jeff's a little slow I was giving him a little primer of the budget I think he fell and hit his head once so he might be a little slow today but um thankful for his consideration we work a
013lot together and have a great relationship um but we are moving into budget season so I'm hopeful that you folks are thinking about that it may be capital and helping Jeff through that and maybe uh if we could impose oursel Tom for several years has been on our Capital subcommittee that is a separate subcommittee of the Town hopefully we could impose and maybe you could continue and come and help us review those capitals not just for um the school board but for the entirety of the town and how we go forward so um that'll be coming we're kind of a little bit off kilter this year because our audits like a lot of small towns seems like there's just not a lot of Auditors so the audits won't be ready until March so maybe we
014can have that ready for February but um anyway thanks for what you do and I appreciate it I know my kids had a great experience I had a great experience coming here and I know it's not easy so thank you very much thanks anyone else all right seeing none we will uh move on to the next item which is the superintendent report okay thank you and good evening to everybody we will start off with of course our student reps which are Emma and Dexter we're so appreciative of their efforts today and we look forward to their reports I know that they will share their information and again just as a reminder once you have completed your report there's no obligation to stay but if you would like to you're always welcome to do so uh
015so just make sure you your mic is on green and then you may begin thank you I interviewed Miss gaheen on what SEC our second graders are up to a New Hartford Elementary and Bakerville School in math the second graders are learning about measuring in inches and centimeters they also just learned how to make line plots in ela the students are learning about what paleontologists do and how fossil are Crea I still remember when I did that unit and how fun it was in science they are studying animal adaptations the students are said their favorite things to so far this year were the big field trip to Yale P body museum and making their own bird feeder prototypes in science I also asked Miss gaheen and other teachers to work together how they work together
016I was very curious about this topic because they are in different schools and they still work together Miss gaheen informed me that the second grade teachers have weekly meetings where they plan special activities and get ready for upcoming lessons they do also work on working together during professional development days thank you good evening February is a lot of fun for the whole District first we will parti participate in a world read aloud day on February 5th this is a day where we celebrate The Art of Storytelling a special guest from our community will come in to all of our classrooms to read to us some of our readers are the Board of Education members our first selectman Mr jerum our superintendent Mr Susa Lions Club members beakley Library staff and Miss Mrs Bon from Bon
017Farm one thing that is really special is that they donate the book to our classroom thank you to Mrs weberman Mrs mathys and Mr organizing our world fre toow day on February 6th we will have the 100th day day of school it's a day to celebrate our progress in school depending on your grade level kids might be able to bring in a collection of a hundred things or dress up if they were a 100 years old every year we have a kindness week from February 10th to February 13th we will do all sorts of kind and fun things Monday is peace love and kindness day so wear tie-dye Tuesday is to workout problems with kindness day so wear workout clothes Wednesday is a dream of kindness and wear your pajamas to school last is Thursday
018love how kind you are and wear valentine colors this week represents showing kindness to everyone together our schools are showing kindness by showing that we care from my experience I feel like I had a nice and kind environment in school ruler teaches us how to come together and let everyone feel like they are in are in a safe and support supported at school everyone works hard to be kind to each other thank you very much student reps appreciate it very much all of the updates and the ongoings and they did steal your you're allowed to steal my thunder anytime you want because you're the students and you're the priority but read aloud day uh coming up tomorrow we're super excited about it so thank you to all the volunteers that are going to be in
019our schools reading um allow to our kiddos um I will be in fifth grade if I'm not mistaken and reading uh rubbe Goldbergs I'm looking forward to that in Mrs D's class and maybe another classroom as well so looking forward to that so thank you again both um Emma and Dexter appreciate it all right other uh pieces of information that I wanted to share um uh under the superintendent's report there are a couple items number one are Tools for Schools um indoor air quality component is uh completed and all of those uh pieces of information all of those reports a great thanks to our school administration our school custodians uh for taking the time to work through our tools for school and also environed which helped uh train us to meet the statutory requirements for
020indoor air quality and hmac um those reports are all online they are under the Board of Education website per state statute so if there are any interests please please please make sure you look at those read them if you have any questions of course follow up with me or um one of the school admin uh for our indoor air quality updates I have to um give a huge shout out when environed came in and took uh samples of our air and looked for mold dust all sorts of particulates they found our schools to be extremely clean and they do a lot of work throughout the state of Connecticut they said they did not find any that were as clean uh indoor air quality and as pristine as ours so a huge kudos to our custodial
021crew that's really really really powerful um to know that they take extremely good care of our buildings so Kudos Kudos kudos to our staff um the component that is will be uh posted also on the website shortly is our HVAC um upgrade so we're just waiting on a couple reports uh from our um from our vendor from excuse me environed once those are uh available those will all be published on the website so just want to make sure that everyone is aware of that it's part of our statutory obligation as a board of education to enure the safety and um the indoor air quality and that our HVAC systems are up to date and doing exactly what they're supposed to be doing so that information like I said will be posted shortly um up next
022I just want to quickly transition to U Mr Jerm thank you so much for being here sir um and I did dust myself off when I fell bumped my head I'm good to go um but I do have a five-year uh Capital just I want to share with the Board of Education just so we know it is uh and I'll steal the words of Mr jerham it is a fluid document this document does not lock us into anything this is just what the future plans um would be let me just share one two three four copies to my left and then to my right this will help us obviously prepare for our capex within our within our budget uh season so all right everyone have a copy excellent um so first and foremost a tremendous
023thanks to Board of Education Board of Selectmen and board of Finance for supporting our school uh security grants you'll see that is not listed on our um Five-Year Plan anymore because we are rounding completion of that probably at the end of this school year and a little bit maybe into the next um some of the other items of priority that you'll see there um you'll see the uh Antolini floor which has been um plagued by moisture from a slab underneath and tiles are popping up our custodians are doing their absolute best to remediate by removing and gluing down new tiles but with moisture underneath it it's kind of a fighting losing battle so we'll be looking to remediate that floor that is not projected until next year you'll see on the uh The Five-Year Plan
024um outside of that um there are there we have a board of education Dodge Caravan right now that is falling apart it's rusting I have photos that I could certainly share we've had uh spark plugs and pistons and all sorts of issues with its engine it's coming to the end of its life that's another item that's more of a priority now than it is later so you'll see that in the requests for this upcoming 25 um sorry 26 school year budget uh outside of that you'll see five years out um we do have to start paying attention to our underground storage tanks um which will be coming to the end of their life they were installed in the Years 2000 and 2001 they are registered with the US and deep which do not make our
025jobs easy at all um however they do need to be repl placed um so we'll be looking at that and developing a plan going forward but that is about five years out so I just wanted to share the plan again fluid plan non-committal but you know outside of the short-term goals of next year um the others are more long range goals uh technology continues to be a refresh item that we're constantly looking at and making sure that our devices are all up to date uh students first and staff as well um so those are the main priority items if there are questions I'd be more than happy to field them or explain any additional pieces before moving that on to capex yes Kristen can you explain what the minivan is used for currently y absolutely
026so the minivan is currently used for as a mail Courier between all of our buildings also if we need to move equipment from building to building um so not just mail but sometimes when students transition from one of our lower elementaries to our upper elementaries and they have equipment that they need for whatever um their disability may be that's another thing that we use it for also when um if students were out placed and we need to um recuperate some of the equipment there they'll go out on site and retrieve it um also we do a great job if a shipping cost is too expensive and our guys can go out and get something when we're ordering things we're always looking to save money our guys will get in the van go and pick it
027up and bring it home so those are some of the uses for it you're welcome Jeff on the yes ma'am on the floor yes the people I put sorry okay sorry the green button go ahead the people that originally put in our floor are they responsible for any of whatever is happening to it now do we get money back from them are they going to help with the cost of replacing repairing fixing whatever excellent question so I researched that probably my second year in and unfortunately they did not they were not aware of the moisture the moisture problem didn't exist at that particular time so they are not they didn't void any of their warranties or any of that um but great question okay the um SE the I was gonna say septic tanks the
028oil tanks are they single wall or double single wall yeah are you able to because there's there single wall are you not able to extend their life expectancy like another correct 10 years yeah they've been extended as far as they can be and if you look at the regulations for deep they don't like I said they don't make it very easy to continue to extend that we have them inspected every single year we have water removed from them every single year um tightness testing um as we see fit when it's needed parts are constantly replaced on them as needed whether they're bolts that are corroded or things of that nature because they are underground but they are looked at every single year to ensure that they are not leaking causing an environmental ha environmental hazard
029um but they do get to the end of their life expectancy and we are responsible for the replacement of such and we have four we have two at anellini one at Big Bakerville and one at New Hartford Elementary School so it behooves us to start creating a plan uh working with the board of finance and the Board of Education to make that happen we're five years out it behooves us to start making a plan in terms of having those uh remediated and removed and replaced are there any grants that we could apply for that would help with the cost of replacing them yeah not that I'm aware of I've researched that on the usdp website and I have not found anything is there any way to do it I'm sorry Tom is there any way
030to do it with in conjunction with the ones that are being replaced at the Town Hall um no I think the life expectancy might be a little different Dan can certainly chime in because he's in our audience but thank you extension [Music] have okay thanks is Paul out there Paul can you just give a quick sweep see what's up thank you okay thank you you're welcome the tank estimate of $250,000 for four tanks one one right one one tank that could it could be any of the one tank out of the four one tank only can we think about appropriating some of that money in 2028 29 so we're not whacking that one year because right now I mean obviously this is a fluid document as you said MH but we got a lot less
031than Le two previous years we can move some of that money and set it to a nice 5% yield I like what you're thinking account and let it build sure I don't know yeah it's worth but I think we should think about moving that into yeah when we meet out our capex I think that's a valid point for sure for sure because some of those off years are a lot lower in capital costs it would make a ton of sense to do so yep that Paul oh fantastic thank you exact yeah thank you any other questions that I could engage the board with regarding our fiveyear Capital regarding the underground storage tanks going back to that when are the other tanks at their end of life between the years 20 20030 and 2031 so they
032were all either installed in 2000 or they were installed in 200 what's that if you had to do a six-year plan it would be all four tanks I do a sixe plan it' be all four tanks eventually yeah this is just the onset of one of the tanks that the three one tank needs to be replaced by 2030 the other three are by 2031 for example so that would be in the next year plan like that's what I'm asking like if we're looking one year past this we have three more tanks immediately after that just yeah wanted to confirm yeah but couldn't we start like Tom said like in 28 put some of that money set it aside we certainly can so we can build it up yep do we as a fluid document we
033certainly can do so and it's going to take communication and partnership with our Board of finances right for sure absolutely do we spend all of that 35,000 every year for new Chromebooks and whatever uh depending on the year um again fluid document those are just estimates but there could be a year where it's not for example Le if again as a fluid document we could postpone some of those costs if necessary yeah again as a fluid document we have that flexibility to do so yeah I don't want sendor spread this out over a couple Generations last fiberglass yeah dual wall y Al set with the five year all right uh moving on more updates more updates more updates um there is a 68 page Transportation request for proposals for our bus transportation bid that is
034out there we have several companies that have reached out to us um so spread the word or it's now public so want the uh the public to know about that that we are soliciting proposals for our transportation for all of our students um inclusive of datco and other companies that are interested so please um submit your proposals up next um let's see we could transition to talking about the New Hartford Elementary roof project um recently at one of our town meetings the um Town graciously supported and we had to read very specific language for a resolution at the state level um that the superintendent of schools can apply for accept or reject uh the grant which is a weird thing but it's the state it's how the state words it and that's the resolution that's
035what it is on Connecticut standard there's a form like 1045 I believe we had to read it verbatim so we had that meeting the town unanimously supported that next piece of the puzzle is informing the Board of Education the the roof at New Hartford Elementary the blueprints that we were able to to find in town hall looked like about 1984 I can't tell you for sure that that was the year that it was installed or not but the blueprints were there so it's approximately it meets the life expectancy and then some uh for a grant so it meets those requirements for that because of its life expectancy outside of a small portion of the roof which was added on as an addition um and we'll Venture that when we get to the the finalized project
036um but the board of education has to give the green like to then start the process of exploring it so there are numerous leaks um in the building this has been happening and ongoing for years um student work has been damaged in both hallways and in classrooms and in the library um technology has been damaged as well um because you just don't know when it leaks and you're moving things around and oh look there's another leak there so uh it's been in the hallways it's been in classrooms it's been in the staff Lounge uh so much so that it is starting to um really to face some of the concrete and the paint work that's in there um leaking down all the way throughout the building and even into the basement so things have been
037damaged um wanted to make the board aware of that at a second time this probably not my first time talking about it um and just wanting us to move forward with this project that would be the next step and then I will of course come back to the Board of Education with updates regarding specs engineering I'll be working with Dan to complete that um as a a mini construction committee or building committee if you will um Dan and I are going to be serving on that it doesn't have all the bells and whistles like we're picking different colors we're looking at a very simple roof replacement um so wanted to share that with the board and I could of course engage in any questions that the board may have regarding the roof replacement we're looking
038at about a 50% maybe 5052 depending on it changes every year um a reimbursement for the roof project so if it's an $800,000 roof $400,000 but we have to follow very specific requirements and guidelines 72 questions that are listed that we have to go through make sure that we follow everything to receive reimbursement for the project so that's that questions you need a motion to get this started yes please um I provided no okay I'll get something I can get it real quick it was in the email just as it I have the email up I can I can do a motion fantastic oh great I still have my microphone on I would like to move that we consider uh that we allow Jeff to begin the process of collecting information to submit to the
039state for an approximate 50% reimbursement of the roof project for new Harvard Elementary School I'll oh there we go sorry that again but a little bit SL we can send you the email lit just the for of the [Music] motion is there any discussion any questions any discussion on the motion when are you going to be doing this roof next summer the plan is for this summer oh okay do you have any contractors lined up for this nope got to follow very specific Rules by the state got to get motion at the town meeting got to get the motion at the board of ed then gotta there's so many steps that you have to follow very succinctly otherwise they disqualify you from a reimbursement so we're going to go step by step very slowly and
040I'll update the board as we go and where do you go next with this now that we gave you our permission so then Dan and I will me meet we'll convene and determine the next steps what's required what are the qualifications put out a request for proposals we need engineering those are kind of the next steps to come we want to do it very succinctly very specifically in alignment with what the state's requiring we do not want to disqualify ourselves from 50% reimbursement that's a lot of money and you don't need to go to the board of Finance for any of this we they already aware of that okay so yeah we're there already great questions well this is this is bonded right through the top the the board is going to take that up
041once they see what the quote is if it's 400,000 they may choose to just pay cash we have to pay 400 right no this is uh this is on the town side yeah it's not in your budget and we do still have some arpa money dedicated towards this project which will further reduce our cash that we had appropriated for the Jeff's not kidding you gotta go through any further questions seeing none all those in favor please signify by raising your hand that is unanimous all right moving on superintendent's report staff updates um as the board knows John pucho retired who we've hired in his stad is um staying within the family is Mark palut is now our new custodian at Bakerville Elementary School we're super proud to announce that and filling Mark's position in a
042domino effect is Frank Galler he's now the Antolini custodian here uh Bri Brian bajin is our new one of our new par Educators at anini and Jessica bck is also one of our new par Educators at new Harford Elementary School those conclude our staff updates quick update for K8 curriculum Council again just as a reminder to the board that is New Hartford heartland colbrook norfol region 7 and barstead working together um for a curriculum Council we had our second meeting and we have completed our bylaws those are completed we'll now be um working to determine what the next steps are going to be as a committee as we move forward we're scheduled currently to meet three to maybe four times a year depending on the need as we look at curriculums together um for alignment
043purposes throughout our region up next I have a community recognition piece that I received post sending out um of our board packets uh this was directed to Bakerville school um and it came from uh Shaban Kramer and Alicia Donovan from the Susan B Anthony project it reads dear Bakerville school thank you your support for Susan B Anthony's 2024 adoptive family program has made another successful year for our clients the generosity generosity that is shown year after year is such a testament to how wonderful our donors are this year we had over 177 donors that included families uh individuals and businesses from 56 towns in Connecticut as well as New York Massachusetts Virginia and Florida your thoughtfulness provided 420 individuals with hope during a season that is often stressful for those who have experienced trauma or
044are in transition these individuals included 38 single women four men 121 moms and 257 children who received these amazing gifts a brief list of the gifts received to fulfill very special wishes includes M Rachel dolls play kitchen play kitchens and accessories Barbies and Disney Princesses bedding Hot Wheels household items arts and crafts and tons of Legos here's just a couple of comments from our families this year a mom let us know that her son was looking forward to a specific video game uh gift for Christmas but knew his mom has just lost her job he told her he would be happy with any gifts that she could afford on Christmas morning when he opened the video game he cried his mom expressed how grateful she is to be part of this program and says thank
045you for making this possible another quote thank you all so much for the Christmas adoptive family program and the gift donations I love my candles bag and the gift cards they're all very much appreciated thank you for your kindness generosity generosity and huge Hearts I hope everyone had an amazing holiday and best wishes for a very Happy New Year and that's with gratitude again from Shaban Kramer and Alicia Donovan executive director and adoptive family coordinator so kudos to the Bakerville school um for their contributions and making a difference in people's lives it is noticed so thank you very much also in community recognition and I'm probably embarrassing like my admin because they didn't know I was going to do this today but um there are also various efforts at anini school um to support the
046families that were displaced this is not something that's publicly known but our wonderful Dr Carol as well as uh staff has been working very hard to help um behind the scenes to take care of families all the way across the United States so thank you for that also um in superintendent's updates we have a mini partnership going on with Northwest Regional 7 and their students interested in becoming teachers so Northwest region 7 offers a Yukon half credit course for juniors and seniors called if you love it teach it the course is about teach teaching learning and schooling in the US as well as the future of Education one of the components is a field experience in which the students observe in a K12 setting so both Mrs Kennedy and Dr Carol arrang that with our
047Northwest region seven students the purpose of the observations is to make connections to teaching Theory it's been great having potential future Educators reach out to visit us and we're very proud to partner with region 7 on that I want to make sure those are all of my updates give me one other quick moment yep I'm good that covers it those are the superintendent's updates take it away sir back to you okay thank you does anyone have any questions for superintendent sua based on the uh his report okay moving to the Board of Education chair's report um I have just one thing I wanted to mention today is as Dan said we are entering budget season um at our February 25th meeting the Target is for our superintendent to uh propose his budget to the board
048um so I'm asking that everyone please try to be here for the February 25th meeting um for the first presentation of the budget the plan this year is going to follow what we did last year I think it worked out well unless somebody has some other um ideas uh but to again funnel all those questions again I'll take that lead again funn them through me we'll we'll compile all the questions uh for our superintendent to be able to address those and then have a follow on meeting where uh he will then um give us the answers or give us more clarity on the on the budget line items any questions on that good uh moving on to routine business approval minutes from January 7 2025 would anyone like to make a motion for approval I
049make a motion that we approve the board minutes motion by Frank do have a second second by Eric thank you any discussion any comments questions um modifications or Corrections on those minutes all right seeing none all those in favor please signify by raising your hand i'm abstaining any opposed and one OB so we have 801 next item on the agenda is the expenditure report can we get a motion to approve the expenditure report I'll make a motion that we approve the expenditure report motion by Penny I get a second I'll second second by Tim thank you any discussion the one thing I was going to ask here was actually on the 2324 audit um and where we are with that but I think Dan said that that is a bit backed up March I think
050you said is when it's targeted when okay right they had reached out to us recently regarding our EFS which is the Connecticut state U method of um auditing for all of the public schools in the state of Connecticut and we have filed an extension so we're in compliance um so we'll just await those results yeah there was a question that came my way um in a conversation about the ups and downs within the expenditure report and again all of it settles out at the end of the year based on the fine budgeting and and finance degree you have to be able to manage all that um but it's good to see when we get these audits we find we can see where we landed the previous year because then we do have the um lapsing
051account um that we can then um fund or again A shortfall P money back out right okay any uh further questions on the expenditure report comments seeing none all those in favor please signify by raising your hand that is unanimous okay moving on to new business first item here under new business is Food Service discussion and possible action to survey School families sorry I have an old one discussion of possible action relative to Food Service again leaves it more open for discussion and potential action by the board um so with that I will leave it to anyone who would like to start the discussion on uh Food Service Jeff can you I guess I'll start um so I'm not exactly sure how you want to do this what's the process again we left the agenda
052item open again last meeting we had a report out from Ed Advance they came Becky came and explained their their their their offerings what's available um again we had some correspondence between last meeting and this meeting again that we wanted to have some further discussions about it potentially make some motions uh for the board to decide do we want to one again initially survey the community um or does the board want to um discuss making other actions um again I've heard uh through some correspondents about um limiting the food offerings that at Advance brings within our schools um similar to some of our neighboring towns have done where it's only healthy options um again limiting the um whatever they call that that menu where right menu right so again this conversation can go again it's
053on here to be able to allow it to go wherever the board wishes to go okay so my question to you is oh I'm on it's on I'm loud anyway um so how much perv like what is our do we have to be buying from certain vendors because the rest of the school districts we have power in buying from the specific place that we're purchasing from for snacks for example that that's currently my understanding so what is the place that we're purchasing from I don't know that specific answer Becky knows those more than I do we know the options that we're allowed to choose from so like do we know every sing like instead of Doritos do we have this choice this choice and this choice or do we just have to buy Doritos as
054it example she would have that answer specifically for you I know that there are options um but yes they're definitely contracted for Consortium and bulk but I don't know the specific of what other options are out there she would know that we could ask to provide all of those for us but I don't know what they are what other chip options are for example I I'll probably say they're not thing so all right so here's what I would like to see happen so first of all the stuff that we're getting is horrible has horrible ingredients we've already discussed that um I mean anyone in this room if they want to read the ingredients did everyone read the ingredients from the last time when she was here did everyone actually go through because there's a bunch
055of stuff that she didn't bring that we ended up we ended up going and looking and the ingredients are even worse than what she presented um so if if everybody's okay with feeding or I mean this is a bigger bigger issue across the country but the the food that we're feeding our children in schools is contributing to the problems many of the problems we have with our children in the schools to begin with so um either we eliminate those options or we find alternative options that are better ingredients to feed our children so that our children have better food um when they're in the school district and the time that they're with us it would be what I would say so I don't know what those options are I brought lots of options with me
056tonight that I that I buy if everybody would like to see them um these are readily available I'm G just pass these around these are just a couple examples um um if you look at the ingredients of all of these items you want me to pull mine to and she has a bunch too um these are healthy snacks that you could easily get at Costco that have like two ingredients in them as an example so I guess what I'm saying is is what do we have within our power to be able to purchase items that are healthier if we're GNA if we want to feed our kids snacks and if we don't have that option then I'd like to see those options elim ated and not given to them and we come up with something
057else that or or we just eliminate we don't we we don't offer it and we limit it like other districts do well and I also know like I I'm sure cost is going to come up but if all of these items are all theart anyway it cost you know I don't think it should be an issue at that point because if you don't want to pay for it then don't buy it don't let your kids purchase it with the extra cash that makes sense yeah I would agree with that that's sort of my position in terms of even taking any action on this is that none of the parents who send their children to the school districts are forced to engage with or purchase any food from the school district and they have their own
058means of home to select food and send it into school to some with the kids so I don't think any action is necessary from us at this time uh the board should be focused on policy that advances learning and achievement um and the science regarding minuscule amounts of some of these ingredients hitting kids and actually impacting behaviors is not fully like vetted um and I just think it's not appropriate for us right now I would prefer I would move that we table any action regarding um all theart menus or hot lunch items within the school all right I will say this as being in on this board the longest of all of you and the oldest I mean it's not my job to say to you or to any of you that your child not
059have Oreos if they want them or Doritos it's your job as a parent not to give them that extra money to come into school to buy these aloc cart items if we were to all of a sudden decide that we don't like what Advance is doing we could also lose funding from the government or from the state whoever is helping us pay for that food so I mean it's I agree with Kristen I mean there's other things that we should be worrying about like their education helping them with that and not with you can't have Doritos or if you're going to have a special snack then send it in with your child don't don't put it on this board that you're going to tell them that they can't buy anything don't give them the money
060so what if they scream and yell at you and say that you're a bad bad parent they will get over it they will live without having Doritos corn FL Corn Flakes corn chips whatever and Oreos well I I so there are lots of scientific data and studies that suggest that the food that you feed your children does affect their performance in schools so I do think it is an important topic um so why are we offering it why can't we offer something alternative why are we offering it why do we feed them ice cream and Doritos I'm just I'm just ask think it's the purview of the board for us to discuss the like day-to-day operations of the school it's just our job to set policy and focus on learning and achievement so it sounds
061like we've outsourced this to Ed Advance we've sent a contract with them if we want to revisit the Ed Advance contract when it's up for Renewal we can do that and see if there are other providers who meet stronger criteria but it just doesn't seem like something we need to worry about right now but also per Ed Advance it's up to the individual schools as which which is what she had said last time as well so other schools are also not offering these allart items five days a week as new Harford is which I think is excessive CHF is are there any policies in related to F Food Service in our list of policies I haven't looked well because we um at Advance is our sponsor that means they run all operations relative to Food
062Service um if we and that because of that we participate in the nslp national school lunch program that's how we get reimbursement for funds that's how they uh pay their employees at a net loss I mean there's just you get don't get a a full reimbursement for every meal sold for example um there are other companies that provide the same but they're going to be sourcing the food from the same thing until federal government changes a lot of their regulations um I came prepared tonight with a letter that I'd be more than happy to share with the board that I'd be more than happy to send on our behalf to the US Senate um and all of our Representatives across the state of Connecticut encouraging them to push the government to change some of these
063regulations because of some of the uh chemicals gloss fight pesticide other things that are in these Foods because they really have that perview of what is being offered to um our children under this program if the board opted not to have a sponsor with Ed Advance we would have to pay for every single thing that would be another additional net loss every year for us we'd have to pay for a manager a food director um we'd have to have someone managing all of the foods coming in checking every single thing um if that was the board's desire that is not something that we would be engaging as for a profit so there's a lot of pieces to this and I'm concerned that other families that can't afford food now we're going to take that away
064because if we go another Avenue outside of having a food sponsor what are we doing for families that are on free and reduced lunch we have to provide that for them and right now there is no mechanism for us because we don't operate independently there's so many different layers to this um if we wanted to have them provide other additional foods that they could Alternatives we we'd have to ask them for that because I really don't know what those alternatives are I would lie to you and tell you I'm a nutritionist and a specialist in this area I am absolutely not um to answer that question Tom in a long in a long-winded fashiony we have a policy that yeah we have a policy that states that we provide meals to our children and we
065do so under the nslp guidance and guidelines because we participate with that advance in that that is our policy currently right now so to say that it's not you isn't exactly correct also to your point this this is a national issue that is much more it it starts there much more involved than us to saying here we're going to change I understand exactly what we're what's over there in that table is what my wife does the same thing so but to do that at this point would be a major overhaul of our current structure structure and to some was po about parents who are involved with uh free or reduced launches that would that would fall on it would fall on us y I have a question for you the snack Bringers you're talking about
066the snacks right you're not talking about the meals right now I know the hot lunch part is a is a huge major issue I don't think we can you're focusing on hocart snacks to start yes do you really want us to get started on the actual ingredients you probably don't one so we're not talking about lunch we're talking about these snacks well we're actually talking about all of it but that's such a major national issue and there's no way like that that's just a bigger issue so what we're trying to say is let's start a little bit smaller can we can we introduce something a little bit healthier as an option the my thought was when I saw the original proposal for today it might not be a bad place to start with a survey
067of parents to see what they think so that we're not representing a few voices but has that been done uh where parents comment on lunch no I outside Saye public comment on specific at Advanced food policy in the classroom no and that was my recommendation two meetings ago and even a meeting ago would be surve a good place to start so we're not just speaking for ourselves but we hear what the public thinks about it so if we do a survey I'd like the ingredients from all of the snack items sent home with the survey so I'd like the parents to have the survey if you if we want to do a survey and I'd like the parents to have the food labels for the items that we're talking about sent with the survey so
068that they're educated on what's being served to their children or given as options to their children do you expect that to be in like a mailer because that's going to be expensive for us to actually send out a physical mailer that has all of that paper in it to all of the school parents you can send the survey through email and you can also send the food label items in the survey links yeah just send the links that's all you have to do it's very simple I can help you with that Jee if you need help what you blessed I have a thought on the survey too you could ask a few options like this is just me I'm only speaking for myself here but I've always been a big fan of maybe the Friday
069you know Pizza Fridays and that kind of stuff where Friday they could have that stuff some of the schools that we heard from that she gave examples from do something like that right ice cream on Fridays yeah there were it varies yeah you could put that as one of the options should it be every day never Fridays put those kind of questions on there we could all look at the survey and refine it we uh yeah we're going to need a Let it it would be right and it should be on the community um one question I have you know as we as we talk with at Advance so at Advance is our food service provider but we give them right currently they take full Liberties in what they're providing to our school our Administration
070doesn't get involved with that um well I would say that admin I would say student voice we're surveying students right now to have like student centered meals I know that's going on with one of our managers Brandy she does a phenomenal job she procures local produce um so just some of the information I sent along in the email they are encouraged to do that and they do and kids had food tastings and parents were made aware of that and feedback from the kids was they loved it they loved some of the carrots they tasted like candy for example they had like rainbow assortment of C of locally um hydroponically grown lettuce and micro greens so there are a lot of other healthy options are we doing a good job promoting that probably not and I'll
071take responsibility for that but I'm not also the food nutrition services but I am the superintendent the buck stops with me I need to do a better job of illustrating that to our community and I could certainly do that um but it's one of the many options right but I'm a big proponent of choice and deciding for yourself what you'd like to ingest um but I also understand the board's concern and wanting to get ingredients out there that's going to take time for Ed advance to do no problem we direct them to do so um but we would have to have specific language and what em motion would be that we want to execute for me to go forward and then and make sure it happens for the board okay that's kind of where I'm
072I'm at right now so we do have some input on there [Music] obviously any other comments right I again in my in my opinion I am on the side of of it's not our role to restrict food offerings to Community without Community ort um I think that the survey is a good idea I think that that survey should start with the community outreach subcommittee um they should come up with a survey the questions that we feel um are are pertinent to this conversation um every anybody on the board is welcome to join that meeting um and and participate as a board member um sorry I'm sorry y I'm sorry y get feedback elicited but not everybody come to the meeting we have yeah trouble yeah exactly um send feedback to send feedback but the public
073can go yes public can go Y and also get information from the uh principes and school administrators because they they're here every day at lunch he their input on the survey but don't forget too any food that at Advance feeds our children they're Bound by certain guidelines as to what they can feed them so they're not feeding them bad foods it's what they are allowed to do as a vendor to us granted the cookies and the and the chips are not the greatest thing in the world to eat but I again I don't think it's our job to S to say to a parent please don't send money in with your child we're not offering these anymore it'd be like the board saying on Fridays you will wear khakis and button- down shirts everyone we're
074not doing that I I don't think we're asking to do that that's not what we're asking we're asking not to you're we're we're asking to provide alternative Solutions but you're asking to to Doritos and drumsticks and ice cream that are in the school systems we're not asking to tell parents you can't do that I'm simply asking the question what is our choices as far as providing alternate healthy ingredient snacks to our children so that we are feeding them the best food possible so that they can be the best they can be in the classroom we're giving them vegetables we're giving them fruit it's their choice if they don't want to eat it it's not our choice it's how you raise your child if you raise your child to like apples and grapes and peaches and
075pears and celery and carrot sticks it's fine but if you just have a bunch of junk food around it's I mean it's not fun really but it's not our job to tell them what to do and what since I'm on the community outreach committee I would like to I want to be directed this go go figure this out because this is not going to get figured out so my question before we even do that is a what's our what is our what are our options from Ed Advance right so if Ed Advance doesn't offer any of those items over there how does that even why would we survey the community and ask them hey would you prefer uh the orange chips over here or the Doritos but they say yeah we want those orange chips
076well okay so now what we walk by at Costco every weekend no so what do we what do we have for you in options coming out of that Advance if that's where we're going to get our food right so she gave us so it's either you offer what's at Advance has to offer or you don't offer it it's not like no at Advance I want you to offer that that's not probably not even an option so why ask the public if that's what they prefer that's not even the question that should be on the survey correct in my opinion right corre so the question is do you want to offer I I would love to offer that stuff but I don't think it's available to us right so are we going to ask them would
077you prefer not to offer any offerings or the Franks would just like to offer on Fridays only are you okay so that's we can't ask them do you like what we're offering because if you don't like what you're offering don't don't give your kid the food maybe but as far start providing them the information of what we are offering that might be something that's worth putting out there not asking the question would you I mean and here here's what here's what our here's what our school currently offers Monday through Friday this is the ingredients in those offerings do you do you agree to offer those once a week twice a week three times a week four times a week five times a week not at all that's your survey comes back everyone says offered every
078day but only go the own I mean again I don't think we have any ability to change what we offer only how often we offer it am I mistaken in that because I don't want to go have a subcommittee meeting and spend six hours and try to figure out what would be show those to shoot out there to the public that's but you're talking just allive card right yeah we are we are talking S car and I think again I think the survey is that question but also again if you if you go back to what was provided by Becky at our last meeting on that menu are some healthy options right some offer water they have fruit they have milk they have yogurt right so again like I think it's Canton might be one
079of them that only offers a certain number of things five days a week and only offers the Doritos and ice cream on a Friday right so off everything all right there was there was one one of those schools in that that Becky have provided but you know if we want to create a survey it has to start somewhere right and it can't be a nine-person board creating a survey so unless we have another idea of where that survey is going to be created if we want to create a task force to create that I don't mind creating a survey through through this this current subcommittee I just want some I want this current board to understand that I forget M on that board can we maybe as a start find out what our options are
080first right so like if we have a a list that ated Advance gets to pick from what's on the list I I think that I mean again we we can get that list from at Advance right we could say what do you what not what do you offer in new Harford right now what do you have as all of your offering what's in the co-op we're allowed to from and we use that as a starting point and then from there then we can and then in my mind I'd like to you know send something to the parents at least educating them on what is being served something so so I I again I I'll I'll I'll say let's take back doing it through the community outreach Comm subcommittee let's create a task force right we
081can do that and have a meeting as long as it's not Quorum of a subset of members of this group so but we have the why can't we just do why can't the three of us just do it because I think we want the input of those who are on this side of the table who are discussing I see so my opinion and my participation on the committee in relation to doing this is not valid you can you can I don't think that you could be on the task force I don't think that I don't think that's that's not what we're saying at all that's not what we're saying at all so this doesn't need to be a contentious conversation okay it's not a contentious conversation we're just trying to figure out what our options
082are and know nothing went home to the parents about what the food labels are nothing went home to the parents and I I mean I've read the menus every day and you know the breakfast option is cereal okay what cereal you know I've heard from parents it's you know Cocoa Puffs or whatever you know just a little more information for all the parents to see I think would be greatly helpful you know like I want to know like you know what are the ingredients in whatever the pizza on Friday like there's no information whatever anywhere onites or anywhere that I have access to unless I ask but there asking again about non allart menu items everything but we're only disc discussing olart and I'm and that's fine but I'm also saying in general it I
083think it'd be nice to have ingredient lists on everything that's being offered it's just informing it's informing parents I know for them to make decision different things that we're discussing let's worry about the other Foods how about ingredient lists ingredient lists on the allart items because those are not available either okay I think there would be value in doing a survey like this because with a family it'll lead to discussions maybe a little reflection on what their kids are eating have a conversation that they really haven't thought about a survey or when the survey goes out just having that survey and filling it out could lead to a discussion it could lead to you know that's probably a good thing how about if we just have a survey that goes out to parents and say
084would you like the allart menus to continue they include Doritos ice cream whatever it is that they offer allart yes or no and leave it at that and if you want list the ingredients that are in the art menu art items it's got to it's got to start with at Advance we've got to we've got to speak to them we've got as say we got find out what our what our options are and what they're what they're able to do and then that's how we can make the change we have to meet we may not be able to make change right we don't know anything until we find out what is available at at Advance for the Consortium and what is what what we can purchase if there's any if there's any leeway with what
085we can purchase they probably don't have any anything remotely listed up here would be my guess they're going to suggest instead of lays they're going to sus faked lays so there I'm not sure any anyone will be happy with that right alternative exactly they they likely do not have healthy food options but we don't know so let's find why don't we use that as the first step we find that out just doesn't feel like the venue changing what Advance available to offer particularly when we as aard we have a lot of work Ahad of it's information gathering at this point it's information gathering at this point information we have the information the ingredients available here at at Advance they came and with presentation they ingredients to the meeting and we all we sat it on
086paper and all of that stuff was publicly available through our feed that is live it's part of some of that information I thought was available to meeting abely the but the information that we have has been made publicly available through our regular Communications Chann I think from what I remember on the on the presentation I'm just going to use a number there was maybe 10 items that are actually offered through at Advance and we offer five of them just using numbers I don't think we offer every item that at Advance does offer under alak cart menu again I could be wrong so I think what we could do just to start the ball rolling and not put a big load on on superintendent Susa is to ask at Advance to provide us with all of
087your allart options with the ingredient list it's a simple it's a simple PLL provide that to to Jeff and it could be we can use that as a starting point for this Outreach subcommittee to have that information and we can decide as a subcommittee how do we present this information to the town and a simple either Friday folder or email whatever is simpler and Le and not expensive and that and along along with us if we're going to do a survey you know here's what's offered you know are we offer would you prefer this offered on one day a week two days a week all week whatever and it's they have it we it's all there it it could prompt the discussion when people do see these items so it doesn't we're not doing anything
088we're not making decisions we're saying here's what's offered to your children at school just so you know do you agree that we're offering it five days a week would you say No it should be offered one day a week only then it's out there and they could they can make their opinion on it and it's simple it doesn't cost us a whole lot of time or money yeah I personally think we're kind of complicating this a lot right now I think the easiest thing would be to to me anyways in my opinion would be just to offer it one day a week just on Fridays same snacks is fine if you want to give your children different snacks the rest of the week give them something else to bring with them that would be uh
089a little bit easier so we don't need any motions to collect information to ask our superintendent to collect information does anybody have any motions that they'd like to put on on the floor or do we want to wait for the information think we should wait for the information okay I do think this is an important topic I don't think it's a waste of time I think it has every relevance to our children learning in schools just as important as the budget just as important as anything else that we discuss here so I don't think it's a waste of time it's not a political issue it's not a personal issue I personally never let my kid touch any of the food in the school systems but I but a choice no one no one I thought
090I was talking I apologize for so again this is an important topic it should be an important topic to every single person in this room who cares about the children and why are we're all going through this I mean we all don't this is we're not getting paid to be board members we are doing a volunteer job because we all have one issue that we care about which is children and their education the food that we feed our children does affect their education it does do you want me to bring in all the scientific studies that suggest that I can certainly do that the food we feed our children affects their learning it affects their time in school and there's just a whole bunch of other ramifications I'm not saying pull the food I'm not
091saying make the choice for parents I'm saying can we look at what we're offering or limit what we're offering or provide other options that are healthier that's all I'm saying that's all I'm asking for it doesn't need to be a contentious topic we don't we all we don't need to get upset about it but it should be something that is important to every single person in this room just like the security of our children just like the learning of our children it should be important what we're feeding them all I'm asking is let's not feed them stuff that's not healthy and if we can find another alternative option let wouldn't we want that for our children if we had healthier options wouldn't we want to provide that for our children so all I'm asking the
092solution is right here if you read Jeff's letter to the Senators and Congress um this is how it get started so this is a good start right here this might be all we need to do right now so thank you for going there that's I was going to go next would anyone like to make a motion to ask our superintendent to send this letter to our uh Representatives I'll make a motion for him to send it thank you for doing it very well and I second a motion by dear Dre second by Eric anybody have any questions comments all those in favor please signify by raising your hand all those opposed any extensions motion passes 810 um so before we leave this topic Jeff um can you inform the board or tell the board again
093we had a couple individuals talk about the use of Ed advance for classroom parties and for classrooms is that um is that something mandated by our Administration so it's um more than a quick uh response um and it has different layers so we are very conscious of students their allergies and that's the primary driver we are there's some mandates components to it with a wellness committee that we have to establish and review every three years to ensure that we're doing the absolute best to educate our students about the food that they're ingesting and also to educate our parents about that as well so that's a component of it that's the Mandate that's behind it we have to complete a um uh assessment inventory called the wellstat and Mike is leading that effort uh with a
094stakeholder group um so those are the review practices that take place all of the time um in terms of having at Advance involved that's the primary driver was again to Evol um eliminate or to be more uh considered of the allergens that are in foods and that impact Kids versus foods that come in and again um have to be checked and verified against a an allergen list so there's many reasons why uh We've contracted with that advance to provide those Foods um and that is again a decision made by our Wellness committee um in conjunction with um our Educators our administrators and our district as a whole again just considering the number one priority is the safety and well-being of our kids I have a question when did we start having Ed Advance come in
095and run the parties in the classroom for holidays and whatever and we this year this year because in previous years when my grandchildren went to school here it was the room parents that did the parties like one of the ladies said all the food has to come in through the nurse she checks everything before it goes into the classroom the room parents knew exactly which child had an allergy so you did not the room parents then would contact the other moms or whoever's in charge of the children and say please do not provide chocolate because we have someone that's allergic to chocolate or to milk or whatever but we never when my grandchildren were here which was just a few short years ago we never had some Outside Agency bringing the food into school costing
096our parents money it was the parents of the children that provided all the food and there was never an issue and that way is there's not this monetary burden put on parents some parents can't afford to send in money with their child for a party and then that makes them feel bad I really think we should go back to the way we used to do it and let the the the moms or dads who are in charge as room parents know which child or just say you don't have to maybe if you don't want to say the child's name just say there is a young child that has a milk allergy or a chocolate allergy so please do not provide those items I understand your point um my job as superintendent is to protect the
097board from liabilities and when foods are coming in and I can't tell or know because I'm not there looking at all the food ingredients and something gets ingested by a child and we have an issue then it's my job to protect us from that but it is the nurs responsibility when the food comes into school to look at them I'm sorry I didn't mean to interrupt it wasn't finished I'm sorry that's all right I lost my track my train of thought please go ahead I'm done okay Jeff was the reason the Outside Agency can you help me understand that the we we started providing food for the parties through Ed Advance because of liability issues that's one for sure with other schools in the dist like other districts do the same thing I can tell
098you other districts don't even let Foods in the buildings because it's so restricted completely we don't even do food that's previous districts that I've been in it's not even permitted there's no food in the classrooms when we're celebrating we're doing it with other means whether it's whether it's whether it's games board games whether it's books you bring in any of that that's but why are we having party like why do we need to I'm not again please don't yell at me don't get contentious again in this conversation I'm just asking the question why are we having parties with does it have to have parties with food and other stuff or can we have another type of party where there's no food involved we could certainly have other types of food where there's I mean other
099types of parties where there's no food involved I think it's rooted in Tradition well that's what that's that was what I was gonna ask you that's simply what I believe so we've had parties where food is involved in the past so we're just going to keep doing the same thing because it's roed in Tradition that's that that's of where we're at right now that's my understanding something I as a teacher I I've noticed as parents are getting less involved we quit doing our silent auction in our school because we could not get enough parents to participate and when you move to Ed Advance these these things are great because they get talk about community outreach they get the community involved it's fun for kids and when you Outsource it like that you lose that start
100to lose that connection of people coming into the school it's it's important for community outreach Jeff have we ever had a situation where there's been some issue with the parents bringing in food um I or you're just trying to protect against I'm trying to protect against that yeah that's my main my main job I could tell you in other districts that I've been in absolutely there's been issues ISU absolutely because you don't know all the ingredients of every single thing and the parents with good intentions right not with bad intentions are bringing in a food that maybe wasn't checked and now we have an issue in the classroom and then it's a lawsuit it's a liability um again from previous districts that I've been in that's just been eliminated completely I think this is just
101something that's stowed away in Tradition and we don't want to be the fun sucker outers of every opportunity in the elementary level I get it but there's serious considerations to take um when thinking about food in the classrooms I think the uh again I agree right I agree that we need to we need to protect ourselves right we don't want somebody to to to receive Food because we don't know ingredients I think that the the other side of it of the cost needs to be considered right so if we have students that are in a room that can't pay for that food because of their own means that's unfair to them so I think we need to rethink how we handle those situations at a minimum for children who don't have parents who can that
102like do we have like non food or like other party AR that Jeff I'm sorry who's paying again who is hang hang on hang on please question was just asked yes keelly go ahead you don't allow for birthday cach like birthday B oral this are just like classroom parties that are likee yeah four a year currently for our for we have four current celebrations for the course of the Year under our policy and what are the part what are the part like uh what so what is it again and how much is it a year U I don't know the cost for advance I don't know that's well no say just I'm a room I'm a room parent as well and so yeah there's like what four celebrations I paid $36 last week I wrote
103a check um for ice cream and it killed me but anyway you know you know I and I'm not asking to be reimbursed of that but um the other room parent she'll do a list like oh if somebody wants to you know bring in plates or you know this for the craft or whatever so it is try you know a combined effort but you know some parents will give more money you know for others who can't or whatnot so it is there's never been an issue as far as that's concerned but I can see where becomes one with money so it sounds to me that money is not just a food problem corre Advance like parents are outl money for for classroom celebrations at Advance is offerings are more expensive than the parents have if
104they needs to be a food element they're the only option is that fair like we don't have to have food but if we have food has to be through Ed advance and because Ed Advance offerings are more expensive it's costing the parents more money on top of stuff people are already outlaying for other party supplies right that's right parents and parents used to be allowed to make things they used to be allow to make used to we can't I'm sorry sorry we can't oh sorry yeah Jeff are are they asking what for these parties are they asking the parents to send in money to help yes so like something goes home and says we need five bucks from each parent to pay for this party is that what I'm is that what is that what's
105happening yes and then the cost is is unfairly being distributed on room parents who are always contributing because they're part of it and they have to pay more money than they had to last year because of Ed advances food offer then we have to reach out to other parents like hey can you give money for this and and then me I'm just like I'll just I'll just pay it I don't want to you know keep asking because again you keep asking for money often the last often they'll last for $3 per kid or something like that and then maybe like you were saying 75% of them will turn in the $3 and then 25% they won't right is this just quick question is this a board Pol is this a board decision to to stop
106doing that is it or was this an advanced decision or was this contractual that will come from our wellness policy committee um for recommendations for the board and that's and that's why it changed this past year okay so the 25% that can't pay who picks up that what they're saying the room parents do but what happens if the room parent doesn't pick it up that that happens whether or not we have a contract of that advance or not you know I'm also a room parent and poting up money and I don't have it advance in my district but then we pay for other people that happens all the time where I'm begging people hey money for the teacher's gift I don't get all of it back I get it it's not a risk I take
107it's just something that I signed up to do and I just do it outside of whether we have this policy with that advance or this contract with that advance or not across the board that happens end of your gift you know or a teacher going out on maternity and we want to buy them a nice gift because they're having a baby it happens we're we're collecting money people give what they can if they can't they shouldn't feel badly about it it just is what it is we're asking and if we don't then someone else contributes or not and then we just use what we have um but that happens despite no matter what but we're not making the other parents who can't afford it feel bad no we can't we're just just you can't contribute
108some of them don't even know because they're not even on the list to be contacted to ask for money yeah yep so but again who picks up the deficit of the money that's not being the parents but it's an ancillary activity person that's what she saying the person that so if you're the room parent you're that room parent could get stuck with a lot of the extra costs that are associated with it not re right but that's not right we shouldn't be putting it on the room parents because say I can't afford to send in five books to have my child have ice cream at the Christmas party or whatever I don't think it's the room parents job then any more than it is this board's budget to cover it well if it's not the
109room parents and it's not the board's budget like there's not really like there isn't any accountability right this is something that room parents in the PTO are trying to do as a nice thing for the classrooms so when you try to do nice things somebody has to deal with it but there's not really much the only thing that we as the board can do to even help with this is basically give a yay or nay in terms of at Advance being the only vendor for this which would eliminate some ancillary cost for food at the party because the advanced food is expensive but it doesn't eliminate the burden of either the like the parents having to pay for it well then you'd have to go try to find another vendor for like four parties I'll
110just I'll just give on behalf of my company to pay for the four parties this is kind of crazy so I guess to all the room parents throughout our district have we communicated the wellness policy to them and the reason why we use that advance and we no longer can solicit donations in a formal letter or wording or anything like that not outside of the website um and maybe Friday folder to some degree that's where we've communicated that out already so people know about it can we do that again to all the roar sure I will ask our administrative staff to make sure we send that out can we just like make donations can we just make a donation to PTA and that would be separate set aside specifically for the four parties for the
111PTA to use so that the parents do not have to the cost can we just can we do can we do that as long as it follows our policy for receiving gifts we can't receive gifts for specific purposes by donors P can receive a gift can't they P um I know that the Board of Education can pto's got maybe got different bylaws I don't know all of their bylaws to be honest but the board of education has very specific policies in receiving gifts with specific purposes in mind I think the bigger ask from the parents and I apologize if them stepping out is that they would just like us to amend the Ed Advance contract so that they're not the only vendors that's allowed to bring food in into the classroom that's the real only
112remedy they're asking for regardless of who's paying for it regardless of what's going on it sounds to me that that is like the very specific as that was within the board's control when we renegotiate the Ed Advance contract is that is that what we're asking that's what I have for my notes is to we were asked to um explore U the cost and to see if we could renegotiate that that's one of my notes that I wrote down cost of remove the like it sounds like what is new to the contract is that they're the only ones allowed to do it this year so regardless of what their cost is the issue is that parents cannot bring in other food so if we amend the contract to say you can still provide food people can
113get it for you and pay whatever $500 per cupcake that it is but the parents have the other option to bring in other food regardless of who's paying for it and I think the the payment piece and I really appreciate and bu will be one of those parents writing checks to bring food into classrooms like next year I can't wait for it but like the fact that parents are paying the money is not what really the issue is the issue is they don't have any other options on where they're putting their money does that seem like a good summary to everybody in terms of what's going on and again what is actionable for us which again actionable for us it sounds like to me is amending the Ed Advance contract so that they're not the
114exclusive provider of food for classroom parties I would prefer prer to see them go back to the way it used to be and have room parents do it it is the nurse's responsibility when the food comes into the school to check everything out and and split the burden of the parties amongst all the parents and not be paying this money to a vendor because they must have some I'm sure there's some hidden costs in there someplace and they're not just paying dollar for dollar well yeah but like if we take it out that they're the exclusive vendor then parents can still opt to use Ed Advance if they want but other people like don't have to but it would essentially be allowing people to bring food back into the classroom the way that they were
115which is what you're asking for do we negotiate with Ed Advance every year um we do we do so regarding this particular thing we certainly can so we can take this up in negotiation then um we certainly I'm gonna put in a request to meet with Becky okay um so again summary on Food Service one superintendent sus is going to reach out to Becky get a full list of the offerings that they have for the alment and ingredients and ingredients um second thing is the letter to the representatives superintendent Susa will go ahead and and send that in based on the the motion and the approval and then the third thing is superintendent Seuss is going to reach out to Becky regarding um the classroom parties and um looking at a cost there to be
116able to adjust on that that capture everything for now okay I don't think that asked Tock ISM on the cost of the parties I think it's also like do we have to have that part of the contract well it is right now so we can't right okay maybe that helps subsidize the lunches we got to talk to that advance okay moving on uh we have some first reads of three policies for today um starting with policy 9274 bylaws of the board PNY are you R for this sure all right and justff gonna help oh sorry I don't talk loud enough all right bylaws bylaws of the board 9274 board member code of conduct first read I hope you all have read this does anyone have any questions I mean they gave you a sample bylaw
117to consider at the end and I believe this is what we're following right Jeff correct um so purpose and intent is this to be uh to have board members understand um their roles to be more effective in governance champions of Education primarily and to inform public elected officials of this important role but also inform the public hey if you want to be part of the board of of Education these are some of the very important pieces that we follow uh regarding code of conduct it also consolidates all of the pieces it was all over um in our policies this brings it all into one place so the only change that I saw quickly was on Page 9274 in parentheses B it says maintain a priority was changed to PRI prioritize and maintain board focus on
118increasing on increasing student learning and then the rest of it so we we have a second read next meeting the next one is before you get off what's with all the references to New Jersey I don't this is this came from so that's background just for um the subcommittee and the board just to understand just some other language that is out there okay and who and this came from cab yes correct pages one through I pages one through four from cab yes as background information for consideration of the subcommittee as they working to um tailor it to the needs of our Board of Education here in newart how does this Dove tayor what our current policies are regarding board member Behavior you know they saw there's you know censuring yep it just brings it into
119one um codified policy versus it being all over the place currently in our bylaws um a lot of it is similar just some of the language may have changed um over the years in terms of what's been given as feedback uh to C that they then consider they put through their policy committee and then present it to boards for consideration it's going to substitute four other law policies that we have in our c that it's going to get rid of some it would supplant yeah board governance the roles board code of conduct superintendent relations admin of policy and then any sanctions if necessary so pulls them all together versus being all over the place in current okay yes all right the next one is policy 9273 bylaws of the board conflict of interests it goes
120along with the previous one we added new Harford So This spells Sal new Harford Board of Education on the third page again this all came from Cape even though some of the sources are all over the place major drive here if I could just add would be that we put the hole before the self um when we're meeting together and how we're operating and conducting uh business any questions the third one is policy 61 63.3 instruction live animals in the classroom um on the first page we omitted that a miniature horse is not a service animal so some people would think that they are along with peacocks and whatever else snakes um have have been removed yes this really is just refers to four-legged dogs on page three we added in the director of special
121education or design shall respond to that request for bringing in um a service animal does anybody have any if you look on I'm sorry if you look on R 6163 32A it specifies specifies what a service animal is it is a dog right so all kidding aside uh relative to other animals it is um very important that the board of education has upon request a mechanism to vet and understand the need this is not just a pet in the classroom um this is a procedure that we will follow again liability wise we want to make sure that we have appropriate trained dogs that would come into the building to provide a number of services if you look on 61 6332 not just a guide dog or seeing ey dog this is to illuminate the many
122possibilities that we have a dog in the school hearing or signal dog psychiatric service dog um sensory signal dogs or social signal dog seizure dog um there's a lot um that our dogs are the dogs are trained for to help support students that would need the benefit of having such um in the classroom setting there's also a lot of requirements regarding vaccination in addition to the training um also handling and also response to that our Administration needs to be able to have if the dog is causing fear or other things to our other children in the classroom we are very sensitive to that as well this policy is Laden with very specific instruction of how to handle all of those pieces previous to this we did not have this in the board and I have
123to give um a great amount of kudos to our chairman who brought this up for my attention through his constituents and working with other board chairs as well that's where this um came to light we didn't have such uh in place again to service our students that would have the need has this ever happened in my tenure no in my tenure no I've worked in other districts absolutely that we've had therapy dogs in the school um and again with Advanced Training advanced notice to parents to students in terms of how to respond and then what students that are that have fear of animals or anxiety regarding animals and how do we um properly Implement such a plan so that we're not causing um undo stress for another child that has fears of or dog of
124dogs as well Frank to answer your question three or four Librarians ago um at Bakerville school she brought in of her son's service dog because her son was autistic so a couple of times he would come in along with his service animal into the into the library down there and the dog would sit very quietly and the kids just loved him the dog not the child child I'm sure both I'm sure both he was a teenager he was the same size as them okay it was a golden retriever all sorry okay let's uh old business let's move on Old business thank you Penny thank you for the comic relief we need something we have some second reads of uh four policies for today so we went through these at the last meeting uh Penny will
125run us through them quickly here and we need motions in seconds for adoption all right so the first one is p1327 relations with youth organizations we've all had this to read now for two meetings is there any questions or changes that you'd like to make get a motion to approve motion to approve motion by dear I get a second second by Frank yes all those in favor please signify by raising your hand that is unanimous the next one is policy 4222 par Educators tile one par Educators take a motion to approve take a motion to approve it second motion by dear second by Tim any discussion all those in favor unanimous the third one is policy and regulations 5131 81 electronic devices motion to approve motion by Penny second any discussion seeing none pleas signify
126by raising your hand and that is unanimous the last one is bylaw 9030 commitment to democratic principles in relation to community comma staff comma students motion to approve so moved motion by Penny do have a second I have a second second by dear any discussion questions seeing none all those in favor that is unanimous okay thank you Penny moving right along um on to item number I reports first item here is report for at Advance deer January yeah I the biggest thing is that all of thetive how many people they servicing with their food programs you had shared with us the January report this is just the minutes from uh January did we issue that to the rest of the board that did go out I got the minutes no the report if not we
127could resend it I know you sent it to Jeff and I just don't know if we issued it to the rest of the board I'll find out so there is a there's a January report that at Advance um produces dear G had forwarded on to superintendent sus I apologize for not foring it but we'll get that out to you um there was pretty much anything else they just were on this they were reporting that January minimum minimum W not up and any questions for dear je you have that right yeah I'll make sure that it's sent out to everyone else and included in the in the board packet and then logged in at the town hall or town cler office okay second item under reports is community outreach subcommittee who's taking that um we met
128we met in January on January 21st um myself Penny Kristen and Jeff uh we discussed the history of the subcommittee and its purpose so that U everyone who uh everyone understood what we were there for um I know Jeff I think this went to everyone this the summary of we discussed um you know the need to not operate in a vacuum which is why the subcommittee was formed um and we uh the in the subcommittee first met years ago we you know we we just tried to figure out how we can get uh more people at our meetings more people engaged with what we do so we don't operate in a vacuum we do our you know our self- evaluations we sit here and Pat ourselves in the back without any Community input so and
129and what's come from that um mostly due to mostly due to our remote meetings we held over the last three or four years due to the response to the covid we uh had YouTube uh views available to everyone now so Jeff provided the average of 60 or 61 people average uh watch uh viewing our meetings or viewing them later right these are these are total views not live views so that's that's actually you know obviously more than the zero we have here now which is good say 61 61 yeah and then there Jeff also provided 20 221 followers on Facebook 25 on Instagram and the town clerk provides additional information to 623 Tod residents who sign up for the email blast that we get you know um discussing the various meetings in the town so
130that's 623 that's that's a good uh it's a good reach for that that um blast that goes out to everyone who signed signed up for that particular service um we also discussed other ways to um advertise our meetings how to attend them I I've noticed them come through that you know uh the announcement that our meetings are available on Facebook and view them any times time since that meeting I noticed uh we discussed it so Jeff did did a nice job with that um I think I'm not sure if we did anything with the Friday folders up that yes it's been in there as well okay we got put into this from Friday folder information follow us on Facebook follow us on Instagram and then you can view as well on you so we're getting
131out there our meetings are more than just they can be viewed in more than just the seats and I think Penny you had done something with the town shatter is that I haven't done anything I will that was discussed to do to get some advertisement on the on the local chatter pages and the last thing we talked about was uh just you know the purpose of the meeting whether the purpose of the subcommittee was there a need for it anymore and we decided that a once a year meeting would be adequate to assess um the goals that we had set you know we could we could gauge our next year at this time you know the same metrics that we have here how many people do it on Facebook how many people sign for the
132blast so that was what we decided to do now that was before our meeting tonight about the food so we'll see if that changes that once a year meeting but that's we decided to once a year follow up on community outreach yes I have a question of the 631 people that have requested the blast what's the open rate of people looking at the blast and clicking through do we know that I asked I asked the town clerk she just has the distribution list of who is signed up to receive it not who's clicking opening or anything else because you have to go online and register to what minutes you want to receive or agendas you want to receive from the town on the town website so she just informed me that 600 23 constituents have
133signed up to receive it there's no Open click rate for that at all that company doesn't have that data for us that they [Music] use what about I'm sorry what about the blast the E are there email blasts going out are we sending out email like newsletters to parents yeah it's in our Friday folder right that's it that's all we're doing correct and how many people are opening those do we know we don't even know I would it depends on who opens the Friday folder and reads um the information that's within there that's sent out every single Friday to all sent how is it sent out I know it's sent out through but what platform just through your your email email distribution just through Outlook uh Google we use Gmail as our platform but it's
134sent out to all uh emails that have registered and have enrolled as students here at Antolini at Bakerville and at New Hartford that's how it's sent [Music] out I'm just curious how many people are actually opening them up people are opening them up are they reading it just curious would Paul know it's not it's not if it's sent through Outlook or Google you can't you can't open it it's I was just curious just to know if someone's actually reading it okay thank you than you Tom thank you to Penny and Christian as well uh moving on to the next item of the agenda is public comment for agenda items only would anyone like to address the board yes so if you would just your name and your address um and I'm pretty much coming here
135tonight as a parent and also as the Director um as a parent I have been involved in all different aspects of the school Community for the past 12 years um I've always been an advocate for recreational activities and I know um that you guys are all aware of how important it is and how important it is fortiv um we are really fortunate where we live that we have amazing Fields amazing grounds um we're able to get a lot of activities rolling except for when the weather permits for us to be inside um we truly don't have the adequate space to have any kind of athletic um capabilities like your hall or anything like that is not big enough um you use our gym here which is awesome um and I know that in order to
136build something we would have to go and get taxpayers to agree with this and I think it would be really we have amazing school thatti hours um it stated in the Board of Education the community relations policy thatn that the district school builds andring vital Community Resources the board is committed to making these facili to the Comm as much as possible under the appropriate conditions with that being said we went from having six hours after school for programs and activities down to an hour and a half New Hartford custodians were always contracted to have second Shi that went from 2 to 10 unfortunately when hit that was taken away so we could have more hands on De to keep the school and everything and it was definitely needed um and it just never came back
137which is fine but then at Advance now has the gym Ed until 5:30 which again is all great um and superintendent soua has been wonderful I vented this to him he's probably going his eyes in his head right now for me standing here but um it is it's such an issue when it comes to basketball or any of our we pushing so hard to get these kids and we had to actually turn them away this year because we did not have enough space to be able to have practices so instead of having the six or seven teams that we could have had we only ended up with five because there's no way that we could have practices stretch out that hour and a half time frame to get um the parents from work to get
138the kids there um and to get the whole practice in um in the beginning of the year I was told that there was going to be as you mentioned tonight the new um janitor the custodian that was hired and thought that it was a perfect opportunity to put back the two to 10 but maybe like a one to n or something like that which I thought was going to be we discussed it and I thought it was going to be an excellent solution unfortunately for whatever reason it did not come to reality because um of the contract um so then the other uh which back to the policy 1330 use of school facilities um number seven states that inate public school custodian staff or other designated staff by the superintendent has the ability and responsibility
139for SEC for the security of the school facilities when Community groups it as a result a custodian or designated staff member will be assigned every for the scheduled use of the facilities outside organizations so according to the first select's office being a town of new Harford employee should give me enough credentials to meet the requirements we are even under the same umbrella for insurance and everything else and ask the board and superintendent to please consider this request to either have a one to n Shi put in or name myself under the responsible for the security of school when Recreation Department thank you Carol anyone else sure sorry Jeff you mentioned however I will numerous opso free free guide free options that are way cheaper than what Ed also depen's Point regardless whether schol has check
140you also have to put an order two weeks in advance which is hard for us um uh even if we offer parents a listing of food safe items would um you guys mentioned commity Outreach I think I'll have to say I feel like 60% a lot ofes they don't have Facebook a lot of parents don't Facebook or Instagram thank you anyone else okay seeing none um our next item on the agenda is executive session so can I get a motion to enter executive session at 9:01 I'll make a motion we go into executive session at 9:01 p.m. and invite superintendent soua to join us second thanks Frank right y motion by Penny second by Frank all those in favor that's unanimous thank you thank you all