CorpusRecord 114354

New Hartford Public Schools - Board Meeting - 01/07/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / NHPS Board of Education
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Northwest Hills Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,919 words · about 78 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay welcome everyone and happy New Year to everyone um I'm going to call the regular Board of Education meeting to order for January 7 2025 at 7M uh we will start with the Pledge of Allegiance so if you're able please join us frag today back corner y yes I pledge of allegience to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay thank you um next item on the agenda is order of business uh for the order of business today we were going to make one change we're gonna under the superintendent report we are going to take Item B before item a I have no other changes you good yeah perfect um next item communication to the

002Board of Education uh we have one communication we'll take up under executive session um and then the next item is public comment um so would anybody like to address the board Mr Carlson please come on up if you would just state your name and your address for us my name is Olie Carlson I live at 455 West Hill Road and uh dear board this is to the Board of Education your task is to provide the best education in the safest manner at the lowest cost to the children and the taxpayers of New Hartford so let's review first at the end of last year you needed police at three schools to guard against the threat now we have a little over 400 students that could easily fit into this school that would create a medium-sized school

003with one principal instead the board insists on having three schools with a superintendent and staff for mostly empty schools that could hold 1100 1150 students one of your schools would not be allowed to oper hold students today because it lacks of a sprinkler system basically you spread vulnerable children over three locations we're living in a crazy time with Carnage reported almost every day in our country the board for years has avoided creating the safest School possible for the children New Hartford what should you do to change the situation second the objective of any school system is to provide an education to the children how well have you done that over the last five school years the average Ela score is 61.6 4 and the average math score is 52.8 to if these numbers were great

004it's fair to and it's fair to think of them as grades the school system you're responsible for would receive a grade of f but more importantly these scores mean that 40% of the students are not achieving grade level in ela and 50% of the students are not achieving grade level in math now this is with a 30 a 37 certified uh teaching staff and 24 non-certified staff helping teach now if you assume a class size of 20 you have a certified staff that could teach 740 students you include the non-certified you're over 1,200 if you look back over the last 10 years you'll find the number of students meeting grade level year after year is consistent for this year's numbers now what do these numbers suggest well it suggest you do not have a teaching

005staff capable of teaching 40% of the students in ela and 50% of the students in math now before you disagree these are your numbers third the school budget for 2023 2024 was 9,418 1532 now that works out to 8,189 61 per seat remember you support 1150 seats in this school system but you only have 480 448 students So based on these numbers you misspent 5,749 5250 and before you disagree these are your numbers the board for years has overspent and over taxed the citizens of new Hartford not provided any benefit to the students in return and what should you do to rechange the situation over the years the board has been consistent in overspending and disregarding safety the superintendent and the board have been consistent in not improving student performance the teaching staff has been

006consistent in their inability to teach and require students to focus on learning consistency is only good if you're on target or close to it the numbers tell the story you're consistent in missing the Target now you can disagree with what I've said tonight but before you do I remind you again these are your numbers this is your school thank you no well Mr Carlson hands that out is there anybody else like to address the board okay one last for uh public comment anyone like to address the board right seeing none uh we will close public comment and move on to item D superintendent's report yes I'll turn it over you all right thank you so much chairman KPS um first and formost most happy New Year to everybody echoing the sentiments of Mr kleps and

007looking forward to a successful 2025 school year with our staff students and school Community I'm confident that this will absolutely be realized um with the change up in the superintendent report I do want to give the opportunity for Emma to present first so I will turn it over to her just want to remind you Emma to press the button make sure your green light is on so that you are broadcasting live and thank you in advance good evening I interviewed Miss Dinger to find out what's going on in third grade I asked her about the third graders transition into anini she told me that the first thing they do is a meet and greet field trip in second grade they are paired up with a fifth grade buddy who shows them around the school and

008introduces them to the teachers to help them feel more comfortable at the start of the year they also do a lot of exploring of the school in those first few days there is a lot of extra adult support for the third graders for example there are a lot of other adults in the hallways during drop off and dismissal to show the third graders exactly where to go and just like everyone else the third grade does a lot of team building I remember my transition into anini and all of the teachers helped us feel welcome I was also curious about what the third graders favorite subject was and Miss Dinger said while most students would say recess or lunch all black has been the favorite subject this year because students are able to rotate stations and

009practice more of what they're learning from their model lessons in ela in all block students are learning about different tenses of words and their rules that go along with verbs in all blocks students also have independent reading group work with the teacher and vocabulary work in math students are learning to add and subtract three-digit numbers with regrouping finally they are learning about Native Americans in social studies and went on a field trip to the Native American Museum it sounds like it's very fun to be a third grader thank you very much Emma for your updates and your reports much appreciated and Dexter of course sends his regrets as well he had a family commitment so he could not be here he's our other board representative uh student board rep so thank you again Emma all

010right continuing on with the remainder of student of the superintendent's report after our student uh report was um I'd like to first off thank profound profound thanks uh as I did publicly already to Lieutenant Colmes of State uh Police Troop Beric B Trooper figel who's actually here today thank you so so much sir um Trooper wedge officer jenko officer PUO for coordinating and really prioritizing the safety of our schools um in conjunction with first selectman Dan jerum I was in all three schools um that week of the 18th the 19th and the 20th and staff made the routine smooth and normal uh for our students very very proud to see that um and for the well-being of our students um any parent that had emailed me directly relative to the uh perceived uh non-direct threat

011to our schools but in our community I called directly and spoke to I know our administrative staff also did the same thing so that we would have voice to voice hearing people on the other end I think that was very critical instead of just providing an email response so kudos to our administrative staff as well for speaking to our parents directly um on the 18th of December the absentee rate was 22 students which is equivalent to 5.1% in absence on 1219 uh we had 106 students students out which is equivalent to 25% of our student population and on Friday the 20th of December we were back down to 26 students out at 6.1% the um staff at the schools did a great job these specific absences were due to the perceived threat and they were

012asked as such so they were not due to illness or other things or family vacation so um wanted to just share that information with the Board of Education uh from right prior to the winter recess uh also again thank you to the board of education uh our mental health supports were certainly utilized in our buildings throughout for students that needed help or support navigating either conversations or feelings or emotions on those particular days uh up next um want to just update the board on our curriculum Council we've had our first meeting we had that meeting on the 19th of December we have reviewed our mission statement and our bylaws and we set up the next meeting date to continue our Collective work there are many new members since the uh curriculum Council has not met

013since the 2018 or maybe 2019 school year right prior to covid the curriculum Council involves the following region 7 our Hampstead colbrook New Hartford norfol and Heartland and the mission is really to get together and discuss curriculum and alignment of our work together and do more together um as efficiently as we possibly can in the in our region for region 7 so more to come from that um also a very special thank you to all of our town um we had a town meeting in the month of December so I want to thank the town residents for your unanimous support of our grants and projects moving forward that was very much appreciated so thank you for that um also of note we received notification after the posting of our of this meeting that we received

014approval finally from the um state of Connecticut and the Department of Education for our increasing education educator diversity plan that was submitted once needed revisions was resubmitted in August they just got back to us in the month of December that that has been finally approved so let me see if I made um any n those are all of our updates that I have before wanting to turn it over to Becky Terrell who we've invited here to be with us from nutrition services at at Advance before we turn it over to Becky does anybody have any questions for Jeff regarding the uh superintendence report okay seeing none welcome Becky thank you for joining us thank you I assume this is on y yes it's live so um just listening to your start of your meeting and

015the things that you are talking about um I can't help but remind you that I'm a 24 year yes 24 year veteran of the planville Board of Education and my skin is therefore very thick um and so when I rolled into school Food Service it was really well uh it was a good thing because school Food Service requires some really thick skin too um so I'm here this evening to talk about a couple things one of the first thing really is the differentiation between um meals that we serve and um the purchase of allart items um so I think you might have in front of you the list of what area schools are doing um and I used um you know the area schools that we work with Winchester bark Hamstead coldbrook botel um Region

01620 schools and then also reached out to Avon and Canton just to ask what they were up to because of their proximity to you um and you could see that they do not sell as many items to their students as you do um and that is something that um was the way uh is a history of the way that new Harford has operated for many years um when I came to Ed Advance eight years ago eight nine years ago I um we were not the sponsor of the district the district was privately run and we helped operate it um and that food was sold as that's what the district wanted to do and it and that's what was sold um another company came in here I believe it stayed the same we took it over

017last year the year before same thing we're just continuing on doing what the practice was prior to uh you know us being here we did not bring in additional Foods or additional items um I know there is a thought that it's a you know there there's well it's a fact it's a money maker because it's over and above the $3 that we get for a meal um so it does assist us um so far this year from I think you have a list that shows up until November but I just updated it today so far this year um up until today the total amount spent on um by students on allart items is $1,966 of which 620 is milk so um when a student purchases alart um I think superintendent explained this you know know

018it's something that their parent gave them money to do um because the only other item besides a meal that you can use your charge for is um milk so kids purchase milk and meals with their accounts and other than that it's cash for any other alart item um and also I think the superintendent mentioned that if you want to and this is absolutely your decision I mean it's 100% your decision as far as what you serve in your buildings but I would you know caution what parents are used to and if they want to keep it versus whether they would like to go in a different direction so that would be you know I would agree with that as far as um just checking to see uh what people might think about making a change

019um so that's it's not something that's an advaned Thing by any stretch of the imagination um we are not a food service management company we are your res and um Pro provide service to you um to try and you know we exist to feed to We Exist my food service department exists to feed kids that's what we exist to do so our meals on the other hand are very um everything is regimented even even the alart items that we provide the you know the rice krispy people have created Rice Krispy treats that um are compliant for School meals they are not the rice krispy treats that you could buy for your children in the grocery store they are modified to meet the guidelines of the uh USDA um and that falls in line throughout all

020the different manufacturers and products and everything these items aren't sold anywhere else they're only sold to schools um and and that is you know the way the process works um so um when it comes to the meals themselves we it's very prescripted as to what we can give and uh what we need to follow we're limited for sodium we're limited on calories we're limited on fats um and so a lot of the items that we serve are also modified to make sure that we can meet those guidelines um we um you know we're trying to one of the one of the biggest hurdles that we all face is trying to make ends meet we make these meals on pennies if you can imagine what we try we try and give our folks that work for

021us a good wage um and that's always a challenge and then make these meals for usually $3.50 um and some subsidy from the uh from the USDA um so we are you know it's we're constantly challenged to try and do better and do as well as we can um we are you know always trying to strive to do um to do the best that we can and and do a good job um we are very fortunate here in New Hartford that we have the staff that we do we actually had um we had a turnover staff at the beginning of the year and it was a little concerned but we brought in somebody who's really awesome as our manager and all the buildings actually have really strong staff which is one of the biggest things

022um that makes a difference because the staff in those buildings are the ones who will take a step up and do uh more we over the course of the year so far I think we've spent between I want to say I want to say it's around $1,400 from the beginning of the year till December 1st on local produce from the Northwest Food Hub it's um something that we had done with some of our other schools this year we brought new Harford into the mix um and so they're buying apples they're buying lettuce they're buying micro greens and you know just things that you wouldn't think the kids would get um and I let them do that without really watching what they're doing knowing that they're being cautious with the with funding knowing you know knowing

023that they're doing that to just try and improve the quality of the food give the kids something better and you know support the local economy which is something that we are really trying to do um so um you know that is one of our one of our goals to continue doing that to increase it if we can um and with that I'm going to stop and I G I gave you a lot of information I know some of you got it earlier because I did send it out um to to the chairperson and um I Believe Miss Albert had the question initially so um I'll let I'll open it up to if you have any questions of me so let me start just by asking a question on the alicart report by schools that you

024have here all of these offerings are a daily offering yeah and then I do see I was going to ask you about the Miss 450 but I see on your at Advance sheet if you hadn't seen that the board it does explain the 450 is for the oill student meals okay um with that I will open it up to the for for any questions you have for Becky how much food waste there food waste well one of the best things that the and there aren't too many um great things that happen with the program but one of the best things they developed was something called offer versus serve so the students can actually make a decision offer versus serve students can make a decision about what they want with their meal they can choose whether

025or not they want to take milk and they can usually choose the kind of milk they want um they can choose if if let's say the meal is being served with broccoli they don't like broccoli they can Ser they can choose from a an array of different vegetables we call it a rainbow tray that gives them a l lot of different options they can choose the fruit they want and you know we just we always giving them a lot of selection so that that they can take something they like and hopefully eat it and not throw it out because food waste is something that everybody is trying to avoid and as far as individual schools um I couldn't tell you exactly what the food waste quantity would be I'm then I guess I wasn't expecting

026an actual volume pound per day but I would like that'd be nice to know but I mean generally is do you you see a lot of waste going away again because it seems like that's a place where we maybe we to start saving some money and maybe being able to offer better Foods versus more of foods that are get thrown away I again I don't I'm just asking a question how much really just gets the kids like yeah I'll give broccoli yes right so so in order for a kid to take what we know as a compliant meal they have to take a full serving of fruit or vegetable right so that is the one thing that we have to make sure they take and that's the one thing we're worried about them taking because

027they have to and throwing it out so that's where the offering of all these different you know uh options comes in they don't have to take a fruit and a vegetable they could take one or the other we'd like them to take both matter of fact fruits and vegetables are pretty much unlimited because we do have a lot of kids who come up and want to take multiple and that's what we want them to take um so you know as far as how much gets thrown out we're always working at trying to make things you know as appealing to kids and giving them those choices and letting them um decide what they would like to take are there any other questions come on you guys must have [Laughter] something are these Tyson products is that

028Connecticut based country based I think I Tyson is is a national I know it is but does every school get the Tyson product Tyson is one of the big ones in the market that that we that we in schools use um but there's a company called proview There's um Breakin Bush there's like four or five big chicken folks yeah um gold kissed so there's a couple yeah if we were to go with some healthier products for lunches what kind of cost increase would that be what do you mean by healthier products um yeah like like grilled chickens things like that yeah we have gred chicken you do yeah we have things that not everything is breaded all the time but we have to make sure that again we're trying to make sure we're putting food

029out that kids take our menu is driven by uh what students accept a lot of times because we're trying to make sure that our um participation is up there so we know what kids take um and that's what we're working from um our breaded products are whole grain breaded with whole grain they're lower in fat than what you're going to get at the grocery store they're lower in sodium than what you would get um and you know that's we're following those guidelines and doing it for $350 so every kid gets offered an 8 ounce milk multiple fruits and vegetables gra whole grains and then we call it meat meat alternate because sometimes it's not a meat necessarily it might be you know might be a vegetarian who's having beans or you know something like that

030I mean I think for me the concern and I know this is like a bigger picture like across the country I mean I look at the ingredients in this and it's horrific I mean I don't know why are we offering it like if we don't offer it then they won't eat it and they won't be tempted to eat it and we teach them how to eat healthy I mean this this is I mean canola oil I mean canola oil canol is horrible for you malade extran silicone dioxide I mean has anyone actually looked at this sheet are the parents actually looking at the sheet I mean because I'm looking at the sheet and I'm I'm like I want to throw up right and and we're feeding this is what we're feeding kids and I know

031this is a bigger issue I know that we don't have a budget for this but that's the sad part is that we're feeding our children horrible ingredients that have been proven to be bad for you canola oil is bad for you that's just a proven fact I mean and I look at the other ingredients and this is what we're feeding our children I I don't know there's got there's an issue um I don't know if we're going to solve it tonight probably won't but I just think the more healthy options that we give our children it's just like in my home we don't we're not serving this food that's not that's not available this is what we're serving we're serving grilled chicken we're serving whatever it is we're serving and then they just get used

032to the idea of that's what we have to eat because we can't get breaded stuff that's got you know 100 chemicals in it right but then the cost is obviously we understand the cost is exorbitant but I'm just trying to figure out like why are we feeding our children bad food like then we wonder why they have ADHD and all these other issues in class because we're feeding them dyes and and food that is not healthy it's a question it's a bigger question as all I'm asking so one of the things that this that these companies are trying to do is they are working on being more clean label they are working on that kind of thing you'll notice that they don't do a lot of dyes um they are using other things usually to

033die their you know I think it was there was something where they're using beets and you know they different options so that they're not using uh food d as readily is that the alart purchases yep probably I have two questions one of them I don't know if you can answer is the uh dollar amount you gave is that net or gross is that profit or just the total the amount for the allart allart that's how much money we brought in so that's prior to purchasing the product and prior profit margin there's not probably huge either and this is not a ton of money really I mean you know it's it's we're we're well over half year were maybe if if things continued as they were you would make $4,000 at the end of the year

034and my second question 4,000 and that's not profit that's 4,000 in sales so it's not making the bank by any okay you it didn't seem like a ton the other question I had is um do you know how many students bring lunch versus get school lunch I don't know what your participation rate is right now off the top of my head not sure we could get that for you though thank you you're welcome so there are a lot of people who think there's a better way to do this and I am believe me when I when I tell you that I'm all up for improving products and trying to uh you know get away from some of the things that are in our our uh you know in our Foods in general not just in

035school nutrition everywhere right um but it's it is a it's a very difficult road to hoe and it's and it's takes time and um people making noise about it parents making noise about it um before the industry starts to turn I do think that they're getting the message because we are when we go to our food shows we're hearing a lot more about products that you know are are clean more cleanly label and just avoiding things and you know looking at that kind of of what's actually in those froods what is the uh I may you may have copied it in the email you sent but the standard weekly menu right because again what we have here in front of us is a lot about chicken patty fritters I have breeded golden crispy tenders I

036have some pen EG but again is there like a like a pizza offering on certain days what else is offered so so we run what's known as a five-week cycle so pretty much it's it's you know a five-week cycle that changes once in a while especially it might have we might have a couple things we change seasonally we certainly interject things when there's a holiday or something like that um but that cycle generally does have pizza on Friday or a pizza type product um uh and you know we there's a pasta usually once a week there's chicken a couple times a week kids definitely like chicken um and you know the menu is posted you can if you have kids in school you can definitely see it and then the other question I have is

037on your sheet here it has fruit rollups listed here in in an order of popularity but I don't see it here is it something that was removed and is it is it under the so you're talking alicart yeah alicart has it must be I don't know they must be putting it in they miscellaneous or something and it didn't get picked up MH he's he's asking I think he's asking if it he's not seeing it for the s list you know the S list is not here I guess is where I'm where I'm what I'm reading and when do they get these like sour blue raspberry Cyclone cups and Strawberry Shortcake bars and cotton candy Twirls every day they we may have them every day I don't know there's also something that we've we started doing

038this year where we're offering um we're offering those celebration classroom celebration items um and some families are op opting to do that as opposed to you know have bring in cookies or whatever like that kind of thing so I'm not sure if those are on the list because that's one of the choices or if it's something that they carry in the building every day I mean they have great marketing to try to say that it's there's no nutree no AR artificial dyes no high fructose corn are but it's full I mean when you read the ingredients I mean it's it's full of um really bad stuff like every single one of them is full of bad stuff the vanilla sandwich the birthday cake cone um Strawberry Shortcake bar um like I said they have great

039marketing to make it look like they're okay but they're they're really bad yeah it's a you know they're they're they know how to make something that's compliant that passes muster I just want to say I think you're doing a great job with the limited resources that you have you have your hands tied behind your back um it's always a struggle to get kids to eat and you know you can give you can give them the healthiest of foods but as Tom was saying they're gonna go it's G to go right in the garbage if they don't like the taste of it so you know that's the struggle that they have too you know they have to figure out what kids will eat we have to think like a kid here and uh they're not concerned

040with those chemicals and whatever it is that's in their food they're not concerned with that they they want something that tastes good so thank you for all your all your efforts we really focus on trying to make like the meal look nice when the kids come up to take it because you know kids have gotten a lot more Discerning they're customers they know what you know what it's like to go out to eat whereas you know years ago they didn't have that experience but now kids really do do they know you know they go to Panera they know what uh what a nice sandwich looks like they know what you know food looks like when it's packaged um you know and looks and looks uh like something you you want to eat um and that's

041what they do first right they see it and then they're going to decide whether or not they are going to take it um but I I appreciate that and it's you know it's food service industry is tough School Food Services is tougher than than anything I've ever done so um you know the regulations are are excessive and the finances are really low and um it's like I said thick skin you need it for this uh kind of uh kind of work but um yeah we're you know we we try and do everything we can uh to bring in some really good stuff um one of the things that one of my weaknesses is that I'm not good you know you see how these guys are good at telling you what's in those you know that

042the that the ice cream's good I have not gotten out much information about our local produce and what we're doing because I just it's like it's unfortunate but it's like the last thing at the end of the day and I don't get that out there but I would like to do something where and I know it's really simple I could probably send something to the principles and they would be more than happy to send out something and say hey look what we did um so we're always you know I've been kind of bugging the managers for new pictures and show us what you've done with the vegetables and the fruits that are local let's put it out there and say hey look at these you know apples that we got from March Farm or whatever

043but uh yeah one more is there an option is there a way to opt on the different foods like like we find it something has no canola oil it because again canol oil is one of the worst things you put in your body prom oil canoil it's all in all that stuff so is there a way to get rid of is there an option to for your company to buy a different from a different Source or is you guys are that's why I ask about the Tyson they're stuck if you're stuck with Tyson you're stuck with what they produce and Tyson's just a factory so one of the things we have to do is we have to abide by a bid so we're in a we're in a Consortium with a bunch of other school

044districts and we're we have a bid list and we have different options that we can choose from on that bid list but we have to stick with that bid list for most of the time uh I think 70% of our purchases have to come off the bid um but the good thing is we kind of control what the bid is by what we use um so there is definitely some there's some options there and there's some things that you can change but you are limited by Price sometimes um if we're the only ones using a product it gets more expensive because the quantity is not there um that kind of stuff Jee is it possible to send the um ingredients home to the parents yeah i't I'd like to see them actually in their Friday

045folder yeah these will be they're gonna be posted publicly too this is gonna go I want to go I I want these ingredients and this kind of stuff and say this is what you these are the options the children have we're also just being transparent to let you know that this is what's going in to your child um this is what this is what we have in the schools well it's that is an option for a parent to buy right that's what I'm saying so if you want to say I've never seen this when my son went to anini I've never seen any ingredients like again I understand listen I'm not I know you have a tough job this is not me attacking you like this is literally not me attacking this is a greater

046issue that I have a major problem with it's not a school issue it's not a school issue it's a major issue and I'm what I'm trying to say is we can do something if if we all sit here and say oh well you know it's just we feed our kids it's okay like okayy this what we got no that's not the right answer the answer is all of us can and have the power to start doing something even if it's one product we're taking off instead of Doritos let's have seeta chips instead of you know this there's got to be a healthier version that we can get like if we get all the parents involved like my kid's not in school here anymore but like he he wouldn't he doesn't eat this crap like I

047would never Fe and that's why I sent him lunch every day that's why I still send him lunch every day at school up in up in Regional because it just because I know what's in the products and they're really really bad so we can to sit here and say we can't do anything about it we have a big bidding system and we you know we have to just buy from that no I don't think that's an answer I don't think that's what I said no no I'm just saying in general it's not just you I've heard it from other schools what I'm saying is we have the power to change even if it's a little bit at a time we have the power to take this crap out of the schools not feed our kids

048canola oil not feed our kids palm oil and if the parents know and we educate the parents about the really bad parts about this stuff and the dyes that are in here that are that are hurting their children and we send them home let's send them home so at least we're transparent and then the parent can make the choice if they know this stuff exists they know what's in it and they they get it every week then and they still want to feed their kid this stuff and that's their choice but at least we have a responsibility to do something like we really do have some responsibility as long as I'm on this board we have some we can do something I just I don't know I know it's expensive I know but maybe we

049start small we change Doritos to see at the chip how about that can we do that I don't know if those are on our acceptable Foods list they have to be on the state makes a list right just get rid of Doritos in general yeah I mean I mean that's all that's all the cart stuff that's up to parents to purchase if they want we're offering it we offer then they're they're gonna eat it you don't have to you don't have to sell it in your schools if you want to pull it out of your schools you you have absolutely you can do that we every school we go into we work with what the actually not even the District administration because sometimes it's different building to building there are certain buildings where they don't

050want anything other than maybe water and milk as all Aur that's fine that's what we do um and they they sometimes they want it for different reasons because they don't want kids um to feel like they can't get something they don't want it to take up too much time you know there's different reasons that people have for what they sell in their in their buildings but it's it's the building's call it's not it's not Food Services call um for all aart not just Federal so that stuff will be com down system just saying to do nothing and be like you know what the school is okay likey it's out of our power you know we have to you know we have to just have to buy it that's what we got to buy we got

051to operate I to me that I'm not satisfied with that and I'm not okay with that but I think if we tell the parents this is what's in the food and these are the nutrition facts and they get it and they're educated about what it is and send stuff home to the parents and say hey canola canola this is this is the bad parts for your children I don't know if a lot of parents would keep get that every week and say hey it's okay feed my kids at raspberry strawberry I and there's no way to know how many of those were sold there may have been two of those sold this year for all we know I mean you know so you have to also put things in perspective you know um there's not

052a ton I mean there's not a ton of of alicart being sold in your schools um more than most but there's there's still not a ton when you see that the highest purchased item is milk you know so just so we just so we we stay on on task here right this was a this was a report right so again this was information sharing question and answer to be able to have Becky here to be able to share additional information to us if the board would like to have further discussion would like to again publish the information to the public we can add an agenda item under new business for our next meeting where we can have further discussion that we could take action on this is a report out today all right so please

053if there's any other questions for Becky please ask her ask her while we have her she's very busy it took us a took us some time to get her here I know well your your last meeting was the same as my last Mee we had I had a meeting board meeting the same night so all right thank you guys appreciate appreciate your passion and you're looking into this that you know it's like you're asking the same questions that a lot of people either are or should be asking so all right thank you guys thank you so much Becky before we close the topic again would the board like us to have an agenda item at a future meeting where we we could take some action on whether we want to publish information to the public

054I heard again some ideas about you know proposing some Alternatives right if you have those ideas please plan to bring them into the next meeting so that we can I'd actually ask that maybe you send an email prior to that way we have a list of the the proposed options that we could share with Becky and at Advance uh to see if there's an opportunity to make some changes right and again as I look at the area of schools alicart around here again you know Becky's absolutely right you know they're many of them are milk in a second meal milk and ice cream on Fridays only milk water juice and yogurt it seems to be the the uh the theme for you know at least Avon a Canton on this list as well as Region

05520 I can tell you that Canton sells all the same things that they sell here even though it's not on this list chips cookies everything do you know why was before me so what she saying is that Advance came in and took over for another Food Service I'm going to say this board is the first board to bring it to the board level to have a conversation would be my assumption yeah 8 to 10 years yeah okay so we'll add it to uh the next meeting agenda please if we could prepare before we get there with any options you might have that way I want you to send it beforehand please yep yes yes just put it in an email and send it up place so I will add that on to our agenda for

056the February meeting thank you under new business thank you all right moving on to the next piece under superintendence report we have our district engagement Plan before you you should see an updated copy a front page copy with a introduction statement of purpose um at your table so if you could have that out for reference um there have been a couple other tweaks and edits that I will go through uh for our first presentation of the district engagement plan want to thank our chairwoman for the subcommittee dear Dre for her work and Kristen young and Megan Albert as well and a cute little Butchie as well that was there at our meeting recently Butchie is adorable um so this is a very important work that we do as a board of education and this comes

057with a lot of thought probably you know for my my tenure here looking at previous plans um where they are how often they were referenced what meaning what power what passion did they have driving behind it and unfortunately with you know strategic plans they become something that is introduced and unfortunately sometimes not Revisited and becomes something that's collecting dust on the Shelf because it's too robust or it has too many moving parts to it or Things Fall by the wayside um so as we met as an administrative team and a leadership team we determined that we were going to come in with very strategic pieces before the board to get us to a place where we could develop Baseline information and really have a good springboard going forward so originally you'll see uh that it

058was a district engagement plan of of a five-year piece we've really limited that scope to what some of the work is now and why and going into the 25 26 school year again with the intention of coming back and looking at all of the goals and having this be a living breathing document not something that's stagnant and not going to be looked at again so our commitment and promise is going to be to come back to this at least twice a year if not more because we already do look at our parent survey data every single year in the months of August and September one of the goals here in culture and climate you'll see is very P very important to us we want to have more ownership over our um methods and you'll see

059that here um also so the other piece is um sorry I lost my train of thought living breathing document coming back to it there was another piece and I I'll get back to it in a moment um but this is really providing a uh a navigation like our North Star this is really the direction we want to move our district in there are a lot of big lift pieces here um they are not always all connected to percentages or numbers because every single year we get brand new kids that come in and we're trying to move them from point A to point B so the board's goals should be really theories of action basically if we're providing certain conditions for something to happen then we should see outcomes what all those out outcomes are going

060to be we don't know yet because we've implemented as you'll see one of our larger larger goals we've have been implementing a new curriculum of reading and we have more work still to do with that and a lot of Kinks to iron out a lot of assessment pieces to iron out and then we're going to be looking at data comparing dible scores what they were like beforehand of our implementation and afterward obviously we want to maintain or increase our achievement that's an obvious component but we need to start somewhere and have a good foundation and Baseline um and have it be succinct because too many goals leaves it too spread out so we've met over the course of years being together as a leadership team and we've come up with these three components which we

061feel are very very important to the success of our school district the first and foremost teaching and learning so we have to put conditions in place for our Educators to constantly be learning um through our professional development calendar which is made in conjunction with our teachers and we have a pck committee that I've talked about before to the Board of Education they are really a huge Cog and a huge wheel in determining what the next steps are and why because they are living it every single day with the kids in the classrooms they are looking at student uh achievement all of the time every day based on how they are learning or the way that they are not learning those are both very important pieces of information um and they take that information and then

062they adjust on the fly on The Daily we meet very often in terms of our intervention schedule we're constantly looking at what we can do better for kids we don't want anybody to fall through the gaps so teaching and learning you'll see here if we provide highquality instruction through a coherent and relevant curriculum with balanced assessment uh students are going to engage in meaningful experiences that will maximize their holistic growth so again as a board goal that is a huge umbrella for all of our schools prek to sixth grade okay does it get more finite as we go to schools and grade levels and looking at individual students absolutely and that is done on a yearly basis but that's not Incorporated in a large umbrella goal for the Board of Education right that more finite

063Lens comes as we work with kids individually work with new families every single year and work over the course of their seven years when they're with us to move them from point A all the way to point B I don't want to put the cart too much before the horse but getting to that point B that final piece in sixth grade we are missing a a portrait or a a vision of what that learner should be as a sixth grader ready to go to region s other surrounding districts have that that's part of our goals here in the third component we'll see that all right so if we look on teaching and learning on that second page please ignore any of these uh there's a highlighted piece there about mapping each of these these are

064just notes that we had there so implementation of new curricula based on the science of reading we've done that we've started to do that we're going to continue to do that that is not a finalized piece there is so much professional development that goes behind introducing a full curriculum uh from changing it from the way we used to do things we've always done it to we need to find a better way something that's more engaging and meaningful to our students to our staff and to our families and that's the feedback that we've been receiving with the new El education curriculum one piece these are all big lifts they sound easy on paper but our professionals do this consistently they work with other outside agencies to help us we collaborate as often as we can with

065regional Partners to make this realized uh just saying that we're implementing a new curriculum makes it sound very easy oh you're just following a script and it's done absolutely not there are so many options obstacles and intricacies to introducing a new curriculum that we could do a whole workshop on that here tonight so that is a major goal for all of our staff across our district and not just regular Ed staff because special ed also has implications with this as well in terms of how they're teaching and how students are learning when you introduce a new curriculum you'll see the next part in goal number two this hasn't been done in a while here in New Hartford Public Schools but the report card has to now align with these new expectations that has to be

066done again in a meaningful way where teachers feel confident that they are grading students according to the expectations of a new curriculum that parents understand the grades that are given or the numerical assignment to how they're achieving or not it has to make sense this is a huge piece as well it's a big big lift for revising our current report card to align with our current practices and curriculum so we need to do that that is going to involve teachers across a breath of grade levels because it's not just one report card there's a lot more work to be done there and then we're if we're looking at that report card we also have to think of implications for students with special education needs there's so much more that goes along with this and we

067also need parent input so there's going to be a lot of other focus groups that are going to be developed and subcommittee work so that we are doing it right and involving all of the stakeholders that we need to um we're going to start that work this year and continue that until we have a finalized product that we are proud of and that we feel strongly that that reflects the work that we're doing so along the way we'll have to assess that and then when we're done we'll also have to assess it again because we're not going to be complacent with what we have as a product math is also an area that we need to look at as we know these are our state Assessments in ela and in um and in mathematics we

068need to review our current math practices we had a big lift right before the pandemic of introducing a brand new curriculum that then did not get its full meat and potatoes of having professional development that was very systematic and very succinct but also very focused per grade level our El education we've had the wonderful luxury of being in person having outside coaching having our amazing curriculum coach Heather matis working with all of our staff taking lumps and bruises along the way this isn't going well yep oh this is going better okay it's getting there this is a long long process mathematics also needs the same type of um investigation and revision of its curric um with a lot of professional development so it is our job as the board to create these conditions to do

069so yes through our budget yes through our beliefs and um and working through the process together so that's teaching and learning in a quick nutshell there are other pieces here that helped us determine that these were goals that we found were necessary to move our district and Propel our district forward some of these scores and percentages that you see here yes Our intention is absolutely to maintain them or in increase them over time but with a new curriculum a new measurement we need a baseline this is really going to provide that catapult so that we can have that and measure against it and compare are we doing better why or why not you know is it individually is it the curriculum we always want to take very very careful lenses and looks at all of

070the information that we'll have coming forward if we look at the second School climate again another area that we want to maintain we have tremendous scores here as we've presented presented to the Board of Education uh for our parent survey data we have a lot of amazing amazing feedback 90% plus satisfaction in many many many areas but some areas that we want to work on and that we realize are going to take time to work on are the following we have to implement a new school survey climate yes the state of Connecticut has told us to do that but then that's a lift because that's a change in Dynamic a change in all the questions to be proposed and we need a baseline because now it's about to change uh we've been working with that

071advance and other surrounding districts on this as well we want to make sure that we're effectively measuring the perceptions of our school climate what is going on how are parents informed of student progress there's so much to a u a survey um and then the second part is increased Collective efficacy of our school staff to address um challenging behaviors because if you see the one of the dra the Data Insights that we had there was 67% we presented that here at the board of Staff responded favorably to I believe the school effectively addresses Behavior that's not good enough for us we need to have more Collective ownership over student challenging behaviors as a school not just hey I passed it on to the administration and I don't think I don't agree or I agree it

072doesn't matter it's irrelevant we've lost ownership over student behavior and we need to do better with that so that's not a night flip the switch and we're done with it we need to create very strategic pieces for this it's just an overarching goal for us as a board of education to understand culture and climate needs some work these are some particular areas that we're going to be working on but we have a new survey so we need time to look at that collect that Baseline data we'll do that this year in the spring we'll Analyze That and look at that over the summertime and then come back next year because it's kind of midcycle when we're presenting this we'll come back next year with more of that information to present to everybody and take a

073comparison you need a baseline though first the last piece um is the vision of a learner if you're familiar with region 7 guys they have a portrait of a graduate so they have very specific categories and things they are looking for as students are prepared and ready to graduate from region 7 look at other neighboring districts they have a vision of a graduate or a portrait of a graduate what they look like creative thinkers problem solvers emotionally intelligent to connect with others uh to network there are so many aspects and components we are in the very infancy baby baby stages of this process it's exciting but it's also a huge Endeavor this will absolutely not be done in one year or two years but we're starting this work now because it's something that we lack

074what do we want our sixth graders to look like sound like act like when they leave us and we're ready to launch them into the world in middle school and Beyond right the remainder of their middle school career and then high school and beyond that what do we want them to be prepared with so we have a lot of work to do we have to talk to our parents our families our our community we have to talk to our students we have to talk to Educators we have so much more work to do here to develop that common definition of what the dispositions of a learner really should be in newart for public schools what our expectations are um and then continuously revise that because that may change over time but we need a baseline

075we need something to start with so that we have expectations that are common to our community common to our school uh school um cultures as well that students know hey to be a learner this is what it looks like so there's work so so much to be done here and again at a board level it's very huge it's a big giant umbrella the schools then take the information they take our goals which we've made very succinct they take it and then drive it into what's appropriate for their culture and their climate but if we don't have a navigating Northstar as a board and as the schools everyone's left to go kind of on their own that's not what we want we want the same great educational experience at all of our schools and then to

076see a great student leaving us when they sixth graders going on to seventh grade over at Region 7 so that's the intent of this engagement plan it's an engagement plan because we have a lot of Engagement to do with a lot of stakeholders and a lot of community members and a lot of our staff um so there's a ton of work to do um the introduction statement was lacking I added that in here I apologize that that you didn't have time to review that prior to certainly um you could take a look at that tonight tomorrow over time if you have any questions about that or feedback please email me that so I could um take it under consideration and advisement with the remainder of my leadership team but this is exciting work but it's

077a lot of work and it's some parts are unknown not going to be you know elusive there's some things that I don't know based on this I don't know how many scale score points we're going to see our students increase by we've seen them increase over time we've presented that over the past three years that I've been here so our students are making good growth how much more can they make we need to see after our curriculums have been implemented and other systems have been in place for a while to see how much more we're able to grow and push our kids um with having new students every single year they come into us as little prek kids and kindergarteners we never know what we're going to get and it's our job to take them

078from wherever they are and to grow them further along um and to have them absolutely shine and be their best um every single day with us in newart for public schools so that's it in a huge nutshell um I feel like my mouth is completely dry right now so I need a sip of water um but I would love to take questions comments from anybody here at the board well let me start with you had mentioned an introduction statement where is that is do I not have it you didn't have it apparently sorry I thought I put copies on your table my apologies and I apologize again that was lacking that was not part of it originally so thank you for the subcommittee again for that feedback all right any questions for for uh superintendent

079on uh the district engagement plan I have some questions yes um I want to go back to teaching and learning um and some of the goals here um I see that you've labeled these as 2425 engagement goals um I want to better understand the goal one is implementation of new curricula based on the science of reading you said this is a long-term process what exactly do we expect to get done in 2425 do you expect this implementation to go on past this year how will we know that the implementation piece is completed sure so last year we started to describe the process of uh having part one and part two so the implementation of this curriculum is not just um a one-year process and we're finished right so the first year we did a lot

080of work with um an outside agency Heather what's the name of their yes yeah you can certainly kick in absolutely two [Music] components impl we're implenting the second component in the K2 Community called skills so it's founding sksy all after this year we'll have implemented Bas and's not analis St now mod so is it correct to say that by the end of this year you expect the first phase of like actual implementation R out to be completed and then from here we will not be implementing so much as reviewing our like efficacy in implementation [Music] prrams that were out there our current data the Second Step was to select Implement talk about professional learning that next St are right now that stal interet y okay that was super helpful um when we had talked about

081this a little bit last time we talked about like what goals like this is a fiveyear plan but some upu in only one year all of the steps like for me all of the steps that you just listed out the four steps for the process that is the five-year process I would love to see that documented in this plan for transparency our Step One is this we know this is done then we move on to step two because again this is a fiveyear long-term plan um and what we're doing right now we cannot we need to know that this is done before we can move on and understand what the full implementation process looks [Music] like yeah yeah yeah it's coming right yeah yeah though that and that helped me with like the second question

082which was what is the review current math practices and curriculum and then it says curriculum review process step one so there is a process that you can just that's already documented that you could drop in here so that it's easy to tie those two things together that would really help okay okay that resolves that Sor I know I had more questions but I need to figure this out where they are I'll go ahead and ask while you're looking for yours on the back of Page Three I probably should know this but you know I'm still learning at the top there's H the two indexes with the bar chart District performance index and then Smarter Balance below and this packet here on the back and what's the difference between the DPI and the smarter balance growth

083with the numbers the DPI and the smarter balance growth yeah I'll take Ela and then there's a math one there's only DPI for science um if I'm not mistaken oh this is for ELA versus mathematics is it two different test or is it the same no it's the same it's the it's the smarter balance assessment but District performance index also incorporates other accountability measures correct you know I was looking at this letter that we received today and I think that the numbers he he's using be from the bottom charts and not they're not from the DPI the growth yeah the numbers that he's using are from the growth in DPI you see what I mean I think he's just pulling and I was confused about that myself until I just asked the question it it

084does seem like math is a little lower like it's the one compared to the state that we have the most area to improve on work on I mean that that seems to be very fair I just had one more question um with the this is pro you would know this too I think so the kids go to the teacher in the elementary and they have a main teacher do they ever leave the main teacher to maybe go to a specialist like one teacher is really good at teaching math I'm not sure if we do that in sixth grade do we or fifth grade yeah so get ready for region seven I had that experience I remember and my kids did a long when they went here a long time ago because there would be a

085teacher that's was really strong at something and they would teach all the sixth graders science or something like that we do that a little bit with sixth grade right okay thanks oh thank you uh sorry didn't want to give someone else an opportunity um going back to some of the goals the the school climate goals so um our goal for again this is stated what you have here is listed goals for this school year which we're halfway through so when do we expect to when do we send the survey out the climate survey yep that's late spring every year we send so we're on track to develop a new survey and send it out this year in Spring and then will we have enough time after we get that to actually increase Collective efficacy of

086school staff during this year or do we need to come up with a plan for that and then actual increase for next year so that information's already been reported to staff so we know that that's something that we're going to be working on across the district so that number if we're looking at something that we need to improve upon that's 67% we're looking for that to not decrease we're looking for that to maintain or increase over the course of many years not just one year so go two we are assuming that we've already taken these steps and that when we develop the new surveyance Senda out in Spring we should see an increase in staff responding favorably that we're addressing these challenging behaviors in school I would say I don't know that answer for one

087year one I would not know because really the implementation of the new survey is to have that Baseline because going to be slightly different right so we may have some depending on the nature of the questions that if they don't exactly align that might cause us to look at it differently or pause I'm assuming some questions may be similar but others are going to be drastically different um and then even the tools that we have um that we've been working with uh at at Advance in some of the workshops that we've gone to there's other tools and metrics to look at it so it's going to be a little bit different we but our goal is still to increase this Collective efficacy over time not just this year one I think that's going to be

088a long range more of a longer goal for us to make sure that we do that um so again my feedback here will be around differentiating between what you have listed is 24 and 25 school year goals if we cannot accomplish goal two within 2425 I'd like to see a plan for like what that actually is going to look like when do we expect to have completed the steps that we're going to take that will actually increase in increased Collective efficacy of school staff we're just redoing the survey this year and going to get a new new data set and then work to improve that next year then we can't actually say whether or not we've achieved this goal too by the end of this year yeah I won't I won't know without giving that

089survey and then taking a look at it because I'm not sure exactly with all the new questions are on that survey so I um my assumption is that there's going to be something listed there that is very similar to I believe the school effectively addresses behavior issues but if the wording is slightly different then it yes it will be a baseline so then that will change the these goals and again this is a living doc I don't want to restrict us to being like this is it and it's got to happen I get your point but it may happen over more time so I think if we if we have a five-year plan and we're listing out goals for one school year that we are halfway through we should have a clear point of view

090on what we should be accomplishing over the next five to six months I understand that that may change what we do over the next foure period but my point is that we need to have something that says what what what we set out to do are we successful that we can like confidently say when we get to the evaluation period for this whether or not this is working the way we want yes or no we accomplish this but just for clarity and for my information right as I read this I read these as two separate goals right now right number one is to implement a new school climate survey right something new is going to be imp implemented in 2425 yep but we have data that that tells us right now 67% of our staff

091responded favly I believe School effectively addresses behavior issues are we not and I guess this is the question are we not today putting steps in place to increase that 67% with the survey that's going to go out this spring are we not putting steps in place today too yeah I mean are we I mean we we have this data that came out from last year yeah I'm under the assumption that we have we have information and we have taken steps that when we do this survey in the spring of 25 our expectation is that 67% is higher we're hoping so yes but again I don't know the exact language of the survey if it's going to match this specifically but but the survey again that's why I'm saying the survey is one thing you're going

092put a new survey in place that's he's using the survey results as the measurement for whether or not the goal has been achieved and that's why he's saying that if the survey changes then it's a new Baseline and can't say and that's kind of my point can't you just have two surveys ask the same old questions and then ask new questions on a separate survey for comparative purposes yes but I know that we have to implement a new school climate survey by state mandate I know Amy had her hand up too so she's chopping at the bit to say something please Amy flowchart it's have so we should have some kind ofel go not try to this open isn't overarching so the point of this plan is to be communicating with microphone um the for

093me the point of this plan is to be communicating and getting input from the community stakeholders like everybody in around the place so for people who are not part of this how do we know that the goal has been achieved if I'm just a parent in the school and you're telling me the goal is to increase Collective efficacy of school staff to systematically address challenging behaviors 90% of parents have already saying that they think the school's handling this well so what are we saying to the those people this is actually what we were looking to this is what we're concerned about and here's how we're going to improve it and then we will know that this is improved when we see this stuff that's what I want to see and I'm not worried about all

094of the sausage like the meat that goes into the sausage or whatever but that's what I want to be very clear about you're telling a parent hey we have an issue here and we're looking to address this how are you communicating that to them in a way that they can objectively look and say oh you did meet your goal um or no we didn't that's what I'm getting at y so then I then again I'm just going to bring this back to a pretty very simple Point here should goal two be restricted to year 2425 or should you say that that is a longer term goal unequivocally longer term goal okay unequivocally 24 and Beyond Beyond I have a question I I think so like I come from a corporate world so I'm used to

095looking at like operational plans and like engag it's like there totally different so I think that's kind of where we're like at a you know that's where the difference is coming from I think if you just maybe like break it maybe visually break it down a little bit differently and just put like okay 2024 goals 2025 goal I mean I don't know I think there's a way to break it down easier to get what she's saying because I see what you're saying and I see what you're saying because this could be a massive document yeah I don't want a big massive document I don't care about that I want somebody who is not sitting in the curriculum meetings or sitting in the school climate meetings to be able to say hey we are doing what

096we set out to do and our long range planning and I don't see how we're getting that or making that clear to people I'm totally in agreement with that but again for me that that means the goal too is to set the baseline or something like that for this year if that's what if we're standing out goals for 2425 all you're trying to accomplish this year is set the Baseline do you understand what I'm saying [Music] y yep I for longer yep yep totally understand you look like you wanted to say something very holistic multifaceted multi measure approach so can't went upss all we end yep I think that's that's why it's hard for us sometimes to put I agree and I don't want check boxes either I don't I don't know how better and

097dearg I know that you kind of like are understanding where I'm coming from here [Music] yeah BL do clearly yeah no one would know that yeah so by looking at it think you're saying I'm what you're saying how are we how is someone else being able to hold us accountable to meeting our strategic goals how do we know that what you set out to do is like we're getting there or we're making progress against this we can go yeah and I'm again I'm also the same thing you know but like when we talked about the earlier thing it was like Hey the implement of the curriculum has four steps you guys know the path that you're doing for this stuff how can we document the path that you're looking to take for this stuff in

098a way that somebody who's reading it can be like oh here are the four steps for this and we are we have completed step one this year we don't know how long it's going to take to get through steps two or four because we're learning that as we go but this is what the entire process looks like at a very easy level like again I'm not looking for anything here but yes yes so again for 2425 is our goal just we are establishing the baselines for all of this stuff part of it where we're at yes and no right part of it where we're at at this time of the school year and when how we're presenting it now part of it yes but part of it also no and that's just the nature of

099when we're presenting these these particular um District goals I don't really understand you mean like are you saying that like part of these all of this is already some of this has already been done some were in process yeah and then other pieces are obviously not obviously they're just going to continue on with revisions over time because it's alive it's not it's not done and it's not and some is unknown like I said when I was originally starting because there are so many pieces that we won't know the answers to without having the Baseline which we did put it's somewhere in the introduction I remember writing it um that we need that information first to then catapult from there and move forward so that's why the revision process is critical I think coming back at

100at least twice a year to the board and presenting this information is critical and adjusting um and I think we'll have a better clearer picture as we get more time to look at the data and look at the trends and things that are we're noticing across all of them for teaching and learning for culture and climate and especially the the development of a vision of a learner there's I canot there's no way I could just say hey this is what I think it's going to look like we're GNA get to that point I don't know yet because there's so many other steps that we have to take right to get there um so yes and no for me sorry this is what we're working on the next months iage yes I'm going to be real

101short and singular and focus here the six when I look at the data the 67% of Staff saying that we believe we address behavior issues effectively seems low to me as a teacher and I would not want to have avoid that by just having a new survey and pretending that goes away I would ask that question again uh is a teacher I would want that question ask again I've seen this happen in my teaching years you know we'll bring up something and then they'll just reinvent the wheel to move on past it and that seems low to me and I would ask that question again that's mying I'm not making the statement that that question's going to go away I just think it may be worded slightly different but still have the same spirit and

102intent and then once we collect that information we could address it going forward from there je but I get I get what you're saying yes sir so again on the same question 67% of Staff how many staff were surveyed I'd have to go back and look I don't have that a majority I would say 90 something percent of the staff took the survey at least what's the number oh I don't because if it's 10 people one person had a bad day swings 10 points that's the point yeah it's a majority of our staff so I would is it a large number is it 30 oh my gosh I'm trying to have my photographic memory work if it's 30 each person's three and a half per. if Mr Carlson's numbers are right it's 37 certified and

10324 non-certified but who resp how many respondents one one bad day or two people had a bad day it goes up six points now six points and if he goes up six points that we're doing great but just only because two people had a better day that day MH we're putting a lot of emphasis on this percentage Point that's my point if it's a small cohort it's it's GNA swing all over the place you got it yeah it's it's districtwide and I I know it's a majority of our staff I just don't know the exact number Amy do you have all of those [Music] so again just so we can keep going so we can keep going here again if I summarize what I heard through the ation that just happened I think I heard

104two important things that the board is looking for one when it comes to setting the goals again and I'm going to summarize and tell me if this is correct the board and again I would agree that the board is looking for more defined targets for the current year I understand from my perspective all of your your your your thoughts and your perspective of you don't know where you're going to be right there's going to be things that change you don't know where You' be but we have to take a shot at setting a Target there may be reasons you don't hit that Target but we can't set ourselves up to always beat the Target right is I think what I'm hearing and I would agree right we can't set ourselves up to beat the Target

105because we don't know we don't know right so we have to put a Target out there based on your best estimation of where you're going to be in the process of what whatever that process might be right but there's got to be a goal somewhere we've got to go after the second thing I heard and I would agree with this as well and and Frank you're absolutely right I don't think that we send any question that says anything different than the question we sent last night like we're worried about 67% right even if it has to be on its own we should survey our staff with the same exact question they responded to that gave us the 67% number right I don't know that's that's my opinion again I'm I'm summarizing what I heard but

106I'm also you know giving my own opinion and I want to um I think you surmised that really well in terms of my concerns my biggest concern is not when someone we put this plan out there and then we say this is what our goal is when we say that this is done or if we get four years into this process and we don't have a way of saying whether or not was effective how are we holding ourselves accountable for that in a way that makes sense to other people I don't want to go down this road and then kind get to the end of it and be like we're using all this different evaluation criteria and like hey the stuff we originally looked at over here that made us think we needed to fix

107this is still bad but all this other stuff over here looks good and like we're winners in that situation like I would like to be a little bit more consistent with what we're looking at understanding what that is and making sure that we are holding ourselves accountable to that same piece here I know that there are different moving pieces with with students and teachers and all of that I just don't think that we can set a goal and not be clear on the goal evaluation criteria um and then have that be a meaning it's not a meaningful process to me because you can just come back and say well the goal was this and now I'm using all these other things to say that we hit it and just kind of cherry-picking the data to

108support that whether or not we meical I feel like they have you have that I think what we're missing here I mean I don't know I'm getting tired so I think I'm missing something but I literally think you have it you just haven't put it on the document like I'm envisioning a live Google Document where you guys are literally I don't even care if it's 37 steps at this point like write all that stuff down that you guys are already doing and that you yourselves internally are keeping track of like you have all this stuff internally that you're talking about that none of us even are aware like you're doing so much so just put it on the paper I guess and delineate 2024 this was the goal these are the steps step one two

109and three we've done step one so far we're working on step two now we're going to go to step three like you already doing it you're talking about it amongst yourselves it's just we're confused because we don't see it on this document and this document is very confusing right they're already doing it you have what she's asking for you I'm pretty sure it's just we haven't put it on the document am I wrong I think that's part of the summary of what we're okay you have the information I think just give us just give it to us and show us the steps and make it a little bit clearer you're you're already we're done you got you got it you're already doing it we just want to see it I think is what what the

110problem is I think am I understand that and I'm going to say that this becomes at least what I'm envisioning is this is this becomes a rolling document so the problem we have right now is the catchup yep of what's not on the document because things already happened y I think that I think the board is asking for a summarization of what's been done to date just to know where we are in the process and then what the Target or the goal is for the next step of the process by the end of 2425 and next year this document again is a rolling document so now we know what we did and now we're going to Target the following year do that make sense it does yeah I think that was part of our intent

111and unfor you know following where we are it's kind of makes it fuzzy this is a dumb question but is it just would it be more cohesive to present this at a different time of year so it's not so confusing uh it could it could have helped in C in certain components of it yeah yeah because if it were at the beginning of the year and the Baseline was created and we're further into the school year and then we could say hey yeah we've completed this component here are the steps that we've taken and how do we know we're done or how we know we've completed that step I mean it would be at a different pace and different process at a different point in the year I I don't necessarily think that's true because

112why you should know what you've already done this year like just if done the step I don't really I'm not saying that I'm saying for next year if we were in the beginning of the year next year then I would be able to say hey last year we've completed this so she what she's talking about is time of year where where we are right now is in the middle so it just makes it a little bit more confusing I point very well take and understood okay all right so uh I would like to unless there's more we'd like to propose to come back we'll table this and re uh bring it back to us in uh in February with a little bit more uh meat and potatoes on it if you will with some steps

113and some different pieces um and looking at them by year so I think we've got it I'm good with that everybody good to move on all right item c 25 26 Calendar yes calar so thank you to the board we had um made some adjustments in our December board meeting those calendars are now um posted online so those are available for the public both our school calendar and our Board of Education calendar um so those are again posted to our website just a just a quick update on those okay that concludes the superintendent's report you believe that um longest one on record are there any question good it's good it's good all good are there any uh further questions for superintendent going once going twice it's gone all right Board of Education chair's report um

114I am going to be very brief on this again I talked about the subcommittee discussion we talked about it last week I think the subcommittee as I see subcommittees have really uh been re-energized you know between curriculum that we just went through in detail uh plan facilities and operations there's been several of those meetings lately going through some some things that'll be reported on once we have some more information um policy clearly we have some policies to review today negotiations was ongoing so again that that that jump start to each of these subcommittees has been great um the one that I would like to make sure we get scheduled if it's not to date is community relations Rel yeah right so if we can get that one going again if there's another subcommittee they're all

115posted on our website you all know what membership you're you have on them if there's something that you or a meeting that you'd like to have but we should be relooking at each one of these as all right good routine business uh we have the approval of the minutes from the December 3rd 2024 that was a virtual meeting are there any uh can I get a motion to approve motion to approve the meetings meeting minutes from December 3rd 2021 motion by Kristen can I get a second second by dear Dre any discussion seeing none all those in favor please signify by raising your hand all those opposed and any obss so we have um how many do we have we on we have eight eight of us here 801 701 yeah I can't do math

116no 701 one Z8 so Tom abstained because he wasn't part of the meeting right um the next item is the approval of the expenditure report uh can I get a motion to approve make the motion what we got Tom Buzz I'll second it second by Tim Russell all right any discussion any questions comments on the expend expenditure report seeing none all those in favor please by raising your hand that is unanimous okay moving on to the next agenda item under new business uh we have looks like four policies or actually three policies and one bylaw uh to review Penny typically brings us through that yep I could these do you want do these need to go today or do you want to take these yeah we could because we want to have first read and

117second read we've already scheduled a second policy subcommittee meeting for Thursday and we're going to have additional ones to have first and second reads uh going February into March good all right so policy 1327 is um a practice that we already are engaged in this just puts it into our policy manual and codifies it this is that we engage with um our Winchester Youth Services Bureau uh we have a yearly meeting scheduled with them in terms of uh some of the pro uh programs that they offer and supports they also support us here at an anini school and with this basically States it's a component for student privacy so if you've read this policy over it is making sure that information that needs to be shared is only shared that needs to be number one

118and that has uh educational interests it's not just because someone wants to know something about a kid so so they support our students they take care of our students that's what this policy is in place to do we've already met and signed the memorum of agreement with them have no issues we feel very well supported um by them and the likewise it's a wonderful relationship so that's policy p1327 uh policy sorry do you want to stop again any all changes are highlighted in in red right so again um outside of that these are these comes straight to us from C so does anybody have any questions based on your review right this will move to a second read at our February meeting next one policy 4222 is um again from uh State legislation um working

119towards making sure that our par educators are called par Educators not tutors not not all these different titles that's what this did uh it's Public Act 2441 an act concerning educator certification teachers par Educators and mandated reporter requirements so that's what this has done um that's the essence of this policy it's making sure that we recognize them as par Educators not that all of these different uh titles why do we have the strikeout for with instructional duties what's that strike out for uh that is for title one and how do we we we communicate this differently to our our our parents what do we say about the title one piece why do we cross this off subcommittee I'm forgetting for the par Educators okay yeah no when we met we said we didn't need this

120form so okay thank you okay any questions on p422 two all right again this will be second read in February yeah uh for P51 31.817324 this is regarding electronic devices our team went through this uh with tooth and comb I felt this was probably one of the most uh scrutinized policies that we've had in a while but with very good intention because this policy really puts a lot of the onus on um families and parents as well as our school staff to make sure that students are being safe they understand um the ramifications but also that cell phones and things of that nature are not allowed in the schools because of the distractions social media implications if you haven't read anxious generation please read read it um it's very very eye openening um so this

121basically puts into place all of the um important barriers and uh distracting limitations within our school day so we've gone through we've even on the bus we've talked about that uh when the school day ends when the school begins it's very clear now in our policy as to um the restrictions on cell phone usage because of the significant I'll put it out their dangers that they POs to our our young ones so I would like to Jeff if you don't mind if everyone's looking through that a lot of the strikeouts on the policy are because there was a lot of language in there around being able to use the cell phone for school purposes because it was for K through 12 and we were just like no small children don't need to do that so

122if you're that was sort of the impetus behind it yeah I have a question yes sir so I just I was reading through the policy Elementary School students May possess cellular telephones possess them and other Wireless communication devices on school property and school sponsored Transportation the bus provid such devices are not visible used or activated and are kept in an off position throughout the instructional day so this Blends this first sentence Blends both non-instructional day and into the instructional day I'm confused as to what as a parent I would if I read that like well you can't use it on the bus at all you can possess it you can possess it yeah but so so some parents some parents are going to say well no matter what I want to be able to communicate

123with my child but it's off all the time yeah I mean I'm not opposed to I'm not arguing with it I'm just saying to me it's not written clearly meaning um between the bus and the school day start well Elementary School students May possess cellular telephones they hold it an on on school property yeah they could have them as long as they're not and and on the use activate right provided such devices are not visible what in her pocket use or in their backpack yeah typically in backpacks or activated and are kept in the off position so they're complet all in order for them they use it it have to be some sort of ask permission emergency I got a call yeah so phone has to be off all the time yeah that's the intent

124of this policy that is that's exactly right ask somebody to go anduse it they feel need to call call you and okay I'm not F I'm fine with it I just still want to make sure it's clear so just for clarification again I I'm I'm on board with this as well but this would say the instructional school day starts when definition and later on correct if you right so it sounds that that's where I was going so it sounds yeah but to me this is this is the school building until the final dismissal Bell so that would mean on the school bus when they are on the ride here they can use their phones no the school but it's again that's why it says you can have you can possess the phone on a on

125school property and on the bus you can possess it MH but it can't be visible used on being activated and and it's kept in the opposition so you're you basically the kid can take the a phone that's dead basically turned off no power to it and put it in his backpack and that's the extent of his possession of that phone until such point he asks an adult I need to call my mother or the mother calls the school and says have Johnny turn his phone on I got to talk to him whatever that otherwise the phone's off no batter uses whatsoever the time he walks out the door that's B yes who's enforcing it School administration teachers staff bus bus to yeah more importantly who's enforcing it on the bus bus driver bus reports conduct

126reports right yeah I don't know how you would possibly that well I mean that's well no but it's our policy this is right the school day is the most important yeah that is uh for number two that's where that's where I'm stuck right is we're saying they can't have it on the bus on the way to school or somewhere else but the in the school day is defined from the time they enter school to it should be a three three-word no phone USIC or else that's all it needs to say I'm not I'm not seeing it when I look at elementary school student on page one I'm seeing that it's it's defining that you can't have it during the school day and I would also search this document for when you're changing you have another

127reference to instructional school day so instructional school day yeah yeah no do you see here still call you're calling it out so I would search this document for any reference to instruction school do all right because you haven't removed them all but what I'm reading here is that the instructional school day is when they can't have it they can't have it on the instructional school day or on school property can't be on was the intention but again what I'm what I'm saying is item one here is is defining that but it's calling it out during the school day school day definition is saying that's the time from the time the B bell rings I'm sorry till they enter the school till when the bell rings those aren't align with each other we added we added

128we add that school sponsor Transportation could be between the time they enter school they go on a field trip yeah it could be any come back but this doesn't say to me again when you define this you define the school day as the moment the student enters school until the final dismissal there's a time before you're saying they can't have it and a time after you're saying they can't have it that's Miss so the easy the easy fix might be to just say the student when the the moment the student enters school property SCH schools not all of them take the bus need to make sure great policy and exits the school so after final dismissal Bell and exits the school bus right because if they're Walkers that's or they're getting picked up that's one

129scenario so then exits the school bus I got it all right we'll retype that up for um the second read okay next bylaw 9030 we've done this we've we actually do this in our board orientation and when I was looking at it the bylaw adopted date um did not have this visits to school uh re um reference so I wanted to bring that to the board's attention we do this you know Tim we did this at the board orientation just recently so when we added that on there all I wanted to do is obviously update the date as well it's our practice this is what we do there's nothing different this is how we interact with our community uh what the expectations are so that's it nothing else out of the ordinary with that all

130right those are all the first reads good moving on to item H uh old business um dear you had an update or just a report out for at Advance yeah there's we have a December one you want me to I you guys don't need to time to read all that's the highlight's advance do a lot of doing a lot of great work um and there's a sheet on here that you have included um so they send this out every month which I really love says here's here's what we're doing here's what's happening and sorry I'm loud um they do this every month they send us a highlight of what's happening what they've been doing which I really like and then the end of the year they send how are they serving you Harford which I

131think is really cool and you can see like what our general membership resources are what we get um somebody asked me the other day what does Ed Advance actually do and I was like I was able to pull up this document I'm like well this is what they actually do um so you can just see you know the the communities and the members that they're serving and what they're doing um and the Direct Services to the district and how their staff are helping us so that was that's that's what you see in front of you um and it just goes into I mean I would if you haven't read it you don't want me to read every piece of this right okay so if you haven't read it and you have questions you know ask

132me but you can see that they're doing quite a bit and when I sent it to Jeff I was like wow we really this membership is really for good um and the December update just a little bit more than what you have on here but there's not really anything that's relevant or anything we need to go detail I don't think okay good y that's it thank you um next item is reports we've covered everything to date so we'll move on to item J public comment for agenda items only all right uh then the next item we will exit the regular meeting and go into executive session we do need to have a motion to enter executive session and also to invite superintendent Sosa into executive session so can I and invite superintendent so motion by

133Frank at what time do we have hi guys thank you 854 second second by Tom Buzzy all those in favor please signif by by raising your hand that is unanimous

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.