CorpusRecord 11646

February 18, 2025 School Board Rezoning Feedback Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Charlottesville City Schools
Date
2025-02-21
Location
Charlottesville city, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,687 words · about 49 min
Collected
2026-06-03

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001balancing balancing enrollment and balancing demographics even so there is there are no easy or Perfect Plans and that's why we've gathered that's why we've gathered to get your feedback tonight we also want to minimize the impact on individual families with the exception of families who live in the dice Street neighborhood who could have who would have an implement ation date of August 2027 these changes would not go in effect until August 2029 until current kindergarteners would enter fifth grade for our current kindergarteners and their younger siblings we have an outl we have outlined some exemptions and options to help families make a plan I would like to thank my advisory committees their thoughtful input has been a key part of this process we also appreciate all the feedback we have received throughout this process to

002date at meetings and emails and via the first survey in addition to the public comments you still can submit feedback via the survey posted on our website until March the 12th as we start this feedback session please remember to clearly state your name and address and we ask that you limit your comments to three minutes we also we are also accepting feedback via Zoom you can find the registration link on our website if you are on Zoom we ask that you turn your camera on while you're presenting your comments and at this time I um open the floor for comments from the public there is a sign up sheet here so that we can just come up in order and I believe the first person who signed up is shaa uh Dan I think okay

003okay okay thank you then uh I guess at this point people can just come up and uh I I think just uh just for recordkeeping this isn't an official board meeting it's it's a listening session but for record keeping it might be good if people sign in it might be it for recordkeeping it might be good if people sign in this isn't an official board meeting where there's any action taken or the board is following an agenda but as a listening session it just might be useful to have a record especially if you have questions that it might be useful for the staff to follow up on the questions or the feedback hello good evening my name is Elizabeth hand uh my family and I live on the 900 block of St CLA Avenue um

004so just north of Route 250 bypass we have a current and a a wouldbe future student eper Maran Elementary School and we walk 0.5 miles to school with our child daily and we oppose the current uh proposed resoning because it significantly reduces walkability throughout the city um while I originally opposed the current resoning due to our own neighborhood's reduced walkability that is because our commute would change from 0.5 miles uh walking to a 3.4 Mile bus my opposition has crystallized upon learning some additional information uh mainly three things uh one Charlottesville residents who do not currently have students attending Charlottesville City Schools were not informed in writing by charville city schools that the resoning is taking place to my knowledge uh while I appreciate the efforts made to hold meetings at some schools um and

005virtually only families of current students and those who follow local news closely uh were made aware of the rezoning since the rezoning will ostensibly last several years if not decades it behooves ccs to approach the city as a whole when planning two Kindle Wood's neighborhood is located 0.5 miles from their Local School Summit elementary school as well and it will also be moved to an unwalkable school that is burley Moran Elementary School while I am person person Ally thrilled that BME could be expanding its socioeconomic racial and linguistic diversity that is if we were allowed to continue attending BME um that would be wonderful to be there to support that however it is in it is counterproductive and unconscionable to uproot Kindlewood from its local school and bust them away in an effort to serve

006them better Kindle Wood's residents are less likely to own a car and have Community or family supports to offset the challenges of living outside of walking distance from their school and I should note that of the 150 families approximately that are represented in Kindlewood about 70 of them do not speak English as their first language um three feedback from the residents affiliated with summon Elementary in last FSE feedback survey uh registered quite low compared to um its current student po population about 22% of the total number of students had a respondent on their behalf that's much lower than B's 55% response rate compared to its student population I don't know of other data that that CCs is taking into consideration by way of feedback but it behooves the CCS school board to involve Kindlewood much

007more before pulling the trigger on this decision thank you good evening my name is Taylor Brown uh I live at 828 St Clair Avenue both my children will go to BME next year um uh first I want to say thanks for the Endeavor to evaluate this ahead of when it's needed uh this planning is really important so I want I want to say thank you um one question I'm assuming that we won't receive answers now but one question that I do have is um you know was was the walkable zones factored into the decision-making process um I totally understand the need and the desire and the importance of levelize socioeconomic outcomes across the schools totally get that and I'm in support of that um it it doesn't seem like the current recommendation took into the

008walkable Zone zones AKA B you know B's current walkable Zone was cut in half and a chunk of summit's walkable Zone was also cut off um my my question you know to the board and staff and the consultant is you know can those sces metrics still be hit while maintaining the walkable zones um you know I think the data shows that communities are strong when they're together right so walking to school you know meeting the neighbors right that that's often times where people meet other for the first time um and that that's really important um a couple of uh of of stats here um option four which the respondent to the survey clearly was uh was overwhelmingly the the number one chose uh chosen option versus the current recommended plan uh the current recommended plan

009would uh would relocate 21.1% more students versus option four the current recommended plan would move a 150 kids from Summit that's half of the current enrolled School base there um 79 kids would be walkable in option four versus 667 in the current recommended plan there'd be a 6.3% improvement with option four I I understand that we need to think about all of the different metrics um my my request to to all those who are considering the option is can we maintain the walkable zones while still hitting the socioeconomic and other metric uh factors so thank [Music] you hi my name is Rashard D suo at 950 Locust Avenue um I don't have a lot to say but what I will say is that um our kids go to Charlottesville Day School currently it was six

010and a foury old but the reason that I wanted us to go to buram morand one of the largest reasons is because I wanted my kids to go to school with their neighbors um we currently go to school where the kids come from everywhere and the idea that we will again possibly have the option of or the opportunity not the opportunity the lack of opportunity to do that uh I think concerns me in that way and that my whole goal of going to public school is that they would be in school with their neighbors and be close and walkable to the house um the other things I'm from Montgomery Alabama so I'm from an area where um segregation was strong and so I've seen kind of firsthand or secondhand when you take people from a

011neighborhood and move them to another how that affects them and it has not really P panned out to be the thing that I think makes the most sense because the resources are still removed from that neighborhood they're not kind of still in that neighborhood and so I I just I'm just curious as to whether or not the thought of reallocating funds to better support the schools that need them as opposed to taking kids and moving them to another school presuming that they're going to get the things that they don't have in their current place and what that does to affect those kids who now go from a place where they may see comfort with people who are more like them to a place when they're not so hello my name is Holly Barton keesling I

012live at 625 Hinton Avenue in between Avon and Kindlewood my son is a third grader at Summit and I have a fifth grader at Walker who attended Summit I'm a co-chair of the PTO but I'm speaking on my own behalf today I support Royal gurley's recommendation for the new upcoming zoning our primary responsibility is to make the decision that is best for all the kids in our community to provide them with love support and the best possible education the current proposal does the best job of that is it best equalizes low sces across the city all other recommendations left Summit with a low sces of close to 80% way higher than anywhere else with other schools as low as 34% why does this matter low sces reflects income education levels and current employment it does

013not mean poor it reflects having fewer advantages having parents who value education but may not have had good educational experiences it reflects families who may have less time because they are working more because their job jobs don't pay well it reflects families who are new immigrants who are navigating things we can't even imagine it does not reflect families who don't love their kids and want what is best for them the reality is that low sces families are very diverse in terms of need but many do need more support concentrating all those kids in one school is harmful to everyone as an aside I graduated from Nelson County High School in 1995 with a family income of $30,000 I didn't have running water until I was seven the house I lived in still has plywood floors

014I went to college where they were looking for lower income kids from rural areas and I was pretty good at basketball and they wanted my perspective that is to say that Burnley Moran is lucky to have the kids from Kindlewood it will enrich the school and I don't want people to forget that and like all parents of kids who attend BME Green Brier Jackson via Johnson or Trailblazers I love my kids school I love Summit I love going to morning meetings and looking out at the very diverse student body of Hispanic kids black students Muslim Students and white students what is a better way for our kids to grow up I love the fact that I know many of these kids from playing in the old Big Field down at kinderwood and I'm truly sad

015that in 5 years the elementary school aged kids on my street won't be classmates with the kids from Kindlewood in an Ideal World I wish that Kindlewood could stay at Summit but I came to the same conclusion as Dr Gurley it is not in the best interest of all the kids my older son spent all in elementary school at Summit he's now in fifth grade at Walker he had four principles and there are only two of his teachers remaining from his five years there while Summit creates a wonderful nurturing environment for the kids that is a harder place to teach than other schools across the district thank you to the committee for all the hard work and thinking about this resoning plan there are many small details in this plan that I really appreciate particularly

016that there may be opportunities from families at Kindlewood with long ties to Summit who could possibly stay but has taught me anything is that we need to consider infrastructure in schools and all of our future development plans a school board member needs to be on the Planning Commission lastly my son was also zoned to move to Burnley Moran in one of the scenarios I told him that if that happened he would have more friends in middle school and I would and he would get to ride the bus he obviously went wanted to stay at Summit but he was open to moving these changes will give us all new opportunities perhaps having a bus will make it easier to get to school Charlottesville is only 10 miles by 10 miles we'll never be very far from

017each other the most important thing is is for us to continue working together as a community to support public education is the most powerful thing that we do together as a society it opens our doors for us to meet people who are different than we are and that's beautiful thank you good evening my name is Conor Welch I live at 10:25 Locust Avenue and I have a daughter who attends kindergarten at Burnley Moran and a son um who may one day as well um I'd like to thank the committee for having and hosting this uh feedback session um uh like others uh you know I feel strongly about this um and I have a few objections as you can imagine um I'm here uh to voice them I I think that the balance uh has

018not been stricken a proper balance for walkability um along with the really important goals of uh better diversity in terms of socioeconomic status um and I think that walk walkability Zone it should be sacred um it's something that's really logical and makes sense if you live a quarter of a mile from an elementary school that your child would walk there would go there would bike there my daughter bikes to school she walks to school some mornings when we have a little more time and I think that's really important and that's lost when she's going on a bus three miles to Greenbrier um I think that there's also an opportunity it was sort of a strange thing when the um the email came through last January uh that the recommended plan wasn't one of the four

019that we voted for um I say voted for for um offered our feedback about and everyone submitted um and so I would ask the committee what was our what was our feedback for and how was it incorporated into the final plan there's like kind of a dark sort of like unclear element is like this feedback was sought solicited and and was kind of overwhelmingly in favor of one of the proposals and then what came out was actually none of the proposals sort of this unique one um but again I do appreciate that you're hosting in these feedback sessions I think like someone mentioned earlier um I don't think there was enough notice about it I know you had a few sessions maybe at the end of October but that was before that there was anything

020to look at meaningfully or that that I knew of there were no proposals at that time um and uh so I I really I think that there's a better balance to strike on the walkability and I think it's just it kind of defies logic that you could be a quarter mile from an elementary school and not attend that elementary school um and Burnley mirand is uniquely cleaved in half by this 250 um and I think that's uh you know a great mistake thanks for your time hello I'm Aon Feldman I live on River Vista Avenue uh just on the other side of Long Street from berley Moran and around the corner from CLA my kids are grown now they're 20 and 23 but when they were young I took great pleasure in Walking them to

021and from school ber Moran and U it was helped to create the part of the community of me go go there and play on the playground after uh school and walk home and it saddens me that other families might not have the opportunity to uh participate in their neighborhood school like this like my family enjoyed and so I've just come to add my voice to the others who U want their kids to go to their neighborhood [Music] school good evening School Board my name is Janette Scot and I live at 1209 St George Avenue I live in the Locust Grove neighborhood and I'm a parent to a current Burnley Moran student and a future Burnley Moran student with the proposed rezoning plan our home would be rezoned to Green Brier Elementary School anyone who is

022out and about in our neighborhood at 7:30 a.m. will see the groups of Joyful families and children as they walk to school walking to Burnley Moran has become part of the culture of our neighborhood it would be an immense loss to our community to negatively impact the ability of students to walk to school not only is walking to school convenient for many families Studies have shown there are many benefits as well walking can improve students attention span physical health and lower stress as a teacher myself I understand the issues affecting Summit Elementary School and the desire to balance socioeconomic status amongst the schools however I found it alarming that there were only 67 responses affiliated with Summit Elementary School on the fall survey compared to bm's 161 responses I do not feel confident that the

023voices of the families currently zoned to Summit were heard especially the families in Kindlewood some of whom face language barriers I would not want to assume what the families of Kindle would want but there has to be some value in their ability to walk to school as well picking up a sick child attending family events and volunteering at school are some areas in which proximity to a school building could be important to families when I first heard of the rezoning plans I wrongly assumed that we would not be affected because we're in the walking zone of BME after the first round of survey results were shared I felt relieved to see that most people preferred option four which would keep us at BME and most people disliked option one which had the biggest shift of

024students however that relief was shortlived as the proposed resoning plan was announced last month rezoning Charlottesville schools will have a long- lasting impact and I would encourage spending more time thinking through other options that could allow for more diverse socioeconomic status in the schools across the city as well as maintain better walkability and less impact on students thank you for your time good evening my name is Brad Connors uh my family lives at 1201 bellw which is in the Locust Grove neighborhood um which you've heard a lot from this evening uh I have a nine-year-old seven- year-old and a three-year-old this decision would impact our three-year-old um is this a conversational or are you just listening okay um to I I Echo everyone in our neighborhood what you're sharing um about the walkability two um

025possibly different thoughts one it uh I believe the or from the communication it felt like the the highest area of need may have shifted in December in the middle of this process or one floated to the top um it was presented to us that there were five or six main concerns or bullet points that we were trying to capture with the rezoning and then um one floated to the top uh and I and that was the socioeconomic distribution within the city so if that were the case which I believe it to be true then I think the four options that were given to the community should be void and we start the process again if one if one initiative truly became the most important so that's the one thing I wanted to share and then

026the second thing that I wanted to share is that there there is this feel a growing feeling of distrust between the board and the community um and this is another example in that um and I'll share some from the past like and this is a small example of naming of the schools two years ago we went through this huge process a community event of coming up with a school name um and then at the end of that process we selected a name and the board squashed it and said nope we're not going to do that and then round two another process of choosing a name for the school of those four options then after round two the board says nope we're not going to do that and now our name is Sunrise Elementary which is

027a beautiful name but the process to get to that name felt like a huge disconnect between the board and the community asking for our input and then completely disregarding it um and that feels like the pro that exact scenario is happening here but with much bigger impact on our families and communities so I just wanted to share that that is a growing sentiment in our community of this massive disconnect in leadership asking for input and response and surveys and then it really feels like just total disregard for input I mean the data suggests across the city surveys the biggest amount of support for option number four and that was not the option that was was uh moving forward from your end so I just wanted to share of a huge um disconnect in the processes

028that we have been involved in in the last few years thank you hi there um again um appreciate you taking the feedback from the community tonight uh my name is Corey AER I um I'm a resident of the northeastern Charlottesville neighborhood Locust Grove I had two children ATT 10 Burnley Moran and um currently one in the school system uh I've sent a lot of my uh personal thoughts um already directly through the feedback channels um it would really i' like to use the opportunity to talk to the room to let um people here know that you should probably spread the word there are other people um that I think we've heard already um that haven't spoken yet so I think there's more voices in the community across the city that be interested to hear their

029feedback um there's a few data points I think that are interesting um Citywide from the consultant at the question and answer session um the previous session on this topic um that the statistic was the walkability excuse me across the city was reduced from 42% to 36% so that's a that's an across the city metric that measures one of the um criteria or goals of the rezoning and uh yeah I'd like to Echo I think some of the suggestions to uh take a look at this topic of resoning take a look at the goals and prioritization of the goals keeping the priorities keeping the waiting which topics are important for the community but bringing forward more measurables on some of the goals for which we haven't really received a lot of measurable data yet so we

030have the metrics on SCS metrics on walkability I gave you one for the city which came from the consultant for the neighborhood for the school um my measure was something between 800 and 900 addresses that are going to be sliced from Burnley Moran Zone and Reed District to Green Brier so that's a data point those data points can be measured across the city the impact can be measured that can be measured measurable quantitative data point that can be used together with some of the other goals that you have of community neighborhood cohesion um transportation Logistics diversity and inclusion all those metrics I think could be balanced better um my personal opinion is that there's more work to do here and uh that's my my request is that we we consider the the impact of this

031and take more time to make the best decision thank you [Music] if there's anybody on the zoom call who wishes to make public comment um you can use the raise hand feature and we'll promote you one at a time for a three minute speaking period um and just give us some patience as we uh try to pipe that sound through so that the board members can hear it for hello yes uh we can hear you and we'll uh set the timer for three minutes thank you Mr CUO um my name is Ariel Bruner I live at 293 Tennis Drive um in Charlottesville I am a third grade teacher at Summit Elementary um and I wasn't going to speak tonight but I feel kind of compelled to do so because I I understand a lot of

032the community members that have spoken um and their thoughts of kind of not feeling like every voice has been heard um which I agree is true um however I think that I also want to say to Dr Gurley and to the board that I appreciate the fact that one of the leading principles guiding you in deciding which particular rezoning um to follow is looking at more Equitable socioeconomic status um being a teacher in Summit I see how we have the highest um students that are disadvantaged and more housing units can create even more of that population and I see how we have had several teachers who are not able to stay in Summit because it is a very challenging school to work in because of the amount of students that we have that are disadvantaged

033um I think something that we need to remember is the privilege that we have um and the privilege that a lot of the community members that have spoken have as well as my own and understand that walkability should not be the leading cause going and playing at a playground which all of the Charlottesville School Playgrounds are considered public access after a certain time so regardless of what school your Zone to you can play at any of them I don't think that should be the number one priority with we're thinking about what is going to keep our teachers in the buildings what is going to best serve every single one of our students academically emotionally and socially rather than thinking of just walkability from what I'm hearing a lot of people are saying they agree with

034inclusion they support those things and diversity however walkability is something that should be a non-negotiable and to me when we're thinking about our children and we're thinking about educating them getting them the services and the best services that they need and also retaining teachers especially in these buildings that do have higher populations of disadvantaged students we need to take into consideration spreading them out and I just appreciate Dr Gurley and the board for making that a priority um thank you for your time e are you able to hear us I see last name of STG i l l you're un a to unmute at this time and give your public comment for three minutes great can you hear me yes perfect thank you and thank you board for taking the time uh to listen to

035us today my name is batty stur and I'm a resident uh on River Vista AV in Locust Grove neighborhood currently have a first grade enrolled at BME uh as well as a future kindergartener uh we can literally see BME from our street and uh are obviously respectfully requesting that the school board reconsider the decision to rezone our neighborhood to Green Brier one important fact I think I'd like to point out is we're using this term walkability but it's really a sense of community um that we have built over the years of having our walking bus go to school uh kids kids have gotten to know each other low soci andeconomic kids have gotten to play with uh you know different diversity kids and it's really built a sense of community that is going to be

036missed if we have to drive and bus our kids uh we're daily Walkers to and from BME and I cannot stress enough how walking has given our family that again that sense of community how much uh my partner and I have become involved in the PTO um because of of the sense of community we're getting and being so close to our school um instead of sitting in car distracted by traffic we're able to talk to the day uh with our first grader we hear what she's learned what fun things have happened what she or even what she's struggled with we talk about the silly things difficult things and everything in between um we walk with neighborhood families building bonds and relationships we volunteer for those PTO events that we wouldn't really know otherwise but from

037word of mouth on these uh these walks that we get in but again I really want to stress when I'm using that term walkability I'm really talking about community and building those uh not only bonds within our family but within uh our neighborhood as well uh and I respectfully ask that the decision be reconsidered thank you okay we'll do one more round if there is anybody that is um on the attendees list in the zoom webinar there is a raised hand button if you'd like to use that will allow you to have uh permission to speak up on the stage here for up to three minutes [Music] okay I see a user with the last name d a v i s I'm promoting your role you should be able to unmute and provide your public

038comment just let us know that you can hear us hi my name is Colleen Davis can you hear me okay uh yes thank you great I live at 909 St Clair AB um in the Locust Grove neighborhood I can see the Burnley Moran Elementary School from my house um and I just want to say first of all thank you for hosting this and for giving um us the opportunity to provide comments tonight we appreciate it um I do share some concerns that have already been voiced uh specifically around the quick timeline of this planning process uh the lack of awareness and communication and uh the decreased walkability across the plan um including the Kindlewood and Locust grow communities so U regarding awareness I wanted to talk a little bit about the fact that some neighbors

039and I have been trying to raise awareness in several communities that are really impacted by this proposal and we are finding very low awareness and that is a big concern to us I um I know I won't get this answer tonight but I would definitely like to know more about Outreach um any that has been done specifically at Kindlewood it seems that awareness is very low there and I would definitely like to feel confident that your plan incorporates their very valuable feedback regarding um the Locust grow community I have reviewed all of the information you've provided I have um read through your FAQs um and all the arguments about why Locust Grove needs to go to Green Brier and the main issue I have with this is that it completely sacrifices walkability for the goal

040of the U balancing socioeconomic diversity across the schools and I agree that that's important but I don't think they need to be mutually exclusive I think both can be achieved with a few small changes to your plan and I would really like to see you all consider ideas that some of us have um it would help achieve that finally my comments about the timeline um I believe that it seems pretty rushed especially considering the current proposal isn't even one of the four that was originally circulated and considering um the new priority that was announced well into the uh process about the um rebalancing of socioeconomic diversity across the schools so I want to be clear that I absolutely recognize this is a huge undertaking and a large amount of work has already been um done

041but I think that since your plan results in some really large changes to our entire Community um I think that alone is deserving of sufficient time and attention to get this right I don't think that a few more months in the planning process will have any significant impact on your timeline and I truly believe that with some small changes it's possible to implement a plan that achieves the school board's objectives keeps your plan largely intact but also addresses a lot of the concerns that we've heard tonight um also including walkability so I am respectfully asking that you delay the March vote on the current plan and consider a few adjustments to the plan and also gather and incorporate more Community feedback thank you again for the opportunity to speak with you tonight and I um

042I look forward to working with you on this process okay is there anybody else in the attendees gallery on the zoom webinar who wishes to provide um up to three minutes of public comment just simply need to raise your hand using the tool um found on your computer or phone okay I see a hand raised um last name is a n d r s o n um be promoting you to speak please um state your name and address um for the board and you will have three minutes for a public comment my name is Aisha Anderson I live at 2334 Rolland Road s in Scottsville Virginia I am the secretary at uh Elementary School um did you hear me Mr CUO yes yeah we hear you yes um I am speaking up solely on behalf

043of myself and some of the community members that I have heard back from um I heard some of the things that have been stated um tonight so and the walkability is the one that sticks out the most for me because of um they different things that come into play with the walkability um like attendance and being accreditation um all of those things and when kids are out sick because they're walking in 28 degree weather or below um even though they have the proper gear and we make sure that they have what they need they're still getting sick they're still missing school um some of the things that Ariel pointed out um Ariel Bruner is that um it is to hold and withhold teachers in the building it is um draining at some point to a

044lot of us me being here at Clark for 19 years I've seen a lot happen um I've seen a lot of change within the division um the walkability piece is a big concern um for me as I run the walking bus in our Zone um we have families that carpol together and I heard somebody make the statement about a sense of community well I'm sorry when you look at the walking bus and you see the students that are on our walking bus they are black and brown students um half of the parents are single parents don't have cars don't have things um so it's not Equitable or feasible for some to be able to do certain things if some of our kids you know are housed over to Burley Moran um it's just a lot

045I think um I I had a parent reach out to me just a few minutes ago last minute information that was put on her doorstep at Kindlewood um she wasn't aware that there was a bust where they could be bust over there to be to be able to speak to the board tonight so I just think the lack of information that is getting out I heard one parent say you want our feedback but then it's like it's in a sense brushed under the rug I hear that a lot from a lot of parents so maybe the way we're choosing to reach out to families um to get information or to get feedback maybe need maybe we need to do something different I know we've had meetings in the communities at the school um and it

046seems like as it's getting closer I'm hearing more voices speak up and I'm trying to encourage people to speak to the board to email the board to to get um answers that they need so with all that being taken into consideration um I mean I know the change is going to happen regardless whether we give our feedback or not but there are have been some very good points made but I wanted to speak on behalf of my school alone [Music] okay I guess we'll do one more round of attendees who may be listening on the zoom webinar there's a public comment you wish to make please use the tool on your device to raise your hand so that we can promote you to uh the panel and give you three minutes up to three minutes

047for your public comment [Music] okay at this time I'm not seeing any um attendees in the zoom webinar with a hand raised [Music] yeah is there anybody else in the audience who wishes to give uh public comment at this [Music] time hi my name is Myrtle hin so I was I didn't come to speak I came to listen I do come to stand for kinderwood families because that's who I deal with every [Music] day though they are just getting into the process believe ye me this these are families that care about their children they care and they they want you to care also so even though they're just getting there I committing myself to working with them to let them know to educate them one word alone rezoning and Zoning terminology that most of you

048all might know but they may not understand so I want you to know that from our perspective Community wise we're willing to work with you all if you are willing to work with us and just know that they will be well represented thank you all e for [Music] all right at this time we will um the board is going to take a 10-minute break we will U all those who want to stay absolutely uh can stay and then the board will resume taking public comment at um 605 spe even e oh I didn't even see that [Music] it's [Music] are you scar I saw one or two did you see the new one I did not no one of them passed away e e e spe [Music] all right we are um we are now

049going to resume I do want to thank everyone who came forward um during our first hour um to provide comments to the board uh please know that we are capturing your um comments and concerns and we do anticipate um that we will be providing um additional feedback to you all um at this point we will um allow for comments from the audience again as well as anyone in the um Zoom room hi my name is Ali Sturgill and I'm a resident on River Vista Avenue in the Locust Grove neighborhood I currently have a first grader enrolled at BME and a future kindergarten we can see BME from our street in fact I can see it from my yard um I'm respectfully asking that the school reconsider the decision to rezone the Green Brier our neighborhood

050to the Green Brier School we're daily Walkers to and from BME and I can't stress enough how walking to and from has given our family a sense of community and how much it has gotten my partner and I involved in the PTO and instead of sitting in the car distracted by traffic we're able to talk about the day with our first grader and other children um and we are involved in the walking bus the relationships sense of community and pride for one school will be lost with the proposed rezoning the rezoning is illogical for Locust Grove we're fully aboard on board with the values that have been stated um as part of this resoning but it's just not quite logical and I encourage you guys to think about a way that we can make these

051changes align with those goals but protect Community because that's what we'll be lost thanks hello my name is Eduardo I live in Coleman Street uh B 912b why do they want to move uh um um Burly Moran people because um for me burle Moran is the close to school because when I walk to school I can talk to my friends and other people thank you for all me talking let me walk to school we'll just give the same reminder for the attendees on Zoom if you do wish to provide a a public comment for up to three minutes at any point during this uh during this meeting just simply raise your hand and we will make sure that you have that opportunity again you just simply need to raise your hand in the attendee gallery

052and that will signify to me that you'd like to make public comments thank you for so of I everyone coming tonight to com to us we areed to here until that's hi I'm Lauren wington I uh live in Locust Grove um I have a first grader and a future kindergartner trust has all already been mentioned so I'd like to build on that at first you outlined five priorities for rezoning but when decisions were made four of those priorities were abandoned in favor of just one socioeconomic balancing and when we ask why we can't get a clear answer that makes sense we need transparency why is socioeconomic balancing so so important to the school board that you're willing to override overwhelming Community opposition lack of diversity in and of itself is not inherently a problem so

053what is it so what is the problem you're trying to solve it feels like you have another agenda entirely this isn't about overcrowding is it without transparency we're left to do our own research and draw our own conclusions so here's what I found according to virginia.gov summit's reading pass rate is 1% and its math pass rate is 49% that tells me that these students need more help and more resources considering 21% of summit students speak English as a second language it's not surprising that they may require additional support but wouldn't it be so easy to just move 150 of those struggling students to the highest performing School in the district the numbers would just balance themselves out instant Improvement Kindlewood is a community where many families rely on walking and public transportation you want to

054move those students farther from their homes making it harder for parents to stay involved in their children's education the school board should be removing barriers for these families not adding new ones without transparency the only conclusion that I can draw is that the board is prioritizing appearances over actual solutions by shifting students around you can make District wide test scores look better without having to address the root issues affecting student achievement instead of making real improvements where they're needed you're making a decision that disproportionately harms the very families you claim to be helping you say you want Equity yet you're making life harder for the families who struggle the most you say you care about students but you're using them as Pawns in a numbers game at first I got involved in this fight because

055I wanted what was best for my kids but the more I looked into it the more I saw an underprivileged Community being taken advantage of being used as a political prop if the goal is true educational Equity we should focus on strengthening the schools that need support rather than uprooting hundreds of children there are many ways to balance enrollment without sacrificing the walkability we value thank you my name is Emily Harding um we live in Elliot Avenue in the summit District I have a third grader and a kindergartener was not planning on speaking tonight because I didn't think I'd make it so I have nothing prepared um I am a member of one of a five person PTO um three of us which handle just about everything um my husband is one of those members

056um we we very much value walkability we live in Belmont because how much we value being to walk um my husband every night is the best part of his day was riding his bike with my kids to school we we know the importance of that um the teachers are overwhelmed our PTO does not have the funds or the bandwidth to support the teachers as they need um the kids the kids are wonderful the kids do their best and the teachers do their best but with very limited resources you have a large population of children that need more support and they they they do what they can and our teachers do what they can um but given the the resources that we have and are provided by the city we understand that we are given more

057as a title one school um but what the children need is a a more diverse population with parents that can have more resources to help support we are sometimes we we bring snacks to school every week because there are kids who don't have enough food that and I understand walk abilities importance but you're talking about children who need more more support and and we do what we can um but but the teachers are are overwhelmed with what they manage and we want a more Equitable for everyone um again I had nothing prepared but I this this is not a a game we we we're just trying to balance the system to give everybody what they need to succeed we we want all of these children succeed at Walker and Buford or whatever they're going to

058be um and we I support the The Proposal so thank you for for I do see somebody in the attendees Gallery I will Pro you momentarily to have your a three minute period of time to speak just bear with me as I head back to the computer hi this is Katherine gray can you hear me yes we can hear you thanks sorry I couldn't make it in person tonight um I am a teacher at Summit uh one of the English language development teachers and I also have my own children attending Summit and Walker I also was plan planning on just listening tonight um but want to add my voice to those in support of this proposal uh it is not an easy Choice um either way no matter what the decisions are we lose students

059and families to prevent overcrowding not for a numbers game but because we will be unsustainable within a few years I don't want to say goodbye to anyone that I work with um or that my students my own children go to school with I don't want them to lose potential class um I recognize all of the hard work and thought and care that the team and the commities have put into rezoning I know no decision can make everyone happy because we have to lose walkability because of summit situation and the historical um historical decisions that have been made by the city um that led us to where we are today um so I appreciate everyone's hard work and hope that uh that we can move forward and and help make Summit and the whole City's future

060uh more sustainable thank you right for for for my name is Neil Davis I don't really have any students at either one of the schools or any of the schools that we're talking about right now I've got a granddaughter who's currently at Burnley Moran what I do have is a kind of unique perspective because growing up in Charlottesville I lived in I grew up in Belmont which meant I went to Clark for part of my um my growth through Elementary School we moved over to Locust Avenue just on the other side of the bridge where the cut off is for for this solution um and spent time at Burnley Moran and my daughter who you heard from already and my son went to greenb so I've kind of got a unique perspective on all three

061of the pieces of the solution here I think what I've heard tonight is a lot of different reasons for things like socioeconomic and we're talking about being able to walk to school but I don't think you're solving the real problem with the solution here because this this problem has been here for over 40 years I think the problem that needs to be solved is aligning the city government with City school systems to get the proper funding the proper resources to help address the learning issues that exist over what I refer to Still Loving Me as Clark um and now Summit rather than moving students around all over the place because it's the same problem that existed 40 years ago the city Dynamics have not really changed that much in terms of the neighborhoods and and

062their makeups it's been this way forever so I think the real problem is we we've got solutions that just move the problem around you're going to pick students up out of one school move them over to the other school which now balances both schools from a a performance standpoint but it doesn't solve the problem because if learning challenges currently over at Clark they're going to just get picked up and moved over to Burnley Moran if they're not adequate resources put in place to help with the learning environment and I think that's really the problem it feels like there's more discussion that needs to be had and that maybe you guys need to go back to the city council and fight for the resources that are needed here rather than moving students around and inconveniencing a

063whole bunch of people and families and things like that so [Music] anyway thanks e e h know if this is allowed but since nobody else is getting up we're all here um forgetting the Equitable part um they have the city they should have come aligned with the school board when they made the decision to increase the housing in Belmont um but they didn't right and so they have tripled if not more the density of our housing in Belmont and so moving students while nobody wants to move Kendall doesn't want to move the lcus growth families don't want to move and we everybody understands that but spacewise I remember sitting on a PTO Citywide meeting three years ago and then pointing out that Summit was the only School in the city that had no room for

064expansion we don't have we don't have the ground space to put trailers out so keeping everybody at Summit that is planned to be in our neighborhood within the next five years is not physically possible um I wish they hadn't done it that way I wish they had planned better and not just kicked the can down the road and made it our problem but that's not what happened so there has to be lines redrawn somehow to make physical bodies fit in the schools um and Summit is the one that that does not have capacity because of our land how we are locked in landwise to expand um I got here late so I don't know if that's been brought up but that's that is just that's just the math of it um I will say I

065think the walking bus is one of the best things that came out of covid I it brought tears to my eyes on day one when Dr gley was walking those kids to school I was I love it um I will say we we walk and bike our kids to school every day the majority of Kindlewood families do not walk their children to school they mostly drop off in cars um so I think ex now that we've got our buses up and running and making sure they do have access the public transportation is important I'm a huge bike Advocate I think making bike Lanes from Summit to burle Moran and improving the safety of that the I take that bridge every day there's other ways would I would I would be willing to work on that

066um but as a walker biker we don't see a huge group of of Kindlewood walking and and using that that that opportunity um but I I think I think the math of it is important to remember that that somehow these lines have to be redrawn I'll I'll just give the figure if we don't redraw the lines Summit goes to at least 140% of its capacity Miss Bruner I see your hand raised um promote you back to the stage thank you Mr Cuomo um I didn't know if I was allowed to do this but then I saw one of our PTO moms kind of do it get up there and speak again and so I felt a little bit more couraged to kind of speak again um speaking to the um community members that have made

067comments about looking at what resources need to go into Summit um I know that Dr Gurley and anyone on the school board anyone that works in Summit can tell you that we are being provided with as many resources as we are allowed to have however I think something that we need to realize is when you have the most out of any other school's population disadvantaged regardless of how many resources you put in that building you're going to struggle and I think something that we also need to be thinking about is we have so many students that need more resources and when people are saying put more resources into Summit in the last seven years there has not been one internal transfer in the Charlottesville City School District to come to Summit because the teachers the

068Specialists they don't want to come to our school because it's a hard school and that is no dis to any of our family members or anything we are all trying our best however that would then provide the opportunity for more teachers and more Specialists to see more diverse students we have not we've lost several of our teachers who are some of the best Educators that I have ever seen in my building and just in general transfer to other schools in the city because they're easier on them because it's not so emotionally draining going to work and having only two or three of your students come in that are disadvantaged versus in my classroom over 60% of mine are and so when we're talking about putting more resources into a building I think yes 100% but

069that's not something that the district has not tried to do we continue to get first year people coming into our buildings because that's all that will come into Summit because Summit has a stereotype which is terrible and awful that needs to be battled but I think telling Dr Gurley and the school board that they just just need to put in more resources and that's the problem it's not like they're not trying but I'm going to say it again in the last seven years there has not been one internal transfer to come to Summit and there have been multiple year after year to leave Summit because it is so draining on our teachers if you spread that demographic out more you will not have these teachers leaving from school to school and saying I'm not going

070to teach in that school because that's the hard School everyone will get what they need thank you and again Dr Gurley in a Schoolboard I appreciate you guys considering this e for for for hello again I apologize for taking up more of your time um again Elizabeth hand I just wanted to make the comment that while the plan proposed may be the best solution looking at resoning from an SCS perspective that's that would if that's the conclusion that's the way it will be and I know that the families who get changed schools will receive the services that they need at the their new schools that being said I would like to ask for you to observe the room and notice that there don't seem to be many people here who have spoken from the Kindlewood

071neighborhood itself and that to me gives me pause and some concern that perhaps they are not being included in this decision-making process as they ought to be if they were and if they had the ability to have meetings on site with interpreters and the opportunity to voice their priorities and their concerns and if the same plan were created after those sessions and their feedback then I would say well shoot now we're not going to walk to school but it's a sacrifice that we're going to make because that's what the community has decided together I don't believe that that's where we're at in this however um and I at the risk of sharing information that is probably not public yet there are some questionnaires circulating in Kindle Kindlewood about their awareness of the resoning plans um

072not all 150 families have responded yet obviously um and this needs to be done in partnership with interpreters so it's a slowish process but about 30 families have responded already who the results are overwhelmingly that people are unaware of the close resoning against the neighborhood being moved and they say walkability is a a priority and so I don't know as a citizen as a resident of Charlesville I don't really know what to make of this other than that the absence of their voice in this type of setting is concerning to me and if nothing else a delay in the decision making process in order to incorporate more of their feedback would be the right thing to do thank you for e for for for for for for [Music] what for for for hello everyone it's

073Conor Welch again and since everyone else is doing it I figured speak again that's okay um we've heard from a lot of people in Locust Grove and I was thinking about why that might be um there surely various explanations and reasons for that I mean one there's definitely privilege there that we have the time or the resources the availability to be here um there's also awareness there's been like a lot of awareness being raised which um credit one of my neighbors I'm not sure who but dropped off leaflets trying to just raise awareness which um I'm appreciative of um but I think there's another one here is that you know this is just a really confounding decision um when the the first word reached my eyes around this was like sometime in October I don't

074think there was anything proposed yet I don't know if there were any of the four to debate the four options but um this is the only walking Zone that is just is really decimated um and again live a quarter of a mile from their local elementary school um have this unique opportunity and it's really special um opportunity to have a daily ritual with your child to walk and to to kind of unpack the day and their their what they're anticipating or what they went through at the end of the day and um I I strongly believe that um there's a way to balance these to thread this needle um and to achieve the soci and economic um objectives to ensure that Summit um isn't uniquely disadvantaged in any way um and overcrowded in any way

075while also preserving what I view is pretty essential and and sacred and logical which is keeping a community that can walk really closely and and be at school in five 10 minutes um together and so I I really hope um that you you know take this feedback as I AED earlier um I'm you know it's it's unclear I know you're accepting a lot of feedback but it's as someone it's unclear where it's going or how it's factoring in um into your process but um I do hope you consider that thank you I do see somebody in um the attendee Gallery last name is c n n o RS um you've been promoted to um the panelist position so you can unmute and you have three minutes for public comment and just please state your name

076and address so that we can make note of of you thank you um is the person with the last name c o n n o RS if you could unmute yourself if you wish to make public comment all right we'll try one more time if uh the person who would like to give public comment c n n o RS you are promoted as panelist your hand is raised and all you need to do is unmute your microphone and we can uh hear your public comment at this time all right well if you change your mind you can raise your hand again and yeah I I've switched the microphone so that the you should be able to hear me I'm seeing that it's coming through loud and clear on the audio here hi can you hear

077me yes we can hear you can you hear us yes sorry about that um my name is car Hors I live at bav um I've been listening in and um one of the things I wanted to just add is it's starting it started to feel a little bit like a summit versus BME argument um and in my opinion it's not it isn't Summit versus BME it's Summit and BME um I don't think you know anyone from BME or our Locust Grove neighborhood is arguing against utilization or the diversity goals um we are arguing for the board to spend some more time looking at new options now that we know that diversity is the top priority um I think there should be some time spent finding for new options so that we can then get feedback

078on those options now that we know the new priorities thank you hi I'm Jason Comfort I work I live in Locust grow excuse me oh yeah Jason Comfort I live in the Locust Grove neighborhood um and let me start with um I don't think my child's going to be affected by this just based on her her grade and the timeline but um I I do feel strongly about walkability as does my whole family community attempting to better balance the numbers of students in the schools um the options that's currently recommended was the least popular in the survey it's also clear from the survey that not all the communities responded in strong numbers um maybe awareness has been a part of that issue um you know in my family my wife and I are very plugged

079into the schools we get all the notifications we were kind of hearing about this sort of shortly after it started a lot of other parents don't have that um luxury of being able to be that involved in that you know sort of PL plugged in with the schools and knowing what's going on I think a lot of people don't know that this is going on I would just ask that you consider delaying the decision to give additional time for awareness and Outreach uh to the communities to get more input to create additional alternative options to those that are currently proposed um I know that the rezoning does need to happen I understand the math um but I think we can come up with additional options besides those that are proposed that might be meet more

080of the resoning goals but still Max imiz walkability uh more than the current proposal um and not move such a large number of students from just one or two schools um so again just please consider delaying the decision uh and consider time for maybe more surveys more Outreach um to all the the members of the community that this affects to have a better balance of meeting all these resoning goals and not just one or two thank you hi I'm Jeff Fuller um I live on St Charles Avenue um I have a kindergarten right now or kindergarten right now and uh incoming kindergarten probably in five years so it does sort of a stakeholder in both situations you know now and later here um and uh I don't know to me walking's critical you know I

081I'm not scheduled to be moved but like just to think someone else is going to get moved it's just I mean it's just horrible um like it's one of my best times with my kid and you see all the neighbors Everybody Talks it's great a lot of people have gone into that detail so I don't need to do that more um uh one thing that kind of jumps out of me a little bit is is like the whole the zoning thing you know we just had the zoning changes uh for like building code and all that kind of stuff um Building C anyway we just had like the um the Zoning for residential and changing all that and you know it's screaming build build build and I haven't heard anybody say like okay we're going

082to add on to Burley Moran to build capacity or something like that like if the city's building we need to be building um and I you know maybe some people haven't saying that but like you know I I basically my thoughts like you know you add on you add some capacity so that everyone can actually stay where they are who are walking actually um and then add capacity for more people and then you know then I'm you know more interested to see what might happen you know so um and my son already has 27 kids in his class and they've been looking for another kindergarten teacher for the whole year and they're not going to find it so it's you know there's that whole scalability thing that concerns concerns me anyway well thank you [Music]

083sorry sorry um this does conclude our feedback session um I do want to close by saying that um if no action is taken Summit will reach 140% of its capacity while green buyer remains underutilized we have held multiple engagement sessions in Kindlewood with interpreters our Schoolboard members have gone door knocking in the Kindlewood community um this is not about shifting so scores um rather doing nothing is not an option with more housing developments on the way summit's capacity um will Ex will be exceeded as we acknowledge no solution will be ideal for anyone um the school board members have recorded your questions and your comments this evening we will provide some followup and continue our community engagements we do appreciate everyone who participated um both in person and online and this does conclude our session

084have a great evening

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.