CorpusRecord 11648

January 30, 2025 Charlottesville City School Board Budget Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Charlottesville City Schools
Date
2025-01-31
Location
Charlottesville city, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,686 words · about 65 min
Collected
2026-06-03

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e it [Music] t [Music] so well em was Sunday [Music] so Emily was Sunday right Emily was Sunday wasn't it her birth your birthday was Sunday right yeah she's over there all quiet [Laughter] I your for all right everyone um it is Thursday January 30th and I'm going to call this meeting to order um as we get started I just want to take a moment um there's been a lot that's happened just in the last 24 hours in the last several weeks and so if we can just take a moment um to collect ourselves and be present in the work that we are tasked with right Madame clerk if you can call the role yes Madam chair Miss Burns pres Miss Cooper pres miss douly here Mr Morris Mr Meyer here miss Richardson

002here and Miss Torres yes thank you next up may I have a motion to approve our proposed agenda I'll make a motion to approve our proposed agenda I'll second all right we have a first and a second to approve our proposed agenda all in favor say I I I I all right we have a proposed agenda and I will turn it over to you Dr Gurley all right we will begin with Miss C who um will talk with you all about our furniture requests for fifth grade reest for potential use of fund balance in order to get ahead of some manufacturers price increases that are already known to situ we have is that we got mle school schol all and we have our elementary schools currently which have all been modernized except the trail which

003is in progress as we speak things get furniture package summer the same time we talk about this fa fa fig to solve we don't want to have a situation fth graders schooles graders to go back neighbor neighbor don't that one the preschoolers they have some things that they got through modernization the schoers intentionally didn't have as much of a touch uh with special Furniture because we we still working towards that I'm sorry I thought it was on I'm so sorry I thought that thing was L up oh yeah know you don't want that okay I guess there's a brighter sh of green um anyway the um preschool in the one and a quar million when they come over there'll be some changes to this building and there'll be some there's allowance in there for some

004furniture touches but we really we feel strongly that the that we will want to equip those fifth grade classrooms with Furniture that's comparable to every other classroom in the elementaries by authorizing fund use of fund balance for this purpose um the manufacturer is a the major manufacturers agreed to um which is 80% of it um they will we can secure our we can put our order in secure the current prices which actually saves us enough money roughly in our estimates for the other 28,000 or so we'll need to get some kidney tables and a few specialty items that aren't offered from this one manufacturer so uh we just asked that the board approve this as an authorized use of fund balance so we can um get our order in and secure the current prices ahead

005of price increases thank you all right thank you Miss pal any questions from the board Mr Meyer yeah thanks M pal this all makes sense I appreciate you all getting ahead of this uh normally this would be a CIP related type item versus like an operational budget item it it it could certainly be a CIP yes it could be a CIP item it's large enough purchase where it would qualifies as a capital purchase okay and did we ask the city for we did we did Deni the request so this is this has been an ongoing conversation um it's not a new conversation this has been for years I would um you know talk about whether we could get it in small cap or whether we could get it if there was um a favorable variance

006you know enough cushion in the project for the middle school and they didn't say like the answer on getting it into the favorable variants on the middle school was never like well we have was always we'll have to wait and see we have to wait and see but the reality is we've hit enough Rock there's been enough that happened there's not money left that was the original hope is that there would be money left in the Middle School uh project that would be sufficient to cover this fifth grade furniture and that's that that is not the case and we know that now so then when you talk about the larger CIP budget um what I would say about that is you know the list of things is long right that we're asking for out of

007CIP that we want to see um Energy Efficiency accelerated restroom modernizations lots of Touches for CHS um there's a lot we're we're looking for um I would say that if you take action tonight to approve this as a use of fund balance it doesn't close the door to continue asking for the city's support on this but we need to get the order in does that make sense so you could authorize this when you authorize something as a use of fund balance you're just saying that if if it's needed you can use fund balance for this purpose but if it's not needed if we would be successful in continuing conversations with the city about CIP or whatever then that that's no harm right but if we miss putting in this purchase order during the month of

008February I you know I like a sale I want to get things at the current prices no I appreciate that context and uh I bring it up because the city has a $22 million surplus that they're putting into the CIP contingency there Y which is used as their slush fund and and I'm glad that we would have the flexibility potentially to maybe tap that here so I'm a little bit surprised unfortunately that they or I'm not surprised that they told you no but a little bit mythed that they wouldn't necessarily but I also want I I do also want to say that we do have some opportunities based on my meeting with Sam on Monday we have some opportunities to tap into that money to address our safety projects um so okay I think this

009could be brought to the table in the continuing conversations around Surplus and CIP but miss Hoover we can't really put a purchase order in the system without knowing that we've got it covered and so fund balance is a way we could cover it we need your permission um but that's not to say it's always it's authorizing the use of but there's always an if needed on the back into that because sometimes it's not necessary and hope you know maybe the F CIP conversation will take a different direction and it hasn't to be clear also I know there's a process behind CIP in my recent conversations with the city I haven't even bothered to Reas because again that's part of a bigger process and I don't want anyone to think it's been a recent no I

010know the do closed on the middle school project [Music] line sorry colle I just sorry I just bring this up because 300,000 could be our Surplus for this year and I know been working really hard on building that up as Mr Hoover often reminds me because I'm looking at ways to potentially spend it and she reminds me that we want six months of operating cash flow and so to use our fund balance for something I feel like sorry that the city should be paying for is a little frustrating however I do recognize the need to make the decision and we can argue with the city afterwards about if we can they pay for it or not so thank you Torres yeah I mean I concur with Mr Meyers um fully I mean so you need

011action on this tonight no no next week well this is tonight got got gotcha all right I need action this month so next meet I do need we do need action in early February to comfortably get that it's a large purchase order we would like to get it in to secure the prices no I I mean I fully support um doing that but again to to Mr Meyer's point I mean we're always so thin on our fund balance as it is um I mean for the most part so I I just would this seems like a no-brainer that they should be supporting us with this so everybody stick a pen in this so that I'm sure we won't forget to um bring it up again so thank you any other questions on this no I

012appreciate Mr my you're bringing that up I think um I appreciate that the conversation on Monday included some discussion of surplus funds coming back to us to quite frankly take care of items that the city was responsible for doing that they didn't um and so there is some frustration there that we should be grateful for this gift um that was part of a contract for them to have completed all along so miss pal I hear you we will take action on this next week um and continue the conversation with our city Partners all right you're still up all right we will have a budget conversation um Welcome to our um 20 fiscal year 2526 budget development uh we can go on to the next slide here's our outlined agenda for this evening um and I

013know that you all will but I just want to make sure I say that as we go through this if you have any questions go ahead and shoot those questions while we um I'm going through the presentation next slide um I just want to start by just recognizing our finance team um you know this meritorious um budget award really is a testament to the work that they do uh daily U to set us up for Success uh I uh want to thank Miss Hoover for her leadership I often feel like I report to her sometimes because she she keeps me in line and makes sure that um we are always in good standing and being good stewards of the of the city's money next slide uh this was in our previous presentation but I just

014want to make sure that people know where we started this work uh we started this work with our strategic plan which is um in the gray boxes at the top um and then through the work through the collaborative work through the school board and through our ptos and other stakeholder feedback we identified our budget priorities which are listed um down at the bottom we're going to start with Revenue um and by focusing on Revenue um which comprises of the funds that support our staffing and meets the needs of our School Division so let's look at our Revenue this slide highlights our various funding sources um the pie chart is based on our current Year's budget and offers a consistent representation of our divisions funds over the past years um um the city remains there um

015that 62.4% the city remains our biggest um portion of our funding sources of our funding sources and then if we look at our other Revenue it consist of state federal and local which are smaller pieces of the pie this slide uh displays our 7-year Trend um of total budget Revenue and so during this period the state revenue has averaged about 23% of our overall revenue and so for fiscal 24 that was the highest um budgeted revenues um of our seven-year time frame and so as you look at um from fiscal year 24 to 25 you do see that there is a dip of approximately 3% in state revenue and I think that it's important for us to remember that this is when they recalculated the um LCI the local Composite Index which reflects our locality's

016ability to pay and so our um LCI increased from um increased to 77.2% resulting in the state contributing less um which is um 22.9% towards our s soq so that means when that happens we're picking up um we're picking up more of the tab um until the state re benchmarks and next year in 2026 um this will remain our funding formula and so lot of work to do in this area next slide um so this is the second year of our bium um budget and the um s soq revenues are determined on the formula based on our LCI rate uh which means that less funding which means less State funding and greater Reliance on the city uh which we will continue to talk about throughout this presentation and as noted on the previous slide we

017saw the the increase in the LCR the dip in um the state contributions so on our state revenue estimates um the governor did present his proposed budget back in December and that budget um had some technical updates and some minor adjustments to ADM formula um um the lottery programs state taxes and um there was a little bit of work um in the area of English language learner so not a lot of um changes because we are in the second year of the um vium next Slide the um so as a result of the state revenue the our estimate um is an additional 53800 553 in state revenue the increases are concentrated in the following three areas um the um compensation supplement the that represents the state share of the um 3% ofq and I think

018we always want to remind people that we are staed well above the soq um the S soq formula um there was some additional monies for at RIS um that's the lot um through the lottery and this allocation is B was based on the Lottery's um revenue and then lastly there was um more dollars for the um English as a second language program and so um we saw the numbers that were presented by um Dr FS back in November and you'll see in the presentation we've done some work in that area to align with the new um the new changes um to ESL stat laughing yes sir Dr I've been following a lot of the bills but I don't haven't seen many that are suggesting major movements in any of the state funding I don't think

019no and we're not fixing really any of the so soq no right okay just want to so we're not last year I know there was a lot of questions and things are moving around a lot this year we're pretty sure about where we're GNA land right yes and and I think that goes back to what I said a few moments ago about you know the I feel like every year it gets wiser and wiser in the budget process and and really it's because we're in that second year of the of the bayum and there only those technical adjustments um next slide so this slide just represents our Trends um our Trends in the city's appropriation annually over the last seven years and so um again the city has been our is the biggest part of

020where we get our um our monies from and so that's why this um slide is so important as we talk about um how much funds they do allocate for us and we'll go into it in Greater detail on the next [Music] slide so this slide represents our um funding formula of um 40% of our formula for the real estate and personal property and so that's listed in that that blue area and so along with the actual is represented by that red bar so it's the funding formula and then what did the city actually give us and so you will see that um during the pandemic years um there was some some dips there but if you notice that in um the 24 year they um funded us right above and then if you look at

021last school year um they funded us significantly above our a what we requested when we look at the um FY 26 the funding formula for the city is $3.4 million um and so however I think it's the work we've had with our city the advocacy on your part um advoc advocacy on um from our um CA through the U through our Union process our collaborative processes with my regular meetings with Sam um our city manager they did come in above our funding formula for this school year so they so the funding formula was $3.4 Million they gave us an additional um 1.4 almost 1.5 um 1.4 million which um brings our city increase to um four 4, 9227 no I said that 27,000 4 million of is the hard number that there's no movement on

022that going forward so initially the initially the formula number was $3.4 Million so we so we had our ask so when we met back in December we showed this is this is where we are I think that was seven 7.9 so that was 7.9 million dollar and that was inclus inclusive of City contracts um you know our ask in terms of instructional personnel and so we knew that the 3.4 was not going to be where we needed to L in we did some work internally just to make sure based on the budget request um from schools what um what students need to be successful we knew that the 3.4 the 3.4 which is the formula was not going to be what worked and we had this number that we said you a you absolutely must

023provide this to us in order for this to work and not only work work well and that was that additional 1.4 almost $1.5 million yeah I mean colleagues I just bring this up because I remember last year when we were in January had this conversation with our city colleagues and we were saying the formula which is a rule of thumb it's not an ordinance and as I don't like this formula because it's only based on basically real property taxes in town which the city has been adjusting the other taxes they have in town personal property taxes funding and fees uh lodging taxes food taxes they've adjusting all that up so what we're doing is we're getting a smaller and smaller P piece of the pie basically as a total tax base for the city because

024they're adjusting they're not only using the real property taxes they're adjusting other things other taxes to increase their revenues that's why you're seeing all that in addition to they I would say underestimate every year the the proposed amount of real property taxes we're going to get and that's why you see a $4 million surplus and that means 40% of that 1.4 is 1.6 million dollars that we should have got you know last year now they bumped us up I don't I don't think we should be showing this graph in the future because I think we need a new funding formula that is not based on the 40% our increase every year based on the 40% rule of real property taxes so uh I don't like being constricted to this because I don't think it's actually

025legitimate and I don't think we should be basing our decisions on what they're giving us being and what they're owed us being this funding formula which is again not an ordinance and just kind of roll up so sorry get on a soap box here but just trying to for my colleagues I think it's great that they're considering $5 million from us but this is an initial proposal by them and I think that number should go up and could go up if we base on our needs-based budget that you presented to them earlier go ahead so I just needed a little clarification I mean I know that we we that meeting that we had with um Council was considered an early and a newer meeting correct but I feel like we've jumped to this point Without

026Really sitting and doing the work with you I mean I feel like you took what Mr Sanders and everybody um shared with you as far as the amount of money and you and your team adjusted but I feel like we lost I feel like the meeting where we all kind of sit and look at your big want right last last year we had what n million was where we started or was it higher than that 12 and then to nine and then and then they gave a seven I mean I just feel like we've lost a meeting somewhere actually I feel like that I feel like that still h i I hear you all I think I disagree respectfully with love always I I disagree that we just didn't settle for the number because if

027they said we were only going to give you three $3.9 million I would be still sitting here today saying we need $5 million no I agree and I I respectfully with love I'm going to push back to you sir a little bit and I and I know you guys have done the work to look at this but I feel like um I mean so I'm I'm looking at our schedule of of budget development calendar so what what's the meeting that's going to happen on February 10th I mean you you you've already presented your proposed um budget to us the week before and then we meet with them again why are we even meeting with them then we don't we don't have to and I'm not saying we don't have to I'm saying that first meeting

028was kind of a preliminary like here's what's going on and I really kind of anticipated that we would be then meeting again saying okay here's where we are and I think a lot of things have happened in the country in the last couple of weeks few weeks that I have a lot of questions and I'm sure all my colleagues do and everybody does as far as Federal funding and and you know how that's going to trickle down to State and then to us you know and and to to the city so I just feel like there is more work that needs to be done and a lot more discussion and I'm sure no one has answers you know I mean we don't seem to really know what's going on and how that might impact you

029know the different titled monies um but I want to make sure our students are okay and how do we do that I mean this is UN unknown well I think this slide aside if we can move past this slide and give staff an opportunity to actually present what they have worked on to us and then have greater conversation about whether we as a board feel like that is sufficient to accomplish the goals that we've set out um or not but I think we need to give Dr Gurley and his team a chance to actually share with us the work that they've done in putting together this budget I completely agree with you my point here being is we put ourselves in a negotiating disadvantage by using this formula and then showing them being generous with

030us by giving us another 1.4 million which is sorry and this slide doesn't necessarily have to be the one that gets put into what we present to city council my point is let's give them a chance to to share with their work proceed waai on waiting on Leslie all right so um next we will talk about our um let's look at our expenditures so let's shift so um our enrollment is is remaining um we I think we're we're doing well in terms of we're bouncing back um from the pandemic um I think we're stabilizing and so I think you see that we've since 22 we we've been about the about the same place specifically last year it's only the increase of about two students all right so um our expenditures so um when you look

031at our expenditures about 74% of our um what we spend our money on falls in the category of salary and salary and wages and benefits and and so the next portion um that as you can see there is the contract services and that's where we can continue to try to work through like and massage the the contracts and and and gain a better understanding of just what is it that we're spending our monies on um with the city and so I think that that's one area that we're going to continue to work on and when you say contracts that's Transportation that's maintenance ma' thank you yeah those are all City contracts All City contract All City contracts no independent contractors or Outsourcing of Labor Works Etc City might be sure the city could be but

032we're city is a predominant uh contractor I mean we spent about 10 to 11 million with them and then we have other small contracts but the majority of it is [Music] City all right um so our staff allocations um a significant a part of our budget as we just talked about is salary and benefits and so we know that 70% of our staff are dedicated to the instructional roles including teachers Librarians and instructional assistants um 19% of those um are those school-based services such as um our custodians and nutrition workers and then the last 11% are division wide operations and administration so that can be human resources technology and and finance I know we're very lean and we do and is there benchmarks that you know that are for each one of these categories that

033can we compare ourselves to oh in terms of like what are our allocations I don't I don't think I mean but I think well not industrywide yeah for education so I mean is it 11 10% your normal admin spend this is would be going in the way back machine but the last um there was a time and it was around the time I came here or just before that so it's been about a decade ago they had these efficiency studies in the state would offer that you could that they would come in and do efficiency studies and um we still have that report um but it was it what it showed at that time is that Administration was the air like over Administration was where we were light uh in comparison to other school divisions

034um I could gladly share that report but there's been um nothing we have there hasn't been a look at that since but there was an independent um efficiency review Charlottesville City took advantage of that and had people come in and and assess all of that and so that that's the last time that it was done as far as current benchmarking work um off the top of my head I'm just not sure what the comparables would be for that I just I remember that study being mentioned and I think it's a feather in our cap if we could the efficiency state that and show that that we're efficient with our our spending or spending you know again more than the average on schools and less on Administration Etc thanks as far as that as far as

035that specific breakdown yes it showed we very efficient for administration all right um so one of the U one of the top priorities for this budget development did fall within the um realm of compensation and wages um and in terms of attracting and retaining staff and so we do have our first ever um collective bargaining agreement for licensed staff and so what you see here um first you see we um worked on the steps um the steps on the on the current I was gonna say previous but the steps on the current teacher scale are not even um some of them are one and a quarter some of them are one some of them so they ver one yeah they vary through the collective bargaining process um the first thing that happened there on that

036first line is that all of them are now equal at 1.5 and so there um so you see that is a cost of of $2.2 million to fix that and so um in terms of as we've been having conversations about what this cost um this is am I saying this is a one-time cost because we're fixing it this one year and you won't see the need you won't see this line again in our next year's budget because the steps have been fixed um but what you will continue to see is the next part where um included in the agreement is also a raise of $4 million I'm sorry 4% 4% um that raise cost us um um close to $2.6 million 2.5 um and then the for the general and administrative staff um there here's

037the 3% increase which is reflective of the um of the governor's um the governor's budget and that cost um $677,000 and then you see what our um Insurance um you see what our insurance cost um in December we did bring to you all that we thought the premiums would be increasing by 9% um for a total of about $1.1 million and this was dri this was driven by some CLA um our claims experience um of about 107% um and so we have now um this has been revised based on our last um six months and so we did um we got that number back and that was yes that was yesterday we got the number back yesterday and so our cost is an increase of 6% and so that number changed to $585,000 um so

038that was a a save in that area um we do have a savings of $2.5 million um through staff turnover and the um through the vrs hybrid program and so that money had been um earmarked there so you see that in parenthesis in that chart and and so when we look at what the salaries and benefits cost us um for our licensed staff and our um licensed staff and support staff in the healthc care the total cost there is that $3.5 million so that second line is actually just the 4 per raise yes it's a 4% plus% but the one point the in the column on the right the 2595 is just the 4% raise no no and they're moving up those same these Year's this year's teachers are going to be on the next

039step which is one and a half% higher for a total of five and a half and then just fixing the pay scale is 2.2 million which is an exact 1.5% okay all right because presumably we're making a a difference for some teachers who are gonna be on a step if we didn't fix it would be one% or one and a quar I'm just sorry I got confused thought we were double counting that one and a half per no we got an email from C uh I think last week or this year about budget priorities and number one priority being taking care of Staff do you believe this addresses that concern the oh absolutely I mean again you know we you all along with um our teacher Union worked really hard um through the collective bargaining

040process I I mean I know the they would say that this is reflective of the the work that they've done through the process and so yes I do believe that um you know this is reflective of the the work that's been done and we know that um our support staff is going to be engaged in collective bargaining and you know this is this can also be another area of opportunity um through the collective bargaining for um that group as well thanks uh one last thing that the savings for the retirements system is this oneoff or is this going to be annual going forward one off this is a one time and so we will have to find $2 and half million dollars next year to again basically meet this year's salary increases the first line

041item is a one time so there is some netting out potentially yeah right okay for my colleagues understand that we have to find another $2 and half million dollar next you're basically uh right off the bat if I understand these correctly no no are are you referring to the second row the the annual 5.5 because that will be our cost next year if not a little bit more because that's the agreement for next top one the 2.2 is a one okay so that kind of balances out all right yes so it's my understanding Mr D M Dr cley we we haven't received or that collective bargaining contract hasn't been fin finalized yet correct they the ratification process and so it really it technically hasn't come to us for approval yet well that that number will

042not change on their end so it's going to be presented to the teacher Union that um so the ratification process is these are the things that you said you wanted to uh bargain upon the contents of that document does not change so like they they won't come back you won't get a document that says that the salary increase for um licensed staff is 7 million because those numbers their numbers don't change is that what the question well but we haven't I mean we haven't voted on we haven't voted on it yet so I mean it's just it's it's being reflected here but it we haven't voted on it yet so I just I guess I wanted that in the record and then also um I was trying to look back and help me Miss pal

043or whoever or or Miss Hoover on average the last let's say five six years I mean I know that the board has always prioritized and done everything we could to maximize um teacher salary whatever percent we could get them um has it averaged what three to five 5% is that it's about 4% is that about right about 4% is what the average was okay thank you sorry and I think maybe my colag over or her birthday land might be able to 6% it seems a little bit higher than uh inflation Healthcare inflation though is usually higher than regular inflation I mean Wonder are we above average there for everybody next days or are we cost is a lot lower than the uh Health Medical Market Trend the the market Medical Market trend is about nine

044nine it's close to 10% okay so our programs that we have in place are doing a job on at least slowing our costs there these be kind of Again The Benchmark out in the market okay thank you all right um so then our nondiscretionary um our non-discretionary so this these are some of our contracts so when we had our joint meeting we did provide you a high level overview of our City's contracts and uh um and we did not have all of the numbers at that time so we initially presented to you the three-year average um and so last was it was last week we did receive the numbers and there was an increase of about $73,000 over the last three years so the city maintenance contract um did increase 434,000 $434,551 and then the

045pupil um the pupil contract the last time we did have a much larger number for you um and there was a couple different reasons there um but the and we had projected a cost increase of about $786,000 um but then once we got the actual numbers from them there was no increase uh because we had absorbed the um we're absorbing the cost of the position we brought over and so it just really worked to our favor Miss I can I can expand it's okay so the um at the bottom there's a note that says this number is it fundamentally it ended up being Net Zero because when the expenses we took over for with the transition of the um planning and routing position that offset the non-discretionary increases on their side one being a increase

046in like uniform costs for their driver core and stuff but then there are a couple other pieces that I want to elaborate on one thing that was in that request is this piece where they have a lot of a fair number of Drive of the driver core is in what they call the um 30h hour positions instead of the 40-hour positions and there are a fair number of these apparently there's still a fair number of these 30h hour positions that are having to drive consistently over 30 hours but they don't get full-time benefits contribution they get overtime but they're not classified as full-time employees um that is a longstanding discussion about the number of 30-hour FTE versus 40-hour FTE that are in this the way that pupil is organized but that's a matter that I

047believe they will have to work out through their collective bargaining process in the future that is not something that's coming up that's not being Advanced at this time and that's something for them to sort out internally um so that's not coming forward right now so that was one piece that's being set aside the other piece is not being set aside I'm hopeful that this is going to be resolved um without a budget increase to us um Miss Hoover and I talked with Chrissy Hamill and explained this issue where we really want to get off the drug so to speak or transition away from using the dependency on contracted Services the level of dependency that we have on third party contractors to trans do a lot of our special needs transport rep s right and for

048the dependency that we had before the pandemic it even ramped up you know since the during and since the pandemic we want to get that down the only way to do that is to have like a more Vans and more van drivers the it's not a a true net increase all the time they what we really want to do is move money from the purchase Services line over into the um van drivers line whatever they call their classification for people who drive Vans it's not a full CD or CDLs the city had um you know they like like us you try to tightly control your FTE and the the frustration that Transportation has had is that they can't post for the van drivers without the budget funding but the funding really has to stay on

049the purchase Services line until we've got the other solution in place to because you got to have those contractors these are not discretionary transports so we spoke with Chrissy Hamill about trying to work with their HR department and their finance department to help figure out a way to get out of our own way to allow the postings to be done with the understanding that money will transfer fluidly from the purchase service line into the uh payroll lines to support the drivers coming on board to drive Vans and their um Sher Eubanks and the transportation department was able to make a move even this year to continue increasing the number of Vans and we're trying we've supported them as well with Van purchases um so so that's so part of the re part of it that

050went that's out of this request that was in the bigger number before is something that I think just has to wait and go through their processes with how they're organized with their drivers and their labor but this other piece with getting away from contracted services and moving to the van drivers I think there's a way to do that without that temporary almost artificial increase in the budget but Pro procedurally it has to be worked out and so um I was asked today I'm going to write a letter to Garland a note just to clarify what we would like to see happen in facilitating that transition and um we'll see what happens from there so you need $50,000 or something like that just to like it will end up at our bottom of a wash at

051the end of the year I think we I'd like to see us do as much as possible in that transition working within it's a big line for purchase Services these special transports are not inexpensive I think it's 600 and something thousand so I want to see how far we can get just with working out the Logistics of them being able to hire van drivers use the available Vans and anything that we can purchase you know uh support from our vehicle line because we've done that before and we were able to get ahead on our vehicles with some of the Essa money so when we were in that time so I think it can be worked out so I don't I'm I'm okay with saying we can make progress on this good progress just working out

052these details and I'm hope um that's that's what I want to focus on sorry so how much do you think in savings we could we could net out I don't think there's going to be any savings to claim right now because we have there's there's still the van purchases and all that but I think going for like 50k a year or something oh that's what I'm not I better not speak on that part but I I just I'm not sure I don't want to hang on number on that but hopefully Let's see we need to be looking at the budget versus actual reports to see what happens in time I this is a thing that I I mean going back to your point Lis so like what are we going to be meeting about with

053them in a month but think I would like to see presented if you cannot resolve it between now and then yeah well I think I think asking for you know continuing the conversation because it came up the last time we were in here for the joint meeting about what type of reporting you're interested in seeing on these contracts and being really yeah that that's that's all fine to talk about good stuff to talk [Music] about thank you I think in in that same vein and previous conversation looking at the city maintenance contract Dr Gurley I appreciate you sending that out for us to review I myself had not seen it in some time but was drawn to a section um specifically in regards to records um and asking the city to maintain complete and accurate

054records in a form mutually agreeable to the parties to substantiate its charges for services rendered upon request the school board shall have right to inspect those reports and so I'm just wondering if if that's an opportunity for us to see where I understand we just get a line item of of what we are to pay every year for services but we don't really know how that happens or if it happens and maybe there's some question that it isn't happening and so if there's savings on the city side that comes as a result of that work not being done that money doesn't come back to the school system system it goes back into the Surplus at the city of which we do not see often and so appreciate I know Dr gly you're working with Sam

055to kind of look at those agreements and see where we need to massage them a little bit and and be a little cleaner in our detail of what the expectations are and I appreciate that there was acknowledgement at city council CIP meeting that some of us attended so appreciate the work that's being done there but I think just as we continue to move this process forward that is something my colleagues and I would like to see that that there is some line item accountability to see what that looks like and Miss po and I've already started that work um so I started that in my conversation she's done the same thing um working with Chrissy and so we we've already said we we need some type of um Reporting System that's understandable by both groups

056so then we know what the services are that are being rendered you know like what are we getting for the money and I don't I don't know how much of a heavy lift it is on the city side or on our side but I you know and speaking with my colleagues I I would like to see a couple years of that if if that's if that's reasonable um again don't want to over task anyone but let's try to see what a trend is and what's meaningful um to get this work done in a way that cares for for our grounds and what the contract was intended for I think thank you if I already started it one more question about transportation and uh because I was scarred I think a year and a half ago

057from having not having bus transportation for my child and uh was it like two months we didn't have enough drivers so it got worked out right and so while I'm very happy to see that they're not increasing the transportation budget here which you kind of elaborated on I am a little where are we are they fully staffed right now so Staffing um is fluid just like it is in our operations I can't say in this moment that they're fully staffed but they are certainly much closer to being fully staffed sometimes they'll be they'll be fully staffed and then you know next month they lose somebody and then they've got they've got people in the pipeline and it it's more of a revolving door than you than we would like to see still but um you

058know vast Improvement has been made vast improvements have been made and um that's my point being here is I'm willing to say give us you know if you need an extra 50k to take those 30h hour people to a 40 hour because you're more likely to not have them leave because they're getting benefits uh maybe we should do that so that in August when I you know or when we ask you for report on that and they have to come and talk to us we don't have to worry about enough you know school bus drivers so I'll get more what I will do is I'll get a more in I'll put together a a report of the current vacan you know current vacancies and all that where they are with the fills and who's in

059the pipeline it's been a while since I've done that um and I will also um put together the narrative around you know how many drivers they estimate are driving 40 hours but are really in the 30 hour you know bucket and and and those types of things um so that you all can see that um I again I I do they H you know they're in collective bargaining just like you all are and so I don't know that we have to be I think we do have to be concerned about getting ahead of them and how they're managing that because that is a challenge that's all I would say there but I agree I'm all in favor of making sure we have enough drivers and um that's why I advaned their full request because I

060understood every component of it but that piece of the transition from purchase Services over to payroll I do think is there's got to be a way to work through that without an artificial one-year inflation and we're gonna get slammed next year for again really difficult attendance records which we know are impacted by we have a lot of English language Learners 20% of our population basically right and if they can't get a good school bus at the start of the year we lose days and then we start getting dinged and you know it's our schools aren't getting accredited Etc I don't this time because I talked with we're already talking about next year at this time there's no concern that we won't be able to start the year with the same routes we have this year

061which are which are no weight list so I I do want to give you that that reassurance in this moment but um I don't take anything for granted with Transportation anymore so anyway but for what it's worth they are there seems to be no flinching that we'll start where we are now and this year we we started without wless I believe so one last thing on ktech uh you guys were talking to Nelson I think about bringing them in is that going to happen and help reduce this we've been talking with we've been talking about talking to multiple um localities so um I think if I think I don't think that they're the place where they want to um where they've been want to express a commitment but I know that um we've we're we've

062taken on a little bit more of flana um right now and we've had some interest from other places so I mean right now K's doing really well and that number that you see up there is a decrease of $110,000 from the what we showed you in December uh it's probably gonna go down hopefully hopefully hopefully all right um students are student needs and so the next couple slides will lay out so I think it's worth noting here um and I'll read from my notes here um so the changes to the standards of quality for um our English language Learners so what we've done here is this slide has been this table has been broken into what the new requirements are for levels so level one the one to 20 level two 1 to 30 level

063three 1 to 40 level four 1 to 50 um and so you see the efficiency levels um in the tables so based on our calculation so when we presented this when we presented the slide to you all back in um December it showed 5.5 teachers from um Genie FS from Dr FS our um specialist for um our eel programs so what we did was we went through and did some manual calculations to make sure that our numbers were calibrated So based on on our calibration um our division required um our division is required to have um 28.57 El teachers I don't know where you find the 0.57 um but that's how many we're required to have currently we have 26 budgeted full-time um positions so to meet the new um requirements we would need to

064add two more FTE um however what we're doing is um we are baking in using Kim Pal's words we're baking in one more position we're adding in one more to accommodate the growth um and and sometimes I know that when you're doing these numbers like you see that 057 um you know we're talking about people so what does that 5 s means if it's a couple schools and so this does give us um a little bit of room here with this extra position that if we need to uh move a position between schools to better address what's happening at with the master schedule that extra that position will um will do that and so um the estimated cost for the three FTE is um $284,000 646 and so as a reminder you know our our

065El students um our students that require English language learner Services um you know make up a about 177% of our student population um and and so we know that the standards have changed it's gone from 11 semesters to three um so we do feel like this is a good investment and and Dr Fels you know while we are um kind of overestimating the one position here one thing she said during our meeting is that I know we've been talking about what the trends are but there's a lot of uncertainty now um in terms of whether we will see the growth um you know so um I think that the the three additional three positions is um it's the right ask um based on our total numbers and Dr Fels is totally on board with it

066and I think it more than um it will more than serve our students um in the manner in which we needed to yes now we're at 750 or something or 740 um so it's pretty minimal I think my point being here it's pretty minimal increase you're projecting this is the current this is the current oh this is the current no no uh level one uh has an es of an additional point oh yeah level one services so it's a mix we have a mix of a estimate plus a numb we took that table we took the table number we took the current number and we just add an estimate of 20 additional students because that's what if you recall the presentation she did in November we used that we used the table from November um

067to do the C to do these calculations so we went through when we looked at how many level on she had level twos and that's what we used to get this num it's been a long time can you speak to like lure of elll teachers and if this number were to decrease how th that staff might be reallocated within the buildings to provide services are they dual endorsed in elll and you don't have to be anymore I mean when we were first when we first went into education it was um an add-on endorsement now it's some people's only it's now some people's only Endor ment so hopefully we don't have to do anything where we talk about having to repurpose staff and other positions but if that were the case then yes we would have

068to look at people's licensure to determine if there's somewhere else that they could serve in the building um and I think one of the things that we'll continue to do is um especially with the climate and and how things are going we will continue to monitor the numbers to see if we see any downward trends um especially if there's some uh statistically significant um changes I guess alternatively the ratios are better right so if there's fewer students we're [Music] providing colle we're not expecting any new housing projects to development large housing developments to come online over sum anytime next F year correct any other questions on this sorry yeah real quick sorry are the current budgeted the 26 are those all filled there's a 0. five position at um Johnson Elementary that's not failed okay

069we've had applicants all right um just a reminder about the um accountability implications um the accountability system does change um next school year um and so we know that the needs of our students continue to change and so we are looking at how we allocate our um human resources and our um instructional resources and some of that will be reflected in U what I will share with you as we talk about um POS positions and programs to support our students needs and so um we'll continue to make sure that um our schools are adequately funded I mean adequately staffed to address the um accountability um and so I will talk about that on the next slide in terms of student needs so the three positions um the three positions are there that we just spoke

070about um with regards to um the ESL program and you see the cost there uh we've been having some conversation um and you see ESL here and we we're going through a couple iterations of what we're calling this position um Miss Johnson Bianca Johnson does our um Family engagement and um restorative work and we have been going back and forth about what her work looks like and and what the Gap is and so we do recognize that there's this need for um the continued um Family engagement the boots on the ground work um and right now it's earmarked as ESL on this sheet but I will tell you that the position will still be there we're still flushing it out whether um it's solely focusing on our multilang multilanguage families or whether the position just

071should be someone who's engaging in our community um so it'll be one of the two iterations um as we continue to um work through this as we talk about addressing the the needs of our um students um we are going to add a um the request is to add a an additional reading and math specialist it does not have a school listed to it um we are working through what we are U referring to as our differentiated Staffing model where the position we will deploy these positions to the schools that have the um highest need and when these um positions are filled the people filling these positions know that your you will you will have a job always but your school may change year to year I think a lot of times what we find

072is that people get really wetted to like I applied to this to work at this school and only this school and we know because all of our schools are great um but we want people to come on board knowing that your position will move as the student needs move um as the students's um needs change and so that's what you see reflected here um Dr coffee um and Dr OD and um Dr HTH I think talked to you all about our health and medical Sciences position when we did the program of studies um this is the 0 five position here and then in future budgets they will talk about um how do we make that position whole um the recruitment specialist position is is listed here um and this is really about keeping we really

073need someone to just continue this to focus on getting the talent and this is not just our teaching positions this when we have custodial positions and when we have IIA positions um you know our HR staff works hard but many days when they walk in the door um whatever it is they thought they were going to do on that day they're not doing that because something's come up and they have to go address this need at a school so this position is really focused on keeping the um website up to date you know making sure that they're scheduling our recruitment fairs making sure that we have the right people attending those things um the engagement and and so we are really excited to figure out how to um you know how to incorporate this into

074our human resources department our transportation coordinator I will tell you that uh Miss dval um has been like a lifesaver I sent a message over to the city and said you know I know we for a long time we're trying to figure out what's this going to look like why are you all requesting this back but miss Duval I mean she's in the schools she's meeting with the principles she's going out to the buses all the things that were getting in the way of our principles because they were stopping to to do or Miss pal who's not the transportation doesn't have the kid background she was was doing some of those things so this gives someone who brings the experience can serve as a representative of the central office but also can relate to the

075work of what principles are doing with um students on the buses um here um we have you don't see the FTE but what we have here are the clinical social workers if you all remember um we used some one-time monies a long time ago to create positions uh and This Is Us putting the money into the budget so that we can start bringing on those positions it's still leave some positions out there that are still on one-time funds and so um we will need to in our future budgets try to bring those positions on Miss rasnik is working uh with our mental Wellness teams a and really this is a slow rollover to ensure that as we um continue to work with these staff that we um that she really has done a very good

076job of building out what the roles and responsibilities are um what that support looks like and so This Is Us starting to bring those positions over we still have one more year left of um the money which you all earmarked for these positions and and so here you see us um what you see reflected is US starting to transition those um positions over from the onetime monies that we have allocated Mr Meyer your brow your brow have a question yeah I'm sorry um so the transportation cordinator is that Mr Deval or is that above and beyond so how did we just like contract her we used money how did how she's with us now right so we are um invoicing the city got for her payroll expense from Point she came over through the end

077of the year and we also brought the software over inous uh Pat Cuomo's team already spent a lot of time dealing with the interfaces between power school and versatrans and so it was a great opportunity for us to have versatrans all behind our firewall we were also able to go ahead and start implementing some of the um additional features and we're looking to do even more with that because we were constrained from doing that when it was under uh City it so um but for the run out of the software cost for this year we're also invoicing back to the city for that in fact Miss ho and I were just talking about that before this meeting great thank you uh one glad to see Mr dual over on our side officially I know I

078think Dr Gurley that was a suggestion from Miss Powell that can you speak up the mic uh if I remember Dr P or Dr Gurley I think you were a little hesitant to bring over uh but um anyways uh glad to see that she she's over and not because of I think it was just questions about it was good to stay over there at the city or or not here anyways uh clinical social workers this is more psychological work or is this more connecting to Social Services or all the above sorry um no it's about the mental well-being of students um they do a lot of that boots on the ground work with our um students they are very much a integral part of um the mental Wellness teams in our schools and so miss

079rasnik has them deployed um differently at various schools and so the current layout consists of um there are School psychologists in buildings um smhp School mental health professionals um social emotional workers supp support counselors so there are a lot of different variations of but they have clearly defined roles under the leadership of Rachel rasnik which we appreciate and so this looks like two and half basically the equivalent FTE that were two two okay and they're going to be on contracts then they're contractors or they currently are are Charlottesville City Schools Employees we've just have we've designated some money but it's not recurring funds okay that's why you're not showing the Ft there okay there not understand that correctly uh it sounds like you're reading a math Specialists uh again we I like the idea of

080them being able to move around uh maybe address higher need schools where we're seeing testing issues ETC that sounds like it's kind of the idea to help and then addition new accreditation challenges we probably facing great uh the family engagement Le is on is there going to be a focus on uh attendance and assisting in well you attendance and making sure there's an attendance or can I ask just because of the accreditation like right we have a I believe well not I believe I absolutely know that the current work that we've been doing with attendance is yielding results um our attendance um The Chronic absenteeism rate um has dropped I thought I um I may have attached it in the board brief um but the at um The Chronic absenteeism rates have um decreased significantly

081and that's because of the work that we been the attendance work that we've been doing um and so when we looked at from this year time to last last year this time to this year we've seen some s um definitely some increases in the attendance and a lot of that has work through um our attendance folks uh SEO folks how have they've been deployed at the schools so the family engagement is is really about really connecting with our families what do you need um it's some of that tier three work when our students are not really meeting with success and sometimes it's some things that they need the supports that they need from home home and and really the family engagement Le liaison is the is the conduit between school and home just a question

082about engagement is that an additional person or is just one person for the whole it's an additional person so it would make the the team of two now a team of three okay yeah so that person would work directly with um Bianca Johnson since you brought up Bianca um what happened what was the discussion around removing the restorative justice position that we saw in December well um Bianca's still gonna do the restorative it's she's going to relinquish some of the F she still wants to very much be in the f I don't know how to make her unicorn position like something different other than to what we've talked about is her relinquishing some of the family engagement components and it going this um the umbrella of the liaison position so I don't need two coordinators

083and so she's a coordinator right so I don't need two coordinators so this person can work alongside her just not at the same rate and take on some of those additional duties that she was doing so it gives her more time in the um restorative justice world but still she very much so there are facets of family engagement that she wants to do um and you know when people want to do the work then I mean you can't you can't say no so it's it's kind of a win-win with her she gave a very compelling presentation at our last board meeting and it seems like it's the work is yielding results and so I guess I'm disappointed that there's not a position that we're not expanding upon of Justice work we were never we were

084um it was always family engage it was always the family engagement part that we were her position is technically already budgeted so I guess I thought at some point I had heard that we were like adding to like another full-time restorative justice person because she couldn't she was at capacity that position so what the last so at the last meeting when we had the restorative justice my thought was that it was going to confuse people if they saw the restorative justice because then it it's like she's applying for this position and we know that that's her so my thought is after talking with her let her go forth and do the restorative justice peace but she still gave her compelling argument that she wants to still live in the family engagement so I can give

085her less of the family engagement her title will still be her percentage will probably be more restorative justice than family engagement but now the things that she's like in order for me to have more time to do restorative justice the restored um the family engagement liaison can do those things so the focus still is restorative justice it's just in the budget I need someone to do this and she's going to do restorative justice and does this person have a teaching license or could they be it can be anyone anyone who has skills or we looking for somebody who's bilingual trilingual some of those things will be preferred like Bianca comes to us with no I mean she did I think she did a little bit with the class um program but like she's not had

086any teaching experience it's really someone who can who has a heart for the work and who can get in and do it and and and so we're still working on that job description other questions on this slide I didn't do the last sorry oh um just um touch back because my family engagement was really huge for me and so I would like to see that that job description not have so many restraints because I would like to see that someone that's committed in the community doing the work and not everybody has a degree so I just hope that when that job is posted that that's not one of the requirements so that it's open to I say I think a lot of these positions I I see we do meet those needs and again the

087upcoming challenges we're going to be facing with the news set accreditation Etc so I appreciate that I see that there's a lot of meeing the observations that Cube sent us also which I appreciate uh last year I know I think we've made changes we had a lot of permanent substitute positions uh we didn't get all of them we wanted I know we've I think been done a better job of attracting with our pay change is there still the need for a permanent additional permanent subs or I mean well I think if you ask a principal they're gonna say Yes um but I you know I think I definitely think that they would say yes oh yes we could definitely um we would definitely like a a permanent sub but I will say that uh we

088did budget um we did budget those positions um so those positions are um reoccurring for this year I think that they've met the needs of our schools um I just met uh met with the high school I think it was like two weeks ago maybe last week and um I know that they are very appreciative of the board um and the work that was done at the central office to um get the pay increase for Subs at the high school um I think that many of them will um testify that um that has had a positive impact on um School climate um their productivity in the schools and so those are the types of things that um you know we've been focused on as we move forward okay so it's not common practice anymore to

089have school teachers having to spend their planning periods or lunches covering classes frequently well when I was at the high school he said he an FTE but you know if there other ways we can solve this problem which sounds like we have so thank you yeah yeah um and I do I did not get to U mention so um this was not on our first screen uh on our first presentation back in December um but we did have when we started this process back in um back during the fall and and I asked um The Walker staff about you know what is it that you all need in order for us to support you as we go through the reconfiguration process um one because uh knowing that this school is closing and all of the

090uncertainty uh you know it it invokes a lot of anxiety for some people because it's the unknown one the first unknown is will I have a job then it's um where will I be working is it somewhere that I want to work um so that was a lot of the conversation and and so back during the fall they did ask um at that time I think it was um could we give them $5,000 um for a retention bonus uh and so we did have a request from The Walker CA reps um about a a couple of different things and included in that was a retention bonus a and so as I had conversations with my central office colleagues about um about the response to this one thing that was very clear is that um I

091didn't feel that we would be setting any type of Precedence by responding to that c CA request by saying yes we would honor it because what's very different about this um situation is that you know we have a whole school that's closing and and as positions come open anyone from this school can go and apply anywhere and make it really hard for Dr Thompson to fill positions in the last year of this school creating a lot of uncertainty for people um you know there are a lot of attractive positions within our own School Division um where if someone wants to leave and go to the elementary school they could apply and go do that next year and create a situation for Dr Thompson where she would need to get those positions field so with her

092advocacy and with the ca's advocacy um we did move forward with um I'm moving forward with the recommendation of saying for licensed staff that they receive a $2,000 bonus um to stay and for um our support staff $1,000 and it would be paid um December the 15 of 2024 2025 I'm sorry um and then the second payment would be in May 15 of 2026 and that's to keep them here um because again good people can work anywhere and they're all great people and we definitely want to see them um stay with us and so um it's been a heavy lift I'm so appreciative of our teachers and and working through with them and they're gonna get some information tomorrow and next Wednesday the first phase of the teachers will learn um their placements the classroom

093teachers license staff would extend to our admin team as well I'm thinking our admin team too um because we y I think we have to I believe we have to honor everyone because um it's a W Oil machine here um I mean it's it's working in this building and really we don't we want people to have a peace of mind that they know where they will be and um come 2026 and help this to just remain a W Oil machine throughout next school year all right okay um so summary of the budget so um here's our um bottom line um listed right here when you look look at our Revenue um our expenditures um we are looking at a budget change of um 5.4 U million do 5,466 441 and so I think to go

094back to what was said at the beginning like why do we have the next meeting um you know it takes a lot of work to get to this moment and I don't think one of the things we haven't talked about is just that we also have to internally look at our practices and how we spend money and making sure that department B um making sure that department budgets um that we're not just holding money over here and thinking we're gonna spend down like we have to be very good stewards of um of the Public's money and I don't believe that all years will look like this I believe that you know as the needs of our students change and we have this large number we may get to this we may arrive at this meeting

095and I may be saying to you the city's saying that they're not going to give us what we need and that's why that next meeting that Miss Torres was referring to I think that that's what that meeting is is for now if this next meeting evolves to something else because we feel like this is not it then absolutely but I definitely think that this budget is a reflection of the voices of um our Charlottesville City Schools Community that's it for me so go ahead I'm gonna start on this side if we've got questions Miss Torres I do I want to say thanks for this um so I'm I'm just a a comment I guess more than anything and a question people you know make make the day make all of this happen and this is

096really people focused right positions a question to you you know I mean we really haven't for a while that I can recollect talked about programmatic changes or investing in things not that people don't make a difference for the students but we just haven't been in a place where we've had to add programs I know that when you came in we asked you to really look at what programs were here make sure that we were doing what we needed to do but do you feel like there's anything we should be looking at to improve the day-to-day experiences of our students I think right now when we think about um programs and we think about what happens in the instructional day a lot has changed um and they're not not all of those changes are changes that

097have been initiated by us so we think about what's happening now with our reading programs um with reading um that was a systematic change that occurred because of Virginia literacy act um so that's one thing that has in evolved our instructional practices but um it's had implic on our master schedule so while it didn't Spawn from our um from our budget we do know that how we deploy our reading specialist how we set up our master schedule those things have continued to evolve um I think we've talked about our Alternative Learning Program I mean those spaces continue to evolve we've done um new Pathways you know we're getting ready to Embark upon changes in the math standards um so that's going to change the way so I think the district Le um how we how

098we deliver instructional programs um is evolving because there have been changes in legislation and and so yes I think I said all that to say yes I believe that we are meeting our students needs and I don't think that the last couple of years have been about um more programs because I think that the teachers I think the teachers are are doing a lot and one more thing for them to learn at this moment I think would be the the straw yeah no I I agree I mean I feel like so much is good stuff but also mandated stuff right so as far as that yes but it you know are there is there enough money set aside for um field trips and and different things like that are there other areas where we should

099be investing and supporting so that kids can be kids or those types of things that's already built in baked in y um all of those things all of those things are baked in and you know and rarely is the answer no um you know rarely is that answer no and I think that that's one thing that we've done a really good job I mean anything that comes that hits our desk we've always found a way and and a part of the budget process this year was like oh there's not enough money because we've been going into academic services to get the money so we've shifted this because we've noticed that there's been a lot of money at the end of the year in this area so now it goes into this pot so we don't

100have to keep moving money so I think that was a very big part of our budget process um this school year so field trips will always happen they're going to go and do those things so nothing doesn't happen here are there any in your opinion in um areas that we we need to be a little bit more cautious about with this budget just because of the the current climate and and so many things that we don't know um I don't think I don't think so I think the approach that we're taking is just it's business as usual and and so I don't think that that's made us cautious I think that was one of the questions I got in an email today um you know I'm I don't have a lot of worries about what

101we're doing internally um because we just every student belongs we're going to keep teaching students the accurate history um you know nothing changes um I mean I don't have any worries at this point and I typically try to use our team um as the thermometer and and I think we're we're really good um we're really good and how we're supporting but I'm open for suggestions if we're missing something um just to backtrack a little bit I know we talked about like the sore like the teachers that will be like transitioning of school officially um and then receiving was it $2,000 2 licenses licensed um Personnel will get $2,000 and then um all other staff the support staff will get ,000 and we did that because that's typically how we um tiered um you know just

102because there's a little bit more work that goes into earning the credential in one area than the other so we've typically done that um typically done things that way so could that be 2015 1500 just like um just thinking about like how you know people would feel like knowing like you know if you're a teacher and your license teacher you get 2,000 but I'm support staff and like just like you know I would be like like you know I may work just as hard so why am I not compensated at least close it doesn't maybe have to be 2,000 but it's a, Gap so just kind of thinking about I guess it would it be possible to put together what the budget implication would be to increase the support staff to, 1500 how many I

103would support how many people are we talking about Miss who can give us the number but um we meet next week is next week oh God and are all those support staff folks have they all been placed in in other as well yeah yeah we we're just in limbo with um less than a handful of positions I mean all the teachers um all the teachers will have somewhere to go just a few um few support staff positions and um just got to make sure we have some way for our administrators to um our administrator no I thinkk thank you Miss Cooper for bringing that up I did have that that feeling myself and just recently had somebody who was I guess would be considered support staff um that I remember from high school who just

104passed away from ALS um but that person my memories of her um just the smiles and the interactions and how she made me feel um you know so those people are really also yeah they are important yep so we'll bring that back to you um at the next meeting they'll put put that on our list did you have any other comments okay uh yeah just thinking worst case scenarios Federal money disappears 6.8% of our budget does our fund balance cover that amount well our initial um so our initial so we know that the federal funds are off the table but when even when they were on the table they weren't those funds that we were um the funds that we were getting so um many of those funds are already allocated and Miss U can

105explain this better than I can but many of those funds are already allocated um and so that wasn't the initial worry I know some of it is just like when the um we had the fear of like government shutdowns and things of that nature um it's those reimbursements those time timely reimbursements but you have some different words for that what I would share with you is that our Title One title 6B are Fally funded um programs that are formula driven and they are are the awards that we're currently working on have our the money has already passed through to the state so they are already secure and and and even with the a awards for um the next year the method and the way that they're calculated was not uh in line with the financial

106assistance uh um money that they were targeting so we feel like that we were okay that we were safe now to address your if the world should fall out and and those Federal uh monies should dry up then that's when we're going to be going to the city and saying hey we need an additional six s million to pay for it so I mean that's my me that Federal allocation was right around $7 million and our Surplus budget fund balance right now is how much off the top of my head I think it's about six million five six million okay so we kind of have in our banking account just in case worst case worst worst worst case scenario okay thank you uh I yeah I I think Dr Gurley you answered some of these

107questions because I don't want to limit ourselves to this five what I again think is an artificial formula kind of number and I appreciate that they're being generous with us and I again would equal with that but uh we used to have in elementary schools Spanish being taught you know and we used to have you know some other things here I'm just again I know we've been this I think this is what Lisa was getting to miss to was getting to like a very low level like we just got survive mentality for the last couple years and I think we I'd like us to think beyond that and like what are the other richment activities Etc again other than hopefully beating the basic needs right we are a wealthy community here and our community should

108be investing in this students in these schools um so you know I just want to make sure you don't feel like you're liting yourself here I know you have to negotiate with Mr Sanders but it's also our job to negotiate with our city council colleagues for more money um so I'll leave that there but I didn't hear from you any specific like Gap that you're like oh wow we're we're missing but at the same time um I know this is not the number you brought to us originally with all the Ft you want originally uh lastly I didn't see anything here on the CIP I know this is all operational but we attended a meeting was it last week where they talked about our budget and we've been talking about the priority project allocation and

109it's been stuck at 1.25 million for five years is that going to go up because I didn't see that in their presentation last week and even though we've been talking about it for three months which drives me a little nuts uh you have not heard about an increase for that right so I mean I would just hope that you know that and Miss Dy asked me to go get money for you know these other things and so I I'm also H really happy with the schedule they presented last week about the solar roll out Etc and so you know I would like to see us present the asks on the CIP to not just our operational budget also I think it's something that we can work on again for that next one but there are

110some gaps there I think in the city needs to come back to us and increase the amounts in that to make sure our facilities are operating like they should and our students have a healthy and our staff have a healthy environment comfortable environment an environment where you know it's amenable to their teaching and learning so um that's in general there but I do hope and and I think I want to see an accelerated kind of layout on some of the solar roll out and other things that can drop down and reduce our expenses in addition to increasing that priority project amount thanks M Richardson any comments um I was just curious about um diversity and inclusion are we concerned about any programs or funding in that area um well we saw the executive order um

111Dr Johnson is still um she's doing still doing the good work for us of of equity um her department has evolved over time and so we've been um we've always called well this mostly last school year this school year we've been saying that she's the office of strategic initiatives because that's where a lot of the um program initiatives have um have been but I mean she's still doing the equity work still going and and be in the face of that for us and so I think that's another one where we're still saying it's business as usual okay I just wanted to you know ask about that yeah thank you you're welcome right Mr Meer thank you for your comments I think you know gives us some feedback as we work together to think about what

112our presentation looks like um I don't have any further comments uh so at this time we will open it up to public comment um I'll ask there's anybody here to raise your hand in the zoom room are we on Zoom okay raise your hand on the zoom room anybody in the audience that would like to give public comment no takers nobody everyone's passing anybody in Zoom okay um all right we've got some just a few meetings coming up just real quick CA doesn't have public comment which can we interpret that as this is that's yeah not the time to interact they will engage with us as they as they choose um so some meetings that are coming up um Thursday next Thursday February 6th um we have our normally scheduled uh Charlottesville City school board

113meeting at 5: and we get to recognize some teachers uh beforehand which will be exciting um Monday February 10th we have a joint budget work session back here uh with our city council colleagues uh Thursday February 13th we have our school budget work session um and then there are also some additional meetings that have gone out today through parents Square related to um our rezoning efforts as well um if you guys will indulge me I wanted to read just something um thanking uh the community for reaching out and sharing concerns regarding the recent executive orders and their potential impacts on our students and staff as a School Division we remain committed to fostering a learning environment where every student regardless of their background or identity orientation feels valued safe and supported uh we recognize that

114policy changes have created uncertainty and concern uh and we want to assure you that our Focus remains on the well-being of all of our students and staff our School Division uh has long upheld values of diversity inclusion and respect and we will continue to do so we appreciate just how uncertain this time is our curriculum has not changed it is not going to change uh and we look forward to continuing to uphold our mission of being better together so with that I will call this meeting meeting concluded

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.