001want to thank city council uh for this meeting U for participating in this um if you all can recall last school year um last budget cycle I should say we had some conversations with regards to meeting earlier and just having some conversation um about the needs of the school um so that it would feel a little bit more um intentional in the work so I appreciate that um I also want to acknowledge my Council part um Mr Sanders um you know he's a an excellent thought partner he has been very responsive to City Schools we have been having regular check-ins and I think that as the uh needs of the school have been very uh fluid he's responded of to various things and and brought city council up to speed so I just appreciate for
002all right next slide here is the agenda for the evening um and I will not read it to you but these are our highlighted areas um that we will use to facilitate the conversation that LE um and so this slide here um these are the things that we have been using so we did some Community sessions with regards to outreach about what these people want to see included in our budget um and so through our various listing sessions and engagement the words you see that are listed here of words that became themed and and really Rose to the top will not read all those words but you fold the word the more frequent the word occurs and so such as reading and math achievement attracting quality Educators modernizing facilities chronic aism compensation retaining teachers and
003support staff and um so on CHS group um are just some of the things that really um stood out in our budget presentations and I also want to say to both to our Council and to our school board that if you have questions as we go through this presentation please ask them dur the presentation you don't have to hold to the next slide please so from those things uh what we did we uh created the budget priorities and listed in the um darker green area of are those priorities and what we did was we aligned those with our strategic plan so under our increased academic achievement you will see that we created the priorities of increased student out support resources ensure that class size small and also a theme of sustaining funding Arts emerg under
004the area of culture and safy ofong we see that enh achievement equity and attendance a priority um supporting our staff we have competitive W benefits and attracting and retaining High qual teachers and staff and lastly under the isue oper of our strategic plan um Contin [Music] to our we thought it was essential to really keep the main the main thing and so to that end um ourd centered on the direct needs of our students um and so to fully understand what a core of what we do it's really about understanding who it is what help to sh the for our so this is our membership Trend since the 2014 2015 years and as you can see from this gra we have had some Inc enr since the and so that with that 2019 2022 so
005that year we have seen we have seen increase um but however we still are about 100 students currently we about 100 students than we were we were were and if you noce from last scho we had I don't differ [Music] terms graduating know Cort arear and small so this [Music] show that right [Music] some schols are are nearing the and also know there's a lot of Redevelopment happening throughout um the city particularly in our in the sou end of this the city and so if you've been engaged in our process you know that we've been having a lot of conversation as it relates to school sies I do want to point out one of our G which is luga mcness uh luga mcness is our alternative program and we have 32 students enroll in and
006while that seems like a really small number that wom put them beyond what the max the school can hold but we've been very creative about how we can support students and so um I just want to point that out because 32 is look back in time we've not had 32 students in Ro get so this on our next slide um our student de demographics and so the look back here is 20 years and so if you look back over the last 20 years you you see that there is a shift um and the racial demographics of our school um if you look back on look back in June of 2004 um you know our black students made up a significant portion of who SCH those City Schools was um and if you look now in
0072024 you see that that number has um significantly declined and and so as we bring this conversation you think about how many students you are you have in a particular sub group versus how much of the resource they require um and I think that that's what you will notice in the change from 20124 I'm sorry from 2004 to 2023 next slide so this is um an important slide here as we talk about the work so here you will see the percentage of students identified as economically disadvantage over the last 20 years and economically disadvantage is indicated in GL so you will see that um and back in 2004 economically disadvantaged represented less than half of our student population and so um now if you look at um if you look at what has happened in
0082024 we've we've increased that number by almost 177% and so um I know last year we used a lot of acronyms um and so I'm going to try to not as use many acronyms and just um say things um completely so in terms of economically disadvantage and just want to remind you all of my last conversation these are um these are our students who um they uh qualify for free and reduced la and so we don't just use that qualifier anymore because every student in our school division now qualifies for prece fun because of our C program um Community eligibility uh program but these are our students who are directly certified to T temporary T um Medicaid snap so these are our families represented in that blue Bo that 63.5% who are directly certified their
009families receive some type of benefit and so that number has you can see how that has shifted from 2004 to 2014 that was a little bit over half to now we are 63.5% of our students absolutely sorry um since that metric has changed um does is is it a direct equivalent or or are there does It capture Yeah a different population just because of the metric has changed you say the metric are you saying the free right is it is it the exact equivalent no number of folks you take that part you can take the you can that's the state's definition so because everyone in Charlottesville City Schools qualifies for the CP uh because we a CP you can remove that as a as an indicator and it's still apples and but so in effect
010if we you know you said we're using uh tanif snap and Medicaid for the 2024 numbers did we go retroactively apply that to the 2004 numbers it was the same it was the it was it's always been this has always been the definition actually back was still applications num in 2024 you don't no longer have lunch applications to includ students also part there was going to be this gap of the reduced meal cost for kiddos that we would um the I would more recent time last year we've seen a pretty sharp increase in our disadvantage numbers as well as like umer care which also feed into that um so that's just looking from one year to the next which those are definitely yes yeah okay thank you and so so if a student is experiencing
011hessig student at any they automatically are as student under the EC next slide so I want you to think about the 63.5 number the last of the 63.5% of the students this is the racial breakdown this is the demographic breakdown of the 63.5% of students see what it was in in 2004 um and it was Lely black students if you look at the progression through the 20 years now we're sitting at it's it's almost evenly distri CLE I will say that it's a little bit misleading it's a little bit misleading in terms of how check race on applications oh um particularly in that box where it says white and other um that to me is more of a um it's more of a great area because we see there are a lot well many families
012of course that are not checking black because they don't identify as black um but they are checking white they are doing um they are doing others so I don't know that this clearly shows you who our families are based on who we serve in in Charlesville City Schools but this is the breakdown as it is reported from the state next slide so we um that was the economically disadvantaged um student group so now the students that we serve um students with disabilities so we do serve students in Charlottesville City Schools um who qualify for special education services from ages two until their through their 22nd birthday and so what this table displays is the number of students who receive greater than 50% of their time um with special education services and students who receive um
013less than 50% of time and for um special education services and when we talk about less than 50% of services we're talking about um how much time they're spending with the special education teacher if they're spending how much time they spend in the general education setting um how much time they spend in the special education classroom and so as of December the 1st of 2024 our number um we're holding pretty steady uh we're serving 568 of our students um are students with disabilities um they receive some form of special education Andor related services so as I see the as I did a quick little bit of math then so 568 out of a total enrollment of 4,446 is about 133% does that sound about right yes that's correct and remember some of these students um
014and one thing that I will continue to reiterate as we go through the presentation is that um many of these stud students are the same student so you can be um of course you can be a black student who's disadvantaged um who's also a special education student or you can be an English language learner um and also receive special education services so you can fall into many of these um many of the categories in terms of where you need support next slide um so as we shared last year our enrollment for our multilanguage Learners continue to increase um this year we continue to Trend upwards um with our multilanguage Learners making up about 177% of our entire student population um many of our English language Learners come to us with um little to know U
015little to know English proficience English language proficiencies um and I've put over in that corner so we're now up to 757 of our students who require um English language learner Services I did not want to make this presentation complicated but these are students who are receiving services with an English language learner teacher we have students who are also being monitored because they're no longer receiving Direct Services so that number Trends up to 800 uh we have about 800 plus students um we were looking at that and I was going to make some modifications to the presentation but I think that we live in this world and I think it makes a lot of sense to us um but it may get a little bit confusing when we start using multiple numbers so there are um
016800 plus students um that are English language learners but 757 of them and I forgot the exact date that this was pulled um but 757 at that time are receiving um Direct Services from an English language learner teach um teacher so in that on that rightand corner um I want to pull this apart for you because this will start to get at the work that our teachers and our support staff and our Specialists are doing in the building so when our English Lang language Learners come to us and I'll just use um I'll just use an Afghan student who has no English who has no language English language when they come to us under our um under the current model that we had 11 semesters that they could test with us before their so score
017would count towards um our accreditation that under the new um under the new standards of accreditation that is now changed we have gone from 11 semesters to three so after three semester their um their so scores their so test results will start to go towards um our accreditation that is huge and and when I say huge that's like trying to land um aen 747 at the Charlottesville Airport there's just not enough Runway to do that um and so you have to have some type of urgency about okay the flight plan the plan that you're developing for our students how you're going to support them will need to change because the timeline has gotten shorter um and and when I say this this is a stressor this is a stressor that happens that will happen for
018their um their specialist teacher their English language learner teacher to how I support them this also has implications for that general education teacher because remember they're spending their time in the general education setting with their general education teacher um who's feeling the pressure of in three semesters this student will be testing with us versus 11 seme versus 11 semesters um yeah um there's a question yeah Dr G just a question uh the state changed the this requirement on us right is the state giving us any more money to uh help meet those new higher uh standards um they are not um so no money comes with this um this is this is all on you know you figure it out and I'll talk about I'll talk about that um in a little bit but this
019is like a you figure it out model and I think that you know you ask any teacher um you ask any teacher they all are working very hard um and this is something that is keeping people up at night now um because I just met with a group of teachers uh well I met with meet with teachers all the time but I met with the whole staff of teachers who these are the questions that they're worried about um because they feel like whatever happens for them whatever happens from this process is a reflection on them and um I don't feel that way um I think that this is something that's being put upon them and then as a division we've been asked to just figure it out you were I think you had a question
020okay um and the last thing I'll just say about that um that I have noted over there in the right hand corner is that um 10% of their ma 10% of their achievement will now become a component of our new accreditation system um so a lot of imp a lot of implications all the way around next slide um so this is um the two the spring 24 Spring 2024 English um re the reading Pass rates from the so test and I will say that I want to preface by saying that this these are the percentages of students that passed this does not show um because like when you look at our accrediation you'll see that the number is actually a lot higher um and that's because our accrediation ra rating shows like um gives us
021credit as students continue to make growth so they may not have hit the proficiency score but they showed growth so you will see that some of those um many of those scores many of these scores are higher under our accrediation rating because students are given growth from moving giving credit for moving from one band to the next um and so what you'll see in this what you will see in this presentation I'm sorry in this slide is that um our white students are outperforming all of our other student groups um and so you'll see that in some areas they're um in double digits that they are outperforming our students if you look at our English language Learners um you know their their pass rate is 20% um if you look at our black students it's
02240 it's 40% the question that often people will say is does this mean our students can't read um does this mean only 40% of the black students can read and the the response is absolutely not this is about whether they can pass a test um this is about 40% of us Stu 40% of black students pass the test not whether they not whether they are reading um on a below grade level next slide um same thing here this slide is about um this is the math so test this is about whether our students are passing the test uh not about how proficient they are within each reporting category um and this the same Trends the same Trends exist our um white students are outperforming our other student groups as it as it relates to uh
023passing the so um the so test um any questions about those any questions about those two slides all right our next slide so I want to talk about the implications um currently um I want to begin by saying this and this is not on the slide So currently five out of our six schools five out of six of our elementary schools are fully accredited um we have one elementary school that is accredited with conditions and that Summit Elementary um I will tell you that our schools have done a phenomenal job of moving the needle as it relates to student achievement um when I say that the teachers are doing the work they're doing the heart work they're doing the hard work um you know they're just I mean it's Blood Sweat and Tears they are
024meeting families where they are um as a School Division we are providing the resources uh but I will tell you that there are a lot of implications as we move into um our next school year beginning with the test results at the end of this school year next school year year um next school year we will be um evaluated under a new accountability system and so the results from the spring of 25 which is this current school year the results of spring 25 will be used to evaluate where we stand with the new accreditation system for the 2526 school year and we've gotten an we've had an opportunity to have a preview of what that looks like so remember I told you five out of the six of our elementary schools are accredited um fully
025accredited they've done the work you've seen them move the needle under the new system only um uh under the new system four out of the six of our elementary schools have an unfavorable rating because they have completely changed our new um accreditation system um and again I think it's about they have done the work um and as I've been meeting with teachers I've been meeting with staff over the last over this month this is the one thing that they're extremely worried about because they feel like this is an evaluation of them and I'm I'm telling them that that's not what this moment is about so under the new accreditation system four out of the six of our elementary schools are not accredited and it's a it's called off track and so with that off track
026rating means there's something different that we're going to have to do to support our students um and I will say that nobody wants to be in that situation right I mean um and so we will have to create plans we will have to support students um this will be you know these things will be headlines and news in the news because we know that about 60% of the schools in Virginia will have an off trck rating um under the new Under This new system um a lot of politics involved um don't mind saying that for the record um and so keep that in mind as as we talk about um resources and budgets so I'm framing this because this is about resources this is about what we do for students this is about um this
027is about you know when we were little uh when you would take the water and put it in the ketchup to you know you're trying to spread it this is like you can't do that anymore there's nothing left in the bottle um you know it's like you're going to have to do something different um so you you take that accrediation um system and and to play and then you look at our enrollment so if you look at our enrollment you may say well you're down about 40 students um so you're working with less students now that's not the case because I showed you that the number of our English language Learners continues to Rise um the number of students with disabilities while it did not increase it's the needs are still there um those needs
028are not um those needs haven't gone anywhere but when we talk about our English language Learners remember we've gone from 11 semesters where we were supporting our students to three we have to do something different we're going to have to support them differently um I had a meeting um at an elementary school um Johnson Elementary School I'm I'm going to name them I'm going to name them met with Johnson this week they're very concerned um because they feel rightfully so they feel like they're underst staff because their number of students with um their number of students requiring English language learner Services has increased um has increased and so some of that is about um are we equipped to meet the needs um of our students knowing that we're changing we're going from we have less
029time to get them where they need um to get them where they need to be and and so how do we um how do we how do we work with our how do we work with those students like what's the sense of urgency is what's the sense of urgency from the superintendent from the school board from the city council these are the questions that they're asking but I also will tell you that as we Embark upon this process our human capital our instructional resources will need to be allocated different ly across our schools because the needs continue to be to evolve the sheer fact that we're saying that 63.5% of our students are economically disadvantaged tells us that we have to support our students differently and that doesn't mean and I want to make sure
030that I preface by saying this because you are a student um who is economically disadvantaged that doesn't mean that you're not successful when you come to school but what we do know is that many of those students don't always have ex um have access to the appropriate resources so that's about what what is it that we do differently at schools so although we strive to meet the needs internally and I think that that's that ketchup bottle right we we want to make it work so we'll just add water to the bottle but sometimes it just doesn't work it lose it loses the flavor it just doesn't do what it's intended to do we've done that internally um so then those resources just aren simply are not enough um to support the rising needs of our
031student groups and so we have to do something different and then we also know that the standards of quality are well below the minimum to to truly meet the needs of our students and there was a jck study and I don't know what jar stands for um yeah yeah joint legislative audit and review that was a JLo study which we put into one of our presentation last year that just simply says what the state allocates to us doesn't even like touch scrape the bottom of what we need let alone get us to the top um and so the s soq u funding level just is the bare minimum and so I just employ you to just think employ you to think about who it is that we're serving how we serve them why we serve
032them um and knowing that this is what our teachers and our administrators and our support staff this is the the love these are the students that we that we love every day but recognize that they need something um they need something different before we move forward any questions about um anything I've said thus far I'm going to take a sip of water yes please go ahead no go um so for the new standards that you were talking about for accreditation um what just like generally what have they changed um so part of what they've so part of what they've Chang is it's not a it's not so growth is weighted differently um growth is weighted differently it's weighted now um it's weighted differently so there's um a percentage for growth there's a chronically absent U
033chronic absenteeism which that was factored in a while ago which we I I'm gonna speak for myself I absolutely hate because that's the one thing that a teacher can't control is whether a child gets to school our team has done a great job of um of repurposing um school um School social workers and um mental health professionals to support um attendance and we've we've definitely prioritized attendance um our attendance The Chronic absen ISM rate is dropping but it's the one thing that we can't control and it's facted into our accreditation system um and it's like I don't know how I why am I evaluating the principle or the teacher on whether um a student can get to whether a student can get to school it doesn't mean that we should not do our due diligence
034and we shouldn't prioritize student attendance um it's just one of those areas that we don't we can't control so but it does have some um it does have some bright spots it talks about work-based learning um it talk so we get points for work-based learning but then they also have how many many Advanced courses a student takes um is um calculated into the um equation and I I find it really weird because yes we we want to advance our students but when the model consists of how many uh High School courses you take in the Middle School um you know like how many Advanced is it English it's science it's math math is one right now and then it will the next one will be um I think it's two for advanced courses anyway it's
035at the middle school level and I agree but I don't agree I mean sometimes kids aren't ready at the middle school to be in a a high school level class so it's about how many high school level classes will be factored in and I just don't think that sometimes we push kids too fast and that's why they get disin um they're not interested in the in the programming yeah Science and History so yeah so thank you you're welcome anything else instructional related I will keep on so um operational cost um I think this meeting this meeting has prepared us to talk about the budget differently than we have um I don't think that in our previous discussions because I think we were already um it was January already and we were having uh we were
036having conversations about where we were and what we need and it just felt very responsive like asking you um or telling you this is where we are not budget we get to have a dialogue about operational cost just as we said we have this meeting earlier we now get to say is there a way that we can do things differently as we move forward um to address um to address cost um so the next few slides will um highlight areas both where staff and the board have questions about and you will see that the two biggest drivers in our operational cost are our maintenance and and our transportation contracts and so and maybe you all have some answers in that area that I don't have um and so um I think as look to the
037future we can talk about is this does this continue to be the approach next slide um so this slide displays our energy use um intensity and water use um that dotted line that you see on both of those graphs that's our targeted use by 2020 um 20 I'm Sorry by 2030 um which is six years five years from now um so as shown we um are exceeding the target for both energy and water um and our our current consumption levels I have that we are not on track to meet that Target because we um continue to be well above that um well above that line um if you look if you um are following the operational if you're following the operational cost um including water and and um energy usage the significant impact overall to
038um this is a significant impact to how we run our um buildings I mean when you look at the operational cost of the um the utilities and so I think as we have conversations about our um Capital Improvement plan as we talk about how we invest in our facilities I think you all have demonstrated you've you've we've talked about what it would look like and how we can address mitigate some of these costs um but it truly is time as we look at our consumption and are we just being good stewards um of the people's money um is this the best way like what energy efficiencies how do we how do we continue to retailer and um and address our Capital Improvement um our Capital Improvement plan projects so that we can redirect our savings
039towards supporting our students and improving uh and improving outcomes and I do want to give the city um Team a shout out uh Mike Gard um and team just being responsive helping us to prioritize um making the main thing but also sometimes the CIP is a fluid document and we have to move things around um we have to move things around to address the pressing needs of the schools I see a hand yeah Dr g i I asked Dr gury to include this because we did get this report from your your team last spring because I'm looking at where can we find money and Savings in our operations and I think as you all know that we don't necessarily we don't control that is the thing that I've learn this is uh again your facilities
040Department your finance department making decisions on what projects to invest in in our facilities that can either save money uh from reducing energy usage and water usage Etc and you've seen here unfortunately it just has not been going down and we' rather against you prefer to spend that money on the teachers and educating our students rather than sending that to dominion and or cville gas but I do think this is uh to my again colleagues counselors this is the political question of how much money do you want to invest in our schools to again reduce our operational cost so we can spend more money on on our teachers okay thanks all right we can do the next slide um and so when we talk about performance cost um this slide shows that in terms of
041we're not when you when we're looking at sustainability and investment and and our energy consumption I mean we've only gone down 2% over the last 13 years um and then our Gap consumption has increased um has increased uh by 6% and so it's just that Trend that as we're thinking about sustainability and some of these bigger older dated buildings I will tell you that I've been doing what I call well checks at schools uh meeting with the staff and and talking about um like what's what's something that I can get out of your way and and a lot of times I'm I think that the first thing that they're going to say is something about planning or something like that but they point out like um at Johnson um our bathrooms downstairs just continue to
042overflow um I mean it just how are we GNA bring fifth graders back in the building uh when I was in Green Brier um and their only concern heading into the winter break was the bathroom um and so the facilities um the facilities are dated I mean we are talking about we have schools that range from 50 from 100 years old um to 50 years old and and so the long-term plan and I know that U Mr Sanders and I have had a conversation about this in terms of um building a long-term plan because we won't always be the people at the table um but building a long-term sustainable plan to just address um facilities and the modernization of facilities and what happens when you need bigger buildings and Etc and so I just I
043put this here yes one at the request of um School Board member uh Meyer but also that our um how we're using utilities and and the age of our facilities have an impact on how we're spending the money that you give us that we basically give back to you um and so that's something that we should be addressing over time ask one question about this yes sir electric is that the amount by which the rate has gone up in one year is that over a period of time what is that that was my G Slide sorry I actually don't know because I I didn't Mike's behind from the report it was on our last it was on our last presentation from the city R changes but yes that is the that is the that is
044the increase that is the increase somebody from say seven seven cents to 10 cents in one year or seven seven bucks to 10 bucks in one year that's the research it was on the last City slide I'm pretty sure this is from 2011 to 2023 the increase in the rate so you're right lyd and as much like the rate per kilowatt hour it's gone from like s cents to 12 cents a kilowatt hour or something like that all right I think my point here though too is the before where our energy intensity has actually gone up and so and if we contain that if we continue on that energy rates are only going to continue to go up and we're going to have to keep on paying more and this is where you know again
045our ask for rooftop solar to reduce the total amount of energy electricity we're having to consume and hedge that cost for the next 20 25 years is an ask that we've been making a long time and trying to hit this home right here can you appropriate the money to get and have your staff focus on getting those things done because again we'd rather spend money on teachers and staff rather than our utility bills next next slide um so as we um as we talk about our facilities um there are things that have happened um that are in progress well things that are have happened past tense things that are currently in progress um and things that and things that we are looking to the Future for um and so these are things that have have
046and had of financial implications uh and so as we think about our Safety and Security infrastructure um it's ongoing um we will continue to um include those things in our budget but we have a a daily need to ensure that we we have safe and secure um facilities and so as we um go through our safety audit um just about um keeping our interior and exterior um doors um safe we've had some things related to fencing and um fencing and Gates the modernization of our our buildings so again if we don't have a plan to continue to refresh things then it feels like we always need to address these um we have to do this big lift um to address things um um so particularly at C particularly at CHS um and so you see
047those things that are in progress and and again I think always want to shout out um our city um City counterparts for just being responsive because I know we did have a um we did have a pivot when we um when we moved up in priority the bathroom um the bathrooms that are in the uh B Commons the single star bathrooms were you g to say something Miss yeah I was going to ask are the um restrooms near the gym nasium included in this upgrade on near the gym Oh So eventually we want all the restrooms in in charlotesville high school to be the style that the type that's currently in the B Commons and the type that is going to be in all of Charlottesville middle school because fortunately it was designed in for
048charlotesville Middle School um it they're they're not inexpensive projects we actually had the B Commons Second Story uh boys restroom on the second floor was identified as a second area that we were hoping to tackle at the same time we did the B Commons restrooms at the cafeteria but it was like a an ad alternate and we were really just able to there was only enough funding available to just do the restrooms for the be Commons and that was a great it's been a wonderful proof of concept it has been a huge help for charville high school now it just leaves us wanting more throughout the whole building um um because what's happened is the behaviors and concerns that you know that were the impetus behind moving on this and even bumping it up in
049priority those things just now concentrate elsewhere in the building where we still have old style restrooms that very difficult to supervise and these new restrooms increase privacy for students while while also increasing supervision so they're just a really great new design it's unfortunate they weren't always this way but so that would be that bullet is referring to just the holistic addressing of all the restrooms at Charlesville High School we'll have to eat that elephant one bite at a time all right um also just um as we talk about facilities um the prek the prek center um is something that's um is very important to us um I know as we um go through our current reconfiguration process and we um eventually this building that you're in right now um we will move fifth GR ERS
050back to the elementary school and we will move sixth graders to the um re I mean the B the new building is bigger than the current building so as we move them to that building which will be Charlottesville Middle School this building will be vacated and our teachers are hoping to only camp out here for a little while because we will have a new pre Center so I know that we will continue to have conversations about that and also as I talked about earlier just continuing to have the conversation about elementary modernization I know that the one and a qu million um we have U appreciated um as we have you know done um upgrades to the library um to the library at greenb and we've done some vegetable work at a school and the
051Terrace and some Terrace work at another school um all those things are greatly appreciated but I think um overwhelmingly um you know our elementary teachers know that they're in Old buildings um and we they weren't designed for the size bodies or the number of bodies that we have in those schools now and so we just need to keep thinking about what's the long-term range what's the long-term plan for our elementary schools and then lastly um just the Energy Efficiency upgrades um I think that if we have solid plan to address our energy efficiencies it translates into how we can move the money that we're saving um back to our um back to our schools Dr GLE as you're looking looking at the CHS modernization just go back to that a second yes we talked about
052restrooms what's with ceilings MLK oh okay I'm sorry um so the restrooms we've talked about the restrooms are putting the single stall the single stalls um the ceiling tiles um I don't know if you when you walk through um they have the drop ceilings um they are in I mean some very deplorable um conditions in some areas you um they are hanging they're sagging they're discolored um it you know one day we will be talking about new Charlottesville um High School I believe because it's not this is not the school um aesthetically that it's not aesthetically pleasing and and it doesn't lend itself to the learning spaces it's very open um all of the doors that we have now put alarms on um it's very um it's very free so it's not built in an
053age where we it wasn't built in an age where we were thinking about security um where we were trying to control access it was very much you walk out the school and go to Smoking Pit um type scope um and and so that's the ceiling the MLK pack um which is the pride and joy of um you know it's it's one of our crown jewels here it's dated um it's orange um it's very much um very much um kind of Brady Bunch Fred sanf forish in terms of um color it's very dated very shag Carpe is um we've had some lighting issues but we know that it is it is one of the things that brings people to our communities because they come to um our plays they um you know we have outside people
054who want to use this space but um it's just not something that's aesthetically pleasing and I would say even having upgrades to like the sound and I mean I think if we had endless amount of money that it could look totally different but being realistic there are things that we do need to address very quickly such as Carpeting and seats um I mean that's just lwh hanging fruit right there and I'm almost sure that it comes with a huge price tag unfortunately but that's because these things are not they're they're now getting on a list but they weren't on a list at one point and they got they kept getting pushed back what about their field the turf field um turf fields have um a shelf life um and so we will need to replace
055uh we will need to replace the turf field at at some point we still have a few years um on it and that we can patch and and make it work uh but we will be nearing the end of the shelf life for the for the turf field I mean five years 10 years two years no it's pass it's I think it's past past it's past its um due date so to speak for when it should be replaced but we are doing the regular service our athletic department is calling for like annual service on it to kind of keep nursing it along but there comes a point where you just can't do that anymore so you know we're at three years or less I think of being in like the real we we've been past
056due and I think we're within three years of not being able to keep nursing at long um per se so that's the concern but we are doing annual maintenance to keep it prolong it as long as we can miss Asher said how old is it yeah how old is it Mike 20 no it's not 20 um it was before my time and I came here in 2014 so I apologize I don't have that number handy but it does have a prescribed life and we're over it yeah yeah thank you any other facilities thank you um Mr snook for asking this question all right well we will um continue on down yes I'm sorry there we go just wanted to um make a point and share and I know it came up in our our CIP
057meeting The Joint meeting um and it came up I believe at our last Schoolboard meeting that that and we continue to be grateful for that I believe it's 1.25 um that we get for the modernizations that have been used for the elementary schools and some of the projects um like the bathrooms at CHS this last year but that that that number has remained fixed for several several years at least five years and so there was discussion about just consideration that you know we get less for that same amount of money and so that we do have at least one Elementary School that that work is still continuing so just you know it was a conversation point that that amount um if if that could be considered um to adjust that that would be appreciated excuse
058me I'm sorry all right um transportation so um as we um talk about our transportation contract um again I want to um shout out our city city partners because um you all did allow us to have Miss Duval and I know that um I now call on her regularly um to help me with supporting our families because we uh get a lot of Transportation uh calls and um we don't have to feel them within our office she's done a very good job of um taking care of them so we appreciate that um and so in terms of our transportation contract we know it it covers all of our services with regards to transporting our students with the exception of the um um chartered transports which we do um which we work with our schools and
059um and our clubs and and things to um to work with Charter and transportation when needed to take those um distance trips um and so what we know is that we will talk about um later in this presentation about the transportation increases and so uh it's our understanding that the transportation increases are um related to the increase in cost for benefits and wages which you see here on our um on our on the screen um and then we also know that you all are doing work with regards to um the drivers working actual hours I think one of the I think one of the things that um I probably need help with and I always am am calling on um on um Miss poell is in terms of I think with all of our contracts
060if we could just figure out a if we could just figure out a different way of like reconciling that at the end of the year um it's I mean we are we're giving you the money but it it would be nice if we just had this way of just seeing like okay this is what it all went towards because like when we have vacancy savings then we then this is what happens with the money so if positions aren't filled then um just creating a just creating some other process in this where we can say you had a contract with us and then we can reconcile that this is where the money went to just like this is where the the increase goes the next year does that make sense it doesn't so we give you
061so you all give you all tell us this is how much it costs for transportation or this is how much it costs for maintenance if we could if we could reconcile that contract by saying that this is what the money went to this is how we applied the money that you we requested from you all this year like the salaries benefits or we had three vacancies we had three vacancies in in maintenance so this is what I think that that's one of the questions that we get that I never have the an like my board that's shaking their head they have a question they have questions about that but I don't really know the answer to that and so it's not about you're doing or not doing whatever with the money it's we don't I
062don't know the answers to if you had seven vacancies then of course I mean I would assume that I think Mr Williams even said this one one time that like well if you had three vacancies then I had to pay somebody overtime right then I had to pay somebody overtime I think it's that kind of stuff like right you're good with coming up with processes um and um what else did I miss anything else I missed from this Miss po I don't think so my understanding is and the the second area one that um we've been talking about for years there's um a number of 30-hour positions and what we what we hear what I what um what I hear heard again this year is that despite all the progress we've made uh overall with
063the transportation system there's still a good number of 30-hour positions that are routinely working 40 hours in order to cover all of our regular day routes the midday routes the special transportation services the field trips within the metro area and so um of course then that then you have the those 30h hour positions that are like well I'm always working 40 hours but I'm don't get the same level of contribution for the benefits and so they're asking that this next contract balance the 30 and 40 hour positions to the level that's needed overall but you know it's about the overall number of drivers but it's also about recognizing the number of drivers that routinely are required to work 40 hours in order to provide all the services so that's that midle middle piece there and
064that last piece especially during the driver shortage overtime our dependency on contract services for the middays the special Transportation just kept climbing and um we really the idea of course is we want to rain there's understandably a desire to reain that back because it would be I think a better level of service and more cost-effective in the long run but at first there's this process of having to get more Vans and get more drivers while reducing the dependency on the cont cont ract services and so um that's hopefully something that we'll see a savings from in the next budget cycle but this is what was uh included and and presented to me in the proposed increase for next year any other questions before we press forward uh yes please so do you currently have Vans
065and van drivers or is this all new and Garland can chime in here too there are two Vans and it was determined that in order to really get get away from contracted Services we would six additional Vans would be needed and presently the the van the people who are driving the Vans as well as some cars if it's just one or two students being transported to a special program a lot of times it ends up being the bus AIDS who get pulled to drive those special runs and then that taking an important support off of the buses and so this is um hopefully that you know prayerfully the increase that's put forward this year kind of balances the equation in a the most efficient way as far as supply and demand and then the hope
066would be that the increases would not be as significant you know once we get over the post postco hump of rebalancing what really is a more efficient way to deliver all the services that's my understanding and it just anecdotally what I know from my from my office I I I do see pieces of this for sure as being needing to be adjusted Dr gley sorry real quick and yes I I know that city's been taking a lot of having a lot of questions about transportation and buses the EV buses is the priority on getting school buses to be Electric so that we can save money in the future or what's where are we going with that because again this is something that a school board we don't control this is all in your guys's court
067and something that we'd really like to have to reduce our operational expenses going forward or at least hedge those thanks yeah so when you reference priority uh priority is is probably measured in a couple of ways one we are definitely working towards the integration of electric buses uh the commitment has been made that we right now have two uh and we are in the last stage of determining are we going to apply for up to two more um that is a budget decision because there's a local match requirement uh the team has completed the work on reviewing that and I'm in the process of reviewing whether or not I can find the money to pay for an additional Grant to then to pay towards an additional grant that might get us up to four the
068the plan is yes we're we're talking about Fleet conversion we're talking about total Fleet conversion so that is the priority but that comes over time right and just to my my counselor colleagues I know there's a million dollars a year in the CIP for climate related initiatives for the city yes you know this is some things where you know I think we would like to see you know how's that benefiting our schools was it you know again through Energy Efficiency improvements or matching grants or Investments you know and or is some of that money going to be matching grants for Ev buses for us so we can reduce our expenses going and that's I mean I haven't got any Clarity on again how that million dollars is spent and again how is that being also
069benefiting the schools so those are the things that I think you know it could be again matching to get rooftop solar on our schools but I I think we are interested in seeing EV buses as many as possible to reduce our operational expenses going forward and I would just add briefly as was mentioned there are electric school buses that are being Acquired and pursuing additional ones but in the sake of forthrightness I think one of I think at least for for Council one of the guiding assumptions of having Fleet conversion be a top priority was the available of federal money through the bipartison infrastructure law um inflation reduction Act and the local matches full Fleet conversion will only be feasible if that money is accessible for upfront infrastructure costs as well as acquiring the buses
070themselves so we are very much watching what if anything gets cut that is unspent from those bills because obviously if the new Administration Cuts those I think the ability for us to do a full Fleet conversion becomes much much harder um so I think honestly that's probably the biggest variable for us I will offer just um from an operational standpoint the question you pose there is not a direct answer because it was not established with a director from Council to to make it as clear as what you just asked there is no answer for me to give to you in regards to what is the percentage of benefit that might impact schools for the climate action fund that wasn't a consideration what was what was considered was Council adopted a climate action plan and there
071needed to be some funds put into implementing said plan the effort was to identify funding and then to allow the subject matter experts on our team to determine and how do we deploy that so that's the work that's being done um I do understand that that is going to impact schools because we're in that conversation with them right now about this this EV bus application more than likely if we are to move forward with these two buses one of the questions was could some of that money come out of that fund if it hasn't already been earmarked for something else for this fiscal year so that's part of the answer but I can't I'm not in a position to give you a more concrete answer that I believe you desire because that was not the
072directive that I was given either so I have a million dollars a year in the CIP and we plan to deploy it to the best of our ability to make an impact across system I also want to go back and just make sure for a council's benefit it is and I'm looking backwards just to make sure I get the right knot head the head knot um this slide represents what has been discussed between cat and School staff correct all right I just want to be sure that that this is not just so that you can appreciate this was not a dictate from us to schools this was worked out so when we look at this this is about the change that is is taking into consideration how do we serve the needs of getting kids
073to school so that's this is the result of that and now we have to wrestle with how we pay for it yes did a Wonder job in explaining the information director she did a wonderful job in explaining everything the 16 on the full time represent the numb that we need to make sure that we have ample fulltime drivers in the summer so that is a component that is that we need to continue to focus on if we continue have a bunch of part ERS they're not necessarily requ so this Mak sure that we have the number of D you desire to get your students to that I have a question um I wanted to know what is the current wage for this position and what would a um increase look like what's the current wages
074there actually the contract um that we have with the m trans they actually have an increase that will go into place January 1 um so what you'll see in the budget ref of the true cost of that Mr Sanders do you have any sort of you have any update on rooftop solar for CHS it's something that I've heard uh about quite a bit and my understanding was there was an issue with Dominion in terms of there's a lot there okay the honest answer solar is a is a complicated issue it's a lot um I don't believe that we're in a position to to go deep into that because I also would need the benefit of Miss rbo being present uh for efforts that are underway but I know that we have we have a full
075Finance I don't want to I was going to call it a scheme and I don't want to minimize it but we have a finance effort underway where we're trying to determine is there an opportunity for us to establish a financing mechanism got it that is viable that would then support our ability to to accelerate when uh and how many rooftop solar uh projects we could take on in addition to where else we might be able to do other improvements but I I would say that on this item I take this as a request for additional feedback from us and we can make sure that you have the conversation to then be able to provide that okay I would be particularly interested not knowing all the details or what barriers there may or may not be
076what the opportunity for power purchase agreements could be that could make The Upfront cost to the city significantly less correct and that is part of the strategy I mean crystal is aware of that but we are we're actually also having to work with our outside Finance team to help us even consider this because this is complicated and we have already learned that other municipalities have not been able to deploy it so we're of course a little nervous about that too I'll also go back to the the maintenance section and say that that too is a part of further conversation that we probably should have with Mr gard and Miss Ral to then just kind of talk about how CIP has impacted and and what our approach has been because those are true direct ask for
077changes to what we've been currently doing and and you would have to consider that oh okay you have the number a question about the wage um I'll give you the wage that starts January 1 $23 um for starting pay that 2350 for the start top contract first year it takes years second year it Tes second contract just to restate that into the microphone in case anyone at home missed it um the starting salary for uh people Transportation Drivers is $23 an hour and the um the top rate is $31 an hour starting in January and that increases by about uh 50 cents in July all right anything else uh Transportation related before we move forward all right seeing no other questions we will press forward so um now we have our um uh 20 FY
07826 budget considerations next slide um and so want to show you here uh um for the last four fiscal years we've kept our salary at the um on par with the state rate so the state rate increases and so that is that gray bar that's trending um that's trending up and down and so um you maybe looking at the 24 year and 24 to 25 fiscal year and wondering what the up and down is and so I want to make sure we explain so uh back in the FY 2 we gave a um 5% raise on July the 1st of 2023 but then the general assembly adopted a budget in the fall which required a 2% raise effective um January the 1 and so you may be saying well five and two is seven but
079we because it was only half of the year which we implemented it that's um then that is where it um it equates to like basically 1% because it was only half of the year so that's where we get the um it was a 6% raise for that year um and then for the FY 23 um I'm sorry for FY 25 which is the Year we're in now we gave a 3% raise which was approved with the um full impact of a with the um to include that 2% raise that we had given midy year um which equates to 5% for the upcoming year and so one thing that I am very appreciative of our school board is just really always prioritizing um making sure that the wages are competitive um for our staff um for
080all of our staff members next slide um so using the last four year gley could I ask one question I'm Sor sir yes sir the impact of collective bargaining is that part of this later on um yes I'll have baked into the conversation it'll be baked into the it'll be baked into the conversation um where am I okay I'm sorry um so on this so on this slide so um using the last four years average salary um then the the the average is 5. five and a quarter and the state um bium which is the 24 26 bium budget has a raise of 3% for the fiscal year um for the fiscal year 26 um which is for our upcoming budget so the one so I we are still working to um to um codify
081the remainder we're right at the end of our um our collective bargaining contract we we feel like we will have something to um just tighten up the few the remaining remainder of the language so that the Union can um present it to the bargaining group so within the conversation of compensation is the um there is a salary action there so included um included in the estimated compensation we're talking about um 4 point that 4.25 is inclusive um of the salary action for collective bargaining and for all employees so that's so it's using your word Mr then it is baked in um it is baked into that um into that number um did I did I say that right y it's five yep 4.25 um so it's baked into the um that number so collect the
082bar the collective bargain and ask is in there um our early um our early health insurance projections show an increase of about $1.1 million remember I don't know if this is the same for the um city but we are self-insured um and so ours is based on claims um our rates are based on claims and so this is um based on our 1.1 is based on last year's claims loss of about 117% um so we are hopeful that that um we are hopeful that that number that that number will come down um that will it will come down um but we will have to wait and see um and also there are no vrs um there's no vrs changes at this time I um next slide um won't spend a lot of time on this
083because this is the bill that you all give to us um but our um so our maintenance contract has seen an average um for the last three years of an increase of about $361,000 um our student transportation is projected to increase about $786,000 and um we will have some expenses from our ktech um from ktech our acquisition of ktech and so we are projected to increase in that area of about um, any um questions about the non- discretion well I will move on yes um I think this is where to speak to your ear point in the accounting the math where we as a board are saying 361 additional thousand for what what what were things spent on last year and and where did the money go and how did that get done where were
084bacancy savings or did it come from Public Works did it come from Parks and wreck where where did our line item money go um just to speak to that point and truly understanding um what each space is accountable for um whether it's our maintenance staff that doing the work daytoday or whether we need that support from the city um just really understanding kind of the process by which that happens and and then where that money is allocated for which space thank you anyone else before we vacate this slide all right question on student transportation I don't want to assume but is that a result of collective bargaining mostly new budget 12 all everything everything there okay thank you all right um so I in terms of our um budget request for student Improvement want to
085um as we look at what's here um and as we look at what's here and that's it probably should have changed the title after we ended up adding a couple other things on there um but the ESL teachers our ESL our English language learner specialist is requesting um five and a half FTE um and that's to support um the change um it's the the numbers increase in numbers but also the programmatic changes uh as it relates to our standard of accrediation um we um are seeing some fluctuation in our needs in terms of how we support stud students um with regards to reading and so bringing another reading specialist online um would it will definitely be an asset and we are looking to how we can deploy those um that support differently um and and
086what we are referring to as um differentiated Staffing so that the support moves with the student need um so if the student need changes from year to year from schools then this reading specialist support changes from year to year I have a question so how do we decide um why we only have one reading specialist well compared to like our numbers just one additional yep so this is this is one so the one additional is based on a change in um a change in the number of students we serve so the um the screener that we used to the screener that we used to identify students that screener changed and so when we're looking at case loads of how many uh when we're looking at case loads at how many students are being served by
087the reading specialist we feel that adding one to the to the pot brings down that case load and we want to be very intentional about where we place that one person so we exceed the state so we exceed the State numbers when it comes to case loads that's for everything that's for special education that's for L's but what we want to do is we want to temper that even more by being able to bring that number um that case load number down um and so that's based on current that's based on current numbers okay and then you're you said being intentional do we have a idea where we want to place this we do we've we we've had some so I don't want to speak out yet because we've not like inform the schools but
088yes we do and and along with this work um and we've not had a you all may not have been privy to a lot of this conversation um we had a change U with the Virginia literacy act um it's called the VA um the we had the Virginia literacy act and so our teachers um are going through um what we call letters training um it's this um and um science-based instructional um instructional reading um professional development to work with our students so they're going through that training but they also are writing reading plans so I mean the ask that we placed on teachers um has grown exponentially and so they're writing um they're writing um literacy plans you know they're doing um having Student Success meetings um with regards to um individual students so all
089of these things are happening and so we have interventionist in schools so some of this work can be done by the reading specialist and then some of this work is done by the classroom teacher and so that's why there's the one position there um for right now um we have seen um we have seen and continue to see an uptick in student behavior um particularly in our um with our Littles this is about this is about our Littles but they can work with all of our students but what we see is that kids have not gone they've not participated in a formalized preschool program they're coming to school they're disregulated um our students our teachers are spending a lot of time uh with those students and they're not having the opportunity we're not meeting those
090students who are disregulated we're not always meeting them where they are um and so from our student services department there is the proposal of adding um three behavioral support technicians people who can get in and do some of the most intense work model model what needs to happen but spend the time um with the students um help to do some of the functional behavioral assessments help to do the behavior intervention plans um our goal should always be that we should not see Behavior as as the pathway to special education services because they're not the same things um but often times um it gets conflated these misconstrued is one thing is the other and they're not not so this is um Miss rasnik um plan to how do we address this how do we give teachers
091and principles another tool without um having to burden the teacher with the teacher and the social worker with doing this work just not knowing the the terminology with these be positions that they end up basically working one-on-one with students or oh I just not fulltime with not full-time onetoone but could do some um could do some um interim time maybe one to one while they're helping to get the child regulated and modeling but the intent is not that this becomes the onetoone for the student yeah um they're they're they're bringing the knowledge they're working they're rolling their sleeves up they're doing the work alongside the teachers um and then they're providing the strategies and they're modeling but no they're not full-time uh onetoone with the student I'm G come back to the HR um the
092HR position we have a um in our attempt to continue to meet students where they are we um are um proposing in our programs of study a health and medical Sciences pathway um so this is a gateway to whether you want to be a nurse or whether you want to do something in the medical field so we are adding this pathway and it requires um a halftime FTE in order to um teach the um in order to teach the class and then lastly not well lastly and then I'll go back up we have the re uh restorative justice education specialist currently our um Family engagement specialist Miss Bianca Johnson is serving as the um restorative justice person um we find um loads of success in the work that she's doing but she is splitting her
093time she's splitting her position currently doing that work we have found um success from our students with spending time with her um helping to restore relationships um and helping students um helping communities of students um to just get to a better space she's also doing some work that looks like an extension of Human Resources because she's also working with staff members um she just did a whole she just did a whole restorative um with a school um just because there was some spaces where they weren't feeling well and she just really went in and she had to bring in some people from the community to help her do the work because she couldn't facilitate the groups by herself um so we're finding a lot of um we're finding a lot of benefits to that we
094want that position to be full-time she would actually move into that role and we would post her um we would post her current role um which is the family engagement so she would move over to restorative justice and we would post the family engagement and then um and then I want to go back to the um HR recruiting specialist what we are finding um what we're finding now um and this is probably true in every industry right you come to work and you think that you're going to do something one day and then all of these other things happen and you never can get to them um and that's very true of our HR department um in terms of um that department there's the director and then there's an HR administrator and then there's a
095person who does benefits and then we have um another person who um does a lot of the data day um administrative um task uh but on any different they wear so many hats that they get pulled for um investigations um they get pulled to I mean that takes up a lot um doing a lot of that Student Center work on sometimes people don't make all of the best choices so they spend so much time in that that we really don't they're not spending a lot of their time in the HR recruitment areas um they're recruiting for teachers but it's not um they can't always get into the work and so this allows us to put someone in place that that's their job um they get to stay into the social media um spaces make sure
096that our um make sure that our public facing job boards are up to date making sure that the um HR recruitment plan um is being implemented that we are tapping the right people to be doing those recruitment things and so that's what position is and so those are our um those are our position requests as it as they relate to um FTE um and so here is just a here's a summary of um what we've talked about what I've talked about as it relates to um preliminary request um so the preliminary request um our compensation and benefits and so back to Mr Pinkston question um baked into this number is um is the our um just the salary portions um baked into it is the salary portions from our collective bargaining um contract um and
097then there are the non-discretionary ask the student Improvement which I just um showed you which gives you a total of $7.9 million um thus far and and you can see where the bulk of the ask um is you know on compensation benefits that's baking in uh you said salaries for collective bargaining is it not baking in anything on the benefit side related to collective bargaining um I know just try that was not what that's not baked into no that's not baked into this benefits from um Collective bargain aren't baked into it okay so the the compensation change we're saying it's 5.3 million and that's the cost of the contract what about the employees that are outside of the contract that that includes projected increase for them too that's everyone yes that's everyone and so I
098gather this 7.9 million more than last year's that's correct and what we've done I did not say this but as we always do um we are looking at we are looking at current positions um and how we can use positions differently um because there are other needs but we're trying to make sure that we can address those things internally so that we're not passing the cost so that we're not passing the cost over to you all this is all this is operating budget this is not Capital that's correct okay is there going to be any additional Capital request in terms of CIP I'm going make sure well that that that's been made without dollar figures is what I'm appreciating because there's been a there's a already been a request to reconsider what the lump sum
099allocation is so that would be an increase if we were to change that and if there was uh further prioritization of solar and modernization that too would have to be a question th those are the things I think we have to talk about so and you raised the you mentioned the lump sum M and get a note that Miss ham is going to be responsible for my being able to hit because she provided me the information saying that there is from a prior year a $5.8 million lumpsum to schools that apparently hasn't been spent and a total of about $9 million of un of authorized but not issued Capital commitments that we've made to the school is money that has not been spent I'm just wondering whether do those amounts make sense for if you're
100not spending the money that that we're giving to you okay well gave me money that I didn't capital is all you all we don't spend the capital budget you guys spend the capital budget capital projects are with you MRN so clarifying that that's just bonds that we haven't sold there is a many many pages of plans that have for projects that are allocated um are in the works and then a lot of that list um is monies from we're always a year behind so at least one the 25 budget is in there that those bonds have not been sold yet so it's not necessarily a correlation that the dollars have not been spent is that the bonds have not been sold yet pardon my ignorance but if the bonds haven't been sold yet we don't
101have the money I assume we haven't spent it we actually sell bonds most of our bond issues um when we sell we sell there's a tax implication if we do not spend the money within 24 months so often when we sell bonds we are reimbursing ourselves for some portion of that um so sometimes we are um reimbursing ourselves up to 50% for expenditures that have already been spent okay this list and this nothing to do school folks this is a list that's been about 7080 million even more than that for as long as I've been on Council and some of the items have actually had years put on them going back to clear in four and five years uh I it's been sort of a pet peeve of mine that I just sort of have
102this notion that when Council makes a tough decision to spend money that things are going to get done and clearly they're not getting done and my question partly to you Miss Hamill and partly to whoever else may know something about this is as we look at the $19 million worth of of school related expenditure is on this list which includes HVAC replacement it includes just says CCS priority improvements that's $5 million reconfiguration expenses CHS roof replacement uh Clark windows and the lump sum to schools I'm I'm just wondering I mean if this money has actually been spent then I don't have any issue with the school people if it has if it has been spent and we just haven't gotten around to the issuing the bonds that's a it's really not really a budget consideration
103it's a an operational how do we accomplish it consideration but my understanding has been that at least some of the items on this $76 million List have have not been spent that is correct has any of the school $19 million not been spent maybe except for the ones in the in the year right we're in right now we we can go back and get get you that list for example the Clark windows are almost done but we haven't sold the bonds on that one CHS roof is uh a large one that we've not sold all the bonds for yet because again we are selling we sell bonds once a year um and we're trying to make sure by the time we sell the bonds that we will be spending them within the IRS tax exception
104is it just take CHS uh roof replacement is that underway is that planned for a period of time so that's a it's a phased project so they can only do so much with some of those projects you know during summertime or when students aren't in the building so that one has been on there a long time um and and Mr Goddard I'm sure can share some of that with you done so Mr Goddard had a a meeting couple weeks ago I was not able to attend but I'm on that committee make sure you get that PowerPoint if you've not gotten it Yeahs so that that may be on me um could you please Mr Gard resend that um maybe send it to Sam and then Sam if you could get it the rest of council
105but it it does a really good job explaining um his portfolio of the work that he has going on and sort of how he's managing it um my guess is that there's not like a lot of slippage in terms of what's been committed and the work that's being done and if there is it's probably because of things that are you know outside of people's control to some degree folks on Council of he expressed this concern before that we don't get a very good there's not a very good information flow to us about how projects that we have approved are moving forward or if they're moving forward in some cases and that's something that I've been hoping for four and a half years now to that something would change on Miss uh councelor snook to to
106your point I mean I appreciate you asking that question and just from a school's perspective and I don't feel like you're you're questioning this at all I think everything that is on that list needs to be done um there's definitely and and has been on that list for a long time and I know that some of it you know is is timing some of it you know is is Manpower um from what I've heard so I mean please don't think that we are bringing forward um projects to that list without some serious thought I mean you I know you've been in the school buildings and and I know that you're familiar with Green Brier bathrooms and and things that haven't even made the list you know so there is a long list and and we
107have have actually and I know that U Miss pal and Dr Gurley are probably meeting with with um counterparts because we have had a recent safety audit of of the entire School Division and there's a long punch list on that that I'm sure will be shared and discussed um at some length as far as what needs to be done to just get our schools um just basic safety up to par so I appreciate again you asking you know where we are with those funds but everything everything and more well I needs to be on that list years ago there uh one of the reasons we had why there were things on this list that hadn't been done were that we were hoping we we didn't want to invest more money at Buford because we thought
108we were about to embark on this major renovation project which clearly in the long run made good sense I mean there was an explanation for why something had been on that list for five years uh and I don't know my purpose in asking the question was that I I simply when when we've got a list of probably 30 or 40 Projects Citywide not all school stuff ranging $76 million uh and we just as a matter of how we oversee our government that's a question we ought to be asking every year if not more frequently than that why are these funds previously allocated by Council not yet spent uh and i' I've always said Council has sort of a fire and forget mentality we make the decision we're going to approve this expenditure and then we
109don't see it again we don't know what happens we don't know whether things are happening that are supposed to be happening that was a purpose of my question anyway thank you councilor snook i' like to address that because I mean we conversation we had last year was thinking about how we fund schools too we never got around to that between Council and Schoolboard and I would like to address we think about that more because we got frustrated with just all right we're going to cut the schools operationally you know a chunk of the additional sales or not excuse me real property tax increase right and that was a rule of thumb and we need to found out a new way to think about how to fund our schools and like a needs-based budget all right
110here's our needs-based budget right also right so regarding that CIP we had two meetings this year of the school CIP which is 100% increase off of one meeting which had been the previous my understanding like protol I think a quarterly meeting to to get you your point to be reviewing all this uh would be appropriate it would help kind of I think get more attention sorry I mean because we don't control that right from the Schoolboard side of things we're asking things to get done and at the mercy sorry of you all prioritizing Mr Sanders to get those things done right and or hire the project managers Etc to make sure that budget gets spent so and Project's executed so that one reason one way sorry not one reason one thing I can think of
111of how we can make sure and prioritize getting the things done would be a little bit more oversight by both of our our parties basically having a quar quarterly CIP meeting at least on that side of things because it's not us not spending the money regarding CIP thanks well let me just say to what school folks haven't heard me give the the sort of detail but every quarter we get a a fairly detailed report from the Rana water sub Authority and uh it has literally every Capital project that they have on their books for the next 40 years and it says where it is in the process and how much money is allocated and when do we expect it's going to get completed so every quarter counselors can get a report that says we know
112where the money we're giving you is being spent we know that you all are on the ball we can report to our our constituents what's happening uh my concern has been that we don't have that comparable information from the rest of the city government not just the schools but the rest of city government totally uh and I've been asking uh for a few years now that we get some quarterly report like that and it would have the kind of detail I would hope I mean it's not a lot of detail but at least it's some mention of what it is that uh would would enable me to I don't want to Triple the number of meetings everybody's got to go to but I'd just like to have more information flow yeah and I I do
113think you know there there is a standing meeting a standing committee that ju and I are on and you know if I've not shared that information on um more completely relative to the schools I apologize we can certainly get that information um Miss Torres is in those meetings I can't who else from your side of things yeah so yeah I I just want to be careful we're not mischaracterizing the status of the school uh CIP projects my um my own View and talking with Mr Godard and attending the meetings and looking at the slideshows and everything else that is a a tightly run uh portfolio that um things are going on the list and they're being executed we just you know funded a major uh project at Buford obviously um which needed to be done
114and there's a lot more things that need to be done but I I just want us to be careful with this narrative that seems to be emerging that we're not keeping up with a list of projects for schools if there's concerns that people have on the school board I would love to sit down with people we can sit down with Mr Godard Inu those concerns and I I would like to say um from this from the city side that um again as I started with that the city has been very responsive um particularly as we most recently upgraded the bathrooms those are CIP things there are some things that do push other things down um and that's when we do reach out to Sam and his team so yeah I don't want to mischaracterize that
115either that's my um last slide um key budget dates is the last slide um we have a we have another joint session with you all in um February and so we will um we will we still have a few more budget requests that we are working through about that we yes is that your number um if I had to live with that number today we would live with it but there there are a few I mean one thing we're going to have to do differently next school year is I mean it feels like we're going to be starting the year um with budget request because we're literally crafting this presentation up till yesterday morning because we're going through the budget request and so we tried to pull out some of the big ones so I
116know that there are people in the division that are watching that don't see something that they requested on the list and that doesn't mean it won't make it um but we did try to pull um some of the um heavier things out um but so um Brother Sam we will we will try to keep this number within this ballpark when we by the time we come back in in February February the 10th with all due respect and and appreciating your work I mean we this is the first kind of look we've had at these numbers as well so we we have a couple of meetings with Dr Gurley and his team yet um coming up um I if it's okay with you all I'd like to open us up for public comment at this point
117so we have I do have a couple of people on the list um here I believe in the rooms um we have Mr heartline if you would like to start and if you will just please state your name address and we have three minutes for public comment thank you good evening board members and City Council on can you hear me now it's not gonna okay that's fine good evening board members and City Council Members Derek Harline 1517 antoinet Avenue lifelong City resident um I want to address both groups tonight uh two weeks ago I addressed the board about the vehicle Fires at Jackson via on November 20 that happened on November 25th after that discussion I want to know that city council will support the schools to ensure safety on grounds the fire that destroyed
118for vehicles that morning was due to the buildup of leaves that have accumulated in Jackson via staff lot the city's plan to maintain School spaces needs to be better and done more regularly the city isn't picking up the leaves enough causing the buildup that also caused the staff member to fall leaving work this month the wind today brought down many more leaves and I watched them blow to the lot where the staff Parks each work day we deserve to be safe at work I fear that if the Le accumulation isn't removed over the two week winter break we risk another chance of a fire and possible more staff injuries along with the leaves the entire fence line growth that protrudes through the fence and into the parking lot poking into our vehicles needs to be
119cleared the overgrowth used to get cut back properly and hauled away but this has not been occurring and as a result bad things are happening it used to be a team of city workers who came and cleared the grass of leaves and trimmings and now one sole individual does all the mowing these cost-saving changes have led to the decline of our school's grounds and resulted in safety concerns I'm asking tonight that both parties can assure safety of Jackson VI staff and families by properly removing the brush and all Le along the fence line over this break once the city decided for Jacki to be a polling place I thought the upkeep of the property would be a bigger priority but sadly that is not the case I look forward to hearing and see changes before
120January 7th when school resumes I promise to update the board at the next meeting on January 9th and want to report good news please help make this a reality thank you thank you um next go ahead Miss gilin um my name is Shannon gilin um I am a teacher for the last 15 years in the city schools I'm a parent and I am the proud president of CA our Educators Union you heard a lot tonight about the needs of our students um all of we which I feel deeply on a daily basis 20% of my kindergarteners are English Learners several are homeless the needs are real but without quality Educators we can't meet those needs you know there's a national teacher shortage and last year CCS lost almost 70 Educators the union has been working
121since 21 to earn the right to bargain and we've spent the last four months in meetings with ccs to negotiate a strong contract that supports Educators and values our time you'll be hearing a lot of details about this soon the best thing that Council can do is to fully fund our contract so that we can keep our Educators without this contract album ra already pays better than the city and you will lose more teachers please value our Educators who are doing this work every day and do we have someone else in the room goe good evening school board and City Council Members my name is Celia Carr and I am here tonight representing both charlott United for public education and my organization not me I believe which is dedicated to anti-bullying efforts as we enter
122budgeting season we must remember that every line I'm so sorry I'm just my throat okay uh where was it okay so every line item in our budget reflects not just numbers but values our values as as a community and our commitment to our children Educators and each other over the past year organizations like charlott field United have worked to engage our community showing up at events knocking on doors and asking the people of Charlottesville what matters most to them and the community has spoken loud and clear the top three priorities were heard it was social emotional Wellness um school safety educator support and those are clearly what we all think about anyway so these priorities are not separate issues they are deeply interconnected a child's social emotional Wellness impacts their safety in schools just as
123the support we provide our Educators directly affects their ability to Foster that wellness and ensure a safe inclusive environment for all but we must also take a deeper look at the at the systems in place bullying doesn't create um excuse me and I can't see I don't have my glass where are we y'all bear with me Wellness impact social emotional Wellness impacts their safety in schools just as the support we provide our Educators I skipped over a lot I think um bullying doesn't just happen between students it's embedded and the structure that it continues to create inequalities and push people of of color especially into cycles of survival and we we all know that and I'm G to stop there but I know that this isn't uh this uh we need to look at it
124in all angles and I I do love the factor of all the numbers I do not come to most of these meetings but I will be because it is important for us Educators as well as people of um within the community to start coming in and listening to what's going on in these budgets because our our kids are affected by it and so are the community members thank you if there's anybody else I'm sorry who's having trouble with the mic anybody else who would like to offer public comment I don't know if we're showing anybody online okay if you we see Mr Brian Ray if you would like to make public comment just uh indicate so by the raised hand icon oh never mind thank you for being with us all right anybody else okay
125any any other comments from Council or questions for us I just wanted to return to the issue of projects for schools um I believe the media was held um on or near Friday November the 22nd most of the people here were copied on it so if you could just look in your email uh there's a really excellent PowerPoint that was put together um by Mr G laying out all the work they have going on as well as prioritization for the upcoming year so I think my suggestion would be if folks don't have a copy of that that they get one and if they got questions maybe that'd be something for like a a smaller group to work on since there does seem to be concern on the part of the school board that projects are
126being requested that aren't occurring uh November 22nd and then James just resent it Mr Mr Pinkston yeah I don't think that concern was from us I seemed like I heard that so no did I not hear that from you okay right okay we're appreciative of the list that's it my observation more recently is right Mr goddard's team has been increased he's been promoted and I'm very happy with and he's been man project managing Charlottesville Middle School it's on time on budget Etc he executed the the bathrooms and the high school all that's been really well so what I'm advocating for now these days is more budget to do more things so that his team can do more things and for our schools which is you know there's again as we've seen and I tried to
127you know show you a proxy of our energy uses just a proxy of kind of where our building's at certainly right and additional things we need done which you know I hope my ask is that you give appropriate more money for the list of projects we have and allow his team and give him maybe another project manager to execute on all those things so I think and my my observation now at the moment is yes you have a very good team in place that's executing maybe that wasn't the case 10 years ago uh and why there's a longer list of other things to get done but uh in general our facilities make up a very large percentage of your square footage for all the city facilities I just want to make sure we're getting the
128appropriate attention and resources invested in them uh again to make them reduce costs let us spend the more money on our a staff thanks any final comments from Schoolboard questions all right I want to thank everybody for your time um for the prep the questions we'll continue to have conversation um and then just quickly we do our next regular school board meeting is Thursday January 9th um and then we have a couple of budget work sessions scheduled um Thursday January 30th February 6th and then again as Dr Gurley said we'll be meeting um back with um counselors on Monday February 10th 2025 so uh if there's no further comments um we will adjourn the meeting so thank you very much everybody stay safe happy holidays