CorpusRecord 11651

December 7, 2024 Charlottesville City School Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Charlottesville City Schools
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Charlottesville city, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,711 words · about 66 min
Collected
2026-06-03

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001yes M chair Miss burs president miss Cooper here miss dly here Mr Mo Mr Meyer here and M Miss Tores yes thank for approval of [Music] we will U we're going to get started but our first item for discussion which is our elementary we Ved we do have Karen Jackson is online and she will be um she will drive our presentation and Ken is oh oh she is in our time you all right oh I am able to share my screen I was wondering if that was going to be the case or not let me this and we will get started oops all right can everyone hear me okay I can see if you just shake your head perfect okay well thanks for having me this morning um I'm excited to be here virtually to

002share some updates with you about what we've heard so far um about our options so the first thing I want to do is go over the process again a lot of the questions that we have received have been about the overall process and how things are going to kind of shake out so I just want to do a quick review of that and then we'll get into um some of the survey results and then some of our other frequently asked questions that I just want to cover this morning I um if the board members have questions as you're going through the presentation it's just those questions but we don't have to do all that okay yeah I don't mind if you uh if you interrupt me either get question no problem all right so for

003our process overview this is our overall um resoning process kind of layout um I do have a slide for each of these so I'm going to kind of Breeze past this guy all right so we started off the process with a plan for planning meeting um really this is was an organizational meeting to get us prepared for the process and kind of nail down the timeline and things like that we next took a deep dive into the current state of the schools so we reviewed various data sets related to this process um I do have slides specifically about this within the presentation for the um oopsies uh for the options so I'm not going to go through the background data sets if you're interested in kind of the data that we use to pull together

004to inform this process it is available on the project website for you I think I skipped a slide there my apologies this is I'm on a weird screen here okay so next met with the rezoning committee which is made up of school and Community stakeholders they're geographically diverse we have representatives from every school on our committee um and they assisted with the op creation as well as utilize those key considerations to guide that options creation the options the four option that that we have presented for feedback they are options that the committee uh created with my help um so we did we I did not make those in a silo we did have community members assisting with those options we then took those options back to the staff work group for rezoning and we decided

005which options would move forward um I believe we started out with seven or eight different options and we narrowed those down to just the four that you're seeing today as a part of our community feedback sessions we then took the options to the community um and this is kind of the step that we're currently in we are still collecting feedback to date we have received 439 surveys beyond that we've also received multiple emails from folks asking questions and providing feedback it um and we have we've also been meeting with folks and I do have a slide about all of our engagements later on so once we get the feedback from the community and everything is compiled into a report we'll then take that back to the resoning committee to make modifications um so the modifications

006that you're going to see are going to be based on both those key criteria for resoning as well as the um the community feedback that we receive um once we get the feedback compiled like I said earlier it will be available on the project website so that you can go in and see exactly what everybody said about each option um just so you know if we encourage people not to put any personal information within the survey but if if they do we do take that out ahead of any um public report a lot of times people will put um comments like my son Johnny who lives at 123 Main Street wants to stay at their current school or something like that and we just do don't like having um that identifying information public so anything

007that is redacted from that report is just that uh personal information that we don't want to get out there so once we meet with the resoning committee again and come up with recommendation we'll then have a public hearing that goes over the recommendation during the public hearing we're going to highlight every area of change and when it will be changing um and we're going to ask the community for an additional set of feedback about the recommendation from that um there will be opportunities to uh make public hearing comments both virtually and in person for that once we have done that public hearing we'll compile all the feedback that we received into a report give that to the board so that they can be informed in their decision um so that that is our last step

008of the process that implementation um will the school locator will be available for the next couple of years just because you are going to be implementing um the boundaries over the next couple of years um so that'll be available as as well as the project website that'll also be available for folks to review if next year they're like oh I I wonder why we made this decision that that project website will be available moving forward so moving on to our survey results this is the more exciting part of this presentation first up this slide just shows all four of our options um you can see they're they solve the problem differently they do have different varying levels of um like going along with those key considerations for rezoning we have had some really interesting um

009comments that we've seen of people comparing those key considerations for resoning to the options and if more of those want to come through like keep it up that that's really great information for us all right moving on to our preliminary survey results these are the survey results as of Monday of this week so December 2nd um we did have to submit the presentation ahead of time which is why everything was pulled on the second so there have been probably 20 more responses that come in since the second but this is based on what we had heard as of Monday so in looking at those who are responding we've received the most feedback from those who are affiliated with Burnley Moran Elementary School um not surprising that Locust Grove neighborhood is really where we're hearing the

010majority of our feedback and I I'll show you a map later of um where we have been hearing feedback from we're also getting feedback from the majority of our elementary school parents um if you look at the second the second table over here this we've received over 250 responses from parents or guardians of elementary students and then it kind of tapers off from there um not surprising we're we're adjusting the elementary levels so that's that's who I absolutely expected to hear the most from all right so this next slide just goes over what we have heard so far and kind of the results as of today so the chart on the left is showing the level of support that we have received from each option please please please keep in mind that when we are

011doing this work the comments are will be more highly considered when determining that recommendation than the overall level of support um you as the board are actually the only group that gets a vote in this whole process um the community this is the level of support is not a vote it's meant to gauge um it is meant to gauge the support but it is not everything so those comments are going to be the most important piece when determining that recommendation um also a lot of this level of support information is driven by who we have received the most information from or the most responses from um something else to note the survey will be open through the end of December so if you have not had a chance to respond please consider responding even if

012you're not impacted by this process um this is a community-driven process and we want to hear from the whole Community not just those who are impact Ed so just a summary of what we've heard from each option for option one there were there are some concerns about the number of students moving and the reduced walkability there concerns about specific neighborhoods moving um especially related to that walkability and proximity piece and there are concerns with the imbalanced diversity metrics among schools for option two we've heard that there is support for better balancing diversity among schools um there are concerns about specific neighborhoods moving again related to that walkability and proximity piece option three there is a lot of support for that walkability um there are concerns about the imbalanced diversity metrics and option three there's also

013a lot of support for fewer students being moved option four again just like with option three there's a lot of support for moving the fewest students um there is support for the walkability on option four and then again we're seeing a lot of concerns about the higher socio e omic and English as a second language rates at Summit elementary school so the map on the left and on the right is actually showing the same information um so on the left we have our density of where we have received responses from so far um like I mentioned before this area just north of 250 near Burnley Moran um it incompasses some of the Locust Grove neighborhood is where we have received the most responses from so far that being said I don't want that to wash

014out the other responses that we have that we've heard um if you look at the map on the right this is actually showing the locations of where we have received results so far and you can tell while this um well the neighborhood just north of Burnley Moran is like our highest density for responses we are receiving responses from um the rest of the division as well which is awesome news um there are some areas that are highly impacted in this that I was I was pretty concerned before pulling this data that we weren't going to hear information or we weren't going to hear feedback from but I think a lot of those engagements the additional engagements that the division has been doing with these communities has really helped to draw some of this feedback from

015these areas um so so far I'm I'm very pleased with where we have gotten the feedback from and how much feedback we've gotten I I really hope that we can we can get more by the end of the month but I'm I'm happy with the response rate and where we're getting the feedback from as of today so along with the initial three um engagements that we had at Green Brier Jackson via and Summit the division has also been holding um Community specific engagements for a few different areas that again are impacted within this process um so the top area just shows the past engagements we had again those at those three Elementary schools they there was also an engagement on November 18th at Kindlewood um and another on December 3rd at the Carlson Avenue mobile

016home park looking forward we do have another one of these scheduled on December 11th at the mountain viw mobile home park um and December 12th at the greenstone community center um while these are meant to get feedback from these communities they're certainly open so if anybody watching this wants to attend please feel free to um we're we're not going to turn anybody away especially if you have questions and feedback that you'd like to share with us um the map on the left here does show the locations of each of the engagements um that we've had so you can see the most highly impacted areas uh specifically Jackson vet and Sumit Elementary are receiving the most uh additional engagements just because again these are the areas that are kind of driving this process um these are

017the areas that are going to be tightest if we if we don't make any changes at all so I do want to just go through some of the questions we've been hearing because we've started hearing very similar questions and I just want to make I just want to clear some things up for folks um hopefully we have we have some people watching this meeting and they can their questions will be answered during this so the first question we have received or I would say the biggest question we've actually received has been about housing developments um so I just want to explain how we got our information and how we're kind of moving that forward W so we have worked with the Department of Neighborhood Services with the city of Charlottesville um CJ the pedmont housing

018Alliance and then p Ah whose uh name is escaping me um but we have worked with each of those entities to determine what developments are going to come online within the next probably 10 or so years um with that we do have very clear timelines especially from our affordable housing Partners um they were able to give us some pretty clear timelines which is great because those are the developments that are likely going to produce the most students for us um the cities information we don't have as clear of timelines on those but we should be able to get some of get some of them figured out within the near future um the student output that you're seeing with all within all of our options are we're calculated using the student yields below um so in

019this chart here you can see this is the number of students div div by number of housing units these are the ratios that we applied to each of the developments um to determine the number of students that we can expect from each one um these yields were developed by Wen Cooper last year so they they should be pretty current um typically when we look at student yields they they really don't fluctuate that much from year to year um over like a 10e span they can but year after year we don't usually see in many divisions much change at all um we also applied weights to some of the developments that were not likely to come to fruition according to the city um there have been some developments that have been on the docket for 10

020plus years that have not developed yet um so these are the these are the developments that the city flagged for us and said no this is not likely to happen anytime soon if at all um if something was weighted like 25% so it's 25% likely to come to fruition we applied 25% to the number of units moving forward and that's kind of how we how we calculated those plus development utilization column we used that the development information um so for example if we have a 100 single family units a 100 single family unit development outside of the University Zone um we can apply 0 22 a022 yield of that we're assuming that that development is going to yield 22k through 12 students or about probably 10 or so Elementary students something I really need to

021note because there's been a lot of confusion about this the diversity values for each option are not forecasted um if we were to start forecasting the diversity metrics for each option they would it would turn into an extrapolation of an extrapolation um which is not something that we really ever do um it turns into a big assumption and it's not likely to come true so the diversity values for all of the options are based on current data but they've been updated to reflect each of the boundaries for each option so if an area moves the students are counted within the new boundary but they are not forecasted to for the next five years um my apologies something else I want to note about this is we are updating this Housing Development information as new information

022comes in um for example we had a new development come in I think last weekend um it was over Thanksgiving and so that has been added um unfortunately that's hitting that's also hitting the summit area that new one so it's just another just adding on to Summit who already is going to receive the most uh students from developments but we are adding on to this as new information comes in um we want to use the best information that we have available for this process we have a question about which um the new development will you say that again I had I didn't hear the tail end of it we have a question related to was the new um development that you added to the list I don't know the name of it um if you

023go on the project website though it's number 58 on our um on our list it's I can show you where it is I wonder if I can zoom into this yeah so it's right down here near um my gosh what highway is this 64 it's number 58 right here and I believe it's 260 Apartments um market rate Apartments but the more information whoopsies more information on that can be found on the project website if you go to the resources section there's just a document that is dedicated to housing developments and you can find it in there so oh go ahead the new so the next biggest question that we have been getting is about phasing um and phasing kind of has two different buckets we have phasing by geography and phasing by cohorts um phasing

024by cohorts is the more typical phasing approach or exemption approach that we that we use in any resoning process this allows entire like an entire C- or grade level to remain at their given school so this would be something like saying okay all current fourth grade students remain at their at their um Elementary School for their last year of elementary school to avoid that additional transition we also have phasing by geography and this is this involves moving targeted Geographic areas over time um and we would do this to avoid under or overutilization of schools as developments come online um we know that the developments aren't going to come online all at once which which is actually a really great thing for us um one of the reasons that we were doing this process this year

025is because we thought one of those developments that's going to hit Jackson viia is was going to come on next summer so we needed to make changes because of the development the change in development timeline we now have we now have an additional year to implement boundaries which which is awesome and we also know that developments while we do have timelines for them today things happen and we may not be able to follow the exact timeline um so the phasing phasing in especially with geography will likely last anywhere from 4 to eight years um and with that it would be based on when these developments are supposed to be online um and not just completed construction we're talking about developments being occupied as well um so any student that would be required to change schools

026would only be moved once so let's say your neighborhood gets moved I don't know from like Summit to Burnley Moran okay you are locked in once you once you move once you will not move again as any part of this process um that's not to say in the future when another process happens you would certainly not be locked in but as a part of this process and this phasing you would be locked in as soon as you move so anybody any student would only be expected to move once if they're being moved at all um like I said any phasing plan would likely last anywhere from four to eight years this does that 4 to8 years timeline does not include those fifth the or not fifth graders but the cohort phasing that is just based

027on geography um along with this uh the options presented are showing end stage so we've gotten a lot of confusion about how the options really work what we're showing you right now is end state so where we want to be maybe like five years down the road once all of the phasing has been completed um once we get once we land on a recommendation it will be much much more efficient to figure out which areas need to move and when but until we can get to that point it's really difficult um it's really difficult to have a phasing plan for every single boundary option that we create um something else to know is that families that choose to participate in phasing would likely need to provide their own transportation to and from school each day

028uh that is very standard um many many school districts and school divisions across the country are dealing with uh Transportation issues right now bus drivers they don't grow on trees it's everyone is having trouble finding drivers right now um and so we need to be sensitive to that and understand that if you're going to choose to to participate in any sort of phasing you will more than likely need to transport your child to and from school every day um and some families will choose to do that and others others may not and that's okay um something else I do want to talk about with phasing is that underutilization piece so if we were to make all of these changes today um let's say we take one of the options and we make we just rip

029the Band-Aid everything for next school year 26 27 everything happens because a lot of the developments will not be completed especially in Summit Elementary we really want to avoid having Summit sit at like 50% utilized until some of those developments come online which is which is another good reason to do the facing by geography that way when we move students when they need to be moved we're not moving them ahead of time just just to get them out of the building um we're hoping that this is going to be a much more accommodating approach for families as well um not by not moving everybody all at once we may be able to move fewer students as as a result of this and that is all I have are there any other questions I know we

030went through kind of a lot make a comment this is something Karen and I talked about this week about I wanted to confirm with her what the way would actually work just from a nuts and bolts perspective and I I believe it would be it would take on something like this and Karen validated that this was the way it would work around December of every year you know we are since about a year ago I've been having quarterly meetings with edmont and CR and IND um NDS I actually have a monthly meeting with them now but in December we would just have a concerted point where it's like where are we with these developments what what's coming online this coming summer and during the next school year so about nine months out getting very concrete

031about what's coming online for occupancy of these developments that we're tracking and then we would knowing that in December then in like January we would be having conversations with the board okay this next step of this phasing plan based on what we know nine months out this is where we are with the next moves if you will with the with the bound the next wave of boundary change implementations and so then the board would see that in January take action in February and then everybody knows the community knows this in vision of where we're going but to tackle this issue of trying to sync up with the actual developments and not moving kids too soon we need to do that reality check because we've already seen what we thought what we originally been given as

032impacts from South First Street on Jackson Baya that would be hitting next year you know as you get closer we'll know it's actually not going to be till the following summer so it won't impact until the next year right and that's what bought us some time more time in this process so um does that make sense to everyone about how this kind of drum beat will work every year of knowing what's really coming online nine months out and then saying okay we're ready to implement this next phase sorry I think it does I think to Mr Meers yesterday Thursday um about having someone on the planning commiss that is a member of the school board that is part of these overall approv to fully understand the implications to the school system um versus the catchup

033that we proactive information is always helpful so this pal and car so to be clear sounds like the suggestion is we use a geography Focus phasing approach where we would [Music] know where eventually the lines are going to be drawn more or less families could understand that but that we would not be like again on day one making all that but again basing it based on when we expect these housing developments to come online and US easing our way into it families want to know exactly like all right eventually my my two or three-year-old or fouryear old might be at this school or might start at this school but you know you could decide to do that or not or you can decide to start your your kid in the school where eventually it would

034be based also and that that's where you migrate from that geography part of phasing into the cohort decision making about what type of practices we would allow for people to apply and then they're providing their self select earlier you can but you have to you have to get your child there things like that Ken do you want to add because this is the part where my brain has been for a bit trying to figure out how this is going to actually look operationally in our work in our continuing work with the board um we will continue working with walart for annual enrollment projections moving forward because of the uniqueness of our situation and with these boundaries the linear regression modeling we've been doing based on static boundaries and somewhat no big changes in the housing

035development in the city up to this point those linear regression models are not going to work particularly for planning Elementary Staffing and so forth so we're because of the geolocation tools and so forth that wpart brings they will be assist they're assisting us with um they'll be assisting us with um enrollment projections until things are more stable um because of the geolocation piece that they canect um Karen is there anything else you want to add on to that conversation we had this past week yeah I mean I I think that's really good to knowe like we're we'll be around don't worry we're we're still gonna track this for you we it is not our practice to abandon you once we give you a plan um we'll certainly make sure that everything gets implemented properly um

036you do bring up an interesting point with the uh early start conversation so and I think that's that's important because we've heard that feedback from others um there are some future CCS families that we've heard from that have said well if my child is going to be expected to move during their career can I just start them at the next school and I I think that's absolutely wonderful feedback um so with that cohort phasing we're also considering early start as well along with allowing people to stay instead um and I just I just want to clarify we are planning to come to you within the next couple months with a recommendation that does have a road map for when each area will move this will be more of making adjustments based on those timelines so

037we're going to use the information like the best information we have today to inform when areas are going to move but every December we're going to go back to the drawing board and say okay does it still make sense for this area to move this year and if it doesn't great we can we can let them be for another year if it does okay then they already expected to move um I I do not foresee well typically developments don't go faster than they're expecting them to uh they either go on time or late so I don't think we're ever going to run into a situation where something takes off faster than we thought it was going to and we need to move students before that timeline it'll be more like this area will move in

0382627 uh or 27 28 one of those situations um but we will be coming to you with that road map moving forward we will know should everything go exactly as we're planning we'll know what's going to move every single year we just want to make sure that we're adjusting annually just in case piece that's important to me as we're getting this recommendation is paying attention to our fifth graders or the future fifth graders just we a unique position where we're tackling rezoning at the same time we're doing the re configuration um and so just like I'm not going to be supportive of a plan that has our fifth graders move three times correct when the goal is to have a stationing if we need I need a phasing that allows fif graders to stay or

039have the option of staying um in that phased approach and I imagine there's a sibling phasing conversation that but I appreciate that we can't get to phasing until we get to a recommendation yeah and we'll be running all those scenarios for you like I I know who are I I have everybody's address so I know who where the siblings exist um and I'll be able to model that typically what we find in any sort of phasing plan is allowing one one grade to say stay is not going to make or break anything um it has very little impact and quite honestly we don't see as many families taking advantage of it that say they're going to take advantage of or want to take advantage of it um so it it usually it's usually just fine

040um even siblings it's usually it's usually okay to do that once we start looking at like fourth and fifth is is sometimes when we have issues but we'll be able to model all of that with our recommendation um and be able to tell okay what is our utilization at each school and if it's it's going to break one of the buildings like if we're going to be over utilized at a building because of phasing that's that's not where we want to be but if it's if we're gonna be able to accommodate the students great but we we love that oh just you know the addresses of siblings who are enrolled in our schools now don't necessarily know younger non school age students but I guess be such a small number we be able to chair

041point do you want us ask any questions now and or provide our observations and then have public comment or clarifying questions Comal I have some questions going back to the uh the options again and just looking at the some of the statistics associated with some of the options and if I understand correctly these are a current set of options but they might also evolve and modify it's not like we can only get three or four or two you know but it could Shi around based on feedb right yeah so typically what comes out of this a process like this is a combination of options we'll try to take the best pieces of all of the options um especially the pieces that the community really likes and mend those together into a final recommendation um what

042we're hoping to do is take all that feedback and make sure we can incorporate as much of it as possible as long as it doesn't go against the um the key considerations for resoning and come to you with a recommendation that's it'll probably be pieces parts and pieces of options put together did that answer your question yeah so great looking at options three and four for example seem to be the most popular based on the survey the low SC kind percentages though bring us to summon having 80% of their students in option three and or 78% of their students four out of five basically students being at Summit correct yes and keep in mind those are current numbers um a lot of the a lot of what we have had questions about is is are

043those are those assuming that those affordable housing units are completed and in there no so those numbers may be low but given all of the developments within Summit um the majority of the developments are not considered affordable so it could be it could be a wash with the diversity of metrics that that could be where we land it may not be more or less if that makes sense all right I'll just say that number is way too high for me at the moment okay and this is based on my my understanding that better academic results from a good mix of income levels of socieconomic diversity but I think that's the conversation that this board we need to have that because that is the point is between these options are you know moving more students or

044achieving better balance in our schools and I think like that is the conversation that we need to have I appreciate M Johnson how engaged you've been in this conversation since it directly impacts your school our school our students um but I think like we can't hide from this conversation because this is like this is the Crux of it I think we can alleviate a lot of the concerns and feedback that we've received through phasing like we can accommodate specific families concerns about their student moving or the younger sibling being able to continue through we need to be having this conversation I think at a much higher level about what we want our schools to look like and I think one thing that I would offer for the board as you they are hard conversations and

045and I'm glad that you point out that that number is high so and none of these models that we've been presented um so for example when we were at kendlewood and we had a conversation about what would it look like as they continue to SP expand what would it look like if that neighborhood was split between two schools um because what keeps the numbers high right now is that like you know it's um very dense High saturated and on one area one thing that's not on any of the maps right now is what's going to happen in tolon that's going to Triple in that's going to Triple in size is going from 60 to 180 so what's not considered models right now is that conversation we had that day what does it look like to

046um divide that Community half and I know that we heard that it was not well received however we do know that by doing that it does then reduce some of the um it does reduce that number of the number of high low SCS and summon and then it moves part of it to another school um and so I mean but people don't like that but but what I hear Miss Julie saying is that's the conversation that we have to have out loud um because they are areas where we can do that I mean we I mean it currently happens at know in the UMP areas where the community is divided and so maybe that's something that again we're considering here so while it may not be popular by the people in the community it's the

047decision that will have to take on their advisement because if not you're essentially leaving things the exact same now I think I doo just have been so impressed with your engagement presence through this process and I know your voice I to but a lot of different lost a lot of Sleepover know we love all all different ways you know definitely first and you know knowing that has beened good condition um we are 78 currently um and we you know Gap rots that we are in our stff works very hard not only but they to person sometimes you have to get to that layer get the there are things that students come to school with and and you know a lot and those are hard the academics and sometimes it's like a repeating cycle I hear

048the teachers that have been there for 30 plus years and they have taught the or the grandparents of a lot of these students and it seems like the same cycle outside of the school is continuing to happen in the community and so there are things that these families need that the school can't provide we can do definitely everything in our our um for students and pents but there are things out society that we just can't with and sometimes it's like a battle you know as an educator to see this I've worked in different schools I worked in Greener I came to city school here years ago I'm started at Green I worked at Johnson you know and so I've seen the diversity I've seen what who's who's in this school who works with the students

049and I can say that you know people love our kids we love our kids but what I'm saying if we stay this way and we don't make these changes I want best for these children if that means we have to SP Community we're going to have to do that I want to balance ofs I know each school has resources except some it does have one extra MTH specialist this year but we have the resources at every school we have Rich have a lot of resources so if we can dispers our students to this bu like at our school even right now and just looking at option three and four protection if that that happen it's just going to get far I feel like my sta may not say um we had ey turnover last year

050for different reasons there are some people have to go but I people talk and you know people don't want to know that we are accredited with conditions you know we he the they're the only school I that L that upsets me a lot I know work that goes into making sure students what they need and what it takes to do that when you're at the you know and so I want if we Happ to do that as much as I don't want to any uh we have to do that so that it is baled um I know there are some people who don't come to certain school because they don't want to have to work with or do that extra work to get these children from where they are to where they need to be

051and every child that come from is not a struggling student so want to put that out there these families love their children and parents do what they feel is right so that means coming to the school and buing at me or calling me about different things then that's what they do because that's the way they show they love their and so somebody you know it's one of our conversations it's not going to be happy with whatever this decision but I think the balance of the SCS is going to be helpful um so that because the resources are around the city let's use all those resources um but putting more pressure on IND that are already there pressure on admin to support teachers and build around there lot a lot that has happen um I've heard

052things about the school when it was part when I was teaching at a another school and a lot of those myths and things are not true and so people hear Sumit and I know some people will opt into say um three and four because they don't want the kids in certain spaces I'm just going to keep them real that's one thing about what I feel is the truth and then some parents inw say they don't come out to advertised and I put it in parents s we put stickers on the kids to go home and you get a handful of people that come out because they feel people they they think the decision has already been made they're going to do what they want to do they don't care what we think and so that

053comes again from things of society that are brought into this and so I don't know how to change people's perspective that yes what you say does matter we know you love your kids and in order for your voice to heard have the table and so when we went to um Carlton you know there were more people but that should have been a bigger turnout and so that saddens me because people have expen noes because of what has happened in the past over Years also has a history many of you know it um but in order to change that people have to come and I don't know how to get that through the parents even getting parents to come to uh events at school I feel like your child going be halfway across town you can't

054even get within a 75 mile radius even we sent a bus and you still don't come how are you going to go be part of that Community you know the parents are sending to spes and so all of these things play play a part and I'm feel you know as far as transition for the children you know the siblings the Generations Family I people in the community suit CLK chur they my grandma and so they Generations Family and so but change is hard and change happen and I want best in these resources for these children for our staff I want my staff to say it takes special people to work with different populations and children and all these children are not bad they are wonderful they are sweet they are smart they come to school

055happy they want to be at school they run into the building they want to be here they visit your teachers they see you on public they they they just they just love and you want was best for them so we spread we spread them out PR that will happen and the parents will you know come on more but to keep them all in one space and that's going to grow over time and we're already in a space where credit and working part just stay on top of things it doesn't look like it's going to helpful in well thank you the options that we've seen haven't explored a split it's all that actually came up from the community feedback yeah that's how we got to that as an idea because we are you know we are

056listening to people and so guess what is the stomach for that I think we hear the stomach for that for me there's yes all of those things I think as elected officials Educators we are Char with making and taking all of the feedback all of the and all of the data science don't geted in but they are of of the student body and I think our children [Music] and when they're struggling to have a coach to get to school and our team does a tremendous job of to get schol see each other after um and think about that how that um when is R when is um when B then start looking at ways that we sh those children to other areas and keeping what we have um in place for now um but like

057just kind of seeing what that look like in the future forward so that we're not up fam you know coming from um a low income Community I leaned a lot on folks in the community like I so I know how important um the community family structure is um and so sometimes when you do split communities like that a child is too child you lose that Community or support keeping those things I I would and Str I also like good elevating her but I would like to see other um principles from as well um hear what they have to because I think that's important right we make the decision but we're not so I would like to see what some of the impact um or you know concerns of like the um the teachers um or

058the principal's adment at the school um because I think their voices are the most important also we we do have someone with us that I wanted to um prompt to share some information we have Renee Deval with us she's the person that I've been talking to you about when I've talked about the change with the transportation coordinator coming on board and one of the one of the many benefits that she's brought to our school division are her experiences with re zoning specifically in alal county and so she has some comments that I think would be really helpful for you for you all to just hear how some of these um issues of divided neighborhoods and phasing and siblings have have been handled when when other divisions have called through the surve please share um I've

059been resoning Caro County for over 20 years every redistricting and they're all hard period um to the first point geographically it's smart to do this phasing I remember um biscuit run anybody remember that in the news 3,000 units that's all coming on board they did a county W District in they pulled the Band-Aid right off Walton Middle School has suffered ever since they do not have the students that they need and now his tret has gone too big with population to add them back into W so they have this year after year the school being underutilized okay as for um our students our Rising fifth grade because we were pre 8 through fifth um our fourth graders that were go into fifth rule of thumb was that they would stay with their siblings to finish

060out that year Transportation was not provided except for once when we um expanded Woodbrook Elementary our Urban ring are our most atrisk kids that's the dense of our population we have them all throughout the county that was a high dense population so the school board decided that at that point my time for that one year the fourth graders that wanted to stay in fifth grade because of being used to that school the parents were used to that school um we did provide transportation for um students Rising fifth graders and their siblings for one year okay because that school to that school the ones that were redistricted to Woodbrook um as for diversity our Urban ring was tough and we had to do that redistricting and we did have to break apart some neighborhoods we had

061to go into um Engle wood so if you look at Woodbrook I mean it kind of like snakes through everything because we want the diversity you need diversity if we didn't do that basically we would have made agna hert a completely white school because of the way agna hert was through our road and all that so doing that and all the schools have the resources it's like at the end of the day these kids will come back these neighbors will still babysit these kids you know the bus stops we tried to make them in the area so yeah you might have to bring Johnny out at 710 and Susie will go right behind at 7:20 you know but that Community stayed strong um so and we also have other communities that are split by buses

062you know it's not just you know schools but by buses um barck West we have two buses that roll through there and we would have to stagger up so even then the babysitters in there the masas of the neighborhood that took all the baby you know they would have to come out two times just for one school or just sit there and wait for the others but the neighbors still stay neighbors and the kids still have their babysitter and Renee talk a little bit more about the sibling people we talked about that earlier this week how exactly what the standard policy was for siblings and managing these transitions basically they they went that onee school um with the um Rising um fifth grader and then after that they'd go to their base school so was

063a one so for siblings to be clear it was a onee if you know the priority was to preserve the theing F grader that not splitting the parent right and not to split the parent right and so then but this just like you had say a first grader with a rising fifth grader the first grader would stay for second grade but then the family would understand that then for third that then the change would be happening and then that leads into a question of depending on what the board wants to do with out of Zone applications whether you want to the policy now is that it's only for child care reasons that we entertain um out of Zone applications and um you know expanding that could be Pandora's box or not um but those are

064other things to consider thank you Renee I'm glad you all finally got to meet her because I think I've talked about her for a while off an on board meeting this is y have any more questions about redistributed zoning things that I've been through because we we've been beaten up real good at County years it doesn't necessarily have to include more busing or we would't necessarily again if you face it sounds like strategically you don't need more busing and buses and bus drivers in a sense no um when we did redistricting farmal County basically if 100 students was going to go from Brownsville to Ros those buses would follow from the those neighborhoods um we didn't not have a large walking um that would impact the buses so that's something that we would have to

065consider but the areas that you're looking at you're not talking about a 100 kids per area so would it be possible with like the next iteration to see that what the bus drivers that's a that's a really good question and point I think we could do some of that with Rene's part of that um staff work group along with Dr Johnson myself Pat Pomo because of all the data in this process um Karen what they're asking is like when we as we move into this the final recommendation showing what the projected impact with Rene's involvement we can kind of project the additional need for buses SL drivers because to the extent we're reducing walkability there will be to bring you're looking at Citywide walkability so if you're if you're reducing walkability by 100 students Citywide

066that's that's going to it could blend out with existing buses right and it it might not cause such a hardship and plus not only that are we depending on which one you go Summit might become pure walkability so we gain a bus that's there's one bus now serving the outer areas of so yeah it all depends on how I mean we can look at the numbers and look where the numbers are higher than the other but but to answer the question with the with the recommendation absolutely and the answer may be there's no change but yeah good question yeah it may not be perfect but we can certainly estimate it yeah thank you I don't have questions think I'm just split of summit a little bit I think my initial was great we can put

067greenst back together and keep Summit you know I know that there were some concerns in terms of uh over population at with the new development as well um so I think that's just something consider so a couple of questions I actually have a question for the board just before this uh committee comes together again in mid January to consider all this feedback I I think it would be helpful for that committee to know does the board have the stomach to consider moving all of Kindlewood to Burnley Moran I think that's a question that's going to come up for that committee I mean that's option two right there's two options one and two yeah mes K all I think one is Johnson mayy and one is Jackson but comb yeah I believe you're right so that

068the respective communities together moves more students but if SC is our one moves it to Johnson two moves it to Jackson and keep in mind moving students is not one of the key considerations for resoning that is a lot of the feedback that we're getting but it's not that is not one of the considerations the main considerations a couple of questions that I had and I don't know if they're even would impact anything but just in looking at or reflecting back we just had a board meeting two days ago I don't know what day it is um but anticipating the increase in the students with special education needs and how that's going to play out at the kindergarten level and I I don't know if we have data that shows where those those students are

069to land or which schools they would would go to but just again May I'm looking too much into the weeds but just looking at programming differences too as far as will any of these changes affect I mean we have the teach program right at bur and is that correct so for leap um Jackson Jackson VI is currently housing the leak classrooms for the elementary level but that will like just as um I think as a former special education director and I think Rachel was say exact same thing she was just support follow the students so if there um so she was talking about um the students that are foure that are four year olds right now who will um who will go to kindergarten requiring special education services um if there are some like one

070toone services or if there's whatever those specially designed Services look like she's prepared for them um and right she's prepared for those services to follow the students um and we've had this and this conversation comes up a lot even during reconfiguration because even with projecting special education teacher support needs we're going to have to do that closer to uh when we reconfigure because right now um the special education numers up a little bit students are identified daily and students exit so right and I guess I was thinking um more about students who any that self-contained classrooms you know even the Walker program right so I don't know we have what grades at Walker as far as in that self it's middle middle school is with um The Walker students the the LEAP program for the

071middle years which would be Walker MB for is currently hous at Walker but when you think about leap those are almost like sort of treated like magnet programs where the students are are busted to where the program is that they need and in the and really where that comes into play and this so zoning is actually sort of irrelevant for leap it really is because those kids are going to get to where we're having that program that that addresses those needs and then but what is relevant about Le is um we checked in with Rachel rasnik and we are anticipating needing to add classrooms classrooms for leap and that is factored into the capacity that we allowed for at the schools because we believe we will have it at um and I'll because the folks

072are aware likely Green Brier and Jackson via so there there is an expansion for leap baked into this process but the actual zoning isn't relevant because they're going to be just like they're bus now from all over the city to Jackson Baya for the elementary level leak program that will continue but we did account for it in the capacity and so the Middle School go to the middle school no oh yeah yeah that space is a great space um that's that's been designed at at Beford it's really awesome so those students necessarily won't won't impact the rezoning elementary school the key around that level of need in those programs is having the space and and making sure that that carved out of the capacity when we assess like the capacity for Jackson via the capacity

073for gri because those are carved out just like an art room just like um your stem room you know we didn't count those as classroom regular classrooms and then the other question I had was outside so our out of District students so outside of our employees and and city employees that bring kids in are the numbers negligible as far as if we were to change the policy or take those numbers out of the schools would it impact enough to make a difference or not really number was small I mean most of most out District are employees children right and so that is when you consider especially at the elementary level it's mostly our employee children and we always still even with employees it's managed on a space availability basis once they're our student though we

074do treat them as our student as long as the student's in good standing under the policy and that's true for tuition paying forers as well but um we don't we certainly don't contemplate or anticipate allowing any increase for it I think it's a bigger discussion if there would be a change particularly with the employee piece because that's where most of the students are coming from it's that ability for staff to bring their kids with them into the city when they come to fill our venes so and I think if I remember correctly that happens mostly in the elementary and then and then do they go to their our staff students a lot of them track all the way through with this a lot of our staff students track all the way through so we didn't

075answer be's question um and I you know I would be interested if we can solicit feedback from the community about specifically we have to do something do you like do you want the whole Community move to Burnley Moran or would you prefer a split that's currently I mean the whole move is an option correct but it's option two but I we haven't they're also given the option to stay right in three and four and so I think something specifically soliciting feedback you know our priority is a balance of SCS we know that it's this specific Community what is the preference is that possible so you're um I think we've heard clearly from that Community they'd rather stay at Summit they'd rather not be split so I guess what you're questioning what you're saying is look

076at least half of you are probably going to go to Burnley Moran would you rather have all of you go to Burnley so that you can stay together okay I think that's possible is that question I think so right you're saying yeah giving that community that specific option he one way or the other someone's going to move either you move together or we switch you up right if we're prioritizing if that's what we yes and colle that's I mean I would get my my sense on this my perspective all this is again I want social economic diversity in our schools so I think that's going to ensure all of our kids get the best opportunity for educational achiev so to me something like number two that is modified whether it again is giving us that

077diversity not only on the fs but on ell and and using so something like that is what I would like to see and that's what I would be suggesting to the community to consider personal and that's the one where we've already heard Community feedback now I've seen Community feedback that again but skewed very towards from Burley Moran folks who I know organized around this and understand why then three and four is a preference but that does not get us you know again to the data of the diversity at least that I'm looking in our schools so I I would again my argument or at least my personal preference on this is something like number two I'm happy to give the Kindle folks like get them more feedback on whether they prefer to be split or

078uh move all the Burl Mar in and what does that look like I guess it's number two but um I think we should be sending a signal that we we want a diverse set of schools elementary schools I mean I'd love to see guess the map I mean split we can certainly explore that I I don't think I can create it right now it'll take some time for me to put together um but I I think it's it's worth exploring when we get to the next committee meeting I am planning to bring I'm going to go through all of the results and bring kind of those modifications to the committee that we can uh that we can make and have them go through that um so that that is going to be something that we're

079going to talk about probably at Great length is splitting versus not splitting especially with the Kindlewood community so this question just post it there my assumption is for trail laser the reason why we're not seeing a lot of change or these kids moving around for them is because there's not that much development up in the north and west side because of all the single family housing that exactly um the other thing with Trailblazer that I that I think is important is because that that boundary currently kind of like there's that Peninsula well there's kind of like two little peninsulas it's in the University Zone we know that those the developments pointed at the University will not yield nearly as many students as some of these other developments will um so it's they're not going to

080experience the same level of growth as the other ones you're exactly right I'll just say is when I'm going to be interacting in the public and when I I have been getting a lot of feedback from this but what I want to hear from the public is their priorities at these higher levels not how necessar impacts their P what is your priority for diversity e sped Etc personal request to to isue and we've kind of been echoing the same thing um at all the community meetings I told folks it is not helpful for me to get feedback that says don't move my kid um it it is feedback I totally understand I get it you don't want to move but that we can't do anything with that um if if you're G to take the

081survey awesome just be sure to in your in the comments to kind of to make your argument something else not just don't move my children or don't move my child um give me something that I can work with to make that accommodation because if if all I hear is don't move my kid over and over somebody has to move um that's just the unfortunate part about rezoning we're going to be over utilized if we don't make any changes at Summit so we I really want to hear comments probably more related to those key considerations to rezoning more so than don't move me don't move me don't move me so I think at this point we've got a couple of questions question that have come in online and we will open it up public comment for

082anybody here as well but I'm going to go ahead and read these um so the first one is can you speak to why Trailblazer has the smallest impact in number of students despite having a greater capacity than some schools more affected in no scenario does trail laser have more than 35 students affected I think we just address the next one is speaking as a BME parent we have not been given an option of absorbing students from Summit or any part of the city without moving students out of BME I believe BME is so far below capacity that it can just absorb all or part of Kindlewood without students out of is that I I think I my my supon is that that would leave Green Brier really below yes yes Green Brier is currently utilized

083at 51% so unless we're going to take an island from Summit and put it at Green Brier uh Burnley Moran or Trailblazer would be our really two main options to put more students into greed Brier and not leave them underutilized right I think you've said it in several of the meetings for whoever this parent is that's asking this question that I mean everybody kind of has to shift North North avability exactly how will survey feedback be analyzed what tools will be used to analyze written responses do you want me to answer that yes please okay okay I didn't know if we were like if we were responding or not um sure so once we get all the feedback and we've already started doing this on some of the feedback that we've gotten already um the

084first thing that we do is plot it on the map um so if you remember that slide I showed you with all the dots it was next to the density slide um we will be looking at that and looking at comments neighborhood by neighborhood um what we typically do is once we plot we'll kind of see who will will color the dots based on level of approval um and then kind of go from there we'll zoom into each area if an area really likes an option we'll figure out why if they really hate option we will figure out why um the question what tools will we use to analyze written responses um I I we'll be reading every single one of them and kind of summarizing them from there so I guess I guess my

085brain is the answer there I don't have a better response for that um but we will be using the data probably primarily geographically to inform the recommendation along with that we'll have we'll have the whole report on the project website once it's available for folks to also do their do a review if you're interested yeah the board as well like comments go into a vacum exactly all of the comments are published and the only thing that is um redacted is if it's got personal information or or cus wordss or C yeah if there's something especially nasty I might I might pull it out especially if it's like pointed at an individual um but other than that it'll be exactly what your community said um so another words the community will be able to assess that

086the comments were reflected fair in the in the work yep and they'll be organized by option too I don't know this is a question but I'll read it Su is walking distance from the community that's being considered for splitting talking it makes for a great sense of community in Belmont 6 Street Garrett not sure splitting is a good idea Burnley mirand is a great school but not walkable for any parts of Belmont at six 6 Street Garett area again Transportation good feedback and some of the families that we heard from when we visited Kindlewood did say if you provide a bus bus service for us we're fine they one of the things we were curious about is how many if any families would say they would prefer bus service um and with that you know

087that would be a reason they would want to perhaps go over to Burnley Moran but um we didn't get like any kind of overwhelming sense that um that the having bus service would be a a big plus for them but I think a lot of folks would view it as a as a plus in the context of other things that they would be from from not no longer being at their neighborhood school can we speak can someone speak speak about current walking I know some things are changing at Kindlewood in terms of walking bus or partnership with City promise kww they walk Miss Johnson staff walks with them um every day okay yeah there's no um partnership with City prom but I think to Miss Johnson to your point earlier um participation is generally whether

088you offer they come or they've done a better job attendance in I think one of the things that I'm considering and this might be too too long term but I definitely think it's be uh I know it's be an issue later on as we're looking at our schools aging and if we the community generally speaking for the last at least two decades or so have been very interested in keeping their neighborhood schools and then if we take this pocket and say you can be a neighborhood but then you're not going to your neighborhood school but what that what that looks like in the future and that that c is what I'm that's assuming we keep that school right we're g to open it up for for join us'll questions thanks I just your name yeah

089hi everybody um my name is Beth Schuler um I am my address I'm at 2406 Jefferson Park Avenue um in Bry Springs so I am a parent of a current kindergartner at Johnson Elementary um and so I you know come to this with a lot of humility in part because I'm kind of new to the school system but invested great um and I also um you know professionally I'm a researcher and I study K12 education policy so I'm kind of coming at at this with with that background as well thank you for your email yeah so thank you guys for um you know I've had a really a lot of thoughtful engagement with folks um that way and just really appreciate um your time and just the thought you're putting into this I appreciate Karen's

090time she's been really resp responsive and quick you know with with requests and that kind of thing um so you know and and so I think a lot of what I'll say is like consistent with a lot of the thinking I think is already occurring um so apologies for you know but just to re you know kind of reiterate and and lend support to your thinking um you know as a researcher I think I think about I come at these issues from um the perspective of trying to sort of maximize student learning student academic achievement in learning and Equity of student outcomes and student learning outcomes um and so you know I think um from that perspective to me the the idea of uh you know balancing uh demographics across schools um would be beneficial

091from from that perspective of kind of maximizing um student learning I think that concentrating you know the research is pretty clear that concentrating disadvantage at any one given school you know just creates a lot of challenges for you know as as has already been explained right um for uh for schools in serving students now I'm less aware of the sort of nitty-gritty of the issues of sort of splitting communities and and um you know I think all that should be weighed against kind of student learning but but I think student learning should be one of the criteria that we're thinking about when making these decisions right um so and then I think you know one of the challenges that you know you've already sort of put the I think nail on the head right is

092that there's the the plans that would do the most for balance right are also the plans that um you know without a sort of phased in approach would uh you know require the most kind of forced involuntary transfers across school and so I'm really glad to hear you all thinking about um options for for phasing in um because I think you know it's not just um you know I think a lot of the that conversation has been around sort of the inconvenience for families and parents but uh I think it's not just an inconvenience right it is a matter of of student learning because those forced transfers create real disruptions um and I think there's not like a perfect research literature that speaks to this but we have work on you know movements across schools

093grade configurations school closures and and reconfigurations um and also some from sort of historical uh integration plans um that sort of is at least suggested none of it's perfect to our situation but I think it's suggestive that you know forced movement is is disruptive right um and we've had a lot of disruption in recent years with Co and all that so um you know uh so I think that should be something that's kind of weighed here um and so you know I think one way to sort of overcome this tension of like you know between balancing and and minimizing forced uh movement would be some sort of phased in approach and it sounds like you guys are giving a lot of thought to how to do that um most uh effectively to kind of minimize

094those um those transfers and I just I think that uh you know my my suspicion is that a lot of the public resistance to the the the approaches that would increase balance um are coming from a place of you know that because people are not they're assuming there's no phasing so I think um guess that's our timer sounds I'm sorry I just so anyway I just think that the public feedback today May sort of understate the support for balancing because folks have been giving it under the assumption that you know it would require all this movement um and so I think if if people actually were here this morning and could hear that there you know there is a lot of consideration of how to do this kind of thoughtfully and in a um you

095know in an order of operations that would sort of minimize um disruption that there there would be potentially more support from that from the communities that are you know making the most noise um and that kind of thing so anyway I'm just grateful to be here grateful to you know I'm still learning more and updating my views on all of this um and I know there's a lot to way but and if there's ways that I can be helpful you know with the process please let I can pull the dock up and um for the purposes of this process I do want to mention that Dr Johnson and I um uh have an upcoming meeting to talk about Kindlewood because I know we're in the in our current conversations we're talking about SCS but we

096also have to keep in mind that there's a phase of this that we um don't quite understand because it's also going to be mied income so we're we we are some of the conversation is we're talking under the assumption that it's all going to be um lows but we um we have coming meeting just to get an idea of what the phasing of the different income models will look like so then that will also give us a better understanding of just you know what the implications are for our schools we can answer this one question really quickly does utilization look at utilization by grade level no because within us within our schools currently classrooms aren't hard and fast t to a particular grade it all depends on the cohorts as they move through so sometimes

097you'll have a small cohort and you'll have two or three classrooms for that grade level but then you'll have big cohorts go through which generally go around four classrooms for that cohort um our Norm is three classrooms per per grade level in any given school but it we have the ability and we have to uh fluctuate that year to year based on how the Cowart sizes changed so utilization is at the building level not the gr level and then the next comment is I'm still a little confused about the process moving forward after the recommendation and the public hearing is there any room for further modification and additional opportunity for feedback from the community and I'm going to say yes butre if I'm wrong you are exactly right um this is a very iterative process

098where we started off with a whole series of options we narrowed it down to four we'll then narrow that down to one recommendation with the committee when we bring that uh recommendation to the public hearing what we're looking for is the community to provide feedback and then the board will be able to say okay based on this feedback we got from the public hearing what happens if we move this piece or not don't move this piece what what does the utilization look like so most definitely there is still room for improvements beyond the recommendation being announced um we at that point we would just be relying on the board to provide those modifications um the committee after the second committee meeting we are we will be completed with the committee it's on the board at

099that point to tell us what modifications they'd like to see so process wise we would have one of our monthly meetings have public hearing at that monthly meeting January 22 22nd and then two weeks later we're going to basically V the action be two two weeks later the board would begin discussions okay and then the board can set the timeline for the voter and at any point in time if we feel like we need more time or we want more information I just would like to I just would like to make sure that everything you want us to consider um because I think what happens when we do do that respectfully I think what when we do do that is we give people a lot of heartburn so when we bring it to you I

100want to make sure that we're heading towards the the conclusion of this process so like everything you need like let's go ahead and give it to Karen let's give it to wer and let's consider it I think there are a lot of things that we've added to our list today that are all great things for consideration um make sure that we we've done all the public engagement and and as we told theity Community it is a very Co process we keep pushing it out I think once we hand it off to you all um you know it's almost like you know this is everything you've asked and you know we'll put it before you and you know then we can hopefully be like to first read of because if not people then lose they get

101they lose interest in our process and they expect that we've done the right thing so if we want to influence the recommendation that the committee brings to Us in January we need to say something right now or follow up with myself or Nicole Etc to you part of that commity and plus we will have the commun and plus we will have that community and the um the community for for the public hearing you can come and testify um of what you what you like and don't like I mean that's what it is is you can you can bring your like these are all the this is all the search I've done and I hate it I don't like it I love it but yes but we give it to you all I would just like

102for us to place in our process because we want to push it out so that will be the opportunity to show up in person or they can email statements ahead of time and all of that will be bo review correct they can record videos they can record a fun videos will be more highly considered I'm just kidding I'm totally kidding but I would love to see some so I mean really what's important for me is I want to see and I want to clearly understand all of the phases that might be proposed I want to to acknowledge at least verbally right now because I was at the meeting um you know that there there are concerns and there are groups you know of parents who feel like it's a done deal you know and um

103but also the fact that that specific neighborhood is going is potentially you know slated to go through a lot and a lot of change so I want to acknowledge those types of things and if that's going to be pH I mean that's that's what I need to understand a little bit better um for me personally I don't know this is a question for you all you know just if there are any financial implications or budgetary implications of doing this and I know the Staffing is up to you all and that you guys will take care of that but again me in my heart you know wanting to make sure that you're okay and your staff's okay and the staff at other schools are okay and um I don't know I know that's not part of

104your presentation probably Ken just speaking and that part that and we keep hearing that part and I'm glad M Johnson said that today the part about people feel like it's a done deal it's you know it's societal it's what has happened to marginalized people and I think that one thing that we can continue I've said this about every process that we had including on Thursday that I mean we continue to work transparently and I mean and that's how we gain people's trust and we've not done anything without engaging people and considering their voices and being very transparent about what we've done and this I think it is is an amazing process because we continue to Pivot based on what we hear from people we add based on what we hear from we take away based

105on what we hear from people um and so hopefully that's be gain their trust but they have said that in every community that has had something happen to them historically expect well I to your point I mean you said it historically Charlottesville has done to community where we're you know this is where we're at where we've landed right now and as far as development where where we can develop are in the communities where where history was was the hardest on on you know these parts of our city and so we I mean I we um you are committed to trying to my says do better you know and take care of each other and it's tough when you know there's no major development going on in in the green BS you know or other areas

106that that might spread affordability a so I just like I'm gonna we're going to get a a recommendation it's not going to be options coming to us in January right a recommendation with with fa with a recommended phasing so that just my other thing is we are going to get a phase plan a phasing plan also not with options but a phasing plan also that we can say this is exactly what we like or not I think it's just hard having options right and I don't want to have more options in the future I want to have a plan that we can react to to be very concrete the recommendation will includ I and I would just wonder I didn't they said this before but I would really like to see that phasing in a

107thought out way I think the geography and and mixing in the Cort kind of things make sense to me and the only reason that I brought up that mechanics part is because of like what Renee shared about the biscuit run right and that experience in the county I do think we want to have a fa we want to be clear about the endgame we want to be clear clear about the plan phasing but I think we also because construction is what it is and we just have to be mindful that we're going to need to double check our work every year and then be very transparent and we'll have at least around you know over six months nine months of where we're announcing anything we're seeing that's that's changed from what our plans are based

108on in this moment so I also heard some of your sessions Ken you know individual families ask about you know just very speciic specific requests you know like and you want to hear those specifics again not just the I don't want my student move but if there's a compelling reason I'm I mean I'm supportive of that and I'm going to trust that you all in the committee are going to look at that and allow those things to happen if it's appropriate for whatever that is well so if if a family were to I don't know I can't can't even remember some of the let's say we like we left one parcel out of a whole neighborhood out like we send them to Jackson via but the rest of the neighborhood to Johnson um that was

109kind of what I what I was hearing from some of those families like why did you include this part of the neighborhood it's because I didn't realize that was in the neighborhood so great let's let's make that move um I I heard a lot of like one-offs from families that in like we've got to have a single plan for people then to be able to provide that level of specific feedback not everyone will be rest assured you will stop hearing about it once the process is over I I know it's kind of tumultuous right now but you will people people will move on from this so it's probably hot and heavy right now but once once we get through this it'll things will calm down in terms of resoning and and Karen I more specifically

110than just people will move on you've reported that people are happy in a year or two people are happy and you know I think a lot of that is probably going to be credit to how great all of your schools are um people what I have noticed are people people are fiercely passionate about their schools it does not matter which school you are talking about people do not want to leave their school and like gosh what a it's like kind of a great problem to have people love their elementary schools and typically what I see is people fall in love with their new elementary school as well and they they're really embraced by that Community um some things that I that I know have worked well in other divisions are like open houses so maybe

111each school over the summer can have an open house for the students that are or like an ice cream social or something that are moving to that school so that they can be welcomed by that community and the staff there um we've seen things like that work really well maybe field trips where you're taking all of the students who are going to be moving to one school and seeing what it looks like at the other school during the school day um so kind of those like welcoming events are really really have been positive for other divisions think back on that really quickly during the BBA conference I went to a session um with fburg they were presenting it's a little bit different conversation they were closing two elementary schools um it was actually the fil

112that actually really helped their Community by having those students and the teachers that were transferring from the clo from the schools that were closing so actually do a field trip during the day so they can see what that process looks like at school and how they were welcome that really help how far out um I think they did it March April or so so we're talking about towards the end of the school year but still enough time to have questions all us all right thank you I do want to say thank you for part of this

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.