001e okay perfect e good afternoon everybody today is Thursday December 5th and we are here at charlottesville's Schoolboard meeting in the media center so I want to welcome you all um if you will um please join me in a moment of silence thank you and if you'll stand and join us for the Pledge of Allegiance the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty justice for all thank you so much Madam clerk would you please call rooll yes Madam chair Miss Burns here miss Cooper miss dly here Mr Morris Mr Meyer here miss Richardson here and Miss Torres yes thank you and our student rent miss hak here thank you um I will now entertain a motion for approval of our proposed agenda please
002I move that we approve our proposed agenda second second by Mr Meyers thank you any questions or discussion all in favor please say yes yes yes any opposed all right thank you uh the next item on our agenda is 6.0 and this is um our first opportunity for comments from members of the community and 6.1 specifically is for any students who might be here and present who would like to come to the podium to make public comment all right and then we do have an opportunity like I said our first opportunity and we have another opportunity towards the end of the meeting for comments from members of the community so um we do have looks like I have three people who have pre-registered um so I'll call your your name please step up to the
003podium state your name your address you have three minutes for your comments um and first on my list is Mr heartline was Sor good evening school board members and superintendent Dr Gurley my name is Derek Harline 1517 antoinet Avenue lifetime City resident I'm here this evening to talk about safety and a need for change for the way things have been done in the past 10 days ago on the morning of November 25th a vehicle fire at Jackson VI destroyed one parents car and three employees vehicles on December 3rd the charville fire department determined in the report that the radiant heat from the exhaust system ignited the dry leaves starting the fire they responded that the amount of leaves in the staff parking lot was so abundant the drain wasn't able to be found uh causing
004gas and water to puddle up and give off hazardous fumes the cfd also reported that the uh that the leaves on the lot led to the spread of the fire enormous amounts of leaves at jacksonv isn't uncommon in my 2 first fall season work in the Jackson via as the leaves fall the winds blow the leaves along the fence line to collect the safety concern I have is those leaves in the parking lot do not get collected until winter break while the other leaves on the grounds get collected during the school day when staff are parked in their designated lot also the vegetation that caught fire was in large part because it didn't doesn't get cut back on the Jackson VI side of the fence I'm asking for a change where the parking parking lot
005leaves get picked up multiple times throughout the fall and the vegetation by the fence get cut at least once so if a fire were to occur again it would not spread so quickly this fall the leaves could have easily been picked on on October 14th November 4th November 27th and November 29th while the staff Lots were virtually empty only in the environmental Corporation hepo came on November 27th to pick up the gas soaked Leaf south of the fire the north side of the lot is still covered by leaves cfd issued a reminder to not park on leaves but if the majority of the staff parking spots are covered with leaves how are we to do this there are 80 staff members total at jacksonv currently with only 63 spots of those five or five to
006seven are always taken by the rental units across the street who use the lot as their personal overflow parking spaces even with the toe en Force sign if parked during school hours I'm asking for the board Dr Gurley and Miss Powell to help please see the facility's maintenance picks up the parking lot leaves multiple times each fall if the lot can be clear for snow surely it can be clear for leaves multiple times and done correctly so the leaves are not just blown against the fence with lots of leaves still being parked on currently in the staff lot please look into this as soon as possible also please have the city police department support the tow and enforced lot during the school day I want to leave you with a quote from Kyle Irwin he's
007the public safety inform information officer for the city of Charlesville he States the city and CCS remain committed to the safety and well-being of the community let's make this a reality for Jackson via by proactively changing the way leaf removal has been done in the past and keep this from ever happening again thank you thank you Mr heartline next on my list I have uh Mr David McCormick I believe good afternoon my name is David McCormack 950 Glenwood station Lane number 202 it's my pleasure to speak to you once again I hope you remember me from last time um as a reminder I am a product of the Charlottesville City School's fifth grade Orchestra program which I understand is on The Chopping Block today I am also a graduate of Charlottesville High School I'm a
008currently a professional violinist and the executive director of early music America I'm here to be a myth buster today I think there are three myths that you are operating under that I want to help bust myth number one is that offering fifth grade General music is equivalent to offering fifth grade band and Orchestra I've heard this said and I want to say just because you're spending the same amount of money doesn't mean that these things are equivalent so I want to ask you uh do you think that learning to dribble a basketball in gym class is the same thing as joining the JV or varsity basketball team not the same thing right we're talking about the same difference here so in Orchestra class you learn teamwork working towards a goal hard work Pride self-worth these
009are things that you're going to learn in much greater quantity in a group team setting like band or orchestra than you are in a general music class and I want to really emphasize from my own experience and I think this experience is really shared by a lot of folks the spark for music is lit in these teamwork environments for me it was not lit in fourth grade General music class I loved my fourth grade General music teacher but the spark was lit when I was in Orchestra class myth number two is that cutting fifth grade Bandon Orchestra isn't an equity issue I've heard that said and I'm really concerned about that I first want to just offer up some thoughts on this from my perspective running a national Arts organization I think that there's a
010perception of classical music of what it was a hundred years ago a thing for old dead white guys right um that has changed a lot in the last 20 years every Arts organization in the country is working for representation both on stage and in the audience and um that's no different here in the Charlottsville City Schools if you look at the numbers I've seen the numbers your band and Orchestra classes are very diverse right and um they're providing an opportunity for free or lowcost instruction that otherwise cost thousands of dollars just my mom okay violins cost a lot of money signing up for the Youth Orchestra costs a lot of money these are um things that are offered free and low cost for the fifth grade Bandon Orchestra program um and I also want to
011say that um you're at risk students they often come to school because of programs like Bandon Orchestra or art class or their um their sports teams and the the success that they have there the confidence they build in those environments bleed over into their academic work there's a lot of studies that show this myth number three is that this isn't logistically possible that's what I've heard from folks and it's just not true I was a fifth grade your time is up so please make this final Point 30 thank you or 20 seconds even um I was an itinerate fifth grade strings teacher in the prince Ram County schools for three years I went to four schools every day it was not that logistically difficult to figure out and you have current recently retired teachers who
012can help you figure out the logistics I'm willing to help free of charge if you'd like my assistance in figuring out how this works I realize that it's a challenge but I hope that you won't make your legacy that you found an easy way out but that you found a way that is really excellent and re recognizes the Excellence of this program thanks so much and next we have uh Harley Saxon hello people I no longer live in Charlottesville my address is 1102 West Grace Street Apartment 4 in Richmond um anyway my name is Harley Saxon I am a musician activist and music educator originally from here in Charlottesville although like I said I currently reside in Richmond and traveled specifically here today for this purpose it has come to my atttention that Charlottesville City
013Schools as an organization has been toying with the idea of cutting funding to the fifth grade level band and Orchestra programs as a Charlottesville City School's Orchestra Alum who initially joined in the fifth grade in 2009 and stayed enrolled in the orchestra until 2017 when I graduated I can say with a great deal of passion and a vivid not so distant memory of my entire time spent in the program do not cut the funding I was one of the many kids in my grade who were not only anticipating and looking forward to the novelty and excitement childhood Wonder of playing a stringed instrument as part of a credited class in school but I had already made up my mind years prior that I was specifically going to play the viola I still play the viola
014to this day among a plethora of other instruments and I love the viola and the experience that it brought me so much that I have an altto cleff tattoo on my left forearm joining the orchestra in the fifth grade under the direction of Dr paully cybert Who has since retired was so profound and impactful to the trajectory of my life that I felt it essential enough to commemorate not only with permanent ink but by swearing to myself that I would become not only a musician but a music instructor as well for very many children in my same age group who were born into more put together families with more put together lives perhaps they had already been introduced to formal music training I however had not aside from a month or two period of weekly
015guitar lessons that my maternal grandfather was able to spring for when I was six years old but through the Orchestra program in the fifth grade specifically I not only received that formal music training in a class environment I also was able to to participate in private tutoring with local music instructors through the boy Tinsley Foundation my family was poor we faced constant food in security evictions Family Partnership planning through Child Services eventual foster care placements we didn't have regular transportation we rode the city bus for a good majority of my childhood me my mom my dad my little sister and our various crises which being poor contributed to you must understand how groundbreaking and imperative an opportunity for Quality Early Childhood music education was for me through all the lack of security in my life
016I was gifted Something Beautiful to fight for to occupy my attention to challenge me to enhance the quality of my existence grant me a measurable Joy a deep understanding of what I wanted to do with my future life skills social skills amazing friends who I still share mutual love and support with to this very day but most importantly to make my days worthwhile and give me hope through my years spent as a student in the charville city schools Orchestra I was blessed with three amazing conductor directors Miss Thomas Mr Brew Baker and the AFF forementioned Dr cyber though all of us have since moved on these are people who made it possible for me to have access to playable instruments waving rental fees allowing summer use even hosting a separate summer Orchestra program for kids
017who were really committed in the school a auditoriums on their own time this was at Walker these people taught me valuable lessons that I still carry with me today and through my work as a music instructor performer and freelance Creator in the present day I've been awarded many opportunities that I never would have had otherwise Miss Saxon we need you to wrap up please wrapping up thank you hear me out with my high school rental Viola which was awarded to me as part of a scholarship that I was was nominated for by Mrs Thomas herself I have played countless shows from classical to Hip Hop to rock and metal I have recorded and tracked oneperson string ensembles for individual artists to producers to getting my own composed pieces approved and licensed for independent film scores
018I have written my own music and accomplished unfathomable levels of success both as part of a band and as a solo musician and most importantly I have guided influenced and hopefully blessed my students of over 2 years one of whom is almost 9 years old and is dead set on becoming a professional chist thank you thank you is there anyone else here in the auditorium before we look to online again state your name you got three minutes thank you you of the school board my name is Sydney rasmason 91% that is the percentage of students who qualify for reduced price or free lunch in San Antonio Texas in the David Douglas school system in Portland Oregon this percentage is 75 in Charlottesville this percentage is 74 you might be asking yourself why am I bringing
019up San Antonio and Portland in all of these schools band and Orchestra start in the fifth grade in the David Douglas School System diversity plays a major role the racial breakdown of the students is as follows 35% white 25% Hispanic 19% Asian and 12% black 26% of these are ESL students this diversity is almost perfectly represented in the music program what makes us even more shocking are the quotes from these students many of which describe these vastly diverse music groups as a family going further let's look at Los Angeles specifically let's look at the harmony project this project founded in 2001 in Hollywood California currently provides free music education to 4,13 students from lowincome families in the Los Angeles area 97% of seniors in this group got into colleges 79% of these were first generation
020college students according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics the national average of seniors admitted to colleges is 61.8% that's a big difference in David Douglas a similar situation regarding GPA occurred the average GPA of those not in the music program was around 2.82 for those in music this GPA average was much higher around 3.35 five a study done by the rotman research institute helps to shine a light on the reasons behind this phenomenon the study consisted of 32 eight-year-olds half of which were given free music education the other half art none of the students had had any previous experience and they were randomly assigned to these groups no of the student the music group showed vast increases in reading skills connecting written words to their spoken sound and listening abilities these children were better able
021to pick out nuances in speech a skill vital to understanding emotion these results appli to 90% of the students for comparison the typical study has a success rate of 60 to 70% there are too many benefits to list in just over 3 minutes however I have tried to list some of them to conclude this speech I ask you to remember that music is vital to our community's future don't take away the strong roots of our amazing unique strong music program thank you for your time thank you very much next hi thank you I didn't know if you would have time for me Sandra IET avales um good evening Dr Gurley members of the board thank you so much for having us here today um I wanted to address a few key issues um first I
022want to briefly touch on the rezoning process as many of you know this effort as a result of the school reconfiguration process sorry K I didn't realize I wasn't that close um as many of you know um there is a huge urge for City residents to fill out the feedback survey it's extremely important that parents and community members share what works best for their families and children we know that a lot of times District Lines don't always make sense in hearing from people directly affected by these decisions can help make this process uh Fair effective and efficient um now I want to focus on a significant concern um many people are here speaking about this today and this is the um fifth grade uh Orchestra being removed during the reconfiguration process um many families have
023started um to share how much they value the program and eliminating it would will would eliminate a lot of options for our students um we should aim to preserve as many opportunities as possible for our students especially in the Arts even if some view Orchestra as a predominantly white program we need to try to and avoid taking away programs that enrich students um and in their education um while working to expand and diversify these opportunities um this brings me to a larger point and uh this is that we are consistently hearing from parents in our communities particularly particularly black and brown parents that programs intended to serve bipo students often lack meaningful follow-through uh presentations about these programs are but without genuine effort to ensure that these are impactful and accessible they really fall short
024one issue directly tied to this is the uh persistent language barriers that prevent many parents from engaging fully with the school system um we cannot simply Express a desire for greater involvement from our marginalized parents uh we must actively create the spaces and remove the barriers that keep them from participating resources and information uh must be available in the languages that our families speak um the top three that we've been hearing right now is Spanish Zari and poshu um those are the the top three many families want to engage but feel left out or unwelcome because they lack access to the tools that they need in an Ideal World we would have more teachers that reflect the diversity of our students but we can start now by ensuring that books programs and classroom materials represent
025and affirm our students identities uh and then lastly I just want to thank the school board uh for your efforts this feedback is not a criticism of anybody's work um but it's just to amplify the voices of the community and continue to build a school system where all students and families feel included and valued thank you so much for your time and your commitment thank you anyone else here in the uh Media Center currently all right and if not uh Mr Kom or anybody signed up indicating that they would like to make comment now if so please raise your hand there or use the raise hand icon I do see one uh Mr Mrs Excuse Me Miss Karen Meers go ahead and you can start you unmute yourself you can hear me yes ma'am hi
026um I really think I can't speak any more eloquently than the students that um you've just heard but I would like to express my strong support for the music program uh as well um in fifth grade I think that uh everyone recognizes that Charlesville schools have something very unique and this would be um cutting off a very important um beginning part of this this wonderful program and I just want to express my support thank you thank you see we're checking to see if anybody else uh would like to make public comment now online and as a reminder we will have another opportunity towards the end of the meeting um for public comment so thank you everybody who took time out of your day and made the journey here um for your comment we appreciate that
027all right um again I do want to and I apologize that I didn't do this earlier but we do have a new student rep um joining us here with the board so we have Miss Ana hudok is that correct hudok thank you I'm sorry um anyway this we want to welcome you we're grateful that you're here appreciate you um being a representative of of the students here with Charlottesville City schools and at this point in our agenda this is a a designated time um if you have had an opportunity or have anything that you want to bring forward um to not only the board but in a public forum this is kind of a designated time for you to do so good evening thank you for this opportunity it is an honor and a privilege
028to represent chs's student body I would like to start by saying thank you for addressing the water filter issue that was pointed out at one of the first Schoolboard meetings this year students including myself appreciated this quick fix please continue to monitor the filters as students need to have the ability to fill water bottles and stay hydrated throughout the day today many peers have requested longer bkts for next year as the year progresses they still find the 45 minutes to not be ample time to visit teachers which occurs only once per week after the break students voiced their concerns about the parent collection of phones concerns such as parent certain parents working later than the phone pickup time which is 4:30 and some parents not having the accessibility to reach the school students fear that
029if their parent doesn't pick up their phone in time they may need it after school to navigate to an appointment or for safety reasons if there's an accident it's understood that this is to help prevent students from having their phones out in the first space but they feel this may be an unnecessary precaution a suggestion for you to consider may be a happy medium where students get their phone confiscated once and their parents are then notified and if the issue is to reoccur than parents are to be involved with phone pickup many students were also wondering if personal computers and airpods would be confiscated going forward like phones for upper classmen who drive and park in the student parking lot they request that we have csas um conduct traffic as they did earlier in the
030year the system of conducting traffic seems to work efficiently and allow students to feel more safe students feel the curriculum in n9th and 10th grade doesn't best accommodate all of the different levels of students that are placed in those classes those who feel underchallenged in freshman and sophomore English classes don't want to wait until an AP level to feel accurately challenged and feel the underclassman curriculum needs to address to suit all levels lastly students are very appreciative that there are two lunch periods this year instead of three thank you again for your time consideration and the opport to speak on behalf of my peers thank you we appreciate that yeah nice report [Music] um I would if if it's okay I I don't know so I'm hoping that some of those things you and your
031your peers are are reaching out to Dr Malone about and especially curriculum based and and we happen to be bringing the program of studies up tonight so that was timely and that you bring that but but I would hope that you're being directed or being able to meet with him anything else that anybody wants to say no all right thank you for that just just I mean because we we love to hear the responses but I want to make sure that that he's he's in touch with you and I know he's standing here looking at me right now yeah to hide um if I may some say something we do have like a lunch talk um where a few students get to meet and I unfortunately I got to miss one of them because I
032was sick um that happened last week but we do have that opportunity in emails so no and I think that's great feedback I mean especially if it's coming from students and I think that's exactly what we want to hear but that's exactly what what he needs to hear is he's working with his team and and looking at that um and then working with Dr OD and Dr Gurley as far as big picture things so thank you for that um also if I may I again I wanted to thank everybody who made public comment but I also wanted to just double check Dr Gurley is there somebody and and Miss avales I don't know if you have regular check-ins or if there was something specific that you could you know or please touch base with um
033Miss Chuck or somebody if you wanted to direct her about um groups of people that she felt might need a little extra touch so I'll let you think on that and then if you can follow absolutely I was going to um I had made a little note to um address that at the end but most certainly if there if there's um a group of students I mean a group of families or particular community that we're not reaching I know we've been sending some direct messages and um even when we did our community engagement on Tu on Tuesday night uh on Tuesday night we uh we also made sure for the families there that they're using the parents Square app app and that that's another good communication tool to get information in there um the language
034but most certainly if there's another group that we need to reach please let me know and we can do a I can do a followup with you yeah and we had an interpreter yeah sorry thank you yes ma'am no I think and that's again somebody from the community who might be getting feedback so we appreciate that you know and just making sure that you feel like you have a a direct line not just here at the at the board meetings but we do appreciate receiving that but I think at this point hopefully you've got you know a a good connection um with Dr Gurley and his staff and and being able to feed that type of um those concerns to us so that we can make sure they're addressed so thank you I see you
035you can you can see me up here there okay all right just want to make sure you heard thank you all right um next we have uh or hopefully I can get um a motion for adoption of the consent agenda please I move that we adopt the consent agenda second great thank you any questions concerns discussion all in favor please say yes yes yes yes any opposition say no all right thank you so much um our our next item is an action item um and Dr Gurley is gonna step up and introduce this please good evening members of the board um on last month we brought before you information as it relates to the salary action for school board members um at that time we did update the presentation which was done for you all
036at the Schoolboard work session with the um with the line item um that was requested and tonight you all will need to take action um I guess before we before I turn it back over to you all I didn't know if there were any other questions that we could clarify um I could clarify for you all on behalf of the finance team so just for my memory um when we were at the work session and we asked for those updated numbers um which are what we're looking at right now was that equivalent to can we pull up that slot uh can we pull up the SL was it a 75 or 80% um go down right right go back up um oh no I'm sorry you're right keep going down it's this slide right here
037thank you yep so the increase to um the increase to the budget would be [Music] $28,750 per all the way up to the increase of 100% so I know you all um I think that's discussion you all can have so um yeah let's go ahead and get a motion in a second and then we can open it up for discussion I guess I'll move to uh increase the school board members salaries from to $88,500 and the chair to $110,000 Second all right so let's let's offer up the opportunity for any discussion or comments at this point M Richardson um I just want to clarify that this will not be in effect until 2026 correct correct I believe the code yes since this is an election year would go into effect as of January 2026 correct
038just wanted to clarify that yeah thank you miss dly any comments Mr Myers Mr Morris um as I've stated before board members I'll just say philosophically I'm against uh public officials giving themselves raises um I do firmly believe that this should be a ballot measure for the public to decide um and that is not just the school board I understand that we are working in the code of Virginia um and that's the way that it's written right now but I do think that's is something that should be changed uh therefore I will be V voting no today thank you um and as I've said to you personally privately I appreciate that and I respect that um perspective and I I do um respect and and appreciate the comments and the discussion that we had at
039our work session um with the understanding and and realization for me personally I will just speak to just the value of the time that we do as as board members put into this and the value of my time and um had never really looked at it that way so um just wanted to acknowledge again and thank uh other board members for their discussion and their input around this I personally um am supportive of of an increase I'm I'm not really comfortable with the 89% um and and felt more comfortable with I think a previous where is that slide Miss doctor sorry probably more aligned to the the 50% increase or something like that but I I don't know at this point that I'll I'll make a friendly amendment to it but I just wanted to
040publicly state that so if there's no further discussion we have a motion and a second um all in favor and again the motion is to increase board members to the 89% which which is recommended here which was written up all in favor please say yes yes yes yes any oppose please say no no so it passes thank you all right and I'll just Cent you're sitting down so the next action item um is our school calendars with Dr OD good evening Madam chair members of the board and Dr Gurley I I come to you this evening uh to talk about the calendar drafts that we presented in November uh last month we presented drafts for the 2526 school year as well as the 627 school year as you know we also share those drafts with
041the community to review and receive input on at this time I come with the superintendent's recommendation for you to act on the calendars that were presented do have separate no so I would like to make motion that we approve both the 2526 and the 2627 calendars as presented second uh is there any discussion questions comments at this point Mr Myers is hiding down there um all right all in favor please say yes yes yes yes any opposed no Mr Myers with the now all right thank you thank you Dr Odie thank you alrighty we will um up first under items for discussion we will have Aaron ior with the orchestra and band presentation good evening Dr Gurley Madam chair and members of the board I'm pleased to meet with you tonight to talk about our
042plans to sustain excellence in our band and Orchestra programs after the opening of Charlottesville middle school and the return of fifth graders to our elementary schools there's been a lot of discussion about the impact of your reconfiguration and our beginning band and Orchestra programs my goal with this presentation is to provide you an overview of the current proposal and the factors that that led to this point I will also outline our next steps as we move forward with our planning for post reconfiguration as you can tell our music and Fine Arts programs are connected to a number of areas in our strategic plan the statement that most guides the work that I do for our division can be summed up by these few sentences and they are so important that I'm going to read them
043aloud Charlottesville City schools views the Arts as essential for the complete education of every child in Charlottesville the Arts have never been viewed as Frills but as an indispensable part of our culture and history a Heritage to be shared by all this philosophy is embraced by the school board our Administration and the community at large throughout the years our division has made intentional choices that have led to CCS becoming a model for the region we've not always been perfect and over the past several years we have worked diligently at removing barriers and obstacles such as access to instruments waving participation fees and eliminating course scheduling conflicts for our programs our commitment to these programs is evident and can be easily observed and experienced each year the Virginia music educators Association awards the Blue Ribbon to
044schools whose top band choir and Orchestra all earn Superior ratings at District assessments Charlottesville City schools has earned the vmea Blue Ribbon 13 times performing grade six musical literature which is the most difficult category CHS ensembles regularly earn top ratings in domestic F music festivals and have been invited to perform internationally at locations such as Rome Florence bong Paris Vienna London and Dublin to name a few and you have heard at our most recent Schoolboard meetings even tonight the larger Charlottesville Community has come to cherish our Fine Arts programs and as you know we have received a number of messages of concern both at our Schoolboard meetings as well as in emails and be because of the unique configuration of Walker School we have been able to offer beginning band and Orchestra to fifth and
045sixth grade students following the model of a middle school rather than an elementary students meet multiple times a week during the school day to receive specialized instruction in their chosen elective this model has allowed for instrumental programs to thrive and has set us apart from other schools and divisions we know our Fine Arts programs are special and that they have impacted families over multiple Generations so if we as we have been developing plans to reconfigure our schools it is not surprising that community members have begun sharing their concerns about the band and Orchestra programs this list is a summary of the concerns that have come to our attention and it is my hope that you will see how these are addressed as I describe our current situation and plans for the future the concerns expressed
046include potential loss of instrumental music instruction the impact on student social and emotional development and the positive academic benefits of music education specifically concerns were raised about the loss of fifth grade music instruction which can be a crucial time for students to develop their musical skills and form lasting connections with their peers in the fall of 2023 band and Orchestra directors met to begin discussions around reconfiguration and to Envision what a post reconfiguration would look like for band and Orchestra this team identified and listed best practices for beginning instrumental programs and used several research studies looking at at the influence of beginning instructional grade on enrollment retention and music performance to inform our process and you can see on this slide is a list of the best practices they identified these best practices are our
047most important consideration in making the final recommendation as secondary music teachers and I began to work to develop a proposal we initially focused on starting specialized inst Al education in the sixth grade however we later decide to propose what we Most Wanted instrumental education beginning in the fourth grade and you can see this proposal here on the left however as you can see that even under this proposal we could only attain three of the recommended best practices and if we scaled the Elementary in instrumental program back to the fifth grade we only attain two of those recommended best practices on top of that a number of major hurdles also became clear chiefly this model requires the entire school day to be extended 30 minutes an idea that the fifth grade advisory committee had initially explored
048But ultimately set aside because of costs and complications also this plan requires that students lose Library time that would need to be made up elsewhere it requires space that many of our schools do not have and cannot build and it requires budgeting for additional full-time staff finally we realized that the elementary instrumental music program would become the driver of our elementary school's overall schedules due to Staffing availability it just wasn't tenable since the original plan couldn't work we considered other options we entertained the idea of developing a special Afterschool band and Orchestra program but this Ray is various concerns about equity and accessibility this plan could potentially be limiting to students who receive tutoring or are involved in seasonal activities additionally there were concerns regarding hiring Qualified Staffing who could work during these after school
049hours we investigated how other divisions introduce Elementary instruments and found that sometimes these programs relied on pullout models and While others acknowledged that the logistics in coordination of their programs Place strain on the school schedules looking back I realized that the fourth and fifth grade proposal was a bit of a stretch but I also know that it was important that we fully explored the option we all agree that we would love for our our students to begin learning their chosen instrument in fourth grade but our band and Orchestra directors agree that if we cannot recreate the Excellence of our current program under the elementary model then it is essential that our focus should be on high quality program at the sixth grade level with this in mind our secondary music teachers and I turned our
050attention back to our original idea beginning specialized instrumental music instruction at sixth grade it's hard to say goodbye to what we had at Walker but we had we have a great plan for sixth and fifth grade music and I want everyone to know that this is not a cut in Staffing or in funding this current sixth grade plan includes students meeting regularly at least three times a week for a full year not by semester we are going to assign our current Walker Band and Orchestra Staffing to the Middle School level to provide small group instruction for beginners in like instrumentation we will ensure dedicated time during the school day for students to play as a whole ensemble as well ensure as ensure dedicated time for after school rehearsals with Transportation provided for those who need
051it it is also recommended that the sixth grade students are provided with two elective options so as not to detract from initial band and Orchestra enrollment all music teachers feedback has contributed to this model even if some of them would still advocate for elementary instrumental instruction some of our teachers are here tonight continuous collaboration with band and Orchestra teachers will be essential as we continue this process and band and Orchestra teachers will be part of the master schedule development process at Char Charlottesville Middle School um to ensure that the best practices can be met when we compare this plan to our list of best practices you can see here that we are hitting them all except for the early start this plan also includes adjusting our fifth grade General music program we will be enhancing
052our elementary General music cre culum in collaboration with Bandon Orchestra directors to ensure that by the end of fifth grade the students will be prepared to enter our Bandon Orchestra programs at Charlottesville M Middle School paying special attention to music literacy and notation as well as experience and exposure to instruments we will be refining the introduction of musical instruments such as recorders ukuleles and ORF instruments in the elementary program we will arrange field trips featuring instrumental music for students such as the the annual Charlottesville Symphony Orchestra program children's concerts sponsored by the Tuesday evening concert series as well as the youth performance by the Charlottesville chamber music festival we will arrange special in school visits by instrumentalists using Community Partners such as the prage program which brings local professionals to music classrooms to demonstrate instruments
053we will ensure that we have face-to-face meetings with the rising sixth graders and Bandon Orchestra directors during the elective selection process and we will also schedule Charlesville middle school and Charlesville High School ensembles to perform for both fourth and fifth grade students it is important to note that this fifth grade music program will reach all students and not just those who elected I hope you can tell that my colleagues and I have put both time and heart into this recommendation under the new model all fifth grade students will be exposed to instrumental music through the general music class our sixth grade beginners will be supported by a very robust staff to get them off to a strong start and there are no funding cuts to no funding or staff Cuts in this model we also
054know that other divisions that start teaching instruments in sixth grade have also been able to achieve Excellence as we continue to refine this new model we are committed to continuous collaboration with the band and Orchestra teachers and I am confident that we have identified the best way forward with a strong plan to support these programs that we all love thank you for your time and I'm happy to answer any questions thank you um board members any questions comments Mr Myers uh thank you Mr ior this was a great presentation I've very impressed with the thoughtful I think process and criteria and Analysis you have all done in order to come to this uh I again note that and I've heard this in the public a lot that would be cutting things or cutting teachers and
055this is I think different but not cutting and I think that came came to me very clearly in this presentation uh my child has been participating in fifth and sixth grade band resarch and uh I've seen the benefits from it I also I think appreciate that now a lot fifth graders will get a deeper experience all of the fifth graders will get a deeper experience and be able then to uh select into a I think looks like it sounds like a more robust sixth grade experience uh if that's what they want to do so uh I appreciate this and thank you for your time and I know it probably wasn't what you were hoping to have to do but uh when considering reconfiguration overall and that benefit to all of the CH uh the students
056in this community I think um I think this is uh a good path forward thank you thank you um I echo my colleagues sentiments and also want to appreciate I think the collaborative approach um that you took along with Dr Gurley um and really working with the existing staff um to hear from them hear their concerns and really take them to heart and to do the work of of how do we um cultivate and care for every student not just one sector of students and not wavering from a massive change in scheduling and and really taking a whole approach to this and so I appreciate that um appreciate that we're not cutting funding the board is not cutting funding to any particular program or to any particular group I am looking forward to this um
057new revitalized maybe even programming um and hope that everyone who has taken the time to come out and to speak um will remain engaged and will be a part of these opportunities that Mr iour has talked about bringing in professionals into the schools and offering students the opportunity to learn um from so many of you who have reached out and talked about your incredible experience I hope you'll remain engaged and offer to lend your expertise in a new way in a meaningful way to a group of students that might look a little bit different um but we'll be welcome and so I encourage folks to continue to engage in that way so thank you for the work Miss dly I'll echo my sentiments of thanks um I am impressed by this I like the programming
058um I am not a fan of hypers specialization too early in a students um education and so I appreciate that this is keeping options open for students to um have the experience of exploring um a vast range of curricula um as they you know matriculate through our system um to what their ultimate goals are going to be so thank you m Richardson um I would like to say thank you and everyone who came to speak I have a riseing fifth grader who wants to be a music producer so I'm extremely excited to see how this program will evolve and I will be keeping tabs on that thank you um now I just want to thank you for your presentation and your time do you have anything no okay thank you sir oh I'm sorry uh
059hi I just wanted to say as someone who is graduating from the string Ensemble program and obviously like went through the fifth grade program I think that this sounds like a good plan and um is sounds like it sounds like a good accommodation and something that I think students will still be excited about and um look forward to thank you next up we have 10.2 school name review update good evening Madam chair school board members and Dr Gurley we're here to present an update on the school naming process including recommendations for the four schools which were under review I am not going to review this slide but I think the big picture of this slide is that we've been at this work for a while since 2020 in particular and we have made a a
060a lot of progress in that time if you consider uh Trailblazer if you consider Summit and the good work that those schools have done to established new culture uh We've also made the change to ktech to make that Charlottesville area and we've also renamed Charlottsville middle school so that actually not all of that falls under the scope of this exact renaming um charge but it's just a history of the work we've done in this area I do want to add a few things because in the in the weeks that we have been getting feedback this fall we've heard a couple of um questions about people saying well weren't you going to change every single school name that that kind of thinking so I just want to explain that a little bit that was actually never
061uh the schools never stated that we were going to change all the school names and the the task from both Dr Atkins and Dr Gurley have been to evaluate the school names whether they are in keeping with our values today in fact the very first question on every single survey we used the same survey effectively over and over and over again was do you think effectively I'm paraphrasing but it was do you think the school name should change or do you think it should stay the same so um and the other thing I think this these various committees in the board can be proud of is that up to this point for that question of change the name or not change the name in every case the committee and so far the board has been
062in sync with the community feedback on that all right uh if you don't mind advancing to the next uh a little bit of History because we we kind of came to this point this fall at an unusual spot we had four schools left to finish up the process four but two of them Burnley Moran and Johnson we had begun this process us a year or so ago and then we paused at that point the decision had been made to change the name of the schools but we had not successfully found the new names of the schools so just as a reminder we uh the the bottom line for the committee that recommended this name change to you to the board which again it was a slightly different board then but was that the regardless of
063the accomplishment or Merit of those individuals those school names commemorate an era of segregated education that no longer reflects the division's values and I think another way of thinking about this is we would like names for our schools that at a schoolwide morning meeting the school principal and the school staff could literally help the students celebrate and feel pride in their school name and they wouldn't have any um ambiguous feelings about the name or or remembering a history that doesn't represent all of our students so that is just another approach to why we have uh really engaged in this process overall I'm I'm not I looked at this slide a few minutes ago I don't think the date is quite right but it is right in the LA in the sense that we've kind of
064gone back and forth on this policy because there was a little technical error but I believe it was last November that the board really did a a some work perhaps uh with Dr Odie and Dr Johnson to um to okay so may maybe the timing is right I'm not not positive but in any case the the board over these years uh Revisited the policy and really um declared a preference for names if we if we are changing a name from individuals we're not going to pick new names for individuals and we would the the preferences for names that really are centered around a sense of purpose and place and this and I remember Miss Powell was the one who came up with the this this idea for us and it was very effective it really
065resonated with the original naming Committee of the time and with the executive leadership team and I think you will find this has been helpful to the Committees that began their work again this fall and so after the policy was updated the leadership team developed a seven-step process which you see to guide the review of a school's name as outlined this process involves forming an advisory committee attempting to notify relevant stakeholders and holding committee meetings where data is reviewed and thoughtful discussions take place step one through three which are detailed in the slide have led to the committee's making the formal recommendations to the superintendent and so that's step one step two and step three and as a result the superintendent is prepared to make a recommendation to you all this evening which is step four
066during this process four schools were reviewed BR Moran and Johnson's committee started with the task of selecting a new name name for the school as the decision to change their name was made in 2023 as Beth discussed Green Brian Jackson vaa Begin by reviewing their current school names and we will now go over the recommendations for each school starting with BR Marin each of our slides outlines the process followed by the 2024 committee as well as key data points and sources they considered the burin Moran committee reviewed all Nam suggestions made since 20 20 and carefully considered excluding all area landmarks or street names that were not in close proximity to the school this led to the elimination of names like river viw and river Vista while the river is nearby it is it is
067within this it is not within the school Sidelines so the committee decided to focus on features that are directly visible from the school instead after much discussion the BR Moran committee gave their final recommendation to to Dr Gurley of Sunrise Elementary School this name gives a ND to the school being the eastern most School in our city with lovely Sunrise views committee members like the way that Sunrise conveys a sense of hope warmth and New Beginnings as well as the power of students Rising through their years in our school one Committee Member noted Sunrise evokes all the positives of a fresh new be new beginning end or new day every student re receives that New Perspective and chance to grow each day as part of today's BME Community also if you have ever attended a
068BME schoolwide morning meeting you know that sunrise and the sunrise is prevalent and physically interconnected with the school's processes moving on to Greenbrier the process was pretty straightforward the committee concluded that the school name is already named after the neighborhood where it's located which aligns with the purpose and place criteria outlined in the current policy additionally there was a strong community support for keeping the current name therefore the committee has recommended to keep the name Green Brier Elementary School moving on to Jackson via the committee took their time with this recommendation since we know that naming schools for individuals can be a little bit more complicated part of their work included reviewing the biographies of this women reviewing accounts of these women from the people who were Trailblazers when Johnson's school was desegregated and Via
069was their principal and they also uh actually went to one member went to special Collections and did a deep dive of via's own writings to really be able to answer the questions of of the various committee members I mention all this because um I really think it's a it's a window into how hard and how carefully these committees worked it wasn't just uh you know sitting around and kind of like looking at survey data and then saying this is what we're going to do they actually took time to do research and do some deep and uh thoughtful consideration and once uh once they reviewed these accounts from the Trailblazers who were all who were very strongly in favor of keeping baia's Name by the way in the research of the person who went to special
070collections that committee like almost all of these committees came to a unanimous recommendation to keep the school's name their uh one Committee Member wrote in a time and society that is deeply divided let us draw from the examples set by Nanny Cox Jackson and Betty Davis via let us Embrace Unity determination love of learning community service and an upstander spirit in doing so Jackson via continue to produce civic-minded citizens committed to making the world a better place as you can tell this unanimous recommendation for Dr gley was to keep the name as is Jackson via elementary school and one final point that was important to the committee was that in 1969 these two women were specifically chosen as fitting examples for charlottesville's first desegregated school and the committee believes that they are still fitting examples
071of that work today finally we'll move on to Johnson Elementary School this is another one that like Burnley Moran has been years in the making when the previous committee made there when the you know the 2223 committee made this recommendation it was to the board for Cherry Avenue Elementary School but that name was paused the 2024 committee decided to revisit that name a little bit but as they because there were wrin people who who had requested reconsidering Cherry Avenue however alongside those write-ins for Cherry Avenue the committee felt like they were hearing people saying I don't care for Cherry Avenue it doesn't have a deep more inspirational meaning and it speaks to one very specific Street in our city instead of the whole school community so the committee uh sort of they set that aside
072and I'm going to give a few other examples of some of these top recommendations to give you kind of their thinking because again I I think it really shows the the level of detail that our committees uh took up for Forest Grove uh that was actually the top vote getter on the on the kind of conversation starter survey we did this fall uh that one got the highest votes but they also heard from people saying Forest Grove sounds a little generic and it's also very repetitive one one person even wrote in to say it sounds a little bit like ocean water you know it and the committee the committee took all this feedback into account and and set that name aside for Rock Creek which was also a fairly High vote getter uh people liked
073that name in many ways but the committee like some of these other committees that you've heard from was very sensitive to the the fact that Rock Creek and Rock Creek Road are not actually adjacent to the school and they did not want to pick a name that might cause confusion for people who are thinking that it must be on Rock Creek Road or really close to ro it is close but not exactly adjacent that's the kind of thinking that has been really prevalent in these committees and then Tall Oaks was the next highest vote getter and that one the more the committee worked with it the more they really did like it and so um I'm going to that in fact was the recommendation of the committee and that um I will uh speak in
074the words of the committee for why they chose this one to uh it evokes the beautiful trees that dot our campus including a historic giant Oak Tree near our playground families students and staff often comment that our outdoor spaces truly make our campus oneof a kind as a parent noted when they nominated this name there is an ancient saying from Little acorns come mighty Oaks we felt this saying captures the growth and empowerment that occurs among all of our students who walk our Halls it's also worth noting that Tall Oaks Elementary School still fits with the song's traditional the school's traditional song which was actually another request of the staff so these committees really had a lot of requests to work with and they tried to honor his as many of the requests as they
075could so thank you all for giving us the opportunity to present this information to you this evening as we can conclude this farther presentation and move into the superintendent's recommendation I would also like to take a moment to acknowledge the hard work of both our current and past committee members as well as the collaborative effort from our school Community um members of the board um I before I get started I do want to thank our committee members both past and present uh for doing this work specifically I want to thank Dr Baptist I saw her today um and I tell her often that her Legacy still lives on she did this work uh for quite some time she along with uh Dr Johnson I also want to acknowledge Dr OD because I know she did
076some work on the policy alongside um Dr Johnson and also miss Chuck um who has been a great supporter and great communicator of ours um I have um I did meet with each one of the Committees and I will tell you that um I think I had a moment each time that I met with them because many of the words that you heard them say just really resignated with me and I think I was um profoundly moved as I heard each each one of the recommendations um so it is with enthusiasm that I do present these um names to you all when we come back in the month of January I plan to um ask you to um to accept the rec the names that have been presented to you and I hope that you
077all accept them without recom U without reservation because a lot of hard work did go into um arriving at this moment this evening of finally completing our school naming process so uh again I'm in support of all the names presented without recommendations and we'll bring them back to you without reservation and we'll bring them back to you in January do we have any questions I know we had questions when they came the last time so if approved in January these would go into a effect fall of 25 the fall of 25 is what we would think we would follow the um what we did this school year in terms of the implementation okay um thank you for revisiting this process I think I was somewhat cynical in the beginning and some of my board colleagues
078current and past um I was suggesting that we go the way of New York City and just do public school one two three four and just avoid all of this completely um I have had a change of heart um attending the ribbon cutting ceremonies um specifically the one at Summit when the students uh were able to read their interpretations and definitions of the school that was really impactful and I really appreciate that so many of these names um hold that deeper meaning for students so I guess Green Brier is the one that I still kind of question a little bit I don't know what the deeper meaning of Greenbrier is I guess besides the neighborhood um but certainly um will be in support of this I believe in January um and then just a note
079to some of the public that has had some reservations about some of the names um renaming doesn't mean that the mascot has to change um and so I know that there's still a lot of um commitment to some of the various school spirit animals and whatnot and so um we'll look forward to how some of those evolve or stay the same thank you Mr Mor i' like to speak to that mascot thing just just uh I think uh you can tell that Summit actually their staff and their students chose to embrace a new mascot and uh I mean AT Trailblazer they chose to embrace a new mascot and at Summit they they definitely did not want to pick a new mascot and both of those are great options that the schools could consider for themselves
080I'll just keep it very simple uh I'm very pleased with the process and the outcome it's so much different than the last time and it feels a lot easier um just just to hear and and I I feel like um just the stories behind the the names U that alone I think changes what we did previously so thank you and I was not here previously but watched online and from home and this feels very different um and so again I think we are seeing the continuation of a more collaborative approach and how how um we as a School Division do things and that um Dr Gurley Dr Johnson Miss Chuck really taking Community feedback um into consideration and elevating voices and really working with everyone to come up with what fits the time um and
081and honoring the work that's happening in there so thank you for that and thank you to everyone who joined in the process and like Miss Julie those ribbon cutting ceremonies were pretty great was with Miss Torres that one as well over at um Trailblazer and I think Just A Renewed sense of community and excitement and t-shirts who doesn't love a free t-shirt um and I love being out in the community and seeing the little eagles with their new t-shirts so that's pretty great thank you just say I look forward to supporting these recommendations thanks Miss hudok do you have any comments okay um I just want to say thank you to everybody as well I mean I was on the board through this prior process um as some of us were um I was not
082on the committee this time I was um on the committee so I was able to join maybe all that one of of the meetings um and just wanted to Express gratitude for the work that was done I think it was very collaborative and and as has been said by both Miss Chuck and and Dr Johnson um just the conversation and and the back and forth and the thought process and the the work that some uh committee members um initiated um by themselves you know just the time spent um I was just very impressed and and um it was really good work so thank you up next we have uh 10.3 uh Miss Pal's not here but I will stand in for her we will have Mike Gard come before us and give us our Capital
083Improvement update hi everybody I'm Kim Powell just kidding um I'm here once again to give you the uh yearly or sometimes more more or less than yearly update on capital projects can everybody hear me all right all right um we go through a few items here um projects underway and completed that's what we're doing right now uh upcoming work in the next fiscal cycle uh the priority Improvement program discussion uh and some general discussion about our way forward from here I think we're both doing it sure that would be great um we can just skip right past this one this is the agenda of projects we're working on um and go straight into our first project this is probably the most exciting one uh the Middle School reconfiguration uh this is as most of you
084know a $91 million uh reconfiguration project out at uh what was once known or is currently known as Buford Middle School soon to be Charlottesville Middle School um this is a multi-year uh reconfiguration project and I think most people know the scope of it but just a quick overview we're moving the uh we're moving this to a three-grade School sixth seventh and eth and fifth grade will go back to the elementary schools uh and then a future project will move prek into a prek center uh go ahead advance so this is a view a rendering of uh from our design process of what the project should approximately look like when it's complete um we're about a year into our construction process now a little bit more um go ahead and Advance here's another view uh
085another rendering of what the project will look like this one's a little more interesting because if you'll Advance one more we have the current condition so on the right hand side right hand side of that image you'll see uh the existing U kind of cafeteria side of Buford where we all St stood and cut that or or shoveled some shoveled some dirt a year ago uh and you can see in the distance and to the left already grown up a a couple of new building volumes so we're well on our way on this project go ahead another of our renderings from the uh design process and one more this is where we were a year ago when I came and spoke to you and one more and this is where we are today that Vantage
086so the angles are a little different because I'm standing on a massive pile of soil that's out there right now uh soon to be moved away but you can see that we're making very significant progress on this project I'm happy to report that as of right now we're on time and on budget I have no concerns for uh for this project getting completed as planned uh of course anything can happen so I'll knock on wood there but everything is Full Speed Ahead presently go ahead another project we have been working on is the Johnson modernization now apologize in advance I do not have all the new names necessarily in my head this one's still underway but some of them have already taken place but you'll see some old names in here because these projects were
087named before the renamings took place um this is a learning Terrace and this is part of our priority Improvement uh program uh otherwise known in the past as the school modernization program and a little background for those who don't know that's a 1.25 million doll yearly investment from the city uh to modernize parts and pieces of our schools um that's not enough money to do a whole lot but it is uh about what you can get done in a summer which is important uh and it's been especially tight this past summer because it was a little bit shorter than usual go ahead uh this project is complete now so you can see here a view of what it looks like um our plantings on the left-and side are still taking uh but this is a
088project that's intended to uh give the students an opportunity to maintain the planted areas and also to give them some outdoor teaching space and Gathering space um what you're seeing was just the uh black rooftop of the uh school's gymnasium so it was basically unusable space and it was actually originally intended to be built out in a similar way to to what we've done here and I don't know why it wasn't ever built out as an occupiable space but I think it probably had to do with funding and and budgetary concerns at the time so we were happy to be able to come in and um and bring that up to to where it was originally intended to be and I think it's a really nice space go ahead and one one more and it's
089a little hard to see in this slide but it does give a really nice uh overview of the playfields and the Tall Oaks that the schools uh soon to be named for so um here's a very glamorous project that we're working on this is uh the CHS electrical switch gear project this is our third year working on this project so uh phase three um we've gotten through the first two phases phase three is just about complete as well so uh you'll be happy to know that the electricity that runs into this building is running through all new switch gear and I and I'm sure you all noticed um but it was a safety concern so we're happy to have had it addressed even if nobody really noticed another um very visible project the uh CHS
090roof replacement also in its third phase um so we have finished two phases of the roof of this building um and we're moving into phase three which will be completed next summer uh and then we're hoping to roll in with a solar project shortly thereafter so this project is going pretty smoothly there have been some hiccups here and there as there usually are with big Roofing replacement projects but um it's a $6 million three-year investment into keeping the water out of the school again it's not the sort of thing that people love to spend money on but it's the sort of thing that you hate when it fails so it's another view of that beautiful new roof all right this one is uh one I am a little more excited about for functional reasons uh
091this is also here at CHS um this was a bathroom or restroom renovation project this one came to us pretty uh pretty late in the game and so we scrambled to get a design team together uh and to get this out to bid and built over the past last summer uh the intent of this project was to create more restroom space that uh gave both better privacy to students uh and also was a little easier for staff to monitor so uh we heard reports that things were happening in the restrooms that weren't the best um and also uh I think this kind of responds to some of the concerns that folks have about gender and who uses what restroom and blah blah blah I think this basically makes it so that everybody uses whatever restroom
092they want and nobody has to worry about gender uh which I think is a very good thing um we worked with Wy Wilson Architects to do a pretty complicated little uh design here uh but it actually turned out pretty nicely I think Martin horn worked with us on the construction and we got it done just in the nick of time can me go ahead one more another view of that uh Central Area so there's a sort of a public handwashing station if you want a better view of this you can just hit it on your way out it's right across the hall there um and so we're pretty happy about this vaping and smoking uh sensors are inside the little restrooms and they're sized appropriately so that you really can't do much more than one
093person go to the bathroom in those in those stalls and that was for uh that was on purpose another nice thing about this is that it is similar in design to what we're doing at the middle school so um it was kind of give us a chance to try that out in real time uh so far so far mostly positive reports I think on that our softball field Access Project uh this one has been a little bit of a rough ride but um it's a $425,000 project that is intended to uh increase access to the softball viewing areas um especially for people with disabilities some of the old uh retaining walls out there had degraded over time a little prematurely I would argue but uh so it goes um we replace those retaining elements with
094concrete so they should hold up a little better and we're also working on a batting cage over there for the softball players to use for their training and that should be done pretty shortly go it's another view of one of the ramps down to the viewing areas as you can see that's smoother than the old uh Old Paths that were there that were pretty degraded go ahead another small project there's a there's a focus in the schools as with the city with access lately and so we're picking up a lot of projects that have to do with making it easier for people to get around um this one I'm it is quite small $30,000 but I'm very proud of it because uh recently our division facilities development sort of gobbled up the project management team
095who does sidewalks and streets and vot projects for the city and so this was our first uh collaborative effort between those two groups of people who we had brought together under our office and we suddenly had the ability to do things that we hadn't been able to do in the past and that was very advantageous so Johnson had some uh some settlement in the sidewalks leading up to the school kind of just past that tall tallest oak the tallest of the Tall Oaks um and it was making it so that when things were rainy people had to walk through mud to get to school so there was some back and forth in the city about whose responsibility that really is and finally we kind of it settled with us and we were happy to take
096care of it um so a very small project but I've gotten more positive feedback from this than I think anything else we've done so $30,000 well spent I would argue go ahead another view of that and some of our oak trees and the playground and so that's a overview of the bigger things we're working on of course we're always working on a 100 little things that you might not notice um for the upcoming uh work cycle we've got a a few more projects coming up first of which the Venable which is not Venable anymore but it is the modernization for that school um we're still settling on exactly what that project is so we're scoping right now um we do have an architect on board so we're moving through that process pretty quickly uh that
097one is slated for construction not this coming but the the following summer um Walker prek adjustments this is not the big prek Center project but rather uh a short-term um make it make it work kind of project where we'll go in and um so if you're following the move of prek from um from the various elementary schools to the center there's going to be a period of time when uh the fifth grade has already gone down to the elementary level and the prek has been displaced in the interim they're going to be displaced to Walker as it currently stands and the prek won't be constructed yet um in that interim we intend to go in and make some adjustments to the school just to make it fit a little better some play and learning spaces
098some access projects so that the playgrounds are easier to get to that kind of thing so that's in that's coming up in u the following summer uh CHS track lighting there's been some significant interest and fundraising from uh from various groups and the schools to get the track lit up and those have been successful we're working on that right now and I've got a project manager uh getting a contract together for putting that track lighting in so the CHS track will be lit very shortly um we have Lighting in the PAC here at C PHS coming up so uh there are issues if you use that space with the reliability and the quality of the lighting in the PAC so we intend to change out those lights both the house lights and the uh stage
099lights and hopefully put an easier to use control panel in as well because the one that's there is not the easiest to use and there's also an Energy Efficiency component to that project that we're happy about so we should be able to uh save some energy while making the quality of the light better in that space there is the summit window replacement project so this one I did get the name right on uh some some windows started to degrade a little more quickly than they should have over at Summit so we had to roll in in kind of an emergency fashion and sort of make some uh repairs so that those windows would be structurally sound and wouldn't fall um and now that that's done we need to start replacing those windows so if you've
100ever looked at that school you can imagine that's quite a lot of Windows Windows aren't cheap so that's been U it's a significant undertaking when you have to kind of shoehorn a project like that into your uh budget when you're not ready for it but um we've got some demonstration windows in place now and I think they're looking pretty good so we're going to roll in with a full replacement uh in phases because again you can't do all the windows in a school in one summer the Burnley Moran roof replacement that's scheduled for fiscal year 27 we think that's going to cost about a million and a half dollars it's a pretty straightforward project it's the replacement of the roof at Burnley Moran which will be scheduled for completion that year um and then I'll
101jump ahead to the Jackson V roof replacement because it similarly is just the next roof to be replaced they're they're all kind of go in sequence um and so we're planning on getting all of the elementary school taken care of as quickly as we can so that we can have fresh roofs everywhere um it's worth noting that all the roofs that we put on are going to be solar ready that's the city's standard now going forward with ro roof Replacements so um and we're working with our friends in sustainability at the city to uh put together a funding model where we can put solar panels on any of the roofs that make sense to do that on meaning they have good exposure Etc I'll jump back to the prek center at Walker campus so this
102is in the city's CIP presently uh we have it says 25 to 30 I think it's basically 30 that we have scheduled and that's an FY 27 so the intent here is to roll straight into the design and construction of the new prek center which we've already got a schematic design for uh we did that schematic design at the same time as we did the Buford project schematic design because we wanted to present a package that the city could look at and understand um so when we get the funding for that we'll roll into full design get those designs finished out and we'll go to bid and build that project so it should be a pretty seamless flow so that our construction team can move from the Buford project straight into that Walker project and
103then we also have uh CHS generator upgrades which are coming uh and that's simply a project to make the generators of the school more reliable and increase their capacity a little bit so that's the overview for what we've got coming up so I mentioned earlier the priority Improvement program and uh I think some people have a pretty good understanding of it who've been around for a while but not everybody does so it's worth noting as I said 1.25 million per year we dedicate that to school improvements um you can see the stuff that's in black is kind of set in stone or is completed already so we started at Clark went to Jackson Bia Burley Moran Green Brier and Johnson those are all complete CHS restrooms we completed this past summer uh Venable we're working
104on uh we're we have to use the fiscal year 25 funds for Walker temporary condition I mentioned that earlier and that was uh a little bit of horse trading that went down down when we needed to fund the Buford project um because it was a tight squeeze to get that into the CIP um that leaves us with the fiscal year 26 funding coming up next and that's these are in red because they aren't fully decided and I think there's some question about what we should do there um the CHS turfield is in need of replacement uh just the top surface not the entire field um but that's a significant project because the size of it and just the cost of turf fields so uh it's possible that we could use uh the 26 funds to
105do that field replacement if we don't do that we have to come up with some other strategy and I don't know what that strategy would be presently um and then in 27 the suggestion has been that we do some interior ceilings or maybe some restroom a second phase of that restroom process here at CHS this is something that will be uh open to suggestion from Schoolboard on you know I think this is these are all open questions um we take you know whatever the school board Dr Gurley give us his advice on what they would like to see we generally take that advice and run with it we don't unless there's some good reason why that's not going to work we tend not to push back so um that's something for you all to consider
106and if you have some ideas that we haven't thought of it's worth talking through those and that's what I have to present for tonight if uh anybody has any questions I'm here for you I'm GNA start down here with Miss Richardson Miss Richardson since I assume that your list is gonna be long no Miss dly you're okay right now maybe we're going to get to you just a quick question I've heard some conversation in the past about like WiFi access over at the field at the football field is that is that in your perview or does that is that on a list somewhere I think that would be a school's it question um I think that's the question about when we um and what makes me remember this is during the tournament when they cut
107the cable trying to get the internet open to the yeah that's I don't know if you have more yeah I know it's something that's in the works so the the short answer is it's been on a list that's been on a list that's been on a list um we have some temporary workarounds but yes it's a project that keeps coming up with Kim Powell and myself um we've done some exploratory about getting the permits to run necessary fiber and cabling underneath the railroad which takes several months and we've explored some cost but no action has yet been taken besides that exploratory to the field Mr K I'm sorry can you speak more to what so what's lacking over there there's just no Wi-fi there's no internet that connects from our current Internet connection to the
108field so we would just it would be a matter of running fiber from the high school the point at the high school to the field and then setting up the necessary infrastructure to to broadcast um internet there and so and that's impacting students doing homework there or what what other no it's essentially would be a space that could be used for um recording of games um in the event of uh that space being used in an emergent situation there would be um Wi-Fi there we do have some portable 5G router hotspots that can accommodate some of that need that's uh temporary in an emergency but that was the design of the bringing permanent internet over to that space thank you thank you uh Mr Gerard uh appreciate this presentation I mean I saw this as
109part of the Joint Committee we have with the city the other day and and I really appreciate it and for my colleagues uh just a little bit of a report out and I think some things I want to highlight for you all uh one I think we're very lucky to have Mr goodard he's been promoted and I think more importantly now has a team so that there is more capacity within the city to execute on the projects uh whereas I think in the past unfortunately there has as much capacity so that's uh I think a welcome change and is not necessarily operational budget that's coming up our budget it is operational City budget but we are a majority of their I think as you all realize uh of their square footage for their buildings and
110Facilities uh another thing I want to point out is I saw this there was a joint meeting between what similar to what we will have between the AL County Public Schools and the Board of Supervisors for Al County talking about their CIP and for the county schools their CIP equivalent just for the schools is $560 million for five years $560 million ours at this moment in time 53 and while Alber County public schools has three times as many students as we have they're getting 10 times as much budget allocation now I don't know exactly that's all going to pan out but to give you an idea of the difference in how some of our our neighboring districts you might say are funding their facilities and I think we all know that despite and again excellent
111team by Mr goodard he only can work do so much with the money that he's providing so we have a political challenge I think and for all the people in this room here to understand that we have a hole of of a of a deficit of infrastructure improvements to our facilities and for our buildings that we need to desperately dig out of and we are not putting enough money towards that what I hope and what I saw uh and heard at our meeting is is that this 1.25 million we're getting for these performance Improvement projects which are I don't want to call them Band-Aids but you know slight improvements for some of the building you know of uh of our facilities it hasn't been increased for inflation since 2020 and we bumped it up from
1121 million to to 1.25 I'm hoping we get it bumped up to 1.35 now $1,000 is nice but it still only keeps us again equal to what we were getting about four or five years ago um I also want to note and I think very importantly and and Mr ger you mentioned this that we are on track though to see and I don't think have a delay in getting pre-walker Walker pre-walker built and remodeled um so that is I think SOL SOL uh Solly in there and I think we can count on that not having a lot of political questions and being delayed kind of what we saw with the Charlottesville Middle School um I also want to note there are energy performance contract which I think is jointly held between you Mr goodard and
113um the climate team which can see some more projects built not on our dime but under somebody else's time and I'm hoping we've asked to see what those projects might be and I don't think any of those unfortunately were included in here but those could cover some of these hvacs and other lighting and other things uh that we desperately need in some of our buildings I I think we'll keep on pressuring to see uh City colleagues to bring those forward to us uh we were joined by a planning commissioner I think it was the first time in many meetings at least if I understood correctly that a planning commissioner has joined us at our joint meeting the other day and he mentioned the ability to develop a master plan which would map out better uh
11410 15 20 years potentially what the facilities and buildings and remodels Etc should look like and I do hope we will uh with our Planning Commission colleagues uh be able to see that built out which would I think help us solve some of the underfunding in our CIP uh and bring more attention to the needs that we have for our buildings uh and finally I you know I sat in at the the Planning Commission meeting the other day with Mr gter and a bunch of others when they were presenting the CIP and I do think uh we should think about I'm sorry for going on about this but I do think we should think about pushing having one of us sit on the Planning Commission because at the moment when I looked at it I
115think there was two people maybe who have kiss in school and or have kids go through the school system and there's just not as part of the Planning Commission which gives a lot of advice to the city council on how they spend their money necessarily so I think my point being in here there's a lot of politically I think we need to do I think we're blessed now though with Mr goodard and his team to actually execute though but we need to go get the money thanks anybody else no thank you thank you Mr Mr Godard thank you again um up next we have um 10.4 and we have a lot of people who will be coming to the podium so if you all want to start making your way um so that we can
116move quickly and efficiently through this presentation Madam chair members of the board and Dr girl a good evening again over the past several months I've worked closely with this dedicated team plus others uh to bring to you the program of studies draft uh that I'll be talking about tonight our team included principles and coordinators uh just really thinking about what is best and right for our students I want to thank this team the entire team um again all of them aren't here tonight but many are uh for their collaborative efforts in streamlining and clarifying uh different parts of our document every year we think we've cleaned it up and made it perfect and don't have much more work to do and then every year we say oh there's work to do so we have spent
117hours and hours to get this document ready for you uh our collaborative effort has focused on maintaining consistent and clear language while eliminating unnecessary petition throughout the document I do want to also thank our teachers and students who shared their insights on what the program program of studies should include uh we provided surveys to get their input uh to get teachers input and students input and so we do thank them for the time that they took to share uh we had many internal discussions during this preparation phase and again uh we just wanted to make our document more streamlined and easier for everyone involved so um I want to talk about the Strategic plan uh as you can see here we have placed a strong emphasis on Priority One which focuses on increasing academic achievement
118uh highlighted the specific targets and strategies that directly support this um priority next slide please so this evening we're going to be providing a brief overview of the program of studies we will share General updates uh show you the this CCS secondary courses document that we introduced last year as a new tool and uh we will highlight specific School changes uh for your information and then lastly we will outline the next steps next slide please our program of studies serves as a comprehensive resource providing a catalog of academic Career and Technical and elective courses available in secondary education it also includes a detailed list of elect Ives that may be offered depending on student interest and Staffing availability again may be offered next slide our team made several General updates to the program of studies
119including uh revisions to course descriptions course names prerequisites uh we also introduced clear guidance lines for adding and dropping classes last year so we made sure that we included that process again this year uh and we clarify policies for repeating courses additionally we streamlined the document by consolidating certain courses to create a more userfriendly re resource for students and families as I mentioned before next slide on this slide uh We've included the link again uh just fine-tuning that document if you're able to click on that link Miss ster uh this this um document thank you Dr Gurley for sharing from his previous division this wonderful resource it provides a clear overview of available courses and helps illustrate potential Pathways uh students can follow so at your uh Leisure please uh take a look at that
120and just see how students can peruse and look to see where they can go with specific coursework we do have that embedded in our program of studies I've I've added it to the first page which says simply something like another look another way to look at it I can't remember the language that I used uh at this time we will have our principls come up to share their school specific changes we do have uh Dr Thompson here from Walker and I think she will say there are no changes for Walker but we're gonna let her come up um we have Mr Jordan here for for Buford but you will notice in our in our presentation that it is called Charlottesville middle school because we are talking about 2526 and it will be called Charlottesville Middle
121School we have Dr Malone uh here to present for the high school Dr trod is here for LMA I think he will likely say there are no changes for L and lastly we have Dr hilz here to talk about K Tech and I'll come back to you at the end good evening everyone it's lovely to see all of you thank you for having me tonight as Dr OD said there will be no changes for Walker in the program of studies for this coming school year thank you thank you good evening Madame chair members of the board Dr Gurley uh for Charlottesville Middle School for the 2526 school year there will only be one change uh right now in the program of studies um it does say that students who um would like to take a
122world language class has uh they must have a c or higher in their previous year's English course we are removing that so there will not be um any prerequisites for level one courses um in World languages and that will allow us to be um consistent with uh the high school and also we we offer um Urban farming and marketing and we also offer engineering one and there are no prerequisites um at the middle school for those courses also there's videoe language that suggests a level one is an entry point for all students um and so they beginning to develop uh language skills um and so we want to remove the prerequisite and just focus on giving them an opportunity to um take the level one courses for World languages um are there any questions thank
123you all right thank you madam chair m members of the board and Dr Gurley as Dr OD said um our work with the program of study has been largely with the themes of refinement and Clarity and economy of the language of our program of studies similar to what Mr Jordan shared about our world languages changes the world languages prerequisite for is removed for all level one courses for that alignment with bdee guidelines part of best Equitable practices um and to acknowledge the entry point for level one for all students who are developing language and their selected skill and creating that access to those cultural elements for people who speak that language um also removed or being added rather is a level change to our honors for bio2 anatomy and physiology this change is to align
124with the rigor in which the course was intended and created uh and was as put forth by its current teacher Miss Caitlyn Ray any questions as I go through one at a time okay there's a recommendation to add health and physical education for grades nine and 10 each as a one credit option so this will remain as half credit options in the short term But ultimately the reason for this this change is to reduce the number of students that need that half credit for health or PE in their senior year specifically either to due to students not having passed previously or they're being scheduling issues dependent upon their transition or some other Factor related to their schedule I think more importantly this will also allow us to average health and PE grades together which will
125be helpful for students being able to pass that those courses respect ly and maybe most specifically our English Learners there's a recommendation to update these following courses renaming intro to theater to theater one renaming seille players to acting performance and combining seille players two and three honors into one course called seille players honors the renaming of intro to theater to theater 1 will help distinguish this course from the eford beginning theater course currently in place changing the name of Charlottesville players one to acting performance better describes the focus of the course and helps distinguish it from Charlottesville players honors course objectives and then finally combining Charlottesville players 2 two and three honors are focused on Advanced theater leadership skills such as stage directing playwriting and film directing will help distinguish this course from the acting
126performance course okay all right the following recommendations to remove are again in line with that theme of refinement and economy of the program of studies language so you'll see there are a significant number of these courses that have not been requested or taken for several years including as far back as so these courses are recommended for removal from the program of study due to that reason the timeline since the course was last requested but perhaps more effectively to prioritize the value of each course that we are asking for putting forth in our program of study and helping secure that students have scheduling options that are most current and most relevant to them and it includes removal of many of our manager and assistant positions to help prioritize students focusing on graduation requirements and to refine
127our current teaching assistant positions that are currently available um but to velop to develop them out so we can focus on longrange education and career goals and focus on those opportunities for students to experience firsthand career or career field experiences either interning with Professionals in the school division or in their Community Dr Malone real quick can you differentiator what's the difference between personal living and finance and what what's offered upstairs or with Miss helz Dr HZ so personal living and finance is solely for students with disabilities um and we have found that our students with disabilities are able to access and pass econ personal finance with their General Ed peers um and so also that course um would require students to have special credit accommodations and that is not a guarantee so um our students
128that access the general Leed setting have been successful in econ personal finance or students to need more of like daily living skills and related to um economics and personal finance get that um through their special programming thank you Dr HZ I know when to walk away so the recommendation to add the following courses English language develop velopment 3 and reading Foundation is an extension of our reading foundations one and is a course for our English Learners who continue to build on their foundational literacy skills later on in the presentation we'll talk more about technology foundations and Technology robotic design as part of our engineering extension Pathways uh Dr coffee will help support that augmenting of that conversation good evening Madam chair members of the school board and Dr Gurley the proposed updates to the engineering
129program align course offerings with student interest and Workforce needs these changes introduce additional entry points to Technology and Engineering Pathways ensuring accessibility for students at all levels the program emphasizes skill development in engineering Robotics and other STEM related fields a structured progression has been developed with Advanced courses like electronic systems one and two planned for future years to prepare students for higher education and career opportunities the program introduces two new entrylevel courses designed to complement the existing engineering one course each focusing on foundational skills technology foundations provide a broad overview of Technology Concepts students will use engineering design tools to build and controll objects and Systems Technology robotics design offers specialized knowledge in robotics focusing on Hands-On design and construction together with engineering one these courses expand the range of entry points to the program
130allowing students to explore foundational skills in Technology robotics and Engineering Concepts these offerings provide a comprehensive introduction to stem Fields preparing students for advanced studies like PVC CDE engineering courses and electronic systems 1 and two these changes require no ftc's by offering these courses students can choose a pathway that aligns with their interest in career goals whether they prefer a general technology education a focus on robotics or a comprehensive introduction to engineering principles next slide this past fall we surveyed our six through 12th grade students we had 1,092 responses of those responses these are our top interest for the career Fields they were most interested in you can see that stem was 25.7% which is 280 responses of that this data underscored the need to enhance STEM related offerings such as engineering and Robotics Pathways
131to cater to the 25.7% of the students interested in those careers next SL students were asked about their interest in Career and Technical education Pathways engineering and Robotics received interest from 28.4% of students with 210 responses uh ranked third after business and marketing and arts and communication this reinforces the importance of offering diverse accessible entry points into engineering and Robotics students can complete various sequences starting with technology foundations or robotics leading to Advanced courses like engineering 2 and three or pbcc de engineering for or Electronics too Pathways provide flexibilities to match student interest in career goals in engineering and Technology currently our concentration sequence is just engineering one and two with this plan you can see now students have multiple up to six chances of completing those CTE completers next slide Staffing oops there it
132is sorry Staffing and course coverage three Tech Ed endorsed teachers are allocated to ensure all courses are offered and accessible you can see based on the second chart teacher 1 2 and three is how we are predicting um the number of course enrollments for each of those the structured pathway and Staffing plans ensure that students receive consistent opportunities to progress through foundational and advanced levels in Technology and Engineering preparing them for post-secondary success thank you good evening Madam chair members of the board and Dr Gurley this evening I will be presenting an expanded pathway for health and medical Sciences um health and medical Sciences courses are not only um of interest to students but increasing the course offerings in this pathway both at CHS and ktech will also help help address our local Workforce needs
133by connecting interest to relevant coursework and preparing students for their next steps whether that be studying medicine in college or entering the field upon graduation currently in Charlottesville City Schools there is only one option for students who are interested in health Andor medical sciences and that's the nurse assistant program at kch presented here I am proposing uh a new course introduction to health and medical Sciences which exposes students to a variety of Healthcare careers and helps to develop basic skills required in all health and medical Sciences including the Health Care System basic terminology and anatomy and physiology to name a few if approved this course will be offered starting next school year at CHS and would require um a half FTE for this next school year the other recommended addition to the um the other
134recommend recommendation is to add the practical nursing program to start in the 2026 2027 school year at kch this edition of the program expands opportunities for our students to be able to enter the workforce with multiple credentials a successful completion would allow students the opportunity to become not only a certified nurse aid as well as a licensed practical nurse this addition give students the option starting in 10th Grade uh to follow a pathway in nursing and additionally students who complete the practical nursing program and work in the industry for one year would be able to uh get the RN program prerequisites waved at the community college level thus reducing the amount of time to become an RN if that is their career pathway again the recommendation um is for the 26 27 school year however
135um I would like to seek approval now as starting a new program such as nursing requires us to obtain approval not only only from the Virginia Department of Education but we also must work through the Virginia Board of Nursing um and all that takes time um if we delayed this till next January um the fear would be that um we wouldn't just have enough time to get all the approvals um and things that we need in place to pull it off um so these are the proposals for new courses and programs are there any questions before I move to the next slide okay so this slide is unrelated to new courses or programs but is related to required course credit changes that we need to make at ktech so historically ktech and other Regional centers
136have a awarded Credits based on the number of hours that students were physically in the classroom or lab space as many Regional centers across the state pull students from multiple divisions um and so um you know the to make sure that they're making that time worthwhile when students are there so the state has um made everyone aware in recent years that those schools were incorrectly awarding credits and that there needs to be alignment between what is referenced in the career in technical education reporting system and the actual number of credits or awarded rather uh with ktech aligning with these state requirements students would earn slightly fewer credits but it's pretty negligible um however we Rec recognize that the value of our programs and the the time that students spend honing their skills as such every
137ktech student will also concurrently be enrolled in a career strategies course which will capture their ongoing work with uh career and Workforce Development which not only helps offset that negligible loss of credits but also really give them credit for the work that they're doing um as those components are embedded into every um program at ktech and also we find that students barriers to graduation or not typically due to a single credit um or but rather due to maybe not having a CTE sequence or meeting one of the other graduation requirements such as the verified credit um in addition this is really a requirement that we just need to come in align with um so that we're um meeting the requirements uh for the Department of Education are there any questions Dr HS I actually have
138a question back I'm sorry on um with the introduction the health and medical science is that that part so that's A5 FTE so the the idea and if you see there under Health and Medical Science there's the medical terminology um which is a CTE sequence completer so the idea is that to start intro to Health and Medical Science next year and then next year we'll be asking um and trying to make that position whole um to add the medical terminology with that so each like a semester or it would just be based it we don't feel that we could offer um five sections of health and medical Sciences in year one so we're trying to fix it on once it's I'm going to stay positive because I'm excited about this pathway um so I mean
139do you foresee that it would be a a full year to take the introduction to health yes it is a it's a one credit course a yearlong one credit course okay as is medical terminology and both of those would happen here at the high school awesome and it's also um that is an option and it um like intro to health and medical science is a recommended prerequisite for nursing it is not a required prerequisite so really students aren't prevented from just hopping right into nursing if they want but it is an opportunity for students to maybe explore um the the health and medical science field um and and see what their options are because we know here our Workforce we have tons of options and in health and medical Sciences so that's the goal great
140thank you yeah any other questions anybody for her thank you good evening uh chair board MERS Dr Gurley Lugo mcginness has no changes have I thought of a question before Dr Malone and Dr coffee get too far has there been any uh discussion around physics first and changing the sequencing of our science courses so that physics is in ninth grade with [Music] algebra she's saying no no it hasn't been discussed or no it's been discussed and not of Interest um so physics first is an effort to um change the sequencing of science courses in high school so that physics would be uh the ninth grade course followed by uh chemistry and then biology um with the belief that many students have a foundation in algebra that leads nicely into physics um or that algebra physics
141could be taken simultaneously to support students acquisition of uh those math skills that's with physics too so they would be coming from e8th grade and right into a physics point I know other districts around the state and Country start with that pathway which is the physics first and then I saw biology and then chemistry but I guess it would be either way I find that an intriguing question and and we will continue to look more into that thank you Miss D sorry can I have a more another question for that I regarding the engineering uh modifications and I guess technology uh this new pathway are we needing new FTE because I know we've been having challenges trying to fill some of the existing engineering positions or does this make it easier for us to hire
142teachers in those positions the two the courses that are being recommended to be added do not require additional ft okay if I am correct we still do have a vacancy uh in engineering that we are currently trying to feel but these two do not require an additional FTV and the changes to some of them though would that make it easy iier or it okay that's what kind of why we're doing it also is to make it easier to staff them okay it only requires a tech endorsement instead of Master's engineering another good good question okay are there any additional questions for this wonderful team of of experts I know that you have the opportunity to ask and if there are not any additional questions you see before you our next steps um the board to
143review our our program of studies over the next month uh we we certainly hope certainly tonight is just an informational document and we hope that we would be able to uh have you take action in January so that our high school can get busy with the next step for getting ready for next year year uh so um I'll come back to you in January to ask for your approval are there any additional questions or comments at this thank you and thank you everybody for showing up nice to see all of you all all right good evening um I I am going to um go over our 2526 budget priorities you can go to the first slide um so this evening I will go over the um themes that arose from our um conversations related to
144budget development what those priorities are how those priorities are aligned to our strategic plan and I will conclude by giving you some dates as they relate to our budget development process um here is a word cloud um in the shape of a um graduation cap um and these the bolded the bolded statements here B bolded words here are things that um when we did a dump of all the um qualitative feedback this these are the things that came to the top um solar on top of CHS modernize our facilities um attract quality Educators um math and reading achievement chronic absenteeism compensation and paying our staff and among other things and so you'll see these things reflected as I go through the remainder of this presentation next slide so here listed are some things that just
145emerged as um priorities I will not go into a lot of depth on this particular slide because on the next slide what we did was we took the things that emerged and before I move on I want to say that these budget priorities came about through um meetings with the PTO um from each school it came with um two on two sessions with Schoolboard members it came from um qualitative feedback as we met with um various stakeholder groups and so these are the things that emerged what I did on what we did on the next slide is we took those themes that um emerged from those conversations from those listening sessions and we aligned them with our strategic plan and so here are the things that we will prioritize as we develop the budget for
146the 2526 school year uh we will look at improving our outcomes um for our students through targeted supports and resources um ensuring small class sizes and sustaining um Fine Arts funding you know I I know we've had a lot of conversation about that this evening as we talked about band and Orchestra at the fifth grade level and I think that we will continue to prioritize those things as we develop our budget for the upcoming school year U moving on U to our next um strategic no stay on that slide moving on to our next uh strategic plan St um priority we then aligned it to our um the new budget priority of enhancing um our student achievement and equ and Equity among um and equity and then also focusing on um our student attendance we've
147I think we've done a very good job this school year of um really being laser focused on student attendance and I know that Miss rasnik and um the building level teams have done a lot of work in that area but we will continue to prioritize that because we don't want to become complacent we know that when students are present they are learning and so we will continue to um put monies and uh and our focus in that area as well as our student achievement um and I think that all things that we do should be centered around students and student achievement and you see that here and and I know that that kind of Teeters between both of those um priority areas I'm supporting our St have um that competitive um compensation in terms of
148pay and benefits um is very important to us and we want to continue to prioritize those um things and attracting and retaining high quality teachers and staff and I know that Miss Miss Chuck sent out an email today about some of our teachers who will be going to um the comedy show and so what we've solicited from our staff just tell us those things that we can do that just in time things as they relate to um keeping staff Morel High and acknowledging the hard work that you do and I think that we also see that reflected in the budget in the um school calendar where our school board said um for the upcoming school year where what are those moments in our school calendar where we can um just have those mental Wellness days
149where our staff can focus on themselves and not have to think about planning for classes and creating sub plans and and all of those other things and lastly the effective operations of our school we want to continue to modernize our school including safety um in to include safety and those safety recommendations and one thing that we've been talking about for many many years um those sustainability efforts and energy efficiencies we want to ensure that we advance those things forward in our budget next slide so as they relate to um key dates with our budget we do have a joint session um on Thursday December the 19th 2024 where we will be meeting with our city council and um one thing that was asked of um our city manager and our uh and the city council
150is to start giving them some rough estimates so they can begin to um prior us um I want to give a shout out to um Sam um Sam Sanders we um have a regular check-in and I just have this appreciation for the work that Sam is doing in terms of um working with our city council to continue to prioritize the schools I mean one thing that they acknowledge is that we are a big part um the schools are a big part of the city's budget and so um in that meeting on the 19th one thing we will do we won't give them our complete ask but we will start to rough out some numbers for them that this is what it will look like um when we ask to implement um the following things and
151then we have a regular school board meeting the first week we return back to school after the winter break on Thursday the nth and then we have a budget work session on January the 30th um and just um you see our mission there is just to um that we're interconnected Equity focused School Community focused on on providing skills and knowledge needed for lifelong Learners engaged citizens and personal fulfillment are there any questions this evening about our our budget priorities um is there something that you thought you would see there that you don't see and maybe I can provide an explanation as to why you don't see it but I think hope we've tried to um we did some hand um theming um we tried to come up with some hand themes as well as to
152use some AI tools to um go through a lot of um data to come up with our themes here are there any questions uh thank you Dr gley I do think this reflects the feedback of the at least I provided and and I'm looking forward to seeing this uh more details on that I one question about our meeting with our city council callings on the the 19th which I think is from 5: to 7M yes uh at walk will you be providing them an estimate on the collective bargaining uh costs that we expect that um I will I'm not quite sure we may um I know that we've um had just a little bit of a um law as it relates to getting the um final contract back with them because there's some language that
153we need to rough out but most certainly I think that there are some highlevel items that we will be able to pull out just so that they don't have any surprises with us from us because we do want we do want and hope that they fully support our collective bargaining contract um that we will um that I hope that hopefully you all will pass and then we will pass that bill on to them so hopefully they will be able to fully fund that and I know that our teachers will be most appreciative of that yeah I mentioned that because I know they're also going through with you getting collect to bargain negotiations with some of their staff also and just regarding uh the collecting bargain unit for us have they signaled that they'll be participating
154in any of the the budget meetings that we have um I mean not necessarily as obviously members on the dice of the school board but but will they will be in attendance also well one thing I do know I don't want to speak uh personally for them but I do know that throughout this process one thing um that they have done in good faith and I've appreciated the work that they've done um along with our team to help us get to this moment is uh one thing that they're very good at is being Advocates and and I'm almost confident that they know that we are going to Advocate a in good faith um as you heard me say a few moments ago before you even asked the question that you know I hope that they
155would fully fund our um the ask as it relates to our collective bargaining contract and I would hope that our CA colleagues I know that they will do that alongside us they will wear their red will we see any highle information before that joint work session um I no not collective bargaining but budget oh um the presentation that we will use for that yes it'll be always posted the week you'll get it so it'll just be an ESV we don't have anything no yeah now it might be closer to the 19th because we have a lot of number crunching so you know we normally try to do it a week in advance but there will be a lot of number crunching leading up to the 19 but you'll have have it before the day of
156Miss Richardson any questions thank so if there's something that that is concerning that might come in late that maybe didn't specifically meet this list um we'll bring that to you oh absolutely I mean the process is I mean one thing that since I feel like since I've been here our process has been very fluid absolutely um and we've tried to make sure that every group that every group and our students are represented and our um ask and our staff are represented and our families are very clear on how we spend our money and I I believe we will continue that transparent process yeah and I just want to um shout out to I mean we did have a great group advocating last year throughout those meetings with us and showing up and and this will
157be for everybody's you know the first time that we are going through this process with with a a ctive bargaining contract um parallel to to working through the rest of the budget so it's going to be kind of new and different and we as a board have not seen that yet so we don't know what that looks like um but I look forward to um you know your team support and and the board's advocacy and then uh advocacy from staff and community members and I know I've had a couple of opportunities to just remind people in committee meetings that um to show up um you know with with their concerns and their asks and to follow along with city council as far as their budget meetings and their schedules um as they work through their
158their different parts of their budget so thank you and I will say that um before I sit I mean it's I think it's been a very engaging process with collective bargaining and then and one thing that um I think will be apparent for all is that I mean know a lot of folks benefit from the hard work um both that the staff and CA did together and it'll have a lasting impact for our community and those around us all right thank you up next we will have Rachel rasnik with a uh special education presentation the December one child count hi good evening everybody Madame chair Dr gly members of the board um so I'm going to go through our preliminary December one child count um there's two sources of data for this one is our
159current local determination um which is really lagging data so we received that in October of about every year um and that's for fiscal year 2022 so what I've included is that data last year's data and this year's data just to be able to show some Trends um I do want to acknowledge that whenever we look at students with disabilities in this way um my team and our teachers think about students with their name their strength and their need um but this is a way for us to plan and prepare um for our students um and in another important way okay so um this first um this first chart just details the number of students that receive services at greater than 50% of their instructional day and those that receive Services less than 50% of their
160instructional day we can really think about that of as students in intensive special education programs and students to receive resource level support as you can see our students in our intensive support programs has remained stable um we are serving fewer students in the um in the resource level of support at this time than we did in 2022 this outlines um the breakdown of our students by their special education designation as we know there are 13 designations some with sign ific anly lower incidents in a population than others um over the past three years we have seen a noticeable increase in the identification of students with autism and multiple disabilities to have to have multiple disabilities you have to have two or more of the designations that require a comprehensive program that supports both of those
161disabilities um and could not be met through a program that just supported one um students with multiple disabilities ities are in our most intensive support programs at this time we have seen a noticeable decline in the incidents of specific learning disabilities in our schools um which um we attribute in some ways to an availability of structured literacy interventions um in general education for many many students um whereas previously to receive that level of support you often had to be found eligible for special education so that been a trend we've seen over the past five years actually um the next slide is placement code so this is important because some of our special education indicators um reflect um how we're making improvements in least restrictive environment so so you know public Day School is um students
162K12 who attend one of our schools um that includes students who are at Parkside um who are up through age 22 um it doesn't include any preschool students public separate School are students that are enrolled at our our public separate school which is Ivy Creek private Day School encompasses um any private separate school that students are enrolled in examples would be like Keys Academy Lafayette um elk Hill Charlottesville Gand um over time um so I looked through some files from from about 8 years ago um and we had six over 60 students enrolled in private separate schools so we've seen a significant decrease um this is due to an increase in programming in our Public Schools um and it's something that we're very proud of we are now below the state average um for use
163of public separate settings um the next slide talks a little bit deep more deeply about lease restrict environment as you can see in our current local determination we did not meet our targets um you can see that our students were included in regular classrooms 80% or more of the day we didn't meet that Target or our students who spend the majority of their day in the special education setting however when we look at our current data um we've made um significant gains in the use of um special education being provided in the regular classroom setting for students students um and that's something that we've been focused on as well as in students being served in separate public settings what's interesting here is the target for separate public settings is as you can see about 4%
164um but we know from our work with the state um and we received notification from them that we are below the state average the next is preschool um and this is one of those um um this really stands out to us so having 29 students served in the regular Early Childhood setting and 43 this year that's a significantly larger number of Early Childhood special education students um we are just about at our case load maximums for our early childhood special education teachers um however what's exceptional about this slide is that um these students are being served in our preschool programs in local public preschools um and so we continue to focus on that and only use um separate special education classes when it's absolutely necessary um for students the other thing about that number that
165will play into as we're talking about next school years um over 50% of them are four-year-olds so that means our kindergarten special education enrollment will be higher next year um and will require us to think about our resources there yep thank you sorry do you have so back to the regular Early Childhood numbers yep um so those are our students in our current buildings and sites that we serve throughout the city or that we partner with yes so we serve so for students have the placement code of regular Early Childhood Program that means that they attend a regular Early Childhood Program um it can be a preschool of the fames choosing it can be VPI it could be Head Start um and so some of those students attend a preschool that we go to to
166serve them some of them attend a preschool that then their parents bring them to us for speech services um but we go to we have made available to any school that we do mixed delivery with we will provide special education services in those schools um and we currently serve students at Barrett and the YMCA and then are those numbers those aren't included in the K through 12 so are you tracking or seeing a similar um diagnoses change or shift as far as uh or not diagnoses but um the category no we've actually seen so like developmental delay we've seen about the same identific um that slide with designations does include preschool um so we are seeing um an increase in students with autism um and developmental delay um you can only be have that designation
167until age seven so really it's an opportunity for us to provide some early intense intervention with the goal that you would not require special education after age s um but we are seeing developmental Delight and autism as the primary designations in preschool and speech language impairment and then Staffing are we looking okay as those four year olds or I'm assuming we might hear more of that or see something right now right now we're doing okay um we have some excellent itinerant teachers um who are able to support students in a number of different schools um in those regular Early Childhood programs um as we start really crunching these numbers and looking at next year um we will have to look really closely at kindergarten for example I know one of our elementary schools is going
168to have five identified students at least um and when we think about case loads um it's not a full case load but it is a substantial number of students and so how we support those students um will be important the good news is they've been in regular Early Childhood programs they've received that general education instruction and so those some of those foundational skills have been built already which is really exciting the next slide is our preschool least restrictive environment this has an been an area of focus for us and we are reaping the benefits as I would like to say we significantly exceeded our targets and our local determinations um and we participate in every opportunity to further inclusion in preschool that we can um we just um found out that we'll participate in um
169a in a um in an opportunity with Tac to learn how to use the inclusive classroom profile which helps teachers create more inclusive general education classrooms through the use of observations and feedback and then my last slide so this is about are students with intensive support needs application so each year um I look at all students who are serve 85% or more of their instructional day who have the designations autism emotional disability death blind hearing impairment multiple disabilities or traumatic brain injury for those students we can because we are part of a regional program we can submit the students with intensive support needs application where we actually turn in to the state the actual cost of educating those students um and then we are reimbursed for some of that our local Composite Index is applied
170um to be able to offset some of those significant costs this year we have 44 students that we submitted in the application I think one of the things that we we are advocating for um when we can at the state level like through our Council for special ed administrators is there we have a number of students who are in intensive support programs whose designation is not included in the list um and that's somewhat confusing um for example intellectual disability um makes up a number of students who require intensive support needs um but we cannot include them in the application and so we um don't we are not able to um receive that reimbursement for them there are some students that don't get included because the reimbursement would be less than what we would get um
171through ADM so we do that calculation as well and then my last slide just an update on where our case loads stand um some celebrations tonight um we're going to have um our last vacancies teacher vacancies filled we filled our speech language pathologist vacancy a teacher at Charlottesville High School and a teacher at Walker which is really exciting um we do we did just post um for two instructional assistants and there are some outstanding instructional assistant positions um but I just wanted to give you an idea of where our case loads stand um for special education teachers we are well below um what the maximum is um for intensive special education teachers so that's like leap and structured teaching are two intensive support programs um we're at about um one student less um than where
172we can be for them and then Early Childhood special education when I include um my evaluators um where at six and then our slps OTS and PT are also reflected here any questions any questions anybody no so with the preschool numbers are we getting better at identifying students early do you think that's related to the uptick in that number of students identified like should we anticipate fewer identifications in our kindergarteners next year yes um we are identifying significantly more students this year who attend our VPI program referrals are coming from our teachers um as opposed to coming from um early intervention the majority of preschool referrals come from parents and early intervention um they don't W come from teachers because um we don't serve all preschoolers in our schools um I what has what I
173think we are also rebounding from is there was a dip in identification postco um because of where we get our referrals from students weren't necessarily um getting the attention of like their pediatrician um in the same way but this has also happened before where we've had one year that was just like a blip like when we added the seventh ecse teacher it was a year we where we where we shot up any other questions no thank you thank you have a great night thank you to all the presenters again um the next item on the agenda is board respons to written reports again that's a summary of uh just committee work and and work that board members have been doing in the last month and now we are at 12.0 which is our next uh
174opportunity for comments for members of the community so if anybody in the media center would like to approach the podium again this is an opportunity um to make a statement if so please state your name and you have three minutes hello my name is Jacob Beckham I'm a resident of Charlottesville a parent and a teacher here at CHS I have an extremely diverse professional background that does not mimic the traditional teacher Pathways even my degree is not in teaching but in educational Innovation which spans teaching methods accessibility policy buildings programs Equity Etc although this is only my first year in the with my own classroom I have been a substitute teacher youth mentorship coordinator and Club advisor in various districts across the country from grade 6 through 12 for almost a decade I'm here to
175encourage you to think outside the box and addressing the issues that various stakeholders have brought to you tonight as this pertains to the reconfiguration project a hired consultant will do exactly what you ask them to do if you ask for lines to be drawn in a certain way they will draw a very pleas looking lines but if you want to improve the equity of access of residents to schools then continuing the traditional method that was founded on the principle of segregating populations is counterproductive and continues practices that have damaged our community since the founding of quote unquote public schools in the area eliminating School zoning would allow families to do what's best for them whether it be choosing a school that is more proximal to their residents or more convenient to their daily routine by
176choosing a school that's on the route to work perhaps for Blended families one that better accommodates those family structures a common concern with such practices is overcrowding of one school as it becomes more desirable than another school districts that have eliminated school zones address this by implementing a lottery system for their schools some have even found that every family gets their first choice of school this leads me to iterate my previous proposal albeit completely separate of swapping to have one Central Elementary School and multiple high schools this would again switch 5 to 10 year- old students walking to school to 13 to 20y Old students doing so the fifth grade Orchestra issue would be moot as Charlottesville students would attend school with all of their peers until they reach high school the point in life
177that they start to decide what they want to do and who they want to be having various focused high schools that could focus on languages Arts stem Career and Technical um very some that support students Journey just to colleges and others that support trades or skills or any other Focus area we decide would better nurture our students aspirations having multiple high schools would allow diverse schedules that better accommodate our working students or students in families that observe religious holidays it can increase the number of athletic programs that would in include intra City competition the possibilities are endless one of the concepts I teach to my students is the sunk cost bias if you are not familiar with this it is the idea that the more you invest into an idea or business or project the
178harder it is to change direction even if it's clear that the path you're on leads to failure please don't allow previous efforts and expended resources which I assume were done in good faith lead us to the disasters of our past none of these are new ideas nor are they exhaustive of what could be done if you want to change something for the better you often have to do something you've never done go somewhere you've never been or talk to people who seem to have nothing in common it might hurt and it won't be easy but maintaining the status quo is condemning the future to the mistakes of the past thank you thank you anyone else here in the media center all right anybody online Mr Como if there's anybody online um please use the raise
179your hand icon and we can set you up to speak thank you for listening and attending um we will move on and we are at the point where we are with comments or at comments for from the board excuse me um Miss hudok do you have any comments thank you Mr Meyer yeah I want to engage with the Mr harlin's uh observations about the fire um at Jackson via the carf fires I was present that morning and um disturbed by what I saw I ironically I watched a city facilities leaf blower collector like block traffic in the middle of the emergency to go collect the leaves in the front of the uh the school area um so I I do think uh you know I would like to see and hear some responses more than
180how from the city because they're responsible for maintaining I think that area uh you know how we can ensure that doesn't happen again and we don't see those leaves build up Etc um I we talked a little bit about the budget tonight about the CIP and again we heard about the priorities and I just want to reate for the public that I while we control our line items we don't control the top line of the budget so you know and ask for the community members who really care about our public school system and and our budget to also show up to the city council meetings Etc and Advocate there uh finally I have heard there's been changes in the cell phone policy imple implementation of the cell phone policy and new rules and and I
181am I think maybe different than the student but but happy to hear a little bit more about uh the enforcement happening and I think uh better results in the actual implementation thank you thank you Mr Burns Mr Morris Mr Miss Richardson um I want to say thank you to everyone who presented tonight and um for the feedback and updates especially in regards to the fine arts program I'm definitely happy to hear about um the committee coming to an agreement with the name change that is exciting to going to have that be done with um I am also in agreeing with the pay increase for the future board members in 2025 and then oh yeah sorry 2026 um and then I would like to send out my love and support for fellow Black Knight alumni for
182the class of 20 2008 um he lost his daughter so I'm sending my love and support to the Glover Family thank you thank you um yeah thank you for everybody all your comments all the hard work um appreciate that I want to um just wish everybody um happy holidays as we're getting closer um to break for some of you all um and um we will now move it to superintendent Dr Gurley your comments please sure uh I I want to first uh acknowledge Mr heartline uh thank you for um your continued advocacy and I I like Mr Meyer I want to um acknowledge your concerns this evening and um I continue to have conversations with um Mr Sanders and I two was taken back a little bit by the communication about the parking on the
183leads because it does feel like one of the things that you know we can't control but just in my conversations with the city I think your recommendations um are well taken that we have to be a little bit more proactive because we have to park our cars for those of us that do drive cars we have to park our cars in in order to educate our children um and the next thing I just want to um for me just U speak on the um I want to speak on the orchestra um because it's weighed on me um I get a lot of emails and a lot of phone calls and um and so I think that I just want to make sure that people understand where where I stand on the matter um because often
184I know that the boy the board's voice is elevated and the presentation is blessed by me and I work very closely with our team um but I think it's just I just want to leave this here for the public record um and so as a child um I was taught that you always um work from a place of good um you see the best in people you have the best intentions and um and I walk that walk as an adult um I always see the best in people and I always believe that people are working with very good intentions and so over the last few months um I've had a I've learned a great deal about people and their perspectives and recently um I've read countless emails I've had conversations with families and community members
185um and they value Bandon Orchestra and I think I want to be very unequivocal in my statement here that as your superintendent I value the exact same things um and Charlesville City Schools values our um find and Performing Arts programs that said um we do must also recognize the reality of our broader goals um our community fought hard for reconfiguration to create a new middle school and throughout the planning process we work diligent to um preserve all the things that are great about Charlottesville uh we've been very transparent every step of the way and in fact our band and Orchestra teachers um have been right there with us and they have been clear you heard that this evening and Mr iort presentation that if we cannot replicate it in its entirety then we need to
186prioritize what happens in the sixth grade and we have expressed we have shown that we will build a strong six sixth grade program and out of respect for their exper expertise we are um designing a sixth grade program um for the band and orchestra that will be robust that will continue the Excellence that you all that we continue to build for years to come but I also want to address this issue about equity and comments suggesting that this will change what happens to black and brown students disproportionately and let me be clear that I rarely see black students represented in our Orchestra programs and in fact I pull today our fifth grade Orchestra numbers to see who's enrolled in it and there are six black students again if our concern are about our marginalized students
187then let's do Outreach in West Haven let's do Outreach in Prospect let's do Outreach in Kindlewood that may change the trajectory of what we're talking about because tonight I want to acknowledge Miss AES po tonight is the first time that I've heard someone say that Orchestra is about white students she's the first to say that aloud and so the emails that I get suggest that your black superintendent is neglecting black students and that is not my intent and it is very harmful to suggest that that is what I am doing if you are going to continue to rely on Facebook for your information please understand that you're going to get one side of this story again tonight Mr ior gave you um along with others how we have made this decision and what and so
188I'm going to leave that at that um but finally I'm going to discuss the fundamental issue which is instructional time um some in our community advocate and continue to advocate for reducing instructional time for the gain of other programs um but I will tell you that this will directly impact students becoming fluent readers and fluent mathematicians that is the real disservice to our students I've had opportunities over and over again to talk with element teachers consistently they share that there simply is not enough time in the day to meet all the needs of our students who is listening to the voices of our elementary teachers I will tell you who I am that's all I have thank you sir um um we have I think a wrapup I don't think there was anything on the
189list nice to see you miss whip thank you um and then upcoming meetings um we have this Saturday December 7th the Charlottesville City School Board has a an advance and um on that um agenda which I think didn't we didn't talk a whole lot about it tonight was the rezoning so this is an opportunity that we've asked to kind of sit down and make sure that the school board um just has an opportunity to ask questions and understand the metrics and the process that's being used and just to evaluate and to think about those things so no decisions being made this is not what this is about but again an opportunity for us to sit um and and talk uh about it and everybody's welcome that's a public open meeting so again that's this Saturday
190um starts at 8:30 and again it's at kch um then we do have um Thursday December 19th which is um the first opportunity we will meet with city council again that's a budget work session 5:00 pm Walker upper ele Elementary and then our next regularly scheduled board meeting will be Thursday January 9th here in the media center at 5:00 pm um and with that I'm going to call this meeting adjourned good night everybody stay safe