CorpusRecord 116922

[2/10/25] D65 - Committee of the Whole Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / District 65
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Cook County, IL
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,639 words · about 110 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all right I want to welcome everybody to our committee of the whole meeting I'm going to ask adila to please do the roll call yes today's February 10th 20125 uh the time is 4:32 p.m. roll call Lindsay Ryan here hper here Salem here Sue here Wilkins here Kim here Hernandez here okay all right um I'm going to read the land acknowledgement let me see here just a sec we take time to acknowledge that the land we meet on is the traditional homeland of the Council of Three Fires the patami oju and Odawa this land also served as an important meeting place for Miami hunk the manamon inoa sack Fox Poria Arapaho cheyen and other tribal Nations this land has long been a center for indigenous people to gather trade and maintain kinship

002ties located at the intersection of several great waterways the region has become the sight of travel and prosperity we acknowledge Evon and John Evans are tied to the massacre of the rapo and Cheyenne for railroads in Westward Expansion upon which John Evans developed his wealth and founded Evanston this land was viant taken under settler colonialism through genocide and open Warfare and the region that is now Illinois and Chicago land is still home to thousands of native people who are actively struggling for sovereignty self-determination and Justice genocidal acts of settler colonialism extended to peoples of Africa and their enslaved descendants despite Illinois eventually prohibiting slavery slavery was an accepted practice before and after statehood the vages of slavery remain throughout the United States and directly affect the descendants of enslaved peoples rich and heterogeneous communities who

003help Define the the African diaspora the genocidal patterns of violence against peoples of African descent and Indigenous people have been replicated to exclude and harm people from many intersecting marginalized identities in the United States religious minoritized disabled and lgbtq identified peoples black and indigenous people of color and people of color at large these patterns demonstrate that the pursuit to end State sanctioned violence against bipac is a daily struggle for Liberation from continued social political and economic anti-black racism and oppression today we acknowledge that we are living breathing loving grieving laughing and sharing space on unseated territory may we learn to honor the historical and contemporary presence and power of the people and the belief that we must be caretakers of the lands and Waters for the livelihood of future Generations we encourage everyone to continue

004to expand their knowledge and reduce their harm through awareness of local Mutual Aid models for survival and through engagement with online and local resources such as the Chicago American Indian Community collaborative and shorefront Legacy Center with that I'll give it over to Omar for the approval of meeting agenda I move that the board approve today's meeting agenda as presented second Salem yes Sue yes Hil yes Lindsay Ryan Yes Kim yes Wilkins yes Hernandez yes next item up is our public comments members of the public are welcome and invited to address the board during open open public meetings speakers are discouraged from using the public comment period to Heir specific concerns about staff members being mindful that the public comment period is not a suitable for for fact finding or resolution of disputes rather we encourage

005members of the public who have concerns about specific District employees to follow District communication guidelines found in the student handbook please remember to state your name and that you have three minutes to address the board also note that it is not customary for the board to respond to public comments the best way to correspond with memb M of the board is by emailing Schoolboard district 65.net and with that do we have any public comments ad um yes we have uh two speakers signed up Diana Newton and Peter boyra good afternoon superintendent Turner and board of directors my name is Diana Newton I'm the director of communications and development for infant Welfare Society of Evanston uh we are on your agenda tonight for discussion of the early um childhood education program and our partnership and first

006I just want to uh share some written information that we sent earlier but we also have a print out that I'm going to send your way and we ask that this be made part of the public record that people could View later thank you um so why am I here so my job I think uh probably most closely correlates to everything you're going to talk about tonight um you know I'm tasked with fundraising and communicating about the agency and you're going to talk quite a bit about our agency tonight and we have information in that packet I just handed out that was intended to just expand the knowledge base and uh share a few of our viewpoints on on our partnership um and I want to just start by thanking you for your investment in

007evon's children uh one thing I do know about Evanston is that this uh City cares about its Children and Families it really does and part of my job is to write grants to talk to Major donors and to um sell them in a sense about why us you know so we know you know because you run An Early Head Start program what the issues are with uh children young children and why we need intervention like what you provide and what we provide not everybody knows that even as a parent I will say I had to when I started this job two years ago I thought well what is Early Head Start what what does it do and ask teachers because as a parent uh and and many of you are parents you just sort of

008do what you know how to do right but you don't necessarily understand the value of that and those early years are so incredibly valuable and that is that is one of the the premier uh benefits of infant Welfare Society of Evon is to explain why why that is so valuable that we you know I heard somebody say once that it's if something bad is going to happen to a child and I've worked in all kinds of fields homelessness domestic violence it's better that it happened later right than early because those early foundations are so important so we know you know all this so why us well we've been uh astoundingly in the community for 112 years a century uh we were the first licensed zero to3 Child Care Facility in the state of Illinois one

009of the few uh first in the country so we've always kind of been leading the curve been out ahead of the curve a little bit and that in 1971 uh that facility opened and then in the 1990s we have we looked at teen pregnancy which we still operate and are the only one in the region that provides that support for team parents and their children in the Fifth Ward um we we serve the most vulnerable and economically challenge families in Evon and skoki and we really take that to heart we are a hub for them we're not just a services provider but we we've been around so long and our and our uh tentacles go out so far and so deep that people know that they can they can come to us um and that

010that uh teen baby nursery is important we just reinvested in a new lease on a new facility and we're committed to those families um I've already talked about the foundation of learning the social emotional the cognitive development that we do the screenings where parents you know part of what I have to do with a grant or anything else just to really break it down for people why this matters so we start thinking about how you get your children to um uh appointments so if you have a job a professional job where you can take time off it might be kind of easy to get your child to speech therapy or something else but our parents don't have that luxury they don't have the time off to do all that and many of our kids especially

011postco have multiple issues that we're dealing with so they would need multiple appointments that's so invaluable that the the the Consultants are right there they come right into the classroom and help them there it also builds the trust because in this unstable World increasingly more unstable for nonprofits for sure and for families um that's important to say we can do that all right here and we're going to catch it now before it gets too late before they all before the children get to you which you know it's too late by then you know I come from a line of Educators I went the a different route but I say to them why why is early Ted star so important he said it's everything it's absolutely everything they learned how to stand in line how to

012make friends how to follow rules how to um the the staff can become prepared to know how this child learns best on day one one when that child arrives so uh that's you know that's where the importance is and I think finally we we are a village not just internally I mean we have teachers um that have been with us we have one that has been with us 50 years can you imagine that she started at 22 she's you know 17 well we don't know her actual age and she'll kill me so I'm not even going to go there publicly on that because if I start talking about that but 50 years we celebrate another teacher this week 30 years that's unheard of I mean I've been in the belly of the beast on a

013lot of nonprofits that kind of stability is unheard of and we have other staff administrative staff 15 years 20 years our program director at baby toddler 20 years so we just point that out as a tremendous value to the community because we've been able to offer that stability um and finally uh you know Communications is in my title right so I want to say to you that we look forward to turning the page with District 65 to start a new chapter to communicate with you and um build this partnership and I think in these uncertain times if we don't know what's happening at the federal level we are a good partner to have because we we have the connections outside of our agency to say help us in this time of need like let's support

014early childhood education and I know you value that and I thank you for your service as board members too I know you value your kiddos thank you for the your time and I also have our executive director Stephen Vic here and I'm happy to answer questions as is he thank you so [Applause] [Music] much hello everyone my name is Peter boira and I'm an Evanson native and and Kingsley parent currently I wanted to say a few words in light of some recent events and observations some of them are a little hard to talk about so apologies if I get a little choked up um two weeks ago we lost a wonderful person who impacted countless students staff and community members over the years Mario Chess or to many of us known as Mr Mario was

015a fixture in the Evon Community from time his time here as a student to his career here helping so many lucky enough to be in his care my children had the fortune of being part of student age child car Kingsley where Mr Mario helped so many children experience continuity and belonging even as they moved through grades classrooms and Friends key Miss Gil and the rest of the sa team at Kingsley have been just as integral to my children's positive School experience thus far as the Educators they've been with throughout the school day rest in peace Mr Mario I also want to address the experience for the Kingsley staff that week because I think it's symptomatic of a broader issue that we urgently need to address which is the well-being of our Stu our school staff

016as if the sudden Unthinkable loss of a colleague wasn't enough staff had to internalize this loss for a whole day to allow the rest of the community to catch up and learn of the news my understanding is that there was grief support provided the following day but it was student oriented which is important but it wasn't uh there wasn't one that was necessarily specifically oriented to to uh staff members um and it it was also mentioned to me that you know to multiple people's awareness there was only one person that entire week that visited to check in from the central office just one it's hard for me to ignore the irony that on the day of this loss we held a meeting that impacted staff both across our schools as well as that central office

017as these Cuts were being approved we were told not to expect White Glove service moving forward if you asked your staff would they say they've been getting it I find the sentiment unacceptable and insens sensitive we really need to prioritize the well-being and morale of our staff across the district and rebuild Bridges between them and the central office we're better than this thank you that concludes the public comments for tonight right thank youa thank you for our public commenters next item up on our agenda is the approval of the January 2025 meeting minutes I moved at the board approv the January 2025 Committee of the whole meeting minutes as presented second Salem yes Sue yes El yes Lindsey Ryan Yes Yes Wilkins yes Hernandez yes next item up is curriculum policy okay let's start with

018the committee review document who has questions there was a lot in there I don't go ahead want to start sorry my computer is just died so I'm G to try to get my questions off my phone um I had a a comment about um the gcn um rates I wanted to say congratulations there's some excellent Improvement in the um percentages of who is and where how much folks have' accomplished so far so congratulations to all the folks involved in that um I had some Panorama is Donna here I have some panor Panorama survey questions is there a presentation after this about that or we okay then we can wait on that other folks have questions on the review document itself I think I was misremembering that a lot of the things are in that document

019not in the review document GC uh Tiffany gcn stands for comp sorry Joey anyone what Dr P is here compor Global compliance Network so our our Educators have to complete certain amount of trainings over the course of the year and we had had some lags in percentages of participation but we have had some pretty significant increases in compliance of uh and really and considerations for how how are there better ways to have uh folks get that done so you have a mic right there if you want to take it though she actually just drafted so so we talked about this last week uh Dr Pitts and I and Dr Pitts um feel I do not want to steal your uh Thunder but let me just uh talk for a few minutes about what we've discussed

020so a couple of things that we're doing differently we actually had to pause gcn in the beginning of the year for our school base because of um our unions work concerned about just the timing that it took for it in addition to that um we really needed to send out some type of reminder so what Dr Pitts and I have shared is there should be some regular reminders well people should know what it is um because I think that's what we were very clear about from last year I think people might have been getting that little um maybe the gcn or maybe not because we actually as a new person I didn't receive anything for GCM so I think that's what we established first is we need to make sure that it's going out and

021then there should be some type of regular reminder to um department heads as as well as the actual individual for uh gcn so Dr pitch drafted something a very nice um what do I call it she call them newsletters that talks about like what it is the global compliance um the trainings that you must take and then that you will receive a reminder regularly about that and then today I did receive my gcn um uh update to say I have went in to do some trainings but I have a few more that I need to do and so I think just putting it on the radar for people will help our compliance uh moving forward and Dr pittz if you wanted to share anything in addition because she's been spearhead heading these efforts good work

022Dr pits other review document questions no ready to have uh strategic plan Equity progress indicator update that one has a lot of pieces so come on up Donna and Nisha all right hello good afternoon is this oh clicker here yeah okay all right uh good afternoon um so I'm going to be presenting a quick over rview of our Equity progress indicator and strategic plan report um the full report has been provided for you in your regular board packet and it's full um and I'm just going to hit some of the highlights um and then okay so I'm going to start with learning conditions as part of the the Epi um so we have some strategies I want to highlight um one being um theal and behavior mtss framework uh that's been built along with social

023workers counselors and l aison so that everyone who works with students uh providing social emotional support um have roles and responsibilities and resources in which they can provide that support um they're also working on a full year of morning meeting slide decks for prek uh that should yeah pre to 8 um right now they're about a half year through and so by this time next year they will have or Sorry by beginning of next year they will have a full year so every single teacher will have something every single morning uh fa leaon also facilitated some CPI training for 138 staff members and 70 additional staff members um been trained in deescalation and Fa leison are also uh some have moved down to the elementary school this year uh supporting those fourth and fifth graders

024at lunchtime doing kind of some Lunch Bunch groups to increase students sense of belonging and connection to school at those at those grade levels and that's new for this year correct correct Terence Terence that's it's new for this year that they're moved y yep um so our goals for the learning conditions uh we have a goal of 95% attendance rate currently we're at 93.8% uh which is a little bit better than last year this time last year we're at 93% we also have some Behavior goals uh we want to decrease the percent of students who level 3 four and five currently we're at 3.8% um we also want to increase the percentage of level three four and five behaviors in comparison to all we're a little bit higher than that but we've also just seen

025a a decrease in behaviors period um um and then uh the districtwide student suspension rate below 2% right now we're at 0 1% um so what I'm going to do now is just hit the glows and grows uh for learning conditions so some glows uh over the past three years we've had significant decreases in level three four and five behaviors um those are the upper level behaviors that require admin support um so a really nice decline over the past three years um we've also seen and this is something we've been paying attention to over the past few years with disproportionality of students with IEPs um we've seen a substantial decline in the total incidents of students with IEPs from, 1600 to about a th um and a really nice drop in the high level level

026three four and five intensity of incidence so about 360 to 301 um so it's really important for us to make sure that our students with IPS were bringing that disproportionality rate down some other glows so our fifth through uh fifth through eighth graders uh on the Panorama survey that they took in the fall um we've saw sense of belonging going up to 58% positive responses which is the highest it's ever been um and then also in well-being andal we see 73% positive responses again the highest it's ever been that fifth through eighth grade now we have some grows um in our third and fourth grade we saw engagement drop pretty significantly we haven't seen that over the over time as you can see so that 58 to 48% um um and then as we're digging

027into some of the sense of belonging and looking at some of those questions by race um most of them are pretty consistent but this one kind of stood out 21% of black and African-American students report that they do not belong or they only belong a little um which is much higher than the other racial groups um some other grows uh black and African-American students still continue to account for 48% of behavior instance 80% of those are level one and level two but still that disparity is there however um we have seen the number of incidents decrease by about 50% for black and African-American students um from 2500 in syy 24 to 1260 in sy25 it's a pretty significant decrease but still have the disproportionality rate student learning um these are the two strategic objectives that

028it connects to some of our highlights the fourth through e8th grade science PLC has been launching um what's interesting about this one is the Educators get to select their focus so something like providing student feedback or uh having students take the cotting of lift whatever that Focus needs to be um teachers kind of grouped in that way by their own selection and provided resources collaboration and coaching um their the walkthroughs are uh completed for sixth through e8th grade looking at their align tool for standards spased learning and Grading middle school math um are working on standard-based common assessments to not only understand the current level performance students are but then what's the next steps in learning so if a student is doing this what might be that next step in instruction and learning um and

029then also the mtss and multilingual team are collaborating to support duly identified students so some of our student learning goals here this is just a progress check um our goals are all set by the spring so the winter is just a progress check fairly consistent across time um and I'll show you some of those glows and grows so some glows as we're looking at the cohort um again looking at students across time our eth grade math our eighth grade cohort in math continues to show that Improvement uh in their average percentile um from 56% two years ago to 67% um this year so that's good to see um again in that cohort we're also seeing the decrease in the students below the 25th percentile in that seventh and eighth grade cohort in language arts and

030in math um moving to mat fluency uh our kindergarteners in both languages 74% are meeting are exceeding in phonics and word recognition in both languages um so over the past few years that focus on um strategic phonics instruction explicit phonics instruction I think is already showing um some really good results there in first grade uh also phonics and word recognition we are seeing 66% in English and 68% in Spanish um of our first graders are meeting or exceeding or or meeting in that phonic s recognition so now we have some grows um the percentage of students meeting uh expected growth from Winter to Winter uh in math dropped pretty sharply um from 69% to 49% um and then in language arts uh from 62% to 53% so that's something we would need to investigate again

031that's a winter to Winter growth um I looked back over all the way back to 20 5 um and really last year was kind of an anomaly that winter so just looking all the way back for for math especially um this doesn't fall way out of the range last year was actually the the anomaly uh and then another grow is that slight decline in the students meeting College radius Benchmark both for act and SE sat especially in math it's slight but it's there and we want to keep an eye on it um so now this is something a little different that we haven't looked at um so this is our first year with middle school with standards based grading um and one of the things I wanted to look at and then we want to

032look at the success of Standards based grading is its alignment to the I so at the end of the year our students in the spring will take the Illinois assessment of Readiness grades three through eight and that's an Ela and math and the the I assessment is measuring students proficiency toward grade level expectations Boom the end it is not an Adaptive test uh like map um it's not referenced by by you know their peers Norm reference compared peer-to-peer it is are you on grade level that's where we want our students to be standard Bas grading has a very similar uh Vision we are measuring academic performance where are students at uh toward grade level expectations so those things should be balancing out so as we're looking at standers based grading for the first time one

033of the ways that we can evaluate its Effectiveness is are is it aligned to I uh so this is the standard space grading um the kind of codes and then the IR uh performance level from level one do not does not meet expectations to level five exceeding expectations so since they only take I in the spring and we want to kind of look at progress across time wait let me I miss oh no it's the next one sorry my apologies um so one of the ways we want to look at the effectiveness is again is the standards based grades aligning with what we're seeing on I so for standard Bas grades is that meeting and extending about the same amount as the meets and exceeds on I is that progressing in uh SBG matching that

034approaching and partially partially meets an i and then that beginning and not meeting are those matching that's what we kind of want to see to see are we grading effectively we don't take IR to the spring so in order to look at that uh progress NWA map has a linking study um that can predict a student's performance level based off what their RIT is so if I got this this particular RIT score in the winter it'll say if I were to take the I assessment in the spring I am predicted to get a level three or a level four on I this a projected proficiency again it's just a prediction but it's what we can use now to kind of monitor our progress so what I did is I looked at the trimester 1 grades

035um um for ELA and math for 6th through 8th grade and then I looked at the projected proficiency score from their winter map to see are we on the right track for standage based grading um so you'll see sixth grade ELA pretty well aligned here with the kids that are meeting extending with the kids that are meeting exceeding um sixth grade math is the only place where we see that a little bit different we have more students in the meeting extending than we would on the projected proficiency on I um um so we'll continue to look at that again seventh grade ELA is fairly consistent seventh grade math is fairly consistent eighth grade ELA is consistent and eth grade math is fairly consistent so just looking at this start of standard based grading it's looking

036like we're we're on the right course um making sure that our grades are valid and reliable indicators of student proficiency toward standards expectations now I'm going to yield my time and turn it over to our wonderful director nria thank you oh and then I'll take questions afterwards yay is that okay okay fantastic there's a little clicker good evening everyone I'm Nisha param the director of Early Childhood programs here je and as you can see we are truly fired up here in our Early Childhood Center this is um opening day for our staff and as you can see they are very excited to welcome our little ones back so tonight what we're going to focus on for JE is that we have four um s swp goals which we're going to focus on one of them

037tonight so of the four they Encompass seal they also Encompass mtss and they also um focus on climate and culture but for tonight's presentation we're going to look at gold a which is um by Sy y26 je ECC kindergarten alum will show a 20% increase on the beginning of the year map literacy Readiness assessment to 47% in listening comprehension and 61% in the area of picture vocabulary so as you know for JE that's a little hard for us so we're looking at our Alum students um to do that so to do that I want to begin by thanking you for purchasing cognitive Toy Box because that has been an excellent tool to help support us in our work to make sure that we are actually meeting that goal and where how we are progressing with

038towards meeting it so with that thank you again cabinet and board of education for that purchase cognitive toy box is a research Universal screener that we use to screen our students it is a five minute game-based assessment and through that um assessment it is aligned to Common Core State Standards as well as iel s standards the Illinois early development standards although in je we are still utilizing teaching strategies goal as our observational assessment to meet all grant compliances for that component this is to help support our work to to see how our little ones are doing if they are truly kindergarten ready within the universal screener um based off the recommendations the students take nine tests I know you will see 10 of there but they did assess in nine tests at the beginning of

039the year here this the cognitive toy box is less subjective and it focuses on the ability of what the children can do versus what the teachers think they can do so within those assessments the teachers um assess the children with a f- minute assessment and it gives real-time data teachers are then able to look at the students needs as well as their gains which I'm going to share shortly with you um and from that they are able to assign parents and families embedded activities to help support the students on those areas needing further concern so it's our first year doing this and the teachers are quickly adjusting to our new assessment tool and now I'm going to share with you how our little ones are doing so for the fall um sy24 3% of our

040students were meeting or exceeding actually 3% of them were exceeding age level expectations in those following areas 60% of the students were meeting age level expectations and 37% of them were below expectations in the fall so our areas of success so our growths as Donna just said our grows is that 93% of our students are meeting executive functioning skills inal development 93% of them are meeting age level vocabulary as well as 80% of them are meeting or exceeding letter sound correspondents the area of improvement is that 10% of them are needing are meeting our exceeding reading comprehension as well as 37% with quantifies and 59% of them in lore alphabet what we learned from that is that since majority of our students 93% of them are meeting executive functioning skills that is going to continue

041continue to be a monitoring goal for us and the teachers have decided if we could please um begin to assess alphabet in uppercase so we have replaced that assessment we will no longer assess executive functioning but we will now assess for alphabet lower uppercase and lower case and you will see that so our middle of the year which they just finished last week and we were able to quickly get that data thank you to Donna and her team R 3% of our students are still exceeding age level expectations now now 61% of them are meeting age level expectations and 36% of them are still below meeting expectations you will see our area of success so we're going to celebrate our two points uh from the previous checkpoint of growth with vocabulary um no growth for

042letter comprehension or letter sound correspondence but we did have nine points of grow growth in counting as well as 8% worth of growth for our lowercase um alphabet you will see now in the area of improvement although reading comprehension it was um 10% we did have an 11% growth for area of in reading comprehension in the middle of the year and 16 percentage points of growth for quantifies as well as 54% of our students are still meeting or exceeding an alphabet uppercase which it's great because our teachers they have been busy working and we wanted to make sure if we're doing all this work through our professional development is it supporting it and as you can see it is supporting it the teachers and I they have um they were intentional in stating that they

043wanted to do executive functioning which as you can see our 93% of them are meeting executive functioning skills so that professional development has helped as well as we are really focusing on higher order thinking skills to help with reading comprehension um through that work um we're having par professional training so we're not only teaching and doing professional development for our Educators we're also including our PA of Professionals in this because they are a part of our work as well and not to mention or not to forget that for reading comprehension we are also doing Champs and and we are doing intentional teaching cards with more Fidelity with our teaching strategies goal to help support reading comprehension so overall we are also doing a lot with family engagement so we don't want to just do all

044the work with academics how are we engageing our families every month we have a monthly engineering stem club that they uh the students come and their families come and enjoy themselves we have monthly music night as well as cultural heritage celebrations so in October we did our Hispanic Latin ex culture and at the end of this month in February we will do the black experience where um for all of the cultures we embody food the culture uh music dance the children perform and it's a wonderful time for families to come out and join so board you're welcome to join us as well as cabinet that's my presentation questions thank you I'm goingon to suggest we ask questions on this report first and then we can bring Donna back up rather than making you all ping

045pong sure for um would anyone like to start sure thank you for sharing again this new approach the cognitive toolbox uh one of the things I'd love to see and I've asked this before um is uh an alignment perhaps with the kids assessment which again takes place in the um uh in kindergarten so again it attracts our students and it's still it's it's a it's an approach that again it's holistic right it still carries the the the um intent of of Early Childhood which is again this holistic approach to uh measuring children right social emotional executive function cognitive all that good stuff um and really aligning it to this new uh approach to measuring which again is a holistic approach so just something to think about uh and maybe again if we can get our

046our kindergarten teachers to kind of sit down with our prek teachers and and learn from one another right I think it's always an great opportunity particularly in these transitions that you know one of the things I always I always talk about is I think where we tend to um to lose our kiddos in regards to or we lose ground in regards to academics is is transition so making sure those transitions are as smooth as possible between prek actually even starting from Early Childhood right uh from from um you know kids who are um again in neighborhood um Early Childhood programs who transitioned to maybe G G from early intervention to 0 to3 to 3 to 5 and then that transition into kindergarten and then the transitions from U Elementary to Middle midd school and then

047uh Middle School to high school like those those are places I think um as a system right we should always um uh try to be cognizant of particularly for for our most marginalized students who again I think that that is where we we tend to lose ground um but again it's exciting to see just some of the the results just on the adoption of of so so congratulations to the team and J Who again again I I have visited before I have been part of some of the cultural celebrations I encourage my colleagues to if you get a chance it's just a wonderful wonderful way that that yall are just some wonderful work that you're doing to engage families and then keep students engaged so uh I think that's at the core of how we

048continue to again see progress um I think Early Childhood again we've shown historically uh through our data that early childhood is where we we have closed uh racial achievement gaps right now the KE key is how do we sustain right so so I appreciate the team um really adopting this new tool to really C have have us have another tool in our toolbox if you will to to Really uh sustain um how we close the gap um uh opportunity Gap starting preck so so thank you thank you thank you we actually go back to the toy box data um first I want to say I was glad to see that we had gains in the kindergarten uh the K1 Span in Spanish that's great that I know that's been a area that we needed growth

049in um yes thank you but I I'm very concerned about the reading comprehension so I wanted to dig in of like is that consistent with years past is this like what's going on do we think with uh us being that far below so thank you for that question so in years past um what we have done we used to do you know we still do teaching strategies goal which is pretty much observational um and from that data we thought like based off a teacher observation that the children were truly kindergarten ready um through cognitive Toy Box being that it is techn it's on an iPad it's Technology based um it's truly getting to the core of seeing what the children know versus going off of an observation um by the teachers so with that it

050was a concern of ours too um which is why we have also been implementing with trying to implement with Fidelity um champs as well as the teaching strategies um intentional teaching cards where we intentionally ask higher order thinking questions more an more um wh questions to the students the what we are why and how and have them begin to truly explain um when we're reading in our stories um the setting what does that mean what are what are like basic character analysis and things of that nature to help see if the students truly understand um reading comprehension um and doing our research we've also know um noticed that um and thank you to our literacy team for that support when students are asked questions sometimes when they have a field of choices that they are

051looking at like oh it Lucy skates and they may see a little girl they may see a pair of skates but they may not look for the girl that's truly skating and they'll just pick the first one so we're really trying to delve deeper into that work um to help them with their reading comprehens and slow down and truly analyze what the qu listen to what's being asked of you can I ask a granular question you said this is done on an iPad is the student using the iPad to answer yes okay so is there any piece of this since this is new that we think is a technology challenge right like I want I want us to have the attention in the right spot is it that the kids are not a the reading

052comprehension is not there is it that the mechanism in which we're conducting the assessment is confusing like what's your sense we just or am I just old and all three-year-olds know how to use an iPad everything no it's very valid all very valid questions an assessment I mean I know they know how to find YouTube and they but like an assessment is but it might be also how they're absorbing information on a screen versus uh paper right cuz I also just like looking at a screen right you're just like I'm touch my screen right like not necessarily read all the options yeah exactly you don't slow down on a screen I think you're just like next absolutely and that's really um thank you Mr Hernandez for lifting that we've kind of heard that once they

053take the map assessment in kindergarten that a lot of them didn't have the academic technology yes they know how to use the iPad yes they know how to do a smartphone but to actually use the device for academic learning they didn't have that so we are wondering and we're beginning to expose them and teach them this is for acade you know it's a test let's slow down let's listen to what's being asked of us and let's take our time so I'm we're hoping that in the end of the year with the students now having um two tests that they've uh completed we're hoping that the end of the year will'll show you know a decrease in our reading comprehension as well as like I said when we're doing our uh Champs reading they are slowing

054them down and they're asking them questions and not just saying you know pick this one or what was that so we are listening to the children and hearing their responses and being more intentional in that regard so thank you yeah just to clarify I know they know how to use an iPad but there's a difference between I'm gonna just keep touching everything until I get it to work and I'm going to like consider all the different questions that I'm being asked well it's about how are you learning how to take a test really using an iPad which is different from just reading or playing with an iPad so absolutely thank you other questions I just had a question about because you uh you know to Sergio's point about um seeing previous data from early childhood

055about having closed significantly closed the opportunity Gap um for our black and brown students if you have the uh data disaggregated by race and if we could see that you know in a in a future update because I think we we saw that before um I want to make sure that the new assessment that we're using can also disaggregate by race um I know um you know for JE uh a larger percentage of students do have IEPs so if we can see that um data as well I think we it would be good to have the disaggregated data yes okay you one of the things I also want to point out with this is you know there's a lot of talk about the science of reading right and um for for a couple of decades

056we've been utilizing the Caulkins um curriculum right which turned out to be again just educational malpractice um so the we and the rest of the country and the the whole country right as a teacher I was against somebody who was trained as a teacher I I was taught Lucy ckins right um and so again we've moved away from that we're moving away uh and this is promising and then again even with with this slide that you're seeing here you know just the middle year from from the first time the kiddos took the test you know we're seeing an improvement right um but again all of these skills vocabulary letter sound correspondence again that's the phonemic and phonetic uh all of those really you know root Roots um skills that you need to learn uh and

057spe specifically for for anybody who's a dual language learner I think it it it's critical so again I agree with Sula like seeing like what that progress is aggregated by again by race and by by student group like kids who are multilingual Learners again it's going to show us that that that again if if you get to the to the core that that So-Cal science of reading right which is phic awareness phonetics uh you give those back grounds because we're going to see dividends I mean in the next couple of years and I think even this is exciting just to see just the the the improvement from the first time they took the test at the beginning of the year to the middle of the year and I'm excited about the end of the year

058is and if yeah if that yeah once once you get those results i' love to see those absolutely definitely I'd like to piggyback on that Sergio and I guess this conversation for me focuses a lot on teaching strategies gold and um the toy box and that's all that's all the assessment data so that's all the after the teaching um and I would love to know more we heard a lot in the past couple years about the the change to the science of reading and the materials in the k through2 um part of the organization and it would be great to know how this is being taught in early childhood um and how that Pairs and transitions into kindergarten right because we want that uh to be similar and we want that transition to be successful

059cuz I mean a well-prepared child will be able to take any assessment yes so I care less about what the different assessments are and how they relate to each other I care that our kids can perform but you know teaching them the tests in early childhood sounds a little counter to the Early Childhood experience that I thought we were having a je um cuz when I think about the J experience I'm still thinking about play I'm still thinking about hear stories and hearing an adult think out loud and asking children to evoke responses and practice their language and um it's an experiential process um but that what I heard was a lot more technical presentation so I'd love to know more about how do we teach reading um how do we practice reading at J

060and how do we how do we do that and hope that the data the lagging indicators that we present here will be influenced by that the last thing we want to see I think is again and I think we hear I we hear this from the community as well I know some of the community engagements that I was at you know we folks talk about just the the technology right and the uh the preponderance of it uh throughout um just learning overall right uh so really and going back to what Joey was saying in best practice right in early childhood for folks who really care about love it play is learning right uh so so we always want to keep that peace that aspect of children interacting that social emotional development that holistic approach to

061to developing a young human being into a caring adult uh with again the cognitive as well as social emotional and motor skills uh to be able to be successful um so so again it's just I I think we again we always want to balance it so I appreciate that that again you you're not just going whole all the way in with CTB with with with cognitive toy box but you still are looking at tsg which is observational and then again which is why I talk about also kids assessment which again is an observational assessment it is there's a line to be drawn there as well right um to to really kind of continue uh that holistic approach to uh child childhood learning at that at those early stages so yes and I was glad to

062hear it's a five minute assessment right so it's short it's not like kids are sitting in front of their iPads for long periods of time so I do want to Echo Joey's um point about hoping that the the actual instructional practices are still play B and you know tactile kinetic and all of that stuff that we want to see in early childhood so yeah that would be good to get more detail about that well sorry I just have like two comments the first was you know while the cognitive Toy Box data is presented for Early Childhood being able to link this to later academic performances could really provide some insights to the long-term impact of early interventions there and then um my second one was actually your last slide um right here family engagement I

063love this and I was just curious a little bit about like participation rates like music night looks like it's really popular you know are you able to share a little bit more sure yes so our um Family engagement typically we have anywhere from 30 to 50 families that will come out um cultural Hispanic uh his Heritage celebrations we have majority of them more like 70 75% of those families come out for those events so they are very well turned out events but for music night um we did a little shift in that um this year so we're really focusing on inclusion so it's more sensory focused so we're seeing a larger population of our students of our inclusion students that are coming out um and so it's not as loud and um it's more engaging

064for all children to be able to participate so families have really taken a liking to that um thank you to Dr Turner she was there um at one of our in music nights and um her name is Juliana and she was there performing and she was very engaging um and in a way to get all of the children active and they all have musical instruments that they're playing with or shakers um during that music night that are not too over you know stimulating or anything like that so it's a very welcoming environment so families have really they're really enjoying both of those events num too thank you any other questions on this part of the report thank thank you thank you Bo thank you all right Donna if you can come back and we can

065dig into the k through eight piece fire away I'll kick us off because I had a bunch of questions on this one so um okay I clearly this like the seventh and eighth grade data is rather exciting right like there's a lot of like both from the belongingness standpoint from the academic side um I think there seems to be a lot of things working there and so one question I have is whenever something's working right let's how why right like are we are we seeing data that looks you know we have we have the average of e eth grade let's say are we seeing that the numbers are actually significantly higher one of our middle schools than our other middle schools is it you know are we seeing that like okay that group of Educators

066went through uh you know culturally responsive teaching professional development or that group of Educators like I just I I think um because the je position of that 78 is looking good and younger grades are are concerning makes me want to say like can we figure out why there's something going on so positively in seventh and eth and replicate it for other grades can I just jump into just before I want to say that a lot we're seeing here is matching what's happening Statewide and nationally right so if you look at the so the nation's report card U got released uh at the end of January right that's when they test fourth and eighth graders every couple of years right just to do a check and what they're seeing is similar to what we're seeing right

067it's you know we're you're seeing growth in in in the upper grades but it's those kiddos who are in the third fourth fifth grade that actually the children of of co uh who started remote uh where where again we have a lot to particularly for black and brown kids and and working kids with special education needs and all of that I mean the gaps are just it's it's it's yeah there's a lot of work to do there so I just wanted to for to contextualize that right again we what we're seeing here is happening on a state and National level as a matter of fact I think Illinois actually performed a little bit better than than the rest of the country and certain aspects right but we're still I mean there's still gaps particularly for

068our most marginalized students that's important to note I you know I think we also want to look at our investments as a district right we've added guidance counselors we've added Avid we had academic skills centers right we have a lot of things that we we we you know we were really lagging in Middle School supports five years ago right so there's been a a very intentional effort to build a lot of these things up um in the middle school and face leaz on right like and I know we said we're starting to have have the face leaz on do more at the elementary but I'm just I'm curious if there's any Grand insights of like we're seeing these these interventions are really helping at this grade so we need to replicate them at other grades

069or or what so I think that's what is the most interesting about the cohort analysis of following students across time so that we can slightly not completely isolate those variables but we can we can know that okay at this year this was added and now we can see the the transition the change for these students being compared to themselves so I think that's really helpful and can I just add that like and we're seeing it on there's there's less students under 25th percentile there's like belongingness is higher like it's on every metric for that a bunch of exactly so I i' we have the I haven't split it out by school for the cohort analysis yet but I do think that could be an interesting um an interesting View um yeah I think that's we

070could we could certainly look at that especially like it might it might be this Co piece it might be whatever but I especially that seventh and eighth grade group because the eighth grade group last year we saw a similar yeah uh a similar jump in that eighth grade group uh in math especially so I'm wondering like okay see seventh and eighth grade again this year right and if we have Educators that are killing it like let's go talk to them say what what is working so well right um so I think if we could get absolutely if that data could be explored by school and see if there's any particular interventions or or either direct things that are being provided to students or professional development that is being experienced by the Educators that we feel

071like is adding to that um because then I am I am very concerned about our younger grades yeah I think Don this is also a good opportunity to just kind of point to program evaluation because the pilot that we're doing right now is focused on fa leaz on and counselors working with Terence working with just Plaza and so that process is kind of articulate what are your measurables what are you trying to return on long-term and short term to get to really your question of like is this investment paying off and is is it can we draw the line to a shift in practice or a shift in experience in our outcomes for kids so we can do that dive but then it's also going to be completing this program evaluation pilot and being able

072to kind of learn from that and be kind of more in the front front of these things with our programs well and Stacey since you chimed in this just made me think and we have our joint meeting next right I also want to see what happens to the data of these students when they go to the high school yeah right if if we're sending a group that has higher data than we've had in a long time that should result in that cohort in the high school having higher data than they've had in a long time so making sure that that is actually happening and and how you know what we can learn from that and I also want to call out the data dashboard that Donis team has created aligns School leaders to be able

073to go in and pull this data and really keep track and keep focusing on this data so it becomes a bigger part of their practice in terms of working with their sit teams and their leadership teams and just it's easily accessed so if you can have eyes on it you can track it better too so I think that's been a really helpful tool I also business question made me wonder in terms of looking at school data specifically if there is that Corr ation that uh between uh social emotional learning sense of belonging and academic achievement right because that's the big kind of assumption that we're saying those two are deeply connected right if you have a greater sense of belonging you learn better you know you you um engage better right so is that there

074is that that that correlation and can we you know hone in on schools right some middle schools have a greater sense of belonging or their culture is more you know healthy and stuff do do we see that in the data so I don't know if we have enough data but maybe over time that's something that we can track right yeah and I think drilling down not just beyond the school level data but I think looking at the places there are within some schools where Educators have greater relationships with kids and so how do we get that granula yeah um I think will be helpful and it will be different for us as an organization we're used to looking at it at a global high level right how do we get real granular where we can

075start really having some really authentic conversations with with with our colleagues yeah and I think that also tracks with the lower incidents of discipline right that you reported um that is a significant decrease which is great to see um again I'm curious like what does that actually reflect right um is it something about the reporting is it something about the way Educators perceive behavior is it something about their skills in deescalate right in the moment right so to be able to drill down into like what is that what is that lower incidence actually reflecting in terms of practice and relationships and culture right that's really interesting because we certainly have had way more people CPI trained in the last couple years than we did before so like is it is there Poss possibility for you

076know teacher bias or discomfort of like I used to be really concerned about this level Behavior or any of this things and now I know what to do and I I know who the right people in my building are and I have like there's a better Network and system so that I don't feel the need to kind of push on some of these lower level behaviors right like I mean it could be all of these combinations of absolutely of things that is affecting that data yeah I appreciate the hypothesis now one of my questions was really about I love that the behavior data numbers keep going down and that's level 34 five right suspensions we're talking big behaviors things that you hear things that you notice um but I also know that when we talk

077to Educators in bargaining in different times like the the plan for what we do with those level behaviors is a constant state of conversation right so I know there's a lot of work that's been done between Administration and staff to make those plans it would be really interesting for me because I don't want to assume what's happening you know the five essential survey has caring environment as one of the um areas and there's a lot of safety questions there so there's students and staff questions about how people feel Comfort wise in the environment you know it's very possible that we're just keeping kids in the building and not suspending them and people aren't any more comfortable than they were before but the numbers have gotten better right I don't think that's happening but or to

078add to that Joey it's possible that we have a couple of rock stars in the building that get sent all the kids who are in yep sorry that are disregulated and so they're not reporting because they have the tools to handle it but teachers are not feeling more equipped that's the bigger thing is like the the number of students that are being reported like we have repeat offenders versus you know kids one off you Shar that the belonging numbers decrease a little bit so like we want to see the full package going better so teacher uh competency to handle um this is one area like what do we look at to tell whether Staff feel more comfortable or more equipped or more supported right um in that teacher administrator relationship a part of that's how

079administrators respond when I ask for help um but then there's also the the numbers which you're sharing unlike out of school suspensions and the level 34 five data it be I'd be curious to see what data you pull together from that the various places where we collect Panorama um to kind of tell that story to see if we can make any sense of it yeah right because it it's hard to tell if some of the things that we're doing like hiring guidance counselors are impactful in the ways that we predict if we don't have regular measures to to check against including the qualitative ones like asking people yeah you know how has this impacted your life absolutely and I think that's that's where as Dr Beardsley said the program evaluation is really yeah helpful because

080you know right now uh Mr little and and Brian Harris and myself as well as Dr Jess Plaza are doing program evaluation for face leaon and guidance counselors and in because they are very knew we can really isolate we know exactly the kids that they have worked with either over one year two year we know exactly the amount of times that they met with them because we're like okay how are we collecting this data so we can look at progress for those particular kids and then we can look School culture you know all right oh man Terrence I'm I'm jumping into our agenda for next week sorry man this what's we're going to talk about but we we want to look at that the local students that are being supported directly and the school building

081as a whole um and are we seeing those changes are we seeing those connections and then same with counselors as well it it is it does make it a um this this a good one to start with because they are both faily new and we can really hyperfocus on the students that have been supported in that area but but I will add the the first step is program evaluation we've talked about that for a very very long time this is the first year that this department is working toward a framework and we can't just jump out there you know in in the pool and the Deep dive we have to Pilot this um very slowly and methodically as they figure out what the framework will look like once we get a hold of this framework

082this will become how we do business in this organization it's through a program evaluation kind of model really being able to assess if what we're doing how do we know it's really giving us a return on our investment cuz right now we didn't have that and we've talked about it for a very long time and so this gives us the First Step at trying to really do it and why not do it with the focus around our face leaon and our counselors because those were two new things that we really implemented during Co how how do let let's let's start there to really know know if it's working so I just want to publicly commend the the rad team and Dr beerley leadership for as much as we've been pushing through and talking about it

083this is the first year that we're actually putting it in motion and making Mak it happen and it's not an easy it's not an easy task it's a very tedious process and so I just want to publicly say thank y'all for for catching the vision getting the win and kind of getting the momentum around it yeah that's great and I I I'm really encouraged to see you all moving in that direction um and I know you're still like starting the pilot but do you have an idea for sort of how it will work long term do you think you'll like be evaluating every program every year different times time frame I'll let you talk about that Dr B yeah so we um essentially there's a draft of a full program evaluation framework um all the

084way down to the training and the tools um the pilot this year will let us know give us feedback directly on what we need to refine there the goal that we have is that we would start with kind of Key Programs but there would be three to five year goals and then annual benchmarks that people are working towards um the formal review would occur more in a 3 to five year timetable but programs that are have gone through the onboarding for program evaluation would have their own annual metrics kind of formative as opposed to summative that they're working towards and kind of reporting back in the same sense of like I'm off what change do I need to do so we set Folks up we get them through kind of phase one they've got their

085long-term goals they've got their shorter kind of formative goals and then their data collection is ongoing Year bye with a more formal review on a three to five year cycle got it and did you I want let me add a clarifying question I know you mentioned we're doing this with um tian's department and Dr Plaza's team was there any other places departments or teams that we are piloting this framework to kind of get people so tested in the water so part of our priority work this year will be to take a program from each of the cabinet members departments and get them through phase one while we do the complete cycle for these two and so it's to get essentially another four to five program evaluations started where the long-term goals and the qualitative benchmarks

086the annual benchmarks are defined so they have teed up for their data collection processes and can pull their first data ideally by the end of this year so we're on boarding in order to be able to pull more programs into the process next year and they will have already set themselves up to start that's great that's great I've got a different question question just related to some of the data we're seeing with third and fourth graders and I know that you know we don't have all of the answers but from an engagement perspective especially with uh black third and fourth graders do you have any ideas or hypotheses about what's going on there um I'm for for my perspective I'm going to say no because you know looking at the day in the fall it

087was a bit of a oh a little bit of a shock because we haven't seen I mean it's been fairly consistent across time so seeing that that kind of significant decrease it it was a it was a bit of a whoo um if you go back to your learning um go back to the the Epi ones the the learning indicators I think that's one that we'd really kind of turn to teaching and learning in the school's team to really try to discover more I don't better understand I mean interestingly enough I was having this conversation with the school leader today saying look we're seeing dips in just that specific School in fourth grade but then we know nationally fourth grade is typically a lower data year I mean year-over-year in my career fourth grade is

088a tough grade so how do we start to drill down how do we look at their de developmentally going from third to Fourth who are the teachers they have in front of them what are we doing in terms ofal supports you know do they need additional seal supports and then what are you know from there what are the academic supports they need um I think especially in fourth grade all of that is tied together and if if I understand the fac leaon is focused on fourth and fifth grade but I think fourth graders take a little bit more time that was one of the reasons to that point that was one of the reasons why Terence wanted to shift out of it just being a middle school focus to going into the elementary schools and

089you can speak on this Terence I don't want to speak on behalf of you but it was important because we saw stuff bubbling up and we wanted to make sure that the supports the checkin checkout all of those things were being put in place um for that but I'll be honest with you third and fourth grade is is bubbling up across the district in in areas so like we we got a couple of places where it's it's some hot spots um for us that we still need to really hone in um but but I will say you know that that sense of belonging and and feeling connected and having the relationships and all of those things are hugely important for for kids um after doing a a deep data dive with Mr Harris in the

090clim and um on the coaching climate team we noticed that we did see a lot of numbers at that third and fourth grade level um and like I say we wanted to still maintain that level of service at the middle school that we had done I think that's to me in my opinion my personal opinion that's why you see some of that data in the middle school cuz you're seeing three years worth of work um and three years worth of building um cold I mean Building Systems routines in that middle school and so now it's kind of some of the kids have um Tools in their toolkit to be able to adapt to those type of things so now instead of playing catchup we want to get be proactive instead of reactive we want to

091go down to some grade levels that our fac zones was able to address um and start building those twool kits and we also one of the major things that we want to do that we understood was the fact that they will be transitioning to Middle School school so we wanted them to we know that like I say it's rough at the fourth grade level but it's also rough at the sixth grade level so we wanted to make sure that we had a connection for them so when they go to sixth grade into a new school they had a person that they would have already connected with they have built some skills with them and that is also familiar with that school so that way that student would know how they would know how to work

092with that student on that individualized school because they know the strengths and the weaknesses of the administration strength and weaknesses of the school what normally happens in that student population and they know that student that is transitioning over there so I think you'll see similar data in the next two years at our fourth and fifth grade levels and this is just the beginning of that that's good to hear oh goe um I had a question about the survey the seal survey um is there a question about that asks about like students relationship with adults in the building like do you have a positive relationship with used one adult right so there's a question of um how much support uh do you get from adults in the building it could be from one adult multiple adults

093whatever um and then there's different responses that like a little bit you know some a lot an extreme amount of support I get from adults so they keep it as adults um and not just teachers so that could be a PR professional it could be a principal it could be this it could be that so it's how much support do you get from the adults in the building but I was just kind of thinking along the same lines that while there's an opportunity at middle schools for kids to slip through the cracks because they're not with the same person all day there's also more touch points right so there is you know different adults that there's a chance that one of the you know eight or nine teachers that I'm with in the day yeah

094I really Vibe with right whereas if you know in the stress of being a teacher in an elementary school is you have that whole group of kids that you're trying to build relationships with simultaneously when in shared space so um so there's ways that that cuts where it is harder in middle school but if it means that if our educators are doing it right then they should have an advantage uh as well in terms of of like how many kids are seeking that at that time and how they might have lower expectations of like right like I I'm only seeing this person for an hour so if I have a great five minute conversation with that teacher that has more meaning than I had all day with one person and I didn't have points connected

095it's interestes it's a question really I don't have an answer oh that's a good point cuz I think we do have a few places at our elementary schools um I I could think about if dolls I believe who has a semi departmental model yeah at those right but I will be honest it's a game changer but it's also it requires a mindset shift yeah yeah it's the best thing to do for kids to have that um to have multiple several things it it's a good thing for kids to have a few adults that they interface with during the day but then it also is a great opportunity for educators that I also sometimes don't think we really realize because the demands if we just go back to standards based grading standards align grade level instruction

096is not an easy task to do what we're asking Educators to do here in this district and do that across multiple content areas is a lot of work when you can hone in and I have to learn Ela and the curricular resources that our standards align and focus on my grade level standards I I get my capacity strengthened to be an an expert in that particular area and more beneficial for kids and I got more beneficial relationships with kids and I'm not trying to prepare for 20 million content areas I'm zeroing in on the content area of which is my area of expertise and I think dolls right now for us is probably the space where you saw when when Teresa came and did the presentation their data has been looking great yeah like I

097mean it works but again it's it we we got and and my hope is that shifting to a school based Staffing model will allow us to to reinvigorate high quality teaching and learning for the children in this district and so because it will give schools the ability to really be able to do that and say what is it that we need at our school level to really be able to do that so it's it's exciting when you can see places places like that who have caught on to the wave of it and can see the changes for their students cuz I mean you get great results for kids when you do so that would be a great example of like if you want to isolate and say let's look at the data at do right

098is it different than the other schools okay they are doing something different in their academic structure what do we how can we extrapolate corate that academic structure with academic indicators but also indicators right to see if there is that correlation that we want to other questions for Donna one more question so I'm really pleased to see how well um the standards based grading is aligning with um what we see on assessments um I'm wondering is that going to be I guess eventually everything is like a program that's evaluated I'm just trying to understand because I think there are multiple parts to that it seems like you know it just from this data the teachers are beginning to understand if it's lining up with the assessments I think another part of it is like the parent

099connection and do parents understand understand what those mean and I know that a lot of work has been done to sort of try to communicate that out um but I guess my question is are we getting feedback like from parents and teachers and students to try to understand like from their perspective what you know what's working what's not working what else do they need um because this is a really big change especially for middle school and I want to just make sure we're like accurately thinking about it and reflecting on it yeah and I I'll let Dr speth speak on this but I mean we know because we've had folks to come to public comment and and kind of share their thoughts on it and I will say it's new um I will say it

100is a again everything is is a mindset shift right like when when you're not used to um when when when when you're not used to kind of how it functions it it changes hard right and I think it it makes it even more harder and complicated knowing that when you leave District 65 and you go to 202 right now we we have different grading uh systems I do think an area of growth for us very transparently as a district is we we got to do more educating with with folks and and and I will say I I said this when I came into this District it's really as slow as we must and and how do we continue to keep building capacity how do we keep supporting all of the Stak cers that are involved

101in it and continue to build that knowledge base but in middle school this is our first year Rolling it out in middle school and we're in what year what year two or three with K to 5 the there' been a competency based report card in K5 for well over 10 years we realigned it to the Common Core three years ago right so again I I still don't think that we've put in enough time to bring bring all of the stakeholders along and if you ask me where's you know what's our area of growth our area of growth is in that area we we got to do better right that's that's why the resistance is and so as we think about you know and I I think this will get at with this level of reimagining

102what our district looks like moving forward and how do we deprioritize some things the things that are most important how do we go deep and have a solid plan for continuing to stay the course on that and bringing folks along until we get to a level of you know comfortability with it but I I'll be honest it's still new for us yeah I think there's aot there's a high risk in the standards based reporting Dynamic with families in that you're reporting on whether kids are at grade level along the way and then we take the I and a few months later get a report about whether our kids are at grade level and if you haven't been honest in the reporting aspect of that I might have a different expectation going into the summer than

103I met with in the in the fall when I get the report and that that creates a lot of emotion and I I guess I want to come back Dr speth you mentioned that like in fourth grade there's typically a a lag that year in terms of if you look at like National Data quite often there is a a dip in fourth grade data um devel what the the fourth grade slump it is like it's developmentally it's also just going from being a third grade some schools do have um departmentalized uh classes like da it takes kids a hot minute to just get used to that but typically there is kind of a dip and then as they get used to being just this next level of of being a stu a child yeah I

104think I think we should come back later to have that explained because I I don't think our our Fleet of fourth grade teachers would think that they're here for a dip year right they're trying to inject in the trajectory of children um so I just want to make sure that the reporting has to be accurate I think that's a real challenge for educators um it's a real challenge for parents to comprehend something that's a different system than we were used to um but I think the expectations have to be there for the organization too that right this is all about an experience that's supposed to change the trajectory of kids upward abely right um and I think it all comes back to expectations and execution and a lot of that's communication yeah and think could

105be interesting in the fall like when we get the our results in the summer and we're able to map that back to what how students perform this year on their grades we'll have a better idea of like how how good how close are we on what their expected proficiency is versus what they actually got an eye of right and I think that's an exercise the staff have to do because parents don't have the capability to do that right that's not parents don't read the two things and are like well let me you know academically break this down the staff should be able to do that but at the point at which the data comes out to parents it's late but you guys get the data a lot earlier and have the ability to kind of

106look at that in a more real time and a reflective time um to try to calibrate that going into the next year to try to get closer and closer to even right absolutely and it's almost like we would probably need to think about restructuring our we we we go back and forth with the names whether it's open house or whether it's culum night like how do we make these spaces is powerful to that point the data comes back late but it comes back we we have it in time for when those events happen how are we making that powerful for bringing parents and families along and understanding what this data says it means um yeah I think you both said something that's really important like a lot of this is about execution and communication and

107we should not underestimate given what a big change this is what it takes takes to make it go well so that everyone understands and can use it and have what they need and we just like we really need to be honest about like where we focus and making sure we have enough resources enough time enough everything to make things work well especially when we make really big changes I think to that communication piece like it it might be helpful for parents I mean I as a parent like concrete examples right so if there's a standard that the report card is measuring like what should what is an example of something my child should be able to do right so like ratios and proportions right like what is an example of a question my child should

108be able to answer about ratios and proportions right what's is what's is 2:1 equivalent to 4 to8 right like something like that I don't know um so those concrete examples of this is the learning that your kid should be should be meeting might be helpful right like at curriculum night right here's the grade level examples so at least like parents get a sense of the content a little bit because I have to say at least that my middle schooler does not bring work home and doesn't talk about what they're learning you unless I drill them and then even then right so I think those curriculum night and parent teacher conferences or like the little Windows where but I think beyond that there's an importance of empowering Educators to really understand the tool what does Power

109School provide how can they use power school this is an ongoing work that we have in within the teaching and learning Department um our Middle grades uh content directors are consistently working with and doing professional learning around what does standards-based grading look like but it's also working with them on the actual tool of power school and are they well versed in the tool are the school leaders well versed in this tool can they go in and manipulate that so from there we also have to empower students because if a student really understands what is standard phas grading how do I go into Power School how do I own my work they can then communicate that to parents and that's really an ongoing goal of all of ours is the leaders need to know how to

110work this both the tool and the understanding of the system the Educators need to be really comfortable with the tool in the system and then we have to empower kids to really be able to advocate for themselves and be able to go into power school and say Here's what I'm learning here's what I need to work on and explain it to their parents and in middle school that's something that they need to learn I think if we have that trajectory of six to eth grade we send them off to high school really well first and and engaging and being um uh owning their own learning yeah and but we also have to close some of the gaps right in middle school we proudly state that we teach four years of math in three years so

111how does that impact the standards based grading report card um because I don't think we address it like there's gaps like that that have to be addressed so that people understand you've you've tell you're telling me my kid's trajectory is impacted by programming but it's not being reported differently as a result I'm still getting sixth grade math standards on the sixth grade report card right or um those types of things I think create questions that we should be able to plan for anything else for Donna just one of the things I'd like to uh suggest you know as you think about the supports as we evaluate programs right um and we look at just going back to the academic outcome piece um I I invite the team to look at the Illinois's comprehensive literacy plan

112uh if you haven't looked at it already I may assume you do uh but I just I think it's just got it's just a really really great tool um that really kind of digs into just some of the again based research based approaches um and and again it's it's it's it's guidance it's not governance right is is is what the state says so just you know just a really great great tool if you if if the team has not seen it uh and and I know if there's a opportunity I know the State Board is also going to be embarking on a Statewide numeracy plan right so if there's a way we can get our some of our district colleagues uh as part of those um sessions that'll be helping develop that plan that'd be

113really great too so just just putting that out thank you Donna all right thank you so our next agenda item is agenda item number six a power school cyst data breach come on UPA so we know um I will provide kind of a recap of um what's been going on over the past month since we had initially shared in the beginning of January a communication out to families and staff members about the power school Cy data breach and then shared some additional information at the committee of the whole meeting on the 13th um since then I'll kind of cover three different pieces um on let's see so a communication was sent out to families um on February 4th um that communication was also stored under all current and student um current and former student digital

114records in compliance with the student online personal protection act soapa um and notably in that communication information was shared about the identity protection services that power our school is offering for two years through Experian um in order to take advantage of those Services families must opt opt in either online or by phone so that link was shared and it was also shared via the communication and um has been linked to our district website so that families are aware um families need to opt in by May 30th if they're interested in that there's no cost for that but have to call or respond to the link that's correct and then additionally in compliance with soapa as well we did list the breach information along with the Communications Department um on our District 65 website and that

115includes all um Communications that have gone out to staff and families as well as important links like that link to enroll in identity protection and then finally we did open a claim through our Insurance cyber security insurance provider through click and we've been working with our claims support specialist to share any communication that we've received from power school and then any communication that we have sent out as well for their requests wonderful are there any questions I apologize if this was asked why I ran to the restroom um if someone did not receive an email does that mean they're in the clear and their their data was not accessed so all current families should have received an email uh two emails actually one in January and one most recently on the 4th all former families

116should have received an email as well if we were able to pull their contact information so if we had an email on file for them even if they even if their data was not breached we sent them an email or not know it was an extensive breach it's every forrent think there any guarantee that anybody's data was not potentially thank you yeah so we notified all current families and all former families for which we had emails four and we uploaded the letter into the student record for all former and current students yep thank you and I think what you're saying is if you didn't get an email that's because we don't have an email on file something was not current or correct with want to say that piece to because it's important to make sure

117that we have updated current contact information and that could be you know if there is somebody that didn't receive it we do have a page on our website student online privacy and safety and as Elena shared the the communications are all hooked there under the data breach section there's a couple of families that enrolled post the breach that we did not include in the um communication um that was probably like 20 just families that had enrolled after January I don't know the date but that their student information obviously wasn't in our information system so it would have would not have been breached 27 yeah can you clarify where do we get this information off our website so off the website it is on the student online privacy and safety page um and specifically a little

118bit further down it's data breach which is the easiest way is to hit the little magnifying glass and type breach and it'll come on up it'll come up under the student online privacy and safety and then you go to data breaches and it's right there yep scroll down it's right there okay okay um has this cost us any money yet um is click a guaranteed $25,000 click so it has not cost us any money other than well we do pay ongoing fees for our cyber security Insurance um but have we paid any extra fees related to the breach not that I aware of not at this time any other questions all right thank you thank you next up is our sap 3 update which is a conversation about Early Childhood expansion and Early Head Start

119options Dr McCoy hello everyone um I am Dr sharmika McCoy and I'm here with members of the jhe ECC team both uh principal Parham along with members of the grant compliance team alexandraa wear and Katrina Jones so for our Sab 3 process we started off by really embarking on reviewing our subrecipient relationship and what our district has the capacity to do especially as we start to go into looking at expansion for 0 to5 programming along with our sdrp work the information that we've gathered does have impacts as it relates to both Financial operational and Community outcome comes the rationale for this evaluation first looking at the sustainability of what our district has the capacity to continue determining if we are able to continue to carry any inherent Risk by having a subrecipient agency under our

120grant funding for Early Childhood looking at our capacity to to sustain a subrecipient model and then also looking at the impacts um that we May face as we Embark upon our current federal mandates that are coming down from the new um Administration just last week actually the week right before that we had a major scare with the funding almost being completely paused or eradicated which would have a significant impact on our all of our grants but especially our Early Childhood Program the other part of the rational for this evaluation is looking at the what we have what we want to strengthen in our program so so this is the big part of the sa 3 work that our team will be starting next and be sending out communication to our community to participate in and

121that's streamlining our 0 to five programming going from half day to full day for our early childhood programs minimizing the racial inequities and then also continuing to align our work to the sdrp work that is taking place historical context of this partnership in 2014 d65 applied to receive Early Head Start and the funding that goes along with that through um a Federal Grant at that time iwse asked if they can be included in that Grant as a subrecipient of d65 in 2015 both us as the recipient and iwsc as the subrecipient were approved for that financial support as we are moving forward over the course of the 10year partnership um there have been issues with under enrollment on both e65s part as well as iws but specifically looking at what that impact is when we

122are working with an outside agency outside of our um District by itself and then the last component is looking at the um past Financial negotiations and how that has had an impact on our district reputation along with any legal concerns that have come up um from the subrecipient so I'm going to turn it over to principal param so the key issues leading to the decision is the grant compliance risk such as under enrollment as well as health services District 65 every time um we risk um increase with when we managing our own in-house challenges as it relates to understaff um an under enrollment but also we increase those risks when we have those with subrecipient agency and we are also as a district going undergoing our own structural deficit reduction plan the reputational and legal

123risk is that we've had um disputing of funding claims two most recent ones listed there you can see the communication challenges as well as Dr McCoy said the federal Administration threats and plans to reduce or eliminate uh Federal funding of our grants so there are three options to consider that the team we've looked at that we would like to present to you today um and after reviewing those in Partnership um the first option is to extend our agreement our subrecipient contract for another 5-year cycle um that is our annual renewal option it's same as our current model that we are currently in option two is to extend the subrecipient contract for one year we would clude that partnership at the end of school year 25 and 26 which will allow for us to develop a

124transition plan to occur for District 65 for us to complete our STP three as well as um in the midst of our school structural red um reduction plan or deficit plan and then option three is to end the subrecipient contract at the end of this school year 2425 and just conclude the partnership with iwse the next steps for all three of those options no matter which option that the board decides and on and chooses tonight we will continue to do monitoring and evaluation of our programming here through sap 3 and the sdrp we will formalize and communicate decisions to all stakeholders we will support our families and our staff um through those options and we will develop our transition plan so as a board you all have the full memo of information so at this

125time we just put together a quick highlight um but we will turn it over to you all for discussion and any questions I um I have one question so I mean obviously early childhood education is really really important and we want to do as much as we can to to support that in Evon um it does seem like there are some risks to the subrecipient model both for District 65 and overall so you know if something goes wrong with one program it could affect funding for both which means that we have two two programs that could be at risk um I guess the thing I don't understand is are there benefits or is it more likely for iwsc to get funding if we do the subrecipient model or you know is that like not impacted

126so basically could they get their own funding through a similar Grant or does it sort of hurt them um if if they're not able to use a subrecipient model I'll give the initial response but then I'm going to turn it over to our Master here Miss Katrina Jones who can give a more explicit response um yes there are more risks so when we think about the under enrollment for example sd6 5 we've had under enrollment issues of our own that we've been working to address when our subrecipient has those as well those are two pieces that then we are held accountable for if the federal government were to say that we could not if they were to take that funding away we would be responsible to take that funding from our local funds to pay

127that because we have a contract with them to cover their cost and so we are essentially responsible for what happens in that space they are able to apply for this same grant that we have um and so there are other options that they would be able to address ditto what she said there if funding opportunities are available iwse has the opportunity to apply for that funding same way as we do and I think these are oh so these are the Cent the enrollment numbers that are in the memo are from November 2024 is that right that's the most recent that was based off of the ending period of our corrective action plan and to date I think they're at about 702 76 so we're still under enrolled in both programs in District 65 and the

128subrecipient or so in December um in November our Early Head Start program in-house met full enrollment so we were at our 31 so at 100% okay um and we were still at about 70 some percent for the subrecipient agency thank you so I mean a big part of why this is being reviewed is because we're going through a structural deficit reduction planning process is that right yes but not only that we're up for fiveyear cycle renewal correct I was going to say that's the sole reason why the primary reason is because this is the end of the fiveyear cycle and so we're at the point where we need to either renew the contract and resubmit the um paperwork for the grant or we need to I to make the grant agency aware that we of

129what our plan is going to be yeah I guess globally or CommunityWide I've commented several times that I think there's a lot of places where we should all play in the sandbox together City High School lower school and other groups and this just seems like a partnership that while there are hardships um make sense I I understand possibly going from a 5-year cycle maybe to a one year at a time partnership to to work out some of the current Kinks that are happening um like early childhood education um there's no greater responsibility those kids come here right um so and we can't we can't do it alone right we don't have the capacity to take on these kids so it's not like we're take like if we're talking about expanding our program that's years away

130also um I I just would like to see us to find a way to be good partners to each other um and and make it work I get not making a fiveyear commitment if that's not advantageous to kind of mitigate some of the risks um but I think we have to be committed to to Early Childhood yeah I just want to jump on that and I agree like for me option three is not an option right we we really need to right leverage all early childood Community Partners to ensure that we as saying Joey um are are all in together as a community around how we really value Early Childhood as a strategy to close to continue closing opportunity gaps um so again again I'm I'm down for really down for option number two given

131some of the federal uh challenges that we have uh but again it gives us enough time as we embark on on on on the sap 3 process to reimagine how we deliver early childhood uh but in Partnership ship with with all of our you know you know Community Partners that that do um U Early Childhood work here in the community um again uh the again infant Welfare Society has been here for hundreds of years um they're really are in in are tougher or in the wars that have the have have experienced some of the most marginalization economically uh again we right now don't have a a plan B if we were to go to option three I mean we it's just not possible as you were saying um so I'd love for us to continue

132maintaining um that the partnership with um iwsc uh if it's right now on a year-to-year basis that makes sense to me given that again we have these Federal challenges uh where we again it'll give us enough time to kind of work through that as Community Partners but also um help us think through sap three as we reimagined early chood delivers I would just add and I both been in a lot of meetings um about this topic and so I also don't think option three is is an option um you know I think as we've been having all of our financial discussions we're we're constantly trying to Center what's good for students and families and I I um I don't think we're equipped to take over those those spots right now I don't think that that

133gives enough time for infant welfare to make whatever adjustments they need to and I think that there's a a high chance that that those families would be most impacted by that decision so um I I also so don't think we should really be consider we have to have the options right got to put everything on the table but I think that um because we are about to have a process to examine our early childhood work you know I think we need to have the time to go through that process um but I would be very concerned about what the impact of families would be if we if we were to end at the end of this year because I don't think either organization is ready to move on with that reality right now I agree

134and I did I'm sorry to mean to interrupt I did just want to clarify something between option one and option two option one is what we currently have it is a 5year cycle and every year at the end of that cycle we re-evaluate but it is a 5-year contract option two would be to continue for through the end of next year and then conclude at that time given both um d65 and iwsc an opportunity to make the necessary transitions get the necessary funding identify what number of seats we have the impact on our staffing students Etc so I did just want to clarify that from um a misstatement that I heard so I mean I think option two provides the greatest flexibility for us right without negatively impacting the families who are at in F

135welfare currently right um because the future is uncertain because we don't know where the structural reduction plan or plans to expand Early Childhood in District 65 are um it seems like option two gives us that flexibility and gives infant welfare time to prepare um but we are considering the conclusion of that partnership correct because I think what your Sergio and Joey you're not saying that necessarily but it felt like the memo was saying that it would conclude that relationship so I just want to get clarity on that well the concluding of the partnership in option two as I understand it is we're at the end of a five-year cycle so there will have to be a new one-year partnership um put together and it is d65 is still going to reapply for the Early Childhood

136Grant right correct so I think with you're probably doing that now right or getting ready to to do that so again thinking about the partnership of the sub subrecipient they haven't had to do that previously right correct they've been able to join us and that's one of the benefits so we have our deficit reduction plan going on um we're building a new school down the line there's going to be opportunities to talk about Early Childhood differently because we're going to have space in some buildings possibly and we're going to have an opportunity to reimagine with our partners like how can we do this best um that day is not today so how do we service the kids we have I think we have to maintain the model um we have but I think a year

137a year byye relationship makes sense I just I don't want to get rid of the expectation that we should work with our partners even though not all of them want to work with us and I'm not I'm like I'm not talking about the INF Welfare Society I'm talking about in general we talk about safety patrol or the crossing guards um that's my example with the city like we have to be good neighbors to each other in the same town where we take care of the same kids and I think option two gives us a chance to continue doing that and try to get better at it and maybe this is an opportunity and motivates both sides to come together and be honest about what's working not working and and find a way to smooth it

138out I think the challenge with the way we have the options right now is that part of why option two exists is that we've kind of put infant welfare in a tough spot by way by the timing of our own processes and so um a certain you know a concern for me would be that like if we decided right now we weren't moving forward for next year they don't have as much time to solve all those problems so the concern I would have about keeping we either need to decide if there's a fourth option but but like part of the logic in having the like decide now that we're concluding at the end of next year at least in this constellation um was so that we're not stringing them along for all of next year

139while we figure things out so I you know whatever that looks like I just I want to make sure we don't we have a responsibility to them so that if we are going to make a decision to go on our own that we are giving them plenty of Runway and plenty of time to to solve problems themselves right so I I just I like there might need to be another option where we say we're evaluating it each year but then we have to be really clear about when is that because the things that we would be asking them to do if they aren't our sub recipient we'll we'll take them time they can't we can't wait until next February to make that decision right well this is one of my concerns with in in our

140district we're not in a special Co-op there's things we do just here so we don't know how other places do it all the time like in especially Co-op partner districts work together and they have to give each other sometimes 18 months or two years notice before somebody can pull out because of the economic impact because of the organizational impact like maybe option four is a two-year commitment because we know when the school's going to open there's going to have to be a year of organizational change happening before we consider maybe adding something new right there's still the financial planning that has to happen so maybe there is an option for if people are open to it that gives us and infant Welfare Society some consistency for a period of time to to still reimagine or

141rethink it later without being four months out of the the deadline but that wasn't on there so you know I'd be super stressed to have to fill out that Grant application if I was infant Welfare Society because if I mean it's 277 pages I mean the grant is not 27 pages but there's lots of things associated with it um it's a lot to do and there's a reason to pull resources to do that together to maximize the dollar to maximize the services so I think I hear potentially the consideration of a fourth option and we'll bring it back to the board for to view those four options and then you all can vote at the February even though it's a joint meeting we still can somehow deal it this way I need need you we

142can still yeah we can still have some items we need all four options or can we reduce it to two two and two a I do just want to name that the Grant application for whatever we do has to be submitted in March or in April at the beginning of April so the board has to look at the Grant application information in the March meeting so I do just want to name that when we think about timeline I think we're all pretty much saying option three is is not something we want to consider because it does doesn't get enough time I mean I think we're talking about one year like option two but what that option two means is slightly different yeah I guess I'm just trying to make sense of what everybody's saying so

143would the fourth option or what whatever option we would add would that be that it's a two-year commitment with a I I would encourage us to have a commitment of when the decision is going to be made right so like if we said we were doing a two-year but that in one year it would be determined whether it was ending in two years or like because if we did if we did option two a one-year extension that means probably by September out of respect we'd need to tell infant Welfare Society if we weren't going to continue with them so that they can plan and we won't know much between now in September that we don't know today so like maybe we do a two-year commitment that's where I was thinking of what's the what is

144the I might maybe I'm supposed to know this but in terms of our early childhood expansion sat process what is the current estimate for when we would be knowing what our what when recommendations would come to the board or where or admin would be informing us as to what the next steps are on Early Childhood what's the next part of what we're going to be looking at is the shift from halfday programming to full day programming and then coming up with different options for expansion into different buildings um not knowing what it looks like for phase three of sdrp but having some different pieces put together for that so that is work that we're doing when we go into March we'll be starting the committee meetings with the goal of having those pieces ready to

145submit to the board as we go into the summer before the summer because uh there also are deadlines that have to be submitted for that um half day to full day shift so yeah I I I think you you know this isn't an easy this this is as everything it's an entanglement um it's it's it's a it's a it's a whirlwind process right and so what I do know is phase three is happening what I do know is the board has been very clear around wanting to expand Early Childhood across this District what I know is is when we lock into long-term commitments it has a financial impact on us as a district and so what I hear is we can take off essentially or or reward option two to become a 2-year you know

146extension if that's if that's what the board would like for us to provide but just want to want to kind of be clear that all of this stuff is running simultaneous and will have a huge impact in the the phase three and and and what we do know is is that we we do have spaces where like the district could expand Early Childhood in this in the district you know it it could be a consideration as part of phase three it's too early for us to really assess that right now but locking into long-term commitments won't give us the flexibility of knowing how we want to plan out what the future of this District looks like so I think I mean it essentially we could do that if if that's what I hear re rethinking

147option to to really be a two-year commitment yeah with what I think uh Biz was saying like what is the timeline for when we like yes option two reworked as a two-year agreement builds in a fork in the road where you have to decide yes we continue or no we don't whereas option one option two currently is saying this is the last year right so I think if we do have a second option it has to spell out clearly at what point we make a decision about that fork in the road well and I'm thinking option two and a two-year agreement thinking about where we are now next year we're still building a school continue status quo in year two we're going to be opening a school the first year of implementation of maybe an

148expansion probably isn't going to happen the year that we're working on opening up a new school with all the changing boundaries and everything like we should be able to a year from now if we do a two-year plan know how much longer we need to maintain the status quo before a change happens I just if I may respectfully say Clarity is kindness and what I hear is expanding for two years and then still reconsidering which way we're going to go which means our team would be continuing to navigate how we are going to either continue as we are or figure out how we will support the families and the seats that we would have with the shift in the Grant and the funding shifts that that would cause so I only bring that up because

149there is an impact one way or the other um on us as a district as well as the subrecipient in which way we go and the longer we put off we're really doing option one and if that's what we're doing that's what we're doing but if we're saying we're making a decision to be clear and to be kind then we need to actually identify what that would look like if we are reviewing at the end of option two the second year that's really continuing option one but there's a big question mark in in my in what I was trying to articulate about what happens a year from now or maybe a year and a half from now the big question mark is can we financially even afford to expand early childood you have to invest

150in that right space and um and AD all the things um and we won't know that right correct and I mean I think there's a growing need for early childhood education right so I don't see this as you know we're going to have too many slots I see it as as as as many slots as we can have you know whether it's in District or whether it's infant Welfare Society there could be a benefit to that I guess I'm more concerned about the risk to both of the programs if there are problems with one of the programs because that could put us in a situation where you know we're either having to provide funding out of our other budget or you know we're not able to maintain both programs and then that puts families in

151disadvantage because we've got funding pulled for both so I think like we should just really think through when we need to make these decisions and really think about ways that you know that that we can support and maybe that's through this model maybe there are other ways we can support but like really think about what that impact is um because there there is a risk and I think that you know on both sides we've seen some problems where maybe our funding could have been in Jeopardy and what is that do to both programs what does that do to families if we can't get that funding for both programs we can't we can't absorb the number of seats that infant Welfare Society currently serves within our current setting not currently notr to serve the families that

152need we need a subrecipient to help do that right now well no we would re we would resubmit our our grant for the number of seats that we currently have and then the funding would adjust to the seats that we currently have right now we have that they're programming at risk and they have to figure out the funding on their end right would then look at potentially the same Grant and put in for those seats for that they have or different funding agencies I also just want to highlight you mentioned this but like a lot of this is affected by federal funding and so I I think I think I'm hearing folks not necessarily looking at the option one but I just want to highlight for the community that like us taking on a 5-year

153commitment and then losing Federal funding because we just can't predict what's going to happen on the federal level would be us taking on a lot of risk and responsibility that you know even so there's there is the usual like we're not really making a lot of fiveyear decisions right now because of our structural deficit piece with an added layer of so much of this is dependent on federal funding um that us making a five-year commitment that we couldn't cover in house if we lost that money would I think is is is a challenge so it sounds to me me like nobody wants option three I don't think anybody wants option one sounds like we need to have two option twos right to clarify what those terms are and then an opportunity to look at that

154over the next week and a half or whatever and then in our meeting on the 24th vote between those two options is that what we pretty much all would go for an option like 2 B with that twoyear I think it depends on the specifics yeah and dates too because I really want to understand like not just for us but for infant Welfare Society when do they need to know decisions in order to be able to get and we have to recognize sorry that our team is our team is about to be reduced significantly so uh like we have to think about the impact not just to infant welfare but what's the impact to our staff well managing whatever it looks like moving forward as we go through budget reductions yeah so how does it

155intersect with the budgeted uction plan process as well right and I guess my question for you is for the um Grant deadlines right what are the specific things that you would need to have in place like what would you need to know um do you need to have the decision about the subrecipient in that Grant application yes we need to know which subrecipient and the service area that they will um be in oh I'm sorry so every year the cycle is from March to we have to get it to you by March so we can get it to them by April right yeah so my team and I rek working too we will have it ready for you when we come back for uh The Joint meeting we'll I think the way we do it

156is there's a separate something where you all can vote on some stuff and we'll have it we'll have it reworked with what we heard you asked for all right thank you thank you thank you our next agenda item is the School construction update no update thank you Kirby get a thumbs up for the update um agenda item uh the next agenda item is the approval of the intergovernmental agreement for road salt and brine procurement are there any questions about the letter of agreement for road salt this is the exciting part of word this is where it's at people this is the salt don't judge our salt come on now it's the service the city provides a nice service for us because it's storage and salt and so it's easy to access by trucks and supports

157our ability to keep School safe we don't want to be without salt if if it's no place over so if there is I mean if there is less need for it we get to just store it indefinitely right whatever salt we purchased that's a Stacy question do we have salt storage the the city stores the salt and then we access it okay great so I am not sure about excess which this winter is a fair question but we did price the salt and comparison to other providers and the storage plus the salt is coming in at a good price okay I would just like to to say that I didn't know until this memo that salt was $775 per pound or ton sorry I was going to say if you're playing pound I looked up

158and that's uh it's a cheap T all right so I move that the board approve the intergovernmental agreement with the city of Evon for road salt and Bryan procurement second Salem yes Sue yes haper yes Lindsey Ryan Yes Kim yes Wilkins yes Hernandez yes next up is our deficit reduction Plan update demography also the fun stuff yes it's on the all right um so thank you good I think we've moved from afternoon to evening so good evening um essentially today I want to be able to share some of what we've learned from the most recent demography study that we completed in District 65 and make the connection move your mic a little closer for me St thank you do that we want everybody to know the demography all right so the goal tonight is to

159share the most recent demography study and to make the connection with the upcoming work where we'll consider potential school closing and consolidation to give a little bit of background essentially um demography reports are completed to better understand demographic factors so will ultimately influence the enrollment levels in the district schools to determine the impact of demographic changes will have on future enrollment um couple important things to Note One the the report is linked to the memo so everybody has full access to it that's available publicly structure-wise you can see on the left that there's and we include information on the data included assumptions methodology and then largely we're going to be focusing in on the findings in the executive summary and the data tables tonight there we go we go we're going to bring these in

160so little bit of background slash overview as the board is aware but Community isn't always entirely aware this is the second demographic study that we've completed in the last really four years the initial one was completed in 2021 that was completed by Charles coffrin that is available also on our district website and that reflected our um population data and enrollment by schools for our current attendance boundaries this most recent report which was completed uh and finalized in December of 2024 um was essentially charged to be able to take a look at some of the patterns I would say mid pandemic to post pandemic around enrollment as well as to take a look at enrollments numbers for our new attendance boundaries which are board approved scheduled to go into place in 2627 all right um making

161that connection to potential school closings and consolidations essentially one of the things we've determined is that we save approximately 1.5 to2 million on operational costs if we close a school so operationally an estimate for building expenses on an annual basis is $1.5 to $2 million when we look at that money that is excluding any decisions about what we do with property should we close a school that's a separate bucket and a separate conversation all right um just reiterating that you know essentially on the left not the black lines but the colored shading are our existing K5 boundaries on the right are the boundaries once we have open Foster school which is referred to as Fifth Ward here so the left would be the coffren demography report completed in 2021 on the right is the most

162recent for some if you look at our numbers as we look at these tonight you may take a look and it says uh for instance enrollment in Kingsley being around 180 in actuality right now there's 322 that's because this will reflect the people that would be living in the current attendance boundary or the future attendance boundary excuse me all right we're going to go ahead and start by taking a look at the enrollment forecasts um this is at the district level K8 all the way on the left it's super tiny for you I apologize but it is in the memo as well on the left essentially you have our enrollment for 2019 2020 and you can see a rather steep slope that then levels out the blue reflects the forecasted data the green are actuals

163in enrollment and so when we look at the blue forecasting going out to the 2034 35 school year we continue to Trend in a downward Direction on enrollment but a more gradual slope and then in the last three years it levels out and we see a small increase back um the net decrease is 7.3% or 401 students is what is being forecasted by our demographer um and couple things to note about these Slide the left is the table the right are bullets that are directly taken from the executive summary in the demography report so I didn't want to pull his words and take them out of context they're the direct quotes or bullets from the board from the demography report couple things to note there is that he is largely attributing this decrease in enrollment

164to Growing elderly population and an increase in empty nest housing stock with a relatively no low number of housing units turning over and so specifically looking at um kind of an aging population in Evanston not moving out of houses couple now essentially now we're moving on to the next enrollment table this one captures the trends in enrollment by school 2024 29 and then 2034 now this is the one I think that trips people up because if you look and compare it to the Illinois uh school report card people are saying but that's not my school's current enrollment it is not your school's current enrollment it is the enrollment that the school would have with the future attendance boundaries so we're applying the 2627 boundaries to generate of the students what schools would they be in

165today okay so even Washington and Dewey even though their boundaries on the map grow they still are going to see a decrease so if you take a look at repeat that question Joey on the boundary map the 2027 boundary map Dewey and Washington grow they both expand East or West geographically they get larger but over time they get smaller Dy current enrollment is below 417 right now so this reflects that if we had those larger boundaries now they would have slightly larger enrollment but if we look at the for instance Dewey if we look at the enrollment forecasts over time they're exp expected to Trend downward over the next 10 years by 99.6% they have like some of the sign most significant decrease yes thank you yep um just an example to Kingsley shows as

166an enrollment of 189 um if you look at the Illinois report card right now Kingsley has an enrollment of 322 but because their attendance bound boundary shrinks they're really 189 students that live in the future boundary that would be at Kingsley today all right um again executive summary exerpts below primary factors causing the District 65 enrollment to decrease over the next 10 years is the increase in empty nest households and you'll see there's some data about median age that is Shifting in town as well as birth rates being below replacement rates in the report all right now I'm going to shift from enrollment to population so the data points that were used in the report data from the Census was pulled in as well as a variety of other places including the Illinois Department of

167Health and actual enrollments and projections that we provided from District 65 so the trick here is now we're on to a population table as opposed to an enrollment table and so to use Joey's example here Dewey's enrollment was going down by about 9% the population for Dewey goes down by 1.5% and what this is indicating is that population in the Evanston skoki District 65 School District actually goes up by a half percentage point but because it's an aging population because the median age is getting older in the school district because we have fewer School AG children and lower placement rates around fertility there are fewer schoolage children to enroll okay and so this table shows us population Trends on by each of our schools at the K5 level in comparison to the enrollment trends that

168we had on the previous table so it's important to hold that they're different and it's because of the age I do want to note like Fifth Ward shows some decrease in round enrollment but continues to show strong increases in population okay I just want to make sure I'm understanding this right so population numbers include like all of us who are not school a children yeah the other the enrollment is about kids okay so the enrollment the population of the school district itself everybody from age zero to age 100 and whatever is going to go up slightly but the enrollment in the district is slated to go down by 7.3% total 5.4% in our K5 thank you yep and we call out here on this slide some of those wise the median age of the population

169in the school district will increase from 37.2 years in 2020 to 41 in 2035 continuing you know confirming a continuation of the district's aging Trend secondly the resident the resident total fertility rate essentially is below replacement they pull out the college age and it's still at 1.64 and they say that number should be 2.1 to be at replacement rate all right um this I'm going to just briefly touch on this one this captures some of the age distributions in the different School attendance boundaries and you'll notice there's a lot of variation in the percentage of householders that are 65 plus but in some of our feeder patterns a pretty significant percentage all right now now one additional table I'm going to walk you through tonight essentially takes a comparison of school age population to school

170age enrollment and admittedly this is small it is also in the memo as well um I want to walk folks through this a little bit um if we take a look at the first and second row essentially the first and second row Capt the first row captures a child's age when the 2020 census was taken and so if if we go to the orange rectangle that is vertical that column is going to capture essentially the enrollment trends of students who were five years old when the census was taken in 2020 okay um and then the next thing I want to show you is talk to about is the second row going across captures the number of available students that are in the school district to enroll at that particular age band so if we use

171that orange vertical rectangle again the students that were five in 2020 they're in 886 available students to enroll and those students are currently in let me do our math right here they are currently enrolled and they are currently in our fourth grade all right so you can see that right under the 886 we see grade four and we see that we are enrolling 642 of the event available 886 that is an enrollment percentage of 72.5% all right so I want to call out a couple things to note here if we look at the red rectangle going horizontally the lowest percentage of students enrolled is in our current 8th grade class at 68.8% this is a group that was in third grade when the pandemic hit um and if we follow their enrollment rates down we

172see that that first year of the pandemic they were at 77.6% we lost about 10% of that cohort in the two years around the pandemic and we did not recover those students okay now one thing I want to call out about that rectangle going across also is when we take a look at the median percent of students enrolled for students in 2425 currently we're at 79.3% 79.3 % of the available students using the median are enrolled in District 65 if I compare compare that to the same data for 20121 we were at 81.7% of the students enrolled I want to call out that we have had a 3% increase over the last three school years moving up from 7 a low of 76% to 79.3% so we are trending back to the enrollment percentage of

173that we had at the 2020 21 school year and we're May so we're about halfway back we have 3.4% to go we've recovered about 3% I also want to call out that when that 68.8% cohort falls off we are trending at enrolling our kindergarten and first grade at higher levels and so we really should see an adjustment pretty close to the median that we are experiencing of that 2020 21 school year and so I think the story on this table is there's certainly some more students out there potentially to enroll but the district is recovering a pretty significant percentage of the students that we did lose in the pandemic and we're getting back closer to that number that we had right as we entered the pandemic but overall there will be fewer schoolage children over

174the next so what I want to call out and thank you Sula so the last thing that I really want to call out on this chart is if you look at the number under the 13 years column for 13y olds there are 1,56 students available to essentially enroll and now those folks those kids are they were 13 at the time of the census so they're that's their crew that are moving out all right if you follow that number to the left we go from 1,56 to 1,1 we drop into the 900s then for the the kids that were eight at the time of census we fall into and currently the kids that are in our kindergarten class there's 703 available students so students available to enroll has fallen off by 350 wow which is a

175very significant shift over a period of years and that is grounded in available students based on our population that live in the school district so the biggest driver of decreasing enrollment is the fact that there are fewer available kids to enroll and the demographer is saying it has to do with aging population and decreasing essentially decreasing fertility rates this is um very awesome sheet and good data I'm just curious do we have is it possible to see some of these percentages from like traditional like is there anywhere housed in our data that we could see this from like 10 years ago 15 years ago previous demography studies not now but is it possible to find you think or probably not I hold that request I can determine whether it's something we can generate cool not

176sure I can find it's good data to have but we took the same report and essentially shared some of the very a lot of the same data I shared with you today with the superintendent Advisory Group and they did some processing our goal here was to really kind of hear what they were extracting and felt was important ultimately to be able to turn around to feed into a process around potential school closing and consolidation and their headlines they were rather taken with that previous slide as well and so they were really noting that that percentage number is a lot more stable it's the enrollment that's not recovering the percentage of kids enrolled is recovering but the actual the but because of decreasing available students we can't get back to that number so they were holding

177that um and there another headline they generated was like I I I would summarize a little bit by don't chase who's not here let's focus on manag our current enrollment for sure um and then they gave us a series of wonderings to really kind of questions that they think are important for us to be carrying potentially into conversations around schools closing and consolidation and really began to now take this information about numbers and began to wonder about capacity of the schools and conditions of schools I mean yep with the Aging population too it seemed like part of that was less housing turnover right so and and the afford of housing for young families the demographer really just touched on the fact that um people seem to be staying in their houses longer yeah and um

178and that's compound probably a bit noted a bit about the real estate market but then also a lower than optimal number of senior housing units available in town as well yeah one I'm assuming I don't know what everyone's story is around the table but a lot of people move from the city at either to start a family or when their kids are of a certain age and if there's no housing to move to yeah we just can't get in the population that's going to use schools in the same way if there's just it's that's not available right like the availability has shifted dramatically in the last 10 years he did note that there's you know he picked up in his data I think a trend that a lot of us see is families moving in

179with that first child in the kindergarten age and so he said he noticed that there's an inflow of population that comes in with about five and six year olds that helps to offset a lower zero to four population but if um if there's an overall declining school age population that should also be reflected in neighboring districts as well right like if it's like lower fertility overall and aging or is that not this was focused solely on our the census data for this District so I stayed focused in that space all right um the other quick thing that you know as we're talking about potential inputs or thinking about conversations for school closing or consolidation is to really at some of our neighbors and so we did re refresh the chart that Serita Smith provided with

180us a few years ago and just kind of noted these are districts that have enrollments that are in our neighborhood all right and so and what we did is just pulled the number of buildings and their current building types and structures you know so some are K5 some are K2 some of k8s have different ways of going about it but it does show where we are relative to our enrollment and the number of buildings in comparison to other dist districts within the state I focused on districts of the same enrollment that were K8 structure I did not pull any k2s all right and then you're familiar with this this is the pathway that we're talking about as we move into kind of getting information for categories and criteria and modeling potential um scenarios and this

181is also engagement with Community to come to potential scenarios we did questions as we went you go back to go back to the slide I had the district on there yep I think this this slide is important specifically when we talk about building types right you'll notice that and and again as we go into phase three this will be hugely important for us to see what our what the district comparisons are in terms of if we expand Early Childhood do we shift to prek to2 schools in this District do we switch to three to five schools do we have middle schools do we have some Ka schools so this slide helps us to see what other districts our surrounding districts and what the model has for us to think about as we continue to you

182know explore more more Avenues of our data and really be able to think about what makes the most sense for us you know moving forward so just wanted to call that out yeah this is very helpful and I think it's worth noting that like there is there are other towns that have like District secession where they break off for like financial reasons and they have you know like I it is not common to have this many schools with such a range of Economics um and so I think that you know there there you might find like skoki has what five districts right to to meet the needs of's Township I mean right right so like like you know that that that having this many schools still in in relationship with each other is is not

183always what is happening everywhere right it's in there like sky 73.5 and that's like and that's like one school I mean mean yeah yeah so it's it's like yeah so yeah I think it's also useful the projections showing kind of a stabilizing at around just under 6,000 so that's helpful in planning in terms of like what's the capacity that we should be shooting for right so it sounds like it's around 6,000 the I did the presentation also links to these tables with the D to these charts with these data tables so yeah it does it's I'd have to go back and look but it's around 6,000 slight eight if you can when you're done doing what you're doing it is there's a lot of great data here thank you Stacy so as Stacy pulls up

184the slide the slide that she gave uh wasn't g to p SL in this or as you go back to whatever slide I think Omar was referring to Stacy but um the superintendent parent advisory Council was you know as we said as soon as the phase two reduction work ended we immediately started with the phase three our first stab at and we want to take the same approach is just really educating people around because as we have to make some really hard decisions having the most accurate data and understanding the platform of where we are is going to be hugely important and I think we learned that from phase two of you know and want to just make sure that we're thoughtful going forward and making sure we all operating off the same data it's

185all public and available as we make these tough decisions ahead so just really want to call that out in terms of kind of the pathway forward and in phase three of that work and Tam is doing a good job you know with our team she's the lead for us on the phase three aspects of this work because it solely entails the school closings and consolidations and has huge financial implications for us in terms of what that looks like and so they have been working extremely hard on that so just wanted to name that publicly for the board and the community as well Y and then I something you made me think of something real quick Dr Turner two and then I'll talk to the number and take whatever Omar's question is um for those one

186of the things that came up in the superintendent Advisory Group was people are like wait a minute where's King Arts so please note that this is this shows where students live so it only reflects where people live in their attendance boundaries so what you don't see here on these chart is Park rice or king art doesn't mean that they don't exist it means that the kids come out of attendance B boundaries essentially they are removed those numbers are pulled out of these the enrollment sua for you K8 so kind of holding that that's a K8 number when we look at the last couple years um 2031 is 5,421 the next year is 5,46 and then it picks up a little bit to 5,454 5,466 so really it's in those last four years we're right around

187500 400 5,430 or so so it does level out right at that point and that is K8 Omar what was your question and I kind of Dr Turner spoke to this a little bit but I obviously I think having the data as clear as possible when we're talking about consolidation but I don't know how possible it is but to have something like this if when we're looking at moving boundaries would be incredibly helpful I don't know if that's possible but like on you know on the Google Maps you can kind of play around with the boundaries it would be amazing if we could get numbers cuz like yes I mean we can look at what schools are the smallest based on this enrollment but consolidating buildings changes a lot of that right and the bound

188it's not like we're just going to put two boundaries together so just something some food for thought if that's even possible or at least we definitely have the ability to do some actual modeling with what we know of current enrollment so we're able to move the boundaries be able to see what that does to current enrollments and we're able to look at that around different groups of students as well cool great thank you so much that's awesome our next agenda item is the approval of the structural deficit reduction planning Consulting Services contract with student center Services LLC for phase three work that uh proposal was in our packet um my only question was what to go a little bit into the modeling and why or why why or why not it would be a good

189idea to go with it like why is it optional for us so the optional piece for good evening everyone um the optional piece for the modeling was simply do we charge SCS with doing that modeling uh for us or do that inhouse um I'm cap capable of doing that and saving those dollars for the district so that's why I was on there optionally and I asked SCS specifically to put that cost on there so we could see exactly what that would be okay so the recommendation is to approve it without the modeling correct make sure I was remembering correctly any other questions about the contract all right just sorry just real it's a not to exceed correct so if we don't, so it could be less beautiful well yeah we have both numbers are in

190there sounds like Tamar's already saving us money too so thank you for that great investment I move that the board approved the structural deficit reduction planning Consulting Services contract with student center services for phase three work as presented not to exceed $56,000 second Salem yes yes haper yes Lindsay Ryan Yes Kim yes Wilkins yes Hernandez yes all right uh we won't be having a call session today so um but that's so I'm going to move us with no further business I adjourn this meeting at 710 p.m. thanks everybody e e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.