001e e e good evening everybody let's see good evening everybody Welcome to our committee the whole I'm going to start us off with the roll call adila can you please do the roll call yes today is Monday January 13 2025 the time is 4:34 p.m. roll call Salem here Sue here Hil here lindsy Ryan here Tim here Wilkins here Hernandez here okay uh next item up on our agenda is the land acknowledgement we take time to acknowledge that the land we meet on is a traditional homeland of the Council of Three Fires the parami oju and Odawa this land also served as an important meeting place for Miami hunk the manaman enoa sack Fox Poria Arapaho shyen and other tribal Nations this land has long been a center for indigenous people to gather trade and
002maintain kinship times located at the intersection of several great waterways the region has become become the site of travel and prosperity we acknowledge Evon and John Evans are tied to the massacre of the Arapaho and shyan for railroads and Westward Expansion upon which John Evans developed his wealth and founded Evanston this land was viant taken under subtler colonialism through genocide and open Warfare in the region that is now Illinois and Chicago land is still home to thousands of native people who are actively struggling for sovereignty self-determination and Justice the genocidal acts of settler colonialism extended to peoples of Africa and their enslaved descendants despite Illinois eventually prohibit in slavery slavery was an accepted practice before and after statehood the vestiges of slavery remain throughout the United States and directly affect the descendants of the enslaved
003peoples rich and heterogeneous communities who help Define the African diaspora the genocidal patterns of violence against peoples of African descent and Indigenous people have been replicated to exclude and harm people from many intersecting marginalized identities in the United States religious minoritized disabled and lgbtq identified peoples black and Indigenous people of color and people of color r large these patterns demonstrate that the pursuit to end State action violence against bipac is a daily struggle for Liberation from continued social political and economic anti-black racism and oppression today we acknowledge that we are living breathing loving grieving laughing and sharing space on unseated territory may we learn to honor the historical and contemporary presence and power of the people and the belief that we must be caretakers of the lands and Waters for the livelihood of future Generations
004we encourage everyone to continue to expand their knowledge and reduce their harm through awareness of local Mutual Aid models for survival and through engagement with online and local resources such as the Chicago American Indian Community collaborative and the shorefront legacy center the next item up on our agenda is our public comments members of the public are welcome and invited to address the board during open public meetings speakers are discouraged from using the public comment period to air specific concerns about staff members being mindful that the public comment period is not a suitable form for fact finding a resolution of disputes rather we encourage members of the public who have concerns about specific District employees to follow District communication guidelines found in the student handbook please remember to state your name and that you have three
005minutes to address the board also note that it is not customary for the board to respond to public comments the best way to correspond with members of the board is by emailing Schoolboard at district 65.net and with that deal do we have any folks signed up for public comment yes we have Dr tiricia Baker Beth Brady Daniel Foster and Victoria white good afternoon Dr Turner council members members of the school board and the M community and our deck membership I'm Dr Baker currently serving as the union president for deck and here's my speech so we're over the hump or the mountain of negotiation and I want to acknowledge again the work of the members of the table team and research team to thank them again for their talent time passion and grit in getting it
006done now that that's done we jumped over right into the School Board elections and the deficit reduction plan and all the other pieces of Vis that both the union and the district have to address on a daily basis with that with with that regard and the deficit with regard to the deficit reduction planning that is still now in full swing I still find it quite fortunate that the district is in the state that it's in financially yesterday as I had opportunity to sit in and hear the individuals buying for the positions of school board uh school board members and hear the thoughts and their intentions if they get elected I listened as some refer to Evon and his former glory one of the go and one of the goals to bring Evon back from the
007abyss of where it was then to now not only financially but also instructionally and in the eyes of the community this community with students at the center always deserves the very best we as the adults can bring and to offer period as members of the community the Educators we report who report every day to their assigned buildings to serve this city let me back up as members of this community the Educators who report every day to their assigned building to serve the children of the city we too have high stakes in this process we are in a very unsettling time in the face of reductions that are coming I am here to remind Administration and future board members and the community that we are still here I'm calling again on our Educators to not sit
008on the sideline and just watch as all these actions that going on on around us educating children is a hard work and I know that every day you're working hard and doing your best on behalf of our children so I'm asking you to continue to push our Union our profession forward by getting involved and holding all stakeholders accountable to their word we will get through this we will for sure because we are Educators and that's what we do I also want to acknowledge the other unions who are here in solidarity with us and we stand with you as well thank you [Applause] my name is Beth Brady and I teach English with multilingual students at DAW and in this moment of difficult decision- making I really appreciate the commitments that I've heard from this board
009and this Administration to make the cuts to correct our structural deficit in ways that cause the least Interruption and impact on our students I'm here today to provide some context for ways in which we're currently underserving our English language Learners and my concern about the ways in which we will protect them from further reduction in service as we confront the challenges ahead of us multilingual students bring enormous assets with them to their learning as well as some specific needs English Learners at every level of proficiency require General practices to ensure points of access to content and support with academic language that's inclusive learning spaces they also require specialized instruction to extend their language skills this is time dedicated to language development goals and additionally some students and families require individualized support for the work of
010learning the culture and language of school particularly true for students new to the United States or with limited or formal Interruption prior to their enrollment our current recommenda recommended minutes of service for our department which inform Staffing allocations are based only on direct language instruction does not include time required to collaborate on linguistically supportive inclusive learning spaces which benefit all children but are required by law for English language Learners nor the time required to support the particular needs of Children and Family new to form formal education in the United States in the work to right sizee the district we often hear the word efficiency looking for ways to do more with less but I worry that this means maximizing the number of children served while minimizing the number of adults here to serve them the
011efficiency lens tends to assume how educators could and should manage their time and also our essential PA professionals time who are often the relational anchors for students who are not yet thriving in our tier one environment while ignoring the many ways in which each of these staff members is already using every single minute to absorb the impact of schedules curriculum and instruction that were not designed with every Learner in mind unstructured time to decision makers may look like inefficiency when such time is required for flexibility responsiveness and collaboration we have no unstructured time I trust that the people in decision-making seats are leading with students well-being in mind and therefore I urge you to engage in personalized school-based audits of efficiency together with a staff charged with serving students and collaborate on ways to adjust
012our new parameters uh informed by those closest to the impact that you have pledged to minimize we must insist on centering our commitment to the success of every child as we Face very real limitations in our available resources the adults in relationship with children in schools are the best situated to identify where the actual opportunities lie for greater efficiency as well as a potential impact for particular policy decisions as they play out in our learning spaces thank you Danielle Foster hello my name is Danielle Foster I'm a third grade educator at La um but I am here not only as an educator but as a parent in this district and as an advocate for the social emotional wellbeing and academic success of every child in our school Community this year I started the year with
01329 students rostered I currently have 27 in my small third grade classroom at Daws this is due to two smaller classrooms being combined into one which was approved by the board when colleagues in other schools have numbers as low as seven I feel compelled to share how this larger class classid negatively impacts our students while I am doing my absolute best for my students every day I know that I am not meeting their holistic needs for all of them I have seen an increase since covid in the number of children who struggle with anxiety and social emotional needs these unmet needs directly impact their ability to learn our historically marginalized youth such as students from low-income families black and brown students English language Learners including newcomers and students with disabilities are disproportionately harmed by large
014class sizes this compounded over time and I am routinely asked to make up two years of learning or more with third graders in a year with 20 students this is a struggle this year it feels impossible yet the expectations on my shoulders haven't changed at the same time those kids who are gifted or who are Advanced may find their talents going undernourished I feel like my classroom is been has been the guinea pig for future increased class sizes due to budget constraints the mismanagement of previous administrations should not fall on the backs of my 8 and nine-year-old students or on us as teachers as a teacher I strive to create an environment where every student feels valued and supported yet large class sizes leave me feeling stretched extremely thin the time and energy required to
015address social emotional issues differentiate instruction used culturally responsive teaching practices and provide constructive feedback are spread across so many students that receive the attention that they truly deserve it is harder to build strong teacher Rel uh teacher student relationships the kind that Foster trust confidence and a sense of belonging which are our goals at Daws for children facing social or emotional challenges or those who simply need more that lack of connection can have long-term consequences studies consistently show that um smaller class sizes lead to better academic outcomes particularly for younger students and those in underserved community communities when we invest in smaller classes we invest in equity engagement and the potential of every child I urge you to consider the significant impact of class size on the quality of our educations our students deserve better
016thank you for your time Victoria White okay then that concludes our public comments for tonight thank you uh it looks like I skipped the uh agenda item approval of the meeting agenda s Omar I moved that the board approve today's meeting agenda as presented second Salem yes Sue yes H yes lindsy Ryan Yes Kim yes Wilkins yes Hernandez yes next item up is our finance personnel and building and grounds Joey take it away so our first item is the sap 3 update followed by a foster School construction update Kirby any updates uh given the extensive review of the Foster School update and the bid group analysis we did in December and the focus of today's meeting we're going to defer on the Foster School update till the next board meeting except to say everything is
017still on schedule uh nothing to note and the budget still is the same positive status that we reported on in December uh as well the sap 3 update we have uh three sap projects up and going and moving the Foster School transition committee meets uh for the fourth time this Wednesday as we move towards uh subcommittee work uh choosing school colors planning a February Community event um and the other two St uh um sap groups uh working on Early Childhood transition and um working on Dual language placement are up and moving forward as well and we'll have a further update in Fe later in January thank you uh item C we have a technology lease memo that was in our packet today um so this was a explanation of the plan for leasing technology over
018the next uh few years life cycle Replacements things like that does anybody have any questions about it no just that I was glad to see the plan I think we had seen earlier plans uh Draft plans um and the cost savings associated with it so I was glad to see that um and also the review of various educational apps right because I think that had been also a question of are we getting our Roi how many users are there per license and all of that stuff so so I'm glad that kind of audit is now kind of part of the process so thank you for that work you I think I just want to also add you know the lease how it does reflect a significant reduction in what was presented before as Sula was
019saying um and I also appreciate one of them was uh transitioning to secure print options so we're also lessening our killing less trees and lessening our footprint there too I had a question about the auditorium upgrades is that $100,000 across all schools for common upgrades or are we targeting the middle schools what's that for um checking to see if Helena's going to come up and CH guess $100,000 doesn't go very far no it's certainly not across the board but she'll give us some information on the specific Focus um yeah for the AUD Auditorium upgrades um that is for this year AUD Auditorium upgrades were part of our 5-year technology plan um Matt zinsky who supports AV districtwide has done walkthroughs with District leaders and administrators um through November and December just to get a sense
020of what kind of Technology we have in different spaces there's currently a lot of different technology in the AV spaces due to um requests and um PTA funds being used or School funds being used to purchase different pieces so we really wanted to get a baseline of what different schools had and the $100,000 this year will really be used to um kind of fill in the gaps for needs that we have like microphones speakers that can be portable and can be brought to different spaces so um Matt has just finished that up with school leaders and we're really looking forward to filling in some of the holes that we currently have as we continue to make some hopefully larger upgrades um to spaces that really needed over the next couple of years thank you any
021other questions about the technology memo awesome thank you I'd like to move that we approve uh the technology lease for 2024 through 2027 and bring it to the next board meeting for approval second make that tonight because we have oh it's a longer the what we can do the approval tonight it was oh we can do it today all right I will amend my motion I move that the Board of Education authorize the superintendent to sign the related property schedule of the master tax exempt lease purchase agreement dated January 13 2025 and all the related documents with American Capital Financial Services Incorporated for the financing of the school district's lease of technology equipment for fiscal years 24 through 27 in an amount not to exceed $100,000 second Salem yes Sue yes kilper yes Lindsay Ryan
022Yes Kim yes Wilkins yes Hernandez yes all right thank you agend item 4D is the uh reduction plan preliminary presentation awesome thank you a do looking you make great so welcome everyone so tonight we're we're gonna kick off um our presentation and so just really want to really talk about and ground us and the focus of tonight is just really reinvesting for our future and and the focus is around the structural deficit reduction plan so if you can click to the next slide for me our time tonight what you can expect for tonight um we're going to revisit our financial Outlook we will share uh at a high level what we heard during the listen and learn sessions that we engaged in with all stakeholders during the month of December um I'm going to talk
023a little bit about uh what preserving critical Investments really means for us as a district SCS uh our consultant that have been working alongside the district to really craft the scenarios will come up and provide an aerial view of those scenarios and then we'll close out with really what our next steps are I just really want to ground Us in the why tonight around why the theme really here tonight is reinvesting for our future um really the goal is to rebuild trust and ensure physical health of our school district in both the short and the long term and so we want school we want schools where the best and brightest want to work and where every single family in this community can feel confident that their child will receive a high quality education but we
024know that you know in order to do that tonight we got to make some uh discuss some really difficult decisions that we'll have to make and yet ones that keep our students at the center and maintain a joyful learning environment for all and just want to name that this while this is not um an easy task to do we recognize that this will is is what's best for us for our future here in District 65 so I just really want to talk about and this this slide is really familiar um to the board and to the community and really want to talk about the evolution of the phases of our structural deficit reduction plan uh really want to just name here with this slide that this work really began the the misconception out is that
025this the bo the district and the board is just doing this work and honestly this work began in February of 2024 hence coming into this school year uh we engaged in Phase One immediate cuts and reductions of 6.5 million coming into this current school year so what that that phase one entailed uh we engaged in a hiring freeze we eliminated vacant positions we reduced our purchase services and then we started to develop Vel more intimately the need for a much more deeper uh structural deficit reduction framework that allowed us to really gather some information from our stakeholders the decisions that need to be made uh will discuss the scenarios tonight but essentially the board will come for approval on January 27th really will send us into phase two and really stabilizing this district and as
026I've said before the reductions really are around 13 .2 million in reductions and so again these reductions really took into consideration stakeholder engagement and decision making that we engaged in in December 20 2024 and then we will again after the scenarios that are released tonight engage in another stakeholder engagement around those things but knowing that all of the decisions coming out of phase two will go into effect effective July 1 2025 and then as we forecast ahead the work still is not done there's still additional reductions that have to be done and so as we forecast into phase three it's really around sustainability and so really within this particular phase we will really be having more conversations uh with the board and with the community around school closings and potential consolidations uh that will have
027to be done to really get this District back to a level of solvency and get us back stable as a district you clicking I think who's clicking okay okay that's okay all right I'll kick it over to Tamara you want to talk about this on Tamara thank you Dr Turner um good evening everyone so as we look at this slide on revisiting the need for Budget reductions this really ties back to Dr Turner's message earlier of reinvesting for our future so as a reminder um there's the financial performance that has happened over the years actual performance fy21 through fy2 24 and then projected performance for fy2 and FY 26 what these numbers represent are all funds except our bond and interest fund our debt service fund so you see those first two years there the
028district experienced some surpluses across those funds uh and then in FY 23 and FY 24 actual deficits occurred so that $7.9 million deficit in FY 23 8.5 million deficit in FY 24 and then our projected deficit for this budget year fy2 of just under $ 13.6 million that FY 26 project projection would be if no action were taken as far as reducing the structural deficit so we would be projected to have a 16.67 uh million dollar deficit they on the left side of that screen projected days cash on hand and what that number really represents is how many days cash the district would be able to operate if all sources of revenue more to cease we know that is uh not a realistic uh thing that would happen but it is a measure that the
029state of Illinois uses as far as to determine a District's Financial Health so we are projected to have 71 days cash on hand for fy2 uh again if nothing were to happen as far as our structural deficit reduction FY 26 we would be projected to end the year with 36 Days cash on hand which would put us into a situation where we would need to issue tax anticipation warrants or other short-term borrowing FY 27 you see uh they're negative 13 days and then FY 28 a negative 63 days on the right hand side of the screen there is projected fund balance and again that's all funds except The Debt Service fund so for FY 26 we would be at a projected $19.1 million and then FY 27 you see the the cash or the uh
030projection is negative and then further negative in fy2 so the slide really is a a picture of why we need to take uh steps towards reducing our structural deficit to maintain to stabilize the financial health of the district and then to begin uh rebuilding those fund balances as a reminder there the board policy is for uh the district to have 90 days cash on hand and so really that phase three is to address that to begin to rebuild fund balance reserves and get the district towards at that 90 days cash on hand per board policy thank you Tamara so I want to just hone in here and really you know from from that explanation she just gave it's no easy task really trying to determine the scenarios but what we tried to do with phase
031two reductions was really be cognizant around ensuring that scenarios um really include and have a minimized impact to our students a minimized impact to staff that directly support students a minimized impact to our racial inequities and really focus on the key areas identified by the administration and the approved and approved by the board and so the other the other thing we want to make sure is avoid short-term borrow borrowing which is taws and I I'll kick it to Tamara to just explain it uh what the acronym Taw means again and those related expenses uh Taw is tax anticipation warrant so it's basically taking a loan off of anticipated tax receipts thank you and so as a result of that as provided previously this would mean that $1 13.2 million in reductions need to occur as
032we go into FY 26 this upcoming school year and so I'll kick it over to Melissa who will just walk through high level uh what we heard during the state in our process for the stakeholder engagement Road show thank you Dr Turner so um as we discussed in December we really wanted to be intentional on the front end about getting stakeholder voice in terms of priorities and what we need to be considering as we make these difficult decisions so we held a series of 12 different sessions um that began in late November and um went through December before winter break um and those are a combination of inperson and ver virtual sessions and you could see below some of the groups that we had targeted so we tried to leverage as many existing spaces where
033there were already meetings that were taking place so that included um PTA Council meetings bilingual parent advisory coun IL in addition we engaged with Community leaders who represent our various IES Services um also at the start of the school year Dr Turner uh launched a parent caregiver advisory Council um so we were able to engage in two different conversations two sessions with them um as well as our students knowing that the decisions that we make ultimately impact our students so we brought this conversation to our superintendent student advisory Council um we're really pleased with the turnout overall we know that December and that time of year is just really busy for folks and so we had 270 participants across the in-person and virtual sessions and then um recognizing that it's a busy time of year
034we also offered the opportunity the same questions that we posed in person um people could fill that out electronically and we received um 209 online responses um and so there were some really key takeaways that we heard um that really resonated across both our um internal groups which we spoke with our union leaders we had conversations with staff members as well um and there were really common themes and and most importantly I would say is really around a holistic uh student learning opportunities so balancing not only academics and what happens in the classroom but people seem to be very proud and said that the district generally provided um you know strong wraparound services and thinking about various needs for students and thinking about well-being and social emotional development tied to that academic support as as
035well um additionally retaining um highquality dedicated certified student facing staff um so those are really the staff and um people that are in our schools every single day who work with students in a variety of capacities um as well as resources that support those individuals and being able to do the work that they do every day um additionally coinciding with that is the need to reduce spending on Administration and to rightsize Administration and to make decisions that um well difficult as they may be don't directly or there's not a perceived impact directly on students um so that was focused on Administration and central office reductions and then lastly this goes back to the holistic learning opportunities um people shared how much the District offers in terms of thinking about um Fine Arts programming computer science
036media Arts drama um Athletics extracurriculars so the debate and spelling be and just providing a well-rounded learning experience for students so I'm working to preserve all of those as much as possible and so in preserving the critical Investments the this is what we heard and what our response is as we develop those scenarios so what we heard was prioritize and retain talent and Educators what we wanted our response to that is we reached the foure contract with deck with highly competitive compensation package uh we heard reduced central office administration we're reimagining a top- down approach uh moving away from a top- down approach at the central office level and we did that through a reduction of if you if you can recall in Phase One reductions we reduced central office already coming into this fiscal
037year by 22 central office staff right now we're proposing an additional 21 to 26 full-time FTE central office reductions for FY 26 as part of phase 2 we heard support our most vulnerable students and so it's really important to us to maintain with the goal of enhancing our individualized education and multilingual services for our students we heard retain staff who support students mental health and social emotional needs there was no reduction to Social Work psychology mental health and therapy services that are provided for our students we heard avoid shortterm borrowing or the state taking over in order to do that we had to make really have Resolute decision making by bringing forward an aggressive plan that hits reduction targets and you'll see that in the scenarios that we'll present in a minute what we heard
038was class sizes should remain small our goal is really that class sizes will remain within the district guidelines and just so we know K2 the guidelines is 23 students 3 to 5 is 25 students 6 to 8 is 28 students and so our goal is to try to get close to those numbers but be also cognizant of the guidelines we heard ensure students have access to Arts Athletics and extracurriculars and what was important for us is maintaining Fine Arts physical education and Library Services as part of students daily schedule which includes seal computer science and Athletics we heard ensure continuance of magnet programs we will continue to offer ACC twe with dual language expansion through eighth grade we heard be thoughtful about school closures and retaining assets what we can say is going into the
039FY 26 school year there are no school closings however in school in as part of the structural deficit reduction plan in phase three which will begin February 2025 in the future there will be consideration for future school closures or consolidations and so as we go into these scenarios I just really want to ground Us in uh these five areas and so the scenarios are going to be presented at a high level one to maintain the humanization of the folks who will be impacted by that understanding the impact that it will have on the people who are who work in this District we also wanted to maintain Unity we came into this school year really focusing on the ongoing collaboration with our Union leadership and honoring our Collective bargain in agreements and so we want to
040hold true to that to that and we also you know while this work is hard it's it's really about how do we continue to Foster the joy for Learning and experience for all students and I I can tell you for someone who really pushes the J Factor this has been extremely hard to have to do so the next area that we're going to talk about in the scenarios that will be presented to you again we focus on really maintaining uh minimizing the impact of these reductions and so again this is we this is not new we presented this in December of really saying that coming up with these scenarios we took into account the the minimal impact on student staffing and the ratio uh minimizing the impact on our racial Equity as it relates to
041equity and inclusion and again really being thoughtful about how to to make sure that programs or services that support our most vulnerable populations are taken into consideration with the scenarios that we have presented so now I'll turn it over to our uh is this me this is still me I think this is still me okay not yet okay so before we go into the scenarios I want to walk through the categories that show up across all of the scenarios so as I stated before the first category cuz we heard over and over again and I want to remind the community and the board this is not our first time reducing central office and so we will we have still taken that into consideration and continue to uh have a reduction of our administrative staff we
042also have as a category purchase services so this is really around non-transportation this is really contractual Services software subscriptions training technology we've heard oh you know we've set in board meting and we've talked about how much we spend on agency cost all of those things are in uh categorized in this particular area we also have taken into consideration where reductions can really happen in transportation and so student transportation services and I want to be very clear this is focused on a reduction in our nons special education areas and so I just want to really name that that that's where we're honing in for reduction in transportation supplies we came again in phase one we reduce supplies in Phase One and so our proposal in the scenarios is to get really get around Cost Containment actions
043specifically centralizing purchasing um to minimize cost variances is an example and then a greater utilization of our purchasing cooperatives to contain uh cost and so really want to be mindful and have a system in place to do that when we look at other objects really revisiting out ofd District student placement we've heard the board really bring to us consider concerns specifically around the number of students that we outplaced and so we have presented in this reduction scenarios a reduction in in that as well we also have academic Skills Center here as as part of where the reduction so right now that is high dosage student tutoring programming that we implemented to support pandemic learning loss it was initially funded through Essa when the Essa funds ran out the board the I'm sorry the district picked
044up the cost of that in the local funds and so it's something that with other services and supports that we have uh for students this is one area that is added to the categories for reduction we also have summer learning is factored in here and so later today we will present to the board a summer learning program where we have uh there's not a complete elimination but we have reduced the number of Summer learning programs that we will offer there will be no impact or reduction of programming to support students with IEPs or our English language Learners and so I just really want to name that that although we are cutting the summer program those populations of students we serve will not be impacted classroom section reductions we also have taken this into consideration as
045part of the scenarios and so it's really around a reduction of classroom sections specifically the number of classrooms and certain grade levels of schools to get more closely aligned to our student enrollment we also looked at leveraging attrition to avoid job Cuts so retirements non renews non renewals resignations as part of this and then again as I said before really uh remaining within District size class siiz guidelines uh is really what's on the table for us as part of these scenarios and then the last is just School level nir instruction and so we were thoughtful about making sure that we are restructuring through a reduction of school level staff who do not directly delivered student instruction and really making sure that the scenarios that we have outlined align to the state of Illinois guidelines and
046more importantly they still provide Equitable support based on student need and enrollment and so all of these categories are what was taken into consideration to really develop the scenarios that we're going to present uh to you and so now I think is a time where we'll have uh Dr Harkin come up to walk us through the scenarios so good evening board and community and valued um staff members that are here tonight we really appreciate you being here one thing I want to start out by saying is we have been very thoughtful in this process and this is not a fun task for any of us to be participating in however I do believe the humanization and trying to come up with a plan that does uh really aligned with that uh slide earlier that talks
047about what's the least impact to our students how do we minimally impact our staff and how do we really look at the racial equity which is an important um impact assessment that you want us to do I have been through this process before um where that hasn't taken place uh where there's a conversation where we're riffing 400 teachers um and really I believe we tried to be very thoughtful in that process but it is not an easy task to get to 13.2 million in reductions um so I would say to you um I appreciate the approach I appreciate the thoughtfulness and unfortunately you're at a place right now that you have to make these reductions but I will tell you I think we're trying to do it in the most humane way possible uh through
048the collaborative approach that we've had with uh Dr Turner and I really applaud the board and everyone that's in this room tonight as we've approached this to try to do it in that manner and it really is important for our students and your community Comm to do that with that in mind then what's up in front of you is by staff and I know that green is hard to read so I apologize to everyone for that piece of it but we really did try to identify uh the FTE the dollar amount the areas that we uh she just uh Dr Turner just spoke about and really at the end of the day just so you know every one of these scenarios are over the $13.2 million that was intentional there's some categories on here that
049aren't going to be easy right that that we want to make sure that there is an ability to say okay if we can trim it you have that in front of you by the time we get to the next board meeting that said you still have another round of reductions so if you can take these it will mean less reductions in the next go around so again as you wrestle with this as a board to give us the direction give Dr Turner the direction ultimately we've got some ability to still uh work around these numbers to get to the 13.2 so we will go in detail there's done by four different scenarios um scenario one has a reduction of 72.5 FTE 26 of those would be central office staff uh 22 of those would be
050school level section reductions 24 A5 would be non-direct instruction seal scenario two has a reduction of 76 uh FTE it is still 26 across the board with the exception of scenario uh three of of central office staff reductions 22 section reductions and in that scenario it is 28 um non-direct instructional going back to scenario one it is a $15.2 million total scenario 2 is a $15.6 million total with 7 6 FTE scenario 3 is the one with the deepest staff Cuts it's at the $16.1 million um one of the scenarios then looks a little bit differently at central office and one of the approaches that we tried to present which is exactly what Dr Turner talked about earlier how do we shift from a topd down approach especially when we're reducing this amount of central
051office staff and really then what do we do to support our buildings but giving more a autonomy to the buildings um so this one is probably maybe a little less top down and really looks at okay how do we still provide the amount of supports to the building from central office that's what the differentiator for scenario 3 is unfortunately to get to the ability to get to the amount of staff that's the one that goes the deepest into the uh School level Cuts what I would reinforce with those is their non-direct instruction uh nonel staff positions um scenario 4 gets us back to the 26 reductions of central office staff maintains the school section reduction goes a little bit uh deeper in scenario one in scenario two with the school level non-direct instructional um gets
052us to 79 FTE reductions and about 15.5 million so those are the numbers the next slides will take you through what are the pieces that go along with the FTE Broken Out by those categories so in scenario one which has $15.2 million in reductions in 72.5 FTE 26 of those are central office 24 and a half of those are School level non-direct instruction and again 22 are section reductions in alignment with the class that we'll try to uh get to those reductions through resignations retirements and non-renewals in every one of the scenarios we have proposed to you $4.5 million of Transportation reductions that one probably is the biggest challenge because there are some impacts to what we do for kids and students in our in your school and so that piece again as we look
053at it there's 's opportunities there but it does have some impact as we move forward of what does this look like for Evanson and changing probably what we currently do for our students one thing we thought that is um something that should be on the table is removing bus AIDS except for those approved through IEPs and 504 plans it is our understanding that through covid through some of the measures you put into place um you went to bus a on all of your uh buses that is not a typical practice in the state of Illinois and most school districts so we would put on the table removing bus AIDS what we would say is depending upon how deep you go with these Cuts if you decided that there were routes that still needed bus AIDS
054due to a variety of reasons that what we do is leave that as a conversation to come back we don't want to put any uh situation where we aren't providing what we believe is the best experience for our students but what we would say is that really is a line item you should look at because that isn't typical uh we did look at consolidating bus routes uh what that means is if we have underutilized bus routes we would consolidate them and what we would do is get more efficient with our bus routes and there's some opportunities there it does provide eliminating after school uh and summer school busing and and we also are putting on the table because it's a significant dollar amount eliminating non-mandatory preschool routes um that's the one that I know is
055going to be the toughest but again as you're looking at $13.2 million we felt it was important to put everything on the table um Let me let me give a point of clarification the eliminating after and summer school services that would not impact our esy program correct so I just want to be very clear I know sometimes we'll we'll read that and create Nar that that is not eliminating our esy uh services that we provide for our students so I want to just name that we'll make sure it gets cleaned to the next presentation so yes all it was was our um additional services that we provide but it is not esy again as was discussed very articulately by Dr Turner um underutilized purchase services and contracts that's consistent it's about 1.8 million supplies reduction
056by 10% and again you've already made reductions there so there could be you know feeling some pain but I I I like the approach to how do we get more efficient with how we're purchasing things if we can do it in that manner hopefully there's no impact that we feel in the system from that reduction when we look at the 5% other objects or outplay students ultimately if we can get our kids back in our schools that is best for kids and I would be thoughtful making sure that we can provide the appropriate services for our students when we bring them back back and look at that opportunity I know we're in the process of the special education audit as well too that I think will give us some clarity on is there opportunities for
057to provide better services for our special ed students but being more cost efficient with how we do that but the expectation isn't to lessen services and again that's our Focus we really want to make sure we preserved what we do for kids and that was the directive that was given to us um we are looking at and I believe there's going to be then a presentation later about summer learning programs and just really less offerings again you're a very lucky School District that offers a lot to your community and really at the end of the day when we're trying to preserve the overall uh educational system that you provide to your students um there's a conversation around that but maintaining the programs you value and felt was important so that really isn't eliminating it's how
058do we look at the programs that are going to help you maintain what you're doing but shouldn't have a significant impact to your students and then the last thing is is the conversation about eliminating Esser funded academic skill centers that money's gone away the intention of that was really to help our students when they were in coming out of covid and so at this point with the loss of the revenue that's on the table so that's scenario one in scenario 2 um what you'll see here is there's um same central office really at the end of the day it's those Staffing areas that are there we go a little deeper into non-direct construction seal positions I believe the last slide was 25 so's about three maybe 3.5 more positions that we put on the table
059to get us to Total reductions of 15.6 million in all of the scenarios it really is with these scenario one two and four it really is focused at as we're making these central office reductions how do we reimagine what we do for our buildings and really look at a um school system that addresses student needs what I would tell you in here there's also a consideration where we would add a couple of Staff back in areas that are at that level that we would repurpose that we feel would address um our students with special needs address the needs of our our students that you know are disregulated and so therefore while it's there there's actually a resif of some of the positions to really look at what do we believe our buildings need and our
060students need um and our staff should be there to support them for that portion of it all of the other areas remain the same in in the scenarios for this scenario scenario three goes deeper into the school level non-direct instruction that's the only number that's there it it is ideally getting us to 16.1 million we thought we'd push your cheese ideally it's not what you want to do they are non-direct instruction noncl but we wanted to put that option on the table for you if you wanted to go a little bit deeper into where your buildings are don't have to do it so I'm just putting that out there but certainly what we felt was is we needed to give you an array of scenarios and that was one where we made went a little
061bit deeper not trying to hit direct instruction but looked at some positions that are non-direct instructional the last one is um 26 again a little bit reconfiguration this one actually does have an impact to um some positions that are impacting um seal um it's on the table I believe it is a priority position that would be there and again as we're being humanized we're trying to avoid those conversations of what are those specific positions until we get your direction on it but this would give you $15.5 million in reduction and 79 FTE so again each one of these scenarios is beyond the 13.2 gives you flexibility that again as an example if you decided that you did not want to make all the transportation reductions you can implement M the rest of the plan and
062take some of those reductions out to still get you to the $13.2 million I will leave it there right now to see if there's any questions no we got still got we got oh okay okay so just to recap what our next steps and walk through the process as I said before we've been engaging in stakeholder engagement feedback since December 18th uh all the way through even over the twoe winter break uh we analyzed that work and we worked with uh the consultant to determine and fine-tune proposed reductions um to be able to present the scenarios that were presented tonight for phase two um following beginning tomorrow all the way through January 23rd we will again Garner stakeholder feedback on the proposed scenarios same content um but just we want to hone in and hear
063back from the different stakeholder groups doing those those sessions our plan is January 27th that the the board has all of the information now to really determine uh which of the phase two reductions which scenario they want the district to move forward on uh immediately for the spring of 2025 uh we will provide um an update on the phase two reductions and again this will go into implementation effective July 1 2025 so really just want to talk through uh and and really wanted to just share that today in terms of where we are um with the timeline of the work that has been done around this so just as a reminder in each one of these scenarios you're anywhere between 9 million to12 million in reductions to get you to a place that you're sustainable
064and stable moving forward so um you know we had presented this timeline we adjusted it a little bit we did work with your staff I think I threw it pretty threw it together pretty quickly your team had worked on what they felt was a timeline that mirrored because you don't meet in July so it'd be hard to do some work that we had up on the uh timeline uh without you being here so again um the expectation is you do begin revisiting that you've gathered a lot of data already for school consolidations you have that data ahead of you um you would use those data points to develop Baseline models to start uh making sure you can move towards if School cons validation is the direction of this board um develop the criteria that you
065would want that would align to what is that decision making if you are going to consolidate schools um develop a tool to incorporate that criteria into the modeling and then begin the process to engage with your stakeholders about what would the criteria be if you were were going to choose uh choose to close schools what would that be because certainly there's a lot of different ways to slice and dice that um um then finalize the proposed criteria and then develop school-based data sheets using that criteria you know just at that point obviously there's a lot of work that's going on to get ready to open the next school year so uh we would probably slow down a little bit and then really re-engage back in the world uh work late July early August um really
066getting very fine-tuned what is the rationale what would be the basis for how we select what schools again if we consolidate them what comes along with it is um attendance boundary changes that would have to be looked at and be approved um so we would want to be doing some of that modeling behind it to ensure that we understand the impact to the students and making sure that we get to schools that have class sizes that can be more Equitable throughout the district because I know part of the challenge right now with School uh class sizes is the fact that you've got some pretty small schools that um makes that challenging um so certainly then if we can get that greater bandwidth of the number of students in a in one school we can avoid
067that um scenario then the plan would be in September uh present proposals to the board again I think you've got a phenomenal team that knows how to engage with your stakeholders to dissect that data to inform decisions really all of that was taken into consideration tonight I think you saw that as part of the conversation and I think that really is an important place for you to get back to which is how do you engage with your stakeholders it's not an ideal situation but if you can inform them and help them understand the why and get them to what the the ra rationale is and I really command this your your team here that held as many meetings as they did in December that's getting ready to gear up to do that again that's a
068huge time commitment but it's an important step in the process to serve your community so again go through that process you will have to hold uh school closing hearings if that is a decision for the board um certainly there'll be could be other Alternatives that are pro provided and then ultimately you'll have to approve the proposals you would want to do that no later than December so that you can plan for the implementation of school consolidations and make sure that you're helping support everybody in the process of the transition into what that will look like um and really speak to what are some of the other things that need to get done furniture and those such things um so it's there um I think you know ultimately you've got a pathway moving forward and again
069it's not over but I think you're absolutely on track to put yourself back to what you believe is best to serve the students in this district and I applaud you for making some of these hard decisions that I get I believe and strongly say I think we really tried to do it in a thoughtful way that really does minimally impact our students and I think that that's really important so now we'll open it up questions from the board I'll start um I'd like to start with Transportation if we can because that's $4.5 million in all the scenarios yep and can you go back to the scenarios please that's good fool me once shame on you fool me twice shame on me um can you help validate where that number comes from who is a part
070of determining that number um specifically are the bus companies and transportation companies in the know of these reductions and have they vetted that these reductions and price points will in fact be realized should we do some of these actions so one we hired an outside consultant who's done this work extensively um and has a lot of experience in this what was done was the actual pulling of your transportation bills that went behind developing all of these numbers was a quick turnaround so at this point yes we feel confident that the numbers are as accurate as they can be right knowing what your current enrollment is um and at this point conversations have been told that this will be coming through the system and will impact the transportation I would say at the end of the
071day you're still going to be the devil in the details right what your enrollment right everything's always a moving piece in school districts right because the students we receive is is different from this year to next year but yes it was extensively reviewing the billing um and reviewing all of the data points that go into it to come up with those numbers and we're our vendors involved in that conversation well okay yes um so they had an opportunity to say you know you can make this reduction but we're going to raise the cost elsewhere or yeah well you currently have a contract where they can't do that right so that's the piece that's good about that piece of all of it um so you know you have pricing that's currently in your contract that is
072unless they wanted to pull out right but no we've had already conversations and and really at the end of the day one of the biggest pieces of the 4.5 million is I believe it's okay I don't have it in front of me a significant amount of the AIDS right a million dollars in and the other issues you're really having a hard time finding people to fill those positions as well too I just wanted to um name that that that line item is not FTE on the district side but it is it is Staff um it is a working folks on the staff Joey can I add a tag on question there how many years do we have left in our transportation contract I think several I will defer to Doc and the reason I'm asking
073is is several years I mean we just renegotiated that contract okay good because we we have had a challenge and that there's some monopolies that run the transportation companies and we don't always get competing bids and so for us to those numbers you know we need to know that those numbers are going to be those numbers if we have a contract for y Beyond two three four years we've had those conversations and certainly will continue right at the end of the day um but rough there's definitely an opportunity 4 okay thank you we just I know when we tried to bid it out the last time we we did not we had hope to have more competition in that space Absolut and and I would say to you you know some of the things that
074previous practices that you were um adhering to impacted some of that as well too right so so I think when I think there was a change in your um uh insurance that you required for them that helped to I think at least make it better but to your point but you do have a contract that is currently in place um and again the conversations would be is how do we consolidate routes and really working with the big guy that you have thank you I got more but happy to wait yeah one one of the you know as I look at all the scenarios what I see is the you know again the all of them include a el elimination of non-mandatory preschool routes uh you know I think as an instructional strategy as we try
075to close um opportunity gaps in this District particularly for our most vulnerable students most of our preschool programs are geared towards um those marginalized student populations so again I as we you know you know as we do our process around engaging community in how we reimagine Early Childhood here right that might be one of the ones where I'm I'm I'm a kind of a let's let's take our let's take that one back or or scale that one back a bit and then maybe apply it uh as we progress in that particular process and how we reimagine U Early Childhood um simply for the fact that again again our preschool for all our prevention initiative visiting program like all all of that is geared toward Head Start that is all geared towards um you know really
076focusing on uh our most vulnerable students so again just sharing that with colleagues in the community again that that's some you know preschool for me is is whatever we can do to support it and support the families that it's that uh it engages uh I think it's it's worth the cost right um again if we at some point let's say the discussions around um the sap process come up with okay let's do neighborhood School schools and put in the neighborhood schools let's put preschool programs in neighborhood schools okay then let's proceed let's pull back around those non-mandatory preschool R because we will have a walkable School District but for now I think that's for me that's kind of where I'm that's where I stand in regards to the preschool rout can I can I ask
077a clarifying question about it are the preschool routes all preschool routes that are coming here to je are they also going to Partners it would be any preschool route that isn't required to provide transportation so it would be all routes in relationship to preschool that's outside of that one one of the other pieces that was looked at is you know with head start being in the district they're not picking up any of theirs so it would be worth a conversation as well too which is could we get you know and I don't know how i' I've typically seen Head Start outside of a school district not inside the school district and it's funding separately so it would be worthwhile to explore could we get more grant funding as too and that is in our report
078right so maybe we don't cut it but and I who knows right I don't know where that's going to go but it's with a lot of these questions we have to be able to assess impact right and so I don't I don't know that I understand like I can make an assumption that us not providing bus for preschool would then impact people's access right but we probably need to talk to the folks that use our use our preschools to say like would not having busing be make the difference for you right make sure we're like solving the right well I think there was some mention of underutilized buses right like our preschool routes also underutilized right I think that's a question and then also um what percentage of the bus savings is the preschool routes
079that's substantial right because if it's a substantial percentage of the savings I don't know that I would take it off the table immediately right I have to really think about Impact versus long-term term um you know it's over $2 million right now now right part of that has the aid right there's the AIDS piece in it as well too right so again there's a way to bring it down I mean and and again where we believe Aid should be on the buses we have that I think there's different routing considerations for that and again I I I think you keep this you could keep it on there but again how are we as long as we're getting to the 13.2 you know do you leave it on and leave that as a safety valve if
080you need it down the road but I think the problem is is if you if you if we continue to Kick the Can down the road then the problem becomes right at what point are we then back to where you've been historically and I know like this is not this is not the end of the conversation and that you know you all have already explained all of the steps that you that you're taking after this including all of the community and stakeholder engagement and I think that'll continue to be important and one of the things that I really want to understand in addition to the impact um for these scenarios especially the ones that are closer to impacting students directly is what sort of Alternatives can be considered and what sort of supports either inside
081or outside of the district are being set up to um support families and students as these changes are made um and I think the transportation um is a good example of that the early childhood educ ation are there you know you already mentioned other areas to explore I think it's going to be really important to think about those so that if we do have to make big changes um we're not just leaving families and students with no Alternatives and no options um and that kind of goes into um a question that I have about um some of the other transportation and some of the other areas as well I mean I think even something like you know elimin after summer school services for transportation you know it may be that there are no other options
082but that's something where we should explore all right does that mean the students don't get to be as engaged or the you know like what are the other options if that isn't um is no longer available um and even the goad even the um academic skills centers I think you know we've talked about this in earlier board meetings I think it's important to sort of acknowledge that with the you know with eliminating the academic skills centers we know that there was a need and there was a reason why those were put into place and that we'll continue to have needs in the future but I'd love it if you could talk a little bit about a little in more detail about how we'll be solving that need of students needing extra and additional support if
083the academic skills centers aren't there so my have I'm sorry if I can just you really want to understand is there a way to mitigate the the the potential reduction that's up there if we can communicate that back at the next time is that what you're looking for okay so understanding what the impacts are and you're doing I know a lot of community engagement to understand that better but then also how to mitigate some of those impacts thank you to jump off on the points that you brought up Maya I think with the academic skills centers I think one of the reasons that we had discussed last time in discontinuing it is that we didn't really see the ROI that we were hoping to see we had early initial good um promising data and then
084it didn't really pan out partly because of implementation right partly um because of the difficulty of keeping tutors right in those roles Etc there there were a lot of factors um but the need is still there right the the need to support students I think is Maya's point so yeah how else are we um you know thinking about or REM iming Staffing models to support students and strengthen uh mtss supports and and push in Services um and then with the transportation for summer learning too I wonder just um Maya's saying can we think about Alternatives I think one of the things we had talked about is that the halfday programs are difficult for Working Families um and if the full day programs could be you know if we had more full day programs that went
085even like an hour some of them end at 3 3:30 can we extend them to 4:30 and absorb the cost but then cut Transportation right that might make a real difference for families um picking up uh after school Etc so just things to or or have a an after school option like um after care option so that then it's easier for parents to pick up their kids um after the program so I think in exploring those Alternatives it might be like cutting transportation but then adding a little bit of expense to to make the access um easier I guess so yeah just one other thing as you're exploring um ways to sort of mitigate the impact so we can understand um and you know let me just acknowledge because I don't think we've done that
086like how hard this is and how much I appreciate the thoughtfulness and the work that you all have put into this um I know that like we're talking about numbers on a page but we're talking about much more we're talking about people here so appreciate how you've tried to humanize this process as much as possible um so just want to put that out there um but just getting back to the impacts on students and families one of the things that I'm really hoping for you to explore and I know this is in your plan but really just want to emphasize this is any sort of Partnerships and any sort of resources and ways that we might be able to fill the gaps with other Community Resources I think that's going to be really really important
087in terms of um reducing the impact that families feel I think one thing that's important can we go back a slide or two where we really I think one of the things that's really critically important right and and this is really the conversation as we go into it um go back to the even before this because I I really want to commend this group keep going I apologize keep going keep going you know yep nope that was it sorry you know I will tell you this team did a really amazing job to ensure we preserved a lot of things that I believe is the identity of Evanson and and you did challenge Dr Turner to figure out how to reduce her staff and that's going to make everyone's job a lot harder and and she
088did that um you know we don't have a proposal up there that we're impacting your vulnerable students and again I heard tonight you know your El Services right and and you know absolutely as an educator I understand you know that that need right absolutely right our kids are different they're changing but we made a commitment that we didn't impact that could you do better of course right and and really again I think it's this continuation of reimagining right as we look at the next round how do we reimagine to really look at what do our kids deserve right and is there a way for us when we can consolidate schools can we enhance and provide better Services through that um you know we really didn't touch Social Work psychology mental health and therapy services and
089I really think it's equally as important to call out what we're focusing on reducing but what did we preserve right if we go to the next slide you know class sizes yeah you know you know we can continue to beat that one up because right you we know the job is harder than ever in the classroom it is harder I I absolutely I again that wasn't an easy one for us to throw up there and please know none of it was easy to throw up there but we understand our kids are um more needing of our teachers more than ever and I really believe you know that's an area that we you know really tried to preserve and we'll try to Pres serve to minimize that impact we didn't touch Arts Athletics extracurriculars other than
090there's some incidental stuff that go along with it and Maya you rais a really good point which is how how can we still make sure our kids have access right have those things keep them engaged and want to come to school right so so you know kept our magnet programs and really are being thoughtful so you know I'm like I said it's terrible right 13.2 million is not a small number but we really tried to be honoring these things and I think you know that's a testimony to all of you and it's a testimony to Dr Turner and her staff that we could come up with something we aren't done but but those are the things I think we need to remember that we got to right and and now we have to go to
091how do we get to 13.2 do we can we go a little deeper so we can make less impact do we decide 13.2 is where you need to go but I really believe there's while this this could have been a lot worse so just want to call that out cuz I think there's a lot of really good powerful things in these two slides thank you can we go to the slide with the scenarios so I can reference it the scenario at a glance yeah the scenarios at a glance there you go um I guess I would like to see purchase Serv like I'd like to look at purchase Services non- transportation that seems a little low um you know if you add up all purchase Services it's about six something 6 million and change um
092but we spend I think our budget this year was 30 almost 31 million and at our last meeting we looked at like the budget since 2021 and our purchase Services have have almost doubled since 21 so I'm just I'm wondering if there are more opportunities there I know um like one place would be like Outsourcing temp agencies things like that fall under purchase services but I'd would like to see if we can look even harder there so we can have few cuts to staff and student facing things so um I'll stop there for now I think I do want to acknowledge as Dr Turner said you know there were cuts that were made already to Staffing when people are like cut positions these are people we're talking about that human aspect someone who's a parent
093a grandparent a guardian all of that and so looking at this it is hard seeing you know 73 to 81 people humans families are going to be impacted um I think the transportation one like Joey said I'm a little hesitant I I want to believe it um I'm also worried about like the you know the the preschool The Early Childhood um cutting that especially since that is a population that we don't we often we don't talk about that one enough I think go ahead sorry no just going through kind of like my list of things that I have in mind there but did you want to add on I was just think about what you said Maya and I think there will come a point where this community can absolutely be a great partner to
094each other the the entities there's a lot of resources here um and I think this is one of the first steps that this Board needs to take in writing are wrong right like we we have lived outside of our means as a board we have not forced that situation to correct itself um it's not cold-hearted like the these are people but we have to do this things operationally are going to change right whether that's the after school clubs and how kids get to and from whether that's early childhood whether that's the class size pinch like things have to change otherwise the entities that we want to rely on as partners will not trust us to be a partner and to use their resources well either right and I think that's one of the things that
095we have to do first when I think about the chicken or the egg like that this has to come before we reach out to a Northwestern or an eths or to um other entities in city of Evanson and say can you help us somewhere um so I I appreciate the sentiments and like we have to keep our eye on the ball and get through this hard part like the staffing agencies I completely agree Omar we need a thriving Workforce we need a place that people are like pining for their friends to come and work with them but we don't have that place right now that's a that's a trust piece so I think this is this is our burden to bear right now and hopefully that brighter day will be down the road I I
096think it's worth also I don't know that everybody watches every board meeting um that is um and that knows what all of these numbers mean um so so my understanding is that with the cuts that went happened last year and the cuts that are happening this that were proposing here that would be reducing central office by about 50% is that correct so I think that's important right like that number most people don't know how many people work in central office right so you know that I think in that slide where you say like what we've heard like that's a it's a really substantial cut um and I think it's one needs to happen um CU I think we you know I think the piece that gets lost when you talk uh historically right is that
097we did have a pandemic in the middle of all this and so um we had needs that we were have never had before um and we had students who you know had had needs that you know third graders wetting their pants like they I mean we just were we were just functioning in a way that um hasn't happened in a really long time and so as we've explained like there were Esser funds there were there was a need to add all of these things to try to stabilize everybody and now it makes sense for us to to make those those cuts I you know I think so I I just wanted people understand like when we say 26 like that's that in context that gets us to a 50% reduction personally like I think it
098would be irresponsible for us to go much further than that without seeing what life is like with 50% less Central M and stuff like I think you know um folks think they might know what the solution is but we have to see like what does that mean on the dayto day right what does that mean I have less there's more time that I have to wait for a response from HR that's more time before X Y and Z right like and so but I think a 50% reduction helps us um we make sure that that is further away from the student experience but the one thing I will say on that number for us we we Challen alled Dr Turner specifically with the number for that so that and we compared it to a like-sized
099um Elementary District and so that was so right now we feel that you're appropriate you would be appropriately staffed to be able to support your buildings effectively and and really in alignment with what's appropriate so so yeah and I appreciate that context as well is like I think lots of districts are doing it with less staff but change management we have to go through whatever adjustments we need to and I'm actually saying though right it's a big adjustment down and at this point I think we're we're hopeful and it is going to have impacts right you know I think the one thing we said consistently is you know there's an expectation from our parents of of of being able to quickly respond you know giving them what they want right answering their question whatever that's
100going to have to change with that many less staff it's going to require staff to do more work I'm not saying it's easy this this right because again expectations the service you've gotten is what is going to be the piece that's going to be the real oh this is what that meant right so so I would say people are working hard every one of them everybody up on that sheet is working really hard but it's going to feel different when they're not here I would I also want to just Susan you GRE and uh and I had a conversation pretty early on and that was one of the first questions I asked was you know I think a lot of folks myself included want to see a lot cuts at central office um and with
101the experience that you both you and Greg both have and working in districts of various sizes um and you both agree that we probably are a little top heavy right so I I I I get that we're cutting by 50% and that looks heavy but like I and as you alluded to we really should be comparing ourselves to other districts of of like size um and not just what the status quo is here because with all du respect to all the humans and the people who have these jobs like our first priority are the kids um so there's to share that I think the first rule of education for educators is if you ever catch up with your work you're probably doing it wrong because you're never cut up um and like it's going to
102it's going to be what it's going to be for at the central office um do you know contractually because I don't have the contract off top of my head how much notice do we need to give to the to the transportation companies to make a change yeah so we had notified them already that there would be potential changes coming so so that was already that that conversation was already held I believe it was in January Tamara do you remember what I know we did it in December make sure that notice I don't remember the date but yes the notice was already sent I think we had to send notice to them by I believe it was by December 31st so I sent a notice to the transportation company and they they received the notice and
103they worked with our transportation consultant as well got it um I had one other question about just procedurally um how does this work when staff are reduced right I I think there's yeah um right it's not just if you read the title who's ever in that title today necessarily right there's a process and rules can you right sure so there's collective bargaining agreements within the collective bargaining agreements there are um bumping rights so depending upon how that's established and Tiffany knows this better than I do but she I've worked closely with her right um the conversation would be depending upon seniority depending upon lure there could be depending upon the position um what might be a position we're thinking is going away may not be that person in that position because they could slot in
104somewhere else based upon your collective bargaining agreement as well as school code and we will follow all of the contracts and um make sure that we do not do anything that's illegal anth unethical or immoral thank you and they've got it really solid process as they looked at that piece of it I think also one of the things we had talked about I don't remember um which discussion or board meeting but the the idea that you know not every school building is going to get everything that everybody else does right that we are really going to look at this uh assessment in terms of resource allocation as where is the real need for students and what resources do we need to put in that building so that will look different building to building and I
105think that's also really important um for us to keep in mind and for the community to keep in mind right that if we are prioritizing what students in those buildings need it is not going to look the same yep doc Dr Turner and her team um Dr speth I think it was you right did a very extensive where what they did is looked at all different types of data points related to students student needs tenure of the principal experience of the principal all of that was taken into consideration so while see gross numbers up here that says buildings are going down by this it was developed in a thoughtful way which is how do we make sure we provide the right resources um and that's certainly in the best interest of the school so again
106we we early on with Dr Turner said are there ways for us to do these reductions that really allow us to reimagine what is an opportunity to maybe look at things differently and they did an extensive job on that piece and and I want to just leverage a criteria perod was used to do that I think the question on the table is did we just come up with this out of Osmosis we actually leveraged um a model that was developed uh with the state of Illinois to determine uh evidence-based funding and so um we were fortunate enough to have our consultant who sits part of that committee to determine that and so an example is that formula basically says if you have this if your enrollment is this many uh students then it qualifies for
107you to have these level of um positions at your school and so what we did was use that as a framework to then develop based on what our enrollment needs are here specifically tailored to District 65 coupled with the profile of every school right how many special how many uh students do we have with diverse needs at that school is this a school that has dual language is this this is this that and and we use all of those things to really be ful about really reimagining our school-based model and shifting from this idea that we have historically I like that word Biz uh used in this District of doing a model which is a one-size fits all hey if we give it to this one school everybody get it and we get it to
108the one everybody get it to what are the needs of this specific school and how are we thoughtful about uring that those needs are met with the right folks and the right makeup at that school and so essentially we refer to it as a a a school-based staffing model that we're shifting to but our goal is is to not just do this for the sake of hey we're in phase two and we need to do a plan what does long-term sustainability look like in this District moving forward as we reimagine uh what we will look like and as I said before really being thoughtful about how to shift from this very top down approach to really a more inclusive collaborative approach where we are partnering with our collective bargaining units to be thought partners with
109us in the design of what the school-based needs are to then be thoughtful about what this implementation and how is it an all Hands-On deck to really be able to do that and and I mean I can't say it enough but more than ever this shift is really going to force us to really have to be uh more collaborative partners and so just really want to name that folks asked for it so now we're giving it to you and can I just that in addition to all of the the considerations for specific populations which we absolutely need to have I'm not sure the general public is always aware that like some of that's also just numeric right we have some buildings that have 200 more students than other buildings and so for us to have
110a model where everybody gets the same three or four staff members uh doesn't make you know the the population they're serving just in numbers can be dramatically different in addition to needs so it's really about I think we've been talking about right sizing the district as a whole but really we're talking about right sizing each school um and right Staffing each school um and I think that's a you know I I look forward to seeing how that plays out in terms of a school-based staffing model um that's more intentional and then as you said more collaborative it'll be by necessity more collaborative right you know one of the things that I I I want to go back to that collaboration piece is that again there's a lot of we have several committees that meet that
111are made up of folks who are from our bargaining units as well as from you know School staff for for for our community just to clarify that so we're really going to be want to be leaning on those committees right uh around curriculum development around again again again those committees are going to take on a a new level of importance because again as we because because we're shifting from a top- down model to really school school building centered approach to education right uh meeting folks where were at right and that to me that's Equity work right that that's really be ensuring that we know what what is it that are your specific individual needs are at your school and how can we as a school district um and as barting units and as an Administration
112as an board and as Community Partners what can we do to to Really wrap around um and leverage the services that we can provide to you uh to better to best educate the students that you're serving in that specific Community uh which again goes back to having neighborhood schools right and walkable a walkable School District that is what's going to make it make the difference it's going to make it an effective and help us close uh you know opportunity gaps that we've seen historically can I just um ask about just touch briefly on the other objects I I know that that was about um reducing the number of students were out placing um and if you could go a little bit into detail about how like what are some ways that can better serve those
113students so that they don't need to be outplaced and in some plans Dr Turner about yeah I think one of the ways that we we've vacillated uh you know as a um a cabinet team is around being thoughtful around ensuring that we provide a Continuum of services I think it it also you know SE several different scenarios have come up in terms of how we could really be thoughtful about doing Special Education um different for our students and making sure that we provide the supports but I think at the at the very basic level just being thoughtful around the Continuum of services and making sure that um we have the services in District to provide to our students a little bit more broader um than what it is but I'll be very honest with you
114that that that's going to require um a mindset shift uh for us organizationally is going to require um a level of Buy in and commitment uh from everyone um and I I think throughout this entire process and I want to publicly thank uh the community uh Partners the IES uh leaders uh from case the Moran Center ccdi um meeting with them and just hearing their perspective um around ways that we can really reimagine was really really great but also was very transparent with them it comes with some historical systemic challenges in this community around how um and what our beliefs are that we we still got some some room room to grow and I'm talking internally for us as an organization around how that can look better um to better support our family so got
115some work to do looking forward to really diving into that work a little bit more in phase three um but it's it's really to be thought F about how to better support all of our students no matter what what diverse needs you have or what background you bring to the table thank you and I would imagine that it's not going to be just a straight reduction right it's going to be like okay we're not spending the money on Transportation anymore but we're going to need to make sure we have more PA professionals or more folks with uh various trainings to to ensure that that student's needs actually get met here so you know I think we've mentioned this before but as we look at some of these things to your point earlier we're going to
116cut some things from from places and go okay well that means though that we have to increase something over here to make that work it's not going to be just this line item goes and this line item goes and this line item goes because you know I think we we've said repeatedly like in terms of uh really serving our AES students there's going to need to be more money going into that area we'd like to see it not be to agencies to try to find the Staffing we'd rather it be hiring folks that can that have the training and desire to really serve our students and not not be looking at outplacement as a solution until the like it it should be like the last last last last Last Resort not um it comes up
117a little too early sometimes right and so so some of these is is not just a straight reduction they're shifts right they're by doing it this way so we're going to get rid of some stuff in central Administration but we're going to need to make sure we're probably do more professional development for some of the folks in the buildings because they're going to have some responsibilities that they they didn't have before when we're when we're focusing on more centralized autonomy in the schools right and if if we shift in that direction that's where the collaboration comes from our collective bargaining agreements um to really be thought partners with us around how we are making sure that every um stakeholder group or every adult gets the professional learning they need to better support the students that
118we serve in this district and so yeah I I think you know to to a comment that was earlier is like when we talk about efficiency let me speak for myself when I talk about efficiency um I mean that I don't think we're doing it as well as we could um that doesn't mean Financial loss always right that doesn't mean we're going to cut this job and cut this job because it will be I don't necessarily think it will be more efficient to have less people helping children right I think we just have to make sure and maybe maybe it's like they need less purchased surfaces they need more right like they need more this versus what we've been funding so I think that um I hope that the next board recognizing that many of
119us are not going to be here through that slide that you provided um is able to really wrap their head around that piece of like it's not just cutting line items but really figuring out where the needs are where the the skills of our staff are where we can make sure that that our staff for having the most positive experience possible for their careers as well as our students having the most you know that's about it's going to be about relationships it's going to be about collaboration um and then it's going to be about putting some resources in different places to be more effective not just cutting for efficiency thank you for those details thank you any other questions questions as always thank you Susan and Greg for all of your support and working alongside
120me so I appreciate that your team's done an outstanding job one of the things we said um is Dr Turner has stepped up and she's done a marvelous job this was a quick turnaround if you remember I think you approved me and us and uh either late November it's been a whirlwind we had the holidays in there and and we've gotten to a level of specificity we said we didn't want to just throw numbers on a page we wanted to make sure that what we put in front of you had the um actual details and such there everybody that's sitting here from her team has done an inordinate amount of work through her leadership so I just want to say thank you because we could not have done it without them and so you do
121have a excellent team here that's done a great job and really try to be thoughtful throughout the process so thank you my um like I said I've been in districts where it has not gone way and I and I'm really appreciative because I value public education when I sat in front of you to begin with and again these aren't fun cuts to do but I don't believe we're harming kids with what we're doing and if that's our goal post we I really believe that it it will be different it won't be what you've had but I don't think there's anything in here that harms kids and that's you know in Grant we need to do better than that but I will tell you that's if we were forced into Corner that could have been a
122process and and I really believe at the end of the day your kids are still going to have the quality education they deserve and that's what should matter yeah I appreciate that I want to publicly thank my team too because I think as I stated on that slide we've been at this since February 2024 so it was easy it was it was good that we could give you a quick turnaround because we've been working behind the scenes all the time on this so when it was time to produce the information we were ready to go and so again I just want to publicly thank the folks who sit up here because this is not an easy task and even some of the folks that sit in the audience in terms of things that we've just
123asked for them they've been able to generate for rest and produce so again thank you for that acknowledgement y problem for the January 27th board meeting you're going to ask us to vote yeah I not sure how had a discussion about for scenarios yes but we haven't had like a leaning or anything like are you going to is there going to be more specificity how are we going to narrow this down to a recommendation or is that going to be the next course of discussion that we'll have on on the 27th yeah so I'm going to ask Dr Turner how do you how would you like since this is your board that um do we want to get back to them on what that process I mean what we could do is it is very
124easy for me to model changes to pieces of this there's data that that sits behind so it's very easy to say okay tell me which one do you want to start out with the bottom of it it says 13.2 and we can start playing with it assuming we're good with these categories and I think I heard some things in here that we could still look at maybe a little bit more and see if there's something that's there I think from there then if if if if we're still aiming for a 13.2 we could do that live I will not be here I i' a year ago I planned a vacation during this time that was not expecting to have this job uh Greg can be here that was the plan I can be online and
125it may actually be easier that way U but we could certainly go through which is okay hey let's think about this cut um and Dr Sher maybe you and I can talk through what the best approach for something like that might look like because obviously want to do this right the discussion in front of your community is what is important right and so I think that's the next piece is that again we we we do have a couple of community engagement sessions that are coming up this week so as a board member I think we're going to want to wait for that so then that we want want them to weigh in as well as we continue on this process so I think by the 27th again we'll have a much better idea in regards
126to what the community how they respond to these different scen scenarios that have been presented to us I mean I think the challenge is that we can't have public Personnel discussions in detail right because I want to respect everyone's privacy and this is sensitive information um and I think the in in the specific scenarios and trying to distinguish among them um I think the feedback that would be helpful for me um too is if we are moving to school-based Staffing models hearing from school-based staff and those who will be managing that work of the different remodeled right scenarios um their input right about what what would what they would need support on right what supports are effective what supports are um you know they see as best for students in their building I think that
127kind of qualitative feedback I think would be helpful and trying to distinguish among the different um scenarios yeah I think that would be helpful and then Al also I know we had some questions tonight where I'm hoping to get more information and I think part of that will come from the community engagement but just really you know we might not have the full answers but really understanding what the impact will be on community members and ideas that we might have or people might have for mitigating um some of the impacts of those I'd like to see that as much as possible as well just oh just to add a layer to that so for me when I when I hear he impacts and this is what is hard about not being able to talk about
128specific roles right is but being able to say like this work in scenario three this work wouldn't have a home so we would have to figure out yeah where like I think if we could find a way and we may not always be able to do it with privacy concerns but like I I want to be able to understand you know impact is Broad right so saying like Okay if we made these changes and I want our our staff to understand right like if they're like well let's cut all of this from this right then saying okay but that means in this scenario these four things are going to have to get covered really differently right um I I don't know exactly the right way to do that but I think if we could if
129we could not talk about impacts in a in a workflow kind of way right like what kind of content isn't potentially covered in that scenario um because I I you know I I we have varying levels of knowledge uh of what the granular jobs are of everybody in a building so thinking about areas of work so so so it's I think for me when you when you when you start talking about areas of work you still compromise the Integrity of Staffing I I just I don't feel it does not feel good to me to to to to to do that I I think what what I've said in full transparency to um meeting with collective bargaining um leaders I would respect the humanization of that and so to do that and again this is phase
130two we we didn't do that in Phase One of a public you know broad discussion about that right like what we did commit to is when all the decisions everything were made we came back in July and we we showed what positions no longer exist for this organization after it had already been communicated to the people that was impacted after it right so like for me I just have to my the the humanization part of me just won't I can't get past that um yeah I don't know if there's a way to be vague enough where it's not yeah I mean because honestly just having office up there is is still a l it's a lot and I I I took a risk with with with just putting that that up there and so to
131to go beyond that so okay so then um back to your slide that had like what we heard and what our responses are if we're able to lean into um what people are afraid of and being able to answer have a response to right like so what are we afraid of in in this scenario what are we afraid of in that and then being able to respond of how how we need to not be afraid of that thing or how yep that's going to change or like and again I I am not and I think I think there's a combination on that one it's what is the impact right how are we mitigating the impact right so I think right what is the consequence of mitigation that's why I said I'm adding a layer but
132I I I think the the fear piece is important right I think for folks to understand whatever scenario we select we we need to understand what what folks are afraid of um and and determine whether and I would say you know fear and we shouldn't do it or the piece I'm going to say it's is I love people that are passionate about education right because at the end of the day we could talk ourselves out of everything that's up there right and that consequence is the people that are making decisions aren't you right about your finances so so what I would gently push back on it is very easy to talk ourselves out of everything that's up there right and that and that's that's the reality that that isn't an option yeah I want to
133be clear I'm not I know that we have to do the cuts okay I think for us to try to decide scenario versus scenario I'm still struggling to know exactly what to to determine which one is the the better scenario so it's not that I'm like no we can't do that like but like I think we're at the edges we're at the details that's why I want to understand understand that information and you know you told us we did have some wiggle room in some of those numbers so it's like deciding between the scenarios and figuring out if there are things that make sense to shave off but I think we all agree that we're going to have to make some big cuts so like for for example what we might some of us might
134be like okay the transportation AIDS cut that that's a good idea and then some of us might be like but like preschool babies with no AIDS right like there might be some hesitation based on population that we need to talk through and say okay we are comfortable with that as kind of a default setting but there's going to be some places where we still think that's necessary and I know we talked about it in terms of so so if we can go back to the slide with all the numbers on it I think the piece that we can do is talk about what the support model looks like and what the impact is for that because right at the end of the day it's the Top Line the next two lines are the only things
135that are changing and understanding what is kind of that overall what is it what where is it impacting trying to avoid right trying to still be human with that we could talk about that and I think if we grounded ourselves there first then after that right that's that's you know depending upon which one and we're in agreement that we're moving forward with those three in scenario 3 four five right what's that number right and here's you know then from there then are we good with it maybe the last one you go to to is the transportation one or there's some approach to it that says okay with this we put this in there we put this in there because or we prioritize it you know I think there's a different way of of of of
136approaching it but and maybe it's let's prioritize right and how do we get to 13.2 because again you know just looking at one it's 3.1 plus 2.3 6. four right 6.4 plus 1.9 right I mean there's a good portion of it right so I think there's a way right because at the end of the day it will be math right and so how do we but but right it has this whole human component behind it so I think you know you know Dr Turner you and I could probably talk about what is the best approach to kind of really getting us after we get the feedback because I think you the feedback may you know give us a lot of information at that point as well too once you have your engagement sessions yeah I
137do think like in your engagement sessions especially um with you know families communities like there are things that will impact them that they'll be able to weigh in more than other things just because not everybody works in a school district and understands how central office or how other things operate so I do like expect that you would get like the most feedback on those things that families actually understand and actually impact them like Transportation um where you know people can um tell you what their EXP experiences are and what will work with for them and what the impacts would be on them yeah they don't know who the people are that are delivering it but they know the service that they have right and I believe there's conversations with staff as well too so right
138so you'll get that feedback as part of these so I think that's a piece that needs to be layered in there as well because they know firsthand how some of these things could potentially impact them as well I think our desire to ask for more information is because all of us recognize that there's real people behind these numbers and we want to I'm sorry that all of us realize that there are real people behind these numbers and we're trying to make sure that we are the best stewards possible of this decision that none of us want to make right we we absolutely expect you to so y we have mitigated some of that by the reality that we don't have to do the reductions in force technically until late March maybe even early April right
139and we're choosing to do it earlier so that people can find out earlier and have a chance to land on their feet right in preparation for the next school year right so I think we've build some of that by accelerating the process into the plan and this isn't the things you got on the board for right so so your questions are not taken in any way that it's because you care about kids you care about your community you care about your District right so so absolutely and so mine is is just making sure we go on record which is you guys have you all have very tough dis decisions in front of you that you didn't get on the board to do and we're trying to help support you and absolutely all of those questions
140are very very important and we'll do our best to make sure I'm assuming somebody did it really I tried to take notes as we went along so all right thank you appreciate it um our next agenda item is 4E which is the approval of the municipal adviser PMA Securities contract Soo uh there's a memo and then we actually have um the representative from PMA Securities who is on virtually he's actually um not able to be on site tonight so he does have a presentation what I wanted him to do was to go through exactly what this debt issuance is going to be the reason why we are um hiring a new Municipal advisor at this time is so we can have someone in place to help us uh to issue the outstanding the remaining authority
141of Debt Service extension based bonding Authority that was approved in September of 2023 so uh Bob Lewis is the senior vice president of um senior vice president and managing director of PMA Securities and PMA Securities is the firm that I'm recommending that the board approve as Municipal advisor um so Mr Lewis if you can hear me we are ready to go with your present and then when he's done with that presentation we can move forward with the um recommended approval a de Shar a copy of it and Tamara we do have a deadline that we are working against too right correct that's correct um the we need to in order to issue that bonding Authority and get it on the 2024 Levy that Bond sale has to occur yes we can hear you uh that
142Bond sale has to occur by February 28th uh so that is the other time constraint that we have okay and we can hear you Bob uh so go ahead and you have you're sharing your screen right so you can share the presentation as well great Tamara just introduced you and you have the sharing ability can you see my screen yes yes we can see your screen okay and everybody can hear me fine yes we can hear you okay terrific thank you well uh my presentation today we want to review the district's outstanding debt review a couple couple of Concepts first then talk about some ref financing opportunities and then lastly conclude with some new money scenari that interact with those refunding opportunities to begin with one concept we want to review is this the Deb
143service sucession base which comes out of the tax cap law uh it's equal to whatever the district was leving for its nonreferent debt service in 1994 that was $4.8 million and that has increased by the Consumer Price Index ever since then and now stands at just below 6.9 million so the intent of the Deb Source extension basis part of tax was part of tax cap law was to limit schools districts community colleges their ability to borrow on a non-refund basis and graphically your debt extension Bas is reflected by the solid red line here which again limits your annual payment to how much you can Levy to pay on your nonreferent debt service and the dash line represents what that could be over time if that constraint were to increase by 2% so you can see
144that your current payments are below the red line for a few years and then some future payments are anticipated to be below the line as it continues to increased by CPI now this the current Lev year Lev year 23 which is reflected here in this slightly different blue shading is for taxes collected in 2024 and your the payment in that year is higher than it was currently scheduled to be for L year 24 for taxes collected in 25 uh this decline in the payment the from the red line down to the Blue Bar represents about $21 of a tax impact for immediate home within your District which is $466,000 according to the American Community survey which is something that's produced by the Census Bureau if the district wants to issue debt to continue to keep
145it at the constraint as it has done stor cting your deadline to sell the bonds would be February 28th of next month so you you have a little bit of time to uh Implement some new debt in order to maintain that payment this next slide is a summary of your lease certificate Debt Service which is not paid from the levy so we're showing that separately but the prior side of the graphical representation is a collection of your uh non- referendum General obligation combin so your payments here sorry I need to hide this bar of my screen so I can see the Top Line oops your payments are about $3.2 million per year your monthly interest payment dueing June 1st 2025 is $924,000 and then you have that payment again due um December 1st of 25
146and in addition to principal payment due on a Le certificates of $1,415 th000 I highlight those those payments because it's part of the third section of this presentation that will'll go over here in a moment so let's jump in to the refunding analysis so this slide is a representation of the principal payments of your current outstanding indebtedness which consists of eight different General obligation bonds General obligation bonds again are bonds that are paid on separate taxy all of yours are issued on non referent basis and therefore constrained by The Debt Service extension base and then right here are your lease certificates now uh at the bottom of each column we we reflect the original purpose and it's just a generic description of what the purpose was but more importantly at the bottom is important for
147today's discussion is the call date so you have two bonds that are callable in the near or future or aren't callable right now what does that mean a bond is callable so we always like to talk about refinancing Bonds in the context of what we do as homeowners that we refinance our home mortgages the difference though is that home mortgages are redeemable at any time if the homeown chooses to pay off a home mortgage it can do so municipal bonds should say pay off or refinance a whole mortgage can do so at any time municipal bonds have a period of time which there cannot be refinanced or paid off and that's until you get to the call day so the call day in the 2014 bonds we just passed up December 1st to 24 so
148it means they're callable at any time now and then you have another Bond that's coming up that's callable towards the end of this year in December 1st of 25 we're going to talk about these two Series in more detail subsequent slides but before we do that I do need to introduce one other concept of a zero coupon or capital appreciation bond which we call a cab the cab is a bond that does not have periodic interest payments there which typically from Municipal bond is every 6 months instead the investor receives one payment at maturity equal to the principal value and so they're very similar to US savings bond many of us have probably encountered savings bonds at some point in our life and those are purchased typically at your bank and if you buy for
149example a $50 savings bond that means that you would pay $25 today and at some point the future be with $50 but no point did you ever receive an interest pay and the reason why issuers who use uh cabs is to get around constraints that they're managing and an example of that could be the de service extension based constraint or the Visa and so these two bond series that we're talking about are funding both of these are capital depreciation bonds so they don't make a payment until you see the first amount in each one of these boxes there's no interest payments before then they only make a payment at matur the reason why we went into that math is because they're not making an interest payment when we go to refinance them we would like
150to refinance with a typical bond that pays interest every six months and uh as a result that creates some what we call negative interest flow where it has some negative Savings in the first few years which are manageable because we have room within your desk or it's extension based constraint you see that right here okay so so let's talk a little bit more about this this 2014 bonds they became callable just at the end of last year there's about $1.4 million of created value you can think of that as principal value as of today because again they're not paying interest they they create towards their full value the average yield on those is about 4.8% uh the estimated fings are reflected on the next slide one thing to point out is a uh because these
151are current refunding which means we're at the call date you can refund them on a tax exempt basis just a reminder that uh I believe all of your bonds are tax exempt what that means is your investors don't have to pay taxes on the interest that you pay to them so they're willing to give you a lower interest rate so whenever possible we' like to sell our bonds on a tax exempt basis and as long as you close within 90 days of your call date you can sell that as tax exempt you try to do it more than 90 days before your call date then sell it taxable which is not advantageous so this is the savings that we're projecting here based off of marketing conditions on January 10th so this is what we ask
152to make the nude payments would be and this is would be the old payments you can see here at the bottom of the column there's quite a bit of savings opportunity about $1.3 million present value basis that's $826,000 but here's that negative coupon flow I was talking about these earlier years that's because there's no payments currently on the outstanding bonds there significant payments until you get a few years down the road now we're able to manage those um by fitting them into your DM constraint but that is something that we have to uh manage is part of the process the 2015 bonds as I mentioned earlier in the principal summary slide become called on December 1st of 25 it's a little bit smaller is 7.6 million of cred value and the yield is a little
153bit lower so what that means is a smaller issue smaller yield your refunding opportuni is not going to be as large um now any refinancing of this Bond cannot close any earlier in September 2nd again it's got to be within 90 days of that December 1 to 25 call Dat ideally though as we look at this the refunding opportunity we try to do both at the same time to economize on your cost of issu so you're not selling two bonds for the purpose of refinancing you're only be selling one so again here you have savings opportunity of a total $900,000 reflected the bottom column again we're dealing with some of that managing some of that negative um coupon flow here which we can do and fit into your debt service extension base okay so the
154last section here is the new money analysis so this is where we're going to bring in the refunding along with uh some possible uh issuance of debt to pay for other needs or projects so the district has up to um $3,425 th000 in non-re diesa bond Authority and the reason why that is is because you went through the proceedings in 2023 to create that Authority uh the proceedings are a hearing and a 30-day petition period so the amount that you went through when you did those proceedings was higher than 3 million4 that's what was left over from going through those proceeds well in Consulting with the administration uh the administration and assum made it was part of the plan that you saw earlier tonight um is recommending that this authority to be used to pay
155a portion of the death service doing a lease certificates uh in 2025 and said it shouldn't say a portion there should be uh should say all I forgot to remove that when um earlier draft in the presentation so that would include $924,000 due on June 1st 25 and the balance would be used to pay the 2, 339,50 of Debt Service due in December 1st 2025 now the same rules apply here that appli to the other bonds is that any financing to pay these off has to close within 90 days of the payment date so uh if you wanted to do this we would do a a plan of Finance that's set forth right here this is the course of action and so first step would be to do $950,000 of bonds to be issued in
156March 1st of 25 now that it be sold before March of 25 so it could be filed with the county by the February 208th deadline um so the benefit of this it would allow the District to maintain dity at the at the line so you're going to experience a decline that I showed you earlier in the presentation and because this would be be within 90 days of the June 1st interest payment and the leas certificates it could be done tax exempt and lastly because this would be a relatively small sale would be paid back over a couple of years we would recommend doing it as a direct placement and what does that mean a direct placement it means that you would go directly to purchase to buy your bonds like a bank or perhaps even
157another year in a government instead of going to the public market where your bonds would be rated and underwritten and then sold to um investors of the underwriter and one of the benefits of doing that is right now it's you're aware you're going through uh some crucial decisions for the district and some of decisions are still or the decisions are still work in progress and by doing a direct placement you would avoid having to do an official statement and doing a a public uh disclosure document when maybe the information that we need to disclose isn't fully known yet so you wouldn't have that disclosure risk that you would with um a public offering if you were to do a direct placement for this and a second step could occur then later this year to do
158about 21.5 million bonds that would close in September it would sell in August and that Bond would be used to pay the December 1st 2025 principal interest payment on the leing certificates and then uh it would qualify as being tax exempt because it would be within 90 days of that December 1st payment and it could be anticipate that would be sold as a public offering because it' be a long larger longer financing and subject to market conditions we'd also expect that that financing refund the callable 2014 and 2015 bonds and so if the board were to proceed with this plan the green bars here would represent what we're call the 2025a bonds and then the this blue uh bonds here would represent the 2025 B bonds uh the new money portion as well as the
159refunding of those bonds now uh that would all fit within your de extension based constraint other than this little blip here which is just a few hundred, one of the a couple different options for this blip that would exceed the red line one the CPI may be higher so line would be higher than that two you you have other bonds that are callable so that can be refinanced to fit within the line and or three uh the district could use funds that are available The Debt Service fund at that time to make that payment you wouldn't be a levy for it but you likely would have funds available that's fun make it from funds on hand so that that little bit over the D is is not concerning to me so what's an alternate course
160of action is the the district could go ahead and do all the new money portion to make the payments on lease certificates now uh with a sale in February for closing in 2020 in March of 25 the timeing would again allow the district to maintain its DEA ly However unfortunately only the tax exemp portion only the portion to make the June 1st payment would be tax exempt the larger portion to be sold is taxable because would be more than 90 days from the due date of December 1st to 25 because that be sold as taxable we estimate the the payback and additional interest to be about $375,000 more so financially it's likely not going to be advantageous to to try to sell these two together and it's possible to still sell as a direct replacement
161the reason I say it's possible is the that portion that would make that payment would be placed in this year right here which uh is several years down the road uh and it may not be as attractive as a placement to to potential buyer so that would take some more investigation whether it could be so as a placement or not and then you could still refinance your 2014 and 2015 bonds by coming back and doing those later in this year so you still had two different Bond sales uh following this approach uh the advantage I suppose of this alternate is that you you set aside all the funds now on the present to make both the June 1 and December 1 payments the disadvantage againist estimated $375,000 of additional interest by having to do a
162portion of this tax lastly uh this last side goes over a possible timeline if the board should choose to follow uh the this potential plan of finance and that the so that begin with the board passing a parameters resolution to authorize the sale of 25 a bonds whether that's just doing the tax exempt piece which was the first recommendation are doing the tax exempt and a taxable piece you accept bids if we're able to do it as a direct placement which I'm confident we would be able to do the first scenario as a direct placement we accept it somewhere around February 17th they'll be before the February 20th deadline we close on those on March 11th and then we come back out uh on June 2nd that Community the whole to represent the plan of
163Finance for the 25 B bonds talk about what's changed in the market some tweaking of the plan it currently is in here you looking at a couple different options for that perhaps and then asking the board to approve the primers resolution to sell the 25b bonds on at the June 9th meeting and then we could add the sale approximately October 4th so we could close by September 2nd which should be 90 days before the call day of the the 15 bonds and 90 days before the December 1st 2025 principal and interest payments on the Le certificates so that concludes my presentation and I now will um answer any questions that you may have on the presentation thank you Bob any questions questions this might be more for Tamara but what's the downside of the first
164original plan is there one in your eyes in my opinion no there's no downside to the first one um one thing that I want to make clear so the reason why we're um recommending using these funds to make the lease certificate payment so for at the end of this fiscal year that $900 so th000 remains in fund balance and then for next fiscal year we preserve our fund balance as well otherwise we would have to look at even more Cuts because that would be eroding our fund balance so that's really why that recommendation is being made um and before we had used the proceeds from Bond sales for Capital Improvements right we've done that before but this time we're saying we're feeding it into certificates which is building a new building so it is in
165a way it's still Capital so correct yeah okay but it does again this allows us to preserve that bit of fund balance um and buys us more time so that's the reason for the recommendation yeah what is the risk of maxing out The Debt Service extension base um there's no risk of maxing out The Debt Service extension base you in my opinion you want to keep that Debt Service extension base as high as possible um as Bob mentioned during his presentation the equivalent would be about $21 worth of reduction on the tax bill if we were to um not utilize what's available in the DB right now so it's a that's a minimal impact um but if we continue oh I'm sorry go ahead Bob oh I was just saying I think the risk of
166filling up the Deb service extension base has been mitigated to to a significant amount because of a recent change in the law that was done in June of last year so often times when we're doing a financing like this I'm ask like what if uh emergency roof repairs come up or boilers break or you know something like that comes up and you would potentially want to issue debt to pay for those emergency improvements well uh now the type of bond called like safety bond which you may be familiar with used to count have to fit within the debt service extension base as a result of the law change last year those bonds no longer count against that service extension base so if you had some sort of improvement like that the nature that I described
167you would have to get the life safety approval but the projects I described would like to qualify for it and then you could issue Life Safety bonds to finance those emergency or or special needs that uh wouldn't have to fit The Debt Service extension so a year ago it might have been been more concerning the D but given that new legislation that's alleviated a lot of those concerns thank you any other questions thank you for the presentation Bob you're welcome thank you for having me um so the recommendation is to move that the Board of Education approve PMA Securities as the district's Municipal adviser has outlined in the proposal and the agreement second Salem yes Sue yes hper yes Lindy Ryan Yes Kim yes Wilkins yes Hernandez yes motion passes than you're welcome thank you
168that concludes the finance personnel and buildings and grounds items for this evening all right we are on to curriculum and policy I know this is a finance heavy meeting so people may not have as many questions about the committee review document but let's start there anybody have anything that came up as you were reviewing that just a question about the I know there was a new demographic study done as part of the uh structural deficit reduction plan as just any high level like are there differences or did it conform pretty much to the last demographic study in terms of trend lines um yeah so so we'll bring for a forward a memo either later this month or early February depending on timing with the board that will reinforce some of the high points you know
169like from the executive summary and then share some of the graphs and more detailed information and the full demographic study will be made public on our district website similar to the previous demographic study uh trend lines are similar I think um in this particular demographic study it does slow down a little bit faster if with coffin's report we had a High series a mids series and a low series um McKibben who is the current demographic study Trends more towards our mid series and but just above it and so declines continue um really what we're looking at is an aging population in in Evanston slower turnover of real estate market and lower numbers of movein and so looked at a variety of things there um but we'll give you know we're going to make the full
170report public and we'll bring forward a memo with the high points later in January or early February based on the right timing for that conversation I think important in that study also is that we did enrollment projections new using the new um attendance boundaries so we can kind of see moving into those what potentially Foster enrollment looks like and other schools enrollments which will support step three or not step three the school consolidation or closing work okay thank you I just wanted to know that there were no big surprises or unusual no big surprises trend lines are very similar slightly different slope okay thank you one question Stacey I don't know if I it was in there in the summary but um is there information going to be in there about like impacts of gentrification
171is the only word I can think for like I know on the south end of Evon houses have gotten significantly larger which means there can be fewer of them and that is going to affect po was that housing I know the I know the housing turnover issues with folks who have kids that have aged out is in there but will there also be just that like there's less houses and the there there is some information in that space we did not go as deep this time through that as we did in the coffrin report but there is some some information from the Census that will fill that in and some other information around the enrollments in the schools yeah I don't know if that's across town but it's certainly the south end the the housing
172is changing pretty substantially I'm wondering if we I imagine we might have one more City School liaison meeting and I think that might be an opportunity for us to have a conversation with to see what demographic studies the city has done yeah right to see then we compare notes uh as they think about Invision Evanston 2045 right they're thinking about the again just affordable housing that's that's the topic U that that they're uh exploring there uh but again it just be a good conversation to kind of maybe prepare for once once we have that meeting with the city yeah thank you this particular demography report has some pretty interesting visuals about the um number of individuals that are living in each of the school zones by age bands which also gives you a sense of
173the nature of the population in those age bands in those particular School boundaries it and for me it's I mean I literally am seeing the change in the neighborhood that I live in where there's probably at least 20 to 30% less houses than when I moved into it 20 years ago so um that that will be significant in population numbers as well other uh questions on the committee review document great we will look forward to more information on demographic study all right uh AI guidance for employees and students up yes I was trying to see I was like I think you're still back over there y welcome again thank you um so the AI guidelines that we've presented is um a document that we're really proud of it's really been like a year and a
174half in the making just to give a little bit of background um last school year our technology game our technology team engaged in um AI lunch chats at all schools just to gather Trends on usage and really see um what Educators were using what they were interested in what they were fearful of love and so we had different professional learning opportunities throughout the spring and the summer throughout the summer we had an asynchronous group come together um that really helped us kind of move towards developing more formalized guidelines rather than specific policy um and then this November and December we had a wonderful group of District 65 staff members that worked both asynchronously through some learning and um synchronously together through different Zoom sessions to draft the guidelines a lot of what is currently in
175the guidelines is what we're doing right now um so speaking to how um really staff are currently using AI um and then it's also aspirational thinking about really how we hope to integrate um AI into learning opportunities specifically for middle school students in order to prepare them for um when they leave District 65 um right now what students can access um in District 65 compared to let's say eths is very different so we want to prepare them with the tools to be able to use AI um responsibly ethically um as they leave District 65 so the guidelines speak to some different professional development pieces as well as some opportunities for curriculum in U curriculum intersection which would require some type of curriculum writing such as over the summer and we're very open to different grab
176grant opportunities in order to move this work forward um but know that right now what we have kind of hoping for the next year is something that we can support with local funding um and so yeah I'm we're really excited about it and we're hoping for approval of the guidelines so that this winter and spring it's something that we can communicate with staff members and um family community family and community members within that professional development piece you can see that we outlined the importance of um learning and professional development for not only staff members but also family and community members and so um hoping for approval of those guidelines so we can move forward with communication and then preparing for some hopeful curriculum writing sessions this summer and learning opportunities in the upcoming school year
177here I say I really go ahead I was going to say I really like the guidelines I I I appreciate how um the focus is on just making sure students are using it in the age appropriate way but then recognizing that AI is probably here to stay and so it's helpful for them to start learning how to use it some of the ethics behind it Etc my only question is how are we going to make sure students know that they can't use AI to do all of their homework so basically how are these policies going to be communicated to students yeah that's a really good point um some of the pieces that we really were intention about about weaving into the guidelines were currently were current policies we have in place so we talked about
178um policy 7190 and student behavior that addresses cheating and plagiarism um and we really would like to talk about um the opposite of teaching or the opposite of cheating so teaching for integrity as we use AI um you know people or students can cheat with various different tools and so knowing and just because we cheat one time it could be an accident and we can reflect from that so knowing how to use AI in order to support their learning in order to brainstorm is something that we hope to tie into curricular pieces with different lessons that are already developed from Common Sense Media and other resources we develop as a working group great thank you so I have similar questions and um concerns I I feel very conflicted about AI as someone who works in
179higher education and has to deal with academic Integrity issues related to AI tools it's a big headache sometimes um at the same time I can see how it can be a really useful tool for educators um to you know there's a lot of coming up with examples it's hard to brainstorm exercises and you know as you said differentiated um you know uh curriculum and so I can see the benefits right so I was glad to see that at least in the lower elementary grades there is minimal engagement with the tools just building awareness um I wouldn't even mind not having it so much in three to five right I can see the the usefulness in Middle School um in terms of awareness how these tools work really I hope there is that emphasis on like
180how these large language models actually work it's not like there's a a robot who has Consciousness right it's just you know pattern recognition and predictive model so I think students really need to understand what it can and can't do um as these tools evolve um and then I'm I'm a little I'm concerned also about I know you said there's going to be privacy um you know uh language for each of the contracts with the tools um but I do worry about when you're feeding uh your work into AI that's different from prompting AI to give you an output right because there's a lot of Ip issues and stuff like that when we put a lot of student work or you know proprietary work into those machines so yeah you yeah yeah so one of the
181things that was really important in the guidelines was including a piece about um student personally identifiable information um developing understanding and digital citizenship skills both for students as well as Educators um the majority of the members on the committee were Deck members and they stressed the super importance of having professional learning for staff members around um different data privacy student data privacy laws so thinking about soapa Copa fura what actually is defined as student personal identifiable information what is a student record so that not only will Educators and staff members be very careful and mindful of when they're inputting data into these a toi tools but they will be able to teach students as well um about what they can and cannot share yeah I I understand about the personal identifying information but I just
182mean like student created works that you know you can cut and paste and put into the Bots and then they essentially own it you're training the the Bots when you when you upload the more work that you upload the more you're training these Bots to do their you know um generation more effectively right so I I worry about the the intellectual property issues that that are related to that um students can write essays that are personal they share personal information in their schoolwork and then that gets uploaded into the tools so just I think prompting the tools to generate text is one thing but I worry about students cutting cutting and pasting personal work or their friends work or whatever into um the the chat boots yeah one of the tools that we're really excited
183about that we're currently um trialing with our technology team is the securely chat um AI tool which is developed by our securely which we use for our filter so it's really securely chat our filter and then it does use um open AI as the language model behind that um but we've just been practicing a whole different slew of things to see what it will and will not block so um we have a lot of different um control over that and can pull any kind of way that a student would use it so that's a tool that we're really excited to use as we teach students um to be prepared to use tools like this on their own responsibly as a leave District 65 and that's not paid that's something that we have access to um
184within our current subscription to security track when a student is inputting like how they're using the tool like how they we can we we would be able to pull every single conversation that the student had with the chat bot y my my brain is broke um sorry I had two other questions before you just said that um first I just want to acknowledge how difficult it is to build these guidelines while this is exploding around us so thank you for you and everybody who participated in the process trying to wrap your heads around something that is expanding every second while you're trying to get a handle on it um two questions one is you know in light of the news this week right of power schools national breach what are we thinking about in terms
185of security increases that we need to do related to this usage um and that you know to sula's point about student data and and what other whatever information we feel like we're going to have to have enhanced protocols about is that where are we on the security concerns sure so um while it is extremely unfortunate that there was a data breach with um a third party vendor Power School um I always try to think about what is in our locus of control um so we can't control what external vendors um what kind of security incidents happened with SEC uh external vendors however we can assure that we have data privacy agreements with vendors that we work with and then we also um manage the kind of data that we're sharing with them for example we
186have different Technologies that we only use at a certain point of the year or for a portion of the year so after that we will pull our student data from that technology and upload it again when we go to use it again um the next school year um so depending on the technology we will review that with our technology team to ensure that we're not oversharing student data when we do have a data privacy agreement with that vendor um from our perspective what we can do um is we try to relax on the security practices that are recommended for Illinois school districts from the um learning Technology Center of Illinois there's 48 different practices there was two recently that were just added one about penetration testing which we already do on a Cadence and then
187also um one about incident response management so we have been working on our internent response or IR plan um with two of our new appointed technology Services team members who supports cyber security our infrastructure manager and our Network and cyber security manager to um be appointed to different parts of that plan and really build out that plan in a more robust way and so along with the other practices um those are two that are recently added that we want to make sure that we are on top of so that we can stay as secure as we possibly can yeah and I you know I think all of all of the world has their data stolen sometimes so like it's it's the world we live in um I am interested based on what you were saying
188earlier about how we might use uh the access for like threat assessment right when we have a student that has said something being able to access what their uh history is on we can access a lot through our student filter which is one of the pieces that we have to have in place due to the um sipa the children's internet protection act are they do they all end they all end in PA there is a lot there's a lot of f Hippa impress that I knew that one but yeah um and then my last question is you know as we were talking about in our structural deficit conversations about the need for collaboration how can we use AI after all of these Cuts right as we have like how can we help the the staff
189that remains especially I'm thinking of in in central office like making sure they get professional development so that they might be able to use AI to help with some of the functions that they are maybe their new purview has them covering so I don't know what the collaboration plan is from your office to everywhere else but thinking about how we can streamline some work for folks with AI yeah got a lot of ideas fantastic see I completely geek out over it I've been on the higher ed but kind of research ing the AI ethical use working with faculty and students um so I love the guide I really appreciate I feel like it's innovating in the sense that it is a guide and not a don't do this don't do that it is i' I've
190love that you guys have created this framework here um really allowing both students and teachers to grow from it um I appreciate securely I think even just checking out my students securely search being like I think we got to talk about some of these things but it's a great you know talking a good start um for some conversations at home too I know with AI personally it has been a tremendous support in various factors um I don't have an adila for my personal life but I do appreciate having like a meeting summary or recording for an interview so I'm not sitting here scribbling down every single note and not being an active participant so there is that and I think being students being able to see that and figure out okay well there was this
191part that allowed me to be a more present student so I do you know I think that there's framework there um trying to think what else no there's a variety of different AI tools that I'm excited for our students and teachers to play around with and figure out what would bring out the best and I think another tool I know I've personally used is speechify and being able to create that audio and that accessibility into the classroom has been also really helpful awesome I'm not familiar with that one so I'll take a look I'm happy to share I like my toys yeah I I um just wanted to say you you all read my mind and um one of the sessions that I attended at the triple ey conference in November was specifically around Ai
192and Ed education and everything you described and what you've outlined in the in the GU in the guidance document that you shared with us um is aligns with some of the best practices right um you know they talk about starting with administrative efficiency initial training carefully piloting classroom use cases making sure there's a regular impact assessment uh continued stakeholder engagement but what really sticks out to me is is this educational ethos right and they say it's AI is to augment and not replace human interaction right and I think as we move forward with this right any technology right I think we know I think a huge source and a huge root problem in our society at least in our Western societies is that again we've adopted technology and it's it's become this wedge like we
193could curate our realities the algorithms uh that we you know engage with uh through through our technology have really caused the wedge between human interaction so again as we and I out about all the technology as well but at the same time it's it's very concerning um and I think we we're in a place in society um in this point in time where you know again it it just we we need more human interaction and we just really need to be very careful uh as we Implement any new technology and and approaches uh and really try to ensure that we utilize it to again going back to what this presentation said the educational ethos is AI is to augment and not replace human interaction so just just keeping that in mind as we continue on
194as this is folds uh and blows up all around us uh just again making sure that we that that is something that is our ethos going forward I'll just quickly add uh holistically I think it's really awesome I think this is great very few districts in Illinois have this ISB has no guidance for this so um I think you all did a great job something I just want to highlight that my colleagues haven't yet is the like you talked about professional development for staff uh but you know I also want to highlight on here for District 65 families I think parents need to learn about AI parents need to know how it's being used in class parents need to know the capabilities and what to be on the lookout for um so I think that's
195awesome that you all included that uh so I'll just stop there I think this is very impressive so um excited to see what happens and honestly they need to know whether they're like what the kid is doing is whether that's okay or whether that's cheating like your kids like no my teacher said it's okay that I like I think that and I would even add as the my my children are younger um just kind of making sure they know what it is because it's showing up everywhere right like AI is on you like you know suggestions come from AI so just making sure they know what they're getting even if they're not using it in class I try to make sure they know what they're doing so I think um you all are on the
196right track with that and just you know it's always changing and uh again I think these guidelines are are really strong so yeah I think part of the ethical use use is being able to document and acknowledge that you used it and how you used it right that students have to be very like they have to disclose and then also track what are the prompts that they used and um a lot of the I mean I'm trying to develop guidelines for my own school so this is very timely so this is this is some of the things that we're thinking about like if faculty are going to allow use to what extent and for what purpose and then having students document their use I think is really critical so okay any final questions or comments
197thank you very much thank you thank you all right Dr speith we we would like to learn about summer learning all right here we go summer learning sy20 bye I'm gonna stand over here so it doesn't blow all over me I'm uh Dr I'm bringing Dr oser up because I just want to appreciate the amount of work that she's done around summer learning 25 so my partner in crime um so hang on a second yeah here we go um summer learning sy24 cost we wanted to revisit that so for summer learning 2024 we did a deeper dive and allocated Transportation expenses we included newcomers and jump start expenses into the general education costs you can see here we came up with a total cost of $1,433 in sy24 um with the structural deficit Reduction Program
198we knew um our goal was start to start to reduce those costs with minimal impact on students so we took a look at four um really four and a half because y has two programs we took a look at four proposed programs three are internal one is an external very valued partner so we have jump start prek that's run by d65 staff a student capacity of 70 with uh proposed cost of 48,000 newcomer summer learning 40 to 50 students at a proposed cost of 30,000 um Mall YMCA and MX multimedia we're looking at about 240 students a $400,000 cost and then the summer literacy intensive which is 2nd through 7th grade at $50,000 at about 60 students that's their capacity so we have a total of 420 students at $528,000 in comparison to sy24 these
199four programs serve 452 students so just a little bit about the programs that we're proposing for this summer jump start prek is Early Childhood it serves our youngest students in the district uh newcomer summer learning program serves our second language Learners who arrive in the United States between January 2024 and the present school year sum are literacy intensive serves students who are reading 1.5 plus years below grade level and they have significant challenges with encoding and decoding this is equivalent to a tier 2 intervention and then the metam media serves Middle School student population and YMC AK4 serves YMCA K4 um it's about 200 plus students it uses a 500 full day a five a full five-day model and it also meets parent and caregiver needs while providing an afternoon enrichment and morning academics and
200I just also want to jump in real quick the um the newcomer summer learning last year um we housed uh up to almost capacity but this year with numbers checking with Amy already we're only at about 33 students so that program unless we receive some um new commers to our district that number is still on the lower end so we still have we there will be some money saved on that part these are also apart from esy esy is still fully being fully planned in Dr herrera's department so phased out summer learning programs so these programs are potentially being phased out if the partner secure their own funding we can provide in kind services so we're looking at project sincere ABC boosters and eppl stem are both out of Evon Public Library ABC boosters uh
201partnered with um jumpstart and eepl stem was also at Evon public library and then summer lift at eths and then additionally um these Partners currently operate at no program cost to District 65 books and breakfast operates virtually in the summer Yu is a 21st century grant that ends in August Kumba operates at e justest that yellow part was supposed to get taken out we're we're working on a WR at school programs but those are they would they would uh pay a fee to work with us so it's even more fun when you highlight the part that supposed to take version this the copy all right so wrong version I want to make sure we're hitting it's not on ours that we have oh it's on yours okay good so wrong version but thank you I
202did get the answer from stac Dr Beardsley has always come through we're good to go I know that was pretty basic questions comments things we can answer for you um Dr oser has done a very good job with reaching out to every single one of these partners and having conversations with them the general education cost for 2024 compared to this year's proposed cost is about half yes we look at a 50 which was also in the SDR sdrp right and those are comparable programming situations they are comforable programming because the ones that we're saying the the if we go back here these phased out programs we're saying we can no longer afford to hand you a check could you plea we would love to have you with us could you please seek other funding great
203um so I have a question they are a valued partner the $400,000 to the YMCA go back I think I've asked this before why do we spend $400,000 for kids to go to a YMCA Camp in the summer as opposed to letting the YMCA as a partner run a community summer program that people can opt into I think it's a good like why is it not the why's expense why is it our expense well and I'm asking this because going back to my comment my response to Maya before there are places where we have asked for a partnership um across the city crossing guards are a really good example yeah where the city was doing the crossing guards and all of a sudden we're doing crossing guards but like there city streets and it's I
204don't understand why it's has to be all them or all us and we are where we are um but this number was bigger in previous years too absolutely so my my issue in previous years was the same um I we need to be able to you don't have to answer it today but we need to be able to answer the reason reason why we're going to spend almost half a million dollars to send kids to another camp that ultimately aren't our goals They Might Be Our Community Values but they're not our institutional goals right right and I think when we talk about the cuts and the broader plan like that's one of the things that I I see I value the partnership I just don't know that it's worth sacrificing something that we are responsible
205for right yeah um and it that's hard to say in this town because people get up in arms about it and I appreciate that because I value the relationship but we are going to do the part that we have to do to rebuild trust so that we can go back to the table and ask for Northwestern to be a better partner like there was a time I think project excite a long time ago Northwestern paid for the busing to bring kids over to to Northwestern right for experiences like there's ways that we can get back to the table that's just one that stands out is again I said you don't have to answer it don't answer it CU I want to can I sorry can I ask a related question they're just we have to
206question we have to question right but so the proposed cost for the let's use the Y as our example went down significantly did the number of students being served also go down like is it still 452 students no that's with all all programs so which why we had about 263 students approximately for the YMCA so like when we say that cost is going down are they is is it costing us less or are we just serving fewer students I guess is what serving fewer stud we're serving fewer students so serving serving fewer students with a very targeted Focus I think one of the things that uh in our meeting with Dr OSHA she's been like on An Inspector Gadget mission to kind of unpack this she she has identified that the again it's a it's
207it's similar to the academic Skills Center the original design or intent for the program is not supporting those children right and so what I mean by that is we have some children in there who are 50th percentile or higher and it's not this is supposed to be a program that support students below that percentile I think I think the uh the other thing that we um discovered with this is while we've reduced the cost the reality is is I think and and I met with um the leadership uh with the YMCA and I think both both and I'm not going to speak on behalf of Mo'Nique but I think Mo'Nique and I both agree that moving forward there are other ways that we can reimagine this funding in a future in the future um that
208requires would require you know the superintendent kind of getting out there and being more connected to you know some fundraising opportunities that would bring in that funding for that um and and so again that's that's I think her and I have talked about and we have a regular Cadence where we want to look to reimagine that moving forward just to completely cut um this particular program I I wasn't I didn't want to do that in addition to there's some re-evaluating so I evalu I observe this program in the summer and and we got some catching up on um our updated curricular resources that we use and those types of things that Dr OSHA will be working with them to ensure that it's supporting um and reinforcing what Educators do with students throughout the year so
209that we can get a better return on our investment so those are just some ways that we have unpacked this a little bit more to get to get smarter but I think you know we're this is this gets us at targeting the the students who deserve it in a way without ripping the Band-Aid off completely but it's also something I mean it's it's this we gave the breakdown for you a little bit more intimately this this is just like the transportation aspect it's factored into the the structural deficit reduction plan so if the board came back and say no like look we want to take the 400,000 from here versus somewhere else it it there's flexibility in in that that is certainly your discrepancy to to guide the district on I mean I like it
210that it's full day like I said before right that was a big issue with and has has evolved over time right it it is the academic portion in the morning but in the afternoon it's the enrichment and and more of the other activities but then it also gives on Friday a full week for our our families right on Friday there's um field trips and so forth right that's provided it's a it's breakfast lunch and snack and it is five five days a week and we know it is very difficult in our our community with our most marginalized students for our families that might be working multiple jobs and you know um care is difficult and when you have only partial care and have to find another option on top of that it's difficult and challenging
211yeah I have a oh go I just being familiar with some of these programs and just knowing like they you know like just the quality of the program I feel like it's worth just before making big changes or big cuts to some of these again seeing if there are ways to mitigate that impact so if we know in our community we don't have programs that are meeting those needs what can can we talk to the city can we talk to Community Partners and say is there a way for them to put it in for future years or is there a way to you know share funding for some of these or is there a way to you know improve what the original intent was some of our educational goals I think it's important for us
212not to be shortsighted and to sort of think through some of these things but good questions definitely wor well the value is the value is there I'm not debating the value um you're just theom model right I mean camps camps are businesses right so like are we spending $400,000 about $1,600 a child to go to camp that you know is at a profit to a community partner yeah right I would necessarily be okay with that that might be the reality though right and I think we just need to dig into some of those uh things and see if we're expending some of our money that way while we're looking at things like early childhood busing I think the the long-term piece of that I really the more we can try to figure out right if
213you want to go stumping and fundraising for the W right like whatever those things are that can help that can help fund some of these things or I don't know if it's soon I got phase three so it'll be one day you got to figure out what's the right time that people want to give you money I don't know when that is I sorry go ahead yeah I was just say in the short term I have a logistical question in that I know this is about the time that fames start signing up for summer camps and so both like what is our decision date and what is our communication date and have we considered whatever the really I I don't have little kids anymore so I don't know what that date is it used to
214be I used to have an alarm on my phone ready to go but but like so making sure that we're letting families know if there's going to be fewer options before they have then gotten themselves knocked out of the options in town that's why we presented today these decisions and then we can make a decision in the January 27 we vot we'll vote that night and then we've got time to turn it around for parent conferences if needed I I what I my concern is that the date might need not be able to wait till parent conferences we might need a communication that goes out the 29th like I I don't know what the date is but let's say it's February 1st I think it would make sense for us to send a communication out
215to family saying we want to let you know about these changes to Sumer learning opportunities here's how you sign up for the stuff with us and also know that there's fewer options so that if you're if you want to look at city or other programs because because those fill up pretty much day of registration so we don't want to tell we don't want to tell people after that I was to say yeah H have we communicated these changes to the city because that might impact some of the program decisions they yeah they might be able to add more spots or hire more staff or anything now so how are we communicating to our families before the the camps would go live and making sure we talk to those uh whatever the our leades on our
216community partner is with the with the city to make sure that they're ready for what might come their way right CU realistically also we have I mean we have 60 plus less seats right and so that is you know I don't want to refer to it like The Hunger Games but I mean there's it's limited right and prioritize really you know who is the program built for right online could feel like hunger yes remember the year I was remember the year that the system crashed and everybody had to go to Ley Center at 8 in anyway we everyone remembers we're all traumatized so looking at that one last thing I just wanted to add about this slide is also you know some of the thinking behind it one you know we also feel our Educators
217know our students the best so having you know our Educators you know um run and provide services to our students in the why also last year hired 100% of their Educators were from District 65 this also spans across everywhere from jump start early childhood all the way through middle school so it's option for everybody throughout all of our marginalized you know that poses another question is like our staff that are there any programs that we're cutting that are staff helped provide like is it going to affect anybody that would have had jobs this summer that's it's all external these are the ones that all employ District 65 staff the ones that we're looking at and funding did not great okay the other thing too is that we're looking at especially for programs is is looking
218at and so like why with curriculum in the morning like what is the curriculum you're using what is the assessment plan you're using and how is it align to the d65 K through four um Ela you know literacy and math instruction but the key to that too is also um using the d65 assessments with Fidelity so we have measurable data coming in and measurable dat going out and so then we can come back to y'all to say this is how it's working and we've been in conversations with Donna cross and Je Dr Jess Plaza as well to how do we own possibly the assessments and making sure we're not over assessing because they just finished Assessments in the spring right and is there a way to M take what's in the spring and then just
219use what's in the fall and still measure without constantly also losing that summer school time right because they spend anywhere from you know the first week of summer camp or school right of really really doing assessments and is that really feasible where we can be doing instruction and we can do the the assessment on the front and in the back well or could we skip the additional assessment and just have better tracking of which students went to the summer program we have our data on both ends and then we just know which of those kids went to our summer programs I I don't we do that's the conversation with Donna and Stacy's team that we've been having so absolutely yeah I'm glad to hear that because I think one of the frustrations I've had with
220the summer learning report it is that we don't have good data about the impact and the ROI so if we can do our own yep assessment the crazy thing is all that data is stored in power school right the registration the tests yeah that um and I think for me I'm just logistically thinking you know you know this is the capacity I know last year I commended you all on the early release of information so parents could start planning and putting that into their calendars um my concern is if we get the this information out too late is it not going to get included are we not going to be as competitive and not hit you know the capacity did we I forget with registration last year did we have more um interest than spots
221available yeah I think I think yeah there there there some of them in some programs program some but I think the way you are looking at design this program is that 240 and all of those kids we going after targeted kids that the program is designed for so we really don't want like a hey right I think we've done that before we got to get to yeah I just want to point something out so so that again I get somebody mentioned how again when you want to register your kids that's if you have the means and that's you have if you have the Savvy right again I know parents and some of us are sitting here who you know waiting with baited Breath by the computer you know for for for registration to open up
222so our kids can get on there what we do we're doing here as a system is that these kids are already pre-selected we already know their scores that need they they the parents don't have to wait with baed birth like we did to get these Services going directly to our the students who actually need definitely need these Services then the rest of us can have our little you know yeah hung gam I just want to make sure that it's not that the timing is such that a family who is looking at the summer going I have to get child care I'm going to pay for all these camps that has the need and it's just a scheduling issue right so I don't when are we when are signups for I guess it's not signups when
223are when is when are the students being identified and communicated with they get invited at conferences hopefully by conferences as soon as all of at this proposal then goes through and the decision is voted on um in the meantime I am going to work with uh building administrators also pulling data and who are these students already you know uh and then identifying who's our first goto and if they aren't going to participate parents say hey we're going out of the country we're doing whatever we need to do right or you know I have another program set up then we have who's up who's up next right and then trying to fill it that way um more an Outreach from us to them saying hey we we have this space available we'd like your child to
224participate in our program um and then own it on our end and then have just separate lists based on need because it can't be you got five seats at your school five seats it's not Equitable where is the need in the district and then operating off of that first I just to Sergio's point I don't want families who are struggling to afford the child care piece spending any money on on other Solutions if we're going to be their solution for both the academic need and the child care piece right so the idea is that we can communicate how we are aligning these programs with academic needs of students and what the goals ofr are and given that we will have fewer seats I think there's ways to tear this communication out so the board makes
225a decision on the 27th we work with Melissa to have kind of that initial like Hey we're gonna here's a heads up we're going to have smaller spots we then continue to Target those populations to ensure that we are meeting the needs of the students need that there might even be a cushion um I don't know if if there's a sec like if February 1 is the starting date for camps there might be a date where you can get refunds by or um full payment is right like so there might be an extra y couple of weeks of wiggle room from the city that's probably worth checking I the biggest the biggest next step is we know the board has to vote y this is where we're going so we going to keep the train
226moving keep moving as though cuz we know we got kids lives in our hands so I think that's where we're identifying you're connecting with the academic interventionist and Dr Plaza and school leaders to identify who our kids for this is all hands on deck to make sure that we start getting those kids or getting the interest so that at least people are informed that that this program is designed for so that once the board approves we can we're not losing any time until to your point got people paying for a program that this program is going to meet their needs more yeah do this is a question I probably should know at this point in my board decree but can we vote tonight yeah I mean in the ideal world that that would save that
227part of the sdrp could we move that so that you guys have oh is there any reason why we don't feel like we could vote tonight and then that gives them two more weeks to get moving this is ideal because honestly we wanted y'all to vote tonight and I was like no they gonna vote next next time they vote because we a put this on the agenda so if it's okay I'd like to I'd like to move that the Board of Education approved the summer program 2025 not to exceed a dollar amount of $528,000 and a student seat of 420 I guess it could be more if the dollar is the same um for this upcoming summer second got to write got to write an extra row of votes on there um Salem yes Sue
228yes Kern yes Lindsay Ryan Yes Kim yes Wilkins yes Hernandez yes we just made the next meeting shorter too great thank you we we we want like I know there's a lot of moving parts and if we can make that more streamlined so suan that it should be counted as a definite in the scenario whatever one look at look I don't think I've made any suggestions in six years that have made that many people smile in the room so I can just finish up today any anything else I want to publicly just say thank you to Dr OSHA the the work she has done has been incredible um between SCP superintendent parent advisory stuff working to unpack some of learning next up is uh sa so give her all the Kudos cuz she got another
229big feet ahead of her with uh our before and after school and so thank you doc you're welcome thank you all right folks um without uh any further business before the board I know we have an fi we have a district calendar I know folks have been waiting for that as well it's a draft that we have out there um so I'm going to journ this meeting at 7:42 clar so we're going to are we going to vote on that calendar at the next board meeting is that correct yes okay then we are you are we motioning to close session or no we're not going to close session so we're just going to Jour oh there's no close session to close session more Smiles so I without any further business before the board I adjourn
230this meeting at 7:43 p.m. thanks everybody have a good night and a good rest of the week e e e