CorpusRecord 117286

Naperville 203 Board Meeting 2/3/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Naperville 203 Board of Education
Date
2025-02-04
Location
DuPage County, IL
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,721 words · about 155 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening since 5:00 pm the board has been in close session to consider the appointment employment compensation discipline performance or dismissal of specific employees or legal counsel including hearing testimony and a complaint lodged against an employee or legal counsel to determine its validity and Collective negotiating matters between the school board and its employees or their representatives or deliberations concerning salary salary schedules for one or more classes of employees I will now take a motion to come out of Clos session second a motion in a second have been heard please call the role Mrs Patton Fitzgerald I wan key I Kelly black I ksky I MC enan I giry I Kush I we the motion passes we are now an open session Welcome to our February 3rd 2025 board meeting our mission is to empower students

002to develop a learner's mindset demonstrate adaptability communicate effectively think critically and become Global Citizens please call the role Mrs Patton board members present this evening Christine giry Kristen Fitzgerald Charles Kush Melissa Kelly black Joe ksky Amanda McMillan and Donna wanky please now join the board in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all we have now reached the point in our agenda for good news okay we indeed do have good news today we celebrate 203 day in partnership with the Neighborville Education Foundation observed on February 3rd the second month and the third day of the year the special day is all about gratitude giving and celebrating the people

003places and moments that make Neighborville 203 exceptional so take take a moment in short appreciation let's take this moment to show appreciation perform acts of kindness and give back to make our community even stronger and in honor of 203 day I'd like to introduce Neighborville Mayor Scott Worley uh and his interns with him from the mayor's office uh and mayor Worley has some comments and a proclamation to share thank you and good evening and I'm glad the mayor of Lyall and I worked this out because I'm jumping the Border here to uh present this tonight I I did confirm with mayor Worley it still holds its validity of an official Proclamation so as you mentioned I want to introduce our our chief of staff interns and and take a moment to just share the inspiration

004about how we got here with this new pilot program joining me today are are Sanji and shus and nii from Nia Valley and then we have Regan from Neighborville North and Alice from neille Central and Tabitha who is not here tonight who also attends neille North so we have half from 203 and half from 204 and that all worked out really well when I was running for office for the first time I got a a question from a editor of the naville central times he was interviewing me and he specifically asked what can kids do to get involved in working at City Hall and getting and working with the mayor's office and I told them I would love to see kids someday interning and and helping us out and learning about city government and then

005the Workforce Development program The District 203 put on um I I served on it along with our Deputy city manager Pam gallahue and that kind of confirmed that it was time to try this new program so these Chiefs of Staff they come with me to different appearances they work with us at City Hall they've been trained in leadership and all of the things that are important for how to uh set up a uh important visit with our partnership with N9 amend and kids matter so they are in addition to the 25 students we have from District 203 and 204 who have been selected to serve as junior members of our boards and commissions within the city and the wonderful thing about that is all of those students including these students were selected through competitive applications

006of over a hundred students and they were vetted out by our emerging leaders program at City Hall which is made up of um employees who are are chosen um in their own competitive world to uh do a leadership program that takes 18 months and they will be our future directors and and uh Deputy directors at City Hall so it's a great program the emerging leaders told us what a tough job it is to select these kids because their applications are so fantastic and you should be very proud of what you are doing as Educators with that how about a proclamation for 203 day whereas February 3rd 2025 marks the death the celebration of 203 day for neille 203 Community whereas naville Community Unit School District 203 in partnership with the Neighborville Education Foundation seeks to

007honor the achievements and contributions of our students staff and community on February 3rd as we reflect on and celebrate our Collective success and whereas this special day is dedicated to gratitude giving and celebrating the teachers staff students parents volunteers schools community members and businesses past present and future who work collaboratively to make District 203 an exemplary school district and whereas Neighborville 203 and the Neighborville Education Foundation will annually commemorate this day with the community empowering students to develop a learner's mindset demonstrate adaptability communicate effective ly think critically and become Global Citizens and whereas naville 203 remains committed to upholding the dignity and uniqueness of every individual fostering responsible citizenship and demonstrating that Excellence is achieved through the collective efforts of students staff parents and the community now therefore I Scott Worley mayor of the city

008of neille the H hereby Proclaim February 3rd 2025 as 203 day in the city of neille congratulations [Applause] mid thank [Applause] you okay thanks to the May and our interns we do have additional good news to share four of our Junior High first Lego League teams recently competed at the Illinois sectional tournament for first robotics demonstrating their creativity teamwork and problem solving skills these students worked hard to design build and program their robots while tackling real world challenges through Innovation and collaboration congratulations to all who participated at Riverwoods our entire school is reading The One and Only Ivan exploring themes of friendship and freedom together as a community along the way students have learned fascinating facts about silverback gorillas and even compared their arm spans to Ivans as part part of a special Community project

009Riverwoods came together to donate funds to support the Lan gorillas at the Brookfield Zoo Lincoln Junior High welcomed our students for a winter wonderland bash hosted by our amazing student council a huge thanks to our amazing kids and our Lincoln home and school who partnered with us for this fun event and a special shout out to our parent volunteers who helped make the event a success we look forward to hosting more in the future [Applause] in January Madison junior high students had the opportunity to book a trip around the world in the learning commments through this interactive experience they explor different countries and cultures by engaging with books artifacts and activities that highlighted Global Traditions histories and stories students discovered New Perspectives broaden their understanding of the world and celebrated diversity through literature making connections

010between their own experiences and those of people from different backgrounds great job that's our good [Applause] news uh Donna I would like to propose because we have uh such a wonderful turnout from our community that we move the item 8.06 the Innovative School experience recommendation report to prior to our public comment and at which point then we can all um benefit from that presentation I'd like to propose like normal that the school board asks questions uh after that presentation and then we hear public comment but we leave the item on the agenda at the end so that if we have further followup questions from the P public comment we can still uh address those within the within the scope of the meeting so that would be my motion which to be move item uh 8.06

011to before public comment but also leave it in the agenda where it is okay so we have a motion to move the item do I have a second for it second okay a motion and a second have been made so we'll just just to be clear for everyone we'll move item 8.06 to discuss now we'll still follow our same procedure where the board um can make comments and ask questions and we're going to leave it though to to kind of circle back okay motion a second have been heard call the role Mrs Patton Kush I Kelly black nay Fitzgerald i wony i kinsky i McMillan I giry I the motion passes so at this time we will hear the presentation on the Innovative School experience okay so uh changeing the agenda here there you go

012you got it perfect okay okay okay good evening uh tonight we plan to share the second presentation to the board of education on the work we're doing to innovate the school experience tonight we'll focus on creating a deep understanding of the level recommendations our outcomes for tonight include reviewing the stakeholder feedback and insights from community staff and students and present our final recommendation for board action as we reflect on what school is for it's important to remember that school is not just about helping students succeed in school or preparing them for the world we grew up in instead it's about equipping them for a future we can't fully predict previously we shared that our students will likely hold 12 to 15 different jobs before they're 40 and many of the careers they'll pursue haven't even

013been invented yet it's not enough for us to have a system that prepares students to do well in school our true vision for our school district to help build a passion for lifelong learning that means we need to prepare students for Success after they leave school today's students will be in the workforce well under the 2080s navigating Industries and challenges we can only imagine with 80% of high school students expressing a desire for on the- job learning opportunities as we just evidenced with our interns with the mayor's office it's clear that education must evolve to meet these changing needs and Empower our students to thrive in their future as a district we've achieved remarkable academic success and our students staff and Community have made strides in creating a sense of belonging and know there are

014still dispar I ities that some of our students face in their learning sense of belonging and extracurricular experiences we invest in continuous School Improvement to ensure that every individual thrives in our school Community School Improvement is beyond a single measure it provides us opportunities to implement actions that create an inclusive environment where every student's unique experiences and needs are met acknowledged and valued our goal is not just to increase academic performance but to lift every single student's sense of belonging when we talk about success it's when all members of our community are represented have access to meaningful participation are safe and genuinely feel like they belong here and are a respected part of our community this is the work of school Improvement and the reason for our Innovative School experience work and proposed changes that

015we are presenting this evening our strategic blueprint guides the direction of the district commitment 1.3 which calls for an analysis of innovative school day models has been a part of our Focus since before 2018 and was added to our blueprint in 2021 and is the focus of our presentation we want to begin by sharing the community input which includes families staff business owners and students that we have received and how we have responded in an effort to seek input from the community regarding the experiences our students need to be college career and life ready we held two Focus 203 events with multiple opportunities for community members to participate we had 200 total parti participants attend these events in person and nearly 2,000 viewed the presentations after the events occurred on Friday January 24th the district

016sent an email to all families that included drafts of the recommendations proposed for next school year the email received more than 44,000 views as of last Wednesday at noon and led to over 10,000 visits to our new Innovative School experience web page designed to provide all stakeholders with the information they need to stay informed between the 24th at 3 p.m. and last Wednesday at noon we received 222 let's talk messages on innovating the school experience 139 of those submissions expressed disagreement with the proposal and 131 of those comments related to the start and end times within the proposal from the time this slide was developed last Wednesday until 4:00 today the district received an additional 113 let's talk submissions several of which were submitted by the same sto stakeholders as the messages represented on this

017slide of the 113 additional submissions 76 of them expressed disagreement with the proposal and 57 of those 76 referenced personal schedules as the reason for disagreement overall the total number of Unique Individuals who submitted at least one comment as of 4:00 today was 290 representing approximately 1.4% of the recipient of our communication our team has analyzed the feedback Trends from the focus 203 events and the let's talk submissions to make revisions to our proposal along the way community feedback included the need for our students to experience real world learning that is set up in flexible personalized and Equitable ways our design teams have built schedules with flexible blocks of time to allow for work-based learning experiences and has expanded what I need or wi time across all schools where we can embed supports and extensions

018without stealing from instructional time we have also received comments and questions regarding the potential impact of start and end times on students participation in community events we want to assure you that we have reached out to many Community providers who have assured they can be flexible with youth activities and would collaborate with us moving forward next we will highlight the opportunities for formal staff input and involvement in shaping the Innovative school day experience teams conducted research using data on attendance behavior and academics and participated in both in-person and virtual site visits to other school districts to inform the development of foundational beliefs for these recommendations they then collaboratively developed and built consensus around the recommendations for their level representing the perspectives of their colleagues members were selected through a collaborative process involving District cabinet members

019the Nua executive board and principles and included certified Educators educational support professionals and administrators from various roles and schools the teams work together to ensure alignment and consensus on the final recommendations the following slides highlight the dedicated Innovative school day team members by level we thank them for their Innovative collaborative and diverse perspective Ives in developing and refining these recommendations while advocating for the needs of their specific level they were able to see the bigger picture and understand how each level is part of a larger system where plans intersect and support one another the Early Childhood design team met five times throughout the last year to develop their recommendation our gratitude extends to the elementary design team who met eight times to refine their recommendation we are grateful to the Middle School design team for

020their dedication and meeting six times to refine their recommendations all right we are also grateful to the high school element I to the high school design team uh for all of their work in refining their recommendation staff input was gathered through a variety of methods to ensure Broad participation and feedback the fall 2023 staff morale survey identified recognition and value ownership and input and time as and resources as key areas impacting morale Innovative School experience staff surveys were launched across all levels additionally additionally listening and feedback sessions were held at each School level throughout the year along with targeted breakout focus groups for specific areas like middle school performance music music an elementary project idea an internal website was created as a request from the staff morale committee to keep staff informed and engaged with

021the updates on the Strategic blueprint work throughout the past year the Innovative School experience design team emphasized transparent communication by providing regular level specific updates to staff across Early Childhood elementary middle and high school levels all staff were kept informed through updates from superintendent bridges in the spring and fall of 2024 with additional Communications in December and January Key Resources such as FAQ documents based on listening session themes were developed for elementary and middle school staff and shared in January 2025 High School staff received presentations on the proposed schedule during meetings in December ensuring alignment across all levels the Innovative School experience internal website launched in August 2024 providing a central location for staff to learn about the ongoing work at each level additionally the superintendent's cabinet the Nua executive board held collaborative IPC meetings

022discussing the Innovative School experience at five of the meetings since March as we've progressed through the innovating the School experience initiative we've been intentional about ensuring that staff voices are heard and that communication is transparent and consistent to do this we collaborated with Nua Union leadership to establish design teams we sent surveys to staff provided updates after meetings and created a district website specifically for sharing information about isse and other District initiatives despite our efforts we know that some concerns remain let's address some of the key feedback we've received first some Middle School staff have shared concerns about the late dismissal time and how it could impact extracurricular activities our operations team is actively working with principes and athletic directors to maintain current extracurricular schedules while also exploring before school clubs and Inter mural opportunities

023we're also coordinating with the conference schools to align our efforts next some Elementary staff have expressed concerns about the addition of 15 minutes to the school day this change was recommended by the design team to allow for morning meetings a Wind Block four days a week and to address non-instructional times these components are essential for providing student support intervention and enrichment while also protecting the Integrity of core instruction after reviewing schedules the team determined the 15minute addition was necessary to achieve these goals at the secondary level we've heard feedback regarding the need for additional professional learning and planning time to adjust to the block schedule in response we develop a comprehensive professional learning plan with clear implementation expectations over the first three years we've also received mixed feedback on the staggered start and end times

024Elementary staff in particular have voiced concerns about the earlier start times and its impact on daycare needs to address this we've increased communication about the rationale behind this recommendation after considering multiple start time scenarios the operational team determined that a 745 start time would be manageable particularly since high school staff has successfully navigated this schedule for decades while arranging daycare we understand the challeng the change brings challenges and we are committed to continuing this dialogue listening to feedback and refining our approach as we move forward student voice was gathered through surveys focus groups and meetings with student leaders at both the middle school and high school levels to inform recommendations for the Innovative School school day experience we gathered valuable feedback from students in grades 6 through 12 through surveys and focus groups to inform

025the Innovative school day experience a total of 173 high school students and 2,777 middle school students responded to the surveys additionally we received input from the middle school student leadership Focus Group in December High School principal advisory teams throughout the fall and the superintendent student advisory committee in both September and January our students have provided valuable and enthusiastic feedback on the upom upcoming changes middle school students are excited about the addition of band chorus and Orchestra to to the exploratory wheel and they appreciate having more time for math support and additional exploratory classes they are also looking forward to the morning flexibility whether it's sleeping in or using the time for homework additionally they are pleased with daily PE and recess and have shared suggestions for improving the structure and activities during recess high school

026students Express relief that bus issues will be resolved improving their daily time management and they see the new schedule as better preparation for college they also emphasize the import importance of passing periods and lunch for socialization and stress the need for 85 minute classes to be engaging and interactive rather than extended lectures their thoughtful input will help guide us as we move forward with these changes at the last Board of Education meeting we shared our district data highlighting our celebrations and opportunities for improvement after reviewing all of the data and student and staff feedback we identified these four tenants of school design as our guiding Focus for creating conditions for responsive changes to enhance the entirety of the school experience the following areas of focus are the operational arms that translate these essential lenses into

027thoughtful application now that we have explored the feedback Trends and actions taken let's transition to the Innovative School experience work and the final recommendations based on this input throughout this process we identified these structural barriers to creating the Innovative School experience our students and staff deserve focusing our design energies on solving these areas our proposals at each level are centered on increasing student engagement and deepening belonging while delivering robust aligned and personalized instruction that authentically and comprehensively prepares all students for their future our designs honor staff need for comprehensive professional collaboration and build space for continuous professional learning while thoughtfully considering the operational impacts of shifts different committees were tasked different problems the ISC level design teams focused on instructional design and administrative committees focused on operational scheduling involving Transportation the ISC level design teams

028conducted a review of current conditions in relation to lived experiences requirements and District constraints they identified core values and beliefs about student experiences structures and future considerations based on strategic blueprint 1.3 the committees then developed recommendations to enhance the school experience supporting students academic social emotional and behavioral development additionally they determined and recommended optimal learning conditions for students and staff providing rationale and examples the operational steering design team and level Administration identified unstructured time during arrival and dismissal as a contributor to discipline concerns they worked with teams to adjust strap off times considered to velopmental impacts of start times collaborated with a transportation consultant created schedule options and gathered leadership feedback for a final recommendation our district is proud to be a comprehensive system that serves students from Early Childhood through transition programs next we

029will share the proposals developed by each of our level design teams The Early Childhood design team has proposed several changes to enhance learning and better meet the needs of our youngest students first they recommend increasing planning and collaboration time to allow teachers to innovate and design instruction that aligns with Early Childhood standards and addresses each students's unique needs second the team proposes tailoring instruction to students develop mental stages by differentiating attendance times based on age level ensuring that each child receives the appropriate support and opportunities for growth finally they emphasize the importance of play-based preparation for kindergarten to help children transitioning from Early Childhood programs develop the skills and confidence they need for success in kindergarten the proposed schedule for Early Childhood introduces significant improvements to better meet the developmental needs of our students while

030supporting our Educator's ability to plan and collaborate under this proposal three-year-olds would attend only in the morning for a slightly shorter session of two hours and four to 5-year-olds would attend in the afternoon for the same 2 and a half hour session as before this change allows for tailored instruction align with each age group's developmental needs similar to our current structure on Mondays only students requiring additional supports would attend for targeted interventions ensuring they receive the focused help they need additionally on Friday mornings three-year-olds would not attend giving Educators the time to conduct home visits provide community events and collaborate with colleagues this schedule also allows Educators to have 55 minutes minutes of daily plan time a significant increase enabling them to design Innovative and individualized instruction for every student I will now share priorities

031for the elementary design team the elementary design team has identified several key proposals to address the current challenges and create a more consistent and effective School experience for our students and they proposed adding 15 minutes of time to the length of the student day in order to adequately address the first three components of their proposal first they propose built-in time for individualized in interventions and extensions to ensure that all students receive the support and enrichment they need second the team emphasizes the importance of establishing a daily morning meeting routine with explicit social and emotional learning opportunities to foster a sense of belonging and build essential life skills third they propose maximizing instructional time while accounting for non-instructional tasks like snacks and transitions finally the team recommend commends increasing opportunities for collaboration both within schools and

032across the district to ensure consistency and to empower teachers to work together to enhance student learning the sample first grade schedule reflects the proposed changes highlighting how we can create a more consistent and intentional structure for our elementary schools the schedule includes a dedicated 15minute Home Room period each day ensuring time for morning meetings and explicit social and emotional learning the routine Fosters a sense of community while setting a positive tone for the day Additionally the schedule accounts for necessary Transitions and non-instructional tasks without taking away from core content areas for example you will see 20 minutes allotted during the morning recess time even though recess is 15 minutes and there's 45 minutes allotted at the midday lunch and recess time even though combined they are 40 minutes this approach helps us maximize instructional time

033while addressing the logistical needs of the school day now I will share the priorities for the Middle School design team the Middle School design team has proposed several impactful changes to address current challenges and create a more balanced and enriching School experience for our students first they recommend increasing math instructional minutes to 53 to 60 minutes per day to align with best practices and provide deeper support for student learning attached to the math course is a 20 minute what I need period during which students stud can receive additional math intervention or enrichment from their math teacher or support from other Specialists and related service providers second the team proposes incorporating time for individualized interventions while ensuring students maintain access to exploratory offerings so no one has to sacrifice opportunities for support or enrichment they also

034suggest adding a weekly anchor day that includes advisory and a point of connection with all classes occurring this day would focus on building Community strengthening social emotional and profile of a learner skills and supporting connections across content areas Additionally the team emphasizes the need for deeper learning opportunities in math science and social studies with flexible time built in for Hands-On projects interdisciplinary connections and collaboration a flexible modified block for social studies and science means that teachers have the autonomy to collaborate and decide if a full block or split period is instructionally appropriate throughout the week a student may have a combination of science or social studies blocks as well as individual periods finally they propos adding Innovative exploratory choices to expand opportunities for students to explore their interests develop new skills and continue to build

035out Pathways aligned with the high school the proposed Middle School schedule introduces several enhancements designed to better meet student needs provide personalized learning opportunities and address key structural challenges students have many options in the exploratory pass that they can choose this schedule includes a flexible modified block which maintains a two period English language arts instructional block this slide increases the schedule increases mathematics instructional time to 53 to 60 Minutes daily aligning with best practices to ensure students have adequate time to deepen their understanding with a 20-minute win or what I need period attached to math offering individualized support for any content area including math tailored to student needs social studies or science are organized into flexible time blocks that can be combined or separated depending on the instructional needs of the day this structure supports

036deeper learning and Hands-On projects in these critical subjects students will now have access to two daily exploratory classes plus physical education ensuring opportunities for enrichment and personal growth choir band and Orchestra would now be embedded in the schedule and eliminating the need for students to regularly Miss core classes to participate additionally students receiving interventions will still be able to take an exploratory class ensuring equity and access for all daily PE and launch with recess remain a part of the daily schedule meeting students physical and social emotional needs we are looking at offering a variety of options for students to participate in during the recess period as many students have voed they want recess time but do not all want the traditional outdoor recess as it is now the schedule will also reduce one to two

037transitions per day decrease hallway traffic and improve overall flow additionally this structure supports the expansion of exploratory wheel classes giving students more choices and opportunities to explore diverse interests while fostering an engaging and supporting learning learning environment the recommended proposal is to have a weekly anchor day on Wednesday there will be an advisory to start the day and then students will progress through all of their classes we will now share our high school priorities one of the key shifts recommended by the design team is a focus towards deep learning this approach emphasizes inquiry based project oriented and collaborative work that allows students to apply their knowledge in real world scenarios longer periods of time are essential for engaging in these types of complex and impactful learning activities when student support time including when and sore

038were added to the high school schedule class periods were made shorter making it harder to meet our deep learning goals the level design team seeks to increase the time for student support while minimizing any impact on classroom instructional time a significant focus of the design team's work was to find the balance between maximizing instructional time while organizing it into larger chunks for deeper learning and provide more time for individualized interventions and social emotional support in order to accomplish all these objectives simultaneously a new way of thinking about time was necessary currently our students spend between 8 to 9 hours a day at school while only having between 5 and 6 hours of instruction daily the extra time in the school day is the result of Transitions and transportation constraints the design team has recommended a

039schedule which reduces unstructured time and creates a more compact efficient and engaging school day which we believe will also improve attendance and connection with school finally we recognize the importance of teacher collaboration currently limited to Wednesday morning late starts this time is insufficient to meet the growing demands of interdisciplinary and collaborative teaching the proposed schedule seeks to increase opportunities for Teacher collaboration to support the high quality learning experiences our students deserve to meet the goals of our desired State the high school design team recommends a block schedule this framework includes four block days and one anchor day in a typical 5-day week on block days each course is scheduled for 85 minutes of instruction with the third block extended by 52 minutes to allow for lunch lunch periods can occur at the beginning middle or

040end of this block and upper classmen will retain their off-campus lunch privileges block days are organized into two clusters A and B maintaining the current number of courses while adding an additional two 40-minute periods for interventions or Home Room the anchor day shown in the middle of the week follows a traditional high school schedule of 46 minute periods ensuring each course meets three times in a 5-day week in shortened weeks the anchor day would be eliminated to balance the schedule it is important to note that this is not the same block schedule used during pandemic learning this model doubles the amount of time available for interventions and student support reduces time spent in unstructured passing periods and compacts the school day by 35 minutes going from 7 hours and 25 minutes to 6 hours and

04150 minutes this adjustment allows students to get more sleep while giving faculty time to meet before school without needing a special schedule truly a win-win for both students and staff while the student day is shorter instructional minutes remain maximized teachers spend just as much time in instruction now as they do in the future as they do now but benefit from longer blocks which reduce reduces the need for tasks such as taking attendance and opening and closing each class the time used for these tasks has been converted into whenn and sore time which allows for more instruction in subjects where students may need additional support or the opportunity to extend their learning the flexibility to add time during the day in areas where students may need extension or support is designed to address the feedback we

042receive from students and staff and is in alignment with our level belief statement these longer blocks also enable deeper deeper learning activities allowing teachers and students to fully engage without interruptions or delays connections is District 203's tristem program serving students with disabilities aged 18 to 22 our connections program is already extraordinarily Innovative in its efforts to provide real world application and vocational training we are innovating their program through expansion and design of space and no scheduled changes are recommended at this time having having reviewed the final School experience recommendation from from the level design teams now let's shift our Focus to the operational recommendations necessary to support and Implement these changes the current schedule presents challenges for both student well-being and transportation efficiency research including guidance from the American Academy of P Pediatrics shows that

043adolescents need later start times due to biological sleep cycles while younger children naturally wake earlier and are better suited for an earlier start adolescents experience a natural shift in their circadian rhythms making it difficult for them to fall asleep early and wake up as early as our current schedule requires this misalign misalignment contributes to difficulties in focusing increased stress and negative impacts on mental health and academic performance performance on the other hand younger children tend to wake earlier making them better suited for an earlier start time the current schedule does not reflect these developmental differences which is why a stagger start time stagger starttime system would better meet the needs of all students with younger students starting earlier and older students starting later our current schedule does not align with these developmental differences additionally the

044nested scheduling model creates inefficiencies in transportation with only a 15minute gap between start times buses are stretched thin causing long wait times and supervision challenges some students arrive as early as 6:45 a.m. While others wait outside for up to 30 minutes before school given our limited capacity for additional buses land constraints and Driver shortages expanding resources isn't feasible a stagger start schedule will maximize our current Fleet reduce weight times improve supervision and create a school day structure that better supports student learning and well-being When developing the Stager schedule the operations committee carefully reviewed a wide range of factors to minimize disruptions and enhance the experience for students staff and families this included analyzing current bus routes ridership and Fleet usage sunrise and sunset times stakeholder impacts and feedback from the national School Bunch School service

045consultant the team also examined surrounding schools district schedules Transportation infrastructure and potential Partnerships to ensure a thoughtful and feasible plan currently start and end times for all levels are aligned in a way that creates inefficiencies in transportation and student well-being for the 25 26 school year we recommend adjusting start and end times to what is reflected on this Slide the recommendation for adjusting school start and end times was developed by the operational team steering committee and our national bus service consultant firm in close collaboration with principles District leaders and transportation experts the order of start and end times was was determined based on a combination of research-backed findings and operational constraints after careful consideration adding buses to our fleet was determined not to be feasible due to infrastructure Staffing financial and partnership constraints minimizing gaps

046further between start and end times would also create significant student supervision challenges shifting Elementary to a later start would cause more disruptions for families and delay middle and high school extracurricular buses until after 4:30 p.m. similarly shifting High School later would limit District participation in conference events and negatively affect student inter internships and jobs our transportation consultant conducted simulations that showed buses need at least 35 to 40 minutes between each level's bus routes which we have decreased already in our recommendation additionally minimizing the gaps between St and end times further would increase supervision challenges as mentioned previously especially for elementary students who would require additional supervision if their start time was pushed later in summary these are the highlights of the proposed structural changes within our recommendation this evening now that we've outlined the proposed

047structural changes and detailed rationale we will transition to discussing the outcomes and metrics that will help us monitor the success of these shifts in this section we'll explore the key indicators we'll use to assess the effectiveness of the changes ensuring that we can track progress address challenges and make adjustments as needed to ensure the best possible outcome for our students and staff this slide communicates a three-year professional learning Focus areas that will support our staff in effectively implementing and adapting to the recommended shifts in the school day structure and experience for students we will utilize professional learning structures such as Institute days professional learning communities career 203 and job embedded learning structures to ensure professional learning is consistent and ongoing as we Implement these changes we will monitor progress using three-year professional learning metrics focused

048on key outcomes for Effective instruction we will track improved student math proficiency teacher engagement in Block scheduling training and lesson plans with chunked instruction and clear transitions wind sore inter interventions will be dated driven showing measurable student growth for student engagement inal success will be measured through fewer tardies increased intendance reduced disciplinary incidents and the use of active learning strategies belonging in relationships will be assessed through peer collaboration student surveys on connectedness and ensuring inclusive teaching practices and strong teacher to- student relations as we move forward with implementing the new schedule instructional practices we do anticipate challenges challenges can be complex and require effort and resilience to overcome we strongly believe our students deserve our resilience and our efforts families will need time to adjust to the new schedule and staff will need learning and

049support to adapt to the updated schedules and new instructional practices additionally there is the impact on contract negotiations with our unions establishing consistency and homework expectations within a block schedule will be important as will refining the transportation schedule once writers ship data is available lastly we will review Middle School extracurricular transportation and start times to ensure alignment and efficiency ongoing through our implementation at all levels the new Innovative School experience maximizes instructional time increases intervention and extension opportunities and enhances student engagement belonging it allows for more differentiation interdisciplinary learning and staff collaboration while improving Transportation efficiency to reduce unstructured time at the EC level we believe the experience will provide stronger family connections and a developmentally aligned curriculum will better support our youngest Learners and will promote kindergarten Readiness Elementary shifts will Foster consistent learning

050experiences across schools and increase targeted support while protecting core instructional minutes and Fin finally at the 612 level middle school students will gain two days of exploratory courses including performance music increased math minutes and targeted intervention time and at both levels later start times align with adolescent research and reduced unstructured time May decrease disciplinary incidents a more manageable workload Fosters deeper student teacher connections while high school students will retain their instructional minutes and access to high quality courses tonight throughout the process we have sought to tell the full story of our charge and our work we know that a great way to do that is by listening to the voices of those um we work with and so here's a small window into that very important perspective when we really tear it down and think

051about the primary goal of education is not just to do well in school we want them to be successful when they leave us as well our kids are demanding different and the technology is changing at such a rapid Pace as a generation that wants to take advantage of that and how it supports them and helps them who we are what we do and how we do it is changing continues to change every day and that continues to be true addressing these barriers is essential to creating the kinds of learning environments that will prepare students for their Futures at its core innovating the school experience is about transforming learning opportunities and creating flexible scheduling to meet the needs of all students as they prepare for their future have the time and tools to iterate innovate and

052build Dynam dnamic authentic learning experiences [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] I am really really excited about the innovative school day um and the possibilities that it brings for both the teachers and the students uh being a math teacher of course I'm excited about the extended math time um because I think it gives kids um the time and the flexibility to really reflect on their math um and build those connections I'm really excited to be able to like receive support in like a lot of the classes I'm taking especially in my senior year where I'm like kind of challenging myself with a few AP classes that I'm not really like well versed in I think being able to have the time with like off before schools and like having like flexible win sessions it um really allows

053me to like get support especially if I'm struggling in something so starting school later would definitely help me cuz it gives me more time to get up get ready for the day and then I could actually be better at first period and actually like give them my all cuz I'm fully awake and my mind's like okay I'm ready for the day I got this um I think students will be able to experience a more efficient day where they are not having to arrive by bus up to an hour before school begins integrating band Orchestra and choir into the school day would help because um then kids would get more time for like superise study where some kids have a harder time focusing at home and need the superise study environment to be able to focus

054better if we're looking to add new classes I think that they should add some more Arts programs because some kids outside of school maybe don't have time or maybe some families don't have the funds to afford arts classes I honestly love the whole idea of the blog schedule and how like all of our classes are getting longer because I feel like number one is more similar to the college experience and number two I just feel like you're kind of more in the zone with longer classes and you'll just have more time to like understand your material I like uh new things happening so I think it excites me a lot when like my schedule gets changed or I get a new exploratory I would like an extra period for math cuz sometimes I feel like

055we don't have enough time to work and understand everything that we're [Music] doing school Improvement has always been and always will be our North Star today our commitment to that Northstar extends beyond the traditional roles of our school systems and structures it's about responding to the evolving needs of our students an educational system truly fulfills its purpose when it actively cultivates conditions that align With The Changes our students are calling for both explicitly and implicitly together we're not merely reacting to the change We're The Architects of a new era in education as we build these New Foundations we're shaping a future where every students potential is recognized cultivated and empowered we're excited by this work and the opportunities it provides for every student the February 18th Board of Education meeting we'll bring back this agenda

056item and seek and recommend board action for the Innovative School experience learning structures and the proposed school start and end times additionally our recommendation would be the that we transition and Implement at the start of the 2025 2026 school year thank you for sharing a portion of your evening with us uh we're grateful for your dedication and partnership trusting us with your students together we'll create opportunities and set them up for success in their Futures I'd also like to call your attention uh to the information included in board dos in addition to tonight's presentation you'll find uh links to many different documents uh to provide additional information in support of our recommendation okay so at this time just as a reminder to to the board we'll go through our questions and comments time um and

057I will recognize each individual to ask questions or comments and as per our board agreements we will share time with each other um after each person has had a turn we'll go back around if necessary and if you do ask a question please state if you sent that question ahead of time questions or comments from the board Melissa well preparing for this I did what I usually do and I look at all the district documents and I start formulating my questions um what I also take into account is the feedback I get from the community because I represent you this is just the emails I got um from the last board meeting and uh only two of them do not not show parents staff members or students having significant concerns they bring thank you for

058sharing this with me because I hear the perspective of so many different people and it makes me a better decision maker but what I learned is my Approach is not going to work tonight there are so many valid questions and concerns in here that there is no way they could be addressed right now adequately so I prepared my own statement that I'd like to read um it's abundantly clear that the parents and staff have fundamental concerns with being excluded from participating in the decision-making process from the beginning do not feel that the plan is developed enough to be properly implemented next year and that the hardships created for our families as well as staff far outweigh any potential benefits at this time many parents and staff members have continuously complained that the super the superintendent

059and school board do not listen to their cons concerns or valuable insights I would like to see tonight's meeting focus on repairing and strengthening the community's trust in the school board we are all living in radically Changing Times that will cause B big challenges to our educational system and the lives of our families I think our parents and staff need to feel that the school board prioritizes their concerns and well-being the desire to be viewed as an Innovative School District should not outweigh the school board's oath to represent the voice and best interests of our community unfortunately unfortunately I think the board intends to support the superintendent and push for a vote before the next election other questions or comments at this time from the board Charles all right um thank you for uh the

060presentation um so uh I I sent a number of questions I had in fact I think I sent 21 questions um and I I know they're not all going to get the opportun we're going to get the opportunity to answer all of them but I know you do have them and I know that uh you'll get back to us with uh with the information but I did want to um share uh some sentiments I had I had the opportunity to speak to a number of parents personally on this in addition to we receive several emails and things like that um and the overall sentiment one one parent put it this way um uh she said parents and famili structure their lives around their kids um and these changes are going to cause a major disruption

061to family routines and while there are a lot of questions around the academic side of this and there's a lot of data a lot of research and the reasons behind why some of the structural changes are being made um I think the biggest challenge that I heard from the members of the community that I spoke to was the logistics and the disruption that this is going to cause to folks in terms of the scheduling um just the upsetting of the routines and um and that's that that those are a lot of the questions that I have are reflective of that um also significant concern around kind of decision timing know there's been a lot of information that's been shared around the rationale for this but some specifics specifically around the scheduling and the going from

062nesting to to to staggering and the earlier start time for elementary school is something that's a very relatively recent development part of it it was not um shared at the last presentation the rationale for why to do this was but the specifics of what that was going to mean for families and I think that's when it really hit home for folks that you know now my elementary school has to get up you know has to be 745 and that's a significant difference um the other concern that was expressed was the The Ordering of the Staggering so you have many families who have uh Elementary age students who also may have one who's in is in junior high and so the the significant gap between those two again creates significant disruption in terms of the way

063that uh those kids are going to be able to get themselves up and ready for school um and and really just again that that level of disruption um so that's kind of some of the overall sentiments that I heard um and um you know I think the other piece is that um because the information around the scheduling was not released until relatively recently um you know folks are feeling a little bit blindsided and the thing that I heard overwhelmingly from basically everyone I spoke to was that their concern is having enough time to transition to uh some of these changes effectively to be able to reap some of the benefits that um have been talked about you know in the research that's been quoted so those are some of the the concerns that I wanted

064to share on behalf of the community members that I spoke to um and one question I will ask and then I'll yield my time and I know we all do rounds of questions but um is really getting an understanding of um you know how and we talked a little bit about this in the presentation but how do we plan to measure the effectiveness of the changes and what is the expected trajectory of those metrics so I think at the last meeting one of the things I talked about was I get the rationale for why we want to do this and how we need to be Innovative but a lot of it has to come down to the how we have to recognize that there's there families behind every one of these changes we make uh

065and the hardship and the burden that we could be creating is important for us to factor in and take into consideration before we make um this level of wholesale change so um you know understanding and providing some level of an you know uh information around the fact that change is hard and being able to say okay so this is what we would expect some of the downsides to be here are some of the things we would help to put in place to mitigate um some of these challenges for families can you give me a sense of What Not only what some of the expected shortterm issues are going to be how we're going to get through those and then um what mitigation strategies we'll put in place to help the families who are the ones

066who are going to have to um execute on this and that's that's the family side of it there's a whole another set of questions I have around um our Educators and preparing them for these types of changes uh in an effective way so can you give me some sense of that yeah I'll invite to to um support this response as well I'd re recall your attention to slides number 48 49 and 50 in the presentation where we've identified really I would say um a couple significant buckets in terms of areas of implementation metrics metrics uh one around the the effective instruction uh built around student outcomes specifically as we're targeting uh in mathematics uh the use of uh time like win or SAR uh in regard to personalize the instruction in supporting kids in terms

067of either what additional support they need uh to to reach standard or extension Beyond um so I think that would be one we would anticipate um academic outcomes second would be around student U engagement and belonging as well as supporting our profile of the learner skills um so kind of looking at um opportunities through that you know kind of the deeper learning experiences uh to be able to help them hit those as well and we recognize listen I I I do not want I I recognize and it changes hard and these schedule changes um would impact everyone right and so we recognize that so there are there will be an adjustment to that um in terms of timing of our recommendation it really is has the process worked out our design teams were asked to

068create what their recommendations were around their priorities um and it really took us to the time that it has taken as well as collaboration with a transportation consultant around looking at scheduling of of things so we do anticipate that there will be there will be um challenges um the benefits we've identified uh would be the again uh instructional time increase intervention time uh extension time uh focus on belonging sense of belonging among uh our students relationships among students and staff um and so you know I think we've identified those on those slides right there um in terms of looking at specific um growth targets and numbers will continue to Ed that through our school improvement process with our schools independently looking at their data and setting the numbers I don't know if there's anything that

069we wish to add to that Jane no but we do have a um professional learning threeyear outcome and Metric stack that should have been uploaded in board so we will ensure that that gets up Amanda again I just want to thank everyone for the hard work that has gone into coming up with the proposals that we have here you know was obviously the video as a snapshot of you know how there was a lot of effort um to engage multiple voices in the decisions I so I I want to applaud some of the things that um I really appreciate like one I really appreciate just focusing on the Innovative school day around adding more time in that middle school and high school around math because that's one of our areas that we've been struggling with

070um and so being able to provide more time and attention on that to ensure that every student succeeds and I really do believe that that and then also adding in those win sections in those areas will really I believe provide that structure that can help us um close that achievement Gap so that's something I I think is really important and I'm really pretty much on board with the change of the the scheduling uh for the junior high and high school what I think is really challenging though is when you have the adjustment of the the schedule because that is something that's going to have a huge ripple effect everywhere right because 203 is such a huge body in this community and so it not only affects um uh families but also you know as you

071mentioned all the community uh things that work with youth and families and I'm just thinking about myself as a working parent currently have three middle schoolers and if my work day starts at 9: and my kids are getting on at school at 8:50 how do I even get to work on time you know what I mean um it's it's things like that that um I'm wondering if we can consider like a phase in you know focusing on changing the school day and then giving us a year to be able to possibly look at and really think about Chang changes in schedules and like what really makes sense being able to give people a chance to adjust their schedules I'm not and just really thinking about does is this the type of schedule that makes the

072most sense right you know because when you have and I you were saying okay bus routes are 35 minutes and so you have your elementary school that's 35 minutes to high school and then 30 minutes to the junior high one of my actual questions is do you use your whole Fleet for every single section is a whole Fleet out for elementary whole Fleet out for high school whole Fleet out for Middle School uh currently the answer is no um but in this proposal we're looking to maximize the efficiency of the fleet and we are using the majority of and we're talking about the big large 71 passenger buses at this time because there's lots of other uh fact factors when you when you say that but if you're looking at the what you would consider

073you know a large school bus um there is most of them are being used at all three levels except uh we have some spars to handle various situations uh especially at the end of the day for athle athletic runs at the high school and at the junior high so there's less a few less being used at the junior high okay um and so how did that go into like if you're if the majority of buses are out for elementary but there's less for junior high and high school except for maybe after school how does that go into figuring out what is actually needed for the start day because again just looking at there's almost an hour gap between elementary and middle school and most families kind of have that succession right you know um so

074I'm just curious when you say there's an hour gap between for the start date I'm so for elementary at 7:45 and then the Middle School 850 right and then High School is 8:20 right so that's why I'm just like if you're a parent that has a third grader and a sixth grader right then you have to wait almost an hour before you get and so I'm like well how's that going to avoid loitering at the middle school level now for an hour you know if parents have to drop them off and get to school or get to work you know versus right now we have the loitering at the high school level that are being dropped off an hour before school does that make sense yes and the at the Middle School there's there's they're

075being dropped off early too sometimes they wait in the bus for an extended period of time yeah currently the bus is arrive around 7:20 to 7:30 we start school at 8:00 currently so maybe it's not 60 minutes but uh that amount of time with our age group is difficult to a difficult way to start our day so how would this new schedule change that help me understand that I'm a little bit more visual I'm just so the difference is the transportation consultant has uh run the routes so that the students would arrive um so that they have enough time so they start their time much earlier now so that they can get to the elementary route really at the end of the day because they're nested in so they're worried about getting the elementary students

076to their start time to meet the start day of school so they deliver the high school students early then they start the middle school route and Deliver us early just so they have enough time because we have 91 buses for the elementary route we have 14 Schools the most of the majority of the buses or all of them and all of our drivers at least are needed for that Elementary route so they have to start so much earlier uh One support that wasn't mentioned um yet is that we obviously know um that the Middle School start time uh could be a concern for many for some families so we have two Community Partners currently who are interested in doing an in school before school program for any families that would be interested um similar to

077what some elementary schools have so we do have two partners interested in doing that for all five schools if that is something we choose to do but would that add a cost to [Music] families for I mean currently yeah if they're outside Partners it would be a cost if a student or family is considered free or reduced lunch they do get waivers or reduced fees okay um and then what did you do what have you guys done as a District to think about the Ripple effects of how this will impact um the larger community and the youth um um engagement so like clubs and things like that right yeah you want to talk about the junior high school Lis just do you mean Community Partners like not the clubs and exploratories within our schools yeah

078so we have reached out to several Community Partners um the large majority of them that we've been able to connect with have said that they are flexible and they will work with schedules to make sure kids can still have access things to things they're passionate about okay I I'm done I again I just you know since the schedule came out we've had like 62% of the U communication coming in is negative so it just gives a lot of pause right so I just wanted to State kind of where I'm at Charles did you have a yeah I thought I'd just do a followup I mean I thought somebody else had their hand up but Okay Go Okay I I just thought that our convention was we would let everybody speak before we that's fine I

079didn't know Joe had his hand up either go ahead Joe thanks yeah I um Echo what others have said about um you know the feedback that we've gotten uh recently uh I appreciate um all the emails that we've gotten um and really recognize that the um that the schedule of the school day is uh really the biggest impact and um Charles asked some and uh Amanda asked some very good questions about uh kind of those areas um I do want to follow up with one more area one more question on that and then uh transition to kind of um the implementation of the schedule uh um the the school day um and that is the um the ordering of the uh of the schools um in the slide that was shown um the other districts

080that were compared uh start uh go high school middle school elementary uh do you have examples of districts that uh do the Elementary first and uh what's the literature around um Elementary School uh children's schedules so there are other districts that start with Elementary then do high school then do middle school and the research with Elementary is well yes they do need sleep that they really thrive on routines and schedules and consistency and so if you do change bedtime um and wake up times of elementary students they're going to thrive when they have that consistency of their bed times and their wakeup times and they will be engaged in learning early and ready to go for the day and the start times um are they around 7:45 or I know is this a comparable uh

081start time to those districts that do Elementary first so there are districts that have start our current start time is 8:15 there are surrounding districts that have start times that are earlier than 8:15 I would want to get you specifics on the exact times and the different districts there are ones that start before our current time yes thank you um and then I wanted to uh switch over to uh some of the implementation of the Innovative school day um and um jump to one of the comments that was brought up at the um uh High School ssac uh meeting around um you kind of the the class structure um for an 85-minute um uh School block and the uh um preparation and professional development around that um you know I I I'm an educator I've

082had to transition courses from a 50 minute 3-day a week uh uh schedule to a 75 minute two-day a week schedule and um the feel for those classes is very different and um making sure that the uh students are engaged that that the active learning is in place um that it's not the 85 minute that the students uh are concerned about is really critical um and uh yeah I just um I'm curious to to hear where the uh planning uh is in terms of um you kind of restructuring that curriculum and uh ensuring that the uh professional development is there and and would be delivered in time uh to really ramp up at the beginning of next year um is this something that has been going on already um or you know is this something

083that that can be uh put in place on such a short time scale yeah the answer to that is both right we know we have continued professional learning to do and like I said I will we will ensure that you get that three-year professional learning outcomes and metrics that detailed document that we have prepared for you um but we absolutely so some has already started at the high school but we know there's much more to do and like we were saying earlier that will be done through different professional learning structures that we have in place such as our Institute days our professional learning communities will utilize career 203 but just like with any sort of initiative um and shift in practice we will have um professional learning attached to that thank you yeah and I

084I realize that there's you know a lot of Shifting that goes on um uh I'm actually pretty interested in this block schedule um and block schedules I think work well especially for things like The Sciences um where where you can have continuous Labs uh for a long period um and uh but but it has to be done very thoughtfully and it has to be done right um in order for it to uh you be effective and even then when it's done right the the first you know year or two or will be bumpy there there will be bumps in the road right um and that's no matter where you're teaching when you're putting a new curriculum in there's a learning curve so I think it's important for the community to understand that uh and for

085everybody to uh you know kind of uh you know know that any transition like this is is challenging um and that there's you know kind of a learning curve that that goes on with it Kristen so I want to thank the community for are coming um it's it's exciting to see so many people be passionate um and we appreciate your communication as well um the board isn't always able to answer all of the emails that we get because of the volume but we appreciate you sharing your concerns so that we understand the different kinds of things that need to be um looked at I also want to thank the huge group of people who have put so much time and effort into thinking about this proposal um I want to think a little bit about

086why we're doing this because clearly it's hard as we are seeing it's hard to think about these changes and it's hard to look at schedules and all these kinds of things which make a difference so I want to go back to some of the things that we've talked about at this board for years and one of the things that we've talked a lot about is that we are not able goal to help all student all students be successful we have enormous gaps between our student populations and we are not providing for the success for each of our students and so I appreciate you taking a look at all the different things that we do to see how we can do better because we have to so looking at um our performance I'm looking specifically at

087math because a lot of this is about math so I I'm looking at our data Patrick you're the data person so you can jump in here and correct me if I'm wrong and I know that we talked a lot about math and language when we looked at our scores and the area where we haven't caught up to our pre-pandemic performance is math it's not enormous when you look at the average but I'm I pulled out just the 11 th grade and just the eighth grade because that's where we're looking at all these changes we're looking at Junior High adding to the math and in high school you know one of the presentations that I thought at the ssac was so helpful was looking at how you could have a math block plus a win or

088SAR the day in the middle the block the date so that would add not just add minutes it adds um focus time which is you know looking at as we've worked to try to say how can we help all students do well how can we still help the groups that need to accelerate their growth how can we help all of them that that's known we know that focused time does make a difference so I want to ask um from the group that has worked on this if you could speak specifically to what you looked at on math and how would it could be used under this model to impact some of the groups of students that we're really looking at and I I looked at both the average in 8th grade and 11th grade we

089haven't caught up in eth grade or 11th grade on average or in our groups and the and the order of magnitude of gaps for some of our student groups is 40 to 50% for some and some 20s and some 30s but I'm thinking specifically of of of some of those students how will you use this can you give us more detail as to how you will use us in the junior high and the high school level to help all of our students be able to graduate from District 203 and be able to meet standards in math yeah go ahead uh specific to the Middle School model we are excited for the in increase in time per day it ends up being over 80 minutes per week just of instruction and then another 100 minutes that

090can be utilized for what I need that would put us in uh the best practice range specifically what you're talking about is we are very proud of our students overall proficiency and attainment we are we have work to do when we look at even similar um demographics and across the state with our rate of growth specifically with subgroups and so it does call for a need for us to have more time as well as time to break down and work in small groups on groups on skills that they need and uh so we do think the additional mathematics minutes can help us address specifically subgroup performance and rate of growth uh our attainment overall is very good and I actually think I'll take it from a an EC to 12 lens so when we really

091think about um early trumps later right and I think some of our shifts that we're looking at DC are very much being directed at aligned curriculum even for our littlest Learners and of course that would be developmentally through play we we definitely believe in play for our youngest ones but increasing that tier one for early childhood and we look at what we're what we're proposing for elementary we'd get more differentiated time for targeted interventions during that wind time more at more at um Junior High and then more more at um differentiated time uh for math if if students need math the one thing that's nice um for the wi time is what I need not everyone will need math but we absolutely know that Kristen that we that we definitely need to address math so

092we'll have more targeted time for that so we hope not just in middle school and high school it's not just shouldered on on those two areas but the whole system increases because we know more time on task in C in subjects matters and so to increase math minutes across matters and that will increase our student achievement um and our growth my next question is with regard to specifically looking at the high school so I was a part of the profile of a learner group and thank you to all of you who attended that because there was a huge group of our community that also looked at the kinds of skills that we need to help our students have as they graduate adaptability work-based experiences all those kinds of things I know that this block has

093you know positives and negatives and there's a lot of things that would need to go into it instructionally but how does that structure impact our efforts to ensure that we are able to help as many students as possible have those kinds of innovative workplac experience because I know that we are ahead of some school districts but we're behind many others and I know that as our students are getting ready to apply for colleges that they utilizing the information that that that that that they learn in these kinds of experiences to help them go on for their career and and college goals I don't mean behind I just mean I know that we there are some districts where people are graduating with you know more credits or those kinds of things the way I look at

094that that kind of work is that we're in time that is just what our students need right now so can you tell us how this kind of a structure impacts those kinds of goals so I'm going to talk about our work-based learning experiences and how a block can can enhance those so right now our high school um is working on a high school audit and they're looking at classes and they're really looking at how can I embed some of these um work challenges um into our classes which does require some some extra time and those work-based challenges incorporate all the profile of a learner skills now as a district we still need to look and say okay we have our profile of a learner skills what does that look like at Kinder what does that

095look like in third grade what does it look like in fifth and seventh and 12th and so we do need to look at that as we align just skills in general when we think about you know content's important but our skills very much are as well and so those work-based challenges that our high school is really working on most a lot of our courses in our Pathways we we'll need a work-based challenge for our diploma endorsements so they're coming to us and saying okay in this course we want to um designed this work-based Challenge and that that absolutely has those skills embedded because it's not just content we have to have our students know how to be critical thinkers adaptive Global Citizens have different perspectives so all of those will be embedded within the work

096based challenge when we work with our um Innovative um work-based uh Council that uh Mr whle talked about today they've are also pointed out the skills that actually align directly with our profile of learner and those will be embedded just like when we talked about professional learning it's not just the content how do you chunk content but how do you import skills within that and that's something our staff does very very well when we think about the um seal that our staff does with our um students they're very intentional and that we just have to identify that more I have more questions but I know that other people have questions so just go ahead Donna first of all thank you thank you all for um being here um coming together and sharing um the research

097that our uh staff has put together and the concerns that have um you know our audience members here um I can assure you your read your emails have been read um your voices are important and they've been heard um and I thank you for your patience as you um you know walk through the presentation with us and our questions and I really look forward to your questions um as well so thank you again um my colleagues have shared that like that we do understand how challenging that changes so I did send a number of questions ahead of time one of my questions in particular is uh you know as we continue um to the point where uh the board makes a decision and uh whether or not we um Implement um just move forward as

098a community I want to understand how the uh our parents students teachers staff and Community will continue to have input and an opportunity to understand better I know that you've you've explained some of that but I think that Gathering continued input and and hearing those voices are important so help me with that yeah go ahead listen I think uh we are working really hard to expand the ways in which we're seeking feedback and opportunities for that so we've talked a lot about additional um community events and listening sessions for staff Etc as we continue to move forward should this be approved and and I guess as a follow-up to that is as we get that feedback and that information like tonight from our community Through the emails um you know as we seek more input

099from staff how is there room for us to Pivot and make adjustments to address those needs I think we've already been doing that to be honest just last week because of the lot of feedback we received from families specifically about middle school starting late and the impact that that would be immediately Mrs boute reached out to some Community Partners to say do you have the capacity to potentially offer before school care so that's one example of something that we we've already done so I think we will continue and be transparent about and post to our site about here's the feedback we're receiving and here's been our response now depending upon what is approved and the timeline and all that like there may be some things that we may not be able to Pivot on um

100and we're also looking for kind of themes throughout that feedback right so what what is the general consensus about the feedback and can we do something to accommodate or pivot or modify our plan to be responsive to that I also just wanted to add on I think we continually have to look at the data that is in front of us so a lot of the recommendations specific to the plans like at the middle school level was to decrease exclusionary discipline and unstructured times to increase our rate of mathematics growth to increase our sense of belonging by building uh allowing for deeper connections and relationships with staff and students like increasing the use of student Voice through a variety of groups so by utilizing all the data whether it's academics discipline attendance um as well as

101the survey data we have a plethora of data from Community we have five Essentials we have staff surveys we have morale surveys uh the feedback the Innovative school day design team would have to continue to meet as well as all levels have some form you know of leadership so at the middle school level meetings with Department chairs team leaders that follow through athletic directors with principles today the principales and myself met again today to review and talk about some of the feedback that we we've received via emails and how we need to continue to move forward to come to consensus so I think on a daily basis there is a review of some data point in a thought a thought process around how can we improve how can we make tomorrow better than today and

102part that is a lot of the cabinets job but also our leadership teams and so um we would continue to do that and uh you know on behalf of the middle schools increasing our visibility their access to us and then following up on if we add additional exploratories what what are what do the staff feel the curriculum needs the professional learning needing needed um so I do think uh there is a lens of transparency around the recommendation and then from the operational recommendation of start end times we have to look at how the logistics are falling into place how many students and families actually want the before school care and will utilize it um what does our club and athletic supervision and coaching look like are buses really ready to you know are they ready

103to go at dismissal and what is our conference time so that constant communication with our conference schools which has already been going on for a few weeks um around those things like we would have to monitor and ensure that if it's not working we can't wait a whole year we have to revise and and react to it so I think looking at the data and the times we we have no choice but to address it in the moment our kids deserve better and and I really appreciate that the global perspective the research based behind the the presentation that you're giving but I also really appreciate the detail of the the individual family experience of what they're sharing with us that they how this is going to affect my family right like I think that it's

104important that we look at both aspects of that and um and I'm glad that you've looked into uh you know before school care being available I just don't think that some families are going to necessarily be able to afford that or have planned or budgeted for that you know so I think that we need to we need to be aware of that as well so I think I I mean I appreciate it we you know I think we just need to continue the conversations and have open conversations one thing that I did not send ahead that I heard today that's a little concerning to me is um before school clubs now I know that that happens in high school currently um I I know that some of that happens in junior high as well but

105to me that um I'm my concern with that is that we're undoing the benefit of what we're trying to implement of a later St start so how I I think we need to be careful with um addressing that with our staff I don't want us to uh have the late start because of all the research of how important that is and then undo that so talk to me a little bit about the guide rails or you know how we're going to put that in place currently each school has a variety of before and after school um Athletics and intermurals the next steps in conversations with the principles today was that they were going to go back to the athletic directors gain some more information and look at how many clubs at each of our schools

106because it does vary on the time of day that they are occurring and what that would mean obviously you still want to have access to before and after school and we don't want to you know some students can do morning better and some students can do after school and so we do want to make sure that our students have access and are there additional activities or opportunities throughout the day to leverage their voice okay one last comment before I I'll I'll yield and then I have some more questions um I've spent a lot of last year advocating with ihsa because we have students who are swimming five hours a day partially before school partially after school I didn't send this ahead but we've talked about this before in this meetings um I would hate to

107have us move this and then have those students practicing even more before school than they are like you know like starting at the same time that they're starting now with those practices but with a later school start so I think we really need to be conscious about that I'm I'm concerned about uh how we're going to make sure that we are addressing that um ihsa came out with some recommendations based on all that advocacy um because NCAA has 4our restrictions and ihsa doesn't have any so this is an important passionate piece for me that um our students mental health depends on and if we're really going with the research we have to make sure that we're being true to that so you know you know I I know you sort of answered that already but

108it's it's important that we put something in place to put some guide rails on that to have more to help me on that I'll I'll take that one for Alison I feel like she's had to take the brunt of that that's more of a high school question uh the the entire purpose of this was to try and get students more sleep not to add more time on a swim practice thank you so that the students mental health is GE is one of the top priorities of all this work I'm going to yield but I do have a host of other questions that I've that I've sent that I you know may or may not a lot of my questions from last time um from the last meeting um you have nicely innovated or or implemented

109into this uh Prof or into this presentation so you know I asked it about when we were thinking about implementing that's now been given I asked um to uh review some communication that's gone out to like staff and like the process of that and the parent feedback um and the process for communicating to parents you've imple you've put that nice timeline in there so um thank you because I I see a lot of my questions that I asked at the last Mee were put into your presentation so um I I have a couple comments right now um to reiterate what Donna said I do appreciate Administration I see the questions that have been asked and I see the that the presentation was it has evolved based on the feedback we're getting that you're receiving not

110only from the board but from the community um the other thing that I I want to State um in listening to my colleagues and reading through the presentation many times even prior to the time I've been on the board the board has been very um they have directed their efforts at making sure we're serving all students and putting resources in place when that they when gaps um deficiencies were identified and they were have always been and I'm I'm speaking about prior to my time they had always had an eye on serving all students and I feel that in my time on the board we have continued that we identify things that are needed and the board has been uh supportive of allocating resources for that I see this a I see this recommendation is a

111continuation of that because the one thing that I feel we have not fully addressed is the time Factor I've heard that for many years I'm finishing up I'm coming up on eight years on the board how time is so important students need more more time staff need more time to make sure our students are successful so this proposal for me feels like that's where we're at now we've we've done so much and we've done such a good job with it but now we have to address this piece that being said I do support the recommendation because I do like how it addresses time but I am concerned that we might be doing this too quickly and so in my mind what I've in my mind and i' I've shared this with Administration is that is

112there a way to phase this in so that everyone in the community everybody who's affected by this because this is everybody this is not one section of segment of students or one school Community this is the entire community if we could somehow my brain just keeps going back to if we could phase this in and so maybe we do part of the change in 25 26 school year and then the 26 27 school year I don't want to see an implementation over 10 years that's not what I'm talking about phasing in but giving everyone a chance to adjust to one piece and then the you know taking a a second piece to it so that we give ourselves the time to have the professional learning so that our students are served to the best of

113the abilities that our educators will serve them and we have families time to make the adjustments they need to to best fit their family situations um I don't want to see this go away in any way shape or form um I just want it to be and I said this at at the last board meeting I've always been proud when I was a parent and Community member and I'm and as a board member I've always been proud of the fact that we learn from other districts we take the time to figure out how it's going to best work for us and we make those changes and so I feel that this is one of those opportunities there will be bumps in the road it would be disingenuous of anyone to ever suggest that change would

114be super smooth but maybe we can lessen the bumps a little bit they don't have to be as severe and I just want to make sure that how we do this keeps our students fully at the center every single one of our students has to be at the center of this and I want to make sure and I think Kristen had made mention about being just in time we've had a lot of focus on coming out of the pandemic and rightfully so and recovering learning loss and we've done a fantastic job with that but just the recovery we cannot be satisfied by saying we got to X point we have to say we've got there and what are we now going to do going forward because complacency has never been part of nville 203 and

115so that's where I'm at with this I want to see this move forward because our kids need stuff that in some ways we haven't even been able to Envision and we cannot just say it's good enough that we got out of that period of time we have to keep looking forward because that is exactly what this district has always been we are forward thinking we are extremely professional and the commitment to our students is unmatched so that those are just my thoughts um my questions have always all been answered I know they're part of the FAQs um with that I know we can I oh please follow up on that I think it's just really important thank you for what you just shared um to to go back to kind of what's all within the

116recommendation that has just been shared this evening it's really made up of multiple parts right and you know these multiple Parts the recommendation was really created or brought to the Board of Education through different ways right I'm going to take us back to like really 2018 and before 2018 um where as a a part of the first strategic blueprint we'd identified this as a priority and started to do some work and like it was this time it was a cross-section of people throughout the district whether they be Educators administrators even s surveys through students and parents about their school day experience were used to try to work toward recommendations and we never formally brought a recommendation to the board um because it it was clear that we weren't there yet right and we didn't have

117it where we needed it needed it to be um and I don't know that we were really explicit enough on on the why okay why we want these recommendations and so really you know within our overall you know the comprehensive recommendation here there is now again as a result of about almost two years of work uh among admin administrators and various staff to try to address the barriers that are getting in the way of either collaboration learning belonging all of the overall School experience collaborated to create the the recommendations through the design team and the recommendations came forward because it was the consensus of those teams that those recommendations of the instructional shifts uh that had to be made or we should make came from those committees right and so there may have been individuals

118in each team that didn't fully agree but it was agreed that the these are these are the things that we need to do and then kind of looking at so now I'm going to skip to the recommendation from us that we presented tonight because we believe these shifts need to happen to your point was that we do that for the 25 26 school year right but these are changes we we get that we understand that we believe we can be ready for these but but that's something that through the feedback that we've received we'll we'll have to continue to evaluate right I do not want to see these recommendations go these are the right things for our experiences in the schools in our classrooms for our kids and I think responsive to data that we

119have um from staff as well my hesitation on delaying would be that it gets set aside right right so that was part of our our basis for our recommendation for this coming year but you know we're in February right I get that so that's something that has to be considered now regarding the school start and end times you know we've we've done our best to try to be granted you know transparent about the the windows right that we said no earlier than this no later than this but then when you see it and we get to how this is going to impact me and my family and potentially my child and participation things that's that's an impact so that has to be considered but I think through the board conversation here you know I I

120just want to bring you back to um our design teams worked hard to come forward with recommendations that they thought would shift the experience for both students and staff and we can't lose those but we do have to be responsive to feedback that we got so that'll be something that'll be a part of our conversation moving forward thank you Charles um can I ask you to hold on for just a second okay um so I'm I'm I was going to ask the board in general um would you be willing to consider moving saving our next round of questions and comments for when it comes back under without action so that the public commenters who signed up can then just in in an effort to be respectful of everyone's time is the board okay with that

121Charles did uh so yes I would be but my my other question would be I know that the original at least my understanding of when we were introducing this topic was that this was the without action and it would be I I would propose if there's an opportunity to create a little bit more space and time to allow for those broader discussions to happen not just the public comment tonight but uh it just seems that there are a lot of things that need to be ironed through um and I don't know that it it doesn't sound to me like we'd be fully ready by the next but I I I would commend pushing it okay the decision we can we'll we can talk um board leadership we can with the superintendent we'll start that conversation

122and move forward from there okay so at this time um we will move to um our public comment did you have a question oh okay the Board of Education welcomes comments from the public at its meetings citizens who wish to address the Board of Education should identify themselves by name comments by individuals shall be limited to three minutes if the individual is representing multiple individuals or a group they shall be allowed to speak for five minutes the board respectfully requests that speakers refrain from commenting about specific individuals as I call an individual for public comment I will also designate the next speaker so that they have appropriate time to prepare in accordance with board policy issues raised in public comment will be taken under advisement by the board of education but will not be discussed

123this evening issues raised during public participation may be added to Future agendas or addressed by administrative staff because the questions raised in public comment address District operational matters the student the superintendent is the board's design to coordinate response to public comment and will apprise the board accordingly as outlined in Board of ucation policy 2230 individuals addressing the board should conduct themselves with respect and civility toward others individuals are free to express their criticism regarding decisions or policies but the Board of Education expects that they refrain from personal attacks on our superintendent Board of Education and administrative staff at this point I would like to welcome Kimberly blch who will be followed by who will be followed by anarie Tomy Tom Tom Tomac I'm sorry my name is Kim bch and I'm a District 203 parent

124I have a high school student and a Junior High student I am also a 22-year veteran teacher within our district I'm currently the PE teacher at Kingsley but have also taught at many of our Junior highs tonight I am here speaking to bring awareness to the board administrators in our community about a program that I am passionate and extremely proud of but more importantly that my students have loved for the past 11 years the program is called Cardio Club it's an Innovative before school intermural already established and proven to be extremely beneficial for schoolwide learning Readiness providing social and emotional learning opportunities and fostering a sense of belonging it is inspired by the high school's learning writing PE program in research conducted about exercising the brain from Paul sentari remember when that was Innovative and

125no it can't be run after school that defeats the whole purpose currently doors open for this club at 7:20 a.m. in order for it to run effectively with the proposed change doors would open at 6:50 would this new start time be what's in best interest for elementary students think about it maybe a fourth or fifth grader okay but for a Kinder first or second grader remember they also need to wake up get dressed eat breakfast before they even leave the house additionally Champions After School Care like most schools uses my gym every day after school so I can't do after school in murals if we are aiming to support the academic social emotional and behavioral development of all students then this program is a key component to doing just that at the elementary level Please

126be aware that if the proposed changes to the elementary school day occur by beginning 30 minutes earlier it will negatively impact this program for our students this club could not be able to run as it is today did you know how many students this impacts looking at last year's sign up I had 158 students participating K through 5 which equals about 39% of our School population again over 100 this year data shows this is our average kingsley's Cardio Club is allinclusive every student K through five including students within structured learning are invited to participate together it is a place where everyone belongs and building community and self-confidence is a priority there is no limit on the number of students who participate with other proog program at the elementary level is this inclusive yes participating in

127Cardio Club is also about building healthy exercise habits too but it's more about creating a strong sense of belonging helping students to be ready to learn as soon as the academic Bell Rings students are proud to say that they are part of kingsley's cardio Club they feel like they belong to something special which translates into their interactions with peers and build self-confidence thank you for listening when considering the district proposal on time change please remember the negative impact it has at our elementary school levels um with programs every school has programs like this and it's so important the whole sense of belonging this is where it starts and kings is amazing because of programs like that on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next will be Amry Tomac and she will be

128followed by Julie [Applause] Walsh we just sat through a block and it was really hard my name's Amry tomc and I here represent my myself I'm that with the group uh you know change isn't the issue yucky change is an issue unnecessary change is an issue change that's not uh well thought out is an issue but change is not an issue so I I really don't like it when I get emails saying change is hard I don't have problem with change we adop adapt and adjust every day with our classes so uh I got a problem with that I have a problem with Administration that um calls teachers down when teachers like me maybe get up and say something or email board members and they get called to an office to say we have to

129have a chat because um we don't maybe like how you addressed something I'm saying no to that I'm saying no to those who have uh been talking about the school day publicly like it's a done deal knowing fully well that it's got to be negotiated I got uh a no to the unfilled holes in this plan and the problem is every initiative that comes out teachers are always the ones figuring it out on the Fly because it's not thought out and we it's not rolled out well enough so we're figuring it all out while we're teaching we're doing our differentiation we got our sccl in we're IP in 504s P plc's mtss in we got the standard-based stuff going on um it is a platter it is a platter piled high and on top of

130that we're figuring out all the initiatives that come our way nothing's coming off that platter I got a problem with um a plan that is not Innovative block scheduling is not Innovative Changing Times of a date that's not Innovative give the supports that are already in our structure that we currently have give the supports that's needed and we can make that work but that's not provided um I'm saying no to research conducted by our management team from Gates Foundation private schools Charter Schools that's got nothing to do with us I'm saying no to extracurriculars for students are not a guarantee I don't like that I'm saying no to those who don't want to negotiate contracts with teachers but would rather spend Community money to hire lawyers which come off as it comes off as un

131unwilling inept Andor afraid to sit down I'm saying no to those who are avoiding creating solutions to address a very low morale in this District it's still not addressed time on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next next is Julie Walsh who will be followed by Ross Berkeley good evening my name is Julie Walsh I've been a proud neille resident for 34 years I'm also an Alum of the 203 school system and have been a teacher in the district for 12 wonderful years my husband and I chose to live in 203 to give our kids the best possible schooling experience like I had one that makes them feel valued understood and heard my focus tonight is on a particularly vulnerable and all too often overlooked population our middle school students and the

132implications of the later start and end times to their day the proposed grossly late start time for Middle School is not conducive to learning and success just about any middle schooler will tell you that they focus better in the morning both inside and outside of the classroom Walking The Halls of a junior high will show a trend of more positive behaviors in the morning and a spike in negative behaviors later in the day the fact that we hold assessments like map and I in the morning is a testament to that shift as was the sample schedule that was chosen to be shown tonight with so much already working against these students simply given their developmental stage why over complicate the situation after the final Bell many students jet off to Myriad non-school Associated activities the

133start time of those activities will not change this will force Susie to leave school before math has even ended to attend her dance recital or see all of her hard work and dedication simply twirl away that is not fair nor kind to ask of them in the same vein a later end of the school day will unfortunately lead to a decrease in the number of students able to participate in school sponsored activities yielding a decrease in a sense of belonging which is important to all of us junior high is the time to explore and try new things the proposal removes so many opportunities for these students to stretch their interests and take risks it is also not Equitable to different populations of students Middle School lays the foundation for important study and life skills including

134ining time management study habits and pathetic listening collaboration we are not setting them up to hone these skills with the proposed shifts instead we are asking them to arrive at school already mentally physically and emotionally tired after being up for hours already or staying up too late the night before we are then asking them to focus and fight against their exhaustion until well past their need for a break we then ask them to arrive home at least an hour later and continue to focus as they study and complete homework finally we ask them to collapse at the end of the day in order to wake up and do it all again all while fighting every impulse and change coursing through their bodies we cannot send a message that these important and impressionable students that they

135do not matter we cannot tell them that their well-being is being sacrificed for the sake of those older and younger than them the proposed changes send exactly those messages and throw them into a system that is inherently set up against them how can we expect them to come to school ready to learn and willing to trust the adults around them if that is what they are being told that is certainly not what I want for my daughters to feel when they enter into their middle school years and I would venture to say it's not how any of us wanted to feel at such an important age either thank you for your time on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Ross Berkeley who will be followed by Vicky kles hi good

136evening uh I'd like to request five minutes as I'm speaking on behalf of the Neighborville Education Association board members cabinet staff members neille 203 parents and community members staff members nille 203 staff members community members and parents my name is Ross Berkeley and I'm the president of the neille unit Education Association representing over 1,400 educational Professionals in one of the largest Illinois Education Association Affiliates in the state of Illinois the mission of Nua is we Empower and advocate for each other to cultivate positive healthy environments that value and strengthen public education and our core values Encompass the following communication we communicate relevant information policies and procedures with Integrity empowerment we are empowered by knowing and uphold upholding our rights and responsibilities advocacy we advocate for healthy environments for our members and our students growth we're

137committed to growth through the cultivation of leadership skills and education we value education as a vehicle to personal and professional success in order to serve my constituents and stay true to the mission of our organization I along with others this evening will be speaking to our mission specifically in cultivating positive and healthy environments and communicating relevant information with Integrity for advocating for our members and students for the record I am a 24-year resident within the 203 boundaries I'm a taxpayer as well as a parent of a neille 203 student bear with me I consider myself well traveled and I enjoy vacations however there is one place that I do not enjoy visiting Disney World this is not to say that my family does not often visit the Beloved theme park oh no my family is

138excellent at visiting Disney World however Disney World Vacations for me are not a vacation they're a chore they are a chore because in my family every day down to the minute is scheduled and meticulously from the quick dine breakfast at 6:00 a.m. to the location to view the fireworks at 9:00 p.m. every moment between Parks restaurants amusement rides shows everything's planned while I appreciate the detail and thoughtfulness that goes into my family's trip planning I have learned one very important thing Central Florida's weather can be unpredictable I've also learn that you can pretty much stick to the plan during in inclement weather Disney World much like our school dist district is a well-oiled machine nothing that rain or a few R wind gusts it can't withstand however I have learned a very important lesson in

139weathering a storm or two at Disney World build in a rain day and be ready to Pivot of course you can muscle through the day without missing a beat on the planned itinerary but at the end of the day you're left with a family that is tired wet cranky and didn't have a very good experience and they won't be looking forward to tomorrow so tonight I'm asking the board and cabinet to look at the weather forecast listen to your family and give them the best chance at positive eni environments for all stakeholders board members community members staff and parents you can reference the Nua survey data by visiting tiny url.com 203 teers or yel key.com feedback thank you for your time on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Vicky kles

140who will be followed by Eric Don good evening I am Dr Vicki kuris and UA treasur and membership chair as um our board president just met as our executive board president just mentioned um you can follow the presentation of the survey that we held with our teachers at tinyurl.com 203 teers or at yel key.com feedback on January 24th Nua sent out to all members a survey to gather feedback on the shifts proposed in the Innovative School Day presentation andclose the survey at 5:00 pm on January 31st specific questions varied by level but generally included questions about start and end times because those had just been released length of school day shifts in instructional practices and teacher work day out of the 1482 Nua members 1,2 members completed the survey giving us a 68.3% response rate

141which can be considered a strong response rate contributing to the reliability and valid validity of the survey results level participation rates included 25 from Early Childhood 436 Elementary School 261 from Junior High 282 from high school and eight from psac and connections combined as we begin reviewing results of the Innova Nu's Innovative school day survey we will start with the professionals that support our youngest Learners in District 203 our 37 Nua Early Childhood Educators the proposed start and end times have been a key question asked across all five levels and this was the first question asked at the Early Childhood at the EC level there's no shift in the proposed start time for either the morning session which will still begin at 8:15 or the afternoon session that begins at 12:05 in terms of proposed

142end times the morning session is the only one with a potential change ending 30 minutes earlier from the current practice currently it ends at 10:45 and the proposed time is 10:15 but the afternoon session there is no proposed change to the current end times of 2:35 16 of the 37 members responded to to this question with 100% responding stating that they were comfortable with the proposed start and end times the second question addressed the bigger proposed shift at the Early Childhood level which is to dedicate the am session for three-year-olds and the PM session for four and 5-year-olds 25% or excuse me 25 of the 37 members responded to this question resulting in 96 of the respondents stating that they were in favor and want to start in the fall with 4% stating that they

143needed more information before they could decide thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Eric danne followed by Rob hunt thank you uh I'm Eric danne I am the Nua Elementary executive and I'm speaking on behalf of Nua I'll be talking about the uh Elementary results from the survey I'm going to mention the URLs again so tiny url.com sl23 teers or yel key.com SL feedback for access to the data so one change being proposed by District cabinet at the elementary level is a change in start and end time for the student day currently most students arrive 15 minutes ahead of the instructional day beginning if that practice or assuming that practice stays the same with the proposal most students would be arriving and entering the buildings Elementary buildings at

1447:30 a.m. in our survey survey with 436 Elementary Nua members responding 6.7% of them are in favor of the start and end time being proposed the next uh piece that the district cabinet has stated is that teachers are asking for more time in the school day for a variety of reasons therefore they have proposed that the elementary student school day be extended by 15 minutes 1515 to clarify of the 436 Elementary Nua respondents 10.6% are in favor of an additional 15 minutes in the student school day last there has been a proposal and statement that uh elementary teachers want more collaboration time in order to meet with each other in their building or at other District 203 buildings therefore uh a directive has been proposed that would direct certified Elementary staff to stay after school

145105 minutes each week for the ability to collaborate for this question 3.5 % of the elementary survey respondents are in favor of this proposal and agree with that thank you for your time on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Rob hunt who will be followed by Dan Iverson good evening thank you for your attention and your time this evening I am Rob hunt and I am the Nua Junior High executive speaker speaking on behalf of Nua tonight I'll be summarizing the survey results from our Junior High members board members community members staff and parents you can reference the Nua survey we're referencing the data by visiting tinyurl.com 203 teachers or for the next 19 hours yel key.com feedback there are 338 members at the junior high and we had 259

146respondents which is an impressive 77% % response rate the first Junior High survey question asked are you in favor of the proposed start and end times for your level 82.2% indicated no 5.8% indicated no preference 5.4% said yes an additional 6.6% chose other and entered replies mostly expressing concerns about the later end time frustration with the decision-making process and the impact on coaching and uh extracurriculars as you can see that overwhelming 82.2% majority disapprove of the proposed time change which would start and end the junior high day 50 minutes later this would make us the only Unit School District in the Chicago land area with middle school starting and ending latest as you can see on slide 41 from the presentation earlier for the second Junior High survey question when asked how do you feel

147about about moving to the proposed modified block schedule 260 responded for a 77% response rate respondents were allowed to select more than one response but most only selected one 31.2% do not want to go to a modified block at all 28.5% need more information before they can decide 18.1% need more training on how to teach in a modified block before they can decide 13.9% have no no particular preference 8.5% are in favor and want to start in the fall an additional 1.9% are in favor but request time training or access to their schedule beforehand 88.5% indicate that they are in favor but need at least another year to prepare 13.1% shows other and wrote comments expressing concerns about implementation the length of the blocks a need for more specifics and the start end time shift

148this data would indicate that most members are not in support of implementing the modified block schedule in the fall but with additional information training and planning it is possible that support for the mock modified block could be earned overall the major shift in start and end times at the junior high level would have a negative impact on staff and their families we have proven time and time again that we are open to change we will support new ideas we support new initiatives we support new curriculum we support each and every new idea that comes our way many of these implementations take place over a series of years how long did we pilot the new grading system how long do we pilot a new curriculum we have months to completely turn the ship around it's not

149enough time however none of these are done with so little time to implement members feel that the district is pushing this too fast without adequate time to plan and address the ripple effect through programs and sports without consulting the committee since major changes have been made without new exploratory offerings being developed and without bargaining having having having even started this is eroding trust and morale among staff while creating anxiety frustration and confusion I believe that more members would be in support of many of the proposals if given a year to prepare and given more specific such as what their schedule might look like what their teams might be and given time to plan for this fundamental change thank you again on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Dan Iverson who

150will be followed by Crystal moff hi my name is Dan Iverson I'm the Nua second vice president and I teach at North have done so for 31 years and so I've been around a little while uh I'm talking about the uh High School addition of the the previously referenced survey but you can get it at yy.com feedback at the high school level we had 280 responses which is about commensurate maybe actually a little lower than the elementary and Junior High but 280 nonetheless uh the responses were about evenly distributed North and Central and I think it's fair to say when we asked about the new start times uh there was some confusion there seems to be General acceptance of new start times at the high school level however one of the things that came up

151again and again in survey responses was that there was it was unclear as to when the staff day would start which is something I'll get back to in a second but when it came to whether we wanted to teach in a modified block the picture gets really interesting and it's worth a deep dive 29% responded that they don't want to go to a block at all but 21% said they want to do it next year 16% were ambivalent 13 were in favor but reported needing another year 18.5% said hey we need more information when asked what it would take to become comfortable in teaching with a block if they weren't there already there emerged a strong theme of time to prepare and a list of significant concerns some of which would likely take a bargaining

152process that has not yet begun but to give you a sampling 75% said that we needed paid unstructured time to work on Switching all of our class to a block format 67% reported that it was crucial that all staff have daily planning time something that isn't clear from the schedule 63% said it was important to ensure Staffing not be reduced 58% said it was crucial to have a detailed impl implementation plan while in advance of any changes 46% said they need more time to collaborate with plc's 40% said they needed at least another year before implementation 33% said they need more District sponsor halftime to prepare and only 5.4% said that they were ready to implement right now overall the survey results indicate that while there is some interest genuinely in moving to a block

153schedule at some point the vast majority of members feel that additional planning training preparation time are necessary it's obvious that there is deep apprehension at the prospect of rushing into this process when there is really no need to do so and there are still so many questions on so many levels exemplified by which in the video that was shown earlier tonight one of my former students who I love dearly expressed excitement at being able to meet with teachers regularly in office hours that are schedule that we have not been told anything about and that just feels wrong and icky to be able to hear something out there in a propaganda video about something that hasn't been negotiated needs to be negotiated and that really kind of is upsetting thank you on behalf of the board

154thank you for your comments next is Crystal moff and she will be followed by Julie Rush joliff hi I'm Crystal moff and I'm the Nua recording secretary and I'm speaking on behalf of the Nua once again if you would like to reference the Nua survey data you can do so by visiting tinyurl.com 203 teachers or yy.com feedback I will be summ mizing the survey results from our members at psac and connections members in these buildings are in a unique position in that there are no proposed changes to the working conditions in their home buildings yet they are just as impacted by the decisions District leadership has made about the school day at all levels these members had only one question on their survey it was while the Innovative school day changes that are currently known

155do not have direct impact on the workday of psac and connection space employees there could be indirect changes to your working conditions are there any issues that Nua should consider for psac connections based employees in relations to the Innovative school day initiative their responses fell into five categories first let's talk about about itinerant staff those who work across multiple buildings these employees already juggle juggle complex schedules there is concern that altering school hours could stretch their work days even longer without careful planning we risk overburdening them leading to exhaustion and burnout second Transportation issues present another major challenge connections employees rely on District transportation to carry out their curriculum if the bus schedules change their ability to provide quality instruction could suffer these disruptions wouldn't just Impact Staff they directly affect students as well work

156life balance is another a fourth concern was the impact on teachers schedules and the amount of work already on their plates next year teachers already have a new literacy curriculum to learn and Implement adding an altered school day to this mix will only increase demands on their time especially during the summer when they are expected to prepare for these changes finally multi-level teachers those working in both Elementary and junior high buildings are at serious risk for extended work days if Elementary and Junior High schedules do not align these teachers may find themselves working significantly longer hours than their counterparts who stay in one level at the heart of these concerns is a simple truth our Educators work tirelessly to support students and we must ensure that any changes to the school day do not come

157at the cost of their well-being thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Julie rash jel followed by Emma Oliver good evening I am Julie rash jel uniserve director for the Illinois Education Association region 39 which includes Nua I'm requesting five minutes board members community members staff and parents you can reference the Nua survey data by visiting tinyurl.com 203 teers or yy.com feedback we are on slide 14 we'd like to provide you with a timeline of some key events from the past month on January 8th Nua and the cabinet held their IPC meeting where the district shared their timeline on the final recommendations roll out on January 14th the Nua executive board met to prepare a survey for our membership on January 24th the district publicly released the start

158end times with only a 30 minute notice to Nua leadership on January 29th Ina met with HR and informed the District of the current data Trends from our survey and shared Our intention to share the survey results with the board Nua invited The District administration for further discussion also on January 29th Ina requested an audience with the board in closed session under the open meetings act exception Our intention was to share these survey results with the board privately and give them an opportunity to ask us questions our request stated that we wanted to meet in order to be transparent about our survey and the results on January 31st the board president denied our request for a closed session meeting and directed us back to District leadership and the bargaining team I'd like to point out

159that we begin bargaining in less than 48 hours and we still don't know who is on the district bargaining team so just like our high school teachers who were surprised to learn that they were going to hold office hours I guess we're all just going to be surprised on Wednesday about who will be sitting across the table from us really looking forward to that the district has known who our team is since September I believe and the District administration has not yet asked to discuss the survey in spite of our offer to do so we've encouraged our members to share their concerns about the proposed changes directly to the Board of Education in a highly distress ing turn of events we are hearing from some of those members that after they have sent their email

160to the board their building principle has called them into the office to discuss the contents of those emails this is having a chilling effect on our members willingness to speak up about their concerns and it leads the union to believe that there is a systemic effort to suppress teachers voices this is is alarming Behavior by both the Board of Education and the District administration and that behavior must stop thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Emma Oliver who will be followed by Kyle Hall good evening my name is Emma Oliver and I'm I'm a parent of a rising kindergartener at Highlands and a band director at Kingsley and Elmwood schools I'm speaking this evening as a professional and a community stakeholder in my family we make sure to

161trust the advice of experts in their respective fields to guide our decision-making doctors lawyers contractors and especially teachers at this point in my career I have earned the title of Veteran teacher I have a master's degree in music education I am national board certified and I have taught for 13 years 10 in naville 203 I hope you'll trust my professional expertise when I tell you that fall 2025 is a rushed and unrealistic timeline for many of the sweeping changes that are rolled into the Innovative School experience proposals fall 2025 may seem far away but teachers and students are already living with one foot in this school year and one in the next as a band director I'm already communicating with parents about summer learning opportunities in music I've already started to recruit third graders to

162start band in fourth grade or over the summer I'm talking to fifth graders about their transition to Junior High we're setting performance calendars for next school year already as an elementary teacher setting realistic expectations is critical we give so many pre-alerts we are constantly explaining what something should look like sound like and feel like before it happens setting students up for Success means helping them to Envision the future before stepping into it with so much uncertainty on the horizon for fall 2025 I already feel like I'm hindered from giving my students their best opportunity to be successful specific to my content area performance music I feel particularly hamstrung in planning for next year and preparing students for fall 2025 because there is still not a finalized proposal for scheduling performance music in grades 4 through

163eight while there are some exciting possibilities in the early plans for performance music we currently don't have the facilities to deliver on the preliminary proposals for Bandon Orchestra at the junior high and there are still many questions left to be answered please don't jump into these changes without considering the time to transition we need at least a year to enact these plans it is too late for us to completely revamp our performance music courses for fall 2025 we're running out of time for our music staff to give feedback much less rewrite our curriculum to account for different amounts and types of student contact time we also want to ensure that these Innovations are actually improvements for our program and we've run out of time to vet proposed changes different doesn't always mean better I'm proud

164to teach in 203 our teaching staff is exceptional and when we are given the time tools and advanced notice to succeed our students flourish please hear me as a professional when I say that we need more time to work out the details of the proposed changes in the Innovative School experience proposals I'm excited to work toward an even better future program for our students in music and feel grateful to be a part of the ongoing discussion if changes are to be made to grade 4th through e8th performance music music they need to be carefully consider time on beh have of the board thank you for your comments next is Kyle Hall who will be followed by Jill soul my is Kyle Hall and I'm a teacher assistant here at Kennedy Junior High when it comes

165to parenting when thinking of parenting you think of them being role models for their children making sure they are the best people they can be I'm talking on behalf of parents I am not a parent myself just yet but most importantly parents are supposed to be there for their children in times of need and to spend good quality time with them however a lot of our staff are coaches with the new start and end times for junior highs the coaches will be the coaches will be getting home late from practices and competitions how can a child be under their care and and be supported by both parents when their mom doesn't get home from a track meet until 9:00 or later and their dad knocking home from a volleyball game until after their kid is

166in bed the kids may start to wonder if they if they are very little where is Mom all the time or where is Dad all the time and why they never see them plus kids should not be home alone under the age of 14 if this could be a possibility they should be taken into consideration when when these decisions are made thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Jill so who will be sa sorry who will be followed by Joe nickel good evening as both a District 203 parent and a 203 teacher I'm here tonight to share multiple concerns I have with the newly proposed school day schedule first I believe there needs to be additional Focus two or three meetings or something similar to discuss genuine feedback

167it's wrong that the meetings with staff parents and Community all occurred before the actual scheduled times were released these meetings occurred without all of the information how could we provide the appropriate feedback without the complete picture in regards to schedules many of our 203 teachers are often parents often of young children if the elementary day is to going to begin at 7:45 then students will be arriving in our classrooms at 7:30 and elementary teachers will need to be in the building by at least 7:15 a majority of Neighborville dayc carees and child care centers are not open early enough to support these scheduled changes it's already February childcare for next year has already been planned and wait list are long my current dayc Care's weight list is often up to 9 months to a year

168depending on the age of the classroom yes the high school C teachers currently begin at 7:45 and those child those teachers need child care too the difference there is that those teachers already knew when getting hired or initially securing child care what their start time would be our elementary teachers are being asked to suddenly make a change that may not even be possible at this point our community in terms of child care is not ready for this why is the district trying to push something forward that the community at large is not ready for and did not request additionally as a two or three parent I have concerns about the middle school starting at 850 this does not work for working families and there for our children students likely won't be getting the benefit of

169additional sleep they'll have to be woken up before their parents go to work to ensure that they are up and ready to go to school before their parents leave there also isn't before school care for middle school students yet sixth graders are only 11 or 12 years old this seems like a safety risk myself and many other working parents are not ready to are not ready or willing to take Middle School needs to start their day far earlier I'm also deeply troubled by the response that concerned teachers and parents have been given when voiced when we voiced our concerns the district response provided via the FAQ in the email to teachers last week was and I quote our students deserve this how could we wait at what cost these changes are essential to meet their

170academic social and emotional needs and to prepare them for the future end quote this is emotionally charged language that does not use any data the reality is that the district has always placed a strong emphasis on data when making major decisions so why emotionally charged statements needed and being used to convince Educators and parents like me to make these scheduled changes this response implies that if anyone disagrees or has concerns with this plan that they then they don't want what's best for our students and our children and as a teacher and a mom I find that deeply insulting and inaccurate Educators and parents care deeply about our children I for one wouldn't be in my classroom every day and I wouldn't be here tonight if I didn't I'm not against change in fact I believe

171we can innovate and improve education for our Learners I believe strongly that all stakeholders should work together to provide quality education and even make appropriate changes when necessary that being said big changes need more time to be effective than the Innovative school day is being given this plan also still needs to be negotiated with Nua negotiations haven't even begun yet and historically go into the summer or into the case of the last time time on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Joe nickel who will be followed by Kelly vitton good evening my name is Joe nickel I'm here as a resident taxpayer voter and parent in neille 203 I want to start off first of all thank you for choosing to be a leader in the educational world uh the

172decisions that you have that you make have great impact on a lot of people and that's nothing to uh shake her head at I want to express my concern with the plans and roll out of the changes in the school day uh as shown you could see just from the data presented that only 1% of the public has responded with feedback and the current proposed scheduled time was only given out just a few weeks ago messaging has been rushed messaging and communication has been confusing I feel as a voter that this process has not valued the voice of your constituents I hope that you all listen and I mean truly listen to the challenges that are being faced by all these stakeholders as it stands now the plan and roll out that I have seen

173is a plan that has not been thoroughly vetted I thought twice about coming to speak today because there has been rumor that this is a done deal where is our voice in the process if you've already made your decision why even have these meetings so listen to the people tonight listen to the families listen to your teachers and Educators and truly listen to what they have to say because as it stands now if this is passed I will let my voice be heard at The Ballot Box thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Kelly viton followed by Julia ELO thanks so uh Julia ELO who will be followed by Ashley McMahon okay um hi my name is Julia Alo I'm actually new to all of this I am

174a parent of a kindergartener at BB Elementary um and I share many of the concerns that have already been voiced tonight about the proposed changes uh specifically to the start and end time of the elementary school day starting the Elementary School uh day at 7:45 puts us way out of line with neighboring districts and will make it challenging for young students to get enough sleep ACC according to the slides that were posted online from the last school board meeting we will have the earliest Elementary School start time of any of the surrounding districts by 15 minutes or more which is huge and our start time for elementary schools will be a full hour and 20 minutes earlier than District 204 when I emailed my thoughts to the district I received a response that basically said

175young students can just go to bed earlier to meet their sleep needs which we also heard tonight uh which isn't true in my experience my 5-year-old has extracurricular activities just like other kids they may not be as late but neille Park dish soccer and gymnastics can end as late as 7 or 7:30 by the time I get my daughter home and in bed it's rarely before 8 getting her up now at 700 and time to catch the bus by 7:45 is already a challenge by the Friday of each week she's visibly exhausted and often sleeps for 12 or more hours on the weekend to catch up on sleep if we decide to to start our schools an hour and 20 minutes earlier than District 2 or4 our students will suffer I would be shocked if

176we don't start to see decreases in our test scores relative to those in 20 204 which would cause harm to the reputation of our district I know that the district is trying to balance a lot of competing needs with the proposed changes but I also think we can make improvements to the existing school day hours that solve many of the current issues without introducing uh major problems at the elementary school level um I also know that there are a lot of good recommendations in this proposal related to changes in the curricula and what we teach our students and the content that they're able to receive um but they're being overshadowed by the proposed changes to school start and end times as we've heard today my neighbor was also um was actually a member of the

177design team the Middle School design team she teaches at Washington and came up with a lot of the proposals um to the curriculum and and school day block scheduling but she was very concerned to learn uh at the same time we did just a few weeks ago that the administration was tacking on changes to the start and end times of the school day um onto these proposals and was very worried that they would overshadow um all the good work that her team had done so I know a lot of been people have a lot of people have been working hard on this proposal I don't purport to know all of the issues or to come up here with a perfect solution but I really urge the board not to pass a proposal that is going

178to harm our youngest students thank you next is Ashley McMahon who will be followed by Sarah Forster hello my name is Ashley McMahon I'm speaking you tonight as a teacher of nine years at neille North High School for many months a process has unfolded that should have been transparent and coherent to all stakeholders of nille 203 but has remained anything but that that of potential school day change as a staff member I want to share the frustration of being told that this Innovative school day is student L and staff L when it feels anything but when colleagues who served on the Innovative School Day committee share that they never even saw times applied to their working drafts of the high school schedule I am frustrated when I receive emails from District leaders that contain hundreds

179of words yet are disturbingly empty of meaning I am frustrated when I see colleagues informed that this schedule somehow addresses teacher morale concerns yet Cuts our instructional time further I am frustrated for me it is the incoherence of this proposal that leads me to oppose it as a classroom teacher I did what I knew best when faced with chaos I went to my students across my classes today I projected the proposed schedule and asked my juniors and seniors to tell me their thoughts as always they delivered students shared out period by period and they voiced confusion and questions why has the schedule been brought about if no students parents or staff asked for it why is our instructional time less and our home room time at North more what will my Blended classes look like

180under the schedule what will my early dismissal my late arrival my block schedule my tcd what will that look like how will I get through a class period for 80 minutes when I struggle to focus with our current schedule one student shared a ALB today during our 55 minutes and I'm not sure for those who have challenges of ADHD under 504 IEP plans will handle that time overwhelmingly students expressed opposition to this proposal in fact I only had two two students out of my entire 89 who were present today of my US History classes who shared that they were having positive feelings of those two one said that they wanted to use the time to sleep in and another said they weren't sure about the start or end time so that being said overwhelmingly my

181students expressed opposition to the proposal and shared their bewilderment that at this point their simplest concerns and their most base level questions many of whom are about to enter into senior year remain unanswered this by the district this by leaders and this also to staff it is with their voices in mind and my own concerns that I ask the board not to approve this proposal unless we can have more time to prepare as well as survey all of our stakeholders thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Sarah Forester who will be followed by Amy baling good evening my name is Sarah forer I'm a parent of two um girls in this District a first grader at neap Elementary and a sophomore at um neille North High School I

182am recalling 5 years ago when when an unknown virus um entered our community and we had to address that as the year unfolded it was something that we had no control over and and it was something that you know as the year unfolded the pit in my stomach you know you welled up and I knew it wasn't going to be good and the start of the school year was a disaster and that year in 2020 was really very disruptive for all of our kids and it was something that was not really something that we created or had control over this is something that you know I don't really have an opinion one way or the other the goals of the Innovative School plan they're very laudable the the new block schedule it it may or

183may not be great I don't have a very strong plan about it but when I look at the lack of um training and planning and um helping the teachers to to become familiar with what's going to be needed developing curricula uh making sure that everything is in place to make things go smoothly addressing the concern that there has been inadequate preparation with well we'll just do a three-year plan starting in the fall of 2025 that tells me that well in the fall of 2025 when my daughter's in apus history here's an 85 minute block and well you know whatever happens happens because the teacher hasn't had time to develop a block or maybe this negotiating which this is a change in work conditions maybe it doesn't go so well and the start of school just

184doesn't happen on August 14th that's a very realistic possibility guys so I'd really like you to just think about that I think this is something that with training sending teachers to you know opportunities to develop their curricula over the next year I think this is something that could be great starting in 2026 it really could and and it's just something to think about making it something that could be successful so time on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Amy Vogal saying who will be followed by DPAC [Applause] Patel good evening my name is Amy vlang and I am a teacher at neille North I have critiques of the Innovative school day plan from its research basis to the misrepresentation of Staff support and potentially misleading claims of minimizing unstructured time

185I have concerns about the magnified impact of absences potential Behavior management issues and the prioritization of win and Home Room the benefits of which I believe have been overblown while the costs have been downplayed but for time I will focus on my most serious issue the biggest red flag for me is the proposed timeline while the board will vote on whether or not to approve the changes in two weeks contract negotiations between the district and Nua are just beginning this Wednesday in the previous round of negotiations we did not reach a ratified agreement agement until September 1st it feels premature to schedule an implementation starting next year when we do not know when we will have a ratified agreement the professional development plan will be a three-year process in the current school year we have

186only one and a half professional development days remaining this is not enough time for teachers to adequately prepare for the upcoming school year I have also been told that teachers will not receive paid time to rework our lesson plans until learning Services implements the next stage of the plan if at all this places an implicit Demand on Educators to do unpaid work to revise their courses to be effective in the new structure we need more transparency about the teacher workday there has been talk of teacher collaboration time but it is not shown on the schedule we have received and there are so many other questions and details yet to be addressed I am open to making changes to improve the learning experience for students there is plenty of room for growth however I do not

187think the benefits of The Proposal before you outweigh the cost if there is a decision to move forward I beg you not to let an inflated sense of urgency push us somewhere we are not ready to go there are already big changes underway for the coming school year like the expansion of the El program to naville Central which also doesn't have a fully formulated plan at this time please give everyone in our school Community time to sufficiently prepare for success thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is De Deepak Patel who will be followed by Jenny George good evening can you guys um little tall for this uh so the first of all thank you all for everything that you guys do and I know your job isn't easy

188at all so I really appreciate all the hard work that you guys have put into everything for our kids so thank you and I want to thank all of you amazing testimonies and you guys did half of my work so I just I'm going to go off the limb here so my name is deep Dr deep Patel and the reason I never address myself a doctor but I'll get to why I'm doing that today so one thing I want to share with you from 18 years of corporate America experience that I've learned is in order for any plan to be successful there three things are very imperative and they really need to happen you have to be transparent you have have to get the Buy in and you have to have all the impacted members

189be part of the team that creates a solution you did not do any of that you did not do single thing and I also heard a mother today talk about kids waking up to get to school at 7:45 I have an elementary school kid and a Junior High kid and his basketball practice right now is at 6:00 p.m. so the by the time he gets home and gets to bed it's 900 p.m. and you're asking him to wake up early to get to school so he's cranky already he's going to be more cranky and then I'm going to have to deal with that and another thing is I currently work nationally and my company's based out of Northeast they start working at 700 a.m. my time so I'm already behind when I start work right

190now with the schedule that you're proposing right now it is going to set me back two and a half hours when I start work when I actually have to go and and work from behind and then I also have a team I manage in the West Coast that I'm already working till 700 p.m. so when the kids come home you're asking me to work the whole time not spend enough time with my kids and that's not fair another thing the reason why I brought up the doctor thing is you talked about a lot of research here that supports what you're looking to do and I'm more than happy to flood your inboxes with a simple PubMed search of what you're doing is completely wrong and there's plenty of research that goes against what you're doing

191if you really want to change this if you really want to change this they're very very simple things you need to do in school one focus on mindfulness simple meditation two to three minutes before the class even starts is exponentially going to get you to the higher higher scores you're looking for it increases the attention span another thing you talked about leading in increased Time Blog time increases attention it does not it does not increase Focus time for adults 30 minutes is your attention span after that it goes down after 60 Minutes it goes down exponentially after 90 minutes you get nothing so with kids trying to get them into 100 minute 86 minute time blocks guess what's going to happen you're going to lose them you're going to lose them you want to you

192want to you talk about creating kids for the future teach them hard work teach them accountability teach them self motivation the way you do that is to give them the 55 minute to an hour schedule class give time on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Jenny George who will be followed by Tim Kaine good evening my name is Jenny George and I'm a parent in the district I'm here tonight to oppose the proposed block schedule changes at the high school level first there's nothing inherently Better or Worse about a block schedule of course there are pros and cons some classes are better in Block some are better in a standard schedule some kids will do better in Block sum in a current schedule any evidence the district claims to have

193supporting this change is just cherry-picked the real issue here is changing to a block schedule from our current schedule in a short time frame moving from 45 minute classes to 85 minute classes will require every teacher to completely change every single lesson plan for the entire school year it will take an enormous amount of time and effort for little to no benefit some teachers may be willing to spend their entire summer break doing this but most will not and I don't blame them they were not involved in making this decision despite what the administration said in their presentation tonight their honest feedback was not solicited obviously in fact the district did not engage any members of our school community in an honest and transparent way the decision to change the schedules of our district was

194made long before any teacher student or parent was even informed of the proposals and it is an insult to this entire Community to say that this was a collaborative process it was not the district has admitted that implementation is a three-year process but yet they plan to adopt the schedule in August well before teachers are prepared this will create a chaotic situation for both teachers and students and is not conducive to a high quality learning environment second the district is removing an additional 112 minutes of actual instructional time per week at the High School level they have done this by shortening the day and doubling the amount of time spent in home room and sore slw support just in the past s to eight years the district has reduced the amount of time our kids

195spent learning by 277 minutes per week first they implemented late start that was 75 minutes gone then they added home room and sore support which was an additional 90 minutes gone per week now they're doubling support and Home Room Time by removing moving an additional 112 minutes from core and elective classes this added time for support might be great for some students but for the majority it will be wasted time spent on their phones just like it is today there will be no effective way for teachers to cover the necessary curriculum with this reduction in class time once again the district is focusing their time and resources on areas that will not improve educational outcomes for students we should be focused on improving literacy and math proficiency and giving teachers the proper training and resources

196to help students Thrive rather than wasting time on every new fad that comes along thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Tim Kane who will be followed by demitra white my name is Tim Kane and I've been a teacher in the district for 28 years at Jefferson Junior High I'm also a parent of two current Junior High School students and one high school student um I just want to mention a couple things uh in regards specifically to the change of times for the junior high school day um my children have been lucky enough to have been able to participate in lots of extracurricular activities both within the school or within the school community and outside of the school community and I fear that um down the road students

197will not have that ability currently many of our uh extracurricular teams practice at the junior high level from anywhere from 3 o' to 5 o'clock some schools even later when they if they only have one gym um those practice times on a daily basis would more likely end closer to six o'clock uh at the on contest days I know that the committee has said they're working on things to try to ensure they'd be as close as possible to what they are but the reality is they would definitely go longer um while my kids are soon to be out of the junior high level and quite honestly I won't be teaching here all that much longer but I speak on behalf of the future we talk about the future and the students down the road and

198um there are a couple issues that I haven't heard brought up with the vast change in the junior high school day that 340 start I feel like one and this has been mentioned we're going to have a hard time um getting students to be able to participate in those extracurriculars we're going to have a hard time getting teachers who are able to stay after late to run things like homework club or extracurricular activities not athletic related other clubs that that do take place after school each day um and then long term that concerns me because I fear that we would be looking at a situation where it's going to be hard to retain and hard to attract teachers when we are the only Junior High in the Chicago area getting out close to 4:00 I

199could see lots of lots of potential hires down the road saying that's not going to work for my family and they'll have ample opportunity in other districts and uh that concerns me for students in the future thank you so much for listening on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is demitra white who will be followed by Lisa Shamrock good evening members of the board thank you for taking time to hear our concerns to prepare for this talk tonight I spent some time considering the mission beliefs and values of District 203 according to a recent article our district is an outstanding District the fact that our students achievement results are in the 99th percentile for unit districts is exceptional and something that merits our trust and District's efforts teachers and the work

200ethic of students are also huge contributors to why our our district is outstanding many families seek out naville as a place to raise their children due to how well we well this District performs I know that I did as a teacher and now a parent in this District I am standing before for you today to express my concerns regarding the proposed schedule change as a teacher coach coach and most importantly a parent of young children one who attends school in this District this new schedule poses significant challenges for achieving a balanced work life Dynamic the later start and end times interfere with my coaching responsibilities as practices in game often take place in the late afternoon or early evening with the new schedule I will struggle to fulfill my commitment to the team while also

201being present for my children this change not only impacts my ability to support my athletes but also limit my time with family creating additional stress I am not alone in this either based on concerns other parents have expressed to me I believe this change may not affect only my capacity to coach but overall the well-being of many families in our community my daughter attends deeper run and she loves her school the negative feedback I've heard about this new proposed schedule is not only from parents of my students but the parents of my daughter's peers with this proposed change young children will be in school earlier and parents will be home much later leaving little time for connecting with family we continually teach seal lessons with our middle school students that Express the importance of unwinding

202and connecting with families and friends this schedule will rob them of those opportunities I am not alone in the fact that I rely on coaching and a part-time job to support my family outside of school School the new proposed schedule will make it impossible for many teachers with the same situation to maintain their part-time jobs this financial hardship will have unimaginable consequences for many families according to our district website District 203 believes in Collective Partnership of students staff parents and Community overwhelmingly students staff and parents are not on board with the school day change one hour may not seem like a big deal but for many of us it will negatively impact our physical emotional social and for some Financial well-being I am afraid of losing some awesome individuals I get to work with every

203day commute times will change child care cost can increase ability to make appointments after school can mean taking more half days this change will impact much more than meci thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Lisa shamron who will be followed by sulaman farooqi good evening and thank you very much for the opportunity to speak to you tonight my name is Lisa Shamrock and I am a teacher at neille North High School a parent of two District 203 alumni and a District 203 taxpayer I have to say I'm disappointed that the board voted to allow the district's presentation in their comments and questions to proceed public comment as some parents and community members may have not anticipated such a late start to this portion of the meeting I

204would like to share my thoughts about the district's plans for an Innovative School experience firstly I have some concerns about the information presented at the second Focus 203 session on January 14th 2025 which I attended and um to uh excuse me and to the board of education on January 21st of this year uh first the district wants to reduce the amount of unstructured transition time however we are talking about children and teens here who still need breaks I would argue that any time gained by reducing the number of Transitions and passing periods at the junior high and high school will be used up in order to give students and staff much needed breaks while the district leaders cite a number of references at the end of their presentation the slides do not contain any summaries

205or Graphics from these sources that demonstrate that block schedules improve student outcomes in fact in June 2024 Lions Township High School decided against developing a block schedule because they could not find a benefit to such a schedule a number of statements made in the presentation were are simply Irrelevant for example slide 42 reads 77% of courses at the University of Illinois orbana champagne are longer than 50 minutes most are 80 to 80 minutes what evidence do District leaders have to support that longer high schools longer class classes for high school students are beneficial um what is the connection between an Innovative School experience in the statement on slide nine that approximately 50% of our graduates graduates obtain a post-secondary degree with four within four years there are host of reasons that students do not complete

206a post-secondary degree within that time span um since I began teaching in 1994 student attention spans have decreased significantly and many students lack the grit and stamina necessary to engage in activities beyond the typical class period I often hear students comment that Mondays and Fridays seem very long because the high schools have 50-minute periods on those days at the high school we currently have 90 minutes per week of Home Room intervention time so why do we need to increase this to 160 minutes per week especially when only about 10 to 15% of the student population need an intervention the intervention sessions that seem to fill most quickly at the high school are the study halls in the large spaces where students receive very little time on behalf of the board thank you for your comments

207next is sulaman Fuki followed by Brian sui hello dear board members uh I'm requesting five minutes as I'm including the expert opinion of uh Pediatric Sleep Specialist Group which I think is an effective use of an additional two minutes okay all right my name is Dr solaman faruki I'm a psychiatrist serving our local community I'm concerned about the proposed Elementary School start time change I've consulted with Dr Darius a logman MD a Pediatric Sleep specialist at Advocate Children Hospital who opposes the shift later start times for teenagers is certainly a commendable effort because it's an attempt at following the science but as Dr logman put it it's like trading punishments by placing the burden on younger children as these changes still introduce serious health learning and developmental risks with no strong evidence of academic benefits

208Dr logman also emphasized that sleep is a family issue it's if uh one group suffers the entire household is affected shifting elementary school earlier does not just impact students it reduces sleep for parents increasing stress for Ames and disrupts morning routines rushed and stressful mornings increased cortisol levels in both parents and children which is linked to higher anxiety impaired memory and difficulty regulating emotions chronic elevated cortisol can negatively impact learning immune function and overall mental well-being making mornings even more challenging for families already struggling with an earlier start time we talked about research but I don't see any health professionals here uh you guys are talking about circadian rhythms like my mom talks about the Illuminati uh I would suggest that we all stay in our lanes and collaborate with health professionals in our neighborhood

209uh this is neille we can consult our neighbor probably as Dr deepok mentioned earlier some PubMed articles actually compiled multiple articles here including meta reviews the highest level of scientific evidence rather than cherry pick case studies because I'm trained to evaluate health research so I suppose I'll summarize which is kind of a shame I cited everything it was an amaa format I'm sure some of you may have appreciated this while it's true that majority of teenagers exhibit circadian phase delay and many younger children do have earlier chronotypes there is actually significant individual variability in younger children versus teenagers essentially not all young children have the same circadian rhythms this is like plant growth teenagers are like a species of evening Prim roses that mostly Bloom at night while young children are like a mixed Garden

210where some flow where some flowers bloom early in the morning some midday and some still at night just because many younger children wake up up early doesn't mean all do and forcing them all into the same schedule ignores their natural differences Research indicates that children's bed times and wake times do not always align with their biologic sleep cycles meaning early School uh start times can negatively impact some While others adapt more easily sleep deprivation is uh in children can mimic ADHD symptoms often leading to misdiagnosis and unnecessary medications while evidence supports later school start times for ad lessons studies on younger children actually show mixed results there is no strong evidence for this with some adapting While others experiencing poor academic performance while enforcing earlier bedtimes does not effectively shift circadian rhythms actually making rigid

211school schedules a potential risk for children's well-being as a psychiatrist I cannot ignore the significant mental health impact this seemingly Small Change will have on children and their families earlier school start times have been linked to increased risk of anxiety depression childhood obesity emotional instability and behavioral problems if the goal is to improve adolescent sleep schedules this should not come at the expense of younger students and their families the number of parents I treat for anxiety due to poor sleep is overwhelming and the ripple effect that has on children's well-being is just as profound we are not a healthy society and our and our schools and the lives of our children should not be made to fit our Antiquated unhealthy work culture the board should explore Transportation optimizations or a more moderate adjustment to mitigate

212harm I urge the board to reconsider and prioritize child and uh family well-being over logistical convenience the naville school district is widely recognized as a destination for families who prioritize academic excellence and evidence-based educational policies parents choose this District because it follows the science values student well-being and implements research back decisions that support both Learning and Development I appreciate your time and both I and Dr logman would welcome further discussion on this thank you on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Brian sui followed by tyres Spencer Hi my name is Brian coochie um I'm speaking as as a parent who students in all three levels of schools in the district um I know a lot has been spoken today um but I'm going to focus primarily on the high school

213block schedule uh one of the slides said very clearly that this was done to maximize education time but clearly that's not the case as was said previously 112 minutes of Education time is being removed from the schedule that accounts to 7% 7% how can you guarantee any person in this school in this room in the school district you can get 100% or more from the students with 7% of the time or 7% less of the time you can't and we have teachers here today all telling you the same thing they can't do this and that doesn't even take into account the 85 minute periods where these teachers are probably going to have to give five minute breaks or so in the middle of it further reducing that education Time by up to 10% you can't

214get it one of my students one of my uh kids will actually need these interventions but I still do not believe that this wasted time over the HR wi or uh whatever words are being used for it is going to be valuable because all you're doing is teaching to the lowest common denominator you're not actually lifting everybody up you're you're helping the lowest people which I I I think you should be praised for but we need to get everybody the the maximum amount of Education to allow them to succeed um the other I do want to uh make one other comment about the junior high schedule and how you're taking away time from both the sciences and the social studies and I think that's important I while math is important and so is reading those

215other courses are equally as important we are becoming a very technical system Society a very driven by technology by science that cannot be sacrificed and if we look at our political structure the way it is right now social studies is very important because if you don't learn from history you're doomed to repeat it thank you thank on behalf of the board thank you for your comments next is Tyrie Spencer who will be followed by Lily Yun hi thank you I'm ty Spencer um I'm a proud father of a second grader and a soon to be kindergartener um I'm here to talk about the early schedule and moving the elementary um time up start time up I totally commend you wanting to make Innovations that's great more sleep for junior high and for high school is

216fantastic but it can't be done at the expense of the elementary kids and the comment of will they like structure and we'll just move up their sleep time isn't realistic if you do the backwards math if we start school at 745 that means they're there at 7:30 that means if you're close you leave at 7:15 that means you're up at 6:15 studies show Mayo Clinic um Cleveland Clinic American family uh Physicians all say 10 to 13 hours of sleep for that age do the backwards math are we putting our kids to bed at 5:15 6:15 maybe 7:15 at that point we've only gotten 11 hours of sleep we can't make the decisions to make improvements by taking it off of the backs of the elementary kids thank you on behalf of the board thank you

217for your comments next is Lily Yun okay as we finish our public comment period I would like to thank each of our participants on behalf of our whole Board of Education I also want to acknowledge the public comments submitted by email we appreciate your advocacy I want to share each public com public commenter regardless of the format in which you have commented your concerns have been heard by the Board of Education we thank you for taking time to keep us informed and we do consider you to be a vital part of the process of reflecting the views of our community as a reminder because the questions raised in public comment address District operational matters the board has designated our superintendent is the spokesperson for the district as our designate to respond to public comment and

218he will apprise the Board of Education accordingly this will conclude our public comment period we have now we have now reached the business portion of our meeting as a reminder to the community the board understands and has affirmed through our board agreements that it is each individual member's responsibility to prepare for each meeting additionally we understand that it is our responsibility to effectively communicate our concerns either to the superintendent or board president prior to any meeting in a timely manner board members have also agreed that avoiding no surprises is Paramount in displaying respect for All District administration and the community in the spirit of no surprises the board has tasked itself to send questions in advance of each meeting to the superintendent this practice allows for the superintendent to provide the best possible answer for

219the community additionally it allows for maximum efficiency during the community's meeting those same submitted questions may also be asked in Open Session along with new ones that may arise during discussions once again if you ask a question please state if you sent that question ahead of time Mrs Patton what's what time was the email sent to board members advising us that board docs was loaded and ready for our review emails were sent Thursday January 30th 2025 at 4:09 p.m. and no emails bounced back thank you Mr Bridges did you receive questions from board members in advance of tonight's meeting I did I received questions from all seven board members thank you item six action by consent 6.01 the adoption of the Personnel report I move to approve item 6.01 the adoption of the Personnel report

220as presented second a motion a second have been heard please call the rooll Mrs Patton Kelly black I Juan key i g I Kush I McMillan I kinsky Fitzgerald I the motion passes and with the action by the Board of Education and approval of the consent agenda I'd like to introduce to the community there is Jay wtl Jay wle has been approved by the Board of Education as the next principal in Neighborville North High School currently serving in that role as interim congratulations Jay I'll you I'll repeat my joke I thought everyone was here to see me do this but I was clearly wrong um thank you uh I've been at Neighborville North for 23 years it's an awesome place um the students staff and Community there are unbelievable I'm just honored to get this

221job so thank you item seven Communications 7.01 Board of Education reports does any Board of Education member wish to give a brief update on something they've done in their official capacity Joe okay uh so last Tuesday I had the opportunity to uh visit Ranch viw uh um with which is one of my adopted schools with um the superintendent um and we uh one of the very exciting things there is um we saw the uh that the ground is broken for the new addition uh for Ranch View and um plans to open uh next fall I believe so um that was exciting news um and then uh we got to learn about a number of initiatives and and uh things going on uh at the school uh including staff um uh LED professional learning opportunities such

222as uh developing a new uh very engaging uh math uh pedagogy for the the students and then we actually got to go into the second and fourth grade classrooms uh and see the the kids uh working in teams problem solving um is really uh great to see the the students having fun with math so um it was a good visit um and I'm looking forward to the uh addition uh sing that addition when it comes online Kristen hello oh that one works good okay so just a quick report from the state assessment Review Committee um I want I always want to thank Patrick for helping to staff US with um being able to share our perspective from the district about our state assessments um at our most recent meeting we talked a little bit about

223the proficiency standards that are going to be um upcoming um and out for public comment um and the state assessment Review Committee would like if we have the ability to look at those standards when we have them so they're going to send them to us and um if we if we would want to comment about um the new proficiency standards I believe at all levels so um those will be forthcoming thank you Charles yeah uh in my capacity as a board member had the opportunity to visit one of my adopted schools uh superintendent Bridges and I paid a visit to Scott School I see principal Hub Boger in the audience there um and it was a great visit uh the thing that that struck me that I wanted to share with the community was um

224it always amazes me the uh level of knowledge that our uh building principles have of the students um you walk through the hallway and they know the names of every student and it just amazes me the capacity um that those administrators have one student in particular shared a story that was particularly moving for me um both reflecting how um principal bogers the impact that he's had on that particular student but student was walking through the hallway and um uh principal Boger just said hey you know why don't you guys why don't you tell uh Mr kushion superintendent Bridges about your idea so apparently the student had come to you a couple of days or weeks earlier um with an idea of a garden kind of a Garden Club to kind of plant a garden and

225uh uh principal borer said okay great idea you know come back to me with a couple ideas what we do implementation Etc and I was just struck by the composure of this fifth grader standing there looking at superintendent Bridges and I I don't think we're necessarily that intimidated but we're significantly taller than this kid and he is just yes I went and I researched and I I mean literally he was giving a presentation that would rival you know uh an entrepreneur doing a pitch night for a bunch of venture capitalists it was it was an awesome thing to see and this is as a fifth grader and I just reflected on to my own capacity when I was in fifth grade to not not only speak that articularly but also um you know when you

226have two perfect strangers asking you questions in the hallway uh and it just again reminded me how uh awesome the kids that we have and the administrators and the teachers and the staff and everyone that goes into building our kids up so it was a great visit thank you Charles Amanda I also had an opportunity to visit my adopted school with um superintendent Bridges at BB Elementary and visit with the uh principal O'Neal there and the amazing team and when we do these visits we open it up so that um you know parents or teachers or staff anyone that wants to come in and just share their thoughts um are open to that and principal O'Neil gave us a good overview of kind of like what are some of the strengths and some of the

227challenges of the school this year and then um we had a couple kindergarten teachers come in and share their perspectives about things that they would like to see and I felt that was um a really great touch point so I appreciate that so thank you for the opportunity thank you okay item 7.02 the president's report um I just want to draw the attention to two documents that are loaded under the president's report um one is in um one pertains to questions that have been raised about the bills and claims and the procedure for the Board of Education and what our role is there um there it is there for your review I just want to point out um that the board's review of bills and claims is not to make sure that all bills are

228paid and that all claims are processed correctly but rather to make sure that the administration is complying with the policies and procedures that the board has set out our role is uh it's truly governance in that way and uh we are looking to make sure our policies are being implemented Faithfully the second document is that is loaded uh pertains to questions that were uh raised in a public venue regarding board member Amanda McMillan's um uh employment her full-time employment at the alive Center and it draws attention to the fact that there is no conflict of interest between her role here and her role at the alive Center and those documents are loaded for the Public's review item 7.03 the superintendent staff school report okay item eight discussion without action 8.01 General and optional fees okay

229annually the board of education has asked to approve school fees for the coming school year uh loaded in board docs is the proposed listing of General participation fees uh which includes a multi-year history as a reference um Administration recommends approval of the school fees that are presented um we're proposing the general fee for K12 be increased by $4 which would be used to directly increase the school allocation budgets as part of the fiscal year 26 budget process half day fee for half day programs would increase by $2 and a $2 increase for junior high school yearbook to cover its cost those are all highlighted in yellow on the schedule and we'd recommend approval of these fees at the February 18th Board of Education meeting uh our CFO Mike Francis any additional information happy answer any

230questions questions or comments from the board Melissa um well I had a question will the these fees change if we go to the block schedule no okay so they won't be affected um I guess my other thing was that you have a increase to the general fund the general fee for the K through 12 of $4 um I guess I had asked in my questions that I said ahead of time um what's the process to determine what these fees will be uh over time the building buildings get allocation each year based on per per student amount and um that amount had not changed in a number of years nor had our general fee changed so at the request of some building principles and some other cabinet members they wanted to increase the building location we

231had not raised the general fee in over 20 years last year was the first time we changed that General fee and those was additional dollars went straight into the bilding allocation which is part of the uh budget process this request tonight is very similar it's not as much of a request it's $4 I think last year was six um but those dollars again will go right to the building principles to allocate for use in their buildings okay and how do you do you have feedback back from the community members the the community is not involved in this particular the building allocations that's done it to each of the each by the principles in each of the buildings but so you get when you develop these uh fee schedules we don't take in feedback from any

232of the community members we have typically not done that no we do uh show the the the school board the survey of our other local Unit School Districts that and their General fee schedules I included that in the questions today was a a survey that we did last year and you'll notice that our our fees are I believe the lowest uh in our in our uh in many areas not quite all but in most no the general fee I'm talking about oh yes y okay no I I just know that there's a from constituents a lot of them you know there is concern with each year asking for the maximum with the tax levy then they sometimes feel like maybe nickel and dimed I don't know I'm just passing this on and then I just

233am asking who do we get feedback about this or how do we put do we ask our parents about any of these fees you know typically it appears on a board agenda at a public meeting for board discussion and the board would take its feedback and input um as it would on any typical agenda item okay other questions from the board Amanda just a quick question especially for the ECE are these Annual fees are these what are these Annual fees yes okay that's all no the EC fees are monthly fees oh I'm sorry okay that's what I was wondering CU like $39 for a year that's great I apologize okay that makes more sense that there that's an annual fee but there's a monthly fee for Early Childhood gotcha okay so this $39 for Early

234Childhood is just a register for that's correct okay so it's a registration free okay other questions okay item 8.02 High School course fees okay also annually the Board of Education reviews uh and is requested to take action on high school course fees uh they're presented this evening without action um and we look for Action by the board of education at the next meeting uh loaded in board docs are those recommendations um fee changes uh recommendations for fee changes include things like increases in printing costs revisions to the curriculum Associated instructional materials both additions and removals uh increase in Publisher prices new courses that have been added also recommended the removal of some courses course fees because those courses no longer exist we' recommend you approve these at the February 18th meeting questions or comments from

235the board Amanda um these suggested fees uh especially the ones that are increasing does it cover the full cost per student for the fee that they're paying for that class like so for example I'm looking at AP drawing $45 per semester does that pretty much cover what the expense of like all the materials they would need for that AP drawing class so um yes there okay all right thanks other questions item 8.03 establish hourly rates of pay okay also annually we review uh recommended rates of pay for various uh groups employees um you'll see our recommendations uh for 2526 uh Dr H you want to make any quick comments regarding the recommendations no typically we're just kind of looking at some of the incentives that we offer our substitute teachers so our rate of pay

236is aligned with our um comparable districts but we're looking at some of the bonuses and incentives we offer um also a rate of pay for long-term uh leaves as we know that that's an area that uh we want to make sure that we're covering um and then just a substitute maintenance position that's not been something we've had in the past but in collaboration with building and grounds we see that being valuable um just like we have substitute custodians questions from the board Kristen was just a comment I just appreciate your efforts to continue to look at things so that we are able to fill all of our sub vacancies so I appreciate that I know that you propos some increases and thank you for that other questions Melissa um I just have a comment because

237I referring back to in I read the emails about the uh black scheduling one of the concerns and I know that we're doing this which I commend as far as we want to be fully staffed we don't want you our to overwork our staff and we want to make sure our students get what they need um however it has been a challenge um what are the concerns expressed was about having substitutes if we struggle now um has there been a discussion of how the change of hours might affect our a our availability of getting substitutes and other professionals I think we're always looking at ways to draw in new substitutes and and recruit regard less of what the schedule is right we average around an 88% fill rate um obviously the goal would be to

238have that at 100% so we're always looking regardless of the schedule we want our our positions filled um so I think that's an ongoing conversation that we're we're having and surely one that we always would need to be looking at other questions item 8.04 press 117 update yeah not much to to for the board at this point um it is time for another uh press update which is the policy subscription service through iasb there one 17 updates are out our typical process will you're going to receive these tonight to give you time to review them I know you with the Innovative School experience recommendations you had a lot to go through um our typical process would be present them to you so you have them begin the review Send questions to me that you may

239have we will publish that document in board docs we'll come back at the February 18th meeting for disc discuss without action um if there are any that are simply a reference change we'll do a policy consent agenda on those uh and then the rest would be discussion without action and then we'd look for um action at a subsequent meeting after the February 18th meeting any questions or comments from the board item 8.05 the first reading press policy 480 accounting in audits yeah unrelated to the Press update is an update a recommended update to board policy for uh colon 80 County and audits as a result of feedback from the completion of our audit so its recommendation is really to to relate to unclaimed property and capital assets I don't know if our CFO Mr Francis

240says anything additional add uh Tracy Angel our director of business service but I think overall I think it's a couple simple changes yeah very simple changes and there uh in response to our comment we worked with uh we worked with them over the last few weeks to uh to implement the recommendations that they had in the a question or comments from the board Melissa um I do I have a statement to read um and the first part of it won't directly address this um it's more to do with the overwhelming theme today of you know effective boards and a good board um and so the first four things I'll list are the iasb states this under what is an effective School Board what's a good school board makes every effort to operate openly by encouraging

241public attendee at its meetings and keep constituents informed two enact policies after study and consultation with all persons or groups affected three attempts to reach decisions that all members can support four maintains a effective procedures to conduct business so one of the issues brought up at the last meeting was the bills and claims um for those of you I've had a lot of questions of how this how we go about doing this so to give you an idea is we rotate so a couple times a year Melissa I have to interrupt you bills and claims is not an agenda item tonight the the agenda item we're discussing is the okay me just finish my statement and you'll see how it's tight in but please follow follow the rules I'm not to be interrupted I have

242the floor but we have to uh adhere to the published agenda that we have to follow Robert's Rules if I just finish excuse me Melissa the agenda is what the community is expecting us to talk about and it's only the items on the agenda that we discuss at any meeting currently the individual board members R rotate taking turns reviewing the list of changes that the only Melissa you are out of Melissa you're out of order that the agenda item is not bills and claims I have serious concerns about how our budget is overseen so if we are addressing an issue about accounting and audit I think there should be a transparent discussion about how we go about doing that and I don't think that cutting people off before I make my statement is appropriate or

243let's it's not respectful we sat here we listened to all these people speak today about how they felt like they weren't heard you could have simply let me finish my statement no harm no foul and seen if it didn't make sense and didn't relate but I think it does because if we're going to address our accounting and audit policy I think we need to have more transparency with the community I'd like to see the community a lot of school districts actually have a committee a board committee that it you know we get input from all stakeholders and that way we can make sure that we have efficient and effective um you know procedures and practices in place and this we take an approach other than bickering and leaving the community wondering what is going on

244how is this done let's be transparent let's invite them into the process because this is their money any other uh Kristen you had a question it's actually not a question I was just going to propose I know that our accounting policy and our audit policy um is what is proposed by the Illinois Association of school boards but I was just going to suggest since our own accountant has suggested this addition to make it better we might want to just send it back to ISB that they would potentially consider including it in the model policy we've talked to them about that specific speically because they're telling their clients to do this and we asked them why don't you work out this with press so that all school districts can benefit from this this change they said

245that they've had some discussions with press already but this is where we're at so if that's successful at some point in the future we may come back and have to amend this again if we want to go back to a standardized press policy that changes but in the meantime our recommendations are above and beyond what press currently here between now and the next meeting Mike can we maybe have a one of our uh Council just review it too thank you yeah I oh I if I I think that um I applaud our Auditors for going Beyond even the the Press policy I know that press works to make sure that we follow all applicable laws and best practice in our policies but I'm glad that that our our auditor had has an addition but I

246just think that potentially even if we reached out to ISB as opposed to the auditing group just to say we think it's a better policy that they they might be interested in that so other questions or comments from the board Melissa I'd just like to clarify that this has come about um because that there were issues with the audit um initially that's is not true there is no there are no issues with the audit there would there would be an sas 15 notice if there were if the Auditors found any issues with the audit these were simply minor changes uh that the Auditors thought we should Implement regarding um outstanding checks that are sent to the state of Illinois which we already do on an annual basis there is no other issues with the audit

247just to clarify um can I just can I ask a clarifying question so um an audit isn't only just to like find a major problem it's also to help us just be better you know if there's there's something we could do better and and that's how I was reading like with this policy there's a better way to do it or maybe a more efficient way it doesn't mean we were doing anything wrong or that we were out of compliance that's correct these two particular recommendations are simply our Auditors um feel that there's a they should be in policy and there's a better way to do it just like you said okay all right thank you for that item 8.06 the Innovative School experience that we're circling back to um so we said at this time

248if there were additional questions and comments from the board that we would kind of do round two now so Donna go ahead I have a list of questions that I've submitted that I'd still like answers to I'm not going to go through through them they're uh about implementation and mostly dealing with staff questions but I think our staff has expressed questions that I would prefer to have answers to first and so I'm a little confused I'm a little frustrated and uh I I don't think as Charles indicated in his statements before uh that I'll be ready to vote on this at the next meeting um I need a lot more information and uh answers to the questions that were posed during uh public comment thank you yeah I I think we actually have heard a

249lot tonight from questions from the board as well as statements and things from the community so I think it's clear to me that the board will not be ready for action at the next Board of Education meetings so I'd recommend we come back without action at the next meeting uh and work to try to respond to some of the concerns that we have heard and you're you'll continually update the questions in the FAQs with what we've heard tonight what the board has submitted correct okay other questions or comments from the board Kristen so I I know we don't have very many people left in the audience that came and spoke but I do want to express our appreciation to the people who came and all of the things that they shared so I think that

250was very helpful and it shared concerns about how our staff is feeling about the implementation and the roll out so thank you for expressing that honestly I do want to ensure um we welcome that feedback and that there is no um um no concerns expressed to our staff who did come and express their perspectives Melissa I do want to say that I was alarmed to hear people being pul pulled in the staff members that spoke so I certainly hope something is done because if that actually happened that's I'm very concerned about that um and I I I believe we can address that but I believe so I believe it's an un um right word in terms of um misunderstanding in terms of what the intent of that was I hope and so we'll follow up

251on that for sure okay Amanda I just want to reiterate um I just want to thank everyone especially the staff because I know it's really hard to tell your boss that it's I don't like what you're doing so I just want to say that's a lot Really Brave and I appreciate that I think uh you gave us a lot to think about and so I just want to thank you all very much for and expressing your feedback so thank you Charles so echoing what a couple of my uh fellow board members have said um definitely want to get answers to the the questions uh a lot of the issues that were raised today one thing in particular I just want to highlight was um a couple of comments were made around the idea of extended

252time for potential roll out I'd be interested in looking at what an alternative so in addition to getting the an to the questions if we were to try to roll this out of our blogger period of time what it look like over a longer period of time to give everyone involved the opportunity to understand Implement understand the full issues associated with making these types of changes what that would look like so if that's something that could at least be high level sketched out for us to have some discussion around and what that looks like as an alternative um that would be great Joe yeah I uh appreciate all the um uh feedback and comments as well um and um I think I definitely agree with uh kind of waiting on this coming back and and

253uh kind of hearing the responses and then um Christine had mentioned earlier um you know potentials for phased rollouts and and different uh you know implementations of something like this I'm I think um there are a lot of positives with um you know kind of an Innovative uh approach to the school day um but I think we need to uh you know really uh take a little more time to think about how to phase it in and roll it out Donna I I just want to reiterate because I think I was a little bit uh emotional at the beginning of my first comment um my frustration and confusion is with the process and I appreciate that the staff pointed that out um to us and that they brought that to our attention um that that's

254I I really appreciate all the work that the Administration has done um I think I'm just confused and and frustrated with the process so thank you for that Kristen it was a similar uh comment that I just I I understand that this whole entire thing is all of us working together to try to do better right so we get that and there's aspects along the way that we you know challenging in terms of communication and other kinds of things but we appreciate the intent of all of the work as well as the care and perspective of all others that were expressed tonight and we we have an amazing School District we have amazing Educators we have amazing administrators we have amazing people who are thinking really hard about all the kinds of things that we

255can do better for students so I know that with all of the work that's been done and with continued work we will find the right path for our our students and to continue making the innovation that our students need and I I would agree with what has been stated already and I think that um this process while it might not always be easy or comfortable it's necessary you know and it's it's not saying that anybody did not do put in all you know 100% effort I believe everything that was stated in public comment is genuine I believe the information and the presentation has been genuine um I just think that when that's part of this that's part of the process it underscores that this is the Public's meeting that we're here to listen and balance

256all these all these different factors so um for again just to reiterate everyone who has commented either by email or in person appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts and certainly everything Administration has done um is very much appreciated item nine discussion with action we do not have any items item 10 old business we do not have any old business item 11 new business we do not have any new business item 12 12.01 the schedule of events right just a reminder that uh Monday February 17th is President's Day so our next meeting uh will be February 18th 2025 I do believe we are are still experiencing some um earace issues and we'll plan to be back here again okay item 13 13.01 motion to adjourn I move we adjourn second a motion in

257a second have been heard please call the role Mrs Patton Fitzgerald I Kelly black I wanky I giry I McMillan I ksky I Kush I the motion passes we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.