CorpusRecord 117420

RCS 137 Board Meeting 1 16 25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Rantoul City Schools 137
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Champaign County, IL
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,917 words · about 72 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you Anna Johnson here johnon here Diana here here Tyler Wilson Robin V action agenda modifications we just make the motion I'll do that motion to approve the agenda removing and correcting items as presented a second hi second thank younson hi johnon hi hi P hi Wilson hi John I time for public comments speak are we ready we have Mr Lawrence speak first he like come up and Mr Lawrence if you could turn on the microphone and speak know thank you my name is Liv 10 years I'm here can you hear me well my name is Lawrence have lived in ranold for 10 years and here to speak and supp of the change rights in our

002school fortunately the change means that we will have to send our child to dayare before school just like many other parents already but it also means that they will get to go to school to follow their graduate high school class dur the their school career my understanding is that the changes are for love balancing and cost savings due to changing demographics in the district the alternative to this change is Raising property taxes we already have one of the highest property tax rates in the country the taxes up at long pack family is much more than this change it's a good compromise Dr Woods would not be suggesting this changes if he thought it would hurt education there's a handful of very vocal people who are against the change the change will have minimal to no

003real impact on the majority of faculty and students some people fear change others just like to have something to be angry about some teachers don't want to switch schools others have unfounded fear that they lose their jobs there are practical issues with this change but most of the complaints are edge cases that can easily be solved as long as parents are willing work together with school administrators others bring up unfounded concerns with the efficy of the change majority of opponents are viewing the change from an funtional place I have full faith in the ability in the schools administrators to figure out logistics required majority of issues will resolve themselves when the time comes there are much bigger issues to address in this change unfortunately that fa glal opportuni are using this as a way to

004undermine public opinion I've seen calls to vote out the school board and get R of Dr Woods there's a real threat to public education in this country extremists are running for school boards everywhere it's already happening in other states Indiana is closing Five school districts right now so they can privatize in the coming months and years of long GI bur will'll face threats to Federal funding on our culture War issues like teaching certain topics or having a teachers blue States will be targeted the most teachers will face serious criminal targets for teaching topics like gender identity or sex there are serious concerns with Immigration Services coming in schools to detain students and teachers children will be separated from the families never to be seen again we had to live with the constant living through of

005violence against schools as well these are real issues that we should be worried about a minor administrative change thank you next is Kayla and I just decided as Bo president you have one name app it get this done the audience is all going like this all right so talk make sure you're talking hello okay all right so I'm here today to encourage you to make a decision on uh the reorganization of the schools grade level centers whatever you decide to do I personally would prefer the grade level centers make a decision as the teacher I don't I understand that I'm in a very good position being the music teacher at Eon however you need to make a decision because I I want to know what is going on next year the families need to know

006what's going on next year everybody needs to know what's going on and there's so much left on the table that we can't do until you all make a decision make a decision right the next thing I want to talk about is I want to invite you to East for our East Lawn events we have two big events coming up um yeah it's right in front of you on that purple piece of paper save those dates on February 13th from 6:00 to 7:00 p.m. we're going to have our special person dance and as I've said before I throw on a very good dance um and then uh March we don't have a family event scheduled because we have parent teacher conferences but then in April we do have our Spring Showcase it's going to be first

007grade third grade and fifth grade if you are unable to make the evening performance at 6: p.m. we do do uh one at 145 that is like our dress rehearsal and I'm very very excited about it um because this winter we the students read a book to the audience and uh the vast majority of the students in the monolingual and the bilingual classes were able to uh I recorded them and then they the audience got to hear all of their voices read the book it was really really cool and so I planned to do that with fifth grade as we read the book Elmer uh for this concert so I'm very excited and I hope to see you there um also in addition you are always welcome in my classroom if you want to set

008up a time feel free to email me my email is on your paper that that blue paper that I got you your invitation um or if you just want to stop by just stop by we really really want to see you in our buildings because God you're making decisions for us as teachers as employees but you're also making decisions for our students and our families and they need to see you we would like to see you so please come thanks thanks thank you 11 [Music] seconds n SP hello uh my name is G orino I am a first year fourth grade teacher at Pleasant makers elementary school and I have heard from you guys that you're just kind of looking to get a lot of perspectives on this matter so I'm here to share mine

009but I do want to start with a quote that I received from a parent that I think is wor worth sharing so this parent said quote when I went through this District as a student I struggled in school we moved around a lot and I moved schools a lot and I struggled at each and every one Pleasant Acres was the one that set me on the right count end quote uh this was a quote that was shared with me after meeting with the parent regarding their students positive academic and social emotional growth um and I've thought about this quote a lot when thinking about this discussion um especially when thinking about Equity um and how this transition might affect our students socially and academically Equity recognizes that every student has unique needs and deserves to

010have those needs met um and reflecting on that parents experience I think about how their needs were met specifically at Pleasant Acres and similarly I've heard from other parents who worry about um how transition schools could disrupt the support that their children are currently receiving at their school um a lot of my colleagues have already spoken about how uh this transition might affect relationship building and I really don't think I could do a better job than they already have uh but I do think it's worth mentioning that I was able to form a relationship with this student and her entire family because I had a relationship to uh their previous teacher um I've read the research on the uh model of grade level Center and I do think it's it's important to now evaluate how

011relevant This research would be in practice here at RCS um I went to school in Edwardsville Illinois which uh uses a grade level Center model but that town which is my hometown um has a population that is triple the size of Rand tool um and that meant for me that I had 8K through two schools that I could have gone to um but I still went to the school that was in my neighborhood and um I believe that I received a lot of benefits from that um because I was receiving instruction that was tailored to my peers and I who shared very similar experiences um another thing that I urge you guys to consider is um how this transition might feel for students who are still developing and trying to make sense of themselves and

012their circumstances and the World At Large um could bringing these students together with vastly different experiences possibly cause some division amongst students um and you know I've actually been talking all day long today so I think I'm [Laughter] gonna Emma let's see if you can top that good evening hello my name is Emma lison I'm a first year teacher at pleas Acres born and raised in Ran Illinois in a Thunder Bird I want to start by uh sharing my gratitude and my respect to all of you for your work and this decision that you're making um and just reiterate the fact that this issue will impact all of the students you serve while you may not be solidifying your decision tonight and how you move forward I do know that your consideration to all of

013our Village's options are swarming with details and the questions and the push suggestions that you've been receiving I want to reiterate that it is your decision and what you decide in the coming will make an impact regardless I also want to highlight one of the biggest areas that I think us the grown-ups the stakeholders the decision makers haven't really gotten to yet the kids it's no secret that the change you're considering will make a difference in the academic and emotional can't stress out that emotional well-being of our kids it's also super unfairly glaring that our students will be expected to change schools every couple of years just as they're starting to get comfortable with the environment the expectations the Educators that they're working with if if we're asking for a true learning participa partnership to

014take place and we all set out to do our best each and every one of us then we have to embrace the best option for our Scholars which my H opinion is to not uproot and confuse and complicate their learning by shifting to grade level centers now yeah I have got a lot of feelings about this and how our kids will be affected but I'm not the only one at the last morning board meeting I spoke at my own students soon learned the changes that you'd be making and where you would be leaning towards or what you're considering and physically upset mind you second graders 8 years old changes hard so much so that they decided to write letters to each of you I will be sharing those later this evening it's in Emil I

015also have the pleasure of being a jwor cheer coach um and my cheerleaders who I'm missing their game right now but they're out there and they voice their concerns to me and how they couldn't imagine getting to fifth grade and having a completely new school especially one where they called H since kindergarten they also stressed how fair unfair it would be if they didn't get to have the mentor opportunities that they did within their neighborhood schools working with kindergarteners or the younger students and setting examples as leader now as grown-ups we can accept that change is hard members of the board I ask you to deeply deeply consider that this change is it right and is it what our kids eat next up is uh is it Tanya yes thank you Tanya can you guys

016hear me I'm losing my voice a little bit so I apologize uh since the last time I spoke in the last meeting I've been doing a lot of watching listening and talking to both parents students other teachers and I've just been observing and I think the things that come across is why um why are we even considering this because it seems so against what both the teachers and the parents have asked for or would prefer and even the students and as parents we're supposed to have our children's best interest at heart and that's what we're supposed to look for and that's what we expect out of parents is that our parents are looking at at students their children and they're picking the right thing for their children and as teachers we're supposed to have the

017best interest of our students at heart so if we're going against the choice es and the preference of both teachers and students who is looking uh sorry both teachers and parents who is looking out for the the students best interest while I know that change has to happen um or that something has to happen I think six transitions between 3K and junior high is a lot and the fact that the kids will never the students will never be able to make connections with adults long-term ones until they hit Junior High when they can see their sixth grade seventh grade and their eighth grade teacher three years in a row I think that's sad that they have to wait that long um this week I've watched that students from fifth grade or fourth grade are having

018big feelings and the first thing they do is they go visit first grade teachers their first grade teacher who knows what they need and their first grade teacher can can help them with those big feelings when if the students are changing every year or every two years if they're lucky who are they going to go to who is their safe people now we can say that all the teachers and staff in every school is supposed to be safe but we don't get to pick the safe people for kids they pick their own safe people so while I might be safe for half six different kids and I'm their safe person six other kids there's a totally different person and if they don't get to build those relationships and choose those safe people for themselves what

019are they going to be able to do and how are they going to be able to grow as people and improve or is every year for them just going to be a new start starting all starting all over and starting all over and I just think that's a shame um that's I think all I had to say Alana Elena Elena sorry Elena S I tried sorry um so my name's Ela and I just like to share with you guys some insight based on my experience last year which was my first year teaching over at Pleasant Acres um I'll start from the beginning first I first joined the district and I was assigned here as a student teacher near my University and it wasn't long until I quickly fell in love with everything F makers and

020this community had to offer um so I went into my first year of teaching very excited and had High Hopes but did face some very tough challenges last year taking on Easton's fifth grade um was very hard I have never before witnessed such Division and competition among students in any other school that I've been a part of along with that I've also never experienced so many teachers lose their joy in teaching um from this I am the only fifth grade teacher to have returned to Pleasant Acres this year and from my own experience I feel it's because we as a staff had to take on a nearly impossible task which is to get so many students acclimated to a new environment um RCS has been through grade level Centers before and it has been stated

021that the biggest challenges that come with that was an increase in student behavioral issues and a decrease in academics and I can say that the glimpse of what last year shown me um I have a strong urge that that trend is going to continue with this decision um there's also been a lot of data shared publicly from other school districts that have also showed the same outcomes which I am under the impression that has been shared with you guys as well um shot I wish I had more time just to be able to discuss like all these circumstances with you but I do want to say as I've already told Mr woods and Mr round tree yesterday like I don't want to make your jobs any harder than it already is I do know you

022have a lot on your plates and this is a very tough circumstance to be in but I do ask you to please please please consider all of our concerns that we're bring up because we went through it last year and truthfully I don't know if I can go through it again and I don't know if many other people can go through it again so especially the kids just leave it up thank you mer is next I want to know when you start okay okay hi I'm Meredith McKenzie I'm one of the social workers from Eon I am here because I want to publicly show support for the grade level Center options um first I want to address um I've heard several comments about the Easton students going to Pleasant aers um I am quite frustrated

023with uh the sentiment that the Eon students were a source of chaos um they were nine years old and there was um that's an extreme oversimplification of what went on last year um and it's frustrating to myself and other um Easton staff members um at Eon we are currently bursting at the seams I um share an office space with three other people and a conference room I'm the social worker and I'm trying to provide Social Work Services um in a shared office space and in the hallway um so are most of our other service providers um our Easton students deserve better and I don't know how other Educators can hear how things are going at Eon and think that this is um accept I don't know how we can urge you to take more time

024with this decision we need help at Easton something needs to change um and we need to do it our students deserve better than what they're currently getting they deserve there's other buildings with empty classrooms um and it it's not Equitable and it's not fair um in terms of academics we're performing very low in the state and nationally we have a lot of students that are in the first percentile in reading and math um the grade level Center proposal is going to offer all of our students more they're going to have more services they will get more special education services and time with special Educators they will have Enrichment Services for kids that are high performing which we don't currently have um and there will be equal opportunities for all the kids that live in rual

025um I know that there's a lot of parents that uh feel that this is going to be very inconvenient for them they might have kids at many different schools and while that might be true um I I'm a mother and if I knew that my son and daughter were performing in the first percentile um I would drive them to the Moon if that's what I needed to do um to give them the best education that they could get um I also I I know that there's a lot of frustration with discussion of the budget um but uh I also I'm a homeowner and I pay outrageously High property taxes think that we can all agree that Federal funding is definitely going to decrease that's going to come from the state is going to have to

026make that up that's going to come out of our community's pocket um and I think that it is very very important for us to consider that and this option is the best um in terms of finances and I have four seconds so done thank you thank you Rachel well hello I've spok at almost every meeting so you all should know who I am I'm Rachel Palmer and I'm a special education teacher at Easton and I've spoken several times now on this issue so I think you know how I feel I am 100% in support of grade level centers your Administration team has done a lot of research on this issue and brought you this proposal to to you because they feel this is what's best for kids and staff and financially staff want a decision

027now we don't want to keep changing things year after year the other options listed don't have a longterm effect and aren't financially the best decisions so if you look at everything that's been presented and what's being proposed by our leaders that you hired I think you what you need to do and grade level centers is the option thank you thank you public comments public comments thankk you all for doing this it's very much appreciated we do take what you say seriously number four action consent agenda items Tyler the motion to approve theenda item including report has submitted with stimulation required apply all requirements for new hirers as indicated Illinois statutes and rcard policy procedure including ratification pra by finance manager board policy for can I get a second I'll second thank youo Johnson Hi D

028Johnston hi Diana Mendoza hi d p Wilson I don R Ione to five possible change we don't have to worry about that six resolution Illinois Vision 2030 all right uh board members whether you know it or not you are all members of the iasb the Illinois Association of school boards um and uh Vision 2030 is a uh policy document that has been put in place or written by five Statewide organizations the superintendent Association the School Board Association the principal's Association School business officials and Regional superintendent of schools associations um this was done in 2020 also uh it would have been a few years before 2020 when it was approved but the purpose of uh Vision 203 is to set a policy uh a a agenda for all Statewide educational organizations focusing on four areas student

029student school student and school safety future focused learning shared accountability and predictable funding one of the biggest things that came out of the last uh version of this which was Vision 2020 was the evidence-based funding formula that was something set forth in Vision 2020 um and has been a uh A A major benefit for this school district um so really what you're being asked to do tonight as uh members of this board is to go ahead and uh approve the resolution the goal is that every school district in the state um will uh pass the resolution which gives it more Force when it comes to um going into spring field and trying to work with our legislators on policy changes uh for the next 10 years I don't know much more than that about it

030so there's a document in there that in your packet that has a lot of detail in it but that's it unless anyone has any questions any questions I'll make the motion to authorize the item as presented I give a second I moto moto John hi John hiana mza hi Tyler Wilson hi John Brotherton hi ages number seven the selected bargaining agreement all right with the teachers well um before we I go into the details I want to thank the core negotiation team that was involved with this with the uh RCA represents all of our uh certified staff members which is our largest employee group so uh Rachel Palmer Tara Kaiser Meredith McKenzie and Laura Su were part of the rcca and on the district side we had Tom Majors Allison Didier Heather Jacobs Mr Brotherton

031and myself um and so after negotiations this is uh just a very short summary for the board and I know I've provided some more details than this to board members but uh I would also add the association uh took it to their members on January 6th uh and they ratified it but it doesn't become official until board ratifies it so both sides have to agree um so a three-year contract uh it would go into effect the start of I think it's July one um the salary increase structure is uh 5% followed by 4% followed by 4% U CL we clarified when a student with special education services um counts towards home room room class sizes U I'm just highlighting some of the the big things we kind of talked through as a group um we

032updated the retirement incentive for teachers uh we moved from three years at 6% to four years at 5.7% 5% um and we removed other sections in the contract that were related to retirement enhancements that may have been in conflict with uh some recent court rulings so it was kind of in everyone's interest to no longer have that in the contract so um I'm I think both sides worked well together um we were happy to get this uh resolved and see if you have any questions I didn't put a motion on the screen realize that now but it's pretty basic motion make the motion to gratify this Katie Johnston hi Mendoza hi nck penett hi Tyler Wilson hi John brother hi that's like a gratifying a contra well we're moving on to number seven which is

033discussion of the K5 School Organization we would like to say something first by the way I had an entire second slide of things we did in the uh the CBA that are up there now but my screen is going wild not sure what's happening um but yeah there were several other things along with the motion so uh you should have that in the packet members of the public that are here so I am seeing technical difficulties so let me see if I can that's okay it's not I don't know that it's okay be able fix well we may have to live with it I'm glad I have hard copies everybody has hard copies folks in the audience you should also have hard copies if you want we had them there at the table um so

034yeah I'm going to just kind of go through some things I um since the last board meeting I've presented information to a lot of different groups uh not just me but uh my team we've done um some parent meetings I know board members also were in attendance at those we've uh over the last week we've had some administrators go out to each Elementary School at lunches when we could make it um and so I feel like part of what I'm going to do tonight is answer some of the questions that are coming through to as some of the more common questions um so what challenges are we trying to resolve this um there's a lot of things that we have to consider but what are we why are we really doing this so I highlight

035four areas and I will go through each one of these four areas in a little more detail but one all students should have access to a similar School experience planning ahead for future Financial challenges concerns with High student ability shifting student demographics can I trade M I think that still turn off yeah I think that's you're hello okay shifting student demographics there we go so what do I mean by all students should have access to a similar School experience well we already in our district have inequities between the different schools I'm not talking about things being equal I am talking about things being Equitable so we staff our elementary schools or specials equally and then we have an inequitable outcome so that's what I'm showing here in this first example so for instance North viw

036and Pleasant Acres each have four specials teachers but that means it's a ratio of one specials teacher to 54 students at North View compared to one special teacher to 73 at Pleasant Acres a specials teacher just for clarification is Art music PE technology another example would be class siiz imbalance um within so this is the example I have here is uh English only classrooms uh second grade so right now broad Meadow has a class with 22 students and pleasant acres has a class with 12 so even though we are Staffing both schools with two strands of englishon teachers because of how boundaries are and how it's going to fluctuate uh year to year we get these imbalances and I think most teachers uh would say that a class of 22 students is different than a

037class of 12 and probably most kids would no that difference too um another one would be the disproportionality between our bilingual classrooms and our English only classrooms uh so an example is bilingual first grade in our district it's an average of 17 and a half students in our English only first grade classrooms the average is 14 students um and I talked about this a couple meetings ago but one thing that you should see is the bilingual class size average should actually be lower than the English only class siiz number so again this is what we're trying when I talk about a similar School experience this is the type of of thing I'm talking about planning ahead for future Financial challenges um I think I said these same things at the last board meeting but uh

038there's a projected $3.2 billion deficit heading into the next fiscal year from the state we likely have no additional funds uh coming from the the federal government and then I think an important thing to note and I put these graphs up here too to show it is that we receive 72% of our funding from state and federal sources compared to the rest of the state the rest of the state receives its funding um the federal and state is 36% so we are double uh we're doubly dependent that's not really the right way to say it but on state and federal funding we do not get a large percentage of our budget from local Revenue so if there's a change at the state or national level to our funding it's going to impact us more than

039it would impact um many other districts around us uh another area of concern is High student Mobility um we are uh just about D or more than double the state average on student Mobility uh and student Mobility generally means um a student is new to a school district uh in a given year so that's what the state is looking at but it's actually a higher percentage when you look at it slightly differently I simply pulled our current fourth graders I could have done this probably with any grade level uh and had relatively similar numbers but um of our current students in fourth grade only about 40% of them actually started with us in kindergarten so most kids in our district do not continue in the same school but there are about 28% so onethird of

040our students move to a different School in RCS during that time so they may have been enrolled K through 4 but they' gone to Pleasant Acres broad meow North viw and then back to pleas and uh we do see that a lot uh in our district so part of what um the opt some of the options that we're presenting does is it's trying to minimize it improves Mobility having less Mobility by U minimizing those IND District transfers um you know we had a uh I'm aware of a student who transferred this week from one school to another and the student at uh the school where they were this you know they're receiving intervention services okay so now they've moved across town but you have to now transfer all of that level of intervention services too

041and so now we have a delay in the intervention services um the there's a level of communication that has to happen now between the interventionists when if we were in one building um that child's move would have had no effect on their education uh the other big area is Shifting student demographics so we serve an increasingly large multilingual student population and we're required to provide specialized services for these students um and I we I shared these pictures last time but you know our enrollment is not increasing this it's flickering screen is but our um our percentage of our total student population that is multilingual is increasing so one of the things that's happened over uh I I I'm aware of the last five years is that we have had to increase Staffing in bilingual classrooms

042but we have not reduced Staffing in our uh English only classrooms which is part of what's leading to the imbalance so I've been asked this uh 83 times exact since the last board meeting I don't know the exact number but um are we consider is the board considering other options so what happened at the last meeting uh was my recommendation um and I think it's important to be clear uh that in previous meetings over the last two years we have talked about a lot of different options um what I see right now as realistic options for next year are these next four okay this is not a secret I I've been sharing this all week okay um so there there are four options I'm going to kind of just talk briefly about pros and cons

043to each one um I'm probably highlighting the cons more on all of them because I think that's what um we're going to need to hear um so we could maintain 4K five schools however um that will also mean we have to make some changes with the existing schools so um Easton and Pleasant Acres would no longer be able to maintain two strands of English only classrooms that doesn't mean we would just cut all these English speaking teachers but in the example I gave earlier where second grade has uh a total of at Pleasant Acres a total of say 23 students do we are we able to justify maintaining two separate classrooms when we need another space classroom for other uh purposes um so those are things that are going to have to start to happen

044next year if we maintain the current programming um the other would be and this has caused a lot of concern from people is the we have to staff the schools equitably so that does not mean we would be eliminating any teachers or eliminating any positions but would what would likely need to happen is in order to provide more services and whether that's teaching services or social work or reading interventions in order to provide more services without increasing costs is you would have to have staff at North viw and Broad Meadow some staff would have to be traveling to East Lawn and Pleasant Acres to provide services so that they have adequate um Staffing uh another thing would need to look at and make some decisions on is redrawing School boundaries um and I actually think

045I have this on all four of the or the first three options which would mean it somehow we've got to look at shifting uh some of the enrollment from the north VI broad Meadow area to the East Pleasant Acres area it is not something we can just reboundary the teachers asked me this question last week at every school um we cannot just if we can just put all of our students into one barrel and scoop them out and put them in different schools um because our students require different um services and our students are very diverse so there's a lot of other variables we have to look at other than just redistributing the boundaries it's it is more complicated than that um so but looking at boundaries and options one two and three are things

046that uh I think need to be addressed um it's the only way we're going to be able to balance the overall enrollment uh across four K5 campuses um split Pleasant option two um and this is definitely one that was discussed last year would be split Pleasant Acres and East Lawn for all students So currently Pleasant Acres and Easton are already partnered schools but they're only partnered for their bilingual students uh so the pleasant anres has all of the K2 Eon has all the 35 um that is actually not been uh a big problem in any way I don't think for the students or our staff that I think the hard part that is our families have experienced this year is from the perspective of our bilingual families who are the only families where their students

047are split up like this uh across two buildings um so one thing to do would be to shift the partnership to include the monolingual students um at both schools and then what you're doing there is you're ensuring that there would be at least two strands of monolingual and at least two strands of Boling and so you wouldn't be risking having a school with the uh we have one right now the the solo teacher at one grade level um with 25 kids um so we would be able to do that that would be the benefit it does also reduce um there is efficiency in doing that um between those two schools all like up again we'd want to look at sh how are there is are there places out of the current Pleasant Acres Easton boundaries

048that could be shifted into the north B broad Meadow attendance area the third option is to do partner school so the option just before this we partnered Pleasant Acres SL um and then I think where we can gain a lot more efficiency even uh to address some of the many other things that we've been talking about is to partner Broad metto and North View also um North View would be K2 monolingual and Broad meta would be 35 monolingual Pleasant Acres and Easton would have that same pattern but they would also have the Bal program um isn't this what we did 20 years ago in a way yes however they were different shared schools um I believe I'm going to get it right Brad meow and Pleasant Acres were paired and north viw and eastlon were

049paired we were also operating our own transportation uh which I think in the year after we stopped doing the grade level schools is when we shifted to private transportation uh and I do think that may have had uh an impact on why there were transportation issues the first time this happened 20 years ago um option four is the grade level schools I don't know that I need to review that one because we did that was the whole meeting last time so those are four uh I think that are reasonable options the one I would caution us on because I don't see a longterm it's not a longer term solution would it be option one that buys us a year right and I think we would still have to be considering a bigger change but it

050would allow year of whatever we might need to get done in that year all right so okay next kind of Shifting topics grade level schools how would Transportation work I have a lot more answers on this um and uh I'm not going to do all of the scenarios but I want to kind of go through I'll do why don't I do three of them and then people will probably start to nap so you can read through them they're all pretty much the same so when you look at the map in front of me there's a DOT down here in um Golf View and I randomly picked the house 887 St Andrew CLE so that's about where that family lives uh and I it's a madeup family I didn't actually look up a real Pap for

051this um so kindergarten first grade and fifth grade so in the grade level schools model this family currently currently they're they already are busted from their neighborhood all all three kids to North VI okay so the the transportation model that we're proposing is or that that I'm exploring for grade level schools is that this family would actually go to their bus stop which in this case the simplest bus stop is Pleasant Acres it is 0.6 miles away so if Pleasant Acres really was a 100% neighborhood School these kids would already be at Pleasant Acres uh North View is two miles away so what what the solution would be from a transportation point of view is the family is getting their child children to the bus stop which in this hypothetical the bus stop is Pleasant

052Acres it's as I said 0.6 miles from there it becomes our responsibility to get the kids to school um so the kindergartener is already at school okay so now there would be a bus that would get the first grader to Easton and a bus that would get the fifth grader to Broad Meadow um we would be using a shuttle system uh what's an interesting discovery of this is doing this model actually reduces the amount of time most kids are on a bus uh on average from what they currently are because so right now our bus routes are uh longer than what they would be under this model um so that's just one family I'm going to pick an I call an in between family okay so this family on scenario two they live about the

053same right about the same distance between Easton and Pleasant Acres excuse me Easton and North View North viw is their currently their neighborhood school all of their kids K1 and four go to North viw North he the closest school but East Lawn is actually not that far away either okay so but we've got to get children I'm a parent I need to get children this is one of the big things I definitely hear from families is how am I going to get three kids to school to three different schools well uh from a parent perspective your responsibility is to get kids all of your kids to one school so most likely what would happen is one of these two so I'll use possible solution two is all three kids get to North View so the

054parent either drops the kids off at North View or the parent drives excuse me or the kids walk to North View um they're still walking with their siblings um the first grader is already at school and now the shuttle system would get the kindergartener to East Lawn or the and the uh I'm messing them up aren't I get the first grader to Easton kindergartner to Pleasant anes and the fourth grader is the one who's already at school now as a parent I might say I'd rather get my uh first grader the younger kid to school instead of my fourth grader right so you might go to East Lawn instead and then the shuttle would work the same way okay so there's six total scenarios in there like that um where you know I'm just trying

055to kind of play out what it would look like for different families um and then I'm going to jump ahead to what would costs be under grade level schools and then so I'm jumping ahead to the slide that says current general education busing okay so in grades K through five uh right now we are transporting 250 students on general education bus routes that is not at all all of our busing so we have we have six routes for K5 kids for 250 kids we have an additional five rout that run doortodoor transportation for special education students that's separate okay those kids are already bust those students will continue to be bust we run I'm going to mess up the number I think we're running four prek routes and they go Twi they do their routes

056twice a day because there's a morning session and an afternoon session we also have uh Rise Academy route we have um out of District routes for students who are in private placements but the bulk of our routes are going to be uh this is the largest group it's the six bus routes for K5 gened what also happens which isn't really that relevant but I thought the board might want to know is those same six bus routes turn around and then run the junior high routes so it's six buses that are running the K5 program when they unload all the K5 kids then they go back and run the JW routes uh to give you an idea of our current costs it's $389 uh per day for a bus route and we run each bus route

057169 days unless we have a snow day and that comes out to $48,000 is what we're spending right now on general education blessing we're spending well over a million dollars right now on Transportation alog together but remember what we're really talking about in these models is is going to affect the general education buessing um so there are three scenarios that I had first student do um and I will just lead with they are expensive scenarios so I'm going to talk that through with you one would be to Route all students who are Beyond one and a half miles from their assigned school and if they have a sibling in K5 at another school uh the would be on the same bus same stop same time okay so that's one and they're not vastly different options

058one and two and they do basically cost the same so number two is using more of a shutle system where schools are the primary bus stops it is it was really kind of surprising to me when uh the maps gave me the the most kids in our district live within a mile and a half of a school the only kids who really live beyond a mile and a half of any school are um South Point forget now west of the interstate that's very few students that we have west of the interstate um and South Point that was really those really the and when I say south point I basically mean housing in the that's South um not just um but that excludes golf VI because almost every kid in Golf View is a m within

059a mile and a half of Pleasant Acres so uh the third option would be just route kids who live beyond one and a half miles of an assigned School ignore sibling status I don't think that's the route that the board is going to want to go because that is going to mean parents would have drop offs at potentially have drop offs at multiple schools and what do I mean by that in this scenario this family in scenario two up here if we used uh that last busing option this parent would have to get let me do if I do it right they' live here they would have to get the their child to East Lawn and then they their students would be bust to one would be busted broad Meadow one would be bust plus

060and Acres pros and cons to that but I think the concern would be is that the parent is the parent going to have a bus stop and going to have to get that first grader delivered to school um so that's what scenario three does it it is cheaper okay so here's costs on them interestingly we would go from on that first scenario um we would go from busing 250 students to to 650 students that means the majority of our K5 students would now qualify for busing um it would take us from six buses to 12 it would be a net increased cost of 4 $48,000 but the thing I need to make sure you know is it we will pay for student $48,000 but after we are reimbursed first from the state the estimate is

061we would actually be spending only an additional when I say only we it's a it's a lot of money but we would be spending somewhere between $150 and $200,000 more to add those six bus racks so um well it does say 48,000 I just want to make sure you know that we will get reimbursed at least 50% of that that was that's the 204,000 number um and then the the highest range I used was a 62% reimbursement which is what we got last year now one thing I want to make sure I say is on scenarios one two and three we haven't asked first student to map it out for us yet um but Darcy who I think you all know she does a lot of things for us but she does a lot of

062our buses for us she does think we would need to add a special education route um arguably I'm looking at Allison right now I don't expect you to say anything but arguably we need to do that uh we could do that this year uh because our busing has been pretty tight uh so we may be adding a special ed Route One Way or Another so the addition of one special ed route and again I want to clarify it might be something we do whether we change even if nothing happens because we think we may need to do that for efficiency of getting kids to school on time um so but a special R does cost more because it does require a monitor um so and then that shows you the the total CL one special

063ed routes about $100,000 and then that shows you what our reimbursement would be the reimbursement for special education has been coming back lower than for general education um scenario two 630 students would be eligible um for busing again it's the same exact costs as the last slide it's six more routes the interesting thing about shuttles is that we noticed is there it's a lot more efficient in terms of time children are on a bus um I do think that if we looked at staggering start and end times for the elementary schools that we would potentially be able to reduce the number of buses uh in this system we just haven't so this is the I guess kind of giving you the maximum cost uh it could could go down with some efficiencies if we uh

064changed flexed around the start and end times of the schools because right now this is assuming all kids in K5 dropped off at school at the same time on these scenarios uh scenario three which I'm going to go out on 11 and say would be the least popular is um it would be going up to busing 450 students it would only cost 10 buses increase so there is a significant uh cost savings to doing that okay so I've talked about why we are looking at doing this four realistic options for the board to consider um I've talked about what Transportation would look like in the most complicated option okay which is in terms of transportation and that is the grade level schools model um if you were to look at uh splitting schools you know

065and doing the the k235 models Transportation isn't going to it's going to be less in transportation costs than what you're saying here because we would have fewer routes um so next steps and then it's my job to be quiet and let the board talk and answer questions if you have them but my I was kind of thinking what are the next steps for me and for the board and a suggestion I have and you can direct me how you want me to do it I need to continue to work through the cost feasibility of transportation for option four um and that it's going to require me and Chris Johnson the business manager to look at um is that a realistic amount for us um another thing for me to do and I've already asked for

066students to start working on this when I met with them Tuesday was to identify do the same thing they did for grade level schools for transportation costs but do that for options two and three so I've given them those parameters uh and they are working on that so we know is it a difference of you know is it going to be a difference of 75% or a difference of 10% I don't know um I'm going to bet it's a difference of about 50% um I in some conversations I've had with the individual board members uh I've been asked if I would be able to do uh some additional survey for families additional survey for staff those are other things that I can do I I think we're at a point where it's a much more

067straightforward survey of these are options the board is considering which ones do you like I think is more straightforward on that so um that is all I have for my presentation thank you Dr W that's our turn all speak and say what we can say would anybody like to begin uh Dr Woods with the current model that we are in is special education in every building and B lingual in every building I know the aners but just so everybody knows the answer so yeah special education in every building we're only providing bilingual Services right now at East Lawn and Pleasant Acres but we do have multilingual students who receive English as a second language at Broad M North with the option of grade level centers will special ed continue to be in each building and

068will bying will then move to every building yes thank thank you Tyler nothing no yeah I do I have um question on um busing actually Transportation um I actually have a person that I know that actually works for first and uh unless he was mistaken us going from 6 to 12 going to Triple our cost of what we're paying now and the other problem and it's really not even about the cost because I know that other people negotiates the cost this person doesn't um there's not enough bus drivers they don't they don't have enough bus drivers we having problem now with bus drivers that we have um he said there's no way in in our district or the district even in in the district I work and in in Champagne there's no way they can

069get the bus bus drivers first of all so that's still going to be a problem transportation is going to be a problem continuously is all I'm saying and that's not including the actual cost that it's really going to cost us and I know you said it's going to take uh the state pays us back what 62% which takes us down to what 150 160,000 um if federal and state are going to start um taking back money or not giving money we're losing there too anyway it's right off the bat um taxes I know some of the people I don't know how many of you guys live in ran to or care because your taxes AR aren't going to go up anyways but that ain't the point the people that do live here we do care

070and as of students um one of the questions and some of these questions and some of the things I'm bringing to your attentions coming from other people not just me um do you know how many uh multi um parents we have out there that has more than two or three kids that are going to have to dri their kids to two or three different schools in each school do you know for example like North you I mean does anybody know I didn't know if you done for example I don't have the answer on top of my head but we did pull the data on families and the number of siblings in grades K through five so we because we've been doing that with the transportation modeling how how many do we have on that by

071chance I got a number I just want to know what you're is no I if I were I don't want to give you the wrong numbers that's something i' have to look up and get back to well I mean even if the number's close I mean um I got them actually just for two schools not not for not for four um I did a little homework on that I also got the number of sped kids we have in these schools too um and the reason I did some of this was to help these parents out to understand why we're doing this I know we have teachers that came up here and we have uh certain people that came up here that are 100% in favor of of great Center and I don't discredit that at

072all I'm not saying that great Center is a bad thing or a good thing but my goal as a board member is to make sure we do what's what I feel needs to be done not only for the parents but for the students and for the teachers as well I think we're I think we'll hurt oursel more with grade centers now I'm not saying in the future I'm saying right now but these are just some of the things that that that I'm coming up with I I got a ton of things that I have on here but there's no reason bringing it up now because some of it was already said some of it uh we've already talked about and um I think everybody's tired we're tired the board's tired you know we got people

073coming up here and tell us to make a decision um we want to make a decision you think we want to come up here every every month and sit there for the last year and a half two years talking about the same old thing we don't at least I don't we want what's best for our our our community we want what's best for the students we want what's best for these teachers and we dang at least I don't dang sure don't want to lose good teachers we got people that's been here a long time and we got people that's just started that has shown that the that they will leave but do we care grade level I hear uh the gentleman say or somebody had said um we won't L we won't um lose teachers

074yes we will is that going to eliminate jobs yes it will let's be truthful upfront that's what these teachers want to know that's what the people want to know do we have a job next year do we not have a job next year are we going to be moving from from school to school these are the questions these teachers want to know if and if Dr Woods and the administrators already know the answer to this then tell these teachers tell them the truth that's it I will I do know that the concern about the number of bus drivers and being able to staff which is something that I do have to discuss with first student management um I can get you were asking me you wanted to know a breakdown of bilingual families with kids

075that would be in multiple schools I really I I have enough numbers okay um for example for example depending on who I'm talking to sometimes when I'm talking to someone they make comments of saying well we don't have that many we don't have that many parents and we don't have that many many people that have to worry about because they don't have multikids they don't have two kids or three kids in a school that's not true so that's the reason I went and investigated how many do we have if we don't have that many why are we fighting this but that's not true and I can give you the numbers of of two schools and there's a lot of people this is affecting this is affecting a lot of families I'm just letting you know

076that can you give us the numbers that you have I won't just like Dr Woods I'm not sure I didn't get them got them from somebody okay yeah no I can I do have that data because Darcy and I pulled it uh to in our work with first student I just don't have the exact numbers um yeah I mean so I I would be guessing at that point um as far as whether someone will have a job um I've been very clear that none of these proposals uh eliminate Staffing um I can't cannot give staff members an exact answer as to what their job assignment would be next year until I know what direction we're going so I I can't um so right I don't know the answer so when I don't give the answer

077it's because I don't know the answer not that I'm withholding information thank you Dr Woods okay my thoughts are disjointed bear with me okay so as I see it um I'm still interested in pursuing option four um option one is not longterm I think that one thing that we've been that sounds really strong but we've made peaca decisions before we've made decisions that were not as long term as we'd like and it does feel like sometimes we just keep going back to the same thing and you know this keeps coming up as an option and there is the possibility that it keeps coming up as an option because it's the best option um I think that it's sometimes really hard you know like all of us are in the community we care deeply about the

078community we care deeply about our teachers our students like our kids um and you know it's just to the point where I think that in some ways we have to make the hard decisions someone asked why why would we do this if people are not seemingly immediately in favor of it and I think the answer at least from my perspective is to be proactive um I would rather us try something different that will work or that could work you know um as opposed to just letting us continue to slide down in test scores continue to slide down and have teachers be really angry and disenfranchised for us to have the same conversation over and over and over again so I think that we just need to also be real about like our community and what

079the needs are you know I think there are a lot of different students a lot of different backgrounds like not my situation as a person who has children in this district is not the same situation as everyone else in this district and from what I see and hear and read and you know am aware of I think that this gives us a chance to be more Equitable and fair to all of our students and try to improve those educational outcomes that is ultimately what it's about is educational outcomes in doing or what is right for the students in this District um and I mean just to I I have children in this District you know I have children who for whom if I didn't my child did not have the relationship that he has with

080his teacher he would not be as successful you know I'm aware you know of how important those connections are but at the same time up here I don't have the luxury of just thinking of my child with our background and what's going on with my child I have to think about the wide range of backgrounds in this community and try to make the decision that is best for all of them anyway I sorry I got a little passion there that's fine great thank you I'm going to be speaking in draft I've learned that term in my Dei conference that I've been attending all week at you by um you do it it's great um it's not that I am afraid to make a decision however when I say that I don't think that people hear

081what I'm saying so I'm going to say I am in favor of the great Bel because in my opinion I think that is what is best for the kids I know that there would be difficulties that would arise there would be some problems everything that we have to work through it would not be a SPO transition but there are positives and negatives for both you can make a case for it you can make a case against it but in my opinion it is the best for the kids um what I do not agree with is doing a rush job I think that that is what we are known for and I think that's why we fail what I don't want to see is for us go through all of this only to see something fail

082and have it change in three to five years I am tired of it I would like to have an informed decision I would like the stakeholders the teachers to be more involved it is my opinion that I would like to know what's going to happen but I don't want to begin it at the beginning of next year because again rush job it's January we haven't we don't even know what choice we're going to make but yet we want to make changes at the beginning of next year to me that's way too soon and all we're doing is setting ourselves up to fail I'm not saying I don't want you guys to know I do want to make a decision on what's going to happen I just don't want it to be the beginning of next

083year because I think you guys need to be involved and parents need to be involved because perhaps the the great administrative team that we have isn't thinking of everything and I think that if there were and I've said this I said this last time if there were different um teams not teams committees thank you um to help organize this the outcome would be better I think that's all I really have to say but again I realize it's all just my opinion so there he goes thank you VI Miss Mendoza I me I agree so I agree with both Nikki and um KY and I go for option four also I mean in the last couple of weeks we've seen many staff come up here and explain and talk about the wise and the why Nots

084and pour their hearts out and that means a lot like having staff members like you guys teach our children it's amazing and um but also and I understand what Nikki's saying and what Katie is saying at the end of the day it's what's best for our children I do not have a student at RCS but I know many of their children that go to RCS because I worked here for a very long time and and I've grown to to you know care for these kids and seeing them grow up as they move older and they move you know and I know that there are some tasks like the transportation we have to tackle that and we have to know what's you know we have to make sure that what we're doing you know is it

085but also I say this with the utmost respect is we also in my opinion trust our atmin to what they're doing because we have them and you know we have them up here they're there for for one reason and and we're looking you know I have conversations with them I ask them questions and they're always you know willing and able so you know in my opinion do we have to you know work work on some things yes but also being like flimsy like we're going to do this we're not going to do this also puts you as staff members in AA chaotic mode because you want to know and and my opinion is option four um well I am a board member with a student in the in this uh District I'm G start from

086I mean actually I had three I have one now and I'm going to tell you right now I don't have to worry about that part of it the part that we're going over now but I will tell you this if it wasn't for at least one I'll go with one of my children being able to stay with the teacher or teachers or the school that he was in he would fail he would fall between the cracks listening to some of us talk and everybody has a right to their own opinion mark my word when I ran for school board almost four years ago the first thing was to get our academic grade level at a higher level for the state and National level that hasn't happened but if it wasn't for my son having certain

087teachers and certain people that he trusts and can depend on he would have fail so if that one boy is not important enough to wait a few minutes then to me we fell we fell as a board we fell as a as a superintendent we fell as administrator and we feel as teachers your job is to do the best for like Katie said all the kids we don't leave none behind I was at a IEP meeting this morning The Advocate that I had for my son very very helpful I love her to death that group of people that was in that meeting every one of them had different ways and different things that has made my son succeed so far this year I can't ask better I'm not trying to say that any of the

088teachers any of you guys are doing a a bad job a good job or whatever I'm sure you're doing a good job but I do know that all of you want the same thing Nikki said it too it I mean honestly we all want the same thing and it's going to be hard for all of us to get this get what we all want but in my opinion like I said I'm not saying one way or another if I agree or disagree with with the grade centers I just think right now it's not a good fit for the school because of what we will lose we have too many teachers and too many kids that need us and need the right decision to be made and it's nothing against anybody but I'm just saying one

089child to me is most important is the whole group and if you guys don't feel that way I'm sorry I just wanted to clarify that when I say that I don't want it to begin in this fall that doesn't mean that I want to wait five years I would like it to start the next year I just don't think that we have our ducks in in order to start I think it's going to be too chaotic in order to start it this year we don't have enough information and we're starting to in order to do it effectively but again my opinion doesn't really mean squat cter that doesn't matter anybody else K Nikki I can say a lot more but it's not going to I think one other thing that you know in thinking about

090this and you know implementation is maybe there's a compromise option between starting and the fall for sure and starting next fall for sure maybe there's a way for us to set a date for which we have our ducks in a row and if we don't have our ducks in a row by that date wait and I don't know it's just Happ I think children and like like hey let's compromise compromise let good I'm just thinking that I feel like I talk loud that I'm just thinking that last year when we had to vote on what was happening this year we did it so late and as you heard it was a cluster so I don't want to have a cluster I'm tired of this has we have been talking about this since was elected to

091this board I'm tired I would like to make a decision that will stick again I want this for the betterment of everyone I know that it that doesn't mean that I'm going to make everyone happy but I want it for the betterment of everyone I am for equality and inclusion and diversity I want equity for everyone and we're not getting it how it set up right now we are failing students our teachers therefore our community something has got to change but it's not going to change no it will change I just don't want it to be rushed because I want to have something sustainable I want to be proud of I am proud of rant tool I want rant tool to be proud of rant tool because it doesn't sound like we are people wanted

092according to that one of the the first gentleman that spoke wants to try to get rid of us get rid of Dr Woods I I understand it's a and I have an elected position and so what I'm saying may not be popular for the people that are listening and they may not want me back that's fine but I'm still it's not going to stop me from talking I'm still going to advocate for all the people that I try to advocate for which is so you're still GNA see me talking may not be up here but you're still gonna see me talking what because I'm still going to fight for the teachers and the parents and the students I think maybe now I'm done speak speak anybody else I don't know with my thought of compromise

093one other thing is I will say I know that it this is going to be controversial we are a little ahead of where we were last year I think we voted in March and it all goes according to plan hopefully it would be February and we'd also still have a month of like background time up until the point of a vote so I don't know it's just J I'm going to scare you now oh gosh the vote to the move to the what happened with the bilingual program option 7 what it was called last year that happened on February 20th okay our next board meeting is February 20th yeah okay I'm not saying that to make a point I just I was just looking at the I could remember board meetings we had a special

094board meeting on the 15th on the regular meetings the 15th and then there is a special meeting the following Tuesday I have one more question Dr Woods current model that we are sitting in as of this minute and I know I asked this last last month but I want to out there again current model will work next year correct or incorrect cor correct but there would have to be some changes but com yes there I think I I want to highlight them one more time we' be looking at um consolidating reducing the number of English only classrooms where we would need to not everywhere um and I would I will be coming back to the board if that was the case to make some shifts of total population so we add some enrollment into Broad

095and north thank you anybody else I guess it's my turn um I don't think this is U going be a surprised when I say I advocated for ever since we start talking about things like this that I want to do the very best that we can for the students with the least amount of disruption um I I personally feel that we can do one of the options real well this fall that would be the the sister school program uh I would first not to have to do this but I I I would not be doing my job if I did not look at this stuff realistically the information's been given to us by Administration that we do have to do some changing some major changing to get the results that we want to get so

096to me I I think if we go with option three that we could with more information given to us by February's meeting that we could make a decision in February and may if that is voted in don't know that we could start that this fall um I've tried to listen to everybody's opinion everybody's and but you still taking what I think are the possibilities and the one thing I speak about for myself is that I have had I have experience I'm not smarter than anybody else God knows I'm not smart but I have seen how things have worked for many many years and I just think if we are going to make a change that option three is the best way to go however I am one board member and what I would like to

097propose right now is that on our February board meeting we decide what we're going to do that that will be the the cut bait dat that we're going to make a decision whatever it is if we want to keep it the way it is and you know do the modifications if the majority gets that that's that's what we'll do they want to go with with number four then we'll do that but I I think that we it's only fair that people know as soon as we possibly can do this what's going to happen as the teachers students the parents I think they just sure to have an answer and I want to give them an answer so I'm hoping that we on February we can come to consensus what we're going to do does that

098sound fair please let me know I me you know I just I'm talking from experience certain I talk being smarter but it's I think our board split I think some of us like grade level centers some of us want to start grade level centers next fall some of us like grade level centers but we don't want to start until 2026 some of us don't like grade level centers I think we're all across the board which again just cluster decision May one years but we we I feel again this is me speaking we need to make a decision what we're going to do or one punt the ball from here okay that's fine we can't even make a decision until we have a definite thing about the transportation again I don't mind making a decision I

099can make a decision decision my mind's already made up but we are split what are we going to vote on are we going to vote on which proposal we want which option we want or are we going to vote if it's going to start this fall or not what do we got to vote on well I I talked to Dr Woods and he assured me by February you'd have what force answers Transportation Transportation yeah um I'm wondering though because this is is not a secret the board knows that Nikki and John and I meet and we prep the agenda um you know one of the options for we talked about is that the next meeting it' be two parts remember one would be deciding which option is preferred by the board and then deciding when

100so we're going to have two different votes well I don't know how it would work as far as I don't know for sure procedurally how it would work and it also that's what we were remember that I mean I also like to bring up a point of order you cannot propose during a disc an action or a discussion item that would have to be brought up during new business we've been waiting three [Laughter] years yes no I mean and it also it could be one vote right so it's a matter of having different motions prepared so on our agenda your agenda would be that it's an action item but different motions would be prepared um and I I would have to check with the rules of order to see how we would do it like

101SK would it be uh we're just we're still just discussing this item um is uh it could yeah right would it I don't know if it would have to be listed on the board agenda as two separate action items so I mean there's two questions that I'm hearing which is what that's one question and when is another question so I would need to check how that would be work procedural um and we would have to get some of that ironed out through email probably prior to to the next meeting but You' have I mean I mean I could see theoretically we'd have 10 different options 10 different motions pre-written and then it's a matter of which motion the board can come to consensus on didn't you have something I could have swar I read it

102somewhere but I don't know I can't find it um that said something going out to the teachers survey yeah yeah I was just suggesting that was another piece of data I could collect right was that we could do some that I don't feel like sorry I don't feel like they had any say so in what they would prefer so again yes I think that admin did a wonderful job but I think that it could have been done better I don't I think that more stakeholders needed to come to the table you you guys made a lot of different decisions and talked about a lot of different scenarios which is great but it's not having the people that are in the trenches I don't even know if that's right I mess up saying all the time

103I don't the people that are doing the work come and say what about this what about pingpong ideas which is to me I've always learned that is what is needed before a major change like this happens and we didn't have that and that's disappointing to me because again we had a great opportunity to have the everyone involved the community parents teachers and now everyone's like let's hurry up Do It Let's hurry up Do It Let's hurry up and do it I don't know if we can go backwards and get opinions on hey we can improve it this way way have did you think about this hey did you try doing it this way I don't know but that's what I think is needed said that before so Dr Wood let's just go back to what

104we kind of post can we have that done by February can you do more parents and and any way we as a board can help I it takes you know meeting every night I can I can rearrange my schedule yeah I mean I think that um we uh building again needing for parents to come in is that a possibility and I don't mean an informational thing I mean where you can ping pong ideas like that's what we could do have them come in that what we'll do leave it up to them they W talk yeah I think it's um one is getting the continuing to get more information about Transportation um and yes I what we talked about previously was getting OPP unities for more feedback um surveys that could be more um events we

105were uh we did three events um the event here at one Aviation we had I think 10 families represented the um zoom in English uh was very well attended a lot of our staff were in attendance um and then the zoom in Spanish I only had two folks logg in and they were staff so we actually didn't hold that one and we were we talked about rescheduling and doing something in person for our Bilal families so um but yeah I mean it's but yes so you asked me can we get more feedback get more information yes and ping PA yeah they need to be able to sayable so I had on my slide deck which is not up there right now but um possible next steps I said were um continuing to work through feasibility

106of transportation for options two three and four we really only looked at Option four um survey to family survey to staff and I'm hearing also scheduling some other um opportunities for family interaction family engagement um I'm going to say I I know there it's got to be a little of both I think we you and I talked about this privately now I'm telling everybody but um you know some in at the neighborhood schools but also some uh virtually because it it's about being able to meet families and community members where they are um yeah and I am I was I am the staff knows this I was planning to do a zoom just for staff through that webinar um but we didn't end up doing it this week and because once this was scheduled as

107a discussion I thought we should wait a week and um we can try to do it well now before February 20 so are those our next steps I definitely want more on the transportation money makes the world go around me too and as much as you much as some people don't like to hear it government is a business this is a business kids are our business but money makes it go around money makes you guys have jobs the ones that are teachers out here assistants money is a lot of things so I would like a good breakdown that is why Nikki and I I believe are on the same page Nikki and I have had a conversation about this that we don't want it to be rushed as she said just because we want an

108answer don't get me wrong we want to give you give the 30 people that are watching on the internet right now and the 30y people that are out here and everybody else and all that we want to give you an answer answer we just don't want to say okay here's the answer and we're going to do it tomorrow good luck so please get us some more numbers on the transportation I would add board members if there is other data you want um so I did make a note about getting you the information the hard numbers on families with multiple kids now um but if there's other data you want in order to inform your decision the earlier you can get those questions to me and my team the better and then I would share that

109back with the whole board um okay since Mr Brotherton brought up option three can I just ask a couple clarifying questions just so I have all the information so because it's splitting up the way it is to me it doesn't necessarily seem like it helps with the goal that we've kind of Express that we want to move to that dual language model would it be a possibility we could go to Pleasant anr or Pon for it okay um yes not everyone saw my head not perfect okay um would it be a long-term solution or another pecal solution that's option three I believe would be a long-term solution you what the Dual language because what if more families are would like to um be involved in that but because of spacing because we're only doing that

110at two different schools they're not able to so whereas if we had grade level centers it would be available perhaps I don't know but I'm just saying across no it it would position us option two three or four would position us to be able to start they're talking about uh true dual language where english- speaking students can also be in the B classroom um yes I think two three and four would position us to do that what would happen in um so what happens typically in a dual language model is your English-speaking kids um Transportation becomes more of an issue um because somehow we have to get those kids to whatever school has it um I don't think that's a significant issue um some districts have said to the English speaking families if you want

111your child in dual language and you have to get your child there and that's that kind of goes with it I know that's how champagne and Urbano both Do It um so that would be something for a future discussion I wouldn't I wouldn't get held up on Transportation of that slice um but yeah I mean it would really be looking at just option three is English-speaking kids at North you and Broad Meadow if they wanted to be in a dual language program that would only be at PA and Eon there would we would have to make a decision on would we be busing those kids or would we uh put the burden of Transportation on to the family um and it's going to matter too where they live um right because right now a large

112pretty good chunk of kids at north of you are already Walkers would be Walkers to Pleasant Acres or Esau as it is and I think one of my big concerns with this particular one is last year we asked our bilingual families to trust us that we weren't planning to do things that you know in some ways could make them feel further disenfranchised and I am concerned under three that it's going to seem like we are just again adding to some of the stress and strain on PA and Ison and the Optics is not necessarily what I mean it's really about feelings like I don't want to go back on what I said which is that I really do deeply care about those families and making things seem more just to them you know like make

113it seemed just better so I just I'm concerned about that piece of it I just had one thing um sorry again I wanted to wanted all of you guys all all the teachers and and um community members out there to know that at least I I'm and I'm sure the rest of the board appreciates you coming out and expressing your feeling I know sometimes um especially if you're you're uh staff member for the district some of you don't want to get up and and and prefer not to say anything um but the administrators um I'm sure Dr Woods and a ton of you teachers have done tremendous amount of work trying to trying to figure this out I know that um Nikki had said that we need we need a lot more information um but

114from what I got out of it it seemed like majority of at least the people that came here and spoke in front of the board has showed that they would prefer not I'm not saying that that's where we're going I'm just saying that they prefer not but at the same time the ones that did come in and Sh showed their expression of one running it I take my hats off to all of you because it takes you're giving us your ideas you're giving us your opinions and that's what we need we need your opinions one thing that kind of touched me um especially um listening to some of the teachers and and Community actually Community people we do have room and why are we having teachers and sped people in one class I feel bad

115for the people that's Eon if that's what's happening to them I mean we have to fix that we have to at least fix the things that we can fix you know it's not that and I believe the board feels the same way we're not trying not to do nothing we're just trying to do the right thing for everybody so please like Nikki said uh Mr Brotherton said Excuse Me Miss petett said we do need the information because if we don't get the information we can't we can't make a good good decision as a board one way or another so thank you guys very much and thank you for the hard work thank you guys all hard work like Nikki said we're split up here and we're not only split up here because we're trying to

116be at each other's throats or just want to disagree with each other together we're hearing different things from different people and we're looking at things differently but Nikki might be knowing something that I don't know um Excuse Me Miss pett might know something that I might not know so we have to know and hopefully the next couple weeks we can get something something done and hopefully we can make that vote on in February thank you one thing I'd say to many board members recently and I've shared this with our staff is that this is actually this is the process right this you're you're elected officials where we are the government whether we want to say it that way or not um and so this is the process it's transparent it's happening in public um and

117I think I in my conversations with our teachers especially they're very respectful of uh yes they know they want a decision but they do understand that the board is um being thoughtful um and considerate about the process so just fun to add that in you got which so hey B we're going to have more information from uh much about transportation and we'll decide if we're going to vote or not yeah on what we're going to do so so you're going get those things together for us yeah and I'll work with board leadership on and honestly I'll probably have to work with legal counsel to make sure I'm drafting motions properly on something like this m okay we'll do it Mondays but I will we'll have to work on uh work with board leadership on drafting

118what possible motions might be for the board to consider and again I'm just going to say it again what I'm hearing is decision on what and a decision on when okay fair to say what and W so two questions right okay one more one more question Dr Woods because I just F my paper over with option four would there be social workers in every school yes thank you I mean unless kindergarten still need it J of course they do oh are you going to send out a survey to them yeah they can tell us which families and one for families one for staff um and I've already started grafting it okay and as I said I think it's going to be uh in this type of survey more direct than you know this or that

119not so a simpler survey okay number nine information items oh very excited information items we had our a foia I forgot to put on the agenda last month to share with you but it's just a recurring one um I'd like to say that while the prade level schools has gotten us some media lately I did not put out a press release or ask for media just so everyone apparently wcia reads our Facebook posts um the student discipline report is in your packet first reading of board policy Updates this was from the October 24 press issue it is nothing uh significant there are seven policies to be updated um and it's all just um either part of fiveyear review or just updates because of new laws but nothing substantial so um I'll do a more careful

120reading of those uh prior to the next board meeting and that'll be on usually those are on the consent agenda at the next meeting so that was it for information on do business have new business I uh nck and I are are on the same page I know everybody wants us to rip the bandaid off I want to rip it off too I get it uh but for an action item to go up for vote next month I would like whatever decision is made to be Implement to be whatever decision is made that it would be implemented in the 26 27 school year so can it be worded like that I think that it would need would it yes it can be worded like that but that might not pass well I mean that's why

121I I don't know but I don't have a good answer I'm just thinking I think it's because he just talked about how we're going to V on two different things next time we're going to vote on which option want and when it's going to start what it this coming but since I made it a new business would it would it have to be worded as I worded it not necessarily it could be that can be a motion that someone could make okay I'm not sure I we decide couldn't we can make motion about that right so what I was trying to get clar because I can't because I can't make the motion right now right right because we can't have a vote yet so um what I want to get clarification on is can we

122do it with just one vote or do we need to have it be two separate votes that makes sense so option so we'll say date a or date B so like well it could be like okay someone would make a motion for grade level schools okay it's a second so now we have to vote does it pass okay the vote happens it fails now someone's going to have to call a motion for option three does that pass that passes then there can there be another motion then that says we start fall 25 and then or fall 26 you're wanting to wrap it up all into one I want it to be 26 27 yes a motion to say I will make a motion for whatever we choose to start 26 27 but I want the

123option in that case for 2425 25 25 26 sorry that's this year yeah not saying that that like but but I think that if it can be done I want that to be an option so because I mean I think thing is we're getting information from well and I think hopefully the teacher survey like please give us like honest perspectives if we do this few things we can do well because otherwise like we're waiting a year so I think that that is really another piece of the puzzle now like if it's grade level centers you know what's wrong with waiting a year to get our ducks in I know you keep on saying because of the financial piece of it but what it like I'm not better if we financially if we only do something

124this major once and I again I don't disagree I'm not like dead set on it I'm just saying like I think that we could get some more answers and it could be feasible yeah so I'm not comfortable saying absolutely not 26 if it's possible in 25 so it's not that I'm saying I'm de set on the fall like not even in the slightest you know if it can't be done it can't be done but if it can and it can be done in a that makes sense then why would we wait and not realize those benefits you know what I mean so and I think it's a lot because the preschool is moving we want to go to whatever option it's a lot we talk about mental health and all the stuff are we talking

125it's so much I'm not saying I'm like all I got do gay or nay wait for the survey and back Dr Woods trust the administration this all all this information and then we can make more they say enlightened decision and I want you to say survey say all right good buiness say so and super comments superintendent you want go first uh just some a lot of water some dates uh coming up uh Sunday January this Sunday is the CommunityWide Martin Luther King celebration we are not hosting it but it is being hosted at AER um in the in the main gym the Summers Carter gym um so two o'clock everyone's welcome our next regular meeting is Thursday February 20th uh the africanamerican Heritage night celebration is Friday February 28th that's something you're going to want

126to go to board members uh we'll make sure to get information out I think the committee met today to finalize some things and how are going to have some information go out soon uh kind of a cool thing which nobody else needs to attend but we uh are hosting an event for for the for isby the Illinois School Board uh we're a regional location for them on March 26 they're launching a new platform that really only administrators and clericals deal with uh it's currently called IW and they're moving to in system called my isby and we're one of the host sites so if you really want to come and hang out with people from ISB tech department come on March 26 that's my birthday is that spring break I didn't even check that's not spring

127break is it was I'm supposed to be there all right that's all I have for superintend Bo comment thanks everyone than once again thank you I say it every meeting thank you it takes a lot of C to come up here and say what you need to say we appreciate it and Co [Music] bills will make the motion to adjourn can I get a second thank you says thank you everybody Gat someone told me right no I didn't br

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.