CorpusRecord 117421

RCS 137 Board Of Education Meeting 12 19 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Rantoul City Schools 137
Date
2024-12-20
Location
Champaign County, IL
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,713 words · about 104 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Johnson hi di M hi Vicky pedit hi Tyler Wilson hi Robin B hi John Brotherton hi like public comments so just a point of clarification for the public that the item number 11 which was the K5 uh vote is going move to discussion only for tonight so the board will not be voting on that this evening uh we're going to move to public comment and I get to R this uh members of the public are welcome to speak during public comments public comments section of the meeting only comments are limited to five minutes per speaker board members uh will not respond to comments or questions during this time but they may follow up with speakers following the meeting and on the form there was a place to leave your contact information if you would like

002follow up um if the total time for public comment reaches 30 minutes the board May suspend further comments until later in the meeting uh speakers are asked to please conduct themselves with respect and civility toward others which has never been a problem Mr I think we have eight or nine this evening uh I think we at 11 11 are we going to go straight through all 11 not split them I think it's probably better to go straight yes all right okay so the first you're first sorry right I did not me and if you want to make sure you turn on the mic yes okay sure I know what you said here but we got five minutes okay right here good evening my name is Nilda Smith this is my third year in the role

003of multiable literacy specialist for RCS this is the that's some feedback is still here I'll swap out your microphone that's what it is we'll let you start over Nilda thank you okay testing okay good evening my name is Nilda Smith this is my third year in the role of multilingual literacy specialist for RCS this is the first year in this phys that I've been that excuse me that I've seen considerable growth in my students literacy skills that is directly related to my instructional practices why is this the first year that I've seen this growth my first two years I've traveled between two schools only seeing my students either two or three days a week depending on school I work with them primarily in Spanish the primary purpose of a literacy specialist is to provide support

004to students who are having difficulty learning to read and write within the regular classroom setting these students have learning difficulties that must be looked at closely it's my job to to help the school figure this out exactly what they need now that I'm at Pleasant Acres fulltime and I see them 30 minutes every day five days a week this has enabled me to give the Spanish speaking students at paa the same chances as English-speaking students to learn how to read and write plus with the added bonus of doing that in two languages if we go to grade level Center this way may or may not be happening as we know learning to read and right is a human right no matter where you are born or what language you speak it's my understanding that the

005district may or may not hire more support bilingual support staff to send to North View or broad Meadow right now the middle school has no bilingual literacy specialists more than likely myself or the other bilingual literacy specialists at Eon will be asked to travel between schools well thank you this won't be fair to Spanish speaking students it will also help to continue the cycle of giving power to certain groups and privilege while keeping other groups in a cycle of depression and poverty for the last seven years our multilingual program has become unified strong and effective our multilingual staff has given their blood their sweat and their tears to our students and our families we have bilingual literacy Specialists special education teachers ESL teachers administrators and building coordinators who have learned to work together complimenting each

006other's strengths and learning leaning on each other during difficult times if we are spread across by schools we will not be able to do that I'm just trying to shorten my com here so the following information was was taken from the article effective implementation of bilingual prog programs and this is from a 1998 article good bilingual programs upgrade the quality of instructional programming for multilingual students while at the same time providing a quality instructional program that enhances bilingualism as an advantage we need to have a Clear Vision about what we want to do for our program and we need to prioritize that at every single building that houses bilingual students administrators need to be proactive and informed about best practices for our multilingual students the key to program success is clear communication by everyone involved

007if our multilingual program is split five ways it will weaken losing opportunities to collaborate a sense of community and family and eventually our students will no longer be giving a chance to learn in Spanish and it will slowly die like it did almost a decade ago RCS lost many gifted and talented bilingual staff that year and if we continue along this path that we are going it will happen again thank you thank you ra good evening are you on good evening uh everybody greetings my name is rais and I'm the teacher at blr I have been working in RCS since 2016 in various capacities all involving in the community uh I have I have notice uh that words and definitions have been used so far without the precise academic connotation what the public understands of

008those words are the same ones that Academia use mean us when AC Academia use the term bilingual it means someone that can understand and use more than one language or when most people talk about bilingual education they're meaning the academic term biliteracy biliteracy is the capacity to read and write in two languages implying that they can also speak and understand both languages the term litery do does not exist in Spanish and all of those speakes will use the ter bilingual for the same term another term that is used out of academic context is Transitional bilingual education tve the program that we have that's the one that we're reporting to state that we have right now and it's supposed to be a program with a bable approach to use the home language education for early exit

009the idea is to move them as soon as possible to the regular mainstream English class this system is considered subtrac substractive meaning that the goal in English is English Mastery not by literacy and is not considered by experts at as the most beneficial we have a TW program happening that I'm talking about us that is called transitional program of instruction or TPI the difference is that there's no educational approach to the home language because we cannot provide a term that is never used is one way dual language education and it's not it's not made out got name it's a real thing by name we use uh by name we use the TBE to report to the state but in practice we're very close to this one that's the one that we actually almost Happ in

010right now we're very close this is considered a late exit program this program goal is the development of student bilingualism and biliteracy this is the definition by Garcia and cl 2018 in the book this Model start with a 90% just like in our case Spanish 10% English and well throughout the elementary with Pro progresses until 50 50/50 language time allocation uh in my own opinion we're closer to fully achieving that late exit model we need to add willing English modual students but we have a space issue that I will discuss later the last term that is generally understood correctly by everyone each dual language is dual language it is very simple every student receive 5050 location on both Langs the problem is the support needed to make it work champag international Preparatory Academy tried and

011didn't not work as suspected and it ended with a one way door language in the present time the problem that I I can perceive right now we're having presently is we like space not in the district as a whole but what it matters I'll give it an example to make it C there are t of thousands of homeless people in California and Nevada and all this and and California and Nevada and all the state to the north are practically empty people do not want to live there does it our town is more heavily populated on the east side than in the west side it is simple the East Side housing is mostly and generally more inspective than the West I know because I live right here we need the room where it's needed the proposal

012organization will fill to the brim e on Norv at the available space to grow will be be at P BR we just move the location of the problem not the solution there will be no no room to grow in those schools and the other two school will have plenty of room to spay this year the overcalling of Bing classroom is trigger triggered the change trigger the CH biling are the C as everyone W last year we were putting the board I good problem to have they are not aan they are our students Hispanics African-Americans Caucasian Asian all of them the new proposition do us allow space to grow between one and third grade and fourth grade in the bilingual program and will require that we keep shrinking the classroom strands to commodate classrooms I think

013that we need to really have a well plan that is planned by the people involved ining expert in each area or using the ones that we have in our RS plans don't so far do not foresee future problems because they're always familial we were doing with our studing is working we need consistance we have changed three years in a row and we're planning the four change student in Fr every classroom is set a solution is a big patch I think the board and our district can do better than that M um and and anyone else that since I noticed you have written comments so if you want to send those to me and know the whatever you didn't get to read we can put that in the minutes for the next meeting okay and sure

014lightly I'm the literacy specialist at acre I've been in the district for 12 years um I am against grade level centers of any kind I have expressed all my concerns to the board H for and the fact that we're here discussing this again makes it feel like we're not being listen to two years ago Eon had over 300 students so they're fifth grade students were SE to% Acres when they came to our school the climate changed drastically it felt like an us against them mentality against us staff um this year the climate is completely different the new students that we do have quickly became comfortable with me because they saw that their peers already felt safe with me our Administration agreed with Eon that it is too difficult to manage more than 300 students at

015one school the rec M plan for next year has one school with 330 students and another with 342 it feels like we're repeating the mistakes of the past instead of learning from them one concern I've heard is that bilingual classes are large and overcrowded and that we're out of compliance with the 90% rule the recommended plan does nothing to address this it does not add a single bilingual classroom what it does instead is increase the monolingual class size significantly from a district average of 16.3 up to 20.7 We are giving every teacher in the district the same problem that we claimed this plan would fix we know that students who move schools have a difficult time adjusting because we see in our students our high fers are overwhelmingly students who have moved in I can

016tell you example after example of students that displayed alarming Behavior on a regular basis but now after multiple years of consistency at Pleasant Acres our fine and functional the recommended plan guarantees that every student in our entire Community will be forced into this change every one to two years if we care about the emotional well-being of our students we will provide them with stability not transitions according to um Scott's November 15th email um the board is trying to figure out quote how to improve the overall quality of education for all students while meeting the needs of our increasingly multilingual population I do not see how making classes bigger putting many more students at two of the schools and adding unneeded transitions meets that goal as a literacy specialist I rely on my relationship and rapport

017with the struggling readers that I work with I see the ma vast majority of my students for multiple years without consistency across R lost our struggling readers will suffer I also have the unique perspective of being a former kindergarten teacher it is a Herculean task to take a group of students and teach them how to do school I relied on the example of older students to set the tone of our school and model expectations there are not enough people in the world to effectively support 186 kindergarteners in one I'm advocating on behalf of the students in this community because I hear deeply about them and their emotional health but my final point is a selfish one the way that I've been able to stay in this profession despite the odds is by seeing the successes

018of the students that I've taught our fifth grade class this year is the perfect example the world shut down for the pandemic when they were in kindergarten and they came back to us in second grade with the emotional and academic abilities of kindergarteners I am proud to report that out of our entire fifth grade class there are only three of our traditional Learners that need our District's new phonics intervention all three of them are on the highest level of work testing our program there is no higher motivation than seeing my former students Thrive and hearing them read success thank Youk good evening I'm Lindsay Brotherton a second grade teacher at makers and know not related to John brother this is my 11th or 12th if you want to count part of a year that I

019was at Pleasant Aces and my 14th year at RCS plus some subing years before that just as just so you know I am pretending that you are seven and eighty olds because those are my fa we start each day in our class room with a morning meeting and our commitment I say it is our job as your teacher to keep you safe so that you can learn and it is your job and they say to keep it that way this allows for them to feel safe and that I am giving them safety safety is key for our Scholars to learn it's brain science in order to create safety relationship is key a big factor to relationship is six transitions kindergarten 1 3D 5ifth 6th and nth will not build relationships with students and it will

020not be safe I realize that three of these Transitions kindergart and six and nth grade we can't really but the other three are preventable we can keep students in a grade in a school from ker to fifth grade but I should also make that the larger class sizes will not help either in my 11 years at PA I have had four principles a new team almost every year but the core of the PA still stands and most of them are here tonight we are adults and transition comes and goes and change is much easier for us with our adult-sized brains this is not the case for our Scholars with still growing brains I watch a first grader each day pass my classroom and his classroom and go down and hug his kindergarten teacher then he

021goes to his first grade classroom and I want to watch him do this next year go to kindergarten and hug his teacher and go to first grade and hug his teacher and then each day I see former students um in the hallway I give them a thumb wave and sometimes they pop over and give me a hug even though it's not really loud we're supposed to say it's okay because they're giving hug this would not be possible from the grade level Center structure or after school kids I see fifth graders all the time not quite doing the right thing I call their names I give them a quick reminder and they're like yeah I know I can do that when I was when it was the K2 model I was a second grade teacher at

022Pleasant acors the second graders had this I'm in charge mentality and the next year when those third and fifth grader fourth and fifth graders came back they seem to change their mentality and they're like now I have some older students to be my role model we also do class buddies to help with those older role moders for the younger students and with a grade level Center we won't be able to do class buddies with fifth graders gr um not only teacher relationships but also um teachers outside the classroom like the cafeteria workers the specials teachers the support staff the admin the janitors and many more these relationships matter to students and should be supported with stability not transition I keep hearing that this is not the same as what RCS had before when we have

023the K2 3 five centers sister schools and that is true it's not the same this is actually wor because there's more TR positions for students um yeah I've seen that there are other districts that came up in the proposal that we compared to and I'm most familiar with one of them because I'm from that community and currently in Muhammad there are only four transitions for students which three of them are required with kindergarten Sixth and Ninth Grade but not um but only one is unrev that could be preventable if the buildings were um in neighborhoods like ran our buildings are in neighborhoods so we should have neighborhood schools in that District the buildings aren't in neighborhoods so it wouldn't work that way I didn't see any other of the other comparable districts with six transitions

024like RCS I could I could go on with lots of examples and um every staff member here can too and I realize that there's positives with money and but health is more important and I can't stress enough how important relationship and safety is for the learning of our students I would like to urge you to take action and vote against this recommendation for the restructured and grade level centers and keep the current School structure we need to grow relationships and safety not transitions thank you for your time hello my name is lon and I'm born and raised in Ran Illinois I come to you tonight as a Staker in our children's learning I'm a first year teacher and a lot of Gusto I have in Pride in my pleas family those are my people as

025a first year teacher I know I'm still learning where the is I'm aware but I also am learning how to handle this job in its entirety I also know I'm invested invested in this town in this district and in our kids they are my priority each and every day no one is disagreeing where this impact is going to come our kids will experience whatever decision you make when you make it our staff will lead whatever example you tell us to lead I see firsthand how our intentions are received with our kids how oural and our academic content is interpreted at my second grade level I see the excitement of students and their families as they have the opportunity to invest right back into RCS more specifically the school their children's their children attend these families

026are investing in their scholars in their educational and emotional well-being as being active members of their learning so no it's not what the dollars in their pockets but families have a lot of responsibility I get the opportunity and the honor every single day to speak beautiful words into these children we touch on pure conflict we touch on transitions grade level academics and whatever else seven and eighty olds want to come up with that day we cry together we laugh together we problem solve together but most importantly we learn together we are a class family now now I know it's possible to build a strong class family each and every year but the pros of our neighborhood schools are that the teachers interact within all student experiences at all levels so that when the chance comes

027that they get to enter my class they get to enter my class family I can better love care and teach them I'm prepared so boor please consider the class families the student families the ranal community you are disrupting with the move to grade level centers as a first year teacher I may be able to empathize more than anyone as freshly learning where the bathroom is who are the safe people to go to who are my people where can I go to solve a problem how can I follow this school's expectations and do I even belong here those are questions that will be asked each year as Scholars move to a new transition in their learning our goal should be clear lesson the unknown an impact of change to strengthen the families we build in our

028school they say it takes a village so I'm calling on my Village ran tool moveing the best efforts for our kids thank you cson it's co first I want to thank you for always being willing to hear from me over and over and over again I know the task that you have in front of you is difficult to say the least and you volunteering your time and energy to do this important but unfortunately often thanless job so thank you I worked at RCS since 2004 and lived here since 2006 my own children are currently at JW and RT HS and they attended PA for Elementary in the past I shared with you my beliefs and experiences regarding the grade bubble schools and I still stand by everything I've shared but I wanted to give you

029a different perspective tonight while I was talking or vening to my son about the proposed change yesterday when he was home sick we started talking about his experience at PA I asked him what he liked about PA and without hesitation he surprised me by saying that his favorite was when he had the same teacher in both fourth and fifth grade she had chosen to follow she had chosen to follow her class to the next grade level and he still remembers that as being one of the most positive thing for him and his classmates while at PA this practice is called looping and it was especially interesting that he brought it up because I just finished a book called hidden potential by Adam Grant where he references this practice and a study conducted specifically to fine

030schools that had made some significant improvements to student achievement loping was found to be a major contributor to that success no I am not suggesting that we mandate loing in our schools I do believe it can be beneficial but I also believe it has to be the right fit and that not all teachers students or parents would choose that path however the reasons that it is impactful and successful is because of the connections built between the teacher and the students the teacher bur relationships learns the Scholar's interests what motivates them what doesn't and how they learn best learning just simply continues from year to year because the teacher already knows the specific needs and where learning left off the previous year this can result in improved attendance reduced suspensions tailored instruction and supporting Scholars emotional

031needs students are connected trust has already been established and because those needs have been made that the brain can operate at the optimal level like I said while I'm not necessarily advocating for looping unless of course the choose teacher chooses to and I realize it's not the answer in every case I am advocating for us as Educators to allow for the positive outcomes however we can when I asked my son what he liked his answer was simple he liked his teacher she liked him she knew his interests where he was academically and personally and they just clicked and when I asked him if he thought that his classmates liked it he said definitely those that often struggled from year to year and he knew who they were had already bonded with her she knew how

032to calm them down or even prevent situations from happening before they started and the specific kids that he mentioned were not new to the district some of them I even had had in first grade the difference was having a consistent teacher not consistent classmates cons consistency of adults whether it be the classroom teacher principal special teacher interventionist Etc is the key we need as many experts on our Scholars as possible this of course includes families building trust and communication with them also takes time do gry bubble Center create these opportunities or we Str or or we struggle to make that happen having more teachers in the same grade level was also mentioned as a a potential POS in my experience with Centers before the obstacles that we faced with this were that we still didn't

033have the plan same plan time because there are only four special options each day because we had different students with different needs our pacing wasn't always in line we tried to divide students based on the skills that they needed reteaching in so like in our literacy block we would divide them up on their specific needs we quickly learned that this extra transition was difficult for many scholars and it even sometimes created division amongst our teachers our goal was to provide instruction and monitor progress so that we could move them through those skills as they needed them but because there was so little time for us to get to know those students and form that trust learn what they needed and how best to connect with them we often found ourselves with significant if amount of

034kids that were unwilling similar struggles occurred when we consider departmentalizing in closing please believe me when I say that I do welcome change and I'm not opposed to it I promise I'm not out to proove anything or make your decision harder than it already is and I will do my best as I always do to carry out the initiatives that are decided upon thank you for listening and thank you for continuing to ask the hard questions to all our students need to be successful hi sorry I did not write anything I wasn't planning on coming and so I showed up um my name is Tanya Bell I have of my four children that are so school they we moved here a year ago the same day school started and three of them started at PA

035one started at ader and within two weeks of my students starting to win fifth grade this year um I realized I had to become as involved in the school as I could and I then made it my mission to hold as many jobs in the district as I could in um two paid one not um but I did become a parent Mentor first um and got very involved with the current third uh the third grade who wasth grade and then I became a general at TA and I did a quick stent as custodian as well um my thoughts tonight is based basically on how my two daughters handled fifth grade last year and it wasn't great I brought in four straight A students to the district that excelled that tested well and those two girls

036in fifth grade last year struggled they struggled with the climate they struggled with B uh one of my daughters became a sh of herself within months and it was sad and it was sad to see and when I became involved in the school and I came in and I saw the the chaos in the classrooms I saw where it was going I saw th graters that were hiding in the library during lunch hour because the librarian was nice enough to do a reading out because that's the only place they could escape from the chaos that had ensued that their school that they hadn't had before I watched children that had no connections to the teachers and then there were fifth graders that did and the fifth graders that had connections their third grade their kindergarten

037teacher would be pulling them aside and talking to but the fifth graders that had no Anor at that school it didn't happen this year I'm aenna ta PA at Pleasant Acres and the connections are there so the kids that are there they're helping out with fifth graders instead of being this chaos entity they're reaching out helping the kindergarteners I watched one student yesterday check in with a particularly hard case and how are you doing sir you know you better I better hear good things from your teacher and I watched this kindergarten glow under the attention of an older student and I wonder what happens to the school when that doesn't happen and that's gone my youngest child is currently in fourth grade so next year would extremely affect her and I'm sitting here wondering what

038kind of a parent I would be knowing what happened to my two daughters last year letting my daughter go into a school that that chaos happens this would be the first year or whether or not as a as a parent I protect my child from that and P her and find somewhere else that is better suited to what her needs are because I would hate see A Happy Well adjusted child who runs around the school somewhat like her mother trying to have as many jobs as she can I would hate to see her become a shell like her sister or struggle and then wait for junior high to find herself again or find her voice I would i' hate to see that happen um as a general at TA I I wonder what a entire

039School of kindergarteners that all need help and there's only so much help looks like and how many connections can I make with how many kindergartners at once how many one on ones can I have I'm only one person and even if you hire a bunch T how many are going to keep um as far as fifth grade goes we were I know we lost a lot of fifth grade teachers last year districtwide we were lucky to keep one amazing teacher at pa um and I would like to see her Inspire more fifth grade teachers to stay and not leave the district but I'm not sure if what happened last year at PA happens at another school if we could keep teachers at all or students I think that's about all I have to say thank

040youel you're okay well I know you guys all know me I'm Rachel Palmer and I'm a special education teacher at East Bond and I'm here tonight just talking to you as Rachel Palmer the special education teacher and um I'm gonna kind of flip the rooll because I'm actually really in favor of grade level centers gotta find My Notes here and I just want to go over a bunch of reasons why number one Focus curriculum and resources teachers and staff can specialize in a narrow range of grade level allowing them to develop deeper expertise and tailor instructional practices to specific developmental stages resources such as libraries Technologies and learning materials could be better aligned to the needs of particular age group number two peer collaboration and Social Grow students interact with peers who are at similar

041Developmental and educational levels fostering stronger age appropriate social connections and collaboration grouping students by grade can reduce the challenges of a wide age range with a single School such as balancing vastly different social emotional and academic needs enhancing teacher collaboration teachers working within the same grade levels are in closer proximity making it easier to share strategies collaborate on lesson plans and align instruction to state or District standards professional development efforts can be more focused and relevant for teachers within specific trade veas tailored School environment the physical environment classroom setups playgrounds and restrooms can be designed specifically for the develop developmental needs of each grade range school policies events and traditions can be customized to fit the age group creating a more cohesive and age appropriate culture equity and resour ources grade level centers often help

042distribute resources more equitably across the district for example instead of duplicating specialized programs or services at multiple schools they can be centralized and consistently delivered special services such as reading and math interess could be better coordinated for students and specific grades efficient use of facilities grade level centers can reduce duplication of resources and space making it easier for districts optimize building use and maintain smaller class sizes I heard um some people speak earlier about um worried that the class sizes were going to get bigger and I just I can't figure out where that's coming from because in my eyes every class would be at the same or maybe one off so I don't think that class sizes if we're not losing any staff um the class sizes shouldn't grow um stronger focus on developmental mileston

043schools can create program programming curricular and events that align closely with the developmental mil stones of specific age groups ensuring students get the right support at the right time and now for the special education benefits which is what I am passionate about um centralized specialized Services centralized specialized Services grade level centers allow for centralization of special education services speech therapy occupational therapy behavioral support making it easier to develop to deliver these Services efficiently and consistently specialized staff such as special education teachers paraprofessionals and therapists can work closely with a more focused group of students peer grouping special education students are grouped with peers of similar Developmental and educational stages providing opportunities for Meaningful interaction and socialization grouping by level reduces the wide age gaps that can occur in general education or resource rooms creating a

044more age appropriate learning environment improv teacher expertise teachers and staff can specialize in spef specific grade levels allowing them to refine their understanding of Developmental needs and best practices for working with students in those age ranges staff are more likely to be familiar with individualized education program goals that align with a specific developmental stage of of the students they serve increased inclusion opportunities grade level centers often have a larger student population per grade level which can facilitate inclusion opportunities by matching special education students with general education peers in classrooms or extracurricular activities teachers and grade level centers may have more experience implementing inclusive practices due to the fostered nature of the school enhanced collaboration between Educators special educator special education teachers and general education teachers can collaborate more easily within a grade level Center to

045ensure that instruction aligns with IEP goals co- teing models may be more feasible providing students with additional inst structional support one more this Harper sorry this Harper hi I'm Sherry Harper and I am a kindergarten teacher at Brad metal Elementary however I am not speaking for myself this evening I was sharing a letter that was written by Lindsay brayer who is music teacher at Brad Meadow and I'm able to do this because my thoughts very closely align what Lindsay is thinking so I'm going to read it now as if I am Curr hello my name is Lindsay Brer and I am the music teacher at Brad Meadow this is my 11th year with RCS and my 13th year in education I'm here tonight to express my concerns regarding the proposed implementation of grade level centers

046within our school district while I appreciate and understand Dr Wood's efforts to improve educational outcomes and address logistical challenges I believe this restructuring could have signic ific unintended consequences for students families and our community as a whole I respectfully urge you to veto this proposal and consider alternative ways to achieve our District's goals I have the privilege of serving as the music teacher at Broad Meadow over the years I have been in a unique position to see every student in our school from kindergarten to fifth grade I've had the honor of watching my first group of students grow into college students Young professionals and even parents I've seen children who struggled academically socially and behaviorally Blossom into successful and confident individuals this has been one of the greatest joys of my careers I second that

047ly in my role I don't just teach music I collaborate with classroom teachers to integrate other subjects into my lessons whether it's math history or reading I do this because I care deeply about our students and education and want to contribute to their success in every way possible I care about their Futures and want to equip them with the skills and confidence they need to thrive in addition to my relationships with the students I've also built genuine friendships with many families these relationships create a sense of trust and continuity that benefits the entire School Community this is one of the things that makes our school so special and I'll second that as well in addition to my relationships with the students I have also built genuine friendships with many of the families these relationships create

048a sense of trust and continuity that benefits the entire School Community this is one of the things that again makes our school special I think I read that one twice um while I value my personal connections my concerns about the proposed grade level centers go beyond my own experiences I firmly believe this approach will not best serve our students or their families the mission of ranal schools is to build a stronger Community by educating our students this Mission emphasizes the importance of unity consistency and collaboration in fostering a supportive educational environment transitioning to grade level centers would disrupt the continuity that is critical for both Student Success and Community cohesion families rely on stable School placements to build longterm term relationships with teachers staff and peers splitting siblings across different buildings and requiring students to

049adapt to new environments every few years undermines the stability and creates it creates unnecessary stress for families special education and bilingual programs would be particularly affected by this transition students receiving specialized Services Thrive when they have consistent relationships with building staff who understand their unique needs moving these students between grade level centers could disrupt progress and delay delay the development of trust and Rapport similarly bilingual students benefit from programs that build over time with a single School Community constantly changing schools would hinder their ability to fully engage and succeed in these programs our district has worked hard to establish after school programs that support academic achievement Social Development and family engagement ment transitioning to grade level centers May complicate these efforts as well as Transportation Transportation Logistics and program continuity could become more difficult to

050manage the loss of these vital resources would disproportionately impact families who rely on the after school care for their children another critical concern is the potential loss of Staff many Educators and support staff value the strong connections they have built within their current School School communities one of the greatest strengths at brotto is the sense of school family that it Fosters I'll second that students thrive in environments where they feel a strong connection to their peers teachers and support staff by dividing students into grade level centers we risk dismantling these close-knit relationships replacing them with a more transient and impersonal experience for younger students especially the continuity of seeing familiar faces and very sorry wants to know I forget he's here this is Cooper He's a therapy dog at um broad met Elementary just another

051reason why um we would not want to have grade level centers because the students there K through two have all met Cooper and have bonded with him Mr Kelling you're next so I have that's my other little piece there I needed to get there you got it'ser I apologize I'm not as um so I want to apologize I have been trying to think all day what to say um I came here with the intention of asking you to table L as a discussion and move action next month or at a later dat so thank you Miss P for doing so uh my name is cran Kelly I'm the parent of a North View second grader and a later seventh grader um believe me this is not the RCs building I hope to be at tonight

052I had to leave my son's basketball game at half time and see my daughter Christmas program to be here when my daughter looked at me and asked why I said I got to go I have to speak for you for your cousins for your classmates for your um this really she's in second grade ago yeah this plan would ever there for third and fourth grade she have one transition it's not a lot of impact on this but I think if this if this would have happened a couple years ago it would have thrown off our whole experience my kids are a few years apart they have in their entire education they had one year for kindergarten year is fifth grade year that they were in the same building and I think of how much that

053helped her did through experience having si in the same building um I think about the teachers that my children have experienced as AR view um you know as as all of you I spent many years in the classroom as a student I then taught for 12 years I wasn't as strong as these people behind me to survived the classroom um that's one I one of the ones who who got out um out of all my years as a student out of my years as a teacher my years as a parent I have to say that and I tell everybody this the teachers that you have experienced at Northfield are phenomenal absolutely NE uh I wish I would have worked with teachers with passion they I wish I would have experienced the teachers that they had

054out of the teachers my son had K5 and now my daughter in second grade there are only two remaining in the classroom at nor others have moved on others have uh moved to other schools run Administration i' I've listened to a bunch of amazing Educators and I think what I want to ask you tonight listen and support these amazing Educators time um listen to the community hope I be one of the only parents up here it's hope more be able just sit up here and say I all uh but I'm glad I came and SP um please give us more time consider uh the full impact uh it's there's a lot more i' love to discuss um some other thoughts with you as well uh but please listen and and support there's there's fire there's

055passion behind me and it's hard I know from experience it's hard to maintain that as a teacher so please continue to support me thank you thank you thank you thank you you have anything else you like to send to us please do or just our thank you public comment section we have one more that was turned in there's one more sorry I did I see it I mean go through who is your microphone my teach voice if I need to good evening my name is Nikki Prat I'm a second grade teacher at Brad elementary school I have been a teacher at Brad for seven years and I am speaking on behalf of multiple teachers from BR Meadow members of the board we are writing to address the upcoming vote on the proposed K5 grade level

056redistricting schedule for tonight as K5 teachers within the district we feel it is important to present our concerns and offer a perspective that we believe has not yet fully been considered we acknowledge that Dr Woods has discussed this redistricting plan for some time and has shown great interest in bringing it to fruition in ranal schools however it was not made clear to us that a vote on this proposal would take place this year and even more surprising that it would be expected to take effect by the start of the next school year this is a significant and complex undertaking and we believe that any plan of this magnitude requires a carefully considered implementation strategy one that reflects the gravity of the changes being proposed while we hope such a plan exists it has not been

057shared with staff or families for review this year our district began implementing an inclusion model by establishing cross-curricular classrooms in each building this shift represented a major change for both special education and general education staff while we are supportive of inclusion practices the implementation was rushed and we feel the process was not Ade communicated moreover the lack of comprehensive training on best practices for Effective inclusion has left staff feeling unprepared the process felt like we were building an airplane while flying it with insufficient contingency plans in place to support both students and staff if support plans for staff students and families existed they were either unclear or sorry they were either unclear or not effectively communicated given this experience we are now being asked to accept a plan to redistri our students into grade level

058centers by the start of next school year without a clear shared understanding of how this will be implemented in the past when similar plans were considered staff were surveyed and multiple question and answer sessions were held before the vote was taken this time however staff had not had the opportunity to provide feedback or asked questions parents were notified via parents Square last night but the communication was vag offering little information about what the redistricting plan actually entails the email sent to staff was only distributed prior to tonight's board meeting effectively eliminating the chance for Meaningful dialogue or question staff were informed that a question and answer session would occur only after the decision has been made this approach feels deliberately designed to avoid the push back that would inevitably inevitably arise from both staff and

059families leaving little room for Meaningful input students in our district like all children thrive on predictability trust and strong relationships the proposed districting plan would create a situation where a student entering preschool in the 2025 2026 school year could potentially attend six different schools as they begin high school students in special education face particular challenges with this model as self-contained classrooms have already been relocated once in the past year for the students and families this would mean disrupting established relationships with teachers and staff forcing them to adjust to new environments staff and expectations every year or two for students and life skills cross partic Cross C sorry cross cat or social emotional classrooms there is no Clear Vision of how their needs will be met in a district organized by grade level centers these classrooms

060typically serve to mixed age groups and offer students the opportunity to spend part of their day in general education settings while maintaining their self-contained classroom as a base the small class sizes and the classrooms allow for more individualized support and skill development however it is unclear how this model would function within the grade level structure and we have not been provided with any details or a clear plan regarding how these students will be supported in this new system it is difficult to fly assess the impact of Any of of any of this proposal as there is now no concrete timeline or detailed implementation plan available for review the current plan provides only an outline of the what with no Clarity on on the house for the past few years it has felt as though the

061district has become increasingly impatient with the efforts and to implement change unfortunately this impatient often comes at the expense of thoughtful planning and open discourse the grade level Center model has been tried before in this district and it failed at considerable cost to the district while this plan has been presented as a solution to the challenges within our school district we are not convinced that it's near difference from the current model guarantees it will be an improvement Dr Woods has indicated that he is competent this change will lead to some staff departure but that the majority of the staff members tend to stay even when changes are proposed while this may be true it is important to recognize that the relationships built between staff students and families are one of are one important and often

062discounted reason staff members remain in the district sorry thank you sorry I it was here I messed up okay team over there are any other didn't know we did I want I know yeah thank you had all right um my name is dores I am a third grade teacher at elementary school as well came in not expect me to speak tonight so I didn't write anything out was in promp to and I'm like okay yes I need to go um and I'm speaking as a former administrator who knows and understands the impact po CL has on a building and disrupting that uh could potentially cause the loss of some very talented Educators who have just begun their career and chose to begin C man tool um for example my colleague my third grade colleague and

063I have taken on student teachers and those student teachers actually came back to interview and wanted to teach at Pleasant Acres that speaks to the collegiality and the culture and clate that we have set up at building in addition to the relationships between the colleagues families have also developed relationships with with us as teachers our administrative staff and so um many people have already spoken about how difficult it is to build relationship with families um but we have been able to do that we have students need heard over and over again about students coming back and visiting their previous teachers the kids need that the families need that so um you know as I think about the relationships that have been built in the culture and climate and cality that we have at cin I've

064been in education for over 26 years and it does not there is no other place that I've taught that has those kinds of relationships and cality that we have with families and our our colleagues aters and so I'm I'm selfish in saying I would like to continue to have that kind of relationship with our families and our colleagues in the building that we are currently um I am very concerned about using talented teachers again teachers are not easy to find and when you look at um student the student Graphics it is hard teaching is hard and it's even harder in an area where um you know you have a diverse popul thank you thank you the audience if if any of you would like to leave now we could know we going back to our

065regular programming [Music] I that's fine take a moment and just you we're Notch uh K5 tools are a discussion topic coming up so if you want to hear the discussion don't don't [Music] we anything yeah nine 10 okay okay [Music] you're not it number four agenda all right Bo in the con Miss not back yet wait second do you see Miss vau I think she went to go find water oh no okay I won't say anything all right um the on the consent agenda tonight we have the board meeting minutes from our last meeting the regular financial information uh Personnel report I want to bring attention to the board that within the Personnel report this month is a revised salary schedule for occupational and physical therapists um and also a contract for psychology Services which

066is because we are short staff with psych Psy school psychologist if there are no questions motion to approve consent agenda items including person report and submitted within stipulation that each individual all requ newo stat RCS policy proceeds ination of bills prepa by the finance manager under board policy 4 thank you can I a second second nikk Moto Johnson hi Johnston Diana Mendoza hi Vicky pedet hi Tyler Wilson hi Robin Bond Don brother hi yeah six okay so the first thing up is the approval of fiscal year 2024 audit report and the annual financial report um there is a brief summary of the audit in the board packet there were no findings of any significance um in the audit thank you questions from board am like make motion motion to approve the resol mo to approve

067the presented I'll secondo Johnson hi Katie Johnston hi Diana mza hi Nikki ped hi Tyler Wilson I Robin V we're voting to approve the audit okay I brother hi okay there we go up next is the resolution concerning and affecting the tax levy for 2025 I didn't put what I was going to say in here um so it's in the board's P um so this year we presented last month is we will be reducing the property tax rate Chris is here if anyone has any questions but you want me to put you on the spot right and uh it we are projecting an actual percentage increase of 3.62% um and with a tax rate reduction of all greater than a quarter of a point and all of this uh increase in revenue is a result

068of increased property values um so this is the levy is when we um were asking for the county to collect the taxes they typically don't collect them all so the number that we Levy is is always slightly higher than what we anticipate so um that is what is in there there's a resolution uh related to The Levy in your packet would like to read the recommendation or the recommended motion I'll make a motion to improve the resolution concerning and affecting tax L thank K second okay second Johnson hi Johnston Diana hi hi Tyler Wilson hiin Bond hi number eight you're okay eight nine and 10 are basically the same thing so for members of the public we have to read the really long motion and vote on three of these in a row um what

069they are is we have uh bonds that have been issued over the years for facilities improvements we actually just issued one this year for the prek center um so this is a resolution saying we aren't collecting property taxes to pay for those bonds we are using sales tax and it's a very long document we just have to read the resolution and if you would please Tyler I think I'll make the motion to approve the resolution abing the tax 34 Lev for the year 2024 to pay debt service on taxable General obligation School bonds alternate Revenue Source series 2016 qu qualified School construction bonds of school district number 137 and I'll just record which this will be in the minutes but it's in that first line I should have had 2016 not 2024 so it's not

070your fault but just clarifying this is the 2016 Bond the motion's good so a second I'll secondo Johnson hi Kati Johnston hi Diana Mendoza hi Nikki pett hi Tyler Wilson hi Robert Bon hi John Brotherton hi all right Tyler before we try to do this I'm gonna fix this because it's just going to trick us there we go this is one I know I couldn't do live television okay now I want to do number nine I'll make the motion to approve the resolution abating the tax here cour levied for the year 2020 to pay debt service on General obligation money schol B School bonds alternate Revenue Source series 2020 and School District number 137 I'll second it MoGo Johnson hi Katie Johnson hi Mendoza hi ped hi Tyler Wilson hi Robin Bon hi John brother

071I up next number 10 Mr Wilson the motion to approve the resolution the the tax here Bo for the year 20204 p services on General obligation School bom Rue St series 2024 school district7 I'll second that lto Johnson hi ktie Johnston hi Diana Mendoza hi Vicky pedit hi Tyler Wilson hi Robin B John brother I now move number 11 is PD discussion of K5 School Organization okay um and I do what every year I ask do we really have to read all three of those and the answer is still yes so um all right we're going to go ahead and jump in and um also the my team over here on this side of the room I know I've asked Allison Vier who's our director of special education assistant superintendent and uh Jamie Round Tree

072who is the director of CRI instruction if you guys can to wait they're going to be chiming in throughout so I don't know if you want to get each of you could have a mic I know there's two over there um but here we go um so I realize that it it does seem like a broken record that we are again having a discussion at board meetings about possibly reorganizing uh K5 schools and I I'm going to start off by providing some background for everyone um in the 1970s I'm going to go way back right in the 1970s RCS had an enrollment of almost 5,000 students as of today this day we are at 1,683 um which also now includes prek students um RCs at the time had a total of six Elementary campuses plus

073other locations and over that same time period the village of ranol has de increased from a community of about 25,000 residents to about 12,000 prior to Shen Air Force Base closing in 1993 enrollment was already declining and we we were down to the current Four elementary school buildings beginning in 2006 2007 RCS shifted to grade level centers Pleasant Acres and Easton served K grades K2 and North View and Broad Meadow served grades three through five so the version of history that I hear I don't think you are on the board then were you this a serious question you were in 2006 all right and uh so that's when we shifted to grade level centers and it's not 100% clear why people have different versions of history about that but uh what I've shared when I'm

074asked is there were several one was new accountability measures that were a result of the No Child Left Behind legislation um it was an attempt to balance student demographics in a a dramatically shifting demographic within our community um and shrinking local Financial Resources so as the population had declined uh resources to support the schools was also declined these seem to be the main reasons when you ask folks who were around then as to what was happening at the time and the model of grade level centers ended in 2014 2015 so last school year and we have had a K5 structure I say plus or minus a K5 structure since 2015 2016 so uh someone emailed me today and asked well what was the reason we ended grade level centers in 20145 so I have an

075idea in my head I went back guess what there are multiple News Gazette articles online quoting former board members and the superintendent at the time so here's what I found so according to accounts in the News Gazette um there were significant concerns about student Behavior ongoing issues with transportation and a lack of academic progress around that same time RCS was also making some other significant shifts um I would say two the two big ones are at the start of the 201516 years so we went back to K5 schools that is also the year that Oran City Schools exited the special education Co-op so we were taking control of providing our special education services at that point within another year we were no longer operating our smar own transportation system which tells me that we were

076struggling to operate the transportation system uh when we had K or the grade levelers so those were two of the big things we've been with the first student ever since and we're going to talk about that later tonight however what you can see on this screen I know it's a little hard to see um for those of you in the audience but I'll just tell you this it's pretty much a straight line okay U and this was from the demographic report that the board commissioned that was presented earlier this school year um since 2014 and that's how far back we went with the study our enrollment has remained stable student enrollment in 201415 was 1,662 right now it's 1,683 um it has gone up uh we got really big before Co we had this year

077of 1,800 kids and uh but other than that year um it's pretty it's been very stable um so meanwhile RCS became increasingly diverse in that time I'm going back farther than 2014 um and I've shared a lot of this with the staff already our multilingual program which is our bilingual program Rafael did a nice job of talking about different ways to talk about bilingual programming but in 2006 the farthest back I could go to get the data from the state 1.9% of our students were classified as multilingual and what I can tell you is in districts that have populations of 1.9% there's almost nothing actually impacted programmatically their districts probably are not even providing English as a second language Services students are in the classrooms they're expected to survive is what happens when you have

078that few um but as you can see that number has increased to the most recent school report card is more than a quarter of our students are identified as multilanguage Learners that does not mean they all participate in our I I'll refer to it today as the bilingual program um not all do but we have a very large uh growing Bilal population so since 2006 our multilingual students have become an increasingly large portion of our student population I'm not presenting that as a problem I'm presenting that as a fact um but our total student enrollment since 2006 has actually decreased last spring when the board commissioned the demographic study that showed these Trends are likely to continue our student population over the next five years will likely um multilingual students will continue to an increasingly

079large percentage of our population and the total student population they project will decrease um slightly I think they had a decreasing by 20 students it's on the previous slide um so what the board has been wrestling with and me too since I came into the superintendency is how to improve the overall quality of education for all students while meeting the needs of our increasingly multilingual population and doing this within our limited resources um I would say that a lot of suggestions I get are things that I would love to do but they involve spending $20 million on a school uh things that simply aren't realistic or add more staff when we don't have classrooms in the buildings for the staff um so I hope everyone appreciates that also that this process even though I I'm

080fully aware that parents and family are families and staff uh may not have been aware of how close the board was to making a decision um this is something that is a process that's been taking place publicly um and as I said already we're not in a position to build new schools add unlimited number of Staff um we would be having a very different discussion if that was something we could do and I I know that the board would be in favor of that if we had those resources um so the board has been considering organizational patterns for several years uh in order to address our enrollment and in the same way that I said it's like a broken record and I've gotten some emails today h I can feel it why are we still

081talking about this um I know the Border builds that way too sometimes is because we have to come up with a solution that's going to last long term and we cannot continue to move a part of our student population each year um as a Band-Aid to move forward um so some things that the board has done because again this is not a new thing uh during the 2022 23 school year eon's fifth graders and most of their siblings and and one of our Miss Bell spoke about this uh attended Pleasant Acres for year this year bilingual program has been uh split across Eon and Pleasant Acres uh I didn't say that in the 22 23 year that was the year uh the board approved um it doesn't affect most people in the room it affects

082families who register after the school year starts and they may not actually attend their neighborhood school because of enrollment so they would be potentially transferred to uh a child may move into the broad menow neighborhood but we don't have space at kindergarten right now so they're going to get transferred to buzz of neighbors so that was another uh fix that has been put in to address some of our issu our concerns so and also at each school board meeting this year the board has considered various aspects of K5 organization and enrollment um and I've got those listed up here um I would specifically say that that we had the demographic study that was presented in September um I did share the family and staff survey data presented in October and I do want to clarify

083that uh I've gotten a lot of critical feedback about the quality of my survey and I appreciate that um but I will also add that that survey in no way actually supports or supported grade level schools uh that that is not a was not a finding in that data nor was it presented to the board that way um most recently at the last meeting we uh talked about five possible options and I guess I want to communicate that part of the process sometimes is that board members may ask me what would you recommend um and that's where we are right now um in past years we've had a lot of conversation where the boards debated back and forth and I fully expect that they will still do that tonight uh but I was asked uh

084to make a recommendation and that's the recommendation from my administrative team so there are three areas that when when we talk about this and and why we think it's a good longterm decision is looking at um and I've got these listed out on the handout is this is about Equitable access for all of the families in Rain tool and we'll talk about what that means finances cost Effectiveness is a factor um and what we view as the long-term possibility for improving teaching and learning so I'm going to turn it over or I just talked a really long time so I'm going to turn it over to Jamie and Alison who are more interesting and they're going to talk about Equitable access um first off Jimmy R to director of curriculum instruction um a prasis as

085I always do um with something my mom always taught me which is you never come into a community um and tell them what they should do comeing and you ask what do you need how can I help so that's why I'm here because I was asked to help um try to help problem solvings um the other part to this for me is I have a passion for and it's just part of one of my core values and that's a huge lens for me but I also want to say that everyone's um priorities I value those perspectives because they are perspectives that need to be considered and taken into consideration so what I'm going to present to you are just some other perspective whether I agree or disagree with them or I agree or disagree with

086you just presenting some perspectives the same way that you presented um to consider and they're not are not disign um so I'm not trying to convince board or you all I also want to to make sure that we understand this is I don't think there's anything the change is not what people want right I don't think anyone wants to do to to create this type of change um but based on the models that we were presented with with this one provided the best solution um of those to try to achieve an equitable opportunity for our students and the two lenses for me was really about um equ Equitable access for our students and Equitable experiences for our teachers as well when I think about um some of the comments that were made here um I've

087worked in buildings where culture was phenomenal and it was amazing I work in buildings where the culture wasn't phenomenal and wasn't amazing and the experiences of the students and teachers in those places were vastly one one thing to consider is the perspective of every student is going to get the same experience um they're not going to just be at one school where hey they've got all things figured out they have less transition and um you know more of a veteran staff um and then another building does have that those kids are going to experience all the same culture and climate at every level just something else to look at this SCH um I'm also a huge fan of trying to grow um leadership um teacher leadership administrative leadership student leadership and another perspective is to

088look at this as an opportunity for some of our Master Teachers or teachers that bring specific strengths to the table to share those with other teachers who may not have those shs especially when you're talking about focusing on spe specific grade level or um a specific instructional approach and so the professional development opportunities that are there are ALS could also be seen as very beneficial for our teachers as well as which would benefit our students um a lot part I'll say is um I do I do I do recognize that um this is part of it's going to be an inconvenience for a lot of different stakeholders right um but I think as you think about what your lens is um they're all important every right all of our perspectives are important um but the

089key is how do you prioritize how do we prioritize what's most important right as a parent students five children um yes number one for me is safe right we had this conversation right a lot during covid where it was you know are we prioritizing like instruction or we prioritizing safe right and for me safe right then if I feel like everything's safe then we can focus on um education and and the academics and this is very similar right in terms of how do you prioritize how do we prioritize what's most important for us and for me my role is the learning the learning of students and the learning of teachers I'm not I'm a parent so I understand it's going to be an inconvenience to to a certain extent but for the opportunity for a

090child to have an equitable experience you know any parent will take that um you know uh uh would would you know would take that so their student could have the best education experience right sacrifice like we always do so I think that's something El Tak in consideration because your child and all the students are now going to have have the potential to have much more Equitable experience um so those are some of the things that for me uh stood out when I looked at at all the different models was really how do we provide most Equitable educational experience for both our students and our teachers those are the two most important love parents I'm a parent I'm not saying the parents input and and community's input isn't is it because it is and I just

091try to think if we all have to prioritize something but do want so those are some of the things that that when we were talking about it were the things that uh stood out for me as consideration made this model seem what he read off my notes um I think for me you want to make sure everybody knows who you are sure yeah I'm Al assistant superintendent director special ed um I think a lot of what we have to keep in mind is when we think about the different models what Jamie was talking about prioritizing I think we recognize the needs of our teachers through their experience right so Jamie's talking about um you know job satisfaction right I think there's a lot of stress and the expectations of our teachers is UNM right now

092right and so one of the things that I've had to do in years past is what's called a root cause analysis and with um a group of Staff hearing from them what is it that makes your job so hard what is it that makes your job hard and what is it that would make it better for you and what came out of that and both times that I've done it is wanting more targeted professional development wanting more training and support from and for their admin um and support with the overwhelming job responsibilities I think that we're going to get into some of the teaching and learning a little bit more but I think a lot of this plan addresses those needs I do absolutely hear the concerns with the transitions I certainly understand that I

093just I I my focus right now is thinking about a long-term plan as Dr Wood said but thinking about how to get to a better place with job satisfaction and retention and support for our teachers while also thinking about the equity experience for our students so one example that I would give right now and I just looked at at so I hope these are accurate from our staffing Chief a second grade classroom at Easton has 12 students and a second grade classroom at Broad Meadow has 22 when you think about Equity there is no way that two second grader at Easton and second grader at Broad met getting the same experience I mean Wy brother Chang having 12 versus having 22 that's a different experience for you as the class one future right so I

094I I think the hard thing is we have to come up with a plan but coming up with a PL that addresses the priorities while also hearing the concerns GNA we'll come back for questions there okay only two more slides actually so the or three um what I want to talk about is the cost Effectiveness and efficiency and I know um when I was a teacher I would roll my eyes at this part because schools are not a business okay I understand that we are not a for-profit entity um however we're a business because we have to pay the bills and we have to pay you um and community members don't like it when they think we're wasting money um so a consideration in any decision making for school districts has to include our resource

095allocation and I have talked about this with all the board members individually but for the past several years we have experienced solid finances we have had times during Co where we have had um money to spend on things that you wouldn't normally spend money on because you have to spend it on specific things I'm sorry I'm in talk now but inside baseball but it's um the federal grants that were coming out during Co allowed us to uh have healthy fund balances pay our bills increase salaries um all of those things we we wanted to do however the financial health of the district right now is primarily due to the state and the EV it's called the evidence-based funding formula ebf and RCS now receives about 50% of all of its dollars from the state of

096Illinois if we weren't receiving those monies we wouldn't uh we wouldn't look like we do right now at all I would say but um unfor and I would also have most school districts get somewhere between 20 and 30% of their dollars from the state we get a lot more uh because the state this funding program is supposed to go put more dollars into districts like ours that soed much higher uh lowincome students higher rates of low-income students and that's primarily what it's for but unfortunately the state is now projecting a $3.2 billion deficit for 20126 at the same time I would say any reasonable Observer knows that we are not going to be seeing an increase in revenue from the federal government um for the next several years Federal funding accounts for 22% of all

097of our dollars we will be fine next school year I keep saying that we're going to be fine next year but I am extremely concerned about what will happen to our district in the 2627 school year we can choose to position the district now so that we can absorb significant a significant budget shortfall if not now I am concerned that we'll be forced to make Cuts in the future that will have a significant effect negative effect on student programming and we won't have the opportunity to plan for those cuts um so that's all I'm going to say about cost effective and efficient is that I am very concerned about future finances I'm not saying this is a scare tactic it's not a secret that state of Illinois is going to run out of money okay

098um I'm going to kick it over now to focus teaching and learning take it away L right all right and again these are perspectives to for us to consider right and the opportunity for um when you think about what the load is on teachers if you you know we did a brief data dive and look at just a fourth grade teachers uh class fourth grade as a district rather and where the diaspora of needs the students have in terms of their abilities right you've got students that have um learning abilities all the way up to 8th grade in one classroom all the way down to inter and we're just talking about maybe just even reading per say right that's a lot for a two person team to take on and try to figure out how

099do we support that call it differentiation um but I don't know if it really giving our teachers a real opportunity to differentiate because they're really creating groups of stud ability group students um to try and meet their needs and catch them up without having the true resources to meet those students needs um so I really think that's a huge factor and again this potentially could help address something um I think the other part of the the targeted professional development that um you'll be able to conduct amongst yourselves um is another possibility where you are actually getting Prof development in areas that you are currently working in um it is challenging being an administrator in a building to try to provide meaningful professional development kindergarten in fifth grade and make it seem like it's practical and

100relevant all time whichit students or teachers because teachers aren't getting what they need uh in terms of using their time effectively and efficiently um think there's for a lot more flexibility with our students um in terms of provide finding those teachers that have that level of expertise um for instance we talked about it uh someone spoke about it earlier where you have a fifth graders who still need uh instruction that might be much more people would I guess say would be more relevant to a kindergarten because they're still learning sounds they might still be learning site words um and to have all three graders together can move them in ways that would not eliminate them having the opportunities to have appropriate developmental experiences with their peers um and so those are just some of the

101opportunities I think the other part is reading Specialists we get Target at probably our most medious area and that is K12 to make sure that our students do get what they need learn the code um because if they don't have that makes it really challenging for the rest of their educational experience and right now a current model has not we have not figured out how to do that in this current model meet those needs of the students especially our stents social emotionally as well as academically when it comes to trying to get them caught up for close the gap um so from an instructional standpoint I think it provides some opportunity again it comes with some challenges um but we have to prioritize what is our you know what's most important to us I know

102there's a lot of adult feelings M included um and and nervousness about what this overhaul is going to mean for our departments for our schools for our relationships but again right our main number one priority is trying to ensure that our students and our children have the best education experiences all around and that starts with creating opportuni for to be successful academically and social not one or the other I told you I told you you should go first okay all right so sorry can I say one oh you go sorry I can go but I do want you to know I can't speak everybody is you know I want to reiterate this it's not something I want I'm not saying I want five centes I think everybody in it's a dream to have a neighborhood

103student right where you can walk to same kids right families over and over um it's it's just not a reality um to be able to give kids and students I students and teachers the experience they need given our current conditions and where we are in terms of our outcomes so those are things that I'm just presenting a perspective right I'd much rather be saying hey yeah let's keep doing what we've been doing it's been great but I do want I do want you to know that I don't think I've hurt anyone when we dug into this because we were given initially four models and then another model to look at this model wasn't on the original so we work that one started to look at this one and we saw some of the possible benefits

104for so um I don't think it's a can a can't we it's just how can we and what do we need to do to ensure that our students are going to have the best experience so you have we all have to ask our as we think about our own all right okay so uh B on this next slide I had eight slides where I was going to use a metaphor about how ating a child is like building a house and I was told not to do that so I got to keep one slide uh my whole team read my metaphor and thought it was weak so um but the idea I'll do it in one slide the idea is that we have experts at each stage of the process of educating the child um it's

105not a perfect metaphor not at all but each step of the process has to be done to the best we can so that we have a strong house I did it it's doesn't sound good I'll stop I so good all right so let's go on I would encourage everyone to review the frequently asked questions document that has been provided um you will see that we are planning for increased Transportation access for families and we want to assure everyone that ser ious thoughtful planning is going into this recommendation um I would also add that part of a reason I think it's appropriate that the board is not taking action tonight is that there are definitely still some pieces that need to be uh more solidified as as some of you said that um we need more

106concrete details about what this is actually going to look like um you know and especially I know the number one thing I hear from so far is about Transportation um more so how do I get three kids to three schools at the same time that's not the same question as Transportation but they do go together um I want and I do know that in general the board is not in favor of making parents lives harder okay I shouldn't speak for more um I want to acknowledge that I understand family members in the community um and our staff uh understandably May view this as a sudden recommendation but this is something that has been discussed on an ongoing basis and publicly so it is my professional opinion that there are substantial benefits to this structure for

107students families and staff primarily the structure expands Equitable access for our students it is more cost effective and allows for improved teaching and learning the overall goal as we've said is to improve student learning outcomes so I am employed to manage and lead the district uh I'll tell you the simplest thing to do is to not change anything and I will continue to manage and Lead our staff will continue to work hard and we will do our best for the community uh I also understand that my recommendation will win me no popularity contests one teacher in this room gave me a dirty look today um I don't know if you me it but I believe this is the right thing for our school district to do um in the long term so at that I'm

108going to say questions from Bo floor is open go first okay Rob school can you elaborate a little more on um what we've discussed regarding Transportation right so um it's hard to give very specific details because we are actually working on what routing would look like board members this this meeting brought Darcy to the room so she's the one who helps with Transportation uh she asked me to don't commit to anything is what she said but our goal is is that if I'm a parent that has children in multiple schools is that I would have one drop off that's the target um and that's also we don't have a concrete answer on how much that would cost um and what that would look like um we would hope to have that soon after break but

109as I said the goal is that a parent would have one drop off and one pick up so for example one of our teachers who has a child in will have children in kindergarten first grade and third grade next year um asked the question when she got my email yesterday um but this parent lives relatively close to North View so the ideal is is that there is a bus stop uh maybe the the bus stop currently for that parent would be the school and that we're we're getting the students to all three schools at that point um yes this would include um needing to work with our transportation provider to make sure that we can scale up any transportation that we need uh we know at the last meeting we presented that if all we

110did was Bus kids that were on a mile and a half we would already be doubling the number of students that would be accessing Transportation at the K5 students um but a net cost is actually only adding two bus routes um when we do that so I'm not sure I answered your I did not answer your question brief I um this don't work give I may be mistaken but um it's round I don't think there was no no one that I think that spoke staff or parent wise speaking negative any anyways about anything um or saying that they didn't want change I think everybody that came up here was very positive and very respectful on the situation that they're having at their school at least that's what I think from it I think what the

111public is wanting to know and I wanted to know is the transparency that they did not get before this meeting and one the data that we supposedly somehow got that they're not getting no information one okay again they ask questions and there's no answer to answer we're not giving them an answer just like as a board member there's questions that I asked at the meeting I didn't get a full answer so I think what they're what they're looking for is more concrete answer to what are we actually going to do just like Dr Wood said don't commit to nothing with uh Transportation that's a huge problem we had a huge problem with just changes from last year to this year where there was quite a few parents and teachers and Grand not teachers and grandparents

112that had problems getting their kids to school on time now I know in our meeting we did make you guys uh brought to my attention that's a possibility to do uh startup times at different schools how will that affect the teachers okay now they say I'm supposed to go to work from this time to this time but now I got to change my time of 45 minutes to an hour now because of this change these are things that they there want to know um I understand fully on what they're saying about um for example like Mr Kelly said with the family having a daughter in kindergarten and a son in fifth grade having that son made that daughter feel a heck of a lot safer than not having someone there at all I'm not saying

113that this is negative I'm just saying that these are going to be thoughts questions and definitely in the back of the Mind of a lot of these teachers that have built tremendous relationships with these kids you know now they go k through first grade at Pleasant Acres how many kids did we actually lose if we take first stent fifth out what's the numbers does anybody know that mean meaning the the number of kids that we were taken out of uh PA considering that we we did that build on you know the restructure for prek I'm just asking number wise um and the reason I'm asking that is because we s that much money building and adding on to the pa um but now we're going to take away first grade to fifth grade and we're

114going to add all the kindergartens is there huge difference in kids that's going to be going there considering the kids coming out of there and do are we are we not going to have the room unless I misinterpret some of the the uh things that I've read or looked at here number-wise um there was a speaker that said that she didn't feel that the numbers of the classes were going to go up maybe I would maybe I misit but it does look like in some of the I think in Broad metal the number of students that's in a class is going to be a lot larger and I could be wrong I could be read piss wrong but um anyways like I was saying I just I have a lot of questions that I want

115to know but I think what the public wants to know and some of the teachers want to know um what are we actually going to do be time to ask the questions I'm happy to answer questions I mean um that's that's the way I'm looking at it I mean we're sitting there saying okay it's okay to go ahead and lose good features I don't think that's in my opinion I don't think that's a good thing um you know I don't want to see teachers Le that that I feel is beneficial to our district um from emails and textes and stuff that I've been getting we're losing we're going to be losing good people anyways just because the fact that we're we're even considering this and still talking about something that um they feel might not

116work what I'm what I'm asking you to Mr rry Mr and Dr Woods they need more information on what really is going to go on and that's what they're asking so that way they can make a decision for their life you know they want to they want to make a decision hey do I stay or do I go and I think that's what some of these people are in here for they're not in here to try to make our jobs harder as a board member because when when like I said when I ran as a board to to become a board member almost four years ago it had nothing to do with none of this it had something to do with the education part of it of our kids in District 137 and like I

117said since I've been here it has so you know I think that's what they're looking at that's what they they want us to answer and I don't think and still just listening to what I just heard I don't think we answer nothing that they're they're busy really wanting to know that's my opinion thank you Mr joh Are there specific questions that you want answer now well honestly no because um it seems like some of the questions that's being asked majority of the people that talked already asked these questions or have asked these questions or emailed these questions to us um a lot of times and I'm glad you said that to where it's at publicly it's publicly known um I think sometimes when we get um brought into a to a meeting let's say oneon-one

118or whatever the public don't know what's going on and if they don't understand what's written on paper or or even an email that's being sent out they're W to know they want more clarification and I do too as a board member you know you can feed me all this information and I might not know they not thing what you're saying you know you're giving me the information you want to be to me I want to hear information that's legit and factual okay so what information is it you would like the administration to provide the bo the right information the information that I can give to the to the public the information I can give to teachers that want to know what the information that they're asking for I'm not asking for anything no no different

119than what they're asking for I mean I'm a parent I have I have a child in uh RCS I'm not I'm not trying to um say we're doing something that's not right or wrong I'm just saying I need the clarification and I need to understand it and if I can't understand it I'm sure some of the people out there can't understand it especially if it's brought to our attention too late to even look at it or read it and I'm not saying that's what happened to me but I'm sure it did to some of the people that are here because they they had to make last minute changes hey look this is what's going to happen at for meeting let's go so what you're say saying is you want to you want the District administration

120to say this is why we have this is the reason and why we're deciding in this this organizational skills this this plan because you for to be more broader to the public to the staff and to the people of okay this is why we have to do this this is a reasoning why as administrative we as board members as Mr Woods Mr rre and aliser which we all met with to explain why as to why so what you're saying is let's give them you guys are asking for more questions why are we why are we getting to this point is there a reason why we have to do this our children keep you guys employed I mean but honestly without children there would be no schools so our voice matters parents it do it does

121it does matter I have a son in special needs that it gets hit constantly you know and that's issue another day I know thank you the board is you know talking now so I mean I have some questions myself because I heard a lot about special education I parent brought out special education and um just you know from that I want and there was F they brought it up um so how I gu I was and that would be a question for you how is how much would that affect or what are the precautions or is there anything that you know this plan will affect special education I I think that's a pretty broad question I thought Rachel did a really great job of describing some of the benefits but as far as are you

122asking how does it negatively impact um there is no significant impact that would be specific to special ed meaning the changes that are happening to all groups and all students are the same for specialized so if I'm a first grader I'm going to go to the school that provides services to first grade right is that is that what you're asking just for the needs of the students that continue that have the needs to continue to get them what they're getting and they were expect the other question I had some friends brought up you brought it up you know this was brought up on you guys you guys didn't know what was going on um we we the board knew that there was surveys going on back in the fall correct and there was question ARS

123being sent out but from listening to some staff members and some parents was I mean that was not the case but we saw we saw that information we saw the feedback so um Mr you're saying that you know I I just want to like understand because that's the feedback I also got here today like wow like you guys are doing this you're not telling us what you guys are doing you're just throwing it on us so but if there was service question done in the fall so then are they right are the question right I mean we're getting right so as I said earlier the survey that was done in October may have been end of September does not support making this change not that's not that survey data is not being used support CH

124what the parents say that it is okay but I mean what I'm saying though is is the board we the data was presented to the board it's publically available in and that is a piece of this process so if again I guess what I'm asking is specifically what questions do does the board need more information so I'm aware um and I want to clarify my make no commitments about transportation is because I don't we don't want to make promises we can't keep um and that's an important rule to have is we're not going to make a promise that we cannot keep um and one of the reasons not to vote one way or the other tonight is because we don't have concrete answers on Transportation right now um so yes I'm aware that that is

125a very specific area that parents are going to want to know um but also keep in mind most families unfortunately don't find out Transportation information until a few days before school starts normally um I do know that if I'm a parent with multiple kids I need to know how I'm getting them to um and that is something that we would if we can't do it it's it's nothing then the board's not going to approve this right I I'm I'm aware of that um so we need to be able to present um a concrete plan for how it works um and how it would work on Transportation I just wanted to respond briefly to your comment um all of this that we're discussing has been pre presented at multiple board meetings like we've had PowerPoint presentations

126we've had um the the consultant we hired drove all the way to or know she presented it via Zoom but she gave us a presentation on our demographic data that we paved her to do to do this survey record data that we asked asked for it's not like we're not intentionally trying to give you information we've given you information at every board meeting and we are working through this ourselves um it's it's just transparent as we can possibly make it maybe maybe I'm misunderstanding something because I know from from the Texas email and phone calls that I receive today none of these people knew this was going on and I personally as a board member didn't know I was going to come in here and try to make a decision and and vote on this

127being done someone El vo on exactly we're not v on it because we took it off the table so what you're saying is if I'm a board member and I didn't know you expected all these people to know before last night when would when was it but on um parents Square last night what time thought we were discussing this no it's not about discussing this and yes you're right we had discussed this for and that's what a lot of people are tired about anyway is we keep going over the same thing over and over and over and over I'm talking about the transparency of this meeting tonight A lot of these people and I could be wrong maybe every single one of them knew about this no are you talking about the voting but uh

128yeah basically voting yes voting tonight sorry they thought I think majority of them thought we were going to make a vote tonight and this was going to happen next year that's what they're thinking and that's what they thought so am I missing something are you guys having meetings without me that I don't know what's going on my understanding of this is that it was to give us the option to choose to vote I could be incorrect but I think that was like a point of procedure I think that you know what we've elected to do is just have the discussion and postpone the vote but I think it was to give us the option that if we felt as though we were prepared for it we could we could I don't think that it was

129that we had to and also the agenda for this meeting was posted at the required 48 hours before the meeting um which every person in the public has the option to locate and read yes we have make foundations I mean it's just it's real yes audience please this we gave you your time and I understand and this this is this is a very tricky thing so please be patient with we go through this ourselves because we're we're picking up stuff too I'm not trying to be rude but this is our time is what now speak thank you I feel like I need to address it m Mr Johnson you know the board has not met without you um and I think it's um it gives the long impression to make that comment that the board

130is having meetings without um or information from you all board members get the same information uh we cannot meet as a the board cannot meet as a board with outp posting a public agenda and being open to the public when comments like that are made it makes it seem as if we're not unified or there's some against one and that's just not how it is it's not the case I'm going to read what I am very now I want to be 100% authentic I am in favor of the grade level centers based on the word that the information was presented to you however I do not think that this topic should be rushed this is something that has been brought up every year since I had been on this board although I do not agree

131with some of the harsh words that have been said regarding our Administration I would have preferred that this was handled in a different way I speak about communication and parent and Community involvement all the time in our discussions I'm continuously telling my fellow board members that we need to become more more comfortable with each other so we can start having the hard thought-provoking discussions that will lead to changes that can be beneficial to our district and therefore our community I would have preferred that our admin team compil the compil the group that consisted of teachers parents board members and possibly other community members that do not have children in this District by doing this there could have been wiely discussions about various scenarios when there is communication and collaboration more problems are solved different people

132bring different ideas and perspectives to the table this is what is needed and is necessary before a change this big H happens I don't think that happened and I think that that our admin team missed a huge opportunity to foster a family with this whole Community which is what it seems like everyone is trying to say in their own different way I like what you said about a different perspective I do that a lot I say things on the screen that I'm looking at because if you watch a TV program sometimes it can be a scene and you see somebody doing something and then you see another scene somebody else doing something you have the whole entire picture but the two people in the two different scenes don't have the whole picture and so it

133takes looking at things with a different perspective people are not trying to hurt students only think about their own agenda no one no one's sitting up here in any of these seats no one sitting out there in any of those seats are trying to do that we are all trying to work together for the betterment of these kids if we weren't trying to do that we wouldn't spend so much time on this board it takes a lot if we didn't care about the kids we would not be up here so I think that what it takes is for us to talk and collaborate with one another because there are questions because after I started talking to people there are questions that are not being answered and it's a big decision it's a big change um

134and I know some people think that we shouldn't be asking questions over and over again it's time to just make a decision and go with it but to me it's too big of a thing to just go with I like information I can't make a big decision like that without having some type of um knowledge behind it facts behind it but like Robin was explaining because I understand that people are do not like the way that things were um presented to them or the timeliness how everything happens and I can't agree with that but on the other side of it from a different perspective all of this has been talked about numerous times but there were sprinkles of people that came to the meetings for months on end not even the normal people that come

135were here it was just us talking so in order to be heard you also have to show up so if you want to be heard then please it's not a um I'm not beating with a STI I'm just saying please come to the meetings talk to us that's what we want let us know how you're feeling about stuff let us know what's going on in the schools because I also it is my understanding and please correct me if I'm wrong um that in order for this to work when we're at grade level centers is that we're all going to be people are going to be teaching with the same curriculum is that correct well I found out that we have this great curriculum that sometimes teachers don't they don't have to follow it and you're

136not it's just up on the Shelf some people are following it but other people aren't so then how is that going to work that's a question for me I mean from me I do also have a question about how the the uh are there going to be different start times how is all this going to work how is the transportation going to work these things I don't understand but I don't know to ask these questions one because I'm just a volunteer and I'm not in the school no that's not true true I'm in the school a lot I'm just not I don't work in the school I'm not everyone sees me a lot but some of these teachers see me often in the school um so I need to know how a lot of the

137these things are going to work but I don't know what questions to ask unless I talk to the teachers and the parents because they bring a different perspective which is why I will go back and say before a decision is made I think some type of collaboration where we can all Talk Amongst each other it's going should happen I don't know if it will or not but I think that's what is necessary in order for this to be the best possible solution because I know you are you guys are tired of it but so are we and like I said it's been on a topic every year since I've been on this board and so if we're going to make yet another change then it needs to be something that's going to work for the

138the majority of the kids across the board and we need to understand how and we also need to look at the negative parts of it and why it wouldn't work and if that happens brainstorm really quick for a plan B but by just talking with the admin staff that doesn't do it because you guys are admin you're not in there like they are and you guys aren't parents with kids in this District like they are and so that's what needs to have in my opinion in order to have the best solution for this town which is what this town needs I specific questions I could answer thanks thank you and I also want to share for everybody that I I would say that we actually almost all agree on most things most of the time

139including the teachers okay um and it's okay to have discourse and disagreement um curriculum what you said about curriculum and are all teachers following the curriculum is a uh I don't think that's a problem specific to grade level schools no it's not right I think what happens at a grade level school though is if I am the building principal the instructional coach um I'm when I'm going going into fifth grade classrooms that's all I'm doing all day is going into fifth grade classrooms and it's going to be very apparent if one of my teachers is not following curriculum um now I say that we also want teachers to have autonomy and be creative but I what you're talking about is like the big picture three um and I think when we're asking a principal or

140that instructional coach and I use them as examples because they're in and out of lots of different classrooms and assistant principal um is they cannot be experts on what is being taught at six different grade levels they try really hard um and so I think that's actually one of the ways that we would have less of that I would hope with grade level schools I'm not going to say it will be perfect because um even when I was a teacher I thought what I wanted sometimes um Jamie wants to add something yeah also also to be careful we don't generalize a lot and say you know there might be some teachers who are still trying to find their way to use the gck that say but it's not the majority teachers I think our teachers

141are working as hard as they can to deliver the curriculum of fidelity it's a new curriculum as well so I want to be careful before we paint pictures of of teachers um what they're not doing what they are doing because they they're there's always a lie and I don't I don't what I've seen I wouldn't say that the majority our teachers are not teaching teaching that's to dis I have no idea if it's the majority or not but I do know with teachers and I don't think I said the majority I think I just said that there were teachers out there that were not and I know that from teachers that have told me and I think all teachers have their moments where they want to teach what they want and that's that happens that's

142fine start times and then the other thing we specifically asked is how will Transportation work so I think I've answered that the best I can tonight how Transportation will work um you don't really know but I mean I I I do have an idea and and that is going to be the piece that would affect start times um I do want to shair that one of the I think this is a positive for our parents and the daycare providers because we get feedback from them too is most likely with a shift to this model and again we won't know until we've modeled the routes and things is we would have to start to allow parent drop off much earlier um with supervision so that the buses can drop off at Easton and then go to

143Pleasant Acres and then go to North so to have that system work it is going to open up the doors so to speak to uh dropping off earlier and expanding that window I know right away in the room the teachers are saying who's supervising those kids um so that's the next question and um I don't have that answer yet either because I don't know what times we're looking to cover we would need to know um what the amount of time is that we have to cover and how we would staff that so a lot of it does come down to Transportation um as I said I we know what we want to do we know what we want to do with transportation and that is a parent has one drop off one pickup right but

144we have to make sure we can do that before we say that's what's going to happen don't we don't want to make promises we can't keep so um and that is the biggest piece so keep in mind there there's a thousand about a thousand K5 students um we don't know who 180 of them will be next year we don't know who our kindergarteners will be and where they're going to live um and so trying to map out it it's just it's a big technical problem right and I know that's what I that's my job is to solve these things but even just figuring out how far every kid is from their house that took one whole day this week and don't feel sorry for me it but it was it's a very um big problem

145to work um and and that's what we're trying to do we do this every year normally for bus okay it's just we have to model it on taking kids to different places is what it does this make sense okay so but I think for me the reason why I'm disappointed is because there are so many unknowns yet it was put on as an action item so that if we had the choice to go on it we could and we don't know enough and I but I also didn't know that I didn't know enough and so I I am disappointed that before you guys brought to us to do something like that all these things or more things weren't put in place and set and figured out before it was brought to us to think about

146for a vote that I just pulled this mytop so Dr Wood shared with us the email that he sent to on the uh parent Square as well as the email that it sent in s do I think that it should have been worded differently 100% uh it says it's listed as an action item which means the board may take a formal vote doesn't say that we will be taking a formal vote it just says that we may I got a phone call from a teacher last night or yesterday while I was at work and asked me about it actually two teachers that I was on speak about I don't get those emails forwarded to my phone I have to wait till I get home till I get the school so I didn't know anything about

147it that the email had been sent out right then but when I got home I Reddit I think the administration should have worded that as a discussion just like what we changed it to or what you motioned it to change to so there's only one job that I know of and I held it for a little while that you have to be perfect when you start and get better as the day go that's being a baseball onire you have to be perfect when you start you have to get better we're trying to get to that better by having these discussions and we're not perfect I'm not perfect ask my wife um but we're trying to get there and by hearing what you guys have said what other board members have said the admin said that's

148what we're trying for I agree with you that it should have been worked differently but sometimes you got s Po and by putting it in there as an action item all of you showed up and it's great hey and congratulations to those that got up here I did two board meetings in a row and I was scared sh sorry yeah but the squeaky wheel gets the grease right I putting it in there that way we got a lot of grease for that for the squeaky wheel up here that is all we we want it the entire time and discussion by 13 I believe at people and the seven of us sitting up here of you includ Dr Woods is what we need so like I said I just I agree that it should have been

149worded differently I did I did take a moment and send a followup to the staff today it was pretty late but it was kind of on that point like um let me CIF they may not be voting I was trying to be more clear about it um but the uh I think what I would and I didn't anticipate that we would have a about when we met and talked last week um we did meet with board members individually that's for the Public's know that's allowable um and uh but I think as I shared with you um next steps um and what that would look like um if this is something that the majority of the board is comfortable moving forward with that doesn't mean the board is voting right now okay but I know for

150me and the District Administrative team and our principles and our teachers that it this isn't going to go anywhere then we'll stop now okay but I think what the next steps should be is that after winter break and before the January board meeting um and I again I shared this before and I've shared it with the teachers is that especially on the teacher side I would be coming out and visiting um all schools I can share that schedule with board members if they'd like to e drop in the room um and I was calling it a road show what we would be doing when going out and giving staff the opportunity to ask questions that they have and would answer them the best can because I would say the staff questions are going to be

151very different than parent questions um and then the other part was is yes as I talked with the board we were planning to host uh forums or whatever we want to call it for parents the same idea where we would be going out to the schools um and giving parents the opportunity to hear more detailed information because again and I appreciate what Mr Johnson said earlier what is presented in the PowerPoint tonight is a presentation to the board it's not it's different from what a presentation to Agri good parents who have first graders different than how we would I would present it to that grp and I hope that makes sense right that um all the board members had an opportunity to already review all of this material so I skipped a lot of it

152I didn't get into details thanl it but um so my question to the board is is this something that you want uh me to continue and go out um and get do the feedback piece okay it's not committing to anything but going out and explaining um I'm fully aware I'm not going to convince a lot of people that this is what they they're going to want to do but um I think it is fair to uh present the information share the information answer questions directly one more question obviously we talk we heard people talk about the implementation licky split right you know that was they conern current model will work for one more year let's say that we did all the forms in the road show want to say it will and then it comes

153back everybody is on board not on board however can we go with the current model for next year so that we would have a year to implement whatever we go with it says the guy who's not going to be on the board next year so yeah I mean we spoke last month option one I think I don't remember the but one of the options is to not do anything it is going what that means um is that some of the stressors that are being felt right now at Eon and Pleasant Acres um will continue and but I mean that's the impation it's continues one more year and then we're having this conversation next I'm not saying bad or good I'm just saying yes to answer your question yes I'll stop thank you for asking that

154that was my question as well and I I almost think it has to be that way because again I'm going to go back to I think this it's going to take a lot more planning and discussion with parents and teachers and Community involvement if we want to Foster the growth and change that we keep staying Foster um M I want to say something real quick um first of all I wanted to um thank uh Miss stard and Mr BR tree and Dr Woods and anybody else that might have been involved in setting this up and trying to get this um implemented it's not that I'm trying to say that this is not going to work or if it is going to work um from the past to the future of course we did have a

155person that spoke up saying that um it's no different than the past except worse now um but I do want um and I think Mr R kind of hit on this when you were speaking um as P these teachers are out here doing the very best that they possibly can with what they have and how they have to do it and the way they have to work that's why they came in there of course they don't want to change if if it doesn't have to be done and then you have teacher you know I'm sure um they come in to their job and do the very best that they possibly can so going to have two sides automatically on what each individual person thinks should be changed or shouldn't be change and I'm not saying

156one's better than the other or one's right or wrong I'm saying exactly what you just said and um what Mr Wilson just said we needed more information of course when I went in to that individual meeting you guys sold me on it I'm thinking yeah this may work this is this something that's good but at the same time I brought up some of the things that was brought up tonight some of the things that I just said such as Transportation all we want at least all I want and I'm sure the rest of the board members and administrators and the teachers want is what's best for our district and what's best for our town and the only way we're going to do that is if we work together meaning that we have the transparency and

157information not only out to the board members but also out to the public and also out to the teachers so we can come together and make a good decision thank you okay we go I just want to say that um every email that you guys send out I read I even respond to some staff members even if it's at 11:30 at night but I read every single email that the teacher sends that Scott sends every single email I read regardless of what's going on in my life and like he said we had a meeting and was discussed and it was presented and we felt confident but then when I started reading those emails and when I started reading every little word that was reported to those emails outside that's why we decided to you know

158a it but um every teacher that came up to that Podium everything that was said you guys are amazing you guys pour your heart into your students into everything you do and RCS is blessed to have each and any one of you and I know a lot of you personally I work with some of you and I know how you guys feel because I was there at one point and it's hard it's not easy tonight it was very hard for me to come but I still am here supporting you guys because I care so when people like I know in my point and I know that none of us are making irrational decisions we care we want to support you and yeah there's more questions but at the end of the day you know we

159also have to listen to our leader to the people that are leading the district as to how can we best meet the needs of everybody and it's a hard decision but I just want you guys to know that I care we care I know that we all care and what you guys tell us I take it to heart each and everything you guys say okay so I had my Cranky Pants on a little bit before I got here but thank you for your comments because I feel a lot better about what You' said and I really appreciate um you your perspective and how you feel this decision would make um an impact on our students and on our teachers um I also prepared a statement I was to save it to the end for comments

160but I guess I read it now um okay so thank you for your comments um I also have a student in um the rental City School District my um son goes to a right now and my other son graduated from R City schools and I am a ran City School Al um as a board member I do not have the luxury of only considering my child um I have the responsibility to consider all of your children as well and I take that responsibility very seriously um I want to take a minute and go over a few things um over the past couple months I and my board um fellow board members have all um spoken with several parents um we've also been spoken to by several parents um some of these conversations have been positive

161um more than a few have been negative um the board has been accused of being yes men to the administration and just agreeing with everything the superintendent asked of us um we have been accused of rushing our decisions and not giving discussion due diligence some of the most hurtful discussion I have been a part of um has accused us of having some ulterior motive for participating on this board none of this is the case I don't want to say that I am all um that all my interactions with the community members have been negative because that's not true at all um but I feel like I need to Define and defend our positions or at least my position on this board I am a public servant by profession I currently work for the Department of

162Commerce and Economic Opportunity for the state of Illinois I provide guidance for business and individuals that need assistance with grants community Assistance like Li heat csbg and training opportunities before I did this I ran a licensed daycare um and I was fortunate enough to get to participate in some of our youngest community members for of the years I spent um a lot of my life driving as a FedEx driver and delivering your packages in town um and before that I spent 12 years as a ler so I've had a lot of experience in various levels of the community for 12 years yeah um sometime during all of this I work to receive my formal education and eventually obtain my masters in political science I'm not telling you my work history out of vanity or um

163some other self-serving reason I'm telling you this because I understand what it means to wake to wake at 3:30 in the morning and start work at 4:30 or 5:30 I know what it is like um to work a job so physical that you want to crumple in a chair at night for a few hours of sleep that you can get before you start it all over the next day and I know it is like to struggle to find transportation for my kids to get to school or to make sure they are safe at night while I was in school I know what it is to sit at the table with my kids while we are all working on our homework and I know what it is to receive the support from them while I'm trying

164my best to better myself for them I know what it is to have a strong desire to give back to my community that has given so much to me my work in Springfield I drive three hours to my job um today I left at 4:45 and I drove all the way back and got here just when I got here I had the option to move to a better Comm or Community closer to my job but I choose to stay in R and make that drive because I believe in this community and I believe in the kids in this community and the families in this community and I want to watch your children grow a board member does not receive a salary we do not get benefits from this work most board meetings go long after

165the cameras are off when we get into closed session most board work takes place behind the scenes for example board packets can contain 300 plus pages of documentation that we all must review before we walk through the door because my vote is my responsibility some of this documentation can include check registers discipline reports sales tax revenue compensation reports Personnel reports contracts audit reports I could go on a lot of times I use my own vacation days to attend school programs um give out gifts to our teachers like this past Friday um and make sure I can be there for the new 30 minute informal discussion we have in the meetings now before board meetings I I missed my own son school activities to attend these meetings like tonight I am missing his basket game because

166I want to be here to listen to your concerns each board member here has their own reasons for being a board a member of this board for me I love this community I appreciate our staff members and I care for your children I want to make sure their educational experience is impactful I want our staff to feel valued and appreciated and I want want our community to be United safe and prosperous there have been a lot of discussions about the concern for K5 reorganization and we have been accused of not taking the parents in the community into consideration while we debate we've been accused of rushing their process so I want to start oh we've already talked about all this stuff we had you know board meetings we went through in April and made a

167decision that was like a stop Gap in 2023 U moving the fifth graders from E to PA um and last year we went into this discussion again and we ended up you know moving the bilingual program was another stop Gap and unfortunately these these Band-Aid issues did not resolve the primary problem and um we've requested several surveys from parents and staff and we had special SE session forms for comments we took months to review multiple proposals we've asked for additional options when we didn't agree with the options that were proposed to us and finally we ran into the point of no return where we had to make a decision for the next school year and that is how we ended up with the current system of the split bilingual programs and split classrooms in in

168this situation um we recently just return to discussing this in the fall um the implementation of the programs that we've done has supposed to been temporary these weren't going to be long lasting Solutions it never was considered to be a longl lasting solution we knew from the beginning when we started discussing these things that we needed to come up with a stable long-term decision that was going to benefit our kids um every board member has had ample time to review documents add their perspective ask questions and provide valuable changes to the K5 reorganization plan um we have been working on this issue for almost two years our staff deserves to have a safe collaborative functional work environment and so do our children they deserve to have a stable system that will not need to be

169changed year after year after year um our choice on this decision has been lengthy but thoughtful um but it's time for um a decision that will benefit all students in our district um I know we can do better um I think we've just been afraid to make the hard decisions and upset people and I think we just have to sit back and make the hard decisions I'm done sorry it was really long I'm sorry need apologize anybody else I think I will answer the question from my perspective that you asked Dr WS which is should we continue to explore this option and like do some of that leg work and I believe that we should I'm not saying automatically you know just like Robin said like you know there have been a lot of things

170that have been said about us not doing our due diligence and not caring and it's it's been a lot but I think the thing is we have to do something we all acknowledge that what we're doing is not working I'm not saying this is the best option I'm not saying that when we have these meetings with teachers in the community that things are not going to be considered because I certainly would expect that they would be but I think that we're to the point where the stop gaps are not working I'm concerned with waiting another year to make the hard decision I'm concerned with what as a person in finance I am concerned about our finances you know it's it's a really important thing to have money and it is a good thing to have

171the luxury to spend money in ways that we deem fit um and we might not be in that position for forever so you know I would prefer us explore this option look into it more and be able to make the decision versus having to make have the decision be made for us so my vote is yes to continue exploring it have your roacho um you know we'll be there to talk and support and I I for one am so grateful that we have you know I saw 43 on the zoom I see like the people who are in this room right now I'm glad we're having these conversations I'm thrilled that I'm getting emails and phone calls and we can like have these hard conversations like it is something that we really have wanted and

172I know that it's been said that like we've asked for it in meetings as well and you know it's difficult to do more than that than to say in a meeting like please come talk to us so thank you all for being here appreciate you last chance just want to say the thing that I'm scared about is that it looks fit on paper but once we implement it it's not going to work and so that's why I want to have as many answers in place as possible because I feel like that's kind of what happened with the situation that we're in now you know we heard you know in the public Communications the nice lady from BR was speaking on behalf of the teachers you know we want to be sure this is something that

173is not rushed as far as implementation like we need to have I think some good answers and have a good plan so and I just want you to know that yes it looks good on paper and do I worry um that I mean I've said it to some board members but this is how superintendents get fired is you push for a plan like this and if it doesn't work um I know what happens so it's not something we take lightly for me um at least um I I had more to say but then I said that I srack myself so happens it's almost 9 o' we still have closed session know so I'm not trying to cut us off thank you thank you for attending move on to valuation for all the fun stuff where

174you going now yeah this is just something that I it's requ Reed that it's on the agenda so it's on the agenda um I know you may be you've been working on it so we may go to close session on this tonight um but it is due by February 1st and I the responsibility to inform you of that are you informed okay information items um we did have one for you uh this month and so that is in your packet and those are public student discipline report the one item that's on information items that I I am uh seeking a little bit of board uh feedback on is um we are in the last year that we can extend our transportation contract so we can extend it for one more year it's my understanding so

175it's 10 years since we started with first student um I discussed this with Council and um and Chris and I agree that we think it's probably time for us to go ahead and put it out for bid instead of waiting another year but unless the board feels strongly against that um it's this isn't something where you have to approve asking for the bid it's you would approve the actual bid once it comes in um so is there any reason anyone would not want us to put this out to bid like IDE yeah um and as I've shared with some individual board members who've asked me about this one is um there's no I don't want you to think there's a long line of buff service companies beating down the door um we may not get

176uh very many bids there's really two main companies in this area uh my hope would be uh I think Chris and I are aiming at the March meeting uh to approve a bid but if we can work it I if let's say we only have two companies I think it would be fair for us to have them each come in and do a presentation um and uh yeah that's it so we unless are we good with Chris and I putting this out to bid new business do they have anything they want to say Tyler sure last chance Tyler I want to say something yeah have the board packet um so um Chris y to your team you did amazing that audit that's the first time the AUD beener yeah I read it good job and

177Scott Allison thank you for taking the time to explain to us even though sometimes you know it's a little bit harder than it is for everything all the hard work you guys put into all this we appre I appreciate you thank you for keeping us has informed because you know we get those emails thank you I do I want to say that Tom and Jennifer had a lot of involved they just weren't the ones talk thank you thank you and you're gonna be missed I actually have no board see I have no cols can I just say one thingly I just want to say that um Mr Brotherton and I T the new preschool last Friday thank you and it was did I steal your thunder I'm sorry no no no no I'm no I

178was I'm glad you're saying this but don't forget we got oh yeah we had wear at part um but they are doing an amazing job and it is a lot bigger classrooms than I thought they were going to be and I'm very excited to see it when it's done nice I'm assuming I can't go like this right go like this I want to go well you should probably go I don't know that it's quite accessible at the moment you get a good idea what looks like I I have see it yeah I can't visualize like but I can see it now I those Jack and Joe bathrooms are huge they're really big the job construction okay yes next is close session I'm sorry I think we do have to well so all we need for

179the motion is the top two lines there I'll make a motion to move CL session regarding personnel and colletive negotiation negotiating matters I'll second Johnson John hi hi hi wison hi one two and I going to go ahead and stop the zoom folks we do have an action item afterwards um and the board agenda that we are going to go ahead and stop the uh public portion if anyone's in the room when we come back you cank happy Holidays happy holidays will you no I want to as a charger because my phone's dying and if I it dies be

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.