CorpusRecord 119114

Regular Meeting - Dec 10 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Oak Park Elementary School District 97
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Cook County, IL
Material
Transcript
Extent
35,669 words · about 199 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right uh welcome everybody uh let's get started today is Tuesday December 10th 2024 at 7:09 p.m. can you call the r please sure Kim yes Mo yesy yes St yes Burns yes R yes Johnson yes meeting call to order 7 thank you okay our first item is a public hearing on the 2024 tax L I don't think we have any comments on it need to the motion thank you I move the Board of Education of Oak Park School District 97 move into Open session with the public heing the districts 2024 tax seconds yes yes burn yes sparlock yes Mo yes Kim yes Carney yes motion to open the hand we have no public comment for the record so someone can make a mtion I move the Board of Education elementary school7 public hearing on

002the district's 2024 okay um that takes us to public comment um thanks everyone for coming out tonight we appreciate your engagement uh and value your comments as I think folks probably know while we welcome your comments we generally don't respond to them during public comment however we do give them serious consideration uh if you wish to speak hopefully you've signed in already when your name is called please step up to the podium state your name for the record uh because we have a number of people signed up tonight we're going to actually um give folks three minutes each if you're still speaking when you reached three minutes please finish your thought and conclude we request that speakers conduct themselves with respect and civility toward towards others and if you have a written copy of your

003testimony please provide it to L when you're done so she can included in the minutes for the meeeting and first up we have David Wells right um hello everybody how's your month then good to see me um so um we are the permanent substitutes um have read with interest the attached agenda item that's 9.1 on the docket um which is regarding a pay increase for non-union personnel with specific specifity to uh permanent substitutes um and we also including the explanatory memo that's scheduled to be voted on tonight um we' like to thank you for following through with the rates that you put forward at the November board meeting as we have mentioned in many previous Communications it's a step towards Equity that is long overdue so we are glad to finally see concrete action being

004taken therefore the main reason I'm here is to encourage and urge the board to approve the basic payrate increases that have been put forth by HR they're long long long long long long long long long over do um however thinking about it further there are four more points that I feel need to be rais um Point number one we again ask that the proposed pay raises be made retroactive to the beginning of the school year in late August uh to refresh everybody's memory human resources first put forth a pay rate Equity proposal to the board back in June as we have mentioned in the past many of us made long-term plans at the beginning of the school year only to find that the rate was rescinded and it faced significant hardship as a result we

005were encouraged when the HR team included this in their presentation at last octob at October's no sorry November's board meeting but it doesn't seem to be included in the memo for tonight's proposed vote um are we to assume that the retroactive pay is simply a given and if not I hope that that measure can be amended to include that um two we noted with interest the statement that the new pay rate is 91% of the median level of sampled schools uh since I'm sometimes called upon to teach middle school math I would like to remind everyone that 90 91% of the median value does not Place Us in the top 90% of schools as we should all know the median is the exact median value so 91% is a polite way of saying that the

006proposed rates are slightly below average I wondering would our district probably set a goal of being slightly below average in any other category I'll let you answer that to yourself as the saying goes this is point number three this meeting could have been an email or at the very least the dozens of our largely unanswered emails from M May onward and the many times that I and others have come forward before you for public comment could have easily been a simple meeting face to face the process could have been a lot simpler and I for a district that values openness and communication in all of their stated um releases um we need to actually be able to sit down into steps instead of us just saying something that we have no idea where it lands

007and then number four and the final point it's also important to realize that this measure is a first step and sorry I did prepare for 5 minutes I had just like three more sentences and are also still behind in other ways especially in terms of year-to-year job security and only 3 days worth of si le um meanwhile back at Julian we are getting two emails per day requesting substitutes um back in early September board member Spurlock urged that the district take a multifaceted approach to equity suggesting that a quick and easy proposal for pay Equity be brought forward for a vote but also to continue seeking solutions to make the propos position more Equitable overall board member Kim stated the willingness to thinka about Solutions and the whole AR I I I understand um but

008all many of us have prepared five minutes and this is something appreciate that but we have a lot of people want tonight thank you uh next up is Amilia Mato Muto apologies if I just got your name wrong my name is Moo I'm a Lincoln parents sorry I I'll fair five minutes so I'll try to keep it um short but I really wanted to take my time both acknowledge um and shout out to some of the wonderful teachers we've had at Lincoln and also bring up a bit of some concerns about how acceleration is being um maybe being handled with the middle school math change um we feel truly blessed by teachers my son have had so far at Lincoln they have built classroom communities that feel like family they instill love of learning they

009very quickly get to know their class to see how to best support individual needs and have gone above and beyond to differentiate instruction for my son to offer more challenging curriculum needed um and I give many examples for each of them kind of pick and choose now when my son started kindergarten our biggest concern were the social aspects of school and a concern that he could get potentially bored with the academics um Miss Clark gave us frequent update she quickly realized he was a fluent reader helped give him chapter books additional challenging material and had a full detailed plan by conferences of how she was going to help him and differentiate instruction for him um same thing in first grade with Barker her and another first grade teacher work together to um pair him and

010another high Lev reader in a different class together to have their own little reading group and again this is going above and beyond what is being asked to them it's really um reaching them at the level that that he needs um and again he started accelerating to miss Cortez's second grade class from math in first grade and you know we weren't sure even though he was ready how he'd be accepted by his older peers but miss ctez had set a wonderful um environment where they welcomed him right away really made him feel included as part of the classroom um and having this acceleration opportunity was really critical even with the classroom differentiation we knew that it needed to be stretched further um again with Mrs Wheatley in second grade he she said a wonderful Community

011wonderful projects and again every time I get to conferences she they've already set out like I see what he needs we've talked through it there's a plan for how they're going to meet him where he is and I say this because you know full year acceleration has been brought up to us us but we really feel like it's important for him to be with his peers with his age group um for social emotional reasons and um and for growth and because just because a kid is Advanced academically doesn't mean they more mature than others and that they would excel in other aspects of being um in a higher grade and so I when I come so to tie that a little bit to the math part um when it comes down to the math in

012particular in terms of math when he's in fourth grade he been a math class of fifth graders and many of these students will hopefully pursue this new act well not new but access to algebra and Bridge to middle school but he's currently would be excluded from it so even if he's the top math student in his class he is not allowed to take the same opportunities um to kind of further Excel Excel or accelerate into the middle school math program he's not um he's not eligible for it so he would really be separated from his math cohart that he's been with since his first grade so I would hope that the math a large part of this math class would pursue that extra kind of um and called acceleration what would term it and so

013I don't know if the purpose for excluding accelerated students for the bridge to m is because you feel like they already going to get there anyway because they already get to algebra but I think this is missing the needs thank you um to disregarding the needs for these students and meting every student where they're at and so I would really my ask is for you to look at bringing back the advanced math courses to the middle schools and also seeing how advanced students needs are being met um through this transition thank you Ty berelson for I apologize um I would like to talk about the 10th grade math acceleration or the lack thereof I've noted that in past year years there have been uh programs allowing middle schoolers to accelerate to the 10th grade in

014mathematics and I've known that now of course it has been restricted and I really don't know why I personally this year this fall tried extra hard on like the math testing on the math testing so that I could accelerate another grade and Advance my education more but it was kind of disappointing to go and realize that the district can't refuses to uh show that and refuses to have a program for me to accelerate and I really don't know why it's necessary I just want to know why and I think it would really help a lot of students in like college admissions and other things to advance their careers and Etc to have to go and say I accelerated I was able to progress look at me I'm impressive but to stop them from doing that

015is restricting them for no real reason okay so thank you I just wanted that to be known thank you [Applause] Emily brelon hi hi's my kid I'm proud of him told him he could do it I could be I could get over my nerves and I could do it too so um I'm coming and standing in suppored my son um he was accelerated in math and I believe it was fourth grade and um in the middle of Co and he has always it was very hard to even get him accelerated a year he has always scored within the 99th percentile since kindergarten on all of his map scores um I this year he wanted to accelerate an additional grade he's in ninth grade um math now um and so he wanted to accelerate to 10th

016and we had a friend who was going over to the high school and doing that so I went and spoke with the district even uh the person in charge of acceleration that that had been eliminated and it wasn't a possibility for him um I think that you need to realize the impact this is having on our students um because of his abilities in math we are considering applying to the Illinois Math and Science Academy which students can apply for in their eth grade year to go there in nth grade or in 10th Grade it's a public school for highly gifted math and science students it's residential um however the ninth grade math in order to even be considered you have to have completed Algebra 1 and the ninth grade math that is offered through the

017districts through the district does not have all the components of Algebra 1 so our children our eighth graders are not allowed to apply to that school and are not even able to be considered um whereas if he had been able to take 10th grade math this year he would have at least been able to be considered so now we're going to have to wait an extra year and apply in nth grade fortunately they let you nth grade um but you're restricting his opportunities and I wanted the board to take that into consideration because you know it is a public school that we're looking into imsa is and um we're denying our right as kids those opportunities um and I do realize from all of what I've been told is the decision has been made um

018because uh they are under represent under representation of certain racial group minority groups in the gifted program so we're kind of just getting rid of it um because for Equity reasons but I think this is inequitable one for the minority students who are in those programs you're taking it away from them as well and then it made me wonder what other programs are we going to get rid of under the same basis like my son is in and loves Orchestra but the orchestra is has an over representation of uh Caucasian and Asian students so are we going to think about getting rid of that for equity um you know I think we need to look at the big picture we shouldn't penalize certain of our students we should just try to find a way to

019make uh admission to these different programs more Equitable as opposed to saying we can't do it select you know get rid of the program um so that's what I have to say we need to stop harming our most gifted kids and this this elimination of uh the ability to take 10th grade math has had clearly a very real harm for my child all he want and he's like all I wanted to do I tried so hard on the math test just so I could go over to the high school and uh what are we telling him you know you can work really really hard but we're still not going to place you in the most appropriate place for you thank you for your time I appreciate it thank you Jamie Winchell hello good evening um

020my name is Jamie Vel and this is my 10th year as teacher librarian at Julian I'm a proud Oba member and today was my 75th day working on an expired contract I am dedicated to serving the students and families of the Oak Park Community I am making it known to the Board of Education we the Oak Park Teachers Association need Fair wage increases and working conditions that show respect to us as experts tomorrow I will fulfill all of my job duties and more at Julian which will be my 76th day working on an expired contract thank you thank [Applause] yous Head Start hi everyone um I'm Claire Brooks a teacher at Julian Community member and OA member um as many of you know I normally have a lot to say a lot of words um

021and I love my numbers and my stats but tonight I'm kind of just at a loss of what to say um which does not happen often or frequently um so I'm not sure if there's anything to say beyond that we've been working under an expired contract for 75 days thank [Applause] you Paul Packer uh good evening my name is Paul Packer and unlike Claire I actually have more to say this evening I'm a member of opa and I have been a teacher in the district for 32 years and I been on the collective bargaining team three times this is the first time in those 32 years that I've been has to work under an expired contract and I don't understand why I along with my colleagues are tired frustrated and angry that we do not

022have a new contract we have been working under this expired contract for 75 days adding insult to injury we are continually being bombarded with demands by Administration to prove our Worth or that we are doing our jobs if you have been listening since last spring to public comment there should be no doubt that we are doing our jobs last April the language art Specialists mtss coaches instructional coaches and enrichment specialist positions were attacked based on misinformation that there was minimal student contact time without actually discussing what the positions entail with the people who do them then two months ago those that are nationally board certified were told without any discussion or input that they need evidence that they are doing their jobs and that their stien is Justified and just last week the teacher leaders

023who by the by the way appli for the job and then are interviewed and hired for their roles were told that they need to provide evidence from the last three months that they have been doing their jobs all of this occurring over email with cute subject lines or non-identifying signatures yes we do share emails and different groups within Opa do talk to each other all of this while being told by Administration that we want to collaborate we want you to have a voice and yet none of these groups was approached before or after these decisions and demands were made all the while we go to work day in and day out Above and Beyond on an expired contract 75 days what group is next I hoping to have a nice holiday season despite this hanging

024over my heart and mind I wish the same to you and yours thank you for your time this evening [Applause] hi um I understand it's uh the board president's right to lower the minutes but I prepared five minutes and with Jamie rell's permission I'm going to take two of hers um to add to this so I'm going to go doesn't quite work that way but if you could hustle it up that would be my name is Joel blacka I'm speaking as an Opa member uh can kindgarten teacher at Irving and d97 parenting I'm part of the 45% of the Union who are o Park residents this figure signals enormous commitment to our schools our love of and belief in our schools is such that we entrust our very own children to attend our Collective Halls

025of learning however that love is giving way to a deep frustration since as we've heard it's day 75 of working under an expired contract with high inflation and Rising Oak Park property taxes compounding the financial stresses of the holidays we teachers need to new contract with a fair increase now but I'd like to take this opportunity to shine a real positive Spotlight on the work of one of my colleagues Kier Moody she's the mtss interventionist and Cole um skip ahead here she does so many amazing things but let me just give you a glimpse of what uh it looks like in action her job and why it's so integral on day one of the school year K was in my classroom getting to know all the kindergarteners and reading her favorite books to the class

026so that they knew her well by the time she needed to work with them that is really paid off the kids run to her when she comes to pull them for intervention time and the kids who don't even work with her welcome her arrival with hey Miss Moody I miss you Miss Moody and lots of hugs Kira is energetic positive and always focused on students and that translates to how much she supports me my colleagues and families she's a thought partner for planning and helping find appropriate resources recently I sought her help in supporting a kindergarten who couldn't identify number names no matter what I was trying she listened and provided me with resources and strategies by Day end her partnering with families is inspirational she's always seeing me on families for uh from the

027kids in my class the emails are incredibly detailed full of data goals Kudos all written in a way that parents can digest as a parent I'd feel super impressed super informed and profoundly grateful that my kid is in her hands that all extrapolates to how the kids she works with in oh let me back up she attends every single parent teacher conference of children that she works with extrapolate that to all grades K to five and that's a ton of parent teacher conferences she's always sending home uh easy use resources for parents to use working with this woman reminds me of how our work can be a joyous collaboration with parents for the benefit of kids and she routinely goes above and beyond all that this year care co uh co-created ANL our first family

028math night huge hit she also takes time at every beginning of the day and end of the day to serice students checkin checkout coach from providing warm warm words of encouragement for those kids who are struggling with meeting Behavior expectations she also supports a school leadership plan by working with our fcal cohort students in Reading Irving's focal C cohort students are our black students as our black Excellence teaching in Oak Park representative Kira LED our first Wellness Wednesday in November for All Families of the folkore cohort she's an integral part of the Irving school and I'm proud to work with her please give K give me give the opta a fair cont right thank you so [Applause] much Judy Fen oh so in September I skipped up here and a blindly promised to become a

029better d97 educator I just seen this portrait of a d97 educator and I was so excited but also terrified of the things I wasn't doing and I wanted districtwide gratitude and respect to grow for me then came one of the most difficult assignments in 20 years that I've ever been given I don't think I would have asked for it but I'll tell you my eyes have been open this fall well so I used to think selfishly that the music's departments were like the best in the district I'm sorry but we just thought that and now I I do have to say I've spent every two to three weeks in a different School different grade level um supporting jenet teachers and Tas in caught and Blended classrooms where their special educator wasn't able to be present

030for a couple weeks for you know various reasons and my respect for my colleagues in this district has shot through the roof there is no way that any of us could be in every room in every building every week and get an idea of what's going on but from the sampling that I've had this fall I will tell you what I think is going on in the quiet Corners everywhere in this District meticulous planning patient and Artful unfolding of the Year wise and experienced Educators honing their crap day by day year by year not just plugging in A and B and hoping to get C but Educators working with little humans very messy little humans with magnificent days themselves and extremely frustrating days two steps forward one step back they need our patience they need

031our encouragement our boundaries our inspiration our safe place to grow and make mistakes and be themselves and be heard and challenged and loved some teachers are having the best year ever this year some are having their most challenging year ever yet every single one of them shows up to meet our kiddos with grit with determination with smiles and with loads and loads of Excellence so I'm going to give a shout out to the people I've been with this fall shout out to kindergartens in fifth grade at B School Miss Hannah McMahon and kindergarten amazing don't ever lose her miss Karen fog amazing the Tas Miss Stokes Miss Jordan Miss Stanton and then I've just been at Whittier in early childhood oh my gosh you guys this program over there Miss Molly Brennan the TA that

032because I was in for Miss Juliet fre Miss Valerie Len Miss sha marocco Miss Jenny Ray and Miss Jordan Danto and the effervescent Miss Julia Espinosa amazing so we ask for a good contract CU there are just some fantastic people out there Not tooting their horns but they are getting it done day in and day out with many smiles and much love for all our kiddles thank you [Applause] Erica Shannon hello my name is Erica Shannon and I am a member of the d97 no Park Teachers Association this school year marched my 25th year of teaching and my 23rd year here at N d97 I currently teach the fourth and fifth grade Orchestra classes at hatch Irving Lincoln and man elementary schools prior to 2014 I taught the orchestras at Holmes Elementary School I also

033taught six grade General music for 12 years at Percy Julian Middle School when I joined the d97 teaching faculty in the fall of 2002 I couldn't believe my good fortune I had spent the two previous years in the neighboring School District traveling from classroom to classroom teaching General music on a cart stocked only with a set of music books and a CD player with zero budget to purchase instruments and other resources once in O Park I was elated to have my own dedicated General music classroom space and was full that was fully stocked with instruments a good sound system and and other materials plus a yearly budget at my disposal I was also so happy to teach Orchestra in a district where instrumental music classes happen as part of the curricular school day thus ensuring

034that every child who wants to learn to play an instrument can do so without lack of financial resour sources or time outside of the school day standing in their way once more I soon became aware that the public education in the Arts was very much appreciated and strongly supported by Oak Park's families as well as d97 administration at the time it truly felt to me like teaching a dream and I was so happy to become part of the Ensemble with so many top-notch Educators my connection to Oak Park is also very personal very truly District 97 brought my family into being I met my husband now retired d97 instrumental music educator Brian Shannon when we shared an office and commedy plan time at Percy Julian Middle School our two sons now 17 and 19 are

035proud products of the fine education they received respectively at Whittier and hatch elementaries then later at Brooks Middle School Now 23 years after coming to teach in d97 I can still honestly say that I love my job I love watching the Wonder in my students eyes when they open their cases and hold their instruments in their hands for the first time I love seeing the excitement on their faces when they learn to make their first musical sounds I love seeing their senses of accomplishment and confidence grow with each new playing skill they Master to myself and to many of my colleagues here in d97 teaching generations of children is not just job where one clocks in and clocks out teaching for us is a calling into passion we count ourselves incredibly lucky to be doing

036the work that we love and work that is incredibly important we are shaping and learning the lives of the children we teach and we do it with compassion and kindness the academic and life skills our students learn in our classrooms accompany them their entire lives the Oak Park Teachers Association is an outstanding group of professionals we are the boots on the ground expertly delivering well-rounded education and our social social emotional support to our students every single day we are Masters in our field we deserve to be recognized respected and treated as such by Administration the fact that we have just completed day 75 of teaching under an expired contract is not only mindboggling but frankly feels very disrespectful here's another fact it has been six years since members of the OPC last signed a new

037contract it is time way past time I'm almost done for a new contract one that ensures safe working conditions for all teachers one that demonstrates that teachers are respected and supported by Administration and one that words our Collective talent and loyalty as hard workers with fair and Equitable salaries we deserve a good contract we need it now let's get it [Applause] done um I'm not wearing my R I'm District 97 teacher um my name is k o'keef I've been an educator for over 20 years and this is my ninth year teaching in District 97 and my 75th day is teaching without a contract I'm also a d97 parent my kids went to holes Brooks I got one at high school now um I'm here to talk to you about leadership at my school as you

038know we have a new principal Nick filipowski as well as two new assistant principles Adrien court and d f these three people have been working tirelessly to repair our learning environment and establish a more structured positive and restorative climate in our school I am so grateful for each of them and for their dedication to our school and our students in fact I have more faith in them than I've had in any of the administrators I've had in all my years at Julian and there have been a lot of them um I worry though that these three shining stars will burn out not only are they each completely new to their roles but two are new to the school there was no one there to show them the ropes and they walked into a building that

039was really kind of on fire at the end of last year they worked so hard but they spend so much time dealing with student behavior and restorative work which takes more time than just giving a simple consequence and they don't have time to do many of the things they want to do desperately like be in our classrooms be at our COI meetings be at our team leader meetings Mentor new teachers Etc um together I feel like we've come so far but have the potential to do so much better we need more support we need a third assistant principal like we used to have before the restruct restructuring um as you probably know prior to 2022 each school had one principal and three assistant principles I'm talking just middle schools um each assistant principal was responsible

040for uh one of the grades and therefore a combination of curriculum discipline teacher evaluation and other schoolwide responsibilities with the rest structuring the number of assistant principles at both middle schools was reduced from 3 to two one responsible for culture and climate the other for curriculum teaching and learning in the process we lost several talented committed leaders during this restructuring due to the fact that they had to reapply for their jobs and wait through the summer to find out which role they would get a new division of responsibilities has made these jobs very difficult to fill very few APS won a job that is 100% student disciplined with no ability to impact curriculum teaching and learning for one it is a thankless tiing job also a number of years in this role would deprive you

041of the opportunity to develop many of the skills that a building principle would need and that's the role that most APS are preparing for um from what I understand at Julian both Adrian and danda signed on believing their job would be a curriculum job in the end they made a compromise so they are both doing both curriculum and discipline at Brooks where my son has attended for the past three years my daughter attended for two years the ap of culture and climate position is still vacant four months into the school year so I ask the board and new Dr Shaw to please return to our previous model of three APS one principal and to please post these positions early enough that the new leaders can be hired at the end of the school year and

042have the summer to be trained by our current leadership teams who we hope and pray will stay with us and sign on for another year thank you [Applause] Elizabeth viton vson V hello my name is Elizabeth vson and I am speaking as an Opa member I teach second grade at homes and as I wrapped up report cards over the weekend I couldn't be more proud of the students in 2B for their effort willingness to take risks and the growth they have shown both academically and socially during trimester 1 it seems that many people assume teachers don't work outside of their contracted hours however I typically spend about 4 hours beyond the school day each day an additional 6 hours on average over the weekend working now I know some people think I'm a little hardcore

043but I feel like I need to put that in in order to do my job well um even with 25 years of EXP experience as being a full-time nationally board certified teacher and the recipient of the 2023 those who Excel award each year truly feels like I'm starting a new job teachers must adapt their instruction and classroom to meet the unique needs of each new group of students a lesson that works for one group of students may not be effective for another every year I have students that have different accommodations which I prepare for on my own time in addition to these above responsibilities that come with being an Effective Teacher other times I spend outside in school are sending and responding to family emails writing my Weekly Newsletter unit planning to meet all the

044Learners with best practices reflecting on my own teaching practices adjusting my instruction trying to make teaching fun and engage all mentoring early career Educators and constantly changing members of my team I also have to give a shout out to Oak Park free box and freeo a good home because I run around all weekend long I see your name um picking up free things for my classroom we just had a PB reward and being craft day all thankful to all of the Oak Park Community who donated wonderful things and we did origami and we did sticker by number and we did the glue where you put the glitter on top and we made all these designs and all the things were donated but I went around and picked them all up all weekend long since I

045been on band D um since 2018 I have not been receiving any pay increases to my base salary besides the cost of living living increase that every employee receives which does not cover our annual Consumer Price Index I am dedicated to serving the students and families of Oak Park Community and I have been working under an expired contract for 75 days I love my job and I love my students I am making it known to the Board of Education that we the Oak Park teachers of associ sorry need Fair increases and working conditions to show respect for us as experts thank [Applause] you Damien tap welcome Lord sorry second good evening members of the school board thank you for allowing me to the opportunity to speak tonight my name m dam t I am here

046to express my deep concern and frustration regarding the treatment my children have faced within this District as a parent it is incredibly difficult to stand before you to but I feel it is necessary to address the unacceptable experiences my children has had at your school recently my son was called a racial slur a word that has historically been used to degrade dehumanize black people the pain that comes with this come with hearing that word is immeasurable it was not just an insult it was an attack on his identity his dignity and his Humanity was even more troubling is that after I recorded this incident to the school I received no direct followup what action school did not reach out to me and I had to take it upon myself to come into the school and

047make sure that this issue was addressed to make matters worse my other son has been subjected to harassment he's also has been called a homophobic slur another word that carries with with a deep pain shame and discrimination this resulted in him being jumped last year arm broken emotionally distressed all happening at the middle school with no supervision this kind of bullying should never be tolerated especially in the school environment but it has been allowed to happen just like my other son there has been no significant action for the ad from the administration to ensure that these slurs and acts of bulling and stop nothing but Force apologies from the students what frustrates me even more is that my children are not only suffering the harm of these words they are also feeling unsupported by the

048very people who are supposed to protect them I have yet to see real meaningful consequences for the students when who are engaging in this kind of behavior it is clear to me that these issues are being downplayed dismissed or Worse ignored as a parent I should not have to fight to ensure that my children are safe at school I should not have to worry that my children will be will be Target because of their race their identity and who they are it is heartbreaking to see the my sons are being subjected to such cruelity in a place that is supposed to be a safe and supportive environment for all students my house is full of disarray because of this in addition I witness the Educators being Target about administration of Wier for similar reasons involving

049unequal treatment I'm here to ask this board this District to take these matters seriously racism homophobia and all forms of discrimination have no place in our schools these kinds of slurs are not just words they are harmful they are damaging they perpetuate they perpetuate a culture of hate that we should not be working to eliminate we should be working to eliminate and not condone my children deserve to go to school without fear of being targeted for who they are I should not have to send my children to school every day wondering whe they come home feeling us a shame or unsafe I am asking for more than just apologies I'm asking for Action Real consequences for those who engage and bullying education for all students on the harmful impact of these slurs and in commitment

050from this Administration to Stand Up Against Racism homophobia and to protect all students from discrimination the administration Willam especially has done nothing in multiple scenarios that swept it under the world the word saying statements which I quote at the young age they are they are not considered anything more than man cost I hope that this board will take a long hard look at how these issues are being handled and that we can move forward with a renewed commitment to creating a truly safe inclusive and supportive environment for every child in this District thank you for your [Applause] time Candace next hi I'm actually gonna follow up with what he said because our boys are in the same class at the same school my name is Candace Nicks my son is in second grade and we

051your Elementary as he mentioned there was an incident where some white students were saying the nword and my son and his son asked him to stop and they did not they said and I quote we can't stop saying it it's in our heads my son did not tell me about this incident until 7:00 p.m. that night so I didn't know about it but he felt that it was bad enough and it made him feel bad enough that he needed to come tell me so I immediately called a parent of one of the boys that conversation wasn't as fruitful as i' liked I felt she was INE equipped to talk to her son about next steps and I also immediately alerted the school as well as the teacher I mean the teacher as well as the

052um principal uh my biggest thing I think he eloquently summed up that no racist language no offensive language should be tolerated and there should be immediate action taken so I'm my ask and I've asked this several times is um a few things but before I get there I do want to say I asked this uh principal to send out a correspondence immediately regarding what had happened because I felt that the community at wer needed to know what was going on um I got a little bit of push back but it something was sent out and it was very generic um there was racial the what I think was said was there was racial language being used among students that's not true the racist language was used toward students and it was not stopped when asked

053um and I think the big thing is that there was no contention when I had this conversation with the principal and the administration and I don't want there to be contention but I do want the next steps that I'm about to say to somehow come magically appear at some point I do have a group of people here as well who are not only here to support me but to discuss the experiences as well as um the education needed for something better to be done um it's kind of interesting interesting because I attended Whittier way back then um and uh these situations were even worse um o Park helps itself as this diverse community and I don't think that's seen a lot in the way that we handle situations within our school um a couple of

054things I want to throw out there that I think may be helpful but I do want to see because I won't stop talking about it um is we need to have Equity education for our students so there's no age limit on when this should happen if a child is five and they have heard that word if a child is three and they've heard that word and they're old enough to understand the implications of it and there's curriculum and teachings out there that are appropriate for those students to learn through um additionally uh I want to provide a safe environment for all students but particularly our black and brown students and very particularly our black students because what we've seen is that sometimes these is um situations are swept under the rug and kind of pushed

055like this was an incident that happened and we can move forward from it but essentially now his child my child our children don't feel safe and then I get involved and now I'm also feeling unsafe because nothing is being done um additional to Children needing that education and this could be done yearly or or every trimester our Educators need updated anti-racist training so maybe they don't really quick in how to talk about this with do maybe it's the first time that they've come across it and they don't know what to say I know I heard the time I'll be really quick um maybe they don't know what to say which is understandable I'll give that but this is upon all of us especially the board who runs the district to ensure that all of your

056teachers are equipped they don't have a contract but they they also don't have the equipment to push forward initiatives to make sure students are not bullying each other make sure students are or not saying racist language and I want to put this out there if you all have students or children um would you want your child coming home and telling you hey Mom Dad somebody said N word to me somebody said a racial slur about me being whatever and the school really didn't do anything about it we talked about it once and that was it how would you feel as a parent and maybe take that in consideration when you're thinking through this because I'll be back and I'll continue to send my uh emails and continue to try to talk to you all and

057I want us to be in Congress uh but I want us to do it um in a way that is collaborative so I'm not here to yell and scream and fight with you but I am here to say this won't be the last time you'll hear from me and this won't be the last time that um I'm bringing this up so I'm going to stop there I'm getting a [Music] [Applause] little the biggest problem I I really had with this is that my son was made to apologize I'm very confused as don't like he did something wrong for reporting it for letting that child know what he said was inappropriate and wrong and somehow at the end of this him being called the word he ended up apologizing that to me way more unacceptable than

058I could ever believe should have been should have been in that situation and then giv to me no explanation to basically just a sweep on on the road and I've been waiting for weeks now for a response once still wai that's un I'm [Applause] [Music] sorry Jane Zimmer hi I'm Jane I'm back um Candace is my friend this is not the first time I'm here to support another friend to talk about the same issue about equity and racism in our schools particularly to our black students um I could go on and on about my son's experience at Whittier um he's in second grade with these two families as well um in kindergarten he had a teacher who was super racist school's super well aware of that we've talked about that a million times in first

059grade he was taunted for being chocolate and gross while other white kids were vanilla that's right um are vanilla they had restored a Justice meeting no call was made to the parents my son told me not at 7:00 but at 8:30 when it was B time because that is the best time to bring up conversations um and I'm the one who notified some other parents and brought it up to the school to say hey when there's racism are you all going to call us or no and it seems like what even though I brought that up that still is the case that when racist actions happen we isolate the incident act as though that doesn't happen and we have no policy it seems to actually address it in a meaningful way why is that why

060is there no policy on this and I've been in meetings here where we talked about the inequity among students and I don't know how many people are aware of this um really the numbers I pulled the numbers off of the Illinois report card between 2019 and 2024 white Learners in 2019 met an exceed standard at 50.6% in 2024 I'm sorry in 2019 in 2024 that number jumped to 65.6% of white Learners meeting an exceeding standards in 2019 black Learners only only 16.6 met an exceeded standards and in 2024 we're seeing 26.1% of your black Learners needing an exceeding stand currently in 2024 black Learners 74% % of them did not meet partially met or approached Illinois State Standards so do you think there's something correla with the inequities that we're seeing in our education with

061the racism that we our students see in schools if we don't deal with the racism that our students experience structurally as well as casually how do we expect these numbers to change in our Community how I I will not be so blaz to say I've done research I've done a lot of Googling just to be clear I'm really good at the Google machine but I came across a really great study and there are some things that I there are two quotes that I just want to end with schools can violate the P psychological safety of black students when there is a failure or refusal to explicitly discuss racism with with students potentially re-traumatizing so in my son's life at his it's seven years old just to be clear my son is black um anyways um

062just to clarify he doesn't see the school stepping on there's races P so what are we telling what am I telling my black yeah you're just going to have to deal with it that's okay because we know what happens because he's not seeing that change he's not seeing it when I told him the parents are doing something he's like thank you Mama because the kids are all talking about it and the way they're talking about it is completely uneducated it's completely seveny old and stupid and silly the last quot I will say I heard the timer one can argue that the constant debate regarding the black white opportunity Gap and achievement can be considered a microaggression because it is typically assumed that the low academic performance for black students is due to internal ACC attributes

063or their parents characteristics I really hope that is not true in the core beliefs of who we are as individuals in this community leaders in this community at this board and the Educators here but that is what our experience is we are here as community members to say that we know that this is not a fight that we can abolish we get that but we are here to do that work but I've asked that many times and I've been here a few times and there has been nothing and what's at stake is our kids and we're saying that's just okay because we're not taking action thank [Applause] you Erica Kates yeah okay I love liter uh I love the second gr community and as a part of the community I must stand up when black

064students are called the N word and I am not here alone I speak for several of the women sitting behind me and more that are on and watching this is not okay I'm a psychotherapist and I specialize in trauma and when our children are in fight flight or freeze mode which is what happens when they are exposed to something like the nword or called the nword they cannot learn we wonder about the difference between the black and white Learners if our students don't feel safe those numbers will not get better my concrete ask for both an immediate and longer term schoolwide intervention is the following I ask that this incident of racism be used as a teachable moment for every student in the building so that in the event this happens again we can point

065to the moment they were educated on this and why it is not okay specifically within the next few weeks every student is alerted to a with a schoolwide assembly a grade byg grade discussion or a classroom by classroom discussion that there was an overt racist incident in our school where a black student was called a racial slur and that we at withier simply will not tolerate this we will not tolerate racism we take it very seriously so seriously that we are all having a discussion about racism today and that we will have one every time one of these incidents happen in regards to the long sorry I'm almost longer term interventions what has the district done to handle things like this in the past to Jane's Point what is the policy how are we continually

066leaving in Jedi Justice Equity diversity and inclusion into our curriculum that is not simply about spotlights and don't get me wrong I love the spotlights but if we are not especially for our seven-year-olds connecting that back to hey we are spotlighting a woman of color this month because what she did she did in the face of this thing called racism and let's talk about what racism is they are not necessarily connecting the dots I love my kid but p7 okay thank [Applause] you soia in the past they've said it all okay she has a you could you can if you want it to be part of the minutes you can um well thanks everyone for coming out and delivering public comment tonight it's much appreciated as I said we value the input and insights that

067we get from you all um we are going to go to superintendent remarks now so um oh okay um doesn't matter I don't need a a deck um I think um I'll do you have that okay I'll go ahead and get started um while we're calling the de deck up um I think we heard uh I wanted to say we heard a call for um a safe environment for all students especially black and brown students it's I just want to start with that tonight um that call is a shared one and it's not it's also not optional um the call for inclusion and fairness that we heard is a shared one and it's also not optional if there are concerns I think it's important that we speak to the people closest to the incident to

068and I think you um you know we heard illusion to this that um have an opportunity to talk and understand and learn together because we're not we're talking about complex things like biases that we're walking around with in our head and we need to talk about them we need to learn differently we need to change our behaviors and every adult in our system is part of that solution and it's not acceptable to not respond it's not acceptable for us not to engage those are requirements and if that's happening that you're not getting a response I want it to be clear that that that that's not okay and that you do need to escalate that so that you do get a response and that that we sit down with you know not just the administrators but

069all of us that are involved so that we can learn and grow and create a different kind of District I think it's important that you know um that we also talk about the fact that words and talking to each other and learning uh together are part of the solution but if we're going to have a substantive impact on the kinds of things we're talking about here like historic racism then we're also going to need to change the way that we use our resources time people and money just continuing to do the same thing and talk differently or use different words is not going to lead to a different outcome and so we're going to have to need to have some courageous conversations about resources time people money technology how do we actually Place dollars in

070ways that are different than the way that the system is set up right now we also need to come together differently not one group I can have the title of superintendent and you can have as many administrators that's not going to solve the problem we actually need to show up differently learn differently connect differently and do our work differently every single one of us self-included if we're going to get to a different result because it's not like we have really any examples of school districts as verse as ours coming together in the way we're trying to come together that have gotten this done so if we think we're following someone's Playbook we're going to get there that's just it's it's not true we are doing something that hasn't been done and it will require that

071we do things differently I think we need to have some courageous conversations about that about whose voices get heard who gets to speak for whom and whose voices are not heard including our students and especially as we talked about our black and brown students and so instead of talking about it what we've done and what we're doing is all of our school Improvement plans are built around the experiences of our focal cohort students and what that means is we are saying as a school district we are challenging ourselves to Center the students who have historically been underserved For Whom the system is not designed and we've asked ourselves how do we need to think differently and you he have heard even in public comment how people are thinking differently connecting differently that's us moving resources

072differently and that's what it's going to take to get to this vision of universal Student Success and I I want to say on the agenda tonight that's the next slide um our our areas of work and things that we're trying to do um that make this work more transparent that invite you to be part of it we do not get it right all the time but we are trying to be more transparent more inclusive and try to figure out how we need to reinvent our organization and that's not like I said something that comes out in an email it's actually something that we're going to need to figure out and we miss some things and sometimes the critical questions and the critical feedback are also part of that change process and so we welcome it

073I think tonight we're have on the agenda several things that are related to the big work in the district we have a presentation on Workforce diversity and the Strategic Staffing cycle the most important resource we have is the people that we put in front of our teachers in front of our students and the impact of our teachers is immeasurable and we need to think about why does the data indicate that our black teachers are leaving the district we need to ask what's that experience and how are we going to change that so you'll see that data and you'll see some of the things we're working to do to change and we invite you to be part of that culture change work we need you to be part of that culture change work you'll also see

074on tonight's uh um agenda Community guidelines for giving this is about our policies that require resource Equity we we have we heard about like the generous Spirit of Oak Park that's awesome and amazing and people driving around to like how can we use our resources in a smart way to bring experiences to our students we also have a community that's eager to donate and to be part of you know fundraising and bring beautiful experiences and opportunities to our students we've got to we've got to balance that with our commitment to have resource Equity across our schools and so what you're going to see tonight is a framework for how do we actually put administrative guidelines in place that ex that that Implement those policies that do call for not an option to be inclusive and

075Equitable in how we do our work and you'll see two then will'll have the framework and then you'll see two actual donations come forward one for a Gaga pit at buy and the other one around black Excellence education ultimately we know that if we are not achieving Universal Student Success it's because something's broken in the system it's not it's not the students it's us it's what we are offering our students we've got to rewire the system and that's what we're looking to do ultimately the deficit is in what we offer to our students and we've got to rewire and change that system that's the courageous work you'll also see on the agenda is the access to algebra and I'm going to spend a couple minutes talking about some of um uh just some of uh

076our commitments in that space um the access to algebra work is part of a broader commitment to make sure every student has access and we include every Advanced student should always be challenged in this District always that is our commitment uh everybody getting everybody stretching everybody becoming every student on the path to where they're going uh that's the vision we also have a master facility plan uh on the agenda today and you know even just in the last few days there have been such um amazing gatherings in the community around uh sustainability and around coming together as a community so we're excited to bring forward um agenda items that reflect these values and that um you know that our our work together to put them into practice to really make this a an inclusive place

077a place where we challenge ourselves and challenge each other to to of all of our students so those are the the presentations and I the first one tonight is our Master facility plan [Applause] good evening tonight within the master facility plan and sustainability update we will provide updates regarding the following the sustainability Task Force update which will be presented by Dr Sheila Johnson assistant superintendent for finance and operations and uh the community solar update which will be presented by Becky Thompson with niia energy as you are aware we currently have a request for proposal out for the installation of roptop solar panels at homes Julian and Longfellow the District does not have sufficient roof space to install solar panels to fully offset the district's electricity usage the sustainability task force um the installation of solar

078panels and participation in community solar projects are integrally connected to the master facility plan to in excuse me to integrate sustainability into each step of the process and plan the master facility plan phases overview which will be presented by Jennifer castano with Str Partners uh will be our final piece of this presentation I will now turn the presentation over to Dr Johnson good evening uh what you see here is a timeline for the sustainability taxk Force so the board you approved a sustainability policy in uh last December and within that policy the superintendent and task is assigned with creating a sustainability task force so we've had two rounds of applications so far so in the first round we received about 15 applications and we interview uh most of those applicant the ones that uh replied

079to our communication um thank you to Amanda she helped us create a sustainability task force flyer and we sent that flyer out and we also put communication in um the school newsletters so after that we received the 15 applications for the first round we um met with the applicants we had a few questions for them we interviewed them to talk about their interest on the sustainability task force um this December we had a meeting brief with those nine applicants which went very well um each applicant told us about their background and what interest them and why they wanted to sit on the sustainability task force and we have two rounds because after the after the meeting greet we receive more applications so we want to make sure we give every applicant a chance to be

080heard and a chance to participate in the process so right now we're currently in round two of reviewing the application and after that we will um provide an update to the group uh on next steps we're thinking about creating uh subgroups within the task force to work on different aspects of the sustainability policy um we only have two meetings scheduled right now and that's in March and in may but we're going to add more meetings to the uh schedule because we need to meet more frequently in order to create the sustainability plan so um as the policy calls for the plan must be created within one year of seating the task force so we're hoping that happens by December of next year next like I said we had um nine applicants for the first round

081and then uh I mean 20 15 applicants for the first round and out of that we had nine applicants and then the second round we talked to two so so far we have 11 members on the task force and it's not including the administrators and with that I will turn it over to Becky from Mania she's going to give an update on the community solar yeah thank you thank you for having me this evening so um Community solar just as a little background this is not the on-site solar request for proposals that's currently open so community solar represents a way to engage in renewable energy in exchange for a discount to your utility rates um without participating in any purchase or uh installation of on-site solar infrastructure it was originally designed in Illinois to make

082solar accessible for people that it's otherwise not so Community solar is actually open to residential uh you can uh sign up for your home and the way that it works is that if you've ever driven down the interstate and seen these really large uh solar Fields out in the middle of nowhere and there's no houses nearby and you're like what what's going on here what why is this out there so basically that ties into the grid and puts green energy onto the grid it creates um renewable energy developers on Wall Street uh usually third party investors are purchasing and building out these systems then they're getting subscribers to take off take that power and there are a lot of incentive programs out for solar right now uh the district is actually going to be eligible

083for some of those with your um your specific on-site solar projects and in exchange for them getting these incentives uh and then having subscribers kind of purchase the power from these fields they are sharing the savings model with those that are subscribing so uh for residents uh this can be 20 to 30% of your utility bill um and for larger commercial and Industrial size users uh in Illinois the discounts are about 5 to10 % of your electricity cost so this is a a way to help hit some of your sustainability initiatives by participating in renewable energy for the schools where onsite solware is not a viable option currently based off of roof space or roof age um while still reaping the benefits financially of that discount so it's kind of a a dual benefit scenario

084so with that in mind we went out uh to the market to the community solar developers that have available available space uh for you to subscribe uh just for the locations that are not currently engaged in the on-site solar RFP the reason for that is that we think that eventually those uh that will have on-site solar will also be able to participate in community solar but we don't know how your usage is going to change and fluctuate quite yet so that is a not yet um kind of mentality so uh this just evaluates all the facilities that are not currently um within that on-site solar project um with that we had three respondents for Community solar developers with varying degrees of discounts in contract terms um you can see up here that it's about 5

085to 10% depending on the actual provider um and there are some nuances with the contracts uh so we actually invited uh if we look Arcadia and ampian the two Below had very similar responses there weren't much difference between the two of them so we actually invited nexamp and ampen to um participate in an interview process with us so they were able to do a presentation of what their their scope of services included what did their contract look like and then engage in some question and answering through that process um through that uh interview Discovery uh next y came out kind of on top from our recommendation standpoint um they have availability starting in probably q1 of 2025 uh whereas the other two providers were about 2 years out for for a wait list for an

086open field and and open availability um they did represent a longer contract but they also had about double the savings offering as well and so um with that we're uh really just providing an update to you that um currently looking at the contract or requested a contract from nexamp for review and negotiations of what those terms would include um taking into account specific Provisions such as if they wanted to add on-site solar to any of those facili that are under consideration what would that look like um and so next amp is preparing that contract for a review from the district but uh if it moves forward then it would be about estimated $58,000 in utility cost savings annually for the 20-year term um with projected savings uh expected to start late fall of 2025 any

087questions about it can you just like can we go like one level deeper the implications of a 20-year term contract and the potential addition of on-site solar and the implications for us being locked into a 20-year contract and like what what's the like logic that you all have put into that equation yeah so the provisions in the contract that we're specifically asking nexam to include is that if any on-site solar was considered for facilities that are under this contract um that it would be a 24mon notice which is typically a construction time frame for onsite solar anyway so you could provide them notice uh that you were considering on-site solar and then they would allow you to do that without penalty the reason for the longer term contract is um from a standpoint uh you're

088essentially taking an anchor position being a larger user for these commercial Fields so if you think of like a new mall coming in and they want an anchor tenant before they can kind of parse out some of the smaller they want someone that's going to be around for a long period of time before they make the multi-million dollar investment um which is why nexamp is one of the largest national National providers and so because they have the most favorable discount and uh the quickest turnaround time I think that they're able to kind of ask for that longer contract term which makes their investors have a higher level of comfortability I guess then like if we're waiting to look into Community solar for the schools that are going to have on-site solar because we're not sure

089what our energy usage is what's the flip side of that this fact pattern so you could uh it's far easier to add uh additional facilities in than it is to remove okay dedicated so that was part of the consideration uh with the open proposal we know that that usage is going to come down for those specific sites so maybe not include those right out of the gate but we could always add those into the contract at a later date um with some of the other schools that are not yet considered we don't really have a definite time frame of when on-site solar would you know happen if at all with some of those um so we don't want to risk the discount disappearing or Community soier not being a viable option um so getting you

090those savings immediately was kind of the thought process behind that okay that's helpful thanks yeah absolutely and some of those similar questions were asked and the representatives from next am they are very flexible they appear to be flexible with the contract so they say we could put some of those Provisions in the contract so once they send the contract then we will review and make sure some of those Provisions are in there or yeah we want this to be a win for you not something that you feel behold to I have a question so are there I understand putting solar panels on the roof and how that works this is new to me so are there any um structural changes that we would have to make for Community solar y so it's coming from the

091grid correct yes so this is um it's a fancy paper exchange if you will got it so it's going to be a transfer of credits on your ComEd invoice there's not any actual electrons that will be flowing from this community so we field to your school does that make sense so it's really it's um it's going to be negative a credit on one bill and then a charge on another bill and the difference between the two is the net savings the 10% that we see here yeah but are we still doing something for sustainability by doing it or is it just a money we're buying solar energy so the the case that can be made from a sustainability standpoint is additionality is the term so they're um as you dedicating 20 years making a 20-year

092commitment to a community solar farm um that may not have existed without your 20-year commitment you are providing additional green energy onto the grid as a result of your commitment to that that you speak in a circle there did that make sense there's a new there's a new asset as a result of your um commitment I no I to I I get that but my point is um we talk about with our community about making our buildings green we not changing our buildings to make them green we're committing to supporting solar right well we're doing both so Community solar is part of a larger package we can't meet our energy needs through rooftop solar alone so this is to pick up the remainder essentially and then in terms of like efficiency and things like that

093that's much I think that's more part of the master facilities plan than this but um solar is a big piece of that sort of overall sustainability but it doesn't sound like we're accessing the actual solar energy they're building it they're providing it to the grid based on our commitment contractually to buying the energy that they are putting into the grid yeah sustainability our usage right I'm sorry and therefore our usage no we're not using it yeah it doesn't impact your usage your usage would remain the same so our right that and that's the that's my point too we're not using it but I guess where I'm saying though I think the point on by committing to this like if we didn't commit to this we would still be using that energy and we would be

094using energy from coal plants and we would not there would be no offset anywhere causing them to build this we're helping them build this solar farm which then goes into the overall need people to make commitments that are large users because then that allows that allow oh got it okay but because that that energy goes into the whole energy Collective system of the area but then you still need people to use the energy so it goes we're not using energy aat it's a generator of energy just like a coal plant or a nuclear plant or natural gas generation it goes straight into the same um grid infrastructure like the power lines right is it fair to say that like what energy we're using we're offsetting by P by having solar energy available to someone else

095I uh so to have to to claim an Offset you would actually have to purchase okay offset a term of okay our carbon reduced so here here's TR I I yeah I understand so um the state of Illinois has uh made a commitment that by the year of 2050 as part of the climate Equitable jobs act that energy that is created and distributed in the state of Illinois will be 100% grain backed which does not mean that we're closing every coal plant it means that there will be as uh as much renewable energy on the grid as there is brown power or coal powered to offset to use to use your term the the way that you kind of make the net difference between the two is through a renewable energy credit or a solar

096Renewable Energy Credit so if anyone has ever come to you and talked about srex it's actually part of the payback that you get for your on-site solar and SRE is the piece of paper that says there is new renewable energy that is on the grid as a result of this solar farm ComEd and amarind downstate the state of Illinois they need to purchase these certificates to prove that 100% offset by 2050 right they're not they're not building All Grain infrastructure they're doing pretty well with the the brown power that's out there so they're going to purchase these certificates they need to purchase these certific get from massive renewable energy sources I.E large community solar Farms so the offset and the claim to direct sustainability is being purchased by ComEd from this particular Community solar field

097that we're referencing so o perk School District cannot claim the direct offset but what you can claim is additionality and you get to claim some of the Savings in the interim before we're able to do the on-site solar for these other facilities it is an addition to some of the sustain sustainability initiatives that you have it's not one or the other they're stackable and correct me if I'm wrong with this analogy it's like if you have a a bucket that you have to fill up to provide energy for all of Illinois and right now it's being provided all by Brown power and we're saying hey we're going to fund this green piece over here so part of that energy is now being provided in the bucket by that green energy right so every body's taking

098from the bucket separately there's not like a direct line from us to the green field but because we have done this the amount of green energy in that bucket increases is that that yeah that's a fair analogy I think it's important to remember that sustainability is a spectrum it's not black and white and so um the claim to savings um or additional renewable energy being on the grid as a result of some of your efforts here is still a sustainable initiative um it may not hit every single bit of your sustainability policy but it's certainly a step in the right direction so is that helpful I know we went way in the Weeds on that you guys are going to be rolling around with this later like what have we talk about but I think

099it's important for the community know to know that what we're not doing is like directly like that this is a this is a strategy and it's a viable strategy and it's a strategy about being part of a community and part of the solution on a larger scale but it's not like Oak Park we're not going to be able to claim that Oak Park is powering its schools on solar energy that's not what we're doing well I would think of it like if you put $5 in the bank and you take out $5 it may not be the exact dollar bills that you put in but sure you're taking out something you put in so we're causing a certain amount of kilowatts to go into the grid that are green and then we're taking out that

100many kilowatts so it's not directly plugged into our buildings but I don't think the fact that it's not directly plugged into our buildings doesn't mean that we're not getting green we're not energizing our buildings providing energy to our buildings that's renewable totally I I see savings on here annual and then contract savings I'm still a little fuzzy on this so admittedly is there an initial like we're needed because we are a larger consumer and as with any other a mall a college or whatever um is there an initial investment on our part no okay confused I'll get there okay comment I guess there's I don't understand why you'd say no I'm sorry this feels too good to be true and and not trying to be but I don't know why someone would say no right

101you're not asking me for any money I'm going to feel good because I am contributing to a Greener environment like roundabout sustainability and I know we have these um solar panels that we're going to be putting on a couple of the roofs of our school um further reducing our carbon foot I'll just say that way so I I guess yeah I don't really see why someone would say no uh the biggest headwind when I start talking about this because it's so dense and there's so much Nuance to it and when we get into the weeds is that exact sentiment if it sounds too good to be true um not everyone is eligible for Community solar if you are not a public entity then you have to be investment grade credit uh because if you are

102making a 20-year commitment they want to make sure that you're still there in 20 years uh so public entities are far and away their preferred clientele because you have good credit you pay your bills on time and you'll still be here in 20 years um and the the biggest pain that we're seeing with this like the other two respondents have a two-year wait time because the queue is that thick that there are that many people buying to get in Home Depots and the Starbucks of the world are really sucking up a lot of this available space and so we're trying to get bring this to the public as much as we can um the only downside as we see it is that it the the contract term it's the 20 years and I understand why

103they have a longer term and that's usually the biggest headwind when we bring it before a board is just and the far has the farm been built no so so you your commitment uh so for the state of Illinois for them to get what's called notice to proceed to be able to then start investing and build it and get the permitting they have to have a certain amount of off tap and so your entering into the contract would then make them eligible to move forward with that process okay thank you sure another factor that might help explain why it feels too good to be true is that it's actually cheaper to produce renewable energy than fossil fuel energy so that's part of where the savings comes from is that we're actually going with a cheaper

104source of energy with with the current incentives being what they are yeah that that's why the on-site solar actually makes sense for the facilities that are currently eligible because it's a three or four year Roi where traditionally it's been four times that I'm I say return on investment return on investment absolutely great questions so I know it's it's a it's a interesting concept but um it's a great it's a great initiative especially having that um projected potential savings starting next year instead of 3 years from now is a way for you to start seeing immediate savings on your utility bills um and the the contract itself is not a fixed rate it's just a fixed discount so as Energy prices go up and down that 10% applies to if Energy prices go up then that's

105going to be a larger realized savings goes down it'll be small smaller it will vary year to year based off your actual energy cost I think one of the things that's um difficult or like difficult to adjust I wonder Venus if this is what's happening too is like we're used to analyzing things about kind of that individual benefit or like what's the cost benefit for our own organization you know like what's the bottom line um and in this case there there's multiple things happening there's still a bottom line benefit but we're also like changing the way we think about metrics and about impact and about you know there's this shared notion of collective well power and energy um so I just I I guess as I'm getting new and introduced to the sustainability effort I

106wonder what you think about that there just seems to be it it kind of uh shakes some of our assumptions when we're analyzing something and so that way we're kind of like wait a minute um it's because it's different than how we're used to analyzing I don't know what you would think yeah I think that's a really wise interpretation of it and the term Community solar we think that it means it's in our community it just means it's in ComEd territory it may be two hours away from your actual School District community means that it is available to members of the community and so it's a sense of public entities small businesses your residents um you know you can encourage your parents to join this program and say we are an anchor tenant of this

107specific field in this location and then they may be eligible for 20 or 40% discount on their ComEd invoice as a result of participating in the same subscribed field as you are so it's a way for you to bring that climate and Equitable jobs act it's specific to make this Equitable to make renewable energy available to everyone not just people who can afford to put a rooftop solar panel up this is a way for everyone to participate and secure some savings as a result so it actually meets your sustainability but it actually could also the case could be made for some of your Dei initiatives as well thank you absolutely next we would turn it over to Jennifer to start the discussion on the master facility plan thank you uh good evening everyone um what

108we see up here is the timeline that we've shared for the master facility plan um over the next year uh we have kind of moved through phase one we're solidly in phase two uh to be followed up next um late winter and spring in phase three I'll share the overview of the different phases um in the next slide um and then hoping hoping to wrap up and get an adoption of the plan next um September so uh just to kind of briefly remind all of us what the different phases are uh phase one is was meant to set the goals and some expectations um and identify the stakeholders um that we are hoping to engage in order to inform the master plan and then also to gather the exting data that we have um available

109from the district as well as out on sites uh phase two which is really where we're um in the bulk up right now is the assessment and Discovery phase so that has been a lot of conducting of studies so that we're going to use those studies to inform the overall master plan um some of those studies involve capacity and utilization studies uh the facilities assessments educational adequacy um sustainability goals and the plan uh phase three which will be borne out of the um out of all these studies uh we will start to create options and recommendations for how we can address some of the the things that we have found out of our um our research we'll begin to identify costs with those options and then have those options vetted with the facility advisory committee

110um phase four will then start to finalize those options again work with the facility um advisory committee to prioritize and create a framework for how we prioritize those options uh finalize the costs identify Target annual costs so that that gives us a target for how we um move forward with that prioritization and then phase five is just to adopt and implement the plan and get approval and figure out how we can start moving forward um so the update as to where we are just a quick reminder our goals here are really to assess your educational adequacy and the spaces as well as your physical conditions of your assets and figure out how we can address the curriculum space at the same time that we're addressing facility needs so that we can best maximize your dollars

111and benefit all the district and the taxpayers so for uh to share with you some of the studies that we've begun working on and where we're going the capacity and current utilization we have completed our facility walkthroughs for all of the schools with each princip and PTO members um what's happening now with that is that we're creating utilization plans to show how the spaces are being used and we're documenting some of the concerns that came out of those studies with the principles uh additionally we are drafting a Capacity Analysis based on the enrollment projections from the study with karta that you've had done in 2022 as well as the historical enrollment data that we have um in order to just confirm that we have the right number of spaces for the students that are attending

112those schools um our next step is to meet with the District administration in order to confirm the assumptions that have been made so that we can finalize that report um and in the next steps we'll be compiling a report for both of those studies in order to highlight any outliers and share any concerns and how they should be addressed um this is an example of one of the space utilization plans this is uh the first floor of Brooks just kind of giving you an idea which trying to graphically show how the spaces are being used um our next step will be working on how we identify which areas have some issues that we should be talking about um and highlight those and similarly with the elementary schools um this is just an example of homes

113but we're in progress with with each of the facilities for the facility cons conditions assessment uh we have completed the roofing surveys for each of the facilities and currently right now they compiling the report and putting together recommendations and some estimates we will be meeting with the facilities advisory committee as well as John and his team in order to identify the roofing system so that we can better put together the options and and those cost estimates uh similarly for The Hardscape conditions surveys those have been completed at each of the schools and a report is being put together for that um the facility assessment so we have provided to each of the building Engineers a workbook um trying to get a high level idea of any issues or concerns that are come come to mind

114with them right now they've completed that information it's been sent back to our consultants and they will be scheduling our Consultants will be scheduling surveys during winter break um to go along with John and his team into each of the facilities and not only look through the workbook but get eyes on um exactly what the what's going on in each facility um and then also for the fact we have introduced the master plan with them we shared with them the the um presentation that was provided to you all in September um they are starting to formalize and volunteer for a subcommittee so I think somebody was very interested in jumping in right away so that's always good so they'll be heavily involved in the concept towards the end of the conceptualization phase three and and

115definitely in phase four when we're doing the prioritization and creating that framework um and then also in progress we're working with John to review some of the Legacy items that have been left open from our last Capital plan as as well as some lists that he's already shared with our team in order to make sure that those get captured onto the next plan and for educational adequacies we have worked with um and I I may forget last names but Louis and Patrick as well as the the core team to identify criteria against which we should be evaluating um all the spaces that are currently being used in the facilities so for elementary schools making sure that we have the different spaces for the programs that are required at elementary and also at the middle school

116School level um we're going to be continuing evaluating those um findings and confirming that criteria once we get these plans I think put together it'll it'll help us inform that discussion as well um and then from the principal walkthroughs you know documenting any issues or concerns that they have with being able to serve the programs that are required at each the elementary and middle school level so that that can again inform um our options and recommendations moving forward and an example um this is kind of the list that's been put together together for the elementary schools and the criteria of just the bare minimum spaces that are required in each of those schools so that we can check against equity and make sure parity is happening between the elementary as well as the middle schools

117and as for stakeholder engagement um we had shared uh a list that's an evolving list I think we're continuing try to add people as we we can for each of those various studies so you can see the a little orange arrow is showing the ones that we're kind of already engaging and in progress with um the green arrows or check marks are just that because we've completed that space realization um survey does not mean that we're finished talking with the principles or the PTO or definitely going to keep them involved um but it's kind of showing uh where we are with each of those studies in this phase too and uh what's yet to come with a little gray check marks that we have like that did you have um good participation from the PTO

118um I think that there were at least half of the schools where the PTO was able to make it to the it was kind of a last minute maybe thing but yeah they were they were very involved and their their input was really helpful so on the ones where they weren't able is there maybe another opportunity since the last one was left yeah in fact and I ended every survey saying you know this isn't the last you're going to see me yes there will be plenty of opportuni as we build these programs and are are ready to launch how is that being communicated to the school Community is that something you guys will communicate to the along with the principal or are you having the principal share that information with them I'm sorry which part

119is it you wanted to so as you're ready to launch some of the changes and uh at each of the schools um based upon your Sur results right how are you how is that information about hey here's what to expect here's what changes are happening how's that can be communicated to each School Community yeah I think that's something that we uh will be working with together I think um first we have to decide how you know what framework and what guidelines we going to um affect what happens at each school like where the priorities are and then I think we come together and and determine how we involve each of the schools and there's been talk of having um different schools to attend the fact committee meetings in order to kind of talk through what

120the option are and and how that best serves with them so I think that's a conversation that we still are having um but I I appreciate you bringing up because it shouldn't be lost and speaking of things that shouldn't be lost up to Holly's Point um can we just make sure that we're doing a checklist for each to make sure we get to the PTO I know they're going to be offered more opportunities but just make sure that we're not missing folks definitely all right well thank you all oh I have a couple other questions so um you had mentioned learning spaces like possibly updating them when the walls are open like we say so that but we just did the referendum updating of learning spaces what's an example of we redid the libraries so

121we kind of had those conversations about learning spaces like in the last whatever how five or six years so can you just give an example of what that might be of learning there was one point where you said it was like phase yeah do you know what I'm talking about you said there it was these arrows and it was the bottom said learning space is when you have the back of the where's the beginning I was hold I could have asked the question back a little further back back right there address curricular space needs at a time what is a curriculum space need so um some of the highle findings that came out of the tours there are spaces within schools that um such as man and spy and um there was even a space

122at Lincoln where um it's like an open pod right so there there's difficulty in scheduling the spaces because of how classes function right so um so that's one one of the opportunities um I think that the other thing that came out was a um a need for more intervention small group uh class siiz spaces uh especially at the middle school level there are opportunities to make that happen at the ends of the Wings and they're kind of being used that way now but it's an open space and again it's disruptive and um not really a dedicated space so I think th those are the kinds of curricular needs that I think are going to come out of that and there are probably a few others that as we goil through this that will affect the

123learning environment no I understand that I I ask that cuz I have another question which is we're seeing enrollment changes and we also know that special needs to use your point about intervention like our needs change and so like building a wall somewhere right that kind of changes a space and then our need our enrollment changes or our needs change and then is that space still usable I I guess I just want to keep in mind that whatever our demographics look like right now and our needs are now we just need the flexibility because we can't you know we shouldn't be doing permanent changes I think to structure um when we are seeing some enrollment fluctuations and we don't I don't right things change the hope is that we'll be able to find ways to

124repurpose space or redistribute space at least um with some of the programs I know there's concern about how um programs are located that they don't um directly feed into necessarily their home middle school and so keeping peers together is a concern and um not knowing yet exactly how all this is going to shake out but I I agree flexibility is definitely the key and that's the the trend anyway um like moving forward and another example of learning spaces is science labs that are completely not flexible in the middle schools right now and it's something that we can also outdated like and yes very very outdated so um yes flexibility is the key and and meeting different types of needs I think we were somewhat successful with that with the learning um libraries that we did

125or the Learning Centers that were done because we had these Tinker labs and these steam Labs the steam lab could be used by either the library or become an overflow classroom if it needed to be or other things so keeping those kinds of opportunities um in mind as we're looking at all these space utilization plans is is really going to be ke one of the uh things I've done over the years when we talk about building some of these smaller spaces if we're taking a room and dividing it into two we make sure that the way the heating air conditioning controls uh fire alarm uh audio visual devices are all set up to function for both rooms so then it's a factor whether or not the walls there or not whether or not we have

126to redo hbac fire alarm systems interc comp systems we can have all that stuff in place and make the room more flexible long term uh as we're looking at upgrading these different systems including fire alarm and those things so it's really being intentional about building in not just the change but the flexibility as we go yeah I appreciate the question uh H and and the answers as well I think the notion of flexibility every up and down everything we do so when we talk about Universal Design for Learning it's about saying even within the classroom instead of like you know definitely not like desks bolted to the you know the floor but really more choices for students like I I I it's better for me to do this work in this space even within a

127classroom so even when we're talking with you just described John when we have when we are dividing spaces how do we make it so that it can be bigger or smaller with movable walls you know things like this being smart about that I think um and I'm glad you referenced kind of instructional program placement because that's another piece of I think an upcoming phase is to um and and just to kind of highlight what Jennifer just talked about um making sure we're being thoughtful about if our students that have special need you know have special needs are placed at a school other than their home school for a program how might we make sure that across both of our feeder patterns they would have an opportunity to be placed at a program in the ideal

128scenario so that um they still end up going to middle school with the peers you know that uh that they live with or live around you know thinking about what's that whole trajectory of the experience um and it because that one we got to be careful about right because people move and they like the population could be in a different place and so and I think yes but like I would I would hate to cater it to the current population and in five years we have a different population well and that's the thing you I think you're raising that that it's an uncertain um situation so it depends we might have one year and we we need to be responsive in our um in our staffing and what the programs we offer to the students

129we're serving of course um but just trying to think about things like that so engaging um our special education uh leaders um in helping to think about that you know we've got these great co-taught classrooms what what our our teachers experiences to or what have we heard from our families and our students that might inform how we place programs Donna you know getting her insights and thoughts um based on what she's heard from families that's I think what I appreciate about the process is it's really making sure we connect and listen to um you know to what are the experiences of our families Y and then my last question I know that we are looking at I don't know wants and needs for lack of a better way to decide and I know we've we've

130had you know this a column B column C column we've done it a bunch of different way I guess so a lot of um so I think needs are the easiest right to prioritize um but then once we get to the wants section um I think it would be great to have kind of plan for some conversations about that um include teachers and community members and board members and things like that because um one person's like number one thing they want is to be very different than someone else's and I think it's really important that we you know just try to decide how we're going to prioritize and not saying everyone gets a vote I'm meaning like all 55,000 people in O Park but uh but you know so we can talk about it and

131then the question is from an equity standpoint what if one school Community finds one want and it's the same cost as another want more important for their Community right so I just think there's a lot I think we're having this conversation with PTO and the giving and it's the same concept if we've got you know three things that are all on the the want column and one school wants one of them and another wants another another ones another they're all the same cost are we willing to have schools um do different things I mean is that part of the conversation like you said about programming needs if you have to place people at different schools like how willing are we to have different um facility based offerings like physical offerings to school communities based on

132the needs part like I said is kept heat and NB and fire alarms but those are easy right but you know different shapes to classrooms and physical spaces and then you know conversation about the carry on effects are because as you were talking about population changes all a sudden one school's like well why don't they have that and we don't yes that's the that's the point right getting ahead of the swings conversation and like where you know we did we did the playgrounds what and now this group of parents would like new playgrounds again I don't blame them things plays change like the interest change so how do we try to think about that that was thank you all appreciate [Applause] it all right next up um 3D Workforce diversity and strategic staff and cycle

133Workforce diversity data so we have um Dr Natasha Campbell tomov and Dr anah CER coming up for presentation [Applause] everybody clicker you do conf okay all right so hi so um Anna and I are going to review kind of just some overall things that have been happening in um some professional learning Workforce information just overall HR and where we're looking to go with some projections um timelines for staing so um we've talked about our big idea this is our team that we've been working with um we've touched U all the Departments core instruction um which includes teaching and learning student services um and so we've really been working collaboratively across all areas um Early Childhood included so um professional learning Workforce diversity and Strategic Staffing are our topics Dr Shaw talked about our big idea

134earlier today and as we've been working through all of our presentations we've really been trying to highlight where these particular um presentations are hitting within our Equity policy and so tonight we really are looking at where are are we in recruiting um retaining employing supporting our staff um professional development as where as well as how our how can our students benefit and then supporting one another throughout um additionally tonight because we have been really working across the organization we're going to talk about goals that hit Upon Our we lead we learn and we celebrate together we got a little backwards there but but then also how are we going to be aligning our resources so we're going to be working in one and three so in one we're going to be talking about all professional

135learning and just what are are some of our objectives related to the equity policy but then also how are we relating that to instruction and where are we going with that um what's our what is our model how is that model playing out and then in the three area in to goal three as we're aligning our resources just where are we that's 3C and 3D so in 3C it really gets into how are we starting to look at addressing our gaps but then also where are we looking at um our resources how are we starting to try to align that making things a little bit more transparent and um just with our staffing plan how can we show uh where we're going and how we're looking at for 2526 so a couple of the things

136that we really wanted to just kind of point out is we are in the process of working on a multi-year professional learning plan um as you know we have been working on just what are our processes and procedures in HR along the way and then what's the integration what's the communication how are we making that those things not just transparent but what are the protocols and procedures that we're letting staff know know about as we are doing those things and then again as we started at the end of last school year when I started um it was pretty clear that we wanted to make sure that we had um a plan going into Staffing for this year and starting early and communicating those um as early as possible and making that that process more transparent

137and collaborative so you've seen the slide several times we're going to keep it up here um again because we want to make sure that it's professional learning across the organization but how are we integrating it and one of the things that we wanted to identify is some of the things that we're really asking ourselves as we're working on professional learning is we are asking these three key questions and so our three key questions are who are we sorry the little animations and not like okay it's n9ine o'clock I've had a lot of coffee um who are we what are we trying to do what are we trying to achieve and then how are we going to get to Universal Student Success so as we're trying to achieve as we're trying to move forward we're asking

138our questions how do we get there who are we trying to be and then how are we exemplifying that and then how are we seeing that in our students so um we've got our January Institute day so that's really been like on our on our radar but it's not just January we've also got to look at March and then we've got to look at April and then how does that lead into our summer and then even into August so um we started out with our three August Institute days and January March and April so we've really tried to say our Institute days are really going to be focused on Equity the framework for teaching performance evaluations and safety and compliance so we're tying all of our professional learning around those Concepts and so if somebody's

139saying well we've got the pilot and the non-pilot schools but what are they doing and how are those conversations or how are those professional learning pieces tying back to those strands and so if people aren't part of those so even our AAS what are they going to be learning and how can we tie it back to those so they might be working in safety and compliance they might be working on performance and Valu ations um we might be working on if they're not part of one of those maybe they're in a department meeting working on um strategies and things like that that we can tie back to the framework um or what Equity presentations what are we starting to do around implicit bias so some of those things that we want to start building into

140all of our um trainings and days so making sure that we've got some consistency as we start to build build both that multi-year plan so as we move into thinking about Sy 26 then the next piece is we have to build we build every year a professional learning calendar and that professional learning calendar some of those spaces are really meetings right so we want to actually look at what's on that calendar and decide are we leveraging those meeting spaces for professional learning and then taking those meetings off of that but calling what they are you know saying okay these are truly meetings and we want them to be meetings or can we leverage them to do these things here and actually turn them into professional learning spaces because they may have started out as professional

141learning spaces but maybe they've turned into meetings is that makes sense so we we have lots of them but are we doing the are we getting the learning out of them are we capitalizing on the the people in the room what's happening in the room and are we um really producing what we want we want to leverage those times and spaces so that's kind of the learning spaces and what we're looking to do moving into syy 26 in professional um development um area so when we're looking at that though as we're trying to develop some of these things across the organization one of the things that we said was we've got lots of people going out to different um different uh conferences or different learnings and so an example is we went to a zoretta

142Hammond um Workshop but what we did is we took individuals from all these different um areas from across the organization and so this is our hoop and so all of these people is about 20 of us and then we are coming back and then what all of those people are doing is we're now coming back to say how are we sharing this what are we putting together so that then we can share this consistently across the organization and then reflecting to see how is it actually going to impact student learning and how is everybody in the organization going to get it rather than just the 20 of us that went and so whether it's going to be on a lunch and learn whether it's going to be part of a building meeting or whether it's

143going to end up on one of our Institute days that's going to be one of the models that we use versus just one group goes and then that's just the group that gets it and shares it so that's kind of like a who would go and then how we would use that model to then share that across the organization so I'm going to pause there before I get into this questions so far on kind of how we're building out the model for the multi-year plan and then how we're hoping to build and use those types of shared learning models for um our professional learning so I have a quick question on that last side you have the reflect and plan piece that has you know evaluate Effectiveness when you say evaluate Effectiveness are you evaluating

144effectiveness of uptake from the adults in the room or the impact on the kids in the room or both so it'll be both but initially it would be the adults right so the first part would be did we get it delivered and shared out appropriately then hopefully the next piece would be how did that work with the students but that's kind of a longterm further out piece because we need to be able to get there we need to be able to so like we went to zaretta Hammon in November we're now working on trying to develop the presentation that we want to share out with the buildings so then then it's about implementation of it so then that's that next piece I I totally get that progression I would encourage you strongly yeah yeah to

145ensure that that student component is yes because that because it's got to get that determines whether that professional development was impact was impct yeah so that's that's that follow through piece yeah so all the way through yeah so like even for our for our August Institute days it was how did not just how did it go what do we need to do for the future and then starting to use that information to even plan for the future too so that's part of the information we're using even for models like this and planning for our future Institute days so we sent surveys out and I think we got not a ton of responses but a little over 200 responses from our August Institute days I have a couple questions can you I think it's slide 16

146where we talk about yes that one no one more one more I mean the other direction okay Shi that one yes okay so I think this is a clarifying question and then I have a comment yes so currently there were three Institute days in August through the fall no Institute days CU they're meetings and then January March in April and you're looking to shift that so that it's so all of so in so we have this professional learning calendar so all of those things on the even on the right all of those things occur now and they're on this professional learning calendar yeah it's just that some of them function more as meetings but they're on this professional learning calendar so we're saying are they really doing professional learning during that time or are they

147really just functioning as meetings so what we want to do is next year we want to say if it's a meeting let's just call it a meeting but if it's going to be a time where we're doing professional learning and doing a you know a share out about what occurred or learning about a strategy or something like that then we want it on this professional learning calendar okay I'm just trying to identify I think I understand you but in my opinion there seems to be a gap between August and January what you're saying is that there are meetings that happen during that time some of have professional learning component and you want to identify the Pig and the cow meeting yes yes so absolutely um my next piece is so I'm this is going to

148be really awkward I'm going to try to integrate what I'm looking for is integration yes so let me see if I get there so if I look at Equity framework for teaching performance evaluation and even safety those are some of the categories professional learning that have um happened in the past um which I'm fine with but what I'm so we also have a focal Cort in our sips right which is our black and brown students what I want to implore is that within each of those categories that same focal Cort focal cohort is front and center so that there is integration so I I feel like the professional learning absolutely should contribute and be a a significant component of what's happening in those sip plans yeah and so I think that that's a part where

149like we didn't get into the context of so like the zoretta Hammond um professional learning that we did was really around instructional um instructional strategies for for um diverse Learners and so it really was more so geared towards how do we reach our um students that are struggling the most so it it was we're trying to find things that we think are going to most benefit our students but again trying to make sure that we do not keep our eyes on what we're really trying to focus on doing so and I do think that that's important to make sure that we do those things and yes understood yes I don't I don't want it to be covert I want it to be over yes okay yes I'm asking that's why I saying yes okay I'm

150done now okay all right um so moving on to these pieces so then the next part is that Equity piece that first category was when one of the things that we've been working on is identifying possible Partnerships and um support for how we can do more coaching more um work around our Equity policy and so we've really been working with trying to identify whether we're going to work with one organization or multiple organizations to partner with to help us really just kind of uh further our work um um and we've been we've been engaging with all of these um different groups or individuals to see how they could best fit within our organization so like we already work with msan we've done previous work with the national Equity project and so um we work with

151West 40 and so all of these different groups have sent us proposals and so now we're trying to fine-tune how they might best work within with us and whether it's an individ ual project related to um like a our portrait work or um because collaboraction does some really um ingenious work around um students and community and things like that so just really looking for some things that might be able to bring some uh some different perspectives to us and so we're we've just really been looking at some things to bring forward to um further our Equity policy and training for um our staff our um community and our students so just a more holistic picture so this is on the horizon and so we just wanted to kind of put that out there that this

152is soon to come and we'll be bringing those ideas forward for the board um in the very near future um and so next up is um our Workforce equity and um data sure so the next two slides will hopefully feel a little familiar um so just pausing to look at some data that we can use to assess our progress on the equity policy so here just pulling out some language on Workforce equity in our policy um developing a teacher administrator Workforce reflective of the diversity of our student body and developing retention plans so two analytic questions we can ask ourselves to assess our progress on that part of the equity policy is one to what extent do our teachers and administrators demographic profiles near our students that is to a large extent answerable with public

153data on the illary report card which we'll look at and the second is to what extent are we retaining teaching staff across demographic groups across time so the next few slides again um we hopefully feel a little familiar this is these views are not available on the illary report card but the data are on the illary report card so I've taken the data and just put it into these particular graphs so you won't find something it looks like this on the on the report gra you should find the underlying data um so pausing here to just um digest what we're seeing so we have um the yellow on the left most that's the percentage of our students of each uh in each racial me racial ethnic category uh the middle bars are the percentage of

154our teachers those red bars and then the blue bars on the right the percentage of our administrators of each race ethnicity so you can tell there comparing first the yellow to Red bars compared to the student population T d97 teachers are more likely to be white and less likely to be Hispanic or multi-racial here I'm just calling out categories where I see a difference of about 5 percentage points no great reason why I chose five except that um those pop out to me um and then now comparing the administrative uh administrator populations of the blue bars to the yellow bars compared to the student population d97 administrators are more likely to be black and less likely to be white Hispanic or multi-racial and that's and year4 most recent data um looking at gender um again

155yellow are students so looking first at uh teachers and administrators actually together you can see that most um teachers and administrators in D7 are more likely to identify as female compared to our student population slide um so here now we're looking at teacher retention rates um so what I've done here is put um the three racial ethnic categories um where there are um cell sizes of at least 10 so at least 10 um female and um or male student um excuse me EXC me staff in each category are shown here so that leaves white Black and Hispanic teacher retention rates here and then the bars on the leftmost that's our overall rates so what you can see here um again overall rates are yellow the red bars represent the the pretention rates for female students

156and the blue bar is for males not males I said students teachers I'm so sorry there a retention rates for teachers um and so what you can see here is that we retain male teachers of any race ethnicity at higher rates and female teachers so you can see those blue bars are above that line showing the renti rate overall um we also retain um Hispanic and black teachers at the lowest rates especially Hispanic and black female teachers at the lowest rates those are three year averages as you see in the notes next SL so now we're looking Across Time by race assessing kind of where we are in that excellence and Equity Target so over the last four years you've seen that you can see that we we improved our T retention rates so that

157yellow line with the circles as dots shows that we have slightly increased our retention rates and you can see different lines in for each of those racial ethnic categories um unfortunately what's gone down is the retention rate for Hispanic teachers one um point that you might want to consider in that data is that there's been a fair amount of turnover in the Lincoln Spanish Immersion program and that's where a lot of native Spanish speakers are coming from so you might want to consider running the data without that subset um because that's also tied to the Spanish Immersion program and not necessarily the culture of the district per se um you might lose too many of your numbers to make that significant but that's just one thing I was thinking about in terms of um explaining

158why there's such a big de and that you will see that in many districts um who have not offered um signing bonuses or um retention bonuses for bilingual programs because that's been a huge incentive across across districts especially with are we able to identify where we stand with teacher retention with our peer districts and then also if you can go back one slide I think I think like so Baseline is 2021 yep what changes occurred between 2021 and 2024 to make our overall go up to to make the changes in all the C yes you want to know what happened why yeah I can't answer that right now um so here's the same graph but just for female teachers so over the last four years we've seen very slightly improved D rates overall for female

159teachers um but not among again Hispanic female teachers the rate actually went down um and while slightly increased for black female teachers between 2023 and 24 you see that we're still not quite at the levels we were at at 2021 for our black female teachers so again we might call that Excellence with that Equity was slightly increasing but not for everyone same graph but for male teachers so we saw actually um just a slight decrease in male retention rate between 23 and 24 um and again that's especially among Hispanic males um one happy note is the rate for black male teachers did increase over time so we might call that Equity without Excellence so you see those lines are coming together that's Equity um but the overall um rate is only slightly not quite not

160quite going up um each year so maybe it's Equity without um so going back to those questions we asked ourselves to what extent do our um teachers and administrators demographic profile our students so if the goal is to mirror the student population demographics um we would need to recruit male teachers and administrators we need to recruit white Hispanic and multiracial administrators and we need to recruit Hispanic and multiracial teachers and then we would need to focus on retaining Hispanic and black um teachers especially he black female teachers based on this data questions I had um a question or I guess a comment maybe similar to what Venus asked which is just I think and I know that we're working to be more um consistent with like exit interviews and things but I think that the

161qualitative piece of this is really important like why I mean if somebody leaves because they retired or they're decided to have a family and out of the workforce like that's a very different reason than I had a really negative experience in District 97 and so I'm moving to another District Etc um and so obviously you can't create that data tomorrow but like just having that um over time would be really helpful and as part of that it kind of made me think as Anna as you were talking about like equity and Excellence like it's not there's to it raised a question in my mind of like what is excellence in this context like it's not 100% right people retire people have life changes they move whatever um but maybe this is where looking at peers

162and sort of broader demographics becomes important because we can and also qualitative data to figure out okay Excellence is if somebody leaves the district it's not because we weren't providing you know them with the supports or opportunities or whatever that they needed to thrive here so you're suggesting naming targets for ourselves yeah and sort of thinking about what does that really mean right like what what is what would an excellent retention kind of not just rate number but like practice look like right and we have started to collect um some subjective and objective some qualitative and quantitative information from those exit interviews um we because it is an optional piece we've had some people start to fill those out not many because we haven't because of the time of year it is we haven't had

163many people start to fill them out but you know we have had a few fill it out and so that's at least the start of the collection on that end um to be able to provide us some of that data that is at least some actionable pieces that we can start to use to build some um at least some information off of okay so um actually piggy back piggy backing off of that um what we're using to actually help improve some of those numbers and address some of those pieces um in HR we've started to engage our staff so um we've started to do um from the professional development we we're surveying and we're using that information to build upon our next Institute days or what other improvements do we need to make from our

164exit interviews we took what we were using um that was mostly qualitative um to now we've actually added some quantitative pieces to it so that it's a more holistic view so we're engag engaging more of our staff um in just more interaction with our staff to get that collect that information so that then we can actually identify more of what our staff is needing from us so that we're getting more of that one-on-one contact and information so that then we can address more of the staff needs um as we're rolling out more things we've gotten um some good feedback from some of the people using the new portal from our um let's talk and being able to access that information so again it's really just trying to engage with them finding out what the needs

165are and then being able to address those needs it's a slow process but being able to do those pieces um as we've brought on um one of the new HR managers we've started to go out to college fairs and so we've already been to three different job fairs we've gone to Triton College we've gone to Illinois State and we've gone to Northeastern we're also registered for Dominican um West 40 and the Illinois Association of um School Personnel administrators those are coming up in the next couple of months and then we continue to watch for future um job fairs um in all of these cases we're looking for not just that they're there but how many people might be participating who's participating so that then we're actually not just saying we're signing up for everything but

166one we're getting out we're increasing our pool but we're also trying to go where we think that people are going to be so we're not just staying in our normal circle of where are we you know people come to us um additionally we are starting to work with our student teachers so some of our student teachers are starting to finish their semesters and either they're applying or we are reaching out to their Mentor teachers to say we know that you're finishing up how did your student teachers do so that then we can reach out to them to either invite them to apply to be um substitute teachers for possible openings in the future or do we have openings right now that they might then be able to fill for the spring semester so again the

167internal recruitment for the people who are here now as well as going out and actually um so finding new candidates that may not have been um in our per before so um oh yes IIT to you guys yeah so no this was just a picture of um a couple of the different job fairs so we have some um they don't show our swag on there you can't really see it we've got some swag we've got um our uh administrators out talking um HR managers there that's Melissa I don't know how many of you have met her yet but um so this is just us trying to get out and um we've got some flyers to tell people how they can apply for different licenses if they're not licensed yet so just really trying to support

168um even if they want to apply to be a TA just trying to create some pipelines um yes sh are you I think that might be the yes because then we're going to go into St um so just wanted to um I guess advocate for to do the engagement um to really have a full plan because I feel like o Park in general does a lot of surveys we do a lot of like um let's let's ask you questions but then there's never any like real followup um and to people of color any like uh any community that has been like underinvested like that gets exhausting cuz you're not being compensated to bring up the trauma and it's just um any trauma that you're facing or anything that you're going to going through that is

169traumatic to you and then like there's no resolution and so I know Venus and I um we sat here one of the btop meetings at the end of last year we heard teachers explicitly say I feel targeted I don't feel comfortable I like all these things and we did nothing with that um we also talked to um staff over the summertime came back with the report of like all the things we heard and so I can understand like as a teacher or staff member if I feel like I already talked to like three different people and nothing has happened then that could be exhausted and that's probably another contributing factor to why um we're seeing these numbers decrease um so just like letting them know like this is what's going to happen this is the

170timeline this is what you can expect and also like this is what we can't do right so if you're going to say like no we we we're not going to be able to change it overnight um then make that be known and then also I think that I I get the idea having that link in that space but also this kind of imp personal right um when you already have like a issue with trust like sending something to like a random link um there's there's not that relationship to say like I understand you've been going through a lot like let me have a conversation I don't know what the answer is but just keeping that in mind that if I've already experienced something I'm not likely to go especially people for some reason don't think

171hum Mar s is very like friendly um and we get the like thing like human resources doesn't work for you they work for the company so just something to think about in you're messag in the approach are you can I ask are you thinking of like the let's talk are you thinking about the exit survey or just in general in general yeah just like as you think about like your engagement plans and like talking to to folks and asking them like why you know why aren't you why are you leaving even um it's like I would just give the example like somebody was was resigning and I actually called them and had a conversation with them and then followed up with information and then they did complete the exist right so some of those pieces

172it it it may be some of the dialogue that we have to Enga to engage them to help them feel more comfortable to complete those things so so I do so I do know what you're saying because I don't know if I just sent them the email if they would have responded yeah um and then the next point is just like I think this is a great start in terms of the recruiting but I think if we're if we're like really investing it's one thing to invest like dollars but it's another thing to invest like time and some of these things are like to me low hanging fruit so if we are having the most trouble with black and brown teachers to me it makes sense to go to HBCU um if if um Finance

173you know to fly I know some of these things are maybe $200 and you add on flight and all that stuff but I think it's worth the investment to go to schools that you know have a great teaching program or have a and I can help you with that um but then like secondly you talk about hispanic women um UIC is a Hispanic institution right down the street so I think all these schools are great but I think we also want to talk to teachers and student teachers who've been at that school and their experiences what they've heard about us um but I think also like that Chicago state is a predominantly black HBCU it's not HBCU is not it is not like for the record with a camera Chicago snake is not a it

174is not an HBCU it's a predominantly black servant institution um let's get that straight um so but having said that there are many talented amazing Educators that come out of Chicago State and so that is another thing that is right down the street it's a nice little drive but r so what add Roosevelt to that as well terms of Roosevelt as well so but in particular USC is over 40% Hispanic serving so I just if we could be just like a little bit more creative um in those efforts that would be great and I know you said those are the ones coming up just keeping those schols in mind and seeking out when they might be having a job fair yeah and I and I appreciate that and again these are just as we've been

175building our team these are just the ones that we've been able to tackle and so that just that's what we done and it's interesting that you said that because one of our areas that we're lower on is multi-racial despite having a pretty large multi-racial population I was just sitting here thinking like not sure you're going to be able to find a school that specifically can Target right so I I do think from a Crea my point from a creativity standpoint like thinking about how to um I mean if I mean that's just you know that's if that's an area you want to increase I it's going to require more creative things than like yeah a school or a and I think that's what's coming up I'm looking to do all my recruiting now and of

176course I was like you're at the University Chicago just do it there and I'm like I'm not going to get I'm not going to get diversity there so um just feel like yes I'm going to do univers Chicago but I'm also going to go to UIC and other schools that um you know and I also shared a article a couple of months ago about how black students perform so much better when their um Professor comes from HBCU so just than keep my mom yep appreciate and this is to extend or possibly resay you can tell me Shere shar's earlier Point um about the feedback loop I think that extends through everything you've just talked about I just want to be clear because you know when you're talking about engaging staff identifying staff needs and addressing

177staff needs if you take the time to gather that feedback and then you just kind of do some of the things off the list but don't ever address all the parts and say we did hear all of this just's point of saying you know we can't do this stuff right now we can do this now it's just you have to you have to show that you actually listen yes all right and then our last um our last section is about Staffing plans and timelines and so um again this is the team that we anticipate um at least being the initial start um of our plan we've already engaged um at least having conversations with all of these people in regard to what the timelines and the process that we hope to use um so just

178for educational purposes in regard to what the Staffing plan is supposed to be it's supposed to be a tool that helps with instructional administrative and support staff needed to design educational experiences for students um in regard to what we're looking for it to be um next year because that's really the biggest piece of this Staffing plan we do expect it to be relatively this relatively similar barring any major shifts in um enrollment levels and so that's really the biggest part of moving forward for next year is where are those where are those shifts going to be what's that are we looking at shifting here shifting there that's what we're going to that's what we have to play out in the next couple months and so that's what we're going to be working collaboratively with our

179teams to do um but we do expect for it to be relatively consistent um and so that's that's kind of the goal moving forward um when we're looking at the Staffing plan we do hope to that our staffing plans Provide support and they focus on providing the ability to engage students provide access to students and then provide social emotional support and um engaging them in positive learning environments so as we move forward I think it's important because one of the things that we were really talking about at the end of last year was what are all of the different groups that make up a staffing plan who are all of the different people we had talked about out of classroom positions in you know the classroom teachers and then administrative staff like all of these

180people in all of these different categories make up all of the schools and how they run and you know we even heard tonight like we think we need more of this staff and we think we need more of that staff or how do all of these people work together to help the school run and so we wanted to make sure that we covered all of these and so as we move forward we'll talk about who's in all the buildings and how do they help the buildings run and so we wanted to make sure that those groups were identified in the Staffing plan so that we're clear um and transparent about um who's in each building so this is our anticipated timeline for this year it is aggressive in in regard to we're hoping to get

181information out to staff um earlier but also the community earlier so that um as we're moving forward we're being as transparent as possible we want um people to have the information we want to get you the information but we also want to be able to work through the information in a collaborative way so we've already started a conversations with the principles and the district um leadership team to review this timeline um we do um we will be having more conversations uh later this week and next week with principles in regard to what we believe uh enrollment is going to be uh based upon current enrollment and changes that we've seen in Trends um then as we come back that week of January we will be talking about specials based upon the Gen Ed sections and

182we'll start to talk about um any what information we have related to special education and any um adjustments that may be needed in outof classroom positions um we are looking to review information with fork because that is something that is uh generally occurs uh before we bring numbers and information to the board so we were we hope that January 8th is um that's an anticipated Fork meeting for um us to bring anticipated or projections to um fork and so that then we can have a tentative plan for the January 14th meeting so that then our goal would be to bring a finalized Staffing plan um to the board in February with that being said then between March and April we would be working on finalizing schedules and assignments um for um our different um groups

183and then we would also be working on our teacher leadership roles as well as opaa assignments um so that they can go out um April May is um how we going to do it this early without enrollment being open yet for next year so would you like to sure we estimate enrollment for most grades based on current enrollment in the pre grade level so there's 100 second graders we're going to assume there's 100 third graders next year school the obviously the wild card is definitely kindergarten a little bit first grade and we um use the carda report to estimate kindergarten numbers um and then we use historical um not historical current first second and third grade to estimate first grade number unless that number is larger than so but with enrollment going down kind of

184year-over-year are we do we just account for a certain percentage decrease I mean so the estimates are based on just current enrollment except for the kindergarten numbers which we use the cassard report so and then also on the fork meeting why are we limiting it to general education section instead of out of classroom positions also so we do anticipate so that's probably a typo we do anticipate to anything that we're bringing to the January 14th meeting will be at that fourth meeting okay yes and so we will have also um special education they'll be working through um IEPs and um those case loads as well remind me what's the deadline for letting obca teachers know the N of assignment may may yes like I thought that's what it was but yes verifying yes so I'm

185just anticipating like this information um how are we going to communicate this because I can totally see somebody walking away see remember those staff and changes they're making them now um so how are we going to roll this out to the community and what collaboration has been done with teachers to make sure that they understand so that they can communicate if uh families have questions um so that this doesn't spiral into um see I told you um they were going to do this last year so again that's why we were highlighting that we expect Staffing to remain relatively consistent barring any um changes in um enrollment so we're expecting Staffing to remain relatively consistent I understand what you're saying to me I'm just saying like like when we're making or anytime we're talking about Staffing

186so maybe this isn't a question for you but anytime we're talking about Staffing or anything like that right someone's going to see a snippet of this and it's going to be like something else something else is happening they're hiding something so is has there been an opportunity to have like conversations or bring people to the table to say like what questions do you have let me explain this to you um so that you understand like everyone's not going to watch this for right so we will be reviewing this timeline with all of the different Union groups so basically Opa and opaa um we will review this timeline with them to identify this is when we anticipate moving forward just so that then they're on the watch to just know what's happening we um because again

187we are hoping to be as trans as transparent as as we possibly can answer any questions that we can I would highly recommend some type of talking points of infographic something that's I can look at this real quick and say oh this is what they're doing um I think when we put stuff in the the weekly update that's very long um I think people going to see Staffing and yeah and I and I will say that that's also part of why we've already started the conversation with the principles and the district leadership team to make sure that we're all on the same page so that there aren't as many questions um so that then people all feel like they're part of the process um so that then there aren't um miscommunications and different people feeling

188like they're getting different messages as well and when we say Staffing is the same is that a number or every position is in every school is likely to be the same is there going to be a concern that someone's going to lose their individual students reading sler because there'll be a reallocation of resources where even though Staffing is the same is every person that's currently doing their job right now expected to be doing the same job next year that is our goal is to be relatively the same next year but again we're we're Staffing based upon our enrollment so we we have to look at what the needs are but that's why we're trying to be as collaborative as Pro and everybody at the table so we're not trying to be like we're going to

189make this decision over here and then bring it back to this person over here so we're all going to be in a room together and having the conversations about who what you have where and what do we need to be doing so even in our last leadership meeting it was everybody's got these positions how are we using them how can we use them more consistently versus just not even having conversations by the way I didn't mean to imply that that it needs to stay the same but if it doesn't then explaining why it's changing yeah I think what you're seeing also over time is Building Systems so that we're looking at projections to bring and we're putting the projections up and here's what we found so that was something that happened uh we did do

190you know shared in a board meeting here's what we're doing but I think one of the things we learned to your point Sheri that doesn't mean people got the message so we're also sharing it here another thing that we're doing differently this year is we're sending out the board highlights we have about 10,000 opens on that board highlights email this will be included in there and I think highlighting you know this information so there's absolutely the effort I think what you're saying is just to be as clear as possible so let me just be clear like I've said this also when we've gone to PTO meetings there's no like plan to bring back what we you know had proposed last spring there isn't a plan to bring that forward uh know I and as I

191said in the remarks I do think and I would say that we do need to look at resources over time like how are we using our resources how are they lined up who are we being really deliberate about what students experiences with the resources but there are no plans for significant changes to positions in the manner that was brought forward last spring for the upcoming year well and also I mean I do think from a a resources Point what was a slide I can't remember it might have been on our um find I don't know I saw there was a slide that talked about the increase in expenses per student in the district as enrollment has fallen because and so whatever structure like I I mean I do think that if enrollment goes up we're

192not going to get more Revenue they're moving into the same house that exists now paying the same property tax so if our cost per student has gone up because our enrollment has gone down are we and are we and we're providing more resources to kids because we're able to do that that's great but if the enrollment goes up again we're going to have to then spend less per student so I do think when we think about these Staffing decisions we should be thinking about not just enrollment going down but enrollment going up and um and not always I mean and if enrollment does go down whether that's an opportunity actually not to over staff but to you know be really sensitive to bringing our staffing to the level of the enrollment um so that we

193continue to kind of stay with the budget yeah and that's right and I want to that's why I mentioned um that one of the things is to build actually the Staffing model on actual numbers what we were doing for a number of years was just turning over that's why we had class sizes of eight and six or 11 you know in the district so there's a a fiscal responsibility as well as what as you're saying so it has you know I think your one kind of putting those new systems in place and building a a databased model that's more fiscally um responsible and data responsive uh adding on now these systems and timelines and collaboration and communication so we're headed in that direction where people know and we want um people to be part of

194also the tough decisions that we're going to need to make and be aware of them um in terms of like using resources differently to get different outcomes and I think this year where you're not looking at the big shifts at this point this is a good year to really identify clearly your communication channels and the circles like what information is coming in and then what information is going out so teachers are an example what do they need to hear in terms of their position in terms of understanding what's going on and then who do they communicate with and what do they need to hear and so all of those pieces and making sure it's identified what when and where and who um is getting messaging just to be clear across the board I think that's

195that's really important because it's you know we we even last year communicated in some spaces uh you know and communicated to what we thought were key individuals but that may not have gotten um you know to the people or it didn't Cascade in the way that uh we thought it would and so I think your uh suggestion that to really understand the the way the system actually works and the way communication actually works is really important and especially important here in Oak Park um I think also any major changes when of the things is how do we make sure that not only the teachers and first of all the teachers and the impacted people or the impacted uh office staff or the impacted uh teacher assistants or the impacted administrator like knows what's happening that's

196something that didn't happen last spring that was very difficult for the system is the people that were being impacted weren't notified in an appropriate way and then I think the second thing is how do all of the other groups like you're suggesting ncy you know PTO and you know going and making an active communication plan I think those are the some of the learnings and like I've mentioned we're making some of those moves it's not a light switch but over time like creating uh yeah you know like I said the board highlights we've gotten a positive feedback like thank you for this this really helps that I I appreciate this you know and um continuing to do everything better over time one idea for just um dealing with staff vacancies is not necessarily filling them

197right away and so that's a less painful way of reducing some of the Staffing costs um and because we do have declining enrollment and we do have you know very small class sizes in some schools and some grades and so um I know we don't want to necessarily impact immediately the folks who are already in positions but as people retire or leave for other reasons um we might want to consider not automatically filling those positions until we get a better sense of what we have because then it's not necessarily directly impacting folks obviously class sizes might go up but again if we're looking at data we should have a better sense of what that would actually look like so this goes that I think what you're suggesting JN then also um goes to what you

198said Holly you know in terms of like building that capacity in the system to be more responsive to where what what the data says in case enrollment does go up as opposed to having positions where we always have them you know in case enrollment goes up um the capacity to well because I do think like as the potential for shortages comes down the pipe like tasia's earlier point about signing bonuses like I remember when I graduated like there were signing BS but mostly for certain states that were hard to staff um but I do think about if that's going to be like how we're going to remain competitive and so if we're stretched already um because you know we have you know lots of things going like the cost for people is really really high

199like that doesn't leave us to be very competitive in terms of attracting you know hard to staff positions And so there's a lot of there's a lot of flux in terms of what this looks like and what the impacts are um and I do think we're going to have to be more creative cuz even I know like uh one of our adjs is at um lien Township and I know they have like a signing bonus for students who actually graduated from their uh District they get like a I think it's like two or $4,000 it's pretty it's not cheap it's not like change um and so you know those are interesting things too when we think about like who we're recruiting what that means and things like that so I well I was going to

200bring this up with the math because I wanted a public comments but I think the is applicable to everything especially since we had the conversation about recruiting and retention and we talked about race I think it's I hate I strongly strongly strongly dislike what people say we're losing something because those students um so I think when we talk about like why we're recruiting why we're being intentional to make sure that we address the elephant in the room we're not saying we're only going to look for black teachers they're only going to look for Hispanic teachers we're saying that this is an area we want be reflective of our community like whatever the messaging is I'm not a Communications person but that just really stuck with me when she said that um one of the public

201comments was that we were getting rid of math because of certain students um and I don't want that to be the narrative I think most people don't believe that but I can see um there some people going to say you know I think it happened at the high school when they got rid of and people were like oh well you know uh yeah tracking oh well you know just bring those kids up so just like making it the implicit explicit cuz I was just like cringing so hard over here and so I just want to make sure that anything we're like changing and we talk about race that we say like this is why we're doing it and this is not why we're doing for the record teachers of color benefit all kids everywhere like

202achievement goes up so there is research on that I concur but I just I'm like as my kid sits in an advanced class I was like if you had to take it away to make it better for everybody take it away like but yeah just want to say that likewise I was going to save this comment but since you've opened that door I've also seen online sorry conversations about you know the district has given up Excellence for equity and I just want to be clear you can't have one of those without the other like if you say you have Excellence but you don't have Equity then you don't have excellence and if you have Equity but you're not challenging kids and you're not giving them Excellence then you don't really have Equity so those two

203things have to go together and and I appreciate when that is recognized and I think we have to hold firm on the fact that that is where we stand oh and I would also like to point out that multiple people on this board have kids who are accelerated so it's not something that's totally off our own personal experience so all right we're getting off to we're closing the door no board comments for you guys sorry thank you great thank you all right uh Community guidelines for giving process update so we have uh Luis Rodriguez coming on up here welcome good evening everyone I'm Luis Rodriguez and I will be giving you an update on the donations guideline document that we've been working diligently on since my return um basically what I'm going to share with

204you today is three things the purpose of the document a quick background and overview as well as some of the Salient points of the existing guideline document um and I wanted to share at the outset that this is a document that has lots of malib and what I mean by that I'm going to share with you very briefly so I want everyone that's listening and in the room as well as the board to understand what this document is and it is not it is an administrative guideline it is designed to align with and clarify existing policies ensuring consistency and understanding across the district this document is not a new policy um it's also a collaborative effort shaped by the diverse needs of the district and its interest holders including donors School administrators central office staff

205and B the board sharing it with you and taking your input um this document was not created in a silo there was lots of inpoint input from a lot of different people that got us to this point and lastly it's an evolving framework um it represents a thoughtfully considered starting point and I want to emphasize that because the theme here tonight is that we are evolving there are certain things that were doing new for the first time and we recognize the fact that as time goes on this document is going to more likely than not have to improve uh to meet the needs of the district it is not designed to be a stag document really quick where we were as it relates to uh donations and donations come from various sources they can come

206from private third parties but primarily in this District we have PTO that are one of our primary doning sources so where we were we had a decentralized donation practice and Luis didn't just make this up this is what he was able to gather from getting input from various interest holders um that means that primarily what was happening was in the schools and the central office kind of might not have had a really good understanding of what that meant how it aligned with policies or whatnot there was timeliness of board approved donations as an issue in the past sometimes there were matters that were floating out there for a while and it's not necessarily sure why did go before the board or whatnot so this guideline is trying to address one of those issues from where

207we were previously and also this document or where we were is that we didn't necessarily have context for board approvals so there may have been instances that came before the board we didn't have context or the full background on is the administration backing it up what's the purpose of the donation Etc so that's my understanding of where we were and Gathering input where we are we're creating the guidelines for giving document we're in the process of creating it and I think we've got a good starting point um with respect to this document applying to those matters that come before the board for approval and I'll explain that shortly we're also still Gathering input from interest holders so far input from the building principles that's via not just an intake form um to address board member

208Mo's point but also like sit down meetings conversations on the phone pulled into the legal lounge and saying hey Louis you need to understand how this affects my building or whatnot um and then also implementation of review process this is where we are you will see shortly after my presentation we're actually taking a first stab at giving this guideline document and its tenants which I'm going to talk a few about shortly um an opportunity to see what that looks like as it relates to a proposed donation that the board has to approve so that's where we are and where we're going briefly is we are seeking to enhance donation review so we're also looking at the idea of we recognize there are donations that need to come before the board because they passed the policy

209requirement threshold there's a whole lot of donations that don't require that and so what we're trying to look at is a a process that enhances that so it's not obstructionist and I think that's the last two point points uh on this slide we're also look we're so we're looking to enhance the donation review we're looking to imp improve the board approval process so making sure the presentation that comes before you it's clear it's succinct we're not being overly Louise that means overly verbose we're just giving you what you need and then you can ask the questions as it relates to the presentation also these are the two points I was just referring to we're looking to find the right balance I think everyone recognizes the value of PTO and donors that are trying to contribute

210to the district so we don't want to put in place administrative guideline documents or barriers that are going to impede the desire for entities to donate to the district and then this is kind of related to the last point which is streamlining the PTO donation process and we are in the works of doing that and this part in particular is primarily for those PTO donations that are occurring at the schools I'm learning that that there might have been ongoing relationships with various PTO with various building principles it looks a little bit different in different buildings so we're trying to get a sense of that so that we can address it appropriately again in a non obstructionist way that's where we're going um so this is the first page of the document it's been shared with

211all of you before um and I will re forward it so that you can all have a look actual administrative document but the Salient points the highlevel ideas from that document our first we have three key criteria for board approved donations and what this means is when an administrator comes before the board to explain hey this is why we would like the board to approve this donation they're going to hit three things they're going to answer for you if the gift or donation is inclusive and how it aligns with the equity policy so some aspect of what the donation does to hit that the next criteria that they will hit is does the gift or donation align with school district specific priorities that benefit students and there's a number of those that have been already

212identified by the superintendent so things like early childhood sustainability there's a myriad of them and that will be shared with you by the administrator that's presenting and then the third one will be will the gift or donation impose additional costs on the district's budget administrative and staff time or other limited District resources so those are the three things that will be hit in the presentation When an Admin is asking the board to approve a little bit more specificity with respect to criteria one the administrative team will explain of the board the inclusive aspect of the proposed donation to our district and how it contributes to ensuring Equity policy maning so an example would be a proposed donation that funds an extracurricular activity exploring diversity topics promote Civics debates open dialogue understanding Etc and such a

213proposed donation contributes to student development access to exploring diversity topics and is inclusive to the student school student bu that's just an example but obviously each proposed donation might look a little bit different as to what's being shared uh about the donation that meets criteria one criteria two again this is school specific priorities so how does it or District priorities how does the proposed donation align with them the district's administrative team will explain how the donation ties to a priority the district such as ensuring student access to art programs or providing similar play experiences for students in all school buildings an example of this again I'm not exhaustive example the donation would help provide safe place spaces for students to contribute to development and socialization opportunities uh another would be the donation helps increase access

214to a district-wide initiative like the district's theater program let's just say again just an example and the priority there is providing more exposure to The Yards the third criteria would be um how the additional costs are how might there or might there not be additional cost associated with the donation so the admin will explain to the board how the donation is not cost prohibitive or does not create additional expenditures for the district that outweigh the benefit of the donation that's self-explanatory but a quick example proposed donation that adds a playbase fixture to a school building that has a one-time installment cost that's funded by the donation and has limited to no additional impact on the operational upkeep of existing equipment on school grounds just suppose that with a donation that's worth $10,000 and then the

215quarterly expenditure to upkeep it is $100,000 that would be something that might rise to the level that seems cost prohibitive and then to wrap up the process that's um delineated in the guideline document is we basically have a five-step donation approval process um step one and there's way more detail in the document to answer I think uh n you brought this point up like it would be really good to know who does what the guideline document actually does that with specificity at each level of these five steps so the first step is the prospective donor contacts District's administrative team most of the time that's going to happen at the schools PTO or some donor there reaches out to the principal who will then reach out to a central office administrator other times it might just

216be a proposed owner reaching out to one of the senior leaders in the room or a department head so for example you know the special ed department or another sub dep Department that's upstairs in this building so they they contact The District Administrative team step two the administrative liaison does a primary assessment of the proposed donation through the lens of the three criteria just shared I'm pausing there really quick because sometimes there are donors that want to donate they don't know what to what exactly or they just they might be proposing a donation and it just needs some steering as to how could that best meet the needs of the district that discussion would more likely than not happen at step two and at any other point even after we take input from the board

217once a presentation is from the board once a presentation is made to the board the third step is the alazon prepares a cinct memo with the recommendation to the superintendent's design about the proposed donation um step four would be the superintendent design prepares a form linking the memo and routes to the district leadership team DLT for review and in one of the proposed donations that actually is going up for vote today you'll see all those documents linked another one is a first time reading so you won't see that level of specific City but if the board decides to move forward it with it you will see it and then the last step is that the proposed donation gets placed on the agenda for first reading and for a final vote that's that two vote Cadence

218to allow for the board to ask questions or whatnot as it relates to the proposed donation one of the ones that are before you today I think the board already knew by which is why it's up for vote today um go ahead sorry yeah so I can see this for like large donations but someone wants to give like $500 worth the sandwiches are they really going to have to do this whole big process so that's I know but like I know but that's my point people are going to work up right I mean I appreciate all the work that went in and we have to address donations I'm not saying that but like food donations you know I mean there's there's so many things that are so I just feel bad for the administrative team

219has so much to do to be it's $500 it's food or whatever you want to say there's just I feel like there should be some discretion in this process that because it feels very it feels appropriate for the ones that we all you know you'll know when you see it but it feels I mean even like talking about it and the book looks like a book like it just feels like it might discourage people like I don't want to give cuz I don't really want to deal with all this and so I just I don't know I I want you to keep going but I like that so intense that looked so intense I was like holy crap I've never donated anything to the school that's that the call we were on was really really

220really intense um I was not expecting that um and I know you had some follow conversations with folks and um actually I saw someone on Thursday and they were like people are really upset and so I I got the same be back to yeah so I remember talking to one of the moms and they were like we're going to um I suggested in the interest of time it's always better to come with some type of suggestion as opposed to like a blank slate and then you're like brainstorming together as opposed to saying like here's some some thoughts that I had um and so I know they were developing some categories on what things would come before the board what things you know they could spend on so to the point food or if there's an

221emergency you know we've helped families who were experiencing hardships I would not want to have to go through this whole like when you're experiencing a hardship you need money right um and I understand like the equity piece of it but just like we're in the holiday season and we're doing a lot of like donations of volunteering and I know those things are immediate and so I do think to Holly's point if there could be like a a threshold um similar to like with the administration certain things come to our attention if it's over I think 25,000 um other than that it's at your discretion so I think and if we need to change our board policy we should let's just change it so would it be okay if I just share a few thoughts yes

222so as it relates to the I guess the interactions that you have um on the call or what not same thing I experience the same and to be fair and transparent for everyone listening there's nothing in this document that doesn't align with existing board policy so when the the statement is made about a threshold the existing board policy as it relates to a gift or a donation is that the board has to approve it if it's above $500 that's just in the existing policy so with this document so then and and also earlier I shared that for those smaller donations that don't rise to the level of approval we're trying to get a grasp on how to best address those for all of the reasons you just stated H yes can I just I think

223one of the things that came out of those discussions is that the policy threshold is too low so there are things that fit into the bucket of routine PTO donations food teacher appreciation day whatever that could easily get over $500 my understanding and suggestion would be as we're figuring out how to handle the routine that that includes the routine that's over 500 I wouldn't want to come in and go to the PTO and say okay anything that you do that's routine now it's over 500 is now going through this process because they've told us that they actually don't didn't go through our pre-existing process because it doesn't work with what they're doing so I think we I think assuming this is the intent I think we should just be clear that until we figure that

224stuff out it's it's business as usual we're not going to place donation going to die that's this point here that's what we're trying to do in this bullet all the way to the right streamlining a f donate is in the works particularly for those regular routine donations including those over $500 yes and and I am acknowledging that that is an area of opportunity for the district to address it so that it's streamlined and all of the push back that you talked about um Sheree is addressed and and we're acknowledging that isn't we do have to focus on that IM right and I would just ask I think um I agree like we and we've talked about this we want people to be enthusiastic about giving us money we want people to feel like we're Partners

225we don't want people to feel like we're a hassle to give money to um and part of that is how do we deal with the routine one of the other things that um I think is underway is looking at different PTO budgets because you can imagine a situation where $500 donations $1,000 donations $2,000 donations repeated 50 times in the school year adds up to okay this actually does raise Equity even though each individual one may not sort of trigger Equity concerns like in the collective they do and so I think that figuring out part of what we need to figure out is how do we contextualize and I think you said this specific donations because it's really hard to consider Equity across donations if we're just looking at each individual to but I think there's

226a way to do that so like collectively if you know putting a a a cap on per year right so per act per yes academic per Academic Year like you can have if you want to do a 100 um breakfast you can do that as long as at the end of the year it doesn't total a billion dollars just because it the um I think that gets to the point of it because you're right people will say I do it at work I'm like I know that this is going to make the compensation team have to like weigh in on this so instead of pay somebody 60,000 I pay them I pay them $59,999 and99 so that it doesn't fall under that prview but then if I do that with every single person eventually it

227adds up and it's they see like oh it's over your budget so what they do is they say yeah I know this person was under but you have five people under total that's you you went over your budget so I think doing something like that and then just like having that open honest conversation to hear like their concerns yeah and I know you've done that but I think um just continuing that dialogue and letting them know because I was not expecting to walk into that and I was just like whoa whoa whoa so I've been trying to say like you know we hear you we want we want to prioritize this but I think um what I I guess I'm uh hoping won't happen is like what happens often somebody gets a snippet of this

228and then we start with so I think just like the communication of like this is where we are so Sheree on that note I will say that that is a challenging aspect of this but I'm also committed to the idea of having those condos with individual so that they understand what's going on and what I'm understanding here is to things for those things that are going to come to the board moving forward however that is whatever amount we'll use this criteria to share with you why the proposed donation is good and then the next piece is figuring out that front-end aspect for those donations that might not always come to the bo we figuring out a way so that we have a streamlined process to address those so that those contributions to the schools aren't

229looked at as we're trying to get in the way you're handing that would that be fair or they come to the board in the aggregate I think you know a category of donation we give to you know this art supplies we donate this we donate that like making sure if we have one school that's donating 200 bucks a year in art supplies and another is donating $20,000 a year that's no that's this is really good feedback and it's helpful um can I just sure one additional thing that I think we've talked about is how do we encourage folks to make donations that are districtwide in benefit so it's not just each PTO thinking only about their school obviously PTO will think about their schools but we can I think a big piece of the equity

230is going to be thinking about shared priorities that our people are excited to fund raise for across schools yeah my thought on that it's just a thought is that that's more of the continued culture conversations and participating so that donations are thought of through that lens because typically they're not they really are thought of as you know the group that that works with the school cuz they're parents and children in school understand that I still say yeah if you don't have an affinity no I love Long Fellow and hatch but um I I is I would give to all the schools if I could but I can understand like people are going to give to where their kids went or where they went and theyve said the communication also comes from their own school I

231mean you're not going to you're not going to put yourself on the PTO email list of everything school so you're not going to even like the you're not part of the conversation and if we I think it I think that's right both of those things are right I also think if if we can work with PTO to articulate districtwide priorities that they could raise money for whether it's field trips or theater or you know I think that something that both plays into their values and gets people excited I think that's going to be important because I don't think we have a mechanism right now for those conversations to happen it is just school by school by school I think you're talking about a fundraising position uh I mean honestly I don't think it is I

232think it could just happen through PTO maybe so we I have a question sure um we've talked a few times in this meeting now and then I know it's come up before about that $500 threshold but I know it's in the policy so we can change that word can change policy and I think spring is when we talk about policy Chang we can change and change it what do you [Laughter] want um I think we may need to just go ahead and do that I mean I think I don't want to thw what you're trying to do but I I think you're right addresses some of the burden I would just want to make sure it aligns to what whatever comes out of this sort of routine process so that we change it in a

233way that they kind of function it together I I think that I think we should change the threshold but I also think we need a mechanism and I think this is going to be on the administrators with their PTO hey this is this is what we did this year this is how our fundraising went these are the donations that we made um and and that be a regular mechanism in all of this and having on that side of things I'm not sure we know if those if those donations fall under that $500 I'm not certain we know about it I know the school Community knows about some that fall above is what we've learned but they do all budgets um well I know ideally I mean honestly this has been drilled into pto's heads about

234going to the board it's interesting so to be fair for those watching the intent really is is it to obstruct any it's to get it understood but my question is I do think that there should be sort of an end of the year report that hey all 10 pto's this is what we did this is what we spent money on um not to be labor intensive but just so that we have an idea of what our schools are doing um maybe and and that's the that's the compromise perhaps of increasing that uh threshold so we're we're not being so burdensome to you but we we do need to know what's going on in the schools right um so because I I agree someone said like we need a little data to know what that number

235should be we I mean maybe there's an in fix where we say something though where we just add like a phrase like anything over $500 get run by the policy committee before I mean if you emailed colen and I we were back board doesn't need to se sandwiches we're good Bo doesn't like do you know can we put in the policy something before we have the data on the Comm that reduces the Fe for full board approval and allows talking about not bringing that to us until he figures has a proposal like that would be to me from my point in the interim what do we do now because our polic but that is the now right I mean we've been not following our policy fine but I'm I'm just saying like so you're just

236saying so this this procedure is already bypassing the policy the current practice is bypassing the policy right which we're trying but we this is a proposal to stop doing that so but we don't want to stop doing that because or else it could take three months to approve sandwiches right but I think what I'm saying and we could do I don't have strong feelings about which way we do it I think what we're saying what Lis is saying tonight is we're not going to apply this process to the routine sandwiches whatever that's happening regardless of the cost of it until we have something to propose in terms of a process for reviewing those donations is that what you're saying I didn't think to full transparency trying to get a grasp of the entire issue in

237its complexity because it's multie there's the threshold piece there's the small donations by PTO there's an approval process by outside parties that don't donate that contribute larger amounts all of that falls under a gift to the district so addressing all of that via the existing policy language we need a starting point to say hey this is what we're going to do so for those that do come before the board like so for example the two that are coming today we want to hit these three things to explain to you this is how the proposed donation does that for the little ones I'm trying to get a grasp of what that means but meaning how often do they occur what dollar amount they are some might be above 500 significantly larger number are under 500 so

238I literally am trying to figure that out and I'm acknowledging it here that we need to do that and what in the and in the interim how is the approval going to come keep coming to the board now when you see them because now we realize we're not following our policy are we trying to follow our policy going forward until or are we going to continue to not follow our policy well as the district's Council I always advise the board to follow its policy and the existing policy has a threshold and if a proposed donation comes I think the administrative team would be proposing that to the for to accept or deny so that's right that's the okay we need to give very clear messaging to the PTO that are listening to this if you

239are saying anything over 500 goes through this process people are going to be very unhappy with that my understanding please correct me if I'm wrong of what we are saying tonight is that anything that is routine or regular that the PTO are currently doing whether it's above or below $500 will not go through this process until we have figured out an appropriate right-sized mechanism for those things to be reviewed we are put another way we are not now saying to pto's if your sandwiches cost $510 put them through the five-step process So my answer to that is no because we don't know what that means or at least I don't in my discuss I don't even know how many when you say no no I'm wrong or I don't know what so when you're saying

240the donations that rise above I don't know what kind of donations are what I'm saying is if tomorrow if tomorrow a PTO wants to buy sandwiches and the sandwiches cost $510 are you saying they have to go through this process to buy the $510 of sandwiches or are you saying that's a routine slre donation that we don't yet have have a process for and so until we have a process for it go ahead and buy your sandwiches I am saying the latter we don't have a process for that and therefore you do not have to go through this process you can go ahead and buy your sandwiches yes and I would also like to share that I think that's part of the confusion and The Angst I still think we're going to get confusion about

241routine and regular I well I mean we have to define those things I'm just trying to make clear to folks because I think this is the fear that PTO have is they do all these things on a regular basis that can't go through a monthlong approval process and what they're going to want to know when they watch this is do those things have to go through this process and I just want to make sure that for now the clear answer is no yes we are trying correct just say just no yes no to you yes no no no caveats no and what would go ahead would it be feasible back to the categories idea for them to come with some some categories in terms of like what is um regular or normal business whatever we're

242calling it um and then we we look at that or you you look at that whoever looks at that to say sandwiches that's regular um art supplies art supplies that's regular um hand sanitizer or band those are regular face painter for the vendors for I think you're right I think I think it for now we're not going to like some of this has to happen now because donations are happening now but I think you're right we have to figure out those things going forward so can we like just and and I'm on that committee so maybe the next and we don't have a scheduled next meeting but maybe we say um can you submit before the end of the year some General categories right your most used categories however they want to come up with

243it the next one they share that with us and then we say that sounds reasonable or if they're like we want to buy lipstick oh wait that ain't that's not take that off no Sephora for you so so so to that point to to the point because other people not buying lipstick and I guess I guess what I'm going with this is I think we can come up with some top level things like it is something that has happened annually for the last few years it is something that does not require District cost to be added to it but my thing is to let them come up with that because they know and while we're doing that it's business is usual right because that will take time and Lise if you see something that you're

244like oh I don't know there's like seven people that have 60,000 others in the we're here we have yeah no and I appreciate that the discussion the tus went up but I really am as picking this up again really trying to understand the nature of the issue and part of what you're sharing those are all of the considerations that this document is trying to address and we are not there yet as far as being completely done while we're moving along this giving Continuum I would that board approved donations May reasonably take three months is not reasonable to me so oh see let's work on not let's work on that making it shorter yes okay that's fair just I mean why and I'm not saying right now I'm saying as we're building this plane let's keep

245that in mind as a feature so goal to shorten the time yes first class and the more time you have the more time you fill up which means people are working really hard for like on something that like that's one one of the reasons I worry about folks spending so much time on something that might not yeah we don't want to have administrators spending like reviewing 500 donation requests every month let let us take the feedback that you've given and come back I mean it could be a tiered approach I hear like three different things I hear like um denus when you're talking about the report there could be a pre-approval at the be like a blanket for these kinds of things routine staff appreciation whatever it is in the beginning of the year share

246us with us what you're going to do at the end of the year give us a report so we know just kind of for that Fidelity of transparency and resource Equity then maybe there are some things that fit in the middle Holly this your idea like they go to the policy committee for a quick email review and then there are the things that have the big review um because they're significant and we need to wrestle with them you know something like that so may we can think about there's a couple reports mentioned in the process I don't think they need to be made bullet points or nice right like there like a isn't there a form the form's not helpful and Sheree you uh what you're saying is engage the PTO C when we meet

247with them in that kind of what could that what's in those different tiers and categories and I will say um that getting the PTO budgets I think will be very revelatory in some ways just I've seen one and I would and there's some like line it in it that are like oh like they're spending a lot of money on X or Y um so I think that'll help us inform like this notion of tiers and categories and areas where there might be um more prominent Equity concerns okay great good and that's my report thank you yeah thank you thanks thanks for the importance all right um next we have the the consent agenda I got a motion move board approve agenda yes hary yes Burns yes stock yes K yes joh yes yes motion excellent

248U action item 9.1 non nonunion employee increases I moov Bo of Education District 97 approve the not administrator employe compensation is outl in the memo dated December 4th 2024 one question is that memo been published to the community yes okay great I have a second question which is it the memo says that the increase is retroactive to the beginning of the school year yes it does yes great it's actually the first sent it's the first sentence in the memo below are the proposed retroactive 2024 to 25 I'm not sure how that was supposed to be anyone second second car yes Kim yes yes yes yes yes yes all right uh action item 9.2 2024 tax levy I'm going to read this motion but I do want to so I moov that the Board of Education

249District 97 approved the T certificate of tax levy and Associated resolutions providing for the adoption of the 2024 tax levy second I just want to make one comment before we vote and that is there are some questions that came up on social media and just want to clarify a couple things one of the questions was why do we do this in December when it's a really busy time for families and to them to people that may not have been paying attention since September when we started talking about the budget it felt like it came on kind of suddenly so the levy is due to be filed with the state on the last Tuesday of December the last Tuesday of December is December 31st so we try to file it on the last Tuesday that we're

250in the buildings which means that we always approve this on the December meeting in order to finally do that we also have a conversation starts with the budget conversation in September it proceeds with a levy presentation in November and I think we talk about the levy three possibly four sometimes times and the budget between September and December um the other question that came up was why why are is there a tax increase in this time 3.4% and um the the just reminding everyone of the pel law pel law that says that we can raise um the TA the tax levy by CPI or 5% whichever is lower um the reason that CPI is used is because it's industry standard and in the market that most collective bargaining Agreements are um structured with CPI B aligned

251raises in order for boards to kind of have an understanding of what a contract that might go out for two three four five years um be able to project finances um that's why this number tends to align with CPI the other thing that happens our budget is about 70% salary and benefits and for our staff and our including all the staff teachers administrators and um Opa custodians um but also all the other things that make up the other 30% of the budget um CPI is a number that's used to show how much inflation affects your average bills that includes Transportation um out of school placement for tuition I mean the electric bill supplies like all of the things um that kind of go up on an annual basis by approximately that much and so every

252year when you look at it and see what CPI is um that is a way for us to maintain balance thank you so much H Ren yes hary yes Burns yes starlock yes Kim yes yes Johnson yes more yes all right action item 9.3 summer program access to elbra um I would like to propose that we hold off on this because we got new information yesterday um so in the interest of like having an opportunity to ask some additional questions and for everyone to have thorough time to review all the new information that was presented but that the some of the questions that were asked um I would like to hold off I propose we hold off so my only question is from a funding perspective can we hold off I do believe holding will

253interrupt our timeline for implementation because we are talking about a spring and summer implementation so if we were not to take action today um we we won't make our timeline for communication and and implementation are there questions we could try to answer now that that are still on your mind I just want to make sure that everyone's had time so we got that we got additional information at six o'clock yesterday so I know there was there was just a lot of questions and confusion and things that we wanted to clear up so if if everyone feels comfortable but I know there were conversations yesterday there there were still questions and we were still discussing stuff so um I just wanted to make sure that we have space for any additional conversations or questions can I

254ask a question so I have a couple questions but I think Emily or Edy someone probably can answer them um to get to the point about this but I do think that a lot of the questions that are being generated about our math curriculum generally and so maybe an alternative because this is $20,000 I'm not trying to minimize $20,000 but from a funny perspective and the big picture it might not be I I don't know when we talk about the January 14th um agenda perhaps one of the things that are on here because this is a big heavy agenda maybe you know an overview of the math curriculum is appropriate for that because there's some confusion there I'm just just to clarify this does not change the math curric it doesn't but that doesn't mean

255that there is a whole bunch of questions about they got conflated I just want to make sure people understand so because this doesn't affect it and maybe some of us have some questions that are really isolated to this maybe we can get through those questions and still get the 20,000 approved for your to the point of timing and funding so it's not back till January 14th but I don't think we should lose sight of the fact that our math curriculum has generated kind of some confusion and just people yeah yeah so what I think that's a a great recommendation we can bring forward on January 14th um you know an overview of the math Pathways and of our math you know our our approach to math also how we're syncing with oprf and responding to

256some of the data that they have been giving that actually we need to make sure that students are standards based ready as you know as they advance in math and so we'd be happy to you know address that question uh on the January agenda because even um the comment tonight and highly you respond on like this is the trend people are saying like I can't get into college and so I don't want students walking away um who may have heard this while they were playing a video game and their parent was watching this I don't want them to walk away saying oh I have to double accelerate or this is not going to be I'm not going to be able to do this so I think just like making this a little bit more clear

257and any communication like even if it's um I'm happy to go to schools talk to pto's talk to parents whatever it is but I do think the the miscommunication is I want this to be successful I want people to feel good about this I want teachers to feel good about this and if there's so much confusion and people are like I heard this I think this I did you hear this that they're going to like make kids start subtracting different a whole different way um we should be able to answer that question and be like no but at this point I will honestly say and I'm speaking for myself if someone asked me a question I'll be like I'm not sure so I want to feel confident as um a Community member of liaison whatever

258you want to call it um so I just want a little bit more clarification so we can sort this all out we can do that and bring It Forward on January 14th we ask some Summer Bridge questions absolutely so can I finish up that's piece first because I um so just as part of that making sure I think you mentioned this but just what the full pathway is because math is so impactful at the end of the road as well so you can't just stop at the end of Middle School it does need to really carry through on what this impacts in high school um and math is just already has a reputation for being hard when it should be lovely so the more we can actually have people understand the process and not be

259stressed by the process of math and the the flow and to that point if we could also this might require a lot of coordination in a month but I'd be really curious how this Stacks into how math is changing at 200 because like it's weird because I have kids back to back and they're going to be in totally different math tracks because of where they start I mean also one kid's accelerating the other one's not um but even she's been asking like can I accelerate before 9th grade and I was like I I don't know like like I don't even know what you're supposed to be doing next year because it's a different math curriculum um and so like that level of continuity because even for the kids who are going to be accelerated or

260double accelerated next year like I don't know what that means for those kids cuz like the curriculum is changing and so um yeah that would be helpful I think for yeah that was my ask that we if we could have a one of the Math teachers from the high school um and maybe even one of the kids who were in The cohort to talk about their experience um that would be super helpful cuz I think just I've had the privilege of having someone explain it to me but I'm still confused I'm not going to lie double accelerated what do well they were just like this is what you need to do and then here are your choices so like understanding like what my choices are as a result of this change like are my is

261it still the same what's happening at the high school because there's a welcome to the high school event that Jung and I are not at tonight um so I'm missing all that information so it would be helpful to like understand like what our choices are when we get to the high school um and what that impacts now so if if it all possible I know that's a big ask in a little bit of time yeah I I think it's important and again um I I think it's important that and you said this but we're not bringing forward any changes our math curricul is not due for a change for two more years what we have changed in terms of integrated math is to sync up with oprf so that we have that continuity because even

262in some of the language it's like talking about ninth grade math 10th grade math that's not how we talk about math it's actually talking about standards based courses and that's one thing that was different before we were having a situation where students were like just being Advanced to a different course but what was being missed that was were they ready as measured by the standards so in addition to it's important to get different perspectives because we also got a um you know feedback from a parent whose student W you know did Advance Through Math that way that said wow if I would have known it really damaged my student because what it did was like you're Advanced you're Advanced and actually then it damaged the students understanding of themselves and their feeling of competence in

263math so we want to be careful when we're talking about it to make sure that we're talking about standards based instruction and we're making sure we're thinking about kids students motivation for math as opposed to some of the language around acceleration actually more about adult stuff sometimes about wanting the kids to move through a course and that's not how we think about it and our colleagues at oprf we want to follow their lead they're setting a bar around standards and some of the feedback they've been giving us has been you're sending us kids that aren't appropriately prepared for the courses that they're being assigned to so that was some of the feedback that I I did receive but I think like sharing that so that parents watching this can have that to say I was

264told that they that some of these kids are not they're missing like the foundation but I think to your point even about the language like we're I'm still saying my son's a ninth grade manth because the language this is the language that I have been you know up with but yeah because it's like he skipped he skipped this grade and then he tested into you know the next grade so we we think about these things in terms of like grades so I never say like my son um is taking algebra I'm saying he's taking ninth grade math um cuz I don't know what the choices are in the high school it's been 100 years since I was in high school so I think just having someone here to say these are the courses that are

265available at the high school um this is what you would take you know just very high level but I think for a parent like I I was like so close to not coming tonight cuz I was like I need to know like what's happening with my son when he goes into the high school next year um so I know I wrote somebody that's going to be recording for those people who are watching who did not attend tonight there's going to be a recording but I think like making that connection I think to nany's point making that connection is really critical so that you don't have um students really I I have to do this but they understand there's a pathway if you just keep along your path that you're on now I can read the

266couple of points that you sent us just so that we're Crystal Clear access to algebra is an access pathway not an acceleration pathway I'm going to repeat that access to algebra is an access pathway not an acceleration pathway every d97 student matriculating to D200 regardless of math advancement has the opportunity to be on track to take calculus at D200 before high school graduation we are committed to providing high quality standards based instruction to all students we are committed to listening to feedback from all key stakeholders to continue to evolve our programs we are committed to ensuring that all our students are properly prepared for high school and yeah um the only thing I want to clarify and we should just clarify is I know but I'm not I I don't know if that's 100% accurate

267without summer summer school so it it they have the opportunity if they do the Bri so if they don't but to clarify on that if if you just you know what I'm doing what I'm doing I don't want to do bridge then you would have to take um summer school and high school but as a district offering that access we're still offering but but that's important to know that's important not every kid can go to so it's important if summer school is required to access it when you're in high school just be clear on the high school side not on on the district on d97 but yes those kind of clarifications are what it would be nice to see in the overview of what's going on just I said that because I wanted to try

268to calm some of the um families out there that might be upset or confused because of some previous information that was said we're going to go into detail as we said for our January meeting but I I wanted to try to um reduce the misinformation that was out there that's my I appreciate that thank you Venus and again you can we'll bring it in January it wasn't here because we weren't changing any curriculum if you know those are all questions relevant when you are actually making curriculum and course Chang changes that's not what's happening here right and that's an important distinction nevertheless if there's a need to clarify information let's do that can we ask a couple summer is anyone else I have just a few summer questions anyone else want to do it from

269there I don't blame you go ahead go ahead up here um okay so one of the things and I I didn't see a difference here one of the parts of yes she should go up there because my way this is the same person that was back there I was talking um okay so one of the questions was the original proposal talked about this taking place in school in sore yes and one of the questions I had I think that there are some kids that really depend on sore to get their work done and to see their teachers and to drop off things so um so a kid that might be really ready to accelerate in math or not to have access algebra through this program but that could cause them not to be able to

270finish their other work so then parents and that student feels kind of the anxiety of choosing between like are my other grades going to suffer so can I do this and I know that there was maybe some contemplation of maybe some other places to to schedule it maybe using advisory or academic onore have you guys contemplated that and kind of figured out a way to get let kids have both the opportunities to work on their homework and consult teachers and do makeup stuff and do math so I think and I think that we can take this on a so nothing is changing right now for the middle school students so it has always taken place during the day for sure but I think that if families are feeling that stress like we want this to

271be available to everybody like I encourage them to reach out to their school the principal you know myself and we can certainly plan for each student individually um I think scheduling like to say that that's that that that we're just going to do that and move everybody around I think would be a nightmare for the middle schools in general but I think if families are concerned about missing this you know sore because of academic concerns then yes reach out let's talk about it let's problem solve let's see how that works for your student can you prepare people to middle schools to of course CU they might not know right they might be like sorry it's only sore right like just because they're not listening to the absolutely at 11 yes and each sore each student

272feels different about sore and how they're approaching it and there yes and so we want to make sure in the same vein that some students have um an IEP and are receiving IEP minutes during that time we don't want them to not have access so we do encourage people to reach out because this is not a program that wants to eliminate access for anybody okay it's the it's the opposite and in that having that conversation we want to make sure that the parent and the student understand the impact and how important it is to be on this Pathway to algebra by 8th grade or to integrate in math one and so we'd want to figure out how to meet those other needs and and and prioritize this if that's what the family's looking for okay

273so can I segue off of that quick quickly Holly because it's related to your question I would love it um just to clarify this year not next year but this year this 20,000 it is only third trimester sore and it goes into summer still so yeah so this 20,000 is for this year is primarily for our summer programming to hire staff and then it's to hire a coordinator that would oversee trimester 3 and summer because we're moving fifth grade uh uh fifth grade the bridge course from outside of school to inside of the school we will no longer need staff outside of um to teach it after school and we'll no longer need Transportation so we're decreasing the cost but that 20,000 is for a coordinator for trimester 3 and summer and then just the

274summer teaching staff that would teach those three weeks over the for the oh we're still doing summer this year just this year that's why I wanted to I thought it was getting next year is when it shifts next year is when it Shi because it's shifting to trimester 2 and trimester 3 and since trimester 2 started in November we but we couldn't it was just it was we didn't have a turnaround to be able to do it this year so we're moving in we're doing in a stage where we're moving fifth grade to during the day this year to match their sixth and seventh grade peers and then everyone will still do summer and then next year everyone fifth through seventh grade will move during trimester 2 and trimester three during the day so there

275will be no after school or summer portion so that we're increasing access across the board so if someone can't do the summer do you still recommend them signing up to do trimester 3 weeks so that they can get some of this you like to ask the hard questions H um would I recommend that's really hard because the requirement is that they have to pass the end of course exam with an 80% or higher and when they're missing summer they are missing a significant portion of the curriculum and so that is a decision that the family and the student needs to make because they would have to take the test early and they would be missing that instruction so I I don't know if I would blanketly say yes still sign up but I also we

276also have data that shows that kids that participate in the uh Bridge class really just end up fearing better whether they pass or they don't pass and so if we just want extra support then yes sign up but if you're looking for the purpose to access algebra to move on to the next level of math it might be fairly Difficult by missing three full weeks of instruction and so we're also eliminating the independent program which I agree with but can we provide some list of Standards some recommended materials to families who want to do it on their own um I my kid did the independent so I like firstand knowledge it's like literally just the books I agree with ending it but do we have something that we can do pass on to a tutor

277or a family member that's a math teacher or an older sibling that's really good at math where they could still have this opportunity if they can do the summer we don't currently we are not currently set up to provide that information I mean we could certainly always provide the standards um and we can certainly provide the workbooks that we give the student but that is what we did for independent studying it was showing that it wasn't very effective um so I don't know I wouldn't even ask for just any supports for the families because this is um as someone who's a planner like not being able to tell my child like what to study we tell kids to practice whatever you're doing you're practicing Bravo my daughter is in the mirror all darn day practicing

278lines and singing so the same I think would apply to math like you have to practice and if you have like oh you're going to practice Algebra but like what part of algebra what am I going to be tested on I think that it's so important because it was just like I'm grabbing for straws here like I went to the Illinois math website whatever it was printed out all those pages was like just do it all and myself was like and it's summertime and he has other things and I was like I don't care just do all these worksheets do all these sample problems I don't think none of that stuff he did was on the test so I think like just being very like um intentional if we're going to set Folks up for

279Success like giving them the tools necessary well and that was going to be my next question do we and just to add it so you don't answer it twice um you know I I people said that they like practice tests and like like a lot of like things to prepare that the test doesn't really like the test is kind of surprising content wise to kids it doesn't align to actually what they are doing every day in the frge course has that changed at all are we giving practice tests so that kids know what they're seeing I mean every single I I just feel like the the format isn't the same and they're we're teaching standard we're teaching in a standards and then they're getting tested and it doesn't line up to what they learned um

280I can assure you as somebody who has gone in depth with all of these materials that we do have study guides that we use that are actually the same test questions with like different numbers like so they are exposed to the format of the test through the study guide um I we can certainly make a commitment so one of the commitments we're already making is to make the we do send progress monitoring um notes home to families but we are going to make sure that they're more standards aligned we're going to make sure that they're coming home on a more regular basis so that families do know what's happening in class uh we're going to one other commitment that we can make is to make sure that the materials go home teachers often say you

281know like you can take this workbook home we're done working out of this and then it's really kind of up to students whether the workbook goes home or it sits in their locker you know uh goes right into the recycling bin The Works don't have answer keys they're not very they don't but the kids that are going through the bridge class will have that work in there with that they've worked on through with a teacher and so their their work should be in there and updated and correct and they're also receiving the study guides uh they are going over those in class so we are going to I mean we we're going to continue to train our staff um we are pushing for more having more um of our Math teachers um we're working to

282try to encourage more of our Math teachers from our math department to work over the summer we do recognize and understand that there is a there is a change from when students go from third trimester to summer because they're changing staff they're change there is a break in consistency there is sometimes a break in teaching styles like oh I really like this teaching style and I'm struggling more with this teaching style and that's kind of the another push I mean the first push is access that's another push to moving it into trimester 2 and trimester 3 for continuity and consistency throughout the entire program that they are learning from the same teacher that parents know who to reach out to at the same time so that we can can kind of take some of this

283these issues that are coming up where families feel disconnected and to make them feel more connected and I'm just going to add in again because you opened it up to the semester 2 and 3 piece to please next year when you're looking at that don't just layer the math classes think about it as a whole continuity with just more time yes well there will be a little bit because they will be learning in their math class I hear what you're saying but in their like if they're a sixth grader they'll taking math six and they are learning math Six standards but the bridge class that they would be participating in would be math 7 so they will be learning seventh grade standards so there will be some continuity but there might also feel sometimes that

284there is some layering because they're moving through that at a condensed in Faster pace so that they can um get that information for that end of bridge um but we will try our best to make sure that it doesn't feel very disjointed but there might be some points where it it does because they're learning different standards and skills over time and this might be asking too much for next year recognizing um considering it a joint math 67 class that just gets expanded in those last two semesters with time you would be able to have continuity of going through six and seven more rapidly and this is don't we don't need to debate this right now that's that's longer term and nobody want it's already 11 o'clock we don't need to go into that fair enough

285but um yeah call for the vote are we good with voting on this tonight or and then next meeting we'll do the more deeper dive into the pathways yeah so then we need a motion we had a motion and we second we didn't say the mo motion we didn't say this motion we stopped we paused but you can do it you look ready I promise you we said the motion because it's everybody repeat after me vus is we did we second it yes I second all right you get this one no it's the call it's the roll call I think we read the motion it's been a while since read the motion again okay I move that the Board of Education of O Park Elementary School District 97 moves to approve the access to algebra

286summer bridge program budget not to exceed $2,974 for school year johnon yes your is that me we should make a correction the mo should be oh gosen yes yes for sy25 yes Spurlock yes more zi yes Kim yes yes all right thanks Emily thank you next up for discussion and action item 10.1 by Elementary PTO donation yes give it all pck Robinson's coming up or this the board has a memo um if you have any questions we don't I don't know if we need a discussion we till 11:05 I moved at the board of education of Oak Park Elementary School District 97 moveed to approve the buy PTO donation of $4,644.00 K yes Burns yes Spurlock yes Kim yes yes yes Mo great uh so that takes us to discussion items item 11.1 black Excellence

287education donation so uh eony and Patrick can come up with their questions I haven't seen any have we seen any materials I yeah there's a memo in the yeah oh MRI abue will speak to it and then we'll make sure that you have I'm sure it's there and we're just discussing this no way it's discussion and then action in Janu yes awesome um so we just wanted to talk through a donation request that we received from an anonymous ster in the amount of $10,000 um and they have a vested interest in making sure that we um actualize our it policy by thinking about Innovative programming um for our district local court and our local student local c local school local CTS sorry after 11 o' it starts my apologies um so the goal here would

288be um for teachers to submit Innovation proposals um that are aligned to the portrait that take place at during out of school time um that really think about high levels of student cognitive engagement that maintain that Family School partnership um and also one that's flexible enough to respond to whatever that need might be um at the same time monitoring progress over time so teachers would essentially submit proposals um in this vein and the donation would be used to support that and I'll turn it over to Patrick to talk through how it actually fits um the criteria that Louise share with us so when we think about the first criteria um The Proposal being inclusive so one of the recommendations for a successful project proposal as outline um that eony just got done talking about is

289making sure that Innovative programming that serves students both districtwide and local meaning the school um will be based on an imperative outline in our Equity policy and is supported by our district data um the second one um making sure that it supports the district or School priorities um the donation will be utilized to support um students um that are that at the district and at schools that have been identified in need of additional support programs to address our students that are at most need um uplifting um that will uplift the student body as a whole and then the Third um meaning is there any additional um costs to the district this budget there will this proposal there will be no additional calls um to the district because everything will be covered within the donation being

290provided by the donator so I appreciate that you went the criteria but we don't have what is what is we don't have any kind of background so applying criteria to something that we haven't seen what is the what are we applying it to I just res shared it oh I'm sorry yeah that's okay I just don't I just yeah that doesn't I maybe it's me but I can't I can't click on anything yeah we didn't have access to it CU I think I tried to click on it earlier or now we do but okay so essentially it provides the ability for teachers to craft Innovative programming that addresses um our district and school local cohorts um around an area they identifi in the academic realm um and then it meets to all those hars it

291is and it is out of school programming it is out of school program it's School programming and is it for one person like one scholarship sponsorship or multiple so it would be likely um so for example say it was it's an elementary school proposal so it could be that a teacher proposes designs curriculum and perhaps from February March 8 that is meant to support again academic achievement for the district and local school local cohorts um but then also providing entry from other for all elementary schools um to somehow either virtually patch in or to receive the the content but wanting to make sure that it's both Innovative and inclusive but focused on something that is identified by what our district data is telling us is a need um on the in the academic realm so

292is there a window a like a proposal window yes yes so so once it is approved um that gives us the ability to actually advertise it with our teachers and we want them to come up with this kind of proposal and we hope to within that month um finalize and and come up with um just approve a plan that they've kind of proposed and then to start um in this spring in this spring there's going to be um a cap per application like you can only apply for up to $3,000 to try to disperse the amounts or like one person's going to get all $10,000 or I think it it could be a combination of all those depending on what we think might be most impactful um and then also meets those these criteria so

293we don't want to look at a 10,000 proposal that requires us to then put on another 10 to make sure that so um it would just depend on kind of them hitting the Hallmarks that we've outlined and kind of The Proposal requirements but also true to um the donor requirements and and how is are we I mean I guess I negotiations on the brain are we using like $10,000 as like um based on the amount of time it is uh is that based on materials if there it's a onetime event for 200 kids or is it a weekly event for two kids so though they can be any range of anything there's no on the from a quantity like quantity like quantifiable slave like so we want maximum so we don't want to see a

294class of two children when we're talking about a focal cohort that is probably more than that so we'd be looking for something that it is at least obviously maintaining sort of a small group to make sure that it is impactful but not a group to students um so we do want Maximum Impact for the dollar and I know this is this is like a really negotiating question does this go through the district and affect TRS and 6% or is it a gift that comes from the donor directly and doesn't go through us and affect their salary I think that's a great question so um yeah we can let's get that answered we did I don't think we contemplated that I don't really matters just as long as we don't mess up question can I ask

295a question okay you thinking I'm not done I think you might not be done um so I are we asking the teachers in their proposals for measurable outcomes anticipated outcomes and plan to we'll evaluate and see if they met that those their goals and their criteria and that's built into this Innovation proposal template asking them to think about that and I think finding that right balance like ebony was referring to like not two students but also sometimes offering some Boutique experiences to a small group that you know all it doesn't always always have to be 30 either high impact can be a you know whatever n number of students you know but like a meaningful experience that's tailored to them so I think that's the other thing about Innovation we want to be a little

296bit open to see what things people come up with you know and and I I know that we want to avoid number three but I wonder if just so that you encourage a wide range of teachers from less seasoned to more experience to want to participate maybe it is worth it to say there will be a administrative Mentor or administrative thought partner that can help walk you through that even though that would be adding time to somebody that's a district resource just because or else might it might become less intimidating that way someone might be more willing to take it on if they know they have someone that will at least talk about it yeah I we definitely Che for yeah and I'm glad you raised that like what's I think that's important maybe we

297need to distinguish what's talked about here is like you know if an administrator is going to spend a bunch of time doing soil sampling and getting quotes for something that's different than an administrator supporting in this way I don't think that's what's being talked about in in number three there what's the process for approval so if I say I want to do a skating class um like how do you how do you quantifi like what's impactful so to your point like you want to be creative so I just found out Brooks has Double Dutch or a jump roping class um or Club so to me like I was super excited like oh this is awesome but like how would you define like this criteria meets this because people be trying stuff and so like we

298don't want someone saying like we're going to have a cleanup club and this is going to help black kids give me $3,000 so I think clear is kind so that's why we wanted to make sure that we kind of go through what we're looking for what Hallmarks of a good proposal stand out for us so again making sure there's part to the line that IT addresses an academic um kind of need or strength um and that we think about this idea cognitive engagement that we're designing things that kids are interested in and really kind of not just meets behavioral engagement but has them thinking about how to use these skills Beyond just this space um takes place at school um but then also has like this Family Partnership and communication component um I think we're

299just referencing so that we're actually bringing folks in and then um also designing for making sure that we're flexible and how we deliver so as we're thinking about because even though this is not this is a novel design we still want to be able to be memble enough to if something isn't working um despite our best efforts that we're able to to Pivot and then um also think about how to progress monitor so we want to be clear about what we're asking at the beginning and so as you're receiving the proposals and evaluating them um that everyone is clear on what it is that we're looking for and also measurable outcomes too so you have to have measurable outcomes and not just something crazy that you're just putting in your proposal yeah I can be

300I can make myself a club um and then who is there committee or is there one single person who approved no my committee um it wouldn't yeah we wouldn't want to just do it um in isolation so we want to make sure that we get a number of different key points looking at the process could we also have them present their findings somewhere whether it's at their school PD or let's say someone takes all $10,000 like they could come before the board I think that would be helpful to kind of share what people have come out with we we actually thought about actually using this to kind of tell a story yeah around like doing something Innovative and kind of like telling the story or kind of telling the journey along the way and so

301using that as a way to kind of start something new so if this is if this Innovative proposal works this is something that we can kind of start throughout our district um and so we actually thought about doing that exact same way and if there is a program of Promise like how do you think about how do we replicate yeah and is this a one time or do you get the S it's an annual or just a one okay it's a one time as far as we point okay they would be interesting like I was just looking at uh uic's Institute for racing policy or whatever irpp is and um public policy and they actually have like a they actually have kind of a similar program for social justice Educators I think so um in

302all your free time it would be nice if you could create a list of resources for teachers who are interested uh maybe not just math but like other places where teachers can't apply for funds for kind of this in Innovative kind of work um I'm sure someone's made a resource list somewhere um so hopefully it won't be a ton of work for you but it's kind of nice because I think sometimes like teachers often think like I'll just go to donor's choose which is not really the most sustainable or you know um and so it would be nice if there were options for teachers who don't do math or who don't make this cut but they're interested in looking at other uh funding Revenue sources as community and teachers as community and teachers that are

303already doing it they might have rather than want to do Google yeah but I think there's also a certain level of prestige to to have like a funding group tied to back we have a lot of professors uhhuh and I'm not I'm not giving do we have any more questions for foran I'll argue with you later be very wary of any application from Shar oh we don't have a mo we don't motion all right okay thank you both than thank you Patrick I'm glad you had a reason to stay this slate uh all right next up 11.2 sy2 C budget Authority yeah agree this yeah this is I'm I'm Sheila you can come up here because you're here I'm not trying to take your Ste your thunder this is just the annual authority to start

304talking about the budget that's up I approve we're just discussing we're just discussing any questions no no all right um that only thing I will is to the my point about the levy it'll be nice to publish the date of our budget conversations are in here we can highlight them so we can then tell people remain all right 12.1 board remarks that's my board remark I wa any others um I have one board remark I think we need to be a little in I all of us um we had a really great and robust discussion about access to Al at 11:00 knowing that it was a hot button in the community um we should have moved it up earlier in the agenda and just made an amendment to the agenda that's it what would you

305have kicked out because actually I think we K having substantive convers my point is tonight we just had a really needy agenda I'm not sure there was any place to move it because we were talking about diverse Workforce about giving like what do you think deserve less Cog right today was just a we got through everything on the agenda is your think more people about math than the other things cares more about algebra than Workforce diversity I would not I said move I said move the agenda I did not say um take something off when we considering where to put it the agenda only my point in saying this is since you all are all over me um when we have something such a when we have something that is a Hot Topic we need

306to be considerate and talk about it a little bit earlier fair enough and making that and I will say like once the agenda goes out if anybody sees something that's feels like it's buried too much please let us know and we can or the people that set the agenda see that it was I mean if we thought it was too much we would have moved it up already so all right I have one thing to say so when we talk about like all the um from your superintendent comments so thank you I appreciate that and I think it um I hope that people find it helpful to hear from you from that but to that point about um all the changes that we're making I think it starts with like education and having a shared

307language about some of the terms that we use so I think people often get Equity like really confused yes and I also think like the policy so when the um Dad came today and talked about that so so um my daughter was also a c n word a couple of weeks ago and so I was like what is the policy like what happens and so I was able to get a really good like followup and like you know they explain to me what happened but I do find it troubling that their inconsistency is that this Dad did not get followup I did get followup when I was talking to the the staff member they were like they he and then they T to stud's name and my daughter had already told me the name um

308so like like having a consistent policy so or process so that if you know it happens to someone else I can say oh that was my experience too um but then also like that piece around the restorative piece of it so my daughter did not have to apologize and I would have raised all types of hell if she did but she was like you know when they walked away the little boy was like don't you ever speak to me again and he was like I'm I know had to get away with things and he was send all the stuff to her and so I was like it was restored there right so it wasn't it was like they sat there they had the conversation and you know most times kids don't want to be the

309they don't want to tell on their friends she like begged me not to and I was like this is important because of these things like this is a Learning lesson so we had the conversation but I bring all that up to say that it's not just to like don't say that word apologize to her like I think it has to be more than that because let's just be honest at middle school that kid's going to walk away and he's going to call her all types of names he going to tell her friends she's going to be further ostracized luckily I told her I will come up there but um don't be that parent I will be that parent but no um all jokes aside I was I was appreciative that I got the Outreach I

310think that every parent should have that what I don't like though is that this kid walked away like this girl is a jerk and he's GNA tell his friends and then she's GNA face potentially further like stuff and she's not going to tell me um and that was really really hard because I was like on the one hand I could ignore this but on the other hand I want her to know that sometimes you're going to have hard conversations you're going to have to like do hard things so it was me like trying to teach her a lesson so I would like to see a something more than that like little minute restor um conversation and then also she was like really mad she was like they took me out of design and now I'm

311going to be behind so like just being more thoughtful about how we're boring classes can I add to that I know that we're g to we we have PD but I is there I mean one of the comments was like how do you I don't know we're all a lot of us do have to do corporate training right there's all these corporate training if you're sitting in a room and someone says something inappropriate these are your choices you can disrupt you can distract I don't know there's like three of them or whatever do we have some kind of like even a a video resource or a popup that we could get to teachers kind of quickly for name for name calling like if someone uses a name and I'm not talking jerk a a racial

312slur a homophobic slur a any kind of ethic I mean these if this happens in your classroom or you are in the presence of kids that start doing this this is what you do like totally prescriptive we can have a conversation about it we can explore it we can have all kind right now I think I feel like and I was there was a coach that had that my kid was on this team and it happened and this coach didn't know what to do and I called him and I was like listen I think you might I know you're not quite sure what to do this is my he's like oh my God thank you for telling me next day he called a meeting and he just did it and we didn't have to have

313like because he just needed someone to say to give him some help and I just feel like it's if we could find a literally we probably could buy like a 15minute this is what you say when this kind of harassment or name calling happens so that teachers have something to immediately because that's the important thing right immediately I think that that gets tricky because there's also like a certain level of publicizing for the kid that's like that's already been attacked totally so like I I was a little uncomfortable with like there should be a whole like educational moment I'm like no kid wants to be an educational moment like but no one knows that that kids so for me also what I I found troubling was that no one called me until I reached out

314so when I asked my daughter I said what are the steps she said I tell a trusted adult she told two trusted adults so it's like you do all that you tell your kid what to do and then they're like still nothing happened so then I got involved much to her like she was really peeved about it so but I do think that had there been an assembly no one would know that it was my daughter who was involved but I think it's like I I'm not saying you should feel that shame but sometimes you have to be uncomfortable so if I said you know J I don't like your shirt then we have a conversation about bullying and talking about shirts no one will know that I said something to you but I will

315be like I know I said something about her shirt um and also like letting parents know we're going to have this conversation um like when something happens the parents should know how to deal with that because my daughter was holding that in for the whole time it wasn't I think I was on the phone with vus telling her about something and my daughter said yeah someone come meetwh I was like wait what let call you back so to know that she was going around with that um was super hurtful so I'm like I should have been notified so I could have dealt with it or not but then also like other parents need to know like these are the conversations we we're going to have an assembly or whatever it is so they can have

316we're going to have the conversation in the CL this happened in our classroom and tomorrow we're going to talk about it because it's not acceptable some just I guess some tools is the point and we can't wait for an Institute day and it doesn't have to be all day it can be a shorter popup type of like let's figure out how to people so that that does I think like at the first level there should be some sort of protocol in terms of like this should be reported to like or title mind person um so we can track it but then there should also be a protocol like when this happens you need do XYZ and I think like situation with like it's different in middle school cuz the kids know what these words being

317like with second graders it gets a lot dodgier right like they know it's a hurtful word they don't always know what it means and they clearly heard it somewhere right um and so I think like that for me I was thinking a lot about we had this anti-racist curriculum but like we didn't really do a lot of that in the elementary schools and that's where sometimes kids learn like the first time I explain racial fls to my kid it wasn't because they had heard it it's because like I knew it was going to come up at some point and I'm like I can't believe I'm teaching my k Regal fls and I think so I think there's something around that of like what are things you might hear in the future that are hurtful and

318whatever and it's preparing kids and I mean that always brings back that conversation of like when you ask white people like when's the first time you thought about race and sometimes people are like in their 40s they're like never right um and so sometimes and so same thing for kids we talk about race and Equity a lot but I don't think sometimes in the little bubble that we live in kids are always aware of what that really means um and I've also been really surprised surprised by how much casual racism my kids have encountered in the middle school so like kids pulling like slanty eyes like that kind of stuff unfortunately because like we talk so much about race like my kids will say something they don't report it and they aren't particularly like they're

319angry but they're not like particularly C about it because they're like they're stupid um which maybe isn't the best but um but also I think like the other thing is that I I I think the bystandard training cuz I'm like how many kids were involved in this and how many kids actually use the word how many kids let that happen right um and so I think the bystandard training I know they talk about this inal but it's like such a weak curriculum sometimes I think the way they talk about it CU I'm a bully according to my children that's what they've learned incl I'm a bully um but I think like the bystandard training stuff is really important because like even my daughter like we've talked a lot about fat shaming and body shaming and

320so she'll call out like kids like and she'll get like upset cuz they're like they don't take it seriously and they know that they should know that's wrong but like she does say something and like how many kids are seeing things and they kind of know they should say something but they don't have the skills they don't have the and if you can't say something there's other ways to do it you can always say hey Venus let's go play over here right I mean you don't have to actually take on race at seven years old you can see someone that has been clearly hurt by something and you can go and play with them somewhere else and that's an okay way to be a good friend but I think to the to the point like

321we need to have a sheer understanding language and like so do our kids and also like I'm just going to call it out um I told my kids like you know you're going to hear different types of kids use the N word um now if you're if your black friend is saying it it's a whole different there's a whole different cultural thing just like with girls I remember being at em Brooks and we would always call each other the b word and it was like Hey and it was like a term of endearment and then I got to like my freshman year my friend was like can you not call me that and I was like we've been doing this like what do you mean so like there are different cultural things I don't know

322if white people do the same but if I I do think like understanding that you know you're going to hear this and I always tell my I always told my kids if you are in a private space with your friends that are black like I don't want you using that word but you have to understand like that is a word you're going to hear you're going to hear it at Family re going to hear whatever but but when you go to school you do not that is not how you interact so if you have a black kid saying I don't care it's in a rap song you can say it that's not acceptable and we need to have that conversation so I know it's uncomfortable cuz my kids are like why can some people say

323some people can't that's just what it is um you know like my cousin was telling me the other day like he he's um he's gay he's like I called you know my friends that but if a straight person were to say that and I was kind of like I get it so understanding those Norms but I just bring all this up to say I think people will use like oh I have allergies that is equity issue that is not I've seen how div CCO has changed since when my son started school to what it is now so being very explicit about these conversations the fact that like so many parents are coming up talking about their kids experience like I think this is something we need to like really focus on I think like saying

324all that thing all the things you said were great but like parents want to feel like something's actually happening I I hear you um here's what I hear and here's what what I owe you a response on number one what are we doing proactively to build that shared language and send the message that this is the expectations here you know and and addressing explicitly like what our values are and what things are off limits to say and why um and the bystander piece what do you do if you hear it walk away just some St strategies teaching that I think the other thing we hear I hear you saying is when something happens what's a protocol so we just haven't agreed upon response piece and then after that also how are we communicating to families

325so what's our shared understanding if we hear something here's what we're going to send out and here's some resources we'll send with uh to families so thinking about what those tools are uh and those responses and then I think the other thing I really want us to think about is when you described Sheree that conversation it's actually not a restorative conversation just because they sat down together there's a whole depth of work thinking about when you're being pulled to have this conversation is part of planning for a restorative conversation because that means I'm not ready it's not the right time for me and it has to be the right time also the prep work around reflection individually before we sit down and some agreements that want to have this conversation and and you know facilitating

326that in a much different way it is not a restor what you described if somebody's walking away making faces that means we didn't do it right and we don't fundamentally understand restorative to be fair they asked her but I think she felt like she had to because I told her like you you need to like have this conversation so they did ask her but I think even to that point like there's a power Dynamic of a teacher saying do you want to do this and you're asking ask these questions so I think like age appropriate rest sort of Justice because if you ask me and I'm like mad I'm be like no but I don't I don't know if I would have had that agency at 11: to say I'm not ready to have this

327conversation um and I wasn't there to be her her advocate um and then the last piece I I do just want to call out cu we talked a little bit about this today like teachers like the things that our black and brown teachers are experiencing in the schools we don't talk about that enough enough um we have heard explicitly like people talk about being retaliated against being targeted and the the treatment that they're experiencing and at the schools um and I think we don't have that conversation enough and so if we're going to talk about like retention people have to feel safe to come and be at work and not feel like you're going to say a joke and then someone's going to like go tell the principal on you so I think as we

328talk about this these processes and procedures like what do you do when you feel like you can't speak your mind or someone is like dismissive of your ideas like all the things we heard in that BT meeting like I walked away like I understand I've had that same experience and so to know that like we're sitting on this board and we heard that and we haven't done anything is um is is just a huge mess up so I think we can end uh I know we're at 10 but I'd like to talk about we haven't done anything and maybe we can address that um at a different time I think um naming that space and and then actually working together to make some changes substantively is what our focuses not to say that there aren't

329other things we need to do but I'd like to revisit that and and talk about what we did do and maybe also what we should do more can I just add one thing to your list of your not on your notes and that was just um making sure our teachers and our school communities are prepared to kind of um teach about how you respond when you witness or are part of or you're the adults and they're the kids and some of these words are used um and then on the restorative practices to your point we heard a little bit about kind of I don't it almost sounds like everyone thinks everyone has to apologize like it's not restorative and sometimes it's just one way sometimes only one person apologize only one messed up and the

330other doesn't have to say I'm sorry what are they saying I'm Sor am missing restor does not mean Mutual apologies to picky back on what hly said um and I was going to say that um there may be some misunderstanding about Resto what restorative means because the victim should not be apologizing to the um perpetrator um and I don't I've now heard about three examples of that so there is something going on well if the perpetrator is not sorry don't don't force like weak apology that's not the point either I don't know what that is but I want to make sure but I want to make sure of that point that that the person who is the victim is restored as much as possible and their trauma is addressed and reduced as much as possible

331additionally when parents get involved and this has happened and their situations of bullying and name calling and these other situations they do want to know what has happened to that child that is not appropriate we cannot share that information and I understand that but I think we can say we have taken I think they're not getting anything I think we need to say taking H do you mean the consequences when you say they're not getting anything meaning the parents we're not going to share with another family what has happened with that student but if we're clear on the process they would already know is it's transparent this person we called their parent we had a conversation with their parent they were told that this is inappropriate behavior period or just we follow procedure there is

332a there will be consequences in in place without going into any detail to protect ourselves whatever we have to say but I think that we build resentment when we just say oh I can't tell you yeah and I don't think we we don't do that you know but we do we in in different situations we have communicated but it may not be the level of detail that um someone is seeking and I think to your point Venus we that's something we just have to you know but we can offer resources and say Here's what you can do here's the next step I will say that um we are often faced with that where we just have to say that is you know it's unsatisfactory because you want to know more but to your point but

333I will say this is where having some policies and procedures on what happens here that are generic to the situation that can be shared okay yes and as far as the kind of no non apology apology or whatever if the person who is supposed to be apologizing clearly doesn't get it but also that's that's like that's their issue it doesn't even have to be dealt with in front of the other student the other student can get support from the adult if the child's aren't ready and then that child though needs some followup right like we can't let if they're just walking away and I mean there's there's clearly still more for them to work out possibly just individually with the social worker with the Student Success coach with whatever else but there is that that

334issue doesn't also have to be done in front of the other student perhaps it can be done away and then later the apology is more sincere and you can come back to it and say you know are you ready now and then you have a better understanding I think there it's a pretty big assumption even with 12 and 13 year olds to assume that they can process what they said why it hurt why it was inappropriate and why they're in trouble and why they shouldn't do that and and like all of their feelings around it so I I think we should give kids that space too and also follow up with the parents as well just on behalf of the child like in a child- centered way we're all working this issue so to just

335quickly email the parents and then you're done um just make space for them to come back if they want so also makes me wonder how many like how much diverse diversity do we have with our social workers like I don't know and so even like their level of like sensitivity and awareness with racial and cultural differences and how to deal with some of this stuff because I think again I think kids can be ret traumatized sometimes when like these incidents are handled badly well it also begs the question of whether social workers are being engaged in this Happ yeah that in my case it was not and I think my daughter's going to be okay but I'm just thinking like if she had she not told me and this kid like continue to call her

336this well if you who you were too yeah well yeah and he called her this on multiple occasions so it was so I just think like having that sensitivity and then I do know like white teachers have told me like I'm uncomfortable like I don't want to make a mistake I don't want to do something wrong and black teachers and other teachers of color we don't have that um we don't have that privilege we have to deal with it like hearing from black teachers to say like I have to take on all these additional things in addition to my normal job like that's common I do it at work all the time so I think we have to like push a little bit and say yes this might be hard you might say something wrong

337but we're counting on you as an adult in the room to say like this isn't right and and do what you think is right don't sit there and say I don't want to say the wrong thing that I'm accused to being a racist like I'm J we got in the room back sustainabil two sentences do we have any PTAC we're almost we're almost there awesome Fork was there anything we January 8th it was on the schedule okay I no PTO we touched on a little bit in the context of donations anything else no meetings have been scheduled for the for the new year CC tri board was changed into a regular meeting because we did not have forum for a couple of the groups um they are on budget they're actually under budget but they

338anticipate more cost towards the end of the year but so they are good with budget um there's a lovely presentation on the basics themes um which I will not go into right now but there's some lovely slides you can look at on it and I'm happy to answer questions and the last piece on this is that we will be adding questions to our registration for kindergarteners to look at um access and Equity issues related to preschool BK programs um two quick questions for folks that folks here have been working with C on and that's my report can I ask one question you know when we formed the CC predates me it predates all of us I think it had 25 uh we had this tri board because we needed this oversight but now that it's

339embedded institutionally in our culture I just wonder if there's a better way to Showcase them we are having a governance conversation we decided not to do it this time because we didn't have Quorum for everybody but that will be happening I maybe it's a different thing maybe it's in inv the community maybe it's a town hall like thing maybe it's just something else where we don't have to have quum but the boards are encouraged to come what I can I I will pull the board on okay op uh we are meeting on 18th great o p rfcc nope no thank you edre uh they confirmed their initiatives for 24 25 school year so one is trying to maintain the exemption for school districts and the um paid leave ordinance uh they're working on Dual credit

340quality act and then they're still desperately trying to work on deprioritizing school as schools as Hing places so um all right agenda review the one thing I'll note is just the request around the math presentation that we talked about as an addition I don't know if that means that we're going to yeah we can shift be to like another six hour meeting covered a lot in Workforce diversity I don't know if any of that was duplicated no it's kind of the next phase of it so we'll make some changes because it would be too much so we'll bring that forward as the agend anything else on the agenda or that's not on the agenda folks see anybody want to go back in close session all right uh how about

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.