CorpusRecord 119741

Board of Education Meeting: December 17, 2024.

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SYC427
Date
2024-12-18
Location
DeKalb County, IL
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,725 words · about 55 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right if you all rise to the same pledge algi to the flag United States America the for stands na indivisible jusice for all Kelly would you call the RO here here Christian here Evans here alexos here Eric Jones is pres Al pres for is Pres all right good evening as a reminder our board governs by policy which is aligned with State Statute it's essential that our practices reflect these policies ensuring transparency accountability and effective governance only in a duly convened public meeting with the Forum present can the board govern as a whole where our practices and policies do not meet the current needs of the district it's our responsibility to amend those policies we legally allowable to better serve our community in align with our strategic plan our mission is to empower all Learners

002to succeed in their world our vision is to provide an ideal learning experience where students and staff are engaged and want to come back the next day our board policies and actions should reflect that mission and vision the consent agenda uh is up for approval the recommended action is to approve the consent agenda as presented uh is there a motion to approve the consent agenda which consists of minutes of regular meeting November 26 2024 minutes of executive session November 26 2024 bills payable and Personnel reports so move Jones second cop mov in second any discussion see no discussion Kelly would you call the role shoh yes Co yes Evans yes Gros yes Jones yes St yes yes motion Carri all right the next item on the agenda is the Nia consent agenda the recommended action

003is to approve the ni consent agenda as presented is there a motion to approve the ni consent agenda consisting of Ni treasurers report ni bills payable ni Personnel report ni contract and vendor agreement report so move second moving second any discussion on the ni consent Steve I was just curious hawthor Associates of Lake County do a significant amount of work it was just a very big build for for ni yes um I didn't look at that didn't um I mean I can look into it if you like I don't have uh any feedback on that and I um operates separately from the district I said on the board but we didn't meet uh this month it was lot of business so but I'd be glad to follow up with Mr Malone who's the director if

004you got a question about yeah thank just curious any other discussion all right Kelly would you call the yes Evans yesos yes Jones yes zanu yes Shiloh yeso yes the next item on the agenda is audience to visitors if you wish to address the board this evening please raise your hand at this time and when call upon kindly state your name and address and limit your comments to 3 minutes please refrain from mentioning specific names during your remarks and in accordance with the Illinois open meetings act the board should not engage in deliberative discussions or take immediate action on items not listed on the agenda however we want to assure you that your comments are important to us and will be taken into consideration thanks for your understanding seeing no comments we move on to

005the next item on the agenda which is superintendent reports see Steve so uh first of all building and Department updates have been submitted you guys have had a chance to to read those and and walk through those um the one item I'm going to speak about tonight is just a kind of an overview of the budgeting process and we' talked about this a little bit I'm going to stand because talk better when I'm standing up I guess um just want to walk through the what the the the budgeting process looks like you know in any given year uh we're using FY 26 as an example but this is pretty much how it works every year um the first thing that happens is the board uh officially votes and delegates to the superintendent the creation of

006the budget for the following year I don't create the budget um Nicole does that with her office um that decision though was made in in September for the following year okay so that's really what kind of starts the whole Pro process the year before on August of the the current fiscal year um we present the tenative budget that's based on work that we've done already in the previous spring over the summer uh we present that to the board um for approval has to be on display for 30 days uh so we watch that timeline from one board meeting to another to make sure that in September um the board approves it within that 30-day timeline has to be approved before the end of September by school code and then we get it filed with County

007Clerk's Office in both the Cal and King counties so once the budget uh is approved by the board um we go right into talking about the tax levy so um in October the board approved the tenative tax levy Nicole works on that um we talk about that um we live in tax Capa County tax cap and Nicole does a better job talking about this than I do um tax extension is what's kept not the tax levy so what's actually extended given to taxing bodies including the school district is what's Capp um we have to take things like that into account um we work with the uh County sesor office to get an idea of what eav looks like what's what's changed from the priv previous year to the current year um Nicole builds that that

008Levy presents it to the board in October uh and then typically what we've done is approve ask the board to approve the final Levy in November has to be filed but with the Calvin K counties again um in December before the end of the the calendar year so Nicole also takes care of that in January about Midway through the current fiscal year we start reaching out to Department chairs building principles directors there are a couple of except uh exceptions um uh art music I think those are the only two or the only two uh departments that um we get their budget recommendations because those cover the entire District right music and and art so those Department shares give us their budget requests um other directors principles we start Gathering that information in in January um

009part of that is Department of budgets this is what you had the previous year are you asking More For Less nobody asks for Less believe it or not um if you need if you're asking for more what's the Ral behind that we have to take all of those things and then fit them into this pretty significant puzzle uh in terms of what the requests have been and then what the budget is going to allow us to do that starts in January and goes for the next couple of months while we're Gathering that information um researching kind of the pros and the cons of of the different requests and then part of our job is to to prioritize what the requests are weighed against uh what our financial resources are so if we know that our

010budget is x amount of dollars what can we afford to do and what we what do we have to say no to that's one of the things that the board delegates to to the administration is we have those conversations with staff inter internally um this is what we can afford this is what we can't um but we don't get all those requests and then sit in our office and make that decision right as requests come in we have additional conversation What's um in terms of special education what's the need what's the ask what's the impact of NBN students um in with special education which is a little bit different that's federally required right so if a student qualifies for services we have to find a way to work that in the budget so special education

011is is typically prioritized primarily because those are federally required services that we have to provide if a student qualifies for them there are always additional asks um we would love to say yes to everybody but we can't right at some point you have to draw a line in the sand and our commitment um both Nicole and I has always been to live with PR we want to provide the best opportunities for our students that we can we have to to live within our means uh several years ago uh the district was deficit spending and had to make significant Cuts it's very painful it's a very difficult process I don't ever want to have to live through that again so um we are doing our best to avoid that but that means having those difficult conversations

012Every Spring uh letting people know what we can add what we have the resources to add and saying no when we have to historically we've made a presentation to two members of the board uh in a district finance committee uh meeting that's typically happened around April um the request this year has been that that presentation gets made to board not to that committee that will change a little bit and then as the school year winds uh down uh we also know that there are unexpected requests that come up along the way too so we start asking directors principes Department chairs what do you need in January we're working on that through April but we know that things pop up at the end of the year and one really good example is that we may have

013a a family that moves into the school district who has um a child with significant special education needs we didn't know that in April but in May or June we have to find a way to make that work so we know that there are unexpected changes to what's requested and the needs of the students and the staff um so we're weighing that throughout the summer one of the other things we watch really closely are Elementary um section numb so sometimes you just have a big class of third graders right um maybe you know that they're working their way up through the system can kinderg first grade second grade and then every once in a while you have a lot of move outs or we have a lot of move movein and that just changes um

014one grade level and we're constantly pretty much every year Watching what those section numbers look like and every once in a while we have to um add a staff member maybe over the some the last minute because we've had so many move bends to to keep numbers as balanced as we can that happens throughout the summer and then in August the whole thing starts all over again um we been inative budget um back to the board for the current fiscal year um one of the things that I used to remind the board in the future or in the past is that we're asking you to approve a budget in August and September um that we're going to use for the rest of the fiscal year with a lot of unknowns between September and June um

015we build in some safeguards and some contingency um to take care of issues as they pop up but um it's always our absolute best guess and then we monitor so the school year I work closely with Nicole and and Nick to monitor those things um but Nicole has many years in the district who's been monitoring that and kind of used to what might come up what might not every once a while there's a surprise but for the most part you can kind of budget for those things and and give yourself a little bit of breathing room so that's a month to month and a high level view in terms of the budgeting process um the the steps that we work through I just want to pause for a second and ask if there are any

016questions uh from the board so from a semantic standpoint we have a kind of a levy Le budgeting process from the standpoint of the levies established first because we have to get that documentation submitted so that we collect our tax revenue in what July and September June and September so we kind of are setting how much money is going to be received and then figure fig out how to budget from within that as opposed to maybe in another business cycle or something where a company might say here's how much we want to spend now how are we going to raise that money right um the other thing um is sayate funding and most of our funding comes locally locally local taxpayers we do get some funds from the state we do get a little bit

017of funds uh from the federal government that's fairly consistent um State funds have been pretty consistent over last several years since evf was implemented um if you went to join annual conference what you might have heard um of talk or in certain sessions is that there is a fear that ebf may be impacted uh in the coming fiscal year um receips watch the state budget receips are a little down right now um and the state has to find a way to figure out how to make up either make that up or cut back I think you mentioned this last month also um some of you I live through a time when this state just put paying school districts it's rare rarely happen but it does happen um so those are also the sorts of things

018that we claim for uh local property taxes is a huge part of our budget but we watch those other things as well um but our budget is driven by um what what Revenue we're going to have access to par expl is a really good one if we decide we want to do more we can't just go out and and try to raise more money could if you wanted to go out for a referendum I'm not recommending that I don't think anybody wants to do that at least not right now um but our budget is driven by what are our resources and how can we best allocate those for our students in our St well and I raise I raised that just because we had a comment during the last public meeting at when we were

019adopting the levy that was um you know making the request that we that we cut back on our on our Levy requests and I think to your point we could idealistically show up and say right going to hold the levy steady from last year or reduce it by x% but any one of those uncontrollable things that you just mentioned Could Happen bunch of movein we have to hire a bunch more sections special edit requests whatever and now our hands are tied which we can't go back and change the levy after the fact so it's just it's a a complication with that that budgeting cycle that we can't control like other tax and bu any other questions for me just about General this is just kind of high level General overview about the pled process any

020this is just an overview it's not we're not proposing any changes or anything this is just how it's been yeah this is how it's been done yeah we we'd had a lot of discussions last meeting about that calendar and so i' asked Steve to just kind of give a high level for everybody who's newer to the board you know what does that process look like welcome tonight or get out of here tonight you have more questions shoot me an email let me know and and include the question the answer one comment I just wanted to make on this as well I thought just tying things back to policy a line that I really lik to look for it is the district's budget including how when by whom it's prepared how the district's mission and goals

021are translated are reflected in a dollars and cents plan and so like a big part of the final budget that the board approves should be a direct reflection of its goals and priorities and the um there's a book uh Essentials of Illinois school finance and in that book uh section 23 outlines financial responsibilities to the school board and in that section it lists really well desired outcomes and priorities for the budget process and one of the things um that I think really is uh pertinent and one of the appendix items is the budget calendar like what we've recently adopted but then more particularly like as we get into April and we get that budget presentation uh in terms of prioritization it'll be really really important that our goals where our current goals are um we

022have a really clear understanding of and that a policy translates to those goals and that those goals translate to those budget allocations so that way it's super clear across all three of those planes um to the community on how this board ultimately wants to prioritize uh resources so like big picture goal setting is going to be front and center for us in the coming months um and so the budget should be really kind of second thing to think about as we start getting into those goals is like how we're going to map that to prioritization in the budget how we're going to make sure that if anything there's clear expectation for maintenance of the district's Financial Health relative to those goals so um if you want to check out like f like five pages is

023what it is in the essential to Illinois school Finance not the whole book but section 23 really does I think like a nice job of outlining what our role will be in that process as we give that Co set Fe so that's just something I don't I want to T on to your comments so then the next item on the agenda uh is board reports a little change to board reports uh we've got foer report and uh any comments on the foyer report no okay uh the suspension report will be able to be accessed in uh the diligent portal so if you guys are interested in seeing that you can find it uh for Board District and non-district committees Reports i' say if you guys have any comments questions things that might be good for

024future agenda topics anything that you want to bring relative to your own respective uh roles with the district this would be a great time to let those out when you say the suspension reports are in the portal what exactly do you mean by that so the diligent uh portal uh the one that's public facing um you know that diligent meeting where all the meeting agendas are yeah yep if you go in there uh there will be a section where Des you'll see suspension reports in the in the next there's no report this month um but it'll show up in the board information December next month start showing up next month anything else there was no planning and zoning commission meetings not the report other than I got my Monday night back I know nice Spartan

025Senate met um and we had a little more discussion on the student board rep I know that was in a recent agenda item at our level but we're Administration is still working on hammering on a proposal on how that would work I know that was delegated to the policy committee but I figured i' I give an update it's still work in progress administration okay citizens advisory committee met and there was um we talked about uh a lot about the new building um there was a concern about the food pantry since it's going to be moved that there wouldn't be as much access and a couple people brought up some good ideas of getting others in the community involved to help deliver uh packages to people's doors if there was needed and um yeah we also

026it was mainly about the new building a lot of introductions and there was a lot of people there this time a lot more than I remember being last year seem like we have a larger Group which is good but all in all it was a good meeting I don't think we're meeting again until February it's February 13th is the Spartan food pantry an external en or is that part of the district that's an external anything else any other committee sub commmittee I think the superintendent evaluation process we're going to try to set up a meeting maybe in January or February um for those of you who volunteer to want to participate and then obviously all is welcome to participate anything else okay so then on to new business or I'm sorry old business we have

027item 7.01 approval of the 2025 2026 District calendar second reading uh the recommended action is to approve the 2025 2026 District calendar it's the second time it's coming in front of the board uh is there a motion to approve the 2025 2026 District calendar I move to approve the 2025 2026 District calendar second cons seconded any discussion about the district the only significant change it sounds like was this the half day scenario um I guess was staff approving of that that that's kind of like what they were asking for I would say it was a combined ask from both admins and and staff um looking for more opportunities for professional development just to try to squeeze in a little bit more time where we could um so I would say it came from a couple

028of different angles um but the calendar not only did I share the leadership team so the admins but also um I had a chance to look at so um going get their St to thank you just a question it just popped in my head if there's a snow day on a half day is the makeup day also a half day if if there's a snow day um doesn't this so have to be a half day uh because it gets added at the end of the year yeah probably wouldn't make it a half day I'd probably make it a full day okay I that doesn't happen yeah I was just curious I've never heard of that happen I just wonder yeah we we would have to to make up the day whether it's a half or

029a full sure have to figure that out okay all right see no comments uh all in favor hi hi all right stands approved that's everything on Old business chugging through here let go a new business 8.01 approval of resolution to support Vision 2030 uh the recommended action is to approve the resolution to support Vision 2030 as presented uh is there a motion to approve the resolution to support Vision 2030 so moves Jones second all right any discussion around approving Vision 20 2013 um could there be a little bit more just Absolut perfect it's all high level then jump in if you were at join Ann conference you should have heard about uh something about Vision 2030 um Vision 2020 was a an initiative planned um just prior to 2020 was about 2015 is um at

030the time uh school funding was hard to come by there were there were Cuts there was pration um and a variety of other issues and for a long time several of the state organizations felt like always you know telling the legislators what we don't want and um multiple organizations kind of came together at the same time and and kind of came up with this idea why don't we put a platform together to sort of communicate what we would like to see instead of always having to say no all the time so just some information here um kind of referenced um there are a thousand stakeholders Who had who had had input similar to um it was developed by the school administrators Association that's superintend Association uh IBS have been involved IPA IBO um IRS um

031Vision 2020 the biggest issue was State funding but it also U promoted teacher recruitment policies College in Readiness as well as the Illinois B balanced um accountability model they've had a huge impact on the state of Public public education since 2020 wouldn't say that we checked all those boxes but but I would say because of that that initiative there was a lot of push and a lot of Leverage and um legislators in specific when so many school districts were kind of speaking the same language so many school districts had approved a resolution supporting Vision 2020 really gave lobbyist and Springfield a lot of power and influence to to have meaningful conversations with legislators so a couple bullets here on on Vision 2030 um uh provid a road map to K12 education in in Illinois it's

032really important that it shair is an articulated or a shared commitment across multiple organizations in the state um there are four pillars I didn't include those here um if you go to the ISB has provided information so ASA can get a little bit more information there um the plan details uh Advanced policy advancing policy initiatives legislative and fiscal Solutions leveraging public resources verus um more local flexibility and Leadership um so that decisions can be made closest to home local control we can talking about that for a long time so uh as a means to kind of gather some steam and start these conversations with legislators in Springfield as well as other leaders throughout the state um all of those organizations are are encouraging school boards to approve a resolution and supported Vision 2030 um and

033the more districts that do that the more ow that LS to initi there's a there's a quick snapshot again glad to answer any questions and and Michael you know Eric anybody else who was at the join annual conference anything that you kind of picked up that was particularly meaningful I didn't pick somehow I missed that in its entirety so I'm not helpful they did four pillars it was keeping students safe keeping high quality Educators in front of students and ing postsecondary success anding measurement of what is working that was like the they called it the Backyard Barbecue talk right I like the idea of having more at the local level that's for sure I was interested but was there much discussion about uh like expanding this like School maintenance projects grants the grants themselves or

034title for funding go ahead so big piece of it was trying to gain more secure commitment to the evidence-based funding model that was the priority number one on the list uh that they provided but then they go into more specialized uh funding and Grant acquisition that they're going to try to do and so there's actually a packet um it's like 24 pages uh I can make sure you guys all get it but it um the predictable funding under like the section two of the package is basically talks largely about pension reforms um Equitable funding resources for Capital and safety needs and then flexibility in terms of inter fund transferability those are the those are the four steps to the um uh financial piece of the pillars that they're working on so not too much related

035to Grant other than tied to the evidence based funding and then the property tax relief Grant go talk about uh liability for mention before fails yeah so again the the big piece was like they talked about analyzing the tier one and tier 2 systems um and trying to find a more sustainable nonlocally sourced funding path but their second pillar was just identify a pension model that could work so it sounds like it's more exploratory than it is driving at the one thing that I thought it it had a a dollar commitment or a percentage increase in evf I thought that was the only number that was in The Proposal are you talking about the like 90% of the adequacy target it was to ensure all students receive supp like 300 million additional per year for

036that was just to keep at the stat minimum basically saying we want to maintain what you said you're going to give us I it's not it's nothing super ambitious here but maybe it is for Illinois assume based on talk earlier receiving any other discussion around this questions um so this resolution what impact does it have specifically for us is it just kind of like our we throwing our hat in or so we can so like boards a mechanism boards can do is they can adopt resolutions to show support so that's that's all this is it's just a hey we're with you but we have no actual commitment Beyond saying we have committed there's no monetary as or poon support formal supp just effectively our relationship with iasb like when we do the delegate assembly votes

037like we're we're just voicing uh our support for those resolutions and then those resolutions become the lobbying effort for I um uh okay any other discussion you can read more at Illinois Vision 2030. that's where I hold up the Q uh so there's a motion in a second uh all in favor all right it stands approved uh okay the next item on the agenda is item 8.02 approval of Southeast Elementary School Improvement plan maybe EXP on this yeah so um glad to do that last year Southeast so let me back up a little bit every year the state of Illinois based on a variety of factors characteristics um designates every school as either underperforming um what's other comprehensive then exemp um glad to say that all of our schools are commendable received a commendable designation

038this year last year Southeast uh received a targeted designation um so what comes with that um our our some fun or some funds uh to support the school to to try to make some changes to support um to address needs identified in the designation process probably the best way to put it um last year Southeast was designated as targeted this year they're designated as commendable but once you receive that designation you get those funds for 3 years so we have access to those resources for 3 years we're going to take advantage of those um but in order to do that um M Frank witz and um Mr rice and Mr R probably involved in this needed to put a a plan together um to tell the state here's kind of how we're going to do

039that uh and a lot of that is going to go towards professional development uh support the teachers throughout the school um there was a specific group of students um that really triggered that designation but the nice thing is that we can use those funds to to support students across the school so that's that's what we're going to do um kind of talked about all of those things that are on the board um one of the things that's required though is that we don't just submit the the the report or the plan to the State Board of Education has to formally approv the plan and which Miss Frank and Mr Rice have uh put together so they have that it's ready to go all we need is the board to formally vote to support the plan

040and then we can start put that plan in process is there a motion to approve the plan V is there a second second any discussion I saw a couple pages that weren't completely filled in I just assumed that some of it didn't have to be filled in for example key Activity 3 there aren't dates there because some of it's Ates that there is um the option to include pages but some of them have been it wasn't very I don't think the form was super user friendly but is everything that needs to be filled in filled in everything that needs to be filled in is filled in It's Not Unusual just so the board knows it's not unusual for us to submit what we believe is a complete application or a complete Grant and to get

041returned because we put a the instead of an and or um a variety of other things not uncommon to have to to redo reports until State Ward gets just the language that they're looking for but we believe that everything is in the report that needs to be in the report assuming that the board approves it tonight we'll submit it and uh if there's any corrections or additions that need to be made we'll wait to hear from theate and in this case this was a template from the state that so download the template already have that information or some of those areas that just Goa thanks so this that is a grant technically it's it's a grant the funds are already committed um so we know we're going to get the funds we just can't access

042the funds until we've submitted the a grant to tell the state how we're going to use it and there's no obligation to meet or exceed those goals no you want to ideally right we use these resources to to implement some changes additional support whatever the case may be um so that students um test scores improve and and and other metrics improved it's already happened we've already hit that commendable again this year so we'll continue to monitor those things and there are there are um measurements things that we'll monitor that's part of the grant so we'll do that um if we don't we don't reach you know what we're hoping to it's not like they take the money back we have to pay it back right you know then there's a question well you know what

043didn't maybe work um but there's nothing to say that we set the bar here and we really shooting for here any other discussion comments all right all in favor I I all right motion passes all right next item on the agenda is the approval of resolution for at large Board elections is there a motion to approve the resolution for elections at large so move second second any discussion regarding this resolution I just wanted to make a comment because I was actually kind of surprised on this topic for me I've talked to quite a few people who actually didn't vote for this or voted no against it and I try to gauge and understand why and what's been surprising to me is that most of them it wasn't an education process of why it's important but

044that they understood that and that they wanted the they they wanted to maintain the process as it was today for representation throughout the so that surprised me more than I would have expected so yeah just very surprising to me I probably I won't be supporting it for that reason because I had quite a few discussions throughout the city that that that point of view which surprised me interesting and I I encountered a lot of confusion over what this really meant um I Heard Tales of people thinking that this meant people from Cook County could apply to be on the school board um so there's probably some effort on our part to explain what's going on of course we have the at least the current race in the spring is a perfect example of why this

045would be beneficial to the district because once again we have an opening that nobody's running for for the school board the spring so will be left with a school board that's going to get to choose its own members effectively which we've now done twice uh in the last two years um so being able to allow people that are engaged and want to be on the board to fulfill that role is perhaps better than letting us try and find somebody that meets his criteria and force them on the board but um we'll just see what the voters want I guess my comment would be um similarly to Eric I'd like to explain two things one that board members still have to reside within the district that was something that people surprisingly did not realize and second

046what um completely lost it sorry but that was the main one you have to actually live in s War 427 to be on the sore 427 for regardless of if we have um precincts or not yeah and oh I guess the other one was if we could tell the story that we're experiencing now that might help this current election and through prior election we didn't have enough candidates in certain precincts but we did have enough candidates to be on the board well except for either way but there's people out there who want to be on the board that can't be on the board because of this telling that story I'm not sure how to disseminate the information it's so difficult but yeah I mean the picture this race is is is the perfect picture of

047it I mean or an exaggerated story that if 80 people from the north side of town want to run and only one person in the south side of town wants to run the one person can elect themselves and the 80 will just have to fend over what spots are left like it seems ridiculous that that's that's the process but um and there's a lot of complications to it if you move you move to the other side of town guess what you got to give up your seat happened which has happened yes yes which is how I got on the board and then how I elect myself back onto the board this this whole thing is a a very very big problem and I would love to see it go one thing I I learned at

048the join anual confence there was last year's join conference not this actually there's a demographer and they said that in the um Consolidated elections the demographics tend to skew older um and it's sort of a generalization but older people tend to get their news from physical or are more likely to get their news from a physical newspaper have we ever used the chronicle as a medium to explain um sort of District happenings like this instead of Facebook or just uh on the website which some some members of the community might not access or have the ability to access or the tools so we've sent um you know we send M releases to the the chronicle sure they're not obligated to to print them um they print a lot of them if they don't print all

049of them right so we can send the information to them and ask them to consider it but whether or not they print it is totally their decision I I guess is it have districts ever paid to have it print or is that unusual or not even allowed um you could um you could pay to have an ad run but then and provide information yeah get tell people to do it or not do it the only the only risk would be um you know the cost of that yeah you know you have residents taxpayers that sure sure using my text you know well not necessarily the district but forming a referendum committee essentially I don't know if there'd be an interest in something like this there's a separate that forms a separate from the district and

050funds itself and runs itself they can do whatever they want how would that could board members form that or is there right it has to be a non I guess do you have any idea how those would start because I to me this is an issue I'd like to help solve but I don't know how if if we're not allowed to disseminate information or give an opinion typically districts you know try to identify one or two people who are passionate about it that aren't you know on the board and and then they kind of have to take it over right it's it's a matter of identifying who those people are um but then they have to kind of take their R and I I I took issue with this the first time we put it

051on the ballot um I take it issue with it again it's statutory the language is specific has to be there uh if this something something clearly that like think the majority of the or wants to do do we contact Jeff ker do we contact our state reps to see if there's a way to statutorily expand upon this CU on the ballot getting to your your ballot you're looking at it you're just seeing this paragraph and you're not you're not getting if you haven't seen anything in the paper you haven't seen anything on Facebook wherever you get news you don't have a whole lot to expand upon which is this paragraph you have no maybe you don't have any idea what it means but if that legal ease that's in here I I think there's a

052better way to fix that just to make it easier for people to understand welcome to reach out to the K or anybody else the stable that's the only way guess would there be any interest in trying to find people out there that would be willing to campaign for this or contribute to it in our last Town Hall um we had person come who happened to actually be the Ford president of for Jim D he came and he spoke in favor of it and um so he I know had some interest uh but like Steve was saying it's it's a a fine line to walk because we can't expend resources as a district to really endorse this so that's where it's like you know I think it's a natural inclination as a board member to like

053want to Champion a cause and so um I know like the roundabout had a uh the roundabout that's only in front of North Grove had a group um that was spearheaded by somebody I know very well um and it got a lot of success and It ultimately the advice that I was given was if you want to get something done like you have to have a coalition and you know that's that's something but I don't know that as a board there's really any vehicle for us to be able to to lawfully endorse other than in a vote and in just producing at no cost information related to it it's just it's a it's a trying spot with any resolution to that matter so and it could be just a bad road to travel as well

054you supported this but you're not supporting this you really don't care about that and right all that so I guess in say giving our support could we help form that Coalition or or is that you saw we gave a nice resolution division 2030 you know that was yeah something like so this is our next resolution about all we're putting it out to put it out any other discussion all right I'm going to call a roll call on this Jones yes S no sh I'm sorry could you say that no no Shiloh yes yes Evans no Ros yeso yes motion carried all right so the next item on the agenda is the of these double negatives approval of the cancellation of the IAS facilitated administrative procedures review um this one again I think better to have

055some explanation first and then we can decide what the motion should look like I'm going to give a quick 30 second I'm going to turn it over to to Alex as chair of the policy committee so over the summer um we voluntarily um expressed interest in reviewing our administrative procedures which are documents that the board doesn't approve but support board policies so those can be useful for the administration um to implement board policies in every almost every section of the policy manual so we reached out Tob timy is here from IB um got that all set up and and then there was kind of a shift in um maybe reviewing the policy manual we reached out to to IB originally because we felt like the policy commit or policy man was in a pretty good

056spot you may remember last spring uh late winter spring we did a lot of revisions and updates in policy man so we felt like it was at a good place and reached out to ISB and started a conversation um since then especially this fall a lot of changes um kind of Taken Bo's taking a different look at the policy manual and now one of the things that IB made really clear Tammy made this really clear don't do the administrative procedures review if you're not 100% confident that your policy manual is in in a good place because your administrative procedures are tied to your policy policy you should really make sure is in a good spot first so um there's been some conversation about investing uh in the review of the policy manual customizing the policy

057manual or going to do that will it make sense not to do the administrative procedures review but I'm going to stop there and let Alex um kind of talk about maybe the desire to do a policy station sure for this Tammy would you mind giving s sort a really brief summary of what the AP project would do and then highlight what the policy customization project do sure um so um I'm director my name is Tammy I'm director of Poli services from the Illinois Association of school boards and so right now your district is signed on to do an administrative procedures project um if you would like to do that it starts in January and um it would end in about August and so how that works in the process for ISB is that we take

058a current policy manual that's adopted and then we base the procedures off of that and then this entire editing process will be with the administration of your District um the board will not be involved in it because the board had already um allowed the to sign onto this project um onto this project so um there will be no board involvement in that sense um and my understanding from having various meetings or meeting at uh JC as well that um your policy manual may or may not be in the best state as you would like it to be and so uh my suggestion is that if you would like um assistance from ISB because we've done everything that you have all our subscriptions already the only thing that we can offer you is maybe you would

059like to um do a the manual customization project with us instead and so that is much like the AP as in I would come out and help you guys but instead of the administration doing is the board because it's board doing policy work so that process would look like um it would be up to date with the most current issue of press and so right now that would be October 2024 issue 117 and then during the process of um the customization I would make sure if there are new issues you would get those draft updates through me as well and when you adopt it you be up to date regardless and assuming you continue your subscription Services basically it's rewriting your manual but knowing it's going to be up to date with all our samples

060so the policy committee's recommendation would be the same as the administration's recommendation to cancel the administrative procedures project and it would essentially be a change order to the board policy customization project but the way I would prefer us to do it would be first cancel the administrative procedures project and separately approve engaging with them for the customization the policy customization project so that's why it's there's two separate agenda items but they're they're closely related say the the reason that I'm here that the reason that we need to have answer is that I do need to answer the aps so that if you're continuing great I'm going to take your manual ases and we build off that I would not be like helping you rewrite your polies in that sense um but if there's anything discrepancies

061that I will still give your draft updates for the policies in this process of this APS okay um you do not need to choose or make a decision if you want to do the customization now um that's you know can be a long discussion amongst yourselves or um when you come in for your Workshop in January if you have more questions on that so that answer you don't have to approve purchasing this you know project for customization I just need an answer for whether you would like to continue APS which is great you're on board you don't need to do anything or no you don't want to do anymore and then we can kind of figure out how to you know guys you're money and make sure off the contract officially that's what I need

062sure and I would feel I strongly recommend actually to cancel um the agreement with IP to do the administrative procedures project because the policy manual is kind of in a state of flux um whether the board decides to engage with ESB policy customization board decision and regardless there's not any Financial impact to to back out of the contract it won't cost the district anything they'll get their a refund for whatever may or may not have been paid right right you will get your refund this you did not do the project so and I understand there's a weight list um for these yes for the AP projects because every districts on the same timeline so we have four directors um for policy services and we work with um 10 districts but everyone's on the same timeline

063so everyone starts in January everyone ends in August and there's only one program to run that first draft manual and all the editing meetings happen in the same time period that is a the AP project has the only biggest difference is that AP project has a stricter um timeline because those dates are set in the contract um customization that timeline is fluctuating between whenever you start your project because you can sign on in any month it doesn't have to be January through August it can be anytime you know start in December through whatever you know you can have that at any time there is a wait list um because every year we only take 10 at at least right now so um you guys were were secured a spot because you uh had returned a

064signed contract uh you were one of the first 10 to return a signed contract this year um so the process in the future if you were so inclined to do an AP project in the future when your policy manual is more set in stone or even more satisfied with that um the process probably will be much similar on this we design it and that would be there would be a webinar late summer and then again the request of a contract is first from first serve when you sign it you return it back press come first serve and then you use a f your spot in the next one um the only prerequisite for APS is that you have to be on press plus so assuming you do or do not do this customization May retain

065having press Plus or else you wouldn't qualify to do the AP project in the future thank you you have any no with that I I'd like to I move to approve the cancellation of iasb's facilitated administrative procedures review second and second any discussion all right see no discussion uh all in favor hi all right so we canceled that project next item on the agenda is the approval to engage the iasb policy Serv in board policy manual customization project the recommended action is to approve to engage iasb uh policy services in board policy manual customization uh if no motion is made the item would die and we would do nothing um and the recommended motion is to approve the policy services and Bo policy customization from the administration so with this I'm going again given the

066nature of this item being somewhat nuanced um there's just a little explanation may be preface before we host the motion we got a a slide up here yeah so the the board chosen to to not do the administrative procedures project so Tammy really got the the big answer that she was looking for and um got some guidance there this one really is board preference um you know the board has engaged uh our attorneys and reviewing some of the policies already um isb's review is is pretty comprehensive they will review the entire 400 page policy manual and um customize it so that it's exactly what the board wants um Alan's term earlier was I think really good hard reset there's a hard reset on the policy manual so that um board knows exactly what's in it

067um I think there's value in that but really whether or not the board wants to engage in that process is up to the board um one of the things we talked about where you're taking your picture I I had this question for T we just wanted to clarify and she said ear this one the board doesn't have to engage in it could there is a policy Workshop coming up in January or could go through that policy workshop and then decide whether or not wants to engage in in it afterwards because the timeline on this is is not as strict as the administrative procedures want you could start it at any point March July September whatever truly truly the board's decision on this so with that information I'll also just add additional context before we list

068the motion that we've uh the policy committee has been working through a whole series of uh policies for revision and a lot of this work I think has been related to what this could be and so I guess i' just turn and ask the policy chair and the policy committee has a recommendation on this I know you guys didn't have a ton of time before this meeting to come to that conclusion so just more or less if there are any individual comments then from the policy committee on this um that would be super helpful personally I I have enough information to feel comfortable recommending that we move forward but if the board would like additional information um I'd be happy to wait as well but I would support moving forward with this tonight are there

069any other comments from the policy committee related to that again only on the basis that in the time allotted there wasn't enough to reach full consensus or discussion that I trust your judgment on it but what is the cost what would be the cost 9350 I believe right is that does that sound right that was the prizes for student size the district whether it's administrative procedures or the policy Man review so um it's exact same you know we've already dedicated those funds to the administrative procedures project um if the board doesn't do either one IP will cedit the check back make a down payment to commit to it um if the board decides to do the policy manual review um customization down payment is essentially already made like Alex said to to change where we're

070just shifting it from one project to another and if we were to try to do it ourselves then what is the cost like the LA lawyer fees to make sure we're in compliance are we better off pay them financially yeah just from a cost perspective it's it's um cheaper it doesn't mean they don't do a good job they do a great job right thank you yeah then I I support it as well if it's going to save money if I ever heard the conversation earlier correctly they will provide legal advice as to whether those policies are legally compliant is that correct well they make sure I get this right Danny their legal team vets policies prior to being presented to the board right so are they in line with State Statute school code if the

071board wants to customize something and is looking for a recommendation in terms of what language to use they will not provide that that's something that we would need to talk to our attorneys about is that accurate so I'm going to answer a couple questions here um I don't know how financially well it is um for your I don't know your billable hours to your attorney so that being said though all the school law in the state subscribe to press so when they're looking for information their first mode of action is to look on press and look at their footnotes and they're using our material but building you so like you might as well cut the middle man and come with Source personal hotake but um that's the opinion there um the second part about um

072do we give recommendations so for example like if we had a policy that didn't have a time limit for like public speaking or something right we have you know we don't have that but we'll say like hey if you would like to limit that you can however there are suggestions that you don't go under 20 because of XY andz if you do it less than 20 consult your board attorney like we would tell you if something is flagged as not the best motor brand everything that we write everything that's produced actually goes through a strous process our press editors obious are all attorneys um we also have a p review our press Advisory Board review which is go which goes to whoever wants to be on it willingly which a lot of our school law

073attorneys who will be using our policies as examples or basing knowledge off of it as well would give suggestions and stuff prior to a press issue even being released um if there's anything of concern or like you know something has to be report to isby but isby doesn't have a system yet or our trains are in contact with isby asking them like hey is this actually happening or is this not it's effective on July 1st however your system isn't in place until September do we still want write it that way with our attorneys um our press editors are in contact with all these like we have a source we don't just make things up and write it we also have a government ations um Department that monitors bills and we get suggestions from other attorneys

074of how to support which bills we support versus not so anything that's published on Press online our samples we are responsible of our own samples we are very confident in it's legislative compliance in that sense when your board edits whatever they do um if I know um I will look at all the footnotes and make sure that there isn't any suggestion of keeping a certain thing or not keeping or anything that's legally required be in policy or something's legally required but not necessarily to be in policy I would tell you those suggestions that's for sure the thing that I won't do is I cannot write it for you um so I do give recommendations and like sometimes your policy say superintendent or design right and if I know like a policy is best practice not

075to write or design I'll tell you this not best practice is not to put Bo desn't me but you know it's your choice that you guys do decide to do it then it's on you because once the board adopts a manual that is the board's um responsibility we're not we're no longer like with what your language is so during the process we are definitely I will be involved in all that I can look up things I can ask our PR press out other things I can see what is recommended what is not what is best practice but I cannot write it for you I will just give you the suggestion like best practice is not to do something the board decides to do it I mean that's your call if it's legally questionable that's up

076to you too you would make sure your board attorney's on board of everything because anything that's triggered your board attorney is who's defending you so if your board attorney suggests something and you trust board attorney that is the language that you should be doing because they're the ones who will be need to uphold whatever the policy says so that's that part of question I I guess I'm a little confused but I I would defer to the recommendation of the policy committee I just don't understand exactly what this accomplishes versus our our current press subscription our uh months long so far rehashing of of what's in there and and I'm covering all that um you know I I just don't know what this does for us specific and I on that note I mean a lot

077of work has been done already a a lot of time has been put into this process already uh we have a workshop coming up where I think a lot of the things that we may want to accomplish be done through that Workshop as opposed to uh this so um I would be of of continuing the course of the process we' started maybe tweaking some things with the workshop um but then maybe tbling this for next year because I don't want to jeopardize any of the admin the PA at all I want to make sure that that eventually does get done um and it sounded like based off of correct me if I'm wrong um if we're taking off of press plus while we're doing this uh that could jeopardize us getting the PA next year

078if we wanted to try it next year so PA what proceded sorry sorry was public I'm not aware elid just um so let's see what was the question is okay um so yes so I kind just want to touch base with kind I've had meetings with um I've had a meeting with the superintendent and your reporing secretary in September I had a uh inperson meeting with your board president at the Joint Al conference and I had a 5ish meeting minute meeting on Friday with um with Alex um so separately speaking with you guys I kind of have an and also I spoke to Laura Martinez your your um Outreach and training director from MB so they kind of have a picture of kind of what's going on you know or like what your concerns are

079so I can see that so my um analogy that I gave uh Mr gito was that what you're doing right now is kind of patching your policy manual and it's fantastic way to do it you you're do willing to do it you have people who are willing to dedicate this time passionate about it care about it and that is a method that works I agree um but if you're saying that oh I don't know if I missed anything during this process well I don't know either right as a person who works at ISB who is a policy director like I wouldn't know either because you also already had a complimentary um Quality Assurance review from my department head back in February as well so we've done all the measures that we can provide for you

080and you are subscribed to everything that we can possibly offer for you so if you're looking for assistance from us about what's legally required what versus what is not other than hard setting it there's really no mechanism that I can do to help you if you want ib's help in that sense um so why would you want to do rewrite it basically um because if you rewrite it now or whenever if you do the policy manual customization project which is I don't care either way we do it or not um the process is the same it is uh you will be provided with it is rewriting your manual so it's replacing your current one it is going to be you will be provided with the most upto-date press updates so everything from press in my

081standpoint is legally compliant and has been you know fine-tuned and tweaked based on all the advice that we get from isby all the advice that we get from school law attorneys so it is written to be legally compliant in the N itself um so if you don't trust that part of press then maybe you should be employing outside attorney even beyond your board attorney should maybe apply you know if that's a concern a big concern for you about compliance because they do base off their knowledge of press as well they are all subscribers to press um so the cleanest way if you want to know if your compliance legally speaking is that if you have press you are legally compliant you should be and the basics of the samples you would be so that's why

082if that's a concern about being legally compliant having other language that you need then that would be the easiest way to know that you will be at least up to date to most current issue um is that the only way to do it no is press the only way to do that accomplish that also know you know you can be paying billable hours to an attorney to do it but that means that that attorney is using our resource so they're basic they're starting off with our resource and then they're going to make edits to that resource and then charging you is probably what will happen um is it worth it yeah maybe I don't know uh that's up to the district's call if you think that is the better method I know you've dedicated you

083know duration of time doing this already so if you want to continue it I completely see why that is a very valid option to do so so there's no rush in how doing a customization you can do that at any time and point um if you were to do it the logistics is what um you had brought up which is um you the subscription of press plus would be paused um during duration so the reason of that is because there could only be one working draft going on at the same at at a go so usually you get draft updates on your press plus dashboard we would no longer provinding those press plus Dash updates on the dashboard because you were getting press plus updates through me so if our if we you do sign

084on for the contract your subscription for press plus will be paused and then um your school policies Online subscription will continue so that means public viewing public facing those policies are still viewable they're still standing but you are having draft or your working version is the one with me which would be a PDF during the duration of the project so at the conclusion of the project that PDF the word documents replace everything that's in your pr+ assuming you sign up for pr+ again so that's the biggest difference um and during this duration if it takes six months or how many months during the customization and you want to update your policy manual public basing you can still do so you would just take the word version you can download the word version on your schoolbook

085policies online make the edits that you want then send them to me and then I upload it onto the website you just don't have the editing mode access available for your recording quick question to the policy committee how much more time do you think you would need to be able to finish the work that we've started in terms of reviewing the list of potential policy issues and then applying the legal opinion in terms of statutary requirement and that's not statutorily required how many how much time do you think that will take wasn't that legal opinion just on the list you provided not all of our policies that's correct I mean based on that I'd say we're about 20% of the way I thought our current policies were based on press they are yes did 200

0862008 we did the hard reset so and since then we've been relying on press plus yes I'm just assuming that if press plus is updating our policies then doing a hard reset gives us the same policies just allowing us to go in and tweak some of them which is the process we're going through right now of reviewing everything going do we like this do we want to make a change so like that's where I'm still stuck in understanding what the hard reset actually does if our policy should already be up to date with press current press plus language it doesn't take into account any decisions that were made back in 2008 so if they wanted to deviate from the recommended language at some point back in '08 which we found based on the most recent

087opinion that was the case press plus wouldn't give an opinion on that and a solution to that is that we come January at the workshop establish a schedule that we monitor all of our policies in either a onee or twoyear basis Beyond just the the Press updates and that could just as well give an opportunity for us to do the same thing effectively am I wrong in that I mean it would just shift the I mean essentially the work would fall on the policy committee as opposed to getting assistance from ISB but the same task would be concluded and we should still and something in Jan we should still do the other thing I just described yeah we would still do the review but if we don't engage this we we do a review and

088potential revisions along with the review continuously or if we fill out the questionnaire get the policy manual how we want it we would just review to make sure we're following it but we wouldn't have to sit there and look at the alternative language and determine if it was selected back in 2008 if local language was written back in 2008 or whatever it would it would it would be this board's call what the policies um are I think there might be value we're not under the going to make the decision this evening that that meeting that we have the training that Tam is going to do in January might be very enlightening as to where we stand deficiencies that we may or may not have or maybe we're in a much better State than we believe

089and maybe we table until sometime after that maybe IM me after or discussion at that training to say this is a great idea we should move forward or we're in better shape than we think or some other and I would support that Alan but just for clarification so really what we would be vetting is the language that we a board had opted to change from 2018 to now 2008 20 2008 to now we're basically double-checking the work that was chosen by are the words that were selected by Boards through them that that's that's the part of question way to put it more back in 2008 because subsequent boards had their policy revisions based on that language and we've come to find that that language wasn't necessarily compliant with statute that was my understanding that the

090problem was we weren't in some areas legally compliant and it wasn't correct but that board selected that language based on attorney's opinion maybe right maybe J just wanted it I don't know we don't know that but then isn't this an ever going cycle of rechecking boards work forever like at what point do we draw a line in the sand and say hey look we are going to do it this way we've made this selection we're going to live with that until somebody tells us we shouldn't or there is something glaring here it just seems like what's the end here there is no end it's just now two years from now we go back and we're second guessing what this board decided and so on and so forth forever and the me the mechanism that iasb

091has isn't one that we have to use but is effectively having policy maintenance done on a recurring basis by the policy committee and like what we've been doing is using and it's been fine it's been working somewhat okay for us is the Press updates has been our like maintenance but what you'll come to find with the workshop in January is one of the iasv tools that they have Tammy sto me the monitoring of policy uh mechanisms that iasb suggests which are fairly detailed and we may not want to adopt something as detailed as that but but they give a really nice routine for us to un an ongoing basis take care of our policy Beyond just the Press updates that if we patient could very well accomplish the same thing uh that this policy making

092customization would do but to Alex's point would require patience and more time from Individual members sure by adopting it but the problem too like to Alan's point is we don't know what that is yet you're only hearing folklore of Michael speaking of some grandure thing that should come at this Workshop so it I certainly think it would be worthwhile since there's interest in knowing more to wait until after that Workshop so that way the board can can work on that that's is there any ask from me or the policy committee on some sort of report as to how much more we'd have to review I don't I don't think there's a an end goal for me there it's really just understanding there's two it sounds to me like there's two approaches start with Virgin press

093policy and compare that to what our current one is to figure out what got changed and if we want to keep those changes or start with our current policy and look at virgin press and figure out why it's different and whether we want to R back to the other both of those sound like the same level of effort to me but the difference is ISB would help with one and they wouldn't help with the other okay but same amount of effort on our part potentially that's and that's where I guess I'm deferring to the policy committee if it's going to be you know your guys' time and you think one of those is going to be 50% more efficient for you but for me the cost is not the biggest deal of this that's how

094I interpret it is if we do the one with ISB it would be it just still seems to me like you're hand walking through every single policy having to make all these same decisions that we're making right now anyway well I guess could you give a little more how the questionnaire process works and just before we get down to much of a rabit I think there seems like again appetite to just postponement so I think that's probably a good route so if nobody makes a motion on this it'll die we don't have to actually motion to postpone it and then why don't we just wait until after the workshop and then at that next you know at the onset of that we can kind of brainstorm action is that okay with everybody yes yeah I

095just think that topic would be an excellent the workshop would be a great venue for that well I agree I think that's perfect that conversation awesome so that's that's everything on this there's no motion then perfect okay uh then is there a motion to go into executive session for consideration of matters related to the appointment employment compensation discipline performance dismissals employees so moved second roll call yes Evans yesos yes Jones yes yes yes [Music] yes 12:5 wow all right we're now an open session and we stand a journ all right okay oh

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.