001e e e for this executive order all right call meeting order at 701 uh first on the agenda we are going to uh move into executive session to discuss strategy relative to collective bargaining with the mass economic par professionals association association of Professional School administrators Association of support staff and afscme state Council 93 local 939 executive session purpose number three there is determined that having this discussion an open session may have a detrimental effect on the district's bargaining position the school committee will return to open session at approximately 7:30 p.m. um second second second okay so we need do roll call on this Kendra Bill yes Lisa yes Adrien yes Matt yes Melissa I'm a yes and I'm a yes also um that off Matt yeah text e e e here that's got here Matt
002is anybody in the waiting room h she's in okay not on screen okay all right we'll start with remarks uh from the chair I do have some remarks tonight um there have been many interesting topics in the news recently how much of them represent noise versus reality almost an open question in the interest perhaps reducing that noise I'd like to summarize a few areas where the administration and the school committee are working to ensure that Masco is meeting the needs of all of our students after unfortunate delays tomorrow night stanch will go before the Boxford conser Conservation Commission for a review and hopefully eventual approval of their artificial turf field design proposal this design uses materials that are P free and incorporates natural infills and is consistent with existing environmental laws approval of the design
003will enable the Masco Sports Foundation to begin fundraising in Earnest only after fundraising efforts are complete will the school committee know what the actual cost if any will be to the taxpayers and only then will a vote be taken to proceed with the project as designed or to go in another Direction it's anticipated that this decision will occur in fiscal year 2026 and if supported go to meeting in May of 2026 for implementation beginning in fiscal year 2027 uh second item tonight we continue our discussions on the FY 26 budget the initial outline of a level Services budget was presented at the last meeting and it showed a year-over-year increase of more than $3.4 million about 2 million of that increase represents spending that is 100% out of District or school committee control and it's
004driven primar by increases in outof District placements and insurance rates Our member towns have requested that we examine options to constrain year-over-year Town contributions at a 2% increase level reaching that Target will require cutting 2.18 million from that level service budget that was presented last meeting this can only be done through the elimination of a large number of teaching positions I believe this level of cuts is on 10 able though other members of the school committee may feel otherwise tonight I'm asking instead for the administration to put together an alternate proposal which delivers a 2% increase taking into account only the costs that are within our control I believe this still requires 975k roughly in cuts from the level service numbers I think it provides a better floor with which to bound our budget discussions
005uh I asked the administr be creative and looking at ways we can be fiscally responsible yet still deliver an outstanding education all ideas should be on the table for these discussions and then lastly return to the topic of of um things in the news uh from Washington there have been statements made and executive orders issued on topics ranging from hot button social issues to the potential elimination of the education department it's logical the wonder how this really impacts our school School the short answer at this point is minimally if at all we are a fairly wealthy School District which receives a minimum level of state aid we do not anticipate any material impact to our budgets from potential changes at the federal level and lastly we are primarily governed by state and local laws and
006these laws cannot be overridden via executive orders so with that said we've got a lot of work ahead of us uh so let's move on to to regular business and next up is comments from the audience any comments okay that moves us to the student Advisory Board update Luke you're on uh good evening everyone I'm Luke James I'm The Freshman uh student Advisory Board representative and I'm here in jitz place to give an update on the student body uh first of all here's the biggest news from the past month uh Masco varsity basketball has been on fire at 15-1 under new head coach jaob Morales girls varsity basketball is also in the lead in the Northeast conference uh track recently wrapped up and we had uh gold medalist in the 4x400 meter race uh the
007biggest event for the student body between Christmas break and now was the russan sophomore semi-formal dance which took place at the Double Tree Hotel on January 24th and a buffet dinner was served and entertained was provided and everyone had a good time um in terms of events coming up we have on February 13th the mmpa is hosting a Valentine's Day dance it's a fundraiser at Middleton Congregational Church and then uh break is the 17th the 21st and course selection will start late February early March uh I've only heard a few complaints LLY uh complaints Lately from peers but one or two are that there's been a lack of consistent communication from a few teachers uh to students through Blackboard and Google classroom and then the second floor boys bathroom by house B has a door
008that uh it's always propped open and some people have told me that they feel like this is an invasion of their privacy uh okay lastly after the last student council meeting we have finalized the open projects that we plan to take on over the next few months student council will be divided into groups to organize and work on the projects the five that we are doing are um a blood drive um members from the executive board will have a meeting next Monday with the Red Cross to discuss this we are doing a cultural affir along with the ace club and other clubs uh the group assigned to this project will plan and host a cultural fair to express all cultures embodied by the school and then there will be a baking competition which is still
009in the works and will be tricky because we have to comply with certain restrictions uh allergies Etc uh we will be designing a mural that we hope to hang up near the library and then lastly myself and the other members of the student Advisory Board will have our own open project uh due to the other projects not focusing on school issues Jack decided that we will pick an issue we can work on come up with Solutions and propose one of them to all of you in the future obvious obviously some issues are out of our control so we will make sure to pick one that is attainable for the five of us and and we'll keep you posted on this in the future throughout the rest of the year you'll begin to see the sophomore
010Junior and senior Sab Representatives uh to provide future updates at these meetings thank you questions that yeah thanks luk well done uh you're free to stay weave whatever you appreciate it got better things to do go do them that's tomorrow up right okay that brings us to budget deliberations Mike and Jeff and Brad you Brad why don't you come up and join us yeah yeah right next to no the de we'll cover preliminary Cherry sheets and primary funding sources uh will'll cover the two uh largest expense categories uh that represent uh approximately 75% of uh our total expense and uh approximately 70% of the uh $3 million increase uh on a year-over-year basis uh I'll cover um salaries and uh we have Brad uh here with us tonight that will cover uh out of District
011tuition special education transportation and student services uh service providers um and then along similar lines to what Joe just talked about in his statements we'll we'll talk about our spin on um non-controllable expenses and uh the possibility of establishing uh some Target um that uh that we can take away and come back on the 26th and uh begin uh scenario planning deliberations uh On th on those items uh before I get started um I wanted to mention that you've all been provided with a copy of the deck as well as um what I call the budget book so it's a 50 some odd page document that has lots of detail information in it um that you can uh view at your leisure um these materials have also been posted uh on District's website under Finance
012uh in the FY 26 uh budget folder uh both the deck and the budget book uh for anyone that's interested in uh seeing the materials themselves um so unlike past years's I'm we're trying to we're going to try to streamline this a little bit we're not going to rehash uh lots of the slides that we presented at the last meeting even though some of the numbers have been updated so uh those are in the budget book if you're interested in viewing them uh on pages 6 through n the key highlights and the assessment update and all those kinds of things so this first slide um is kind of a recap of the CH the impact that the uh FY 26 preliminary cherry sheet that was released the day after our last meeting has on our
013recommendation um and I'll go into into some of the details in in a few minutes um but the impact reduces our recommended FY 26 operating assessment by a little over $65,000 um so it's it's not a big impact uh the biggest impact was uh Chapter 70 which as we had talked about at the last meeting I had incorporated into uh the original recommendation so moving forward um preliminary Cherry seats so uh I'm going to cover some of these details for the benefit of our newest members who haven't necessarily um had a long history with what some of these terms and reports are so uh I'm going to highlight a few of them and to the extent you're interested in the smaller accounts there um the descriptions are uh are provided in at the back of
014the budget book so uh funding sources I'm going to talk about three primary funding sources um uh I'm going to talk about Chapter 70 funding which is up on budget to budget a little over $230,000 I'll talk about uh Regional Transportation reimbursement which is up budget to budget a little over $887,000 and then talk a little bit about excess and deficiencies for some of for some of you uh aren't familiar with that concept so real quick um what's a cherry sheet so a cherry sheet is the official notification from the commissioner of Revenue of the upcoming fiscal year state aid and assessments to cities towns and Regional districts the purpose of the cherry sheet is to ensure that local budgets reflect realistic estimates of the amount of Revenue a Regional School District will actually receive
015from the state during the upcoming year as well as the amounts that will be assessed upon local governments to pay for a variety of State programs preliminary Sher Cherry Sheets Were released on Thursday January 23rd so the day after our last meeting shortly after the governor released her FY 26 budget and have since been incorporated into our budget recommendation like I said see the budget book for a copy of the preliminary cherry sheet I think it's on page 42 final cherry sheet should be released shortly after the legislature adopts the governor adopts and the governor signs the FY 26 state budget which won't happen until the end of July or early August well after the school committee and the towns have approved uh the fiscal fi 26 budget so typically we carry some sort of
016variance into the the following year which we reflect in our uh our uh annual forecasts as we did um in my presentation in January how much was that this year again how much was that this year a couple hundred grand okay so Chapter 70 refers to the school funding formula created under the education Reform Act of 1993 which by which state aid is distributed through the cherry sheet to help establish educational Equity among Municipal and Regional School Districts the formula's minimum Aid provision guarantees all districts receive at least the same amount of Aid in FY 26 as they did in FY 25 plus a 75 per pupil increase so that's what's reflected in our our budget recommendation last year the the kicker was $30 per pupil so it has increased substantially from year to year
017the Regional School transportation um reimbursement is state aid distributed through the cherry sheet specifically to Regional School Districts while the law and tile Regional School Districts to 100% reimbursement for qual qualified School transportation costs State funding has consistent consistently fallen short of this Benchmark qualified costs exclude the cost of transporting students that live within 1.5 miles of school spe special education Transportation field trips and the cost for any transportation outside the normal school day which include athletic Athletics Transportation C s preliminary cherry sheet estimates for FY 26 reflect a reimbursement increase of 87,4 77,000 over FY 25 at a proposed reimbursement rate of 81.7% so not the 100 a little higher than the current year which is 80% so it's at 81.7% the reimbursement amount is based on the product of total qualified reimbursable School
018transportation costs as calculated by my office and submitted through our district 2024 end of year report schedule 7 multiplied by the proposed reimbursement rate of 81.7% Melissa did you have a question I start your hand I do but yeah I just I needed to raise my hand before I forgot the question so you can finish all right cool all right all right we should write it I wrote it down but ask us ask me later oh all right yeah I will ask all right so excess and deficiency this one's a little tricky and it's a kind of a interesting concept so every Regional School District is required to maintain an D and fund on its books of account the end of every fiscal year any surplus or depths in the district's general fund shall be
019closed to the end fund on or before October 31st of each year every Regional School District shall submit to the Department of Revenue the forms and schedules they require for the purpose of reviewing and certifying the balance in the Regional School District's end fund end is not available for appropriation until it's certified by the do do so this is critical for my office for us to do our thing and to get this package into the do so it gets certified so that the committee can use the funds if it chooses to in the following fiscal Year's budget which we're doing this year a regional school committee may use all or part of the certified balance in end fund as a revenue source for its proposed budget if the certified balance exceeds 5% of the budget
020the committee must use the amount in excess of 5% as a revenue Source in its proposed budget in practice Masco uses the amount in excess of 4% as a revenue Source in its proposed budget so for the FY 26 budget recommendation this excess amount is 72 $1,882 so back up to the first paragraph it says at the end of every fiscal year any surplus or deficit in the district's general fund shall be closed to the end fund so if we go back to July and we think about how we closed the year FY 24 we Clos the year a little over $71,000 favorable to budget $450,000 favorable in Revenue 250,000 favorable and expense roughly 700,000 we're closing 72,000 in in change in end so the ending year balance almost always translates into what the exess
021will be that we will use in the following Year's budget to kind of connect connect those Concepts okay so the next slide shows the calculation would with so um we closed and certified through the do um an end balance of $2.3 million in change the amount above 4% of our budget is uh yields a difference of 712 882 th000 which if you go back to that other slide think with the with the numbers right there yeah if you look at the bottom red arrow you can see that we're using that 720 sorry $712,000 number as a revenue Source in the FY 26 budget got it okay 15 gears so District salary review so um our salaries are increasing 1,317 um our Sal our all of our salaries represent 58% of our total costs and that
022increase of $1.3 million represents 35% of the increase over the total increase over the FY 25 budget that we've talked about so how does that $1.3 million break dollars breakdown so I've tried to reduce it to kind of um easily understanded understandable U buckets so um the largest bucket is the teachers union Cola so as we all know just finalized negotiations on a new success or CBA the the cola for FY 26 is 3.75% so 3.75% of a $16.3 million base salary for that unit is $610,000 so there's other forms of compensation increases in a teachers's contract including the mta's contract the first includes the concept of steps right so as folks when folks aren't at the top step and they earn a year of I'll call it credit um they'll move an additional step
023so we have 41 members of the teachers union slated to move a step the value next year the value of the that step movement is $141 $49,000 the next component of the teachers contract um that I wanted to talk about is what we'll call degree advancements so if you think about the salary schedule it's steps and columns The Columns represent degrees bachelor's degree master's degree Master's plus 30 credits um Master's plus 75 credits A cags a doctorate right moving to the right in the contract it states if you provide notice to the superintendent by December 15th of the preceding year your intent to move a column then we we acknowledge that we do the math and we incorporate the value of those advancements into the following Year's budget this number is extraordinarily high this for
024next year we received 20 requests submitted by the deadline with a estimated value of $193,000 so I've Incorporated that into the budget all other salaries and step increases which include um the unions to be negotiated finalized negotiations Andor start and finalize negotiations the par professionals Union the profession administrators Union the support staff Union and the mpfts um providing detail Beyond total number uh could potentially jeopardize the committee's bargaining position so I'm not going to go there but the value of the placeholder that we have in the FY 26 budget recommendation cumulatively is $48,000 increase from year to year other smaller components of the increase um as you all know we increased uh the mta's parental leave we expanded that from 2 weeks to 6 weeks there's a value associated with that um six week increase
025uh I carry I assume five parental leaves in each year in the budget the value of that increase God bless you is $50,000 we also uh lifted the sunset provision on the associate Master teacher stipend I've assumed 10 um 10 current teachers will earn that uh what um that stened uh at a value of uh $14,000 for next year um the next entry is all stiens all stiens colas uh new positions revised positions uh reflects a total increase of $67,000 so all of our stiens uh cumulatively represent a base of approximately $750,000 so apply a 3.75% increase to that and then add um new stiens for um the jazz band and choir um the uh changes for the foreign exchange program uh summer nurse days uh and then new stipended positions uh um through the
026club provision of the contract uh for next year that we've assumed so the total value of that is 67,000 when I presented the FY 25 forecast a couple of weeks ago I talked about um replacement savings we replaced 25 approximately 25 positions we saved $160,000 um that should follow through into the FY 26 budget in process so I've carried that $160,000 uh decrease there um and their career benefit costs last year we carried in our budget around $125,000 worth of the career benefit costs we're currently carrying $19,000 um so uh uh the increase or the decrease there is reflective of those uh those notifications s and then lastly uh We've Incorporated additional Staffing requirements uh associated with the IEPs of students coming up from the uh sixth sixth grade to the 7th grade so in
027total of those entries uh amount to an increase of 1.3 billion uh which is an increase over prior year of 5.4% any questions Melissa yeah I actually went back to Transportation yeah so I heard last week that Regional Transportation was that they're actually going to be reimbursed for fisal year 25 at a much higher rate than it was in the original budget through the supplemental budget Pro Millionaire's tax yeah I hadn't heard that yeah so I heard it from one of their one of the our local legislative AIDS I'll believe it when they so that but that doesn't come out till September is that so that's reflected in our budget forecasts next year yeah that's the problem we don't get if if the budget is not set until August we don't have those numbers at
028town meeting when we're actually so but the supplement for to make up for this year so if we receive what we receive by June 30th will we will this is basic accounting right will be recognized in fy2 what we receive between July 1st and June 30th 2026 will be recognized as revenue for FY 26 so I guess for the committee that if you reach out to your reps and ask them to include funding for Regional Transportation still we still have to do it in the summer after our we approve budget I heard a number of like 97% is that what yeah you heard W yeah they're trying to get as close to 100 as POS possible wow but that I mean that's never happened so what's 97% get us 97% of but this year or
029next year it would be reimbursed the Del in dollars 100 Grand probably so I I guess we should all in addition to reaching out for but for this year we should also talk to our legislator legislators about supplemental for fiscal 20 so Joe um aund 97% for this year would be um 150,000 more for this year a difference of 20% for FY 26 would be 180,000 sign yeah but you know it's all about timing right if yeah if we receive it by the end of June then we'll bck it into I I I think they were thinking September so yeah it would be great for June based on what we talked about a couple of months ago a coup yeah I have a couple of questions some of these might be in the weeds I'm
030sorry um talking about the bus um contract I know we got a fixed contract for a couple more years still so you know we we keep getting uh inquiries from our towns that the student population has gone from 1,800 to 12200 roughly my question is do we have the same number of bus routs as we used to have or are we making adjustments based on the populations as we if you recall around this time last year um we we actually decided to reduce the number of bus routes for FY 25 the current year from 28 to 25 and we reflected that reduction in the fy2 budget okay and that that takes some so for everyone's benefit so the bus contract we do it in collaboration with the TTU so what we do they have to
031do and what they do we have to do so you know fortunately that was an easy one to kind of navigate through with my Pier over there where we quickly came to agreement that you know it made a lot more sense to to reduce it by 3 to 25 contract allow you to modify the number of bus routes year to year if you need to it does yeah yeah with notice add or reduce can add and reduce right that was one the second question I had was he said the fat uh y 25 staff replacement savings how many positions was that so we replaced uh there were 25 positions or there boats that we replaced coming into this year and the net result of all of th those Replacements some higher there was some lower
032yeah um a reduction of $160,000 so was that an unusually high number um no no if you recall the conversation from early January it was primarily driven by two two movements that we didn't anticipate when we were developing the FY 25 budget so what we'll do is if we know someone is retiring let's say now we'll incorporate savings for for next year right but if we don't know someone's leaving and someone leads you know um unexpectedly and let's say they're at the very high end of whatever salary schedule they're on and we higher at a lower salary schedule we'll we'll we'll save a lot more because we didn't know it was happening and we didn't budget for it try to incorporate the Savings in the budget process that makes sense were two technically retirements but
033I don't even know if it was officially retirements but they made you know notified us later in the year so it was after the budget was done so these Replacements are typically not not teachers I'm guessing one was a teacher and one was an administrator we said there were 25 positions we won't name names but right he said there were 25 positions totally so out of the 25 it's all over the board and it's varies from year to year I mean members of the MTA represent you know 70% of our working staff so it's you know I think it's propor but um yeah I guess what I'm wondering is you know we've been talking about how they're so far I think they're aren't many people that have said they're retiring this year or maybe none
034so far whatever the there are none in the MTA right so when I heard 25 Replacements I was thinking when I when I see the zero I think we don't have that much turnover when you say 25 Replacements sounds like we do have some churn what's it where's it coming from it's coming from younger teachers that are leaving or that's why I'm asking whether they're primary primarily teachers or not they're proportionately teachers yeah my last question is where do we find the end balance that's being kept year to year is it here somewhere there line item somewhere no I mean going back in history year historic you could you could refer to every one of the audit reports if you're that interested well the reason I'm asking is because we're you know as the budgets
035are increasing by different numbers year to year the amount of end you have remaining is a percentage of a number that's bouncing around year to year by different values we have right now is that a lot compared to what we've had in the past it's modestly higher than what we've had in the past um but if you think about let's let let's project a year from now and think about the forecast that we talked about a little over a month ago we're forecasting the year to end zero so they will be zero end if that happens which would result in a decrease in a revenue of $713,000 zero additional to that 1.6 million so it's the byproduct of the end of year variance to budget but we're still going to have 1.6 million at the
036end of the year correct correct won be adding any to it if we end the year on budget right so yeah I'm just wondering if it's been you know staying level over time going up slowly going down the end number would go up just based on the the percentage of the F the previous year's budget the the remaining balance is only creeping up modestly by three or four% because we use whatever is in excess of 4% of the budget every each and every year right so the ending balance the remaining balance changes ever so slightly okay anyone else have questions boring you all sorry count on you guys to ask the good question all right so at this point uh I will hand it over to Brad who will cover a of District tuition special
037education transportation and student services uh service providers this category represents 165% of our total costs and 34% of the three plus million increase um in our refed in the current uh budget recommendation for next year all right thank you're driving okay um I think this is a um like a familiar format so if um you know you have questions just kind of stop me along the way and I'll uh do my best to answer them um obviously the three-year overview you can see this year um in looking at the tuition and transportation Transportation the blue line um modest increases um I think everybody knows that if a student is placed out of District we're obligated to transport that student um to and from the school that they go to um just so you also know
038that we don't have have like with the yellow bus's one provider we put those we call them runs we put those runs out to Bid And there are probably 10 different companies that we um work with through the bidding process and um you know we choose the the best option um uh the tuition number and graph you can see did cross the $6 million threshold there um uh up from last year that's an increase of um obviously the two variables that impact at are the number of students that are out and the cost of the school so we are plus seven this year I think we've talked about it in here that 69 out of District students in the um in the budget so when you say this year you're referring to FY 26 correct
039sorry yes this budget um so yep we that's a A plus seven this is um a breakdown of the the tuitions are um we have private school tuition that's all special ed schools students for schools for students with disabilities so it's not you see private don't think St John's Prep or pingry think Landmark think cotting think Nea um the collaborative we belong to two local collaboratives the NorthShore educational Consortium in Beverly and Crest collaborative out of Andover um and uh the tuition instate in this case though that's a number that reflects collaborative that we don't belong to um like I said we belong to two there are several in Massachusetts and um based on you know student need or Pro programming who attend collaboratives outside of our like network if you want to call it
040that um obviously we're up on all of them so um it's pretty pretty easy to see the next slide um this is kind of the detail about the past you know 12 months or so um sorry I thought I had a question um since the last budget approval we had 12 students kind of un unaccounted for that were placed out of District five of those students were from masconomet we actually you know placed them out four of those students were students last year who were in the sixth grade and were not on our radar um or even really the tri towns radar to give us a you know a heads up that you should put these kids in your budget so there were four kids who we sort of lost maybe you know they should
041have matriculated to mcow but they didn't um and then we had three students actually move into the district with um really needs that exceeded what um what we can do here so that's question yeah how does that happen the or that were lost the communication breakdown like what did we learn from how how did how did that transpire and what did we learn from that that we can prevent that from happening in the p in the future so there's a slide that touches on on some of that um generally we're we work pretty well with the TR toown so if they're aware aware um so there were some instances where maybe they weren't aware um that g to talk about unilateral placements and a couple slides forward that would explain those for would not knowing
042the details of how how all this happens but I presume sometimes it happens that an individual's condition deteriorates yep entirely possible and that would be one reason that they weren't on the radar but now now they have an issue that needs address yep not uncommon for there to be you know even one incident that can lead to you know if you watch the news um you know things can happen with with a student that might preclude them you know staying in their public school yeah so it's kind of a combination but I got a slide okay coming up that um I was just right there I was a little concerned the the notion of someone being lost in the system that's yeah l in we were expecting to come here services in house and we
043got to the first day of school and they're not here I just didn't want where they I didn't want the public to hear that right so yeah no I appreciate the clarification and lost probably wasn't my you know not a 10 is seventh grade is that something that the TR toown Union approved for an out of District basement or so there we're going to talk about unilateral often times it's a unilateral placement that we don't know about until it's already done do right um also just so everybody knows if a student is does not attain a high school diploma we're responsible for them until they're 22 um so last year we did have three students age out that's what we call it when you turn 22 you've aged out so out last year having eight
044students graduate from out of District placements so things were looking like close to even um you know it's a 12 11 so there's one um in this upcoming budget cycle in this budget we've got five um sixth graders coming into the seventh grade in out of District placements um can I ask a quick question on that so they don't graduate we have to keep um paying until they're 22 does it change in cast requirements do anything to that equation probably not these These are students who whose needs are there severe need different than yeah I mean these are students so probably there was there is an mcast ALT which is a different version of the test for you know depending on the need for severe special need students um to more of a portfolio based
045assessment um so those students were still taking the all but if if they for whatever reason weren't able to actually make the competency determination we still would have to service them until their 22 um we are aware luckily uh of a student who will be moving in to the district um already aware of so um we're able to include that in the budget rather than be surprised by it but but yeah the the as you can see that the result 997 um oh Isa um sorry back to the a 22 Yeah so is it till they hit 22 or if they graduate or is it even if you graduated 18 you'll still get the if you need additional most of these students aren't working towards a high school diploma okay um if that helps you
046know don't graduate there's who I all right I didn't know if it was an either or kind of it is I mean the rule is yeah the rule is you get your high school diploma and you know that kind of is the end of special ed services you don't get your high school diploma you know generally you're eligible till 22 one more quick one yep um my initial reaction is we we don't have much control over the tuition costs but we may have some control over Transportation because You' referen that you use the number of different vendors is that a fair assessment yes yeah y okay during the summer we we go out to bid um so my office works at Brad's office and we you know we assess and evaluate each and every run
047that we're anticipating for the 69 kids and then we'll put it the bid and will um typically uh but not always uh except the lowest bidder um the range just the range isn't from cheap to expensive it's pretty much expensive to ridiculous when we get those right like there aren't right there aren't a ton of Bargains out there but it's one of those costs that we'll talk about a little later that's it's not controllable right it I mean it is what it is we have to the law requires us to trans right you can try to get the best price that you can but it's not going to be cheap right thank you so one other point on the 997 so that's a combination of what I'll call rate and volume right so there's an
048increase of seven students and there's also an increase uh in tuition rates so um more often than not the increase in tuition rates is at least 4% um it could be higher for some of the private schools uh but that's kind of a good kind of that's a that's a strong point it's not 997 divided by seven and these seven kids aren't that number it's the whole right it's four it's a 4% increase on 669 kids um and then the cost of the tuition for seven new placements um this next one is just some context I um I think somebody asked this at one point uh a few weeks ago um kind of disability categories of um students who are out of District you can see um the five sort of primaries um and it's
049pretty even um distribution with um ASDS autism spectrum disorder sld specific learning disability I should have wrote those out for you guys um emotional and neurological and then intellectual has the you know the pie Eric oh sorry Erica thanks um Brad can you speak to like the most common category within specific learning disability like dyslexia dis graphia language processing auditory like how does it break down excuse me within that yeah it I'd say it's reading by you know far and away and and and you know in the context of reading you know is it dyslexia is it comprehension we'd be kind of parsing there because sometimes it's both so I think it's fair to say that the reading um learning disability is the The prominent one okay um so where where do all these 69
050students go um primarily they're going to separate day schools um So within the context of a day school like on the placement form there's private day schools which are the landmarks at 12 we have 12 students at Landmark which is the highest number that I've seen in you know 18 years or 19 years here um cing School Nea those are schools that are um you know independent they've got their own infrastructure their own um setup we've got 35 students in schools um like that 25 in the collaboratives so the the crest collaborative the NorthShore education Consortium they've those collaboratives run multiple different programs so um it's not one type of student who goes to like for the most part students who go to Landmark have a reading disability that's it right students who go to
051Crest or um neck they've got a bunch of different programs so it can be a different you know depending upon the program could be a different disability category so it's um it's harder to just kind of pin down what those schools are focusing on for us um and then there are uh students um not a lot but uh residential and unapproved schools those are schools that are not approved as special ed schools by the state of Massachusetts they're approved as private schools um but not specialed schools those are generally the result of um some legal involvement okay this was the slide I think adri sorry so um you might I don't know you've you've been you've been here a little bit so maybe you can answer this maybe not but I'm curious if there's been
052conversations along the way as we've sort of stacked up to nearly 70 kids to say are there Investments that we can make to provide different services or curriculum or something that might meet more of the needs and keep some of these kids in house versus just stacking up that expense and and you know losing members of our community um so does that happen and you know what's the trade-off look like what have what's the outcomes been do have there been conversations absolutely all the time um the there have been different um um action plans maybe or different effectiveness of different action plans based on the people involved in the conversation I guess um it wasn't too long ago that we had um some stronger programming that kept um more of these kids in District where
053I mean at one point our landmark number was was single digits it might have been one or two um I think you know our programming isn't the only variable involved with that landmark number I think the if you follow the news you know the country is you know talking about reading and all the time some of the shortcomings of what what's happening but yeah it's a it's a topic of conversation it's been a topic of conversation um yeah I just if I could add one thing to that there was going back a few years um it might have been 2015 2016 that that we we did invest in bringing some additional U capabilities in house because I the the thinking then was that that number had grown to a point where could actually uh justify
054on a long-term basis of having the capabilities in house and and not sending the the kids elsewhere um again that was probably 8 n 10 years ago so I can't speak to how it's fluctuated since then and whether or not that that whatever capabilities we gained are they still here did they leave or have they just proven been um insufficient for the growing demand for for these Services I I can't speak to that but I I specifically will call us discussing and and choosing to make an investment um in in in having some capabilities in house that we didn't have before okay yeah that's that's my thought is you know like that's one of the few things that we can do to support you guys is put it in the budget so there are things
055we can do we should I think we should be thinking about them but obviously there's a lot to un yeah yeah I think the biggest challenge particularly in a year like this year right you're looking at a 9% increase and typically when you're when you're looking to build a program let's say reading you got to make a heavy investment staff right and it's unlikely you're bringing back any of these 12 right you're not bringing any of those folks back right so you got to analyze the pipeline three or four or five years back and then have the bandwidth to make the investment so you get the return five years down the road so it's a complicated convoluted so I suspected it was going to be a very strategic conversation is why if we have any
056hope of influencing it we should be having it and we should be continuing to have the conversation that that's the point that I wanted to make internally there's conversations you know every day I mean I've we had one yesterday we had one yesterday Brad program programs I was at you know Manchester Essex is kind of you know in the belly of the Beast they're right with landmark and they've got phenomenal programming and I was over there last week and I talked to Allison Collins who's my counterpart over there um can we recreate what they have no but because you've got a structural K to2 okay yeah a structural issue that I think is coming up in a slide that's part of our yeah they they start their program and early on the elementary and it
057carries up through eth grade and that's yeah there is continuity there opportunity for partnership yeah thanks I think Jeffy I think you mentioned it but um the assumption is once a kid goes out of District they're not coming back it's it's difficult hard really difficult very unlikely right that's yeah um I guess how do our numbers compare to comparable schools are we so this to what I spoke to like to there aren't a lot of comparable schools just based on the fact that essentially we're a k through six and a seven through 12 yeah right got a slide coming up we lose a lot of kids six to seven yeah um presumably Georgetown doesn't you know Hamilton whenham doesn't because they're K through um so we're we're higher than every neighbor we've got this was
058a topic of conversation years ago when we used to have the big giant twice a year meeting with the two School committees there was more continuity there was more communication there was a more seamless handoff there was discussion about these budget implications making long-term Investments it's hard to make an investment when the school committee turns over every year and all we're thinking about is that number we're trying to get our finance committees 2% and so but it's like we have to start thinking about what our future School committees are going to inherit and how do we make long-term Investments only ever thinking about these short-term budgets agreed 100 gu think I have a hard time to get my head around is that whether it's K through 12 or not you know something's happening at sixth
059grade where people decide that the to are fine and masco's not right I'm not sure what if we have the cause of that I mean I think it's if you if you experience it with a sixth grader you sort of know like there's a lot of apprehension amongst kids and parents going from their neighborhood essentially their neighborhood school coming to you know a school where two-thirds of the kidss new it looks ginormous kids are bigger you know there's a lot that goes into it that doesn't you know this we're getting awful budget a little bit but to me that sounds like it's more of a perception that we can address we were talking about this yesterday when I meet with seventh graders and I say what surprised you about the middle school and their answer
060is everybody's so nice here there's a perception issue going on and I I I do think that plays into 100% I I I work here when my kidss were in Proctor school and I heard and I'm like that's not true that teacher's never been up here they don't know so it it's you know um I went to the latest CPAC meeting a few weeks ago okay and this came up um and they said there is a perception that some of those elementary kids the parents don't think that the elementary school handled them well so they assume we can't handle them well and so they don't even yeah attempt and I I don't know if I mean when I talked to Jackie she was going to talk to the board about possibly you know having some
061of those parents talk with us or talk with you and see if maybe we can fix that perception because again it was well Elementary can't do it so Middle School's not going to be able to do it right yeah I'll talk to Jackie I by and large I'm willing to talk to anybody anywh or any like so I'd be happy to work with Jackie and partner on some type of meet and greet or yeah whatever whatever would make sense so they never come back there's a perverse of here for them to never come back because all of those schools are getting full tuition right these kids and it's an automatic payment by the government I mean the whole thing is it's pretty frustrating when you really are involved I mean I prior to sitting here
062I was the out of district coordinator for 15 years and would go it yeah it's right I mean it's and it's part of the IEP process so that you know the team will propose an IEP and if the parents reject it then the the you know a position then becomes what they call stay put and so until the parents actually agree to a different IEP the placement that that student is in is where they stay so as you know kind of to your point there not a really lot of incentive once that students in that out of District placement the parents actually have to agree to give up that tuition and have them come back and that's a state law is that what that is yeah that's the I don't know the regulation it's not
063really law probably yeah and and then there's an appeals process that gener kind of talk about that here that um that generally it's with the this Department of Education the Bureau of special education appeals their rulings generally are always in the student favor it's you know I'd have to get percentages for you but winning at the bsea doesn't happen for districts a lot so I can't remember if I started on this but how did we get here um 20 of these students we inherited you know the old the oldfashioned way they were already out of District um generally placed by either the elementary school or you maybe somewhere if they were a move in but um you know a team already determined that their needs were in excess of the public school essentially um it's
064the next one here that's really the the the frustrating one for me it's unilateral decisions um so when at an IEP meeting talk about IEPs and we talk about placement those are team decisions so the IEP team determines the level of service that a student needs and then the team determines where those services are to take place by and large the teams you know oh Masco we've got programming for this Masco if a parent disagrees you know there's a process to reject an IP and you can follow a process but if you have the means you can reject it and then place your student in a school of your choosing and then it becomes a fight with us where attorneys get involved and it nobody ever really wins and as so again that that appeal
065and those attorneys you could go to the bureau speci special education appeals um one of the the reasons we try you know we don't a lot is because bsea can also award legal fees for the family um so if you lose you wouldn't just be paying the tuition you're also going to pay all the lawyers fees to get to the point where you lost for both sides from both sides the family's legal fees too um W so again it's there's this calculus that we go through all the time this the one we're gonna fight you know because if we lose we lose big so there's a lot you know there's a lot of s it's it's these it's kind of disheartening once you start peeling back so oftentimes what we'll do here is we we'll
066we'll try to negotiate right and recently we were very successful in a negotiation so um without and either side incurring substantial legal fees so um and then we do have to our conversation earlier about the post high school students there are 10 sorry go he can finish class afterwards okay um 10 students who are in you know post High School type programming um till their age of 22 you do that math and you end up with 17 students that we 7 through 12 Masco actually placed out of District which is probably on par or better than neighboring districts um but some of those other factors they do definitely hurt us I was gonna say if we looked at the number the percentage of students who are in out of District placements like it's percentage of
067our student body or what however we calculate it if we compared it to another District that had similar resources and wealth then we would we would likely be similar we're probably still up because of that six to7 hiccup okay um right yeah but to your point it does you do have to find equivalent um so that number is actually more than the City of Salem right that we have out but Salem has more programs in house there's a few things working against this obviously like we're a you know upper middle class communities you know people have means that's you know the the disconnect between um Elementary in Masco at 6 to7 that hurts us so like couple strikes um already against us thank Erica has a question Erica thanks Joe um I'm just I think
068that there's a really strong connection between the unilateral decisions and the pr issue or like the perception of Masco and services and what we named there are two things I'm thinking about that are really strongly connected there one um I recently learned that there's an outstanding um educational attorney that I've worked for before as an advocate um far outside my Masco dealings who works within the tri town and I would imagine that being a community of means that could potentially be a connection to like override or move past some of the the team processes so my question there is like what metrics or level of specific services does our team use to determine what we can or can't provide when that would trigger for like the 17 students that we placed outside or when we're
069doing that calculus of what are we going to really fight and advocate for versus not like what are what are the specific services that we are saying here we cannot provide and I asked that question because last year in the budget conversations one my questions was around a $250,000 special education consultant line item 215,000 of which was for reading related IEP services and at that time it was named that we didn't have a reading specialist so to hear that now about a quarter of the students who are moving into outof District placements have a reading specific related disability I think that there's a potentially a real missed opportunity excuse me me and I'm just I'm wondering what is our metric or what is the bar what are we saying we can do here and what
070are we saying we can't do here and we think that an outof District placement would be appropriate I mean that's a team decision at every um at every turn you know it's an individual decision I don't think we have a you know a line in the sand that we sort of publish and say okay if you if you're this we can't we can't service you or we can't work with you um it's more it's more individualized and more nuanced probably than that is there like a number of hours are there specific like I know I'm sure like within those Consultants we have someone who comes in and does Wilson or Orton Gillingham reading interventions with students I'm just wondering like given the cost that we're looking at as we think about this to the of
071the budget it is probably worth considering H hiring a reading Specialist or again just having a strategic conversation about that long term so I guess I I know that each situation is of course different and it should be treated as such but overall there has to be something that makes the team say we can't support this so even just an example of you know here's a specific need that we couldn't service here's a need that we could kind of be helpful because right now we're looking at this number that is very high and is not something I think we we can sustain and the community can sustain so there's like multifaceted approach but when it comes to the technical component of that calculus that I think Jeff mentioned which is a phrase I I I
072like like how are we how are we doing it can we do what can we not do yeah I'm not sure I'm fortable saying that we can't if there's something that we like by and large as a rule can't do um I will I will say to my recollection we haven't placed those students at Landmark so a lot those aren't situations where we're saying you know we're not capable of um teaching reading at mascow that's not um that's not something that we've done so um it's the families making a determination that they're not satisfied with the services or the student is not advancing at a level that the families find acceptable A A lot of times but I'm a little nervous just with the sort of confidentiality piece like right I I don't want to
073inadvertently somebody okay but with an N of 35 make some like with with we're talking about 35 students so you know or Larks 12 allove the 35 yeah so I'm going to talk about the reading and the Consultants as we keep going maybe we do just Erica have a reading specialist um I'm not sure what was presented saying we didn't um we have a new staff person this year new this year yeah our reading specialist yeah she's excellent um so this kind of also speaks to um I think a little bit of your question that as I said the placement decisions are team decisions um and as I said the IP team considers you know all of the students needs and and makes a determine determination on an individualized basis as to um where those
074services are most appropriately delivered um and if you hang around with specialed teachers or administrators enough um this term fape free and appropriate public education um that's a term we use a lot uh that's kind of the Mandate when we're determining placements that it has to be you know free to the family free to the student has to be appropriate sort of deemed by the team as um um able to meet the students needs um public obviously and then um you know guarantees that the student is um is making progress the next bullet is also an interesting one with the least restrictive environment that's that's the the the law really um that we're supposed to um ensure that students with disabilities are educated with peers who don't have disabilities that's kind like that's our mandate
075that's what makes it interesting that like there are no stud students at Landmark without disabilities so it should be a pretty high bar to say that a student cannot be educated with a student who doesn't have a disability it is a pretty high bar for us to say that right um but again you know unilateral decisions sometimes you know parents can make their decision which then puts their student in a special ed school where there are no students without disabilities um it's it's just kind of an interesting um yeah somebody explained it to me once and said if if you place a student in an out District who does not belong there you are violating their civil rights because that's it's free and appropriate education in the least restrictive environment is the right right and
076it it's kind of an interesting situation when you read the laws the laws seem to be written as if schools are doing that and they're trying to prevent schools from doing that but we're not trying to do that at all um so it's always interesting when a when a parent presents that and we can say really your your child cannot be educated with students without disabilities that's that's a bold statement generally when you really break it down questions before I turn to Consultants okay um so I think um sort of got a little foreshadowing on this um we look at the the special ed consultant line is up um again this year um it's up to provide services to IEP students but it is up um and that is where the reading uh Consultants that
077we do work with um are are you know it's in that line item but the reason for the increase this year is um speech and language consultant if we can go to the next one um so we currently have one speech and language pathologist in the district and we've got over 60 students who have speech and language services so it's it's become untenable for one person to to manage that um so that's the um the increase or the the bulk of that increase as you see um the the reason for the Consultants is generally students have sort of like loow incidence needs that don't require a full staff person so um teacher of the deaf you know we don't need a teacher of the deaf here eight hours a day 5 days a week for
078you know 184 days but we do need pieces of that so that's that's where the Consultants come in and that's where um when this gets broken down there's you know vision consultants there's physical therapists there's occupational therapists who you know we don't have enough need to have a full-time person do that so we work oftentimes with the collaboratives um and that's where our Consultants generally come from uh the collaboratives [Music] um that's basically it questions Erica I don't know if I answered your questions I it's it's great to hear I'm glad that we um I'm glad that we hired a reading specialist what you said about like just the touch points I think makes complete sense in terms of this other list of Consultants and I'm curious as to like how much of that 48,000
079reading takes up and what it would what it would mean cost-wise uh programming wise for us to remove some of those Consultants bulk up our programming again just thinking back to that pie chart and the number of students who um have outed District placements with a reading related disability yep um yeah the reading takes up more than half just over half of that um 408 number so we have and we are looking um at that all the time the the interesting thing about the Consultants is it does allow a certain amount of flexibility that if we were to you know trade in or you know not use Consultants but hire another reading specialist um I think the jury's still out as to whether you get the bang for your buck in terms of um in
080terms of like is it an e uh would would another reading specialist be able to Service as many kids as those um Consultants do so maybe if I could add so the the number Erica I remember our conversation from last year is unchanged year-over year it's 217,000 and it's made up of four Consultants uh that specialize in Wilson and OG um they each provide a little over 750 hours a year and Brad and I have had a lot of conversations about this I I really think it it it's a smart affordable delivery model um because of the rate the average rate that we pay and the fact that we don't have to pay benefits costs which can run anywhere from 25 to $30,000 per staff person uh certainly something we're talking about all the time
081there's no preps right that's that's the other piece not on the teachers cont there's some if they're not in the these these Consultants are not in the teachers contract so they're not limited by you know number of minutes per day that they can work they're not guaranteed preparation time or meeting you know other meeting time that the teachers contract is so it's it would be a you know interesting to see if if it's really anything better than a wash wouldn't I don't want this to sound like though Erica that we're just saying status quo and it is what it like we are looking at ways to do things um you know differently that that will have an impact on some of these numbers yeah I I really appreciate I mean just all of that context
082and know that they're more Logistics than just looking at the number and doing a plug and play with it I think think what I'm really eager for and feel like as a community we need is specific followup outside of this conversation today around what that could look like what those ideas are um just based on the numbers and where we are and knowing we're locked in here but can't afford to continue to move forward so I just really love some specific followup at another time I think thank you go so 32% of the out of District placements are unilateral is that typical for you for is that high for this year so it um or I guess our total I'd have to year over-year what's our unilateral number uh I'm not sure you so and
083I think as a district we've recognized that there are reading um issues and we've addressed them at the seventh grade level so it would be interesting to track that number because I think that sometimes once a family's made a decision that Masco is not the place for them they're going to make that decision no matter what and I don't necessarily know that that's within our control but we can provide the best Ser I think we would also want to look at how many how many students within our district are getting those reading services in house right um and I think that's a test to that we are serving them well it's not even an argument if you were to compare um five days a week of Orton Gillingham to anything that Landmark does it's not
084even a landmark wouldn't even argue that I don't think like it's not even close so um yeah some of it is perception um and hopefully we can start to shift that yeah it's it's like a and I think maybe for the elementary schools are doing the work for especially on the reading issue that I've seen come up from the from the elementary schools uh the school committees and the elementary schools and I think that it's a process but unfortunately I think that once someone has the idea that Mas is not the place it's yeah we're going to end up paying for that it's a sad reality it's a it's a privilege extion for middle class privilege and I think there's some some number that we're going to just have to be like we're not going
085to get these kids to stay at Masco no matter what yeah manchest amazing an amazing model Manchester has I would think equal demographics to the tri toown and they don't have you know they've created a system that yeah has kind of almost eliminated ated um okay the placements to Landmark can we um you know share either Consultants or full-time employee across between the elementary school and here in order to sort of transition those kids I I thought of that idea the other day and I was like I wonder what that would look like if we but love that idea again I don't know how that how that plays out I don't know I don't know either easily yeah yeah yeah well contract let them know you're G to have the same right problem is that
086I don't know that and I I don't want to speak out a term but I don't know that the tri town is ununified you know what I mean like they do things a little differently in top Shield than they do in Boxford to Middleton so yeah because they're not they're not really a school district be a discussion between schools but it's something to think about right that's Andre that's what I I was just going to say very very quickly I don't want to take up too much time but as a mother of two children with autism in fifth and sixth grade I'm right in this whirling dervish right now of of a lot and for me I think because of the way in Middleton the schools are separated like you were saying where it's not
087K through 12 that's been our biggest challenge is that it's it's so many different Transitions and at least for my children that don't do well with that and my younger one that has very severe needs there was a lack of flowing communication I think for me at least even in like third grade I feel like I I would have liked to have had conversations or know about ins and outs of programming already to sort of figure out what's going on so I think the way the schools are set up I think that's a big problem at least for families like mine with the sixth to seventh grade change especially in their ages they're going through and at you know 12 and 13 years old doesn't help the situation for a kid on the Spectrum so
088I would love to see a a smoother flow I've always wanted that even when they were in third grade to have a a more open idea of what to expect to sort of prep them in third grade and not just fifth grade so quickly so for me living it and we had to before we moved here do the unilateral placement in preschool for another town and it was it was not pretty and I I lived it and it's horrible so and I don't want that like I want my I would want my children to be in a class with role model kids to be able to be with them you know so I think from their Community who they see around town and Agreed 100% so I think that's definitely a void there of starting
089very early in the elementary schools but it is hard because Middleton box with Topsfield they're all so different and and we Marie Bridges who works she's the assistant director special ed and I have been working we're working hard to connect with Susan Haley and to connect with Mimi and Boxford and to connect with Allison in Topsfield and have those connections not just you know connecting with Matt or Scott but connecting into the schools and and then it's just time right you know we're we were out to how Manning um maybe a month ago we were at spafford pond last week um so we're we're we're trying to get to all of those um and and our and our coordinators from the seventh grade have been out to um spford Pond and we're scheduling Proctor school
090so we're it's a lot of lot of working parts yeah it's it's a lot of yeah I appreciate we're trying to smooth that um gap for lack of a better word thank you thank you it's really helpful thank you for giving me a seat and not telling my wife they're gonna make me stand up there for next time in the middle so this last section is um kind of the byproduct of conversations um that I've had with Mike and Joe and Trevor and is is along uh similar lines to some of the comments that Joe included in his opening remarks um and is kind of a a play into conversation I'd like to have with the committee around you know given the magnitude of the budget recommendation which is still our recommendation um is there
091an appetite or a charge for a request to Administration to to start doing some scenario analysis uh ear than we typically would in the process um but given the numbers that we're looking at uh like to have that conversation tonight so um quickly go through the analysis that I prepared I'm calling it the non-controllable expense analysis so anys at the top you can see um the the the recommended increase to Total operating expenses is a little over $3.7 million and then what I did is I went through and identified um the noncontrollable operating expenses the the fixed items that just changes aren't negotiable it is what it is uh and includes some of the things that Brad talked about tonight so uh quickly going through that group uh that totals close to $2.2 million of
092the 3.7 million it's out of District tuition at a little less than a million uh special education Transportation a little over 200 K uh an increase in the service providers of 65,000 uh an increase of 93,000 in additional Staffing required through uh IEPs uh health and dental benefit increases of 450,000 the Essex retirement appropriation uh which is a bill we have simply have to pay $112,000 increase our transportation contract with nrt uh that we talked a little bit about earlier um with Joe's question an increase in property and liability insurance of uh 48,000 increases in utilities which we spoke at length about during um my January forecast presentation and then our successor janitorial contract uh an increase of a little over 50,000 so the combination of those fixed costs is an increase of 2,197 676
093so that leaves a remaining increase of all other operating expenses including all all of the salaries that I talked about earlier tonight um of a total amount of $1,533 th000 of which 1, 317,000 is salaries so 86% of that number is salaries so if we assume that a 2 and a half% increase to our FY 25 total operating assessment uh which equals 8 131,000 if we assume the Delta between the controllable piece of a million5 and change and the operating assessment Target increase of a little over 830,000 the potential for Target reduction in this scenario would be a little over 700k so that was the math that I kind of put together it's not too dissimilar to what I think Joe talked about earlier uh it's a little lower um I'm curious to have a
094conversation with the committee um Beyond Joe and Trevor I know their position what the with the idea is for us to um at the February 26th meeting um we're prepared to take the charge to come back to you uh with some ideas around making reductions principally focused around Staffing for obvious reasons so um particularly in topsville we've been asked to really look at the um the Staffing summary as everybody knows on page 20 so when you do the analysis of Staffing reductions if that's where we go is there a way to provide us with a some explanation of why we need exp like what reductions in staff actually actually mean not like an average of like I don't know if we have to get it from a registration perspective for classes like if we only
095if we reduce like you know 10 members for I'm not saying that please don't but like but like what how does that affect classes and scheduling classes and the [Music] extracurriculars because I think that always gonna have I know it's I know you're GNA say that we talked about that last year It's Tricky I was commiserating with colleagues today about budget and one of them said yeah they want you to cut everything but nothing can change so that's so for not possible so if I'm looking at it from a parent perspective I don't I don't want a staff reduction to affect the extracurriculars that my students can take at school like I don't want them to not be able to take music everybody knows I didn't my daughter didn't get to take music classes this
096year because it didn't fit in her schedule so when we're looking at Staffing models it's that is the impact okay it's going to be and that's not something we necessarily talked we talked about until they were actually we' actually made them but I think they have real world con they have real consequences that's not just taking the number of students dived by the number I mean but that's the only way average a class size average but no matter what I mean ultimately there's this sort of trajectory that we're on that you know we'll hit a critical mass in losing staffs to the point where the program will look very different than what it does right now but I think last year Melissa was a unique set of circumstances with the performing arts department so as
097I think about the work that we've already done in preparation for the next meeting I don't don't hold me to this but I don't think that any of anything that we might recommend at the not recommend just present it's not our we're not recommending this um I don't think anything will impact extracurriculars right I think that's yeah but I think that even if it's not cutting from departments that offer extracurriculars it limits the offerings that students can take so that's different that's always gonna happen so I think we just have to have I think we need to be prepared for that conversation because I think there were a lot of upset people yeah yes as a result and it's just something we need to talk about so yeah I think I'm happy last year so
098I think we'll we we'll have to take a look at extracurriculars and offerings yes right and I options are important and I want to be able to present to our town saying you know we do still have you know we we've had net reduction of uh four and a half yeah five people five people but we're still we haven't cut any programs and that seems to be what's important to our town our residents so I want to look at all the scenarios because it's our job to present it to the towns but I just think we need gets harder and harder I know said make you know reduce the budget but don't change anything exactly and so that's that's part of the conversation with our towns we can't just look at Raw numbers okay okay
099I think it would also be helpful to understand that in detail so that you know as we have the conversations leading up to finalizing the budget we can understand what the appetite is of people to follow that override if they're like well making Cuts means X Y and Z go away I'm going to show up and I'm going to make sure that I'm voicing my opinion and and getting that through so having those conversations all along the way I think is incredibly important and we can't have them if we don't really understand the outside impact of all this in a way that we can explain easily I know that's a big ask I'll say that yes it's probably nearly impossible yeah but I think it's important that we just say it yeah Chris I'm just
100building on momentum but for the people who on the committee who do not have children who have gone through the high school experience or who have not yet gone through the college experience or don't have the perspective of post colle students what makes this school system so unbelievable is the diversity of offerings and what our graduates are prepared to do when they hit college that students in most of the private schools and many of our peer districts are not prepared to do there is more engineer ing offered here than any other school district in Essex County private or public there is more Hands-On experiential learning here than most colleges the Arts the perform like the other thing that I think is a you you all know I think we should start offering AP classes earlier
101than we do here and the AP requirement is becoming an increasingly High bar across to get into any one of the top 75 colleges and so those are the things that are going to get cut not just like oh well you know our class sizes are going to go from 20 to 22 what makes this school special will change so are we willing to change the face of Masco and change the options for our students we're losing students to Essex Tech at a really rapid rate personally I believe some of that is a perception is is a lot in large part perception I don't think we have a communication vehicle to really convey the experience itial learning that is provided here but that's something I hope we can all work on in another date but
102we are about if if we take this too far we're about to completely change Masco so I there might need to be some testimonials we might need to encourage recent graduates to come share what their experiences are but I just heard from three parents today whose Masco grads are crushing it on other stem tracks in really great schools um and their peers who went to other schools outside of mascow and who are from this District are struggling with Calculus Advanced chemistry and other STEM related courses like we we have to hold true to that if that's what's important to the citizens of the tri Town Jeff and I don't disagree with anything I've heard I just think you know these towns came they're big ask you know very aggressive and we have to show them
103what that means so we should give them the hard truth like if e they ask for anything we get stuck with the repercussions I mean this town need to know if you ask for this model is what you're getting you know slash and burn Bare Bones cutting departments cutting extra cular that kind of thing um I just yeah I think we have to just not be aggressive but be honest like if you're going to ask for this this is what it means not us trying to in pretzels to make it look like it works um said it a lot better than I did you said it a lot better and much shorter too so so yeah yeah go I would ask you this je which is how difficult is it for you to come in
104here and say Here's what a 2% number looks like here's a two and a half here's a three I mean can you do a range of stuff uh easily because you know in the end we're not looking at level versus two and a half or two we're going to end up somewhere else probably as my guess and it would be interesting to just to see what the different scenarios lead to I I think what we could start with is um two scenarios that get us to this number and get us to your number and then then the details of those things and as much detail it might be impossible to do what you guys are asking for right in terms of the impact on extracurricular offerings we haven't even started our scheduling for next year
105yet right so but I think we can start the conversation with two scenarios that range from 700 to a million I think your number was a million yeah I think that's a fair fair start um that's what I think we're prepared something else that I want to just throw out there is um and I don't know this is one of the things that frustrates me continuously and I know I repeat myself on this like everything happens in yearly buckets yeah know there's potentially more bus funding coming um we can't include in this year's budget but we have $1.4 million in end right can we be conservatively creative with some of these other um pools of money that would allow us to again you know maintain as much Service as possible and keep the school as
106strong as possible while you know limiting the you know remember remember what what I said about end yeah right so end goes to zero unless we change we reduce the threshold from four to three% or even to 2% which I wouldn't recommend doing because of the outlook on this current year right also reflect back on the conversation that we had on Janu on January 5th where I talked about the fact that I'm depleting our reserves right to cover the current year right special ed costs right so I think we need to be really careful and really thoughtful about how hard we go at this thing because we could completely empty the coffers right the other the other issue is when you use things like and D is a one-year plug you set up a cliff
107for two years if if you don't have the same amount of money understood um and actually Lees me back to a question that that I'm sorry I want to ask Brad also and again this gets to the we're looking at things in yearly buckets and we don't necessarily look too far in the future and back so you presented here's what we have coming in this year here that we have leaving do we know what next year looks like because I'll play M budget varied by it went down by a million then came back up by a million is it going to go back down by a million again next year is it going to go up another million because I think we we should be taking this into account if we can right I I
108can't off top of my head but I have it on a on a spreadsheet um the trick is that sometime like stuff just changes I think we talk about you know it's hard to plan on you know some of our number numers because you know you get three movein or you get um I know there was fixing in a lot of Replacements right right we can tell you what's in fifth grade that's not that's a very small piece of the picture right I mean we were look I know it's the nature of the beast but I feel like we sit around you know waiting for the for the answer to land on our laps so we can't do anything about it so from fy21 to FY 26 placements have increased by 20 from 49 to
10969 I know right so you would argue that you know regression to the mean would be back in the other direction probably I don't know if we can just be again creative at these numbers I don't know how what that really means think outside the box I guess slot machines in the any other questions just one one question [Music] um terms of the SK the schedule is there a tool you guys are using is this like 80% automated 20% manual is it 80% manual 20% 100% manual and you're looking at the tool the the scheduling of buget classes oh I budget that's a mix automated yeah a mix of automated in hand it's an automated tool with tons of like what do we human input but it's also not available until people sign up for
110course it starts with specul signups right which right is in open up next is if it's 80% automated you have the tool and you could run some scenarios based on historical plug in some numbers see what comes out maybe give us some ranges of you've clearly never worked in a public school it doesn't work like that no it does I'm sorry doesn't work there's there's nothing no they like to stand on it is so 20th century right it really does again it starts with all the kids sign up for classes is there a better month out there not that I've seen I mean ours is right right through our our om LMS it's right through Power SC yeah I can't imagine because of our off I'm sure that costs 10 times the right yeah 10
111times 10x yeah right and and then the question is what's the setup involved in that when you sure get a yeah home package change management stuff and then to your point Jeff the budget is you and some Excel spreadsheets yes hundreds yeah it just all linked yeah there was nothing when I got here six years ago zero in our accounting systems we've various accounting systems that are Deca several decades old actually we their only District in the state that uses our accounting system now so Melissa it works is there a way to take the special ed positions out of the enroll out of the Staffing summaries yeah it's what we talked about today because then it will it goes to chose premise that we take away our cost without our costs that aren aren't within
112our control yeah I we can lice and dice the information we have I mean I could probably do it too but yeah have the spreadsheets and just hide something and exclude it all right that might be helpful for when we're approaching Our Town yeah yeah so the focus I think I think is going to be on these scenarios and then we'll kind of work from there if that's what the committee wants us to do are you going to include a look at going the two teams in junior high as part of that scenario um analysis probably not just because of the enrollment so the the Middle School enrollment is still pretty much between 250 and 290 a team I have to go back and look at the exact numbers so it's still it's still a
113three te team number if if it had dropped below 250 in class that might be a thing but what's special about the teams I guess is a I'm relaying questions that I good question what's special about the teams why can't you just have it being open so then it's not a middle school anymore it's the whole model of a middle school based on then we then we change it to a junior high school which is you know scheduling more like a high school where kids don't have the same four teachers for you know so basically that the model is that a roughly a 100 students have the same Core group of teachers for all for their classes and so those those teachers know those students well meet regularly and talk about those students and their
114issues they have the same guidance counselor sign same special Educators it's a core group that works with you know smaller slice of a school um that's the Middle School model if we were to it might make that transition from six to seven scarier yeah deining enrollment numbers like leading us to a point where we move to two teams it's they're not necessarily dropping in the Middle School it's more of the high school eight to my question we get a lot of feedback on dropping enrollment but if you're not seeing it at the middle schools you they're only a few years from high school so it's you know just we see it coming right and we're kind adjusting a small drop but if we're right back at it it's counterintuitive to making short-term reductions to hire
115them back in three years right it's a tough problem exactly right yeah you gota you gota somehow see the future a little better right you have to bridge that Gap somehow right yeah ready to move on another two hours we go yeah we should probably get going sorry and these are important discussions are we good with what what we talked about yeah I guess ask is concern said so like two scenarios coming out of this yeah that'd be great thank you I have one Melissa are we having a special meeting with the towns or do we invite the towns to come to a budget presentation we did it in the fall thought it was on the calendar but it wasn't no it's not on the calendar no no you should though I was asked I
116was asked about it yeah all right policy so these are policies for first read um they are policies that were sort of like hanging in the last group um of policies to be approved before we then look at the entire um group or entire book so the first one is ADF this is a wellness policy that was developed by the um school health advisory Council last year and we were asked to present it um for approval it will replace the ADF that's already in there the second one are our Title Nine policies they are um AC which is non-discrimination ACR um these are we already have all of these policies um changes were made to various laws at the state level and federal level last year um mask the mass Association of school committees who
117has been advising us on this project Pro I developed these policies presented them to us we completed the information um and um I had asked because there was a there we had approved them in January um and there were some changes to the laws that were being addressed and mask advise us to adopt these because they are the latest um policies meeting the latest laws and they'll work on policies when and if we need to change them um but we needed to have these on um our books by with law the next section is KGB Lisa has a question oh sorry sorry um so when I was going through those there were a couple of spots that were highlighted like we needed to add in information do those spots need to be filled in before
118we approve them those are for I think they're for links um oh page yeah we'll do it we will add it we can add it when we do the final review of them okay or we can add them now but I have a question about and this as well sorry um I know you mentioned that mask said they will change and adapt because of the obviously executive orders I know executive orders aren't law but they are an indication of where it will go so how will that work I mean should we hold off on a proving something like this if if it's not going to be considered you know the same as federal law is it something that we should hold off on until we can assess it more and figure out what is going
119to happen with you know mask advise us to adopt them um I have a personal opinion on that and it's that we adopt them because Massachusetts our education laws are not um we have really strong education laws and I think as a district have a opportunity to protect our children and and let them know that um despite everything that's going on we're here to protect them so that's my personal opinion um that can be debated as we discuss this but um mask did advise to adopt these this fite whatever's going to happen so um right now what we have on our books is outdated correct yeah there were changes so then adopting this kind of brings us up to code and then any changes beyond that we can sit okay thank you and that was
120as a last fall as a are changed in the fall okay so let's let's explore this potential law change um if it were to happen tomorrow we we'd obviously say hold on let's let's wait right if it were to happen two months from now would we have how long would it take us to um make the adjustments we would just make the change and then we have to do a first reading and a sec second reading again right but that that would be it right so there's no reason to wait for a law that doesn't exist don't know when it's going to be made especially with the way that Congress works these days I mean nobody can agree on anything down there right but when it does come along we incorporate the change right okay
121PR straightforward but I'm on my own that's okay okay please said answer your question um one is the is a website for the title n grievance procedure that's highlighted and then it looks like Brad name and phone number is one of them the title Title Nine coordinator uh and then the other one's the principal's names and yeah those were the links you can add those obviously just add those in I just know if that stuff had to be in there before we approve do you want to if you want to make a motion to when we make a motion to or to approve with those we can authorize Mike to fill it in okay or Jackie yeah Jackie would do it yes OB yeah we would definitely make it make those I thought they were
122in there so I don't know doesn't change the policy it's actually just the yeah the contact info um okay so I think the changes then there's KTP which is parent advisory councils and this is required under General Mass General law um this is the Mas version and they we as a committee agreed to um put it in um and then the final one is ebaa which is fuel efficient vehicles um this is one that was kind of strange in that it like required us to take inventories and and keep it maintained here as a policy and it didn't really quite make sense but um we talked about as a committee that we could take our sustainability policy at ECF and add that um and add basically that we should consider fuel efficient vehicles when purchasing
123fuel efficient when purchasing vehicles for the district um it was questioned whether or not any of our vehicles would even be would even fit under this because I actually reviewed the policy when I purchased the last vehicle so it complies yeah old star believe it or not but we didn't even know if like they were the the right class of vehicle to we we don't buy him that big so in any case yeah um so the recommendation of the subcommittee was to adopt uh was to resend ebaa and make that change to EC yes quick comment I just I really think that was smart move um yeah one kind of overbearing unwieldy policy you're able to roll into something else it's it's a good philosophy in general and I did notice the numberings off in
124um ECF so it should be um change to AB c d i those are that so um that's all I got handful of allies before we for the big one cake or something I'm gonna have champagne personally but got comments should ENT entertain a motion anyone want to make a motion pleas just make a motion to approve them all together I'll make that motion I'll motion to approve these as stated I can but um do you want to allow the district office to make the changes as I say with with the our administrative updates too yeah have a second I'll second any further discuss question no I'm sorry all right roll call vote starting with you Erica yes Jeff yes Lisa yes excuse me Adrian Matt yes Melissa yes Andra no Chris yes Bill yes
125and I'm a yes so 9 to one carries H that gives us or sorry moves us to um voting to ratify the collective baring agreement between or with the massom PA professionals Association we want to do any kind of review of this whatsoever we already reviewed this everyone's aware of what what's in it going to be made public or the public to look at we have a motion a motion to ratify the Collective buing Agreement with M economic par professional association second any further discussion okay roll call vote Erica yes yes Lisa yes Adrian yes Matt yes Melissa yes kandra yes excuse me Chris yes Bill yes yes carries unanimously 10 nothing brings us to the district calendar believe it or not we're already plan it for next year so this is uh District calendar
126for the committee's approval for the 2526 school year um I have shared this with uh the masscom Teachers Association leadership so they've had a chance to read review and approve uh and it's also been shared with Dr Morrison from the trown union so we're trying to line everything up as closely as possible between the two so think he had said it looks his looks like it's going to be the same but he hadn't had it has his boards look at it so but pretty pretty standard I think um if I questions ask the question I've always wanted to ask why the two days in August why not just start after Labor Day so it gets us a couple of days earlier it gets us out of the third week of June what I'm sorry what
127it gets us out of the third week in June oh okay goal is to like the later you go in June and the warmer it gets the more the kids melt and especially after State testing's done it's just um you know so after we do the HVAC system though we can go back to a I don't know did so that you know desie a couple of years ago couple years ago Dusty came out and said you really should start before Labor Day because the way W the weather had been going we've had a couple of good years where you know like last year we were out two full weeks before a before July 1 so um you know I think people like it long the summer as possible yeah you have a lot of snow
128days yeah I mean you know past we've had you know not here for us but you know years past we've had snow days all the way through like the end of June that was here yeah you know I'm trying to trying to avoid Jun as a you know that break up in the middle of the last week of school things like that yeah there on this calendar though I just don't like the January give two back toback what's that weekends it's a with little kids it's brutal the MLK day and then the 26th yeah uh yeah 26th is is actually per the teachers contract yeah it's a good ski weekend yeah what is it it's a teacher work day between semester one semester two and go skiing and not have to pay holiday prices on
129a Monday everybody go skiing son it was like box for day up there yeah okay any further discussion have a motion approve the calendar all right roll call Erica yes Jeff yes Lisa yes Adrien yes Matt Lissa yes Andra yes Chris yes Bill yes I'm yes unanimous 10 Z brings us to the superintendence report oh all right got a project um from readers to reviewers masonomics Young Adult Book Club shares their top picks is it kind of a um so this is from uh Riley Finnegan's English class um about the young adult book club class they uh the students uh share that they love to browse young adult novels in independent bookstores then discuss their discoveries in a coffee shop uh from that first discussion came an idea rather than talk amongst themselves why not
130have students share their views with the world uh I thought this might be a fun way to learn to lean into their love of reading and give them an authentic learning experience where they could share their passion for young adult books with the public said finnean who teaches the new Young Adult Book Club elective uh here at the high school uh finigan contract contacted the jabberwock bookstore and Newport which agreed to display the students recommendations uh students participating were Aaron Benson Taylor Blanchette uh blind bue Lydia deal Jordan fallis Bella Florentino Charlotte Guido Crystal harlo po Powell uh Gwyneth Kane leysa Patel Carly Peterson Finley pogi Amelia palano Emily Sterns and Savannah Stevens uh they brainstormed the question if someone's to read only one young adult novel what would you recommend and they wrote down
131their suggestions uh Jabber walki set up a display at the entrance uh displaying the students picks and their books uh the students selected interesting and thought provoking novels uh English department chair Megan hilderbrand uh has said uh this is a wonderful project and aligns with Mas anomic Vision that a love of reading puts our students on a path to being lifelong Learners uh hilderbrand andigan also wish to thank jabberwock Bookshop owner Sue little and store manager Paula bruy uh for their support for this project and for just discounting students's purchases to further encourage their love of reading um so there is this when you go into jabbawockee bookstore right in the front center there is a display with our students recommendations uh for other Stu other young adult readers to come in and take a
132pick on so really great Hands-On project um there's actually the recommendations are listed in my blog and some good photos of the actual display itself so um congrats to this vinan it a great project Joe already mentioned but uh we will be presenting our application to the Boxford Conservation Commission for a permit to construct two artificial turf fields on the Masonic campus uh this presentation will be tomorrow night uh February 7 o'clock pm uh the meeting will be held by zoom and can be accessed uh through the boxer conservation commission's uh agenda and it'll actually be a link in my blog to the to the zoom call as well uh we want to congratulate Sophia pomerance uh for placing first in the National Association of teacher of singing auditions uh in commercial music congratulations Sophia
133it's a a great competition that she's entered and uh that comes from from the music department Mr Cass um also we heard earlier the Masonic music parents Association is having a fundraiser uh for a Valentine dance uh with our Jazz choir and Jazz combo uh that's Thursday February 13th at 6 p.m. uh at the Middleton Congregational Church and then uh our High School parent coffees uh for February are going to be uh next week from Friday February 14th in the high school library uh at 8:30 in the morning and our next Middle School Parent coffee will be on February 28th in the Middle School library also at 8:30 and we ask parents to check in at the main office to sign into the building and we'll get you over to the parent Cofe okay subcommittee
134reports community relations we have our next Community Dialogue on February 26 I know we need to schedule a working meeting to sort of start our timeline on getting the the budget and capital planning out you know to our all of our communities so we will schedule that and I think and that's it and we're just on getting the communication going and starting with the timeline that we worked on a couple weeks ago to get as much information out as efficiently and as easily to understand as possible so that's it DCI budget uh just two quick things one I think once you guys have your your uh your plan if you want we'll we'll review that and uh where you guys send it out um otherwise we haven't had any meetings uh we'll probably have another
135meeting in early March I'm guessing um um I just want to also say thank you to Jeff for getting the critical track U repairs scheduled for spring so thank je okay vocal uh no updates we're probably GNA be early March policy we cther yeah we do we are scheduled to have a meeting on Monday but um have to get policies to Le them out and um at I'm wherever they are ask um so I did reach out to the committee today and ask if we could reschedule so we may or may not have on Monday I'll let everybody know uh Lea's on um Bu from anything from Topsfield wonder you mean I don't have a date yet okay Middleton I know we have a meeting March 1 I think it is March 1 yeah so
136otherwise all the updates one thing I meant to add is that I've reached out to um Rob o' Donnell I think his name is the Director of Finance uh who has been uh enormously helpful in the past and helping to explain uh sometimes very seismic movement in net School spending and minimum contribution uh so trying to set up a meeting uh with him as well as some representatives from Topsfield vcom and select boards if they want to participate as well Rob is the state dec's um resident expert on Chapter 70 in Rel ated topics so he's a good guy yeah been very helpful in yeah very okay on the Boxford front we met with our uh town government Representatives this past Sunday um thousand questions on the budget some of which we relayed some we
137haven't um they had some ideas that they passed along um sort of outside the box ideas that I think I might send to you Jeff because of um the nature of the something that we we wanted to talk to you actually about in in executive session and and I forgot to ask a question because it's the nature of it is that I don't think we want to talk about an open open committee so I I owe you that so we could do it at our um planning session to four of us but if I was going to be next Monday I was going to be in the Western Hemisphere I'm not okay I'm not going to be at that you know where to find me yeah sound good or send me an email um anybody
138talked to mascal Schwartz Foundation recently at all okay so we'll skip that one and there's uh try do we have a are you leaz on to the um what's the name of the committee CAC yes oh CPAC I I think actually Lisa you went to the meeting I have not been to one of their meetings yet so I need to find out when they're meeting next but I think you went to one of the recent ones I did um so the February meeting is actually going to be a seminar um and not an inperson uh their March meeting will be in person somewhere around St Patrick's Day but in the morning and then their April meeting is going to be another seminar so those are the I I I wrote them down but I don't
139think I brought that with me so I'm not sure the exact dates um but yeah we'll get in I'll get to and follow up with them because I know last year it was hard their meetings were exactly when we were meeting same time so like running up and running down so I'll coordinate and touch base with them too to get updates as we go along especially Okay and like I said Jackie said she was gonna reach out and talk to some of the members and see if they'd be willing to talk with us and um have those kind of conversations too I didn't know if they I asked if they'd be willing to come here and talk with us and she said she would talk with them too okay anything further negotiations good well just
140what we decided today which was that we have three U three new rounds of negotiations that that will be beginning shortly uh one with the uh mpfts the multi-purpose facility technician uh organization as well as the support staff um and that we've designated Mike and Jeff to to handle those um you know with our Direction uh but that the uh the bargaining unit representing the professional administrators the uh the negotiations team along with Mike and Jeff will handle that so those three will be beginning some point this spring or winter I guess all right that brings us to consent agenda a motion there's something in the January 22nd minutes that I think is in ER yeah um section K there are two no votes but only one is in the summary so it should be
141a 10 two zero or maybe one of those noses an eror I don't know there was one we he the consent agenda minutes only yeah but it's Trevor's on there too as a no I don't think Trevor did Might copy and Trevor yes this was on the field trip no yeah it was on the consent on the consent yeah it was the field trip that yeah yeah it was just je and above that in the liaison updates J clean attended the Middleton select board I might have did you was it okay she'll get around busy motion to approve this consent agenda as presented second with corrections as noted yeah Corrections all right Bo or sorry roll call vote uh Erica yes Jeff yes Lisa yes Adrien yes Matt yes Melissa Andra yes Chris yes Bill
142yes and I'm a yes with that we are adjourned long ones