001okay it is 701 and I'm calling this meeting to order um remarks from the chair I have none besides I hope everyone had a good holiday season and the New Year's off to a good start and we got a lot of work for the rest of the year so get ready um and besides that all I have so we'll move to comments from the audence anyone in the audience have any comments seeing none moving right along um going to move to our student Advisory Board update from Jack we can take it away uh good afternoon here's on the S Body um sorry uh the week before Christmas the prer weding group um have their own Spirit um like spirit days um Sor I'm like haven't done this in a while um the school po conversation
002will be held tomorrow uh best of Lu to the students who were uh selected um it is also that time of year again where seniors such as I are poting for internships uh we will have an assembly for more information on Friday uh last week the Freshman softb assembly for will be held at Del tree as well uh switching over here's an update on the student government um so for the months of January February and March we are poting on running open projects similar to last year the group will be broken into five smaller groups where each group will pursue some like sort of idea or like goal objective to better the school Community uh these can range from donations such as food or uh book drives um an awareness of a certain issue that
003we see at school um hosting like an event after school um like or the blood drive that one of our members planned last year during around March um next meeting I'll have someone else give an update and that's all I have thank you thank you applying to any good internships yeah y yeah it's always a good program I think that Masco offers and it's Unique so anyone else have any questions all right seeing n you're free to stay free to go whatever you want to do and then so moving on to item e on our agenda we have our friends from stantech here um so if you guys want to introduce yourself and then there's should be a microphone up by that Podium so if you want to stand Trevor I'll introduce yeah so um
004I've asked the the stantech team to join us tonight to update the school committee and community on the status of the project specifically the notice of intent and strong water management application with the Boxford Conservation Commission joining us tonight is Ananda Heron she's a senior principal at stantek professional engine engineer and will um serve as our new project manager on the project moving forward I'd also like to W welcome Mike boltus uh principal uh engineer and Lead Wetlands scientist with stantech I'm an engineer but not an engineer okay what Wetland scientist okay um so welcome appreciate you guys coming and um giving us or the project the attention that it deserves going forward so we'll hand it over to you Ananda yeah first off I want to start by apologizing for lapses in communication um
005and the project over the last several months um our environmental folks have been working towards um you pulling all the information together for the environmental surveys um as they identified additional Wetland delineation uh we realized that it would be a bigger a lot more steps to push the push the project through permitting and and and they've been you know gather they were gathering the additional information needed for the Conservation Commission um as Jeff said I'm a non as the project manager making sure we have continued communication throughout the rest of the project right now we're working on um submitting a new noi that's in process right now um well there's our SS all right kind of go through the timeline today so I put this together as kind of a timeline as to how we
006got to where we are right now um so if if you're not familiar with the history um I'll give you the tldr here um so uh August of 2023 was our first site visit to conduct a delineation in the area of the uh new Fields uh following that we had applied for the notice of intent in late January of last year the first public hearing or that notice of intent was February 1 um and the first site visit with the Conservation Commission was uh mid-march so uh midm March was um a viewing opportunity for the commission to get familiar with the resources that we delineated as well as to understand the project uh on the ground uh following that there were uh a few other public hearings uh one was in June one was in
007the beginning of August uh following that here they had requested another site visit with I believe Ipswich River Watershed Association was also a part of that meeting uh as well as the school or the commission's uh peer reviewer for the Ani so that site visit was mostly focused on identification of resources specific to mean annual high water line which has an effect on the riverfront area delineation for the site following that visit um we had you know discussed with the commission about our approach for identifying meain anual high water line we followed that up with an actual site visit again with our delineators two of them at the time uh in the end of September uh we had another public hearing with the commission uh a couple days after that we did not have the
008information packaged together yet for presentation at that hearing um in the interim after that there was another uh public hearing at the end of November where they had closed the hearing and followed that with the order of conditions that was a denial order of conditions so I wanted to show this graphic and you know forgive me for the scale I wasn't really sure how this was going to uh show up here but I wanted to give you an idea of the resources that are affecting the field here and how things changed from our first visit in August 2023 um and then following that in September of last year so various colored lines I'll go over the Blue Line obviously is the ipswitch river I mean that's the main Channel um the ipswitch river as you
009know is kind of a low flow in some areas it just breaks Channel completely but this is based on the mapping uh this yellow line here is represents the delineated bank which also coincides with manual high water line following that there's this um kind of like psh line that represents the bordering vegetated Wetland area um and then this section here of the yellow line and these yellow lines here were added uh in September of 2024 so at the time in in August um the delineator that was out here had noted that the you know the bank continued in easterly Direction following the the river here um and understanding the implications of Riverfront area associated with the back in the me high water line um and because the access was tricky like at this point it
010gets really sketchy out here and you know coming back with a canoe would be necessary in order to pick these up which they did in September of of last year um she did not delineate further than this point because you can uh let's see so this red line represents the riverfront area which is a 200 foot buffer from that bank and you can you can see how you know if you carry this across here it doesn't intersect with the green line which represents the limit of work but this area here was uh the topic of the August meeting with the commission um at the site because they were questioning whether or not the mean annual high water line associated with the IP switch River was correctly identified on the site in March there was if
011you recall from the schedule in March of to uh 2024 there was a site visit at the time they had observed a high water line that was somewhat coincident with this pink line here um however the definition the regulatory definition for mean annual high water line does not just include whenever the you know the U the river overflows the banks and is not like the high tide or the high uh water line for the for the river so they wanted to come back out here and make sure that you know we had missed anything there were some areas in this location that were um kind of questionable and at the time that we were out there in August of 2023 it was um if I recall correctly it was drought and the uh the weather
012conditions were uh suitable for identifying the the the mean annual high water line in this area it really depends on like the identification of aquatic vegetation so obviously when it's droughty that vegetation is is not present or not observable and that's the key for the delineation is you have to have oberved aquatic vegetation to carry it in but in September when we went out there it was more normal weather conditions and even though you know it's identified on here it was very difficult to delineate this this area as you can see they're just little fingers that kind of stretch out from from the river here and you know Jeff was out here with the commission and myself and it was um quite difficult to just identify it in the field there but this is what
013we identified in September and as a result um as as I said over here that riverfront area which is 200 feet from the bank or the meano high water line extended further into the site so so at the time we were preparing uh the information to present to the to the commission we were also uh preparing a modification to the application and in the interim time between you know preparing that they ended up denying the permit application um so that's kind of an explanation uh is there any question about this I know that was a a lot but yep just to check for understanding so the red line is the current boundary as established by that new like orangey points inclusive of like b11 b14 b29 the red line is what we are currently using
014is that correct red line is the riverfront area extent yeah inclusive of the 200 feet barrier that needs to be so the red line is correct Curr this was already here in August so as I said um you know the riverfront area basically went like this um so it wasn't necessary to delineate that section because it was not you know impacting the limit of of the project so Mike what so maybe in layman's terms for the group what what does it mean when you see a red line like that in the middle of a proposed limit of work such as a such as a turf field right so the project um because it has a limit of work extending into these buffer zones and Riverfront areas you have to demonstrate in the application that you
015meet the performance standards to get a permit for that activity it's the same with the the bvw here there's a 100 foot buffer associated with that so all of these different resource areas have their own performance standards that you have to demonstrate to the commission that you satisfy so our new application will address those so in a nutshell is the issue or was the issue where the the red line crosses into the green line is the green line the area where work the green line is the limit of work correct okay so prior to this red line being added to the you know to the remainder that was here already um this BBW was here and the 100 foot buffer associated with that so that triggered the need to get a notice of intent that
016buffer so we're not talking about something that was identified that ended up requiring an application it requires additional information within that application yep Melissa um so I just am looking for a clarifying question for the committee and audience if we didn't have that second field would be required to file an noi or is that what's debatable the only situation where that would be required to file an Ani is if um there was storm water management facilities that would be um located in any of these resource areas that would be tied into the rest of the project okay and Stan Exposition is that it's just on the first so my understanding is there's storm water drainage that runs under field to and uh spills out um into the Eastern side of the oh sorry I didn't
017look at that yeah yeah you can something happened oh these are just the the I'm sorry I was trying to blow it up big enough and then I can't see the yeah the scale of it is kind of tough so you can kind of see the pipes so there's under the fields there's 254 in drainage um pipes yep believe there's two of them that run under field to and spill out into the river the Eastern side of our of the limit of War yeah so dog house structure so we're tying into that's the outfall right here um you know close to the river if we tied in if we tied in you know any closer it would be more construction within the river front so we tied in here so we're not making to limit
018the impacts in the that right there should be another outfall probably 100 yards to the north yeah yeah yeah I'm sorry apologize about the scale of this it's not very clear on this graphic but yeah down here and and right up here um there's a lot of drains under the field right now and we're not touching any of those we're only touching it on the outside of the perimeter tying right before the river so just a piggyback off of Melissa's question so because of that and because of the the existing drainage that the project will utilize on the site if we eliminated field two and only went with field one we would still need to file a storm water application with the Conservation Commission yeah I mean the you know the the application itself would
019be quite a bit different you know in terms of the content because it would just be dealing with a couple existing you know storm water management facilities and tying into that um but on the aspect of um you know the BBW the buffer zones Riverfront area all that would fall away okay so are we gonna be getting the presentation from DCI before they forand files their application what topic what's that so this is re a resubmittal we're g to resubmit for two Fields we're going to resubmit the or original application the noi okay and the storm water application because it was denied on December 5th yeah by the Conservation Commission for lack of information and lack of Engagement so this is a continuation of the work that we had started a year ago but if
020the I guess I'm getting to if the DCI has is recommending something that's not to fields and I don't know because I think I heard that perhaps um and I know that's happening at the next meeting which I think is 22nd application might be so I just didn't know how this is a continuation of the scope of work town meeting yeah no changes yeah not yet all right any other questions on you know what was filed uh the delineations we know right now this one okay so this presents the kind of look ahead with respect to the new filing um so right now we're uh fast at work at developing the the new application um our plan is to present the draft uh to Jeff on uh the 15th which is next Wednesday I think
021um and that is in preparation for the filing which would occur on the 23rd so once you file noi uh the commission has 21 days to hold a public hearing uh to talk about the application at which time they can uh you know ask questions um um ask for additional information uh they can continue the hearing if they need to um either get new information or uh you know maybe schedule another site visit Etc so the the schedule for the commission review is kind of undetermined at this point but I would you know hope that this review period would be um quicker obviously because there would be additional information that's being provided that they've already asked for so we're going to satisfy the requests that they've already made for additional information in this application so
022I'm giving it three months um it could go faster it could go longer um but I think that's a reasonable frame for most uh notice of intent reviews uh following that review the commission at their you know last public hearing would um make a final decision and and vote on whether or not to issue an order of conditions for the project um so that final decision I'm anticipating uh in May and then following that they have 10 business days to issue the order of conditions signed and and ready to go so that is where we get to the end of May any questions on schedule just to maybe say back what I think I just heard sounds like we won't have a final determination till May time frame yeah resubmittal for in January hopefully the
023first Hearing in February and then from there in the hands of the commission I mean they dictate they're going to want to do a peer review they've already told us that I don't know how long that's going to take do you have any idea um so I mean you know they're they're on a schedule you know to make decisions right and they can't uh technically um you know continue a hearing without the applicant you know requesting that even though they strongly encourage the applicant if they need additional time continue the hearing um they already had a peer reviewer for the last application so I would anticipate the process of uh finding a peer reviewer um I I would hope that they would just use the same person we paid them so they didn't do anything
024they didn't do they didn't do any work paid but they didn't do anything yeah yeah okay so um yeah so to be determined on that but if that Pro hopefully goes quickly then um they should be you know Expediting this review with the peer reviewer So based on what on what you're saying um they'll have the information that the peer reviewer had is in need of and has requested by early February so the peer review should be able to commence so we already know the history of what they've asked for um you know with the last application uh we know the deficiencies that were already there um so we're building that already into the application itself and hopefully nothing new pop up um but can't can't um and I have Joe on Zoom Joe go
025ahead yeah my sorry excuse me sorry um my question is is with respect to the February 6th public hearing have you guys given the commission a heads up already that that's what you're shooting for um I'm just curious because if I'd like to attend it but if it gets delayed it's gonna I'm worried about I got to go on vacation during that month so I don't want to miss it so How likely is is the sixth um so we've been in contact with the agent and um we've already let them know the plan for filing so we'll have that information or we'll have that filing for sure on the 23d um whether or not they put it on the agenda for uh February 6 could be dependent on how much they have um you know
026within their workload but again they they are supposed to have a public hearing within 21 days of that filing so I'm betting that we would have the first public Hearing in the 6 but no later than the 20th that because that would be the next meeting probably would be right okay thank you sure great yeah we're looking at you know a year and a half two years go to you know order conditions is that a standard process you I mean it's not typical I can yeah I'm hear like you know lack of chairing lack of Engagement you know redoing a lot of work yeah it's a lot of time to get there and makes me concerned you know first the budget you are we paying for all this extra work that wasn't sufficient and what
027we going to do to get this a little more engaged because I'm in bford and I've been at meetings where s agenda wasn't there or I'm hear feedback that they feel like they're not getting enough from you guys yeah I mean we're working on the application on our own you know dime at this point so there will be no amendments to the contract that's kind of weing yeah we're we're acknowledging that we need to correct the situation um you know that being said um there could be other issues that they bring up that we can't you know resolve ourselves if as you know there's concerns about the artificial turf and um the application of that so yeah I've done in process personally it's it's not a box doesn't make it as easy as I could
028sometimes yeah so I'm on the Conservation Commission for my town and our I live in Hamilton we're going through the process of getting an artificial turf field built at our middle school and high school and it's almost the same like situation as you guys are going through so I feel for you ask one other question slide six did we talk about that I just didn't understand what that looks like the buffer zone is going right through the projected fields we may have different slides than you guys it goes out on seven look different too yeah it's I think that was an old slide that was related to the March uh visit where they had observed a high water line that was not a regulatory mean annual high water line um so I think that was
029kind of what spurred the question about you know did you to identify the resource area properly so these lines are justs off of a single time Point yeah they they are not jurisdictional Lin okay that's why heading that direction that seems to be a bigger problem than just timelines right what's that if if you know the buffer zones are moving that dramatically oh challenge than just oh yeah exactly and that's you know that was one of the issues that was brought up during the public hearing process that need to be resolved amongst other things so thanks y Alissa we think that if we have to do peer review that they'll apply the cost of the last one because they didn't actually do any work in touch with I can't say with 100% certainty but there
030wasn't any work done so I can't imagine that we'll have to I didn't the peer riewer so I met the peer reviewer one time Mike he was at the 16th yep um track out into the mud um but that was the only time that I think he attended a meeting or a hearing so because like I said earlier they were he he was waiting for information and wasn't really fully engaged it wouldn't be a nice move on behalf of but like to think that maybe we can I'll work it apply it I guess it depends you know they not do the work because they weren't providing the information or they just didn't weren't engaged if they were trying to engage they couldn't versus yeah that's I don't know yeah I don't know either I don't
031know if we have a status from town box the project wasn't ready for them to be engaged okay they didn't have they didn't have the information they needed to do their work so that sounds like it should be you know credit forward or something but magic I [Laughter] like you good like that I am questions so Mich um just hypothetically speaking so we as a member of a Conservation Commission you you go through the process that you just talked about and the commission denies an application yeah what happens next hypothetically so uh so the commission has discretion to deny or issue an order of conditions denial um for various reasons like not satisfying performance standards um but it is a little bit subjective um so if they were to deny the project again um there
032are two regulations that come into effect there's the local Wetlands regulation as well as the State uh Wetlands protection act so um with the local uh bylaw if they deny it based on the local bylaw there isn't much recourse in terms of appeal uh you can appeal that decision to the Massachusetts Supreme Court um but it's very unlikely and it's very time consuming and costly to pursue that and I wouldn't uh put a high likelihood of succeeding on on that front um obviously we're going to demonstrate why we satisfied a local bylaw um but then with the wetlands protection act if they deny it based on some performance standard associated with that regulation we do have the option of appealing to D to get a superseding order of conditions uh which happens all all the
033time and um you know it it delays the overall process but um it is doable thank you yep any other questions here's a timeline but it sounds like it's probably premature for that at this point just for out with Landing say again Jeff I was curious how how it affects the overall timeline but it's probably too early yeah I don't think it affects it play it out I think we play it out and see where the permit gets to and then I we're still talking about 12 months from May okay having to go to town meeting so y I think the piece that it could impact and correct me if I'm wrong guys but we are not pursuing we can't pursue permits we decide to do a single field we can't go get permits now
034that would allow us to go do fundraising sooner than later right so if we weren't going through this process we could go and get a permit for one field be done move on fundraising right but because we're going through this process it might take three or four more months we're pausing that permit process which means we're pausing the fundraising window that we have okay so I think that's the only maybe drawback Y in my mind Jeff I think I think we'd have to go get a permit for just one field too and there they would there would be issues that to yeah that's what I was asking is we only had one field would we still need to get we're still going in that there still it would be a different permit but we're still
035gonna have to go through conservation to look at the the storm water Just Happening four months later I think is what Matt's getting to yes can we can we submit applications currently no so so what we're talking about is a a what what we're talking about kind of right right now benefit is so the current project has field one field two which is the one with all the issues right now yeah there's some consideration being given to only field one right right and that's this internal conversation we're having right now yeah so I can say that that would be a a bad idea because of the riverfront area performance standards we have to show a thorough Alternatives analysis which does include a reduced scope alternative um so part of our alternative analysis is demonstrating that
036there isn't a need for the second one so maybe it's a a want but we are presenting it as a strong need um you know in application you know whether or not they buy that or not um you know we'll see so could the Alternatives analysis say field one is Turf as proposed field two is hypothetically our grass field with that that is one upgrad Alternatives yes okay y so we have we have six different Alternatives as part of our discussion for the performance standards so there's the no build alternative right um there's A reduced scope alternative which would be either um you know eliminating that field or um reducing the size obviously reducing the size is not possible because there are requirements for the field size um we're also considering a number of alternative
037locations and that's just based on you know where there are open areas on the site and you know we're selecting those uh with you know the the arguments that are are necessary for um demonstrating that they won't work um size constraints um and then um see for field two one of the Alternatives I think originally we had the feeding right on the other side on the west side but we side because it has less Wetland impacts you can kind of see the where the bleachers are it's readed around that um so we're presenting that as an alternative but it would have more impacts okay and then a grass field option also like if we decided not to go with artificial turf here and did a grass field option instead got it so that could potentially
038um offset the concerns with our artificial turf um but if they want to be creative um and you know continue the storm water discussion associated with that field then that could be different I guess I just need to clarify so if we you go in you're successful we get a order of conditions on the project for two fields and six months 12 months down the road the school commune decides you know we we're actually only going going going to build field one do we have to go back to the Conservation Commission I don't we do even though there is a possibility that we could amend the application after filing based on you know an obvious um you know opposition to the idea of field two alog together okay so okay were trying what we were
039trying trying to do with the last application but are you saying you would put it on hold due to funding yeah yeah well so various yeah that would be the major reason yeah phasing phase one and then phase two is kind of on hold until they get the funding uh I mean the approval is for the entire project so it wouldn't matter whether or not it was I mean you don't have to build it if you get the approval see can keep going but you can also keep going and asking for extensions yeah there's so there's a threeyear uh per um and then you you can request extensions of the year every year Joe I see your hand up thank you yeah I have a question with respect to the storm water drainage um and
040that is again if if we go down this contingency path and it's determined that field two needs to be natural turf or something else whatever whatever might satisfy requirements um what are we getting approval to do is really my question because I don't think we've really selected the final materials that the turf is going to be made of right so this is what I'm curious about um there's obviously going to be a time when a vendor gets chosen to actually build the thing and then the final materials are selected so does this approval mean any you know what are the um constraints on the materials chosen down the line you know do you have specifications um that are part of the plan set that will limit what materials can be used um I don't those
041are not part of the sub those are not part of those part of the submission to the pon do you know the specification previously I don't believe so but if they asked for that we can Prov our our spec actually has um I don't know if I want to say past free Turf but no detectable levels of pfas in the in the turf yeah so we had a meeting uh early on um a group of us and you know a long conversation about those types of materials and we selected those and identified kind of range of specifications that would be and an alternate infill other than Crum rubber was another piece that we had on there right yeah I I guess my my point is things are evolving in this area quite a bit in
042terms of past and materials I think we can all agree to that right I mean it's in the news all the time for all we know a different material is going to come out tomorrow that is somehow artificial organic and and never um you know you can eat it and it's not a problem right so what gives us the ability to choose that other material based on this um um application you know our see I'm where I'm getting at is there a range of solutions this opens us up to or is it only a couple of potential Solutions that's that's really the question pretty much the guard rails for the Conservation Commission are going to be whether or not uh proposed modification would have a material effect on the resource areas right so and you
043know significant delarius effect um so they do have some discretion but I wouldn't consider a change in material of artificial turf um to be something that they would um you know have a problem with or could present an issue with our permit because of now if we're uh changing locations of different facilities or adding impervious surface where there wasn't any or um you know modifying the storm waterer management um drainage um significantly um those are the kinds of things that could be uh needing a modification to the permit application so usually there's a condition with the order of conditions that they finally issue that if there are any changes to the project that you need to discuss those with the Conservation Commission especially if there are plan changes um but they do allow for certain
044minor modifications that are necessary because of uh construction constraints or you know the selection of a contractor that might per prer to use a certain silt fence instead of another silt fence um I Joe are you all set I guess the last thing I would just comment on so that from what I'm hearing here it sounds like we if we get approval it'll be approval for a past free material and after that there's possibilities I'll put it that way is that is that a correct interpretation yeah yeah we received satifications from several manufacturers that are all past free including as Turf and you the big ones I I just had one question when we were talking about those alternative options how and when during these hearings is that brought up is that something that you
045guys bring up or is that something that they introduce like let's talk about alternative option two yeah so that's part of the application it's self so that'll be what is filed on the 23rd um so we have a a section that just deals with the Alternatives and we have Graphics associated with for example the alternative location um options so there'll be a pretty sizable section talking about that so their job once they get the application is to review that and just ask any questions that they have so would the permit be inclus we'd be getting permits also of those alternative options no so how do we change you see what I'm getting at how do we change Alternatives need to come to the conclusion that they are not the preferred alternative or they are not
046feasible Alternatives okay that is where we'll end up with those Alternatives thanks just to clarify question so the denial and the concerns from the clom is it Turf specific or it to me felt was a border issue with any construction the issues they brought up they brought up several issues that was that was on there that was one of them okay but it's not just material it's also just general stent construction along the river banks issue right regardless of grass Turf cement whatever right yeah they had concerns about the artificial turf past storm water management design um as well as the resource area yeah we we go care every time because it's a Hot Topic but sounds like it's not end all be all for concerns no no one of others sure yeah um yeah
047I'm you know personally just to me it's sounds like we don't at this point you know we're talking about changing locations changing plans changing everything and those are all on the table again and you know going for notes you know we just require that we we submit this alternative analysis requested yeah so we're just providing documentation of everything else we've already considered right all options we've already been through and this is just putting it on paper for them to see in this middle that we kind of I'm just amazed like I go through the notes here and you know it's 919 presentation from stantech and we're you know 2025 now we're still not having really solid plan forward so you know that's because we didn't vote to have a Turk field until 2022 still you
048we have to permit right we're supposed to permit this year and we're still kind of spinning our Wheels right at the time we formally engag them with the town meeting vote was really when those conversations I guess it goes back to you know involving STS evolving regulations you know change intivity around plastic and Turf and all that and if we're in 2028 who knows where we're gonna be that had that was really more the committee um and not necessarily think general just the process is just you know my mind up I would say this because of what we talked about earlier we won't rehash it again but there's been a six-month delay and a bit of a hiccup they issued a denial now we're going to resubmit and we're hopefully GNA get this thing finished
049in the next three three to four months yeah other CH get T Fields put in all the time uh but I'll put give this in 2017 I went to the Conservation Commission in Hamilton to get that field permitted oh did Mike deny it no I wasn't on the no but then the past the three years lapsed because nothing happened yeah they had to go back so we started working on that field in 2012 right yeah and it's not even built yet it's 202 just takes a long time yeah I think when you see it you don't see behind the scenes you see that end result right yeah so you want you should come back to a meeting and just no thanks it's going we have enough meetings we have enough Matt sorry yeah so I
050just want to apologize again for the bad um you know communication and process that you guys have been experiencing um but you know just so you know that you know we're bringing in um you know a different team and um you know myself and Michelle Simo who who is um's great yeah kind of leading the application process and was also part of the delineation team are taking uh ownership of the application forward and we'll be doing all the communication with the Conservation Commission going forward so it's already improved tenfold since I sent that email on December 6th so yeah good good I think Matt yeah I'm sorry you have to excuse my engineering mind um but you had said something earlier during Melissa's question about a permit for field one and well this permit here
051and if we only were to do field one at first and delay the second field you had said something along the lines of you don't have to build it and I wasn't sure if you meant you don't have to build the whole project or can we in fact just not build field two if so um you could as long as there were no modifications to um you know the the approved facilities as a result of just taking that out right so there might be some tweaks to the storm motor management design I'm not an engineer but um you know if those were to happen um I would anticipate that you could get those um amended through the permit but you don't have to build anything that you get approved I mean Melissa I'm sure where
052you're going with this is we don't want to six seven eight months from now now make a decision to go and just do field one for the time being and then have to go back to the perming and Hanscom process again well yeah I mean that wouldn't be ideal but like I said I I would unless they you know are just they don't want artificial turf fields no matter where they are and because they have the discretion to review an application that's associated with that um you know they could be creative with the storm water management concerns I guess I think one point for the district too is we want the capabil we don't want to get denied second field just because it is our campus and we want to be able to work along
053the riverfront as long as we have that opportunity so I think that's part of it too that we're the administration and the school committee should maybe see this application through um just so we have ownership of our own land and I think that's part of it yeah that's for what you want yeah all right any anything else none all right well thank you guys for coming thank you appreciate the work you have ahead of you okay and we are still ahead of schedule y um we have enrollment data presentation by the Middle School administration and the school counseling School counseling Brad Denton Kevin Kevin part of this I didn't think he was Kevin's just here for because he had nothing else to do on a Wednesday night mat can you keep knocking these onto the
054eight there we go we're back Joe can you hear us yep right we're all set on our end whenever you guys are ready all right hi everyone thanks for being here T not that you got a choice um this is the 8th and 9th grade enrollment data uh because I know that you all had a question about our eighth grade students and where they're going um for high school if they're not going to Masco so we're going to break that down for you and and uh and show you the um last year's data and then where things are trending this year so um start us off we'll talk about tonight who are our eighth graders where do they go in ninth grade the historical application data that we track uh then the class of 2029
055applications which is current eighth grade class and then moving forward um how we plan to continue tracking that this but then also find out a bit more information about why students may be choosing to go elsewhere other than Masco so our eighth graders are as you know one cohesive class of students that come in from Boxford Middleton and top field so in seventh grade they uh arrive here and we distribute them among our red white and blue teams mix them all up um and they engage in a diverse and challenging curriculum here at mosow uh they participate in curriculum based educational experiences they participate in our citizens workshops which um are related to our culture of kindness that we promote throughout the middle school during their two years there uh they participated in student rec
056recognition initiatives including our Chieftains of the month um as well as our gotcha tickets where students are awarded for being caught in the act of doing something good um and we also have multiple service-based um programs at the middle school including uh the recent uh food drive at Thanksgiving and then also uh collecting gifts for um students at the pathways program over in Beverly uh those are just a few of the things that they've participated in this year so it's you know it's it's a group of students that didn't necessarily know each other outside of their own individual elementary schools in sixth grade and by the time they get here go through seventh and then into eth grade we have one cohesive class of mass gomic students so why not Mas them uh students May
057pursue a trade or career path um and they leave Masco because of that reason which obviously is is not um a program that we offer here uh we have um tracked a number of students who leave the district after 8th grade they move out of the triar area um legacy admissions for private school as you know are are strong around here um You probably have have met other families where one of the parents has gone to one of the many private high schools and they want their children to follow in the same path uh single sex education could be a choice uh religious education private or Independent high school of which we have many um schools on the North Shore and in the general area um that fall into that category or Athletics Masco does
058have a great Athletic program however we don't have every single sport that a student may want to play and if they want to leave somewhere to go and row on a crew team in high school uh you know that that could be a choice as well so moving forward here I'm going to pass it to um Brad right now who's going to talk about student placement thank you um I I just want to start by saying this was I know you guys had a you know kind of Spirited discussion a month ago and I think you know three of us and sort of a larger group had you know some really good discussions on this it was an interesting kind of dive into sort of what happens and as a kid who grew up in
059the tri toown I had friends classmates teammates who left and it was always like wow I can't believe somebody's leaving and then my kids who are here experience that so it's it's interesting to look at um this data is pretty straightforward um I don't really want to read it to you but you can see um the blue is um our S6 Tech students who were left in eth grade and I think sort of what spawned this you know presentation and discussion was that clearly last year was a you know a big jump it is interesting to note that it was a downward Trend prior to that you know since covid we had kind of been um decreasing in terms of U students going to T um last year was a big jump um the prep
060and um sort of all the other privates there's not really a pattern there I think um historically it kind of es and flows I think when you've been around you know Mass or probably any any school you'll notice that each class has its own kind of personality and its own traits and sometimes you know that plays out in to pursue um and alluded to my town kids are pretty fortunate that there's a lot of options you know available to them they've got got a lot of schools would been 15 ask yeah real quick question um certainly heard an or experienced anecdotally kids that left but then came back any thoughts on on that or supplemental data you might have even if it's just yeah I mean itive I was trying to not put that in
061there because i' you know got a lot of friends who either they left or who their kids you know I can name half dozen kids right now who right to pursue something else and then you know for whatever reason something else wasn't what they thought it was going to be and they're back at Masco and they're thriving so um that does that does happen that doesn't necessarily show up in our presentation but 100% there's I don't know a number but there's a yeah it might be useful to know that at some point but my guess is that it's it's probably not insignificant yeah so yeah and even from the tech not just the private schools but kids who come back from from SX tech for sure um I should have said if you got questions
062by way raise a hand and that was assumed by the way okay good um really just a numerical representation of that chart um see we did do uh a four-year average so you can kind of get a get a look at it um I think in terms of ess6 tech obviously last year did throw that average um you know had a pretty good influence on it um this next slide I thought was maybe one of our most interesting slides because I know in your discussion there was some talk of why why kids are leaving or what do we need to do at Masco if anything to to keep kids and um I think it was Matt you made a point about like listen we got to be careful and terms of like who we are
063and what we're and and this data this came from Essex Tech website they've got a lot of data on there I'm just gonna caution it's their data not ours so I'm not gonna speak to how accurate but um based on their stats we've got 124 um M kids Tri toown kids at SX Tech and these are the you know they call them shops the shops that they're in so you can see like you know Plumbing electrical um hvic otology so you know a lot of things that that's typically not our bread and butter um I think historically it would be I should shout out to the local guys who I know there's a lot of successful plumbers and electricians and hbac guys who did come through mosow but I think kids today probably see that
064SX Tech would give them you know an advantage in in that field so it's hard to fult anybody sort of pursuing so I think we wanted to provide just kind of a snapshot of what the current class of 20129 looks like are current eighth graders um we have 288 students right now in the current eth grade um of those students 214 have no active application to seek Ed their education Elsewhere for the upcoming school year we have 55 students who are pursuing an application Tech um and we have 19 private school students right now um the majority of these students I would say within the private school numbers um nine of those students are applying to two or more schools and two of those students are applying to a private school and to Essex Tech
065so the 55 students that I mentioned that are applying to private uh to Essex Tech 53 are solely applying to the tech and then two have a mix so the majority of our students are pretty sectioned off they're either saying at Masco they're looking at the tech or their private school there's not a lot of overlap there um of the 19 students that are applying down here we have 16 private schools that are represented in that grouping with the vast majority of them um or about the majority of them being at pingry then Brooks Governors St John's Prep Austin prep Philips Academy and over Philips exitor St Paul's and then we have a large handful of school students that have um schools that just active application so how Brad was talking about you know in
066the area we have a lot of private school opportunities we have a lot of educational opportunities for our students in this area um and they are taking advantage and spreading their wings a little bit here to to see what else is out there um most of these schools have application deadlines coming up on the 15th okay um St John's deadline was this past Monday so our number actually to St John's is significantly lower than what we've seen in past years um um the tech their deadline is this Friday that um gonna say that number last year was 801 to St John's no to Essex Tech Essex Tech yeah so Essex Tech number is already down a little bit there um and then our you know St John's is usually one of our I would say
067average is about 12 to 13 students that we see annually go there and that number has come down significantly there um for this year um because about that as well since St John introduced school we can start there now in sixth grade so we see some students that just go straight from our elementary into um St John's um but that has been several you know a couple of years now so that's not something that's just brand new to this year so we've seen um you know still even with the opportunity to go into sixth grade couple of years our numbers were still pretty consistent around that the mark So this year kind of like how our our Essex Tech numbers like kind of peaked last year you never know why there might be a certain
068e and flow as to why they're higher or they're lower one of the years but it's definitely something that we discussed for sure nth grade one interesting the Boston Globe has over the last price 12 months really been you know kind of hitting articles on private schools I print I brought them I I didn't make a copy but I can leave them they're interest to read that was was it the 30th was the last article where they actually you know talk about private school enrollments across the state are down but that's mostly because the inner city Catholic schools have all gone out of business but in the more affluent communities Private School enrollment is actually up um so it's you know it's definitely a socioeconomic thing at play here um so yes there's the access
069and the you know availability but we also have families with the wherewithal to to afford it and and I mean in terms of with that um technical education population I think a lot of families and a lot of students are being Savvy about the choices that they're making because of the cost of um college and education these days so for many of them I would have numerous conversations when I was counseling students and a lot of them would want to go on to um become plumbers or electricians or whatnot while they were here um but they would still want to go on to a four-year college instead of going off and doing their apprenticeship because that's what you're supposed to do um and I think now that mentality of wanting to go into the trade
070has kind of jumped a little bit ahead whereas instead of coming to the high school here they're going into that trade right into the tech and kind of getting a sense of of is this going to be you know I'm going to get a head start on my career because as we always say to students um you know there's always going to be need for a plumber for you know dental hygiene cosmetologist like that is a growing need and that is a skill that is really important and to find someone in those fields that you can trust is a great thing um so we want to make sure that we're providing them the opportunity to gain access to those things and learn learn about them and I think they're just starting to realize um because
071it's hard to kind of break the norm right of what everyone else done um and to be able to start doing that sooner I think good is to them for doing it because I wish you know for those that should be going on to trade and accessing that we want them to be able to do that um and so I'm glad that they can start realizing that part of their life can start sooner than before and maybe with a little less debt um so moving forward I think it's important for us to start having U more open conversations with our students um so I've been chatting with the middle school counselors about as they're um following up with students about their applications for what they've put forward and when we find out when the um
072decisions are being made to kind of get a sense from them based on the outcomes of their applications what are they thinking about their decisions um do they have questions about going forward to the tech or going forward to the high school year private school what could be the pros and the cons of those um experiences and so just having more Frank open conversations with them and then as they have made decisions and if they do decide to move on from us um to specifically between counselor and student have a conversation and then from our end send out family surveys to get you know it's always interesting to get a student perspective and a parent perspective because they could be very different or they could be exactly the same who knows um so sending those
073out towards the spring so that way we can have that information and if it is something that we should hear and we should know about so that we can improve our programming and opportunities for students here it'll be good to hear it might be hard to hear but it'll be good for us to hear so that we work on that um because we always want to be growing and moving forward as a community start do you mind going back up to the top where you list reasons people leaving um so by the way thank you for putting all this data together I think there's some really good data here um and I think that this is a good list I I think buried in some of these bullets here is Prospect of some displeasure with
074something here at mascow and it goes back to the point that you brought up at the end right about the surveys and asking why but it goes back to the question of are we doing something that's supposed to be are we not doing something that's are we not doing something well that's supposed to be in our Charter and our people now electing to pursue these other opportunities because of that so we have a lot of data on where they're going and perhaps at a high level you know why not Masco but I appreciate that you guys are pointing out there's still more data to collect and it's Soft Data it's not the hard data that you're that we have today so yeah we had a pretty lengthy as BR said discussion about this very slide
075of you know with that question of Are We is there something we can do to change that was the other thing I wrote down right there something we can do to to that's that's the question at the end of the day are people are people just choosing because of these things and a lot of them we can't have impact over y or are you know they choosing a know is this state is this just not speculating what causes could be we don't know I mean these are really kind of speculative I mean these are but generally these are the the a lot of the reasons people go these are the like it's all that's what you hear when you ask you know like I I've had not a thousand but a hundred of these conversations
076probably in life with either my friends who left or with people who are currently here whose kids are leaving and typically it's something along those lines but you might add to this list as you move be a sck these are anot these are data right no right but also you know I think you know their points like if if someone isn't made you know isn't their goal is don't want m they should be open to go somewhere else and I think you it's solid Point saying you want what's best for the student but we also want to know if we're you know not delivering on our side right that's a it's it's a two-sided coin right right well I I'll tell you in 2012 I left St John's from working there and I was the
077director of admission um before I came back to the public school world and this these are the reasons that people chose St joh because we did survey students and families back then um the only other thing that I would ask to that is um a perceived academic Excellence because St John's is a preparatory school and number of APS and things like that um but that was that was very soft data because it you know people it's you don't really know that until you get there and and if that's the right fit for your child or not um and there were two children that did Lo leave St John's to come back to their public high school um for various reasons one of those being Athletics as well because Athletics at and schools like that are
078very very competitive um versus Masco when and we have kids that can play All Sports and a lot of the teams here don't have FS that was a big reason why students left Chris so thank you I want to join in all the thanks for me the most telling slide was a slide that speaks to this first bullet of that the number one reason was trades right Plumbing yeah we can't do that and it's amazing that the students who live in this District have access to Essex Tech which is you know the best of the best in that area however I also think what we're what I'm reading from what you've presented is this strong desire and passion that we're seeing globally not just in Massachusetts not just Nationwide globally for experiential Ed Project based
079learning and particularly in the postco environment right where students want to learn by doing and there's a lot of media and talk about it and Essex Tech is a leader in that however I think our problem is that we are not communicating what happens here because if you really dig into what experiential education is we have it in Spades here The Internship is just one example service-based learning project based learning opportunities for employment for projects within the community for uh teaching assistant opportunities those are all experiential education you're getting it here I'm watching friends and peers of my children go through the ess6 tech programs and try to navigate what they were looking for and it is very narrow when you get there because you have to choose a particular path there's more opportunity for
080exploration in the experiential learning that this curriculum provides I think our problem is after reading this data a Communications issue I say the same thing sorry you said earlier the perception when you're at you know St John's does always match reality and I think we always have a perception Gap at Moscow because people do leave here and do that was another point I was about to make is the perceived academic excellence and that's where it's like I wish we could do some kind of a longitudinal study because the kids who were all at my house over the winter break who are in college are killing it who came from mcow and they sticking with the colleges where they landed and they are leadership positions and fellowships and co-ops and internships opportunities are endless and the
081perceived academic Excellence is underrated here um so I think it it goes back to another Communications issue and then when you think about you talk about I want to be able to support the students who want to be in the trades and in those fields but I read this fantastic article from The Brookings Institute this morning about people who enter the trades with an Associate or a bachelor's degree have higher lifetime earnings because they're more entrepreneurial they know how to run their business better Network sales Etc and now that also addressing the debt issue Community College is now free in Massachusetts and the UMass system is now moving towards UMass Boston is now free there are a lot of ways to eliminate academic debt and still earn higher education that can help you pursue experiential
082programs um professions that hit all of those notes and that can be part of our Charter like we want to give everyone all the options and let them know what the options are but I think people there's a misperception of what your options are coming out of Masco well you'll notice data notice in the data we present to you the the number one school obviously is the free choice it's you know the cost really is Big a concern for the families who are choosing the the private schools you know and we're we're also the free choice you know here at Mas I think that's I I agree with you important to note that Erica I noticed something similar just I'm looking at this list before the meeting about a fifth of the students not knowing
083all the specifics of these programs there are five of them I would not classify as a trade that I think and Community relation subcommittee is going to dig into this more have really competitive courses with biotechnology engineering some of the things that Chris was speaking to were if a fifth of the students and of course not all are going to Essex tech for courses and programs that we can be really competitive with that is within our wheelhouse a place for us to explore certainly which we have plan to do excuse me um and I just I want to reiterate completely agree with everything that you just said Chris but really with the the like thought and fluency around Financial Empowerment when it comes to debt and the short-term understanding of what that means to have
084student loans versus the long-term earnings potential I think that there I don't know what we're doing explicitly to share with students that now but and families the fear that can understandably and rightfully come with that can really be a determent a a detriment in the long run and so I think that having a really clear view of how we are competing with Essex Tech and things on this list and where places where we are not which I think we are all in agreement there are many places in which we are not and don't want to is really important but the specificity of those conversations in relation to the financial impact uh I think is an important one too so excited for the work that the community relation sub commit is doing there because I think
085it will be really enlightening um in addition to going and seeing those classrooms in a six Tech in person um and then seeing what we're offering will be really enlightning too Adrian do you have something yeah I'm just curious to go back to I again wholeheartedly birthe everything you said Christine the the idea of experiential learning as a a parent of the middle schooler I have no idea that we have experiential learning in the high SCH School setting I don't know that there's a ton of it going on in middle school and it's probably not necessarily like as easy to get into that because you're getting a little more specificity in those High School courses but maybe there's an opportunity to expose the seventh and eighth graders to what's coming and get them excited about
086it I don't know what that looks like necessarily but some something that gets the kids excited will communicate to parents and those conversations start happening and they involve Masco and what's available um just you know I would I would love to know what's coming because I think it's just more of the same which for me I think is fantastic she's had a great experience here but I don't know what else is there I mean I think there is a level that's a little bit also but a little bit of what excuse me Katie and the folks in the high school would you know Beginning by kind of bringing that back you know bring eighth graders in and sort of meet with some of the staff in the high school and sort of see what you
087know what it can look like um but yeah no point we'll take it yeah we also have um with the eighth graders we started this last year the peer leaders from the high school pair up with um an eighth grader in the spring and bring them up to the high school and talk about the program and things that they do and that just started last year it wasn't in place before that so we are being more purposeful about transitioning the eighth graders to the ninth graders or to n9th grade um but again you know how many kids are going home to talk about that with their parents probably not that many you know we we we put it in our newsletter the eighth graders are doing this this week coming up say in May um
088but yeah it's not something you necessarily hear about I will say too when I was here we also had like student Le a student Le open house where I had a group I don't know if it was because of I was in student council or peer leading where we had a group going and with parents going through the high school we went into um I wanted go to like the medical field at that time that's why I was looking at SX Tech but we have a program here where you can get EMT certified um through taking the EMT course and I was like why would I go there when I can get somewhat of the same experience here so bringing those parents in showing the medical students that like we have this option you take
089this track course and um you can end on a very similar path and trajectory so we do do some of that is there room to grow there's of course but yeah that's it I agree with it's like a communication issue it's also a mindset shift for our community to say that Masco can provide you these opportunities and you don't have to go to um I think that's a big reason why a lot we're not getting to the IV at this point just because kids are sort of realizing where they want to maybe they're not applying to them because they know where they want to go um but I want to say that a choice that my son wanted to go to Tech but then on the eighth grade open house many years ago we were
090up in engineering lab and that really sealed the deal for Masco because it was Hands-On learning and um as a family we were very much when we were doing the college process that starts as a junior year we really knew where his strengthwise and the guidance Department actually Julie was my son's guide and counselor for a while they sort of steered them towards the programs that would be best for Hands-On learning um and ultimately he chose the school that was learn do learn um which was is exper experiential learning um but it's it's a mind shft mind set shift and the more that we talk about it and we bring these programs um and I was thinking SX Tech after dark doesn't have this Myriad of list it's only electrical and I think carpentry right
091no no so we we what they have Avail like space Oh okay so it's that bottom of the list smaller oh whe there's you know newer students that they have open in because it's less popular like you know penion animals so like I see that like that might not even help our students bring in SX Tech after dark because yeah that's what we've been so our administration's been going as te after dark meetings for this whole semester and you know things those are their under enrolled programs like they're because we were thinking about you know budget's coming up is there something we want to try and pursue for next year and you know it's not everything that we thought it was so I think it's something to talk about some more and it's pricing yeah
092yeah and it's five students for how much 4 $338,000 I'm thinking like it's probably not even necessary if you have things like intros intro to um engineering and you touch on some of these things um I saw Joe and then Kendra and then we'll go back to Adrian Okay so this is probably a lesser question after the last few um if you go back two slides to student placement by year just for um from a usefulness perspective moving forward because one of the things that I'm I was hoping to get out of this data today was to be able to predict how many kids we're going to to lose we expect to lose as we're heading into budget season here right so what I'm curious about is looking back at this data um how many
093kids actually applied uh to leave and then also um it would be good to have the total number of kids in the class though I know we can get that that I can get that data another place but how many total kids were applying to leave and how many of them actually left you know is it a 100% rate for everyone accepted or is you know is it 80% of the kids CU you just said that there's 74 applying how many can we expect to to to lose is a question for me yeah that's really hard to predict because this uh I mean last year we had 82 applications to Essex Tech and then um they they took 40 had 42 kids that that went um but this year we're trending lower a lot lower
094on the SX Tech applications and the other applications as well it's just it's very very hard we we never thought last year that we were going to have 80 plus applications to Essex Tech and that many kids go that was much much higher than we' seen but that's kind of where I'm getting at is is what percentage of the class actually applied um because yes there's a difference in data year to year here but the class size might have been very different year to year for instance um or it was just a huge Spike one year and it resulted in a huge number of of um additional kids uh know that the data is going to be noisy but it would just be good to have that historical record to refer to because I mean
095we would all agree that it's not going to be more than 74 kids leaving right and we would say it's probably gonna be half of them at least oh it could be a lot right Jo I think um so the previous 8th grade had 281 students this 8th grade had 291 so about a 10 student difference and the numbers we're seeing of applications to Essex Tech I think is a positive for us on our end just on what we're seeing now it absolutely is I'm thinking of the person who's sitting here 3 years from now who wants to look at this data and have a historical perspective and be able to say Okay I I I understand where this is headed and what we're doing that's all that'll be in our budget though the the
096student enrollment numbers are yeah that was that was part of the that was part of the 101 report but they're all they're all after the fact is my my point if you're trying to predict what's going to happen next year right I think let me just pop pop in here for a second I I think what I'm hearing Joe say is that we have the data I think on a year-by-year basis of of what the applications are um where where they ultimately went so how many of them actually left another useful data point in in analyzing this this data going forward is if we had a sense of is it is it 80% that leave once they get accepted is it 20% that leaves and by school um I mean honestly I think that's a
097pretty mundane calculation I mean I don't I don't I don't think it's no that's that's that's not what I'm saying I want to know the toal the total okay the total number of applicants actually actually that applied so that when we get to this point every year next year the number is going to be 73 right um I can't compare back to this year without knowing that there were uh 74 this year next year we come here there's a chart that's shown here's how many people left the 74 that we now are talking about has disappeared it's not in the data anymore that's my point it's not written down anywhere it has as a separate uh number it's a mundane thing but it's it's a predictive um um piece of data that we should we
098should keep somewhere do we know how many people applied in 2021 for instance probably not right applied to S Tech or to anywhere anywhere M to to anywhere to anywhere yeah it's not on this on the slide but I'm sure we could we could have to yeah I'm sure they could get yeah so just add the total number of of out placement applicants for each year and I think that that would be a little more accept illustrative that's all well I think having it by percentage personally I think that's actually more useful um because that would enable you to to predict as we go into budget seon how what we think the enrollment changes might be not just the raw number here yeah but you can calculate the percentage that's easy enough either way either
099one either number works right okay I'm done thank you next um I had to set a quick question so about the um the curriculum and the the courses and the classes that are being offered here similar to what was mentioned earlier I have no idea I mean I know my daughter came home one day and mentioned that there's a a radio station or there's like a local thing I was like you know why aren't you doing this or why didn't you sign up for it are you kidding so I is there some kind of a like a specific newslet that will maybe could go out to parents or families before the school year highlighting some of those pieces of the curriculum maybe it does it and maybe I yeah I mean that's so so like
100the radio station or everything else so students have they have an activities fair for all the ninth graders inber it's a club okay not a club and I believe the slide deck from the Pres from all of those presentations went home to families is that it's usually sent out like here leaders put it together um all the clubs and organizations that are available and that gets posted on the website and students have access to it right um we publish an application form and it's on the website and yeah that can that's the clubs and activities information and then we have you know in addition to the radio station we have the TV station station so there's classes that are associated with that um equipment and such and so uh in March we have a course
101selection night where we talk about and highlight the different opportunities new courses unique courses like the EMT class Trevor was talking about um to highlight to to families um so even students who we know are applying elsewhere um or who are adamant that they're going somewhere else we still have them go through the course selection process so they pick classes uh as if they are coming up here because one I've seen my time kids on our door on the first day of school during their freshman year they like no I am coming here here um and so we have something for them kind of pre-planned but it also gives them an opportunity to kind of take another look at us and look and see what classes and what courses they could take if they were
102coming up here um so that that is that just in person or is there something that a program of studies that will be available online a to read and that's available in February parent for selection night for parent section night that's my for parents yeah so the program that we have talk about I guess I was trying to think of an e easier way to sort of organize and highlight some of the I want to say some of the coolest without putting them all on there but as much as we can of a of a selection to show when we specifically are talking about trades or or kind of those labor intensive you know opportunities here at school or at this school at least to maybe organize it to get it out there a little
103bit better maybe maybe it's on on me or on us as school committee to sort of gather those together and Flash out to say Hey you know if you're like EMT or TV state or whatever other as much as we can of a of an opportunity to get that information out as easy as possible for parents I mean I feel like an idiot that I didn't know that but but that's again I think that's part of the problem there is a little bit of a disconnect it's there we just have to organize it and get it out there a little bit more frequently I guess is what I'm looking and if you're looking for the program on studies online right now it's because we're updating it is that why I'm like I like updating it
104now we're going into that was even the organizations and clubs so that's why I was there the so one of the things that I know you guys work closely with essextech to have them come in and do presentations for the students so they they understand what they offer and are there any discussions about maybe bringing in some of those Masco alumni who are in the trade and maybe did matriculate from Masco and maybe didn't Associates or went right into the trades and they talk about their experience and how Masco help them just to kind of we definitely we have that will reach out to us and that we want to come in and and talk to students and when those opportunities present we definitely take advantage of them could we be tapping more into our
105graduates and you know of all you know experiences and such more yes 100% and last year for example we had two uh young women who are Coast Guard Office that presentation that was great yeah you know so talking about things that you know our kids are doing yeah I think it'd be a good way you know we did kind of before covid you know we had that engineering day with the math department which was you know amazing where you know Engineers within the community would come in and speak to classes of kids about this is how you pursue this career the courses you should be taking and things um I think we're kind of building that stuff back um a lot of that sort of infrastructure when Co sort of closed the building it sort
106of close those opportunities for a few years but I think we're of Turn The Lights On Again to a lot of those things so hopefully more to come and I think we're also working now in such like we always talk in my office about how we're trying to prepare kids for jobs that don't ex exist yeah because the job world is just changing so much and the Outlook is changing so it's really about able skills and attainable skills and usable skills and and how that can be you know transferable skills um to use in any opportunity you know that pops up to them once they leave here um because you know all know that AI didn't exist you know them for that so um so here we are so we'll um we're trying to evolve
107constantly and to be aware of what's happening out there so so we can make sure that the kids have the information to be best prepared as well Chris I'll skip it anyone else I'm any discussion all right I don't think so well thank you guys for coming in taking the time to that data together okay and then from here see the fy2 Financial forecast and Jeff will be walking us through that presentation Jeff I'd like to invite Brad to join us at the table he owns the largest variance in our budget so yeah he knew he knew yeah he and I he and I texted get in front of your screen was you had a hard time you're good right thanks it might make sense for me to go through the presentation and then um
108hold questions till the end and then we can field them all um so first forecast for the year uh preliminary forecast as of December 31st uh where we've completed a little little over 40% of the uh the current school year and 50% of the fiscal year um it's more likely than not that the forecast will change uh as the year progresses uh despite a very large variance that we'll get into in a particular area of our budget um I've developed a plan and a forecast that keeps the district on budget for the year uh slightly favorable to budget so we'll get into some of those details in a minute uh the next forecast will will be presented uh updated and presented in early April um and then we'll go over the attached for um revenue
109and expense variance details um I've highlighted the primary drivers so the accounts that have not been specified in the forecast are assumed to be on budget uh for the year so the next slide is an overview of kind of the numbers U of the budget um that first section shows that Revenue uh or income is um forecasted to be favorable the budget by $196,000 I'll go into those details and our expense budget after offsets is forecasted to run uh a little over $192,000 unfavorable the budget which results in a forecast versus budget of uh roughly $4,000 was favorable very very close so that's the good news the bad news is and and I'll get into the details um we're going to have to use some of our uh sacred reserves to make this happen um
110which for a CFO is not something that you ever want to have to do but we'll talk about that so from a revenue perspective um revenues are forecast at the end to end the year uh roughly $196,000 is favorable to budget two primary drivers there um Chapter 70 is forecasted to run $117,000 favorable to budget and that's basically a difference between the preliminary cherry sheet that we used to build the budget and approve the budget and the final budget U that the state approved in August uh there was an additional $74 per student in Chapter 70 funding approved in the state's budget and for Masco that means an additional $117,000 will come our way um interest income is forecasted to run $882,000 favorable to budget so when I say interest income interest income refers to
111interest the district earns on its deposits in interest bearing accounts currently the district maintains interest bearing Accounts at TD Bank and the mass Municipal depository trust interest rate Ates over the past two years have ranged from roughly 3.5% to 5.5% so interest income for this year is trending ahead of our fy2 budget which was established using um for the most part FY 23 actuals of about $190,000 as The Benchmark um additionally um this year's interest income is trending slightly behind last year's actuals of $33,000 uh as as our interest rates continue to fall so as you can see we budgeted $190,000 in interest income I'm forecasting uh roughly $273,000 in interest income um over the course of the Year expenses on the other hand are a different story so expenses before offsets are forecasted end
112the year approximately 174,000 unfavorable to budget what' I say you said one 74 674 th000 unfavorable the budget I'm not sure what I said um it's getting late expenses after offsets are forecast at the end of the year approximately $192,000 unfavorable the budget and there's several uh primary drivers that and make up those numbers and I'll go through those salaries all salaries are forecasted um to end the year approximately $229,000 favorable to budget that's made up of two primary issues $160,000 of that is through replacement savings so over the course of the spring and the summer and the fall we had 25 open positions we filled those positions and we we that resulted in $60,000 in FA salaries that were ran favorable to budget interestingly enough half of that that savings came through two positions
113that we hadn't budgeted for they were um they weren't planned I'll call them terminations but they're voluntary terminations um so these people left we didn't know about it we didn't reflect that in the budget we replaced them and we saved with just those two people a little over $80,000 uh the second item driving um the part of that $229,000 favorable variance is the fact that there's no title one grant funding in fy2 so this resulted in two things so first No tit uh $69,000 in title one teacher salary savings so we didn't have a title one teacher coming into the year if we got grant funding our plan was to hire a title one teacher we didn't get grant funding so we didn't hire hire a title one teacher um but at the same time
114as you know in the budget we budgeted an offset of $588,000 in Title One Grant salary offset so I have to cancel that out as well so it only yields $111,000 worth of favorable um budget variance in the end uh just a little bit more on the title one Grant so 2022 Federal Census Bureau poverty and population data for Mass school districts was used to calculate the fy2 title one allocations earlier this year so after we established our budgets uh at that time it was determined that Masco was no longer eligible for Title One grant funding so that kind of played itself out at the beginning of the fiscal year and those are the results um so here's our largest unfavorable U cost category um forecast out of District tuition out of District transportation and
115Consultants are forecasted at $798,000 unfavorable the budget and the primary driver behind that number and the reason why I asked my friend Brad to to join me um that we have eight additional outof District placements currently versus our budget so there's currently 70 placements versus a budget of 62 placements so normally you can't overcome a $100,000 unfavorable variance in a particular cost category so what I what I need to do is increase our circuit breaker offset so take our circuit breaker Reserve account and pull from that account an additional $440,000 to cover these unanticipated unbudgeted cost increases zero at the end of the year um so we can field some questions on that at the end property and liability insurance is forecasted at 25,000 unfavorable to budget uh the district's property and liability insurance policy
116was put out to bid for FY 25 and like the last two years um before this one um unfortunately the bid process only yielded one submission from our current provider which is glatfelter National Union fire uh insurance company um this problem um for the lack of a better term is driven by the fact that our three years claims history um was terrible if you recall three and four years ago we had we had two extremely extremely large uh claims the first was a lightning strike that caused roughly $400,000 worth of damage to various parts of our infrastructure and then in Fe on February 1st of 2021 which was our last clim uh we had a flood in the Middle School utility room that caused a ton of damage as well so if we can get
117past February 1 of 2025 that'll clear us negative claims history which will enable me to put next year's policy out to bid with the hopes of getting a much more favorable premium and options to choose from which it hasn't been the case over the last couple of years M next house insurance costs on the other hand are forecasted to end the year $90,000 F $90,000 favorable the budget um and the driver behind that is that we've got uh net three fewer HMO individual and three fewer HMO family plan enroles U versus budget so together um uh that will if that holds that'll drive a $90,000 favorable variance budget so the last two categories I'll talk about I wanted to provide the community and the committee a little bit of background on utility costs because a
118lay person isn't necessarily familiar with how utility bills work so um bear with me um so National Grid is our District's delivery company for both electricity and gas all electric and gas bills are comprised of two separate charges one for delivery and one for Supply based on actual consumption delivery charges cover the cost of maintaining the infrastructure that delivers the utility like telephone poles and pipelines and all those all those kinds of things while Supply while Supply charges cover the cost of the utility itself so the poles and the wires that bring the electricity to the to Masco is delivery the electricity itself is Supply the district can either purchase Supply directly from National Grid or delivery company or it can put Supply out for competitive bid and award it to a supplier other than
119National Grid in my professional experience with utilities the bid process is 100 % the way to go it always yields the most favorable pricing the market has to offer it's a lot of work but it always yields the best pricing so the district's electric and gas supply contracts recently expired and they were put out to bid competitively and awarded awarded to suppliers other than National Grid which yielded the best pricing available in the marketplace it's a lot higher than the pricing that we previously had but it's the best pricing that was available at the time in the marketplace so National Grid is our delivery company company as I said and they will continue to deliver to us regardless of who our supply company is that's the background so electricity is forecasted to run at $84,000
120unfavorable to budget so there's two things driving that first is the loss this first one has nothing to do with what I just talked about first is the loss of approximately $50,000 in net metor metering credit savings through unanticipated changes to the May 2021 net metering agreement that we entered into at the town of Boxford uh you were all copied on my email to the Boxford uh Board of selectman chair on October 2nd the chair responded to me on October 18th and I have not heard from the Town Administrator to the state which is disappointing um so the second piece is has to do with Supply costs so I'm forecasting the the district to run $34,000 unfavorable to our electricity budget because of increased Supply costs so we entered into a new four-year Electric City
121Supply contract which became effective on no November 18th 2024 with Constellation Energy and this new contract which reflected the best pricing available in the marketplace reflected an increase of 20% over the prior contract so it increased um the price of electricity Supply from 9 cents per kilow kilowatt hour to roughly 11 cents per k hour um that's the bad news the good news is that I'm forecasting consumption or volume for the year to remain unchanged versus budget at roughly 2.85 million kilowatt hours for the year so that's electricity for gas I'm forecasting the district to run $86,000 on favorable to budget $211,000 has to do with uh increased gas supply costs we entered into a new 2-year gas supply contract which becomes effective on January 1st 2025 with Direct Energy NRG this also reflects roughly
122a 20% increase in Supply rates but it also reflects the best pricing available on the marketplace this increased our gas supply from $6 roughly $6.50 to roughly $8 per deca I'm also forecasting the district and the year um an additional 65,000 um due to additional gas consumption costs as uh forecasting as usage for the year is expected to increase approximately 20 20% versus budget to 29,000 decm age in it and we've heard this a lot in our conversations about the capital plan and with the DCI the age and inefficiency of our existing mechanical equipment continues to worsen it's more inefficient this year than it was last year and more inefficient than it was the year year before and it will just keep getting worse coupled with the fact that our existing BMS so remember the
123BMS is the building management system it's the headend it's the brains the computer behind controlling ring 300 plus pieces of equipment that's pretty much failed so on October 1st I turn everything on it cranks and I don't turn it off until May and we have very little ability to you know do nightly setbacks weekend setbacks I know when I leave my house in the morning I have my little thermostat programmed to go to 64 degrees or whatever right and then before the boss gets home it's back up there right so that's I mean that that's essentially like in the easiest form you can't do that like a BMS and we can't do that so what we would have to do if we want to toggle we would need an army of people running around the
124building adjusting 300 pieces of equipment including on the roof when it snows right it's not feasible so we can't set the set it back at night we can't set it back on the weekend vacation week the Heat's running and efficiency cost a talking point in the capital plan discussion yeah okay good so you know so gas usage is projected to run at an all-time high and FY 25 so when I got here a little less than six years ago we used 19,000 decm now roughly six 60% of those 300 pieces of mechanic mechanical equipment weren't working right so it's hard to measure what the true increases because we've repaired all the equipment it's all working at its optimal State we take care of it all we provide maintenance and we've lost complete control of the
125BMS so I don't know how much of the you know that $10,000 10,000 decm increases due to what but a lot of it's due to the fact that the equipment is you know anywhere from 25 to 60 years old right and needs to be replaced I won't get into that so um so that's the Crux of the forecast those are the primary drivers the majority of these variances will carry forward into our conversation two weeks from now so remember what we've what we've talked about in terms of a of District placements in terms of utility costs in terms of property and liability insurance hopefully some of that goes away um but a lot of these big ticket item variances will translate into a much bigger ask in our level service budget recommendation that you'll begin
126to hear from us on the 22nd so um um a lot of work and thought obviously went into this Brad and I because of the nature of a lot of the things that he does and the fluidity and unpredictability of a lot of the costs and his space we spend a tremendous amount of time together we prepare a monthly forecast on how to District placements related Transportation costs contracted service providers um and Brad and his team has done you know done a really good job in a short period of time getting me the things that I need to make sure that we're on track to stay within our appropriation so I'm sure things will change between now and April 5 5th when I present it the next time if something happens that puts us off
127course I'll be back before April 5th to let you know right if we get 10 more placements that we didn't know about today hypothetically um you'll know about it right because um you know we're getting toward we're now getting towards to the thick of the year and towards the end of the year where uh we don't have a lot of flexibility to deal with either so um that's what I've got any questions it's for Brad hi Brad um eight additional can you can can you speak to those placements what grades were the student are these students who've been here they knew like yeah I don't know how much detail I can give you a lot right so I can just I think the underlying question is how to eight kids how are they not on
128our radar right so yeah good question um those like the primary way that happens is but there's a couple of ways right a move in somebody who moves in from out of town out of District um oftentimes um you know that would reflect a sixth grader who was planning to come to mow and then who maybe one of the towns we kind of inherit that um there are situations where again we're planning on somebody coming here and um at an elementary school at a team meeting anywhere that could be unilateral placement where that's a parent and a family making their own decision to then seeking us to pay for it so those are kids who aren't necessarily on our radar um or it could be you know a a Basco student who has you know
129maybe uh a change in their level of need or their level of service that exceeds what we you know feel we can manage here um those four cover yeah Brad and I looked at this a couple of weeks ago one of the interesting things is of those 70 students 41 have never set foot in this building so we never got a shot I mean that's that happen so like Brad said either there a move in that was already in and out a district placement or you know um something that happened in sixth grade that we you know like our under like specialed guidelines it's free and appropriate public education so that's our Charter that's our Tas ask and you know the term appropriate what does that mean it means you know your your programming has
130to be you know reasonably reasonably calculated for the student to make effective progress another vague term right so um there are times when um there are students who you know wouldn't make effective progress at mascow and you know the elementary school they wouldn't make effective progress at any of the elementary schools and they get placed in a different school then when their time at you know the tri toown school is up and they come here you know we they stay they stay in their out of District placement and don't come here District placement because we're not set up to accommodate certain things just quick follow up to that like since we have a substantially separate program these like that's almost 12 kids per grade that's like that's a substantial number 70 it's a big number
131it's a lot it's really big so I guess my and I understand that you can't speak too specifically but when it comes to the specific type of disability when it comes to these eight because I believe that I we talked about the 62 earlier um or last year in the budget season but what types of disabilities are we seeing because I guess my question is do we have a need specific to Staffing and budget that would be related to beef up some programming here or are we talking about um you know maybe just different disabilities where we're not the place we're going to be the place and it's appropriate for us to not be the place because that number is just PR really big oh it's huge yeah um wait what is that is that
1324% just under a thousand it's I think that's a number yeah oh wait is that that's a that's a district that's actually just to be be fair that 70 covers students who are till 22 till 22 right because our responsibility continues so is it grade 7 12 or 9 through 12 that we're talking about right now 7 12 I think eight of the 70 are seventh grade2 years of age our enrollment number is a 7 to2 enrollment but those 70 are essentially 12 year olds till 22 so seventh grade 22 four years past the senior in high school I think eight of them I think eight of them are between 18 and 22 so I was gonna so and we'll do Sor sorry to interrupt hold that thought so we'll do that same stratification that
133you talked about on the 70 or whatever the number is going to be in two weeks yeah it might be 69 or 68 or 70 or yeah we're still fine- tuning that number but we'll still we'll do that you know the number and the why and it's a good question and it's a question that you know I ask myself I ask these guys I ask you know you know I think we just like what can we be doing differently what should we be doing something differently can we kind of you know some of these students and the challenge is critical mass right to and and the ability to invest in a program and get a return on it in a small District like this is you don't really hard to don't make savings when you
134do that because those those 70 don't come back even if you Institute a program it's really going to be trying to keep more from going out later you don't you know once once somebody's in a placement it's really hard to get somebody to come back to keep their kids in District with their peers as many as you think not as many as you think no a lot of times when people get into a program they like it they're comfortable there their kids are doing well why change it um you know that's why I said my frustration is that that 41 that have never been um you know some of those are unilateral you know that that's I think there's a breakdown in that 6 to7 transition where it's like you know I'm in my neighborhood
135school and I know everybody and you know I've heard all these you know when I meet with the seventh graders and eighth graders they talk about well teachers here are really nice that's not what we were told you know and I think that you know plays on a on a larger scale here where parents say you know I don't want to send them the big bad Masco I'm gonna you know put them in a private school you know unilaterally and then they come back to us for us are there any big categories of disabilities like ADHD or like a or Trends you were seeing or reading emotional disabil reading been the big reading the biggest Trend reading been the big one we have a lot of services for emotional it's it's really reading is the
136one we're seeing dyslexia specifically or like that yeah kids looking for you know needing some pretty serious high level reading interventions but yeah definitely kids who are reading several years below grade level whether that dyslexia or not is something that we've really been looking at and trying to you know part of part of our conversation with Dr Morrison a couple of weeks ago was what's going what what do you what's happening with reading in the elementary schools because we're seeing a big number of kids coming up with serious issues and they've they promised the changes are coming but but again that's going to take years to I think what's tricky too is I've noticed this over my career is that the multiple dis like there's just like a a tapestry kids of you know some
137might be dyslexic and might also have ADHD and so it's sometimes it's you know tricky to parse out necessarily what's what's what and how to most effectively program um Lisa did you finish your point well no I oh yeah I guess you kind of danced around it like because you said you're going to have better numbers in a couple of weeks but I was just curious as to if you had an idea as to we won't have better numbers we'll have different numbers and we'll have yeah like how many are and we'll have more information yeah right do you do you have an idea as to that or will you we'll have all the we'll have all that data for as part of the the budget process beginning in two weeks okay Melissa so it's
138about four 4.7% of our students have had a district placements is that normal for a district like Masco hi hi Sor I didn't know if it was an affluence the average is six% um because sometimes families with more resources are more likely to um to our previous conversation it does not help that a lot of V district schools happen to be on the NorthShore and happen to be within you know and yeah and there's just certain communities that have more knowledge around certain um programming and things like that you know whole point you know we have probably a nationally known School for students who are reading disabilities a drive away at lant I mean so those are the kinds of things that that we do wrestle with and we can never have a landmark at
139Masco because wouldn't be we can try but again it's always that you know how how can you be better than them you know yeah exactly well so be fair you you could well they're they've got a lot of they got a PR machine that makes it they do a lot of PD they come I mean well I've spent a lot of time there I'm pretty familiar like it's but yeah they' got other other things that are in their favor anyone else I had a question about circuit breaker when do we or do we can we anticipate how much we will get back from this year on the other end it's part of the whole okay projection process yeah so I I spent a lot of time on that Trevor believe it or not because I
140needed I needed to be pretty certain that if I used 440 that I felt comfortable enough knowing that the results of the claim for for this year that we file in July would be sufficient enough to cover what I'm recommending as an offset in two weeks that was my question yeah so I think I'm I'm pretty certain we're good unless the state changes its mind on you know circuit breaker reimbursement rates which is right now 75% on the tuition side of the calculation and roughly 44% on the eligible Transportation side of the calculation so I feel pretty good about it okay thank you yeah anyone else y um for the net metering credit with the town of box are we going to keep fighting with them that or I I'm I'm exhausted by it so
141so yeah so we we entered into this agreement back in 2021 so it was an agreement that I worked on with um that that they pestered us on for two years to get into so we'll leave that part out but um no I'm not yeah so so anyway so uh during Co the height of cover Co we sorted it out we got the agreement done um Mike and I signed off from a the district's perspective the board of selectman signed off from the town's perspective so basically what net metering is for some of you that don't know right is Boxford has a solar field and that solar field produces x amount of excess um electricity that the town had determined that they didn't have the need for so w use the word pester so they
142they came to mascow and said we want you to use it great so um and you get you can buy it from us at a discounted rate which is the the cool part right so um so we can buy 20% of what's produced by the solar field at roughly a 25% um um discount off of Market rates and will generate roughly $50,000 worth of savings for the district that's pretty good so everybody signs off and it took us for it took us 14 months to get this thing set up with the with National Grid with the owner of the solar field with the town with the state it was brutal so we get it there was a dozen of us working on it for 14 months so we get it set up and then it
143starts humming away and then which was awesome and then last spring goes to zero on me so I called over to the town and they said yeah we've decided to use those excess credits on our own municipal buildings and I said to the town administrators are you can't do that we have a contract they blew me off so I wrote to Margaret the board of selectman chair who responded and said the Town Administrator would reach out to me and I haven't heard from him in three months if you ask me to keep pursuing it I will keep pursuing it at your if those are your wishes but um I I've taken it out of the I've taken it out of the forecast and I'm I've taken it out of budget recommendation for for the 22nd
144we have a contract for five years uh for a minimum of 20 years 20 years wow there's 16 years left on the term of the contract I put that that's you can refer to my note that I copied all you guys on the contracts in that note too yeah so I don't know just crazy it just seems like in the scheme of things yeah 50,000 is a drop in the bucket but if we can get get back $50,000 and use that somewhere else so 50,000 over years years yeah yeah obviously okay I know yeah it's getting late you don't have to tell me I mean I'm the one facing this thing okay yeah anyways that's the answer to that any more questions or discussion about the forecast thanks guys yeah thanks BR um and good
145news we're actually punting item H until join us in person so we're still almost on schedule um so I'm going to hand it over to Melissa the second reading of policy section d y so as presented it's just the clean up version second reading of policy section D um I just took the red lines out and I will entertain a motion if there are no questions I'll make a motion to accept the changes a second hey I have a motion from Bill a second from Erica to accept um policy section d as presented by Melissa and because Joe's on zoom we're going to have to do a roll call so Bill yes Kendra yes Melissa yes Jeff yes Erica yes Matt yes Adrien yes Lisa yes Joe yes and I am a yes so policy
146section D yes I'm a yes oh sorry Chris you weren't here when I wrote my list down and Chris said yes so it passes unanimously and thank you to the policy subcommittee for the continued efforts and getting us closer so then I will pass it on for the superintendent report all right first up uh we have we're in the process of conducting a survey regarding uh parents and Guardians experiences uh with our schools uh We've partnered with the education Commonwealth project uh ECP which is a research group located at the University of Massachusetts at ammer uh to administer the survey uh ECP surveys are currently in use in districts across the state encompassing uh more than 10% of all students in Mass Metts Public Schools uh this past Monday January 6th all uh masconomet families
147received an email uh from no reply at qemil server.com uh that contained a personalized link to the survey and so we ask people if they did not receive uh that email to please check their spam filter uh before contacting their child's school um the survey itself will take uh 15 to 20 minutes to complete uh and if you have students in multiple schools uh we'd appreciate if you can complete multiple surveys as they are specific to each School survey will not collect personal information and all responses will be anonymous uh the parent Guardian survey window will close on Monday January 20th uh so we hope people will take the time to share their perspectives with us uh the feedback of our students faculty and community members is an important source of information as we develop
148plans uh to improve our programming uh momic students and faculty took separate versions of this survey uh this past week uh this one's kind of really hot on the processes so um we have to inform the community of a recent cyber security incident involving Power School uh the student information system that we use uh here in the district to manage Student Records attendance academic and behavioral information uh yesterday we were notified by power school that their systems were compromised in a national data breach uh affecting student and staff record information across multiple districts including us uh our director of technology is confirmed that no social security numbers or financial data were involved uh as masit does not maintain Social Security numbers within Power School uh however it's possible that addresses phone numbers and email addresses
149may have been affected um we have a copy of a a communication from power school that we shared with families um and it'll be the link will also be in my blog uh we would ask people to please be vigilant for any suspicious emails or phone calls in the coming weeks uh as compromise contact information may increase the likelihood of fishing attempts or scams uh and we'll keep everybody informed as we get more information from power school so we just got this yesterday so um still pretty fresh is it current students end alumni I think it's uh that's a good question I don't know have to ask where what the don't I don't okay I don't know what exactly they got access um I've read somewhere and again this is still pretty fresh so I
150don't have a confirmation on this that actually it was sort of a ransomware yes thing it wasn't where there was a ransom that power school paid to whoever broke into the system and the person claims that they deleted everything but who knows um you know that's the problem so so one communication went out today I I expect or anticipate another communication going out either tomorrow or Friday and then we'll it will continue continuously communicates but that's a great question power school did a webinar at 3 o'clock today for for the districts that were involved so you know I and I I know Vin was part of it so I well they originally said we weren't involved but my team du behind the scenes and they found some some traces some nuggets yeah so wow yeah
151how many districts were involved I don't know it's a lot this is like power international actually they say it's National but Power School actually is intern the data breach was you know back in December it was end of December when it happened so it's they were pretty slow and informing us unfortunately okay uh and then we have our uh next High School parent coffee will be Friday January 17th here in the high school library at 8:30 in the morning uh and then our Middle School Parent coffee will be on January 24th uh in the Middle School library also at 8:30 parents to check in at the main office and sign into the building and then we'll have them escorted to their app to the respective coffees any questions for Mike Jo ask Joe just with
152respect to the power school stuff um why are addresses and phone numbers in that system could you just make every kid Anonymous somehow that's our that's our student database Joe so that's where you know the main office has to look up a kid and that's where we keep all of that information okay through Power School I I think it was also connected to all their college board information I think the two are linked I think they got everything that we have in the database is what and this year we added I looked into this this afternoon this year we added Google signin for power school that was new for the students so I was curious their Google like I had my kids change all their passwords tonight it would make sense because they're instructed and
153Spofford to use one password for all education so they don't forget anything I don't think we store passwords and the password is login right yeah one two three four five at sord yeah so jod your question like so it's it's everything that we maintain on Student Records you know we have uh it has a link that uploads everything to the Department of Elementary and secondary education that's the format that they ask for that they require it to be in um yeah it's not not something where we could make everybody Anonymous um you know it doesn't you know same thing for teachers there's a there's a state database for student information there's a state database for Teacher information as well um so this is the the format that we have to keep it in to upload
154it so yeah they need some encryption techniques or something though I mean yeah right now power schools it's it's actually Pearson publishing I mean again an international corporation so any more questions all right thank you Mike and we will move on into the subcommittee reports Comm community relations our next meeting on Friday this Friday at 1:30 at the central office building Then followed by our community Dialogue on January 22nd which will be at six o'clock here before our meeting um in the library perfect and then DCI budget uh we have not had another meeting uh since our last school committee meeting uh so no updates there we are meeting this Friday morning 8:30 Central Building um I don't know if you want to talk as Thea Zone about the meeting we had last night or
155if you want me too yeah muffins or bagels [Laughter] or that's my chop than you eat a bagel um you want to give the update you me too you can do it okay so you know 30 second update we did meet with uh Middleton select boy last night uh presented more or less what we presented back on November 13th for the full school committee um with a few minor updates just on you know data that we've learned since uh the 13th the the plan was well received by the three select board members and two administrators that were there um they had it was a good interaction um I'd say it was a a positive step you know a positive step in the right direction here so was there any constructive feedback or criticism or there
156was there there were questions um there was some feedback in terms of Maintenance um and maintenance systems within the program within uh Masco and how do we how are we going to ensure as we're doing all this work um that you know future Generations will have a system in place that will um know how to maintain the building because that's been our problem that's why we're in the situation that we're in right now is for years the building hasn't been maintained the grounds haven't been maintained in previous administrations and school committees whoever however we got to where we are today the feeling was that the the district would benefit from a model that allows us to track maintenance right so that was I think the big piece of feedback that we got anything else and
157then there were just some questions around and we can easily provide the G and iates updated estimate um and then yeah that's on the that's on our website I already have a draft and email to send back and then um just some of the Category 3 items um what they were what they entailed how we were prioritizing them and that was all laid out pretty clearly in the presentations Co I will say that we we extended the invite to the January 22nd meeting there was a little bit of I don't know if was feedback or criticism but it was the feedback was um it'd be great if they could engage in some capacity um at the meetings right they said if we if we can't engage we might as well just watch it on TV
158the next day it's much more efficient that way to which we said yep we understand that yeah we'll approach it with with the full school committee and the administration um we'll figure out do that okay anti-race sure uh we met in December kind revise some goals and accomplish there um probably I meet next week or two do Zoom call because the hold [Laughter] out um can we do still have outstanding you know we'd like to approve the kind of repurpose the name change and change the remit um idea like to kind of I did send it out earlier today through email like to get formally approved either now or at the next meeting just to you know Tyle SS up yeah we definitely can't do it now but we will keep that on mind for
159next meeting um policy Melissa left but do you guys have a meeting planned we do this coming Monday at uh 12:30 12:30 to 1:30 on Zoom the text and said she'll send out the agenda to be posted tomorrow okay um leison updates we heard from Matt about Middleton top show in the Boxford or turf up or do we have a CPAC leaz on still thought what just real quickly I've um been talking with with Topsfield fincom about having a meeting between now and sometime in February so we haven't come up with any any dates yet I'll just say real quick right I did update the charts that were presented yeah I'll share them with the DCI for sure but if anybody's going to talk to their respective towns I'd encourage us to try to use
160a consistent story yeah good point all the towns great yes I had note to get whatever deck you used I'll just right now anything new and exciting out of box or Joe I see your hand yeah that was always uh we've got a meeting on the 13th coming up uh I think it's the 13th but it's uh next week where I'll give a an update it is is one of those update fairs where 300 different committees all come in and you sit through um two hours of other people giving updates before you get to talk but um hopefully I'm I'm well by Friday because I'd like to come to DCI meeting and and catch up with you guys and then be able to give a better update on on at that meeting on the 13th
161and I'll also raise the issue of the $50,000 Jeff you can bring the muffins then yeah yeah I can bring him a back if I'm feeling up to it I will how's that good um I did have one additional update out of Middleton when we were leaving the meeting last night Jackie had kind of our assistant Town Administrator had briefly said while we were leaving that we would only have to come to one of the budget Saturdays and not two and that she would be corresponding with me about which one they were expecting us at and which one they were not I don't know if it was I don't know if tonight's presentation Chang it I don't I don't know where they're getting that we only have to come to one and not two but
162there's no Capital there's no Capital right so I don't know what information they're working off of but yeah because it was always one was operating one was big Capital right yeah little Capital us there both based of Prior feedback but we'll see um share one other um the community relation subcommittee has a meeting this Friday as Kev mentioned um we're going to discuss there the SX Tech site visit um if anyone's interested please let me know we haven't reached out to them to schedule want to have an idea of how many people are interested we'll probably do like a do like we'll figure out the timing but if that's something anyone is potentially interested in please just let me know by 3M on Friday and just do be cautious um no more than five members
163from the committee and um negotiations I know you guys are meeting tomorrow so good luck right yeah tomorrow afternoon the Paris mediation with the Paris we actually did get um a request from the uh administrative assistance Union start negotiations um because they their contracts up at the end of this year so administrators are up at the end of this year support Personnel is up at the end of this year and the mpfts the maintenance guys are is up the end of this year and Par is still in flux still going Joe do you have something to add okay all right well I think that is good for our subcommittee report so then we'll move on to the consent agenda which is the approval of the December 18th meeting minutes um warrants in the amount of
1643,557 882 and then accept um MFA a and Ms uh Middle School author MEF grants um that are included in the consent agenda consent second do I have a motion from Bill a second from Matt to approve the consent agenda as presented and again we're going to do a roll call Bill yes Kendra yes Jeff yes Erica yes Matt yes Adrien yes yes Chris yes Lisa yes uh Joe yes uh Trevor I'm a yes and Melissa is no longer here for Lynn who is joining us via Zoom okay so that passes 10 to Z all right and with that I will adjourn our meeting thank you g six minutes ahead right