CorpusRecord 121115

MRSD School Committee Meeting | 12/18/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Masconomet School Committee
Date
2024-12-19
Location
Essex County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,672 words · about 82 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I was not ready y good okay I call this meeting order at we got 702 702 702 pm. and we'll start with just uh some brief remarks um I want to start by just thanking uh the school committee for the work we've done as a group so far this year um you know I just picked up my daughter from college today and so she's halfway through her year you like to think that we're sort of at halftime here but I was I was thinking through what's ahead of us just starting budget season now it's really almost like the end of the first quarter for us unfortunately um but there's been a lot of good work done so far um I think the DCI subcommittee has been doing a lot of work to try to get

002their arms around a number of issues uh the policy committee continues to work doggedly through the least glamorous part of what we do but um an important part of what we do and uh community relations has been doing a great job publishing um what what it is we do and um uh um anti-racism subcommittee is is coming in with a proposal for how they want to Define what they're doing moving forward so just want to thank everyone for all the work they've done so far this year and um I guess get ready because the real meat is ahead um starting with uh probably the second session in January is when it really starts but in the first session of January one of the things we have on the agenda is we're going to do a

003review of our goals that we set for the year just to do a check in to see where we are um I'll say Midway even though it's not Midway as I said um and then uh like I said the fund begins so with that said I just want to say happy holidays to everyone I hope you can go away and enjoy a few weeks off um and I look forward to uh more great stuff in the coming year so with that said um we'll move on to comments from the audience and I see a number of hands for who how many comments we have one two three four and I'm gonna start with Sarah who was quick with the hand there I'm Sarah Guido from Topsfield I'm president of topsi and mville soccer Vice pres

004president of massic sports Foundation um for you new members I want to share a few points for you to consider as you take in the presentation tonight from the paper of organic brass Fields first I want you to consider the high impact that sports like football and Lacrosse have on natural grass fields and what those sports do to the field over the course of the season in all the examples that you will be shown of communities with organic grass fields they all have Synthetic Turf Fields as well chesra Connecticut just installed Turf l Spring Springfield recently added an additional turf field and a baseball field Governor has turfed for hockey and field hockey and Lacrosse and I could go on um typically the examples of the highquality organic grass fields are single sport specific or

005used at a recreational level at Masco we have a need for a multi-use Stadium Field that is safe and reliable and available for postseason play so it has to get through the whole season and still be good for all sports not just football are there any examples of highquality grass Stadium fields that are used at the high school level for multi-use Fields available to All Sports I don't know of any um locally for sure I want to make you guys aware of the white Stadium project in home park historically it's been used by uh Boston Public Schools there's a plann renovation it's a public private partnership with the professional women's soccer team that's coming um the soccer team is now stipulating the field not be used for football during their season which means placing public

006school football teams until Thanksgiving bear and tear of football is just too much for the quality of the field um I also tonight want you to consider the environmental impacts of grass fields high quality grass fields require an enormous amount of water um they require one inch of water per we during the grow growing season and more during the summer um the if river is one of the top 10 most endangered rivers in the country not because of pollution but because it's critically overdrawn in climate patterns in the last 20 years we've had increasing frequency and severity of droughts as we've all just experienced this year and two or three years ago three or four years before that in these more frequent periods of severe and critical drought how much harm will watering our Fields

007impose on the habitat and the availability of drinking water as it depletes our critical resources I also want you to recall that masco's design will incorporate environmentally friendly materials that eliminate many of the concerns of the past many of the health concerns and concerns over microp plastic migration relate to the use of recycled um fires Crum rubber as infill our design will specify the use of the natural infill I also want to point out that many Turf manufacturers have eliminated pasas from their supply chain and production and turf can be tested prior to installation finally the thing I want to emphasize the most that brought me to this issue personally was that the need for increased access to Rel reliable field space is not just a question for the high school Community it is a

008community need um we have a shortage of reliable Playing Fields available to our growing youth um and adult recreational programs a turfield at Masco would be available for this additional usage that we currently is beyond the usage of our high school Fields now um without you know increased wear and tear a grass field would not be able to accommodate this additional use so I just want you to consider those points tonight when you guys are thinking about grass fields um I I wish I wish we could do it we don't have enough space to have as many as we need in order to get through an entire season without the wear and tear so and I don't want to keep kicking the can down the road right we've been talking about this for 15 years

009now so thank you very much appreciate the time thank you SAR go ahead sir hi I'm B Haron I'm from top seal 2017 I initiated an effort to ban the distribution of single-use plastic bags in topfield and at the May 2018 town meeting our citizen petition was passed by a majority of the attendees since that time we've noticed a substantial reduction of plastic waste in our yards forests waterways and Open Spaces recently I learned that our school district is considering replacing the grass at our school Fields with Acres of plastic carpet the fake grass blades alone on these fields are equivalent to millions of plastic bags over 8 to 10 years the fake grass carpet wears out and has to be replaced in that time 10 to 15% of that plastic grass tears off and

010becomes Airborne or waterborne in the in the adjacent ipwi river which is just right beyond the fields that is far more plastic than the plastic bags we remove from our environment with our effort just a few years ago it works out to the equivalent of 20,000 this is a conservative number 20,000 bags of plastic per year released for each artificial turf field while the plastic BL while the plastic grass blades do not fool many people as to their authenticity Wildlife get scammed into thinking it may be good to eat plastic blades floating down the river are poisoned to fish Ducks yeast and other unfortunate Critters consume them many of us are struggling to keep the uch river healthy for both humans and fauna introducing this much plastic clear a threat thank you thank you next

011go ahead ma'am as good evening my name is Cindy Bosa and um as you can tell by my shirt I am here for the par professional concerns of not having a contract yet um and I know we have been sharing information with you at your uh different schol committee meetings and um I would just like to be a little more personal tonight um during I am um a parah in the Middle School um I'm in the lrc The Learning Resource Center which primarily has the most challenging academically students um my students range from everything from being able to be um included in other traditional classrooms vers and we also have a few that just need to learn in our environment anyway um I just wanted to let you know that I'm sorry that I'm I'm

012also the treasurer of the union and I'm also on the bargaining unit so during our meetings this past year at one point um we were asked well why are you even in this job and it took me back I was a little surprised by that question and maybe maybe you need to know why and I think all of us have a different reason and my reason is I started as a teacher in fact I still am a certified teacher um in another district and I was there for about 30 years started young and it got to the point where um in Massachusetts we were supposed to have master's degrees I have two bachelor's degrees um and my children were about to become ready for college so I made the decision to put money into their

013education secondly at about the same time there was an increase in parent control and a lot of administration sort of not backing up teachers kind of letting parents talk about it and so it was like admin coming at us and teachers coming at us or at least at me um so those two things made me consider why why am I here well I love being with kids I just have always liked working with children as a matter of fact I married into a family that ran a day camp so being in education was perfect as far as the calendar year goes I worked the school year and then in the summer I put on my Camp outfit and there we were and it and it was just a wonderful perfect position for me and then

014so being a par would also fit that yeah yes I took a huge pay cut but at the time we were able to work it out and um I still was able to really enjoy my job without the hassle of creating papers at home um dealing with parents and um all those other things that the classroom teachers still in my opinion have to deal with but as a paup that position has really changed and when I came here um about nine years ago I was responsible for doing a certain amount of things I actually started in the student support center and I was helping kids with all different kinds of reasons why they couldn't be in the classroom or you know needed to get homework done and that was fine I enjoyed that and then

015the next year is when I started working in the lrc and that was a big eye opener very very different clientele and over the years I've become more and more professional in that regard I have been trained now to do the Ace Program I sit with with a student and I take data and put and it goes right into the to the computer so that the my um coordinator as well as Carly penda who's our bcba can take that data and do what they will with it I've been trained not for restraining but in case a child grabs me my hair I've been trained on how to get out of that safely for both me and the student um it's called CPI training I've had the EpiPen training I've had first aid training and the

016CPR training although I think a lot of professionals get that as well um so the expectations of being a parah have really gone up high whereas my paycheck to compare that really has not matched that and it wasn't until actually even three years ago when our first uh contract was settled we did get a little bump in pay and we were all excited but we started I started looking at things and I realized wait a minute masco's down here and a lot of other districts are paying their Pais up here and I believe you folks got a letter I mean a piece of paper regarding that a few maybe even last month or so but I said well okay I'm going to wait three more years and see if we can level this out a

017little bit and in the meantime and you've heard it like people are coming in because they need jobs and whether it's a stepping stone for them or whether it's for me like just being able to work with kids and be a supportive person or whatever it is Mother's hours I don't know it's not of my business but it's really kind of surprising that a lot of us who have been here for a while are getting paid here and the people we're helping to train to be great pairs are getting paid up here so that's one thing I would like to see I would like to see those levels a little better a little closer together um because I feel like I'm worth it um and actually one thing that I hope I'm not going over

018my few minutes here but every Wednesday we have this really good I think training it's online training and they call it par Educators and that's really how I feel we are now we're not just par professionals we are educating we're par educators we are in the classrooms and helping we're we're not planning the curriculum so much but we're instructing it especially when the teacher has to leave last minute um it's not available and there's they're scrambling for substitutes they're now looking at us because we know the kids we know what they're doing and we know how the classroom works so so yeah thank you for your comment you're well over time the end so thank you anyone anyone else okay uh we don't have student Advisory Board person here so we'll move on to the

019appointment of Brad Denton do you want to come up where do you want come up H you can come up over there so I am pleased to recommend the appointment of Brad Denton to the position of assistant superintendent of student services uh Brad has served in this role in an acting capacity since the end of March of 2024 uh Brad has a deep understanding of the student services department of masconomet he first joined masanam as a special education program coordinator in 2006 uh and was promoted to the position of assistant director of special education in 2009 as the assistant director of special education Brad has been involved in all aspects of our student services programming including program development student case management and the evaluation and supervision of faculty and staff in this role he was

020and continues to be an integral member of our social emotional learning leadership team SE llt uh which has implemented a comprehensive approach to addressing the mental health needs of our students we also coordinated our summer programming for special education and for credit recovery uh through these roles and responsibilities Brad has demonstrated his capabilities and talents are great match for the assistant superintendent role uh Brad has also developed meaningful relationships with faculty and members of the community uh as a member of the mass economic leadership team Brad has worked closely with all members of our student services department and has earned their trust and support as a former special education program coordinator he has an intimate understanding of the needs of our special educators and the challenges they face uh in his time at masconomet he

021has worked closely with our school counselors and nurses on developing programming to meet the needs of our students uh as assistant director Brad has worked with our department heads and principles on solutions to school and district-wide issues uh such as the development of our Student Success centers uh Brad is also a momic graduate and a Topsfield resident and he has been able to leverage his understanding of the community masconomet serves to build strong relationships with parents and community members uh these relationships both inside and outside masconomet will serve him well in the role of assistant superintendent for student services uh Brad has been serving the role of acting assistant superintendent for the last nine months and has demonstrated he is clearly the right person for this role uh while simy an acting position As a

022caretaker role uh Brad has spent his time working to improve and strengthen our programming LED an analysis of our special education programming this year including reviewing our current programs and looking at Future needs that may require adjustments to the services we offer uh this review has led to developing stronger relationships with our counterparts in the tri toown School Union so we can better understand the needs of students who will be entering masom in the near future most recently Brett has been engaged with meeting personally with the special ed education coordinators in the three upper elementary schools to discuss the needs of the current sixth grade students as they prepare to transition to mass anomic and to review the profiles of students in the lower grades these conversations will allow Brad to be proactive in developing

023programming to meet future student needs under other circumstances I would normally undertake a search to fill the position of assistant superintendent for student services given Brad's experience relationships and performance in the acting role I wholeheartedly believe we already have identified the right person for the job I asked the school committee approve my recommendation to hire Brad D of assistant superintendent forent student service Brad's here so has any questions any questions is this something we can table until we're better prepared to actually ask Brad questions and have full consideration of this I mean I literally the only information I have is what you just read I I also didn't know we'd be voting yeah because has to approve the appointment but of my recommendation but would we normally yeah because like we didn't forget that right

024for assistant superintendent you would do okay because he's a director okay I I share that I I feel like what we heard were a lot of the inputs I guess I'm wondering like what specific progress has made you know been made data around like some of the output components agree yeah I mean I not a knock on you Brad I'm sure you're doing fantastic I just I this is a little catching me off guard I don't I don't have anything to assess BR other than what you just said and honestly I don't even have in front of me to like read through it again or anything so it feels a little Melissa I'd like to remind the committee that it's not our role to um hire Brad um it's Mike's role role to hire and

025it's our we can support him or we can't so I just wanted that the our our role as the school committee is policy budget and the hiring of the school committee so we oversee Mike um and any feedback we have for him would be done at the review process so maybe just whatever you just read and writing would be helpful I don't know it's agenda I didn't this afternoon and I yeah put it in oh so it's in there now okay I looked earlier and didn't see it by Melissa I I can make a motion to approve Mike's recommendation have something you wanted to say well after we get a second I'll ask my question okay second all right so any further discussion just TR for our last assistant superintendent for student services she had

026attended a lot of our meetings is that something that we would bring back I something we've discussed um I think it's something we want we probably want to discuss as a chair and assistant chair sure I just don't know if the need is there for every meeting that's the the question is I hate to have somebody come here and sit up sit here for three hours and not say a word okay I do have a four minute commute so it's not call me so we can call you up and get you over here yeah I can pick you up probably tonight would have been helpful I I give question Brad do you have anything that you want to say or to the committee or you know just I mean I'm not sort of prepared to

027to sell myself um I think for the folks who don't know me Mike did a pretty a really good job of sort of reading through but um Masco has been a big part of my life like like said you know I graduated here my kids go here my parents still live here I live here so it's not something that is you know it's not a stepping stone it's not like it's a big part of of who I am and and what I do so um I I take it seriously and I take you know sort of your your role seriously and and how you you know how you work through this but it's something that I you know wake up and I come here every day and work really hard to make sure that not

028only are the kids getting the best that we can offer but that the community is getting you know the value that I think Masco provides I think kids are lucky to go here I think people are lucky that Masco is in the tri toown um that being said I don't r on luck you know I think from my standpoint people who know me I think strategically I work hard I work collaboratively I reflect on you know decisions and practices and try to get better so that's kind of me in a nutshell he you no looking at me furtively okay sure just I I'm just uncomfortable the process I feel like I'm not informed enough to make a decision either way um yeah there I didn't know vote as well just just to say the statute

029is the way the statute's written so I make a recommendation this the school committee has to approve it uh it ALS It also says you won't you know unreasonably withhold that approval um so I mean it is kind of based on my recommendation let me ask another question so close your is what I'm saying is Brad I don't think things personally don't turns out to be absolutely horrible at it is and when by approving it we're not approving him to be here 20 years we're approving him to be here for it's it's approving me to enter into a contract with him for it's usually thein amount of time and what's a typical find amount it's no more than five years um typically a first contract for an administrator is three and yeah this is all

030theoretical you know here doing a great job for a while but yeah five years you can do a lot of damage too right I me just you know there's nothing but a vote here there's no resume there was no additional search I just don't feel like I have any information right say yes or no either way that's sort of my concerns on processes like these in general um you know I'm not here to hire anybody but asking me to put my name on something that no no background on is unreasonable as well it just feels a little last last minute I don't know like this is like presented days ago or even a week ago and it was like hey this is coming up I want you guys to have this information so you can

031ask questions or it would have felt better for me to put my name on it this feels like wait what what are we doing why how I didn't even fully understand my role in this so to be able to address those things offline before we get to this table and do write by Brad and Frank by you Dr Harvey like this it feels like let's I don't know table it and do over and make everybody feel good about this decision but maybe that's not the way we want to go I don't know what would it require for you to be good feel good about it uh a minute to think about it and ask questions would be great and I don't think I want to use the Committees time for that and say hey let's

032take a 10-minute recess so I can think and come up with some thoughtful questions that are going to do right by our district so I will add just to piggyback off what Melissa said our job is to hire Mike and we entrust Mike to make these decisions for the district and so like Melissa said we really have no ground to stand in the way of him performing his job as he sees best for the district so I'm ready to appoint Brad Denton I guess that's true why have a vote huh statute statute 71 it's chapter 71 section 59 I guess I have to put my name against something I want to be informed on it so I don't want to call a vote and have have it not succeed I think it's going to succeed

033but I don't want to do that so does someone want to make a motion there is a motion I know but put a motion to table the have to vote on the first motion first so that yeah you have one on the table I know but does someone want to amend it there's option to withdraw just checking just go back this isn't a d I'm just I have no information at all so okay then we're gonna vote on I was I I would like to voice my support because I get it we this kind of did come up as a surprise however Brad has been at our meetings several meetings and he's stood up there with both of the principles and he's provided us with a whole lot of information he's been involved and so

034I don't see this as a bad thing he's he has clearly been invested he's been very supportive of the students that he's going to be here helping and I I just don't I don't see this as a bad thing he's done you know exactly what you've said in this H so just just because we don't have actual data but he's actually been here he's spoken to us and he's we've had these meetings so agree I think you know no one has issue with process and the procedure that people are concerned about yeah which I think is less of a it's not at all a brad thing man I'll just say I don't need a process personally I trust Mike who has been interviewing Brad the last seven months and if Mike's good then I don't

035to approve anything further just one comment I I would like Brad to come to more when it's applicable and when we're talking about whether it is enrollment or what going on with students in curriculum I would I would love whoever it's Brad or not um to have them here as often as possible being you know having two children in Special Ed I I could you know definitely use the information as I'm sure a lot of other parents as well could so I would I would welcome that it's also a very large part of our budget it is a large part of it so um I would just welcome that you know it's also when I get feedback externally this is a about top three issue or concern not this concern but this affects a lot

036of folks when I hear things sure I'm hearing about this a lot good and bad you know people you so so I don't doubt the value this role or anything just I think a few of us were comfortable introduced I don't necessarily I don't see a downside to moving this potentially to our next meeting I'd love to hear about the analysis fed program results thinking about the school Improvement plans we wanted more specifics wanted more data we wanted goals it could be a really great and powerful opportunity to give some of the processing time but also share those results and how would you use that data to evaluate this appointment I think it would just be a great share of knowledge I don't think it's evaluating the appointment but thinking about processing time not knowing

037there was going to be a vote excuse me feeling comfortable putting our names behind it I think to just point why vote Yes statute but like what is the what are we doing so to feel comfortable I don't I don't see a downside to that is there a downside to delaying it to next meeting does it interrupt any we have a pretty full agenda for next I mean I I I don't think there's a significant downside to delaying it other than it's just another thing on a pile of stuff that's coming our way right and if in the end it's not going to make a difference in terms of whether it gets approved or not then why wait that's be my my point so if we question for Mike so if we have a vote

038here and it's not approved back at the next meeting yeah I'll have to yeah same with Brad again right so we can have the vote and if people want to wait I would say vote against it and we'll see what the committee wants to do if the committee wants to approve at this this meeting it'll get approved um if they don't then we'll bring it back let's vot so let's do a uh we'll do a a roll call vote Adrian I'd like to abstain Jeff abstain Chris yes Kendra yes Bill yes uh Trevor yes thank you Erica OB Matt I want to call you Alex tonight for sorry about that Alissa yes Lisa yes all right I'm GNA be a yes so that's uh eight with three abstentions 8 Z with three extensions congratulations approved

039but I'm sure you'll be willing to answer any questions we have in future meetings he's going be back in the next meeting yeah I'm on the agenda next one anyway so it was gonna be yeah I'll be here whenever thank I got an open door so thank you congrats stop by thank you I don't have to stay for the rest this one in that chair gets exciting all right that brings us to the athletic fields presentation uh R do you have the floor and do we have um is it Susan is that her name is she online yes she is can she hear us she yeah we tested com back I feel you gonna are you g to start the you said you'd start the there you go thank you my name is Fred gloren

040from Boxford Mass uh thank you for this opportunity to uh on a presentation on natural grass athletic fields while my name is listed as one of the presenters from real grass I want to acknowledge all the other members of the real grass group who have spent countless hours on researching and spending a lot of time developing what you can see tonight I'm going to ask if people hold their questions until we get through to the to the end of this uh the slideshow so that uh we can get through all the slides as rapidly as possible I am going to introduce to you Fred and Pam Nukem who were from P JC Organics out of Rowley Massachusetts they specialize in organic surf fields for both municipalities schools and private people and also who's going to

041be on Zoom is uh Susan chapnik who is president of new environment environmental Horizons uh and as their Chief scientist is also Commissioner of uh the Conservation Commission of Arlington we believe that outdoor recreational green spaces are essential to the life and well being any campus and Community because these spaces are so cherished they help Define and enrich the quality of life it is essential to maintain the quality of an athletic complex for the school district that ensures the highest level of safety and health for the athletes and Spectators and is environmentally and fiscally responsible any action that is initiated must be looked at for its environmental impact the goals of our presentation are to show the benefit and limitations associated with natural grass and artificial turf athletic fields understand the costs involved with natural

042with with natural grass and artificial turf highlight wild natural grass fields are the most costeffective choice for the school district understand the environmental health impacts of the art of artificial turf and then offer some solutions for the next steps to move forward with that I'd like to introduce uh Fred Nukem who is going to go through some of the benefits and limitations trying to make it easy thanks Fred Ry Mass so not to bore you all reading details of this PowerPoint um you have to understand that both um natural turf fields and synthetic turf fields have carrying capacity how many hours they they can be used um because the natural grass field is a living environment if you will um it's usually that it's being in the northeast of that useful time period is 26

043weeks where um the Synthetic Turf industry likes to say that their fields are available 247 65 when in reality that it doesn't necessarily work out to be that but for this acknowledge the fact that natural grass fields are going to have half the hours of usage that a synthetic tur field and to do this in either environment natural grass or turf requires maintenance it's not it's not a given you can't just put in a art artificial turf field and but it onun its course nor can you just put in a natural grass field and let it run its course as well um as I already mentioned there's a significant environmental impact in um their environmental benefits of having a natural grass field from carbon sequestration water filtration things of that sort so um and the

044other thing a benefit perspective to be aware of there is no definitive end of life for a natural grass Shield limitations as I mentioned already both require U proper maintenance with that um budgets um there are costs associated with each from installation maintenance um in particularly with the Synthetic Turf field replacement because fortunately these Synthetic Turf Fields do have an end of life uh sythetic Turf industry will generally warranty these fields depending on um certain parameters we'll discuss a little later but for period of eight years and then you have to plan to replace them this is um 10year cost um comparison comparison between natural grass field and artificial turf field that was put together by Tom Irwin advisors for the uh for the Town of Arlington um construction of a natural grass field in

045this case is a native soil field and there are other options for natural grass fields sand or a sand cap field which um for most high schools is not um advisable just take advantage of the Native soils that you have um put in proper main uh proper drainage Crown field irrigation things of those sorts would be uh and SED would be part of that ballpark $400,000 figure uh maintenance could argue um on on those I would argue on the numbers of 30,000 a year but for these purposes we'll just accept that um whereas construction of a synthetic turf field is um in the ballpark of a million dollars um maintenance is less according to Tom Irwin of roughly 15 ,000 a year um so you're looking at 150 and then replacement and Disposal at that

0468 to 10 year period uh running roughly another um, so total cost over 10 years for your uh synthetic or artificial turf field would be um see a million a versus 700,000 for the native uh natural grass fields um so the significant Capital outweigh sorry other things to consider surface temperature just briefly my uh my two daughters played Collegian field hockey um remember one beautiful September Day 70 degrees out we're at the youngest daughter's field hockey game the temperature on the field was 135 degrees at that time the NCAA had a rule at 140 degrees you couldn't play they've since amended that rule it's now it's 120 Dees so while we often think that these synthetic Fields allow you to play all the time there are other issues around heat um but the hardness um

047even weather events water those sorts of things all affect the the usefulness where um in the case of natural grass it it doesn't create that heat is in effect uh another thing that we should probably all be aware of even if all we have are natural grass fields are how hard those fields are in the case of the Synthetic Turf industry they put in in in practice what I consider to be a a good practice which refers to this gmax testing they actually you take a a machine and you a weighted machine and you see how hard the field is so it it figures it calculates what the absorption of the body hitting the the field is it won't tell you whether you get a concussion or not but how hard those fields are it's

048important for the Synthetic Turf industry because that's how they validate or invalidate their warranties and and but that same practice can and should be applied to a natural grass field and the NFL does that so the numbers you say gmax at 200 you're likely to break a bone at 165 the Synthetic Turf industry says that's a good number the NFL says a good gmax number is 100 um just this last October I was out at Holy Cross for uh nesma the New England sports turf managers on field day their natural turf fields have a T Max read readings of 35 and 38 so it it's very different and in the scope and there's there's a lot of things that go into that Compact and it's the same for natural grass and different factors but still

049have the same effect as the synthetics but natural turf fields whether they're compacted or not how much Turf coverage is on the field uh whereas in a synthetic field shock pad infill material and the amount of infill all all those things are factored again just highlighting the need that that both um surfaces need to be maintained and maintained properly player preference if you read anything about the NFL and FIFA and the World Cup there's players say that they prefer to play on U natural over now I want to introduce Pam but uh just to quickly step back on one of couple of things that Fred had mentioned um in regards to the cost comparison these these numbers are a couple of years old Tom Irwin is is a nationally rowned uh uh Turf uh expert

050uh that happens to be based in Massachusetts but they handle golf courses all over the all over the world uh with their with their maintenance so these numbers are are pretty low they're very conservative and I just wanted to point that out and I know that you all have this this presentation the player preference I think is very important obviously it's been shared with people uh prior to the tonight's presentation um but I encourage you to to look at that with that this is pav Nukem who will speak to uh F conditions and such there I'm Pam Nukem I'm also from Raleigh um and one of the things also that we wanted to mention is uh this fall stellos field up in Nash New Hampshire they failed their GX test and their field T shut

051down in the wall um so now they're facing that what they originally thought was going to be a $870,000 uh replacement bill is is going to be pushing 1.2 million and so they at the last minute have to find somewhere else for their players to play so um there is an end of the life it is something that you do need to be prepared to plan for um and we were asked to come here uh we've been doing organic Turf Care for 20 years we serve as customers from Maine to Maryland we work with landscapers schools and municipalities that want to implement an allnatural organic approach to the maintenance of their fields whether they may have some synthetic Fields there or not is not something we get involved in we're just here to let you

052know that that it is possible to have all natural organic organic fields that look good um this particular slide we were asked to do a trial in Stanford Connecticut in 2019 on one field the field on their left had been um on a synthetic fertilization program so it had been been being managed um we did a one-year trial they were so pleased with the trial that they went Citywide the next year and uh have 35 acres under organic management right now uh again as you know obviously somebody got to see the slides ahead ches uh Connecticut we started working with them in there have been a customer since 2020 they send us pictures of their field Hoy field this field is um this picture was taken in 2023 and then this is the Governor's Academy

053and while yes they might now have a field hockey field that they have synthetically they've actually been um pesticide free on their campus I was I would say with the exception of pesticides that are used on their synthetic fields to disinfect uh because you do need to still maintain your athletic fields and disinfect and um there's a regime there since 2009 the Governor's Academy um part of their sustainable initiative is to have a pesticide herbicide campus so since 2009 um they have 14 Acres both campus Lawns and athletic fields under um organic management and uh they're doing they're doing great and I mean I could show you picture after picture I'm not here to I think that the conversation that's on the table quite honestly we don't usually get involved in these talks because it's

054advocacy group against the community and it's really something that the community needs to sort through and decide what we're here to tell you is that you can have all natur organic tur Fields um that as you saw look good and are safe to plan on when we work with schools we go through we talk about your field expectations your Staffing what equipment do you have uh everything starts with the soil test we put together a product set and then we you you you rank your Fields you tell us well we want this to be a tier one field a tier 2 field to tier three field based upon use and expectations um and that's kind of the key part uh we came out and we walked the Masco fields in September when we were first

055asked to get involved in this project because we wanted to see what they looked like um I don't know how many people here have actually gone out and walked your fields and then we came back in December because we wanted to see what they looked like at the end of the year and I'll tell you um with the exception of the football field that definitely could use a higher level of care your other fields other towns would covet they looked good and I think I want to give a shout out to uh because as as Fred said our our kids play field hockey for triton so we've seen the MCO Fields about 15 years ago and your Fields have come a long way um so a shout out to whoever has taken that over and

056brought the level of play up if we were to rate the little bit we've not gotten intimately involved in what your issues are here what your program is here at the little bit that we learned I would say that your maintenance is probably falling out a tier three or a sub tier three level um so obviously if improving the playability of your Fields is important there's a lot of room to grow um that you can't just look at the fields that are out there and say you know we can't play on these fields because you really need to look at what are you doing to your Fields um how are they being maintained and I think that this is really the bottom line um for every school and municipality we talk to we get these

057call the time budget and labor those are the two things if you guys put the money into your Fields you could have more playable hours and your Fields could look better if you go by the Governor's Academy right now their football field is under a Turf blanket for the winter and they do that because they play on that football field they do football in Lacrosse so in the spring when they take that Turf blanket off that Field's ready to play um right now you know your field is in need of repair and you guys don't have the budget to go out there into your end of the season aeration over seating so you know you're just hoping it's going to look better in the spring so there's things that you can do to increas in

058you know improve the playability of your fields that are going to cost a lot less when you look at those budget numbers too and and the budget is is you know everything's about half half the life half the budget um that budget are fields that are maintained you know I'm sure if you look at your budget you're not spending $30,000 a year to maintain your felds here so I think it's something to really think about that if you guys want to have a level of play that's higher you want your fields to look better whether you're going to stay with natural grass or whether you're going to go to artificial turf you've got to put the budget there and you've got to have the people there because if you go artificial turf you have to

059maintain it you know you have to maintain it it is not maintenance free um and I think that that's just really important to learn obviously we're in all natural organic land care so I don't have to tell you which way we lean but I think we're seeing this we're seeing a shift you know the NFL players are wanting to go back to Natural Turf there's a you know we have carbon footprint we have sustainability goals and I like to think that these schools who are teaching our kids all of these things might want to invest some money into the program to teach the kids how they can you know do some sustainable Turf Care on their fields um the the question she brought up you know if you're trying to get the community in here

060and to use your Fields I mean those are all things you guys got to decide you know who's going to use the fields one are the fields going to be used right now your fields are not used over the summer which is great it's why they look so good in September um you know the same is true with artificial turf you use those fields more your life you know your your expected life of the turf is going to go down so it's just something to really go in I just encourage you to be eyes wide open because yes the schools you know some of the towns we work with have artificial turf marble had somebody set Fireworks off on their turf field and they burned it now that was not warranteed um you know like

061there's it's just it's just something you got to just really think about people think they just roll it out um or people you know outside groups fundrais for the turf and they put it in and then the town's left the cleanup you know so just really there's a lot of factors to consider and it's not just about money I'm going to turn it over to Susan chapnick who's going to talk about health in the environment and I think when it comes to our kids and our community that's pretty important so now uh coming up is Susan chapnick you can see her um screen uh Susan is with new environmental Horizons as president and the chief scientist for them as well as on the Arlington Conservation Commission there we go these These are the human health

062and environmental concerns that that we want to remind people of thanks Fred um just for the record my name is Susan chapnik I'm from Arlington Massachusetts as Fred said I've been 10 years on the Conservation Commission in Arlington where I'm the current Vice chair and the former chair of the commission I'm also president and principal scientists of a small uh women-owned business that does environmental Consulting in terms of planning and evaluation of environmental data so I have a lot of experience looking at chemicals um I've also uh done many webinars and expert testimony on uh impacts of artificial turf fields on the environment uh most recently I did a webinar um entitled artificial turf research on plastic pollution posos and health concerns for the collaborative for health and environmental um concerns and that was in

063September 2024 so um I want to um just spend a few slides going through the environmental chemical concerns as well as climate concerns and sustainability chemical hazards escape from these Fields a number of the chemicals components of artificial turf are soluble in water so when rain and snow per fall down on these fields and percolate through all the layers the turf the infill the shock pad the geotextile fabric all these layers they can bring with them toxic chemicals down into the ground water they could bring them out to surface water and contaminate soil some chem that are not soluble in water actually migrate with the particles either the infill that comes out or the weathered broken plastic blades and we did hear earlier that the infill proposed was not that nasty Tire crumb rubber um

064which we know had contains multiples of toxic chemicals both to human health and the environment however recent studies including one conducted at Mount siai in New York and by the toxic use reduction Institute that's tur out of UMass LEL has found the presence of known carcinogens and neurotoxins including polyaromatic hydrocarbons and lead and zinc in almost all alternative infills so they they are not a free ticket to No nasty chemicals in the environment uh the the previous one of the um public speakers talked about posos and how uh Turf manufacturers have been eliminating pasos uh based on my research and actual looking at real environmental data from analytical Laboratories most recently in burville uh Rhode Island or a field that is planned on going in in that town this is a field Turf product artificial

065turf product posos does Leech from these materials at very low levels however very low levels are hazardous EPA recently promulgated drinking water levels for two of the thousands of pasas chemicals pfoa and pfos at four parts per trillion and to put that in perspective one part per trillion is a drop of water in 20 olympic size swimming pools that's a minuscule amount of this material is can cause cancer and other toxic effects including um uh Behavior Ural and developmental issues it in burville Rhode Island um the Rhode Island Department of Health roh and the Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management was so concerned about this field going in that they sent a letter to the town about the potential for pasas from this Turf to contaminate the aquifer and this turf was being put over

066a drinking water aquifer in the town besides um posos the infill and weathered plastic blades routinely migrate from older Fields into the surrounding resource areas and are a significant source of plastic to the environment a recent peer-reviewed paper that came out of Barcelona showed that 15% of the plastic that was found in the ocean was from artificial turf fields that's a huge amount a huge number that frankly I didn't expect um to come off of these fields next slide please we already talked a bit about heat um you can see here the thermal image on the bottom um very clearly shows the artificial turf on the right hand side as readed at degrees Fahrenheit um there's the perimeter drain that most of these fields have surrounding the fields and then on the left is grass

067based on Mount siai uh in New York they report that children are less able to regulate their body temperature than adults making them particularly susceptible to conditions of extreme heat including dehydration heat stress heat stroke and Burns besides the human health effects there are severe environmental effects to this excess heat heated runoff can negatively impact cold water Fisheries have cold water Fisheries in the ipswitch river and Aquatic environments in fact EPA under the Clean Water Act requires that temperatures not exceed a rise of 3° fah which is a very small amount for cold water Fisheries to survive in addition excess heat prudes Wildlife from even traversing these fields next slide please artificial turf fields alter the environment we've talked about some of these issues pollution groundwater drinking water uh they also cause the loss of

068habitat soil is removed from a foot to more a foot to two feet depending upon how the these fields are engineered so there's a loss of habitat for insects and invertebrates a loss of habitat for foraging a loss of wildlife corridors to to allow Wildlife to cross over these areas to get to other areas in urban environments and bio biodiversity impacts the Boxford bylaw and local regulations for Wetlands include resource area values that go beyond the values of the wet of the state Wetland protection act so the Boxford bylaw actually has 13 values the state has eight um and I'm going to read them to you and then you can evaluate whether these fields are consistent with these Wetland values these values include public and private water supply prot protection groundwater protection flood control erosion

069and sediment control storm damage prevention water quality Water Pollution Control Fisheries wildlife habitat rare species habitat including rare plant species agriculture Recreation values and Riverfront area values next slide please adverse climate change resilience and adaptation impacts are the result of these fields this picture is when uh taken in Franklin Massachusetts several years ago when a field there an artificial turf field needed to be replaced this is the turf carpet they rolled up the turf carpet they put it on the edge of the field it stayed there for months and months and months and this edge of the field was with within the wetlands jurisdictional area so as the um the the the climate um the heat the the rain Etc is falling on these fields right by right in the Wetland jurisdictional area before they

070were removed then um artificial turf fields are not rec cyclable the the industry does say that they have chemical recycling or Advanced recycling what these processes actually are is they produce a very um a what's called a sin fuel which is which is a not a very useful Fuel and they don't produce any meaningful amount of new plastic materials so basically they're incineration and they they actually cause pollution these fields use fossil fuel during manufacturer during um during transportation to installation during installation during replacement and then during um when when the field needs to be replaced as opposed to Natural turf fields they have a limited lifespan as we've talked about so these fields are not sustainable there are many directives on the state level as well as your Boxford Wetland values that are not

071supported by these fields there's executive order 618 that recently came out this year talking about biodiversity goals there's executive order 569 that came out several years ago that require s communities towns as well as the state to prepare for the impacts of climate change by assessing vulnerability and adopting strategies to increase the Adaptive capacity and resiliency of their infrastructure and the community needs to consider are these fields consistent with these strategies next slide please in summary um the district the district should consider these issues that we've discussed today Urban heat the life cycle costs the location of these fields whether they're over aquafers uh or in Wetland resources the health and environmental impacts chemical and plastic pollution the climate impacts and sustainability impacts I will um mention just two other um issues the children's environmental

072health center of the Ian school of medicine at Mount siai New York strongly discourages the installation of artificial turf PL surfaces and Fields due to the uncertainties surrounding the safety of these products and the potential for Dangerous heat and chemical explo exposures to children in addition recently this past spring Oak Bluffs in moth's Vineyard Massachusetts banned artificial turf fields due to the potential for pasas to leech into the aquafer which is the drinking water aquifer several other towns have followed I will close with also saying that um several Watershed associations including the Mystic River Watershed Association and the Charles River Watershed Association have come out with um strong um posts on opposing artificial turf saying that they cause excess heat in the Watershed saying that they cause chemical and plastic pollution concerns and disrupt habitat

073and Watershed values there's a practicable alternative to artificial turf which is sustainably managed natural grass Sports fields and I'll turn it back over to Fred um to thank you Susan y um we've given you some information and uh we're proposing that you things need to be considered health and safety of our student athletes and children is is obviously most important I think for the school committee environmental impact with excess use of plastic and the replacement cost Associated budgetary concerns supporting all of the athletic fields here and programs it's not the responsibility of this school committee and this District to support three communities for all of their sports activities either before or after whether it's adult leagues or whether it's it's uh uh other leagues or or youth leagues prior to coming into this school it's

074not your responsibility it's your responsibility to take care of what's needed at the school district I think in light of the fact that the applicant uh for the uh Stadium project was put forth in February 1st um and has been denied by the Boxford Conservation Commission I'm not sure if you're aware of that but it has been denied for a couple of reasons first and foremost is the original proposal done by the the the proponent uh was in violation of a whole bunch of applicable laws related to uh uh the we BR sorry to interrupt but we have that information and actually there's it's on the agenda for the next meeting so responsibility that part I want to make sure that that we're kind of you're kind of back to ground to ground one so

075what we're proposing we aren't back to ground one oh we not so I want that's a misconception we're not back to Ground Zero because if it was denied it was denied without prejudice so so that's on the Merit to resubmit in the beginning of we're yeah but it's not ground was not on the merits of the application it wasn't on the merits of the application not respond is this open form again we're just gonna start talking no that's thank you thank you hold your uh comments please we we we would like to recommend establishing a subcommittee that assesses the actual needs for all of the sports programs here at the school district assess the actual School usage assess the annual cost for all natural field and artificial teals for both fields for both maintenance labor

076equipment and replacement address the Title Nine compliance issues address the ADA compliance issues be a leader in supporting the school district's sustainability po policy and collaborate with all of the stakeholders including a representative from the Conservation Commission with that we to answer any questions if anyone has any thank you very much for your time so and I don't know who's gonna answer this but there's thank you for coming and give us an information um I think there was a lot of confusion in my brain because we started off talking about natural grass versus Turf and then organic Fields um but nowhere did I see where these fields that were presented are hosting 15 teams in one season so we have in the fall we have field hockey boys and girls soccer football that's that's three

077teams each um that's 12 bus in and then the spring I'm sorry not 15 18 in the spring we have lacrosse that use our grass fields um these are all Heavy uses and there was no comparison in the information as to how how many teams actually use each of those fields that were shown um some of our Fields this year were not used um field hockey played at box for commments so the beautiful field was beautiful because there was no use on that um and I have a few questions are organic fertilizers regulated and have there been long-term studies as to what's in them um has um the heat that was the heat picture in the presentation what was the info on that um and then there was I also would like information on the

078water necessary for organic fields and natural Fields I have to defer to if these are things if you want to submit the questions we can get those answers back to you okay because I mean as far as the governors you know they have full you know I guess if you're looking for us to go out and find School and playable hours you know that's something that we can do it's relevant to our discussion at M well and that's something too you know quite honestly we're not paid to be here so you know if we were to look at masco's schedule versus governor's schedule and look at all there's a whole formula for playable hours like it's not in one to one hour like one hour of football doesn't necessarily equal one hour it might equal

079two hours so you know there's a whole formula that goes into that so if you're looking for references where you could call and that's why I think if there was a subcommittee we'd be happy to provide references where you could actually talk to people that do this as far as our organic fertilizers regulated all fertilizers need to be registered for sale in the state that they're used um our fertilizers are omry listed they are approved for use by the organic material review Institute so yes they are um they're water insoluble nitrogen so they don't leech into the environment different than water soluble nitrogen products you guys are probably on a synthetic program here so you know are there studies yes would you like us to find some we can find some but as far as

080the products that we sell um and we were just asked to come talk about what our company does because if you're looking at natural grass you can be talking about a synthetic program versus an organic program when it comes to an organic program uh the cost of your materials go down over probably a three to five year yes we have those studies that show um needs go down because grass actually starts living off of the soils as you increase organic matter levels in the soil and an organic program it increases the water holding capacity of the soil so wet Fields becomes less of an issue um as far as water requirements go in an organic field you have a deeper rooting system so your water needs go down and by the way artificial Turf needs

081to be cooled with water so you're not without water requirements on an artificial turf field when they get hot got to be cooled down um so yes that information's out there and if you really want to know that information and put them in questions and get a subcommittee we would be happy to provide that to a subcommittee um did that answer any of it I because yes it is true there are you I can tell which side you're on and I'm not to I I just I'm I'm finding this frustrating as an exercise just to the committee in general because all of this has been done for 15 years no let me tell you no you have not done a proper maintenance program on your Turf because I talked looked at all these looked at

082all these issues but you haven't done them so there's difference I mean because we do this all the time we go into schools we tell them and it costs a lot of money and it costs a lot of yeah okay proposing cost I am a I am a proponent of tur so twice as much money okay so you can't say you've been doing this because from what I've been told you're l than a tier three here you're not doing that I know so it's fine this I have I have a lot of questions as well but I it's kind of pointless to ask them be if we can't answer the question that is the most pressing which is we think we have one facility one field for 11 to 15 teams playing on at the

083same time in the fall only in the the fall that is what that is what the proposal is for the artificial turf field right for a stadium that can do that right and the reason for that is because we need to have controlled access to the fields for playoffs so that every team here can actually play in front of crowds for during home home games in the fall right now we just want to state championship in soccer we couldn't play any games at home because we don't have a sufficient field for the soccer team to play on with a controlled uh environment for admissions and so they played all of their games away yes that's and and again that's another issue if you guys want to host those tournaments you guys need to think it's

084not a tournament these are just games right one game but there's no regulation in the MIAA that requires youd have an artificial field no there isn't but what I'm but and and like I just said said show me the grass field that can handle 11 teams at once that's that's the question that's the overriding question in all of this all the other stuff is interesting stuff if you can't get to yes on that question we can't build three stadiums be great if we could we can't my daughter goes to Penn State they've got six stadiums Grass Grass Grass Grass Grass except for one field hockey Turf that stadium that could be as as organic as they want it to be and it's still Turf because that's what field hockey wants you know all I'm saying

085is I love there to be an organic solution here I I really would about playable hours there's no question you can play more on artificial turf we're not even debating that but I like to think that it's not just about that you know I think you really need to consider the health and the environmental it you know you have to look at the and the cost it comes with a cost a financial cost a cost to your health and a cost to the environment that's all we're saying is you need to look into and I think Fred's recommendation if people are confident that the artificial turf is the way to go then why don't you support him and and be able to do this so that you can go before your towns and say you

086did your due diligence we have we have subcommittees already that are looking at this so we don't need to have another subcommittee sorry have a DCI subcommittee and this Falls underneath their jurisdiction we have a you know an artificial but a uh um stantech um task force that's looking into what they're doing with their design if you guys want to you know propose building a field for free for us or something and you'd like us to start a task force for that we're happy to do that too right and this is why we don't even usually go to school committee meeting meetings because it's so adversarial all we're saying is if somebody wants to sit down and talk about playable hours on your football field we consult we do that and we'd be happy to

087let you know if it's possible I mean you're throwing out hours and you know when we look at your schedule online it's totally playable you know with with what you have online but you know where is where is that playable hour list does it exist I think you just got up and said that football U ruined one of the fields that you mentioned that during your talk did you not the need of repair it's not it's not been level it's not been maintained and there's what I'm here to say and there's no irrigation there which is another factor which I wish this presentation focused on ways we could get there and just on grass and not making an adversarial presentation tearing down the other side an adversarial what we're suggesting is we we're trying to

088get to a point where we can have these discussions but so my point the entire stantech proposal was very blind singular we're going for artificial turf and of subject because that's what we paid anything I didn't see anything that that that engaged other Alternatives so yes because we paid them to come up with plans for an artificial turf structure but like I was saying the road to getting that football field to playable condition For All Seasons is a long one and we put a lot of money into those other fields to make them look the way they do now including rest like Melissa was saying so I wish we looked at better ways like irrigation just one example that football field that doesn't have irrigation at it and that's why it looks the way it

089does because of one summer where there was a problem so the point here is if you want to know what it is like I mean we're not going to come out for free and and do all that and tell you this is what an IR you can call an irrigation company get a quote on what it's going to cost inst irrigation on your football field I mean you know we can come out for pretty short money you know $1200 we'll put an organic fertility program together for you and tell you what that's GNA be sorry but with all with all the respect this is Fred presenting an idea for the community this is not you coming in to sell your services right so this discussion is pointless at that level question because what he said

090was he was hoping that we come with a proposal for what this cost I understand that but I'm I'm just telling you that that's that's all got to be funneled through Fred's presentation right so you're either speaking as part of the group presenting right or you're not one of the other and you're going off into another Direction when it comes to talking about pricing on things sorry any other questions can I just I just want to add one more comment because I'm a pain in the ass when it comes to this stuff your um slide that showed the total cost is is wrong because it shows the replacement cost of the turf which gives you another 10 years of life and you're comparing 10 years over here to 20 years over here in that slide

091so if you just change the online to say disposal cost and I agree with it but it looks like you've got extra cost in there on the turf side first as was identified there was a a a cost comparison done for the Town of Arlington number of years ago by by Tom Irwin associate hopefully someone in Arlington noticed that as well to the as if you if you go back to slide I this is really just something because someone's going to ask that question to you guys in the future whoever presents this anywhere else no just better everybody you mean the residing may be necessary in 10 years if proper maintenance isn't carried out right see the replace and Disposal take the replace out of there and it's a fair comparison but have the replace

092so notice if proper maintenance is carried out you don't need to reside you will have to replace and disposed on the other the assumption this cated at $30,000 a year is that you're properly maintaining the Fe no I'm talking about the turf side of it the turf side of it you're saying replace it after 10 years and you're including the cost of replacement which means you're but you have to it's not optional I know but that's for the next 10 years whereas on the left you're showing 10 years worth of cost there's a difference may I make a comment you can just say it's 20 years and then just double double double the that's fine double the grass one you're still going to see the same ratio it's still twice as much yeah you'll see

093the same not twice as much yeah it's it's wor after 20 years you have to replace the shark tag I mean let's say that I only want a field for 10 years just 10 only 10 right at the end of 10 years I'm going to build a I'm going to put a parking lot in there because I love parking lots right oh still what's the cost become then you're not replacing it you're just disposing it dising it right disposing of it a million no you're at maybe 13 13 1.3 that's my point is that there's a little bit of a of an inconsistency there that's all I think yeah it's not gonna fly I'm not getting it let's move on any any other any other questions anyone um didn't didn't sit in on on the

094whole history the question did come up of like is there is there that list of playable hours like was that something that we provided to stantech or they provided back to us or does that view exist today I've asked a number of times for it and i' any playable hours for what for evaluating field needo playable hours for a single use or for a single field artificial turf field playable hours for one of our grass fields what playable hours for the entire campus what are you referring to in the original bid our fedo Stant was there a playable hours requirement in there yeah it's from our given the athletic teams that we have what is the number of hours of Field playing time that we need to be sure that we okay get to I've

095asked know a number of times for that information and i' I've been told that it does not exist is that true I doubt that that's true he would he's the guy who gave me that answer it I I mean it can be obviously calculated awfully quickly right we know how many teams we have we know how many practices they have it wouldn't take much get the number hard number to I guess not an insurmountable obstacle viral conversations Stant there must have been a spec that we gave like this is the am like these we need to build towards right I'm assuming we hand it over most of us here but I'm guessing it's propal or so when you're saying we gave them um that was in the 400k right I'm not ex have it on

096top of the head now but yeah exactly I just when you you know when you're ask we'll have to go look at it I mean we could look at the original RFP from like 2016 or 17 yeah exist right can we socialize the requirements that we but I don't I don't proposal just so that the rest of us are caught up and we understand like what what exactly but so I guess there's two ways of looking at this one there's one like how many playable hours do you need and then think we need two Fields because there was a community proposal put together that there was all this money coming that was going to pay for this for free that's what generated this whole thing to start with right so it wasn't a question of

097we need this number of playable hours it was we want you to give us a design proposal for two Fields yeah that's what was put together and so playable hours wasn't really necessarily going to be a part of that discussion whether it was or not it might have been right but if you go look back in time when they were trying to do a a um a a cost uh uh comparison or or a uh Net Present Value calculation on the entire project when there was a proposal to put artificial turf across every single piece of blade of grass on the entire campus just about there was some kind of analysis done and that would have played into how many hours of usable time there would have been to sell to the community that that

098was done at some point are are you referring to the dun and Barry report yes it dunberry originally well very done did the but there was but but there it preceded 2019 when the original stantech presentation was was given to us that had the pH this September of 19th yeah September of 19 there was feasibility study could Happ it's not I don't think there's the hours aren't in there but they look at it when they but there was a cost analysis done with a payb payback for the number of hours you're going be able to rented that was that was in 2022 yeah I don't think hours wor we'll get it and Rental money 50% of of the rentable income that was being suggested in that report was based around the use of baseball fields

099had nothing to do with football no I actually redid the report I did a I did a Model uh that is available not according to the report that filed in the MCO school no my presentation is also on on file point of I just want to put that out there thank you um there's obviously a lot more to discuss here I just wanted that clarification because it's a good thing to see and and understand but I heard the original stantech presentation was September 2019 and then the other one was Melissa I think you said 2022 um there was a a a use analysis done in 2022 and then Stant presented again um okay January 2022 January 2022 okay great I can I can dig into the archives and try to those up and educate myself

100really hard to know how to find anything on our site so I'm trying to get leads so I can get smarter faster and not the subcommittees there's a turfield task force page yeah and there's a document on there that's the history and updates which actually goes back 26 I thought we only had a liais on and not an official subcommittee it's a task force task force it was a task force years ago so it's no longer in no the school the school committee voted for turfield when 23 was that 22 or 23 22 mean that keeps coming up I'd love to someone could point me to that because it it's possible to find things on in the minutes what are you looking for when was the vote that we said had to have been after

101the January 2023 Stant Tech presentation just you I think maybe we take this offline we're swirling pretty hard right now yeah as my recomendation move on okay um and just one thing I Turf of mas. org also has a list like history and documents and plans with all the presentations we've just talked about linked so if you want to go to I can send you the link too but it's all there as well real quick Matt I'll just point out right even for the Turf supporters here I think that there was some good information in here for us to be able to be smart on with any organization that we talk to and ask more informed questions so if we're leaving the topic maybe leave on a high note and just say thank you for

102the information I'm smarter I appreciate what you guys presented there's a few things I struggled to process but I smarter because of it so thank you guys thank you Susan and and thank you and all we're asking for is to let's look at what the entire School District I mean your most popular sport here is track and field and nowhere are we talking about what are you going to do with the track that's literally falling down that's no that's not true' been talking about it in detail one of the things come doing something but do do you have a natural grass uh uh track for us because that's artificial too isn't it I'm kidding I wasn't making a joke of it thank you thank you very much for your time thank you Fred [Music] cl

103play would work slippery though all right uh first reading of policy section d oh sorry we're sorry it's us it's me who's running this it's oh it's me sorry not me thought we doing something I apologize I distracted it wasn't ready all right on Lisa take your number all right right section D let's go um so I presented it as preev um okay so da is staying the same we re these are all sub commmittee recommendations no action required um under DB the recommendation is to keep um not to keep Masco that's not right but um dbr we're going with the mask ma mask version as it um has the regional language that's required BBC we're recommending a change to um the section that refers to from v- a to v-b um and then we're

104taking dbd dbe dbg together um Masco has dbe but not the other two uh so the recommendation is to um keep masco's version and adopt dbe and dbg um sorry I could learn how to page down that would be great um DBI is Masco only um and it Shores up the superintendent's Authority so the recommendation is to keep the Masco version um dbj the recommendation is to add Regional School District to the title use the mask version with the additions from The Mask policy um DD The Mask version was updated in 2016 recommendation is to go with that version um DDA talks about um all sources and we do not need this policy I apologize I was not ready for this yet all right I got to scroll down can't see it from I can't

105see the board from here okay we are removing DDA is the recommendation um and DEC we the recommendation is to adopt the map version um and remove ours but change it to add you know just our language is the mask inment Regional School District um DFD we are striking the policy this should be in a procedure manual and not in policies DGA is a maskon policy um and it falls within our what we do anyway so the recommendation is to keep that talks about the treasurer um DH um we are adopting the M version with the added last sentence that the cost of the bond will be paid by the district um di no action was required the policies were the same um diba um is it's basically an explanation of Reserve funds um and

106not really necessary uh to have in our policy manual so the recommendation is to strike it um same with dib um because that's an accounting procedure and then dib-r is already in section J so the recommendation is to remove it for redundancy uh did um is again more procedures so anything that's talking about procedures in this section we are recommending to delete so that also goes to diie um section DJ deals with purchasing uh the recommendation is to strike the Masco policy and use the um the mask version with a cross reference to our sustainability policy DGA we're recommending um approval and Adoption of the mass version Masco did not have one um djb again discusses procedure so the recommendation is to delete uh this one as well as DJ um and then DJ we

107had a series of DJ e- R1 R2 and R3 um and it's determined that we don't need them because of um statutory law it's covered in section uh Mass General L 30b as well as um we have regulations and then there's internal controls at Masco DJ GA um not required solicitations are covered in section K so this is a redundant policy um DK is a policy that Mas that Masco didn't have and the recommendation is to adopt it um dka dka a we're recommending removal dk-1 we are keeping um that's statutorily required in Masco didn't have that policy dka is a procedure we're deleting that dkc deals with reimbursements and um it is a Masco policy we're keeping the Masco version um of that one and then DM is Passion school buildings um it's a

108procedure and it's something that um is not needed so those are the presentations and anyone has any questions okay um so it seems like we're kind of doing this effort to scrub all the the procedures from the policies presumably that means that there are existing procedures that would be referred to if if there aren't procedures documented what's the fallback is it if there's no policy and there's no procedure or the procedur is outdated like what do we what's so our job as AE is to have policies the administration carries them out um and we have the ability to ask the administration whether or not they're comparing them out that's essentially how it works so we don't we don't have oversight over any day-to-day operations of the district correct yeah okay so we're is it is

109it an assumption that there is procedure in place when grabing this um and at most of the um at most of our policy meetings the Administration has gone through the policies with with prior to and have attended the meeting to confirm procedures in place okay that's helpful thank you um I think there's a lot of there's a lot of D's and other letters and I I might have missed one somewhere but there was one that jumped out at me only because we had a recent was it the grants proposals and special projects DD private yeah grants private sources I think is what the title was um because we were pointed back to policy for that and now we're scrubbing the policy on that so I'm not sure where to go from there so um that

110makes me feel like there's not a procedure in place for the school committee has not ad there's there's a policy as to how we get grants from private sources um how in my as the chair of the policy subcommittee how I see it is we have this we're doing this um the school committee hasn't authorized us to or told us exactly to um we can't do anything without a vote of the school committee sub subcommittees aren't supposed to act independently so right if it's the will of the committee and they want us to look at something then tell us and we'll look at it okay I think I'm just trying to understand the that was rale that was one that was in the community relations section though I think there policy and another policy but

111that refers to more the state federal and other yeah I think the one we were talking about though was so my my my opinion and just having reviewed having reviewed the policies is that in the winter or after the New Year we're going to look at all the policies again so we've gone through them all since 2020 and we we've had made recommendations and then mask is putting together like the final version of it and then at that point we'll adopt it and then we if there's policies that need to be taken out and redone or looked at I think that's I personally think that's the appropriate time to do so or to say let's flag this and this is when we're doing it so you'll notice in the existing policies they have like review

112dates like last reviewed 61 2022 next review date 2023 I think that having do done having reviewed it for five years that's how we have we have to do it have to we have to adopt it and then we have to go back and look at it there 's a couple policies that the committee has asked us to look at um and has taken a vote that we are working on I think we talked about it our last meeting um yes okay so I could explain this to everyone but I'll tell what he just told me which is that these are grants not gifts and they're different things that gifts policies and other section that's okay I well there's also considerations for some of the other subcommittee work that we're doing that's unrelated to the

113community thing but also applicable so yeah those questions understand um okay and so if we're scrubbing something is it generally the case that we would post the rationale in that kind of red line of like we don't need this it's procedure or we don't like if I say a red line and there's no reason for the red line assume it's because this procedure in place versus we're adopting the ASC policy instead or yeah I didn't I didn't I did not put the um I did not have Jackie put the um all notes the the notes from the from the index because I when I was doing my minutes I found them confusing okay um so our notes our minutes from these from the October 4th meeting say exactly what we did okay but and I

114can forward those no I can look in the subcommittee page that's fine yeah um so what I have here I just thought it was a better look at them um to see what I actually yeah I took out the I took out the notes because oftentimes they were um not accurate okay and it got confused when we did the last section have something I was going to ask about gifts actually because of what's come up with in the DCI recently but sounds like it's in a different section so yeah there's in the I can't section there's a gifts policy I'm pretty sure it's hard for me to search the policies this yeah that's the other issue they're all right now them so Trevor I have a question on policy dib-r and I know we're doing

115away with a lot if not all of our RS um because they're usually procedural in nature um but these have come up whether that be um like funds for co-curricular activities that different sports teams have their boosters is that incorporated in this policy it's in section J okay okay yeah there's a Student Activities files policy in J I think yeah I think I went over that okay yeah because the class accounts too have been come up yeah so the goal of the go the goal of the policy review is to remove redundancy in our policies because sometimes there were sections that had the same idea but said it different ways so it got confusing um and then also to remove anything that's procedural to keep the aspirational concept of the policies with a few exceptions

116because some sometimes there's a a statutory requirement that we have a procedure in our policy based on a law with that I move that we adopt section b um or approve it for a first read second second further discussion all right we'll do just a Voice vote all in favor say I I opposed exensions passes by unanimous voice for okay uh superintendent's report so let's see first up uh the some updates on uh the DECA program uh our Deca program competed at The District 24 conference at the Double Tree in Danvers on December 10th and 11th uh some big numbers here so bear with me 114 of the 220 masconomet Deca members in the competition were top seven winners in their category St so had 114 kids qualified to represent Mas anomet the state de

117Deca conference that's that's some remarkable numbers you know about half the kids and actually the 220 is is like 20% of the school is actually in Deca so um so it's again great program these Deca state qualifiers will have the opportunity to Res represent Masco and earn a spot at the international Deca conference which is uh in Orlando Florida in April and so there's there's actually a much longer release uh that is uh included there's a link to it my will be a link to it in my block uh we also want to congrat our congratulate our science team uh they finished second overall at their December meet uh took first place in nuclear chemistry uh second place in the Leaning Tower of Pisa build and third place in insects and arachnids of Massachusetts and

118so our team is now third they moved up from fifth place in the league to third place in the league after that meet so congrats on that work um we also had our uh Model United Nation team uh they kicked off their conference season with a one-day simulation hosted by uh St John's Prep uh 18 Masco delegates joined with hundreds of students from schools around New England for an exciting day of debate and negotiation uh to create resolutions for some of the world's most pressing issues uh student G delegates were assigned to one of a dozen committees including traditional un bodies uh such as the special political and decolonization committee uh the United Nations human rights committee and the committee on the peaceful uses of outer space u as well as more specialized committees such

119as the US Senate debate on IM immigration reform uh and the British House of Commons debate on brexit uh we had several mascow delegates receive Awards of recognition we're proud of their efforts uh Dylan Guido was uh recognized as best negotiator and fortunately SAR left uh Delaney Ogden was best delegate as the uh United Kingdom and uh the SP po committee great debater to takes after for her mom congratulations mosta uh Thomas Buckley was best negotiator uh as the United States in the general assembly and Landon butier uh was the best negotiator and he was at Hunter Thompson in the ultim Ultima committee which I really want to see pretty amazing so congratulations to all of them uh we are going to uh update on uh the school quality measure survey um beginning January 6th

120uh the district will be conducting a series of surveys to help us better understand the experiences of students parents and faculty in our schools uh these School quality measure surveys uh will be administered through the education Commonwealth project uh which is an organization that's based out of the University of Massachusetts at ammer uh and it's dedicated to assisting Massachusetts school districts gain a better understanding of their strengths uh and areas for improvement uh all of our middle and high school students uh will take the school quality measures survey during mblock on January 6th uh the survey will take about 25 minutes to complete uh and parents and Guardians who have questions about the survey should contact their child's principal um we'll also be sending a companion survey link to all masconomet parents through the email

121address that they provide to the district and then faculty members will complete a Sur a version of the survey during the their faculty meetings on January 6th all survey responses are Anonymous and will not collect personal information uh the school quality measures framework uh seeks to create a comprehensive picture of the effectiveness of a school uh rather than focusing solely on achievement test scores uh the sqm framework evaluates a school's Effectiveness in the areas of teachers and Leadership School culture resources academic learning and community and well-being through collecting uh School reported data from the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and secondary education uh and through surveys of school stakeholders uh the result of this data collection is the creation of uh sqm dashboard uh that offers a more Dynamic picture of school student learning than a

122single standardized test uh there's a link in my blog for more information dashboard uh and the education Commonwealth project and so we want to thank everybody in advance for taking the time to fill out the surveys uh we'll use the sqm dashboard to guide our school Improvement efforts uh and creation of the dashboard uh is a component of our Mass economic strategic plan so actually a little ahead of schedule on this one too because didn't know if we were going to be able to do it this year and we're going to do it so it's good news and then on January 6th and 7th uh the high school nursing and counseling staff will administer the sbirt health screening to all ninth grade students uh the SBT stands for screening brief intervention and referral to treatment

123uh it's used to screen for alcohol nicotine tobacco and Other Drug use on health screening is required by mass law so there'll be some details coming from uh the high school for details this say a date of that again actually it'll be the sixth and 7th January yeah and that's for an update and actually just want to wish everybody a happy holiday and a couple of weeks away back on the second all right subcommittee reports community relations Mary you're up our we're tentatively scheduling a work meeting I was a little sick for a couple days sorry I still I'm fine but I'm just this won't go away so um we're tentatively scheduling a working meeting for hopefully the week of the 28th probably like January 2nd or 3 um we'll have that figured out by

124the end of this week we have our community Dialogue on the 22nd I know that I think it was the last meeting that we put Erica in charge of the survey or heading up a type of a survey for figuring out a little bit of what you mentioned um Mike about getting information from families that about their experience here at mascow I'll let Erica kind of take over but I think I I was kind of hoping we could maybe have results of something even for the January 22nd meeting or Community dialogue just in my brain thinking to kind of get information out but I know you had yeah thanks for sharing I know that's I don't want to overload um yeah our goal was to have it live early to mid January um thinking about

125like the um I definitely want to go back through like our draft questions and make sure we're not repeating um given our aims but we're we're discussing having or creating a survey that we send to all members of the community versus just families or students who chose not to come to Mascus so that we can get a bigger picture of what is drawing people to Masco and then people opting for other places um we're also discussing a mini flyer potentially mailer with a QR code thinking about the mailer that the community relations um subcommittee made shine to zilly um before the budget last year that went to all households just to inform with a QR code it would make it really easy we're shooting from no more than seven questions so that's uh fairly quick

126to hopefully complete um so still definitely in draft form and discussion like Kendra said but working to uh get this live and try to get as much perspective as possible um would do want we actually have uh M School administration and the uh School counseling office to uh prepped up to come to our next meeting um and then we're going to talk about some next steps too so okay I want to think about there Nary yeah is that something should should you facilitate us connecting with them so that we can make sure that we don't yeah step and reach out to you Mike to make sure like in terms of what they're gonna share and also align our timing right I was just trying to find I have the education Commonwealth project ser questions somewhere

127I got to get my hands on them and I can send those to you guys too that'd be great thanks we met again on December 13 um it was a brief meeting in fact we even finished before Mike was back from his with parents um we got a quick update from Jeff we've received the HVAC uh study proposal that came in 156k um we're still waiting for the feasibility study uh for track and softball fields and we are waiting for the interior elevator um modernization estimates as well and so Jeff was hoping to have those uh in house before the holidays um so do you see that today was it today or yesterday I haven't checked my email today did it Comm in yeah great not a lot of moneyy softball $13,000 or something it's

128isn't great um I think the other thing Jeff's been doing is he's starting to get estimates for some of the other items on the list that would go into the 2026 big ask um but you know remaining focused on you know those three priority studies and the the two the two studies the interior elevator um as a reminder you know the discuss it was around yeah you have a 650k app I think that the strategy here that we talked about would be that we would propose so the full school committee would be um if the two studies and the interior elevator modernization come out to over 650k which it doesn't sound like it's going to um if it does come out to over 650k then we'd ask for more than 650 50k if it comes

129out to less than 650k we' um sort of deliberate on maybe a couple easier tasks continue the mic I'll pause I'm sure everyone wants to hear all the things there you go we're on all right as I was saying if it's if it's more than 650k for the three items we would ask for more than 650k if it comes out to be less than we'll pick a couple other easier things to uh um to cross off the list uh in the next fiscal year as well um otherwise um our next meeting is on January 10th where we plan to kind of digest um the latest estimates and start to talk about a format and formula for our presentation on uh January 22nd the only other thing that I'll note is just a reminder that the

130um Middleton folks are meeting with um the Middleton Town Representatives on January 7th January 7 so my plan would be just to brief the charts that we brief to the school committee a few weeks ago Point okay anti-racism sure we uh just met prior to this being here today um just moving forward with our draft Charter trying to work towards that so we've identified some opportunties some data analysis or some public databases are out there and we're also looking to do a little Outreach too uh some of local groups as well as any few nonprofits that are in the area space did you want that to be an agenda item for next meeting ready just to be official I think um we have the charter in the renaming be nice to get that stamped you

131think you're good to go yeah it's ready whenever you guys want on the agenda yeah yeah I don't think it's a high priority but if it's time be nice anything further for policy um our next meeting is January 13th at 12:30 that a Monday or Tuesday it's a Monday I think it is yeah it's a Monday okay leaz on updates um I was going to say Middleton folks were meeting January 7th at the select board but Middleton's been pretty quiet after town meeting so nothing to report Topsfield I think we have to coordinate right I'm sorry have to coordinate with yeah yes yes they we've talked about a need to have a meeting but we just haven't come up with the uh with a date yet so they offered that um I guess a variety

132of Mondays in in January um but also want to be sure that I I'm pretty certain they they have our our budget presentation calendar but I you know want to highlight any particular thing that it's worthwhile for them to come did anything come out of the listening session on Saturday yeah okay just board members there essentially they talked about trash nothing to do with Masco fincom people um no there was no questions for Masco really oh we talked about um talked about Civics all right sorry I missed [Laughter] it oh the Boxford uh folks got together with our uh did our monthly breakfast uh session which took three hours surprisingly um I I was like shocked that we've been talking over that long breakfast um kind of status quo there's really like uh two things

133that are foremost on everyone 's mind um one is do whatever you can to keep the budget increase as small as possible consider all options like you know do we need three teams in junior high is it time to go to two teams of student body populations down by 33% those kind of things um the other one is you know engage with the Masco building committee those are probably the two hot most hot button issues coming out of Boxford um was there anything else those are definitely the top two those are the top two I'd say they offer up recommendations on that you would like us to engage with the Masco building committee well I told I told them that that uh you already were you know sharing everything you've been receiving in terms of

134quotations with them for feedback and I I mentioned that you know it's a little difficult to bring in six additional people up front to talk to people about giving us bids on things it's just going to slow things down they seem somewhat satisfied with that but I I also let them know that that because you had just gotten um a response from one of was it Josh was Jared okay I mentioned that and I said that you know you guys are definitely engaging um they did say you know they they'd like to know when the NBC is going to have a full tour of the facility um whether that has happened yet I said no I don't think it's happened yet but I know that you guys are working on it um and uh even

135one of them Mike Mike said he would be he' be willing to join that when that when that happens so I'm definitely coming we provided them with a copy of our Charter oh yeah they we went over that yeah they they know what it looks like yeah but there their take on it is that you still need to engage I know that that you know we explained we're not going for a big capital capital is not happening for at least a year and a half therefore the the urgency has been reduced right but their take is you still need to start engaging with these people to get them on your side so that they can then advocate for you um you know so and I said that that would begin happening in the second half

136of the year now that you guys have gotten the priority list behind y y so just keep doing what you're doing because I it looks like you're moving that direction anyway I add a little we also got an info from msba this week that um the statement of Ventures period will open on January 13th and it'll close uh March 21st and it looks like they reduced the age of roofs to 20 years oh Christmas came early there's a webinar coming up Jeff and I are both GNA do it but it seems like that's their website now is that they want their 20 year proof did they not add heat pumps as well heat pumps were added too yes so that's good good for us but it creates more competition maybe I don't know don't be

137a downer the glimmer is that it they we're eligible now be their first project for yeah I mean that's that is [Music] definitely and he pumps together like serving it to them on a silver platter perfect okay uh negotiations anything we're not really right nothing done question is it possible to have an executive session afterwards we would have had a post it to ask about the status era negotiation so that we have a session on the 9th um with a mediator that's January 9th January that we got that update we haven't had anything since the last okay last week we had okay thank you okay that brings us to the consent agenda moov of the December 4th 2024 meeting minutes warrants in the amount of 2,42 8142 and the third thing here is the approval

138of an overnight Disney World field trip this is band trip that they came in and presented on and they just changed the date of it so we have to approve the new date so moved I have a question about the field trip which I think is great it's just my bad it seemed like people already should have had a deposit in a couple of days ago do people know that don't I don't know that they've advertised it at all yet they generally would not until you guys said yes oh do they advertise it at all has has Jared advertised it all I don't think he's collecting deposits yet well the the kids and the families know going pricing they know change of date payment schedule that's good I read that I was like oh that's

139interesting um um so I'm not sure how it'll get shifted at a conference this week um don't have those answers for you I'm sorry that looks like it's from the but we're approving that they can go on the trip we're not approving the yeah yeah yeah I don't think this is something they were planning on going he started collecting money yet no no Money's been right in the document the first payment was due on the 15th of December right I presume that's Chang they're gonna have to make yes Jeff um I just two quick comments they kind of fact handwriting these forms is very hard to read 2025 guess we get these typed or digital volunteering I'm happy to use a guy like you I I know we movies to you know out of individual

140votes but you know I still same statement I have concerns with the way these are so very paper heavy here amazing make a sub team on that I'll volunteer to um State ability good St but my other is the same one you I still have concerns of the way we oversee field trips in general at the school so you it's going be a standard comment in general not on the specific one but just the the process and the polici we' handle this just to call back to Jared's presentation I think he was excited at the idea of like coming back to say here's how the trip went this is something to celebrate about the kids and all that so just a call out it might be a nice way to close loop on these things

141if there's room on the agendas can I make a motion is there a second second it any further discussion we voice F this Voice vote all in favor say I opposed exensions right so we got 10 and one that meeting R ran out of agenda you for the sh mik welcome for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.