CorpusRecord 121116

MRSD School Committee Meeting | 12/4/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Masconomet School Committee
Date
2024-12-05
Location
Essex County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,393 words · about 69 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e okay call us meeting to order at 701 according to my phone and 7 o'clock according to my computer so I don't know which it is but we'll say 701 uh starting with some remarks excuse me I want to start by just uh congratulating our girls soccer team for winning this state championship um should be two years in a row because last year the refs kind of did us over uh in the semis but um great to see it and hopefully they they can win it again next year um and speaking of which you know one of the subjects that's near and dear to all the soccer players are the the field situation um there's a couple things going on that I think people need to be aware of coming up uh we're

002expecting a an update from stantech in one of the up coming meetings uh for those of you that aren't aware uh we don't have permitting approved yet uh with this with the um Stadium plan and until we get there then the Masco Sports Foundation cannot do the fundraising that we need them to do in order for the school committee to determine how and and um when we we move forward second thing going on is uh next uh meeting we're going to have a team come in and give us a presentation on using natural grass instead of artificial turf um I think there were some comments made at the last meeting I wasn't here uh about uh us ignoring um the wishes of people that weren't interested in Turf and I just want to say that's

003really not at all what's been going on we've been we're aware we've been aware of it we've been waiting for the DCI uh subcommittee to determine what timing looks like on some of these projects also working through teachers contracts and now working with parent contracts as well there's a lot going on um we never intended to ignore anyone uh we just were looking for the right time to actually put that into the agenda so that's being addressed now uh other than that uh we'll move on to comments from the audience anybody have a comment yep all right we've got one please State uh your name and where you're from my name is Andrea I am from the Middle School uh I'm a parah here I've been here for eight years I'm also the vice president

004of the par professionals Union and I am a tri toown resident my daughter attends the eth grade I want to talk tonight about how we are still working without a contract let me first say that we enjoy our roles here we really do we adore the kids we are on the front lines but each year there's an increase in students and their needs are becoming more and more demanding we are seeking a salary increase we are also looking for fairness across the board for all the power professionals and a competitive salary schedule right now compare it all the other districts we are at the bottom come on now TR toown we should be at the top really we're at the bottom in the grand scheme of things we're asking for a small amount it's not

005a lot I still can't wrap my head around why this hasn't been settled but it hasn't we know there's a budget we know it has to be adhered to but budgets are like elastics they can be stretched Lord knows it can be stretched in my house and our students are worth that's it thank you thank you anyone else okay give me a p stter good evening please uh say your name and my name is Leslie Crow I've worked here at Masco for five years throughout the time I've been a nurse a teacher a counselor and a therapist and a babysitter I've been sneezed on excuse my language I've been farted on dripped on and coughed on I've been shoved pushed and punched I've been sworn at talked down to and disrespected I've ran through these

006halls in Hot Pursuit and I've walked at a snail's pace with all the patience I possess I gather breakfast items for those students that arrive late to ensure none of our students stop their day hungry I greet the bus in the morning and make sure our students board the bus safely in the afternoon I'm a lunch Monitor and a bathroom monitor I deliver mail and packages throughout both schools with our students as a vocational task Fridays our class brings joy to everyone by selling and delivering bagels and coffee I love my job I love our students I'm a power professional in the high school lrc and I find it insulting that other districts are willing to pay $ 30 to $40 an hour for power professionals and our district doesn't even know our value I

007encourage you all to speak with the teachers who rely on our services talk with our principal and our assistant principal our superintendent and assistant superintendent of student services and our security team they know what we do they see us every day running sitting on the floor waiting for a pupil they'll tell you how truly valuable we are thank you for your time and I hope this contract will be resolved soon so we can all have a happy holiday thank you anyone further that's it okay we'll move on then to um student Advisory Board Jack good afternoon I'm Jack savitzky here's update on the student body um prior to break the school participate in its annual pep rally uh with the modifi changes in the schedule such as increasing the time for PowerPuff to 30 minutes

008rather than 15 and the unique um assment of games that EXA chos along with the rest of the student government I say that was an overall improvement from previous years and we had a much for time um spirit week also took place prior to the break overall turnout was good among students and teachers though I would say that Spirit Day themes that we picked were a little bit challenging to do I know from my own experiences um Hall decorating was also a success with all gra and well um sophomores one in case anyone was wondering um being the most spirited out of the four grades um next up seniors will have their Snowball Dance over at Black Black Swan on December 12th and also on December 12th the senior citizens holiday concert will take place

009uh this is where the band and the course of reforming concert for the counts on aging from the three towns and EXA well is a help Prov I want as well that's all I have thank you thank you any questions for Jack all right you're free to stick around leave whatever you feel best uh that's going to bring us to the enrollment report we'll keep that pace all right so uh this is the uh package uh that uh demonstrates our October 1st uh 2024 enrollment report uh we use October 1st because that's the date that the department of Elementary and secondary education uh requires us to report on uh it's also the date that we use uh for our regional agreement uh in setting our percentages of apportionment um for our budget for our annual

010budget um so you can see this first uh page is a resident enrollments by Town um so this does not include uh faculty students as you see down at the bottom of the footnote there are three faculty students and 43 non-resident uh school choice students that are not included in these numbers this is just Boxford Middleton and Topsfield uh and as you can see this year the October 20 24 number is uh, 1498 total students um and then the second table there is the assessment percentages by Town um so you can see that in the FY 26 column this is actually the uh I believe it's the first year first year that we're using the full fiveyear rolling average uh that we uh had DED through our change in the regional agreement going back five

011years ago now um and so you can see that's the 37.25% for Boxford 33.0 n% for Middleton and 29.6 six% for Topsfield uh and you can see the year-over-year changes to those numbers uh almost half a point uh reduction for Middleton a 38 Point increase for Topsfield and a 08 uh percent increase Boxford um you know just historically looking at these resident enrollments you can see we're down uh just about um almost over 500 students actually um over the last uh 12 years going back to October of 2012 uh this is something we've talked about at a pretty uh length last year talking about we're looking at really an average reduction of about 50 students per year uh over the last several years uh the next slide next sheet in this deck actually looks at

012uh the reconciliation for our enrollment for this year and you see there we used the October 23 total enrollment was 1592 students uh we graduated 262 seniors back in the spring uh we added um the new seventh grade came into the middle school was 268 students uh we also participated in the school choice program in grades seven and nine uh for this year uh we were able to actually enroll all 10 ninth grade seats uh we were only able to enroll four uh seats of the 10 that we had allocated for grade seven uh as we talked about this also last spring uh we had 80 students uh 83 students in grade eight uh transfer out at the end of the eth grade year uh we had new ninth graders eight transferred in and then

013across the entire district and another seven uh transfers in uh those 8th grade uh transfer out you can see we broke down how where those students went uh 42 to Essex Tech 13 to St John's Prep four to pingry uh five to Austin prep and then 19 other single uh schools that students went went to coming from the eighth grade uh for ninth grade um 42 for Essex Tech is actually double of the year before there were 21 just give it since 21 students went to Essex Tech last year 10 to St John's and then there were 17 others that were singles that 83 number over the last looking back eight or 10 years has averaged 45 right that's 38 students higher in this single year than the average over the prior decade yeah there

014are some I think that were similar numbers and decreases 13 to 14 was 77 uh 15 to 16 was 95 reduction I was I was speaking specifically to grade eight yeah but there some of those to that that 83 number that you know the um the grade transfer out yeah prior question here a transfer yeah I just actually had a question did has asex Tech published a reason why they increase enrollment no because our our population didn't shift I don't think amongst the member towns for the district but yeah I think actually SX Tech is actually um targeting a different profile of student okay quite honestly they're they're touting now at SX Tech their advanced placement program um they're really you know I was doing some research on because I wanted to see when the

015actual new building open and it was in 2014 um but their most recent they had an article on Salem News in the spring about two students get to admitted to the ivy league um so I think I do think they've shifted in their their approach to what types of students they're actually admitting yeah I was just curious because I that's big that's double and I don't think our population anywhere else would have doubled in the no sorry um I'm just I know we're kind of just peeling back the onion on this but do we have a sense of what amount of that population might Boomerang back to us because I know that there has been anecdotal things about kids that maybe leave to go to a private school and then end up back at Moscow

016um it's probably looking you know that all other seven down at the bottom that would be students that come back in different grades other than grade nine um you know I I've heard that too you know yeah I I just didn't know St John's wasn't for me and they're back you know yeah so if we're tracking that at all or I mean it would be good information to know to so that we can maybe help these kids understand the choice they're making and support them in that choice in a better way I don't know so question I have is and I I think it's kind of what Melissa was getting at but I don't know if it was the exact same thing I'm thinking was is this a demand issue or a supply issue meaning

017are there more kids looking to go to Essex Tech or is Essex Tech just taking more kids which which is it I don't know have we we'd have to and is it unique to Masco do the digging into you know how many applications were actually and the middle school guidance Department may know this of how many applications every year they've they've been putting in and is it the same number of applications and we just had a better rate of acceptance or were there more um more applications than there were in years past you know I think I think if you also think about what's going on in the media where we're talking about you know getting kids you know Real World skills and not having kids graduate from college with mountains of debt I mean

018the vocational program kind of plays right into that but what we don't know is what's happening in the other member towns right right I don't know if somebody else didn't get other towns reducing their number of students that are going which is freeing up seats right and increasing right they didn't open a new building right I can reach out to the Topsfield rep on the Essex techit um anecdotic I heard that the the classrooms are really crowded at the tech this year i' believe it I wonder if we could get data from them didn't they have an addition it was what were they working on it wasn't I I thought it was an athletic building I remember their older athletic buildings that were working on last fall okay I remember a capital request coming through

019but yeah I think that's what it was Chris so I think it it would be very interesting to hear what other districts like ours are experiencing because there's been a lot in the globe recently about the vocational um Bush General Nationwide and Massachusetts has really seen it um I think the numbers I saw had Massachusetts had the lowest rate in over a decade of students High School seniors matriculating to two and four-year College Programs this year and so I think you know Essex Tech serves a really unique um um Niche when that value proposition about college is being called into play and that's where I'm really interested in learning more about the after dark program um if we could ever have a presentation about that or if there's materials we can read about it I

020met with the S6 Tech super um two weeks ago on um a different matter but mentioned to her that Mas would be interested in learning more about that and so so our high school principal and I'm trying to think of I think our director School counseling have been attending meetings with SX Tech about the after dark program this this fall awesome I know that they've got to at least one I want to say two um meetings on on after dark so so I think that could be an interesting option for our students um and it could also be really interesting for parents and students in the Middle School who are considering vocational options to know that is a pathway later on for Masco students moving on this fits in here our next um slide looks

021at um total enrollment so this includes uh as you can see on the the tallies there includes the faculty children and the school choice students um by grade so when you include our um non-resident students the total enr is 1544 uh students right now and you can see the bottom half of this slide uh shows the current enrollments uh in the TR toown School Union uh by town and so we're looking at around 282 students total in sixth grade um that would be candidates to come into seventh grade next year so that we'll use that number as the basis and then um generally as we try to predict our enrollment we subtract 45 um redo the average it might be a little bigger but generally and then we'll see uh we can do some more

022digging into the Essex Tech question I do want to talk to guidance and see how many students applied this year and then then last piece of this looks at total enrollment distribution by grade uh and that's it this is historic going back to October of 2014 um and so you can see there our fiveyear change uh all the way to the right is a reduction of 222 students or 12.6% uh the one-year change talked about was a reduction of 48 students or 3% of our total and see again that grade six at 282 students as I said is the number we'll we'll use to make our estimates to for for next year as we as we look at our budget there's the pro projections that we're talking about for 2025 we shouldn't say I misspoke

023when I said we reduce the sixth grade we actually add students in sixth grade and we reduce going from eight to nine um as we as we'll do projection so looking back over that same 8 to 10 year period um historically we've added 15 students from sixth to 7eventh grade so we typically get the full class from the TR towns uh in sixth grade and then there's on average 15 other students that come and enter um grade seven here at mascow so we add 15 at grade seven on average we subtract 45 at grade nine so the 25 would include 10 Choice students is that uh the change oh no the change I'm sorry it's year this has nothing to do with Choice my mistake yeah that's year-over-year change the projection assumes uh three faculty

024students uh and uh 43 Choice students right in that right so if the same Exodus happens from 8 to 9 right the the number is going to be a lot lower than 1571 right the next highest number um was last year actually it was uh it was 47 um so it went from 40 average was 45 so it's always Teeter to right around 45 then 47 last year then 83 this year right I feel like we need to understand this right like if if we if this was a company we were losing clients like 30% of the eighth grade did not want to continue their education here whatever the vocational proposition is that's out there that you know that's only that's only a the tip of the iceberg we we I I feel like as

025a school committee we need to understand this so what do we do what's what's the process for digging into it how can we help um one of the things we talked about this last spring and it actually didn't happen was doing a survey of uh families that are leaving um I asked the guidance uh director of School counseling to do this last spring it actually didn't happen and it got caught up in the her resignation honestly um so we do have a survey that we're we're sitting on right now and that we would be you know I would think we would put it out in the spring for this current Year's eth grade when we know students once students let us know that they'll wait until we have another Exodus well Ian we could do

026this we could do last year's now it's just kind of after I mean as a parent of an eighth grader at mascow right now this is when we're having the conversation we've been having the conversation so so and the and the high school did ight on the 12th 21st of November couple of weeks ago just for that reason uh because we know that's I was attendance it was pretty good I think from what I to the principal about okay I mean is there any reason we can't I know the forget the survey I mean we must have parents' phone numbers of the kids that left can't we have someone in in the district call them up one by one and just say why did the same can't do that even last year you know we

027feel didn't disappear we we have a contact I mean we do have the contact info from the people that left from last year we could could send survey yeah I think to a lot people point you know it's what what's the return going to be on that is the real question but well I think what we might lose next year is I mean there's a difference between sending out a survey we collecting data and you don't really know why you're collecting data you're going to get extreme ends of the spectrum you always do with the survey right I care about this a lot I don't care about this I'm GNA respond I'm G to respond for negative reasons or I'm going to respond I'm going to respond for positive reasons you're just going to get

028the outliers um I mean is there a creative way to do this where like I know there's someone that actually calls and checks in with those people and says hey this is so Ando for masup you guys made a choice to leave us see how things are going with child a and you know is there any feedback that you have from us if they're having a great experience tell us what we could be doing and if they're not you know let us know if you need anything that's what I suggest sorry just create a personal connection there's only what 40 something I mean not only but it takes time I get that and resources but you know this matters a lot yeah morning time here U Matt soorry I think this came up before maybe

029it was last year it was a mat yeah and I'll say the same thing that I said last year right is I just I think we need to be careful about what we're trying to achieve right and so I agree with what everybody's saying Chris I'm not sure I agree with the analogy to a company right a company's purpose is to grow and to keep customers at any expense right I want to know because they want something different or they leaving because we're doing something wrong right there's a big difference between those two things they're leaving because they don't believe they don't subscribe to our Charter but our Charter is true then let's stay head fast if they're leaving because we're not adhering to our Charter and what we say we're going to do then

030let's fix that right but I just want to make sure that we're not trying to become something that right we're not we don't want to be and right now we don't know and are we going to sit back and not know for another year and so you don't like the company analogy but the fact is we are not serving the people in our community in the way in which they're looking for their children to be educated and maybe it is because they want something it's probably a host it's probably 83 different reasons but whatever it is we shouldn't be operating in a vacuum be operating in a vacuum y I agree um I have two points um we the first is we keep focusing on Essex Tech because they took such a larger amount however

031if you add up the numbers of kids that left there's 41 kids that left went elsewhere so we can't just keep focusing on what Essex teched because there's whole other half that left for other reasons and then my other point you guys are talking about calling but is somebody again if you think of it as a business I left you I don't want you calling me I think a less invasive would yeah are we going to get the outliers and people don't want those surveys but I want a phone call even less I left you for a reason I am more likely to answer a an email or a per a paper survey then I am a phone call because that feels very pushy and I wouldn't I wouldn't want that I'm not going to

032answer that I might answer a paper though or an email Melissa I was G I actually have a different I I think we should be really concerned with the numbers going to Essex Tech because those are I think what I wrote down was that last year we lost 10 and then 17 to to not to nonex Tech private schools I think that's what you said but I'm like 27 21 or something like that was 21 Essex Tech 10 St John's 10 C three central three governors okay two Boston two Brooks okay so 21 and 20 so those numbers are not as off as the essextech and if SX Tech is doing a better job of if we need to bring in a program like like if if if for instance our applications to SX Tech

033doubled and then I think that we need to really reconsider some of the the that the after school after dark whatever it is program because I know that even when looking at colleges the vocational schools that offer more Hands-On training they out like job availability and um I happen to have a child out of vocational college so um I know the importance of it but and and in talking to people you know in a the local coffee shop saying oh my kid my son went to he didn't get into Essex Tech but if we had another program like SX Tech after dark that would have been a good fit for him so because last year I think there was a high percentage of kids who applied and didn't get in so in 23 to 24

034but that those again are just an anecdotes um but I I think that's really the outlier is the SX Tech number um and 30 years ago we had some vocational programs at mascow we had um auto shop and there were some programs at our school that have gone away so um yeah I agree with a lot of the points here I I don't think we should be chasing things we don't aren't in our you know our priorities but we should understand why people are here why they're not here so I don't think we should be using this as you know if it's something we're doing people feel leaving because of something we're not providing we can't provider don't want to that's fine if if they are choosing to go somewhere else because they're dissatisfied we

035should understand that regardless so that's s we just spent 20 minutes talking about this we have no information to make a conclusion which so it it's R we talked about this last year and we're still in the same spot so I really like to get moving on understanding you know what the causes are um and I think I I actually would encourage a phone call or an email I think you know over the last two years it's under 80 people it's not a ton of work we don't need it tomorrow but that personal Outreach saying hey you know you are part of the Mas Community we're just trying to understand we're not trying to play you back in but just you know because I think if you do a survey you are going to get

036the extremes which is useful but not complete so so I think you know a casual conversation somebody we could find who has the band withd just to reach out and if you get a third respones it's a little more detail a little more Nuance than just ping in the people are really angry people feel really frustrated because it is effort to get a survey and respond back so reaching out might be the way to go I'd really encourage that I'm happy to call 21 of these people and create a list of questions you can ask I feel similarly like this is a lot like families that I talked to didn't know about that event it wasn't in the Middle School memo I had a box for family Reach Out feeling frustrated about that and saying

037this is on your agenda this week we didn't like this wasn't included in that what are you doing about this families that I know view Essex Tech and one got off the weight list and was like she got off the weight list at Essex Tech and when I grew up here it was Essex Aggie and my parents do not have a positive connotation you know it's very different they got two kids into the ivys last year we did so if I'm a parent talking to you know those parents are like it is everything that we can offer plus they got a kid iny plus vocational as an option but so many AP courses so I just I feel like we have to move because this is clearly a really big threat thinking about the continued

038Financial implication of like the you know climate that we're operating in this is not going away I'd be shocked if that number shifts drastically next year I am happy to create create a list of questions call half of these people share it in a Google form however I agree I feel like we we have to move I I sort of like they decided to jump in just a you know may school committee leading the charge on this because it is one step remov from the administration and can deescalate things it's more of a casual conversation versus you know officials calling in so I'd be happy to you know Pi that load too and it also takes off the burden of you know your your day job I don't know how people would like the fact

039that the administration's giving us their contact that's what I was just wondering yeah well maybe there a process we start the charge and get people to buy into it and then yeah like can they give us the their yeah I don't know if we can yeah it's a good point you get an optin if you send an email that says we'd love to understand more about why you decided to leave the Masco Community our school committee members are deeply committed to this issue and would love to reach out to you is it okay for us to provide your contact information and they say yes you have explicit consent and by any law that I know about yeah they opt in yeah you're good if you were planning to send an email anyway maybe that's the

040email you send and then we do hard for you I also think we should do something with younger families because I know a lot in the TR Town yes who are already with kids in elementary school have a sibling at SX Tech and young siblings are saying that's where I'm going like I think too there's a lot of what is making you consider this for your children who may not be at Masco yet it's a really important thing to understand and has I have a lot of questions about SX Tech in there like what they're doing to get kids into the IVs and why or do they have a higher like Co College have they been steadily increasing their college enrollment um numbers and things too and why um because it is a vocational school

041so we know which IV I don't but and dart Brown and dart the article said um and what programs programs yeah yeah yeah it could be like their robotics program or you know engineer engineering yeah so um there's a lot of factors and are more kids where do our kids want where do they want to go and I know I heard it was harder to get into some of the um the exploratory programs this year because of the high enrollment I think one of the things I keep in mind here is with the um action being overturned by Supreme Court a lot of selections are based on Z codes it's harder to get into an Ivy League school from our ZIP codes yes than it would be from someone in Salem and it could be

042just that but it is what it is um so one thing I think the the I think des's e Toc Hub will have data on Essex Tech's trendings in terms of like enrollment and college and all that but separately is there any component of this that makes us want to look at curriculum because I think a lot of the anecdotal stuff I hear about is how much more appealing the stories are coming from Essex Tech and how it's like Hands-On learning and you're doing stuff and it's interesting and interactive and engaging and like this is a more traditional academic situation and we're not doing anything Innovative or creative really so is there an opportunity in our work with curriculum to look at that more closely and say what can we be doing to make this

043a more engaging academic environment for the kids that models a little bit more about what they're hearing happening at a tech school but for this harder Jeff add in our purview we're kind of verion off of the original topic but just on the the ivy league you know enrollment one of the things I noticed that we talked about last year was with the school counselors and the Outreach to the school systems and the colleges and you know we did not have very robust Outreach to the Ivy Leagues and certain schools and I think that maybe SX Tech is doing that I think a lot of these schools especially the more Elite schools do have a pretty strong network with the guidance counselors and I think I'm looking forward to you know I think we have

044some new leadership there in that group we should revisit that because I think that was one of the things that came up pretty aggressively last year about you know targeting the school SCH to engage with and sell our story I'm just you know I'm always concerned that we're just not on the radar for a lot of schools tror and I don't want to bring this off topic but I think it's worth mentioning um about our meeting on with the town officials who gave us um their input um on our enrollment and what that should mean for our staffing models and all that so just I want everyone to remember this conversation when we have a budget meeting um later down the road and just keep that in mind yeah I'll wait till the uh Lea's

045on part of the meeting gets here to comment on that meeting I was just gonna say sorry go ahead um I do think we should put something out January is is a a nice little dead zone after everybody gets through the chaos of the holiday so the beginning of January for me would be if I'm gonna put out a survey or put something out to say if you you know if you decided not to come back to Masco or if you're you know a younger family in the tri town and you're not thinking about coming here you know would you would you consider filling out this survey I would think January like beginning of January is when I would say we should have something out there to whether it's an exit interview type what everything

046that everybody has already said here today I would would say that it should be that fast I I I at least just so we can get an idea and just start working with the information that we have that's what I would I would suggest just just thinking of like this month is crazy but January is where everything sort of dies and everybody is sort of sitting around not us but everybody else sitting around kind of um thinking and and have it's bad outside everybody's on their computer everybody's focusing on the spring and what they're going to do and that's the time when a lot of kids start to think about you know the end of the school year and then the beginning that's where families usually start so I would say if we could get

047something together to get out in January a survey some at least that part of it to get that part and still do phone calls if we want but at least have a a starting point of something to put out there to families or an automated email either or or both I would I think we could maybe do a community dialogue with this as a topic oh definitely from community members and really just like advertise maybe in January 2 January 22nd is our community dialogue so we um but I'm I'm also I'm just coming back to like what are we doing like where are we Landing with this because the phone number thing is obviously a great point in terms of reaching out to call people and what are we what are we saying that we're

048going to do I I I would think we just we would put out put out a survey in the beginning or early January get the information and then whenever we have our next meeting or after the community dialogue somehow be able to look at that and figure out what our next move is do we address is it curriculum issue or what was the overlying reason that most people left and I think so let me just uh interject do we want to does anyone here want to be a point person this because I think there okay Erica thank you and you're on the community relations subcomittee as well right I think working through the community Rel relations subcommittee and taking the point on it is is the way we should coordinate this and and 11 people

049brainstorming or 10 brainstorming is great but never going to get there so yeah good we don't need to vote on that right okay good um just another question I had for for uh looking at these numbers is it looks like the big drops are in Middleton and Topsfield so is the um those 43 S6 Tech kids where is it heavily um Middleton and Topsfield Asos to Boxford I don't have that I've heard they've accepted a lot of kids from mle I don't that just means in the long R right because if we're retaining other two towns you don't P the town's the town it doesn't boxer so I know but our budget when we allocate our budget out to the three towns it's based on the number of students right so we're if Bas is

050not losing any and the other two towns are losing consistently um over the next six years the percentage of the budget that's has get paid by boxer is going to keep going up that's my point I ask a question what are you thinking Chris for every student that goes Essex Tech who pays for that the town so isn't it kind of a wash I think what Joe's saying is that it could impa a disproportionate shift could impact the apportionment calculation shift which is what Mike talked about at the very beginning this sheet yeah that shows but now that it's a five-year calculation it would take a lot to yeah I know but if if a shift let's say that we lost Point valid we lost 20% of our students right we could adjust our staffing

051by 20% and therefore it would be that the change in cost per student would stay the same but you can't change the size of the building you can't change the capital stuff you can't change any of that right so it's going to become more and more a portion to Boxford or whatever Town loses fewer students else I think point though it's it's the Masco budget but the towns are net zero right so every student that leaves from Middleton to Tex Tech Middleton's still paying that I don't think it's not zero I think it's more expensive because our cost per student is g go up here and then if and then I guess SP the charging right the town with the highest number of students here is 2024 share that if you want to hold on

052one second I can tell you your answer so it's TW 20 kids from Boxford 20 of the 42 W were from Boxford hold on one second thatx Tech though yeah okay yeah 15 were from Middleton and so that leaves seven right for Topsfield seven for Topsfield so the drop in Topsfield from 8th to 9th grade had more to do with the population in those grades and not much or like St John's private to private school Austin private right one of the other whatever it is we need more info yeah I have all that info right um I just didn't present it that way I think it's the info that the we don't have what we were talking about for 25 minutes St right we don't have that okay any further discussion are you done with

053your uh y presentation um I have a question when is the deadline for students who are considering applying to private St like let our guidance know or like whatever that process uh it really is up to there's it can let us know whenever as far as there's no deadline for us yeah it's more of the application yeah process which I would expect is closing around now I know the middle school guidance does advertise that piece that if you need to get an application in somewhere you have to get the paperwork to your guidance counselor it's in the principal's blog actually to when they have to get that inv to them to their guidance counselors by um probably know pretty soon how many kids are planning on apply for next year yeah yeah we should this

054know they're actually coming in soon I think it's the next sometime in the next couple of weeks to come in and talk to the eighth grade like they come in and make a presentation here do we do a presentation we well you did that was what the high school did on the 21st that's what that was sorry wasn't sure what you guys were talking about I'm on the Essex Tech website their applications are due January 10 yeah to soon so then we should have some numbers soon in terms of being able to compare the number of applications from last year to this year within a month yeah okay I made a point good is the meeting after that and is that an agenda item on that meeting is an update on well let's make it

055an agenda item when it makes sense right so either late January or early February okay we done with this one let's move on to the second reading of policy section e okay so I would actually skip the the red line first page because it Wass two or three pages to start at eBay those policies are the ones that we approved the last time it was um a cleanup getting rid of um procedures and sort of just um times choosing mask policies getting rid of D duplicative policies that were elsewhere I don't know if anyone has any questions I'll move that we approve all section e second it uh Voice vote all in favor say I wait sorry any discussion um you did get a pretty lengthy email from a Community member about the food allergies

056um admittedly I don't have the historical context to make my own informed decisions about what was shared but I thought there were a lot of good points in there so I'm just pausing to say I'm surprised nobody has any discussion I feel like there should be discussion but maybe help me understand why there shouldn't be if that's an okay request I don't know um we went through the policies with mask they're all policies that have been here we took out a lot of them are consolidations I actually spoke with said Community member earlier today and explained that some of her concerns were actually covered um and for instance like with the food allergy stuff um it's all in one policy where we had like sometimes we had like six policies mask has more concise and

057comprehensive comprehensive policies um the idling one we chose to adopt the mask program The Mask policy because it was more concise and it followed the law to the to the letter so um I don't remember what the others are um find that email I have it you addressed the food allergies the um policy EBC was the other one met emergency plans um I was looking at it before it was just a question of whether it was fully compliant with Mass General law so all the policies are compliant with Mass general laws and that is why we use mask as part of this process so we've been doing this since 2019 2020 um and that was the goal was to make sure that all of our policies comply with law um and the good thing about

058using mask is that they're constantly updating them um multiple times a year um and they actually use the firm that's our count our district council um to do the updating and you'll notice that like when we get the book on the laws for school committee like there that's the law firm that that that's who guides mask that's who guides a lot of school districts in the in the um in the Commonwealth okay there was another one about Universal free lunch um we have Universal free lunch there's um language in there that says we'll comply with laws as we see fit soate okay okay that was super helpful thank you any other discussion okay uh we'll take a Voice vote on this all in favor say I I all opposed any extensions passes by unanimous voice

059fol those will get cleaned up um and we'll work on everything shortly Friday give an update later superintendent report all right announcements as Joe already mentioned we want to congratulate the varsity girls soccer team for winning uh the MIAA division 2 State Championship uh the team defeated Duxbury five to nothing on November 23rd in Worcester uh to clinch the State title pretty amazing stuff they finished with a season record of 220 And1 and I I heard this this actually came out of the Boston Globe and the kids talked about it this this the rally their goal differential was a 101-6 in the season that's wild amazing so also want to congratulate uh head coach Allison less and her coaching staff uh in the entire team uh we also had want to congratulate it was pretty

060amazing yeah and have a state championship be five nothing and was over I think duckburg hit two posts and that was as close as they got wow that was it um otherwise it was not even close I actually stood next to some people from ducksbury I was watching the game and they were shocked at how shut down their team was wow because I think they cruised through the playoffs too so it was pretty impressive uh we also want to congratulate our momic cheerleading squad they finished in second place in division 2 uh at the uh 2024 Massachusetts school administrators Association state meet uh and that was on uh November 24th in Worcester uh the team finished second to Bela and they earned a score of 88.5 so congratulations uh to cherle uh we also had

061um our Middle School principal uh Phil mcmanis and school counselor Jess Jessica Goldberg uh shared their experiences with the special Commission on combating anti-Semitism uh during a hearing at the State House on Tuesday November 19th uh anti-semitic acts have increased in recent years uh with the anti Anti-Defamation League of Boston reporting that incidents in New England tripled from 2022 to 2023 uh principal mcmanis and Miss Goldberg shared the impact of the discovery of the swasa graffiti on campus uh that impact that it had on school committee Comm on the school Community uh and the importance of continuous communication with stakeholders uh they were joined uh by Deborah Colton who's the executive director of the La foundation and Beverly uh and she provided uh anti- they provided anti-Semitism Education Services uh and support following the incident

062uh members of the commission were particularly interested in the school's quick and strategic response uh leading to positive response from parents in the school Community uh the special Commission on combating anti-Semitism was created in July uh and was charged with soliciting feedback from across the state on proactive measures to reduce the incidents of anti-Semitic attacks uh members include representatives of the House and Senate uh mun municipal government education and law enforcement uh including our own Essex County district attorney Paul Tucker the district are committed to continuing its work with the Lapin foundation around educating students about anti-Semitism and the Holocaust uh and maintaining a safe inclusive and welcoming School [Music] Community uh we also had massic middle school held a successful food drive prior to Thanksgiving prior to the Thanksgiving holiday uh the entire Middle

063School collected 2,790 food items uh to donate to local food pantries uh and that's the most that's been collected in uh several years and just so you know the eight blue team won the schoolwide competition to donate the most food items with 872 collected uh donated food was delivered by the middle school student council on the Wednesday for Thanksgiving November 27th uh to the first church in BO o for uh Trinity Church in Topsfield and the Accord Food Pantry in Hamilton so we want to thank everyone who donated for the generosity it's a great program that they're putting that there uh also on the days of giving um our peer leading program is sked is uh excited to share that masonomics High School's days of giving will run from Monday December 16th to Friday December

06420th uh the peer leading uh organization strives to create and the importance of community within and outside the Halls the walls of masanet uh this holiday season the peer leaders are seeking donations of gifts uh Andor gift cards for adolescents who are aged 11 and up uh the age rage is to ensure that all children have a merry and bright holiday season uh all collected items will go directly to students and families in the TR toown and donations can be dropped off uh outside the high school library here or in house B each morning uh before school people to participate in that uh our next High School parent coffee will be held this Friday December 6th uh here in the high school library at 8:30 in the morning and we ask parents uh to check

065in at the main office and sign into the building uh and then they'll be escorted to the library for the parent coffee uh we also heard a little bit about this before uh actually not this one yet but our um High School winter chorus and band concert is next Tuesday night at 6:00 in the auditorium it's a free show it's uh always a great take so invite everybody to come and uh get into the holiday spirit so we'll have our choruses uh the P percussion Ensemble and our concert band will be performing uh that night what I was going to say earlier our senior citizen holiday lunch in is on December 12th uh and this uh luncheon is for senior citizens in Boxford Middleton and Topsfield uh and it'll be held here in the massom

066auditorium uh our Mass High School band and our Coral groups will perform uh at this luncheon uh we want to thank the institution for savings and so Bean Juice Bar and Kitchen for sponsoring the event uh was just have uh any interested senior citizens uh should contact their local Council on Aging uh for more information on how to attend and then earlier this week and is it snowing yet um put out our school cancellation notification procedures um uh so it was sent out to everybody so rather than read it to all everybody but we just we do our Communications in two ways uh we do the what we call the passive ways so Instagram and through all the news media outlets and the district website uh and then the other way that we'll do that

067and that which will come later hopefully not wake people up in the morning is then that phone call through Blackboard uh communication system and email um um just you know I had them change the language it said will be prior to it it said should be because sometimes we get information real late and it doesn't get calls I know what happened last year where we didn't get the message out until after six o'clock uh in the morning because the tree fell filled the power and um neither none of us knew it would happen so I knew when the police showed up night I was Rider sent the sent the it woke me up it was one of those it was the day we close because of power and neither of are expecting to have a

068snow day and I don't sleep with the phone next to me and I do but it didn't wake you up didn't but the policeman did sorry yeah so I do owe you Jim so yes so those are our Communications methods um and we just also want to remind parents that they always have the final Authority uh to make a decision uh whether it's safe or not for their child to attend school based on the conditions uh that they have they're seeing outside their Windows um remember our communities are pretty big uh geographically so things could be different from Topsfield to you know the west side of Boxford so and that's it okay sub commmittee reports uh uh community relations well you kind of stole my thunder with the senior citizen holiday concert that was my

069that was my big lead so all right um yes it's next Thursday it's at 11:30 in the morning and it's it's a really awesome event last year it was really nice to see all of our senior citizens from the tri toown come in they get their little lunch bag from Soul bean and they go into the auditorium and enjoy some really fabulous um holiday music um and yes thank you again just to Institution for savings and soul Bean our sponsors this year um we have our next Community Dialogue on January 22nd believe and um that's all I have so I don't know if there was anything you probably covered it last week wasn't here um so that's all I have you guys have anything else no okay uh DCI uh well it's been a whole

070two and a half week since we've last met so um missed you earlier we missed you um we did meet on the 15th of November and we went through the remaining items in cap in uh Category 3 so we have them all prioritized um let's see we also planned our next meeting which is on 13 December I think everybody got a copy of the agenda for that meeting um and so during that meeting we'll uh work to refine our proposal if we get all the way through it uh the hope is that we'll the full school committee on the 18th of December if we don't get all the way through it then we'll brief everybody in early uh January question for you have you met with the building committee um so we met with the

071building committee a couple months ago um we uh we haven't met since um I had invited them all to the capital briefing on November 13th uh here at the school committee I know there's at least one member the audience I know there was at least one that had dialed in I'm hoping there were more that watched it I I shared the briefing with the with the group um actually have an email drafted right now just touching base with them I know there was interest Lisa was mentioning from one member that um that is curious about the the tour of the school I think um you know for the moment my plan um would be you know uh that we're we're going to enter budget season there's going to be a lot of he heavy lifting

072for the administration as well as the school committee during budget season um I'll continue to keep them informed on anything related to Capital as we go through the next few months um but I'd encourage them to participate in the capital related um not participate in the discussions but you know dial into the discussions uh that we're having on Capital and uh you know postpone the tour until at least the spring once the heavy lifting is done with uh with budget season I've Sil I'll comment further later maybe on next Friday we can talk about a date in March or April sure I'll need to get everybody on the roof and everything and the the winter's not a good time to do that yeah it's not safe up there another the committee before I have to

073uh anti-racism um we haven't met in a few weeks uh last update is the latest we do want to get the charter on for final approval through this group here we'll probably meet next week or two okay Aly anything further Aly we have a meeting Friday 6 at 12:30 via Zoom I'll send a copy of the agenda around and I think we're just looking at the last section that needs to be approved um a little clean up on stuff and we're going to get a plan at leash I'm waiting for some documents so okay uh uh Lea's on update so chance with Topsfield for if you have anything for Topsfield just that we'll have a listening session on the 14th okay uh as far as Boxford is concerned um and I guess somewhat Middleton so

074we Trevor and I met with one um select board member couple of fincom people one Town Administrator uh to just give them an update on where we're at with capital planning and budgets not budgets but more Capital planning um and basically told them there's not going to be a big Capital ask this year that it's really kind of being pushed out to the May 2025 meeting for fiscal year 2026 thought they would be somewhat happy to hear that and said they um they focused on some other things I'll say I'll put it that way so few things that came up I I raised the issue that you know we've got a um proposal now to do an hva study and that it's going to cost 15K or whatever it was um and suggested that that

075wasn't comprehended in the original 650k that was approved for spending this year and asked them if if we could go to 800 instead they sounded some receptive to that which was nice um but then after that they started asking questions about student to teacher ratios fact that we've lost 25% of our student population in the last 10 years question is what's happened on the Staffing side and has it reduced by similar amount so they'd like a um they like some inputs on that or some kind of report on that um they also said they're supportive of the capital idea for the most part but it would be a good gesture by the school committee if we could commit to controlling expenditures uh over the next couple of years just to show that we're serious about

076being responsible with money that's almost like an exact quote and then um I got an email earlier this week I think it was I don't know who has copied on it but the Boxford vcom is saying they would like boxford's allocation for this upcoming budget season to increase by no more than 2% versus last year minus Insurance yeah minus some insurance but those are smaller parts in the budget so just so you all know that wouldn't even cover Boxford share of the new teacher contract yeah just the teacher contract we got a similar letter yeah from Topsfield from Topsfield same same answer it was slightly bigger usually don't they do it on the total assessment and not on their apportionment like when they send guidance isn't it usually on the it's on the bottom line

077number which wouldn't even cover their share of the feuture contract okay I I was going to basically respond and B and say something along those lines I decided not to um Adrian are we all versed enough to explain the component of funding from the state that significantly impacts us like when the state funding comes in and it chapter 7 do you mean yeah and it and it doesn't quite hit the mark and we have to go to the towns and always ask for you know more and seek overrides and do all of that work well we're one of those towns that receives minimum yeah so we we receive minimum funding I know I don't know if that's being articulated well enough so that people understand that no matter how responsible we are even if we

078do the bare minimum there isn't any help for the district so we constantly have to go to the towns and ask for the funding it's just reality y I didn't understand that when I was sitting in the audience but I have a better understanding now but I don't know if we can all articulate that well enough I would say tops Field's probably done the best job in the last that since I've been here and articulating that we've had annual meetings where we I don't know if we had one last year but where we've met with fincom members select board members we've brought in people from Desy to sort of explain our numbers um so yes there's people on this committee who could explain that sure well I think there are but are we all versed

079so that like if if we're having these R we have to I think it's on us as individual members to become Versed and there's a lot of mask programs and there's a lot of Desy program a lot of resources that we can use and I'm happy to share what I have from prior years for everybody and then I connect liaison members with a person or a team of people at desie who are in charge of the calculations and yeah Rob Rob O'Donnell probably Le led the yeah so he'll he'll make himself available to the towns and walk people through the calculations and all those things but there's an aspect of the budget that we cannot control like out of placement tuition like if we get a 15% increase in that again you know in order

080to stick to 2% it's going to be significant or even a you know a larger number of placements yeah right I mean those are the things that are you know we we simply can't you know those aren't variable yeah so in my opinion I mean you it would make more sense to have a Target the things that we control as opposed to all of stuff that's out of our hands you know which is bottom line the vast majority of our budget is fix right I mean the the one piece that's variable at head count and you know I'm surprised to hear the comments that you shared because we spent I don't know five six meetings last year talking about enrollment and ratio and whether we should add or subtract or all these kinds of things

081so you know did that last year and I think we can do it again that was stops field raas that was it they it every year we have the same in Fox yeah he he was 2% guy but the student same conversation did ble from Top shield and they cited like net numbers and I was like well we did make some adjustments last year and this was our 19 .11 was our projected student to teacher ratio which isn't anything to you know so yeah so it's going to be an interesting uh budget season I think just one more thought when I was at the the conference recently there was a town who faced extraordinary budget issues and they had to go for overrides and they had to do their override asks in a I think

082it was a three or a fiveyear ask so they had to commit in detail to what they were willing will to do to cut if they didn't get their funding and articulate it well and and so they actually had a step chart that said if we just keep exactly the same funding this is what we get and if we go less than that these are the things we start to lose and they step down and if we do more than that these are the things that we can actually afford to start doing and it laid it out in very simple terms to say if you're willing to give the funding we're asking for this is what you get for it if you're not willing to come up to this base level these are the impacts

083that it'll have and so it very clearly laid out what it looked like to say no and yes at what level I don't know if we can get there but it is a really helpful tool and it's a good one pager to put out there to say this is what it looks like during budget season Allin there are options all over the place but ultimately it's up to the the towns to say what can we do and this is what it like so if I can get a copy of that slide I'll certainly send it to you guys and show you what they did but just a thought that it was like a very powerful way to lie it out and be like J we say no they're going to cut eight people and we're

084going to lose this program and they're going to have to cut two sports or something it really sends a message and it explains the complexity of everything yeah because I think communication is a big challenge around budget season the last thing that I have here for a note is um and they close the meeting with's going with the with the Masco building committee right that's why I asked the question um and if I were to summarize I think they feel we're really wasting an opportunity um because the Masco building committee members are people that could be showing up at Town meetings and arguing in our favor for the capital expenditures we're going to make so they think that we're um bypassing the ability to have some Advocates that are not part of the school committee

085going to town meeting and saying yes what the school committee is suggesting makes all the sense in the world we're not part of the school committee we're experts in our field etc etc they would like us to engage with them more I miss anything I think the only thing was um there was discussion about um like our buildings how it's laid out how our classrooms are structured um the they out of box for that's where that came from and they wanted to like have a because at one point the committee talked about it and it's kind of fell off since we've had these kind of urgent matters that have had to be addressed so they wanted um some discussion about that as well part of this sorry know until we know again so the ASP

086in the towns has been Bring It All To Us chunk right that's what what started this all and so we said okay here's what we think we've got coming this sports package which is going to be whatever we're doing with the stadium whatever we're doing with the track whatever we're doing with the softball Fields that's the sports stuff and then there's the HVAC system and the heating and then a question was well what about this plan to change um classrooms and change the learning environment I said well that's not going to be ready for at least a couple of years and we can't wait on all this other stuff because we're never going to get all of this all done con currently because the moment you get to that point they'll still you there will

087be that wait a minute your roof estimates too old now right I mean at some point you've got to say We Know This Much let's go with it right and that's what that's where that came up about the classes and I said we won't know that for a couple of years yet and so it'll have to be a different ask um two things one got the prioritization you were talking about was the building Committee involved in that conversation no or they just informed they're not consulted on it they're just informed they'll be informed they're informed was the expectation that they were going to be consulted as part of that discussion no okay just just making sure because I don't know what else would we be engaging them for at this point and why do they

088feel bypassed as can we get to root cause there I don't know the expectations I think are different they vary from person to person okay well then that's a different Challenge and so even though there's a charter has a charter articulates for instance one person said you know you have this estimate here from the same people that did the estimate on at spord for spford school in foxford yeah why wasn't the building Committee involved in that estimate because then they might have added some expertise to how what that estimate's going to look like and I was like well I will say that the estimate was shared with the entire building committee few ago and there was um limited feedback provided I mean to me that that makes the most sense you just share it for

089feedback and if they think that something that can be done better we're doing something wrong that seems pretty good but let's get 20 people together to get an estimate doesn't make a lot of sense to me I want to say that directly to some people and you know what their ideas are but um is there a succinct way to summarize why we have them assembled right right now just to reiterate it I mean I thought some of us have differing opinions on that yeah what's in the charter I guess is so the the whole reason so we agreed to put this committee together in the anticipation that town meeting was actually going to pass the the funding so that we could start doing design work on the roof HVAC and BMS system and that this

090group would be engaged in that process so if a holding pattern right the charter states that they will advise on construction projects that are greater than a million5 we don't have any yeah right okay yeah and I mean I think even if the strategy was to go to town hall with a big ask this spring then we may start to ramp them up in some capacity but not even approaching time we're still gathering information so that we can check all the boxes of all the asks from the LA from what we in the last time around okay so that we can be ready for the big ask in May of 2026 I love the idea of having them help advocate for funding and answer questions to the community and they're going to have to at

091some point become involved in what's going on here but that that that those Advocates we we won't need for a year and a half um the other thing I was going to mention was you know to the point about redoing classrooms and learning environments and stuff there was a creative idea that I heard also at the conference of a school that set aside small budget you know five to 15 grand and they kind of created a application the teachers would apply and say I want to propose my classroom is done in this way for this thing to have these new features available and they would fund you know a class or every year to slowly turn them over over time so there was always something happening but it was on a small scale so that

092they could turn over all the classrooms and really focus the efforts without having to do a huge ask yeah so what what we're talking about here is the it's a educational Master planning study right so almost exactly a year ago we brought in an expert from flansburg Architects to kind of start the thinking around a proposal to look at our space in the context of our strategic plan and it kind of get derailed when the capital plan didn't move forward move forward okay so so I mean that's a way to do it right are there other ways to maybe creatively address I don't know are are the teachers asking for better Collaborative Learning environments or anything or no I mean I've heard you think it's there's not there has not been a ground swell of

093sentiment in that way and I also think you know the educational doing an educational master plan means ja has a a a big picture coordination behind it where peace mail you wind up with a couple of different things and you thinking of the lab that's up above um over here that the science department took took part actually went into that was something the the MEF funded um but again it's you know so those grants are available from the MEF but we don't necessarily have people writing them for that kind of kind of work outside of that one one space so are we encouraging that that yes yeah dis guis a limit on those things MEF was here begging for people I know yeah okay I just want to back to the the building committee one

094last time um I've heard a little bit of grumbling myself as well um I think it's probably natural you know that early Sav as a team it's a new team so I get that storming norming all that stuff but you I think the a thing is it's really important but also if we don't get a hold of this and get this so people feel comfortable with it they could be anti- Advocates they could start ring to the towns and saying and know we're doing you know justy or not but their voices are to be heard so the more we get them engaged and get them on board sooner rather than later even it's just saying we're not ready yet we're gon to come back just being overly clear with these people because I think a

095lot of people on this committee aren't used to being on this type of service but just tipping down the anxiety getting people to feel comfortable with it go a long way I I don't want the message to be misconstrued and people hear things and and all that so yeah it's a definitely a positive opportunity if we don't control it it can go the other way yeah I think as far as the uh classroom modification subject goes it was only thrown out there in terms of well you said you're going to do this five years ago where's that now it was more of a you know do we really believe you and and how much are you coming to us with and it was more of a probing methodology than a you know we really want

096to see the classrooms get remade you know what I mean um trying to make sure we were we were sharing everything we knew with them more than anything really so in the end you got to do it the right way right I mean it doesn't make any sense to well I mean you can set a strategy and then take it down Peca you don't have to swallow the elephant right I mean I don't think we need significant advisory to set some preliminary strategy that would allow us to do minor impact projects peace mail until the big stuff came through and we could like really affect some change then and do big projects with big budget but to just sit on our hands feels really wrong right now at a time when morale is low the

097communities are not thrilled we've got so many things coming at us I mean something to build Goodwill and and show that we're getting something done I think is going to go a lot further than explaining why we can't get anything done you know Finding creative ways to do something good we have money we we got half of the capital we're working on projects yes so there's tangible things that you can see in touch that we've got reports on so I think and Meanwhile we're planning for a $50 million yeah so when when when there's people complaining on the town side it's like day to be honest it's like we've been hearing this I've been hearing it for six years um so there's a lot of stuff that we do and I think that was in

098our budget that we passed in the spring that allowed us to do the smaller projects this year so I we're all done yeah and we got that at the end of the summer and we we only did half of them because the towns would only give us half the money this year so I don't know I think so what so I guess I'm offended by the the notion that we have are sitting on our hands because we worked really hard last year so so I apolog I'm not directing at you Adrian I was just like no if people are thinking that like we're not sitting on our hands because we worked our butts off last spring to get us to the point where we could get small amount of money we're working our butts off

099right now exactly well I think that's the point feeling every day I appreciate the fatigue I really do but I think if the message isn't getting out then we're not going to get the support we need to do the to do the stuff that we want to do and to we put in the hard work and then it it falls flat it's also it's also information faake too because if we start talking about it too early we get lost in the shuffle like you can't talk about it this time of year and nobody even came to our meeting when Matt presented yeah I'm sorry there were a couple people I will say that to I mean it's a great Point Melissa right I think that we should have somebody from community relations starting to attend

100some of the the uh DCI meetings just as a as a witness and being able to take notes and be able to St share the message you can't talk can't can't talk that way Joe except when Joe's there yeah I mean I think we're open to that and one of the questions we had in our meetings was how do we disseminate talking points who is The Keeper of the talking points who is the source of Truth so that we all have them it's piece of message putting it out into the community responding in the same way it's succinct it's crisp it does everything we wanted to who does that is it the chair is it the administration is it no I mean it it's presented as as DCI came in and presented what the overall

101Capital plan looks like um last meeting and there's going to be another one uh final version of it coming up then it'll be presented as part of the budgeting process it's all going to happen over the next few months my comments here were simply about giving them an update on where we're at and telling you what the feedback was right had nothing to do with we're not communicating to anybody I mean the intent of that meeting was to communicate to those folks right and we're just feeding back what the feedback was that's it so Joe just to clarify were they still in support of a big ask or was it still mixed bag there they are but um they're they're just saying use the Masco building committee as advocates we really want to see that

102as part of the process you know in the end um and if if we could magically wave a wand and show up with one big package that covered everything they would love that but we can't do that we can't because we're just not going to have the school side of it ready but we can have the athletic stuff and the uh HVAC roof that's what that's what we told them and they're they're fine with that you know I thought they'd be happy that we're you know a year further out on this stuff and they have to worry about it this year but I think you could go to them any year with that information and you're still going to get the same level of feedback because they're reluctant to say okay let's spend $60 million

103yeah right and I think and I appreciate everyone that went to that meeting took the time out of their day to come but I worry that some of the members are reporting their own personal feelings and not the feelings of their board because I mean I took notes at a select board meeting um way back and it was verbatim the same point that the select board member that went to that meeting that we both went to that he said at that meeting last spring it was his talking point you can't fix you can't try to sell a solution to a problem that the people don't like that that's his so I worry because every single person at the select board meeting that I went to that time had a different idea and direction for us

104to go in um so I just I mean we're meeting with the Middleton select board on January 7th they invited us to sit down so I think we'll get a good idea then but just to add little color to everyone's okay with the big ask I think we'll find out that day I just say you know I think you know ad Point broader you know we're doing a lot of work with the slom the fincom across the towns and they're very engaged and they know that the nuances but this is going to have to go to an override this is going need to vote from the town if there are rumors and misunderstandings out there now we have to get ahead of that you know last year we talked about a big you know PR

105campaign to make sure people understand what we're doing well and what we're not doing and I see this a lot this in this committees like we say someone complaining outside and we get mad that they're not coming to our meeting not listening to us we have to be correct like pushing out because if we don't own the message we let the rumors and everything else become you know the reality we're just going fighting uphill battle all day long where people you know this's is dumb you know rumor that or reputation that you know we don't have fiscal responsibility here we do but that's not getting out there and people need to understand that so I think we do need you everybody this commit needs a sheet of talking points so when someone asks you in

106the street we can say this is what we're doing this what we're doing this what's happening and so we're all consistent in our message and we're taking the same points because if people do hear that they want to hear if someone on some Committee in one town says one thing and they're talking to their friends that snowballs then becomes more reality than it needs to be and I think you know we're doing really good work it's just it's very wonky nuanced work here we need need to get some a little more something for for the public I just want to say one thing real quick because you you said override I don't think it's an override thing just capital is not considered it's a exclusion there's a slightly different thing to make sure that people

107are are aware overrides when you're going past the three point whatever percent level on your annual the be voted on by the towns for approval yeah town meeting and then a ballot question yes so like just like last night yeah so is there like an update that goes out to the building committee after you guys have a DCI meeting that says hey guys here's here's the status update we don't we don't communicate with the building committee yeah no I was asking okay well you looked at me too so just um I would say there not a a uh we wrapped up the meeting in the there's a note that goes to the mascal building committee I would say that they've broadly been kept informed of our progress as we've hit big Milestones um you know

108I've I've pointed the group towards all of the material to the DCI on our website um so those are the types of things that are there okay right I I do feel like there's a still a gap in the expectations of what this building committee is for and what our engagement with that building committee is supposed to look like they've been assembled so I suspect they want a job and if there's a way to give them a job and they it would probably help maybe but we're not the charter States their roles and responsibilities not going to give them pretty narrow but the job might just be hey guys here's the progress we made here are the talking points spread the news let us know if you have any feedback from the people you're talking

109to yeah I don't think that's what they think their their job is on that think we have to just overc communicate because that's what I don't want to be hearing people is that hey we P this committ together we're not doing anything what the hell's going on and that snowballs I I understand I know it's not on it's just you know I think I understand I understand concern about whether or not we're leveraging the building Committee in the Masco building I understand that concern I want to make it clear that there's a charter and we need to stick to the Charter of what that building committee is intended to do and we're not at a place today where we're really in a position to make take advantage of what they're supposed to be doing I

110think that's a fine statement we just put that out there just remind people and some tell them once tell them twice and tell them a third time you know people much we like they're not as you know detail AR as as we expect so just to say there a charter is not helping if we just push it out saying hey we have Comm going we have some time I I can I can push information out yeah I my focus right now and the administration's Focus right now is getting through the capital plan which I think is that's all i' really takes right yeah are laser focused on the capital plan Chris what you gonna say just we can push the minutes to the building committee our meetings sure Melissa I just want to caution that

111the school committee has not taken any votes on anything so to have a discussion about communication to any any of our communities it's a little premature because you H you run the risk of getting the wrong information out there and the budget process is long so for anyone who's been part of that budget process process it's literally a three-month process until we actually have a vote it's painful it changes by the week it sometimes changes every three days when we meet Monday and Wednesday so the only thing we can do is ask our communities to be informed about the process and tell them when we're going to be talking about certain things at this point that's my opinion because and every town is different every town is looking for a different specific information so when

112the time comes to do a one-page mailer that's going to be like the end of March April that's when people start listening about until then my opinion is the only thing you can do is point them to like the actual meetings and say hey we're going to be talking about XYZ it might be interesting to you but we haven't made any votes yet on any anything I'll be cautious about that but I think and at least in Middleton we can't we did that route before yeah and so I for me I'm not going to say no to a meeting if we're asked to go there so I'm gonna be careful and make sure everyone knows we haven't had anything set in stone but we don't have anything and toward toward that end though I mean

113what we were sharing with them was not this is what's gonna happen this is what the plan looks like today that's pretty much what we told them right yeah I even made a statement you know hey if Mascus Sports Foundation shows up with $10 million in February then maybe it it's on the ball of this year right exactly but but this does raise an important point which is there needs to be some sort of a campaign over the next 18 months yeah to get people informed on the problem and what our solution looks like for the capital plan Capital plan once we've voted once you've presented it again and we' voted on it appr it I mean yes voted or not there's still stuff that could be said around here's the problems at Masco there's

114a roof that's not leaking today but maybe leaking Tomorrow there's eight units that have caught on fire there's right there's a softball field that's not compliant there's yeah etc etc etc right and to get the community informed on the challenges that we're facing and to say we're working on it right yeah we're in the relationship building there you towns don't have kids in Masco so this is not on the radar at all so the more we can get awareness the better it's going make which is where I think a lot of the community relations department could V do we have budget do we have a budget yeah conations yeah I mean we were able to do the Flyers last year flyers then you get a question on why you're spending your money on that but

115I would just like I'll I'll be attending to now at this point um the DCI meetings and we can easily put together with obviously approval checking in with simple easy this is the problem this is we're working on simple image simple information doesn't have to be complicated just so that everybody knows that we're communicating with them that's I think at least in Middleton that's the big thing make sure we tell them everything that at least that we're working on to say we're working on it even if we don't have an answer so that's easily doable and I think that will that's the best that we can do I mean that's all we can do is is do that and that's that's an easy an easy yes I'm also just thinking about like a greater I'm

116really stuck on the comment about changing the classroom physical space because we are doing the Strategic plan which is like Kevin is here and they're doing curriculum and they're like that is where we are so to move also hearing there isn't a lot of Outreach and potential buying from staff on that would be a major misstep to try to project or push something forward so I feel like there's also a messaging piece around the capital plan but also the Strategic plan and just what our priorities are and why and I wonder if just as a the community relations subcommittee we could take a bigger step back to think about how we are embedding certain messaging just in general like beyond the meeting updates which I think are fat plus but I just I think that's

117really important because I'm shocked by that I'm like we are doing the Strategic plan that's not anyways I think that that would be like a technical solve that would miss a ton of adaptive challenges shocked by what comment comment by who um just inquiring about classroom physical space given the status of all the other Capital items and like speaking to that strategic plan is like great well in the Strategic plan we're actually like we are doing it before that comes the step um so I just I I understand the intent is to ask for one big ask but lumping those two things together feels like lumping a priority one with like a priority five when there are sequentially things that of course need to happen beforehand um so I'm just thinking about like what have

118we done or not done around the continued communication of the Strategic plan that we could improve to prevent that moving forward so just thinking about how we our updates and strategize further all right let's we wrap this please um stating things uh somewhat so uh negotiations is not here um May comment from you guys do we we don't have anything going on with the group that was here earlier anything coming up actually we heard from the um the LR yes today that they've assigned a mediator and we will be meeting on Friday with Greg Council to uh propose our first three dates that's how the process starts so we propose three dates they propose three dates we get with the mediator and try to pick some dates um so that's the next step we just

119heard about that this afternoon okay uh with that said moving on to the consent agenda make a motion I'll move that we sorry I have one revision um for the November 13th minutes in section H it has me noted as voting yes for ratifying the CBA a I was an exstension it is noted in the vote count just says yes next to my name where's that uh page four yeah thank you that work yeah okay I move that we now present the consent agenda as presented a second all in favor I opposed extensions all right passes by unanimous Voice vote on we don't adjourning do we all right meeting adjourned 44 after some lengthy discussion what you doing better

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.