CorpusRecord 12153

MGT Boundary Adjustment Informational Presentation at Patrick Henry High School

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Hanover County Public Schools
Date
2025-01-30
Location
Hanover County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,540 words · about 48 min
Collected
2026-06-03

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001so uh good evening my name is uh Dr Lance Richards and tonight with me is Daniel Dominguez uh and we're with a company called MGT uh and we're here tonight to kind of share the information that we've brought forth to your community to kind of help you make an an informed decision going forward a little bit about my per my I guess my personal and professional background I was a teacher for nine years an elementary principal for 12 uh central office director of operations Transportation all things at uh for six and then later a school superintendent for another six uh I do still have my CDL I do this little part of my speech every time I have my CDL I can still drive a bus your District needs bus drivers get your CDL mention

002somebody mentioned do you drive a bus no okay thought you mentioned uh they always need drivers um and so uh just a few things about tonight and kind of our setup number one no decisions have been made I know that was a conversation that that took place in terms of many of the communities that we've talked to and then the places we'll go but no decision has been made it was our job to bring forth what we thought were viable scenarios good bad or otherwise that might help create a solution to the challenges that your school Community faced number two they're going to be the biggest question I got last night after the session was well if they go forward with redistricting what about grandfathering what about kids that are already there and all those

003kinds of things none of those decisions have been made because you can't make that decision until you know what the first decision is and go is trying to if you're a monopoly go is trying to figure out what a boundary adjustment might look like before you can go forth with any other decisions I would and I want to stress though that no decision has been made nothing has been chosen at this time the important part of tonight is that we share this information with you and then we we're going to pull you we have live polling here it's kind of like Who Wants To Be A Millionaire when they PLL live poll the audience very similar bar graph slide on the screen we'll take all that information back and they'll be and then we'll share

004that with the board the last qu few questions are kind of open-ended so it's very important to us that you provide us the information you provide us your insights if you have some other Solutions please share it with us and then we'll be able to quantify that and bring that back around to the board I will also tell you this your board has a tough tough choice because we are dealing with your most important resource and that's your children so anytime you get into these situations where you're dealing with children and talking about attendance zones and all those things you take it personally and you should because you're here to advocate for your children as parents and thank you for being here tonight so let me just jump into this and we'll get started again

005if you've not logged into the uh internet here please do so uh we'll have have a QR code here at the end of our my portion of the presentation so we can get started with the live polling well what did I do here Danny no it's not going to work that's not going to work either all right so just a quick agenda for tonight um uh demographic and economic overview we'll talk about that we'll talk about how we got to where we are in term of forecasting we'll talk about Resident versus enrollment capacity and utilization we're going to give you uh student forecasts and then we're going to talk about the guiding principles kind of that framework for making the decision and then we'll we'll also be sharing the new attendance areas and pattern choices

006and we have three to present for you tonight a blue a green and a purple in terms of scenarios so bound to review just a quick breakdown of the framework and the timeline so in looking at this we had an initiation we got with your District folks we started day the Gathering looking at the capacity of the buildings econom enrollment patterns and that was in August and September then through October and December we were creating our forecast taking a look at some of the challenges and getting to know your Community because the the great thing about doing this work is when we come in we really don't know we don't know anything we don't even know what we don't know um so we look at those we look at your preliminary boundary options and then

007here we are in January February so iterative is just doing the numbers we've created these scenarios based on the numbers we were given and the data we have we're hosting our community forums Gathering the community feedback and this and the information that comes out of these meetings then can then lead to whatever choices the board might make going forward we do have cases honestly we have times when the information that we receive in these meetings do come back around into the scenarios where we've maybe missed something and we're able to kind of provide those insights to the board and other options and then in March or April I think it's April we're going to make our final recommendations we'll deliver our reports and then the board will engage and vote so right now the most

008important part of why we're here to tonight is to gather your insights and to gather everyone's insights in order to uh help us make that decision another thing if you've got friends or family that can't be here tonight on Thursday the board will post this presentation a recording of the session from tonight they will also have what we call study Maps where you'll be able to go in and and drill into the maps in neighborhoods and houses and all that I'm not able to do that here obviously so you you be able to D drill in see the neighborhood see the maps and all those kinds of things but tonight what we're going to share is the process and how we got to where we are well there we go so just just a quick

009demographic overview Hanover County presently has about 114,000 folks in it we're saying by 2033 most of our forecasts deal with kind of a 10-year window 2033 you're going to grow by about 12% up to 127,000 the state's tracking it about a 4% growth and nationally we're looking at about a 4% growth so in this particular case we have it broken out by age groups and it's what in this Red Bracket of course that's what we're here to talk about the student populations within those age ranges 5 to 9 10 to 14 and 15 to 19 so what what you're seeing though is a percentage growth going forward we're we're you're actually in a situation where you're getting you're going to be a little younger 5 to n year olds will grow in that point 10

010to 14 15 to 19 and then it's represented as a bar graph here so you can see we're anticipating growth across that 10-year window in all of your age ranges that impact your schools and you you can also see the growth in other age ranges as you go forward in this one you can just kind of see the uh uh racing ethnicity breakdown of Hover County and again you're going to see growth in in all areas um largest Industries uh retail trade kind of leads the way at this point but I think this is important to note that transportation and warehousing we're forecasting that transportation and warehousing will be the largest area of growth in terms of employment within the county and then just some basic uh Community overview I think this is kind of

011interesting at 144,000 median household income that's very strong um you've got a Broadband connectivity at about 90.1 which is a terrific number as you carry across the bottom structure types the large the majority of your homes or residences are actual structural houses um and uh quite a bit of your housing stock was built um post 2000 so that's that's very those are very strong numbers similarly in this case interestingly 83% of your homes are owner occupied so just a little bit in terms of the rental stock um and as you came down over here 90% of your folks are in the labor forth and you have very strong educational attainment within this County those are very very very strong numbers in terms of your overall Community student projections get in kind of the meat of

012it so how do we do what we do what's the process what's the procedure basically how is the sausage made okay so we do we have three major components birth factors Mobility factors and student yield factors and I'll explain those so birth birth birth factors are quite what that is how many kidss are born today and then how many of them show up 5 years later and we're going to track that forward okay that leads to your kindergarten class your Mobility factors are basically who moves in who moves out and you've got some very you got strong numbers on kindergarten birth factors you got strong numbers on mobility and then your student yield factors that's just a fancy way for saying development you build houses you build Apartments you build multif family structures how many

013kids how many students can you anticipate Gathering out of those those types of home and we're able to map that all of that comes down into our student forecast okay you know kindergarten is a very specific point kindergarten but Mobility is all student cohorts all grade levels again development generally is all grade levels going forward so this is this is how we get to our student forecast so thinking spatially okay okay so somebody one of the early questions one of your early arrivals was well how did you get to where you got okay that's some terrific English there isn't it how did we get anyway how do we get here so basically we verify the students and their residences and then everybody gets a dot in the county in terms of a household with students

014and the number of students within that house so you might have two dots on a house because there's two students within that residence and then we create study areas so for your District there's about it'll say in a later slide there's 50 to 75 kids within a study area and so that's how we move the kids and we move the the students around in order to create our demographic analysis and we do that based on natural barriers subdivision lines all those kind of natural spots where you can chunk the kids that's why it ranges from 50 to 75 so we we can create these chunks that we can move around and allocate in terms of of capacity and utilization to your build buildings so each point is a student and we have 448 study areas

015and it's very important demographic analysis is very very very much like baking a cake you've got to have the right ingredients you have to have the right amount of baking soda you have to have the right flower all that's very important up front so the hard work really is getting the data make sure making sure your data is clean and you're accurately reporting it so that you can create those forecasts that's the important part of it so student density nothing surprising here okay that area around Cool Springs and all those areas at lead uh chck Chickahominy that's where the kids live kind of closer in range to Richmond proper and then you have of course the area around Han or Ashland is kind of another heat map spot so the the vast number of your

016students live in terms of that density that that heat map and as you go out into the lighter purple you can see that it that it's less dense all right so this was something that we found that was almost a little bit shocking to us okay and now you're looking at the G waen what's all that mean so let's let's let's talk about this in uh in 2016 and they're coming into 2021 Kinder year the kids born in 2016 you had 942 students born kids born to your res but you got aund 1,96 so your capture rate let's go over to the chart to the right your capture rate for 16 with with starting kindergarten in 2122 was 116% so what that means is as kids are born into your community the kids also move

017into your Comm Community ver with the mobility Factor okay so sometimes you look at numbers and you go that just doesn't pass the sniff test so you go back and recalculate the numbers we did this three different times one of the reasons you saw that other bar graph earlier where we talked about age rages is is we went out and found different data to confirm this data because we didn't believe our own numbers okay we had a lot of conversations around this with District officials you had your Gathering Ing 116% 112% and 118% and for 2425 you order 123% capture rate nobody has those numbers that we've worked with okay we typically see we've seen as low as 65% we typically see about 85% of a capture rate okay so again we didn't believe our

018own numbers and of course that 110 kind of carries out just as an average going forward um all right so those are just crazy numbers and then we come back to Mobility all right so if it's green you're in the positive one is a one:1 ratio okay so let's kind of take a look at this um so as you go as you go across you got 100 kids in kindergarten in the map there 23 24 that 1.06 what means is is that when they went to first grade now there's 106 of them okay so now you got 106 and you travel forward out of 100 you gathered to going up to you know uh 108 so each year as you go forward and you can what you can see is the Li and share of

019this is green as you're capturing more students as you're coming in you're going from 100 to 104 you're going from 100 to 106 everything and that but remember this when you're looking at Ashland here or go down go down to Battlefield Park they went from 100 to 103 K to 1 but now their number is 103 so then that 1.01 means they went from 103 to whatever 104.5 so your base is always the new number so you have exponential growth as you go across in terms of that Mobility Factor now that these high school numbers are very typical early graduation other things factor into the high school students but these are very strong Mobility numbers in terms of your historically mapped students uh in your division so you're not only are you capturing more in

020terms of kindergarten rolling in you're growing in each grade level as you move forward due to mobility and then development yield factors so we mapped all of the developments in your in your division maap them out and and then got with developers got with County officials to confirm we had Fact one more click here that's some of our folks on the ground we actually lays lay eyes on it because sometimes with developers they'll say it's going to be a 500 home I'll make up a number 500 uh unit place but you get there and they haven't turned any dirt so you really can't build that into your forecast yet but if they've already got Footers in the ground and you half your homes are built that's a different forecast Factor so so for student yields

021really you kind of look here at the bottom this total1 16429 512 so what that tells you is is out of a hundred you're going to get about 16 kids out of an apartment complex on a multif family you're going to get about 20 kids for 100 units and for home single family homes that's what kind of drives it what do you have the most of single family homes you're going to get about five kids per 10 houses or 50 kids per 100 and that's a pretty strong number that's a very strong number um I I did see a little number when I was working in Utah larger families uh one one one kind of De demographic note when we talk about child birth and size of families and things as we know many of

022us I was born into a family of three okay many of us were born into larger families and families that we have um and so and also what we're also seeing is delayed childbirth folks you know having births used to have kids in their early 20s many folks are wait waiting closer to 30 to have children so all those things kind of play into your birth factors play into your student forecast but these are very strong numbers but you do have quite a bit of development but the reality is and one of the reasons we had to check our numbers so much the reality is the development while it helps and in is and is helping with your growth it really is the cycling of the homes and folks moving in that are spurring a

023big chunk of your growth all right so here's your current attendance areas okay I apologize that's a little darker than I had anticipated it would be here but you can just kind of see based on how they are and I know this kind of looks like a Jerry Jerry mandard map from a political but you kind of draw the lines in order to fill the buildings to be honest with you and as you morphed out and brought kids in here here are your boundary and so as you can see with your with that heat matap from earlier you get into that that cond that the kind of the smaller area of Cool Spring and uh Washington Henry because there's just there's more kids there and you're going to have schools in closer proximity as a

024result so these are your current attendance areas as we move forward this will be a little clear so in looking at your schools one of the things that we feel that we have to do is we have to assess your buildings how many students can the building hold and then we determine a utilization based on the number of students so we looked at your building Maps we determined that capacity and utilization and I think that's important to note because what we're saying is you you've heard of disinterested third parties well we are an interested third party but we have to make sure that the data that we bring forth to you is accurate so we want to make sure that we're the ones determining how much uh or how many students can fit into a

025given building and have that building still be functional all right so in looking your Elementary attendance Matrix you can kind of gather the the current enrollments and where those students live now this is very important and I and I apologize I should have stressed this earlier the dots that you saw earlier in terms of residence we're talking we're building this up from elementary always build up from elementary and it is resident attendance so we charted every student that lived within that attendance Zone and these numbers are reflective of the students that reside within that boundary and where they go to school okay and these are very strong The Lion Share of your students go to school in which where they reside you know you may have transfers because of Faculty or staff or special programming

026but by and large you have 619 students living in the boundary of Ashland 588 of them go to Ashland all right five of them go to beaverdam six go to Elmont 11 to ciry Creek two to Mechanicsville what that six to South Ana so that's all of that 619 okay so you can look at your individual School of course the um the dark block is Battlefield going to Battlefield you know as you as it carries over but if you come down then you'll see across the bottom the total enrollment there's total of 7600 students and then as you carry that across you can see the total enrollment as you go across all right and so utilization that's really this is really why we're here why we're having this conversation okay so I mean we've got

027Cool Spring uh blocked out there because as you go across there you see K5 760 in terms of capacity that we've determined there are 834 Kids that actually reside within that attendance Zone and so that utilization would be at 110% but 852 are actually enrolled there so it's at 112% and just so you know what we determined basic the best that sweet spot in terms of utilization really is in that 80 to 90% range that's what we call Green and so when you see later when we when we talk about the charts and we have these graphs later you're going to see 80 to 90 being our green our Green Spot going forward and we talk a lot about getting all the schools to Green in terms of the mapping so as you carry this

028across all right so you got got Cool Spring at 110 but as you go down you got Paul Green at 66 you got South Anna at 63 um this is important to note um Washington Henry's current capacity is 378 the new Washington Henry is slated to go online or come online August of 27 so that was kind of A Wrinkle in our forecasting and our modeling because we're having to factor in all right if we're going to give some relief to Cool Spring next year they can't all go to Washington Henry but more can go in 27 so that's part of the blue green choice that we're going to talk about here uh momentarily so your your challenge is is you do have some buildings that are crowded overcrowded in in in case of Cool

029Spring you have other buildings that are fairly crowded in terms of the '90s and so but you have you in overall if you look division wide you have capacity for the number of students within your division collectively from the 50,000 foot view all right so here's your middle school Matrix so when we got into this part of the conversation was about all right we're we're we're really here to talk about elementaries but in looking at the elementaries can you also address some of the concerns the future concerns of what's going to happen with Chickahominy in terms of their utilization so Chickahominy if you carry this across their current utilization is 95% so that's important because we're building out this 10year forecast this five and 10e forecast and so it's important that not only we fix

030it maybe for next year but we fix it for that 5-year Benchmark and we fix it for that 10-year Benchmark what you don't want to have happen is for me to be back here in two years having this same conversation with you so in talking to your board and talking to your division leadership they want solutions that will fix the problem today and in the near future and and I'll talk more let me this is probably a good time to talk about this so when we do our forecast we talk about this five and 10 year window right it's it's kind of like the weather bear with me if you're going to have a party in 10 days and the weather and it's an outside party and the in the the forecast from your local

031weatherman or weather person is it's going to rain in 10 days and you go H I'll keep an eye on that you get to the 7-day forecast that's going to rain you're paying attention at 5 days you're going to make alternate plans and at three days if they say it's going to rain outside you're moving the party indoors so and so much like the weather forecast you need to have it updated daily as you're getting closer to that party that party date same thing with school demographics we feel very confident about our threee threeyear forecast very confident you get to five and so the numbers can shift a little bit another development comes online your Mobility goes up one way or another when you get to 10 that gets a 10 year that between 5

032and 10 is based on the assumptions you've made from zero to five and so the there can be more variability there so it's very important much like your weather forecast that you update that data every year so that your threee and fiveyear can be as accurate as possible so you have the information that you can make a more informed decision going forward and you're not guessing all right similarly here uh for high school Matrix and utilization we have a similar challenge as you carry across this for Atley atle's already at 90 in terms of enrollment utilization 75 at Handover 72 at Mechanicsville and then 84 here so at Le at the high end of that green and Patrick Henry's kind of basically in The Sweet Spot of that of that going to Green utilization all

033right so I this is usually where I do the weather forecast so act like I said it here okay so this is our resident uh our student forecast to ensure that ensuring that we consider the future and kind of take a look at this cuz that green kind of represents the growth across there but if you track out of 2021 that kindergarten class of 1096 and you carry that down and carry it across to 1 1184 1228 1271 1311 1348 1393 1414 1473 1432 1392 1396 we're saying they're going to grow by basically 300 students as they make their way through across across their time in school and so division leadership has to plan for that that that anticipated growth and you know because because of the partnership between County Commissioners and the schools in

034terms of facilities that's also something then that your county and your County Commissioners have to be a part of in terms of that conversation in terms of building need so that's what we're seeing in terms of the future again as we carry forward we feel really good about that kindergarten number you know kind of carrying out to to 2027 based on charts pretty good about that number out to 2029 but there's other things that can come into play as we get out past that so it's important that your numbers are updated but what it can tell you is is what we can all look at this and we all go okay we're growing and we're growing at a pretty good clip uh going forward are we going to be able to ask any questions slides

035as going through this no ma'am we will be gathered thank you for that question though um we the point of our live polling is is so that we can gather the insights of everyone in the room it's important to us that we have information from everyone participating here you're very welcome to come and talk to me afterwards and I'll be glad to answer any questions you might have we also have some District leadership here surrounding that I I but for those of you that are a little bit later in ding we won't have any qu answers in terms of grandfathering in terms of students and because there's really again no decision has been made regarding the choices that we're going to see tonight and so before we we will come back to your board and

036present our final plan and that kind of thing and at that point is when the board uh could elect to take action will our participation in the survey tonight be considered a vote for the county are they going to actually hold a vote for the residents to there will not be a countywide vote I that I can tell you you have elected officials here to do certain jobs uh but well you County Commissioners are elected all right all right um having said that I let me say this it's my assumption there will not be a countywide vote that is not typically how these processes are are handled all right so student forecast um again we're talking about Resident students um your historic count and then kind of carrying that forward again this is just kind

037of showing you setting up the stage for the kind of growth we're anticipating and so it it kind of complicated our growth you you'll see one little caveat here actually with the 9 through 12 at coming forward of the next four years we're forecasting a little bit of a dip because you've got some smaller classes presently it's your junior high level or your middle school level but then what we're also forecasting then as it as it comes out of that fourth year that it's going to going to go back up again however as you see that growth with K5 and 68 what we're saying is is that that growth back there more than makes up for the slight dip we might see in 9 through 12 um going forward so that kind of an interesting

038Trend but for us okay cuz you that 912 we saying you might dip 1.5% down about 82 kids um but for us we have to then build into our forecasting the ability to address the needs not only K through 8 but 9 through 12 not only in this school but in all the high schools across your division all right so suup forecast here so here are our study areas so that we could capture um so we could capture the the the students and so we have our study areas of 50 to 75 but then we H we forecast within the study area how many students we're anticipating would grow or move out of a given study area so if you're looking at this we're seeing this is that Resident year net change okay so if

039you come down to this um you come down to this far Corner uh adjacent Devonte in the corner it's a light purple and we're saying there's going to be a 1 to 24 change there in terms of just growth 40 it's broken out into 24s in those white is a no change so this this General section in the center there is kind of a push in terms of growth so this is our forecasted growth based on development based on everything that we've seen across the division broken down by our study areas so there's um you know you've got only a few areas in this darker orangey color located about but you have several uh there with purple as well especially notice how dense the study areas are in and around um atly and cool springs

040and chikama because of the of the density of population there all right so we got into this again we're here because the initial conversation stemmed out of what is taking place at Cool Spring but as we got into this you can see you've got uh 2024 students and everything's based off of 2024 because that's the complete set of data that we had to start the process okay so 2024 and what we saw here is the the dark blue is the capacity of the facility so you can see what's going on at Cool Spring but also notice rural point so as we're looking at this and we're looking at our forecast at that five and 10 year mark if we're going to take a look at what is happening at Cool Spring we also then have

041to take a look at what's happening at R rural Point okay and then we also have to then balance what's going on at Washington Henry and consider the new uh capacity of 495 that will come online in 2027 so again in in a casual reference across this you've got some blue which means you've got some capacity in several of your buildings across the division all right so here's your current uh utilization based on just kind of a color code in terms of the utilization of the building so the yellow is under 70% utilized the light green is 70 to 80 in this case I apologize but that is supposed to be kind of a darker green the more aqua color is that 80 to 90 the darker blue is the 90 to 100 and then

042the uh purple is over 100% so as you bring that forward what you're going to see is in the 5-year forecast some of those yellows flip to Green okay and some of those lighter Aqua Blues turn into a darker blue as you carry that forward then the only school at the 10year forecast that's in the yellow is Pole Green so what the these are the forecast again all these will be available on Thursday online um with the study Maps but what we're what again this is all making the case to show to you you've got growth you've got growth at 5 years you've got growth at 10 years and we want we're doing our best in terms of creating scenarios and bringing ideas and solutions forward that will solve the problem not only at five

043but begin to address the concerns that might happen at 10 um here's your middle school and high school utilization and so in looking at your utilization across that um five and 10 year window okay uh what we're seeing Is We I mentioned that the high school numbers were going to dip a little bit but it's not at atly so in 5 years we're anticipating atly to be over capacity and continue to be over over capacity in 10 years similarly at Chickahominy if you come over to this side we we're seeing that growth they already in the 90 now going to be in the mid 90s and they're going to push toward 100 as they go forward so you've got you know and it kind of ties back to you got Cool Spring and the number

044of students that attend there tracking through the middle school and high school and the reason we bundle these together in terms of presentation is is your high school and middle school attendance zones are the same so and that's a big part of the conversation we'll have later in terms of feeder patterns but your high school and middle school zones are exactly the same all right and so here's your middle school utilization again you got um kind of that light green tracking to a light like an aqua blue over here to the right for Liberty um ulno kind of hold Chickahominy stays in that 90 closer to 100 and then um Bel Creek actually goes from the the 70s and into the 80s so again AC growth across the division and and similarly for your high

045schools Atley goes from a blue to a purple um and the other's kind of hold oh Mechanicville dip then comes back doesn't it all right so let's kind of get down to how we got to where we got to in terms of our of our choices that we made in communicating with your District officials so there's guiding principles and these are kind of the the the processes and the procedures and the framework we use to kind of get where we're going to get to it's a road map for making the decisions okay and so these out you got guting principles in the center and you got all these things around the edge that have to be considered when you're thinking about redistricting or you're trying to create an attendance Zone okay um and so in

046and they're in a circle here they're always in conflict with one another okay it's not a situation where it's very linear you just do one then you do two then you do three it doesn't work that way it's more like um when they draw for the um when I'm going to try this one they draw for the lottery and you see those ping-pong balls bouncing all around inside of it that's kind of how the guiding principles work off of one another because not one single thing can be the only driving factor or consideration going forward so you got transport you always have to consider Transportation they don't have enough bus drivers okay it costs $5 to $6 a mile and that was 3 years ago to run a bus down the road transportation's expensive you

047know that you own your own cars you maintain your own Vehicles just put that on a you know a 72 passenger or 80 passenger bus um capacity and utilization has to be factored you can only fit so many kids into a facility which is you know why we're here okay neighborhood schools you do try to create a geographic cohesion as best you can but sometimes the schools aren't located in the center of their own attendant Zone and that is for a number of reasons it may have been the only flat ground that happens a lot it may have been the only ground available uh or when the school was built it was Central and things happened and other schools were built and so you try to create your your your neighborhood schools you avoid Island

048zones what you don't want to do what you don't want to do is say all right we got this cluster of subdivisions down here next to Cool Spring you're all going to South Ana okay we're going to run 10 buses out of here and we're just going to take care of this problem you you don't want to do that that ruins kind of that cohesion to the school it happens sometimes so sometimes in an urban center you'll get a a new development somewhere a new Housing Development and they there simply is no place for them to go they won't fit in their school and they have to be you know taken across town but you you want to avoid that as best you can uh feeder patterns we've talked about we feel it's one of

049our tenants that we kind of feel like we try to keep clean feeder patterns so your Elementary feed to their middle school and your middle schools feed to your high so in this case you know Chickahominy and Atley are together so whatever elementaries would feed into Chickahominy would then go on into Atley now you do have a few splits and we're going to talk about those in just a second but you try to maintain these feeder patterns and you guys by and large have some pretty tight pretty good feeder patterns this this one's pretty good all right major barriers and natural roads or no natural barriers and major roads all right so you know if you've got a park that runs through someplace or a Waterway or a train track or a large a main

050road we try to draw our barriers and create our study our study areas based off of these natural or man-made barriers you really don't want to draw if you can avoid it a line down the middle of the street where Johnny on one side goes to one school Suzie goes to the other sometimes we do have to you might do a aign if there's a power easement through a subdivision you might run the line down through there with their backyard neighbors but you try to avoid that as best you can again it doesn't always work all these things pull against one another and almost serve to defeat some of your grand purposes going forward uh special populations if you have a like a gift and talented program or special needs students or certain programs at

051a given School sometimes you have to consider that in terms of your of your process and then you try to do it with the minimal impact and involve fewer students in the process and and it's it's not a function of not making the most people mad it's a function of what's good for kids and the least impact that you can have on kids is important for everyone in your school community so all these things I spent a lot of time on this and you try to balance these things across the division need but sometimes they have an unintended consequence you know an unforeseen consequence but all of these things pull against one another in making these choices so you're in talking with your District officials and with your school board these were kind of the

052this is kind of how they set up the guiding principles the B they wanted to balance for the current and a five and the 10 they wanted to bring everybody to Green they did I will applaud them for this they said early on we don't want to kick this can down the road or in light of the football season they don't want to they don't want to punt this down for the next uh set of Schoolboard officials to deal with okay they want to fix it they want to fix it once and they want to fix it right so we're not having this conversation later and and so that parents and students have a clear understanding of what the future holds I think that's incredibly important especially for students minimize the number of students impacted

053as best you can um try to maintain all of your neighborhood schools and avoid these Island zones or these pockets of students because it's not fair to those students consider Transportation impacts I mean we'd like to say no we don't have to but there is a a practical and functional reality behind transportation and uh again minimize the special program impacts or special populations uh economically disadvantaged all those things trying to balance all these things so as you can as you can tell there's a lot going into this and it's a very hard process and it's a it's at this point where you're very happy you're not a Schoolboard member because these things have to all be considered in weighed as we bring forth these scenarios all right so again you know kind of looking at

054some of the things natural boundaries Transportation hurdles Transportation times when you get farther Out Future capacity increases neighborhood cohesive all these things are things that we kind of had to lean into as we built these as we built this forward brought this forward presently you do have four splits okay and so one of the things that came up out of this is if we could in this process fix the splits and so it's it's really three splits that impact four elementaries okay so the kids up there um at Elmont on the right side of 95 go to a different you know go somewhere else okay as you come down to Pearson's Corner that's split out a little bit between Chickahominy um and then as you come down here to Mechanicsville there's a split in Mechanicsville

055I'm the reason I have Mechanicsville bolded up there is that through our processes and procedures we were able to fix the other three splits we can't fix the Mechanicsville split it's it's too dense of a population in terms of that I think it's Mechanicsville Turnpike and that the right the street that's there and we didn't and just as a note because someone last night thought we had shifted that that Mechanicsville Turnpike is the boundary going forward that we didn't shift that boundary all right so again Cool Springs is the is the U is the challenge or the opportunity if you'd like uh the challenge that the district uh had to tackle and the reason that we're here I mean the entire reason that I'm by the way I'm from Southern Indiana or Louisville Kentucky the

056entire reason that I'm here to talk to you tonight is that we're here to talk about Cool Spring and the challenge faces the in terms of capacity and utilization there and looking at ways to relieve the pressure on that school okay um so in let's see high part while applying The Guiding principles executive team an investigator reassign the area south end of Cool Springs down to Washington Henry so let me let me jump forward because this gets into our blue and our green all right so we have basically a blue a green and a purple scenario now the blue and the green are largely the same they end up at the same place two years from now in terms of 2027 because it's about those students coming down to Washington Henry okay the purple is

057the different um it's a different scenario that involves King's Charter and so but again we're going to lay into each one of these so you can see them in detail so the key difference between the blue and the green is just what kids move when and what neighborhoods are impacted okay Giles atly Manor cranny island farms and cranny Island estate neighborhoods throughout this at the end of this process end up at Washington Henry end up at the new Washington Henry okay um but right now as we well know Washington Henry in their old building doesn't have the capacity for that so as a result we looked at two different possible scenarios and that's how we got to blue and green okay so in the blue okay in the blue choice these students through and it's

058I know it's kind of a weird pattern again but we're trying to draw out to draw the right number of students down in order to provide some relief to Cool Spring but not overwhelm Washington for that transition year okay so in the cool in the blue scenario Gil's neighborhood reson to Washington Henry starting the 25 26 year while the remainder of the potential change area remains there until the 2728 season uh year and then they move down to Washington Henry so the inverse of that is the green all right in this particular scenario in the green scenario uh J stays where it is and comes late and you're moving at Le Manor and the crany island neighborhoods okay so again the difference between blue and green is just who moves when and and we'll talk

059about what percentage in utilization and all that and how that impacts all those schools in just a moment all right so in this scenario that the the only difference between the blue and the green is what happens in terms of cran is and Giles and those neighborhoods okay everything else that takes place across the division um is the same whether it's blue or green it's really larger the same where it's blue um green or purple so in looking at this okay we create a domino effect and I'm going to drill into each one of these so don't think this is the only slide that that goes to this but in order to relieve pressure at Cool Springs you got to slide over to to uh Washington Henry but that really overwhelms Washington Henry so then

060you got to slide around and to perhaps Laurel Meadow or over the rural point and so so and you're coming down toward Cole Harbor so all of these things cuz no school no school has the capacity to absorb all of the students that are in in play here okay students are in play those other communities I'm sorry how many students are totally in play that are in the blue and the green that are moving from Giles and and and the other neighborhoods crany Island that'll come up in the data as we go forward so you'll have total enrollments here in just a second so um all right so so here's the blue and the Green in terms of rural point and Pearson's corner so you can see the division the the uh the students and

061where they shift to so already you had this this weird little Zone that was going across the way to uh to R Point that's going to come back to Pearson's in proximity and we're going to use that uh I think that state road is that two or three um as the dividing line there and then these students will move from Washington Henry over to rural point in order to create space at Washington Henry for the incoming students from Cool Spring uh that are coming going to come in so again kind of that shift and that domino effect and again on Thursday you'll be able to drill I know you guys know where you live but you'll be able to drill in specifically to neighborhoods and houses and that kind of thing on Thursday on on

062uh on this particular situation kids move from rural point over to pole green to create additional utilization and to build up the utilization at Paul Green and allow rural point to receive some students from Washington Henry so again I I I I normally say early on and I'll say it now what we're talking about here is chess not Checkers there's just a lot of moving Parts because the the utiliz the overutilization is at the core and the underutilization is at the periphery so you're having to push out and balance out as you go in this particular situ these students move from Washington Henry over to Mechanicsville and this helps alleviate the Washington Henry uh uh again creating we're having to create additional capacity at Washington Henry to bring in those Cool Spring students and so

063this area is south of meow Bridge uh and that's a fairly large road as you well know and those those students then transition um across the south southern boundary over to Mechanicsville in this particular case again because of this transition you've got folks moving from Mechanicsville over to Cold Harbor to increase cold Harbor's utilization because they were underutilized and had space and this allowed Mechanicsville then to absorb those students that are coming in from Washington Henry again we're building from the we're having to come from the inside out in order to backfill the buildings where the capacity is and this area potentially moves from Cold Harbor to battle Field park to balance utilization between those two schools and you'll see the charts of all the utilization and the enrollments here shortly and again you've got

064Ashland here moving to South Ana to increase utilization of South Ana and ashin ashin situation is the situation coming into the future of what we're forecasting in terms of future growth again here we have so come from Elmont over to Cy Creek uh using the uh the interstate I believe as that zone is that dividing line and this also later fixes part of that one of those situations with the split Middle School High School attendance would it make an addition tool Spring Elementary potentially Chom and aty then moving all of these different I think that's a conversation that you can have with your Schoolboard officials that was not that was not a a choice given to us in terms of how we created our utilizations here's what but here's what I would tell you in

065In fairness In fairness while you have this great number of students you got 114,000 folks that live in the community and they're all ta a big Chun you know 60,000 of them are property taxpayers or whatever the number might be and so the school board in taking a look at this is looking at the bigger the larger question for the entire division is is do we have enough seats in our division to accommodate the students within our division and if you're looking at it from this view you do okay I would also tell you this you've already got us Washington Henry coming online in 2027 and I know that there's already plans to replace two other schools going forward a lot of construction goes as planned right so if it's delay ma'am I I don't

066have an answer that is that was not within here's the short answer I'll give you that was not within our scope all right so again in the blue and green scenario here are the new the new boundaries and you've got the lines that that show those shifts and where they move to so again like the up here with South Anna that hash mark line those kids come into the purple and they go to South Anna in the pole green down here those area in the green come into Pole Green um that kid the the students there adjacent to Pearson's Corner move over in the brown now move into rural point but those stations those kids that used to go to rural point now shift over into Pearson's corner and then this this buildout here is

067depending on which choice we made is made in terms of blue and green in terms of those students near Cool Spring coming down into Washington Henry acoss the street so um again uh you can just see the the entire impact and again it goes back to that domino effect how it goes across the across the division and in in the green not it's just blue and the green they're the same base depending on which move is made in 25 or 27 uh the other ancillary areas the other portions of the division remain the same now in the purple scenario it's a it's a different um it it's a different setup in terms of the core in terms of what's going on around cool spring those areas involving South Ana or Elmont or um or Ashland

068or down into Laurel meal Mechanicsville all of those shifts remain the same in terms of the Domino the question is is where do we how or what neighborhoods are impacted in terms of providing relief to Cool Spring and so drawing on a different neighborhood creating a different scenario there so in this particular case a purple scenario involves another path Rel leaving Cool Springs it reassigns parts of the Kings Charter neighborhood from the Cool Spring Elementary attendance Zone to the Pearson's corner at elementary and this would split King's Charter neighborhood across the Charter Lake Road so it takes it takes King's King's Charter and and and takes a chunk of those students out and takes them up to Pearson's Corner the cranny Island States and cranny Island Farm neighborhood would potentially change from Cool Springs attendant

069zones to Washington Henry additionally rut vill Town Homes West of Atley Road moved to Pearson's Corner uh from Pearson's corner to W Washington Henry into the purple scenario this helps if Pearson's corner is going to accept students from King's Charter then we have to bring some students out of uh Pearson's Corner um under this scenario so it again you're moving students around it one of them's kind of a clockwise method and the other one's a counterclockwise method again all trying to pull away from the core at Cool Spring invol but involving fewer students off of this Zone the purple scenario rolls back potential change areas and the blue green scenarios east of Shady Grove and west of Highway 301 in terms of Pearson's corner and no changes to these areas U there are no changes

070to those two areas so this little wonky chunk thing that that that we had moved into Pearson's Corner uh doesn't go doesn't come into play Under The Purple scenario because you're having to create that space or that um capacity at Pearson's corner so it it it it's either pull it from the North or pull it from the south I mean in terms of chunking those kids so and so here's the the big moves within the purple scenario you can see the um again like those students that were going to Elmont are still going to cury Creek the pole greens the same Battlefield Mechanicsville Cold Harbor a little bit at Laurel Meadow but not a lot uh but the the key difference in the purple is what takes place at King's Charter uh and and the

071number of students that come out of the southern end now this kind of this is kind of getting to Green all right in terms of the percentages in terms of utilization all right so exist boundaries okay think of it in terms of 2024 being this school year because we had to use those numbers if the blue scenario were in place today at school that 2024 utilization for the blue scenario that would be the current utilization if the blue was in play today if the green were in play today that's what the current utilization would be at all the buildings in 2024 and if the purple were in play today that 2024 utilization would would be what it is currently but in looking at the 2029 okay if you look at the blue scenario in 2029

072we're saying that Cool Springs at 85 and uh and then 84 in 2034 the blue scenario what your key takeaway here is the blue scenario in 2024 or for next year provides more immediate relief to Cool Spring than does the green scenario in the green scenario Cool Springs is still going to be close to 100% because there's more kids pulled and and I apologize I don't have that number right in front of me there's more kids pulled in the blue scenario and if you look it in either way in either way Mo the numberers pretty between blue and green you'll notice at the 2034 that number Remains the Same as you push out as you get over to the um as you get over to the purple scenario again as you move forward you can

073see a Cool Spring in 2029 is still running up above 91% at that point so they're plus or minus 90 pushing out to 2029 and into 2034 all right oh sorry sorry all right so Middle School options in terms of blue and green what happens with the these is is we're basically realigning the Middle School and High School attendance Zone to match whatever changes have been made to the uh to the attendance the Elementary attendance zones okay so this area moves from Chickahominy over to in Atley to oakn and Hanover there adjacent to ciry Creek uh this area moves from Oak Middle School in the blue goes from Oak and Handover to chick homon in Atley and because it aligns now with what has taken place at Pearson's Corner U this area would move from

074chiah homon an ATL to Oak in the the lower green to Oak um to Oak Nolan Hanover because of the Rea alignment with uh rural point and I'm G have flow chart I'm going have a flowchart for you in just a moment um and so what this does is it keeps that it creates that clean feeder pattern except we couldn't fix the Mechanicsville SPL they're just there's there too too high a density of population all right Middle School scenarios options in terms of the uh the purple and purple this area moves that the the brownish tannish block there moves from Chickahominy and Atley over to oakn Hanover and that aligns with whatever the new cury Creek is okay and then in the Green oakn Middle School and Hanover these kids go over to chiam atly

075to realign with what was going on at Pearson's corner and again the Mechanicsville line does not move okay um and just as a note that little area there with Laurel Meadow the reason we don't have anything in an arrow there's no kids in there there's like five houses but it but putting a line there actually puts it in line with the middle school zones so if a family moved there their attendance zones would change all right all right so this is your clean feeder pattern I apologize I thought I had a specific student count number and I don't in this slide in the slides um all right so the current feeder patterns okay from Elmont U with the ele in in terms of fixing the Elmont using the Elmont split along I95 the feeder patterns

076are ashin beaverdam and South Anna feed directly into Liberty and Patrick Henry rural point Pole Green now um feed into U Oak null and then with this new split on Pearson's Corner in kon's Creek those kids these I'm sorry these are the current feeder patterns you got that split with Pearson's corner and KY Creek that feed into these middle schools and high schools Mechanicsville is split again we can't really fix that along the pike but you got Washington Henry and cool springs that go to Chickahominy and Atley Battlefield Cole Harbor and Laurel Meadow coming into to Bell Creek and Mechanicsville this is the current feeder pattern the current feeder patterns which I know it's kind of complicated but it's still pretty clean based on what we see oh what we see elsewhere regardless of scenario

077though here are the new this would be the new feeder patterns so we still have the Mechanicsville split along the the turnpike feeding into those schools leading down to chomy and Atley and Battlefield call low Meadow coming into Bell Creek Mechanicsville but over here there are no splits so the four schools here to the right feed directly into Liberty and Patrick Henry and ciry Rule point and Paul Green Feed directly into Oak and Handover um if we don't if you don't realign the boundaries you go from four to six splits I don't have that number but I know it's six so if you don't if you don't f fix it then you'll create two more splits in terms of middle school high school and you won't fix anything going on at those two schools all

078right so in saying that here are your options and your utilizations you got your existing boundaries as they are now and the if you do nothing these are what your numbers are going to be here's your blue green option because again it's the same for the whether it's blue or green it doesn't change what happens at the middle school high school at the secondary level and so for example in this particular one Atley goes 82 9296 in the purple option they're going 86 95 97 okay um Oak null Rises a little bit comes up to 73 71 75 those are still strong numbers you'd like for them be a little higher in terms of utilization uh but they're still strong especially if you look at that 2034 um and H Handover moves out of that

079darker blue into the lighter blue in terms of balance so you've while it's not as perfect as we might like it to be it does do a better job of balancing the overall utilizations in those in those facilities all right so this is where we kind of gathered the information that you have this is where you're going to scan the QR code if you've not logged in already um we didn't put that on this slide does anyone need the login information you can also use your mobile data there is a text message functionality as well so if you'd like to text mg Consulting 3 as if you were just putting into a phone number and then using the text message function and typing in 22333 it'll also work in that regard and so I'll get

080the first question activated here you'll see it just a moment you should be starting to see that populate on your phone uh being able to to reply to that first question and then I'll show it on this uh screen once we get everyone situated with the QR code the live pulling will be something that we capture for all three of these meetings there will also be a survey that's going to be the exact thing that we use for these questions um on Thursday so that when you are interacting with those survey Maps um online we'll be able to capture that and myself on the back back end with Lance and our team will um that code It theme it and then provide that for the division to articulate that interpret that within the decisions of

081collect you guys it is something that we have influence on the theing engagement will influence um but as far as the data goes it's just another piece of that Pi making sure that the community has opportunity to provide their uh feedback if there is something that we can glean from the information that we go didn't think of that we'll do our best to fold that in and bring that forward all the information will be shared with your board so if enough folks say I don't want to say anything out loud if enough folks say certain things we will we will we will we'll bring that information forward

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.