CorpusRecord 121595

Salem School Committee Meeting 1/21/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Salem Access TV - Education
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Essex County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,733 words · about 82 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001call to order the meeting of the Salem school committee of Tuesday January 21st this meeting is taking place in person at 29 Highland Avenue room 227 you can also join via zoom using the link below um we do have one me is Veronica Shan currently yes I'm present okay uh we do have one member participating remotely so um while she is participating remotely all votes will be by roll call vote our first order of business is approval of the agenda move to approve the regular school committee agenda seconded moved by member Cruz seconded by member Campbell uh roll call vote member Campbell yes member Cornell yes member Cruz yes member Hoffman yes member Manning yes member Miranda yes and myself yes public comment the Salem school committee would like to hear from the public on

002issues that affect the school district and are within the scope of the committee's responsibilities Spanish interpretation is available for anyone who needs it the members of the school committee would like to remind the public that Salem public school students regularly attend school committee meetings we encourage all meeting participants to model respectful and productive public discourse for our Young Learners public come in the room thank you for having me my name is Kate M my son Teddy is a kindergartener at the Bentley school um before he was there we were at the Salem Early Childhood Center for 2 years and I'm here tonight to talk to you about their playground um I some pictures if I can pass these out to the school committee I'm also happy to email those to you um the ECC is

003doing amazing work but their playground that serves 130 three and four year-old students every day is very Bare Bones um there's a swing set a water table that has no water source a short tunnel and a spinning cup that's safety rated for children 5 through 12 um most parents only go inside the building a handful of times a year for parent teacher conferences drop off and pickup is outside for many families this playground is their first exposure to Salem public schools and for many kids this playground is their first Glimpse at their first school it's hard to get a three-year-old excited about school when this is the play space that's waiting for them as a parent it's also hard to trust Salem public school tools when your first exposure is a space that looks so

004unfinished this park is owned by parks and rack not by the school system parks and rack was kind enough to co-sign on a CPA grant for a shade structure which should be installed soon for which I'm enormously grateful um however because the equipment was selected by a previous principal and because they have so many properties to manage parks and rack cannot commit more money to this property or prioritize this property for grant opportunities anytime in the near future parks and R is willing to help place a small climbing structure if the cost recovered by the district over the past two and a half years I founded a PTA the ECC and no small part to focus on this project I've met with superintendent Reich parks and rack Amanda Chan Coline the department of planning Community

005Development playground vendors the landscape architector I wrote that shade structure Grant I written to local businesses to see if we could find a sponsor um but I'm at a dead end and I'm here tonight to ask for your help I know that a lot is changing for Salem public schools and that this property might not be the ECC in 5 10 years however in the meantime hundreds of kids are going to use this playground um every day and personally I don't think this project can wait I'm not sure how that's accomplished whether the property can be managed by the schools instead of the city whether the district can find money for a play structure and work with parks and rack um if there's a corporate sponsor somewhere perhaps equipment could be installed and then moved

006if the school were to be moved um but the ECC is the entryway to Sal public schools and I think our kids and our families deserve better thank you can I just any other wait suppos to respond can I just ask a question I didn't catch something a clarifying question yeah yeah could could you just I didn't quite catch what you said about Parx and wck won't do another Grant because did you say the there was a previous principal involved previous principal selected the equipment that's there yeah I'm not sure why the equipment is um a little underwhelming um but I think from Parks and Recs perspective they installed this playground you know I don't know maybe 10 years ago um and they have to prioritize all spaces okay so the the connection is not

007that it was a different principle that is it's fairly recent in they feel that the school district had input on it oh okay all right I just didn't quite know what you meant by that okay thank you thank you other public comment in the room anyone online public comment only none mayor can I just I I just want to um just thank Kate because her child doesn't even go to the ECC anymore and she's been a strong voice and a force around um advocating for the program there and so I appreciate that even Beyond her child's time at the ECC so I just want to thank uh Kate for um you know parent don't spend a ton of time there but the fact that um that the advocacy has continued says a lot about your

008involvement I hope you stay involved in the sale and public schools all throughout uh your child's experience so thank you absolutely I'm so grateful that program right the next item on our agenda is approval of the consent agenda um I'm not going to read all six of the items that are in here sorry 10 of the items that are in here um is it I'll take a motion to accept these um with the exception of the uh item number four which is the field trip to S New Hampshire for the um Salem Junior and senior winter color Garden percussion Ensemble competition March 15th that um not Salem London dery apologize number three number three London Dairy trip um because that competition is taking place in Everett Massachusetts so it does not require School Comm approval

009so this is approval the consent agenda items 1 2 4 5 and six appr under discussion could we my fault because I did not see this I didn't look at it to to see this was on but can we pull out the basketball trip out of the consent agenda just so I can ask a couple of questions about it when we get to it um yeah item number two I yeah I think it's two it's it's in uh February 9th to something I'm flipping through here to see if I can find it quickly but I can't so if we can just move it move to approve all but item two and three okay here's a motion second motion made by member Campbell seconded by member Cornell uh roll call vote member Cornell yes member Cruz

010yes member Hoffman yes member Manning yep member Miranda yes member Campbell yes and myself yes did you want to take up item number the um basketball field I'm still I'm still looking for it um I I I guess maybe superintendent would just know the the answer um I'm just want to be sure that a we don't have they're not that's fa that's vacation dates right that's right are they are they playing in any game games when they're down there are they actually playing basketball um they they will at least be practicing I think they were looking to see if they could scrimmage uh my understanding is the Mia has changed their ruling of around playing games um so um they were he the coach was looking into that but the key is that this is

011during vacation week right uh and they were going to be playing basketball of some kind whether that's practice or but okay but they I don't know it's not a it's not going MIAA changes is enough that okay but it's not going to be a um like a a tournament or a set game or tournament yeah okay thanks for the opportunity to question Cornell just related to this because this did come up last year and I I specifically asked coach Doyle if we were going to be in this situation again and there wasn't going to be an opportunity to engage in a game or other kinds of play that students do some kind of service related activity while they are there and so I think this really obviously needs to get referred back to policies because

012I think we have to take a look at um these kind of trips where our students whether they're missing school or not um I I think there should be some kind of service component to this um if our kids are going to be out um traveling together with no other agenda um and it's a and it's our you know sort of stamp of approval on it the same as last year I'm not going to be the person to vote no but it I would have liked to have seen something like that on the agenda M Chris can I just a clarifying question are you uh suggesting that we bring back the field trips policy to review not not saying not referring this particular trip okay just want to make sure i' move to approve item

013uh two seconded motion made by member Cruz second by member Campbell a roll call vote member Cruz uh yes member Hoffman yes member Manning yes member Miranda yes member Campbell yes member Cornell yes and myself yes student Representatives report so after these past four weeks um due to the meeting now occurring two weeks ago um we have a lot that has happened so we could not meet this week due to Martin Luther King day and so this was just from the four weeks and the meeting we had two weeks ago we went over a building survey regarding the new high school and students in the group were able to add anything they would like to prioritize so anything that was science related or sports related they could talk about any rooms they were talking about

014they're talking about more collaborative spaces and more study areas and we're also mentioning the grade configuration for the new school whether that be 7 to 12 or 9th to 12 there are differing opinions on that I think most people agreed on a 9 to 12 the other update we have the update on the spice Barn the salad plate um both have been fully implemented more students are I've seen personally going to the spice bar they're adding sriracha and hot sauce and even tomorrow is national hot sauce day so we're trying new local brands of hot sauce that we're adding the crank sauce so that's good we also have the salad plate that's fully um introduced we also have M wikins coming back and we now have an official meeting room in Room 101 and that

015means we now have an official Google meet that's set up for the new Liberty and S Prep students who weren't able to come originally just cuz due to transportation and I'm even in touch with one of these students who wanted to join so I'm going to have a call on Wednesday going out and I've have yet to hear from two other students but that's TB day and other than that it's just midterms week so everyone's a little stressed about midterms but I think that everyone's got this I think so but that's it thanks yeah can I Mark can do you mind just um also uh mentioning talk a little bit about there's some new additions to the group oh yes and um I think I want to give credit to one of the gentleman sitting

016over there who presented to your uh group right about did you mention the artificial intelligence no I did not that was the one thing I missed so we did have a you had a lot to cover Mark don't worry we had a meeting regarding AI usage and how Sal Public Schools took a rather slow and steady approach rather than um Banning it outright and so that means the uh Mark Mark LeBlanc right yes Mr ganc came in and he talked about how we were talking we were taking a sko and study approach and so he wanted to ask what our thoughts were and what we use AI for in our daily lives and so we went over a lot of that and how Sal Public Schools should approach it their way and yes we did

017have our first official meeting with around 10 12 new students I'd say 8 to 8 to 12 I'd say but it's a lot bigger now so and how are they selected just so the committee knows uh it was by survey so we had people come in through a survey and and we had the whole group talk about what they liked about the application and what we didn't like if things could improve but a majority of people were selected I think there was only one or two but that's what we went over question member Cruz Mark thanks so much for your report and uh it's great to see that you're all getting your house in order um I think one of the things that it would be great to uh discuss is um one of the

018charges of the student advisory committee is that they're actually supposed to be hosting um monthly meetings with the school committee um so we know that you all have been busy with getting organized your elections uh securing a meeting room all the important things that are necessary to have good governance uh but I would love to propose um you have two Liaisons on the committee myself and Miss Campbell that perhaps we could get together to chat about um having our first ever full School Comm meeting with the student advisory Council I think it would be great to have a committee of the whole and we can talk about things that are on your minds and that way the whole committee would get an opportunity to be able to engage with the advisory committee um and we

019can be in compliance with the law so that would be really good I love that that sounds perfect we can work on a date for that excellent I'm talking a lot here but I I I'd be remiss if we didn't congratulate mark on his acceptance to Boston University uh it's a big deal very proud of him and he should be proud of all the work he's uh done to get to that place and I know he'll represent us well so congratulations Mark good luck in the bean pot thank you I I just wanted to add something about the spice bar um this was a suggestion from the student Advisory Group to the food and nutrition services department that um students would enjoy the lunch more if they could customize their meals um with their own

020spices so we put out a survey and the number one requested spice was Frank's Hot Sauce followed by Sriracha so both are available on the spice bar and it's great to hear that students are enjoying it anything else all right thanks Mark superintendent report all right it's gonna be a spicy report here tonight um oh good no but um I got to say uh listening to the spice conversation I didn't even know what half the spices were that they referenced certainly when I was you know uh in high school I love how how uh interested kids are in spicing up the food and making it more interesting and uh I think we might have had like 30 to 40 recommendations of spices so I don't know how big the spice bar is but uh there

021was a lot of interest in a whole lot of spices some that I had never heard of before so um and I'm I'm very excited about this group moving forward we have a real good representation across the grade levels uh very different perspectives um and uh I for the first time in my time here I I think we are going to be able to do some powerful work with a a strong base of student voice around and and Manny thank you for your suggestion or Mr Cruz that we bring you know we we haven't been able to have that joint meeting and I think we've got the right folks to make that happen now so thank you for that suggestion um I want to start by just um congratulating all the students and staff that

022were part of the show Chicago um this weekend I was blown away by the talent uh it was spectacular performance um I want to thank uh Leah Hamilton French who directs it and there's so many other people that to thank that I I will forget but certainly um the staff and the students um you know if anybody questions the talent of our students just check out the show it seems to get better every year and I what I appreciate the most is the effort to be as inclusive as possible with um uh all any student who wants to be part of it can be part of it whether they're part of the pit or they're part of the stage crew um and they you know included uh all any student who wanted to perform had

023a chance to perform in that show so that's a real credit to uh them I also want to um acknowledge the four students at horse man who will be recognized next Monday at Salem State's 35th annual MLK convocation and celebration um obviously yesterday was MLK day but I want to call out these students and I I really want to call out Joel Tobin who is the teacher the fifth grade teacher at Horseman who every year has his kids apply um or submit essays um and um I just want to acknowledge who those students are the fifth grade co uh co-winners were Emanuel Dela Cruz odia Aaron uh tafu and Johnny San uh and then Rosie moika was named a runner up um they will each receive $100 the three uh winners and the runner up

024$50 and they will also receive a copy of the book march by the late us Congressman uh John Lewis um and so uh on next Monday there'll be a lunch in where they'll be recognized everybody's invited to attend at Salem State um and um they wrote about the legacy of Dr Martin Luther King which I think is as important as ever right now in this country and I just applaud um them and Mr Tobin for making sure that our students um have the opportunity to contribute to the Civic um you know the uh to this really important civic responsibility and that they're um you know part of this event every single year so congratulations to all those students um and um we hope next year more students will apply to uh or submit essays to

025be part of the um competition so um thank you um and with that I'm going to turn to um I think can we start with the calendar my favorite topic every year um and I do uh so we're going to start with the calendar for the upcoming school year and of course in Salem we have multiple calendars and this year you actually have all the calendars um in front of you already we have them all Carlton's calendar we have um the calendar for Salem High School and Salem prep which are together and we have the calendar for um the District as a whole every other school in the district and I just want to call out um I do have a I do um have a recommendation which you see here but there is a

026question I want to pose to the committee and get your feedback on but if you go to the next or I gu I can go to the next slide here we go um so just a couple things the first day of school on the calendar in front of you it's a lot clearer for us now with the language in the contract and we worked with the St and having a fixed first day of school um and I should mentioned New Liberty has their own calendar too so there's four separate calendars of course um but the first day of school uh now is um is let me just see is uh the work year for employees May begin no earlier than the Monday prior to Labor Day so in honoring the spir the language in the

027contract the first day that students could start with three professional days for teachers is the last Thursday of um August which is the 28th of August which would be the first day of school in this calendar so allows us to start before Labor Day um and then um we would have school on the Friday before Labor Day so there'd be two days um a short week for kids um two days that first week um the other thing that I note about this calendar uh this year is that per the discussion in uh during the contract negotiations Good Friday is no longer being observed as a day off or no longer needs to be observed as a day off from school uh there were a lot of strong feelings I know on part of the committee

028and in our negotiations that uh this is ensures consistency with how we support students and staff who who celebrate a variety of religious holidays and have a variety of religious beliefs that we don't uh recognize specific religious holidays in the calendar as a day off from school of course CHR does fall on winter break but there are no other days in the calendar other than historically Good Friday that were connected to a particular religious um you know religious belief and this way you know staff if they needed to take the day off as staff do for religious reasons they can use um a religious observance day um for that um Halloween there's never a perfect way to H handle Halloween but generally we got pretty decent feedback this year uh the recommendation is to have

029an early release and then staff would have a chance to get students and staff would have a chance to get home in time and then we'd um have asynchronous professional development they could essentially work from home to do uh work that's assigned we tried to make it a time for teachers to catch up with report cards or to uh complete grading and things like that but that um the work would be done um from home so that students and staff could get home before the crowds arrive and this year Halloween is on Friday which will be a very um I don't have to tell anybody here will be a very busy day in the city um and then what's I just want to call out that there are backtack professional days in March one is

030a full day and the other is a half day um the reason people have asked like why would you do that why would you have two days back to back and the thought process here is we're trying to move towards student-led conferences um in and we want to Pilot pilot that next spring universally some schools do student Le conferences now but our our we need ample time to try to implement it and pilot it and so the thought from the academics team and um and and Kate's team has been to um build in two consecutive days one a full day one a half day to give sufficient time for that to happen and see how it goes and we get some feedback that's why that looks that way um in the calendar to have the

031backtack days um in um in March uh so that's the thinking I will point out too that um there is in the contract the attendance incentive that if staff um are able we have 95% um attendance rate or better that we would give back a professional day um to um we take away a professional day and give people that off as a vacation day as an incentive if that does happen we don't know what will happen this year the day that would come off the calendar for staff is the November 4th uh that's typically the primary or El I should say election day um and that day would not be it would just be a no school day for students and for staff I just want to call that out that was part of the

032um conversation uh that we had with the St and so we'll see um what the attendance rate looks like at the end of the year so just some feedback I did share this out to the staff and predictably I got a lot of feedback from people um I more recently I have shared it I shared it with parents in the newsletter um this week um and there's just a couple things that I just want to share the feedback we've gotten um some are recommending that students start after Labor Day um so that the full the first full week is not a full week for staff because if you look at that it would be a full week of staff for staff the last week of August um if we start after Labor Day it just

033pushes the Year back um later in June um there is a lot the the the most um frequent feedback I received is that people are very concerned about student attendance on December 26 22nd and 23rd because um and they are recommending that these days be included in the winter break and that we push the school year two days that's the question I have for you all we did have very bad attendance this year on the two days we returned from Break um it was a Thursday and Friday the 2nd and the 3 um we had terrible attendance on those days and that's feedback that we've received from um teachers that they would like us to consider and I'm I'm open to it I'd love to hear what the committee has to say about that would

034mean that essentially there'd be two full weeks of break over the um December break for for uh students and staff um staff did raise concerns about the PD days in March that they're consecutive um and they'd be worried that students will not attend school on Friday to have a long weekend so Kate and I did discuss maybe moving those two days to Monday Tuesday um so that people um so that there wouldn't be this temptation for people to take the Friday off so that that's um another question I would have um and then there is this concern about Good Friday there are I got a number of emails about Good Friday um and I I know staff other districts have struggled the first year they've implemented no school on Good Friday um I do think

035it'll be Rocky the first time through but I do think after that it'll be just the way we do things in Salem that we don't have that we do have school on Good Friday some suggested that we have a half day on Good Friday but um I don't want to Short Change kids on learning time in school um so I I still recommend that we move you know we move with having school on Good Friday but I just wanted to be open with I wanted to share with you what I heard from staff um and then there was concern about high school graduations might be in late May instead of early June um there's nothing that says that it has to be on the first Friday of June that's just been the tradition in Salem

036um and so um but it it doesn't mean that we can't move the graduation earlier because the year ends earlier um and so um my final Reflections oh I didn't change my okay um this is my suggestion is that this is a draft and um I'll ask school committee for a final vote at the February 3rd meeting I'd like to put it on the table and let it marinate out there for a couple of uh weeks before we take a final vote um Bentley does plan to follow the Salem public schools calendar I just let people know they they have the we could have a fifth calendar wanted to have their own calendar and I know Ann loves having so many different calendars just like I do um and I gave you copies of all

037the calendars um so you have all of them right now for review um for what I would you know request as a vote on February 3rd so with that I'll turn it back over to you mayor and see if there's any comments or feedback on the calendars member Hoffman I have a question about the March dates that you're talking about the 18th 19th is that the one yes you take off the Monday Tuesday wouldn't people still take a long weekend would you consider doing or the Monday Tuesday is that what you said or did you say Tuesday well the thing is if you it's the Friday that I worry about because they'll take off they they have off essentially or half they have a half day and a full day and then they'll take Friday

038off because I would be one of those parents that be like H it's Monday Tuesday right for a long weekend just throwing that out there right but if we put it on if we have the the full day and the half day um on Monday and Tuesday of that week there'll be less okay temptation to take another day off remember Cruz um I think the one flag I would offer is uh in September there will be a preliminary election uh I don't see that noted and I know the calendars haven't all come out yet on dates for that we know November 4th would be the general election so I just flag that is just needing to be notated on this calendar uh and then I think we we plan accordingly um but it's usually that

039first or second Tuesday um in September uh for the preliminary Municipal elections so that that would be my one flag uh and then I think the uh only other uh question that I had or in response to your piece on um how to handle uh the Good Friday um I don't have strong feelings about this so I'm I'm comfortable with that recommendation uh Dr stri I what I would say is I think we just need to be thinking about uh the the concern that's raised around Staffing buildings and getting a pulse check of what that actually looks like um and the only other thing that I was curious about is um what what how long will it take to produce the attendance rate for the in uh attend attendance incentive so if you could let

040us know how long that would take to just calculate and when we would get that as committee members I think you said end of the school year does that mean that we' get it in June or that we would get it in that one school committee meeting in July I I think we would know probably in early June I mean you can see where we're headed based on the rate um I I I'd have to ask Jill but I think you'd get we'd get it in June okay it doesn't really affect the caler for families at all because it's already an off day for kids so uh it would be a me be messaging to staff uh once we know if we met if they met the attendance goal or not thank you I'm remaining

041um regarding Halloween like you do know that large crowds arrive before noon time on Halloween no I do know that just checking um no they arrive arrive before the sunrises right they arrive in July they arrive in July there you go yeah but um I just you know I just had to laugh when you said before the crowds arrive I thought yeah right um the PD days in March okay I'm I'm confused are those is that a day and a half that teachers will meet with parents for conferencing with kids that's correct then why are we calling them PD days they're not professional development they parent teacher conference days that that's true we would I mean it just it's consistent with the colors but the uh but uh normally I would love consistent colors you're

042right you're right it's not but it's not PD and I don't think that's accurate because if we tally up PD days or whatever I think we need to change the terminology so that people realize yep like me that they're not professional development cuz I thought maybe it was in that you were training like the schools that do it were training the schools that don't Etc but if it isn't let's change it okay thanks other questions comments oh member Cruz the the winter break the winter break I'd love some feedback on that yeah uh Beyond I think students not returning because they they might extend their travels um I also think that time of year lot of illnesses um in households so I'm I think I'm comfortable with a more a longer um winter break and

043and testing that out um so i' I'd be on board with that idea if the attendance was incredibly low I think we just need to look at that data and see what that looked like um so you know leading up to that February meeting if you could send that over just so we know um exactly what you mean when you say that attendance was low I think I have an idea of it but I'd just like to get a better sense of um what it actually looked like in terms of uh both our students but then also um staff as well yeah Mark maybe we can I mean I I should have had it ready for today but Mark can probably have it ready in the next 10 minutes what the raids were on those

044days I bet he can just checking our dashboard any it's at his fingertips right it's already going Campbell um I similarly had concerns about the 2 and 23rd um because I know that it is already so challenging to manage the pacing of learning leading up to Winter Break um as you're trying to hopefully wrap up some units of study before segueing into the next unit fresh from the school year um so I'm just thinking about in terms of which days that being said um sometimes that is happening at the end of the school year too so if you're swapping those two days for 2 days in June like what's the you know and obviously some of this is requiring you to forecast like how many snow days you know because if you bump it out

045to you know like I think it's going to be awkward on in either location so that being said I really am comfortable with it ending up in either spot I think there's arguments to be made in terms of like student time on learning um whether those two days are in December or in June I think you know teachers who are you know really instructing and working through the material like that's going to happen whether it's December or June um I did notice though and I'm not sure if this is an error or if this is Carlton doing Carlton um that they have the school on the 22nd but not on the 23rd um and that struck me as a little bit odd that they would come back just for the Monday before and then have

046off the 23rd 24th 25 and so that to me I do have significant concerns about coming for one single day um and like I said I'm not sure if that's a typo or if that was part of their plan but I would prefer to see that mirror the rest of the dish in this one particular instance I have a hard time understanding why you would come for one single day um that's a good catch we can ask Carlton that I I don't know if it's just Carlton being Carlton which could be but um we that's a good followup we can check okay thank you um yeah other than that I feel like the winter break is is such a toss up there that um I I kind of can't imagine either solution being particularly elegant

047when you realize that the days are going to get tacked on to the end of the year but I do think um uh the concern around illness and sickness at that time of year is particularly um important to consider but to me it's a bit of a tossup um and then I would flag I know I do this every time but the um primary days and election days in general I do still feel very uncomfortable having school that day while there are um elections and strangers coming into the buildings and I know that everybody's very proactively planning for it and you know prepping but you know as somebody who works in a school every single day and and you know that that's just always at the Forefront of my mind I want to make sure

048that um ideally we would be not having school or moving towards finding different polling places um than in our buildings it makes me really really uncomfortable to have it so I just want to flag that again um especially in a year where we have the mayoral election and city council and school committee it's you know it's an all all play so it just you know that's always something I'm thinking about forther all right yeah so I'll make uh many of the revisions that you suggested this is good feedback I I do think the staff the feedback I got from the staff is pretty clear that they would prefer the 22nd and 23rd be off not just because they would like those days but also because they're concerned about kids um attendance and I think that's

049important away here um and so um you don't have those attent you do okay of course he does okay 79.9% Terri compared to the next Thursday was 92.6 just yeah that's a big drop and then 82.2 to the next Friday which is 91.2 yeah I mean that that says a lot I want to inome I wouldn't want to do it yep all right all right so I guess I'm next to on um un building uh conf uh grade configurations and before I present I um I wanted to pass it over to um School Committee Member uh Cornell who's on the building committee who I think wanted to share some perspective before we get into this topic um so I apologize because I wrote it down so I wouldn't forget anything um I'm just hoping to

050because I'm a member of this the building committee with Dr Z and the mayor uh and Lisa golden I just want to kind of hopefully provide a little bit of clarity for folks I know a lot of community members have participated in the process and our Middle School teachers uh had a great conversation with drj recently um so I appreciate everybody coming to the public forums with the design firm so everybody met the the design firm uh who showed up at those meetings so I and I also hope that there are people particularly middle middle school teachers who are tuned in um to this meeting so I just wanted to put like the finest point on it that I can I just want everybody in the community and the school committee to to know that

051uh the designers the engineers The Architects The Firm Liaisons have no role to play when it comes to how we as a district educate students none at all um the building will support the district's educational plans and objectives and not the other way around so I I think that that Clarity is maybe something that gets a little bit lost because we are partners with the design with the design firm in a lot of ways but not when it comes to delivering education so at the moment when talking to stakeholders and representatives uh the representatives from the design firm Are focused they have been pretty focused on the needs of the high school and I think that that's causing some confusion for for some folks at least some of the emails that I get um because

052the design firm has put an overemphasis on what's possible in the high school because as of right now that's the only part of the design that is 100% getting built a high school is getting either you know rebuilt or completely uh you know or improved but that's the only thing that's done is that we are redoing the high school U so they do spend a lot of time using the words the high school talking about the high school um Perkins has already started engaging with different programs at the high school as as Mark pointed out engaging with students um you know music Athletics academics and um any ideas that they're sharing about possibilities for the Middle School a middle school um and a middle high school at this point are just ideas um Perkinson will

053is a great firm they're a world-renowned firm and the designers and architects in general are just creative people so they have lots of ideas and they get excited and I'm super grateful for that but until this body takes a vote on grade configuration they can propose chocolate water Mountains and the hallways of the middle school and it doesn't matter um they can you know none of that matters until this body takes a vote um and all of that is meaningless and and in fact once they start talking about the high school in a and if we vote on a Middle High School in a they can't really begin thinking about that in a concrete way until they start talking to our Middle School leaders and Educators um so again neither did the design firm nor

054the building committee which we all serve on has any say in how students are educated or how programs are administered none um that's the job of District leaders and school committee members to collect information from Educators and other stakeholders and make sure that the building supports the educational program again not the other way around regardless of what the grade configuration is so we've had some really great feedback from the community especially from our Educators on grade configuration in the new building on the high school campus um and the school committee had a productive Retreat which I think we're going to hear about in a minute um that was facilitated by Rachel scarrett who has experience as a principal of a 9 through 12 school as well as a middle high school and I think that

055conversation raised a lot of really important considerations from us all especially around the middle middle school experience um we're also really fortunate to have um two Educators experienced Public School Educators and leaders on this body and Mary Manning and Amanda Campbell and they gave us a lot to consider also um so I just want to say before we kind of launch into into a summary of our conversation and next steps that I think I think it's fair to say that I can speak for all of us here uh when I say that middle school students deserve an educational experience that is unique to them that is distinct from the experiences of high school or elementary students and that is driven and supported by Middle School Educators who understand and are committed to this particular particular

056age group so I just want folks to know that like that's sort of how the conversations are happening and when they don't happen like that on you know in the building committee we just remind folks that that's that's what Drive who and what drives the process so um however the body votes on grade configuration uh I know that we're going to continue to support a rich unique and and rigorous Middle School experience for Salem kids all right yep do you do you mind putting up the presentation okay so um this time I'll click through um the whole way uh so we um as um member Cornell mentioned we did have a series of community conversations many in the last month and a half or so about um the building project where we did discuss building

057configuration there were four Community meetings uh one was all in Spanish which was the most recent one at um ESP spasio and then there were three English um language meetings one was in person and one was on uh I'm sorry two it should say two in person and one on Zoom um and then we did one staff Zoom session which was pretty well attended and there was discussions at the parent advisory group the teacher Advisory Group and the student Advisory Group and additionally I did have a chance to meet with U Middle School teachers um last week um and have a conversation with them as well uh about some feelings some ideas and um some strong feelings they had about 7 to 12 versus a 9 to2 so we've had a chance to speak with

058a lot of people and this doesn't include the conversations that happened last school year in in June when we discussed this and then um you know turn back the clock to three or four years earlier when we did the master facilities plan and we had some of these conversations as well the key question that was asked uh during these meetings was what do you see are the challenges and benefits of a change in grade configuration so uh I just wanted to share um and I I don't want to necessarily read all of them to you but I'll just summarize uh what we heard the support for a change in in configuration um had to do with more efficient use of resources spaces and services and this is in no particular order um I think this

059is just um a collection of what we heard in all these meetings that there was opportunity for you know more um collaboration and mentorship across the span you know having older students be able to work with younger students do some of the things we want we wanted our high schoolers to have the opportunity to do to mentor and Lead younger students this obviously makes it easier to do um the flexibility around course offerings the opportunity to um offer middle schoolers um a larger variety of courses um and and if you have eighth graders or seventh graders who want to take High School level courses because they're ready we be much easier to do in the past we've had students do that but we have to transport them and so forth and this would make it

060easier to to um you know meet students where they where they where they are um academically um we talked a we heard a lot about um alignment um and collaboration across the middle school and high school with Educators um in ensuring that we could um align our instructional practices um to be stronger than they are right now between the middle and high school grades um a lot definitely heard a lot about access to specialized spaces that middle schoolers would be able to have uh CTE more advanced Labs Athletics you know more kids would have more access to some of these state-of-the-art spaces um extracurricular options we already know that our middle schoolers in Salem because of our size d take advantage of some of the spectacular extracurricular options that exist at the high school level

061around Sports band um so forth and this would make it easier students do have to go back and forth and that's not easy to do um and so more students would have access to those um I think we've heard a lot about this the idea that in building a a facility that would be for uh more grades that more students in the in Salem almost 40% of our total student population would have access to a brand new state-of-the-art facility um that is you know newer healthier on days like today warmer um and on hot days definitely cooler uh than what they uh do now across the two buildings uh or in this in now it's three buildings because we have middle schoolers at Salt and stall um that there would be fewer transitions for students

062um ability to have a stronger connection uh during a you know a time in students lives where they need those social emotional connections and relationships more than ever um and then you know we we have heard a lot about the need to be more competitive and uh in ensuring that we keep our enrollment moving in the right direction as it has been that it provides stronger competition for um places like S6 Tech um and places like the charter where we would you know we would now be able to have our um elementary students stay um connected or our sixth graders stay connected to an elementary school or a a different experience because we do lose a lot of kids from historically between fifth and sixth we think that's changing now but that this would be

063an opportunity to even be more competitive with the charter and with Essex Tech which is the two places we lose the um you know the majority of our students too as they move into middle and high school and again we're on a good Trend now we've started to see shifts but having a brand new facility would certainly help um that as well at both those grade spans um we've also heard concerns about change in grade configurations um a lot of it has to do with um scheduling challenges of shared spaces will the middle school students have Equitable access to the different spaces how do we know that the high school is not going to dominate the spaces at the new facility uh there is concern you know essentially about the um the Middle School experience

064being lost um and bethanne touched upon that in her comments um the supervision of shared spaces came has come up parents are worried about having middle schoolers and high schoolers together and what that would mean um although I'm sometime I'm not sure exactly who's more scared of whom the middle schoolers or the high schoolers or vice versa but there we did hear you know that influence um of high schoolers might not be what is in the best interest of mill middle schoolers um there was concern about not having enough space for the varied programs we have a lot of specialized programs here at the middle school and a lot of access to specialized culinary spaces um spaces for life skills programs that are middle school specific and then same at the high school like how

065do we make sure that uh that those spaces aren't lost because the footprint may be smaller we have a large building here that was a former high school and then obviously a high school at Salem High uh concerned about that um people are worried about traffic we've heard I hear that I hear that everywhere in Salem but they're concerned about that's already a very busy site and if it's not done right then you're going to have a lot of extra traffic um on that on that campus and people are really worried about that what will do for the um getting in and out of those schools um I mentioned the Middle School losing identity to the high school um I think people feel I mean I think this speaks very positively about the Middle School

066how people are feeling about Collins Middle School right now I heard very positively from the teachers that they feel good about their school the culture at their school the direction it's going and they're worried about you know they didn't feel that great A couple of years ago and they don't want to revert back to that um if um you know if the middle school and the high school are on the same C campus people feel very strongly about separation um and and I think everywhere I've heard that separation is really important um and people again we heard a lot about the social emotional needs very uh greatly across the different grad spans the last thing I heard we heard loudly is about sixth grade and the importance of taking care of the sixth graders people

067are worried about the sixth graders losing out by remaining with the younger students um and that and that both on a from a social standpoint um but also from an academic standpoint uh the sixth grade standards are more closely aligned with 7 to 12 and so by cutting them out um there is concern from you know this came from Educators who are very passionate about making sure kids are taught what they're supposed to be taught and so that was important feedback that we received as well so um we I think we received a lot of you know a lot of strong feedback on either side of this question um just to make your decision that much easier um but the final Reflections I have is that I I I think there's a strong rationale for

068both options I can understand um the rationale for both options um you know I I think I don't think there's a a mistake that can be made it's not the building that's going to determine the quality of the experience it's the people we have it's the design it's the the programs we offer um that's what's going to make the experience for kids um I think we do have regardless of the decision we make we do need to strengthen the alignment between middle and high school and so you know I think I think you know regardless of whether it's a all they're all in one building we do have a lot of work to do to improve the alignment um both you know from an instructional standpoint but also in terms of transitions for kids um

069that can be improved so whatever we do we're still going to have to make sure that that goes right um and and gets better because I think in all honesty I think that's a place where um as a system we have not totally hit our stride um I think if we move to a 7 to 12 facility there's a a strong preference to keep the two grade spans up part as much as possible I think the designers have heard that um in the conversations we've had but I that's that came out loud and clear um I think the as I just mentioned there are a lot of questions about sixth grade and I do think we're going to have to talk about that if it moves to a 7 to 12 like you know that

070whether that means that sixth grader stay at elementary school or you create some districts do put fifth and sixth graders together in their own um location um that I've seen that work in some places that may be something that this committee wants to consider but I just I do think that that um the more I hear from our teachers that looms very large the the worry about sixth grade and I think I I I understand it and I understood it more after talking to our staff and then I just would submit that as you know the proposed vote on grade configuration I'm proposing that it be on the agenda for the February 3rd school committee meeting as I think you all are aware so that's my update um wasn't more than a few slides and

071hope it but I and I hope it captured a ton of input um that we've gotten over the last few weeks and and months so thank you back to you mayor thanks um we can open up for discussion now on this topic yeah I I do have some comments that I want to make that I've been um sort of holding back I've I've gone to all of the forums the parent forums that um have been held and I see some of what um Bean conell was referring to um and I have some difference on some of that um and I think that um it makes it's it was a question of whether I was going to sort of make my comments tonight or wait until um the next meeting when we'd be voting but I

072felt that people definitely dug in by then and and everybody will know what they're going to do and I just want to throw some things out for folks to think about before that that last chance um and I'm not using the term Last Chance lightly because I do think that the idea that um we can make a decision to make it a 712 and then um make decisions about programmatic and educational and a wide variety of things um after the fact doesn't make a lot of sense um I I do want to talk first about this building as literally the building um and um like I said I I I I do have some some thoughts and I am going to share them and I I just I want to apologize because it'll take a

073couple of minutes but I think this is my my only opportunity to really say some of this um the building itself you know everybody realizes it's buildings built in the 19 early 1900s 1911 I think 1913 um and is probably the most solid of the schools that we have still um the addition the big addition was done in the um early 1990s 91 to 94 um took off the automotive added the back in 2010 to 14 did another big project which was sort of an envelope um a lot of environmental work on the building um and the the building is um fitted for a it was the high school but it is fitted for the Middle School um architecturally almost perfectly I mean we have in the in the middle school right now um an

074auditorium that fits a grade level um I know from experience that we won't get uh and I think this is one of the points that when folks listen to the Pres ations and it talks about you know they you'll have a new Auditorium you'll have a new cafeteria you'll have a new gymnasium you'll have a new whatever they won't be new available to both schools um equally the reason we have a a Middle School auditorium that fits a grade level is because even back in the early 1990s we already had the big auditorium at the high school so because they had that the middle school got a smaller one and that's that's okay the city needs a large Auditorium the middle school does not need a large Auditorium needs an effective Auditorium and we have

075that and I think that we only look to to uh need to look to the success of the theater program here and I know Dr Z was mentioning earlier the success in the high school and the uh quality of the Productions and I think for a middle school level we could match that easily with the history of the theater program here and the auditorium that we have um and you can need to look no further than the students who've gone through our program at the middle school then our program at the high school and come out and gone into theater in college and you know are successfully in that working in those areas but my point is we have that Auditorium right now available to middle school students 100% of the time we have a

076full-size gymnasium full middle scho middle school siiz gymnasium full um it's there's a full schedule in there every day for fizzed class is all day every day there are no free periods um it's unclear to me um when I look at the after school schedule there which is Collins inter murals car Collins inter School athletics Salem High School on occasion having their practices here the boys club leap Community programs on weekends um every single morning basketball before school here for any kid that wants to come in um I don't see how that would be replicated um in a 7 to 12 situation um we have a music area that has three music rooms a very large Band Room three practice rooms six I'm sorry four to six practice rooms we have four out rooms um

077culinary four culinary rooms four teed rooms we have a kiln um music area really um it's not like you have to develop a lot of new um infrastructure there in the technology education and in The Culinary rooms yes that would need we would need some money put into those programs uh those rooms to bring those up to date but they're there and they're certainly usable um again I'm only mentioning these things because I I have serious concern for number one the need to piggyback schedules exactly so that our students can use the a room which may be empty um maybe not scheduled for a particular room in an automotive or something but it's certainly not going to be on a 5050 basis I doubt it's even going to be a and it's going to tie

078up the middle school schedule so that the flexibility that the Middle School likes the flexibility of the pilot um is is based on um that overlap is is that's not going to happen because the overlap is going to have to fit that a middle school class could go use a CTE room which happen to be open for that period um the organization of the middle school that we have is perfect for the division of into smaller houses that make sense for students of this age um the room size that we have in this building is I believe it's 900 square ft in the majority of the building the rooms in the addition are 750 Because by the time we did the uh the addition the um what the state would pay for changed I don't

079know if it's changed again but I do know if you ask teachers is it valuable to have theot the that extra square feet the answer is certainly going to be yes this building has an a very large IMC it's an instructional media center it's not just a library the technology is available there there's a classroom there it's a multi-use space it's available 100% of the time to middle school students there are three science labs um fully equipped science labs when they were installed which I'm not sure now what they're used for I think some of them maybe science rooms but not really Labs we sort of got away from that somehow but easily could go back to being true lab situations we're not going to get any of this with right sizing any common spaces

080or any of these types of classes at at a 7 to 12 when The Architects talk about right sizing they're talking about making it the size for the high school and if we want to pay additional money we get another room but it won't be as large I don't understand the discussion that we can make a decision to go to a building to go to a 7 to 12 without talking programs and schedules and programmatic needs and educational needs for students and say that we'll retrofit that all afterward um I'm unclear on how that happens um I'm very concerned about the sixth grade issue um you know it's beginning to feel the to me like soon the sixth grade basically as we design things doesn't have a home or won't have a home we need

081to figure that out the same reasons that the superintendent used to talk about why salt and stall students should be brought over here many of those are the same reason sixth graders should remain with seventh there there were climate issues there are resource in issues that are age appropriate there are organizational issues and expectations and responsibilities sixth grade students in today's world don't don't want and don't need and shouldn't stay as an elementary student and if you ask the students they know that if you ask the parents they know that um I think it would be a big mistake to put the sixth graders back with the fifth graders and because the state won't bring them up with the seventh graders then where are they going to go if we if we take the 7

082to 12 model my other question is what's going to happen with the pilot program if we want we say we're going to extend it the plans to extend it to the whole Middle School well how are we going to have a pilot program then for sixth graders if they're um down in an elementary with fifth graders science and social studies and I think we all got a email on that earlier yes yesterday or today about the time on those two topics on the time on those subjects um there's a huge difference between the way science and social studies um are addressed at elementary level and and Middle School level the con the construction not construction I'm sorry but the the design folks The Architects from the very beginning from the first meeting at of the

083building and ground subcommittee a couple of years ago the very first meeting that they presented they came to present to the buildings and grounds first on the idea of the middle school coming out of the master plan and when they arrived they came over to the table over here where we were meeting so I was on that committee then and I still am and all of their signage and their and all their presentation was called middle Jun senior Junior High School middle wasn't even on the name from the very beginning the mindset that was presented to the community started with Junior Senior High School and I remember basically being pretty vehement that the signage needed to that they were presenting they needed to change it and they needed to change it before they came back

084to talk to us because it it was already setting up in folks what we were talking about now we hire designed for that was one firm that was sort of a feasibility firm or then then we have the design folks and I understand that their concern is we've said we want to have a 9 to2 and they had bringing him with information about a 9 to2 um sorry a seven a high school then we put in we also might want a middle school so I I I hear bethan when she's explaining that their focus is more on the high school cuz that's what they've been tasked right now to do but it's wrong when they come in and at all four forums I've heard them say we're not presenting on a um 7 to2 model

085because on you you already know what a middle school is like and this is to the parents so there's no need to talk about that right now um we we're talking on the one model because you you already know the other model and they don't know the other model the the parents that are going to these meetings have students who are going to be coming into the middle school not that are in here or that have had kids in the Middle School the other people who don't know what a middle school is like they are listening to presentations about you'll have a new this you'll have a new that you'll have a new whatever without an understanding that you might not have a new one or if you do it won't be the big one

086that you're picturing it'll be a small one or you'll share with a place that you won't share 50/50 um and the pictures that we're seeing are pictures of like areas where students are sitting on couches chatting and and those kinds of things and it's it's misleading and I'm only saying this today because I've already said it to people from the team from not the Salem team from the the uh Consultants I've already said that on the design team I guess is the Architects I've already talked to them about it um and I've asked them to either present more information or don't present why we should go with the 9 through 12 and I sat through all the presentations listening basically to what parent concerns should be um why we should keep things separate um the

087other night at the uh the last one the uh consultant I'm sorry the design person I I'm the I'm struggling here because to me they were Architects and now they designed something and I just I keep getting the terms um I want to just keep saying architect so I'm just going to use that term one of the architects who came to present in Spanish which you know I appreciated but what she told the parents was that all eighth graders are um are afraid um they're they're very scared to go to the high school that they have to make new friends all over again to learn meet new people um she feels and I'm quoting um that we should do a 712 because it's it's better for students she feels that um it it's less frightening

088I mean it was like a we're not paying these folks to present what they feel about which which way we should go we're not looking for people to come in and scare our parents about why the kids are all going to be afraid all the eighth graders aren't afraid they're excited some of them are nervous but they're not afraid um by the vast majority but parents are hearing two things they're hearing you're going to have all these wonderful things but you better keep them separate and there's a lot of discussion of how to keep the kids separate at the new 7 to 12 if the focus is so important on how to keep them separate then why are we putting them together I'm missing this I don't understand not from an not from a a

089physical I mean I can design a building that's going to keep middle school students in one place in high school in another and never the twain shall meet but if the point we haven't focused on the point the point is either to get them together or to keep them apart do you know we're saying um you know I'm hearing parents say I be I can't wait till they build the middle school at the high school so I don't have to drive my daughter up to the high school to soccer practice anymore you want do you want your student on on a soccer team with high school but you don't want them in a corridor with high school do you want them to not come in a door yet it's okay to go to an advanced

090class I mean I don't think we've really looked at this what you know what are people really thinking saying when they're saying keep them separate and then they're saying get them up there to have them together and have more advantages it we we either have to talk about both or we shouldn't be talking about one or the other we can't wait to talk about what the Middle School needs at the high school until we've made the the decision and then go back to talk about what they need the conversations that have started with the high school folks on what do you need in your department what do you need need here what do you need there if we're going to build these buildings or one building at the same time they should be happening with

091this level too none of that is happening for the middle school students or the parents that it's only happening for high school and when is it going to happen if we if we vote next week or in two weeks then we retrofit getting information on what the Middle School needs and I don't think I don't think folks are um are get getting the the full scope of what they're what they think they're getting um we're paying these folks to design for us a building that's either 7 through 12 or 9 through 12 but I believe that there's a lot of um misunderstanding among some of the parents and it's probably some of the staff too because the presentations are unclear um I've heard I've heard Middle School um teachers saying well we've been told that

092we don't need to think about that yet because that'll all happen in the future well when is it going to happen in the future you know I mean when the future is what after we decide yeah we want to building but you know the the future we have to we have to talk about this now before we part of this issue I think the issue is that the vote I was surprised and I think some a lot of other folks were surprised that at the December meeting um Margaret from the msba announced that she wanted a decision by the end of December then she moved that to the end of January we thought we had to Le into the year you know that was a that's a big difference so now a lot of what

093probably should be talked about is not going to be um the quote you already know about 9 to 12 so we're not going to talk about 7 to you know it doesn't make sense to me um they've been you know references to having one principal um down the line I know that's down the line and folks say you know know that would that's just a POS possibility but people put possibilities in in people's heads and then pretty soon they come to fruition um I'm not sure why we're discussing the issue of um Middle School separately it it doesn't make sense to me it makes sense that we're um we we're either going to talk about the whole thing all all both levels and what both levels need we it's not a tag team where you

094add the middle school on after the fact and that's that's I have a lot of reasons I think it shouldn't happen but I also have a lot of concerns that it's going to it's going to happen without due diligence on the Middle School part of this are the people concerned about parking um right absolutely you already have you're going to have three schools up there if you put the Middle School up there the parking and the traffic are problems the common areas are going to be problems um one model they showed us this the high school had the this big front door main entrance and around the back of the design was this little door and it was the Middle School Entrance um is that equ quality not to me I you know I don't

095know I guess the issue is nobody has been able to give me a reason why with doing this other than these three answers so everything I've talked about is like problems I see and what's happening but my biggest problem is I don't understand why we're doing this one answer when I say why I've been told well because they share the CTE and the new areas of the building um middle school kids are 11 12 13 14 years old they don't need to share a brand new um state-of-the-art um Automotive or medical assisting or electricity any of that they need exposure to all of those they can do that in a middle school setting they don't need to be waiting for their turn to have a a time in the electrical room when they can have

096their own electrical room and take that as a subject at the middle school that all of that would change schedules it'll it'll uh depends on renovation depends on you know how much we would have to put into it here we're not even looking at it we're not even looking at what it would take to retrofit the technology education areas here which is CTE areas and what it would take to retrofit The Culinary areas here nobody's looked at that because the big jump is to get them to the high school so they can take one or two classes a week in these Ultra you know upto-date programs which I'm not saying we don't need and need for the high school but we don't need them for the Middle School the second reason people tell me why

097well there'll be more after school if there's more after school stuff more clubs and things how are they all going to fit you know know at one point the high school was coming down here to practice when I asked at one point about well why are we doing this for for the clubs one of the answers I got was and when I said well we're not going to have room for everybody one of the answers was well they can go down and use the Middle School gym you know where's the logic in this that we're moving a school and part of it is the concerns they can be up at the high school to use facilities when the answer is well they can be like on the team but they can come down to the

098Middle School to use the gym they had the Middle School gym fulltime now we'll saying take a walk down Highland a well the parent who doesn't want his kid walking on Highland a and wants to give him a ride now they're going to ride down Highland a you know the I don't know there's a big big push do we have the the the money it's it's because we have money to do the new building do we have to spend it on a 7 to 12 or account we just put that money into a 9 through 12 I know you can't take that money to retrofit fit here those two areas that needed but we could come up with it we don't have to put it all in in one year we have a lot of

099the stuff here we can use and keep adding to it back to close a building a middle school building which provides a climate a culture a schedule an organization of of Education 6 through 12 so that students can participate in activities and take CTE in a new um area because the money is there to do it it's only there to do it for the high school if we take that money to a building that we're going to add a middle school into it's not going to answer all these things that everyone thinks are going to come true it's going to be very difficult it's going to change the whole um the whole existential being of what a middle school is it's going to cause confusion it's going to cause um it's it's it's going to

100change you won't have a middle school you'll have a a a addon to the high school I know this I know it doesn't work well I know in in a lot of areas I you know I've been in Middle School a long time over all those years I talked with plenty of folks informally informally who um are in schools that were changed onto high school campuses in made 7 through 12 and if there's no reason to do it they would never have done it and and they don't like it um but you know I just I don't have anybody telling me what really is a good reason to do this and I see a lot of reasons we shouldn't do it and um this is not against our building committee or folks this is just

101against the whole idea I think is something that we're we're going down a road we shouldn't be going that's all other members member Campbell I had one quick question question um my um initial question that I had raised back at the retreat was around the accountability data and how the seven it might be I don't know if you have had a chance to look into it but around um the fact that our accountability um formulas compare like to like which means if we are a 7 to2 we are then only compared to other 7 to 12 um schools is my understanding and I just am wondering if that has been looked into in terms of um whether that may have some unintended consequences based on perhaps demographic variables of other 7 to 12s or um

102maybe some unintended perks obviously that's not like what the decision would rest on but I think it would be important for us to look into it um prior to making any decisions yeah I I believe the answer to that is it would be compared to other 7 12s but I would like to I I did not research that um I will call the accountability office and get that answer I so I to back up I I am I know that they are compared to other 7 to 12s what I'm wondering is what what does that do for us because now instead of being compared to such a large population of 9 to 12s we would then be compared to a very select number of schools that are 7 to 12s I don't know how many

103there are across the state but I know that there are significantly fewer than 9 to 12 and so again like what and I know you know obviously Lynn has a 7 to 12 and I know when we look at our accountability data it it is very very different when you look at that particular school um and so just you know really doing our due diligence around that not again not that it would make or break a decision for me at least but I think it would be important for us to know what that means going into it I can get you that information thank you remember Cruz my my questions are process related uh I think one of the things that happened at the retreat we had talked about receiving um uh a couple of

104follow-up from the the design firm uh just with respect to Committee Member questions around um the two different designs and if something could be put together for us to take a look at um I hadn't seen if that had come through I'm having trouble with my emails but um I think Dr Z you had mentioned that you'd you'd follow up on that for us and then the the second piece was I think we had referenced um uh around the decision Point um opportunities for members of the committee to go and visit um um the previous uh designs um of the the firms or folks that have gone through the process and I was just wondering uh for clarification purpose did we say that that's something that would happen post a vote prior to a vote

105um and if it's if it's post a vote I think it would just be great to get the list uh as folks are doing their like final rounds of due diligence um just so that way um if we needed to make our own inquiries into some of those we could and then add additionally um I guess the we're at the 21st now this is being proposed for the third so it would just be good to get a pulse check from the full committee about uh whether or not the third is the appropriate interval for us to be able to do this and folks to finalize whatever due diligence they have to do or if we should push it to the second uh meeting in February or as member Manning mentioned we said we had more

106time so I just I guess I'm trying to figure out timeline wise where folks are at with this um because I I would hate to come to the meeting on the third and then folks wanting to either push back or anything like that so um those would be the the three uh clarifying questions I have about process um so I'll take the last one and then I don't know if you want to address the others but um uh I I've asked the superintendent we're going to put this on for for the February 3rd agenda that that we've we've worked backwards from a timeline through the msba process that you know even even pushing this to the to a February meeting was uh I think shortening the time frame within which the design team has to

107work to meet certain deadlines with msba I wouldn't want to push it even further into February so my my intention is to keep this on the agenda for February 3rd Dr Z did you want to yeah on the um on the other two questions I'm not sure I understood the first question that you what you're looking for around designs can you just can I had posed a question to the designers about um whether or not they could roll something to us about the um configurations and they I remember they had this AA about well we can't get you uh I think super detailed information that's not what I was looking for I was looking just for some high level information about some of their work okay around the due diligence and that was that's what

108I was looking for you mean other yep projects they've worked on or this project other projects worked on that's right the actual you want to actually see the design I did yes want to see the design um and then the question about visiting the schools I know my conversation with members of the committee or we had discussed um doing that after you know as we you know as you get closer to designing with the building to visit schools if the dec depending what the decision that the committee makes we do have a I can provide you with a list I do have a list of all the s to 12 in so I'd be asking for both for a list of the S to 12 and then the 9 through 12 that have recently gone

109through the msba process just so that way as I'm doing my own due diligence I can just make some of my a list of the 9 to 12 set have gone through the just in the area okay in the area yeah yeah don't go Statewide please okay not giving you busy work no I think I that that's the the project manager should be able to get us that information pretty easily thank you charlee I hope you got that I hope you got all those notes down because I'm not sure I'm going to remember my be able to read my notes tomorrow so all right Miranda I just wanted to ask so are we going to talk about what our plans are or like what members ideas are for the grade configuration like we've heard the

110concerns around six we've previously talked about um options around prek and kindergarten and I think it would be helpful to have like some Plan before making this decision yeah so I think that this is the platform in the time to to talk about members concerns around configuration we heard from Member Manning pretty clearly there I you know I I'm coming down in a place where I think that a grade 7 through 12 building does make sense I share the concerns around um the sixth grade and what the you know the future um uh plan for the sixth grade is but I don't think that should that I think that this is not a decision that we make and then tomorrow the building is done and we we start the school year without anything for the

111sixth graders we have literally several years to develop that to develop our thinking around what what you know what the Future model is going to be the facility master plan does lay out I think a very strong concept for um for a configuration of a 7 through 12 building and then um 1 through six for elementary schools and a centralized prek-k facility which we've discussed I think before um as a potential future model for this District um I I also share member Manning's concerns around not not wanting to uh create this building and then be scrambling last minute to think about how we have a program that supports 7th and eighth graders having Equitable access to the facilities in that building for their programs their extracurriculars um but I also believe that we have we

112have time and we have the expertise in our district to have a a solid program for that before the building is operational and that the timing for decisions that the design team need to have locked in place around whether they're proposing a 7 through 12 or a 9 through 12 building does necessitate us having to make some of these decisions now um cell I think I I'm not sure that I necessarily want to raise this because I don't know that I necessarily want it to be a discussion point for tonight but I do feel a little uncertain about the comment around 6th grade standards that I I feel like I almost just want to flag and maybe it's something we need to have maybe just for standards nerds like myself but I I hearing member

113Miranda raise it as a concern I my own understanding of the standards is that Ela is a key anchor standard that builds from prek all the way through 12 so the vertical alignment on the La side of things is always the same from one grade to the next grade to the next grade there is no such thing as one being more aligned than the other the math standards and I double checked the coherence map to sanity check myself math standards are more closely aligned to fifth grade than they are to seventh grade science is a bit of a mixed bag it's really only social studies that they're really closely coupled with um and and so I just don't that's my understanding of it so I don't want there to be this perception that all of

114the sixth grade standards align with seventh grade standards they in many cases equally align with Fifth and seventh with the exception of social studies so I I think just a point that I would flag for possible consideration for future I'd want to do my own sanity checking on my own thinking of it so you have some homework to do yes got that all down well I mean my answer to this uh I mean a lot of it's never about the building it's always about how we the design and I I never think schools are going to be defined by the um by the grade configuration I think we um whatever is done whatever decision is made is going to require you know careful planning if it's regardless if it's a 7 to 12 or 9

115to2 UM in a design for the new space I I think there are some good questions here to to answer I don't think anything I don't think there's a bad decision that can be made here I think we have to do what's in the best interest of this community in this moment in time uh there are a lot of considerations um and anything that's different is scary for people for sure um but at the but um I think you have to weigh you know the context here the size of our District what the needs are of the kids we serve um I'm not I I'm not concerned either way with what the decision uh you know there's going to be have to be extensive planning but we're also five probably six seven years away from

116opening the new building and I know that'll come sooner than later but there's ample time to plan for whatever's next um as I said before I do think we have work to do uh with uh continuity between the Great levels um and the the alignment between our middle and high school which is not where it needs to be right now um and so I will get you all the information I let me just clarify I have a question here about accountability data list of 7 to 12s and then recent 9 to 12s in the area there's questions about um configuration um what the design could look like is what I'm hearing Mana you're looking for that and then I think Amanda you're bringing up questions about curriculum in the Ali and so I'd have to

117connect with my our academics folks which I see nodding over there just to get their uh feedback on the specific um content areas and what their um Reflections are so I can I can provide all of that to you in the next week or so and ultimately it's going to be up to the committee about when they want to vote but I know there is a time is of the essence as um the designers need to know which direction we're going um you know I no later than the beginning of February that's what we've been told all right um I do um I just want to share uh there are we are getting questions um regarding um just want to pull up my uh regarding immigration and I just want to make uh a comment

118about that because I think it's really important um we're working on getting clear guidance to staff um about um what you know to the extent where immigration officials come to schools and I know just today there was some um information about um the ban being lifted about coming in and around schools which is very concerning to me um as an educator um and at this point we have guided all our school leaders to direct officials to my office and to our legal team well our legal team is our attorney we don't have a legal team um although sometimes I have to I feel like I play a legal team but we um we have an attorney that we speak to um but as a reminder the Salem public schools does not ask for any immigration

119status from current or perspective students and we do not keep that data we don't care it's not important to us we enroll who comes to our door and we enroll them as soon as possible into our schools um and we believe that schools are protected locations despite some of the messaging uh that has gone out um because and places that immigration officials should avoid um our schools are not going to we will not allow our schools to be places where um immigration officials feel like they can take liberties with our students so I just want to make that clear we do have work to do to give more guidance to our uh staff who have been asking for that and to give our families um you know that information um as well and so we

120are uh Laura sad is on Zoom but we are preparing an information session for uh some of our newcomer families in in the next week or so um so I just wanted to make that point uh and there's obviously um I have a question as I we're looking at these um requests to go out of Massachusetts to do um good question school things how are we going to protect those students and also our LBGTQ I plus students that are going to run into problems with bathrooms um locker rooms or also potentially not being okay to be who they are and how do we protect them um if they use a different name or go by a different gender like these are all thoughts these are all my concerns of being responsible for children in our

121city to go to a different like we really need to research what their safety is yeah I I it's just pathetic that we have to have these conversations um but I you're right and thank you for asking that question I don't have a good answer for you right now and I'd be muddling through some bad response so um but I I thank you for raising that and I will be sure to uh provide Direction because I'm sure those are questions that our staff is going to have because I do believe our staff feels very strongly has a lot of the same values we do and they're going to be very concerned about um putting any of our children In Harm's Way uh whether it's in the state or um but obviously there's more concern when

122you leave a state like Massachusetts Cruz thank you Dr Dr for uh including this in your superintendent report I was going to say something about this during announcements uh with the priority enforcements uh changing and then additionally uh the resending of the 2012 memo that uh created the protections for schools churches and other um sensitive locations um uh what I would uh say to you superintendent is that uh immigration law and anti-discrimination law I think requires um maybe some external support Beyond school committee Council uh so I'd be happy to connect you with Folks at the Massachusetts immigrant and Refugee Association and then some of the other Statewide legal groups like Lis for civil rights um ACLU Etc um I do think it is a kind of all handson deck to understand what's going to

123be coming out of the federal Administration um and there's um some of these organizations miror in particular on the immigration front they're already hosting um know your rights um events and sending out materials to school districts to try to help and advise them through this period so um I'd be happy to send out that information and to share those contacts with all members of the committee uh just so that you all have those at your fingertips in the event that you do get questions uh from members of the the community or Educators or even our students so yeah thank you i' certainly take any of those uh we do have a couple of um uh Statewide um webinars coming up specifically about this to topic with the Department of Education and with um The Association

124of school superintendents and Laura Assad has been very good about starting to put us in touch and we're trying to um accumulate in as much information as possible this is unart well it is unchartered for sure because this feels different than it did uh the last time around and so um but again you have access to a lot of information that we don't have so I would appreciate that thank you member Cornell I think once um once you and member Cruz can kind of like Get Like take the Pulse a little bit in the coming weeks I think it would be worth having a committee of the whole meeting to really take a look at where we need to have strong language in our policies or um you know the way the ways in which

125this body can reaffirm for our Educators and District leaders that we support them um you know in helping to make our students feel safe and respected and um but some of the like what member Hoffman brought up you know which is like yeah what's going to happen we're we're going to approve students to leave the state to to go places and what can can we protect them should we be allowing talking to families about whether or not is a good idea for students to go to Florida um you know so those are those are conversations that I think that that we a conversation that we can have as a body when we have a little bit more information um I will say that member Hoffman and member Miranda and I last night attended a forum

126on lgbtq Joy and the lieutenant governor was there and um uh Paul Tucker was there and they were helpful in in making I I felt a little bit better about the laws in place in Massachusetts and so I asked um uh lieutenant governor Driscoll if she would be willing to come and if we had a cow maybe talk to us a little bit about um you know where you know where we can sort of beef ourselves up and where we're doing okay and and just you know counsel us on how to protect our kids yeah certainly um and I know Laura is very immersed in this work and I think we can we plan to do something for our families uh I believe it's by by the end of January um we had we were

127hoping to do something for families so we'll we certainly can come back to you I think it is worth having more of a conversation thank you for asking that question member Hoffman I think that um I hadn't thought about it like that and that's really helpful um we should be thinking about those things so thank you um member Manning can you just CL clarify um are you talking by the end of January for um families um on LBGTQ issues or families on immigration immigration okay here I I just offer to members of the committee if you want to reach out to uh me on an individual email basis about particular requests from uh different types of subject manner experts about what might be coming uh down the pike from the federal Administration just send me

128kind of your topic areas and then I'm happy to put time into um put together a pretty solid and comprehensive list I just have one more um thing is tomorrow night is our um Early Childhood Expo um start time Kim is 6 6:30 uh where we our our entire team presents to families who are interested in the Salem public schools we're very excited to welcome uh new amilies to our all our uh Early Childhood programs threeyear olds four year olds and 5year olds uh it's overwhelming at first but uh then we follow that up with an inperson meeting here at Collins which is the week after um and so it's tomorrow night 6:30 on Zoom uh we hope to see uh please share with your neighbors and friends and folks who you know have little

129kids at home who are interested in coming to school we've done a really good job this year uh Laura and the family engagement facilitators have reaching out to the Early Childhood um our early childhood Partners as well as home dayc carees as well and child care uh locations so that we um hope to have a good turnout for families at this event so just again uh tomorrow night uh we uh we will be showcasing all the good work that's happening across the Salem public schools in early childhood so uh with that mayor I think there's some transfers on here Elizabeth yeah uh just so uh folks who might have the agenda to know the enrollment targets update will be provided at the next meeting because the data is not available yeah the the reason behind

130that is the state had said they were going to publish the data for um uh lwi income um by last Thursday and they did not and I even though we know it internally I don't we I want to keep consistent with the data point we've used every years which is des's published October 1 data and so because we don't have That official data yet um I can't uh present it until we have that um final so that will be on next uh month's or next uh meeting's agenda and then the next item is uh transfers uh good evening there was a memo in the packet about a few transfers that I am bringing to this body for your approval um I noted that in most cases these trans ERS are moving from expense line to

131Personnel lines which is why I am bringing them to this group it has been the practice to um note for the committee when money moves from non-personnel to Personnel um technically all of these are moving from non-personnel to Personnel but in two instances they were the funds were always intended for um Personnel expenses and were budgeted to a nonperson line so that is the HR stiens there's a $20,000 transfer recommended from contracted services to stiens those are for the talent finder it was always intended to be a stipend and it was budgeted to the contracted Services line so that is a cleanup the second one is similar there is a $9,000 um it's the last one on the memo a $9,000 transfer recommended from Horseman contracted services to um a paraprofessional line and that is

132to pay to subsidize the salary of the lunch paraprofessional which was part of last year's budget process and it was budgeted to contracted Services instead of a salary line the other uh stiens are adjustments that are being recommended midyear based on what each uh either department or school has anticipated for yearend uh stien costs so either because there were additional events and additional um cause for professional development that for which employees receive stiens or because there is more work uh than had been originally planned so these other three the first from it the third from New Liberty and the fourth from Carlton reflect either the department head or the principal's recommendation based on where they can move money to provide stiens for staff so I am asking for your approval to make these uh transfers

133any questions member chis just so I'm clear um and I think we have one department head here from it uh so with respect to the Tech Supplies being transferred those would go to stiens for staff that are part of um the IT team yes okay so that is within the it cost center but it's going from non-personnel to personnel which is why it's here um and so just on the table thank you for the question I should have just oriented you to it on the left hand side it's the department the second column from the left is the where the money is going to um and then as you go over it's where the money is coming from so so I understand that that is a just a shift in where the priorities should lie

134um I guess just with that one in particular because it's Tech Supplies um is it anticipated that we'll have enough to cover everything we need in the budget without this 5.3 all right just wanted to get the reassurance thank you that's it for me thank you thank you any other questions uh the last two items I think we talked about the M we talked about the msba quite a bit um about the grade configuration and finance and operations report I don't believe we have any other than the transfers that were just requested so that concludes my comments mayor uh subcommittee report rep s anything from subcommittee's policy uh we at the request of the larger committee the policy subcommittee reviewed the Marine Corp Junior Reserve officer training Court memorandum of agreement and uh it does

135not require a vote but uh the three members of the subcommittee recommend that the superintendent signs uh the memorandum of agreement with the Marine corpse uh I would also just note that it's the perspective of the mayor and the city solicitor that having a rifley range at the high school violates the city ordinance against weapons in public buildings and so that not that ordinance which one it's the ordinance prohibiting air rifles oh thank you uh the ordinance prohibiting air rifles uh and so then that is out of school committee hands and something that um the next step is for the city to uh bring that to the attention of the Marine Corps cool they're going to respond great I bet uh the other thing that I just want to put on people's radar which does

136not require a vote uh is we've been uh asking for a while for some updates from uh the Hall of Fame committee and they did a lot of work and so they they have two uh proposed amendments to their bylaws which are in our opinion good proposals that uh we recommend they move forward with the first is to amend a bylaw the non-discrimination bylaw where in wherein they and I will just say to school committee members I just sent you the wrong version of this um because we changed some of the language they they made a little mistake around Title 9 um but effectively they want to give special consideration to women when considering people to induct into the Hall of Fame because Title 9 uh made it difficult for women to participate in sports

137uh I'm sorry schools made it difficult for women to participate in high school sports prior to 1972 so that's one of their charges is when considering New Hall of Fame members and then the second piece of this is that um as part of their kind of rubric for analyzing uh candidates they also have created a legacy level of the Salam High Hall of Fame uh which basically retires uh a uniform for um you know and it's framed and hung in Salem High School for exceptional uh graduates and so um we don't have any women in that category at the moment I think there are a lot of us who have a particular woman in mind that uh will be that person uh and so again this doesn't require a vote you can you can uh

138I'll I'll have uh I'll ask Charley to resend the one that I edited uh with the language to everybody so that you can see it uh but again we think that this should go forward we think these are good changes and it really does doesn't require a vote I don't know if either of you want to add anything to it uh I just would add that um when when I've inquired about um you know how do I get the form to fill out to nominate someone to the Legacy level um there is um the ad's answer has been we need things okay by the school committee so hopefully this will just move this all along and I think this this is that this is that moment because they they ask for a vote but we

139don't it doesn't really require a vote it just sort of is our you know um yeah we discussed it and and think that they're doing a good job so I can get that tomorrow morning yeah they this is their green light to move forward with the materials I think so I'd just like to uh express my gratitude to the athletic director and the Athletics committee for all the work that they did to put this together it was no small feat we gave them a pretty big task and uh we were having a lot of conversations about um the future of sports within the district and I certainly want to thank member Cornell for all of the leg work that you've done uh both in the policy subcommittee to Shepherd this conversation but then additionally your

140direct engagement with those stakeholders and I know uh member Manning and I were doing our own due diligence on the side to kind of just check on how things were working um so it really was a a I'd say a districtwide kind of effort um so you know I think they landed at a really good place in terms of a process uh and hopefully we'll be able to celebrate some of the um untold stories here in Salem High School's illustrious uh Sports history yeah and I I would also just like to um uh thank Bob gizell who was the previous athletic director who I had several conversations with and and he was helpful in trying to remember and go back and research things that were sort of not on paper around you know so I

141just acknowledge Him and Peter Dolan any other subcommittee reports no all right um motions and resolutions we have um policy 5103 second reading I move to appro approve policy 5103 controlled Choice Student Assignment policy for a second read second second motion made by member Cornell second by member Cruz all in favor any opposed the matter carries um calendars and enrollment targets were deferring correct yeah we're going to defer yep uh then is there a motion to approve the proposed budget transfers midyear budget transfers no moved second motion made by member Campbell seconded by member Manning all in favor any opposed none opposed the matter carries any announcements is this the old res the old uh announcements and resolutions category or something like when can I ask a question you can could I could I ask

142that in in his um report the mark the student rep U mentioned that the configuration had come up at discussion at their meeting and that um he felt you know the majority of the kids were in favor of the 9 through 12 could we could the school committee like see that in more detail more like like do you take notes at those do you do you have any reference of like what they were so about when they when you I don't have have any like specific notes from the meeting but I mean I don't need it right now I just wanted if you could provide us with something so next time we meet um next Monday I can definitely put in a like topic we can Dr Z we can put on the agenda for

143everyone well that's that's your meeting I'm not I'm not at those so you're in charge of the agenda the next one would be the 47th no like the one I meet with you oh that one's on uh February February 3rd okayu you could you guys could discuss it next Monday if you want yeah okay could you get it to us before then then before the third then mhm I can certainly bring it up thank you those are fors oh the dates yeah you have them right there you bring it up on your meeting the so I'll share the uh get get it to us somehow District's budget forums for the public been scheduled for uh Tuesday February 4th from 6:00 to 7:30 at the high school and then Monday February 10th from 6:00 to 7:30

144on zoom and then there's a separate one for staff only uh we're starting to engage tomorrow night we no uh Thursday night we're meeting with the parent advisory group so we will be talking to them about uh the budget um as well so the the process Now we move into the budget um input phase so that's um yeah so that we hope to see as many people there the fors but I'll also be engaging with teacher advisory parent advisory and the student advisory as well great when you meeting with when do you me with the parent advisory Thursday night yeah yes would you like to come I would just as a finance you know thanks sure all right no further announcements to adjourn I'll second motion made by member Cruz second by member Miranda all

145in favor any oppos the matter carries we are Jour thank you everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.