CorpusRecord 121632

Scituate School Committee Meeting - 02-10-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Scituate Community Television
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Plymouth County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,493 words · about 59 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001thanks okay the citu school committee is committed to providing an environment of respect during meetings we ask all members to interact in a polite manner even when there is disagreement we value the participation of our community and want all participants including marginalized and minoritized communities to feel welcomed and respected we ask our committee members and all who participate to commit to these standards to support and respect our community uh let's call the February 10th 2025 C school committee meeting to order here at 6:01 uh and we'll do a roll call Vote barosi Yes here hello benwick yes Gates yes randini yes L blam yes Al righty thank you uh let's begin with public comment we have no participants in person so I will look to Virtual hands I see one hand raised uh um I

002can [Music] you how's that she hi can you hear me yes perfectly clear wait hi everyone um been a while and I saw that school calendar was up again for discussion I did listen in the January 27th recording I first actually wanted to make a comment on the recordings it took me a little bit in a call to Nicole to find out where I could find the recordings easily so I was wanted to request if with the agendas and minutes it would be possible to link the um YouTube recordings to the s.org page to make it easy to find so that was a little comment on that before I move on to the school calendar um I think everyone in the room probably knows how I feel because I've spoke before about the school calendar

003and before and after Labor Day and I appreciate that some of you Maria and Nicole brought up on the January 27th meeting some of the points that I've brought up in the past about um the start time and I've tried to look at this objectively with pros and cons of what is better for our district as a whole and I'm actually having a hard time finding Pros for for starting after Labor Day as from an educational standpoint what I've read on a post even on situate mom's page people were talking about the weather is better I want to take my family vacation time when it's less busy but I'm not seeing valid reasons education Ally of why we need to start after Labor Day when our counterparts um in the in the state as well

004as across the country are starting earlier and getting in those days um I just feel like September learning is more beneficial to our students and teachers versus June learning when all of those spring tests have already happened so I would love to hear I know you brought it up in the last meeting about teachers and what they say I'd love to hear if um that's going to be touched on tonight on the discussion of what the teachers say about fresh brains at the beginning of the school year vers June I I think that's really important again we in the past couple years we have the juneth which falls into um place which the rest of the state and the rest of the country may not have to deal with that we do as well as

005data on how many fall athletes do we actually have at situ High School those are the types of things I hope I we can hear tonight when that's discussed um the amount of fall athletes the amount of um even psycho football and cheerleaders who are practicing and already in town um as well as absences how many absences have we had when we have a half a day in June verse um after the juneth so I'm I'm looking to hear some of that data tonight but more importantly what are the other towns in Massachusetts doing do we have the data on that but other than that I think the the um I even looked in the um KFC pool is already closed in that last week of August so I even went to as far as

006let me check that calendar and sure enough the past few years that that pool is even closed because those College lifeguards are gone so we don't have the camps available we do not have the um uh the babysitters here Etc but I think most of it was touched upon at the last um meeting so um I'll leave it at that but I just wanted to to chime in and um put some comments in there before you discuss that tonight so I appreciate you all and thank you very much all right thank you Miss wiro noted I took I took a couple notes and I think we probably will touch on a lot of those points so uh thank you again all right uh not seeing any other hands raised remotely let us move on to

007our student report okay thank you for having me I would like to begin with a sports update um so congratulations to a wrestling team for winning our Patriot league title um which was highlighted by being the Plymouth South team who had not lost a league since 2011 and principal Ranger noted that he was Plymouth South's coach for 29 years so he is happy for the sailors feeling a sense of remorse for his old team seems like they're struggling now that he is gone um congratulations to the boys hockey team for winning at least a share of the Patriot league title and good luck as they move on to tournaments and this past Saturday was the winter track League meet congratulations to Jack deondra Grayson Foley Tyler Morrison and Ben Roach for setting a new school

008record for the 4x200 Grace Taylor for placing first place in the high jump and Lauren Thompson for throwing 386 in the shot put in Auto qualifying for Nationals that is quite the accomplishment and um on February 12th this week we will have stepup night for 8th grade caregivers um which will be run by the counseling department and they'll host a presentation for parents to prepare them for their students attending high school next year and also on Wednesday the counseling department will offer an armed service vocational aptitude battery test um battery for any students interested in this unique opportunity and furthermore this past week the English AP mock exams took place and another round is scheduled for February 12th um thank you to miss mesner for all of her hard work for making this happen and

009one furthermore we collected another survey of surrounding Wind Block data um 10th 11th and 12th graders share their input Administration asked two questions for do you feel Wind Block is useful 79.9% of students said yes and do you feel Wind Block should be longer 98.1% said yes and that is all I have for you guys today any questions is Wind Block still the same it hasn't changed no it's 39 minutes thank you thank you only because I was there but the um check swim team is that self sectionals girls on Saturday Boys on Sunday but committing and I think the girls are pretty good we had I think a second place second or third place for a freshman oh Bella yes she also set a School record I believe she set a new school record

010she did at one of the meets against Mar yeah yeah yeah yes sorry Miss sorry I was there so thank you you no I'm okay well just about Li block it's okay yeah well I guess I was just curious um just to clarify um in one block students are completely self-directed during that time um I if I believe as a teacher you can make your student like you can schedule them in your room if they're like struggling your class or need to make up a test but students are supposed to schedule themselves for the week where they see best but a teacher could intervene basically and put them in the class so like for an example you might like visit one teacher on Monday and a different teacher on Tuesday and when you go to

011their class what happens um some teachers will do like I know back when I took chemistry like some teachers offer like additional material it like lectures mini lectures um some teachers will help you go over test if you didn't do too well on it yeah um some kids just like to chat with their teachers kind of depends yeah thank you that's what I thought I was just kind of trying to remind myself of how it looks at the high school level thank you you're welcome thank you Nicole I know I know we'll talk about it later when we bring up the school calendar but I thought this was appropriate time to also just give a shout out to the high school and the article that came out and the situation I just love once again

012we're we're bringing student voice so to miss with r's point about voice um if she hasn't seen that article I I would highly recommend reading it it really does talk about how the students feel about the change in the calendar so just just wanted to point out that as another resource great Point absolutely scary all right of our leadership report is Dr or maybe everyone thank you so we've presented at the um hearing initially to the school committee and to the Community um and uh last week we presented the U revised uh budget FY 26 budget with feedback from school committee um and the community and this evening we're looking for a vote so um Dr R has anything to add we'll turn it back over to the school committee and just uh as a

013reminder for folks uh tomorrow night uh Dr R and I will be presenting before the select board approximately 7:30 8 p.m. and on Thursday night we'll be presenting before The Advisory Board which uh meets virtually at 6:30 I believe so if folks are interested on um writing more feedback and getting another opportunity to look at that presentation live those are two more opportunities that we will be doing that also we'll be presenting our U Blue Book at town meeting uh that will be a comprehensive kind ofm summary once it's approved um to share with the community to give them um in layman's terms kind of what each aspect that the budget brings some of those numbers to life and um with with words and numbers and hopefully a way that's articulated so that the non-

014educator can understand I think we've had good success with that so that's also another um access point where the community can get a hold of those information and finally to the community that's watching or that eventually watches us um you know the process goes right till Tom meeting so you have any questions concerns this will be all be posted uh it's a lot of information so it might take some time to digest we'd be happy to speak with anyone in our community about um anything on our budget but I think one of the things we pride ourselves on is the transparency of our budget so we're again happy to have any conversations with our community members staff about our budget and um open that up to the community so thank you thank you super bad

015anything else no thank you just to Echo that point and to say that last week's presentation is online so anybody take a look at it all right uh any comments or further anything um just when when is the earliest time that the that the um books will be available for the community I should have them by the first week in March okay and are we that we in the central office to pick up are we going to provide them any place else like the library or to typically I have them at Town Hall I certainly put them in the library as sure and I just want to um just hearing bits and pieces from surrounding communities the difficulties they're having with their budgets I want to thank you for having this you know no override

016no just a great budget yes no Cuts thank you else all right we'll take a motion on the FY 26 budget can I just offer something sorry Nicole I was trying to get yes no go right ahead um so I I wanted to Echo what Janna said too I've appreciated having multiple meetings being able to sit with it and the dialogue that we've had back and forth both with the schools but also as a committee it's been a really good conversation I'm certainly in support of this budget for all the reasons Janice said and more I just would love as we move forward to think about as we present for next year thinking about data and like not just making the case for what you want for next year but showing us you know early

017what what the payoff was I know we've talked a lot about Roi so like maybe Tom and and Ryan you know some of the preliminary PR presentation of the budget for next year could be a presentation of the ROI um I just really want to see that it's not going to stop my vote tonight I just want to keep talking about that and see how we can can do that thank you for saying that if I could comment I actually plan on putting some of that information in the blue book so heard it loudly great thanks Dr marosi great Point um all right take a vote if no one else has any added comment fire I make a motion that the school committee vote to approve the FY 26 budget as present second all right

018uh roll call Vote bosi Yes benwick Yes Gates yes L blam yes brandolini yes all right and fantastic okay up next uh we have a teaching and learning update missula our world language Department CH people people home Ides with the arrows all right great so thank you so much for having me this evening I have to say honestly this is one of my favorite nights because I love talking about teaching and learning and I'm really proud of the work we're doing in World Language and I think you're going to see that tonight the other thing I want to say is I think it will be abundantly clear to you throughout this presentation that the work we are doing is so closely aligned with our strategic plan with our school goals at gates with our school

019goals at the high school with our superintendent goals so you're going to hear things about rigorous curriculum you're going to hear about um excellent instruction you are going to hear benchmarking assessments and helping students grow throughout this entire presentation so what are we working on not a whole lot of brand new initiatives we're still refining and tweaking things that we implemented over the past couple of years so we continue to award the seala by literacy um which is the Massachusetts designation which you've heard me talk about a thousand times because I just love it and I love this little chart that that's up there for you to see because we are on this amazing upward trajectory we have come a really long way since 2021 that growth is exceptional so last year class of 2024

020we awarded 17 students on stage with the Sealab by literacy medal this year it will be at least 19 we are still collecting some final scores from from the lovely week of mid years where everybody fell ill with the flu um but we're at at least 19 students in the class of 2025 um what is new this year was I had an awesome opportunity to collaborate with our uh director of supplemental Services Miss Ward and we submitted a grant to the state and we we were awarded the grant luckily and so we're going to be able to expand our stamp testing opportunity to our eighth grade students which we're really excited about it's not that we anticipate that our eighth graders will qualify for the sale of by literacy there's still a little ways away

021from that but we now have a piece of data um that will tell us how effective our middle school program is because we spent three solid years on a novice program and it will be great to look at that data and see if the slow roll out and approach is actually effective with students in addition we may moving forward have a piece of data that will help us make informed decisions about placement for students in ninth grade right now we use a grade book and it's fine but it's not the best and so having another piece of data with a cut off score will really refine that practice of recommending for either the honors or CP level one of the things that's come out of that Grant is we are serving on the World Language

022advisory team for the state of Massachusetts right now which I remember saying to you last year I really felt like we were on the brink of putting the C of public schools we a language department on the map and this is the type of work that will put us on the map collaborating with districts hearing what they're doing sharing what we're doing um has really been a rewarding experience it's been extremely validating um I had a meeting last Friday with the state the center of Applied Linguistics in Washington DC attended and um it was really fun when when they were asking us questions and talking to us about how we afford and how we got teachers on board to do proficiency instruction and the growth and our cutup scores and all those things they're like

023this is the stuff we need to see more of in the state so I I feel really good about the work that we're doing and and that the state is even recognizing that as well we are also new this year working with Avant assessment Avant is the company that sponsors the um stamp test um so we're working with them to do some professional development which will help our teachers calibrate their scores so we know exactly at this point in the year we're almost wrapping that professional development up we know exactly what they're looking for for cut off scores for certain proficiency levels we had teachers on their own grade the midar assessments to see if they were in agreement with the Raiders from Avon and we had high levels of cor correlating scores between what

024Avant was scoring our students at and what our teachers were rating their students so that was really good um the next level of professional development we'll do this year is powering up strategies so we have this whole half of the year and we have all of this stamp data how are we going to help these students grow how can we push them forward and so we're going to spend a day with reps from Avon learning what those powering up strategies would be we continue to offer our Pathways designation in global citizenship um in full disclosure this is not an Innovations pathway program like the one in business and environmental science and the only reason for that is simply because the state doesn't have one yet so that's another piece of work that we're doing with

025the World Language advisory team at the state level and the other great thing about that is when Mr rer and I collaborated on that initiative we were lock in step with we need to have required courses we need to have additional courses what what number of credits would constitute a pathway designation um additional outside of school extracurriculars that link to the topic of the pathway program a Capstone or an internship so we have the same requirements um so if the state and when the state is ready situate Public Schools is in a great position to have an additional pathway um designation with the state another new thing this year is we are offering dual enrollment to our ninth graders in their level two Spanish courses this year um we're offering the dual enrollment through quinsey

026college um and we'll expand that to French and Mandarin um as we progress through this was just a trial year to see how it went so ninth graders that complete successfully complete their Spanish two course could receive college credits for doing so current ninth graders yes yep um and then you hear hear all about our exchanges and our trips and um you hear about them through the approval process but you never get to really hear about them on the tail end on the back end but they continue to be extremely successful probably one of the most rewarding pieces of the work that I do with the students and the teachers here um it's funny because I was thinking about this on my drive here today and I was thinking if back in 2020 or 2021

027you would ask me if I would if I thought we would see the Spanish exchange again and the French exchange again I I wouldn't have been able to look you in the eyes and say that confidently yes we would and not only have we brought those programs back but we're expanding so we're off to China on Friday um we've brought back the Quebec trip and you know Ireland is brand new so we're in an even better place than we were five years ago wanted to talk quickly about the data the stamp testing data that I talked about when I mentioned the Seal of bi literacy that we continue to award um I'll do everything I can to stay seated I get so excited when I see charts and numbers and um so I apologize but

028I'm so inclined to like get up and point so in the right hand corner of the screen you'll see Advance stamp testing scale those are proficiency levels when we graduate students from the CIT public schools and they've been doing World Language since sixth grade we want to see them at at least a six so that's an intermediate High student that I told you last year correlates to like a four on the AP exam that's very very strong so what you have in in front of you and you saw this last year this is our Target end ofe composite scores for our stamp test broken down by level starting with level one at the bottom and then our highest level AP at the top so those are our end ofe Target scores you can see our

0292023 data our 2024 data and this year's brand new data 2025 which is about I would say 95% complete we're still working on getting a couple of kids scores in and completed but what's exceptional and something to highlight is that those are middle of the Year scores we have decided as a department to administer the stamp test in the middle of the year because it allows us time to process and look at student growth and provide interventions and enhancements in the classroom to ensure that all of our students are growing I've had conversations with Mr Lynch about like well maybe we do want to do it at the end of the year because maybe we would see more students getting the Seal of ey literacy but I admire that my teachers push back about that

030and they say Kate if we can do it in the middle of the year we have a whole half of the year to push kids even further and to have conversations about our programming 6 through 12 so it's important to see that overall our middle of the Year composite scores are just about so meeting and in some situations exceeding our end ofe Target which is great sometimes falling short but only by like a tenth or or a 20th right is that the right place value hundred 100 100 that's what it is right you know what you mean you know what I mean this is why I do a world 10 place yes okay um my God thank God all right yeah this is embar yeah is thank God someone knows in the room um okay

031so that's that's something we're that we're really really proud of the other thing I want to highlight for is and I think I was transparent about this last year one of the challenges that we've identified in the department is that our kids become stuck in this intermediate level sophomores get stuck and that is something that happens in any language um acquisition process and we get stuck in the intermediate mean I think you remember with your own children like they started off learning language and it was ridiculous they're picking up words every day and growing so much and then we kind of level out a little bit and so that happens naturally but we were seeing that our level three students weren't doing um as well as we thought they could and so that's an area

032that we're seeing a little bit of growth in this year which I'm really happy because the teachers have really worked on the curriculum and the instruction for that course okay three is nth grade yeah three is 10 yes three is 10 um okay and it's not all lollipops and lovelies um we do have some areas of growth and so I wanted to share with you our AP data um our enrollment is steady but it could be better we would love to see more students opting for the AP level class in full disclosure and then we saw a dip in our scores this year and um there were some reasons for that um we had to offer one of our AP courses online this year and then we had a staffing situation we had a staff

033who needed to go out on leave and we end up going through two substitutes in the amount of time that she was out um no one's fault at all but just a lot of transition for the students right and so um that could be a reason why we saw some changes in our AP score so be interested to track that um again this year but this is definitely an area of focus for us as we um continue to work on just getting better and better um so what's next um we as a department set out a student learning goal this year that was to take our stamp data and track individual student growth so instead of just looking at that chart that you got to see here now we want to look at student by

034student and how much growth students are achieving year to year and so that's each teachers um each 9 through 12th grade teachers student learning goal for the year and they've gone about that in a variety of different ways but I ironically what's funny is they've all used some sort of color coding system where um students that are going down a level um are colorcoded red students that are staying the same or they're seeing minimal growth are a yellow and students that are growing are being colored green so on all of these spreadsheets I will say that the happy thing is I'm seeing 90% green our students are really really learning they're really moving along on this proficiency scale um and it's it's based on data that we're able to look at it's not just hearsay

035it's not looking at grade books and things like that we really do have a concrete set of data to look at over a bunch of years which helps us to um to make broader conclusions about what our programming our professional development this year has forced us to look at how we grade and forced us to have conversations about report card grading and how it is sometimes tricky in giving in a through f grade when we have such a different scale of proficiency a one a two a three and how do you correlate that to an ABC in the grade book and so we're just having conversations about that um we're having conversations and reflecting about AP which I shared with you we are working on expanding our dual enrollment to our French and Mandarin students

036for Equity reasons and um I thought it would be important to share with you that um we are exploring opportunities to grow Our World Language programming last year we talked quickly about what about a world language program and what were my thoughts on that and I told you that in order for all of our students to get to that six on that proficiency scale and achieve the seal by literacy we were looking at third grade as a good Target start they've got their early literacy skills um and that addition of two years to their language learning really does push more kids that's what Axel says and axel is the national um Organization for World Language instruction um one of the things that's important to Mr Lynch and I is equity and feeding all three of

037our languages and so that would have an implication on FTE for World Language at our elementary schools we would be looking at at least meeting three to feed our French Mandarin and Spanish program equitably um obviously you've already seen the budget for next year this is not something we are in a place to be looking at for next year but we are continuing to explore are ways in which we can bring World Language down to our elementary students and I think that's all we've had a math lesson we've had a World Language update we've had all the things fantastic all right thank you very much questions thank you Kate that was very informative you're welcome appreciate your enthusiasm um I have a couple of questions first um first question is this by literacy can you

038just explain exactly what needs to be accomplished in order to receive that and in our 19 What U languages with that was that it okay so in order to achieve or qualify for the Massachusetts CA by literacy you need a certain score on the mcast you need to be proficient at least on the mcast and you need a certain score on a state approved assessment and aant stamp which we give is one of those state approved assessments so in Massachusetts you need a proficient score on hcast and at least a six in all four domains on the stamp test got it so that mcast would that be senior year whatever we use the sophomore year mcast scores sophomore year MC and you can qualify on the stamp test any year so we have had freshman

039qualify but you have if you don't qualify as a freshman because we don't really expect that right you can qualify sophomore junior or senior year where most of our stud students are qualifying in junior year and it's offered in all of the languages I just happen to share the Spanish data just because that's our highest INR language but on the 19 that are going to get the seal by lit what language is is that just Spanish predominantly Spanish but not all okay so there are some French students um and Spanish students that are getting the Seal of by literacy in the class of 2025 okay and um this isn't specific to where language is but I'm curious um this will lead into our calendar discussion I think um AP exams what are they given during

040the week or on the weekends they're given during the week during the week for a two we period so 10 school days there are morning administrations and afternoon Administration so there's an 8 AM test and a noon time test and if I'm not in an AP class what am I doing during those you are going to class business business as usual and um remind me again of that is it may those are in May the first two weeks in May okay thank you um I was just curious um so it seems like the stamp test might not like correlate well with ap if we're seeing success on stamp but not so much on the AP exam I was just curious I feel like Massachusetts usually has a pretty high standard so it's surprising that they

041that there wouldn't be I was wondering if you also agree or if I'm not I think it's more of a numbers game I think you know we are fortunate in situate that we are stamp testing I mean this year alone we're stamp testing 733 students for grades 8 to 12 whereas when you look at the AP enrollments we have you know in some cases single digit students taking the actual exam so um I think it just has to do with sheer volume of tests taken right it's also like we're offering more AP so it's that's a you know as you we enroll our high schoolers it's like it's Choice time and you know that could feed into this for 100% does it work similarly to the other APS where you can sometimes get college credit

042if you get a certain absolutely language yes and you don't get college credit for the seale by literacy but one of the cool incentives with the state right now is you get a voucher to take the teachers test because we're there's such a shortage for um bilingual Educators teachers of ESL um and teachers of World Language so um it was really awesome to mail those letters home and touch base with some kids about like you know you should really take this you should sit for this test because why not you could get licensed and it's just another you know maybe you don't feel like being a teacher now but maybe down the road you could so um one cool part with the Sealy thank you so much I feel like that was just a really

043nice presentation where it's clear I think for us to see what your Department's vision is your enthusiasm obviously you know I think bringing some of the data with the historical Trends was super helpful too just so we can situate it you know um and understand you know I think also the fact that you guys are having such high standards and saying no we do want to you know see where we are in the middle of the year is so nice to see so thank you for yeah that's awesome thank you for all of that checking if Dr over there good all right thank you very much thank you I'm going to go get some math lessons from my first grader on place [Laughter] value that's true very all right we have new business uh see

044we have a policy being shared by our policy subcommittee miss and miss LM bom Mr mostely be begin I can start so um we at the policy subcommittee we discussed the um student competency determinations and the reason that we are discussing this now um is that with ballot question two um the voters of Massachusetts decided that the mcast would no longer be required for every um student to pass in order to graduate and so um absent that um it's important for us to kind of get clear on what it is that we are expecting this particularly is timely and very important for the current class of seniors so um in sichu we have a small number but still you know a number nonetheless of students who did not pass um the 10th grade and cast

045and so for those students um we need to make sure that we are giving them you know the path uh and making sure that they're all on it um in terms of what it would take for them to graduate so um in our packet uh we did put the some some FAQs um which might have been helpful just to kind of understand it's one of those things where every school committee in our state is currently needing to do the same thing right now um and desie and mask have not really issued complete guidance they've done this fq document which is helpful but no one has kind of said you know I think everyone's learning in flying the plan we building the plan while we fly it on this topic at the moment one thing we

046did talk about at our policy subcommittee meeting is that what we can do tonight is something that we know will work immediately for those kids who really need it and we could always revisit this um next year at some point as more information becomes available or we all start to really think a little bit more about if there are other ways we would want to um adjust this do you want to add anything um I think that's a very good explanation and just so people listening at home understand um in order to graduate from high school in Massachusetts there are two requirements the local graduation requirement and this other piece is this competency determination that we're talking about so previously students met the competency determination by passing their mcast tests and then meeting graduation requirement

047ins situ it since question two pass competency determination is no longer there so for students who did not pass the mcast they're missing one of their graduation components this policy like Miss benwick said will provide that especially for these um for a number of situ students in the class of 2025 who will need this policy passed in order to earn a diploma from citu high school and the state has promised that it's going to look at graduation [Music] requirements next year would be great to have a policy uh from the state it sounds like that could take several years so that's just two points I want to add thank you I wanted to add that you know this by passing this policy it helps the current seniors but was GNA look at it deeper you

048know moving forward not waiting for the state well um was this policy kind of I guess back tested to make sure that it covers our students that kind of how we did it so have to ultimate goal with this with this version of it yes there is a kind of clause at the bottom that says the principal May on a case-by casee basis review a students transcript and determine if the successful completion of course constitutes a reasonable equivalent so that is a sort of a catchall for you know sometimes a student might have moved here you know after they would have taken one of these classes like there's all different sorts of circumstances that we'd want to have in mind um to make sure that we that like I said there's a pathway for every

049child makes sense all right any other questions so this is just a first reading so thank you and we will are the are the students who I guess have not passed they kind of asking what they need to do in order to graduate is that s about their Forefront is that their ultimate goal do you think are going they paying attention to this policy I think we need to very good question I think we need to educate um once the policy is passed think we just need to educate everybody about what what it means um I know the high school administration is tracking the same students that we have access to there's a Desi report that says who are your students who haven't met the competency determination I know the high school administration's on top

050of that I do think we have uh we should reassure students when this is passed all of our students that they're on track to meet the graduation requirements as far as it's related to the competency determination part of it so um we we still have some work to do to just educate um families I think I know the situation is running an article about this their reporters have been on top of it since the GetGo they actually participated in our meeting so that'll help I think we should communicate this to families un passes Mak sense all right thank you that was our first reading we'll revisit this again um next time all right uh some old business here assistant superintendent Lyn you can start us off on our second reading of the 25 26 school

051calendar sure thank you um this is the second reading of the 2526 uh school calendar the school committee asked us to go back and um make a couple of changes to uh reflect uh the committee's input so you'll notice here on the current um draft proposal the staff return date would be Monday August 20 25th for professional development day um as well as Tuesday August 26th the first day uh for students would be uh September I'm sorry August 27th that would be the Wednesday prior to Labor Day and their second day would be the 28th and no work and no school on the 29th uh so these were the updates that uh were made in line with the recommendations from school committee we also uh shared this with the PD Council again uh to collect

052uh input from the members of the professional Development Council so um we're here tonight presenting the those updated changes and uh for the committee's consideration all right thank you you're welcome um comments questions from the committee on the updated calendar um I think I mean we we talked about this at the last meeting but I know we've this topic has gotten a lot more attention since the last meeting so I think it might be helpful to start off with just some of the reasons why we wanted to make this shift or or see what the shift would look like I think um I've spent a lot of time over the last week looking at a lot of other District's calendars to try to understand how people make this work um and I no one has

053like an amazing example of how to do this perfectly but I think there's in some ways there are some competing interests I think um we've heard that there is a greater value to some of the days at the front end of the year um before the testing happens but also just those days are more productive and full than the days at the end of the year um we also have an interest in trying to end the year in advance of the juneth holiday which is tricky because we might have S days and even if we plan to end it you know three or four days ahead of time what's been happening is that if we have any s days we end up bumping us into it we have this awkward end of the school year

054which is not great for scheduling um also not great for kids and the teachers you know that's just makes it very a weird ending of the year um we also you know have been looking at making sure that teachers have enough uh professional development time and that the professional development schedule which usually in involves either full days off or early release days is not overly cumbersome for families um because uh you know there's I think two things that matter you know um I was GNA say something else I forgot uh so anyway I think we're trying to figure this out um one thing I will say is that I was the person who brought this idea forward at the last meeting although I know it's been discussed on and off for many many years prior

055to me being on the committee um but I will say you know I do have uh Sympathy for the fact that this particular year uh because uh Labor Day is so early um on September 1st um and the fact that um a lot of trips have been planned camps have been signed up for like of all years to make this shift I do think next year it just presents extra challenges so I just want to put that out there and thinking um I've been thinking a little bit about maybe next year isn't the right year to make this shift maybe it's the following year when Labor Day moves to the seventh or the eth those are the years when it's most problematic um I will also say back on the first side that next year

056even with Labor Day being the earliest it could ever be we are still running up right up until June juneth that's still going to cause a weird ending of the school year um which also you know provides it own challenges for everybody so I don't know some of my thoughts thank you for sharing you guys think I think we should we can go through if everybody has any thoughts or comments no I would just I would just I mean EO I think Maria did a nice job of summarizing I also again just want to acknowledge I loved hearing from the community we got so much email this week and for every email I got that said start early I got one that said start late so even you know even when superintendent Burkhead presented the

057data that was 50/50 and remember it was a small n that trend is still holding true um I'd also want to add in there Maria just because that situation article the students so there was you know just it was 77 I think students 71 students that responded and about1 yeah what was it 71 thank you yeah and just under 50% said they didn't want to change it so it's still a 50 like a 5050 kind of split there were a group of students that were indifferent but what I wanted to bring to bear here is also the students were talking about the tradition of situ going back after Labor Day so I wanted to acknowledge that again not saying Pro or con the other piece that was brought up that that I thought was interesting

058was weather and so the concern that if you're not at Gates but at the high school the temperatures and I would just offer I I can't believe I did this I don't think I've ever on this but I went to The Almanac today and looked at average temperatures and actually now of course there can be random days June and August actually aren't that much different and we there's a likely chance that if we stay later in June that we could get some hot weather versus August so I just want I just want the students to know like we're taking their input seriously and I really mowed that over cuz I thought that was a really compelling thing to think about like because they're sitting in seats and it can be very hot and how well

059can you learn in a really hot room and so I just you know whe however we vote I just wanted them to know we are paying attention to what they say um yeah and I don't know Maria I think you bring up a good point about you know the earliness but given what um Miss wiro shared about the the pool closing early and you know I don't know that there are a lot of camps that last week of August even though it's an early Labor Day I'm not convinced that it's going to bump up against camps and and the pool you know those sorts of issues even if we decided to vote for it this year but just just my two cents yeah thank you Carrie appreciate that and definitely agree it was fantastic to

060hear from the students and thank you to Kathy hall for sending us that article and putting it in our view um oh any of my other fellow committee members just about the the PD days and I know that the election day we use that as PD because the schools closed um and do we would we save any days at the end if we had like the half day PD like a half day would have had us what have teachers prefer I guess what what is how do they get the most benefit the PV so just if I could take the first question first part of the question if I understand it correctly was would there be a benefit to to half days um so we we're required for over the course of the year for

061990 hours at the secondary level 900 hours um we just passed that information in it is I don't have it on the top of my head but it's it's pretty close um you need to have 180 days of school regardless of also you're required to do that so those are two components that so it really doesn't as long as we meet the 900 and the 990 we have 180 showups we're meeting the requirements um and then the second question was do we the teachers prefer a full day or a half day um I mean we talked about in PD Council a couple of times and um what teers appreciate I think is the ability to collaborate across the district so uh the if you can set up professional development dat the opportunity people to collaborate

062that is they would identify that as high quality from our surveying I I would say with the half days logistically it's it's challenging sometimes particularly last year when there was the early release which was uh 1230 at the elementary level and then then you're contractually um you know you're working till teachers are are working until like 3:25 you can't travel between schools with that sort of tight amount of schedule so then you can't collaborate so I think it's more difficult to pull off on on a half day it's just because of the logistical elements um but if I were I mean I'm sure teachers would appreciate any time for professional development so I don't want to say that they don't appreciate half days they do any any opportunity they have they they do appreciate I

063just want to state that it's a little more challenging when you do the half days especially if you ask them to leave their building and go to another building you're just losing time so it's more beneficial the full day eating I I I think that the statement is true there's only four of those in the contract but I think that that can be a better way to there's only really one day because school's closed on election no but I have a question about that too though because there is there any discussion or was it what placement of value has there been on if you have one a month one of those half days a month which honestly Maria and I not jokeing we looked at like 50 calendars in state pretty much between the two

064of us there a lot of them do the half day PD and those ones tend to have a tighter start date end date than I and don't seem to get caught up in juneth uh but I'm wondering if there's value in when you have a half APD being like oh we'll pick up on this again next month or we can you know table that or incorporate into our NE whereas with just the four it sort of like one lots of time lapse than another is that accurate or am I misunderstanding um if you're if you're asking for my opinion I think teachers will will gladly work very hard for any time that they're given to work together I think it my opinion is also that there's another constituency that we may need to check in

065with about this idea about if parents are having early release once a month I think that they would be another group of people that right would that might be a change that really hasn't been talked about in this uh these iterations that that we've done so um if it were the committee's decision to add half days I think we would need to figure out where where to put them and I would say um teachers always appreciate being able to work together um and they would make it work just not sure what um when we would have to identify those days because that would be a new a new change I will say I did hear from a few parents on that who said didn't use to have half days you know so I didn't hear

066from it was not an overwhelming number who brought that up but of the people who did bring it up it didn't seem to be as much of a barrier as sometimes the full day off um I mean it's anytime kids are not where you expect them to be it's going to present the challenge to parents um but I think Nicole's right those are one of the main drivers it look like um it's the starting earlier and the use of half days are the main things that will pull that year sooner so you're ending on a June 10th 11th 12th which gives you that offer you know any District that had that that's how they got it also so you know I'm not to say we need to do that right now but I'm just I

067do think it's something to think about at least yeah I also don't love speaking for our teachers I know there are some Educators on the school committee but I just I just I don't know I mean I'm hearing that they want collaboration time I'm hearing that it's hard to logistically move from one building to the other if they only have a few hours so I just want to make sure that their voice is Central to this decision I know Ryan you met with the PD committee I'm just wondering like I I know that I hear what you're saying that they appreciate anytime like that's I'm hearing that what I I guess what we're really trying to get at is if they could wave the magic wand and pick like what what do they want to

068see in the district in terms of their PD because like quite frankly it's it's their time right like they're going to be there and they need this time to do the work together and whether it's implementing new curriculum or technology or whatever it is so I just would love to hear a little more if you have it I'd like to add some context if I could so if you recall about three years ago we had a a real crunch on student learning time and meeting our time maned by the state even the beer minimum in fact I think we were in five years ago when I got here we found out that we were in we were short of the high school um and at that time we had many Wednesdays half days and we

069had the half the late start at the High School um so these all contributed to us being near the bottom and I think that was very concerning at the time for the school committee certainly to me both student learning time I like the idea of ending early starting like I mean we're work anyway so it doesn't matter to me so I'm I think I'm unbiased in this I'll be here if we start in mid August or end in late June um right we're here because of student learning and academics so I think we should start from that base and I think what happens is when you trade in half a day we get credit for Day from the state but the kids only are here for half the day so we lose three hours every

070time we whack a half a day off so if you do that three uh six times you're you're you're losing the two days of learning mathematically that you just gain by starting early two days um so I think right there it was a problem the reason why we got rid of it the PD council is made up of teachers Department shairs um you know and what we were seeing on the uh feedback of all the PD we do is we just didn't have enough time for the half day we couldn't travel it limits you like we said versus a p a full day and and what you can do by offering you know the whole District time together just because of the travel parking with dismissal at different times they can't get into the building

071so you know think about that it's really logistical nightmare as well you get out of school at whatever 12 o'clock and by the time you get over somewhere else at 12:25 and find parking you get into the room where the meeting is it's 1:00 and you know tired and versus getting there at 8: a.m. ready to work having the ability to get um all different groups together really broadens your ability to create um a well structured PD day so for all those Reasons I'm it's your a call on this that's one area that I've lived and have been um vly against for all those reasons I just think it and also we've got parent complaints we got a lot of parent complaints but I got middle middle of nowhere on Wednesday I got to pick

072my kid up at half day and I'm in Boston working versus the one day where I know that day is off you know instead of five half a day so it was an inconvenience for pretty much everybody so I think that's tempting and it shortens the year but are we about shortening the year or we about providing great PD and and um more hours we can as more hours as we can in the classroom in front of teachers as we can for our kids Nicole I appreciate that explanation sorry Ken no no I was just gonna say I will say that your earlier Point around the continuity because right that we know best practices of PD is not episodic right it's ongoing and continuous and so I wonder if this is not to solve tonight

073but I wonder if the next conversation after we settle this is how do we support the teachers in their daily schedule so that when they do a day of PD that there are opportunities within their regular schedule to do some followup that aren't half days out of school but like a collaboration period or right like what's the thread that's keeping those conversations going and how can we as a school committee help you know our central office think about building it just like we build in Wind blocks for students what does it look like for a teacher and a team of teachers um so I think again not going to solve it tonight but I do don't I don't want to lose your thread of the importance of continuity across those you know dayong PDS yeah

074thank you Carrie I I totally totally agree and more posing that as food for thought in terms of half days versus full days because of just feedback and I think it's good for parents and and um stakeholders to know what the thought process is and thank you superintendent for that was a good explanation of of the why and where how we got to the full days because we get that question of you know ah a whole day off and on a random day of the week like why why are we not you know doing it this way so there's there was in intentional shifts there and sounds like that's that's a good thing um Okay so what else oh we did have the go ahead I just wanted to say one more thing on the

075voting so that's a question that has come up is why must we close all the schools on voting day so um I've been trying to do some research on this and basically in situ it um we do not have another location that would be large enough and handicapped accessible enough parking all of that to accommodate uh one single polling place so instead we'd be looking at pre at prein based polling places which would mean we would need several of them of which there do not seem to be enough also it increases the cost quite a bit because then at each polling place you need the police details and the different warrants and deputies and things like that that are Staffing the the polling places so it would come at a at an increased cost so

076it's not to say it couldn't happen in the future but I don't know that there's an appetite to take on such a cost right now um however it is possible to close just the high school um on a voting day I know that that would be unusual because it would be kind of odd to say like oh the high school doesn't have school today but uh no you don't have to close Gates I asked you keep gates open um so any I think um you know that would be unconventional I did see another Cal at least one other calendar that did Split For Teacher professional development by uh level so there were some days where the elementary school had a half day but the other schools didn't so it's not completely unprecedented but I know

077that would take some further creativity and thinking so I say that not for next year's calendar but possibly for September of 2026 when we will have a state election maybe we could start thinking about whether that would be a possibility and what that might look like yeah that kind of Segways into my thought I think we have the shift the Labor Day question to hand right now and then there's some subsequent components to this you know including one that Dr kosi just mentioned too about threads and how that ties into workday pieces but you know how to support teachers but yeah so step one here really is perhaps this this is kind of a big shift in and of itself and maybe those other pieces are how do we build up to those but um

078I did want to note too that the situation articles stated I think it was 75% or something of um high school students are participating in Fall Athletics so that's a really active campus uh for Mid August it's a lot of a lot of kids out there um the weather component I think was touched on thank you grie for all the knacking that out um trying to think of what else I do think it's it the emphasis can't be placed enough on just sort of that attentiveness September versus June for students especially obviously but um and you know it's not I think uh superintendent burkhead's Thursday thoughts survey there was I forget the numbers exactly but it the biggest support of that sample wanted to go back were teachers who said they wanted to go back

079before Labor Day not a a massive sample size but they had the highest majority go back before um you know I don't know I do think I like a calendar and I think it was Miss Fenwick who brought this up last time with the November just this particular year with the weird Tuesdays um I think it would be good for that sort of flow if the fourth was the 10th maybe but yeah I agree with that I think that helps us address some of the problems that we see sometimes with um with families taking vacations on non ation weeks which I think cost is a huge driver when parents make that decision and I understand that um as a parent of free like taking your family anywhere is extremely expensive um and so if there's

080an opportunity to give people an extra like I I think beur is another town that I've seen them do this they'll back e day up with an existing 3day weekend to kind of throw parents a bone I think um in terms of like you know if you're going to have the day off you may as well maybe this is a time you could fly somewhere or you know do the type of thing you might not be able to do during um when the entire state is also trying to fly um so I think that is something that I would like to see just ease that a little bit you know for parents I I think if the 10th was what you talking about like maybe the 10th PD day yeah moving the PD Day from

081the 4th to the 10th but I think you know we as long as the the election is on the four is like really but it's not next year next year there's no election oh I think Ryan had it in there for that continuity of that first Tuesday's election Tuesday but this 20 5 six calendar it's not maybe it makes more sense to do the T um first of all this is no it's a no win situation uh I think Marie everyone that spoke I I fully agree with everything that has been said and it's not an easy answer I think that um I think I had brought up the weather a couple years ago about that but I think it's a real issue I think that the data that we got was like August was

082I think slightly hotter but it wasn't a big deal um and obviously you can get really hot days really cold day or rainy day or whatnot um and I mean we could talk about all different angles of this one angle that I do think I mean with high school kids 75% of the kids participating in a sport I don't know if that means that it's easier for them to potentially go back to school or that complicates things because I know that there's practices and soone that have been historically scheduled that week before school so I know if that would even push High School practices back another week they can only practice whatever a week or or so before school begins so I'm not sure what complexity that brings in I don't really know um and

083then with elementary students um you know I guess I feel like it's okay waiting and going back into September in in September um or after Labor Day and then again on the high school side I do think that the AP exams are an important consideration um so IID asked Kate about the um kind of the format of the AP exams and it's interesting I didn't know that we actually take days I don't know it's two-hour blocks to take these exams um I'm just trying to figure I configure in my head exactly what that looks like and how much time it takes away from their other learning not sure it really does because it's the end of the year but it does to some degree if they're taking a two-hour exam and a 50 minute block

084they're obviously missing that second block if they're taking five AP exams Junior end or senior year that's a lot of time so I don't know if that necessarily is offset by starting school earlier or later but just an observation um I think probably what's more um would be more important relative to AP I know this is focusing on the high school is our successes or failures or I guess of our students not getting four or fives what are the reasons for that there's one of them they not getting enough instruction um is one of them absenteeism either on the teacher or the student like what is what is what's causing the either the the good or the other not not good H things um so with all that being said I don't know which is

085better I feel like this year I guess ultimately I I took an informal or formal pool in my neighborhood of families with kids at all different ages split 5050 um my family incredible how that has held up yeah my family is vly opposed to going back before Labor Day um and I think this year particularly and is we're getting out a little bit late this year then we're starting early so it makes the summer extra short um and I think they will always have that problem so one year if we do decide to go back for we're going to have that issue but this particular Year we're getting out June maybe June 18th and we'd be going back in August so as as as quoted by a family member they would only have one full

086month office I think what that's how that's how comments that was a I think I think it is important though to remember that we're only talking about an August start when Labor Day is on September 1st or 2nd like this is not a typical I think the problem is not actually next year the problem is years when we're going back to school on September 9th that's a problem I think that to me is a very clear like no one should be starting school September 9th there is legitimately no camp that is running on September 4th Fifth and 6th you know what I mean so like that to me is absolutely like the problem next this coming year just happens to be the anomaly year that comes every whatever seven years or whatever it is that

087um is not a problem right real do you know what I mean start school September 2nd uh right which is what it would be is actually no different than what it would be if we kept the same model and in future years Labor Day was on the 8th we'd still be starting in September 2nd so we're not actually gaining that many days so I guess to me that also beges the question of whether we want to revisit the idea that we've discussed in the past about a model where we have a cut a cut off so like if it's September 3rd first second or third we start after Labor Day meaning the first day of school would be the second you know one day after yeah and then if it's September 4th more later we

088flip and start before do I mean then we we're starting school around the same day every year I guess I would just I appreciate what you're saying Maria I just wonder for families I mean I'm I'm hearing the students talk about tradition like the problem with that scenario for me is that now families can't count on like the longer Labor Day right because we're giving them Friday and Monday so like if we change the calendar for good then they're getting a little bit longer vacation versus well some months some week years they will some years they won't and so I'm just wondering you know could we start New Traditions if we start before Labor Day where they're doing something on a long weekend again I I don't really know the other thing Peter I appr

089appreciated your observations around AP I don't know that starting before Labor Day can solve any of this because we have so many students I mean how many folks come in front of us and talk about these amazing trips that our students are taking where they're out of school we have athletes who are out of school we have um uh the DECA that are out of school the model un who are out of school right so we have all these different constituencies so I don't know that we can even ever solve that sort of issue right cuz they're all into so many cool things that do take them out of the the school year and and changing the calendar is not really going to impact that either way in my opinion so to speak to the

090having like the date a cut off date I think if we just parents I mean currently the the expectation is we start Tuesday after believe it if we moving forward we you say we're going to be the kids are going to be going back to School the um Wednesday and Thursday so every year it's the Wednesday and Thursday before yeah that's consistent no matter what the date because our ultimate goal is to help us at the end of the year all right well I think we've disced it thoroughly and I'm I'm here for a motion if anyone is uh interested in well and although one thing about moving that that Tuesday November so Tuesday November 4th to Monday November 10 well I guess right I mean whoever's making the motion can present it how they

091like but that could be either way depending on the start it doesn't matter start taking yeah no I mean but just we're voting on the 25 26 Calendar so in this iteration it's you know what I mean it's like it's the fourth that's there are no there's no reason for it to be the fourth it could easily be the 10th this coming September you know this coming school year I think that would be helpful for parents so would we vote twice or would we vote once with multiple things in it well I was thinking if someone was going to make a motion it's as yeah right if that's the change that the person making the motion wants to make if we change the the PD date of attemp does that affect anything you have scheduled

092for that PD date not yet no thank you for asking yeah yeah it would be yeah so it's the calendar as presented I mean as amended what that's what the 2017 the first day can I have one more question sorry motion the thing that's holding me back is just the idea that I know that you know some people have already made uh plans assuming that we would follow the same pattern that we've always followed which is going after so I just worry that this particular year stands to be disruptive at the beginning of the school year with kids we're going to miss those days um and I think if we do that it just I just worry that it will get things off on the wrong foot um if if teachers and families experience this

093year as it's my only worry and I don't know I I don't know I have no way of knowing what how L that number is maybe it's tiny and I just happen to AP from three of them but um but I don't know I don't know so I just wanted to say that one last piece so if if that's if that's a case because I think that's something to think about how how do you imagine we preent prevent that in next year because there could be people that aren't sure what we're going to do so I'm just wondering like at what point do we prevent that well I think we got to start talking about the calendar like in the fall um because we can see it coming there's nothing that prevents us except for

094the fact we have all these other things we also want to talk about but if we really commit to putting this on the agenda much earlier like there are some districts that publish their calendar I think two years out I've seen so um you know we really commit to that and say this is something that we're going to do um I think that or some type of a a cut date or you know I guess we can't vote on next year's calendar now but you know I guess that's that's how I think about it yeah I mean don't forget we don't vote the last day of school until we know more information there either so that's always in yeah somewhat of a flux situation we could air voting on the last day of the school

095year with the first day two years of the following year right to talk about anyways yeah I there's really no reason not to honestly like we can look as far out as we want to see when Labor Day is yeah right on then I think it would hopefully help you know Ryan and the PD committee to get planning and parents on travel and things like that you know anyone can make a motion at any time with there I feel like they just rip the Band-Aid off and just do this there are they going to be parents that have already made plans the end of the year too I mean it's and there are some people that make plans to go away on school days so that's true I mean true we can only do what

096we can do y all right anyone and you don't have to vote how you how you want to vote I am making a motion that the school committee improve the 25 26 school calendar as amended okay we have a motion on the table we have a second second okay we're gonna do a roll call vote I knew you were gonna I knew you were gonna make me go first Nicole that's I I vote Yes okay then way I write down the line I'm veryable can I explain my vote while I vote can I say a word or am I just V just vote I'm a no I'm a no only because of the the particular problems for next year that I named I a yes overall the concept but technically you're no yes Gates no

097yes so this is not the first time I've been in okay uh randini yes the motion passes we have on this on this and the hisory books will tell you that I so just to clarify for next year the gr school will start for students August Wednesday August 27th they will have school Wednesday August sorry Thursday August 28th um and the rest of the calendar will be published at some point soon PK to K yeah September 2 September 2nd for PK and kindergarten yeah and the calendar will be published soon to show all the other days and things like that that is correct and and the as amended part would identify two based on the vote of the committee just so I have it correct Tuesday November 4th is a full school day 2025 Monday

098November 10th will be a professional development day in no school followed by Tuesday November 11th which is a Federal holiday so we will make those changes and that will be the voted school calendar for for next year will it go up via push notification for families on the app I guess yeah yeah we're GNA ASAP do that put up on the website where we'll just have to make sure again I'm sorry I'm focusing on Athletics but I don't know what the rules are relative to Athletics start they can M that they have they have start dates doesn't matter where the school starts okay it's because they school they couldn't do that because every school starts as we talked about tonight at different time so they they'll have the first game they work backwards from the

099cut off date you call a cut off date which is the last game you can have and they'll move forward the preseason so x amount of days before or after day so similar to what you do it won't have impact as far as when the kids start or not we have a little bit more we to do uh we have an approval of minutes from January 27th and February 3rd comments looks good to me anyone else oh February 3rd and January 27 I can make a motion yeah oh anyone who wants to I make a motion that the school committee vote to approve the January 27th 2025 and February 3rd 2025 minutes as presented okay a second all right uh rosi yes benwick yes Gates yes lwam yes randini yes for tonight oh we have

100correspond we're not there yet do our February too oh you did same wow um no Lawrence tonight no correspondences up oh I just wanted to say thank you to the H students from I think it's wamp who made Valentine's for us I think we all got a little pack a packet of them so that was just really lovely to see and we very appreciative of of yeah very nice beautiful artwork and honestly really my Valentines have fantastic handwriting all right um any other business um I will I don't know I assume everyone got the email from the state of Massachusetts that we have to I don't know if yes I just I just got to my birthday or we just get it every year two years every two years you need to do the uh

101ethics oh yeah certification and or training class just make sure you do that and send your um certificate I guess to Kathy your certificate think you can email it too or Maria think you can just yeah email it oh okay completed just they start sending you these notifications that you oh no I did mine I just didn't send I think it's two I didn't okay okay um any future agenda items so we got a great email from Mr Lynch today about the Wi-Fi and networking and I would love to hear more about that in the future just because I've heard from families just what Mr Lynch was describing sort of intermittent service in different parts of gates you know in terms of disrupting learning and so it would be awesome because we have a new

102team just to hear what they're doing how that's going just to sort of level set expectations for families and students um not not pressing just more of a curiosity but I appreciated seeing that email Ryan it's good to get those updates welcome thank you all right uh if nothing else we'll take a motion to adjourn motion to adjourn at 7:26 second all right second by Miss benwick uh roll call vote Miss barosi yes Dr barosi my and Miss sorry M Miss L yes and brand yes

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.