001okay there we go like to call the January 22nd 2025 meeting of the coass school committee to order good evening everyone this meeting is streamed live on Facebook and recorded it's also being broadcast on goass 143 TV and you may also participate virtually by logging on to zoom utilizing the link that appears at the top of our agenda um would all committee members that are present please indicate so in roll call Mr carrr present Mr dile present Mrs Hannah present Mrs leski pres chair is also present giving us a full panel of five members the meeting is officially called to order and I'd ask that all who are able to please rise for the recitation of our nation's Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag the United States of America and to the
002Republic which stands one nation God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay thank you very much uh the first agenda item as always is is public comment um and this part of the agenda is reserved for questions or areas of concern or any discussion point that you would like to raise that's not related to something that's uh already on our agenda agenda if you have a concern or question discussion Point relating to something on the on the agenda just wait until we arrive at that point in the meeting make yourself known and we you shall be heard but at this point I want to give uh anyone who is attending virtually I don't see anyone uh in the audience that's here for public comment so anyone that is uh participating virtually May utilize the
003Q&A feature on Zoom to enter your name and address and any discussion point that you would like to raise now I'll give you a few minutes to do that or a few seconds anyway and if you don't get it done at this point don't worry uh it'll pop up and I intermittently check these um comments so we will absolutely address them if you're a few minutes late no problem we want to hear from everyone and we encourage participation okay I don't see any at this point in time like I said feel free to chime in as the meeting progresses so with this point we'll move forward to the uh next block of our agenda which is Block C which is reserved for invited guests and we have a special invited guest who is one of
004the student representatives of superintendent Shannon's um superintendent student advisory Council so I would invite uh Mr Jack Kierney to come to the invited guest table to present your report in any format you wish Jack please uh begin whenever you would like well thank you very much uh honored to be invited today uh student body just a quick update on what's going on with us uh it's finals week I'm sure many of you know so there's sort of a buzz around that but the final schedule that was implemented reimplemented that two years ago is definitely appreciated the half days plus splitting it all up is defin like that's great it honestly wouldn't be manageable without that so thank you all very much uh also thank you for the lunchroom we talked about this in student advisory
005committee but there's always like a lot of congestion and I know there's been a couple new faces in the lunchroom when it comes to staff and the skipper calf has been serving food more consistently and that's really appreciated uh it's not like there's still definitely congestion but that comes more from the physical space and I'm not sure can do there besides knocking down some walls so uh yeah lunches at the end of the day it's a good problem to have you know people want the food so again thanks for that uh also there's a bit of a I don't know if anxiousness is the right word to use but so we I'm going to use around the foam B on Monday I know that's a thing uh at the end of the day there's going
006to be moaning and groaning because you're taking away something we like but I think it'd be nice if there was more communication on like why because I don't know if that's been communicated to like the planning the I forget the name of the phone committee and like we talked about it at our committee but I think the wider student body if it could be explained like specifically why you're taking away at schools because like we know phones are like bad for us we hear that all the time it's like why at school I think that' be benefit to I think that'd be to the benefit of the students and to the staff because people are less likely to intentionally try to break a rule if they understand why it's happening yeah that's you guys have
007any comments or questions love to hear it Des fire Willie if you have any questions for Jack about school or student body concerns M leki could you please tell us more about the phone ban and how it's working or sort of what the so kids come in for the day and phones stay in the backpacks or phones get turned in somewhere so how is this all what are the logistics of this program my understanding was it goes in the bag and then there's like if they see it there's like a firsttime offense thing and then it builds up up to a like the Merit on Aspen that like all your teachers can see and like Mr Turner head of NHS can see and like it can be really bad for you please feel free to
008create correct me Mr Shannon it hasn't started it'll start on Monday starts Monday okay I'm just curious about the workings and what are your fellow students concerned about with not having their phones is it just the pleasure of like relaxing with your phone for 10 seconds before class or yeah I think a lot of it just comes from like what is this change besides just making our day a little less enjoyable because we already we already can't take it out during class I don't have a single teacher who like if I started just going on my phone wouldn't call me out for it it's like a lunch and utility thing I think that's what people are really I'm I'm saying concerned but no one's like gonna start you know crashing out over not having their
009phone all day it's just like I said it's gonna be moans and groans no matter what but we'll see how it goes anything else for Jack we're doing a lot about the first GR presentation thanks um I like we like your guest by the way very much withing with us um we are making a lot of strides um on the food is there any further suggestions of what we might be able to do better there uh maybe I'm just not as creative as I think I am but uh not really I will say with popular dishes are definitely the pizza the burrito bowls and probably the orange chicken putting that out there and pizza gate is behind us now Pizza gate is behind us is behind us yeah grateful to have that Mr dial Jack
010great presentation you know I liked about your presentation that you came used your own own voice your own way of speaking give and you weren't afraid to give ously critical but you know honest feedback with the committee so that's fantastic and very much appreciate that so thank you um understand about the anxiety I like your your turn of phrase there maybe it's not anxiety but it's the word use I'm not actually use that myself going for it um but are there any other areas where the students on could use some are that we should know about as the committee um I know that in the past one of your esteemed family members was uh really focused on the uh outdoor grounds and and that um and areas and then also the gym equipment uh as
011well is there any other areas that as a second generation KY you you uh want to uh impress upon our committee well when it comes to like Outdoors um yeah we really don't get Outdoors that much I know it's winter and everything's frozen but I mean if more classes in the spring like want to go outside I think that'd be awesome I have had classes where they're like it's so nice out let's do French outside and so we've done that that's definit there are classes like environmental science they like play in the dirt all day so I think stuff like that's awesome uh when it comes to like the wait room I definitely have friends who like are there almost every day after school I haven't really been so I don't really know how like
012chaperoning and all the legistics gone over there but it's definitely something that people take advantage of both teacher and staff or teacher and student dra then you look forward to your future presentations as the as a anything else for Jack okay so Jack uh I will offer to you that uh first with regards to some of the positive things you mentioned uh like the quality of the food and the fitness center that's being utilized and Foods being enjoyed the secret service agent that you brought with you uh in the back is actually uh responsible as you know for a lot of those improvements so I think you have him in part certainly to thank um with regards to the phone issue that you addressed um I think that we will uh I think principal Scott
013obviously was directly involved with that um cell phone Task Force is the group that was um comprised of parents and uh your teachers and a few of your peers uh as well as Mr Scott to sort of devise a policy for this pilot program that's going to be starting on Monday and I think principal Scott uh has uh taken a lot of steps to inform the various St stakeholders as to like what the expectations are going to be and you had I think a pretty good understanding of that however um your point relative to the reasoning behind it and having that communicated to the student body um is something that we can give more consideration to um because we certainly wanted to ensure that the student body had agency in that and so that was
014that objective was was you know we attempted to accomplish that by inviting student participation on the the actual team um but I think it sounds like you know students are still wondering so we'll work on that I know principal Scott is always willing to communicate with the students everything and we we'll figure out a way to do that I think that's a fair criticism I will offer you this personally and you can share this with your peers beyond what I'm sure principal Scott will do is that the reasoning behind this pilot program is was based um on a book uh by a man named Jonathan hate who uh wrote a book called anxious generation the anxious generation and there was a community read and and that that book focused on the adverse impacts of Technology
015specifically handheld personal technology on the development of of children's brains and and just child development in general and it raised a lot of alarm and concern so as a school district we reacted to that and superintendent Shannon and the school committee participated in this very well attended Community event where uh families and students also uh you know spoke up and from that that cell phone Task Force was born in order to address these concerns that were raised in that book and then you know a few of the I think what what a major point of that book was that um sort of the the the free play that was associated with childhood in the past and the more sort of independent and amorphous sort of social interactions between peers uh was being replaced by this
016dependence on these devices and social media was being replaced with more from an in-person sort of direct authentic interaction with a digital interaction so we're trying to avoid that and we're trying to do right by all of you um by limiting the amount of time that you have when you're in school with these devices because it can also um distract you significantly from your learning so there's an academic element of course as well it's I think you know largely social emotional so to your point that utility and lunch are two times in particular where students miss these things there's a good reason why we don't want you to have them at those times because especially lunch table a lot of times people will be sitting and maybe conversing about something that's on here or maybe
017playing a game or texting when I have you know uh Paul Kierney sitting across the table for me or Jack Kierney sitting across the the the table from me and I am basically not interacting with them even though they're three feet away and that's something that is just it's become a problem so that's why we want to ensure that we delivered a different experience to you you a more a more traditional experience in terms of social interaction as you guys are developing and growing so that sort of is the general impetus I think principal Scott will do a much better job at explaining that in a in more maybe uh comprehensible and more relatable fashion to all the students but I just wanted to let you know what what was going through our heads when
018we thought about doing that so we'll see and it's a pilot program right so it's going to go through I think to April 4th if I'm remembering the date correctly so it starts Monday and we're going to take it through to April 4th and see how it goes because we're certain that there's going to be some unintended adverse consequences that you know maybe we didn't think of um and we're going to may maybe have to Pivot a little bit but um overall I think we're pretty confident that it's going to be a positive thing and it's just it's just it's just sort of a cultur ship for you guys like anything you're young you guys will completely adjust and adapt um then you get them after school so you can coordinate with mom and dad
019or your friends about rides to sports and all of that but during school we we' it's really important to us that you guys have that time without them it's a I think it's it's it's a gift that we're trying to bestow upon you so we'll see how it goes so keep us posted okay and the ssac will do that um I'm sure and we'll we will uh your point is well taken and we'll relate that to principal Scott about maybe explaining the reasoning to the student body at large a little bit better so thank you for letting us know yeah thank you I mean me person I think it's like like once you lay like I'm fortunate enough to be on the committee where we talked about the actual reasons so like personally I'm not
020gonna say excited but excited to see like what happens I'm curious and I would love to see more communication and just like enjoying each other's company but I think when it's just happening without that communication it just feels like it just feels like they're just doing it to do it just feels it's a it's a great point and we're glad that you brought it to us and we're going to wa add it so that is a great example of why it's important to have the ssac and why why we're fortunate to have talented and courageous students like yourself on that on that committee so thank you Jack and uh unless there's anything else you'd like to add we're we're happy to let you go and do homework or whatever else you got any you need
021to do now right finals all right so um maybe uh it would be most appropriate superintendent Shannon for you to let principal Scott know about that um and I'm sure if he hasn't already anticipated a way of doing that maybe it's just helpful if he starts a little bit earlier than anticipated I think he he has a very comprehensive plan about this so I think he does um but always room for growth right and Improvement so that was that was great okay moving on uh to to the next block of our agenda is our superintendent report and so at this point I turn the meeting over to our superintendent of schools Mrs Sarah Shannon um thank you so I was going to touch on the cell phone as well so I'm not going to repeat
022everything that was just shared I will just add a couple of pieces um one I would like to thank all of those who are on the committee for all of their work the teachers the administrators the um parents and the students it's it's been a lot of conversation and though I'm not on a committee the reports I've been getting have been that there's been some really good debate back and forth about what is right and they've you know even to the point where the original pilot was going to be for a shorter period of time and the committee decided that they weren't going to get solid enough data so that's why it extended um to the entirety of third term I also would share that there's going to be a pre survey for students and
023a post survey for students and I think staff so that we can get some data um I think it's going to be very interesting to see um because I think Jack brings up some really good points and that I think students don't necessarily know the benefits and may not think there will be benefits until they experience them um as you look at news coming out of other schools across the state of Massachusetts and across the country when schools have taken these steps at the high school level because in cohes it we're actually away for the day already through grade e um but when they do it at the high school level there are such positive um student interaction improvements that happen and student stress levels start to go down a little bit and you know
024I think there is both the student um superintendent student advisory Council and at my own dinner table right there was there's apprehension is maybe the word um around this by from the students um it's interesting because all of them talked about like they're not quite sure what it's going to be like they're not necessarily upset about it they're just curious um to see what happens I think that the unknown is real for them they haven't really had lives without cell phones um and so this will be an interesting exercise size um and there are even States who from the state level are saying away for the day K through 12 and so I wonder you know could that be in our future as a state and so this is a way for us to figure
025out how this works for us here in Cohasset so um I'm sure that principal Scott will keep us informed and up to date and um it will be really interesting to see how the kids adapt and adjust so so that is happening um additionally it's been a busy two weeks since we last met we kicked off our strategic planning process which has been awesome we have held forums we have actually held seven forums we've had some staff forums student forums family forums a municipal Forum you all had a forum we had a leadership Forum as well um we had a family form that was in person last week and actually currently right now on Zoom is another family forum for anyone who couldn't make it in person um we're grateful for everybody who has taken
026the time to participate in these forums the information has been really robust and we're looking forward to pulling it all together with TLA to use as data that we can use to building our Str our strategic plan additionally for those who haven't been able to participate yet we will be sending out a survey to All Families we'll be sending in it to students grade 6 through 12 and to the community The Wider Community as well we're actually going to be asking that any family who has a recent graduate in the last one to three or four years that your graduate Also may want to fill this out um and that's going to be coming out and that survey will be open for about two weeks and so we hope that people will fill out that
027survey because that data is going to be really important and My Hope sort of sneak peek ahead that we had over 500 respondents to our survey about vacations and so I'm hoping that maybe we get just as much interest in this survey about the future of the district as well um additionally this past monday it was a no school day as we celebrated Dr Martin Luther King and we're just grateful to the Cohasset diversity committee who hosted a Martin Luther King breakfast and to danella Clark who spoke to us um those of us in attendance and shared a message of love and caring for others as Dr Kain did as well and finally I want to remind people we've been sending reminders about next Tuesday night next Tuesday night is the second in a series
028of three forums around the middle school and high school feasability study for anyone who is out there this is the meeting to come to this is where we are going to start to to see conceptual designs for any potential building that might happen here in town um those conceptual designs will be presented by our Architects ai3 and then the third meeting in our series which happens after February vacation the Tuesday after February vacation um will be where they ai3 come back and they actually share cost estimates for those conceptual designs and so you know our goal right now is not to choose a a potential design it is to gather a lot of information to see what is possible so that when we get accepted into the msba core process we have a leg up
029we have this information available to us so when we go through that process we already have some really good ideas about what a potential new facility could could look like here in Cohasset so those are my updates um but I also want to talk a little bit about the district calendar um so moving into that conversation I do want to thank all of the people who participated in the survey with regard to the 2526 school year calendar um we asked really two questions we asked a question around the December break and we asked a question around the Good Friday holiday um we have literally 56 responses um that many people completed the survey and the responses were at least for one overwhelmingly clear and so we'll talk first and share with you about the responses
030for the December break so with regard to December break 72.9% of the respondents opted for the full two weeks off for students 16% opted for no school from Tuesday December 23rd to January 2nd and 11% voted for no school on Monday no school from Monday the 22nd to January 1st but coming to school on the 2nd so really 73% of families voted for the two full weeks to be vacation for their for their children or what was the overall response number again 59 or 56 so that's a lot that's a lot yeah um with regard to the Good Friday question um 46.8% of the respondents opted for the half day of school for Good Friday while 28.5 opted for no school on Good Friday and 24.7% opted for a full day of school on Good
031Friday so um that's that's something for the committee to have a conversation about um one thing that was interesting that happened um as the survey was being filled out by families and staff was uh a phone call from the representative from the teachers who really asked if this goes the way of having two full weeks off instead of potentially having professional development on January 2nd could we actually do it on that Monday December 22nd because we're already in school mode and so to come back for that Monday and then be off all the way through actually seems like a nice option so we had that conversation they actually surveyed their own um staff members and though it was close um their recommendation is actually to have the professional day on the 22nd um which I
032think we are actually fine with and it doesn't impact students at all um I understand that perspective and then another suggestion that came in that is different than what was presented was originally there's an early release day currently presented on February 6th um if that day is an early release there's only one full we of school before February vacation the suggestion was to that early release day to January 30th so that you get two full weeks of school for for better continuity of Educational Service service and so um that also made sense and so I would recommend that that that we actually move that February 6 early release dat to January 30th it it works better for continuity of educational experience for students and stff okay thank you for that summary super Shannon Dr scollins
033do you need to be made a co-host or you already a co-host um I do not need to be made okay I know you're not up yet I was just anticipating okay so I want to State at the outset of our discussion about the calendar that there was a vital T typo in the email that we sent out last Thursday and it was my fault I had input the school committee meeting date at which we would discuss this as January 29th and it was today I'm not that we're making decision today anyway we did correctly State when we were making the decision so um you know we may I'm going to send out another email uh in collaboration with superintendent Shannon where we correct that and let people know that we will be making the
034decision just so everyone knows that we'll be making the decision at the next meeting um which will be on uh February 5th or four Fe be clear I will double check y clear Wednesdays yeah February 5th will be the meeting that we're making the decision on the calendar so we'll just we'll we'll there'll be an opportunity for everyone to discuss it then too but today was supposed to be the body of our um introduction of this concept and deliberation on it and then we are we're we're going to implement um vote and Implement on um or vote to implement excuse me on February 5th just wanted to state that that was an error and I apologize we will do better uh but you will nevertheless have plenty of time to participate in discussion if you
035wish and it sounds like everyone has already sort of made their voice heard through their input on the survey especially where we have 73% um on one of the results I mean that seems to be a resounding uh response or support for that particular item so with that said I invite school committee members to sort of speak at will relative to the calendar and the different options before that I guess uh from on the was breaking it up into two things on the December break from an administrative perspective do you have a preference as to the two weeks or the one day missing or the two day missing options I think that given past experiences when you have one days like that they tend to be days of low attendance and they tend to um
036not the um you know as productive because of student absence as we would like um I think our teachers do a really good job of trying to make those days really meaningful days but when you don't have all of your students that's hard um and so they're teaching to partially you know partially full classrooms um and so I think in this case and it's not something I would recommend every year but in this case I think that you for families make sense and for full disclosure I'm fully prepared to throw my law in with the 73% yeah but I wanted to get that out there um have some thoughts on Good Friday but I can hold on that if we want to fight for k no why don't should just no we don't need to
037just your input always on on Good Friday that one is seems to be to be at least not as clearly in one result or another and I know from prior conversations that part of the issue that we have is um the economic cost of it um I also know that from the data you've given that it looks like the absences are primarily at the higher School levels and so one thing that I'm thinking about I still feel uh I I still like the idea that we do not have a religious holiday notwithstanding theal options of having a day of attendance or whatnot but I don't know that we've had a full enough cycle to really allow for that change to take hold within the district uh and you're seeing the younger families have higher attendance
038than the older families and I'm if we change back now then it never changes and so I'm a little reticent just sharing my own personal view to change that on only a couple years of behavior um because my prediction would be that after a couple more years you'd have higher attendance on that day as the community becomes used to it and the people who've done it for 10 nine eight years in a row you know they people have annual PL like oh yeah I'm going to go on Good Friday so I think that the this is a a behavioral change that is grounded in and and good reason so again I'm I'm not committed and dogmatic about it one way or the other but I guess I would just offer my perspective that I still
039would lean towards having Good Friday be a school day for the reasons that we had originally made a change so thank you Mr di Miss Hannah um is there data on you when um April vacation Falls the week after Easter right like so I don't know where Good Friday fell these past few years to your Mr dial on I can see why there would be no no one coming to school if April vacation were right after that so I don't know if that analysis has been done so we didn't we've only done it for a couple of years and it didn't it didn't come up against the vacation this is the first time it's coming vacation and that happens just like the two we kind of thing that you're talking about for the holiday every
040six or seven years you get this yeah yeah and the data that I had shared um last week with those absences that was the data from last year so that it didn't back up to Vacation okay all right anyone else or Miss Hannah were you not finished um I I was just gonna say I actually I'm on the other side of the fence from Mr D on this one where I feel like the teachers and the students are speaking by not showing up right like by taking their and not in a way of like revolting or anything else but they're taking their religious holiday and students are not coming to school that day and so I do worry about it being a productive day of learning um and I think if we are to keep
041it there we need to kind of admit to ourselves that it probably isn't a productive day of learning and maybe adjust the curriculum to that uh standpoint where maybe it is more of a fun activity that might actually get kids to want to like fight back on their parents to stay in school that day but then you run into the problem of teachers actually being like being able to you know we'll be running substitute teachers it's costly like there's there's a lot there as opposed to just being religious kind of holiday so that's thank you Miss Hannah anyone else M leki um the half day option um in any experience that you have does that actually solve for absence is both from the teacher and and family perspective um I I feel like there may
042be some families who feel like a half day is okay to miss from time to time particular It lines up with other family plans um for a religious holiday weekend um and faculty I assume even if it's a half day they could observe Good Friday and attend a service in the afternoon they have the ability to say I'm actually going to a morning service or the service is only available to me in the morning or the commute is such that I really can't make this work so that that the half I'm just wondering if if just sort of narrowing sort of the the choices and what the half day does solve for is the last day of school and where that falls okay all right I just wanted to make sure I had that yeah
043clear sort of answer the question you started with I actually don't have experience of having a being an early day I have only ever experienced having school on that day or not having school on that day thank you any else I just think it's great how many people wait in I think that's significant I um and very helpful you know just like it's great I kind of I on The Good Friday thing I I I lean towards either have it or don't have it I'm sort of mixed on the half day um so but it's nice to have a little time to think about it and and I think we're getting great input from everybody on it great okay yeah I mean my my thoughts are um I think the two we issue uh is
044clear I mean I think it makes sense personally but you know beyond what my personal perspective is we have like I said a resounding response to the survey so I don't I don't think there's really a question I mean the the school Community spoken told us clearly what they think we should do it's a calendar that impacts everyone and I think we should probably listen to them um but you know no decisions are being made tonight but that's my perspective so I agree with Mr dial and I think um I think everyone is sort of embracing that but um I could be wrong so I'm not speaking for anyone uh Good Friday I actually think um it's the same I think the survey results are very helpful I think it's a difficult issue because it's
045very important to me um as someone that sits on the board that uh governs our district that uh our Public School District that we we aren't recognizing religious holiday for just one religion um you know we're a secular non-religious institution and we should I think it's an all or nothing proposition that said there are legitimate operational concerns um given the makeup of the community that we serve and the religious beliefs that the vast majority Embrace um so it's a difficult issue but to me the survey results are really helpful because while it's not a resounding 73% that think one thing it is there is clearly a response that has the largest amount of respondents that agree and that is the half day solution so in a situation where I think it's sort of a difficult
046issue to come to consensus on and make a decision on I think that I would turn to the results of the survey that we sent to our stakeholders and to me that's really helpful guidance um and I think that it makes a lot of sense because I think that for the most part those Services those Good Friday services are in the afternoon um certainly in the Catholic church that is a few hundred yards away from our school um it's offered in the afternoon so I think that is a helpful way to address that issue without observing a full day off of school for one particular religion when we don't observe other religious holiday so I think my position is to adopt um the consensus of of both survey responses but we'll see if uh again
047superintendent Shan and I will collaborate on getting some additional reminders out a correction of that last date we'll see if we get more input in person or virtually at the next meeting so we can have a more robust discussion with everyone if not we'll have a similar discussion go around once everyone's had a chance to think about the surveys Maybe get more survey results because we did accurately include the Sur the survey deadline that's what caused me to erroneously insert January 29th as the next meeting so I was thinking we wanted it before the meeting it was 3 P.M before that meeting day but it's 3M on January 29th is when the survey responses are due so we still may get some and it may change things I don't know one way or the other
048doubtful it changes much on the on the winter break uh issue so are there any other thoughts before we move on Mrs Hannah one quick question yes where were where did the teachers lay like did they weigh in on that part like would they show up for a half day or so we didn't separate responses by educator or staff member in family um we just asked and so their responses are sort of moved into the responses of share okay um so I'm thinking just to prepare for the next school committee meeting that I may just update some draft calendars um to to have some updated drafts that include the two weeks for December break PD on the 22nd of December early release on January 30th not February 6 and then one calendar with a um
049half day on Good Friday and one calendar with no school on Good Friday and that way you'll be able to really look and see what those two calendars would look like one last question yes if it's a half day on Good Friday how does that impact the last day of school is that it doesn't it like a half day else before move on superintendent Shannon anything else before we move on pass the superintendent report no that's it all right we'll move into the next block of our agenda which is the teaching and learning section which uh requires me to turn the meeting over to our assistant superintendent Dr Leslie scollins thank you and did you make me a call you I did not I I didn't know so you pleas just well because actually I
050wasn't but then I realized I want to share something so thank you yes um no you are co-host are okay great okay so just quickly our PD day that we had um last week was terrific the middle and high school I've been working really hard on um benchmark assessments and kind of pulling that all together bit more on mapping and so um that was very fruitful for them and the elementary was doing some workshops um between the both schools so that was a really collaborative experience our winter benchmarks are happening for our elementary and middle school your students may have told you so there being assessed midpoint in reading and math through I ready um but what I wanted to share with you and we've been sending this out it was a slow opening for
051this um but we have a Facebook page and here it is and and so um right now I it's the person adding things so it's been a slow roll out um but one of the things I want to share with you is our post from today which I me scroll down so you can see it is that Dr Duncan from the high school her marine biology students presented um and they're going to another group is presenting tomorrow but their research for their course um in conjunction with the Cohasset Center for student Coastal research and it was so impressive so you do this the pictur be better yeah um and so there were four groups I think right um and to have them explain their research their hypothesis what what was exciting for them what they
052learned what the surprises were kind of their impact on their next steps um we had one student actually in this picture she has taken every one of um Dr Duncan's courses and she's upset because this was the last one that she will be able to take um but just the reasons they came into and I think one student here is a is a sailor and so they were really interest it was a lens from which they were looking so um they were just really really interesting I so enjoyed talking with them they did an amazing job presenting like no fear no fear at all just really relaxed and explaining their process um and you can see Mr right here from CCR and our own um Kathy Cudi also because obviously these students took her research
053class in 8th grade so um just a really wonderful wonderful um experience today so um this is my plug for not only our programming but please um like us on Facebook and follow us you'll be getting information from there we're posting things and it's been it I think it it's a nice way for us to get information out we did have Twitter which became X we don't have that anymore this is it and it will be feeding into our website also so Leisa for he's working on that for us oh I sh that's what I have for you quick update today all right well thank you Dr scolin do any members of the committee have any questions for Dr scollins No okay thank you so much Dr scoll we'll move on to our budget resource
054and governance section at which time I turn the meeting to our Director of Finance and operation Susan Owen Miss Owen thank you you sharing I sure can there you are congratulations on your promotion not on this budget right good evening everyone um this is a report on the f25 December um Finance report so it comes from July to December 31st um school budget the voting budget of M23 m99 um I'll get through we we have spended a little over 10 million and we have encumbered supplies materials and projected payrolls purch through the end of the year in the amount of 14,58 this leaves an estimated shortfall of about 740,000 $27 um not a great number but this is definitely a decrease over last month so the budget freeze is starting to to help in lowering
055our shortfall which I wanted to point out we're closely monitoring all accounts um as I said in the budget is frozen we're not allowing anything to go through unless it's Necessities sped tuitions the the same there was a shortfall um last month is about 263,000 that has also decreased to 935 um so again that that could be attendance it could be students it it could it could really vary what what that is is the tour um from now to June will fluctuate depending on attendance results and placements you can see that the budget items are still the same categories that are holding us pulling us back the tuition the utilities the special Transportation the custodio supplies materials or maintenance and than our salaries um we're definitely chipping away and trying our best to decrease that
056number the next area is just um the breakdown by school depending the budget is what each School defended what's been incumbered with the balances what percent has been used and how many ftds of each building and then there is a capital um current year um what was voted and what was voted on the campus stabilization fund as well you can see it here we have a draft um which is changing as we go it's probably change it's probably changed since our last meeting we're working um diligently with leadership and town um lades on to the capital committee to um come up with a very conscience um number because there's only a small amount that has to been spread throughout the whole town so you can see here what our requests have been um this is
057not final this is still in direct form um I don't believe we're meeting with Cal February February May um so this this will definitely um be more finalized and currently it's the top the top number um you see 59570 that number will probably decrease um as we prioritize and decide what we can we can put off for another year and what we can and we still have facilities um we're looking for facilities to help us build a multi-e plan um for the all the asphalt roads and sidewalks and painting carving Etc and all of other it um so that's a to come later not really sure we're just making sure it's on it's on our list it's been on our list for years I know there's a new roads and sidewalks um budget so I'm
058not sure if you that will play a part in this but we still working through that these are our grants um then you can see our balances are low we are spending our grants um wisely but effectively which year we have been receiving less and less in RI and then the same with our rolv accounts um the past years we've had very high balances we have used the revolv accounts to help subsidize our budget over the last few years um some of these accounts can no longer you subsidize more than what what they're eable to be doing um so you can see right now Athletics is running about 55,000 in the red um still has spring fees to come in so that that will certainly make that deficit go away um they just haven't been
059reported because this is through December and the same with that school lunch um we had a very very large balance there but Mr Corona food service director has been very diligent as you continue to hear about all the upgr that he has done and he's probably opening up his own pizza business today get he made strum bullies for everyone I don't know if it was Sample I think it was a sample thing but um I I didn't find out how well that went over but was some strumble with me you L spicy that's what I was that's what I was trying spicy but they were good I ate it I was sampling uh this just gives you breakdown of Staffing by FTE and head count um by grouping has it changed summary by Personnel summ
060by salaries nothing has changed here this gives you each schools and how many how many positions of each in each building and how they're funded no changes here we have not added a lost that here total Grant my grant fund about 11.3 FTE and our resolving fund about 22.9% FTE there is our enrollment for January 1st um and you can see class sizes for for the elementary still very low and then there's a month month of enrollment um in November December and actually January is here as well then we get into our utilities so this is our electric summary um again our kilowatts are pretty much the same as last year um the price is a little bit higher obviously based on cost and gas um gas are firms are down um and our cost
061is also down slight um my guess is after this month it's probably going to be a little bit different um just because of c spell we we're having last year this time we and then we have a food service meal account that um I've been working with to to report each month um so you can see you know it's 60% participation rate this year since 55 last year um Mr condone was here last December and then you can see the November um it was 57 and 52% you can see how many meals was serving um how many breakfasts how many lunches and then how many are being purchased participation rate is definitely definitely up um transportation you know with stairway Transportation our Riders ship um it's increased over the last years you know some of
062our buses are almost out capacity our old boobird um apparently retired in the process of being start bus through town that and the we have a a mini bus that been sitting out of for many many years so we're just trying to offload some of the old old materials supplies materials I didn't want to say the old metal we other um so at this point in in the school year you know our concerns are the same we do have a deficit we are working very hard to um Rectify that by you know freezing budgets and reviewing all of our accounts and working very closely um but you know it's it's again utilities tuitions transportation and some salaries then you know by next month those numbers could be lower um and I know Shannon has more
063based on some of the things we've been doing to help with budget yeah so um you know we have shared that the Hope was that we would be able to share the report from open Architects at this meeting um unfortunately that report hasn't come in yet I did um receive an email from our um um consultant at open Architects on Monday who had shared that he was trying to do a few other things um just to finalize things and to see if there was anything else he could learn um but he and I did meet on Tuesday and so I have some high level information that he is going to share in the report that I can share with you this evening um so first he informed me that what their findings are is that
064our Current financial processes are sound and that we have not found ourselves in this deficit situation as a result of any mismanagement of funds or poor processes um he shared that there is actually a lot that we are doing well um so thank you Miss Owen um he also shared that since the start of the school year he has found that communication and collaboration between the schools and towns has improved and that there's a lot of hope that on both sides that this will continue as will the relationship to collaborate on how to um support the schools financially as we move into the future he emphasized that um it was really nice to see the level of communication and transparency about the current situation while recognizing that we were in a difficult place um he
065shared that the reason that we're in the situation um is is not unlike what Miss Owen has shared is that um though the town has funded the schools above net School spending which I will spend a little bit more time at our next meeting when I present the um FY 26 budget around how we get to net schools funding but although the the town has funded us above net School spending the appropriation doesn't necessarily meet our current needs we are in a place where um there are a lot of costs that are outside of our control and that their increase has helped contribute to the situation that we are in um he did talk about that we are running a very lean budget that there is not a lot of wiggle room for us and
066a lot of that to cut um and recognize that we are trying to make Cuts where we can and a lot of that is exhibited through our current budget freeze um he recognized that we are currently as a district trying to do more with less um but these increased costs are outside of our control um and that we need to continue to look at how we partner with the town and what we do within our district to continue to look at how in um a you know a time like like this in these Economic Times we continue to meet the same levels of service while we are though the town is support of continuously underfunded um and so he shared and I agree that the district when we were building the fy2 budget should have
067made some shifts at that time um or sought out other Revenue sources and so we are in a place where we are looking at both of those things as we look towards the FY 26 budget um and that we are going to have to continue to work with the town to think about how we meet our FY 26 and Beyond needs um you know we don't want to dismantle all of the good that we have done in terms of meeting student needs um that is resulting in high levels of student achievement and we need to really take a close look at how we can achieve both goals continue to meet our student needs and be fiscally responsible um so the bottom line he shared is that you know continue to do what we're doing um
068as Miss Owen alluded to we were able to bring down our deficit by $40,000 the hope is that we will continue to bring that down um you know we froze the budget in November we are finally seeing some of the fruits of that freeze um hoping to continue to close that remaining Gap by June 30th knowing that we are likely not going to close the whole Gap but we have been working and cannot express um more strongly the appreciation for the collaboration of the town in this area um and that you know we will continue to look to how we increase our Revenue um or potentially make some reductions to not impact our current level of service um but to present a More Level FY 26 budget and hopefully by the time we meet again
069we will have the full report so I apologize that we don't have the full report are they going to present that to us we can ask him to come and present if he said he would do that let's do that okay I will let him know okay any questions for either Miss Owen or superintendent Shannon on anything that was just reported to us Mr Carr none from me Mr D no I'm just always so energized after our budget presentation I me to return to you no no I'm good good thank you thank you for the thank the report update and for your report as well Mrs Hannah I have this is leski Miss Owen you reported that we had about an $80,000 decrease in out of District tuitions yes but only a $45,000 decrease in
070the projected shortfall why wouldn't it why wouldn't that $80,000 decrease be reflected in the overall shortfall figure well if some of our costs in different accounts are going up like for example substitute teachers I mean that that account number is going to continue to grow um those numbers are not incum there you know there are some other things that are not encumbered that are be on our control that that are probably increasing you know overtime is needed substitute teachers things like that um that those numbers are probably going up why some of the others are going down um so it was probably you know more of a savings um but considering we're in you know another month out um our our expenses are going to continue to rise in some areas some C okay does
071the $45,000 decrease in the overall shortfall figure reflect the over incumbrances that we had made I'm not sure I F the question well you had I thought we had we had over encumbered certain amounts like we had we yes overestimated the amounts that we we we slightly overestimated the um incum payroll for the end of June um and each month I plug in the actual payroll with which subtracts off that amount um so that also could play a part in some of this as well um but I have not adjusted those I don't want to say buildup of um or the over estim overestimation of incumbent they have not changed so okay hopefully there when we come to the end of June that there will be some um some money remaining there in the incoming
072purchase order for the Sal okay did that answer your question cor yes the answer I think was no but that's because they can't be reflected yet but they may once we get to that point in time and then that whatever our reduced shortfall is may be reduced further at that time or it may not be yes that's safe to say okay uh lastly once we have a lot going on here with your department so um I don't want to overburden you so once we sort of get through the budget season can you make a note to have Mr cordone come and give us a presentation on what he's been doing uh specifically I'd be interested in um improvements but also I'm looking at I'm glad by the way we're we're starting to use that food
073the um sorry the school lunch revolving oh yeah um because it was a huge amount of money and we we always had that and we weren't improving the program so now we are but I'd be interested to know what we're spending on sure so I have um Shan and I have talked and I I've already asked Mr kadon um to prepare some type of presentation for the spring great um on basically what's been happening what's he been doing and what his future you know future plans are what he sees happening um for us going forward um and you know he's got some Desy requirements that that need to adjust um fees but well second L just basically okay perfect you're a step ahead of the game thank you so much I appreciate it thank your
074report anything else anyone before we move on okay thank you Miss Owen moving on to block G which is community relations and communication reserved essentially for uh subcommittee and liaison reports subcommittee Andor liaison reports so we'll just go around in alphabetical order and if you have anything to report feel free to share with the group Mr Carr Mr dial nothing Mrs Hannah all set Mrs leski school meeting next week um okay um I do not think I have anything to sh share from my committees at this time um so yeah so no report okay well that one was quick um moving on to um the last the penultimate block of the agenda uh school committee governance uh we do have our goals um better late than ever uh prepared for everyone for a vote this
075these goals Incorporated everyone's input and was the product of a group collaboration um Mrs Lei took the laboring or on putting these together they appear as item H1 in your packet and as we had discussed at our strategic planning Forum slw Workshop moments ago or prior to this meeting um I did suspect that we made a in inadvertently uh followed the current strategic plan which we did there are four goals and each is reflective of a different compass point of the current uh Andor uh terminating strategic plan uh which is teaching and learning social emotional growth resources and Community engagement so um our goals always want to be reflective of the Strategic plan and they are in this in this case um these are the goals that we had um that we had come up
076with I don't know if superintendent Shannon might be able to retrieve or Dr scollins might be able to retrieve there's the email that went out from miss serus that had the school committee packet material so maybe there's a way while we're talking for you to I would do it but I can't access my email on this computer I have you can do that there's no pressure just take your time see if you can figure it out um Miss ly do you want to leave the conversation or introduce this at all or make any remarks don't have to if you don't feel like need to but no I think that it you know the bulk of this came from the workshop that we had had um back in the fall just reflects sort of this year
077that is a bridging moment in time um to connect to strategic plans but we'll s of serve as beacons to guide um us for and some of the things we've already I think accomplished and um other other items on the goals um will be work to prise thank you yeah so I think if you look at like so take the second goal for example support students physical and mental Wellness um we have a um very timely example of that today with Jack herne's uh presentation uh the the representative from the superintendent student advisory Council where he discussed the new cell phone policy which is and we head here as one of our strategic initiatives or as the Strategic initiative to encourage Community discourse on healthy child development by identifying and or hosting three or more
078discussions forums or presentations we've had one of those um which was the an Generation Um for and from it um the cell phone Task Force was born and we now are about to roll out that policy so that is an example of how we've accomplished at least part of these goals we're looking for ideally three of them and uh actually Mr Scott had just suggested another one and the topic escapes me at the moment do you recall superintendent Shannon what Mr Scott was talking about he was suggesting another Community read he is I think was it based on achievement it's achievement it's um um I have the book on my desk not enough no I have the book on my desk and I started reading it and it's about um sort of achievement culture and
079how um achievement culture can is great and has a flip side that um has impact on student mental health and wellbeing um and just as is on the side having attended a lot of the school committee forums I will be surprised that that doesn't come up as a theme um as we look at our strategic plan so it's called Never Enough by Jennifer Walls y um I just um was able to bring up thank Scott email so um he sent I don't know who he had sent it out to a few of us uh I was on there PSO buttonwoods and so we're thinking of doing a sort of similar we had a lot of success from a lot of participation from the community I should we had success generating a lot of participation from
080the community in connection with the anent generation so I think Brian Scott principal Scott excuse me is looking to replicate that uh effort so he's suggesting this and I think it's probably something will it makes sense yeah so you know more to come on that but that's an example of how we're progressing and and and and keeping in line with our goals an example of another example is our fourth goal Empower constituents um which is really I think I like that better than Community engagement because it it I think carries with it uh a sense of or or or impresses the communicates the importance of providing agency to our stakeholders and also so holding ourselves accountable and one thing that um Mr leki and I have recently done is we've put together so remember we've
081been talking about this community resource guide where we're trying to send this out and derive input from various community members about what they might be willing to contribute connected to their expertise uh so for example Mr car has a lot of expertise in government um um and maybe you would be willing to I'm not volunteering your time I'm speaking hypothetically uh host an internship for a student or make a presentation in a class or something like that this is just pure example um you would then um indicate that you are in the you know law social studies government area and that this is specifically what you do and then we would be able to compile a guide for all the teachers to utilize when they're they're you know working on different units and different um
082topics that they're strucking students on in the classrooms and it can I think deliver a more meaningful memorable learning experience and turn towards more of this project based learning approach that our superint superintendent is somewhat of an expert in and so we just developed that I think uh s we haven't I I think we're about to send it out to the community I I so superintendent Shannon I think I need to just finalize that with you I'll swing by so we can send it out like this start getting it out there because I think it's going to require like a a little bit of a push like over time to get people to do this but um I think people are going to be really interested in in doing it I think it's I think
083it's going to be effective so we're we've started that that's a big deal if we can get that done so um I don't know if anyone has any discussion on any of this or any points anything any comments any corrections edits revisions whatever anyone fire will there's a small great on two perfect no I think that's founds some discussions and founds good this is good is good thank you miss anything else anyone else seeing anything else okay so while we're making um correction maybe Mrs leski as you have the document maybe we can just put the titles above the the Dark boxes the colored box the navy blue boxes like maybe we can ship that down a little bit and put teaching and learn like mirror it to the compass points just put teaching and
084learning social emotional growth um just so it's clear anyone else excellent okay so is there a motion to approve the goals as revised given the comments tonight so mov motion been made by Mr D there second second seconded by m Hannah all in favor I I all opposed exensions great that motion unanimously carries Mrs leski thank you so much for doing that and um Mrs leski would you mind once you make those revisions to just send it to um superintendent Shannon and CC misus so that they are able to post it on the website for us somehow y or direct it to the appropriate person that would be able to do that that one um thank you are we gonna host a f on this multiple multiple um next item on the agenda are the
085topics not recently anticipated nothing was brought to my attention approval of minutes Mr Carr do we have any n to but I'll have some for next meeting perfect and um Mr dial and I will we're going to have some for the Forum we just attended the the um uh strategic planning forum and the meting and the um that just occurred uh the um budget Workshop yes thank you which was entirely in executive session and then there's executive session minutes that we need to do we have those yet no that's with me okay so we need to vote on whether we're going to just declassify certain executive session minutes yes let's try and do that U Mr I'll help you let's try and get that done so we're we're good to go next time so there's
086no approval minutes and there are there will be no reason to move into executive session I don't believe unless still want to give an update okay so um I won't skip the future agenda items what um do any are there any items that that any members of the committee would like to see discussed at a future meeting that are on your mind just fire will I'm not sure if I've said this before to be on agenda but interested in sort of the progress with the evaluation of the writing curriculum and any potential changes yeah okay all right so that's still of interest to me great yep yep yep and I think that would I think that would be probably once we get through the budget season that' be the best thing so still they're still
087meeting so right yeah right so that'll give us time maybe in the spring Dr scin that seem like the Tim would be right proper facil anything else great Zanna nothing okay nothing with Athletics I always have questions I'll spare you guys right now Mr anyut agenda items you'd like to see no I think they're they're all queued up okay great so with that there is a reason to move into executive I was mistaken I was thinking the only thing we had placed on there had placed that on the agenda was for the consideration of declassification of minutes but we uh also want to discuss collective bargaining strategy so we are going to look for a motion or I am going to seek a motion executive session for reason number three uh in Mass general laws
088Chapter 30 cap a section 21 Mr Carr moved by Mr Carr is our second second seconded by Mr dial we need to take a roll call vote in alphabetical order Mr Carr car I Mr dial I Mrs Hannah hi Mrs leski hi and the chair also votes in favor of the motion so un man carries we will not be reconvening in regular session so for all of you you that are watching at home on Facebook or on Zoom we thank thank you so much for your participation and we look forward to seeing you soon on February 5th 2025 have a nice night