001hey good evening everyone welcome to the February 5th 2025 meeting of the cassa public schools school committee with all members in attendance please Nick gate so and roll call Mr Carr present Mr D was not present Hannah Mr leki present chair is also present giving us a panel of four out of five members which is a quum would all who are able please rise for the reputation of our nation Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag United States Amer naice thank you very much I officially call the meeting to order and remind everyone that the meeting is being recorded and live streamed uh by Facebook it's being broadcast on c43 TV and one can also participate virtually by accessing Zoom uh through the link that's uh appears at the top of our agenda
002and you can participate by utilizing a Q&A feature on Zoom speaking of which uh the first agenda item as always is a public comment and we'll provide those uh who are either in attendance or who are participating virtually with a moment to make public comment public comment is the section of the agenda um section of meeting excuse me reserved for uh comments or thoughts or questions that do not relate to something that's already on our agenda if you have a question or comment or discussion point on something that's already on the agenda just wait until we ride that point the meeting we'll be happy to hear from you so at this point I would give a moment to those that are participating virtually to utilize a Q&A feature on zoom and type out a comment
003or question a few moments to do that and we'll be periodically monitoring this as well so if you miss your opportunity don't worry we want to hear from everyone uh but this is the designated place that we would provide you to do that right now anyone here that wants to make public comment no everyone's attending the art show that we're about to say okay I don't see any so we'll move on move right into our uh invited guests and at this time we're welcoming um Miss burwitz and students to present on a recent art project which uh a few of us had the opportunity to see in progress today could could you give me sharing Mor is here too um sharing rights but I'm going to share presentation thank you for having us I'm Stephanie
004morard the department head for Vis Performing Arts um we're honored to be here tonight to present uh a new Endeavor this year and I'm going to be very brief because the students are more important and we'll get right into the slideshow um but the Vision was to bring to life one of the core values of our uh art program which is community um and that's some through collaboration and teamwork and all these amazing things that you're going to hear from the students uh and see in our presentation tonight but the the goal was to engage students of all ages we had kindergarteners through 12th graders in collaborative spaces with very few very few rules and lots of supplies so the mess the laughter um The Joy was incredible and I definitely think that your meeting
005is far more beautiful this evening not that you aren't all a wonderful backdrop but due to the final pieces um created by our students so I thank you very much for uh the support of many people who allowed this day to occur and I would be remiss not to recognize the wonderful art teachers who are in the room Miss burz Miss Anthony Miss hon miss shru and Mrs Schwarz who dedicate um countless hours beyond what we can see to these kids difference for so many so I would like to turn it over to miss burkit who will give you a more vibrant recollection of the day okay okay so we have a short slideshow we'll go through it and tell you about how the day went um we advertised for this for a little while
006a couple of weeks where students we had 81 kids accepted students applied by filling out a short questionnaire the younger kids had to just answer some questions and the older students had to to write an essay about why they wanted to be part of the Arts and then they brought with them their favorite piece of art that they were most proud of to share with each other today um we obviously Miss Mor already already thanked all of these people but the cafeteria staff and the custodial staff really helped us today um the elementary kids thought that the lunch was they would not stop talking about here um these were some of the answers to some of the questions that especially the younger students wrote about why they love art um and we love we we
007brought it up throughout the day we loved that they could be creative they went through all of our materials they told us how it's so calming to be in a space where they can be themselves and use materials and not have to talk and be able to talk if they want to and be able to share with each other and be themselves so these were some of the comments that they made in their applications on um we asked them to ask to tell us what their teachers would have said the three words that describes them best for um we showed them this slide actually when we presented the whole program today but we spent the day the idea was that kids connected with each other so many young kids went back saying they made new
008friends met older students that they connected with I think we've got a couple of babysitting jobs lined up um but it was really I mean the conversations that were going on and the way that these especially these kids over here were talking to the talking to the younger students I heard them talking to them like they were their peers and in a but in a very appropriate way and asking you know what they love about art what they're doing at in school themselves what they do after school what they're going to do later so it was that that in itself besides what they made for art today was amazing um they talked about Community they talked about what community is to them there were some kindergarteners that came back to the room and said what
009is community no like really what is it like they did it wasn't that they couldn't Define it it was that they still needed someone to teach them about it and it was it was so sweet so they all got together they came up with lists about what community was to them and then on the next page I think so this is their brainstorming session in the morning we did a slideshow they broke up into groups you can keep going um and these were the things that they said Community meant to them they were talking about their homes their houses their pets who lives in their homes who lives near their homes who lives on their streets and then they got bigger you know what it's like to live in this town what it's like to
010live in a town like this what it's like to be part of um they did some sketches they came up with their own ideas some kids did sketches that they wanted to keep some kids cut out pieces of those sketch skes that they end up using later some of them translated them into something else going these were just some highlights um and then the biggest thing was that it's a it was a mixed media project there were really not a lot of rules we'll go on to the rules on the next page they had to say within the rectangle they could use any of the techniques that we kept giving them so many kids kept saying they never tried this and they never tried that one of our our favorite things was I didn't know
011that I could glue so many things onto a canvas I thought it had to be paint they went through all of our drawers and found I mean there are like earrings hanging on some of the pieces and turned into something different like it looks like it came out of the ocean and is hanging on netting you if you get close you'll see some of that stuff so all of the different art teachers gave different techniques our Advanced students taught them techniques and you can go on the biggest rule was that you were kind to each other listened to each other and explor the materials and really they followed the rules those were the they were they had a great time so we just celebrated upstairs um with a little reception and it had a huge
012turnout and a million thank you and we have many more pictures that you don't have to um that we didn't put up on the slideshow so if anybody wants to see them at another part another part in the day um so we asked the kids at the end we did a little culminating group session in the hallway um what their best parts of the day were making art with friends working together combining all of their creativity um at the bottom we said this was one of the highlights with was there were so many ideas and everybody worked off with each other's ideas which we really liked what did I learn today art can be 3D other than clay lots of mixed media can you be used I learned all about new tools one of the
013kits talked about how they never knew you could use a paint roller as a tool in an art room like they were using forks and toothbrushes and one girl was dipping a pencil in paint looking guilty and I said go for it you know like they as as long as you clean the pencil when you're finished um so and one of the things that one of the students said that I thought was brilliant was working with the community makes our community stronger who knows um and these were things that they thought were really important to illustrate in their pieces what our community specifically is and they said family togetherness different ideas inclusivity blue and white kindness things that we love there are a lot of cars and just things that kids connect to and there
014were there was uh one of the highlights also that we didn't talk about putting in here was there were there were groups of kids taking a high school student and just talking about things they liked and then putting them in there Taylor Swift and cars and spaceships and but it's part of their Community because what they all agree that they love and shared with each other um and of course another quote we liked was that there's space for everyone to be celebrated Sports arts and anything in between these were things that they were proud of everyone's excitement every art piece that they made they were really showing them up to their families just now overcoming challenges and what they were talking about was that they would get through something that wasn't working somebody would have
015an idea and they would get through it um and they had a really just had a really great time and these were just some of the comments at the end of the day and I wrote thank you three times because we got thank yous all day long so we have one more little piece that we would like to share with you and we have a few high school students that just wanted to read a little bit about the Arts being important can we have you can we just have you come over here so hear you and I love that you want to say something on your own off [Music] the um I just wanted to say that I really like that like as soon as we walked in almost immediately every question was can I
016do this am I allowed to do this can I use this and I kind of just said you know you're allowed to do whatever you want because there really are no rules when it comes to Art you're the point is to express yourself however you feel is fit for you and so I think that's really important to be to a room for the first time at a young age and to be allowed to do whatever you want with you know materials and resources that are very generously provided by the arts department um yeah I just think that was really important and I got a lot of questions of like am I allowed to do this like I said and I kind of just gave them a creative Liberty to just do whatever they wanted because
017I think that's really important in developing minds and kind of being able to have an outlet to express yourself um because that's what I do um but yeah so research consistently highlights the significant importance of art education in schools studying art can positively impact student engagement academic achievement create creativity critical thinking self-esteem and overall well-being our education can Foster collaboration cultural understanding and problem solving skills across various disciplines we would like to share some key findings from research conducted by the National Endowment for the Arts regarding art in schools um I also agree with S I think it just gives you like a bigger sense of like Independence as well just I don't know as a child you don't have a lot of freedoms and just giving that little bit is is really important my
018little reading here improved academic performance studies of Link increased Arts education with higher test scores better writing abilities and improved academic achievement across subjects including Math and Science um I'll add on again to this I guess for me in my life it's kind of fitting here at a school committee I am somebody who definitely looks towards creativity when it comes to critical thinking things like that and I do kind of wish sometimes that I had more opportunities like this to learn in an environment that's more artistic like I I love music I do a lot of music in my free time had I done that more in my life I feel like I might have enjoyed learning almost not that I didn't enjoy it things like that um just yeah this enhanced creativity and critical
019thinking engaging in art activities encourages students to think creatively explore different perspectives and develop solving skills which are valuable in all areas of life I also want to add on to what I was saying just because Grayson something that um I think that like when I saw the reactions to telling them that they had the Liberty to do whatever they'd like with whatever they'd like it was almost really not emotional but it was really eye opening to see the sparkle in their eyes that I had from such a young age and that I still carry with me um and to kind of like see that the first time in Young Artists is really important because art is changing rapidly and you know not there isn't a big portion of people who are really interested and
020really passionate about art and pursuing that and I think that giving that to them today was really important okay thank you very much guys thank you so we felt we felt the support today and the love and I hope they felt it because they were rock stars so thank you for giving us does anyone have any questions for any of our students about the experience anyone you fire will any the committee members any comments anything I have a goofy job I have to keep not I'm s spear I'm isab all right very cool you got to do more of this yeah yeah absolutely I just want to give like applause amens all around um 100% these are the things that we need to be doing for our kids I love the approach that you brought
021that was I mean I think when you said you were like emotional about kids like lighting up when knowing that they had freedoms to use their own sort of creativity around materials and tools it it I'm emotional about that because I think that they should be learning that when are in preschool kindergarten all the way through and that really making that a a sort of hmark of Arts education is the freedom to be make decisions and to use your creativity and think critically um and those things are so connected and I'm just major Applause so excited this was I I hope the tip of Iceberg of a sort of movement forward um for the district and thank you for being um sort of leaders uh you know peer leaders and I think that multi-age creation
022and teaching and learning is also incredibly important um so I'm just tinle pink thank you thank you too oh that was a colorful little not unintentional can I ask a question that I kind of know the answer to but I think it would be great to share is first of all what the public can't see is the actual artwork that here is here in front of us which is amazing so we're going to make sure that we get that out um probably on our Facebook page and of that but what's happening with all this thank I realized that we didn't um we made six pieces to be hung in all of the public schools indefinitely you know until it for whatever reason it's time to move on but the kids are waiting to find out
023which one is going to be in their school and we have two that maybe one could go down to the central office and maybe one could be in the learning Commons or maybe they find a place in town I don't know but maybe that's your conversation and do you did you how are they being assigned or chosen or is that up to it's a good question okay because we want to make sure the public can see them because they're amazing yeah they we were impressed too that Anor pictures yes good awesome that's good to know thank you so thanks to everyone that was involved this and you guys for you know your courage coming up and speaking about it uh I mean total win-win situation right because each of you uh got some value out
024of it and uh I know that the kids that I saw them and it's just generally cool to be around older kids right we all thought that when we were younger and you can tell in there it was like a little bit more the students were acting more as the teachers than the actual teachers were and that in end of itself um I think maybe extends a little bit of Independence right um but also I think that this experience speaks to speaks volumes uh and to which spit and you already know but how important the Arts are um and how we all have different interests and um you know different Outlets to express ourselves so it's important that we never forget how important the Arts are sometimes we would be you know maybe overfocused uh
025on Ela or you know math uh science the mic realm or Athletics or athletic realm um but you know the Arts are super important too and uh not just Visual Arts um you know music as well Performing Arts all of it so thank you guys so much it was really it was it is super interesting to hear your perspective and uh I found it I found it really interesting so thank you so much for for presenting this and yeah we can't wait to display all these I'll just note that um so when I was asking one of the students I think she's like a fifth grader what um um U maybe she was fourth grader she was doing this one over here and the people that are participating virtually can't see but um I asked
026them like what was I didn't know what the assignment was right so I was asking them what was the deal like oh we're supposed to be creating this you know representation of our community and uh so they're pointing out some things and I was like oh and like you've got some mountains here they're like yeah that's someone climbing Everest and I was like oh like cuz it's awesome it's great you know so it's just was it was fun you know to see uh just again like right like whatever's on their mind like no rules right so I just thought that was kind of funny so thank you so much uh big round of applause [Applause] for thank you guys oh and all our principles were here in support as well I see principal Mills from
027the Middle School Sullivan Hill School got from oood and principal Scott what's that yes you guys are going to have to do that I think we should do like a roach show and they go to all the buildings for a while so that all the kids can see them that's a great idea um okay so before we move on Miss crims when if you want to yeah there's not going to be any there're AR going any more inperson visitors so if you want to take a seat at the table there's space for you now if you want to come up here I thought that was chy well she still here um no she left um Ken and I were gonna go Pocus before the close session just making good on our promise so so much
028all right the seats available whenever you want it um so we'll move into the next uh block of our agenda which is budget resources governance block D we're going to start that with a presentation from open architect she an outside consultant that we engaged recently I'll turn the meeting over to our superintendent of schools uh Miss Sarah Shannon to introduce that part portion of our meeting Shan okay thank you very much so um yes we have been talking about the open Architects report and so we have TJ plant here with us from open Architects he is going to spend a little bit of time tonight reviewing some of his findings um strengths areas of that need to be addressed and then some recommendations for us um and so he will present and then there'll be
029opportunities to ask him questions so um TJ I you all set to yeah I'm ready I'm ready to go thank you superintendent um so my name is TJ plant I work for a Consulting and data Company open Architects uh and we were tasked to kind of look at um some uh risk assessments related to the finances and so today I'm going to uh present on some of the areas that have been really strong and some of the areas that uh may need some improvement uh but just by B uh by way of background uh I have about 25 years experience in uh public sector Finance um I've been a school CFO I've been a municipal CFO and I've worked in uh the state house uh Senate ways and me for a number of years so
030I have a broad-based background and I've been working closely with the superintendent on this we have interviewed in my count at least 15 people on both City or excuse me town and school side to kind of g gauge uh where uh coet is coass schools are so um I will just kind of dive in uh the strengths I think the first strength that we've noticed is that there's a improved collaboration between the town and the schools and that is monthly meetings that uh started I believe back when you started superintendent um with the town manager the board of Selectmen uh school committee uh and other folks that may need to be part of those meetings and I think that is a huge step forward to be able to communicate uh the challenges that Cohasset schools
031are facing uh but more importantly uh it trickled down to the Departments because uh in our conversations with all the various departments it trickled down to uh the collaboration that both the town and the schools want to do together whether it's HR whether it's payroll whether it's benefits whether it's any of those things which uh is fantastic because that's opening up the lines of communication and kind of getting um the schools in the town on the same page as it relates to that um there's challenges and I'll get to those in a minute but just by way of it's not lost on this group because there is definitely um a challenge related to FY 25's budget and the potential deficit um so I know that's not lost but the spending freeze was put into into
032place on November 1st and that is not easy to do uh in a school district as you're trying to educate kids uh but sometimes it's a little necessary to try to stop the bleeding and make sure that you kind of find Solutions uh you run a lean budget there aren't a lot of Frills in the budget um it's just kind of covers exactly what uh coet schools need and but you have strong processes internal processes both on the town and on the school side which is huge uh to make sure that you have um the resources you need and that you're you know and you like I'll just I'll use an example like the the process to onboard is pretty tight um on both sides how you get folks hired and uh through the process
033and benefits are strong there's very low risk in the benefits area um the town does a good job on behalf of the schools uh so that student services I can't say enough about uh how impressed we were with student services and their projections and how accurate they were based upon um what their needs are or their budget needs are so I mean those are definitely huge uh strengths and I don't know superintend if I missed a couple but those are the big ones in my mind y um challenge wise uh I'm just going to focus on the ones that are um we would we would say critical or high uh based upon our experience in open Architects and our experience and the industry um the first one is long-term planning and multi-year financial planning uh
034there isn't really a lot a lot of um everything seems to be shortterm and trying to put out fires rather than long-term looking at everything and that's something that uh creates a challenge for and we'll get to that too collective bargaining creates a challenge for some of the unforeseen circumstances creates a challenge for um you know making sure you can align Staffing to the budget and that has been kind of a big challenge for Cohasset is just making sure that your FTE match your budget match your needs and you know longterm what that looks like and that so that a recommendation at the end will be something related to that um and then looking at and there's definitely I know kassa goes after a lot of Grants and Kaza does not necessarily win a lot
035of Grants um and that's a challenge but uh I give you know kudos to the team that I keep trying to find alternative funding sources to help uh the students of Cohasset so um the next one is we look at a domain of like how do you deal with unforeseen budget circumstances and right now between the last couple years uh CPS has had some challenges you've tapped out your resources and now you're facing a deficit for potential deficit for fiscal 25 and you don't have a lot of we call them blueberry pots like a place to go and find money to solve a problem and um you know there there aren't a lot of places to go um so we we consider that a a pretty high risk and that you know we don't want
036to create further strain and we know FY 26 is uh already going to pose a challenge and I know I've had conversations with many folks in coet about it uh for now that we know the governor's number but we could kind of work through some of that stuff and I know we met with the town as well um but yeah so there's definitely some challenges as it AR uh as you don't have like circuit breaker you've had to deplete your version of circuit not version but your um appropriation of circuit breaker to balance the budget so you don't like in our world circuit breaker if you could be strategic enough you push it out a year because it's you get it for two years and if you have the ability but uh right now um
037you've had to tap into all of your resources and the town's resources to solve 24's problems and you're probably going to tap into some resources for um the other one is uh position control and hiring uh position control is probably a big one is there's no clear position control and that really comes down to um how do you make sure you have the FTE you need and how do you make make sure you uh account for them and their salaries and project out into um the remainder of the fiscal year plus also future fiscal years and taken into account collective bargaining and what that looks like uh and so there's a lot of that um it's done on spreadsheets right now which is we call Shadow systems and it doesn't need to sound Shady but
038like I mean you don't have a clear system and I'm going to get to an Erp system but um but yeah so there's definitely like everyone seems to be doing what they can what they can do with the systems that they have uh there's disparate systems um so there's a lot of systems that we could kind of pull together and I'll get into that in a in a minute and then the final highrisk category and this is certainly not lost on anyone in this room is that the collective bargaining agreements that are coming up uh in in June and I think everyone's seen what's going on around the Commonwealth between the strikes and the just share amount of requests from the unions on and the sustainability of what both the schools and and or the
039town can afford and that uh poses a risk to coath it and I have no idea what the bargaining strategy is going to be but uh we just know uh if the town can only afford a certain amount and you uh are get as being requested for higher than that and you're trying to do higher than that then then it just requires other budgetary decisions so so that's the update the recommendations uh in in our minds is an Enterprise System an Erp system that kind of pulls together all your uh payroll and uh position control and all these other things into one system and it doesn't have to be what is known as munice munus is the big one that's kind of around that most cities towns and uh school districts use but um it's
040a similar system like that where you have a contract module you have the requisition process with proper workflow you have all these different uh and you pull everything together so it's not four or five different systems um position control just pull that out by it by itself that is huge just so you know uh your vacancies you know um how many positions you need to fill in terms of or you want to fill based upon the budget and you make sure that HR and um payroll or talking uh to each other through a system like that uh right now spreadsheets are are fine but it does pose a little risk when if they're not updated in timely enough fashion to really understand the needs because I mean I everyone everyone here understands that trying to
041educate students trying to run a school system and educate students is really the top goal and you're trying to generate a surplus and you know generate free cash what's what's known as free cash in the municipal side and it's really trying to make sure you have the you understand where you're at so you can reinvest the funds quickly uh to make sure you're maximizing education so uh that's kind of an issue budget planning um making sure that your budget process is sound I know superintendent you're presenting tonight on the budget uh tonight uh and then a multi-year financial plan is looking out looking back three years and then Out 3 to five depending on what you want just to have a sense and it doesn't need to be 100% accurate it just needs to have
042uh enough information to kind of know where you're heading so when you go into negotiations or when you go into um contract negotiations with a vendor or when you have a spike in something you're not aware of you can just be just know like like what that's going to mean long term um I just ask you to try and wrap up in the next two minutes because I was just G to say I am absolutely looking at my notes and I am done so all right perfect that works too uh any members of the committee have any questions uh from Mr Plant relative to uh anything he just presented excellent work so Mr PL I I do have a question um you mentioned some of your recommendations uh is there a recommended next step like
043in terms of you know doing a a deep dive into the actual numbers the financials and uh if so uh you know is that costing the district extra to do that to have open Architects do that if so how much so I don't have a I don't have a number if is anything um I did have a quick conversation with the superintendent earlier today that if your data that comes from soft is I won't say clean but easy to maneuver like you can get it out into an Excel spreadsheet and we can kind of manipulate it and do a payroll projection on your behalf uh and then do a PO projection or encumbrance projection like that's probably going to be minimal if if at all like we like if we we could probably manipulate that
044and turn something around with relative speed if the data is harder to like harder to mine the data or get it out of the system then we might have a different conversation but I would I would love for us just to send you a data request and get the information and then see what that looks like and then have a further conversation okay that'd be helpful and and those those two um processes that you described would would that be uh would would that be trying to target areas of waste or redundancy to try and uh identify areas that we may be able to realize some level of savings and mitigate our current shortfall yes that's the hope the hope is to is this is the lad uh is to say okay we're going to tighten
045up a payroll projection based upon all the collective bargaining agreements based upon the salaries based upon the assumptions in the budget and then uh do that for salaries and then do that for the OT we call otps other than personal services the below the salary line um and try to figure out if there's areas that can just kind of grab some savings it will solve the whole problem I'm not sure but at least we can tighten up the budget okay well we'll be interested in exploring that next step with you um so we'll we'll get back to you on the platform whether it's going to be easy to extract that dat data as you just described and if so then you know we'll be looking forward to seeing uh what if any extra cost that
046may be uh for the district so thank you so much for your presentation and for your uh your attendance here tonight Mr Plant thank you so much we'll talk soon okay thank you thank you all right moving right along into the uh the primary budget presentation superintendent Shannon share my screen so the information you just heard from TJ was really looking at this current year what I'm about to present is um looking forward to FY 26 which is the 25 26 school year um I'm trying to accomplish a little bit of two things in the presentation um because I think that there are a lot of people interested in our budget for next year so I'm trying to one educate folks on how schools are funded and how we specifically look to fund our schools
047and what we are looking to do for next year because we have been two years in a row um running at a deficit and we need to create a y 26 budget that is a balanced budget that is fiscally responsible um I will preface this with um it's a bit hard to give firm number information for this coming school year because there are a lot of unknowns um some of those unknowns are we're unsure where the governor's budget is going to land so the governor's budget just came out her first draft that still has to go through its process and then the town will know exactly what numbers come out of the governor's budget that benefits the town um the other thing and Mr Plant alluded to this is that we are currently in negotiations
048with all five of our unions and so it's really hard to predict where we will land in terms of salary increases for the staff and so we had to build budget not quite knowing what that real number will be um and then the other thing we're going to talk about is you know there's two ways to to close a budget shortfall one is to reduce but the other is to increase revenue and so you'll see in this presentation where there are opportunities to in increase Revenue um through different areas of of or different ways of doing that through fees and through other things so this is a draft FY 26 budget is the first attempt um we are looking to as we come back each time to talk about budget have more firm information um
049and we're also looking to continue to collaborate and partner with folks as we try and think about how we continue to solve this problem as we move forward um so just a few context sitting items so our budget is really designed to help us meet our mission vision and core values as a district we are a district that puts students first so this is a budget that put students first um it is a budget that is designed to help us meet our vision of a graduate and it is Guided by our FY 26 budget priorities we shared and you approved our budget priorities a couple months ago and these are really based on our goals and the former strategic plan that many of those themes will be through lines into the new strategic plan as
050well it's also designed to help move us into the future as we have been working on the feasibility study at the middle school and high school level we've been talking about what we want education to look like in the cassa public school schools in the future it's not that work hasn't just been what does it look like at the middle school and high school it's also what does it look like across the entire district one of the things that our current budget has worked towards is creating opportunities for students that we don't want to see dismantled we want to in continue to move forward with those and enhance them um and this is a budget that is really trying to prioritize some of those things and and maintain some of what makes us so great
051so it's a long process to design a school budget takes takes the better part of a year actually um we start talking about the budget in the fall um Mr Plant alluded to the fact that chair mlen and I have been meeting with the town manager and the chair of the select board monthly to keep on track of where we are budgetarily um I've been meeting with all of our principles and our directors to think about what the different budgets look like where there is room to potentially make reductions where there is opportunity to increase Revenue um and we worked together on January 21st so a combination of our administrative leadership team with members of the school committee and that was really a great session because we talked about a lot of things and um
052some creative ideas came out of that I really feel strongly that our teachers are the backbone of our school district and I think they see a lot of things and so I presented this budget presentation to them on Monday in different forums a secondary forum and an elementary forum and you know ask them what their ideas were um one I think this impacts them on a day-to-day basis in a really real way but also where do they see some some efficiencies um and there in some ways still thinking about that but in other ways some ideas came forward that actually have landed in this presentation so we're grateful for their collaboration in this effort today is our first preliminary budget presentation to you we will continue to discuss this um over the next few meetings
053um there will likely be a joint school committee and select board an advisory meeting with a public budget hearing on March 19th and then on April 2nd will be the day that you as the school committee vote for our budget so that we can bring it forward to town meeting on May 12th and that's when our budget is finally truly truly set and approved um there are several types of budgets that exist within our school department and and in any organization even families right um and so you can have a fully funded budget that is everything all your hopes and dreams um and I'm going to talk about what that could include for us um in a minute you can have a level service budget that means that you have the exact same level of
054service that we provide for students currently um and that everything we have this year is paid for in full for next year you can also have a level funded budget meaning you get x amount of money in fy2 which is our current school year and we're going to give you that exact same amount of money for FY 26 we know that already we don't have enough money in FY 25 so it definitely wouldn't be enough money for us in FY 26 so really that level funded budget becomes a reduction budget and so we really are in a place where we need to reduce but you'll see that we are looking to actually short lessen that shortfall through a variety of ways outside of just reductions and there are very specific drivers that Force us to
055make decisions when we're designing our budget um and some of those are contracted salaries special education costs facilities and maintenance class size course offerings transportation in fees and many of most of our money is in contracted salaries but you heard um Mr Plant re um talk about those other things those other things do make a difference in our budget and so talking about what our budget breakdown is the majority of our budget is salaries um it is really over 80% of our budget and a lot of these other areas while there are things like professional development where we have the opportunity to make reductions but like utilities we don't have any real control over what utilities charge us um and so there are some of these where we have some ability to make an impact
056and some where we don't and so like I said 84% of our school budget is salary and there are two types of contracts there are personal service contracts and there are union contracts across the entire district there are 24 personal service contracts and we have five Union contracts and all five of those Union contracts will expire at the end of this current school year and we will be and are currently in negotiations with all of them um for the 25 26 school year and for anyone who's curious how does that 84% of budget sell salaries break down this is how it breaks down um and you know we are nothing without our Educators um and without the folks in this District who are supporting our students um because every adult in this building supports our
057students in some way special education costs also play into our budget um we have a variety of special ed services that I'll talk a little bit more about we have actually a really nice Continuum of service here in Cohasset for being such a small district and we are continuing to think about how we expand that Continuum of service but one thing that does come out a lot is the out ofd District costs for Cohasset students we have several really amazing members of our Cohasset Community who need to be educated in in a different setting um and so we provide that per their IEP and their Special Education team makes those decisions but there's this group that's called the operational service Division and they help set rates for those out of district tuitions and you heard
058Mr Plant talk about how we had to use two years worth of circuit breaker funding in order to cover some of our special education costs the reason for that is because in FY 24 out of District tuitions went up 14% there is no school district that had planned for and prepared for that or had that kind of money set aside and then in fy2 those costs went up another 4% and they are expected to go up 3.67% again for FY 26 and so we need to continue to educate our students and we have to figure out how to pay for those out of District costs and as those costs went up so too did the cost of out of District transportation so we're trying to figure that out and not to sound Flip but every
059district is trying to figure that piece out too um because it was unexpected and so as we look at special education this is a really nice list of all of the services that we offer across the district we are continuing to build programming so that we can better support some of our out of District students in our own District um but it takes time to build programs and so you know feel very fortunate that Mr Stapleton has started to think about what types of programming could we create um but that doesn't happen overnight and that could take a few years to get off the ground but um it's something that we are looking forward to thinking more about and and um designing how we would strategically bring some of that programming to the district facilities
060and maintenance you know I I alluded to this some of those cost we are actually using fewer utility resources yet our costs continue to go up so that's where some of this is outside of our control a year or so ago the district did a some work in all of the schools so that we could reduce our usage and that has played out we just aren't seeing the monetary savings because of inflation um we also as a district do more around our school grounds than we used to and so that is costing the district more money in terms of custodial overtime and some um routine maintenance costs and some routine um materials fees class size is really important in coass and this was an interesting thing for me to look at and learn um this
061is a district that really Prides itself on its smaller class size and I think it's really important I think it's part of what makes us who we are I think it's part of why um we are really doing a good job at starting to close those achievement gaps but you can see that over time the number total number of students in the district is going down and when I first shared this slide deck I actually had fewer years on here and somebody who's been in the district for a very long time said can you really go back and look at all the numbers because most of us who've been here a long time knew that there was going to be this big bubble in the middle and then we were going to start dropping again
062and so I did that and that person was absolutely correct that is exactly what I found and so to me this speaks to to that long-term financial planning that Mr Plant was talking about we have a service um Nez in New England they provide 10 years of enrollment data they project out um and so I think we can do a better job using what they provide to think about what our student numbers will look like as we move forward and do some more planning of our financial planning in years three to five but this is our current class sizes um for the this current school year um and you can see that we have really nice class sizes and so when we talk about some of the things that make us an amazing and excellent
063School District this is something that even though we're trying to close this deficit that we are trying to not impact um and as a matter of fact in a minute I'm going to talk about the fact that we also even though we are going to be making reductions we are going to through some reimagining of some staffing um increase the number of classrooms you see for grade four next year because that 125 students is coming up to fourth grade in five classrooms would mean that in we have about 25 students in a class Which is higher than what we typically like in Cohasset and you know in talking to principal Sullivan that's those are some grades where we typically see movein every summer and so we also want to be prepared and have a little
064bit of space in each classroom another thing that really makes us special is all of our course offerings we are a district that really provides a comprehensive cor curriculum all the way through K through 12 and we are a district that you just saw the evidence of are placing value on the Arts um that's special and it's important because we know that that makes well-rounded children we know it adds to the academic experience and we know that for some students are in music and fiz Ed are places where our students feel like they have a sense of Bel and we want to make sure that all of our students have that place um we also have a really aligned and growing technology and computer science curriculum we offer two languages 6 through 12 I know
065that many want us to offer down into the lower grades um right now we're still 6 through 12 we offer fre stem programming K through 12 and we have an increasing catalog of electives for students at the high school that are really aligned to our vision of a graduate and our strategic plan Transportation um it's always an area of struggle for us a little bit we do um have eight buses they are leased part of the cost for our lease buses is actually supported by capital budget and part of them currently is supported by operating budget um and so we're continuously trying to think about how how that split happens um and we do charge students fees but we can't charge all of our students fees we are by law required to provide transportation for
066our elementary students and students who live beyond a certain mind miles um and so we can really only charge for those students who fall outside of those areas um and so this is this is an area that I'm going to ask that we look at in a little bit um to see if there's some some room to bring in some additional revenue or if we want to keep it as it is and fees in general there are a lot of other fees that we do and we do not currently charge that we are going to be looking at um currently we have fees through Athletics Transportation building rentals and some other fees to look at and consider our student parking activity fees um preschool and full day kindergarten and so how do we get all
067of our money I think that's a big question for people um some of it is revenue like I just talked about with the fees um we also you heard Mr Plant talking about grants I think Dr scollins does an amazing job applying for Grants often our district doesn't meet the qualifications for those grants and so we are not awarded them even though we are applying for them um and I'll explain a little bit of why we don't often qualify for them and so I think we're starting to really look outside of the typical grants to see what we could access um we just heard actually this week that we are recipients of a National Science Foundation Grant so that is like an example of the kinds of Grants we need to start going for but
068the M vast majority of our funding comes from Chapter 70 which I'll explain a little bit more about because I think a lot of people hear about Chapter 70 but don't understand what it is and town Appropriations um and from the town they give us money that supports our operating budget in addition to that they um Provide Capital funding they have appropriated money for our school facility stabilization funds and they often give us one-time funding Appropriations when they can so Chapter 70 was designed to give an assure fair and adequate minimum per student funding for public schools in the state of Massachusetts by defining a foundation budget and a standard of local funding that every city and town had to give to the schools um the amount of Chapter 70 funding is based on six
069different factors the foundation budget that's the part that comes from the state and that is based on our student enrollment it's based on the wage adjustment Factor so they use the mean or median of um home prices to figure that out and inflation the hard part here is two things one our student enrollment has gone down which means we are eligible for Less Chapter 70 money but also their inflation rate doesn't keep up with what our Rising costs are so it is always less than what we need and then the other part of our funding comes from local contributions what the town gives us and they base their ability to provide us with money through property value income and Municipal Revenue growth factor Cohasset is a wonderful Community but almost all of the Town income
070comes from property values in property taxes because we have a very small commercial base many other towns have a large commercial base and that adds to the amount of money that they can give to the schools one of the things I have found through this whole learning process of of our budget is that our town does everything it can to really fund the schools um but they only get so much money and so that's where we're a little bit stuck and even as a town and in conversations it's you know they can't give us enough to keep up with inflation either and so at what point do we have to think about what are some other Alternatives here to help us get to what we need and the reason we don't get the same amount
071of state chapter 70 money is because of these um italicized categories numbers 8 through 12 what Chapter 70 does is it says these are the 13 categories of students and numbers 1 through 7 we're going to give everybody the exact same amount but for numbers 8 through 13 we're GNA give those numbers more money so for instance a school dist District that has multilingual Learners who are in the hundreds if those students are being given 10 extra thousand per student they're getting hundreds of thousands of dollars more a district like Cohasset has about three to five multilingual language students that's a big difference and it's also why we're not qualifying for lot of Grants because many of those grants are um awarded based on the numbers of students that you have in these categories 8
072through 13 and we as a district just we don't have those numbers to qualify and so when you hear on the news that Governor Healey has given more money to Chapter 70 she has but because of those italicized numbers I just showed you most of that money is going to other districts as a town we may get about $105,000 but as a district we're only going to see about half of that because the town takes the other and I don't mean to say takes but that's the way it supposed to work half of it goes to the town half of it STS and so some of that information also factors into our per pupil expenditure and we are on the higher end of per pupil expenditure because it doesn't necessarily translate in the sense that
073because we're a smaller District we have fewer expenses and we don't spend as much money every school still has to have the same amount of Staffing in some ways the same you know you still need to have a principal in every school you still need to have a director of student services so those needs don't change based on the number of students necessarily and so that's why when take those needs that are common across all districts and you divide it by the number of students we have we have a higher per pupil expenditure because we have us students and yet that per pupil expenditure still doesn't meet our actual cost as a district so where are we currently I think this is important not going to spend a lot of time on this current Year's
074budget but it's important to note that last year's or this current Year's fy2 voted budget amount was just under $24 million and I think that's an important number for the public to hold in their head because when we talk about any percentage increase that the town gives us over FY 25 that's the number that the percentage is is factored on so while they also gave us an additional onetime special ed costs and while we have funds that are offset by Circuit Breaker those numbers aren't factored into what our foundation budget is for fy2 that will help us determine what our FY 26 month numbers are and as you can see here you know even though that we ended up with just over 24 million our costs for fy2 are 25 million which is why we
075have our shortfall so if we were to look at a fully funded budget for next year and I think this is important because I think people should see what is possible and then what we're what we're doing um if we you know this is if someone came and said hey Cohasset Public Schools you have an additional $10 million what do you want to do with it um we would add a grade four teacher we would add another school adjustment counselor at the elementary level so that each Elementary School had two full-time adjustment counselors we would add assistant principles to our elementary schools we would add some additional electives at the high school we would add to our professional development money and all of these are things that have been identified for the last few years
076as um needs and potential increases for the district not necessarily a comprehensive list right there are other things but even just these would require over a 10% increase from our FY 25 members and so it's not it's not feasable it's not fiscally responsible if we looked at just the level service budget which means the exact same services that we have this year nothing changes we would still need at least an additional 6.8% and I say at least because I think it's important to reiterate that n none of these numbers include any negotiated salary increases we just don't know what those will be yet a level funded budget as I said earlier would still leave us short 1.128 million um and it would require us to do some of what we're going to propose that we
077do and so what are we actually proposing for this year it's a little bit of a combination of all of those things so if the town again and the other thing is because the state doesn't know what all of their budget's going to look like the town doesn't exactly know what it has available yet either and they're playing with some unknowns you know we've had lots of conversations with Chris Senor the town manager who is being told that health insurance costs are going to rise between 10 and 20% that's a huge spam and until he knows what those numbers are for real he doesn't necessarily know what number he's working with as a town so if we just assume a 4% increase on our fy2 budget which was that 23 million number we would get
078around $950,000 from the town over and above what we have um that gets us to you know 24 mil 865,000 but we know that that's not enough because this year we already have spent 25 million so we know that at a minimum with no negotiated increases we would need an additional $670,000 we are making a guess that when you add in salary increases we may need to find about 1.2 million and so how are we going to get there this is our proposal for how we get to the $1.2 million um some of that is potential salary and Supply reductions um to the tune of about $575,000 we would like to not go deeper into our reduction of Staff than what that reflex and we're not quite ready to share exactly what positions those are
079because it it could shift based on some different factors um but what I can share with people is that we worked really hard to First Look at non- student basing positions um because we really are trying so hard not to impact what happens in the classroom and every position impacts students in some way but not as a um not in in a way that like it would up class sizes or change the number of classes at say a third grade level just to be clear superintendent Shan this would reduce the amount of human resources that we have at goass public schools and some of those may very well be student facing um positions um if if deemed necessary yes so it's something that everyone needs to prepare for in the event that it is unavoidable
080um and it's not something that we take lightly nor is it something that you know we want to do um we want to keep the positive moment that we have and certainly reduction reduction of Human Resources can cause us to lose momentum um but you know I just want to make it clear what that line item is that would be um staff people that work at this District that would no longer be working here so everyone needs to understand how serious the situation is you know should we need to resort to that yeah and I think sort of to add to that is that as we look at some of these areas of potential Revenue if any of these were not voted upon by you to increase some of those fees or we weren't able
081to get that this onetime special ed cost of $350,000 again then the number of Staff reductions would actually have to grow because no matter what we have to get to that right amount so that we are moving forward with a balanced budget and there's only two ways to do that so we are gonna I am going to move into potential areas of e that we could talk about um and again this is a first pass and there's lots of conversation to have about all of these so everything that people are going to see this is just a first first blush and there'll be multiple meetings where all of these are talked about but um and the one of the things to talk about is kindergarten fees in fy2 the district moved from requiring families to
082pay $3,000 fee for full day kindergarten and when that happened the town supported that transition with one-time funds to cover the cost of the kindergarten fees but that cost wasn't necessarily absorbed into the budget in a way that also then reduced somewhere else for a break even and so on the table would be to reinstitute the full day kindergarten fee to offset 300 approximately $300,000 if you chose to go back there and if it was $33,000 a student still um talked a little bit about transportation fees this is another area to look at we are currently almost at the highest transportation fee um hangam just voted for FY 26 to increase their fee to $360 per student with a family cap of $625 we're currently at 350 with a family cap of 590 and a
083late fee of $50 um if we were to increase our fees um to $400 if would potentially bring in an extra $27,000 if we went to 425 it could bring in an additional $39,000 and if we went to$ 450 it could bring in an additional $55,000 athletic fees we are not near the top in our athletic fees so this is an area where we could um increase fees there's a little bit more room here one of the proposals that we're making is that we actually create two tiers of fees many districts have two-tier fees for athletics so tier one would be instead of a $250 fee it would be 350 with a family cap of 1,400 based on our current this is a little bit of a combination we used um this year's fall and
084winter actual numbers with last year's spring numbers to try and come up with what our our numbers of students are um so that would be 360 students paying the fee um with an increased revenue of $57,000 tier two fees would be hockey swim and football because those are sports that actually cost the district a lot more money um with hockey we're also renting space at the ice Arena swim we're renting space at the pool and football there's a um a pretty big charge because every year we have to recertify the helmets and pads which costs over $122,000 a year um so the proposal is that those fees would go up to $500 with a family cap of 20 2,000 you have about 91 students um between those three Sports which brings us to an additional
085potential of 23,000 750 there's also a caveat here that the ski team would stay at the three or go to the 350 re but that those students would be responsible for buying a home ski pass at Blue Hills and though the total here is 880,000 we also in 2030 2023 24 had families um who reached the cap which saved them but reduced the district income by $117,000 so we took that out so if we did this proposed increase fee for athletics it would bring in approximately 67 or $64,000 we also looked at gate fees gate fees are what we charge folks who come to games um and we don't charge for all games we charge for some of the sports that costs more money um through building use or or additional refs or expensive refs
086um and we we did an analysis of other towns and what their gate fees are and we actually are very much in line with what other districts are doing so we're not actually proposing an increase in Gate fees but we thought it was important for people to know that we we gain about $440,000 in Gate fees um each year um this is the proposal that actually came out of Staff feedback um and had some conversation as a leadership team around the idea of proposing a Student Activity fee um and for a couple reasons one is that we've been hearing from students that um we don't get enough attendance of students at each other's games and sporting events and perhaps one of the things we could do is actually not charge each time they come to
087an event um and that might improve their attendance improve School culture it could potentially also reduce our Revenue um but the counter proposal to that was to have a yearly activity for students that includes skate fees clubs and other non-sport activities what it would not include are activities that serve as fundraisers and school dances because those that money goes to either that fundraising cause like a trip or it goes to um student council and so the proposal is that it would be $60 per student at the middle school and $100 per student at the high school include theater though right yeah yeah no um people would still pay to yeah we also talked about um student parking fees we did a little survey again of surrounding towns and almost everybody does charge for student parking
088Milton did not but they are talking about doing it for next year just as we are um and so we are proposing that um students would pay $2 a day to park at the high school which would bring um it would be about $360 per year that would bring in about $41,000 to the district um and we are talking about this in addition to moving our buses from the lot over by aishan where we currently pay $48,000 to lease that space bringing the buses back to the high school location where they would park here overnight we are working with the town to find a place that they could be during the school day so that we don't lose student parking spots um and hopefully get the best of both worlds where where students are helping
089us def Fray the costs um by paying for parking and we save the $48,000 from bus you know parking fees over on the edge of town we are also proposing that you think about building rental fees um we take in between in FY 24 was almost $35,000 in building rental this year it's $4 ,000 we have seasonal rentals we have other rentals it's not a huge amount but I think it's something worthwhile to have the committee look at um to see if there's a benefit there in increasing those rental fees and so you know really this is where we are we are in a place where we have to think about the increased fees and the impact of either increasing fees or not because that will have a real impact on the number of staff
090that we have to reduce because no matter which way we slice it um we need to get to a place where we are um reducing at least $1.2 million in school funds so that's where we are as of today and so open for questions ideas um I told the staff that this is a collaborative effort amongst everyone the town school committee leadership and the Educators um and I also want to say just very publicly that we have been really collaboratively working with the town and they are being very supportive of our efforts um and we hope to continue to have those conversations thank you superintendent Shan so in acknowledgement of the late start of the meeting meeting and also the fact this is the first presentation initial presentation of this budget um which we'll be
091discussing uh for several meetings um certainly take some brief comments or or limited questions at this point I think that's a lot of information that everyone has got absorb a little bit but Mr car I don't know if you have anything just around order presentation okay just Hannah do you have anything at this point in time Mrs leski very appreciative I think this was I appreciate the approach and how comprehens no questions I need to digest yeah there's a lot there and i' just like to note that our superintendent actually spent a great deal of time um on this presentation um and uh has I think this might be the fourth time that you uh have presented it this week um yes it it's the fourth time I've seen it so you know which is
092which is which is which is good right we need to know this well um but thank you because it was you know celeski corre that is really really well done it was put together uh properly and uh I think logically and uh it's very intuitive so uh it leaves us with a lot to thank thank you very much um we'll move right into the next block the agenda which is a block the superintendent updates and hopefully uh superintend sheny can give sort of a brief update then move right into the district calendar discussion that we have and I have a very fre update um so first I want to say that it's National School counseling so we want to thank all of our counselors for all they do for all of our students and staff
093and I want to give a shout out to Allison Batista who is um a high school counselor who won The Rising Star Award at the Massachusetts school Counselors Association um and this award is or this award winner so Allison is a model for new counselors demonstrating the highest standard a professional conf confidence outsen and contributions to the school community and profession and has demonstrated strong rapport with students parents in the school Personnel so congratulations to miss Batista um I also would like to congratulate the high school and especially coach a um because he has been sort of the person behind a lot of this work um their application has been selected to be nominated to the US Department of Education Green Ribbon School um so we're currently awaiting further instruction from the federal program and
094we'll keep everybody apprised of where we are but who knows at some point we could see both a blue and a green ribbon so very excited about that um and so if you're all set I'm ready to move into calendar okay let's go okay thank you so you have two calendars in front of you um and we are looking to hopefully vote for one calendar this evening so draft one actually I'm going to say both calendars um could I just pause you for one minute super Dr scollins do you have access to the PDF copy from the agenda materials while super Chan is speaking or if you want to do just it might help just to put them up let me pull it up hold on sorry there's actually a decent amount of people watching
095no that's fine okay the other one out sh my screen okay so both calendars have the same first day of school so students in grades 1 through 12 will start school on September 2nd our kindergarteners will start on September 3rd and our pre-s will start on September 8th both calendars have a full two two we winter recess for our students and families with December 22nd that Monday being a professional development day for staff both calendars nope I'm not going to say that the first calendar so option one has Good Friday list it as an early release day with the last day of school being June 17th the second calendar sorry blocking my ability to switch screens the second calendar has Good Friday as a no school day due to operational challenges with the last day
096of school being being June 18th and so those Good Friday options and the last day of school are the two differences and that is really what we're deciding on oh yes the other thing that I do want to mention is that though you may be voting on a calendar tonight um due to some of the recent um news coming out of Washington D see we are waiting to hear some from state government Massachusetts state government around any some potential changes to federal and state holidays if state holidays change we may have to revisit some of this calendar but we don't have enough information to make any decisions about that now but I do think it is prudent to move forward with this decision so this is our starting good thank you yeah any adjustment won
097be too severe I so we'll be a to make that but I think I agree it's prudent to move forward at this point with a vote we've talked about a number of times at our meetings so at this point just go around in alphabetic order as we always do and ask for any comments or questions for the superintendent or any member of the administration that's present and uh and then eventually we'll uh entertain a motion for a vote when everyone feels they've had inadequate opportunity be heard and I'd encourage anyone that is watching at home that might have an opinion or a position or perspective to share to please just chime in um I'm monitoring the Q&A feature on Zoom so we'd love to hear from you Mr Carl no questions just observation I think
098both cend are very well thank Mr car m h no questions I have them answered in the past okay m operationally is the challenge that there are not enough students in attendance or there are not enough teachers in attendance for the curriculum to move forward or both I think at this point it is both okay um what I have tried to discover but cannot ascertain is so which came first um but I think now we are at a place where it is both um espe Es at the secondary level and becoming more so at the elementary level with each passing superintendent CH I wonder um because I think we were taking survey responses even Beyond were the last meeting so I wonder if it makes sense to just bring those up I can do and
099share them with everyone at home as well as the members of our school yeah yeah so we are at 552 responses total and 46.4 of the responses are saying a half day 46.4% yes and 27.9 are saying no school altogether do you want to know numbers of people cuz Who's Who and and what's the percentage of uh of full day yes you know what I'm going to just share my screen did everyone can see this hold on sorry I have a lot of tabs open you go is that big enough yes okay so 46.4 are saying a half day school on Good Friday 27.9 are saying no school 25.7 are saying a full day of scho and then as to the you already sort of made the decision with the uh with the winter break
100because it was like an overwhelming response so both offs present that two we vac that two that was this was the data from the December break and the only issue there was the teachers um yes you know request that we consider maybe different professional development days which don't impact the families corre so that okay so if we could scroll back down to that yeah and I don't know if it's helpful but this 46% is 256 responses this one for the no school is 154 and for full day is 142 so to me um and if anyone has any comments now um just jumping but to me I mean the survey was um extremely helpful guidance in making this decision even with this where it's a little bit more split um clearly there's a a a
101response a choice that most people selected or agreed on um so I personally I would just adhere to the guidance of those that I represent and I would I would personally favor going with the half day for Good Friday um but I don't know where everyone was at so I what I would I that's just my personal perspective but I would ask for a motion to approve one of the two calendars and then obviously that motion would need a second and then it would need to pass so uh if anyone has any sort of uh as the chair I'm not going to make the motion uh but if anyone has a calendar that they would like to see voted on please move at this time move to vot on two okay so um draft two
102that is the calendar that presents Good Friday as a no school day okay there's been a motion to vote on draft two is there a second to that motion okay hearing no second uh there will be no vote taken on that motion so that only leaves us with any one other option so I'm guessing maybe two other committee members would move for for that calendar one of you or perhaps you guys don't like either option I guess okay so the motion up for draft one Mr Carr that includes okay yes so there's been a motion one okay there's been a motion to approve draft one of the calendar which presents Good Friday as a half day and leaves the last day of school on June 17th is there a second to that motion to approve
103draft one of the calendar I'll second okay there's no pressure Cel no okay motion's been seconded by Miss leski so all in favor we'll do a roll call Mr Carr hi um Miss Hannah can I voice my concern for um sure sure I I think the only thing is we just went through an extensive reason like we're in a m major deficit and the last time we talked about this there's significant savings by closing the school because of the lack of students in this building and the major increase in having to have substitutes and so there's a significant savings and to go and go through this and then kind of ignore the fact that there's significant savings and if you put students first and they're not in school then I don't know why we open
104the building okay um because we've already made the motion and it's already been seconded I'm still G to go through with the vote and I'd ask you for some vote Miss Hannah if you want to vote for against or abstain it's up to you um otherwise I I'll vote against but that so nay um Mr leki I'm voting for but I with the caveat that I that I hope we continue this conversation in subsequent Years Around the quality of Education that if there is a half day in the school is open that it's being used for educational purposes not as a short little um visit to school before everyone heads off on a long weekend or that you know to really pay attention to the attendance data but both in terms of cost but also
105in terms of educational value um and that I also personally feel really strongly about the separation of schools from religious observations um however given the situation that we're in I also think it our job is to educate students and the students need to be here um and looking at the data I'm hoping that families will be here and that teachers will be here and find ways to celebrate um or observe Good Friday um outside of those school hours okay so just to recap so far Mr car is i m Hannah is nay Mrs leski is I okay just public record Craig mclen I thank you Mr leski motion carries by a vote of a majority vote of three members uh to one nay and one member who is not present so superintendent Shannon we'd ask
106that you please Implement that calendar for the upcoming Academic Year uh Miss leki great point and and frankly I think this is an example of something that we review constantly because Good Friday was formerly a school day and it it doesn't didn't seem to be working so it's now going to be a half day so if if that doesn't work then there may be a demand to revisit that um I think miss Hannah's observations were uh absolutely valid um and I don't know you know if they would have changed anyone's position um but you know I I just just because of procedure we had for V because it already been seconded that motion seconded but I I think that that was a really good comment to make um okay thing yes the point that you
107just made Ley about um early release days and turning into some long weekends and things I think that's something that um I think we will revisit in general because the elementary schools specifically have been keeping some really interesting data um and we're finding that even outside of the Good Friday um those early release days we have a significant number of students who are absent and when you add up all of that time that's a lot of lost academic time and our teachers are really doing a good job trying to make those days valuable um but when we have large numbers of students absent it becomes difficult um and so I think um it's something that you'll see out in some school newsletters um because we can't teach students who aren't in their seats and so
108um even a half day is a really valuable academic day so thank you for raising that well I think it's also really hard for teachers to move curriculum forward if you have a lesson plan that's a critical critical lesson to the curriculum um if you have only 70% of your seats filled you're going to need to retach that at some other time and I think it impacts it impct all kids um all right well let's move on to the next block uh of the agenda which is block F and is uh our teaching and learning section um tonight we have a presentation from our director of student services Mr Michael St Stapleton and we also have our C fault is on Sarah Davis in the audience who I asked to please come and join us
109at this time Mr Stapleton so I have a brief presentation tonight it's really just a data sharing update as I do you know at the meetings that I attend um so we got a very busy month in January of 2025 just kick off the new year um at the elementary level there were seven annual review meetings there were four re-evaluations all of which the students are found eligible for special education there was five initial evaluations um or sorry six initial evaluations five students are found eligible one student was found not eligible um five requests did come from families um and then one came to the mtss process there was one coass resident private school evaluation that was completed and then one independent evaluation that was reviewed um at the secondary level there were four annual
110review meetings there were nine reevaluations which was a lot of work on you know staff so I thank them for that you know dedication to comping those reevaluations there are two initial evaluations one was found eligible and that came through the mcss process and then outou of district there was one reevaluation where that student was found eligible so you'll see the total of 34 meetings um in the month of January and then moving to the next um you know request from the school committee to monitor the IP acceptance rate so this was September through December but then for the month of from September 1st to January 31st you know we're at um 106 accepted IEPs you know based on how the meetings have fallen there's 13 IEPs being written and then we still await 35
111responses from families within that 30-day window families have to respond to IP so again very positive and successful month um for student services for special education thank you Mr Stapleton that concludes your rep report okay and anything any input uh from our special education parents advisory Council Miss Davis no pressure no pressure um we had a great meeting last month well yeah last month and Michael reported on all of our different types of programming for special ed in kasset and it was awesome it was actually really thorough and I think any parents who want know should like go online because you posted it it'll be on um and look it up I feel like I learned some things as well so it was a really it was good meeting we had a lot of people
112turn out and we had some good conversations did he turn the heat on for you this time we weren't in that room it's that's and that's just super important to we consider you know what superintendent shanon presented about as we consider the budget and like those components how we can build out programming too um and knowing what strengths we have right now where there's areas of improvement um and how we built those up over the years it's just important to have CAC understanding and parents aware of what program we offer and then areas for growth yeah we learned a lot about the co- teing model I think some parents didn't really know much about that so that was great um and uh yeah I'll be interested to see what you do forward you know programming
113okay um M Davis any um from the parents perspective family's perspective I should say uh any uh constructive criticism about anything right now what common themes anything you're seeing that You' like to be aware of um think so top again no pressure you can always contact us so you know ask this off the top of your head right now but we do have a meeting coming up so I'll let you know can you tell me when that is because I like to go it is we're doing it after February vacation so it's the Thursday after the 27 yeah is it 11 I don't I have to check the time I'm not sure we're having a presenter so okay well it' be wonderful if you could text that yes I'll tex it to you thank you
114so much appreciate that uh any questions from the committee members uh or anyone participating virtually for our director student services and or our CPAC representative goodbye principles thank you thank you for coming St um would you be able to speak to or just provide a little color if it's possible around um with the elementary um column where there were five family referrals and four of those kids were eligible I I mean that seems like hot to me like all of a sudden here we are mid year I don't know if that's parents looking at their kids all of a sudden but that those kids weren't scooped up by the mtss at this point um I'm just wondering if there's anything else you can say I understand that there may not be um in this type
115form but so I think I can speak kind of broadly to that answer so I think at the lower levels you know with principle God that being new and like kind of my work with mtss and like refining that process um full transparency that's something I'm still working on in this role and really getting down there to see that so I think that's what I would attribute that to is like you know calibrating with the new principal um some new Personnel down there really like navigating that process but I would say that I think we've been responsive through this right by you know moving forward the evaluations and determining that eligibility so I think that's really that piece at the Osa level um and again you know five does seem like a lot but like
116in the scheme of you know grade levels and percentages that we're at I see that you know being something I definitely want to keep an eye on but not overly alarming sense thank you thank anyone else okay okay thank you both thank you that was a great bu presentation all right um moving on to block G reports from any uh subcommittee assignments or gon roles anyone you just fire will I got to no we go all right um the Cohasset High School school council met last week um and I'll just to keep it short we'll just I'll just let you know what we talked about um Mr Scott reviewed the um budget proposals and some of the impacts and I think that what makes the high school school council really interesting is that students participate
117as well and so I think it's great that our students are beginning to sort of understand also how School District Works um there was some discussion about scheduling and new courses which was a proactive move by the high school in um anticipation of some budget decisions needing to be made and sort of knowing how um students were going to choose their courses for next year what sort of Staffing um would be needed there was discussion of the competency uh determination approval which was is related to the um mcast and graduation um business that we go on while ago cell phone Task Force update um it was great to hear from the students again just about how they were um experiencing the first week of the cell phone um away from the day and then um
118talking about how to brainstorm around having difficult conversations as a community um mostly around to the to race so that was absolutely fantastic um and then um a quick update from the CF um in the fall um they gave almost $87,000 um to the schools across all four schools um with some amazing grants um they are looking to add board members um so if you are interested in serving on that really fun board um speak to one of the current members or you can go on their website and you'll see their email address on there um the phone is on pick up your phone your home phone which almost never rings um March 3rd and 4th um they will be the CF is looking for um donations at that point they'll also have the spelling
119be in May on the 19 20th and 21st for grades three and five and teachers who are listening spring grants are due on the 5th of April so um we're very appreciative of the CF and all that they do um for our schools especially um as budgets get tighter and to our community for supporting the CF because allows them to do what they do as well I still do not know a contact for food service or the wellness committees okay okay or if I'm supposed to be having been at meetings for either of these so for wellness February 11th maybe you're not on those make sure you're so February 11th at 2 o' okay and it'll be in the community room but I'll send you hav was out I was out there was just one
120meeting the very beginning okay I don't call say hand who is on the Food Services Comm be with you I am okay so um you would just basically coordinate sort of that is that was like an ad hoc Committee created uh when we wanted to re-evaluate or you know take a deeper dive into the food services and um the meetings are all initiated by the committee members and it's through the superintendent um usually we would notify um superintendent that we wanted to it was not at the time superintendent Shannon or superintend Sullivan that we would want to have a food services meeting and usually Miss Ellen was involved and then obviously Mr cordone who is the director of food services and usually that takes place um it can take place anywhere oftentimes it takes place
121at one of the schools during lunch service and a lot of times you eat lunch there to see what's going on see how it serve so um it's actually a great committee but I don't think it's met at all this year um but it probably could because now mrone has been here for a full calendar year and uh he's done a lot um more than a slightly more than a calendar year now um he's done a lot so maybe it's time to I don't know sit down with him and figure things out I know that Elementary was always the that was still like the developing side he had done a lot of things immediately with the secondary building um and I think that he's done a good deal with the Elementary in terms of sort
122of streamlining the service and maybe offering a wider array of healthier options but um yeah it's sort of like up to you guys when you feel like it and there's zero pressure so you know between the two of you than perfect anything else Mr car do you have one no nothing from Mr car okay um I met with superintendent Shannon as part of the uh super endent eval process our midyear um checkin and found that superintendent Shannon is uh well on her way to accomplishing all goals that she presented at the beginning of the year there's adequate evidence uh in terms of like what she has been doing to uh accomplish those goals and um fulfill strategic objectives or initiatives um we will be every one of us will be asked to fill out a
123form that I will distribute to the committee at the end of the year because one of our major roles as school committee members is to evaluate um the operational head of our school district which is the superintendent and it it is done on specific form um traditionally we presented that in July superintendent Shannon has asked that we do that earlier this year um so I will circulate those in May um because they always always take a long time for everyone to do um it really isn't that burdensome but you do need to like set aside an hour or to sit down and do it and take it seriously and there's a little bit of like a rubric to it so um but I we have like you know you have last years that's already been
124published so you can use that as guidance to see how it's done um I'm also happy to answer any questions but just letting you all know that that is coming down the bik that's all so um unless there's anything else move on to the last block or penultimate block of the agenda school committee governance um may not have any topics not recently anticipated I know of anyone have any topics that are I don't know about I would like to um propose creating a subcommittee for athletics um I think it's been brought to my attention that you know um really like the community is scared to speak out in retaliation of their children and so most of our kids play sports and um and you know the success of our teams have been masked um have
125been actually masking the operational concerns of the department and I think it's time that we dig in on it and just understand more of you know how you know coaches are hired how they're fired um you know there's questions around the safety protocol policies and scheduling of the the um you know athletic competitions and everything and so the list kind of goes on and kind of what I've heard around and what I've been feeling and everything and so I'd like to propose that we move forward with the committee kind of focused on the department yeah I um anyone have any comments on this it's support of it so um Mrs Hannah and super Shannon and athletic director rundi and I met um several months ago now um keeping in line with just ensuring that every
126element of the district um is getting the attention it deserves is you know uh has the resources it need it needs um that we're evaluating all for improvement and Innovation with within each within each you know uh Department of the school and we just had a meeting Rel relative to Athletics and so I mean I think that um you know I I certainly um um you know am in favor of having um school committee oversight we did this with the food services and uh I think that um I ideally I would like to um I had I had um tried to post this on the agenda for this meeting and um I didn't because it just wasn't posted in time um and so I didn't anticipate discussion tonight about it I'm glad to Han of
127brought it up um I one thing I felt like not it not being posted was a little bit of a blessing in disguise because from the Food Services Endeavor I learned that sometimes um the roll out can have uh the way we roll out that sort of at this at the committee level can have like unintended consequences so I mean I guess so Miss Hannah are you proposing that we establish that tonight right here and now yes okay so um yeah I mean I I mean it's been I mean it's been proposed by one of us and I think that like you know it aren't some discussion if someone's uh if someone is uh looking to do that you know I think it's driven by a desire to make sure that we're you know providing
128all departments all the resources they need so um I don't know what what are people's feelings on it I'm sitting here trying to remember what do we generally do on New committee roll out what what do we do yeah do we we whenever we want one we vote on it and we do it or do we vote how do we so TR so ordinarily um so what we did with and all I can do Mr Carr is like I I don't know if there's like a real policy to this I mean I think that the school committee can establish whatever subcommittees it wants to have um we from memory we sort of established like it wasn't officially a subcommittee because that's usually done when we Recon reconstituting the the committee but it's like an ad
129hoc committee right so like with the Food Services we established this committee that you know the two members volunteered to sit on and then we would meet discuss the Department discuss needs discuss wants and um and then from that came the suggestion that we for formally create a subcommittee right so when the time came for that um it wasn't done like in media race um I don't I don't know that that's I I don't know if there's any any you know rule to follow um I must admit so I got to concede that I'm not sure if there's some sort of proper procedure with that um but the committee is certainly welcome to form a you know some sort of you know offline non- Quorum um committee to you know I I would say that
130it almost always would need to involve the superintendent of schools if we were going to do that because if it looks at any sort of operational facet at the school district I mean it has to we can't just like unilaterally I think approach that without involvement I I don't think that would be appropriate and I think that it would be maybe it would it would be um counterproductive to do that too because I think it would be met with some maybe like it would be received um in in a manner that maybe it wasn't intended to bece that we did that so I think it could just mirror the and this was always my thought on it it would just mirror the the St the the Food Service uh issue that we did we just
131saw that like something that may been not given the amount of attention that maybe other departments have been given for a period of time and so we said well why don't we take a look at it and uh from that we ended up having this you know professional chef leading the department and and and people are raving about the kids are raving about the pizza I mean almost every meeting I feel like we're talking about the food services department how wonderful it is so you know I think there's value to it yeah and so Mrs Hannah has proposed that you know we form so I guess what I would do is just ask you know if there's two I imagine Hannah is is volunteering herself to sit on it um so if there's like another
132member that would join her in that effort and then that can be coordinated with the superintendent um to start and then I think that like a thought partnership there can happen in terms of like how I can because the danger in these I speak like the danger with these things right is that the school committee's overall perview right there's like three primary things uh evaluating our superintendent uh developing uh policy and overseeing the budget um depending on the district school committees vary in terms of their involvement in operational matters our district uh currently and has for as long as I've been on the committee um been fairly involved in in operations now of course the superintendent is always the one making operational decisions but we are thought partnering with the superintendent a lot I've been
133chair of the committee with superintend Shannon twice with superintendent Sullivan and all those experiences as the sort of you know conduit I've been very involved with with you know sort of operational discussions not decisions like we're not you know the school committee isn't making necessarily operational decisions superintendent is but so you know this would be one of those instances where we would be you know injecting ourselves into the operations of the school so um my point in mentioning that is that um it can sometimes be received as um you know people may interpret it the wrong way people get I've said this before in open meeting um staff can get their hackles up um feeling that the the school committee is targeting them unfairly or suggesting that they're doing a bad job um I don't
134feel that that's ever why we're doing something like this it's because we're just five people that have volunteer at a time to represent the best interest of all the stakeholders and we're trying to do that job as effectively as possible and make sure that everyone's getting the resources they need and we're we're delivering the best possible experience to the kids yeah right um and to date our superintendant have been really receptive of that and and have been willing to thought partner with us some superintendence aren't right we've been fortunate but that's also part of the deliberate hiring process that we have as well I mean questions that we ask the candidates um so we just have to be cognant in that and respectful the fact that if you're working here right I think that the
135nature of school committees in itself can be a little bit off-putting um you know just to provide a some sort of you know uh extreme example I'm a lawyer if I had to if I worked in an organization where uh uh and sometimes there are Educators in the school committee but predominantly it's people from all different walks of life if I had to be governed by a board of folks that weren't lawyers and and you know and I felt like they were sometimes overstepping I would that would that may bother me so we just have to be respectful of that and cognizant of that that that sometimes that's how it's interpreted and and it's not that even though it's not meant to be um there may be some unintended consequences of that so um yeah
136I mean I'm I'm always all four doing that I mean I'm I'm always all four these these sort of like ad hoc committees I think it adds value it just needs to be I think approached in the right way so that we're not like from the outset dealing with people that you know engaging with people that have already they're feeling attacked right so um yeah so I so did would anyone else volunteer um to serve on the Athletics sort of ad hoc committee I'd be glad to to to work with Miss Hannah and and and superintendent Shannon and figure out what that's going to look like inter if you have bandwidth de that's great if you do not you can you can call me up and I can sub in I'm also willing to so
137what whatever would you like to do it Mr car sure okay all right so why don't Santa and Mr Carr contact superintendent Shannon in the not too distant future and figure out you know collaborate on on on how this is going to be launched um I think too this department is also one that serves so many students uses a you know is a big budget consideration and for those two reasons in and of itself um it I think it is good for us to all be fully informed on the on the sort of operations side I think Athletics is one of those areas I I truly believe that it's something it's a major part of the district right it's just outside of the walls a lot of times the classroom walls we're think about it
138a lot and it can easily go you know with with without getting the attention that it might deserve right so you know um I think it gets a lot of attention right I mean as um as Mr di put at one point like you know I think he was concerned that athletes get more attention than others and I think my concern is this is that we have um like we have very successful Sports teams right on paper out on the field we have successful sports team I don't think that the athletes are necessarily getting the support and getting the you know the the safety protocols that they deserve and that actually are part of their rights and so for that and I think as well with like coaching staff and all of that like really
139treating coaching staff and really thinking about The Hires of those coaching staffs because those kids are actually with those coaches maybe more so than with teachers depending on the blocks of the schedule and everything and so those coaches are incredibly important for the growth of our students and the wellness of our students and I think when you hit the athletic field versus when you're in a structured classroom like it is fairly unstructured in the sense that you're doing different things and being tested in different ways and everything and if that's not done by somebody who is trained professional in doing it it can actually have some really negative consequences and so there are a lot of concerns from that standpoint um you know we scheduled three basketball games in the middle of midterms this year
140for for our girls and so like we're about students first and you know but then we sit there and we put them in a situation where they've got to play three games and they also have to do all their midterm exams like things like that are just not being thought through right now and so I you know again it might not be that the departments getting the support they need so that's really where this is coming from is like let's understand what the struggles are and you know and give them the support that they need in order to be successful but I think the fact is is like I mean one coach got fired this year because they brought forward complaints safety complaints and you know unfortunately like we're sitting here and those have supposedly
141been taken care of but like there's been no outward communication of how they've been taken care of and you know these parents deserve that and these students deserve that to be able to go out on a field and know that they're going to be taken care of to be able to go out on a field and know that they don't have to practice in a lightning storm um and all of that is is something we owe to them as a school committee as well that their kids are going to be safe with us and so that's where this is coming from yeah so when I said it didn't get attention certainly I have a great deal of awareness here right I'm talking about attention at the committee level like we have a student services update
142every other meeting right that didn't happen before we a spotlight on student service as well before Mr Stapleton was the director so that's what I mean right so and that's why I think that sometimes you know highlighting different facets of the district like student services like food services and giving an attention at this level that it might not have gotten it before certainly at the popular level at has a lot of attention and awareness because most as you said most kids most most people's kids play one or more sports right yeah yeah that's not what I meant um but um so I agree yeah so okay so great all right any other topics that anyone had that I was not aware of but I just say that I to not to counter anything I I
143think our students currently are who play sports are are safe on fields and I would not want this to come across as if we have a major safety issue um because I think that could create other issues yeah I I mean I yeah well thank you for that I understand what you're saying and I think you know I think everyone's perspective is valid and you know I think that this is a positive thing you know and and I think it I think good only comes from when we do this um there may be some Growing Pains there but I I truly believe that these types of efforts have improved the district over at least the years that I've been on the committee it's just that the approach um I think has been refined over time
144um and and uh I think it's gonna be a positive thing so thank you Mrs Hannah um any approval of minutes oh that's me sorry uh no but I will turn them back to the district by Friday I'm almost done with the edits and Cathy PA continues to be amazing um she is sa I think and on many occasions it's me who was a little delayed so I will have those return back by Friday so you can vot on to okay yeah great um we're still well in compliance of notes okay thank you SC future agenda items uh anyone I was going to suggest that we put Athletics on there but Hanah took care of that no okay so we do have a reason to move into executive session tonight uh pursuant to Mass General
145laws Chapter 30 capital a section 21 um reason number three under subsection a of section 21 is to um engage in strategy surrounding uh Collective targeting negotiations and so uh and or litigation same exception um so is there a motion we'll need to do this in a roll call to move into executive session for the reason I just stated and to not move back into Open Session to adjourn from the executive session second motion has been made by Miss leki it's been seconded by Miss Hannah all in favor please indicate so in roll call Mr Carr uh I Mrs Hannah I miss leki I I motion carries by unanimous vote the memb present we are here by an executive session thank you everyone who joined us both virtually and in person tonight have a very
146nice night