001yeah there you go there you go look at that I buttons like anybody's business definit so according to CIO time it is now 6: pm on November 20th 2024 which means it's time for our regular meeting of the Coit school committee uh we're going to start with our call to order which I just effectively did uh then we're going to do a roll call I'll just go in random order um Mr Carr Pres Miss leki present Mr dial present astute and regular observers of the school committee would note that we have two abces Miss Hannah she's going to be a few minutes late so we will see her arrival shortly and Mr mclen who had another engagement and so therefore you're stuck with me substituting him for him as uh as the chair of this
002meeting uh so with that we'll do uh we do have a quorum of three out of the five so we can proceed with business and we'll start with the Pledge of Allegiance Pledge to the flag the United States of America and to the rep for it stands Nation indivisible liberty and justice for all so uh opening remarks I will just say we've got we've got a nice substantive agenda to cover we got some trips on the agenda which is great excellent opportunities we're going to be talking about mcast scores which I think there's some some um stuff to be proud of and stuff to uh as it was explained to me glows and grows um so we we'll talk about that um and then uh the other thing that I just wanted to uh extend
003a specific thanks to our faculty uh as we're going through our um our our parent meetings uh I know that's um special for that's that's an extra work for our for our faculty and our staff to help coordinate meet with our with our parents but I can say as a as a parent of a of a middle schooler I benefited from having a um a conference with our with with our teachers and I just wanted make sure our staff and faculty know that that we appreciate their willingness and um attentiveness to those matters it really helps connect with us with our kids' efforts in our school so thank you very much with that um with that I'll move it over to our next agenda block which is agenda Block B uh public comment uh this
004is the time in the agenda for public comment uh usually we ask that you uh limit your public comment to anything that's not on the agenda and hold off uh for anything that's on the agenda for the appropriate time at the agenda uh but you can let us know now if you are going to have a comment at the time um I am not I'm I'm scarily responsible oh you have it that's good so uh do we have any uh Dr comments no comments still no comments so we're GNA close off public comment uh and now we're going to move into our invited guests we have two invited guests we're going to start in um ascending order of schools at least age wise uh with two trips uh so miss SES uh welcome and um
005I believe we're going to talk about a Quebec trip yes yes hi thank you for your time thank you for coming the floor is yours okay um so I'm GNA read um if you don't mind so um my name is Kathy Sanz and I'm here um Here I Am the French teacher at kassa middle school and I'm here tonight to propose a three-day trip to Quebec City for grade eight French students on May 8th 9th and 10th 2025 um this cultural Excursion will give our students a chance to practice their French while learning one of the while learning about one of the oldest cities in North America we've received strong interest from students and parents and with past support from kassa public schools we've enjoyed many successful trips this will be my 16th year chaperon
006I didn't go two years because of Co um we have teachers from kasset middle school who have also volunteered to chaon our chapon ratio is um 1 through 10 1 to 10 sorry and we have 15 students this year we have a small group of students um so we are going with situ we have gone with situ in the past three years um the plan is to go with situ um they have about 30 students not all students will go but that's um that's what our uh numbers are so far um this is our 30d I mention going with situ and I also want to add that Cohasset and situ have high high schools have gone on past uh trips together to um the French Exchange program which is very successful program that has been
007going on for several years um our tour company is Jump Street tours which I have used for several years uh several trips in uh Jump Street tour guide stays with the group the entire weekend um we travel by motor coach and we visit all Sites by walking or with the motor coach um activities may include a walking tour of the old wall city of Quebec m waterfalls mples Sugar Shack with traditional food and dancing um the St La Lawrence river boat cruise and the Heron First Nation light show um students academic expectations include research of sites and journal writing about the trip so the uh CMS World Language Department believes that this excursion will help our students understand the importance of learning about other cultures through language and lay the foundation for further study abroad
008so if you have any questions hopefully I um thank you very much I appreciate it just in time Pledge of Allegiance tonight did quick very efficient very efficient today um so with that I'll open up to the committee for any questions Mr con no questions I went to a different school I took this trip when I was that age I loved it it's one of the most icon Miss leki thank you for doing this for our children um thank you for doing it for my child who will benefit from this um but as you were speaking I also was reminded too about the way in which tradition helps to build community and I think of this trip being one that my child has experienced as a cassic middle school tradition part of the tradition of
009being a student taking French um in the district and I think that that too is is something to also be recognized in terms of of how we think about some of these sort of Milestone moments um for our students yeah and it's a great memory they all it's a great memory for them they'll always remember as as you mentioned and then you have older kids say you know to the younger the older kids say to the younger the next group coming up oh I heard about this trip from you know an older friend of the family or siblings so I think it's a really nice just sort of a side benefit of of trips like this or even just events that that the district does thank you Miss Hannah has joined I'm not going to
010put you on the spot just yet I'll let you get get settled in uh and I'll I'll ask a couple I'll Channel my um inner correig mlen uh and if you could just tell us a little bit about the supervision uh aspect of the trip and how the kids will be supervised and you know whether they will be gender appropriate separation and um overnight accommodations Etc okay so we do as I mentioned um we we have um I shap shapon we have the ratio is 1 to 10 Mr Mill shapon last year so we do um for security reasons we have um we are together all the time walking either doing a walking tour sometimes we do uh split off into smaller groups but we're always together um one our shaon is with students at
011all times um at the hotel we have usually we're all on one floor small group anyways we're all on one floor and Boys on one section the girls on the other chaperon in the middle um we do have secur and we do have sec yes we have overnight security and they start at 10: and end at 6: in the morning and then report to me um you know any if they they would come to me obviously in the middle of the night if there's any issues um yeah that's that's very fullsome well um as as you know from this other other requests I think myself uh in particular and the committee as a whole very supp of these trips these are incredible educational and memory building opportunities for our students and we thank you so
012much for for putting them together um one question request I'll I'll reiterate uh that um I'd love to see at some point is we you know get these trips and we review them it'd be great to get an inventory of which ones we have because the one thing that I not the one thing but one thing I worry about is the aggregate burden on our on our families these trips cost money and so you don't want to to create a situation where there are some kids who are able to do tons and tons of things and other kids who are not able to do other things we've done some great things with some trips and fundraising and the like but it would just be great to have that mapped out because the reality I think
013for most of our families is that we're we're families of not unlimited means and so it just be great to understand um as we're approving these trips where that where that burden in the agre could fall on a family who wants to do as much as they can so um that could be something for a future agenda item we don't need to assess it now but I'm still interested in that um just to that point the uh in the past know and work Witham we've sometimes had families that had uh difficulty covering the tuition for the trip and the schools helped out or we've done different things to make it affordable and also the last couple years Madam San has worked with situ so instead of setting a group of 15 kids let's say with
014prices being you know exorbitant will share the bus with situ and each group will have their own tour guide um you know they'll have some similar experiences some sort of a different itinerary but overall that keeps the price down too and then along the way I mean we saw last year some kids made friends or re rekindled old friendships where they might have played Sports together when they were younger so it's a a really positive um aspect of the way the trips together yeah know I I I I think it's I think it's great and uh I appreciate I mean Quebec is a French speaking Province right here it would be a shamed not to take advantage of that so I really again appreciate you guys putting this together with that I'll close off my
015time miss hand I don't know if you wanted to take the up ask any questions or make any comments I don't have any questions I think you know I absolutely agree with the fact that being these opportunities is crucial and important so um I love it thank you yeah thank you very much uh and so with that unless there's any other um comments from I'd entertain a motion to approve the uh Caz middle school quec trip of 2025 any motion to that effect made by Miss lki do I have a second second second by Miss Hannah all in favor I I I all opposed no extensions uh so the motion carries for nothing and uh thank you very much m I won't even pretend thank you so um I think we'll invite Mr Willis to
016the to to the front for a discussion about the C High School Europe trip um this ending order so the floor is yours thank you say maybe before he starts we could just say congratulations thank very much big wi last night I you know down to the wire those of us in the stands I'm sure you as well felt the stress the pressure in the last seconds took by but really fun afterwards yeah and we wish you luck on Saturday thank you very much Lindfield defending state champ so try to take time for I hope so down that' be great so uh but uh but a Europe trip it's for 26 us what you what what you know um so this will be my 12th I think um we tend to go every year to
017leave room for other trips that opportunities that pop up and um so this one will be uh kind of international relations focused starting in Geneva and ending in Munich um we um will go through um a good chunk of Switzerland and lonstein and go to salsburg and Austria and then end up in Munich in Germany um it is a agenda from I want to say 10 10 maybe 11 days um it will be uh capped at probably in the neighborhood of 40 it's usually cap at whatever the our bus can fit um um so we usually you know we'll open it up to everybody and then when it's full we start a waight list from there and go to about 4 I think our last trip the Switzerland the C The MAX bus was 49
018so we had 42 kids and seven adults it's a one to six um adults to shapon to students so it's 1 to six plus we have a tour director from MEF who comes with us as well um we're GNA you know um we add things as we go but that itinerary is a customized itinerary that I did through EF um they and I have been working on it for about 6 months now um I've been throwing them things that I want to do and they've been working out how to get it in there and then when the price is too tooo high we would drop stuff move stuff to try to get it back down close that the price that's there doesn't that includes um some travel bonuses but I'm hoping that um we can
019actually get it down under another another 400 less because of the amount of students we'll have and because we'll be able to offer it I hope to students with a little bit of an early registration bonus the goal is to get them in before um give them the option that if they want to sign up before January they can that way they can uh knock some knock some money it and also gives them a full year to sad the payments um and to organize fundraisers at B so to um been over April break of 26 and um the chaperon would be worked out between myself and Mr Scott we tend to do a I I try to try to come up with a mix of of teachers a couple of people who' have gone with
020me before so I've got some experience a couple people who haven't had an opportunity to go on a trip like this before and then maybe a few people who are not teachers because to lower the the burden of Subs of the costs usually miss one sometimes two days max of school um because we usually fill a bus and have one trip that we usually get our first we we have at least the last five or six times we've gotten our first priority for departure dates so we've been able to minimize the M days usually it's one or two on the front side of April break almost all we've always been back by we haven't missed any days on the other side of April break which is good it's usually senior junior senior dominated and they
021come back for AP exams okay um I just before we move it open the floor uh the material seem to have maybe maybe some pages skipped um so can you can you remind us what the cost is I have if you want to give me the I have it I2 5100 5200 and that's with the global protection and there and with the um with the a couple of other fees that might they are optional um and that's also without the early registration bonuses so I think that if they were to put full full price the max would be I think I want to say it's 5200 yeah yeah uh yes there's the first eight days right there um there it is yeah the adult cost isn't actually that because our adults go for three it's
022one for six um so that's it and you said it's junior senior dominated they're they're the ones that tend to sign up first a lot of the younger kids we we've had on occasion um I never had more than one or two freshman and I've had on occasion sophomores go typically though the parents want to wait until their kids are older and and do it when I used to teach a for European history to 10th grade I had a lot of 10th graders now that it's 11th and 12th grade course I don't give very many 10th grades um and a lot of times if your parents have students in the 10th grade they're like well you go every other year so in a couple years we'll try um I open it to everybody we come
023up so the goal is to try to have a um you know have it introduce it to students and parents before the holidays sometimes parents and families like to like to use that as their as their logic Point um and it also gives them a chance to think about it and have a few weeks to sign up ahead of January 1st because you get a qu you get a discount if you sign up previous year um and and then um yeah it's not a senior trip it's not a AP Euro I teach AP European History and they're the ones that seem to be the most interested but it's not restricted to them anyway I open it to everybody and it's it's it's very much you know put stuff all over the school and we we
024tell all the kids we through the and they we have them come in and then I I tell them when when the registration is going to open and then usually typically in the past it has filled up relatively quickly within you know a month or two um but I would also say that about 75 to 80% of kids who get on the wait list eventually do get in because what happens is a lot of families will sign up early and then by May or June they decide we're going to do something different and come back I'll just uh open up the committee for questions if you have questions or want raise your hand sorry no no you're fine mki um could you elaborate a little bit further please on um the fundraising aspect because what
025I heard was sort of that like if kids decide they want to fund raise is it done as a group is it done individually we haven't done them as a group because um we we would do them as a group I I would be happy to do them as a group if everybody wanted to typically they don't which means that when we've done them miss a group some kids have put a lot more work into it and gotten less so what I encourage them to do is if they want to do smaller independent ones in small groups or even individually I'm going to support them and help them do that um if they wanted to do a big group one and everybody was in on it I would help them do that as well um
026typically over the course of a year uh the one the other benefit of if we can introduce it now and they can get started it gives let's them spread out payments over a 14mth period um so sometimes I find out about the fundraisers that they because they do it on their own in the community or within their own own families and stuff but um yeah you know the fundraising thing is is it's it's kind of wide open and it's really up to them whatever they have the energy to do I'm going to help them and support them and do it but I don't have any like big set organiz that I run for them and do you feel like the student body is aware of of that opportunity enough so that a child for whom
027fundraising would be essential to their participation in the trip that they would feel like there was at least enough sort of understanding of how this works to like come to you and say like I really want to go but you know my family can't quite swing this or could only swing half of it um what are my options I don't want to overgeneralize I think that I've been very I've been Amazed by the innovation of some kids in terms of what they've come up with and how they've done it um and I certainly tell them right from the get-go at the beginning meeting when I introduced it to them and parents said hey if you have ideas for fundraisers I'm on board and I'll help you out um but I'm not going to give them
028to you and I'm not going to run them for you I'm going to help you run it and I'm going to be a resource uh so whether they take me up on that is I guess um hit or miss it's different every year um but I I don't want to say they are all aware of it because I I don't know that that's true questions I would just you're not familiar with Education First this is a Class Act they are based here in Boston um they run this is all they do the whole family is own company for the whole time so they're highly competent oper yeah I've always worked with the f um ever since my first trip back to Russia in ' 06 07 and that was the first time and um I
029was I just loved them as a company and so I just sense um there are there are other companies some are some are most most of them T to be a little pricier but they might have you know U maybe they have bigger meals or hotels close to the city and stuff I've always been of the attitude listening to get me there I'm going to augment the trip and make it I've done this enough to know how to like kind of add things as we go to make them you know uh I just want to I just think the experience of going as a group for the kids is something that it's just been lifechanging I've seen so many of my Travelers go come back and immediately start like applying to college in Europe see
030I've got when we were in lucern last year I ran into a whole family um whose son had gone with me a couple of trips earlier and they said oh he's living in Italy right now with because he got the bug when he came over here and it's just um it's just I've seen it just change kids lives and I I think it's a really amazing experience for um and that's why I hope that I'm you know vocal enough when I tell tell them hey if you don't think you can afford it let's let's let's talk about that let's make it work I bet we can find resources for $5,000 for a year um can you talk to us a little about the um again inter uh the supervision aspects I will um you know
031sure we arrange Etc um the trips are so we're usually on one bus together for most of the trip um there have been trips on occasion we've done trains boats um I'm actually try and work a little bit of train went into this one but I think it's going to be majority us it's it's one to six um adults to plus we have uh a tour director who's an EF person who's there with us all the time um I would say 90% of the trip is is is as a grouper or in small groups um there are free time opportunities in cities where we'll we'll be we'll be in a square and we'll say okay we've got two hours and this is Year we're in groups of three or four they all have my my
032cell number and the tour director cell number the chapons are just kind of spread around um I think those free time opportunities uh are sometimes the kids most favorite or at least one of the most impactful moments because they are in a city where they don't speak the language and now they've got to function and and it's just kind of amazing to see what they do um the um but the trip as a whole we have I'm it's not just me the tour leader I have a tour director that EF sends with me and they're with us they're there all the time um they run tours there all the time all the hotels and restaurants we use are used to having multiple tour groups through um EF has you know places they use um so
033they're always pretty good about you know this is this is uh we do this all the time so this is where we can be and what we can do what about lodging and saving RS all hotels that EF uses usually a lot of other groups sometimes um sleeping RS are always you know there's um male and female rooms um between two and four I get them into groups ahead of time and we jockey them into groups where we have groups of four but then two twos within it so that they um so they get their preferred roommates um chaperon are always on the same you know on the same floors they're in hotels that EF uses all the time um often times um there's other tour groups from other schools in some of the hotels
034we go to because there's other tours that are either intersecting with ours or traveling along either the same route or reverse um yeah I mean I I I um I I between myself and EF we've just done this I mean I do you room checks and St like that but other than that I I don't sounds like you've had a lot of experience doing it as well so that also and keeping kids out of trouble we we're b in a thousand so far so hopefully we'll keep keep going uh the only so in all the years we've had the only the worst things that ever happened is we've caught kids planning to do things and we're yeah no it's it's um it there's a pretty amazing shared responsibility and shared um one of the things
035I emphasized with the m the we do a number of meetings and little workshops up until the church leave um is you know this is a you you really are making each other's trip too like you this is great I'm loving that you have this I love that you get to do this but in the end you got to recognize that you're you know you have an opportunity to positively or negatively impact a lifechanging experience for 51 other people and you you got to take that seriously and they shared social responsibility of it they they really do take it seriously they really do look out for each other um it's amazing how close they get um I've seen kids who didn't even hang out or really know each other at all beforehand become very fast
036friends on trip and afterwards um and it's uh I think that Collective sort of look out for each this is where I think my coaching thing comes I just I I treat the trips very similar the way I treat a a soccer season where I tell the kids from day one listen you you don't all have to be best friends but you're all responsible for all of us coming home happy and having having had a great time and and they I think they they have all universally across the board has students I've taken I've always taken that very seriously been great that's great any other questions or comments from Mr so there's a great deal of unrest today here but hopefully that will be wrapped up um if you don't have a plan can you
037discuss with them timeline for cancellation and things I have to do that yeah we've had right up until they can we can do c we can do cancellation with either money back or with vouchers and stuff all the way up until we buy plane tickets which is usually a couple of months before um and we've had it we we've had we had a trip to Spain where we were going to Morocco and there was unrest in Morocco and we had to at the last basically three weeks beforehand we had to cut Morocco from the trip and we were able to add a couple of other states in southern Spain to it we had a trip that was completely canceled because of the Iceland volcano one year where we were all getting ready to go to
038Prague and uh Vienna and we had to um the whole trip was canceled because the Iceland volcano went out the week before before we were supposed to leave and shut down and we were able to um basically get all the kids their tickets and all the kids who wanted to they could either get a voucher to go to the next year or they could get a voucher to go to the next year and we were able to off reoffer it to students and get them all sold for full price and get all the money back to that um we've been when I went to Russia one year we were in St Petersburg and there were riots in Moscow and we were in Moscow and there were riots in St Petersburg and we found out about
039both when we got home um we were in France with were in southern France from theal burn down um we were into par we went to um Paris and there was a u a a tourist attack attack on tourist in Paris right before like a month before we had gone uh and I always tell parents and students you know the safest time to go is after that happens security is crazy everybody on high alert um but so we've had a we've had enough we had had the um I had a trip where we were all going to Eastern Europe and I had to rebook everybody's flight the weekend before we left get us on 52 flights because of cancellation so we we've pretty much run into most things up until then but yeah when it
040um EF does this all the time they um air a good friend of mine was was on um uh was on a trip to Greece where they had to cancel the trip at C home from Rockland High School and um because a student had Cardiac Arrest while they were there um totally anything was just thing and the way EF dealt with it blew my mind and I just like they so good at this and they just have every contingency led up so um you know I feel pretty I feel pretty comfortable I feel like I've seen most of what of War breaking out Cas we can the trip something there another um questions or comments to the committee I'll will uh request a motion to approve the grass School Europe trip for 2026 Mo made
041by Mr car I second second second by Miss Hannah all in favor I all opposed no all right motion carries four nothing which is unanimous with our uh with our Quorum tonight so thank you very much for doing this trip again and uh we look forward to hearing about how wonderful it was you all very much thanks for that too good luck thank you I'll be honest having my kid live in Europe afterwards is an selling point um so I don't he's got to stay here mine's in Arizona that's way too far yeah so excellent so thank you very much uh that include concludes our invited guests we'll move on to our superintendent updates with our superintendent schools Mr Sarah Shannon hi Shannon it's floor is yours um so I would like to to start
042off by celebrating educational support Professionals Day which was today um our educational support professionals or esps are integral to the success of our district of our teachers and of our students um they are the people that our students and our staff rely on on a day-to-day basis they are often the first people who celebrate a student when they need to be celebrated or they are the first person to notice that they're struggling or to give them the pep talk that they might need um and their kindness their compassion their skill for working exper with our students does not go unnotice we' be lost without them and our schools all did different things to celebrate our esps today and we just want to publicly thank them for all that they do on on a regular basis
043um we could not function without them I also wanted to give a quick update on our feasibility study process um we are well on our way we are probably about halfway through the visioning process or the feasibility process we finished the visioning sessions and we've been having some program meetings those are smaller meetings about the numbers of spaces that we need things like that um a lot of the location Studies have been completed um they actually came today and they did a traffic study and so we're ready to update the community about where we are so we will be holding a community Forum on Tuesday December 2nd at 6:30 right here in the learning commment we'll be sending information out about that tomorrow um and you know we hope that people will come and listen
044and ask questions it's definitely still a work in progress we won't be completed with the feasibility process until mid to end of February but we think it's really important that the community gets regular updates and so we invite everybody to come in on Tuesday at 6 Tuesday December 2nd at 6:30 I think is it Tuesday is the third oh might be yes December 3rd December 3rd it's December 3rd at 6:30 thank you very well you're right the second is the Monday we come back yes um so December 3rd um also wanted to share that as part of my entry plan I had scheduled and planned to spend full days in all of the schools and I was able to spend the day in De hill and in Ord already tomorrow I'll be at middle school
045and Friday I'll be at high school and they have been really fun um there is nothing better than being out of office and seeing teachers and talking with teachers and seeing students and talking with students and I've just learned a lot and been able to just sort of see a regular day in each school and it's been great um and so it's a practice that is a part of my entry plan but actually I think it's a practice I will continue to try and do like twice a year because I think there's just great value in being available um for any stapff to just check in or touch Bas or whatever the case might be I also love when teachers say hey I'm doing this why don't you come by and see because then you
046get to see some really great things happening so I thank o good and dear Hill for hosting me and I'm looking forward to being at the middle school and the high school this week um you know Mr Willis was just here but I do want to congratulate all of our fall sports teams most of who have wrapped up their Seasons um the girls soccer team played a tough game last night they did please to Sutton um in the end three to one but um we're excited to go watch the boys play on Saturday at Curry College in the state tournament for soccer for division 4 I think we're not quite sure what time that game is going to be yet so as soon as we know we definitely will publicize that among the community um
047and I just want to encourage the entire Community this Friday night at 700 p.m or Saturday afternoon at 4 P.M is the Middle School U musical it is High School Musical Junior and so it is sure to be a lot of fun we're also going to be publicizing that with our elementary schools because it'd be a great play for elementary students to come and enjoy and maybe get their first taste of theater um although I know dear Hill does plays as well so but it's always fun to see the older kids performing so um I'm going Friday night and hope that lots of folks will pack the pack the theater for our middle schoolers who put in a lot of time and energy to make this performance happen and to do it well that's my
048report for today thank you very much any questions or comments on the report from the Committee hearing none I think we'll go to our next agenda block teaching and learning uh with a uh report student achievement update uh I think we're talking incast results I'll turn it over to uh Dr scollins to uh to take us through Rock is gonna say I was say rock Roberts our director of data evaluation curriculum pulled this all together did most of the work on this so um will take us through and it's his birthday today oh and it's birthday [Laughter] I wanted I thought I saw them bring celebrate with the entire community and um and Michael steton our director of student services will also be sharing some information so the three of us are take you through
049all right so uh I just thrilled to be here on um my birthday to celebrate an our data um and one of the nice things about being in this position for the last two years in Cohasset is really being able to see our data at all the different buildings and kind of creating this presentation really was really kind of creating our story it's because the data tells a story there's a lot behind the data every data point is students it's teachers it's one grade leading into the next grade um and so I think tonight some things I want people to take away from this is yes we're an exceptionally High performing District we have a lot to celebrate um we're proud of our teachers we're proud of our students um and we're always looking for
050the areas to grow we don't rest on our Laurels we look at the areas where um we can improve and and seek to to improve those areas um the other thing that I would say just a as uh a second you're um member of the Cohasset public school district is um one of the reasons I came here and and one thing that I see uh in the work that we do is we really do try to live our vision our mission and our core values and our vision of a graduate is really I think the whole notion is that our students are shaped by those things um so rather than start today and kind of go through the data I really wanted to start where the foundations are laid with osit so the the um
051presentation will will go from our youngest students to um our our seniors so um we'll have our celebrations uh we're going to before we actually get into the data we're going to talk a little bit about mcast in the election because that's the topic I'm sure people are thinking about uh a quick I I have the wrong one I think you're good you're good yep nope that's a wrong one thank youit L of different Sor it's uh revised about that talking about I said you know what I I had six uh different versions of happy birthday today so I think I'm good good we could make that happen I I bet you could I bet you could could had sing French now that that would have been something all right there we go now we're
052good that's that's it yeah uh so yeah we'll talk a little bit about mcast the election and uh then move into this uh spring data and U highlight some some things and then talk about kind of our next steps so accountability so here is our um 2024 accountability data data for meeting and exceeding our targets so high school um is and I'm going to do my best with this this is a new formula too for us and so I've got all my little information here um and so they changed it last year so I want to do a little bit of that before I talk specifically of our numbers um but in 2023 it was two years of data now they're looking at three years of data they're waiting it um a little differently so
053um prior the the was 22 23 the 22 years were 40% of the waiting and then the the 23 was 60% now it's three years of data so the first two years are 15% your most current is 60% um and so that kind of changes how how things look a little bit um and they also are looking at some of the different pieces around chronic absenteeism now has a little more weight than it did in the past because that's a problem we have in the district they're looking at um that gap between our um lowest performing students and higher and then what's happening with our general achievement scores and so um that's why we have um so it's like this big soup so we're still trying to figure it all out because it is so
054new for us um but they're still looking at achievement student growth High School completion rate for the high school um looking at engl English language proficiency which actually isn't a big um we don't have a lot of students who are ml or multilanguage Learners um but that is a criteria and then The Chronic absenteeism also um and then the number of students that take Advanced courses at the high school level so those are all the criteria they use so if we look at the high school um our lowest performing students earned four out of four for growth and four out of four for achievement that's very very good and so we're really happy about that um we earned all our points for chronic aism so we did not get d on that because at the
055high school level we actually don't have a problem with aism um other districts do we do not which is really nice um and then the seven out of 12 points for all students um in achievement it's interesting because this is if we look at it from a districtwide if you but if you want to go in and look at all the accountability ratings if you look at the high school it has four out of 12 so we're actually is that right yeah they have two different they have two different numbers so we're not exactly sure and we have to get we need more information about what that means um but this is where um but this is where we're at right now um and then for non- high school so that's anything obviously um three
056through eight we had 10 out of 12 for achievement in math Six out of our eight points for growth in math and Ela and our lowest um performing students chronic absenteeism didn't get any point so we do have um our absenteeism at at the elementary level is higher than we would like it to be um it gets a little better in middle school and then it's not a problem in high school so and that and even at o good so that's something that we're going to look into and work with families around um trying to get our kids into school and figure out why they're not coming to school and then supporting families to get their students here um and then these are the really nice numbers are accountability percentiles so we get kind of
057ranked 95% at the High school um the middle school 93% 93% and then de Hill is 87% those are really strong just yeah no I I think from the perspective if you guys have questions just jump in it's better do it now while we've got the data and the slides up ex our mind so just miss have question is the four out of four or the seven out of 12 is that out of um like four out of four areas of growth or four out of four total points the total points okay and are those is that the structure for all of those sort of fractional um pieces so it's seven out of 12 possible points in achievement yes okay okay and what is the definition of chronic AB absenteeism uh 10 days okay and
058sorry um and then the accountability percent that is a standard that the state creates for each district and so that we're meeting 95% of what the state believes we should be doing okay thank you on that is it are we better than 95% of all districts of the state or is this we're have we're meeting 95% of the things that we should be doing so it's a comparison with schools like us that have the same okay so so we are better than 95% at the high school but we have a higher accountability score than 95% of our peer schools that's yes okay and that that helps us put some context because I didn't know what seven out of 12 7 to 12 is good or 7 12 is bad because yeah like that was a
059that was a math quiz 7 to 12 probably not great but if it's if that leads to the 95% accountability for is probably pretty good and as we and as as we get used to this new formula we'll have a better sense of it um it's always a little bit been using we kind of call it the ncast soup and put all these things in together but um when we look at some of the big things around our performance our growth um we met our targets and so those are all good things did they change the formula every year that's good that way that way you don't compare your prior years exactly and it's really hard and they did a big shift for this year because they had it an extra year that Reed it
060they put you know so um we we thought to be honest with you when they rolled this out in the spring I figured at the high school we would see something because of just how the formula was worked around it it took away from our acheve they took it actually away from our achievement and put it in other places so looks like we got it back yeah I mean we actually did okay yeah but when you kind of look at some of those numbers you know like 12 out of 12 but you know but like so I'm just trying to figure that out any other questions from the committee Mr car the the number 10 in The Chronic absenteeism is that by semester by year 10 days oh 10 days in a year yeah so
061anything over 10 10 or more consider and the state has that has been their push for to this is the second year in a row and so they are um raising so takes for us in the accountability because of absenteeism um and so it's a big Focus it's a big push and you know you it's hard to teach students who are and is this also looking at The Chronic absenteeism only of our Lo lower performance students or is that just overall Elementary attendees because here like I'm just reading it as didn't get the points for our lower performing students because there's too much chronic abs ISM in that population okay we're working on a communication strategy around that so um Michael will talk more about this towards the end but we do have a system
062in place there are certain rules and regulations and laws actually that um dictate how we deal with attendance and so when a student is absent for 5 days unexcused they get a letter 10 days they get a letter then it sort of progressively becomes more we have partnership meetings we have conversations with parents at the extreme it does become a process where we look at um Court involvement things like that that's the extreme I don't want to freak people out right um because it's very rare it but there is a very power process I'm notified as this like increases for students and so if students are in IEPs like IEP meetings will be held information will be adopted into those documents to address um challenges [Laughter] withm um all right so uh big question that
063people have what happens now the mcast happened the elections happened and now um the um mcast is no longer considered part of your competence determination when you are graduating we have lots of other pieces that um go into whether you uh you know whether the competence determination has happened right it's not just mcast um and so um we shall see what people you know what happens but um there's other things and other criteria so what computer it's my computer yes oh God so just those at home there's there's a buzzing that's coming so that's superintendent Shen's gonna take this over I'm gonna shut my computer down so people don't have to listen to this um but just before um we get there um the students that are taking the fall mcap that are making it
064up it still counts um and then um the law actually doesn't take effect until December 5th at the ear you have shut it down oh there it goes so anyway so more to more to be um revealed as we move through this and to see what it actually is going to look like um in the spring when we get more information after the L to expect all right so let's get to the data uh so here here's the foundation so uh this represents the composite scores uh for our K through two students on dibles um composite so Dibbles the Dibbles testing is a number of different components this takes it and puts it all together uh so you see where kids were in kindergarten first and second at the beginning of the year middle of
065the year and end of the year um the blue is what Dibbles uh refers to as core Plus so they're kind of like above grade level the green is core um yellow is strategic and the U the red is intensive so that kind of dictates the amount of intervent what their intervention needs are um so that gives you a sense of where our kids are in terms of uh and this is all around literacy so this is literacy k through2 then also it uh o good we have um I ready and so these numbers correlate pretty closely with uh Dibbles and so you can see that 75% of our um students at o good are uh mid or above grade level um and then 12% being early on grade level but considered grade level and
066then the yellow is one grade below um and it's it's worth noting that um of all our students it OS could we don't have anyone who's uh more than one grade level below which is uh when we were talking with the uh person from IR who was doing a lot of our training he said you just don't see this kind of thing um because there's a lot of kids who struggling right out of the gate so it's pretty impressive and here it is for math we don't uh we don't have dibles for math dibles is all literacy so this is the I ready uh math and here you see we have 69% mid or above and 13 at uh 17 one below and 1% um is two grades below so we leave OSG good and
067head over to Deer Hill walk up the hill um and here we have three three through five this is dibles data so we we we uh Minister DBL K through 5 uh and so here you see the same thing it's composite the uh components that are tested change they get more challenging as kids move on uh the literacy uh I the literacy demands are a little bit more complicated so you see that there you're starting to see some kids kind of in that intensive Zone where the red was a smaller at OSG good it's now you know you see there's a 9% 11% 8% um kids but still you're uh above and at are um you know 79 80 81% and we also run I ready and we start mcast so here we have our
068mcast data our grades three through five is on the top part of that slide and the IR ready 335 data is on the bottom so just taking you through through our 3 through five uh mcast the uh bar graph on the left shows our exceeding meeting partially meeting not meeting uh with the percentages corresponding and then the line graph on the right shows Trends over time so that's 2021 which is kind of a funky year because it was like an abbreviated mcast uh and then you get 22 23 and 24 you can see just a a slight dip that's a couple percentage points uh between 23 24 um but we had 62% of our kids me exing and I don't there's a number behind the growth percentage 54.2 okay 54.2 so what we're looking for
069growth in terms of state is between 40 and 60% um so we're right in that mid so so the kids kids are growing at the expected rate um and that's our 3 through five and then at the bottom is the I ready the I ready kind of closely corresponds with the exceeding and meeting of mcast um it's interesting that that's mid or above grade level and some of the conversation I've had around IR ready is it's a little bit different in different states based on what they're U testing is so they were doing they were adding in a whole another piece for Massachusetts that were kind of predicting where your mcast scores would be um that they kind of put in place last year and here's the same thing for math uh worth noting that
070the number of uh students exceeding in math is 14% so that number uh seems to be rising pretty consistently and our total number of students exceeding meeting is 70% which is a is a nice number and that that line graph on the right is is trending upward um and then not meeting is at 5% um which is uh if you were looking at the uh I ready data from Oz good that number was uh was around six or seven so it's it's interesting as kids kind of uh move further into mathematics uh it's it's it's kind of fun to watch the math in our district move because uh kids are moving up and more kids are getting exceeding and um and the trend lines are nice too uh all right so then we go into
071science so science grade five we had a uh we had a nice year last year 71% of our students exceeding a meeting uh we had a nice jump from the previous year and again only 3% not meeting uh is a pretty good number and now we'll move on to the middle school so the Middle School Ela now we have 24% of students exceeding which you see that exceeding number grow uh our total number of students meeting and exceeding is up to 7 75% um our Trends line is pretty stable um and then down to the I ready is uh we're still the 78% early on to above grade level um but you can see that the the 65 the bottom level that now we see a few more kids popping up in the three or
072more grade levels below uh so those are a lot of our kids who are seeing a lot of support things that nature and then math uh we got 12 12% exceeding our total 67% meeting are exceeding uh took a slight dip between 23 24 uh but still significant number at or above grade level uh that 3% not meeting um is also is a pretty good number we're minimizing that we and we introduced a new math program at the middle school so sometimes you'll see a slight dip yes getting used to so we're digging in deeper and yeah that was the implementation last year yeah and then uh Science and Technology uh last year we had 55% uh meeting exceeding um kind of digging into this one a little bit uh we missed some we missed
073some points really around Life Sciences so we're going to kind of look at that and see what's going on with that and then we move to the high school so here's our high school mcast we don't do I ready at the uh High School level uh but this is this is a um our Ela scores now we're up to 93% meeting or exceeding and I the percentage is at the end of exceeding and meeting are missing so I'll let I'll let you know there was 32% of students who took the uh pla mcast in 10th Grade exceeded expectations and 61% met um that's just phenomenal um that uh was the third highest in the State uh and our growth percentage is 60% too so even you know we had great scores last year I believe
074we were 89% to go 89 to 93 and then have 60% growth um for our students is is it's fabulous and you can see that there's nobody in the not meeting expectations and the same with not meeting expectations in math we have uh zero kids who aren't in that category I took a little dip in math from 2023 uh we're looking at that as well looks like some geometry questions but we're drilling down figuring out where it was and um what we can do about it uh again we got growth at 56% and uh and then not being zero and so that number of the 28 partially meaning those numbers are um are better than they were I believe last year Science and Technology uh we had 177% exceeding it's 78 exceeding and meeting uh
075there's just the trends are great um it's there isn't a growth percentage on this because they they didn't take it successive years um but uh you know it's that's a great number this is physics yes is a physics and now moving into kind of our upper classman are 11th and 12th graders on the left hand side is the percentage of total AP students with scores of three or better and so that's over a fiveyear period um that number I believe over 2024 is 88% the same as 2023 uh so I mean that's that 88% of your kids are scoring three or better um is significant and then uh this isn't on it but doing some uh subsequent research it's 80 to 85% of our students take at least one AP um test uh before they
076graduate um so we've got a significant number of kids taking APS and a significant number of kids doing very well uh and then on the right is just a school summary by year uh the number of exams that were taken the number of students and um there uh number of kids who were three plus uh and then the total number of AP students who scores three plus percentage sorry so then what I did is I looked through all our AP data and we have a ton of AP courses for a school our size so we had 22 different tests taken some were Singleton some were three some were seven um so we're meeting a lot of the needs of kids who want to take AP test in different subject areas but what I did is
077I I took the classes that had enrollment of 20 or more um and so these are those courses the number of students that enrolled in those courses and then what the average score was uh so you can kind of see that and then in parenthesis next to it looking at this data over five years span where did that number come in in terms of um in relation to other years so highest next to it means the highest average in the last five years so it was a phenomenal year um really when you're looking at a k through 12 um and just even the varied statistics uh in the English lit and as a former AP Lit teacher uh was 67 kids taking it and with a 3.45 uh average um that's that's pretty amazing because
078that's more than half of your senior class probably two-thirds of it and sat data is a little different because you're mixing maybe a sophomore and juniors and seniors together uh so what I did with this is the year constitutes uh the tests that were offered over that period um and just kind of combined them and took uh averages and compared it to the national average at the same time so you can see here that um our average combined with the ntion we're significantly higher than the national average of in the last three years and uh our reading and writing scores and our math scores are very strong and uh our number of test takers has decreased sat was being used a little bit less right around the pandemic and now it seems to be um
079gaining in popularity again as as schools are looking for that standard number that they can kind of look at all their students through the same lens my expectation would be that that number will probably grow but it also reflects our own population too now the fun part when we look at our district in relation to surrounding towns and and uh so here we have grade 3 through eight Ela on the left grade 10 Ela on the right uh the the line that's above us on the left is uh hangam and below that is situate Marshfield and the state so those are your your colors uh and then you can see our uh 10th grade ELA scores up there almost all the way to the top that's 100% at the top we're closing in on that
080and then here we are for math same thing same colors top one uh on the left is hangam and top one on the right this year is also hangum um and you can just kind of see that we're we're all kind of up there if I to pause there very quick just to see an observation um the bump up on grade 3 through eight math seems to be a secular bump up something changed in 2021 um we said does that correspond to the bridges program y so that's a nice visual um proof in the pudding nice and then this is the science so uh you see our uh 3 through eight science on the left and we had a uh we had that significant jump um in 10th Grade where u a lot of the
081other districts were going in out a direction yeah and Russ Sears who is our physics teacher he's been involved with the state so he's been on this um committee and so he's been learning all sorts of things about the assessment and what they're looking for and so we started changing our practices um based on that you can see how it popped up and then second so I'm want to give him a lot of credit for because it's extra time for him to do this but also it's been really helpful for us when we're looking at what are the expectations around of Science and it's made it more Hands-On more how do we how do we get kids to thinkers um the whole team job and then just putting together some celebrations um all of our
08210th grade students met the mcast compeny determination um you can't go without saying that the National Blue Ribbon School for academic Excellence the High School AP Platinum school there are numbers for exceeding meeting expectations uh the third highest in ela uh 86% of our high KN students met are exceeded expectations and um again none of our students scored not meeting expectations and then looking six through eight our sixth grade ELA scores were um the highest in the state our fifth grade eighth grade scores um our fifth highest eighth grade ELA scores sorry I've got numbers and words confused my experience as English teacher uh and then we had 67% of our students meeting are exceeding in math and uh for high needs we had growth and partial inclusion student math scores from not meeting to
083partially meeting and then in grade three through five fifth grade achievement scores were higher in all subject areas uh our fourth grade students exceeded expectation in math increased by 9% and our third grade student succeeding expectations in ela increased by 8 % which um put our meeting and exceeding scores uh higher than they have been uh in then going back even to 2019 so in third grade we finally you know in the state there's been a lot of concern because the scores in ela and literacy have been consistently going down um since 2019 uh our third grade is now moved up and is actually going in the other Direction um and then High needs in grade three is the first time test takers had the smallest number of students not meeting expectations which is significant
084because that was a concern of ours coming in to this to uh last Academic Year exactly that was our our uh student Opportunity Act was that plan part of what we knew that we needed to do for our um High population and now in terms of our op opportunities for growth we've had our glows here our grows uh while we've made strides and writing and it's been a focus uh last year there's still room there's still room to grow there uh and and we're we're doing um writing responsive reading we've got a lot of different initiatives going around with that as well um we're also doing a lot of work with benchmark assessments uh and a lot of those are U related to run so that is happening U this year um in math and
085science we're looking at standards and we're using some of the new data U resources that we have uh been working on this year to kind of identify growth standards but we can now look at them over a four or five year period and see where we've been missing um the mark over a span of time and then look at that in relation to our curriculum uh and see what kind of changes need to be made uh as always we look to move the margins we look at um the students who are kind of just on the border and how do we how do we get them over to the next level how do we move kids and continue the high percentage for growth um I've been doing data meetings uh I just went through all
086the uh Deer Hill teachers and showing them the new data dashboards that we're working on to bring about uh hopefully well everyone will have access the end of this year early next year and how they can look at their own data to drive their own instructional decisions so there's been a great really great conversation and um just having a one spot where um teachers can look at uh their classroom data uh it's going to make a big difference and then also um we're working uh districtwide with the development of benchmarks uh especially at the secondary level which uh will help us with our curriculum alignment so when we're moving we're not losing sight of uh all the standards and how they flow from one grade to the next um so then when we think about
087action steps to support High need students the data in 2023 did indicate um that there was a proficiency gap for high need students when it related to Statewide assessment and so you know recently I attended a conference with Dr scollins and our data you know support lease um it person to kind of sort out where these discrepancies were was it a data component which was an element to why we received that rating but then also really to look at um why there's that prions you got foring students so that could be you know special education students um you know elll students low income students and so I'll be working um to create a task force in the coming weeks that will be inclusive of general education teachers special education teachers parents you know District representation
088um to really look at those root causes behind those um proficiency gaps um without you know diving too deep into individual student data which will also be happening you know parallel to this process to really look at you know reasons behind that you know obviously students with identified disabilities you know would will struggle with you know State assessments um but it's really important to look at that data and to create individual plans for students to try to close that Gap um to move students forward I have to say it is exciting news though to see that all of our special education students um did meet that threshold for graduation requirements that you know meeting or exceeding expectations and it's also worth noting to that um while it has changed with the new with the election
089partially meeting also would indicate like that constitute determination and so it is good to see that while we have students identified as not meeting you know in the lower levels as we move through that number really to decrease and then at that 10th grade level where it really does you know kind of count in a sense um we see that kids do make it over the line um and so again the task force will really be looking at like what we can do sooner to try to close that proficiency Gap and so I welcome any you know participation from families or anyone you know at this point in time but there will be a correspond coming out um for an opportunity to join that that committee and that task force and then it's just important
090to consider what our special education staff do to support students on IEPs um when it comes to mcast scores and looking at kind of the breakdown of where you know students fell down on these tests so in item analysis which that data is relevant and will be super important too as we look at the different data dashboards that are created by the district um so special education teachers can really Target that specialized instruction with where there may be gaps whether it's a certain type of question on math um you know is it the open responses is it the writing which is a global concern that we're working on um and so that work does go on behind the scenes and that will come up at IEP meetings um with families as we consider how students
091um who receive special education services receive support when it comes to Statewide assessments great all right anything else before I open it to committee or so I I'll just kind of go around the room um M Hann you have any comments question questions yeah I mean this is obviously incredibly impressive from a number standpoint data standpoint and everything um curious and I get the focus of this is around mcast but like what are we doing to balance teaching to the test versus teaching in general yeah I mean I I think it's a good question I think um what I tried to do this year was kind of bring in some other data points where last year was all mcast um but we're reallying looking at a lot of our I data our benchmark assessments uh
092and and really that's driving it what mcast really helps us to do is say are we addressing all these standards and or are we falling a little short here and then um using that information we go back to the curriculum and look at our benchmark assessments look at our other assessment data and and we teach the standards so that's that's what all our curriculum is aligned to so they are teaching the standards but say well the test is the standards so if we are teaching well then they're going to do well on that right it's holistic and I think you know you are part of the visioning meetings as well and so as we think about those meetings and the Strategic plan that led us to this year and the Strategic plan that we will
093be building we are trying to build student learning experiences that are meaningful and it in Project based or deeper learning experiences and all of those experiences are designed around the standards and so there are ways to teach the standards that aren't what I think TR Community thinks of as teaching to the tests and so when you teach the standards in engaging ways where kids are jumping in and really thinking about content and curriculum then the test scores continue to show that they are achieving at high levels and that the teachers are teaching in ways that the the traditional test measurements so um I think it's it is a balance and I don't want anyone to ever think that we are only teaching to the test where this is the only measure of success you know
094student engagement and student um love of learning is equally as important um and one other question thank you for that I think that's important in terms of like do we as we look at this data are we looking at any like gaps from Co still being uh taking it effect or being a factor in especially in the that like Middle School Deer Hill So Co the impact of Co we're not seeing that as in any we're still a little bit um at Deer Hill but third grade like I said just just crossed that threshold um but that's been the longest delay has been the the literacy piece um I think we're the data coming out of OSG good is is really strong um and I think that feeds into that third grade um so um
095all the other subject areas that we don't see at all I'm sorry the fourth graders were in kindergarten during Co so it it's just I know that it it affected every grade level every child in a different way but every grade level in a different way and it just didn't know if we were seeing any sort of patterns or anything yeah no even uh we have seen it in in the 335 group um but even the last couple years it it's not significant once we get to middle school so it's like they're working through it they're yeah and it doesn't mean that some students still need support for sure but um we're not see Trends thank you Mr just I um I think that think I of data that looking at a lot of places
096don't um I work in a city that lost control of their public schools because they don't have any dat or tools to do so thank God we have this um I just I'm so pleased with the results I mean it's always there's room for improvement but I just it's nice and and I think it's great that we're transparent about what the results look like I think that's great so congratulations to everybody this true thank you mrki thank you I mean this is this was a lot to digest I was doing a lot of writing and like scribbling um so I probably have a 100 questions I'll limit myself um to maybe the ones that three minutes no no to two minutes watching I think my first just sort of observation was there was actually sort
097of what I looked at to see like sort of some like a static to our CH to the number of children to the population that's operating low grade level both on the Dibbles and in I ready and on the mcast at our elementary level and that by the time they're in high school that seems to go away which for me looking at that says well goodness if it is possible to have a school population within a building where all children are pretty or or at least above that um you know not meeting expectations then I would expect that that's also possible for our younger grades and what concerns me most about that is the sort of self-esteem aspect around struggle um and that presumably these children are sitting in our classroom struggling um in one
098way or another whether it's academically struggling or emotionally struggling to sort of engage and so of what can be done about that to move that needle um because that needle to me looking at it statistically wasn't really significant I'm not a statis you you could tell me be like no Jen that was a that is a St statistically significant change in those populations but looking at it as a sort of a neoy I was like yeah our our kids are going through Elementary School those who are in the Red Zone stay in that red zone gosh that stinks for them um and so I just sort of want to put out there sort of what can be done about that um how do we move that needle I really appreciate um Mr Stapleton how you
099put forward like really doing that item analysis really sort of digging in because these potentially these children are the ones who really need like oh gosh it's not all of this math section it's just that you didn't understand the comparative part of it um or whether it's the reading of the directions or the using of the technology or one of those things and I appreciate that as like a first step but I think overall looking at it that was a concern for me before before you go build on this question I have I have a similar thought always prompt ideas in my head is are these populations static or do we see kids come some kids come out of the Red Zone and into the green and then kids in the green to the red
100like how how how static or is it the same kids year over year who are are struggling that's a issue yeah and that's why I wanted to make a comment if it's okay just about like one of the growes of the partial inclusion students at the middle school level moving out of that not meeting range into partially meeting I think it's important to consider and like you know like obviously confidentiality is important in this type of venue when we look think about how many students because again the number isn't isn't large like the students that are not meeting or fall into those red zones have been identified as either special education students or students that are moving through like the mtss process so I completely understand we want to move them forward as well but
101they those students are receiving you know either specialized instruction or tiered support in these go areas and not necessarily teaching to the test but they align with the skills that would be on the test whether that's reading comprehension skills decoding skills math skills and as you know a former special ed teacher I think developmentally sometimes the test is overwhelming for students and why we see like as they grow developmentally as they receive specialized instruction over years how we are able to get them over that line in grade 10 not to diminish like I mean I think it should happen you know at the lower levels too um but I think that we are starting that work to really dive deep into like that analysis and recognizing that you know you know while we want High
102achieving for all students like there will be like you know some variability in how students perform and so I think it is important to emphasize that the students who are not meeting have been identified and are receiving supports to help them know globally not just to for the assessment comp as well but it's also across different measures so that with that with the the presentation that we're seeing dibles and I ready and mcass and you know part ofy understands these like sitting down and taking a standardized test is odious for anyone um dibles takes all three minutes and just still not be performing at a nor at you know that's a normed test um and that those children even though they're receiving that support and some of them have been reting since kindergarten but may
103still be within that Red Zone in in fifth grade um how can we move that needle I guess that's it's just sort of a call to action to sort of really make sure we're supporting our youngest students um the best we can and I think I think that district is doing a good job um it's just it was just that's what the data was that was what the story was that I talking when I was looking at those those um red bits neither here nor I mean it is here there um what's that it's here and there it's here and there yes um are all kids growing at the expected rate but when we're talking about average growth rates so is that an average and and how do we I guess maybe it's linked into
104this like really paying attention to our vulnerable students are they also growing yes yeah so some kids aren't so and they're on our radar and that's something you know people are looking at when they go to mtss things of that nature um and again just to elaborate on that too like if we see that a student is not making expected growth rates like that is an indicator if they haven't already been identified that they should be identified whether that's for a psycho educational evaluation to dive deeper um again so it's it's being addressed and then we're also considering the students disability in the profile and then how we support that glob and then I'll just end on because I know I only have two minutes and then five that's the correct style the looking at
105adding additional benchmarks in the upper levels is that something that's already been done in the elementary levels or if and if not why is that not applicable in the same way in terms how that works in the elementary level a lot of the benchmarking is done through the I ready and the dibles assessments as well so they have contion they have pre-test and po post test that they're using the elementary curriculum is far more structured uh than it is 6 through 12 so 6 through 12 often it's one teacher teaching a class and so then it becomes well what is what's that piece that's going to make sure that we're aligning sixth grade seventh grade e8th grade ninth grade so that's a lot of the benchmarking conversations happening at the secondary level at the elementary
106a lot of those are already placed you you have five six teachers right think thank you and again I mean I only have questions because it's interesting and I'm actually paying attention and engaged good questions you know and I think the beauty of some of the work that rock is doing with the data and the data dashboard develop is will be able to better actually answer some of those questions with regard to some specific students that we have been in the past um because we didn't have the visual representation that we need in order to actually than you um so I definitely agree with Miss and others there was a lot there will this be available to people website I think that I think that'd be that'd be helpful I know I myself would like
107to spend a little more time with some of the data just to understand what it is maybe have some more questions I guess generically speaking um you know you've got some you put forward some action plans and some some uh recommendations were there any other themes that have you've identified so far where we should be paying closer attention as a as a committee or just as a as a school or other opportunities for development at either at a building level at a grade level at a curriculum level um just trying to tease out what this data tells to the experts in the I mean yes I not sure there's anything yet for the school commity to support us other than you know helping us budget wise and making sure that we can keep people we
108have and grow when we need to add people positions that's the biggest know can do um to support us um Trends wise I think I don't think any I think the writing was really big and that's something that we're really focusing on because that is also across content it's not just in English it's in science it's in social studies it's even in math so I think that piece is our work this year to look at that and make sure there are literacy skills in all the all the content areas so we need to make sure that teachers are attacking that and that it's that we're working together in the same methods right in order to identify what those skills are should yeah I think so and it ties into the curriculum review cycles that we're
109we're doing too so we're doing curc review cycle in um English and social studies this year and so the data and and how we go about that whole review cycle and then what are what are our needs what are we lacking that's what we're looking for um and then you know what comes out of that um maybe maybe some ideas that are Beyond just the scope of what we're doing I certainly think that the school district should be lauded for certainly some of these data points um I think I saw a couple on there best in the state fifth best in the state I mean these are not these are not you know di Minimus accomplishments so kudos to our staff kudos to the administration and and also the students um I think that's great
110there's one this this presentation was different than prior years um so there's one data element that I didn't have that maybe we can look at in a in a future meeting um but a few years ago we had a data element that showed our um our our I don't I'm lacking the word but the lower performing students and there was a our our special needs students who had had um there was a high percentage who were not meeting expectations there was like 60% or something it was really it was really remarkable and I know Dr scol and J recall that and we really focused on that and I think that has improved over time and I'd love to see an update on that number which I didn't I didn't quite wasn't quite able to tease
111it through these statistic I know things may have changed and so on but uh that that is something that I think I'd like to U learn a little bit more about but this is this is great I think everyone should be should be proud of where we are and uh and I definitely commend you where we're going so any other thoughts from the committee any um questions before we move on great well thank you very much that was a incredibly fullsome report and I appreciate your uh your presenting it uh now it's my new least favorite section of the agenda budget resources and governance it's really the budget part that makes it my least favorite now um but um I will turn the floor over to miss Susan Owen our Director of Finance and operations
112to give us a another iteration of our uplifting budget report it's not as exciting as yeah we just went well I mean to be to be fair if we were making the most money of any school in the state as far as profits that'd probably be a problem so um but anyway let's let's see where we are okay so this is the um Finance report through the month of October um obviously the school budget numbers have changed the one thing that has changed is and I mentioned in the last meeting was we were going to project our salaries and get them encumbered on a purchase order so we can manually um track that we make sure we have enough um funding remaining to complete all our payrolls through the end of the year um that
113amount through the end of October was about a $17 million um number for salaries and that left us currently at the end of October with a shortfall amount of about $616,000 and when you say shortfall do you need a projected shortfall or do we have negative money in the bank right now um if I unencumbered the salaries we wouldn't be a deficit we have money in the bank but we know when we spend those that 17 million salaries we you will run out run out of it's projected deficit it is projected um but we do know and we've been following it and um superintendent Shannon and I and assistant superintendent scotlands have gone we literally have gone through the budget line by line by line and there is there is nowhere where there is someplace
114that we can Gathering savings um the other thing that Owens has encumbered are our utilities yes because we knew correct from previous years that those tend to go over so they've been she and Karen have encumbered what we have rejected plus a little bit correct expecting that those costs might rise there are you know there are other things that are incoming but the payroll is something that we haven't we haven't done in the past um the software we have doesn't allow for it so we we manually did it um but as of right now if those were the salaries to be paid out through the end of the year and the incumbrances that we have for utilities um we're looking at a deficit um and we're very aware of it um the budget is Frozen
115um there are not we're not overriding any budget um unless it's an emergency situation and that can only be approved through the superintendent um not great news um but we know about it early and we're we're doing you know doing everything we can to try to resolve that um and making we're communicating that out now um so it's not a surprise and doesn't grow um our sped tuitions um have not changed over the last month so last month we reported there was a shortfall of about $263,000 um that number did not change from last month to this month it was due to had three unanticipated out placements and one student mov from a collaborative to a private which is a very significant difference in tuitions um a quick quick summary if you go through the
116reports will show spend tuition on the 26340 on shortfall the utilities um the shortfall with the incumbrance is$ 189,000 were about 100,000 or more um short at the end of fi 24 um a special education Transportation has a short fall of about 10,000 right now codium supplies materials currently shows a deficit of 10,456 and we still have the remainder of the year to purchase um and there are some things we can't freeze like for custodia supplies we need to replenish tissues and paper towels and toilet paper cleaning supplies so that custo supplies materials deficit is going to grow um and then our salaries um whether it be we just hired in higher than the positions that we had or there are Lane changes um but right now salaries um are showing a shortfall um and
117and so these numbers here they add up to the 66 624 yes okay and then on the salaries these shortfalls this shortfall versus our budget amount that we approved the 239 million yes how do we the salaries how do we miss salaries by 143 was there additional staff because that should have been a noble budget so if when we when we plan the budget we're planning it now October November months December months the late um and we're presenting a budget um a lot of things change from January to June um there's Lane changes you know if teacher leaves and replace it with someone else um custodial salaries um we've been we've asked them to do more work than they used to doing so there was lots of Road time that was kicked in for the
118landscaping and stuff um same thing with you know a bus drivers um their s have been have been elevated so I mean that number um is with that incumbrance that incumbrance number could change if if I have you know if I have a teacher leave now that's at the highest step and then we hire and someone lower then those that salary number and that incumbrance number is going to lessen right okay so so between between when we projected when we planned our 23.9 million school budget we had changes in our staffing which resulted in yes 143 a snapshot in time no that's very helpful I appreciate that thank um these numbers could change um and again like our utilities we based our utilities and coverance on the usage from last year which is very high
119it may not happen again this year depends on the time of winter we have um and what the rates are at the time whether they Peak or off peak so again the utilities could also change that number is showing with all our incumbrances through June um so again it's it could wa there there's room here um but I'm just telling you the bad news up front y worst case scenario and then you know the usual I can show you that you know each school and where their budgets are and what they spent uh circuit breaker um nothing's changed with circuit breaker this is our current capital outlay um for f25 what was regular capital and what was stabilization and what was used and then this is a very draft Capital list for the following for
120next year um so you'll see you know we we have buses on there we have the electric bus on there we um are looking to add a bus as we have retired a bluebird aird is officially dead um so we've added an extra bus in there to replace I should say extra bus must to replace that blue bird because that is our spare bus um other things on the list are that were important were you know for Safety and Security reasons window shades um fix fix and replace in all buildings uh we still we have the numbers now we're into the measuring of the windows so I don't have a dollar amount for that yet um same thing with the replace of projectors um the presentation equipment for o and Deer Hill we did the
121Middle School two years ago we did High School this year 255,000 so that and then security equipment um which also cludes cameras so we have de Hill has does not have um as many cameras as we would like um there's some areas within all our those schools that either our security cameras and Equipment need to be replaced or there is currently not any um cameras or Security in those areas so that on the list and then we're continuing on with our furniture um we're trying to keep that as a standing line item every year so we can um rotate um between buildings and offices as you know di Hill has um replaced all the furniture and all the grad so now we'd like to finish up rep placing the furniture in the main office um
122and then at the middle of the high school we've asked them to um get some quotes and information on our counseling offices because some of those areas that we've walked through um the the tables are broken chipped um the things that staff brought in on their own um they they look pretty pretty awful um when you're doing counseling or you know have parents or or students in so we're looking for ports in those areas um again we have shortfall and transportation for athletics so you'll see on the list of two 15 passenger vans iPads at odd good which will give each class their own set the high school the ban conference room which I've never heard called that before um next to the guidance office um that furniture as well is pretty old in rickety
123and then the um Nick and Facilities is um pricing out soft dat for the elevator at the middle of the high school um and the other items on here um we're trying to come up with a plan um for facilities of how we can start to address some some of the needs in our sidewalks and um roadways um in curving which is Bard want to come um we're just we're gathering information now um but we're trying to be diligent and have um more information than capit would ever want to see so we don't have to go back multiple times don't have so many questions and um superintendent Shan and I have tentatively with um Capital leaon just to kind of stop the process so they know where we are they and then you can see
124the grants um we're we're we're not fortunate um in the grant department um is is we don't have a lot of low income so our eligibility for Grants um is Slim we only have a handful of Grants um we lost the title one Grant this year so you you see that on here um so truly it's you know about five grants one of them is the Medco um two of them are special education and then we have the me St of Justice which is a new a new Grant last year revolving as well um you can see there are no excessive balances on revolving accounts athletic revolving is showing a deficit um that's only because all the collection of winter sports has not gone in yet um so that deficit will go away um it's
125just a matter of timing the end of October the deposits weren't made but you can see none of none of the balances um are excessive right down to our school lunch program um you can see um we've done lots of enhancements in that area and we've brought that that um balance on to Ru $100,000 um obviously we still have reimbursements coming in we've all to see SE reimbursement um so we have nine more months of reimbursements which usually are $200,000 each time so that number's probably going to grow this just gives you a breakdown if anyone's interested in our FTE and by category and our head count nothing's changed we're not we have not had any staff and what percentage um and salaries are regular and what what mandated special Aid and then undistributed which
126are the custodians and cafeteria people that are not um designated to either area and if anyone wants to dig down into each school and how many positions of what they have um this breaks it down and what's budget funded and what's Grant are revolving funded and how many positions of each we have so um it's line by line it will tell you exactly how many um staff we have and white areas this is The Middle on the high school um again it will show you our grant fund about 11.3 FTE and a revolving fund about 22.9 FTE our enrollment um for November 1st and class sizes the elementary levels um level nothing's changed here our total right now is 1398 and here is the comparison from um October to November so we we've added one
127student between October November summary um you can see our costs are higher than last year um I us it just down a little bit um we are looking deeper into that facilities is going to do a deep dive for us and find out you know why we haven't seen any type of savings with the new lighting um and all the other upgrades and enhancements that we made and gas is the same so gas for whatever reason the OS Elementary School they did not bill us for gas September and October they told us we had a credit um so you'll see um the number here is not really a true number it does show we used less but that's because there was no reporting of data for September like the bank era in your favor Monopoly
128all so F Department continue to be very successful um we're still looking anyone out there looking for some work we're looking to hire several Food Service workers if anyone is interested please apply um can apply on school spring you can apply directly to the email to uh our food service director Vinnie quadon and this is his email address um poas middle school and front of doly Hill have their guiding program going um which is going very well and then um the mail count so I know this was that we we we had a brief summary of it last last month um I'm going to start building each month and you can see the meal count um here 25 for October breakfast and October breakfast September October lunch the totals um and then last year's so
129you can see the comparison breakfast is down um the elementaries I know de Hill got away from the sit down breakfast as doing grab and go which is which is why the numbers are much lower um the grab and go is not as um illustrious as the sit down breakfast um but if you look at the middle in the high school you can see um Middle School is we've sold 10,000 meals High School 13,000 meals and then based on last year it was 8,500 and 11,000 so um we're definitely increasing our our sales in Food Service Transportation um we have transportations ongoing you know R sh is up our as I said earlier our old Bluebird bus has been permanently retired is no longer repairable um I'm working with the town to plus the bluebird
130along with the mini buus which has not been in service for at least the last five years probably more like 10 um some of us probably don't even know that we have a mini buus somewhere um so we're g to we're going to Surplus those we just waiting to to gather the titles um and that's why we we're making a request to C to replace the for next year um I also um an update on the electric bus so I was able to finally track someone down from nlx um the division that was handling our electric bus has gone out of business and moved um to Spain I believe um but there are other divisions that are open that are taking over um and they've assured me um that their division is taking over um
131what status the electric bus project with another um division that's gone bankrupt and this division out of California has taken over the project and will continue to sport it um and take over the contract um so that's good news last I heard they were just bankrupted we were trying to Fumble around to find out who's going to support the software on the charger um they assured me that they would be taking that over um and that we would not see a loss in service um and the person I spoke to my contact said she was guaranteed her job for at least another three years so um that doesn't mean that in three years that that division of anel will be gone but she said she was insured at least three more years so um not
132not a very happy ending to our budget presentation um just hard facts we're not alone in this um we're probably one of the L ladder districts that have started to hit these shortfalls um in all these areas um but we are now there so you know our major concerns are utilities tuitions transportation and some of the salaries and again like I said the budget is Frozen um except for you know the essentials that we have to have and we are going through with a leadership team um to try to rectify that deficit and then plan forward for next year um so we don't end up in the same place as well as we have five b units to negotiate with so going into it probably another difficult year I don't know if there's any questions
133on that thank you Sue sorry for the bad news awesome I'll open it up to uh any questions comments from the committee I'll start with Miss Hannah thank you that was pretty Thor I have no question I can't always do good Mr car the um there's an issue with the level three charger for the electric bu and the bill and it got turned off is that that's also also this new division okay so we have um we are convening a subcommittee meeting budgeting yes the next two weeks t i Ser on that so begin great um cki just a quick question again thank you like I and I I appreciate the transparency and the sort of not trying to describe this than anything other than what it is in terms of this the situation being
134a difficult one that we're in um the new bus is that a lease is that an own is that an a buy and used bus that that quote of $20,000 for a bus was that just to lease a secondary bus to lease to replace okay yes um thank you so I I've got a few questions as I want to do on the budget matters um I'm going to start with the easy ones um so I saw in there that we're looking for food service workers I also am preparing for discussions with our bargaining units I noticed that um one of the provisions of our contract is is that teachers do not do lunch supervision is it a potential Avenue to hire people to do lunch supervision would that fit into our food service budget so
135that we have like lunch monitors that because I think I think now a lot of that's done with the with principles frankly and Administration staff so I'm just curious if that's a if that's an aage that's been explored so lunch Mars cannot be covered by Food Service because they're not actually preparing in serving me what if they did prepare and serve meals and then then watch the kids eat them okay anyway so it's that that sounds like it's not an option okay um you know just trying what I can um what happened to the bluebird the bluebird it's beyond repair it's um a 2010 um it's rotted it leaks um well I just didn't know it because it was I know it was dying and I just didn't know if like it exploded or like
136it just no it didn't explode it's just it it's beyond repair now okay um the amount of P needs fire exceeds so we're just going to Surplus it in losses so um one interesting thing for the lunch uh and the meals uh would be a what I'll call it is an uptake percentage or whatever but a number of if everyone got breakfast and lunch all students in fac are however want to do it but that would be a certain number of meals what percentage of that are we selling so like are half the kids bringing their lunch or is it 3 you know what I mean so like over the course of a week you would expect to serve a lunch to every kid to eat a lunch so like that would be the theoretical
137maximum number of lunches so I'm just curious as to what the percentage of lunches how many kids are eating lunch you Ser serve them versus how many you're bringing um I don't have that yeah just for for the next next absolutely and I will tell you that I learned um because I now do a super kit student advisory council at all the schools some of our kids bring a lunch and get a lunch that's something I've learned that's because they're free and so they're getting two lunches but if they if they but it's not free if they try and get two lunches correct no they're and when I say they're having two lunches they're having the lunch that they brought from home yes no and they're having the lunch that the cafeteria serves I learned
138by looking at my school box that you pay for the second lunch as well so yeah so yeah um or any Alat like so any of the snacky type food that's not considered a meal it's called Alat you have to pay for that's good because we're going to need the money which gets to my final question so $616,000 um physics will stop us from being able to spend money once we get to zero in our bank and that's going to happen at some point in I'm going to guess marchish maybe April um so do we I I know we're aware of this but I guess what are our what are the levers we can pull to help love mean I bake sale I I I don't know what are the potential levers that we could
139do to cut costs or to raise revenues I guess what's on the table so we're waiting for open Architects to complete their report we are hoping that and we actually did our kickoff meeting with them today we've talked to them a few times but soon I met with them today um and I know she's going to talk about this but I'll jump the gun a little bit um and they're reaching out to we gave them a list of people across the schools and the town to talk to um and they're doing a full risk assessment of us and their part of their task is to find Opportunities to help us close this Gap um so we're waiting to see what what they can share we have gone through um there really aren't any places for
140us to cut um we have cut everything that we can cut we have um stopped spending um so it we may not be able to find other Alternatives other than what open Architects can find for us at this point so we've been talking you know um chair mclen and I have been talking with the select board and the town manager so they're aware of sort of where we are we can to keep them updated um and then going into the following year is where we'll be able to start to make some decisions that close that Gap um so that may look like raising fees it may look like um making some Cuts in places that we would prefer not to but don't really have any choices um so we're going to have some hard decisions
141to make as we go into the next year we are starting the budget process with our principles um looking at what that could look like um it's it's it's a grim picture um and fun decisions open Architects is going to give us a report hopefully by the end of this calendar year that we can use to build a more sustainable Budget moving forward and Sue just put up all of the areas that they look at they're going to do deep dives into these areas so um these are the 10 areas of Financial Risk that they have identified um for districts um and they're going to look at all of it from student services and transportation to fees um to our spending to utility usage they're going to look at it all um so the hope
142is that they'll find where we can sort of shore up our shortfall and then um give us some recommendations for how to move forward in a way that gives a balanced budget which is not what we currently we didn't come into the year with a budget that was balanceable um so do to build on that I'm excited to hear about this but do we I guess we're going to have to have a plan for this year's Gap and and and end of the year for are they going to give us that or um you know do we know what our options are too because it seems like we need to raise $617,000 by the end of the year or save $67,000 by the end of the year yeah um they're gonna hopefully be able to
143close that so it's small focusing on next year's budget they're focusing on no I don't expect them to find 600 ,000 I'm hoping they find a couple hundred, um but then we can figure out from there what the plan is with in in collaboration with the town because right there is a reality to the increases that we were given for this year really covered just our staffing increases um and yet utility costs continue to rise and those aren't things that we can choose to cut we can't choose to not use the electricity or the heat and so it's going to have to be a collaborative effort to close that Gap what a year to join that's that's right so you know what I like to be a problem solver so here we are we're going
144to solve some problems and they're they they're hoping to have us the report to us before um hopefully yeah so so just kind of going back the agend unless there's anything else on the um monthly update I think our next thing is the budget calendar budget calendar can I just ask about the Consultants um can they look at things like um they work for a bunch of districts other uh suggested solutions to budget short they have some best practices category or yes they do other schools are dealing with this what other people do the budet calendar um obviously it's a little delay to to normal um normal year um and we want to be you know um thorough and in our budget evaluations we want to get through open architect and see what you know
145what suggestions they have so you'll see some of the dates on our calendar pushed out um normally in the M beginning of December we're presenting a draft of a budget we not we don't have a draft of a budget um we're focusing on this year right now um and we're just beginning the steps of next year um so what we've tasked um principles with is you know maybe department heads maybe need to present us three budgets um one level funding one level services and one if if you if we need to cut where would you cut um what areas would you cut you know obviously we both want to cut um so we're looking at all three um so it's it's going to be a delayed process in a sense um we're looking to we're
146going to meet one-on-one when everyone I'm just trying to see in the calendar uh January 8th be probably the first time you see a draft for prop proposed ating budget so it's a little bit later maybe a month later um again we don't usually find out what what the number is that the town is going to allocate to the school until the end of February beginning of much when the government releases the budget so um a lot of times we doing you know doing the work ahead of time and then sitting and waiting and then have to make changes anyway so this gives us time to go through um and have meaningful conversations to see you know what what we can do you know and I I can give you an example we um recently
147we had a um a physician custodian um resign and the both the head cust the leag custodian said um they don't think they really need it to be replaced so we're not going to replace it so that's a savings a small savings this year um and it would be a savings the whole position for next year so you know if we get creative and do things like that nobody is you know we're doing it through um portion no you know no one no one was cut we just didn't fil um and that's not to say in 3 years we don't put it back on L and say we now need it um but they feel very strongly that we do not need it right now so um in that sense you know we're we're looking
148at things like that as well but this is the calendar um pretty standard to what we do every year it's just the dates have been pushed out um we're still going to have a budget Workshop school committee um and the leadership team and every everything else is the same it's just been pushed I'll note for committee that this these these this calendar is in your material so I'll just open for there any questions about the calendar before we move on to our next hearing none um quick update on the electric bus or did we cover that in the budget report covered covered excellent um and then we started the update on open Architects but I'll turn give you the floor for more fullsome that's it that's it yeah we just had that we just had
149our kickoff meeting today so there not a lot of information um they're going to set their um document request of what what kind of documents they want us to send and share with them um get the bog rolling and then they're gonna start um intervie with a SL people both town and school excellent well I hope that finds millions millions of dollars have they dug for oil at all underneath the apparently there are lots of things that have happened underneath the school how about crypto but um I just want to say thank you to all the folks on the town side who we're going to be meeting with open Architects on our behalf we appreciate them um in their time in supporting our efforts yes absolutely um so okay that was a thoroughly inspiring Budget
150Finance update um we do have something to move forward on though and that is on the agenda item is a vote on Oz good roof and fire alarm funding requests um and uh Mr Shannon you can fill in gaps I've got the um the general high level but in some the committee is being asked to vote on three items of Appropriations from our stabilization fund two of those are in connection with the uh the msba approval for the accelerated repair of the Joseph oos good roof and the third one is in connection with what we've already speced out as an important um line item is the uh repair of the Middle High School firearm so um the first item is uh for the uh hiring of a project uh manager for the overall roof repair
151uh and that will be a request from the stabilization fund to the tune of $15,000 uh we understand from msba that that is the price that will not be exceeded um so $15,000 would be the um the hiring of the um the project manager and do you have a question now I go to the next yes they have a list of people they doot so the second the second um line item related to the Joseph o roof is the hiring of a designer engineer for the roof we don't have a fixed number on this uh but Nick barard has gone out to look for similar um roles for similar projects and the number is estimated to be about $100,000 for that work so the second request would be $100,000 appropriation from our stabilization Fund in
152order to pay for that Designer engineer again this is at the request of the SBA so that they can then take the the project to the next level uh so those are the first two things the third thing is the um the fire alarm replacement as you know one of the early items that we identified in connection with our um stabilization fund research was the big ticket item of replacing the fire laong uh it looks like that amount will be around $1.43 million to replace the um Middle High School fire law that sounds like a lot because it's a lot of money but it is a very big building and fire alarms are very very important so um that's apparently what they cost in commercial uh commercial buildings so um that's the outline uh Miss
153Shannon anything that that I've missed or Miss Owen anything to to fill in on the gaps there you coming any questions from the committee on those three line items so I'm going to look we are going to vote on these uh and the vote will be to request the um with request funds from the uh stabilization fund that will eventually go on to the town warrant uh and be voted on at the Town um so uh I will take them in order just so we have them right first I'll request a motion for the $115,000 allocation from the stabilization fund for a uh a a project manager for the Jose o good roof replacement the motion made by Mr carard have a second second second by Miss Le all in favor I opposed none uh
154the motion carries for nothing uh our second funding item I'll request a motion for the approval of a um transfer of $100,000 for the hiring of a a project designer engineer for the Joseph Ood roof replacement motion made by Mr Carr second second um Miss leki as the second all in favor I I opposed okay so the uh motion has carried uh for zero uh finally um we have a we make the motion now for the alarm system I okay so finally we're looking for an motion for requesting $1.43 million from our stabilization fund to pay for the um for the um replacement of the fire loan I will say should said this earlier do I can confirm we do have funds in the stabilization account to make these requests and I believe also any
155pending requests to the roof yes and there's an additional the town voted an additional plus two and a half% to go into the fund so we are using some those so do I have a motion for the 1.43 million allocation from the stabilization for the purposes of replacing the uh middle high school fireal so so moved um Mr Carr and do I have a second second second by Miss leki all in favor I I all opposed that motion also carries four nothing so we have approved the request for all three items um Miss Shannon if you can and Miss ow and if you can make sure that goes to the appropriate budgeting steps that would be awesome um that'll close off our budgeting item we'll move on to agenda block G community relations and Communications
156do we have any reports from our school committee subcommittees are Liaisons I will make a report um the middle school council where I'm the school committee leaz on met today and I dutifully did not attend although I do have a an in my wife is on the middle school council as well uh one of the things they discussed that was um not an issue but was a was a point of um discussion a couple years ago was the survey that went out to middle schoolers talking to them about all sorts of different uh activities coming and conect with Safe Harbor uh they looked carefully at that survey and um address some of the concerns that it raised uh a couple years ago so uh that's happened and they're also moving forward with some other policy
157stuff so uh I I actually have now made a report as my my liaison Ro as middle school council so um there are no other reports I'll close off that agenda block um there are no topics not reasonably anticipated by chairman Clen or me and his stad uh I don't believe we have any minutes to approve just an update um Kathy continues to have at me on a regular basis um I did finish them today I will send them to Jenner perfect thank you Mr car and thank you Miss Bob um so with that I'll see are there any ideas for future agenda items um that wanted to pack fundraisers anyone we have any um executive questions set aside for discussions around contract negotiations uh we do not have one for today just in general
158but we we don't have them scheduled we will call them actually chair will will call them when there when we have uh news report so I can speak on behalf of the I guess the subcommittee or the team that's working on that um we are engaging there's nothing to this point to report to the to the committee but we will definitely keep the committee in the loop every step of the way uh as we move move forward with that process um great so what there is no reason uh on that score to move into executive session and so with that I will entertain a motion to adjourn the meeting motion made by Miss Hannah you have a second second second by miss leski all in favor I I all opposed zero all right with that
159the unanimous 40 vote the meeting is hereby thank you everyone at home for attending and thank you everyone here for all your work very much appreciated good job