001e e call the meeting to order please rise for the pledge yeah pledge of alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all roll call please yes uh Wonder Jim here hore out stephus here Gardine here Palmer here Dean here man here thank you mhm the Quorum please note as a Coury to the members of the audience in the Board of Education please silence your cell phone public will only be able to speak during public comment has signed up I have two was Trent I thought you were were you signing out another one or all right so just the two all right thank you um approval of agenda can I get a motion so Mo
002support all those in favor yes yes passes all right uh we're yes I and I'll I'll mention that about the agenda we have a couple things on here that won't take place tonight due to the weather so we'll postpone those till another time we didn't want kids uh out in this so uh so the uh Cummings report will take place at a on a different date and under superintendence report uh Granville High School career and college riness will do the same so we'll bring those back around to you when the weather's better all right thank thank you will we will go to board member reports uh Joe you have anything sure thank you uh two things first of all uh Mark and I are going to go do a walkr at Resurrection Life church for
003a reification process coming up next week I believe so I'll report back next board report on that and does wal Walt do you have that picture what is it I'm sorry reunification training so uh reunification training is if there's a AC of violence at our school or we have to evacuate like where are we going to go to get kids back to their parents okay that's what that is yeah no problem um I wanted to share this picture that that young lady there is Emma Perez and uh she's got a lot of Blood Sweat and Tears on that Court behind her and uh I just thought this was a really cool uh photograph so you can see her knee brace on she blew her knee out I think game two mhm this year basketball yeah
004as a senior and um it just you know it ended her career in basketball high school basketball at Le so um what's cool about this is you see the emotion there um but look at Mike I think that's just an awesome representation and I know that there's a lot of people in this District that are just like him but I want to acknowledge the class um you know that it took for Mike to grab that microphone stand out there and talk about Emma on her last game it was just cool so I wanted to share that with you all oh thank you yeah AES that's all I have thanks Joe y go to Sally okay um my only reports are at this next Monday I think Bob and Amy and I are going to go
005to the B Grand Event at Grand View Elementary I'm looking forward to that um but also I wanted just to commend so many of the teachers in the district who um are uplifting their students in their classes there have been a number of students who have had some um pretty big hardships in their life fires or um parents passing away and such and these these teachers are always lifing up their kids and fulfilling needs that they they have and I just uh just want to emphasize again what a great staff we have and how caring and how much they care for our students it's really neat to see thank you uh yeah so first um I want to publicly apologize to Heather um apparently and it it's apparently it did happen I never noticed it
006but I offended her with the discussion we had with regard to the gmbb discussion and the RFP so I you know I I never KN really know what I'm going to say um try and keep it restrained but I know she works very hard actually if I were to grade and this is the honest truth if I were to grade since I've been on this board um our assistant sups of Finance she'd be at the top that put in Dev number two but you'd be at the top so I apologize for that um second thing still tied to that is I just want to reiterate why I was talking about that RFB and um specifically in the private sector and again we don't have to have discussion I'm just telling you from my position in
007the private sector and actually in the public sector because when you're working uh through any kind of government rfps are kind of the thing and it is very common to manipulate the RFP process whether inadvertently knowingly or just trying to gather information and you're the innocent party as you're developing it so uh I did meet with Raj and gmbb has brought value to the district there the difference that we have in that and I think it's um I'm going to go back to Ronald Reagan so Ronald Reagan used to say trust but verify so when we do construction projects we are already know what our limit in funding is but what the board never seems to get is the back end so if we say we're going to build a building for $40 million and
008we authorize it and we look at the bids and we approve the bids when it's all said and done we never really know what was spent on that building I I've never known that so that's where this and I guess maybe my um unknowledgeable with regard to the relationship with gmbb and how they do help us but I never get that piece so it's an open end for me so going forward that's and I already talked to Raj about that I would like to see that going forward so again you're a rockstar Heather all right thank you Bob M uh just a couple things I wanted to um kind of bring attention to mark easterly I know you've met worked with him and just really what he's doing for our schools looks really really great
009I mean just even looking at where people are putting things and storing things and tables and chairs are in the way of some of our fire extinguishers and I can see how that could happen real real quickly with not having maybe a lot of space thinking this and so I really appreciate the emails have been coming from him to show safety and that we're thinking even in that regard um it's not always just active shooter you know it is fire to and having those things available to our um students and to our staff without having you look for it so I just want to appreciate him and the work that he's doing to keep our school safe and building safe it's so important to me um that that happens and even though this is just
010oh hope they don't mind moving their chairs but again knowing that the we need to have them open it's just so important lastly I want to thank you Roger for the pool information so I haven't been really on this except my neighbor is is letting me know and some of the things you've mentioned are very helpful to me to be able to explain um particularly the delay in getting back in the pool is just I didn't realize what a large process that is for the cocking and the drying and then the draining of the pool first and so thank you so much for um providing me with information to help us understand a little bit more about how the pool is um being mainten maintained and what it takes to do that so thank you
011that's it all right thanks B Amy um yeah I would like to invite people to go on February 8th there is a Grand Rapid symphonic uh concert and it will be featuring one of our very own high school seniors Leb Gregorian who actually um placed first in the state for um um uh one of the most one of the highest band honors and so um if you can make it and see our music program the students we produce it's just really cool that he gets to be up on stage with the Grand Rapid symphonic orchestra so that's one of the really cool things I'd like to celebrate those same band students are still um working towards soul and Ensemble I know my son is in a quartet and a solo and they pay private companists
012and they these kids work non-stop I mean marching band is over but then they go right into Winter Winds and then they go right into Sol and Ensemble and then they there's just non-stop this is a really great program we're really really blessed to have it um the other thing is the hockey team for two weekends in a row traveled once up to Traver City and then this last time they took an 8h hour and 15minute trip which was actually longer because they would stop and you know move um and they went all the way up to hotton and they um they've just really improved so much over the last year it's really cool to see they did they did not beat the Gremlins but they did beat the Jets and last year they lost
013to both um first one pretty significantly and this one was a really they're really tight games I'm really also very thankful and proud of that program because Joel does create some very uh really great young gentlemen too in the process there's a lot of Integrity going on there's a lot of I just love that program so proud of the hockey team 14 and four yeah I should know that but I don't y beat the Rockets tomorrow they they have to beat your old stomp yeah so tomorrow we travel to re pu okay okay good luck thank you hopefully there's a game they can skate all the way there good that' be a good warm up Joe all right Amy is that it Amy that would be it right thanks lot thank you I just wanted
014to Echo with uh Bob's comments with with you how and how much the board appreciates what everything that you do for the district so thank you um also thank you to all the students and staff for the board appreciation things I haven't had a chance to look through those yet but thank you for that I think Roger might mention more on that but thank you um for me I've gone back to wrestling a couple events that was is cool I haven't been to those since my brother wrestled in high school so it's been cool to go back and and see some of those and beat beat Rockford that's it's always uh whenever we beat Rockford and anything that's always cool um I noticed in our in our email and I I hope to be able
015to get to this is uh we've got a play coming up the end of January here so like last year I traveled way too much and this year I'm hoping I I don't so I can that be at more of that and then just mention it's it's crazy but for people that don't realize how much uh effort our coaches put in my son I mean not that he does a whole lot but he helps with football and baseball and coach steel has already had the the kickoff meeting for football with all the coaches and they started hitting baseball team started hitting in the cages last week so that tells you uh well Spring's on the way hopefully but all the time that our coaches and uh players put in to to do everything that they
016do and uh we appreciate that so that's all that I have so pass it to you Roger all right thanks so as you know January is board appreciation uh month and boy do we appreciate all of you um your commitment to the this District um your ability to push thinking your ability to um you know really work as a team with me to do everything we can to provide the greatest experiences for our kids and our staff could have used you this morning with the the wind chill and this just kidding but uh anyway all seriousness just want to say thanks for all that you do I mean I am around a lot of superintendent on a lot of different things and I know sometimes you go to board meeting board uh professional learning and
017you come back and go wow are we fortunate I'm telling you we are truly blessed to have the people at this table you guys um it's not like that everywhere it just isn't um I feel you really allow us to do our jobs um our day-to-day jobs you you push our thinking um and if you don't understand something you ask for clarification and and that's really all you can ask a Bo to do so just thank you for everything that that you do um and I I know at times we might have disagreements but you know we're still locked up and I I know you have my back and I certainly have yours so thank you and you can see some of these things you're going to get more because we've been out of school
018a couple days we we have a few schools that couldn't bring theirs in uh but you're going to get uh some more things uh coming up but we just want to make sure you have these small tokens of appreciation um and again thank you very much thank you so along those lines obviously my son stopped by today so this is to our awesome school board from the first graders at West I told my son just don't get me a bunch of mugs and stuff so I said I appreciate the intrinsic stuff a lot better so this is for the board pretty cool awesome he didn't tell me it was here either I need to go up thanks Bob all right we have moving on then no old business the next one is consent action agenda
019can I get a motion please mov support all those favor yes yes yes opposed no motion passes all right moving on to the next item the regular action items um preschool and Treehouse tuition rates can I get a motion please so move support all right it is recommended that the Board of Education establish the tuition schedule for preschool and Treehouse programs for the 2025 2026 school year that was shared as part of the January 10 2025 board update and is outlined in the tables below to follow this recommendation it is further recommended that the board approve the program increases in sub subsequent years as follows 5% increase to preschool tuition 10 or $10 per week increase to Treehouse boost before and after in summer programs so I wasn't going to read all the charts here
020but uh Roger do you have anything yeah we have we we have some things I mean mainly we'll we'll open up for questions but we just like to commend Megan and Julie they put this together with Heather um and and really looked at what's happening out there uh around the area with other programs and and so on and and all we're trying to do is is provide the best service the best support possible for our kids and our families um and you know not be at the top end of everything but you know but yet we do have to in order to do what we have to do we have to land somewhere around the mle midle so uh yeah so if you have any questions or anything you wanted to add Heather Megan or
021Julie yeah sure so I we just have a real short presentation so we can throw the um slides up there so you could see but just to Echo what Roger said uh Megan and Julie did all the leg work on this and um it's really hard to find Apples to Apples comparisons and then it you can around we Tred to do that around our neighboring districts um which I feel like we did a good job of finding the most comparable to put in the slides um the other piece to that is to you know the for-profit entities that do this the apple tree and whatnot they're not so willing to give you their information go figure um but um I think we kind of outlined what we're looking to do and um it is amazing
022how many programs um we were able to offer our families so um so just a brief agenda here is what we'll go over and when we talk about the program goals um for us it's affordability for our families um we do offer a lower tuition or um free in most cases gsrp to families from a preschool perspective um and then also the financial sustainability so it's always um been for preschool at a minimum just to break even um and then the Treehouse side of things the daycare that is always always brought in some additional money so we can um cover our indirect costs um associated with um maintaining those programs so um I did put a little history in here um and I included the minutes and the proposals from the previous times we've brought
023you um increases to the preschool tuition the last time was January 6th of 2020 which un unanimously approved again that's in that longer packet within your board packet and then in in 2023 um we brought mainly some adjustments like we eliminated the twod day programming and then we increased the summer offerings by $10 a week which was also approved um so those are in your your packet if you wanted to take a look at that um why the increase is necessary it's really directly related to labor costs in the market and our ability to recruit and retain our staff um we're seeing turnover every 2 to 3 years a lot of our staff are um uh college students which is great and they're headed into the education World um but then they're leaving the you
024know the early on the Treehouse side of things um for their jobs so um I think we have a pretty good funnel from Grand Valley and some other places that um they've worked with but we are still observing a lack of applicants um and then the ability to offer the these programs right it really hinges on generating enough Revenue um to cover our expenses so from here I'll kind of turn it over to uh Megan and Julie so they can go over the programming differences but and thank you to all the board members we do really appreciate everything you do and I know I've worked side by side with many of you so thank you um so to start start out with the proposed preschool rates um currently we offer three and 4day programming for
025three and foury olds so our current tuition rates range anywhere from $11,200 to $1,600 and we are looking to maintain that middle of the road tuition affordability to our uh community and doing a 15% increase which would range between 1380 And1 1840 um So currently this ranges our current rate is about $12.50 per day um we're looking to just increase that 15% to range about uh 1450 so overall just a couple of dollars a day to help sustain pay those wages that um our dedicated staff uh deserve as well as keep up with The Changing Times and make sure we can continue to provide a quality preschool for our future Bulldogs all right and um for those that I don't know I'm Megan sty I'm the director of Treehouse um and so Treehouse has lots
026of pieces um starting with the Treehouse boost um we named that a couple years ago this is what kind of com it's our wraparound service for our preschool families um our current tuition you see is we offer 5day and 4 day um 130 for 5 and 110 for 4 days I'm proposing a $20 increase in both areas um just to cover cost of toys toys are expensive and keeping up with the keeping up with what's cool you got to bring that in because you got to keep those kids engaged for those times that they're there most some kids are there from 6:30 a.m. to 5:30 and they go to preschool for 2 hours um keeping up with crafts and snacks um food we've seen the increase in food as well um and we're comparing um
027with Byron Center um they have a similar program and they charge 2,000 um sorry 240 a week um for their program um and then we also um assist gsrp families cuz we have three of those classrooms in our building um we give them a discounted rate because their time with us is shorter um CU our preschool program is 2 and a half hours so gsrp is 8:15 to 3:15 so they're with us essentially before and after school um so we offer a 4 day at $90 um and a 5 day at 126 um just cuz on Fridays there's no school so it's a full day for them so it's a little more of a cost is still $36 a day so we would just increase those by $10 to keep it still within a reasonable
028rate for our families that um might not financially be able to pay for child care and we do work with DHS um and we work with um Michigan Tri share this is the first year I've done that and so where the employer pays a portion the employee pays a portion and then the stateboard and pay a portion so we do work with kind of any Financial need and like offering even like the Student Assistance fund if families are really hurting and obviously we work with families if they come to us personally and say I'm struggling we're not going to deny them care um we're going to work with them on a payment plan um but we pref we want to in include everybody give them that opportunity and then we have no school weeks um
029where we have um so PR people start off their Labor Day so we have two weeks that we have just full days with wonderful three and four year-olds so we offer 5 day 4 day and 3 day um and because it is full day it's 180 for 5 days 160 for 4 and 125 for three so we're just I'm looking to add $20 to each one of those just to help with um Staffing I need more staff on those days um ratios are smaller at that age group um so just having more people on hand which you know having the additional tuition raise would be beneficial all right um moving on to before and after um so this services our young canders through fourth grade um at elementary buildings in the district um so we
030kind of have a all aart I want to call it I guess because we have a before and after you can so you have before and after as an option um 5 days 4 days and 3 days um we require that minimum of 3 days because of Staffing it's hard to plug in people that want 2 days and 3 days so we just put that 3 days as a minimum and we actually have only three families that utilize that um 5 days is $100 essentially $20 a day which means it's $10 in the morning and $10 after school um so I'm looking to increase that um by $20 um in both five four and 3 days and our other comparable areas are iron Center um which they charge 130 for 5 days before and after
031and Hudsonville is 120 so we're kind of in the middle there um and similar with the four and 3 days and I don't know I know how does early release days so I'm not sure how that works with their before and after so I think that's why their prices a little lower in some because they they charge an additional fee for those early release days um and then we offer before or after um so this is just for families that need one or the other um and it's 80 for 5 70 for 4 and 65 for three and so I just put no change there um just because we're very similar already to what iron Center and Hudsonville have so I didn't want to raise anything at that in that area um before and after
032our registration fee is currently um $30 per child and and then 50 for a family I'm asking to raise that to 40 per child and 60 per family um other districts charge 60 per family fir Center at H charges $100 a kid for registration um and then s days and no school days um all students that attend have like a daily Max um so for example if a student attend 5 days a week Monday through Friday they pay $100 for that week and it's divided by wi5 is $20 a day so we make that we would add $30 to make that day $50 for them to attend so it would increase the daily Max up to 60 um and the other districts nearby fire and Center Huts will charge 55 on top of their already
033top that is added on top of their current tuition so they would that week it would be 130 for tuition um and then half days um currently we don't have a fee for before and after if you attend it's kind of like a little bonus that you if you attend both before and after you didn't pay to come on Gap days and then we were seeing just a flux of people that are just dropping their kids off CU it's kind of free so um which is great we' love having kids here but it just you know to add that $15 to their daily to their weekly charge would be beneficial just to like because that's an extra four hours or we need staff on sighting um you know using space using supplies um a lot
034of our elementary buildings are really big into the pler beads you would not believe on many F beats I bought this year um but I mean so they're using things throughout that for additional hours on top of the 3 hours that they would be there after school so it's just additional fee and then before or after does have a current fee right now of $20 and we would just be increasing that by $10 to $30 and then my last one is summer um our summer program has really grown over the last few years um our the I think my second summer here it was we had under 100 families last year we had 133 families that attended um we are known for our field trips um we are known for you know just the flexibility
035um so we have a 5day option A 4 option and 3day option and this is for school age children um so our current tuition for 5 days is 200 I'm asking to increase by 20 4 days is 190 up to 210 and 3 days from 150 to 165 so that's a $15 it's a little different just it made more sense based on the numbers from the other districts we we didn't really want to be higher than them in that area um our Bon Cent is 240 for a week and Hudsonville is 235 and then we also have a registration fee for this program as well because our school year program and our summer program are completely two different programs there are two different sessions it's usually like we have a week between each program and
036so we just flip the program and it's from school year to fall up to Summer and you know theme weeks field trips and all that stuff so our registration is currently $30 a person $50 per family we're asking to still keep that but we're asking to add a Feld trip fee field trips have gone up over the last house for 3 years I have seen an increase and increase and increase we don't want to have to take away field trips because that's kind of what we're known for we're known for going and exploring things that some our families might not be able to do out on their own with their parents um and we took 90 kids on field trips last year and we brought in home field trips for three and four-year-olds cuz you
037can imagine blessing three and foury olds would that be that fun so we are um we bring in programs we bring in we did a phone party last year with bubbles on the playground and I've never seen so many three and four have so much fun um we did it for the older kids as well we did cone ice we did ice cream we bring in some science um clubs that do like a science show for the little so that they still get to experience field trips um but we do leave uh we we go off site with our older kids and we tend to be gone from like 8:30 to 3:30 and so we utilize that time and we do utilize free places like the zoo um but we also like to give them
038other experiences like where we go we um I know one year they went to a white CS game before I came um I know that we're going to try to do swimming this year um just because we have some male employees that worked for me last summer and that's easier to go to a pool and you have males that can supervise the men's room and you know the females so we're hoping to do swim this year um and so just the first year I think we did three field trips a week one of those being a park or a splash pad in the middle of a week we've kind of gotten down to two a week just because by the end of the eighth week kids are dragging because you have to get in there
039earlier and so we started to see a lot of kids exhausted by the end of summer with just arriving earlier for the bus but um so we try to do two and then every other week to do a third one with a slack tab or a park which typically the younger kids like so that $100 would go towards paying for all those field trips um last year I think we paid $177,000 for field trips and if we charge 100 families $100 that would take care of a lot of our our budget for field trips and that may give us the opportunity to do a couple more um things that we would like to do with our kids and but also it allowed me to have more staff to go on those field trips and being
040fully staffed while off site um and then most I think byon Center they include their field trip fee in their tuition so their 240 includes their field trip so they have like $5 a week that gets added in there so if we were to break the $100 down for the N9 weeks that we open that's not very much per week but to collect it up front it just makes it easier when we're paying up front I mean we start paying for field trips in next month February we start booking our stuff um so just having that just would really utilize is giving them a better Adventure giving you know having the staff to support while we're off site as well any questions I'm going to tell you this was a incredible presentation and proposal it
041was you Justified it so simply plus I also like color so you did that really well but thank you for the work you put into this because you you've Justified tons of information for sure yes and the the comparisons are awesome to have that because you always wonder how would we compare to other districts yeah and it was definitely harder to get like the private places like apple tree like they lock that stuff down and I didn't pretend to be a parent I mean I mean theirs were definitely higher than what any of our districts apply but um for but it was definitely it's definitely hard to do that digging and a lot of places aren't offering their stuff out it's very basic so to do some digging and just make opportunities for everybody I'm
042assuming that your proposals are based on like average enrollment like for example in the before and after categories is that correct based on right now we have I believe 83 in the before and after and typically we have um sometimes behavor that we have the ones that choose just before or after um most parents can get their kids on the bus so it's our after program seems to be a lot bigger um just because after school is harder for families especially with some kids um so typically we do have like a handful of kids that are before and after but then we just have a couple that are just we have a lot majority majority of them are before or just after um for people that work early in the morning they drop their kids
043off but then can pick them up after school so that gives them that flexibility where they're not also being charged an arm and a leg for their kid to be watched for an hour as compared to somebody that needs before and after and lay $100 to them for their kid to be watched for 4 hours they're like sure I'll do that right you you keep them we open till sa so people have that flexibility my my only question was on the half days is $15 enough do you have enough is that going to we I think based on our all the information I've collected we don't have a ton of those families that come for that so typically like our morning kids sometimes just get picked up after school um but that's something that can
044be watched over time and if we're like hey this is increasing so maybe we need to talk about increasing this more okay good thank you do you see this um increasing the salaries of your staff that you'll be hiring yes um I would to increase the salaries of my staff my staff work extr hard um I do have a lot of college students so my I work with them for a couple years and then they go and do their career and some of them end up working in gramble which is great um but then I have my longtime people that have been here probably as old as I am um so I have people that obviously everybody deserves a little bit more money and obviously education there's not a lot so a lot of people
045have their heart in this and the money is not a big deal but to give them a little bit more to make them feel appreciated for all the hard work they do I mean they're keeping they're keeping a human alive all day especially I three and four year olds those those teachers have amazing Hearts um but just in raising the rates would help to be able to give that to my employees I totally support that I'm not questioning I just I'm glad to hear that part of this increase will help you in that um amount to pay our our great staff yeah and I mean just like hirings hard in general already um you can go to McDonald's for $17 I mean you get people that are happy and mad about their meals where it's
046work in child care you get hang out with kids all day that tell you the silliest things and um it just grows your heart you know and so just giving them that extra couple dollars especially my people that have been employed for 30 years making $16 whereas a new person at 15 like that's heartbreaking and just to Value them um I know they would appreciate it a lot well having had family and friends who've had kids in your programs um it's been an outstanding program I'm a former preschool teacher as well and so I've appreciated all you've done but also to put together a budget that's so competitive with the nearby um districts is amazing I mean your numbers are impressing I equate your staff with that many preschoolers to hurting cats so they deserve
047they deserve a raise um and second of all uh everything that you propose is extremely reasonable and probably on the low end of what I would consider even bump up a little bit but that definitely reasonable thank you for putting that together one of the things I really you know you know me I'm like your biggest fan um the the entire um staff works together and knows each kid individually I know this for a fact because you know I have my little 5-year-old granddaughter there and we've been through some stuff right and so um I would say that one of the things that I'm super impressed with in this particular um program is not only your heart for these kids but also the fact that you're also working with gsrp and sometimes for free um
048to monitor that as leader ership and so I'm extremely grateful for the dedication that you have and I know you're like oh we get to hear all these great things from these kids it is also remarkably exhausting and so I I am always amazed at how much you try to Steward that for a lot of people who are struggling Child Care is insanely expensive insanely expensive and so um I I love that you did give us that comparison um when you had first talked about like we're going to look at these other districts so smart and still your summer programs are lovely you forgot about the bunnies that you brought in so I mean it's just been it's been really um it's been really heartwarming because it is it's lovely to be with kids it's
049all hard all day and you are great stewards for so many families and I think it is so cool to have um families that say they started off and Miss Heidi's pre school and they're graduating as seniors right I only have one child that's even started in kindergarten through here so my granddaughter will be my first and she wears those Bulldog sweatshirts with pride she's like I'm a bulldog I'm like okay good so thank you so you know where I stand good point that we're growing Bulldogs here in preschool and that that's really important for our numbers good care Affordable Care that we're going to keep these families with us and I think that's just the real benefit of what y'all are doing is making it so folks can come here and receive an excellent
050education not only in Pre school but throughout their whole their whole time here and a lot of them do move on from preschool care up to Elementary care with us um so we do get to see them kind of grow up through Elementary years and um it's wild to see some of the kids from what I started only 3 years ago um this is my third school year and just like wait what your you're you're leading M element schol what it's just it's amazing to see them grow and all the things that they change and mature like from preschool up to like first or second grade yeah it's amazing to see the change you're really the starting that Foundation of learning so great job all right any other questions anyone to do oh all right
051vanck yes polymer yes I's absent stephus yes Guardian yes Wonder Jam yes danan yes motion passes thank you Megan Julie thanks thank you thank you very much stay warm all right we'll move on to the uh 2015 Bond refunding can I have a motion please some move support all right it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the attached resolution which author izes the issuance of the 2025 refunding bonds for the purpose of refunding 2015 Series 2 of bonds approved by the voters of Granville public schools on May 7 2013 not to exceed the sum of 39,500 that ground Roger yeah that was good was good did you have a motion and support I did I'm sorry okay no that's okay that's all it all this is always an exciting thing to bring to
052people and bring to our community and I'll turn things over to Heather uh and you can kind of see what's taking place here so I I'll kind of start back I guess at the beginning so as part of that um vote in 2013 um that the voters approved um we issued Bonds in three series that that time we issued in 2013 which we've refunded and again a refunding is similar to like refinancing your mortgage um and you're looking for savings on your interest rate or um a reduction in your debt Service as well so um so now we're we we're able to uh refund or refinance the series 2 2015 bonds um this amount was a lot higher than that first series um that we were able to refund so that again is a reason
053for that overall interest rate Savings of about 7.48% typically on average you'll see Savings of around 3% um and in fact like our financial advisers won't recommend anything below that so um so we're able to save the taxpayers this is not like any funding that comes directly to the district it's on that repayment so over the taxes that they're paying on on that millage an estimated 2.8 million um um and that's from a $3.8 million reduction in The Debt Service um schedule so um upon approval um I will need um Amy and then I'm going to meet with Jason tomorrow to sign the bonds and some other documentation to send back to our attorneys I like that word m anybody have any questions it's not like you got to pay it back person questions no
054all right want to do another vote you bet please Wonder Jem yes H is not here Stef yes Gardine yes Palmer yes Don yes benett yes motion passes I'll do with the motion after I read it this time do you you can do whatever you want works it works all right we're not going to critize True board policy reading to and approval it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the trun board policy updates as presented and reviewed in the during the 1625 board meeting upon adoption these policies will replace and or update the current policies get a motion please oh support support all right so as you know we brought uh revisions to you for a first reading and uh you had those ahead of time to review we've had some time go
055by Between the last reading and now um so bringing these back to you and the review that uh John provided for you as well uh an overview of those changes and uh we hope to have that second reading and any questions you might have taken care of so that we can approve this so turn things over to John and uh take your way uh just a few things before we jump into these revised policies I anticipate within the next month for sure there'll be a few additional policies that I'll need to bring one of them is the earn sick time act depending on whether the Senate bill or the house bill has action and does something with it but if that those bills take too much time we close to February 21 we will need
056a policy to ensure that we adhere to that I just need you to know we're already in alignment we're good from a leave time standpoint with all of our employees but we'll need that policy in place and also uh you may have noted that uh Kansas Court vacated the 20124 um Title 9 regulations why it was important for us to hang on to those 2020 board policy regulations trun is already looking at and working through again another adjustment to their policies to move the 2024 out and to bring the 2020 regulations back into that like I said we hung on to the Neola policies so that we were covered should that have ever occurred all of our buildings are now covered under the 2020 regulations pending any additional litigation or court cases or any of
057the things that go along with that but I know trun is already have talked to Katie brus who um is the attorney that had kind of worked with us on it and they're already working on the the policy changes for those so just know that um even though we're going through a large bump here those two pieces um are things that I'm going to need to bring within the next month or two uh before we jump into anything else so yeah I just wonder if you could talk about that Title Nine a little bit more you say a court threw it out yeah so I knew that there had been legal response to that yeah yeah so the Kansas Court vacated it vacated but essentially ruled that the US Department of Education didn't have the
058power and authority to to add the language that they added um I do anticipate that there'll be some additional changes um I don't know if it's going to hit the middle I don't I don't know um but in essence the the guidance from trun and our attorneys is with that court case ruling we're now all of our regulations all of our all of our buildings are are required to investigate based on the 2020 regulations thank you for that clear it is help thank you would you say say that's probably the most fluid policy I mean that could change it it sure feels like it in the moment um I I think there were there were some things in the 2024 regulations that I think uh were really positive I'm hopeful that the two sides can
059come together and find some sort of a middle ground that that fits both of those pieces so yeah will it go back to the Department of AD then is that I don't know okay it could be some other body that reviews okay yep thank you and I think just to go back to what we said when legally we passed that title 9 policy it really doesn't change what we do either way right so when this change back our process is still our process I mean there there are some things in there that um probably helped with the efficiency of process but how we invest tigate is really I mean it's nothing nothing that we have to look at and go oh man we've got to make major changes and it wasn't when we passed it
060because legally we you know it it was a legal document we had to pass it and now that it's not there it doesn't change again so um okay either way anyway before we jumped into the other policies just wanted to make sure that based on recent events I brought those things to your attention what questions do you have on the policies that we brought forward can I jump forward to 3402 yeah the drills of plans um jumping on board of what you're saying earlier Barb uh Mark E has done a great job with letting people know where stuff is and Etc you'll notice the highlight of portion there the that the all the coaches had to be certified in CPR and AD I'm sure yep they probably usually do anyway but they have to know
061the locations of the ads uh which is you know that's a big deal to know where those are at yep um the next part down though SE drinking water management plan yeah do we have one yeah sweet yep Fred and his team have already been integral in in working through adding out all making sure the drinking water that we have is appropriate testing all of those things and working on that plan yes so we have a due dat what's that we have a due date that's my only question on that by January 2025 it is it's ending yep does the board have to approve that plan the um if it's in line with our filter first grant ICT me wrong um it's actually approved by eagle okay and then we have to post it um
062after that I we're in the process we've been approve for the grant we're in the process of updating just th me for a loop when I said the board will develop right correct already J that's why I'm asking the question yeah that uh always slides this way and this way got understand it's through we're still kind of you know it out y just on that one we don't have any buildings where you can't drink the water in the building do we we do not have any buildings where riverb was like that Riverbend was like that yes yep all right two years ago when I started I had a let assessment done of all our buildings by eagle and that with the original development our drinking water Med a plan and any any fixture that tested
063hot we replaced so technically right now we are LED free y but the state is still making us go through and add filter water stations to the building every building per 100 students yep I get that yeah and and I watched Fred knock a hole in a wall to recreate uh a a filtered water drink or fountain at the high school uh this summer it was a giant hole was it wait a minute was it a necessary hole 100% okay 100% you never told us uh and then I just wanted to just make a comment on the back side of that page um as far as the reporting mandatory reporting I see Mark sent something out he also shared that with every District safety security personnel and said please use this as you will and
064we did yep so um to say that he is valued as an understatement that guy is he's on it so just a quick little reminder who's a mandatory reporter who's not how to do it what happens what your responsibilities are is pretty awesome so Inc that's all I have yeah thank you thanks John other questions you have on the policies 245 John yeah I'm going to keep them in order for you um item D board vacancies yeah so I'm kind of I'm confused on two and three okay so for two makes sense we got rid of treasure but then we crossed everything out of three and then in the uh if the office of treasure becomes vacant the board will promptly elect why not get rid of three and say vice president or secretary or
065un un Redline the or treasur and then just make it simpler right I think the the effort that they were trying to do there was to make it more simple based on the language that was there cuz they had president or secretary or Treasurer and then the next one down was secretary or Treasurer didn't have the the vice president piece I think what they were trying to do was pull the treasurer piece out of that um it doesn't make sense to me can you just ask him about that because sure it three seems unnecessary if you were to bring the treasure into that paragraph yep because it's the same what does the board have to do for this policy right yeah okay thank [Music] you [Applause] um 3102 I was doing this wi watching television
066so I got to okay um this is item two on the on the second page for C it says the district prohibits a sale of possession okay the superintendent or Des design will consider exemptions to this prohibition and I guess something I would like to have for consideration is wouldn't we also want okay my phrase is upon review an agreement um by the majority of the board I'm just asking the question right you know because I I mean I can give you an example of something that would happen there if you had a church service and um you know they had uh certain liquid that maybe had a little alcohol in it in their service they would ask and then I could look at everything and determine that situation and what that is and say
067yay or nay um what brought my question up is in parenthesis it's got CBD yeah that that the one that he's asking about is specific to to C to all no it's cvd and and I know like if we had um we had somebody that needed to use that medically um and they were dosed appropriately I think that's probably under the use side of it I can understand what you're saying as it relates to sale possession distribution dispensation um I'm open to the dialogue I'm you know what if you can explain explain it fine it's I just saw it and wanted to have a question on it that's all so I'm not tied to it John it's just let's have the discussion is CBD a drug consider no THC is yeah it's a derivative so
068it makes it yep yep CBD does have a trace TC in correct um 4101 did did you want to talk about that at all is there I just wanted to make sure did you said you wanted to talk about it and then just want to make sure no I just want to bring it up because I saw it um you said 40101 Bob 40101 Jen okay so unlawful discrimination unless unlawful harassment and retaliation my qu why wasn't this in the first review that's my question because you added the unlawful discrimination including unlawful harassment and retaliation where you took out that piece so what was why was there a need for a change in this right we took out discrimination unlawful harassment and unlawful retaliation mhm and then you made it a you you put it
069um you changed some words around unlawful discrimination unlawful harassment and retaliation it's I'm just confused so that almost reads the same yeah um this one adjusts quite a bit because in their without the um the Title Nine policy that we passed that was trun um it it separated out some of the discriminations the unlawful harassments Etc what this does at least in this moment and that's why I say going forward there'll be some additional changes this was one of the policies under 4101 that identified harassment outside of the title 9 policy the way that the 2024 regs were built all of those investigations were determined and needed to be done similarly if not the same so they made some of those changes based on the way that I believe if I remember correctly the way
070that that title 9 law was was written I anticipate that 4101 is is going to change yeah and I would agree with you so John here so I have multiple questions yeah this next one is along the same lines yep so to me as I was reading through these I'm I'm thinking is this in preparation for the 2024 the elements of the 2024 Title 9 disseminating yet there's value in some pieces of it that they restructured that is now being implemented into these policies yeah is that what I'm reading yeah so these what you're reading in the 4101 is a catch up in their policy to the title 9 regulation for 2024 got it that's what that is it just it it it aligns it helps these policies to align with those 2024 RS which
071is why I say I think I'm certain that there's going to be some adjustment to these as they go back and rewrite again uh their unlawful discrimination unlawful retaliation and harassment pieces back to the 2020 regulations so and again my notes on this overall where 44 4101 through 4105b 4109 yep got it yep all right those are all those were all yeah those were all created that's why you see all the yellow and the strikethroughs and all that stuff cuz they were believe it or not as much as I'm tired of reading especially the first section I did you I got to do you Justice John for what you're trying to do um okay so my question is what's the purpose of removing the action process cuz it's all gone now it basically says we're
072not going to do it but it it appeared to me that the paragraph that's disappearing is the purpose of it I'm trying to understand it is that MCL number part of what that process would be John yeah I why that's high is that maybe new I'd have to understand what because if you look at the legal Authority they struck through 38157 388 1766 and 1766 a so I would have to look I don't remember if it detailed it in here let me look and while you're doing that John so if you look in in this part of it it says that it was updated to reflect a repeal of a law that prohibited certain District official board members and District employees from referring a student for an abortion or assisting a student with obtaining an
073abortion the policy is now optional the discipline appeal procedure specified in the repealed law has been removed from the policy so the procedure that was there was part of the law that was repealed and so they took it out of and and when I read these I used this was great cuz I that was really help my guide awesome but I didn't keep them in tandem okay [Music] John um 5103 so my question on this search and seizure mhm is is this also influenced by Title 9 and the changes no it's not mm okay there's just a question almost [Applause] done 5206 B student discipline so my question on this specifically in a change of placement mhm can can you define for me the difference between suspend and remove catching up to you Bob sorry
074you're all right I just didn't have it marked 5206 so a remove for a student with disability is more of a change in placement and so I think that's why they reflected that that number I mean a sup suspension is a change in placement it's a removal from instruction um and under with students with disabilities if I remove a student with disabilities from an instructional space uh in school suspend them right I pull them out for an hour but if I do that if I do that 10 times I've now have a pattern of removal in that class for that student during that time frame and I may be violating idea law um because I've removed them so I think my guess is that's why they they took out the word suspend and made it
075remove because if you remove a student from instruction you remove them from a a school setting especially a student with disabilities there are some significant factors that you've got to make sure that you maintain before you get there yeah and I get that yeah yep um so because you're still going to do a manifestation correct yep and patterns of removal before that right um is that just a soft way of saying suspend because suspend suspend is I think people look at suspend differently I mean suspend could mean they are removed from school it could mean they're in school and and I think the terminology of changing it to remove means you know from a legal standpoint as John said anytime you remove a student in actuality it's considered one of those days yeah you can't
076remove you can't you you whereas you could say well we didn't suspend we didn't send them home we didn't suspend them but if you say no every time you remove a kid it counts as one of those days then it's more defined in what that is it's not an arbitrary you know I guess said somebody could say well we didn't suspend them we just sent them down to this room to you know work with so and so for a while well in actuality that is from an Ida standpoint that is a suspension does does the change in um words mhm does it benefit the district or the family it benefits the kid and the family in particular the kid because there's no work around well you know you all of a sudden you've removed a
077kid you know 12 times but you didn't do the other processes that are in place um if you have the remove word you remove them got if you have suspend like I said it's it there and we wouldn't do that but there are places that would say there are places that would say well we didn't suspend them we just removed them down to this room or that room Y no I'm familiar no I'm familiar with manifestation that's I I like the fact that it says remove because we have to do a pattern of removals and so now we're considering all removals not a snap suspension a suspension a detention yeah okay um 53 06 and again I was watching TV and I did some other stuff my question here is the district does not discriminate
078against students based on immigration this is the new stuff for Visa status and the students failure to comply with federal laws regulations and guidance May negatively impact the student's immigration or VISA status so and I wrote this down and my brain isn't functioning right now to be able to tell you why but I have there's a ruling um of us um a rule sorry a ruling I think it is uh US versus or something the department of Ed rule there's an apartment of Ed rule on immigration status and if they're considered an illegal IM immigrant then they're not entitled to Services am I right with that no so the court case yeah the court case that was in Texas it's interesting I was in uh a meeting today and we were we were talking about
079immigration status court case in Texas in the 80s um indicated that if a parent comes in illegally child still has a right to an education because they're here because their parents brought them here um so in terms of enrollment and being a part of school they're able to be a part of school they're protected by furpa all of those things that second part where it says if if the student so I'm assuming that we're not talking about an an elementary student maybe a student that's in high school fails to comply with federal laws regulations and guidance what I think that that's telling us is that it changes their protections under furpa okay those two sentences confusing I understand and believe it or not John that's all question okay um so we brought up a few
080questions earlier and that's why I said are we done discussing do you know we're taking these for Action is there you want to take action with the understanding we're coming back um with the clarification on those one or two do things or yes I don't there's nothing here that is stopped yeah in my mind okay okay A lot of it was question understanding yep you know and I understand it's kind of fluid so from that there's nothing there's no red flags what I read anyone else have any red flags with any of that we'll we'll check into the things that were mentioned and come back and there will be there there will there will be changes I mean obviously there'll be some additional changes last it more than likely there's yeah yeah yep so okay
081thank you nice job yeah yeah and typically they'll do those updates every six months right they'll typically bring one in in July and typically another one in January um they just gave us the estaa policy they put it in as a January update it was the only policy that they were updating like I said I think I think we'll get a few more as the transition between uh presidents continues over the first month and then we'll see what that looks like after that so thanks John this was really that and the highlights are fantastic appreciate it the way you present it easy to track good part of that is the way that TR organized this initially um is really helpful they did it with the esta too so it is a ton simpler yeah right
082thank you wanted do roll call I would love to hore is absent Guardian yes benck yes Wonder J yes Jan yes hmer yes stus yes motion passes thank you move to a public comment at this time so we have uh two in do you want to please keep time the 5 minutes oh [Music] sure so we will uh we have two public comments we'll begin with Jeff Johnson please remember if I have to read something right here or not do I oh yeah you reminder you have five minutes and Amy will give you a one minute notice [Music] good evening everyone uh members of the board fellow Granville parents friends neighbors um first of all I want to take note of the uh the switch from popcorn puns to chewing gum puns here enjoying that
083um and I also want to say I did not realize when I was coming here tonight that this was part of board appreciation month so uh I commend you all for your service on this board um it's a real commitment to our community and I appreciate uh what you're doing for us so thank you for that nearly 3 months ago the people of this nation and this state spoke at The Ballot Box for a certain type of leadership a certain agenda people in groups that support that agenda no doubt will show up at this microphone and call for this body to go along they might claim a mandate they might claim moral justification but I want to point out that at the same in that same election voters here in our community in this District
084voting for this board spoke just as clearly they decisively elected two candidates who not only promised skilled and thoughtful leadership but who campaigned openly and clearly on a message of support and compassion for every student the outcome of that school board election reflects our community values and ought to be respected these values as I have said before are also reflected in the mission strategic plan and beliefs affirmed by our excuse me affirmed by our district and declared on the wall of this chamber excuse me and there there's a disconnect here that I see between these stated values and an agenda that I feel is steeped in discrimination devaluing and disrespect and even if this agenda is endorsed by and handed down from the highest levels of our government that does not make it right or
085honorable just yesterday we celebrated a holiday dedicated to the life and example of the Reverend Martin Luther King Jr who believed that people have a moral responsibility to obey just laws and the same moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws but what constitutes an unjust law in Dr King's view an unjust law is something that a major majority group creates for a minority group to follow with no burden imposed on the majority he also provided this example of unjust laws grounded in his era noting that everything the Nazis did in 1930s Germany was legal while everything that anti-communist Freedom Fighters did in Hungary in the 1950s was illegal unjust laws Dr King said degrade our humanity and are out of harmony with moral law and it wasn't just empty talk for him as I think we
086all know he famously wrote about that in a letter from a jail cell now I've referred to those who support the new presidential administration's anti-lgbtq stance as having an agenda to be fair that can be said of almost anyone who comes before this board my agenda tonight is to speak up for the values on that wall and against the advance of unjust laws or orders the people of our community knew what was at stake in November when they chose the makeup of this board they chose compassion and I ask all of you each of you to make the same choice at every opportunity in the weeks months and years to come why for the best reason of all for every student thank you thank you next we have JR vanderwall hello folks Jr vanderwal 3585
087Earl Avenue Southwest normally I don't uh just read um but given my time limit I don't want to go off on tangents or get emotional in this so uh Buckle in uh good evening school board members Administration the purpose of me speaking during public comment is to bring attention to the aquatics facilities in our district being leaders in our community I assume you have the full detailed history of both confusing and irrational original High School design of the pool the age of the Oaktown pool and more urgently the consistent mechanical issues with our pools both of them if you do not I'd be happy to share what knowledge I have or connect you with aquatic staff Community ad Personnel or affected student athletes another time you may or may not know but I also serve
088on the GPS facilities committee and I recognize that the pool is is and has been an issue on the radar of that committee I am urging that conversation to start back up with intent and purpose and work towards a potential solution a new pool was proposed in 2019 and the bond unfortunately failed failed narrowly the facilities are continuing to have issues and cause frequent and mass Interruption both to the student athletes and public programming as well high school middle school and age group swim and dive and water polo teams are constantly having practices and competitions disrupted canceled or moved to other facilities while we're lucky to have two pools in our district they both are being looked at as the old failing and expensive vehicle that you just can't replace while we're also fortunate to
089be able to lean on other neighboring districts like Jennison Hudsonville and Byron Center to share pool time with us that brings its own significant and unique challenges as well my point is straightforward we need to resurrect and resume the conversation about a new Aquatics facility this time however the conversations need to have multiple player Partners at the table as I and others will be enthusiastically championing champ that's a hard word to say championing efforts to get others involved I'm asking for your support support us as parents of aquatic athletes that want more for what they deserve support us as community members that would also utilize a new facility support Grandville public schools that our pools would not be seen as the worst in the OK red or the whole region in general but most importantly
090support and encourage relationships that are going to be built with other entities like the city of Granville the mall the YMCA potential private investors or other school districts in general this is no longer the pool people complaining about what's wrong but rather let us help let us support and let us be part of this journey We Appreciate You serving our community we are lucky to have such great leaders that care passionately about the best interest for so many thank you for your time and I'm sure if you'd like to connect with me indiv usually on this you know how to reach me thank you thank you all right the next board meeting of grand or next meeting of the Grandville Board of Education will be Monday February 3 2025 at 7: p.m. at the administration
091building this meeting [Music] isour for